Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Tabi et al.
Original Article
TABI M.M., POWELL M. & HODNICKI D. (2006) Use of traditional healers and modern medicine in Ghana.
International Nursing Review 53, 52–58
Purpose: To gain understanding of the use of traditional and modern medicine among the people in Ghana, West
Africa.
Methods: Data were collected from nine participants using a semi-structured questionnaire developed by the
researchers based on review of the literature.
Findings: Data analysis was performed manually using reduction methodology to develop broad themes.
Findings indicated that choices in healthcare modalities by literate Ghanaians included either traditional or
modern medicine, or blending of both. Strong influences on these choices were the level of education and related
themes, influence of family and friends, and spiritual/religious beliefs.
Implications: Findings indicate that traditional and modern medicines will always be part of Ghanaian healthcare
delivery and efforts should be made to integrate traditional practitioners into the national healthcare delivery
system.
The study and significance medicines and spiritual therapies, either used singularly or in
The objective of this study was to conduct qualitative interviews combination to treat, diagnose and prevent illness to maintain
with a small number of Ghanaians to determine personal per- well-being (Craffert 1997; Du Toit 1998; WHO 2004). Approxi-
spective when choosing healers, particularly, Western or tradi- mately, 80% of the population in Africa uses traditional medicine
tional medicine, or blending of both, for health care. The cultural, for health care (Patterson 2001; WHO 2004).
family, educational and religious influences on these choices were Traditional medicine has been part of the Ghanaian culture.
of particular interest. The traditional medicine system includes not only herbal reme-
Research questions: dies for specific diseases, but also folk knowledge, traditions and
1 What factors influence Ghanaian’s choice of healing for tradi- values, health behaviour rules and patterns, and identified per-
tional, Western, or blending of both modalities? sonnel and structures for delivery and restorative therapy (Hevi
2 What criteria do Ghanaians use to determine the effectiveness 1989). There are many types of practitioners available in Ghana,
of a specific modality? each with a distinctive approach to diagnosis and therapy. There
3 What are the social, educational, cultural and spiritual factors are secular healers often referred to as ‘traditional pharmacists’
that affect these choices? who use herbal medicine prepared from selected leaves, roots or
The study is significant due to a dearth in qualitative documenta- other parts of plants and animals. There are also plant drug ped-
tion of personal preference and rationale for healthcare choices in dlers who travel to towns and villages, as well as sell herbal medi-
countries with viable traditional and modern medical systems. cines at workplaces, bus stops and in the streets.
The results are important when considering the emphasis on The most common type of healer in the traditional medical sys-
Western medicine for solutions to health problems in developing tem is the priest and priestess of deities and gods who use tech-
countries. niques such as divination and rituals in healing practices (Hevi
1989). They cure organic and spiritually based diseases. Others
Review of literature such as sacred healers are faith healers who usually use prayers,
fasting, incantations, herbal medicines, as well as occultism.
Healthcare delivery systems in Ghana Among these different types of healers are differences in special-
Healthcare delivery in Ghana is pluralistic consisting of tradi- ization. Some healers focus on one or a few illnesses, while others
tional and modern medicine (Anyinam 1989; Hevi 1989). The are generalists. Among the specializations are bone setting, child-
individual’s interaction with other sectors of health care depends care delivery and psychotherapy. Some healers are full-time prac-
on how the health problem is perceived or sanctioned by the sick titioners, and others practise traditional medicine as a secondary
person, and most importantly, by relatives and close friends (Hevi occupation (Patterson 2001).
1989). Depending on prevalent symptoms of illness, a person may
choose to disregard an illness or health problem, use treatment The modern medical system
modalities known to the individual, friends or family, or make a The modern medical system includes government-operated/
decision to use services of a traditional healer or modern medical financed delivery systems with medical care provided at hospitals,
practitioner. health centres, clinics, health posts and maternity homes. Some
Ghana is administratively divided into 10 regions, each with a quasi-government-operated health services include those pro-
regional hospital. Accessibility to health care is defined as living vided by the army, the police, and some large firms and corpora-
within 3–5 miles of a health service (Tabi 1994). Approximately tions for their employees. In addition, there are private healthcare
70% of the population lives in a rural area where accessibility to services provided by religious missions such as the Catholic Mis-
health service is a problem. In Ghana, the ratio of medical doctors sion, the Presbyterian Church and Seventh Day Adventist Church.
to population is 1 : 20 000 and the ratio of traditional healers to The government also supports these mission health services. The
population is 1 : 200 (Patterson 2001; Tabi & Frimpong 2003). modern medical system is officially managed by the Ministry of
Often, for the rural and urban poor, traditional healers provide Health, which provides medical care, maternal and child health
the only affordable and accessible form of health care (Cocks & services, health laboratory services, mental health, dental health,
Moller 2002; Sodi 1996; Tabi 1994). The majority of the time, they nutritional health, environmental health and health education
are the first line of contact in the healthcare system in rural areas. (Tabi 1994).
