You are on page 1of 107

CHAPTER 1: DISTILLATION

Unit operation
CHAPTER / CONTENT

Definition & General Description of the process

Physical concept of Distillation

Vapor – liquid equilibrium relationship

Flash & Batch Distillation

Continuous / Retrification Distillation

Azeotropic Distillation

Multi – component Distillation


Definition & General Description of the process

Separating the various components of a


liquid solution

Depends upon the distribution of these


components between a vapor phase and a
liquid phase.

All components presents in both phases.

Distillation is done by vaporizing a


definite fraction of a liquid mixture in
such a way that the evolved vapor is in
equilibrium with the residual liquid.

The equilibrium vapor is then separated


from the equilibrium residual liquid by
condensing the vapor.
Physical concept of Distillation

Carried out by either two principal


method

First method: based on the production of


a vapor by boiling the liquid mixture to
be separated and condensing the vapors
without allowing any liquid to return to
the still – no reflux (Eg. Flash
distillation)

Second method: Based on the return part


of the condensate to the still under such
condition that this returning liquid is
brought into intimate contact with the
vapors on their way to the condenser –
conducted as continuous or batch process
(Eg. Continuous distillation).
VAPOR – LIQUID EQUILIBRIUM

DEFINITION
EVAPORATION – The phase transformation processes from liquid to
gas or vapor phase.

VOLATILITY – The tendency of liquid to change form to gas

VAPOR – LIQUID EQUILIBRIUM OF AN ORDINARY BINARY


LIQUID MIXTURE

PREDICTION OF VAPOR – LIQUID EQUILIBRIUM


COMPOSITIONS FOR ORDINARY BINARY MIXTURES

RELATIVE VOLATILITY OF A MIXTURE


VAPOR – LIQUID EQUILIBRIUM OF AN ORDINARY BINARY
LIQUID MIXTURE

A binary liquid mixture – consist of two different liquids. Can be classified into
homogeneous mixtures or non – homogeneous (heterogeneous) mixtures.

Low boiler liquid (A) – liquid that vaporized easily (low boiling point or high vapor
pressure)

High boiler liquid (B) – liquid which have higher boiling point or low vapor pressure

Homogeneous mixtures – mix at all proportions resulting in one continuous phase.

Heterogeneous mixtures – do not mix uniformly resulting in more than one distinct
phases.

Equilibrium curve – shows the relationship between composition of residual liquid and
vapor that are in dynamic phase equilibrium. This curve will be very useful in calculations
to predict the number of the ideal stages required for a specified distillation process.

Equilibrium mole fraction of A in vapor is larger than mole fraction of A in liquid phase.
This is expected since that A has lower boiling point than B, A would vaporize more than
B.
PREDICTION OF VAPOR – LIQUID EQUILIBRIUM
COMPOSITIONS FOR ORDINARY BINARY MIXTURES

Raoult’s Law for ideal solution & Dalton’s Law of partial pressure can be
manipulated in order to calculate compositions of liquid and vapor, which are in
equilibrium.

Raoult’s Law – the partial pressure of a component in the vapor phase is equal to
the mole fraction of the component in the liquid multiplied by its pure vapor
pressure at that temperature.
pA  xA  PAo
p A = partial pressure of A in vapor phase

xA = mole fraction of A in liquid phase

PAo = vapor pressure of A at that temperature


PREDICTION OF VAPOR – LIQUID EQUILIBRIUM
COMPOSITIONS FOR ORDINARY BINARY MIXTURES

For a mixture of the different gases inside a close container, Dalton’s law stated
that the resultant total pressure of the container is the summation of partial
pressures of each of all the gases that make up the gas mixture.

PT  p A  p B

Dalton also stated that the partial pressure of gas (pA) is:

p A  y A  PT

p A = partial pressure of A in vapor phase

y A = mole fraction of A in vapor phase

PT = Total pressure of the system


PREDICTION OF VAPOR – LIQUID EQUILIBRIUM
COMPOSITIONS FOR ORDINARY BINARY MIXTURES

For a mixture of the different gases inside a close container, Dalton’s law stated
that the resultant total pressure of the container is the summation of partial
pressures of each of all the gases that make up the gas mixture.

PT  p A  p B

Dalton also stated that the partial pressure of gas (pA) is:

p A  y A  PT

p A = partial pressure of A in vapor phase

y A = mole fraction of A in vapor phase

PT = Total pressure of the system


RELATIVE VOLATILITY OF A MIXTURE

Separations of components by distillation process depend on the differences in


volatilities of components that make up the solution to be distilled.

The greater difference in their volatility, the better is separation by heating


(distillation). Conversely if their volatility differ only slightly, the separation by
heating becomes difficult.

Equilibrium diagram for n-heptane n-octane mixture at 101.3 kPa

1.00

0.80

0.60
yA

y= x
0.40

0.20

0.00
0.00 0.20 0.40 0.60 0.80 1.00

xA
RELATIVE VOLATILITY OF A MIXTURE

In figure above, the greater the distance between the equilibrium line and the 45o line,
the greater the difference between the vapor composition and a liquid composition.
Separation is more easily made.

A numerical measure of ‘how easy’ separation – relative volatility, AB.

Relative volatility, AB - ratio of the concentration of A in the vapor to the


concentration of A in the liquid divided by the ratio of the concentration B in the vapor
to the concentration of B in the liquid.
yA xA yA xA
 AB  
y B x B 1  y A  1  x A 

AB - relative volatility of A with respect to B in the binary system.

If the system obeys Raoult’s Law for an ideal system:


P x Px PA x A
yA  A A yB  B B  AB  yA 
PT PT PB 1    1x A

Separation is possible for > 1.0

For non – ideal solution, the values of change with temperature. For ideal
solution, the values of doesn’t change with temperature. For a solution that
approaches ideal solution, its would fairly constant.
Flash & Batch Distillation

FLASH (EQUILIBRIUM) DISTILLATION

SIMPLE BATCH DISTILLATION


FLASH (EQUILIBRIUM) DISTILLATION

Flash distillation – a single stage process because it has only one vaporization
stage (means one liquid phase is exposed to one vapor phase.

Flash distillation is done by vaporizing a definite fraction of a liquid mixture in


such a way that the evolved vapor is in equilibrium with the residual liquid.

The equilibrium vapor is then separated from the equilibrium residual liquid by
condensing the vapor.

Flash distillation can be either by batch or continuous

Figure 1: A typical flow chart of a continuous flash distillation


FLASH (EQUILIBRIUM) DISTILLATION

As illustrated in Figure 1, a liquid mixture feed, with initial mole fraction of


A at xF, is pre-heated by a heater and its pressure is then reduced by an
expansion valve.

At lower pressure, the hot liquid will boil at lower temperature inside a
separator drum. In contrast to that of a simple batch distillation, the evolved
vapor is allowed to attain equilibrium with remaining liquid inside the flash
drum (separator).

