2/9/2019 Reformed Apologetics Ministries: One Muhammadan’s War against Allah and His “Messenger” Pt.
1
http://www.reformedapologeticsministries.com/2015/10/one-muhammadans-war-against-allah-and.html
2 captures
18 Oct 2015 - 3 Apr 2016
ABOUT
My name is Keith Thompson. I am
an apologist and documentary film
maker. I write for www.Answering-
Islam.org and am the owner of
Reformed Apologetics Ministries. I
can be reached at
keithtruth2010@hotmail.com.
Home Page
STORE
To enter our store & purchase our
documentary films on DVD click
HERE
ASSIST MINISTRY
DONATE ANY AMOUNT
DONATE SET AMOUNT
MONTHLY
Monthly Payments
Option 1 : $5.00 CAD - monthly
WATCH DOCUMENTARY FILMS
ONLINE
- Sword and the Crescent
- Atheists Don't Exist
- Purgatory Debunked
- Reformed Answers on the Roman
Corruption of Christianity
- Word of Faith Teachers: Origins &
Errors of Their Teaching
- Joel Osteen: Origins and Errors of
his Teaching
- Historical Case for Paul's
Apostleship: Critique of Muslim
Arguments
DEBATES & DISCUSSIONS
- Is Muhammad Predicted in the
Bible? (Keith Thompson vs.
Inamullah Mumtaz)
- Is Papal Primacy Primitive? (Keith
Thompson vs. Catholic Minister)
https://web.archive.org/web/20160403192403/http://www.reformedapologeticsministries.com/2015/10/one-muhammadans-war-against-allah-and.…
Go OCT APR MAY 👤 ⍰❎
03 f 🐦
2015 2016 2017 ▾ About this capture
Wednesday, October 14, 2015
One Muhammadan’s War against Allah and His “Messenger” Pt. 1
By Sam Shamoun
Here begins a series of articles where I will be citing from Shabir Ally’s debates and
lectures, primarily from his recent exchanges with Christian apologist and philosopher
David Wood, in order to show how Ally makes statements and claims which end up
condemning Muhammad as a false prophet. As a result of his blatant inconsistencies
and uncritical thinking (at times), Ally says things that prove quite damaging to the
credibility of Muhammad and which even call into question his moral integrity.  
As an example of such damage, in one of his debates with Wood I had called in
challenging Ally to address the fact that his prophet condoned temporary marriages
called muta, marriages done for the sole purpose of gratifying the sexual lusts of Muslim
men. What makes these so-called marriages so shameful is that the Muslim men
knowingly marry women for a short designated time which both parties agree to, and
for a sum of money or some other form of compensation that the men are required to
give for the sexual services provided by these women. Such marriages are nothing more
than prostitution, plain and simple.  
A Muslim youtuber has done us all a favor by actually taking my brief exchange with Ally
and turning into a short clip for all to see and hear (Is Muta (Temporary Marriage)
allowed in Islam?).
I had mentioned the criteria that the Lord Jesus gave in Matthew 7:15-20, a text which
Ally himself alluded to in defense of Muhammad’s prophetic claims, where the Lord
stated that a false prophet will be known by the rotten and evil fruits he produces. I then
mentioned certain narrations from Sahih al-Bukhari concerning this issue of muta, citing
them as an example of a very rotten and reprehensible fruit which calls into question
Muhammad’s prophethood, and asked Ally how he could justify such a gross distortion
and perversion of marriage, which in reality is nothing more than prostitution.
Here is what I was referring to:
Narrated Jabir bin ‘Abdullah and Salama bin Al-Akwa': While we were in an army,
Allah's Apostle came to us and said, "You have been allowed to do the Mut’a
(marriage), so do it." Salama bin Al-Akwa' said: Allah's Apostle's said, "If a man and
a woman agree (to marry temporarily), their marriage should last for three nights,
and if they like to continue, they can do so; and if they want to separate, they can
do so." I do not know whether that was only for us or for all the people in general.
