Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Semester VI
Submitted
By
Sayli More
Roll No. 19
BHANDUP- 4000 78
DECLARATION
I, SAYLI V. MORE the student of T.Y. BAF Semester VI (2018-2019) hereby declare that I have
To list who all have helped me is difficult they are so numerous and the depth is so numerous.
I would like to acknowledge the following as idealistic channels and fresh dimensions in the
I take this opportunity to thank University of Mumbai for giving me chance to do this project.
I would like to thank my Principal Mrs merry mam for providing the necessary facilities required for
Completion of project.
I would also like to express my sincere gratitude towards my project guide whose guidance and
I would like to thank my College Library, for having provided various reference books and
Lastly, I would like to thank each and every person who directly or indirectly helped me in the
complention of the project especially my Parents and Peers who supported me throughout my
project.
laundering would have a time of several countries in order to obscure its origin. It
was difficult to discuss the topic of money laundering nationally in abstract. If done
so would have appeared as a patchwork. to have a comprehensive paper, the
researcher discuss the theme of the paper in three parts.
INDEX
SR.N TOPIC PG.NO
O
I PART-I
I.I Introduction to money laundering 08
I.II Money laundering- The root Problem 08
I.III Money laundering- The concept 11
I.IV Money laundering- An organised crime 11
I.V Money laundering-Historical evolution 12
I.VI Money laundering- The Alarming Statistics 13
II PART-II
II.I The process of Money Laundering
II.II Some Techniques of Money Laundering
II.III New Areas of Operational of Money
Laundering
II.IV Harmful Effects of Money Laundering
II.V Argument for money laundering - how far
sustainable ?
II.VI Rational for Anti money laundering law
III PART-III
III.I Regulation of Money laundering international
perspective
III.II Basel committee on banking Regulation and
supervisory practices
III.III UN Convention against illegal traffic in
Narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances
III.IV GPML
III.V The financial action task force
III.VI Council of Europe Convention on Laundering ,
search, seizure and Confiscation of the proceeds
of crime
IV PART-IV
IV-I REGULATION OF MONEY LAUNDERING IN
INDIA
IV-II Salient features of prevention of Money
Laundering Act 2002
IV-III The schedule to the Act
IV-IV Inclusion on New Definition
IV.V Prevention of Money laundering Act 2011
IV.VI Financial Intelligence Unit-India (FIU-IND)
IV.VII Role of Reserve Bank of India
IV.VIII Role of Securities Exchange Board of India
IV.XI Problem area for India in having a proper AML
PART-I
I.I. INTRODUCTION TO MONEY LAUNDERING
Money is like fire, an element as little troubled by moralising as earth, air and
water men can employ it as a tool or they can dance around it as if were the
incarnation of a God. money vote's socialist or monarchist, finds a profit in
pornography or translation from the bible, commissions Rembrandt and
underwrites the technology of Auschwitz. it acquires the meaning from the uses
to which it puts.
"Capital as such is not evil; it is its wrong use that is evil. Capital in some form or in
other will always be needed.
Money has been regarded as bone of contention between friends and relative. It
is said that lend money to a person if you want to spoil him or make foe.
Moneywealth, property or estate have always caused family, feuds or even
murder for it is said that all is fair in love and war. Money is devil's child and
responsible for mischief and evils. Some people think that money can bring
happiness in life but it is not so.
Money is root cause of many evils like corruption, black marketing, smuggling,
drug trafficking, tax evasion and the bucks does not stop here it goes to the
extent of sex tourism and human trafficking(A human selling another
human)people are crazy for money. Majority is here to become rich and money
has become the basic goal and education. The more developed the nation, the
more the standard of living of the people. People want more money to cater to
their needs and at a point of time they don't hesitate to have money from any
source. this is available soft corner were the concept of money laundering enter and
prosper.
EC directive defines the term 'Money laundering' as " the conversion of property
knowing that such property is derived from serious crime, for the purpose of
concealing or disguising the illegal origin of the property or of assisting any
person who is involved in the such an offence or offences to evade the legal
consequences of his action and the concealment or disguise of the true nature,
source, location, disposition, movement right with respect to, or ownership of
the property is derived from serious crime".
