Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Stockton University
Tait Chirenje
Envl 3241
THE EFFECTS OF ILL-PLANNING FROM THE SMEDLEY TRACT PARK CONSTRUCTION SITE 1
Abstract
In the summer of 2018, sediments originating from storm drains and retention basins at
the Smedley Tract Park site, located in Media, Pennsylvania, made their way to the local
spring-fed creek, Spring Run. This caused significant discoloration to the otherwise transparent
water. A local resident, Jaclynne Polcino, contacted Dr. Tait Chirenje of Stockton University in
the hopes of determining the cause of turbid water within the creek. Our group’s investigation
was launched with the hopes of confirming the source and cause of sediment pollution. The laws
and regulations that dictate the construction site’s practices were researched to determine the
legality of the matter. It was determined that the Dodge Construction Company is at fault for
violating Delaware County Regulations § 141-25 Pollution and refuse, as their permitting was
revoked in response to residential complaints. Therefore, any sediment discharge which took
place in October of 2018 could be regarded as unlawful and may be subject to fine. In addition,
the adverse effects of sediment pollution were also researched. Suspended solids can lead to
Table of Contents
Abstract 1
Legality of Events 14
Environmental Concerns 16
Conclusion 17
References 18
THE EFFECTS OF ILL-PLANNING FROM THE SMEDLEY TRACT PARK CONSTRUCTION SITE 3
The Smedley Tract Park site is located in Media, Pennsylvania directly north of
Middletown Road (39°55'13.4"N 75°25'34.7"W). The site sits in between a more populated
shopping area to the south a suburban community to the north and is approximately 512 meters
(1,678 feet) west of the local Penncrest High School and directly across West Rose Tree Road
from its adjacent athletic fields. It is currently owned by Middletown Township as a means of
creating a neighborhood park over the old agricultural fields donated by the Smedley Family to
the county.
Figure 1:
The site in question is the ‘County Park (Site Development drawing to be prepared)’ within Media Borough, approximately 2 miles from
Smedley Tract was historically the site of farming from the late 16th century to the mid
20th century; several on-site buildings and facilities support this. Talks of construction on the
Smedley site goes back as far as 2005 when the land boundaries were surveyed. Middletown
Township purchased the property from the Smedley Group in order to prevent developments
from being built on the site. In 2010, plans to begin altering the then farmland into a park began.
In 2018, construction was approved and hence began site operations. The construction of a park
on the Smedley Tract is part of a greater operation called the “Middletown Township Recreation
& Open Space Plan”, which began in 2000. The plan lays out recommendations to construct five
to eleven mini parks and three to eight neighborhood parks between the years 2000 and 2020
Figure 2:
Smedley tract consists of two agricultural fields, shown in Figure 2; Field Area A, which
is the southernmost field and is situated on approximately 10 acres of land, and Field Area B,
THE EFFECTS OF ILL-PLANNING FROM THE SMEDLEY TRACT PARK CONSTRUCTION SITE 5
which is the northernmost field and is situated on approximately 11.1 acres of land. Bisecting the
two fields is a private road which leads to the various on-site buildings historically used for past
farming operations, as shown in Figure 3. There are seven buildings: One general barn (Bank
Barn), one dairy barn (Test Barn), one shed (Wagon Shed) and four residential buildings. Along
with the buildings is a communications tower owned by Middletown Township and leased to
American Tower. This tower is located just to the north of Field Area A. It is of an important
note that all buildings on-site are considered to be of significant cultural heritage. As such, these
buildings are likely to remain standing in the future and possibly redesignated in role to suit park
The Bank Barn is deemed to be the most prominent building on the site. It consists of a
main building with two silos. The barn silos were added in the 1920s as part of the ongoing dairy
operations taking place at the farm. Along with this, cold storage was built inside for dairy
products. Currently, the barn is in a state of severe disrepair after being abandoned for several
years. In an effort to preserve the barn, stabilization construction will occur. Several suggestions
as to what the barn can be used for in the future have been taken into consideration (Smedley
The Test Barn was constructed in the 1920s as a result of the dairy operations at the farm.