Abu Abdullah (Al-Bukhari) said: ‘Ali made it clear that the Prophet said, "The Mut’a
marriage has been cancelled (made unlawful)." (Sahih al-Bukhari, Volume 7, Book
62, Number 52)
Narrated Abdullah:
We used to participate in the holy battles led by Allah's Apostle and we had
nothing (no wives) with us. So we said, "Shall we get ourselves castrated?" He
forbade us that and then allowed us to marry women with a temporary contract
and recited to us: -- ‘O you who believe! Make not unlawful the good things
which Allah has made lawful for you, but commit no transgression.’ (5.87) (Sahih
al-Bukhari, Volume 7, Book 62, Number 13o)
1/6
2/9/2019 Reformed Apologetics Ministries: One Muhammadan’s War against Allah and His “Messenger” Pt. 1
- Is the Roman Catholic Papacy
http://www.reformedapologeticsministries.com/2015/10/one-muhammadans-war-against-allah-and.html
2 captures
Biblical and Historical? (Keith
Thompson vs. Roman Catholic)
18 Oct 2015 - 3 Apr 2016
- Papal Primacy and Canon Debate
(Keith Thompson vs. Catholic)
- Is Justification by Faith Alone?
(Keith Thompson vs. Catholic Peter
Dimond)
- Is Paul a True Apostle? (Keith
Thompson vs. Muslim Nadir Ahmed)
- Does the Immaculate Conception
Contradict Scripture and History?
(Keith Thompson vs. Richard a
Roman Catholic)
- Catholic Apologist Admits he can't
Historically Prove Peter was First
Roman Bishop & More (Keith
Thompson vs. Fidei Defensor SPQR)
-Infant Baptism Debate: Chris
Gautreau vs. Zachary Kueker
(written debate)
- Is God Sovereign Over All? (Chris
Gautreau vs. FaithandPractice)
- Is Christianity a Religion of Peace?
(Keith Thompson vs. Muslim Sami
Zaatari)
- Discussion with two Catholics on
Interpreting Scripture
- Is Free Will Biblical? (Keith
Thompson vs. Charismatic
Arminian)
- Is Original Sin Biblical? (Keith
Thompson vs. Two Pelagians)
- Does the New Testament Teach the
Deity of Jesus? (Keith Thompson vs.
Yuratchka the Arian)
- Does Scripture Teach
Predestination? (Keith Thompson vs.
Arminian - very short)
VIDEO TEACHINGS
- Josephus and Tacitus on Christ: An
Analysis
- Refuting the Lie John Invented
Sayings of Jesus
- Shabir Ally & Raymond Brown’s
Redaction Criticism of John
- Answering Muslims: Is Jesus a Son
Among Tons?
- Refuting Bart Ehrman’s “Passion
Contradictions” Muslims Parrot
- How Salvation Works: Plain and
Simple
- Catholic Idol Worshiper's Big
Justification Lie
- Jesus Sent for Jews Only?:
Answering Muslims
- Old Testament Genocide?:
Answering "Atheists"
- The Bible and Slavery: Answering
"Atheists"
- Absurdities of Youtube Atheist
"CultofDusty"
- Absurdities of Youtube Atheist
“Thunderf00t”
- Absurdities of Youtube Atheist
"AronRa"
- 20 Reasons to Never Join Islam
- The Bible Teaches Original Sin
- Whalid Shoebat’s Son’s “Christian
Militancy” Teaching Refuted
- Proof Virgin Mary is not the Ark of
the Covenant
-Brief Explanation of Calvinism
- Jeffrey Daugherty's "Apostle Paul
Antichrist" Theory Debunked
- Refutation of Heretic Jesse
Morrell's Documentary "Beyond
Augustine" part 1, 2
- Myth of Imputed Righteousness of
Christ? Answering Heretic Jesse
https://web.archive.org/web/20160403192403/http://www.reformedapologeticsministries.com/2015/10/one-muhammadans-war-against-allah-and.…
Tragically, there were some instances
in which women evenGogotOCT
pregnant through such
APR MAY 👤 ⍰ ❎
immoral unions: 03 f 🐦
2015 2016 2017 ▾ About this capture
Yahya related to me from Malik from Ibn Shihab from Urwa ibn az-Zubayr that
Khawla ibn Hakim came to Umar ibn al-Khattab and said, "Rabia ibn Umayya
made a temporary marriage with a woman and she is pregnant by him." Umar ibn
al-Khattab went out in dismay dragging his cloak, saying, "This temporary
marriage, had I come across it, I would have ordered stoning and done away
with it!" (Malik’s Muwatta, Book 28, Number 28.18.42)
Ally started out his response by first calling into question the historical veracity of al-
Bukhari’s reports, arguing that these may have been something which the hypocrites
concocted and managed to dupe the Muslims into believing that they actually came
from Muhammad himself!
