Republic of the Philippines

MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES

Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Case No. 16166
Plaintiff,
-versus- -for-
ROSEMARIE CARANDANG y CARPIO, ORAL DEFAMATION
Accused.
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------X
MINUTES
of the SESSION held on Nov. 27, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.
PRESENT:
HON. CYRUS B. GOCO ---------------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano ---------------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi ---------------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo ---------------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira ---------------- Process Server
APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
---------------- For the Accused

ARRAIGNMENT AND PRE-TRIAL

WITNESSES:

MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE:

REMARKS:

CONTINUATION OF HEARING:

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO

Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV
COUNSELS:

Prosecutor Counsel for the Accused

 Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES
Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Case No. 16167
Plaintiff,
-versus- -for-
ROSEMARIE CARANDANG y CARPIO, OTHER LIGHT THREATS
Accused.
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------X
MINUTES
of the SESSION held on Nov. 27, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.
PRESENT:
HON. CYRUS B. GOCO ---------------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano ---------------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi ---------------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo ---------------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira ---------------- Process Server
APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
---------------- For the Accused

ARRAIGNMENT AND PRE-TRIAL

WITNESSES:

MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE:

REMARKS:

CONTINUATION OF HEARING:

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO

Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV
COUNSELS:

Prosecutor Counsel for the Accused

 Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES
Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Case No. 16171
Plaintiff,
-versus- -for-
JUDY ANN ACUPAN y PESTANO, THEFT AS AMENDED BY RA 10951
Accused.
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------X
MINUTES
of the SESSION held on Nov. 27, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.
PRESENT:
HON. CYRUS B. GOCO ---------------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano ---------------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi ---------------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo ---------------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira ---------------- Process Server
APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
---------------- For the Accused

ARRAIGNMENT AND PRE-TRIAL

WITNESSES:

MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE:

REMARKS:

CONTINUATION OF HEARING:

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO

Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV
COUNSELS:

Prosecutor Counsel for the Accused

 Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES
Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Case No. 16174
Plaintiff,
-versus- -for-
JAYCEE BARRUN y DELGADO ET AL., ORAL DEFAMATION
Accused.
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------X
MINUTES
of the SESSION held on Nov. 27, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.
PRESENT:
HON. CYRUS B. GOCO ---------------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano ---------------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi ---------------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo ---------------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira ---------------- Process Server
APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
---------------- For the Accused

MOTION FOR RELEASE OF MOTORIZED FISHING VESSEL

WITH UNDERTAKING
WITNESSES:

MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE:

REMARKS:

CONTINUATION OF HEARING:

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO

Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV
COUNSELS:

Prosecutor Counsel for the Accused

 Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES
Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Case No. 15864
Plaintiff,
-versus- -for-
MARRIANE LOIS ABACA, LESS SERIOUS PHYSICAL
Accused. INJURIES
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------X
MINUTES
of the SESSION held on Nov. 27, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.
PRESENT:
HON. CYRUS B. GOCO ---------------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano ---------------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi ---------------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo ---------------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira ---------------- Process Server
APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
Atty. Leoncia Ma. Cecilia M. Dimayuga ---------------- For the Accused

CONTINUATION OF PRESENTATION OF DEFENSE EVIDENCE

WITNESSES:

MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE:

REMARKS:

CONTINUATION OF HEARING:

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO

Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV
COUNSELS:

Prosecutor Counsel for the Accused

 Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES
Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Case No. 16166
Plaintiff,
-versus- -for-
ROSEMARIE CARANDANG y CARPIO, ORAL DEFAMATION
Accused.
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------X
MINUTES
of the SESSION held on Nov. 27, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.
PRESENT:
HON. CYRUS B. GOCO ---------------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano ---------------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi ---------------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo ---------------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira ---------------- Process Server
APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
Atty. Leoncia Ma. Cecilia M. Dimayuga ---------------- For the Accused

ARRAIGNMENT AND PRE-TRIAL

WITNESSES:

MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE:

REMARKS:

CONTINUATION OF HEARING:

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO

Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV
COUNSELS:

Prosecutor Counsel for the Accused

 Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES
Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Case No. 15902
Plaintiff,
-versus- -for-
RODOLFO REDULLA JR., y MORALES, VIOLATION OF RA 8048 OR
Accused. COCONUT PRESERVATION ACT
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------X
MINUTES
of the SESSION held on Nov. 27, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.
PRESENT:
HON. CYRUS B. GOCO ---------------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano ---------------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi ---------------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo ---------------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira ---------------- Process Server
APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
Atty. Hospicio I. Laygo, Jr. ---------------- For the Accused

CONTINUATION OF PRESENTATION OF PROSECUTION’S EVIDENCE

WITNESSES:

MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE:

REMARKS:

CONTINUATION OF HEARING:

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO

Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV
COUNSELS:

Prosecutor Counsel for the Accused

 Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES
Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Case No. 15867-15869
Plaintiff,
-versus- -for-
CELIA ACHA-JURADO, VIOLATION OF BP BLG. 22
Accused.
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------X
MINUTES
of the SESSION held on Nov. 27, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.
PRESENT:
HON. CYRUS B. GOCO ---------------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano ---------------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi ---------------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo ---------------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira ---------------- Process Server
APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
Atty. Leoncia Ma. Cecilia M. Dimayuga ---------------- For the Accused

CONTINUATION OF PRESENTATION OF PROSECUTION’S EVIDENCE

WITNESSES:

MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE:

REMARKS:

CONTINUATION OF HEARING:

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO

Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV
COUNSELS:

Prosecutor Counsel for the Accused

 Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES
Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Case No. 15866
Plaintiff,
-versus- -for-
JERSON FABELLON y MORTEL, MALICIOUS MISCHIEF
Accused.
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------X
MINUTES
of the SESSION held on Nov. 27, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.
PRESENT:
HON. CYRUS B. GOCO ---------------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano ---------------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi ---------------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo ---------------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira ---------------- Process Server
APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
Atty. Leoncia Ma. Cecilia M. Dimayuga ---------------- For the Accused

CONTINUATION OF PRESENTATION OF PROSECUTION’S EVIDENCE

WITNESSES:

MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE:

REMARKS:

CONTINUATION OF HEARING:

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO

Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV
COUNSELS:

Prosecutor Counsel for the Accused

 Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES
Fourth Judicial Region
Province of Oriental Mindoro
CITY OF CALAPAN
-oOo-
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Criminal Case No. 15846
Plaintiff,
-versus- -for-
BENEDICTO SIBAYAN y SLIGHT PHYSICAL INJURIES
PAGCALIWAGAN,
Accused.
X--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------X
MINUTES
of the SESSION held on Nov. 27, 2018 at 8:30 o’clock in the morning.
PRESENT:
HON. CYRUS B. GOCO ---------------- Presiding Judge
Ms. Abelyn R. Montellano ---------------- Clerk of Court IV
Mr. Ronald C. Cusi ---------------- Interpreter II
Ms. Rubirosa F. Albo ---------------- Court Stenographer II
Mr. Timoteo L. Matira ---------------- Process Server
APPEARANCES:
Pros. Jose Jay E. Dela Chica ---------------- For the Plaintiff
Atty. Leoncia Ma. Cecilia M. Dimayuga ---------------- For the Accused

CONTINUATION OF PRESENTATION OF DEFENSE EVIDENCE

WITNESSES:

MARKED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE:

REMARKS:

CONTINUATION OF HEARING:

Prepared by Certified Correct:

Ronald Arvin C. Cusi Mrs. ABELYN R. MONTELLANO

Interpreter II Clerk of Court IV
COUNSELS:

Prosecutor Counsel for the Accused