Solutions Manual for

Separation Process Engineering

Includes Mass Transfer Analysis
Third Edition
 TABLE OF CONTENTS

6$03/(&RXUVH6\OODEXVLQ6HSDUDWLRQ3URFHVV(QJLQHHULQJ S

(;$03/(6FKHGXOH$(TXLOLEULXP6WDJHG3OXV0HPEUDQHVZLWK&RPSXWHU/DEV S

(;$03/(6FKHGXOH%&ODVVLFDO(TXLOLEULXP6WDJHG&RXUVHZLWK&RPSXWHU/DE S

(;$03/(6FKHGXOH&9DSRU/LTXLG6HSDUDWLRQV&RXUVHZLWK&RPSXWHU/DE S

(;$03/(6FKHGXOH'(TXLOLEULXP6WDJHG6HSDUDWLRQV3OXV$GVRUSWLRQ,RQ([FKDQJH 
&KURPDWRJUDSK\ZLWK&RPSXWHU/DE  S
$VVXPHVVWXGHQWVNQRZ)LFNLDQ'LIIXVLRQ 0DVV7UDQVIHU

(;$03/(6FKHGXOH(&ODVVLFDO(TXLOLEULXP6WDJH&RXUVH:LWKRXW&RPSXWHU/DE S

(;$03/(6FKHGXOH)0DVV7UDQVIHU 'LIIXVLRQ3OXV0DVV7UDQVIHU$QDO\VLVRI'LVWLOODWLRQ
$EVRUSWLRQ0HPEUDQH 6RUSWLRQ6HSDUDWLRQV   S
$VVXPHVVWXGHQWVKDYHKDGDQ(TXLOLEULXP6WDJHG6HSDUDWLRQV&RXUVH

(;$03/(6FKHGXOH*6HQLRU*UDGXDWH$GYDQFHG0DVV7UDQVIHU 6HSDUDWLRQ S
$VVXPHVVWXGHQWVKDYHKDGXQGHUJUDGXDWHPDVVWUDQVIHUDQGVHSDUDWLRQV

SOLUTI ONS TO PROBLEM S:

Chapter 1 S
Chapter 2 S
Chapter 3 S
Chapter 4    S
Chapter 5    S
Chapter 6    S
Chapter 7    S
Chapter 8 S
Chapter 9  S
Chapter 10    S
Chapter 11    S
Chapter 12    S
Chapter 13    S
Chapter 14    S
Chapter 15 S
Chapter 16    S
Chapter 17    S
Chapter 18 S



 SAM PLE COURSE SYLLABUS
CHE 306 DESI GN SEPARATI ON PROCESSES
COURSE SYLLABUS

Prerequisites: M ust have passed M ass & Energy Balances and Thermodynamics


TEXTBOOK: 3&:DQNDW6HSDUDWLRQ3URFHVV(QJLQHHULQJQGUGHGLWLRQRI(TXLOLEULXP

6WDJHG 6HSDUDWLRQ 3URFHVVHV 3UHQWLFH +DOO   <RX ZLOO QHHG WKH QG
HGLWLRQRI63(QRWWKHVWHGLWLRQ


Goals: %\WKHHQGRI&+(\RXVKRXOGEHDEOHWR
 'HVLJQIODVKGLVWLOODWLRQE\KDQGDQGFRPSXWHUFDOFXODWLRQV
 'HVLJQGLVWLOODWLRQV\VWHPVE\KDQGDQGFRPSXWHUFDOFXODWLRQV
 'HVLJQDEVRUEHUVDQGVWULSSHUVE\KDQGDQGFRPSXWHUFDOFXODWLRQV
'HVLJQH[WUDFWLRQV\VWHPVE\KDQGDQGFRPSXWHUFDOFXODWLRQV
 'HVLJQPHPEUDQHVHSDUDWLRQV\VWHPV

I mportance: 6HSDUDWLRQVFRQVWLWXWHWRRIWKHFRVWFDSLWDODQGRSHUDWLQJRIFKHPLFDO
SODQWV  'LVWLOODWLRQ LV WKH PRVW LPSRUWDQW VHSDUDWLRQ PHWKRG LQ WKH FKHPLFDO DQG SHWUROHXP
LQGXVWULHV6HSDUDWLRQVDUHRQHRIWKHNH\LWHPVZKLFKGHOLQHDWHFKHPLFDOHQJLQHHULQJIURPWKH
RWKHUHQJLQHHULQJGLVFLSOLQHV

Course The basic course outline is:
Structure:  ,QWURGXFWRU\0DWHULDO ZHHN
 )ODVK'LVWLOODWLRQ ZHHN
 %LQDU\'LVWLOODWLRQ  ZHHNV
 0XOWLFRPSRQHQW'LVWLOODWLRQ  ZHHNV
 &RPSOH['LVWLOODWLRQ ZHHNV
 %DWFK'LVWLOODWLRQ ZHHN
 'LVWLOODWLRQ'HVLJQ  ZHHN
 $EVRUSWLRQ6WULSSLQJ ([WUDFWLRQ ZHHNV
 ([WUDFWLRQ  ZHHN
0HPEUDQHVHSDUDWLRQV  ZHHNV

7KHGHWDLOHGFRXUVHRXWOLQHLVDWWDFKHG


7KHW\SLFDOZHHNO\VFKHGXOHZLOOEH


0RQGD\:HGQHVGD\DQG)ULGD\/HFWXUHVSOXVRSWLRQDOKHOS
:HGQHVGD\7KXUVGD\ &RPSXWHU/DEZKHQVFKHGXOHG
6LQFHWKHVFKHGXOHZLOOVRPHWLPHVGHYLDWHIURPWKLVSDWWHUQIROORZ\RXUGHWDLOHGFRXUVHRXWOLQH

Suggested 5HDGERRNEHIRUHFODVV&RPHWRFODVVSUHSDUHG7KHUHZLOOEH
Study VKRUWTXL]]HVWRHQFRXUDJHSUHSDUDWLRQ1HZPDWHULDO
Procedure: ZLOOEHSUHVHQWHGLQFODVVDVQHHGHG0DWHULDOLQWKHERRNWKDWLVDUHYLHZ
RULVHDV\WRXQGHUVWDQGZLOOQRWEHOHFWXUHGRQ$VNTXHVWLRQVLIWKHERRN
LVQRWFOHDU$IWHUFODVVUHUHDGWKHERRN0DNHH[WHQVLYHQRWHVRQRULQ
WKHERRN%HIRUHHDFKH[DPVXPPDUL]H\RXUQRWHVRQRQHSDJHDQGWKHQ
UHGXFHWR[FDUGGRXEOHVLGHG\RXFDQWDNHLQWRWKHH[DP



 7KH VXJJHVWHG ZD\ WR GR KRPHZRUN  )LUVW ZRUN RQ DOO SUREOHPV E\
\RXUVHOI  7KHQ PHHW ZLWK \RXU VWXG\ JURXS WR FKHFN DQVZHUV DQG WR
FRPSOHWH VROXWLRQ RI PRUH GLIILFXOW SUREOHPV  $VN IRU KHOS RQFH WKHVH
RWKHUHIIRUWVKDYHIDLOHG)LQDOO\SUHSDUH\RXURZQVROXWLRQWRKDQGLQLI
WKH KRPHZRUN ZLOO EH JUDGHG ,W LV LPSRUWDQW WR VROYH D ORW RI SUREOHPV
LQFOXGLQJKRPHZRUNWKDWLVQRWKDQGHGLQ
!"#$%&"#'($%)*+($,$-"$./$&"#0%$12+3'#(2+4$3'5%%$6$'57$-28*9$"+$-&2%$3"#0%*$
*:*0;$ <**=>$ $ ?@$ ;"#$ 50*$ %)*+(2+4$ '*%%A$ <"0=$ 8"0*$ )0"7'*8%$ 7"-&$
2+(2:2(#5'';$5+($2+$;"#0$%-#(;$40"#)>$



!"#$$%&'( B"$*+3"#054*$%-#(*+-%$-"$)0*)50*$@"0$5+($5--*+($3'5%%A$-&*0*$<2''$7*$5$%*02*%$
"@$.C$%&"0-$D#2EE*%A$<&23&$50*$,F$"@$-&*$3"#0%*$405(*>$B&*$ '"<*%-$405(*$
<2''$ +"-$ 3"#+-A$ <&23&$ 2%$ *D#2:5'*+-$ -"$ "+*$ @0**$ 57%*+3*>$ $ G@-*0$ -&5-$ 5+$
57%*+3*$<2''$7*$5$E*0">$$H-#(*+-%$<&"$-#0+$2+$5$D#2E$<2-&$-&*20$+58*$"+$2-$
5+($ <&"$ %-5;$ -&*$ *+-20*$ )*02"($ 5+($ )5;$ 5--*+-2"+$ <2''$ 5#-"85-235'';$ *50+$
ICF>$$B&*0*$<2''$7*$!"$D#2E$85=*J#)%$5+($+"$-5=2+4$D#2EE*%$'5-*$#$%&'(")(
'*+( ,-.( )"&( %''+!/%!0+( 12( 3+1!4( "!( '15+( ±( 1)( 6"7( 8%!'( '*12( 0&+/1'( 5%9+(
%''+!/%!0+( %( *14*( :&1"&1'6;( <!( "'*+&( 8"&/2=( %!( 1!'+&>1+8( 12( ?@A( %( >%B1/(
+C072+()"&(51221!4(%(D71E;F(K2%%2+4$/$D#2EE*%$@"0$)'5+-$-02)%$<2''$3"%-$.F$
"@$-&*$3"#0%*$405(*$±$DVPDOOSHQDOW\:ULWLQJDQRWKHUVWXGHQW¶VQDPHRQD
D#2E$ 5+($ -#0+2+4$ 2-$ 2+$ @"0$ 5$ 405(*$ <2''$ 7*$ -0*5-*($ 5%$ 5$ @"08$ "@$ 3&*5-2+4>(
L05(*($D#2EE*%$<2''$7*$)5%%*($"#-$2+$'57%>$


Homework: 7KHUH ZLOO EH  KRPHZRUN DVVLJQPHQWV ZKLFK DUH KDQGHG LQ  6WXGHQWV
ZKRVROYHDOORIWKHSUREOHPVDUHYHU\OLNHO\WRVHHWKHLUHIIRUWVUHZDUGHG
E\KLJKHUWHVWVFRUHV7KHKRPHZRUNWKDWLVKDQGHGLQZLOOEHRIWKH
FRXUVHJUDGH7KHSURIHVVRUDQG7$VZLOOJUDGHRQHSUREOHPVHOHFWHGE\
WKHSURIHVVRUDQGRQHSUREOHPVHOHFWHGE\WKHVWXGHQW±ZULWHWKHSUREOHP
\RX ZDQW JUDGHG RQ WKH WRS RI WKH DVVLJQPHQW  *UDGHG KRPHZRUN
DVVLJQPHQWVZLOO EHSDVVHGRXWLQ ODEV:RUNLQ JURXSVRQKRPHZRUNLV
HQFRXUDJHG7XUQ LQ \RXU RZQVROXWLRQQRW;HUR[FRS\EXWSOHDVH OLVW
QDPHVRIJURXSPHPEHUVRQLW


Exams: $UUDQJH\RXUVFKHGXOHWREHDYDLODEOHIRUWKHQLJKWH[DPVRQ6HSWDQG
1RY  7KH WKLUG H[DP ZKLFK LV not D FXPXODWLYH ILQDO H[DP ZLOO EH
GXULQJILQDOV([DPVLQFOXGLQJWKHODEWHVWDUHRIWKHFRXUVHJUDGH
<RXU ORZHVW H[DP ZLOO EH  DQG WKH RWKHU WKUHH H[DPV ZLOO FRXQW DV
HDFK([DPVH[FHSWWKHODEWHVWDUHFORVHGERRNEXWVWXGHQWVZLOO
EH DOORZHG DQG HQFRXUDJHG WR KDYH RQH  [  FDUG GRXEOHVLGHG ZLWK
LQIRUPDWLRQRQLW$OOHOHFWURQLFGHYLFHVRWKHUWKDQDFDOFXODWRUPXVWEH
WXUQHGRIIDQGEHEXULHGLQ\RXUEDFNSDFN8VHRIWKHVHGHYLFHVZLOOEH
FRQVLGHUHGWREHFKHDWLQJ*UDGHGH[DPVZLOOEHSDVVHGRXWLQODEV


DO NOT M AKE TRAVEL PLANS UNTI L YOU KNOW THE FI NALS SCHEDULE

M ake-Up Exam: 6WXGHQWVDUHVWURQJO\XUJHGWRPDNHDWWHQGDQFHDWH[DPVDYHU\KLJK

SHUVRQDOSULRULW\DQGPDNHDSSURSULDWHDUUDQJHPHQWVWREHSUHVHQWDWDOO



 H[DPV,IDQH[DPLVPLVVHGVWXGHQWVPD\FKRRVHWRPDNHLWWKHLUORZHVW
H[DPJUDGHDQGUHFHLYHD]HURIRURIWKHLUFRXUVHJUDGH
$OWHUQDWLYHO\DVLQJOHFRPSUHKHQVLYHPDNHXSH[DPDYDLODEOHRQO\IRU
VWXGHQWVZKRPLVVDWHVWZLOOEHDGPLQLVWHUHGGXULQJILQDOVSHULRGDIWHU
([DP7KLVZLOOEHWKHRQO\PDNHXSH[DPDYDLODEOH,QFDVHVRI
H[WUHPHGXUHVVHJKRVSLWDOL]DWLRQWDONWRWKHSURIHVVRUIRURWKHU
DUUDQJHPHQWV


Computer Lab: &RPSXWHUODEVDUHVFKHGXOHGIRU:HGQHVGD\VDQG7KXUVGD\V:RUNLQODE

ZLOOLQLWLDOO\EHGRQHLQGLYLGXDOO\DQGODWHULQWKHVHPHVWHULQDVVLJQHG
RU SHUVRQ JURXSV  )HHO IUHH WR KHOS RWKHU VWXGHQWV DQG WR DVN IRU KHOS
GXULQJ ODE  /DERUDWRU\ ZLOO XVH WKH $63(1 3OXV VLPXODWLRQ SDFNDJH
0RVWRIWKH ODEDVVLJQPHQWVDUH LQ \RXU WH[WERRNWKXV \RXZLOO QHHGWR
EULQJ\RXUWH[WERRNWRODE
$
$ B&*$'57"05-"0;$1+"-$2+3'#(2+4$-&*$'57$-*%-9$<2''$7*$.IF$"@$-&*$3"#0%*$405(*>$$
G--*+(5+3*$6$5--*+-2"+$2+$3"8)#-*0$'57$2%$0*D#20*(A$5+($<2''$7*$MF$"@$-&*$
3"#0%*$405(*>$$B&*0*$<2''$7*$5$'282-*($"))"0-#+2-;$-"$("$'57$2+$5(:5+3*$"0$
85=*J#)$5$82%%*($'57"05-"0;A$7#-$<2-&"#-$&*')$@0"8$-&*$BG$15005+4*$<2-&$
;"#0$BG$-"$%&"<$;"#$&5:*$("+*$-&*$'57$<"0=9>$$N*35#%*$%*5-2+4$2%$'282-*(A$
%-#(*+-%$572'(5--*+($-&*20$%3&*(#'*($'57"05-"0;$)*02"($#+'*%%$5005+4*8*+-%$
50*$85(*$2+$5(:5+3*$-"$5--*+($5$'57$%*%%2"+$-&5-$&5%$")*+$%*5-%>$$L0"#)$'57$
0*)"0-%$ 50*$ 0*D#20*($ @"0$ -<"$ '57%>$ O57$ 40"#)%$ 50*$ *P)*3-*($ -"$ &*')$ *53&$
"-&*0$ @"0$ -&*$ -<"$ '57%$ -&5-$ 0*D#20*$ '57$ 0*)"0-%>$ $ Q+';$ D#*%-2"+%$ @0"8$ -&*$
*+-20*$40"#)$<2''$7*$5+%<*0*($7;$-&*$BG$"0$)0"@*%%"0$@"0$'57"05-"0;$&*')>$$
O57$0*)"0-%$<2''$ 7*$ '282-*($-"$-<"$)54*%$"@$-*P-$)'#%$"+*$)54*$"@$ @24#0*%$
5+($-57'*%>$$B&*$-<"$'57$0*)"0-%$5+($-&*$85%-*0;$'57$D#2E$*53&$3"#+-$R>CF$
"@$-&*$3"#0%*$405(*>$
$
 7KHUH ZLOO EH D lab test ZRUWK  RI FRXUVH JUDGH LQ )51<  RQ
1RYHPEHUWKDQGWKGXULQJ\RXUUHJXODUO\VFKHGXOHGODEKRXUV:RUN
ZLOOEHGRQHLQGLYLGXDOO\7KHODEWHVWZLOOEHRSHQERRNDQGRSHQQRWHV
7KHXVHRIHPDLOWKH,QWHUQHWRUROGFRPSXWHUILOHVZLOO QRWEHDOORZHG
GXULQJWKHODEWHVWPlan on being present.

)"**+,-( S#2EE*%$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$,F$ 1.T/$5--*+(5+3*$6$5--*+-2"+9$
of Grading: *UDGHG+RPHZRUN
([DPWRSOXVODEWHVW   ORZHVW JUDGH LV  RWKHUV DUH 
HDFK
$ O57$L05(*$15--*+(5+3*A$'57$0*)"0-%$6$'57$D#2E9$ .IF$1MF$5--*+(5+3*9$
 ([WUD&UHGLW

Grading Scale: 7KHFODVVZLOOYRWHLIWKH\ZDQWWRXVHWKHWUDGLWLRQDO$%&'VFDOHRU
VZLWFKWRWKHVFDOH7KHHQWLUHFODVVPXVWEHJUDGHGRQWKHVDPHVFDOH
 *XDUDQWHHG*UDGH6FDOHIRU$%&'VFDOH
  $
  %
  &



  '
 *XDUDQWHHG*UDGH6FDOHIRUVFDOH

!"#$% !&'()#*+% ,%-.//%0$%$(,#01%
!"#! $%& '()*&&
!) (%+ '&%&,),'-%'
." (%( /+%&,),/'%'
. (%& /(%&,),/0%'
.) -%+ /&%&,),/-%'
1" -%( ++%&,),+'%'
1 -%& +(%&,ʹ,+0%'
1) *%+ +&%&,ʹ,+-%'
2" *%( 0+%&,ʹ,0'%'
2 *%& 0(%&,ʹ,00%'
2) &%+,ʹ,3456748, 0&%&,ʹ,0-%'
96:48;,<=88>?@,
@A=B4,
C &%& D,0&%&

,

)RUERWKVFDOHVVOLJKWO\ORZHUFXWRIIVFRUHVPD\EHXVHGDWWKHGLVFUHWLRQRIWKHLQVWUXFWRU

Lectures: $FFRUGLQJWR8QLYHUVLW\UHJXODWLRQV LWLVWKHUHVSRQVLELOLW\RIVWXGHQWVWR
DWWHQG DOO FODVV VHVVLRQV DQG WR PDNH XS DQ\ PDWHULDO WKDW LV PLVVHG  7R
DLGVWXGHQWVRQHRIWKH7$VZLOOWDNHQRWHVRIHYHU\OHFWXUH7KHVHQRWHV
ZLOOEHSODFHGLQUHVHUYHLQWKH3RWWHU/LEUDU\
$ U"-*V$ $ -&*0*$ 2%$ 57#+(5+-$ *:2(*+3*$ -&5-$ %-#(*+-%$ <&"$ 0*4#'50';$ 5--*+($
'*3-#0*%$-*+($-"$*50+$&24&*0$405(*%>$

./0#12+3(4%3/( B&*$ W0"@*%%"0$ "0$ 5$ BG$ <2''$ &"'($ 5$ &*')$ %*%%2"+$ (#02+4$ -&*$ 0*4#'50';$
%3&*(#'*($ 3'5%%$ 1,VRC$ -"$ .CV/C$ 5>8>9$ "+*$ (5;$ 8"%-$ <**=%$ "+$ K"+(5;A$
X*(+*%(5;$"0$Y02(5;$1%**$(*-52'*($3"#0%*$"#-'2+*9>$$B&*$X*(+*%(5;$3'5%%$
"+$ -&*$ (5;$ "@$ -&*$ -<"$ +24&-$ *P58%$ <2''$ 7*$ 5+$ ")-2"+5'$ &*')$ %*%%2"+>$
G((2-2"+5'$ &*')$ %*%%2"+%$ 35+$ 7*$ 5005+4*($ 7*@"0*$ -*%-%$ 2@$ %-#(*+-%$ 0*D#*%-$
-&*8>$ $ ?+$ 5((2-2"+$ -&*$ )0"@*%%"0$ 5+($ -&*$ BG%$ <2''$ &5:*$ "@@23*$ &"#0%$ -&5-$
;"#$ 50*$ %-0"+4';$ *+3"#054*($ -"$ #%*>$ $ H2+3*$ "@@23*$ &"#0%$ 50*$ -05(2-2"+5'';$
+"-$&*5:2';$#%*($*50';$ 2+$-&*$ %*8*%-*0A$-&2%$ 2%$5$4""($-28*$-"$4*-$2+-"$-&*$
&572-$ "@$ 5--*+(2+4$ "@@23*$ &"#0%>$$ G'%"A$ @**'$ @0**$ -"$ (2%3#%%$ D#*%-2"+%$ <2-&$
;"#0$'57"05-"0;$2+%-0#3-"0$(#02+4$'57"05-"0;>$

Feedback to :LWKDYHU\ODUJHFODVVLWLVHVVHQWLDOO\LPSRVVLEOHIRUDSURIHVVRUWRNQRZ
Prof. Wankat HDFKVWXGHQWDQGWREHDZDUHRIWKHGLIILFXOWLHVWKH\DUHKDYLQJLQOHDUQLQJ
WKHFRXUVHPDWHULDO7RSURYLGHIHHGEDFNWRWKHSURIHVVRUDJURXSRI
VWXGHQWUHSUHVHQWDWLYHVZLOOEHFRQVWLWXWHGZLWKRQHUHSUHVHQWDWLYHIURP



 HDFKODERUDWRU\VHFWLRQ7KLVJURXSZLOOPHHWZLWK3URI:DQNDWRQFHSHU
ZHHNWRSURYLGHDQRQ\PRXVIHHGEDFNIURPDOOWKHVWXGHQWVLQWKHFRXUVH

5,16%&&#12+3( H-#(*+-%$2+$Z[\$RCM$50*$3"+-2+#2+4$"+$5$)0"4058$"@$%-#(;$-"$7*3"8*$$
Behavior: FKHPLFDOHQJLQHHUV(QJLQHHUVDUHH[SHFWHGWRXSKROGWKHFRGHRIHWKLFV
ZKLFK LQFOXGHV %HLQJ +RQHVW (QJLQHHUV VKDOO EXLOG WKHLU SURIHVVLRQDO
UHSXWDWLRQV RQ WKH PHULWV RI WKHLU VHUYLFHV DQG (QJLQHHUV VKDOO DFW LQ
VXFKDPDQQHUDVWRXSKROGDQGHQKDQFHWKHKRQRULQWHJULW\DQGGLJQLW\
RIWKHHQJLQHHULQJSURIHVVLRQ6WXGHQWVLQ&+(ZLOOEHH[SHFWHGWR
EHKDYHLQDQHWKLFDODQGSURIHVVLRQDOPDQQHU

7KLVLQFOXGHV  +RQHVW\RQTXL]]HVH[DPVDQG ODEWHVW&HOOSKRQHV
SDJHUV SHUVRQDO FRPSXWHUV 03 SOD\HUV SHUVRQDO
GLJLWDO DVVLVWDQWV HJ 3DOP 3LORWV  VLPLODU
HOHFWURQLF GHYLFHV PXVW EH RII DQG QRW LQ VLJKW ± QR
SKRQH FDOOVWH[W PHVVDJLQJRUXVHRIVWRUDJHDYDLODEOH
LQ WKH HOHFWURQLF GHYLFH  $OSKDQXPHULFDO GDWD RU
SURJUDPV DUH QRW DOORZHG LQ FDOFXODWRUV 7KH XVH RI
KHDG SKRQHV LV QRW DOORZHG  1RWH  VLQFH \RX ZLOO EH
DOORZHGWKHXVHRID[FDUGWKHUHLVQRUHDVRQWRWU\
DQGEHDWWKHV\VWHP
  1RSODJLDULVPRUFRS\LQJ
$ R>$ Z'528$30*(2-$@"0$&"8*<"0=T'57"05-"0;$"+';$2@$;"#$<*0*$
2+:"':*($ 2+$-&*$%"'#-2"+>$$]^"$UQB$-#0+$ 2+$5$3");$-&5-$
;"#$ ("$ +"-$ #+(*0%-5+(>_$ $ B&2%$ 2%$ 3"88"+$ %*+%*$ ±$ +"-$
3&*5-2+4>$ $ H-#(*+-%$ <&"$ 3");$ &"8*<"0=$ 1%-023-';$
%)*5=2+4$ -&2%$ 2%$ '*45'A$ 7#-$ %-#)2(9$ <2''$ ("$ )""0';$ "+$
*P58%$5+($0*3*2:*$'"<$405(*%$7*35#%*$"@$-&2%>$
  1R GLVUXSWLRQ RI FODVV  %HFDXVH FHOO SKRQHV DUH
GLVUXSWLYHSOHDVHWXUQFHOOSKRQHVRIIEHIRUHOHFWXUHVRU
ODE,QDGGLWLRQVLQFH PDQ\ VWXGHQWVUHSRUWWKDWZKHQ
VWXGHQWVWDONWRQHLJKERUVGXULQJOHFWXUHLWLVGLVUXSWLYH
SOHDVHGRQRWGRLW
  0DNHDFRQFHUWHGGLOLJHQWHIIRUWWROHDUQ




 EXAM PLE Schedule A: Equilibrium Staged Plus M embranes
with Computer Labs
6NLS&KDSWHUDQG
1RWH&ODVVHVDUHORDGHGWRZDUGVEHJLQQLQJRIWKHVHPHVWHU
&K()DOO
          5HDGLQJ
  0 ,QWURGXFWLRQ 2YHUYLHZ6HSDUDWLRQV   &KDSW
  : 3KDVHHTXLO)ODVK'LVW$VSHQ3OXV   &KDSW
  :7K /DE,QWUR$VSHQ3OXV)ODVK'LVW$SSHQGL[&
   Bring textbook to all labs except lab test.
  ) 4XL]3KDVH(TXLOLEULXP)ODVK/HFWXUH)ODVK'LVW&KDSW
  0 %LQDU\ 0XOWL&RPSRQHQW)ODVKGLVWLOODWLRQ  &KDSW
  : 4XL]%LQDU\)ODVK&ORVHGERRNFDQKDYH[FDUG
   6WDUWGLVWLOODWLRQ     &KDSW
   :7K /DE)51<)ODVK'LVW $SSHQGL[&KDSW/DE
  ) 'LVWLOODWLRQ0F&DEH7KLHOH    &KDSW
  0 /DERU'D\±1RFODVVDQGQRRIILFHKRXUV

  : +:GXH/HFWXUH0F&DEH7KLHOH   &KDSW
  :7K /DE'LVWLOODWLRQ  $SSHQGL[&KDSWHU/DE  
  ) 4XL]0F&DEH7KLHOH±RSHQERRN0F&DEH7KLHOH&
  0 0F&DEH7KLHOH     &KDSW
  : 0F&DEH7KLHOH FROXPQGHVLJQ   &KDSW
  :7K /DE'LVWLOODWLRQGHVLJQ$SS&GRODEDQGLIWLPHVWDUWODE
  ) +:GXH4XL]0F&DEH7KLHOH[FDUG
   0&GLVWLOODWLRQSURILOHVFDOFXODWLRQV   &KDSW
  0 2SWLRQDO+HOS
  : 0&'LVWLOODWLRQ±6KRUWFXW    &KDSW
  :7K 0DVWHU\ODETXL]±FRXQWVVDPHDVODEUHSRUW)LQLVKODE$SS&
  ) 4XL]0&'LVWLOODWLRQ[FDUG   
   0&'LVWLOODWLRQ±0DWUL[6ROXWLRQV   &KDSW
  0 +:GXH)LQLVK0&'LVW5HYLHZKRPHZRUN &KDSW
  : 2SWLRQDO&ODVV±+HOS6HVVLRQ
  : Night Exam, Lilly 1105, 6FKHGXOHGIRUWR
D[FDUGZLWKLQIRUPDWLRQLVDOORZHGRWKHUZLVHFORVHGERRNDQGFORVHGQRWHV
   :7K 1R/DE
  ) 5HYLHZ([DP6WDUWFRPSOH[GLVWLOODWLRQ  &KDSW
  0 &RPSOH[GLVWLOODWLRQ     &KDSW
  : 4XL]&RPSOH[GLVWLOODWLRQRSHQERRN
   &RPSOH[GLVWLOODWLRQ     &KDSW
   :7K /DE&RPSOH[GLVWLOODWLRQ$SS&ODERUODE
  127(6RPH\HDUV,GRODELQ$SS&RUDVVLJQDVDJURXS+:
  ) 1RFODVV QRRIILFHKRXUV
  0 2FWREHU%UHDN±1RFODVVDQGQRRIILFHKRXUV
  : 2SWLRQDO+HOSRQ+:5XQE\7$V
2FW :7K /DE([WUDFWLYHGLVWLOODWLRQLQODEJURXSV5HSRUW'XHRU 
  LQODE $SS&ODESS
  127(,QODE$SS&GLGQRW\HWH[LVW,ZRXOGDGGWKLVODE
  ) +:GXH$EVRUSWLRQ VWULSSLQJ   &KDSW



  0 $EVRUSWLRQ 6WULSSLQJ    &KDSW
  : 4XL]$EVRUS 6WULSSLQJ6WDUW([WUDFWLRQ  &KDSWV 
  :7K /DE$EVRUSWLRQ 6WULSSLQJ5HSRUW'XHRULQODE 
   $SS&ODESS
  ) +:GXH6WDUWH[WUDFWLRQ    &KDSW
  0 2SWLRQDOKHOS
  : ([WUDFWLRQ      &KDSW
   :7K /DE([WUDFWLRQ $SS&ODESS
  ) 4XL]([WUDFWLRQ[FDUG([WHQVLRQ0F&DEH7KLHOH&KDSW
  0 +:GXH5HYLHZ+:)LQLVK0F&DEH7KLHOH &KDSW
  : 2SWLRQDO+HOS
  : Night Exam 2, Lilly 1105,6FKHGXOHGIRUWR
D[FDUGZLWKLQIRUPDWLRQLVDOORZHGRWKHUZLVHFORVHGERRNDQGFORVHGQRWHV
   :7K 1R/DE
  ) 5HYLHZH[DP
  0 1RFODVV±$,&K(1DWLRQDO
  : 1RFODVV±$,&K(1DWLRQDO
127(3XUGXH¶VVHPHVWHUKDVFODVVSHULRGVSOXVWKHH[DPLQ)LQDOV7KHQRFODVVDQGRSWLRQDOKHOS
SHULRGVDUHLQFOXGHGWRFRPSO\ZLWKXQLYHUVLW\UHJXODWLRQV
  :7K 1RODE
  ) 2SWLRQDOKHOSZLWK7$V    
  0 %DWFKGLVWLOODWLRQ     &KDSW
  : %DWFKGLVWLOODWLRQ     &KDSW
 1RY :7K /DE([DP )51<
  ) %DWFK'LVWLOODWLRQ4XL]EDWFKGLVWRSHQERRN &KDSW
  0 1RFODVV
  7KDQNVJLYLQJ9DFDWLRQ
  0 +:GXH6WDUW0HPEUDQH6HSDUDWLRQV  &KDSW
  : 0HPEUDQHVHSDUDWLRQV4XL]0HPEUDQHVRSHQERRN&KDSW 
'HF :7K 1R/DE
  ) 0HPEUDQHVHSDUDWLRQV    &KDSW
  0 2SWLRQDOKHOS
  : 2SWLRQDOKHOS
'HF  :7K 1RODE
  ) +:GXH0HPEUDQHV±6ROXWLRQWR+:5HYLHZIRUH[DP
6DWXUGD\(( EXAM 3.1RWFXPXODWLYHFRYHUVEDWFKGLVWLOODWLRQ PHPEUDQH
VHSDUDWLRQV$[FDUGZLWKLQIRUPDWLRQLVDOORZHGRWKHUZLVHFORVHGERRNFORVHGQRWHV

M AKE TRAVEL PLANS AFTER THE FI NALS SCHEDULE IS AVAI LABLE!

),1$/67%$±0DNHXS([DPIRUH[DPRU&XPXODWLYH

 'RNOTVFKHGXOHDQ\FRQIOLFWVZLWKODEWHVWRQ1RYDQG

5HDGLQJVDUHLQ6HSDUDWLRQ3URFHVV(QJLQHHULQJ

!"#$%&#&'&"$#()#*#+*,(-#.*+/01#&+&-2&".34#.(0-1&#-&506-&+&"$14#7&*786"&1#*"7#2-*76"2#
/&-.&"$*2&1#*-&#109,&.$#$(#.%*"2&1#$%*$#+*3#9&#"&.&116$*$&7#93#*#-&'61&7#1&+&1$&-#.*8&"7*-#
(-#($%&-#.6-.0+1$*".&1:##;(#$(#<8*.=9(*-7#$(#2&$#6")(-+*$6("#*9(0$#.%*"2&1#6"#$%61#.(0-1&:




 EXAM PLE Schedule B: Classical Equilibrium Staged Course
with Computer Lab
6NLS&KDSWHUV
&ODVV   6XEMHFW 5HDGLQJ
   ,QWURGXFWLRQ3KDVH(TXLOLEULXP&KDSW
   3KDVH(TXLOLEULXP6WDUW)ODVK &KDSW
   )ODVK±%LQDU\ 0XOWLFRPSRQHQW &KDSW
   )ODVK±%LQDU\ 0XOWLFRPSRQHQW &KDSW
  /DE,QWURWR$VSHQ3OXV/DE$SS&
   )ODVK±0XOWL&RPSRQHQWDQG$VSHQ3OXV &KDSW
   %LQDU\'LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW 
   /DE±)ODVK'LVWLOODWLRQ/DE$SS&
   0F&DEH7KLHOH &KDSW
   0F&DEH7KLHOH &KDSW
   /DE±%LQDU\'LVWLOODWLRQ/DE$SS&
   0F&DEH7KLHOH
   3URILOHV ,QWUR0&'LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   /DE±0&'LVWLOODWLRQ/DE$SS&
   (;$0 
   5HYLHZ7HVW 0&'LVW0DVV%DODQFHV &KDSW
   /DE0&'LVWLOODWLRQ/DE$SS&
   0&'LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   6KRUW&XW'LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   /DE±&RPSOH['LVWLOODWLRQ/DE$SS&
   &RPSOH['LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   &RPSOH['LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
  /DE&RPSOH['LVWLOODWLRQ/DE$SS&
   &RPSOH['LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   &RPSOH['LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   /DE([WUDFWLYH'LVWLOODWLRQ/DE$SS& 
   6WDJHG&RO'HVLJQ &KDSW
  3DFNHG&ROV'LVWO&RVWV(QHUJ\&RQVHUYDWLRQ&KDSWV 
   /DE7UD\5DWLQJ/DE$SS&
   ([DPUHYLHZ
   (;$0
   5HYLHZ([DP 
   $EVRUSWLRQ 6WULSSLQJ &KDSW
   $EVRUSWLRQ 6WULSSLQJ &KDSW
   /DE±$EVRUSWLRQ6WULSSLQJ/DE$SS&
   ,PPLVFLEOH([WUDFWLRQ &KDSW
   0LVFLEOH([WUDFWLRQ &KDSW
   /DE±([WUDFWLRQ/DE$SS&
   0LVFLEOH([WUDFWLRQ &KDSW
   ([WHQVLRQ0F&DEH7KLHOH &KDSW
   /DE7HVW
   %DWFK'LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   %DWFK'LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   ([DP5HYLHZ
),1$/6   (;$0
$



 EXAM PLE Schedule C: Vapor-Liquid Separations Course
with Computer Lab
6NLS&KDSWHUVSDUW
&ODVV   6XEMHFW 5HDGLQJ
   ,QWURGXFWLRQ3KDVH(TXLOLEULXP&KDSW
   3KDVH(TXLOLEULXP6WDUW)ODVK &KDSW
   )ODVK±%LQDU\ 0XOWLFRPSRQHQW &KDSW
   )ODVK±%LQDU\ 0XOWLFRPSRQHQW &KDSW
  /DE,QWURWR$VSHQ3OXV/DE$SS&
   )ODVK±0XOWL&RPSRQHQWDQG$VSHQ3OXV &KDSW
   %LQDU\'LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW 
   /DE±)ODVK'LVWLOODWLRQ/DE$SS&
   0F&DEH7KLHOH &KDSW
   0F&DEH7KLHOH &KDSW
   /DE±%LQDU\'LVWLOODWLRQ/DE$SS&
   0F&DEH7KLHOH
   3URILOHV ,QWUR0&'LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   /DE±0&'LVWLOODWLRQ/DE$SS&
   (;$0 
   5HYLHZ7HVW 0&'LVW0DVV%DODQFHV &KDSW
   /DE0&'LVWLOODWLRQ/DE$SS&
   0&'LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   6KRUW&XW'LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   /DE±&RPSOH['LVWLOODWLRQ/DE$SS&
   &RPSOH['LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   &RPSOH['LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
  /DE&RPSOH['LVWLOODWLRQ/DE$SS&
   &RPSOH['LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   &RPSOH['LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   /DE([WUDFWLYH'LVWLOODWLRQ/DE$SS& 
   6WDJHG&RO'HVLJQ &KDSW
  3DFNHG&ROV'LVWO&RVWV(QHUJ\&RQVHUYDWLRQ&KDSWV 
   /DE7UD\5DWLQJ/DE$SS&
   ([DPUHYLHZ
   (;$0
   5HYLHZ([DP 
   $EVRUSWLRQ 6WULSSLQJ &KDSW
   $EVRUSWLRQ 6WULSSLQJ &KDSW
   /DE±$EVRUSWLRQ6WULSSLQJ/DE$SS&
   0DVV7UDQVIHU5HYLHZ)LFNLDQ'LIIXVLRQ 0DVV7UDQVIHU&RHI&
   0D[ZHOO6WHIDQ'LIIXVLRQ 0DVV7UDQVIHU &KDSWHU
   /DE±/DE7HVW
   0D[ZHOO6WHIDQ'LIIXVLRQ 0DVV7UDQVIHU &KDSWHU
   5DWH%DVHG'HVLJQRI'LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSWHU
   /DE±5DWH%DVHG'HVLJQRI'LVWLOODWLRQ/DE$SS&
   %DWFK'LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   %DWFK'LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   ([DP5HYLHZ
),1$/6   (;$0




 EXAM PLE Schedule D: Equilibrium Staged Separations Plus Adsorption,
I on Exchange & Chromatography with Computer Lab*
$VVXPHVVWXGHQWVNQRZ)LFNLDQ'LIIXVLRQ 0DVV7UDQVIHU
6NLS&KDSWHUV
&ODVV   6XEMHFW 5HDGLQJ
   ,QWURGXFWLRQ2YHUYLHZVHSDUDWLRQV&KDSW
   3KDVH(TXLO )ODVK'LVW &KDSW
   )ODVK'LVWLOODWLRQ$VSHQ3OXV &KDSW
  /DE$VSHQ3OXV )ODVK'LVWLOODWLRQ/DE$SS&
   )ODVK± &KDSW
   )ODVK &KDSW
   /DE±)ODVK'LVWLOODWLRQ/DE$SS&
   ,QWUR%LQDU\'LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   %LQDU\'LVWLOODWLRQ $VSHQ3OXV &KDSW
   /DE±%LQDU\'LVWLOODWLRQ/DE$SS& 
   0F&DEH7KLHOH &KDSW
   0F&DEH7KLHOH &KDSW
   0F&DEH7KLHOH H[DPUHYLHZ &KDSW
   (;$0
   5HYLHZ7HVW0&3URILOHV &KDSW
   0&'LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   /DE±0&'LVWLOODWLRQ/DE$SS&
   0&'LVWLOODWLRQ0DWUL[VROXWLRQV &KDSW 
   0&'LVWLOODWLRQ 6KRUW&XW &KDSW
   /DE±0&GLVWLOODWLRQ/DE$SS&
   &RPSOH['LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   &RPSOH['LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   /DE±&RPSOH['LVWLOODWLRQ/DERU/DE$SS&
   &RPSOH['LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   &RPSOH['LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   /DE±([WUDFWLYH'LVWLOODWLRQ/DE$SS&
   6WDJHG&ROXPQ'HVLJQ &KDSW 
   3DFNHG&ROXPQ'HVLJQ 'LVW&RVWV &KDSWV 
   /DE±7UD\6L]LQJ/DE$SS&
   5HYLHZIRU([DP
   ([DP
  $EVRUSWLRQ &KDSW 
   $EVRUSWLRQ 6WULSSLQJ &KDSW
   /DE$EVRUSWLRQ6WULSSLQJ/DE$SS&    
   ,PPLVFLEOHH[WUDFWLRQ &KDSW
   0LVFLEOHH[WUDFWLRQ &KDSW
   /DE([WUDFWLRQ/DE$SS&
  $GVRUSWLRQ)XQGDPHQWDOV (TXLOLEULXP &KDSW
   $GVRUSWLRQ±VROXWHPRYHPHQW &KDSW
   $GVRUSWLRQ FKURPDWRJUDSK\±VROXWHPRYHPHQW &KDSW
   $GVRUSWLRQ FKURPDWRJUDSK\±VROXWHPRYHPHQW &KDSW
   ,RQH[FKDQJH±HTXLOLEULXP VROXWHPRYHPHQW &KDSW
   ,QWURWRPDVVWUDQVIHUHIIHFWV ]RQHEURDGHQLQJ &KDSW
   5(9,(:IRU([DP 
),1$/6   (;$0



 Schedule E. Classical Equilibrium Stage Course Without Computer Lab
 6NLS/DEVLQ$SSHQGLFHV 6NLS&KDSWHUV 

   ,QWURGXFWLRQ3KDVH(TXLOLEULXP&KDSW
   3KDVH(TXLOLEULXP6WDUW)ODVK &KDSW
   )ODVK±%LQDU\ 0XOWLFRPSRQHQW &KDSW
   )ODVK0XOWLFRPSRQHQW &KDSW
  )ODVK0XOWLFRPSRQHQW
   )ODVK±'UXP'HVLJQ &KDSW
   ,QWUR7R%LQDU\'LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW 
   0F&DEH7KLHOH &KDSW
   0F&DEH7KLHOH &KDSW
   0F&DEH7KLHOH &KDSW
   0F&DEH7KLHOH
   3URILOHV ,QWUR0&'LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   6WDJHE\6WDJH0&&DOFXODWLRQ &KDSW
   6WDJHE\6WDJH0&&DOFXODWLRQ &KDSW
   ([DP5HYLHZ
   (;$0 
   5HYLHZ7HVW 0&'LVW0DVV%DODQFHV &KDSW  
   0&'LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   0&'LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   6KRUW&XW'LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   &RPSOH['LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   &RPSOH['LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW  
   &RPSOH['LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   &RPSOH['LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW 
   6WDJHG&RO'HVLJQ &KDSW
   6WDJHG&RO'HVLJQ &KDSW
   3DFNHG&ROV &KDSW
  'LVWO&RVWV(QHUJ\&RQVHUYDWLRQ &KDSW
   &ROXPQ6HTXHQFLQJ &KDSW
   ([DPUHYLHZ
   (;$0
 5HYLHZ([DP 
   %DWFK'LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   %DWFK'LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   %DWFK'LVWLOODWLRQ &KDSW
   $EVRUSWLRQ 6WULSSLQJ &KDSW
   $EVRUSWLRQ 6WULSSLQJ &KDSW
   $EVRUSWLRQ 6WULSSLQJ &KDSW
   ,PPLVFLEOH([WUDFWLRQ &KDSW
   ,PPLVFLEOH 3DUWLDOO\0LVFLEOH([WUDFWLRQ &KDSW
   3DUWLDOO\0LVFLEOH([WUDFWLRQ &KDSW
   3DUWLDOO\0LVFLEOH([WUDFWLRQ &KDSW
   :DVKLQJ /HDFKLQJ &KDSW
   ([DP5HYLHZ
),1$/6   (;$0



 Schedule F. M ass Transfer & Diffusion Plus M ass Transfer Analysis of
Distillation, Absorption, M embrane & Sorption Separations*
$VVXPHVVWXGHQWVKDYHKDGDQ(TXLOLEULXP6WDJHG6HSDUDWLRQV&RXUVH
6NLS&KDSWHUVH[FHSWHTXLOLEULXP&KDSWHUV
 ,QWURGXFWLRQ0ROHFXODU%DVLVRI'LIIXVLRQ 6HFWLRQ
 %LQDU\)LFNLDQ'LIIXVLRQ 6HFWLRQ
 %LQDU\6WHDG\6WDWH'LIIXVLRQZLWKRXWFRQYHFWLRQ 6HFWLRQ
 %LQDU\6WHDG\6WDWH'LIIXVLRQZLWKFRQYHFWLRQ 6HFWLRQ
 %LQDU\6WHDG\6WDWH'LIIXVLRQZLWKFRQYHFWLRQ 6HFWLRQ
 %LQDU\)LFNLDQ*DV'LIIXVLYLWLHV 6HFWLRQ
 %LQDU\)LFNLDQ/LTXLG'LIIXVLYLWLHV 6HFWLRQ
 /LQHDU'ULYLQJ)RUFH0RGHO 6HFWLRQ
 0DVV7UDQVIHU&RHIILFLHQW&RUUHODWLRQV 6HFWLRQ
 0DVV7UDQVIHU&RHIILFLHQW&RUUHODWLRQV 6HFWLRQ
 'LVWLOODWLRQ+78178FDOFXODWLRQV 6HFWLRQ
 'LVWLOODWLRQ+78 +(73 6HFWLRQV 
 3DFNHG7RZHU&RUUHODWLRQV 6WDUW$EVRUEHUV 6HFWLRQV 
 $EVRUEHUV 6WULSSHUV 6HFWLRQV 
 5HYLHZIRU([DP
 (;$0
 *RRYHUH[DP%LQDU\'LVWLOODWLRQ7UD\(IILFLHQF\ 6HFWLRQ
 /LPLWDWLRQV)LFNLDQ'LIIXVLRQ 0XUSKUHH(IILFLHQFLHV
 6WDUW0D[ZHOO6WHIDQ$QDO\VLV 6HFWLRQV 
 0D[ZHOO6WHIDQ$QDO\VLV 6HFWLRQ
 0D[ZHOO6WHIDQ$QDO\VLV 6HFWLRQ
 0D[ZHOO6WHIDQ$QDO\VLV 6HFWLRQ
 0D[ZHOO6WHIDQ$QDO\VLV 6HFWLRQ
 5DWH%DVHG$QDO\VLVRI'LVWLOODWLRQ 6HFWLRQ
 5HYLHZRI7UD\'HVLJQ &KDSW /DE
 $VSHQ3OXV5DWH%DVHG$VVLJQPHQW /DE$SS&
 6WDUW0HPEUDQH6HSDUDWLRQV 6HFWLRQV 
 *DV3HUPHDWLRQ 6HFWLRQ
 *DV3HUPHDWLRQ 6HFWLRQ
 5HYLHZIRU([DP
 ([DP
 *RRYHUH[DP)ORZSDWWHUQVLQJDVSHUPHDWLRQ 6HFWLRQ
 5HYHUVH2VPRVLV 6HFWLRQ
 5HYHUVH2VPRVLV 6HFWLRQ
 8OWUDILOWUDWLRQ 6HFWLRQ
 6WDUW$GVRUSWLRQ 6HFWLRQ
 /LQHDU6ROXWH0RYHPHQW$QDO\VLV 6HFWLRQ
 /LQHDU6ROXWH0RYHPHQW$QDO\VLV 6HFWLRQV 
 /LQHDU 1RQOLQHDU6ROXWH0RYHPHQW$QDO\VLV 6HFWLRQV 
 1RQOLQHDU$QDO\VLV 6HFWLRQ
 ,RQ([FKDQJH 6HFWLRQ
 0DVV (QHUJ\7UDQVIHU 6HFWLRQ
 6ROXWLRQVIRU/LQHDU6\VWHPV 6HFWLRQ
 /8%$QDO\VLV 6HFWLRQ
 5HYLHZIRU([DP
),1$/6 ([DP



 Schedule G. Senior/Graduate Advanced M ass Transfer & Separation 
$VVXPHVVWXGHQWVKDYHKDGXQGHUJUDGXDWHPDVVWUDQVIHUDQGVHSDUDWLRQV

 ,QWURGXFWLRQ5HYLHZ)LFNLDQPDVVWUDQVIHU 6HFWLRQV
 5HYLHZ/')PRGHOPDVVWUDQVIHUFRHI+78178 6HFW
 3UHGLFWLRQV)LFNLDQGLIIXVLYLW\ PDVVWUDQVIHUFRHI 3UREOHPVROXWLRQV
 /LPLWDWLRQV)LFNLDQ'LIIXVLRQ 0XUSKUHH(IILFLHQFLHV
 6WDUW0D[ZHOO6WHIDQ$QDO\VLV 6HFWLRQV 
 0D[ZHOO6WHIDQ$QDO\VLV 6HFWLRQ
 0D[ZHOO6WHIDQ$QDO\VLV 6HFWLRQ
 0D[ZHOO6WHIDQ$QDO\VLV±3UREOHPVROXWLRQV 6HFWLRQ
 0D[ZHOO6WHIDQ$QDO\VLV 6HFWLRQ
 0D[ZHOO6WHIDQ$QDO\VLV 6HFWLRQ
 0D[ZHOO6WHIDQ$QDO\VLV±3UREOHPVROXWLRQV 6HFWLRQ
 5DWH%DVHG$QDO\VLVRI'LVWLOODWLRQ 6HFWLRQ
 5HYLHZRI7UD\'HVLJQ &KDSW /DE
 $VSHQ3OXV5DWH%DVHG$VVLJQPHQW /DE$SS&
 5HYLHZIRU([DP
 ([DP
 *RRYHUH[DP6WDUW0HPEUDQH6HSDUDWLRQV 6HFWLRQV 
 *DV3HUPHDWLRQ 6HFWLRQ
 *DV3HUPHDWLRQ 6HFWLRQ
 )ORZSDWWHUQVLQJDVSHUPHDWLRQ 6HFWLRQ
 6SUHDGVKHHWVROXWLRQVJDVSHUPHDWLRQ &KDSWHU$SSHQGL[
 5HYHUVH2VPRVLV52 6HFWLRQ
 52±&RQFHQWUDWLRQSRODUL]DWLRQ 6HFWLRQ
 52±&RQFSRODUL]DWLRQZLWK0D[ZHOO6WHIDQ 6HFWRQV 
 6SUHDGVKHHWVROXWLRQ52 6HFWLRQV$SS
 8OWUDILOWUDWLRQ8) 6HFWLRQ
 %DWFK8) 6HFWLRQ
 3HUYDSRUDWLRQSHUYDS 6HFWLRQ
 0RGHOLQJSHUYDS
 5HYLHZIRU([DP
 ([DP
 5HYLHZH[DP6WDUW$GVRUSWLRQ 6HFWLRQ
 /LQHDU6ROXWH0RYHPHQW$QDO\VLV 6HFWLRQ
 /LQHDU6ROXWH0RYHPHQW$QDO\VLV 6HFWLRQV 
 /LQHDU6ROXWH0RYHPHQW$QDO\VLV 6HFWLRQV
 1RQOLQHDU6ROXWH0RYHPHQW$QDO\VLV 6HFWLRQ
 1RQOLQHDU6ROXWH0RYHPHQW$QDO\VLV 6HFWLRQ
 1RQOLQHDU6ROXWH0RYHPHQW$QDO\VLV 6HFWLRQ
 ,RQ([FKDQJH 6HFWLRQ
 ,RQ([FKDQJH 6HFWLRQ
 0DVV (QHUJ\7UDQVIHULQ6RUSWLRQ6\VWHPV 6HFWLRQ
 /LQHDU6\VWHPV±/DSLGXV $PXQGVRQ6ROQ 6HFWLRQ
 /LQHDU&KURPDWRJUDSK\ 6HFWLRQ
 /8%$QDO\VLV 6HFWLRQ
 ,QWURGXFWLRQWR$QDO\VLV1RQOLQHDU,QWHUDFWLQJ6\VWHPV
 5HYLHZIRU([DP
),1$/6 ([DP



 SPE 3rd Edition Solution M anual Chapter 1

1HZ3UREOHPVDQGQHZVROXWLRQVDUHOLVWHGDVQHZLPPHGLDWHO\DIWHUWKHVROXWLRQQXPEHU7KHVHQHZ
SUREOHPVLQFKDSWHUDUH$$%%'

$ $QVZHUVDUHLQWKHWH[W

$ 1HZSUREOHPIRUUGHGLWLRQ$QVZHULVG

% (YHU\WKLQJH[FHSWVRPHIRRGSURGXFWVKDVXQGHUJRQHVRPHVHSDUDWLRQRSHUDWLRQV(YHQWKH
ZDWHULQERWWOHVKDVEHHQSXULILHGHLWKHUE\UHYHUVHRVPRVLVRUE\GLVWLOODWLRQ

% 1HZSUREOHPIRUUGHGLWLRQ0DQ\KRPHVKDYHDZDWHUVRIWHQHULRQH[FKDQJHRUDILOWHURUD
FDUERQZDWHU³ILOWHU´DFWXDOO\DGVRUSWLRQRUDUHYHUVHRVPRVLVV\VWHP

% 1HZSUREOHPIRUUGHGLWLRQ)RUH[DPSOHWKHOXQJVDUHDJDVSHUPHDWLRQV\VWHPWKHLQWHVWLQHV
DQGNLGQH\DUHOLTXLGSHUPHDWLRQRUGLDO\VLVV\VWHPV

% 1HZSUREOHPIRUUGHGLWLRQ<RXSUREDEO\XVHGVRPHRIWKHIROORZLQJFKURPDWRJUDSK\
FU\VWDOOL]DWLRQGLVWLOODWLRQH[WUDFWLRQILOWUDWLRQDQGXOWUDILOWUDWLRQ

' 1HZSUREOHPIRUUGHGLWLRQ%DVLVNPROIHHG
  NPROH(   0:   NJ 
NJ
   NPRO:DWHU   0:  
WRWDO NJ
 :HLJKWIUDFWLRQHWKDQRO  

 )ORZUDWH NPROKU>NJNPRO@ NJKU



 63(UG(GLWLRQ6ROXWLRQ0DQXDO&KDSWHU

1HZ3UREOHPVDQGQHZVROXWLRQVDUHOLVWHGDVQHZLPPHGLDWHO\DIWHUWKHVROXWLRQQXPEHU7KHVHQHZ
SUREOHPVDUH$$WR$&&&'J''''WR'()
*WR*+WR+

$ )HHGWRIODVKGUXPLVDOLTXLGDWKLJKSUHVVXUH$WWKLVSUHVVXUHLWVHQWKDOS\FDQEHFDOFXODWHG
DVDOLTXLGHJ K 7)3KLJK F S /,4 7) 7UHI :KHQSUHVVXUHLVGURSSHGWKHPL[WXUHLVDERYH
LWVEXEEOHSRLQWDQG LVDWZRSKDVH PL[WXUH ,W³IODVKHV´,QWKHIODVK PL[WXUH HQWKDOS\LV
XQFKDQJHG EXW WHPSHUDWXUH FKDQJHV  )HHG ORFDWLRQ FDQQRW EH IRXQG IURP 7 ) DQG ] RQ WKH
JUDSKEHFDXVHHTXLOLEULXPGDWDLVDWDORZHUSUHVVXUHRQWKHJUDSKXVHGIRUWKLVFDOFXODWLRQ

$ <HV

$

!"#$

6782)29028:$
5' $ @'$A$#"BC%$
;.80/$'*1/0<$
()*+,$
"%$ -./0*1234$
)23/$

=">?$
#$
#$ "%$ &' $ !"#$

 


$ 1HZ3UREOHP,QDIODVKGUXPVHSDUDWLQJDPXOWLFRPSRQHQWPL[WXUHUDLVLQJWKHSUHVVXUHZLOO
L'HFUHDVHWKHGUXPGLDPHWHUDQGGHFUHDVHWKHUHODWLYHYRODWLOLWLHV  $QVZHULVL

$  D.LQFUHDVHVDV7LQFUHDVHV
  E.GHFUHDVHVDV3LQFUHDVHV
  F.VWD\VVDPHDVPROHIUDFWLRQFKDQJHV7SFRQVWDQW
  $VVXPSWLRQLVQRFRQFHQWUDWLRQHIIHFWLQ'H3ULHVWHUFKDUWV
 G.GHFUHDVHVDVPROHFXODUZHLJKWLQFUHDVHV


$  1HZ3UREOHP7KHDQVZHULV

$  1HZ3UREOHP7KHDQVZHULVE

$ 1HZ3UREOHP7KHDQVZHULVF




$ 1HZ3UREOHP7KHDQVZHULVE

$  1HZ3UREOHP7KHDQVZHULVF

$  1HZ3UREOHP7KHDQVZHULVD

$ 1HZ3UREOHPD 7KHDQVZHULVWR 
  E 7KHDQVZHULV ž& 

$1HZ3UREOHP7KHOLTXLGLVVXSHUKHDWHGZKHQWKHSUHVVXUHGURSVDQGWKHHQHUJ\FRPHVIURPWKH
DPRXQWRIVXSHUKHDW


% 0XVW EH VXUH \RX GRQ¶W YLRODWH *LEEV SKDVH UXOH IRU LQWHQVLYH YDULDEOHV LQ HTXLOLEULXP
([DPSOHV
 ) ] 7GUXP  3GUXP  ) 7)  ] S  ) K )  ] S 
 ) ] \ 3GUXP  ) 7)  ] \  ) K )  ] \ 
 ) ] [ S GUXP  ) 7)  ] [  HWF
 ) ] \ S GUXP  ) 7)  ] 7GUXP  S GUXP 
 ) ] [ 7GUXP  ) 7)  \ S 
 'UXPGLPHQVLRQV ] )GUXP  S GUXP   ) 7)  \ 7GUXP 
 'UXPGLPHQVLRQV ] \ S GUXP  ) 7)  [ S 
 HWF ) 7)  [ 7GUXP     
  ) 7)  \ [   


% 7KLVLVHVVHQWLDOO\WKHVDPHSUREOHPGLVJXLVHGDVSUREOHP'FDQGHEXWZLWKDQH[LVWLQJ
ODUJHUGUXPDQGDKLJKHUIORZUDWH
  :LWK\ [ DQG9) ZKLFKFRUUHVSRQGVWR'F
OEPROH
  ,I )  ' DQG/ IWIURP3UREOHP'H 
KU
 6LQFH'Į 9 DQGIRUFRQVWDQW9)9Į)ZHKDYH'Į ) 
 :LWK) 
   )QHZ )ROG 'QHZ  'ROG  DQG/QHZ 'QHZ   
 ([LVWLQJGUXPLVWRRVPDOO
 

)H[LVWLQJ ' H[LVW 
 )HHG UDWH GUXP FDQ KDQGOH  ) Į '    JLYHV
  
)H[LVWLQJ OEPROK 
 $OWHUQDWLYHV
D'RGUXPVLQSDUDOOHO$GGDVHFRQGGUXPZKLFKFDQKDQGOHUHPDLQLQJOEPROK
E %\SDVVZLWKOLTXLGPL[LQJ




 5$A$"%GH$

D$A$"=%$;!CCC#<$A$?!%#$$$$$$
!CHCC#$
=%H###$

EF-1*)$
GI?#$ &$

6LQFH[LVQRWVSHFLILHGXVHE\SDVV7KLVSURGXFHVOHVVYDSRU
 F /RRNDW(TZKLFKEHFRPHV
9 0:Y
  ' 
. GUXP  / Y Y

 %\SDVVUHGXFHV9

F .GUXPLVDOUHDG\3HUKDSVVPDOOLPSURYHPHQWVFDQEHPDGHZLWKDEHWWHUGHPLVWHU
ĺ7DONWRWKHPDQXIDFWXUHUV
F ȡYFDQEHLQFUHDVHGE\LQFUHDVLQJSUHVVXUH7KXVRSHUDWHDWKLJKHUSUHVVXUH1RWHWKLV
ZLOO FKDQJH WKH HTXLOLEULXP GDWD DQG UDLVH WHPSHUDWXUH  7KXV D FRPSOHWH QHZ
FDOFXODWLRQQHHGVWREHGRQH
G 7U\E\SDVVZLWKYDSRUPL[LQJ
H 2WKHUDOWHUQDWLYHVDUHSRVVLEOH

9 ]$ ]%
& 
) .%  .$ 

)] L
& D6WDUWZLWK [L DQGOHW9 ) /
/ 9. L
)] L ]L
    [L RU[ L 
/ ) / .L / /
 .L
) )
. L ]L
  7KHQ \ L .L[L 
/ /
 .L
) )

. L  ]L
  )URP \L [L ZHREWDLQ 
/ /
 .L
) )



 ]L 9
&  I )URPGDWDLQ([DPSOHREWDLQ
9 )
 .L 
)
9)           
I      



&1HZ3UREOHP

S GUXP $
($A$E$J$D$

)] /[ 9\ $
7GUXP $
&$ 5$
K-)L/$M-0$E$N$D$

O0$8+/$)/L/0$*0:P08)/$

@$



& 1HZ3UREOHP'HULYDWLRQRI(TVDQG2YHUDOODQGFRPSRQHQWPDVVEDODQFHVDUH

 ) 9 / /  
 )]L /[ L/ / [ L/ 9\L 

 6XEVWLWXWLQJLQHTXLOLEULXP(TVEDQGF

      
      )] L /. L/ / [ L/ /  [ L/ 9. L9 / [ L/ 
  6ROYLQJ
)] L )] L
      [ L/  
/. L/  /  9. L9 /  /. L/ /  ) 9 / 9. L9 /

  'LYLGLQJQXPHUDWRUDQGGHQRPLQDWRUE\)DQGFROOHFWLQJWHUPV

]L
      [ LOLT   
/ 9
 . L/ /   . L9 / 
) )

. L9 /  ]L
  6LQFH \L . L9 / [ L/  \ L 
/ 9
 . L/ /   . L9 / 
) )
 
& & & &
  6WRLFKLRPHWULFHTXDWLRQV [ L/   \L WKXV \L [ L/   
L  L  L  L 

& . L9 /  ]L
   ZKLFKEHFRPHV   
L  / 9
 . L/ /   . L9 / 
) )

. L/ /  ] L
   6LQFH [ LOLT . L/ / [ LOLT  ZHKDYH[ LOLT 
/ 9
 . L/ /    . L9 / 
) )
& . L/ /   ] L
   ,QDGGLWLRQ [ LOLT [ LOLT    
L  / 9
 . L/ /   . L9 / 
) )
' D 9   DQG/ ) 9 NPROK 
  6ORSHRSOLQH / 9   \ [ ]  
  6HHJUDSK \ DQG[  
 E 9   DQG/  5HVWVDPHDVSDUWD
 F 3ORW [  RQHTXLO'LDJUDPDQG \ [ ] \LQW HUFHSW ]) 9  
  9 ) ]   )URPHTXLO \  
 G 3ORW [  RQHTXLOLEULXPFXUYH



 / ) 9  9 ) 
    6ORSH 
9 9 9 ) 
  3ORWRSHUDWLQJOLQH \ [ ]DW]  )URPPDVVEDODQFH )  NPROK
 H )LQG/LTXLG'HQVLW\
   0: / [ P 0:P [ Z 0:Z      
0:P 0:Z  
  7KHQ 9/ [P [Z   POPRO 
P Z  
     / 0: / 9/   JPO 
3 0:
Y
 )LQG9DSRU'HQVLW\ Y 1HHGWHPSHUDWXUHRIWKHGUXP
57
 0: Y \ P 0: P \ Z 0: Z      JPRO
 )LQG7HPSHUDWXUHRIWKH'UXP7
   )URP7DEOHILQG7FRUUHVSRQGLQJWR 
 \  [  7  & .
PODWP
Y DWP JPRO  .    JPO 
PRO .



  )LQG3HUPLVVLEOHYHORFLW\



 X SHUP . GUXP / Y Y
    
 
. GUXP H[S $ % Q)OY & Q)OY ' Q)OY ( Q)OY
9
   6LQFH 9 )   OEPROK 
)
OE
   :Y 9 0: Y   OE  K 
OEPRO

/ ) 9   OEPROKDQG:/ / 0: /    OEK 

:/ 9   
 )OY  DQG Q )OY   
:9 /  

  
 7KHQ . GUXP  DQGX SHUP  
IWV 
 
9 0: Y   JOE
 $ FV  
IW   
X SHUP  Y     JPO POIW
  7KXV ' $ FV  IW8VHIWGLDPHWHU
  /UDQJHVIURP  ' IWWR ' IW  
  1RWHWKDWWKLVGHVLJQLVFRQVHUYDWLYHLIDGHPLVWHULVXVHG
 I 3ORW 7 YV [ IURP 7DEOH   :KHQ 7  & [  \    7KLV SUREOHP LV QRZ
YHU\ VLPLODU WR 'F  &DQ FDOFXODWH 9) IURP PDVV EDODQFH )] /[ 9\   7KLV LV
9 ] \  
)] ) 9 [ 9\RU  
) \ [  
 J3DUWJLVDQHZSUREOHP9 PROK/ \ [ 

' :RUNEDFNZDUGV6WDUWLQJZLWK[ ILQG\ IURPHTXLOLEULXP)URPHTXLOLEULXPSRLQW
9
SORW RS OLQH RI VORSH  / 9   9 )      7KLV JLYHV
) 
]  [ VHH)LJXUH7KHQIURPHTXLOLEULXP \  
9 ] [  
 )RUVWDJH  
) \ [  

' D ]  9 ) 9   N PRO K /
/
\ [ ] 9 )
9
  2SHT 

\ [  

 6HHJUDSK \ [ 0 7 a  & OLQHDULQWHUSUHWDWLRQRQ7DEOH 




 E 3URGXFW  &[  \  
   0DVV%DO )] /[ 9\ ) 9 [ 9\ 
    RU   9  9 
     9 DQG 9 )   
  &DQDOVRFDOFXODWH9)IURPVORSH




9
 F )    9  / 
)
/ ]  ]
  \ [ [  
9 9 ) ] 
  ,I \  [  # HTXLO 

   7KHQ ]  
  


  &DQDOVRGUDZOLQHRIVORSH WKURXJKHTXLOSRLQW





 
UG
'1HZSUREOHPLQ HGLWLRQ+LJKHVWWHPSHUDWXUHLVGHZSRLQW 9 )  
  6HW ]L \L . L \L [ L 
  :DQW [L \L . L  
   . UHI 71HZ . UHI 72OG  \L . L 
,ISLFN&DVUHIHUHQFH )LUVWJXHVV . EX WDQ H  7  &  . &  . &  
\L   
   7WRRORZ
. L   
 *XHVVIRUUHIHUHQFH
  . & 7  &  . &  . &  
\L   
  
.L   
  . &1(:    7   . &  . &  
\L   
   
.L   
  . &1(:    7  &   . &  . &  
\L   
   *LYHV & 
.L   



 8VHžĺ$YJODVWWZR7 . &  . &  . &  
  
  \L . L  
  
 7 a  ž & 
 1RWHKH[DQHSUREDEO\EHWWHUFKRLFHDVUHIHUHQFH 
' D  

L!$A$(=$
L=$
5!$A$@=$
@!$A$#"%%$ 5= $
.!H=$A$!$*1:$
!$ =$
(!$A$!###$ 9
 $
) 
$
&= $
&!$A$#"I#$
$ 
$

/ )
 E \ [ ] 3ORWVW2SOLQH 5!$A$#"CC$A$@=$ 
9 9
    \ [ ] 
    WR[ RQHTFXUYHVHHJUDSK
/   
  6ORSH  
9   
/
   / 9 )  
9

 9 
D!$A$CGQ"%$R:-)S,$A$(=$  $
 )  
  
9 / )
 F 6WDJH  \ [ ]  3ORWRSOLQH
) 9 )
 ) ] 
  $W [  \ ] 9 ) $W\  [  ]  
 / / ) 
  )URPJUDSK \  [   
9
  9 )    NPROK  
) 




'  D$

  ($A$!"#$R:-)S:23$ WX?$A$="?$
 F$A$%#TU$ WX%$A$#"G#$
 @X?$A$#"?%$ V$A$=##$RV*$ WXC$A$#"I#$
 @X%$A$#"I%$

 YXC$A$#"=#$ E$
. L  ]L
 55HT  )LUVWJXHVV9) 
 .L  9 )
     
  I  
        
 8VH1HZWRQLDQ&RQYHUJHQFH

GI N F
. L  ]L
  

G 9 ) L   .L  9 )
9 9 IN
  
) N  )N GI
G 9 )
  



  
GI       
    
 
9         
G
)
9 
    
) 
     
  I  
        
 :KLFKLVFORVHHQRXJK
]L  \L . L [ L
 [ F   
9    \F   
 .L 
)

  [ F  \ F    
  
  
  [ F  \   
   [L  \L 

9 ]$ ]%
'  
) .%  .$ 
  .0 DQG. 3  
9  
   
)    
]0 
 (T [ 0  
9   
 .0 
)
  [3  [0   \ 0 . 0 [ 0   
  \3  \0  
9 . L  ]L
' 8VH5DFKIRUG5LFHHTQ I  1RWHWKDWDWP N3D
)  .L  9  )
)LQG . L IURP'H3ULHVWHU&KDUW .  .  .   
 &RQYHUJHRQ 9 )  9 ) 9 ) NPROK/ ) 9 NPROK 
]L
 )URP [ L ZHREWDLQ [  [   [   
9
 .L 
)
 )URP \L . L [ L  ZHREWDLQ\  \   \  
' 1HHGK)WRSORWRQGLDJUDP6LQFHSUHVVXUHLVKLJKIHHGUHPDLQVDOLTXLG
  K ) &3/ 7) 7UHI  7UHI  IURPFKDUW
  &3/ &3(W2+ [ (W2+ &3Z [ Z 



 :KHUH [ (W2+ DQG[ Z DUHPROHIUDFWLRQV&RQYHUWZHLJKWWRPROHIUDFWLRQV
 %DVLV NJPL[WXUH

  NJ(W2+ NPRO 

  NJZDWHU    
  7RWDO NPRO
 
 $YJ 0:  0ROHIUDFV [ (  [ Z  
 
 8VH &3/ DW &DVDQDYHUDJH&3  YDOXH
(W2+

NFDO
  & 3/      
NPRO &
& 3/  NFDO
   3HUNJWKLVLV  
0:DYJ  NJ &
  K )   NFDONJ 
 ZKLFKFDQQRZEHSORWWHGRQWKHHQWKDOS\FRPSRVLWLRQGLDJUDP
 2EWDLQ 7GUXP  & [ (  DQG\ (  
 )RU )  ILQG/DQG9IURP) /9DQG )] /[ 9\ 
 ZKLFKJLYHV9 DQG/ 


  1RWH,IXVHZWIUDFV &3/   &3/ 0:DYJ  DQGK )  $OOZURQJ



'1HZ3UREOHP6ROXWLRQN3Dž& ] &  0ROHQEXWDQH [ &  
 )URP'H3ULHVWHUFKDUW . &  . &  . &  
]L
 .QRZ \ L . L [ L  [ L   [L \L  ]L 
9
 .L 
)
. L  ]L
 55  ] &  ] & ] &   ] & 
9
 .L 
)
]& ]& 9
 )RU&  ] &     
9 9 )
 . &   
) )
9
   ] &    
)
  ] &    ] & 
 55(T  
9 9 9
     
) ) )
 HTXDWLRQV XQNQRZQV6XEVWLWXWHLQIRU ] & 'RLQ6SUHDGVKHHW
 8VH*RDO±6HHNWRILQG 9 ) 
9
  ZKHQ55HTXDWLRQ  
)
9
 ] &      
)
'    / )  9 )   / 9  
  2SHUDWLQJOLQH 6ORSH  WKURXJK\ [ ]  





'  )RUSUREOHP'FSORW[ RQHTXLOLEULXPGLDJUDPZLWKIHHGFRPSRVLWLRQRI7KH
UHVXOWLQJRSHUDWLQJOLQHKDVD\LQWHUFHSW ] 9  )  7KXV 9 )  VHHILJXUHLQ
6ROXWLRQWR'9DSRUPROHIUDFWLRQLV\ 
  )LQG/LTXLG'HQVLW\
   0: / [ P 0:P [ Z 0:Z      
0:P 0:Z  
   7KHQ 9/ [P [Z   POPRO 
P Z  
     / 0: / 9/   JPO 
S 0:
Y
  )LQG9DSRU'HQVLW\ Y 1HHGWHPSHUDWXUHRIWKHGUXP
57
   0: Y \ P 0: P \ Z 0: Z      JPRO
  )LQG7HPSHUDWXUHRIWKH'UXP7
   )URP7DEOHILQG7FRUUHVSRQGLQJWR \  [  7  & . 



 PODWP
   Y DWP JPRO  .   JPO 
PRO .
  )LQG3HUPLVVLEOHYHORFLW\ 

X SHUP . GUXP / Y Y

  

. GUXPKRUL]RQWDO  . GUXPYHUWLFDO H[S $ % Q)OY & Q)OY ' Q)OY ( Q)OY 

  6LQFH 9 9 )   OEPROK 

  :Y 9 0: Y   OE OEPRO OE  K 

/ ) 9   OEPROKDQG:/ / 0: /    OEK 


:/ 9   
   )OY  DQG Q )OY  
:9 /  
. GUXP YHUWLFDO  DQG. GUXP KRUL] 
       
X SHUP  
IWV
 
9 0: Y   JOEP
   $ FV 
X SHUP  Y      JPO POIW 
   $ &V IW   $ 7 $ &V  IW  
  
  :LWK/'  ' $ 7 IWDQG/ IW 

'1HZ3UREOHP 7KHDQVZHULV\FUHVRO 
[S  
   6LQFH [ F  [ S  \ S  
  [S   
     \F  \S  
FS [F 
    2U \ F  FS  
 FS  [F SF

93& 
'  5DRXOW¶V/DZ . &  
37RW
ORJ  93&  93&  PP+J
   
ORJ  93&  93&  PP+J
]L
   [L   
 .L  9 )



  
   
 
     
3 3
  6ROYHIRU3GUXP PP+J
]L
   [L 
9
 .L 
)
 
  [ &  \ &  . &  [ &    
 
  


   [ &  [ &   \ &   

     &KHFN  

'  7KLVLVDQXQXVXDOZD\RIVWDWLQJSUREOHP+RZHYHULIZHFRXQWVSHFLILHGYDULDEOHVZHVHH
WKDWSUREOHP LVQRW RYHURUXQGHUVSHFLILHG8VXDOO\9)ZRXOGEHWKH YDULDEOHEXWKHUHLW
LVQ¶W:HFDQVWLOOZULWH55HTQ:LOOKDYHWKUHHYDULDEOHV]&]L&]Q&1HHGWZRRWKHU
HTQV ] L& ] Q& FRQVWDQWDQG] & ] L& ] Q&  
  7KXVVROYHWKUHHHTXDWLRQVDQGWKUHHXQNQRZQVVLPXOWDQHRXVO\

  'R,W5DFKIRUG5LFHHTXDWLRQLV
. &  ]& . L&   ] L&  . Q&   ] Q& 
   
9 9 9
 . &   . L&    . Q&  
) ) )
  &DQVROYHIRU]& ±]L&DQG]L& ]Q&7KXV]& ±]Q&
  6XEVWLWXWHIRU]L&DQG]&LQWR55HTQ
. &   . L&   . Q&  
   ] Q& ] Q&  ] Q&  
9 9 9
 . &   . L&    . Q&  
) ) )
. & 
9
 . & 
 7KXV  ] Q&  ) 
. &   . L&   . Q&  

9 9 9
 . &   . L&    . Q&  
) ) )
 &DQQRZILQG.YDOXHVDQGSOXJDZD\.& .L& .Q& 
 6ROXWLRQLV]Q& ]L&  DQG]& 

'  ] &  ] &  ] &  ] &  . &  . &  . &  . &  
  VWJXHVV&DQDVVXPHDOO&LQYDSRUa&LQYDSRU& &LQERWWRP
    9  )       7KLVILUVWJXHVVLVQRWFULWLFDO



 9 . L  ]L
  55HT I 
)  .L  9 )
       
     
           
9 9 I 9 ) 
  (T 

)  )  ]L . L 

9
 .L 
)
  ZKHUH  9) 
DQGI 9  ) 
 
  FDOFXODWH  9) 
    
    9   NPROKDQG/    
] & 
    [ &  
 . &  9  )   
   \ & . & [ &    
  6LPLODUIRURWKHUFRPSRQHQWV

'  D 9 )  /   6ORSH / )  
   ,QWHUFHSWV\ [ ] 3ORWOLQHDQGILQG[$ \$ VHHJUDSK
E 9 / 5HVWLGHQWLFDOWRSDUWD
  F /RZHVW[$LVKRUL]RQWDORSOLQH/ [$ 
   +LJKHVW\$LVYHUWLFDORSOLQH9 \$ 6HHJUDSK





G 9 / /9 
  )LQG[$ RQHTXLOLEULXPFXUYH3ORWRSOLQH ILQGLQWHUVHFWLRQSRLQWZLWK
   \ [OLQH]$ 
]K

]L 9 [K
'  )URP [ L ZHREWDLQ 
9 ) . 
 .L  K
)
  *XHVV 7GUXP FDOFXODWH . K  . E DQG. S  DQGWKHQGHWHUPLQH 9 ) 
.  ] L
    &KHFN  "
 .  9 )
 ,QLWLDOJXHVV,I [ K  WKHQ 7GUXP PXVWEHOHVVWKDQWHPSHUDWXUHWRERLOSXUHKH[DQH
 .K  7  &  2Q WKLV EDVLV ƒ WR ƒ ZRXOG EH UHDVRQDEOH 7U\ ƒ&
. K . E  . S  


9  
    1RWSRVVLEOH0XVWKDYH . K  
)   
 7U\ 7  & ZKHUH . K  7KHQ . E  . S  


9 
    
)  
 &KHFN 
. L  ]L      
  
 .L  9 )         
 &RQYHUJHRQ 7 a  &DQG 9 ) a  

' UHFRYHU\QKH[DQHPHDQV  )] & / [ & 
 6XEVWLWXWHLQ / ) 9 WRREWDLQ ] &   9 ) [ & 
  &  EDODQFH ] & ) /[ & 9\ & ) 9 [ & . & 9[ & 
   RU ] &  9 ) [ & [ & . & 9 ) 
 7ZRHTXDWLRQVDQGWZRXQNQRZQV5HPRYH [ & DQGVROYH
 ] & .9 )
    ] & &  
 9 )
9 
 6ROYHIRU 9 ) 7ULDODQGHUURUVFKHPH
) . & 
  3LFN7&DOF . &  &DOF 9 ) DQG&KHFNI 9 )  "
. UHI 7ROG
  ,IQRW . UHI QHZ 
 GI 7



  7U\ 7  &. &  . &  . &  . UHI 
9 
    
)   
  5DFKIRUG5LFHHTXDWLRQ
     
   I  
        

    . UHI 7QHZ  XVH 
 
  &RQYHUJHRQ 71HZ  
a  &7KHQ. &  . &  DQG 9 )
  
'1HZ3UREOHP7KH.YDOXHVDUH . (   . %   . 3  
   &DQXVH(TRU,IZHXVHWKH5±5HTQ
     
9 . L  ]L
     I  8VH] )  ] % ] (  ] % 
) 9
 .L 
)
   ] %   ] %
   7KHQ 55 HT  
       
       ] %  ] % 
      ] %  ] %  

' D  . & . &  
9 ]$ ]%
  6ROQWR%LQDU\55HT 
) .%  .$ 
9  
    
)    
]& 
   [ &  \ &   
9   
 . & 
)
   [ & \ &  
 1HHGWRFRQYHUW)WRNPRO
   $YJ0:      
NJ NPRO
   )   NPROK 
KU NJ
   9 9 ) )  / ) 9 NPROK 

/ Y
 E  X 3HUP . GUXP 
Y

  7RILQG 0: /      



    0: 9       
  )RUOLTXLGDVVXPHLGHDOPL[WXUH
0: & 0: &
    9 [ & 9&OLT [ & 9&OLT [ & [ & 
&OLT &OLT

 
    9/   POPRO 
 
0: / 
   / JPO  
9/ 
0: Y
  )RUYDSRULGHDOJDV Y

57
DWP J
N3D 
N3D PRO
   Y J  PO 
PODWP
 .
PRO.
:/ Y
   . GUXP 8VH(TZLWK )O9 
:9 /

NPRO NJ
   :9   NJK 
K NPRO
   :9   NJK 
 
   )O9  
 
 

. GUXP H[S   Q   Q 
 
 
  Q   Q  

 
X 3HUP  IWV

   
IW P
  PV
V IW

NPRO NJ
 
9 0:9 K NPRO
$&  
P 
X 3HUP  Y P V J NJ  FP
  
V K FP  J P

   ' $ & P 
 $UELWUDULO\
   / '  / P 



 9 . L  ]L . L3  ] L3 . 13  ] 13
'   I 
)  .L  9 ) 9 9
 . L3   . 13 
) )
  6ROYHIRU9)
9 9
    . 13  . L3  ] L3  . L3  . 13  ] 13 
) )
9 . L3  ] L3 . 13  ] 13
  ZKHUH ] L3 ] 13  
) . 13  . L3 
   S GUXP S WRW PP+J7  & 

   ORJ 93 13
  
 
   9313 PP+J  . 13  S WRW  

   ORJ 93L3   
 
   93L3 PP+J  . L3    
  1RWH 0:L3 0:13  ] L3  LQERWKZW PROIUDFDVGRHV ] 13 
9    
     
)  
] L3
    [ L3  
9
 . L3 
)
    [ 13  [ L3  \LS . L3 [ L3 \ 13  

'   ƒ&N3D
   )LJ . 0  . HWK\OHQH  . (WKDQH  . &  
9
   )LUVWWU\  HTXDOVSOLWHWK\OHQHDQGHWKDQH
) 

9        

 I  
)            
9
I
9 9 ) 
 (T  
 
)  )  ]L . L 

9
 .L 
)
]L
 7KHQ(T [L [ 0  [ HWK\OHQH  
 .L  9 )
     [ HWKDQH  [ &    2.
 )LQG   \L .L [L 




'1HZ3UREOHPS N3D
  $WDQ\7 . & \ & [ & 
  .¶VDUHNQRZQ . & \ & [ &  \&  [ & 

 6XEVWLWXWHVWHTXDWLRQLQWRQG . &  . & [ &  [ & 
  6ROYHIRU[&  [ & . &  . & [ & 
   [ & . & . &  . & 
 . & . &  . &
   [ &  \ & 
. & . & . & . &
 $WN3DSXUHSURSDQH . &  ERLOVDWƒ& )LJ
 $WN3DSXUHQKH[DQH . &  ERLOVDWƒ&

 . &   . &
 &KHFN DWƒ& [ &   \ &  
 . &  . &
 . & 
   DWƒ& [ &   \ & 
. & . &

 3LFNLQWHUPHGLDWHWHPSHUDWXUHVILQG . &   . & FDOFXODWH [ &   \ & 



7 . & . & [ & \& . & [ &
 
 
ž&     
ž&     6HH
ž&     *UDSK
ž&    
ž&    
ž&    
ž&    
 ž&     




 



 
 



E [ &   9 )   / 9   
 2SHUDWLQJOLQHLQWHUVHFWV \ [  6ORSH  
/ )
  \ [ ]
9 9
) 
 DW [  \ ] 
9   
 )LQG\F DQG[& 
 &KHFNZLWKRSHUDWLQJOLQH      2.ZLWKLQDFFXUDF\RIWKHJUDSK
F 'UXP7 . & \ & [ &    'H3ULHVWHU&KDUW 7 ž&
/ \    I
G \  [ a   6ORSH    
9 [   I
9 
    I  
) 

' 1HZ3UREOHP0HWKDQHDQGQEXWDQH
9
     7GUXP  ž&  )LQG S GUXP 
)
9 . $  ]$ . %  ]%
      I 
) 9 9
 .$   .% 
) )
    
   3LFN S GUXP N3D. & . Q&  
    $Q\SUHVVXUHZLWK . & DQG. &  LV2.
   
