Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Bankruptcy
for
Small Business
Owners How to File for
Chapter 7
• Find out if Chapter 7 bankruptcy
is the best solution for you
Emma Cofod
Dear friends,
Ralph Warner
Nolo co-founder
Products & Services
Books & Software
Get in-depth information. Nolo publishes hundreds of great books and
software programs for consumers and business owners. They’re all available
in print or as downloads at Nolo.com.
Legal Encyclopedia
Free at Nolo.com. Here are more than 1,400 free articles and answers to
common questions about everyday legal issues including wills, bankruptcy,
small business formation, divorce, patents, employment and much more.
Lawyer Directory
Find an attorney at Nolo.com. Nolo’s unique lawyer directory provides
in-depth profiles of lawyers all over America. From fees and experience
to legal philosophy, education and special expertise, you’ll find all the
information you need to pick a lawyer who’s a good fit.
Bankruptcy
for Small Business
Owners:
How to File for
Chapter 7
Elias, Stephen.
Bankruptcy for small business owners : how to file for chapter 7 / by attorney Stephen
R. Elias and Bethany K. Laurence, J.D. -- 1st ed.
p. cm.
ISBN-13: 978-1-4133-1080-1 (pbk.)
ISBN-10: 1-4133-1080-X (pbk.)
1. Small business--United States. 2. Bankruptcy--United States--Popular works. I.
Laurence, Bethany K., 1968- II. Title.
HD2346.U6E45 2010
346.7307'8--dc22
2009041933
Please note
We believe accurate, plain-English legal information should help you solve many of
your own legal problems. But this text is not a substitute for personalized advice from a
knowledgeable lawyer. If you want the help of a trained professional—and we’ll always
point out situations in which we think that’s a good idea—consult an attorney licensed
to practice in your state.
Acknowledgments
The authors gratefully acknowledge Lisa Guerin’s superb editorial assistance and
Jake Warner’s helpful tips. And much thanks to Terri Hearsh and the great staff in
Nolo’s production department for getting out the book.
CHAPTER
Table of Contents
Appendixes
C Tear-Out Forms
Form 1—Voluntary Petition
. ....................................................................................................................................387
Index...................................................................................................................................................................565
Your Small Business Chapter 7
Personal Bankruptcy Companion
If you’re considering filing for bankruptcy because won’t be the answer for every small business owner,
your small business is drowning in debt, you’re for two reasons:
not alone. The economic downturn that began in • Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy covers only
2008 took many small business owners (not to debts for which you are personally liable. If
mention politicians, bankers, and economists) by your business is a sole proprietorship or
surprise. For a variety of reasons—from reduced general partnership, you are personally liable
consumer spending to cutthroat competition, for all of your business’s debts, and you can
cutbacks by business customers, and shrinking get them wiped out in Chapter 7 personal
(or disappearing) lines of credit—the number of bankruptcy. If your business is a separate
bankruptcies filed by small business owners has legal entity—for example, a corporation or
skyrocketed. limited liability company (LLC)—you are
You might be considering bankruptcy because: personally liable for its business debts only if
• Your business debts have grown so large that you personally signed for them or guaranteed
you’ll never be able to pay them back. them, as explained in Ch. 1. Otherwise,
• You want to get out of an expensive commer the corporation or LLC is responsible for
cial lease, sales contract, or vehicle or its own debts and must file its own business
equipment lease that’s preventing you from bankruptcy case to discharge them. This
operating profitably. book doesn’t cover the special process that
• You want creditors and bill collectors to stop corporations and LLCs must follow for
harassing you and your employees. Chapter 7 business bankruptcy (which
• Your business lost a lawsuit and was ordered requires an attorney).
to pay a judgment that’s well beyond your • You may have to close your business if you
means. file for Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy. If
• You racked up a lot of business debt and you’ve already decided that you want out of
need to lighten the load so you can pay your your business, this won’t be an important
mortgage, car loan, or current accounts consideration. Some business owners—
payable. especially those who own service businesses
• You want to stop (at least temporarily) a with few assets—may be able to stay open
vehicle repossession, a garnishment on your during Chapter 7. And, plenty of business
spouse’s wages, or a foreclosure. owners have closed down, used Chapter 7
• You want to remove a lien from your home to get out from under their debts, and then
or get out of your mortgage without owing a started a similar business later. However, if
deficiency. you want to continue operating your business,
This book explains how to file for Chapter 7 and particularly if you have any valuable
personal bankruptcy, which could be the right business assets (which you are likely to lose in
solution to many of these problems. However, it a Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy), Chapter
2 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter
7 bankruptcy may not be the best option. fill out all the necessary paperwork, and handle
Instead, you may want to reorganize your routine issues that may come up as your case
business in Chapter 13 bankruptcy, negotiate progresses.