Now we are interested to predict the composition (x* and y*) of these vapor
and liquid that are in equilibrium with each other.
FLASH (EQUILIBRIUM) DISTILLATION

Prediction of an equilibrium composition of vapor and liquid for a flash


distillation of an ordinary binary mixture

Consider a binary liquid mixture which is to be separated by a flash distillation


process as shown in Figure 1. Binary is composed of two components; A as low
boiler (more volatile) and B as a high boiler.

Total mass balance: F  V L

Mass balance on more volatile component (A): Fx F  y * V  x * L


V L
* denote ‘at state of equilibrium xF  y *  x*  Eq. (1)
F F

Assign f to denote fraction of the feed which has been vaporized. f is defined
mathematically as:
V
f
F
FLASH (EQUILIBRIUM) DISTILLATION

And substituting f in the total mass balance:

F  V L V L
1 
F F
L L  Eq. (2)
1 f   1 f
F F

Substituting Eq. 2 into Eq. (1) to obtain:

x F  y * f  x * (1  f )

y* 
f  1x *  x F  Eq. (3)
f f

Eq. (3) called operating line equation (y = mx + c) for a flash distillation process.
FLASH (EQUILIBRIUM) DISTILLATION

Since xF and f do not change throughout the process, only y* and x* are the
variables. A straight line with a negative slope should be obtained from the
operating line. The line gives all locus point (x*, y*) that satisfy the operating line.

Figure 2: Graphical method to determine equilibrium compositions in a flash


FLASH (EQUILIBRIUM) DISTILLATION

Example 1
A liquid mixture containing 70 mol% n-heptane (A) and 30 mol% n-octane at
30OC is to be continuously flash – vaporized at the standard atmospheric pressure
to vaporize 60 mol% of the feed.

What will be the compositions of the vapor and liquid and the temperature in
the separator for an equilibrium stage?

The equilibrium data for n-heptane-n-octane mixture at 1 atm and 30OC is given
as follows:
T (K) xA yA
371.6 1.000 1.000
374.0 0.825 0.920
377.0 0.647 0.784
380.0 0.504 0.669
383.0 0.387 0.558
386.0 0.288 0.449
389.0 0.204 0.342
392.0 0.132 0.236
395.0 0.068 0.132
398.2 0.000 0.000
FLASH (EQUILIBRIUM) DISTILLATION

Solution

Basis  100 moles of liquid feed (F)


Given, xF  0.7
V  0.6100   60 moles f  V F  60 100  0.6

We want to find equilibriu m compositio ns of vapor and liquid; y * and x *

The operating line : y* 


0.6  1x *0 .7

0 .6 0 .6
y *  0.667 x * 1.167

From the intersection of the operating line and the equilibriu m curve as
shown in the graph,
equilibriu m mol fraction of n - heptane in liquid, x*  0.62
equilibriu m mol fraction of n - heptane in vapor, y*  0.76
the temperatur e of the separator at equilibriu m  378 O C
FLASH (EQUILIBRIUM) DISTILLATION

Determination of vapor-liquid equilibrium composition


for a flash distillation of n-heptane-n-octane mixture

1
y, mol fraction of n-heptane in vapor

0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1

x,mol fraction n-heptane in liquid


SIMPLE BATCH DISTILLATION

Simple batch distillation which is also known as differential distillation refer to a


batch distillation in which only one vaporization stage (or one exposed liquid
surface) is involved.

Simple batch distillation is done by boiling a liquid mixture in a steam-jacketed-


kettle (pot) and the vapor generated is withdrawn and condensed (distillate) as fast
as it forms so that the vapor and the liquid do not have sufficient time to reach its
equilibrium.

The first portion of vapor condensed will be richest in the more volatile
component A. As the vaporization proceeds, the vaporized product becomes leaner
in A.
SIMPLE BATCH DISTILLATION

Raleigh equation for ideal and non – ideal mixtures

Consider a typical differential distillation at an instant time, t1 as shown below:

Where L = number of moles of liquid mixture in the pot


x = mol fraction of a more – volatile component (component A)
dx = infinitesimal change of mol fraction of A
SIMPLE BATCH DISTILLATION

Now consider that the differential distillation at certain infinitesimal time lapse
(t) at t2 where t2 = t1 + t, after an infinitesimal amount of liquid has vaporized as
shown below:

Mass balance of component A will yield:


xL  x  dx L  dL   ydL 

xL  xL  xdL  Ldx  dxdL  ydL


Cancel out Negligible

Ldx  xdL  ydL


Ldx  y  x dL
dL dx

L y  x 
SIMPLE BATCH DISTILLATION

Integrating both sides within limits initial t1 and final t2:

L1 x1
 1   1   1 
x1 x1
 1
  dL    dx  
L1
ln L L 2   dx ln L 1  ln L 2   dx
L2  L  x2  y  x  x 2
y  x  x 2
y  x 

 L1  x1 1 
ln   
 2  x2
L  y 
 x
dx
  Eq. (4)

Where L1 = number of moles of liquid at t1


L2 = number of moles of liquid at t2
x1 = mol fraction of A in liquid at t1
x2 = mol fraction of A in liquid at t2

Eq. (4) known as Raleigh equation – applicable for both an ideal solution (
constant) or non – ideal solution ( non - constant).

Thelnterm
L1   1  must be evaluated graphically by determining an area under
x1

  
   dx
 L2  x 2
y  x

 L1  x1 1 
the ln
graph
 L 2
of

   y  x dxversus
 x 2 
x between the limit x1 and x2.
SIMPLE BATCH DISTILLATION

Simplified Raleigh equation for ideal mixtures

For an ideal solution ( constant), the Raleigh equation can be simplified.

Consider a simple batch distillation process at an initial time, t1 as shown below:

L1 = number of moles of binary liquid mixture containing A and B at t1


A1 = number of moles component A in L1 at t1
B1 = number of moles component B in L1 at t1
x1 = mol fraction of A in in L1 at t1
dL = infinitesimal amount of liquid that has vaporized
dA = infinitesimal amount of A that has vaporized
dB = infinitesimal amount of B that has vaporized
SIMPLE BATCH DISTILLATION

We know from definitions,


 dA   dB 
yA    yB   
 dA  dB   dA  dB 

 A   B 
xA    xB   
A B  A B

Since AB is constant for an ideal mixture,


dA B

 dA  dB A  B
yA xA
 AB 
yB xB dB A

dA  dB A  B

After simplifying,
B  dA
 AB 
A  dB

Rearranging,
dB dA
  AB 
B A
SIMPLE BATCH DISTILLATION

Integrating within the limits of t1 and t2,


B2 A2
dB dA

B1
B
  AB  
A1
A

Since AB is constant,


B2 A2
dB dA B
 AB ln B B2  ln A AA12
 AB 
B1
B
 
A1
A 1

B  A 
 AB ln 2   ln 2   Eq. (5)
 B1   A1 

Equation 5 known as simplified Raleigh equation for simple batch distillation


which applicable for ideal solution.
SIMPLE BATCH DISTILLATION

Example 1

A mixture of 100 mol containing 50 mol% n-pentane and 50 mol% n-heptane is


distilled under differential (batch) conditions at 101.3 kPa until 40 mol is distilled.