   7ULDO  I   1HHGORZHU S GUXP 
     
. &  3ROG 
. &  3QHZ 
 G I 3ROG  
      

     3QHZ . &  
   
      I    
     

      . &  3QHZ  
 
      3QHZ . &  
   
     I  2.'UXPSUHVVXUH N3D
     



 ]L 
  E    [L  [ &  
9   
 .L 
)
      \& . &[ &    

' 1HZ3UREOHPD &DQVROYHIRU/DQG9IURP0%  ) 9/
        )] 9 / 
      )LQG / DQG9 
\ & 
  E 6WDJHLVHTXLO  . &  
[ & 

     . &  

   7KHVH.YDOXHVDUHDWVDPH73)LQGWKHVH.YDOXHVRQ'H3ULHVWHUFKDUW
   'UDZVWUDLJKWOLQHEHWZHHQWKHP([WHQGWR 7GUXP  S GUXP )LQGž&N3D

' 1HZ3UREOHPD 93&  ORJ 93   
 
93 PP+J 
  E    93   PP+J 
  ORJ 93    7  
   6ROYHIRU 7 ž& 
  F   3WRW PP+J >DWERLOLQJIRUSXUHFRPSRQHQW 3WRW 93 @

  G   & ORJ 93   
 
      93 PP+J 
      . & 93& 3WRW    
   

     & ORJ 93&   
 
      93& PP+J 
      . &    
  H   .$ \ $ [ $ . % \% [ %  \ $    [ $  
    ,I . $ . % DUHNQRZQWZRHTQVZLWKXQNQRZQV . $ \ $ 6ROYH
 . &  
     [ &  
. & . &  
     \ & . & [ &    
  I 2YHUDOO0%) /9RU /9
     &  )[ ) /[ 9\ /9   
   6ROYHIRU/ 9/  9 PRO
  J 6DPHDVSDUWIH[FHSWXQLWVDUHPROPLQ





'1HZ3UREOHP D$
 
 ,$


Z$




($


 E$
 )URPH[DPSOH [ +  7GUXP .  9 )  \ +  ] +  
9 0:Y
 :LWK K ' & ' 
X SHUP  Y &

 & 0:Y OEPOEPROH([DPSOH
 PO OEP
   Y    J PRO 

J OEP IW IW 
([DPSOH

/ Y
   X SHUP . GUXP  . KRUL] . YHUWLFDO 
9

 )URP([DPSOH . YHUWLFDO   . KRUL]   


 
   X SHUP   IW V >GHQVLWLHVIURP([DPSOH@

9 OEPRO
  9 )    OEPRO KU
) KU
OEPRO OEP
 
K OEPRO
  ' IW 
IW V OEP
   
V K IW
  K 'IW 

 8VH  RU  IWGUXP


'1HZ3UREOHP7KHVWUHDPWDEOHVLQ$VSHQ3OXVLQFOXGHDOLQHVWDWLQJWKHIUDFWLRQYDSRULQDJLYHQ
VWUHDP&KDQJHWKHIHHGSUHVVXUHXQWLOWKHIHHGVWUHDPLVDOOOLTXLGIUDFWLRQYDSRU )RUWKH3HQJ
5RELQVRQFRUUHODWLRQWKHDSSURSULDWHSUHVVXUHLVDWP
7KHIHHGPROHIUDFWLRQVDUHPHWKDQH SURSDQH QEXWDQH LEXWDQH 
DQGQSHQWDQH 
E$WDWPWKH$VSHQ3OXVUHVXOWVDUH/ NJK NPROK9 NJK 
NPROKDQG7GUXP R&



7KHYDSRUPROHIUDFWLRQVDUHPHWKDQH SURSDQH QEXWDQH LEXWDQH 
DQGQSHQWDQH 
7KHOLTXLGPROHIUDFWLRQVDUHPHWKDQH SURSDQH QEXWDQH LEXWDQH 
DQGQSHQWDQH 
F$VSHQ3OXVJLYHVWKHOLTXLGGHQVLW\ JFFOLTXLGDYJ0: YDSRUGHQVLW\ 
JFF NJPDQGYDSRUDYJ0: JPRO NJNPRO

6LQFHWKHIORZDUHDIRUYDSRU /'DQG/ 'WKHDUHDIRUIORZ ' 7KHQWKHHTXDWLRQIRUWKHGUXP
GLDPHWHULV

' ^>0:99@>ȡ9XSHUP/'@` ^>NJNPRONPROK@>NJPXSHUP
IWVPIWVK@

ZKHUHWKHXQLWFRQYHUVLRQVDUHXVHGWRJLYH'LQPHWHUV7KHYDOXHRIX SHUPLQIWVFDQEHGHWHUPLQHGE\
FRPELQLQJ(TVDQGIRUYHUWLFDOGUXPVZLWK(TD

)OY :/:9>ȡ9ȡ/@ >@ 

5HVXOWLQJ.YHUWLFDO .KRUL]RQWDO DQGXSHUP IWVDQG' PDQG/ 
P$SSURSULDWHVWDQGDUGVL]HZRXOGEHXVHG

'1HZ3UREOHPD)URPWKHHTXLOLEULXPGDWDLI\$ PROHIUDFWLRQZDWHUWKHQ[ $ PROH
IUDFWLRQZDWHU
&DQILQG/$DQG9$E\VROYLQJWKHWZRPDVVEDODQFHVIRUVWDJH$VLPXOWDQHRXVO\
/$9$ )$ DQG/$9$ 7KHUHVXOWVDUH9$ DQG/$ 

E,QFKDPEHU%VLQFHRIWKHYDSRULVFRQGHQVHG9)% 7KHRSHUDWLQJOLQHIRUWKLVIODVK
FKDPEHULV
\ /9[)%9]%ZKHUH]% \$ DQG/9)%)% 7KLVRSHUDWLQJOLQHJRHVWKURXJK
WKHSRLQW\ [ ]% ZLWKDVORSHRI7KLVLVVKRZQRQWKHJUDSK2EWDLQ[%  \% 
/% IUDFWLRQFRQGHQVHGIHHGWR%  NPROKDQG9% )%±/% 

F)URPWKHHTXLOLEULXPLI[% \% 7KHQVROYLQJWKHPDVVEDODQFHVLQWKHVDPHZD\DVIRU
SDUWDZLWK)% DQG]% /% DQG9% %HFDXVH[% ]$UHF\FOLQJ/%GRHVQRW
FKDQJH\% RU[$ EXWLWFKDQJHVWKHIORZUDWHV9%QHZDQG/$QHZ:LWKUHF\FOHWKHVHFDQEH
IRXQGIURPWKHRYHUDOOPDVVEDODQFHV) 9%QHZ/$QHZDQG)]$ 9%QHZ\%/$QHZ[$7KHQ9%QHZ 
DQG/$QHZ 




 *UDSKIRUSUREOHP'
$




(1HZ3UREOHP)URP$VSHQ3OXVUXQZLWKNPROKDWEDU/ 9 NPROK:/ 
NJK:9 NJKOLTXLGGHQVLW\ NJPOLTXLGDYJ0: YDSRUGHQVLW\ 
NJPDQGYDSRUDYJ0: 7GUXP R&DQG4 N:

7KHGLDPHWHURIWKHYHUWLFDOGUXPLQPHWHUVZLWKX SHUPLQIWVLV

' ^>0:99@>ʌȡ9XSHUPPIW@` 
^>@>XSHUP@`

)OY :/:9>ȡ9ȡ/@ >@ 

5HVXOWLQJ.YHUWLFDO DQGXSHUP IWVDQG' P$SSURSULDWHVWDQGDUGVL]HZRXOG
EHXVHG0ROHIUDFWLRQVLVRSURSDQROOLTXLG YDSRU 

E5DQZLWKIHHGDWEDUDQGSGUXPDWEDUZLWK9) 2EWDLQ:/ NJK:9 
GHQVLW\OLTXLG GHQVLW\YDSRU NJP

' ^>0:99@>ʌȡ9XSHUPPIW@` 
^>@>XSHUP@`

)OY :/:9>ȡ9ȡ/@ >@ 

5HVXOWLQJ.YHUWLFDO XSHUP IWVDQG' P7KXVWKHPHWKRGLVIHDVLEOH

F)LQGLQJDSUHVVXUHWRPDWFKWKHGLDPHWHURIWKHH[LVWLQJGUXPLVWULDODQGHUURU

,IZHGRDOLQHDULQWHUSRODWLRQEHWZHHQWKHWZRVLPXODWLRQVWRILQGDSUHVVXUHWKDWZLOOJLYHXV' P
LIOLQHDUZHILQGS 5XQQLQJWKLVVLPXODWLRQZHREWDLQ:/ NJK:9 
GHQVLW\OLTXLG GHQVLW\YDSRU NJP0:Y 

' ^>0:99@>ʌȡ9XSHUPPIW@` 
^>@>XSHUP@`

)OY :/:9>ȡ9ȡ/@ >@ 

5HVXOWLQJ.YHUWLFDO XSHUP IWVDQG' P

3ORWWLQJWKHFXUYHRI'YHUVXVSGUXPDQGVHWWLQJ' ZHLQWHUSRODWHSGUXP EDU

$WSGUXP EDUVLPXODWLRQJLYHV:/ NJK:9 GHQVLW\OLTXLG GHQVLW\
YDSRU NJP0:Y 

' ^>0:99@>ʌȡ9XSHUPPIW@` 
^>@>XSHUP@`

)OY :/:9>ȡ9ȡ/@ >@ 

5HVXOWLQJ.YHUWLFDO XSHUP IWVDQG' P

7KLVLVUHDVRQDEO\FORVHDQGZLOOZRUN2.7 GUXP R&4 N:



0ROHIUDFWLRQVLVRSURSDQROOLTXLG YDSRU 

,QWKLVFDVHWKHUHLVDQDGYDQWDJHRSHUDWLQJDWDVRPHZKDWHOHYDWHGSUHVVXUH



( 7KLVSUREOHPZDV'LQWKHQGHGLWLRQRI63(
 D:LOOVKRZ JUDSKLFDOVROXWLRQDVDELQDU\IODVK GLVWLOODWLRQ&DQDOVRXVH55 HTXDWLRQ7R
JHQHUDWHHTXLOGDWDFDQXVH
   [ & [ &  DQG\& \& . & [ & . & [ &  
 . &
  6XEVWLWXWHIRU[& [ & 
. & . &
  3LFN7ILQG.&DQG.&HJIURP'H3ULHVWHUFKDUWVVROYHIRU[&7KHQ\& .&[&

7ƒ& .& .& [& \& .&[&
    
   
   
   
   
   
   

/  9 ) 
  2S/LQH6ORSH  ,QWHUVHFWLRQ\ [ ] 
9 9 ) 
  6HH)LJXUH
  \& DQG[& 7KXV.&  
  7KLVFRUUHVSRQGVWR7 ƒ& .


 E )ROORZV([DPSOH



  0: / [ & 0: &
[ & 0: &
     
0: 0:  
    9/ [ & &
[ & &
  POPRO 
& &  
0: /  POIW  OEP
    / JPO  
9/  JOEP IW 
   0: Y \& 0:& \& 0:&      
S0: Y  JPRO
   Y JPO OEPIW  
57 PODWP
 .
PRO .
  1RZZHFDQGHWHUPLQHIORZUDWHV
9
   9 )    OEPROK 
)
   :Y 9 0: Y    OEK 

  / ) 9 OEPROK:/ / 0: /    OEK 

:/ Y   

   )OY   Q)OY  
:Y /   

. GUXP H[S     
   
 
      

   X 3HUP . GUXP / Y Y     IWV 

9 0: Y  
   $ &V IW  
X 3HUP  Y   
   ' $ &V   IW8VHIW 
  /UDQJHVIURPî IWWRî IW

   1RWH7KLVX3HUPLVDWRIIORRG,IZHZDQWWRRSHUDWHDWORZHUIORRG VD\
KDYH
   X 3HUP   X 3HUP     
   7KHQDWRIIORRG$&V ZKLFKLV' RUIW

)
[%           
\ %           
 
 %HQ]HQHWROXHQH HTXLOLEULXP LV SORWWHG LQ )LJXUH  RI 3HUU\¶V &KHPLFDO (QJLQHHUV
+DQGERRNWKHG 

) 6HH*UDSK'DWDLVIURP3HUU\¶V&KHPLFDO(QJLQHHUV+DQGERRNWKHGS





 

  6WDJH ] ) I   6ORSH  


    ,QWHUFHSW \ [   ] 


 6WDJH ] ) I   6ORSH   


    ,QWHUFHSW [  \   ] 

 6WDJH ] ) I   6ORSH 

    ,QWHUFHSW [  \   


) %XEEOH3W$W3 N3D:DQW .] 
 *XHVV   7  & .  .   .     
 &RQYHUJHWR 7  &
]
 'HZ3W&DOF :DQW  
.
 7U\   7  & .  .   .     



 &RQYHUJHWR 7  & 7KLVLVDZLGHERLOLQJIHHG
 7GUXPPXVWEHORZHUWKDQƒ&VLQFHWKDWLVIHHGWHPSHUDWXUH
 )LUVW7ULDO*XHVV  7G  &  .  .   .   
 *XHVV 9 )  5DFKIRUG5LFH(T
       
     I9 )  
         
     9 ) JLYHVI   
 %\OLQHDULQWHUSRODWLRQ 9 ) I    ZKLFK LV FORVH HQRXJK IRU ILUVW
WULDO
     9 9 ) )  /  
]L
     [L DQG\ L .L[L 
 .L  9 )
    [ [  [   [  
    \ \  \  \  
 'DWD3LFN  7UHI  & 3HUU\¶V HGSDQG3HUU\¶VWKHGS
WK

     FDOJ  NFDONPRO 
     FDOJ  NFDONPRO 
     FDOJ  NFDONPRO 
  DW  7  & &S/ FDO  J &  NFDONPRO & 
  )RU 7 WR & &S/ NFDONPRO & 
  DW  7  & &S/ NFDONPRO & +LPPHOEODX$SSHQGL[(
    &SY D E7 F7  
  SURSDQH D  E î F î

  QSHQWDQH  D  E î  F î
 
QRFWDQH  D  E î F î
  6PLWK 9DQ1HVVS
  (QHUJ\%DODQFH(7G 9+Y/K/±)K) 
)K )          NFDOK 
  /K /           

9+ Y       

         

        

  ( 7GUXP  7KXV7GUXPLVWRRKLJK

 &RQYHUJHRQ 7GUXP  &  .  .   .   
 )RU 9 )  I    9  /  



  [  [   [    [  
   \  \   \   \  
   )K )   /K /   9+ Y  ( 7GUXP  
 7KXV7GUXPPXVWEHYHU\FORVHWRƒ&
   [  [   [   
   \  \   \   
   9 NPROK/ NPROK 
 1RWH:LWKGLIIHUHQWGDWD7 GUXPPD\YDU\VLJQLILFDQWO\

/ )
)  1HZ3UREOHP \9 /[ )]   RU  \ [ ]
9 9
/
     9 )  9 NPRO K  /   VORSH 
9
)
     [  \ ]    
9
   )LQG 9 NPROK/ NPROK

   )URPWKHJUDSK[ \ 

   (TXLOLEULXPLVIURP157/RQ$VSHQ3OXV




FI GURE 2.F.4.



*8VHG3HQJ5RELQVRQIRUK\GURFDUERQV

  )LQG 7GUXP  & / DQG9 NPROK 
  ,QRUGHUHWK\OHQHHWKDQHSURSDQHSURS\OHQHQEXWDQH[L\LDUH
              

 
* 8VHG3HQJ5RELQVRQ)LQG 7GUXP  & / 9 NPROK 
 ,QVDPHRUGHUDV*
[ L \L DUH              




* 8VHG 157/  7GUXP  &   [ 0  \ 0    &RPSDUHV WR JUDSK ZLWK
[0 DQG\ 0  'LIIHUHQWHTXLOLEULXPGDWD
$

*1HZ3UREOHP
    
&203 [, \,
0(7+$1( ( 
%87$1(  (
3(17$1(  (
+(;$1(  (
9)   

* 1HZ3UREOHP8VHG157/7 4 N:VWOLTXLGWRWDOOLTXLG 
&RPS /LTXLG[ /LTXLG[ 9DSRU\
)XUIXUDO   
:DWHU   
(WKDQRO   

* 1HZ 3UREOHP 8VHG 3HQJ 5RELQVRQ )HHG SUHVVXUH   DWP )HHG WHPSHUDWXUH  R&
9)   4GUXP   1RWH WKHUH DUH YHU\ VPDOO GLIIHUHQFHV LQ IHHG WHPSHUDWXUH ZLWK
GLIIHUHQWYHUVLRQVRI$VSHQ3OXV


&203 [, \,
0(7+$1(  
%87$1(  
3(17$1(  
+(;$1(  
9)   


+ 1HZ 3UREOHP  7KH VSUHDGVKHHW ZLWK HTXDWLRQV IRU SUREOHP ' LV VKRZQ LQ $SSHQGL[ % RI
&KDSWHU7KHVSUHDGVKHHWZLWKQXPEHUVIRULEXWDQHUHSODFLQJQEXWDQHLVEHORZ

0&IODVK+:*E0&IODVKZLWKL
EXWDQH

.FRQVW D7 D7 D7 DS 
DS 
DS
0      

L%      

Q3HQWDQH      

Q+H[      
S
7GHJ5  SVLD  ) 
]0  ]L%  ]QS  ]QKH[

9)  
   


 JXHVV
.0 
.L%      
.Q3HQ      
.Q+H[      
8VHJRDOVHHNIRUFHOO%WR
  FKDQJH%
  

[0  
[LE      
[Q3HQ      
[Q+H[      
6XP      
550      
55Q%      
55Q3      
55Q+H[      
VXP55      
     

+1HZ3UREOHP8VHWKHVDPHVSUHDGVKHHWDVIRUSUREOHP+EXWZLWKPHWKDQHIHHGPROHIUDFWLRQ

$QVZHU9) 
[LE 
[Q3HQ 
[Q+H[ 
.L% 
.Q3HQ 
.Q+H[ 
\LE [LE.LE DQGVRIRUWK$



 &KDSWHU

1HZ3UREOHPVDQGQHZVROXWLRQVDUHOLVWHGDVQHZLPPHGLDWHO\DIWHUWKHVROXWLRQQXPEHU7KHVHQHZ
SUREOHPVDUH$$$&&''*

$ 6LPXOWDQHRXV VROXWLRQ LV OLNHO\ ZKHQ RQH RI WKH NH\ YDULDEOHV FDQ EH IRXQG RQO\ IURP WKH
HQHUJ\EDODQFHV)RUH[DPSOHLIRQO\RI [ '  [ % '% )5 $GLVW DUHJLYHQHQHUJ\EDODQFHV
ZLOO EH UHTXLUHG  7KLV LV FDVH IRU PRVW RI WKH VLPXODWLRQ SUREOHPV DQG IRU D IHZ GHVLJQ
SUREOHPV,QVRPHVLPXODWLRQSUREOHPVWKHLQWHUQDOHTXDWLRQVKDYHWREHVROYHGDOVR

% D [ '  [ % RSWIHHG 4 5H E 
  [ '  [ % RSWIHHG 4 & 
  [ '  [ % RSWIHHG6RSHQVWHDPVDW¶GYDSRUVWHDP
  $OORIDERYHZLWKIUDFWLRQDOUHFRYHULHVVHWLQVWHDGRI [ '  [ % 
  ' [ % RSWIHHG/'

 E 1 1 ) FROGLDPHWHUIUDFUHFRYHULHVERWKFRPS
  1 1 ) FROGLDPHWHU )5 $ GLVW /R ' 
  1 1 ) FROGLDPHWHU )5 $ GLVW45 
  1 1 ) FROGLDPHWHU )5 $ GLVW4& 
  1 1 ) FROGLDPHWHU [ '  4&   RU[ %  
  1 1 ) FROGLDPHWHU6VDW¶GVWHDPVDW¶GYDSRUVWHDP [ '  RU[ %  

 0DQ\ RWKHU VLWXDWLRQV DUH SRVVLEOH >HJ  IHHGV VLGH VWUHDPV LQWHUPHGLDWH FRQGHQVHUV RU
UHERLOHUVHWF@

&  6HHVROXWLRQWRSUREOHP'

&  6HHVROXWLRQWRSUREOHP'

&  1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ )PL[ )  ) '% 
  )PL[ ] PL[ )]  ) ]  '[ '  %[ % 0ROHIUDF09&

)]  ) ] 
   ] PL[ 
)PL[
  1RZVROYHOLNH)HHG&ROXPQ  )PL[  ] PL[  )URP(T
] PL[  [ %
   ' )PL[ NPROK
['  [%
   % )PL[  ' NPROK

&  1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ6HHVROXWLRQWR'3DUWE




'  
)  ) %  '[ %     !
4&
9 )]  ) ]  %[ %  '[ ' ['  !
' [ '
) "! /R § ] DYJ  [ % ·
6ROYH' ¨ ¸ )WRWDO !
© ['  [% ¹
) ! )WRWDO )  ) NJK !

)]  ) ]          

] DYJ 
)WRWDO 

/! 9   
45 ! '   NJK !
!
  
NJ
% [ % % )WRWDO  '     !
K

 0DVVEDODQFHFDOFXODWLRQLVYDOLGIRUSDUWVD EIRUSUREOHP*
/R
  D  (T    4&   /  '  '  K '  +  
'
   K ' LVDVDWXUDWHGOLTXLGDW [ '  ZWIUDF)URP)LJ K ' a  NFDONJ
   + LVVDWXUDWHGYDSRUDW [ ' \  + a  NFDONJ
    4&            NFDOKRXU
  (%DURXQGFROXPQ )K )  ) K )  4FRO  4&  45 'K '  %K % 
 K )   & ZWHWKDQRO  a NFDO  NJ K )   & ZWHWKDQRO  a NFDO  NJ 
  K % VDW¶GOLTXLG±OHDYHVHTXLOFRQWDFWaZWHWKDQROaNFDONJ4FRO DGLDEDWLF
 45                        NFDONJ
 E 9 %  PDVV



 9 ! /0123!415&)6!
/K /  45 9+ 9  %K % !

#$%&'($)! 45 ! / 9  % Ÿ /    

/ !
!
^Ăƚ͛ĚůŝƋĚ!
9 % RU9 %  !
*+ [ % ,-.---"!
^Ăƚ͛ĚůŝƋĚ!

$SSUR[LPDWHO\ [ % a \9 a [ / 7KXV K / K %   +9 |  NFDO NJ 

    45              NFDO  K 

   (% 4& 'K '  %K %  4FRO  )K )  ) K )  45 
    4&             NFDOK 

'  &ROXPQPDVVEDO)6 '%
   09&)] 6\6 '[ '  %[ % 
   1RWH \6 
   HQHUJ\EDO )K I  6+V  4& 'K '  %K % 
  &RQGHQVHUPDVVEDO 9 /R  ' 
   HQHUJ\EDO 9+  4&  /R  '  K ' 
  6ROYH(TVDQGWRJHW
)]  )[ %  6[ %        
    '  
['  [%   
  1RWH1RW(T6ROYH(TVDQGWRJHW
    4& '   / '  K '  +  
  6XEVWLWXWH 4 & LQWR(T
/ 'K '   )  6  '  K %  )K )  6+ S
     
' '  K '  + 
  )URP)LJXUH K )  K '  K %  +S  + NFDONJ 
                  
    / '    
     

'  ([WHUQDOEDODQFHV)& %' 
    )]  &[ & %[ %  '\'  
    45  )K )  &K & %K %  '+ '  



  ) & ]  [ &  [ %  \'   K )   &    
  K &  VDW
GOLTXLG   K %  VDW
GOLTXLG   + '  VDW
GYDSRU  NFDONJ 
  $URXQGUHERLOHU  / 9%
      /[ 1 9\ 5H E  %[ % 
      /K 1  45 9+ UHE  %K % 
  )RUDWRWDOUHERLOHU [ 1 [ % \ 1 [1 [ %  K 1 K%  
     0%  9  % K 1  45 9+ UHE  %K % 
45
     RU 9 VLQFHK % K 1 
+ UHE  K 1
     +5HE  VDWXUDWHGYDSRUDW \ 1   
)]  &[ &  )\ '  &\ '
  6ROYH(TVDQGIRU% % 
[ %  \'
      
   7KXV  % DQG'  
  
  )URP(T 45 %K % '+ '  )K )  &K & 
   
 45                     FDOK 
45 
    9 NJK 
+ UHE  K 1   

' 1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ ) % ' 
09& )] %[ %  '\ ' 
 %XWJLYHQUHFRYHULHV7KXVXVH
  )] )0 )UDF5HF0HWKDQROLQGLVWLOODWH '\ '0 
 DQG  )] ): )UDF5HFZDWHULQERWWRP %[ %: 
] )0  ] ):   ] )0  
 \'0 XQNQRZQ[ %: XQNQRZQ 
 0HWKDQRO     '\ '0 
 ,IPHWKDQROUHFRYHUHGLQGLVWLOODWHLVLQERWWRPV      %[ %0 
 :DWHU       %[ %: Ÿ  ZDWHULQGLVWLOODWH
       '\': 
 6LQFH ¦ [ L  DQG ¦ \L   ¦  '\ 'L  ' DQG ¦  %[ %L  %
 7KXV ' '\'0  '\':     NPRO K 
 % %[ %0  %[ %:     NPRO K 
 &KHFN %  '  )  2.



 '\'0
  \G0    
'
 [ %0 %[ %0 %    
D '   / '  7KXV /  
5HIOX[OLTXLGLVLQHTXLOLEULXPZLWKYDSRU \ '0  
)URPHTXLOLEULXPGDWD7DEOH [ 0 a  OLQHDULQWHUSRODWLRQ
E (%3DUWLDOFRQGHQVHU 9+  4F '+  / K  
9 '  /  
9\ '\  / [  Ÿ \  '\  / [   9 
 \0           \:   \0  
  O0   - PRO# &  N-  NPRO Ÿ FKRRVH0H2+UHIHUHQFHž&
 O   - PRO# &  N-NPRO Ÿ FKRRVHZDWHUUHIHUHQFHž&
 7KHFRQGHQVHULVDWž&OLQHDULQWHUSRODWLRQ7DEOH
 + O 0 \0  O : \:  \0 &390   7     \: &39:  7    
 9 LVDW 7 LQHTXLOLEULXPZLWK \0  )URP7DEOH 7 a  & 
 $VVXPLQJRQO\FRQVWDQW OLQHDU7WHUPDUHLPSRUWDQWLQ &39 HTV & 39 &3  7DYJ  )RU
     
PHWKDQRO 7DYJ  & )RUZDWHU 7DYJ  & 
 
- PRO N- N-
 &390       
PRO  NPRO  - NPRO &
- N-
 &39:      R
 
PRO & NPRO &
 '70      '7:     
7KHQ
+                         
 +  N- NPRO 1RWHȜWHUPVGRPLQDWH


 + ' LVDW \' # & 
 +' O 0 \'0  O : \':  \'0 &390  7'    \': &39:  7'    
  
 &390 &390  70DYJ   7DYJ0  

 &390      
  
 &39: &39:  7:DYJ    7:DYJ  

 &39:       
 '7:     



  +'                    

+'         
5HIOX[OLTXLGDWž&DQG [ 0  [ :  
 5HIHUHQFH0H2+ž&ZDWHUUHIHUHQFHž&
 K  &3/0 [ 0 '70  &3/: [ : '7: 
N-
 &3/0 &3/0  7DYJ        
NPRO &
 K             N- NPRO

4& '+ '  / K   9+                 N- K

2YHUDOO(% )K )  4&  45 '+ '  %K %

RU 45 '+ '  %K %  4&  )K ) 
K % LVVDWXUDWHGOLTXLGZLWK [ %0  DQG [ %:  
 ,QWHUSRODWLQJLQ7DEOH 7%RW |  & 
K% &3/0        &3/:        
  
 7DYJ0  DQG &3/0       
 
K%       N- NPR O

)HHGLVVDWXUDWHGOLTXLGDW ] 0  ] :  
 )URP7DEOH 7)  & 
 K) &3/0       &3/:        
7DYJ0       DQG &3/0       
K)  N- NPRO 7KHQ

45                   
            N- K 

'  0DVV%DODQFHV) '6% )] '[ '  6[ 6  %[ % 
   6ROYLQJVLPXOWDQHRXVO\% NJPLQ' NJPLQ
   &RQGHQVHU 4& 9  K   +  
   9 /  '  / '   '     NJPLQ
   )URP)LJXUH K   NFDONJ[ 7 ƒ&
   +  NFDONJ\ VDW¶GYDSRU
   7KXV 4 & ± NFDOPLQ
   2YHUDOO(QHUJ\%DODQFH )K )  45  4& 'K '  6K6  %K % 
      45 'K '  6K6  %K %  )K )  4& 
   )URP)LJXUH
     K 6   [ 6  VDW
G/LT
G   K )  ]    &    



     K%   [ %  VDW
G/LT
G   K ' KR  
  7KXV
  45                        NFDOPLQ

§ ]  [% · §    ·
'  )URP(T' ) ¨ ¸  ¨ ¸  OEPROK
© ['  [% ¹ ©    ¹
   7KHQ% ) 
   &RQGHQVHU 9  /R  '   /R '  '  ' 
      4&  K '  + 9  '  /R '   
   :LWK Q& KDYHHVVHQWLDOO\SXUH Q& 7KXVLWLVDWLWVERLOLQJSRLQW
     K '  +9  O &  %WXOEPRO
     4&        %WXK
   2YHUDOO 45 'K '  %K %  )K )  4& 
   'LVWLOODWHLVDWERLOLQJSRLQWRISXUH Q&   . &  RQ'H3ULHVWHU&KDUW ƒ&%RWWRPV
LVDWERLOLQJSRLQWRI Q&   . &    ƒ&
   &RQYHUWLQJWRƒ)ƒ& ƒ)ƒ& ƒ)ƒ& ƒ)
   1RWH IHHG LV REYLRXVO\ D VXEFRROHG OLTXLG  $UELWUDULO\ SLFN D OLTXLG DW ƒ) DV UHIHUHQFH
7KLVZLOOQRWDIIHFWWKHUHVXOWDQGRWKHUYDOXHVFDQEHXVHG
     &3) [ &&3/&  ] & &3/& 
     &3)           %WXOEPROƒ)
     K) &3  7)          %WXOEPRO
)

   'LVWLOODWHLVDOPRVWSXUH Q& /LTXLGDWƒ)

     K' &3/&  7'LVW         %WXOEPRO
   %RWWRPVLVDOPRVWSXUHOLTXLG Q& DWƒ)
    K& S/&  7ERW   
     %WXOEPRO
  45                     %WXK
§ ]  [% · §    ·
' (T ' )¨ ¸  ¨ ¸  NPROK
© ['  [% ¹ ©    ¹
     % )  '  NPROK
  &RQGHQVHU /R  /R '  '       NPROK
    2QO\WKLVUHIOX[LVFRQGHQVHGVLQFHSURGXFWLVDYDSRU
    4& /R  O  ZKHUHȜLVIRUHVVHQWLDOO\SXUHQSHQWDQH
§ NPRO ·§ %WX ·§ OEPRO ·
    4& ¨  ¸¨ ¸¨ ¸
© K ¹© OEPRO ¹© NPRO ¹
%WX - -
    4&    u  
K  u %WX

K



  )URPRYHUDOOEDODQFH 45 '+'  %K %  )K)  4& 
  'LVWLOODWHLVYDSRUDWESRISXUHQSHQWDQHƒ&IURP'H3ULHVWHUFKDUW . &  
  %RWWRPVLVERLOLQJQKH[DQHƒ&
  &RQYHUVLRQV ƒ& ƒ)GLVWLOODWH )HHGDQGƒ& ƒ)ERWWRPV

  $VUHIHUHQFHDUELWUDULO\FKRRVHOLTXLGDWƒ)
   )HHGLVVXEFRROHGOLTXLG
     &3) ] &&3/&  ] &&3/&           %WX OEPROR ) 
     K) &3)  7)   
      %WX OEPRO 
  'LVWLOODWH + ' O &  &3/&  7GLVW    
     + '           %WX OEPRO 
  %RWWRPVLVSXUH & # ) 
     K% &3/&  7ERW          %WX OEPRO 
ª§ NPRO ·§ %WX · § NPRO ·§ %WX ·
45 «¨  K ¸¨ OEPRO ¸  ¨  K ¸¨  OEPRO ¸
¬© ¹© ¹ © ¹© ¹
   
§ NPRO ·§ %WX · º ª OEPRO º § %WX ·
 ¨ ¸¨  ¸» « »  ¨   ¸
© K ¹© OEPRO ¹ ¼ ¬ NPRO ¼ © K ¹
%WX -
   45    u - K 
K  u %WX

3.D8
1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ
)  ] (  ] Z  
 
 UHF(LQGLVWLOODWHUHFZDWHULQERW
  ' 'LVW            NPROK 

\ '(
  
 
 

  % %RWWRPV          NPRO K 

\'  ' + ' !

 E 3DUWLDO&RQGHQVHU

4F !
9DSRU !
+ \ 9 !
/
 / '    NPRO K [   /  K 
'
!
  [  LQHTXLOLEULXPZLWK \  WKXVIURPHTXDWLRQGDWD [   

  (QWHULQJYDSRU \ IURPJUDSK  



   9 /  '   NPRO K 
 F (%RQ3& 9+  4F '+GLVW  / K   &DQXVH)LJXUHE\FRQYHUWLQJPROHIUDFVWRPDVV
IUDFV%DVLVNPROH
  'LVWLOODWH PRO(  0:   NJ( 
NJ:
   PROH:  0:  
NJWRWDO
   0DVVIUDF(       
  9DSRU 9  PROH(    NJ( 
NJ:
   PROH:   
NJWRWDO
   0DVVIUDF(     
  /LTXLGUHIOX[ /   PROH(    NJ( 
NJ(
   PROH: 
WRWDO 
   0DVVIUDF(     
  )URP)LJXUH +GLVW a  NFDO NJ + a  NFDO NJ K  a  NFDO NJ 
NPRO NJ NFDO
4F '+ GLVW  /  K   9+      
KU NJ NJ
  
NJ
      NFDO KU
NPRO
  2YHUDOO(% )K )  45  4F '+GLVW  %K % 
  .QRZ 4F   NFDO K 
  DQG '+GLVW    NFDO K 
  7RILQG )K ) DQG%K %  QHHGWRFRQYHUWPROHIUDFWRZWIUDF
  %DVLVNPRO
  )HHG PROH(PROH     

    :     
WRWDO NJ NPRO
   0DVVIUDF(    
  %RWWRPV  PROH     

   PROH  
WRWDO NJ NPRO
   0DVVIUDF(    
  )URP)LJXUH K )  VDWGOLTG  |  NFDO NJ 
   K %  VDWGOLTG  |  




  7KHQ 45 '+GLVW  %K %  )K )  4F   
NPRO NJ NFDO NJ NFDO
45        
K NPRO NJ NPRO NJ
                   NFDO K 

3D91HZ3UREOHPUG(GLWLRQ% ['±]['±[%) >±@ 

45  /K 9+  %K % DQG / 9  % 

 $VVXPH K K %   4 5   /  %  K  9K 9  +  K  9O 
  9  9 % %    NPRO K 
 %RWWRPVLVDOPRVWSXUHZDWHU O Z  NFDO PRO  NFDO NPRO 
  45 NPROK     u  NFDO K 

3.D10 DWPî N3DDWP  N3D3HQWDQH5HFRYHU\  u )] 3 '[ ' 

       '
      NPROK
 
       % ± 
  6LQFH %[ %   3HQWDQH5HFRYHU\%RW  )] S   

    [%
      PROIUDFSHQWDQH

  'LVWLOODWHLVHVVHQWLDOO\SXUH3HQWDQH%RWWRPV3XUHLQ+H[DQH)URP'H3ULHVWHU&KDUW
    . 3 # S N3DZKHQ7GLVW  & 
    . Q + # S N3DZKHQ7ERW  &  
§ /R ·
  )RU7RWDO&RQGHQVHU(T 4& ¨  ¸ '  K '  +  
© '¹
    K '  SXUHSHQWDQH  &3/&  7GLVW  7UHI  FKRRVH7UHI  & 
NFDO NFDO
    K'       
NPRO & NPRO
    + K '  O DVVXPLQJȜLVLQGHSHQGHQWRIWHPSHUDWXUH
%WX ª  OEPRO º ª NFDO º NFDO
    +    « » « »  
OEPRO ¬  NPRO ¼ ¬ %WX ¼ NPRO
NPRO NFDO
  (TLV 4&         
K K
NFDO NFDO
    K %  SXUHKH[DQH  &3/&  7ERW  7UHI        
NPRO & NPRO
  )HHGLVDOLTXLGDWƒ&
     K ) > &3& ]&  &3& ]& @  7)  7UHI  
       K) ª¬         º¼    NFDO  NPRO 



     45 'K '  %K %  )K )  4& 
   45                
     45    NFDOK
  1RWHWKDW 4& DQG4 5 DUHUHODWLYHO\FORVH

3.E1 :DV'LQQG(GLWLRQ
 4&


 ' [ ' 

 ! 9.*.!!!!8!:!0!,!;!:!*!

 8! )] 0  6\60 '[ '  %[ % !
5!,!".-!127!
  NPRO K
 0'<=$!>2$17!'>!5?)$+! \60  !
! ] 0  !


 0! @<&A!! ) ] 0  [ '  [ % !
 *!
 [ %  ! B<C<&A<>!0+!;+!*+!!!!D$$3!E.*.!

 )K )  4&  6+6 'K '  %K %

 3LFNDVEDVLVOLTXLGDWƒ& K :  K 0  HVVHQWLDOO\VWHDPWDEOHFKRLFH
 $VVXPHLGHDOPL[WXUHV
    K ) &3DYJ  73  7UHI  ZKHUH&3DYJ &3: /   & 30 / 
 )HOGHU 5RXVHDXS &3:  N-PRO
    &30    u 7 N-PRO
    &30 &30  7DYJ  &30         &30   &  
    &30    u     
    &3DYJ           
    K)        N-PROIHHG N-NPRO
 &DQDOVRXVHVWHDPWDEOHIRUZDWHU
N- NJ
    + 6 LVVDW¶GYDSRUVWHDPDWP +6  
NJ NPRO
   6WHDP7DEOH) 5S + 6 N-NPRO
   K ' LVVDW¶GOLTXLGDW [ '  )URP7DEOH7 ƒ&
   K' &3DYJ      ZKHUH&3DYJ &3:  &30 
   &30 &30  7DYJ  &30   &     u      
   &3DYJ          



   +'      N- PRO   N- NPRO 
   K %  6LQFHOHDYLQJDQHTXLOLEULXPVWDJHVDW¶GOLTG0H2+
     7DEOH7 ƒ&
   K% &3DYJ      ZKHUH&3 DYJ &3:  &30 
   &30 &30         & 30   &  
   &30    u     
   &3DYJ           N- PRO 
   K%      N- PRO  N- PRO 
      
   4& GR(%DURXQGFRQGHQVHU
§/ ·
   4& O GLVW 9O GLVW  /R  '  O GLVW ¨ R  ¸ '   
©' ¹
   OGLVW | O 0H2+  O : 
 )HOGHU 5RXVVHDX O0  N- PRO  O :  N- PRO 
N-
   OGLVW            N- NPRO 
PRO
   4&        ' ' N- K 
    
  3OXJ 4 & QXPEHUVLQWR(%
       '  6 '  % 
  RU 6 '%
   
  6ROYHVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ZLWK0%6 '%
     '%
  2QHFDQXVHDOJHEUDRUYDULRXVFRPSXWHUSDFNDJHV

  2EWDLQ ' NPROK% NPROK
     6 NPROK4&  N-K 

NPRO PRO
E2 :DV'LQQG(GLWLRQ )    
K K
    )6 '%
    )]  6\6 '[ '  %[ % 
    HTXQNQRZQV
  &RQGHQVHU 4&   /  '  '  K R  +  
      1RWH(TQRWYDOLG

  )RU HQWKDOS\ SLFN UHIHUHQFH SXUH OLTXLG ZDWHU ƒ& DQG SXUH OLTXLG PHWKDQRO ƒ&  )HOGHU 
  
5RXVHDX &30H2+   7 DW 7DYJ  &30H2+  - PRO & 




    $VVXPLQJGLVWLOODWHSXUHPHWKDQROERLOVDWƒ&
    K' &30HRK OLT  7  7UHI   -PRO       - PRO 
    + K '  O  DW )    -PRO -PRO 
    4&       '  ' -KZKHUH'LVPROK
  2YHUDOO(QHUJ\EDODQFH )K )  6+6  4& 'K'  %K% 
  %RWWRPVLVHVVHQWLDOO\SXUH +  2 DWƒ&
§ - · -
    K% &3: OLT  7  7UHI  ¨  ¸      
© PRO & ¹ PRO
    +6 K %  O :  DW &    -PRO  
  )RUIHHGPROH0HWKDQROERLOVDWƒ&7DEOH
   K) ¦
&3L ]L  7  7UHI                  -PRO
 1RZ(TVDUH
   )6 '% RU6 '%
   )] '[ '  %[ % RU '%
§ /R ·
   4& ¨  ¸ '  K '  +  RU4&  ' 
© '¹
   )K )  6K 6  4& 'K '  %K % RU6
         4 & '%
 6ROYHVLPXOWDQHRXVO\' % 6 NPROK
   4 & îN-K

) $Q HQWKDOS\ FRPSRVLWLRQ GLDJUDP LV DYDLODEOH RQ S  RI 3HUU\¶V &KHPLFDO (QJLQHHU¶V
+DQGERRNUGHG
§ ]  [% ·   
  (T ' ¨ ¸)       NPROK
© ['  [% ¹   
  1RWHWKDW 1  PROHIUDFWLRQVZHUHXVHGVLQFH 1  LVPRUHYRODWLOH% )±' 
  )URP HQWKDOS\ FRPS GLDJ K '  +  NFDONPRO K %  K )    7KHQ
4&   /R '  '  K '  +          NFDOK
     45 'K '  %K %  )K )  4& 
     45             4&    NFDOK

) :HZLOOXVHWKH HQWKDOS\FRPSRVLWLRQ GLDJUDP RQSRI3HUU\¶VWK HGLWLRQRUSRI
3HUU\¶VWKHG'RIRUNPRORIIHHG
  &RQYHUVLRQRIIHHGIURPNJWRPROHV %DVLVNJ
         NJ 1+   NPRO
         NJ + 2 
         7RWDONPRO

   7KXVNPROLV NJ



  :LOOZRUNSUREOHPLQZHLJKWIUDFWLRQVVLQFHGDWDLVSUHVHQWHGWKDWZD\
  UHFRYHU\)]  '[ ' RU'  )]  [ '   NJ
  % )±' NJ
  [%  )]  '[ '  % ª¬        º¼    
  )URPGLDJUDP K '  +  K %  K ) NFDONJ 
  (T 4&   /R '  '  K '  +         NFDONPROIHHG
  DQG 45 'K '  %K %  )K )  4& 
  45             4&  NFDONPRORIIHHG

G1.D 8VLQJ157/ 4& NFDOK45 NFDOK 
  E 4&  NFDOK45  NFDOK 

G2 1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ
  $63(13OXV' /' 3HQJ5RELQVRQ 1  1)  DUELWUDU\YDOXHVLQ5DGIUDF
     [' [ '& u 
     [%  
4&  u  %WX K
     
45  u  %WX K

! ! ! ! ! !

! ! ! ! ! ! ! !



 63(UG(G6ROXWLRQ0DQXDO&KDSWHU

1HZ3UREOHPVDQGQHZVROXWLRQVDUHOLVWHGDVQHZLPPHGLDWHO\DIWHUWKHVROXWLRQQXPEHU7KHVHQHZ
SUREOHPVDUH$$&&'''''((+WR+

$ 3RLQW$VWUHDPVOHDYLQJVWDJH/9
 3RLQW%YDSRUVWUHDPOHDYLQJVWDJH9
 OLTXLGVWUHDPOHDYLQJVWDJH/
 7HPSRIVWDJHNQRZ . \   [  FDQJHW7IURPWHPSHUDWXUHFRPSRVLWLRQJUDSKRU
'H3ULHVWHUFKDUWRI. I7S
 7HPSLQUHERLOHUVDPHDVDERYHUHERLOHULVDQHTXLOLEULXPVWDJH

$ D)HHGWUD\ ] GUDZ\ [OLQH\) [) 
 E7ZRSKDVHIHHG
 F+LJKHU

$  1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ$QVZHULVD 

$ 6HH7DEOHDQGIRUDSDUWLDOOLVW
  
$ 1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ
  $ $QVZHULVE
  % $QVZHULVD
  & $QVZHULVD
  ' $QVZHULVD
  ( $QVZHULVE
  ) $QVZHULVD
  * $QVZHULVE

$ ,I IHHG VWDJH LV QRQRSWLPXP WKH IHHG FRQGLWLRQV FDQ EH FKDQJHG WR KDYH DQ RSWLPXP
IHHGORFDWLRQ

% D8VHFROXPQVLQSDUDOOHO/RZHU)WRHDFKFROXPQDOORZVIRUKLJKHU/'DQGPD\EHVXIILFLHQW
IRUSURGXFWVSHFLILFDWLRQV
 E$GGDUHERLOHULQVWHDGRIVWHDPLQMHFWLRQ6OLJKWO\OHVVVWDJHVUHTXLUHGDQGDGGVVWDJH
 F0DNHWKHFRQGHQVHUDSDUWLDOLQVWHDGRIDWRWDOFRQGHQVHU$GGVDVWDJH
 G6WRSUHPRYLQJVLGHVWUHDP)HZHUVWDJHVDUHQRZUHTXLUHGIRUWKHVDPHVHSDUDWLRQ
 H5HPRYHWKHLQWHUPHGLDWHUHERLOHURUFRQGHQVHUDQGXVHLWDWERWWRPRUWRSRIFROXPQ)HZHU
VWDJHVEXWDOOHQHUJ\DWKLJKHVW7UHERLOHUVRUORZHVW7FRQGHQVHUIRUVDPHVHSDUDWLRQ
0DQ\RWKHULGHDVZLOOEHXVHIXOLQFHUWDLQFDVHV
&(DVLHVWSURRILVIRUDVDWXUDWHGOLTXLGIHHG6KRZSRLQW ] \ ' VDWLVILHVRSHUDWLQJHTXDWLRQ
   6ROXWLRQ2S(T \ / 9 [ / 9  [% 
   6XEVWLWXWHLQ  \ \ '  [ ]
     \' 9 /] / 9 [% 
   %XW T  9 ' / ) / 9 %
     \ ' ' )] %[ % 
   :KLFKLVH[WHUQDOPDVVEDODQFH4('



   &DQGRVLPLODUIRUHQULFKLQJFROXPQIRUDVDWXUDWHGYDSRUIHHG

&1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ,IZHFRQVLGHUȜWKHODWHQWKHDWSHUPROHWREHDSRVLWLYHTXDQWLW\
WKHQ 45 9   :LWK &02 DQG D VDWXUDWHG OLTXLG IHHG 9 9  /  ' '  DQG WKHQ
45  '  /  ' 

&  1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ'HILQHDILFWLWLRXVWRWDOIHHG )7  ] 7  K 7 
)] ) ]  )K ) ) K )
     )7 ) )  ] 7   K 7
)7 )7
    ,QWHUVHFWLRQRIWRS ERWWRPRSHUDWLQJOLQHVPXVWRFFXUDWIHHGOLQHIRUILFWLWLRXVIHHG) 7
'UDZDFROXPQZLWKDVLQJOHPL[HGIHHGWRSURYHWKLV
    7KLVIHHGOLQHJRHVWKURXJK \ [ ] 7        

>'2E"069+)"" T 7 T7  "

+ PL[ K7
>E)4)"" " T 7 ""1*5" + PL[  K PL[ "14)"0123412)5"
)7 + PL[ K PL[
"
(1+94"1*5"6'73'5")*2E16+')0"12"8))5"021D)"98":963?*">'2E"

?'!)5""8))5<"

"

" 

&'()*" +," -./," 0123412)5" 6'73'5" 4)863!, [ '  [ % "

%"
#" ] " 9+2"8))5"69:12'9*0," ] ]  ) ) K ) K ) "

] " "
$"
]7 "
"
] " "

;692"29+"9+"6'*)<"";692"166"="8))5"6'*)0<"/41>"
[% "
!" 6'*)"849?"+9'*2"%"29"$"@"!"@" 29"9A21'*"

T) T  )A92<"9+<"6'*)<""B9**):2"+20"#"C"B"29"D)2"

E 'RHV T7 
)7
?'556)"9+<"6'*)<"

"


 )K ) ) K )
+ PL[
+ PL[ K7 )7 ) ) + PL[ )+ ) ) K )
   FKHFN T 7 
+ PL[ K PL[ + PL[ K PL[ + PL[ K PL[ )7
   ZKHUH + PL[  K PL[ DUHYDSRUDQGOLTXLGHQWKDOSLHVRQIHHGVWDJHRIPL[HGFROXPQ

) + PL[ K ) + PL[ K )
)
+ PL[ K PL[ + PL[ K PL[
    T7 
)7
   8VXDO&02DVVXPSWLRQLVȜ!!ODWHQWKHDWHIIHFWVLQHLWKHUYDSRURUOLTXLG
+ PL[ K ) + PL[ K )
   7KHQ T DQG T 
+ PL[ K PL[ + PL[ K PL[
)T ) T 
   7KXV T 7 LI&02LVYDOLG
)7
/ / / / ' 
' D 7RSRSOLQH \ [  [ ' DQG  
9 9 9  / ' 
 ,QWHUVHFWV \ [ ['  
/
 :KHQ [  \  ['  3ORW±6HHGLDJUDP
9
/ / / 9 % 9 %  
E%RWWRPRSOLQH \ [  [ % DQG 
9 9 9 9 9 % 
  ,QWHUVHFWV\ [ [% 
   
    # \ [  WKLVLVFRQYHQLHQWSRLQWWRSORW 

F 6HHGLDJUDPIRUVWDJHV2SWLPXPIHHGVWDJHLVDERYHSDUWLDOUHERLOHU
 HTXLOLEULXPVWDJHV35LVPRUHWKDQVXIILFLHQW



 G )HHGOLQHJRHVIURP\ [ ] WRLQWHUVHFWLRQRIWZRRSHUDWLQJOLQHV 
T
   6ORSH RUT  
T 
  7KLVLVDSKDVHIHHGZKLFKLVòOLTXLG òYDSRU

'1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ3DUWD

/ ) 9  9) 
\ [ ] ( 6ORSH  
9 9 9 ) 
 E )URP7DEOHDWƒ& \  
+ K)
 F OLTXLGDWƒ& T DQGPROHHWKDQRO
+ K
  7KHSUHVVXUHLQ)LJXUHLVYHU\FORVHWRDWPWKXVLWFDQEHXVHGEXWPXVWFRQYHUWWRZW
IUDF



  %DVLVNPROIHHG
   NPROH(  0:  NJZWIUDF 
NJ
   NPRO:DWHU  0:  
WRWDO NJ
  )URP)LJXUH +  NFDO NJ  K  K )  &  
 
   T  
 
T 
   6ORSH 
T  
  $OWHUQDWH6ROXWLRQ PROHHWKDQROERLOVDWƒ&7DEOH
   7KHQLISLFNUHIHUHQFHDVVDWXUDWHGOLTXLGDWPROH
   K ) &SOLT   
   K  + (

NFDO
 G PROH( ZW+  NFDO NJ  K K )  & S YDSRU   
NJ
   &3YDSRU \ ( &3(YDSRU \ Z &3Z YDSRU 
  $VVXPHRQO\VWDQGQGWHUPVLQ & 3 HTXDWLRQVDUHVLJQLILFDQW
  )URP3UREOHP'
   &3YDSRU   7   7  
   NFDONPRO 7LV & 

  ZKLFKVLPSOLILHVWR &3YDSRU  7 


  )RUOLQHDU & S G7 LVHTXDOWR &3YDSRU # 7DYJ  



NFDO
  7DYJ     7KHQ & 3Y DYJ     
NPRO
NFDO NFDO NPRO
   K)     
NJ NPRO NJ
   K)    NFDO NJ 
  
   T  
  
) 
 H  T / / I  / / ) / )
 
 
   T    VORSH T T   
 

9 /  9 )  
 I )ODVK   
) 9 9 )  
 6HHJUDSKIRUIHHGOLQHV





*UDSKIRU'



'  D %DVLVPROHIHHG
    PROHV(W2+î NJ(W2+
    PROHV+2î NJ+2
     7RWDO 
    ZWIUDF    ZWIUDF(W2+ 
  &DOFXODWHDOOHQWKDOSLHVDWZWIUDF+Y +/ IURP)LJXUHK)LVOLTXLGDW
ƒ&$VVXPH&SOLTLVQRWDIXQFWLRQRI7(VWLPDWH
K K /  & K    NFDO
   & 3 OLT ZWIUDF a  
7    NJ  &
  7KHQ K ) K /  &3/   K /  &      
+Y K)   T 
    T    
+Y K/   T  
E )URP)LJXUHDWZWHWKDQRO+Y DQGK/ 6LQFH&02LVYDOLGREWDLQLQJERWK
HQWKDOSLHVDWZWLV2.7KHIHHGLVDOLTXLG
  K ) & 3OLT 7) 7UHI &3OLT   
  &3OLT &3(W2+ ] (W2+ &3Z ] Z LQ0ROHIUDFWLRQV 
  %DVLVNJVROXWLRQ
    NJ (W2+   NJNJPROH 
    NJ :  NJPROHV 
     7RWDO NJPROHV 
    $YJ0:   NJNJPROH 
 7KXV]: DQG]( 
    &3OLT      
&3 
    & 3OLT LQ NFDO NJ &  7KHQ
0:$9* 
NFDO
    K)   &  
NJ &
+Y K )  
    T  
+Y K/   J</J1" $"@"!"
' D   K) + &3Y   +   
  F"
+ K)
    T  
+ K 8))5"
6'*)"
  6ORSH T T  \ [ ] LVLQWHUVHFWLRQ 

      <G" <H" <I"
 E  T / / )ZKHUH/ / )7KHQT / ) /  )   DQG
  VORSH  T T   
 F T / / )ZKHUH/ / )   T / ) / )   VORSH T T  



 K OLT K UHIOX[  
'     I/  
+ YDS K OLT  
/ / ' 
      
9 / '  
/  IF /  9  
     
9  I F /  9   
 $OWHUQDWH6ROXWLRQ
/ + K  
  )RUVXEFRROHGUHIOX[ T  
/ + K  
  7KHQ / T/ / 
/ / / ' / /
      
9 / ' / '  ' '
/ 
     
9 
' 1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ D  ) ) % '
           % '   
    6ROYHVLPXOWDQHRXVO\
     ' DQG%  NPRO KU 
   E )HHG T  YHUWLFDODW \ [ ]  
    )HHG YDSRU OLTXLG T   
T 
    6ORSHIHHGOLQH    WKURXJK \ [ ]  
T  
    %RWWRP2S/LQH \ / 9 [ / 9  [ % 7KURXJK \ [ [% 
9 % 
       6ORSH / 9  
9 %
    0LGGOH  / ) % 9 
/ ) ]  %[ %
      /[ ) ]  %[ % 9\ \ [ 
9 9
) ]  %[ %
    :KHQ [  \ 6ORSH / 9 
9
    $OVRLQWHUVHFWVERWRSOLQHDQG)HHGOLQH
    'R([WHUQDO%DODQFHVDQG)LQG' %7KHQ 9 9% % %  
     / 9 %  
    $WIHHG / ) / RU / / )    
     9 9 )     
     / 9  
 
     [  \  3ORW0LGGOH2S/LQH




 / /
     \ [  [' 
9 9
    .QRZWKDW \ [ [ ' DQGJLYHVWKURXJKLQWHUDFWLRQ0LGGOHDQG)HHGOLQH
    $OVR / / )    DQG 9 9  WKXV
     / 9    
   F 6HHJUDSK

*UDSKIRU'




/
'  D 3ORWWRSRSOLQHVORSH [ \ ['  6WHSRIIVWDJHVDVVKRZQRQ)LJXUH
9
/ 9
 E 3ORW ERWWRP RS OLQH  VORSH    [ \ [ %    6WHS RII VWDJHV
9 %
UHERLOHULVDQHTXLOVWDJH)LQG\ 
 F 7RWDOVWDJHV UHERLOHU
  2SWLPXP IHHG SODWH   RU  IURP WRS  3ORW IHHG OLQH  *RHV WKURXJK [  \  ]  DQG
LQWHUVHFWLRQRIWZRRSHUDWLQJOLQHV
 T
  VORSH JLYHVT 
 T 


'  7KH HTXLOLEULXP GDWD LV SORWWHG DQG VKRZQ LQ WKH ILJXUH  )URP WKH 6ROXWLRQ WR 'F
T DQG T T   
 D WRWDOUHIOX[1HHGVWDJHVIURPODUJHJUDSK±IURPVPDOOGLDJUDPVKRZQ
 
 E / 9 PLQ  VHHILJXUH
 
/ 9 PLQ
  / ' PLQ  
 / 9 PLQ
/ 9 
F ,Q' / ' DFW 
 / 9 
  / 'DFW 0XOWLSOLHU / ' PLQ

   0XOWLSOLHU  



 G 2SHUDWLQJ OLQHV DUH VDPH DV LQ 3UREOHP '  6WDUW DW ERWWRP RI FROXPQ  5HERLOHU LV DQ
HTXLOLEULXP FRQWDFW  7KHQ XVH ( 09 $% $&   LOOXVWUDWHG IRU WKH ILUVW UHDO VWDJH
6WDJHLVWKHRSWLPXPIHHGVWDJHUHDOVWDJHVSOXVDSDUWLDOUHERLOHUDUHVXIILFLHQW




' 1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ D
 ) ) ' %  )  % ) %  
     )] ) ]  '[ % %[ % )      % 
    6ROYHVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ %  )  
 / / '  
   E  / '  
 9  / '  
/
     / '  9 / '  
'
    6DWXUDWHG/LTXLG)HHG  9 9  
     / / )     / 9  
   F 7RS2S/LQH±1RUPDO \ / 9 [  / 9 [' 

     7KURXJK \ [ [ '  6ORSH  \LQWHUFHSW   

    %RWWRP±1RUPDO \ / 9 [ / 9  [ % WKURXJK\ [ [% 
/ ) 
  $OVRWKURXJKLQWHUVHFWLRQ ) IHHGOLQHDQGPLGGOHRSOLQH )HHGOLQH) VORSH 
9) 



 ' )]
    0LGGOH \ / 9 [ [' RUGRDURXQGERWWRP
9 9
     6ORSH / 9 7KURXJKLQWHUVHFWLRQIHHGOLQH ) DQGWRSRSOLQH
'[ ' )]    
    $OVR [  \  
9 
   G2SW)HHG ) VWDJHIURPERWWRP2SWIHHG ) 6WDJHVWDJHV35PRUHWKDQVXIILFLHQW

*UDSKIRU' 



 / / / ' 
' 2SHUDWLQJ/LQH \ / 9 [  [ '  ZKHUH  
9 9  / ' 
 7KXVRSHUDWLQJOLQHLV\ [
\ \
D (TXLOLEULXPLV [ RU[ 
 \  \
6WDUWZLWK\   [ ' 
\ 
(TXLOLEULXP [  
 \   
  2SHUDWLQJ  \ [      
\ 
  (TXLOLEULXP [  
 \    
  2SHUDWLQJ  \ [       
[
E *HQHUDWHHTXLOLEULXPGDWDIURP \ 
 [
[       
   \        

  3ORWHTXLOLEULXPFXUYHDQGRSHUDWLQJOLQH6HH)LJXUH6ORSH /9 \LQWHUFHSW[ 
\ [  [ ' )LQG [   



' D 6DPHDV'SDUWJT VORSHIHHGOLQH 
  E 7RS\ / 9 [  / 9 [ ' JRHVWKURXJK\ [  [ ' 
/ '
   / 9  #[ \ /9 [ '   
 / '
   )HHGOLQH6ORSH T T  \ [ ]  



  %RWWRP2SOLQH

/ 9" \9 /[ 6\ 06 %[ % "

" #32" \ 06  "L;34)"02)1?M"
N'2E"BOP" % / "
#" K"
/ /
\ [ [ % ""
9 9

  \ [  [ % $OVRJRHVWKURXJKLQWHUVHFWLRQRIIHHGOLQHDQGWRSRSOLQH
  6WDJHV$FFXUDF\DWWRSLVQRWUHDOKLJK([SDQGGLDJUDPIRUPRUHRFFXSDQF\
    $VGUDZQRSW)HHG 7RWDO LVVXIILFLHQW

 
F    / 9 PLQ
6ORSH  
 
/ / 9 
      
' PLQ  / 9 PLQ
 
  $FWXDO/'LVîWKLVYDOXH






 / '
' / 9  VORSH7RSRSOLQHJRHVWKURXJ \ [ ['   
 / '
/ /
 \ [  [ '  # [  \    
9 9
%  )URP6ROQWR'RU
  %RWWRPVORSH / 9  
6  IURPJUDSK 
  )HHG OLQHLV YHUWLFDODW] &DQDOVRSORWWRSDQG IHHGOLQHVDQGWKHQILQGERWWRP IURP
SRLQWV \  [ [ %  LQWHUVHFWWRS IHHG 
  )RUDFFXUDF\±8VHH[SDQGHGSRUWLRQVQHDUGLVWLOODWH QHDUERWWRPV
  )URP7DEOHIURP[ \ 
    'UDZVWUDLJKWOLQHWR[ \ 
    )URP[ \ GUDZVWUDLJKWOLQHWR[ \ 
      RU[ \ 
  
2SWIHHG IURPWRS1HHGHTXLOLEULXPVWDJHV
"

"

"

"



 "









'1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQD 6HH)LJXUH

/  
 E 6HHILJXUH  
9 0,1  
/ / / 9 
   
' 0,1 9 /  / 9 
/ / / ' 
 F  / ' 0,1    
' 9  / ' 
/ / /
  \LQWHUVHFW  \'  7RSRSHUDWLQJOLQH \ [  \' 
9 9 9
      *RHVWKURXJK \ [ \'  
/ /
  %RWWRP \ [  [% 
9 9
  *RHVWKURXJK \ [ [ %  LQWHUVHFWLRQWRSRSHUDWLQJOLQH IHHGOLQH
  )HHG/LQH9HUWLFDOVDWXUDWHGOLTXLGT 7KURXJK \ [ ]  
 3ORW 6WHSRIIVWDJHV2SWLPDOIHHG EHORZ3&3&35PRUHWKDQVXIILFLHQW
 
 G 6ORSHERWWRP6HHILJXUHIRUSDUWVF G/ 9  
 
 
   9 % 9 / 9  
/ 9  



 

*UDSKIRUSUREOHP'



 

'D



 S)>"K<K<"

Q!2)4*16"O<#<""K"@"#"

""""""""""""""""""""""K$0"@"#!#"<""K'*:)"$K"@"R"L+34)">12)4M"

"""""""""""""" !#"@"R"

""""""""""""""""""""""""

K" #"


'E 7ZRDSSURDFKHVWRDQVZHU&RPPRQVHQVHLVDOOPHWKDQROOHDNVRXWDQG [ 0$  
0F&DEH7KLHOHGLDJUDP7KLVLVHQULFKLQJFROXPQZLWK ] \V  ,QWHUVHFWLRQWRSRSOLQHDQG
KRUL]RQWDOIHHGOLQHLVDW [ [ 0E  ZKLFKLVDOVRDSLQFKSRLQW7KXV [ 0G  DOVR
T
'1HZ 3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ 6DWXUDWHG OLTXLG T   IHHG OLQH YHUWLFDO# ]  
T 
/ / / / ' 
7RSRSHUDWLQJOLQH \ [  \ '  6ORSH  
9 9 9  / ' 
  \LQWHUFHSW  / 9 \'     DQG \ [ \' 
  %RWWRPRSHUDWLQJOLQH \ / 9 [ / 9  [ % JRHVWKURXJK \ [ [% 
  $QGJRHVWKURXJKLQWHUDFWLRQIHHGOLQHDQGWRSRSHUDWLQJOLQH6HHJUDSK
  2SWLPXPIHHGLVVWDJHEHORZSDUWLDOFRQGHQVHU3DUWLDOFRQGHQVHU3DUWLDOUHERLOHU
HTXLOLEULXPVWDJHVDUHPRUHWKDQHQRXJKWRREWDLQVHSDUDWLRQ

  
 



 

*UDSKIRUSUREOHP'




// +Y K)
'   T 
) +Y K/
   8VLQJƒ) ƒ&DVUHIHUHQFH7 K )  %WXOEPROH
   +Y K/ $SSUR[ DWIHHGFRQGLWLRQV
        %WXOEPROH 
   )RUDSSUR[WHPSHUDWXUHRIIHHGVWDJHGREXEEOHSWFDOF
    \  .[ .] 
   3LFN7 ƒ&aRIZD\EHWZHHQERLOLQJSWV
    . &  . &   .[      

    . & 7QHZ 7QHZ  & 

    . &  &   . [       &ORVHHQRXJK
    +Y K /  & IHHG
  &  ) 
     +Y &3IHHG /LT     
  1RWH  &3 IHHGOLT LVIURP3URE' 
    +Y    %WXOEPROH
+9 K)  
    T  
+9 K/ 
  1RWH K ) LVIURP3URE'
/ /
' 7RS2S/LQH \ [  [ '  JRHVWKURXJK\ [ ['  
9 9
/ / '  
     
9  / '  
/ 
    [  \  ['
  
9 
    3ORW7RS6WHSRIIVWDJHV)LQG [ 6 a  
  7KHYHUWLFDOOLQHDW [ [6  LVWKHZLWKGUDZDOOLQH
  %RW2S/LQHLQWHUVHFWV7RSDW [ [ 6 
  $OVRNQRZLWLQWHUVHFWVIHHGOLQHDW [ [ % XQNQRZQ
  ([WHUQDO%DODQFHV ) ' % 6 'RQ¶WNQRZ ' % RU[ % 
    )] '[ ' %[ % 6[ 6 
  )HHGHQWHUVDVVDWXUDWHGYDSRU7KXV T  9 )
  %RWWRPVOHDYHVDQHTXLOLEULXPFRQWDFW LWLVVDWXUDWHGOLTXLG / %
  'RIORZEDODQFHV
   9 )  
   9 9  VLQFH6LVUHPRYHGDVVDWXUDWHGOLTXLG



 /
   / 9    ' 9 /    
9
   / / 6    / 9    
   % /  
)] '[ ' 6[ 6     
   [%  
% 
  3ORW2SOLQH
  6WHSRIIVWDJHVLVPRUHWKDQVXIILFLHQW


' 1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ)HHG )  ]   VDWXUDWHGOLTXLG T  T  T  



   )HHG )  ]    YDSRUKHQFHOLTXLG T /)  ) )  )   
T 
      
T  
   3DUWD %RWWRPRSHUDWLQJOLQHJRHVWKURXJKSRLQW \ [ [%  
   0D[ / 9 WRSRLQWLQWHUVHFWLRQIHHG)OLQHDQGHTXLOLEULXPFXUYH
/  
    6ORSH  
9 PD[
 
9 9  
     
% PLQ
/ 9 / 9  

   3DUWE / )  
    / / / )     
    / 9 %DQG 9 %  

     / % % %  


    9 / %    / 9  

    ' 9 9 9)     
/ 
     
9 
   &KHFNRYHUDOOEDODQFH  ) ) ' %     2.
   7RILQG \ ' XVH09&PDVVEDODQFH
    )] ) ]  '\ ' %[ % 
)] ) ]  %[ %      
   RU \'  
' 
/ /
   $FWXDOERWWRPRSOLQH \ [  [% 
9 9
/ 9 % 9 %   
    
9 9 9 %  
   *RHVWKURXJK \ [ [ % 6ORSH   
   QGSRLQW \ [ WKLVZDVDUELWUDULO\IRXQGE\VHWWLQJ\ 
   3ORWERWWRPRSOLQH
/ '\ ' ) ]
   7RS2SOLQH \9 )] /[ '\ '   \ [ 
9 9
   *RHV WKURXJK LQWHUVHFWLRQ IHHG OLQH IRU )  DQG ERW RS OLQH  'RHV 127 JR WKURXJK
\ [ \ ' 
   6LQFH' )SDVVLQJVWUHDPV3RLQW ]  \ ' LVRQRSOLQH




 
)LJXUHIRU'

'  % 7KHQIURPH[WHUQDOEDODQFH) '%PXVWKDYH' ) $FHWRQHEDODQFH
EHFRPHV )] '[ ' RU[ ' ]  
/ /
 7RSUHGLFW [ % QHHGRSHUDWLQJOLQHV7RS \ [  [' 
9 9
/ / 9 
     DQG\ [ ['  
9  / ' 



 %RWWRP / 9  7KXV\ [LVRSHUDWLQJOLQH)URP)LJXUH [ % WR 
 )HHGOLQHFDQEHFDOFXODWHGEXWLVQRWQHHGHG




'  7RXVHHQWKDOS\FRPSRVLWLRQGLDJUDPFKDQJHWRZWIUDFWLRQV%DVLV NJPROH

  'LVWLOODWH  (72+  
     :DWHU  
     7RWDO 
  :HLJKW)UDFWLRQV (W2+ :DWHU 

  )HHG  (W2+  
     :  
     7RWDO 
  :HLJKW)UDFWLRQV (W2+ : 

  %RWWRPV  (W2+  
     :  
     7RWDO 
  :HLJKW)UDFWLRQV (W2+ : 

  &RQGHQVHU(QHUJ\%DODQFHLV 9+ 4F /R K R 'K ' ZKLFKFDQEHVROYHGIRU / R ' 
/R 4F
     
' ' KR +
  )URPFKDUW K ' .FDONJDQG+ .FDONJ 
  1HHG'LQZHLJKWXQLWV&RQYHUWIHHGWRZHLJKWXQLWV
NJPROHV
  (WKDQRO    NJKU 
KU
  :DWHU  NJKU
  7RWDO ) NJKU



 ) ] [%  
  7KHQ '  NJKU
[' [%  
 
  7KHQ /R ' 4 ' KR +    
  
  1RZGRXVXDO0F&DEH7KLHOHDQDO\VLVXVLQJPRODUXQLWV1RWH / R ' LVWKHVDPHLQPDVV
DQGPRODUXQLWV
/ / / / '
  7RS2SHUDWLQJ/LQH \ [  [ ' DQG 
9 9 9  / '
/  / 
    [ \ ['  \ LQW HUFHSW [     
[' 
9  9 
  )HHG/LQH *RHVWKURXJK\ [ ] 
  :HLJKWIUDFWLRQRIIHHG 7KHQ K I NFDONJ+ Y  DQGKN  
+9 K)   T 
  T  6ORSH  
+9 K/   T   
/ /
 %RWWRP2SHUDWLQJ/LQH \ [  [ % *RHVWKURXJK [ \ [ % DQG
9 9
LQWHUVHFWLRQWRSRSHUDWLQJOLQHDQGIHHGOLQH

 )URP)LJXUHQHHGDERXWHTXLOLEULXPFRQWDFWVLQFOXGLQJDUHERLOHU6WDJHDERYHUHERLOHULVWKH
RSWLPXPIHHGVWDJHORFDWLRQ




' )HHG T  VORSHIHHGOLQH 
 )HHG T   VORSH T T    
/ / '  / /
 7RS   \ [  [ ' 
9  / '  9 9
/
 *RHVWKURXJK \ [ [ ' :KHQ[  \  ['  
9
 %RWWRP 6LQFH ) LVVDWXUDWHGYDSRU 9 )  NPROHVKU

-"
) 9 9 )   
%2"8))5"" ) " " "
) " 9 "
/ / )
"
 
  / / 9 9    
    ' 9 /   
    % ) ) '     

  %XW%LVVDWXUDWHGOLTXLG / %  
  &KHFN / / )     2.
  'UDZWRSRSOLQH,QWHUVHFWVZLWK ) IHHGOLQH7KHQGUDZERWWRPRSOLQHZLWKVORSH
    / 9  
  ,QWHUVHFWLRQERWWRPRS TOLQHJLYHV [ %  
)] ) ]  '[ '   
  &KHFN [ % RU[ %  2.
% 
  &KHFN([WHUQDO0%
     ) ) ' %    2.
    )] ) ]  '[ ' %[ % 
            2.
  6HH0F&DEH7KLHOHGLDJUDP2SWLPXPIHHG HTXLOLEULXPVWDJHVPRUHWKDQ
VXIILFLHQW IUDFWLRQ  DEDF 




 
' $URXQGWRSRIFROXPQPDVVEDODQFHVDUH / ' 9 & DQG /[ '\ ' 9\ &[ : 
/ ' &
 6ROYLQJ  \ [ \' [Z 
9 9 9
 )RUSXUHHQWHULQJZDWHU [ :  :LWKVDWXUDWHGOLTXLGHQWHULQJ/ &7KHQIURPRYHUDOO
EDODQFH9 '7KXV/9 &' ôDQG'9 2SHUDWLQJHTXDWLRQEHFRPHV
    \ [   [  
 6ORSH  \ [   \ [   \ '  \ [   1RW\ ' 



'  1RWH/9&'VLQFH&LVVXEFRROHG/HWF DPRXQWFRQGHQVHG7KHHQHUJ\UHTXLUHGWR
KHDWVWUHDP:WRWKHERLOLQJSRLQWPXVWFRPHIURPWKLVFRQGHQVDWLRQ7KDWLV
    + K F K K: & 
K K: &S 7   
    F & & & 
+ K 
    / & F & 
    9 ' F ' & 

    ,QDGGLWLRQ&' ôRU'& 
/ &  
     
9 ' &      
 7KLVFRPSDUHVWR/9 LIHQWHULQJZDWHULVDVDWXUDWHGOLTXLG9HU\OLWWOHHIIHFWVLQFHȜ
LVYHU\ODUJH
/ / ' 
     
9  / ' 
  *RHVWKURXJK \ [ \'  
  :KHQ  [  \  / 9 \'  
/ /
 %RWWRP2S/LQH \ [  [% 
9 9
  7KURXJK \ [ [ '  DQGLQWHUVHFWVWRSRSOLQH#IHHGOLQH
 2SW)HHGLVEHORZSDUWLDOFRQGHQVHU±VHHGLDJUDP1HHGHTXLOVWDJHV3&DQHTXLO
FRQWDFW

 1RWH±&RPPHUFLDOFROXPQVXVXDOO\RSHUDWHPXFKFORVHUWRPLQLPXPUHIOX[UDWLRDQGKDYH
PDQ\PRUHVWDJHV

  / / 9 0LQ
 E / 9 PLQ
   
  ' PLQ  / 9 0LQ

  F 7RWDOUHIOX[VWDJHV3&VXIILFLHQWRU
      HTXLOFRQWDFWV3&     HTFRQWDFWV
DE PP
  ZKHUHIUDFWLRQ  RU
DF PP




 








' D PHWKDQROLVHVVHQWLDOO\SXUH3XUH0H2+ERLOVƒ&
/  IF /R '
  (T  ZKHUH I F &3/ 7%3 7UHIOX[ 
9   I F / R '
 )RUSXUH0H2+ &3/     7 DYHUDJH ƒ&
  &3/  N- JPROH  0H2+  N- PROH 7%3  
/  
  IF       
9   



 / / ' 
 E  RU  PRUH UHIOX[ ZLWK ƒ& FRROLQJ  8VXDOO\
9  / ' 
VXEFRROLQJQRWLPSRUWDQW
' D IHHG T / / ) / / DPWYDSRUL]HG / )  
)  T   
 T / / ) 6ORSH   
  T     
  IHHG6DWXUDWHGOLTXLG±YHUWLFDOIHHGOLQH3ORWERWKIHHGOLQHV7KHRQHZLWKORZHVW
LQWHUVHFWLRQSRLQWZLWKHTXLOLEULXPFXUYHZLOOQRUPDOO\FRQWURO 9 % 
PLQ

9 
  )LQG / 9 7KHQ 9 % 
PD[ PLQ
/ 9 / 9 
PD[

  9 
   / 9 VORSH    
PD[
  % PLQ
 
 E   / 9  9 %  
PLQ

9 % 9 %  
    / 9  VORSH
9 9 % 
/ /
  %RW \ [  [ % *RHVWKURXJK \ [ [ % ZLWKWRWDOUHERLOHU
9 9
/
   \   [  / 9 [ % RU[  / 9  [%  / 9  
9

 [ \      

    ,QWHUVHFWVIHHGOLQHZLWKIHHGILUVW
 0LGGOH RSHUDWLQJ OLQH  'R PDVV EDODQFH DURXQG ERWWRP RI FROXPQ  0DVV EDODQFH LQWHUVHFWV
VWUHDPV /   9 LQFROXPQ)DQG%
   \9 / [ ) ] %[ % 
/ ) ]  %[ %
  \  [
9 9
,QWHUVHFWVERWWRPRSHUDWLQJOLQH IHHGOLQH
    # [  \ ) ]  %[ %   9  6ORSH / 9 
   )RUIHHG T   / /   ) 
  ([WHUQDOEDODQFHV  ) ) ' % DQG )] ) ] '\ ' %[ % 
  )LQG' DQG% PROHVPLQ
  6LQFH 9 %  9 DQG/ 9 %  
  7KHQIURP T   / T  ) /     
  9 / ) %     6ORSH / 9  
  \LQWHUFHSW[  \>     @    
  7RS ,QWHUVHFWV IHHG OLQH IRU  IHHG DQG PLGGOH RS OLQH DQG JRHV WKURXJK
\ [ \ '  



 QT"
K21D)0"" 1:2316" 9+"
DFWXDOFKDQJHOLTXLG
 ( 0/
FKDQJHDWHTXLOLEULXP
" )7<":E1*D)"


)LJXUHIRU'




 / /
'  7RS2S(TQ \ [  [' 
9 9
/ / '  /
     \LQWHUFHSW  ['  \ [ ['  
9  / '  9

/ ) ) /
/ /  T 
  )HHG T    VORSH   \ [ ]  
) )  T 
/ %[ %
  0LGGOH 9 % / 6  9 \ %[ % / [ 6\ V \ V  RU\ [ 
9 9
  'RHVQRWLQWHUVHFWDW \ [ [ % RUDW \  [ [ % 'RHVLQWHUVHFWWRSRSOLQHDWIHHGOLQH
1HHGDQRWKHUSRLQW
/ / / 9 % 9 %  
  %RWWRP \ [  [ %   \ [ [ %  
9 9 9 % 9 % 
  7KHVWHDPLVDQRWKHUIHHGWRWKHFROXPQ6DW¶GYDSRUT TT \ [ ] \V 
  0LGGOH2S/LQHLQWHUVHFWVWKLVVWHDPDWERWWRPRSOLQHVHHILJXUH
  
  7KLVSUREOHPLVDWZRIHHGFROXPQZLWKWKHORZHUIHHGVWHDPLQSXWDWDQRQRSWLPXPIHHG
VWDJH2WLPXPIHHGLVUGDERYHSDUWLDOUHERLOHU1HHGHTXLOLEULXPVWDJHVSOXV35





'  7KLVSUREOHPZDV'LQQGHGLWLRQ
/ /
6WULSSLQJ6HFWLRQ \ [  [ %  \ [ [ %  )HHGOLQHLVYHUWLFDO
9 9



   9 9  
  / 9    
PD[
  % PLQ
/ 9 / 9  
PD[

9 9 9 % 9 %   
       / 9  
% % PLQ
9 9 % 
/
  [%
9   
 2SOLQH \  [  ,QWHUVHFWLRQ2S IHHGOLQHVLV \ ' 
/ 9 
 2YHUDOO%DODQFH ) '%
    )] '\ ' %[ % '  %   ' '    
'    NJPROHVGD\%  1HHGDXVHIRULPSXUHGLVWLOODWH


)LJXUHIRU'




/ / 
'  / '       ['   
9 9 
  6WHSRIIVWDJHVRQWRSRSOLQH)LQG [ 6  3RLQWRQWRSRSOLQHDW [ 6  LVDOVR
RQPLGGOHRSOLQH


!/"

=" !0,"K""@"UG"

VW" -W"
X"@"/"Y"#"Y"K"
X""@"URR" H"
"F""@"<H" )] '[ ' %[ % 6[ 6 "

K96()"0'?3621*)9306$"/"@"GR<UZG,"#"@"=J<[IG"

UR"

"!H""@"<U"


 ,QWRS  / ' DQG9 /' 

 6LQFHVDWXUDWHGOLTXLGZLWKGUDZQ9 9 
    DQG/ /±6 ± 

 0LGGOHRSOLQHVORSH / 9    

 0LGGOH2SOLQH \9 / [ 6[ 6 '[ ' 
/ 6[ 6 '[ '  
     \ [  ZKHQ[  \  
9 9 

 )HHG] YDSRU OLTXLG T 
 )HHGOLQHVORSH T T    




 /R /R ' 
'  D 6XEFRROHG5HIOX[  / /R FDQG9 9 F
9  /R ' 

/ R 9
 /  /R  
  F / R    
 9   /R
9 /R 
  9
/   
  6XEVWLWXWLQJLQYDOXHVZHKDYH  7RSRSOLQH \ [ ['  
/      
  6WHSRIIWZRVWDJHV [  [6 \6 
  



  0L[HGIHHGWRFROXPQ ) 6 )0   )] 6\6 )0 ] 0 
  6ROYLQJIRUPL[HGIHHG ] 0  
  (QHUJ\EDODQFHIRUPL[HGIHHG )K ) 6+6 )0 + )0 
  6LQFH + V K ) VDW¶GYDSRU K )0 +6 K ) VDW¶GYDSRUDQG T )0  KRUL]RQWDO
  ([WHUQDO%DODQFHV) '% )] '[ ' %[ % 6ROYLQJVLPXOWDQHRXVO\'  % 

  /R '  DQG/ /R  VXEFRROHGUHIOX[ 9 / '  

/  
  0LGGOH / / 6     9 9  6ORSH  
9  
  ,QWHUVHFWV7RS2SOLQHDW [ 6 
  3ORW%RWIURP \ [ [ % WRLQWHUVHFWLRQIHHGOLQHDQGPLGGOH
  6WHSRIIVWDJHVVHHILJXUH1HHGHTXLOLEULXPVWDJHV

E 0DVVEDODQFHVIRUPL[HGIHHGLQMHFWLRQ 9 )0 9 
  9 9 )0     9 %   



' :DVSUREOHP'LQQGHGLWLRQ6ROXWLRQ LV WULDO  HUURU 1HHG WR SLFN /9  )LQDO DQVZHU
VKRZQLQILJXUH
/   
      
9  
/ 9 / 
      
 / 9 ' 
  1RWHIHHGVWDJHLVQRWRSWLPXP







)LJXUHIRUSUREOHP'

'  ([WHUQDO%DODQFH) % DQG )] %[ % 7KXV [ % ]  
 
' D / 9 PLQ
 WDQJHQWSLQFK

/ / 9
     
' PLQ  / 9 PLQ

/ '
 E / ' DFW
 / 9  
 / '
  7RSRSHUDWLQJ/LQHWKURXJK \ [ \'  
  %RWWRPWKURXJK \  [ \%  DQGLQWHUVHFWLRQIHHGDQGWRSRSHUDWLQJOLQHV
  )HHG / / ) ) T   VORSH T T   
  2SWLPXPIHHGLVUGIURPERWWRP1HHGUHDOVWDJHVSOXVSDUWLDOFRQGHQVHUVHHILJXUH
F )URPILJXUHVORSHRIERWWRPRSHUDWLQJOLQH / 9  
  6LQFHVDWXUDWHGVWHDPDQG&02YDOLG % 6 / 9 
  $OVRKDYHPDVVEDODQFHV6) %'
    6\6 )] %[ % '\ ' \V  
  6ROYHHTVVLPXOWDQHRXVO\6 OEPROHVKU OEVWHDPKU




 
'  7ULDODQG(UURU)HHG / / ) )   T   6ORSH  

)LJXUHIRU'
( )LQG/9PLQVHHGLDJUDP
  / / 9 PLQ
   / 9 PLQ    
  ' PLQ  / 9 PLQ



 / / / / '
       
' DFW ' PLQ 9 DFW  / '
 ([WHUQDO0%) '% )] '[ ' %[ % 
] [%   NJPRO
 RU(T ' )   % )±' 
[' [%   K

/" / / ' '  "

V" -
-" X" V"@"-"Y"/"@"U=R<U\Z"
VW" -W"
%2"8))5" 9 9 ";ƐĂƚ͛ĚůŝƋƵŝĚͿ"

VƎ " -Ǝ "
;"@" / / )  "
[3 "
9 /
" "

#"

"

/
  7RSRSOLQH\ [  / ) [ ' QRUPDO $W[ \ 
9
/ /
  VWPLGGOH  \ [  [ % ORRNVOLNHXVXDOERWWRP
9 9
      *RHVWKURXJK \ [ [ %  DQGLQWHUVHFWLRQWRS IHHGOLQH
/ 
      6ORSH
 
 9
  $WSXPSDURXQGUHWXUQ 9 9  
       / / 3   / 9    
  $WSXPSDURXQGUHPRYDO 9 9   / / 3 /  
  &KHFNDWERWWRP   / 9 %RU    2.
/ /
  %RWWRP2SOLQH   \ [  [ % 6DPHDVILUVWPLGGOH
9 9
 6WHSRII35VWDJH DERYH [ 3 LVOLTXLGIURPVWDJH [ 3  9HUWLFDOOLQHDW [ 3 LV
ZLWKGUDZDO OLQH IRU SXPSDURXQG DQG LW LV IHHGOLQH IRU UHWXUQ RI SXPSDURXQG  QG PLGGOH RS OLQH
VORSH / 9 LQWHUVHFWV [ 3 ZLWKGUDZDO IHHGOLQHZKHUHERWWRP VWPLGGOHLQWHUVHFW



 / 3 %[ %
 8VLQJ0% \9 3[ 3 %[ % / [  \ [ [3 
9 9 9
3 %[ %   
 :KHQ  \  [ [3   
/ /  
 'UDZQGPLGGOH ±6WHSRIIVWDJH VWDUWLVRSORFIRUIHHG DQG ZKHUHSXPSDURXQGLV
UHWXUQHG1HHG35HTXLOVWDJHV$FWXDOO\DQGDODUJHIUDFWLRQ
"

"

"

"

"

"

" "

"

"

"

"

"

"





/ / T
(  )HHG  T  / / ) T    VORSH 
) T 
 %RWWRPRSOLQH6LQFHVWHDPLVVDWXUDWHGYDSRU 6 9 DQG % / 
 7KXV  6 % / 9  2SHUDWLQJOLQHJRHVWKURXJK \  [ [%  
 0LGGOHRSOLQH 9 % 6LGH / 6RU9 / 6 % 6LGH 
     9 \ %[ %  6LGH [ VLGH / [ 6\6 
/ %[ % 6LGH[ VLGH
 6LQFH  \6 WKLVLV\ [ 
9 9
 6LGHVWUHDPLVUHPRYHGDVDVDWXUDWHGOLTXLGVRT 
 6WHSRIIWZRVWDJHVVHHILJXUHDQGILQG [ VLGH  



 )LQGVORSH 9 6 % / 6LGH 
/ 6LGH % 6LGH %   
   VORSH 
9 6 6% 
 'UDZLQWKHPLGGOHRSHUDWLQJOLQH6WHSRIIVWDJHV7ULDODQGHUURUWRILQG [ '  VHHILJXUH
IRUILQDOUHVXOW


!

