Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T
Keywords: Low cost housing refers to those housing units which are affordable by that section of society whose income is
Natural materials below than median household income. This depends on three key parameters—income level, size of dwelling
Low cost techniques unit and affordability. This paper aims to point out the various aspects of predestined building methodologies by
Low income group highlighting the different available techniques, and the economical advantages achieved by its adoption. In a
Structural component
building the walls, floors and roofs are the most important sections, which can be analyzed distinctively based on
the needs, thus, improving the speed of construction and reducing the construction cost. This paper also aims to
cover the use of local materials in the different components of building to make them as low cost available
solutions for low income groups. To own a house by middle and lower income groups in today's economic trends
is very difficult. Therefore, it has now became a necessity to adopt cost effective, innovative and environment-
friendly housing technologies for the construction of houses and buildings and availing them at low cost com-
paratively. In order to come up with viable solutions this paper compares the construction cost for the traditional
and low cost housing technologies and it was observed that with the use of technology and reuse of waste
material as building material the cost of construction can be minimized to an extent. It was observed that with if
the filler slab can be used as an alternative to conventional slab the cost of construction can reduce upto 25%.
With the time more studies are going to identify the reuse of waste material like fly ash, rice husk, etc as building
material. After realizing the true potential of these waste materials as building material in construction industry
the cost can be minimized to a greater extent. In addition the building up of cooperative to supply those al-
ternative raw materials rather than importing from somewhere else would help in reducing the cost by 20–30%.
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: manjesh.srivastava396@gmail.com (M. Srivastava), vikaskumarnitk@gmail.com (V. Kumar).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jobe.2017.11.001
Received 4 January 2017; Received in revised form 30 August 2017; Accepted 1 November 2017
Available online 10 November 2017
2352-7102/ © 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
M. Srivastava, V. Kumar Journal of Building Engineering 15 (2018) 102–108
compromising the strength, performance and life of the structure. There building is also an important intuitive change.
is a huge misconception that low cost housing is suitable for only sub • Extensive planning of each and every component in a house the
standard works and they are constructed by utilizing cheap building wastage of materials due to demolition of the unplanned component
materials of low quality. The fact is that Low cost housing is done by of the house can be avoided.
proper management of resources. Reducing cost of structure is also • Every component should be analyzed for its usability in the house if
achieved by postponing finishing works or implementing them in not needed then the component can be done away with totally.
phases. Seeing the past constructions one can see the use of natural
materials like straw, bamboo, fibers (jute, coir), earth etc. as an old 2.2. Ways to achieve cost effectiveness
practice in India. These materials apart from being locally available
have easy workability and speedy construction hence reducing costs. In this section, construction method of walling, roofing and lintel
After analyzing various industrial wastes it had been observed that fly are compared. During construction strength and durability of the
ash and rice husk do possess pozzolonic properties which can act as an structure, stability, safety and mental satisfaction are factors that as-
excellent substitute material. This paper aims to compile the studies of sume top priority during cost reduction. In the case studies for walling
all these materials keeping in mind their affordability. For the con- and roofing it has been found that about 26.11% and 22.68% of the
struction of high strength structures and for high rise buildings the construction cost can be saved by using low cost housing technologies
dependence on the materials like steel, cement has been increasing in comparison with the traditional construction methods respectively
widely day by day. Thus extensive use of such materials has also been [2]. From these results it can be said using low cost housing technol-
linked to global warming at various platforms. Therefore, the use of ogies is a cost effective mode of construction that can be adopted in this
sustainable and eco-friendly building materials have now became a industry.