Money laundering has a close nexus with organised crime. Money launderers
accumulate enormous profit through drug trafficking, international frauds,
arms dealing etc. Cash transaction are predominately used for money
laundering as they facilitate the concealment of the true ownership & origin of
money. It is well organised that through huge profit the criminals earn from
drugs trafficking and other illegal means, by way of money laundering could
contaminate and corrupt the structure of the state at all the levels, this
definitely leads to corruption. Further, this adds to constant pursuit of profits and
the expansion to the new area of criminal activity.
Through money laundering organised crime diversifies its source of income and
enlarges its sphere of action. The social danger of money laundering consist in
the consolidate of the economic power of criminals organisations, enabling them
to penetrate the legitimate economy. In advanced societies. Crime is
increasingly economic in character. Criminal association now tend to organised
like business enterprise and to follow the same tendencies as legitimate firms;
specialisation growth expansion in market and linkage with other enterprise.
The holders of capital of illegal origin are prepared to bear considerable cost in
order to legalise its use.
Another celebrated mode of doing money laundering was with SWISS bank.
Gangster Meyer Lansky used the number of SWISS bank accounts to hide his
illegal money. He used the "loan-back" concepts, which meant that the illegal
money could now be disguised as 'loans' provided by complaint foreign banks,
which could be declared as their 'revenue' if necessary and a tax-deduction
obtained in the bargain. Money laundering as a crime attracted the interest in the
1980s, essentially within a drug trafficking context. It was from an
increasing awareness of the huge profit generated from the criminal activity and
a concern at the massive drug abuse problem dealers by creating legislation that
deprive them of their illegal gains.
john walker was the first to make a serious attempt at quantifying money
laundering and initial output. His model suggests that US $ 2.85 trillion are
laundered globally. As per an estimate of the international monetary fund, the
aggregate size of money laundering in the world could be somewhere between 2
or 5 % of the world's GDP. Although money laundering is impossible to
measure with precision, it is estimate that US$5000 billon to US$10,000billon in
proceeds from the serious crime is laundered every year. Though data on the
size of money laundering in the scant UK and US officials estimate that the
amount of money laundering in the financial system worldwide was roughly
$500billion gross domestic product.
II.I The process of Money Laundering
money laundering is not a single act but is in fact a process that is accomplished in
three basic steps as enumerated below:
1. Placement:
Placement refer to the physical disposal of bulk cash proceeds derived from
illegal activity. This is the 1st step of money laundering and ultimate aim of the is
to remove the cash from the location of acquisition so as to avoid detection from
system by opening up a bank account in the name of unknown individuals or
organisations and depositing the money in that account.
2. Layering :
3. Integration:
"Integration" refers to the reinjection of the laundered proceeds back into the
economy in such a way that they re-enter the financial system as normal
business funds. The launders normally accomplish this by setting up unknown
institutions in nations where secrecy is guaranteed. New forms of business with
just a webpage and convert his illegal money to legal by showing profits from
the webpage. There are other ways like capital market investments, real estate
acquisition, the catering industry, the gold market and the diamond Market.
Money laundering, at its simplest, is the act of making money that comes from
source A look like it comes from source B.
II.II Some Techniques of Money Laundering:
1. Hawala:-
Also known as smurfing, this method entails breaking up large amounts off money
into smaller, less-suspicious amounts. In the United States, this smaller amount has to
be below $10,000- the dollar amount at which U.S. banks have to report the
transaction to the government. The money is then deposited into one or more bank
accounts either by multiple people (smurfs) or by a single person over an extended
period of the time.
3. Third-party Cheques:-
4. Credit card
clearing credit and credit card balance at the counter is different banks. Such cards
have a number of uses and can be used across international borders. For example, to
purchase assets, for payment of services or goods received a global network of cash
-dispensing machines.
