Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chethana G Krishna*
Introduction
Hootsuite, the widely used social media platform in partnership with We Are Social,
a global social media agency, conducted a survey on ‘Social Media and Digital Trends’
across the world in 2016 and released the report ‘Digital in 2017’1 on January 24, 2017.
According to the study,
• Global Internet penetration stood at 3.77 billion users’ or covered 50% of the
world population.
– There were 2.80 billion social media users or 37% of the population, 2.56
billion users were using mobiles to access social media which meant 34%
penetration.
– 83% of Americans had a social media account.
†
This paper is a revised version of the paper presented at the International Communication Management
Conference (2018) at MICA, Ahmedabad on January 12, 2018.
* Assistant Professor, Department of Soft Skills, IBS Hyderabad (Under IFHE – A Deemed to be University
u/s 3 of the UGC Act, 1956), Hyderabad, Telangana, India. E-mail: chethana.krishna@gmail.com
1
Simon Kemp (2017), “Digital in 2017: Global Overview”, available at https://wearesocial.com/special-
reports/digital-in-2017-global-overview, January 24.
© 2018 IUP.
Starbucks All Rights Reserved.
Communication Strategies – More Than Just a Cup of Coffee 23
As per the study conducted by Jahn and Kunz2 , there are three main motivation
areas for consumers to use social networking sites.
• A relationship area, where the focus of the individual is to stay connected
and interact with others and participate in a social (online) life.
• Content acquisition and distribution based on the individuals’ interests.
• Self-presentation, which is related to the social context and for self-assurance
and personal identity.
When it comes to business, brands and marketing,3
• It was observed that 48% of Americans had interacted with one company or
institution over social media. Among those, 28% preferred to connect with
the brand or company first through social media rather than visiting a physical
store, 59% of Americans agreed that customer service via social media had
become easier.
• Facebook was considered number one as it had 1.65 billion users in 2016;
nearly 50 million businesses had Facebook pages, 2 million advertisers used
Facebook to market their brands and nearly 32% of Facebook users were
engaged with brands regularly.
• Instagram had the highest per follower engagement rate at 2.3% in comparison
with other social media networks; Instagram had 58 times more engagement per
follower than Facebook, with an order value at $65 from Instagram versus $55
from Facebook. A significant 68% of Instagram users engaged with brands
regularly.
This means that the Internet has complemented consumers to engage with brands.
The traditional one-to-many customer approach is evolving into a one-to-one approach
through social networks like Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, etc. Social media networks
have changed the traditional customer-company relationship in many ways and
companies cannot remain ignorant of this new channel of marketing communication.
Businesses are trying to recognize, research and explore the opportunities for brand
building through customer engagement from the fan pages in these virtual networks.
Marketing managers are attempting to integrate their traditional marketing with social
networks as part of their marketing mix.
The contemporary shopper is furthermore involved in conversations on social media,
is well informed and looks for reviews, comments and recommendations for making
a purchase or for service delivery. The avant-garde consumer expects the brands to listen
to his/her needs and fulfill them. The buyer is not merely looking for sales promotions
2
Jahn Benedict and Kunz Werner (2012), “How to Transform Consumers into Fans of your Brand”,
available at http://www.emeraldinsight.com/doi/pdfplus/10.1108/09564231211248444, February 19.
3
Kendall Walters (2016), “125+ Essential Social Media Statistics Every Marketer Should Know”, available
at https://blog.hootsuite.com/social-media-statistics-for-social-media-managers, November 30.
Starbucks India
Starbucks Corporation signed a 50:50 joint venture with Tata Global Beverages Ltd in
2012 and opened its first store in Mumbai’s Elphinstone Building, Horniman Circle.
The outlets are branded Starbucks “A Tata Alliance”. The coffee chain positions itself
not as a seller of coffee but to provide experience and create a “third attractive place”
beyond home and the workplace.10
9
Fortune names Starbucks 2017’s third most admired company in the world, available at
www.newsstarbucks,com, February 16, 2017.
10
Paul Leinwand and Varya Davidson (2016), “How Starbucks’ Culture Brings its Strategy to Life”,
available at www.hbr.org, December 30.