global concern from environment point of view as well. Thus there is an
urgent need to look out for cheaper yet sustainable low cost housing 2.3. Technologies
technologies. The recent developments in this area in India have been
done under various organizations like Building Materials and Tech- The environmental friendly building material technologies for low
nology Promotion Council (BMTPC), Central Building Research In- cost housing that can be adopted are as follows:
stitute (CBRI), Indian Institute of Technology (Delhi, Roorkee, Madras,
Kharagpur) and Indian Plywood Industries Research and Training In- • Lime- Sand Brick
stitute (IPIRTI). These institutions have discussed many such materials • Cement -Waste Slag Brick
along with their potential applications and cost aspects. Numerous is- • Concrete Hollow Block
sues in context of these materials have been highlighted like lack of • Decorative Concrete Block
codal guidelines, technology transfer and manufacturing facilities. • Light Weight Concrete Block
• Concrete Paving Block
2. Literature review • Wall Plaster
• Paint for interior and exterior wall
Realising the importance of low cost housing in countries which
have varied living standards and huge population to cater alongwith 3. Methodology
keeping a check on availability and use of natural resources in con-
struction; the option of low cost housing needs to be explored at the Concept of prefabrication/partial prefabrication has been adopted
fullest. Several studies have gone under pilot project to estimate the for speedier construction, better quality components & saving in ma-
cost reduction. If only walling and roofing to be analyzed alone for low terial quantities & costs. Some of these construction techniques & ma-
cost solution they saved 26.11% and 22.68% respectively [2]. Using terials for walls and roofs that are used many times have been described
several alternative building materials as discussed in subsequent sec- further.
tions of this paper will also help in saving the cost of construction be-
cause if materials are locally available then cost of transportation will 3.1. Review of different techniques adopted by changing certain design and
be reduced which is approximately 30% of the total construction material being used
budget [5].
Different techniques are adopted for different components of a
2.1. Importance of planning building to reduce the cost and without compromising the strength of
the building.
In this section, it has been described that on incorporating certain
changes and concepts while planning of structure, keeping in mind the 3.1.1. In walls
deliverables in terms of low cost houses following methodologies and In the construction of walls, rammed earth, normal bricks, soil ce-
technologies can be adopted. ment blocks, hollow clay blocks, dense concrete blocks, small, medium
and room size panels etc of different sizes are used. Although bricks
2.1.1. Some alternatives that can be adopted continue to be the backbone of the building industry, in actual con-
struction, the number of the bricks or blocks that are broken into dif-
• Reducing plinth area by using thinner wall concept i.e. 15 cm thick ferent sizes to fit into position at site is very large which results in
solid concrete block wall. wastage of material. On increasing the size of wall blocks they will
• Using locally available material in an innovative form like soil ce- prove economical to an extent due to greater speed and less mortar
ment blocks in place of burnt brick. consumption, which can be achieved by producing low density bigger
• Use of energy efficiency materials which consume less energy like size wall blocks by the use of industrial wastes like blast furnace slag
concrete block in place of burnt brick. and fly ash. Several prefabrication techniques have been developed and
• Using environmental friendly materials which are substitute for executed for walls but these medium and large panel techniques have
conventional building components like use of R.C.C. Door and not proved economical for low rise buildings as compared to traditional
window frames in place of wooden frames. brick work.
• Preplanning every component of a house and rationalizing the de-
sign procedure for reducing the size of the components in the 3.1.1.1. Non erodable mud plaster. The plaster over mud walls gets
103
M. Srivastava, V. Kumar Journal of Building Engineering 15 (2018) 102–108
104
M. Srivastava, V. Kumar Journal of Building Engineering 15 (2018) 102–108
external joints, these models were subjected to identical horizontal of 50 GPa (50,000 N/mm2) than that of steel [6]. The rapid growth and
cyclic load by increasing target displacement with different vertical slab easy availability of bamboo has led to its use as a structural material in
loading. The results had shown that an increase in vertical load will countries like India, China and Japan. G Leake in a paper compared the
cause overturning moment and horizontal replacement [15,16]. Pan use of bamboo and stated that the upper class of Colombia uses concrete
et al. studied flat slab which had external joints including 27 H shape but in India upper class uses stone, middle class uses wood, and lower
specimen under seismic loading and concluded that higher the dead class uses bamboo for construction. Mechanical properties of bamboo
load, higher will be the deflection [15–17]. Tegos et al. researched on vary from specimen to specimen. It can be used mostly as beams rather
the seismic behaviour of joints and internal drift of multi storey than in columns as it has a tendency to buckle. One of the major pro-
structure to understand the deformability of internal slab [15,18]. blems with the use of these is that of connection of bamboo culms. It
