11/6/2018 Large hydropower dams 'not sustainable' in the developing world - BBC News

Home News Sport Weather Shop Reel Travel

AD

Science & Environment

Large hydropower dams 'not sustainable' in the developing world

By Matt McGrath
Environment correspondent

9 hours ago

GETTY IMAGES

A new study says that many large-scale hydropower projects in Europe and the US
have been disastrous for the environment.

Dozens of these dams are being removed every year, with many considered dangerous and
uneconomic.

But the authors fear that the unsustainable nature of these projects has not been recognised
in the developing world.

Thousands of new dams are now being planned for rivers in Africa and Asia.

https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-46098118 1/15
11/6/2018 Large hydropower dams 'not sustainable' in the developing world - BBC News

'They dammed everything' - hydropower gone sour

Are too many hydropower dams being built?

Hydropower is the source of 71% of renewable energy throughout the world and has played a
major role in the development of many countries.

But researchers say the building of dams in Europe and the US reached a peak in the 1960s
and has been in decline since then, with more now being dismantled than installed.
Hydropower only supplies approximately 6% of US electricity.

Dams are now being removed at a rate of more than one a week on both sides of the Atlantic.

The problem, say the authors of this new paper, is that governments were blindsided by the
prospect of cheap electricity without taking into account the full environmental and social
costs of these installations.

More than 90% of dams built since the 1930s were more expensive than anticipated. They
have damaged river ecology, displaced millions of people and have contributed to climate
change by releasing greenhouse gases from the decomposition of flooded lands and forests.

GETTY IMAGES

"They make a rosy picture of the benefits, which are not fulfilled and the costs are ignored and
passed on to society much later," lead author Prof Emilio Moran, from Michigan State
University, told BBC News.

His report cites the example of two dams on the Madeira river in Brazil, which were finished
only five years ago, and are predicted to produce only a fraction of the power expected
because of climate change.

In the developing world, an estimated 3,700 dams, large and small, are now in various stages
of development.

The authors say their big worry is that many of the bigger projects will do irreparable damage
to the major rivers on which they are likely to be built.

On the Congo river, the Grand Inga project is expected to produce more than a third of the
total electricity currently being generated in Africa.
https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-46098118 2/15
11/6/2018 Large hydropower dams 'not sustainable' in the developing world - BBC News

However, the new study points out that the main goal for the $80bn installation will be to
provide electricity to industry.

"Over 90% of the energy from this project is going to go to South Africa for mining and the
people in the Congo will not get that power," said Prof Moran.

"The people that I study in Brazil, the power line goes over their heads and goes 4,000km
from the area and none of the energy is being given to them locally."

GETTY IMAGES

"The nice goal of rural electrification has become completely subverted by large-scale
interests who are pushing this technology, and governments are open to being convinced by
them that this is the way to go."

The report points our that the large installations on these great rivers will destroy food
sources, with 60 million people who live off the fisheries along the Mekong likely to be
impacted with potential loss of livelihoods greater than $2bn. The authors also believe that
dams will destroy thousands of species in these biodiversity hotspots.

In Brazil, which gets 67% of its electricity from hydropower, the response to reduced water
capacity because of climate change is to build more dams.

With the election of Jair Bolsonaro in Brazil, a temporary halt to building new hydro projects is
likely to be overturned. Plans for 60 new dams are already in place.

The authors say that with huge pressure on countries to press ahead with renewable energy
developments, a mix of energy sources including hydro is the most sustainable approach.

"Large hydropower doesn't have a future, that is our blunt conclusion," said Prof Moran.

"To keep hydropower as part of the mix in the 21st Century we should combine multiple
sources of renewable energy," said Prof Moran.

"There should be more investment in solar, wind and biomass, and hydro when appropriate -
as long as we hold them to rigorous standards where the costs and benefits are truly
transparent."

https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-46098118 3/15
11/6/2018 Large hydropower dams 'not sustainable' in the developing world - BBC News

The study has been published in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of
Sciences.

Follow Matt on Twitter @mattmcgrathbbc.

