You are on page 1of 10

Photo credit: Getty Images

How disruptive technologies are


opening up innovative opportunities
in services
Barathram Ananthakrishnan, Venkat Atluri, Harsha Krishnamurthy, and Senthil Muthiah

Technology and advanced analytics are revolutionizing services—


and creating new sources of value for industrial companies that
know how to use them. Here’s a roadmap that works.

In search of sustainable ways to grow, industrial The proliferation of connected devices and
companies are turning to their vast installed base as sensors, coupled with a thousand-fold increase in
a source of recurring revenues and profits. Revenues computing power over the past decade, is opening
from servicing, especially aftermarket services and up new ways to deliver services and interact with
parts, are generally more stable than those from customers (Exhibit 1). For instance, the IoT (broadly
equipment sales and have shorter lead cycles, so defined as a combination of sensors, analytics,
they offer a way to counter the cyclical nature of and connectivity) allows industrial companies to
capital investments. In some subsectors, such as flow monitor equipment health remotely and develop
control, services tend to generate higher margins new commercial offerings, such as outcome-
than equipment sales. What’s more, pursuing new based contracts in industries with high downtime
servicing opportunities can transform a company’s costs. Industrial companies have started building
relationship with its customers by giving it deeper technology-enabled capabilities to take advantage
insight into how its products are used. of these opportunities. United Technologies, for

McKinsey & Company


EXHIBIT 1 Disruptive trends are reshaping servicing.

Key trends Description Impact

• By 2025, 50% Digital offerings • Use devices that accurately report reason for failure
of workers will led by IoT, AA, to reduce diagnostic time 10–25%
be freelance • Use augmented and virtual technology to help reduction in mean
technicians complete complex repairs more quickly time to repair

• By 2035, 40% 5–20%


of productivity Workforce as a service • Workforce is available whenever and wherever
reduction in
improvements needed to help reduce spend on full-time employee
labor cost
will be driven
10–20%
by AI Dynamic dispatching • Use dynamic dispatching to reduce idle time and improvement in
improve field technicians’ productivity productivity
• By 2021, the 30–40%
Reactive to proactive • Next-generation digital, analytics, and IoT tools
augmented- reduction in mean
service support shift from reactive to proactive service
reality market time to repair
will reach $108
billion Proactive fulfillment of • Anticipate service needs before incident and 10–20 pp
customer needs reduce unplanned downtime improvement in
customer satisfaction

instance, acquired analytics firm Predikto in 2018 Where the value lies
to enhance its predictive-maintenance offerings and Our analysis has identified a pool of approximately
scale its digital and analytics capabilities. $40 billion to $110 billion in revenue growth and $40
billion to $60 billion in margin expansion that could
Many other companies are starting to apply be captured through tech enablement in industrial
advanced analytics (AA) and digital tools to derive services globally (Exhibit 2). This value comes from
instantaneous insights into field operations and use four main sources: a 1 to 3 percent revenue uplift
them to optimize deployment in real time through from cross-selling, upselling, and new business
techniques such as dynamic field dispatching and models; a 3 to 10 percent increase in service revenue
remote servicing. These technologies are allowing from smarter pricing of aftermarket parts and
industrial companies to deliver a step change in services; and a 20 to 30 percent reduction in field-
impact through improved technician productivity, service personnel costs from optimizing demand and
reduced mean time to repair, and higher customer labor management.
satisfaction.
A few leading companies are already achieving
Below, we outline the enormous opportunities that considerable success from efforts like these.
tech-enabled servicing opens up, consider the value One OEM reduced troubleshooting steps for its
potential it unlocks, describe what a successful technicians by 50 percent and increased first-time
approach looks like, and review the steps leaders can fixes by 15 percent, enabling it to cut costs and
take to begin their servicing transformation. increase market share. And an industrial-technology

How disruptive technologies are opening up innovative opportunities in services 1


EXHIBIT 2 The value from tech enablement in servicing varies by industry segment.

