Professional Documents
Culture Documents
12 I December 2014
A Piel Beryl
A vintage homebuilt
The Determinator
Klaus Savier’s experimental test bed
Eagle
Meet the Legal
Ultralight or
homebuilt fun!
TOWER FREQUENCY
The Pelton family and their Cessna 195: Jack, Rose, Christine, Ryan, and Christy with
grandsons Noah and little Owen.
ALL RESEARCH SHOWS that a majority of us who fly have a family We have done our best to pass on our values and passions
member who is also a pilot or is deeply involved in aviation in and traditions to our kids and grandkids, and experiencing per-
some other capacity. It could be a parent, grandparent, aunt or sonal aviation is a big part of that. Actually going flying is an
uncle, or even a more distant relative. But the link is solid. important part of that tradition, but so is telling aviation stories,
Families have been very successful at passing down the excite- reliving the experiences we have had over the years, and even
ment and challenge of personal aviation. passing on the tales from earlier generations. Shared experi-
But what about people who are not born into an aviation ences, shared traditions, and shared interests are what bond
family? How can we best show them the great joy and feeling families and any other group of humans together.
of accomplishment we all draw from personal aviation? EAA To keep the EAA family and what it means to all of us going,
can be a big part of that solution. we need your help.
EAA is, after all, one really big family made up of people Volunteers are essential for almost every EAA activity
from all walks of life who love aviation. Our Founder Paul whether it be at a chapter event that welcomes the community
Poberezny repeated countless times that “airplanes bring us or among the many thousands who make our annual convention
together, but friends we make keep us together.” Nothing at Oshkosh possible.
could be truer. Young Eagles flights are possible only because so many thou-
Our biggest family event happens at Oshkosh every summer sands of you donate your time, your airplane, and pick up the
where we get to meet and greet old friends, and more impor- costs. And I thank each of you.
tantly, make new friends. Oshkosh welcomes anyone with an But to continue our work of growing the aviation family EAA
interest in aviation into the EAA family and shows them up- also needs donations. Your gift of any size will be very helpful.
close and hands-on what personal aviation is all about. Many members are including EAA in their planned giving in the
Our nearly 1,000 chapters certainly function as families same way they plan for the future of their families. There are
throughout the year meeting to share experiences, dispense many opportunities to support EAA, and in every case your
advice learned from building all sorts of airplanes, and pro- donation is tax-deductible to the full extent of the law.
mote the value of personal aviation to the community. Personal aviation faces many challenges, and EAA works every
And the nearly 2 million youngsters who have gone flying day to resolve threats to our freedom to fly. But in the joyous holi-
in our Young Eagles program now know the freedom and day season when we gather with family and friends to share, I ask
excitement of personal flight firsthand. And they also have you to please think of EAA as part of your family. Together we can
new family members—the pilots and chapter members who be certain the excitement, challenge, and fun of personal aviation
organized the Young Eagles rally—who can guide them to a carries on to the new generation the same way all families cele-
future in aviation. brate the experiences and traditions they hold most dear.
I think about our EAA family at this time of the year Rose and I, the EAA board of directors, and everyone at our
because Rose and I are finalizing plans to celebrate the joy of Oshkosh headquarters wish you and yours a very merry
the season with our own children and grandchildren. And I bet Christmas, a happy New Year, and a joyous holiday season with
you are doing the same. your family close and together.
Features
EAA PUBLICATIONS
Founder: Paul H. Poberezny
Publisher: Jack J. Pelton,
EAA Chairman of the Board
Vice President of Communities
and Member Programs: Rick Larsen 08 Leonard Milholland’s 16 Keeping up a
Editor-in-Chief: J. Mac McClellan Legal Eagle Family Tradition
Homebuilding Community Manager: A popular plans-built ultralight Randy Weselmann and his Piel Beryl
Charlie Becker BY DAN GRUNLOH BY BUDD DAVISSON
Editor: Mary Jones/EditEtc. LLC
Senior Graphic Designer: Chris Livieri 24 Klaus Savier’s Determinator
News Editor: Ric Reynolds He makes speed mods look EZ
Copy Editor: Colleen Walsh BY LYNNE WAINFAN
Multimedia Journalist: Brady Lane
Visual Properties Administrator:
Jason Toney
Contributing Writers: Charlie Becker,
Marino Boric, Sean Curry, Budd
Departments
Davisson, Dan Grunloh, John Mangold, 02 Tower Frequency 06 News from HQ
and Lynne Wainfan BY JACK J. PELTON NEWS FROM EAA
Display
Sue Anderson Columns
Mailing Address: 32 What Our Members Are Building
P.O. Box 3086, Oshkosh, WI 54903-3086 2014 Perseverance Awards
Phone: 920-426-4800 BY JOHN MANGOLD
Fax: 920-426-4828
E-mail: experimenter@eaa.org
Website: www.EAA.org 38 Under the Cowl
Introducing the D-motor
Need to change your address or have BY MARINO BORIC
other membership questions?