Related Topics

Amazon rainforest Democratic Republic of Congo Climate change

Share this story About sharing

Science & Environment

Helpline to tackle bullying in chemistry

6 November 2018 Science & Environment

https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-46098118 4/15
11/6/2018 Large hydropower dams 'not sustainable' in the developing world - BBC News

Ron Howard: Creating vision of a Mars colony

6 November 2018 Science & Environment

Revealed: The secret of the poet's daffodil

5 November 2018 Science & Environment

More Videos from the BBC

Recommended by Outbrain

https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-46098118 5/15
11/6/2018 Large hydropower dams 'not sustainable' in the developing world - BBC News

What happens when the People line streets for 'I learnt more as a
beat drops? 463-tonne delivery barmaid than at
university'

Nina: 'Women in pop Meet Harriet: Ireland's Living as an ex-Muslim

support each other' singing donkey

Elsewhere on BBC
Recommended by Outbrain

BBC News BBC Future

Jets scrambled to 'unidentified aircraft' One country's plan to solve the world's
hidden health crisis

https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-46098118 6/15
11/6/2018 Large hydropower dams 'not sustainable' in the developing world - BBC News

BBC News BBC Culture

Khashoggi body 'dissolved in acid' Ten films to watch in November

BBC News BBC Travel

Missing man's body found near Why the French don’t show excitement
cemetery

From Around the Web

Promoted content by Outbrain

Entdecke True Sound zu Hause. Näher kannst du deiner

Musik nicht kommen
Yamaha Music

Every Driver In Germany Should Have These Night Driving

Glasses That Make It Safe To Drive Again
techdiscountfinder.com

800 Years: China’s Unique Papermaking Village

CGTN

Wintercheck: Ist deine Heizung bereit für den Winter?

tado° Smart AC Control

https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-46098118 7/15
11/6/2018 Large hydropower dams 'not sustainable' in the developing world - BBC News

Mehr Zeit für den Kunden: So hosten Agenturen Projekte am

effizientesten
Basic Thinking Blog

Computer Owners Are Using This Simple Trick To Get Free

Protection
The Review Experts

Top Stories
Trump makes final bid for votes
The president appears at three rallies in three different states before the mid-term vote.
6 minutes ago

US warns of 'relentless' pressure on Iran

5 November 2018

Newlyweds die in air crash leaving wedding

1 hour ago

ADVERTISEMENT

Features

https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-46098118 8/15
11/6/2018 Large hydropower dams 'not sustainable' in the developing world - BBC News

Invincible, but for how much longer?

Large hydropower dams 'not sustainable'

https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-46098118 9/15
11/6/2018 Large hydropower dams 'not sustainable' in the developing world - BBC News

Israel-Arab ties warm up after long deep freeze

No-deal Brexit and other EU countries

https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-46098118 10/15
11/6/2018 Large hydropower dams 'not sustainable' in the developing world - BBC News

India's tiger killings: A success story gone wrong?

The city banking on more guns to make it safer

https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-46098118 11/15
11/6/2018 Large hydropower dams 'not sustainable' in the developing world - BBC News

How the humble lamp-post could help power our cities

This country banned plastic bags - should we?

https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-46098118 12/15
11/6/2018 Large hydropower dams 'not sustainable' in the developing world - BBC News

BBC Future: Should we really all fly less?

Elsewhere on the BBC

Lyrics quiz
Have you been getting these songs wrong?

https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-46098118 13/15
11/6/2018 Large hydropower dams 'not sustainable' in the developing world - BBC News

Feeling hot
What happens to your body in extreme heat?

Most Read
What happened to Michael? 1

Grenfell Tower bonfire: Five men arrested over video 2

Texas newlyweds die in helicopter crash leaving wedding 3

Queensland fatal shark attack: Third incident in tourist spot 4

British sailor admits killing wife at sea 5

Landmark day for state pension equality 6

Large hydropower dams 'not sustainable' in the developing 7

world

Boy, 16, 'stabbed to death' in south London 8

Mid-term elections 2018: Trump makes final bid for votes 9

Big Brother: Winner of final series announced 10

Why you can trust BBC News

https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-46098118 14/15
11/6/2018 Large hydropower dams 'not sustainable' in the developing world - BBC News

BBC News Services

On your mobile

On your connected tv

Get news alerts

Contact BBC News

Explore the BBC

Home News

Sport Weather

Shop Reel

Travel Capital

Culture Future

Sounds CBBC

CBeebies Food

Bitesize Arts

Make It Digital Taster

Nature Local

TV Radio

Terms of Use About the BBC

Privacy Policy Cookies

Accessibility Help Parental Guidance

Contact the BBC Get Personalised Newsletters

Advertise with us Ad choices

Copyright © 2018 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our
approach to external linking.

https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-46098118 15/15