Professional Documents
Culture Documents
JISPPD
Journal of Indian Society of Pedodontics and Preventive Dentistry
S O C I E TY
AN
DI O
IN
S
PR
O D O N T IC
E
VENTIV
AND
ED
T ISTR
D EN Y
Official Publication of
The Indian Society of Pedodontics and Preventive Dentistry
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
78 J INDIAN SOC PEDOD PREVENT DENT | Apr - June 2010 | Issue 2 | Vol 28 |
Mani, et al.: KAP among caretakers in Kubang Kerian, Malaysia
culture, environment and individual-level factors within dentist and community dental health specialist. It
a system with its own societal and environmental had 29 items, 10 each in the knowledge and practice
characteristics.[31] More attention needs to be focused components and 9 in the attitude component, and took
on family dynamics and behavior in solving the problem about 20 minutes to complete. The scoring for attitude
of ECC.[32] and practice was based on 5- and 4- point Likert scale,
respectively, while the scoring for knowledge included
Mothers are undoubtedly the primary source of early true/false/don’t know responses. All aspects of oral
education in children with regard to a good oral health. health promoting factors in children including oral
However, in the 21st century, the numbers of mothers hygiene, diet and fluoride were addressed.
employed outside their homes continue to rise, perhaps
in an attempt to increase the quality of life. As a result, Data were entered and analyzed using SPSS 12.01.[33]
young children spend a considerable amount of time The ethical clearance was obtained from the Human
in day-care centers. In day-care centers, the caretakers’ Ethics Committee of Universiti Sains Malaysia.
role is similar to that of school teachers and may be
even more important because they are involved in Results
children's daily diet, general hygiene and oral health
care. Despite this, no study to the best of our knowledge The demographic characteristics of the caretakers are
has focused on determining the role of such caretakers shown in Table 1. Children under their care were aged
in promoting oral health among children. between 1 and 5 years. Each caretaker was responsible
for 2 to 19 children, depending on the day-care center.
This pilot study was undertaken to assess the The mean duration of their services was 9.9 h/day,
knowledge, attitude and practice of oral health which was determined by the parents’ working hours.
promoting factors in infants and young children among Most of the caretakers had secondary school education,
caretakers at day-care centers. with only three individuals having any form of tertiary
education. A majority (52.9%) had more than 1 year of
Materials and Methods experience as a caretaker, but a quarter had less than
1 year experience.
This cross-sectional study involved caretakers working
in all the day-care centers in Kubang Kerian, Malaysia. Table 2 shows the knowledge of the caretakers. Most
From a total of 11 day-care centers employing 40 of them had good knowledge of a child’s tooth eruption
individuals, 34 consented to participate in the study. stages, role of fluoride and tooth brushing in caries
development. About 32% knew that caries can affect
Consent was obtained from the proprietor of each
nursery after explaining the nature of research. All Table 1: Sociodemographic characteristics of the respondents
the caretakers who fulfilled the inclusion criteria were Variables n (%)
approached. Inclusion criteria for the caretakers were Age Mean: 30.5 years
Gender Female 34 (100)
(1) they should be aged 18 years or above, (2) those who
Ethnic Group Malay 34 (100)
took care of normal/healthy children and (3) those who
Education level Primary 2 (5.9)
were employed as caretakers for more than 3 months.