The barn housed cattle at the time of its construction to when farm operations ceased. Despite it
not being maintained, the barn remains in fair condition and requires very little reconstruction to
occur. Like with the Bank Barn, the Test Barn has several potential uses laid out in the master
plan for park construction (Smedley Tract Master Site Plan, 2010).
The Wagon Shed was built around the time the original farm house was built. It consists
of an older stone construction with a modern wooden construction. Currently, the shed is being
utilized as a vehicle shed and remains in very good condition. The Wagon Shed is planned to
remain a vehicle garage once the park opens, allowing it to be preserved (Smedley Tract Master
The Hilltop Residence is one of four residential buildings located on the site. It sits on
West Rose Tree Road and is currently occupied. As such, the building is in very good condition
and is in no need to maintenance. Since it is owned, the best option for this building is to keep it
The Longview Residence is the second of the residential buildings on site. Historically, it
was used as the farm creamery and offices during dairy operations. Despite being vacant, it is
currently in good condition and only requires painting on the outside. For the future park
operations, it is suggested that this building become the site of park offices and some indoor park
The Oaklawn building is the third of the residential buildings on site. Despite there being
local accounts stating that the building was once a schoolhouse, there is no evidence to prove so.
The building is currently vacant and is in good shape, though minor repairs need to be done to its
roof and a new coating of paint needs to be applied to the outside. Plans for the park involve the
Oaklawn building remaining a residency going forward (Smedley Tract Master Site Plan, 2010).
The Spring House is the final of the residential buildings on site and is located the
furthest down from the farm’s private road. The building is fairly small and historically has been
used mainly as a residency. The current state of the structure is fair, requiring some maintenance
during park construction. Going forth, it is planned that the building will continue to act as a
Our group’s investigation was launched with the hopes of determining the source and
cause of sediment pollution. Along with this, we wanted to know any adverse effects the
sediment could have on both Spring Run and its outlet, Ridley Creek. As the sediment-polluted
water was being discharged into the wooded area, it is suggested that contractors in charge of the
site are violating environmental regulations that have been enacted by federal, state and local
legislation. In order to determine these violations, we have researched the regulations that dictate
the site’s practices and identified environmental concerns that are potentially related.
THE EFFECTS OF ILL-PLANNING FROM THE SMEDLEY TRACT PARK CONSTRUCTION SITE 8
The concern for this site lies in the fact that sediments originating from storm drains and
retention basins made their way to the local spring-fed creek, Spring Run, and caused significant
discoloration to the otherwise transparent waters. The source of the creek originates in the
wooded area just to the southeast of Field Area B and continues flowing north east through
several residential areas in Media, Pennsylvania. The sediment entering the creek was caused by
a period of heavy rainfall in early October. After which a local resident, Jaclynne Polcino,
contacted Dr. Tait Chirenje of Stockton University in the hopes of determining the cause of
turbid water within the creek. She was concerned the discharged sediment water may have been
toxic. According to town officials, the sediment had made its way from retention basins and
storm drains built on the Smedley site during a period of heavy rainfall. After the initial incident,
in late October, a similar period of heavy rainfall again caused sediments to be deposited into the
creek.
After an on-site investigation by our group, it was determined that waters carrying the
sediments could have originated from one of three retention basins built on-site in order to
contain waters carrying loose sediments from ongoing construction. Two of the retention basins
were located on Field Area A and one located on Field Area B. Conditions at both field areas
were extremely muddy from rainfall and channels where water had washed away surface
sediments were evident. Though it seems that attempts to contain the flow of water were present;
In the form of silt fences lining the property and several dirt banks on hill slopes, the volume of
precipitation had encroached upon the fencing limits. During site inspection, it was noted that the
THE EFFECTS OF ILL-PLANNING FROM THE SMEDLEY TRACT PARK CONSTRUCTION SITE 9
retention basins were filled with water with a very similar color to that of the creek during
sedimentation. In order to control overflow, outlets comprised of loose rock were added in each
of the basins. The retention basin of concern was situated on Field Area A. The retention basin in
this area had its outlet facing directly to the hill that leads to Spring Run’s source. It is likely that
this basin had overflowed two times during the two periods of heavy rainfall, causing water
Along with the retention basins, a storm drainage system was installed on the site. The
system appeared to be very new, likely being installed not too long after construction began.