a workout with your creditors, or consider If your small business finances have reached the
other options (as explained in Ch. 3). point where bankruptcy is a serious consideration,
Part I of this book will help you decide whether you may feel anxious, isolated, or even like a
Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy is the best option failure. But you’re not alone: The current recession
for handling your small business debt. First, we is taking down thousands of businesses, large and
explain how to determine whether you or your small, including many that were well-established
spouse are personally liable for your business debt. stalwarts of our economy. Our bankruptcy system
Second, we describe what effect filing for Chapter recognizes that financial missteps, overextension,
7 personal bankruptcy will have on your debts, and simple bad luck happen—and it provides relief
your creditors, your property (both business and to those who are willing to let the court help them
personal), and your business. We also cover the get out from under.
other options available to those who want to close Filing for bankruptcy can even be an important
their business down, as well as to those who want step toward future business success. Chapter 7
to stay in business, and explain how those options personal bankruptcy gives small business debtors
compare to Chapter 7 bankruptcy. the opportunity to wipe out some or all of their
If you decide that it makes sense to file for debt while protecting their personal assets to the
Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy, Part II of this book extent possible. In fact, many bankruptcy filers go
provides step-by-step instructions and detailed on to start another business and become successful
information that will help you figure out what the second or third time around. So if you’re ready
property you’ll get to keep (and what property you for a fresh financial start, let this book help you
may lose), decide how to handle your various debts, navigate the bankruptcy process and get back on
your feet.
l
Part 1:
Making the Decision—Is Chapter 7
Personal Bankruptcy Right for You?
1
C H A P T E R
put you on the hook, such as signing a lease your personal assets to pay all of the business’s
or contract in your personal name rather than debts, not just your pro rata share. But fortunately,
your capacity as a corporate officer, or pledging filing a personal bankruptcy will get rid of all of
personal property as collateral for a business debt. your liability for the partnership’s debts, as well as
any money you owe to your partners.
CAUTION
Whether your business is organized as a Corporation or LLC
corporation, LLC, partnership, or sole proprietorship,
If your business is organized as a corporation
you are legally responsible to pay taxes your business
or LLC, you and your business are separate
withheld from employee paychecks. The IRS isn’t
legal entities. You have limited liability for the
interested in any of the details: If you withheld those
business’s debts. In theory at least, this means
taxes, you are personally liable if you don’t pay that
you aren’t personally liable for the debts of your
money to the government.
business, so creditors can’t take your house or
other personal assets to pay business debts, even
if your business can’t pay them.
Sole Proprietorships
and Partnerships Example: Cook’s Nook, Inc., orders kitchen
supplies from 20 wholesalers before the busi-
If you are the sole owner of your business, and ness tanks. Unable to pay its expenses, the
you haven’t filed paperwork with your state corporation closes its doors. Talia, the cor-
to incorporate or form an LLC, you are a sole poration’s sole owner, auctions off the store’s
proprietor. The same is true for some businesses inventory and uses the proceeds to pay
owned by a husband and a wife: If you live in a Cook’s Nook’s creditors, who receive a few
community property state (discussed below), you cents on the dollar. She then dissolves the
and your spouse can run the business and still corporation by filing dissolution papers with
call it a sole proprietorship. the state. Because the business is a corpora-
Legally, a sole proprietorship is inseparable tion, Talia is not personally responsible for
from its owner; the business isn’t a separate entity paying any of Cook’s Nook Inc.’s remaining
that can take on its own debt. You are personally debt. Its creditors are simply out of luck.
liable for every penny that your business can’t
pay. If your business doesn’t have enough cash Unfortunately for small business owners,
or assets to pay its debts, creditors can, and often legal theory is not necessarily legal reality. There
will, go after your personal assets. are many ways corporate shareholders or LLC
If you are a sole proprietor considering bank members can make themselves personally liable
ruptcy to get rid of your business debts, you for business debts. In fact, most owners of small
need to file a personal bankruptcy, not a business corporations and LLCs voluntarily take on
bankruptcy. A personal bankruptcy will help personal liability for at least some business debts.
you wipe out most types of debts, whether or not Below are some common ways an owner of a
they are related to your business. corporation or an LLC might become personally
The same is true of general partnerships. In liable for the business’s debts. If you are personally
a general partnership, each partner is personally liable for some or all of your business debts, you
liable for 100% of the partnership’s debts. If there will have to file a personal bankruptcy, rather
aren’t enough business assets to pay those debts, than a business bankruptcy, to rid yourself of
and your partners are broke, creditors can take these debts.