Literature Review
Customer Engagement
Customer engagement is defined as the relationship that a company tries to maintain
with its customer base to foster their loyalty and awareness. Peter Verhoef and Katherine
Lemon, in their book, Customer Value Management: Optimizing the Value of the Firm’s
Base, view that customer behavior goes “beyond transaction, and may be specifically
11
Moinak Mitra (2014), “How Starbucks is Localizing to Crack the Indian Coffee Chain Market”, available
at https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/magazines/corporate-dossier/how-starbucks-is-localizing-to-
crack-the-indian-coffee-chain-market/articleshow/38976431.cms, July 25.
12
Vandana Ahuja (2016), “Starbucks and Social Media: Striking a Chord with the Indian Consumer”,
available at http://www.digitalvidya.com/blog/starbucks-and-social-media-striking-a-chord-with-the-
indian-consumer/, April 4.
13
“Starbucks Opens 100th Store as it Completes 5 years in India”, available at www.moneycontrol.com,
October 25, 2017.
21
Shezray Husain et al. (2014), “Brewing Innovation”, available at http://www.businesstoday.in/magazine/
lbs-case-study/how-starbucks-survived-the-financial-meltdown-of-2008/story/210059.html, September
28.
22
Michael Welch and Jerome Buvat (2013), “Starbucks: Taking the ‘Starbucks Experience’ Digital”, Capgemini
Consulting.
23
Brian Roemmele (2014), “Why is the Starbucks Mobile Payments App so Successful”, available at
www.forbes.com, June 13, 2014.
24
Aaron Smith (2015), “Starbucks Goes Nationwide with Order-ahead App”, CNN Money, September 22.
Source: https://www.geekwire.com/2016/coffee-chatbot-starbucks-unveil-starbucks-barista
-ai-technology-placing-mobile-orders/
The mobile app called the ‘digital flywheel’ (backed by Artificial Intelligence) had
13 million active members in the Starbucks Rewards program during Q1 of 2017 with
an increase of 16% year on year. The Mobile Order and Pay app represented 7% of
the US Company-operated transactions during Q1 which was more than double in
comparison to the same quarter in 2016. The caffeinated Siri version of ‘My Starbucks
Barista’ was unveiled on the investor day in December 201625 to 1,000 users for limited
beta testing in early 2017. The company teamed up with Amazon Alexa to make coffee
ordering easier through voice facility. The new chatbot allowed loyal customers to place
multiple orders, gauge their preferences and habits from previous orders and thus
enhance customer engagement.
The company introduced the mobile app to Indian customers in May 2017 to facilitate
mobile payments, register for the Starbucks rewards program, earn stars, track and
redeem rewards, obtain information on products and promotions, etc.
25
Maggie McGrath (2017), “Starbucks Mobile Order Grows, but not Enough to Lift Q1 Sales above
Expectations”, available at www.forbes.com, January 26.
Facebook India
India’s digital landscape is also evolving due to government’s initiative on digital
development, the young and digitally-aware population, improved connectivity, growing
mobile penetration, digital payments and ecommerce is empowering India to become
a digitally powered economy.30 Groupon and Zomato were some of the companies who
tried to engage customers and provide personalized deals based on their browsing
patterns. This cost-effective ‘me-commerce’ pattern benefitted the marketer to focus on
the communication strategies and target the right customer. Customers are expressing
loyalty to their brands to obtain a better and customized brand experience.31 Flipkart,
28
Starbucks Frappuccino, available at www.facebook/frappuccino. Accessed on January 7, 2018.
29
Robert Brodo (2015), “Starbucks Growing by Innovative Marketing Strategies”, available at http://
www.advantexe.com/blog/business-acumen-review-starbucks-growing-through-innovative-marketing-
strategies, November 3.
30
“India Digital Customer Engagement, available at www.researchandmarkets.com, August 2017.
31
Jaisekhar Kothandaraman (2015), “The Changing Face of Customer Engagement in India”, available at
www.cxotoday.com, June 29, 2015.