(  7KLVFROXPQKDVVHFWLRQV7KHH[DFWVKDSHLVQRWNQRZQDKHDGRIWLPH3ORWWRSRSHUDWLQJOLQH
/ / '  / /
     \ [  [' 
9  / '  9 9
/
     ['    \ [ [ '  
9
 6WHSRIIVWDJHVDQGILQG [ 6  \6 )HHGOLQHIRUWKLVYDSRULVKRUL]RQWDO)HHGOLQHIRU
IHHG WR FROXPQ LV YHUWLFDO DW ]    )URP ILJXUH WKH IHHG LV LQMHFWHG EHORZ WKH OLTXLG
ZLWKGUDZDODQGDERYHYDSRUVWUHDPIURPLQWHUPHGLDWHUHERLOHU&DQQRZFDOFXODWHIORZVLQHDFK
VHFWLRQRIFROXPQV
 2YHUDOO%DODQFH )] '[ ' ) ' [ % 



 ) ] [%  
     '  
[' [% 
/
 )ORZV / '  9 / '  9 9 9 9 6  
'
     / / 6   / 9  
     / / / )   / 9  
     / 9  WKLVLVDFKHFN
 7RSORW)URPVWDJHGUDZOLQHRIVORSH/9)URPLQWHUVHFWLRQRIILUVWLQWHUPHGLDWHRSHUDWLQJ
OLQHDQGIHHGOLQHGUDZOLQHRIVORSH/Ǝ9Ǝ'UDZOLQHIURPLQWHUVHFWLRQRIVHFRQGLQWHUPHGLDWH
RSHUDWLQJOLQHZLWKOLQH \ \ V WR \ [ [ %  &KHFNLIVORSH / 9  2SWLPXP
IHHG LV WK EHORZ FRQGHQVHU ZKLOH YDSRU IURP LQWHUPHGLDWH UHERLOHU LV UHWXUQHG RQ  WK VWDJH
1HHGòVWDJHV
 1RWH6PDOOGLIIHUHQFHVLQVWHSSLQJRIIVWDJHVPD\FKDQJHFROXPQJHRPHWU\
"

" "

"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
( 1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ ([WHUQDO%DODQFH
  D ) ' % )] '[ ' %[ % 
] [%  
    ' )  NPRO K  %  NPRO K 
[' [%  
  E   9 %  9 %  
     / 9 %   / 9  
   $WIHHGDPRXQWFRQGHQVHG & ) 

     / / ) & / ) )    

     9 9 &    



   $WVWDJH / / / 5 DQG9 9  
     / /  
/ 
        
9 
     /5 / /    NJPROHV KRXU 
/ /5 ' / /
  F 7RS2SOLQH \ [ [' [  [' 
9 9 9 9


/" /5 '
\ [ \ [' [ '  VLQ FH9 / /5 '
/ " 9 /
"
Q*()69+)"894"29+"

V" -" 6ORSH / 9   \ [ [ '  "

/5 /
" [ \  ['  "
9



       3ORW
/ 
   0LGGOH \ [  / 9 [ ' 6ORSH \ [ ['  
9 
   %RWWRP \ / 9 [ / 9  [% 
     \ [ [% 
9 % 
     6ORSH / 9 
9 %
   1RZKDYHVRPHZKDWUHGXQGDQWLQIRUPDWLRQ
   &DQSORWERWWRP
   ,QWHUVHFWLRQERWWRPDQGIHHGOLQHVKRXOGDOVREHRQPLGGOH±2UXVHWKLVSWWRILQGPLGGOHRU
ERWWRPRSOLQH

   )URPJUDSK2SW)HHG 
    1HHGVWDJHV35




 Graph for 4.E.4.

/ 9 % 9     
( 1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ 
9 9 9 %   
/ /
   %RW2S/LQH \ [  [ %  \ [ [ % 6ORSH / 9
9 9
' ] [%    
   ([WHUQDO0% ) ' %DQG)] '[ ' %[ %  
) [' [%    
   '  NPRO GD\  %  NPRO GD\  9 9 % %    NPRO GD\
    / 9 %    NPRO GD\ 
   $WIHHGVWDJH 9 9  / / )RU/ / )    
/ 
     
9 



 / /
   0% / [ '\ ' 9 \ ' 9 /  \ [  \ ' 
9 9
   *RHVWKURXJK \ [ \ '  DQGLQWHUVHFWVIHHGDQGERWRSOLQHV
   $WVLGHZLWKGUDZDO  / /  9 6 9 RU9    
   2SOLQHE\LQWHUPHGLDWHFRQGHQVHU / ' 9 6 
/ '\ ' 6[ 6
    / [ '\ ' 9 \ 6[ 6 RU\ [ 
9 9

   )LQGIURPLQWHUVHFWLRQ / 9  RSOLQH# \ \6 SOXV VORSH  RULQWHUVHFWLRQ

WRSRSOLQHDQG [ [ 6 
/ 
   $WVLGHVWUHDPIHHGSRLQW / / 6  9 9  7KXV  
9 
/ /
   7RSRSOLQH \ [  \' &DQGUDZ \LQW HUFHSW     
9 9



 
Graph for 4.E5.
)
 " K'*:)"A9229?0"14)"()4$"+34)" K % K ZDWHU "]"ZUZ^X"
9" /
" " +6  ""
(" + (TXLO  """""L'*":963?*M"
""Q!241"E)12"U[\<J"#23.6A"
K" #"
""^ŝŶĐĞLJуdž͕DtĂƌĞƐĂŵĞ"




 0XVWYDSRUL]HPDWHULDOLQFROXPQ
H[WUD KHDW 0: 
   Y 6 6 6 
0: 
   % / Y 9 6 Y
/ % Y %6 Y6  
    
9 6 Y  Y6  
 ,IVXSHUKHDWQRWLQFOXGHG / 9 %6  ZKLFKLVLQFRUUHFW

)  $Q DSSUR[LPDWH FKHFN LV WR FRPSDUH PRODU ODWHQW KHDWV RI YDSRUL]DWLRQ  'DWD LV DYDLODEOH LQ
3HUU\¶VDQGLQ+LPPHOEODX
 D 6HH([DPSOH
E LVRSURSDQROȜ FDOJ0: Ȝ NFDOPROH:DWHUȜ NFDOPROH
&02LV2.
F &02LVQRWYDOLG $$ NFDO  JPROH  :  
G Q&Ȝ NFDOPROH0: Ȝ NFDOJ
 Q&Ȝ NFDOPROH0: Ȝ NFDOJ
 &RQVWDQWPDVVRYHUIORZLVFORVHUWKDQFRQVWDQWPRODURYHUIORZ
H EHQ]HQHȜ NFDOPROH0: Ȝ NFDOJ
 WROXHQHȜ NFDOPROH0: Ȝ NFDOJ
  &02LVZLWKLQDERXW

* D  $QVZHUVKRXOGEHFORVHEXWQRWLGHQWLFDOWRUHVXOWREWDLQHGLQ([DPSOH

* :DV*LQQGHGLWLRQ8VHG3HQJ5RELQVRQ 4&   %WXKU
  45   %WXKU
  2SWLPXP 1 )  1  7RWDOFRQGHQVHULV
  [ ' DQG[ %  
* 6HHDQVZHUVWRVHOHFWHGSUREOHPVLQEDFNRIERRN

+1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ8VH9%$SURJUDPLQ$SSHQGL[%RI&KDSWHU
[G  [E  )  ] 
/'  T    IHHGVWJ 
SDUWLDOUHERLOHU WRWDOFRQGHQVHU (WKDQROZDWHU 3URE+
9/(WK WK WK UG QG VW FRQVWDQW 
       
\HTDW[LQW  \LQW  [LQW   
VWDJH [ \     
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       



       
       

+1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ7KH9%$SURJUDPLVLQ$SSHQGL[%RI&KDSWHU:LWK/' 
WKHUHVXOWLV
[G  [E  )  ] 
/'  T    IHHGVWJ 
SDUWLDOUHERLOHU WRWDOFRQGHQVHU (WKDQROZDWHU 3URE+
9/(WK WK WK UG QG VW FRQVWDQW 
       
\HTDW[LQW  \LQW  [LQW   
VWDJH [ \     
  5HIOX[UDWHWRRORZ5HIOX[UDWHWRRORZ  

:LWK/' WKHUHVXOWLVJLYHQEHORZ:LWKIHHGVWDJHVEHORZWKHIHHGVWDJHZDVWRRORZ
[G  [E  )  ] 
/'  T    IHHGVWJ 
SDUWLDOUHERLOHU WRWDOFRQGHQVHU (WKDQROZDWHU 3URE+
9/(WK WK WK UG QG VW FRQVWDQW 
       
\HTDW[LQW  \LQW  [LQW   
VWDJH [ \     
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       



       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       



       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       

+1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ7KH6SUHDGVKHHWLV
[G  [E  )  ] 
0XOWLSOLHU  T    IHHGVWJ 
SDUWLDOUHERLOHU WRWDOFRQGHQVHU (WKDQROZDWHU 3UREOHP+
9/(WK WK WK UG QG VW FRQVWDQW 
       
/'PLQ  /9PLQ  /'  /9 
VWDJH [ \     
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
%HFDXVHWKHPXOWLSOLHULVFORVHWRWKLVDQVZHULVYHU\VHQVLWLYHWRWKHGDWDILWXVHG
2QHVROXWLRQWRWKHFRGLQJLVWKHIROORZLQJ9%$SURJUDP

2SWLRQ([SOLFLW



6XE0F&DEH7KLHOH

)LQGPLQLPXPUHIOX[UDWLRDVVXPLQJLWRFFXUVDWIHHGSODWH7KHQ

/'DFWXDO /'PLQWLPHV0XOWLSOLHU6WHSVRIIVWDJHVIURPWKHERWWRPXS

$VVXPHVWKDWWKHIHHGVWDJHLVVSHFLILHG
6KHHWV6KHHW6HOHFW
5DQJH$*&OHDU
'LPLIHHGVWDJH$V,QWHJHU
'LP'%[G[E)]T/RYHU'/RYHU9[\[LQW\LQW\HT$V6LQJOH
'LPDDDDDDD/9/EDURYHU9EDU/RYHU'PLQ$V6LQJOH
'LP/RYHU9PLQ/RYHU9GHOWD0XOWLSOLHU$V6LQJOH

,QSXWYDOXHVIURPVSUHDGVKHHW
[G &HOOV9DOXH
[E &HOOV9DOXH
) &HOOV9DOXH
] &HOOV9DOXH
0XOWLSOLHU &HOOV9DOXH
T &HOOV9DOXH
IHHGVWDJH &HOOV9DOXH

)LWRIHTXLOLEULXPGDWDWRWKRUGHUSRO\QRPLDOWRILQG\DLVPXOWLSOLHG

E\[WRWKHWKSRZHU
D &HOOV9DOXH
D &HOOV9DOXH
D &HOOV9DOXH
D &HOOV9DOXH
D &HOOV9DOXH
D &HOOV9DOXH
D &HOOV9DOXH

&DOFXODWHLQWHUVHFWLRQSRLQWRIWZRRSHUDWLQJOLQHVDQGXVHWKLVWRILQG

PLQLPXP/'DQG/9,QLWLDOL]H
/RYHU9 
/RYHU9GHOWD 
'R
/RYHU9 /RYHU9/RYHU9GHOWD
[LQW T /RYHU9 [G]T /RYHU9T
[ [LQW
\LQW /RYHU9 [LQW/RYHU9 [G

(TXLOLEULXP\DWYDOXHRI[LQWHUVHFWLRQ:KHQ\LQW \HTKDYHPLQLPXP/9DQG/'
\HT D [AD [AD [AD [AD [AD [D
/RRS:KLOH\LQW\HT

3ULQWLQWHUVHFWLRQDQGHTXLOLEULXPYDOXHV
/RYHU9PLQ /RYHU9/RYHU9GHOWD
/RYHU'PLQ /RYHU9PLQ/RYHU9PLQ
/RYHU' 0XOWLSOLHU /RYHU'PLQ
/RYHU9 /RYHU'/RYHU'
&HOOV9DOXH /RYHU'PLQ
&HOOV9DOXH /RYHU9PLQ
&HOOV9DOXH /RYHU'
&HOOV9DOXH /RYHU9

&DOFXODWHIORZUDWHVDQGUDWLRV
' ][E[G[E )
/ /RYHU' '



9 /'
/EDURYHU9EDU /RYHU9T )9T )9

6WHSRIIVWDJHVIURPERWWRPXS)LUVWVWDJHLVSDUWLDOUHERLOHU,QLWLDOL]H
[ [E
L 

/RRSLQVWLSSLQJVHFWLRQVWHSSLQJRIIVWDJHVZLWKHTXLOLEULXPDQGRSHUDWLQJHTV
'R:KLOHLIHHGVWDJH
\ D [AD [AD [AD [AD [AD [D
&HOOVL9DOXH L
&HOOVL9DOXH [
&HOOVL9DOXH \
L L
[ \/EDURYHU9EDU/EDURYHU9EDU [E/EDURYHU9EDU
/RRS

&DOFXODWLRQVLQHQULFKLQJVHFWLRQFRQWLQXHVWR/RRS:KLOH\[G
'R:KLOH\[G
\ D [AD [AD [AD [AD [AD [D
&HOOVL9DOXH L
&HOOVL9DOXH [
&HOOVL9DOXH \
L L
[ \/RYHU9/RYHU9 [G/RYHU9
,I[7KHQ
&HOOVL9DOXH )HHGVWDJHWRRORZ
([LW'R
(QG,I
,IL!7KHQ
&HOOVL9DOXH 7RRPDQ\VWDJHV
([LW'R
(QG,I
/RRS
(QG6XE
"



 63(UG(G6ROXWLRQ0DQXDO&KDSWHU

1HZ3UREOHPVDQGQHZVROXWLRQVDUHOLVWHGDVQHZLPPHGLDWHO\DIWHUWKHVROXWLRQQXPEHU7KHVHQHZ
SUREOHPVDUH$&''''+WR+3UREOHPVDQGVROXWLRQVIURPWKHILUVW
HGLWLRQWKDWZHUHQRWLQWKHVHFRQGHGLWLRQDUH''''(

$


 (WKDQHLVOHVVYRODWLOHWKDQPHWKDQHVRLWGHFUHDVHVWRZDUGGLVWLOODWH$WERWWRPVLWLVPRUH
YRODWLOH WKDQ SURSDQH DQG EXWDQH VR PXVW GHFUHDVH WRZDUGV ERWWRPV  7KXV HWKDQH
FRQFHQWUDWHVZLWKLQFROXPQ

$ FFDVDWXUDWHGOLTXLGIHHGF%

$ 3XUH /. FDQQRW EH ZLWKGUDZQ EHFDXVH /1. LV SUHVHQW  3XUH /1. FDQ EH UHPRYHG DW
GLVWLOODWHLIDOO/.LVUHPRYHGLQVLGHVWUHDP+RZHYHUUHFRYHU\RI/1.ZLOOEH

$ ,I ] +1. )  IUDF UHF +. LQ ERW ] +.  ) WKHQ WKHUH LV PRUH +1. LQ ERWWRPV DQG FXUYHV
FURVV

$1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQDDEGFEGFHE

&1HZ3UREOHPLQ UG(GLWLRQ6WDUWZLWKHTXLOLEULXPHTXDWLRQ\LM .LM[LMDQGPXOWLSO\ULJKWKDQG
VLGH E\ .UHIM .UHIM 2QH REWDLQV \LM  ĮLUHIM .UHIM[LM  7KHQ   Ȉ \  Ȉ Į LUHIM .UHIM[LM  6LQFH .UHIM LV
FRQVWDQWEULQJLWRXWVLGHWKHVXPPDWLRQDQGVROYHIRU.UHIM ȈĮLUHIM[LM7KLVLV(T




'1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ

"#! '[ 0 G      

'[ %G 
'[ (G       !
'[ 3 G       

' [ LG ' NJK

$#! "%%&'(! )*! +,(-."/01! "/2! /3$&-"/01#! 20! /0-! 24%-54$&-(! +"11!
'(-."/01!4/!-06!"/2!"11!$&-"/01!4/!$0--0'#7!

 ZWIUDFLQGLVWLOODWH0 ( 3 %  

ZWIUDF
[ LE
%[ 0 % 

     %[ %%       

%[ ( %      

%[ 3 %      
% [ LE %  NJ KU
       &KHFN%' )2.

' 1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ \   \   \   3 PP+J 

   5DRXOW¶V/DZ  \L 3 93L [ L 
%
   $QWRLQH¶V(TQ ORJ 93 $ 
7 &
   'HZ3RLQWFRQGLWLRQLV [L 

\L 3
    [L IURP5DRXOW¶V/DZ
93L



 %
    93L  $ IURP$QWRLQH¶V(TQ
7 &
   &RPELQHZLWK'HZ3RLQWFRQGLWLRQ
\3 \3 \3
    % % %

  
$ $ $
7 & 7 & 7 &
  

     
      

  
7  7  7 
  

   8VLQJ*RDO6HHNLQ([FHO7 ž&

' $VVXPHWKDWHWKDQROLV+.7KHQDVVXPHWKDW+1.¶VDUHWRWDOO\LQWKHERWWRPV
    [ 0GLVW  [ (GLVW  
       '[ 0' 
 
    ' DQG% ) '  
[ 0' 
  %RWWRPV0H2+ 

    [ 0ERW  

   
   [ Q SURSDQROERW  

   
   [ Q EXWDQROERW  

   [ (W2+ERW  [ 0H2+ERW [ Q SERW [ QEXWERW  

' D ) ] & '[ &GLVW  DQG)] & %[ &ERW  
  ) ] &ERW
%[ &ERW  DQG)] & '] &GLVW  
  $VVXPHDOOKHSWDQHLQERWWRPV
   )] & %[ ERW&  [ GLVW&  
  7DNH(TV   '[ &G 
    ' [ &G 
     ' [ &GLVW 
   '[ OGLVW '  NJPROHVKU
   % )±' ± 
 E  [ &GLVW  
  
   [ &G  

   [ &G    



   
   [ &ERW  

  
   [ &ERW  

   [ &ERW     
 F  / /''  
   9 /'  
   $WIHHGVWDJH /  /)  
   9 9) ± 

' $VVXPHDOOPHWKDQRODQGHWKDQROLQGLVWLOODWH
   '[ 0H2+GLVW      
   '[ (W2+GLVW      
  
   '[ SURSGLVW       
   '[ EX WDQ ROGLV         
     
     '  
   % ) ) '  
 &KHFN  %[ 3U RSERW        
    %[ EXWGLVW       
      
    &KHFN 
 0ROHIUDFWLRQV

    [ 0 ERW [ ( ERW  [ SURSERW  

    [ EXWERW  [ SURSERW  
   
'[ 0H2+ GLVW 
    [ 0 GLVW  
' 

    [ (GLVW  


    [ SGLVW  

    [ %XWGLVW    
      
    &KHFN 2.

'7KLVLV'LQVWHG




 
 
 

' $VVXPHUHFRYHU\ &   SURS\OHQHLQGLVWLOODWH
 $VVXPHUHFRYHU\SHQWDQH KH[DQHLQERWWRPV

&RPS 'LVWLOODWH NJK [' 
&   
3URS\OHQH   
Q& >@  
 Q& >@  
& &   
  '   

%RWWRPVIORZUDWH  ) ) '    NJK
    
 [ %&  [ %SURS\OHQH  [ %&  

    
     [ %&  

     
  [ %&  [ %&  
 

' 'LQVWHGLWLRQ$VVXPHDOOEHQ]HQHLVLQWKHGLVWLOODWH



 



 



'1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ



 
UG
'1HZ3UREOHPLQ (GLWLRQ$WWKHEXEEOHSRLQW \L  

   [ & [ & S PP+J  \ & \ & .  [ & .  [ &  



 93& 93&
   RU [ & [ &   93& [ & 93& [ & 3WRW 
3WRW 3WRW
 
 
7  7 
         

7ž&  &WHUP[ &WHUP[ 680
  î  î  
 )LQDOUHVXOWLV   
  î  î  

':DVSUREOHP'LQQGHGLWLRQ63(6LQFH [ L NQRZQZDQW \L  .L S %3 [ L 
. UHI S ROG
 )LQGQHZSUHVVXUHIURP . UHI S QHZ 
.L[L
 8VHHWKDQHRUQSHQWDQHDVUHIHUHQFH
  )LUVWJXHVV7U\ . &  S N3D 
  . 1& . &  
  .L [L        SWRRORZ

  . UHS S QHZ a  S QHZ N3D  . 1& . &  

  .L [L        

  . & S QHZ  S QHZ  N3D . Q& . &  

   . L [ L        
 $QVZHUZLWKLQDFFXUDF\'H3ULHVWHU&KDUW N3D

':DVSUREOHP'LQQGHGLWLRQ63(D+LJKHVW%37HPSLVSXUHQRFWDQH . &  7  & 
 E /RZHVW%37HPSLVSXUHQKH[DQH . &  7  & 

':DVSUREOHP'LQQGHGLWLRQ63(/HW QEXWDQH QSHQWDQHDQG QKH[DQHS N3D
 %XEEOH3RLQW)LUVWJXHVV . DW7   .  DW7   .  DW7   
  7ILUVW ]7        
  .  .   .   .[         
 &KRRVHDVUHI(TLV .  7QHZ    
  7QHZ  &.  .   DQG . L [ L  
 (TLV .  7QHZ    
  7QHZ .  .  DQG . [ 2.7%3  &  
L L

(7KLVLV(LQVWHGLWLRQ



 



 



 
+ 1HZ 3UREOHP LQ UG (GLWLRQ   6DPH SURJUDP DV + H[FHSW GR QRW OLVW \ YDOXHV DV GLVWLOODWH
'LIIHUHQWLQSXWLQVSUHDGVKHHW±VHHEHORZ
7HUQDU\'LVWLOODWLRQ&RQVWDQWUHODWLYHYRODWLOLW\6WHSRIIVWDJHVIURPERWWRPXS8VHZKROHVWDJHV
6\VWHPKDV$ /.% +.DQG& +1. &+
DOSKD 
$OSKD&  
$%  DOSKD%%  %  IHHGVWDJH 
]$  ]%  ]&  HSVLORQYDOXHVIRU 
1ORRS
)  T  /'  FRQYHUJHQFH 
GI+1.IUDF
IUDFUHF%LQGLVW  JXHVVIUDFUHF&ERW  UHFRYHU\ 
IUDFUHF$LQGLVW 
'  % 
 /9  /EDU9EDU
 
0DVVEDODQFH
[$GLVW  [%GLVW  [&GLVW ( YDOXHV
0DVVEDODQFH 
[$ERW  [%ERW  [&ERW  YDOXHV



 6WDJHE\VWDJHFDOFXODWLRQV
L [$ \$ 
[% 
\% 
[& 
\& 
1RWH[ 
       [ERW
      
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
      ( 
     ( ( 
     ( ( 
     ( ( 

       

&DOFIUDFUHFRYHU\&LQERWWRPV
    M
   
+1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ7KHVSUHDGVKHHWLV
 
7HUQDU\'LVWLOODWLRQZLWK&RQVWDQWUHODWLYHYRODWLOLW\6WHSRIIVWDJHVIURPWRSGRZQ 
6\VWHPKDV$ /1.% /.DQG& +.   
DOSKD$%  DOSKD%%  $OSKD&% IHHGVWDJH 
]$  ]%  ]&  HSVLORQYDOXHVIRU 
)  T  /'  1ORRSFRQYHUJHQFH 
IUDFUHF%LQGLVW  IUDFUHF&LQERW  GI/1.IUDFUHFRYHU\ 
*XHVVIUDFUHF$LQGLVW     
'  %  /9 /EDU9EDU 
[$GLVW  [%GLVW  [&GLVW 0DVVEDODQFHYDOXHV 
[$ERW  [%ERW  [&ERW  0DVVEDODQFHYDOXHV 
6WDJHE\VWDJHFDOFXODWLRQV     
L [$ \$ [% \% [& \& 1RWH\ 
      [GLVW
      
      
      
      
      
      
      
       
      
       
       
&DOFIUDFUHFRYHU\$LQGLVWLOODWH  M  



+1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ/'PLQ E\WULDODQGHUURUXVLQJVSUHDGVKHHWLQ7DEOH$


+1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ
7HUQDU\'LVWLOODWLRQZLWK&RQVWDQWUHODWLYHYRODWLOLW\6WHSRIIVWDJHVIURPWRSGRZQ 
6\VWHPKDV$ /.% VDQGZLFKDQG& +.  *H 
DOSKD$%  DOSKD%%  $OSKD&% IHHGVWDJH 
]$  ]%  ]&  HSVLORQYDOXHVIRU (
)  T  /'  1ORRSFRQYHUJHQFH 
IUDFUHF%LQGLVW  IUDFUHF&LQERW  GI/1.IUDFUHFRYHU\ 
*XHVVIUDFUHF$LQGLVW     
' % /9 /EDU9EDU 
[$GLVW [%GLVW [&GLVW 0DVVEDODQFHYDOXHV 
[$ERW [%ERW [&ERW  0DVVEDODQFHYDOXHV 
6WDJHE\VWDJHFDOFXODWLRQV     
L [$ \$ [% \% [& \& 1RWH\ 
    [GLVW
    
    
    
     
    
    
    
    
     
    
     
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
     
0DVVEDODQFHIUDFWLRQVWDJH$%&FDOFXODWHGDWERWWRPHUURU% 
    ( 
&DOFIUDFUHFRYHU\$LQGLVWLOODWH  M  


3DUWG)UDFWLRQDOUHFRYHU\RI%LQGLVWLOODWHLV1RWHWKDW%JRHVWKURXJKDPD[LPXPRIFORVHWR
RQVWDJHVDQG
7HUQDU\'LVWLOODWLRQZLWK&RQVWDQWUHODWLYHYRODWLOLW\6WHSRIIVWDJHVIURPWRSGRZQ 
6\VWHPKDV$ /.% WUDFHVDQGZLFKDQG& +.  *H3DUWG 
DOSKD$%  DOSKD%%  $OSKD&% IHHGVWDJH 



]$  ]%  ]&  HSVLORQYDOXHVIRU (
)  T  /'  1ORRSFRQYHUJHQFH 
IUDFUHF%LQGLVW  IUDFUHF&LQERW  GI/1.IUDFUHFRYHU\ 
*XHVVIUDFUHF$LQGLVW     
' % /9  /EDU9EDU 
[$GLVW  [%GLVW  [&GLVW  0DVVEDODQFHYDOXHV 
[$ERW  [%ERW [&ERW 0DVVEDODQFHYDOXHV 
6WDJHE\VWDJHFDOFXODWLRQV     
L [$ \$ [% \% [& \& 1RWH\ 
    [GLVW
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
     
    
    
    
    
    
     
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
     
    
     
    
     
    
0DVVEDODQFHIUDFWLRQVWDJH$%&FDOFXODWHGDWERWWRPHUURU% 
    ( 
&DOFIUDFUHFRYHU\$LQGLVWLOODWH  M  

+1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ
7HUQDU\ 'LVWLOODWLRQ ZLWK %XEEOH SRLQW &DOF 6WHS RII VWDJHV IURP ERWWRP
XS  
6\VWHPKDV$ /.% +.DQG& +1.    
      IHHGVWDJH  
]$  ]%  ]&  HSVLORQ ( 
)  T  /'  1ORRS  
IUDFUHF%LQERW  JXHVVIUDFUHF&ERW  GI  



IUDFUHF$LQGLVW   7UHEJXHVV  SSVLD  
.FRQVW D7 D7 D7 DS DS DS  
Q% $        
Q3HQ %        
Q+H[ &        
        
'  %  /9 /EDU9EDU  
[$GLVW  [%GLVW  [&GLVW (   
[$ERW  [%ERW  [&ERW   
        
VWDJH [$ \$ [% \% [& \& 7 .%
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
     (  
     ( (  
     ( (  
        
'LVWLOODWHPROHIUDFV \YDOXHV   (  
&DOFIUDFUHFRYHU\&LQERWWRPV   M   

2SWLRQ([SOLFLW
6XE7HUQDU\BERWWRPBXSB%3

7HUQDU\GLVWLOODWLRQZLWKFRQVWDQWDOSKD)UDFUHFRYHULHVRI/.DQG+.JLYHQ

7KHUHLVD+1.SUHVHQWDQGLWVIUDFUHFLQERWWRPVLVJXHVVHG
6KHHWV6KHHW6HOHFW
5DQJH$,&OHDU
'LPLMNIHHGVWDJH1$V,QWHJHU
'LP$D7$D7$DS%D7%D7%DS&D7&D7&DS$V'RXEOH
'LP)IUDF%ERWIUDF&ERWT/RYHU'/RYHU9$V'RXEOH
'LP/EDURYHU9EDU'%/9/EDU9EDU(TVXPIUDF$GLVW$V'RXEOH
'LP[$[%[&\$\%\&]$]%]&[$ERW[%ERW[&ERW$V'RXEOH
'LP'[$'[%'[&%[$%[%%[&[$GLVW[%GLVW[&GLVW$V'RXEOH
'LPIUDF&ERWFDOFGLIIHUHQFHHSVLORQGI$V'RXEOH
'LP7S7LQLW.$.%.&VXP$V'RXEOH

,QSXWGDWD
$D7 &HOOV9DOXH
$D7 &HOOV9DOXH
$DS &HOOV9DOXH
%D7 &HOOV9DOXH
%D7 &HOOV9DOXH
%DS &HOOV9DOXH
&D7 &HOOV9DOXH
&D7 &HOOV9DOXH
&DS &HOOV9DOXH
IHHGVWDJH &HOOV9DOXH
) &HOOV9DOXH



T &HOOV9DOXH
/RYHU' &HOOV9DOXH
]$ &HOOV9DOXH
]% &HOOV9DOXH
]& &HOOV9DOXH
IUDF%ERW &HOOV9DOXH
IUDF&ERW &HOOV9DOXH
IUDF$GLVW &HOOV9DOXH
HSVLORQ &HOOV9DOXH
1 &HOOV9DOXH
GI &HOOV9DOXH
S &HOOV9DOXH
7LQLW &HOOV9DOXH

7KH)RUORRSUHPDLQGHURISURJUDPLVWRREWDLQFRQYHUJHQFHRIJXHVVRI

IUDFWLRQDOUHFRYHU\RI$LQGLVWLOODWH
)RUM 7R1

&DOFXODWHFRPSRVLWLRQVDQGIORZUDWHV
'[$ ) ]$ IUDF$GLVW
'[% ) ]% IUDF%ERW
'[& ) ]& IUDF&ERW
%[$ ) ]$ IUDF$GLVW
%[% ) ]% IUDF%ERW
%[& ) ]& IUDF&ERW
' '[$'[%'[&
% %[$%[%%[&
[$GLVW '[$'
[%GLVW '[%'
[&GLVW '[&'
[$ERW %[$%
[%ERW %[%%
[&ERW %[&%
/ /RYHU' '
9 /'
/RYHU9 /9
/EDU /T )
9EDU /EDU%
/EDURYHU9EDU /EDU9EDU

3ULQWYDOXHVRIIORZUDWHVDQGPROHIUDFWLRQV
&HOOV '
&HOOV %
&HOOV /RYHU9
&HOOV /EDURYHU9EDU
&HOOV [$GLVW
&HOOV [%GLVW
&HOOV [&GLVW
&HOOV [$ERW
&HOOV [%ERW
&HOOV [&ERW

LQLWLDOL]HUHERLOHU DQGVWDUWORRSV

L 
[$ [$ERW



[% [%ERW
[& [&ERW
7 7LQLW

&DOFXODWLRQVLQVWULSSLQJVHFWLRQHTXLOLEULXPWKHQRSHUDWLQJ
'R:KLOHLIHHGVWDJH

%XEEOHSRLQWFDOFXODWRQ
)RUN 7R
.% 
.$ ([S$D77 7$D7$DS /RJS
.% ([S%D77 7%D7%DS /RJS
.& ([S&D77 7&D7&DS /RJS
\$ .$ [$
\% .% [%
\& .& [&
VXP \$\%\&
.% .%VXP
7 6TU%D7/RJ.%%D7%DS /RJS
1H[WN

3ULQWYDOXHV
&HOOVL9DOXH L
&HOOVL9DOXH [$
&HOOVL9DOXH \$
&HOOVL9DOXH [%
&HOOVL9DOXH \%
&HOOVL9DOXH [&
&HOOVL9DOXH \&
&HOOVL9DOXH 7
&HOOVL9DOXH .%

%RWWRPRSHUDWLQJOLQH
L L
[$ \$/EDURYHU9EDU/EDURYHU9EDU [$ERW
[% \%/EDURYHU9EDU/EDURYHU9EDU [%ERW
[& \&/EDURYHU9EDU/EDURYHU9EDU [&ERW
/RRS

&DOFXODWLRQVLQHQULFKLQJVHFWLRQ
'R
)RUN 7R

%XEEOHSRLQWFDOFXODWLRQ
.$ ([S$D77 7$D7$DS /RJS
.% ([S%D77 7%D7%DS /RJS
.& ([S&D77 7&D7&DS /RJS
\$ .$ [$
\% .% [%
\& .& [&
VXP \$\%\&
.% .%VXP
7 6TU%D7/RJ.%%D7%DS /RJS
1H[WN

3ULQWYDOXHV
&HOOVL9DOXH L
&HOOVL9DOXH [$



&HOOVL9DOXH \$
&HOOVL9DOXH [%
&HOOVL9DOXH \%
&HOOVL9DOXH [&
&HOOVL9DOXH \&
&HOOVL9DOXH 7
&HOOVL9DOXH .%

7HVWIRUIHHGVWDJHWRRORZ
,I[$2U[%2U[&7KHQ
&HOOVL )HHGVWDJHWRRORZ
([LW)RU
(QG,I
L L

7HVWIRUWRRPDQ\VWDJHVZKLFKPD\PHDQUHIOX[UDWHLVWRRORZ
,IL!7KHQ
&HOOVL9DOXH 7RRPDQ\VWDJHV
([LW)RU
(QG,I

7RSRSHUDWLQJOLQH
[$ \$/RYHU9/RYHU9 [$GLVW
[% \%/RYHU9/RYHU9 [%GLVW
[& \&/RYHU9/RYHU9 [&GLVW

7HVWIRUFDOFXODWLRQVEHLQJGRQH
/RRS:KLOH\$[$GLVW

)UDFWLRQDOUHFRYHU\RI&EDVHGRQVWDJHE\VWDJHFDOFXODWLRQ
IUDF&ERWFDOF \& ') ]&
GLIIHUHQFH IUDF&ERWIUDF&ERWFDOF
,I$EVGLIIHUHQFHHSVLORQ7KHQ([LW)RU
IUDF&ERW IUDF&ERWGI IUDF&ERWFDOFIUDF&ERW

7HVWLIKDYHFRQYHUJHQFHRIIUDFWLRQDOUHFRYHU\RI&
1H[WM
&HOOVL9DOXH &DOFIUDFUHFRYHU\&LQERWWRPV
&HOOVL9DOXH IUDF&ERW
&HOOVL9DOXH M
&HOOVL9DOXH M
&HOOVL9DOXH 'LVWLOODWHPROHIUDFV \YDOXHV
&HOOVL9DOXH \$
&HOOVL9DOXH \%
&HOOVL9DOXH \&
(QG6XE




 &KDSWHU

1HZ3UREOHPVDQGQHZVROXWLRQVDUHOLVWHGDVQHZLPPHGLDWHO\DIWHUWKHVROXWLRQQXPEHU7KHVHQHZ
SUREOHPVDUH$$''**

$1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ7ULDODQGHUURU7U\DIHHGVWDJHDQGGHWHUPLQHWKHGLVWLOODWHDQG
ERWWRPVPROHIUDFWLRQVRIWKHNH\FRPSRQHQWV5HSHDWIRUDGGLWLRQDOIHHGVWDJHV7KHIHHGVWDJH
WKDWSURGXFHVWKHEHVWVHSDUDWLRQLVWKHRSWLPXPIHHGVWDJHIRUWKLVYDOXHRI1

$1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ7ULDODQGHUURU3LFNDQ1WKDW\RXWKLQNLVFORVHDV\VWHPDWLF
PHWKRGWRGRWKLVLVGHVFULEHGLQ&KDSWHU)LQGWKHRSWLPXPIHHGVWDJH,I\RXQHHGPRUH
VHSDUDWLRQWRPHHWVSHFLILFDWLRQVLQFUHDVH1DQGLI\RXH[FHHGVSHFLILFDWLRQVWU\GHFUHDVLQJ1
)RUDQLQLWLDOHVWLPDWHRIWKHRSWLPXPIHHGORFDWLRQIRUWKHQHZ1DVVXPHWKDWWKHUDWLR
2SWLPXPIHHGVWDJHWRWDOQXPEHURIVWDJHVLVFRQVWDQW&RQWLQXHSURFHVVXQWLOVSHFLILFDWLRQV
DUHPHWRUVOLJKWO\H[FHHGHG

& D :LWKDVLGHVWUHDPPDVVEDODQFHLV
  9M \ M / M [ M 6[ 6 9M   \ M  / M [ M  )M] M 
  ZKHUH / M LVWKHIORZLQWRWKHVWDJHEHORZ / M / M 6 [ 6 [ M 6LQFH / M [ M 6[ 6 / M [ M  (TV
WRDUHXQFKDQJHG1RWHWKDWWKH / M  LQSXWLQWRWKHPDWUL[ZLOOEHFKDQJHG
 E 1RZ / MK M / MK M 6 MK M LQWKH(%DQG
M M M  M 
  /M 9M  ' )N 6 N  / M  9M ' )N 6N 
N  N  N  N 
  6XEVWLWXWLQJLQWR(%ZHILQG
M M 
'(M )M K )M 4M ' KM  KM ). K M ). K M 
N  N 
  
M  M
 6. K M  6. K M
N  N 

& 3DUWLDOFRQGHQVHUPDVVEDODQFHVLV
  '\ /[ 9 \  )]  
 7KLVEHFRPHV
'. 9
    .   )]  
/ /
'. .  9
 7KXV %   &  DQG' )]  
/ /
 1RWHWKDWRQO\ % GLIIHUV

' )RUQSHQWDQHIURP([DPSOH7 ƒ& . &  / / NPROHKU 
   /  /   % 9 9 9  
 0DWUL[ M WRWDOFRQGHQVHU

!"#$
$
 .  9   ' 
  &   %    ' 
/  / 
.  9  
  M  &   
/ 
9 . 
  %   $   '  
/
.  9  
  M  &   
/ 
9 . 
  %   $   '  )] &    
/
 9 . 
  M  5HERLOHU  %   $   '  
/
    & 
    & 

    & 
    & 

 9DOXHVIRU & WR & DUHLQ([DPSOH

' S DWP ] &  ] &  ] &  ] &  
 $VVDW¶GOLTXLG IRUESFDOFXODWH ] L [ L :DQW \L  
 3LFN &  DVUHIDWP  N3D DWP  N3D
VW
  *XHVV:DQW . &  . &  'H3ULHVWHU&KDUW
 7U\7 ƒ& . &  . &  . &  . &  
  \L          
. &  
 1HHGORZHU7 . & 7QHZ  
.L[L 
   7QHZ   . &  . &  . &  
   \L      2.
 3URSDQH0DWUL[$QDO\VLV . &  % ) '    / 
   ' )] F  ' ' ' ' ' 
   9 9 9 9 9 / '  
/
   / '  / / 
'
   / /  )  / / 
 7RWDO&RQGHQVHU

!"%$
$
   %  ' /  & .  9 /      
9 .  9 .   
 6WDJH $  %  &   
/ / 
9 .  9 .   
 6WDJH $   %  &   
/ / 
9 .  9 . 
 6WDJH $  %   &   
/ /
9 .  9 .   
 6WDJH $  %  &   
/ / 
9 . 
 5HERLOHU6WDJH $   %   
/
 0DVVEDODQFHPDWUL[
     
     
 
     
   
     
     
 
     


'1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQS DWP N3D
] &  ] &  ] &  ] &  
 $VVDW¶GOLTXLG IRUESFDOFXODWLRQDW ] L [ L &DOFXODWLRQLVVDPHDVLQ'WRREWDLQ7
5HVXOWLV 7ES   . &  . & . &  . &  
 QEXWDQH0DWUL[$QDO\VLV . &  % ) '    / 
  ' )] F  ' ' ' ' ' 
  9 9 9 9 9 / '  
/
  / '  /   / /  )  / / 
'
 7RWDO&RQGHQVHU
   %  ' /  & .  9 /      
9 .  9 .   
 6WDJH $  %   &   
/ / 
9 .  9 .   
 6WDJH $   %  &   
/ / 
9 .  9 . 
 6WDJH $  %   &   
/ /

!"&$
$
 9 .  9 .   
 6WDJH $   %  &   
/ / 
9 . 
 5HERLOHU6WDJH $   %    
/
 0DVVEDODQFHPDWUL[
     
     
 
     
   
     
     
 
     

'1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ / / ' '    
  9 / '  
 6DWXUDWHGOLTXLGIHHG 9 9  / / )  

 !$

     / / /  / / / /  % ) '  
     9  9 9 9 9 9 9
 9 $
 )$

    /  $ %XEEOH3W6HW ] L [ L \L .L [L 
9 $
     
     ($    
*$
 \L  RU . L [ L  
  9 $  /  $  0   (   13   1%   


"$



[L L
\L
 E (T [L L 
   ]L L          
] 13 13
 
   7KHQ \ Q3  
]L L 

   DQG . Q3 \ [ Q3
 


!"'$
$
    .0 . 13  . (  . Q% . 13 
0 13 Q% 13 

F  0DWUL[IRUQEXWDQRO . Q%  ] Q%  
  6WDJH $  %  ' /   

9 .   
    &  ' 
/ 

9 . 
  6WDJH$   %    
/
 
9 .   
    &  '  
/ 

9 . 
  6WDJH$   %   
/
 
9 .   
  &  
/ 

   ' )] Q%XW   

9 . 
6WDJH$  %    &   '  
%
     
     
   
     
     

G \  9 %  9  9  

  M  9 % $ 9 
    
    9 ' $  9 
9    

    9 &  9  

  M   9 % $ 9      
    9 ' $9 9      
    9 & 9    


!"+$
$
  M   9 % $ 9 
    
    9 ' $  9 9      
    9 & 9 QRWQHHGHG 
    1% 1 9  ERWWRPVIORZUDWH
    1% 9 9      
     1% 9 9      
    1% 9 9      
93 93 LQ PP+J
Q3
H  5DRXOW¶V/DZ . Q3 
3WRW 
   93 . Q3    PP+J 
  1HHGWRLQWHUSRODWH93GDWD:HNQRZ Q 93   7 
    Q   Q   Q  
       (    (  
  /LQHDU,QWHUSRODWLRQ
(  ( 
   (   
 
   7E3   RU 7E3  &


) 3ORWVRIYDSRUSUHVVXUHDUHDYDLODEOHLQ0D[ZHOOVHH7DEOHIRUUHIHUHQFHZKLOHWDEXODWHG
YDOXHVDUHLQ3HUU\¶V . 93L S WRW 'HZSRLQWFDOFXODWLRQRQIHHGJLYHVƒ)
 2YHUDOO0DVV%DODQFHV' / ' 
  9 /'  9 9 )     / /  % )±' 
    First Trial Values
6WDJH 7 / 9 .% .7 .[
4   %    0.534
3      0.534
2      0.534
1 245.7 150 30 = D 2.307 1.042 0.534

     Benzene
6WDJH & % $ ' Ɛ
4     7.9886
3     29.5978
2     57.058
1 -2.8404 1.2 - 0 135.6569

     Toluene
6WDJH & % $ ' Ɛ
4     27.1651
3     59.5188
2     61.5875
1 -1.2504 1.2 - 0 64.1742
!#,$
$
     Xylenes
6WDJH & % $ ' Ɛ
4     22.7361
3     36.6120
2     21.1971
1 -.6408 1.2 - 0 11.3193

* 8VLQJ3HQJ5RELQVRQ$VSHQ3OXVVROXWLRQ

6WDJH 7ƒ& /NPROK 9 & & &
    [   
\   
    [   
\   
    [   
\   
    [   
\   
 

* :KDW9/(SDFNDJHGLG\RXXVH"3HQJ5RELQVRQ

5HSRUWWKHIROORZLQJYDOXHV
 7HPSHUDWXUHRIFRQGHQVHU R&
 7HPSHUDWXUHRIUHERLOHU R&
 'LVWLOODWHSURGXFWPROHIUDFWLRQV &  &  &   
 %RWWRPVSURGXFWPROHIUDFWLRQV & (  &  &  
:DVWKHVSHFLILHGIHHGVWDJHWKHRSWLPXPIHHGVWDJH"<HV1R
 ,IQRWKHIHHGVWDJHVKRXOGEHDFORVHUWRWKHFRQGHQVHUEFORVHUWRWKHUHERLOHU

:KLFKWUD\JLYHVWKHODUJHVWFROXPQGLDPHWHULQPHWHUVZLWKVLHYHWUD\VZKHQRQHXVHVWKH
RULJLQDOO\VSHFLILHGIHHGVWDJH"7UD\'LDPHWHU P
 
:KLFKFRPSRQHQWVLQWKH RULJLQDOSUREOHPDUHWKHNH\ FRPSRQHQWV" /. 3URSDQH+. 
EXWDQH

  &KDQJH RQH VSHFLILFDWLRQ LQ WKH RSHUDWLQJ FRQGLWLRQV NHHS RULJLQDO QXPEHU RI VWDJHV IHHG
ORFDWLRQ IHHG IORZ IHHG FRPSRVLWLRQ IHHG SUHVVXUH IHHG WHPSHUDWXUHIUDFWLRQ YDSRUL]HG
FRQVWDQWWRPDNHHWKDQHWKHOLJKWNH\DQGSURSDQHWKHKHDY\NH\
 :KDWRSHUDWLQJSDUDPHWHUGLG\RXFKDQJHDQGZKDWLVLWVQHZYDOXH"' 
 7HPSHUDWXUHRIFRQGHQVHU R&
 7HPSHUDWXUHRIUHERLOHU R&
 'LVWLOODWHSURGXFWPROHIUDFWLRQV &  &  & (  
 %RWWRPVSURGXFWPROHIUDFWLRQV &  &  & 



!#!$
$
* )RUFROXPQUHSRUWWKHIROORZLQJ
D)LQDOYDOXHRI/'
E6SOLWIUDFWLRQVRIHWKDQROGLVWLOODWHDQGQSURSDQROERWWRPV
F0ROHIUDFWLRQVLQERWWRPV(
G0ROHIUDFWLRQVLQGLVWLOODWH
)RUFROXPQ
 D2SWLPXPIHHGORFDWLRQLQWKHFROXPQ
E0ROHIUDFWLRQVLQERWWRPV
F0ROHIUDFWLRQVLQGLVWLOODWH

*1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ
7HPSHUDWXUHRIFRQGHQVHU B.7HPSHUDWXUHRIUHERLOHU BB.
4FRQGHQVHU BBBBBFDOVHF4UHERLOHU BBBBBBBFDOVHF
'LVWLOODWHSURGXFWPROHIUDFWLRQV% 7 %L3 (BBBBBBBBB
%RWWRPVSURGXFWPROHIUDFWLRQVB% (7 (%L3 BBBBBBBBB

:DVWKHVSHFLILHGIHHGVWDJHWKHRSWLPXPIHHGVWDJH"<HV1R[
,IQRWKHIHHGVWDJHVKRXOGEHDFORVHUWRWKHFRQGHQVHUEFORVHUWRWKHUHERLOHUDBB
1RWH'RPLQLPXPQXPEHURIVLPXODWLRQVWRDQVZHUWKHVHTXHVWLRQV'RQRWRSWLPL]H

:KLFKWUD\JLYHVWKHODUJHVWFROXPQGLDPHWHUZLWKVLHYHWUD\VZKHQRQHXVHVWKHRULJLQDOO\
VSHFLILHGIHHGVWDJH"$VSHQ7UD\BBBBBBBB&ROXPQ'LDPHWHU BBBBBBBBBBPHWHUV
>8VHWKHGHIDXOWYDOXHVIRUQXPEHURISDVVHVWUD\VSDFLQJPPLQLPXPGRZQFRPHU
DUHDIRDPLQJIDFWRUDQGRYHUGHVLJQIDFWRU6HWWKHIUDFWLRQDODSSURDFKWRIORRGLQJ
DW8VHWKH³)DLU´GHVLJQPHWKRGIRUIORRGLQJ@

:KLFKFRPSRQHQWVLQWKHRULJLQDOSUREOHPDUHWKHNH\FRPSRQHQWVODEHOOLJKWDQGKHDY\
NH\VBBBBB/. WROXHQH+. ELSKHQ\OBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

&KDQJHRQHVSHFLILFDWLRQLQWKHRSHUDWLQJFRQGLWLRQVNHHS1IHHGORFDWLRQIHHGIORZIHHG
FRPSRVLWLRQIHHGSUHVVXUHIHHGWHPSHUDWXUHRUIUDFWLRQYDSRUL]HGFRQVWDQWDWRULJLQDO
FRQGLWLRQVWRPDNHEHQ]HQHWKHOLJKWNH\DQGWROXHQHWKHKHDY\NH\$OVRLQFUHDVHWKHUHIOX[
UDWLRWR
:KDWRSHUDWLQJSDUDPHWHUGLG\RXFKDQJHQRWLQFOXGLQJWKHUHIOX[UDWLRDQGZKDWLVLWVQHZ
YDOXH"' BBBBBBBB
7HPSHUDWXUHRIFRQGHQVHU BBBBB.7HPSHUDWXUHRIUHERLOHU BBBB.
'LVWLOODWHSURGXFWPROHIUDFWLRQVB% 7 %L3 (BBBBBBBB
%RWWRPVSURGXFWPROHIUDFWLRQVB% 7 %L3 BBBBBBBBB

*1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ
7HPSHUDWXUHRIFRQGHQVHU BBBB.7HPSHUDWXUHRIUHERLOHU BBBB.
4FRQGHQVHU BBBBBBBBFDOVHF4UHERLOHU BBBBBBBBBBFDOVHF
'LVWLOODWHSURGXFWPROHIUDFWLRQVBB% 7 S[\ (BB
%RWWRPVSURGXFWPROHIUDFWLRQVBBB% 7 S[\ BBB

:DVWKHVSHFLILHGIHHGVWDJHWKHRSWLPXPIHHGVWDJH"<HV1R[
,IQRWKHIHHGVWDJHVKRXOGEHDFORVHUWRWKHFRQGHQVHUEFORVHUWRWKHUHERLOHUD
1RWH'RPLQLPXPQXPEHURIVLPXODWLRQVWRDQVZHUWKHVHTXHVWLRQV'RQRWRSWLPL]H

:KLFKWUD\JLYHVWKHODUJHVWFROXPQGLDPHWHUZLWKVLHYHWUD\VZKHQRQHXVHVWKHRULJLQDOO\
VSHFLILHGIHHGVWDJH"$VSHQ7UD\BBBBBBBBBB&ROXPQ'LDPHWHU BBBBBBBBBPHWHUV

!#)$
$
 >8VHWKHGHIDXOWYDOXHVIRUQXPEHURISDVVHVWUD\VSDFLQJPPLQLPXPGRZQFRPHU
DUHDIRDPLQJIDFWRUDQGRYHUGHVLJQIDFWRU6HWWKHIUDFWLRQDODSSURDFKWRIORRGLQJ
DW8VHWKH³)DLU´GHVLJQPHWKRGIRUIORRGLQJ@

:KLFKFRPSRQHQWVLQWKHRULJLQDOSUREOHPDUHWKHNH\FRPSRQHQWVODEHOOLJKWDQGKHDY\
NH\VBBBBBBBBEHQ]HQH /.WROXHQH +.BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

&KDQJHRQHVSHFLILFDWLRQLQWKHRSHUDWLQJFRQGLWLRQVNHHS1IHHGORFDWLRQIHHGIORZIHHG
FRPSRVLWLRQIHHGSUHVVXUHIHHGWHPSHUDWXUHRUIUDFWLRQYDSRUL]HGFRQVWDQWWRPDNHWROXHQHWKH
OLJKWNH\DQGS[\OHQHWKHKHDY\NH\
:KDWRSHUDWLQJSDUDPHWHUGLG\RXFKDQJHDQGZKDWLVLWVQHZYDOXH"BB' BBBBBB
7HPSHUDWXUHRIFRQGHQVHU BBBBB.7HPSHUDWXUHRIUHERLOHU BBB.
'LVWLOODWHSURGXFWPROHIUDFWLRQVB% 7 3[\ BBBBBBBB
%RWWRPVSURGXFWPROHIUDFWLRQVBB% (7 3[\ BBBBB

*1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ3DUWD / '  E / '  F' 6 OLTXLG
  GLVWLOODWHPROHIUDFV(  %  3 (
  VLGHVWUHDPPROHIUDFV(  %  3 
  ERWWRPVPROHIUDFV ( ( %  3  
 GGLVWLOODWH (  %  3 (
  VLGH (  %  3 
  ERWWRPV ( ( %  3 
  6LQFHYDSRUPROHIUDFWLRQHWKDQH!OLTXLGPROHIUDFWLRQHWKDQHLV/.KDYHPRUHHWKDQHLQ
YDSRUVLGHVWUHDP
 H7KHVHSDUDWLRQRIQSHQWDQHDQGQEXWDQHLVPXFKPRUHGLIILFXOWWKDQEHWZHHQHWKDQHDQGQ
EXWDQH7KXVVLGHVWUHDPSXULW\LVOHVV$OVRIHHGKDVORWPRUHSHQWDQHWKDQHWKDQHZKLFKPDNHV
VLGHVWUHDPEHORZIHHGOHVVSXUH

*1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ
5HSRUWWKHIROORZLQJYDOXHV
7HPSHUDWXUHRIFRQGHQVHU BBBBB.7HPSHUDWXUHRIUHERLOHU BBBBBB.
4FRQGHQVHU BBBBBBFDOVHF4UHERLOHU BBBBBBBBBFDOVHF
'LVWLOODWHSURGXFWPROHIUDFWLRQV0 ( 13 1% (
%RWWRPVSURGXFWPROHIUDFWLRQV0 (( 13 1% B

:DVWKHVSHFLILHGIHHGVWDJHWKHRSWLPXPIHHGVWDJH"<HV1R;
,IQRWKHIHHGVWDJHVKRXOGEHDFORVHUWRWKHFRQGHQVHUEFORVHUWRWKHUHERLOHU$QVZHUD
1RWH'RPLQLPXPQXPEHURIVLPXODWLRQVWRDQVZHUWKHVHTXHVWLRQV'RQRWRSWLPL]H

:KLFKWUD\JLYHVWKHODUJHVWFROXPQGLDPHWHUZLWKVLHYHWUD\VZKHQRQHXVHVWKHRULJLQDOO\VSHFLILHG
IHHGVWDJH"$VSHQ7UD\BBBBBBBBBB&ROXPQ'LDPHWHU BBBBBBBPHWHUV
>8VHWKHGHIDXOWYDOXHVIRUQXPEHURISDVVHVWUD\VSDFLQJPPLQLPXPGRZQFRPHUDUHD
IRDPLQJIDFWRUDQGRYHUGHVLJQIDFWRU6HWWKHIUDFWLRQDODSSURDFKWRIORRGLQJDW8VH
WKH³)DLU´GHVLJQPHWKRGIRUIORRGLQJ@

:KLFKFRPSRQHQWVLQWKHRULJLQDOSUREOHPDUHWKHNH\FRPSRQHQWVODEHOOLJKWDQGKHDY\NH\V
BBBBBBBBBBBBBB/. HWKDQRO+. QSURSDQROBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB


!#*$
$
&KDQJHRQHVSHFLILFDWLRQLQWKHRSHUDWLQJFRQGLWLRQVNHHS1IHHGORFDWLRQIHHGIORZIHHG
FRPSRVLWLRQIHHGSUHVVXUHIHHGWHPSHUDWXUHRUIUDFWLRQYDSRUL]HGFRQVWDQWWRPDNHPHWKDQROWKHOLJKW
NH\DQGHWKDQROWKHKHDY\NH\
:KDWRSHUDWLQJSDUDPHWHUGLG\RXFKDQJHDQGZKDWLVLWVQHZYDOXH"BBBBB' BBBB
7HPSHUDWXUHRIFRQGHQVHU BBBB.7HPSHUDWXUHRIUHERLOHU BBBB.
'LVWLOODWHSURGXFWPROHIUDFWLRQV0 ( 13 (1% (B
%RWWRPVSURGXFWPROHIUDFWLRQV0 ( 13 1% BB


$

!#"$
$
 &KDSWHU

1HZ3UREOHPVDQGQHZVROXWLRQVDUHOLVWHGDVQHZLPPHGLDWHO\DIWHUWKHVROXWLRQQXPEHU7KHVHQHZ
SUREOHPVDUH$$'''''*

$1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQIQRQHRIWKHDERYH

$1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQDHVWLPDWHIUDFWLRQDOUHFRYHULHVQRQNH\VDWWRWDOUHIOX[

&  8VH \L M  . L [ L M  7KHQVXEVWLWXWLQJLQWR(TZHKDYH
     9PLQ . L [ L M  / PLQ [ LM '[ LGLVW 
  ZKLFKLV 9PLQ . L [ L M  / PLQ [ LM  '[ LGLVW ZKHUH . L L . +. 5HDUUDQJLQJ
9PLQ . L . +.  '[ LGLVW L
/ PLQ [ L M  .[ LGLVW RU / PLQ [ L M  
/ PLQ 9PLQ . +. 
/ PLQ L

F F
'[ LGLVW L
  7RWDOIORZUDWH / PLQ LV / PLQ / PLQ [ LM 
 $
9 . 
L  L  PLQ +.
/ PLQ L

%[ L ERW L
  %\DVLPLODUDQDO\VLVREWDLQ / PLQ  %
9PLQ . +. 
/ PLQ L

9PLQ . 9PLQ .
  /HW  /
 /
&
/ PLQ / PLQ
  $GG(TV$DQG%DQGXVHH[WHUQDOPDVVEDODQFH
F )] L
     T) / IHHG / PLQ / PLQ L
 DQDORJXH
L   L /

F '[ LGLVW L
  )URP(TV$DQG&ZHKDYH / PLQ DQDORJXH
L   L /

& )RUVDWXUDWHGYDSRUIHHGKDYH 9) ) )RUELQDU\V\VWHP(TLV


]
   ]
       
 
   &OHDULQJIUDFWLRQVZHREWDLQ
          ]   ]  
   $IWHUVRPHDOJHEUDWKLV
      ]
    ]   
   6ROXWLRQVDUH RU   ]
   ] 
   )RUVDW¶GOLT¶G 9)  &OHDUIUDFWLRQVDQGHTXDWLRQLVOLQHDU



 [  [ GLVW  
Q Q
[  [ ERW
 
' D (T 1 PLQ  
Q  $% Q 
   7KLVLQFOXGHVWKHSDUWLDOUHERLOHU(TDJLYHV
[  [ GLVW  
Q Q
]  ] IHHG
 
     1 I PLQ  
Q $% Q 
]% ]7
 E 6DWXUDWHGOLTXLG 9I  (TEHFRPHV % 7

% 7

   $IWHUFOHDULQJIUDFWLRQVDQGVROYLQJIRU 

7 ]%  
      
% ]% 7 ]7    
   :KLFKGRHVOLHEHWZHHQWKHĮ¶VRIWKHNH\V7RXVH(TZHQHHG')URPPDVV
EDODQFHV(T
] [ ERW  
     ' )   NJPROHVKU
[ GLVW [ ERW  
% '[ %GLVW 7 '[ 7GLVW
   (TLV 9PLQ 
% 7

     

     9PLQ  
   
     / PLQ 9PLQ '  / ' PLQ  


/ ' / '
 F   / '  / ' PLQ
  [ PLQ
 
/ ' 
1 1 PLQ
   8VLQJ(TE  
1 
 1 PLQ
   6ROYLQJIRU1 1  LQFOXGHVUHERLOHU
 
1 )PLQ 
   )URP(TE 1 ) 1   
1 PLQ 
   7U\VWDJHIURPWRSIRUIHHGVWDJH

' 1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ S DWP] & ] & ] & ] &  

   6DWXUDWHGOLTXLGDQGIRUES&DOF ] L [ L :DQW \L  

N3D
   3LFN &  DVUHIHUHQFHWKLVLVDUELWUDU\ DWP  N3D 
DWP
   VW*XHVV:DQW . &  OLJKWNH\ . &  KHDY\NH\8VH'H3ULHVWHU&KDUW



   7U\ 7  &  . &   . &   . &   . &  

\L        

    

    
. &  
   1HHGORZHU7 . & 7QHZ  
.L[L 

    7QHZ   . &  . &  . &  

    \L      

   )RUUHPDLQGHUOHW &  +. EHUHIHUHQFH &&    

 
Q
  
  D 1 0,1  LQFOXGHV35
Q  
  E & &     & &   & &    
   6DW¶GOLTXLGIHHG 90,1 90,1 ,Q(TGLYLGHWKURXJKE\)

L ]L        

     
L    
   6ROYHIRUij)LQGij 1RWH /. +.  +. +. 

L '[ LGLVW
   (T 90,1 $VVXPHDOO &  LQGLVWLOODWH DOO &  LQERWWRPV
L

       '[ L&  '[ L& 

        '[ L &
     
       '[ L &
     
        ' '[ LG  
     
    90,1   NPROH K 
     
     / 0,1 90,1 '   / ' 0,1  
   F  / 0,1  / ' 0,1
 
 
    2UGLQDWH*LOOLODQG  

1 1 0,1 
    (TE     
1  
 
      1  LQFOXGH35
 



 '[ /. '[ +. GLVW  
Q Q
] /. ] +.  
      1 )0,1  
Q /. +. Q
1 )PLQ 1) 
    (TE 1)   DSSUR[LPDWH
1 PLQ 1 
[$ [$
ORJ
[% G
[% ERW
' $WWRWDOUHIOX[XVH)HQVNH(T 1 PLQ 
ORJ  $%

 [$ [$
   5HDUUDQJHORJ $% ORJ 
1 PLQ [% G
[% ERW
 1 PLQ

[$ [$  
     $%  
[% G
[% ERW
 
[  [ GLVW  
Q Q
[  [ ERW
 
' D  1 PLQ  
Q  $% Q 
E )HHGLVVDWXUDWHGOLTXLGIHHGOLQHLVYHUWLFDO


12))  \
!"#$%&'()*) )
 
1)
2)3)*),4) [
\ 
  [ [ ] 

)
/ / 9
!"#$%)&'()*)+,-./0)  )
' PLQ  / 9 PLQ


/ ' / '  
 F $EVFLVVD  PLQ
 
/ '  
  )URP(TE
1 1 PLQ 
        RUGLQDWH 
1  
1 PLQ RUGLQDWH  
    1  
 RUGLQDWH  
 
  )URPILWWHGFXUYHRUGLQDWH  1  
 
  (UURU    ORZ$VSHQ3OXVHTXLOLEULXPGDWDLVQRWĮ 1RWHWKDWĮ 
PD\EHDEHWWHUILW



 [' [%
ORJ
 ['  [% 1 PLQ [' [%
' )HQVNH(TLV 1 PLQ RU 
ORJ   ['  [%
['  ['
  6ROYLQJIRU [ % ZHREWDLQ [ % 1 PLQ

['  ['
  6LQFH 1 PLQ   DQG[ '  WKLVLV[ %  

[' [%  
ORJ ORJ 
 ['  [%  
' )HQVNH(T 1 PLQ  
ORJ  ORJ  
  'HWHUPLQH\LQHTXLOLEULXPZLWKIHHG ] [  
[  
  \  
  [   
/ [' \   / / 9
     
9 PLQ [' ]   ' PLQ  / 9 PLQ

/
  7KHQ    
' DFW

/ ' / '   

  *LOOLODQG&RUUHODWLRQ$EVFLVVD PLQ
 
/ '   
1 1 PLQ 1 
    2UGLQDWH  
1  1 
  &OHDUIUDFWLRQVDQGILQG1 LQFOXGLQJSDUWLDOUHERLOHU

'  S  DWP)URPWKHVROXWLRQWRSUREOHP' 7ES  & 
    . &  . &  . &  . &  

  /HW &  +. EHUHIHUHQFH & &   

 
Q
  
 D (T,QFOXGLQJ35 1 PLQ  
Q  
 E  & +. UHIHUHQFH &&     & &  
      & &    
   6DW¶GOLTXLGIHHG 9PLQ 9PLQ 
]
L L
       
 (T  
L    
  :DQW /. +.   +. +. &RQYHUJHWR  



     '[ L &
)]L   '[ L &
    
     '[ L &
    '[ L &

     
  (T 9PLQ   
     
     ' '[ LG  /PLQ 9PLQ '   / ' PLQ  
 F  / '  / ' PLQ
 2UGLQDWH*LOOLODQG     
1 1 PLQ 
  (TE     
1  
 
    1  LQFO351IHHGa
 
' D &DQ GR WKLV JUDSKLFDOO\ RU FDQ FDOFXODWH VORSH RI D OLQH IURP \ [ [ '  WR
LQWHUVHFWLRQRIIHHGOLQHDQGHTXLOLEULXPRUXVH8QGHUZRRG(DVLHVWWRFDOFXODWHVORSH)HHG
OLQH \ ] )  
\ 
  (TXLOLEULXP [  
\  \   
/   / / 9
         
9 PLQ   ' PLQ  / 9
[' [%  
Q
 ['  [%  
 E  1 PLQ  
Q Q  
  7KLVLVVWDJHVSOXVSDUWLDOUHERLOHU
/ ' / '  
 F / '    $EVFLVVD PLQ
 
/ '   
1 1 PLQ
  2UGLQDWH  RU1  ZKLFKLQFOXGHVSDUWLDOUHERLOHU
1 
  7KLVVHSDUDWLRQZRXOGSUREDEO\QRWEHGRQHE\GLVWLOODWLRQ
/) )] 
'  )HHGOLTXLG / ) ) 9) ) )HHGOLQH \ [ 6ORSH 
9) 9)  
/  
D 6HH*UDSK 0LQWRSRSOLQHLVWDQJHQW VORSH  
9 PLQ  
/ / 9 PLQ 
     
' PLQ  / 9 PLQ
 

 E  1 PLQ  HTFRQWDFWV6HHJUDSK

/
 F     $EVFLVVD*LOOLODQG&RUUHODWLRQLV
' DFWXDO



 / ' / '   
    PLQ
 
/ '   
   2UGLQDWHaIURPJUDSK

  )URP HT E 2UGLQDWH     

DJUHHVZLWKJUDSK
1 PLQ RUGLQDWH  
  7KHQ 1  
 RUGLQDWH  
  1HHGHTVFRQWDFWV35
1 )PLQ 
 1 )PLQ IURPJUDSK  1 ) 1    E 
1 PLQ 


' D 1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ(T
)5 ( GLVW )5 %ERW
Q
 )5 ( GLVW  )5 %ERW
 1 0,1 
Q (%



  
Q
  
    (%   1 0,1  
Q  

  E  1 0,1 LVNQRZQ 3%  
1 0,1 
3% 
   (T )5 3 GLVW  
)5 %ERW 1 0,1  
3%

 )5 %ERW 
  F  '[ ' L
)5 LGLVW )]L 
   (WKDQH '[ '(      
   3URSDQH '[ '3     
   QEXWDQH '[ '%      
 NPRO
      ' '[ LG   
L  K
$OVRDFFHSW' VLQFHWRWDOUHIOX[

'1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ 



     7)


5++) )


] Q  5)
] L3 
 ) 9
] 
 13 ) 8)
)

 ) 6)
8VH8QGHUZRRG(TQV±&DVH$$VVXPH/1.SURSDQHLVDOOLQGLVWLOODWH '[ SGLVW )] S  
)
  E 9IHHG )  T )VLQFHT  

L ) ]L
   (T )  ZKHUHijLVEHWZHHQĮ¶VRIWZRNH\V%DQG+
L
   !ij!(TXDWLRQLV
     
     
  
   6ROYLQJIRUijREWDLQij 



 '[ LGLVW
   7KHQ 9PLQ  )LQG'IURPIUDFWLRQDOUHFRYHULHV

'[ %GLVW     

'[ SGLVW  
    
'[ + GLVW     
' 
     
     
    90,1  
     
    / PLQ 90,1 ' DQG / ' PLQ  

'   $ EHQ]HQH/. $%  )5 $GLVW  
   % WROXHQH+. %%  )5 %ERW  
   & FXPHQH+1. &%  
)5 $ GLVW  )5 %ERW
Q
 )5 $ GLVW )5 %ERW
  D 8VH)HQVNHHTQDWWRWDOUHIOX[ 1 PLQ 
Q $%

 
Q
 
      1 PLQ  
Q  
1 PLQ

$& $% 
   )5 &ERW ZKHUH $&   
)5 $ GLVW 1 PLQ
&% 
$&
 )5 $ GLVW


     )5 &ERW  $OOFXPHQHJRHVWRERWWRPV
 


    :HFDQDOVRVXEVWLWXWHLQWR(T
1 PLQ 
$&
 
     )5 &GLVW   
)5 %ERW 1 PLQ  
&%

 )5 %ERW 
  E 8QGHUZRRGHTXDWLRQV±&DVH%DQDO\VLV
& )]
   )HHGLVVDWYDSRU T   9IHHG )  T )   9IHHG L

L 


     

      
  
   )LQG  



 & L '[ LGLVW
     9PLQ ZKHUH'[ LGLVW )] )5 LGLVW

L 


 '[ $GLVW     '[ %GLVW     '[ &GLVW  '  
   
     9PLQ   
   
/ 
  )URPPDVVEDODQFH / PLQ 9PLQ '      
' PLQ 
  F  / '  / ' PLQ
   
/ ' / '
   DEVFLVVDIRU*LOOLODQGFRUUHODWLRQ PLQ
 )URP)LJXUHWKH 
/ ' 
   RUGLQDWH :LWK 1 PLQ  ZHILQG1 
   7RILQG 1 IHHG  ZHQHHG1 IHHG 
PLQ

[$ ]$
Q
[% GLVW
]% IHHG
     1 IHHG 
PLQ Q $%


      [ $ GLVW  [ %    

 
Q
 
     1 IHHG  
PLQ Q 
1 IHHG 1 IHHG
PLQ
     JLYHV1 IHHG  8VHVWDJHRU
1 PLQ 1

 
'  8VH)HQVNHHT )5 7  )5 7   )5 &  )5 &  
 
ORJ   ORJ 
     1 PLQ  
ORJ  7& ORJ  
     
  8QGHUZRRG 9I 9 9    
  

 '[ LG
   RU8VH DVLWLVEHWZHHQNH\V  9PLQ 
L 


     '[ %G )] %  DVVXPHDOOEHQ]HQHLQGLVW

     '[ 7G  )] 7  '[ FG  )] F  '  
     
     9PLQ  
     
     / PLQ 9 ' DQG / ' PLQ  



 1 1 PLQ  
    *LOOLODQG2UGLQDWH  
1  
  $EVFLVVDaRULJLQDO*LOOLODQGRU/LGGOH
/ / /
  ,IXVHKDYH   
' ' PLQ '
/  
      
'  
/  
  ,I XVH $EVFLVVD     ZKLFK DUH TXLWH GLIIHUHQW  6DIHU WR XVH
'  
KLJKHUYDOXH
  ,I %7  1 PLQ LVVDPH8QGHUZRRG(TJLYHV  RU8VH 
  9PLQ      / PLQ 9 ' DQG / ' PLQ 
  :KLFKLVGLIIHUHQWWKDQIRU %7  

'1HZ SUREOHP LQ UG HGLWLRQ  8VH *LOOLODQG FRUUHODWLRQ WR ILQG WKH YDOXH RI WKH PLQLPXP UHIOX[
UDWLR/'PLQ 
)5 %GLVW )5 &ERW  
Q Q
 )5 %GLVW  )5 &ERW  
'  )HQVNH(T 1 PLQ  
Q 
%& Q

1 PLQ
7& 
  (T )5 7 GLVW ZKHUH 7& 
)5 & ERW 1 PLQ 
7&
 )5 & ERW



     )5 WROGLVW 
 DQG )5 WROERW  
 
 
[ GLVW
'[ G WRO   

     '[ G EHQ]    

'[ G FXP   
' 
[ /. ] /.  
Q Q
[ +. GLVW
] +.  
    1 )PLQ  
Q /.+. Q   
   8QGHUZRRG8VHD&DVH&DQDO\VLVVLQFHWROXHQHLVDVDQGZLFKNH\

)]
     
  (T  9) LV 
L 
   
    DQG ZKLFKOLHEHWZHHQĮ¶V



  (T

L '[ LGLVW    '[ WRO  
   9PLQ EHFRPHV9PLQ 
L 
L   
  :ULWHIRU  DQGIRU2EWDLQHTQVDQGXQNQRZQV 9PLQ DQG '[ WROGLVW 
 )RU   9PLQ   '[ WRO  )RU
 9PLQ   '[ WRO  
  6ROYLQJVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ 9PLQ  '[ WRO  
    ' '[ LG     
    / PLQ 9PLQ ' DQG / ' PLQ
 
/ ' / ' PLQ  
  *LOOLODQG$EVFLVVD  
/ '  
1 1 PLQ
    2UG  2ULJLQDO*LOOLODQG
1 
     2EWDLQ1 LQFOXGHVUHERLOHU
1 )PLQ 
  (VWLPDWH 1 ) 1   8VHVWDJH
1 PLQ 

[ [  
Q Q
 [ GLVW  [ ERW  
' D )HQVNH 1 PLQ  
Q Q 
)] (  ) ] S
 E 8QGHUZRRG 9IHHG (3
 ] (  ] 3   9 IHHG 9 9 )
(3 
   
     RU  8VH  ZKLFKLVEHWZHHQDQG
 
] [%  
  7RILQG' ' )   7KHQ
[' [%  
9PLQ    
      
'    
/
     9PLQ  / PLQ 9PLQ '    
' PLQ

1 1 PLQ  

 F 8VH*LOOLODQG2UGLQDWH  
1  
/ ' / ' PLQ
    $EVFLVVDa  2ULJLQDO*LOOLODQG / '  
/ ' 

9) L ]L
'  6RXQGVKDUGHUWKDQLWLV  I  WRO[\   
[\ [\ 
) L



 ] WRO [\ ] [\
   ([SDQG 6ROYHIRU   WRO

WRO [\

[\ WRO WRO
   5HVXOWLVOLQHDU  VLQ FH [\  
WRO ] WRO [\ ] [\ WRO ] WRO  ] WRO

L '[ LGLVW ] [% ] 

    7KHQ 9PLQ  ' )  
L
[' [% 
   
     9PLQ ' / PLQ 9PLQ '
 

] WRO  ' 9PLQ  / PLQ  /

 ' PLQ
0.1       4.8997
   
      
0.3       1.6269
  '  
      
0.5       0.96934
  '  
      
.7       0.68101
  '  
      
.9       0.429
  '  
      

  &KHFNIRU] 


[' ) 6ORSH  / 9 PLQ

)

12) / [' \
:;<=<)
9 PLQ [ ' 
1) [)
\  )
,-)*)3)   [)

)
 
9) )))))  )
 

    
/ / / 9 
      3HUIHFW
' PLQ 9 /  / 9  
  $V ] DOWKRXJK / ' PLQ  9PLQ  WKXV 4F PLQ
9PLQ DVH[SHFWHG 
      4 5PLQ DOVR 



 )5 $ GLVW )5 %ERW
Q
 )5 $ GLVW  )5 %ERW
'D )HQVNH(T 1 PLQ 
Q $%

  :KHUH$ SURSDQH% EXWDQH $%    1RWHYDOXHĮ

 
Q
 
    1 PLQ  
Q  
  )RU 1 )PLQ DVVXPHQR/1.LVERWDQGQR+1.LQGLVWLOODWH
    '  
   
    [ SURS  [ &  
 
[ & ] &  
Q Q
[ & GLVW
]& )  
    1 )PLQ  
Q && 
 )]
  8QGHUZRRG(TQV&DVH$  9IHHG IRU  


       

     I 
   
     
  )LQG   9PLQ  
     
    / PLQ 9PLQ '     / ' PLQ  
/  ' /  ' PLQ
  *LOOLODQG&RUUHODWLRQ)LJDEVFLVVD  
/' 
1 1 PLQ
  2UGLQDWH  2ULJLQDO*LOOLODQGa/LGGOH)LQG1 /LGGOH
1 
 E :LWK1 RUGLQDWHWR*LOOLODQGFRUUHODWLRQLV
1 1 PLQ  
     
1  
  $EVFLVVD 6LQFH / ' PLQ  VROYHIRU/' 
1 PLQ
& &
 F  )5 &  
GLVW
)5 &  ERW 1 PLQ
&&
 )5 &  ERW

    ZKHUH & &  )5 &ERW  )5 &GLVW  DQG1 PLQ  


 )5 &    )5 &  
GLVW
 
ERW

 



   )RUDOOSUDFWLFDOSXUSRVHVDOO&LQERWWRPVDWWRWDOUHIOX[

 G )5 &GLVW  /  '  )5 %ERW  
)5 &GLVW )5 &  ERW  
Q Q
 )5 &GLVW  )5 & ERW  
    1 PLQ  
Q &&  

    )RU'DVVXPHDOO/1.LQGLVW1R+1.LQGLVW

    '  

       
   1RZ I  
   

  :KLFKLVVDPH>ijGHSHQGVRQO\RQIHHG Į¶V@7KXVVDPHij 

      ""
    9PLQ  
     

    / PLQ    / ' PLQ  9HU\OLWWOHFKDQJH

1 1 PLQ  
'  8VH)LJXUH2UGLQDWH  
1  
/ ' / '
  7KHQ$EVFLVVD ZLWK / '   / '
PLQ
PLQ
 
/ ' 
   $EVFLVVDDSSUR[LPDWHGEHWZHHQRULJLQDO ILWWHGFXUYHV

' D 'LVWLOODWH '[ %GLVW )] %  '[ 7GLVW )] 7  
 
    [ GLVW  EHFRPHV    
' '

   )LQG ' NPROHVKU% ±' 
[$ [% GLVW
Q
[$ [% ERW
$ [\OHQH
 E &DQXVH)HQVNHHTRUDOWHUQDWLYHV 1 PLQ 
Q $%
% FXPHQH
. [\ . [\ . WRO [\ 
    $% [\OHQH FXPHQH  
. FXP . FXP . WRO FXP 
  ;\OHQHEDODQFH )]     [ [ERW  
   [ [ERW  [ FXPERW    



  
Q
 
   1 PLQ  
Q 
  7KLVLVHTXLOFRQWDFWVDWWRWDOUHIOX[
'[ [ GLVW  
 F $OWHUQDWLYH )5 [\GLVW  
)] [ 
'[ &GLVW  
    )5 &ERW   )5 FXPERW  
)] & 
)5 $ GLVW )5 %ERW
Q
 )5 $ GLVW  )5 %ERW $ [\OHQH
   8VH(T 1 PLQ   
Q $%
% FXPHQH
 
Q
 
      1 PLQ  
Q 

'1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ$VVXPHDOOHWKDQROLQGLVWLOODWHDQGDOOQEXWDQROLQERWWRPV
    
 
'[ ( GLVW )] (    
'[ L 3GLVW )] LS )UDF5HFL3GLVW     
  
'[ Q 3GLVW )] Q3  )UDF5HFQ3GLVW    
'[ Q %GLVW 

         '  '[ LGLVW  )
    


 [(GLVW [(GLVW' [L3GLVW [L3GLVW' [Q3GLVW [Q3GLVW' 

      
%[ ( ERW  )
%[ L 3ERW )] L3 )UDF5HFL3GLVW     
 
%[ Q 3ERW )] Q3 )UDF5HFQ3ERW     
%[ Q %ERW )] Q %    

    6)*)/-,+>)
  [ LERW %[ LERW %

[L3ERW %[L3ERW% [Q3ERW %[Q3ERW% [Q%ERW %[Q%ERW% 




 )5 LSGLVW )5 Q3 ERW
Q
 )5 L3 GLVW  )5 Q3 ERW
E )HQVNHHT 1 0LQ  
Q L3 Q3

 
Q
  Q  
   1 PLQ  
Q   
 7KLVLQFOXGHV35
[ L3 ] L3  
Q Q
[ Q3 GLVW
] Q3  
 1 )0,1 (T  D  1 )0,1  
Q L313 

F 8QGHUZRRG(TXDWLRQ$VVXPH1.VGR127GLVWULEXWH&DVH$
L )] L
 (T  9IHHG 
L

]
L L
 )RUVDWXUDWHGYDSRU 9IHHG ) GLYLGHE\)   ZKLFKEHFRPHV
L

( Q3 ]( L3 Q3 ] L3 Q3 13 ] 13 1% 13 ] 1%
     
(13 L3 13 13 13 1% 13

       

     
   
 6ROYH IRU ij EHWZHHQ Į YDOXHV RI NH\V  /.  LSURSDQRO +. QSURSDQRO  7KXV ZDQW
  )URP*RDO6HHNRQVSUHDGVKHHW  
L '[ LGLVW
 7KHQIURP(T 9PLQ ZKHUH '[ LGLVW YDOXHVIURPSDUWD
L

     

   90,1  
      
/ 0,1 90,1 '     / ' 0,1   
  
/
G / '  
' 0LQ

/ ' 0,1 
 
/ ' / ' 0,1 / ' 
 *LOOLODQGDEVFLVVD [
/ '   
 
/ '  / ' 0,1 
/ '

/ ' 0,1  
   RU [  
/ '  

/ ' 0,1 / ' 0,1 




 1 1 0,1
 )URP(TE  
1 
    1    1 0,1  1 LQFOXGHV35

1) 1 )0,1 
 $VVXPLQJ 1)   RU6WDJHEHORZWRWDOFRQGHQVHU
1 1 0,1 

)  (TXLOLEULXPGDWDLVDYDLODEOHLQDYDULHW\RIVRXUFHVVXFKDV3HUU\¶V+DQGERRN'DWDXVHG
KHUHLVIURP3HUU\¶VUGHGS
D 1HHGWRREWDLQDYJĮIURPHTXLOLEULXPGDWD
\1  [ 1  
    [  \    
 \ 1 [ 1  
    [ 1  \  QHHGHGIRUSDUWE
 
    [ 1  \ 1    
 
 
    DYJ WRS ERW    

[  [ GLVW  

Q Q
[  [ ERW
 
   )HQVNH 1 PLQ  
Q $% Q 
[' ]
 E / 9 PLQ
ZKHUH[ LVLQHTXLOLEULXPZLWKIHHG \ ]  
[' [
  )URPHTXLOLEULXPGDWD[ a
  / / 9 PLQ 
    / 9 PLQ     
  ' PLQ  / 9 PLQ  
 F   /  '  /' PLQ
 
/ ' / ' 
  *LOOLODQG&RUUHODWLRQDEVFLVVD PLQ
 
 / ' 

1 1 PLQ
 2ULJLQDOFRUUHODWLRQRUGLQDWH  1 LQFOXGLQJ351HHGHTXLO6WDJHV
1 
* 1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQD $WWRWDOUHIOX[ 1 0,1  
  E / ' 0,1
  



 &KDSWHU

1HZ3UREOHPVDQGQHZVROXWLRQVDUHOLVWHGDVQHZLPPHGLDWHO\DIWHUWKHVROXWLRQQXPEHU7KHVHQHZ
SUREOHPVDUH$$$$'''''''''WR
'(**+

$1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQDSUHVVXUHGLVWLOODWLRQ

$1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQEH[WUDFWLYHGLVWLOODWLRQ

$1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ,IWKHUHDUHYRODWLOHDQGQRQYRODWLOHRUJDQLFVDVLQJOHHTXLOLEULXP
FRQWDFWJLYHVDQRUJDQLFOD\HUWKDWFRQWDLQVQRQRQYRODWLOHV([WUDVWDJHVGRQRWLQFUHDVHWKH
VHSDUDWLRQ,IWKHUHLVHQWUDLQPHQWDVHFRQGVWDJHPD\EHXVHIXO

$1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ6WHDPGLVWLOODWLRQLVQRUPDOO\RSHUDWHGZLWKOLTXLGSKDVHVLQWKH
VWLOOSRWDQGLQWKHVHWWOHUDIWHUWKHFRQGHQVHU7KHUHLVXVXDOO\QRUHIOX[$]HRWURSLF
GLVWLOODWLRQLVQRUPDOO\RSHUDWHGZLWKRQHOLTXLGSKDVHLQWKHFROXPQDQGLQWKHUHERLOHUEXW
ZLWKOLTXLGSKDVHVLQWKHFRQGHQVHUDQGVHWWOHU2QHRIWKHOLTXLGSKDVHVLVUHIOX[HGWRWKH
D]HRWURSLFFROXPQ

\ RUJ [ RUJ S RUJ [ RUJ + RUJ [ RUJ [ RUJ + RUJ 93 RUJ [ RUJ  LQRUJ
& RUJ Z LQ ZDWHU LQ Z LQ Z
 
\Z [ Z SZ [ Z 93 Z [ Z [ Z 93 Z 93 Z [ RUJ  LQZ

  $WVROXELOLW\SW [ Z LQZ DQG[ RUJ LQZ  [ RUJ LQRUJ  
  9DSRUSUHVVXUHV3HUU\ *UHHQ1EXWDQRO
   7 ƒ&ƒ&Oƒ&ƒ&
   93 PP+J PP+J

  :DWHU7 ƒ&93 PP+J7 93aPP+J
93RUJ  93RUJ 
  DWƒ&  DW  
93Z  93Z 
 )RU RUJ Z
XVHDYHUDJHEHWZHHQDQGƒ&&DQOLQHDUO\LQWHUSRODWHDW7 ƒ&
  93RUJ  93Z   RUJ Z LQZ    
    Z RUJ LQZ  RUJ Z LQZ    
Z R [Z [ Z
 )URP \ Z JHQHUDWHHTXLOLEULXPFXUYH
 Z R  [Z  [ Z
[Z      
        
\Z      
   $WFRQVWDQW [ Z WKHFDOFXODWHG \ Z \ Z H[S HUL PLQ WDO 'LIIHUHQFHDW [ %  LV 
   DSSUR[LPDWHO\      

  7KHVHHTXDWLRQVZRUNEHWWHUIRUPL[WXUHVZKLFKDUHPRUHFRPSOHWHO\LPPLVFLEOH




' 1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ 7RS2S(T \ / 9 [  / 9 [ '  [ '  
/ / '  /
       \LQWHUFHSW [   ['   
9  / '  9
     [%  IURPGLDJUDP1HHGHTXLO6WDJHV

"#$%&!'(#!%#()*+,!-./0.!

