You are on page 1of 153

DESIGN

GUIDE
for midas Civil
AASHTO LRFD

Prestressed Box Girder Design

Steel Composite Girder Design


DESIGN
GUIDE
for midas Civil
AASHTO LRFD
dŚĞŽďũĞĐƟǀĞŽĨƚŚŝƐĚĞƐŝŐŶŐƵŝĚĞŝƐƚŽŽƵƚůŝŶĞƚŚĞĚĞƐŝŐŶ
ĂůŐŽƌŝƚŚŵƐǁŚŝĐŚĂƌĞĂƉƉůŝĞĚŝŶŵŝĚĂƐŝǀŝůĮŶŝƚĞĞůĞŵĞŶƚ
analysis and design system. The guide aims to provide
ƐƵĸĐŝĞŶƚŝŶĨŽƌŵĂƟŽŶĨŽƌƚŚĞƵƐĞƌƚŽƵŶĚĞƌƐƚĂŶĚƚŚĞ
ƐĐŽƉĞ͕ůŝŵŝƚĂƟŽŶƐĂŶĚĨŽƌŵƵůĂƐĂƉƉůŝĞĚŝŶƚŚĞĚĞƐŝŐŶ
features and to provide relevant references to the clauses
in the Design standards.

The design guide covers prestressed box girder, composite


steel box girder, composite plate girder as per AASHTO LRFD.

It is recommended that you read this guide and review


corresponding tutorials, which are found on our web site,
ŚƩƉ͗ͬͬǁǁǁ͘DŝĚĂƐhƐĞƌ͘ĐŽŵ͕ďĞĨŽƌĞĚĞƐŝŐŶŝŶŐ͘ĚĚŝƟŽŶĂů
ŝŶĨŽƌŵĂƟŽŶĐĂŶďĞĨŽƵŶĚŝŶƚŚĞŽŶůŝŶĞŚĞůƉĂǀĂŝůĂďůĞŝŶ
the program’s main menu.

DISCLAIMER
Developers and distributors assume no responsibility for
the use of MIDAS Family Program (midas Civil, midas FEA,
midas FX+, midas Gen, midas Drawing, midas SDS, midas
'd^͕^ŽŝůtŽƌŬƐ͕ŵŝĚĂƐE&y͖ŚĞƌĞŝŶĂŌĞƌƌĞĨĞƌƌĞĚƚŽĂƐ
“MIDAS package”) or for the accuracy or validity of any
results obtained from the MIDAS package.

Developers and distributors shall not be liable for loss of


ƉƌŽĮƚ͕ůŽƐƐŽĨďƵƐŝŶĞƐƐ͕ŽƌĮŶĂŶĐŝĂůůŽƐƐǁŚŝĐŚŵĂLJďĞ
caused directly or indirectly by the MIDAS package, when
used for any purpose or use, due to any defect or
ĚĞĮĐŝĞŶĐLJƚŚĞƌĞŝŶ͘ĐĐŽƌĚŝŶŐůLJ͕ƚŚĞƵƐĞƌŝƐĞŶĐŽƵƌĂŐĞĚƚŽ
fully understand the bases of the program and become
familiar with the users manuals. The user shall also inde-
pendently verify the results produced by the program.
Foreword
dŚĞŽďũĞĐƟǀĞŽĨƚŚŝƐĚĞƐŝŐŶŐƵŝĚĞŝƐƚŽŽƵƚůŝŶĞƚŚĞĚĞƐŝŐŶĂůŐŽƌŝƚŚŵƐ
ǁŚŝĐŚĂƌĞĂƉƉůŝĞĚŝŶŵŝĚĂƐŝǀŝůĮŶŝƚĞĞůĞŵĞŶƚĂŶĂůLJƐŝƐĂŶĚĚĞƐŝŐŶ
ƐLJƐƚĞŵ͘dŚĞŐƵŝĚĞĂŝŵƐƚŽƉƌŽǀŝĚĞƐƵĸĐŝĞŶƚŝŶĨŽƌŵĂƟŽŶĨŽƌƚŚĞ
ƵƐĞƌƚŽƵŶĚĞƌƐƚĂŶĚƚŚĞƐĐŽƉĞ͕ůŝŵŝƚĂƟŽŶƐĂŶĚĨŽƌŵƵůĂƐĂƉƉůŝĞĚŝŶ
ƚŚĞĚĞƐŝŐŶĨĞĂƚƵƌĞƐĂŶĚƚŽƉƌŽǀŝĚĞƌĞůĞǀĂŶƚƌĞĨĞƌĞŶĐĞƐƚŽƚŚĞ
ĐůĂƵƐĞƐŝŶƚŚĞĞƐŝŐŶƐƚĂŶĚĂƌĚƐ͘

dŚĞĚĞƐŝŐŶŐƵŝĚĞĐŽǀĞƌƐƉƌĞƐƚƌĞƐƐĞĚďŽdžŐŝƌĚĞƌ͕ĐŽŵƉŽƐŝƚĞƐƚĞĞůďŽdž
ŐŝƌĚĞƌĂŶĚĐŽŵƉŽƐŝƚĞƉůĂƚĞŐŝƌĚĞƌĂƐƉĞƌƵƌŽĐŽĚĞ͘

/ƚŝƐƌĞĐŽŵŵĞŶĚĞĚƚŚĂƚLJŽƵƌĞĂĚƚŚŝƐŐƵŝĚĞĂŶĚƌĞǀŝĞǁĐŽƌƌĞƐƉŽŶĚ-
ŝŶŐƚƵƚŽƌŝĂůƐ͕ǁŚŝĐŚĂƌĞĨŽƵŶĚŽŶŽƵƌǁĞďƐŝƚĞ͕
ŚƩƉ͗ͬͬǁǁǁ͘DŝĚĂƐhƐĞƌ͘ĐŽŵ͕ďĞĨŽƌĞĚĞƐŝŐŶŝŶŐ͘ĚĚŝƟŽŶĂůŝŶĨŽƌŵĂ-
ƟŽŶĐĂŶďĞĨŽƵŶĚŝŶƚŚĞŽŶůŝŶĞŚĞůƉĂǀĂŝůĂďůĞŝŶƚŚĞƉƌŽŐƌĂŵ͛ƐŵĂŝŶ
ŵĞŶƵ͘

Organization
dŚŝƐŐƵŝĚĞŝƐĚĞƐŝŐŶĞĚƚŽŚĞůƉLJŽƵƋƵŝĐŬůLJďĞĐŽŵĞƉƌŽĚƵĐƟǀĞǁŝƚŚ
ƚŚĞĚĞƐŝŐŶŽƉƟŽŶƐŽĨ^,dK>Z&͘

ŚĂƉƚĞƌϭƉƌŽǀŝĚĞƐĚĞƚĂŝůĞĚĚĞƐĐƌŝƉƟŽŶƐŽĨƚŚĞĚĞƐŝŐŶƉĂƌĂŵĞƚĞƌƐ͕
h>^ͬ^>^ĐŚĞĐŬƐ͕ĚĞƐŝŐŶŽƵƚƉƵƚƐƵƐĞĚĨŽƌƉƌĞƐƚƌĞƐƐĞĚďŽdžŐŝƌĚĞƌ
ĚĞƐŝŐŶƚŽ^,dK>Z&͘
ŚĂƉƚĞƌϮƉƌŽǀŝĚĞƐĚĞƚĂŝůĞĚĚĞƐĐƌŝƉƟŽŶƐŽĨƚŚĞĚĞƐŝŐŶƉĂƌĂŵĞƚĞƌƐ͕
h>^ͬ^>^ĐŚĞĐŬƐ͕ĚĞƐŝŐŶŽƵƚƉƵƚƐƵƐĞĚĨŽƌƐƚĞĞůĐŽŵƉŽƐŝƚĞŐŝƌĚĞƌ
ĚĞƐŝŐŶƚŽ^,Kd>Z&͘

ƐƚŚĞƚĂďůĞŽĨĐŽŶƚĞŶƚƐŝƐƉƌŝŶƚĞĚŽŶƚŚĞĨŽůĚĞĚŇĂƉ͕ƚŚĞƌĞĂĚĞƌƐ
ĐĂŶĂĐĐĞƐƐƚŚĞƚĂďůĞŽĨĐŽŶƚĞŶƚƐĞĂƐŝůLJĨƌŽŵĂŶLJƉĂŐĞŽĨƚŚĞŬ͘
Contents

01 Chapter 1.
Prestressed Box Girder Design (AASHTO LRFD)

Strength Limit States


1. Flexural resistance 02
2. Shear resistance 14
3. Torsion resistance 25

Serviceability Limit States


ϭ͘^ƚƌĞƐƐĨŽƌĐƌŽƐƐƐĞĐƟŽŶĂƚĂĐŽŶƐƚƌƵĐƟŽŶƐƚĂŐĞ 31
Ϯ͘^ƚƌĞƐƐĨŽƌĐƌŽƐƐƐĞĐƟŽŶĂƚƐĞƌǀŝĐĞůŽĂĚƐ 36
3. Tensile stress for Prestressing tendons 40
ϰ͘WƌŝŶĐŝƉĂůƐƚƌĞƐƐĂƚĂĐŽŶƐƚƌƵĐƟŽŶƐƚĂŐĞ 43
ϱ͘WƌŝŶĐŝƉĂůƐƚƌĞƐƐĂƚƐĞƌǀŝĐĞůŽĂĚƐ 45
ϲ͘WƌŝŶĐŝƉĂůƐƚƌĞƐƐĂƚƐĞƌǀŝĐĞůŽĂĚƐ 47
7. Check crack 49
DESIGN GUIDE
for midas Civil
AASHTO LRFD

52 Chapter 2.
Steel Composite Girder Design (AASHTO LRFD)

/ŶƚƌŽĚƵĐƟŽŶ
1. AASHTO LRFD 07 and 12 Steel Composite 54
Ϯ͘ŽŶƐŝĚĞƌĂƟŽŶƐ^ƚĞĞůŽŵƉŽƐŝƚĞĞƐŝŐŶ 56
ϯ͘ĂůĐƵůĂƟŽŶŽĨWůĂƐƟĐDŽŵĞŶƚĂŶĚzŝĞůĚDŽŵĞŶƚ 56

Modeling and Design Variables


ϭ͘DŽĚĞůŝŶŐĞƐŝŐŶsĂƌŝĂďůĞƐ 64

ƉƉůŝĐĂƟŽŶŽĨ^,dK>Z&ϭϮ
ϭ͘/'ŝƌĚĞƌ^ĞĐƟŽŶ 84
Ϯ͘ŽdžͬdƵď'ŝƌĚĞƌ^ĞĐƟŽŶ 108
ϯ͘^ŚĞĂƌŽŶŶĞĐƚŽƌ 124
ϰ͘^ƟīĞŶĞƌ 127
ϱ͘ŝīĞƌĞŶĐĞĞƚǁĞĞŶ^,dKͲ>Z&ϰƚŚ(2007)ĂŶĚϲƚŚ(2012) 131

^ƚĞĞůŽŵƉŽƐŝƚĞĞƐŝŐŶZĞƐƵůƚ
ϭ͘^ƚƌĞŶŐƚŚ>ŝŵŝƚ^ƚĂƚĞZĞƐƵůƚ 134
2. Service Limit State Result 137
ϯ͘ŽŶƐƚƌƵĐƟďŝůŝƚLJZĞƐƵůƚ 138
ϰ͘&ĂƟŐƵĞ>ŝŵŝƚ^ƚĂƚĞZĞƐƵůƚ 141
ϱ͘^ŚĞĂƌŽŶŶĞĐƚŽƌZĞƐƵůƚ 142
ϲ͘^ƟīĞŶĞƌZĞƐƵůƚ 143
ϳ͘^ƉĂŶŚĞĐŬŝŶŐ 144
ϴ͘dŽƚĂůŚĞĐŬŝŶŐ 145
Chapter 1.

Prestressed Box
Girder Design
AASHTO LRFD 6th (2012)
Chapter 1.
Prestressed Box Girder Design (AASHTO LRFD 12)
WƌĞƐƚƌĞƐƐĞĚďŽdžŐŝƌĚĞƌŶĞĞĚƐƚŽďĞĚĞƐŝŐŶĞĚƚŽƐĂƟƐĨLJƚŚĞĨŽůůŽǁŝŶŐůŝŵŝƚƐƚĂƚĞƐ͘

hůƟŵĂƚĞ>ŝŵŝƚ^ƚĂƚĞƐ
&ůĞdžƵƌĂůZĞƐŝƐƚĂŶĐĞ

^ŚĞĂƌZĞƐŝƐƚĂŶĐĞ

dŽƌƐŝŽŶZĞƐŝƐƚĂŶĐĞ

^ĞƌǀŝĐĞĂďŝůŝƚLJ>ŝŵŝƚ^ƚĂƚĞƐ
^ƚƌĞƐƐĨŽƌĐƌŽƐƐƐĞĐƟŽŶĂƚĂĐŽŶƐƚƌƵĐƟŽŶƐƚĂŐĞ

^ƚƌĞƐƐĨŽƌĐƌŽƐƐƐĞĐƟŽŶĂƚƐĞƌǀŝĐĞůŽĂĚƐ

dĞŶƐŝůĞƐƚƌĞƐƐĨŽƌWƌĞƐƚƌĞƐƐŝŶŐƚĞŶĚŽŶƐ

WƌŝŶĐŝƉĂůƐƚƌĞƐƐĂƚĂĐŽŶƐƚƌƵĐƟŽŶƐƚĂŐĞ

WƌŝŶĐŝƉĂůƐƚƌĞƐƐĂƚƐĞƌǀŝĐĞůŽĂĚƐ

ŚĞĐŬĐƌĂĐŬ
Chapter 1. Prestressed Box Girder Design: AASHTO-LRFD 6th (2012)

Strength Limit States



1. Flexural resistance
The factored flexural resistance shall satisfy the following condition, Mu чɌDn.
Where, Mu : Factored moment at the section due to strength load combination
ĭ0n : Factored flexural resistance

1.1. Resistance Factor


AASHTO LRFD12
Resistance factor Ɍ shall be taken as follow. (5.5.4.2.1)

[Fig.1. 1] Resistance Factor

I 0.75 if H t d 0.002
dt
I 0.583  0.25 if 0.002  H t  0.005 (1.1)
c
I 1.0 if H t t 0.005

Where,
dt : Distance from extreme compression fiber to the centroid of the extreme tension steel element
c : Distance from the extreme compression fiber to the neutral axis
İt : Net tensile Strain

/ŶŵŝĚĂƐŝǀŝů͕ɸt is applied as strain of a reinforcement which is entered at the extreme tensile


fiber.


Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 2
Input reinforcements to be used in the calculation of resistance in the dialog box below.
೛ Model>Properties>Section Manager>Reinforcements

Rebar coordinate
at the section

Entered rebar data

[Fig.1. 2] Input Longitudinal reinforcement

Once reinforcement is entered at the PSC section, the rebar which is placed at the closest
position to the extreme compression fiber will be used to calculate the strain. In short, the rebar
at the bottom most is used under the sagging moment. And the rebar at the top most is used
under the hogging moment.

Input tendon profile to be used in PSC design in the dialog box below.
೛ Load>Temp./Prestress>Section Manager >Tendon Profile

Tendon position which is placed at the closest


position to the extreme tensile fiber will be used
to calculate the strain.





 [Fig.1.3] Tendon Profile








3 Design Guide for midas Civil


1.2 Calculate neutral axis depth
Neutral axis is determined by the iteration approach as shown in the figure below.

Initial c = H/2
Assume neutral axis depth, c
(H=Section Height)

Calculate Cc (Concrete) (1)

Calculate Ts, Cs (Reinforcement) (2)

Calculate Tps (Tendon) (3)

(4)
NO
Cc+Cs-(Ts+Tps)=0?

YES

Get neutral axis depth, c

[Fig.1. 4] Flow chart to calculate neutral axis depth, c

(1) Calculate force of concrete, Cc.


In midas Civil, the natural relationship between concrete stress and strain is considered as
the equivalent rectangular concrete compressive stress block.(Compressive strain limit of
concrete, ɸcu = 0.003)

[Fig.1. 5] Calculate force of concrete, Cc

Cc 0.85 f 'c Ac (1.2)

Where,
f 'c : Specified compressive strength of concrete for design
Compressive strength to be used in PSC design is defined in PSC Design Material dialog box.
E 0.85 if f 'c d 4.0ksi
0.85  0.05( f 'c  4.0) t 0.65 if f 'c ! 4.0ksi
Ac : Concrete area of compressive zone ( E1c) u width


Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 4
೛ PSC>PSC Design Data> PSC Design Material…

Concrete

Reinforcement

[Fig.1. 6] PSC Design Material

Enter the concrete and reinforcement grade to be used in PSC design. The strength can be
checked for the selected material grade according to the selected material code. When
“None” is selected in Code field, the strength of concrete and reinforcement can be directly
entered.

(2) Calculate force of reinforcement, Ts, Cs.


Tensile resistance due to longitudinal reinforcement (Ts)and compression resistance due to AASHTO LRFD12
(5.7.2.2)
concrete (Cs) is calculated as shown in the following equation.

Ts As f s , Cs As ' f s ' (1.3)

Where,
As, As’ : the cross sectional area of tensile and compressive reinforcement
It is entered in Section Manager>Reinforcements as shown in the Fig1. 2.
fs , fs’: the stress of tensile and compressive reinforcement

In order to calculate the tensile stress of reinforcement, midas Civil calculate the
corresponding strains as per the strain compatibility condition. And then the related tensile
stresses are calculated by the stress-strain relationship. The equation is shown as follows.

ඵ Strain

dt  c c  dc
Hs H cu , H s ' H cu (1.4)
c c

Where,
İs : the strain of tensile reinforcement.
İs’ : the strain of compressive reinforcement.
İcu WKHXOWLPDWHFRPSUHVVLYHVWUDLQLQWKHFRQFUHWH İcu = 0.003)
c : the neutral axis depth.
dt : Distance from the compression fiber of concrete to the extreme tensile fiber of reinforcement
dc : Distance from the compression fiber of concrete to the extreme compressive fiber of reinforcement

5 Design Guide for midas Civil


ඵ Stress
If the tensile stress of reinforcement reaches its yield stress limit, tensile stress will be
applied as yield stress. If not, the tensile stress will be calculated as “ɸs x Es”.

­H s Es ( fs d f y )
, ­H s ' Es ( fs ' d f y )
(1.5)
fs ® fs ' ®
¯ fy ( fs ! f y ) ¯ fy ( fs ' ! f y )

Where,
Es : Modulus of elasticity in reinforcement
Fy : Yield tensile stress in reinforcement

(3) Calculate force of tendon, Tps.


Tensile resistance of prestressing steel, Tps, is calculated as shown in the following equation.

Tps ¦A p f ps (1.6)

Where,
Ap : the cross sectional area of tendon.
fps : the stress of tendon.

೛ PSC> Design Parameter> Parameters…

[Fig.1. 7] PSC Design parameter Dialog - Flexural Strength

Tensile stress of prestressing steel fps can be calculated by code or strain compatibility as
specified in PSC design Parameter dialog box. When code is selected in flexural strength option,
the tensile stress fps is calculated by the equation as per AASHTO-LRFD for bonded and
unbounded tendon respectively. When strain compatibility is used, the tensile stress fps is
calculated by the stress-strain relationship.


Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 6
೛ Load>Temp./Prestress>Section Manager>Tendon Property

Tendon Type
Total Tendon Area

fpu
fpy

Bond Type

[Fig.1. 8] Tendon Property Dialog


ඵ Tendon Type
Internal(Pre-Tension)
Internal(Post-Tension)
External

ඵ Bond Type
Bonded: Section properties reflect the duct area after grouting.
When tendon type is specified as Internal (Pre-Tension), bond type will be taken as Bonded
Type.
Unbonded: Section properties exclude the duct area.
When tendon type is specified as external, bond type will be taken as Unbonded Type.


[Table1. 1] Applicable Bond Type by Tendon Types
Tendon Type Bond Type
Internal (Pre-tension) Bonded
Bonded
Internal (Post-tension)
Unbonded
External Unbonded

ඵ Total Tendon Area


Enter the tendon area (Ap). Click to select the number of strands and diameter in order
to calculate the tendon area automatically.

ඵ fpu, fpy
Enter the ultimate strength fpu and yield strength fpy of prestressing steel.
Tensile stress of prestressing steel fps will be calculated as shown in the following table.

[Table1. 2] Calculation of tensile stress of prestressing steel




Flexure Strength option Bond Type Tensile Stress


Bonded fps for Bonded Type
Code
Unbonded fps for Unbonded Type
Bonded Strain compatibility
Strain compatibility
Unbonded* fps for Unbonded Type
* When flexure strength option is entered as strain compatibility and bond type is entered as
unbonded type, tensile stress will be calculated using the code equation of unbonded tendon
instead of strain compatibility method. It is because strain compatibility method is valid for fully
bonded tendons.

7 Design Guide for midas Civil


Tensile stress of prestressing steel fps is calculated as follows.

ඵCode equation for bonded type tendon AASHTO LRFD12


(5.7.3.1.1)
(Eq. 5.7.3.1.1-1)
§ c ·
f ps f pu ¨1  k ¸ (1.7)
¨ d p ¸¹
©

§ f py · AASHTO LRFD12
k 2 ¨1.04  ¸ (1.8)
¨ f pu ¸¹
(5.7.3.1.1)
© (Eq. 5.7.3.1.1-2)

Where,
fpy: Yield strength of prestressing steel
fpu: Specified tensile strength of prestressing steel
dp: Distance from extreme compression fiber to the centroid of the prestressing tendons
c: Distance between the neutral axis and the compressive face

ඵ Code equation for unbonded type tendon


AASHTO LRFD12
(5.7.3.1.2) 
§ dp  c · (Eq. 5.7.3.1.2-1)
f ps f pe  900 ¨ ¸ d f py (1.9)
© le ¹

2li
le (1.10) AASHTO LRFD12
2  Ns (5.7.3.1.2) 
(Eq. 5.7.3.1.2-2)

Where,
li : length of tendon between anchorages
Ni : number of support hinges crossed by the tendon between anchorages or discretely bonded point. It
is always applied as “0” in midas Civil.

ඵ fps by Strain compatibility


When flexure resistance is calculated by strain compatibility method, tensile stress of
prestressing tendon is calculated by the stress-strain relationship.

[Fig.1. 9] Stress-strain model of prestressing tendon




(4) Determination of neutral axis position

Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 8
In order to find the neutral axis, the iteration analysis will be performed until compressive
strength (C=Cc+Cs) becomes equal to the tensile strength (T=Ts+Tps).

The convergence criterion is applied as shown in the following equation.


ͻŽŶǀĞƌŐĞŶĐĞĐŽŶĚŝƚŝŽŶ͗

C
Error! Bookmark not defined.  1.0  0.001 (Tolerance) (1.11)
T

1.3 Calculate moment resistance Mn


Once the neutral axis is determined, flexural resistance is calculated by multiplying the
distance from the neutral axis.

Mn Cc ac  Cs as ' Ts as  ¦ Tps a pi (1.12)

where,
ac, as, as’, api : the distance from neutral axis depth, c to concrete, reinforcement rebar, tendon.

0.85f˅c
Cs
As˅
a

Cc
c

as '
ac
ap
as

Ap Tps
As
Ts
[Fig.1. 10] Forces and distances from neutral axis depth for Mn

If a tendon in tension is located at the upper part from the neutral axis under the sagging
moment, the flexural resistance will have (-) sign and it will reduce the total moment
resistance.

Mn
Cc ac  Cs as ' Ts as  ¦ Tps a pi  T ps' a 'pi (1.13)

1.4 Factored Flexural Resistance


AASHTO LRFD12
(5.7.3.2.1)
Mr IMn (1.14) (Eq. 5.7.3.2.1-1)

where,
Mn : nominal resistance
ĭ : resistance factor

1.5 Minimum Reinforcement


The moment resistance with considering entered reinforcements or tendons shall satisfy the
following condition. AASHTO LRFD12
(5.7.3.3.2)

M r t max(1.33M u , M cr ) (1.15)

9 Design Guide for midas Civil


ඵ Cracked Moment ( Mcr)

ª § Sc ·º AASHTO LRFD12
M cr J 3 «(J 1 f r  J 2 f cpe ) Sc  M dnc ¨  1¸ » (1.16) (5.7.3.3.2)
¬ © S nc ¹¼ (Eq. 5.7.3.3.2-1)

In midas Civil, cracked moment shall be calculated as per the following equation.

M cr J 3 ª¬(J 1 f r  J 2 f cpe ) Sc º¼ (1.17)

Where,
Ȗ1 : flexural cracking variability factor
1.2 for precast segmental structures
1.6 for all other concrete structures

Ȗ2 : prestress variability factor


1.1 for bonded tendons
1.0 for unbounded tendons
If both bonded and unbonded type tendons are assigned in a section, J 2 will be applied as 1.0
which is more conservative value.

Ȗ3 : ratio of specified minimum yield strength to ultimate tensile strength of the reinforcement
0.67 for A615 ,Grade 60 reinforcement
0.75 for A706, Grade 60 reinforcement
1.00 for prestressed concrete structures

In midas Civil, J 3 wil be applied as 1.0.

fr : modulus of rupture of concrete specified in Article 5.4.2.6


AASHTO LRFD12
In midas Civil, fr will be always applied as 0.37 f 'c .
(5.4.2.6)
(C5.4.2.6)
Sc : section modulus for the extreme fiber of the composite section where tensile stress is caused by
externally applied loads (in3)
In midas Civil, section modulus under tension is applied.

fcpe : compressive stress in concrete due to effective prestress forces only (after allowance for all
prestress losses) at extreme fiber of section where tensile stress is caused by externally applied
loads (ksi)

It is obtained in elastic state (uncracked section) and the following equation has been
applied in midas Civil.

f cpe
¦A ps ef

¦A fe
ps e p
(1.18)
Ag S

Where,
f e : Effective prestress forces of prestressing tendons
e p : Distance from the neutral axis to the centroid of the prestressing tendons
Aps : Area of prestressing tendon
Ag : Gross area of cross-section
S : Sectional modulus in compression


Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 10
In midas Civil, construction type of PSC section is determined in PSC design parameter dialog
box.
೛ PSC> Design Parameter> Parameters…

[Fig.1. 3] PSC Design parameter Dialog - Construction Type

Construction type: Segmental, Non-Segmental


The selected construction type will affect the calculation of cracked moment, shear and
torsional resistance, and tensile stress limit of concrete.

1.6 Check moment resistance


In midas Civil, factored moment is obtained from load combinations specified in Load
Combinations dialog box. In AASHTO LRFD specification, load combinations need to be
generated as shown in the fig 1.12.

AASHTO LRFD12
(3.4.1)

[Fig.1. 4] Load Combinations and Load factors for strength limit state

11 Design Guide for midas Civil


೛Results>Load combinations>Concrete Design tab

Active:
Strength/Stress

Active:
Serviceability

[Fig.1. 5] Load Combinations dialog

In midas Civil, load combinations can be automatically generated by clicking [Auto


Generation…] button. The load combinations need to be generated in concrete design tab.
The most critical load combination among Strength/Stress type load combinations will be
used to obtain factored moment, factored shear force, and factored torsional moment. The
Service type load combinations will be used to verify the serviceability limit state.

The verification of flexural moment obtained from Strength/Stress type load combination
can be divided into two following cases.
1) No need to satisfy minimum reinforcement

Mr t Mu (1.19)

2) Need to satisfy minimum reinforcement

M r t M u and M r t M cr (1.20)

1.7 Moment resistance verification

1.7.1 by Result Tables


The results can be checked as shown in the table below.

೛Design>PSC Design>PSC Design Result Tables>Check Flexural Strength…

[Fig.1. 6] Result table for moment resistance


Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 12
Elem : Element number
Part : Check location (I-End, J-End) of each element.
Positive/Negative : Positive moment, negative moment.
LCom Name : Load combination name.
Type : Displays the set of member forces corresponding to moving load case or settlement load case for
which the maximum stresses are produced.
CHK : Flexural strength check for element
Muy : Design moment
Mcr : Crack Moment
Mny : Nominal moment resistance.
PhiMny : Design moment resistance.
Ratio : Muy/ PhiMny : Flexural resistance ratio, The verification is satisfied when it is less than 1.0.
PhiMny /min(1.33Muy, Mcr) : Verification of minimum reinforcement. The verification is satisfied when
it is less than 1.0. If the verification of minimum reinforcement is not required, it will be displayed as
1.0.

1.7.2 by Excel Report


Detail verification results can be checked in MS Excel report as shown in the figure below.

೛ Design>PSC Design>PSC Design Calculation…

[Fig.1. 7] Excel report for moment resistance

13 Design Guide for midas Civil


2. Shear resistance
Shear resistance without consideration of effects of torsion shall be verified to satisfy the
following condition.
AASHTO LRFD12
(5.5.4.2.1)
M u d IVn (1.21)

:KHUHVWUHQJWKUHGXFWLRQIDFWRUĭ 

Refer to the clause 2.3 Torsion Resistance for the verification of shear resistance where the
effects of torsion are required to be considered. In AASHTO-LRFD (2012), the design for
shear and torsion will be performed for segmental and non-segmental box girders.