Twitter
Starbucks official Twitter page, @starbucks, started in 2006, is a tool for customer service
(replacing customer service phone calls), marketing and public relations.34 Customers can
send in their ideas on the way the store operates, locations, new technology, etc. The
votes that support the idea is taken into account before implementation of the idea. The
customer who gave the idea also earns rewards. The customer has thus been involved
in future plans of the company with this Twitter handle. It helps Starbucks in two ways.
One, Starbucks need not conduct a research or an audience study before implementing
32
Srinivas Kulkarni (2013), “Indian Startup Aims to Improve Online Customer Engagement”, available at
www.zdnet.com, June 3, 2013.
33
Starbucks, www.facebook.com, January 6, 2018.
34
Mellison Allison (2009), “Starbucks’ Twitter Master Talks Shop, Gives Advice at Seattle Luncheon”,
available at www.seattletimes.com, November 11.
Twitter India
Starbucks India Twitter page @StarbucksIndia, started in November 2012, had 147K
followers, 1078 likes, 178 followers and 5,071 tweets in 2017. The webpage had 964
videos and photos. It posts offers, treats, merchandise, customer stories, new store alerts,
products and winners of contests, gifts and events. The likes in the Twitter page contained
user-generated content. Starbucks social media team responds to customer tweets on a
one-on-one basis and it acts as a tool to solve customer grievances.
Instagram
Starbucks operates the Instagram account like a fashion icon with a cool pop-coffee
culture. It recommends coffee depending on weather, feeling, and emotion through high
definition photos. Its target segment is mainly college students and young professionals.
There were 20 million people engaged from mid-July till September 29, 2016 with only
77 posts. It means Instagram received 270K engagement per post.36
35
www.twitter.com/starbucksgold, Accessed on January 6, 2018.
36
Tripti Shrivastava (2016), “How Starbucks Generates Over 270K in Engagement for Each Instagram
Post”, available at https://simplymeasured.com/blog/how-starbucks-generates-over-270k-in-engagement-
for-each-instagram-post/#sm.00012p19gv15eseziy5q4afmrgrmv, September 29.
Instagram India
The page had 24.3K followers with 276 posts.38 Pictures of products, flavors, new stores,
events, merchandise, festive offers, contests and customer experiences garnered likes
and comments. For example, Starbucks India posted “Infused with the spirit of
celebration, the Golden Sparkle Frappuccino has rich espresso layered on mocha base,
topped with whipped cream and sprinkled with an elegant gold-sugar dusting!
Try it at our stores tomorrow” on October 24, 2017. It received 3,922 views and 31
comments with at least 20 people expressing desire to try it out soon. One customer
complained about the product Double Shot Mocha that he received in one of the stores.
Starbucks India immediately responded to the issue and said that the customer care
team will get in touch with the customer. Thus Instagram also acts like a customer
service tool for the company. Starbucks India posted about the new store opening at
Vega City Mall in Bangalore for which one customer appreciated the amazing wall art
in that store. In short, customers not only want to consume their products but also
express satisfaction and experience the store offers in terms of service, interiors,
ambience, etc.
37
Starbucks, available at www.instagram.com, Accessed on January 8, 2018.
38
Starbucks India, available at www.instagram.com, Accessed on January 8, 2018.
YouTube India
Though the company is not posting anything exclusively for the Indian audience, there
were 480,000 posts by users, newspersons, vloggers, and others on YouTube India about
the company, products and experiences.
Pinterest
Starbucks has an official account on Pinterest as well. It had 24 boards and 328.7
thousand followers.41 The boards contain items like secret menu, recipes, refreshers,
latte and health which are pinned. For example, the board Coffee Recipes has 85 pins
and 264,000 followers. Shop Starbucks had 884 pins and around 260,000 followers.
The other theme boards are How To’s, Frappuccino, Food, Starbucks Card, Siren Love
and so on. The pages contain high definition images, clear descriptions and extremely
popular text-based graphics that incite customers to scroll for more. Customers (pinners)
get engaged as they scroll down without any interruption. Starbucks’ rich and appealing
pictures increase the number of pinners. However, Starbucks does not have a separate
official page for India.
