Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Lindsay Andrews
Comparative Politics
Dr. Morris
30 March 2018
2
Introduction
Vietnam is a country that has been through a lot since its creation. Vietnam was chosen as a way
to learn more about how they started as a civilization and what happened throughout their history
that has shaped who the people of Vietnam are and what their culture represents and what it means
to the citizens. Choosing Vietnam was a way to better understand the politics behind how the
country runs, given that even today; Vietnam is still a communist run country. Although it seems
that Vietnam is making changes to the way government is run by allowing non-communist parties
to run in elections and participate in politics, it still seems the country doesn’t plan to give up its
communist ways. Given what Vietnam has endured since becoming a country, it will be interesting
to see what drove them to become a successful state and manage to live somewhat peacefully.
Choosing Vietnam opens up discussions about how they became a communist run country and
what its citizens are doing to bring changes to the Constitution and trying to convince the
government they will only succeed and become a more developed country if they were a
democratic nation.
Choosing Vietnam is a way to expand one’s knowledge on development and why the country
remains communist. It is a way to learn more about the unification of the entire country and how
it can be improved upon or changed to match most of the rest of the world as a free state. It is a
way to understand how they gained their independence and formed government that revolved
around the people and how it changed and became corrupt and ultimately started failing the citizens
in Vietnam.
. The country wants to succeed and become a more developed country in the next few years and
many citizens are constantly fighting for democratic change. Discussing Vietnam expands on past,
3
present and future endeavors to remain unified, but also making the necessary changes to have a
Vietnam is on its way to making proper changes, although it still remains unclear when or how
these changes will occur. Seemingly, a unified country has always been a long term goal for
Vietnam, with not much regard to if everybody would mutually agree on the political system and
how the government would run the country. Over the years, especially very recently, many have
begun to speak out against the government, demanding change and fairness for all, in all aspects,
especially since the Communist Party of Vietnam was denying its people basic human rights and
many, many other freedoms and was also taking advantage of its citizens for monetary gain, not
caring the outcome for those affected by the tyranny and corruption.
History of Vietnam
It is said the first ruler of Vietnam, Hung Vuong, founded the nation in 2879 B.C. China would
rule the state from 111 B.C. until the 15th century. At the time it was known as Nam Viet, and the
Vietnamese people themselves are descendants from nomadic Mongols from China and migrants
from Indonesia. During the time China would rule until the 15th century, the country saw an era of
nationalistic expansion and Cambodians were pushed out of the southern area of what is now
Nearly an entire century later, the Portuguese were the first of Europe to enter into the country;
but France would rise to power and establish influence within the country in the early 19th century.
In the next 80 years, France would conquer all three regions in which the country was divided;
Cochin-China in the South, Annam in the central region, and Tonkin located in the North.
(infoplease)
4
By 1887, France would unify Vietnam, creating a single governor-generalship, followed by the
first physical links between the North and South with a rail-road system. In 1940, Japan would
take over military bases in Vietnam, seemingly taking advantage of the internal differences
developing among the three regions of Vietnam. When Japan took over, a pro-Vichy French
administration would remain until 1945. Ho Chi Minh, a communist leader had organized an
independence movement, which was known as the Vietminh, to exploit all the confusion
surrounding France’s weakened influence in all three regions. (infoplease) By the end of World
War II, Ho and his followers and supporters had seized Hanoi and declared a Democratic Republic
of Vietnam, with Ho Chi Minh as president that would only be short-lived and would end quickly
when French forces arrived in 1946. While Ho Chi Minh and his followers wanted a nation that
was modeled after other Communist countries, Bao Dai and many others in the country wanted a
After gaining independence, Vietnam would split into two different regions; North Vietnam and
South Vietnam. They were divided because those in power in the Northern region wanted a
communist regime and country. The north modeled their government after the USSR, which was
also a communist country. Those who lived in the southern region of Vietnam, were against
communism and didn’t want to live under communist rule; they wanted a democracy labeled after
Paris would then propose a unified government within the French Union under the former
Annamite emperor, Bao Dai. Cochina-China and Annam would accept the proposal and Bao Dai
was then proclaimed emperor of all Vietnam in 1949. Ho Chi Minh and the Vietminh would
withhold support and the revolution happening in China gave the Vietminh the outside help that
they had needed to begin a war of resistance against the French and Vietnamese troops, who were
5
armed heavily by the United States who were worried about a cold war communist expansion.