'7KHFROXPQVDUHVNHWFKHGLQWKH6ROXWLRQWR3UREOHP& % LVEXWDQROSKDVHDQG %  LVZDWHU

SURGXFW7ZRHTXLOLEULXPGLDJUDPVDUHVKRZQ
  D ) % %  )] %[ %  % [ % 



 ] [ %  
   %   % ) %  
[ % [ %  
/ /
  E &RO%RWWRP2S \ [  [ % ,QWHUVHFWV \ [ [ %  
9 
9
T  
   )HHG/LTXLGT  ,QWHUVHFWV\ [ ] 
T   
/ /
   7RS \ [  [ % 
9 9
/   /
  )URP)LJXUH'D      
9 PLQ   9
/
   \LQWHUFHSW [   [ %  
9

1RWHWKDWUHIOX[LV [   2SWLPXPIHHGVWDJH 1HHGDERXWVWDJHVSDUWLDOUHERLOHU

/ /
  6WULSSHU&ROXPQ \ [  [ % 
9 
9

/ 9 % 9 %  

     
9 
9 9 % 

 &RQVWUXFWLRQLVVKRZQLQ)LJXUH'E1HHGHTFRQWDFWVRU35HTXLOVWDJH





' 


 


















D \ [ IURPJUDSK %9) 

/ ) 9  9)  
   )] 9\/[   
9 9 9)  
/ )  
   ) 9/   \ [ ] [ 
9 9  
   9±9 6HH(QODUJHGILJXUH>%HFDUHIXOZLWKVFDOHV@
  9   NJPROHV  K  \ Z  [ Z  
  / NJPROHVK 
) ]Z [ Z    NJPROHVKU
9  
\Z [Z   KU
  8VH7DEOHWRILQG 9 7GUXP # \ Z  [Z  / DQG 7GUXP a  &  




 
' &RPSRVLWLRQV [   [  >6KRZQRQ)LJXUH'D@
   ) / / DQG )]  / [ / [ 
) ] [   
  / NPROHVKU /  NPROHVKU
[ [  
' D :DWHUFRQF:LV
   ) :% : ±%
  :DWHUEDODQFH )] :%
  6ROYH% NPROKU: NPROKU
9 % 9 %   / /
 E / 9 %RW2S(T \ [  [ % 
9 9 %  9 9
 *RHVWKURXJK \ [ [% 



   
  3ORWRSHUDWLQJOLQH,I\  [  

  35VWDJHVPRUHVWKDQVXIILFLHQWVHHJUDSK
 
 F / 9 6ORSH  
PLQ
 
9  
  / 9  
PLQ
/ 9 / 9  

  




' 1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ


)! !!
' [ GLVW !

1+'*23!
! !
!

9! /
!

% [ ERW
!

'3DUWD ) ' %
  )  ' % 
] [%  
  ' )  
[' [%  
E  9 9 % %  5HIOX[ / / 9 9  
  2U9 ) ' /     
/ 9 % 9 %   
 F   
9 9 9 % 
/ /
   \ [  [% 
9 9
  *RHVWKURXJK \ [ [% 

  &DOFXODWHDUELWUDU\SRLQWDW [  
    \      
 6HH)LJXUH1HHGVWDJHV35

9 9 
 G :KDWLV 9 % "  2QJUDSK
0,1 % 0,1
/ 9 / 9 
0$;



 




 \ : [ : LQRUJDQLF \$  \ :   
'  : $  
LQRUJDQLF \ $ [ $LQRUJDQLF [ $LQRUJDQLF  [ : LQRUJDQLF  

 
  : $  
LQRUJDQLF  

'  &RQYHUWZWIUDFWRPROHIUDF
   0:& + 2    DQG0:ZDWHU  

  %DVLVNJ
  ZWIUDFHWKHU NJ: NJPROHV
     NJ( 
      7RWDO 
      [ : LQRUJDQLF  

  ZWIUDFHWKHU NJ: NJPROHV
      NJ( NJPROHV
      [ : LQRUJDQLF  

  \ HWKHU NJ: NJPROHV
      NJ( NJPROHV
      \ :  
\ : [ : LQRUJ  
   : (LQRUJ  
\( [ (  

   ]ZW ZDWHU NJ: NJPROHV
       NJ( NJPROHV
       ] :  

[  
   \ LQHTXLOZIHHG  
  [   

/ [' \ HTXLOZIHHG  
     
9 PLQ [' ]  

/ / 9 PLQ / /
        
' PLQ  / 9 PLQ
' DFW 9 DFW


  *HQHUDWHIROORZLQJHTXLOLEULXPGDWDXVLQJ Z ( LQRUJ  

[:    
\:     



 / /
  7RS2SOLQH \ [  [' 
9 9
  :KHUH/9  [ '  DQG\ LQWHUFHSW  

  %RWWRP)URP \ [ [ % WRLQWHUVHFWLRQRIIHHGOLQHDQGWRSRSHUDWLQJOLQH
    [ %  ZWIUDFNJ: NJPROHV
       NJ( NJPROH
  2EWDLQ [ %  

  6HHSORWLQ)LJXUH2SWLPXPIHHGLVWRSVWDJH1HHG  HTXLO&RQWDFWV



























' &RQYHUWWR0ROHIUDFWLRQV
  0:& + 2     0:ZDWHU  

  %DVLVIRUDOOFRQYHUVLRQVLVNJVROQ
  7RS/D\HU6HSDUDWRU ZWIUDFHWKHU
        NJ: NPROH
       NJHWKHU NPRO
        7RWDO NPRO

   0ROHIUDF [ Z LQRUJ  





 [' 
!

4.455!

9(::(,!;$<+#!=+%$#$:(#!>=! F--!HI!J!7!GK.--F!H,(*!

7!4.408!?:!'#$@.!+:&+#! 08!HI!L!!7!4.00-!H,(*!

A(*+!'#$@.! [ : LQRUJ  [' !

6!7!!4.48!
K0!HI!J!7!8.8M-!H,(*!
B$%(#!>C:(!D(CE+C=+#!>=!
FGF!HI!L!!7!F.K48!H,(*!
<$6+(:#(%+!7!4.FGF!?:!'#$@.!+:&+#!
A(*+!'#$@.! \ :  !


\ : [ : LQRUJ  
   : (  
LQRUJDQSKDVH \ ( [ (LQRUJ    
  )HHGLV \ :  PROHIUDFZDWHU ],QHTXLO:LWKIHHG
LQRUJ

\ 
     [ I    
 \   
[' ]   / / 9
  / 9 PLQ
   
[' [ I   ' PLQ  / 9
/ '
/ '  / ' PLQ   / 9  
  DFW DFW
 / '
  7RS2S \ / 9 [  /  9 [ ': WKURXJK \ [ [ ':  
  :KHQ[ \ 
[
  (T'DWD \ *HQHUDWHFXUYH
 [
    
[    
     \     
3ORWRQJUDSKDQGSORWWRSRSOLQH
[  \ [  \     
         [  \    
  [ : ERW LVDWLQWHUVHFWLRQ\ ] WRSRSOLQH [ :ERW  
  6WHSRIIVWDJHVIURPWRSGRZQHTXLOVWDJHLVVXIILFLHQW
   %XWZLWKWKLVYHU\KLJKUHIOX[UDWHFRQVLGHUDOWHUQDWLYHV



 
' D 93 [
& &
93 :
[:  
  $VVXPHWKHZDWHUOD\HULVSXUH [ :  7U\ƒ& 93&  93:  
    7RRORZ7U\KLJKHUWHPSHUDWXUH7KHDWWDFKHGSORWRI93
YV7DOORZVHVWLPDWLRQRIYDSRUSUHVVXUH1RWHDSORWRIORJ93YV7ZLOOEHHDVLHU
WRLQWHUSRODWHDQGH[WUDSRODWH
    ƒ& 93&  93:   
    ƒ& 93&  93:   
  7 JLYHV 93:  ZKLFKZLOOEHWRRKLJK7KXV7 ƒ&LVFORVHHQRXJK



 QZ S WRW 93RUJ [ RUJ   
 E  
Q RUJ 93RUJ [ RUJ  
  7KLVLVVLJQLILFDQWO\OHVVWKDQLQ([DPSOHZKHUH PROGHFDQHDUH
XVHG'LIIHUHQFHLVGXHWRKLJKHUQGHFDQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQLQOLTXLG


'  [ )RUJ  UHFRYHU\ĺOHIW2FWDQROOHIW  NPROK
  1RQYRODWLOHVLQERWWRPV NPROK

(@:$C(*!

?$:+#!


[ RF WDQ RO  !
LQRUJ  
[) !

J!

=:+$,!



 %
D:DWHU 93 FDQEHILWWR ORJ 93 $ RYHUVKRUWUDQJHV7 7LQ & 93 LVPP+J
 7
%
   7  ORJ   $   $ %   
 
%
   7 ORJ  $   $ %   
 

   7RVROYHIRU$DQG%VXEWUDFWIURP
% %
      % % 
 
%
     $   

 1RZILQG7IRUZKLFK S WRW 93: [ : 932 [ 2 PP+JZKHUH[ :  [ 2  
  2Q6SUHDG6KHHWILQG7 ƒ&
93 2 [ 2 
 E \ 2    
S WRW 

  \: [   

D 0ROHVRFWDQRO  ) ] 2      NPROK
\: 
E 0ROHVZDWHU Q: Q RUJ   
\ RUJ 

  &KHFN(T Q :     
 


[ 3% [ 3GLVW
'1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQN**!@$=+=! %  %  O! '  % !
[ 3GLVW [ 3GLVW 

 
D '     
 
 '     7RWDOIHHG&RO 

E  '    

 '  7RWDOIHHG&RO 


 



' 1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ! !
!
! ) !!!!!!
! ' [ !
! ! GLVW

!
!
! 9 ! /
! !
! ) !
!
! 9! /
!
!
!
!
!
!
! % [ ERW
! !
P$#:!$.! ) ) ' %   ' % !
! ! ! J$:+#Q
! )] ) ]  '[ GLVW %[ ERW      '  %  ! !
! ! ! R(*S+!=>,2*:$C+(2=*<O!/!7!FF.8G!$CE!9!7!-4.MG!
9
! ! )T! ! 9 %  / 9 %  !
%
! ! ! R>C@+!'++E!8!>=!=$:2#$:+E!*>U2>E! 9 9  !
! ! ! ! / / )  !
F'RLQJ0DVVEDODQFHDURXQGWRS 'RLQJ0DVVEDODQFHDURXQGERWWRP
! ! 9 \ )] /[ '[ GLVW 9 \ %[ ERW /[ ) ]  !
/ '[ GLVW )] / ) ]  %[ ERW
\ \ [
9 9 9 9
!!!!!!!!!!!
! ! ! V&+=+!:?(!+U2$:>(C=!$#+!+U2>S$*+C:.!
/ /
! ! ET! 9(:.!(%.!*>C+Q! \ [  [ % .!!"(+=!:&#(2I&! \ [ [ % .!
9 9
/ 9 % 9 % 
! ! ! R*(%+!   .!!P*(:!9(:!W%.!*>C+.!
9 9 9 %
/ 
! ! ! W%.!*>C+!$)(S+!'++E!8Q! R*(%+!  !
9 
! ! ! N:!>C:+#=+@:>(C! ) !'++E!*>C+!$CE!)(:!(%.!*>C+!X$:! [  \  T!?>:&!!
! ! ! ! ! VORSH  !
! ! ! 8!=:$I+=!Y!P1!>=!,(#+!:&$C!=2''>@>+C:!XR++!I#$%&T.!



 !

"#$%&!IRU'

')LJXUHLVRQQH[WSDJH

3DUWE ) % %   )] %[ (% % [ ( 
%

] [ %  
  % )    % ) %  NPROK
[ % [ %  
] [ E [ E [ G    
F ' )    
[ E [ E [ G [G    
   ' ' %  NPROK
!



 '
' !
!
[(  !

040.5!HP$!
0555!
[!
4.KKF!! HP$!
](  !
+:&$C(*!

J$:+#!
L:&$C(*!
FF.K!,(*+!Z!?$:+#!
FF.8!,(*+!Z!
% !
! 
8.D.15. 3DUWD1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ
S RUJ 93RF WDQ RO [ RF WDQ RO  3WRWDO ZKHUH[ RF WDQ RO LVPROHIUDFWLRQRFWDQROLQRUJDQLFSKDVH
  $WDWPDQGERLOLQJ7 SRUJ DWP PP+J 
 )URP$QWRLQHHTXDWLRQ

  ORJ 93 RF WDQ RO
 
7 
 $W  7 & 93RFWDQRO PP+J 
S RUJ 
 6LQFH S RUJ PP+J [ RFWDQROPROH  
93EHQ]HQH 
 $YHUDJHPROHZWVROLGVDQGQRQYRODWLOHRUJDQLFVFDQEHFDOFXODWHG%DVLVNJ
PRORFWDQRO  
    
PRORFWDQRO PROQRQYRODWLOHV  
 0:
  
  0:  
 0: 
E UHFRYHU\LVWUXHRQERWKPDVVDQGPROHEDVLV
 'LVWLOODWHRFWDQROIORZUDWH     NJ K 
 6LQFH 0:RF WDQ RO  WKLVLV    NPRO K 
,QZDVWHWKHUHDUH    NJ KU RFWDQRODQG  NJ K RUJDQLFVVROLGVRU
 NJ K WRWDO:WIUDFRFWDQRO    
 
 0ROHIUDFRFWDQROLQZDVWH  
   



F )RUHTXLOLEULXPLQVWLOOSRW 93 RFW
[ RFWLQRUJ 93Z  S WRW PP+J 
 7KHVWLOOSRWLVSHUIHFWO\PL[HGWKXV [ RFWLQRUJ [ RFWLQZDVWH PROHIUDF 
 6LQFHZDWHUERLOVDWƒ&ZKHQ 3 PP+J 7ƒ&
 (TEHFRPHV 93RFW  93Z   
 6XEVWLWXWLQJLQWKH$QWRLQHHTXDWLRQVIRURFWDQRODQGZDWHUDQGVROYLQJZLWKDVSUHDGVKHHW7 
ƒ&
  93RFW PP+JDQG93Z PP+J 
Q RFW 93RFW [ RFW
G )URP(T 
QZ S WRW 93RFW [ RFW
 )URPVSUHDGVKHHW Q RFW Q Z  
 6LQFH Q RFW  NPRO K Q Z Q RFW   NPRO K 
NPRO NJ
  ZDWHU   NJ K ZDWHULQGLVWLOODWH
NPRO NPRO
 7KLVLVDORWRIVWHDP

' 'LVWLOODWH(W2+VROYHQW&DOFXODWH [ G:    
 'LVWLOODWHZDWHUVROYHQW&DOFXODWH [ ' (    
 )  [ )(  VDW
GOLT
G[ )VROY 
 )LQG '  '   0ZKHUH0DNHXSLVSXUHVROYHQW
     
 :DWHU   [ : 0 )] : '[ ': '  [ ': 
     
 (WKDQRO   0[ (0 )] ( '[ G( '  [ G ( 

 (WK\OHQH*O\FRO 0[ (VROY  )] VROY '[ GVROY '[ G VROY 

 6ROYLQJZDWHU HWKDQROEDODQFHVREWDLQ '   DQG '  NPROK
 )URP(WK\OHQH*O\FROEDODQFH
     0      NPROK
 &DQDOVRXVHRYHUDOOEDODQFHLQVWHDGRI(*EDO7KHQ
     0 ' '  )     2.

'  1HZ 3UREOHP LQ UG HGLWLRQ    6LQFH HYHU\WKLQJ QRZ H[LWV WKH ERWWRPV %  6  ) DQG [ $ 
)]$6)[% )]%6)[VROYHQW 66)

' (WKDQRO3URGXFW(VROYHQWZDWHU

 :DWHU3URGXFW :VROYHQWHWKDQRO

 )  ] ( ] :  




 :DWHUEDO [ :0 0 )] : 3( [ (3: 3: [ :3:   $

 (EDO [ (0 0 )] ( 3( [ (3( 3: [ :3(    %
     
 (* [ 0VROYHQW 0 )] VROY 3( [ (3VROY 3: [ :3VROY ZKHUH [ 0VROYHQW  

 6ROYH$ % IRU3(  3:  3:  NPROK 3(  NPROK

    0      NPROHVK

' 0%DURXQG6\VWHP6LQFHHYHU\WKLQJLQZWXQLWV GR0%LQZWV

 2YHUDOO ) + % % ZKHUH+ PDNHXSKH[DQH

 (WKDQRO )] (  %[ (ERW  % [ (ERW  
   
 +H[DQH )] + +  %[ +ERW %  

 6ROYLQJVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ %  % DQG+  NJK

'1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQD  ) ( :
 
  ([ ((WKDQROSURG :[ (ZSURG 

   ( : 

  (  NPRO K 

  : ) (    
 
)[ :) ([ : (WKDQRO SURG    
 E 9 9  
\ Z  

  ERLOXSUDWLR 9 ( 3U RG  


  / 9 ( 3U RG    
  / / ) VDW
GOLTXLGIHHG    
  ,I&02VWULFWO\YDOLGWKHQ / UHIOX[  

  &DQDOVRHVWLPDWH / IURP B VHWWOHU 3HQWDQHIORZUDWHLQ9 (WKDQROIORZUDWHLQ 9

      (WKDQROORVWLQ:DWHU3URGXFW

  3HQWDQHIORZUDWH \ 39    



  (WKDQROIORZUDWHLQ 9 \ (9    
(LQ9 ( ORVW
[ (UHIOX[ 
/ IURPVHWWOHUWR&RO

(WKDQROORVW LQZDWHUSURGXFW : SURG [ ( LQ:SURG    

  /IURP B VHWWOHU B FDOFXODWLRQ  


  0DWFKQRWSHUIHFWEHFDXVH  &02QRWWRWDOO\YDOLG
    7KHUHLVVRPHZDWHULQUHIOX[
    . G( YDOXHPD\EHLQFRUUHFW

 F (WKDQROUHWXUQHGWRGLVWLOODWLRQFROXPQ 
   9 \ ( :3U RG [ (: 3U RG    NPRO K  
 
  8VLQJDYHUDJHHVWLPDWHIRU /   

  7KHQ   [ ( LQSHQWDQH 
   [ (SHQWDQH  [ (5H IOX[SDQWDQH B OD\HU 

  7KHQVLQFHDVVXPH . G  [ (:DWHU OD\HU 







 G [ (ZDWHU
  ! 9
 9  9 :  NPRO K
:
      
! / : 9 NPRO K
    0!   
     /  !  
      !!
9 

 /  : 
\ ( !
 9

    
 \ (  !


 : 
 !
[ (: 3U RG  !


'



 / 9 %   / /
%RWWRP  [% *RHVWKURXJK \
 \ [ [ [ % ZLWKVORSH 
9 9 %  9 9
 )HHGOLQH +RUL]RQWDOT 7KURXJK\ [ ] 
 7RS0% \9 /[ '[ ' DQG9 / ' 
/ /
    \ [ ' JRHVWKURXJK\ [ [ '  
[ 
9 9
  ,QWHUVHFWV)HHGOLQHZKHUHERWWRPRSOLQHGRHV
 2SW)HHGDERYHUHERLOHUHTXLOLEULXPVWDJHV35LVVXIILFLHQW

'1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ


!
' [ GLVW ! !

1+'*23!
! !
!

9! /
!

[! %!

3DUWD ) ' % )] '[ GLVW %[ ERW 

] [ ERW  
 ' )  NPROK DQG %  
[ GLVW [ ERW  

3DUWE \9 /[ '[ GLVW 
/ ' / /
 \ [ [ GLVW  6XEVWLWXWHLQ ' 9 / WRREWDLQ \ [  [ GLVW 
9 9 9 9
/
 3RLQWVRQRSHUDWLQJOLQH \ [ [ GLVW  DQG [  \LQWHUFHSW  [ GLVW  
9
 $OWHUQDWLYHSRLQWLVDWIHHGOLQH\ ]   [ [ ERW  
 9 ) / % WKXVVORSH / 9 % )    
 \LQWHUFHSW     
3DUWF 1HHG6WDJHV6HHJUDSK
3DUWG 3LQFKDWIHHGOLQHLQWHUVHFWLRQZLWKHTXLOLEULXPLVDW [  
!



 !

[>I2#+!'(#!%#()*+,!-/88.!




'1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ




J$:+#!%&$=+! ]\A!7!4.4-^!

\.A.!P&$=+!



3?!7!4.508! J! [!
 \A!

 J$:+#!!
\>:#(!A+:&$C+!!!! P#(E2@:!

P#(E2@:!
3DUWD ([WHUQDOEDODQFHV ) 10 3U RG :3U RG 

    10  )  10 3U RG  :3U RG  

 
   10 3U RG   :3URG  
 

D :&ROXPQ ] KRUL]RQWDOIHHGOLQH
/ /
7RS  \ 10 [ 10  [ 10 ERW FRO 10  0DVVEDODQFHWKURXJKWRSRI:FROXPQ
9 9
DQGDURXQGFRO10&DQHDVLO\VKRZWKDW



 \ 10 [ 10 [ 10ERWFRO10 
%XWGRQRWNQRZ/9VRFDQQRWSORW\HW
/ /
%RWWRPRSHUDWLQJOLQHORRNVIDPLOLDU \ 10 [  [ 10 ERW FROZ 
9 9
  \ 10 [ 10 [ 10ERWFROZ 
/ 9 %  
  
9 FRO Z
9 % 
&DQSORWERWWRPRSHUDWLQJOLQH$UELWUDU\SRLQW [  \     
1RZFDQSORWWRSRSHUDWLQJOLQHIURPLQWHUVHFWLRQRIERWWRPRSHUDWLQJOLQHDQGIHHGOLQHWRSRLQW
 \ 10 [ 10 [ 10ERWFROZ 
6HHJUDSK1HHG35a   VWDJH%XLOG35VWDJH
E 10&ROXPQLVDVWULSSLQJFROXPQ \Z / 9 [Z / 9  [ Z ERW FRO 10 

9

% 
  / 9 
FRO10 9 
%
  \Z [Z [ ZERW10 B FRO  
 
7RSORW [Z  \ Z    [ Z LVDUELWUDU\SRLQW 
 

 1HHG35a  VWDJHV

9  
F :FRO:DQW9 9  9 9 % :3URG   
%  
   9WRFRQGIURP :FRO  NPRO KU 
9
 10FROZDQW 99 %  10 3U RG    NPRO KU 7RFRQGHQVHU
%
! !



 !

*UDSKIRU'


 



'1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ)URP(TXLOLEULXP \ EX WDQ RO  DW [ EX WDQ RO  
2YHUDOO0DVV%DODQFH  ) 9 % 
%XWDQRO0%   9  %  
   9 ) 9  
  9 9  %  NPRO KU 
7KLVSUREOHPFDQDOVREHVROYHGJUDSKLFDOO\EXWXVLQJEDVLFPDVVEDODQFHVLVHDVLHU

'1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ3DUWD  SRUJ 93EHQ]HQH [ EHQ]HQH ZKHUH [ EHQ]HQH LV
PROHIUDFWLRQEHQ]HQHLQRUJDQLF$WERLOLQJ7 S RUJ DWP 

 )URP$QWRLQHHTXDWLRQ ORJ 93 EHQ]HQH
 
7 
 $W 7  &  93EHQ]HQH PP+J 6LQFH
S RUJ 
 S RUJ  [ EHQPROH  
93EHQ]HQH 
 $YHUDJHPROHZWVROLGVDQGQRQYRODWLOHRUJDQLFVFDQEHFDOFXODWHG%DVLVNJ

0ROHVEHQ]HQH  
    
0ROHVEHQ]HQH0ROHVQRQYRODWLOHV  
 0:
     
    0:  
 0:  0: 

E UHFRYHU\LVWUXHRQERWKPDVVDQGPROHEDVLV
 'LVWLOODWHEHQ]HQHIORZUDWH     NJ K  
 6LQFH 0:EHQ]HQH WKLVLV   NPRO K 
 ,QZDVWHWKHUHDUHNJKEHQ]HQHDQGNJKRUJDQLFVVROLGVRUNJKWRWDO
   :WIUDFEHQ]HQH    
 
   0ROHIUDFEHQ]HQH  
   
F )RUHTXLOLEULXPLQVWLOOSRW 93 E
[ E LQRUJ 93Z  S WRW PP+J 
 7KHVWLOOSRWLVSHUIHFWO\PL[HGWKXV [ ELQRUJ [ ELQZDVWH PROHIUDF 
 6LQFHZDWHUERLOVDWž&ZKHQ 3 PP+J  7  & %HQ]HQHLVPRUHYRODWLOHDQG
ERLOVDWž&EXWPROHIUDFVORZ

 $QWRLQHHTXDWLRQIRUZDWHU ORJ 93Z  
 7
 (TEHFRPHV 93E  93Z   
 6XEVWLWXWLQJLQWKH$QWRLQHHTXDWLRQVIRUEHQ]HQHDQGZDWHUDQGVROYLQJZLWKDVSUHDGVKHHW
7  &  93EHQ PP+JDQG93Z PP+J 




 Q EHQ 93EHQ [ EHQ
G )URP(T 
QZ S WRW 93EHQ [ EHQ
 )URPVSUHDGVKHHW Q EHQ Q Z    
 6LQFH  Q EHQ  NPRO KU  Q Z Q EHQ   NPRO KU

NPRO NJ
   ZDWHU 
  NJ K ZDWHULQGLVWLOODWH
NPRO NPRO 
Q EHQ EHQ
H7RYDSRUL]HEHQ]HQHFRQGHQVHPROHVZDWHU 
Z

 7KLVRFFXUVDW  & . )URP3HUU\¶VWDEOH


+ KJ K KI + K N- NJ

7    

7    
    

 N-
 /LQHDULQWHUSRODWH [    
  N- NPRO 
 NJ
 1RWH WKHGLWLRQ7DEOHLVYHU\VOLJKWO\GLIIHUHQWDIWHUXQLWFRQYHUVLRQ
 7    
:DWHU7DEOH  7    


  Z     N- NJ N- NPRO 

  
 0ROHVZDWHUFRQGHQVHG  NPRO K ZDWHULQZDVWH

  NJ K ZDWHULQZDVWH    NJ K




 



 
(1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ






 J$:+#!%&$=+!
 ]\A!7!4.4-^!
 \.A.!P&$=+!



 3?!7!4.508! J! )
) 
! \A! !







 J$:+#!!
\>:#(!A+:&$C+!!!! P#(E2@:!

P#(E2@:!

3DUWD    ) ) 310 3:  
   10EDODQFH  )]10 ) ]  10 301 [ 103URG 3Z [ Z 3U RG 
10PROIUDF 10PROIUDF

      310  3Z  

    310  310  310  
 310    NPRO KU 
 3Z    
E &ROXPQ:±8VH \ 10 YV[ 10 ZDWHUSKDVHSORW
) ] 10 
 7RSRSHUDWLQJOLQH \ 10 / 9 ZDWHU [ 10  / 9 ZFRO
[ 10
FRO 10 3U RG 9ZFRO

%RWWRP2SHUDWLQJ/LQH \ 10 / 9 ZDWHU [ 10 / 9 ZDWHU  [ 10 

FRO FRO :DWHU  3U RG

  
9
9 % 9 %   9 % FRO Z  9
 / 9  % 
9 9 % 
/ 9 % FRO Z   / )



 7RS,6127IURP \ [ [ 10  WRLQWHUVHFWLRQIHHGDQGERWWRPRSHUDWLQJOLQH
10  3U RG

,QVWHDGIURPLQWHUVHFWLRQRIIHHGDQGERWWRPRSHUDWLQJOLQHZLWKVORSH
  / 9 / ) 9     
 2SWLPXPIHHGLVWRSVWDJH1HHG35VWDJH

)]10
F &ROXPQ107RS \ / 9 10 [Z  / 9 10 [ Z 
FRO FRO ::3URG 9
 %RWWRP \Z / 9 [Z / 9  [Z 
10FRO 10FRO
LQ:03URG

/ 9 % 
   \Z [Z [Z  
 
10  3U RG 9 9 %
 'UDZERWWRPRSHUDWLQJOLQH7RSLVWKURXJKLQWHUVHFWLRQERWWRPRSHUDWLQJOLQHDQGIHHGOLQH) 
6ORSH / 9  VHHLWHPG1HHGVWDJHV352SWLPXPIHHGLVVWDJHDERYH35

G &ROXPQ: 3: %FROZ    
 9 9 % %FROZ     
    / 9 %FROZ   / / )  
NPRO
 6DWXUDWHGOLTXLGIHHG 9 9  
KU
 &ROXPQ10  9 %  310 %FRO10    
9 % 
    / 9  
9 %
    9 9 % %  NPRO KU  /    
 6DWXUDWHGOLTXLGIHHG 9 9   / /    / 9  !
H 0LQLPXPERLOXSUDWH 10 FROXPQ JLYHVFRPELQDWLRQERWWRP WRSRSHUDWLQJOLQHVWRJRWKURXJK
UHIOX[SRLQW \ :  [ Z  
 )URPERWWRPRSHUDWLQJOLQHLQWHUVHFWLRQZLWKIHHGOLQH [ ]  LV
/ /
    \ ,17(5 ] [ : 10 3URG 
9 9
  6ORSHRIWRSRSHUDWLQJOLQHWRUHIOX[SRLQWLV
/  \ ,17(5 / )
    
9   9
   
9 
   9 %   9 9 % %  9 %   / 9 %
/ 9 / 9  
/ )
  *XHVV 9 % &DOF9 / / 9 &DOF\ LQW HU &DOF / 9 
9
 &KHFNLVWZRFDOFXODWHGYDOXHV / 9 DUHVDPH  



 6SUHDGVKHHW 9 %   / 9  
0,1

!

*UDSKIRU3UREOHP(



( %DODQFHVDWPL[LQJSRLQWIRU) 5

  7R%XWDQRO&ROXPQ
  2YHUDOO )7 ) 5  5 
  :DWHU  )7 ] 7: )] : 5[ :UHIOX[ )7 ] 7:  5 
5  
    ] 7: 
 5
  ([WHUQDOEDODQFHV :% ZDWHU :%
  6ROYHVLPXOWDQHRXVO\:  % NPROK

  %XWDQRO&RO 9 %  9 %  
    )7 / 9 %   / 9  
     \ [ [ :EXWRQDO  
    5 )7 )    
  
   ]7  

  9HUWLFDOIHHGOLQHDW ] 7 LQWHUVHFWVERWRSHUDWLQJ/LQHDW\ VHHJUDSK

9 % 9 % 
:DWHU&RO  9 %   / 9  
9 9 %

    \ / 9 [ / 9  [ %ZDWHUZDWHUFRO  \ [ [ %:  
ZDWHUFRO

  6HHJUDSK\OHDYLQJFROXPQ 





 
  






( %DVLVNJVHDZDWHUK
 NJZDWHU NPRO NJ NPRO[ ):  

 NJ1D&O NPRO NJ NPRO[ )VDOW  
7RWDO 
 :DWHU&RQGHQVDWH  NPROK  Q : 
 :DWHU5HPDLQLQJ± 
NJPROHV:
 :DVWH:DWHULV  PROHIUDFZDWHU
VDOW

D ,QVWLOORUJDQLFSKDVHLVSXUHGHFDQH
   93& 93: [ : S WRW PP+JZKHUH[ :  
 7U\7 ƒ& 93& a  93:  PP+J
    PP+JZKLFKLVWRRKLJK
 &RQYHUJHWR7aƒ&
Q: \: S: 93: [ :  
 E 'LVWLOODWH  
Q RUJ \ RUJ S RUJ 93RUJ [ RUJ  
 7KLVFDOFXODWLRQLVDWƒ&QRWEXWZLOOEHFORVH




NPROZDWHUK NPRO
   Q &  & LQGLVWLOODWH
PROZDWHUPRORUJDQLF K

) 93'DWDQQRQDQHS3HUU\ *UHHQ
   
93       PP+J
7       ƒ& 

 6HH 6ROXWLRQ SUREOHP ' IRU SORW 0:Q&     )URP S  3HUU\  *UHHQ
QRQDQHHQWKDOSLHVDUH
7 KOLTXLG +JDV
. .-NJ 
. 
 
:DWHU93LVJLYHQLQ3UREOHP'DQGRQSRI3HUU\DQG*UHHQ

 D 7U\ƒ& 93&  PP+J 93:  $VVXPHZDWHULVSXUH 
   3UHVVXUH &ORVHHQRXJKDQGOXFN\

Q: S WRW 93RUJ [ RUJ   
  E  PROZDWHUPROQRQDQH
Q RUJ 93RUJ [ RUJ  

  F 1HHGWRFDOFXODWHWKHHQHUJ\UHTXLUHGWRYDSRUL]HWKHQRQDQH7  .
 %\OLQHDULQWHUSRODWLRQIRUSXUHQRQDQH K a  +JDV a  QRQDQH .-NJ  

 7DEOHRI3HUU\DQG*UHHQ K OLT:  + YDS :   : .-NJ 
PROZDWHUFRQGHQVHG &
.-NJ NJNPRO
     
PRO& YDSRUL]HG : .-NJ NJNPRO
E 1RZ 93&  93:  7HPSHUDWXUHZLOOEHKLJKHU
    7U\ƒ& 93& PP+J93:  
     ZKLFKLVWRRORZ

    7U\ž& 93&  93:  
     &ORVHHQRXJK

   7KHORZQRQDQHFRQFUHGXFHVQRQDQHSDUWLDOSUHVVXUHDQGRSHUDWLRQLVPXFKFORVHUWRƒ&
Q: S WRW 93RUJ [ RUJ   
      
Q RUJ 93RUJ [ RUJ  

   1HHGORWPRUHVWHDP



) 

C_C(C$C+!

?$:+#!
[!7!0444!
FGZ!C_C(C$C+!
(#I$C>@!

?$=:+!

=:+$,!
?$:+#!


   %DVLVKRXU
$OOMXQNLQIHHGNPROLVLQERWWRPV
  D 
2UJDQLF%RWWRPVLVQ& MXQN VHHSDUW&

     [ &ERW RUJ  

  E 6WLOO7 S : S RUJ S WRW N3D PP+J 
     S: 93: 7[ : ZKHUH[ : 
   SRUJ . & 7 [ FRUJERW . & 7   PP+J  . & 7 
   3URFHGXUH*XHVV7GHWHUPLQH 93: . & FKHFNLISUHVVXUHHTLVYDOLG
     93 :
. &  PP+J"
   7U\7 ƒ&  93:  . &
 'H3ULHVWHU&KDUW
          1HHGKLJKHU7
     7 ƒ& 93: DQG. &  
      VOLJKWO\ORZEXWFORVHHQRXJK

 F NPRO QQRQDQHî NPRO QQRQDQHLQGLVWLOODWH ±  NPRO Q&LQ
ERWWRPV
Q RUJ S RUJ  Q RUJ 
 G (T  Q :  NPROZDWHU
Q: S :   

 H (%VLPSOLHVWR : Q :FRQGHQVHG QRQDQH Q RUJGLVW ZKHUHȜ¶VDUHDWƒ& .
& &
      Q : FRQGHQVHG Q RUJGLVW NPRO 
: :




   )URP3HUU\¶VWKHG7DEOHRUWKHG7DEOHQRQDQHȜ¶VDUH
K J K I #.   N-NJ
      
.   N-NJ
 
     #.Ȝ§  N-NJ

     0: &  7KHQDW.
N- NJ
     &   N-NPRO 
NJ NPRO
    :DWHU. 3HUU\¶VWK(G7DEOH
N- NJ N-
    :     
NJ NPRO NJ

       Q : FRQG   NPROZDWHU


*1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ
)LQDOPDNHXSVROYHQWIORZUDWHBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBNPROK
)LQDOYDOXHVROYHQWUHF\FOHUDWH%BBBBBNPROKDQG/'LQFROBB
)LQDOYDOXHVRIIORZUDWHV'BB%BBDQG'BBBBBNPROK
0ROHIUDFWLRQVLQVWUHDP'B3\U : %LVSKHQRO (B
0ROHIUDFWLRQVLQVWUHDP'B3\U : %LVSKHQ BBB
0ROHIUDFWLRQVLQVWUHDP%B3\U : %LVSKHQ B
0ROHIUDFWLRQVLQVWUHDP%VROYHQWUHF\FOHVWUHDP3\U (: (%LVSKHQRO 
BB
+HDWORDGLQFRROHURQVROYHQWUHF\FOHOLQHBB(BBBFDOV


*1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ $VSHQ3OXV5HVLGXH3ORWDWPXVLQJ157/

   3UHVVXUHFDQKDYHPDMRUHIIHFWRQ9/(IRUQRQLGHDOV\VWHPV&RPSDUH7[\GLDJUDPVIRU
DFHWRQH0(.DWDQGDWP

   $OVRFRPSDUHUHVLGXHFXUYHVIRUDFHWRQH0(.0,%.DW DWP



 !



 !



*1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ
D)LQDOUHIOX[UDWLRFROXPQBBBBDQGILQDOUHIOX[UDWLRFROXPQBBBBBBBB,IWKHVHYDOXHVDUH
QRW\RXDUHQRWILQLVKHGZLWK3DUW%
E)ORZUDWHVIXUIXUDOSURGXFWBBBBBBNPROKDQGZDWHUSURGXFWBBBBBNPROK
F%RLOXSUDWHLQFROXPQBBBBBBBBBBBBBNPROK
G0ROHIUDFWLRQIXUIXUDOLQIXUIXUDOSURGXFWBBBBBBB PROHIUDFWLRQZDWHULQZDWHUSURGXFW
BBBBBBB
H)ORZUDWHRIGLVWLOODWHIURPFROXPQBBBBBBBBBBNPROK
I&ROXPQFRQGHQVHUWHPSHUDWXUHBBBBB. FROXPQUHERLOHUWHPSBBBB.
J2XWOHWWHPSHUDWXUHRIGHFDQWHUBBBBBBBBBB.
K0RODUUDWLRRIZDWHUSKDVHWRWDOOLTXLGLQGHFDQWHUBBBBBBBBBB

*1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ
&ROXPQD%RWWRPVSURGXFWPROHIUDFWLRQDFHWRQLWULOHBBBBBBBBBBBB
 E'LVWLOODWHIORZUDWHBBBBBBBNPROKDQGERWWRPVIORZUDWHBBBBBBBNPROK
 F'LVWLOODWHPROHIUDFWLRQDFHWRQLWULOHBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

&ROXPQD'LVWLOODWHIORZUDWHBBBBBBBBBBNPROKDQGUHIOX[UDWLRBBBBBBB
 E%RWWRPVSURGXFWPROHIUDFWLRQZDWHUBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
 F'LVWLOODWHPROHIUDFWLRQDFHWRQLWULOHBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

*1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ
5HVXOWVDUHUHVLGXHFXUYHVDQGSURILOHVRIPROHIUDFWLRQYVSODWHORFDWLRQ)RUDQHTXDOPRODUIHHG1 
GRHVQRWJLYHWKHGHVLUHGSXULW\HYHQLI/' 1 GRHVZRUNZLWK/' EXWQRWIRU/' 

+3DUWE:DV'LQQGHGLWLRQRI63( 8VH(TEZLWK
$%   %%   %&  
 $ EHQ]HQH% WROXHQH& FXPHQH5HVXOWVIURP6SUHDGVKHHW
6WDJH5HERLOHU [ $   [ %   [ &  
   

  
   
   
   
   
   
   (
   (
   (
   (
   (

+:DV'LQQGHGLWLRQRI63(8VHDVSUHDGVKHHWZLWK(TDVUHFXUVLRQHTXDWLRQ
  5HVXOW LVVKRZQLQ)LJXUH 7KH 9%$SURJUDPZDVJLYHQ LQ([DPSOH7KHUHVXOWV REWDLQHG
IRUWKHVWDUWLQJFRQGLWLRQVJLYHQDUH
H! ! ! 3N! ! ! 39 ! ! ! 3D!
0! ! ! 4.FF4! ! 4.440! ! ! 4.44F!
044!! ! 4.FM^5! ! 4.440M! ! ! 4.4884!
844!! ! 4.FK50! ! 4.448F! ! ! 4.4G5K!
544!! ! 4.-^54! ! 4.44KF! ! ! 4.0550!



K44!! ! 4.^MK4! ! 4.44MM! ! ! 4.50-5!
KG4!! ! 4.G4KK! ! 4.44-F! ! ! 4.K-^M!
KMG!! ! 4.5FK^! ! 4.44F8! ! ! 4.GF^8!
G44!! ! 4.8^F^! ! 4.44-F! ! ! 4.M80K!
^44!! ! 4.444K8! ! 4.444FG! ! 4.FF-^!

5HVXOWVIRURWKHUVWDUWLQJFRQGLWLRQVDUHVKRZQLQWKHILJXUH
 



 )LJXUHIRUSUREOHP+

!

-`.5.!1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQV&+!=%#+$E!=&++:!>C@*2E>CI!:&+!'>#=:!04!:>,+!=:+%=!$CE!:>,+!=:+%=!^44!
:(!^04O!$CE!:&+!B9N!%#(I#$,!$#+!*>=:+E.!
3DUWD      
!
!
       



 6LPSOHGLVWLOODWLRQFDOFUHVLGXHFXUYHVZLWK%3FDOFV 
 D7 D7 DS    
L%      
Q%      
L3      
Q3      
QKH[      
       
5HVLGXHFXUYHFDOF K  1  HSVLORQ (
[L%  [Q%  [L3  [Q3 
VXP[  7JXHVV5 SSVLD  [Q+H[ 
WLPHVWHS [L% [Q% [L3 [Q3 [Q+H[ 75 
       
      
      
      
      
      
      
      
      
      
!
      
      
      
      
      
      
      
      
      
      
      
!
W%:>(C!L3%*>@>:!
R2)!1+=>E2+aD2#S+a9P@$*@XT!
b!!!c!S$*2+!E$:$!'(#!C)2:$C+O>)2:$C+O!>%+C:$C+OC%+C:$C+!$CE!C&+3$C+!>C@*2E+E.!
b!!!WC*<!?$C:!5!'(#!#+=>E2+!@2#S+.!V&2=O!=+:!3!S$*2+=!7!4!'(#!8!@(,%(C+C:=.!
b!!!V&+!#+'+#+C@+!@(,%(C+C:!>=!C)2:$C+.!
/>,!>O!\O!d!N=!eC:+I+#!
/>,!&O!+%=>*(CO!3>9O!3C9O!3>PO!3CPO!3C`+3!N=!/(2)*+!
/>,!VO!%O!$V0>9O!$V^>9O!$%0>9O!$V0C9O!$V^C9O!N%0C9!N=!/(2)*+!
/>,!$V0>PO!$V^>PO!$%0>PO!$V0CPO!$V^CPO!$%0CPO!$V0C`+3O!$V^C`+3O!$%0C`+3!N=!/(2)*+!
/>,!c>9O!cC9O!c>PO!cCPO!cC`+3O!c=2,O!@&H=2,O!>C=>E+!N=!/(2)*+!
/>,!<>9O!<C9O!<>PO!<CPO!<C`+3!N=!/(2)*+!
!
R&++:=XfR&++:0fT.R+*+@:!



1$CI+XfN0GfO!f"04KGfT.D*+$#!
$V0>9!7!D+**=XGO!8T.B$*2+!
$V^>9!7!D+**=XGO!5T.B$*2+!
$%0>9!7!D+**=XGO!KT.B$*2+!
$V0C9!7!D+**=X^O!8T.B$*2+!
$V^C9!7!D+**=X^O!5T.B$*2+!
N%0C9!7!D+**=X^O!KT.B$*2+!
$V0>P!7!D+**=XMO!8T.B$*2+!
$V^>P!7!D+**=XMO!5T.B$*2+!
$%0>P!7!D+**=XMO!KT.B$*2+!
$V0CP!7!D+**=X-O!8T.B$*2+!
$V^CP!7!D+**=X-O!5T.B$*2+!
$%0CP!7!D+**=X-O!KT.B$*2+!
$V0C`+3!7!D+**=XFO!8T.B$*2+!
$V^C`+3!7!D+**=XFO!5T.B$*2+!
$%0C`+3!7!D+**=XFO!KT.B$*2+!
&!7!D+**=X00O!KT.B$*2+!
\!7!D+**=X00O!^T.B$*2+!
+%=>*(C!7!D+**=X00O!-T.B$*2+!
3>9!7!D+**=X08O!8T.B$*2+!
3C9!7!D+**=X08O!KT.B$*2+!
3>P!7!D+**=X08O!^T.B$*2+!
3CP!7!D+**=X08O!-T.B$*2+!
3C`+3!7!D+**=X05O!-T.B$*2+!
V!7!D+**=X05O!KT.B$*2+!
%!7!D+**=X05O!^T.B$*2+!
[(#!>!7!0!V(!\!
d!7!>!Y!0!
/(!
c>9!7!L3%XX$V0>9!g!XV!h!VTT!Y!$V^>9!Y!X$%0>9!h!;(IX%TTT!
cC9!7!L3%XX$V0C9!g!XV!h!VTT!Y!$V^C9!Y!XN%0C9!h!;(IX%TTT!
c>P!7!L3%XX$V0>P!g!XV!h!VTT!Y!$V^>P!Y!X$%0>P!h!;(IX%TTT!
cCP!7!L3%XX$V0CP!g!XV!h!VTT!Y!$V^CP!Y!X$%0CP!h!;(IX%TTT!
cC`+3!7!L3%XX$V0C`+3!g!XV!h!VTT!Y!$V^C`+3!Y!X$%0C`+3!h!;(IX%TTT!
c=2,!7!c>9!h!3>9!Y!cC9!h!3C9!Y!c>P!h!3>P!Y!cCP!h!3CP!Y!cC`+3!h!3C`+3!
cC9!7!cC9!g!c=2,!
>C=>E+!7!$V0C9!g!X;(IXcC9T!_!$V^C9!_!XN%0C9!h!;(IX%TTT!
V!7!RU#X>C=>E+T!
@&H=2,!7!c=2,!_!0!
;((%!J&>*+!N)=X@&H=2,T!i!+%=>*(C!
D+**=X05!Y!>!Y!0O!0T.B$*2+!7!>!
D+**=X05!Y!>!Y!0O!8T.B$*2+!7!3>9!
D+**=X05!Y!>!Y!0O!5T.B$*2+!7!3C9!
D+**=X05!Y!>!Y!0O!KT.B$*2+!7!3>P!
D+**=X05!Y!>!Y!0O!GT.B$*2+!7!3CP!
D+**=X05!Y!>!Y!0O!^T.B$*2+!7!3C`+3!
D+**=X05!Y!>!Y!0O!MT.B$*2+!7!V!
<>9!7!3>9!h!c>9!



<C9!7!3C9!h!cC9!
<>P!7!3>P!h!c>P!
<CP!7!3CP!h!cCP!
<C`+3!7!3C`+3!h!cC`+3!
3>9!7!3>9!Y!X&!h!X3>9!_!<>9TT!
3C9!7!3C9!Y!X&!h!X3C9!_!<C9TT!
3>P!7!3>P!Y!X&!h!X3>P!_!<>PTT!
3CP!7!3CP!Y!X&!h!X3CP!_!<CPTT!
3C`+3!7!3C`+3!Y!X&!h!X3C`+3!_!<C`+3TT!
\+3:!>!
LCE!R2)!
!



 &KDSWHU

1HZ3UREOHPVDQGQHZVROXWLRQVDUHOLVWHGDVQHZLPPHGLDWHO\DIWHUWKHVROXWLRQQXPEHU7KHVHQHZ
SUREOHPVDUH$$&''''''''''(+

$1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ$QVZHULVJ

$1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ$QVZHULVF

$ E7KHVDPH

% 
0XOWL6WDJH 6LQJOH6WDJH
) [ )  [ 'DYJ  1 /  ' 7UHIOX[  3 ) [ )  [ 'DYJ  3 
) [ )  [ :I  1 /  ' 7U  3 ) [ )  [ ' WRW  3 
) [ )  :ILQDO  1 /  ' 7U  3  ) [ )  [ ZI  3 
) [ )  ' WRW  1 /  ' 7U  3  ) [ :I  :ILQDO  3 
) [ )  [ 'DYJ  [ :I  1 7U  3  [ )  [ 'DYJ  ' WRW  3 
) [ )  [ 'DYJ  [ :I  /  ' 7U  3  [ )  [ :I  :ILQDO  3 
[ )  [ 'DYJ  ' WRW  1 /  ' 7U  3  [ )  [ :I  ' WRW  3 
[ )  [ 'DYJ  ' WRW  [ :I  1 7U  3  ) [ )  [ 'DYJ  [ : 
[ )  [ 'DYJ  ' WRW  [ :I  /  ' 7U  3  etc.
[ )  [ 'DYJ  :ILQDO  1 /  ' 7U  3  
[ )  [ :ILQDO  :ILQDO  1 / ' 7U  3  
etc.

% D 5HSODFHWKHFROXPQZLWKRQHFRQWDLQLQJPRUHWUD\VRUPRUHSDFNLQJ
 E 5HWUD\RUUHSDFNH[LVWLQJFROXPQ
 F 5XQDEDWFKLQVHYHUDOVWHSV)RUH[DPSOHWDNHWKHIHHGDQGRSHUDWHVRWKDWWKHGHVLUHGERWWRPV
FRQFHQWUDWLRQLVPHW&ROOHFWDOOWKHGLVWLOODWHDQGXVHWKLVDVWKHIHHGIRUDVHFRQGEDWFK2SHUDWH
VRWKDWWKHGLVWLOODWHIRUWKLVUXQPHHWVVSHFLILFDWLRQV7KHERWWRPVIURPWKLVUXQFDQEHXVHGDV
IHHGIRUDUGUXQRULWFDQEHPL[HGZLWKWKHQH[WIHHGEDWFK
  $QDOWHUQDWHLVWRILUVWFROOHFWGLVWLOODWHRIGHVLUHGSXULW\7KHQFROOHFWGLVWLOODWHZKLFKGRHVQRW
PHHW SXULW\ UHTXLUHPHQWV ZKLOH ERWWRPV LV UHGXFHG WR WKH GHVLUHG SXULW\  7KH PDWHULDO QRW
PHHWLQJUHTXLUHPHQWVLVWKHQPL[HGZLWKIUHVKIHHGIRUQH[WEDWFK
  2WKHURSHUDWLQJYDULDWLRQVDUHSRVVLEOH
 G +RRNXSWZREDWFKVWLOOVLQVHULHV±(LWKHUWRUXQEDWFKRUWRUXQVHSDUDWHEDWFKHVVHFRQGVWLOO
WDNHVGLVWLOODWHIURPILUVWDVWKHFKDUJH
 H 6HHLISURGXFWVSHFLILFDWLRQVFDQEHUHOD[HG
 I 5HGXFLQJWKHSUHVVXUHLQFUHDVHVWKHUHODWLYHYRODWLOLW\DQGPD\KHOS+RZHYHURQHPXVWZDWFK
IRUHDUOLHUIORRGLQJ

&5D\OHLJKHTQ 
[)
G[ :
:ILQDO )H[S 
[ :ILQ
[' [:

 

 %HFDXVH [ ' FRQVWDQWFDQLQWHJUDWHDQDO\WLFDOO\
[)
[)
G[ : [' [)
  Q [' [: Q 
[ Z ILQDO
[' [: [' [ : ILQDO
[ Z ILQDO

[' [) [' [)
   :ILQDO )H[S Q ) 
[' [ : ILQDO [' [ : ILQDO
 0DVVEDODQFHVDUH ) :ILQDO '

)[ ) :ILQDO [ :ILQDO '[ '
   
[' [) 
6ROYHIRU  :ILQDO )  
[' [ : ILQDO
 7KXVUHVXOWVDUHLGHQWLFDO


&  ([WHUQDOEDODQFHVRYHUHQWLUHF\FOH
    )] '[ 'ILQDO :[ Z$YJ DQG ) ':
 D ,JQRULQJKROGXSRQVWDJHVDQGLQUHERLOHU
    2XW $FFXPLQDFFXPXODWRULV  [ Z G' G '[ ' 
 ZKLFKEHFRPHV [ Z G' 'G[ ' [ ' G' 
G'
  5HDUUDQJH G[ ' [: [ ' DQGLQWHJUDWH
'
' ILQDO
G' [ 'ILQDO
G[ ' ' ILQDO [ ' ILQDO
G[ '
   ZKLFKLV  Q 
' ) ' [' [) [Z [' ) [) [' [Z

E $VVXPH&02DQGGUDZPDVVEDODQFHHQYHORSDURXQGERWWRPRIWKHFROXPQ
     
   / 9 %  /[ 9\ %[ Z 
/ %
  \ [ [Z 
9 9
/ /
  \ [  [Z 
9 9

 
 [)
UG G[
'1HZ3UREOHPLQ (GLWLRQ(T :ILQDO )H[S  
[ :ILQDO
\[

    
)URP6LPSVRQ¶VUXOH $UHD 
 \ [ 
\ [ [ 
\ [ 

 )URPHTXLOLEULXPFXUYH7DEOH
[ \ \[ 

\[
   
   
   

 7KH\YDOXHVDUHIRXQGE\OLQHDULQWHUSRODWLRQRIGDWDLQ7DEOH)RUH[DPSOHDW[ 
OLQHDUO\LQWHUSRODWHGILUVWGDWDSWV7DEOH

   \ [ IRU[ 
 

 )RU[  \  
 
 )RU\DW[ 
 \ >@ 

 >$OWHUQDWLYHO\FRXOGILWHTXLOLEULXPGDWDWRFRQVWDQWĮ@
 
   $UHD     
 
   :ILQDO  H[S  NPRO

   ' WRWDO   NPRO

)[ ) :ILQDO [ : ILQDO    
   [ '$YJ  
' DYJ 
 G[
' 5D\OHLJKHTXDWLRQLV :ILQDO )H[S  
\[ 

  0RVWRI YDOXHV RI\ ±[DUHOLVWHGLQ([DPSOH)URP7DEOHFDQ HDVLO\ JHQHUDWH

YDOXHVIRU[ \ \±[ \±[ 7KHPLGSRLQWIRU6LPSVRQ¶V
UXOHLVDW[ 7KHQIURP(TDQGYDOXHVLQ([DPSOH
 G[ 
         
 \ [ 

    :ILQDO H  ' WRWDO ) :ILQDO  
)[ ) :ILQDO [ ILQDO   
    [ 'DYJ  
' WRWDO 
  $JUDSKLFDOLQWHJUDWLRQFRXQWLQJVTXDUHVJLYHV [ 'DYJ  
/ '
'  2SHUDWLQJHTXDWLRQLV \ / 9 [  / 9 [ ' ZKHUH / 9  
 / '

 
  7KLVLV\ [ [ ' 
  :HKDYHWZR HTXLOVWDJHVVWLOOSRWDQG RQH LQWKHFROXPQ)URP0F&DEH7KLHOH GLDJUDP
ZH FDQ JHW WKH YDOXHV RI [ '  ZKLFK DUH UHODWHG WR [ :  3LFN [ '  DQG JHW [ :  IURP ILJXUH
)URPWKLVZHFDQJHQHUDWHWKHIROORZLQJWDEOHRQO\WZRYDOXHVDUHVKRZQLQ)LJXUH



 [' [: ['[:
    
    
    
   
   
   

  6LPSVRQ¶VUXOH(T>0LGSRLQW [ Z  @
[I
G[ Z  
         
[ Z ILQDO [' [: 
:ILQDO [)
G[ 
  5DOHLJK(TXDWLRQ :ILQDO )H  NPRO 
) [ ZILQDO [' [Z
   ' WRWDO ) :ILQDO    NPRO 
)[ ) :ILQDO [ ZI    
   [ 'DYJ  
' WRWDO 


 
'  :ILQDO NJPROHV[ )  [ ZI  )LQG) [ '$YJ  ' WRWDO 
         !
! "! #$%&'()*! 
!
\ [
 +,-+! +,-.! /.,...!
/.,..!
\ [
1,0.! 0,/12! +,0+! +,-+! /+!
!

+,.+! +,01! 0,/12!

,1! ,.! ,-!
+,3+! +,.0! 3,--4!
"!

+,1+! +,./! 1,0.!


&DQXVH6LPSVRQ¶V5XOH(TRUHYDOXDWHQXPHULFDOO\
[)
G[ 
         
[ :ILQ \ [ 
:ILQDO 
 5D\OHLJKHTQ  ) NPRO 
[)
G[ H[S 
H[S
[ :ILQ \ [
     ' WRWDO ) :ILQ  NPRO

)[ ) :I [ :ILQ    
     [ ' $9*  
' WRWDO 

[)
G[
' 1HZ3UREOHPIRUUG(GLWLRQ D :ILQDO )H[S 
[ Z ILQ \ [
   &DQXVH6LPSVRQ¶VUXOHHTZLWKHTXLOLEULXPYDOXHVIURPSORW
 
    I [ Z ILQDO  
\ [   
[ Z ILQ [)  
    I  
 \ [ 
 
 
    I [)  
\ [ 
 


 
 
   
[)
G[ [) [ Z ILQ
    I [ Z ILQ I [ Z DYJ I [) 
[ Z ILQ \ [ 
  
        
 
   :ILQ H[S      '9WRW ) :ILQ  
)] :ILQ [ Z ILQ
    \ 'DYJ  
' 9WRW
  E 6HWWOHU ' 9WRW ' '  ' ' 
     '9WRW \ 'DYW '[  ' [ %   ' '  
    6ROYLQJVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ '  DQG'  
:)  [ : )  [ )  [I
'  8VHHT Q Q Q 
)  [ )  [ : I  [ : I

 
 D )  [ )  [ :I    
:)    
   Q Q Q    
     
   :)   :) NPRO 
)[ ) :ILQ [ :I    
   [ '$9*  
) :ILQ  
 E 1RZ :I   :I  
   
     [ ' $9*  
 
 F   )  [ )  [ '$9*  

:ILQ [ ' $9* [)

  6LQFH ) :ILQ [ ' $9* )[ ) :ILQ [ :I   
) [ ' $9* [ : I
  7KHQ(TEHFRPHV
  [ ' $9* [I  [ :I  
     Q Q Q Q 
 [ :I [ ' $9* [ :I    [ :I  [ :I

) [ ' $9* [I   

  6ROXWLRQLV [ Z ILQ   :ILQDO  NPRO
[ ' $9* [ :I  
/ ' 
'  / '    / 9 VORSH 3LFNVHULHV [ ' YDOXHV3ORWHQULFKLQJVHFWLRQRS
 / ' 
 [)
G[
OLQH6WHSRIIWZRVWDJHV)LQG [ : &DOFXODWH  GHWHUPLQH 
[' [: [ :I [' [:
['  [:  
I 
  [' [:
  
   
  ,QWHUSRODWH
   
  
     
 
     
 

  6LPSVRQ¶V5XOH
[)
G[ [) [ :I
    I [ :)  I [ :  I [)  
[ :ILQ [' [: 
 
            


 
    :)LQDO H[S     

)[ ) :I [ :I    
    [ '$YJ  
) :I  
  
 

  

/ /
'1HZ3UREOHPUG(GLWLRQD2S(TQ \ [  [G 
Y 9
/ /  /
  / 9  [G  [ G # \ [  \ ,QWHUFHSW  ['    
' '  9
  )URP0F&DEH7KLHOHSORW [ Z ILQDO a  

 E   ) :ILQDO ' WRW :ILQDO  ' WRW 
     )[ ) :ILQDO [ Z ILQDO ' WRW [ '  :ILQDO ' WRW 
  6XEVWLWXWHLQIRU :ILQDO     ' WRW ' WRW 
  
   ' WRW  
 
      :ILQDO 

  

 
')LJXUH





'3DUW&
 7ULDO (UURUWRVWDJHVHQGLQJDW [ )  6HHILJXUH
/ /
 \ ,1WHUFHSW   ['   
9 9

 
 / 
    
9 
/ / / / 9 
    
9 ' ,QLWLDO 9 /  / 9  



' D 0DVVEDODQFHV ) ' WRWDO :RU ' WRWDO : 
  )[ ) ' WRWDO [ ' :[ :I RU ' WRWDO : 
  6ROYLQJVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ ' WRWDO DQG:  
  &DQDOVRXVH5D\OHLJKHTXDWLRQWRREWDLQVDPHUHVXOW8VHRIWKH5D\OHLJKHTXDWLRQIRUWKLV
W\SHSUREOHPLVLOOXVWUDWHGLQWKH6ROXWLRQWR3UREOHP'

 E 9DSRULQHTXLOLEULXPZLWK [ :I PXVWEHZLWKLQWKHWZRSKDVHUHJLRQ [ \ [ 
  0LQLPXPLVZKHQ \ [ 7KLVLV [ :I PLQ  6HHJUDSK

 



/ /
'  2S(T \ [ ' 6ORSH / 9 / '
[   /'  
9 9
  3ORWRQ0F&DEH7KLHOHJUDSKIRUVHULHVRI [ ' YDOXHV

  6LPSVRQ¶VUXOH DW [ : [)  [ : [ :ILQ  DQG[ :ILQ [I     
[' [:

[)
G[ :     
    
[ : ILQ [G [:  [' [: [)
[' [: [ ) [ : ILQ [' [: [ : ILQ



            

:ILQDO [)
G[ :
  5D\OHLJKHT Q :ILQDO )H 
) [ : ILQ [G [:

  RU :ILQDO H    DQG ' WRWDO ) :ILQDO  
)[ ) :ILQDO [ :ILQDO    
    [ 'DYJ  
' WRWDO 


 
 
[' [: [ '[ : [ '[ :

   

    
    
    
   
   
 
 [:  

[' [:
[ )   
[) [ :ILQ 
 

[ : ILQ   

[ EXWDQRO,QLWDO 
6 G[ SRW
D11. 1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ(T 
: [ EXWDQROILQDO
\
 1RWH : ZDWHU
 (TXDWLRQLVLQWHUPVRIEXWDQRO
 
6 G[ EXW SRW
  6LPSVRQ¶VUXOH±QHHG\DW [ SRW  EXWDQRO
: 
\ EXW

[ EXW  [ ZDWHU  \ ZDWHU  \ EXW  

\ EXW
    
    
    
  

     
   
6  : NPRO
   
 0RUHDFFXUDWHLIGRQHLQVWHSV7KXVDGGSRLQWVEHORZ
  
[ EXW  [Z  \Z  \ EXW  

\ EXW
    
    



      

 


     

  

  7RWDO$UHD 6 


 
 [)
G[
'  :ILQDO )H[S 
[ :ILQDO
\ [

[)
G[ [) [ :ILQDO   
 
[ :ILQDO
\ [  \ [ [ : ILQDO
\ [ [ :ILQDO [ ) \ [ [)


[) [ :ILQDO
    [) [ :ILQDO [ DYJ    

   
[ \IURPHTGDWD \[ 
\ [
   
   
   
[)
G[ 
      :ILQDO  H[S   NPROHV
[ :ILQ
\ [ 

)[ ) :ILQ [ :ILQ    
' WRW ) :ILQDO   [ '$9*  
  ' WRW 
[I
:ILQDO G[
'1HZ3UREOHPIRUUG(GLWLRQD5D\OHLJKHTXDWLRQ Q 
) [ Z ILQDO
\ [
[ \ \[ 
IURPJUDSK 
\ [ 
    
   
   

   
 6LPSVRQ¶V5XOH
[)
 
      
[ Z ILQ


 :ILQDO )H[S    ' WRWDO ) :ILQDO   

)[ ) :ILQDO [ Z ILQDO
 [ '$9*  
' WRWDO
E 7ZR/LTXLGV [ DQG[  
  / / ' WRWDO / ' WRWDO / 

  / [ / [ ' WRWDO [ '$9* ' WRWDO /  /  ' WRWDO  

 
 ' WRWDO  
  /   / ' WRWDO   
 

' D S RUJ SZ   S RUJ 93& [ & DQGDVVXPLQJZDWHULVSXUH S : 93: 
    93& [ & 93:  
   9DSRUSUHVVXUHGDWDIRU&ZDVVKRZQLQVROXWLRQWR3UREOHP'*XHVVž&
    93:  93& a PP+J 
     
    $Wž& 93& a DQG93:  
     !

    %\OLQHDULQWHUSRODWLRQ 7    ž&

E 8VH0DVVEDODQFHV,QLWLDOO\PROHVQGHFDQHPROHQRQYRODWLOH
D 
)LQDODPROQGHFDQHZKHUH  WKXV D PRO 
 D 
  :ILQDO  PRO:DWHUIUHH
  ' WRWDO ) :ILQDO    NPRO

 $OWHUQDWH6ROXWLRQ5DOHLJK(TZLWK
[)
G[ [)
  ['  :ILQDO )H[S  )H[S Q [ : 
[ :ILQDO
 [: [ : ILQDO

  :ILQDO )H[S Q  Q  )  

  ' WRWDO ) :ILQDO  6DPHUHVXOWDVPDVVEDODQFH
S WRW 93RUJ [ RUJ LQRUJ
 F  Q: ' RUJ 
93RUJ [ RUJ LQRUJ
   6KRXOGUHDOO\FDOFXODWHQXPHULFDOO\IURPLQWHJUDOIRUPRVWDFFXUDF\
'
S WRW 93RUJ [ RUJ LQRUJ
    Q: GQ RUJ 
 93RUJ [ RUJ LQRUJ
  +RZHYHUHVWLPDWHDWILQDOFRQGLWLRQVZLWK 93QGHFDQH a  IURPSDUWD
Q:   
     
Q RUJ  
  7KLVVKRXOGEHDJRRGHVWLPDWH

'  &ROXPQLVVLPLODUWRILJXUHLQ6ROXWLRQWR'EXWZLWKVWDJHLQFROXPQ

D )RUILQGLQJ :ILQ ' WRW GRQ¶WDFWXDOO\QHHGWRVWHSRIIVWDJHV-XVWZDQWWRPDNHVXUH [ :ILQDO 
LVREWDLQDEOH±,FKHFNHGWKLVDWWRWDOUHIOX[±,WZRUNV8VH0DVVEDODQFHV
    )[ ) ' WRW [ G :ILQ [ :ILQ 
  6XEVWLWXWHLQ ) ' WRW :ILQDO 

 
 ) [' [)   
  7KHQ  :ILQDO 
[' [ :ILQ  
  6ROXWLRQLV :ILQDO  NPRO ' WRW ) :ILQDO  
 E 1HHGWRGUDZRSHUDWLQJOLQHVXQWLO LQLWLDO VWDJHVJLYHV[ )HHG  
ILQDO VWDJHVJLYHV[ :ILQDO  7KHQ/9 VORSH
  ,QLWLDO±7KHUHZLOOEHDSLQFKDWSRLQWUHIOX[LVUHWXUQHG
\ [G \ LQW HUFHSW  
    / 9 ,QLWLDO 6ORSH  
['   
  )LQDO$IHZWULDOVUHVXOWHGLQILQDOUHVXOW
\ [G \ LQW HUFHSW  
    / 9 ILQDO 6ORSH  
[G   


 
' D 1HHG/9VRWKDWVWDJHVJRIURP [ ) WR[ '  7KLVLVOLQHDLQ)LJXUHWULDODQG
HUURUZDVXVHGWRILQGWKLV
/   / / 9 D
    DQG  
9 D   ' D  / 9 D


E 1HHG/9VRWKDWVWDJHVJRIURP [ ZILQDO WR[ '  VHHOLQHELQ)LJXUH$JDLQ
WULDODQGHUURUZDVXVHGWRILQGOLQH
/   / / 9 E
    DQG  
9 E   ' E  / 9 E

 F ) ' WRWDO :ILQDO   ' WRWDO :ILQDO 

  )[ IHHG ' WRWDO [ ' :ILQDO [ ZILQDO   ' WRWDO  :ILQDO 
  6ROYLQJVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ :ILQDO  NPRODQG ' WRWDO   NPRO
  7KH5D\OHLJKHTXDWLRQFRXOGEHXVHGLVQRWQHHGHGEXWJLYHVWKHVDPHUHVXOW


'    [ LQLW  6WDUWNPRODQGNHHSNPRO$GGZDWHUDVERLO
[ : LQLWLDO
6 G[ WDQ N
  (T   1RWHEDODQFHLVRQRULJLQDOVROYHQWPHWKDQRO
: [ : ILQDO
\
  8VHHTXLOLEULXPGDWDIURP7DEOH*HQHUDWHWDEOHRIPHWKDQROPROHIUDFWLRQV
[ \ \
  
  
  
  
   

  8VH6LPSVRQ¶VUXOHLQWZRVWHSV6WHS[IURPĺ

 
 
       

   6WHS[IURPĺ

      

    7RWDO  6:ZLWK: 
\ ' ILQDO
UG ) G\
'1HZ3UREOHP (GLWLRQ(T Q 
' ILQDO \)
\ [
  
\ ' ILQDO
) G\
  H[S 
' ILQDO \)
\ [
)
   ' ILQDO \ ' ILQDO

G\
H[S
\)
\ [
 5HDG[YDOXHVIURPHTXLOLEULXPGLDJUDPRULQWHUSRODWHIURP7DEOH
\ [ \[ 

\ [
   
   
   

 
   $UHD      


   ' ILQDO H[S NPRO 

   & WRWDO ) 'ILQDO NPRO 
 (WKDQRO0%
   'ILQDO \ 'ILQDO & WRWDO [ &DYJ )\ ) 
 
)\ ) ' ILQDO \ 'ILQDO    
 [ &DYJ PROHIUDFHWKDQRO 
& WRWDO 


9.D19.1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ
93Z [ Z 93RFW [ RFW 3WRW RULQPP+J      

' :DV'LQQGHGLWLRQ
 [ )&  [ :ILQDO&   [ &$9*  [ &$9*  S N3D 

 
  %3 \L .L [L  )RUDYHUDJHPROHIUDFWLRQVWKH%3FDOFXODWLRQFRQYHUJHVWR7 
žZLWK . &  DQG . &  IURPWKH'H3ULHVWHUFKDUWV7KH \L  ZKLFKLV
FORVHHQRXJKWRHVWLPDWHĮ
. & 
    & &  
. & 
:I    
  (T Q  Q Q  
)    
     :ILQ )   :ILQ    NPRO
     ' WRWDO ) :ILQ    NPRO
)[ ) :ILQ [ : ILQ    
     [ '$YJ  
' WRWDO 
/ '
'1HZ3UREOHPIRUUG(GLWLRQ  / '  / 9 
 / '
/ /
\ [  [ '  EXW[ ' YDULHV   7KXV SORW VHULHV RSHUDWLQJ OLQHV RI DUELWUDU\
9 9
[ '  VORSH   :LWKDWRWDORIHTXLOLEULXPFRQWDFWVWKHUHZLOOEHDSLQFKZKHUHWKHRSHUDWLQJOLQH
LQWHUVHFWVWKHHTXLOLEULXPFXUYH7KLVLQWHUVHFWLRQLV [ : IRUWKLV [ ' YDOXH
['  [:  [' [: 
 [' [Z

   
   
   
   
   
   

 :DQWWRLQWHJUDWHIURP [ :ILQDO  WR [ )  DQGZDQWPLGGOHSRLQWDW [ :  

 3ORW YV [ : DQGILQGYDOXHV
[' [:
 
  [ : ILQDO    [ :$YJ    
[' [: [' [:

  [)    
[' [:
 
  $UHD     
 

 
 
:ILQDO )H[S $UHD  H[S  

)[ ) :ILQDO [ : ILQDO
  ' WRWDO ) :ILQDO   [ '$YJ  
' WRWDO

 
 ' WRW
'1HZ3UREOHPIRUUG(GLWLRQ W 23 WRSHUDWLQJ __1.49 to 1.50K
45
'  3UHOLP&DOF)HHG$YJ0:  0: (
 0: ZDWHU

      0:DYJ      NJPRO
NJ
       NPRO
 NJ PRO
/ / ' 
        
9  / ' 
  $OORSOLQHVKDYHVORSH
&DQGUDZRSOLQHWR [ : 7HQVWDJHVZLOOJRIURP [ ' WR[ : EHFDXVHKDYHODUJHQXPEHU
RIVWDJHV7KXVGRQRWQHHGWRVWHSRIIVWDJHV

 
 
)URP*UDSKFDQFUHDWHWDEOHRI[G±[ZYHUVXV[:
  
 ['  [:  [G [Z  
 
[G [Z

    
    
   [ $YJ   
    
    
    
    

 

6LPSVRQ¶V5XOH [ )  [ :ILQDO  [ :$YJ    
[)
G[ : [) [ :ILQ   
    
[ :ILQ
[G [:  [G [: [ :ILQ
[G [: [ $9*
[G [: [)


           

[)
:)LQDO G[ :
  H[S  :ILQDO    
) [ :ILQ
[G [:

  ' WRWDO ) :)LQDO    NPROH

)[ ) :)LQDO [ :ILQ   
  [ '$9*  
' WRWDO 



































 
' :DV'LQQGHGLWLRQ
 D ) ' WRWDO :ILQ DQG)[ ) ' WRWDO [ ' :[ :ILQ 
[) [ :ILQ
  )[ ) ' WRWDO [ ' [ :ILQ )[ :ILQ ' WRWDO )
[' [ :ILQ
 
  ' WRWDO   NPRO :ILQ ) 'WRWDO  NPRO
 
/ /
E :DQW RSHUDWLQJ OLQH ZKHUH  HTXLO FRQWDFWV JLYHV [ Z ILQ  \ [ ' [ 
9 9
6XUSULVLQJO\ZLWKFRQWDFWV7 (QRWQHHGHG±6WDUWVWHSSLQJRIIVWDJHVIURPWRS IURP
ERWWRPVLPXOWDQHRXVO\7KHLQWHUVHFWLRQSRLQWPXVWEHRQRSOLQHDVLV \ [ [ ' 
/   / / / 9
  6ORSH    
9   ' 9 /  / 9



)LJXUHIRU'


'1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ

0L[WRJHWKHU ) ) )  

 
   [) )[ ) ) [ )     
[)
Z ),1$/ G[ [) [ Z ),1
  Q [ $9*  
) [Z ILQDO
\ [ 
[)
[) [ ),1   
  
[ Z )LQDO
 \ [ [ Z ),1
\ [ [ Z $9*
\ [ [ Z )


[ \ 

\ [ 56)'%7!68%!98:;!;%<=6>:)?@6<%8!
   %&'()(A8(';!B6<6,!
  
  


       

DUHD
  :ILQDO )H   NPRO 
)[ ) :),1 [ Z ),1
  ' ) :ILQDO  [ '$9*  
'
3DUWE  )LUVWJRIURPWRZLWK ) ' 

 7KHQIURPWRZLWK ) :),1 ) 

 
[ y       !
    
 \ [
  
   :),1$/ )HDUHD   
   
 !    
  
   ' ) :)LQDO  [ '$9*  !
 
   
1RZ ) :),1 )    [ ) 
   
 

[ y       
 
\ [
:ILQDO ) H DUHD    
  
    
    '  ) :ILQDO    
     7RWDO ' WRWDO    
)WRW [ WRW :ILQ  [ :ILQ    
 7RWDO [ '$9*   
' WRWDO 
 +LJKHUGLVWLOODWHPROHIUDFWLRQ

 
3DUWF *RIURPWRIRU )   
 

[ y \ [       
   
   :ILQDO  H[S   
   )
  
 )RU ) JRIURPWR6DPHDVQGSDUWRI3DUWE  
DUHD
   :ILQDO ) H    
)

  :ILQDOWRWDO  :ILQDO :ILQ  ' WRWDO ) ) :ILQDOWRW  

) )

 'LIIHUVIURPE±1XPHULFDOHUURU
)WRW   
   [ '$9* 
 
 6KRXOGEHVDPHDVSDUWE7KHUHDUHQXPHULFDOHUURUVLQXVHRI6LPSVRQ¶VUXOH

 0RUHDFFXUDWHIRUWRLVĺ$UHD ĺ$UHD 
  7RWDO$UHD  :ILQDO ) H DUHD    
 7KHQ :ILQWRWDO   ' WRWDO   
   
   [ ' $9*  

 6DPHDVIRU3DUWE

/ ' 
'1HZ3UREOHPIRUUG(GLWLRQ D E / '    / 9   
 / ' 
    / ' ILQDO
  / 9 ILQDO
  
   )RU3DUWEGUDZRSOLQHVZLWKVORSHIRUDUELWUDU\ [ '  6WHSRIIVWDJHV
   )RU3DUWD)URP [ '  GUDZRSOLQHVORSH 7ZRVWDJHVJLYHV
    [ Z ILQDO  6HHJUDSKODEHOHG'F
   $OVRGUDZDIHZOLQHVZLWK [ ' DQG / 9 EHWZHHQDQG )LQG [ Z YDOXHVZLWK
VWDJHV
  E *HQHUDWH7DEOH [ '  [ Z   [ ' [Z 

   3ORW YV[ Z 1RWHWKHUHLVDEUHDNLQFXUYHDW [ '  [ Z WR 
[' [Z
IURP[ ) WR[ Z 
   )LQGDUHDV 
IURP[ Z WR[ Z ILQDO 
 
   $UHD6LPSVRQ¶VUXOH [ Z DYJ  


 
 
     )URPJUDSK  
[' [Z [ Z DYJ

 
   $UHD      


   $UHD FXUYHLVVWUDLJKWOLQH7KXV$UHD ZLGWK[$YJKHLJKW
[' [Z
 
        

   7RWDODUHD 
:ILQDO [)
G[ Z
   5D\OHLJKHTQ Q  
) [ Z ILQDO [' [Z

     :ILQDO  H  
     ' WRWDO ) :ILQDO  
)[ ) :ILQDO [ :ILQDO   
  F   [ '$9*  
' WRWDO 

 
 

  
/' ['  [Z  
[' [Z
   4.0
   2.703
   2.273
   2.012
   1.942
   1.8018
   1.6949
[ Z ILQDO
   

 
 


'1HZ3UREOHPIRUUG(GLWLRQ)URPWKHPHWKDQROZDWHUHTXLOLEULXPGDWDWKHIROORZLQJWDEOHFDQ

EHREWDLQHG

 

[0  \0   \0 
  
  
  
[ SRW ,QLWLDO
6 G[ 0H2+
      
: [ SRW ILQDO
\ 0H2+

6LPSVRQ¶VUXOH       

   6 :  NPRO

(  

:C<6>:)!
@6<%8!

[)  ) NPROH !

D:<! E(>6)!:C<6>:)!(>!D:<!     !F;:)!

G:>H:)6<()%7!(>!D:<    !

7<%6;! [ RFW:ILQDO    !



    ORJ 93:   7 & 93: PP+J 
 7
 D )LQDOFRQGLWLRQV[ RFWLQ RUJ  [ :LQ:  7  &  IURP VROXWLRQ WR
SUREOHP',QLWLDOFRQGLWLRQV [ RFWLQ RUJ  [ :LQ:  
     [ L 93L DWP  PP+J
   )URPVSUHDGVKHHWILQG7 ž&
 ]  
 E   :ILQDORUJ )   
 [ :ILQ  
 F   'RUJ ) :ILQDO  Q RUJ 
' RUJ
S WRW 93 RFW
[ RFW
 G (T   Q: GQ RFW 

93 RFW
[ RFW
 (VWLPDWH 93RFW DWDYHUDJH 7       93RF WDQ RO  PP+J
' RUJ ' RUJ ' RUJ
S WRW GQ RFW S WRW GQ RFW
    Q: GQ RUJ ' RUJ 
93RFW 
[ RFW 
93RFW 
[ RFW

 
 )
    ) Q RUJ ) : [ RUJ   [ IHHG   ) : 
:
 GQ RUJ
   6WHSE\6WHSLQWHJUDWLRQ GQ RUJ    
[ RUJ [ RUJ
Q RUJ  GQ RUJ   :   [ RUJ   $YJ[ RUJ  GQ RFW
  
[ RUJDYJ
      
    !  
      
    !  
      
    !  
      
    !  
      
    !  
      
    !  
      
    !  
      
    !  
      
    !  
      