8 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
realize that their original sales forecast was affairs, creditors could try to hold you personally
too optimistic by half. Five months later, still responsible for the business’s debts under a theory
operating in the red, they decide to close down. known as “piercing the corporate veil.” This
They are personally liable for their $35,000 happens when a court finds that your corporation
credit card debt for the coffee roaster as well as or LLC is really just a sham and you are personally
the remaining months on their two-year lease operating the business as if the corporation or LLC
(unless the landlord can find a replacement didn’t exist. In this situation, a court may decide
tenant). Because Amy and Adam didn’t that you aren’t entitled to the limited liability that
personally sign or guarantee a contract for the your business structure would ordinarily provide.
coffee bean deliveries, only the business is liable One way creditors try to pierce the corporate
to pay the bean invoices (assuming Amy and veil is by showing that you didn’t observe the legal
Adam have properly followed LLC formalities). formalities imposed on corporations and LLCs.
Amy and Adam consider filing for Chapter 7 For instance, you may have made important
personal bankruptcy to get rid of their credit corporate or LLC decisions without recording
card debt and obligation to the landlord. them in minutes of a meeting. Or, you may have
paid business bills from a personal checking or
Tortious Conduct credit card account or paid personal bills from your
business bank account. Even corporations or LLCs
Generally, owners of corporations and LLCs are
owned by a single individual or a married couple
not personally liable for mistakes in management,
have to obey the rules and formalities imposed
but they can be held personally liable for injuring
on these business structures; otherwise, they risk
others. An owner who commits a tort (the legal
losing their limited liability protection.
term for an act that harms another person and
causes monetary loss) can be held personally liable.
Tip
Example: Brian, the owner of an LLC, speeds
List all business debts in your personal
through a residential neighborhood and runs a
bankruptcy filing, just in case your “veil” is pieced.
red light, causing an accident. Damages to the
Even if you don’t think you are personally liable for
other vehicles, which were totaled, exceed his a corporate or LLC debt, you should list all business
$50,000 liability insurance policy by $40,000 debts when you file for Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy.
(he hit a Lexus and a Mercedes). Even though Business creditors might try to pierce your corporate
Brian was driving on work-related business, veil and sue you personally for those debts. But if you
the LLC’s limited liability does not protect list your business creditors in your personal Chapter
Brian from being sued personally for the 7 paperwork, any potential personal liability for the
automobile damages. business debt will be extinguished in the Chapter 7
personal bankruptcy—even though the business debt
Fraud, Misrepresentation, or will remain on the corporation or LLC’s books. If you’re
Sloppy Record Keeping concerned about personal liability for your corporation’s
or LLC’s debts, you should also talk to a lawyer to make
If you misrepresented or lied about any facts
sure you’re doing all you can to protect yourself. At a
when you applied for a loan or credit on behalf
minimum, when you list these business debts in your
of your corporation or LLC, you could be held
bankruptcy forms, check the “disputed” column (see Ch.
personally liable for the debt. Likewise, if you
9), so you won’t be admitting liability down the road if
failed to maintain a formal legal separation any of these debts survive your bankruptcy.
between your business and your personal financial
10 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
Assess Your Spouse’s Liability in a community property state, you may want to
file for bankruptcy to wipe out your business debts
for Business Debts and protect your community income and property;
After reading the section above, you should be able even if you currently have little or no income, your
to figure out which debts you are personally liable spouse may have a good job.
for and which you are not. But that isn’t the end In Ch. 9, we discuss the pros and cons of filing
of the story: Your spouse’s personal liability for jointly or separately in a community property state.
your business debts could also affect your decision
about filing for Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy. For Community and Common
instance, if your spouse is liable for your business Law Property States
debts and has assets or income to lose, it might Community Property Common Law
make sense for both of you to file for personal Alaska* Everywhere else
bankruptcy. Arizona
Whether your spouse is liable for your business California**
debts turns mostly on where you live. So, it’s time
Idaho
for a little geography lesson.