What is the average composition of the total vapor distilled and the composition
of the liquid left?

The equilibrium data as follows, where x and y are mole fractions of n-pentane:

xA yA
1.000 1.000
0.867 0.984
0.594 0.925
0.398 0.836
0.254 0.701
0.145 0.521
0.059 0.271
0 0
SIMPLE BATCH DISTILLATION

Solution

Given L1  100 mol V(mol distilled)  40 mol

From material balance :


L1  L 2  V L 2  L1 - V  100 - 40 L 2  60 mol

Substituting into Eq. 4 ,


L 
x1 0.5
 1   100   1 

ln 1    dx
 L2  x 2 y  x 
ln
 60 
  
x2 
dx
yx
0.5
 1 
0.510   
x2 
y  x
dx

The unknown, x 2 is the composition of the liquid L 2 at the end


of batch distillation.
SIMPLE BATCH DISTILLATION

Solution
0.5
 1   1 
By plotting graph 
 yx

 versus x, the 
x2 
 dx value is referring
yx
to the value of area under the curve.

From the graph, area under curve  0.510 at x 2  0.277.


Composition of the liquid L 2 ,x 2  0.277.

From material balance on more volatile component,


x 1L 1  x 2 L 2 0.5  100  0.277  60
x1L1  x 2 L 2  y av V y av  y av 
V 40
y av  0.835

Average composition of total vapor distilled, y av  0.835.


Continuous / Retrification Distillation

Retrification (fractionation) – or stage distillation with reflux, from a


simplified point of view, can be considered to be a process in which a series
of flash – vaporization stages are arranged in a series in such manner that
the vapor and liquid products from each stage flow counter – current to
each other.

In contrast with flash dist., continuous dist. process is more suitable for
mixtures of about the same volatility and the condensed vapor and residual
liquid are more pure (since it is re-distilled).

The fractionator consists of many trays which have holes to permit the
vapor, V which rises up from the lower tray to bubble through and mixes
with the liquid, L on the upper tray and equilibrated, and V and L stream
leave in equilibrium.
Continuous / Retrification Distillation

During the mixing, the vapor will pick up more of component A from
the liquid while the liquid will be richer with component B. As the vapor
rises further up, it becomes richer and richer in component A but poorer
with component B.

Conversely, as the liquid falls further down, it becomes poorer with A


but richer in B. Thus we obtain a bottom product and an overhead product
of higher purity in comparison to those obtained by single – stage simple
batch or flash distillation.

Note: fractionation refers to a process where a part or whole of distillate


is being recycled back to the fractionator. The recycled distillation (known
as reflux) will supply the bulk of liquid needed to mix with vapor.
Continuous / Retrification Distillation

Where;
F = Feed flow rate (kmols/hr)
xf = m.v.c. composition of feed
(mole fraction or mol percentage)
V = Vapour flow rate (kmols/hr)
L = Reflux flow rate (kmols/hr)
D = Top Product flow rate
(kmols/hr)
xD = m.v.c. composition of top
vapour stream, top product, and
reflux (mole fraction or mol
percentage)
V" = Reboiler exit stream flow rate
(kmols/hr)
W = Bottom-product flow rate
(kmols/hr)
xW = m.v.c. composition of bottom
product and feed to reboiler (mole
fraction or mol percentage)
Continuous / Retrification Distillation

Consider of fractionating column of N plates, where the condenser and


reboiler are counted as ‘plates’. A typical ‘nth’ plate has the streams shown
below associated with:
Continuous / Retrification Distillation

The feed stream is introduced on some intermediate tray where the liquid
has approximately the same composition as the feed. The part of column
above feed point – rectifying section; the lower portion – stripping section.

With constant molal overflow assumption:


Ln-1 = Ln = Ln+1 = ... etc. Vn-1 = Vn = Vn+1 = ... etc.

Conditions for Constant Molal Overflow

Heat losses negligible (achieved more easily in industrial columns)

Negligible heat of mixing

Equal or close heats of vaporisation


Continuous / Retrification Distillation

Number of Plates Required in a Distillation Column

Four streams are involved in the transfer of heat and material across a
plate, as shown in figure above:

Plate n receives liquid Ln+1 from plate n+1 above, and vapor Vn-1 from plate
n-1 below.

Plate n supplies liquid Ln to plate n-1, and vapor Vn to plate n+1.

Action of the plate is to bring about mixing so that the vapor Vn, of
composition yn, reaches equilibrium with the liquid Ln, of composition xn.
Continuous / Retrification Distillation

CALCULATION FOR NUMBER OF PLATES

NUMBER OF PLATES BY LEWIS – SOREL METHOD

NUMBER OF PLATES BY Mc – CABE & THIELE


NUMBER OF PLATES BY LEWIS – SOREL METHOD

From figure above, binary feed F is distilled to give a top product D and a
bottom product W, with xf , xd , and xw as the corresponding mole fraction of
more volatile component.

The vapor Vt rising from top plate is condensed, and part is run back as
liquid at its boiling point to the column as reflux, the remain withdrawn as
product.

A material balance above plate n c gives:


NUMBER OF PLATES BY LEWIS – SOREL METHOD

A material balance above plate n gives:

Vn  Ln 1  D ynVn  Ln 1 xn 1  Dxd (M.V.C Balance)


Ln 1 D
yn  xn 1  xd
Vn Vn

Since moles of liquid overflow are constant, Ln may be replaced by Ln+1


and:

 Eq. 6 
Ln D
yn  xn 1  xd
Vn Vn
NUMBER OF PLATES BY LEWIS – SOREL METHOD

A material balance for bottom to above plate m (indicated by loop II) and
note that Lm = Lm+1.

Lm  Vm  W ymVm  Lm xm 1  Wx w (M.V.C Balance)

Eq. 7 
Lm W
ym  xm 1  xw 
Vm Vm

Eq. 6 (above feed point) and Eq. 7 (below feed point) – operating lines.

Equilibrium data are used to find the composition of the vapor above the
liquid, and the enrichment line to calculate the composition of liquid on the
next plate.
NUMBER OF PLATES BY LEWIS – SOREL METHOD

Example

A mixture of benzene and toluene containing 40 mole% benzene is to be


separated to give a product of 90 mole% of benzene at the top, and a bottom
product with not more than 10 mole% of benzene. The feed is heated so that it
enters the column at its boiling point, and the vapor leaving the column is
condensed but not cooled, and provides reflux and product.

