You are on page 1of 36

Introduction

Money, Banking and Financial Markets:


Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168)
Unit 1
Fall term 2017
Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
Todays lecture

• Monetary policy and international finance

• Financial markets and financial institutions

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
1
Monetary Policy & International Finance
Mishkin, Chapter 1

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
2
Why study monetary policy ?

Money Supply

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
3
Money and inflation

• Increases in money supply are associated with increases in the


aggregate price level (inflation)

Reasons why Central Bank like postive inflation:


• Inflation affects the decisions of firms
- It makes wage negoations easier. Real cost of
− wages / labor demand labor has went down, if wages stay the same.

− prices and production - Hyperinflation: Prices need to be changed


serveral times.
− leverage and investment - Inflation also affects leverage. Usually bank will
factor in inflation into nominal rates

• Inflation affects the decisions of households


− labor supply
− consumption
− leverage, asset allocation

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
4
Money and inflation: Selected countries 2003 - 2013

Source: Mishkin (2015), Figure 1-5.

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
5
Money and inflation: USA 1950 - 2016
(Prices)
(Money Supply)

Reasons for the gap:

Money is used as a
mechanism for storing
wealth

Source: Mishkin (2015), Figure 1-4.

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
6
Money and interest rates

• Changes in the money supply are associated with changes in


interest rates

• Alters the cost of borrowing and the return on savings

• Changes in interest rates affect the investment choices of firms

• Changes in interest rates affect the consumption and investment


choices of households
Inflation affects nominal rates, which in turn affects investment choices. Lower nominal rates makes investment more
attractive.

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
7
Money growth and interest rates: USA 1960 - 2016

(Money)

(nominal interest rate)

Source: research.stlouisfed.org

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
8
Money, interest rates and financial fragility

“.. by lowering the cost of credit and increasing the value of assets, low
interest rates could provide the breeding ground for asset price and credit
booms. In this regard, the current developments in Swiss mortgage and real
estate markets are telling: real estate prices and mortgage credit have been
growing with considerable momentum for several years already.
Importantly, the growth rates of both prices and credit volumes are at
levels which cannot be fully explained by fundamental factors. This has led
to the built-up of imbalances which increase the risk of a substantial price
corrections and of loan losses. “

Jean-Pierre Danthine, 14.11.2013


at Swisscanto Market Outlook 2014

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
9
According to S&P 500, Low interest rates is accerlating
Switzerland 2000-2015 mortgage growth. Slashing of interest rates does not
seem to imply a spur in the mortgage market
(Investment decisions), maybe helps with sustaining
growth.
3.50
240.00
3.00

190.00 2.50

2.00

Libor 3-Month Rate


Index (2000=100)

140.00
1.50
100 in the
year 2000.
1.00
90.00
0.50

0.00
40.00

-0.50

-10.00 -1.00
2000 2003 2006 2009 2012 2015

Residential space - Rental apartments (1 to 5 rooms) - Total


Mortgage Credit Volume
3-Month Libor Rate (Interest Rates)

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
10
Why study international finance?

• Goods markets and financial markets are increasingly globalized

• Exchange rates affect Diversed Portfolio - Global investments


− the price of exported and imported goods
− the value of assets and liabilities denominated in foreign currencies

• Changes in exchange rates affect the revenues, production and


investment choices of firms

• Changes in exchange rates affect the income / wealth of


households as well as relative prices of goods Appreciation of CHF /EUR has a
postive impact. (Next page)
− affect consumption and investment choices

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
11
Trade: Swiss imports/exports

• 2016: 298 bn CHF exports and 266 bn CHF imports

350
In bn CHF

300

250

200

150 Big jump happen in 2011,


as it includes trading of
gold and precious metal,
100
while previously it has
not been included.
50

0
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

Imports Exports

Source: BFS - Statistisches Lexikon der Schweiz

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
12
Capital flows: Portfolio and other investment

• 2016: Portfolio investment 1,282 (1,106) bn CHF Assets (Liabilities)

• 2016: Other investment 837 (1,215) bn CHF Assets (Liabilities)


300%
Portfolioinvestment \ GDP

250%

200%

150%

100%

50%

0%

Portfolioinvestments_Assets Portfolioinvestments_Liabilities
Other_Investment_Assets Other_Investment_Liabilities

Other investment: Currency and deposits of SNB and banks; Loans of SNB,
public sector and other sectors Sources: snb.ch; GDP from seco.ch

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
13
Example:
Nestle invest in Local Infrastructure in
Capital flows: Foreign direct investment Germany (Foreign Direct Investment)

Nestle invest in US Government Bonds


(Portoflio Investment)

• 2016: 1,120 (794) bn CHF Assets (Liabilities)

200%
180%
160%
140%
FDI / GDP

120%
100%
80%
60%
40%
20%
0%

Swiss_FDI_abroad
FDI_in_Switzerland

Sources: snb.ch; seco.ch

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
14
Exchange rates affects value of assets when denominated in
the foreign currency.

Exchange rate CHF: 2000 - 2017 Snce the Financial Crisis, CHF has significantly appreciated
against the EUR.

120

100

80

60
Index : Jan 2000 = 100

40

20

CHF/US CHF/EU CHF/GBP

Source: Quandl, 10.8.2017

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
15
Any exchnage rate changes will
Multinational corporations: Swiss examples affect the value of the assets of the
company.

Sources: Nestlé Annual Report 2016, Swatch Group Annual Report 2015

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
16
Exchange rate fluctuations heavily affect MNCs

• Stock prices at SIX Swiss Exchange in CHF of globally vs nationally


oriented Swiss companies after the removal of the CHF/EUR floor
Discounts future revenue as well.

