Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Goals:
–1–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
Source: “Cellphone envy lays Motorola low”, Brad Stone, New York Times, Business Day Section, page B1, 2/3/2007.
–2–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
If you don’t keep an unsold item in inventory you may have to sell it at a loss.
If you don’t order enough inventory, you lose the opportunity to make a sale.
–3–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
–4–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
–5–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
–6–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
–7–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
The news vendor must purchase newspapers at the start of the day before attempting to
sell them at her designated street corner.
The news vendor pays $0.35 for each newspaper, sells each newspaper for $1.00 and
each unsold newspaper has a value of $0.01 at the end of the day.
Our news vendor orders a quantity y first, then observes (probabilistic) demand second.
–8–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
Example product
Data Newspaper O’Neill Hammer 3/2
p Per-item sales revenue $1.00 $180
c Manuf./acquisition cost 0.35 110
s End-period salvage revenue 0.01 90
–9–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
Step 2: Generate a demand model: (From historical data, expert opinion) Use
a probability model for estimating demand. You may choose to use a stan-
dard distribution function to represent demand, e.g. the normal distribu-
tion, the Poisson distribution or base your demand on the use of historical
data using an empirical demand distribution.
–10–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
Forecasts and actual demand for surf wet-suits from the previous season
–11–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
P (demand ≤ Q) ≡ P (Z ≤ z1 ), where
Q−µ
z1 =
σ
–12–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
z = 325−300
50 = 0.5.
–13–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
P (demand ≤ Q) = 0.975.
Note:
Q−µ
z1 = or Q = µ + z1 × σ
σ
(The above are two ways to write the same equation, the first allows you to calculate z
–14–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
from Q and the second lets you calculate Q from z.)
Q−µ
P (d ≤ Q) = P (z ≤ ) ≡ Φ(z)
σ
In this example suppose µ = 3192, σ = 1181
and you desire to find the probability that demand
is less than Q = 3664 units.
–15–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
If the news vendor carries one too-many papers, she is left with a marginal profit
of her cost less the salvage value of the extra newspaper (Co ). If the news vendor
carries one too-few papers she incurs the loss of profit corresponding to the price
of the newspaper less her cost (Cu ).
$ per unit
Co Cu
Service Level
↑ Quantity →
Q
Balance point Q = optimal stocking level
Consider the “last” item in the ordering quantity Q.
If demand > Q, then we lose Cu in profits.
If demand < Q then we lose Co in profit.
Since we don’t know demand, we have to compute expected losses.
It makes sense to choose Q so that the marginal expected costs of too much inventory are equal to
the marginal expected cost of too little inventory.
–18–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
Service Level
↑ Quantity →
Q
Balance point: Q = optimal stocking level
Service level is the probability that demand ≤ the stocking level.
Service level is the key to determining the optimal stocking level Q.
C
The critical value is = C +C
u
u o
Suppose our newsvendor has uniform demand between 200 and 400 papers.
For the newsvendor’s newspaper problem = C C+C
u
= 0.65
0.65+0.34 = 0.657.
u o
For the uniform demand case she orders 200 + 0.657 × (400 − 200) = 331 papers
We order Q so that the probability not having enough (stockout) is the critical value
Cu
P (demand ≤ Q) = Cu +Co
–19–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
Service Level =
P(STOCKOUT)=0.656
–20–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
Q = µ+z×σ
= 200 + (0.41)(40)
= 216 papers.
–20–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
Step 3: Lookup 0.7778 Look up critical ratio in the Standard Normal Distribution Function Table (page
377–378) If the critical ratio falls between two values in the table, choose the greater z-statistic For this
product, we choose z = 0.77 (From the table we find that z = 0.77 → P (z ≤ 0.77) = 0.7794.)
Since demand is a random variable, for most choices of Q there will be a positive
probability that actual demand exceeds your choice.
–22–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
200
X
(x − Q) × P (D = x).
x=130
–23–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
L(Q) = Expected Lost sales (the sum of the left-hand column) = 7.777 units.
–24–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
For any choice of Q there will be a positive probability that demand > Q.
The expected number shortfall of units is a positive number for normal demand.
where φ(x) is the normal density with mean µ and standard deviation σ .
L(Q) = L(z) × σ ,
where we convert Q to find z and then look up L(z) in a table (pages 379–380)...
–25–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
0.4
0.3
z = 0.9
Density
0.2
Loss=L(.9)=0.1004
Unshaded
0.1
Area=0.8159
0.0
!4 !2 0 2 4
Q=Quantity
Q−µ 5900−5000
z= σ
= 1000
= 0.9
From page 380 of the text, we find that L(z) = L(0.9) = 0.1004,
Expected Lost Sales = L(z) × σ = (0.1004) × (1000) = 100.4.
–26–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
–27–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
Step 2: Look up in the Standard Normal Loss Function Table (page 379–380 of the text) the expected lost
sales for a standard normal distribution with that z-statistic: L(0.26) = 0.2824
you can find L(z) in Excel, by plugging in your value for z into (e.g. substitute 0.26 for z):
=Normdist(z,0,1,0)-z*(1-Normsdist(z))
= (Price - Cost) × (Expected Sales) −(Cost - Salvage Value) × (Expected Leftover Inventory)
= ($70 × 2858) −($20 × 642)
= $187, 221
Φ(0.26) = 60.26%
–30–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
Step 1: Using pages 377–378 of the textbook, find the z -statistic that yields the target in-stock probability.
In the Standard Normal Distribution Function Table we find Φ(2.32) = 0.9898 and
Φ(2.33) = 0.9901. Choose z = 2.33 to satisfy our in-stock probability constraint.
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
Step 2: Convert the z -statistic into an order quantity for the actual demand distribution.
–31–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
Step 3: Convert the z-statistic into an order quantity for the actual demand distribution.
–32–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
–33–
c Samuel K. Eldersveld – OM301 – May 12, 2008
The expected profit maximizing order quantity balances the too much-too little costs.