2.1 Classification of Segmental Box Girder


The program will consider a section is segmental box girder when the following 2 conditions
are satisfied.
1. In PSC Design Parameter dialog box, Construction Type is specified as Segment.
2. When a section is defined with PSC box section (ex. PSC-1CELL, 2CELL, 3CELL, nCELL,
cCELL2, PLAT, and Value type)

೛ Property > Section Property > Section >PSC

[Fig.1.16] PSC section data dialog

2.2 Parameters for shear


2.2.1 Effective web width (bv)
bv : effective web width taken as the minimum web width within the depth dv as determined in Article
5.8.2.9 (in.)

Effective web width (bv) is taken as web thickness. For PSC multi-cell girder, web thickness AASHTO LRFD12
can be automatically taken as a summation of thickness for all webs. Also this value can be (5.8.3.3.3)
entered by the user directly as shown in the figure below.


Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 14
೛ Property > Section Property > Section >PSC

[Fig 1.17] Consideration of effective web width

1) When the user directly enters values for web thickness


Apply the minimum value among the entered web thickness values.
2) When “Auto” option is selected
Apply the minimum web thickness among t1, t2, and t3. These values are automatically
taken as a summation of thickness for both webs at the stress point, Z1, Z2, and Z3.

2.2.2 Effective shear depth (dv)


ඵ Non-Segmental Box Girder
dv : effective shear depth takem as the distance , measured perpendicular to the neutral axis,
between the resultants of the tensile and compressive forces due to flexure; it need not be
taken less than the greater of 0.9de or 0.72h(in.)

In midas Civil, the value of effective shear depth, dv, is calculated as shown in the equation AASHTO LRFD12
below. (5.8.2.9)

§ Mn ·
dv min ¨ , 0.9d e , 0.72h ¸ (1.22)
¨ As f s  Aps f ps ¸
© ¹

Aps f ps d p  As f s d s
de (1.23)
Aps f ps  As f s

Where,
dp : Distance from extreme compression fiber to the centroid of the prestressing tendons
ds : Distance from extreme fiber to the centroid of nonprestressed tensile reinforcement

15 Design Guide for midas Civil


[Fig.1.18] Effective shear depth

ඵ Segmental Box Girder

dv : 0.8h or the distance from the extreme compression fiber to the centroid of the prestressing
reinforcement , whichever is greater (in.)
AASHTO LRFD12
In midas Civil, the value of effective shear depth, dv, is calculated as shown in the equation (5.8.6.5)
below.

dv max 0.8h, dt (1.24)

Where,
h = Total height of a section
dt = Distance from extreme compression fiber to the centroid of the prestressing tendons

Ϯ͘Ϯ͘ϯEĞƚůŽŶŐŝƚƵĚŝŶĂůƚĞŶƐŝůĞƐƚƌĂŝŶ;ɸs)
Hs is the net longitudinal tensile strain in the section at the centroid of the tension
reinforcement
AASHTO LRFD12
§ Mu · (5.8.6.5)
¨  0.5 N u  Vu  V p  Aps f po ¸ (Eq. 5.8.3.4.2-4)
Hs ¨ dv ¸                               (1.25)
¨ Es As  E p Aps ¸
¨ ¸
© ¹

Where,
0 d H s d 0.006
f po 0.7 f pu
M u t Vu  V p d v
As and Ap are taken as area of nonprestressing and prestressing steel on the flexural tension side of the
member respectively.

dv : 0.8h or the distance from the extreme compression fiber to the centroid of the prestressing
reinforcement , whichever is greater (in.)

In midas Civil, the value of effective shear depth, dv, is calculated as shown in the equation
below.

dv max 0.8h, dt (1.26)


Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 16
Where,
h : Total height of a section
dt : Distance from extreme compression fiber to the centroid of the prestressing tendons

[Fig 1.19] Net longitudinal tensile strain

2.3 The nominal shear resistance, Vn


2.3.1 Vn (Non-Segmental Box Girder)
For non-segmental box girders, the nominal shear resistance, Vn, shall be determined as the
lesser of:

Vn Vc  Vs  V p (1.27) AASHTO LRFD12


(5.8.3.3)
(Eq. 5.8.3.3-1)
Vn 0.25 f c'bv d v  V p (1.28) (Eq. 5.8.3.3-2)

Where,
Vc : shear resistance component that relies on tensile stresses in the concrete
Vs : shear resistance component that relies on tensile stresses in the transverse reinforcement
Vp : shear resistance component in the direction of the applied shear of the effective prestressing force.
In midas Civil, shear resistance due to prestressing force, Vp, includes primary prestress force. The
secondary effects from prestressing shall be included in the design shear force obtained from the load
combinations.
bv: Effective web width taken as the minimum web width within the depth, dv (refer to the clause 1.2.2.1
Effective web width)
dv: Effective shear depth (Refer to the clause 1.2.2.2 Effective shear depth)

2.3.2 Vn (Segmental Box Girder)


For segmental box girders, the nominal shear resistance, Vn, shall be determined as the lesser
of:

Vn Vc  Vs  V p (1.29) AASHTO LRFD12


(5.8.6.5)
Vn 0.379 f c' bv d v  V p (1.30) (Eq. 5.8.6.5-1)
(Eq. 5.8.6.5-2)

Where,
Vc : shear resistance component that relies on tensile stresses in the concrete
Vs : shear resistance component that relies on tensile stresses in the transverse reinforcement
Vp : shear resistance component in the direction of the applied shear of the effective prestressing force.
In midas Civil, shear resistance due to prestressing force, Vp, includes primary prestress force. The
secondary effects from prestressing shall be included in the design shear force obtained from the
load combinations.

17 Design Guide for midas Civil


bv: Effective web width taken as the minimum web width within the depth, dv (refer to the clause
1.2.2.1 Effective web width)
dv: Effective shear depth (Refer to the clause 1.2.2.2 Effective shear depth)

2.4 The nominal shear resistance by concrete, Vc


AASHTO LRFD12
Design for shear may utilize any of the two methods (simplified and general procedure) for (5.8.3.4)
prestressed sections identified in AASHTO-LRFD12. In midas Civil, sections can be designed
as per the general procedure.

2.4.1 Vc (Non-Segmental Box Girder) AASHTO LRFD12


(5.8.3.3)
(Eq. 5.8.3.3-3)
Vc 0.0316 E f c ' bv d v (1.31)

Where,
bv: Effective web width taken as the minimum web width within the depth, dv (refer to the clause
1.2.2.1 Effective web width)
dv: Effective shear depth (Refer to the clause 1.2.2.2 Effective shear depth)
ȕFactor indicating ability of diagonally cracked concrete to transmit tension and shear as
specified in Article 5.8.3.4
AASHTO LRFD12
For the sections containing at least the minimum amount of transverse reinforcement : (5.8.3.4.2)

4.8
E
(1  750H s ) (1.32)

When sections do not contain at least the minimum amount of shear reinforcement:

4.8 51
E
(1  750H s ) (39  S xe )
1.38
S xe Sx 12.0 (in.) d S x d 80.0 (in.)
ag  0.63 (1.33)
,

Where,
Sx: The lesser of either dv or the maximum distance between layers of longitudinal
crack control reinforcement, where the area of the reinforcement in each layer is
not less than 0.003bvsx, as shown in Figure 5.8.3.4.2-3(in.) . In midas Civil, it is applied as dv.
ag : maximum aggregate size(in.)In midas Civil, it is applied as “1in.”.
İs: net longitudinal tensile strain in the section at the centroid of the tension reinforcement.Refer to the
clause 1.2.2.3 Net longitudinal tensile strain.

2.4.2 Vc (Segmental Box Girder)


AASHTO LRFD12
(5.8.3.4.2)
(Eq. 5.8.6.5-3)
Vc 0.0632 K f c ' bv d v (1.34)

Where,
bv: Effective web width taken as the minimum web width within the depth, dv (refer to the clause 1.2.2.1
Effective web width)
dv: Effective shear depth (Refer to the clause 1.2.2.2 Effective shear depth)
K: Stress variable K shall not be taken greater tham 1.0 for any section where the stress in the
extreme tension fiber, calculated on the basis of gross section properties, due to factored load
and effective prestress force after losses exceeds 0.19 ¥I¶c in tension


Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 18
f pc AASHTO LRFD12
K 1 (1.35) (5.8.6.3)
0.0632 f c ' (Eq. 5.8.6.3-3)

In midas Civil, the value of K is calculated as below.


1) Calculate the tensile stress of tendon, ft, after losses Tendon based on the
uncracked section.

2) If f t ! 0.19 f c ' , K = min(K, 1.0) AASHTO LRFD12


(5.8.6.3)
If f t d 0.19 f c ' , K = min(K, 2.0)

Where,
fpc : Unfactored compressive stress in concrete after prestress losses have occured either at the
centroid of the cross-section resisting transient loads or at the junction of the web and flange
where the centroid lies in the flange (ksi)
In midas Civil, fpc is calculated as follows.

When the centroid lies in the flange, verify the stress at a junction of the web and
flange.

f pc
¦A ps fe

¦A ps feep
y jo int 
Nu
(1.36)
Ag Ig Ag

Where, yjoint is a distance from the centroid to the junction of the web and flange

When the centroid lies in the web, verify the stress at the centroid of the cross-section.

f pc
¦A ps fe

Nu
(1.37)
Ag Ag

2.5 The nominal shear resistance by shear reinforcement, Vs


The nominal shear resistance by shear reinforcement, Vs, is calculated as follows:

2.5.1 Vs (Non-Segmental Box Girder)

Av f y d v (cot T  cot D ) sin D AASHTO LRFD12


Vs (1.38) (5.8.3.3.3)
s (Eq. 5.8.3.3-4)

Where,
dv:Refer to 1.2.2.2 Effective shear depth (for Non-Segmental Box Girders)
ș: angle of inclination of diagonal compressive stresses as determined in Article 5.8.3.4 (degrees)
; if the procedures of Article 5.8.3.4.3 are used, FRWșLVGHILQHGWKHUHLQ

19 Design Guide for midas Civil


[Fig.1.20] angle of inclination of transverse Compressive stress

The following equation is incorporated in midas Civil:

T 29  3500H s (1.39)
AASHTO LRFD12
(5.8.3.4.2)
(Eq. 5.8.3.4.2-3)

H s :Refer to 1.2.2.3 Net longitudinal tensile strain


Į: Angle of inclination of transverse reinforcement to longitudinal axis (degrees)

Enter the Angle of transverse reinforcement as shown in Fig1.22.

s: Spacing of transverse reinforcement


Enter the Pitch of transverse reinforcement as shown in Fig1.22.

೛Model>Properties>Section Manager>Reinforcements

Transverse
Reinforcement

[Fig.1.21] Transverse Reinforcement

The required input data for transverse reinforcement are as follows:


- Pitch: Enter the spacing of transverse reinforcement
- Angle: Enter the angle of inclination of transverse reinforcement
- Aw: Enter the total area of all transverse reinforcements in the web

2.5.2 Vs (Segmental Box Girder)


midas Civil applies the following equation where the angle of inclination ;ɲͿ of transverse
reinforcement is taken into account:

AASHTO LRFD12
(5.8.3.3.3)
((Eq. 5.8.6.5-4)


Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 20
Av f y d v (sin D  cot D )
Vs (1.40)
s

Where,
dv: refer to 1.1.2.2 Effective shear depth (for Segmental Box Girders)
Į: angle of inclination of transverse reinforcement to longitudinal axis (degrees)

Enter the Angle of transverse reinforcement as shown in Fig1.22.

2.6 Maximum spacing for transverse reinforcement (smax) AASHTO LRFD12


The maximum spacing of transverse reinforcement can be checked by the following steps: (5.8.2.7)

1) Calculate the shear stress (vu) acting on the concrete.

Vu  IV p AASHTO LRFD12
vu (1.41) (5.8.2.7)
I bv d v (Eq. 5.8.2.9-1)

Where,
ĭ = Use the shear strength reduction factor of 0.9.
bv: refer to 1.1.2.1 Effective web width
dv: refer to 1.1.2.2 Effective shear depth (for Non-Segmental Box Girders)

2) Calculate smax differently, depending on whether the section is Segmental Box Girder or
not and on the range of vu.
3) Compare the entered spacing of transverse reinforcement with smax.

2.6.1 smax (Non-Segmental Box Girder)

x If vu < 0.125f’c
AASHTO LRFD12
smax = 0.8dv чϮϰ͘ϬŝŶ͘      
(5.8.2.7)
x If vu ш0.125f’c
smax = 0.4dv ч 12.0 in.

Where,
dv: refer to 2.1.2.2 Effective shear depth (for Non-Segmental Box Girders)

2.6.2 smax (Segmental Box Girder)

x If vu < 0.19яf’c
AASHTO LRFD12
smax = 0.8dv ч36.0 in. (5.8.6.6)
x If vu ш0.19яf’c AASHTO LRFD12
smax = 0.4dv ч 18.0 in. (5.8.2.7)
Where,
dv: refer to 1.2.2.2 Effective shear depth (for Segmental Box Girders)

midas Civil calculates vu using Eq. 5.8.2.9-1 for the shear check and using Eq. 5.8.6.5-5
for the torsion check.

21 Design Guide for midas Civil


2.7 Minimum required transverse reinforcement (Av,min)
The minimum required transverse reinforcement can be checked according to the following
steps:
1) Calculate the minimum required reinforcement, Av,min , differently dependng on
whether the section is Segmental Box Girder or not.

ඵ For Non-Segmental Box Girders

bv s
Av ,min 0.0316 f c' (1.42) AASHTO LRFD12
(5.8.2.4)
fy
(Eq. 5.8.2.5-1) 

ඵ For Segmental Box Girders


b s
Av ,min 0.05 w (1.43) (Eq. 5.8.2.5-2)
fy

In midas Civil bw=bv.


2) Calculate the shear strength of the section, and then verify the transverse
reinforcement using the following equations:

ඵ For Vu фϬ͘ϱɌ;sc+Vp)
Skip the transverse reinforcement checks.

ඵ For Vu шϬ͘ϱɌ;sc+Vp)

Av ,req1
^V u  0.5I (Vc  V p )` s
I f y d v (sin D  cot D )
(1.44)
Av ,req 2 Av ,min
Av ,req min( Av ,req1 , Av ,req 2 )

If the area of transverse reinforcement (Av) is greater than or equal to Av,req , it says OK.
The area of transverse reinforcement (Av) is Aw which is entered from Fig.1.22.

2.8 Check shear resistance


midas Civil checks the shear strength limit state for the Vmax and Vmin cases among the Active:
Strength/Stress load combinations, which are defined in Fig.1.12 Load Combinations dialog.


Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 22
2.9 Check the shear resistance results
2.9.1 by Result Tables
The results can be checked as shown in the table below.
೛ Design>PSC Design>PSC Design Result Tables>Check Shear Strength…

[Fig.1.22] Result table for shear resistance



Elem : Element number
Part : Check location (I-End, J-End) of each element
Max./Min. : Maximum shear, minimum shear
LCom. Name : Load combination name.
Type : Displays the set of member forces corresponding to moving load case
or settlement load case for which the maximum stresses are produced.
CHK : Shear strength check for element
Vu : Maximum shear force among Strength/Stress load combinations
Mu : Bending moment for the LCom which has Vu
Vn : Nominal Shear resistance.
Phi : Resistance factor for shear
Vc : Shear resistance of concrete.
Vs : Shear resistance of shear reinforcement.
Vp : Shear force of the effective prestressing force.
PhiVn : Design Shear resistance.
de : Effective web width
dv : Effective depth for shear
ex : Longitudinal Strain
theta : Angle of inclination of transverse compressive stresses
beta : Factor indicating ability of transversely cracked concrete to transmit tension
and shear
Avs : Area of shear reinforcement
Ast : Area of longitudinal reinforcement
Al : Area of longitudinal torsional reinforcement
bv : Effective width
Avs_min : Minimum required transverse reinforcement
Avs_req : Required transverse reinforcement
Al_min : Minimum longitudinal torsional reinforcement
bv_min : Minimum effective web width

23 Design Guide for midas Civil


2.9.2 by Excel Report
The detailed results, which contain the calculations, are produced in the Excel Report.
೛ Design>PSC Design>PSC Design Calculation…

[Fig.1.23] Excel Report for shear resistance





Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 24
3. Torsion resistance
Check the combined shear and torsional resistance.

3.1 Dimension of section for torsion


The dimensions of section that are required for checking torsion are as follows:

Ao : Area enclosed by the shear flow path, including any area of holes therein (in2)
midas Civil uses the area of the closed section enclosed by the torsion reinforcement, instead of the
shear flow path.
Ph : Perimeter of the centerline of the closed transverse torsion reinforcement (in)
Acp : Total area enclosed by outside Perimeter of the concrete section (in2)
P : The length of the outside perimeter of concrete section (in)

[Fig.1.24] Dimension of section for torsion

3.2 Calculate torsional resistance


Torsional resistance can be checked according to the following steps:
1) Calculate the torsional cracking moment (Tcr) differently, depending on whether the
section is Segmental Box Girder or not.
2) Compare the factored torsional moment (Tu) with the limit, which differs depending on
the type of girder (segmental box girder or non-segmental box girder), in order to decide
whether the effect of torsion should be considered or not.
3) In case where the torsional effect should be considered, calculate the design torsional
strength and compare it with Tu.

3.2.1 Torsional cracking moment (Tcr)


ඵ For Non-Segmental Box Girders

Acp2 f pc AASHTO LRFD12


Tcr 0.125 f c' 1 (1.45) (5.8.2.1)
pc 0.125 f c' (Eq. 5.8.2.1-4)

Where,
fpc: compressive stress in concrete after prestress losses have occurred at either the centroid of
the cross-section resisting transient loads or at the junction of the web and flange where the centroid
lies in the flange (ksi)

midas Civil calculates fpc as follows:


If the centroid lies in the flange: calculate at the junction of the web and flange.

25 Design Guide for midas Civil


f pc
¦A ps fe

¦A ps feep
y jo int (1.46)
Ag Ig

Where, yjoint is the distance from the centroid to the junction of the web and flange.

If the centroid lies in the web: calculate at the centroid of the corss-section.

f pc
¦A ps fe
(1.47)
Ag

Acp2
pc
shall be less than or equal to 2Aobv for a box section.

ඵ For Segmental Box Girders

Tcr 0.0632 K f c' Aobe (1.48) AASHTO LRFD12


(5.8.6.3)
(Eq. 5.8.6.3-2)
Where,

K : Refer to the value of K specified in 2.1.4.2.

be : effective width of shear flow path, but not exceeding the minimum thickness of the webs
or flanges comprising the closed box section (in.). be shall be adjusted to account for
presence of ducts as specified in Article 5.8.6.1. midas Civil uses bv.

3.2.2 Condition for torsion check


ඵ For Non-Segmental Box Girders

AASHTO LRFD12
Tu ! 0.25ITcr (1.49) (5.8.2.1)
(Eq. 5.8.2.1-3)

ඵ For Segmental Box Girders

Tu ! 1/ 3ITcr (1.50) AASHTO LRFD12


(5.8.6.3)
(Eq. 5.8.6.3-1)
Where,
ĭ = resistance factor for torsion(=0.9)

3.2.3 Torsional resistance AASHTO LRFD12


In accordance with AASHTO-LRFD12, the torsional resistance should meet the condition (5.5.4.2.1)
TuчɌdn for the cases of segmental box girders and non-segmental box girders.

ඵ For Non-Segmental Box Girders

2 Ao At f y cot T AASHTO LRFD12


Tn (1.51) (5.8.3.6.2)
s (Eq. 5.8.3.6.2-1)

Where,
At: area of one leg of closed transverse torsion reinforcement in solid menbers, or total area of
transverse torsion reinforcement in the exterior web of cellular members (in.2). Awt of Torsional
Reinforcement entered in Fig.1. 26 will be used.

Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 26
s :Pitch of Torsional Reinforcement entered in Fig.1. 26 will be used.
Ĭ: angle of crack as determined in accordance with provisions of Article 5.8.3.4 with the
modifications to the expressions for v and Vu herein (degrees). The same equation, which was used for
the shear check, will be used:

T 29  3500H s (1.52) AASHTO LRFD12


(5.8.3.4.2)
(Eq. 5.8.3.4.2-3)
H s : Refer to 1.2.2.3 Net longitudinal tensile strain.

ඵ For Segmental Box Girders


2 Ao At f y AASHTO LRFD12
Tn (1.53) (5.8.6.4)
s (Eq. 5.8.6.4-2)

Where,
At : Awt of Torsional Reinforcement entered in Fig.1. 26 will be used.
s : Pitch of Torsional Reinforcement entered in Fig.1. 26 will be used.

The reinforcement data used for the torsion check are as follows:

೛ Model>Properties>Section Manager>Reinforcements

Torsional
Reinforcement

[Fig.1.25] Transverse Reinforcement

- Pitch : spacing of transverse torsional reinforcement


- Awt : area of transverse torsional reinforcement
(the area of a single stirrup among the outer closed stirrups)
- Alt : area of longitudinal torsional reinforcement
(the area of all reinforcing steels which are close against the outer closed stirrups)

3.3 Check longitudinal reinforcement


Check the longitudinal reinforcement to resist torsion. Check it for box sections and for
solid sections, respectively.

ඵ For Solid sections


Aps is the area of tensile tendon and As is the area of tensile reinforcement.

27 Design Guide for midas Civil


2 2
Mu 0.5 N u §V · § 0.45 phTu · AASHTO LRFD12
Aps f ps  As f y t   cot T ¨ u  V p  0.5Vs ¸  ¨ ¸ (5.8.3.6.3)
I dv I © I ¹ © 2 AoI ¹ (Eq. 5.8.3.6.3-1)

(1.54)

Where,
dv: refer to 2.1.2.2 Effective shear depth (for Non-Segmental Box Girders)

ඵ For Box sections


The Code suggests that the reinforcement for resisting torsion is limited to the
following equation for box sections:

AASHTO LRFD12
Tn ph (5.8.3.6.3)
Al (1.55)
2 Ao f y (Eq. 5.8.3.6.3-2)

midas Civil incorporates the above equation to check the longitudinal torsional
reinforcement. The Alt of Torsional Reinforcement entered in Fig.1. 26 will be used. Alt is
only for resisting warping torsion and is used only for box sections.

(Tu / I ) ph
Alt t (1.56) AASHTO LRFD12
2 Ao f y (5.8.6.4)
(Eq. 5.8.6.4-3)

3.4 Check combined torsional and shear stress


For Segmental Box Girders, check the combined shear and torsional stress.
AASHTO LRFD12
(5.8.6.5)
§ Vu · § Tu · (Eq. 5.8.6.5-5)
¸¨ ¸ d 0.474 f c
'
¨ (1.57)
© bv d v ¹ © 2 Aobe ¹

Where,
bv: refer to 1.1.2.1 Effective web width
dv: refer to 1.1.2.2 Effective shear depth (for Segmental Box Girders)
be : effective thickness of the shear flow path of the elements making up the space truss model
resisting torsion calculated in accordance with Article 5.8.6.3 (in). midas Civil uses bv.

midas Civil calculates the maximum combined stress using the equation below.

Vu Tu
 d 0.474 f c' (1.58)
bv d v 2 Ao be

3.5 Check torsional moment resistance


midas Civil checks the combined shear and torsional strength limit state for the Vmax, Vmin and
Tmax cases among the Active: Strength/Stress load combinations, which are defined in Fig.1.12
Load Combinations dialog.


Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 28
3.6 Check the torsional resistance results
3.6.1 by Result Tables
The results can be checked as shown in the table below.
೛ Design>PSC Design>PSC Design Result Tables>Check Combined Shear and Torsion
Strength…

[Fig.1.26] Result table for torsional resistance

Elem : Element number


Part : Check location (I-End, J-End) of each element
Max./Min.: Maximum torsion/shear, minimum torsion/shear
LCom Name: Load combination name.
Type: Displays the set of member forces corresponding to moving load case or settlement load case for
which the maximum stresses are produced.
CHK: Shear and torsion strength check for element
Vu : shear force for the corresponding LCom
Mu : bending moment for the corresponding LCom
Tu : torsional moment for the corresponding LCom
Vn : Nominal Shear resistance.
Tn : Nominal Torsional resistance.
Phi : strength reduction factor for shear
Phi_t : strength reduction factor for torsion
Vc : Shear resistance of concrete.
Vs : Shear resistance of shear reinforcement.
Vp : Shear force of the effective prestressing force.
PhiVn : Design Shear resistance.
Phi_tTn : Design Torsional resistance.
de : Effective web width
dv : Effective depth for shear
ex : Longitudinal Strain
theta : Angle of inclination of transverse compressive stresses
beta : Factor indicating ability of transversely cracked concrete to transmit tension and shear
Avs : Area of shear reinforcement
Ast : Area of longitudinal reinforcement
Al : Area of longitudinal torsional reinforcement
bv : Effective width
Avs_min : Minimum required transverse reinforcement
Avs_req : Required transverse reinforcement
Al_min : Minimum longitudinal torsional reinforcement
bv_min : Minimum effective web width
At : Area of transverse torsional reinforcement
At_req : Required transverse torsional reinforcement

29 Design Guide for midas Civil


3.6.2 by Excel Report
Detail verification results can be checked in MS Excel report as shown in the figure below.
೛ Design>PSC Design>PSC Design Calculation…

[Fig.1.27] Excel report for torsional resistance


Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 30
Chapter 1. Prestressed Box Girder Design: AASHTO-LRFD 6th (2012)

Serviceabiltiy Limit States



1. Stress for cross section at a construction stage
The allowable stress at a construction stage differs depending on the generated stress
because the precompressed tensile zone is defined differently depending on the generated
stress. Therefore, the generated stress at every stage and step is compared to the
corresponding allowable stress, and the most unfavorable ratio of the generated stress to
the allowable stress is searched and checked against the criteria.
That is to say, calculate the ratio of generated stress to allowable stress for every stage and
see if the highest ratio meets the criteria.

1.1 Allowable stress of concrete


(1) Allowable compressive stress of concrete AASHTO LRFD12
(5.9.4.1.1)
σca = 0.60 f’ci (1.59)

Where, the definition of f’ci is stated in 2.1.2.

(2) Allowable tensile stress of concrete

AASHTO LRFD12
(5.9.4.1.2)

[Fig.1.28] Allowable tensile stress of concrete


Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 31
Midas Civil calculates the allowable tensile stress of concrete using Table 5.9.4.1.2-1, as
stated in the table below:

[Table 1.3] Allowable tensile stress of concrete


ʹΠΟΤΥΣΦΔΥΚΠΟ  Case  Allowable stress(ksi) 
΅ΪΡΖ 
Without bonded reinforcement and bonded tendon  
Əta = 0.0
Precompressed    If reinforcement stress ؄min(0.5fy, 30ksi) Ə= 0.24*SQRT(f')
Tensile Zone ta ci
With bonded reinforcement or bonded
   
Non-Segment
tendon 
  If reinforcement stress > min(0.5fy, 30ksi) Ə = 0.0
ta

Other Than
Without bonded reinforcement and bonded tendon    Ə= 0.0948f'؄0.2
ta ci

Precompressed    If reinforcement stress ؄min(0.5fy, 30ksi)  )


Ə= 0.24*SQRT(f'
ta ci
Tensile Zone With bonded reinforcement or bonded
  > min(0.5fy, 30ksi)
 stress 
tendon  Ə = 0.0
   If reinforcement ta
 Reinforcement stress؄ 0.5fyƏ= 0.0948*SQRT(f')
Precompressed tensile Zone
With bonded ta ci

Joint  
reinforcement or bonded > 0.5fyƏ= 0.0
tendon 
Reinforcement stress ta

v›Œ™GŠˆšŒš
  Ə = 0.0
Segment
ta

If reinforcement stress؄min(0.5fy, 30ksi) Ə= 0.19*SQRT(f')


ta ci

Non Joint
With bonded reinforcement or bonded
tendon
  > min(0.5fy, 30ksi)
 stress  Ə= 0.0
   If reinforcement ta

v›Œ™GŠˆšŒš   Ə = 0.0
ta

Description on each item is as follows: AASHTO LRFD12


(5.2)
Precompressed Tensile Zone: According to the Code, Precompressed Tensile Zone is defined
as Any region of a prestressed component in which prestressing causes compressive stresses
and service load effects cause tensile stresses.
midas Civil calculates the concrete stress in cross-section using the following methods
and defines the Precompressed Tensile zone at Before Loss (construction stage).
If it is compressive stress for TendonPrimary(CS)+Tendon Secondary(CS), and
if it is tensile stress for Summation(CS)-(Tendon primary+Tendon secondary).

Joint/non-Joint: In midas Civil, joints can be defined in the dialog below: AASHTO LRFD12
(5.5.4.2.1)
೛PSC> PSC Segment Assignment

[Fig.1.29] PSC Segment Assignment

As shown in Fig.2.2, if elements 1, 2 and 3 are assigned as one segment, i-end of element 1 AASHTO LRFD12
and j-end of element 3 become the joints and the rest become the non-joints. (C 5.9.1.4)

Bonded reinforcement
It is assumed that the tensile reinforcement or the tendon defined as Bond Type in Fig.1. 7
are bonded reinforcement.
Based on the aforementioned, if tensile reinforcement or bonded tendon is present in the
tension zone, it is assumed that bonded reinforcement exists.


Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 32
Check the stress in reinforcement
The Code states that the bonded reinforcement, which retains a specific stress value (0.5fy
or 30ksi), shall resist the tensile force on the tension zone. midas Civil applies the above
regulation as follows:
Compute the concrete triangular stress block on the tension zone, using the extreme fiber
tension stress and the extreme fiber compression stress of concrete.
Compute the tension force of concrete by multiplying the compression stress by the area
of the concrete triangular stress block.
Compute the tension force of reinforcement by multiplying the area of reinforcement and
tendon, which are included in the triangular stress block, by the specific stress (0.5fy or
30ksi).
If the tension force of reinforcement is larger than that of concrete, it is concluded that the
tensile stress of reinforcement satisfies the regulation.

[Fig.1.30] Check the tension force of reinforcement

1.2 Compressive strength of concrete at time of loading, f’ci


The Code defines f’ci as:
f’ci is specified compressive strength of concrete at time of initial loading or AASHTO LRFD12
precompressing; nominal concrete strength at time of application of tendon (5.3)
midas Civil computes the compressive strength of concrete (f’ci) during the construction
stages according to the construction days defined in Fig.2.4 and the function of
concrete strength defined in Fig.2.5.
The days for each construction stage can be defined in Fig2.4.

೛Load> Construction Stage> Compose construction Stage…

Stage Additional
Steps

Activation

[Fig.1.31] Compose construction Stage dialog



Stage>Duration:
Enter the duration of the construction stage.
It is the basic unit where elements become active or inactive, boundary conditions become
active or inactive and loads are applied or removed.

33 Design Guide for midas Civil


Additional Step>age:
Define the specific days for the analysis steps within the construction stage.
Within a construction stage where the model and boundary conditions remain unchanged,
changes in load application timing or additional loads may be incorporated through
additional steps.

Activation>Group List>age:
Select relevant element groups, which are applicable to the current stage, in the Group List
and activate the selected groups by moving them to Activation Group List. Specify the Age of
the selected element groups.
The age entered here will be used to reflect the effects of creep and shrinkage that took
place prior to the current construction stage. The age of the element, which is casted at the
start of the current construction stage, is zero. The age typically represents the time span
from the time of concrete casting to the time of removal of formwork during which the
concrete is considered as a structural element, that is to say the curing period of concrete.

Based on the inputs shown in Fig.2.4, midas Civil takes the following days for the
construction stage analysis:
The duration of the construction stage CS1 is 30 days, the duration of the additional step
within CS1 is 15 days, and the Activation age is 5 days.
The actual duration of CS1 is 35 days (Stage Duration + Activation age).
The compressive strength of concrete is computed at 5 days, 20 days and 35 days for CS1.
If the next stage CS2 is defined with the duration of 20 days, CS2 starts at 35 days and ends AASHTO LRFD12
at 55 days. (5.7.2.2)
The development of concrete compressive strength with days is defined in the dialog
below.

೛ Properties> Time Dependent Materials>Comp. Strength…

[Fig.1.32] Time Dependent Materials dialog

Development of Strength:
Define the function to compute the compressive strength of concrete during the
construction stages. Define a function by selecting ACI, CEB-FIP or Structural Concrete
Design Code, or directly define the values.
The compressive strength of concrete is computed by reflecting the variation of the modulus
of elasticity with concrete ages.
For CS1 the compressive strengths of concrete are computed at 5 days, 20 days and 35 days,
and they are compared to the corresponding stresses.

1.3 Check stress for cross section at a construction stage

V c d V ca
, V t d V ta (1.60)

Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 34
1.4 Check the stress results for cross section at a construction stage
1.4.1 by Result Tables
The results can be checked as shown in the table below.
೛ Design>PSC Design >PSC Design Result Tables>Check stress for cross section
at a construction stage…

[Fig.1.33] Result table for stress at a construction stage

Elem : Element number


Part : Check location (I-End, J-End) of each element
Comp./Tens.: Compression or Tension Stress
Stage : Construction stage at which stresses are maximum at the corresponding section.
CHK : Combined stress check for construction stages
FT : Combined Stress due to My and axial force at Top fiber
FB : Combined Stress due to My and axial force at Bottom fiber
FTL : Combined Stress due to My, Mz and axial force at Top Left fiber
FBL : Combined Stress due to My, Mz and axial force at Bottom Left fiber
FTR : Combined Stress due to My, Mz and axial force at Top Right fiber
FBR : Combined Stress due to My, Mz and axial force at Bottom Right fiber
FMAX : Maximum combined stress out of the above six components.
ALW : Allowable stress of cross section at construction stage.

1.4.2 by Excel Report


Verification results can be checked in MS Excel report as shown in the figure below.
೛ Design>PSC Design >PSC Design Calculation…

[Fig.1.34] Result table for stress at a construction stage

35 Design Guide for midas Civil


2. Stress for cross section at service loads
The element stress at service loads after losses should meet the following conditions:
The maximum compressive stress at service loads after losses ≤ allowable compressive
stress of concrete: σc ≤ σca
The maximum tensile stress at service loads after losses ≤ allowable tensile stress of
concrete: σt ≤ σta

The Code suggests that the stresses in PSC structures after losses shall be checked for the AASHTO LRFD12
(5.9.4.2.1)
followings:
(5.9.4.2.2)
Check compressive stress: for the load combinations of Service Limit state 1
Check tensile stress: for the load combinations of Service Limit state 3

[Fig.1.35] Load Combination for Service Limit state

In midas Civil, the Load Cases to check compressive stress and tensile stress after losses can
be selected via the dialog box shown in Fig.2.9.
The Load Cases in Service Limit1 will be used to check compressive stress, and the Load
Cases in Service Limit3 will be used to check tensile stress.

[Fig.1.36] Concrete Allowable Stress Load Case dialog


Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 36
2.1 Allowable stress of concrete
(1) Allowable compressive stress of concrete AASHTO LRFD12
(5.9.4.2.1)

[Fig.1.37] Allowable compressive stress of concrete

The following formula is incorporated in midas Civil:

σca = 0.45 f’c (1.61)

(2) Allowable tensile stress of concrete


AASHTO LRFD12
(5.9.4.2.2)

[Fig.1.38] Allowable tensile stress of concrete

midas Civil calculates the allowable tensile stress of concrete using Fig.2.11, as stated in the
table below:







37 Design Guide for midas Civil


[Table1.4] Allowable tensile stress of concrete
ʹΠΟΤΥΣΦΔΥΚΠΟ  Case  Allowable stress(ksi) 
΅ΪΡΖ 
With bonded reinforcement or bonded 
corrosion condition - not Worse Ə = 0.19*sqrt(fck)
ta
Precompressed   
tendon
corrosion condition -severe Ə = 0.0948*sqrt(fck)
Non-Segment  Tensile Zone  
ta

Without bonded reinforcement and bonded tendon Ə = 0.0


ta
  Zone
Other Than Precompressed Tensile  Ə = 0.0
ta

(Precompressed Tensile Zone) and  0.5fy,


If reinforcement stress؄ Ə = 0.0948*SQRT(f'c)
ta

Joint (With bonded reinforcement or bonded )If reinforcement  > 0.5fy,


 stress Ə = 0.0
tendon ta
 
v›Œ™GŠˆšŒš
  Ə = 0.0
Segment  ta

With bonded reinforcement or bonded If reinforcement stress؄ min(0.5fy, 30ksi) , Ə = 0.19*SQRT(f'c)


ta
tendon   > min(0.5fy, 30ksi)
 stress
Non Joint   If reinforcement Ə = 0.0
ta
v›Œ™GŠˆšŒš   Ə = 0.0
ta

Description on each item is as follows:


Precompressed Tensile Zone
According to the Code, Precompressed Tensile Zone is defined as
AASHTO LRFD12
Any region of a prestressed component in which prestressing causes compressive stresses (5.2)
and service load effects cause tensile stresses.
midas Civil calculates the concrete stress in cross-section using the following methods
and defines the Precompressed Tensile zone at After Loss (construction stage).
-If it is compressive stress for TendonPrimary(CS)+Tendon Secondary(CS), and
-if it is tensile stress for Service Limit State load combination(SLS)-(Tendon
primary+Tendon secondary).

Corrosion Condition
The data for Corrosion Condition can be entered in the dialog box below:

೛ PSC> Design Parameter> Parameters…

[Fig.1.39] PSC Design parameter Dialog -corrosion condition


The input parameters and the corresponding terms defined in the Code are listed in the
table below:


Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 38
[Table1.5] corrosion condition
Input parameter Term of the Code
Severe Severe
Moderate/Mild Not worse

Joint/non-Joint : refer to 2.1.1


Bonded reinforcement : refer to 2.1.1
Check the stress in reinforcement : refer to 2.1.1

2.2 Check stress for cross section at service loads

V c d V ca
, V t d V ta (1.62)

2.3 Check the stress results for cross section at service loads
2.3.1 by Result Tables
The results can be checked as shown in the table below.
೛Design>PSC Design>PSC Design Result Tables>Check stress for cross section at service
loads…

[Fig.1.40] Result table for stress at service loads

Elem: Element number


Part: Check location (I-End, J-End) of each element
Comp./Tens.: Compression or Tension Stress
LCom Name: Load Combination Name
Type: Displays the set of member forces corresponding to moving load case or settlement load case for
which the maximum stresses are produced
CHK: Combined stress check for Service loads
FT: Combined Stress due to My and axial force at Top fiber
FB: Combined Stress due to My and axial force at Bottom fiber
FTL: Combined Stress due to My, Mz and axial force at Top Left fiber
FBL: Combined Stress due to My, Mz and axial force at Bottom Left fiber
FTR: Combined Stress due to My, Mz and axial force at Top Right fiber
FBR: Combined Stress due to My, Mz and axial force at Bottom Right fiber
FMAX: Maximum combined stress out of the above six components.
ALW: Allowable stress in concrete at service limit state.

2.3.2 by Excel Report


Verification results can be checked in MS Excel report as shown in the figure below.
೛Design>PSC Design>PSC Design Calculation…

[Fig.1.41] Excel report for stress at service loads

39 Design Guide for midas Civil


3. Tensile stress for Prestressing tendons
Compare the stress in tendon with the allowable stress for each tendon group.
After immediate losses at anchorages, the maximum stress in tendon ≤ allowable stress.
Elsewhere away from anchorages, the maximum stress in tendon ≤ allowable stress.
After all losses, the maximum stress in tendon ≤ allowable stress.

3.1 Allowable stress of tendon


The Code presents the following stress limits for tendons depending on the tendon types:

AASHTO LRFD12
(5.9.3)

[Fig.1.42] Stress Limit for Prestressing Tendons

Tendon Type can be specified from the Design parameters dialog.


೛ PSC> Design Parameter> Parameters…

[Fig.1.43] PSC Design parameter Dialog – Tendon Type


The input parameters of the dialog and the corresponding terms defined in the Code
are listed in the table below:


Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 40
[Table1.6] Tendon Type
Input parameter Term of the Code
Low Relaxation Tendons Low Relaxation Strand
Stress Relieved Tendons Stress Relieved Strands
d Pl Hi h t th B
Prestressing Bar Deformed Hige-strength Bar

Pre/Post tensioning can be specified as showin in Fig.1. 8 Tendon Property Dialogue.


Midas Civil applies the stress limits for tendons differently, depending on the Tendon Type
and whether it is Pre/Post tensioning.
Allowable stress in tendon immediately after anchor set at anchorages(AFDL1)
The maximum allowable stress in tendon at anchorages after immediate losses. The values
for “At anchorages and couplers immediately after anchor set” of Table 5.9.3-1 are set as
the limits.

Allowable Stress in Tendon immediately after anchor set elsewhere(AFDL2)


The maximum allowable stress in tendon elsewhere along length of member away from
anchorages. The values for “Elsewhere along length of member away from anchorages…” of
Table 5.9.3-1 are set as the limits. This is not applicable to Pretension.

Allowable stress in tendon at service limit state after losses(AFLL1)


The maximum allowable stress in tendon at service limit state after all losses. The values for
“At service limit stage after losses” of Table 5.9.3-1 are set as the limits.

3.2 Check the stress in Prestressing tendons


3.2.1 by Result Tables
The stress results of tendon can be checked as shown in the table below.

೛Design>PSC Design>PSC Design Result Tables>Check tensile stress for Prestressing


tendons …

[Fig.1.44] Result table for tensile stress for prestressing tendon


Tendon: Tendon profile name.
For Post-tensioned:
FDL1: Stress in tendon at anchorages.
The maximum stress in tendon at anchorages after immediate losses
FDL2: Maximum stress in tendon along the length of the member away from anchorages,
immediately after anchor set.
The maximum stress in tendon elsewhere along length of member away from anchorages
immediately after anchor set
FLL1: Maximum stress in tendon after all losses at the last stage.
The maximum stress in tendon at service limit state after all losses
AFDL1: Allowable stress in tendon immediately after anchor set at
anchorages. The allowable stress for FDL1
AFDL2: Allowable stress in tendon immediately after anchor set elsewhere.
The allowable stress for FDL2
AFLL1: Allowable stress in tendon at service limit state after losses.
The allowable stress for FLL1
For Pre-tensioned:
FDL1: Stress in tendon.
FDL2: -
FLL1: Maximum stress in tendon after all losses at the last stage.
AFDL1: Allowable stress in tendon prior to transfer.
AFDL2: -
AFLL1: Allowable stress in tendon at service limit state after losses.

41 Design Guide for midas Civil


3.2.2 Tendon Time-dependent Loss Graph
The stress in each tendon for each construction stage can be checked from the dialog below:
೛ Result > Bridge> Tendon Loss Graph…

[Fig.1.45] Tendon Time-dependent Loss Graph

In the graph above the stress at the beginning represents the stress in tendon at anchorage
after immediate losses (FDL1), and the largest stress in the graph represents the maximum
stress in tendon elsewhere along length of member away from anchorages immediately
after anchor set (FDL2).

3.2.3 by Excel Report


Verification results can be checked in MS Excel report as shown in the figure below.
೛Design>PSC Design>PSC Design Calculation…

[Fig.1.46] Excel Report for tensile stress for prestressing tendons


Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 42
4. Principal stress at a construction stage
Find the maximum principal tensile stress among the stress check points 1~10 of the cross-
section at a construction stage and compare it to the allowable stress. In other words,
maximum principal tensile stress ≤ allowable stress.

4.1 Allowable tensile stress AASHTO LRFD12


(5.9.4.1.2)
The Code presents the following equation of allowable tensile stress for Segmentally
Constructed Bridges:

V ta 0.110 fci' (1.63)

Where, f’ci is identical to that of 2.1.2.

midas Civil applies the above equation for both Segment and Non-segment.

4.2 Maximum principal stress


The maximum principal tensile stress for each point at a constructions stage is computed as
follows:

V ps

V x  V z r V x  V z 2  4 W s  W t  W p 2 º» (1.64)
2 «¬ ¼

where,
σx : Sum of axial stresses in ECS x-direction
σz : Sum of axial stresses in ECS z-direction
τs : Shear stress due to shear.
τt : Shear stress due to torsion.
τp : Shear stress due to shear reinforcement.

4.2.1 Beam stresses of PSC


The stress components to compute the maximum principal tensile stress can be checked
from the Result Table below:

೛ Results>Result Tables>Beam>Stress(PSC)…

[Fig.1.47] Beam stresses of PSC


Sig-xx (Axial): Axial stress due to the axial force (Fx) in the ECS x-direction
Sig-xx (Moment-y): Stress due to My (moment about the ECS y-axis) in ECS x-direction
Sig-xx (Moment-z): Stress due to Mz (moment about the ECS z-axis) in ECS x-direction
Sig-xx (Bar): Axial stress due to shear steel bars in the ECS x-direction
Sig-xx (Summation): Sum of the axial stress in the ECS x-direction and the axial stress
due to shear steel bars in the ECS x-direction
Sig-zz: Stress in the ECS z-direction

43 Design Guide for midas Civil


Sig-xz (shear): Sum of shear stresses due to shear force and shear steel bars
Sig-xz (torsion): Shear stress due to torsion
Sig-xz (bar): Shear stress due to shear steel bars
Sig-Is (shear): Transverse stress due to shear force
Sig-Is (shear+torsion): Transverse stress due to torsion and shear force
Sig-Ps1: Maximum principal stress
Sig-Ps2: Minimum principal stress

4.3 Check principal stress at a construction stage

V ps d V ta
(1.65)

4.4 Check the principal stress results at a construction stage


4.4.1 by Result Tables
The results can be checked as shown in the table below.

೛ Design>PSC Design>PSC Design Result Tables>Principal stress at a construction stage …

[Fig.1.48] Result table for principal stress at a construction stage

Elem: Element number.


Part: Check location (I-End, J-End) of each element.
Comp./Tens.: Compression or Tension Stress.
Stage: Construction stage.
CHK: Principal stress check for construction stages.
Sig_P1: Principal Stress at the left top of top flange.
Sig_P2: Principal Stress at the right top of top flange.
Sig_P3: Principal Stress at the right bottom of bottom flange.
Sig_P4: Principal Stress at the left bottom of bottom flange.
Sig_P5: Principal Stress at the top of left web.(at Z1 Level)
Sig_P6: Principal Stress at the top of right web.(at Z1 Level)
Sig_P7: Principal Stress at the neutral axis in left web.(at Z2 Level)
Sig_P8: Principal Stress at the neutral axis in right web.(at Z2 Level)
Sig_P9: Principal Stress at the bottom of left web.(at Z3 Level)
Sig_P10: Principal Stress at the bottom of right web.(at Z3 Level)
Sig_MAX: The maximum Principal stress among P1-P10.
Sig_AP: Allowable principal stress at neutral axis in the web.

4.2.2 by Excel Report


Verification results can be checked in MS Excel report as shown in the figure below.
೛ Design>PSC Design>PSC Design Calculation…

[Fig.1.49] Excel Report for principal stress at a construction stage


Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 44
5. Principal stress at service loads (Excluding torsional shear
stress)
Find the maximum principal tensile stress among the stress check points 1~10 of the cross-
section at service loads and compare it to the allowable stress. In other words, maximum
principal tensile stress ≤ allowable stress. Here the shear effect due to torsion is excluded.
2.5.1 Allowable tensile stress
The Code (Table .9.4.2.2-1) presents the following equation of allowable tensile stress
for Segmentally Constructed Bridges:

V ta 0.110 fc' (1.66) AASHTO LRFD12


(5.9.4.2.2)

midas Civil applies the above equation for both Segment and Non-segment.

2.5.2 Maximum principal stress


The maximum principal tensile stress for each point at a construction stage is computed as
follows:

V ps

V x  V z r V x  V z 2  4 W s  W t  W p 2 º» (1.67)
2 «¬ ¼
where,
σx : Sum of axial stresses in ECS x-direction
σz : Sum of axial stresses in ECS z-direction
τs : Shear stress due to shear.
τt : Shear stress due to torsion.
τp : Shear stress due to shear reinforcement.

5.2.1 Beam stresses of PSC


The stress components to compute the maximum principal tensile stress can be checked
from the Result Table below:
Refer to 3.4.2.1 Beam stresses of PSC.

5.3 Check principal stress at service loads

V ps d V ta
(1.68)

5.4 Check the principal stress results at service loads


5.4.1 by Result Tables
The results can be checked as shown in the table below.

೛ Design>PSC Design>PSC Design Result Tables > Result table for principal stress at service
loads(excluding torsional shear stress)…

[Fig.1.50] Result table for principal stress at service loads (excluding torsional shear stress)

Elem: Element number.


Part: Check location (I-End, J-End) of each element.

45 Design Guide for midas Civil


Comp./Tens.: Compression or Tension Stress.
Stage: Construction stage.
CHK: Principal stress check for construction stages.
Sig_P1: Principal Stress at the left top of top flange.
Sig_P2: Principal Stress at the right top of top flange.
Sig_P3: Principal Stress at the right bottom of bottom flange.
Sig_P4: Principal Stress at the left bottom of bottom flange.
Sig_P5: Principal Stress at the top of left web.(at Z1 Level)
Sig_P6: Principal Stress at the top of right web.(at Z1 Level)
Sig_P7: Principal Stress at the neutral axis in left web.(at Z2 Level)
Sig_P8: Principal Stress at the neutral axis in right web.(at Z2 Level)
Sig_P9: Principal Stress at the bottom of left web.(at Z3 Level)
Sig_P10: Principal Stress at the bottom of right web.(at Z3 Level)
Sig_MAX: The maximum Principal stress among P1-P10.
Sig_AP: Allowable principal stress at neutral axis in the web.

5.4.2 by Excel Report


Verification results can be checked in MS Excel report as shown in the figure below.

೛ Design>PSC Design>PSC Design Calculation…

[Fig.1.51] Excel report for principal stress at service loads (excluding torsional shear stress)


Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 46
6. Principal stress at service loads
Find the maximum principal tensile stress among the stress check points 1~10 of the cross-
section at service loads and compare it to the allowable stress. Here both shear and torsion
will be reflected in the stress calculation. In other words, maximum principal tensile stress ≤
allowable stress.

6.1 Allowable tensile stress


The Code (Table .9.4.2.2-1) presents the following equation of allowable tensile stress
for Segmentally Constructed Bridges:
AASHTO LRFD12
(5.9.4.2.2)

V ta 0.110 fc' (1.69)

midas Civil applies the above equation for both Segment and Non-segment.

6.2 Maximum principal stress


The maximum principal tensile stress for each point at a construction stage is computed as
follows:

V ps

V x  V z r V x  V z 2  4 W s  W t  W p 2 º»
2 «¬ ¼ (1.70)

where,
σx : Sum of axial stresses in ECS x-direction
σz : Sum of axial stresses in ECS z-direction
τs : Shear stress due to shear.
τt : Shear stress due to torsion.
τp : Shear stress due to shear reinforcement.

6.2.1 Beam stresses of PSC


The stress components to compute the maximum principal tensile stress can be checked
from the Result Table below:
Refer to 3.4.2.1 Beam stresses of PSC.

6.3 Check principal stress at service loads

V ps d V ta
(1.71)

6.4 Check the principal stress results at service loads


6.4.1 by Result Tables
The results can be checked as shown in the table below.

೛ Design>PSC Design>PSC Design Result Tables>Principal stress at service loads…

[Fig.1.52] Result table for principal stress at service loads

Elem: Element number.

47 Design Guide for midas Civil


Part: Check location (I-End, J-End) of each element.
Comp./Tens.: Compression or Tension Stress.
Stage: Construction stage.
CHK: Principal stress check for construction stages.
Sig_P1: Principal Stress at the left top of top flange.
Sig_P2: Principal Stress at the right top of top flange.
Sig_P3: Principal Stress at the right bottom of bottom flange.
Sig_P4: Principal Stress at the left bottom of bottom flange.
Sig_P5: Principal Stress at the top of left web.(at Z1 Level)
Sig_P6: Principal Stress at the top of right web.(at Z1 Level)
Sig_P7: Principal Stress at the neutral axis in left web.(at Z2 Level)
Sig_P8: Principal Stress at the neutral axis in right web.(at Z2 Level)
Sig_P9: Principal Stress at the bottom of left web.(at Z3 Level)
Sig_P10: Principal Stress at the bottom of right web.(at Z3 Level)
Sig_MAX: The maximum Principal stress among P1-P10.
Sig_AP: Allowable principal stress at neutral axis in the web.

6.4.2 by Excel Report


Verification results can be checked in MS Excel report as shown in the figure below.

೛ Design>PSC Design>PSC Design Calculation…

[Fig.1.53] Excel report for principal stress at service loads


Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 48
7. Check crack
The limit state for crack can be checked by comparing the applied spacing of tensile
reinforcement with the maximum spacing of reinforcement.
In accordance with AASHTO-LRFD, the crack limit shall be checked for the “mild steel
reinforcement”. The applied spacing of tensile reinforcement shall be compared to the
computed maximum spacing of reinforcement.
In other words, applied spacing of reinforcement ≤ maximum spacing of reinforcement

7.1 Maximum spacing of reinforcement


The maximum spacing of reinforcement is computed as follows:
AASHTO LRFD12
(5.7.3.4)
700J e (Eq. 5.7.3.4-1)
smax  2d c (1.72)
E s f ss

dc
Es 1  (1.73)
0.7(h  dc )

dc: thickness of concrete cover measured from extreme tension fiber to center of the flexural
reinforcement located closest thereto (in.)
fss: tensile stress in steel reinforcement at service limit state (ksi)
fss is computed according to the following steps:
1) Compute the concrete stress (fcs) at the location of tensile reinforcement using
the extreme fiber tension stress and the extreme fiber compression stress.
2) Compute the strain of concrete (εcs=fcs/Ec) with regard to fcs.
3) Compute fss (fss = Es εcs).
γe :exposure factor
1.00 for Class 1 exposure condition
0.75 for Class 2 exposure condition
Exposure condition can be entered in the PSC Design parameters dialog.

೛ PSC> Design Parameter> Parameters…

[Fig.1.54] PSC Design parameter Dialog - Exposure Factor

49 Design Guide for midas Civil


7.2 Spacing of reinforcement
The spacing of Longitudinal reinforcement entered from Section Manager>Reinforcements
shall be used as the applied spacing of tensile reinforcement.

೛ Model>Properties>Section Manager>Reinforcements

Spacing of
reinforcements

Top and bottom


reinforcement data

[Fig.1.55] Input Longitudinal reinforcement

When the positive moment is checked, the spacing of bottom reinforcements will be used.
When the negative moment is checked, the spacing of top reinforcements will be used.

7.3 Check the crack width at service loads

7.3.1 by Result Tables


The results can be checked as shown in the table below.
೛ Design>PSC Design>PSC Design Result Tables>Check crack width at service loads…

[Fig.1.56] Result table for crack width at service loads


Elem: Element number
Part: Check location (I-End, J-End) of each element
Top/Bottom: At top of element, at bottom of element
LCom. Name: Load combination name.
Type: produce maximum and minimum member force components for the load combinations including
moving load cases or settlement load cases.
Check : OK/NG
FT : Stress at the top (+ compression, - tension)
FB : Stress at the bottom (+ compression, - tension)
s_use : The spacing of tensile reinforcement in use.
s_max : The calculated maximum spacing of reinforcement.


Chapter 1.Prestressed Box Girder Design - AASHTO LRFD 2012 50
7.3.2 by Excel Report
Verification results can be checked in MS Excel report as shown in the figure below.

೛ Design>PSC Design>PSC Design Calculation…

[Fig.1.57] Excel report for crack width at service loads

51 Design Guide for midas Civil


Chapter 2.

Steel Composite
Girder Design
AASHTO LRFD 6th (2012)
Chapter 1.
Steel Composite Design (AASHTO LRFD 12)
^ƚĞĞůĐŽŵƉŽƐŝƚĞŐŝƌĚĞƌŶĞĞĚƐƚŽďĞĚĞƐŝŐŶĞĚƚŽƐĂƟƐĨLJƚŚĞĨŽůůŽǁŝŶŐůŝŵŝƚƐƚĂƚĞƐ͘

Composite I-Girder Bridge


ŚĞĐŬ^ƚƌĞŶŐƚŚ>ŝŵŝƚ^ƚĂƚĞ

ŚĞĐŬ^ĞƌǀŝĐĞ>ŝŵŝƚ^ƚĂƚĞ

ŚĞĐŬ&ĂƟŐƵĞ>ŝŵŝƚ^ƚĂƚĞ

ŚĞĐŬŽŶƐƚƌƵĐƚĂďŝůŝƚLJ

ŚĞĐŬ^ŚĞĂƌŽŶŶĞĐƚŽƌ

ŚĞĐŬ>ŽŶŐŝƚƵĚŝŶĂů^ƟīĞŶĞƌ
Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design : AASHTO-LRFD 4thand6th (2007 & 2012)

Introduction
1. AASHTO LRFD 07 and 12 Steel Composite
1.1 Check List of AASHTO LRFD 07 and 12Steel Composite
For AASHTO LRFD 07 and 12 Steel Composite Design, Limit State Design is applied. The criteria that
Steel Composite Section must follow for Limit State Design is as follows.

(1) Cross-Section Proportion Limit State


Review on section properties, e.g. width-thickness ratio

(2) Strength Limit State


Review on flexure strength, shear strength and torsional strength

(3) Service Limit State


Review on permanent deformation

(4) Constructibility
Review on shear and flexure occurring from load combinations during construction stages

(5) Fatigue Limit State


Review on fatigue in steel and concrete materials in Steel Composite girder

1.2 Classification of Steel Composite


Steel Composite section can be categorized by the following classification groups.

(1) Section Shape Type


There are three main section shape types in midas Civil; I, Box and Tub shapes. In the case of
box and tub sections, there are two more cases, single or multiple box section.

[Table2. 1] Section Shape Type


I Box Tub

(2) Moment Type : Positive / Negative


For continuous beams, negative moments may occur around interior supports. Design code
may apply different formulas for these cases.

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 54


(3) Bridge Type : Straight / Curved
Based on the horizontal alignment of a bridge, it can be classified as either straight or
curved. The program recognizes curved bridges based on the input of the girder radius for
each component.

Compact Type
(4) Compact Type : Compact / Noncompact / Slender
AASHTO LRFD 12
(6.2)

[Table2.2] Steel Section Classification

Type Description
A composite section in positive flexure, which satisfies specific steel
grade, web slenderness, and ductility requirements, is capable of
Compact
developing a nominal resistance exceeding the moment at first yield,
but not to exceed the plastic moment.
A composite section in positive flexure for which the nominal
Noncompact
resistance is not permitted to exceed the moment at first yield.
Cross-Section of a Compression member composed of plate
Slender components of sufficient slenderness such that local buckling in the
elastic range will occur.

