RUBRICS FOR TECHNICAL DESIGN/PROJECT

Group Members/Title of Project: Duero, Macasarte, Mandacayan, Muring/ Portable Beverage Chiller Machine

Level of Achievement
WEIGH
Elements Excellent Good Adequate Inadequate SCORE
T
4 Points 3 Points 2 Points 1 Point
Clear and complete Overall sound Some understanding of Little or no grasp of
understanding of understanding of the the problem. Major problem. Incapable of
Design Problem design goal and problems and deficiencies that will producing a successful
10%
and Boundaries constraints. constraints. Does not impair the quality of solution.
significantly impair solution.
solution.
Final design achieved Alternative approaches Serious deficiencies in Only one design presented
after review of identified to some exploring and or clearly unfeasible
Alternative Design 10%
reasonable alternatives. degree. identifying alternative alternative given.
design.
Computer-aided tools Computer-aided tools Minimal application and Serious deficiencies in
Use of Computer are used effectively to used with moderate use of appropriate understanding the correct
20%
Aided Tools develop and analyze effectiveness to tools. selection and / or use of
designs. develop designs. tools.
Critical selection and Effective application of Serious deficiencies No or erroneous
Application of application of engineering principles in proper selection and application of engineering
Engineering 20% engineering principles resulting in reasonable use of engineering principles yielding
Principles ensuring reasonable solution. principles. unreasonable solution.
results.
Design meets or Design meets Barely capable of Not capable of achieving
exceeds desired desired objectives. achieving desired desired objectives. No
objectives. Effective Moderately effective objectives. Minimal implementation of
Final Design 30%
implementation of utilization of resources utilization of resources resource conservation and
resource conservation conservation and conservation and recycle strategies.
and recycle strategies. recycle potentials. recycle potentials.
 Effective use of Reasonable Reasonable cost No or totally erroneous
profitability analysis profitability analysis estimates presented, cost estimates presented.
Process Economics 5% leading to presented, but no but no profitability
improvement interpretation of the analysis included.
recommendations. results.
Insightful supported Sound conclusions Serious deficiencies in No or erroneous conclusion
Interpretation of
5% conclusions and reached based on support for stated based on achieved results.
Results
recommendations. achieved results. conclusions.
Printed Name and Signature:
TOTAL

Remarks: