Professional Documents
Culture Documents
69–74, 1999
© 1999 Elsevier Science Inc.
Printed in the USA. All rights reserved
0031-9384/99/$–see front matter
PII S0031-9384(99)00040-2
MARTIN, P. Y. AND D. BENTON. The influence of a glucose drink on a demanding working memory task. PHYSIOL
BEHAV 67(1) 69–74, 1999.—A group of young adult females, who had or had not eaten breakfast, drank either a glucose
drink or a placebo. Fasting was associated with poorer performance on the Brown–Petersen task, a test of memory. A glucose
drink improved the memory of those who had fasted, although it did not influence those who had eaten breakfast. In those
who had fasted, the glucose drink resulted in memory comparable to those who had consumed breakfast. Those with higher
levels of blood glucose upon arrival in the laboratory had better memories. In those taking a glucose drink, after an initial
rise, rapidly falling levels of blood glucose were associated with better memory. © 1999 Elsevier Science Inc.
RAISING the level of blood glucose has been found to im- stated that it places great demands on the central executive of
prove memory in healthy young adults (4,5,13,19,30,32). There Working Memory. [A preliminary version of some of the data
are also reports that in those whose blood glucose levels re- in this article has been published previously (6).]
mained higher cognitive performance was poorer, an observa-
tion made in the normal elderly (13), those suffering with MATERIALS AND METHODS
Alzheimer’s disease (9,10), diabetics (14), elderly rats (36),
and young humans (4,18). Subjects
Only recently have laboratory methods been used to ex- Eighty female undergraduates, with a mean age of 22.6
amine the influence of breakfast on cognition. A consistent years, who were each paid 6 pounds, acted as subjects. Only
picture is emerging—memory is adversely influenced by miss- females were studied, as previous research has reported that
ing breakfast (6,12,34,35). In contrast, other measures of cog- similar responses have been found in both sexes (4,11). No di-
nitive functioning tend not to be influenced by missing break- etary restrictions were enforced, and subjects from choice had
fast. Because following a meal the levels of glucose in the fasted or eaten their normal breakfast. On the basis of a meal
blood increase, one question that is addressed in the present record, and standard portion sizes, the energy content of the
study is the role played by blood glucose in breakfast-induced breakfast was calculated from food tables (32). A mean of
memory improvement. Benton and Sargent (8) reported that 1049 6 767 kJ were consumed by those in the breakfast
those who missed breakfast had a poorer memory later in the groups, made up of 42.6 6 30.3 g carbohydrate, 7.2 6 5.5 g
morning and that those with higher levels of blood glucose protein, and 6.8 6 8.4 g fat. In the majority of cases breakfast
had better memory. However, as this finding was simply a consisted of breakfast cereal and milk and/or toasted bread
correlation, there is a need to systematically vary the level of with butter or margarine and preserve.
blood glucose. Four groups of subjects were compared, those who had: 1)
It has been hypothesized that more cognitively demanding eaten breakfast and consumed a drink that contained 50 g
tasks are particularly susceptible to changes in blood glucose glucose, n 5 28; 2) eaten breakfast and consumed a placebo
(11,31). Therefore, the present study has extended the exami- drink, n 5 25; 3) fasted and consumed a drink containing 50 g
nation of the influence of the control of blood glucose levels glucose, n 5 12; and 4) fasted and consumed a placebo drink,
by considering the Brown–Peterson task (33) as Baddeley (1) n 5 15.
69
70 MARTIN AND BENTON
FIG. 1. The effect of breakfast and a glucose drink on recall of trigrams in the Brown–
Peterson task. The data are the mean number of trigrams recalled in blocks 1–4
and 5–8.
