Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SUMMARY. A group of international experts prepared two lists of drugs with their
serum/plasma and urine concentrations, which should be used when evaluating the
performance of a new laboratory method. The two lists were veri®ed by running in
vitro interference studies in three European laboratories on Hitachi instruments. The
study identi®ed the following new interferants: acid phosphatase in serum by
ibuprofen and theophylline; non-prostatic acid phosphatase in serum by cefoxitin
and doxycycline; creatine kinase MB in serum by doxycycline; total bilirubin in
serum (Jendrassik±Grof method) by rifampicin and intralipid; total bilirubin in
serum (DPD method) by intralipid; creatinine in serum (Jaffe method) by cefoxitin;
fructosamine in serum by levodopa and methyldopa; uric acid in serum by levodopa,
methyldopa and tetracycline; carbamazepine in serum by doxycycline, levodopa,
methyldopa and metronidazole; digitoxin in serum by rifampcin; phenytoin in serum
by doxycycline, ibuprofen, metronidazole and theophylline; theophylline in serum by
acetaminophen, cefoxitin, doxycycline, levodopa, phenylbutazone and rifampicin;
tobramycin in serum by cefoxitin, doxycycline, levodopa, rifampicin and
phenylbutazone; valproic acid in serum by phenylbutazone; C3 in serum by intra-
lipid; C4 in serum by doxycycline; rheumatoid factor in serum by ibuprofen and
metronidazole; pancreatic amylase and total amylase in urine by acetylcysteine,
ascorbic acid, cefoxitin, gentamicin, levodopa, methyldopa and o¯oxacin;
magnesium in urine by acetylcysteine, gentamicin and methyldopa; b2-microglobulin
in urine by ascorbic acid; total protein in urine by ascorbic acid, Ca-dobesilate and
phenylbutazone.
Interference in acid phosphatase, creatine kinase MB and bilirubin methods was
observed at very low analyte concentrations, and therefore it may not be evident at
higher concentrations. The study con®rmed the usefulness of the recommendation.
376
Drug interference in clinical chemistry 377
TABLE 1. Recommended drug list for in vitro drug interference studies for clinical chemical methods using serum or
plasma as sample
TABLE 2. Recommended drug list for in vitro drug interference studies for clinical chemical methods using urine as
sample
Concentration found
Test concen- Test concen- in literature
Active agents soluble in tration C1 tration C2
blank serum or plasma Clinical use (mg/L) (mg/L) Peak (mg/L) Toxic (mg/L)
TABLE 3. Analytes and methods used for interference studies and observed drug interference in serum
Inter-
Activity or ference Inter- Observed
concen- Analyte limit ference deviation
Analyte Method ID no. tration unit (%) caused by (%)
Enzymes, 378C
Acid phosphatase PNP 1553437 1´1 U/L +30 Ibuprofen +76 n
Theophylline +57 n
Acid phosphatase, PNP, 1553437 1´6 U/L +30 Cefoxitin +34 n
non-prostatic tartrate Doxycycline +69 n
Alanine amino- IFCC, 1876805 19 U/L +20
transferase P-5-P
Alkaline DEA, 1662961 160 U/L +20
phosphatase DGKC*
Alkaline AMP, 1557033 72 U/L +20
phosphatase IFCC*
Amylase, EPS* 1491326 62 U/L +20
pancreatic
Amylase, EPS 1729322 28 U/L +20
pancreatic (liquid)*
Amylase, total EPS* 1491300 133 U/L +20
Amylase, total EPS (liquid)* 1729314 59 U/L +20
Aspartate IFCC, 1876848 23 U/L +20
aminotransferase P-5-P*
Cholinesterase Butyryl 1551329 9833 U/L +20
thiocholine*
Creatine kinase NAC 1552147 148 U/L +20
Creatine kinase NAC, 1127608 7 U/L +20 Doxycycline +28 n
MB immunological
Glutamate DGKC 1442422 2´5 U/L +20
dehydrogenase
g-Glutamyl IFCC 1730053 24 U/L +20
transpeptidase
g-Glutamyl Szasz 1551906 20 U/L +20
transpeptidase
a-Hydroxy DGKC* 1552350 108 U/L +20
butyrate
dehydrogenase
Lactate IFCC 1552384 250 U/L +20
dehydrogenase (liquid)*
Lactate SFBC* 1442635 365 U/L +20
dehydrogenase
Lipase Turbidimetric* 1491237 86 U/L +20
continued
TABLE 3. continued
Inter-
Activity or ference Inter- Observed
concen- Analyte limit ference deviation
Analyte Method ID no. tration unit (%) caused by (%)
Speci®c proteins
a1-acid glycoproteinTINA* 1557602 1´27 g/L +10
a1-microglobulin TINA* 1203622 40´8 mg/L +10
b2-microglobulin TINA* 1660551 5´65 mg/L +10
Apolipoprotein A-1TINA* 1551680 1´55 g/L +10
Apolipoprotein B TINA* 1551779 1´21 g/L +10
continued
TABLE 3. continued
Inter-
Activity or ference Inter- Observed
concen- Analyte limit ference deviation
Analyte Method ID no. tration unit (%) caused by (%)
*=No interference founded for this method in this study (neither with C1 nor C2); n=new interference; k=known
interference; ID no.=identi®cation number.