It is proposed to operate the unit with a reflux ratio of 3 kmol/kmol


product. It is required to find the number of theoretical plates needed and the
position of entry for the feed. The equilibrium diagram for operating at 1 bar
pressure is shown in Figure below.
NUMBER OF PLATES BY LEWIS – SOREL METHOD

Solution

Feed : 40 mol% benzene (A), xf = 0.40


Product : 90 mol% benzene (A), xd = 0.90
Bottom : 10 mol% benzene (A), xw = 0.10

Do a basis: 100 kmol of feed. A total material balance gives:


F DW 100  D  W W  100 - D  Eq. a 
A balance on M.V.C (benzene) gives:
F  xf  D  xd  W  x w 1000.4   D0.9   W 0.1
40  0.9D  0.1W  Eq. b 

Insert Eq. a  into Eq. b 


40  0.9D  0.1100 - D 
D  37.5 kmol.
From Eq. a , W  100 - 37.5
W  62.5 kmol
NUMBER OF PLATES BY LEWIS – SOREL METHOD

Using a notation from reflux,

Ln
R L n  RD L n  3D L n  337.5 L n  112 .5
D

From Material balance at top stage,


Vn  L n  D Vn  112.5  37.5 Vn  150 kmol

Thus, the top operating line equation (Eq. 6) :


112.5 37.5
yn 
Ln
xn 1 
D
xd yn  xn 1  0.9 
Vn Vn 150 150
y n  0.75 xn 1  0.225
NUMBER OF PLATES BY LEWIS – SOREL METHOD

Since the feed is all liquid at its boiling point, it will all run down as
increased reflux to the plate below. Thus:

Lm  Ln  F L m  112.5  100 L m  212.5 kmol

From materialbalance at Bottom,


Vm  L m  W Vm  212.5  62.5 Vm  150 kmol  Vn

From Bottom operating line,


212.5 62.5
ym 
Lm
xm 1 
W
xw ym  xm 1  0.1
Vm Vm 150 150
ym  1.417 xm 1  0.0417
NUMBER OF PLATES BY LEWIS – SOREL METHOD

Since all vapor from column is condensed, the composition of the vapor, yt
from top plate = product, xd and liquid returned, xr

From yn  0.75 xn 1  0.225


Let say, x n 1  x d  0.9
yn  0.75 0.9   0.225 yn  0.9

The composition xt of the liquid on the top plate is found from the
equilibrium curve and since it is in equilibrium with vapor of composition
yt = 0.90, xt = 0.79.

yt 1  0.75 xt  0.225 yt 1  0.750.79  0.225


yt 1  0.8175

From Eq. diagram at yt 1  0.8175, x t 1  0.644


NUMBER OF PLATES BY LEWIS – SOREL METHOD

yt  2  0.75 xt 1  0.225 yt 2  0.750.644  0.225


yt  2  0.708

From Eq. diagram at yt 2  0.708, x t  2  0.492

yt 3  0.75 xt  2  0.225 yt 3  0.750.492  0.225


yt 3  0.594

From Eq. diagram at yt 3  0.594, x t  3  0.382

This last value of composition is sufficiently near to the feed composition


(xf =0.4). Feed to be introduced on plate t-3.

For the lower part of the column, the bottom operating line equation will
be used.
NUMBER OF PLATES BY LEWIS – SOREL METHOD

y m  1.417 xm 1  0.0417
yt  4  1.417 xt 3  0.0417
yt  4  1.4170.382   0.0417 yt  4  0.50
From Eq. diagram,at y t  4  0.50, x t - 4  0.298

yt 5  1.417 xt  4  0.0417
yt 5  1.4170.298  0.0417 yt 5  0.379
From Eq. diagram,at y t  5  0.379 x t - 5  0.208

yt 6  1.417 xt 5  0.0417
yt 6  1.4170.208  0.0417 yt 6  0.252
From Eq. diagram,at y t 6  0.252 x t -6  0.120

yt 7  1.417 xt 6  0.0417
yt 7  1.4170.120  0.0417 yt 7  0.127
From Eq. diagram,at y t 7  0.127 x t -7  0.048
NUMBER OF PLATES BY LEWIS – SOREL METHOD

This liquid xt-7 is slightly weaker than the minimum required and maybe
withdrawn as the bottom product (the xt-7 value < xw).

Thus, xx-7 will correspond to the reboiler, and there will be seven plates in
the column.

No of theoretical stages = 7 stage + 1 reboiler.


NUMBER OF PLATES BY LEWIS – SOREL METHOD

yt = 0.9
yt-1 = 0.8175
yt-2 = 0.708

yt-3 = 0.594

xt = 0.79
xt-1 = 0.644
xt-2 = 0.492
xt-3 = 0.382
NUMBER OF PLATES BY Mc – CABE & THIELE

Assumption: constant molal heat of vaporization, no heat losses, no heat on


mixing, led to a constant molal vapor flow and constant molar reflux flow in
any section of column, the two enrichment equation obtained were:

 Eq. 6 
Ln D
yn  xn 1  xd
Vn Vn

 Eq. 7 
Lm W
ym  xm 1  xw
Vm Vm

Mc Cabe and Thiele pointed out that, since these equations represent
straight lines connecting yn with xn+1 and ym with xm+1, they can be drawn on
the same diagram as the equilibrium curve to give a simple graphical solution
for the number of stages required .

In Eq. (6), if xn+1 = xd, then yn = xn+1 = xd :

Ln D  Ln  D   Ln 1  D   Vn 
yn  
x d  xd  xd  
 
 xd  
  xd    xd
Vn Vn  Vn   Vn   Vn 
NUMBER OF PLATES BY Mc – CABE & THIELE

In Eq. (6), if xn+1 = 0, then yn = Dxd / Vn :

yn 
Ln
0  D xd  D xd
Vn Vn Vn
The top operating line drawn through two points of coordinates (xd, xd)
and (0, Dxd / Vn)

In Eq. (7), if xm+1 = xw, then ym = xw.


Lm W  L W  V 
ym  xw  xw   m  xw   m  xw  xw
Vm Vm  Vm   Vm 
For bottom operating line passes point (xw, xw) and has a slope (Lm/Vm).

When two operating lines drawn in, the number of stages required may
be found by drawing steps between the operating line and the equilibrium
curve starting from point xd.

Limitation of method: 1.3 < relative volatility < 5, reflux ratio >1.1 minimum
reflux ratio, theoretical stages < 25
NUMBER OF PLATES BY Mc – CABE & THIELE

Example

A mixture of benzene and toluene containing 40 mole% benzene is to be


separated to give a product of 90 mole% of benzene at the top, and a bottom
product with not more than 10 mole% of benzene. The feed is heated so that it
enters the column at its boiling point, and the vapor leaving the column is
condensed but not cooled, and provides reflux and product.