(infoplease)
North Vietnam – Viet Cong and North Vietnamese Regular Army – was a communist nation lead
by Ho Chi Minh and General Giap, and was backed and supported by the Soviet Union and China.
South Vietnam – South Vietnamese Army -, was led by Diem and the military and were backed
On May 5th, 1954, a bitter defeat at Dien Bien Phu in Northwest Vietnam, had broke the French
military campaign and resulted in the division of Vietnam. (infoplease) In the newly created South,
prime minister under Bao Dai, Ngo Dinh Diem deposed the monarchy and made himself president
in 1955. Diem had a strong United States backing and used it to create an authoritarian regime
that suppressed any and all opposition, but were unable to completely eradicate the Northern
supply Communist Viet Cong. The tensions and differences would result in a full-scale war with
escalating U.S. involvement. What would follow was a U.S. inspired military coup, would oust
Diem on November 1, 1963. The worst of the fighting during the war would occur in early 1968
The Vietnam would last roughly 20 years and proved to be long and costly, and it pitted the North
Vietnam Communist government against South Vietnam and its principal ally in the United States.
The conflict between the two regions was only intensified by the ongoing Cold War between the
United States and the Soviet Union. During the war, more than 3 million people, including over
58,000 Americans, were killed, with more than half of them being Vietnamese civilians.
6
Opposition to the war in the United States would completely and bitterly divide Americans, even
after President Richard Nixon had ordered the withdrawal of U.S. forces in 1973. Communist
forces would bring an end to the war by seizing control of South Vietnam in 1975 and the country
The citizens of Vietnam who were pro-war, supported the war against communism, were provoked
and motivated by the United States and wanted to prove that a military with the right strategy could
defeat and stop the spread of communism. Those who were anti-war believed the war a civil war
dealing with nationalism and the United States had no right to intervene and they also believed
The current politics of Vietnam revolve around a single-party socialist republic framework, where
the President of Vietnam is the head of state and the Prime Minister of Vietnam is the head of
government. This is a one party system that is led by the Communist Party of Vietnam. The
Executive Power is exercised by the government and the President; the Legislative Power is vested
in the National assembly of Vietnam, and the Judiciary is independent of the executive power. On
November 28, 2013, Vietnam’s parliament adopted the current Constitution of Vietnam, which is
the fifth one that has been drafted. The current Constitution was adopted by the Thirteenth National
The President of Vietnam gets elected by the National Assembly for a five year term and acts as
the commander-in-chief of the Vietnam People’s Armed Forces. The President also serves as
Chairman of the Council for Defense and Security. The government, which is the main executive
state power of Vietnam, is headed by the Prime Minister. The executive branch of government is
7
in charge of and responsible for political, economic, cultural, social, national defense, security and
The National Assembly is a unicameral legislative body and consists of 500 members who are
elected by popular vote to serve four year terms. According to Vietnam’s Constitution, the
legislature is the highest organ and power of the state. The Legislative powers include, enactment
of the constitution and its laws, supervising the Government of Vietnam, and other holders of
public power, and also includes appointing members of the Judiciary. The Constitution of Vietnam
and its current legislation are to provide for regular elections for the office of the President of the
The Supreme People’s Court is the highest court of appeal in Vietnam; and there are other
specialized courts that include the Central Military Court, the Criminal Court, the Civil Court and
The country of Vietnam is a one-party Communist State and also has one of South East Asia’s
the year 2020. The country once again became a unified nation in 1975 when the Northern
Communist armed forces would seize control of the Southern region of Vietnam. The population
of Vietnam is 92 million citizen’s, the country’s major language is Vietnamese, the dominant
religion is Buddhism, life expectancy for men is about 73 years, and for women, its 81 years. The
currency of Vietnam is the Dong, the United Nations and the World Bank. Because of the
Communist rule in current Vietnam, they still control who can and cannot run for elections or enact
policies they agree with. The Communist Party seemingly controls everything revolving around
8
who runs the country and for how long. This may/can cause anarchy as the citizens who want
the center. The political tradition of the country is applying borrowed ideas to indigenous
conditions and in many different ways, Marxism represents a new way to express old, but
The most major and significant influences of the Vietnamese political culture were of Chinese
origins; a hierarchy culture that would later rub off on Vietnam’s policies in the future, influencing
the government and how it was run before succumbing to communism in the north. The main
political institutions of Vietnam had been forged by 1,000 years of Chinese rule. The Chinese
system was based mostly on Confucianism and had established a political center by loyal and
dedicated subjects.
