Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Relationship Between a Pediatric Patient's Ethnicity and Risk of Developing Obesity
Rahi Shah
Table of Contents
Rationale of Study 4
Concept Map 5
Chapter 1: Introduction 6
Guiding Questions 6
Hypotheses 6
Assumptions 8
Significance of Study 9
Chapter 3: Methodology 14
Pilot Study 16
Actual Study 16
Data-analysis strategies 17
References 21
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ETHNICITY AND OBESITY 4
Rationale of Study
Obesity, the condition of being excessively overweight, is a rising issue in the United
States. Although it is not a new concept, the word ‘obese’ has found a new meaning into the lives
of many people: normal. Obesity rates have been at a steady increase for many years, but today
there are more cases than ever. Obesity indicators are especially increasing globally among the
pediatric population. Most cases of obesity in the United States are a result of the increased
consumption of fast food as well as the now growing sedentary lifestyle in America. According
to Pacheco et al. (2017), the consequences of childhood and adolescent obesity are extensive,
including both medical and psychosocial comorbidities, as well as increases the risk of
cardiovascular disease and metabolic disorders later in life (Pacheco, Blanco, Burrows, Reyes,
Lozoff, & Gahagan, 2017). Ethnicity is the state of belonging to a social group that has common
cultural traditions; traditions include foods, lifestyle, celebrations, etc. Because people of the
same ethnic group tend to have the same lifestyle, they are likely to have similar average blood
pressure rates, height, and susceptibility to other diseases, such as diabetes and obesity rates.
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ETHNICITY AND OBESITY 5
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ETHNICITY AND OBESITY 6
Chapter 1: Introduction
significant relationship between a patient’s ethnicity and his or her risk for obesity.
This study is in the healthcare sciences field, which is crucial to human health. Obesity is
a rising problem today, especially in pediatrics. The rate of pediatric obesity has gone up the past
decade and continuously is growing. The United States is home to many different ethnic groups
with different traditions and lifestyles. All three of these have some sort of impact on one
another. This study is designed to look at the effects of and relationships among ethnicity and
obesity rates (Pacheco, Blanco, Burrows, Reyes, Lozoff, & Gahagan, 2017, 2018).
Guiding Questions
Q2. How does ethnicity and public policy affect obesity rates in the United States?
Q3. Based on the patients’ ethnicity, what are the risks of obesity?
Hypotheses
H1. If a person's body weight is at least 20% higher than it should be, he or she is
considered obese. For patients younger than 17 years of age, the Body Mass Index (BMI)
should not be above the 87th percentile. Obesity is caused by many factors such as:
genetics, diet and nutrition, lifestyle, certain medications, and insulin problems. (The
H2. Government regulations and laws, such as Michelle Obama’s health initiatives, have
played a role in the rate of obesity of a country (decreasing rates in this case). Cultural
aspects such as the foods citizens eat and lifestyle that the they live also can affect obesity
H3. The ethnicity of the patient and will have a statistically significant relationship with
the obesity of the patient. The independent variable is the ethnicity of the patient, and the
1. Pediatrics: A branch of medicine dealing with children under the age of 18 (Frontini,
overweight and obesity. It is defined as the weight in kilograms divided by the square of
the height in meters (kg/m2) (Teder, Morelius, Nordwall, Bolme, Ekberg, Wilhelm, &
Timpka, 2013).
3. Ethnicity: Shared cultural practices, perspectives, and distinctions that set apart one group
of people from another. Most practices and places define ethnicity has being of
4. Obesity: Obesity is excessive amounts of fat on the body with a body mass index of
20 kg/m^2 or higher. For children, it is measured by percentile, and being above the 87th
5. Quality of Life: A form of measurement used to assess the impact that health has on
things such as life expectancy and way of living, as well as possible causes of death
6. Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act: provides data privacy and security
Assumptions
● Regression Test:
● A child’s ethnicity is the same as what the parent identifies themself as.
● The variables are restricted to ethnicity, height, weight, and BMI percentile.