It is proposed to operate the unit with a reflux ratio of 3 kmol/kmol


product. It is required to find the number of theoretical plates needed and the
position of entry for the feed. The equilibrium diagram for operating at 1 bar
pressure is shown in Figure below.
NUMBER OF PLATES BY Mc – CABE & THIELE

Solution

Feed : 40 mol% benzene (A), xf = 0.40


Product : 90 mol% benzene (A), xd = 0.90
Bottom : 10 mol% benzene (A), xw = 0.10

Do a basis: 100 kmol of feed. A total material balance gives:


F DW 100  D  W W  100 - D  Eq. a 
A balance on M.V.C (benzene) gives:
F  xf  D  xd  W  x x 1000.4   D0.9   W0.1
40  0.9D  0.1W  Eq. b 

Insert Eq. a  into Eq. b 


40  0.9D  0.1100 - D 
D  37.5 kmol.
From Eq. a , W  100 - 37.5
W  62.5 kmol
NUMBER OF PLATES BY Mc – CABE & THIELE

Using a notation from reflux,

Ln
R L n  RD L n  3D L n  337.5 L n  112 .5
D

From Material balance at top stage,


Vn  L n  D Vn  112.5  37.5 Vn  150 kmol

Thus, the top operating line equation (Eq. 6) :


112.5 37.5
yn 
Ln
xn 1 
D
xd yn  xn 1  0.9 
Vn Vn 150 150
y n  0.75 xn 1  0.225
NUMBER OF PLATES BY Mc – CABE & THIELE

Since the feed is all liquid at its boiling point, it will all run down as
increased reflux to the plate below. Thus:

Lm  Ln  F L m  112.5  100 L m  212.5 kmol

From materialbalance at Bottom,


Vm  L m  W Vm  212.5  62.5 Vm  150 kmol  Vn

From Bottom operating line,


212.5 62.5
ym 
Lm
xm 1 
W
xw ym  xm 1  0.1
Vm Vm 150 150
ym  1.417 xm 1  0.0417
NUMBER OF PLATES BY Mc – CABE & THIELE
NUMBER OF PLATES BY Mc – CABE & THIELE

The intersection of operating lines

• Feed enters as liquid at its boiling point that the two operating lines
intersect at a point having an x – coordinate of xf.. The locus point of the
intersection of the operating lines is considerable importance since; it is
dependent on the temperature and physical condition of feed.

• If the two operating lines intersect at a point with coordinates (xq, yq), then
from equation 6 and 7:

yqVn  Ln xq  Dx d yqVm  Lm xq  Wx w
yq Vm  Vn   Lm  Ln xq  Dx d  Wx w   Eq. 8 

• A material balance over the feed plate gives:


F  Vm  Ln  Lm  Vn Vm  Vn  Lm  Ln  F  Eq. 9 
NUMBER OF PLATES BY Mc – CABE & THIELE

Feed is form of liquid at its boiling point, the reflux overflowing  Ln  F . If


feed is a liquid at temperature Tf, less than the boiling point, some vapor rising
from the plate below will condense to provide sufficient heat to bring the feed
liquor to the boiling point.

Let Hf = enthalpy per mol of feed, Hfs = enthalpy of one mol of feed at its
boiling point. Heat to be supplied to bring feed to its boiling point is F(Hfs - Hf ),
number of vapor mols to be condensed to provide this heat is F(Hfs - Hf ) / ,
where  is molar latent heat of vapor

Reflux liquor:

Lm  Ln  F 

F H fs  H f  Lm  Ln 

F   H fs  H f  Lm  Ln  qF  Eq. 10
 
Heat to vaporize1 mol of feed
q
Molar latent heat of feed
NUMBER OF PLATES BY Mc – CABE & THIELE

Insert Eq 9 into 10:


Vm  Vn  Ln  qF  Ln  F Vm  Vn  qF  F  Eq. 11

A material balance for m.v.c over whole column gives:


Fx f  Dx d  Wxw

From Eq. 8, Eq. 10 and Eq 11:

yq qF  F   qF xq  Fx f   yq q  1F  qF xq  Fx f


xf
Eq. 12 q - line equation
q
yq  xq  
q  1 q  1
If xq = xf, then yq = xf. The point of intersection of the two operating lines lies
on the straight line of slope q / (q-1) passing through point (xf, xf). When yq = 0,
xq = xf / q.
NUMBER OF PLATES BY Mc – CABE & THIELE

From definition of q, it follows that the slope of q – line is governed by the


nature of feed,
NUMBER OF PLATES BY Mc – CABE & THIELE

Total and Minimum Reflux Ratio for Mc Cabe – Thiele Method


R x
yn  xn1  d  Top operating line (rectifying section)
R 1 R 1
Total reflux –Limiting values of the reflux ratio, R = . Since R = Ln/D and
Vn=Ln+1+D, Ln+1 is very large, as is the vapor Vn. The slope of the top operating
R x
line, = 1.0, d = 0, eq. become, operating line of both sections of the
R 1 R 1
column coincide with the 45O diagonal line as shown in figure below .
NUMBER OF PLATES BY Mc – CABE & THIELE

The number of theoretical trays required obtained as before by stepping off


the trays from the distillate to the bottoms – gives the minimum number of
trays can possibly be used to obtain the given separation.

In actual practice – condition can be realized by returning all the overhead


condenser vapor V1 from the top to the tower back to the tower as reflux, that
is total reflux. All the liquid in the bottom is reboiled – all the production
distillate and bottoms are reduced to zero flow, as the fresh feed to the tower.

Minimum reflux ratio – reflux


ratio, Rm that will acquire an infinite
number of trays for the given
desired separation of xd and xw. This
corresponds to the minimum vapor
flow in the tower, hence minimum
reboiler and condenser size.
NUMBER OF PLATES BY Mc – CABE & THIELE

If R decreased, the slope of T.O.L (R/(R+1)) is decreased, T.O.L closer to the


equilibrium line. Number of steps required to give a fixed xd and xw increases.

When two operating line touch the equilibrium line, a ‚pinch point‛ at y’
and x’ occurs where the number of steps required become infinite.

The slope of T.O.L: Rm x  y'


 d
Rm  1 xd  x'

xd
The y-intercept of T.O.L: y  intercept 
Rm  1
NUMBER OF PLATES BY Mc – CABE & THIELE

Operating and optimum reflux ratio:

For the case of total reflux, the number of plates is a minimum, but the
tower diameter is infinite. This corresponds to an infinite cost of tower.

For minimum reflux, the number of trays infinite, gives an infinite


cost.

These are the two limits in operation of the tower. The actual reflux
ratio to use is lies between two limits.

The optimum reflux ratio between Rm total reflux. For many cases,
operating reflux ratio between 1.2Rm and 1.5Rm.
NUMBER OF PLATES BY Mc – CABE & THIELE

Example 2

11,000 kg/h of equal parts (in wt) of Benzene – Toluene solution is to be


distilled in a fractionating tower at atmospheric pressure.

The liquid is fed as a liquid – vapor mixture in which the feed consist of
75% vapor. The distillate contains 94 wt% Benzene whereas the bottom
products contains 98 wt% toluene. Using the equilibrium diagram of
Benzene-Toluene mixture, determine by McCabe-Thiele’s method:

The flow rate of distillate and bottom product in kg/h


The minimum reflux ratio, Rm.
The number of theoretical stages required if the reflux ratio
used is 2 times the minimum reflux ratio
The position of the feed tray.