Louisiana
Nevada
CAUTION New Mexico
If you live in a state that allows same-sex Texas
marriage, same-sex spouses are subject to the same Washington
rules about joint and separate debt that apply to other Wisconsin
married couples. Some states that don’t recognize same-
sex marriage allow same-sex couples to register their *In Alaska, couples can elect to treat their property as
union in some form (for example, as domestic partners) community property.
and thereby gain some of the benefits and obligations **In California, community property laws also apply to
registered domestic partners.
of marriage—which may include joint obligations for
debt. If you are concerned about your same-sex partner’s
liability for business debts, consult with an attorney. As
explained in Ch. 5, however, same-sex couples may not
Example: Shelley runs a sporting goods store
file jointly for bankruptcy, even if they are married.
in Tacoma, Washington, as a sole proprietor;
her husband is a local bank executive. Even
though Shelley’s husband isn’t involved in
Community Property States the business, he and Shelley own the business
In the community property states (listed below), jointly, because Shelley started the business
all income either spouse earns during marriage, as with income earned after they married. Over
well as all property bought with that income, is the last few years, Shelley’s store has been
community property, owned equally by husband suffering from poor sales. She finally decides
and wife. For the most part, any debt incurred by to close her doors, owing $40,000 to suppliers,
one spouse during marriage is owed by both of $25,000 to her landlord, and $15,000 in other
them, too; it’s a community debt, and the spouse’s debt.
creditor can go after community property as a Because Shelley and her husband live in
source of repayment (although they rarely do when a community property state, her business
the debt is in one spouse’s name). So, if you live creditors can sue both Shelley and her
ChaPter 1 | Evaluate Your Debts and Your Business | 11
husband personally to collect the money One spouse’s creditors cannot legally reach the
owed. Shelley no longer has any income other spouse’s separate money, property, or wages
to take, but her husband’s earnings are to repay a separate debt. However, if income earned
significant. To prevent her creditors from by one spouse is put into a joint bank account or
garnishing her husband’s income or suing the investment account, that income becomes a joint
couple to take their personal assets, Shelley asset, which a creditor can go after. Fortunately,
files for personal bankruptcy, which discharges in most common law states, a creditor can take
her business debts, Shelley’s personal debts, only half of the money in a joint account to pay a
and any personal debts owed jointly by Shelley spouse’s separate business debts.
and her husband. (If Shelley’s husband has In many common law states, spouses can
separate personal debts, such as a lawsuit jointly own property in a form known as tenancy
judgment against him that predates their by the entirety. The rules for when creditors can
marriage, those debts will not be affected by proceed against property held in tenancy by the
Shelley’s bankruptcy filing.) entirety are complex (see Ch. 5 for more informa
tion). However, the basic idea is that property held
in tenancy by the entirety is protected from the
Common Law States separate creditors of a spouse.
The law works differently in what we refer to
as “common law” marital property states (that See an Expert
is, the states that don’t appear on the list of If you’re concerned about your spouse’s
community property states, above). In these states, liability, see a lawyer. If you have run up a pile of
debts incurred by one spouse—even during the business debts and your spouse owns lots of separate
marriage—are generally that spouse’s debts alone, property (whether or not it’s kept in a joint account),
and only that spouse’s income and property are we recommend that you see a lawyer to find out how to
liable for the debt. Debts are jointly owed by both best protect your spouse’s assets.
spouses only if they were jointly undertaken. A
debt might be jointly owed if any of the following
Example: Robert Horton, the sole owner
are true, for example:
of Horton Rental, rents construction equip
• Both spouses signed a contract requiring
ment and party furniture and supplies in
them to make payments.
Albany, New York. His wife Amanda is an
• Both spouses’ names appear on an account
independent jewelry appraiser who makes a
or title to property.
good living. Robert hasn’t been able to pay
• A creditor was given both spouses’ credit
Horton Rental’s bills for several months, and a
information as part of an application for a
creditor is threatening to sue the couple.
loan.
Because the Hortons live in a common law
• The debt benefited the marriage. In other
property state, the creditor can’t sue Amanda
words, it was for food, clothing, child care,
and garnish her income. And, because the
necessary household items, or similar items
Hortons hold title to their house in tenancy by
of direct benefit to the family.
the entirety, New York law prevents creditors
All other debts, such as a business debt from
from forcing its sale, as long as Amanda is
one spouse’s business, a loan for a car whose title
alive. If Amanda and Robert were to sell the
is in only one spouse’s name, or credit card debt
house, however, the creditor would be entitled
in one spouse’s name only, are considered that
to payment from Robert’s half of the proceeds.
spouse’s separate debts.
12 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
If you and your spouse have not kept your figures to come up with a profit-and-loss forecast
income and property separate, and your spouse and cash-flow analysis—using real numbers, not
brings significant income and/or assets to the table, guesses or rosy estimates.
filing together for bankruptcy can be advantageous.
We discuss the pros and cons of filing separately in Resource
Ch. 9.
