Question: How do you treat the claim of Philippines over Sabah? Is it
Imperium? or Dominium?
According to some articles, Sabah is located on the northern
portion of Borneo Island in which the Philippines are at north and east portion of it. The government of Malaysia and the Philippines has an incompatible agreement over the ownership to the land.
There are a lot of issues regarding the claim of the
Philippines over Sabah. Does the Philippines have the right to claim it? Are the reasons valid? Should the Philippines be allowed to add the Sabah to their property?
As a student, the Philippines has the right to claim for it.
Because Sabah was a part of the Sultanate of Sulu that is given as a gift by the Sultan of Brunei. Philippines said that they are the successor state of the Sultanate of Sulu, in which they claim the Sabah because on year 1878, it was leased for 100 years by the Sultan to the British businessman, and it is the under the contract between them.
Also, Sabah is a Sultan of Sulu, in which it is the citizen
of the Philippines. According to some stories, the Britain contributes payments to the Sultanate as a cession payment, but the Sultan said that these are lease payments. Also, the British North Borneo Company rented it from the Sultan for plantations because the place is rich for mineral resources. Therefore, the claiming of Malaysia in the Sabah is not sustainable because it was only leased to the company and not ceded. The Sultanate used to rule the southern Philippines including the Sabah.
If ever there is a chance that the Philippines successfully
claimed the Sabah, there is a chance to the progress of the economy in the Mindanao part of the country because of the annual income of $70 billion. It would become an economic engine in the Philippines, too. Because it is rich in minerals and fertile lands. There is also an existing oil in Sabah that will help the country more productive. Is it Imperium or Dominium?
The claiming of Philippines over Sabah is an example of
Dominuim because according to the definition of it, it is the absolute ownership of the property by a person or country. The Philippines has the right to claim and use and has the right to control the property of it. Even though the Malaysia pays rent for it, still it is only leased according to the said company but still the Philippines has the right to rule the Sabah.
The Malay Archipelago, The Land of The Orang-Utan and The Bird of Paradise A Narrative of Travel, With Studies of Man and Nature - Volume 1 by Wallace, Alfred Russel, 1823-1913