            
3RUJ

S WRW GQ RUJ 

   Q: ' RUJ    NPRO
93RUJ 2
[ RUJ 

H &RQWLQXRXVKDGNPROHVZDWHUNPROHRUJDQLFIHG7KHFRQWLQXRXVDOZD\VRSHUDWHVDW
ORZHVWRFWDQROPROHIUDFWLRQLQOLTXLG WKXV \ RFW LVDOZD\VDWORZHVWYDOXH7KXVUHTXLUHV
PRUHZDWHUWRFDUU\RYHURFWDQROWKHQWKHEDWFKRSHUDWLRQ

(1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ3DUWVD E 6HHVROXWLRQWRSUREOHP'
PRO% 
[ EHQ] 

PRO%   
F)LQG7IURP(T  :LWK6SUHDG6KHHW

63(3UREOHP(6ROXWLRQIRUWHPSHUDWXUH
7GHJ&  'RVWHSE\VWHS $QWRLQH 93YDOXHV
93:$%&     
93EHQ$%&     
;EHQ  [Z SWRW 
(T   (*RDOVHHN%WR]HURFKDQJLQJ%
PDVVEHQLQLW  PDVVEHQILQ 

 
 GPRUJVXP PDVVEHQVWLOO GPDVVRUJ 
GQZGQRUJ GQZ

G 6WHSE\VWHSLQWHJUDWLRQ GQ : GQ RUJ (T  8VH6SUHDG6KHHWIRU HDFKWLPH
VWHS'LGWKHDGGLWLRQRIVWHSVRIIOLQHLQWDEOHEHORZ     
   Q: GQ : IRUQ RUJ VWLOO LQLW   Q EHQ]   
VWLOO ILQDO

  6HW GP RUJ  NJ 9DOXHVIURPVSUHDGVKHHW


GQ : GLYLGHDOO 7ž&
0DVVEHQ]VWLOO
 GP RUJ NJ  YDOXHVE\ IURPVSUHDGVKHHW
NJ
NPRO 
,QLWLDO7 ĺ ĺ  
 ĺ ĺ  
 ĺ ĺ  
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
 ĺ ĺ  
ILQDO7    

G )RUDFFXUDF\DGGWLPHVWHSVWRWLPHVWHSV 7KLVLVWKHQLGHQWLFDOWRWKHXVHRI
DYHUDJHYDOXHVRIGPIRUHYHU\VWHS
6WHSVBWR 
 6WHSV B   
Q :    NJZDWHU
 
 &RPSDUHGWRFRQWLQXRXVQZ EDWFKUHTXLUHVOHVVEHFDXVHEHQ]HQHPROHIUDFWLRQLVKLJKHU
LQEDWFKRSHUDWLRQIRUPRVWRIEDWFK,IZHWDNHILQDOFXWDQGXVHGWKDWYDOXHIRUHQWLUHRSHUDWLRQ

   GQ :  NJEHQ]HQHRYHUKHDG  VDPHDVFRQWLQXRXV 

 H 7RYDSRUL]H Q EHQ EHQ   Z YDULHVVLQFH7LVGLIIHUHQW
 )RUDFFXUDF\GRIRUHDFK GP RUJ DQGILQGȜYDOXHVDWWKHVH7 
[ G ILQ
G[ G    
( 6LPSVRQ¶V5XOH 
[)
[G [%  [G [% [ G 
[G [% [ G 
[G [% [ ' 

 
  *HQHUDWHWDEOHIURPJUDSK
[%  [G   
         
[G [% 
    ' ILQDO )H  H  JPROH 
  
   % ) 'ILQDO  PROH   
   )[ ) '[ 'ILQ  
 [ %DYJ  
% 




[ LQLW
G[
(  :ILQDO ) H[S 
[ : ILQ
\ [
   7 (VLQFHGLOXWLRQHIIHFWV)  [ LQLW 
  'LOXWHZLWKNJZDWHUĺ6WDUWZLWK [ LQLW   
'LOXWHZLWKNJZDWHUĺ6WDUW [ LQLW   
  'LOXWHZLWKĺ6WDUW [ LQLW    
'LOXWHZLWKĺ6WDUWZLWK [ LQLW    
'LOXWHZLWKĺ6WDUWZLWK [ LQLW    

 
  )RU HDFK GLOXWLRQ ZDQW WR LQWHJUDWH XVLQJ 6LPSVRQ¶V UXOH XQWLO ILQG :ILQDO   7KXV
QHHGYDOXHVRI  \ [ DW [ LQLW  [ DYJ  DQG[ ILQDO  IRUHDFKGLOXWLRQ7KHVHYDOXHV
DUHGHWHUPLQHGLQWKHIROORZLQJWDEOH
 
7DEOHRI9DOXHVIRU,QWHJUDWLRQV
 
'LOXWH [ \ \[ \±[
NJ    
:DWHU    
   
NJ    
:DWHU    
   
NJ    
:DWHU    
   
NJ    
:DWHU    
   
NJ    
:DWHU    
   

   ,QWHJUDWLRQV 8VH6LPSVRQ¶VUXOHIRUHDFKDGGLWLRQ

   'LOXWHNJ      

    :ILQDO H[S   9DOXHLVWRRKLJK:DQWNJ

   'LOXWHNJ  

    :ILQ H[S  WRRKLJK 

   'LOXWH   

    :ILQ H[S  WRRKLJK 

   'LOXWH   

    :ILQ H[S  WRRORZ 

   'LOXWH       

    :ILQ H[S   
  &ORVHWRGHVLUHGNJ7KXVNJZDWHU7KHILQDOVWLOOSRWLVZDWHUVRKDYH
 PROHVZDWHUUHPDLQLQJ0ROHVRIZDWHUGLVWLOOHGRIILV± 
+ 1HZ 3UREOHP LQ UG HGLWLRQ  7KLV SUREOHP LV FKDOOHQJLQJ IRU VWXGHQWV EHFDXVH WKH\ PXVW ILUVW
GHULYHWKHIRUPVRIWKHHTXDWLRQVWKH\QHHGWRXVH

 
$'HILQH7KHV\VWHPLVWKHVLPSOHVWLOOSRWVKRZQLQ)LJXUH)LQG:ILQDO'[$:ILQDODQG[$GLVWDYJ
%([SORUH$WILUVWLWPD\DSSHDUWKDWWKHSUREOHP LQ3DUWDLVXQGHUVSHFLILHGVLQFHWKHUHDUHQRZILYH
XQNQRZQV+RZHYHULQVSHFLI\LQJWKHSUREOHPEDVHGRQWKHIUDFWLRQDOUHFRYHU\ RIEHQ]HQH LQ
WKH GLVWLOODWH ZH KDYH DGGHG WKH HTXDWLRQ IRU WKH GHILQLWLRQ RI IUDFWLRQDO UHFRYHU\ RI $ LQ WKH
GLVWLOODWH7KLVHTXDWLRQLVPRVWFRQYHQLHQWO\ZULWWHQDV

 )]$±)UDF5HF$LQGLVWLOODWH :ILQDO[$:ILQDO  D

ZKLFKEHFRPHV:ILQDO )]$±)UDF5HF$LQGLVWLOODWH[$:ILQDO  E

&3ODQ,IZHZULWH(TIRU$DQGVXEVWLWXWHLQ(TEZHREWDLQ(T
 [ $ : ILQDO  [ $ )  [ $ ) ] $  )UDF5HF$GLVW
  Q Q Q
$%  [ $ )  [ $ : ILQDO  [ $ : ILQDO [ $ : ILQDO
3DUWD,QDVSUHDGVKHHW(TLVHDVLO\VROYHGIRU[$:ILQDOXVLQJ*RDO6HHN7KHQ: ILQDOFDQ
EH GHWHUPLQHG IURP (T E 7KHQ '7RWDO LV GHWHUPLQHG IURP (T  DQG [$GLVWDYJ LV
GHWHUPLQHGIURP(TZULWWHQIRUFRPSRQHQW$RUIURPWKHIUDFWLRQDOUHFRYHU\

3DUWE1RZVROYH(TIRUIUDFUHFRI$LQGLVWLOODWHXVLQJ*RDO6HHN)RUERWKSDUWVDDQGEFDQ
XVHIUDFWLRQDOUHFRYHU\YDOXHVDQG'7RWDOWRILQG[$GLVWDYJ )]$)UDF5HF$LQGLVWLOODWH'7RWDO

''R,W%HFDXVH(TIRU[$:ILQDOLVQRQOLQHDULWLVHDVLHVWWRVROYHWKLVSUREOHPZLWKDVSUHDGVKHHW
DQGXVH*RDO6HHNWRVROYH(T7KHVSUHDGVKHHWVDUHVKRZQEHORZ
3DUWD      
)  ]$  7KHLVLQFHOO' 
DOSKD$&      
IUDFUHF$LQGLVWLOODWH     
[$:ILQ      
WHUP  WHUP  WHUP  
      
(T ( 8VH*RDOVHHN   
:ILQDOIURPE  'WRWDO  [$GLVWDYJ 
3DUWD8VH*RDO6HHNIRUFHOO%VHWWLQJLWHTXDOWR]HURE\YDU\LQJFHOO%[$:ILQ
3DUWE8VH*RDO6HHNIRUFHOO%VHWWLQJLWHTXDOWR]HURE\YDU\LQJFHOO&

3DUWE      
)  ]$  7KHLVLQFHOO' 
DOSKD$&      
IUDFUHF$LQGLVWLOODWH     
[$:ILQ      
WHUP  WHUP  WHUP  
      
(T  8VH*RDOVHHN   
:ILQDOIURPE  'WRWDO  [$GLVWDYJ 
3DUWD8VH*RDO6HHNIRUFHOO%VHWWLQJLWHTXDOWR]HURE\YDU\LQJFHOO%
3DUWE8VH*RDO6HHNIRUFHOO%VHWWLQJLWHTXDOWR]HURE\YDU\LQJFHOO&IUDFUHF$LQGLVWLOODWH
!

 
 63(UG(GLWLRQ6ROXWLRQ0DQXDO&KDSWHU

1HZ 3UREOHPV DQG QHZ VROXWLRQV DUH OLVWHG DV QHZ LPPHGLDWHO\ DIWHU WKH VROXWLRQ QXPEHU 7KHVH QHZ
SUREOHPVDUH$$$$$&&'''*
*

$  $ JRRG SDFNLQJ ZLOO KDYH  JRRG FRQWDFW EHWZHHQ OLTXLG DQG YDSRU KLJK VXUIDFH DUHD ORZ
SUHVVXUHGURSLQHUWLQH[SHQVLYHDQGVHOIZHWWLQJ
  0DUEOHVKDYHORZVXUIDFHDUHDSRRUFRQWDFWDQGUHODWLYHO\KLJK¨S

$ )LJXUHVKRZVWKDWLIYLVFRVLW\LQFUHDVHVWKHRUGLQDWHLQFUHDVHVDQG¨SIRRWLQFUHDVHV

$ D:DQWORZ)VLQFHWKLVJLYHVORZ¨S
 E )GHFUHDVHVDVVL]HLQFUHDVHV
 F &HUDPLFV KDYH PXFK WKLFNHU ZDOOV WKDQ PHWDO RU SODVWLF  &HUDPLFV DUH XVHG LQ FRUURVLYH
HQYLURQPHQWV

$ DIHZHU EODUJHUDORZHU

$$QVZHULVF

%  7KH WULFN LV WR KDYH PD[LPXP DQG PLQLPXP SRVLWLRQV RI WKH YDOYH ZLWK D ODUJHU DUHD IRU
YDSRUIORZDWWKHPD[LPXPSRVLWLRQ
   D 8VHDFDJHWRSUHYHQWH[FHVVPRYHPHQW
   E 8VHIHHW
   F +DYHDIODSWKDWPRYHVXSDQGGRZQ
   G 8VHDVSULQJWRSURYLGHIRUFHDQGPD[LPXPSRVLWLRQ
   H 6OLGLQJYDOYHFRQWUROOHGE\DQH[WHUQDOIHHGEDFNPHFKDQLVP
   I 7ZRIODSVWRPDNHDURRI
  0DQ\RWKHULGHDVFDQEHJHQHUDWHG

%  6RPHSRVVLEOHFDQGLGDWHV
%RWWOHFDSV 626SDGV
%HQWERWWOHFDSV 6FRWFKEULWHSDGV
1DWXUDOVSRQJH 6WHHOZRRO
6\QWKHWLFVSRQJH &RRSHUFOHDQLQJSDGV
0LVFHOODQHRXVMXQN 3ODVWLFFRDWHGZLUH
%URNHQFURFNHU\RUJODVVZDUH 7LQIRLOFUXVKHG
&XWXSWXELQJ7\JRQ 6WULQJEDOOV
*ODVVWXELQJEURNHQ OLQHVWLHGWRJHWKHU
&UXVKHGEHHUFDQV OLQHVWZLVWHG
&XWXSFUXVKHGEHHUFDQV OLQHVVWUHWFKHGWDXJKW
&RDO 5RSH
(JJVKHOOV IUD\HGURSH
6W\URIRDPSDFNLQJPDWHULDO 5RSHWLHGLQWRERZWLHV
2OGVHDWFXVKLRQV 3RURXVURFNSLHFHV



 1XWVEROWVVFUHZVQDLOV 3XPLFH
0HWDOILOLQJV $VKIURP0W6W+HOHQV
:RRGVKDYLQJV $VKHVIURPFRDOVWRYH
.LQGOLQJ 3LHFHVRIFHPHQWEORFN
/HIWRYHUUHGZRRG 3LHFHVRIEULFN
6WDSOHV 3RSWRSV
:LQGRZVFUHHQVUROOHGXS 2OGZDWFKEDQGVWZLVWHG
&KLFNHQRUEDUEHGZLUH %HQWZLUHFRDWKDQJHUV
&KULVWPDV7UHH2UQDPHQWV &RRNLHFXWWHUV
&RUQFREV &RPELQDWLRQRIWKHDERYH

&  /9FRQVWDQWVLQFH/'FRQVW7KXV/*FRQVW,Q ) Y RQO\ *
FKDQJHV)URP3HUIHFW*DV
Q 3
/DZ * 0:Y 0:Y 7KXV ) Y LQFUHDVHVDV 3 +RZHYHUFXUYHLVDOPRVW
Y 57
IODWLQWKLVUDQJHDQG &VEIORRG aFRQVWDQW
 
& VE IORRG / * 
    7KHQ X IORRG 
VLQFH / * 
  * 3
/ [' ]
     9 / '  'DQG' ) VR9 )   
' [' [%
) ) )
    7KXV 'LD       
X IORRG  3
9 3
3

   7KHQ) 'LD 3 DQGH[SRQHQW ò

&  6HHGHULYDWLRQLQVROXWLRQWR3UREOHP&
/ / [' ]
     9  '  ) 
' ' [' [%
  7KHQIURP(T
 
/ [' ]
) 
' [' [%
     'LD 
 S IUDFWLRQ X IORRG

 
  6LQFH 'LD )   'LD  / '  
 
/ *
&  3ORWSRLQWVEDVHGRQ¨SDQG RQ)LJXUH)URPRUGLQDWHYDOXHVFDOFXODWH)
* /

IRUHDFKSRLQW8VHDQDYHUDJHYDOXH




& 1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ3DUWRIWKHRSHUDWLQJOLQHVEHFRPHFORVHUWRWKHHTXLOLEULXPFXUYH
7KXVIRUWKHVDPHVHSDUDWLRQPRUHVWDJHVDUHQHHGHG)RUWXQDWHO\WKLVHIIHFWLVRIWHQVPDOO

& 1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ<RXFDQVKRZWKLVE\SURYLQJWKDWWKHPLQLPXPUHIOX[UDWLR)LJXUH
$RUWKHPLQLPXPERLOXSUDWLR)LJXUH$PXVWLQFUHDVHFRPSDUHGWRWKHEDVH
FDVHV7KHVHUDWLRVLQFUHDVHEHFDXVHFRROLQJWKHHQWLUHIHHG)LJXUH$RUKHDWLQJWKH
HQWLUHIHHG)LJXUH$DXWRPDWLFDOO\FKDQJHVWKHIHHGOLQHDQGPRYHVWKHPLQLPXP
UHIOX[)LJXUH$RUPLQLPXPERLOXS)LJXUH$RSHUDWLQJOLQHVWRZDUGVWKH\ [
OLQH7KLVPHDQVODUJHUPLQLPXPH[WHUQDOUHIOX[UDWLRRUODUJHUPLQLPXPERLOXSUDWLR

'  . & \  [DQG. &  \  [  
 . &
   6ROYHVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ [ \ . & [ 
. & . &
  3LFN7DQGJHQHUDWHHTXLOLEULXPFXUYH %RXQGVDUH. & DQG. &  
7 .& .& [ \
R
 &    
    
    

     
  $YHUDJHWHPSHUDWXUHLV7 ž& .
\ [  
   
 \  [  
  9LVFRVLW\HTXDWLRQDQGWHUPVDUHJLYHQLQ([DPSOH
 
    ORJ &    &  
7 
 
    ORJ &    &  
7 
    Q 0,;  Q   Q    0,;  
  )URP (T  IRU  ( R    7KH KLJKHU SUHVVXUH UHVXOWV LQ KLJKHU
WHPSHUDWXUHVDQGORZHUYLVFRVLWLHV7KLVLQFUHDVHVWKHSUHGLFWHGFROXPQHIILFLHQF\E\

'   7    . DOPRVWSXUHQKHSWDQHDWERWWRP
S0:  
   Y OEIW   /   OEIW   
57  
  1HHG / 9 )LUVWILQG\DWLQWHUVHFWLRQRIRSHUDWLQJOLQHV
/  \
  7RS2SHUDWLQJ/LQH6ORSH  
9  
  \     
/  
    7KHQ  
9  



 / / 0:/ /
     7KLVLVDWERWWRPZKHUH 0:/ a 0:Y 
* 9 0:Y 9
 
/ Y 
    )Y   
* / 
 

  )URP)LJXUH &VE  & VE   
 

 
    X IORRG   

    6DWXUDWHGOLTXLGIHHG 9 9  8VHȘ 
 
   
     ' IW 
    
   6RPHZKDWODUJHU:RXOGGHVLJQDWERWWRPRIFROXPQ8VHDIWGLDPHWHUFROXPQ

'  1HZ¶GLDFRO)LUVWUHGRHQWUDLQPHQWFDOFXODWLRQ

/ 
     ) J   / 9  

9 
  )RU)LJQHHGIORRG,QSUREOHP'GHVLJQHGIRUIORRG
 
FRQVW  
    '   FRQVW    
IORRG
 
  8VHIHHW IORRG   IORRG  7KHQ)LJȥ 
/  
    H   / H  
  
    7KLVLVUHDVRQDEOHDPRXQW

     $ WRWDO   IW  
     $G    IW  
    7DEOH   ZHLU 'LD   ZHLU  IW IW 
     $ DFWLYH    IW   $ KROH   IW 
    JDXJH W WUD\ LQ  KROHV  G  W WUD\  
90: Y
    Y  IW V  &  XQFKDQJHGIURP([
 Y 
   
     K S G U\    
LQ 
 
 
     /J  JSP 
 



 /J 
    $EVFLVVD  
 
ZHLU 
    3DUDPHWHU Z 'LD  )ZHLU )LJ   


   (T K FUHVW   LQ 

   :LWKƎJDS $ GX   IW  


   (T K GX  LQ 
 
    K GF       
    K GFDHUHDWHG    2. EXWFORVHWRGLVWDQFHEHWZHHQWUD\V
   
     W UHV  7KLVLV2.
  
 
   :HHSLQJ(T K LQ 
  
   (T/+6 K SGU\ K    
     [     

     5+6       2. 
     /+6!5+6
   2SHUDWLRQLVVOLJKWO\PDUJLQDOZLWKKLJKGRZQFRPHUEDFNXS

   ,QFUHDVHDSURQJDSWRLQFKHV $ GX IW IW  



     K GX JDS  LQ 
 
     K GF     LQ 
     K GFDUHDWHG LQFK2. 

 
& Y :YDOYH J
'    Y REDO  
. Y$ Y Y

   *LYHQ :YDOYH OEJ  IW V   . YFORVHG & Y  . YRSHQ  
   3UHVVXUHGURSLQWHUPVRILQFKHVRIOLTXLGRIGHQVLW\ / 
:YDOYH .Y
    K SYDOYH &Y Y
Y  
$Y / J /


    $Y IW   Y  OE IW    /  OE IW  




  
   
    Y REDOFORVHG  IW VHF 
  
 
   
    Y REDORSHQ  IW VHF 
  
& Y :YDOYH  OE
   $WEDODQFHSRLQW K SYDOYH 
$/ /  IW  OEIW 

      IW LQOLTXLG 

 
    FORVHG K SYDOYH Y  IRUY   
  

        Y  IW   
Y  LQFKHV 
 
    RSHQ K SYDOYH Y  IRUY   
  

         Y  IW   
Y  LQFKHV   
 
'   'R FDOFXODWLRQ DW WRWDO UHIOX[  )URP D 0F&DEH7KLHOH GLDJUDP QRW VKRZQ  7RWDO 
&RQWDFWV 1 7RWDO±35 
/HQJWK 
     +(73 P 
1 

'   )URP)HQVNHHTDQGGHILQLWLRQRI+(73
]
     +(73 
[ [
Q
 [ GLVW  [ ERW

Q $%

[ [  
     Q Q  
 [ GLVW  [ ERW  

       ] PHWHUV2EWDLQ
     D Į  +(73 
     E Į  +(73 
 
     F $9*   DQG+(73$9*  
   &DQDOVRXVH0F&DEH7KLHOHGLDJUDPVDOWKRXJKWKHVROXWLRQVKRZQLVHDVLHU

' &XUUHQW
) Y   VSDFLQJ2UGLQDWH  8 QI FRQVW FRQVW  8 QI    
   1HZ
 / 9QHZ  / 9 ROG  WKHQ / * QHZ  / * ROG  ) YQHZ ) YROG  
   7UD\V6SDFLQJƎ2UGLQDWHa2UGLQDWH  8 QI î&RQVW



 2UGLQDWH 
   8 1I  IW V 
&RQVW  

'  $W  )Y  &VEI   
 
/ *  / *  
 8I & VE 

 *   * *
 /

Q 0:Y S
   6LQFH S9 Q57  * 0:Y 
9 57
 
* QHZ 
  1HZ&RQGLWLRQ )Y    & VE a   
* ROG 
8 I QHZ & VEQHZ * ROG & VEQHZ ROG  
     
8 I ROG & VEROG * QHZ & VEROG QHZ
 
   8 IOQHZ   IWV 

' ] [%  
'   0DVV%DODQFH  
) [ ' [ %  
     ' NPROK%  
   $WWRS  / 9  9 / ' 9 ' 9 
' 
     9  NPRO K 
 
     / 9 '  NPRO K 
  $WWRSRIFRO :/ :9 / 9 VLQFHSXUH0H2+VDPHPROZW  
NPRO NJ0H2+ OEP OEP
    9    
K NPRO NJ K
  $VVXPHLGHDOJDV7RSRIFROXPQLVHVVHQWLDOO\SXUH0H2+
OE
DWP 
Q 0:0 S OEPRO OEP
  Y 0:0  
9 57 
IW DWP IW 
  5
OEPRO 5
 5
  ZKHUHSXUH0H2+ERLOVDW  & .
 5 
.
NJ OEP FP  OEP
   / 0H2+  J FP   
J NJ IW  IW 
  $WWRS     



    
:/ * 
    )Y   
:* / 
  )LJZLWKƎWUD\VSDFLQJ &VE  
 
/ 9   
   8 IORRG & VE   IW V 
 9  
9 OEP K
  8VH(T0RGLILHG ' 
9 IUDF X IORRG 

   OEP K

    ' 
IW 
  OEP IW    V K
V
   ' IW8VHHLWKHUIWVOLJKWO\KLJKHUIUDFIORRGRUIW±ORZHUIUDFIORRG

[
' 5HI%RQLOOD  \  DW]  [ \ IHHG 
  [
  / / 9 
  / 9 PLQ
  / ' PLQ
 
  9 /  / 9  
/ ' 
  / 'DFW  / ' PLQ   / 9 DFW
 
 / ' 
      / 9 ['  
   $W0LQLPXP3LQFK3RLQW /ORZ 9 / 9 PLQ
RU /ORZ ' / ' PLQ
 
    / ORZ '  / DYJ '  /ORZ /DYJ 
   *HQHUDOL]H /ORZ /DYJ 0 ZKHUH / ' DFWXDO
0 / ' PLQ




'D 6LQFH/LTXLG 9DSRUKDYHWKHVDPHPROHIUDFWLRQV / * / 9
   S9 Q57 * Q 0:Y 9 S 0:Y 57  5 FP DWPJPROHV R 5  



   0:Y      

* $70  J PRO FP DWPPRO  5    5  J FP 

9 / ' '  OE GD\  / '    OE GD\

  / 9    / * 
  

  / * * /      

     +2 /  J FP  J FP   

    )  7DEOH
   2UGLQDWH * ) ) 
* / JF  IURP)LJXUHIORRGLQJOLQH
   7KLVLV

    J FP 
* )  
  OE IW 
      
    J FP   J FP  
  *)  OE VIW       V GD\  OE GD\ IW    * *) 
 
   ),1'$5($$1'',$0(7(5)252))/22',1*
 $5($ 9 *  OE 'D\  OE 'D\IW   IW  
    '   IW   ' IW LQ 
&2/801',$0(7(5
        ZKLFKLVSUREDEO\2.
3$&.,1* ',$0(7(5


 E )URP)LJ *  ) 
 * / J F  DW / * * /  
   
*    

    
 
   

    * OE VIW      V GD\    OE GD\IW  
    $5($   OE GD\  OE GD\IW   IW   
   $5($  '    ' IW  LQFKHV
 
/ *
  F / * ZLOOEHWKHVDPHWKXV ZLOOEHWKHVDPHDQG * ZLOOEHWKHVDPH
* /

    $UHD 9    9 ' DVEHIRUH   OE GD\ 

    DUHD        IW    HDUOLHUYDOXH 
 
 
    ' IW LQFKHV 



'D \ / 9 [  / 9 [ ' :KHQ [  \  / 9 [ '  6HHILJXUH1HHG
HTXLOLEULXPVWDJHV6WRSZKHUHIHHGOLQHDQGRSHUDWLQJOLQHLQWHUVHFW
     +(73    IW [ % a  
E 0LVDW [ LQ \  
/ / 0 
      
/ / 0 
/ / / /
   :LWKLQDFFXUDF\RIJUDSK  
9 / / / / 
   ,IWU\DVKRUWHUFROXPQZLWKVDPHIHHGZRQ¶WZRUN
/ /
     DQGPXVWDGMXVWFROXPQ
/ 9


'  1HZ 3UREOHP LQ UG HGLWLRQ  6DWXUDWHG YDSRU IHHG LQ SUREOHP ' KDV PLQLPXP /9 
 7KLVLV/'PLQ 7KHDFWXDO/9 ZKLFKLVDQ
/'    7KXV WKH PXOWLSOLHU 0 RI WKH PLQLPXP ZDV 0  /'/'PLQ   

 )RUDVDWXUDWHG OLTXLGIHHG /9PLQ  ZKLFKFRUUHVSRQGVWR
/'PLQ    ,I ZH XVH WKH VDPH PXOWLSOLHU /'   DQG /9 

' ] [%  
  0DVV%DODQFH  
) [ ' [ %  
   ' NPROK%  7KHVHDUHVDPHDVLQ'
   $WWRS  / 9  9 / ' 9 9 '



 ' 
     9  NPRO K 
 
     / 9 '  NPRO K 
  $WWRSRIFRO :/ :9 / 9 VLQFHSXUH0H2+VDPHPROZW  
NPRO NJ0H2+ OEP OEP
    9    
K NPRO NJ K
 7KHGHQVLW\DQGVXUIDFHWHQVLRQFDOFXODWLRQVDUHWKHVDPHDVLQ'
 $VVXPHLGHDOJDV7RSRIFROXPQLVHVVHQWLDOO\SXUH0H2+
OE
DWP 
Q 0:0 S OEPRO OEP
  Y 0:0  
9 57 
IW DWP IW 
  5
OEPRO 5
 5
  ZKHUHSXUH0H2+ERLOVDW  & .
 5 
.
NJ OEP FP  OEP
   / 0H2+  J FP   
J NJ IW  IW 
  $WWRS     
   
:/ * 
    )Y   
:* / 
  )LJZLWKƎWUD\VSDFLQJ &VE  
 
/ 9   
   8 IORRG & VE   IW V 
 9  
9 OEP K
  8VH(T0RGLILHG ' 
9 IUDF X IORRG 

   OEP K

    ' IW 
IW

  OEP IW    V K
V
3UREDEO\ XVH  IW ZKLFK LV D VOLJKWO\ KLJKHU IUDFWLRQ RI IORRGLQJ  7KLV FRPSDUHV ZLWK  IW IRU WKH
VDWXUDWHGYDSRUIHHG7KHVPDOOHUGLDPHWHUFROXPQZLOOEHOHVVH[SHQVLYH
:LWKDVDWXUDWHGOLTXLGIHHGDQG&02WKHYDSRUIORZUDWHLQWKHERWWRPRIWKHFROXPQLVWKHVDPHDVLQ
WKHWRS 9  NPROKU)RUSUREOHP'ZLWKDVDWXUDWHGYDSRUIHHG
9 9 )    6LQFH 45 9 
45 OLTXLG B IHHG   45 YDSRU B IHHG 45 YDSRU B IHHG 

7KXVLQWKLVFDVHWKHUHLVDVLJQLILFDQWHQHUJ\SULFHIRUUHGXFLQJWKHFROXPQGLDPHWHUE\WKLVPHWKRG

] [%  
' ' )    %  '  NPROGD\
[' [%  



    9 9 / '  '    NPRO GD\ 
NPRO GD\ K
   RU 9   NPRO V 
GD\ K V
  $WERWWRP / 9 %    NPRO GD\ 
/ 
     
9 
  %RWWRPRIFROXPQLVHVVHQWLDOO\SXUHZDWHU$OVR \ ERLOXS [% 
   7KXV / * / 9 * LV OE VIW   
OE NPRO NJ OE
    9LQ    OE V 
V V NPRO NJ
NJ OE P OEP
 / GHQVLW\ZDWHUDW &   
 
P NJ IW IW 
   'DWDIURP3HUU\¶VWKHGS : /  
OEP
DWP 
Q S IW  OEP
S9 Q57   * 0:Z 0:Z 
9 57 
IW DWP IW 
  5
OEPRO 5
 5
ZKHUHž& .  5 
.
   
/ * 
)Y  
* 
    /

  )URP)LJ2UGLQDWHDWIORRGLQJ 
 
 * / JF
    * IORRG 
 J F  )  7DEOH  
)
 
      OEP
    * IORRG 
  
   V IW 

  :KHUH Z   FSIURP3HUU\¶VS

    * DFWXDO  * IORRG    
9LQ OE V 
    $UHD 
IW  
* DFWXDO OE V IW  
   
DUHD  
    'LDPHWHU IW 
   
)LQW 
   E )  'LDPHWHU ,QWDOR[ 'LD %HUO
 IW 
SODVWLF )%HUO 



 :/ Y
'  )Y  IURPSURE' 
:Y /

   )URP)LJZLWKƎWUD\VSDFLQJ &VEIORRG  



    . &VE ZKHUHı VXUIDFHWHQVLRQZDWHUDWž&


  G\QHV P G\QHV
 3HUU\¶VWKHGS#.  1 P  
1 FP FP

    .       

/ Y  
 X IORRG .   IW V  X DFW    IW V 
Y 

OE
9
V
  'LD (TPRGLILHGIRUXQLWV9LVIURP3UREOHP'
OE IW
Y 
X DFW
IW V

 
  'LD IW 7KLVFDQEHFRPSDUHGWRIWIRUSDFNHG
  
7UD\FROXPQVZLWKWKLVVPDOODGLDPHWHUDUHVHOGRPXVHGLQLQGXVWU\

' )URP(T'LDPHWHU )  ) DQG)  7DEOH 
   
) 
    'LDPHWHU  'LDPHWHU    IW 
) 
   &DQDOVRUHSHDWHQWLUHFDOFXODWLRQZKLFKLVDORWPRUHZRUN

' $WWKHERWWRPRIWKHFROXPQKDYHHVVHQWLDOO\SXUHQKHSWDQH7KHQIROORZLQJ([DPSOH
ZHKDYH
S 0:  
    Y  OE IW  
57  
 \
   1HHG / 9 6LQFH / 9  ZKHUH]  ZHKDYH\  DWLQWHUVHFWLRQ RI
 ]
 
RSHUDWLQJOLQHV7KHQ / 9  
 
/ / 0:/
        
* 9 0:Y
   
/ Y 
       
* /  
   )LJXUH2UGLQDWH DW¨S 



     
     * 
 
   
   7KHYDOXHLV :DWHU
DWž&DQG :DWHU /
6LQFHIHHGLVDVDWXUDWHGOLTXLG
9 9  OEPROV
90:Y  
     $UHD IW  
* 
 
     ' $UHD IW 
   7KLVLVVRPHZKDWODUJHUWKDQLQ([DPSOH7KHUHIRUHGHVLJQDWERWWRP


* / J F  RUGLQDWH
'   * IORRG 

)
   $VVXPHFKDQJLQJSFKDQJHVRQO\ *
 RUGLQDWH7KHQWDNHUDWLRV
* IORRG QHZ * QHZ  RUGLQDWHQHZ
     
* IORRG ROG * ROG  RUGLQDWHROG

* QHZ
S 0: 57 QHZ S QHZ
      $VVXPHVVPDOOFKDQJHLQ
* ROG S 0: 57 S ROG
ROG

7LQ.HOYLQ7VHWE\ERLOLQJFRQGLWLRQV9DSRU3UHVVQRWE\LGHDOJDVODZ

  
/ *
) Y QHZ * QHZ S QHZ
   )Y    ) YQHZ ) YROG  
* / ) Y ROG / ROG S ROG
    1HZ2UGLQDWH9DOXHaROGYDOXHa
S QHZ  RUGLQDWHQHZ 
   * IORRG QHZ * IORRG ROG    
S ROG  RUGLQDWHROG 

'1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ6DWXUDWHGYDSRUIHHGLQSUREOHP'KDVPLQLPXP/9 
 
7KLVLV/'PLQ 7KHDFWXDO/9 ZKLFKLVDQ/' 7KXVWKHPXOWLSOLHU0RIWKH
PLQLPXPZDV0 /'/'PLQ  )RUDVDWXUDWHGOLTXLGIHHG/9 PLQ 
 ZKLFKFRUUHVSRQGVWR/'PLQ ,IZHXVHWKHVDPHPXOWLSOLHUDVLQ
'/'  DQG/9 7KLVLVWKHVORSHZHXVHLQWKHWRSVHFWLRQIRUWKH
HQWKDOS\IHHG,QWKHPLGGOHVHFWLRQRIWKHFROXPQDWPLQLPXPUHIOX[FRQGLWLRQVWKHVORSHRIWKHPLGGOH
RSHUDWLQJOLQHLV /  9       

7KH H[WHUQDO PDVV EDODQFHV VWLOO JLYHV ' NJPROHVKU%   $W PLQLPXP UHIOX[
/PLQ  /  ' PLQ '    DQG 9PLQ /PLQ '      $W
WKHVDWXUDWHGOLTXLGIHHG 9 9 DQG / / )OLTXLG 7KXV
> / )OLTXLG   9 @PLQ  /  9  PLQ  DQG )OLTXLG PLQ 9 /  
6LQFHWKHWRWDOIHHGUDWHLVWKHIUDFWLRQOLTXHILHGLV7KHVDPHIUDFWLRQFDQEHOLTXHILHGDW
WKHILQLWHUHIOX[UDWLRV7KXV )OLT  DQG )YDS  



$WWRSXVHVDWXUDWHGOLTXLGUHIOX[UDWLR / 9  9 / ' 9 9 ' 
' 
     9  NPRO K 
 
7KLVLVWKHVDPHDVIRUSUREOHP'DQGWKHUHPDLQGHURIWKHFDOFXODWLRQRIWKHGLDPHWHULVLGHQWLFDOWR
WKDWFDOFXODWLRQ7KHUHVXOWRIWKHFDOFXODWLRQDWWKHWRSRIWKHFROXPQLV
   OEP K
    ' IW 
IW 
  OEP IW    V K
V
:HQRZQHHGWRFDOFXODWHWKHYDSRUIORZUDWHLQWKHERWWRP$VVXPLQJ&02LQWKHPLGGOHVHFWLRQ
9 9  ,QWKHERWWRPVHFWLRQ
9 9 )YDS    
6LQFH 45 9  45  HQWKDOS\ B IHHG   45  YDSRU B IHHG 45  YDSRU B IHHG 
7KXVLQWKLVFDVHWKHWZRHQWKDOS\IHHGGHVLJQUHVXOWVLQWKHVDPHUHGXFWLRQLQGLDPHWHUDVOLTXHI\LQJWKH
HQWLUHIHHGDQGLWKDVHQHUJ\VDYLQJVFRPSDUHGWRWKHYDSRUIHHG+RZHYHUWKHWZRHQWKDOS\IHHG
V\VWHPZLOOUHTXLUHPRUHVWDJHVWKDQWKHRWKHUV\VWHPV$FRPSOHWHHFRQRPLFDQDO\VLVLVUHTXLUHGWR
GHWHUPLQHWKHPRVWHFRQRPLFDOV\VWHP

' 8VH)LJWRILQG & VE *DVLV 1   /LTXLGLVDPPRQLD
   6LQFHV\VWHPYHU\GLOXWHWUHDWDVSXUHDPPRQLDOLTXLG SXUH 1  JDV
/ :/ NJ K / NPRO K 0:/ 
      
* :* NJ K 9 NPRO K 0:9 

J NJ FP
    /   
 NJ P  
FP J P

S0: Y DWP  J PRO / NJ NJ

    * 
 
57 / DWP P J P
 .
PRO.
 

    )Y   

   2IIFKDUW([WUDSRODWHXVLQJ(TH

    ORJ &VE  ORJ   ORJ  
    ORJ &VE &VE  

   $VVXPH   7KHQ
 
    X IORRG   IW V  X RS  XIORRG  

9 0: 9
    '  9  NPRO K  0:Y  NJ NPRO
Y X RS 
  Y  NJ P  X RS  IW V 1HHGWRZDWFKXQLWV



   
   '  P IW 
     IW
     3UREDEO\XVHIWGLDPHWHUFROXPQ±VWDQGDUGVL]H
   8VLQJODUJHUGLDPHWHUKHOSVWDNHLQWRDFFRXQWWKHXQFHUWDLQW\LQH[WUDSRODWLQJWRILQG & VE 

'1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ7KHPDVVEDODQFHDQGIORZUDWHFDOFXODWLRQVDUHWKHVDPHDVIRU
SUREOHP'

] [%  
' )    %  '  NPROGD\
[' [%  
    9 / '  '    NPRO GD\ 
NPRO GD\ K
   RU 9   NPRO V 
GD\ K V
  /9 7RSRIFROXPQLVFORVHWRSXUHPHWKDQRO
   7KXV / * / 9 * LV OE VIW   
OE NPRO NJ OE
    9LQ    OE V 
V V NPRO NJ
 5
3XUH0H2+ERLOVDW  & .  5 
.
NJ OEP FP  OEP
   / 0H2+  J FP  
 
J NJ IW IW 
   : /    
$VVXPHLGHDOJDV7RSRIFROXPQLVHVVHQWLDOO\SXUH0H2+
OE
DWP 
Q 0:0 S OEPRO OEP
  Y 0:0  
9 57 IW DWP 
IW 
  5
OEPRO 5
   
:/ * 
    )Y   
:* / 
  )URP)LJ2UGLQDWHDWIORRGLQJ 
 
 * / JF
    * IORRG 
 J F  )  7DEOH  
)
 
      OEP
    * IORRG 
  
   V IW 

  :KHUH PHWKDQRO  &  FSIURP3HUU\¶VWKHGS

    * DFWXDO  * IORRG    



 9LQ OE V 
    $UHD 
IW  
* DFWXDO OE V IW 
   
DUHD  
    'LDPHWHU IW 

1RWHWKDWWKLVLVODUJHUWKDQWKHFDOFXODWLRQRI'DWWKHERWWRPRIWKHFROXPQ7KXVGRFDOFXODWLRQV
DWWRSRIFROXPQ
   
)LQW 
   E )  'LDPHWHU ,QWDOR[ 'LD %HUO
 IW 
SODVWLF )%HUO 


'NPRO / 
(   RSWLPH ZKHUH' NPRO    / 9  
' NPRO KU ' 
'
   7KHQ ' 9 / 9 9 9DQGW RS
9
 8VH)LJRU(TDWRILQGIORRGLQJDWWKHHQGRIWKHRSHUDWLRQDWERWWRPRIFROXPQ
NJ
 0:OLT
/ OEP VIW / NPRO K NPRO 
   
* OEP VIW 
9 NPRO K NJ
0:YDSRU
NPRO
   $WHQGRIRSHUDWLRQDWERWWRPRIFROXPQ [  \  SLQFK
/ 
      
* 
0:DYJOLT      0:YDS        

/  OEP IW  (VVHQWLDOO\SXUHZDWHU%RLOVDWaž& .

OEP
DWP 
S 0: Y OEPRO OEP
    *  
57 DWPIW 
IW 
 .
. OEPRO
   
/ * 
   7KHQ )9   
* / 
   )URP(TD

    ORJ RUGLQDWH  ORJ   ORJ ) Y 
   ORJ RUGLQDWH  RUGLQDWH  DJUHHVZLWK)LJ  
  * / JF
    * 

)
 )URP7DEOH )    J F   ZDWHU  & a F S 3HUU\¶VWKHG



 
    OEP
   * IORRG 
 
   VIW 

OEPRO $UHD IW  OEP

  )URP(T 9 * 
V OE VIW 
0:YDSRU
O EPRO


    $UHD  IW  DQG* DFW  * IORRG 

OEPRO   
    9  
V 
NPRO OEPRO V NPRO
    9   NPRO K 
KU V K OEPRO
' NPRO
  7KHQ W RS K PLQ 
9  
\0  [ 0
)   1HHGDYHUDJH  )URP(TXLOGDWD
[ 0  \0
   
   %RW     7RS  
   
   *HRPHWULFDYJ    
   &ROXPQWHPSHUDWXUHYDULHVIURPžWRaž&

    $YJ7   & 

   OLTXLGV
IURP3HUU\¶VWKHG7 ž&S 0 FS : FS 
   1RWH0H2+LVSUREDEO\ZW
   (VWLPDWH Q PL[ [ 0 Q 0 [ : Q : 
   )HHGLV0:
    Q PL[  Q   Q   PL[  
   7KHQ  PL[    
   )URP2¶&RQQHOO¶V&RUUHODWLRQ)LJ ( R  

 (T ( R  ORJ     ORJ     
,IFRQVHUYDWLYHXVH

)   7RXVH2¶&RQQHOO¶VFRUUHODWLRQ)LJQHHGĮDQGYLVFRVLW\RIIHHG
.0 \0 [ 0 \0  [ 0
    0:
8VHG7DEOHIRUYDOXHV
. : \: [ : [ 0  \0
   &DQHVWLPDWHDJHRPHWULFDYHUDJHDWERWWRPIHHG WRS
   
   0 : ERW   0: IHHG [   
   



    
   0: WRS   DYJ  
ERW ) 7
 
   $YHUDJHVFDQEHFDOFXODWHGPDQ\RWKHUZD\V
   7KHIHHGLVVDWXUDWHGOLTXLG)URP7DEOH7 ž&
   9LVFRVLWLHVIURP3HUU\¶VS : FS  0H2+  
   1RWH0H2+SUREDEO\UHIHUVWRZWS3HUU\¶V
   (VWLPDWH Q PL[ [  Q  [   Q  
     Q PL[   Q   Q     PL[  
   7KHQ   
)HHG 
   2YHUDOO3ODWHHIILF 

] [% )   
)  '  % ) '   OE PRO K 
[' [%  
  $WWRSRIFROXPQ/ '/' DQG9 /' 
/ ) ) /
  6WULSSLQJVHFWLRQ / / T)ZKHUHT  
)
    /  9 / %  
  )HHGOLQHKDVVORSHDQGJRHVWKURXJK \ [ ]  7RSRSHUDWLQJOLQHKDVVORSH/9 
 DQG JRHV WKURXJK \ [ ['   %RWWRP RSHUDWLQJ OLQH JRHV WKURXJK
\ [ [ E  DQG WKH LQWHUVHFWLRQ RI WRS RSHUDWLQJ OLQH DQG IHHG OLQH 0F&DEH7KLHOH
VROXWLRQLVVKRZQ LQ)LJXUH2SWLPXPIHHGLVWKIURPWRS1HHGHTXLOLEULXPVWDJHV
SOXVSDUWLDOUHERLOHU





  2YHUDOO(IILFLHQF\)RU2¶&RQQHOO&RUUHODWLRQQHHG $9* DQG )HHG 7FRO 
\(  [ (
   8VLQJ7DEOHZHILQGĮDQGIROORZLQJPROHIUDFWLRQ
 \( [ (
 
   [  \     
 
 
   [  \     
 
 
   [  \     
 
 
    $9*     
  &DQHVWLPDWHȝIURPS(WK\O$OFRKRO+DQGERRNDW ]   ZW
  IUDF  FS7KXVĮȝ )URP2¶&RQQHOO&RUUHODWLRQ ( R  
   1    7KXVQHHGVWDJHVSOXVSDUWLDOUHERLOHU
  +HLJKW     GLVHQJDJHPHQW  ERWWRPVXPS IW 

9 0: 9
  'LDPHWHU&DOFXODWLRQ 'LD 
Y IORRGLQJIUDFWLRQ X IORRG 
  8VHDYHUDJHYDOXHVRISDUDPHWHUVLQVWULSSLQJDQGHQULFKLQJVHFWLRQV
   0: Y 0: HWK 
\HWK 0: :
\ : IRUERWK0: 9 DQG0: / 
  VWULSSLQJVHFWLRQ  0:  

    :/ / 0: /    OE K 

    :9 9 0: 9    OE K 

    /
 J PO  OE IW   %RWWRP 
    %RWWRPV7 ž& ž5
   9
3 0: 9 57     5  OE IW  

 )Y :/ :9 9 /      &VE  

  (QULFKLQJVHFWLRQ  0:  

    :/ / 0: /    

    :9 9 0: 9    OE K 

    /  J PO  OE IW   'LVWLOODWH 

    'LVWLOODWH7 ž& 7 ž5
   9 3 0: 9 57     5  OE IW   



 )Y :/ :9 9 /      &VE    
  

. &VE   IWVHFıVXUIDFHWHQVLRQLQG\QHFPWKHG+GENRI3K\VLFV&KHPLVWU\)
   %RWWRPVıaG\QFP0LGGOHıaG\QFP7RSıaG\QFP

   VWULSSLQJ .     IW V 

 HQULFKLQJ .     IW V 
  X IORRG . / 9 9  IW V 

 
  VWULSSLQJ X IORRG    IW V 

 
  HQULFKLQJ X IORRG    IW V 

 
    'LD 9 0:  9  X IORRG  
9

  VWULSSLQJ 9 0: 9 9  OEPRO K    OE IW   

  HQULFKLQJ 9 0: 9 9  OEPRO K    OE IW   

  'LDPHWHUVVWULSSLQJVHFWLRQ'LD IWDQGHQULFKLQJVHFWLRQ'LD IW
  3UREDEO\XVHIWGLDPHWHUVLQFHWKHUHLVOLWWOHLIDQ\FRVWSHQDOW\

)  1XPEHUVIURPVROXWLRQRI3UREOHP)DUHXVHG
9 OEPROV 0:9  OE OEPRO
  &URVV6HFWLRQDO$UHD 
*  OE VIW  
  %RWWRP / * / 9 0:/ 0:9  a   
  7RS  / * / 9 0:/ 0:9  a   
  ´PHWDO3DOOULQJV )      
  ȥ 'HQVLW\RIZDWHUGHQVLW\RIOLTXLG$W7RS    
  $Wž& Z FS ( FS  Q 0,; [ Q  [  Q  
   $WWRS \ [G   Q 0,;  Q   Q  DQG 0,;  
    0:Y \0:(  \ 0:Z      
    *  OE IW    /  
   
   / * * /     
 
    * )  * / J F IURP)LJXUH 
 
 J F    
   * * /
 
 OEP VIW   
)    
   9  PRO K  OEPRO V 



 90: Y
      $UHD    '   RU 
*
 
 
9 0: Y   
    '  
*  
  3UREDEO\XVHRUIRRWGLDPHWHUFROXPQV
  7KHFDOFXODWLRQDWWKHERWWRPRIWKHFROXPQJLYHVDVPDOOHUGLDPHWHU
    +(73 1 +HLJKWRI3DFNLQJRU  a  IW 

*1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ7KHUHVXOWIURP:DQNDWDLVOLVWHGLQWKHIROORZLQJ7DEOH
5HVXOWVIRUGLVWLOODWLRQRIYDSRUIHHGPROHPHWKDQROPROHZDWHU'LVWLOODWHLVPROH
IUDFWLRQPHWKDQRODQGERWWRPVLVPROHIUDFWLRQZDWHU7UD\VSDFLQJ P%DVHFDVH
FRQGLWLRQVDUHOLVWHGLQ7DEOHVDQGLQ:DQNDWD:KHQWZRWUD\VDUHOLVWHGWKH\KDYHWKHVDPH
GLDPHWHUV7KHGHFUHDVHLQYROXPHDQGLQFUHDVHLQ45DUHFRPSDUHGWRWKHEDVHFDVH

)/ 1)9 1)/ 1GLD$9ROWUD\454FWRWDO GHFU9ROLQFU45
EDVH   

7ZRHQWKDOS\IHHG
   
   
   
   
   
DOOOLTXLG 

,QWHUPHGLDWHFRQGHQVHU
):LWKGU 1)919ZLWK1/UHW1 GLD$9ROWUD\ 454FWRWDOGHFU9RO LQFU45
    
   

7ZRHQWKDOS\IHHG)/ NPROKUSOXVRQHLQWHUPHGLDWHFRQGHQVHU
)ZLWKGU1)91)/19ZLWK1/UHW1GLD$9ROWUD\45WRWDO4FGHFU9ROLQFU45
   
    

7ZRHQWKDOS\IHHG)/ NPROKU1)9 1)/ 1 SOXVWZRLQWHUPHGLDWHFRQGHQVHUV
)ZWKG19ZWK1/UHW)ZWKG19ZWK1/UHWGLD$9ROWUD\45WRWDO4FGHFU9ROLQFU45
 

7ZRHQWKDOS\IHHG)/ NPROKUSOXVRQHLQWHUPHGLDWHFRQGHQVHU
)ZLWKGU1)91)/19ZLWK1/UHW1GLD$9ROWUD\45WRWDO4FGHFU9ROLQFU45
   

:LWKFRQVWDQW4FDQG45WKHWZRHQWKDOS\IHHGZLWK)9 DQG1 DSSHDUVWREHEHVW


* 1HZ 3UREOHP LQ UG HGLWLRQ   5HVXOWV DUH IURP :DQNDW 3 & %DODQFLQJ 'LDPHWHUV RI
'LVWLOODWLRQ&ROXPQZLWK9DSRU)HHGV,QG(QJU&KHP5HVHDUFK




7DEOH6LPXODWLRQFRQGLWLRQVDQGUHVXOWVIRUEDVHFDVHV ) NPRO  K ' GLVWLOODWHIORZUDWH
NPROK 1  QXPEHU RI WUD\V  FRQGHQVHU  UHERLOHU WUD\ VSDFLQJ   LQFKHV   P
RSHUDWLRQDWRIIORRGLQJGLD PD[LPXPFDOFXODWHGGLDPHWHULQPWUD\ WUD\DWZKLFKPD[
GLDPHWHURFFXUUHG$ PD[FDOFXODWHGFROXPQDUHDLQ P  9RO FROXPQYROXPHLQ P    $1
±WUD\VSDFLQJZKHUH1±LVWKHQXPEHURIWUD\VDQGLVIRUGLVHQJDJHPHQWVSDFHIRU
OLTXLGDQGYDSRU 4 5 DQG 4 F UHERLOHUDQGFRQGHQVHUGXWLHVLQN: S FRQG FRQGHQVHUSUHVVXUH
LQ DWP S SUHVVXUH GURS LQ SVLWUD\ 1 IHHG  RSWLPXP IHHG VWDJH DQG FRQGHQVHU LV VWDJH 
1RWHWKLVVROXWLRQKDVD S HDFKVWDJH7KXVVROXWLRQVOLJKWO\GLIIHUHQWWKDQVWXGHQWV¶VROXWLRQV

1 )HHG  1 'LD $ 9RO WUD\ 4 5  4 F   / '  ' S FRQG  S          


(WKDQROPROH:DWHUPROH9DSRU)HHG%DVH&DVH          

           


  
  7DEOH'LDPHWHUVFDOFXODWHGIRUVWDQGDUGGLVWLOODWLRQEDVHFDVHVOLVWHGLQ7DEOH9DSRUIORZ
UDWH 9M DQGOLTXLGIORZUDWH / M DUHLQNPROKUGLDPHWHULVLQPDUHDLV P   
(WKDQROZDWHUYDSRU
7UD\ 9M /M 'LD $UHD
    
    
    
    


 7DEOH6LPXODWLRQFRQGLWLRQVDQGUHVXOWVIRUDGLVWLOODWLRQFROXPQVHSDUDWLQJDYDSRUPROH
HWKDQROZDWHUIHHGVHH7DEOHIRUEDVHFRQGLWLRQV3DUWLDOFRQGHQVHULVVWDJH 1 )9 DQG 1 )/ 
DUHRSWLPXPIHHGORFDWLRQVIRUYDSRUDQGOLTXLGSRUWLRQVRIWKHIHHGUHVSHFWLYHO\'HFUHDVHLQFROXPQ
YROXPH9ROHTXDOWRFKDQJHLQDUHDZKHQWKHQXPEHURIVWDJHVLVXQFKDQJHGDQGLQFUHDVHVLQ 4 5 DUH
FRPSDUHGWRWKHHWKDQROZDWHUEDVHFDVH7DEOH)RUERWKUXQV \ '(  DQG [ %:  

)/  1 )9  1 )/  1 'LD $ 9RO 7UD\ 4 5  4 &FRO 
EDVH         

)/  1 )9  1 )/  1 'LD $ 9RO 7UD\ 4 5  4 &WRW  'HFU9RO ,QFU 4 5 
           
4FWRWDO 4FFRO 4FIHHG FRQGHQVHU


*1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ3DUWD6'LD P'LVWLOODWHPROHIUDFWLRQVYDSRU 
(WK3URSDQH(%DQG(SHQWDQH%RWWRPVPROHIUDFWLRQV (
(WK(3URSDQH%XWDQHDQGSHQWDQH2WKHUYDOXHVDUHLQ7DEOHIRU*
3DUWE:RUVWEDFNXSLVPRQVWDJHVDQG0D[LPXPZHLUORDGLQJLVPVRQSODWH
3DUW F 6DPH PROH IUDFWLRQV VDPH 4F DQG 45  0D[ EDFNXS  P LQ SDQHO $ RQ VWDJHV  WR 
0D[LPXPZHLUORDGLQJLVPVRQSODWHRISDQHO$ZKLFKLVDFFHSWDEOH

*1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ




 9IHHG /IHHG 4FN: 45N: 0D['LD 6WDJH \'& [%&
.PROV .PROV P PD[GLD
 SDVV 1)       
SDUWG 1)       
 SDVV 1)       
       
       
       
       
       
       
E&KDQJH 1  1)OLT  1)YDS     
1
       
! "!#$%&'(!)*+,!-*+.%',!/01231!
! 4$*5!61!7*$8!*$59:;!-*+;*$,!<95=!>9$!?!/1@A3!,!$:B!B')$&%5(!)+*!5*$8!(-$69:;!C01D0AD,E!F!)+*!>G!
6%'$*$:6'!C0103@3,E!+.5$9:!01HH0@!,!.$6I&-!+:!5*$8!3JK!<=96=!9(!$66'-5$.%'1!!L$M9,&,!<'9*!%+$B9:;!9(!
010/NN@!,HO(!+:!5*$8!3J!<=96=!9(!$66'-5$.%'1!!
! 4$*5!B1!P=+<:!$.+Q'K!-%&(!,$M9,&,!.$6I&-!9(!01H3H0!+:!-%$5'! 3/!C$66'-5$.%'E!$:B!,$M9,&,!
<'9*!%+$B9:;!9(!010H0J!,HO(!+:!-%$5'!3/K!<=96=!9(!,$*;9:$%1!



 63(UG(GLWLRQ6ROXWLRQ0DQXDO&KDSWHU

1HZ3UREOHPVDQGQHZVROXWLRQVDUHOLVWHGDVQHZLPPHGLDWHO\DIWHUWKHVROXWLRQQXPEHU7KHVHQHZ
SUREOHPVDUH$$%&''**

$ $V IHHG WHPSHUDWXUH LQFUHDVHV / ' 0,1  LQFUHDVHV KHQFH /9 LQFUHDVHV DQG 4 F  LQFUHDVHV
/ 9 LQFUHDVHVDQG 4 5 GHFUHDVHV7KHQXPEHURIVWDJHVSUREDEO\GHFUHDVHV
 6HH )LJXUH   7KH DEVFLVVD LQFUHDVHV DV / ' PLQ
 DQG /' LQFUHDVH  7KXV RUGLQDWH GURSV
6LQFH 1 0,1 LVFRQVWDQW1GHFUHDVHV

$1HZ3UREOHPIRUUGHGLWLRQ
E$OLTXLGVLGHVWUHDPEHWZHHQWKHIHHGDQGWKHGLVWLOODWH  SRLQWIRUE
F$YDSRUVLGHVWUHDPEHWZHHQWKHIHHGDQGWKHERWWRPV  SRLQWVIRUF

$ ,IWKHIHHGUDWHLVFRQVLVWHQWO\RQHKDOIWKHGHVLJQFDSDFLW\WKHHQWLUHHFRQRP\RIVFDOHZLOOEH
ORVW,QDGGLWLRQGLVWLOODWLRQFROXPQVSUREDEO\RSHUDWHDWORZHUWKDQGHVLJQHIILFLHQFLHV

$ &ROXPQZRXOGKDYHWREHDWDORZHUSUHVVXUHWKDQFROXPQ

$1HZ3UREOHPIRUUGHGLWLRQ7KHKHXULVWLFVWRQRWGRZRXOGLQFOXGHLWHPVVXFKDV
5HPRYHGDQJHURXVFRUURVLYHDQGUHDFWLYHFRPSRQHQWVODVW
8VHGLVWLOODWLRQRQO\IRUYHU\GLIILFXOWVHSDUDWLRQVĮ$QGVRIRUWK
;7 
%  8VHKHXULVWLFV+DUGHVWVHSDUDWLRQLV[\OHQHFXPHQH [ F  
&7 
  7RXOHQHLVPRVWDEXQGDQW8VHKHXULVWLFVWR
   5HPRYHWROXHQHHDUO\
   'RKDUGHVWVHSDUDWLRQODVW
   2QHE\RQHLQRYHUKHDG

  ,IXVHHTXLOPRODOVSOLWV

$# &# %#

'#
(#


    &DQDOVRGHULYHFRXSOHGV\VWHPV

!""#
#
 $# %#

'#
&#
(#


%  $GGLQ+HXULVWLFIRUVORSS\VHSDUDWLRQ
&# &#
$# $#

%#
'# *+# '#

%#

(# (#

&1HZ3UREOHPIRUUGHGLWLRQ7DNHWKHORJRIERWKVLGHVRI(T

 ORJFRVW$FRVW% H[SRQHQWORJVL]H$VL]H%

 ORJFRVW$±ORJFRVW% H[SRQHQW>ORJVL]H$±ORJVL]H%@

 H[SRQHQW >ORJFRVW$±ORJFRVW%@>ORJVL]H$±ORJVL]H%@

'  127(7KLVVROXWLRQUHTXLUHVWKHVROXWLRQWR3UREOHP'(VWLPDWHĮDWIHHGFRPSRVLWLRQ
[ ] 
 . F
 D E )RUELQDU\ [ F  \ F . F [ F  8VH)LJ
. F . F
   7 ž& . F  . F  [ F  \ F  
   *XHVVZDVDLGHGE\VROXWLRQWR3UREOHP'
 
      
 
 
Q
 
     1 0,1 VWDJHV 
Q 
/ [ ' \  
      
9 PLQ [ ' ]  


!")#
#
 / / 9
      
' PLQ  / 9 PLQ

/ ' / '  

 F *LOOLODQG [ 0,1
 
/ '  
   (TE 1 1 0,1 1   
   1     FRQWDFWVRUVWDJHV 
 G 1 DFW 1 HT ( R   RUVWDJHV 
   ´WUD\VSDFLQJîWUD\V IW
          GLVHQJDJHPHQW
         + IW P
P
      ' IW  P 
IW
'
   7UD\DUHD P  &ROXPQ9RO DUHD + P  

FRV W 
   )LJ  P   & 3WRZHU  

P 
YRO P
7UD\ FRV W
   )LJ  P   & 3 WUD\  P   WUD\ 
DUHD
   (T  &%0WRZHU        
S'  
 N3D EDU(T)S    
 S   

   )LJ   & %0WUD\     
WRWDO 

'   ž&ES ž) )  '  %   / 9   / '  
            /  OEPRO K 9  
   (QHUJ\%DO 9+ Y 4F 9K ' JLYHV4 F 9 KR +Y 
   K ' LVSXUHERLOLQJKH[DQH+ Y LVYDSRU 
    7KXV K ' +Y F  %WXOEPRO
     4F      %WX K 
       45 'K ' %K % )K ) 4& 
   3LFNž&DVEDVLV
 )
    K' & 3/ F        
&
%WX
     K% & 3/F        
OEPRO
   )HHGLVDVDWXUDWHGOLTXLG)URP([DPSOH7 ž&

!",#
#
    K) &3/F ] F &3/F ] F    
    K)        %WX OEPRO 
    45          
       45   %WX K 
4     %WX K
  5HERLOHU  $  IW  
8 7%WX  )

  &
KIW   ) &
  ZKHUH8LVDYHUDJHIURP7DEOH
4F   
  &RQGHQVHU $ IW  
8  7$YJ   
 

  1RWHWKHVHDUHDVDUHYHU\DSSUR[LPDWH)RUGHWDLOHGGHVLJQQHHGDPXFKEHWWHUHVWLPDWHRI8

 P
  &RVWV &RQGHQVHU $ IW 
P  
IW
      )L[HG7XEH6KHHW6 7)LJ&RVW P

 P
   5HERLOHU $ IW 
P  ODUJHEHFDXVHRIORZ8  
IW
     ([WUDSRODWHP
   DWP )S  )P  (T &%0 &S  )P )4 & S 

   &RQGHQVHU  & %0  P    
P
 
  5HERLOHU & %0  P  P  
  9HU\VHQVLWLYHWR8

'  1RWH7KLVVROXWLRQUHTXLUHVWKHVROXWLRQWR3UREOHP'
OE 4 5    OE
    6WHDPUDWH   
K  K
  ZKHUH 4 5 LVIURP6ROXWLRQWRSUREOHP'
 OE 
    6WHDP&RVW    K 
K K OE
OE 4F    OE
    &RROLQJZDWHU   
K & S Z 7Z   K
   ZKHUH 4 5 LVIURP6ROXWLRQWRSUREOHP'
 OE  
    :DWHU&RVW    K 
K K JDO  OE JDO


!)-#
#
'  )URP([DPSOHQHHGHGHTVWDJHV35
   K SDFN  IW VWDJH IW P 

'    P
   9RO K SDFN   IW IW 
P  
  IW
  )URP)LJ &S a   P SDFNLQJ 
  7RZHU IWIWEHWZHHQVHFWLRQVIWWRSIWWRS IW
P
   K  IW P 9HVVHO9RO P  
IW
  )LJ &S  P IRUWRZHU 

)S  DWP 7RZHU)0  FDUERQVWHHO  & %0 & S      
  
3DFNLQJ )P  
& %0 & S        

    7RWDO 
  'RHVQRWLQFOXGHFRVWGLVWULEXWRUVVXSSRUWVKROGGRZQSODWHVHWF

'1HZ3UREOHPIRUUGHGLWLRQQ >ORJFRVW$±ORJFRVW%@>ORJVL]H$±ORJVL]H%@
/HWVL]H$ PDQGVL]H% P7KHFRVW$ P PP DQG
FRVW% 
 Q >ORJ±ORJ@>ORJ±ORJ@ >±@>@ 

' 6HHUHVLGXHFXUYHVLQ)LJXUH7KHUHF\FOHLVSXUH0%0L[LQJSRLQWLVGHWHUPLQHGLQVDPHZD\
DVLQ)LJ1RZPL[LQJSRLQWVSOLWVLQWROLJKW/FRPSRQHQWPHWKDQRORQ % 7KXVOLQH
/0LVH[WHQGHGWRPROHIUDFWLRQPHWKDQROWRILQGORFDWLRQRI % 0%DQG
WROXHQH:HFDQXVHPDVVEDODQFHWRILQGSRLQW % DFFXUDWHO\,I ' LVSXUHPHWKDQRO '  
DOOPHWKDQROLQIHHGDQG %  7KHQIURPWROXHQHEDODQFHî  [ WRO% ZKLFK
JLYHV [ WRO%  % ) ZKLFKLVWKHQVSOLWLQWR,6RPHRIZKLFKLVUHF\FOHGDQG % 
ZKLFKLVWROXHQHSURGXFW
    ) 5H F\FOH   0 % ' 
  6LQFH ' FRQWDLQVQRWROXHQH %  )  5H F\FOH  

   %   NPR K  )  ' 0 %  NPRO K 

  )RU&ROXPQ %  HVVHQWLDOO\SXUHWROXHQH %  )    
  2.±6DWLVILHVRYHUDOOH[WHUQDO0%
     '  5H F\FOH ) %    
     '  ZKLFKDOVRVDWLVILHVH[WHUQDO0%


!).#
#
' D 3URSRVHG6SOLW%RWWRPV±(VVHQWLDOO\SXUHWROXHQH
      'LVWLOODWHaPHWKDQRO6HHILJXUHIRU6ROXWLRQWR'
     )  ] 0  ] 0%  ] 7  
  $VVXPHDOOWROXHQHLQERWWRPV ERWWRPVLVSXUH
     %    '  
    [ 0GLVW   [ 0GLVW  [0%GLVW 
E 3URSRVHG6SOLW'LVWLOODWHSXUH0
   %RWWRPV0%76HHILJXUH
   '    %  
  1RWH±'RXEWIXOWKLVZLOOZRUN


!)!#
#
 


'1HZ3UREOHPIRUUGHGLWLRQ3DUWD
 &RVWLQ-XQH       
3DUWE
 ) [) RI([DPSOH
  6LQFH 'LD )  'LD)  IW  RUIHHW  
P
   'LDPHWHU  P 7UD\$UHD P   
IW

 7RZHU 9ROXPH P )LJ &S &RVW YRO a  P 
   &3WRZHU  P P  
 )LJ 

7UD\ FRV W DUHD a  P H[WUDSRODWH  &SWUD\  P  P  WUD\ 
   &%0WRZHU           

!)/#
#
   &%0WUD\V       
 7RWDOEDUHPRGXOHFRVW6HSWHPEHU 
 ,Q-XQH&RVW        
3DUWF 2ULJLQDOIHHGUDWH OEPRO K  
 $W  )RULJLQDO   FRVW OEPRO  OEPRO 
 $W  [)RULJLQDO   FRVW OEPRO  OEPRO



*  8VH)LJEDVIORZVKHHW8VH157/
   )HHG  DWPVDW
G/LTNPROK0H2+70% 
   )HGWR6WDJH
  ,QW5HF\FOHVDW¶G/LTNPROK0%IHGWR6WDJH
     
  %ORFN % 1 WRWDOFRQGHQVHUSDUWLDOUHERLOHU' /' 
   'LVW  0H2+ WRO( 0% 
    %RW  ( 0H2+WRO0%
       
  %ORFN%1 /' % IHHG 
   'LVW 0H2+7RO0%
   %RW  ( 0H2+ WRO0% 
  7KXVWKLVLVIHDVLEOH

* D )RU)LJ$
/ %RWWRPWRO
    &RO1  1 I  '  
' 0%
 
'LVWWRO0%
  &RO1  1 I  / '  %  %RW 0%0H2+ 
WROXHQH
  ,ILQFUHDVH/'LQFROXPQ &RO / '  1  1 I %RWWROXHQH 
  &RO / '  1  1 I 'LVW0H2+%RW0% 

  :KLFKQRZPHHWVVSHFLILFDWLRQV7KXV)LJXUHDZLWKRXWUHF\FOHLVIHDVLEOH

 E )RU)LJ%±FRQYHUJHG1 /' 
       'LVW&RO 0 7±1R0%
         D]HRWURSH
      :RXOGQRWFRQYHUJHKLJKHU1
       'RHVQRWDSSHDUWRZRUNWKXVQRWIHDVLEOH
  
*1HZ3UREOHPIRUUGHGLWLRQ )   (WKDQRODWP6DW¶GOLTXLGIHHG
  1 LQFOXGHVSDUWLDOUHERLOHUWRWDOFRQGHQVHU'  / ' 
  

!)0#
#
 3  1)  45   ['(  [%( 
 1)  45    
 1)     
 1)     
 1)   4&   ĸ
 1)  FDOV   

  
     
3FRO DWP / '     
 1)  45    
 1)  45  4F   ĸ
 1)     

3FRO DWP / '     

 1)  45    
 1)   4F     ĸ
 1)     

6L]HRSWLPDOIHHGFROXPQV6LHYHWUD\XVHVLQFKWUD\VSDFLQJDWDSSURDFKIORRGLQJ)DLU
FDOFXODWLRQPHWKRGIRUIORRGLQJ
  3FRO  0D[GLDPHWHUWUD\ P
3FRO  0D[GLDPHWHUWUD\ P 
  3FRO  0D[GLDPHWHUWUD\ P 

3DUWG 'DWPJLYHVWKHEHVWVHSDUDWLRQEHFDXVHWKHUHODWLYHYRODWLOLW\LVKLJKHVW
'7KHORZHVW4UHERLOHULVDWP7KHHIIHFWRISUHVVXUHRQ4UHERLOHULQWKLVSUREOHPRFFXUV
EHFDXVHWKHIHHGLVDOZD\VDVDWXUDWHGOLTXLGDWDWP)RUWKHDWPFROXPQWKLVIHHGUHPDLQVD
VDWXUDWHGOLTXLGDQGWKHIHHGOLQHLVYHUWLFDO$WORZHUFROXPQSUHVVXUHVWKHIHHGIODVKHVDQGLVDWZR
SKDVHIHHGLQWKHFROXPQ7KHVHIHHGOLQHVKDYHDQHJDWLYHVORSH)RUWKHIHHGOLQHVDWORZHUSUHVVXUHV
WKHVORSHVRIWKHERWWRPRSHUDWLQJOLQHVDUHVWHHSHUZKLFKPHDQVORZHUERLOXSUDWLRV9UHERLOHU%7KLV
PHDQVORZHU4UHERLOHUDWWKHORZHUSUHVVXUHV$QRWKHUZD\WRWKLQNDERXWWKLVLVWKHIODVKLQJIHHGSURGXFHV
YDSRUDQGWKXVOHVVYDSRULVUHTXLUHGIURPWKHUHERLOHU
'7KHORZHVWDEVROXWHYDOXHRI4FRQGHQVHULVDWP$OOFROXPQVKDYHWKHVDPH'DQG/'
7KXV9HQWHULQJWKHFRQGHQVHULVWKHVDPH$WKLJKHUSUHVVXUHVWKHODWHQWKHDWRIYDSRUL]DWLRQȜLVORZHU
6LQFH4FRQGHQVHU 9ȜWKHUHVXOWLVDORZHUDEVROXWHYDOXHRI4FRQGHQVHUDWWKHKLJKHUSUHVVXUHV
'7KHVPDOOHVWGLDPHWHUFROXPQLVDWDWP9DSRUGHQVLW\LVKLJKHVW

3DUWH ,QFUHDVLQJSUHVVXUHDERYHDWPIRUWKHVDPHSXULW\UHTXLUHVPRUHVWDJHVEXWVPDOOHUFROXPQ
GLDPHWHU7KXVFDSLWDOFRVWLQLWLDOO\JRHVGRZQ$ERYHDWPWKHFROXPQPXVWEHGHVLJQHGIRUKLJK
SUHVVXUHRSHUDWLRQZKLFKPDNHVLWPRUHH[SHQVLYH2SHUDWLQJFRVWPD\JRXSLIDKLJKHU/'LVUHTXLUHG
WRDFKLHYHWKHGHVLUHGSXULW\

*1HZ3UREOHPIRUUGHGLWLRQ
D/'PLQ ĺ/' 2EWDLQ1$VSHQ1RWDWLRQ ZLWK1IHHG RQVWDJH
'LVWLOODWHLVHWKDQRODQGERWWRPVLVPROHIUDFWLRQHWKDQRO4 5 FDOV

!)1#
#
4F FDOV'LD P$ P+ P9RO P

3DUWE1RWHWKDWEDODQFLQJWKHIORZUDWHVWRDFKLHYHWKHGHVLUHGVHSDUDWLRQLQHDFKFROXPQLVWULDODQG
HUURU7KHHDVLHVWZDVWRGRWKLVLVWRILUVWILQGDIORZUDWHWKDWZRUNVIRUWKHKLJKSUHVVXUHFROXPQQRWH
WKDW'FKDQJHVHYHU\WLPHWKHIORZUDWHLVFKDQJHG7KLVJLYHVDYDOXHIRU4 &KLJKSUHVVXUH 45ORZSUHVVXUH
7KHQGHVLJQWKHORZSUHVVXUHFROXPQZLWKWKLV45&KHFNWKDWERWKFROXPQVZRUN7KHFRUUHFWIORZUDWH
LQWRWKHKLJKSUHVVXUHFROXPQLVEHWZHHQDQG7KHUHVXOWVDUHUHSRUWHGEHORZZLWKWKH
ODWWHUYDOXH
+LJKSUHVVXUHFROXPQ) NPROK45  FDOV1 1IHHG 
GLVWLOODWHLVPROHIUDFWLRQHWKDQRODQGERWWRPVLVPROHIUDFWLRQHWKDQRO4 F 
FDOV/' 7 FRQG .'LD P$ + P9RO 
P

/RZSUHVVXUHFROXPQ) NPROK45 FDOV1 1IHHG GLVWLOODWHLV
PROHIUDFWLRQHWKDQRODQGERWWRPVLVPROHIUDFWLRQHWKDQRO4F FDOV/' 
7FRQG .7UHE .'LD P$ + P9RO P

3DUWF(QHUJ\UHTXLUHPHQWRIPXOWLHIIHFWGLVWLOODWLRQV\VWHPZDVVHWDWRIWKHVLQJOHFROXPQ
7KLVLVQRWRSWLPL]HGEXWZDVVHWEHFDXVHLWZDVNQRZQWRZRUN&RROLQJLVRQO\LQWKHORZSUHVVXUH
FROXPQRIWKHPXOWLHIIHFWV\VWHPDQGLVVLJQLILFDQWO\OHVVWKDQZLWKRQO\RQHFROXPQ7KHWRWDOYROXPH
RIFROXPQVLVWKHVDPHKRZHYHUWKLVLVPLVOHDGLQJEHFDXVHYROXPHLQWKHVLQJOHFROXPQZRXOGKDYH
EHHQOHVVLILWZDVGHVLJQHGDWDWP7KHFDSLWDOFRVWZLOOEHKLJKHUIRUEXLOGLQJWZRFROXPQVWKDQRQH
ODUJHURQHEXWHQHUJ\FRVWVDUHOHVV

#

!)2#
#
 63(UG(GLWLRQ6ROXWLRQ0DQXDO&KDSWHU

1HZ3UREOHPVDQGQHZVROXWLRQVDUHOLVWHGDVQHZLPPHGLDWHO\DIWHUWKHVROXWLRQQXPEHU7KHVHQHZ
SUREOHPVDUH$$&'''''''*

$  %\UDLVLQJ7RU GURSSLQJSFDQ PDNH JDVGHVRUE7KH GLUHFWLRQ RIWUDQVIHU RIVROXWH

FRQWUROV ZKHWKHUDFROXPQLVDVWULSSHURUDEVRUEHU,I RSHUDWLQJ OLQHRQ < YV;LV
EHORZHTXLOLEULXPKDYHDVWULSSHU

$  1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQF$VSHQ3OXV

$  1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ$D%G&H'K(L

%  &DOFXODWH1RU \ RXW RU1IRU$DQG \ RXW IRU%RUPRU1IRU$DQGPIRU%RU/9
RUIHHGFRPSRVLWLRQRUERUPDQGEIURPH[SHULPHQWVRU2YHUDOO(IILFLHQF\

%  7ZRIHHGV6LGHVWUHDP5HERLOHGDEVRUEHU&RXSOHGDEVRUEHUDQGVWULSSHUVHH)LJXUH
 ,QWHUVWDJH FRROHUV DEVRUSWLRQ RU KHDWHUV VWULSSHUV 3DFNHG FROXPQV 7ZR
GLIIHUHQW VROYHQWV 7ZR GLIIHUHQW VWULSSLQJ JDVHV $GG VROLG DGVRUEHG WR VROYHQW VHH
&KDSW&URVVIORZ&RFXUUHQWIORZ&RPELQDWLRQVRIIORZSDWWHUQVHWF

%  6HH,VRPDQG5RJHUV
(T  
&    (R 1 HTXLO 1 DFWXDO    
(T  
P9 P9
Q  ( P9  Q  ( P9 
/ /
    (R 
Q  / P9 Q  / P9
P9
Q  ( P9 
/
      (R   
Q  P9 /
           4('

   5HI/DFNV'-&KHP(QJU(GXF)DOO

[ G\
&      \  P 

  [ G[   [
G\
   :KHQ   [    E 
G[
G\  
   :KHQ   [    E 
G[
   $SSO\.UHPVHUDV [ RU[  

\1  \
&   *UDSKLFDOO\ / 9 0,1
ZKHUH \ 1   [ 1 DUHLQHTXLOLEULXP
[1 [



           \1  P[ 1 E IRUOLQHDU
/ /
   )RUDEVRUEHUV P   
9 PLQ P9 PLQ

/
   7KXVDV  1  
P9 PLQ

\1 \ /
   (TEHFRPHV  

ZKHUH\ P[  E
\1  \ P9 PLQ

\1  \ / \1  \ /
   RU    
\1  E 9 [1 [ 9
[ PLQ PLQ

P P
   ZKLFKDJUHHVZLWKJUDSKLFDODQDO\VLV

+ 
'1HZ3UREOHPUG(GLWLRQ \ [ [ [ 
S WRW 
  P E  


 *! \  !

 [   ! "#$#%&#!
"#$#%&#!
 (!
 /[  *\ 1 *\ /[ 1


 ! !
 \ P[     !

 )!



\ 1  XQNQRZQ
 *! [1 '! \ 1   ! +,#-.! [ 1 !"#$#%&#/!!
 !
!
"#$#%&#!
 012!3(45678!%9!3(456(8!.:;,.;<!<%!";.!

P9 \ 1  \ P9
Q 
/ \ \ /
 (T  
P9
Q
/

     
Q  Q  
/   / / /
   
/ /
Q Q
 




 7 (ĺEHVXUH / P9  
/ P9/ /P9 5+6
   
   
   
   
     2. 
* 
  [1 \1  \ [     
/ 
Q  
 7KHUHDUHDOWHUQDWLYHVROXWLRQSDWKVEXW/ LVQRWYDOLGLWEHFRPHV 
Q  
 $OWHUQDWLYH7ULDODQGHUURU0F&DEH7KLHOHVROXWLRQ


'
 D / 9FRQVWDQWUHF+6  OHIWLQJDV
     \ RXW    
S + 6 [
  (TXLO  \ [ 
S WRW 
  0%ZLWK&RQVW/ 9 9 9 [ RXW / 
9 
     [ RXW    (  
/ 
/ /
 E 6HH)LJXUH \ [ \ LQ [ RXW ZKHUH \ LQ  [ RXW   \ RXW  [ LQ DUHRQRSOLQH 
9 9
 F


01! )%<.!<>:<! / * PLQ -:#!

! ?.!-:@-"@:<.A!B9%C!:!
\LQ  !
-9"A.!;$.<->2!
[ (  !
/* PLQ
!
=!
/  

* PLQ ( 
/ ! /
\ RXW  !  0
* DFW * PLQ E!F!(24(GH!
7!
!
7! D!





 G /*WRRKLJK±/WRRKLJK±/LTXLGWRRGLOXWH
  1HHGPXFKEHWWHUVROYHQWHJ0($VROXWLRQ


'1HZ3UREOHPUG(GLWLRQ0DVV%DODQFH
!
+
     9\ ,1 /[ ,1 \ RXW 9 /[ (TXLO \ [
S WRW
   6XEVWLWXWHHTXLOLQWR0%
+9[ +9[
   /[ ,1 /[ / [ ,1 [ 
S WRW S WRW

+9[    
   6ROYH S WRW  
DWP 
/ [ ,1 [     

+   
 E  \ RXW [ RXW     
S WRW 
  &DQDOVRGRJUDSKLFDOO\ZLWK.UHPVHUHTXDWLRQWULDODQGHUURURUE\VROYLQJPDVVEDODQFHILUVW
/
    \ RXW [ LQ [ RXW    7KHQ S WRW + [ RXW \RXW DWP 
9


' 0DVVEDO \LQ 9LQ /LQ [ LQ \ RXW 9 /[ RXW 



 / / /
 \ RXW \ LQ [ LQ [ RXW [ LQ [ RXW      
9 9 9
/ /
  2S(T   \ [ \ LQ[ RXW  
9 9
 SRLQW \LQ  [ RXW   DQG SRLQW \ RXW  [ LQ   DUHRQRS
OLQH6HHJUDSK

  &DQDOVRXVH.UHPVHUHTXDWLRQIRUWKLVSUREOHP




            

'  6LQFH HTXLOLEULXP LV OLQHDU LQ ZHLJKW UDWLR XQLWV FDQ GR HLWKHU 0F&DEH7KLHOH RU
.UHPVHU VROXWLRQV )RU 0F&DEH7KLHOH VROXWLRQ NQRZ WKDW SRLQWV
<RXW  ;LQ DQG <LQ  ; RXW DUHRQRSHUDWLQJOLQH0F&DEH7KLHOHGLDJUDPLVVKRZQLQ
)LJXUH1 VWDJHV+(73  IW




  .UHPVHU  6HYHUDO GLIIHUHQW IRUPV FDQ EH XVHG  :H ZLOO LOOXVWUDWH ZLWK (T 
ZULWWHQLQUDWLRXQLWV

      <1  <LQ  <1 P; RXW    
      < <RXW  < P; LQ    
Q    
      1  
Q    
      +(73 K 1   IHHW 

')LUVWDVVXPH1LWURJHQLVDQLGHDOJDV OEPRO FXIWDWÛ&DQGDWP

        FXIWOEPRODWÛ&

     1  IORZUDWH     OEPROK
  :DWHUIORZUDWH,JQRUH &2  LQZDWHU 0:Z  
 
        OEPROK




 +
  (TXLOLEULXPDWÛ&+ \  [ [ 
3727
/ 
     ([WHUQDOPDVVEDODQFHLV
9

/ / /
    \ RXW [ LQ \ LQ [ RXW [ LQ [ RXW      
9 9 9
  &DQ VROYH ZLWK HLWKHU 0F&DEH7KLHOH GLDJUDP RU ZLWK .UHPVHU (T   7KH
0F&DEH7KLHOHVROXWLRQLVVKRZQLQWKHILJXUH1RWHGLIIHUHQWVFDOHVRQD[HV1HHG
UHDOVWDJHV


  

.UHPVHU \ 1   \  \ P[     
  P 9 /  

 
Q   
 
    1  
Q    
  3UREDEO\XVHUHDOVWDJHV

NJJDV
'     * :W  ZWIUDFDLU   NJDLUK
K

      * PROH  NPRODLUK

\ LQ   NJ1+ 
      <LQ  
 \ LQ
   NJDLU

      <LQ PRODU   

  ,QOHW   1+    NJ 1+  
    UHPDLQVLQJDV NJ1+  



  
      <RXW PROH  
 
S 1+  S PP+J S PP+J
  (TXLOLEULXPGDWD7DEOH \ PROH 
3727   

NJ1+    \
; ZW  S <PROH 
NJ: \ PROHIUDF   \
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   

; LQ / /; ZW
      0% * PRO <PRO *<RXW  
 NJ1+ 

NPRO1+ 
/ ZW
     <PROH ; ZW <RXW 
* PROH

 1RWH8QLWVDOWKRXJKPL[HGZRUNLQ0DVV%DODQFH LQ2SHUDWLQJHTXDWLRQ6HHJUDSK
  
  0LQLPXP6ROYHQW
  / ZW PLQ
      6ORSH   
  * PROH
      / ZWPLQ       NJ: K 
NJ:
      $FWXDO6ROYHQW / ZW / PLQ  
K
/ ZW 
      2S/LQH6ORSH  
* PROH  




 

! !



!

(42IG2!1HZ3UREOHPUG(GLWLRQ!

! ; ,1  \ RXW  <RXW  !

!
! / S WRW DWP  PP+J !

*! PP+J !
!
'!
! )  DLU !
*! *!
!!!  PRO+&O
PROHIUDF+&O \  !
 PRODLU
!
; RXW !
!
)  * 
! !  PRO+&O
\,1 PROHIUDF+&O <,1  !
 PRODLU
!