Revenue growth Margin expansion


$ billions $ billions

Automotive1 18–49 15–21

Other
mobility2 5–14 ~1

Aerospace/
5–13 2–5
Defense3

Broader
industrials 26–36
& semi- 13–36
conductors4

Total 41–112 44–63

1
Whole value chain including tier-one suppliers, automotive OEMs, and dealers
2
Commercial vehicles and off-highway equipment (e.g., for construction and agricultural use) including tier-one suppliers, equipment
manufacturers, and dealers and distributors
3
Includes tier-one suppliers and equipment manufacturers
4
Includes industrials, food processing and handling, motion and controls, industrial automation, and electrical, power, and test equipment
across the value chain: component suppliers, equipment manufacturers, distributors, VARs, engineering and services providers, and
product companies

provider that turned its field force into a lead- while in others aftermarket revenue was virtually
generation engine saw five to ten percentage points nonexistent.
of incremental revenue growth.
An innovative approach to servicing
The scale of servicing opportunities is best assessed With a successful tech-enabled service strategy, a
by lifetime value, defined as the total revenue an company can not only gain a deeper understanding
OEM can receive from servicing its installed base. of how customers use its products but also increase
When McKinsey analyzed aftermarket lifetime the number of customer touchpoints, giving it
value in more than 40 Fortune 500 companies more opportunities to explore and respond to
ranging from wind-turbine providers to truck customer needs. Our experience of working with
manufacturers, we found striking variations from dozens of industrial companies on technology
one subsector to another (Exhibit 3).1 In some transformations shows that new value can be
industries the lifetime value of the aftermarket created from all parts of the servicing process:
was almost equal to the price of the initial product, managing customer demand, optimizing field labor,

2 McKinsey & Company


EXHIBIT 3 Service revenues vary widely by sector.

Equipment Aftermarket = Product lifetime x Lifetime x Average annual


lifetime value penetration2 service

% Years % % of sales price


Gas
turbines 75% 20–50 years 29–77% 4–6%

Helicopters 53% 18 years 32% 4%

Data 43% 4–5 years 70–80% 10–15%


storage1

Electric 35% 20 years 21–27% 7%


drives

Wind 34% 25 years 78% 1~3%


turbines

Heavy-duty 30% 10 years 21–42% 107–367


trucks

Passenger
16% 13 years 42% 4–10%
cars

1
Mainly reflects spare parts
2
Lifetime penetration is a function of attach rate, and typically shows wide variation between industries

SOURCE: Aditya Ambadipudi, Alexander Brotschi, Markus Forsgren, Florent Kervazo, Hugues Lavandier, and James Xing, “Industrial
aftermarket services: Growing the core,” McKinsey.com, July 2017

managing parts, and delivering superior customer as aviation, renewable energy, and mining—have
experience (Exhibit 4). started to adopt IoT-enabled condition monitoring
to prevent asset breakdowns, but few OEMs as yet
Managing customer demand have the infrastructure and technology to offer their
Traditionally, the difficulty of predicting and customers monitoring services.
managing customer demand has led to high
equipment downtime and poor service. Two Leading companies are using four methods to
drivers of this unpredictability are the limited use manage customer demand more actively:
of scheduled servicing and the low penetration of
condition-based monitoring, in which equipment ƒ Remote monitoring. By taking advantage of
is monitored while in operation. Industries vary in IoT and real-time connectivity, companies can
their approach to scheduled servicing, but out-of- continuously monitor the health of individual
warranty assets typically suffer lower adoption and assets and entire facilities to predict potential
more unplanned repairs. A few industries—such problems and manage demand. For instance,

How disruptive technologies are opening up innovative opportunities in services 3


EXHIBIT 4 The value in servicing comes from four main sources.

Sources of value Examples of digital levers and enablers

Managing
customer demand Flexible asset-
Remote monitoring Predictive specific planned Upstreaming and
and notifications maintenance repairs remote resolution

Optimizing
field labor
Flexible workforce Dynamic dispatch Next-generation Performance
management optimization diagnostics management 2.0

Managing parts

Predictive demand Virtual parts depot and Network and logistics Dynamic parts
forecasting real-time inventory management pricing

