Professional Documents
Culture Documents
INTRODUCTION
This chapter includes the background of the study, general statement of the problem,
A Sanitary landfill is a waste disposal site designed, constructed, operated and maintained
in a manner that exerts engineering control over significant potential environmental impacts
arising from the development and operation of the facility. This is the definition from R.A. 9003
also known as the Ecological Solid Waste Management Act of 2000, an act that ensures the
proper segregation, collection, transport, storage, treatment and disposal of solid waste through
the formulation and adoption of the best environmental practices in ecological waste
management.
According to Philippine Statistics Authority from the 2015 Census Population, Bacolod
City is the second most populous city in Visayas after Cebu City. The city needs to maintain
proper waste disposal and to ensure the presence of a sanitary landfill for garbage collection and
storage.
The absence of a sanitary landfill in Bacolod City will not only violate the law, it will
create a big impact in terms of health and pollution issues on the residents of the city especially
those that resides near the dumpsite. The Department of Environment and Natural Resources
(DENR) Undersecretary Arturo Valdez has warned mayors who are violating environmental
laws. Currently, Bacolod City is violating RA9003 of the Philippines. Its sanitary landfill is no
1
longer operational and is now categorized as an open dumpsite. The violations include Article 2 -
Segregation of Wastes which includes Section 21 and Section 22 or the Mandatory Segregation
of Solid Wastes and Requirements for the Segregation & Storage of Solid Waste. It has also
violated and Section 37 which is the Prohibition Against the Use of Open Dumps for Solid
Waste.
The study will investigate the market, technical, financing, financial, environmental and
administrative feasibility of a new sanitary landfill for Bacolod City. The feasibility of the study
were divided into these seven areas of focus. Each aims to contribute to the serviceability and
Bacolod City built a sanitary landfill last April 19, 2013 making it among the first 5%
Local Government Unit to comply with the sanitary landfill requirement in the whole country.
However, in 2015, the landfill was turned to an open dumpsite. According to Mr. Ramel Palalon,
Public Service Officer II of Bacolod City and is in-charge of the city’s landfill, if segregation
was implemented in the landfill, it will be full by next year. The difference between the expected
and the current situation of the landfill stresses the pressing need of proper waste disposal and
Civil engineers specializing in waste management have designed landfill sites that
engineering, hydrology, and environmental science are involved as soon as a landfill site is
proposed (Kielmas, 2017). The researcher's goal is to have a deeper and clearer understanding of
the landfill problems and current situation to help improve the current condition of the sanitary
2
Landfills present engineers with a variety of challenges, including how to manage land
use, traffic, liquids, and gases, as well as other environmental, civil, geotechnical, mechanical,
and electrical engineering issues (Galvin & Steinhauser, 2017). The researchers would like to
rise up to the challenges by discovering methods appropriate for the feasibility of the new
The current site of the open dumpsite is in Brgy. Felisa, Bacolod City. According to
Pollution Abatement Systems Specialist, Inc. (PASSI) president Julito Pugoy, Felisa is the best
site to host the facility because it has a landfill. It is also the best barangay to host the project
because it is zonified as a heavy industrial zone, and in terms of social responsibility, the
problem is minimal.
Bacolod City should dispose its waste in a sanitary landfill to address the current situation
in compliance with the law as soon as possible. The aim of the study will be focused on the
1.1 The study aims to determine the feasibility of a new sanitary landfill for Bacolod City.
2. Specific Sub-problems
2.4 How much will it cost if a new landfill will be constructed and operated?
3
2.6 Will it comply with the environmental regulations stipulated in R.A.9003?
Statement of Hypothesis
Null Hypothesis
The propose sanitary landfill for Bacolod City is not feasible; in terms of its market
feasibility that asses if there is a need of a new sanitary landfill, technical, financing and
financial, socio-economic, environmental provisions and administrative aspects for operation and
management.
residents, workers of the operation in the landfill and to the city government. It
will also ensure the health of the people, reduce environmental hazards of an open
2. Compliance with R.A. 9003. The violation of R.A. 9003 is prompting the city
government to come up with a new Solid Waste Disposal facility and process.
Thus, eliminating the risks that the current open dumpsite are causing the people
3. City Government. The result from the study can help the government of Bacolod
City in their decision-making regarding their action on how to address the current
4
4. Civil Engineering. The result, findings and recommendation of the study can
with the feasibility of the technical aspect of a sanitary landfill, also considered to
Definition of Terms
Feasibility
Conceptual: A Feasibility Study is the first stage of the product or service development cycle. It
aims to analyze the viability of a proposed project, product or service. It analyzes the proposed
project, product or service with respect to the performance objectives expected by the
organization, and may be include an evaluation of a current system. The feasibility study may
produce a cost benefit report and a project charter to be used as a guide during the analysis
phase. A feasibility study is the process of defining exactly what a project is and what strategic
issues need to be considered to assess its feasibility, or likelihood of succeeding. (Overton, 2007)
Operational: The feasibility study will assess the operational, technical, market, financial,
5
Market feasibility
Conceptual: In general, a market analysis searches for the intersection of demand and supply that
will create a market for a product at a given price, and a feasibility analysis tests whether a
certain product will meet certain financial or social goals in the market. The market study will
examine comparables in the study area to see what scale and amenities will increase absorption
and capture rates. The marketability study is mainly used to describe what conditions are
Operational: In this study market feasibility will determine the demand and supply. It will also
assess the potential return on the investment, absorption and market capture rates and the
project’s timing.
