Professional Documents
Culture Documents
18 September 2018
2
Table of Contents
References ………………………………………………………… 11
3
Executive Summary
Company Background
Industry/Market Analysis
Regionally based in Harrisonburg, VA, Gemeinschaft offers the largest housing program
in the state (Gemeinschaft, 2018). The organization only accepts residents who were non-
violent, non-sexual offenders, and were imprisoned for more minor charges, such as drug
possession or financial fraud. GH is also the only housing program to have received training in
Decision Points, which is “a cognitive-based program that develops cognitive skills and uses
cognitive restructuring” in order to make residents aware of specific behaviors that could lead
them to reoffend (Fitzgerald, 2018).
GH is recognized as a successful residential reentry program and has housed former
inmates from across the United States and around the world. For example, Eastern Mennonite
University conducted a study regarding the success rate of former residents remaining out of
prison, and found that those who “completed a stay at Gemeinschaft were significantly less
likely to be re-arrested, convicted or incarcerated than offenders who completed therapeutic pre-
release programs in prison,” (EMU, 2014). Gemeinschaft fosters the development of regional
networks among its partners. Their mission of therapeutic service and positive growth has led to
the development of relationships with a number of local organizations, such as Strength in Peers,
Valley Justice Coalition, Harrisonburg-Rockingham Community Services Board, and local food
pantries and churches.
Although GH offers a comprehensive program to break the cycle of recidivism, the
organization is surrounded by a number of other temporary housing associations for the formerly
incarcerated. The most significant competition to GH is other housing programs in Virginia, such
as, Adult Alternative Program, Piedmont House, and Bridge Ministry. There are similar and
more well-known organizations like GH which leads to competition over donations and
confusion among the public as to which place should receive their attention.
There have been some recent regulation and proposed legislation changes that could
affect GH and its industry. The First Step Act, which is a proposed prison reform bill, allows
(ex)offenders to partake in “more rehabilitative programs, by letting them get earned time credits
that allow them to be released early to halfway houses or home confinement,” (Lopez, 2018).
This could solve the issue of prison overcrowding, and possibly reduce the chances of
recidivism. Additionally, there have been no recent political situation changes related to GH. The
organization has grown larger over the past decade, expanding the amount of residential room
available as well as the number of staff members they employ. Because of this, the Virginia
Department of Corrections has secured a sizable amount of funds, and created the Day Reporting
Center, to assist GH in its expansion.
Public Environment
Gemeinschaft, like many other non-profit organizations, relies on community interest and
involvement. In order to understand GH’s connection with the community online, metrics for the
organization’s social media were examined. On Facebook, their most active social media site, the
organization has 353 likes and 350 followers. On Twitter they have nine followers, follow ten
users and have a total of seven tweets. On Instagram, they have 86 followers, follow 18 users and
have a total of eight posts. Hence these low statistics and number of followers, they do not have
much engagement from the community on majority of social media posts.
Aside from Gemeinschaft’s online presence, they are not that well-known in the
community. Unfortunately, in 1996 GH did receive negative publicity following the murder of
the director, Ernie James. It was well-documented in a Washington Post article by Frank Ahrens
6
(1997). After this horrific event, Gemeinschaft had to remodel their internal organization
structure for better services for their residents and tried to reestablish themselves in the
community as a reliable, safe reentry program. Following this event, the older and middle-aged
community of Harrisonburg, Virginia have a reinforced stigma toward formerly incarcerated
individuals and subsequently question the value and safety of Gemeinschaft Home. Millennials
tend to be more empathetic to GH's residents after learning about the personal situations of the
residents themselves, but are not usually familiar with their services unless they are directly
impacted by incarceration and the justice system.
In addition to focusing on GH's improvement as a community reentry program and
distancing themselves from the negative publicity in 1996, GH ceased communication with local
media unless Sharon Ringgold, the house director, was ensured of the positivity of the article.