Help with financial spreadsheets and
business viability. For help assessing whether your
Assess Whether Your business can return to profitability, read Save Your Small
Business: 10 Crucial Strategies to Rescue Your Business
Business Is Viable or Close Down and Move On, by Ralph Warner, J.D, and
Now you know how much of your business debt Bethany Laurence, J.D. (Nolo). This book explains in detail
how to make a profit (including, for those who need it,
you (and perhaps your spouse) are personally liable
how to complete a profit-and-loss forecast and cash-flow
to repay. If you are personally liable for a significant
analysis) and offers an entire toolkit of marketing ideas
amount of debt, Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy
that will help you turn your business around.
might be a good choice for you. Before making
the decision, however, you also need to take a
If you’ve looked at the financials and you
hard look at your business. Undoubtedly, you’re
think your business can turn a profit in the long
considering bankruptcy because the business hasn’t
run, it may make sense to stay open while trying
done well. But could it do better in the future, or
to reduce your debt, either through negotiating
is it time to close the doors for good? And if you
settlements with your creditors (called a debt
think prospects could improve for the business, do
workout) or filing a type of bankruptcy that will
you want to continue at the helm?
allow you to keep running your business. If you
run a service business with few assets, you might
Is Your Business Economically Viable? even be able to keep your doors open while you
Let’s focus first on whether your business can be file for Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy. Ordinarily,
saved. The answer affects whether you decide to however, the owner of a business with significant
keep your business open and which strategy for assets or inventory would have to file for Chapter
handling your business debt makes the most sense. 13 bankruptcy to stay open. (As explained in Ch.
You wouldn’t be reading this book if your 3, Chapter 13 bankruptcy requires you to come up
business was going gangbusters. So we’ll start with with a plan to pay off some or all of your debts over
the assumption that your business is performing three to five years.)
poorly and deep in debt. But does this mean that Before you spend a lot of time and money
your business could never turn a profit? trying to save your business by arranging a debt
If your past-due debts to your suppliers, workout or filing for bankruptcy, make sure your
landlord, utility providers, and other creditors were business plan will allow your business to become
erased, either through negotiating settlements or profitable in the next 12 to 18 months, not just
through a bankruptcy process that allowed your to break even. It doesn’t make sense to invest the
business to stay open, could your business begin time, trouble, and sleepless nights required to turn
to break even? Could it stay in the black for the your business around unless you see a pot of gold
foreseeable future and produce enough income at the end of the rainbow. If you can’t become
to cover your living expenses? To answer these profitable within that time, it may make more sense
questions, use your recent expense and income to cut your losses now by closing the business,
ChaPter 1 | Evaluate Your Debts and Your Business | 13
filing for Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy to wipe especially true if you are willing to let the business
out your debt, and deciding whether to start over go, because you will no longer be tempted to
with a new business. exaggerate the chances of a turnaround.
While it can be agonizing to decide to close
your business down, the sooner you make this
Some Personal History
decision, the better off you will be if you decide to
file for Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy. Bankruptcy For many years, Steve’s father worked in—and
law prohibits certain transactions close to the owned part of—the family department store (Lee’s
time of a bankruptcy filing, including actions you Department Store in the Los Angeles area). His
might want to take to preserve your assets or pay specialty was men’s clothing. He hated going to
off favored creditors. The more time you have, the work, and his family knew it. After several years,
more flexibility you will have in arranging your he sold out his interest in the family business
affairs before filing for bankruptcy. and purchased a small men’s clothing store in
partnership with a brother-in-law, where he worked
for many years.
Do You Want to Continue
After the first flush of enjoyment at being
Owning the Business? his own boss, he realized he was still unhappy
If you think your business has a financial future, working in retail and often wished out loud for a
you’ll need to decide whether you want to be part more creative line of work. Finally, Steve’s father
of it. This decision might depend on lots of factors said, “Enough!” and made the jump to commercial
beyond the prospects of your business, including development. He was a transformed human being
your health, age, family situation, and career for most of the rest of his life. The moral of this
alternatives. little story is simple: Facing up to the need to make
If you’ve come to realize that running a a career change—even one forced upon you—can
business (or running this particular business) isn’t be a positive life event.
your cup of tea, this may be your opportunity to
move on to more fulfilling opportunities. In this
situation, you’ll want to look at how much money At this point, you should have a good sense
you can squeeze out of the business, in or out of of whether you want to continue operating
bankruptcy, before you close the doors. On the your business—and whether that’s a good idea
other hand, if you love running your business, your financially. You also know the extent of your (and
financial assessment may be focused more on how your spouse’s) personal liability for the business’s
to keep it running at all costs. debts. Armed with this information, it’s time to
Once you decide either that you want to keep consider whether Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy
running the business or that you want to move on is the best strategy for dealing with your business
to other things, you’ll have an easier time assessing debt.