Secondary 29 (85.3)
Since all the subjects fulfilled the inclusion criteria, none
were excluded. Informed consent was then obtained Tertiary 3 (8.8)
from every caretaker who participated in the study. Daily working time (hours) Mean: 9.9 hours
Duration of employment 3 months to 1year 9 (26.5)
The caretakers were required to answer a close-ended Between 1 and 5 years 18 (52.9)
self-administered questionnaire. Sociodemographic More than 5 years 7 (20.6)
details taken from the caretakers included (1) daily Primary job option Yes 22 (65)
working hours as caretakers, (2) employment duration No 12 (35)
and (3) whether this occupation was their first choice. Number of children under care 1–5 12 (35)
The questionnaire addressed the knowledge, attitude 6–10 9 (26.5)
and practice of oral health promoting factors among
11–15 9 (26.5)
infants and young children, designed jointly by the
16–20 4 (11.8)
research group with the expert opinion of a pediatric
J INDIAN SOC PEDOD PREVENT DENT | Apr - June 2010 | Issue 2 | Vol 28 | 79
Mani, et al.: KAP among caretakers in Kubang Kerian, Malaysia
Table 2: Knowledge of infant oral health among the Table 3: Attitudes of the respondents to infant oral health
respondents
Items Strongly Don’t Strongly
Items True (T) False (F) Don’t know agree/agree know disagree/
n (%) n (%) n (%) n (%) n (%) disagree n (%)
Caries can affect infants below 2 11 (32.4) 22 (64.7) 1 (2.9) Tooth decay is caused by bacteria 5 (14.7) 3 (8.8) 26 (76.4)
years old that are transmitted by sharing
When does the first baby tooth 31 (91.2) 3 (8.8) 0 (0.0) feeding utensils (e.g: spoon)
appear in the child’s mouth? A balance diet is essential for the 31 (91.2) 3 (8.8) 0 (0.0)
Complete set of 20 baby teeth by 24 (70.6) 8 (23.5) 2 (5.9) healthy growth of a baby’s teeth
the age Night time bottle/breast feeding can 10 (29.4) 5 (14.7) 19 (55.9)
The main types of food that can 33 (97.1) 0 (0.0) 1 (2.9) cause tooth decay
cause tooth decay ... Frequent and prolonged breast/bottle 9 (26.5) 1 (2.9) 24 (70.6)
feeding can cause tooth decay
Weaning from a baby bottle to 31 (91.2) 2 (5.9) 1 (2.9)
a sipping cup should be planned A child’s teeth should be cleaned/ 32 (94.1) 1 (2.9) 1 (2.9)
when the child is: brushed
Cleaning a baby’s mouth after each 31 (91.2) 2 (5.9) 1 (2.9) Effective cleaning of teeth brushing 19 (55.9) 2 (5.9) 13 (38.2)
feeding should begin even before can be achieved by the child him/
teeth erupt herself
Brushing baby’s teeth is important 33 (97.1) 0 (0.0) 1 (2.9) Swallowing of toothpaste can be 6 (17.6) 3 (8.8) 25 (73.5)
for oral health harmful to a child’s health
Fluoride in toothpaste is important 31 (91.2) 1 (2.9) 2 (5.9) It is important for a child to visit the 13 (38.2) 1 (2.9) 20 (58.8)
for preventing caries in teeth dentist before 2 years old
You should start using toothpaste 13 (38.2) 19 (55.9) 2 (5.9) Prolonged used of pacifier can affect 22 (64.7) 4 (11.8) 8 (23.5)
with fluoride for cleaning a child’s the normal development of a child’s
teeth… teeth
It is not necessary to do fillings in 21 (61.8) 8 (23.5) 5 (14.7)
baby’s teeth Worldwide, the numbers of mothers working outside
their homes continue to increase; 70–80% in Poland[18]
infants below 2 years old and about 38% of caretakers and 45–55% in Malaysia. These women have to balance
knew the right time for using fluoride toothpaste for the responsibilities of the family and workplace.
tooth cleaning. Only 24% knew that fillings in baby Working parents of children in nuclear families have
teeth were necessary. mainly two options, to leave the child at home with a
family member/hired help or to leave the child at a
Table 3 shows the caretaker’s attitude toward infant nursery or day-care center, which caters to children
oral health. Five respondents agreed that tooth decay as young as 3 months. Parents opt to leave children
is caused by bacteria transmitted by sharing utensils, at such centers for the majority of the day, during
while 56 and 71% thought that nighttime and frequent the working hours of the parent. Most nurseries are
bottle feeding/breast feeding did not cause tooth small, private organizations, located at residential
decay, respectively. About 18% strongly agreed that areas, which may or may not be registered with the
swallowing of toothpaste can be harmful to a child’s local department of community welfare. Hence, these
health. organizations may not have the ideal requirements and
reach the standards of an ideal nursery. The parents
Table 4 shows the responses to oral health practices. have limited control of activities in the nursery, and
About 17.6% of the caretakers agreed to having bitten there may be inadequate knowledge and standardization
food into small pieces before giving it to the children. of procedures regarding child caring among caretakers
About 85% acknowledged giving sweet food to the child in such centers.
and 53% to giving sweetened liquid in bottle.