Therefore there is not much coverage of Gemeinschaft in the media since the tragedy that hit the
organization in 1996. Common themes present in the little coverage of GH that exists is largly
about residents’ success after leaving the home, GH services to residents, GH events or
legislation that may affect GH. Since most communication ceased with local media,
Gemeinschaft has a tab on their website for recent news regarding GH (Gemeinschaft Home,
2018). The stories on this tab typically focus on a resident living at GH or recently graduated,
new case manager hires and events with the organization in the community like the music project
with JMU students (Gemeinschaft Home, 2018).
In addition to their own coverage, there has been some notable coverage by local media.
In 2014, Eastern Mennonite University published an article talking about the history of GH and
its future saying, “there’ve been other ups and downs… but the trajectory of late has been
strong” (Kara, 2014). Following this optimistic tone, in 2015, WHSV covered some positive
legislation news for Gemeinschaft (Powell). The article describes the voting and approval
process of the Day Reporting Program (Powell, 2016). This program had to be approved by
Harrisonburg City and Rockingham County councils before being implemented.
In 2016 GH was covered in a Bridgewater College news release in which a sociology
professor from Bridgewater and a Harrisonburg Rockingham Page (HRP) Reentry Council
member, Tim Brazill, emphasizes the importance of reentry programs such as Gemeinschaft
(Bridgewater College). He was quoted saying, “The goal is always to ‘disrupt the cycle’ and
prevent recidivism” (Bridgewater College, 2016). Also in 2016, the Daily News Record
published an article about Japanese law officials who came to learn about the transitional
therapeutic program and how they might implement the program in Japan’s justice system
(Reynolds).
While most coverage was positive, a few articles had negative tones toward GH. The first
being the aforementioned Washington Post article, “The Secrets in the Briefcase”, which details
the Ernie James murder investigation (Ahrens, 1997). Aside from that coverage, it is mainly
legislation articles that affect Gemeinschaft. For example, the “Gemeinschaft Bill” on WHSV,
explains a bill proposed by Senator Mark Obenshain which “requires the State Department of
Corrections to notify local governments” and “local law enforcement” on inmates that plan to
live at Gemeinschaft Home (2007). Similar to the “Gemeinschaft Bill”, WHSV covered a Tim
Kaine cut to the Department of Corrections in 2008, where GH gets majority of its funding
(Hyland).
Lastly, and most recent negatively toned coverage, was of a small fire that occurred at
Gemeinschaft Home (Clark, 2017). The fire was due to a “heater in a bedroom doorway to draw
7
out bedbugs in the room” (Clark, 2017). While there is negative news about bed bugs at GH, the
fire was contained and no one was injured.
Publics Analysis
Consumers:
According to the Virginia Department of Corrections, there were 29,790 offenders
incarcerated in Virginia as of January, 2018 (VADOC, 2018). Of those incarcerated in Virginia,
8,159 offenders were located in the Western District, the district that includes Rockingham
county and Harrisonburg (VADOC, 2018).
This public is expected to be difficult to reach due to the regulation of contact with
people who are currently incarcerated. Additionally, negative societal stigma is expected to
increase difficulty in identifying and communicating with populations with substance abuse
issues. Given the difficulty to reach and the restricted agency of individuals within this public,
they are less than ideal targets for the limited public relations efforts deployable by this
campaign.
Producers:
GH employs 18 members of staff counting both full-time and part-time employees. GH
supports nearly 50 residents and operates a Day Reporting Program (DRP) for non-residents
participants. Employees are highly valued members of the organization and any communication
with this public should reflect this. Additionally, some members of staff are former residents of
GH. This gives them a unique insight into the organization and may be a source of material for
the campaign. Given the small number of paid staff, volunteers and interns are important publics
related to GH.
Limiters:
GH has, at times, been the target of open public opposition. Mark Obenshain has drafted
multiple pieces of legislation related to the regulation of GH and has criticized GH in the press
according to one source (Finnegan, 2007). This may represent a challenge for image
management efforts during this campaign.
Immediate neighbors may oppose GH’s existence in their neighborhood and may be a
barrier to the growth and expansion of GH. A 2018 study by AP-NORC found there to be a
significant social stigma surrounding people with drug addiction ( 2018). There might also be a
fear that an organization like Gemeinschaft could lower the property value for those with
property in a nearby as a study published in Land Economics found a statistically significant
reduction in home value for properties within sight, or 200 feet of a group home (Colwell et al,
2000).
Enablers:
Media has impacted the reputation of GH in the past as referenced the above sections
relating to the Washington Post and other negative articles. Negative exposure from the past has
potentially damaged the image of GH in the eyes of some community members and care should
8
be taken when communicating with this public as per the request of Executive Director
Ringgold. However, the average American spends 369 hours per day consuming traditional
media so the value of this public should not be unutilized given the opportunity (EMarketer,
2007).
GH's Community Residential Program (CRP) is regulated by the Virginia Department of
Corrections. As well,GH collaborates closely with local court services, attorneys, probation
officers, and counselors working inside the prison system to place individuals into the CRP.
These individuals are likely well educated and largely control the flow of customers through GH.
Outspoken allies for GH include the Valley Justice Coalition and the Zehr Institute for
Restorative Justice. The Valley Justice Coalition, “is made up of residents of Rockingham
County, the City of Harrisonburg and adjacent areas who are concerned about justice reforms in
our community and in the commonwealth,” (Barrows). And their mission is to, “engage in
reducing incarceration and recidivism through public education, policy advocacy, coalition
building, and grassroots organizing,” (Barrows). This organization is currently working to repeal
the Gemeinschaft House bill.
The Zehr Institute for Restorative Justice, “advocates for restorative justice as a social
movement, and is also a convener of spaces where knowledge about restorative justice practices
and programs can be shared among practitioners and learners, by facilitating conversations and
cultivating connections through activities such as conferences, webinars and both in-person and
online courses,” (About the Institute). Zehr has worked directly with GH in the past and has a
platform to communicate to a wide audience.
Intercessory:
Possible opinion leaders for GH include former residents of GH that have found success
as well as local community leaders that are affable to the organization. These opinion leaders
have the potential to be sources of content for campaign materials and spokespeople for the
organization. Howard Zehr is also an opinion leader for this organization. He operates a
restorative justice blog and is a professor at EMU. He is well regarded and respected within his
field as demonstrated by his seven honors form various organizations. Other opinion leaders may
include faculty at JMU, Bridgwater, or EMU as well as local supportive community leaders.
Target Publics:
Our first target public is college students within the area, particularly students at JMU.
This target public is made up almost entirely of millennials given the mean age of degree seeking
undergraduate students at JMU is 20 (Office of Institutional Research, 2017). Millennials are set
to become the most educated generation in history as they have the highest share in modern
history of 18- to 24-year-olds in this enrolled in college at almost 40% (Pew, 2010). Millenials
are also less religious than their predecessors as one-quarter of this generation say “I’m not
affiliated” or “I have no formal association with religion” (Pew, 2010). Additionally, this
generation identify strongly with technology and say it makes generation “unique,” and leading
adopters of new technologies (Pew, 2010). As opposite as millenials are to past generation, when
asked about, “... what they want to do as they get older, they have very conventional answers.
They say, I want to have a balanced life. I want to be a good citizen and a good neighbor,” (Pew,
2010).
College students make up a large portion of the Harrisonburg community. The
undergraduate population of students at JMU as of fall of 2018 is 20,798 (Facts and Figures,
9
2018). This public represents the most available public for communication efforts and have a lot
to offer GH in terms of community service, volunteering, internships, service learning, and in the
long term, potential donations. According to Cone Millennial Cause Study in 2006, 61 percent of
millenials want to make a difference in the world and feel that others should join them in civic-
minded pursuits (Pew, 2010). The study also found that millennials are placing heavy
significance on corporate philanthropy and social awareness (Pew, 2010). The top 3 social media
sites by usage for this public are as follows: Facebook, YouTube, and Instagram (Statista, 2017).
Middle-aged community members are also a target public because they are the generation
to most likely have negative perceptions of GH so it’s important to educate them as well and
hopefully change any negative perception on the organization. The middle-aged community
members more likely to be financial donors than our the other target public as they have more
income adding to their value as a public.
This target public is mostly within the Generation X cohort. Those that fall under
Generation X or Baby Boomers are usually more skeptical of things and more resistant to change
(Cone, Inc. 2006). Generation X generally have more conservative views than millennials but
more liberal views than baby boomers (Taylor et al, 2014). They are described as self-reliant and
are also a smaller cohort than the generation before or after them (Taylor et al, 2014). The top 3
social media sites by usage for this public are as follows: Facebook, YouTube, and Twitter
(Statista, 2017).
Helpful Harmful
References
Ahrens, F. (1997, April 08). The secrets in the briefcase. Retrieved from
https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/lifestyle/1997/04/08/the-secrets-in-the-
briefcase/454071c1-b04e-48aa-b75c-9551c71bc589/?utm_term=.ef322ccafd4f
AP-NORC. (2018). Addiction: Social stigma among adults U.S. 2018 | Statistic. Retrieved
September 16, 2018, from https://www.statista.com/statistics/859419/addiction-a-social-
stigma-in-us/
Bridgewater College. (2016, January 19). Disrupting the cycle. Retrieved from
https://www.bridgewater.edu/events-news/news-releases/1439-disrupting-the-cycle
Clark, K. (2017, June 13). NEW: Small fire contained at Gemeinschaft Home. Retrieved from
http://www.dnronline.com/news/new-small-fire-contained-at-gemeinschaft-
home/article_ad11311a-505d-11e7-ab05-c32498f96860.html?platform=hootsuite
Colwell, P. F., Dehring, C. A., & Lash, N. A. (2000). The Effect of Group Homes on
Neighborhood Property Values. Land Economics,76(4), 615. doi:10.2307/3146956
EMarketer. (2017, October). Time spent with traditional media in the U.S. 2017 | Statistic.
Retrieved September 16, 2018, from https://www.statista.com/statistics/297054/consumer-
media-consumption-type/
Facts and Figures. (2018). Retrieved September 17, 2018, from https://www.jmu.edu/about/fact-
and-figures.shtml
Fitzgerald, E.J. (2018). Background of Decision Point Tactics. Combat Training Center
Quarterly Bulletin. Retrieved from
https://www.globalsecurity.org/military/library/report/call/call_97-4_chap1.htm
Hyland, M. (2008, October 10). Uncertain future for Gemeinschaft Home. Retrieved
from http://www.whsv.com/home/headlines/30813429.html
Jenner, A. (2014, March 8). It’s their home - helping inmates live outside walls. Retrieved from
https://emu.edu/now/news/2014/03/its-their-home-helping-inmates-live-outside-walls/.
Kara (2014, July 08). It's their home – helping inmates live outside walls - EMU News.
Retrieved from https://emu.edu/now/news/2014/03/its-their-home-helping-inmates-live-
outside-walls/
Lopez, G. (2018). Congress’ prison reform bill, explained. Vox. Retrieved from
https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2018/5/22/1737734/first-step-act-prison
-reform
Pew Research Center. (2010, February). Retrieved September 15, 2018, from
http://assets.pewresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/2010/10/millennials-confident-
connected-open-to-change.pdf
Powell, A. (2015, October 12). Harrisonburg City Council to vote on Pilot Day Reporting
Program. Retrieved from http://www.whsv.com/news/headlines/Harrisonburg-City-
Council-to-Vote-on-Pilot-Day-Reporting-Program-332225182.html
Taylor, P., & Gao, G. (2014, June 05). Generation X: America's neglected 'middle child'.
Retrieved September 15, 2018, from http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-
tank/2014/06/05/generation-x-americas-neglected-middle-child/
VADOC Monthly Population Summary. (2018, January). Retrieved September 16, 2018, from
https://vadoc.virginia.gov/about/facts/research/new-popsum/2018/jan18popsummary.pdf
13