You are on page 1of 8

T E C H N I C A L U P D A T E

Designing for Investment Castings

T he investment casting process can produce


almost any shape from almost any alloy. As
with all processes, however, designing for the
tooling cost. Normal processing in most alloys
will create a rounding to a maximum of about
0.015 inch (0.4mm). Special processing can keep
process can lower cost while achieving the de- the edges sharp if desired. Fillets on inside cor-
sired performance. ners should have radii equal to the wall thick-
The guidelines noted here for investment ness.
casting design apply to part configuration as cast, Isolated bosses. Stock must often be added
without machining. For complex parts with a locally in a more or less uniform wall to provide
dimension larger than 3 inches (76mm), it is a machining stock for metal-to-metal contact or
good idea to make a casting drawing based on bolting. Keep the boss height to the maximums
geometric dimensioning and tolerancing (ASME shown in Figure 4 to minimize cost. Casting holes
Standard Y14.5M), make a finished part drawing through the bosses is more economic for tall
and establish inspection methods that assure (1) bosses.
the casting will fit into the machining fixtures and Internal features. Fluid flow passages or
(2) a dimensionally accurate finished part. internal contours of almost any shape and size
can be cast. If the passage length to the smallest-
Alloy Selection width dimension is more than 3:1 on a closed
Because service conditions—corrosion, local passage or 6:1 on a through passage, more expen-
high-wear areas, weight limitations, appearance, sive methods must be used to cast them. If pos-
etc.—may require characteristics in addition to sible, internal walls should be thinner than the
strength, the alloy should often be selected after external walls surrounding them (Figure 5). Try
establishing the part’s strength. (For a full treat- to avoid thick sections on thin internal walls,
ment of alloys and specifications, see Hitchiner however, unless they meet the criteria for isolated
Technical Update 2D2 and talk with your bosses.
company’s or Hitchiner’s metallurgists.) Linear tolerances for cast dimensions. The
tolerances shown in Table 1 “Linear Tolerances
Design Information for Cast Dimensions” can be applied to length,
Overall size. Hitchiner can provide most concentricity, fillet, and corner radii, holes
parts that will fit into a box of about 18 inches (straight and curved), flatness and straightness.
(457mm) cubed (and larger in aluminum). The table shows three levels of tolerances, from
Wall thickness. Hitchiner can provide cast- lowest to highest quality (also lowest to highest
ings as thin as 0.015 inch (0.4mm) in any of the cost).
alloys it casts and usually in as large an area as Holding closer tolerances requires more
such a section would be mechanically suitable. expensive tooling, more extensive process control
Walls as thick as 6 inches (152mm) can be cast in and often additional operations (coining, for
all alloys. example), all of which increase cost. Hitchiner’s
Some areas of the part require thicker walls capabilities are world class and it can meet the
and, wherever possible, it is better to have the tolerances of any other foundry. Before specifying
walls go from thin to thick in all directions, rather the highest-cost tolerances, however, we recom-
than from thin to thick to thin to thick again. In mend you work with our engineers to assure you
other words, avoid thicker sections surrounded get such tolerances at the lowest possible cost.
by thinner ones. Figure 1 shows recommended Wall thickness tolerances. Due to the nature
ways of changing wall thickness. of the process, investment castings need more
Joining walls. Figure 2 shows the best ways allowance for wall thickness variation, regardless
to join two or three walls. of the wall thickness dimension. For lowest to
Corners. Figure 3 shows the best corner highest cost, the wall tolerances are ±0.015 inch
designs. Tooling outside corners sharp reduces (0.38mm), ±0.010 inch (0.25mm), and ±0.005 inch

Technical Update 2D1 Hitchiner Manufacturing Co., Inc.