Figure 2 shows that those subjects who had high rather breakfast was limited by the supply of glucose. A potential
than low baseline blood glucose levels recalled more trigrams, problem is that because the subjects were allowed to choose
F(1, 26) 5 5.37, p , 0.029. Baseline blood glucose did not sig- whether they ate breakfast, they were a self-selected group.
nificantly correlate with the number of trigrams recalled Are people who eat breakfast more alert in the morning, and
(Pearson correlation 5 0.04, NS). Thus, the phenomenon was for this reason remember more easily, whether or not they eat
associated with extreme levels of blood glucose. In contrast, breakfast? This explanation does not seem to explain the
there was no effect of a change in blood glucose in the 20 min data. Benton and Sargent (8) randomly allowed subjects to
prior to the task in either placebo, F(1, 26) 5 0.32, NS, or glu- eat breakfast or fast, and found irrespective of whether the
cose drinkers, F(1, 26) 5 0.54, NS. subjects normally ate breakfast, that memory improved. In
When the change in the blood glucose of glucose drinkers fact, blood glucose correlated with memory in those who had
while performing the task was examined, a significant main not eaten breakfast. In other studies, where fasting or the eat-
effect was found, F(1, 26) 5 5.86, p , 0.023). Figure 3 illus- ing of breakfast was decided randomly, the meal still bene-
trates that falling blood glucose levels during the task was as- fited memory (34,35).
sociated with better recall of the trigrams. As the change in A related question is whether the benefits associated with
blood glucose while performing the task correlated with the a greater supply of blood glucose is only a reflection of a dec-
percentage of trigrams recalled (20.52, p , 0.001), the phe- rement in performance associated with missing breakfast. Al-
nomenon was displayed throughout the range of changes in ternatively, are the benefits of an increased blood supply
blood glucose. In the placebo drinkers Fig. 4 shows that the more general? Figure 1 presents evidence that a cognitive
two-way interaction, rise/fall in blood glucose 3 block (blocks problem associated with not eating breakfast responded to a
1–4/5–8), reached significance, F(1, 26) 5 6.05, p , 0.021. Fur- glucose drink (Fig. 1), although the effect of the drink was not
ther analysis showed that those whose blood glucose levels apparent in those who had eaten breakfast. There is a series
fell during the task did not show learning/practice effects of reports that the modification of blood glucose levels influ-
from the first to the second half of the test, F(1, 26) 5 0.06, ence cognition in those who have already eaten breakfast
NS. However, those whose levels rose showed a significant (4,5,9). However, after eating breakfast, it is individual blood
improvement in percentage recall in the second half of the glucose levels, rather than simply whether a glucose or pla-
test, F(1, 26) 5 13.93, p , 0.001. In this case, the phenomenon cebo drink has been consumed, that is typically important.
was characteristic of those with extreme levels of blood glu- The impression created is that an increased provision of glu-
cose, as the change in blood glucose did not significantly cor- cose has an influence irrespective of whether you have eaten,
relate with the total trigrams recalled (0.17, NS). although its impact is greater when breakfast has not been
eaten.
The blood glucose values were subject to a series of analy-
DISCUSSION
ses with a consequent increased risk of chance statistical find-
In the present study an exogenous source of blood glucose ings. The series of analyses can be justified in two ways. First,
nullified the negative effects of not eating breakfast (Fig. 1), a blood glucose measure is a single indication of a dynamic
suggesting that the performance of those who had not eaten process; therefore, there is a need for additional analyses to
72 MARTIN AND BENTON
consider changes that occur over time. Second, as discussed reflected a failure to maintain an adequate supply of glucose.
below, the presently reported findings are similar to previous Falling blood glucose levels, after a placebo drink, have also
findings, strongly suggesting that they are more than chance been reported to be associated with poorer performance of a
statistical findings. Conditional Associative Learning Task (31) and an intelli-
A high baseline blood glucose was associated with better gence test (29).