Logo
The company could engage its customers just through the white and green Siren—the
twin tailed mermaid. The company tried to emphasize that it intends not only to serve
coffee but much more. Even though the words ‘Starbucks Coffee’ have been removed
from the logo, it has positioned it in the minds of the consumers that Starbucks means
coffee. It also means that the company is trying to reposition itself not only for coffee
but for other products as well.44
Trust
Starbucks does not have a slogan but relies on its mission statement that defines
their values: “Our mission to inspire and nurture the human spirit—one person,
one cup, and one neighborhood at a time”. The company maintains consistency in
all their products and stores worldwide. The company also believes in being
responsible in terms of taking care of their partners, sourcing their coffee beans
ethically, maintaining diversity, minimizing environmental footprint and community
development. The CEO Howard Schultz conveyed to all the partners on July 25,
2016, that the company had endured for decades because of its values and guiding
principles. The trust among the partners has connected the customers and the
communities they serve.
42
“Thanks to your Support Starbucks Baristas are Earning College Degrees”, available at www.1912pike.com/
collegeplan, May 14, 2017.
43
Mike (2016), “Starbucks Marketing – 9 Ways they Employ Social Media Innovation”, available at
www.digitalsparkmarketing.com/starbucksmarketing, January 12.
44
Nancy F Koehn (2011), “Starbucks Logo Debate Shows Customer Engagement”, available at www.hbr.org,
January 10.
Ideas Which Led to New Products and Partner and Customer Engagement
• MyStarbucksIdea was one of the earliest crowd sourcing platforms which, by
2011, had received 100,000 ideas; out of which 100 ideas were implemented
by 2013.45 The infograph (Figure 4) on customer engagement through My
Starbucks Idea is clearly depicted for 5 years (since 2008). 150,000 ideas were
received out of which 277 were implemented. The number of votes received
stood at a whopping 2,000,000.
• Thus the customers play a vital part in introducing new products in the
company. Starbucks saves on market research as the audience up votes indicate
acceptance.
• The Barista challenge is conducted every month at the Roastery and Tasting
Room at Seattle where basistas brew new drinks based on the theme of the
45
Shimeng Tong, “More than Coffee: Starbucks’ Social Media Presence Analysis”, available at https://
blogs.commons.georgetown.edu/st798/files/.../Starbucks-Shimeng-Tong.pdf
Source: http://smbp.uwaterloo.ca/2015/02/my-starbucks-idea-the-starbucks-crowdsourcing
-success-story/ February 12, 2015
month. The winner’s drink gets featured in the Starbucks reserve Roastery
Experience Bar. Similarly challenges are conducted across stores, districts,
states, country and region-wise in all their locations worldwide. This
encourages the partners to be innovative, feel connected to the company. The
company also benefits as it can include new flavors and menus in its stores.
• Though ‘My Starbucks Idea’ majorly gets ideas for new flavors from customers,
there were 6,000 suggestions to bring in a small serving of Frappuccino from
its fans. Starbucks noticed these discussions and introduced the mini serving
size for all Frappuccino flavors at a price of 10 ounce on May 11, 2015. 46
Kevin Johnson, CEO and President of Starbucks when presenting the highlights of
fiscal year 2017 emphasized that “Food, beverage and digital innovation are bringing
customers into our stores at the same time as ongoing operational improvements are
enabling us to drive increased throughput—particularly in our busiest stores at peak
—and deliver a further elevated Starbucks Experience to our customers.”47
Innovation in Campaigns
In late 2015, Starbucks introduced #RedCups on Twitter to herald the Christmas season
and spread cheer. A custom emoji appeared in every tweet that included #RedCups.
Videos, gifs and images were inserted to celebrate the range of festive drinks.48
Source: https://www.geekwire.com/2016/coffee-chatbot-starbucks-unveil-starbucks-barista-
ai-technology-placing-mobile-orders/ dated December 7, 2016
• Starbucks keeps its post vibrant with colors, peppy, funny and engaging. The
photos and videos are eye-catching and have high definition clarity.