To show you just how desperate and weak Ally’s explanation is, notice what Muslim
scholars have stated concerning Al-Bukhari’s work and the stringent method he
employed to insure the veracity of every report that made it into his collection.
It has been UNANIMOUSLY AGREED that Imam Bukhari's work is the most authentic
of all the other works in Hadith literature PUT TOGETHER. The authenticity of Al-
Bukhari's work is such that the religious learned scholars of Islam said concerning
him: "The most authentic book after the Book of Allah (i.e., Al-Qur'an) is Sahih Al-
Bukhari."… Before he recorded each Hadith he would make ablution and offer
two Rak’at prayer and supplicate his Lord (Allah). Many religious scholars of Islam
tried to find fault in the great remarkable collection- Sahih Al-Bukhari, BUT WITHOUT
SUCCESS. It is for this reason, they UNANIMOUSLY AGREED that the most authentic
book after the Book of Allah IS Sahih Al-Bukhari. (Translation of the Meanings of
Sahih al-Bukhari, Arabic-English, translated by Dr. Muhammad Muhsin Khan,
Formerly Director, University Hospital, Islamic University, Al-Madina Al-Munawwara
(Kingdom of Saudi Arabia), [Dar-us-Salam Publishers & Distributors, Riyadh-Saudi
Arabia, July, 1997], Volume 1, pp. 18-19; bold and capital emphasis ours) 
The following citations are taken from the Islamic Awareness team's response to fellow
Christian writer and apologist Andrew Vargo's criticism of Imam al-Bukhari's compilation:
* The two sahîh collections did not gather the totality of the authentic
ahâdîth as proved by al-Bukhârî's testimony: "I have not included in my
book al-Jâmic but what is authentic, and I left out among the authentic for
fear of [excessive] length.(Footnote 2)"
Footnote 2 says:
He [al-Bukhârî] meant that he did not mention all the turuq [parallel chains
of transmission] for each and every hadîth.[1]
To reiterate this in elementary English for the neophyte, Imâm al-Bukhârî selected
only a few authentic ahâdîth from his vast collection. However, he left out certain
traditions, despite their authenticity, simply to avoid excessive length and
repetition in his al-Jâmic (a discussion about which is given below). If anything, the
privilege to make such a gesture is highly complimentary to the authenticity of
the Islamic traditions. In another tradition, Imâm al-Bukhârî is also reported to have
said:
He said, I heard as-Sacdânî say, I heard some of our companions say,
Muhammad Ibn Ismâcîl said: I selected/published [the content of] this book
- meaning the Sahih book - from about 600,000 hadîths/reports. Abû Sacd
al-Mâlînî informed us that cAbdullâh Ibn cUdayy informed us: I heard al-
Hasan Ibn al-Husayn al-Bukhârî say: "I have not included in my book al-
Jâmic but what is authentic, and I left out among the authentic what I could
not get hold of."[2]
And:
Imâm al-Bukhârî's collection of ahâdîth was maintained to be authentic on
account of his authority, and it has been maintained as authentic EVER SINCE. The
neophyte's assertion, that Imâm al-Bukhârî regarded almost 99% of his own
collection as spurious, is among the most rash and foolhardy statements ever
dared by a Christian missionary. On the contrary, the 7,397 refers to the number of
hadîths that Imâm al-Bukhârî chose to include in his al-Jâmic and left out many
authentic narrations from his vast collection for the fear of excessive length.
…Regardless, we will quote the famous trial of Imâm al-Bukhârî to show how
Maqlub[8] (changed, reversed) ahadîth can be identified with ease by a scholar
of hadîth:
2/6
2/9/2019 Reformed Apologetics Ministries: One Muhammadan’s War against Allah and His “Messenger” Pt. 1
Morrell
http://www.reformedapologeticsministries.com/2015/10/one-muhammadans-war-against-allah-and.html
2 captures
- A Biblical Case for Determinism:
God's sovereignty over all (Chris
18 Oct 2015 - 3 Apr 2016
Gautreau)
- Defending Reformed View of John
6 - Refuting Heretic Kerrigan Skelly
- Was Judas Once a Saved True
Believer? - Refuting Heretic
Kerrigan Skelly
- Theory on the Origins of Papal
Infallibility
-Answers to Theological Questions
Posed by YouTube Subscribers - part
1, 2, 3
ARTICLES
Islam
- The Reliability of the Gospel of
John
- Comprehensive Case Jesus Died by
Crucifixion
- Are the Gospels too late and
Unreliable?