Evidence of another drain being installed in Field Area B supports this. The drainage system
flows underground and down the hill to the west of Field Area A and discharges directly into the
woods where Spring Run’s source is located. Upon inspection of the discharge pipe, sediments
of very similar color to that of the water in both the retention basins and in the creek were
observed along the sides of the pipe discharge point. It is likely that the water from this drainage
system carried water contaminated with sediments directly to the area of the source of Spring
Run.
Township forwarded to our group reveal that an inspector was sent to the site following initial
complaints. The contractors at the site were then advised to stop the excessive discharging of
sediment-polluted waters into the area of Spring Run’s source. Despite this, less than a month
later, the creek was again flooded with sediment-polluted water after another period of heavy
rainfall, indicating that the contractors had not followed the proper procedures put in place by the
town inspector.
THE EFFECTS OF ILL-PLANNING FROM THE SMEDLEY TRACT PARK CONSTRUCTION SITE 10
In the past, soil from an off-site source was deposited on the fields. Large mounds of the
soils and boulders were observed during our observations. According to Jaclynne Polcino, the
soil came from the site of a previous department store which now is the location of new
apartment complexes, located just south of Middletown Road. It is possible the soils are being
The Clean Water Act (CWA) prohibits the discharge of pollutants into navigable
waterways from a point source unless, the discharge was authorized by a National Pollution
Discharge Elimination System (“NPDES”) permit. Under the Clean Water Act it is required that
certain industrial facilities, construction sites, and municipal separate storm sewer systems
(MS4) receive coverage for stormwater discharges under a NPDES permit. As well, they are
Management Plan (SMP) and establish measures to prevent the discharge of pollutants in the
The National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NJDES), specifically the NPDES
Stormwater Program, regulates stormwater discharges from the following potential sources:
municipal separate storm sewer systems (MS4s), construction activities and industrial activities.
A NPDES permit is required from the operators of these sources before discharging stormwater
to prevent stormwater runoff from washing harmful pollutants into local surface waters. The
components of the NJDES permit program. These responsibilities may include the permitting,
In the state of Pennsylvania, the responsibility for administering the federal Clean Water
Act and state stormwater regulations resides with the Department of Environmental Protection
(DEP). In order to regulate and manage stormwater the Pennsylvania DEP utilizes programs such
as, NPDES Permit for Municipal Small and Large Separate Storm Sewer System (MS4
Program), NPDES Permits for Discharges Associated with Construction Activities, and the
The PA Stormwater Management Act of 1978 provides the legislative basis for
storm-water management. It calls for storm-water management plans from counties within
designated watersheds and that each municipality assumes stormwater regulations to implement
each respective plan. There are 376 designated stormwater management watersheds in PA and
each one has its own natural, social and cultural features that may require flexibility to address
located within two watersheds, Ridley Creek Watershed and Chester Creek Watershed
The NPDES permitting and compliance monitoring programs for industrial, municipal
and commercial stormwater in PA are administered by the Bureau of Clean Water. This
department of also oversees the implementation of the Act 167 stormwater management program
from the regional offices of the state’s DEP. The Stormwater Management Act, also referred to
THE EFFECTS OF ILL-PLANNING FROM THE SMEDLEY TRACT PARK CONSTRUCTION SITE 12
as Act 167, was created in order to encourage planning and management of stormwater runoff in
each watershed, authorize a comprehensive program of storm water management and encourage
local administration and management of stormwater consistent with the Commonwealth's duty as
trustee of natural resources and the people's constitutional right to the preservation of natural,
economic, scenic, aesthetic, recreational and historic values of the environment. (Stormwater