Call 800-564-6322 (800-JOIN EAA).
44 Ultralight World
EAA® and SPORT AVIATION®, the EAA Logo® Six Chuter International Powered Parachutes Announces
and AERONAUTICATM are registered trade- New Ultralight P3 Lite
marks, trademarks, and service marks of the REPRINTED FROM THE SIX CHUTER INTERNATIONAL NEWSLETTER
Experimental Aircraft Association, Inc. The use
of these trademarks and service marks without
the permission of the Experimental Aircraft As-
sociation, Inc. is strictly prohibited.
EAA Experimenter 3
HOMEBUILDER’S CORNER
2014 in Review
Homebuilding victories and challenges
BY CHARLIE BECKER
WITH WINTER SETTLING in here in Oshkosh, flying will be put on posed update in this policy document would have seriously
the shelf and my full attention will be back on my homebuilding confused FAA inspectors in the field regarding the ability to
projects. Given the weather we experience during a Wisconsin fly homebuilts over “densely populated areas.” Fortunately, we
winter, I don’t think it was a coincidence that Wisconsin became were able to make our case against this change with top FAA
a hotbed for the homebuilding movement. The weather is par- personnel and are confident that the crisis is over, but we are
ticularly well suited to hunkering down and working on your still waiting to see the revised draft of this document before
project. The end of the year is always a good time to take stock we consider it a victory.
of what you have accomplished during the year, so let’s look at The other major policy issue we fought on behalf of home-
some of the highlights for EAA and the homebuilder in 2014. builders was the FAA Airports division’s proposed revision of
After more than a year’s work with the FAA, we were able the definition of an “aeronautical activity.” This definition is
to make a historic change in the way we flight test aircraft. For critical as things that fall outside of the definition can put FAA
the first time ever, a homebuilder now has the option of having airport grant money at risk; something no airport wants to do.
a second pilot onboard the aircraft during Phase 1 flight testing. The good news is that for the first time ever, final assembly of
We are hopeful that this new option will decrease the num- a homebuilt was recognized as an aeronautical activity. The
ber of fatal accidents that occur during that time of greatest bad news is that leaves all the other construction phases of a
exposure. We implore all of our members who choose to use homebuilt outside the definition. I really can’t think of some-
this option to do so with responsibility by understanding and thing more “aeronautical” than building an aircraft, regardless
following the guidance in Advisory Circular 90-116. We want to of what part of the process you are working on! We are still
be able to show the FAA that this additional privilege will not battling on this one, and the jury is still out.
be taken lightly or abused. It will help us pave the way for more Every year, our annual convention, EAA AirVenture Osh-
options in the future if we are successful. kosh, is a highlight. You never know exactly why going into it,
On a personal note, your EAA staf completed its Zenith CH but it never disappoints. This year, homebuilding took center
750 STOL project that was started back in September of 2012. stage with the construction of the One Week Wonder, a Zenith
I had announced in this column in January of this year that my CH 750 Cruzer, right at show center. It was a huge success. Lit-
goal was to lead this project to completion by AirVenture 2014. erally thousands of people participated in the construction, and
With a lot of hard work by a number of diferent EAA staf, the many more were introduced to the opportunity to build your
aircraft was signed of the day prior to the start of convention. own aircraft. I’m hopeful that “build an aircraft” was added to
Just made it! The aircraft is now finished with Phase 1 flight lots of bucket lists because of the One Week Wonder and that
testing and has become our sport pilot-eligible aircraft in the this project inspires many people to build.
EAA Employee Flying Club. It was a great way for a number of All in all, it was a very good year for homebuilding. Thank
diferent staf here to learn about homebuilding. you for being an EAA member. I hope that you and your
Probably the biggest threat we faced this year was from the loved ones have a very merry holiday season and a prosper-
FAA’s proposed modification of FAA Order 8130. The pro- ous new year!
EAA Experimenter 7
LEONARD MILHOLLAND’S LEGAL EAGLE
Leonard Milholland’s
Legal Eagle
A popular plans-built ultralight
BY DAN GRUNLOH
10 Vol.3 No.12 / December 2014 Photography courtesy of Sam Buchanon and www.BetterHalfVW.com
and gusset tail weigh 4 pounds before covering. Because the
Guppy flew well with the ½ VW engine, it was an obvious
choice for the Legal Eagle. Leonard said he has been drawing
airplanes all his life and decided to make one as simple and
light as possible.