Those who had ruled did so with the “mandate of heaven”, although these rulers were not
themselves considered to be divine. They did however, rule by divine right by reason of their
virtue, which was manifested by compassion for the welfare of the people. A monarch that had
possessed these traits of compassion would gain unconditional loyalty from the subjects. The
selection of bureaucratic officials was based solely on the basis of civil service instead of heredity.
Government institutions in the country were viewed as conduits for the superior wisdom of the
rulers.
The political culture in Vietnam is gradually transforming from totalitarianism to pluralism. This
is happening due to an emerging and independent civil society that is openly challenging the
9
communist party rule. (Nguyen) The best example of this opposition is a petition that was signed
members and retired high-ranking officials of the communist government. (Nguyen) In 2013,
Group 72 had submitted their own Western-style version draft constitution to the Vietnamese
legislature and in the document, they requested a multi-party and inclusive election, and even
called for Vietnam to transform the country from a one-party state to a democracy.
Since the movement started by Group 72, many other movements in Vietnam have come forward,
which include, Declaration of Free Citizens; Declaration 258, which was started by a group of
bloggers. Many more recent movements have included an open letter that circulated around the
internet, was written by a veteran communist party member calling for the founding of a new
political party that could compete with the Communist Party of Vietnam. (Nguyen)
Many of the dissenting members of civil society are Communist Party of Vietnam members who
once held senior offices in government are speaking out because they are frustrated by the decline
of Vietnam. As of 2013, it had been 70 years since the Communist Party took power in the north
of Vietnam. Approximately 38 years since it took over the country, and never in that time has its
ruling and legitimacy been challenged until now. The reason for the opposition and uprising is due
to the fact that the communist party is and has been failing its people. (Nguyen)
There are several reasons for the failure of the communist party, one which has to do with how
corruption is rampant in Vietnam, but is not addressed effectively. The government in Vietnam is
built on patron-client relationships. Another reason members are speaking out has to do with the
authorities evicting people from their land for construction projects, even though farmers account
10
for 80% of Vietnam’s population and are loyal believers of the Communist Party. Land in Vietnam
In addition to corruption and forcing citizens from their land, human rights and freedoms are being
violated, including the right of demonstrators protesting China’s aggressive movement in the South
China Sea. The economy of Vietnam is also at risk of sliding into a deep stagnation.
Civil society activists point out that all these problems surrounding Vietnam are institutional
problems. The productivity of the labor force is being repressed because human creativity and
freedoms are not and cannot flourish. Many believe and point out that only when the party-state
transforms to a pluralist democracy will Vietnam escape the social and economic crises it is
Civil Society
The broad based political organization of the Communist Party of Vietnam combined with the
tradition of a one party state allowed little to no space for growth of an independent civil society.
(Sabharwal & Huong) Since the political and economic context is rapidly changing and is
characterized by opening up the economy and a move towards global integration; it has led to the
emergence of social groups outside the communist party. Vietnam can be described as as
characterized by a low, but increasing tolerance of civil activity, although civil society remains a
po The Communist Party of Vietnam maintained its power and control over all public affairs and
would punish those who challenged its monopoly. In 2016, authorities would restrict basic rights,
which included freedom of speech, opinion, association and assembly. All religious groups were
required to register with the country’s government and had to operate under surveillance. (Thinh)
11
Bloggers and activists would face daily harassment and intimidation from police, and were also
subjected to arbitrary house arrest, restricted movement and physical assaults. Many of them would
end up detained for long periods of time without any access to legal counsel or even family visits.