Spain; and UniversitaÁ Degli Studi di Milano, external quality assessment schemes (EQAS).
Desio, Italy). The drug-free pools were prepared The clinical signi®cance of these analytical limits
from donors taking no drugs. Spiked drug pools was reviewed and modi®ed by the group to
were prepared from either the parent drug or its provide the recommendations included in Tables
metabolite. Ethanol was used as a solvent for 3 and 4.
those drugs that were insoluble in water. The Drugs that showed interference in the screen-
pools prepared for studying therapeutic drugs or ing experiment were included in the validation
drugs of abuse were spiked with the parent drug study, and only those that then demonstrated
(Sigma, Buchs, Switzerland). These drugs were: interference were considered to be clinically
relevant.
Drugs of abuse
D,L-amphetamine sulphate, Na-barbiturate, D- RESULTS
lysergic acid diethylamide, propoxyphene-HCl
and phencyclidine-HCl. The results of the validation experiment at
clinically relevant drug concentrations are given
Therapeutic drugs in Tables 3 and 4. The results of the screening
Digitoxin (Fluka, Buchs, Switzerland), digoxin, experiment using high drug concentrations (C1)
gentamicin, phenobarbital, phenytoin, theophyl- have not been included but are available on
lin, tobramycine, valproic acid. request to the corresponding author.
The following analytes in serum showed no
Statistics interference at high (C1) and normal (C2) drug
Data were subject to statistical analysis using concentrations when using the methods de-
Computer-Aided Evaluation software (Roche, scribed in Table 3: alkaline phosphatase,
Mannheim, Germany) developed by Bablok amylase, aspartate aminotransferase, cholines-
et al.33 terase, b-hydroxy butyrate dehydrogenase,
lactate dehydrogenase, albumin, glucose, total
Interpretation protein, gentamicin, thyroxine (T4), a1-acid
A clinically acceptable degree of interference, glycoprotein, a1-microglobulin, b2-microglobu-
termed interference limit, was agreed by the lin, apolipoprotein A1, apolipoprotein B, anti-
expert group for each analyte studied and is streptolysin-O, C-reactive protein, ferritin, IgA,
included in Tables 3 and 4. These limits were IgG, IgM, prealbumin, transferrin; and in
derived from inspection of analytical perform- Table 4 in urine for amphetamines, cannabi-
ance data in German, English and French noids, methadone, opiates and propoxyphene.