Technical feasibility
Conceptual: Technical and operational feasibility are concerned with whether the proper
resources exist or are reasonably attainable to implement a specific alternative. This includes the
square footage of the building, existing and available utilities, existing processing and material
handling equipment, quality requirements, and skill level of employees. During this process,
product specifications and facility constraints should be taken into account. (Franchetti, 2011)
Operational: Technical feasibility will determine the design and specifications, process of
construction and equipment to be used for the proposed sanitary landfill. The technical feasibility
study will involve evaluating the engineering aspect of the project by applying the principles of
civil engineering.
6
Financial feasibility
Conceptual: Financial feasibility analysis is performed to test whether the project's return will
exceed opportunity costs. Financial feasibility is tested on all types of projects, but the high risk
of real estate development necessitates a successful analysis before proceeding. The financial
feasibility analysis is performed once preliminary drawings and construction cost estimates have
been developed. By combining the results of the market analysis and the cost estimates, the
feasibility analysis will estimate financial returns. Most feasibility analysis include a pro forma
which outlines expenses and incomes in a spread sheet. The feasibility study estimates value
based on market prices and the present worth of the site. Some feasibility studies weigh social
costs and benefits in addition to monetary values. The feasibility analysis will also outline
potential risks and criteria for success. Developers, investors and lenders base many of their
Operational: Financial feasibility study will estimate values based on market prices and the
present worth of the site. It will determine how much will be the cost of the project. A financial
feasibility study involves evaluating the capability of the organization to come up with the funds
Financing feasibility
Conceptual: The use of appropriate technology, combined with good planning and management
can cut service costs, making it possible to charge a reasonable tariff that the users can afford, to
Operational: Financing feasibility will determine who will finance the project if proven to be
7
Environmental Impact
(Jaramillo, 2003)
Operational: Environmental feasibility will determine the effects of the project to the
environment. Environmental feasibility study will involve evaluating the capability of the project
to secure licenses, approvals and permits in a timely and cost effective way.
Administrative feasibility
Conceptual: Responsibility of the local authority: Accordingly, the management and sanitary
final disposal of MSW also reflect the quality of the local management and the commitment of
its leaders, as well as the performance of the highest authority (the mayor). The quality of the
urban cleaning service is an indicator to assess the municipal authorities’ political purpose,
management skills, and responsible attitude toward protection of public health, municipal
workers’ health, and the environment within their jurisdiction. (Jaramillo, 2003)
Operational: Administrative feasibility will determine how the project will be managed
Scope
General purpose: To determine the feasibility of a new sanitary landfill for Bacolod City.
8
Topics studied: Market Feasibility, Technical Feasibility, Financial and Financing Feasibility,
Population:
Limitations
The basis of the study is the historical data of Bacolod City regarding its waste collection
and projection. The study will not include cases of increase and decrease of prices due to
inflation or deflation. The feasibility of the study will be limited to the six aspects to be
investigated which are market, technical, financing, financial, environmental, and administrative
feasibility. Further problems on other aspects to arise not included in the scope of study will not
9
Conceptual Framework
DATA PROCESSING
INPUTS AND ANALYSIS
MARKETING DATA TO DETERMINE FEASIBILITY
OUTPUT
TECHNICAL DATA MARKETING
FINANCING DATA TECHNICAL ESTABLISH FEASIBILITY OR
FINANCIAL DATA FINANCING NON FEASIBILITY
ENVIRONMENTAL DATA FINANCIAL
ADMINISTRATIVE DATA ENVIRONMENTAL
ADMINISTRATIVE
Figure 1. Feasibility of Proposed Landfill for Bacolod City at Brgy. Felisa, Bacolod City
The feasibility of the proposed sanitary landfill will be evaluated through the six aspects
namely; marketing, technical, financial, financing, environmental and administrative. All these
aspects for the feasibility studies are interconnected and may affect one another:
a) Product / Service
b) Process
c) Technology
g) Production cost
2) The marketing feasibility will cover the volume produced and volume capacity.
3) The financing feasibility will cover the investment while the financial feasibility will
include the operation, maintenance and affordable management costs at the local level.
10
5) The environmental factors include negative impacts on soil, water and air that should be
minimized.
Each of the six main feasibility studies will be evaluated by data collection and data
processing procedures setting a criteria in each area. The data collected will serve as the basis for
the technical design of the study considering its market and environmental factors. The technical
aspect will affect the financial, financing and administrative aspect of the landfill. The
environmental and social data can be taken from RA9003 or the Ecological Solid Waste
11
Chapter 2
This chapter includes concepts, ideas and researches relevant to this study and that can
provide insights for the problems discussed in the first chapter. The concepts and researches are
presented in the following order: Local and Foreign Related Literature, Local Studies and
Foreign Studies.