5. Peso broker:-
A drug traffickers turns over dirty U.S dollars to a peso Colombia. the peso then use
those drug to purchase goods in united states for Colombia importers. when the
importer received those goods and sell them for peso in Colombia, they pay back the
peso broker from the proceeds. the broker then gives the drugs trafficker the equivalent
in peso of the original, dirty U.S dollars that began in the process. The list is endless and
quite a lot of techniques are not easily used to one laundering phase alone . With each
reporting of crime, the modus operandi changes keeping in view the earlier detecting.
the money laundering appear to be serious researcher and the officials appear to be mere
readers of research reports.
II.III Some New Areas of Operational of Money Laundering
Both authorities and the money launderers seem to permanently change their
behaviour. when trying to hunt and escape money laundering. One can notice
changed explored new routes of laundering their money. economies with growing and
developing establish financial centres as the latter must have implemented
comprehensive money laundering regimes.
1. Insurance sector
Then insurance sector is a relatively less haunted sector compared to banks and other
avenues of financial and other services, however there has been gradual increase in
laundering activity in insurance sector as well. The laundering in insurances is either
internal or external in nature. the internal channels of laundering money or agent
premium diversion, reinsurance fraud and rented assets scheme etc. phony insurance
companies, staged auto accident, vertical and senior settlement fraud are external
channels of money laundering.
Money launderers have traditionally targeted banks, which accept cash and
facilitate domestic and international funds are transfers. However the securities
markets, which is known for their liquidity, may also be targeted by criminals seeking to
hide and obscure illegal funds. Money launderers can targeted any type of the
businesses that participate in securities industry. Broker-dealer for instance provide a
variety product and services to retail and institutional investor buying and selling
stocks bond and mutual fund and shares. this is more over possible due the instrument
like hedge funds and participatory Notes which have very limited disclosure as to the
source.these funds can effectively used as Laundromat. although the number of
document cases in which broker and dealer or mutual fund accounts have been used to
launder money is limited, law enforcement agenices are concerned that criminals may
increasingly attempt to use the securities industry to launder money. this is new area
which requires a serious thought processing.
3. Cyber crime
Now one has to confront with hybrid crimes, the with many attributes . According to
capt. Raghu Raman "five types of crime are now converging. Cybercrimes such as
identify theft access to e-mail and credit card fraud are coming together with money
laundering and terrorist activities. large amounts of money is now stored in digital
form . Now you can transfer money through electronic and online gateways to
multiple accounts. This convergence leads to a greater problem of tackling of different
issues at onetime.
II. IV Harmful Effects of Money Laundering:
In a detailed study by Unger about money laundering literature they were able to
identify 25 different effects of money laundering. Unger classifies the effect of money
laundering on the basis of its gestation period within which it surfaces, fewer than two
broad heads, i.e. short term effects of money laundering and long term effects of money
laundering.
Terrorism:-
Terrorism is an evil which affects each and everybody. Now and then we can find
terrorist attacks being made by terrorists. These attacks definitely cannot be done
without the help of money. Money laundering serves as an important mode of
terrorism financing. Terrorist organizations rise funding from legitimate sources,
including the abuse of charitable entities or legitimate businesses or self-financing by the
terrorists themselves. Terrorists also derive funding from a variety of criminal
activities ranging in scale and sophistication from low-level crime to organized fraud or
narcotics smuggling or from state sponsors and activities in failed states and other safe
havens. Terrorists use a wide variety of methods to move money within and between
organisations including the financial sector, the physical movement of cash by
couriers, and the movement of goods through the trade system. Charities and
alternative remittance systems have also been used to disguise terrorist movement of
funds.
Threat to banking system:-
Across the world, banks have become a major target of money laundering
operations and financial crime because they provide a variety of services and
instruments that can be used to conceal the source of money, with their
polished.