The caretakers in this study were all Malay females,
Discussion which reflect the ethnic group comprising the majority
in the state of Kelantan, Malaysia. Thirty five percent
Knowledgeable and efficacious caregivers can play did not opt for infant caretaking as their first job
an important role in caries prevention.[4] Child care option, which suggests that a lack of preferred job
centres serve a significant number of young children opportunities may have prompted them to take up
and deserve attention as potential venues for early this profession temporarily which in turn can result in
preventive and corrective oral interventions.[9] decreased quality of care.
80 J INDIAN SOC PEDOD PREVENT DENT | Apr - June 2010 | Issue 2 | Vol 28 |
Mani, et al.: KAP among caretakers in Kubang Kerian, Malaysia
Only 42 and 39% of mothers knew that dental caries dental caries pattern and caries risk are established.[35]
is caused by sugar in Wuhan, Republic of China, and Good oral hygiene in the early years of life is associated
Romania, respectively, and relatively few mothers with decreased caries experience in the individual in
knew the effect of sugary drinks like tea, coffee and later life.[36,37] Time constraints in the schedule of
milk.[27,28] Elsewhere, 78% knew that sugary foods parents working outside the home may put children at
and drinks should be limited to meal-times, but only a disadvantage in learning satisfactory oral habits at
7% could select the four foods and drinks that supply home, whereas secondary caretakers can play a major
children with the bulk of their added sugar intake.[34] role in inculcating good oral habits in these children.
In this study, most of the caretakers (97%) knew that A study in Poland reported that 54% of mothers
sugary food can cause tooth decay, but on the contrary, regularly assist their child with tooth brushing
majority (59%) indulged in giving sweetened liquid in and the proportion is greatest among mothers with
the bottle and 85.3% gave sweet food to the children. higher education.[15] On the other hand, statistically
Seventy one percent and 56% of them also disagreed significant difference between decayed, missing and
that dental caries is caused by frequent/prolonged filled teeth (dmft) index and self brushing, parental
feeding and nighttime feeding, respectively. This might brushing or tooth brushing with parental assistance,
be because they were not aware of the hidden sugars in was not found in another study. [18] In this study,
the milk, or that giving the children bottle or breast feed 91.2% of the caretakers knew that cleaning a baby’s
immediately prior to bedtime and when the child woke mouth after each feeding should begin even before the
up in the night was a common cultural practice of the teeth erupt and 97.1% were aware that brushing is
region. Additionally, weaning from the bottle was also important for oral health. Half of the subjects in this
done quite late; only 3% of the caretakers practiced the study agreed that effective cleaning of teeth cannot
right time to start giving semisolid food for a child at be achieved by the child him/herself, yet 53% of the
the nursery and most of them (64.7%) started feeding caretakers ‘seldom’ or ‘never’ brushed the teeth of the
semisolid food for a child at the nursery at the age of 1 children or assisted them. An excellent way to instill
year, thus increasing the risk factors for caries. oral hygiene habits in these children is to conduct a
regular exercise of tooth brushing everyday in the
The foundation of adult oral health is laid during day-care center with the assistance of the caretakers.
the formative preschool years, during which a child’s Basic habits like drinking plain water and rinsing the
J INDIAN SOC PEDOD PREVENT DENT | Apr - June 2010 | Issue 2 | Vol 28 | 81
Mani, et al.: KAP among caretakers in Kubang Kerian, Malaysia
mouth with water after every feed can also be instilled oral health was not reflected in the oral health of their
in children at a young age. In this study, only 42% children.[38]
reported encouraging drinking plain water after every
feed at all times. This being a pilot study, conducted in one locality,
conclusions cannot be applied to the population, thus
About 62% of the caretakers in this study agreed that requiring studies with larger samples. However, the
it was not necessary to do fillings in deciduous teeth, preliminary findings indicate that the attitudes and
with similar results reported from a study in Poland practices of caretakers need improvement and the
where two-thirds of the mothers agreed that care of community would benefit if the caretakers undergo
deciduous dentition was unnecessary.[15] In contrast, frequent compulsory standardized training pertaining
a study in England concluded that 74% of mothers to child rearing, which includes oral health promoting
thought that dental decay in milk teeth was very factors. The administrators of day-care centers
important, but only about 47% wanted carious teeth should support and encourage such training among
filled, while 15% wanted them to be left and 28% wanted caretakers to enhance the quality of care. It would also
them extracted.[34] In a multicultural community be interesting to compare the caries status of children
in USA, half the participants believed that children placed in such day-care centers with those under the
should see a dentist between 2 and 4 years of age.[31] A care of mothers, to find out if placing children in day-
majority (79.4%) in this study did mouth examination care is a risk factor for ECC.