can also be used as bamboo roofing sheet which is strong, durable, light
3.2. Materials used in low cost housing solutions weight and fire resistance.
Low cost Housing materials can be broadly classified into natural 3.2.4. Straw fiber
materials and manmade materials according to the source of their The early use of straw was done by Mesopotamian and Egyptian in
availability. Materials like bagasse, rice husk, banana leaves, coconut 1500 BCE. Straw had provided reinforcement to ancient products like
husk, are naturally available from the remains of agriculture industry boats and pottery. After the removal of chaff and grain, straw is ob-
[6]. Natural materials such as fibers, earth and fly ash are some of the tained which is one of the byproducts of agriculture industry. This
materials which are easily available and have excellent prospects of variety is toughest as compared to other straws. One has to be extra
being used in the construction industry. Materials like fly ash and ferro careful in disposing it off because if burning is adopted then it will
cement are an example of man-made materials which can be recycled to cause breathing problems, therefore, an alternate mode need to be
make new product that helps in lowering the cost of construction [1] adopted and discovered [3].
(Fig. 4). Applications
3.2.1. Earth 1) Life extended thatch roof – environmental friendly also is fire re-
One of the oldest material available but due to its limitation like sistant and water proof [6]
erosion, water penetration, termite attack and high maintenance it is 2) Improved thatch roof – CBRI has designed a technique to make the
less used. But this limitation can be overcome by: roof more fire and water resistant and by doing the plaster with the
layer of mud makes it more resistant to fire [6]
1) Compressed earth block – developed from adobe block or also
known as earth block and also consists of cement using manual 3.2.5. Bagasse fiber
press. This is obtained from the remains of sugarcane or sorghum stalks.
2) Non-erodible mud plaster – Its constituents are bitumen which is The amount of waste generated is approximately same as the quantity
mixed with a specific mud paste and has the ability to resist water of production. To understand the generation in India the presence of
[3] around 500 sugar mills reflects a big number [3]. Its physical properties
are color pale green to grey yellow, texture and size -non-uniform and
3.2.2. Natural materials bulky. Balaji et al. stated that approximately 50% cellulose and 25% of
Fibers are hair like materials which are discrete elongated pieces both lignin and hemi cellulose is present in the remains and if properly
like threads. They are paintable, attractive, cheaper, rot-resistance, modified will show better mechanical properties. To estimate approx.
having low density with eco–advantages over other composites. Natural 85% of the material is burnt or deposited on field. The advantages re-
fibers have a potential to replace glass fiber but the main disadvantage lated to this are low energy input required, eco-friendly and reduces the
is water absorption, therefore chemical treatments are required. density of product. Disadvantages are because of less impact strength
problem of stocking, degradation of fiber etc. In addition, it can be used
3.2.3. Bamboo fiber as bagasse cement board and panels, bagasse PVC boards and in bio-
Bamboo which can be used as reinforce material is the second lar- mass power generation [3].
gest to be produced in world after China. India grows around 50% of
world's total share with an area of approximately 9.57 million hectare 3.2.6. Jute and coir fiber
[6]. Swaptik et al. stated that the tensile strength of bamboo is around It is a vegetable fiber and cultivation of jute started around 800 BCE.
650 N/mm2 and that of steel varies between 500–1000 N/mm2. It had spread in many parts of India with 33 districts in the list covering
Bamboo is also more flexible than steel having low modulus of elasticity around 98.41% of total area under jute cultivation [3]. Jute used for
105
M. Srivastava, V. Kumar Journal of Building Engineering 15 (2018) 102–108
Table 1
Availability of natural fiber in India and its applications in building materials.