In contrast to the position with insider dealing a few serious academic argument
have been advanced that money laundering is beneficial or even that it should be
permitted there exists theory of legitimisation suggestion that money laundering
enables to criminals to come in from the shadows and take their place in the
legitimate economy. An of this was the Seychelles proposed economic
development assistance act 1995, which would have provided that, where a person
invested a person invested at least US$10 million in the country they would be
immune from criminal prosecution by any party the only exception bring by
Seychelles authorities and then only in the context of the drug investigation,
Further the funds themselves would clean and not liable to the confiscation.
Professor Barry Rider and the other have also pointed out that it may often be
beneficial to the state as well as to the individual not only to keep the origin of
certain funds secret but actually to disguise their provenance. however this
argument is not sustainable because money laundering is essentially concerned
with the enabling of criminals and on occasions their associate to retain or to
recover the proceeds of their offences. moreover the financial confidentiality and
money are to distinct things. Dr. Kris Hinterseer has gone to the context of telling
that actual money laundering is on occasion in a country's interest.
Though academically it could be discussed that money laundering may prove useful in
certain context in light of harmful effects of money laundering posed above no one
would argue against the anti-money laundering laws. there are various motivation to
have an AML mechanism in place to began with at most basic, the rationale is to
support the adage that crimes don't play. Firstly there is the moral dimension; crime
should not pay. it is simply not acceptable to society that a person who does wrong
should benefit as aresult.
This provides a ration able for having an anti money laundering law which act
like a slow poison though to some it may seem as a power vitamin.
PART-III
III.I. Regulation of Money laundering international perspective:-
Today there are an increasing number of states that are passing laws and regulations
but UNDCP estimates that about 70% of the government do not yet have effect
legislation in place. Action at the international level to combat money laundering
began in1998 with 2 important initiatives. The Basel committee on the banking
regulation and supervisory practices and the united nations convention against illegal
traffic in narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances.
This UN Convention was one of the historic conventions in as much as the parties to the
convention recognised the links between illegal drugs traffic and other related
organised criminal activities which undermine the legitimate economics and
threaten the stability security and sovereignty of states and illegal drug
trafficking is an international criminal activity that generates large profits and
wealth enabling transnational criminal organisation to penetrate contaminate and
the concept the structures of the government legitimate commercial and
financial business and society at all levels. The treaty required the signatories to
criminalise the laundering of drug money and to confiscate it where found. All
countries ratifying agree to introduce measures to identify trace and freeze or
seize the proceeds of drugs trafficking. council of Europe Convention on
laundering is motivated by this convention as well as this convention gave a
frame work for FATF to work.
III.IV. GPML
The global programme against money laundering was established in year 1997
in response to the mandate given to UNODC by 1998 UN convention against
illegal traffic in narcotic drugs and psychotropic substance. GPML mandate was
strengthened in 1998 by the united nations General Assembly Special Session
(UNGASS) political declaration and Action plan against money laundering which
broadened its remit beyond drug offences to all serious crime.
FATF regularly reviews its member to check their compliance with these forty
recommendation and to suggest areas for improvement. It does this through
annual selfassessment of and periodic mutual evaluation of its members. The
FATF also identifies emerging trend in method used to launder money and
suggest measures to combat them in addition to the existing 40 recommendation
FATF has come up with 9special recommendation on terrorist financing. As per
the recommendation of the task force all countries have to ensure that offences
such as financing of terrorism, terrorist act and
terrorist organization are designated as " Money laundering predicate offence "
This gives eleven principal as an important step in the fight against money
laundering, corruption and other related crimes. Transparency International(TI), a
Berlin based NGO in collaboration with 11 International Private Banks under the
expert participation of Stanley Morris and Prof. Mark Pieth came out with these
principles as important global guidance for sound business conducting international
private banking. The importance of these principles is due to the fact that it comes
from initiative by private sector.
Normally, most initiatives to date have been public sector led by governments and
their regulatory and law enforcement agencies, or by government representatives
acting through international form such as the Financial Action Task Force(FATF) and
the Basel Committee of Bank Supervisors. The Wolfsberg Principles are a non-
binding set of best practice guidelines governing the establishment and maintenance of
relationships between private and bankers and clients.