1.3 Stiffeners of Steel Composite


The program considers transverse and longitudinal stiffeners.

[Table2 3] Types of Stiffeners

Type Description

Transverse stiffeners are usually provided to increase shear resistance by


tension field action. These work as anchors for the tension so that post
Transverse buckling shear resistance can be developed.
Stiffeners
It should be noted that elastic web shear buckling cannot be prevented
by transverse stiffeners.
Longitudinal stiffeners may be provided to increase flexural resistance
by preventing local buckling. These work as restraining boundaries for
compression elements so that inelastic flexural buckling stress can be
Longitudinal
developed in a web.
Stiffeners
It consists of either a plate welded longitudinally to one side of the web,
or a bolted angle.

[Fig.2.1] Longitudinal Stiffener and Transverse Stiffener

55 Design Guide for midas Civil


2. Considerations Steel Composite Design
2.1 Construction Stage for steel composite
During the construction of a steel composite bridge, the steel girder is constructed before the
construction of the concrete deck of the upper part of the structure. The steel composite section
is divided into three major steps.

[Table2.4] Construction Stage for Steel Composite Section


Construction stage
Description
for steel composite section

Only Steel Girder Only the steel girder has been


(non-composite) constructed.

Steel girder and Although the concrete deck has been


concrete deck constructed, it has not hardened yet.
as load Therefore, the weight of the wet
(non-composite) concrete is applied as a load condition.

After concrete is hardened, the


Steel girder and
strength and stiffness are formed.
concrete deck
Hereafter, the steel girder and concrete
as member
deck work as a complete composite
(composite)
section.

In order to find and portray the Steel Composite Section Design Process within the program, utilize
the Construction Stage function.

2.2 Time Dependent Material


▪ Steel composite section is composed of steel and concrete. Concrete is a time dependent material
and transforms due to creep and shrinkage. Also, the restraints imposed by the shear connectors
cause additional stresses within the composite section. Therefore, time dependent characteristics
(creep and shrinkage) must be taken into consideration.

▪ Modular ratio is the ratio of modulus of elasticity of steel to that of concrete. The short-term
modular ratio "n" is used for transient loads in the program. Long-term modular ratio "3n" is used
for permanent loads acting after composite action. For normal-weight concrete, AASHTO-LRFD 07
and 12 recommend the values of the short-term modular ratio.

3. Calculation of Plastic Moment and Yield Moment


▪ The plastic moment Mp for a composite section is defined as the moment that causes yielding in
steel section and reinforcement and uniform stress distribution of 0.85 in compression concrete
slab. In positive flexure regions, the contribution of reinforcement in concrete slab is small and can
be neglected.
▪ The yield moment, My, for a composite section is defined as the moment that causes the first
yielding in one of the steel flanges or the moment at which an outer fiber first attans the yield
stress. My is the sum of the moments applied to the pre-composite steel section, the short-term
composite concrete and steel section, and the long-term composite concrete and steel section.

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 56


3.1 Plastic Moment(Mp), Yield Moment( My) in Positive Flexure

(1) Cross section proportions


I section and Box/Tub steel composite sections must satisfy the following criteria regarding
cross section proportions. If the conditions have not been met after the design has been
completed, it will be indicated as an “NG” on the design report generated.

1) Web Proportions
[Table 2.5] Web Proportions
Case Condition
WEB
D
Web with longitudinal stiffener d 150 For I section
AASHTO LRFD 12
tw (6.10.2.1.1-1)
(6.10.2.1.2-1)
D
Web without longitudinal stiffener d 300
tw For Box/Tub Section
AASHTO LRFD 12
(6.11.2.1.2-1)
(6.11.2.1.3-1)
2) Flange Proportions
[Table 2.6] Flange Proportions
Section Type

I Box / Tub Flange


For I section
bf
d 12.0 AASHTO LRFD 12
(6.10.2.2-1)
2t f bf
d 12.0 (6.10.2.2-2)
(6.10.2.2-3)
D 2t f
bf t (6.10.2.2-4)
6 D
bf t
t f t 1.1tw 6
For Box/Tub Section
AASHTO LRFD 12
I yc t f t 1.1tw (6.11.2.2-1)
0.1 d d 10 (6.11.2.2-2)
(6.11.2.2-3)
I yt

Where,
Iyc : moment of inertia of the compression flange of the steel section about the vertical axis in the
plane of the web
Iyt : moment of inertia of the tension flange of the steel section about the vertical axis in the plane of
the web

3 3
t fc b fc t ft b ft
I yc , I yt (2.1)
12 12

57 Design Guide for midas Civil


(2) Section Classification
Section Classification
Section Classification of Positive Flexure Moment AASHTO LRFD 12
6.10.6.2 (6.10.6.2)

Yes Straight Bridge?

min( F yc , F yt ) d 70 . 0 ksi No
d / t w d 150 :Curved Bridge

D cp Es
2 d 3 . 76 No
tw F yc

Yes

Compact Section Noncompact Section

End
[Fig.2.2] Section Classification of Negative Positive Moment
Where,
: depth of the web in compression at the plastic moment determined as per Article D6.3.2

▪ The Section Classifications of I, Box, Tub are all the same.


▪ In a positive moment, the following ductility conditions must be met at all times. If not, the
program will show NG.
Dp d 0.42Dt
Ductility
(2.2) AASHTO LRFD 12
(6.10.7.3)

Where,
: Distance from the top of the concrete deck to the neutral axis of the composite section at the plastic
moment
: Total depth of the composite section

(3) Plastic Moment in Positive Moment (MP) Plastic Moment


If the positive moment is applied on a compact section, MP should be calculated as shown in AASHTO LRFD 12
(D6.1)
Table 2.7.

[Fig.2.3] Case of calculation of Mp in positive moment

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 58


[Table 2.7] Calculation of and Mp for section in Positive Flexure Mp for section
in Positive
Case PNA Condition Y and Mp Flexure
AASHTO LRFD 12
(Table D6.1-1)
§ D · Pt  Pc  Ps  Prt  Prb
Y ¨ ¸[  1]
Pt  Pw ©2¹ Pw
Ǥ In Web t Pc  Ps  Prb  Prt
§ Pw · 2
¨ ¸[Y  (t  Y ) ] +
2
M
© 2D ¹
 [ Ps d s  Prt d rt  Prb d rb  Pw d w  Pt d t ]

t P +P −P −P −P
Y= +1
2 P
In Top Pt  Pw  Pc
ǥ
flange t Ps  Prb  Prt § Pc · 2
M ¨¨ ¸¸[Y  (t  Y ) 2 ]
© 2t c ¹
 [ Ps d s  Prt d rt  Prb d rb  Pw d w  Pt d t ]

P +P +P −P −P
Pt  Pw  Pc Y = (t )
P
Concrete §c ·
Ǧ Deck, t ¨¨ rb ¸¸ Ps  Prb  Prt §Y 2P ·
Below Prb © ts ¹ M ¨ s ¸
¨ 2t s ¸
© ¹
 [ Prt d rt  Prb d rb  Pc d c  Pw d w  Pt d t ]

Pt  Pw  Pc  Prb Y C rb
Concrete
ǧ Deck, §c ·
at Prb
t ¨¨ rb ¸¸ Ps  Prt § Y 2P ·
© ts ¹ M ¨ s ¸  [ Prt d rt  Pc d c  Pw d w  Pt d t ]
¨ 2t s ¸
© ¹

ª P  Pw  Pt  Prt  Prb º
Y (t s ) « c »
Concrete Pt  Pw  Pc  Prb ¬ Ps ¼
Ǩ
Deck, §c · § Y 2P ·
Above Prb t ¨ rt ¸ Ps  Prt ¨ ¸
¨t ¸ M s
Below Prt © s ¹ ¨ 2t s ¸
© ¹
 [ Prt d rt  Prb d rb  Pc d c  Pw d w  Pt d t ]

Y C rt
Pt  Pw  Pc  Prb  Prt
Concrete
ǩ Deck, §c ·
at Prt
t ¨¨ rt ¸¸ Ps § Y 2P ·
© ts ¹ M ¨ s ¸  [ Prb d rb  Pc d c  Pw d w  Pt d t ]
¨ 2t s ¸
© ¹

ªP  P  P  P  P º
Y (t s ) « rb c w t rt »
Pt  Pw  Pc  Prb  Prt ¬ Ps ¼
Concrete
Ǫ Deck, §c · § Y 2P ·
Above Prt
 ¨¨ rt ¸¸ Ps ¨ s ¸
M
© ts ¹ ¨ 2t s ¸
© ¹
 [ Prt drt  Prbdrb  Pc dc  Pwd w  Pt dt ]

Where,

59 Design Guide for midas Civil


: Distance from the plastic neutral axis to the centerline of the top layer of longitudinal concrete
deck.
: Distance from the plastic neutral axis to the centerline of the bottom layer of longitudinal concrete
deck.
: Distance from the plastic neutral axis to the midthickness of the tension flange.
: Distance from the plastic neutral axis to middepth of the web.
: Distance from the plastic neutral axis to midthickness of the compression flange.
: Distance from the plastic neutral axis to midthickness of the concrete deck.

= (by reinforcement)
= (by reinforcement)
= (by steel girder)
= (by steel girder)
= (by steel girder)
= 0,85 (by concrete slab)

(4) Yield Moment in Positive Moment (My)


When a positive moment is applied on a compact section, My is calculated as shown in
Equation 2.3.

My Min(M yTop , M yBot ) (2.3) My


AASHTO LRFD 12
(D6.2.2)
Where,
MyTop : Yield Moment of Top Flange
MyBot : Yield Moment of Bottom Flange
M D1 M D2 M AD
Fy  
STop STop(3n ) STop( n )
(2.4) Fy
M yTop M D1  M D 2  M AD AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq. D6.2.2-1)

M D1 M D 2 M M_ytop
Fy   AD (2.5) AASHTO LRFD 12
S Bot S Bot (3n ) S Bot ( n ) (Eq. D6.2.2-2)

M yBot M D1  M D 2  M AD

Where,
S: Non-composite section modulus
S : Long-term composite section modulus
S : Short-term composite section modulus
M : Moment of non-composite section
M : Moment of long-term composite section
M : Additional yield moment of short-term composite section

3.2 Plastic Moment(Mp), Yield Moment(My) in Negative Flexure


For I sections in negative flexure, Mp and My are calculated.

(1) Cross Section Proportions


For negative flexure, cross section proportions must meet the following requirements. If the
program does not meet the requirements, NG will be reported after the design.

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 60


1) Web Proportions
[Table 2.8] Web Proportions
Case Condition
D
Web with longitudinal stiffeners d 150
tw
D
Web without longitudinal stiffeners d 300
tw

2) Flange proportions
[Table 2.9] Flange Proportions
Section Type : I / Box / Tub
bf
d 12.0
2t f
D
bf t
6
t f t 1.1t w
I yc
0.1 d d 10
I yt

(2) Section Classification


Section Classification
AASHTO LRFD 12
(6.10.6.2.3)

[Fig.2.4] Section Classification of Negative Flexure Moment


Where,
: Depth of the web in compression in the elastic range.
Iyc : moment of inertia of the compression flange of the steel section about the vertical axis in the plane
of the web
Iyt : moment of inertia of the tension flange of the steel section about the vertical axis in the plane of the
web

61 Design Guide for midas Civil


▪ Minimum Negative Flexure Concrete Deck Reinforcement
Under negative moment, concrete deck has to meet the minimum rebar ratio requirement.
Once the requirements of Equation 2.6 are satisfied, the next design step can be taken.
Ars t 0.01Adeck (2.6)

(3) Plastic Moment in Negative Moment (Mp) Plastic Moment


AASHTO LRFD 12
Under negative moment, Mp is only calculated when Appendix A6 is used. Mp is calculated by (D6.1)
either of the two following methods. Please refer to Table 2.10 for the equations.

[Fig.2.5] Case of calculation of Mp in Negative Moment

[Table 2.10] Calculation of and Mp for section in Negative Flexure Mp for section in
Negative Flexure
Case PNA Condition Y and Mp AASHTO LRFD 12
(Table D6.1-2)
D P −P −P −P
Y= +1
2 P
In
Ǥ Pc  Pw t Pt  Prb  Prt
Web P
M = [Y + (D − Y) ]
2D
+[P d + P d + P d + P d ]

t P +P −P −P
Y= +1
2 P
In Top
ǥ Pc  Pw  Pt t Prb  Prt
flange P
M = [Y + (t − Y) ]
2t
+[P d + P d + P d + P d ]

Where,
= (by reinforcement)
= (by reinforcement)
= (by steel girder)
= (by steel girder)
= (by steel girder)

My in Negative
(4) Yield Moment in Negative Moment (My) Moment
AASHTO LRFD 12
When Appendix A6 is used for negative flexure, My is calculated and utilized. My is calculated
(D6.2.3)
as shown below in Equation 2.7.
My Min(M yTop , M yBot ) (2.7)
Where,
MyTop : Yield Moment of Top Flange
MyBot : Yield Moment of Bottom Flange

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 62


M D1 M D 2 M
Fy   AD (2.8)
STop STop( R ) STop( R )
M yTop M D1  M D 2  M AD (2.9)

M D1 M D 2 M
Fy   AD
S Bot S Bot ( R ) S Bot ( R )
(2.10)
M yBot M D1  M D 2  M AD (2.11)
Where,
S : Long-term composite section modulus with longitudinal reinforcements

63 Design Guide for midas Civil


Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design : AASHTO-LRFD 4thand6th (2007/2012)

Modeling and Design


Variables
1. Modeling Design Variables
In this chapter, the design variable values, the meaning behind the design requirements, and the design process for Steel
Composite Design in midas Civil are explained.

1.1. Composite Section Data


The steel composite section is mainly composed of steel girder and concrete slab. Stiffeners can be added to steel girder
section while longitudinal reinforcement can be added to reinforce concrete slab. In this section, the input methods for
these sections and the meaning and application of design variables are explained.

&RQWHQWV ([SODQDWLRQ

1.1.1 Composite Section 1.1.1 Composite Section


(1) Composite Section Data (1) Composite Section Data
೛ Properties > Section > Section Properties> Add > 1) Girder Num
When the Girder Num is inputted as more than
Composite Tab
1, the moment of inertia of area in transverse
direction (Izz) is increased assuming that slab
behaves in consistence with each girder in
analysis. When the number of girder is inputted
as more than 1, it is excluded from the
consideration of design.

For design, Girder Num must be inserted as 1. In


such case, cross beams should be modelled to
consider the transverse stiffness instead of
increasing the girder number.

2) The value of Bc for the slab is used as the


effective width of the concrete deck.

3) Multiple Modulus of Elasticity Option


To design the steel composite section, the
modulus of elasticity for short-term and long-
term effect in creep and shrinkage can be input.
The modulus of elasticity input here is applied
for construction stage analysis of Steel
Composite section as shown in [Fig.2.7].
[Fig.2.6] Section Data Dialog Box

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 64


(2) Section Stiffener
೛ Properties > Section > Section Properties> Add >
Composite Tab > Stiffeners Button... [Fig.2.7] Elastic Modulus ratio for Construction Stage

(2) Section Stiffener (Longitudinal)


1) Types of longitudinal stiffeners that are
useable are Flat, Tee, and U-Rib.
2) For I sections, stiffeners can be added on
either side of the web. For Box/Tub sections,
upper and lower flanges can be installed as well
as the web panel.
3) When the check box under c column is
checked on, the stiffness value of the stiffener is
considered in analysis. Otherwise, the value is
not considered for analysis. Regardless of
whether or not the check box is checked on or
off, longitudinal stiffeners are considered in
design.
Based on the assignment of longitudinal
stiffener, Rb, web load shedding factor varies for
[Fig.2.8] Section Stiffener Dialog Box
stiffened web/unstiffened web. It is also
required for classifying the interior panels in
shear check as stiffener/unstiffened.

1.1.2 Longitudinal Reinforcement


1.1.2 Longitudinal Reinforcement
In a steel composite section, the longitudinal
೛Design > Composite Design > Longitudinal reinforcements are arranged within the concrete
Reinforcement ... deck. The strength is calculated as shown in Table
2.11.

[Table 2.11] Applicability of material under the calculation


of strength
Positive Negative
Case
Flexure Flexure

Figure

[Fig.2.9] Longitudinal Reinforcement Dialog Box Concrete


Applied None
Slab
Reinforce
None Applied
-ment

65 Design Guide for midas Civil


&RQWHQWV ([SODQDWLRQ

1.1.3 Transverse Stiffener 1.1.3 Transverse Stiffener


(1) Transverse Stiffener Figure 2.10 shows the window in which users can
arrange transverse stiffeners in steel composite
೛ Design > Composite Design > Transverse Stiffener ...
section. When the transverse stiffeners are
installed, the existence and spacing between
stiffeners determine whether the web is stiffened
or unstiffened under strength limit state. Tension
field action in Shear check for Strength Limit State
is considered only for stiffened interior panels.

[Fig.2.10] Transverse Stiffener Dialog Box

[Fig.2.11] Transverse Stiffener Parameters

(1) Stiffener Type


1) One / Two Stiffener Option Button
Choose between one or two stiffeners. The two
stiffener option is available for I/Box/Tub
sections.

2) Pitch (do)
Pitch refers to transverse stiffener spacing. At
[Fig.2.12] Stiffener Type Dialog Box the strength limit state, this can be used to
distinguish between stiffened and unstiffened
webs or calculate shear strength of the web.

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 66


1.2. Design Material Data
For the design of steel composite section, construction stage and time dependent material properties of concrete must
be defined. In this section, the input method for concrete's time dependent properties and steel composite section
material information is defined.

Contents Explanation

1.2.1 Time Dependent Material 1.2.1 Time Dependent Material


(1) Creep/Shrinkage (1) Creep/Shrinkage
೛ Properties > Time Dependent Material > The time dependent properties of concrete, such
as creep and shrinkage, are defined. During
Creep/Shrinkage ...
construction stage analysis of bridges, these
properties are utilized for concrete material.
During analysis, they are reflected in the
calculation of member forces but not reflected in
the design of the steel composite section.

[Fig.2.13] Add/Modify Time Dependent Material Dialog Box


(Creep/Shrinkage)

(2) Comp. Strength (2) Comp. Strength


೛ Properties > Time Dependent Material > Comp. In order to reflect the change in the modulus of
elasticity of the time dependent property of
Strength ...
concrete, the change in compressive strength or
modulus of elasticity is defined.

Aging effects may vary for each construction


stage since concrete is poured at different
locations. The varying aging effects are reflected
in the calculation of the member force but not in
the design of the composite sections.

[Fig.2.14] Add/Modify Time Dependent Material Dialog Box


(Compression Strength)

1.2.2 Modify Composite Material


1.2.2 Modify Composite Material The material utilized for steel composite sections
(1) Modify Composite Material are provided in the SRC material properties. The
೛ Design > Composite Design > Design Material ... materials should be defined as SRC Type.

(1) Modify Composite Material


Figure 2.15 shows the dialog box where users can
type in material characteristics for the steel

67 Design Guide for midas Civil


Contents Explanation

composite section design. The material property


values entered will have a priority over the values
entered in Material Data dialog box.

1) Steel Girder Section - Steel


႒ Hybrid Factor
Hybrid factor is considered in the case where
flanges and web have different material
properties.

2) Concrete of Concrete slab

3) Steel materials of Concrete slab

[Fig.2.15] Modify Composite Material Dialog Box

(2) Hybrid Factor (2) Hybrid Factor(Rh)


When the check box for Hybrid Factor is selected,
icon on the right is activated. The different
materials for the top and bottom flanges and
web of the steel girder can be defined. Hybrid
Factor (Rh) is determined based on these
material information.

[Fig.2.16] Hybrid Factor Dialog Box

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 68


1.3. Design Parameters for Composite Section
Contents Explanation

1.3.1 Design Parameter 1.3.1 Design Parameter


೛ Design > Composite Design > Design Parameters ...
(1) Strength Resistance Factor
Strength Resistance Factor is defined.
By clicking , the resistance factors
are automatically set to the default values defined
in AASHTO LRFD 12. The values also may be
modified or entered manually.

(2) Girder Type for Box/Tub Section

□ Consider St.Venant Torsion and Distortion Stress


If the Multiple Box Sections option is selected,
lateral bending stress is considered in accordance
with St.Venant Torsion and Distortion Stress. If the
Single Box Sections option is selected, the lateral
bending stress is always considered.

(3) Options For Strength Limit State


□ Appendix A6 for Negative Flexure Resistance in
Web Compact/Noncompact Sections
If this option is checked, Appendix A6 is applied for
the flexure strength of straight composite I-
[Fig.2.17] Composite Steel Girder Design Parameter Dialog Box sections in negative flexure with compact/
noncompact webs. Use of Appendix A6 is optional
in accordance with the code as shown below.

[Fig.2.18] Negative Flexure Resistance in Web


Compact/Noncompact Sections

□ Mnื1.3RhMy in Positive Flexure and Compact


Sections(6.10.7.1.2-3)

Before deciding, whether to apply this check or


not, following conditions need to be manually
verified:

69 Design Guide for midas Civil


- The span under consideration and all adjacent
interior pier sections satisfy the requirements
of Article B6.2,
- The appropriate value of θRL from Article
B6.6.2 exceeds 0.009 radians at all adjacent
interior-pier sections
- In which case the nominal flexural resistance
of the section is not subject to the limitation
of Eq. 6.10.7.1.2-3.

If the above three conditions are not satisfied for


the compact sections under positive flexure in a
continuous span, the Mn value is restricted to
1.3RhMy.

□ Post-buckling Tension-field Action for Shear


Resistance (6.10.9.3.2)
If this option is checked, post buckling resistance
due to tension field action is considered in the
nominal shear resistance of an interior stiffened
web panel. If not, Vn is taken as, CVP.

where,
C = ratio of shear-buckling resistance to the shear yield
strength
Vp = plastic shear force.

(4) Design Parameters


Design and result outputs are generated for the
limit states checked in the Design Parameters.

1.3.2 Unbraced Length 1.3.2 Unbraced Length


೛ Design > Composite Design > Unbraced Length ... Unbraced length factor for steel composite section is
considered. The value input here has higher priority
than the value calculated from Span Group.
(1) Lb
Lateral Unbraced Length is used to calculate lateral
torsional buckling resistance in compression flange
of I Girder or top flange of Tub Girder. If the lateral
unbraced length is not added, the program will use
span lengths. If span lengths are not defined either,
the lateral unbraced length is applied for the
corresponding member length.

[Fig.2.19] Unbraced Length Dialog Box

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 70


1.3.3 Shear Connectors 1.3.3 Shear Connectors
೛ Design > Composite Design > Shear Connectors ... In this program, studs are used for shear connectors.
The parameters used for calculation are shown
below.

(1) Category
Category defined by 75yr-(ADTT)SL equivalent to
Infinite Life (Table 6.6.1.2.3-2)

(2) Fu
Shear Resistance of Shear Connector

(3) Shear Connector Parameters

[Fig.2.21] Shear Connector Parameters

(4) Length Between Maximum Moment and Zero


Moment
[Fig.2.20] Shear Connector Dialog Box
The Length between Maximum Moment and Zero
Moment needs to be inputted by users to verify
pitch as per strength limit state.

(5) Nominal Shear Force Calculation (6.10.10.4.2)


One of the two conditions needs to be selected for
the calculation of the nominal shear force, P which
is applied for the verification of pitch at the
strength limit state.

1.3.4 Fatigue Parameter 1.3.4 Fatigue Parameter


೛ Design > Composite Design > Fatigue Parameter ... (1) Category
Category defined by 75ye-(ADTT)SL equivalent to
infinite life (Table 6.6.1.2.3-2)

(2) (ADTT)SL
Number of trucks per day in a single-lane averaged
over the design life (3.6.1.4.2)
(ADTT)SL can be manually calculated as per
3.6.1.4.2-1.

(3) N
Number of stress range cycles per truck passage
Value can be taken from Table 6.6.1.2.5-2.

(4) Longitudinal Warping Stress Range


For the verification of fatigue, flexure stress is

71 Design Guide for midas Civil


calculated as the summation of Longitudinal
Bending Stress Range and Longitudinal Warping
Stress Range.

By choosing the Auto-Calculation option, fatigue


vertical bending moment is simply increased by
10% for the longitudinal warping stress.

Longitudinal warping stress range can be manually


calculated as per BEF (Beam on Elastic Foundation)
analogy presented by Wright and Abdel-Samad.
The designer guide to Box Girder by Bethlehem
Steel Corporation also presents this method.
Detailed calculations can be seen in Design
Example 5: Three Span Continuous Curved
Composite Tub-Girder Bridge (page 85-94).

Software calculations do not account for


Transverse Bending Stress due to Distorsion.
Therefore, transverse bending stress range at the
top or bottom corners of the tub section need to
[Fig.2.22] Fatigue Parameters Dialog Box be manually checked with the nominal fatigue
resistance.

If the User Input option is selected, longitudinal


bending stress range is summated with the
inputted value of the Longitudinal Warping Stress
Range for top or bottom flange depending upon
the flexure condition at the section.

These distorsion stresses are considered only for


the sections having box flange as those are the
section in which the torsion is considered.
1.3.5 Span Information
೛ Structure > Wizard > Composite Bridge > Span
Information ... 1.3.5 Span Information
The elements of composite sections are defined as
one Span Group. The Span Group will serve the
following functions.

(1) Finding the most critical parts of the group unit


and providing the corresponding results in the
Span Checking table. Refer to Chapter 7 of "Steel
Composite Design Result" for more information.

(2) Calculation of Unbraced Length


When assigning a span group, support properties
are considered for calculating the unbraced length.
The unbraced length can also be manually inputted
once the corresponding support conditions under
the support column are selected. Using the span
parameters inputted, the unbraced length can be
calculated automatically. However, if the unbraced
length is inputted in Section 1.3.2, this value will be
applied as the unbraced length first.

[Fig.2.23] Span Information Dialog Box

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 72


Contents Explanation

(3) End web panels


For each element, location of support, if any, can
be identified as i or j. The stiffened webs with
supports are identified as end panels.
Also, the elements that are assigned with i or j for
the support are considered as end panels. Tension
field action is not considered for the end panel in
Shear Check.

1.3.6 Curved Bridge Information 1.3.6 Curved Bridge Information


೛ Design > Composite Design > Curved Bridge Info ... Once the girder radius value of the element units in
the steel composite section is entered, the
corresponding elements are categorized as curved
bridges.

(1) Radius is used for the review of shear


connectors' pitch and the moment of inertia of
area for the longitudinal stiffener attached to web.

The curve type needs to be determined as convex


or concave so the program determines whether
the longitudinal stiffener is on the side of the web
away or toward from the center of the curvature.

Lateral bending stress due to curvature is obtained


from the analysis results and not using V-Load
equation.
[Fig.2.24] Curved Bridge Information Dialog Box
(2) If convex, left stiffener is on the side of the web
away from the center of curvature and right
stiffener is on the side of the web toward the
center of curvature. If concave, the opposite case
of the convex is applied.

Please refer to the table below for the equations


applied to each case.

[Table 2.12] Curvature Correction Factor for Longitudinal


Stiffener
Case
Z
E 1
Left Stiffener 6
(6.10.11.3.3-3)
Convex Z
E 1
Right Stiffener 12
(6.10.11.3.3-4)
Z
E 1
Left Stiffener 12
(6.10.11.3.3-4)
Concave Z
E 1
Right Stiffener 6
(6.10.11.3.3-3)
where,
β : Curvature correction factor for longitudinal stiffener
rigidity
Z : Curvature Parameter

73 Design Guide for midas Civil


Contents Explanation

1.3.7 Deck Overhang Loads


1.3.7 Deck Overhang Loads
Design parameters for the Deck Overhang load can be
entered. The fl value obtained from F(Distributed
force) and P(Concentrated force) is not applied to Box
section, but only for I-section and top stiffener of Tub
section. The fl value for deck overhang is considered
only for the constructibility limit state. Distributed
Force, F
(1) Distributed Force, F
Distributed force values are inputted
Fl = F tan α

(2) Concentrated Force, P


Concentrated force values are inputted
Pl = P tan ˞

(3) Eccentricity of Overhang Loads, e


Eccentricity of overhang loads are inputted
α = tan-1(e/D)
[Fig.2.25] Deck Overhang Loads Dialog Box

The fl value is generated by combining the values


produced from the analysis and the value inputted in
this dialog box. If this feature is not used, fl value only
from the analysis results will be used. Lateral bending
moment due to uniformly distributed lateral bracket
force (Fl) is estimated as:
2
Fl Lb
Ml (c6.10.3.4-2)
12
where,
Ml : flange lateral bending moment due to the eccentric
loadings from the forming brackets
Fl : uniformly distributed lateral force
Lb : unbraced length

Lateral bending moment due to concentrated lateral


[Fig.2.26] Deck Overhand Bracket bracket force (Fl) assumed to be placed at the
middle of the unbraced length is estimated as:
Pl Lb
Ml (c6.10.3.4-3)
8
where,
Ml : flange lateral bending moment due to the eccentric
loadings from the forming brackets
Pl : concentrated lateral force
Lb : unbraced length

P and F are the dead loads and construction loads


such as Deck Overhang Weight, Screed rail load,
Railing load, Walkway load, Machine Load, etc.
considered for the constructability check only.

The load coefficient applied to Erection (DC) Load

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 74


Contents Explanation

Case is applied to calculate the load in this case.