110

105

100
Index 1.1.2015 = 100

95 Swisscom
90 Nestle
Swatch
85
CHF/USD
80

75

70
02.01.2015 17.01.2015 01.02.2015 16.02.2015

Sources: yahoo finance

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
17
Exchange rate fluctuations and the real economy

Source: http://www.swissmem.ch/en/news-medien/news/mem-industrie-die-frankenstaerke-hinterlaesst-deutliche-spuren.html

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
18
International finance and monetary policy

• A country cannot independently choose its monetary policy,


exchange rate regime (fixed, floating) and currency regime (free
capital account vs. capital controls)

Example (Free Capital Flow,


Soverign Monetary Policy, No Trillema of International Finance
Fixed Exchange Rate) :
US , Switzerland

Example (Free Capital Flow,


Fixed Exchange Rate, No
Soverign Monetary Policy):
Bulgaria, Austria

Example(Fixed Exchange Rate,


Soverign Monetary Police, No
Free Capital Flow) :
China

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impossible_trinity#/media/File:Impossible_trinity_diagram.svg

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
19
Financial Markets & Institutions
Mishkin Chapter 2

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
20
Relevance for monetary policy

• The conduct of monetary policy occurs primarily through financial


market operations

• The supply of money depends strongly on the credit activity of


financial institutions

• The volume of available “money” is strongly connected to the


liability structure of financial institutions

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
21
Direct finance: Financial markets

Typically, Firms do not directlly sell


product and lend money from
Lenders/Borrowers. Hence, there is a
need for Financial Intermediaries

Financial Financial
Intermediaries/ Intermediaries/
Investment Bank Investment Bank

Source: Mishkin (2015), Figure 2-1

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
22
Financial instruments & markets
Traditional Monetary Policy only targets the Money market only!

Debt instruments Equities


Short-term Commerical
(< 1 year) Paper, Treasury Money market
Bills
Capital market
Long-term Bonds,
(=> 1 year) Equities Capital market

• Debt vs. Equity: what are the differences ?


− seniority of claim
− fixed vs. ‘variable’ income

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
23
Financial instruments and monetary policy

Debt instruments Equities


Short-term
(< 1 year) Money market
Capital market
Long-term
(=> 1 year) Capital market

• Conventional monetary policy operates mainly through the money


market

• Unconventional monetary policy may target the capital market


directly (i.e. long-term debt)

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
24
Money market instruments

REPO
Agreements

Source: Mishkin (2015)

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
25
Capital market instruments: USA

Source: Mishkin (2015)

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
26
Capital and money market: Switzerland

Outstanding Amount
In bn CHF 2000 2008 2013
Capital Market
Shares and other equity (domestic
341 436 571
issuers)
Debt securities (domestic issuers excl.
238 267 287
Gov.)
Debt securities General Government 103 138 133

Money Market
Money market instruments (Swiss bank
54 93 78
liab.)
Interbank lending (Swiss bank liab.) 525 664 407

Source: SNB Swiss Financial Accounts Table 1


Banks in Switzerland Table 18

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
27
Financial market structure and monetary policy

• Primary market: Issuance of new securities


− primary dealers: government debt
− investment banks: equity, corporate debt

• Secondary market: Trading in existing securities


− exchange: listed stocks
− over the counter (OTC): bonds. unlisted stocks, repo

• Monetary policy is mainly implemented via OTC transactions in


secondary markets

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
28
Indirect finance: Financial intermediaries

Source: Mishkin (2013)

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
29
Financial intermediaries: Rationale

• Lower transaction costs


− economies of scale

• Deal with asymmetric information Brokerage


− adverse selection (before the transaction)
− moral hazard (after the transaction)

• Risk sharing
− interest rate risk
− liquidity risk
Asset
transformation
− credit risk

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
30
Financial intermediaries: US

Source: Mishkin (2015)

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
31
Asset structure: Swiss banks December 2016

Regional-
Big banks Cantonal Raiffeisen-
in % of total assets Big banks and savings
(domestic only) banks banks
banks
Cash 13% 25% 15% 10% 9%
Customer Loans (incl.
43% 57% 70% 85% 80%
mortgages)
Interbank Loans 10% 5% 3% 2% 3%
Tradable Securities 7% 3% 2% 0% 1%

Total assets in bn CHF 1454 546 553 116 215

Sources: SNB

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
32
Liability structure: Swiss banks December 2016

Regional-
Big banks Cantonal Raiffeisen-
in % of total assets Big banks and savings
(domestic only) banks banks
banks
Liabilities from financial
8% 0% 0% 0% 1%
instruments

Interbank Liabilities 8% 6% 10% 5% 6%

Savings and Sight deposits 38% 54% 51% 56% 56%


Time deposits 4% 3% 4% 2% 7%
Bonds and central mortgage
18% 7% 16% 17% 11%
institution loans

Total Liabilities 1454 554 553 116 215

Sources: SNB

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
33
Key messages

• Monetary policy affects inflation and interest rates


− influence the behavior of firms and households and thus real
economic outcomes
− also influences financial stability

• Goods and capital markets are increasingly globalized


− changes in exchange rates influence the behavior of firms and
households and thus real economic outcomes

• Monetary policy is mainly implemented via over the counter,


secondary financial markets
− the credit activity and liability structure of financial institutions also
influences money supply

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
34
Self-Study 1

• Impact of monetary policy on a Swiss pension fund

Monetary Policy and International Finance (3,168), Prof. Dr. Martin Brown
35

You might also like