Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/307523672
Article in ARCHIVE Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers Part E Journal of Process Mechanical Engineering 1989-1996 (vols · August 2016
DOI: 10.1177/0954408916666573
CITATION READS
1 105
6 authors, including:
All content following this page was uploaded by Qichao Yang on 08 October 2018.
Abstract
The test rig for water-injected process-gas screw compressor is designed and established. The dry gas seal technology
was adopted for the shaft seal of screw compressor and the test rig has the function of regulating and controlling the
mass flow of injected water. The performance characteristics of process-gas screw compressor under different working
conditions are investigated by experimental research. The effect of rotational speed, the injected water mass flow, and
the discharge pressure on the performance of screw compressor including discharge temperature and power consump-
tion were obtained. The experimental results show that the water injection could reduce the discharge temperature of
compressor significantly and increase the capacity of screw compressor at the same time. There exists an optimum mass
flow of injected water that could effectively reduce the discharge temperature and seal the clearance between the female
and male rotor simultaneously. For the tested screw compressor prototype, the proper injected water-to-air mass ratio
is about 2–3 L/m3. The additional power consumption caused by the injected water is small compared with the total shaft
power. The established compressor test rig and the experimental results are helpful for the development and improve-
ment on the performance of water-injected process-gas screw compressor.
Keywords
Process-gas screw compressor, water injection, characteristics, performance, experimental study
liquids that are likely to be present in the gas stream. pressure ratios (up to about 30) can be obtained in a
In many cases, water injection was used to control single stage with a significant reduction in power
the compression process.2 Water-injected screw com- consumption.10
pressor has been used abroad. In China, such com- The injection of water into compressor is now com-
pressors have not been widely applied. Liquid-injected monly used as a means of power augmentation for
screw compressor is often advantageous than dry industrial gas turbine. In this field, water injection-
machines. Water injection is an effective measure to based compressor has often been analyzed as a wet
improve the performance of oil-free screw compres- compression system. A large numbers of studies were
sor. The water injected into the chamber during com- conducted to better understand the effect of wet com-
pression improves compression efficiency by cooling pression in turbomachinery.11,12 White and Meacock13
the discharged air and fluidly sealing the clearances investigated the impact of evaporative processes on
deformed by the male rotor, female rotor and casing compressor operation performance. The use of wet
to reduce the leakage of air. For the process-gas screw compression allows one to decrease the compressor spe-
compressor, the cooling liquid does not react with the cific work and discharge temperature and to increase
media. The liquid including water, lightweight oil, or the compressor ratio and mass flow rate.14 These bene-
liquid hydrocarbon can be injected into the working fits are influenced by various parameters such as the
chamber to take away the heat and seal the clearance. evaporation rate and injected water mass flow rate.15
Therefore, certain gases are kept from polymerizing Many papers have been published on the optimum
or from operating in the explosion temperature design and calculation of both oil-injected and dry
range. In addition, liquid-injected screw compressors screw compressors. However, most of these papers
achieve considerably higher compression ratios than describe computerize numerical solutions for refrigera-
dry machines.5 It is entirely feasible to have a single tion screw compressor. Considering the lack of experi-
liquid injected compressor stage give the kind of pres- mental research on process-gas screw compressor, a
sure performance that would have mandated two or special experimental setup was designed and built up.
more of the dry compression stages. Furthermore, the The preliminary tests were carried out under different
excess liquid flushes the rotor and takes away the solid working conditions by varying rotational speed, pres-
particles and polymers. They can also be used in any sure ratio, and the amount of injected water. Based on
technological process that allows the presence of the experimental measurement, the main performance
water in the compression process. Several synthetic of the screw compressor was obtained. The purpose of
rubber plants that recycle gases, e.g. ethylene oxide, this paper is to give the compressor user an understand-
acetylene, coal gases, and, in very special cases, even ing of the operating characteristics of water-injected
chlorine type gases, use liquid-injected rotary screw screw compressor through experimental results.
compressor.
Many researchers have studied the water-injected
screw compressor and reciprocating compressor, Experimental facilities
which are used for air compressor. Jianfeng et al. stu-
System design
died the performance of water-injected screw compres-
sor used in PEM fuel cell system.6 Ous et al. examined Figures 1 and 2 show the schematic diagram and
the water-injected twin-screw compressor in order to photograph of the experimental setup which consists
develop effective humidification and cooling schemes of the screw compressor, electric motor, oil lubrica-
for fuel cell stacks as well as cooling for compressors.7 tion subsystem, water injection system, dry-gas seal
The temperature and relative humidity of the air system, and measure and data collection system. The
at suction and exhaust of the screw compressor were compressor operates between 2 and 5 bar of outlet
monitored under constant pressure and water injec- pressure, providing suction air flow of 10–20 m3/min.