The number of bloggers and activists that were known to be convicted and sentenced to prison
would almost triple from the previous year of 2016, from 7 to at least 19. (Thinh)
The Vietnamese government is known to frequently use vaguely worded penal code provisions to
against the state”, and “abusing the rights to democracy and freedom to infringe upon the interests
It has been proven that the existence of civil society and its vibrant activism contribute to a nation’s
development and democratization. With the help of social media networks, in recent years, citizens
in Vietnam are more updated and engaged in public affairs and are even more likely to challenge
the legitimacy of the government and the communist party’s monopoly rule. (Nguyen) These
communities are engaging in activities, such as calling for demonstrations and protests or exposing
corruption.
This has many believing that a civil society already does exist and that democratization is coming
in the two regions. For both civil society to operate and democratization to occur, there must be
things like freedom of association, freedom of speech and independent press, and unfortunately,
many theorists in most western civil societies, would agree that all of these are absent from
Vietnam.
12
Many know they cannot be too optimistic about the existence and ongoing democratization in
Vietnam, but there is no doubt there is a solid foundation for change and it is only a matter of time
before Vietnam will eventually make these changes away from the communist party to keep
Despite being a one-party state, Vietnam’s political system has often been responsive to peasants,
workers and others who are pushing for better economic, social and political conditions.
(Kerkvliet) As of 2012, it has been unclear whether the Vietnamese Communist Party and its
government are responding appropriately to the mounting demands to further improve the majority
of the people’s lives. There has been very clear evidence of demands and have become far more
vocal in recent years, compared to what it was in the mid-70s to the mid-90s when Vietnamese
In Vietnam, the electoral system consists of the President being elected by the National Assembly
and serves a 5 year term. The Prime Minister is appointed by the president, and inside the National
Assembly is 500 members elected by absolute majority vote through a two-round system to also
In modern day times, disgusted and angry citizens are demonstrating almost daily at government
and Communist Party offices in Hanoi, and other places. Many citizens will travel long distances
in hopes of making provincial and national authorities to listen to their complaints, read their
During these demonstrations, which can range from only a dozen, to many thousands, participants
will hold placards, wave around banners and distribute lists of complaints to anybody passing by
or even within reach. The majority of these criticisms are against local and provincial officials who
13
will seize their farmlands while paying miniscule compensation, and then will give their property
to investors and developers in exchange for huge amounts of money and other benefits. (Kerkvliet)
The demonstrators share a common belief that these corrupt officials are stealing not just the
people’s lands, but also their livelihoods. Nationalists are lambasting the Vietnamese government
for appearing to do nothing in significance to counter Chinese incursions into Vietnamese territory
In the first 20 years of economic renovation, the transition economy of Vietnam had enjoyed many
remarkable achievements, from 1986 to 2006. The economy would grow at an average annual rate
of 7.5% from 1991-2000. The Amended Constitution of 1992 would recognize the role of private
sector in the economy. (Vuong) Vietnam’s stock market would make its debut in trading in 2000,
and the U.S.-Vietnam Trade Bilateral Agreement was signed in 2001. Along with the impressive
economic achievements, Vietnam had also seen its diplomatic and political status was constantly
In 1986, the economic reforms initiated in Vietnam, known as Doi Moi, had a goal of creating a
socialist-oriented market economy. The communist government in the north and the Democratic
Republic of Vietnam in the south, would adopt a centrally planned economy. Under the command
economy, the central government decided to output targets and prices, input supplies, domestic
wholesale and retail trade and also international trade. The state of Vietnam was aiming to create
By then, Vietnam had established diplomatic relations with more than 170 countries around the
world, strategic partnerships with 12 important economies, both developed and emerging. Vietnam
14
would also successfully host important events, which included the Asia Pacific Economic
Cooperation in 2006.