III.VII.C Egmont Groups of Financial Intelligence Units:
The Egmont Group is the coordinating body for the international group of
Financial Intelligence Units (FIUs) formed in 1995 to promote and enhance
international co-operation in anti-money laundering and counter-terrorist
financing. The Egmont Group consist of 108 Financial intelligence units are
responsible for following the money trail, to counter money laundering and
terrorism financing. FIUs are an essential component of the international fight
against laundering, the financing of terrorism and related crime.
Their ability to transform data into financial intelligence is a key element in the
fight against money laundering and the financing of terrorism. The FIUs
participating in the Egmont Group affirm their commitment to encourage the
development of FIUs and cooperation among and between them in the interest of
combating Money Laundering and in assisting with the global fight against
terrorism financing.
III.VII.D. Asia-Pacific Group on Money Laundering(APG):
All APG members commit to effectively implement the FATF's international standards
for anti-money laundering and combating financing of terrorism referred to as
the 40+9 Recommendations. Part of this commitment includes implementing
measures against terrorist listed by the United Nations in the "1267 consolidated
List". The key functions of APG is to access APG members compliance with
the global AML/CFT standards through mutual evaluations; coordinate
technical assistance and training with donor agencies and APG jurisdiction to
improve compliance with the AML/CFT standards; co-operate with the
international AML/CFT network. Conduct research into Money Laundering and
terrorist financing methods, trends , risks, and vulnerabilities;
contribute to the global AML/CFT policy development by Associate Membership of
FATF.
1
9
7
4
of Smuggling Activities Act.
T
h
e
C
o
n
s
e
r
v
a
t
i
o
n
o
f
F
o
r
e
i
g
n
E
x
c
h
a
n
g
e
a
n
d
P
r
e
v
e
n
t
i
o
n
The Income Tax Act, 1961.
The Benami transaction (prohibition) act, 1988.
The Indian Penal Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
The Narcotics Drugs and Psychotropic substance Act, 1985.
The Prevention of Illegal Traffic in Narcotics Drugs and Psychotropic
Substance Act, 1988.
However, this was not sufficient with the growth of varied areas of
generating illegal money by selling antiques, rare animal flesh and skin, human organ
and many such varied new areas of generating money which was illegal.
MoneyLaundering was an effective way to launder the black money (wash is to make it
clean) so as to make it white.
However the implementation of the same did not see the light of the day
until 2005 when it was enforced. The time when the Act of 2002 came to be enforced it
was too old to cater to the current needs of the anti-money laundering law. To bring the
necessary changes in light of the liberalization of economy and securities market in
India, there was a need to have more comprehensive anti money-laundering law and
that is how the Preventions of money laundering Act 2008 came into existance, the
salient feature of which will be discussed later.
IV.II. Salient features of prevention of Money Laundering Act 2002:-
8. In case of cross border money laundering the present bill enables the central
government to return the confiscated property to the requesting country in order to
implement the provision of the UN convention and corruption.
9. Expanded the reach of the act by adding many more crimes under various
legislation in part A and part B in the schedule of the Act.
PART A
1956
Act 1999
2002
Paragraph 21 The protection of plant varieties and framer's right Act 2001
1974 Paragraph 24 The air (prevention and control pollution Act) 1981
PART C
From the aforesaid amendment it is evident than the legislature is vigilant towards
the illegal proceeds from various fields like illegal killing of animals, violation of
environmental laws violation of intellectual property laws, proceeds from selling of the
antiques and treasure against the law violation of customer Act, proceeds from internet
related crime cyber crime, proceeds from bonded labour and child labour, illegal
organ transplantation, proceeds from the illegalities in the securities market like insider
trading, violation of laws relating to dealing of explosive substances and many more.
The new skills provides few definition and amends a few for further clarity
and broadening of theAct.
Authorised Person:-
Means carrying on activity for playing games of chance for cash or kind, and
includes such activities associated with casino or such other activities as the central
Government may by notification, so designated from time to time.