• The company does not try to market but tries to build relationship with
customers by giving brands a personality or a human touch. The response
from the social media team does not appear to be scripted but natural and
spontaneous. The customer complaints are handled with great dexterity and
a solution to the problem is initiated.
• Each country is encouraged to maintain their own Facebook page. For example
Starbucks India has a separate Facebook page to engage its own customers.
• The loyalty program of Starbucks India rewards, which was initiated in 2014,
had 250,000 members in May 2017.
• Footfall: In the event to herald the 100th store was held on October 28, 2017,
4,200 customers took part and 8,700 indicated interest.
Objectives
This paper is an effort to look at how Starbucks:
• Employs social media and mobile app as its strategic partner to connect to
its store partners, influence customers and also create a fan following.
While we do not know much about Gen Z kids yet (Born: 1995-2012 Coming of
Age: 2013-2020), we know a lot about the environment they are growing up in. This
highly diverse environment will make the grade schools of the next generation the most
diverse ever. Higher levels of technology will make significant inroads into academics
allowing for customized instruction, data mining of student histories to enable pinpoint
diagnostics and remediation or accelerated achievement opportunities. Gen Z kids will
grow up with a highly sophisticated media and computer environment and will be more
Internet savvy and expert than their Gen Y forerunners.
All the numbers represented in the paper are directly taken from the social media
platforms. The responses of the consumers on the various pages were collected and
monitored. The number of ‘likes’, ‘retweets’, ‘number of shares’, ‘emojis’, ‘questions
aired and responses received from company people, influencers impact on audience
(especially in YouTube), participation and selfies of using the product on the Facebook
pages were done elaborately. Real time data was captured for two months from October
2017 to January 2018 on a daily basis.
100% of the sample were active on Facebook. The other social media pages in the
order of preference were Instagram and Twitter. Only 38% conveyed that they have
visited the Starbucks India Facebook page, 10% Instagram page and the rest have not
visited any of Starbucks India pages.
40% respondents who visited the Starbucks page conveyed that the promotional
offers and deals attracted them. 15% said that photos, logo, festive images, videos and
stories were creative and the page was very dynamic and responsive. All the respondents
indicated that they visited the page rarely (Figure 7).
When asked which product they usually purchase after looking at the page,
20% of them said they prefer coffee, Frappuccino, hot chocolate and 3% said ice
beverages. Only 10% indicated that they have recommended it to their family and
friends. Only 5% indicated that they belonged to two communities of Starbucks,
Starbucks India and Cherrydale Starbucks. 10% had availed the 100 offer on October
28, 2017 and 3% availed the 'buy one, get one free’ Holiday drink on September 13,
2017. The rest had not availed any promotional offers. None of them had contributed
to mystarbucks idea.
Product
Nearly 25% of the respondents conveyed that they would like to visit Starbucks to try
new flavors and customized drinks. Almost all of them voiced that Starbucks is
synonymous to coffee. Though Starbucks has several tea flavors introduced into its
menu, the Gen Y and Gen Z population would like to try out more variants of coffee.
Many would like to taste the virtual drink featured in the social media pages.
Pricing
70% of the respondents said that coffee is quite expensive for Indians. In fact the survey
‘Latte Index’ by a US consumer firm ValuePenguin on the price of a tall hot latte across
44 countries reported that Starbucks coffee in India stood 5th in its pricing53 as shown
in Figure 8.
53
“India Among the Most Expensive Places to Order a Starbucks Latte”, available at www.livemint,com,
May 12, 2017.
The respondents also suggested that Starbucks should reduce the price to attract
more customers from the middle class. However, the company has positioned itself as
a premium brand in India. 30% of the respondents expressed that they were ready to
bear the additional cost to experience the ambience and taste Starbucks products.