Since 2008, Vietnam’s Gross Domestic Product pace of expansion has slowed down significantly,
with the rate declining to 5% in 2012, which is the lowest level its hit in 13 years. The macro
economy faced paramount turbulence, large trade deficit, high inflation, overwhelming business
sovereignty confrontation with China in the South China Sea. (Vuong) In Vietnam’s history, it had
barely seen economic prosperity that lasted for decades. Up until the early twentieth century, the
feudalist nation was a small and outdated agrarian country with continuous wars and constant
invasions from the North –mostly China and Mongolia- and other conflicts with its South West
In 1989, Vietnam had quickly grown to become the world’s third largest rice exporter, following
China and the United States. The policy-makers had been the core element to bring about change
in macroeconomic management in the 1990s although the Communist Party of Vietnan had
The United States expressed commercial interest in Vietnam’s growing economy and strategic
political interests to work with allies and friends in order “to promote stability and development
by integrating Vietnam more fully into existing East Asian Order”. (Vuong) Over $10 billion U.S.
dollars from the FBI had entered the country in 1996 together with billions of dollars also coming
from the World Bank and the Asian Development Bank. Vietnam’s Gross Domestic Product would
grow at 9.5% and 9.3% annually in 1995 and 1996, the highest rates recorded in the post Doi Moi
period. (Vuong)
15
Integration in the international markets brought about new market opportunities and would help
the country to deepen its reform. This would also expose the country to some contagious risks, and
although less hurt by the Asian financial crisis in 1998 than other major Asian economies, Vietnam
With an average GDP growth of 7.5% in the period of 2000 to 2005 and ranking at 58 th largest
economy in the world in 2006, Vietnam would look little compared to other economies in
Southeast Asia. The rapid growth rate would succumb to a ‘resource curse’ problem as evidence
would show that the economic growth heavily relied on overconsumption of physical assets and
capital endowments while innovation and productivity were not the main focus. This would
Vietnam faces renewed challenges for further reform. The country at this point faces two different
options: the country continues with the same pace of change and risk falling economically behind
neighboring countries, or to undertake a more radical economic reform and possibly risk losing
control of the country. Evidence has recently suggested that prescription for economic reforms
cannot be carried out effectively without modernizing the Communist Party of Vietnam’s political
decision-making progress.
Amidst strengthening recovery in the global economy since late 2016, Vietnam’s Gross Domestic
Product had expanded by 5.7% during the first half of 2017, all while inflation has so far moderated
and the core inflation remains fairly low at less than 2%. (Ngan)
According to the latest World Bank bi-annual economic report on Vietnam, the service sector –
which accounts for approximately 42% of the GDP- had accelerated in 2017, and was driven by
16
retail trade growth, as a result of sustained growth of domestic consumption. Industrial growth
remains robust, even though there has been a significant reduction of output in the oil sector, and
growth has begun to gradually recover in agriculture, although the recovery is still considered
fragile. (Ngan)
The monetary policy continues to balance the growth and stability objectives, with low interest
rates and rapid credit growth of about 20%. The same report notes that after a large surplus in
2016, the external current account balance of Vietnam started to decline in early 2017, which was
Looking to the future, Vietnam’s medium-term outlook remains positive, with real Gross Domestic
Product growth expected to accelerate slightly to 6.3% in 2017, which is a result of buoyant
which was aided by a recovery in external demand. (Ngan) Inflation is expected to remain
moderate, reflecting a more stable core inflation, lower food and energy prices and diminishing
administrative price hikes. The most current account is expected to remain a surplus, at a lower
level as stronger import growth resumes. Over this current medium-term, Vietnam’s growth is
The more long term challenge for Vietnam is to be able to sustain rapid growth and poverty
reduction. Considerable gains are achievable from structural reforms that would alleviate
Conclusion
17
In early 2017, drought had affected farming, while mining had faced high production costs and
declining sales prices abroad. (Jennings) In January 2018, United States President Donald Trump
made the decision to withdraw from the Trans Pacific Partnership pact, which would further whack
Vietnam as a signatory and major exporter. Policymakers then feared that the country would miss
their growth targets. These setbacks would be seen as blips for Vietnam’s overall $202 billion
Gross Domestic Product. The Communist Vietnam that had opened to foreign investments in 1986,
is still seeing success and buildup of that capital from offshore. (Jennings) Many foreign investors