1.3.8 Design Force/Moment
೛ Design > Composite Design > Design Tables > Design
1.3.8 Design Force/Moment
Force/Moment...
This feature displays design member forces (strong
axis moment, My), weak-axis moment (Mz) and shear
stress (VU) for the local axis of elements under
selected load combination of steel composite section
for each construction stage. For explanation
regarding design member forces under construction
stages, please refer to Section 1.5 in this chapter.

[Fig.2.27] Design Force/Moment Dialog Box

75 Design Guide for midas Civil


1.4 Load Combination for steel composite section
1.4.1 Application of load combination in midas Civil for AASHTO LRFD 12
(1) Application of load combinations and factors in midas Civil for AASHTO LRFD 12
The load combinations used for the review of each limit state as per Table 3.4.1-1, are shown below.

[Fig.2.28] Load Combinations and Load Factors

Using the Auto Generation feature of the program, the load combinations regulated by the design code can be
automatically generated. Load factors are considered for each load combinations in this program. Load factors are
considered only within the program, and γp value can be designated by Auto Generation feature.

[Fig.2.29] Load Factors for Permanent Loads, γp

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 76


&RQWHQWV ([SODQDWLRQ

(1) Auto Generation of Load Combinations (1) Auto Generation of Load Combinations
೛ Result > Combination > Load Combination > This feature automatically generates load
combinations under provision of AASHTO LRFD 12.
Composite Steel Girder Design > Auto Generation ...

1) Design Code
When load combinations are generated, they
strictly follow the design code selected by the user.

2) Load Modifier (ηi)


Load modifier is a factor relating to ductility,
redundancy, and operational classification. It is
defined by the following equations.

For loads for which a maximum value of γ i is


appropriate:

ηi = ηD ηR ηI ™ 0.95

For loads for which a minimum value of γi is


appropriate:

ηi = 1/(ηD ηR ηI ) ≤ 1.0

Where,
ηD: a factor relating to ductility as per 1.3.3
ηR: a factor relating to redundancy as per 1.3.4
ηI: a factor relating to operational classification as per
1.3.5

3) Load Factors for Permanent Loads (γp)


Load Factors for Permanent Loads are as per Table
3.4.1-2. Each option button for γp value is activated
when the corresponding static load case is
defined.

[Fig.2.30] Automatic Generation of Load Combinations


Dialog Box

If a user wishes to review limit states based on the load combinations defined manually, it can be done by selecting
the load combination of interest in Load Combination Type as in Section 1.4.2.

77 Design Guide for midas Civil


1.4.2 Used load combination for steel composite design
Load combinations used in the steel composite section design are defined under Load Combination Type.

Contents Explanation

(1) Load Combination Type (1) Load Combination Type


1) Strength Limit State
೛ Design > Composite Design > Load Combination Type...
Choose load combinations for use under
review of strength limit state.

2) Service Limit State


Choose load combinations for review of
usability limit state.

3) Fatigue 1 Limit State


Choose load combinations for review in
fatigue limit state (Fatigue ൕ Load
Combination is for infinite life design;
(ADTT)SL inputted in the software > (ADTT)SL,
equivalent to infinite life as per Table
6.6.1.2.3-2).

4) Fatigue 2 Limit State


Similarly, choose load combinations for
review in fatigue limit state (Conversely to
Fatigue I, Fatigue ൖ Load Combination is for
finite life design).
[Fig.2.31] Load Combination Type Dialog Box

1.5 Modeling Steel Composite Sections for Construction Staged Analysis


In this section, methods of construction stage modeling, implementation of concrete's time-dependent material
properties in steel composite section and 3 types of design member forces applied to steel composite section design are
explained. Construction stages of steel composite section can be implemented differently for case 1 to 3 as in table 2.13.

[Table 2.13] Modeling Construction Stage Cases for Steel Composite Design
Case Construction Stage Time Dependent Material(Creep / Shrinkage)

Case 1 Defined
Defined
Case 2 Not Defined (Apply modular ratio of 3n)

Case 3 Not Defined Not Defined (Apply modular ratio of 3n)

1.5.1 Member forces and stresses used in steel composite section design
(1) Member forces
For design of steel composite section, member forces per construction stage of steel composite section must be
calculated. The program considers two main factors for design and review of construction stage of steel composite
section.
▪Construction stages of steel composite section
▪Time dependent material properties of Concrete (Creep, Shrinkage and Compression Strength)

Design member forces used for design of steel composite section are divided into three main categories.

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 78


[Table 2.14]Design Force and Moment for Steel Composite Design

Design Force/Moment Description

Member forces before the concrete deck is activated. Only steel section properties
Dead (Before)
are used.
Member forces occurring due to erection load cases defined by user with the time
Dead (After) dependent material properties (Creep & Shrinkage) of concrete Long term section
properties are used.
Member forces from the post-construction state and load cases not included in
Short Term
the above categories. Short term section properties are used.

(2) Stress
Bending stress (fbu) used for design of steel composite section is calculated as in equation 2.12.
M D1 M D 2 M AD
f bu   (2.12)
S NC S LT S ST
Where,
Md1 : moment of non-composite section
Md2 : moment of long-term composite section
MAD : additional yield moment of short-term composite section
SNC : non-composite section modulus
SLT : long-term section modulus
SST : short-term section modulus
fbu : largest value of the flexural stress in the flanges at the section under consideration

On the other hand, lateral bending stress (fl) is calculated as in equation 2.13.
M uz  M lat
fl d 0.6 Fyf
Sl
(2.13)
Where,
fl : flange lateral bending stress
Sl: lateral section modulus of the flanges about z-axis
Muz : flexural moment about z-axis
Mlat : lateral bending moment in the flange calculated from the overhang loads
Fyf : specified minimum yield strength of a flange

1.5.2 Case 1
In Case 1, construction stages and time dependent material properties of concrete (Creep/Shrinkage) are defined.
Composite sections for Construction Stages function must be defined as well; otherwise, the sections shall be
excluded from design. If time dependent material property information is inputted as well as long-term modulus of
elasticity, long-term modulus of elasticity has higher priority in consideration of calculation.

79 Design Guide for midas Civil


೓ Define Composite Section for Construction Stage

Contents Explanation

Composite Section for Construction Stage Composite Section for Construction Stage
೛ Load >Load Type> Construction Stage > Composite For definition of construction stage, information
in this window must be defined.
Section for C.S...
(1) Active Stage
Construction stage where steel composite
section should be activated is inserted.

(2) Construction sequence


1) "Material Type" column
□ By choosing Element, material property of
the element is used.

□ By selecting Material, material information


chosen under "Material" Column is applied
with higher priority.

2) Composite Stage column


[Fig.2.32] Add/Modify Composite Section for Construction stages where steel girder and
concrete slab should be activated are chosen.
Construction Stage Dialog

3) Age column
Age information when each part is activated is
input. Information in this column has higher
priority over the age input during definition of
construction stage.

(1) Member forces under Dead (Before composite)


Member forces before activation of Concrete Deck are applied. (Refer to Table 2.4 in "Introduction") For design
purposes, Dead (Before) member forces are applied after multiplying the load factors applied in Dead Load (CS) in
Load Combination dialog box.

(2) Member forces under Dead (After composite)


For the member forces under Dead (After), in post-composite stages, the long-term modulus of elasticity is
determined by the time dependent material properties defined by users. Member forces under Dead (After) consist
of static load cases and construction stage load cases. If Dead Load of Component and Attachments (DC2), Dead
Load of Wearing Surfaces and Utilities (DW), Creep (CH), and Shrinkage (SH) are defined as erection loads, they are
accounted for the Dead (After).

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 80


೐Define Erection Load

&RQWHQWV ([SODQDWLRQ

(1) Define Erection Load 1) Define Erection Load


೛Analysis > Analysis Control > Construction Stage > Load Cases Erection Load is defined.
to be Distinguished from Dead Load for C.S Output >Add
(Modify/delete)... 1) Load Type for C.S
Determine the Load Type for the
construction stages of the composite
section. Load types are considered by the
software for auto generation of load
combinations.

2) Assignment Load Cases


Define Erection Load by selecting and
moving the Load Cases desired from the
List of Load Case panel to the Selected
Load Case panel.

[Fig.2.33] Define Erection Load Dialog

(3) Calculation of the short-term member forces


Short-term modulus of elasticity of the composite section is calculated based on the DB value inputted. All load
cases are considered as the short-term loads except the ones defined as Dead (Before) and Dead (After).

1.5.3 Case 2
In Case 2, construction stages are defined without the time dependent material property (Creep/Shrinkage)
information. Long term effects are considered using the long term modular ratio entered in the Section Data dialog
box. Sections for different construction stages must be defined and differentiated using the Composite Section for
Construction Stage definition. Otherwise, they will not be considered for the design check.

(1) Member forces under Dead (Before)


Dead (Before) is applied before the concrete deck is activated. (Refer to Table 2.4 in the "Introduction") For the
design, the Dead (CS) multiplied by the load factor is applied as the member force under Dead (Before).

(2) Member forces under Dead (After)


The effects of Creep/Shrinkage are reflected by applying the ratio of elastic modulus that is inputted in the Section
Data (Refer to Section 1.1.1 (1)) for the long-term stage. In other words, the Creep/Shrinkage effects are reflected
by using the section information with the ratio of elastic modulus that considers the time dependent material
property for the analysis and design. These long term modular ratios defined for considering creep and shrinkage,
auto generate Section Stiffness Scale Factors for the sections in which these are inputted. Section Stiffness Scale
Factors need to be activated in the construction stages in accordance with the Composite Section for Construction
Stage definition, i.e. the section stiffness scale factors are activated when the corresponding section becomes
composite as per the definition of composite section for CS. If users compose construction stages and define Dead
Load of Component and Attachments (DC2), Dead Load of Wearing Surfaces and Utilities (DW), Creep (CH), and
Shrinkage (SH) as Erection Load, the load cases will be included in the Dead (After).

(3) Short term member forces


The ratio of elastic modulus of the composite section is calculated using the DB value inputted. All the load cases
which are not activated in the Construction Stage are considered as the short-term loads.

81 Design Guide for midas Civil


1.5.4 Case 3
In case the construction stages are not defined, users can model and define steel composite sections by using the
Load Case for Pre-Composite Section function at
೛ Load > Load Type > Settlement/Misc. > Misc. > Pre-composite Section.
For this case, short- and long-term ratios of elastic modulus defined in the section data (Refer to Section 1.1.1 (1)) are
used. In this case, instead of member forces per construction stages, member forces under Dead (Before) is used to
check the constructibility of the model.

(1) Member force under Dead (Before)


In the Load Cases for Pre-Composite Section dialog box, users can define which load cases to account for the
member forces and apply as Dead (Before) in design. Since this is for pre-composite state, the steel only section
properties are used (Refer to Section 1.1.1 (1)).

Dead Load (Before)

[Fig.2.34] Load Cases for Pre-Composite Section

(2) Member forces under Dead (After)


Member forces under Dead (After) use the long term section properties. These loads should be separated from the
short term member forces by the use of Analysis > Analysis Control > Boundary Change Assignment.

1) Data Selection
Check the box corresponding to Section Stiffness Scale Factor. As explained earlier, Section Stiffness Scale
Factors are used for considering the long term section properties.

2) Boundary Group Combination


Create a boundary group combination considering the appropriate boundary groups from the boundary group
list. The created boundary group combinations need to be selected for the post composite long term load
cases. For the static load cases assigned with the section stiffness scale factor boundary groups, long term
section property will be used.

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 82


Dead Load (After)

[Fig.2.35] Load Cases for Post-Composite Section

(3) Short-term member forces


The ratio of elastic modulus from the database is used for the short-term loads of the composite section. All load
cases are considered for the short-term loads except the ones considered for the Dead (Before) and Dead (After).

83 Design Guide for midas Civil


Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design : AASHTO-LRFD 4thand6th (2007/2012)

Application of AASHTO
LRFD 12
1. I Girder Section
1.1. Introduction
The program designs I-girder sections according to the orders in the flow chart below. This chapter
demonstrates how the AASHTO LRFD 12 is applied in the program.

[Fig.2.36] Flow chart of Composite I-girder bridge

Typical I-Sections have a cross section as shown below:

[Fig.2.37] I-Section in positive flexure

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 84


1.2 Strength Limit State
The program checks the strength limit states for the flexure, shear, and ductility of the composite
sections.
Strength Limit States
6.10.6

Check Ductility
6.10.7.3

Check flexural resistance


6.10.7 & 6.10.8

Check shear resistance


6.10.9

[Fig.2.38] Flow chart of Strength Limit States

1.2.1 Ductility
Ductility shall be checked to prevent premature crushing of concrete. For the verification of a
web section that is under positive flexure, the ductility shall be verified as:

Ductility
D p d 0.42 Dt (2.14) AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.7.3-1)
Where,
Dp :distance from the top of the concrete deck to the neutral axis of the composite section at the plastic
moment
Dt : total depth of the composite section

1.2.2 Flexural Resistance


There are four cases for checking flexural resistance of I Sections as shown below.
Check flexural resistance
6.10.7 & 6.10.8

Yes Positive Moment? No

Check Ductility f sd Straight


ks Bridge?
D p dM0c,.Ed42( zcd,bart / I y ,c,bar ) No
6.10.7.3 :Curved Yes
Bridge

Yes Slender Section?


Straight
Bridge?
Yes No No
:Curved :Compact or
Bridge Noncompact

Compact
No Use Optional
Section? No
APPENDIX A6?

Yes Yes

Case 1 : Case 2 : Case 3 : Case 4 :


Check flexural resistance of Check flexural resistance of Check flexural resistance of Check flexural resistance of
Positive Flexure Moment in Positive Flexure Moment in Negative Flexure Moment Negative Flexure Moment by
Compact Section Noncompact Section using APPENDIX A6
6.10.7.1 6.10.7.2 6.10.8 APPENDIX A6

Positive Flexure Moment Negative Flexure Moment

End

[Fig.2.39] Flow chart of flexural resistance

85 Design Guide for midas Civil


(1) Case 1: Compact Section in Positive flexural moment Case 1
AASHTO LRFD 12
The flexural resistance shall be checked according to the flow chart below if the section is (6.10.7.1)
under positive flexural moment, satisfies the ductility requirement and is a compact web. If
the ductility requirement is not satisfied, the program will display NG in the design result
page.

Flow chart of Case 1


AASHTO LRFD 12
[Fig.2.40] Case 1 : Flow chart of flexural resistance of Positive Flexure Moment in Compact Section (6.10.7.1)

If a section is compact and under positive flexural moment, flexural resistance shall be
checked according to the following equation:
Flexural Resistance
1 AASHTO LRFD 12
M u  f l S xt d I f M n (2.15) (Eq. 6.10.7.1.1-1)
3
Where,
fl : Flange lateral bending stress
Mn : Nominal flexural resistance of the section.
Mu : Bending moment about the major-axis of the cross-section.
ϕ : Resistance factor for flexure.

1) Nominal Flexural Resistance(Mn)


[Table 2.15]Calculation of Nominal Flexural Resistance(Mn)
Mn
Case Mn AASHTO LRFD 12
Dp d 0.1Dt Mn Mp (Eq. 6.10.7.1.2-1)

AASHTO LRFD 12
§ D ·
Otherwise Mn M p ¨¨1.07  0.7 p ¸¸ (Eq. 6.10.7.1.2-2)

© Dt ¹

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 86


Where,
Mp : Plastic moment of the composite section determined as per Article D6.1.
Dp : distance from the top of the concrete deck to the neutral axis of the composite section at the
plastic moment
Dt : total depth of the composite section
2) Strength Resistance Factor for flexure (ϕI )
The design code defines the flexural reduction factor as 1.00. However, the program
primarily considers the factor that is inputted by users in the design parameters.

[Fig.2.41] Composite Steel Girder Design Parameter

3) Especially, the following requirement regarding the nominal flexural resistance must be
satisfied when " M n d 1.3Rh M y in Positive Flexure and Compact Sections" is checked at
೛ Composite Steel Girder Design Parameters>Options for Strength Limit State. (Fig.2.41) Nominal flexural
resistance
AASHTO LRFD 12
M n d 1.3Rh M y (2.16) (Eq. 6.10.7.1.2-3)

87 Design Guide for midas Civil


(2) Case 2 : Positive flexural moment in noncompact section Case 2
AASHTO LRFD 12
The flexural resistance shall be checked according to the below flow chart if a section is under (6.10.7.2)
positive flexural moment, satisfies the ductility requirement and is noncompact. Curved
bridges are considered as noncompact sections.

Case 2 : Check flexural resistance of


Positive Flexure Moment in Noncompact Section
6.10.7.2

Check Compression flange


f bu d I f F nc
F nc R b R h F yc

6.10.7.2.1-1, 6.10.7.2.2-1

Check Tension flange


1
f bu  f l d I f F nt
3
F nt R h F yt
6.10.7.2.1-2, 6.10.7.2.2-2

End

[Fig.2.42] Case 2 : Flow chart of flexural resistance of Positive Flexure Moment in Noncompact Section

1) Compression flange
At the strength limit state, the compression flange shall satisfy the below criteria regarding
the flexure:
Compression flange
f bu d I f Fnc (2.17) AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.7.2.1-1)
(Eq.6.10.7.2.2-1)
Fnc Rb Rh Fyc (2.18)
Where,
fbu : Flange stress calculated without consideration of flange lateral bending.
Fnc : Nominal flexural resistance of the compression flange.

 Tension flange
The tension flange shall satisfy the below criteria regarding the flexure:
Tension flange
1
f bu  f l d I f Fnt (2.19) AASHTO LRFD 12
3 (Eq.6.10.7.2.1-2)
(Eq.6.10.7.2.2-2)
Fnt Rh Fyt (2.20)
Where,
fl: Flange lateral bending stress, ≤ 0.6
Fnt : Nominal flexural resistance of the tension flange.
Rb : Web load-shedding factor.

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 88


(3) Case 3: Negative flexural moment in composite section and noncomposite section
The flexural resistance shall be checked according to the below flow chart if a section is
under negative flexural moment and is one of the following cases:
▪ Curved bridge
▪ Straight Bridge but slender section
▪ Straight Bridge and compact or noncompact, but Appendix A6 is not applied

[Fig.2.43] Case 3 : Flow chart of flexural resistance of Negative Flexure Moment

Compression Flange
1) Discretely Braced Compression Flange AASHTO LRFD 12
For a compression flange, the following requirement shall be satisfied at the strength limit (6.10.8)
state:
(Eq.6.10.8.1.1-1)
1
f bu  f l d I f Fnc (2.21)
3

Where,
Fnc Min( Fnc( FLB ) , Fnc( LTB) ) (2.22)
Where,
F ( ) : Local Buckling Resistance based on Discretely Braced Compression Flange

89 Design Guide for midas Civil


F ( ) : Lateral Torsional Buckling Resistance based on Discretely Braced Compression Flange

[Table 2.16] Calculation of Fnc(FLB)

Fnc( FLB )
Fnc(FLB)
Case AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.8.2.2-1)
O f d O pf Fnc( FLB ) Rb Rh Fyc
ª § Fyr ·§ O f  O pf ·º
AASHTO LRFD 12
O f ! O pf «1  ¨¨1  ¸¨ ¸» Rb Rh Fyc (Eq.6.10.8.2.2-2)
Fnc( FLB )
¸¨ ¸
«¬ © Rh Fyc ¹© Orf  O pf ¹»¼

in which:
: Slenderness ratio for the compression flange
: Limiting slenderness ratio for a noncompact flange
Rb : web load-shedding factor determined as specified in Article 6.10.1.10.2
Rh : hybrid factor determined as specified in Article 6.10.1.10.1

b fc AASHTO LRFD 12
Of (2.23) (Eq.6.10.8.2.2-3)
2t fc
E AASHTO LRFD 12
O pf 0.38 (2.24) (Eq.6.10.8.2.2-4)
Fyc

E AASHTO LRFD 12
Orf 0.56 (2.25) (Eq.6.10.8.2.2-5)
Fyr

Fyr : compression-flange stress at the onset of nominal yielding within the cross-section, including
residual stress effects, but not including compression-flange lateral bending, taken as the smaller
of 0.7Fyc and Fyw, but not less than 0.5Fyc .
Fnc(FLB)
[Table 2.17] Calculation of Fnc(LTB) AASHTO LRFD 12
(6.10.8.2.2)
Case Fnc( LTB)

Lb  Lp Fnc( LTB) Rb Rh Fyc AASHTO LRFD 12


(Eq.6.10.8.2.3-1)

ª § Fyr ·§ Lb  L p ·º
Lp  Lb d Lr Fnc( LTB ) Cb «1  ¨1 
¨
¸¨ ¸ R R F d Rb Rh Fyc
¸¨ L  L ¸» b h yc
AASHTO LRFD 12
¬« © Rh Fyc » (Eq.6.10.8.2.3-2)
¹© r p ¹¼

Lb ! Lr  Fnc( LTB) Fcr d Rb Rh Fyc AASHTO LRFD 12


(Eq.6.10.8.2.3-3)

Where,
Cb: Moment gradient modified

[Table 2.18] Calculation of Cb


Case Cb Calculation of Cb

Unbraced cantilevers and for members AASHTO LRFD 12


1.0 (Eq.6.10.8.2.3-6)
where fmid/f2 >1 or f2=0
2
§ f · § f ·
For all other cases 1.75  1.05¨¨ 1 ¸¸  0.3¨¨ 1 ¸¸ d 2.3 AASHTO LRFD 12
© f2 ¹ © f2 ¹ (Eq.6.10.8.2.3-7)

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 90


Where,
Lb : Unbraced length.
Lp : Limiting unbraced length to achieve the nominal flexural resistance of RbRhFyc under uniform
bending.

AASHTO LRFD 12
E (2.26) (Eq.6.10.8.2.3-4)
Lp 1.0rt
Fyc
AASHTO LRFD 12
E
Lr Srt (2.27) (Eq.6.10.8.2.3-5)
Fyr
Cb RbS 2 E (2.28)
AASHTO LRFD 12
Fcr (Eq.6.10.8.2.3-8)
( Lb / rt ) 2
AASHTO LRFD 12
1 Dc t w
rt b fc / 12(1  ) (2.29) (Eq.6.10.8.2.3-9)
3 b fc t fc

Lr : Limiting unbraced length to achieve the onset of nominal yielding in either flange under uniform
bending with consideration of compression flange residual stress effect (in).
F : Elastic lateral torsional buckling stress.
rt : effective radius of gyration for lateral torsional buckling
Fyr : compression-flange stress at the onset of nominal yielding within the cross-section, including
Dc : depth of the web in compression in the elastic range determined as per D6.3.1
fmid : Stress without consideration of lateral bending at the middle of the unbraced length of the flange
under consideration, calculated from the moment envelope value that produces the largest
compression at this point, or the smallest tension if this point is never in compression

2) Continuously braced Tension Flange


At the strength limit state, the following requirement shall be satisfied for the continuously Tension Flange
AASHTO LRFD 12
braced tension flange:
(6.10.8.1.3)
f bu d I f Rh Fyt (2.30) (Eq.6.10.8.1.3-1)

(4) Case 4 : Flexural resistance of Negative Flexure Moment by using Appendix A6


The optional provisions of Appendix A6 shall apply to the sections in negative flexural and
straight bridges and compact and noncompact web I-sections according to the flow chart
below.

91 Design Guide for midas Civil


Check flexure resistance of
Negative Flexure Moment by using Appendix A6
APPENDIX A6

Calculate
Yes 2 D cp No
d O pw ( D cp ) Web plastification Factor
: Compact web tw : Noncompact web

Mp ª § R h M yc ·§ O w  O pw ( Dc ) ·º M p Mp
R pc R pc «1  ¨¨1  ¸¨ ¸» d
M yc «¬ © Mp ¸¨ O  O ¸ » M yc M
¹© rw pw ( Dc ) ¹¼ yc

Mp ª § R h M yt ·§ O w  O pw ( Dc ) ·º M p Mp
R pt R pt «1  ¨¨1  ¸¨ ¸» d
M yt
«¬ © Mp ¸¨ O  O ¸ » M yt M yc
¹© rw pw ( Dc ) ¹¼

Discretely Braced
Compression Flange?
No
Yes :continuously
braced
Local Buckling Resistance
O f d ORf No
: Noncompact flange
Mu d I f RpcM yc
No Built-up
:Rolled section Section?
Yes Mu d I f RptM yt

Yes kc 4 / D / tw
: Compact flange kc 0.76
0.35d kc d 0.76

ª § Fyr S xc ·§ O f  Opf ·º
M nc( FLB) Rpc M yc M nc( FLB) «1  ¨¨1  ¸¨ ¸» RpcM yc
«¬ © RpcM yc ¸¹¨© Orf  Opf ¸¹»¼

Yes Lb d L p No L p  Lb d L r No

Yes

M nc( LTB) Rpc M yc ª § F S ·§ L  L ·º Mnc( LTB) Fcr Sxc d RpcM yc


Mnc( FLB) Cb «1 ¨1 yr xc ¸¨ b p ¸» RpcM yc d RpcM yc
¨ ¸¨ ¸
Lateral Torsional
«¬ © RpcM yc ¹© Lr  Lp ¹»¼
Buckling Resistance

M nc min>M nc FLB , M nc LTB @

Check Flexural Resistance


1
Mu  fl Sxc d I f M nc
3
f l d 0 . 6 F yc

End

[Fig.2.44] Case 4: Flow chart of flexural resistance of Negative Flexure Moment


by using Appendix A6.

If Appendix A6 is applied at the strength limit state, the following four requirements
regarding flexure shall be satisfied. The design verification is done for the compression and
tension flanges.

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 92


[Table 2.19] Limit State defined by Appendix A6

Case Limit State Limit State by A6


AASHTO LRFD 12
1
Compression Mu  f l S xc d I f M nc (A6.1.1-1)
Discretely-Braced 3
Flange Section AASHTO LRFD 12
1
Tension M u  f l S xt d I f M nt (A6.1.2-1)
3
AASHTO LRFD 12
Compression M u d I f R pc M yc (A6.1.3-1)
Continuously-Braced
Flange Section AASHTO LRFD 12
Tension M u d I f R pt M yt (A6.1.4-1)

Where,
ϕ : Resistance factor for flexure.
fl : Flange lateral bending stress, ≤ 0.6
Mnc : Nominal flexural resistance based on the compression flange.
Mu : Bending moment about the major-axis of the cross-section.
Myc : Yield moment with respect to the compression flange.
Mnt : Nominal flexural resistance based on the tension flange.
Myt : Yield moment with respect to the tension flange.
Sxc : Elastic section modulus about the major axis of the section to the compression flange taken as
Myc/Fyc
Rpc : Web plastification factor for the compression flange.
Rpt : Web plastification factor for the tension flange.

[Table 2.20] Calculation of Rpc and Rpt

Case Web Plastification Factor Rpc and Rpt


Mp AASHTO LRFD 12
2 Dcp R pc (A6.2.1-4)
d O pw ( Dcp ) Compact M yc
tw
web Mp AASHTO LRFD 12
R pt (A6.2.1-5)
M yt
2 Dcp « § Rh M yc ·§ Ow  O pw( Dc ) ·» M p Mp AASHTO LRFD 12
! O pw ( Dcp ) R pc «1  ¨¨1  ¸¨ ¸» d (A6.2.2-4)
tw Noncompact «¬ © M p ¸¹¨© Orw  O pw( Dc ) ¸¹»¼ M yc M yc
web « § Rh M yt ·§ Ow  O pw( Dc ) ·» M p M p AASHTO LRFD 12
& R pt «1  ¨¨1  ¸¨ ¸» d
M p ¸¹¨© Orw  O pw( Dc ) ¸¹»¼ M yt M yt
(A6.2.2-5)
Ow < Orw «¬ ©

in which:
Mp: Plastic moment
Dc : Depth of the web in compression in the elastic range determined as per D6.3.1.
Dcp : Depth of the web in compression in the plastic moment.
My : Yield moment taken as the smaller of Myc and Myt.