(0.13mm) (cannot be held in all wall thicknesses). stock needed to establish tight dimensions for
Geometric surfaces. Tolerances required for surfaces working against other metal parts
profiles, contours, perpendiculars, etc. depend on increases as the part size increases to assure
their length, so the table for linear tolerances can enough stock for dimensional variation and to
generally be used. For example, for lowest cost, a assure surface irregularities (roughness) are
contour could be held to within ±0.010 inch removed during machining. Since gauging does
(0.25mm) if it is one inch (25mm) long (or one-by- not pick up such irregularities, at least 0.010 inch
one inch (25-by-25mm), ±0.013 inch (0.33mm) if it (0.25mm) more stock than is needed to accommo-
is 2 inches long, etc. Many cast contours are date dimensional variation should be added. If
functional—threads, bearing surfaces and airfoils, the alloy is difficult to machine or the part vol-
for example—and should be checked with gauges ume is high, work with Hitchiner to assure
to assure functionality. minimum stock addition and reduce machining
Artwork. Almost any texture, lettering, knurl, cost. All areas to be machined should be marked
company logo, lines, rule and other types of fine clearly on the casting drawing and the finished
detail can be cast in a way that will convey the part drawing.
intent effectively and permanently. For ease of Geometric dimensioning and tolerancing.
casting, negative lettering width should be Geometric dimensioning and tolerancing should
around 0.025 inch (0.64mm) or larger, the depth be used for larger and more complex parts. It is a
should be held to the same dimension as the formal system approved internationally and
width and a minimum radius of 0.005 inch documented by the American National Standards
(0.13mm) should be at the base of the letter cross Institute (ANSI), American Society of Mechanical
section. Positive artwork can be cast to these and Engineers (ASME) and International Organiza-
larger dimensions and can be displayed on a tion for Standardization (ISO).
sunken surface as well. Hitchiner strongly recommends that its cus-
Surfaces to machine. Depending on the alloy, tomers get this detailed system of design language
the cast surface finish ranges from 90 to 150 µinch from ASME, asking for Standard ASME Y 14.5M.
RA (2.2 to 3.8 µm). In most cases, therefore, the This system avoids buildup of tolerances, which
only surfaces that need machining (any metal can happen when coordinate tolerancing is used,
removal) are those that require visual appeal— and makes it easy to convey the maximum amount
such as a golf club head—and those which are of information. This helps to avoid costly delays in
involved in metal-to-metal contact—bearing, the early stages of tool design and build as well as
rubbing, bolting, fitting, threading, etc. later on in production. Casting designers should
Any surfaces that need to be held more use the system of datum target points, lines or
closely than the tolerances outlined above will areas that can then be the basis for inspection and
have to be machined. Straight round holes requir- machining fixtures. Figures 6 and 7 illustrate how
ing tolerances better than those mentioned are they can be used.
normally drilled, unless the alloy is difficult to Drawing notes. Most drawings have stan-
machine, in which case precision cores may be dard blocks containing information helpful to the
economical. Hitchiner has extensive machining user—general tolerance, fillets, corner radii,
facilities for providing machine finished castings general wall thicknesses (with tolerance), surface
to final print, regardless of tolerance require- finishes, some drawing symbols, material, heat
ments. treat condition, special finishes, and more. Such
If the alloy is difficult to machine (e.g., a notes are helpful to the foundry. Additional notes
nickel or cobalt alloy), it may be economical to relating to the specific part are also desirable—
cast threads or cam or rubbing surfaces. Some nondestructive testing methods, alloy hardness,
alloys can be coined to achieve a surface that weld repair approval, special treatment areas,
functions quite well as a metal-to-metal operating visual quality, microstructure, grain size, sam-
interface. pling plans, references to machining or gauging
Machining stock. Surfaces polished for visual drawings or requirements—anything that aids in
appeal need at least 0.005 inch (0.13mm) stock communicating your needs to the foundry.
(depending on the alloy) to provide a great
looking surface after polishing. The amount of

