Professional Documents
Culture Documents
John B. Jemmott III, PhD, Loretta Sweet Jemmott, RN, PhD, and Geoffrey
T. Fong, PhD
this population. More broadly, research a function how subjects were recruited.) search indicates that this procedure in-
into adolescents' sexual behavior, for the About 97% of the participants were cur- creases the accuracy of self-reports. While
most part, has been conducted on female rently enrolled in school. The mean num- the participants completed the preinter-
adolescents.'3 Yet it is also important to ber of years of education of their mothers, vention questionnaires, they were strati-
understand the dynamics of male adoles- as reported by participants, was 13.82 fied by age and randomly assigned within
cents' sexual behavior. Male adolescents (SD = 3.17). Few participants (4.5%) re- age to either the AIDS condition or the
are more likely to initiate sexual activities ported ever sharing needles or ever having career-opportunities condition and to one
with their partners,1314-'16 and the male's receptive anal intercourse (2.3%), or hav- of 27 small groups (14 in the AIDS condi-
use of a condom is the best method to ing sexual relationships with males exclu- tion and 13 in the control condition) led by
reduce the risk of contracting or spreading sively (1.6%) or with both males and fe- a trained male or female facilitator. A total
an STD during sexual activities. males (0.8%). Their chief HIV risk was of 85 adolescents were assigned to the
Recent studies provide initial exper- from heterosexual activities. About 33.9% AIDS condition, and 72 were assigned to
imental evidence that AIDS prevention in- reported having more than one coital part- the control condition. The sample sizes
terventions emphasizing attitudes, knowl- ner in the previous 3 months, and 12.8% of are smaller in some analyses because of
edge, and skill-building can increase the respondents indicated that they had attrition or because subjects gave no re-
condom procurement among Black male had heterosexual anal intercourse during sponse to the question.
adult STD patients'7 and self-reported that period. About 20.9% of the respon- AIDS risk-reduction condition. Par-
condom use among White male homosex- dents who had had coitus in the previous ticipants in the AIDS risk reduction con-
uals.18 In an AIDS intervention study'9 of 3 months reported that they never used dition received a 5-hour intervention de-
Black and Hispanic adolescents, those in condoms during those experiences, and signed to increase their knowledge of
the intervention conditions, compared only 30.2% reported always using con- AIDS and STDs and to weaken proble-
with those not receiving an intervention, doms. The adolescents were offered $40 matic attitudes toward risky sexual behav-
showed increased ratings of the value of for participating: $15 for taking part in the iors. The intervention included informa-
AIDS education and reduced approval of intervention and $25 for attending the tion about risks associated with
intravenous drug use 1 month after the 3-month follow-up. Of the original partic- intravenous drug use and specific sexual
intervention. DiClemente and col- ipants, 150 completed the 3-month fol- activities. Videotapes, games, exercises,
leagues20 tested an AIDS education inter- low-up questionnaire, for a return rate of and other culturally and developmentally
vention on classes within middle and high 96%. The return rate was not different be- appropriate materials were used to rein-
schools in San Francisco and found that, tween experimental conditions. force learning and to encourage active par-
compared with control classes, those that ticipation. All materials had been exten-
received the AIDS instruction had greater Procedure sively pilot tested and were selected not
AIDS knowledge and less fear of being The study was approved by the hu- only to provide accurate information, but
infected by classmates who have the dis- man subjects committee ofPrinceton Uni- to do so in ways that would be interesting
ease. DiClemente et al.20 urged behavioral versity. Adolescents and parents signed to inner-city Black male adolescents. For
assessments in future intervention studies separate consent forms. They were given example, one video, "The Subject is
on adolescents. descriptions of the study that took into AIDS," was narrated by a Black woman
In the present study we examined account the fact that the adolescents and had a multiethnic cast. In one game,
whether Black male adolescents who would be randomly assigned to an AIDS "AIDS Basketball,"21 participants in
were randomly assigned to an AIDS risk risk reduction intervention or to a career- small-group sessions were divided into
reduction intervention would have greater opportunities intervention. The studywas teams that earned points for correctly an-
knowledge and less positive attitudes and described as a risk reduction project, de- swering factual questions on AIDS. In one
intentions regarding risky sexual behavior signed "to understand Black male youths' exercise, "Uncle Bill's Advice Col-
than would those assigned to a control in- behaviors that may create risks such as umn,"'21 pairs of adolescents wrote a re-
tervention on career opportunities. Most unemployment, truancy, teenage preg- sponse to a letter to Uncle Bill about AIDS
important, we also examined whether nancy, and sexually transmitted diseases, or risky behavior and then read it to the
risky sexual behaviors would decline in especiallyAIDS, and to findways to teach rest ofthe group for discussion. A condom
the intervention condition, relative to the Black male youth how to reduce these exercise focused on the correct use of con-
control condition, during the 3 months af- risks." doms. The participants also engaged in
ter the intervention. The intervention session was held at role-playing situations depicting potential
a local school on Saturday, October 15, problems in tying to implement safer sex
1988. That morning, the participants com- practices, including abstinence. A more
Medwds pleted preintervention questionnaires, detailed description of the intervention is
which took about 90 minutes. Immedi- available from the authors.
