You are on page 1of 11

    


  
    


  #
!!-%#)%!)!-/'.3*")#%)!!,%)#
/) )%0!,-%.3$**'*",.-) *((/)%.%*)
'(5
)%0!,-%.31! !)


  Design Sciences, Faculty of Engineering, Lund
University, Sweden

 Design Sciences, Faculty of Engineering, Lund


University, Sweden

  

$%--./ 3!0'/.!-)!1+! #*#%++,*$%(+'!(!).! %)(.!,%'*/,-!-"*,+,* /. !-%#)


-./ !).-.$!'*,'!0!'! /.%*).!,%'! /.%*)1%.$%).$!"%!' *" !-%#)! /.%*)..!$)%'
"/'.%!-$-%)#!)!,'-.,*)#.!$)%'"*/-!#-!'!.%)#(.!,%'-1%.$+,! *(%))."*/-*)
!)#%)!!,%)#+,*+!,.%!-*"(.!,%'-,* /. !-%#)! /.%*).$!'*,'!0!')!! .**""!,(.!,%'
*/,-!-.$.+,!+,!-.$! !-%#)-./ !).-.*1*,&*.$*)%)-+%,.%*)') )'3.%''!0!'-%)(.!,%'
-!'!.%*)+,*!--!-,'3%).$! !-%#)! /.%*)-./ !).-*".!)$0!+,!*)!+.%*)*"(.!,%'-
) .$!3)!! .*!%).,* /! .*)*+!)(%) ! %)-+%,.%*)'(.!,%'-!'!.%*)+,*!---! *)
-%!).%"% !-%#)(!.$* -$!) !0!'*+%)#)!1/,,%/'/("*,.$!(.!,%'*/,-!-%.%-%(+*,.)..*
.!$(.!,%'-) +,* /.%*)(!.$* -%)*).!2./'%4! -!..%)#1%.$!(+$-%-*)$*1(.!,%'-)
!++,*$! %) !-%#)+,*!--!.$* -)!-!!)-(!).'.**'-.$.% -.$! !-%#)-./ !).-
%))0%#.%)#*(+'!2%.3) *""!,-.$!(-.,/./,!.* !'1%.$/)"(%'%,.!,,%.*,%!-".!,)
!0'/.%*)1!-!'!.! -*(!(!.$* -#/% !'%)!-) .**'-.*%).!#,.!%).$!() .*,3(.!,%'
*/,-!-"*,.$!+,* /. !-%#)-./ !).-!#.$!2+,!--%0!!)-*,%'.'-!)%)#,%0!).!,%'-
!'!.%*)) .$!.!,%',%0!)!-%#)(!.$* $!%(+'!(!)..%*)1!,!( !%).1*-.!+-%)*, !,
.*.!-.!0'/.!) "/,.$!, !0!'*+",(!1*,&"*,.!$%)#(.!,%'-*/,-!-.*+,* /. !-%#)
-./ !).-$%--./ 3*)'3,!+*,.-.$!"%,-.-.!+*"%(+'!(!)..%*)-%)!.$!-!*) -.!+%-/) !,
!0!'*+(!).) 1%''!%(+'!(!).!  /,%)#/./()  


 
.!,%',%0!)!-%#) .!,%'! /.%*) ,* /. !-%#) .!,%'-!'!.%*) !$%)#+,.%!

$%--./ 3!0'/.!-)!1+! #*#%++,*$%(+'!(!).! %)(.!,%'*/,-!-"*,+,* /. !-%#)
-./ !).-.$!'*,'!0!'".!,-!0!,'3!,'*)#+,*!--*"#.$!,%)#&)*1'! #!#%)%)#!2+!,%!)!
) "%)'%4%)#)!#*.%.%*)-1%.$%)0*'0! -.&!$*' !,-1!%(+'!(!).! )!1/,,%/'/(%).$!
"/) (!).'(.!,%'-*/,-!-.$.,!() .*,3"*,'',* /.!-%#)-./ !).-$!, %'-$%".%)
$*1+,* /. !-%#)-./ !).-,!./#$.(.!,%'-) ()/"./,%)#(!.$* -1-+*--%'!".!,
.,)-"!,,%)#,* /.!-%#)! /.%*)",*(.$!.!$)%'"/'.3.*.$! !-%#)"/'.3

  '%0!.%0! +.%0!


182
66*'$')+00+0)1(6*''&7%#6+10&'5+)0567&'0651(6'0*#8'.+/+6'&-019.'&)'1(/#6'4+#.5#0&6*+5
-019.'&)'+51(6'0$#5'&102'4510#.':2'4+'0%'5#5.+0)'0#7
  *'567&;+0&+%#6'56*#6
#%6+8+6;$#5'&14C*#0&510D.'#40+0)%1/$+0'&9+6*5%+'06+(+%70&'456#0&+0)1(/#6'4+#.5+/2418'6*'
567&'065D#$+.+6+'561#46+%7.#6'#0&/#-'+0(14/'&&'%+5+105+0#&'5+)0241%'5541('55+10#.'5+)0'45
#4'6;2+%#..;4'564+%6'&$;#9'..&'(+0'&2#.'66'1(9'..70&'45611&/#6'4+#.56*#6#4'4'#&+.;#8#+.#$.'
#((14&#$.'#0&#%%'55+$.'"+6*-019.'&)'#0&#&''270&'456#0&+0)1(/#6'4+#.5+6+52155+$.'61
%*#..'0)'6*'/'%*#0+%5#0&/#07(#%674+0)9+6*+06'..+)'0651.76+1056*#616*'49+5'/#;016$'':2.14'&
 *1/2510
 