Management Act, 1978). According to the DEP, each county must prepare and adopt a
watershed stormwater management plan for each watershed in the county and it must be
reviewed periodically reviewed and revised every five years. (PADEP, 2018)
As an operator of a stormwater sewer system, the Borough of Media holds a MS4 permit
that requires participation in the NPDES Phase II stormwater management program. In 2017,
Media Borough adopted the Media Borough Stormwater Master Plan i n order to establish best
management practices for stormwater ( Media Borough). The plan addresses stormwater runoff
by identifying and prioritizing the most effective projects throughout the borough to address
flooding and related environmental problems in the town. The Borough has decided to
engagement a stable approach of, “Increasing the service capacity of stormwater collection to
meet standards for urban design.” As well as, “Evaluating a full range of potential ‘green
infrastructure’ interventions which will provide a means to explore a wide-range of options that
will allow plan flexibility to suit the Borough’s needs and align better with current and future
planning goals.” (T&M Associates, 2017). The stormwater management plan for Media
THE EFFECTS OF ILL-PLANNING FROM THE SMEDLEY TRACT PARK CONSTRUCTION SITE 13
highlighted 6 program goals in the executive summary of the report. Those include, (1)
enhancing the overall quality of life for the residents by addressing nuisance flooding issues that
are common in the Borough, (2) address the water quality concerns common to urbanized areas,
(3) use green infrastructure to address resident stormwater concerns and the MS4 pollution
reduction planning goals, (4) to utilize a balanced approach to meeting these goals through a mix
of traditional grey infrastructure and green infrastructure strategies, (5) to develop partnerships to
take advantage of opportunities for runoff reduction, and (6) to provide a model for other
communities for sustainable redevelopment (T&M Associates, 2017). Green infrastructure seeks
to protect, restore or mimic the natural water cycle through a decentralized stormwater approach.
The plan concluded that the main flooding problem areas are contained within five distinct
‘drainage-sheds’ for Media Borough. Evaluation of the existing problem areas was based on each
drainage-shed (T&M Associates, 2017). This plan was designed to determine innovative
methods to increase the effectiveness of the stormwater system in Media, to reduce the frequency
and extent of flooding and to determine the best alternatives for correcting insufficiencies within
the system, adopted in 2017 the plan was to begin implementation in 2018.
have been proposed and plan to be implemented during the design development and construction
documentation phase of the project. The Master Site Plan intends various storm-water facilities
for the Smedley Tract Park. These facilities include, perimeter infiltration trenches and
THE EFFECTS OF ILL-PLANNING FROM THE SMEDLEY TRACT PARK CONSTRUCTION SITE 14
underground detention and/or infiltration beds for the athletic fields, pervious surfaces (in the
parking lot, loop trail, playground safety surface) as well as, two large infiltration areas below
each athletic field area. It is noted that the large infiltration areas will be designed to hold
shallow amounts of storm-water that will slowly infiltrate into the soil the majority of the time.
In the face of larger rain events the areas will hold rainwater for up to 24 hours, both areas will
include emergency overflow structures to transport storm-water to natural drainage ways on the
site at controlled rates (Simone Collins, 2010). The Plan also states that solutions for stormwater
management are offered by the Pennsylvania Handbook of Best Management Practices for
Developing Areas. It also mentions that incorporation of Best Management Practices, such as
porous paving in lots and underground infiltration for recreation facilities, require site specific
soil tests to determine site suitability and the infiltration rates of the existing soils (Simon
Collins, 2010). There is clear intent for the current developers to utilize BMPs while creating the
Park in Middletown however, there is no evidence as to how they are implementing BMPs from
this document.
Legality of Events
The current task at the site is to stabilize Smedley land for park appliances such as a
hiking trail, grass fields and possible playing fields (Smedley Tract Master Site Plan, 2010).