Related Literature
MARKET FEASIBILITY
Quantity of Waste
In the Philippines, where the population has already exceeded 100 million in 2015, and
an average solid waste generation rate of 0.5 kg per capita per day, it can be estimated that an
average of 50,000 metric tons of garbage per day is being generated, of which only 35,000
Recycling offers some of the most pragmatic solutions to reduce the volume of generated
waste. The Philippine Ecological Solid Waste Management Act of 2000, defines recycling as
“the treating of used or waste materials through a process of making them sustainable for
beneficial use and for other purposes, and includes any process by which solid waste materials
are transformed into new products in such a manner that the original products may lose their
12
Improvements in recycling, collection, and disposal will become even more critical as
garbage production continues to increase with population growth and economic development.
Though not yet quite a pervasive practice, organized recycling in the Philippines has picked up in
recent years. According to the National Solid Waste Management Commission (NSWMC),
recycling rates have been increasing, particularly in Metro Manila, from 6% in 1997; 13% in
2000; and 28% in 2006 (Andin, Z; NSWMC, 2007). Among the major reasons for this
improvement are the following: the implementation of RA 9003, the grassroots SWM/ recycling
Based on the 2015 Census of Population, the population of the Philippines as of August
With a total area of approximately 300,000 square kilometers, the population density of
the Philippines in 2015 was posted at 337 persons per square kilometer. This represents an
increase of 29 persons per square kilometer (9.4 percent) from the population density of 308
With an average per-capita waste generation ratio of about 0.5 kg per day, the annual
waste generation in the Philippines is 12 million tons in 2012. This figure is expected to double
by 2025. The National Solid Waste Management Commission (NSWMC) reported that the
13
Capacity of Landfill
The Designed Landfill Capacity (DLC) shall be determined by calculating the product of
the sum of planned waste to be landfilled and soil covered per year, by the number of years that
The municipal solid waste is the combination of different individual waste components,
properties of the individual components controls the overall characteristics of the landfill waste.
properties when MSW is subjected to spatial and temporal heterogeneity. (Tiwari, 2014)
evaluate and predict landfill behavior and hence for landfill operation. However, determining
engineering properties is extremely difficult as mentioned by Manasslero et al., (1997) due to the
following reasons:
waste material
4) Level of training and education of the personnel on site for basic interpretation and
14
5) Heterogeneity of the MSW within the landfill and its variation with geographical
location.
The properties of MSW are determined for designing landfill, particularly bioreactor
landfill. Generally, density, hydraulic conductivity, porosity, compressibility, stiffness and shear
strength are the most important properties of any solid waste. (Dixon and Jones 2005). Density
of MSW is determined to assess volume of transportation vehicle and size of the disposal
TECHNICAL FEASIBILITY
The site layout shall be designed to satisfy all criteria including the siting criteria, and
The site layout shall provide for site entrance, gatehouse, material recovery/recycling
area, structures, access roads, landfill footprint, surface water ditching and management ponds
and leachate and gas management infrastructure if applicable. The site layout should minimize
the potential for leachate and landfill gas impacts offsite taking into consideration groundwater
Site Equipment
loader. A pick-up truck will also be included in the typical on-site equipment fleet (Dillon, et. al.,
15
2007). Other functions requiring equipment are landfill cell preparation, final cover construction,
delivery of drop-off bin wastes to the working face, road maintenance and dust control. Some of
these functions may be performed with on-site equipment, but others may require equipment to
topography of the site, although it is also influenced by the type of soil and the depth of the water
table.
The area method is used on flat terrain, abandoned quarries, depressions, and low parts of
ravines. The features of each individual site will determine whether it is possible to extract the
cover soil from the site or whether it will have to be hauled from nearby places. The area method
consists of depositing the wastes on the surface and laying them against the slope of the inclined
terrain; they are then compacted in sloping layers to form the cell that will afterwards be covered
with earth. The first cells are built at one end of the area to be filled and the work advances to its
The trench method is used when the water table is deep and the gradients of the terrain
are gentle. The trenches can be excavated with earthmoving equipment. This method consists of
depositing the waste at one end of the ditch, placing it against the slope; the workers then spread
and compact the waste in layers using masonry tools until a cell is formed which, at the end of
the day, will be covered with the earth from the excavation. (Jamillo, 2003)
16
Foundation Design
considering unusual aspects related to the mechanics of wastes. Large total and differential
settlements are usually the governing factors in the choice of the foundation types. Shallow
foundation systems are generally preferred to support relatively light structures. Heavier
structures will require deep foundations. However, deep foundations are generally restricted to
older landfill without engineered bottom liner systems. Table 3 summarizes the relative
advantages and disadvantages of deep and shallow foundations on landfills. A detailed overview
on foundations in landfills is given by Phillips et al. (1993), Dunn (1995) and Bouazza and
Seidel (1999).
In assessing the bearing capacity of landfills, one has to keep in mind that the thickness
and the strength of the cover system play a very important role in foundation support. If the soil
cover is relatively thick, then it may provide substantial bearing capacity for shallow
foundations. However, the soil cover may often be thin compared to the foundation size. In this
case, the load for the foundation will be transferred through the cover and will develop its
bearing resistance in the waste. Therefore, a bearing capacity analysis will require evaluation of
the strength of the waste. However, experience has shown that, because of the ductile
characteristics of MSW, large deformations are necessary to activate the bearing capacity of the
waste, and it is difficult to design a structure that will allow such large deformations. Therefore,
while total settlement must be considered with respect to utility connections and building access,
differential settlement tends to govern the structural design of shallow foundations on waste. For
this reason, raft foundations are typically employed rather than isolated footings on waste. In
many cases, if the soil cover is thin, engineered fill is provided beneath the foundation to bridge
17
over non-uniform settlements. Furthermore, the fill can be combined with georgics or high-
tensile geotextiles to create a composite material with a higher rigidity to support larger
Payback period
Landfill cost recovery potential from 8% to 106% of total sanitary landfill costs
(including the gas system), if all revenues go only to landfill cost recovery. However, usually
some revenue needs to cover private developer profit and some is allocated to community
development funding to the host municipality and surrounding neighborhood or waste picking
community. No funds are likely to be leftover for the rest of the solid waste system. When
systems are small and poorly operated, cost recovery potential can be half of the above estimates.