the financial condition of your business. This is l
2
C H A P T E R
I
f you determined, after reading Ch. 1, that you your state law (or federal law, in some cases) has
(and perhaps your spouse) are personally liable declared it off-limits for collection efforts. Exempt
for all or a good portion of your business debt, property typically includes basic living essentials,
filing for Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy might such as clothing, furniture, health aids, the tools
be a wise choice. Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy of your trade, most retirement accounts, and
wipes out your personal liability for most debts, some amount of equity in a vehicle and a home.
including most business debts. But in exchange, Nonexempt property, which you stand to lose
you may have to give up any valuable business in bankruptcy, often includes things like luxury
assets you own, and perhaps some of your personal items, a second car, antiques, artwork, and real
property, so they can be sold and the proceeds estate other than your home. Most business
used to pay down your unsecured debt. You may assets, such as inventory, machinery, equipment,
also have to close down your business. Bankruptcy and supplies, are typically nonexempt, which
has other downsides as well, including bankruptcy means they can be taken and sold in Chapter 7
court fees, attorney fees if you use a lawyer, and a bankruptcy. (You’ll find more information on
damaged credit rating. exemptions in “What Happens to Your Property in
For these reasons, Chapter 7 bankruptcy may Chapter 7 Bankruptcy?” below, and in Ch. 6.)
not be the best strategy for those who want to The typical Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy is
stay in business, have valuable property that they a routine process that lasts three to six months,
could lose in bankruptcy, or wouldn’t benefit much costs $299 in filing fees, and requires no special
from the process because too many of their debts courtroom or analytical skills. Most filers will have
would survive a bankruptcy filing. And, some to follow only these steps:
debtors aren’t eligible to file for Chapter 7 personal • Get credit counseling from an approved
bankruptcy because their income is too high, they agency before filing for bankruptcy.
have already received a bankruptcy discharge in the • File a packet of official forms and documents.
recent past, or they are otherwise disqualified. • Attend a short meeting outside of court
This chapter explains the basics of Chapter 7 (called the meeting of creditors) with a
personal bankruptcy, so you’ll have a general sense bankruptcy official called the trustee.
of how it works, what effect it will have on your • Take a two-hour course in budget manage
property and debts, and whether it’s available to ment.
you in the first place. Once you understand the This section summarizes how a typical Chapter
Chapter 7 process, you can compare it to other 7 personal bankruptcy case proceeds. If you decide
options, covered in Ch. 3, to make a final decision to file for Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy, you’ll
about whether to file for Chapter 7 personal find much more detail on every step of the process
bankruptcy. in later chapters.
and financial transactions prior to filing; a list of a sort of commission system: The more assets the
property you are claiming as exempt; information trustee recovers for your creditors, the more the
on what you plan to do with property that serves trustee is paid.
as collateral for a loan (such as a car or home); While your case is open, you must get the
and more. You also have to file documents, such trustee’s consent before you sell or give away any
as your most recent tax return and wage stubs. of the property in your bankruptcy estate. With
In addition, you’ll also have to file a form a few exceptions, however, you can do what you
certifying that you have completed a mandatory wish with property you acquire and income
credit counseling course with an agency approved you earn after you file for bankruptcy. You are
by the U.S. Trustee’s office. (You can find more also allowed to borrow money during your
on this requirement in Ch. 9.) bankruptcy case (if you can find someone who
Along with your paperwork, you must pay the will lend it to you).
$299 bankruptcy filing fee. If you can’t afford You aren’t the only one prevented from selling
the whole fee, you can apply to pay the fee in or disposing of your property during bankruptcy:
installments or apply for a fee waiver. (Ch. 9 Creditors also generally have to keep their hands
explains how.) Plus, if you use a lawyer, you can off. As soon as you file your papers, a federal court
expect to pay several thousand dollars in legal order called the “automatic stay” goes into effect,
fees. Of course, you can save most of this money which requires your creditors to immediately stop
by representing yourself with the help of this all collection efforts. Although the automatic stay
book (and, perhaps, by using typing services is not absolute (as explained in Ch. 4), it typically
from a bankruptcy petition preparer or legal puts a swift end to collection calls and letters, and
advice from a limited practice lawyer). Many efforts to garnish wages, take property, or cut off
small business owners can handle their Chapter your utilities.