tion rate and at variable compressor operating The screw compressor is driven by a three-phase fre-
speeds. Almasi introduced the oil-flooded process-gas quency conversion motor. The motor operates with a
screw compressor for coal steam gas applications. The variable speed in the range 200–2970 r/min at a max-
optimum arrangement for this compressor including imum rated power of 250 kW, which is controlled by
component design and manufacturing, journal and means of a frequency converter. Gearbox was coupled
thrust bearing seals, pulsation, noise and auxiliary sys- with the motor to increase the speed of the compressor
tems is presented.8 For reciprocating air compressor, rotor. The torque meter was installed between the gear-
the spraying water into cylinders makes its power con- box and the screw compressor. The gearbox output
sumption and discharge temperature decrease, that can shaft was connected by a gear coupling to the male
save energy 8–15% and increase the pressure ratio.9 rotor shaft for the compressor drive. This arrangement
A novel kind of reciprocating air compressor is devel- permitted male rotor shaft to 9000 r/min.
oped, in which quasi-isothermal compression is Because of restrictions applied by the test rig con-
achieved by the injection of a large quantity of water figuration, the air was used instead of actual process
through spray nozzles inside the compressor. The main gas in this process-gas screw compressor test rig
advantages of this type of compressor are that high to study the performance of screw compressor.
The most important difference between air and actual of screw compressor. The performance of actual
process gas is the molecular weight. Unlike the process-gas screw compressor could be evaluated
centrifugal compressor, the screw compressor is a through numerical method based on the experimental
positive displacement compressor. The screw com- data. Therefore, the experimental results on screw air
pressor is ideal for use in processes with fluctuating compressor can provide reference for the improve-
molecular weights. There is only a small impact of ment of design and operation of process-gas screw
molecular weight of the gases upon the performance compressor.
Upon leaving the gas filter, the compressed gas Table 1. Operating conditions of the compressor test rig.
enters the working chamber of the compressor,
Item Value
where it is compressed to the final pressure along
with the injected water. The water absorbs the heat Maximum rotaion speed (r/min) 9000
liberated during compression and seals the gaps in the Capacity (m3/min) 20
flow path. After compression in the compressor, the Water flow rate (t/h) 7.2
gas is separated from the water in the separator. Maximum discharge pressure (MPa) 3
A pneumatic valve is installed at the discharge pipe Maximum rotor diameter (mm) 255
and is used to adjust the discharge pressure of com-
Maximum disacharge temperature ( C) 200
pressor. The power and rotary speed were measured
Motor power (kW) 250
by the torque meter. The capacity of screw compres-
sor was measured by using the orifice plate. All of
the measurement instruments were calibrated before
conducting the experiments. next to the rotor lobe on each end of the machine.
In order to ensure the reliable operation of com- There are journal bearings outside the seal area, which
pressor, the oil lubrication subsystem is necessary to are typically sleeve type hydrodynamic bearings.
lubricate the bearings installed at the compressor and Thrust bearings are located on the outer side of the
gearbox. In this subsystem, the oil was pumped from journal bearings, and tilting-pad type is typically used.
the oil tank and then was cooled and filtered. The oil The main operating parameters of the test rig are
flows into the lubrication parts of the screw compres- listed in Table 1.
sor and gearbox through the oil distributor. There are
five locations needed to be lubricated or cooled,
Data acquisition and control system
including the gearbox, the balance piston, the inlet
bearing, the outlet bearing, and the synchronizer Measurements of the air temperature and pressure
gear. Each of the oil piping pressure could be adjusted are carried out at different locations in the system.
independently and the pressure gauge was installed to The suction and discharge pressures were measured
monitor the lubrication system. using pressure transducers EJA 430 with an operating
The compressed air plant was used to provide the 0–8 bar range. The sensors have uncertainty of
clean and dry compressed air about 0.8 MPa to sub- 0.075% of full range of the output (FRO). The
stitute the N2 of dry gas seal. The compressed air is WZPK series thermal resistances are used to measure
also used to drive the pneumatic proportional pres- the temperature at suction, discharge, and in front of
sure valve in the discharge pipe and the drain valve at the orifice plate. It is also used to measure the bearing
the bottom of the separator. temperature at the compressor and oil temperature at
This water injection system consists of a storage different locations of the oil lubrication subsystem.
tank, air–water separation device, cooler, control The measure range of the thermal resistances is
valves, and interconnecting piping. Liquid water was 0–200 C with an accuracy of 0.15 C. A torque
injected into the inlet of screw compressor in the mod- meter transducer was employed to measure the com-
erate pressure region as shown in Figure 2 and will act pressor driving torque and rotational speed. This cov-
as lubricant, coolant, and sealant in the working ered a range of 0–9000 r/min with an uncertainty
chamber of compressor. The water and gas mixture of 0.1% FRO. The injected water mass flow rate
is discharged through the compressor discharge was measured by the metal tube rotary flow meter
nozzle into a separation system located downstream with an uncertainty of 0.1 t/h of the reading. In
of the compressor. Water was separated in the separ- order to control the water mass flow precisely, two
ator and then discarded. The mass flow of water metal tube rotary flow meters were installed and the
injected to the screw compressor was adjusted by measure range is 0–1.2 t/h and 0–6 t/h, respectively.