recall of the trigrams (Fig. 2). Previously, a high level of base- There are only limited data available that considered the
line blood glucose has been associated with better recall of influence of glucose provision from a psychological perspec-
word lists (4,5) and increased vigilance (5). When an associa- tive. The provision of glucose has been found to aid recall for
tion between baseline blood glucose levels and subsequent word lists (4,6,18) and a story (9,10,13,20), but also retrieval of
performance has been reported, in every instance a higher information learned 24 h previously (21). The presently used
level of blood glucose has been associated with better perfor- Brown–Peterson task has been described as a measure of
mance. As it is known that an equilibrium develops between working memory (1), but any conclusion concerning working
plasma and brain glucose (19), there is reason to suggest that memory requires studies that selectively tap the various sub-
those with initially high levels of blood glucose might have systems of the working memory model. Craft et al. (9) con-
had higher levels of brain glucose. cluded that declarative memory was primarily influenced, a
Figure 3 illustrates that after a glucose drink the ability to view supported by studies discussed in the previous para-
control blood glucose levels was associated with a better re- graph, although other aspects of memory have been relatively
call: those whose blood glucose levels fell recalled more tri- ignored. However, the view that glucose administration ex-
grams. The introduction lists a series of similar findings. clusively improves declarative memory conflicts with aspects
The pattern was different following a placebo drink where of the literature. Glucose has been reported to improve vigi-
falling blood glucose levels were associated with a poorer per- lance (2,3,5), quicken reaction times (27,28), improve mental
formance (Fig. 4). An obvious suggestion is that in those who arithmetic (27), decrease errors in a driving simulator (15),
had taken a glucose containing drink, falling blood glucose decrease the Stroop effect (5), and improve performance of
levels reflected the passage of the basic fuel to metabolically an intelligence test (7). It appears that the view that declara-
active cells. After a placebo drink there is no exogenous tive memory is influenced particularly by changes in blood
source of glucose, and falling blood glucose levels may have glucose and is relatively rather than absolutely the case. It is
GLUCOSE DRINK AND WORKING MEMORY TASK 73
REFERENCES
1. Baddeley, A. D.: Human memory: Theory and practice. Hills- 8. Benton, D.; Sargent, J.: Breakfast, blood glucose and memory.
dale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum; 1990. Biol. Psychol. 33:207–210; 1992.
2. Benton, D.: The impact of increasing blood glucose on psycho- 9. Craft, S.; Dagogo–Jack, S. E.; Wiethop, B. V.; Murphy, C.; Nev-
logical functioning. Biol. Psychol. 30:13–19; 1990. ins, R. T.; Fleischman, S.; Rice, V.; Newcomer, J. W.; Cryer, P. E.:
3. Benton, D.; Brett, V.; Brain, P. F.: Glucose improves attention Effects of hyperglycemia on memory and hormone levels in
and reaction to frustration in children. Biol. Psychol. 24:95–100; dementia of the Alzheimer type: A longitudinal study. Behav.
1987. Neurosci. 107:926–940; 1993.
4. Benton, D.; Owens, D. S.: Blood glucose and human memory. 10. Craft, S.; Murphy, C.; Wernstrom, J.: Glucose effects on complex
Psychopharmacology (Berlin) 113:83–88; 1993. memory and non-memory tasks: The influence of age, sex and
5. Benton, D.; Owens, D. S.; Parker, P. Y.: Blood glucose influences gluco-regulatory response. Psychobiology 22:95–105; 1994.
memory and attention in young adults. Neuropsychologia 32:595– 11. Donohoe, R. T.; Benton, D.: Declining blood glucose levels after
607; 1994. a cognitively demanding task predicts subsequent memory. (sub-
6. Benton, D.; Parker, P. Y.: Breakfast, blood glucose and cogni- mitted)
tion. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. (Suppl.) 67:772S–778S; 1998. 12. Geisler, M. W.; Polich, J.: P300 Food consumption and memory
7. Benton, D.; Parker, P. Y.; Donohoe, R. T.: The supply of glucose performance. Psychophysiology 29:76–85; 1992.
to the brain and cognitive functioning. J. Biosoc. Sci. 28:463–479; 13. Hall, J. L.; Gonder–Frederick, L. A.; Chewning, W. W.; Silveira,
1996. J.; Gold, P. E.: Glucose enhancement of performance on memory
74 MARTIN AND BENTON
tests in young and aged humans. Neuropsychologia 27:1129–1138; the rat hippocampus measured by zero-net-flux: Effects of micro-
1989. dialysis flow rate, strain and age. J. Neurochem. 72:785–790;1999.
14. Holmes, C. S.; Hayford, J. T.; Gonzalez, J. L.; Weydert, J. A.: A 26. Messier, C.; Durkin, T.; Mrabet, O.; Destrade, C.: Memory-improv-
survey of cognitive functioning at different glucose levels in dia- ing action of glucose: Indirect evidence for a facilitation of hippo-
betic persons. Diabetes Care 6:180–185; 1983. campal acetylcholine synthesis. Behav. Brain Res. 39:135–143; 1990.