Study Sample ately before completing the question- Career-opporntuies condition. An
The participants were 157 Black male naires, the participants signed an agree- important concem in designing this exper-
adolescents (mean age = 14.64 years, ment indicating that they understood that iment was to control for Hawthorne ef-
SD = 1.66) from Philadelphia, Pa, who it was important to answer the questions fects to reduce the likelihood that effects
were recruited from among outpatients at carefully and honestly, that their answers of the AIDS intervention could be attrib-
a medical clinic in West Philadelphia would be confidential, and that their uted to nonspecific features, including
(44%); students attending the 10th, 11th, names would not be put on their question- group interaction and special attention. A
and 12th grade assemblies at a local high naires. The participants also signed such waiting-list or no-treatment control condi-
school (32%); and adolescents at a local agreements before completing postinter- tion would not control for these confound-
YMCA (24%). (The results do not differ as vention and follow-up questionnaires. Re- ing variables and consequently was seen
March 1992, Vol. 82,, No. 3 American Journal of Public Health 373
Jcemot Miet al.
as undesirable. In addition, for ethical and eraged to form a scale on which higher rect out of 57 was calculated from the pre-
methodological reasons, every effort was scores indicated higher incidence of risky intervention, postintervention, and
made to ensure that the experiences of sexual behavior. Coefficient a for the scale follow-up questionnaires. Coefficient a
control participants were as valuable and was .67 at preintervention and .72 at fol- was .73, .89, and .82, respectively.
enjoyable as those of experimental partic- low-up. Other measures. On the postinter-
ipants.22 Accordingly, participants in the Intentions and attitudes regarding vention questionnaire, the participants an-
control condition received an intervention nsky sexual behavior in the net 3 months. swered a series of questions about their
concerning career planning and opportu- The theory of reasoned action and a grow- perceptions of the intervention activities.
nities. Structurally similar to the AIDS in- ing empirical literature suggest that atti- The facilitators completed a questionnaire
tervention, it also lasted 5 hours and used tudes and intentions are related to behav- regarding their impressions of the experi-
videotapes, small-group discussions, ex- ior, including HIV risk-associated sexual ence of the adolescents in their small
ercises, and games. The participants behavior.23-27 The participants' attitudes groups and their success at implementing
viewed the film "Career and You." In one and intentions regarding engaging in the the intervention. The Marlowe-Crowne
game, "The Career Game," participants aforementioned sexual practices in the Social Desirability Scale29 was used to
in small groups were divided into teams next 3 months were measured at preinter- measure the tendency of participants to
that earned points for correctly answering vention, immediately postintervention, descnrbe themselves in favorable, socially
questions about careers. They partici- and at the 3-month follow-up. To measure desirable terms.