Delivering superior
customer
experience Digitized
Lead generation and Churn and retention Digital self-serve order-to-cash
management management applications process

makers of heating, ventilation, and air ƒ Upstreaming and remote resolution. After
conditioning systems can connect remotely to identifying issues through remote monitoring,
building-management systems to evaluate the companies can use digital and analytic tools
performance of their equipment. By connecting to automate delivery and support services,
data from meters, sensors, and control panels dispatching field technicians promptly to jobs
and adding an AA-driven intelligence layer on when they are needed and reducing service-
top of existing building-management systems, delivery costs and inefficiencies. One company
they can continuously monitor and model saw demand for simple repairs fall by 17 percent
energy usage and provide recommendations for after using technologies such as automated
appropriate energy-saving measures. The IoT incident-resolution systems to provide remote
specialist Enlighted has taken this approach support for some 23 percent of service calls.
a step further by using its lighting sensors to
identify occupied and unoccupied spaces and ƒ Predictive maintenance. A few companies
offering innovative space-utilization services. are taking asset productivity to new levels by

4 McKinsey & Company


applying advanced analytics to an array of are also taking advantage of data and analytics
structured, unstructured, machine-based, and to move from milestone-based maintenance
nonmachine-based data to predict when and to condition-based maintenance with tailored
how equipment may fail. They use insights from planned-maintenance schedules.
this process to optimize the time their technical
help desk spends resolving issues and to deploy Optimizing field labor
field technicians more efficiently. One oil-and- Although field labor represents the largest share
gas equipment manufacturer reduced downtime of cost in most service organizations, it is often
from its gas compressor by 70 percent through undermanaged. Companies have little or no visibility
such an approach. into employees’ work or schedules, resulting in
wasted time, poor service, and lost revenue. In one
ƒ Planned maintenance. Industrial companies industrial OEM, we found that more than 40 percent
are also using technology to combine repairs of a typical technician’s working day was wasted,
that would previously have been performed with two to three hours of idle time, up to an hour of
separately on different schedules. When an asset unnecessary driving time, and one to two hours of
is down, they use analytics to diagnose other avoidable visits. Few companies codify knowledge
potential problems, allowing the technicians in effectively, and a customer’s service experience often
attendance to perform unscheduled repairs and depends more on the technician than the company.
thereby reduce unplanned demand. Companies

EXHIBIT 5 A one-stop solution helps field techs manage service requests.

3
They can monitor
their performance
1 through KPI
dashboards.
Field techs receive
job notifications
from customers
through a dispatch
4
app, and can They have ready
manage leads. access to info on
customer site,
asset, and repair
history.
2
5
They use a parts-
recommendation
app to ensure they
They use a
have the parts they
root-cause
need before they
knowledge-man-
arrive at the
agement tool to
customer.
resolve repairs.

How disruptive technologies are opening up innovative opportunities in services 5


Four practices can help companies to optimize field Exhibit 5 can help field techs schedule service
productivity: requests, check that they have the right parts,
and understand the root causes of a breakdown.
ƒ Flexible workforce management. To ensure Some automotive OEMs have begun to diagnose
sufficient capacity and enable effective demand issues remotely using telematics signals sent
forecasting and schedule planning, companies from vehicles. A central team uses the signals to
are using digital tools that connect demand and give technicians a preliminary diagnosis, saving
supply in real time. By using digital scheduling them time and reducing wait time for spare
tools to seamlessly manage an efficient mix of parts.
internal workers and subcontractors, companies
can be responsive to customer needs without ƒ Performance management 2.0. Robust
incurring large fixed costs. One industrial- performance management helps companies
services company estimates incident rates pinpoint where service labor needs
and service volumes with the help of real-time improvement. By combining optimized
external data feeds such as weather patterns, scheduling with technology-driven process
then uses this expected demand to schedule improvements, they can improve wrench
appropriate workforce capacity. Another time (the time a technician spends actually
industrial company that introduced flexible performing necessary tasks). One industrial
scheduling was able to reduce overhead company introduced real-time dashboards
by $35,000 per technician and cut overall with granular data and was able to boost field
technician costs by 50 percent. productivity in its regions by 7 to 20 percent.

