Professional Documents
Culture Documents
FACTS:
ISSUE:
Whether or not Ordinance No. 44 of Zamboanga City imposing P0.01 tax per
liter of softdrinks produced, manufactured, and/or bottled within the
territorial jurisdiction of the City is valid?
HELD:
NO. It is null and void. Any taxes paid under protest should be accordingly
refunded to the taxpayers.
RATIO:
Section 19(a) and section 23 of the Local Tax Code allows for the
municipalities to impose tax on businesses.
It is clear that a city, like Zamboanga, may impose, in lieu of the
graduated fixed tax prescribed under Section 19 of the Local Tax Code,
a percentage tax on the gross sales for the preceding calendar year of
non-essential commodities at the rate of not exceeding two per cent
and on the gross sales of essential commodities at the rate of not
exceeding one per cent.
Ordinance No. 44 of the respondent Zamboanga City imposes P0.01
per liter of softdrinks produced, manufactured, and/or bottled within
the territorial jurisdiction of the City of Zamboanga.
o Ordinance is ultra vires as it is not within the authority of the City
to impose said tax.
o The authority of the City is limited to the imposition of a
percentage tax on the gross sales or receipts of said product
which shall be at the rate of not exceeding 2% of the gross sales
or receipts of the soft drinks for the preceding calendar year.
The tax being imposed under said Ordinance is based on the output or
production and not on the gross sales or receipts as authorized under
the Local Tax Code.