involved in places like electronics and polyester yarn factories still favor Vietnam due to its low
costs, abundance of labor, and the country’s matter-of-fact permitting process. This continued
growth has also helped in making people more wealthy, with just 13.5% of the population in
poverty. (Jennings)
According to the Ministry of Planning and Investment, registered foreign investment had increased
44% year-on-year up through to December to a total of $29.68 billion. Foreign operated factories
make their goods mainly for exports and exports in Vietnam had risen 23% to $155.24 billion over
most of 2017. Most of Vietnam’s offshore investments comes from South Korea, Singapore, Japan,
and Taiwan, all places where manufacturing costs more than in Vietnam. (Jennings)
Investors usually look for a labor force that is young, and can be trained easily, and who are willing
to work for a minimum wage of $172 per month. About 60% of the 93 million Vietnamese citizens
are of working age. Vietnam has been poised to remain among the world’s fastest growing
economies as new factories open and direct foreign investment rises. (Uyen) In July of 2017, the
central bank cut its benchmark interest rate for the first time in three years, giving the economy
Vietnam’s government plans to lower the banks’ lending rates and will ensure fund availability for
loans to companies, while also controlling the credit quality. Authorities also plan to tighten up
their control to narrow the trade deficit while boosting Vietnam’s domestic sales. Vu Hong Thanh,
who is the head of the National Assembly’s Economic Committee, stated that the government also
“needs to ensure it can control inflation and continue to improve the investment climate for
businesses”. Thanh also said that officials must also avoid risks such as fueling a bubble in the
stock and property markets and must also quicken restructuring of state companies.
Although Vietnam has experienced impressive and substantial growth economically over the last
few years, it would seem they still need a lot of growth when it comes to politics, government and
the way the country is being run. Many who oppose the Communist Party of Vietnam, those who
speak out against the government and those who are seeking freedom of speech or freedom of
religion are being persecuted within the country. They are continually harassed and monitored,
taking away their privacy and rights. The government cracks down on those who don’t share the
The persecution and unfairness doesn’t seem to stop those who want change within Vietnam, as
they continue to fight, protest and demonstrate the government’s tactics. The Communist Party of
Vietnam is and has been in full and complete control of the country and uses fear and corruption
to their advantage. They want to and plan to continue to stay in power in Vietnam, with unity still
being a main goal despite how so many are against the Communist Party and believe the country
Many do hope that Vietnam can make a more political change to keep up with how well the
economy is doing. Vietnam has been proven to have a had a rough time since its official creation,
19
having always been ruled under another country and not having much of their own independence
When the Communist Party first came to light in Vietnam, it was to fight back against those who
ruled, it was a way to drive out foreign forces in the country to finally become their own Nation
up until when the Vietnam War would break out, due to conflicting beliefs over how Vietnam
should be run.
Vietnam seemingly is trying to change despite the harassment and intimidation, but the country
still has a very long way to go in creating a new government, that could hopefully go back to
revolving around the welfare of its citizens, instead of focusing on making money and oppressing
those with a voice and strong opinions on government. Since Vietnam broke free of Chinese and
French rule, things would take a drastic turn for the citizens who had freedoms and human rights.
Things seemed peaceful, with both regimes having a significant amount of loyal followers and
supporters. Once the country adopted Communist traits from other countries, mainly heavily
influenced by the Soviet Union during the Cold War, everything would seemingly decline and
Vietnam wouldn’t and still may not be considered a developed or strong state.
After things in Vietnam would continue to get worse, especially during the 20 year Vietnam War
that would change the whole dynamic of the Republic of Vietnam and enter into a state of failure.
The failure would consist of citizens being taken advantage of and deprived of what they all knew
they deserved.
These activists don’t plan on abandoning their beliefs and continue to hope that their home country
of Vietnam could eventually become better, greater and more successful than it already is and they
20
are hoping the Communist Party can one day make the political change it unfortunately,
desperately needs.
Hai Hong Nguyen, “Vietnamese Civil Society Bringing Political Change, 2013
Gita Sabharwal & Than Thi Thien Huong, “Civil Society In Vietnam”, 2005
21
Nguyen Hong Ngan, “Vietnam’s Economy Shows Fundamental Strength, With Stable and
Nguyen Diem Tu Uyen, “Vietnam Forecasts 6.7% Economic Growth in 2018”, 2017