EAA Experimenter 11
LEONARD MILHOLLAND’S LEGAL EAGLE
EAA Experimenter 13
LEONARD MILHOLLAND’S LEGAL EAGLE
members and more than 3,000 posts covering more than 500
LEGAL EAGLE XL SPECIFICATIONS topics. The running slide show of completed Legal Eagle
projects may make you want to build one. There is also a Ya-
Empty weight: 246 pounds
hoo discussion group for ½ VW engines. Sam Buchanan has
Wingspan: 315 inches (26 feet 3 inches) a wonderful build site with detailed photos and text about
Wing chord: 55 inches every aspect of his Legal Eagle XL project. The photos and
Wing area: 120.3 square feet explanations add a lot to what is in the plans. Don’t miss the
Gross weight: 575 pounds link to his flying videos. Sam previously built a Van’s RV-6.
Fuselage length: 193 inches (16 feet 1 inch) Les Homan brought his Legal Eagle XL to AirVenture
Height: 75 inches (6 feet 3 inches)
2014 all the way from California and won the top ultralight
award given by the judges in the Fun Fly Zone, as the Ul-
Fuel capacity: 5 gallons
tralight/Lightplane area is now called. He has a lot of great
Propeller: Wood, 54-by-22
videos of Legal Eagle flying at www.YouTube.com/user/
Engine: 30 hp Better Half VW homanles/videos and also some snippets from Leonard’s fo-
Stall speed: 27 mph rums at AirVenture. Les flew a Super Starduster biplane for
Takeoff distance: 250 feet three years prior to the Legal Eagle.
Leonard and his builders have been bringing their air-
planes to EAA AirVenture, and he has been giving forums in
the Ultralight/Lightplane area for nearly 15 years. For some
proceeded to deliver a string of standard jokes with a perfect reason, there are few news and magazine articles about his
sense of timing. He also talked about his age, saying he had airplanes. Leonard said the airplane doesn’t get the recogni-
promised his wife he would live to be at least 100. A check of tion it deserves. Perhaps writers dismiss it as old-fashioned
his calculated life expectancy at this time came out to 104, and instead focus on the “jazzier” airplanes. Check out the
so when they reach that point they will make new plans. Legal Eagles in the Ultralight/Lightplane area next time you
It was a treat to be in the same room and feel the affection come to AirVenture, and watch for news of Leonard’s next
expressed by family, friends, and customers. airplane, an enclosed cabin model with folding wings. Con-
A successful plans-built airplane must have builder sup- tact Leonard at Leonard@lemilholland.com.
port, and that’s where an organized builder community can
help. The Eagler’s Nest at www.EaglersNest.com/forum/ Dan Grunloh has logged 1,200 hours in trikes, and he won the 2002 and
is an online community of builders and owners with 456 2004 U.S. National Microlight Championships in a trike.
Leonard cutting his 90th birthday cake during EAA AirVenture Oshkosh 2014.
ShopEAA.com | 800.564.6322
Your EAA merchandise purchase supports EAA
programs that help grow participation in aviation.
EAA Experimenter 17
KEEPING UP A FAMILY TRADITION
Keeping Up a
Family Tradition
Randy Weselmann and his Piel Beryl
BY BUDD DAVISSON
EAA Experimenter 17
KEEPING UP A FAMILY TRADITION
IT’S HARD TO BELIEVE that EAA is more than 60 years old and Randy Weselmann of Bainbridge, Indiana, would say,
that we’re seeing second- and third-generation homebuilders “Yeah, we had an airplane in the garage, so why not build
following in the footsteps of parents who built airplanes. To one myself?”
the average person on the street, building an airplane sounds Randy’s dad was an aeronautical engineer who worked for
preposterous, but to someone who grew up with an airplane General Electric and Boeing, among others. However, in the
in his family’s garage, it sounds perfectly normal. Doesn’t early 1960s he decided to set up his own airplane factory and
everyone have an airplane in his garage? bought the plans for a Thorp T-18. Being small, Randy was the
ofcial crawl-inside-the-fuselage-bucking-bar holder.
He said, “I don’t know where the urge to work with my
hands came from, but certainly watching and then help-
ing my father take flat sheets of metal and turn them into
an airplane had a lot to do with it. It must be in my DNA
because the urge bit me early. I started on my A&P license
while still in high school and eventually went to work with
United Airlines in their sheet metal and machine shops. I
wanted to build an airplane, but I wasn’t making enough
money to go the normal homebuilt route. So I built a Mitch-
ell B-10 flying wing ultralight.”
It would be easy for another homebuilder to look down
on the concept of building an ultralight, but Randy has the
last laugh.