The capital investment portion of the total costs is divided between site development,
equipment purchases and construction costs. The facility development costs are preliminary costs
associated with the entire site (e.g., characterization studies, land acquisition, engineering and
design studies, and permit package fees) thereby occurring only in the first year of operation.
The construction phase typically occurs in stages as required. Only a portion of the site or “cell”
is developed with each subsequent cell being developed as the previous cell nears capacity.
18
Total Landfill Costs
Landfill costs fall into one of four categories: (1) initial construction, (2) cell
construction, (3) operations, and (4) closure as modeled. Initial construction costs consist of
those activities that would be completed prior to operation of the facility, which would not be
repeated for each individual cell. These costs are amortized over the facility life. Cell
construction costs include all engineering design and construction completed for each individual
cell of the facility and are amortized over the life of the cell. Operation costs include all costs
incurred annually to run the facility. Closure costs include all one-time activities conducted after
all cells in the facility are completed, as well as post-closure monitoring and other long-term
activities related to site maintenance after closure. The post-closure costs are amortized over the
life of the facility so that these costs are reflected in the cost of waste disposal. Landfill gas can
be used directly or to generate electricity or steam. The associated revenues can be sold to offset
some of the costs associated with building, operating, and maintaining a landfill. (Barbara Sich
ENVIRONMENTAL FEASIBILITY
Another aspect not to be overlooked by the designer of a sanitary landfill is the need to
consult with the standards currently in force for the design and construction of the landfill and
infrastructure works, and also for the issue of environmental impact (constraints on the project in
order to prevent or mitigate possible negative effects from the construction and operation of the
19
Analysis of environmental impacts
Environmental impact analyses serve to anticipate the positive and negative effects that every
sanitary landfill project has during its different stages: site selection, construction, operation, and
closure. The measurement of these impacts should be interdisciplinary and should be carried out
on the natural components (water, soil and air), of the site and surrounding area as well as on the
According to Republic Act No. 9003 or “An act providing for an ecological solid waste
management program, creating the necessary institutional mechanisms and incentives, declaring
certain acts prohibited and providing penalties, appropriating funds therefor, and for other
purposes.”
Article 1, Section 2 states the declaration of policies wherein it is hereby declared the
policy of the State to adopt a systematic, comprehensive and ecological solid waste management
(b) Utilize environmentally-sound methods that maximize the utilization of valuable resources
(c) Set guidelines and targets for solid waste avoidance and volume reduction through source
reduction and waste minimization measures, including composing, recycling, re-use, recovery,
green charcoal process, and others, before collection, treatment and disposal in appropriate and
20
(d) Ensure the proper segregation, collection, transport, storage, treatment and disposal of solid
waste through the formulation and adoption of the best environmental practices in ecological
(e) Promote national research and development programs for improved solid waste management
and resource conservation techniques, more effective institutional arrangement and indigenous
(g) Retain primary enforcement and responsibility of solid waste management with local
government units while establishing a cooperative effort among the national government, other
(h) Encourage cooperation and self-regulation among waste generators through the application of
market-based instruments;
(i) Institutionalize public participation in the development and implementation of national and
(j) Strengthen the integration of ecological solid waste management and resource conservation
and recovery topics into the academic curricula of formal and non-formal education in order to
Section 40, Article 6 of Republic Act No. 9003 states the criteria for siting a Sanitary
Landfill. The following shall be the minimum criteria for the siting of sanitary landfills:
(a) The site selected must be consistent with the overall land use plan of the LGU;
(c) The site should have an adequate quantity of earth cover material that is easily handled and
compacted;
21
(d) The site must be chosen with regard for the sensitivities of the community's residents;
(e) The size must be located in an area where the landfill’s operation will not detrimentally affect
(f) The site should be large enough to accommodate the community’s wastes for a period of five
(5) years during which people must internalize the value of environmentally sound and
(g) The site chosen should facilitate developing a landfill that will satisfy budgetary constraints,
including site development, operation for many years, closure, post-closure care and possible
remediation costs;
(h) Operating plans must include provisions for coordinating with recycling and resource
Section 41, Article 6 of Republic Act No. 9003 states the criteria for Establishing a
Sanitary Landfill. The following shall be the minimum criteria for the establishment of sanitary
landfills:
(a) Liners – a system of clay layers and/or geosynthetic membranes used to contain leachate and
(b) Leachate collection and treatment system – Installation of pipes at the low areas of the liner
(c) Gas control recovery system – a series of vertical wells or horizontal trenches containing
permeable materials and perforated piping placed in the landfill to collect gas for treatment or
22
(d) Ground water monitoring well system – wells placed at an appropriate location and depth for
(e) Cover – two (2) forms of cover consisting of soil and geosynthetic materials to protect the
(i) a daily cover place over the waste at the close of each day’s operations, and;
(ii) a final cover, or cap, which is the material placed over the completed landfill to control
(f) Closure procedure – with the objectives of establishing low maintenance cover systems and
final cover that minimizes the infiltration of precipitation into the waste. Installation of the final
cover must be completed within six (6) months of the least receipt of wastes; and
(g) Post-closure care procedure – During this period, the landfill owner shall be responsible for