ƒ Dynamic dispatch optimization. In our Managing parts


experience, field-management systems rarely A badly managed spare-parts operation can not only
provide accurate visibility, and job-booking hurt revenue but also damage customer satisfaction
allocations seldom reflect task times. It’s not and loyalty. When a part required for a repair or
unusual to see more than a third of each day lost service isn’t available, repair time increases, the
through late starts, early finishes, and other customer’s experience is poor, and future revenue
unproductive time. By using sensor data and from that customer may be jeopardized. Getting
fleet telematics to track technicians’ schedules a part shipped to the repair point causes delay;
in real time, companies can add 20 to 30 percent meanwhile, technicians get reassigned to other tasks
to the working day. One leading telecom provider and the job goes to the back of the queue, often taking
introduced an automated job scheduler that days to complete. When a part isn’t essential to a
allocates technicians all their jobs for the day repair or service, not having it in stock could mean
and adjusts their schedules dynamically to the company loses revenue—and upselling and cross-
maximize productive use of time. selling opportunities as well—if the customer doesn’t
return to buy it later.
ƒ Next-generation diagnostics. To perform a
robust diagnostic, technicians need the right Companies optimizing parts management tend to
tools. Ideally, a diagnostic kit would cover model focus on four areas:
year, repair history, customer questionnaire,
suggestions for diagnosis, detailed problem- ƒ Predictive demand forecasting. Most demand-
solving manuals, and lists of parts needed. A management systems still rely on historical sales
mobile one-stop solution like that illustrated in patterns, but the introduction of technologies

6 McKinsey & Company


such as radio-frequency identification (RFID) industrials distributor, we found that using
alongside big data and advanced analytics allows analytics to manage stock at the level of SKUs
companies to move to predictive forecasting and repair points increased stock-on-shelf by
instead. By anticipating when an event is likely more than 50 percent.
to happen and predicting what parts will be
required when it does, companies can increase ƒƒ Network and logistics management.
first-time fix rates and improve customer Supporting a distributed field organization
satisfaction. requires a well-managed fleet, something
companies often struggle to achieve. To unlock
ƒƒ Virtual parts depot and real-time inventory. value, they need to harvest and integrate large
In a distributed field organization, the sheer sets of granular fleet data—GPS tracking,
size of the installed base and range of potential routing histories, and the like—that often go
repair locations makes inventory management untouched because of resource constraints or
challenging. One solution is to convert every the proliferation of data warehouses. In one
technician’s truck into a virtual repair location industrial OEM, we found that the use of digital
by combining predictive forecasting with a and analytics can typically reduce fleet costs
real-time inventory-management system that by 7 to 12 percent and spare fleet by 10 percent,
uses RFID or similar technologies to track the while improving availability by 5 to 10 percent.
parts carried by each technician. Companies
seeking real-time visibility of inventory and data ƒƒ Dynamic parts pricing. Another area where
across their network will need to invest in digital tech enablement helps companies create value
tools to keep track of inventory and advanced from parts management is pricing. Once a robust
analytics to support flexible allocation. In one technology infrastructure is in place, companies

EXHIBIT 6 A self-serve app gives customers transparency throughout the repair process.

1
Customer
reports fault
and receives Equipment
notification
that a field
tech has been
assigned.
3
2 Customer gets live
notifications
Customer can
throughout the
interact with
repair process.
self-serve
applications
such as chat
bots to
schedule and
track services.

How disruptive technologies are opening up innovative opportunities in services 56


can apply advanced analytics to probe supply offers are most likely to help retain them. One
and demand at the level of individual parts industrial company aggregated data from
and introduce dynamic pricing. This involves contract, sales, product, and customer records
replacing standard prices with prices tailored into a data lake, mined it using advanced
to individual customers, locations, and parts or techniques, and then applied predictive
kits based on variables such as price elasticity, analytics to estimate churn and evaluate the
competition, product uniqueness, and customer effectiveness of personalized customer offers.
bargaining power. After introducing dynamic This enabled it to introduce a differentiated
pricing, some OEMs have been able to capture sales strategy that increased the attach rate for
pricing improvements approaching 10 percent. service contracts by 90 percent.