“I have put over 400 hours on it and have gone through
three engines. I still have it but haven’t flown it for a while
because of the Beryl.”
The Piel Beryl caught his eye because he liked “the Spitfire
The cowling is a Randy Weselmann original, since the plans didn’t address the look” that the wing had. Also, the advertisements for it said
cowling in detail.
The Beryl was Claude Piel’s aerobatic version of his better known, side-by-side design, the Emeraude.
EAA Experimenter 19
KEEPING UP A FAMILY TRADITION
The fuselage of the Beryl is much more complicated than most tubing structures of the type because it isn’t square, so the sides can’t be laid out and then stood up. Plus,
the longerons are made of numerous sizes.
Randy’s panel reflects the trend toward glass cockpits in almost any kind of airplane. And the iPad is becoming the most popular navigation add-on.
EAA Experimenter 21
KEEPING UP A FAMILY TRADITION
Save on purchases
at Aircraft Spruce
with the EAA Visa Signature® Card! EAA
Webinars
What would you like to learn?
1
Some restrictions may apply. Visit www.aircraftspruce.com/eaaDiscountGuide.html for a list of discounts. 2 Subject to credit
approval. Net purchases are purchases minus credits and returns. Accounts must be open and in good standing (not past due)
to earn and redeem rewards. Bonus points will be credited to your account within 6-8 weeks after first purchase. 3 Cash back
is redeemed in the form of a statement credit. EAA Webinars are supported by
The creditor and issuer of the EAA Card is U.S. Bank National Association, pursuant to a license from Visa U.S.A. Inc. © 2014
U.S. Bank National Association
EAA Experimenter 23
KLAUS SAVIER’S DETERMINATOR
KLAUS SAVIER CALLS HIS Long-EZ the Determinator. The air- The result of all those improvements? Klaus increased the
plane’s name seems to be a “quadruple entendre”: Klaus is VariEze’s speed from 183 to an amazing 260 mph. His experi-
determined to terminate inefciency, and he wanted to use the mentation made him go—can you believe this—42 percent
plane to determine what can be achieved in efciency and per- faster! Also, if he flies at 15 percent power, the VariEze can get
formance. Or, the name could reference Klaus’ German accent; 100 mpg.
he sounds a bit like Arnold Schwarzenegger’s movie character Klaus considered buying a partially completed Long-EZ
the Terminator would, if he had ever been the poster boy for back in 1985, but he wasn’t very optimistic about its perfor-
experimental aviation. mance over his modified VariEze. “At first glance, there was no
chance that the Long-EZ could do any better,” Klaus explained.
“It could only burn more fuel.” He ended up buying the Long-
EZ at 10 cents on the dollar but continued to work on the
VariEze for several more years. Eventually Klaus had so many
parts left over from his VariEze modifications that he figured he
should just incorporate them onto his Long-EZ project.
So what did Klaus do to his airplanes to make them go
faster? Lots and lots of little things.
Before we get into specifics, some words of caution. “Do
not try this at home,” he warned. “Changing little things on an
airplane, especially a canard, can have big efects, mostly nega-
tive.” EAA Sport Aviation (November 2009) reported that bugs,
paint stripes, or even rain near the leading edge of a canard can
increase minimum flying speed and cause pitch changes.
Klaus’ cautious approach is how he has developed an
impressively methodical and exceptionally thorough process
Klaus Savier and his Determinator, a much-modified Long-EZ. to make his planes go faster. For each improvement he contem-
plates, he goes through four phases:
Klaus, the stocky, serious, self-taught engineer, said, “I’ve 1. Understand the situation.
made hundreds of improvements, mostly aimed at going faster.” 2. Design a fix.
He started experimenting in 1983 with his VariEze. (He calls 3. Test the fix.
that the Delaminator.) Thirty-one years later, he still continues 4. Repeat until satisfied. (This would be “never satisfied”
to improve his airplanes. Some of the VariEze improvements for Klaus.)
were in the propulsion system—more sophisticated intake tun- The improvements Klaus has made fall into three catego-
ing and a better fuel-injection system. Aerodynamic modifica- ries. The first is with the propulsion system: intake, ignition,
tions were more numerous: changes to the canard elevator slot; exhaust, propeller, and fuel subsystems. The goal here is to
upswept canard tips; and a new canard airfoil, among others. improve efciency and run the engine at lower rpm.
from the original cylinder’s exhaust. This means that the second What about the propeller—was there anything to be gained
cylinder’s exhaust gas doesn’t completely leave the cylinder. A from modifications there? Klaus, through his company Light
tuned exhaust, on the other hand, reduces the exhaust pressure Speed Engineering, has designed, built, and tested more than
right before the port closes, using resonances like those occurring 50 propellers for diferent aircraft. He knows how to optimize
in the intake system. This lets spent gas out of the cylinder and their shape.