providing for the general upkeep of the landfill, maintaining all of the landfill’s environmental
ADMINISTRATIVE FEASIBILITY
Operational Procedures
The operational procedures employed at any landfill site will have a significant bearing
on its planned development, performance and potential effects on the environment, particularly
effects on site neighbours. The procedures are the following: landfill management plan, staffing
and training, health and safety, site access,waste acceptance and monitoring, roading, visual
impacts, waste compaction, cover, nuisance control, fire prevention, water control, landfill gas
management, and closure and aftercare. (Centre for Advanced Engineering , 2000)
23
Staffing
management of the landfill. Staffing requirements will vary as a function of size, types of wastes,
and diversity and complexity of site operations. Landfill operators should provide adequate
staffing to ensure that during operating hours all continuous tasks (including waste reception, and
security, compaction and covering) are completed in accordance with the landfill management
Related Studies
Local Studies
Market Study
the adjacent community in Cebu City Sanitary Landfill (CCSL), Philippines. Data were gathered
on April, 2011 using interview-questionnaire covering sixty three households. Areas assessed
include the general household profile, perceived opportunities, water resources and utilization,
health status and services, waste management practices, and perception to CCSL management
and institutions. Result showed that households perceived opportunities in CCSL as a result of
employment, resources, and security through informal workforce like scavenging. However, the
adjacent community was found to be at high risk owing to use of contaminated groundwater and
unsafe waste management practices. These threats were manifested through prevalence of
gastrointestinal, respiratory, and dermal diseases. Households also acknowledged the negative
impacts to health and environment however their major concern was accessed to employment
24
upon closure and relocation of CCSL. The study provided basis for policy makers and concern
considering the closure of CCSL. The study gave idea to the researchers on what to consider in
the formulation of the design and considerations for the new sanitary landfill in study.
In the study “Final Report on Consulting Services for Solid Waste Management
Philippines” last April 2007 provided a breakdown of the costs. The table includes a schematic
calculation for a Barangay in Metro Manila with 10,000 inhabitants of mixed population. The
Barangay has initially eight (8) hauling trips per week to collect the Solid Waste. The Barangay
has initially no Eco Aids designated to the Solid Waste Management System. Each item can
naturally be discussed and modified, but the ambition of the table is to show the orders of
magnitude and where the critical costs and revenues are found.
The investments can naturally vary a lot depending on the starting conditions in the
specific Barangay, the level of ambition, stepwise implementation of the new schemes, etc.
However, the order of magnitude, 1,000,000 – 2,000,000 pesos, is a good estimate for a
Barangay of 10,000 inhabitants. An investment of this magnitude is very hard for a typical
Barangay to handle in one step. However, with a good planning of budget allocations over the
25
Waste Management System within just a few years. Experience from various other projects also
shows that there are other sources of funding than only the Barangay budgets.
The use of part of the Property Tax to the Waste Management Fund seems to be
supported by law. Savings and funding are sometimes difficult due to administrative rules and
regulations where a “saving” from one budget year can not be transferred to the following.
However, it seems as if such transfers can be done given one of the basic rules: “If there is a will
there is a way”. Countries that are engaged in various kinds of support to developing countries
sometimes provide so called Soft Loans (or Concessionary Credits) at favorable conditions.
Naturally, a single Barangay cannot get involved in such a financing scheme, but with a good
coordination between Barangays and the City Level or at the Central Government Level (like the
DILG, Department of Interior and Local Government), such financing would bring down the
The latter two types of funding are available especially during election periods. This kind
of sources can, of course, not be utilized in every Barangays when a full scale Solid Waste
Management work is started. The interest on the investment should be included as a cost in a
complete budget estimate. However, since the budgets for investments in a Barangay are
26
provided on an annual basis by City / Municipality, the interest is of no significance on the
Barangay level.
Another study entitled, “Funding Solid Waste Disposal: A Study from the Philippines” by
Antonia Corinthia C. Naz and Mario Tuscan N Naz , talks about the treatment of solid waste as
a major priority in countries across Southeast Asia. Economic development and population
growth, particularly in the region's mega-cities, have made the challenge more acute. This is
particularly true in the Philippines, where the legacy of dangerous open dump sites such as
'Smokey Mountain' have kept the issue high on the political agenda. This study looks at how a
municipal government in one of the Philippines's provinces should organize its solid waste
management plans to meet strict new national targets. It recommends that the local government
charge user fees for its waste collection & disposal services and recommends a level of service
that will reflect people's preferences, However, even with this level of charges, the study warns
of a funding gap and says that the local government may have to divert as much as 25% of its
Environmental Study
A study by Paz B. Reyes, Mabelle V. Portu entitled, “Greening of the Solid Waste
Management in Batangas” can also help improve design the new sanitary landfill. Management
of solid wastes in the Philippines has long been a responsibility of the Local Government Units
in the country since the enactment of Republic Act 9003 also known as the Ecological Solid
Waste Management Act of 2002. In support to the local government of Batangas City, this study
was conducted to propose a plan of action that will enhance the level of implementation of solid
waste management in the city, lessen the harmful effects to the environment and health of the
27
people and find solutions to problems encountered in its implementation. The descriptive survey
method was used with 204 respondents taken by stratified sampling from selected 69 barangays.