However, with recent weather patterns, increased precipitation has allowed for water and
sediment to overflow previously set retention basins (Philadelphia International). As a result, the
manager of Dodge Construction, contracted by the town to stabilize the site, dumped excess
water and sediment down a corridor into the Spring Run Creek. Dumping of excess sediment
THE EFFECTS OF ILL-PLANNING FROM THE SMEDLEY TRACT PARK CONSTRUCTION SITE 15
into the creek presents itself as purposefully disregarding legislation from the surrounding area
The Spring Run creek, which runs through several neighborhoods and into other main
waterways such as Pine Ridge Run and Crum Creek carried sediment rich water through part of
the Delaware county, impacting the Ridley Creek watershed. Although the town was aware of
the contractors actions, public concern of turbid creek water which runs through individual
homeowners properties initiated the forced termination of the discharge into Spring Run Creek.
The main cause for current concern includes the possible illegality of the contractor’s
methods to remove sediment rich water from several Smedley park retention basins. However, as
previously stated, the increased sedimentation within the waterway was noted on several
accounts after the initial supposed termination of the process. As the action of transferring the
retention basin water directly into the stream below impacted nearby residences, they may be
able to file a claim against the contractor as well as the town in regards to sediment pollution. In
accordance to the legislation described above, the contractor and town is responsible for
obtaining federal permits such as NPDES permitting and SMP. As the site of concern is a
mini-park under Smedley park, Volume III: County Parks and Recreation Plan is responsible for
listing necessary permits. Within the volume, Chapter 6: Smedley County Park p rovides further
information. The chapter states that the Smedley County Park system has already obtained
PADEP and NPDES permitting. However, under The Delaware County’s section § 141-25
Pollution and refuse, t wo subject headers stand out in regard to the current sediment pollution;
A. Pollution of waters. No person shall, within or without said parks, discharge into the
waters of the parks or any tributary, river, brook, stream, storm sewer or drain flowing
into said waters any substance which may result in the pollution of said waters.
THE EFFECTS OF ILL-PLANNING FROM THE SMEDLEY TRACT PARK CONSTRUCTION SITE 16
C. Dumping. No person or company shall dump any material anywhere within the park
without the written authorization of the Parks Department. This is to include depositing in
any dumpster, waste station, garbage can, or recycling can any waste which is generated
outside of the park.
According to these Delaware County regulations, the Dodge Construction company must
have pre-authorization to dump excess sediment-rich water into the creek from the Parks
Department. Although Dodge Construction was approved for the first sediment discharge
occurrence, the termination of their actions by the town discounts further sediment unloading
into the creek. The Code Enforcement Director from Media Borough, Jim Jeffery, was contacted
Environmental Concerns
Suspended solids are naturally found in waterways. Problems occur when there is a
surplus of suspended solids. Often, it is the smallest, most fine particles that cause the serious
problems. Increased suspended solids makes the water more turbid or cloudy. This then limits
the amount of sunlight that reaches aquatic plants – stunting their growth. Fine particles of
suspended solids can also clog fish gills and harm their respiration. Another problem with
suspended soils is that they can make their way into drinking-water treatment plants and interfere
with the efficiency of the water disinfection by shielding microorganisms from the disinfectant.
There are then surviving microbes that enter the drinking water (Hill, 2010).
Water also contains some natural plant debris and wildlife feces which microorganisms in
the water decompose. Microorganisms require a certain amount of dissolved oxygen (DO) to
decompose a given amount of organic material and this is known as the Biochemical Oxygen
THE EFFECTS OF ILL-PLANNING FROM THE SMEDLEY TRACT PARK CONSTRUCTION SITE 17
Demand (BOD). Increased BOD caused by human activities can have negative effects on the
water body. High BOD can reduce or deplete the DO in the water. These low oxygen conditions
are known as hypoxic conditions. Fish can swim away from these hypoxic areas. However,
crabs, snails, and other sedentary organisms usually die (Hill, 2010).
The site drains into the Spring Run, which is a tributary to Ridley Creek. The portion of
Ridley Creek to which Spring Run drains is classified as a High Quality-Trout Stocking Fishery.