fresh mixture into it, improving engine efciency. “It’s really hard to get speed out of a propeller,” he said. “It’s
“I talked to all sorts of people who were knowledgeable about tough to increase the propeller efciency of a good propeller.
exhaust systems,” Klaus said. “One let me use his shop. I spent six All you can do is increase the maximum rpm where the engine
weekends and $2,000 worth of material. After all these modifica- makes more hp.” Propeller modifications let you set your optimal
tions, the best I could do was 10 pounds more weight and 6 knots performance at lower rpm, saving wear and tear on the engine
less speed. This was one of my bigger mistakes.” Klaus urges cau- and reducing fuel costs. But again, he has made discoveries that go
tion when talking to experts, as it’s easy to get bad advice. Because against the conventional wisdom. For the Determinator, he uses a
of that experience and because there is so little room for a longer carbon, fixed-pitch propeller that he designed and hand carved to
exhaust on a pusher airplane, the Long-EZ’s exhaust is still on his an amazing 100-plus inches of pitch. It turns at 2,600 rpm.
list of future improvements. Making real propeller improvements aerodynamically is also
Next, Klaus decided on a timed-sequential, fuel-injection structurally challenging. Klaus cautions that metal props don’t
system. Traditional injectors fire all or two injectors as a group, work on pusher airplanes. “The blades get excited by the wake of
regardless of whether the cylinder is ready or not. A timed-se- the wing and cowling, and the aluminum, with its characteristi-
quential system opens the injector during a specified period in the cally poor fatigue life, will fail sooner or later,” he warned. “All of
intake cycle. Because of cowling constraints, Klaus had to buy a the wood and most of the composite props are fairly thick in order
smaller injector so he could put it in a better location. to have adequate structure. Aerodynamic improvements come
A diferent kind of problem came when Klaus put a header mainly from using a much thinner airfoil. But these thin blades are
tank behind the cockpit to replace the traditional external sump difcult to shape and require a vacuum-bagged laminate of very
blisters. He installed a transfer pump to fill the header from the high strength. Thin airfoils are also very sensitive to angle of at-
left main tank. A standpipe prevents accidental overfilling of tack. This means that if the pitch distribution does not correspond
the header tank. In flight, when the air hit the common vent, to the inflow angles, the blade will stall.” Klaus said that a racing
the dynamic pressure actually pushed fuel into the header tank, propeller is also on his list of future changes.
keeping it full. The solution? Reduce the area of the vent opening. Klaus has an unusual take on prop mounting. “In the 1930s,
Klaus made a new vent by wrapping carbon around the cap of a we stopped using wood propellers due to the increase in horse-
felt marker. Figure 3 shows Klaus’ header tank—with visual fuel power and the better performance of metal props,” he said. “We
gauge—and carbon vent tube. went from eight [mounting] bolts used for wood props to six bolts,
which are plenty for a metal hub.” Wood is less stif than metal,
so the bolts see more bending load. On the Long-EZ project, he
actually broke bolts at two diferent occasions before having a set
of custom bolts made. “Very expensive,” he said. For his 250-hp
engine, he hopes that the industry standard for wood props lowers
the bolt ending load, returning to eight bolts instead of six, and a
crush plate that is splined to the shaft.
AERODYNAMIC IMPROVEMENTS
Klaus has made dozens of changes to the way air flows over his
airplane. Recall that the first of our four-step process is to under-
stand the situation. How does Klaus understand the air?
Readers of last month’s Experimenter will recall from my ar-
ticle that we aeronautical engineers are obsessive about visualizing
airflow. We look for it in smoke trails, cofee cream, Saturn’s swirls,
and movie stars’ cigarette smoke. Klaus is widely recognized as the
world’s flow visualization guru. He uses whatever method he can
find, but the main techniques are oil flow and impingement.
In the oil flow method, special dark-colored oil is put on the
airplane before flight. After landing, the oil tracks show where the
air was—or was not. Klaus has a finely tuned mixture for his oil:
He starts with carbon black, the fine black powder that is added
Figure 3: The header tank with a visual gauge. to paint base to make it black. Carbon black is available on the
Figure 6: The bugs inside the cooling duct show that the airflow into the duct isn’t smooth.
Figure 5: Using oil visualization to determine airflow. Figure 6a: The Determinator’s sleek cowling.
Figure 8: Klaus uses this special blue “flash breaker” tape because it doesn’t
leave a residue and doesn’t come off in flight.
EAA Experimenter 29
KLAUS SAVIER’S DETERMINATOR
WEIGHT
Extra aircraft weight costs performance in a number of areas.