$VVXPH:DWHUQRWWRWDOOLTXLGIORZUDWHLVFRQVWDQWLQERWKVHFWLRQV$VVXPHDLUIORZUDWHQRWWRWDOJDV

FRQVWDQWLVHDFKVHFWLRQ,QERWWRPVHFWLRQ * PRO DLU K  ,QWRSVHFWLRQ
*    PRO DLU K .HHS;DV NJ+&O NJZDWHU IURPHTXLOGDWD
&RQYHUWSWR\PROHIUDFWLRQWR<PROHUDWLRV
NJ+&O S NJ+&O \
; ! J! \ ! < !
NJZDWHU S WRW NPRODLU  \

7! 7! 7! 7!

727GK7! 72777LG6! 62G6LL!05K! 62G6LL05K!

72(M7L! 727(H! 727777(7L6! 727777(7L6!

726(H! 72N6! 727774G4M! 727774G67!

72NK! ((2G! 7277KKH6! 7277KG4N72!

72LH6! LH2N! 7276K(7L! 7276GL6L!

72HHK! 466! 2(L64M! 2(G(7N!

72KGH! GN7! 2LL4H6! (246L6!



  <YV;HTXLOLEULXPGDWDLVFXUYHG
 8VLQJWKHVHXQLWVZHQHHG/LQ NJZDWHU KU DQG * DQG*LQ NPRODLU KU DQGZHQHHGWR
FRQYHUWWKH;WHUPVIURPNJ+&OKWRNPRO+&OK
 7RS2SHUDWLQJ/LQH *< /  0:+&O ; ,1 /  0:+&O ; *<RXW  ; ,1  
/ /
 < ; <RXW  *RHVWKURXJK
*0:+&O  0:+&O 
%RWWRP2SHUDWLQJ/LQH *< /  0:+&O ; RXW *<LQ /  0:+&O ;  
/ /
< ; <,1 ; RXW  / 0:+&O  / 0:+&O ; RXW 
*0:+&O  *0:+&O 
D )HHGOLQHVDWXUDWHGJDVDW <  7ZRRSHUDWLQJOLQHVLQWHUVHFWDWIHHGOLQH
! !
<,1  ! ; RXW !
! ! ! ! !
+$.<->!B%9!E,#!*!A.<.9C,#:<,%#!
!

! O!
/ * 0:+&O  !
!
<)  !
; LQW HU VHF W !
! / *0:+&O  !
 <RXW !
 P!


  )URPSORW ; 287  VHHILJXUH !
/
 7RSRSHUDWLQJOLQH  <RXW ; LQW HU VHF W  <)  
*0:+&O 
/
 %RWWRPRSHUDWLQJOLQH <) ; 287 ; LQW HU VHF W <),1 
*0:+&O 
 6ROYHIRU ; LQW HU VHF W *0:+&O  <) <287 /  7KHQ
/ *0:+&O 
<) ; 287 <) <287 <),1 
*0:+&O  /
/ * *0: *0:
; 287 <),1 <) <) <287 / 0,1
<),1 <) <) <287
*0: * ; 287 ; 287
0: 0:
/ 0,1     
 
     / 0,1  0:+&O    NJZDWHU K 

 6LQFH0:PLQ /PLQ NJK/ /PLQ NJK/0:+&O 
 



! !



 !

 E 0% ) <) *<,1 /  0:+&O ; ,1 *<RXW /  0:+&O ; RXW 

) <) *<,1 *<RXW
   ; RXW ; ,1 
/0:+&O 
     
  ; RXW   NJ+&O NJZDWHU 
  
  
/  0: 
  7RS  
* 
/  0: 
  %RWWRP  
* 
/0:+&O 
  7RSJRHVWKURXJK ; ,1  <RXW  6ORSH  
*
  $UELWUDU\SRLQWIRUSORWWLQJ ;   <    
       <   
  %RWWRPIURP  ; RXW  <,1  
  7RLQWHUVHFWLRQ7RS2SHUDWLQJDQG)HHG/LQH
  1HHGaVWDJHV2SW)HHGIRU ) LV6WDJH)HHGLVDWERWWRP
 
  &KHFN6ORSHERWWRP  .
 
!

! !



 !

Q,R"9.!B%9!(42IG2!



' 5HSHDW'ZLWK.UHPVHU
P9  
 \ P[  P  E     / 9  
/  
 \ P[  E  [  [ LQ   \ \ RXW  \ 1   

 
Q   
 
(T 1  
Q  

    *UDSKLFDOVROXWLRQZDV3UHWW\FORVH


'  8VH.UHPVHUHTXDWLRQVXFKDV
\ $ RXW \ $  / P9
     RXW
1 

\ $ LQ \ $  / P9
RXW

   
 1   P  / 9  \ $LQ  \ $ P[ $LQ     
RXW

      / P9    

  (TXDWLRQEHFRPHV \ $RXW     
  2YHUDOOPDVVEDODQFH \LQ 9 /[ LQ \ RXW 9 /[ RXW  
    
9 9 
 [ RXW \ RXW \ LQ [ LQ       
/ / 
      
'  $Q\RIWKHYDSRUIRUPVRI.UHPVHUHTXDWLRQFDQEHXVHGEXWSUREOHPLVWULDODQGHUURU
)RUH[DPSOHXVH(TLQYHUWHG IRU/ P 9  
/ 
 
\ \ P9 P 
  1 
EHFRPHV  
\ 1  \ / 
 
P9 P
  6HWXSWDEOHDQGWU\YDOXHVRIP
     
P      
5+6      

  %\ OLQHDU LQWHUSRODWLRQ P    1RWH WKDW P   LV D WUDS IRU WKH XQVXVSHFWLQJ
VWXGHQWVLQFH/P9 DQGVSHFLDOIRUPRI.UHPVHULVUHTXLUHG


' 1RWHWKLVUHTXLUHVLQIRUPDWLRQLQ6HFWLRQ



 / 
   /    NJVROYHQWK  
* $OOVWDJHV 
     
  
 ; LQ  ; RXW  <LQ  
   
     
(TXLOLEULXP\ [
[ ; \ <
   
   
   
   
    

  3ORWZHLJKWUDWLRV
/ /
  2S/LQH  <M ;M <;M  
* *
  6ORSH   /*     6WHS RII VWDJHV EDFNZDUGV VWDUW Z VWDJH 1 VLQFH LW LV
GLIIHUHQW WKDQ RWKHU VWDJHV DQG ZH ZRXOGQ¶W EH VXUH ZKHQ WR VZLWFK LI VWHSSLQJ RII
IRUZDUGV1HHGHTXLOLEULXPVWDJHV
  1RWH&DQDOVRSORW\YV;VLQFH\a<DQG*a9


 



'1HZ3UREOHPUG(GLWLRQ6WULS9LQ\OFKORULGHIURPZDWHUDWž&DQGPP+J
+ [
  \ [ [ 
S WRW  
  :DQWSSPZDWHUOHDYLQJ(QWHULQJDLULVSXUH /  NPROH KU 

[ [ ,1 !
 \ RXW \ !
 \ RXW !

 !

 \

!
 1!

((NK2M7N!
 \ ,1  \1  !

 [ RXW !
 \1 !
  [ ,1 [ !

 [1 [ RXW SSP !

   \ \ RXW  [ ,1  SSPPROH
/   NPRO
    * 0,1  
* PL[   K
 EDQGF:DQW *  * 0,1  NPRO K DLU
   / *  6HHILJXUHIRUSDUWE±ODEHOHG+:3UREEP 
 F (T [ 1 
   
1 Q 
    Q 
    
Q   

G  \ RXW /[ ,1 *\ ,1 /[ RXW *
  )RU /  NPRO K   *  NPRO K 
/
\ RXW [ ,1 [ RXW \ ,1    
)
SSP PROHIUDF 
  3UREDEO\VHQGZDVWHJDVWRLQFLQHUDWRU:LOOUHTXLUHDGGLWLRQDOIXHOWREXUQ
H $OOFRQFHQWUDWLRQVDUHGLOXWHHQRXJKWKDW / * DQGHTXLOLEULXPDUHVWUDLJKWDQGRSHUDWLRQLVYHU\
FORVHWRLVRWKHUPDO







 !



 
'D UHPRYDO&+UHPDLQV±&RQVWDQW9 <RXW    
&+ 

 E
&+  012!
\LQ  S &+  [ &+ 
\ &+  [ &+ 
! S 727 
/ 9 PLQ ! !\
&+  LQ 
\ &+  ! [  !
 

\ RXW  !
&+ 

[ LQ [ &+  !
! 
 
     6ORSH / 9 PLQ
 
 
      / 9 DFWXDO  / 9 PLQ  / 9  
9 9
 F ([WEDO   [ RXW \ LQ [ &+  LQ \ &+  RXW 
&+  / &+  /
9 
   [ &+  RXW
\ &+  LQ \ &+  RXW    
/ 
 G8VHPHWKDQHYDOXHVLQ.UHPVHUHTQWRILQG1
P9  
   P       \ P[  E  
/ 
    
 
Q   
 
 1 VWDJHV 
Q  
 H1RZXVH$UJRQYDOXHVZLWK1 WRILQG \ $URXW  [ $URXW 

  P $U  \ $U LQ \1 $U  [ $U LQ [ $U   

P9  
        \ P[  E 
/  $U


 \ $U     
  (T 
 
  


      \ $URXW \ $U     
9 
   [ $U RXW \ $U LQ \ $U RXW    
/ 



  
  $UJRQUHFRYHU\LQOLTXLG   
 

' 1HHGHTXLOLEULXPGDWD)URP'H3ULHVWHUFKDUW
    . & \ & [ &  P &  . & \ & [ &  P & 
/ P9
  %XWDQHLVDGHVLJQSUREOHP    
P9 &  / &
  RIWKHEXWDQHOHDYHVDVDJDV7KXV

     \&    \& P & [ & 
 
P9 \ 1  \ P9  
 Q  
/ \ \ /  
 1  
/ Q 
Q
P9
/ P9
 3URSDQHLVVLPXODWLRQ \ 1 &  \&    
P9 & / &
1 
/

\1  \ \1  P9 \1 
 
 \ 
\ \  \  / P9  

' :DV'LQQGHGLWLRQ
+ &2 DWP
 D (TXLO \ &2  [ &2   + &2   &  
3727 PROIUDF
     PP+J   DWP 
3727 
     [ &2  \ &2      
)HHG
+ &2  
+ &2  
  (TXLOLEULXPLQFROXPQ \ &2  [ &2  [ &2  [ &2  
3727 

  %DVLV/ NPROWRWDOK$VVXPH/ *FRQVWDQW,QSXW îNPRO&2K
UHPRYDO î îNPRO &2  K LQRXWOHWJDV

  &2UHPDLQVLQOLTXLG       NPRO &2  K 

 
    [ LQ [ RXW RXWOHWOLTXLGPROHIUDF    
 NPRO K
 
 E



 
\ PD[ RXW       !
6ORSH  !

=! / \ PD[ \ LQ   


!
9 PD[ [ LQ [ RXW   
6ORSH 
 / 9PD[
\LQ  !
[ RXW D! [ LQ    ! / 
!  
! 9 PD[

+,#-.!*!F!(/!  !
9PLQ 
   NPRO K
 
!

 F     9  9PLQ        NPRO K 
  &RQGLWLRQVIRU.UHPVHUHTDUHVDWLVILHG
  &20DVV%DO     LQ      RXWZZDWHU   \&2RXW 

 
 \ \ &2  RXW 
   
 
Q [1 [ 1 [ [ 
  (T 1 
/
Q
P9

\1 \  
      [ 1 
 [     
P P 

  
Q  
   
      1 

Q 
  

/ /
'    \     
P9 
  &DQXVHYDULHW\RIIRUPVRI.UHPVHUHTXDWLRQEXWFDQQRWHDVLO\XVHIRUPVZLWK \ 1  VLQFH
\ 1  P[ 1 DQG[ 1 LVXQNQRZQDQGKDUGWRFDOFXODWH 7U\(T
1 
/

\1  \   P9
    
 
\ \   /


P9
'RE\WULDODQGHUURU
/P9    
5+6    




  /LQHDUO\LQWHUSRODWH/P9 7KHQ/  NPROK

S  
'D \   [  . \ [  
S WRWDO  


/ [  ! \  [  \ 

! !
(! / / / 
\ [ \L [ !;@%J.!  !
97 9 97 
91   /! 9)  /  !
9) !
\ )  ! ([W0%/[  9) \ ) 91  \ 1  /[ 1 97 \ !

     

[1  !
)! 

[1 ! 91  !
\1   !

/ / / 
S%<2!%B!T%@"C#U! \ [ \1  [ 1   ! 6ORSH  !
9 9 91  





 

 F0LQLPXP/

[1 !
\1 
012!
=! !
\) ! / PLQ
/ PLQ  VORSH !
91 
\ !
/ PLQ / PLQ
VORSH !
97 
[ [!
!

  3LQFKLVDW \ )  [ ) \ )     
     / PLQ 97 6ORSH PLQ      
    / PLQ 97    NPRO K 




' 1HZ3UREOHPUG(GLWLRQ )RXQGPDQG/9LQ([DPSOH
   /P9 /9P  P9/ \  î 
  
 ,IXVH(T1 ^OQ>@`OQ>@ 

'DUHPRYDO +  2 OHIW    PROHVRXWLQ/

       
[ + 6RXW

  0ROHV + 6 RXWLQJDV  
 
      \ + 6RXW  
9 
+ + 6 
E (TXLO + 6\ + 6 [ + 6 [ + 6 [ + 6  P + 6  
S WRW 
+ &2 
     \ &2 [ &2  [ &2  [ &2   P &2   
S WRW 
  &DQXVH.UHPVHUHTIRU + 6 GHVLJQ>GLOXWHOLQHDUV\VWHP@)RUH[DPSOH(T

/ [ [ 1 /
Q 
P9 [1 [ 1 + 6
P9
     1 
P9
Q
/
/  P9
        
P9 + 6   / + 6


     [ 1 \1  P   [  + 6
  [ 1 + 6
 

Q   

     1  
Q 
F )RU &2   [ 1 XQNQRZQ [ 1 \1 &2 P&2  [   .UHPVHU
P9

[1 [
1
/ &2  P9  
1 
 ZLWK1 DQG 
[ [ 1 &2 P9 / &2  


/ &2 

  
P9

/  
[ 1 &2  [ 1 
 
&2  
 P9   

/
/LWWOHDPRXQWRI&2 



 
'1HZ3UREOHPUG(GLWLRQ$EV \ [ [ 


 6WULSSHU \ [ [ 

!

!
\ ,1  !  VORSHHTXLOLEULXP !
! V?;!
=!
6ORSH / 0,1 * !
[ (4    !
!
 
2SHUDWLQJOLQH6ORSH  !
! \ RXW  !  
/ 0,1    NPRO K
!
D! !
[ ,1  ! / DFW / DEV0,1  NPRO K
!
!
!


 / 9 $EV
 

/ DEV [ DEV,1 9 \ DEV,1 \ DEVRXW
 ([WHUQDO0% [ DEVRXW 
/ DEV
    
  [ DEVRXW 

   
  [ DEVRXW [ VWULS,1  
 P9
 .UHPVHU(T P  E   / P9    
 /
  \1  \ ,1  \ \ RXW  

  \ P[ ,1    
 (T
P9 \ 1  \ P9  
Q  Q  
/ \ \ /  
 1 
/ Q 
Q
P9
  
Q  
 1 DEV 
Q  

 



+<9,JJ.9!

! ((G2M7!F!+@%J.!01",@,?9,"C!

! \ (4    !

=!
!
/
F!+@%J.!WJ.9:<,#R!@,#.!
! 90,1
!
\ ,1  !
((G2M7![1 [ RXW 
[ ,1 [ RXWDEV  [
! !
((G2M7!
/  
   
9 0,1  
6WULS


  90,1 6WULS / 6WULS   NPRO K

  96WULS    NPRO K  
  
96WULS \ 6WULS ,1 / 6WULS [ 6WULS ,1 [ 6WULS RXW    
\ 6WULS RXW  
96WULS 
  \6WULS,1 \6WULSRXW  [ 1  \1   

.UHPVHU
/ [ [ 1 /
Q 
P9 [1 [ 1 P9 / 
  1   
Q P9 / P9  
 
Q  
 
 1  
Q 

'1HZ3UREOHPUG(GLWLRQ .   \ .[ [ 3ORW HJ DW[  \  
    /  9   / 9  
   ([WHUQDO0%

    /[ 1 9\ /[  9\ 1  
9
    [1 \1  \     
/
    3RLQWV [   \
   DQG [ 1  \ 1    DUHRQRSOLQH
   3ORW2S/LQH6HHJUDSKODEHOHG'EVWDJHVPRUHWKDQVXIILFLHQW








! ! !
' $SSDUDWXVVLPLODUWR)LJXUHH[FHSWSDUWRIWUHDWHGJDVLVKHDWHGDQGXVHGDVVWULSSLQJJDV

  $EVRUEHU:RUNLQWHUPVRIPROHUDWLRV
   <L Q    <RXW    ; LQ    
  *    PROFDUULHUJDVGD\ /    PROVROYHQWGD\
  (TXLOLEULXP \ [ &RQYHUWWRPROHUDWLRV
[ ; \ <
   
   
   
   
    

  3ORWUDWLRVRQ0F&DEH7KLHOHGLDJUDP
/ / /
  $EVRUEHU 2S/LQH < ; <RXW  
; LQ 
* * *
  ([WHUQDOEDODQFH$EVRUEHU       ; RXW 
      ; RXW $EV  
  6WHSRIIVWDJHVDVVKRZQLQILJXUH1HHGHTXLOLEULXPVWDJHV

  6WULSSHU <LQ  VDPHDV<RXWDEV  ;LQ  VDPHDV;RXWDEV 
   ; RXW  VDPHDV; LQDEV  / PRO VROYHQW GD\KDYHVWDJHV 
  6WULSSHUHTXLOLEULXP\ [&RQYHUWWRPROHUDWLRV

[ ; \ <
   
   
   
   
   
    

  3UREOHP LV WULDODQGHUURU6HOHFW <RXW  'UDZ RSHUDWLQJ OLQH IURP <RXW  ; LQ WR  <LQ  ; RXW 
6HHLIQHHGVWDJHV:KHQQHHGH[DFWO\VWDJHV/* VORSH

)URP)LJXUHILQDOUHVXOWVKRZQ * VWULS / VORSH    PROFDUULHUJDVGD\
       <RXW VWULS a  PROUDWLR




 






!



!


(  &RQYHUWSSPZWWRPROHIUDFWLRQ SSP   ZWIUDF 
  %DVLVJRIVWHDP)HHG/LTXLGSSP ZWIUDF
PROHIUDF
     OJ1LWUREHQ]HQH JPROH  

     JZDWHU     

         7RWDOPRO 
J
         $YJPROZW  

  /LTXLG:DWHU )  J K   PRO K 
    / ) &ZKHUH& 6 9RXW   JZDWHU  & PRO 
        /    PRO K 
  2XWOHW%DVLVJ
   SSP    ZWIUDF  PROHV 0ROIUDF
         JQLWUREHQ]HQH        

  
       JZDWHU  a
PRO
  9 6    PRO K 
     (TXLO \ P[ E E  P + S WRW  
    .UHPVHU(T±6HYHUDOIRUPVFDQEHXVHGĺ8VH(T
/  P9 \1  E
      [ 1 
P9   / P
/ [ [ 1 /
Q 
P9 [1 [ 1 P9
    1  
P9
Q
/
1 (T 
    (IILF  
1 DFW 
  5HI+ZDQJHWDO,(&5HVHDUFK 

+ 
) + 3HUU\¶VWKHGS \ [ [ 
3727 
  7R EH DEVROXWHO\ FRUUHFW VKRXOG FRQYHUW WKLV WR PROH UDWLRV DOWKRXJK DW WKHVH ORZ
FRQFHQWUDWLRQVFRXOGXVHPROHIUDFWLRQVZLWKVPDOOHUURU
\ [
     <  ;
 \  [




 [ \ ; <
   
   
   
   
 &KDQJHVSHFLILHGFRQGLWLRQVWRPROHUDWLRV
[ LQ  ; LQ  \LQ  <LQ  \ RXW  <RXW  [ RXW  ; RXW 
  6HH)LJXUHIRUSORWRIRSHUDWLQJOLQHHTXLOLEULXPDQGVWDJHV1 
+HLJKW  IW
     +(73  
1  HTXLOVWDJH
/ <LQ <RXW  
      
* ; RXW ; LQ  
  ,IXVHPROHIUDFWLRQVILQG/9 


)     . (  . S  .  
  $IWHURQHSDVVRIPDVVEDODQFHREWDLQ



 HWKDQH SHQWDQH RFWDQH
[L   
[L   
[L   
\L   
\L   
\L   


  )RUQHZWHPSHUDWXUHXVHGPXOWLYDULDQW1HZWRQLDQFRQYHUJHQFH
      71HZ  ) 71HZ  ) 71HZ  )


* D1  /  \ $RXW  
 E 1  /  \ $RXW ZKLOHZLWK/  \ $  
 F 1  /  \ $RXW ZKLOHZLWK/  \ $  
 G+DYHDSLQFKSRLQW

* 8VHG3HQJ5RELQVRQ
 D7RWDOQXPEHURIVWDJHVUHTXLUHG   
 E)HHGVWDJHORFDWLRQIRUWKHVROYHQW   
 F)HHGVWDJHORFDWLRQIRUVWUHDP$   
 G)HHGVWDJHORFDWLRQIRUVWUHDP%   
 H2XWOHWPROHIUDFWLRQVRIJDVVWUHDPOHDYLQJDEVRUEHU 
             
 I2XWOHWPROHIUDFWLRQVRIOLTXLGOHDYLQJDEVRUEHU
            
 J2XWOHWJDVIORZUDWH   NPROK
 K2XWOHWOLTXLGIORZUDWH  NPROK
 L+LJKHVWWHPSHUDWXUHLQFROXPQ   Û&DQGVWDJHLWRFFXUVRQ 

*1HZ3UREOHPUG(GLWLRQ8VHG157/
&ROXPQSUHVVXUH DWP)HHGJDVIORZUDWH NPROK)HHGJDVWHPSHUDWXUH R&
/LTXLGIHHGWHPSHUDWXUH R&5HFRYHU\RILVRSURS\ODOFRKRO 
7 .7 .7 .7 .7 .
/HDYLQJJDV* NPROK0ROHIUDFWLRQV,3$ : 1 
/HDYLQJOLTXLG/ NPROK0ROHIUDFWLRQV,3$ : 1 
&ROXPQGLDPHWHU P

!



 63(UG(GLWLRQ6ROXWLRQ0DQXDO&KDSWHU

1HZ3UREOHPVDQGQHZVROXWLRQVDUHOLVWHGDVQHZLPPHGLDWHO\DIWHUWKHVROXWLRQQXPEHU7KHVHQHZ
SUREOHPVDUH$$'''''''''
((**&KDSWHUVDQGIURPWKHQGHGLWLRQZHUHUHDUUDQJHGWRSODFHDOOWKH
H[WUDFWLRQPDWHULDOLQWRFKDSWHUDQGWKHPDWHULDOIRURWKHUVHSDUDWLRQVLQ&KDSWHU7KXVWKH
QXPEHUVRIPDQ\SUREOHPVKDYHFKDQJHG

$  7KHDPRXQWRIVROYHQWVKRXOGEHLQFUHDVHG7KLVZLOOGHFUHDVH)6DQGPRYHWKHPL[LQJ
SRLQW0WRZDUGV6 $VDUHVXOWWKHVDWXUDWHG H[WUDFWSURGXFW ( 1  ZLOOEH PRYHG GRZQ
OHVVVROXWH7KHGLIIHUHQFHSRLQW¨ZLOOEHPRYHGWRZDUGVWKHWULDQJXODUGLDJUDP7KH
FRPELQHG HIIHFW ZLOO EH WKDW IHZHU VWDJHV DUH UHTXLUHG  %\ DGMXVWLQJ )6 D FRQGLWLRQ
UHTXLULQJH[DFWO\WZRVWDJHVFDQEHIRXQG

$  7KHYHUWLFDOD[LVZLOOEHWKHH[WUDFWSKDVHDQGWKHK\SRWHQXVHZLOOEHWKHUDIILQDWHSKDVH
7KHVHZLOOEHFRQQHFWHGE\WLHOLQHV8VXDOSURFHGXUHFDQEHXVHG

$  6LWXDWLRQ ZKHUH (  5 DQG ¨ SRLQW LV DW LQILQLW\  $OO RSHUDWLQJ OLQHV DUH SDUDOOHO
+RZHYHUWKLVGRHVQRWFRUUHVSRQGWRPLQLPXPQXPEHURIVWDJHVLQH[WUDFWLRQ

$F

$ D &ZLOOEHVSUHDGRXWDQGJRLQWRERWKUDIILQDWHDQGH[WUDFWVWUHDPV
 E &ZLOOFRQFHQWUDWHDURXQGWKHIHHGHGJH,I&LVYHU\GLOXWHLQWKHIHHGFDQFRQFHQWUDWH&
7KHQ E\ VWRSSLQJ WKH IHHG EXW FRQWLQXLQJ WR IORZ VROYHQWV VROXWHV $ DQG % FDQ EH
UHPRYHG6ROXWH&FDQQRZEHFROOHFWHGE\ZLWKGUDZLQJDVWUHDPQHDUWKHIHHGVWDJH

%  6SHFLI\ 7S] $  ] %  ) [ $R [ % \ $ 1  \ %1  SOXV
\ %  5(1 )
[ % 1  5(1 )
[ $ 1  5(1 )
      5(\ % [ $ 1 
11 ) \ $ (
11 ) [ % 1 5
11 ) [ $ 1 5HWF
  &RXOGDOVRQRWEHJLYHQRQHRIVWDQGDUGYDULDEOHVVXFKDVVROYHQWFRQFHQWUDWLRQ

% D 2QH FDQ EXLOG VWDJHV ZKLFK DUH FURVVIORZ HJ VHH )LJXUH  ZLWKLQ D FRXQWHU
FXUUHQWFDVFDGH7KLVHIIHFWLYHO\LQFUHDVHVVWDJHHIILFLHQF\1RWWKDWXSZDUGIORZLQJOHVVGHQVH
OLTXLGZLOOEHPL[HG
 E %XLOG FKDPEHUHG VWDJHV ZLWKLQ D FRXQWHUFXUUHQW FDVFDGH WR SUHYHQW PL[LQJ RI WKH
GHQVHOLTXLGDQGJLYHEHWWHUFURVVIORZRQHDFKVWDJH
 F 3XWLQEDIIOHVWRSUHYHQW0,;,1* RIERWKOHVVDQG PRUH GHQVHOLTXLGV7KLV ZLOOEH
PRUH HIIHFWLYH LI FRXQWHUFXUUHQW LV DUUDQJHG VR WKDW IORZ DFURVV VWDJHV LV DOZD\V LQ VDPH
GLUHFWLRQVHHVNHWFK



 !

"#$%$&$! 6WDUWE\GHILQLQJ¨DQGWKHFRRUGLQDWHVRI¨DV
  ( R 5   [ $ ( R \ $R 5[ $  [ ' ( R \ 'R 5[ ' 
QG UG
  5HPRYLQJ¨IURP DQG HTXDWLRQVZHREWDLQ
      [$ ( R \ $R 5  [ $ (R 5   D

      [' ( R \ 'R 5  [ ' (R 5   E

 $VVXPHWKDW ( R 5  1H[WZULWHWKHWKUHHLQGHSHQGHQWPDVVEDODQFHVDURXQGVWDJHVWRM
  5M  ( M  [ $ 5 M [ $ M  ( M \ $M  [ ' 5 M [ ' M  ( M \ 'M 
  7KHVH HTXDWLRQV DUH QRZ LQ D IRUP VLPLODU WR WKH IRUP RI WKH PL[LQJ HTXDWLRQV GHYHORSHG
SUHYLRXVO\7RGHYHORSWKHWKUHHSRLQWIRUPRIDVWUDLJKWOLQHXVHWKHILUVWHTXDWLRQWRUHPRYH¨
IURPWKH RWKHUWZRHTXDWLRQVVROYHIRU 5 M  ( M LQ HDFK RIWKHVH HTXDWLRQVDQGILQDOO\VHWWKH
UHVXOWVHTXDOWRHDFKRWKHU7KHGHYHORSPHQWSURFHHGVDVIROORZV

  8VH (M 5 M  WRUHPRYH¨IURPWKHRWKHUPDVVEDODQFHV
  (M 5M  [$ 5 M [ $ M  ( M \ $ M  ( M 5M  [' 5 M [ 'M  ( M \ 'M 
5M 
\$M [$ 5M 
\'M ['
  6ROYHIRU 5 M  ( M   
(M [$M  [$ (M ['M  ['
  )LQDOO\VHWWKHVHHTXDWLRQVHTXDOWRHDFKRWKHU
\$ M [ $ \'M [ ' \$ M [ $ \$M  [$
   UHDUUDQJHWR 
[$M  [$ ['M  [' ['M [' [ 'M  ['

  7KLV ODVW HTXDWLRQ VD\V WKDW WKH VORSH RI WKH OLQH EHWZHHQ WKH SRLQWV \ ' M  \ $ M DQG

['  [$ LVHTXDOWRWKHVORSHRIWKHOLQHEHWZHHQWKHSRLQWV [ ' M   [ $ M  DQG [ '  [ $ DQG

WKXVWKHOLQHVDUHFROLQHDU)XUWKHUPRUHWKHOHYHUDUPUXOHLVYDOLGIRUWKLVV\VWHP

' D ,IZHKDYHDVLQJOHFROXPQZLWKRQO\SXUHVROYHQWWKHQ



 5 5
      \ [ [ 1 \ 1  DQGSRLQW [ 1  \ 1    
( (
  LVRQRSOLQH (  5  6ORSH 5 (  
  2SOLQHLQWHUVHFWHTXLOLEULXPDW [  7KXVFDQQRWJHWWR [ R  
E 1RZ (    DQG 5 (  
   
6WLOOZDQW [ 1  EXW \ 1   

$W [   HTXLOLEULXP YDOXH RI \ [    $OWHUQDWLYH ZRUNV EXW
KDYHSLQFKSRLQWDQGQHHGYHU\ODUJHQXPEHURIVWDJHV

 F 7KLVDOWHUQDWLYH6D\XVHNJPLQRIEXWDQRO
   
      \1   ZKLFKLVEHORZHTXLOLEULXPSRLQW

  1RZ   5 (    P HTXLO    7KXV WKLV ZLOO ZRUN  2EWDLQ
     
\  

  2SOLQHFORVHUWRHTXLOLEULXP±UHTXLUHORWPRUHVWDJHV
 
  ,IXVHNJPLQRIEXWDQRO \ 1   

   
  5 (     \  

  :LOODOVRZRUN%HFRPLQJFORVHWRSLQFKDWWRS HTXLO\  
 
  ,INJPLQ \ 1    5 (    P HT 

   
      \  \  

  :RQ¶WZRUN
  7KXVWKHUHLVDVPDOOUDQJHZKHUHRSWLRQFZLOOZRUNEXWZLWKPDQ\VWDJHV

'  5  (  [ ,1 [ )  \ ,1  P  E  1 
5 
  .UHPVHUHTXDWLRQ   \ P[  E [ )  \ 1 
P(  
5

\ \  P(
   (T 1 

\1  \ 5

P(

   \ [ ) [ ) 
[ ) ĺ \ [ ) 
 



 [ ) [ )
  0DVVEDODQFH 5[ ) 5[ 1 (\  [ 1 [ ) 

  5HFRYHU\  [ 1 [ )  ZKLFKLVKLJKHUWKDQREWDLQHGLQFURVVIORZ

'1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ
 )URP0% 5  (  5  (\ RXW

:KHUH5 DQGWKHXQNQRZQVDUH(DQG\RXW

DQG(TXLOLEULXP \ RXW [ RXW   


5    
 6 (  NJ K
\ RXW   


$OWHUQDWLYH6ROXWLRQ(TXLOLEULXP6WDJH
! !
! \ [ !
!
!
!  !
!
! \! \ 
RXW
! ! IURP JUDSK
! 5
! 5  
! (  !
(  
!
! 5
( 
! 
!  !
! [!  !
! [ RXW  !
!
 $QRWKHUDOWHUQDWLYHVROXWLRQ  



  ( \ ! '+$!,-./0!
5 [  ! ;F$!
*! [ [ !
5 5
\ [ \ [ !
( (
'(! "! \ !
12-.34! [  \    [   \ !
5 ( 6ORSH !
 '.!'+$!,-./!
5 [
( \  !
! 563! [ DQG\ !6.7.28.!
)!
8</(/! \  \LQ ! \ \,1 ! [ ! 9!:!;!-.!3<-4!=2.>-?6(@3-2.!


     ,I(TOLQHLVVWUDLJKWFDQ8VH.UHPVHUZLWK1  AB2+/! 7.28.C!D!E!"!
   %RWKUHSUHVHQWDWLRQVDUHFRUUHFW7UHDWLQJVLPLODUWRDIODVKLVHDVLHU


'  6LQFHFRQFHQWUDWLRQVDUHORZXVHZWIUDFWLRQVDQGWRWDOIORZUDWHV
  (TXLOLEULXP \  [RU P  
5 OE K (  OE K [   [ 1  \ 1  
  
P( 5 DQG 5 P( 
      \ P[ ,1 E     
P( \ 1  \ P(
Q 
5 \ \ 5
  .UHPVHU(TE 1 
5
Q
P(
5 5  
  \ \1  [ [1     
( (  

Q  

      1 
Q 


'1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ

 3DUWD &DQGRZLWK.UHPVHUHTRUJUDSKLFDOO\
     \ P[ E P  E  
5 
     5  (    
P(  
P( 
     [  [ 1  \ 1    
5 



 5
   6LQFH  FDQXVHHTXDWLRQVXFKDVE
P(
     \ P[  E    
P( \ 1  \ P(
Q 
5 \ \ 5
     1 
5
Q
P(
 
Q   
 
     1 
Q
5 
   ZKHUH \ \1  [ [1     
( 

     1  

   $OWHUQDWHVROXWLRQ(TEHFRPHV
5 [ [ 1 5
   / 5  9 (  1 Q  Q P( 5 
P( [1 [ 1 P(
\1 E  
   [ 1 
  1  
P  
  E 

\  [     !

;F6-B$!
*!
AB2+/!E!G$HIH! 5 \ \1   
 !
( PLQ [ [1  
\1  5 ( PLQ
VORSH

! 
! ( 0,1 5   NJ K
[1  [  ! 
! !


' 1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ
3DUWD (\ 1  5[  (\ 5[ 1 ([W0% 
5 5
  \ [ \1  [1 
( (
 
  \     
 
3DUWE  .UHPVHU(T



 \1 
 &RQYHUW [ [ / 5\ \9 ([ 1 
 
P 
/ 5 
  
P9 P(  
 /RWVRIGLIIHUHQWIRUPVFDQEHXVHG
/ [ [ 1 /
Q 
P9 [ [ 1 P9
 )RUH[DPSOH 1 
Q P9 /
5 [ [ 1 5
Q 
P( [1 [ 1 P(
 %HFRPHV 1 
Q P( 5
 
Q  
  
 1   
 
Q

3DUWF  ;F$!!!! \ [ !

 \ (4 [ 
 !



 *!!!!!


5
 VORSH
 \ 1   ( 0,1
 ! \ [ ! !

 [ 1  )!!!!!
[   !
 !

5  
  
( 0,1  
5 
 ( 0,1  
 
 0D[LPXPH[WUDFWRXW \ (4 [   
3DUWG7KHUROHVRIH[WUDFWDQGGLOXHQWVDUHVZLWFKHGLQWKHWZRSUREOHPVZKLFKFKDQJHVWKHGHILQLWLRQV
RI\DQG[

'      1  5  \ 1   [   [ 1   
  (TXLOLEULXP  \ [ P  [ 1 \1    



  6LQFHUDWKHUGLOXWHDQGOLQHDUHTXLOLEULXPXVHRQHRIWKH.UHPVHUHTXDWLRQV
5 [R [ 1 5
Q 
P( [1 [ 1 0(
     1 PRGLILHG
P(
Q
5
[ [ 1
  :KHUH    6ROXWLRQLVWULDODQGHUURU
[1 [ 1



E R/mE Calculated N
500  5
Negative-Not possible Need 
P(
700  17.01 E too high
650  26.175 E too high
640  29.84 E too high
639 .945015 30.30 E too low

 %\OLQHDULQWHUSRODWLRQQHHG(aNJK&DQXVHRWKHUIRUPVRIWKH.UHPVHUHTXDWLRQ

' :DV'LQQGHGLWLRQ 
[LVUDIILQDWH 5 /
&RQYHUW.UHPVHU \ P[ P . E 
\ H[WUDFW 9 (
8VH   [1 [ 1  P9 /  .( 5
 D 1  

2WKHU IRUPV2. [  [ 1 P9 .(
 
/ 5
      [ 1 \Q  . 

.(  
 
   [1 [ 5    
 
.(  
 
5 
E &DQXVH([WHUQDOEDODQFHRU.UHPVHUWRILQG \ RXW \ 
     (\ (\ 1  5 [ [1 
5 
     \ [ [1    
( 

'  $VVXPHYHU\GLOXWH5 NJK( NJK
  (TXLO < . G ;EHFRPHV\ . G [ 
  )URP7DEOH . GROHLF P ROHLF  . GOLQROHLF PGOLQROHLF  
  UHFRYHU\ROHLF    \ROHLF  ĺ \ ROHLF  



 P ROHLF (  
  8VH.UHPVHU(TE  
5 
      \ P ROHLF [ ROHLF    
P( \ 1  \ P(
Q 
5 \ \ 5
      1  
5
Q
P(
5 
  )RUOLQROHLFDFLG  
P OLQ (  
  \1    1 \ P / [ /    
5

\ \ P(
  &DQXVH(TD 1 

\1  \ 5

P(

    \    ĺ \OLQROHLF  

  5HFRYHU\RIOLQROHLF 5H F     ĺ5HF 
'1HZSUREOHPLQWKHGLWLRQ        
 
J.@B*3-=@B!2(!?(@+<-=@B!42B63-2.!'K$!
A3@?/!"!! )[ ) ( L \LQ (\RXW 5  [ !

! ;F6-B-L(-6M! \RXW [ !

! ! ! )[ ) ( 5 [ !

)[ )  

! ! ! [  !
( 5   

! A3@?/!I!! 5  [ ( \ LQ (  \ RXW 5  [ RXW  5 5 )  !

! ! ! \ RXW [ RXW !

! ! ! !
5  [  
! [ RXW  5  5 )  !
(  5 

! N-)!8-3<!O//P!I! 5 LQ    ! !



 [ RXW 5  [ ) )    
! ! ! [ LQ !
5 LQ 

! ! ! [ LQ  !

! A3@?/!#!! 5  [ LQ ( \LQ (  \RXW 5  [ RXW !

! ! ! \RXW [ RXW !

5  [ LQ  

! ! ! [ RXW  !
(  5   

! A3@?/!Q!! 5  [ RXW ( \ LQ (  \ RXW 5  [ RXW 5  5  ! !

! ! \ RXW [ RXW !

5  [ RXW  

! ! ! [ RXW 
(  5   !

! ! ! \ RXW [ RXW  !

! !



 !





'  5 5 )  ( (  
  (TXLOLEULXP . '  )RUGLOXWHWKLVEHFRPHV P . ' LQZWIUDFXQLWV
  $ELHWLF$FLG5HFRYHU\ [1 5  )[ )     
  )[ )   
  [1   \  
5  ( 
5 5
  7RSRS(T  \ [ \ [ 
( (
5 
  *RHVWKURXJKSW [   \ 6ORSH  
( 
5 5
  %RWWRP2S(T \ [ \1  [ 1 WKURXJKSRLQW [ 1  \ 1   5 (  
( (
  1HHGòVWDJHVVHH)LJXUH


'   P   5 P(   \ 1  \   \  P[LQ 

\   
  (TD  
 
   
      \     
5[ LQ (\ LQ (\ RXW    
  2YHUDOOEDO  [  
5 

' D  [\ UHFRYHU\OHIW     NJRXW
         [ RXW  



  2 [\UHFRYHU\OHIW      [ 2RXW  
  



)RURUWKR \ PD[    
5  
       
( PD[RUWKR  
  )RUSDUD   \ PD[    
5  
       
( PD[SDUD  

 E 7KHS[\OHQHUHFRYHU\FRQWUROV ( PLQ   

5
   (      
(
  &DQXVH.UHPVHUHTEIRUȡ[\WRILQG1
P( \ 1  \ P(
Q 
5 \ \ 5
      1 
5
Q
P(
  P   5 (  \ 1    \ P[ RS   
  0DVVEDODQFHHQWHULQJȡ[\OHDYHVZVROYHQW
  
      \   ZWIUDF

5  5 P( 
     Q    
P(  P( 5 



  
Q  
  Q 
    1  
 
  1RWH&DQXVHRWKHUIRUPVRI.UHPVHUHTLIGHVLUHG
 F )RUR[\FKHFNLIUHFRYHU\!
5
 \ XQNQRZQ \ 1  
\ \ P(
  (TD   
\ 1  \ 5
1 
\ P[    

P(
5 
     1  
P( 
5

P(  
\ \1  \ 1 
\  
  
5  

P(
  ([WHUQDO0% (\ 5[ 1 (\ 1  5[  
5[  (\   
      [1 (  
5 
(\
      5HFRYHU\   
5[ 
6   0)
'ZDV'LQQGHG D 
)   60

  2QFH KDYH 0 XVH WULDODQGHUURU WR ILQG WLH WKURXJK 0  ILQDO UHVXOW LV VKRZQ  7KLV
JLYHV(DQG5  \ $  \Z  [$  [Z 
E 3ORWUDIILQDWH 5 [ $  )LQGWLHOLQHWKURXJKWKLVSRLQWQRWWULDODQGHUURU7KLVJLYHV
('UDZ/LQH(5,QWHUVHFWLRQZLWKOLQH6)JLYHV0
6 6 0)
     )LQG6  NJK
)  60



 
'  6LQFHGLOXWHXVH.UHPVHUHTXDWLRQV$VVXPHXQLWVDUHZHLJKWIUDFWLRQV
 D &ROXPQDWž& [ 1  1  [   (  5  
  (TXLOLEULXP P  WKXV\ P[   .UHPVHU(TD


\  
    
 
\ 1   


  7KLVVLPSOLILHVWR\ \ 1   
  ([WHUQDO0% \ 1 ( 5[ R \( 5[ 1  \ 1    \  

  ZKLFKVLPSOLILHVWR \ 1  \  


  6ROYHHTVDQGXQNQRZQV \FROO  \ 1FROO   
 E &ROXPQDWž& \ 1 FRO \FRO  
  \FRO \1 FRO     [   1  P  (  \ P[  

  8VH.UHPVHUWRVROYHIRU57KLVLVWULDODQGHUURU)RUH[DPSOH8VLQJ(TD
5 5
 
\ \ P(  
      1  

\ 1  \ 5 5
 
P( 
5    
      
5+6    
 :LWKLQHUURU5 
\ 1 ( 5 [  \(   
      [1  
5 




 F &RXOGEHSUDFWLFDOLIP¶VZHUHODUJHUDQGKDYHELJJHUVKLIWLQP$VLPLODUVFKHPHLVXVHG
FRPPHUFLDOO\ IRU FLWULF DFLG  1RW SUDFWLFDO KHUH VLQFH KDYH WR SXPS DURXQG WRR PXFK
VROYHQW,QDGGLWLRQEHQ]HQHLVFDUFLQRJHQLFDQGZRXOGSUREDEO\QRWEHXVHGDVVROYHQW

' D   5 (     5 P(    
    \ P[ $    8VH(TD
\   
   
 ĺ \  
   
( (
      [$ [ $ \1  \ ( 
5 5
E *UDSKLFDOFKHFNZRUNVILQHQRWVKRZQ

5 5 5 
'     \M [M \ ,1 [ M   
(M ( (M 
     [  6HHJUDSK
  1RWH [ [ 1FRXQWHUFXUUHQW  HYHQWKRXJKXVHPRUHWRWDOVROYHQW




 
  

'ZDV'LQQGHG 3ORW6)5DQG('UDZOLQHV6)DQG5(,QWHUVHFWLRQLVSRLQW0


6 0) 
 /HYHUDUPUXOH  ĺ 6    NJK
) 60 

 2U0DVV%DO65 0DQG 6\ $ )[ $ 0[ $  6  ) 0 

  6ROYHVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ 6 




  'LIIHUHQFHLVGXHWRDFFXUDF\LQUHDGLQJQXPEHUV/HYHU$UP5XOHPRUHDFFXUDWH



    

'  (TXLO   .G \$ [ $    

  $FHWRQH   \  <  [   ;  


      [1  ZWIUDF ; 1  

   )'    NJKZDWHU )6   NJKFKORURIRUP

      )' )6  

   (TXLO



 [$ ;$ \$ [$ <$
   
   
   

   

   

   

    

  
  ([WHUQDO0%
)' )'
    ;1  < ; <1 RU<1     
)6 )6
<1
              \ 1  
 <1
 
  5HVXOWVSUHWW\FORVHWR'  YV Z L DFFXUDF\RIJUDSKV
 

1RWH7KHJUDSKEHORZVKRXOGUHDGDFHWRQHQRWDFHWLFDFLGDVWKHVROXWH




 

' D %DWFK2SHUDWLRQ±0L[WRJHWKHU VHWWOH)LQGIUDFWLRQUHFRYHUHG

5 5
  2SHUDWLQJ(T \ [ [   5  6 [  [ ) 
6 6
  :KLFKLV \ [ [ ) 
  (TXLOLEULXP  \ [P  
5Ö 6Ö [  \ L1  [ ) 
  (TZULWWHQIRUEDWFK [ [ ) 
P 5Ö 6Ö 
    )UDF5HF    
E &RQWLQXRXVVROYHQWDGGLWLRQ
6Ö   [ W ILQDO
(T  Q [ W ILQDO [ W IHHG  Q 
5Ö W P  [)
   [ WILQDO [ )
 H[S    
5HFRYHU\ 
!



 ':DV'LQQGHG D /HW$ PHWK\OF\FORKH[DQHDQG' QKHSWDQH
  0DVV%DODQFHV ) ) 6 0RU0  
    ) [ $) ) [ $) 6\ $6 0[ $0  ) [ ') ) [ ') 6\ '6 0[ '0 
   


) [ $ ) ) [ $ ) 6\ $6     
  7KHQ  [ $0  
 
0 
) [ ' ) ) [ ' ) 6\ '6     
     [ '0  
 
0 

  3ORW0)LQGWLHOLQHWKURXJK06HHILJXUH7KLVJLYHVORFDWLRQRISRLQWV(DQG5
  )LQG [ '5  [ $5  \ $(  \ '(  


 E 0DVVEDODQFHV 0 ( 5 DQG0[ $0 (\ $( 5[ $5 

  6ROYLQJVLPXOWDQHRXVO\( DQG5 NJK

' 1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ :LWKLQWHUIDFHDWFHQWHUKHDY\SKDVHIORZDUHDLV
 
$I ' V   DQG 3SHUI ' V '   
 

       U 'V   !


 %/.3/(!
 ɽ! $"!


 ! &
 

%<2(P!
!
$Q""S! U  !
       T.3/(>@=/!
   ɲ!  ș 

UB/.?3<!E!%V!            
         (!  $"!
 & P
@(=! ɲ!
 !

%RI! 

 'UDZULJKWWULDQJOHIRULQWHUIDFHEHORZFHQWHUWRFDOFXODWHQHZSHULPHWHU
 
   VLQ    
U  
 7KHQDQJOHRIDUF    
U   
 /HQJWKRI DUF 
  
   3HUI & DUFOHQJWK P

 0HQVXUDWLRQ IRUPXODVDUHIURP&5&6WDQGDUG0DWKHPDWLFDO7DEOH

  5H VHWWOHU 4 3HUI         
F F 

 ,QWHUIHUHQFHVRPHZKDWPRUHOLNHO\WKDQLQ([DPSOH


'ZDV'LQQGHG D ) 6   0 
  3\UGLQH  )[ $) 6\ $2    0[ $0 ĺ [ $0    
  3ORW0RQOLQH )6   %\7 (ILQGWLHOLQHWKURXJK08VH&RQMXJDWHOLQH
   \ S  [ S   \ Z  [ Z  
   0DVVEDODQFHV 5 ( 0   5 ( 0 
  6ROYHVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ ( a  5 a  1RWH0RUHDFFXUDWHWKDQS\UGLQHYDOXHV
 E     5  6    0 
      5[ $ 6 \ $    0  [ $0  

      [ S\U 0   


  )LQGWLHOLQHE\7 ( \ S\U  [ S\U   \ Z   [ Z   

  0% 5 [Z ( \Z  0[ PZ ĺ 5  (    

      5 ( 0  

  6ROYHVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ (   DQG 5   




  

'ZDV'LQQGHG D )HHG0&+QKHSWDQH) 6ROYHQWDQLOLQH
QKHSWDQH 6WRWDO   6 ) 0  
6 )0
  /HYHUDUPUXOH    )LQG0(DV\ZD\LVGLYLGHOLQH )6 LQWRSDUWV
) 06

  8VHWLHOLQHWKURXJK0WRILQGSRLQWV( 57 (

   ([WUDFW \ 0&+ a  5DIILQDWH[ 0&+ a  ZWIUDFV

( 05
  0DVVEDODQFH(5  0DQGOHYHUDUPUXOH  0HDVXUHGLVWDQFHVRQILJXUH
5 0(

  6ROYHVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ 5 NJK( ±5 

6  )0
E VWDJHFURVVIORZ6WDJH) ȡ  )LQGSRLQW07LHOLQHWKURXJK0
)  06
JLYHVSRLQWV5DQG(
5 ( 0 
  0DVVEDODQFH  ) 6 0 5 ( DQGOHYHUDUPUXOH 
( 0 5 
   )LQG 5   NJ K  (  

  1RWH,VRWKHUPVDUHYHU\VHQVLWLYH7KXVFDOFXODWLRQLVQRWH[WUHPHO\DFFXUDWH
6 0 5
6WDJH0DVVEDODQFH 5  6 0  5 (  DQGOHYHUDUP 
( 0 6 
  )LQG 0  DQGIURPWLHOLQHWKURXJK 0  ILQG5  7KHQFDQILQG5DQG(IURPPDVVEDODQFH
5 ( 0
JLYHQDERYHDQGQHZDSSOLFDWLRQRIOHYHUDUPUXOH 
( 5 0
   6ROYLQJVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ 5   NJ K(   




 


'ZDV'LQQGHGD 'UDZOLQHVIURP6WR)DQGIURP 5  WR( 1 ,QWHUVHFWLRQJLYHVSRLQW

0VHH)LJXUH7KHQIURPOHYHUDUP

6 )0
     ĺ 6    
) 60

E ¨LVDWLQWHUVHFWLRQRIOLQHV ( 1 5 1  DQG(  5 7KHQVWHSRIIVWDJHVDVVKRZQ1HHGVWDJHV





'ZDV'LQQGHG  *XHVVDYDOXHIRU0DQGVWHSRIIVWDJHV5HSHDWXQWLOQHHGVWDJHV
$IWHUWKUHHWULDOVIRXQG0VKRZQLQ)LJXUH7KLVUHTXLUHGVWDJHVZKLFKLVFORVHHQRXJK
  ([WUDFW&RPSRVLWLRQ$FHWLF$FLG :DWHU 
  5DIILQDWH&RPSRVLWLRQ$FHWLF$FLG :DWHU 
  6ROYHQW)ORZ5DWH ) 6 ) 60 6)    6  ĺ6 NJK
  5DIILQDWH)ORZ5DWH 5 (  ( 5 5   5   NJK
  ([WUDFW)ORZ5DWH (1 ) 6 5     


'ZDV'LQQGHG \ $( \ Z(  3XUHVROYHQW


( 0)
/HYHUDUPUXOH  )LQG0/LQH50LQWHUVHFWVVDW¶GH[WUDFWDW ( 1  \ $ 1  
) (0
  /LQHV )( 1  5(  LQWHUVHFWDW 6WHSRIIVWDJHV  PRUHWKDQHQRXJK1HHGaó
(1 05 
  0% ( 1 5 0  NJK OHYHUDUP  IURPJUDSK
5 (10
  6ROYHVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ 5  ( 1  NJK



 



'ZDV'LQQGHG 7RILQG¨3ORW ( 1 DQG5 1  )
      (M 5M  (1 51   
( 1 [ $1 5 1 [ $ 1 
      [$   

¨LVRQOLQHWKURXJKSRLQWV ( 1 DQG5 1  
  3ORW¨2UXVHOHYHUUXOH
5 1 ( 1
      51   
(1
 6WHSRIIWKUHHVWDJHVVWDUWLQJDWSRLQW ( 1 7KLVJLYHVSRLQWV
     5  [ $  [ '  DQG(  \ $  DQG\ '   

  0DVV%DODQFH (  51  5 ( 1 ĺ (  5 (1 51  5   
  DQG   (     5     
  6ROYLQJVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ 5   NJK (   NJK

'ZDV'LQQGHG D 3ORW3RLQWV ) 6 ( 1 DQG5  
  )LQG¨SRLQWDWLQWHUVHFWLRQRIOLQHV )( 1 DQG5 6 
  VWDJHVLVPRUHWKDQHQRXJKVHHJUDSK

 E 'UDZOLQHV )6DQG( 1 127FDOFYDOXH(  5 
   ,QWHUVHFWLRQLVPL[LQJSRLQW0
) GLVW6WR0
  0DVVEDODQFH )6 0DQG/HYHUDUP  
6 GLVW)WR0
  *LYH 6 )     NJK



  $OWHUQDWH2YHUDOO0% ) 6 0 DQG'LOXHQWPDVVEDODQFH
       )[ )' 6\6' 0[ 0' 0 
  6ROYHVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ 0 DQG6  NJK%XWWKLVLVOHVVDFFXUDWH



' 1HZ SUREOHP LQ UG HGLWLRQ      (TXDWLRQ  EHFRPHV 4F $L    XW   VDIHW\ IDFWRU
8VLQJWKHHTXDOVVLJQDQGVROYLQJIRUWKHVDIHW\IDFWRU6IZHKDYH
     6I XW$L4F ± 
   ZKHUH$L 'V/V7KXVVDIHW\IDFWRULVLQVWHDGRI7KLVPD\VWLOOEHDFFHSWDEOH

'1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ6ROQ$.UHPVHU6ROQ  5 P(   

    5  (  P  E  \   [   
   )RUH[DPSOH8VH \ P[  E  
5

\ \ P( \   
    1 
EHFRPHV 
 
\1  \  5    

P(
    \     

[ \ P  

 6ROQE 'RPDVVEDODQFHVDQGHTXLOLEULXPIRUVLQJOHVWDJH



    6\ ,1 )[ ) 6\ )[ 
      \ [ 
   DOVR\ [  6ROYHVLPXOWDQHRXVO\DQGREWDLQLGHQWLFDOUHVXOW
   6ROQF 'RJUDSKLFDOO\DVVLQJOHVWDJHV\VWHP
   6ROQG 'RJUDSKLFDOO\DVFRXQWHUFXUUHQWV\VWHP1 6ROXWLRQLVYDOLGEXWDZNZDUG

' 1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ)L[HG'LVSHUVHG3KDVH
4 WRO 4 VRO 4 IHHG 4 IHHG 4 VRO 4 IHHG
 $WIHHGFRQGLWLRQV WRO
4 WRO 4 IHHG 4 VRO  4 VRO 4 IHHG
4 IHHG 4 IHHG
4 IHHG
 
4 VRO 4 IHHG 
D WRO  
   4 VRO 

4 IHHG
(TXDWLRQRSHUDWLRQLQDPELYDOHQWUDQJH
 
 
   
/ / +
           
/ + /


 )URP([DPSOH  

 7KH   

 (LWKHUSKDVHFDQEHGLVSHUVHG

   E G  DOVRDPELYDOHQWUDQJH


    (LWKHUSKDVHGLVSHUVHG


   F G  $FFRUGLQJWRDWERUGHU


    ZDWHUSUREDEO\GLVSHUVHG
 

    G G  (TXDWLRQZDWHUKHDY\GLVSHUVHG


   ZDWHUGLVSHUVHG 

' 1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ W UHV 9OLT 4G 4F  PLQ V


4G 4F  P V  9OLT V  P V P 


 1RWHWKDWWKHUHLVDLQFKDLUJDSDWWRS
  9OLT + W  G WDQ N    + W G WDQ N 
  9OLT G WDQ N  G WDQ N   
 8VLQJ*RDO6HHN G WDQ N DQG+ WDQ N 





'1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ 1 USP USV
  G L G WDQ N   P
8VHZDWHUYDOXHVIRU 0 Z  NJ P DQG 0 Z    NJ P V 

G L 1 /
  
  5H / HVWLPDWH 
  
/  
 &XUYHELQ)LJXUHDJDLQSUHGLFWVDFRQVWDQW 1 S  

 7KHQIURP(TXDWLRQ 3 1 3 0 G L J F ZKHUH J F  DQG 1  
 
  3  0     0
 $
 0
ZLOOEHIDLUO\FORVHWR F :  VLQFH 4 : 47ROXHQH VHH(TXDWLRQ
7KH VHULHV RI PHVV\ WHUPV IRU (TXDWLRQ D FDQ EH FDOFXODWHG  6LQFH WKH WDQN GLPHQVLRQV DQG
SK\VLFDOSURSHUWLHVDUHWKHVDPHDVLQ([DPSOHWKHRQO\WHUPRQWKH5+6RI(TXDWLRQDWKDW
LVGLIIHUHQWLV37KXVWKHUHVXOWLQWKHVDPHDV(TXDWLRQ%LQ([DPSOH G 3   %

 ,QDGGLWLRQWR(TXDWLRQV$DQG%ZHQHHGWRVROYH(TXDWLRQ
   0 G G  G F  G   G  &
 6ROYLQJHTXDWLRQV$%DQG&ZLWK*RDO6HHN ZHREWDLQ G DQG G GIHHG  
 7KHQVROYLQJ(TXDWLRQ& 0 G G  G F      
 (TXDWLRQ% 3  G   3 :   
QG
'ZDV'LQ HGLWLRQ  )URP(T
( .  (. 
%   &  ' 5  [  
5 5
( M. M ( M . M 
  (T)RUM1 $ M  % M   & M  ' M )M] M 
5M 5M 

(1.1
  (T)RU6WDJH1 $ 1 % 1  ' 1 )1 ] 1 ( 1 \ 1  
51
([DPSOH 5   [ $  [ '  1   ( 1   \$1   \'1 
  )RU$FHWLF$FLG . $ M \ $M [ $ M 8VH)LJWRHVWLPDWH . $ M 
  
. $  . $   . $  
  
  
. $  . $   . $   
  
)RUILUVWJXHVVDVVXPHFRQVWDQW( DQG5 
     ( . $   
7KHQ %   
5 
( .  
&  
5 
' 5 ' [ $    



  DQGVRIRUWKZLWK ' '1    7KXVPDWUL[IRUDFHWLFDFLGLV

"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!I!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!#!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Q!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!S!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!X!

"! "$QQIS! WG$QHX&S! G! G! G! G!

 
I! W!"!   !  ! G! G! G!
 
  G! G!
#! G! W!"!   ! 
 
!
  G!
Q! G! G! W!"!   
 
! !
G!  
S! G! G! W!"!   
 
! !

X! G! G! G! G! W!"! !  !


'3DUWD1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ6HHILJXUH
)RUJ & $T  & $T 1  
 
 
)$T & RUJ  & RUJ 1   
0LQ

/
  )RUJ0LQ )$T   / K  
K
)RUJ 
 E  )RUJ      
)$T 
  2SHUDWLQJOLQHJRHVWKURXJK &$T1 DQG&RUJ1  ZLWKVORSH 
   &RUJ 

  6HH)LJXUH VWDJHVPRUHWKDQHQRXJK a  VWDJHVQHHGHG





 3DUWF 0:=U 12 
     
   0:ZDWHU     



 %DVLVOLWHUPRO =U 12 

  +DYH J=U 12 

  DQG J  JZDWHU 
  ZKLFKLV   PROZDWHU 

 0ROHIUDF =U 12    
 

 0DVVIUDF =U 12    
J
 6\VWHPLVGLOXWHLIFRQVLGHUPROHIUDFWLRQOHVVVRLIXVHPDVVIUDFWLRQV,IGHQVLWLHVDUHFRQVWDQW
WKHQFRQVWDQWIORZUDWHVLVYDOLG(YHQZLWKYDULDEOHGHQVLW\VROYLQJSUREOHPZLWKPROHIUDFWLRQVDQG
FRQVWDQWPRODUIORZUDWHVZRXOGEHDFFXUDWH7KLVZRXOGUHTXLUHFRQYHUWLQJHTXLOLEULXPGDWDWRPROH
IUDFWLRQV8VHRIIUDFWLRQVZLWKFRQFHQWUDWLRQVLQPRO/LV127FRUUHFW

'1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ

3DUWD+(73ODUJHVFDOH +(73SLORW'ODUJH'SLORW PPP P

  IODUJHVFDOH ISLORW'SLORW'ODUJH VPP V

3DUWE+(73ODUJHVFDOH +(73SLORW'ODUJH'SLORW +(73SLORW P

 IODUJHVFDOH ISLORW'SLORW'ODUJH ISLORW V

F8VHRIWKHPRUHFRQVHUYDWLYHGHVLJQGHYHORSHGIRUGLIILFXOWV\VWHPVQ  Q UHVXOWVLQD
PXFKKLJKHU+(73DQGWKXVDPXFKWDOOHUFROXPQDQGPRUHH[SHQVLYHFROXPQWKDQXVHRIWKHGHVLJQ
SURFHGXUHIRUHDV\V\VWHPVQ Q &RQVLGHUDEO\PRUHGDWDLVQHHGHGIRUDODUJHYDULHW\RI
V\VWHPVWRGHWHUPLQHEHVWGHVLJQSUDFWLFH,IDYDULDEOHVSHHGPRWRULVXVHGLQWKHODUJHVFDOHV\VWHPWKH
GLIIHUHQFHLQSUHGLFWHGRSWLPXPIUHTXHQF\LVQRWDVVHULRXVEHFDXVHWKHV\VWHPFDQWXQHGWRILQGWKH
RSWLPXPIUHTXHQF\

' 1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ
& H[WUDFW & WROXHQH
 0:ZDWHU   0:WROXHQH   P  
& UDIILQDWH & ZDWHU
 )  NPRO KU   6  NPRO KU  [ ,1   \ ,1 
 )[ ,1 )[ RXW 6\ RXW DQG \ RXW P [ RXW ĺ [ RXW )[ LQ  ) 6P 
 1RWH P P P LVHTXLOLEULXPLQPROHIUDFWLRQXQLWV$VVXPHH[WUDFWKDVSURSHUWLHV
WROXHQHDQGUDIILQDWHSURSHUWLHVRIZDWHU
NPROHEHQ]RLF  NJWROXHQH
P  H[WUDFW  NJWRO P  NPROWROXHQH
 P   
NPROHEHQ]RLF  NJ:
P  UDIILQDWH  NJ: P  NPRO:
NPROEHQ]RLF NPROH[WUDFW
 8QLWVRQ P DUH 
NPROEHQ]RLF NPROUDIILQDWH



  
 [ RXW   \ RXW   
  
 ,IXVH P  ILQG [ RXW       W 521*

' 1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ
 )HHGLV &&   $$)  NPRO K 6ROYHQWSXUH 6  NPRO K
 HTXLOVWDJH
6  )0 [ )&& [ 0 && 6
 /HYHUDUP $OWHUQDWLYHO\ 
 

)  60 [ 0 && 
[ 6&& 
)
 7KHQ [ 0&&    )LQG0L[LQJ3RLQW0
 >7KHILJXUHLVVKRZQDWWKHHQGRISUREOHP'DVWKHVLQJOHVWDJHPL[LQJOLQH@
 3KDVHVVSOLWDORQJWKHOLQH±7(WRILQGWKHOLQHWKURXJK0
 5DILQDWH [ &&   [ $$  ([WUDFW \&&   \ $$   
 2YHUDOO%DODQFH (5 )6 
 &&Ɛ%DODQFH (5 6IRU) 
 6ROYHVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ 5  (  5 
 127(6LQFH&&ƐPROHIUDFVFDQEHUHDGPRUHDFFXUDWHO\WKH&&ƐEDODQFHLV
SUREDEO\PRUHDFFXUDWHWKDQWKHDFHWLFDFLGEDODQFHHTXDWLRQV

 ! !
' 6 6
 
&&Ɛ

   5 5 5VLQJOHVWDJH 

0L[ZLWK6 SXUH
 ( (

    

 5 60  [ 0  DFHWLF [ 6DFHWLF [ 0  $$ 
 
 6 5 0  [ 5  DFHWLF [ 0  DFHWLF  [ 0  $$
 [ 0$$     
 )LQG0DQGE\WULDODQGHUURUILQGDWLHOLQHWKRXJK06HHILJXUHRQQH[WSDJH
 ([WUDFW \&&  \ $$  
 5DIILQDWH [ && 
[ $$  
 5 ( 5  6    
 &&  EDODQFH  5  (      
 6XEVWLWXWLRQ   5    5   
 5 DQG(   NPRO K 




 !



'1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ
5 1  )   [ && 1    [ $$1   
 ( 6   \ 7($   \ && 1  

0L[LQJ8VHOHYHUDUPUXOH
 6 )0 [1 && [ 0 &&
     

 ) 60 [ 0 && 
\ 6&& 

6
[1 && \ 6&&

) 
  
   [ 0 &&  

6)  

  )LQG0'UDZ ( 1 05  OLQH6HHILJXUHRQQH[WSDJH
 5DIILQDWH  [&& 
[$$  
 3DVVLQJ6WUHDPV ( 1 5 1  ( 2 5  LQWHUVHFWDW 
  9HU\FORVHWRSDUDOOHO8VHSDUDOOHOOLQHVWRVWHSRIIVWDJHV
 (VWLPDWH6WDJHV 
  )ORZUDWHV  ) 6 (  5  
  &&  EDODQFH)  6   (   5  
  
   (  NPRO K  5     
 
 &DQFRPSDUHWR*3DUWF
  ([WUDFW DQG5DIILQDWH  
 ([WUDFW0ROHIUDFWLRQ \ 7($ [ &&  \ $$  
 5DIILQDWH0ROHIUDFWLRQ [ 7($ [ && 
[ $$  
 7ZRUHVXOWVDUHUHDVRQDEO\FORVH



 





"#$YQI$!!@$!!O-(43C!+B23!+2-.34!;D!@.P!Z"!2.!3</!4@36(@3/P!/)3(@=3!@.P!4@36(@3/P!(@>>-.@3/!=6([/4C!
(/4+/=3-[/B*$!
^ĞĐŽŶĚ͕&ŝŶĚƉŽŝŶƚȴĂƚƚŚĞŝŶƚĞƌƐĞĐƚŝŽŶŽĨůŝŶĞƐ&DȴĂŶĚZ"^ȴ͘!
9<-(PC!43/+!2>>!/F6-B-L(-6M!43@?/4$!D//P!@L263!#$!A//!?(@+<$!
1@(3!L$!!;@4-/430!64/!3</!B/[/(W@(M!(6B/$!O-.P!M-)-.?!+2-.3!N!@3!3</!-.3/(4/=3-2.!2>!B-./4!OA!@.P!;DZ"$9</.!
6 )0
 ) NJ  K !
) 60
 &DQDOVRZULWHPDVVEDODQFHVRYHUDOOS\ULGLQHDQGZDWHUDQGVROYHIRUWKHXQNQRZQIORZ
UDWHV)(1DQG58QIRUWXQDWHO\WKLVZLOOQRWEHYHU\DFFXUDWHEHFDXVHLWLVGLIILFXOWWRUHDGWKHZDWHU
YDOXHVDFFXUDWHO\

'ZDV'LQQGHG 3ORWSRLQWVIRU )6 (   DQG5  RQVDWXUDWHGUDIILQDWHOLQH
 (0 ) 
  8VHOHYHUDUPUXOHWRILQGSRLQW0 
)0 6 
  /LQH 5 0 LQWHUVHFWVWKHVDWXUDWHGH[WUDFWFXUYHDW ( 1  [ DFHWRQH  
  /LQHV )( 1 DQG5 (  LQWHUVHFW DW ¨ D VHFRQG SLHFH RI SDSHU ZDV DWWDFKHG WR ILQG ¨
DFFXUDWHO\6WHSRIIVWDJHVLVPRUHWKDQVXIILFLHQW1HHGDERXW VWDJHV7KLV
LVFORVHWRWKHòHVWLPDWHGLQSUREOHP'ZLWKD0F&DEH7KLHOHDQDO\VLV




  


(     . 'P  . 'R  5  (  )  
( (
  6LQFH  . 'R  RUWKRJRHVXSFROXPQDQGVLQFH . ' 0  PHWDJRHVGRZQ
5 5
     \ P1  \R1   [ P [ R 
  (VWLPDWH ( 5 ) 
( )DQG5
5  5 
   ( DQG5   DQG  
(  ( 
  5HFRYHULHV    (\ RUWKR RU\ RUWKR  
      [ RUWKR1  
        5[ PHWD1 RU[ PHWD1  
  3ORWHTXLOLEULXPFXUYHVDQGRSHUDWLQJOLQHVVHH)LJXUH 
  )HHG FDQQRW EH UG VWDJH VLQFH FDQQRW JHW [ P 1 GHVLUHG  &DQQRW EH  DV ZLOO EH SDVW
LQWHUVHFWLRQRI 5 ( DQGPHWDRSOLQHV
  7KXVIHHGPXVWEHWKVWDJH'RQRWJHWPDWFKRIWRWDOQXPEHURIVWDJHV
  1HHGIRURUWKRDQGaIRUPHWD
  $YHU\VOLJKWDGMXVWPHQWRIUHFRYHU\PHWDZLOOFKDQJHWKLV0HWDLVDSSURDFKLQJDSLQFK
SRLQW DW IHHG VWDJH   UHFRYHU\ ZDV QRW HQRXJK  7KHUHIRUH QHHG a  UHFRYHU\
ZLWKaVWDJHV
!



(1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ3DUWD UHFRYHU\S[\OHIWLQGLOXHQW  
 
  [ 1S [\   ZWIUDF 
\ \1
3DUWE 3DUD[\OHQH .D  P (   5   [ 1 
  7KXV
[ P
(TFRQYHUWHGWRH[WUDFWLRQQRWDWLRQLVFRQYHQLHQW / 5 9 (

5 [ [ 1 5
Q 
P( [1 [ 1 P(
   1 
P(
Q
5
5 
   [  [ 1     
P(   

Q  
 
 1  
Q   
P(  
3DUWF RUWKR[\ P  [   [ 1   
5 
[1 [ 1  P( 5
 (T&RQYHUWHG 1 

[ [ 1 P(

5
 
   [1  (   
 
3DUWG $OWHUQDWLYH6ROXWLRQVDUHSUHVHQWHGEHORZIRUPHWD[\OHQH
 P[\ P  [   [ 1  1 (  5  E 
  
    P( 5 

 0XVWXVHVSHFLDOIRUP%XWWKH / P9  IRUP LQWHUPV RI[ LVQRWDYDLODEOH7KXVQHHGWR
GHULYHRUWUDQVODWHRUILQGLQDQRWKHUVRXUFH/RRNLQJDWGHYHORSPHQWRI(T
1 [ [  [ 1
  
[ [1
1
6ROYLQJIRU1 [

:KHUHǻ[LVGHWHUPLQHGLQVDPHZD\ǻ\ZDVGHWHUPLQHGIRU(T
/
\ [ E
9 \
[ [ M [ M  FRQVW [
 
/ 9 / 9 
/
\1 [1 E

9 \1 
$OWHUQDWLYHO\  [ [1 
/ 9 / 9



7UDQVODWLQJWRWKLVH[WUDFWLRQSUREOHP / 9 5 (  \ 1    [ [1 
[ [1 [ [1
   1
[ [1 
[ 
$QGVROYLQJIRU[1 [ 1 
1   

$OWHUQDWLYH 6ROXWLRQ  5HGHILQH WHUPV WR PDWFK (T  >5HODWLQJ \ WR VROYHQW DQG [ WR UDIILQDWH LV
DUELWUDU\6ZLWFKWKHVHGHILQLWLRQV@ 
 \ 1  PHWD [\OHQHLQKH[DQH  
    \ P[\RXWLVXQNQRZQ[  LVQRZLQOHWVROYHQW 
  /  
 P  E   / (      9  
.G  P9  
/
   \1  \ 1 \ [ E  \   
9 
 



 
6ROYHIRU\
\1  
   \  
 

   7KLVLVDFWXDOO\ [ 1 LQQRUPDOQRWDWLRQ


3DUWH6KRZQIRUQRUPDOQRWDWLRQ +)*!/F6-B!4B2+/!E!G$GHG!

  \ (4    !

 *!





 \1   !!
 [ S[\
)!
 [ 1 S[\ !
 
 
!  
 6ORSH2SHUDWLQJOLQH  
 
5 5 
  6ORSH   ( 0,1   NJ K
( 0,1   

(1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ3DUWD3ORWWKHHTXLOLEULXPGDWDDQGSRLQWV)DQG66WUDLJKWOLQH
IURPSRZHU)WRSRLQW6SDVVHVWKURXJKPL[LQJSRLQW06LQFHDPRXQWVRI)DQG6DUHHTXDO
0 LV DW WKH KDOIZD\ SRLQW RI WKH OLQH  )LQG WLH OLQH WKURXJK 0 E\ WULDODQGHUURU  7KLV LV
GLIILFXOWVLQFHWLHOLQHLVYHU\VHQVLWLYH

 $SSUR[LPDWHO\UDIILQDWH [ $5 [ '5  
   DQGH[WUDFW \ $( \ '(  

0DVV%DODQFHV ( 5 6 (  5  ( 
   (\ $( 5[ $6 6\ $V )[ $)     
6ROYHVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ ( NJ  5 NJ 

 3DUWE)LUVWDGGVROYHQWXQWLOUHDFKVDWXUDWHGUDIILQDWHFXUYHDWLQWHUVHFWLRQZLWK)6OLQH
  ,QLWLDO5DIILQDWH [ $5  [ '  
   5 ,1,7 [ $5 )[ $) 6,1,7 [ $6   6,1,7  
   5 LQLW  [ $5   NJ 
   6,1,7 5 ,1,7 ) NJ 
 6HFRQGXVH(TIRUWKHFRQWLQXRXVVROYHQWDGGLWLRQEDWFKH[WUDFWLRQ



 [ W ILQDO $
6 G[ W $
   
5 [ W IHHG $
\$
   [ WIHHG$ LVWKHUDIILQDWHDIWHUVROYHQWDGGLWLRQWRIRUPWZRSKDVHV
  [ WIHHG$ [ $LQLWLDOUDIILQDWH   [ W ILQDO$  
 )URPHTXLOLEULXPILQGYDOXHV \ $ H[WUDFW$SSUR[LPDWHYDOXHVDUH
[ $W  \$   \
  
  
  


G[ $  
        

\$ 
   6DGGHG 5 W  (T$ 
 ,QWKHGHULYDWLRQ 5 W LVDVVXPHGFRQVWDQW 5 W 5 W,1,7 NJ 
   6DGGHG NJ 
 :LWKWKLVDSSUR[LPDWLRQ ( 6DGGHG  NJ 
 6ROXWHPDVVEDODQFH
   5 W [ $,1,7 6DGGHG \ $DGGHG 5 W [ $ILQDO (\ $$YJ 
   \ $DGGHG  [ $,1,7  [ $ILQDO  
  
   \ $ $YJ  


 ,IZHGRQRWDVVXPH5LVFRQVWDQWWKHQ(TLV
  
6DGGHG [ W $
G 5 [ W $
   G6 DGGHG 
 [ W ,1,7,$/ UDI
\$
 :HZRXOGQHHGWRGRDQXPHULFDOLQWHJUDWLRQZLWKDFDOFXODWLRQRI 5 [ W$ YHUVXV \ $  WKLV
FDQEHGRQHEXWLVFKDOOHQJLQJ

*1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ
 ([WUDFW IORZ   [75$  [FDUERQWHW  [$FHWLFDFLG  
  5DIILQDWH IORZ  [ 7($  [ FDUERQWHW  [ $FHWLF$FLG  
  ([WUDFW IORZ  [ 7($  [ FDUERQWHW  [ $FHWLF$FLG  
  5DIILQDWH IORZ  [ 7($  [ FDUERQWHW [ $FHWLF$FLG  
  (QWHULQJFDUERQWHW    NPROHV KU 
  /HDYLQJLQ UDIILQDWH    
  ([WUDFWHG ,Q 2XWLQ5DIILQDWH  
  H[WUDFWHG 




*1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ
  3DUWDVWDJHFURVVIORZ$OOIORZUDWHVDUHNPROK
   7RWDO)ORZUDWH 7($IORZ &&OIORZ $FHWLFIORZ 
([WUDFW        
([WUDFW        
([WUDFW        
5DIILQDWH        
&DUERQ WHW UHPDLQLQJ LQ UDIILQDWH  LV  NPROK  6LQFH FDUERQ WHW IHHG ZDV  NPROK 
NPROKZDVH[WUDFWHG)UDFWLRQH[WUDFWHG  

3DUWEVWDJHFRXQWHUFXUUHQWZLWK6 NPROK
([WUDFW        
5DIILQDWH        

&DUERQ WHW UHPDLQLQJ LQ UDIILQDWH  LV  NPROK  6LQFH FDUERQ WHW IHHG ZDV  NPROK 
NPROKZDVH[WUDFWHG)UDFWLRQH[WUDFWHG  

3DUWFVWDJHFRXQWHUFXUUHQWZLWK6VHWWRJLYHVDPHIUDFWLRQH[WUDFWHGDVLQSDUWDDQGRXWOHW
UDIILQDWHFDUERQWHWIORZUDWHRINPROK7KLVLVWULDODQGHUURU
)LUVWWULDO6 DQG&&OUDIIORZUDWH 
6HFRQGWULDO6 DQG&&OUDIIORZUDWH 
7KLUGWULDO6 DQG&&OUDIIORZUDWH 
)RXUWKWULDO6 DQG&&OUDIIORZUDWH 
)LIWKWULDO6 DQG&&OUDIIORZUDWH 
7KLVLVFORVHHQRXJK
)LQDO5HVXOWV
([WUDFW         
5DIILQDWH         
!



 63(UG(GLWLRQ6ROXWLRQ0DQXDO&KDSWHU

1HZ3UREOHPVDQGQHZVROXWLRQVDUHOLVWHGDVQHZLPPHGLDWHO\DIWHUWKHVROXWLRQQXPEHU7KHVHQHZ
SUREOHPVDUH$$&'''''((&KDSWHUV
DQGIURPWKHQGHGLWLRQZHUHUHDUUDQJHGWRSODFHDOOWKHH[WUDFWLRQPDWHULDOLQWRFKDSWHUDQGWKH
PDWHULDOIRURWKHUVHSDUDWLRQVLQ&KDSWHU7KXVWKHQXPEHUVRIPDQ\SUREOHPVKDYHFKDQJHG


&1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ3DUWD \ \ [ [P  ) 8 6 2 5 8 ( 2
 ZKHUH )8625(DUHNJ
 (TEEHFRPHV
8 8
   \ [ [ ) \ ,1 
2 2
8
 DQG [ [ ,1 \ ,1  8 2 DQG\ [
2
 3DUWE (TEEHFRPHV
2 
    Q [ W ILQDO [ W IHHG 
8 .
 :KHUH . \ [ DWHTXLOLEULXP LQZDVKLQJ


8 [ [ 1 8
Q 
P2 [1 [ 1 P2
'ZDV'LQQGHG D 7UDQVODWHHT 1 
Q P2 8
  1RWH[LQZWIUDFWUDQVODWHVWR[LQ NJ P  LIGHQVLWLHVDUHFRQVWDQW'HQVLWLHVFDQFHO)RU
ZDVKLQJHTXLOLEULXPLVHTXDORYHUIORZ XQGHUIORZFRQFHQWUDWLRQV7KXVP E 
\1  E
  + 62  [ 1 \ 1   [   [ 1  
P
8  P2 
      DQG  
P2   8 
 
Q   
 
    1  
Q  
[1 [ 1  P2 8
 E +&Ɛ8VH(TRU 1 

[ [ 1  P2 8
 P2 8  
     [1 [ 1 
   NJ P  
 P2 8  

P2   \1 +& E
      1    [ 1 +& 
8  P
 $OWHUQDWLYH 

!"!#
#
 [1 [1
  1RWH     
[ +&
[ +  62 

  7KXV LI RQH LV FOHYHU DQG UHDOL]HV FKDQJH ZLOO EH VDPH IRU +&Ɛ  + 62 
P2
VLQFH  1DUHLGHQWLFDO GRQ¶WQHHGWRXVH.UHPVHUHTQIRUSDUWE
8

'ZDV'LQQGHG D FFVDQG FFXQGHUIORZ OLTXLG7KLVLVDERXWJ NJ
OLTXLG(TXLO\ [8VHQRPHQFODWXUHRI7DEOH
8 8
  2SHUDWLQJ(T \ M [M  \ LQ [ RXW 
2 2
8 
     6ORSH  *RHVWKURXJKSRLQW\ [ 
2 
  2YHUDOOEDO  2\LQ 8[ LQ 8[ RXW 2\ RXW 
 
   2      \RXW ĺ \ RXW  

  1HHG6WDJHV±6HH*UDSK&DQDOVRXVH.UHPVHUHT

 E 0DVV%DODQFH 8[ M  2 M \ MLQ 8[ M 2 M\ M 

8 8
  2S(T   \M [M \ MLQ [M  
2M 2M
8
      8  2  VORSH  [ RXW  VHHJUDSK
 
2
  2EWDLQDSSUR[LPDWHO\VDPHVHSDUDWLRQEXWXVHPXFKPRUHZDVKZDWHU 
' ZDV'LQQGHG

!"$#
#
 \ # \ # \ # \ #
   

(#)#!#

$# !# &# '# (#)#!#

[

#

2  2 # 2  2 
   
#\ LQ  \  #\  \
# #
LQ  LQ  LQ



# # #
 

  %DVLV NJ &D&2  VROLGV
  )HHG0ROHIUDFFDQEHDUELWUDU\3LFN [   DVEDVLV
  0%  8[ L1 2 \L1 8[ RXW 2\ RXW 
8 8
     \ RXW [ RXW[ L1 \ L1 
2 2
     \ RXW  [ RXW DW(TXLO\ [OLQH
  3RLQW  [ LQ  \LQ [ LQ   LVRQRSOLQH
8 
  6ORSH2SOLQH 
2 
  6HHJUDSK
[ 
  )LQG    
[ 
[
  5HFRYHU\     
[
  5HFRYHU\LVVLJQLILFDQWO\EHWWHUZLWKFRXQWHUFXUUHQWSURFHVV

!"%#
#
 

' ZDV'LQQGHG   
       2  NJK


!""#
#
 NJOLTXLG

NJ /OLTXLG /OLTXLG NJOLTXLG
   8 )  GU\VROLGV   
K /VROLG NJVROLG K

/VROLG
NJ   NJOLTXLG
      8 )   
K  K
NJOLTXLG
      87 8 ) 8 )  
K
87 87
  ,QVHFWLRQ  \M [M  \ [ 
2 2
   6ORSH 8 7 2    *RHVWKURXJKSRLQW \  [   
  ,QWHUPHGLDWHIHHGDW [ [)  
8 ) 8 )
  ,Q6HFWLRQ \ M [M  \1 [1  
2 2
   6ORSH 8 ) 2    *RHVWKURXJKSRLQW \ 1  [ 1 
 $OVRLQWHUVHFWV6HFWLRQRSOLQHDWIHHGOLQH2UFDOFXODWH \ 1 IURPPDVVEDODQFH(TXLOLEULXP
LV\ [6WHSRIIVWDJHVVHH)LJXUH1HHGHTXLOLEULXPVWDJHV2SW)HHGLV WK


' ZDV'LQQGHG     

    

NJGU\   /
 ) ) ZW 
K NJGU\ /VROLG K
 
/ /XQGHUIORZ
NJGU\   /
      )   ) ZW 
K   K

!"*#
#
 / /OLT
  /LTXLG9ROXPHV WRWDO OLT  ZW 
K K
/OLT
       OLT  ZW 
K
      )7  7RWDO OLTG K  
XQGHUIORZ

NJOLTXLG
     8 I   ZKHUH I  NJ / 
K
8 NJOLT NJ1 D +
 2 1   NJ K  \ 1     8  [       
2 K NJOLT
 [     [ 1 VSHFLILHG 
  ([W0% 21  \ 1 8 [  81[ 1 2 \ 


8[ 8 8 
      \ [1 [ [1    
2 2 2 
  &RQYHUWWR.UHPVHU
 2 9 8 / P  \ P[  [   P9 /     
 
Q   
 
  (T 1 RUVWDJHV  
Q 
  8VHIHHGV

'1HZSUREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQNJZHWLVNJGU\VROLGVLQVROXEOHDQGNJXQGHUIORZ OLTXLG
NJGU\VROLGV
3DUWD  NJWRWDO NJGU\LQVROXEOHVROLGV 
NJWRWDO
NJOLTXLG
  8 NJGU\VROLGV NJOLTXLG  2Y NJOLTXLG 
NJGU\VROLGV
 %HIRUHVWPL[LQJ IUDF%D6NJOLTXLG NJ%D6 
NJ%D6
 VW0L[  PDVVIUDFLQ8 2Y 
NJOLTXLGWRWDO
 6HWWOH±NJOLTXLGLQ8  NJ%D6 
NJ%D6
 QG0L[3XUH:DWHU PDVVIUDFLQ8 2Y 
NJOLTXLG
 6HWWOH±NJOLTXLGLQ8  NJ%D6 
NJ
 UG0L[3XUH:DWHU PDVVIUDF%D6LQ8DQG2Y 
NJOLTXLG
3DUWE 5HVXOWLVVDPH&DQDOVREHGRQHJUDSKLFDOO\
3DUWF &RXQWHUFXUUHQW(DVLHVWVROXWLRQDSSURDFKLVWRXVH.UHPVHUHTXDWLRQ
[ 1 [ 1  P 2Y 8
   1 

[  [ 1  P 2Y 8

!"+#
#
   1  [   P  2Y  8  [ 1 \1  P 
  
   [1 [ 
   
  
 ([WHUQDO0% [8 \ 1 2Y [18 \2Y 
   \ 8 [ [1 2Y      

' ZDV'LQQGHG (TXLOLEULXP [M \ M ZWIUDFWLRQV 
8 8
  2SHUDWLQJ(T \M [M \ MLQ [M  
2 2
  %DVLVFFZHWVDQG
YROZDWHU J NJ
     8  FP  ZHWVDQG NJ 
YROVDQG ZHW FF J

    2 NJ7KXVHDFKRSHUDWLQJOLQHKDVVORSH  

  (DFKRSOLQHJRHVWKURXJKSW \ MLQ  [ M 

    [  \ 1LQ \1 LQ \1 LQ 
    [1  \6LQ \ 1  \ LQ \ 1   \LQ \1  
  6WDUWDW VWDJH 1 ZKHUH [ 1     )LQG \ 1  WKHQ ZRUN EDFNZDUGV WR VWDJH 1  7KLV
JLYHVLQOHWVIRUILUVWVWDJHVVRFDQWKHQZRUNIRUZDUGVHH)LJXUH1RWHWKDWVWDJHVDQG
1DUHQRWFRQQHFWHGVWDJHVJLYHVPRUHWKDQHQRXJKVHSDUDWLRQEXWLVQRWHQRXJK





!",#
#
' ZDV'LQQGHG 8VH.UHPVHUHTXDWLRQ
     )VROY )VROLG  \ P[ LVHTXLOLEULXPZLWKP DQG1 
  5HFRYHU\LV  [ 1 [  
  (TEHFRPHV [ 1 \1  P  
P )VROY


[1 [ 1 [1 )VROLG
      1 

[ [ 1 [ P )VROY

)VROLG
P)VROY [1  
     7KHQ 
 
)VROLG [  
  7KXV5HFRYHU\ 

'1HZSUREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ$VVXPH )6ROLG DQG)VROYHQW DUHFRQVWDQWGHVSLWHUHPRYDORIVXJDUIURPVROLG
   )6ROLG  [ )  \ VROY,1  P (  
)6ROLG
(TEHFRPHV [ [) \ VROY ,1 P( )6ROLG )VROY 
)VROY
 D )VROY   )6ROLG )VROY   
 
 [    \ P( [   ZWIUDF
 
 E [ 6ROYHIRU )VROY  
)6ROLG [P ( \ VROY,1
   
)VROY [) [
[) [  
 )VROY )6ROLG  NJ 
P( [ \6ROY,1   


' ZDV'LQQGHG * +  VWUHDP OE K RI+  &2167$17 
 / 6OXUU\VWUHDP OE K &2167$17  
/ /
 2SHUDWLQJ/LQH0XVWZRUNLQZHLJKWUDWLRV < ; ; LQ <RXW 
* *
[ \ [ LQ
     [  <  ; LQ 
 [  \  [ LQ
OE&+  LQ  OE&+  RXW 
     <LQ  <RXW  
OE+  LQ
 OE+  RXW

     * <LQ <RXW /; RXW 
 ; 
     ; RXW     [ RXW  
  ; 

!*-#
#
  2SHUDWLQJOLQHEHFRPHV
/ / 
    < ; <RXW ZKHUH  DQGJRHVWKURXJK ; LQ  <RXW 
* * 
< ; ;
  (TXLOLEULXP&XUYH \ [EHFRPHV   ĺ < 
<  ;   ;
3ORW<YV;
[ ; <
  
  
  
  
  
   



6HH)LJXUHIRU3ORW1HHGVWDJHV
'1HZSUREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ NJ K ZHWVROLGV IUDFYROOLTXLG 
 IUDFYROGU\VROLGV
  %DVLV P  ZHWVROLGV 
  :HLJKWOLTXLGZHLJKWVROLGV   NJ P    NJ P  
    
  NJ NJ NJWRWDO P  ZHWVROLGV 
  NJ
  7KXV RIZHLJKWLVXQGHUIORZOLTXLG8    
  K

' ZDV'LQQGHG  )VROY )VROLG  

!*'#
#
 )VROLG )VROLG
   2S(T  \ [ \ [ 
)VROY )VROY
   :KHUH\DQG[DUH NJ P   \ P ( [ LVHTXLOLEULXP
  [ ) [   [ 1   [ ) [   \ 1   [ 1  1   )VROY )VROLG  
   &DQXVHDQ\RI.UHPVHUHTXDWLRQVVXFKDV(T
P )VROY


[1 [1 )VROLG  P
       1  

[ [1 P)VROY  P

)VROLG
  :KLFKEHFRPHV P  P   )LQGP 
  
  &KHFN    
 ZKLFKLV2.
  