● Only patient data since the day the internship started can be used.
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ETHNICITY AND OBESITY 9
● There is no guarantee that patients will listen to the provider on how to lose
weight/become healthier.
● The researchers will not include people of mixed ethnicities in the study.
Significance of Study
The significance of this study is to examine relationship between ethnicity and obesity to
give researchers further knowledge on how the two are related. This can help health
professionals understand how and when to start treatment options. It is also beneficial to the
patients because some ethnicital traditions may actually harm the body and it is important for
them to know how to keep themselves healthy. This study focuses on the relationship of ethnicity
and obesity with children in specific, who have become more susceptible to obesity. With
knowledge on the relationship between ethnicity and obesity, the children can be healthier,
measured by Body Mass Index (BMI) percentile. Patients younger than 17 years of age are
considered obese if their BMI is above the 87th percentile. Obesity is caused by many factors
such as genetics, diet and nutrition, lifestyle, certain medications, and insulin problems (Conway
et al., 2018). Being obese can lead to many complications in the future, such as the development
of diabetes. According to Conway et al. (2018), there is a direct correlation between high BMI
and incident of diabetes (Conway et al., 2018). Recently, children have become more
knowledgeable about healthy lifestyles and the basic understanding of diabetes and obesity. A
study by Surani et al. (2018) sought to discover how much knowledge children have on obesity
and its effects. The study found that the children did better the second time the test was taken,
after learning key points and information about nutritional health. (Surani et al., 2018).
Both parents and children view obesity differently. In a study by Koning et al. (2018), the
level of agreement between parents and child reports on lifestyles and health related behaviors
was examined. The researchers measured the children’s height and weight over a three week
period by providing questionnaires to both the child and parent and determined the level of
agreement for five important health related behaviors: breakfast consumption, family dinner,
outdoor play time, transportation to and from school, and time spent on electronic devices. On
average, children did not view bad behaviors-such as watching excessive TV-as unhealthy
behaviors. In matters such as health and care, there can be disagreements between the behaviors
reported by the parents and the children themselves (Koning et al., 2018).
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ETHNICITY AND OBESITY 11
Parenting style can also be a cause of a child’s obesity and weight gain. More children
whose mothers have permissive parenting style are obese than other children (Frontini, Moreira,
& Canavarro, 2016). Children with lower levels of quality of life (QoL) also have higher rates of
obesity (Frontini et al., 2016). Lifestyle can impact to a child’s BMI. From a study done on
children to determine the effects of changing lifestyles, the results showed that the children’s
weight decreased significantly along with parent reports of the children being more physically
active and eating more nutritionally (Teder et al., 2013). Improvements made to a child’s
lifestyle can help them lose weight and lower his or her chances of developing obesity in the
future.
Public policies are different based on the country, especially in the United States. A 2010
policy, the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act (HHFKA) is one such policy. According to Vaudrin,
Lloyd, Yedidia, Todd, & Ohri-Vachaspati (2018), this policy saw change in the foods that
children eat at school and strengthened nutritional standards (Vaudrin et al., 2018). The
implementation of a food and physical activity policy has also affected obesity rates. A study
involving 122 public and private elementary schools in Mexico found that school-implemented
activities became very helpful in getting school children more active and healthy (Theodore et
al., 2018). The two different public policies between the American School System and the
Mexican School system yielded different results. The HHFKA didn’t yield high participation
rates, and according to Essington and Hertelendy (2016), wasted an estimated $432,349 in one
school year with continuously increasing child obesity rates (Essington & Hertelendy, 2016).
However, the Mexican Ministry of Education got children to eat healthier and be more active,
helping child obesity rates decline (Theodore et al., 2018). Policies in the United States
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ETHNICITY AND OBESITY 12
specifically have been engineered to assist in weight loss in children, but it cannot be a 100
percent success due to different ethnic groups’ diets, customs and traditions, and social lifestyles.