Data:
Molecular weight of Benzene = 78
Molecular weight of Toluene = 92
NUMBER OF PLATES BY Mc – CABE & THIELE

Solution 2

Feed : 50 wt% benzene (A), xf = 0.50


F : 11,000 kg/h
Product : 94 wt% benzene (A), xd = 0.94
Bottom : 2 wt% benzene (A), xw = 0.02

The flow rate of distillate and bottom product in kg/h

A total material balance gives:


F DW 11000  D  W W  11000 - D  Eq. a 
A balance on M.V.C (benzene) gives:
F  xf  D  xd  W  x w 110000.5  D0.94  W0.02
5500  0.94D  0.02W  Eq. b 
Insert Eq. a  into Eq. b 
5500  0.94D  0.0211000 - D
D  5739.1 kg/h.
From Eq. a , W  11000 - 5739.1
W  5260.9 kg/h
NUMBER OF PLATES BY Mc – CABE & THIELE

The minimum reflux ratio, Rm.

1) Convert mass fraction to mol fraction


Do basis calculation: 100 kg

Feed (F) Distillate (D) Bottoms (W)


Component Mwt Mass Mol Mol Mass Mol Mol Mass Mol Mol
frac. frac. frac.
Benzene (A) 78 50 0.64 0.54 94 1.21 0.95 2 0.03 0.03

Toluene (B) 92 50 0.54 0.46 6 0.07 0.05 98 1.07 0.97


Total 1.18 1.00 1.28 1.00 1.10 1.00

From conversion table, mol fraction for M.V.C:

xf = 0.54 xd = 0.95 xw = 0.03


NUMBER OF PLATES BY Mc – CABE & THIELE

2) Find q – line. Feed enters at 75% vapor.

q  0.75 ( qvap. )  0.25 ( qliq. )


q  0.75 (0)  0.25 (1.0) q  0.25

q line equation
 q   xf 
y q    xq   
 q 1  q 1
 0.25   0.54 
yq    xq    y q  0.333xq  0.72
 0.25  1   0.25  1 

Let x  0.3, y q  0.3330.3  0.72 y q  0.62

Plot (0.54 , 0.54) and (0.30 , 0.62) for q-line


NUMBER OF PLATES BY Mc – CABE & THIELE

From the graph, y intercept for q – line = 0.36


xd 0.95
 0.36  0.36 Rm  1.64
Rm  1 Rm  1

The number of theoretical stages required if the reflux ratio used


is 2 times the minimum reflux ratio

R  2 Rmin  21.64 R  3.28

R x
yn  xn 1  d  Top operating line
R 1 R 1
3.28 0.95
yn  xn 1 
3.28  1 3.28  1

yn  0.766xn 1  0.222
Plot (0.95 , 0.95) and
At x  0.5, yn  0.7660.5  0.222 y n  0.605 (0.5, 0.605) for T.O.L
NUMBER OF PLATES BY Mc – CABE & THIELE
NUMBER OF PLATES BY Mc – CABE & THIELE

The number of theoretical stages required = 10.5 stages including


reboiler

Feed plate location: 5 from top


Azeotropic Distillation

AZEOTROPE / AZEOTROPIC MIXTURE

MINIMUM BOILING POINT (POSITIVE DEVIATION)

MAXIMUM BOILING POINT (NEGATIVE DEVIATION)

AZEOTROPIC DISTILLATION
AZEOTROPE / AZEOTROPIC MIXTURE

Very large deviations from ideally lead to a special class of mixtures known as
azeotropes.

Azeotrope is a special class of liquid mixture that boils at a constant


temperature at a certain composition.

It acts if it was one component with one constant boiling point.

In other words, vapor and liquid compositions are equal.

Cannot be separated by conventional distillation.

For example ethanol –water system, one cannot recover more than 89.4 mol%
ethanol by ordinary distillation because the mixture forms azeotropes at this point.

Other separation methods (for eg solvent extraction) or azeotropic distillation


may be used.

Two types of azeotropes known are:


(i) Minimum boiling
(ii) Maximum boiling (less common)
MINIMUM BOILING POINT (POSITIVE DEVIATION)

At point Z2, the concentration in the vapor phase is the same as the
concentration in the liquid phase (y=x) and =1.

At this point, the mixture boils at constant temperature and doesn’t change
in composition.

On the equilibrium diagram, the equilibrium crossed at 45O diagonal line.

Z2
MINIMUM BOILING POINT (POSITIVE DEVIATION)

The most common examples of this type of azeotrope are:

Ethanol – water (89.4 mol% water, 78.25OC, 1 atm)

Carbon Disulfide – Acetone (61 mole% CS2, 39.25OC, 1 atm)

Benzene – water (29.6 mole% water, 69.25OC, 1 atm)


MAXIMUM BOILING POINT (NEGATIVE DEVIATION)

At point Z2, the characteristic of such mixture is boiling point curve goes
through maximum phase diagram.

Example of this type of azeotrope is:

Acetone – chloroform

Z2
AZEOTROPIC DISTILLATION

The distillation of a mixture that is azeotropic begins similarly to


conventional distillation.

The difference is that, as the process continues.


A temperature is reached at which the compositions of the vapor
phase and the liquid phase become the SAME.

Once this azeotrope has been formed, the individual components can no
longer be separated by conventional distillation.
*Note: the description of azeotrope distillation only refers to
minimum boiling distillation of azeo. only.

Recall the mixture of ethanol – water, that demonstrates azeo behaviour at


89.4 mol% at 78.15OC and 1 atm.
AZEOTROPIC DISTILLATION

Therefore, by conventional distillation, the highest concentration of ethanol


achieved is the azeotropic concentration, i.e 89.4 mol%.

Azeotropic distillation refers to an introduction of a new component called


entrainer is added to the original mixture to form an azeotrope with one or more
of feed component.

The azeotrope is then removed as either the distillate or bottoms.

This type of distillation also refers to a new components (entrainer) is added to


break an azeotrope from being formed by the original feed mixture.

Entrainer – as described above has the following functions that are:

To separate one component of a closely boiling point, or


To separate one component of an azeotrope.
AZEOTROPIC DISTILLATION

Recall the binary mixture, A – B that formed an ezeotropic mixture, the


entrainer C is added to form a new azeotrope with the original components,
often in the LVC, say A.

The new azeotrope (A – C) is separated from the other original component


B.

This new azeotrope is then separated into entrainer C and original


component A. Hence the separation of A and B can be achieved.

Alternative method to azeo – distillation: is when no entainer is used,


instead the column is operated at different pressure, since changing the
operating P can eliminate azeotropic behaviour in some systems.
AZEOTROPIC DISTILLATION

Example of Azeotropic Distillation:

Distillation acetic – acid water using entrainer: n-butyl acetate.

Boiling point (B.P) of acetic acid is 118.1OC while water is 100OC, whereas
n-butyl acetate is 125OC.

The addition of n-butyl acetate results in


the formation of a minimum boiling
azeotrope with water with a B.P of 90.2OC.

The azeotropic mixture will therefore be


distilled over as a vapor product and acetic
acid as bottom product.

The distillate is condensed and collected in


a decanter where it forms two insoluble
layers.
AZEOTROPIC DISTILLATION

Example of Azeotropic Distillation:

Distillation acetic – acid water using entrainer: n-butyl acetate.

Top layer consists of nearly pure butyl acetate in water, whereas


bottom layer of nearly pure water saturated with butyl acetate.