' ZDV'LQQGHG
5Ö 6Ö [  \ LQ
D 8VH(T  [  HTXLO\ P ( [ \ LQ 
P 5Ö 6Ö
J / LQOLTG  [ )  
5Ö 6Ö    P (   [ [) [ ) 
J / LQVROLG   
  )UDF5HF    
6Ö  [ W ILQDO
 E (TE  Q 
5Ö P( [ W IHHG
  [ WILQDO [ )  H[S   [ ) )UDF5HF ± 

' ZDV'LQQGHG 
%D62  FRDO %D6 &2  
  (TXLO6ROQFRQFLQXQGHUIORZ VROQFRQFLQRYHUIORZ7KXVUHDOO\ZDVKLQJ
     (TXLO  \ [ P  E  
NJ NJVROXWLRQ
8  LQVRO   NJVROQ[ LQ  [ RXW  
K NJLQVROXEOHVROLG
NJ 8 [ [1 
2   \ LQ  [ 1  \    [   
K 2 
Q [1 [ 1 [ [  Q   
 (T 1 RU 
Q / P9 Q   
' 1HZSUREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ:LWKNJKGU\VROLGV 8    NJ K 
D &DQXVH.UHPVHUHTZLWKODUJH1WRILQG 2Y 0LQ RUDVNHWFK

!*&#
#

 \ # (TXLOLEULXPLV \ [

 \ 8 \  
 
 8 2Y [ [1  
0LQ
 
  0LQ
 \1   
[  2Y 0LQ 
 
 [1    
  


 E 2Y 2Y 0LQ  
8 
   
2Y 
\ \ 9 2Y
  .UHPVHU 
[ [ / 8
  (T [1  [ 1  [   P   8 2Y    
8 [ [ 1 8
Q 
P 2Y [1 [ 1 P 2Y
    1 
P
Q
8 2Y
 
Q   
  
    1  
 
Q

  ,QWKHRU\FDQXVH0F&DEH7KLHOHEXWLWLVGLIILFXOWWRDFFXUDWHO\VWHSRIIWKLVODUJHQXPEHURI
VWDJHV
8 
 F  2Y   P  
2Y 
Q    
    1  

Q

1 HT 
     1 DFW ( RYHUDOO  
1 VXEDFWXDO 
  )RU P ( XVH1 DQGFKDQJHP(ZLWKVDPHHTXDWLRQ
 
Q  
P( P(
   1 
P(
Q


!*!#
#
  9DU\P(XQWLO1  P (  
  2QD0F&DEH7KLHOHGLDJUDPWKLVLVWULDODQGHUURU.UHPVHULVPXFKHDVLHU

'1HZSUREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ3DUWD 8 NJ2 NJ[ ,1  \ ,1  
 6ROXWLRQWUDQVODWLRQRI(TLV
8
   [ [ ,1 \ ,1  8 2      
2
 3DUWE:DQW [  2LVXQNQRZQ [ ,1  \ 1  8  6ROYHIRU2
8 8 2 [ \ ,1 [ ,1 [
   [ [ [ ,1 \ ,1  2 8 
2 2 8 [ ,1 [ [ \ ,1
 
   2  NJZDWHU 
 
2
'1HZSUREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ. (T±EHFRPHV Q [ W ILQDO [ W IHHG 
8
 3DUWD 2  8  [ WIHHG  
2 
 [ W ILQDO [ W IHHG H[S H  
8
 3DUWE 8  [ WIHHG  [ WILQDO  

   2 8 Q [ W ILQDO [ W IHHG  Q NJ 

 3DUWF [ WILQDO [ LQ3DUWD
   2 2 QRUPDOEDWFK LQ3DUWE

'  2QHHTXLOLEULXPVWDJH )  [ $ 1  6  \ $6 \ '6 
(  \ $ )[ $1
      [ $0  VDPHDV([DPSOH
( )
  3ORW0%\WULDODQGHUURUILQGWLHOLQHWKURXJK0)LQDOUHVXOWVKRZQLQ)LJXUH
      \ $  \ '  [ $  [ '  
  )ORZUDWHV'LOXHQWEDODQFH 5[ ' )[ '1 
      5 ) [ '1 [ '  
      ( 0 5    

!*$#
#
'  7KLV SUREOHP LV HVVHQWLDOO\ D UHSHDW RI ([DPSOH  H[FHSW XVLQJ H[DFWO\  VWDJHV
&OHDUO\ [ $  VLQFHQRZKDYHPRUHVWDJHV) (  DQG0DUHXQFKDQJHG3UREOHP
LVWULDODQGHUURU*XHVVORFDWLRQRI 5  )LQG ( 1 DQG¨6WHSRIIVWDJHVDQGVHHLI
KDYH FRUUHFW ORFDWLRQ RI ( 1   7KH WKLUG DQG ILQDO WULDO LV VKRZQ LQ WKH ILJXUH
[ $  DQG \ $  

'  $OWKRXJKWKLVLVOHDFKLQJWKLVFURVVIORZSUREOHPLVYHU\VLPLODUWRFURVVIORZH[WUDFWLRQ
:HFDQGHULYH
5 M  [ $ M  ( MLQ \ $ MLQ
       [ $ 0M 
5 M  ( MLQ

0 M [ $ 0M \$ M
    0 5M  ( MLQ ZKHUH 5 M 
[$M \$ M
  6WDJH 5  (LQ  [ $ \ DLQ   [ $0    
  )LQG0RQOLQH 65  DW[ $0 VHH)LJXUH%\WULDODQGHUURUILQGWLHOLQHWKURXJK0

!*%#
#
  7KLVJLYHV ( DQG5  )LQG \ $  [ $  0  
  
     5  
 
  
  6WDJH[ $ 0   
 
\ $  [ $   IURPWLHOLQH  0   
  
     5  
 

  
  6WDJH[ $ 0    \ $  [$  0 


  
     5  NJK
 



' D%DVLVNJPL[LQXQGHUIORZ [ 1D& YDOXHV   \1D& 

FU\VWDOV


 6LQFHFU\VWDOVDUHSXUH1D&Ɛ1D2+LVLQOLTXLGRQO\6LQFHRIWKHXQGHUIORZLVOLTXLG
 [ 1D2+ \ 1D2+ *HQHUDWHHTXLOLEULXPWDEOH
 

!*"#
#

       6ROQ\  
[ 1D2+  0DVVIUDF1D2+  \ 1D&  [ 1D& 
   
   
   
   
#
   
   
   
   
   
   
  
&ĞĞĚŝƐϰϱǁƚйEĂыĐƌLJƐƚĂůƐ͘džǀĂůƵĞƐ͗EĂы;ƐŽůŶͿсϬ͘ϱϭϵϯ͕EĂK,;ƐŽůŶͿсϬ͘Ϭϵϵ͕ǁĂƚĞƌϭ.-/%',!.
-/-,,#)#-/!+'*/##01234#5446#17#%%8#91:;16<#
[ )1D2+ \ 1D2+  \ 1D2+   
# # # # <# #
\ 1D& 
# # =>?@#AB4#4:;191C>1;@#6DAD# #
# # =#)#'--<#0#)#&-<#E9?A#=#F#0#D26#5126#G/#
)0 

# # # # # # 60  #H14#9124#AB>?;IB#G#I1J47#K#F#L/#
( 50

# # # # # # 5 (0 #M@4D7;>46#?2#51I;>4N#
# # # # # # ( 5  5 5  #
# # # # # # 5  OIP@12<# (  OIP@12#
5  5DIILQDWH [ 1D&   [ 1D2+
# # # # # # #
(  ([WUDFW\ 1D&  \ 1D2+ 
# # # # # # #
#
# # HB4#;264>59?Q#17#R#QA#5>D3#3>S7AD97#;WƵƌĞEĂыͿн;ϭ.RN#QA#5>D3#7?9;A1?2#
\ 1D& LVVROQLQHTXLO
# # # # # # #
]   ]  
# # HB;7<## # # #
 
] 2.
# # # # # #  #
# # # QD7#+-8#7?9167#12#T>?C94@#7ADA4@42A/#
#
5 5 (1
# 3/# 0D@4#G/##E9?A# #6>DQ#9124# G#A?# /#
#
# # &#7ADI47#@?>4#ABD2#7;5513142A#
(1 5  5  5 
# # # # # # #
(1 5 0 

# # # # # # 5 (10  #

!**#
#
 5  ( 
# # # # # # OIP@12<# 1 #OIP@12#
5  [1D&  [1D2+ 
# # # # # # #
( 1  \ 1D& \ 1D2+ 
# # # # # # #
#

!*+#
#
 



 

!*,#
#
(D  7KLVLVGLIILFXOWSDUW±FRQYHUWLQJGDWD
  %DVLVOERLOIUHHVROLGV

 \ RLO ]
z [ VROLGV [ RLO
\ RLO \VROYHQW  ]  ]
0    0
0.1    0.01948
0.2    0.044115
0.3    0.07595
0.4    0.1153
0.5    0.16420
0.6    0.2250
0.65    0.26124
0.70    0.303399
0.72 0.28 0.810 0.552486 0.3222

  1RWH \VROLGV  IRUDOOVWUHDPV= OEVROXWLRQOERLOIUHHVROLGV

  3ORWGDWDRQWULDQJXODUGLDJUDP6HH)LJXUH(DEFGH

 E F )6 0 


       )[ RLO) 6\RLO6 0[ RLO0  [ RLO0   


  6HH)LJXUH(DEFGH

0 6 ) 
  &KHFN/HYHU$UP  )LQGWLHOLQHWKURXJK0
0 ) 6 

  ([WUDFW (  \ RLO  5DIILQDWH[ RLO DQG[ VROLGV  

  0DVV%DODQFHV   ( 5    ( 5  
      5 ( OE 
  )LQLVKVWHSF6WDJH 5 6 0    5  0 [RLO0 
   [ RLO0   3ORW 0  DQGILQGWLHOLQHWKURXJK 0  
  ([WUDFW  \RLO 
 5DIILQDWH[ RLO DQG[ VROLGV  
  0%    ( 5    (  5   
      5  OE(  OE 
  G H±6DPHDQVZHUDVE FEXW5 (DUHIORZUDWHV

I 6HH)LJXUH(IVWDJHVLVPRUHWKDQHQRXJK1HHGa  HTXLOVWDJHV



!+-#
#
  /LQHV ( 1 5 1  DQG(  5  LQWHUVHFWDW   










!+'#
#
 








!+&#
#

(1HZSUREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ&RQYHUWLQJGDWDLVWKHGLIILFXOWSDUWEXWLVREYLRXVO\LGHQWLFDOWR
3UREOHP(#
# # UD717#'#OI#?19.5>44#7?9167#

! ! !  \ RLO ]
[ VROLGV ! [ RLO !
 ]  ]
\ RLO ! \VROYHQW ! "!

#! '/-# -/&-# -/+!-# #!

#$%! -/,# /&$&# -/+-%'%# #$#%&'(!

#$)! -/+# /&+!# -/**,$# #$#''%%*!

#$+! -/*# /!!,# -/*$"+!# #$#,*&*!

#$'! -/"# -/$-%# -/*''*$# #$%%*+!

#$*! -/%# -/$+,# -/"*'%,# #$%-')#!

#$-! -/$# -/"--# -/"&%# #$))*#!

!#$-*! ##-/!%# -/"*&# -/%,+-+"# #$)-%)'!

!#$,#! -/!# -/*"%# -/%""%*# #$+#++&&!

!#$,)! !!#$)(! #$(%#! #$**)'(-! #$+)))!

[ W ILQDO
6 G[ W
$SSUR[LPDWHVROXWLRQXVH(TD2LOEDODQFH
5W [ F IHHG
\

 
  6 0DVV6ROYHQW 5 W 0DVVUDIILQDWH VROLGVVROXWH
  [ 0DVVIUDFVROXWHRLOLQUDIILQDWH
  \ 0DVVIUDFVROXWHRLOLQUDIILQDWHLQH[WUDFWVROYHQW

D 0LVQRZDWVDWXUDWHGUDIILQDWHFXUYH [ RLO0  [ VROLGV0  
0DVVEDODQFH)6 0
6ROLGV)6 0
  

  0 ) NJ 5 LQLWLDO 

  6 NJ 
E 1RZPL[LQJLVIURP6WRDSRLQWRQUDIILQDWHFXUYH
)URPHTXLOLEULXPFXUYHLQVROXWLRQWR(

!+!#
#
 
[ RLO  \ RLO   \ RLO 
  
  
  
  
  

 ,QVROXEOH6ROLGV0%
  ,QLWLDO) )LQDO 5 W ILQDO 
   5 W ILQDO
 5 WILQDO NJ 
 5DIILQDWHLVVROLGVRLODQGVROYHQW
 6ROYHQWUHPDLQLQJLQUDIILQDWHLV   NJ 
 1HHGVWREHUHFRYHUHGE\HYDSRUDWLRQ
 'R6LPSVRQ¶VUXOHLQSDUWV
 
       


  
      

 
  6DGGHG 5 W  EXWZKDWLV 5 W "
 (TDDVVXPHV 5 W &RQVW 
 8VHDYHUDJHYDOXHRI 5 W 

  5 W DYJ 5 W LQLW 5 W ILQDO    

 RU 6DGGHG 5 WDYJ    
  6WRWDO ,QLWLDODGGLWLRQ6DGGHG    
 ([WUDFW DPW 6 6WRWDO 6UHPDLQLQUDIILQDWH    E\VROYHQW
 2LOLQH[WUDFW [ ) ) [ ILQDORLO 5 WILQDO      
 7RWDOZWH[WUDFW    
  \RLO    
  \VROYHQW  
#

(1HZSUREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ6ROLG0DWUL[LVLQVROXEOH6ROLGV  NJ 5 W QRW

&RQVWDQWEXW6ROLGLV
6ROLGV
   5W 
[ 6ROLGV
[$
   \G6 G 5 [ $ 6ROLGV G 
[ 6ROLGV


!+$#
#
 [ ILQDO $ [ 6ROLGV
6 G [ $ [ 6ROLGV
   
6ROLGV [ $ UDI LQLW \
[ 6ROLGV UDI LQLW

&KDQJHVOLPLWVLQWHJUDWLRQ
   [ RLO  [ 6ROLGV   [ RLO [ 6ROLGV    
   [ RLO  [ 6ROLGV   [ RLO [ 6ROLGV    
   [ RLO  [ 6ROLGV   [ RLO [ 6ROLGV    
 1XPEHUVIRUXVHLQ6LPSVRQ¶VUXOHDUHIURP6ROXWLRQ(

 
        



 
    
    


7RWDO 
   6DGGHG 6ROLGV WRWDOLQWHJUDO   NJ 
   6WRWDO LQLWLDO DGGHG   NJ 
 ([WUDFW$PRXQW6ROYHQW 6WRWDO 6UDI ILQDO   NJ 
 2LOLQH[WUDFW ± 
 7RWDOZHLJKWH[WUDFW    

   ZWIUDFVROYHQW ZWIUDFRLO 
#

# # #

!!

!+%#
#
 Chapter 15 Solution M anual
6LQFHWKLVLVDQHZFKDSWHUDOOSUREOHPVDUHQHZ

A. 'LVFXVVLRQ3UREOHPV
$ 7KHPROHIUDFWLRQZDWHULVFRQVWDQWEXWVLQFHWKHWHPSHUDWXUHZLWKLQWKHYHVVHOYDULHVWKHWRWDO
PRODUGHQVLW\&PYDULHVDQGWKHZDWHUFRQFHQWUDWLRQ &Z \Z&PDOVRYDULHV7KXV(T
DLQFRUUHFWO\SUHGLFWVPROHFXODUGLIIXVLRQ(TXDWLRQESUHGLFWVQRPROHFXODU
GLIIXVLRQEHFDXVHG\ZG] 

B. *HQHUDWLRQRI$OWHUQDWLYHV
% )RUH[DPSOHRQHFRXOGRSHUDWHZLWKERWKLQIORZDQGRXWIORZDWWKHERWWRPRIWKHWXEH,IIORZLV
FRQWUROOHGZLWKDFRQVWDQWKHDGWDQNWKHKHLJKWRIOLTXLGLQWKHWXEHZLOOEHYHU\FORVHWR
FRQVWDQW

C. 'HULYDWLRQV
&6XEVWLWXWHLQT ȝ5HȡLQWR(TGDQGREWDLQį >ȝ5HȡJ@

&6WDUWZLWK(TDVHWY% DQGVROYHIRU\$Y$7KHQ1$ &P\$Y$6XEVWLWXWHLQWKH
H[SUHVVLRQIRU\$Y$DQG(THIRU-$7KLVJLYHVWKHGHVLUHGUHVXOW

&7KLVSUREOHPLVLQFOXGHGWRVKRZWKDWRQHFDQGHULYHWKHH[SUHVVLRQVLQERRNV7KHUHLVDORWRI
DOJHEUDEXWWKHGHULYDWLRQZRUNV)LUVWFDQH[SDQGWKHGHULYDWLYH
wJ  w § $%     [  [  ·
 ¨ ¸
w[ w[ © > %   $  %  [ @ ¹
 7KHQWDNHWKHGHULYDWLYHDQGH[SDQGDOOWHUPV7KHGHQRPLQDWRUEHFRPHV
 > $   $  % [ @ > %[  $[ @ DQGWKHQXPHUDWRUVLPSOLILHVWR  $ %  [  0XOWLSO\E\[4('

&:LWK&02DQG\DVPROHIUDFWLRQ YPRO
\ $Y $  \% Y% \ $Y $    \ $ Y%  6LQFH1$ 1%
&$Y$ &%Y%DQGIRUDQLGHDOJDV&L \L&P7KHWRWDOPRODUFRQFHQWUDWLRQ&PLVFRQVWDQW
  7KHQY$ \$Y%\$(T$
  ,QWHUPVRIPDVVIUDFWLRQV\$ \$PDVV0:$>\$PDVV0:$±\$PDVV0:%@(T%
  6XEVWLWXWH(T%LQWR(T$DQGVLPSOLI\
  \ $ PDVV   0:%
   Y$  Y% (T&
\ $ PDVV  0:$
 
7KHQLQPDVVWHUPV YPDVV \ $PDVV Y$  \% PDVV Y% ZKLFKDIWHUVXEVWLWXWLQJLQ(T&DQGVLPSOLI\LQJ

YPDVV ª¬  \ $PDVV    0:$  0:%   \ $PDVV  º¼ Y% (T'

  ,I0:$ 0:% YPDVV :HFDQZULWH
  Y% 1%&% 1%\%&P 1%&P±\$(T(
  ZKHUHWKH\DUHPROHIUDFWLRQV6XEVWLWXWLQJ(T%LQWR(T(DQGWKHQVXEVWLWXWLQJWKLVLQWR(T'
ZHREWDLQ
§   \ $  PDVV · § 0: $ ·
&P 1 % ¨ ¸¨    \ $  PDVV     \ $  PDVV  ¸

YPDVV © 0: % ¹ © 0: % ¹
   (T)
\ $  PDVV  0: $    \ $  PDVV   0: %

  6LQFH\$PDVVYDULHVWKURXJKRXWWKHGLVWLOODWLRQ YPDVV LVGLIIHUHQWIRUHDFKVWDJH

!"#$
$
D. 3UREOHPV
G& $
''SURSZDWHU (PV(T - $  ]  ' $%  ' $%  / & $  /  & $   ,I & $ 
G]
NJPLVWKHNQRZQYDOXH & $ / FDQEHODUJHURUVPDOOHUWKDQ & $ )RUVPDOOHU & $ / ZHKDYH
& $ / ±(( 
 
  ,ILWLVODUJHUYDOXHWKHQ & $ / (( 

'7DNLQJWKHUDWLRRI(TFDWWKHXQNQRZQ7DQGDW7 
H[S>  (R  75 @
 ' 7  '  (IRU7 .)OX[
H[S>  (R   5 @
G& $
- $ ]  ' $%   ' $%  / & $  /  & $     u        u 
G]

  7KHWHPSHUDWXUHFDQEHIRXQGZLWK*RDO6HHNIURPDVSUHDGVKHHWEXWRQHKDVWRWULFN*RDO6HHN
LQWRZRUNLQJ0XOWLSO\WKHGHVLUHGDQGWKHFDOFXODWHGIOX[HVE\DQGKDYH*RDO6HHN
PDWFKWKHVHWZRYDOXHV

'DFPVEFPVFFPVGFPV

'DFPVEFPVFFPVGFPV

'8VH$UUKHQLXVIRUPLQ(TFEXWIRUPROHIUDFWLRQLQVWHDGRILQILQLWHGLOXWLRQ:ULWH
WKHHTXDWLRQIRUERWKNQRZQWHPSHUDWXUHVDQGGLYLGHRQHRIWKHVHHTXDWLRQVE\WKHRWKHU7KH
FRQVWDQW'RGLYLGHVRXW7DNHWKHQDWXUDOORJRIERWKVLGHVDQGVROYHIRU(57KHUHVXOWLV
§ ' 7  · §   ·
(  5 OQ ¨ $%  ¸  ¨  ¸ 
© ' $% 7  ¹ © 7 7 ¹
  7KHFRQVWDQW'RFDQEHIRXQGIURPWKHNQRZQFRQGLWLRQVDW7 
   'R '$% 7   H[S> (   57 @ 
  2UIURPWKHNQRZQFRQGLWLRQVDW7 7KHUHVXOWVDUH(5 ( FDOPRO'$%
[ 7  îPV

'6DPHHTXDWLRQVDVLQ'$W.IRUWKHLQILQLWHGLOXWLRQYDOXHVHW& VXFURVH )LQDO
UHVXOWVDUH(R FDOPRO'$%LQILQLWHGLOXWLRQ7 . îPV

')RUDQLGHDOVROXWLRQWKHWHUPLQEUDFNHWVLQ(TLVHTXDOWR:ULWHWKLVHTXDWLRQIRU
WZRRIWKH[$YDOXHVZLWKWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJGLIIXVLYLWLHVHJ[ ZLWK' î
PVDQG[ ZLWK' îPV7KHQKDYHWZRHTXDWLRQVZLWKWKHWZRXQNQRZQV
R
'$% DQG '%$ R R
6ROYHIRUWKHWZRXQNQRZQV5HVXOWVDUH '$% îPVDQG '%$ R

 
î P V&KHFNUHVXOWVZLWKWKHRWKHUWZRPROHIUDFWLRQVDQGILQGWKDWWKHILWLVJRRG

')URPKWWSZZZHQJLQHHULQJWRROER[FRPWKHGHQVLW\RIPHWKDQRODWESLVNJPXVHGD
OLQHDULQWHUSRODWLRQZKLFKPHDQVSDUWLDOPRODUYROXPH GHQVLW\0: NJP
9LVFRVLW\RIZDWHULVFS 3DV NJPÂV
  D:LWKij% '$% îPV
  E:LWKij% '$% îPV

!"%$
$

   U JT   P  $VVXPHWKDWWKHEXONLVSXUH

'&RPELQLQJ(TVEG YYHUWLFDO PD[OLT
ZDWHUZLWKLQILQLWHGLOXWLRQRIHWKDQRO)URP3HUU\¶V&KHPLFDO(QJLQHHU¶V+DQGERRNWKHGLWLRQ
SDWEDU03DZDWHUKDVȡ:POLT NPROPĺȡ:OLT NJPDQG
ȡ:PYDSRU NPROPĺȡ:YDSRU NJP7KHZDWHUERLOVDW.$WWKLV
WHPSHUDWXUHIURPSWKHYLVFRVLW\RIOLTXLGZDWHULQ3DÂVLV
 P: OLT H[S>    7   OQ 7   u 7  @  u 3D ˜ V 
7KHYLVFRVLW\RIWKHYDSRUDW.LVS
 P: YDSRU  u 7  u 3D ˜ V RUNJPÂV
 1RZZHFDQFDOFXODWHWKHYHUWLFDOYHORFLW\RIWKHOLTXLGZDWHUIRUT îPVUHPHPEHUWRXVH
OLTXLGSURSHUWLHV

§  (    ·
YYHUWLFDO PD[OLT    U JT  P 


  ¨ ¸  P  V 
©  ¹
 $FKHFNRIWKHXQLWVVKRZWKH\ZRUN7KHPRGLILHG5H\QROGVQXPEHUXVLQJJDVSURSHUWLHVLV
G WXEH U  Y JDV  YOLT  \ PD[    
 5Hc  
P  u  
§PU·
 7KHJDVSKDVH6FKPLGWQXPEHULV 6F JDV ¨ ¸ 7KHYLVFRVLW\DQGGHQVLW\ZHUHIRXQGHDUOLHU
© ' (: ¹ JDV
7KHGLIIXVLYLW\RIHWKDQRODQGZDWHULQWKHYDSRUSKDVHDW.DQGEDU DWPFDQEH
HVWLPDWHGIURPWKH&KDSPDQ(QVNRJWKHRU\ZLWKWKHSDUDPHWHUVLQ7DEOH7KLVYDOXHRI'(: 
îPV7KHQ6FJDV 6LQFHERWK 5Hc DQG 6FJDV DUHLQWKHUDQJHIRU(TDWKH
PRGLILHG6KHUZRRGQXPEHULV
N S G WXEH  S% OP
 5Hc  6FJDV     
'$% SWRW

')URPWKH&KDSPDQ(QVNRJWKHRU\'1+DLU îPVDW.DQGS DWP
&'()*+,$-./0-123$!'4$+4/
56$7 8"/9 56$: -% ;(<=> -/"#?@1%
A !-"/-# B -/8 AC!D8 .#%./1!!
=EF,2$7 !/%-- =EF,2$: 8/9 =EF,2$7: !/!1..
+(=$7DG: %"/# +B=$:DG: .."/! +B=$7:DG: 819/H"-8
GAD?B=7: -/.-"" I(*$E<>+F -/-9% JE<+2'$E<>+'B(*2>E(<$>2)*+$-.@8
0$7: 8/1.?@1.
03$;,C8D= 8/1.?@1- 

 7KHFRQFHQWUDWLRQDW] /LV&1+/ &1+] -1+/'1+DLU5HVXOWVDUHNPROP
DQGNPROP

'' -/ǻ& îPV6HWXSVSUHDGVKHHWWRREWDLQWKLVYDOXH6LQFHWKHFROOLVLRQLQWHJUDO
ZDVHQWHUHGPDQXDOO\KDGWRGRVHYHUDOLWHUDWLRQV$IWHULWHUDWLRQV7 .VHH
VSUHDGVKHHWDQGQRWHWKDWFROOLVLRQLQWHJUDOGRHVQRWH[DFWO\PDWFKWKHYDOXHRIN7İ$%

!""$
$
 &'()*+,$-./0--3$!'4$+4/
56$7 8"/9 56$: -% ;(<=> -/"#?@1%
A !9#/-#H8 B 1/9 AC!D8 %""./818
=EF,2$7 !/%-- =EF,2$: 8/9 =EF,2$7: !/!1..
+(=$7DG: %"/# +B=$:DG: .."/! +B=$7:DG: 819/H"-8
GAD?B=7: -/"9--#" I(*$E<>+F -/-1#9 JE<+2'$E<>+'B(*2>E(<$>2)*+$-.@8
0$7: H/--?@1.
0$4+=E'+4 H/--?@1. ;KG:%@:" -/91?@-1
;KG$L$?. -/91?@1. M(2*$=++G$>($N+'($;K2<FE<F$:! 

&'()*+, $-./0--3$!'4$+4/
56$7 8"/9 56$: -% ;(<=> 1/111111-"."
A !9#/-#H-991!H-"# B 1/9 AC!D8 O:!PQRSAT:!U
=EF,2$7 !/%-- =EF,2$: 8/9 =EF,2$7: O1/.PT:HV0HU
+(=$7DG: %"/# +B=$:DG: .."/! +B=$7:DG: OQRSAT:.P0.U
GAD?B=7: O:!DW. I(*$E<>+F -/-1#9 JE<+2'$E<>+'B(*2>E(<$
0$7: OW8PW!PQRSAT-D:8V-D08UDT0!PWHPWHP0#U E<$A2)*+$-.@8
0$4+=E'+4 1/1111H--H ;KG:%@:" O:%@:"
;KG$L$?. O-11111P0" M(2*$=++G$>($N+'($
;K2<FE<F$:! 

' )URPKWWSZZZHQJLQHHULQJWRROER[FRPYLVFRVLW\LVFS 3DÂV NJPÂV
$W.'$% PV'HQVLW\ZDWHU NJPYLVFRVLW\ZDWHU NJPV
   &DOFXODWHį PY\DYJ PV5H 7KLVLVDORQJUHVLGHQFHWLPH
ZLWK5HVRWKHUHDUHQRULSSOHV6KDYJ DQGNDYJ (PVDQGNJV
FDUERQGLR[LGHDUHDEVRUEHG

')URPKWWSZZZHQJLQHHULQJWRROER[FRPYLVFRVLW\LVFS 3DÂV NJPÂV$W
.'$% PV'HQVLW\ZDWHU NJPYLVFRVLW\ZDWHU NJPÂV
   &DOFXODWHį PY\DYJ PV5H 7KLVLVDORQJUHVLGHQFHWLPH
ODPLQDUIORZZLWKQRVXUIDFWDQWVRWKHUHDUHULSSOHV6KDYJ DQGNDYJ (PVDQG
NJVFDUERQGLR[LGHDUHDEVRUEHG

')URPKWWSZZZHQJLQHHULQJWRROER[FRPYLVFRVLW\LVFS 3DÂV NJPÂV$W
.'$% PV'HQVLW\ZDWHU NJPYLVFRVLW\ZDWHU NJPÂV
   &DOFXODWHį PY\DYJ PV5H 7KLVLVWXUEXOHQWIORZZLWK
5H6FOLT 6KDYJ DQGNDYJ PVDQGNJVFDUERQ
GLR[LGHDUHDEVRUEHG

')URPKWWSZZZHQJLQHHULQJWRROER[FRPYLVFRVLW\LVFS 3DV NJPÂV$W
.'$% PV'HQVLW\ZDWHU NJPYLVFRVLW\ZDWHU NJPÂV
   &DOFXODWHį PY\DYJ PV5H 7KLVLVDVKRUWUHVLGHQFHWLPH
ZLWK5HVRWKHUHDUHQRULSSOHV6KDYJ DQGNDYJ (PV(NJV
FDUERQGLR[LGHDUHDEVRUEHG

')URPKWWSZZZHQJLQHHULQJWRROER[FRPYLVFRVLW\LVFS 3DÂV NJPÂV$W
.'$% PV'HQVLW\ZDWHU NJPYLVFRVLW\ZDWHU NJPÂV

!"9$
$
   &DOFXODWHį PY\DYJ PV5H 7KLVLVDORQJUHVLGHQFHWLPH
ODPLQDUIORZZLWKVXUIDFWDQWVRWKHUHDUHQRULSSOHV6K DYJ DQGNDYJ (PVDQG
NJVFDUERQGLR[LGHDUHDEVRUEHG

'8VHGDVSUHDGVKHHWVHWXSWRVROYH([DPSOH)RUį PHWHURQHREWDLQV[1+ 
\1+VXUIDFH 1ZDWHU 11+ 7KHFRQFHQWUDWLRQVDUHWKHVDPH
DVLQ([DPSOHEXWWKHIOX[HVDUHîODUJHU

'3DUWD)RUWZRSDUWVROXWLRQQHHGYDOXHVDW[( DQG7KHDYHUDJHPROHFXODUZHLJKWV
DUHFDOFXODWHGDVLQ([DPSOHDQGDUHXVHGWRGHWHUPLQHWKHDYHUDJHPRODUGHQVLWLHV7KH
)LFNLDQGLIIXVLYLWLHVDUHHVWLPDWHGE\LQWHUSRODWLQJEHWZHHQYDOXHVJLYHQLQWKH7DEOHLQ([DPSOH
7KHDFWLYLW\FRHIILFLHQWVDUHGHWHUPLQHGLQWKHVDPHZD\DVLQ([DPSOH7KHQWKH
0D[ZHOO6WHIDQGLIIXVLYLWLHVDUHIRXQGE\WKHVDPHPHWKRG7KHYDOXHVDUHOLVWHGEHORZ

 0:DYJ U P NPROP '(:PV Ȗ( '(: PV
;(    î  î

;(    î  î
:ULWH(TFIRUERWKLQWHUYDOV)RUǻ]IURP[( WRZHREWDLQYDOXHVDW[( DQG
DUHLQ([DPSOH
 u   >  @
']1 (   u   

)URP[( WRLQWHUYDOLVRYHUOHQJWKįǻ]ZHREWDLQ
 u   >  @
   ']  1 (   u   

$GGLQJWKHWZRHTXDWLRQVWRUHPRYHWKHXQNQRZQǻ]DQGWKHQVROYLQJIRU1(DQGǻ]ZHREWDLQ
 1( îNPROVDQGǻ] P

3DUWE6LQFHWKHLQWHUYDOǻ]LVJUHDWHUWKDQWKHLQWHUYDOį±ǻ] PZHVXEGLYLGHWKHLQWHUYDO
IURP[( WRLQWRSDUWV7KHYDOXHVQHHGHGDUHJLYHQEHORZ

 0:DYJ U P NPROP '(:PV Ȗ( '(: PV
;(    î  î

;(    î  î
' ] 1 (   u  
(TXDWLRQFLVQRZZULWWHQWLPHV ' ]  1 (   u   
G  ' ]  ' ]   1 (   u  

DQGVROYHGIRUWKHXQNQRZQVǻ]ǻ]DQG1(2EWDLQ1( îNPROVǻ] DQG

ǻ] P

'2SWLRQDO8QVWHDG\GLIIXVLRQ$WWKHDYHUDJH& PRO/ 'VXFURVH  u FP   V 
&$ ]
(TXDWLRQEHFRPHV   HUI 
& $  u   W
1XPHULFDOYDOXHVRI & $  & $ DUHHDVLO\REWDLQHGZLWKDVSUHDGVKHHWRUZLWKWKHXVHRI7DEOH


!91$
$
]FP W V W V W V
   
   
   
   
   
   
 (  
 (  
   
 (  
   
   
   
   
  ( 
  ( 
   
  ( 
   
   (
   (
   (
   (

3DUWE &  u   ZKHQ &  &  u ZKLFKIRUW VRFFXUVIRUDWKLFNQHVVRI
FP*RDO6HHNJLYHVFP7KXVDWWKLVWLPHDOD\HUFPRUWKLFNHUDSSHDUVWREH
LQILQLWHO\WKLFN
3DUWF &  u   ZKHQ &  &  u ZKLFKIRU G FPRFFXUVDWW VGRQHZLWK
*RDO6HHNRQVSUHDGVKHHW

H.6SUHDGVKHHW3UREOHPV

+/HW$ DLU% K\GURJHQDQG& DPPRQLD7KHQ1& 1$±1%6XEVWLWXWHWKLVH[SUHVVLRQ
LQWR(TVDE

U P '\ $ § \ \ \ · § \ \ ·
 ¨ %  &  $ ¸ 1$  ¨ $  $ ¸ 1%
'] © ' $% ' $& ' $& ¹ © ' $% ' $& ¹

U P '\ % § \ % \% · § \$ \& \% ·
¨  ¸ 1$ ¨   ¸ 1%
'] © '%$ '%& ¹ © '%$ '%& '%& ¹

'HWHUPLQH1%IURPWKHVWHTXDWLRQDQG1$IURPWKHVHFRQG


!9-$
$
 U P '\ $ § \ \ \ ·
¨ %  &  $ ¸ 1$
'] © ' $% ' $& ' $& ¹
1%
§ \$ \ ·
¨  $ ¸
© ' $% ' $& ¹

U P '\ % § \ \ \ ·
¨ $  &  % ¸ 1%
'] © ' %$ ' %& ' %& ¹
1$
§ \% \ ·
¨  % ¸
© ' %$ ' %& ¹

3XWWKHVHHTXDWLRQVDQGWKHYDOXHVIRUPROHIUDFWLRQVDWWKHERXQGDULHVGLIIXVLYLWLHVȡPDQGǻ] įLQWRD
VSUHDGVKHHW*XHVVDYDOXHIRU1$JXHVVFDOFXODWH1%DQG1$FDOFDQGXVH*RDO6HHNWRPDNH
1$JXHVV1$FDOF E\FKDQJLQJWKHYDOXHRI1 $JXHVV
5HVXOWV1DLU (1+ (DQG11+ (NPROV$VH[SHFWHGK\GURJHQ
GLIIXVHVLQWKHSRVLWLYHGLUHFWLRQDQGDPPRQLDLQWKHQHJDWLYHGLUHFWLRQ7KHVXUSULVHLVWKH
VXEVWDQWLDOQHJDWLYHGLIIXVLRQUDWHRIDLU6SUHDGVKHHWVKRZQLQ+EXWZLWKGLIIHUHQW
QXPEHUV

+8VHGDVSUHDGVKHHWVHWXSWRVROYH([DPSOH)RUDEXONJDVWKDWLVDLU1+DQG
ZDWHUREWDLQ[1+ \1+VXUIDFH 1ZDWHU 11+ NPROV

+D6HHVROXWLRQWR+IRUSURFHGXUHDQG+IRUH[DPSOHVSUHDGVKHHW
5HVXOWV1DLU (1+ (11+ (NPROV
E)RUDPPRQLD'HII (PV(VWLPDWLQJG&G]ZLWKWKHGLIIHUHQFHDSSUR[LPDWLRQIRUDYHU\
GLOXWHVROXWLRQ1 - 'HIIȡPǻ\ǻ] (NPROPP (
NPROV7KXVWKLVLVDFFXUDWH)RUK\GURJHQDQGDLU'DLU+ (PV7KHQ
1DLU -DLU (NPROPP (NPROV7KHVDPHYDOXHLV
REWDLQHGIRUK\GURJHQ7KHK\GURJHQYDOXHLVFORVHEXWWKHDLUYDOXHLVQRWFORVH&RQFOXVLRQ
8VHWKH0D[ZHOO6WHIDQDSSURDFK

+6HHVROXWLRQWR+IRUSURFHGXUH5HVXOWV1DLU (1+ (11+ 
(NPROV1RWHWKHVXEVWDQWLDOQHJDWLYHGLIIXVLRQRIDLUGHVSLWHWKH]HUR³GULYLQJIRUFH´
7KHDLULVGUDJJHGDORQJZLWKWKHDPPRQLD7KHVSUHDGVKHHWLVJLYHQEHORZODEHOHGDV'
ILUVWZLWKWKHQXPEHUVDQGWKHQZLWKWKHIRUPXODV

!98$
$
X6$-.@0883 !'4$?4/$Q&?
7O2E'3$:OX83 I$O$YX!
A 8%!/111111111 B$ 8/111111111

0$7:$-$2>, 1/1111#--11 0$7I$-$2>, 1/1111-9"11 0:I$-$2>, 1/1111%H"11

0$7:$ 1/1111!1..1 0$7I 1/111119911 0:I 1/1111!%H11

Y7$FZ+== @1/1111.918"

4+*$N 1/1-1111111 ʌ 1/1"98%"9H9

[7$NO1 1/.81111111 [$:$NO1 1/H"1111111 [$I$NO1 1/111111111

[7$NOɷ 1/.81111111 [:$NOɷ 1/111111111 [I$NOɷ 1/H"1111111
[7$2\F 1/.81111111 [:$2\F 1/8H1111111 [I$2\F 1/8H1111111
ʌȴ[7DɷN 1/111111111 ʌȴ$[:DɷN @H/8".!"9.!H

Y: 1/111-H1#9! G,(*D=
Y7$;2*; @1/1111.918" G,(*D=
;KG$Y7@Y2;2*; 1/111111111
-11111$;KG 1/111111111 M(2*$=++G$>($N+'($
YI @1/1111"-##. ;K2<F+$:-1



X6$-.@0883 !'4$?4/$Q&?
7O2E'3$:OX83 I$O$YX!
A 8%! B$ 8

0$7:$-$2>, 1/1111#-- 0$7I$-$2>, 1/1111-9" 0:I$-$2>, 1/1111%H"

0$7:$ O:%D0! 0$7I O0%D0! 0:I OW%D0!

Y7$FZ+== @1/1111.918%91H!H#"H!9

4+*$N 1/1- ʌ O0!DT1/1"81.%.P:!U

[7$NO1 1/.8 [$:$NO1 1/H" [$I$NO1 O-@:-H@0-H

[7$NOɷ 1/.8 [:$NOɷ O:9P:--D0! [I$NOɷ O-@:-.@0-.
[7$2\F OT:-HV:-.UD8 [:$2\F OT0-HV0-.UD8 [I$2\F OTW-HVW-.UD8
ʌȴ[7DɷN O@0-8PT:-H@:-.UD:-8 ʌȴ$[:DɷN O@0-8PT0-H@0-.UD:-8

Y: OT:-%VT0-#D:"VW-#D0"V:-#D0"UP:-1UDT:-#D:"@:-#D0"U G,(*D=
Y7$;2*; OT0-%VT:-#D:"VW-#DW"V0-#DW"UP:-9UDT0-#D:"@0-#DW"U G,(*D=
;KG$Y7@Y2;2*; O:81@:-1
-11111$;KG O-11111P:8- M(2*$=++G$>($N+'($
YI O@:-9@:81 ;K2<F+$:-1 


!9!$
$
 63(UG6ROXWLRQ0DQXDO&KDSWHU
1HZ 3UREOHPV DQG QHZ VROXWLRQV DUH OLVWHG DV QHZ LPPHGLDWHO\ DIWHU WKH VROXWLRQ QXPEHU 7KHVH QHZ
SUREOHPVDUH$$$&&&'''WR'*
*++&KDSWHUZDVFKDSWHULQWKHQGHGLWLRQ3UREOHPVIURPWKDWHGLWLRQ
KDYHWKHVDPHSUREOHPQXPEHUEXWWKHFKDSWHUQXPEHULVQRZHJSUREOHP'LVQRZ
'
[
& ZDVSUREOHP&LQWKHQGHGLWLRQ (TXLOLEULXP \ 2SHUDWLQJ\ [
  [
\ RXW
G\
Q 2*
6XEVWLWXWHLQIRU\ DQGOHW[ \WRWDOUHIOX[RSHUDWLQJOLQH
\ LQ
\ \
G\ G\
      Q 2* 
\ \ \ \ \
\
  \   \
\ RXW \ RXW
 G\   G\
      Q 2* 
 \ LQ
\ \   \ LQ
\ 

 \ RXW  \ LQ  \ RXW 
      Q 2* Q  Q 
 \ RXW \ LQ \ LQ 
  ZKLFKEHFRPHV(T

& 1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ:LWKH[WUDFWGLVSHUVHG
\ ,1 \ 0287
  ( 0' 
\ ,1 \ 0287

\ 0287
 6LQFH \ ,1  ( 0'
ZKHUH \ 0287 P[ 0287 
\ 0287

 0L[HUPDVVEDODQFHZLWK \ ,1   )[ ,1 6\0287 )[ 0287 

)[ ,1 6\ 0 287

 6ROYLQJIRU [ 0287  [ 0 287 
)
)[ ,1 6\ 0 287
 7KHQ \ 0 287 P 
)
\ 0 287 \ 0 287
  ( 0 '

\ 0 287 P )[ ,1 6\ 0 287
)
( 0 ' P[ ,1
  \ 0 287 
P6
 ( 0'
)

!"#$
$
  ([WHUQDO0% \ ,1  )[ ,1 6\6287 )[ 6287 

\6,1 \6287
  ( 6'
 (TXLO  \ 6287 P[ 6287 
\6,1 \ 6287

6
  6XEVWLWXWLQJ \ 6287 P [ ,1 \6287
) 

\ 6,1 \ 6287 \ 6,1  ( 6' P( 6' [ ,1
  ( 6' \ 6287 
6 P6
\ 6,1 P [ ,1 \ 6287  ( 6'
) )  
( 0' P[ ,1
\ 6,1 \ 0 287
 6XEVWLWXWHLQ P6
 ( 0' DQGGRVRPHDOJHEUDWRREWDLQ
)

P 6
( 0' ( 6'  ( 0' 
)
\ 6287 P [ ,1
  P 6 P 6 
 ( 0'  ( 6'
) )

 7KHGHILQLWLRQRIWKHWRWDOVWDJHHIILFLHQF\LV
[ ' ,1 [ ' 6287 \ ,1 \ 6287 \ 6287
( WRWDO'
ZLWK\ ,1 
  [ ' ,1 [ ' 6287 \ ,1 \ 6287 \ 6287 

6
(TXLOLEULXP \ 6287 P [ ,1 \6287  6XEVWLWXWHLQWRGHILQLWLRQ
)  

\ 6287 \ 6287 [ ,1
( WRWDO'
   6 6 \ 6287 
P [ ,1 \ 6287 P 
) ) [ ,1

:KLFKDIWHUVXEVWLWXWLQJLQ \6287 DQGGRLQJVRPHDOJHEUDEHFRPHV

P 6
( 0' ( 6'  ( 0' 
)
  ( WRWDO 
P 6( 0' P 6( 0' P 6 P 6
  ( 0' ( 6'  ( 0' 
) ) ) )

' ZDVSUREOHP'LQWKHQGHGLWLRQ 7KH FRUUHFWHG YDOXH RI + *( IW LV JLYHQ LQ
([DPSOH)URPWKHUHVXOWVRI([DPSOHVDQGDQGIURP(T

!"%$
$
  
 
      + /(FRU   IW
+ /(,QLWLDO
 
P9
   (TD + 2* + / + * ZKHUH 9 /   
/
  7KHYDOXHRIPWKHVORSHRIWKHHTXLOLEULXPFXUYHYDULHVWKURXJKRXWWKHHQULFKLQJVHFWLRQ
)URP WKH 0F&DEH7KLHOH GLDJUDP XVHG WR SUHSDUH )LJXUH $ YDOXHV RI P ZHUH IRXQG IURP
\  \  WR\ [ '  \  
    
\     
\      
P     
+ 2*      
\ \     
     

\ \

  $ULWKPHWLF$YHUDJH + 2*       


  *HRPHWULF$YHUDJH+ 2*       
     1RGLIIHUHQFH

  7RILQG Q 2* GR6LPSVRQ¶VUXOHLQSDUWVEHFDXVHRIWKHXQXVXDOVKDSHRI  \ \ YV\

    Q 2*       


    Q 2*       

    Q 2* Q 2* Q 2*   K ( + 2* Q 2*  
  7KLVLVUHDVRQDEO\FORVHWRWKHIWHVWLPDWHGLQ([DPSOH

' ZDVSUREOHP'LQWKHQGHGLWLRQD 7KH SK\VLFDO SURSHUWLHV DQG XVH RI )LJXUH 
FDOFXODWHGLQ([DPSOHDUHXQFKDQJHG1RZ) 
 
)  
       * IORRG * IORRG    OE IW  
)  
 
)  
       'LD  'LD   IW 
)  
 E ,Q(T      'FRO  VDPH 
  (VWLPDWH K S a   IW ZH NQRZ LW ZLOO EH OHVV WKDQ EHIRUH 6&9 LV XQFKDQJHG WHUPV LQ
GHQRPLQDWRUDUHXQFKDQJHG   


 KS    
 + * (  
+ * (    IW
 KS    

!"&$
$
  ,Q(T    K S  K S   
   &I / DQG6&/ XQFKDQJHG    
 
 KS   
 + /(  + /(    IW
 KS   

'1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ,QWKHHQULFKLQJVHFWLRQ
 +(73 + 2* OQP9  /  >P9  /  @ DQG + 2* + / P9  / +* 
 :LWK + /  + *  P   /  9       + 2*  DQG+(73 IURP
([DPSOH:LWKWKHVDPHPDVVWUDQVIHUFRHIILFLHQWVEXWP 
 + 2* >    @   DQG +(73  OQ     IW

 $LQFUHDVHLQERWKPDVVWUDQVIHUFRHIILFLHQWVJLYHV + /   DQG
+*   
 )RUP  + 2* >    @   DQG
+(73  OQ>    @  >     @  
 :LWKWKHVDPHPDVVWUDQVIHUFRHIILFLHQWVEXWZLWKP  + 2*  DQG+(73 

 $GHFUHDVHLQERWKPDVVWUDQVIHUFRHIILFLHQWVJLYHV
 )RUP  + /  + *  + 2*  +(73  
 )RUP  + /  + *  + 2*  +(73  

 &OHDUO\WKHYDULDWLRQLQPDVVWUDQVIHUFRHIILFLHQWVUHVXOWVLQDODUJHUDQJHIRU+(73IURPWR
IHHWIRUP ZKLOHWKHVPDOOFKDQJHLQPKDGOLWWOHHIIHFW7REHVDIHWKHODUJHUYDOXH
RI+(73 ZRXOGEHXVHG7KLVLVDVDIHW\IDFWRURI1RWHWKDW%ROOHVDQG)DLU
UHFRPPHQGDVDIHW\IDFWRURIXSWR

 
   
' ZDVSUREOHP'LQWKHQGHGLWLRQ 6LQFHZHKDYHWRWDOUHERLOHU \VLQ  
T 
  )HHGOLQH T    3ORWWKLVDQGRSHUDWLQJOLQHVVHHILJXUH
T 
/ / / / ' 
  7RS \ [  [ ' ZKHUH  
9 9 9  / ' 
/
       \LQWHUFHSW  ['  
'
  %RWWRPJRHVWKURXJK \ [ [%  

!"'$
$
 
G\
       Q*  ZKHUH\ 6RXW \ (LQ  \ (RXW  
\ $, \ $
  )RU HQULFKLQJ VHFWLRQ IURP (T  GUDZ OLQH RI VORSH
/ +* 
  WRJHW \ , DQG[ , )RUVWULSSLQJVHFWLRQVORSHLV
9 +/ 
/ +* 
         
9 +/ 
  )URPILJXUHJHQHUDWHIROORZLQJWDEOH

\$ \$, \$,\$ \$L\$
6WULSSLQJ   
   
   
(QULFKLQJ   
   
    

  6LPSVRQ¶VUXOH Q * 6       K VWULS + * Q *6  IW


  Q * (       K ( +* Q *   IW


' ZDVSUREOHP'LQWKHQGHGLWLRQD 7RWDO5HIOX[ \ RXW  \LQ  

     
  (T Q 2* Q Q 
      

!""$
$
 
      Q 2*  + 2*  

 E )LQLWHUHIOX[3ORWRSOLQH)LQG\ \ VHHJUDSK8VH6LPSVRQ¶VUXOHLQSDUWV

y y* \ \ 
\ \
0.783   16.949 Q 2*
 
    
0.82225   17.467 
0.8615   19.608 $
  
.90075   23.6686 Q 2*     
 Q 2* 
0.94 .973 0.033 30.303
$
 F &KDQJHVLQ/9LQHTXDWLRQFRQQHFWLQJ+(73DQG + 2* 


())$
$
 ()*$
$

' ZDVSUREOHP'LQWKHQGHGLWLRQD  Q 2*    
      + 2* K Q 2*   P 
 E )URP0F&DEH7KLHOHGLDJUDPZHILQGWKHIROORZLQJ
      
\       
\        
\ \       
\ \       
  
 'RLQWHJUDWLRQZLWK6LPSVRQ¶VUXOHLQWKUHHSDUWV  
 
  Q 2*         
 

              

  7KHGLIIHUHQFHLVEHFDXVHRILQDFFXUDFLHVLQ6LPSVRQ¶VUXOH

'ZDVSUREOHP'LQWKHQGHGLWLRQ%RWWRPV [ $  SDUWLDOUHERLOHU   'LVWLOODWH
[$  
  )URPHTXLOLEULXPGDWDLQ'# [ $  HTXLO \  \LQ :LWKWRWDOFRQGHQVHU
\ RXW ['  
\$ [ $
  )LQGDYHUDJH )URPGDWDLQ' \ ZKHQ[  
 \$  [$
   
  %RWWRP   GLVW  
   

  *HRPHWULF$YJ DYJ    
     
  (T Q 2* Q Q  
      
      + 2* K Q 2* P 

' ZDVSUREOHP'LQWKHQGHGLWLRQ  P + 3WRW      

()+$
$
 /   /
  PD[   DFW  %DVLV9 WKHQ/ 
9   9
/
     \ RXW [ LQ [ RXW    
9
/ 
     [ $ RXW    
P9 
  8VH&ROEXUQ(TE
  
  Q 2/ Q    
  
     K   P 
  &DQFKHFNZLWK(TDQGJHWVDPH Q 2/ 

' 1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ
 )RUH[DPSOHLI Q2 ('  ZHKDYHIRUWKHSHUIHFWO\PL[HGPRGHO
(' Q2
 (0'   
 Q2 ('
 )RUWKHSOXJIORZPRGHO
 (0'  H[S Q2 ('   H[S   
 )RUVDPHYDOXHRI Q2 (' WKHSOXJIORZPRGHODOZD\VSUHGLFWVDKLJKHUVWDJHHIILFLHQF\

'ZDVSUREOHP'LQWKH QGHGLWLRQ )RUERWKFRXQWHUFXUUHQWDQGFRFXUUHQW
\ LQ
G\
Q 2*
)RUERWKFDVHV \  DQG\ \ \ WKHQ
\ RXW \ \
\ LQ
G\ \ LQ 
    Q 2* Q Q  
\ RXW
\ \ RXW 
  1RWHWKDW Q 2* LVVDPHEHFDXVHRILUUHYHUVLEOHUHDFWLRQ
 F)ORZUDWHVHQWHULQWRVROXWLRQRQO\DVDFKHFNWKDWDWOHDVWWKHVWRLFKLRPHWULFDPRXQWRIVXOIXULF
DFLGLVDYDLODEOHWRQHXWUDOL]HWKHDPPRQLD

' ZDVSUREOHP'LQWKHQGHGLWLRQ)URP(TZLWKLUUHYHUVLEOHUHDFWLRQ
\ $ LQ SSP
  Q 2* Q Q  IRUERWKFRFXUUHQWDQGFRXQWHUFXUUHQW
\ $ RXW SSP

'D ZDVSUREOHP'LQWKHQGHGLWLRQ  P + S WRW    \ P[ 
/  
      VHH)LJXUH
* PLQ 
/ \ LQ \ RXW
      / * PLQ
 [ RXW  
* / *
  8VH(T \LQ  \ LQ P[ RXW  \RXW  \ RXW 

()!$
$
     \ \   \ \  
LQ RXW

 
     Q 2* Q   K IW 
 

 
E &RFXUUHQW2SHUDWLQJDQGHTXLOLEULXPOLQHVVKRZQLQILJXUH/RZHVW \ RXW LVDWLQWHUVHFWLRQSRLQW
)RU \ RXW      
\ LQ \ RXW  
 [ RXW  \ $RXW P[ RXW  
/ 9 
P 
   8VH(T
/ 9 
  
   Q 2*    
  
       K IW 

'ZDVSUREOHP'LQQGHGLWLRQD6DPHFRQGLWLRQVDV([DPSOH$VVXPHVDPH + 2/ 
  ,IRSHUDWLRQLVSRVVLEOHILQG Q 2*  \ RXW 
   'LOXWH±8VH(TP ([DPSOH
     \ RXW P[ RXW E    
P9   P9 \ LQ \ RXW P9
    Q 2* Q 

/  P9 / \ RXW \ /
 RXW
/
  0DVVEDO   /[ LQ 9\LQ /[ RXW 9\ RXW 
/ /
     \ RXW [ LQ \ LQ [ RXW       
9 9
   P9
     Q 2* Q  
   /
  1RWSRVVLEOHWHUPLQVLGHEUDFNHWVLVQHJDWLYH
 E 6DPHFRQGLWLRQVDV([DPSOHH[FHSW [ RXW  $VVXPHVDPH + 2/ ,IRSHUDWLRQLV
SRVVLEOHWKHQ

()($
$
     \ RXW P[ RXW    
     \ RXW       
  
     Q 2* Q   VWLOOQRWSRVVLEOH
  
 F 6DPHFRQGLWLRQVH[FHSW / 9 DQG[ RXW  

    \ RXW     P9 /    
     \ RXW       
  
     Q 2* Q    
  

'ZDVSUREOHP'LQWKHQGHGLWLRQD 8VH HTXLOLEULXP GDWD VKRZQ LQ )LJXUH 
[  P  [  P  
  0L[HG ( 09  H[S . \ D$ DFWLYH K 9 >(T@ZKHUH 9 $ F DQGE   
9
    7KHQ . \ D Q  ( 09 
K$ DFWLYH

     [  . \ D   Q    ZKHUH    
 

     [  . \ D Q    
  
 P 
  (TD 
. \D N [D N \D
     
  [    [   
 N [D N \D  N [D N \D
  6ROYLQJVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ N [ D  DQG N \ D  
 E [  P  7KHQIURP(TD . \ D    ( 09  IURP(T

'ZDVSUREOHP'LQWKH QGHGLWLRQ$VVXPHIHHGWR([DPSOHLVVDW¶GOLTXLG]  
 
VHSDUDWLRQFRPSOHWH [ ' a  [ % a   [ ) ]  \ I  
  
/   /  
 ['     [ %    
9PLQ   9 PD[
 
/ /
  $W [  \ LQWHUVHFWLRQRSOLQHV [  ['      
9 9
/  
       
9 DFWXDO
 
  &DOFXODWHDW [   LQH[DPSOH    

()#$
$
 [ 6HFW /9 /
P 
(T   
  [ P9
 6WULS   

  
 
 6WULS   

 
 
 (QULFK   

 
 
 (QULFK   

 
 
/ ( 09
  ( P9  FRQVW  &DOFXODWH (SW 6ROYH (T  ( SW Q  
P9 / P9
9
DQGWKHQ . \ D IURP(TD . \ D Q  ( SW 
$ DFWLYH K
[  ( SW  . \D 
  
 Q   

  
 Q   

  
  Q    

  
  Q   

  

'1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ8VLQJ6LPSVRQ¶VUXOHWKHQHZYDOXHIRU$ WKHQHZYDOXH
IRU$ DQGWKHQHZWRWDODUHD 7KHQWKHFDOFXODWHGKHLJKWRIWKHHQULFKLQJVHFWLRQ
P PFRPSDUHGWRWKHSUHYLRXVUHVXOWRIP7KLVLVDQHUURURI
7KXVDUDWKHUVPDOOHUURULQPROHIUDFWLRQVEHFRPHVDODUJHUHUURU

'1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ5HODWLYHHUURUVLQ N * D  
 6DPHUHODWLYHHUURUVLQ + * DQG + /  

 ,QWKHHQULFKPHQWVHFWLRQWKHVORSHRIWKHPDVVWUDQVIHUOLQHLV
 
/ +*   
  6ORSH
9 +/   



()%$
$
 D,I + / FRUUHFWEXW + * YDULHVE\  UDQJHRIVORSHLVIURP WR 
9DOXHDW + *  LVVORSH $WWRS




 ,IHTXLOLEULXPOLQHVWUDLJKWIURPD]HRWURSHWRSRLQW[ \ WKHQFDQILW
WKLVSRUWLRQRIHTXLOLEULXPDV

   \ [  

 07OLQH  \ V[ E 6LQFH \ [   E   V 

 ,I V  E  

 ,I V  E  

 ,I V  E  

 $OOFDOFXODWLRQVDW \ $   \ , DWLQWHUVHFWLRQHTXLOLEULXP \ [  DQG
\ E
PDVVWUDQVIHUOLQH \ V[ E [ 
V


()&$
$
 \, E
 6XEVWLWXWHLQIRU[ \ ,   
V
 6ROYHIRU \ , 
E

  \, V 


  V

   
 \, \, \ \, \
V  E     
V E     
V E    

 LQ ([DPSOH  VLQFH QXPEHUV URXQGHG ILUVW  $PRXQW RI HUURU GHSHQGV RQ
GLVWDQFHEHWZHHQHTXLOLEULXPDQGRSHUDWLQJOLQHV/HVVHUURULIFORVHUEXWPRUHLPSDFW
RQ  \ $, \ , 

 $VVXPHVDPHUHODWLYHHUURUV
  
  + / QRHUURU + * KLJKHU HUURU 
\ $, \$ 
  
+ / QRHUURU + * ORZHU HUURU   
\ $, \$ 
 $VVXPHHUURULQ+LVVDPHHYHU\SRLQW7KXVHQULFKLQJDUHDFDQEHDORWGLIIHUHQWWKDQ
FDOFXODWHG  %XW LI + *  LV GRZQ E\  DUHD LV XS E\  VR WKHUH LV VRPH
FDQFHOODWLRQRIHUURU

 E,I + /  + * ERWKYDU\FRXOGKDYH V  DQG E  7KXV \ ,  

\, \   
\, \
   

 $UHD     6LQFH
 
+ *(  P ] + *( Q *( P ZKLFKLVDLQFUHDVH


' 1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ
 D(TXLOLEULXPLV\ P[9DOXHRIPLVXQNQRZQEXW&H[WUDFW PFRQFXQLWV&UDIILQDWHZLWK

NPRO B %HQ]RLF  P H[WUDFW
PFRQF B XQLWV  :HQHHGPLQ
NPRO B %HQ]RLF  P UDIILQDWH

()'$
$
 PRO %HQ]RLF  PRO H[WUDFW
PPROH IUDFWLRQ XQLWV 7KHUHVXOWLQJFRQYHUVLRQLV
PRO %HQ]RLF  PRO UDIILQDWH
0:H[WUDFW UDIILQDWH
PPROH B IUDFWLRQ B XQLWV PFRQF B XQLWV    
H[WUDFW 0:UDIILQDWH
6LQFHWKHV\VWHPLVGLOXWHH[WUDFWSURSHUWLHVDUHHVVHQWLDOO\WKHVDPHDVSXUHVROYHQWDQG
UDIILQDWHSURSHUWLHVDUHHVVHQWLDOO\WKHVDPHDVGLOXHQW

P  

1RWHWKDW\ ['DQG(0\ (0'

(0\ \LQ\RXW\LQ\RXW ZKHUH\RXW  P[RXW ( 

(0\  

E)URP(TEQ2(' (0\(0\ ± 

.2 D 9PL[HU
Q2 ('
('
 9PL[HU K '        P 
4' ' 0:'
.2 (' D Q2 (' 4' '  9PL[HU 0:' 
  >@ 
 NPRO  VP  PROIUDFGLVS  P GLVSHUVHG  P WRWDOYROXPH
1RWHWKDW . 2 (' D LVODUJHUWKDQLQ([DPSOHEHFDXVHWKHUHVLGHQFHWLPH
9PL[HU
W UHV V LVVKRUWHUWKDQWKHVLQ([DPSOH7KXVWKLVSUREOHP
4 ' 4 &  G
UHTXLUHVPXFKPRUHYLJRURXVPL[LQJ

 F'LIIHUHQWLDO0RGHO ( 0'  H[S Q 2(' 

   H[S Q 2('  ( 0'  

   Q 2(' Q   Q 2('  

.2 (' D Q2 (' 4' '  9PL[HU 0:' 
   >@ 
 NPRO  VP  PROIUDFGLVS  P GLVSHUVHG  P  WRWDOYROXPH

 G8VHRIPL[HGPRGHOV,IXVH . 2 (' D IURPPL[HGVWDJHGPRGHOWKHQ
.2 (' D 9PL[HU
Q2 ('  DQGZLWKGLIIHUHQWLDOPRGHO
4' ' 0:'

()"$
$
 ( 0'  H[S Q 2('  H[S   2EYLRXVO\PL[LQJPRGHOVJLYHV
ZURQJUHVXOWV
 
' 1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ
& ' LQ & ' RXW
 D ( 0' &RQF
ZLWK & 'RXW P&' &&RXW 
& ' LQ & ' RXW

  &'LQ   &'RXW   &&RXW  

  & 'RXW P&' &&RXW  &&RXW  


    ( 0'  

Q2 ( 0'&RQF 
 E ( 0'&RQF ('
Q2 (' 
 Q2 ('  ( 0'&RQF  
.2 (' D Q2 (' 4 ' '  9PL[HU 0:' 
  >@
 NPRO  VP  NPROP   P  GLVSHUVHG  P  WRWDOYROXPH


 F'LIIHUHQWLDO0RGHO
 ( 0'&RQF  H[S Q 2(' ĺ H[S Q 2('  ( 0'&RQF  

   Q 2(' Q   Q 2('  

.2 (' D Q2 (' 4' '  9PL[HU 0:' 
    >@ 
 NPRO  VP  NPROP   P  GLVSHUVHG  P  WRWDOYROXPH
   
 G ( 0'&RQF  H[S Q 2('  H[S  

' 1HZ3UREOHPLQUG(GLWLRQ
 D (T7HUPV G   !EHQ]RLFZDWHU     &
     
&! $ &

IURP([DPSOH
 
GL  
    
J 
  1RWH 1 LQUSV

(*)$
$
 GL 
 
GS 
 
GS 
   
G WDQN 
' G SJ   
   


    
  N&    

   
   [   
 

 6LJQLILFDQWO\KLJKHU%XW1RWH G  VRFRUUHODWLRQPD\QRWEHYDOLG6DPH
  
 :LWKVDPH N G   
. /' N' P &' N &
  
   
. /'  


  . /'  . /' D V  
  . 2(' D     

  ( 0'  ZKLFKDJUHHVZLWKJXHVVIRUUHVLGHQFHWLPH


 E  5HVLVWDQFHGLVSHUVHG  


  5HVLVWDQFHFRQWLQXRXV  

  6XPRIUHVLVWDQFHV   *LYHV. /'    
  UHVLVWDQFHIURPGLVSHUVHG     
  7KLVLVDVLJQLILFDQWFRQWULEXWLRQEHFDXVHRIVLJQLILFDQWO\KLJKHUSUHGLFWHG
FRQWLQXRXVSKDVHPDVVWUDQVIHUFRHIILFLHQW
 F ,I N ' LVLJQRUHG  . /' N & P &'    
  1RWHWKDWWKLVLVVLJQLILFDQWO\WRRKLJK
 G 7REHVDIHXVHORZHUHVWLPDWHRI ( 0'  1RWHWKDW G LVUHDOO\WRRODUJHIRUXVHRI
(T

' 1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ,QVHWWOHUYHORFLW\DSSURDFKHV]HUR
  X W  LQ([DPSOHEXW G S  QRWDVVXPHG7KXV
X W a   P V DQG(TDLVUHDVRQDEOHDSSUR[LPDWLRQ
  6K & N & G !EHQ]RLFZDWHU  ZKHUHLQVHWWOHU G  

(**$
$
 
  N&        

  8VLQJ . /' a N & P&'         P V 
  ,IWKHLQWHUIDFHLQWKHVHWWOHULVDWWKHFHQWHUOLQHWKHQWKHYROXPHRIDTXHRXVSKDVHLV

' 6  / 6  )URP([DPSOH '6 P DQG /6 '6  7KHQ9ROXPH

DTXHRXV SKDVH P  7KHZDWHUUHVLGHQFHWLPHLV
 P  P V V (QWHULQJWRWDOYHORFLW\LV  P V DQG

G  OHDYLQJPL[HU$GURSWKDWVWDUWVDWWKHERWWRPRIWKHZDWHUSKDVHWUDYHOVD
YHUWLFDOGLVWDQFHRI '6   PWRUHDFKWKHLQWHUIDFH7KLVUHTXLUHV
 P  P V V 
  $VVXPHHTXDOGLVWULEXWLRQRIGURSV(YHU\WKLQJKDOIWKHGURSVDERYHLQWHUIDFHDUH
FROOHFWHGYHU\TXLFNO\$OOGURSVFROOHFWHGLQ    IUDFWLRQRIVHWWOHU
,IDYHUDJHRYHUWKLVIUDFWLRQLV  G,1  WKHQ 'DYJ     
  
D G
 DQG . /' D VHWWOHU
a  
GS 
  . 2(' D . /' D 0:'    
VHWWOHU ' VHWWOHU 
9VHWWOHU 4 '    
  Q 2('VHWWOHU  
   
  6LQFHVHWWOHULVQRWZHOOPL[HG ( VHWWOHU'  H[S   
  7KLVLVKLJKEHFDXVHRIORQJUHVLGHQFHWLPH

' 1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ
\ 0287 \6287 \ ,1 \ 0 287 \ 0 287
D  ( 6'
  ( 0'
 
\ 0287 \ 6287 \ ,1 \ 0 287 \ 0 287
   \ 0287 P[ UDI 287  
 )URP([DPSOHLQPROHIUDFWLRQXQLWV P 
 0L[HUPDVVEDODQFHZLWK \ ,1  ([DPSOHLV )[ ) 6\ 0287 )[ &287 

  ,Q([DPSOHIHHGLV  P V DQGVROYHQWLV  P V 
 
 6  P V  NJ P  NJ NPRO  NPRO V 
   )  P V  NJ P  NJ NPRO NPRO V 

   [ 0 287 [ IHHG 6 ) \ 287  \ 287 

  7KHQVXEVWLWXWHLQWR ( 0' 
\ 0 287
    
  \ 0 287

(*+$
$

  6ROYLQJZHREWDLQ \ 0287  
 
 [ 0287 \ 0287 P( 0'    (  
  )RUVHWWOHU \ 6287 P[ 6287 
 6HWWOHU0%LV 6\ 0287 )[ 0287 6\6287 )[ 6287 
6
   [ 6287 [ 0 287 \ 6287 \ 0 287 
)
   [ 6287 (   \6287  
  6XEVWLWXWHLQWRHTXDWLRQIRU ( 6' 
 
 \6287
  
  (   \ 6287
  6ROYLQJZHREWDLQ \6287  
  )URP0DVV%DODQFH
 
 [ 6287 (     (  
   \
6287 P[ 6287  (   
\6287 
   ( 7RWDO'
 
\ 6287 
P6 
 E )URP&   
) 
( 7RWDO'
     

            
 


*DQG*1HZSUREOHPVLQ&KDSWHU$VSHQ3OXVUXQVVKRZHGWKDW1 $VSHQ3OXV
QRWDWLRQZLWKIHHGRQ1IHHG RSWLPXPORFDWLRQJDYHHWKDQROPROHIUDFWLRQVRI[' 
DQG[% 7KHVHYDOXHVDUHZLWKLQWKHVSHFLILHGWROHUDQFHV7KHVWULSSLQJVHFWLRQVWDUWV
ZLWKWKHYDSRUOHDYLQJWKHUHERLOHU\LQVWULS \UHE DQGHQGVDWWKHLQWHUVHFWLRQRIWKHWZR
RSHUDWLQJOLQHV7KLVODVWYDOXHFDQEHGHWHUPLQHGE\FDOFXODWLQJWKHSRLQWVRQWKHRSHUDWLQJOLQHV
[Q\Q)RUH[DPSOHQ [DQG\DUHRQWKHHQULFKLQJVHFWLRQRSHUDWLQJOLQH:KHQWKH
VORSHFKDQJHVIURPLQWKHWRSWRLQWKHERWWRPWKHLQWHUVHFWLRQSRLQWKDVEHHQSDVVHG
7KLVRFFXUVIRU\RXWVWULS \ 

 7KHPROHIUDFWLRQVRIHWKDQROLQWKHOLTXLGDQGYDSRUOHDYLQJHDFKVWDJH$VSHQVWDJHQRWDWLRQLV
XVHGDUH


(*!$
$
 6WDJH [   \     (TXLOLEULXP&DOFXODWLRQP
    
     7KHHTXLOLEULXPSDUDPHWHUPLVWKHDYHUDJHVORSHRIWKH
     HTXLOLEULXPFXUYHIURP[FDOFXODWHGDW\WR[,
     $WWKHUHERLOHU\ IRU[ DQG\  
     IRU[RSHU 7KHQ\DYJ 
     7KHVORSHFDQEHGHWHUPLQHGE\WDNLQJWKHFKRUGIURP
     [ \ WR[ \ 
     P ± 
     7KHHTXLOLEULXPYDOXHVDUHIURP$QDO\VLVLQ$VSHQ3OXV
     $W\RXWVWULS [RSHU \ DQG
     \DYJ P ±±
     RUP 
    

 7RXVH6LPSVRQ¶VUXOHIRUWKHILUVWLQWHJUDOLQ(TDZHDOVRQHHGDQDYHUDJHPIRUWKH\
DQG\ YDOXHVFDOFXODWHGDWWKHDYHUDJHEHWZHHQ\LQVWULSDQG\RXWVWLSZKLFKLV\ $WWKLV\
[RS GHWHUPLQHGIURPWKHVWULSSLQJVHFWLRQRSHUDWLQJOLQHDQG\ 7KHDYHUDJH
EHWZHHQ\DQG\  P ±± 7KHVHFRQGLQWHJUDO
LQ(TDLVWKHXVXDOHVWLPDWLRQIURP6LPSVRQ¶VUXOHRIWKHQ2*LQWHJUDO

\ $ RXW

+* G\ $   \ $ \ $  ±>±

\ $ LQ

    ±@ P


 7KHILUVWLQWHJUDOLQ(TDFDQDOVREHHVWLPDWHGIURP6LPSVRQ¶VUXOH

\ $ RXW

   + /   /  9  PG\ $   \ $ \ $  ^>±@î

\ $ LQ

   >@` 


 7KHQK  PZKLFKLVVRPHZKDWPRUHWKDQWKHPFDOFXODWHGLQ
([DPSOH1RWHWKDWWKH$VSHQ3OXVFDOFXODWLRQGRHVQRWDVVXPH&02ZKHUHDVWKH
FDOFXODWLRQLQ([DPSOHGLGEXWWKHFDOFXODWLRQKHUHUHTXLUHGDQDVVXPSWLRQRIKRZWR
FDOFXODWHP7KXVLWLVGLIILFXOWWRVD\ZKLFKLVPRUHDFFXUDWH

*1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ
 (QULFKLQJVHFWLRQ\LQHQULFK \RXWVWULS DQG\RXWHQULFK [' [ $W\LQHQULFK 
\RXWVWULS WKHFDOFXODWLRQRIPLVWKHVDPHDVGRQHSUHYLRXVO\IRU\RXWVWULS[RSHU 
\ DQG\DYJ P ±± 
 $W\RXWHQULFK [' [ \  DQG\DYJ P ± 


 ,Q([DPSOHWKHHQULFKLQJVHFWLRQLQWHJUDWLRQZDVGRQHZLWK6LPSVRQ¶VUXOHLQWZRSDUWV
)URP\LQHQULFKWR\ DQGIURP\ WR\RXWHQULFK)RUWKHFDOFXODWLRQKHUHZHZLOOXVH\ 
ZKLFKLVLQWKHWDEOHRIGDWDIURP$VSHQ3OXVDVDFRQYHQLHQWEUHDNPROHIUDFWLRQWRGR
WKHLQWHJUDWLRQLQWZRSDUWV)RU\ [RSHU \ DQGWRILQGP\DYJ 
P ± 

(*($
$
 
 7KHDYHUDJH\IURP\LQHQULFK WR\ LV[RSHU \  
DQGWRILQGP\DYJ P ± 

 )RUWKHQGLQWHJUDOLQ(TDLQWHJUDWHGIURP\LQHQULFK WR\ ZHREWDLQ
 
\ $ RXW

+* G\ $   \ $ \ $  >@>

\ $ LQ

@ P

 6DPHLQWHJUDOLQWHJUDWHGIURP\ WR\RXWHQULFK 7KHDYHUDJH\IURP\ 
WR\RXWHQULFK LV[RSHU \  DQGWRILQGP\DYJ P
± 

>@>@ 

 7RWDOIRULQWHJUDO P

 )RUILUVWLQWHJUDOIURP\LQHQULFK WR\ ZHREWDLQ

\ $ RXW

 + /   /  9  PG\ $   \ $ \ $  >±@>

\ $ LQ

@ 


 6DPHLQWHJUDOLQWHJUDWHGIURP\ WR\RXWHQULFK 

\ $ RXW

  + /   /  9  PG\ $   \ $ \ $  >@>

\ $ LQ

@ 


 7RWDOIRULQWHJUDO P

 7RWDOKHLJKWRIHQULFKLQJVHFWLRQ  P
 7RWDOKHLJKWRISDFNLQJ IURP* P
 7KLVLVOHVVWKDQWKHWRWDORIPFDOFXODWHGLQ([DPSOH+RZHYHULWGRHVDJUHH
UHDVRQDEO\ZHOOZLWKWKHQXPEHURIVWDJHVLQWKHFROXPQVLQFH
  î+(73HVWLPDWHG PLQ([DPSOH 

 %RWKWKLVUHVXOWDQG([DPSOHUHTXLUHFDOFXODWLQJDVPDOOGLIIHUHQFHDQGWKHQWDNLQJWKH
LQYHUVHRIWKLVQXPEHU7KLVW\SHRIFDOFXODWLRQFDQFDXVHYHU\VLJQLILFDQWHUURUV7KHJUDSKLFDO
FDOFXODWLRQZDVEDVHGRQDFFXUDWHH[SHULPHQWDOPHDVXUHPHQWVRIWKHHTXLOLEULXPGDWDDQGWKLV
GDWDLVSUREDEO\PRUHDFFXUDWHWKDQWKH157/FRUUHODWLRQXVHGLQWKHFRPSXWHU2QWKHRWKHU
KDQGFDOFXODWLRQHUURUVDUHSUREDEO\ODUJHULQWKHJUDSKLFDOWKDQLQWKHFRPSXWHUFDOFXODWLRQ

 %RWKFDOFXODWLRQVGHSHQGVLJQLILFDQWO\RQWKHDFFXUDF\RIWKHPDVVWUDQVIHUGDWD+/DQG+*
ZKLFKFDQHDVLO\KDYHHUURUVJUHDWHUWKDQZKLFKFDQFDXVHHYHQODUJHUHUURUVLQFDOFXODWLRQ
RI178DQG+78RULQ+(73VHHSUREOHP'IRUWKHVWDJHGFDOFXODWLRQ

(*#$
$

* 1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ
 3DUWE(TXLOLEULXPVWDJHRSWLPXP/'PLQ /' 1 1) VHFWLRQ\&GLVW
[&ERW 'LD PRQSODWHPLQLPXPGLDPHWHU PRQWUD\


 3DUWF93/8*RSWLPXP1 1) \&GLVW [&ERW 'LD P
RQSODWH'&EDFNXSWUD\VSDFLQJ ZHLUORDGLQJ PV1RWHWKDWWKLVVHSDUDWLRQ
LVEHWWHUWKDQWKHHTXLOLEULXPUHVXOW

 3DUWG0,;('RSWLPXP1 1) \&GLVW [&ERW 'LD PRQ
SODWH'&EDFNXSWUD\VSDFLQJ ZHLUORDGLQJ PV1RWHWKDWWKLVVHSDUDWLRQ
UHTXLUHVLJQLILFDQWO\PRUHVWDJHVWKDQERWKWKHHTXLOLEULXPVWDJHDQGWKHSOXJIORZUHVXOWV

+DQG+1HZSUREOHPVLQUGHGLWLRQ)LWIRUWKHHWKDQROZDWHU9/(ZDVGRQHLQ$SSHQGL[%RI
&KDSWHU7KHVSUHDGVKHHWIRUERWKSUREOHPVLVJLYHQEHORZZLWKD\YDOXHFKRVHQLQWKH
HQULFKLQJVHFWLRQLJQRUHWKHVWULSSLQJVHFWLRQRSHUDWLQJOLQHYDOXHV2YHUDOOPDVVEDODQFHVWR
ILQG'DQG%ZHUHGRQHZLWK(TVDQG/DQG9ZHUHGHWHUPLQHGDWWKHWRWDO
FRQGHQVHUDQGIORZVLQWKHVWULSSLQJVHFWLRQZHUHGHWHUPLQHGDWWKHIHHGVWDJHZLWKWKHFDOFXODWHG
YDOXHRIT/EDU /T)7KHLQWHUVHFWLRQSRLQWRIWKHWZRRSHUDWLQJOLQHVZDVGHWHUPLQHG
IURP(T\UHELVWKHVWDUWRIWKHVWULSSLQJVHFWLRQDQGLVWKH\YDOXHLQHTXLOLEULXP\HT
ZLWK\ [ [%,QWKHVWULSSLQJVHFWLRQWKHYDOXHRI\HT±\ZDVGHWHUPLQHGDWWKHVWDUWRIWKH
VWULSSLQJVHFWLRQ\UHEDWWKHHQGRIWKHVWULSSLQJVHFWLRQ\LQWHUVHFWLRQDQGDWWKHDYHUDJHRIWKHVH
WZRYDOXHV7KHQ6LPSVRQ¶VUXOHZDVXVHGWRFDOFXODWHQ2*VWULS IURP(TE7R
GHWHUPLQH+2*IURP(TDDQDYHUDJHVORSHPRIWKHHTXLOLEULXPFXUYHLVUHTXLUHG7KH
VORSHRIWKHFKRUGIURPWKHHTXLOLEULXP\DWWKHLQWHUVHFWLRQSRLQWRIWKHWZRRSHUDWLQJOLQHVWRWKH
UHERLOHUYDSRUWKDWLVLQHTXLOLEULXPZLWK[% PVWULS  \ HT  [LQW HU VHF WLRQ \ UHERLOHU   [LQW HUVHF WLRQ [ %
DQG+2*VWULS 7KHUHVXOWLQJKHLJKWRIWKHVWULSSLQJVHFWLRQIHHWLVVRPHZKDW
PRUHWKDQWKHIHHWGHWHUPLQHGLQ([DPSOH

 ,QWKHHQULFKLQJVHFWLRQDVLPLODUSURFHGXUHZDVXVHGH[FHSWWKHLQWHJUDWLRQWRILQGQ2*HQULFKZDV
GRQHLQWZRSDUWV7KHDYHUDJHVORSHRIWKHHTXLOLEULXPFXUYHZDVGHWHUPLQHGIURP
PHQULFK  \ \HTXLOLEULXP [LQW HUVHF WLRQ   [ ' [LQW HUVHF WLRQ ZLWK \ [' 7KHUHVXOWLQJ
YDOXHRI+2*HQULFK 7KHUHVXOWLQJKHLJKWRIWKHHQULFKLQJVHFWLRQIHHWLVVRPHZKDW
PRUHWKDQWKHIHHWGHWHUPLQHGLQ([DPSOHDQGPRUHWKDQWKHIHHWGHWHUPLQHGLQ
SUREOHP'

 1RWHLQERWK+DQG+WKHDYHUDJHVORSHRIWKHHTXLOLEULXPFXUYHPKDVWREHFDOFXODWHG
ZLWKIDLUO\ODUJHFKRUGVQRWE\WDNLQJWKHGHULYDWLYHRIWKHWKRUGHUSRO\QRPLDOILWWRWKH9/(
7KHUHDVRQLVWKDWWKHILWRVFLOODWHVDURXQGWKHH[SHULPHQWDOGDWDSRLQWVDQGWKHVORSHVZLOO
IOXFWXDWHJUHDWO\


(*%$
$
  
$

(*&$
$
 63(UG(GLWLRQ6ROXWLRQ0DQXDO&KDSWHU

1HZ 3UREOHPV DQG QHZ VROXWLRQV DUH OLVWHG DV QHZ LPPHGLDWHO\ DIWHU WKH VROXWLRQ QXPEHU 7KHVH QHZ
SUREOHPV DUH $ $$ % &' ' '' 'EK '
'(++&KDSWHUZDVFKDSWHULQWKHQGHGLWLRQ3UREOHPVIURPWKDW
HGLWLRQKDYHWKHVDPHSUREOHPQXPEHUEXWWKHFKDSWHUQXPEHULVQRZHJSUREOHP'LV
QRZ')LJXUHVLQWKHVROXWLRQVWRWKHVHROGSUREOHPVVWLOOKDYHWKHGHVLJQDWLRQRIFKDSWHU


$1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ&KDQJHWKHYDOXHRIWKHWDWRWLQWKHVSUHDGVKHHWXQWLOWKHDUHDPDWFKHV
WKHGHVLUHGYDOXH7KLVFDQEHGRQHDVDPDQXDOWULDODQGHUURURUDORRSFDQEHDGGHGWRWKHVSUHDGVKHHW

$1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ3DUWD,QFUHDVHWKHVWLUUHUVSHHG
,IQRJHOLQFUHDVLQJVWLUULQJLQFUHDVHVPDVVWUDQVIHUFRHIILFLHQWNZKLFKUHGXFHV0DQGKHQFH[ZLV
UHGXFHG7KLVUHGXFHV[SLQFUHDVLQJUHWHQWLRQ5
3DUWE'HFUHDVHWKHVWLUUHUVSHHG7KLVUHGXFHVNLQFUHDVHV0DQG[Z:KHQ[Z![JHODJHOIRUPVDQG
5LQFUHDVHVSUREDEO\WRO
!
$1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ6LQFHWKHUHLVDJHOWKHUHWHQWLRQRIWKHORZPROHFXODUZHLJKW
FRPSRXQGDOVRLQFUHDVHV

$1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ'RQRWLQYHVW2VPRWLFSUHVVXUHFDQRIWHQEHLJQRUHGLQ8)EHFDXVH
ZLWKODUJHPROHFXOHVZLWKKLJKPROHFXODUZHLJKWWKHPROHIUDFWLRQLVDOZD\VORZHYHQLIWKHZHLJKW
IUDFWLRQLVKLJK:LWKORZPROHIUDFWLRQWKHRVPRWLFSUHVVXUHLVORZ,IWKHUHLVDFRQFHQWUDWHGVDOWZLWKD
ORZPROHFXODUZHLJKWWKHPROHIUDFWLRQZLOOEHKLJKDQGWKHRVPRWLFSUHVVXUHFDQQRWEHLJQRUHG


% /RRNDW6XN'(DQG0DWVXXUD7µ0HPEUDQHEDVHGK\EULGSURFHVVHVDUHYLHZ¶6HS
6FL7HFKQRO9ROSS±IRUDGGLWLRQDOSURFHVVHV

%1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ2QHSRVVLEOHDSSURDFKLVDVIROORZV,QFUHDVHVWLUULQJWRLQFUHDVHWKH
PDVVWUDQVIHUFRHIILFLHQWDQGUHGXFHWKHZDOOFRQFHQWUDWLRQWRSUHYHQWJHOIRUPDWLRQ7KHQXVHDSHUPHDWH
LQVHULHVFDVFDGHZLWKUHF\FOHRIWKHUHWHQWDWHIURPWKHVHFRQGPRGXOHLQVHULHVEDFNWRWKHIHHGRIWKH
ILUVWPRGXOH7KHORZPROHFXODUZHLJKWSURGXFWLVWKHSHUPHDWHIURPWKHVHFRQGPRGXOH7KH
LQWHUPHGLDWHPROHFXODUZHLJKWSRO\SHSWLGHSURGXFWLVWKHUHWHQWDWHIURPWKHILUVWPRGXOH


FF 673 FP
'    3&2      W P    P 
FP  VFP+J
           SU S+ DWP   FP+J 

    3&+       S3 S/ DWP FP+J 
    3&2 3&+    
$%
Ö &2 Ö &+   S S S U   
 

 D *HQHUDWH57FXUYHIURP(TD
SS
\S   \3 
SU \ 3  \ 3
    \U 
$% $%  \3 \ 3




RT Curve 
\3  \U  2S(T)3 ),1  

    )3 ),1 \ ,1
\3 \ RXW
   )3 ),1 )3 ),1
   \3 \ RXW \ ,1  &2  PROHIUDF
    
   6ORSH 


  3ORWWZRDUELWUDU\SRLQWV
   \ RXW  \ 3   
   \ RXW  \ 3    
  
  
  
1.0  $QVZHUIURPJUDSK \ 3  \ RXW  &2  FRQF
3&2
     - &2 SU \U S3 \3      E
W PV

  FF673FP FF673
- &2  
FP+J  FP+J  
  FP FP VFP+J FP  V
)3 JPROH KU JPRO
)3  
),1 K V V
FF673 / JPROH
- &2   
(  JPROH VFP  
FP V FF /673
)3 \ 3&2 
$UHD     FP 
- &2 
)3
 )3 )LQ NJPROHKU  )RXW )LQ )3   NJPROHKU
)LQ
 E )LQ NJPROHKU 
 
  )3 )3SDUW D   )3   )RXW )LQ )3    )LQ  
 
  6WDJH )3 )LQ     \LQ   
  57FXUYHLVXQFKDQJHG
  
  2S/LQH6ORSH  
 
  )LQGDUELWUDU\SRLQWVWRSORWOLQH

  ,I \ RXW   \ S  RIIJUDSK




  ,I \ RXW  \ S     
  ,I  \ RXW  \ S     
    $QVZHUIURPJUDSK \ 3  \ RXW  \LQ 
)3   \ LQ 
  6WDJH     
)LQ   )3 )LQ 
 
   6ORSH  3ORWFXUYH

    $QVZHU \ 3  \RXW   VHHJUDSK 
   6WDJH 
   FP  673
- &2       
   FP V
/  PRO
     -&2  - &2  (  
FF  FP V
PRO K
     )3    PRO V 
K V
)3 
    $UHD  P  
-&2  

  FP  673
  6WDJH- &2   
     
  FP V
/  PRO
     -&2   - &2  
(  
FP  FP V
OK
    )3    PRO K  PRO V 
V
)3  \ 3 
    $UHD    FP  P  
-&2  
  ,WLVLQWHUHVWLQJWRFRPSDUHSDUWVDDQGE

3DUW DVWDJH$UHD P 
\ RXW&2  RU&+ 
\ 3&2  
  
3DUW EVWDJH7RWDO$UHD P 
\ RXW RU&+ 
\ 3 \ 3 



  )3 )LQ \ LQ
' D \ 3 \ RXW  \ 3 \ RXW \ LQ  &2   )3 )LQ 
)3 )LQ )3 )LQ
 
  6ORSH  :KHQ \ RXW  \ 3  
 



 \ LQ 
  :KHQ \ 3  \ RXW  
 )3 )LQ 
  57FXUYHLVVDPHDVLQ3UREOHP'
  'UDZRSOLQH)URPJUDSK \ 3&2  \ U \ RXW&2  
3$ S U \ U S3 \3
 E   - &2 
W PV
 

  FP  673FP FP+J
 - &2  DWP    DWP 
   FP FP VFP+J DWP
FP  673 )3 PRO
    - &2   
 )3 )LQ  
FP V )LQ V
PRO V  FP  673
  $ 
  FP  
PRO FP 673 /673

/673 FP V
  2U P   9HU\VHQVLWLYHWR \ 3  \ U YDOXHV
)3
 &DQDOVRFDOFXODWH - - &2  - &+  $
Ö- 
&KHFN )LQ )3 )RXW    )RXW )RXW  
  )LQ [ LQ )3 \ 3 )RXW \ RXW          2.