Delivering superior customer experience ƒƒ Digitized order-to-cash processes. Accurate


Great customer experience comes from delighting and timely billing is critical in servicing, yet
the customer at every stage in the service process, few companies do it well. Customers frequently
not just at one or two touchpoints. complain about inaccurate billing and
unresponsive customer service. Companies
Companies that excel at customer experience can address these challenges by adopting
use tech-enabled capabilities in three areas in technologies such as robotic process automation
particular. to manage tasks across the order-to-cash
process.
ƒƒ Digital self-service applications. One of the
biggest pain points for industrial customers is an Getting started
opaque servicing process that leaves them with Growing service revenues through technology
unanswered questions: What is the problem with enablement requires different approaches
their equipment? What caused it, and how can it in different circumstances, but all industrial
be prevented in future? What is the breakdown companies would do well to take a few basic steps:
of the service cost? Which stage has servicing
reached? When will it be finished? Through a ƒƒ Don’t solve complex data problems; find
combination of sensors, GPS technology, app- simpler ways to get the data you need.
enabled field technicians, and digital check-in For companies with disparate systems
and checkout tools, industrial companies can and a distributed workforce, building a
now keep customers informed of progress and comprehensive, reliable data source is no
any changes to plan through automatic updates. mean feat. Service data is often unstructured,
Exhibit 6 illustrates a reimagined customer and integrating data from multiple sources is
experience in which digital and mobile tools difficult. Some companies compromise by using
provide visibility at every step in the service partial or observational data. But advanced
process. data-extraction technologies and data lakes
now allow companies to build a rich granular
ƒƒ Churn and retention management. As in database in a matter of weeks, while cheap data
any industry, it costs much more to acquire storage enables them to store data in any format
a new customer than to retain an old one. or volume indefinitely. Thus equipped, they can
By analyzing data across multiple customer rapidly analyze granular data at low cost and in a
touchpoints, industrial companies can predict scalable manner.
which customers are at risk of churn and which

57 McKinsey & Company


ƒ Define technology-enabled service offerings. ƒ Balance cost with customer experience using
Develop a deeper understanding of your end digital tools. Field technicians usually represent
customers’ economics at subsegment level across the lion’s share of costs and offer the greatest
your business units, brands, and revenue and scope for improvement. Develop initiatives such
profit pools. Segment service needs and identify as real-time tracking tools to drive dynamic
where technology could be a key differentiator. dispatching, optimize time-and-task and
Design a service strategy that uses data first-time-fix rates, and reduce performance
generated—now or in the future—by the variability through granular analytics. Enhance
installed base for your equipment. To craft a new customer experience by offering more self-help
value proposition, create technology-enabled capabilities.
offerings for both your customers (such as
remote monitoring) and your field technicians ƒ Follow a phased approach with a clear
(such as digital diagnostic tools). roadmap that ties technology to your service
strategy. Adopt a two-speed approach to
ƒ Enhance your digital, analytics, and technology: quickly deploy capabilities that
technology capabilities. Taking into account support the customer experience while you
your customers’ needs and your technicians’ work methodically to integrate back-end
pain points, work out which capabilities you functions. Rapidly pilot new tools and analytics,
require, which you have already, which you need and refine your technology roadmap as you go.
to develop, and how differentiated you are from Schedule the rollout of initiatives, the high-level
competitors. Form an integrated view of the investment plan, and quick wins. Determine
capabilities you need, and build them in phases. what performance-management mechanisms
Look at the broader technology ecosystem, you need to sustain impact.
evaluate data and analytics solution providers,
and partner with them where necessary.

ƒ Integrate your commercial strategy across field


tech, inside sales, and direct sales channels. The next wave of service transformation is here,
Tailor your sales approach to drive aftermarket and it is being driven by technology. Industrial
sales. Provide incentives for sales teams to drive companies that can fundamentally reimagine
services as well as OEM projects. Equip sales service technology as a core component will be well
support staff with analytics tools to help them positioned to achieve above-market growth and
mine your installed base for leads and drive superior cost position.
contract renewals. Reward field technicians
for parts revenues and sales leads, and enhance 1
See also Aditya Ambadipudi, Alexander Brotschi, Markus
their digital tools so they can easily pass leads on Forsgren, et al., “Industrial aftermarket services: Growing the
to commercial teams. core,” McKinsey.com, July 2017.

Barathram Ananthakrishnan is a consultant in McKinsey’s Chennai office; Venkat Atluri is a senior partner
in the Chicago office, where Harsha Krishnamurthy is an associate partner; and Senthil Muthiah
is a partner in the Boston office.

Copyright © 2018 McKinsey & Company. All rights reserved.

How disruptive technologies are opening up innovative opportunities in services 7

You might also like