Professional Documents
Culture Documents
INTRODUCTION
Eskom has experience a high numbers of power transformer TABLE 1: Causes of failures
failures as from the period of 1996 – 2004. The high
percentage of these power transformer failures are
Total number of
contributed by internal failures. Eskom is busy carrying out Cause of failure
failures
research studies on the influence of through faults in the Bushing 10
power transformers. This paper concentrates mainly on the Tapchanger 1
inrush currents transients during energization of the Cable fault 6
unloaded transformers. The field testing was carried out and Insulation 72
the data was analysed and presented for debate. A short Lightning 22
overview of the simple controlled switching techniques was Protection 1
presented as the solution to reduce inrush currents. Unknown 11
CIRED2005
Session No 1
TOV’s may exceed the energy absorption capabilities of i. The one main system is consisting of the differential
surge arresters and expose the equipment in the substation to protection, with differential protection relay taking care
overvoltages exceeding their withstand levels [3]. of the high fault level faults.
ii. The restricted earth fault relay and the Buchholz relay
close to the conservator tank. The Buchholz relay is also
TRANSFORMER PROTECTION PHILOSOPHY catering for the high fault level faults, including all
IN ESKOM phase-to-phase faults, which are expected to be quite
heavy in nature.
Transformer protection requirement encompasses a number of
aspects. Of prime importance for an Eskom is the requirement The restricted earth fault also cover the internal earth
to ensure correct, or best possible, operation of the overall faults, including the low fault level faults not detected by
fault clearance system, even in the event of the failure of one the Buchholz relay.
of the components within the protection scheme itself, or the iii. The capability of the overall protection scheme to cater
failure of an external component within the overall fault for high fault level faults is further supplemented by the
clearance system [4]. inclusion of HV instantaneous overcurrent protection and
inputs from tank pressure device, both of which are
Protection regarded as essential for protection of power duplicated.
transformer of normal rating up to including 10MVA
iv. The winding/oil temperature trips are realized as single
inputs but results in the issuing of a trip output to both
circuit-breaker trip coils as a result of cross-tripping.
a) HV Inverse Define Minimum Time (IDMT) Earth Fault
protection (HV winding earthed). The usual HV and MV IDMT overcurrent and earth fault
b) HV IDMT and Instantaneous Phase Overcurrent protection are included to offer local and remote back-up.
protection.
c) HV Restricted Earth Fault (REF). v. Duplicated breaker failure protection for each breaker is
d) HV Breaker fail. provided [4].
e) LV IDMT Phase Overcurrent protection (if no HV IDMT
OC).
f) LV IDMT Earth Fault protection. INRUSH CURRENT MEASURED ON THE
g) LV REF. ESKOM NETWORK
h) Sustained Fault Timer (SFT Timer)
i) Surge devices, pressure devices, oil and winding Inrush current measurements were performed at switching –
temperatures. on of the 275/88kV 315MVA transformer. The measured
inrush currents shown in Figure 1.
Protection regarded as essential for protection of
distribution power transformer of normal rating above
10MVA
Inrush Current - Red Phase
a) Biased differential protection - HV IDMT and
Instantaneous Phase Overcurrent protection. 20
b) HV IDMT Earth Fault protection (HV winding earthed). 10
c) HV REF 0
I (pu)
d) LV IDMT Phase Overcurrent protection (if no HV IDMT -0.1-10 0.1 0.3 0.5 0.7
OC).
e) LV IDMT Earth Fault protection. -20
f) LV REF. -30
g) Tertiary IDMT Phase Overcurrent protection (three Time (sec)
windings).
h) Tertiary IDMT Earth Fault Protection (three windings).
i) Surge devices, pressure devices, oil and winding
temperatures.
The philosophy requires each main protection system to be
able to cater for all types of faults.
CIRED2005
Session No 1
b) Effects of circuit breaker prestrike.
c) Errors in the measurement of residual flux
d) Transformer core or winding configurations that
prevent an optimal solution [5].
Inrush Current - Blue Phase
20 SIMULATION RESULTS
0
I (pu)
CIRED2005
Session No 1
2. @ Applied Voltage phase angle, α = 45 o .
a) Magnetizing inrush current was slightly smaller
at, 0.08Imax = 0.32A
b) The transformer was slightly saturated as shown by
the B-H curve in figure 3.
CONCLUSIONS
CIRED2005
Session No 1
[3] CIGRE WG A3.07, “Controlled Switching of HVAC
Circuit-breakers – Guidance for Further Applications
including Unloaded Transformer Switching, Load and Fault
Interruption and Circuit-Breaker Uprating.”, 09.2003.
CIRED2005
Session No 1