For instance, the wing needs to develop more lift, which in-
creases the drag. The need for more lift means that the heavier
airplane will stall at higher speed than the lighter one. It takes
more control authority to get the same angular rates with more
weight, especially if that weight is toward the front/back or
left/right of the aircraft. Extra weight means more load on
structural members, meaning they might have to be sturdier
and heavier. More weight might mean a shift in the airplane’s
center of gravity.
On the other hand, reducing weight arbitrarily could get you
into trouble, too. Of course, cutting back on structural elements
is a problem, but even cutting back on that wing skin thick-
ness or heavy counterweight could increase the risk of flutter.
On the Facetmobile, the two counterweights on the elevons
weighed 7 pounds, and they afected the CG of its light, long
airplane. It goes without saying (although some should have
Figure 12: A standard NACA cooling air duct. been told) that you need to know what you’re doing if you plan
to increase or decrease your airplane’s weight.
The reason the duct starts out narrow and then widens is Klaus naturally applied his methodical, persistent approach
to increase the area slowly to avoid flow separation. The ver- to cutting weight on the Determinator. For example, when he
tical sides of the duct produce two counter-rotating vortices was changing the injector location, he made an all-carbon-fiber
that roll off the sides and into the duct. These vortices cause intake plenum. He also built a 9-quart oil sump that weighs 2.1
more air to move into the duct than normally would. pounds. The sump alone saved 11 pounds.
Klaus looked at NACA ducts that had been in use for 70 Klaus again warns that such engine parts require a specific
years and wondered something: “How do the two vortices process. “They should be vacuumed for reduced porosity and
created by the duct shape fit into the rectangular opening?” only use cured epoxy from an oven at least 300°F,” he warned.
So Klaus played with the shape of the edges of the inlet. Fig- Some of Klaus’ other weight-saving changes include
ure 13 shows the duct he flies on the Determinator. replacing the plywood and glass firewall with a high-temper-
EAA Experimenter 31
WHAT OUR MEMBERS ARE BUILDING
2014
Perseverance
Awards
Celebrating more builders’ success
BY JOHN MANGOLD
Why wait?
You’ve dreamed about owning an aircraft for years.
Now is the time. EAA Finance Solutions will help you
make those dreams a reality. It’s easy, with no hassles
and no waiting period–submit your documents
securely online and get your answer within 24 hours.
EAA members get access to member-exclusive
discounts on already industry-low rates and
loan fees on the types of aircraft they fly.
Finance
Solutions
Administered by National Aircraft Finance Company
EAA Experimenter 33
WHAT OUR MEMBERS ARE BUILDING
$
29 .95
Jan. 31-Feb. 1 ......Van’s RV Assembly................................................................Waco, TX
February 7-8.........Composite Construction, Fabric Covering, ............Chesapeake, VA
Sheet Metal, Electrical Systems, Gas Welding,
Fundamentals of Aircraft Construction,
$29.95 is the EAA & What’s Involved in Kit Building
Member price.
Non-member price February 21-22 ....Composite Construction, Fabric Covering, ...................Lakeland, FL
is $36.95.
Gas Welding, Sheet Metal Basics,
& Electrical Systems and Avionics
Personal
Insurance
Administered by Falcon Insurance Agency, Inc.
Coverage is underwritten by Starr Indemnity & Liability Company, a Texas insurance company, has its principal
place of business in New York, NY and is an admitted insurer rated “A” (Excellent) by A.M. Best Company.
EAA Experimenter 35
HINTS FOR HOMEBUILDERS
That’s Not Above: Sean’s Destiny 2000 powered parachute. Below: The replaced U-brackets.
Normal
Check your brackets!
BY SEAN CURRY
The D-motor in the B.O.T. SC07 aircraft, imported into the U.S. by Renegade Aircraft, www.renegadelightsport.com.
THE ENGINE CHOICES AVAILABLE for the ultralight, light-sport, Although D-motor’s engines look pretty conventional,
and experimental markets were, in the recent past, fairly they have characteristics that can’t be found in almost any
limited, with the default industry standard Rotax 912 engine other current engine. Despite the fact that the D-motor
leading the way. That situation changed in the last several engines were designed in the last decade, some of their
years with the introduction of several interesting engines design features originated from the past. Side valves or
designed solely for light aviation use, including the Jabiru, the “flathead” design used in postwar times and an ECU
ULPower, and others, along with several auto conversion electronic ignition don’t seem to fit together at first glance.
engines, such as the VW and Corvair, that gained increased This unusual mix made me curious. And it’s one of the main
popularity in the experimental market. reasons why I decided to visit the D-motor plant in Deer-
Among those newcomers is the Belgian D-motor. The lijk, Belgium, and get the design features explained by one
D-motor was first presented in Europe in 2010 as the of the company owners, Alain Dejager.