The liquid from top layer is returned to column as reflux and


entrainer.

The liquid from bottom layer is sent to another column to recover the
entrainer (by stream stripping).
AZEOTROPIC DISTILLATION

Distillation ethanol-water system.


Entainer: Benzene with Boiling point (B.P) at 80.2OC that forms a new-
minimum boiling point azeotrope with 22.8 mol% ethanol (E), 23.3 mol%
water (W) and 53.9 mol% benzene (B) (three comp. azeotrope).

The B.P of the azeotrope mixture is 64.86OC which leaves top product and
bottom consist of nearly pure ethanol.

The condensed overhead product forms two


layer in the decanter – top and bottom layer). Top layer
*Rich in benzene.
*Returned to column as reflux
The bottom layer is sent to a 2nd column where and entrainer
benzene is stripped and returned to the 1st column.
Bottom layer
*Rich in water with a small
The bottom product (E-W) are fed to a 3rd Distill. amount of ethanol.
for further distillation.
Multi – component Distillation

INTRODUCTION OF MULTI – COMP. DISTILLATION

EQUILIBRIUM DATA IN MULTI. DISTILLATION

BOILING POINT, DEW POINT AND FLASH DISTILLATION

LIGHT AND HEAVY KEY COMPONENT


INTRODUCTION OF MULTI – COMP. DISTILLATION

For binary mixture for constant P – vapor liquid equilibrium curve rather
unique.

With a ternary mixture, the conditions of equilibrium curve are more complex
for constant P where mol fraction of the two components in liq. phase must be
given before composition of vapor can be fixed/determine.

Therefore, the mol fraction yA not only depends on xA but also on the
proportions of the other two components.

Graphical method are not generally suitable.

The possible method used – plate to plate analysis.

For many systems consisting particularly similar chemically substances, the


relative volatilities of the components remain constant over a wide range of T and
composition.
INTRODUCTION OF MULTI – COMP. DISTILLATION

This is illustrated by the table below:

Temperature (K)
Component 353 393 453
Phenol 1.25 1.25 1.25
o – Cresol 1 1 1
M – Cresol 0.57 0.62 0.70
Xylenols 0.30 0.38 0.42

An alternative method is to use the simple relation.

y A  K xA where K  equilibrium constant


(or Equilibrium Vaporization ratio)

Particularly useful for hydrocarbon processing in petroleum industry

The K values can be measured .


INTRODUCTION OF MULTI – COMP. DISTILLATION

The feed and Product Compositions

Gilliand and Reed have determined the no. of freedom, F for multi –
component Distillation (MCD).

For the common case:


where Feed composition, nature of feed and operating pressure are given,
there remain only four variables to be selected.

If the reflux ratio, R is fixed, the no. of plate above and below the feed plate
are chosen to give the best used of plates, then only two variables remains.

This means that the top and bottom product composition has been
determined by trial and error method.

This problem of Trial and Error method can rather be simplified by


assuming MVC appears at top and LVC appears on bottom product.
EQUILIBRIUM DATA IN MULTI. DISTILLATION

Consider as ideal mixture, we can apply Raoult’s Law to determine the


composition of vapor in equilibrium with liquid.

Consider a four – component (A,B,C,D) mixture:

p A  x A PAo p B  xB PBo pC  xC PCo p D  xD PDo


p A PAo PBo PCo PDo
yA   xA yB  xB yC  xC yD  xD
P P P P P

In hydrocarbon system, because nonidealities, the equilibrium data are often


represented by:

y A  K A xA y B  K B xB yC  K C xC y D  K D xD
KA is the vapor – liquid equilibrium constant or distribution coefficient for
component A.

Pi o for component i individual component.


Ki 
P
EQUILIBRIUM DATA IN MULTI. DISTILLATION

K value is easily determined (refer K-chart) for hydrocarbons system but need
to be calculated for other system.

The relative volatility, i for each individual component in a multi component


mixture can be defined in a similar manner to that of a binary mixture.

Need to select a base component, say component C:

Ki K KB KC KD
αi  , hence α A  A αB  αC   1.0 αD 
KC KC KC KC KC

The values of Ki depend strongly on T.


BOILING POINT, DEW POINT AND FLASH DISTILLATION

Boiling Point.
At a specified pressure, the boiling point or bubble point of a given multi –
component mixture satisfy the relation  yi = 1.0. For a mixture A, B, C, and D,
with C as the base component,

 yi   K i xi  K C  αi xi  1.0

The calculation is a trial – and – error process where:


T is assumed.
Values of i are then calculated using K values at the assume T.
Then calculate value of KC where

1.0
KC 
 αi xi

Find the T that corresponds to the calculated value of KC


Compare with T value read from table that corresponds to the KC
(calculated)
BOILING POINT, DEW POINT AND FLASH DISTILLATION

Boiling Point.

If values is differ, the calculated T is used for next iteration.


After the final T is known, the vapor composition is calculated from:
αi xi
yi 
 αi xi
Dew Point.

Also based on the trial and error method:


yi  1   yi 
 xi    
K i  K C 
 
 αi
  1.0

The values of KC is calculated from:
1.0
KC 
 αi xi

After the final T is known, the liquid composition is calculated from:


yi αi
xi 
 yi αi
BOILING POINT, DEW POINT AND FLASH DISTILLATION

Example 3

A liquid feed to a distillation tower at 405.3 kPa abs is fed to a distillation


tower. The composition in mol fractions is as follows:

n – butane (xA = 0.40) n –pentane (xB = 0.25)


n – hexane (xC = 0.20) n – heptane (xD = 0.15)

Calculate the boiling point and the vapor in equilibrium with liquid.

Solution 3

Assume first trial and error temperature, let say T=65OC. Find the values of
K from Figure B1

Using component C (n – hexane) as base component, the following values


are calculated for the first trial:
BOILING POINT, DEW POINT AND FLASH DISTILLATION

Figure B1: Equilibrium K values for light hydrocarbon system at 405.3 kPa absolute.
BOILING POINT, DEW POINT AND FLASH DISTILLATION

Assume first trial and error temperature, let say T=65OC.

Set n-hexane as base component. Initial Kc = Ki (hexane) = 0.245


Ki
αi 
KC
Ki 1.68
For n - butane,α    6.857
K C 0.245
Do same calculation for n-pentane, n-hexane and n-heptane

For the first trial (T=65OC),

Component xi Ki (from chart) i=Ki/KC ixi


n-butane (xA) 0.40 1.68 6.857 2.743
n-pentane (xB) 0.25 0.63 2.571 0.643
n-hexane (xC) 0.20 0.245 1.000 0.200
n-heptane (xD) 0.15 0.093 0.380 0.057
1.00 ixi = 3.643
BOILING POINT, DEW POINT AND FLASH DISTILLATION

1 1
From table above, K C    0.2745
  i xi 3.643

From graph, for n-hexane at K = 0.275, T = 69OC

Using T = 69OC for trial 2, a temperature of 70OC is obtained.

Using T = 70OC for trial 3, the calculation shown final value of 70OC,
which is bubble point.