pated in a value-awareness exercise, and intentions, participants were asked to rate
they did a career analysis. the likelihood that they would engage in
After the interventions, all partici- each behavior in the next 3 months on a Results
pants completed the postintervention scale from "extremely unlikely" (1) to Intervention Integrity
questionnaires. This took about an hour. "extremely likely" (7). At each time
To reduce the effects of demand charac- point, the ratings were averaged to form Before considering effects of the
teristics, the questionnaires were admin- scales on which higher numbers indicated AIDS intervention on knowledge, atti-
istered by research assistants, not by the stronger intentions to engage in risky sex- tudes, intentions, and behavior, it is im-
facilitators. ual behavior in the next 3 months. Coef- portant to establish that the participants in
ficient a was .68 at preintervention, .72 at the two conditions were equally involved
Facilitators postintervention, and .70 at follow-up. To in their interventions and found them to be
The facilitators were 27 Black adults measure attitudes, participants were valuable and enjoyable. There were no
(11 women and 16 men) with a mean age asked to rate their attitudes toward engag- differences between conditions in the par-
of 36.2 years (SD = 6.8). The AIDS facil- ing in each behavior in the next 3 months ticipants' ratings of their liking for the in-
itators had backgrounds in human sexu- on a scale from "extremely negative" (1) tervention, their learning from the activi-
ality education, mental health counseling, to "extremely positive" (7). At each time ties, whether the intervention would help
AIDS education, nursing, or social work. point, the ratings were averaged to form them in the future, their general emotional
The career-opportunities facilitators had scales on which higher numbers indicated reactions toward the intervention, or their
backgrounds in education, career guid- more favorable attitudes toward engaging participation level. The only significant
ance, or business. All facilitators had at in risky sexual behavior in the next 3 difference between the groups was that
least a 4-year college degree. A majority months. Coefficient a was .63 at preinter- those in the AIDS condition would be
had experience with small-group facilita- vention, .68 at postintervention, and .63 at more likely to recommend the project to
tion. follow-up. other teenagers than would those in the
One week before the intervention, AIDS and STD knowdge. Partici- careers condition-mean ratings of 4.18
the facilitators received 6 hours of train- pants answered factual true-false ques- vs 3.78 on a 5-point scale, F (1,
ing. AIDS and careers facilitators were tions regarding AIDS and STDs. Thirty 152) = 4.43,P < .04.Thefacilitators'rat-
trained at the same time, but in separate items concerned AIDS and were taken ings of their small groups were consistent
groups. By discussing potential problems from scales previously used in research on with the participants' self-ratings: They
and issues as a group, the facilitators were adolescents by DiClemente et al.2028 revealed a high degree of attentiveness
able to fashion common responses. The Thirty additional items concerned infor- and interest, with no differences between
training emphasized that all facilitators of mation about either AIDS or STDs in gen- conditions. In addition, there was evi-
the same intervention must implement it eral that is not tapped by the DiClemente dence that the facilitators had been suc-
in the same way so as to reduce facilitator measures. To ensure the content validity cessful in presenting the interventions in
effects. of the scale, six AIDS experts-scientists the same way. Analyses on knowledge,
and clinicians involved in AIDS-related attitudes, intentions, and behavior re-
Measures research, patient care, or education- vealed no differences that could be attrb-
Riskysexual behavior ding thepre- rated the information in each item on a uted to the particular small group in which
vious 3 months. On the preintervention 3-point scale from "unimportant" (0) to the adolescents participated, independent
and follow-up questionnaires, the partici- "important" (1) to "essential" (2) for lay- of experimental condition.
pants answered a series of questions about persons to know. Eighteen items were
their sexual practices in the previous 3 seen as essential (mean ratings = 2.0) by Knowledge, Attitudes, and
months, including coitus, multiple sexual every judge, and 39 items had mean rat- Intentions
partners, condom use, and heterosexual ings in the important to essential range The data were analyzed with
anal intercourse. At each assessment, par- (mean ratings 2 1.00). Three items the Condition x Gender of Facilitator analy-
ticipants' responses to the individual items judges considered either ambiguous or un- ses of covariance,30 controlling for prein-
were converted to z scores and then av- important were deleted. The number cor- tervention measures of the relevant crite-
374 American Journal of Public Health March 1992, Vol. 82, No. 3
Reducing the Risk of HIV Infection
March 1992, Vol. 82, No. 3 American Journal of Public Health 375
Jemmott m et al.