The bill introduces a new category that has cross-border implication for
fighting terrorism. This particular provision gives the Indian anti-money laundering
legislation an extraterritorial exposure. Now under this provision a person who is
presently outside India under one of the parts referred to above and transfer the
proceeds or part thereof outside India commits an offence of cross-border Implication.
Thus now cross-border illegal proceeds can be put under the scanner of anti-money
laundering legislation in India.
Payment gateways such as visa master card, money changers, money transfer,
service provider and casinos will soon come under the ambit of India's money laundering
law and face mandatory reporting obligations.
As noted earlier the draft legislation also empowered the Enforcement Directorate to
search immediately after the offence is committed. The investigation agency can attach
any property and search a person after completing the probe. It can enhance the period of
provisional attachment of property from 90 days to150 days.
Enhanced Reporting requirement:-
During 2011 the Finance minister of India Mr. Pranab Mukherji presented the
Prevention of Money Laundering (Amendment) Bill in Lok Sabha. This Bill seeks
to amend the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002.
This law provides the provision to link the Indian law to the laws of the foreign
countries. It also adds the concept of ‘reporting entity’ which would include a
banking company, financial institution, intermediary or a person carrying on a
designated business or profession.
The Bill expands the definition of offence under money laundering to include
activities like concealment, acquisition, possession and use of proceeds of crime.
This law can allow to levy a fine of upto Rs. 5 lakh but upper limit needs to be
reconsidered.
This bill gives the authority to confiscate
the property of any person for a period
not exceeding tha180 days. This
power may be exercised by the
authority if it has reason to believe that
the offence of money laundering has
taken place. Image Credit: PRS Legislative Research
The Bill seeks to make the reporting entity, its designated directors on the Board and
employees responsible for omissions or commissions in relation to the reporting
obligations.
The Bill states that in the proceedings relating to money laundering, the funds shall be presumed to
be involved in the offence, unless proven otherwise.
The Bill proposes to provide for appeal against the orders of the Appellate
Tribunal directly to the Supreme Court within 60 days from the communication of
the decision or order of the Appellate Tribunal.
The Bill seeks to provide for the process of transfer of cases of the Scheduled
offences pending in a court (which had taken cognizance of the offence) to the
Special Court for trial. In addition, on receiving such cases, the Special Court
shall proceed to deal with it from the stage at which it was committed.
Part B of the Schedule in the existing Act includes only those crimes that are above Rs 30
lakh or more whereas Part A did not specify any monetary limit of the offence.
The Bill proposes to bring all the offences under Part A of the Schedule to ensure
that the monetary thresholds do not apply to the offence of money laundering.
IV. Financial Intelligence Unit-India (FIU-IND):-
A. All the cash transaction of the value of more than rupees ten Lakhs is
equivalent in foreign currency.
Recently, the RBI has issued a series of the bank, about the precaution to
be exercised in handling their customer's transaction. Important amongst these is a
guidance note issued about treatment of customer and key to knowing the
customer. The identity, background and standing of the customer should be
verified not only at the time of commencement of relationship, but also be
updated from time to time, to reflect the changes of circumstances and the
nature of operation of the account. RBI plays a significant role AML activities.
RBI, recently block the application of SWISS bank UBS for a banking license
in india on the ground that it was involved in $8 billion money laundering racket.
RBI said it put the UBS application on hold because the bank failed to cooperate in
a money laundering case in which controversial Bombay based business man
Hasan Ali Khan was involved. Khan is charged with large scale breaching of
Indian's currency controls. RBI investigators found a link between UBS and
Khan as a businessman had deposited $8 billion at a zurich branch of UBS.
They cited it a direct evidence for blocking the license of the bank.
SEBI has almost taken a full circle on the issue of participatory Notes.
SEBI has taken certain important measures in favour of the Foreign Institutional
Investor (FII) as well as the unregistered foreign investors who intend to invest in
the Indian Securities market. Looking at the lacklustre performance of the
capital markets and in a order to encourage inflow of foreign capital in india
.SEBI has decided to remove the restriction on issuance offshore derivative
instrument (ODI) commonly known as participatory notes(PN), which had been
imposed on FIIs. This is an evidence of market forces compelling the regulator
to change its tough stance of regulation.