0+6+#.5'%6+1051(6*+5#46+%.'24'5'066*'&+.'//#1(6*'241&7%6&'5+)0'&7%#6+10#66*'6'%*0+%#.(#%7.6;
"'6*'0&+5%7556*'75'1(/'6*1&5+0&'5+)0'&7%#6+10#0&24'5'06#5'61(/'6*1&5(170&+06*'
4'8+'9'&.+6'4#674'10/#6'4+#.5':2'4+'0%'/#6'4+#..'#40+0)/#6'4+#.5'.'%6+10#0&6+0-'4+0)9+6*
/#6'4+#.5"'6*'0176.+0'6*'0'92'&#)1)+%#2241#%*#0&+65+/2.'/'06#6+10+069156'25+06*'
241&7%6&'5+)0'&7%#6+10#6$#%*'.14.'8'."'6*'0&+5%7556*'4#&+%#.2'&#)1)+%5*+(66*#61%%744'&
9*'0+/2.'/'06+0)6*'0'9%744+%7.7/+0#..;9'4'(.'%6106*'$'0'(+65#0&&4#9$#%-51(174
#2241#%*#0&57))'56216'06+#.+/2418'/'065
   
   
'5+)0'&7%#6+10#66'%*0+%#.(#%7.6+'5+51(6'0%*#4#%6'4+<'&$;#%744+%7.7/(14/#6'4+#.5'&7%#6+109+6*
#24'&1/+0#06(1%75106'%*0+%#.2412'46+'57'61.10)5%+'06+(+%#0&6'%*01.1)+%#.64#&+6+106*'
'0)+0''4+0)&+5%+2.+0'*#5#9'..&'8'.12'&%744+%7.#(14/#6'4+#.'&7%#6+105722146'&$;6':6$11-5
&+)+6#.611.5'6%(('%6+8'%1//70+%#6+101(/#6'4+#.-019.'&)'#0&&'5+)0-019.'&)'$'69''06*'691
&+5%+2.+0'5/#6'4+#.5%+'0%'#0&&'5+)0*#52418'061$'%*#..'0)+0)&7'616*'+4&+(('4'06
2'452'%6+8'510/#6'4+#.50)+0''4+0)567&'065#6$#%*'.14.'8'.567&;9'..'56#$.+5*'&6':6$11-59+6*
5%+'06+(+%-019.'&)'6*#6+5C7037'56+10#$.'D#0&&'8'.12'&&74+0)6*'2#56691%'0674+'57%%+#4'..+

  *+5-+0&1(C%106'06-019.'&)'D%#0$'5''0#556#6+%#0&&+((+%7.661#22.;+0#012'0'0&'&
.'#40+0)':'4%+5'6;2+%#.(14&'5+)0567&'065#6'4+#.56'#%*+0)+51(6'02'48#&'&$;#6'05+10$'69''0
1010'*#0&#0#674#.5%+'06+(+%#0&'0)+0''4+0)14+'06'&612+%#0&106*'16*'4*#0&#&'5+)0
'&7%#6+104116'&+06*'24#%6+%'$#5'&#0&%105647%6+8'64#&+6+10#5.+0)
  *'4'+5#6'0&'0%;1(
C9#6'4+0)&190D6*'/#6'4+#.'&7%#6+10(14&'5+)0567&'065+056'#&1(75+0)#&'37#6'7261&#6'
5%+'06+(+%/'6*1&5(41/6*'(+'.&1(&'5+)061%18'4$16*6*'6'%*0+%#.2412'46+'5#0&5'0514+#.
%*#4#%6'4+56+%55$,?40=4'05'0"#4'..#)6#2
 
'5+)0'&7%#6+10#6#6'46+#4;.'8'.0''&5611(('4/#6'4+#.%1745'56*#624'2#4'567&'06561914-$16*10
+052+4#6+10#.#0&#0#.;6+%#..'8'.5+0/#6'4+#.5'.'%6+10241%'55'5#4.;+06*'&'5+)0'&7%#6+10567&'065
1(6'0*#8'#24'%10%'26+101(/#6'4+#.5#0&6*';0''&61$'+0641&7%'&61#012'0/+0&'&+052+4#6+10#.
/#6'4+#.5'.'%6+10241%'55$#5'&105%+'06+(+%&'5+)0/'6*1&5 *'#76*145D190':2'4+'0%'57))'565
6*#6567&'065)#+0#&''2'470&'456#0&+0)1(/#6'4+#.5+(6*'6*'14'6+%#..'%674'510/#6'4+#.5#4'%.15'.;
.+0-'&61*#0&510/#6'4+#.':2'4+/'0655$,?40=4'05'0'6#.
 ;.+0-+0)6*'6*'14;#0&
':2'4+/'065+0#241,'%624'('4#$.;+06*'5#/'%1745'567&'065*#8'6*'12214670+6;61#22.;6*'+4
.'#40+0)176%1/'5+0#241&7%6&'8'.12/'06241,'%6#0&6*+5+5A@'(('%6+8'+0$4+&)+0)6*'&+8+&'
$'69''0C-019.'&)'#$176D#0&C':2'4+'0%'+0D/#6'4+#.5B#557))'56'&$;'&).';1)01.+#0&
#4#0#'&).';1)01.+#4#0#
 

    
'6*1&5%#0$'5''0#5/'06#.611.56*#6#+&6*'&'5+)0567&'065+00#8+)#6+0)%1/2.':+6;#0&1(('45
6*'/#5647%674'61&'#.9+6*70(#/+.+#46'44+614+'5'6*1&5#55+56&'5+)0567&'065+05-+..&'8'.12/'06
#0&614'+0(14%'24#%6+%'6*#6+50'%'55#4;(14&'8'.12+0)+067+6+8'':2'46+5'18'46+/'#*0'/#0
.'+0
'(.'%6+10+0#%6+10%1064+$76'561#4'+0(14%'&24#%6+%'$;2#;+0)#66'06+1061#0&.'#40+0)
(41/&'%+5+105#0&#%6+1056*#6.'#&61/+56#-'51470':2'%6'&176%1/'51(/'6*1&75#)'%*=0
 '6*1&55*17.&016$'5''0#5/'4'+05647%6+10561(1..19$764#6*'4#5/'06#.611.514/+0&5'6

'.(6!0+8'45+6;1( '%*01.1); *''6*'4.#0&5


183
2-3,"#012,"',!0#1',%!-+.*#6'27,"2- # *#2-!-,20' 32#5'2&/3*'$'#"1-*32'-,11*',%
 