four-cylinder LF26 engine with 80 hp. In 2013, D-motor When I arrived in Deerlijk in the southwestern part
followed that with the 125-hp, direct-drive LF39 engine. In of Belgium, I was looking for an aircraft engine manufac-
2013 the LF26 (the numbers behind the “LF” stand for en- turer, but at the address listed I found only a car body shop.
gine displacement in liters) reached the final development Nevertheless, I rang the bell and Alain Dejager received me
stage and went into serial production at 92 hp. Now the personally. Alain explained that this automotive business,
Belgian manufacturer is working on production of a new, M & M Cars, provides the financial base for the aviation
six-cylinder LF39 engine, which recently began test flights. engine development.
EAA Experimenter 39
UNDER THE COWL
the intake stroke, the intake valve will open, and the suc-
tion caused by the downward movement of the piston will
draw the air/fuel mixture into the cylinder and cylinder
head. The intake air/fuel mixture flow path is not smooth.
The flat surfaces and internal corners are not conducive
to good airflow. Usually there are too many obstructions
that cause turbulence and airflow eddies that impede ef-
ficient air movement. The same thing happens during the
exhaust stroke.
When I asked the D-motor designers about this subop-
timal side-valve engine characteristic, I got the following
answer: “That is true and we can’t deny these facts. We
have tested countless cylinder heads solutions with dif-
ferent combustion-chamber shapes until we reached the
present optimal shape. Because our engine is directly driv-
ing a propeller (low rpm engine), those nonoptimal engine
characteristics don’t affect our engines.” That is pretty
This image of the upside-down engine shows the flat cylinder head cover... correct because this airflow inefficiency is not a problem
for low revolving engines, and the LF26/39 engines turn at
3,000 rpm. At D-motor they are particularly proud of the
safety aspect of their engines. They said, “When a valve
of a conventional overhead engine does not close, the en-
gine stops and is likely to be ruined. When a valve of a side-
valve engine does not close, the engine develops less power
but it will not stop running and there won’t be expensive
repair cost.”
The engine block is divided in two halves vertically. The
crankshaft protrudes out of the front part of the engine
block with a prop-flange attachment (different length
prop flanges can be ordered); on the rear, the crankshaft
ends with a toothed gear that drives the single camshaft.
The camshaft ends on the engine front with an oil pump.
Neither of the four-stroke engines has cooling liquid or oil
thermostats, but they can be fitted if required.
...and below it the extraordinary flat cylinder head. For a better explanation, two
cylinder-heads are pictured--one from inside (above) and the other from outside (below). ENGINE PRODUCTION
The D-motor factory has its own molds for the engines,
and most of its aluminum engine parts are machined in-
house, making them less dependent on outside suppliers.
Another interesting engine detail is that the cylinders and
cylinder heads are not screwed to the engine block by long
steel studs, such as with the Rotax 912 engines. Instead the
cylinders are bolted to the engine block with short screws,
as with Lycoming engines. The cylinder heads are screwed
by even shorter screws to the cylinder bodies. Nonmoving
engine parts are aluminum, while the crankshaft, camshaft,
and connecting rods are steel, of course. The cylinder walls
are Nikasil coated. Because of these material choices and
because the engines have a relatively low number of parts,
they don’t weigh much. The 92-hp, four-cylinder engine
weighs only 126 pounds (58 kilograms). The 135-hp six-
cylinder engine weighs 170 pounds (78 kilograms). Those
Close-up of the “real” cylinder head; because of the engine’s flathead design, the valves numbers are for dry weight and include the exhaust,
are not located in the cylinder head. Instead, they are located below it parallel to the intake, fluid coolant, and the oil tank. Wet weight with
cylinder barrel.
EAA Experimenter 41
UNDER THE COWL
ECU. After a short turn of the ignition key, with the OAT at noise level increased considerably, and I could hardly dis-
30°C, the engine went alive almost instantly. ECU checks tinguish the noise from that of a Rotax engine. I liked the
take place at 2200 rpm; that consists of switching between engine most at a speed of 100 mph (160 kilometers/hour),
the two independent channels and basically comparing where the engine rotated at 2,400 rpm with a MAP of 24
the engine numbers. This ECU check is only doable if the inches Hg. The display indicated a consumption of 2.9 gph
optional two-channel ECU is installed. In flight, both chan- (11 liters) at that power setting. The average of the previous
nels of the ECU are active, each controlling separate igni- flights was indicated with 2.84 gallons/hour (13 liters). At
tion coils and spark plugs. low throttle settings below 2000 rpm, the engine sound was
After the engine start, the engine stabilized at just under pleasantly unobtrusive and not annoying. At these speeds,
800 rpm at idle, and after barely five minutes, coolant and you could clearly hear the sound of the slowly revolving,
oil temperatures were in green. direct-drive engine. While taxiing on the ground after land-
During taxi to the runway, I was impressed by the quiet, ing with open doors, I loved the engine sound. Even with-
smooth-running engine and pleasant exhaust sound. At out a special absorbing silencer, the engine was quiet. For
start, as well as in flight, the engine responded very quickly me, the engine was almost too quiet. Alain Dejager laughed,
to different throttle settings, without the engine show- saying, “So far we were able to solve all engine problems;
ing any uncertainties or inertia (delay) after the throttle we are going to fix even this one for you.”