A Likert scale instrument was used to measure the level of implementation of solid waste
management practices of the residents and the problems encountered by the residents in the
implementation of solid waste management practices. A checklist determine the effects of the
implementation of solid waste management practices to the environment and health of the people
Data analysis made use of frequency distribution, weighted mean and ANOVA. From the
findings gathered on the level of implementation of solid waste management and the observed
effects to the environment and health of the people including the problems encountered in its
implementation, a plan of action was proposed with the hope of enhancing the level of
implementation of solid waste management thereby lessening its harmful effects and problems to
Leachate Quality from Balaoan Sanitary Landfill in La Union, Northern Philippines” could be
very helpful as well. The study emphasizes that landfills are point sources of pollution. In this
study, it seeks to assess the groundwater and leachate quality in Balaoan sanitary landfill using
physico-chemical and biological characteristics and to compare the results to quality standards.
Proper coordination with authorities, ocular visits and surveys and final evaluation on the study
site were made to ascertain the presence of a leachate pond and deep/tube wells within or near
the facility.
Groundwater and leachate samples were collected through grab sampling during the
months of February and April and sent for laboratory analyses .Except for the Total coliform and
E.coli counts, the physicochemical parameters of the groundwater samples such as pH,
28
turbidity,total dissolved solids, and nitrate were found to conform to the Philippine National
Standards for Drinking Water (PNSDW). Leachate water samples in terms of chemical oxygen
demand were found to conform to the regulatory limit while toxic metals such as cadmium,
chromium, copper, lead and mercury showed very low concentration based on DAO 35, series of
Technical Study
Solid waste management remained to be a serious problem in the country. Despite the
enactment of Republic Act 9003 or the Ecological Solid Waste Management Act, nothing has
improved. The volume of wastes being generated particularly in the urban centres tends to
increase with increased population growth. Improper waste disposal is not only an eyesore but
has serious environmental consequences to the soil, air, ground and surface waters and even to
human health. Groundwater contamination may be the most serious problem caused by improper
waste disposal because, as usually the case in the Philippines where dependence on groundwater
for drinking purposes is very common. Sanitary landfills are the most widely utilized method for
According to Republic Act No. 9003 which states that “An act providing for an
ecological solid waste management program, creating the necessary institutional mechanisms
and incentives, declaring certain acts prohibited and providing penalties, appropriating funds
Article 1, Section 2 states the declaration of policies: It is hereby declared the policy of
the State to adopt a systematic, comprehensive and ecological solid waste management program
which shall:
29
(a) Ensure the protection of public health and environment;
(b) Utilize environmentally-sound methods that maximize the utilization of valuable resources
(c) Set guidelines and targets for solid waste avoidance and volume reduction through source
reduction and waste minimization measures, including composing, recycling, re-use, recovery,
green charcoal process, and others, before collection, treatment and disposal in appropriate and
(d) Ensure the proper segregation, collection, transport, storage, treatment and disposal of solid
waste through the formulation and adoption of the best environmental practices in ecological
(e) Promote national research and development programs for improved solid waste management
and resource conservation techniques, more effective institutional arrangement and indigenous
(g) Retain primary enforcement and responsibility of solid waste management with local
government units while establishing a cooperative effort among the national government, other
(h) Encourage cooperation and self-regulation among waste generators through the application of
market-based instruments;
(i) Institutionalize public participation in the development and implementation of national and
30
(j) Strengthen the integration of ecological solid waste management and resource conservation
and recovery topics into the academic curricula of formal and non-formal education in order to
Republic Act No. 9003, Article 2, Section 21 states the Mandatory Segregation of Solid
Waste; The LGUs shall evaluate alternative roles for the public and private sectors in providing
collection services, type of collection system, or combination of systems, that best meet their
needs: Provided, That segregation of wastes shall primarily be conducted at the source, to
further, That wastes shall be segregated into the categories provided in Section 22 of this Act.