India started its anti-money laundering exercise in the year 1998, a well
start but not properly tackled and saw the day of enforcement only in 2005
seven years along time for enforcement. When AML 02 with amendment 2005
came in force, It was inherent with many lacunas as there were several
development in those years which the Act failed to address. Then, as obvious a
need was felt to have a further amendments.PML bill 2008 is laid before the
parliament.
Growth of Technology:-
Not only the growth of technology has helped the common man its
proved also a boon for these money-laundering and India is not exception to
this. Cyber finance is the growing concept in this developing economy. The
speed at which the technology is growing is not matched up with the
enforcement agencies, specifically highlighted by the lame situation of
cybercrimes.
Now india has a KYC norms in place in both money market and capital
market. However, these KYC norm don't desist the Hawala transaction as RBI
cannot regulate them further , KYC norms become a mockery because of in
difference shown by the implementing authorities.KYC norms are followed in
letters but the requirement is to follow it in spirit. Increased competition in the
market requires and gives the motivation to the bank to lower their guards.
specifically the franchises banks that are authorised to open accounts.
India has illegal black market channels for selling the goods. Smuggled
goods such as food items, computer parts, cellular phones, gold and a wide
range of imported consumer goods are routinely sold through the black market.
By dealing in cash transaction and avoiding customs duties and taxes, black
market merchants offer better prices than those offered by the regulated
merchants. This is the problem though lessened due to liberalisation policy of
the government.
Tax law:-
justice learned hand in commissioner. Newmen stated the " over and
over again court have said that there is nothing sinister in so arranging one's
affairs to keep taxes as low as possible, everybody does so rich, or poor, and all do
right, for nobody owes any public duty than the law demands. Taxes are
enforced exactions, not voluntary contributions. To demand more in the name of
morals is mere cant. closer Bach home in India, the supreme court of India in
Azadi Bachao Andolan & Anr cited Lord Tomlin in IRC vs Duke of west
minister while uploading the validity of treaty shopping. there is need to make a
distinction between the tax avoidance and tax evasion. There are
comprehensions that double taxation treaties may lead to the money laundering
channel.
Threshold limit under PMLA02:-
As seen earlier money laundering has become hybrid and has not only
related to NDPS cases but many areas of operation. separate wings of the law
enforcement agencies are dealing with the digital crimes. Money laundering,
economic offences and terrorist crimes. The agencies do not have the
convergence among themselves but the criminals have. criminals are working in
a borderless world but the policies in one state is still grappling with the
procedures on how to arrest a person in another state.
Apart from the above problem areas costs involved in having a anti- moneylaundering
regime is also relevant.
V. Steps Banks should follow to ensure a robust anti-money laundering
process
COBRAPOST an online magazine carried out a sting operation in March 2013 against
three private sector banks which had violated the money laundering rules and
guidelines set by the regulatory authorities. These violations are as follows.
2. Opening of account to route the cash to the Bank's menu of Insurance products.
Subsequently COBRAPOST alleged that many Public Sector Bank Units are
also involved in such scenarios and facilitate money laundering. The number of
institutions under the scanner is more than thirty now.
All the banks had immediately issued statements about the robustness of their
systems and about the actions they intended to take to get to the depth of the issue. The
banks appointed external auditors and / or set up high level expert committees to
examine these allegations and the underlying issues, if any. The banks also took actions
such as suspending the personnel concerned or asking them to go on leave till the
completion of investigations.
Subsequently, some of the banks made public statements that there were no
incidents of money laundering found in their processes as alleged by COBRAPOST.
Reserve Bank of India (RBI) had also initiated its investigation based on the sting
operation allegations. RBI investigation had observed various concerns such as not
collecting mandatory PAN details, allowing submission of dummy PAN details,
multiple cash transactions below Rs. 10 lakh to avoid being reported and splitting of
deposits into smaller amounts to avoid providing PAN. The articles also reported that
the banks had been found suppressing the alerts generated through their AML solutions
and non-reporting the integrally connected transactions. Perverse insurance selling
incentive structure had also been cited as a driver of these transactions without due
verifications.