- Original Sources the Koran Stole
its Stories from
- The Corruption of the Koran:
Evidence and New Research
- Muhammad Taught and Practiced
Offensive Jihad
- Are Muhammad and Islam
Predicted in the Bible?
- Errors in the Koran and Ahadith
- Evidence Muhammad was Demon
Possessed
- Jesus as God Before Paul
- Some Absurd and Silly Teachings of
Muhammad
- Refuting Bart Ehrman’s “Passion
Contradictions” Muslims Parrot
- Jesus Sent for Jews Only?:
Answering Muslims
- 20 Reasons to Never Join Islam
- Is Christianity a Religion of Peace?
- Who Wrote the Gospels? Internal
and External Arguments for
Traditional Authorship
- Answering Sami Zaatari on the
Pharisaic Accusation that Christ
Claimed Deity
- A Case for the Deity of Christ in
Light of Muslim Objections
- The Historical Case for Paul's
Apostleship: And a Critique of
Muslim Arguments
- Muhammad's Condition in Light of
the Biblical Description of Demonic
Possession
- Christ’s Deity in Light of not
Knowing the Day & Hour of His
Return
- Daniel 7:13-14 and Christ’s Deity:
Answering Ibn Anwar’s Eisegesis
- The Historicity of the Appearance
to the 500 in 1 Corinthians 15:6
- Muslim Misuse of Hebrews 5:7:
Does This Verse Teach Jesus Never
Died?
- Ibn Anwar’s False Charge of
Anachronistic Error: An Exegetical
Examination of Mark 2:26
- Ibn Anwar’s False Charge of
Anachronistic Error: An Exegetical
Examination of Mark 2:26, Part 2
- Jesus as Divine Judge: A Response
to the Muhammedan Site “Do Not
Say Trinity”
- Bart Ehrman: A Hero For Islam?
- Is Asking “Where did Jesus say, ‘I
am God’” a Good Argument?
- Revisiting “Where Did Jesus Say ‘I
https://web.archive.org/web/20160403192403/http://www.reformedapologeticsministries.com/2015/10/one-muhammadans-war-against-allah-and.…
Go OCT APR MAY
👤 ⍰❎
The famous trial of al-Bukhârî by the scholars of Baghdad03 provides a good f 🐦
example of a Maqlûb isnâd. The traditionists, in order to test their
2015 2016visitor,
2017 al-Bukhârî,
▾ About this capture
appointed ten men, each with ten ahâdîth. Now, each hadîth (text) of these ten
people was prefixed with the isnâd of another. Imâm al-Bukhârî listened to each
of the ten men as they narrated their ahâdîth and denied the correctness of
every hadîth. When they had finished narrating these ahâdîth, he addressed
each person in turn and recounted to him each of his ahâdîth with its correct
isnâd. This trial earned him great honour among the scholars of Baghdad.[9] (On
The Nature Of Hadith Collections Of Imam Al-Bukhari & Muslim; bold, capital and
underline emphasis ours)
The foregoing should make it abundantly clear that al-Bukhari would not include
anything which he suspected was fraudulent or that didn’t meet his criteria for
authenticity.(1) Therefore, since he did include these reports about Muhammad
basically prostituting women under the guise of temporary marriage, this means that
they all must have met al-Bukhari’s very strict specifications and that he was obviously
fully convinced of their historical veracity.
So did Imam Muslim since he too included these narrations about temporary marriages:
Abdullah (b. Mas'ud) reported: We were on an expedition with Allah's Messenger
and we had no women with us. We said: Should we not have ourselves
castrated? He (the Holy Prophet) forbade us to do so He then granted us
permission that we should contract temporary marriage for a stipulated period
giving her a garment, and 'Abdullah then recited this verse: 'Those who believe
do not make unlawful the good things which Allah has made lawful for you, and
do not transgress. Allah does not like trangressers" (al-Qur'an, v. 87). (Sahih Muslim,
Book 008, Number 3243)
Rabi' b. Sabra reported that his father went on an expedition with Allah's
Messenger during the Victory of Mecca, and we stayed there for fifteen days (i. e.
for thirteen full days and a day and a night), and Allah's Messenger permitted us
to contract temporary marriage with women. So I and another person of my tribe
went out, and I was more handsome than he, whereas he was almost ugly. Each
one of us had a cloak, My cloak was worn out, whereas the cloak of my cousin
was quite new. As we reached the lower or the upper side of Mecca, we came
across a young woman like a young smart long-necked she-camel. We said: Is it
possible that one of us may contract temporary marriage with you? She said:
What will you give me as a dower? Each one of us spread his cloak. She began to
cast a glance on both the persons. My companion also looked at her when she
was casting a glance at her side and he said: This cloak of his is worn out, whereas
my cloak is quite new. She, however, said twice or thrice: There is no harm in
(accepting) this cloak (the old one). So I contracted temporary marriage with her,
and I did not come out (of this) until Allah's Messenger declared it forbidden.
(Sahih Muslim, Book 008, Number 3253)
Sahih Muslim even includes a report which states that muta was still being observed all
the way up until the time of Umar’s caliphate:
Ibn Uraij reported: 'Ati' reported that Jabir b. Abdullah came to perform 'Umra,
and we came to his abode, and the people asked him about different things,
and then they made a mention of temporary marriage, whereupon he said: Yes,
we had been benefiting ourselves by this temporary marriage during the lifetime
of the Holy Prophet and during the time of Abu Bakr and ‘Umar. (Sahih Muslim,
Book 008, Number 3248)
Now what makes these hadiths from Sahih Muslim all the more interesting is that, not only
has this collection been deemed as thoroughly reliable by the consensus of the greatest
Muslim scholars that have ever lived, some of these very scholars have even gone as far
as to argue that in some respects Sahih Muslim is actually superior to the hadith
collection of Sahih al-Bukhari!
“… Although Sahih al-Bukhari is the most reliable collection of Ahadith, however,
Sahih Muslim has certain aspects of superiority. Imam Muslim adhered strictly to
most of the principles of the Science of Hadith which were somehow at some
places ignored by his teacher Imam Bukhari. Imam Muslim accepted for his
collection only such Ahadith which had been transmitted with an unbroken chain
of reliable narrators, free from all defects and were in perfect harmony with the
narrations of other narrators. He has recorded only those ahadith which were
transmitted at least by two different transmitters from two different Companions.
Imam Bukhari has sometimes used the Kunyah (surname) of the narrators and
sometimes their names. Imam Muslim avoided this confusion. Imam Muslim is also
particular in pointing out the slightest difference in the text of the narrations. Imam
3/6
2/9/2019 Reformed Apologetics Ministries: One Muhammadan’s War against Allah and His “Messenger” Pt. 1
am God’" A Response to the
http://www.reformedapologeticsministries.com/2015/10/one-muhammadans-war-against-allah-and.html
2 captures
Muhammedan Site “Do Not Say
Trinity"
18 Oct 2015 - 3 Apr 2016
- Contra Paul Williams on the Death
Penalty for Apostasy & Christianity
- Heaven vs. Jannah: Assessing the
Dilemma
- Does Muhammad Pass the 1 John 4
Prophethood Test?
- Historical and Biblical Basis for
the Trinity
- Five Reasons Why Jesus is Not
Merely a Prophet
- Answering “Jesus isn’t God
because God doesn’t change”
Catholicism
- Did Roman Catholicism Give
Protestants the Bible?
- Are Roman Catholics Saved?
- Refutation of Papal Infallibility
- Biblical Evidence Against Peter
being Pope
- Does Matthew 16 Teach Peter was
the Pope?
- Do John 21:15-17 and Luke 22:31-
32 prove Peter was Pope?