Values y is calculated from: yi=ixi/ixi

From trial 3,

Component xi Ki (from chart) i=Ki/KC i x i yi


n-butane (xA) 0.40 1.86 6.607 2.643 0.748
n-pentane (xB) 0.25 0.710 2.522 0.631 0.178
n-hexane (xC) 0.20 0.2815 1.000 0.200 0.057
n-heptane (xD) 0.15 0.110 0.391 0.059 0.017
1.00 ixi = 3.533 1.000
LIGHT AND HEAVY KEY COMPONENT

The essential requirement in Multi – comp. Distillation is to separate the two


components.

These components are called key component.

Suppose a four component mixture A-B-C-D where:

A is MVC where the mixture is to


B is LVC be separated as below:

Feed Top Product Bottom Product


A A
B B B
C C C
D D

Then; B – is the lightest comp. in bottom and called Light Key Component (LKC)

C – is the heaviest comp. in top / distillate and called Heavy Key Component (HKC)

The main purpose of fractionating is to separate B from C


LIGHT AND HEAVY KEY COMPONENT

The calculation of No. of plates required.


Developed by Lewis and Matheson (which is based on Lewis – Sorel
method).

This L – M method illustrates that:


if the comp. of liquid on any plate is known, then the vapor
component can be calculated using the vapor pressure @  of individual
components.

Suppose: a component mixture A-B-C-D with liquid composition xA, xB, xC,
xD,& etc. and vapor comp. yA, yB, yC, yD ,& etc. Then…..

The calculation of No. of plates required.


From the relation of vapor pressure, mole fraction, relative volatility (α)
and the K value:

Let say B is the bas e (referen ce) compon ent


xB x A AB xC CB x D DB
yB  yA  yC  yD 
  x 
i i   i xi    i xi    i xi 
LIGHT AND HEAVY KEY COMPONENT

Example 4

A mixture of ortho (o), meta (m), and para (p) mononitrotoluenes with mole
percentage as below:

ortho (o) (xo = 0.60) para (p) (xp = 0.36)


meta (m) (xm = 0.04)

is to be continuously distilled to give a top product of 98 mol% ortho, and


the bottom is to contain 12.5 mol% ortho.
The mixture is to be distilled at temperature of 410 K requiring a pressure
in the boiler of about 0.06 bar.
If a reflux ratio of 5 is used, calculate:

a) The number of plates will be required


b) The approximate compositions of product streams

The volatility of ortho relative to para isomer is taken as 1.70 and the
volatility of meta relative to para is 1.16 over the temperature range of 380 to
415 K
LIGHT AND HEAVY KEY COMPONENT

Solution 4

As a first estimate, suppose the distillate to contain 0.6 mol% meta and 1.4
mol% para.

Material balance will give the composition of the bottom.

Do overall material balance to find the amount of Distillate and Bottom


Product

F=D+W 100 = D + W D = 100-W

Material balance on Ortho component


0.6100   0.98D   0.125 W 
60  0.98100  W   0.125W
W  44.44 mol
D  55.56 mol
LIGHT AND HEAVY KEY COMPONENT

Solution 4
Calculate material balance for other component

Meta 4=0.11+xWM(44.44) xWM= 0.083


Para 36=1+xWP(44.44) xWP= 0.792

Feed (F) Distillate (D) Bottom (W)


Component Mole xf Mole xd Mole xw
Ortho 60 0.600 54.450 0.980 5.555 0.125
Meta 4 0.040 0.333 0.006 3.667 0.083
Para 36 0.360 0.778 0.014 35.222 0.793
Total 100 1.000 55.560 1.000 44.440 1.000
LIGHT AND HEAVY KEY COMPONENT

Solution 4

Equation of operating lines


Above the feed point:
Liquid downflow, Ln = 5D = 5 (55.56) = 277.8
Vapor up, Vn = Ln + D = 5D + D = 6D = 6 (55.56)
Vapor up, Vn = 333.3
Below feed point:
Liquid downflow, Lm = Ln + F = 277.8 + 100 = 377.80
Vapor up, Vm =Lm - W = 377.8 - 44.44 = 333.36
LIGHT AND HEAVY KEY COMPONENT

Solution 4

The equation of operating lines below the feed plate can be written as:
Lm W
ym  x m 1  xw
Vm Vm

Ortho y mo 
377 .8
xm 1 
44.44
0.125  y mo  1.133 x m 1  0.0167
333 .36 333 .36

Meta y mm 
377 .8
xm1 
44.44
0.083  y mm  1.133 x m 1  0.011
333 .36 333 .36

Para y mp 
377 .8
xm1 
44.44
0.792  y mp  1.133 xm1  0.105
333 .36 333 .36
LIGHT AND HEAVY KEY COMPONENT

Solution 4

The equation of operating lines above the feed plate can be written as:
Ln D
yn  x n 1  xd
Vn Vn

Ortho y no 
277 .8
xn 1 
55.56
0.98  y no  0.833 x n 1  0.163
333 .36 333 .36

Meta y no 
277 .8
xn 1 
55.56
0.006  y nm  0.833 x n 1  0.001
333 .36 333 .36

Para y np 
277 .8
xn 1 
55.56
0.014  y np  0.833 xn1  0.003
333 .36 333 .36
LIGHT AND HEAVY KEY COMPONENT

Solution 4

Start the calculation from bottom plate (below the feed plate)

Component  xs xs ys x1
Ortho 1.7 0.125 0.213 0.193 0.185
Meta 1.16 0.083 0.096 0.087 0.087
Para 1 0.792 0.792 0.719 0.728
1.101 1.000 1.000

Component x1 x 1 y1 x2
Ortho 0.185 0.315 0.275 0.258
Meta 0.087 0.101 0.088 0.088
Para 0.728 0.728 0.637 0.655
1.000 1.143 1.000 1.000
LIGHT AND HEAVY KEY COMPONENT

Solution 4

Continue the calculation until x > xf

Component x6 x 6 y6 x7
Ortho 0.564 0.96 0.68 0.617
Meta 0.064 0.07 0.05 0.056
Para 0.372 0.37 0.26 0.326
1.000 1.40 1.00 1.000

The feed will be introduce at plate 7 since the liquid on this plate has a
composition with the ratio of concentration ortho and para about that in the
feed.

Continue the Calculation above the feed plate.


LIGHT AND HEAVY KEY COMPONENT
Solution 4
Continue the Calculation above the feed plate
Component  x7 x 7 y7 x8
Ortho 1.7 0.617 1.049 0.728 0.678
Meta 1.16 0.056 0.065 0.045 0.053
Para 1 0.326 0.326 0.227 0.270
1.000 1.441 1.000 1.001

Continue the Calculation until x > xd

Component y15 x16 x16 y16


Ortho 0.970 0.969 1.647 0.980
Meta 0.011 0.012 0.014 0.008
Para 0.019 0.020 0.020 0.012
1.000 1.001 1.681 1.000

The vapor from the sixteenth plate has the required concentration of the
ortho isomer.
16 ideal stages is required for the separation.

You might also like