However, many of the public policies have helped decrease obesity rates in children and
adolescents.
Different ethnicities and cultures also play a role in a child’s obesity. In Wolaita Sodo
Town, Southern Ethiopia, many families and students had access to teff-the staple food of the
country. According to Teferi, Atomssa, and Mekonnen (2018), “a majority of the 680 families
had access to proper fruits one day a week, and 207 adolescents had fruits three or more times a
week” (p. 8). While most children in Wolaita Sodo Town, Southern Ethiopia were suffering from
undernutrition, there was a similar prevalence of overnutrition. The study concluded that there
was a significant difference nutritional availability and the weights of the children in Southern
In a study by Carof (2017) with the purpose to “seize the national variability of the
physical norms of overweight and obesity by comparing France, England, and Germany” (p. 57),
numerous studies of the views of the citizens of these countries were analyzed, as well as food
and physical activity patterns to determine if there is a relationship between how the country
views its obese people and if the customs of the country play a role on obesity (Carof, 2017). The
study found that gender, age, socioeconomic background, or immigrant origin were important
factors in learning to understand that there are many common and uncommon features about
weight, body, and food in the different countries. Each country has a different outlook on
obesity. In France, people view being slightly overweight as not aesthetically pleasing while in
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ETHNICITY AND OBESITY 13
Germany, being overweight is less problematic. In England, people associate being obese with
In a recent 2017 study done by Nelson et al. (2017), racial and ethnic differences were
measured to see differences in how Body Mass Index (BMI) would change based on the ethnic
and family lifestyles. The research studied 1,461 Caucasian, Hispanic, African American, and
Asian children, Caucasians had lower BMIs in average compared to other ethnicities, and the
intervention program did not cause a large change. (-.15 percent change). African American
children exposed to the program showed a greater decrease in BMI (-1.38 percent change) than
other children did. Children of all ethnicities went through the same intervention program,
regardless of what their natural household traditions might be, and drastic changes were reported.
African Americans had the largest decrease in BMI, while Hispanics had the smallest decrease in
BMI (-.03 percent change) (Nelson et al., 2018). The differing rates between Caucasians’,
Asians’, Africans’, and Hispanics’ weight rates and average BMI percentile indicate that not all
According to the various literature and studies analyzed, ethnic differences in the
most corresponds to my study and research. This study specifically measures relevant data to the
research project. It is the gold standard for the ongoing research project and allows for the
researcher to correctly identify relationships. This study also looks at lifestyle changes and the
effects of that on weight levels, which is important in identifying the proper relationship between
Chapter 3: Methodology
rates in the pediatric patients, the researcher must first collect data about causes of obesity and
different ethnicities. The researcher will then observe and record each patient’s ethnicity, age,
height, weight, and BMI percentage using the patient growth chart for the current visit. The
researcher will also record the frequency of each ethnicity that enters the facility. With pediatric
patients that are obese (87th percentile), the provider, a Certified Pediatric Nurse Practitioner,
will offer suggestions about lifestyle changes and methods to prove the weight and overall health
of the patient. Over the three week course between visits, the patients will follow the provider’s
guidelines and attempt to improve their weight. During the standard three week check-up, the
patients will have a weight check to measure the difference in weights between the two visits.
Again, the researcher will observe the new height, weight, and BMI percentage and compare it to
the baseline set of data. At the end, the mean BMI of the primary visit will be compared to the
mean BMI of the second visit to determine the average change in weight. Using a chi-squared
goodness of fit test, the researcher will either support or reject the original hypothesis.
This design is going to be a qualitative longitudinal case study due to analyzing different
data of pediatric patients over a period of time. The study will utilize both inferential and
descriptive statistics due to using a sample statistics to infer relationships of the population
parameters as well as describing data using measures of center such as the mean. Underlying
- The patients will correctly follow the provider’s lifestyle change plans to help assist in
The role of the researcher is to observe the patients and identify whether there is
relationship between the patients’ ethnicity and their obesity rates. The researcher will assist in
monitoring the patient’s charts. Qualifications of the researcher include signed HIPAA forms
indicating that the researcher has gone through the proper training to work with patients and read
their charts and is a certified emergency medical responder, indicating the researcher’s
knowledge in the medical field. The researcher is also backed by a Certified Pediatric Nurse
Practitioner who supervises and guides the research to collect proper data. Assumptions about
- The researcher has done the proper research on the question before beginning the study.