in the children but 58.8% did not believe that children
should see a dentist before 2 years of age. For this In conclusion, most caretakers had good knowledge, but
reason, caretakers should be trained to identify carious the same did not reflect in their attitude and practice. It
deciduous teeth and highlight to parents the importance is worthwhile to attempt regular oral health promotion
of its preservation and visiting a dentist at the earliest. education programs, with stress on dietary practices
and other preventive measures among caretakers of
The role of bacteria in the etiology of caries was child care centers.
acknowledged by 33 and 35% of Romanian and Chinese
mothers, respectively.[27,28] In this study, only 15% Acknowledgement
agreed that tooth decay was caused by bacteria that
were transmitted by sharing feeding utensils (e.g., Participants of the study and Dr. Lin Naing are thanked for
spoon). Moreover, about 18% caretakers reported biting their help and support.
the food into small pieces before giving it to the children
at the nursery. Hence, this implicates that oral health References
education should address concepts of transmissibility
of oral bacteria. 1. Brown A, Lowe E, Zimmerman B, Crall J, Foley M, Nehring
M. Preventing early childhood caries: lessons from the field.
Despite having good levels of knowledge of the causes Pediatr Dent 2006;28:553-60.
2. Bedi R, Lewsey JD, Gilthorpe MS. Changes in oral health over
of dental caries, the caretakers appeared to be unable to ten years amongst UK children aged 4-5 years living in a deprived
apply the knowledge in everyday practice. Good levels multiethnic area. Br Dent J 2000;189:88-92.
of knowledge is probably due to the wide exposure to 3. Williams NJ, Whittle JG, Gatrell AC. The relationship between
oral health education and promotion among Malaysians socio-demographic characteristics and dental health knowledge
through school dental service, antenatal clinics and and attitudes of parents with young children. Br Dent J
2002;193:651-4.
other avenues, carried out by the Ministry of Health. 4. Finlayson TL, Siefert K, Ismail AI, Delva J, Sohn W. Reliability
The school dental service in Malaysia provides oral and validity of brief measures of oral health-related knowledge,
health promotion, preventive and curative activities fatalism, and self-efficacy in mothers of African American
using the school dental clinic, mobile dental chair children. Pediatr Dent 2005;27:422-8.
5. Gratrix D, Holloway PJ. Factors of deprivation associated with
and mobile teams, with the aim of rendering school dental caries in young children. Community Dent Health
children orally fit before they leave school. The poor 1994;11:66-70.
practices may be due to the cultural practices observed 6. Jose B, King NM. Early childhood caries lesions in preschool
in the region, which remains unchanged in spite of the children in Kerala, India. Pediatr Dent 2003;25:594-600.
7. Monaghan N, Heesterman R. Dental caries, social deprivation
knowledge obtained, which was also noted by Matilla et and enhanced capitation payments for children. Br Dent J
al.[18] A similar finding was noted in Serdang, Malaysia, 1999;186:238-40.
where the knowledge and attitude of parents toward 8. Hilton IV, Stephen S, Barker JC, Weintraub JA. Cultural factors
82 J INDIAN SOC PEDOD PREVENT DENT | Apr - June 2010 | Issue 2 | Vol 28 |
Mani, et al.: KAP among caretakers in Kubang Kerian, Malaysia
J INDIAN SOC PEDOD PREVENT DENT | Apr - June 2010 | Issue 2 | Vol 28 | 83