.0-(#!2.-02$-*'-!, #4*3 *#2--*5&#,31#"',0#$*#!2'4#"'1!311'-,5'2&2&#123"#,21 -32
2&#'0.#01-,*#6.#0'#,!#-$+#2&-"31%#',"#1'%,.0-!#11,"!,2&#0# 7!-,20' 32#5'2&,
4*3 *#*#0,',%#6.#0'#,!#1
&#,"#4#*-.',%,#5!300'!3*3+$-02&#+2#0'*!-301#1'251!-,1'"#0#"'+.-02,22-2#!&
+2#0'*1,".0-"3!2'-,+#2&-"1',!-,2#623*'8#"1#22',%5'2&#+.&1'1-,&-5+2#0'*1!, #
..0-!&#"',"#1'%,.0-!#116.#0'#,!#$0-+2&#-*"!300'!3*3+&"',"'!2#"2&25&#,"#1'%,
123"#,21,"#,%',##0',%123"#,215#0#23%&22&#1+#!-301#1',+2#0'*,".0-"3!2'-,+#2&-"1
2&#!-301#12#,"#"2- #!-+#2--%#,#0*,""#!-,2#623*'8#"#1'%,123"#,210#%#,#0**7
',2#0#12#"',..*'#"+2#0'*1,"5#0#-$2#,"'1!-30%#" 72&#2#!&,'!*..0-!&',2&#',20-"3!2-07
!-301#12 #!+#"'$$'!3*2$-02&#"#1'%,123"#,212-0#*2#2&#.30#*72#!&,'!*1.#!21-$+2#0'*12-
2&#..*'#"+2#0'*),-5*#"%#%',#"2&0-3%&2&#"#1'%,.0-(#!210*7',2&#"#4#*-.+#,2-$2&#,#5
!300'!3*3+'2*1- #!+#!*#02&2'251'+.-02,22-+)#"'12',!2'-, #25##,+2#0'*1#*#!2'-,
,"+2#0'*#6.*-02'-,12&#70#25-"'$$#0#,2571-$..0-!&',%+2#0'*14,#8--7#,
 
&#70#-$#/3*'+.-02,!# 32"#+,"1"'$$#0#,2+#2&-"1,"+',"1#212#0'*1#*#!2'-,0#$#012-
2&#5#**"#$',#".0-!#11..*'#"',2&#*2#012%#1-$"#1'%,.0-!#115&#0#2&#+2#0'*11#*#!2'-,
!0'2#0'0#"#$',#" 7!-,2#62-$+,3$!230',%,"!-122-0#*'8#,*0#"7+230#.0-"3!2!-,!#.2
2#0'*1!-,1'"#0#"',2&#$3887$0-,2#,"-$2&#"#1'%,.0-!#110#"#*25'2&2+-0# 120!2,"
&-*'12'!*#4#*#%!0#2',%+2#0'*4'1'-,',12#"-$"#$',',%+2#0'*10#/3'0#+#,21$-0.0-"3!2
0#*'82'-,&'1!-3*"!-,20' 32#2-120#,%2&#,2&# '*'2'#1-$"#1'%,123"#,212-',2#%02#2&#'0+2#0'*
),-5*#"%#,"1)'**1',2&#"#1'%,.0-!#11$0-+2&#$3887$0-,2#,"2-2&#1203!230#" !)#,"',
.0-$#11'-,*1#22',%
 
    
*'2#0230#0#4'#551!00'#"-325'2&$-!31-,%3'"#*',#1,"2--*131#"',-0"#4#*-.#"$-0+2#0'*1
#"3!2'-,',2&#$'#*"-$"#1'%,1 (;0,90#,1#,#2*
 &#$-**-5',%+#2&-"1%3'"#*',#1,"
2--*15#0#',2#%02#"',2&##6'12',%+2#0'*!-301#1$-02&#.0-"3!2"#1'%,123"#,21
 
  
  
&#6.0#11'4##,1-0'*2*131#1$-30.0+#2#01,+#*72#6230#2-3!& 0'**',!7,"20,1.0#,!7
-%,-*'
 &#!&021.0-4'"#'**31202'-,-$1#,1-0'*/3*'2'#131',%1+.*#-$+2#0'*1
!-+ ',#"5'2&1'+.*#!-,!'1#2#623*"#$','2'-,#1'%,123"#,210,)+2#0'*1+.*#1 1#"-,
.#01-,*1#,12'-,2&20#13*2',13 (#!2'4#,"/3*'22'4#1#,1-0'*1!*#$'% $0-+-,#1#,1-0'*
#620#+'272-,-2&#0#%*'%&2&#47&#13 (#!2'4#1#,1-0'*+.120'%%#00#*#4,2"'1!311'-,1 #25##,
2&#123"#,215&#,2&#70#*'8#2&22&#0#13*2"-,-2*571!-00#1.-,"2-2&#1!*#"#0'4#"$0-+
- (#!2'4#+2#0'*+#130#+#,21,$'% 2&#.0-"3!2"#1'%,123"#,215#0#1)#"2-0,)2#,+2#0'*
1+.*#1$0-+*'%&22-&#47$'01213 (#!2'4#*7,"2&#,!!-0"',%2-"#,1'27


'% 0-.#027#6.*,2'-,1,".&71'!*1+.*#1!-+ ',#"',2-2&#6.0#11'4##,1-0'*2*1,""#4#*-.#"',2-
1!*#-$*'%&2&#47-%,-*'
  2#0'*1+.*#10,)#"$0-+*'%&22-&#47 7.0-"3!2"#1'%,123"#,21$'012
13 (#!2'4#*7,"2&#,!!-0"',%2-"#,1'27',2&#2-.0-5


 *'4#!2'4#".2'4#
184
 
        
$ $( ,$#*( "))"* %$   #)*%)) )*) $() $#$ &+"* $#$ $
(* %$ $#*( "))"* %$($!!(*$( #%"%()#+"* *
(#-%(!**#()%*)$)%( "(*( )* ))-"")*$ "&(%&(* )**(
# $#*( "+ " $)"&)*+$*)*%+$()*$%-*%#&".%# $* %$%
#$+*+( $#*%))&$+$* %$("*)*%*+)(.&( $ $/%(.#&"
.&(* )$($+"*+("!(%+$