- Biblical Evidence for Sola
Scriptura
- Refuting Rome's Biblical Case for
Extrabiblical Tradition
- The Early Church Fathers Taught
Sola Scriptura
- The Bible does not teach Mary's
Immaculate Conception
- Mary is not the Ark and Tabernacle
- The Early Church did not Believe
Rome’s Doctrine of the Immaculate
Conception of Mary
-Mary is not Co-redemptrix,
Mediatrix of all Graces, and
Advocate
- Some of Roman Catholicism's
worst Atrocities and Abominations of
History
- Baptismal Regeneration &
Justification are False
- Refuting the Catholic Priesthood
and Penance
- Proof the Roman Catholic Mass is
unbiblical and anti-Christian
- Historical Examination of Roman
Catholic Eucharist Theology
- Biblical and Historical Refutation
of Purgatory
- Refutation of Inclusivism: Non-
Christians can not be saved by works
- Justification is by Faith Alone:
Issues and Evidence
- “Works” and “Works of the Law”
in Paul: Interacting with Modern
Catholic Reliance on New
Perspectivism
-Peter Dimond’s Not-So-Stunning
Acts 15 Video
-Peter Dimond LIED about
dikaiosune - Plus Debate Challenge
- Responding to
catholicapologetics.info’s “Some
Tough Questions for Protestants”
- An Articulation of Sola Scriptura:
The Biblical Basis for the Sufficiency
of the Holy Scriptures
- Questions Regarding the Mass
- Catholic Misuse of Genesis 3:15
- Is The Jewish Apocrypha Inspired
Scripture? Pt. 1
- Is The Jewish Apocrypha Inspired
Scripture? Pt. 2
- Is The Jewish Apocrypha Inspired
Scripture? Pt. 3
https://web.archive.org/web/20160403192403/http://www.reformedapologeticsministries.com/2015/10/one-muhammadans-war-against-allah-and.…
Bukhari has fragmented most of the Ahadith and presented
Go OCT APR the portions
MAY under
👤 ⍰ ❎
different chapters, while Imam Muslim presented them as a whole 03 narration. So, f 🐦
the works of both Imams provide different approaches 2015for2016
the2017
scholars▾ and
About this capture
readers of Ahadith.” (The Translation of the Meanings of Summarized Sahih
Muslim, Publisher’s Note, Volume 1, p. ii; bold emphasis ours)
And:
“Imam Muslim compiled many books and treatises on Hadith, the most important
of his works is the compilation of the Hadith collection Al-Jami‘ As-Sahih, which is
famous by the name of Sahih Muslim. Some scholars of Hadith opine that in some
respects IT IS THE BEST AND MOST AUTHENTIC COLLECTION of Ahadith. Imam
Muslim laboriously collected 300,000 Ahadith, but after critical study, he selected
only 4,000 Ahadith for this collection…
“Many students learned the Science of Hadith from Imam Muslim. Those who
became famous and occupied a prominent position are: Abu Hatim Razi, Musa
bin Harun, Ahmad bin Salamah, Abu ‘Isa Tirmidhi, Abu Bakr bin Khuzaimah, Abu
‘Awanah and Hafiz Dhahbi.” (Ibid., p. v; bold and capital emphasis ours).
Note that these are the very sources that Ally has no qualms throwing under the bus
whenever they prove too damaging for his position. This is precisely why I accused Ally
of preaching Hislam, e.g., his version of Islam, as opposed to actual Islam, since he
presents an Islam that doesn’t exist in reality and which isn’t anchored in its primary
sources. Rather Ally’s HISlam only exists in his own wishful thinking.
Be that as it may, this now creates a major dilemma for Ally. Since these traditions are
found in both collections of Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim, this shows that they met
the rather rigorous and stringent criteria of authenticity of both of these renowned
hadith masters and compilers. To put this simply, both of these renowned hadith scholars
were fully persuaded that these reports of Muhammad permitting temporary marriages
actually go back to him. When we add to the fact that the traditions concerning
temporary marriages are found in all the rest of the major hadith collections, i.e., Abu
Dawud, Ibn Majah, Tirmidhi etc., then the problem becomes even more complicated
for Ally since he is going to have to do a whole lot more than simply brush these
narratives aside as questionable.  Ally has no choice but to contend with the fact that
according to the very strict methodology employed by the leading scholars on hadiths
and their authenticity, these narrations concerning muta definitely go back to the
historical Muhammad (that is, as far as Islamic historiography and hadith criticism are
concerned).
However, this is the least of Ally’s problems. Ally went on to claim that Sunni Muslims have
prohibited muta on the grounds of it being classified as adultery. Pay careful attention
to what he said:
“When it comes to temporary marriage, the Sunni Muslim scholars say that this is
not allowed and that it is akin to adultery and fornication, whereas the Shi'i
scholars allow it. And the passages you cited, if you correctly cited them–I am not
familiar with these–then this would reflect that view. And the fact that it is found in
the Sunni book, does not mean that it cannot support an early view which later
on Sunnis would not come to accept.”
Notice that the reason why Sunnis reject temporary marriage according to Ally is
because, “IT IS AKIN TO ADULTERY AND FORNICATION”!