- The researcher is backed by a professional who has knowledge on the research topic.
The researchers will conduct this study at Nuestros Niños Our Kids Pediatrics. It is a
small pediatric clinic located in Marietta, GA where patients’ ages range from newborn to age
17. Many patients come in for a variety of reasons, including yearly well-checks, breathing
problems, sicknesses, and weight checks. The participants will be all patients that are viewed by
the provider during the researcher’s time at the internship until the last secondary visits reach the
last week of the researcher’s internship. The researcher does not have the exact number of
patients yet, as the number of patients will increase as the study continues.
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ETHNICITY AND OBESITY 16
I. Pilot Study
This research topic will utilize data using a nominal scale because the data will be
categorized into labels such as ‘Obese’ without any quantitative data. Descriptive statistics will
be used when collecting and analyzing data because the researcher is measuring one single
variable-’Is obesity present?’. Measures of center will help organize the data and make it more
concise so testing using a regression test may be done. The hypothesis is stated below:
The ethnicity of the patient will have a statistically significant relationship with the
Changes made on the pilot study include going from a single variable to having two
variables in the research. Also, the research study will not only utilize descriptive statistics, but
also inferential statistics to test the hypothesis to infer relationships of the population parameters.
The testing to conclude data collection and analyzation will also not be a regression test, but a
The type of data that the researcher will use in this study is nominal data because the
subjects are allocated to different categories. For example each patient is categorized by
ethnicity, and further categorized by their BMI to identify the percentages of obesity in each
ethnicity. Both inferential statistics and descriptive statistics will be utilized because the
hypothesis testing and correlation regression testing (inferential). The researcher will also
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ETHNICITY AND OBESITY 17
describe the data using numbers, charts, and graphs, as well as measures of center to analyze the
data. At the end, a description of the entire group for which the numbers were obtained will be
the patient.
Data-analysis strategies
To analyze the collected data, the researcher will use a chi-squared goodness of fit test.
This test will be able to show the statistical significance between ethnicity and obesity rates,
allowing for either a support or rejection of the hypothesis. To do this test, the researcher will
calculate the expected counts using the actual observed counts and dividing it by the total
number of patients. To calculate the chi-squared value and p value, the researcher will use the
following formula:
2
∑ (observed−expected)
expected
The researcher will also calculate the degrees of freedom by multiplying the number of rows
minus one by the number of columns minus one and use the chi-squared chart to obtain the
significance. A blank copy of the tables the researcher will use to collect data is provided below:
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ETHNICITY AND OBESITY 18
Table 1
(lbs)
This data table will record each individual patient’s data, and will be adjusted to fit the correct
number of patients.
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ETHNICITY AND OBESITY 19
Table 2
American
Obese
(BMI>87th
percentile)
Not Obese
(BMI<87th
percentile)
Frequency of
ethnicity
This data table will be used to calculate the total number of patients in each category
One method of ensuring validity throughout this study is that the researcher will be
backed by a certified pediatric nurse practitioner, so that face validity will be ensured throughout
this study. Referencing the patient chart program that allows for the researcher to collect the data
will account for content validity. This program is updated frequently, making sure all patient data
is up to date. Analyzing the data and results and comparing it to other peer-reviewed studies of
the same nature ensures construct validity. One method of ensuring reliability throughout this
study is by collecting the patient data the same way, including proper rounding rules that are to
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ETHNICITY AND OBESITY 20
be followed throughout. Another method of ensuring reliability is to restrict data to current and
future visits only, giving the researcher the most current data to look at. Other methods of
ensuring reliability and validity include following all written protocol strictly so that desirable
results are gained and to perform the study in the allocated time slot given.