Suspended solids could decrease aquatic plant life, which could decrease the amount of trout in
this area. Similarly, hypoxic conditions could cause a decrease in the fish populations as they
Conclusion
After weeks of heavy rainfall on the Media Borough, PA area, the Smedley Track Park
construction site found it necessary to discharge their overflowing retention basins into the woods below.
Sediment discharge from the site ran into Spring Run Creek, a spring-fed creek which flows through
several residential areas and into larger bodies of water such as Ridley Creek. Spring Run’s excess
sedimentation may cause environmental pollution such as increased turbidity and lowered
dissolved oxygen concentrations. With concern for the area, further research into the federal,
state and local legislation determined that the Dodge Construction Company is at fault for
violating Delaware County Regulations § 141-25 Pollution and refuse, as their permitting was
revoked in response to residential complaints. Therefore, any sediment discharge which took
place in October of 2018 could be regarded as unlawful and may be subject to fine.
THE EFFECTS OF ILL-PLANNING FROM THE SMEDLEY TRACT PARK CONSTRUCTION SITE 18
References
etrieved from:
Media Borough. (2018). Media Borough Stormwater Master Plan. R
https://www.mediaborough.com/publicworks/media-borough-stormwater-master-plan
etrieved from:
Middletown Township: Delaware County, Pennsylvania. (2018). History. R
https://www.middletowntownship.org/index.asp?SEC=70C31AB4-45D0-4234-8259-7C3
02EDE108E&DE=048A9840-1930-4152-AEA3-C101C9E5ECCD
etrieved from :
PADEP, (2018). Act 167. R
https://www.dep.pa.gov/Business/Water/CleanWater/StormwaterMgmt/Pages/Act-167.as
px
etrieved from:
PADEP, (2018). Stormwater Management. R
https://www.dep.pa.gov/Business/Water/CleanWater/StormwaterMgmt/Pages/default.asp
x
Pennsylvania DEP, (1978). STORM WATER MANAGEMENT ACT: Act of Oct. 4, 1978, P.L.
864,
etrieved from:
No. 167. R
http://www.depgreenport.state.pa.us/elibrary/GetDocument?docId=8143&DocName=ST
ORM%20WATER%20MANAGEMENT%20ACT-ACT%20167%20OF%201978.PDF
%20%20%3cspan%20style%3D%22color:blue%3b%22%3e%3c/span%3e
Philadelphia International, PA History. (2018, October). Retrieved December 10, 2018, from
https://www.wunderground.com/history/monthly/KPHL/date/2018-10?req_city=Media&
req_state=PA&req_statename=Pennsylvania&reqdb.zip=19063&reqdb.magic=1&reqdb.
wmo=99999
Simone Collins Landscape and Architecture, (2010). Smedley Tract Master Site Plan:
Middletown Township, Delaware County, PA. P age 49-52. Retrieved from:
https://www.middletowntownship.org/vertical/sites/%7BE08CD8FE-6BF2-4104-AF8F-
C16770381A63%7D/uploads/%7B4A02692C-5276-4C0E-A3B3-54C3584F8961%7D.P
DF
Smedley Tract Master Site Plan, (2010). Retrieved December, 2018, from
https://www.middletowntownship.org/vertical/sites/{E08CD8FE-6BF2-4104-AF8F-C16
770381A63}/uploads/{4A02692C-5276-4C0E-A3B3-54C3584F8961}.PDF
T&M Associates, (2017). Media Stormwater Master Plan: Borough of Media, PA. Retrieved
from:
https://www.mediaborough.com/sites/default/files/fileattachments/public_works/page/15
531/media_stormwater_master_plan_final_-_july_2017_1.pdf
etrieved from:
USEPA, (2018). Clean Water Act (CWA) Compliance Monitoring. R
https://www.epa.gov/compliance/clean-water-act-cwa-compliance-monitoring
etrieved from:
USEPA, (2018). National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES). R
https://www.epa.gov/npdes/npdes-stormwater-program