15. Keul, J.; Huber, G.; Lehmann, M.; Berg, A.; Jakob, E. F.: Einflu· 27. Moser, L.; Plum, H.; Buckmann, M.: Der einfluβ von dextrose auf
von Dextrose auf Fahrleistung, Konzentrationsfahigkeit, Kreis- diet psychophysische leistungsfahigkeir des autofahrers. Aktuelle
lauf und Stoffwechsel im Kraftfahrzeug-Simulator (Doppelblind- Ernaehrungsmedizin 8:247–249; 1983.
studie im cross-over-design). Aktuelle Ernahrungsmedizin 7:7–14; 28. Owens, D. S.; Benton, D.: The impact of raising blood glucose on
1982. reaction times. Biol. Psychol. Pharmacopsychol. 30:106–113; 1994.
16. Kopelman, M. D.: The cholinergic neurotransmitter system in 29. Parker, P. Y.: The influence of blood glucose on the cognitive
human memory and dementia: A review. Q. J. Exp. Psychol. functioning of young adults. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Wales
38A:535–573; 1986. Swansea; 1995.
17. Kuntscherova, J.: Effect of short-term starvation and choline on 30. Parker, P. Y.; Benton, D.: Blood glucose levels selectively influ-
the acetylcholine content of organs of albino rats. Physiol. Bohe- ence memory for word lists dichotically presented to the right
moslov. 21:655–660; 1972. ear. Neuropsychologia 33:843–854; 1995.
18. Lapp, J. E.: Effects of glycemic alterations and noun imagery on 31. Parker, P. Y.; Benton, D.: The influence of blood glucose levels
the learning of paired associates. J. Learn. Disabil. 14:35–38; on tasks of different cognitive demand. (submitted).
1981. 32. Paul, A. A.; Southgate, D. A. T.: McCance and Widdowson’s The
19. Lund–Anderson, H.: Transport of glucose to the brain. Physiol. composition of foods, 4th ed. London: HMSO; 1978.
Rev. 59:305–352; 1979. 33. Peterson, L. R.; Peterson, M. H.: Short-term retention of individ-
20. Manning, C. A.; Hall, J. L.; Gold, P. E.: Glucose effects on mem- ual verb items. J. Exp. Psychol. 58:193–198; 1959.
ory and other neuropsychological tests in elderly humans. Psy- 34. Smith, A. P.; Kendrick, A. M.; Maben, A. L.: Effects of breakfast
chol. Sci. 1:307–311; 1990. and caffeine on performance and mood in the late morning and
21. Manning, C. A.; Parasons, M. W.; Gold, P. E.: Anterograde and after lunch. Neuropsychobiology 26:198–204; 1992.
retrograde enhancement of 24-hr memory by glucose in elderly 35. Smith, A. P.; Kendrick, A.; Maben, A.; Salmon, J.: Effects of
humans. Behav. Neural Biol. 58:125–130; 1992. breakfast and caffeine on cognitive performance mood and car-
22. Marks, V.; Rose, F. C.: Hypoglycaemia. Oxford: Blackwell; 1981. diovascular functioning. Appetite 22:39–55; 1994.
23. Mathews, D. R.; Holman, R. R.; Brown, E.; Steenson, J.; Watson, 36. Stone, W. S.; Croul, C. E.; Gold, P. E.: Attenuation of scopola-
A.; Hughes, S.; Scott, D.: Pen-sized digital 30-second glucose mine-induced amnesia in mice. Psychopharmacology (Berlin) 96:
meter. Lancet 1:778–779; 1987. 417–420; 1988.
24. McNay, E. C.; Gold, P. E.: Microdialysis measurement of brain 37. Tucek, S.: Acetylcoenzyme A and the synthesis of acetylcholine
extracellular glucose concentrations: Basal levels and changes in neurones: A review of recent progress. Gen. Physiol. Biochem.
during behavioral testing in awake freely moving rats. Soc. Neu- 2:313–324; 1983.
rosci. Abstr. 823:16; 1997. 38. Witmer, L. R.: The association value of three-place consonant
25. McNay, E. C.; Gold, P. E.: Extracellular glucose concentration in syllables. J. Genet. Psychol. 47:337–360; 1935.