: Limiting slenderness ratio for a noncompact web


AASHTO LRFD 12
E (A6.2.2-3)
Orw 5.7 (2.31)
Fyc
λw : Slenderness ratio for the web based on the elastic moment.
2 Dc AASHTO LRFD 12
Ow (2.32)
(A6.2.2-2)
tw
( ): Limiting slenderness ratio for a compact web corresponding to 2D cp/tw

93 Design Guide for midas Civil


E ( )
Fyc § Dcp · (2.33) AASHTO LRFD 12
O pw( D ) 2
d Orw ¨¨ ¸¸ (A6.2.1-2)
§ · © Dc ¹
cp
Mp
¨ 0.54  0.09 ¸
¨ Rh M y ¸
© ¹

1) Discretely braced Compression Flange


For the discretely braced compression flanges, the minimum of the local buckling
resistance and lateral torsional buckling resistance is used to perform the design check
as:
M nc Min[ M nc( FLB ) , M nc( LTB) ]
(2.34)

Compression Flange
£ Local buckling Resistance (Mnc(FLB)) AASHTO LRFD 12
(A6.3.2)
The local buckling resistance shall be calculated as shown in the following table:

[Table 2.21] Calculate Mnc(FLB)

Case kc M nc( FLB )


AASHTO LRFD 12
O f d O pf (A6.3.2-1)
- M nc( FLB ) R pc M yc
(Compact flange)

Rolled kc 0.76 M nc( FLB )


O f ! O pf AASHTO LRFD 12
D ª § Fyr S xc ·§ O f  O pf ·º
«1  ¨¨1  ¸¨ ¸ R M
(Noncompact kc 4/ (A6.3.2-2)
flange) Built-up tw ¸¨ O  O ¸»» pc yc
¬« © R pc M yc ¹© rf pf ¹¼
0.35 d k c d 0.76
Where,
: Slenderness ratio for the compression flange.
AASHTO LRFD 12
b fc (A6.3.2-3)
Of (2.35)
2t fc
: Limiting slenderness ratio for a compact flange.
AASHTO LRFD 12
E (A6.3.2-4)
O pf 0.38 (2.36)
Fyc
: Limiting slenderness ratio for a noncompact flange. AASHTO LRFD 12
(A6.3.2-5)
Ek c
Orf 0.95 (2.37)
Fyr
: Flange local buckling coefficient determined as per A6.3.2-6 for built-up sections and 0.76
for rolled shapes.
Fyr : compression-flange stress at the onset of nominal yielding within the cross-section,
including residual stress effects, but not including compression-flange lateral bending, taken as
the smaller of 0.7Fyc, RhFyt Sxt/Sxc and Fyw, but not less than 0.5Fyc
Sxc : Elastic section modulus about the major axis of the section to the compression flange
taken as Myc/Fyc
Sxt : Elastic section modulus about the major axis of the section to the tension flange taken as
Myt/Fyt
Mnc(LTB)
¤ Lateral Torsional Buckling Resistance (M nc(LTB)) AASHTO LRFD 12
(A6.3.3)
The lateral torsional buckling resistance is calculated as shown in the following table:

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 94


[Table 2.22] Calculation of M ( )

Case M nc( LTB ) ( )


AASHTO LRFD 12
Lb d L p M nc( LTB) R pc M yc (A6.3.3-1)

AASHTO LRFD 12
ª § Fyr S xc ·§ Lb  L p ·º (A6.3.3-2)
L p  Lb d Lr M nc( LTB) C b «1  ¨1  ¸¨ ¸» R pc M yc d R pc M yc
«¬ ¨© R pc M yc ¸¹¨© Lr  L p ¸¹»¼ AASHTO LRFD 12
(A6.3.3-3)
Lb ! Lr  M nc( LTB) Fcr S sc d R pc M yc

Where,
Lp : Limiting unbraced length to achieve the nominal flexure resistance RpcMyc under uniform
bending
Lp
AASHTO LRFD 12
(A6.3.3-4)
Lp 1.0rt
E (2.38)
Fyc

Lr : Limiting unbraced length to achieve the nominal onset of yielding in either flange under uniform
bending with consideration of compression flange residual stress effects Lr
AASHTO LRFD 12
2 (A6.3.3-5)
E J § Fyr S xc h · (2.39)
Lr 1.95rt 1  1  6.76¨¨ ¸¸
Fyr S xc h © E J ¹

▪ Cb: moment gradient modifier, is divided into two cases and calculated according to
either A6.3.3-6 or A6.3.3.3-7 of AASHTO LRFD 12. For the detailed calculations, please
refer to the section "3.2 Strength Limit State > (1) Flexural Resistance > Case 3".

▪ Fcr : Elastic lateral torsional buckling stress Fcr


2 AASHTO LRFD 12
CbS E 2
J § Lb · (2.40) (A6.3.3-8)
Fcr 1  0.078 ¨ ¸¸
§ Lb ·
2
S xc h ¨© rt ¹
¨¨ ¸¸
© rt ¹

▪J: St. Venant torsional constant J


3 3 3 AASHTO LRFD 12
Dtw b fc t fc t fc b ft t ft t ft (2.41)
J  (1  0.63 ) (1  0.63 ) (A6.3.3-9)
3 3 b fc 3 b ft

rt
▪ rt : Effective radius of gyration for lateral torsional buckling AASHTO LRFD 12
§ 1 Dctw · (2.42) (A6.3.3-10)
rt b fc / 12¨1  ¸
¨ 3b t ¸
© fc fc ¹

Where,
: compression-flange stress at the onset of nominal yielding within the cross-section, including
residual stress effects, but not including compression-flange lateral bending, taken as the smaller
of 0.7 , , / and , but not less than 0.5 .
h : Depth between the centerline of the flanges.
: Major-axis bending moment at the middle of the unbraced length, calculated from the
moment envelop value that produces the largest compression at this point in the flange under
consideration, or the smallest tension if this point is never in compression. shall be due to
the factored loads and shall be taken as positive when it causes compression and negative when it
causes tension in the flange under consideration.
: moment at the brace point opposite to the one corresponding to , calculated from the
moment envelope value that produces the largest compression at this point in the flange under
consideration, or the smallest tension if this point is never in compression(kip-in). M0 shall be

95 Design Guide for midas Civil


due to the factored loads and shall be taken as positive when it causes compression and negative
when it cause tension in the flange under consideration.
: moment at the brace point opposite to the one corresponding to , calculated as the
intercept of the most critical assumed linear moment variation passing through and either
or , whichever produces the smaller value of . may be calculated as follows
- When the variation in the moment along the entire length between the brace points is AASHTO LRFD 12
concave in shape (A6.3.3-11)

M1 M0 (2.43) AASHTO LRFD 12


(A6.3.3-12)
- Otherwise
M1 2M mid  M 2 t M 0 (2.44)

: Except as noted below, largest major-axis bending moment st either end of the unbraced
length causing comrpession int the flange under consideration, calculated from the ciritical
moment envelop value. shall be taken as positive. If the moment is zero or cause tension in
the flange under consideration at both ends if the unbraced length, shall be taken as zero.
: Yield moment with respect to the compression flange.
: Yield moment with respect to the tension flange.

1.2.3 Shear resistance


Shear resistance of an I-web Steel Composite Section is checked as shown in the flow chart Shear resistance
below. AASHTO LRFD 12
(6.10.9)
Check shear resistance
6.10.9

Stiffened
No Yes
web?

Unstiffened webs Stiffened Web Panels


6.10.9.2 6.10.9.3
Interior
Web Panel? Yes
No :Stiffened
:Stiffened Interior
End panel
Web Panels

Calculate V n Calculate V n
2Dtw
Vn V cr CV p Vn V cr CV p b t  bfttft
fc fc
d 2.5

Vp 0 . 58 F yw Dt w Vp 0 . 58 F yw Dt w No Yes

6.10.9.2-1 6.10.9.3.3-1
6.10.9.2-2 6.10.9.3.3-2

Calculate V n Calculate V n

ª º ª º
« » « »
« 0 . 87 (1  C ) » « 0 . 87 (1  C ) »
Vn V p «C  » Vn V p «C 
2 »
2
« § d ·
 0 »
d « §d ·
«¬
1 ¨ 0 ¸
D »¼ « 1  ¨ 0 ¸ »»
© D ¹ © D ¹ ¼
¬
6.10.9.3.2-8 6.10.9.3.2-2

Check V n
Vu d IV V n
6.10.9.1-1

End

[Fig.2.45] Flow chart of shear resistance

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 96


The program distinguishes Unstiffened and Stiffened webs according to the following criteria:
[Table 2.23] Classification of Unstiffened web and Stiffened Web
Case Classification

Without a longitudinal stiffener and with transverse stiffener


spacing not exceeding 3D
Stiffened web
With one or more longitudinal stiffeners and with a transverse
stiffener spacing not exceeding 1.5D

Otherwise Unstiffened web


However, even stiffened webs are classified as unstiffened web if the check box is not
checked at ೛Composite Steel Girder Design Parameters >Options for Strength Limit
State>Post-buckling Tension-field Action for Shear Resistance. (Fig.2.41)

(1) Shear Resistance Check


Shear resistance shall be checked as:
Vu d IvVn Shear resistance
(2.45) AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq. 6.10.9.1-1)
Where,
: Resistance factor for shear.
Vn : Nominal shear resistance.
Vu : Shear in the web at the section under consideration due to the factored loads

1) Unstiffened Webs
The nominal shear resistance of unstiffened webs shall be taken as: Unstiffened Webs
AASHTO LRFD 12
(6.10.9.2)
Vn Vcr CV p (2.46)
AASHTO LRFD 12
Vp 0.58Fyw Dtw (Eq. 6.10.9.2-1)
(2.47) (Eq. 6.10.9.2-2)

Where,
V : Shear -buckling resistance
V : plastic shear force
C : Ratio of shear-buckling resistance to shear yield strength

[Table2.24] Calculation of Ratio of shear-buckling resistance to shear yield strength, C


Case C
D Ek C
d 1.12 C 1.0 AASHTO LRFD 12
tw Fyw (Eq. 6.10.9.3.2-4)

1.12 Ek
Ek D Ek C
1.12  d 1.40 D Fyw
Fyw t w Fyw AASHTO LRFD 12
tw (Eq. 6.10.9.3.2-5)
1.57 §¨ Ek ·¸
Ek D C 2 ¨
 ¸
1.40 § D · © Fyw ¹ AASHTO LRFD 12
Fyw t w ¨¨ ¸¸ (Eq. 6.10.9.3.2-6)
© tw ¹
Where,
k : Shear-buckling coefficient
5 (2.48) AASHTO LRFD 12
k 5 2 (Eq. 6.10.9.3.2-7)
§ do ·
¨ ¸
©D¹

97 Design Guide for midas Civil


 Stiffened Webs Stiffened Webs
The nominal shear resistance is calculated differently for the two types of stiffened webs: AASHTO LRFD 12
interior web panels and end web panels. All webs with a support assigned on its i or j node (6.10.9.3)
in the Span Information (Fig.2.22) are considered as end panels and the others are
considered as interior web panels.

[Fig.2.46] Classification of End Panel and Interior Panel

£ End panels
End panels
The nominal shear resistance, Vn, of a web end panel shall be taken as: AASHTO LRFD 12
Vn Vcr CV p (2.49) (6.10.9.3.3)
AASHTO LRFD 12
Vp 0.58Fyw Dtw (Eq. 6.10.9.3.3-1)
(2.50) (Eq. 6.10.9.3.3-2)



Interior web panel
¤ Interior web panels AASHTO LRFD 12
(6.10.9.3.2)
There are two cases of an interior web panel as shown in the following table:

[Table 2.25] Calculation of Vn and Vp of Interior web panel


Case Vn , V p

ª º
« »
« 0.87(1  C ) » AASHTO LRFD 12
Vn V p «C 
2 Dtw 2 » (Eq.6.10.9.3.2-2)
d 2.5 « § do · »
1 ¨ ¸
(b fct fc  b ft t ft ) «¬ © D ¹ »¼

Vp 0.58Fyw Dtw

ª º
« »
« 0.87(1  C ) »
Vn V p «C  » AASHTO LRFD 12
2
« §d · d » (Eq.6.10.9.3.2-8)
Otherwise 1 ¨ o ¸  o
« ©D¹ »
¬ D ¼
Vp 0.58Fyw Dtw

Where,
: Transverse stiffener spacing
: Nominal shear resistance of the panel

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 98


User's option
¥ User's option AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.9.3.2-2)
Users need to specify that the web is stiffened by checking the check box at:
೛Composite Steel Girder Design Parameters >Options for Strength Limit State >'Post-
buckling Tension - Field Action for Shear Resistance (6.10.9.3.2)'. Depending on the
user's verification, the calculation will differ as shown in the following table:

[Table 2.26] User's option: Post-buckling Tension-field Action for Shear Resistance
AASHTO LRFD 12
Check Vn , V p (Eq.6.10.9.3.2-8)

ª º
« »
« 0.87(1  C ) »
Vn V p «C  6.10.9.3.2-2
2 Dtw 2 »
d 2.5 « §d ·
1 ¨ o ¸ »
(b fct fc  b ft t ft ) «¬ © D ¹ »¼

Vp 0.58Fyw Dtw 6.10.9.3.2-3


On
ª º
« »
« 0.87(1  C ) »
Vn V p «C  6.10.9.3.2-8
2 »
Otherwise « § do · »
1 ¨ ¸
«¬ © D ¹ »¼

Vp 0.58Fyw Dtw 6.10.9.3.2-3

Vn Vcr CV p
Off
Vp 0.58Fyw Dtw

Service Limit State


1.3 Service Limit State AASHTO LRFD 12
Flange stress for permanent deformation and web bend-buckling are verified at the service limit (6.10.4.2)
state.

The program does not check elastic deformation. Elastic deformation can be reviewed manually
after moving load analysis at: ೛ Results > Deformation

At the completion stage of the construction, the program applies Service II load combination,
specified in AASHTO LRFD 12 Article 6.10.4.2, and reviews the permanent deformation. Therefore,
the permanent deformation is reviewed only for the composite section since the section cannot
be non-composite in the completed state. But, the software can assume the concrete deck in the
composite section to be ineffective as per 6.10.4.2.1, which states that the concrete deck may be
assumed to be ineffective for both positive and negative flexure, provided that the maximum
tensile stresses in concrete deck at the section under consideration caused by Service II loads are
greater than 2fr. Software performs this check and determines whether to consider the concrete
deck to be effective or not.

99 Design Guide for midas Civil


The service limit state is reviewed as shown in the flow chart follows:
Service Limit State
6.10.4

Check Flexure Yield in flange


6.10.4.2

Check Top flange of Composite Section

f f d 0 .95 R h F yf
6.10.4.2.2-1

Check Bottom flange of Composite Section


fl
f f  d 0 . 95 R h F yf
2
6.10.4.2.2-2

Check Nominal Bend-buckling Resistance for web


6.10.4.2

D
Positive Flexure and d 150 ?
tw

No

Check Web Bend-buckling resistance for webs


f c d Fcrw
Yes
6.10.4.2.2-4

End

[Fig.2.47] Flow chart of Service Limit State

1.3.1 Flexure
Flange shall satisfy the following requirements at the service limit state for the top and
bottom flanges of the composite sections:

(1) Top Flange


Top Flange
The top steel flange of composite section shall satisfy the following requirement.
AASHTO LRFD 12
f f d 0.95Rh Fyf (2.51) (Eq.6.10.4.2.2-1)

(2) Bottom Flange


The bottom steel flange of composite section shall satisfy the following requirement. Bottom Flange
f AASHTO LRFD 12
f f  l d 0.95Rh Fyf (2.52) (Eq.6.10.4.2.2-2)
2
Where,
: Flange stress at the section under consideration due to the Service II loads calculated without
consideration of flange lateral bending
: Flange lateral bending stress at the section under consideration due to the Service II loads
determined, ≤ 0.6
:specified minimum yield strength of a flange

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 100


1.3.2 Nominal Bend-buckling Resistance for webs
Nominal Bend-
If composite section is in positive flexure and the web section property satisfies D/tw≤ 150, buckling Resistance
use the service limit state shall be verified according to: AASHTO LRFD 12
f c d Fcrw (2.53) (Eq.6.10.4.2.2-4)

Where,
: Compression-flange stress at the section under consideration due to the Service II loads calculated
without consideration of flange lateral bending
Fcrw : Nominal bending-buckling resistance for webs with or without longitudinal stiffeners

(2.54) Fcrw
0.9 Ek
Fcrw 2
d Min ( Rh Fyc , Fyw / 0.7) AASHTO LRFD 12
§D· (Eq.6.10.1.9.1-1)
¨¨ ¸¸
© tw ¹
Where,
k : bend- buckling coefficient k
9 (2.55) AASHTO LRFD 12
k (Eq.6.10.1.9.1-2)
( Dc / D) 2

1.3.3 Concrete Deck


The program verifies the stress of the concrete deck for shored construction cases in positive
flexure as per Article 6.10.1.7.

f deck d Mf r (2.56)
Where,
fdeck : longitudinal flexure stresses in the concrete deck with short-term modular ratio,n
Φfr : Φ shall be taken as 0.9 and fr shall be taken as the modulus of rupture of the concrete, 0.24 ČfĜc as
per Article 6.10.1.7

1.4 Check Constructibility


Constructibility shall be verified for the three categories as shown in the following chart:

Check Contructibility
6.10.3

Check flexural resistance


6.10.3.2.1 , 6.10.3.2.2

Check longitudinal stresses In concrete deck


6.10.3.2.4

Check Shear requirement for webs


6.10.3.4

[Fig.2.48] Flow chart of Constructibility limit stage

The constructibility is checked based on the design member forces under Dead (Before).

1.4.1 Flexure
The program shall verify lateral bending stress in discretely braced compression and tension
flanges during the construction stages, for when slabs are not deflected yet. Therefore, the
program considers all flanges as discretely braced flanges for the design check. Constructibility
is verified in terms of flexural resistance according to the following flow chart:

101 Design Guide for midas Civil


[Fig.2.49] Flow chart of flexural resistance in Constructibility Limit State

(1) Section classification


[Table 2.27] Section classification

Case Section Section classification


AASHTO LRFD 12
(6.10.6.2.3-1)
2 Dc E
d 5.7 Compact or non-compact Web
tw Fyc
2 Dc E
! 5.7 Slender Web
tw Fyc

(2) Discretely braced flanges in Compression


in compression
Discretely braced flanges in compression are verified according to the following three AASHTO LRFD 12
equations. (6.10.3.2.1)

 Check flange nominal flexure yielding


For the critical stages of construction, the following equation shall be satisfied. However,
the requirement does not need to be checked if a section has slender web and its f l is
equal to 0.

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 102


nominal yielding
f f  f l d I f Rh Fyc (2.57) AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.3.2.1-1)

 Check local buckling and lateral torsional buckling as per Article 6.10.8.2.2 and Article
6.10.8.2.3 respectively
1 flexural resistance
ff  f l d I f Fnc (2.58) AASHTO LRFD 12
3 (Eq.6.10.3.2.1-2)


 Check web bend buckling as per Article 6.10.1.9
Only for the sections with slender webs, the following equation shall be checked.
web bend buckling
f bu d I f Fcrw (2.59) AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.3.2.1-3)
Where,
ϕf: resistance factor for flexure specified in 6.5.4.2
f : flange stress calculated without consideration of flange lateral bending.
: flange lateral bending stress, ≤ 0.6
: nominal bending-buckling resistance for webs.
: nominal flexure resistance of the flange.

(3) Discretely braced flanges in Tension in Tension


The following equation shall be checked for discretely braced tension flanges. AASHTO LRFD 12
(6.10.3.2.2)
f f  f l d I f Rh Fyt (2.60) AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.3.2.2-1)

1.4.2 Concrete Deck


If the longitudinal tensile stress in concrete deck determined as per Article 6.10.1.1.1d, exceeds Concrete Deck
AASHTO LRFD 12
Żffr then the minimum one percent longitudinal reinforcement determined as per Article (6.10.3.2.4)
6.10.1.7 is required at the section. Code recommends that the minimum reinforcement should
be No. 6 bars or smaller spaced at not more than 12 inches.

The total tensile force in the concrete deck is transmitted from the deck through the shear
connectors to the top flange. Software assumes the shear connectors to be sufficiently present
at this location to resist the force and prevent potential crushing of concrete. Software doesn’t
calculate the length over which this force must be transmitted. Shear connector pitch
calculations are as per Fatigue and Strength Limit State only.

Fdeck d If r (2.61)

Where,
fr 0.24 f 'c modulus of rupture of the normal-weight concrete
ϕ : 0.9
Fdeck: Longitudinal tensile stress in the concrete deck

My
Fdeck (2.62) AASHTO LRFD 12
In (Eq. 6.10.1.1.1d)

Where,
= Es /Ec

103 Design Guide for midas Civil


1.4.3 Shear
The program shall use the load combinations defined in the Load Combination Type (Refer to
Section 1.4.2 in this chapter) for the verification of the shear strength. Webs shall satisfy the
following requirement during critical stages of construction.
Vu d IvVcr (2.63) AASHTO LRFD 12
Where, (Eq. 6.10.3.3-1)
: shear in the web at the section under consideration due to the factored loads
ϕv: resistance factor for shear, ∅ = . (Fig.2.41)
: shear buckling resistance determined from Eq. 6.10.9.3.3-1

The program checks the nominal resistance for unstiffened webs and stiffened webs with the
same formula as the tension field action is not considered for Constructibility check.
(1) Unstiffened/Stiffened web
1) The nominal shear resistance of unstiffened/stiffened webs shall be taken as: Unstiffened/
Vn Vcr CV p (2.64) Stiffened web
AASHTO LRFD 12
Vp 0.58Fyw Dtw (2.65) (Eq. 6.10.9.3.3-1)
(Eq. 6.10.9.3.3-2)

2) Calculation of Ratio of shear-buckling resistance to shear yield strength, C


Please refer to Section 1.2.2 in this chapter for the calculation of C.

1.5 Fatigue Limit State Fatigue Limit State


For horizontally curved I-girder bridges, the range of fatigue stress due to major-axis bending AASHTO LRFD 12
plus lateral bending shall be investigated. Article 6.10.5 also mentions the requirements for (6.10.5)
Fracture. But Fracture Limit State is not considered in midas Civil. Code specifies the fatigue live
load in Article 3.6.1.4 for the Fatigue check. But in the software, fatigue check is performed only
for the moving load defined for the analysis.

For considering the fatigue live load as specified in code, user will have to define a user defined
vehicle and then manually edit the auto generated load combinations, so that the fatigue moving
vehicle is the only vehicle considered for fatigue check and is only included in fatigue
combination.

For fatigue limit state, software assumes the shear connector to be provided along the entire
length of the girder, ensuring composite action. Therefore, the concrete deck is assumed to be
effective in computing all stresses and stress ranges applied to the composite section in the
subsequent fatigue calculations.

1.5.1 Load Combinations Used for Fatigue Limit State Check


For this part of design check, AASHTO LRFD 07 and 12 are applied differently in the program.
Please refer to Section 5.1 in this chapter for more information. Fatigue limit shall be verified
according to the two paths. Fatigue limit shall be verified according to Section 1.5.3(1) for the
load combinations that are inputted as Fatigue 1 Limit State Load Combination Type (Section
1.4.2 in Chapter "Modeling and Design Variables"). For the load combinations that are inputted
as Fatigue 2 Limit State, Section 1.5.3(2) shall be followed.

The program verifies the load combinations defined in the Load Combination Type. If users
define '(ADTT)SL ˜ 75 year (ADDTT)SL' Equivalent to Infinite Life, the verification shall consider
the Fatigue II Load Combination. Otherwise, this combination of fatigue limit state shall be
skipped and Fatigue I Load Combination shall be considered for verification.

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 104


[Fig.2.50] Flow chart of Fatigue Limit Stage

1.5.2 Fatigue Limit State


For the compression flange, compressive stress due to unfactored dead load is compared with
the tensile stress due to factored live load before performing the fatigue check. If two times
the tensile stress due to factored live load is greater than the compressive stress due to
unfactored dead load, then only the fatigue check is performed.

For the tension flange, fatigue check is always performed.

(1) The fatigue limit state shall be verified according to the following.
Fatigue Limit State
J ('f ) d ('F )n (2.68) AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.6.1.2.2-1)

Where,
: Load factor for the fatigue load combination.
( ) : Force effect, live load stress range due to the passage of the fatigue load.
( ) : Nominal fatigue resistance.

(2) The load factor, , specified in the table below, shall be applied for the fatigue load
combination. These factors are automatically considered by the software, while auto
generating the load combinations.

[Table 2.28] Load combination and Load Factor


Load Factor
Load Combination DC, DD, DW, EH, EV, LL, IM, CE, AASHTO LRFD 12
WA WS WL
Limit State ES, EL, PS, CR, SH BR,PL, LS (Table. 3.4.1-1)
Fatigue I -
- 1.50 - - -
LL, IM &CE only
Fatigue II -
- 0.75 - - -
LL, IM &CE only

1.5.3 Nominal Fatigue Resistance


The nominal fatigue resistance is calculated differently for the load combinations in the
Service 1 Limit State and the Service 2 Limit State.

105 Design Guide for midas Civil


(1) Nominal Fatigue Resistance Due to the Load Combinations for Fatigue I Limit State
The program shall calculate the nominal fatigue resistance according to the input categories
made in the fatigue dialog box (Fig.2.22).

Nominal fatigue
('F ) n ('F )TH (2.69)
resistance
AASHTO LRFD 12
The program shall apply the nominal fatigue resistance according to Categories A, B, B', C, C', (Eq.6.6.1.2.5-1)
D, E, and E', specified in the table below. For all other cases, the nominal fatigue resistance
shall be considered as 24.0 ksi (165.0 MPa).

[Table 2.29] Constant-Amplitude Fatigue Thresholds, (ΔF)


Detail Threshold
Fatigue Thresholds
Category US Unit(ksi) SI Unit(MPa) For US Unit,
AASHTO LRFD 12
A 24.0 165.0 (Table. 6.6.1.2.5-3)
B 16.0 110.0
For SI Unit
B' 12.0 82.7 AASHTO LRFD 07
C 10.0 69.0 (Table. 6.6.1.2.5-3)

C' 12.0 82.7


D 7.0 48.3
E 4.5 31.0
E' 2.6 17.9

(2) Nominal Fatigue Resistance due to the Load Combinations for Fatigue II Limit State
If Fatigue Resistance is verified for Fatigue Load Combination 2, the below equation shall be
used. For the verification, the program uses the design parameter values inputted by users in
the Fatigue dialog box (Fig.2.22).

1
§ A ·3 Fatigue ้
('F )n ¨ ¸ (2.70) AASHTO LRFD 12
©N¹ (Eq.6.6.1.2.5-2)

N (365)(75)n( ADTT ) SL (2.71) AASHTO LRFD 12


(Eq.6.6.1.2.5-3)

Where,
A : Constant taken from Table 2.30
n : Number of stress range cycles per truck passage taken from Table 2.31

[Table 2.30] Detail Category Constant, A


A
Detail Constant, A
For US Unit,
Category US Unit (x 108 (ksi3)) ! SI Unit (x1011 (MPa3)) AASHTO LRFD 12
(Table. 6.6.1.2.5-1)
A 250.0 82.0
B 120.0 39.3 For SI Unit
AASHTO LRFD 07
B' 61.0 20.0 (Table. 6.6.1.2.5-1)
C 44.0 14.4
C' 44.0 14.4
D 22.0 7.21
E 11.0 3.61
E' 3.9 1.28

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 106


[Table 2.31] Cycles per Truck Passage, n
Cycles per
Span Length Truck Passage
Longitudinal Members
>40.0 ft ≤40.0 ft AASHTO LRFD 12
(Table. 6.6.1.2.5-2)
Simple span Girders 1.0 2.0
Continuous Near interior support 1.5 2.0
Girders Elsewhere 1.0 2.0
Cantilever Girders 5.0
Orthotropic Deck plate Connections
5.0
Subjected to Wheel Load Cycling
Trusses 1.0
Spacing
Transverse Members > 20.0 ft ≤20.0 ft
1.0 2.0
The n value inputted in the Fatigue Parameter dialog box (Fig.2.22) according to Table 2.31 is
used for the calculation.
Where,
(ADTT)SL : ADTT for single lane

1.5.4 Special Fatigue Requirement for Webs for Webs


AASHTO LRFD 12
The fatigue limit state shall be verified in terms of shear buckling resistance as: (6.10.5.3)

Vu d Vcr (2.72) AASHTO LRFD 12


Where, (Eq.6.10.5.3-1)

Vu : shear in the web at the section under consideration due to the unfactored permanent loads plus the
factored fatigue load

Vcr CV p (2.73) AASHTO LRFD 12


(Eq.6.10.9.3.3-1)
Vp 0.58Fyw Dtw AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.9.3.3-2)
(2.74)

107 Design Guide for midas Civil


2. Box / Tub Girder Section Box/tub

2.1 Introduction
Design of Box/Tub steel composite sections follow the same procedure as for I-Girders.

2.2 Strength Limit State


The program checks the strength limit states for the flexure, shear and ductility of the composite
sections.

Strength Limit States


6.11.6

Check Ductility
6.10.7.3

Check flexural resistance


6.11.7 & 6.11.8

Check shear resistance


6.10.9 & 6.11.9

[Fig.2.51] Flow Chart of Strength Limit State

2.2.1 Ductility
Ductility shall be checked to prevent premature crushing of concrete. If a section is under
positive flexure, ductility shall be verified as:
Ductility
DP d 0.42 Dt (2.75) AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.7.3-1)

2.2.2 Flexure
(1) Classification of Composite Section for Flexure
There are four cases for checking flexural resistance of Box/Tub composite sections as shown
below.

Check flexural resistance


6.11.7 & 6.11.8

Yes Positive Moment ? No

Straight Compression
Bridge? flange?
Yes No
:Curved
Bridge
Yes No
Compact :Tension
No ΗΝΒΟΘΖ
Section?

Yes

Case 1 : Case 2 : Case 3 : Case 4 :


Check flexural resistance of Check flexural resistance of Check flexural resistance of Check flexural resistance of
Positive Flexure Moment in Positive Flexure Moment in Negative Flexure Moment Negative Flexure Moment
Compact Section Noncompact Section & Compression flange & Tension flange
6.11.7.1 6.11.7.2 6.11.8.2 6.11.8.3

Positive Flexure Moment Negative Flexure Moment

End

[Fig.2.52] Strength Limit State for Flexure

The webs that are under positive flexure and satisfy the following requirements shall be

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 108


considered as compact sections. Otherwise, they shall be considered as non-compact sections for
the positive flexure design check. Sections of a curved bridge are considered to be non-compact.