Foreign Studies
Market Study
Management” by Sudhakar Yedla states that waste management, being one of the most important
aspects of urban development, is gaining importance among developing nations. Landfills, which
were initiated for hazardous waste management and subsequently transformed into sanitary
landfills, have been the most widely adapted practice for municipal solid waste management
worldwide. However, the conventional design of landfills not only fails to fulfil the needs of
waste management but also fails to target optimal resource recovery and energy generation. In
the present study, modified design was proposed for partially engineered landfill system based on
theoretical considerations. Its potential for energy generation and resource utilization was
analyzed with a case study of Mumbai municipal solid waste. It was found that the system with
31
modified design could yield 0.157 million tons of landfill gas (0.145 million tons of coal
equivalent) out of one year of solid waste. Further, this could recover resource valued at US$2.49
Sadek* and M. El-Fadel in Lebanon and was published in 2000. As in most developing
countries, municipal solid waste (MSW) disposal has been a chronic problem, particularly in
areas with high population density, high production of refuse, and scarcity of land adequate for
landfills. In such settings, uncontrolled waste dumping along the seashore has been an
unfortunate, yet common practice for solid waste disposal in major urban centers. These
practices along the Mediterranean coast resulted in serious sea pollution problems. Random
disposal activities began around 1975 and were suspended in 1994. Initially, the waste was
limited to household wastes and later included inert fill and construction material. The site
currently covers about 360000m2 and extends about 600 m beyond the original shoreline. During
the period 1975 to 1982, the material dumped was mostly municipal waste with some
construction rubble. At that point 30 000m2 land area had been deposited into the sea. Between
1982 and 1983, large quantities of demolition debris were dumped into the sea north of the
existing waste piles. In addition, the years of war resulted in significant damages to the city
infrastructure, including sewage and wastewater disposal, resulting in the discharge of large
32
Financing and Financial study
The study “Municipal Solid Waste Landfills: Economic Impact Analysis for the Proposed
New Subpart to the New Source Performance Standards” by staff from the Office of Air and
Radiation, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency last June 2014 had given insights about costs
and revenue streams for landfills. Landfill costs are site specific and vary based on factors such
as terrain, soil type, climate, site restrictions, regulatory issues, type and amount of waste
disposed, preprocessing, and potential for groundwater contamination. Landfill costs fall into the
and post-closure. Site development includes site surveys, engineering and design studies, and
permit package fees. Surveys are necessary to determine if a potential site is feasible. Permits are
permanent on-site structures needed to operate the landfill. Cortland County, New York
estimated that the cost for site development and cell construction (not including on-site building
construction) for a 224.5-acre site would be approximately $500,000 per acre (EnSol, 2010). In
2005, a series of articles was written that estimated costs for a hypothetical landfill based on
known market conditions and cost data. The theoretical landfill had a design capacity of 4
million cubic yards and a footprint of 33 acres. The study determined that the cost of
constructing a landfill of this size would be between $300,000 and $800,000 per acre. For the
hypothetical landfill in the study, total building and additional structure costs could total between
$1.165 million and $1.77 million. Operation of the landfill requires a truck scale, scale house,
wheel wash facility, and buildings to accommodate an office and provide space for maintenance.
The cost of each building structure varies depending on its functions and could range from $10 to
33
$100 per square foot. Office buildings cost more while maintenance buildings and tool sheds
cost less. In addition, fencing around the facility and roadways are required and add to the costs
(Duffy, 2005a).
Operating costs of the example landfill include staffing, equipment (payments and
maintenance), leachate treatment, and facilities and general maintenance. Landfill operations and
maintenance activities are performed using a variety of heavy construction equipment with
operating costs dependent on fuel, repairs, and maintenance. Operating costs are relatively small
when compared to the capital costs; estimated annual operating costs from this study are:
• Leachate collection and treatment (assumes sewer connection and discharge cost of
$0.02/gallon): $10,000.
$30,000.
Environmental Study
Hosseini in Iran and was published last July 30, 2015. Open dumping is the common procedure
for final disposal of municipal solid waste (MSW) in Iran. Several environmental pollution and
The objective of this research was to study the suitability of existing municipal landfill sites
34
using geographic information system methods. Tonekabon city in the west area of Mazandaran
province, northern Iran, along the southern coast of the Caspian Sea, was chosen as a case study.
In order to carry out this evaluation, two guidelines were used: Minnesota Pollution Control
Agency (MPCA) and regional screening guidelines. The results indicate that the landfills were
not located in suitable sites and also that there are few suitable locations to install the landfills.