Place
Nearly 30% of the respondents conveyed that they would like to explore and experience
the ambience, the soothing music, the coffee aroma and to be a part of the young
community since Starbucks is majorly located in malls or upmarket places where the
presence of java crowd is the most. This was further emphasized by Manmeet Vora,
Director, Marketing and Category of Tata Starbucks that “As far as marketing is concerned,
the coffee chain continues to bet big on experiential marketing”. He stated, “For us, 95%
of our emphasis is on engagement marketing, not on passive, one-sided communication,
our focus is always on how to put engagement in the whole communication.”54
Promotion
The company conducts events in the form of celebrities and stand-up comedians
visiting the store and conducting games and contests. This was found very appealing
to nearly 80% of the respondents. Other offers like discounts, e-coupons, loyalty
programs, membership cards, Barista Bear, tote bags, limited edition gift sets, web
series and other customized merchandise, referral codes and Starbucks Pay enthused
54
Priyanka Nair (2016), “For Starbucks India, it is all About Creating the ‘Third Place’ Experience”,
available at www.economictimes.com, December 24.
People
20% of the respondents conveyed that the service quality, the take-away bags that create
livelihood opportunities to disabled people and plantation workers, introducing their
employees, social responsibility events, ethical sourcing of their coffee beans and the
feeling of empowerment when they suggest ideas make them emotionally attracted to
the company. The Starbucks social media team’s direct communication to each and every
customer, relatable, inspiring and engaging content and memes were highly appreciated
by all the millennials.
Process
Almost 40% of the respondents were overwhelmed to note that consistency was
maintained in all the stores with respect to taste along with service quality and
exceptional experience. The company’s eco-friendly products and ethical sourcing were
added attractions. They also found customized menu offerings in different locations of
the store like Delhi and Chennai.
Physical Evidence
The ambience of the store, the digital promotion techniques with physical evidence,
and viral campaigns by fans on seasonal flavors of summer such as Unicorn Frappuccino
spurred 60% of them to visit the store.
Conclusion
Companies try to build their social media base by increasing the number of fans.
Starbucks, on the other hand, has endeavored to build relationship and connections
with their fan base and less concentrated on number of fans, sales or revenue. Starbucks’
Alexander Wheeler conveyed that the firm’s social media strategy “isn’t a marketing
initiative. It isn’t a PR initiative. It’s cultivating and creating great consumer value and
great consumer relationships.”55 Starbucks consistently keeps its customers engaged by
offering deals, richer experience, interesting stories about their coffee brands and photos
of their merchandise. The company utilizes the key attributes of each social media
55
Ernan Roman (2013), “Starbucks: Social Media Revenue Based on Relationships”, available at https://
www.huffingtonpost.com/ernan-roman/starbucks-social-media-re_b_2426209.html, March 10.
56
“The Power of Like – How Social Media Works”, comScore and Facebook, available at www.comscore.com,
2011.
57
Ernan Roman, “Starbucks: Social media revenue based on relationships”, available at
www.huffingtonpost.com, December 6, 2017
58
Bernie Brennan and Lori Schafer (2010), Op. cit.
59
Michelle Lodge (2017), “Starbucks Will Soon Use this New Artificial Intelligence to Tempt you into
Buying More Coffee”, available at www.thestreet.com, July 30, 2017.
A survey is being conducted to understand how customers are engaged through the
social media strategies of Starbucks in engaging and influencing other customers,
improve footfall, purchases for the Gen Y and Gen Z Indian demography. We request
you to please complete the survey form.
Please tick the right option:
1. Age Group
18-24 years
25-35 years
35-45 years
2. Gender
Female
Male
3. Occupation
Student
Employed
Other
Below 5 lakh
5-10 lakh
10-20 lakh
9. Which product and brand of Starbucks do you purchase after looking at the
page?
10. How many people have you recommended to read the Starbucks page? On
which social media website?
11. Which community in the Starbucks page do you belong to?
12. Name the promo activities (offers/discounts) that you were a part of in the
last three months?
13. Have you contributed to their #mystarbucksidea. If Yes, please share the idea?
14. Which product pages/ brands make you engaged and look for more updates?
15. On which of the social media platforms do you share Starbucks content and
your experience?
16. List some suggestions for Starbucks to improve their social media pages?
Reference # 50J-2018-09-02-01