change. At full-throttle (WOT) straight and level flight, the
D-MOTOR’S HISTORY
The history of D-motor engines crosses at its beginning
with another Belgian engine manufacturer, ULPower. Both
engines originated with the Belgian Masquito M80 heli-
copter project that was originally powered by a two-stroke
Rotax 582 and later by the Jabiru 2200. Since those engines
were not strong enough, in 2004, D-motor and ULPower
developed their own engines for that project. A few
shareholders of Masquito Aircraft founded ULPower
Aero Engines.
Other Masquito technicians founded Mascotte, the com-
pany that developed the Masschi 105 engine. In 2006 that
company took over the Masquito project and continued
with it until 2008. Later, D-motor was established and the
project was resumed. The LF26 debuted in 2010 in Brus-
sels, Belgium, and at AERO Friedrichshafen in Germany.
That same year the engine had its maiden flight in an
This is the all new double ECU used on the LF39 engine (standard on LF39, X-Air microlight.
optional on LF26); the “B” channel is in use. D-motor plans to raise the company’s registered capital
to $4 million through an agreement signed in April 2014
with a Chinese investor and distributor of the D-engine
products in Asia.
Currently, the six-cylinder engine is flying on the
company’s own test aircraft in Belgium, and since June, on
board of the German EDM Aerotec CoAX 2D/2R helicopter
where it has logged 100 flying hours. As of September 2014,
the temporary retail price of the LF39 is $19,900, according
to the U.S. importer, Doc Bailey. According to Doc, the price
includes the muffler, mounting hardware, coolant lines, and
dual ECU—basically everything but the battery, prop, and
radiator. The first six-cylinder engines are now on the way
to European aircraft manufacturers.
For more information, visit www.D-motor.eu.
Tailor-made
Tailor-made stands for quality and durability.
Like builders and restorers who tailor-make the
intricate details of their aircraft, we take the time
to evaluate all your coverage options to tailor
a plan that won’t fall short of the mark.
Insurance
Visit EAA.org/tailormade or call us
toll-free at 866-647-4322 for a quote.
Solutions
Administered by Falcon Insurance, Inc.
EAALowerRates.com
866-647-4322
EAA Experimenter 43
ULTRALIGHT WORLD
SIX CHUTER INTERNATIONAL LLC recently announced the produc- The P3 Lite is ofered in two standard colors, black or white.
tion of its all-new ultralight powered parachute (PPC) The molded seats are available in a variety of colors, and the op-
model called the P3 Lite. The P3 Lite is a single-seat tional upholstery is likewise available in various colors. The PD
PPC that meets the strict requirements of FAR 103 for 360 canopy has several stock colors or can be custom designed
ultralight aircraft. at no extra cost.
The model is equipped with a Kawasaki 440A engine, Doug Maas, president of Six Chuter and director of mar-
an Ultra-Prop, simple instrumentation, and a Performance keting, outlined the objectives of the design. These included
Designs (PD) Barnstormer 360 canopy. The model is being making a true, legal ultralight PPC that could be more easily
offered for $9,995 in kit form, and the company includes a manufactured and easily and quickly built from kit form. The
$500 coupon for training at that price. price objective was to hit the market with a retail price under
The P3 Lite is built on a strong but light airframe made $10,000. The design also is intended to make a slightly smaller
of aluminum and chromoly steel components. The Kawasaki footprint for ease of transport while increasing the comfort and
engine is rated by the engine manufacturer at 750 hours fit for even taller and larger pilots.
between overhaul. These were quite formidable goals given the cost of materi-
The Barnstormer 360 canopy is easy to fly and ofers great als and the existing competition in the market.
performance. The seat is an oversized molded plastic seat Maas explained that the primary driver for the project was
with optional padded upholstery. The seatbelt is a heavy-duty, when Rotax announced the discontinuation of its popular 503
“racing”-style belt with shoulder straps. engine series. That engine had been used on Six Chuters and
EAA Experimenter 45