  $ $)%*( ")%"($*" 


   
%)%$$(&()+ " $) 
%()$%,(, -%%-($%    

  %$*( +**%*(" )* %$%%(#+$* %$$( * %$ $&(%+*)
$*+($+"* #*"/*(# $%**%)*$,"+%*&(%+*- #+)*+"* #*"/#**
$%(#(!*%)%$(&(  + " $))+&&%(**) $)*+$* $.&"%( $
*&%*$* "$%$)'+$)%**( +* $("* %$*%*)+((%+$ $**( +*))-"")
*$$%$*.* / $*(* $%)*$,"+ *("*)(" )* )$( %**%+")+&&%(*
&(%)) %$") $())-"""* %$ )(+ " $#*( ")"* %$&(%))) $*( )$%
)&  $)-( %$"/%$*.*+""/("*#*( "$ *)**%( ($*)%"+* %$)
+ " $)(,"%&)(* %$*%%-#*( ")"* %$ )*( * %$""/*+* $) $
+* %$


 +(
&(%)) ""+)*(*)#* ""/ $,%",)&+** $*#*( ")**(*%*) $&(%)))*
$*(* $"#$*&(#* $"")&*)%*) $%)%$(&(  



"*$ ,() */%$%"%/*("$)


185
  

"-*&2'7.),*3,.3**7.3,!*1*(947!):&(0)*;*145*)'>7&39&+47)*8.,3*3,.3**7.3,.8
'&8*)439-*<4704+8-'>&3)*'437&39&*8.,3
"-*!):&(04++*782&9*7.&1
8*1*(9.43'&8*)439*(-3.(&15745*79.*82&3:+&(9:7.3,574(*88*8*3;.7432*39&1&3)8:89&.3&'.1.9>
&85*(98"-*574,7&24++*78;.8:&1.?&9.438&3)2&9*7.&1(-&7984+9*(-3.(&15745*79.*8"-*2&9*7.&1
(-&798(&357*+*7*39.&11>'*:8*).3(42'.3&9.43<.9-49-*794418.39-*)*8.,3*):(&9.4394*=51&.39-*
(4251*=7*1&9.438'*9<**39*(-3.(&15745*79.*8&3).39&3,.'1*(-&7&(9*7.89.(8
"-*
;*78.434+!):5&(04++*78&3*<'*9&;*78.43)&9&'&8*+47*3,.3**78&3).3):897.&1
)*8.,389:)*398(&11*)9-*74):(98&9*7.&18&3)74(*88*8)&9&'&8*+., "-*)&9&'&8*.8574):(9
(*39*7*)&3)(439&.38)*8(7.59.438&3))&9&4+2&9*7.&18&3)574(*88*8:8*)942&0*574):(98"-*
574):(9*=&251*8&7*.39*3)*)94&(9&8)*(4).+.*78'*9<**3.39&3,.'1*(-&7&(9*7.89.(8&3)9*(-3.(&1
5745*79.*87&39&*8.,3



.,:7* =&251*4+)&9&8-**98+742!):&(0
&9&'&8*74):(98&9*7.&18&3)74(*88*8"-*+.789
)&9&8-**9)*8(7.'*89-*574):(9>1.3)&1.3*49'>73*&(4'8*39-*8*(43)&3)9-.7))*8(7.'*89-*2&9*7.&189&.31*88
89**1:8*).39-*574):(97&39&*8.,3



 
  
"-*&9*7.&17.;*3*8.,3*9-4)+&(.1.9&9*8)*8.,3574(*88*8.3<-.(-9-*2&9*7.&18&7*9-*
2&.3)7.;*7+.,
"-*2*9-4)*3(4:7&,*8-&3)843.39*7&(9.43<.9-9-*2&9*7.&1&9-&3)+7429-*
+.789*3(4:39*79-74:,-94*=5147.3,&3):3)*789&3).3,9-*2&9*7.&1.3)*9&.1<.9-.98:3.6:*6:&1.9.*8&3)
1.2.9&9.438&7&3&&7&9. 4,341.%**:<;&3)*7&&3
><470.3,<.9-&3*=5147&9.;*
&5574&(-9-*)*8.,3*7:3)*789&3)89-*2&9*7.&1.3)*59-*,*=5*7.*39.&16:&1.9.*85->8.(&15745*79.*8
&3)@    

      "-*2*9-4),:.)*89-*)*8.,389:)*39.3&
/4:73*>+7422&9*7.&15745*79.*8&3)*=5*7.*39.&16:&1.9.*8942&9*7.&18*=5*7.*3(*;.8.439-*394
*=5*7.*39.&16:&1.9.*82&9*7.&15745*79.*8&3)+.3&11>94574):(98(9.;.9.*8948:554799-.8/4:73*>&7*
47,&3.?*):3)*7+4:72&.389*58&8
#3)*789&3).3,9-*&9*7.&1"*(-3.(&1&3)=5*7.*39.&1
-&7&(9*7.?&9.43 7*&9.3,&9*7.&18=5*7.*3(*$.8.43 &3.+*89.3,&9*7.&18=5*7.*3(*&99*738
 *8.,3.3,&9*7.&174):(943(*598


!
1.;*(9.;*)&59.;*
186

&$  0&+*/0",/&*0%")"0%+!.*"0(  
*+.!".0+ ."0")"*&*$#1(,,(& 0&+*!"/&$*"./*""!0+)+2"#.+))0".&( %. 0".&60&+*0+
%+(&/0& 2&/&+*0", +#%"5(/+*""!0+"*("*+2"("4,".&"* "/5 .#0&*$0%"2&/&+*&*0+
)"*&*$#1(,,(& 0&+*0",/
*! +#
%")"0%+! *"1/"!&*!&##"."*0/ "*.&+/*!.*"0(/1$$"/00%"#+((+3&*$/ "*.&+/ 
 "/&$*&*$3&0%."(0&2"(53"(('*+3*)0".&((0%+1$%0%")0".&(&/(&'"(50+%2"/+)"
/"00("!)"*&*$/&* ".0&* +*0"40/0%"!"/&$*"./""'/*"3,,(& 0&+*."/0+"2+'"*"3
)"*&*$/*!0+"(& &01*&-1"1/"."4,".&"* "/
 "/&$*&*$3&0%."(0&2"(51*'*+3*)0".&(3%& %3&((" +),*&"!5#1((5
!"2"(+,"!/),(""$(&-1&!3++!
0%".)+ %.+)& )0".&(/"0 %")0".&(&/
1*(&'"(50+"(&*'"!0+"/0(&/%"!)"*&*$/$&2&*$0%"!"/&$*".*+,,+.01*&050+!"#&*"
,,(& 0&+*."/0%.+1$%3%& %1*&-1"1/"."4,".&"* "/&!"*0&0&"/#+.)0".&(/*!*"3
)"*&*$/)5"&*0.+!1 "!

 "/&$*&*$3&0%)0".&(,.+,+/(3&0%/")&!"2"(+,"!+."4,(+.0+.5/),("/"$#++!
3/0" +),+/&0"/(&2&*$)0".&(/)!"+# 0".&( "((/
,.&*0"!0"40&("/#("4&("
/"0 &* "0%")0".&(&//")&!"2"(+,"!&",.+,+/(&0/,.+,".0&"/."0+"
#1.0%".!"#&*"!0%.+1$%0%"!"/&$*,.+ "//&*."(0&+*0+/"(" 0"!,,(& 0&+*."(/+0+
$"*".0"#""! '#+.#1.0%".)0".&(/!"2"(+,)"*0"$"(/0& &05+##++!3/0"
+),+/&0"!1.&(&05+#
,.&*0"!0"40&(""0 1.0%".)+."/&* "0%")0".&(&/*+2"(&0
&/!&##& 1(00+." +$*&6"*!&/&**""!+#0%"!"/&$*".0+,.+,+/")"*&*$#1(,,(& 0&+*/
0%.+1$%3%& %1*&-1"1/"."4,".&"* "/*!)"*&*$/3&((""(& &0"!
 
        
/"2".(5".(+*$,.+ "//+#$0%".&*$'*+3("!$"$&*&*$"4,".&"* "*!#&*(&6&*$*"$+0&0&+*/3&0%
&*2+(2"!/0'"%+(!"./)!"&0,+//&("0+&),(")"*0*"3 1..& 1(1)&*0%"#1*!)"*0()0".&(/
+1./"/0%0.")*!0+.5#+..+!1 0"/&$*/01!"*0/+3!+"/+*"0%"*&),(")"*00%")"0%+!/
#+1*!/1&0("#+.0%")0".&(/ +1./"/&*0%".+!1 0"/&$* %"(+.,.+$.))"%"#&./0/0",+#
&),(")"*00&+*3/)!"&*0%""4&/0&*$)0".&(/ +1./"/3&0%+10 %*$&*$0%"(".*&*$+10 +)"/&*0%"

"(#0*&2"./&05+#" %*+(+$5%""0%".(*!/
187
!-301#17** 31',12#"*'2#0230#+#2&-"12--*1,"2&#.#"%-%'!..0-!&513."2#"7"-',%'2
',25-12#.1'251+"#.-11' *#2-2#12#4*32#,"$302&#0"#4#*-.$0+#5-0)$-02#!&',%+2#0'*1
!-301#12-2&#.0-"3!2"#1'%,123"#,21&#1#!-,"12#.-$'+.*#+#,22'-,&1 ##,2-0#1203!230#2&#
0-"3!2#1'%, !&#*-0.0-%0++#,"50'2#,#5!-301#17** 31#1&'1123"7-,*70#.-021-,2&#$'012
12#.-$'+.*#+#,22'-,1',!#2&#1#!-,"12#.'13,"#0"#4#*-.+#,2,"5'** #'+.*#+#,2#""30',%
323+,
 
         

&#!-301#       
 
*12!-301#',2&# 12
7#0&1 ##,%'4#,5'2&2&#1+#!-301#17** 311',!#1.0',%2#0+

$'% 0-"3!2#1'%,
&1 ##,0#1.-,1' *#$-02&#.*,,',%,"#6#!32'-,-$2&#!-301#,"2#0'*!'#,!#&4#
-$$#0#"2&#1+#1#0'#1-$*#!230#1$-0123"#,21$0-+.0-"3!2"#1'%,,"+#!&,'!*#,%',##0',%
1',!#


        
& ' ( ) * + , - . &% && &' &( &) &* &+ &, &- &. '%
 

 

     
 
  
 




  
         

  
   (
 
 

 



 
  
!    
 




&"'

 
 

   

"

      

'%30# 9       
 
:


 
&#*#!230#15#0#!0'2'!'8#" 72&##,%',##0',%123"#,21$-0 #',%2--%#,#0*,-22&#-0#2'!*
0#*#4,2#,-3%&,"9+-4',%$-050"2--1*-5:&#"#1'%,123"#,21$-3,"-,2&#-2&#0&,"2&#
*#!230#192--2&#-0#2'!*:,-2 *#2-*',)2&#*#!230#12--2&#0*#0,',%!2'4'2'#1',2&#!-301#1,"
9+-4',%$-050"2--$12:&#0#1-,1$-0%'4',%2&#1+#1#0'#1-$*#!230#15#0#5#**#12 *'1&#"
.0!2'!#',2&#2#!&,'!*$!3*27,"2&#$',,!'* #,#$'2-$(-',2123"'#1&#2&#-0#2'!*.021-$2&#
+2#0'*!-301#1#6+',#"',50'22#,2#1215#0#-$2#,!0'2'!'8#"$-0,-2#4*32',%2&#123"#,21:
 '*'272-*',)2&#-072-..*'#""#1'%,.0- *#+1,-5*#"%#',2&'1$-0+!, #!-,1'"#0#"122'!
',!*3"#"',2#62 --),"12-0#"',+#+-072- #0#!**#"22&#2'+#-$2&##6+,-2**-5#"2-
#!-,1'"#0#"1,!2'4#!0#2'4#),-5*#"%#.0-"3!2'-,-$2&#+-+#,23!!'0#**'
 