The study entitled “The Challenge Of Future Landfill: A Case Study Of Malaysia” by
Sharifah Norkhadijah Syed Ismail and Latifah Abd. Manaf focuses on Toxicology and
Environmental Health Sciences published last May 16, 2013. Landfilling is the most frequent
waste disposal method worldwide. It is recognized as being an important option both now and in
the near future, especially in low- and middle-income countries, since it is the easiest and the
environmental abatement measures, such as leachate collection systems and lining materials. As
a result, a lot of contamination is inflicted upon the environment. Importantly, even with proper
Another major concern is the appropriate location for landfills to ensure the impact towards the
environment are minimized. This paper highlights the challenge to find suitable place for future
landfill in Malaysia. There is a tendency of landfill to be built on unsuitable area such as near to
residential area or on agricultural land where most of the land are grading as high prospect value
The situation in Sweden, relates a lot in the current situation in the city in sanitary
landfills turning into open dumpsites. Mohammad Aljaradin and Kenneth M Persson elaborates
in their study entitled “Design of Sanitary Landfills in Jordan for Sustainable Solid Waste
35
Management” that Municipal solid waste (MSW) is one of the major environmental problems in
Jordan. World Bank visibility study (2004) showed that the rate of production of solid waste in
Jordan was estimated annually of about 1.46 million ton, and is expected to reach 2.5 million ton
by year 2015 with generation of 0.9/kg/capita/day. This solid waste volume is still increasing at
high rates due to the rapid increase of populations and change in living standards and the
consumption patterns. The Majority of landfills in Jordan are practicing open dumping and thus
cause various environmental problems such as health hazards, surface water and ground water
contamination, odors, etc. Sanitary landfills offer a viable option for the Common Service
Councils (CSCs) which are responsible for operation and management of disposal sites in the
country, to deal with the environmental hazards caused by open dumps practice within its
financial constraints. If sanitary landfills are conducted properly, the negative environmental
36
SYNTHESIS
MARKET STUDY
The estimation and analysis of the capacity and volume of waste of the new sanitary
landfill study can be based on the historical information about the amount of population, average
volume of garbage collected in a certain amount of time and other processes necessary for the
landfill from cities in the country or in the Philippines as a whole. The aim is to come up with a
capacity that can hold the amount of volume of garbage collected to be disposed in the landfill. A
study was cited about the market aspects of a landfill in Cebu City in terms of its market
feasibility. Foreign studies cited, also based their landfill capacity from market studies conducted
TECHNICAL STUDY
This related literature provides insights for determining the equipment, facilities, materials
and process involved in creating the design for the new sanitary landfill . It will provide
procedures and process in searching for a site that will be suitable for the landfill. This study also
provides reference for the technical terms and specifications to be used in the study. It also provided
This study provides estimates for total cost of landfill. Results indicate that volume
specific site. However, this study provides useful information to assist community and county
37
ENVIRONMENTAL STUDY
Environmental related literature stresses the importance of negative effects during site
selection, construction, operation, closure. R.A. 9003 that regulates the protection of public
health and environment information about the environmental risks of landfills. Also, some
procedures stated could be applied in the environmental feasibility of the new sanitary landfill in
Bacolod City.
ADMINISTRATIVE STUDY
provides different functions of an organization that needed to be fulfilled properly so that the
landfill would serve its purpose well. This could help us in creating a project schedule for the
38
Chapter 3
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
This chapter includes the research design, data gathering procedures, and data analyses
procedures.
Methodology
The study aims to determine the feasibility of the proposed sanitary landfill of Bacolod
City. The type of research that will be used for this study is descriptive research, this kind of
research focuses on the current issues or problems done by a process of data collection that
enables them to describe the situation completely than without using this method. To describe
the aspects of the phenomenon, descriptive studies are used. And also, descriptive research is
used to described characteristics and/or behavior of the sample population. The most important
trait of descriptive research that more researchers use this kind of study is that it can employ a
number of variables, however only one variable is required to conduct the study.
The descriptive research has its three main purposes: describing, explaining and
validating research findings. The kind of study is also closely related with observational studies
but not just limited for observation data collection method and case studies. Descriptive study
An effective method to analyze non-quantified topic and issues, possibility to observe the
phenomenon in a completely natural and unchanged natural environment, and its opportunity to
integrate the qualitative and quantitative methods of data collection are some of the reasons why
39
The study aims to determine the feasibility of marketing, technical, financing, financial,
environmental and administrative. The methods of descriptive research is most closely practical
for determining the feasibility of the said studies. Collecting data by historical method, surveys,
observations, interviews, and taking it from a reliable source, are used in the descriptive research.
The procedure for the conduct of a project feasibility study are the following:
1. Market Study
5. Environmental Study
1. Market Study
1.1 Service: The “Proposed Sanitary Landfill of Bacolod City” aims to come up with a
sanitary landfill that is designed and constructed in a manner that exerts engineering
control over significant potential environmental impacts arising from the development
1.2.1.1 Gather records from the local government about the average volume of
solid waste disposed in the landfill per day and per week.
1.2.1.2 Conduct a research about the volume of solid waste disposed in to the
40
1.2.1.3 Determine the number of inhabitants and population in Bacolod City for
the next 5 years using the rate of population growth from the City
Government.
1.2.2.1 Project the volume of the solid waste for the next 5 years based on
historical records.
1.2.2.2 Determine the volume and weight capacity of the proposed sanitary
landfill.
41
Vdaily = DSp / Dmsw
VSLul = VSL x n
1.3.2.3 Estimate the landfill land area for the next 5 years.
AT = F x ASL
From the processed Market Feasibility Analysis on the average volume per day
that solid waste in Bacolod City have and the volume capacity of the sanitary
landfill, determine the discrepancies between its past 5 years and the projection
42
2. Technical Study
The determination of engineering layout and design and its corresponding equipment,
facilities, materials and process involved in creating the design for the new
2.1.3 Asses common topography, type of soil, permeability coefficient and the
2.1.5 Determine raw materials and supplies requirement to include the following:
Specifications
2.1.7 Determine the labor requirements taking into consideration the following:
Production schedule
Pay scale
2.2.2 Use the data from 2.1.3 for the design of the landfill.
43
2.2.3 Select construction method that is suitable for the project study.
3.1.1 Determine total project cost which will include the following:
Equipments
Machinery
Labor
Raw materials
Supplies Requirements
3.2.2 Make a list of labor requirements to include payscale, number and monthly
44
Initial Working Capital
Cost / benefits
Payback period
5. Environmental Feasibility
Determine environmental requirements set forth by R.A. 9003 or the Ecological Solid
Waste Management Act of 2000 and the Environmental Compliance Certificate (ECC)
Visit current site at Brgy. Felisa and check for environmental criteria.
45