▪ Flange and web yield strength do not exceed 70 ksi (485 MPa)
▪Web satisfies the requirements in Article 6.11.2.1 as shown below. AASHTO LRFD 12
(6.11.6.2.2)
Webs without longitudinal stiffeners: D/tw ˜ 150
Webs with longitudinal stiffeners: D/tw ˜ 300
▪ Web slenderness limit satisfies the requirements in Article 6.11.6.2.2-1
2Dcp/tw ≤ 3.76√(E/Fyc)

The classification of the section under negative flexure, as compact /noncompact /slender is not
required for the design checks.

(2) Case 1 : Positive Flexural Moment in Compact Section

Case 1 : Check flexural resistance of


Positive Flexure Moment in Compact Section
6.11.7.1

Yes Dp d 0.1Dt No

Calculate Mn Calculate Mn
§ D ·
Mn M p ¨¨1.07  0.7 p ¸¸ Mn Mp
© Dt ¹
6.10.7.1.2-2 6.10.7.1.2-1 Case 1
AASHTO LRFD 12
Check Flexural Resistance (6.11.7.1)

Mu d I f M n
6.10.7.1.1-1

End

[Fig.2.53] Case 1 : Flow Chart of Flexural resistance for Compact Section in Positive Flexure Moment

For compact sections, flexure at the strength limit state shall be verified as:

Mu d I f M n (2.76)
AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.11.7.1.1-1)
Where,
1) Bending moment about the major-axis( Mu)
Mu is the bending moment about the major axis due to the factored loads. The maximum
bending moment from the load combinations, applied to Strength Limit State in the Load
Combination Type (Refer to Chapter "Modeling Design Variable" Section 1.4.2) is applied
as Mu.

2) Nominal flexure resistance(Mn)


[Table 2.32] Calculation of Mn of Compact Section in Positive Flexure
Case Mn
Mn
D p d 0.1Dt Mn Mp AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.11.7.1.2-1)

109 Design Guide for midas Civil


AASHTO LRFD 12
§ Dp · (Eq.6.11.7.1.2-2)
Otherwise Mn M p ¨¨1.07  0.7 ¸¸
© Dt ¹

If a section is under positive flexure, plastic moment is calculated for the location of the
plastic neutral axis. For more information, please refer to Chapter "Introduction" Section
3.2.
Flexural resistance
3) If factor
AASHTO LRFD 12
Flexural resistance factor are taken as 1.00 in AASHTO LRFD 12. However, if the factor is (6.5.4.2)
defined by users in the design parameter dialog box, the user defined value is utilized as a
priority.
Case 2
AASHTO LRFD 12
(3) Case 2 : Non-compact Section in Positive Moment (6.11.7.2)
For non-compact sections, flexural strength limit state is verified as shown in the flow chart
follows. Webs of a curved bridge is considered to be non-compact sections.

Case2 : Check flexural resistance of


Positive Flexure Moment in Noncompact Section
6.11.7.2

Compression
Yes
flange? No
:Tension flange

Tub Section? No
Yes
:Box Section

Calculate Fnc Calculate Fnc Calculate Fnt


Fnc Fb Rh Fyc Fnc Fb Rh Fyc ' Fnt Rh Fyt '
6.11.7.2.2-1 6.11.7.2.2-2 6.11.7.2.1-5

Check Flexural Resistance Check Flexural Resistance


f bu d I f Fnc f bu d I f Fnt
6.11.7.2.1-1 6.11.7.2.1-2

End

[Fig.2.54] Case 2 : Flow Chart of Flexural Resistance for Non-compact Section in Positive Flexure
Moment

1) Compression Flange
At the strength limit state, compression flanges shall satisfy the following in terms of Compression Flange
flexure. AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.11.7.2.1-1)
f bu d I f Fnc (2.77)
The nominal flexural resistance of the compression flange, Fnc, is taken differently for box
and tub sections as:

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 110


[Table 2.33] Calculation of Fnc Fnc
AASHTO LRFD 12
Section Type Fnc (Eq.6.11.7.2.2-2)

Box Fnc Fb Rh Fyc ' AASHTO LRFD 12


(Eq.6.11.7.2.2-1)
Tub Fnc Fb Rh Fyc

∆ and fv
AASHTO LRFD 12
Where, (Eq.6.11.7.2.2-3)
2 (Eq.6.11.7.2.2-4)
§ f · T (2.78)
' 1  3¨ v ¸ fv
¨F ¸ in which : 2 Aot fc
© yc ¹

Δ : a factor dependent on St. Venant torsional shear stress in the bottom flange od the tub section.
Rb : Web load shedding factor

[Table 2.34] Calculation of Rb


Case Rb

Constructibility Limit State is reviewed


Rb
AASHTO LRFD 12
Composite web under positive flexure (Eq.6.10.1.10.2)
satisfies Article 6.10.2.1.1&6.11.2.1.2

One or more longitudinal stiffener & 1.0

D Ek
d 0.95
tw Fyc

2 Dc
d Orw
tw AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.1.10.2-3)
§ awc ·§ 2 DC ·
Otherwise, Rb 1  ¨¨ ¸¸¨¨  Orw ¸¸ d 1.0
© 1200  300awc ¹© tw ¹

Rh : Hybrid Factor

Hybrid Factor, Rh
[Table 2.35] Calculation of Rh AASHTO LRFD 12
(6.10.1.10.1)
Case Rh

12  E (3U  U 3 ) 2 Dntw
Hybrid Section Rh E
12  2E in which: Afn

Non-Hybrid or
1.0
Web strength > flange strength

111 Design Guide for midas Civil


2) Tension Flange
At the strength limit state, tension flanges shall satisfy: Tension Flange
fbu d I f Fnt (2.79) AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.11.7.2.1-2)

For both box and tub type composite sections, the nominal flexure resistance of tension
flange, Fnt shall be calculated as:
Fnt Rh Fyt ' (2.80) AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.11.7.2.1-5)

Where,
2 AASHTO LRFD 12
§ f ·
1  3¨ v ¸ T (Eq.6.11.7.2.2-6)
' fv (2.81)
¨F ¸ 2 Ao t ft (Eq.6.11.7.2.2-7)
© yt ¹ in which :

If 1 − 3 < 0, consider ∆= 0 so that =0

(4) Case 3&Case 4 : Negative Flexure Case 3 and 4


Flexural resistance of negative flexure moment shall be verified as shown in the flow chart AASHTO LRFD 12
(6.11.7.2)
below. (6.11.8.2)
(6.11.8.3)
Check flexural resistance of Negative Flexure Moment
6.11.7.2 & 6.11.8.2 & 6.11.8.3

Compression No
Yes
flange? :Tension flange

No No
Yes Stiffened web? Tub Section? :Closed-Box
:Unstiffened Web Yes Section

Check flexural resistance Check flexural resistance Check flexural resistance Check flexural resistance
Of Longitudinal of Unsiffened Flange of Tension Flange of Tension Flange
Stiffened Flange of Tub Section Closed-box

6.11.8.2.2-1 6.11.8.2.2-1 6.11.8.3-1 6.11.7.2.2-5

Compression flange Tension flange


End

[Fig.2.55] Case 3 & Case 4 : Flow Chart of Flexural Resistance for Negative Flexural Moment

(5) Case 3 : Compression Flange in Negative Flexural Moment


For this part of design check, AASHTO LRFD 07 and 12 are applied differently in the program.
Please refer to Section 5.4 in this chapter for more information.

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 112


AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.11.8.1.1-1)

[Fig.2.56] Case 3 : Flow Chart of Flexural Resistance for Compression Flange in Negative Flexure

The program shall distinguish unstiffened and longitudinally stiffened elements depending on
whether the longitudinal stiffener is applied on the compression flanges in the section
property dialog box. At the strength limit state, the following requirement shall be satisfied
in terms of flexure: Unstiffened Flange
AASHTO LRFD 12
fbu d I f Fnc (2.82)
(Eq.6.11.8.2.2-1)

1) Unstiffened Flange
For unstiffened flanges, the following requirement shall be satisfied:

113 Design Guide for midas Civil


2
§ f · Fcb
Fnc Fcb 1  ¨¨ v ¸¸ (2.83)
© Iv Fcv
AASHTO LRFD 12
¹ (Eq.6.11.8.2.2-2)
[Table 2.36] Calculation of Fcb
Case Fcb
O f d Op Fcb Rb Rh Fyc '
ª § '  0.3 ·§¨ O f  O p ·¸º
Op  O f d Or Fcb Rb Rh Fyc «'  ¨¨ '  ¸ »
¬« © Rh ¸¹¨© Or  O p ¸¹¼»
AASHTO LRFD 12
0.9 ERb k (Eq.6.11.8.2.2-3)
Or  O f Fcb
Of 2
AASHTO LRFD 12
Where, (Eq.6.11.8.2.2-4)
λf : slenderness ration for the compression flange

b fc Ek Ek
Of , Op 0.57 and Or 0.95 (2.84) AASHTO LRFD 12
t fc Fyc ' Fyr (Eq.6.11.8.2.2-8)
(Eq.6.11.8.2.2-9)
(Eq.6.11.8.2.2-10)
For unstiffened flanges, = 4.0 and = 5.34.
2
§ f ·
1  3¨ v ¸ T
' fv
¨F ¸ in which : 2 Ao t fc
© yc ¹ AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.11.8.2.2-11)
(2.85) (Eq.6.11.8.2.2-12)
Fyr : smaller of the compression-flange stress at the onset of nominal yielding, with consideration of
residual stress effects, or the specified minimum yield strength of the web

Fyr ('  0.3) Fyc d Fyw (2.86) AASHTO LRFD 12


(Eq.6.11.8.2.2-13)
[Table 2.37] Calculation of Fcv
Case Fcv

Ek s Fcv
O f d 1.12 Fcv 0.85Fyc
Fyc AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.11.8.2.2-5)
Ek s Ek s 0.65 Fyc Ek s
1.12  O f d 1.40 Fcv
Fyc Fyc Of AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.11.8.2.2-6)
Ek s 0.9 Ek s
1.40  Of Fcv
Fyc Of 2 AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.11.8.2.2-7)

2) Longitudinally Stiffened Flange


Also for longitudinally stiffened flanges, the following requirement shall be satisfied as for
unstiffened flanges. However, the plate-buckling coefficients, and , shall no longer be
constant but calculated to account for Fnc.

2
§ f · Fnc
Fnc Fcb 1  ¨¨ v ¸¸ (2.87) AASHTO LRFD 12
© Iv Fcv ¹ (Eq.6.11.8.2.2-1)
For longitudinally stiffened compression flanges, and are determined depending on
the number and location of stiffeners applied to the flanges.
①Plate-Buckling Coefficient for Uniform Normal Stress(k)
Depending on the number of uniformly spaced stiffeners, shall be taken as:

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 114


[Table 2.38] Calculation of k
Case n 1 nt2
1 1 K
k § 8I s · 3 § 0.894 I s · 3 AASHTO LRFD 12
k ¨ 3 ¸ k ¨ 3
¸ (Eq.6.11.8.2.3-1)
© wt fc ¹ © wt fc ¹ (Eq.6.11.8.2.3-2)

1.0 d k d 4.0

② Plate-Buckling Coefficient for Shear Stress (ks)


1
§ I ·3
5.34  2.84¨ s 3 ¸ ks
¨ wt ¸ AASHTO LRFD 12
ks © fc ¹ d 5.34 (2.88) (Eq.6.11.8.2.3-3)
n  1 2
Where,
Is : moment of inertia of a single longitudinal flange stiffener about an axis parallel to the flange and
taken at the base of the stiffener
n : number of equally spaced longitudinal flange stiffeners
w : larger of the width of the flange between longitudinal flange stiffeners or the distance from a web
to the nearest longitudinal flange stiffener

[Fig.2.57] Definition of w

(6) Case 4 : Tension Flange in Negative Flexural Moment


For tension flanges, flexural resistance limit state shall be verified as shown in the flow chart:
The flexural resistance of negative flexure moment and tension flange will be checked by
the process indicated in the flow chart below.

Case 4 : Check flexural resistance of


Negative Flexure Moment & Tension flange
6.11.8.3

Tub Section ?

Fnt Rh Fyt Fnt Rh Fyt '


6.11.8.3-1 6.11.7.2.2-5

Check Flexural Resistance


f bu d I f Fnt
6.11.8.1.1-1

End

[Fig.2.58] Case 4 : Flow Chart of Flexural Resistance for Tension Flange in Negative Moment

The tension flanges shall be verified according to:


fbu d I f Fnt (2.89)
Tension flanges
AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.11.8.1.2-1)

115 Design Guide for midas Civil


Fnt shall be taken as:

[Table 2.39] Calculation of Fnt


Section Type Fnt Fnt
AASHTO LRFD 12
Tub Fnt Rh Fyt (Eq.6.11.8.3-1
Fnt Rh Fyt '
AASHTO LRFD 12
2 (Eq.6.11.7.2.2-5)
Closed-Box § f · (Eq.6.11.7.2.2-6)
1  3¨ v ¸ T
'
¨F ¸ in which : f v (Eq.6.11.8.2.2-7)
© yt ¹ 2 Ao t ft

2.2.3 Shear
Box and tube type steel composite sections shall be verified for its shear strength as shown in
the flow chart:

Check Shear resistance


6.11.9

Yes Stiffened Web?

Interior Web Panel? No


Yes No :Unstiffened Web
:End panel

Case 1 : Case 2 : Case 3 :


Check Shear resistance of Check Shear resistance of Check Shear resistance of
Stiffened & Interior Web Panel Stiffened & End Web Panel Unstiffened Web
6.10.9.3.2 6.10.9.3.3 6.10.9.2

Stiffened Web Unstiffened Web

End

[Fig.2.59] Flow Chart of Shear Resistance

The program classifies stiffened and unstiffened webs as shown in the table below:

[Table 2.40] Classification of Stiffened Web and Unstiffened Web


Case Classification

Without a longitudinal stiffener and with transverse stiffener


spacing not exceeding 3D
Stiffened web
With one or more longitudinal stiffeners and with a transverse
stiffener spacing not exceeding 1.5D

Otherwise Unstiffened web

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 116


(1) Shear Strength Verification
Shear strength shall be verified as shown in the flow chart:

Check shear resistance


6.10.9

Stiffened
No Yes
web?

Unstiffened webs Stiffened Web Panels


6.10.9.2 6.10.9.3
Interior
Web Panel? Yes
No :Stiffened
:Stiffened Interior
End panel
Web Panels

Calculate V n Calculate V n
2Dtw
Vn V cr CV p Vn V cr CV p b t  bfttft
fc fc
d 2.5

Vp 0 . 58 F yw Dt w Vp 0 . 58 F yw Dt w No Yes

6.10.9.2-1 6.10.9.3.3-1
6.10.9.2-2 6.10.9.3.3-2

Calculate V n Calculate V n

ª º ª º
« » « »
« 0 . 87 (1  C ) » « 0 . 87 (1  C ) »
Vn V p «C  » Vn V p «C 
2 »
2
« § d · d0 » « §d ·
«¬
1 ¨ 0 ¸ 
D »¼ « 1  ¨ 0 ¸ »»
© D ¹ © D ¹ ¼
¬
6.10.9.3.2-8 6.10.9.3.2-2

Check V n
Vu d IV V n
6.10.9.1-1

End

[Fig.2.60] Flow Chart of Strength Limit State for Shear

Shear strength shall be verified as:


Vu d IvVn (2.90) Shear strength
AASHTO LRFD 12
Where, (Eq.6.10.9.1-1)
ϕv: resistance factor for shear
Vu : shear in the web at the section under consideration due to the factored loads

1) Unstiffened web
For unstiffened webs, the nominal shear resistance (Vn) shall be taken as:

Unstiffened web
Vn Vcr CVp (2.91) AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.9.2-1)
in which:
Vp 0.58Fyw Dtw (2.92)
AASHTO LRFD 12
Where, (Eq.6.10.9.2-2)
C : ratio of the shear-buckling resistance to the shear yield strength
Vp : plastic shear force

117 Design Guide for midas Civil


2) Stiffened Web Shear Strength
Program shall determine whether a stiffened web belongs to an end panel or interior panel
depending on whether its nodes are supported or not in the span information. The web
shall be first identified as an end panel or an interior panel and, then, its shear strength
shall be verified. If a web is supported at its nodes, the web belongs to an end panel; if not
supported, it belongs to an interior panel.

① End panels
For end panel webs, the nominal shear resistance shall be taken as:
End panels
Vn Vcr CVp AASHTO LRFD 12
(2.93)
(Eq.6.10.9.3.3-1)

in which:
Vp 0.58Fyw Dtw (2.94) AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.9.3.3-2)

② Interior panels
For interior panels, the nominal shear resistance shall be taken as:

[Table 2.41] Calculation of Vn for Interior Panel


Case Nominal shear resistance (Vn)
ª º
« »
2 Dtw « 0.87(1  C ) »
d 2.5 Vn V p «C 
2 »
(b fct fc  b ft t ft ) « § do · »
Interior panels
AASHTO LRFD 12
1 ¨ ¸
«¬ © D ¹ »¼ (Eq.6.10.9.3.2-2)

ª º
« »
« 0.87(1  C ) »
Otherwise, Vn V p «C  »
2
« §d · d » AASHTO LRFD 12
1 ¨ o ¸  o
« © ¹ » (Eq.6.10.9.3.2-8)
¬ D D ¼

Where,

[Table 2.42] Calculation of Ratio of the shear buckling resistance to the shear yield strength, C
Case C

D Ek C
d 1.12 C 1.0 AASHTO LRFD 12
tw Fyw (Eq.6.10.9.3.2-4)

Ek D Ek 1.12 Ek
C
1.12  d 1.40 D Fyw
Fyw t w Fyw AASHTO LRFD 12
tw (Eq.6.10.9.3.2-5)

1.57 §¨ Ek ·
¸
Ek D C 2 ¨
 ¸
1.40 § D · © Fyw ¹ AASHTO LRFD 12
Fyw t w ¨¨ ¸¸ (Eq.6.10.9.3.2-6)
© tw ¹
Where,
k: shear-buckling coefficient
(2.95) k
5
k 5 2
AASHTO LRFD 12
§ do · (Eq.6.10.9.3.2-7)
¨ ¸
©D¹

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 118


(2) Check for Inclination
For box and tube composite sections, inclination of webs
shall be considered. Shear force on each section shall be
evenly applied to its two webs after the consideration of the
incline angle as:
Inclination
AASHTO LRFD 12
Vu (Eq.6.11.9-1)
Vui (2.96)
cos T

[Fig.2.61] Inclination of Web


Where,
Vui : shear on each web due to the factored loads
Vu : vertical shear due to the factored loads on one inclined web
θ: the angle of inclination of the web plate to the vertical(degrees)

2.3 Service Limit State


For box and tub composite sections, flexure and web bend-buckling at the service limit state are
verified as shown in the flow chart below. The program shall verify service limit state for the
composite sections at the completion stage of construction. Load combinations defined in the
Load Combination Type (Please Refer to Chapter "Modeling Design Variable" Section 1.4.2) shall
be used for the verification of the service limit state.

Service Limit State


6.11.4

Check Flexure Yield in flange


6.10.4.2

Check Top flange of Composite Section

f f d 0 .95 R h F yf
6.10.1.2.2-1

Check Bottom flange of Composite Section


fl
f f  d 0 . 95 R h F yf
2
6.10.4.2.2-2

Check Nominal Bend-buckling Resistance for web


6.10.4.2

Calculate Fcrw and k


0.9 Ek
Fcrw 2
d Min ( Rh Fyc , Fyw / 0.7) k
9
§D· (Dc / D) 2
¨¨ ¸¸
© tw ¹
G
6.10.1.9.1-1G 6.10.1.9.1-2

Check Web Bend-buckling resistance for webs

f c d Fcrw
6.10.4.2.2-4

End

[Fig.2.62] Flow Chart of Service Limit State

119 Design Guide for midas Civil


2.3.1. Flexure
Flexure shall be verified at top and bottom flanges. As per Article C6.11.4, Eq. 6.10.4.2.2-1 and
6.10.4.2.2-2 are checked only for compact sections in positive flexure. Thus in midas Civil, these
equations are not checked for negative flexure and noncompact sections in positive flexure.

(1) Verification of Top steel flange of composite sections for flexure


Serviceability of top steel flanges shall be verified by comparing the stress as:
Top steel flange
AASHTO LRFD 12
f f d 0.95Rh Fyf (2.97)
(Eq.6.10.4.2.2-1)

(2) Verification of Bottom steel flange of composite sections for flexure


Serviceability of bottom steel flanges shall be verified by examining flexure as shown in the
equation below. If a web is under positive flexure and satisfies the requirements in AASHTO
LRFD 12 Article 6.11.2.1.2, its strength shall be determined to be satisfactory and verification
shall be skipped. For box and tub composite sections, flange lateral bending stress shall be
assumed as 0 for the design check.
fl Bottom steel flange
ff  d 0.95Rh Fyf (where, f l = 0) (2.98) AASHTO LRFD 12
2 (Eq.6.10.4.2.2-2)

2.3.2. Web Bend Buckling


Except for sections in positive flexure in which the web satisfies the requirement of Article
6.11.2.1.2, all sections shall satisfy Eq.6.10.4.2.2-4 shown below.

Webs shall be verified in terms of bend-buckling as: Bend-buckling


f c d Fcrw (2.99) AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.4.2.2-4)
Where,
fc : compression-flange stress
Fcrw : nominal bend-buckling resistance for webs
(2.100) Fcrw
0.9 Ek
Fcrw 2
d Min ( Rh Fyc , Fyw / 0.7) AASHTO LRFD 12
§D· (Eq.6.10.1.9.1-1)
¨¨ ¸¸
© tw ¹
in which:
k : bend-buckling coefficient
k
9 (2.101) AASHTO LRFD 12
k
( Dc / D) 2 (Eq.6.10.1.9.1-2)
Where,
Dc : Depth of the web in compression in the elastic range

2.4 Check Constructibility


For box and tub composite sections, constructibility shall be verified in terms of flexure and shear.
Member force under Dead (Before) shall be used as the design member force for the verification
of constructibility limit strength.

2.4.1 Flexure
The program shall verify flexural strength by assuming that concrete hardening has not occurred
yet and all section are discretely braced. The flexural verification shall be done in three cases as
shown in the figure follows.

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 120


Check Constructibility
6.11.3

Compression No
Yes
flange? :Tension ΗΝΒΟΘΖ

No
Tub Section? :Closed-Box
Yes
Section

Check Flange stress Check Flange stress Check Flange stress


of Tub Section in Compression of Closed-Box in Compression of Closed-Box in Tension
6.10.3.2.1 6.11.3.2-1~2 6.11.3.2-3~5

End

[Fig.2.63] Flow Chart of Flexural Resistance for Constructibility Limit State

(1) Open Flange (top flange of tub section) in Compression and Tension

1) Open flange in compression

For tub composite sections, compression top flanges shall be verified for yielding, flexure
and bend buckling of webs, as shown in the equation below. If = 0 for slender webs,
AASHTO LRFD 12 Eq.6.10.3.2.1-1 shall not be verified. Tub Section
AASHTO LRFD 12
1
f bu  f l d I f Rh Fyc and f bu  f l d I f Fnc (2.102) (Eq.6.10.3.2.1-1)
3 (Eq.6.10.3.2.1-2)
For slender webs, bend-buckling shall be verified as:
AASHTO LRFD 12
f bu d I f Fcrw (2.103) (Eq.6.10.3.2.1-3)

2) Open flange in tension


Tub Section
For tub composite sections, tension top flanges shall satisfy the requirement of Eq. AASHTO LRFD 12
6.10.3.2.2-1 which is same as that for I girder. (Eq.6.10.3.2.2-1)

(2) Noncomposite box flange (top flange of box section and bottom flange of tub or box
section) in Compression and Tension ( for constructability check, the top flange of box
section is designed as a noncomposite box flange)

1) Noncomposite box flange in compression

For box flanges in compression, constructibility shall be examined based on the


compressive stress due to flexure and bend buckling on webs. For sections with compact
or noncompact webs, Eq. 6.11.3.2-2 shall not be checked as per Article 6.11.3.2. Comp. Box Flange
▪Verification of compression stress due to flexure : f bu d I f Fnc (2.104) AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.11.3.2-1)
▪ Verification of bend buckling on webs : f bu d I f Fcrw (2.105) (Eq.6.11.3.2-2)

2) Noncomposite box flange in tension and continuously braced box flange in tension or
compression shall satisfy the following requirement:
Tension Box Flange
AASHTO LRFD 12
f bu d I f Rh Fyf ' (2.106) (Eq.6.11.3.2-3)
Where,
2 AASHTO LRFD 12
§ f ·
1  3¨ v ¸ T (Eq.6.11.3.2-4)
' fv
¨F ¸ in which : 2 Ao t f (Eq.6.11.3.2-5)
© yf ¹

121 Design Guide for midas Civil


(2.107)

2.4.2 Shear
For the verification of constructibility, shear shall be verified to prevent shear buckling at webs
according to the following requirement. The program shall distinguish end panel and interior Shear
AASHTO LRFD 12
panel for the verification of shear-buckling resistance. (Eq.6.10.3.3-1)
Vu d IvVcr (2.108)
AASHTO LRFD 12
Where, (Eq.6.10.9.3.3-1)
Vcr CVp in which: Vp 0.58Fyw Dtw (2.109) (Eq.6.10.9.3.3-2)

2.4.3 Concrete Deck


Constructibility of concrete deck shall not be verified for the box and tub steel composite
sections.

2.5 Fatigue Limit State


2.5.1 Load combinations of Fatigue Limit State
In this section, AASHTO LRFD 07 and 12 are applied differently. For more information about the
07 edition, please refer to Section 5.1 in this chapter. For more information on basic
considerations and assumptions for Fatigue Limit State, please refer to Section 1.5 in this
chapter. Fatigue limit state shall be verified as shown in the flow chart:



[Fig.2.64] Flow Chart of Fatigue Limit State for Flexure

The verification of fatigue resistance shall follow Section 2.5.3(1) for the load combinations of
Fatigue 1 Limit State in Load Combination Type (Chapter "Modeling Design Variables" Section
1.4.2) and Section 2.5.3(2) for the load combinations of Fatigue 2 Limit State. However, if
'(ADTT)SL≤ 75year (ADTT)SL' is inputted, Fatigue II Load Combination is verified. Otherwise, the
verification needs not to be done.

2.5.2 Fatigue Limit State

As per Article 6.11.5, one additional requirement specified particularly for tub girders sections

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 122


is in regard to longitudinal warping and transverse bending stresses. When tub girders are
subjected to torsion, their cross-sections become distorted, resulting in secondary bending
Fatigue Limit State
stresses. AASHTO LRFD 12
Therefore, longitudinal warping stresses and transverse bending stresses due to cross-section (Eq.6.6.1.2.2-1)
distortion shall be considered for:
x Single tub girder in straight or horizontally curved bridges
x Multiple tub girders in straight bridges that do not satisfy requirements of Article
6.11.2.3
x Multiple tub girders in horizontally curved bridges
x Any single or multiple tub girder with a tub flange that is not fully effective according
to the provisions of Article 6.11.1.1.

For consideration of these distorsion stresses in the software, Longitudinal Warping Stress
Range input is required in the fatigue parameters dialog box. (Fig.2.21)

Fatigue limit state shall be verified per stress unit as:

J ('f ) d ('F )n (2.110)

Where,
γ : load factor for fatigue load combination
(∆f) : force effect, live load stress range due to the passage of the fatigue load
(∆F)n : nominal fatigue resistance

2.5.3 Nominal Fatigue Resistance


The program’s calculation of Nominal Fatigue Resistance will be different based on whether the
load combinations are entered into Fatigue 1 Limit State or Fatigue 2 Limit State. Between the
two values, the lower value will be applied and reviewed.

(1) The Nominal Fatigue Resistance of Fatigue I Limit State due to load combinations
The program will calculate the Nominal Fatigue Resistance based on the category selected in Fatigue ่
the Fatigue dialog window. AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.6.1.2.5-1)
('F ) n ('F ) TH (2.111)
AASHTO LRFD 12
(Table. 6.6.1.2.5-3)
Within the program, categories of Nominal Fatigue Resistance, such as A, B, B', C, C', D, E, and
E' are applied as shown in [Table2.29].

(2) The Nominal Fatigue Resistance of Fatigue II Limit State due to load combinations
If fatigue review is performed with consideration to fatigue load combination 2, the following
equation is used to calculate the resistance value of fatigue. Fatigue ้
AASHTO LRFD 12
1
(Eq.6.6.1.2.5-2)
§ A· 3
('F ) n ¨ ¸ in which: N (365)(75)n( ADTT ) SL (2.112)
(Eq.6.6.1.2.5-3)

©N¹

Where,
A : Constant taken from Table 6.6.1.2.5-1
n : Number of stress range cycles per truck passage taken from Table 6.6.1.2.5-2
(ADTT)SL : ADTT for single lane
AASHTO LRFD 12
(Table. 6.6.1.2.5-1)
The value of the Detail Category Constant (A) and 75-yr (ADTT)SL Equivalent to Infinite Life (n, (Table. 6.6.1.2.5-2)
truck per day) are each respectively applied in [Table2.30] and [Table2.31]. If, the n value is
entered into the Fatigue Parameter, this value will be applied first.