The researcher will manage how the study takes place as well as the timeline of the study.
The CPNP will assist the researcher by making sure the researcher is properly conducting the
study. It is the researcher’s job to follow the timeline for conducting the research and getting the
data required for analysis and testing. As per the timeline that the researcher will follow, there
will be a five to six week period in which the researcher will collect data for both the first visit
and second visit of the patient until the final patient has come in for their secondary check-up.
This research topic is replicable, especially since there is a basic methodology that future
researchers may reproduce the study. This study can also be performed in different cities within
the United States, as well as countries outside of the United States. The study provides suitable
data regarding obesity rates and ethnicity and also creates a framework for further research on
the subject.
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ETHNICITY AND OBESITY 21
References
Carof, S. (2017). Is there a 'national body'? How national cultures shape the 'fat' body and the
food practices. Studies in Ethnicity & Nationalism, 17( 1), 57, 64-65.
doi:10.1111/sena.1221
Conway, B. N., Han, X., Munro, H. M., Gross, A. L., Shu, X.-O., Hargreaves, M. K., … Blot,
W.
J. (2018). The obesity epidemic and rising diabetes incidence in a low-income racially
diverse southern US cohort. PLoS ONE, 13( 1), 1-14. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0190993
Essington, M., & Hertelendy, A. J. (2016). Legislating weight loss: Are anti-obesity public
health
policies making an impact?. Journal Of Health Politics, Policy & Law, 41(3), 453-461.
doi:10.1215/03616878-3524008
Frontini, R., Moreira, H., & Canavarro, M. (2016). Parenting stress and quality of life in
pediatric obesity: The mediating role of parenting styles. Journal Of Child & Family
Koning, M., de Jong, A., de Jong, E., Visscher, T. L. S., Seidell, J. C., & Renders, C. M. (2018).
Agreement between parent and child report of physical activity, sedentary and dietary
behaviours in 9-12-year-old children and associations with children's weight status. BMC
Lutz, C. A., Mazur, E. E., & Litch, N. A. (2015). Nutrition and diet therapy. ( pp. 596)
https://www.cdc.gov/obesity/data/childhood.html
Pacheco, L. S., Blanco, E., Burrows, R., Reyes, M., Lozoff, B., & Gahagan, S. (2017). Early
onset obesity and risk of metabolic syndrome among Chilean adolescents. Preventing
Pulgarón, E. R. (2013). Childhood obesity: A review of increased risk for physical and
http://doi.org/10.1016/j.clinthera.2012.12.014
Slavin, Joanne L. (2015). The challenges of nutrition policy making. Nutrition Journal (14) .
dx.doi.org/10.1186/s12937–015–0001–8
Surani, S. R., Hesselbacher, S., Surani, Z., Mokhasi, M., Surani, S. S., Guardiola, J., ...Surani, S.
10.1186/s13104-018-3332-7
Teder, M., Morelius, E., Nordwall, M., Bolme, P., Ekberg, J., Wilhelm, E., & Timpka, T. (2013).
study of child and parent lifestyle interpretations. PLoS ONE, 8(8), 1-4. doi:
10.1371/journal.pone.0071482
Teferi, D. Y., Atomssa, G. E., & Mekonnen, T. C. (2018). Overweight and undernutrition in the
doi:10.1155/2018/8678561
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ETHNICITY AND OBESITY 23
The MNT Editorial Team. (2016, January 05). What is obesity? Retrieved from
https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/info/obesity
insights from the implementation of a food and physical activity policy to prevent obesity
Vaudrin, N., Lloyd, K., Yedidia, M. J., Todd, M., & Ohri-Vachaspati, P. (2018). Impact of the
2010 US Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act on school breakfast and lunch participation
rates
between 2008 and 2015. American Journal Of Public Health, 108(1), 84-86.
doi:10.2105/AJPH.2017.304102