1. Tell me about a time when you were sick and you needed modern medical treatment.
2. How well do you think this therapy worked for you?
3. What else do you think they could have done to help you get better?
4. Tell me about a time when you used a traditional healing practice(s) to treat an illness.
5. Do you prefer one method of treatment to another? Please tell me why.
6. Are there any types of problems that you would use only a traditional healing therapy and not a modern medical therapy? Give an example.
7. Are there any types of problems that you would use only a modern medical therapy and not a traditional healing therapy? Give an example.
8. Do you believe one method is better than the other? Please explain why you feel that way.
9. Do you feel one method is better accepted in Ghana than the other? Please explain why you think one method is preferred over the other.
10. What type of barrier is present to the other method that is less accepted?
11. Do you have any other examples that you can share with me to understand how modern medicine and traditional healing practices are used in Ghana to treat
illness?
12. Is there anything else that you would like to share with me to help me to understand the culture of Ghana?
aspects were influential, citing pressure from families and friends Accessibility and affordability of health care
to use traditional medicine. Locality and high cost of medicine seem to be intertwined con-
cepts in choice of healthcare modalities. Familiarity with the local
provider is identified as another factor associated with physical
Choice of healing modalities
circumstances. One participant pointed to poverty in rural areas
Several participants believed in the use of modern medicine as
as a deterrent to the use of modern medicine in Ghana.
preferred choice of healing modality and described the impor-
tance of laboratory and radiology results to identify the cause of You see I feel that they [Ghanaians] use more of herbal medi-
illness. One man mentioned the necessity of tangible parameters cine because many of them particularly in rural areas are poor,
‘because we are living in a scientific age’. He went on to state, ‘If the so they cannot go to or come visit the hospitals. Poverty pre-
doctor is unable to cure your sickness, then I will tell you to see an vents treatment in hospitals because drugs are very expensive
herbalist’. This participant explained how he had treated a previ- and hospitals are not easily accessible without adequate trans-
ous personal illness of ‘swelling in the neck and not feeling well’. portation. Sometimes you have to give money to the nurses and
He stated that findings from hospital laboratory indicated, ‘There the doctor himself to receive treatment, and the medicine is
was nothing to show that I was sick’. He then sought a traditional very expensive, also. There are many people who cannot pay
healer who told him he had a spiritual illness brought about by and so they rely on traditional medicine, herbs. Even for chil-
jealousy of other family members toward him. He was given a dren, they use herbs.
‘potion to drink’, and told by the traditional healer ‘the spirits have
been removed’. The subject verified that he was not bothered by
Internal contextual influence
the problem again.
Internal contextual influences encompassed the concept of illness
Another participant also identified hygiene as a stumbling
of spiritual or non-spiritual sources. The belief was that spiritual
block in the use of traditional medicine, ‘Because the herbalists
illness could only be cured with traditional medicine. Those expe-
often do not use hygiene in preparing their medicines, people
riencing non-spiritual illness might choose either traditional or
think they are not good. But we make it locally which we just don’t
modern medicine; frequently the choice was made according to
test it like and measure and say if one teaspoon or a tablespoonful
faith related to successful past experience with a specific modality.
is needed, we just drink it like that [the way it is given to us]’. He
The perception of personal power vested within a healer, espe-
identified modern concepts of hygiene and the importance of
cially in traditional medicine, played a significant part in deter-
accurate dosage measurement as influential when choosing
mining choice. Some felt this personal power was essential to the
between modalities.
healing process; others feared the source of the personal power
was demonic and synonymous with evil.
Situational factors
Another determinant when choosing traditional or modern med-
Spiritual illness
ical healers is the influence of others, such as relatives, friends and
Some participants perceived spiritual illness as a reason to seek
employers. One participant stated public servants in government
traditional care. One participant spoke of a cousin who was cured
institutions often are required to seek treatment in a hospital. She
of epilepsy by a herbalist. Her personal family experience led her
stated ‘The problem is if you work in a government institution,
to believe that there were diseases that required a spiritualist.
you have to go to the doctor first to do some tests and later to the
According to the participant, ‘Somebody may want to destroy
herbalist. The herbalist cannot give you security’. One participant
your life and a spiritualist may help to protect you. Most of these
remembered her father’s concern with her first pregnancy. There
people have powers’.
was a family history of death in childbirth. He urged her to seek
Another female participant stated she would ‘seek all other
protection from a fetish priest. She stated, ‘In fact it was not my
results with modern medicine, and then seek the herbalist. When
intention to use a traditional healer, I usually go to the hospital’.
there is no way out you definitely have to use the herbalist’. When
She combined the traditional healing with modern medicine and
asked for more descriptive information she stated,
sought prenatal treatment with a medical officer. Her rationale for
seeking modern medicine was: ‘I know the doctor, and I wanted to Sometimes there is the belief that some of the illnesses are
make sure in case there is an operation needed (caesarian- caused by spirits, or spiritual illness. If taken to the modern
section), the doctor can do the operation than [not] the fetish medicine healer, they will treat you based on the physical signs,
priest. I did go to the laboratory for tests, because the fetish priest like if you’re having pain. But the herbalist, I know they read
cannot do any tests’. and they are revealed certain things to do.