&#,0#1203!230',%2&#!-301#2&#+',%-*512-$!'*'22#),-5*#"%#!0#2'-,',2&#',2#01#!2'-,
-$2&#-07,"&,"1-,+2#0'*#6.#0'#,!#&#"'$$'!3*27',+3*2'"'1!'.*',072#!&',%
#,4'0-,+#,2512&2"'$$#0#,2+#+ #01-$2#!&',%12$$&4# ##,20',#"',"'$$#0#,20#1#0!&
.0"'%+1251.0#0#/3'1'2#2-13!!##"2&2**',4-*4#"2#!&#01',2&#!-301#&"!-++-,
4-! 3*07,",3,"#012,"',%-$2&#+#2&-"1,"%3'"#*',#1',20-"3!#",-2-,*72&#-,#12&#7
23%&22&#+1#*4#12#0'*!'#,!#!&-1#,-22--$$#0,#5*#!230#1$-02&#"#1'%,123"#,21 32
11'12#"',12#"2&#"#1'%,2#!&#01',"#4#*-.',%,#5*#!230#1#0'#1&#*#!230#15#0#
"#4#*-.#"',2&#1.'0'2-$!2'4#*#0,',%#*"#00#,2
5'2& 0'#$',2#0*3"#1-$.0!2'!#,"
$##" !)2--$$#02&#123"#,21,3,"#012,"',%-$2&#+-0#!-+.*#6!-,2#62-$$-0#6+.*#2&#
0#*2'-, #25##,2#!&,'!*.0-.#02'#1,"1#,1-0'*!&0!2#0'12'!1&#6.0#11'4##,1-0'*2*1
-%,-*'
 51',20-"3!#","31#""30',%2&#*#!230#1157$-02&#123"#,212-#6.*-0#
2&#0#*2'-,1&'. #25##,5&2'1.#0!#'4#"13 (#!2'4#*7,"5&2'1+#130#"- (#!2'4#*7$'% 
&#!-,2#,2-$2&#*#!230#15#0#*1-".2#"2-"#1'%,123"#,21:.0#),-5*#"%#-$+2#0'*1,"
"#4#*-.#"2-0#$*#!22&#*2#120#1#0!&',2&#"#1'%,,"+2#0'*1"-+',&#,3+ #0-$


 *'4#!2'4#".2'4#
188
!-++#0!'*+2#0'*14'* *#'10.'"*7',!0#1',%,"2&#20"'2'-,**731#"26-,-+7-$+2#0'*
$+'*'#1'1%0"3**7"#!-+.-1#"5'2&&7 0'"+2#0'*113!&1!-+.-1'2#1&#0#$-0#'2'1
$3,"+#,2*2-.0-4'"#123"#,215'2&2--*12-!0#2#2&#'0-5,3,"#012,"',%1-$+2#0'*11*',%
#,3
 

        
) * + , - . / 0 1 )( )) )* )+ ), )- ). )/ )0 )1 *(
   
       
 
  
 

"
 
      
 

     "
   +!
 
 



 
% 




 #



 


  

   

  # 
   

  


$
 



 


)%* 
   
  
"
 




# 




 

 
 
 

    
  


 
    
 
 


%



'%30#8   
      9
 
70#1203!230',%2&#!-301#$'%2&#',2#0!2'-, #25##,2&#-07,"&,"1-,*#0,',%5#0#.32',2&#
!#,20#15# #*'#4#2&#123"#,21%',"##.#03,"#012,"',%-$+2#0'*1'$2&#2&#-0#2'!**#!230#1-,
+2#0'*10#!*-1#*7*',)#"2-&,"1-,+2#0'*#6.#0'+#,21,.0!2'!#2&2!-3*" #*#!230#-,2&#
+2#0'*$+'*7-$+#2*1',2&#+-0,',%$-**-5#" 75-0)',%5'2&23 # #,"',%,"5#*"',%',2&#
5-0)1&-.*2#0',2&#"7&#123"#,215#0#%'4#,+2#0'*,"+,3$!230',%11'%,+#,25#0#2&#7
511)#"2-0#.*'!2#2&#1+#- (#!2',$-30"'$$#0#,2+2#0'*1+#2*15--"!-+.-1'2#1.-*7+#01
2#62'*#1-0!#0+'!1&#123"#,210#!#'4#"2#!&,'!*"05',%-$2&#-0'%',*- (#!25'2&',1203!2'-,12-
!&--1#2&#+-1213'2 *#2#!&,'/3#$-0#!&+2#0'*&#,$',*'1',%2&#$-30- (#!212&#123"#,21
1&-3*",*71##!&- (#!231',%2&##,',%1-$2#0'*1-"#*0,#2*
 ,"!-+.0#
2&#0#13*21',1#+',0#52#!&,'!*"05',%1-$#!&- (#!251.0-"3!#","2&#123"#,215#0#
1)#"2-0#$*#!2-,2&#!-+.*#6!-+ ',2'-,-$+,3$!230',%+#2&-"11&.#,"$3,!2'-,,"&-5'2
0#*2#12-2&#31#0#6.#0'#,!#2-%#2&#05'2&2&#2#!&#01&##!&,'!1-$2#0'*15#0#"#4#*-.#"
72#!&#0$0-+2#0'*!'#,!#$0-+ #',%!-+ ',2'-,-$*#!230#1,"2&#-0#2'!*!*!3*2'-,1
',2-*#!230#1,",..*'#"25-"75-0)1&-.5#0#2&#123"#,215#0#1)#"2- 3'*"!-,1203!2'-,1,"
.32*-"-,3,2'*2&#7!-**.1#","2&##* -02#-,2&#0#13*2#!-,".02-$2&#!-301#2&#123"#,21
5#0#%'4#,"#1'%,.0-(#!25#0#2&#7..*'#"2&#'0,#5*7!/3'1'2'-,#"#6.#0'#,!#',,"),-5*#"%#
 -32+2#0'*1',"#1'%,.0-!#11'+.*#!312'4#-0-,#2--,#0#*2'-,1&'.1 #25##,+2#0'*1
.0-"3!211#,1-0'*#6.#0'#,!#1+#,',%220' 32'-,,"#+-2'-,*0#1.-,1#1"-,-2#6'12$$#!2'4#
2#!&',%,"*#0,',%',2&'10#+312#6.-1#123"#,212-2&#!-+.*#6'27-$!-,2#623*'113#15&'*12
#+.&1'1',%2&25'2&!-+.*#6'27!-+#10'!&,#11',"'4#01'27,",-4#*27#"%*#7#2*
 