Ally has essentially accused both Muhammad and his followers of being a group of
adulterers and fornicators, since the Sunni sources confirm that all of them were
performing muta for years and years before it was made impermissible! Ally’s claim also
means that Muhammad and his companions were all guilty of degrading women by
treating them as prostitutes.
I am going to break this all down so the readers can see how Ally has basically accused
his own prophet of being an adulterer and fornicator without even realizing it.
A. Sunni Islam’s earliest and most reliable sources confirm that Muhammad
sanctioned temporary marriage for a period of time.
B. According to Ally, the reason why Sunni scholars have forbidden temporary
marriage is because it is nothing more than adultery and fornication.
C. Therefore, according to the position of these scholars whom Ally appealed to,
Muhammad and his companions all stand condemned for committing adultery
and fornication, since they all carried out temporary marriages for many years
before someone decided to abrogate this reprehensible and immoral practice.
D. This in turn means that Muhammad and his followers treated women as prostitutes
since they paid certain women to marry them for a short period of time solely for
4/6
2/9/2019 Reformed Apologetics Ministries: One Muhammadan’s War against Allah and His “Messenger” Pt. 1
- Appendix: Addressing Some sex. They had no intention of marrying them permanently.
http://www.reformedapologeticsministries.com/2015/10/one-muhammadans-war-against-allah-and.html Go OCT APR MAY 👤 ⍰ ❎
2 captures
Arguments in Support of the 03 and fornicators f 🐦
E. Ally’s response also turns Shi’a Muslims into a bunch of adulterers
Apocrypha
18 Oct 2015 - 3 Apr 2016 since, as he himself admits, Shi’a Islam still permits temporary
2015marriages.
2016 2017 ▾ About this capture

Other
- Josephus and Tacitus on Christ: An
Analysis
- The Bible and Slavery: Answering
“Atheists”
- Failure of False Religions to
Account for Human Experience
-Youtube Pelagian Sinless Perfection
Cult Redefines Sin
-Whalid Shoebat’s Son’s “Christian
Militancy” Teaching Refuted
- The Bible Teaches Original Sin
- Jeffrey Daugherty’s “Apostle Paul
Antichrist” Theory Debunked
- Jesus' Imputed Righteousness: An
Exegetical Case
- Refutation of Jesse Morrell’s
Documentary “Beyond Augustine”
- Refutation of Jesse Morrell's
Documentary "Beyond Augustine"
Part 2
- Assessing the Isaiah 7:14 Virgin
Birth Prophecy
Click here for Sam Shamoun's
Essays
Blog Archive
►
► 2016 (30)
▼
▼ 2015 (64)
►
► December (8)
Way to go Shabir! 
Therefore, in his zeal to defend the indefensible Ally ended up condemning his own
prophet as an adulterer and fornicator, and for treating women as prostitutes (albeit
indirectly).
Lord willing, we will be posting more of Ally’s indirect assaults against his messenger in
the near future.
Endnotes
(1) It needs to be emphasized that just because these narratives satisfied al-Bukhari’s
criteria for authenticity doesn’t prove that this somehow makes it a genuine saying of
Muhammad. It simply means that those who claim to be Sunni Muslims like Shabir must
contend with the fact that these reports met al-Bukhari’s strict and rigorous standards of
reliability and therefore cannot simply be dismissed and brushed aside. Furthermore,
without these sources Muslims such as Shabir cannot make heads or tails out of much of
the Quran since a great bulk of it is quite unintelligible. In fact, it is these same collections
of traditions that inform Ally how to pray, fast, dress, perform the Hajj, the amount of alms
one is to give etc., all of which he takes advantage of and acts upon. And yet
whenever these same sources prove too damaging for his cause and call into question
Muhammad’s prophethood, Ally will not hesitate to attack their reliability.
This merely exemplifies the circular nature of Ally’s approach, i.e., assuming that
Muhammad was a true prophet and therefore wouldn’t utter such nonsense or engage
in and/or permit/promote gross immorality. It also proves that Ally is not interested in the
religion of Islam as has been historically understood and practiced by the greatest
Muslim scholars of the past fourteen hundred years. Rather, Ally is more concerned
about spreading the message of HISlam, e.g., his version of Islam which only exists in his
own mind.   