7 bankruptcy cases on their own. For more
information on situations when it might make The Meeting of Creditors
sense to hire a lawyer or petition preparer, and
At some point during your bankruptcy case,
help finding one, see Ch. 12.
you must show up at a meeting of creditors and
answer questions about your paperwork. Usually,
The Role of the Trustee and the Court
the meeting is held somewhere in the courthouse
When you file for bankruptcy, you are or federal building. The trustee will swear you
technically placing the property you own and in, and then ask you questions like whether
the debts you owe—called your “bankruptcy the information in your papers is complete and
estate”—in the hands of the bankruptcy court. accurate, whether you’ve given anything away
The court exercises control over your bankruptcy in the last year, or how you arrived at the value
estate through an official called a “trustee,” who you gave for a particular item of property listed
is appointed to manage your case. The trustee’s on your forms. All told, the process rarely takes
primary duty is to see that your creditors are more than a few minutes.
paid as much as possible, so trustees are mostly Despite the name, creditors rarely attend this
interested in what you own and what property meeting. If they do, they will also have a chance
you claim as exempt. The trustee will examine to question you under oath, usually about the
your papers to make sure they’re complete and to location of collateral for a debt or the accuracy
look for property that can be taken and sold for of information you provided to obtain a loan or
the benefit of your creditors. Trustees are paid on credit. In most bankruptcy cases, this will be the
18 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
only personal appearance you have to make. You’ll Who Can File for Chapter 7
find more information on the creditors’ meeting,
as well as other situations when you might have to Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy isn’t available to
appear in court, in Ch. 10. everyone. If you have a higher income, you may
not be eligible for Chapter 7. In addition, previous
How a Bankruptcy Case Ends bankruptcies or fraud may disqualify some filers.
All of your debt counts toward the total, even The bankruptcy law defines your “current
if your business caused your financial difficulties. monthly income” as your average monthly income
If you have a lot of personal debt (such as a over the six months before you filed for bankruptcy.
substantial mortgage on your home or student All gross income, whether taxable or not, must be
loans), you may have to take the means test—even included in the total, except for Social Security and
if you are current on those debts and they aren’t the Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (TANF).
source of your problems. Include your business income, rents, pension, dis
ability insurance, wages, and so on. (You can find
Example: Petra, a small business owner, uses a list of income you must include in Ch. 9, along
her personal credit cards and home equity with the instructions to complete the means test
line of credit to fund her high school tutoring form; you can also do this calculation—and find
business. She uses the same sources of credit your state’s median income—online free, at www.
for personal expenses unrelated to her business, legalconsumer.com.) Importantly, your business
such as taking a trip to visit her grandfather, income is not your gross business income—it’s your
vacationing in Vermont, and buying a new gross receipts minus your ordinary and necessary
bedroom set. She has run up a total of $50,000 business expenses (the same expenses you list on
in debt. Schedule C of your tax return).
When Petra tallies up her debt, she finds Once you have a monthly average, multiply it
that she spent just under $30,000 on her by 12 to come up with an annual figure. Then
business and the rest on personal expenses. compare that number to your state’s median for a
Because most of her debt was incurred for household of the same size (you can find the state
business reasons, Petra doesn’t have to take the median figures online at www.legalconsumer.
means test. com or www.usdoj.gov/ust; select “Means Testing
If Petra also had a sizable home mortgage, Information”). If your income is at or below the
the balance would tip. For example, say Petra median, you have passed the means test and can
owes $150,000 on her home mortgage (not use Chapter 7. If your income is more than the
including the home equity line discussed above). median, however, you have to do some more
Because most courts consider a home mortgage calculations.
to be a personal debt, Petra would have to add
$150,000 to the “personal” side of the debt
scale, and would have to take the means test to Tip
see whether she can use Chapter 7. Take the means test free, online. This section
Certain disabled veterans who will use Chapter explains how the means test works, so you can make a
rough determination of whether you qualify for Chapter
7 to discharge debts incurred while on active duty
7. If you want more precise calculations, or you’d simply
or engaged in homeland defense activities can also
rather not look up the required figures and do all of
skip the means test.
the math, go to www.legalconsumer.com. Once you
Is Your Income Higher Than the State Median? type in your zip code, this information-rich site will give
you all of the state and regional information you need
If you have to take the means test, your first step is and run the figures for you. You’ll need to gather your
to compare your “current monthly income” to your personal and business financial information (on income,
state’s median income. If your income is equal to or expenses, and so on) in order to use the online calculator.
less than the state median, you can file for Chapter If you decide to file for Chapter 7, you’ll find line-by-line
7 without doing any further calculations. instructions in Ch. 9 on how to complete the official
20 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
means test form (Form 22A—Chapter 7 Statement of (such as child support and some tax debts), make
Current Monthly Income and Means Test Calculation), required payments on your secured debts (like your
which you must submit with the rest of your bankruptcy mortgage or car note), and pay a certain minimum
paperwork. amount (currently, about $110 per month) toward
your unsecured debts. If your income will cover all
Secured vs. Unsecured Debt of these costs, you might be forced out of Chapter
7 bankruptcy.