'
1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ6LQFHQRFRQFHQWUDWLRQSRODUL]DWLRQ [ Z [U [ RXW 
. VROY
- VROY SU SS D [U [S
W PV 
- VROY . VROY
6ROYHIRU SU SS D [U [ S    - VROY  
. VROY W PV W PV
[S
  5  [S  5 [ RXW  5  
[ RXW
 [)
DQG0% [S    [ )  

[)  
 7KHQ [ RXW  
 
 5  

  [S  5 [ RXW  

 7KHQ SU       DWP

'3DUWLDOO\QHZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ



 [Z   JP 
 D 0 H[S  - VROY  VROY  N H[S 
 
[U  
 [3 0[U [3
  
[3 SU S3 0[U [3 D
 (    (  
   
(       (   DWP
. VROY - VROY  J
 

W PV SU SS D 0[U [3    (   P VDWP

.$ . VROY
  6LQFH  . VROY . $  . $ . VROY DQG 
W PV W PV
J

.$ P VDWP  J  
   
W PV DWP  P V
 F :ULWH(TDIRUROGDQGQHZVLWXDWLRQV±'LYLGHQHZE\ROG2EWDLQ

QHZ
    N QHZ N ROG (YHU\WKLQJHOVHGLYLGHVRXW6LQFH  USP 
ROG


    N QHZ N ROG P  V 

. VROY - VROY    J 
' D 
   J FP  V DWP 
W PV SU S3 FP V DWP
 )3 )LQ [ LQ
  57HT 5  [ 3 [ RXW 2SHT [ 3  [ RXW
)3 )LQ )3 )LQ
  6ROYHVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ REWDLQ(TZKLFKZLWK0 LV
 5 [ LQ   [3
  [3   [ RXW  
 5     5
 [3 [U [3
     
[ 3 SU S3 [U [3 D
   
 DWP  
    
 E 3ORWWKH57FXUYHDQGRSHUDWLQJOLQH
[3 [3 D  SU S3   [ LQ
  [U  [ 3 [U 
0  D   [ 3
  6HHJUDSK,QWHUVHFWLRQRFFXUVDW [ U  [ 3  
. VROY
    - VROY SU S3 D 0 [ U [3 
W PV



 

    J J
- VROY 
DWP DWP     
FP V DWP FP  V
)3  [ 3  
$  )3 )LQ  NJ V  NJ V 
- VROY  

 NJ V     J NJ
   $  
   FP  P  
  J FP V
'  (TFDQEHZULWWHQDV - VROY  VROY N Q[ J Q[ U 
  3ORW - VROYHQW YV  Q[ U 6ORSH NDQGLQWHUFHSW N Q[ J  
FP ZWIUDF 
- VROY  VROY
 [U  Q[ U 
PLQ GH[WUDQ
  
  
  
  
  6HH)LJXUH3ORW - VROY  VROY - VROY YHUVXVOQ[U
,QWHUFHSW 
    Q[ J  ZKLFKLV[ J  
6ORSH 

. VROY - VROY  J

'  6WLUUHGFHOOGDWD F3 J /   
W PV S  P V EDU 
/
- VROY - VROY  VROY    J  /    
P V EDU
  



  - $ a - VROY F 3    J P  V $OVR - $ 0 F FRXW  5 F - VROY 
-$ 
  :LWK 0F   5 F  ĺ 5 F  
F RXW - VROY  
  6SLUDO:RXQG -$ - VR O Y F 3 0 F FRXW  5 F - VROY 
F3 
  6ROYLQJIRU 0 F  
F RXW  5 F  
. VROY
     - VROY S   J  P V 
W PV
  6LQFHRVPRWLFSUHVVXUHLVLJQRUHG 0 F GRHVQRWHIIHFWVROYHQWIOX[LQ8)

3S
\S +H +    \S 
UG
3U
'1HZSUREOHPLQ HGLWLRQ)URPE \ U+H  
 \ 3 +H

 
  +H +  3+H 3+    S S S U 
   
    
   \ U+H  
   

3S
\ 3+ +  +H   \ 3+ 

3U       
&KHFN \ U+ 

 \ 3+   
+  +H +  +H  
\ U+H  \ U+ 2. 


   \ )+H \ URXW +H  

7KHQ  
\ 3+H \ U +H  
E 8VHVROXWLRQLQ(TVWRH
SS 
D     
 SU 
SS \ )+H   
E      
SU     

F \ )+H      

E E DF     

 \3 
D   

0XVWXVHPLQXVVLJQWRKDYHSRVLWLYH \ S  \ 3+H  




 \ )+H 
  \ U+H \ 3+H    
  
SS SS
F6ROYH57HTEIRU \ S  \ U \U  \S  \ S   \S 
SU SU
SS SS
     \ S  \U   \S \U 
SU SU
F
E
D

SS
 D     
SU
SS
 E   \U        
SU
 F \U    
E E DF  
 \S  
D 
\ )+H \ U+H  
 8VHVLJQIRUSRVLWLYH \ S   
\ 3+H \ U+H  
G )RU3DUW$ ),1 P 673  K   \ +H,1    \ + ,1  
\ U+  \ U+H  \ S+   \ S+    
 
3+  $
8VHDZULWWHQDV  )3 \ 3+ SU \U SS \S 

WPV
     )3 ),1 P 673 K 
  
P  673 FP  K FP  673
 )3  
K P V V

FP  673
)3 \ 3+ WPV      FP
 $  V 
3+  3U \ U+  3S \ 3+   FP  673 FP
      FP+J
FP V FP+J
    $ FP  P  
' D 3ORWWKHGDWDRQDVHPLORJSORWLQWKHIRUPRI - VROY  VROY - VROY /  P  K 




 [U
- VROY N Q  N Q[ J N Q[ U  ,QWHUFHSW N Q[ J 
[J

/ P
  )URPJUDSK VORSH N  DQG N  
 
P K V
  :KHQ [ U  - VROY  VROY - VROY  / P  K J  P V N Q[ J 
 J P V
    Q[ J  [J 
 P  V

7KHYDOXHRI[JLVYHU\VHQVLWLYH

E 7KHUHLVRQO\RQHSRLQWIXUWKHURXWRQWKHƐQD[LV$Q\HUURULQSRLQWLVJUHDWO\DPSOLILHGLQWKH
OHDVWVTXDUHVUHJUHVVLRQ+HQFHDQRWKHUSRLQWLQWKLVUHJLRQZRXOGEHPRVWXVHIXO7KHKLJKHU
WKHFRQFHQWUDWLRQWKHEHWWHU

'D1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ 6ROYH57HTDQGRSHTVLPXOWDQHRXVO\
 SS  
  D    
  SU  
SS \1     
    E     
SU       
    F \LQ      

    
    \S  XVHPLQXVVLJQWRKDYH\SEHWZHHQ
 
DQG



     
   \S  
 
\ ,1  
   )URPRSHT \ U \S   
   
3$ $ Ö $
  E 6LQFH )ÖS \ S$ SU \U SS \S 
W PV
)Ö S \ S$ W PV
    $ Ö
6LQFH ) PRO V  )ÖS )Ö,1  PRO V 
,1
3$ Ö $ S U \ U SS \S
PRO
     FP
V
$ 
 FP 673 FP  / 673
  
    FP V FP +J /673   FP  673 

PRO
FP+J
      DWP
DWP
    $   FP  

)Ö S \ S$ W PV
  F  $  )Ö S )Ö ,1  PRO V 
3$ Ö $ S U \ U SS \
PRO
     FP
V
$


FP 673 FP /673 /673 FP+J
  
    DWP
FP V FP +J PRO   FP 673 DWP

$   FP 
[ ,1 
'1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ [S VLQFH5   [ RXW  
 
*HOOLQJRFFXUVDWDVROYHQWIOX[RI - VROY /P  GD\  ZKLFKLV
/ J GD\ J
- VROY - VROY VROY  
  
P GD\ /  V PV
J  P  V J  P 
7KHQ [ JHO [ RXW H[S - VROY  VROY  N H[S  
   P  V

3+H
'1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ S S  S U    +H +   8VH(TE
3+  



 S 
\ S +H +H +    \S       
SU 
 \ U +H  
 \S    
\ )+H \ U+(  
(TF  
\ S +H \ U+H  
  
'1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ 1D&O [ LQ  FXW  SHUIHFWO\PL[HG
 5 [Q
 5HMHFWLRQ [S  
 5
D ,I [ S     ZKDW YDOXH 5 UHTXLUHG  )LQG 5 LQFOXGLQJ FRQFHQWUDWLRQ
SRODUL]DWLRQHIIHFW)URP(T [ S [S5 [ ,1 5[ ,1 ZKLFKJLYHV
[ ,1 [S  
  5 [ ,1 [S [ ,1 [ S ĺ 5  
[ ,1 [S   
[ ,1 [S  
E ,I [ S     5  
[ ,1 [S   
F ,I5ƒLQKHUHQWUHMHFWLRQFRHIILFLHQWZLWK0 IRUSDUWELV 5  ZKDWZDVYDOXHRI
0WKDWJDYH 5  
0 &DVH% 0$ 
5 &DVH %   5 &DVH$  /HW$EHKLJKO\VWLUUHG 
0 &DVH$ 5$ 5

0 &DVH$  5 &DVH%   
  0 &DVH% 
 5 &DVH$   

Z% [Z [ Z
' 57FXUYH \ Z 
 Z%  [Z  [ Z
Z%  PROHIUDF 6LQFH [ Z ,1  RQO\QHHG57FXUYHEHORZ&UHDWHWDEOHDQGSORW  
[Z  \Z 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

FDO NFDO J
   %   NFDO PRO 
J FDO PRO
  )HHG       NFDO PRO 



  
  & 3%     & 3:    
 
     &3LQ      NFDO PRO & 
    
0: IHHG [:  ) 0:: [%  ) 0:%    
 D $VVXPH \ 3  WRFDOFXODWHȜS      
& 3/LQ 
 DQG 7LQ 7RXW ZKHUH7LQ 7RXW   WKHQ   7KLVLVD
3


PRODUUDWLR6ORSH2SOLQH  DQGRSOLQHJRHVWKURXJKSRLQWPROHIUDFWLRQV

[ LQ 
[ RXW  \ 3  3ORWRSHUDWLQJOLQH)URPJUDSK \ 3  [ RXW  

PROHIUDFWLRQZDWHU7KLVYDOXHRI\SLVUHDVRQDEO\FORVHWRRXUDVVXPSWLRQ
 

 )S  ))  )S 0: S    )) 0:)   0: S  0:)  



  0:S \ S : 0:: \ S  % 0:%  
      LQOEKOEK
  $UHD 3HUPHDWH5DWH )OX[   OE K  OE K IW   IW  
E &XW [ LQZ  
 FXW 
  6ORSH   )LQG \ 3  IURPJUDSK
FXW 
  7KHQ  3      

   7LQ 7RXW 3   NFDO PRO  & 
& 3/LQ NFDO  PRO R &

 F    [ RXW  [ 3  )URP57WDEOHRUJUDSK

[ LQ [ RXW  
     )3 )LQ  
\3 [ RXW  
     3      



 
     7LQ 7RXW  &   & 
& 3/LQ 
'3DUWVEWRKDUHQHZLQUGHGLWLRQ 57FXUYH [ 3  5 0[ U  
  0DVVEDODQFHSHUIHFWO\PL[HG  )LQ [ U LQ )3 [ 3 )RXW [ U RXW 
)LQ
  6LQFH  [3  [ URXW [ ULQ 
)RXW
)RXW )LQ )3 )3 )LQ 
      7KHQ 
)LQ )LQ )LQ )RXW 

    [ U RXW    )RXW )LQ  NJ K 

  $OWHUQDWHJUDSKLFDOVROXWLRQJLYHVVDPHUHVXOW

"#$! 12#!345.!
 )3 )LQ [ U LQ
/!0! [3 [U [3 [ U RXW !
[3 ! )3 )LQ )3 )LQ
!
[ ULQ  ! 
()!*+,-.! 6ORSH !
%#&'$!  [ ULQ 
[U [ URXW ! :KHQ[ URXW  [ 3  !
)3 )LQ 

E$UHD )S-VROY NJK/NJKGD\/PGD\ P

F*HOIRUPDWLRQRFFXUVZKHQ[ Z DQG[Z 0[RXW 00  

G*HOIRUPDWLRQRFFXUVZKHQ[Z DQG[Z 0[RXW 0[)±ș¶ ±ș¶
 7KHQ±ș¶  DQGș¶ 

H*HOIRUPDWLRQRFFXUVZKHQ[ Z DQG[Z 0[RXW [)±ș¶ [)±
 2EWDLQ[) 
 [URXW [)±ș¶  

I:HKDYH[URXW [)±ș¶  0 [JHO[URXW  
 )LUVWRFFXUVZKHQ-VROY  NOQ02EWDLQN /PGD\ îPV

J0 DQGN 6LQFHZHFKDQJHWKHSUHVVXUHV-FKDQJHVZKLFKZLOOFKDQJH0+RZHYHU
ZLWKFRQVWDQWVWLUULQJNLVFRQVWDQW)LUVWDVVXPHQRJHODQGFDOFXODWH-DQG0
SU SS . -VROY  / P  NJ /
- VROY . VROY  VROY   
W PV W PV S U SS   EDU P GD\EDU


 
7KHQZLWKRXWJHO - VROY     / P  G D\
  
)URP(T0 H[S-VROYN 



 0[ )  
 7KHQ [ Z  JHOIRUPV
 
[) 
:LWKDJHOSUHYLRXVZRUNLVLQFRUUHFW6HW5 [ S  [ U 
  
$QGIURP(T-VROY NOQ[JHO[U OQ /PGD\
1RWH7KHVDPHDQVZHULVREWDLQHGLQSDUWVJDQGKLIFRQYHUWWR-VROYDQGXVHNLQPV

K *HOIRUPVVLQFHLWGLGSUHYLRXVO\ N    [ )  [ U  

[ JHO  / 
- VROY N Q N Q  
Q  / P  G D\
 [U [U P G D\ 

'D1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ &DVH%5 % 0 % S S% S U%  
 &DVH&5 & S S& S U&  

 5& SU SS   

&
 )RU([SHULPHQW& 0 & 0%  
 5% SU SS  
%

[ ,1  
E  [ RXW  
 
 5&  

  [S  5 & [ RXW  
. VROY
  - VROY SU SS D 0 & [RXW [S 
WPV
    >   @  J P V


'1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ 
 D ORJ DORJ3 E  3     3    
  ORJ  DORJ   E  D E 
  ORJ   DORJ   E  D E  
     E 
    E   D  
 (TXDWLRQ ORJ ORJ3  
 
 E ,I  ORJ  

ORJ 
ORJ 3
 
ORJ 3  32 %DUUHUV






'1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ,GHDO*DV9RO 0ROH
31  3&2  3+H  3+H    



  FP
  )3 ),1  P V ),1 P V   FP  V  )3    FP V  
 P 

FP+J
 3DUW$  SU DWP FP+JS S FP+J 
DWP
 3DUW%  S U FP+JS S   FP+J  
FP
   W PV PLO FP 
PLO
3L W PV S U
 (TG  . PL 1HHGWRJXHVVYDOXHRI )3 $ RURI \ 3  
)3 $ 3L W PV S S
6LQFH &2  KDVKLJKHVWSHUPHDELOLW\ &2  ZLOOEHFRQFHQWUDWHGWKXVJXHVV \ S&2 \&2,1  
\ ,1 &2 
 7KHQ \ U &2  \ S&2  JXHVV ZKHUH  DQG \ ,1&2  
 
 7KHQ )3 $ JXHVV 3&2  W PV \ S&2  S U \ U&2  S S \ S&2  

 8VH )3 $ LQ(TGWRFDOFXODWHDOO . PL 

\ ,1L
 7KHQFKHFN \ UL  " 
 . PL 
 3XWLQ6SUHDG6KHHW&DQXVH*RDO6HHNWRIRUFH \ UL  DVFKDQJH \ 3&2  
5HVXOWVD \ 31  \ 3&2  \3+H  \3+     
 \ U1  \ U&2  \ U+H  \ U+   
E 6DPHDQVZHUVIRUPROHIUDFWLRQVVLQFH S U S S LVVDPH

   +:  3UREOHP 

    
    
\)   
\)1  \)&2  +H  \)+ 
)FPV  WPFP  WKHWD 
SUFP+J  SSFP+J   
31  3&2     
3+H  3+     
)S     
FKDQJH\SWR JHWVXP      

\S&2  \U&2     
)S$  $FP     
$P     
.1  \U1     
.&2  \U&2     
   


 .+H  \U+H 
.+  \U+     
*RDOVHHN 6XP     
\S1     
\S&2       
\S+H       
\S+       
VXP       
      

(1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ)RUGLOXWHV\VWHPV - VROYHQW - WRWDO VROXWLRQ  ),1 )S )RXW %DVLV ),1  
)S [) [ RXW  
 7UDQVIHU(TF  
),1 [S [ RXW  
[S 
 5     - V X F URVH - VROYHQW[ S - VROYHQW VROXWLRQ [ S
[ RXW  3HUPHDWH

   [ S     NJ /

SHUPDWH

 ,QLWLDODVVXPSWLRQLV2.
- VROY - VROY  VROY  J  P  V   J  /  /   P  V 

 - VXFURVH J  P  V J  P V 
. ZDWHU  [S 0[U [S
E (T ZDWHU VROXWH   
. VXFURVH [ S SU SS 0[U [S D
    JZDWHU
  Z V  
      JVXFURVH
. ZDWHU - VROY
 )URP(TF 
WPV SU SS D 0[U [S
. ZDWHU 
 J P  VDWP
W PV      

. VXFURVH - VXFURVH  JVXFURVH
 (T   
WPV 0 [ U [S   P V ZWIUDF
F 6ROXWLRQ  5  0  5      
 7KHQ57HTXDWLRQLV [S  5 [ RXW [ RXW 
 [)  
 2SHUDWLQJ(TXDWLRQLV [ S [ RXW [ RXW 
 
    [S [ RXW  
 6ROYH57 RSHUDWLQJHTXDWLRQVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ [ RXW   [ S  



 [S
 &KHFN  5   .
[ RXW
. ZDWHU
   - ZDWHU SU SS D 0 [ U [S 
W PV
     >   @ JP V 
    - VXFURVH - ZDWHU [ S   [ S  
     
  - VXFURVH       J P V   
. VXFURVH J
$OWHUQDWLYHO\ - VXFURVH 0[ U [S >   @  
W PV P V
 GLIIHUHQW
[S [S         
6ROXWLRQ 57(T [ U 
      [S

[ S [ S 
 6LPSOLILHVWR [U 
 [ S
 /LQHDUL]H [ U # [ S   . 1RWH[S LVDQDUELWUDU\SRLQW
[S 
 6ORSH   
[U 
 7KHQOLQHDUIRUPRI57HTXDWLRQLV [ S[ U RU [ S [ RXW 
 6ROYHVLPXOWDQHRXO\ZLWK2SHUDWLQJ(TXDWLRQ
 [)
[S [ RXW [ RXW  

  [ RXW   [ S  9HU\FORVHWRYDOXHREWDLQHGZLWKUHWHQWLRQDQDO\VLV


)3 & 3/LQ
( ZDV'LQQGHG(TE 7LQ 7RXW  7LQ 7RXW    
)LQ 3

  6WDJH$VVXPH \ 3 a  ZDWHUHWKDQRO

    3  Z  (  N- NJ 6HH([DPSOH
  )RU)HHG &3/LQ &3/Z  & &3/( 
N- N-
           
NJ. NJ.
  :KHUHDYHUDJHWHPSHUDWXUHIURPWRLVž&DQG & 3 YDOXHVDUHIURP3HUU\¶VWKSS
DQGSS
   
)3 
  DQG)3    NJ KU 
)LQ 



  2SOLQHLQWHUVHFWV \ 3 [ RXW [ ,1  ZDWHUZWIUDF
  
     6ORSH  


  2S(TLV \ 3 [ RXW [ RXW  

  ,I   \ 3  [ RXW    
  3ORW2S/LQHRQ)LJXUHDDQGILQGLQWHUVHFWLRQ
     \ 3  [ RXW [ LQ  ZDWHUYDOXHV
     )RXW )LQ     NJ K


  6WDJH7ULDO6LQFH\S\SDVVXPHGGRDVHFRQGWULDO

 \3  ZDWHU( 3  Z  (      N- NJ 

)3  
 
)LQ 
)3    NJ K  )RXW    NJ K 
  
 6ORSH   \ 3 [ RXW [ RXW  
 

 ,I \ 3  [ RXW  

  3ORWRSHUDWLQJOLQHDQGGHWHUPLQHIURPJUDSK \ 3  [ RXW [ LQ    ZDWHU7KLV
YDOXHRI\SLVFORVHWRWKHDVVXPHGYDOXHRI&DQSURFHHGWRVWDJH

 6WDJH(VWLPDWH \ 3  ZDWHU 3  Z  ( 
  )RU [ LQ   &3/LQ      
)3 
     )LQ     NJ K 
)LQ  
 
  )RXW     NJ KU 6ORSH  


     \3 [ RXW [ RXW  

  ,I [ RXW  \ 3  'UDZRSOLQH,QWHUVHFWLRQJLYHV \ 3  
)LQ  [ LQ  )3 \ 3    
  )RU [ RXW  XVH0% [ RXW   
)RXW  
    
[ RXW  Z RU[ RXW (72+  
  7KLVLVDFORVHDVZHFDQJHWJUDSKLFDOO\
   
  0L[HG3HUPHDWH \ SPL[  ZWIUDFZDWHU
 



 NJ J
)3
K NJ
  $UHD  - IURP)LJEEDVHGRQ [ RXW 
- J KP 
  J K
  6WDJH -  J KP   $  P 

 
  6WDJH -  J KP   $   P 

  2WKHUIORZSDWWHUQVZLOOUHGXFHDUHD$UHDLVODUJHEHFDXVHRIORZIOX[FDXVHGE\ORZHWKDQRO
SHUPHDWLRQUDWH

 
[ [  
)  57HTQ \  [ %HQ]    \  
  [   
 
  [ %HQ]    \  
  
 
  [ %HQ]    \  3ORW57HTXDWLRQ
  
 
2SHUDWLQJHTXDWLRQ6ORSH  3ORWRQJUDSK)LQG \ 3%HQ] a  [ RXW%HQ] a  





    
 3 \ 3EHQ] EHQ]  \ 3EHQ] L3       FDO J 

 &3/LQ [ 3EHQ[Z &3/EHQ]  [ EHQ]LQ &3/ L3      FDO J & 



  3
 
   7LQ 7RXW  &  & 
& 3/LQ 

+ZDV*LQQGHGLWLRQ
7KLVLVVHWXSIRU$UHDEHLQJWKHXQNQRZQDQGFXWEHLQJNQRZQ3UREOHP+
)ULQ \LQ$ FXW )S)LQ 
WPHPFP SUFP+J SSFP+J 
  \LQ% 3$ 
)SWRW \LQ& 3% 
)URXW   3& 
     
*XHVVYDOXHVRI$RUHTXLYDOHQWO\)S$XQWLOVXP\UDQGVXPXSDUH 
)S$ WKLVLVILQDOUHVXOW  
.$ .% .& 
VXP[HT     
\U$ \S$  
\U% \S%  
\U& \S& $UHDFP 
VXP\U VXP\S ( 
     
7KHVHUHVXOWVDJUHHYHU\ZHOOZLWK*HDQNRSOLV¶UHVXOWV 

+1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ3DUWD
 \ S  \ URXW  $  FP  
  E   \ SDYJ  \ URXW  $  FP  

+1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ
&RXQWHU±FXUUHQW6KRZVILQDOJXHVVIRUWKHWD

)LQ 
FPV  \LQ  WKHWDWRW  3%WPV 
3$WPV  SUFP+J  SSFP+J 
0  1  \URXWJXHVV 
 HUURUDFF  
GI 
     
M 1L              
)U       
\S       
\U       
$UHD       
)S       
)S)UM       
\S 
$UHDWRW       
\LQFDOF       
)LQFDOF       
0DVVEDO (      
\URXW       
     





+1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ7KHVSUHDGVKHHWHTXDWLRQVDUHVKRZQEHORZIRUSDUWE3DUWDDJUHHG
ZLWKSUREOHP'3DUWEDQVZHUV\S: ș [RXW: ș¶ 
$UHD IW1RWHWKDWLIWKHVWDUWLQJJXHVVIRU\S:LVWRRKLJK*RDO6HHNZLOOFRQYHUJH
RQDQDQVZHUZLWK\S:!ZKLFKLVREYLRXVO\QRWSK\VLFDOO\SRVVLEOH



!

+7KLVSUREOHPLVYHU\VLPLODUWR([DPSOH,WLVHDVLHVWWRVROYHRQDVSUHDGVKHHWZKLFKLV
VKRZQEHORZ7KHUHVXOWVDUHVKRZQLQWKHVSUHDGVKHHW
1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ
 



 




+1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ7KHVSUHDGVKHHWLVVLPLODUWRWKDWIRUSUREOHP+DQGLVVKRZQ
EHORZ

+7KHVDPHVSUHDGVKHHWWKDWZDVXVHGLQSUREOHPV+LVXVHG 





! 
!



 63(UG(GLWLRQ6ROXWLRQ0DQXDO&KDSWHU

1HZ 3UREOHPV DQG QHZ VROXWLRQV DUH OLVWHG DV QHZ LPPHGLDWHO\ DIWHU WKH VROXWLRQ QXPEHU 7KHVH QHZ
SUREOHPV DUH $ $ % & & ' ' ' ' '
'''''')++&KDSWHUZDVFKDSWHU
LQWKHQGHGLWLRQ0RVWSUREOHPVIURPWKDWHGLWLRQKDYHWKHVDPHSUREOHPQXPEHUEXWWKH
FKDSWHUQXPEHULVQRZHJSUREOHP'LVQRZ'

$  FED
$  FDE
$1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ2QHEDUULHULVODFNRINQRZOHGJH0RVWFKHPLFDOHQJLQHHUVDUHQRW
WUDLQHGLQXVHRIDGVRUSWLRQFKURPDWRJUDSK\DQGLRQH[FKDQJH7KXVWKH\GRQRWWKLQNRIWKHVH
SURFHVVHVDVDSRWHQWLDOVROXWLRQ$VHFRQGEDUULHULVWKHVLPXODWLRQWRROVDUHQRWDVGHYHORSHGDQGZLGHO\
DYDLODEOHDVWKHVLPXODWLRQWRROVIRUHTXLOLEULXPVWDJHGVHSDUDWLRQVVXFKDVGLVWLOODWLRQ
$  5HJHQHUDWLRQLVWRRGLIILFXOW
$  ,QWKH60%WKHPDVVWUDQVIHU]RQHEHWZHHQWKHWZRVROXWHVVWD\VLQVLGHWKHFDVFDGH,QD
FKURPDWRJUDSK WKH 07= H[LWV WKH FROXPQ DQG PXVW HLWKHU EH FRPSOHWHO\ VHSDUDWHG
ZKLFKUHTXLUHVDVLJQLILFDQWDPRXQWRIGHVRUEHQWRUUHF\FOHGDSSURSULDWHO\
$  G
$1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ7KH/8%DSSURDFKDVVXPHVFRQVWDQWSDWWHUQEHKDYLRU/LQHDU
V\VWHPVGRQRWKDYHFRQVWDQWSDWWHUQEHKDYLRU

$  G
$  H

%1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ7KHUHDUHREYLRXVO\PDQ\SRVVLELOLWLHV2QHLVWRGHYHORSVRUSWLRQ
SURFHVVHVWKDWXVHDQHQHUJ\VHSDUDWLRQSURFHVVHVHJSUHVVXUHRUWHPSHUDWXUHWRSURGXFHSXUJHRU
GHVRUEHQWIURPWKHIHHGVRWKDWDVHSDUDWHSXUJHRUGHVRUEHQWGRHVQRWKDYHWREHDGGHG

&     7 H  H 3  H I FU\ 3 
     9DYDLODEOH H  H 3  I FU\  H I FU\ 3 . GL 9FRO 

     3  I FU\ FOD\  3 I FU\ FU\  3 3  I FU\ I I FU\ I 3 

     %  H 3 H I  VDPHDVE
UG
& 1HZSUREOHPLQ HGLWLRQ

  $PRXQWLQPRELOHSKDVH  H 9RO&RO6HJPHQW F H ǻ]D F ǻ[F7 

  $PRXQWLQSRUHV  QRSRUHV
  $PRXQWH[FKDQJHG  ǻ]$ F F57 ǻ\. '( 
    1R  H WHUPEHFDXVH F 57 LVHTXLYDOHQW/
İ H ǻ]$ F ǻ[F 7 Y LQW HU
  2EWDLQ X LRQ
İ H ǻ]$ F F 7 ǻ[ ǻ]$ F F 57 ǻ\. '( 
Y LQW HU
6LPSOLI\WR X LRQ   
F 57 \
   . '(
HF7 [



 &$  ] X$W
&     HUI 

& $)  ( HII W X $
Y LQWHU
  6NHWFKRIEUHDNWKURXJK


HUI D  D  !!

"#$!!
W ILQDO
!

#$!! WZ
W VW !
W
HUID  D  !

/ X $ W VW / X $ W ILQDO
  $WSRLQW  
DQGDW  

W X X$
( VW $ ( W ILQDO
Y Y

 X$
  2U    ( W VW / X $ W VW 
Y
   X $
  OHW   [  W X $ [
VW  ( [ /  
Y 

(   X $  (X $ W
   /X $
Y  Y
      [ 
X $
(   X $   (X $
 /X $
 Y  Y
  /HW  [ W  WKHQ [ 
ILQ

X $
      
  %\GHILQLWLRQ W 07= W ILQDO W VW [  [ 
  8VH VLJQIRUERWKKDVWREHWRKDYHSRVLWLYHWLPHV



   
  (   X $ (   X $  (X $ /X $  (X $
X $ [  
 
/X $
Y Y Y Y
 
  
  (   X $ (   X $  ( X $  ( X $
X $ [  
 
/X $ /X $
Y Y Y Y


(   X $  ( X $
 /X $
  Y  Y
  W 07= [  [  
X $

 (
  ,I / YHU\UHDVRQDEOHVLQFH(LVXVXDOO\VPDOO  
Y

  (
    W 07= / 
Y  X $


&1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ ,Q±2XW $FFXPXODWLRQ
 )RU)LJXUH% ,Q WYLQWHU $ F &7DIWHU [ LDIWHU 
  2XW WYLQWHU $ F&7EHIRUH [ LEHIRUH 
 $FFXPXODWLRQ /$ F \LDIWHU \LEHIRUH &57 /$F [ LDIWHU &7DIWHU [ LEHIRUH &7EHIRUH 
 1RWHWKDW & 57 LVFRQVWDQW$IWHUGLYLGLQJERWKVLGHVE\ W$ F  PDVVEDODQFHLV
Y LQW HU [ L DIWHU& 7 DIWHU [ L EHIRUH& 7 EHIRUH

   / / 
& 57 \ L DIWHU \ L EHIRUH [ L DIWHU& 7 DIWHU [ L EHIRUH& 7 EHIRUH
W W
 )RU)LJXUH%ZLWKDWRWDOLRQZDYH
/
  X WRWDO LRQ Y LQW HU 
W
 7KHILUVWDQGWKLUGWHUPVLQWKHPDVVEDODQFHFDQFHOHDFKRWKHU7KXV 
/
  & 57 \ LDIWHU \ LEHIRUH 
W
   :KLFKUHTXLUHV \LDIWHU \LEHIRUH


&     



 (!
%!
Y Y Y $ SURG X $ L & $ L / L X $ 0 $ X SRUW
)!
&! Y Y Y) X %/ & %L 9L X % 0  % X SRUW
!
*! Y Y Y %SURG X $ 0 $ X SRUW
'! Y Y Y' X % 0  % X SRUW
+!

 
&$
   &% Y 0 % X SRUW &$ Y 0 % X SRUW   
&%
   & $ Y 0 $ X SRUW &$ Y  Y) 0 $ X SRUW 
&$ 0 %
  6XEWUDFWHTIURP & $ Y ) 0 $ X SRUW 
&%
Y)
     X SRUW 
0 % 0 $
&% &$
  7KHQ  Y' Y Y ZKHUH Y  X % &% 0 % X SRUW &% 
          Y X $ &$ 0$ X SRUW &$ 

0 % X SRUW 0 $ X SRUW 0 % 0 $ YI
  7KXV  Y' 
&% &$ &% &$ 0 % 0 $
&% &$
' Y' 0 % 0 $ 0 % 0 $
     
) Y) &% &$ &% &$
'    
  ,IDOO  0L    
) &% &$ &% &$



S$  
'  5HDUUDQJH  S$ 3ORW S $ T $ YVS $ 
T$ T 0$; T 0$; . $




 . .
ST S ST S
   
   
   
   
   
   
    

  $W.         $W.
 
     ,QWHUFHSW    ,QWHUFHSW  
T PD[ . $ T PD[ . $
 
6ORSH   T PD[      6ORSH   T PD[  
T PD[ T PD[
 T PD[   T PD[ 
.$    . $  
 T PD[ . $   T PD[ . $ 



 /VROQ NJ /
'  D OLWHUVROQNJDGV    
NJDGV J JDGV
/ PRO /
  E OLWHUVROQJPROHDQWKUDFHQH   
PRO J JDGV
T PD[ . $F & $ /
   T WKXV . $& E  
 . $F & $ JDQWK
D  JDQWK
      T PD[  
. $&  JDGV
   
'1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ
Y LQWHU
3DUWD XM  YLQWHU H Y VXSHU  
 H
 H  S
 S .G V . LM
H H

 
 XM  X $1  FP PLQ 
  . M    

   7LPH$1 /X$1  PLQ

 E  X '1   WLPH / X 6'1  
   
 F  X X $1 X '1   
5X
  )URP 1   1  
X 6$1 X 6$1
   +(73 / 1 FP 
 
 )URP ZLGWKDWKDOIKHLJKW  SHDN PD[ 1 
 G 7R ILQG ZLGWK LQ WLPH XQLWV SHDN PD[ LV LQ WLPH XQLWV  UHWHQWLRQ
WLPH / X 6$1 PLQ  ZLGWK PLQ 
   W  ZLGWKKHLJKW PLQ 

Y VXS HU  FP
'  Y LQW HU  
H  PLQ
Y LQW HU
 D X V F
 H S .G  H  S V
 .[ 7
H H I

 

 XV   FP PLQ 
     
 
  
   W EU FP  FP PLQ PLQ 




 E$VVXPHZDOOKHDWFDSDFLW\LVVPDOO 
Y LQW HU
 X WK 
 H  H  S V & SV
 S
H H ) & SI
 FP
  X WK  
    PLQ

  
  W WKEU FP  FP PLQ PLQ 


 F. [  J J # &  X V   FP PLQ 
 
  W EU FP  PLQ VHHILJXUH
FP JWRO
0%LQ  $ F FP  PLQ  J FP  
PLQ JIOXLG
   RXW $ F      & FRQF 
 
6LPSOLI\LQJ    &FRQF ĺ & FRQF ZWIUDF 

 
 
&  XV  X WK
$OWHUQDWH(T    
&     
X V  X WK  

&    ZWIUDF $YHU\FRQVLGHUDEOHDPRXQWRIFRQFHQWUDWLRQRFFXUV



 /,01!2!3!,!

!
.!
! 4567!8/,029!
4?@!!
,-,,((!
2!3!,!
?!
,-,,((! 2>6=>!
,-,,((! **(-/!
;<=!

**-/+!!

*:-+#!;<=!

,-()##!
264?!

,-,,((!
,!
**-/+! *:-+#! ?<;A1!;<=!
  
'  YVXSHU  FP PLQ YLQW HU YVXSHU H    FP PLQ 
  )RUVWHSLQSXWZXQIDYRUDEOHLVRWKHUPJHWDGLIIXVHZDYH
Y LQW HU
  /DQJPXLUIRUPXOD X V 
 H  H  S D
 .G S V 
H H  EF
  %XWQRZ E  
 
  XV  
    NJ  
   
 
  OLWHU  F  F

c,g/l us, cm/min tout = L/us, min
0  2.741 min
0.25  2.998
0.50  3.3797
0.75  3.979
1.00  5.002
1.25  6.9625
1.50 4.3499 11.4944




I & S I Y LQW HU
' D X WK 
 H
 H  S :
 S I & SI & SV V & SZ
H H H$F

  ,IZDOOHIIHFWVDUHQHJOLJLEOH
  
 X WK  FP PLQ 
 
      
 

 E W WKHUPDOEU  FP  FP PLQ PLQ 

Y LQW HU 
X V .  FP PLQ
    
H
.G
H S
. [\     
S  
H H

 X V .  . [\ LQVDPHHTQ 

 F W EU .    PLQ  ([LWVDW F )  



  $WW VWDUWKRW W EUKRW    PLQ 
  )HHGLVFRQFHQWUDWHG  

&         

&  X V  X WK X V  X WK    

  &     J / 7KLVFRQWLQXHVXQWLOEUHDNWKURXJKDW
  W  / X V .    PLQXWHV 


,-,*)"/"!
(/-B:-!

DEF!

,-,(,!

,!

?! (:-(+C/! )*-":#! )C-:#C)!




'  YLQW HU YVXSHU H    FP PLQ 
Y LQW HU
 D $Wž& X V $
 H
 H  S
 S .G V . 
H H


 XV  &  FP PLQ 
    
  
 
 WU / XV FP  FP PLQ PLQ &RQFHQWUDWLRQRXWLV]HURIURPW WRW 
PLQXWHV7KHQH[LWVDW & )  



 Y LQW HU
 E X WK 
 H S
 H  S & SV V :& SZ

H H & SI I H $ F & SI I


  X WK  FP PLQ 
   

  
  W EUWK / X WK   PLQ  

  (T$EXWZLWK.ž

   X V  &  FP PLQ 
 
  

   W EUFRQF / X V    PLQ  

2!3!,!

:,0!
:,!
:,0!

.! ,0! :,0!
2!3!,!
4?@!

G74?<6=!?<;AH! ,!
2!&! 2!@<D@! /*-*!
*-+:":! 2!3!,!

   
  F KLJK  F) 
XV  X WK X V  X WK

  FKLJK       NPRO P 


'1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ([DPSOH YLQWHU)  DQG \LQWHUSXUJH  FP PLQ  

 X V YLQWHU)  &  FP PLQ  X V Y LQWHUSXUJH &   FP PLQ

 X WK YLQWHUSXUJH  FP PLQ  X V YLQWHUSXUJH &  FP PLQ

 X V Y LQWHU)  &   FP PLQ 

 ,I W SXUJH KRWSXUJHWLPHDQG W ) LVFROGIHHGWLPHZLWK
 W SXUJH W KRW ZDYHEUHDNWKURXJK  YLQWHUSXUJH  PLQ IURP ([DPSOH  WKHQ EUHDNWKURXJK

HTXDWLRQLV X V Y ,QWHU)  & W ) X V Y ,QWHUSXUJH & W WKHUPDOEUHDNWKURXJK FP 



   
   W)  PLQ

 7KH QH[W IHHG LQSXW DW      PLQ  7KLV VWDUWV D FROG WKHUPDO ZDYH DW
Y ,QWHU)  X WK Y ,QWHU)  FP PLQ ZKLFKEUHDNVWKURXJKLQDQRWKHUPLQIRUWRWDOWLPH
WRFROGEUHDNWKURXJKRI PLQ
 7KHVROXWHLVKRWILUVWDW Y ,QWHUSXUJH X V   Y ,QWHUSXUJH  FP PLQ DQGWKHQ

 X V  Y LQWHU)   FP PLQ DIWHUPLQXWHV1H[WVROXWHVWHSLV

   X V YLQWHUSXUJH   X V)   YLQWHU) W  
   W      PLQ
 ([LW7LPH6ROXWH W) W SXUJH W     PLQ
  6LQFH ([LW 7LPH 6ROXWH   EUHDNWKURXJK FROG ZDYH WKH VROXWH LV DW ƒ& WKH
HQWLUHWLPH

 6ROXWH H[LWV IURP   PLQ WR  PLQXWHV   PLQXWHV  LW H[LWV DW
VXSHUILFLDOYHORFLW\RI FP PLQ  
 0DVV%DODQFH
 $OOVROXWHLQ 6ROXWHRXW
   W ) YVXSHU $ F F ,1 W RXW YVXSHU $ F F RXW$9* 
W) 
   F RXW $9* F ,1 ZWIUDF ZWIUDF 
W RXW 
 7KLV LV VDPH DV SHDN FRQFHQWUDWLRQ LQ ([DPSOH  EXW JUHDWHU WKDQ [ RXWDYJ    7R
KDYHVDPHFRQFHQWUDWLRQV QHHGWRUHF\FOHWKH PDWHULDO H[LWLQJDWIHHGFRQFHQWUDWLRQ LQFRXQWHU
IORZV\VWHP127(&RXQWHUIORZV\VWHPKDVDGYDQWDJHVRIQRWFRQWDPLQDWLQJWKHSURGXFWHQG
RIWKHFROXPQDQGW\SLFDOO\KDVOHVVVSUHDGLQJRIWKH]RQH 

'1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQD  H YLQWHU Y6XSHU  P V  YLQWHU    P V 
H Y LQWHU
  X VIHHG0  P V 
H  H S .G  H  S V 57. $S
  0 IURP(TLVVDPHDV([DPSOH 0  
 3UHVVXUL]DWLRQ6WHS
 )HHGHQGIRUSUHVVXUL]DWLRQ P 0HDVXUHGIURPFORVHGSURGXFWHQG

DWP
   ] DIWHU P P 
DWP
 ZKLFKLV   P IURPIHHGDQG
 

  \ 0 DIWHU   

 )HHG6WHS
 X VIHHG  P V  VHF P P IRUSUHVVXUL]DWLRQVWHS
 P'RHVQRWEUHDNWKURXJKLQILUVWF\FOH)URPWRPFRQFHQWUDWLRQLV \ ) 


 %ORZGRZQ
 0HDVXULQJIURPFORVHGWRS ] EHIRUH   P 


   ] DIWHU P 


7KH IDU HQG RI WKH IHHG ZDYH GRHV QRW JHW UHPRYHG IURP WKH EHG  7KH FORVH ZDYH
RU  PIURPFORVHGHQG KDV


] DIWHU   PVRLWDOOH[LWV7KHPROHIUDFWLRQRIWKLVSRUWLRQLV

 

  \ DIWHU \ IHHG    

 3DUWRIWKHIHHGWKDWZDVSUHVVXUL]HGDOVRH[LWVGXULQJEORZGRZQ


 7KLV ] DIWHU  ] EHIRUH
] EHIRUH ] EHIRUH P IURPFORVHG

SURGXFWHQG7KLVLV   P IURPIHHGHQG7KLVJDVHQWHUHGDWDQXQNQRZQ
SUHVVXUHEHWZHHQ S /  DQG S +  &DQFDOFXODWHWKLVSUHVVXUHIURP(TF
  
] DIWHU 
  S EHIRUH S DIWHU  DWP 
] EHIRUH 
 

  \ DIWHUSUHVV   $IWHU3UHVVXUL]DWLRQ6WHS

 7KLVJDVLVGHSUHVVXUL]HGWR H[LWVFROXPQ
 

  \ DIWHU%'   RUHVVHQWLDOO\WKHIHHGFRPSRVLWLRQ

 ([LWIURP&RO

,-,,/"**
I!
,!
-,,*,!

?<;A!
  
S DIWHU
 3DUWE:DQW ] DIWHU EORZGRZQ  WKHQ ] EHIRUH ] DIWHU 
S EHIRUH


  ] EHIRUH   

 IURPFORVHGHQGZKLFKLV    PIURPIHHGHQG:DQWWKHIHHGWRHQGDWWKLV
SRLQW  'XULQJ FRQVWDQW SUHVVXUH IHHG VWHS IHHG WUDYHOV X VIHHG W ) W )   7KHQ IRU
SUHVVXUL]DWLRQVWHS ] DIWHU IURPIHHGHQG  W )  )URPFORVHGHQGWKLVLV



 S DIWHU
 W ) ] DIWHU ] EHIRUH
S EHIRUH


  
 W )  RUW ) 

  7KXVQHHGDSXUJHVWHSLIKDYHIHHGVWHSDWFRQVWDQWSUHVVXUHIRUFRPSOHWHFOHDQRXW

 
'D SW  ] DIWHU   $  S EHIRUH  DWP 

 

  \ DIWHU   

P
  7UDYHOV V VIRUEORZGRZQ V 
 P V
 E 6WDUWZLWK$UELWUDU\SRLQWDWW VHFHQGUHSUHVV ] DIWHU  IURPIHHGHQG

 
  
  S EHIRUH  DWP  \ DIWHU   
 
  'LVW7UDYHOHG#W VîV P
  )RUEORZGRZQGLVWDQFHIURPFORVHGHQG FP
  
 
  ] DIWHU    \ DIWHU %'   
 
  3XUJH X 0SXUJH  P V ([LWVERWWRPFROXPQGXULQJSXUJHSRLQW

  GLVWDQFHWUDYHOHGXSXUJH V V 


' ,IUHSUHVVXUL]HZLWKSURGXFWEHGUHPDLQVFOHDQ
  )HHGVWHSLVVDPHDVWRSRLQWDWPIURPIHHGHQGRQ)LJXUH
  %ORZGRZQWKHQSWPIURPWRSDQGSXUJHH[LWVDWSWV
  3URGXFWJDVLVFOHDQHU\ EXWWKHUHLVORZHUSURGXFWLYLW\±OHVVIHHGSHUF\FOH
  6HH)LJXUH





 
'B!
*!
+!
I!3!,! I!3!,!

I!3!,-,,/)!

/!

'D 7KHFOHDQEHGUHFHLYLQJIHHGKDVDVKRFNZDYHIRU/DQJPXLULVRWKHUP

  Y VXS HU FP  PLQ $ F  ZKHUH$ F U FP FP  
  YVXS HU  FP PLQ  YLQWHU YVXS HU H   FP PLQ 
Y LQW HU
  X VK 
 H S. G
 H  S T
 V
H H F
T T DIWHU T EHIRUH
  ZKHUHF EHIRUH  T EHIRUH 
F F DIWHU F EHIRUH
 
  F DIWHU  PRO P  T DIWHU  PRO NJ 
  
  

 X VK  FP PLQ 
     
 
  
    W EU / X VK FP  FP PLQ PLQ 
  2XWOHWFRQFHQWUDWLRQLV]HURXQWLO W EU WKHQEHFRPHV
  &RQFHQWUDWHGVROXWLRQHOXWHGE\GLOXWHVROQ*LYHVGLIIXVHZDYHIRU/DQJPXLULVRWKHUP
Y
  X V X GLIIXVH 
 H  H  S D
 S. G S 
H H  EF
 
XV 
       
 
 
   F  F
  &UHDWH7DEOH



 F  X V  W / XV   PLQ
F  X V  FP PLQ  W / XV PLQ
F  X V  W PLQ
     
F  X V  W PLQ
F  X V  W 
F  X V  W 


' $ GH [WUDQ % IUXFWRVH  
    &$ Y X $ 0X SRUW 
     &% Y  X % 0  X SRUW 
     & $ Y X $ 0  X SRUW 
     &% Y  X % 0  X SRUW 
 FP  PLQ
9RO)HHG Y )VXS HU
 Y Y Y )  Y )VXSHU  Y )  FP  PLQ 
'
 
H


&% Y)
 6ROYHHTVDQGVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ X SRUW 
&%
0 0
&$

   
 &$   & %  
 H   H 
 .$    .%  
H  H 
  FP PLQ
 X SRUW  FP PLQ / W VZ 

 

/ 
      W VZ PLQ
X SRUW 
 
0  '
Y X SRUW   FP PLQ  9VXS HU Y H  FP  PLQ
&$  
 
0 
 Y X SRUW   FP PLQ  9VXS HU  FP  PLQ
&% 
0  X SRUW  
Y  9VXS HU  FP  PLQ 
&$ 
0  X SRUW  
 Y  9VXS HU  FP  PLQ 
&% 
 5HF\FOHIORZ 9VXS HU  FP PLQ 


 
'
 ' 9VXS HU 9VXS HU    FP PLQ   
)
0 0
&%
9' ' 9 9 0 0  X SRUW &% &$
 &KHFN 
9) ) 9) &% &$ Y) &%
0 0
&$
 

'  
     2.
) 
 

  5DIILQDWH3URGXFW 9 9    FP  PLQ 
  ([WUDFW3URGXFW 9 9    FP PLQ

'1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ)URP(TF . . + .. /L .+ /L

 $QGHUVRQ¶VGDWD  .. +    
 'H&KRZ¶VGDWD  . . +    
 )RUWKHVKRFNZDYH(TKROGVIRU.
 6LQFHUHVLQLVLQLWLDOO\LQ+IRUP [ .EHIRUH &.EHIRUH &7  DQG \ .EHIRUH &5 . &57  
  [ .DIWHU &.DIWHU &7  
  \ .DIWHU &5 .DIWHU &57  
Y LQWHU
 D  X VK . 
 & 57 \ . DIWHU \ . EHIRUH
 . '( .
H &7 [ . DIWHU [ . EHIRUH
  /
  X VK .  FP PLQ  W VK
PLQ 
    X VK
 
   
 6DPH IRU ERWK VHWV RI GDWD VLQFH . . +  GRHV QRW HQWHU LQWR HTXDWLRQ ZKHQ LQLWLDO DQG IHHG
FRQWDLQRQO\RQHLRQ
 E & W  X 6K.  FP PLQ  W VK PLQ 
 F & W  [ .EHIRUH  [ .DIWHU   \ . YDOXHVGHSHQGRQHTXLOLEULXPSDUDPHWHU
. .+ [ .
   \. 
 . .+  [ .
 
 $QGHUVRQ¶V'DWD \ . EHIRUH  
   
 
  \ . DIWHU  
   



  
  X VK   W . / X VK PLQ
   
 
   
  
'H&KRZ¶VGDWD
 
 \ . EHIRUH  
   
 
 \ . DIWHU  
   
 
 X VK   W . / X VK PLQ 
   
 
   
 
 GLIIHUHQFH   

 G 7KHUH LV D GLIIHUHQFH LI HLWKHU LQLWLDO RU IHHG FRQWDLQV ERWK LRQV  6\VWHP ZLWK KLJKHU
. . + KDGKLJKHUVKRFNYHORFLW\
Y
'1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ3DUWD X VK L
 F 57 \ LDIWHU \ LEHIRUH
 . '(
H F7 [ LDIWHU [ LEHIRUH

[ LEHIRUH \ LEHIRUH 
 )RUERWK 1D  .  
[ LDIWHU \ LDIWHU 
 
 7KXVVDPH X VK  X VK  FP PLQ 
 

 
    W FHQWHU / X VK   PLQ

Y
X LVK
 3DUWE  F 57 \ LDIWHU \ LEHIRUH
 . '(
H F7 [ LDIWHU [ LEHIRUH


 )RUERWK1DDQG.[EHIRUH DQG[DIWHU )RU1D

. 1D + [1D   
\ 1D EHIRUH 
  . 1D +  [1D  >   @

 . 1D [ 1D     
+
 \ 1D  DIWHU  
  . 1D +  [1D  >   @




 Y   
 X VK 1D  
 F 57 \ 1D DIWHU \ 1D EHIRUH   
 . '( 
  
H F7 [ 1D DIWHU [ 1D EHIRUH
 W 1D /  XVK  1D     PLQ  

 )RU.ZHREWDLQ

.. + [.   
 \ . EHIRUH 
 .. +  [.  >   @

.. [.     
+
 \ .  DIWHU  
 .. +  [.  >   @
Y   
 X VK .  
 F 57 \ . DIWHU \ . EHIRUH   
 . '( 
  
H F7 [ . DIWHU [ . EHIRUH

 W. /  XVK  .     PLQ  

Y
3DUWF  X 
 F 57 G\
 . '(
H F7 G[
G\ 1D . 1D +
. 1D /L .+ /L
 

G[ 1D  . 1D  [ 1D  . 1D .+  [ 1D
+ /L /L
  
G\ 1D    
 
  X 1D    
G[ 1D       
 
   
  W 1D / X VK1$ PLQ 
G\ . .. +
.. /L .+ /L
    

G[ .  ..  [.  .. .+  [.
+ /L /L

G\    

  
  X .    
G[       
 
 
3DUWG  [ 1D   [ . 
G\ 1D
    . 1D +     X 1D   W 1D PLQ 
G[ 1D [ 1D 

G\ .
    .. +     X .   W . PLQ 
G[ . [. 

 3DUWH [ 1D [ .  


 G\ 1D 
     
 X  W 1D PLQ 
G[ 1D   
1D

G\ . 
   
  X   W . PLQ 
G[ .   
.

3DUWI7KHYHORFLWLHVDQGKHQFHWKHGHULYDWLYHVDUHHTXDO7KXV

G\ 1D . 1D /L . + /L G\ . . . /L . + /L
  
G[ 1D  . 1D /L . + /L  [ 1D G[ .  . . /L . + /L  [ .
 
 :LWK[1D [.7KHUHVXOWIURPDVSUHDGVKHHWLV[ 


' YLQW HU YVXS HU H    FP V 
0: S  J PRO N3D NJ
  I 
 NJ P  
57 P N3D J
 .
PRO.
T NJWROXHQH NJFDUERQ
  LVLQ 7KHQVKRFNZDYHYHORFLW\LV
F NJWROXHQH NJDLU
Y LQW HU
  X VK 
 H S. G  H  S V T

H H I \
 FP V
  X VK 
      NJ P  T  T

   NJ P  \  \
 FP V
  X VK 
T T
  
\ \
 
  )RU X VK   \  T  \   T   
  

   X VK   FP V  FP K 

 

  X VK   \  T 
 
\   T   
  

  X VK   FP V  FP K 
 
 
 
  $W / PLQ  X VKW / PLQ X VK  W K ZKHUHWLVLQKRXUV


 X VK    
  6ROYHIRU W K
X VK  X VK
 
FP
    / PLQ X VK W   K FP 
K
  7KXVIRUDQ\FROXPQRISDUWLDOOHQJWKZHZLOOVHHDVLQJOHVKRFNZDYHH[LWWKHFROXPQ
Y VXS HU 
' Y LQW HU  FP V 
H 
S9 Q 57
    0: Q 0: S   
Y  NJ P 
9 57  J NJ  
  6LQFH &LQLW & ) *HWGLIIXVHZDYHV
Y LQW HU T 
   XV ZKHUH 

  H  S T \  \
H V
 S .G
H H I \
  FP V
   XV 
    T  T
  
   \ \
y T X V  FP V W / X V  X V
\
0.0010   125,581s = 34.8835 h
0.00075   183,117.6s = 50.866 h
0.00050   291,596.6s = 80.999 h
2nd wave (0.00050) DGG KRXUV 100.999 h
0.00025   535,250.5 = 148.681 + 20 = 168.681 h
0.00 2000 0.00001914 1285937.96 = 357.205 + 20 = 377.205 h

XV \  ! ,-,,,C#! ,-,,,)#!

!
.!
XV \ 

XV \  !
,! ?!
)!
XV \  !

    



 /,-"""!
*+-//!
,-,,(! #,-/::!
,!
>! ,-,,,C#!
,-,,,#!
J!
(,,-""!
J!
(:/-//!

,-,,,)#!

?! *CC-)!



'
1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ
3DUWD  X 6* 6 FP PLQ LVFDOFXODWHGLQ([DPSOH


 X 6)   X X6* X 6)  
  
 


 )URP(T 1 5X X 6* X 6)  
 1( HII
 )URP(TD  1 / Y ( HII / 
 Y

   FP  PLQ
   / FP 
 FP PLQ
 3DUWE W* / X 6*   PLQ 
   W) / X 6)   PLQ 
   
/  
 3DUWF(TD W  W * PLQ PLQ 
X6 1 
 

   W ) PLQ PLQ 


[ $J
' . $J. . $J /L .. /L     \ $J 
 [ $J
 D ,RQZDYH X WRWDOFRQ YLQW HU YVXSHU H    FP PLQ 
  %UHDNWKURXJKRILRQZDYH FP  FP PLQ PLQ 



 Y LQW HU
 E 6KRFNZDYH X VK 
 & 57 \ $J DIWHU \ $J EHIRUH
 .(
H &7 [ $J DIWHU [ $J EHIRUH
  EHIRUH [ $J \ $J  DIWHU [ $J \ $J   
 FP PLQ / FP
 X VK  FP PLQ  W VK  PLQ 
    X VK  FP PLQ

  
Y LQW HU Y LQW HU
 F 'LIIXVHZDYH X V 
 & 57 G\  & 57 . $J .
 .(  .(
H &7 G[ 
H &7  . $J  [ $J
.

 FP PLQ 

  X V$J 
   
  
 
   [  [ $J
$J

 FP /
  [ $J  X V   W RXW PLQ 
 PLQ XV
 

 
  [ $J  X V  W RXW PLQ 
 


 / 
  [ $J  X V  FP PLQ  W RXW PLQ 
 XV 
)URPVSUHDGVKHHW
[$J XBGLI$J WBGLI$J
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  

. &D  /L 
' :DV'LQQGHGLWLRQ7DEOH . &D.  
 
. . /L 
 D F 57  HT /  F 7  HT /  [ &D DWW  
. &D. & 57  
   VKRFNZDYH 
&7 
  &ROXPQ / FPYVXSHU  FP PLQ  YLQWHU    FP PLQ 


    S   H  . (  
Y LQW HU
  )HHG X VK EHIRUH [ &D  \ &D  DIWHU [ &D  
& 57 . (  \

H & 7  [

  IURP(T \ &D  

 
  X VK  FP PLQ  W EU PLQ 
   X VK
 
  

 E 5HJHQHUDWHDWPLQĺ,RQZDYHDW YLQW HU  FP PLQ WDNHV  PLQ

. &D & 57
 1HZ   \ &D XQFKDQJHG8VH(TZLWKQHZYDOXH . &D & 57 &7  
&7
[ &D  2EWDLQGLIIXVHZDYH

Y LPWHU G\   \ &D  [ &D
  X GLIIXVH ZKHUH &D  
& 57 . ( G\ &D G[ &D  [

 \
 &D &D
& 7 H G[ &D
  :DQNDW(TE
G\ 
  $W [ &D   &D  X &D  FP PLQ 
G[ &D  
 
 
FP
  W RXW PLQ VORZZDYH

  $W [ &D  DQG\ &D  

G\ &D   
  
 
G[ &D  
 
  X &D  FP PLQ  W RXW PLQ IDVWZDYH
  
 
 
  $W [ &D  \ &D  

G\ &D   
  
 
G[ &D  
 
  X &D  FP PLQ  W RXW PLQ LQEHWZHHQ
  
 
 

'1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ 
Y) 
 X SRUW  & 7RO  
0 0   H  S
H
& &  S .G . 7RO 
\ 7RO
H H



 . 7RO . H     . [\ . H    

 & [\  
  
Y)
 X SRUW Y )  FP PLQ , / X SRUW W 6: FP 
 
 
 
 Y 0   X SRUW & [\  FP PLQ  Y Y  Y )  


 Y 0  X SRUW & 7RO   

 
 Y 0   X SRUW & [\ 

Y 7ROSURG Y Y   
Y [\SURG Y Y   
Y' Y Y     ' )  
&KHFN Y2XW Y WROSURG Y [\SURG  , Y WRWDOLQ Y) Y' 2.
GS   GS 
' ( HII (' X V . ZKHUH 
N 0F N PF N PF D S
 
 FP  PLQ Y VXS HU
 Y VXS HU 
 FP PLQ  Y  FP PLQ 
FP
Y 
  XV  FP PLQ 
 H 
  .
H

FP 
  
PLQ
  ( HII  
 FP  PLQ 
PLQ 

&  ] XVW
  (T ;  HUI 
IRUVWHSXS
&)  ( HII X V W
Y LQW HU
 W
  $UJXPHQWRIHUI D 

W



  / X V W X V
  6WHSGRZQ ; / W   HUI 

 ( HII X V W 
Y LQW HU
 W
  $UJXPHQWRI HUI  D 

W 
  7RWDO6ROXWLRQ ; ; 
/ 
  ,I W PLQD  D 
 
XV 
 
  ; DQG;     F F) RUF  IRUVPDOOHUWFDQLJQRUH ;  
 
/ X V 
  ,I W  D  ;    D 
 HUI  
XV 
 F 
  ;   )RUKLJKHUW;    F  
 F) 

  3HDNDW  D 
 HUI D  


    ;   

 
  D 
 HUI D   ;    
 
F
      F    
F)
  6HHDOVR3UREOHP*


':DV'LQQGHGLWLRQ &RXW &LQLWLDO &LQLWLDO &) ; ] W  &); ] W 


'1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ 
Y) 
X SRUW  & 7RO .   
0 0   H  S
H
& &  S .G . 7RO 
[\ 7RO
H H

 . 7RO . H     . [\ . H   



 & [\ . 
  




 Y)
 X SRUW Y )  FP PLQ , / X SRUW W 6: FP 
 
 
 
 Y 0   X SRUW & [\ .  FP PLQ  Y Y Y)  


 Y 0  X SRUW & 7RO .   


Y7ROSURG Y Y   

 
 Y 0   X SRUW & [\  

Y [\SURG Y Y   
Y' Y Y     ' )  
&KHFN Y2XW Y WROSURG Y [\SURG  , Y WRWDOLQ Y) Y' 2. 

'1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ =RQHV DUHVDPHDVLQ'VLQFHDW.  
 X SRUW Y )  FP PLQ  / X SRUW W 6: FP 
 Y   Y  
 Y 0  X SRUW &7RO . DQG Y  0   X SRUW & [\ . 
 0 DQG0   UHFLSURFDOYDOXHV
 . 7RO . H[S    
 . [\ . H[S    

 & 7RO . 
  

& [\ .    
  


Y      Y     
 Y7ROSURG Y Y   Y [\ SURG Y Y   Y ' Y Y  
 '  ) 
 

5X V Y 
'D 1  5   X V $  
X V$ X V%  V

 .$


  X V'   X  
 



 
  
  1HHG 1   /  1 FP

/ 
 E W 5 $  PLQ 
X$ 
 
/  
  W $ PLQ PLQ 
X$ 1 
 
&$ W W5 W 
  H[S 
H[S 
S
& $ PD[  W  

t,min 90 92 94 95 95.813 96 97
&$ &$PD[ 7.27E-15 8.3E-7 0.0421 0.52898 1.00 0.9669 0.2573
 
&$
; $ / W   ; $ / W W )
'  &) 
   ; $ / W W )   ; $ / W W)

FP
'D X S / W FHQWHU  FP PLQ  / 07=ODE X SW 07=   FP
PLQ

W 07=/6 G S /6 ' HII 
 E /DUJH6FDOHV\VWHP 
 
W 07=ODE G S ODE ' HII 
  ,QGHSHQGHQWRIYHORFLW\ W 07=/6   PLQ 
Y VXSHU
X S /6 H
/6   
  ĺ X S/V  FP PLQ 
X S ODE Y VXSHU   

H ODE
ODE

  / 07=ODUJ H VFDOH X S W 07= FP PLQ PLQ FP 

  )RUIUDFEHGXVH  V\PPHWULFDOSDWWHUQ
/ 07=   W 07=
  / FP P  W EU W FHQWHU 
 )UDFEHGXVH   
 
  W FHQWHU / XS PLQ  W EU  PLQ 
 
  7KLVLVOHQJWKRIIHHGWLPHLIFROXPQLVFRPSOHWHO\UHJHQHUDWHG

. &D  /L 
' . &D.  
 
. . /L 
 D F 57  HT /  F7  HT /  [ &D DWW  



 . &D. & 57  
   VKRFNZDYH 
&7 
  &ROXPQ / FPYVXSHU  FP PLQ  YLQWHU     FP PLQ 
    S   H  . (  
Y LQW HU
  )HHG X VK EHIRUH [ &D  \ &D  DIWHU [ &D  
& 57 . (  \

H & 7  [

\ &D . &D . & 57 [ &D

  IURP(TXLOLEULXP 
 \ &D  
&7  [ &D   

 6ROYHWKLVIRUXQNQRZQ\YDOXH,XVHGDVSUHDGVKHHW
\&D  

 
  X VK  FP PLQ  W EU PLQ 
   X VK
 
  

 E 5HJHQHUDWH,RQZDYHDW YLQW HU     FP PLQ WDNHV  PLQ

. &D. & 57 
 1HZ   \ &D  XQFKDQJHG8VHHTXLOLEULXPZLWK
&7 
\ &D . &D . & 57 [ &D
ROG\DQGZLWKQHZYDOXH . &D & 57 &7   WR
  \ &D  
&7  [ &D  
ILQG [ &D  2EWDLQGLIIXVHZDYH

Y LPWHU G\   \ &D  [ &D
  X GLIIXVH ZKHUH &D  
& 57 . ( G\ &D G[ &D  [

 \
 &D &D
& 7 H G[ &D
  :DQNDW(TE
G\ 
  $W [ &D   &D  X &D  FP PLQ
G[ &D  
 
  

$VDQDOWHUQDWLYHFDQGRQXPHULFDOFDOFXODWLRQRIGHULYDWLYH$W[ \ [ \ DQG

\  [       ZKLFKLVUHDVRQDEO\FORVH

FP
  W RXW PLQ VORZZDYH

  $W [ &D  DQG\ &D  

G\ &D   
  
 
G[ &D  



  
  X &D  FP PLQ  W RXW PLQ IDVWZDYH
  
 
 
  )URPHTXLOLEULXPDWWKHDUELWUDU\YDOXH [ &D  \ &D  

G\ &D    
  
 
G[ &D  
 
  X &D  FP PLQ  W RXW PLQ 
  
 
 

7KLVLVLQEHWZHHQWKHRWKHUWZRZDYHV!

. &D. & 57 

 F7RnotKDYHDGLIIXVHZDYHPXVWKDYH 
&7 &7

 7KLVUHTXLUHV&7!

'1HZ3UREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ . . + .. /L .+ /L


 'H&KRZ¶VGDWD  . . +    

 D7KLVZLOOEHDVKRFNZDYHVLQFH.LVPRUHFRQFHQWUDWHGLQWKHIHHGWRWKHFROXPQWKDQLW
LVLQLWLDOO\DQG..+!
 
Y LQWHU
  X VK . 
 & 57 \ . DIWHU \ . EHIRUH
 . ( .
H &7 [ . DIWHU [ . EHIRUH
 
  &W  [ .EHIRUH  [ .DIWHU   \ . YDOXHVGHSHQGRQHTXLOLEULXPSDUDPHWHU
. .+ [ .
   \. 
 . .+  [ .



 
 \ . EHIRUH  
   
 
 \ . DIWHU  
   
 
 X VK  FPPLQ
   
 
   
W. / X VK PLQ
 
 $OOWKUHHWLPHVDUHWKHVDPHIRUWKHVKRFNZDYH


 
! K-9! L@<5!M<77!KA!N!O<PP45A!MNQA!5<=>A!RS!<5!7A55!>6=>A=?TN?AO!<=!?@A!PAAO!?6!?@A!>674;=!?@N=!<?!
<5!<=<?<N77I!N=O!..+!

Y LQWHU   
 X GLIIXVH.
 & 57 G\ .  G\ .
 . (. 
H &7 G[ .  G[ .
 
G\ . . .+ 


%?!UR!3!,-(#1! G[.   . .+  [.  > @ !

    

X GLIIXVH. FP  PLQ
 G\ . G\  
!    .
 G[ . G[ .


7KXVDW[. W. /XGLIIXVH.  PLQ7KHQDW[. ZHREWDLQ


G\ . . .+ 


G[.   . .+  [.  > @
 
X GLIIXVH. FP  PLQ

G\  
  .
G[ .


7KXVDW[. W. /XGLIIXVH.  PLQ7KHQDW[. ZHREWDLQ

G\ . . .+

! G[.   . .+  [.   !

 
X GLIIXVH. FP  PLQ
G\  
  .
G[ .


W. /XGLIIXVH.  PLQ


'1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQD  Y6XSHU YLQW HU     H  /  



 
 F 57  F 7  . . 1D  

Y LQW HU 
 X VK .  
 F 57 \ . DIWHU \ . EHIRUH    
 . '(  
   
H F7 [ . DIWHU [ . EHIRUH
 X VK.  FP PLQ W FHQWHUH[S HFWHG PLQ   W FHQWHU PHDVXUHG PLQ 
 
   HUURU   

 E X VKH[S W / W FHQWHU    FP PLQ  
 F / 07= X VK W 07=    FP 
  )UDFEHGXVHV\PPHWULFZDYH   / 07= /  
G S Y 6XSHU ! HII G S  ! HII
O DUJ H VFDOH
/ 07= O DUJ H VFDOH / 07=/DE / 07=/DE 
/DE
 G
G S Y 6XSHU ! HII G S  ! HII
/DE /DE

  :LWKVDPHEHDGVDVVXPHQRFKDQJHLQ ! HII  
    / 07=ODUJ HVFDOH   FP FP 
    IUDFEHGXVH   / 07= /      
  %UHDNWKURXJKVWDUWWLPH W FHQWHU W 07= / X VK  / 07= X VK

Y LQWHUODUJHVFDOH
X VK X VK ODE H[S WO 
    Y LQWHUODEVFDOH 
  %UHDNWKURXJKVWDUWWLPH > @   PLQ 

)1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ&RQVWUDLQWV Z / IW 7 PD[  &  ) 
  Z/K IW  K  IWS  DWP SVLD SVLJ 

G=O!
V<AM! WA<D@?!QA55A7!
6HLGHU HWDO
'L WV / ' L W V  V !
(T 

@!

! !

M!

 6HLGHUHWDO(T



 
   3G H[S   Q S   Q S  SVLJ   
 :DOOWKLFNQHVV
3G ' L ' L
 (T WS (  ' L  
6( 3G     
 ZKHUH 6 SVL S ZLWK6$%VWHHO( 
   V  OEP IW   OEP LQ  S6HLGHUHWDO
K   
 5HODWHZWRK FRV  FRV  ' 
U U '
Z Z Z  
   FRV  FRV  FRV 
U ' ' '

:HLJKW ' (  ' 
' (  '    
' FRV  FRV '

'LQIW ,Q6SUHDGVKHHW$FRV   FRV 
 ,Q6SUHDGVKHHWDQJOHLVLQUDGLXV  
' :HLJKW :LGWK /
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
 *RDOVHHN/ 
 ' IW:HLJKW :LGWK  /  W V IW 
 )URP6HLGHUHWDOS &S )P & Y &3/ LQPLG06 

 (TKRUL]RQWDO &Y H[S   Q Z  Q Z 

 (T  &S/  '  
 )URPS )P  IRUORZDOOR\VWHHO & Y  ĺ &S   LQPLG
 ,QVWDOOHG&RVW &DOF& S ZLWK)P  LQ  &S    
 %DUHPRGXOHIDFWRU )%P  IRUKRUL]RQWDO
   &%P &S )P          

 $EVRUEHQWS &S  IW   &S   





*:DV*LQQGHGLWLRQ)LJXUHVDUHODEHOHG*






 




















* :DV*LQQGHGLWLRQ
 D :LWK4'6ZLWKQRGHVILQG W FHQWHU PLQ 
   W 07=   PLQ 

* :DV*LQQGHGLWLRQ

 D  ' ) '  ( 5 ) 
  )LQG &$ DQG&%  
Y)
  (TD X SRUW 
0 % 0 $
&% &$
)  FP  PLQ
   Y)  
 FP PLQ 
H 'F    

   X SRUW  FP PLQ 
 
 
   W VZ  / X SRUW     PLQ
   &$ YLQW HU X $ 0X SRUW  FP PLQ 

   YLQW HU  FP PLQ 

   YVXS HU  YLQW HU  FP PLQ 

  5HF\FOH5DWH     FP  PLQ 
  2EWDLQHGUDIILQDWH DQGH[WUDFW 
 E 2QH DSSURDFK LV WR NHHS D V\PPHWULF F\FOH  7KHQ '   DQG
( )
( 5  

  )ORZ RSWLPL]HU FDQ EH XVHG WR JLYH W VZ a  DQG 5HF\FOH UDWH a   'HSHQGLQJ RQ
YDOXHVREWDLQUDIILQDWHDQGH[WUDFW!

* :DV*LQQGHGLWLRQ)LJXUHEHORZLVODEHOHG*

* :DV*LQQGHGLWLRQ)LJXUHEHORZLVODEHOHG*





 





 




 

* :DV*LQQGHGLWLRQ

 D N PD S PLQ  / FP 



  PO PLQ
  Y VXS HU  FP PLQ 
P  

 FP PLQ
  (T FP   
PLQ 
  6DWLVILHGEXWFORVH7KXVVRPHE\SDVVHVEXWPRVWXQGHUJRHVHTXLOLEUDWLRQ

* :DV*LQQGHGLWLRQ)LJXUHLVODEHOHG*




 

+1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ6SUHDGVKHHWVZLWKQXPEHUVDQGIRUPXODVVKRZQ












 

+1HZSUREOHPLQUGHGLWLRQ7KHVSUHDGVKHHWVDUHVKRZQRQWKHQH[WSDJHV7KH\DUHEDVHGRQ
WKH SUHYLRXV EXW LQFOXGHV ERWK D VWHS XS DQG D VWHS GRZQ  %HFDXVH RI WKH TXLUN LQ ([FHO QRW
DOORZLQJ QHJDWLYH DUJXPHQWV LW ZDV VHW XS ZLWK PXOWLSOH VROXWLRQ SDWKV  7KH FRUUHFW VROXWLRQ
RFFXUVZKHQWKHUHDUHQXPEHUV

7LPHPLQ          

&            


!

! !



 !



 !