►
► November (15)
Posted by Keith Thompson at 12:21 PM
▼
▼ October (21)
The Reliability of the Gospel
of John
2 comments:
Jesus Christ – The Divine
King of Kings and Holy O...
Jesse October 14, 2015 at 3:34 PM
One Muhammadan’s War
against Allah and His Sam, thank you for this excellent post, but I may have to disagree with you here. I really don't think Shabir is
“Messen... the moderate Muslim he claims to be. He may claim publicly to disagree with Bukhari and act like all these
One Muhammadan’s War Hadith are unreliable, but does he really mean it? I think he is pretending. After watching the final debate
against Allah and His with David on wether the Bible is a book of violence, It became very apparent that he is simply a
“Messen... propagandist, sowing disinformation. Two things revealed this. One, his willingness to lie about David. Are
How can Jesus be God if He we really to believe that after Shabirs' ridiculous accusation that David is somehow benefitting from Islamic
Himself Worshiped God? ... Terrorism, and David responds with sarcasm, that Shabir thought he was serious? Shabir proved he is
dubious, dishonest, and that he is willing to twist truth for his own agenda. Two, his shameless promotion of
How can Jesus be God if He the Palestinian cause without any context, acting as if Zionism is the only reason for the problems in Israel
Himself Worshiped God? ...
and not Islam, with its deep rooted anti-semitism. Honestly, I was greatly disappointed by Shabir. I wanted to
How can Jesus be God if He believe he is actually intellectually honest, trying to promote a real of moderate Islam. Not only did he
Himself Worshiped God? ... utterly fail to do this, but he also proved to be just another of countless dawa preachers, willing to twist truth
One Muhammadan’s War shamelessly. Keep going with this series, it is needed! But people should understand that these guys are
against Allah and His willing to lie to advance Islam and make it palatable for the Western public. Do you think he is engaging in
“Messen... taqiyya, deliberate disinformation? Thanks for all you do!
Turning the Tables Pt. 5 Reply
Comprehensive Case Jesus
Died by Crucifixion
Are the Gospels too late and CallingMuslims October 15, 2015 at 1:11 PM
Unreliable?
Great article as always, Sam is a sword in the hand of Christ, but I have to ask sincerely is Shabir even a
Original Sources the Koran Muslim at this point? I would like to point out according to the Quran:
Stole its Stories from
The Corruption of the Koran: Surah 5:54 "... And whoever does not judge by what Allah has revealed – then it is those who are the
Evidence and New Rese... disbelievers."
Muhammad Taught and
Practiced Offensive Jihad Ahlus Sunnah Wal Jamaah (historic orthodox Sunni Islam) has agreed the authentic hadeeth also contain
what Allah has revealed. And its only the rightful authorities i.e the People of Knowledge ..Islamic scholars
Are Muhammad and Islam with accreditation from other scholars ... who can rule what's authentic and what's not or whats Islamic...
Predicted in the Bible?
since they know the Quran and Sunnah and have a trust to preserve that knowledge.
Errors in the Koran and
Ahadith “And ask the people of knowledge when you do not know.” Surah 16:43
Some Absurd and Silly
Teachings of Muhammad Shabir is a lost man in so many ways, he definitely needs someone to save him. May the Good Lord have
mercy on him.
Evidence Muhammad was
Demon Possessed

https://web.archive.org/web/20160403192403/http://www.reformedapologeticsministries.com/2015/10/one-muhammadans-war-against-allah-and.… 5/6
2/9/2019 Reformed Apologetics Ministries: One Muhammadan’s War against Allah and His “Messenger” Pt. 1
Reply
http://www.reformedapologeticsministries.com/2015/10/one-muhammadans-war-against-allah-and.html
Jesus as God Before Paul Go OCT APR MAY 👤 ⍰❎
2 captures How can Jesus be God if He 03 f 🐦
18 Oct 2015 - 3 Apr 2016 2015 2016 2017 ▾ About this capture
Himself Worshiped God? ...
MORE GROANS FOR
SHABIR ALLY

►
► September (9)
►
► August (6)
►
► June (1)
►
► April (1)
►
► February (1)
►
► January (2)

►
► 2014 (39)
►
► 2013 (20)
► Newer Post Home Older Post
► 2012 (25)
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Simple template. Powered by Blogger.

https://web.archive.org/web/20160403192403/http://www.reformedapologeticsministries.com/2015/10/one-muhammadans-war-against-allah-and.… 6/6