2.5.4 Special Fatigue Requirement for Webs Special Fatigue


The program will perform the review of the fatigue due to the shear buckling of the web. Requirement
AASHTO LRFD 12

123 Design Guide for midas Civil


(Eq.6.10.5.3-1)
Vu d Vcr (2.113)
Where, ASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.5.3.3-1)
Vcr : shear in the web at the section under consideration due to the unfactored permanent loads plus the
(Eq.6.10.5.3.3-2)
factored fatigue load
Vcr CVp in which: V p 0.58Fyw Dtw (2.114)

3. Shear Connector
When the shear connector is defined in the steel composite sections, the review of the shear
connectors is performed. The shear connector performs review of Pitch, Transverse spacing, Cover
and Penetration, Fatigue, Special Requirement for point, and strength limit state.

3.1 Section Proportion Section Proportion


For the ratio of height to diameter of the stud type shear connector, following equation is used. AASHTO LRFD 12
(6.10.10.1.1)
h
t 4.0 (2.115)
d

3.2 Pitch Pitch


The pitch is reviewed using the below equation. AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.10.1.2-1)
nZ r
pd (2.116)
Vsr
Where,
Zr : shear fatigue resistance of an individual shear connector determined as per Article 6.10.10.2
n : number of shear connector in a cross section Center-to-Center
Pitch
Vsr : horizontal fatigue shear range per unit length
AASHTO LRFD 12
(6.10.10.1.2)
Also, the program checks if ≥6× and ≤ 24 ℎ are satisfied as well as
Equation 2.116. Vsr
AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.10.1.2-2)

Vsr V  F
fat
2
fat
2
(2.117)
Vfat
in which :
AASHTO LRFD 12
Vfat: longitudinal fatigue shear range per unit length (Eq.6.10.10.1.2-3)
Vf Q
V fat (2.118) Ffar
I
AASHTO LRFD 12
Ffat : radial fatigue shear range per unit length taken as the largest of either (Eq.6.10.10.1.2-4)
AbotV f lg l Frc (Eq.6.10.10.1.2-5)
F fat1 or F fat 2
wR w
(2.119)
in which :
σflg: range of longitudinal fatigue stress in the bottom flange without consideration of flange lateral bending
Abot: area of the bottom flange
Frc : net range of cross-frame of diaphragm force at the top flange
l : distance between brace point
R : minimum girder radius within the panel
w : effective length of deck (in.) taken as 48.0 in., except at end supports where w may be taken as 24.0 in.
effective length of deck distance

▪ If it is straight members, the value of Ffat1 is 0.


▪ If it is a Box/Tub section, regardless of whether it is straight or curved, the value of Ffat1 is 0.

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 124


▪ The program will consider the value of Ffat2 as 0.
▪ The center-to-center distance of the shear connectors cannot exceed 24inches and 6 times the
diameter of the stud.
3.3 Transverse spacing
(1) The transverse spacing of the shear connector must be more than 4 times the diameter of
the stud.
(2)The shear connectors must be located 1 inch inwards from the edge.

[Table 2.43] Calculation of plate-buckling coefficient for uniform normal stress, k k


AASHTO LRFD 12
Case n=1 n=2 (Eq.6.11.8.2.3-1)
(Eq.6.11.8.2.3-2)
1 1
§ 8I s · 3 § 0.894 I s · 3
K k ¨ 3 ¸ k ¨ 3
¸
© wt fc ¹ © wt fc ¹
1.0 d k d 4.0

3.4 Cover and penetration


The following conditions must be met for the cover and penetration of the shear connector.
(1)The clear depth of concrete cover over the tops of the shear connector must not be at least
2.0 inches.
(2) The shear connector must penetrate at least 2.0 inches into the concrete slab.

3.5 Fatigue Shear Resistance, Zr


This part is applied differently in the AASHTO LRFD 07 and 12. For the 07 conditions, follow Section
5.2 of this chapter. The fatigue shear resistance of the shear connector is calculated as shown in
the following table.

[Table 2.44] Calculation of Fatigue Shear Resistance , Zr


Shear Zr
Connector Case Fatigue shear resistance ( Z r ) AASHTO LRFD 12
Type (Eq.6.10.10.2-2)

Z r Dd 2 α
AASHTO LRFD 12
Where, (Eq.6.10.10.2-3)
75  year ( ADTT ) SL d 960 Case D
Stud N 0 34.5 Zr
AASHTO LRFD 12
N !0 34.5  4.28 log N (Eq.6.10.10.2-1)

75  year ( ADTT )SL ! 960 Zr 5.5d 2

3.6 Strength Limit State minimum number of


(1) Strength Limit State shear connector
After the strength limit state is calculated, the minimum number of shear connector (n) Is AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.10.4.1-2)
calculated as shown in the equation below.
P (2.120)
n
Qr
Where,
P : total nominal shear force
Qr
(2) Factored shear resistance of a single shear connector AASHTO LRFD 12
The resistance of the shear connector is calculated as shown in the equation below. (Eq.6.10.10.4.1-1)

125 Design Guide for midas Civil


Qr IscQn (2.121)

Where,
Qn : nominal shear resistance of a single shear connector determined as in Article 6.10.10.4.3
ϕsc: resistance factor for shear connectors inputted by the user in Composite Steel Design Parameter
(Fig.2.17)

(3) Total Nominal Shear Force, P


Calculate P
1) Calculate the Total Nominal Shear Force, P, for the verification of the shear connectors AASHTO LRFD 12
under positive moment. (Eq.6.10.10.4.2-1)

Pp  Fp
2 2
P (2.122)

Where,
Pp : total longitudinal force in the concrete deck
Pp Max( P1 p , P2 p ) (2.123) P1p , P2p
AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.10.4.2-2)
in which :
(Eq.6.10.10.4.2-3)
P1 p 0.85 f s ' bs t s (2.124)

P2 p Fyw Dtw  Fyt b ft t ft  Fyc b fc t fc


AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.10.4.2-4)
Fp : total radial force in the concrete deck
I t1 ! I t 2 (2.125)

in which :
Lp : arc length between an end of the girder and an adjacent point of maximum positive live load plus
impact moment

For straight bridges, the value of Fp is calculated as 0.


Calculate P
AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.10.4.2-5)
2) Calculate P when the shear connector experiences a negative moment.
PT  FT
2 2
P (2.126)

PT
Where, AASHTO LRFD 12
Pt : total longitudinal force in the concrete deck between the point of maximum positive live load plus (Eq.6.10.10.4.2-6)
impact moment and the centerline of an adjacent interior support
PT Pp  Pn (2.127)

in which :
Pn : total longitudinal force in the concrete deck over an interior support taken as:
Pn Min( P1n , P2n ) (2.128) P1n , P2n
AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.10.4.2-7)
in which : (Eq.6.10.10.4.2-8)
P1n Fyw Dtw  Fyt b ft t ft  Fyc b fc t fc (2.129)

P2n 0.45 fc ' bsts

Ft : total radial force in the concrete deck between the point of maximum positive live load plus impact

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 126


moment and the centerline of an adjacent interior support taken as:
FT
AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.10.4.2-9)
Ln
FT PT (2.130)
R

in which :
Ln : arc length between the point of maximum positive live load plus impact moment and the centerline
of an adjacent interior support inputted by the user in shear connector dialog box (Fig.2.19)

For straight bridges, the value of Fp is calculated as 0.

(4) Nominal shear resistance, Qn

[Table 2.45] Calculation of Nominal Shear Resistance, Qn Qn


AASHTO LRFD 12
Shear Connector Type Qn (Eq.6.10.10.4.3-1)

Qn 0.5 Asc fc ' Ec d Asc Fu


Where,
Stud Asc : cross-sectional area of a stud shear connector
Ec : modulus of elasticity of the deck concrete
Fu : specified minimum tensile strength of a stud shear connector

4. Stiffener
The Stiffener calculates the transverse/longitudinal stiffener attached to the web and the longitudinal
stiffener attached to the compression flange.

Stiffeners
6.10.11

Check Transverse Stiffeners

Check Longitudinal Stiffeners

Check Longitudinal Compression Flange Stiffeners Only Box Section

[Fig.2.65] Flow Chart of Stiffener

4.1 Web Transverse Stiffener


(1) Projecting Width
Projecting width of transverse stiffener attached to web panel shall satisfy following two
conditions:
Projecting width
[Table 2.46] Projecting Width Conditions of Web Transverse Stiffener AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.11.1.2-2)
Check List I Section Tub Section Closed-Box Section
Condition 1 16t p t bt t bf / 4 16t p t bt AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.11.1.2-1)

127 Design Guide for midas Civil


D
Condition 2 bt t 2.0 
30

Where,
tp : thickness of the projecting stiffener element
bf :for I-sections, full width of the widest compression flange. for tub section, full width of the widest top
flange. For closed box section, the limit of bf/4 does not apply.

[Table 2.47] Define bf according to Section Type

Section Type bf

Full width of the widest compression flange with in the field section under
I
consideration

Tub Full width of the widest top flange within the field section under consideration

(2) Moment of Inertia Check


This part is applied differently in the AASHTO LRFD 07 and 12. For the 07 conditions, follow the
section 5.3 of this chapter. The program will perform the calculation of the vertical stiffeners
attached to the web.

1) Vu>Vn
I t t Min ( I t1 , I t 2 ) (2.131)
Where,
It : moment of inertia of transverse stiffener

[Table 2.48] Calculation of Moment of Inertia of the transverse stiffener for I girder section, It AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.11.1.3-1)
(Eq.6.10.11.1.302)
Case It
b 3t
Single-sided vertical stiffeners It tp
3
§ b 3t 2·
Double-sided vertical stiffeners It 2¨¨ t p  bt t p 0.5bt  0.5tw ¸¸
© 12 ¹ AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.11.1.3-3)
(Eq.6.10.11.1.3-4)
(Eq.6.10.11.1.3-5)
3
It1 btw J
1.5
D 4 Ut § Fyw ·
1.3
It 2 ¨¨ ¸¸ (2.132)
40 © E ¹
2.5
J  2.0 t 0.5
( d o / D) 2 AASHTO LRFD 12
(6.10.11.1.3)

Where,
J : stiffener bending rigidity parameter
Ut Max( Fyw / Fcrs ,1.0) (2.133) AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.11.1.3-6)

Fcrs : local buckling stress for the stiffener


0.31E
Fcrs 2
d Fys (2.134)
§ bt ·
¨¨ ¸¸
© tP ¹

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 128


Fys : specified minimum yield strength of the stiffener
do : the smaller of the adjacent web panel widths
b : the smaller of do and D
C : ratio of the shear-buckling resistance

AASHTO LRFD 12
2) Vu˜Vn
(Eq.6.10.11.1.3-9)
[Table 2.49] Check for Transverse Stiffener when Vu˜Vn

Case Verifications AASHTO LRFD 12


(Eq.6.10.11.1.3-10)
§ V  IvVvr ·
Vn ! Vcr I t t I t1  ( I t 2  I t1 )¨¨ u ¸¸
I t1 ! I t 2 © IvVn  IvVcr ¹
Otherwise It ! It 2
Otherwise It ! It 2
AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.11.1.3-11)
3) The following is calculated when the transverse and longitudinal stiffeners attach to the
web at the same time.

§b ·§ D ·
I t ! ¨¨ t ¸¸¨¨ ¸¸ I l (2.135)
© bl ¹© 3.0d o ¹
Where,
bt : projecting width of the transverse stiffener
bl : projecting width of the longitudinal stiffener
Il : moment of inertia of the longitudinal stiffener
longitudinal stiffener
AASHTO LRFD 12
4.2 Web Longitudinal Stiffener (Eq.6.10.11.3.1-1)
(1) Strength limit state
The longitudinal stiffener attached to the web is calculated as shown in the falling equation.

f s d I f Rh Fys (2.136)
Where,
fs : the flexural stress in the longitudinal stiffener
Fys : specified minimum yield strength of the stiffener

projecting width
AASHTO LRFD 12
(2) Projecting width (Eq.6.10.11.3.2-1)
The projecting width of the Longitudinal stiffener is limited as per the following equation. As per
Article C6.11.11.2, for the structural tees, bl should be taken as one half the width of the flange.

E
bl d 0.48ts (2.137)
Fys
Where,
ts: thickness of the stiffener

(3) Moment of inertia and radius gyration AASHTO LRFD 12


Moment of inertia and radius of gyration are calculated using the dimensions inputted in the (Eq.6.10.11.3.3-1)
Section Stiffener dialog box (Fig.2.8). The moment of inertia and the radius of gyration of the (Eq.6.10.11.3.3-2)
longitudinal stiffener shall satisfy:

129 Design Guide for midas Civil


Fys
ª § do ·2 º 0.16d o
I l t Dtw «2.4¨ ¸  0.13» E
3 E
and rt (2.138)
«¬ © D ¹ »¼ Fyc
1  0.6
Rh Fys
Where,
do : transverse stiffener spacing
R : minimum girder radius in the panel
r : radius of gyration of the longitudinal stiffener including an effective width of the web equal to 18*tw
taken about the neutral axis of the combined section
Il : moment of inertia of the longitudinal stiffener including an effective width of the web equal to 18*tw
taken about the neutral axis of the combined section
β :curvature correction factor for longitudinal stiffener rigidity β
AASHTO LRFD 12
[Table 2.50] Calculation of β (Eq.6.10.11.3.3-3)

Case E
AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.11.3.3-4)
For cases where the longitudinal stiffener is on the side of the Z
E 1
web away from the center of curvature 6
Z
For cases where the longitudinal stiffener is on the side of the Z
E 1 AASHTO LRFD 12
web toward the center of curvature 12 (Eq.6.10.11.3.3-5)

Where,
Z : curvature parameter
2
0.95d o
Z d 10 (2.139)
Rt w

4.3 Longitudinal Compression Flange Stiffener (for box compression flange)


(1) The strength of the stiffeners must be greater than the yield strength of the compression
flanges. projecting width
AASHTO LRFD 12
(Eq.6.10.11.2-1)
(2) Projecting Width
The Projecting Width (bl) of the Longitudinal Compression Flange Stiffener is calculated as
shown in the following equation.
E
bl d 0.48t s (2.140)
Fyc
Where,
Moment of inertia
ts: thickness of the projecting longitudinal stiffener element AASHTO LRFD 07&12
(Eq.6.10.11.2-2)
(3) Moment of inertia
Each Moment of inertia of the Longitudinal Compression Flange Stiffener Is calculated as shown
in the following equation.
I l t \wt fc
3
(2.141)
Where,
w : larger of the width of the flange between longitudinal flange stiffeners or the distance from a web to
the nearest longitudinal flange stiffener

[Table 2.51] Calculation of ψ

Number of the longitudinal stiffener attached to \


compression flange(n)

n 1 0.125k 3

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 130


n 2 1.120k 3

nt3 Equally applicable as n=2


Where,
k : plate-buckling coefficient for uniform normal stress

5. Difference Between AASHTO-LRFD 4th(2007) and AASHTO-


LRFD 6th(2012)
This section explains how the functions of midas Civil are applied differently in AASHTO-LRFD 4th
Edition (2007) and AASHTO-LRFD 6th Edition (2012).

5.1 Fatigue Limit State


In both standards, the fatigue resistance is calculated differently.

AASHTO-LRFD 4th Edition (2007) AASHTO-LRFD 6th Edition (2012)

The calculation only considers the Fatigue 2 Load Based on the conditions, the calculation
Combination out of the user load combinations. considers the Fatigue 1 or 2 Load Combination.
AASHTO LRFD07&12
(6.6.1.2.3)
(6.6.1.2.5)
Fatigue Resistance (ΔF)n Calculation
Fatigue 1 Load Case Combination Is not used in Fatigue Resistance (ΔF)n Calculation
the calculation. When using the Fatigue 1 Load Case
Combination, the value of ΔF)n Is calculated as
such:

('F ) n ('F )TH

When using the Fatigue 2 Load Case When using the Fatigue 2 Load Case
Combination, the value of ΔF)n Is calculated as Combination, the value of ΔF)n Is calculated as
such: such:

1 1
§ A ·3 1 § A ·3
('F ) n ¨ ¸ t ('F )TH ('F )n ¨ ¸
©N¹ 2 ©N¹
in which: N (365)(75)n( ADTT ) SL in which: N (365)(75)n( ADTT ) SL

5.2 Fatigue Limit State for Shear Connector


In both standards, Fatigue resistance for Shear Connector (Zr) is calculated differently. AASHTO LRFD07&12
(6.10.10.2)
AASHTO-LRFD 4th Edition (2007) AASHTO-LRFD 6th Edition (2012)

The Fatigue resistance(Zr) of the stud type for The Fatigue resistance(Zr) of the stud type for
the Shear Connector is calculated as such: the Shear Connector is calculated as such:
38.0d 2
Zr Dd 2 t (in SI Unit) Z r Dd 2 (in US Unit)
2
D 238  29.5 log N ( in SI Unit) D 34.5  4.28 log N ( in US Unit)

131 Design Guide for midas Civil


5.3 Transverse Stiffener
In both standards, Transverse Stiffener is calculated differently

AASHTO-LRFD 4th Edition (2007) AASHTO-LRFD 6th Edition (2012)

Calculation of the Stiffener bending rigidity Calculation of the Stiffener bending rigidity
parameter(J) parameter(J)
2
§ D · 2.5
J 2.5¨¨ ¸¸  2.0 t 0.5 J  2.0 t 0.5
© do / D ¹ ( d o / D) 2

When the Web post buckling or tension-field When the Web post buckling or tension-field
resistance is considered, the following is resistance is considered, the following is
calculated. calculated.
It ! It 2 (1) I t1 ! I t 2 AASHTO LRFD07&12
(6.10.11.1.3)
1) Vn ! Vcr
§ V  IvVvr ·
I t t I t1  ( I t 2  I t1 )¨¨ u ¸¸
© IvVn  IvVcr ¹
2) Other conditions
It ! It 2

(2) I t1 d I t 2

It ! It 2

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 132


5.4 Flexure Resistance of Box Flange in compression under Unstiffened
condition
In both standards, the Flexure Resistance of Box Flange in compression under Unstiffened
condition is calculated differently.

AASHTO-LRFD 4th Edition (2007) AASHTO-LRFD 6th Edition (2012)


(1) Fnc (1) Fnc AASHTO LRFD07&12
kE 2 (6.11.8.2.2)
1) O f d R1 § f ·
Fyc Fnc I f Fcb 1  ¨¨ v ¸¸
Fnc Rb Rh Fyc '
© Iv Fcv ¹

1) Fcb
£ O f d Op
kE kE
2) R1  O f d R2 Fcb Rb Rh Fyc '
Fyc Fyc
¤ O p  O f d Or
Fcb Rb Rh Fyc u
ª § '  0.2 ·§ O f  O p ·º
ª ­ ª § · º ½º Fcb Rb Rh Fyc «1  ¨¨1  ¸¨ ¸»
Rh ¸¹¨© Or  O p ¸¹»¼
b F fc
« ° « ¨ R2  fc ¸ » °» «¬ ©
« § ·° ¨ ¸ » °»
¸®1  sin «« S ¨
Fyr t fc kE
«'  ¨¨ '  ¸ ¸ » ¾» ¥ Or  O f
« © R h F yc ¹° « ¨
2 R 2  R1 ¸ » °»
« ° « ¨ ¸ » °» 0.9 ERb k
¬« ¯ ¬ © ¹¼ ¿¼» Fcb
Of 2

3) O f ! R2
kE
2) Fcv
Fyc
£ O f d 1.12
Ek s
2
0.9 ERb k
2
Rb f v k § b fc · Fyc
Fnc  ¨ ¸
§ b fc ·
2 2 ¨t ¸
¨ ¸
0.9 Ek s © fc ¹ Fcv 0.85Fyc
¨t ¸ ¤ 1.12 Ek s  O d 1.40 Ek s
© fc ¹ f
Fyc Fyc

0.65 Fyc Ek s
Where, Fcv
Of
R1 : constant which when multiplied by ¥ 1.40 Ek s  O
f
Fyc
kE / Fyc yields the slenderness ratio equal to
0.6 times the slenderness ration for which Fnc 0.9 Ek
Fcv
from Eq.3 is equal to Rb Rh Fyc ' Of 2
0.57
R1
ª § f v · § k · º»
2 2 Where,
1« ¨ ¸
' ' 4
2
¨ ¸
2« ¨F ¸ ¨k ¸ »
© yc ¹ © s ¹ Ek
¬« ¼» Op 0.57
Fyc '
R2 : constant which when multiplied by Ek
Or 0.595
kE / Fyc yields the slenderness ratio for Fyr
which Fnc from Eq.3 is equal to Rb Fyc
1.23
R2
ª § Fyr ·
2
§ f v · § k · º»
2 2
1 « Fyr ¨ ¸ ¨ ¸
 4 ¨ ¸
1.2 « Fyc ¨F ¸ ¨F ¸ ¨k ¸ »
«¬ © yc ¹ © yc ¹ © s ¹ »¼

133 Design Guide for midas Civil


Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design : AASHTO-LRFD 4thand6th (2007/2012)

Steel Composite Design


Result
1. Strength Limit State Result
1.1 Flexure
(1) by Result Table
As shown in the table below, the results can be checked in the result table.
೛ Design > Composite Design > Design Result Tables > Strength Limit State (flexure)…

[Fig.2.66] Result Table for Strength Limit State of Flexure


Where,
My : yield moment
Mp : plastic moment
Mu : moment due to the factored loads
phiMn : nominal flexural resistance of a section multiplied by resistance factor, phi, for flexure
fbu : largest value of the compressive stress throughout the unbraced length in the flange under condition,
calculated without consideration of flange lateral bending
phiFn : nominal flexure resistance of a flange
Dp :distance from the top of the concrete deck to the neutral axis of the composite section at the plastic
moment
Dt : total depth of the composite section

Based on the different search conditions, the result values which appear will vary, as shown in
the table below.
[Table 2.52] Result Case Table for Strength Limit State of Flexure

Condition Output Items

fle
Applied
xu Section My Mp Mu phiMn fbu phiFn Dp Dt
Clause
re
compact 6.10 & 6.11 O O O O - - O O
(+)
non-
6.10 & 6.11 - - - - O O O O
compact
- 6.10 & 6.11 - - - - O O - -
(-)
- Appendix A6 O O O O - - - -

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 134


(2) by Excel Report
The results can be viewed in an Excel Report as shown below.

1) Positive Flexure

[Fig.2.67] Excel Report for Strength Limit State of Positive Moment

135 Design Guide for midas Civil


2) Negative Flexure

[Fig.2.68] Excel Report for Strength Limit State of Negative Moment

1.2 Shear
(1) Result Table
As shown in the table below, the results can be checked in the result table.
೛ Design > Composite Design > Design Result Tables > Strength Limit State (shear)…

[Fig.2.69] Result Table for Strength Limit State of Shear

Where,
Vu : shear due to the factored load
phiVn : nominal shear resistance multiplied by resistance factor, phi, for shear
bt_lim1 : projecting width limit for transverse stiffener, 2.0+(D/30), as per Eq. 6.10.11.1.2-1
bt_lim2 : projecting width limit for transverse stiffener, 16tp, as per Eq. 6.10.11.1.2-2
bt_lim3 : projecting width limit for transverse stiffener, bf/4, as per Eq. 6.10.11.1.2-2
bt : projected width of transverse stiffener as per Article 6.10.11.1.2
lt_lim : limiting moment of inertia of transverse stiffener as per Eq. 6.10.11.1.3-3&4
lt : Moment of Inertia of transverse stiffener as per Article 6.10.11.1.3

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 136


(2) by Excel Report
The results can be viewed in an Excel Report as shown below.

[Fig.2.70] Excel Report for Strength Limit State of Shear

2. Service Limit State Result


(1) by Result Table
The results can be viewed in an Excel Report as shown below.

೛ Design > Composite Design > Design Result Tables > Service Limit State…

[Fig.2.71] Result Table for Service Limit State


Where,
fc : compression-flange stress
fcrw: nominal bending buckling resistance for webs as per Eq. 6.10.11.9.1-1
fcf : compression-flange stress
fcf_lim : limit of compression-flange stress
ftf : tension-flange stress
ftf_lim : limit of tension-flange stress

137 Design Guide for midas Civil


(2) by Excel Report
The results can be viewed in an Excel Report as shown below.

[Fig.2.72] Excel Report or Strength Limit State of Shear

3. Constructibility Result
3.1 Flexure
(1) by Result Table
The results can be viewed in a result table as shown below.

೛ Design > Composite Design > Design Result Tables > Constructibility (flexure)...

[Fig.2.73] Result Table for Constructibility Limit State of flexure

Where,
fbuw : flange stress calculated without consideration of flange lateral bending
phifcrw : nominal bend-buckling resistance for webs
fbuc : compression-flange stress with consideration of flange lateral stress
phifc : limit of compression-flange stress
fbut : tension-flange stress with consideration of flange lateral stress
phift : limit of tension -flange stress
fdeck : longitudinal tensile stress in a composite section deck
phifr : limit of concrete deck tensile stress. fr shall be taken as the modulus of rupture as per the Article
6.10.1.7

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 138


(2) by Excel Report
The results can be viewed in an Excel Report as shown below.

[Fig.2.74] Excel Report for Constructibility of Positive Moment

139 Design Guide for midas Civil


2) Negative Flexure

[Fig.2.75] Excel Report for Constructibility of Negative Moment

3.2 Shear
(1) by Result Table
The results can be viewed in a result table as shown below.

೛ Design > Composite Design > Design Result Tables > Constructibility (shear)...

[Fig.2.76] Result Table for Constructibility of Shear


Where,
Vu : shear in the web due to the factored load
phiVcr : shear-buckling resistance multiplied by resistance factor, phi, for shear

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 140


(2) by Excel Report
The results can be viewed in an Excel Report as shown below.

[Fig.2.77] Excel Report for Constructibility of Shear

4. Fatigue Limit State Result


(1) by Result Table
The results can be viewed in a result table as shown below.

೛ Design > Composite Design > Design Result Tables > Fatigue Limit State...

[Fig.2.78] Result Table for Fatigue Limit State


Where,
γ(Δf) : Range of Fatigue Limit State
(ΔF)n : Nominal Fatigue Resistance
Lcom : Load combinations used in the calculation
Vu : shear in the web due to the unfactored permanent load plus the factored fatigue load
Vcr : shear buckling resistance as per Eq. 6.10.9.3.3-1

141 Design Guide for midas Civil


(2) by Excel Report
The results can be viewed in an Excel Report as shown below.

[Fig.2.79] Excel Report for Fatigue Limit State

5. Shear Connector Result


(1) by Result Table
The results can be viewed in a result table as shown below.
೛ Design > Composite Design > Design Result Tables > Shear Connector...

[Fig.2.80] Result Table for Shear Connector


Where,
H/D : height to diameter ratio
(H/D)lim : limit value of height to diameter ratio (=4.0)
p : pitch of shear connectors specified by the user
p_lim1: pitch limit value, nZI/(Vsr), as per Eq. 6.10.10.1.2-1
p_lim2: pitch limit value, 6d
s : transverse spacing of shear connectors spacing (Transverse Cross Section)
edge : distance of the top compression flange edge_lim (=1.0 in)
Cover : clear depth of concrete cover over the tops of the shear connectors (> 2.0 in)
Penetration : depth of penetration of the shear connector(>2.0in)
n : number of shear connectors entered in transverse direction
n_Req : required number of shear connectors

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 142


(2) by Excel Report
The results can be viewed in an Excel Report as shown below.

[Fig.2.81] Excel Report for Shear Connector

6. Stiffener Result
(1) by Result Table
The results can be viewed in a result table as shown below.

೛ Design > Composite Design > Design Result Tables > Longitudinal Stiffener...

[Fig.2.82] Result Table for Stiffener


Where,
bl : projecting width
bl_lim : limit of projecting width as per Eq. 6.10.11.3.2-1
I : Moment of inertia of cross-section
I_lim : limit of moment of inertia of cross-section as per Eq. 6.10.11.3.3-1
r : radius of gyration
r_lim : limit of radius of gyration as per Eq. 6.10.11.3.3-2
fs : flexure stress of longitudinal stiffener
phiRhFys : limit of flexure stress as per Eq. 6.10.11.3.1-1

143 Design Guide for midas Civil


(2) by Excel Report
The results can be viewed in an Excel Report as shown below.

[Fig.2.83] Excel Report for Stiffener

7. Span Checking
(1) by Result Table
೛ Design > Composite Design > Design Result Table...

Most critical member results in each span can be viewed in a result table as shown below.

[Fig.2.84] Result Table for Span Group

Chapter 2.Steel Composite Design - AASHTO LRFD4th and6th (2007/2012) 144


(2) by Span Result Graph
೛ Design > Composite Design > Design Result Diagram...

The results of the span group defined by the span information can be checked here. The flexure
and shear results based on distance or node can be checked here. The current applied member
force or elasticity is marked in red while the strength or elasticity is marked in green.

[Fig.2.85] Span Result Graph

8. Total Checking
(1) by Result Table
೛ Design > Composite Design > Design Result Table...

Summary results for each member can be viewed in a result table as shown below.

[Fig.2.86] Result Table for Toal Checking

145 Design Guide for midas Civil


DESIGN GUIDE
for midas Civil
AASHTO LRFD

Prestressed Box Girder Design : AASHTO LRFD

Composite Steel Box Girder Design : AASHTO LRFD

Composite Plate Girder Design : AASHTO LRFD

You might also like