ual behavior and AIDS-related knowledge after the AIDS intervention. Responses, with information about AIDS will result in
were sustained over the 3 months. The however, were unrelated to social desir- greater sexual activity is perhaps simply a
effects on attitudes observed immediately ability bias. Nevertheless, because it is fear.
postintervention were evident at the fol- difficult to validate self-reported sexual The present study focused on sexual
low-up among participants who had a fe- behavior,31 interpretations of the present behaviors that heighten risk of HIV infec-
male facilitator. findings should take into consideration the tion. However, the overwhelming major-
These results cannot be explained as possibility that the participants' self-re- ity of the subjects did not report any ho-
a simple result of the special attention re- ports might have been inaccurate. mosexual or bisexual experiences.
ceived by the adolescents in the AIDS in- It might be argued that the gender of Sharing needles and other intravenous
tervention condition. The two interven- facilitators and group members should be drug use paraphernalia would also in-
tions were matched in length and involved matched to enhance an intervention's ef- crease risk of HIV infection, but few of
similar kinds of activities. Moreover, the fectiveness. Consonant with this argu- these subjects reported engaging in such
participants' evaluations of their experi- ment, the AIDS intervention caused behavior. The important question of
ences were quite similar across the inter- greater increases in postintervention whether interventions of the type used in
ventions. Although career-opportunities AIDS knowledge when the facilitator was the present study would be effective with
subjects did not learn about AIDS, they male than when the facilitator was female. Black male adolescents who engage in ho-
did gain knowledge that would be valuable But this advantage ofmale facilitators was mosexual or bisexual activities orwho use
to them in the future, given the high un- not evident on postintervention attitudes intravenous drugs will have to be ad-
employment among inner-city Black ado- or intentions, and itvanished at follow-up. dressed in future studies. More broadly,
lescents. In fact, 3-month follow-up data revealed research on strategies to change HIV risk-
By its very nature, risky sexual be- that the AIDS intervention caused less associated behavior in diverse popula-
havior is private behavior and conse- self-reported risky behavior and less pos- tions is still in its infancy. We are optimis-
quently must be assessed using self-report itive attitudes toward such behavior when tic, however, that by conducting research
measures, which may be biased.31 We em- the facilitator was female than when the along these lines, it may be possible to
ployed several techniques to make it less facilitatorwas male. These results provide curb the spread of AIDS. O
likely that the subjects would miniize or scant support for the view that matching
exaggerate reports of their sexual experi- the gender of facilitator and intervention
ences: (1) code numbers rather than recipient enhances the effectiveness of Acknowledginents
names were used on the questionnaires, AIDS interventions with Black male ado- This research was supported in part by Amer-
(2) facilitators were not involved in any lescents. ican Foundation for AIDS research grants
000667 and 000952 and National Institute of
way in the administration of question- One common argument against Child Health and Human Development grant
naires, (3) the importance of responding AIDS education programs for adolescents HD24921.
honestly was emphasized, and (4) partic- and children has been that exposing them Some of these data were presented at the
ipants were assured that their responses to information about sex will encourage meeting of the Society of Behavioral Medicine,
them to engage in sexual activity. Our April 1990, Chicago, Ill.
would be kept confidential. Furthermore, The authors gratefully acknowledge the
if concern about how they would be data, however, provide some evidence contributions to this research project of Leon-
viewed by others influenced respondents' that the opposite may be true. Adoles- ard Johnson, Konstance McCaffree, and Di-
reports of their sexual behavior, those cents who received the AIDS intervention onne Jane Latham, and the helpful suggestions
were less likely to engage in sexual activ- of Paula Braverman, David Brody, Ann Marie
whose need for social approval was stron- Carosella, Robert T. Croyle, James M. Jones,
ger29 might have differed from the other ity, and those who did were more likely to Pamela Kato, Caryn Lerman, David Schor,
adolescents in self-reported risky sexual engage in safer sexual activity. Thus, the Melvin Snyder, and Mark Zanna regarding an
behavior or in the change in their reports common fear that providing adolescents earlier version of this article.
376 American Journal of Public Health March 1992, Vol. 82, No. 3
n the Risk of HIV Infection
March 1992, Vol. 82, No. 3 American Journal of Public Health 377