the metal tube flow meter ranging from 0 to 7.2 t/h. The uncertainty of all transducers used in this
There are two rotors inside the casing of the screw system meets the requirements of the National
compressor. One rotor is referred to as male, and the Standard GB/T 15487-1995 (Methods of flow measure-
other rotor as the female. The screw air compressor ment for displacement compressor) as listed in Table 2.
has rotors with an asymmetric profile and a 6/4 gear The instrument control and data acquisition
ratio. The male rotor is driven by a directly coupled system was realized based on Programmable Logical
electric motor and drives the female rotor. The male Controller (PLC). Figure 3 shows the interface of data
rotor and the female rotor maintain a small clearance acquisition and control system developed for the com-
and do not contact each other. To keep phase with pressor test rig. All of the temperature and pressure in
each other, a timing gear is mounted on the rotors to the system were collected. The temperature of bearing
prevent the inter rotor contact, thus ensuring that installed in the gearbox and the temperature of stator
clearance between the rotors is maintained during winding of motor are also monitored to ensure the reli-
operation. To isolate the rotor chamber from the able operation of compressor. The frequency changer
bearing with an oil atmosphere, seals are necessary is used in the test system to obtain variable speed
Figure 4. Variation of volumetric efficiency wih rotational Figure 5. Variation of adiabatic efficiency with rotational
speed. speed.
Figure 7. Effect of injected water on capacity. Figure 8. Effect of water injection on power consumption.
The ratio of injected water and air volume flow is used flow. For example, at the speed of 3000 r/min, the
to indicate the mass flow of injected water for a given capacity of compressor increases from 5.98 m3/min
screw compressor. The air volume flow of compressor to 8.23 m3/min and increased by 37.7% when the
means the capacity of compressor. As can be seen, the injected water rises from 0.35 to 2.02 L/m3.
decrease in discharge temperature was greater at first. Figure 8 shows the effect of water injection mass
For example, when the ratio of injected water and air flow on the shaft power of the screw compressor at
volume flow increases from 0.5 to 4 L/min3, the dis- different operating speed. It can be seen that the
charge temperature of the screw compressor at 2400 r/ amount of power increases slightly with the increase
min decreases from 70.7 C to 28.9 C and reduces rap- of injected water. When water is injected into the
idly. There is no obvious decrease afterwards. The screw compressor, extra power is required to com-
discharge temperature is determined by the mass press the water or water vapor, and the rise of the
flow and the injection temperature of water. The water pressure with the increase of the wet air pressure
injected water temperature was kept constant in the also needs power. The extra power caused by water
experiments and the value is about 17 C. Increase in injection is small compared with the total shaft power.
the mass flow of water injection while the rotational For example, the shaft power of the screw compressor
speed remains the same maximizes the cooling effect at the operating speed of 3000 r/min increases from
of the injected water. As the water is injected into the 47.53 kW to 49.24 kW and increases by 3.6% when
screw compressor chamber, it absorbs heat from the the mass flow of injected water increases from 0.5 to
wet air in the compressor. As the air is compressed, 6 t/h. The injected water has a better effect on the
the temperature of the air increases. Water injection improvement of capacity of screw compressor, as pre-
inhibits the increase of the gas temperature, and thus viously found in Figure 7. However, there exists vis-
the compression process is approximately isothermal, cous loss due to the occurrence of large amount of
which is the most highly efficient compression process. liquid water in the working chamber when the injec-
It also can be seen that the change of discharge tem- tion water mass flow is large. In general, the quasi-
perature of the screw compressor under different rota- isothermal compression could be achieved by the
tional speed has the same trend. injection of large quantity of water inside the com-
Figure 7 shows the effect of water injection mass pressor. The spray of water inside the compressor in
flow on the compressor capacity. It can be seen from order to achieve power and efficiency augmentation
the figure that the water injection has a significant has been proposed from early years of gas turbines.14
impact on the capacity of screw compressor. With The gas temperature increases slightly during com-
the increase of injected water, the capacity of the com- pression for water-injected compressor. Therefore,
pressor rises quickly at the beginning. When the mass the power consumption could be reduced especially
flow of injected water is increased to a certain value, at the working conditions with high pressure ratios.
the capacity of the compressor tends to be stable. However, the screw compressor tested in this study
The tendency is similar under a different rotational has a low pressure ratio of 1.5, and the reduction of
speed. The increase was attributed to the sealing power consumption due to the water injection is small
effect due to the liquid film formed between the clear- compared to the viscous loss due to the occurrence of
ances of rotors. When the injected water mass flow large amount of liquid water in the working chamber.
is low, the leakage from the clearance is larger. As Therefore, the performance is relatively good when
the injected water increases, the leakage will conse- the ratio of injected water to gas is about 2–3 L/m3.
quently be reduced for larger water injection mass According to the previous analysis, the discharge
Figure 9. Effect of discharge pressure on power Figure 10. Effect of discharge pressure on discharge
consumption. temperature.