      
   
&#!-301#      12!-301#
,"7#0&"2&#1+#&'12-0'!* !)%0-3,"
12&#.0#4'-31*7"#1!0' #"   
      $2#0
#6.#0'#,!',%+',*7.-1'2'4##$$#!21-$2&#,#5.#"%-%'!*..0-!&0"'!*!&,%#51
'+.*#+#,2#" 7',20-"3!',%2#0'*0'4#,#1'%,0,#2*
 ,"*'..#"#0,',%#25-0)

#*$2,'4#01'27-$#!&,-*-%7&##2&#0*,"1
189

 /'"5 +),+*"*0/&*0%"/" +*!)*!0+.5)0".&(/ +1./" 
     
*0%"0.!&0&+*(0" %". "*0."!)+!"(0%"0" %".&/0%",.&).5/+1. "+#&*#+.)0&+*5 +*0./00%"
(&,,"!".*&*$)+!"(!"(&".0"(5/%&#0/&*/0.1 0&+*0+(".*". "*0."!,,.+ %3%"."&* (//0&)"
&/!"!& 0"!0+"4,(+.&*$0+,& /&*$."0".!",0%*! ."0&*$.& %(".*&*$+,,+.01*&0&"/"03+.'
 
%"(&,,"!".*&*$)+!"(3/ %+/"*/&0 0&2"(5&*2+(2"/0%"/01!"*0/&*'*+3("!$" +*/0.1 0&+*
/0%"5,.0& &,0"&**!"2(10"0%"&.(".*&*$&*)**".0%0&/,"./+*((5)"*&*$#1(%"
,"!$+$& ,,.+ %%.)+*&6"/3"((3&0%0%""4,".&)"*0(*!"4,(+.0&2"/,&.&0+#0%")"0%+!
%"/01!"*0/3"."&*0.+!1 "!0+0%"0%"+."0& (#.)"3+.'+#0".&(.&2"*"/&$*&*/".&"/+#
/")&*./3%"."0%" (//" )",.0+#/0.1 01.&*$0%" 0&2&0&"/*!0&)"(&*"/&*0%" +1./"
#&$0&/&),+.0*00+"* +1.$"/01!"*0/0+3+.'"4,(+.0&2"*!(/+(".*#.+)#&(1."/&*0%"
&0".0&2",.+ "//+#0&*'".&*$3&0%)0".&(/*!/ +*/"-1"* " ."0" ".0&*!"$.""+##("4&&(&05&*
0%"0&)"(&*"%"/01!"*0/3"."/'"!0+,,(50%")"0%+!0+)0".&(,.+,+/(/0%03"."/")&
!"2"(+,"!"4,(+.0+.50"40&("3/0"*! +##""$.+1*!+.3&0%."(0&2"(51*'*+3*)5 "(&1)
".*&*$0+&*2"/0&$0")0".&(&**"4,(+.0&2"5"0/0.1 01."!35&* ."/"!0%"&*0"$.0&+*+#
)0".&(0%&*'&*$&*0%"!"/&$*,.+ "//*!)!"0%"!"/&$*/01!"*0/."#(" 0+*0%")0".&(/0%"51/"

        
+ , - . / 0 1 2 3 +* ++ +, +- +. +/ +0 +1 +2 +3 ,*
                      " 
                 #    "

  

   %   '       



            
'          ' '  % 
    &       
   
$ &

                 


   
  !
 '  

&$1." 
     
 
%")"0%+!" )"&*0"$.0"!&*0%" +1./"/0.1 01."/+0%00%"!&##"."*0(".*&*$ 0&2&0&"/
/1,,+.0"!" %+0%"."$0%",1((0"/0#&$&*0%",,(&"!)" %*& /+#)0".&(/)+!1("3/
,".#+.)"!+*0%")0".&(/),("/#&$ 0%"/01!"*0/,.+!1 "!&*0%" +1./"%""* %).'&*$+#
)0".&(/" )" +**" 0"!0+0%")"0%+!/1/"!&*0%",.+!1 0&+*" +*+)5)+!1("*!/+#+.0%



&$1."0".&(/),("/,.+!1 "!5+*"$.+1,+#/01!"*0/&*0%" +1./" 
     
 
#+((+3"!5,1((0"/0+#0%"#&*(/),("




 (&2" 0&2"!,0&2"
190

!-* ,*!$+%($+.$'(*'%,0,!$/+,1+,-&,+ ',,'&!*+%!0/!, ,(!'+('$1%*
'*#!&/!, , !*&,+,(+', %, '!&'-*++,*-,-*!+*/*!&-, $$&!&
'*', , *+&+,-&,++!,%&+'''%%-&!,!'&,/&.*1'1!&.'$.'*$+
+'%', +1&*!+!&$*&!&,!.!,!+*$'+,/'-$$!#,'+-+,, ,(*,+', 
%,*!$*-*, *.$'(, (!,-*+-+'*, 0(*!&,!$ *,*!2,!'&*,!&
!&+,*-,!'&$%,*!$'*, *++', ,%'*+!&+,-&,+'-$&!,*'%, %, '



  
 