Rice husk Rice mills As fuel, for manufacturing building materials and products
Banana leaves/stalk Banana plants In the manufacture of building boards, fire resistance fiber board
Coconut husk Coir fiber industry In the manufacture of building boards, roofing sheets, insulation boards, building panels, as a lightweight aggregate, coir fiber
reinforced composite boards
Groundnut shell Groundnut oil mills In the manufacture of buildings panels, building blocks, for making chip boards, roofing sheets, particle boards
Jute fiber Jute industry For making chip boards, roofing sheets, door shutter
Rice/wheat straw Agricultural farm Manufacture of roofing units and walls panels/boards
Saw mill waste Saw mills/wood Manufacture of cement bonded wood chips, blocks, boards, particle boards, insulation boards, briquettes
Sisal fibers Sisal plantation For plastering of walls and for making roofing sheets, composite board with rice husk, cement roofing sheet, roofing tiles,
manufacturing of paper and pulp
Cotton stalk Cotton plantation Fiber boards, panel, door shutters, roofing sheets, autoclaved cement composite, paper, plastering of walls
106
M. Srivastava, V. Kumar Journal of Building Engineering 15 (2018) 102–108
thermal insulating bricks, production of some acids, production of • Filler slab is much more economical than traditional slab as it saves
building materials and low cost sand concrete block. 16%, 44%, 17% of cement, steel and cost in two way slabs and 33%,
46%, 25% in one way slab respectively.
3.3. Manmade materials • Brick panel saves 19% per m3 and Rs 418 in cement, 19% per m3
and Rs 21 in sand, 19% per m3 and Rs 127 in aggregate, and 38%
Industrial revolution created many by products that if not made per m3 and Rs 536 in steel.
would have posed a problem of disposing them off. After a deep re- • Soil stabilized bricks are 27.7% cheaper as compared to country
search into their properties, it was observed that they had best pozzo- fired bricks walls, where country fired bricks use Rs 934 per m2 on
lanic properties therefore these materials were started to be used as an contrary soil stabilized bricks use Rs 736 per m2 also they cause less
alternative material [3]. air pollution, energy consumption and carbon emissions.
• Aluminum form work is a comparatively high cost construction but
3.3.1. Fly ash gives high quality and speedy construction which can be used in
It is obtained from the burning of coal and is recovered from gasses. places where construction is required at a fast pace. For flat slab the
Major constituents of fly ash are iron, alumina and silica [3]. Fly ash total quantity of steel and concrete used are 8.644 m3 and 1294 m3
generation has increase from 68.88 million tons/annum to 131.09 as compared to conventional building which uses 10,593 m3 of steel
million tons/annum from 1996 to 2011. But the utilization has only and 1505.25 m3 of concrete and the cost saving percentage in flat
increased by 6.64–73.13 t/annum i.e. about 14%. Fly ash can be used in slab is 15% in B+G+3 building respectively.
fly ash brick, bulk fill, filler in bituminous mix, artificial aggregate [3]. • Hollow concrete blocks can be used in those places where the load is
not coming directly on wall; the cost is saved by 17.78%.
3.3.2. Aerocon panels
These are inorganic bonded sandwich type panels consisting of two 5. Conclusions
fiber cement reinforced sheets. It is made up of Portland cement, bin-
ders and a mix of micaceous and siliceous aggregates. These panels are Mass housing targets can be achieved possibly by replacing the
eco-friendly, light weight, fire resistance and have sound reduction conventional methods of planning and execution of building operations
properties as well. It had been used in one of the housing scheme in based categorically on special and individual needs and accepting
India under “VALMIKI” for slums [3]. common denominator; based on surveys, population needs and rational
use of materials and resources. Adoption of any alternative technology
3.3.3. Ferro cement on large scale needs a guaranteed market to function and this cannot be
It is a versatile cement product based on the composite material established unless the product is effective and economical. Building
made by cement mortar reinforced with one or more layers of wire houses for low income families as per now poses a great challenge. It
mesh. It has a high performance with good strength of material. The involves a great effort to develop new technologies for using different
only disadvantage is high creep and shrinkage. It had been used for alternate materials in the construction industry. In this study, low cost
making water tanks; cycle shed etc. They are easy to use and hence can housing technologies were studied and the potential for the materials to
be used in post disaster management activities. be used as alternative building materials was discussed. Even though
different low cost housing technologies have been developed but still
3.3.4. Cement concrete hollow bocks there is a shortage of housing. Still we are unable to provide shelter to
These may serve as a cost effective and better alternative to burnt people from low income sections. There are no proper guidelines for-
clay bricks. They are resistant to fire and durable as well. The speedier mulated for structural aspects of these alternate building materials.