Hitchiner Manufacturing Co., Inc. Technical Update 2D1


Linear Tolerances for Cast Dimensions
Lowest-to-Highest Quality & Cost–Inches (mm)
Dimension Lowest (±) Medium (±) Highest (±)
<0.25 (6) 0.010 (0.25) 0.005 (0.13) 0.0025 (0.06)
<0.50 (12) 0.010 (0.25) 0.005 (0.13) 0.0025 (0.06)
< 1 (25) 0.010 (0.25) 0.005 (0.13) 0.005 (0.13)
<2 (50) 0.013 (0.33) 0.010 (0.25) 0.008 (0.20)
<3 (76) 0.016 (0.41) 0.015 (0.38) 0.010 (0.25)
<4 (101) 0.019 (0.49) 0.017 (0.44) 0.012 (0.30)
<5 (127) 0.022 (0.56) 0.020 (0.51) 0.013 (0.34)
>6 (152) 0.25 (0.63) 0.022 (0.56) 0.015 (0.38)
<7 (178) 0.028 (0.72) 0.025 (0.63) 0.017 (0.42)
<8 (203) 0.031 (0.079) 0.028 (0.72) 0.018 (0.46)
<9 (229) 0.034 (0.87) 0.030 (0.77) 0.020 (0.50)
<10 (254) 0.037 (0.95) 0.032 (0.82) 0.021 (0.52)
>10 (254) 0.005 (0.13)* 0.004 (0.10)* 0.003 (0.08)*
* Per inch (25mm) of dimension length.
Table 1

Changes in Wall Thickness

Poor Design

Fair Design

Good Design

Best Design

Figure 1

Technical Update 2D1 Hitchiner Manufacturing Co., Inc.


Joining Walls

Good Fair Optimum


Thin to Thick For Same Wall Thicknesses

Right is Good
Poor for Equal Wall
Thicknesses
Good As Well

3 Times Wall
Thickness
Poor

Better, Best
If Contoured
As Top Right
Figure 2

Hitchiner Manufacturing Co., Inc. Technical Update 2D1


Corners

Poor Design

Good Design When


d
d=t=r
r

r
Good Design When
r=d

d d
Rib Thickness
= or < d

1.5 d
d

Thinning Flanges and Ribbing May Lower Cost


Figure 3

Technical Update 2D1 Hitchiner Manufacturing Co., Inc.


Low-Cost Bosses or Raised Pads
D

3d Min.
h When D = d,
Keep h < 1.5d
d

D
3d Min.
h
When D = 1.3d,
d Keep h < 1.0d

D
3d Min.
h
When D = 2d,
d Keep h < 0.25d

D
h

d
When D = 1.3d,
Keep h < 0.33d
3d Min.
D
h
d
When D = 2d,
Keep h < 0.10d
3d Min.

D If bosses must
3d Min.
h be taller than
above, coring
d
can reduce cost.
0.5 D

Figure 4

Hitchiner Manufacturing Co., Inc. Technical Update 2D1


Keep Internal Walls Thinner Than External Walls

Section AA

A A

Figure 5

A
A
Datum Feature Symbol For Datum Plane A
(Open or filled triangles)

Target area size


6 6
Target number
A1 A1 Alternate A1
If a datum point
Datum identity
Symbols for Datum Target Area and Point
A

This Means this

A1
Symbols for Datum Target Line
Figure 6

Technical Update 2D1 Hitchiner Manufacturing Co., Inc.


A1 A2 A3 C
A
C1
200

200 200
100 B
400 100
B1
75
B1 B2 B2
Dimensioning by Datum Target Points for a
Block. A is the Primary Datum Plane

6 6 6 A3 A Line Contact A3
A1 A2 A2

60

20 100 6mm Dia. Target


6 Areas, A1, A2
This
A3
A1 Means this

Primary Datum Plane is Established by


Two Target Areas and One Target Line
Figure 7

Hitchiner Manufacturing Co., Inc. • PO Box 2001 • Milford, NH 03055 • (603) 673-1100 • www.hitchiner.com

You might also like