 !++,-1 +'*, '(('*,-&!,1,'*$,'&, !,!((*' ,'%,*!$+, !&!&(*'-,
+!&  $$&+'(($1!&&/('!$((*' ,'&0!+,!&'-*++1$$-+*&*
%!&$1('+!,!.0(*!&+ ,*!%($%&,!&, &/('!((*' &%, '+,*!$
!& ++ '/&!&,*+,!&.$'(!&, !*'/&%,*!$'-*++'*, % &!$&%,*!$
&!&*!&+,-&,+ !$'&!&*!&+(!$$1*$,,'%,*!$+'-$&!,*'%
(,!&, +%, '+!&,', !*%,*!$-,!'&,'-$'&,*!-,,'%'*!!&,
-&*+,&!&', +&+'*!$ *,*!+,!+, ,*$!&#,', , &!$(*'(*,!+,'-$$+'
'&,*!-,,'$++%!+'%%-&!,!'&,/&&!&*++!&*+&&'&, &!$(*'++!'&+!&, 
(*'-,.$'(%&,(*'++',& *,*!21%-$,!!+!($!&*1/'*#,*!$+'&+,!,-,, 
( 1+!$((*&'(*'-,& ''+!&, *! ,%,*!$+!+-&%&,$'* '/(*'-,/!$$
-&,!'&& '/!,/!$$((* +(*,', (*'-,+!&-,!'&+,-&,+ .,'.$'(
%,*!$(*,!, ,!&'*('*,+%,*!$, !&#!&!&, !*'.*$$+!&(*,!&, !+!&$-+ '/
%,*!$+*.$-,&+$,+$!&&-
 
 *+-$,++'*!&!,, ,, +,-&,+ .!&,,*-&*+,&!&', '%($0'&,0,'
%,*!$*$,,!.!,!+!&+!&(*'++ *!+,&&1'*,*.*!,!'&'*$.&,
%,*!$&!,+!&, +!&(*'",+!&+,', 3-+-$+-+(,+4-+,!&!$!,1 ++-*(*!+!&$1
'%&,-*$$1!&,*,(*,', %,*!$+'-*++&!+&'$'&*,*,++(*,
,,*!-,-, .!&+,'%%!&, +!&(*'++ +,-&,+.$'(, !*
%,*!$.'-$*1-*!&, '-*++'&,*!-,!&,' ! *)-$!,1&(*!+!'&!&, !+-++!'&+
 '(, ,, !++,-1&!&+(!*,'!&,*'-,*!$*!.&+!&!&%'*+!&-,!'&+



$,&!.*+!,1' &'$'1 , *$&+


191

<+3G;7%D;.7<.7(*;.55*0=*9%
 *=.;2*5<.5.,=287277-><=;2*5.<207.->,*=287H
52=.;*=>;.;.?2.@27*52&7.32&032+*5*2(*322,.2**5.2,&2)53)8(7*6.,2)8(&7.32
*47*1'*5  &0'35,"2.9*56.7<*21&5/
>,,2*;.552 .<207270*7-5.*;7270-2<3>7,=28727,87=.A=<*6.,2 78).*6   


.5-.;$ ;.7=$ ,=2?.5.*;7270727=;8->,=287 .,-*5)8(&7.325.*+  

;*7=*.<207
5&27&)*6.,2$.=;2.?.- *;,1

/;86
1==9@@@0;*7=*-.<207,86,869*7B12<=8;B1=6
*<5270 
.*;7270=1;8>016*=.;2*5<-.?.5892706*=.;2*5<=.*,127027-.<207.->,*=287
85-270%,18858/.<207
*<5270 .7*>&
.?.5896.7=8/=1.6*=.;2*5<.5.,=2879;*,=2,.27=1.-.<207
->,*=287H<=>-B.A958;270*;=2,>5*=2878/6*=.;2*5;.:>2;.6.7=<#*9.;9;.<.7=.-*==1.  
53(**).2,63+7-*   7-27*52&7.32&032+*5*2(*322,.2**5.2,&2)53)8(7*6.,2
"2.9*56.7<3+!:*27*7-**7-*50&2)6
8-0<87%*;9.; //.,=2?.><.8/6*=.;2*5<27=1.-.<2079;8,.<< 8;.=1*7*<.5.,=287
9;8+5.6#*9.;9;.<.7=.-*==1. 

53(**).2,63+  7-* 7-27*52&7.32&032+*5*2(*


322,.2**5.2,&2)53)8(7*6.,2)8(&7.32*0+77-**7-*50&2)6 
  
*17.6*75.27 87-2=287</8;27=>2=2?..A9.;=2<./*25>;.=8-2<*0;..1*5.(&2
6<(-303,.67 

*;*7**;*=2$807852')..>@?*7-.;**7
 *=.;2*5-;2?.7-.<207 
6.=18-=8-.<207/8;6*=.;2*5.A9.;2.7,.<27*52&7.32&03852&03+*6.,2   
*;*7*.44.;=#*7-*,1*;#
=885/8;6.*7270-;2?.76*=.;2*5<<.5.,=287&7*5.&06
*6.,2
   

!.=@8;4
&1./8>;9255*;<8/#E$.=;2.?.-",=8+.;
/;86
774:::0.44*)0*&52.2,35,(160.' #
 *275.(.7<31&.2 %-&2)387%%$*'
)+
#.-05.B"$807852'*;*7*
 *=.;2*5<.A9.;2.7,.*<*/8>7-*=287/8;6*=.;2*5<*7-
-.<207.->,*=28727*52&7.32&03852&03+!*(-2303,<&2)*6.,2)8(&7.32
$807852'
+;8*-<>;?.B87.A9;.<<2?.<.7<8;2*5,1*;*,=.;2C*=2878/6*=.;2*5</8;-.<207
.->,*=287!"3852&03+7-*&(807<3+5(-.7*(785*    
%,1D7
 !-*5*+0*(7.9*45&(7.7.32*53:453+*66.32&067-.2/.2&(7.32*<2,+884<
&1869<87$

53737<4.2,&2)03:93081*453)8(7.32!-*1&28+&(785.2,,8.)*687-87
&1*6.<>-<87
?*7.C88B.7
1*9=.;
6*=.;2*5<-;2?.7-.<2077*;*7*"#.-05.B'$807852
-<&7*5.&06*;4*5.*2(*99  8<=87>==.;@8;=1.27.6*77




%
52?.,=2?.-*9=2?.
192

You might also like