construction can be done while using this. Owing to their larger Lack of awareness is also there among builders on the applicability and
quantity of mortar required is comparatively less. The strength can be benefits of these materials. The use of filler slab as replacement to
enhanced depending upon the end use of these [3]. conventional slab is an alternative method to achieve low cost of con-
struction. Similarly more use of fly ash and rice husk ash is another
3.3.5. Recycled steel reinforcement alternative to cement. The use of bamboo as an alternative to steel is an
Steel obtained from used up constructions can be used as a recycled effective material to be used in construction. Partial prefabrication is an
scrap iron. It is used in steel reinforced structures like building and approach towards the operation under controlled conditions. The es-
bridges. Main criteria to be satisfied to use them as reinforcing bars is sence lies in the systematic approach in building methodology and not
mass/meter run. Rolling tolerance in the range of (+/-) 7 to 3% de- necessarily particular construction type or design. The methodology for
pending on diameter as specified in IS 1786. Wastage can be reduced if low cost housing has to be of intermediate type- less sophisticated in-
purchase in standard length, but if different lengths are needed then not volving less capital investment. The cooperatives needs to set up which
more than 5–7% may be wasted. Electrical melting of recycled steel are dedicated to low cost housing so that cost of transportation and
produces 40% of world steel. The advantages are high strength, bond import of materials can be avoided which in turn will automatically
strength, resistant to termite, weathering [6]. reduce the overall cost of construction budget by 20–30%.
107
M. Srivastava, V. Kumar Journal of Building Engineering 15 (2018) 102–108
[3] Oloruntoba, Kayode, Ayodele E. Olusegun, Local building materials: a tool towards [11] S.S. Patil, Rupali A. Sigi, Flat slab construction in India, IJEIT 3 (10) (2014).
effective low - income housing in Nigeria, J. Sci. Res. 18 (4) (2013) 492–497. [12] Flat Slabs for Efficient Concrete Construction, 2001.
[4] U.J. Phatak, C.S. Chavan, Lalit V. Rathod, Cost effective house by using various [13] GeorgeE. Lelekakis, AthinaT. Birda, StergiosA. Mitoulis, TheodorosA. Chrysanidis,
construction techniques and materials, IJAR 4 (4) (2014). IoannisA. Tegos.
[5] Swaptik Chowdhury, Sangeeta Roy, Prospects of low cost housing in India, [14] Applications Of Flat Slab R/C Structures In Seismic Regions, Department of Civil
Geomaterials 3 (2013) 60–65. Engineering, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki.
[6] 〈http://www.tradingeconomics.com/india/urban-population-percent-of-total-wb- [15] Leonhardt, F. - Monning, E, Regan, P. E., "Behaviour of Reinforced Concrete Flat
data.html〉. Slabs," CIRIA Report No. 89, Construction Industry Research and Information
[7] IJRET: International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology eISSN: Association, London, 1981.
2319-1163 | pISSN: 2321-7308. [16] A. Pan, J.P. Moehle, Lateral displacement ductility of reinforced concrete flat plates,
[8] M.P. Jaisingh, L. Jaisingh, B. Singh A RC filler slab with non- autoclaved cellular Acids Struct. J. 86 (3) (1989) 250–258.
concrete blocks for sustainable Construction, Central Building Research Institute, [17] I.A. Tegos, A.G. Tsonos, Repair and strengthening of slabs against punching shear,
Roorkee. In: Proceedings of the 12th Greek Conference on R/C structures, Lemesos, Cyprus,
[9] Narendra Verma, V.K. Gupta, N. Singh, Balbir Singh, Building Research Note − 79, 1996.
CSIR – Central Building Research Institute, Roorkee, 2011. [18] L&T Formwork Moulding Imagination
[10] “Environment Friendly Indian Building Material Technology for Cost Effective [19] Ecologic Building System Private Ltd, “Advantages of Hollow Concrete Blocks”.
Housing”, Society for Excellence in Habitat Development, Environmental Protection [20] Durganand Balsavar, CSE Conclave of Green Architecture Building Sense – Towards
& Employment Generation (SHEE). Sustainable Buildings and Habitat, 22-23 September, 2014.
108