In India, most of the banks have AML solutions / software that trigger alerts in case
any violation of the above-mentioned scenarios happens. These solutions are, in
general, compliant with the RBI mandated guidelines. However, in light of the
COBRAPOST sting operation and the subsequent initiatives taken by banks and the
RBI, there is a need for the entities to take certain additional steps and make the
whole monitoring / anti-money laundering exercise more robust and meaningful.
Here’s a ten point program banks should follow:
Any untoward incident of this magnitude that can seriously dent the reputation or
confidence of an institution tends to consume large amounts of executive bandwidth. In
the aftermath of COBRAPOST sting, several senior executives were working with their
teams to get a detailed assessment of the issues at hand, and methods and means to fix
these issues. A good crisis management team should be able to investigate an issue,
conduct a root cause analysis and present the recommendations to an executiveteam.
India as a country is known for different types of identity proof documents and the same
comes with an issue. There is no guarantee that the name will be spelt uniformly in all
the documents. For instance, PAN may be in the name of Akshay Kumar Gupta and
the driving license would be in the name of Akshay K Gupta or even spelt as Kumar
Akshay. It also means that same person can open accounts in different names. With
inter- and intra-city mobility being a common phenomenon, the customer addresses can
never be fully relied upon. The date of birth is a potential ‘unchangeable’ parameter,
even though it is not a full proof solution. Augmenting it with multiple addresses
captured by bureaus like CIBIL to create a robust customer deduplication process and
verification is of paramount importance. In the absence of above scenario, KYC
compliance for each account would have no meaning.
Banks should work towards rationalizing the alert scenarios built in the bank’s AML
solution, suiting its requirements taking into account parameters such as bank profile,
customer profile, past alert history, past reporting history etc. Such processes would
gradually reduce the number of alerts getting generated, thereby improving the efficiency
in alert management. Even a conservative 20 percent reduction can have a huge impact
on the way alerts are scrutinized. Further, the bank should carry out such
rationalization process periodically, preferably once in a quarter. Banks should explore
working with the AML solution providers and augmenting current framework through
external consultants for false positive management / reduction.
Despite all the advancements in core banking solutions, database technologies and
platforms, and data enrichment solutions, most organizations struggle to arrive at a single
version of truth in times of crisis. Often, disconnect between various enterprise
systems seems magnified due to inconsistent data. A sub-segment within the analytics/
business intelligence function should be dedicated for resolving inter- system
inconsistencies and ensuring customer data integrity.
Further, most software and solutions are good at capturing violates and creating alerts
and triggers. However, banks need to enable closed loop systems and thinking, whereby
the action and the resolution against a trigger is captured
as structured data, and is used for further profiling triggers, monitoring action windows,
measuring TATs, and evaluating risk to the business. Over a period of time, this analysis
should aspire to build custom risk assessment models for various triggers, thereby
helping prioritize action and managerial bandwidth.
Howsoever intelligent the system, the one’s looking to find a loophole, often manage to
find one. Banks should have an internal Forensic Analytics Units, something that is
already being done in many developed markets. FAU’s core job is to review the triggers
that come in, and find patterns and problems that are not part of the standard rule
based systems that exist today. It takes away the need to conduct these forensic
exercise on a reactive basis, because this team can act as the response team as well as
the proactive deterrent team. These teams can be set up as part of the central
compliance and audit function, or a special unit within the business intelligence unit.
The need for definitive policy is obvious. UN data that terror group financing
accounts for just 0.5% of the total $856 billon money laundering worldwide.
While this amount to just $4.16billon money laundering the potency to cause
for the global economy.
Suggestion:-
BIBLOGRAPGHY:-
WWW.bis.or
g.com
WWW.fatf.co
WWW.un.co
WWW.money laundering.com
AGANIST MONEY
LAUNDERING.