TABLE 4. Analytes and methods used for interference studies and observed drug interference in urine
Activity or Observed
concentra- Analyte Interference Interference deviation
Analyte Method ID no. tion unit limit (%) caused by (%)
Enzymes, 378C
Amylase, EPS 1491326 325 U/L +20 Acetylcysteine +27 n
pancreatic Ascorbic acid +28 k
Cefoxitin +23 n
Gentamicin +28 n
Levodopa +26 n
Methyldopa +34 n
O¯oxacin +37 n
Amylase, EPS 1729322 139 U/L +20 Acetylcysteine +26 n
pancreatic (liquid) Ascorbic acid +26 k
Cefoxitin +22 n
Gentamicin +27 n
Levodopa +24 n
Methyldopa +32 n
O¯oxacin +35 n
Amylase, total EPS 1491300 436 U/L +20 Acetylcysteine +25 n
Ascorbic acid +26 k
Cefoxitin +24 n
Gentamicin +25 n
Levodopa +23 n
Methyldopa +30 n
O¯oxacin +33 n
Amylase, EPS 1729314 199 U/L +20 Acetylcysteine +25 n
total (liquid) Ascorbic acid +26 k
Cefoxitin +26 n
Gentamicin +24 n
Levodopa +22 n
Methyldopa +30 n
O¯oxacin +32 n
Substrates and ions
Calcium o-Cresolph- 1551272 6´62 mmol/L +5
thaleine
Chloride ISE diluted 1298097 156 mmol/L +5
Creatinine Jaffe 1551272 163 mg/dL +10
Creatinine PAP 1551841 172 mg/dL +10
Glucose Hexokinase 1491199 9´2 mg/dL +10
Magnesium Xylidylic 1551353 4´14 mmol/L +5 Acetylcysteine +42 n
blue Gentamicin +29 n
Methyldopa +22 n
Phosphorus Molybdate 1551388 36.7 mmol/L +5
Potassium ISE diluted 1298011 80.5 mmol/L +5
Sodium ISE diluted 1298054 177 mmol/L +20
Urea Urease/GI- 1729691 2378 mg/dL +10
DH
Uric acid Uricase 1662759 59´8 mg/dL +10
PAP
DAU
Amphetamines CEDIA* 1557343 2396 ng/mL +20
quant. 1000
(cut-off)
Barbiturates CEDIA 1557351 2368 ng/mL +20
quant. 300
(cut-off)
continued
TABLE 4. continued
Activity or Observed
concentra- Analyte Interference Interference deviation
Analyte Method ID no. tion unit limit (%) caused by (%)
Speci®c proteins
b2-microglobulin TINA 1660551 3´83 mg/L +15 Ascorbic acid +46 n
Microalbumin TINA 1203622 210´5 mg/L +15
Protein, total Benzetho- 1815199 0.31 mg/L +15 Ascorbic acid +74 n
nium- Ca-dobesilate 732 n
chloride Phenylbutazone 719 n
*No interference found for this method in this study (neither with C1 nor C2). n=New interference; k=known
interference; ID no.=identi®cation number; DAU=drugs of abuse; THC=tetrahydrocannabinol;
quant.=quantitative.
Drug interference was observed in serum at Drug interference studies can be misleading in
normal (C2) drug concentrations for acid some clinical situations and this is illustrated
phosphatase, creatine kinase MB, total bilirubin, below:
creatinine, fructosamine, triglycerides, uric acid,
carbamazepine, digitoxin, phenytoin, theophyl- . Levodopa is metabolized into the endo-
line, tobramycin, valproic acid, complement 3 genous substances dihydroxyphenylacetic
(C3), complement 4 (C4) and rheumatoid factor acid and homovanillic acid. Clearly, this
(see Table 3). makes the use of metabolite in drug
Interference was also observed in urine at interference studies dif®cult. Interference
normal (C2) drug concentrations for amylase, can therefore be mediated either by a
magnesium, b2-microglobulin and total protein pathological process producing these meta-
(see Table 4). bolites or by drug interference.
. The metabolites of ibuprofen, (+)-2-[p-(2
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION hydroxymethyl-propyl) phenyl] propionic
acid and (+)-2-[p-(2 carboxy-propyl) phe-
Most analytes showed no drug interference even nyl] propionic acid were not available for
at the very high drug concentrations that might this study. The use of the parent drug in
be seen with suicidal overdoses. This should place of the metabolites cannot adequately
reassure both clinical laboratories and manu- re¯ect physiological conditions and might
facturers of clinical chemistry analysers. therefore be misleading.