Secured debts and unsecured debts are handled As you can see, these calculations can get com
differently in bankruptcy. A secured debt gives the plicated. What’s more, you might have to use
creditor the right to take particular property (called expense amounts as determined by the IRS for your
collateral) if you fail to pay. For example, a car note area, not the actual amount you spend on particular
is often secured by the car, which the creditor can items. In Ch. 9, we explain how to fill in each line of
repossess if you miss your payments. Similarly, the required form to find out whether you pass the
a mortgage is secured by your house, on which test. Or, you can complete the means test using the
the creditor can foreclose. Filing for bankruptcy free online calculator at www.legalconsumer.com (it
does not wipe out a secured creditor’s lien on the supplies the IRS amounts for you).
collateral, which means the creditor still has the
right to take it back if you don’t keep up with your
payments. CAUTION
An unsecured debt is not tied to any particular The bankruptcy court can second-guess the
piece of property. Typical unsecured debts include results of the means test. Even if you pass the means
credit card bills, legal fees, medical bills, and bills test, the bankruptcy court could dismiss your Chapter
from suppliers or service providers. If you fail to 7 bankruptcy case or order it converted to a Chapter 13
pay an unsecured debt, the creditor isn’t entitled to case if the court believes you have enough income to
simply take your money or property. Instead, the repay your debts. For example, if the current monthly
creditor usually has to go to court, win a judgment income you used in the means test was very low, but
against you or your business, and then institute you’ve recently been rehired at the high-paying job you
collection proceedings. In a bankruptcy case, left to start your business, the judge might decide that
unsecured creditors receive a share of the proceeds you shouldn’t be allowed to use Chapter 7.
from the trustee’s sale of your nonexempt property
(if you have any). Most unsecured debts are wiped
out in bankruptcy.
Other Disqualifying Circumstances
Even if you pass the means test, you might still be
ineligible for Chapter 7 bankruptcy. Here are the
Do You Have Enough Disposable most common situations in which debtors aren’t
Income to Pay Your Debts? allowed to use Chapter 7.
If your ”current monthly income” exceeds the Previous Bankruptcy Discharge
state median, you don’t necessarily fail the means
test. However, you have to do a lot more math to If you obtained a discharge of your debts in a
see whether you pass: You need to subtract your Chapter 7 case filed within the last eight years, or a
allowed personal expenses from your income and Chapter 13 case filed within the last six years, you
see whether you’d have enough left over to pay cannot file for Chapter 7. This rule bars only the
certain debts that will survive your bankruptcy same person or entity from filing. So, for example,
if you already received a discharge in a Chapter 7
ChaPter 2 | How Chapter 7 Personal Bankruptcy works | 21
personal bankruptcy you filed to deal with debts Example: Laura is the sole owner of an incor-
from your sole proprietorship business, you may porated beauty salon business. The corporation
not file another Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy owns the salon’s fixtures and beauty supplies
until eight years have passed—even if your current and is obligated on the salon’s ten-year lease.
debts were incurred for a different business or for Laura is also personally liable on the lease,
entirely personal reasons. because the landlord insisted that she cosign in
her own name. Due to recent business down-
Example: Seven years ago, Fred filed for turns, Laura decides to close the business.
Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy to discharge The business’s assets are worth about
debts arising from his computer repair service, $15,000, and it owes vendors a total of
which he owned as a sole proprietor. As part of $20,000. Laura and the corporation are both
that bankruptcy proceeding, Fred closed down liable for the rent due for the remainder of the
his business. Once he received his discharge, lease period, a potential liability of $75,000
Fred got a job with a large computer company (depending on whether, and when, the landlord
as a network troubleshooting specialist. can find a replacement tenant).
After a few years, Fred decided to go back Laura received a discharge in a Chapter 7
into business for himself. He left his job personal bankruptcy case she filed six years
and opened a new sole proprietorship called ago. The corporation has never filed for bank
“Doctor Network.” His business is doing fairly ruptcy. The corporation may file a business
well, but Fred has run up huge medical bills bankruptcy case now, in which its assets will be
as a result of a car accident. He’s considering sold off and used to pay its creditors. Laura will
filing for bankruptcy again. still be personally liable for the lease, however,
If Fred wants to use Chapter 7 personal and she must wait another two years to file for
bankruptcy, he’ll have to wait another year. Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy to discharge
Even though he’s now running a different that debt. If she is personally liable for any of
business, and his debts are personal this time the other corporate debts (which would happen
around, he is subject to the eight-year bar. if her corporate veil is pierced), that liability
Regardless of the source of his debts, he is could also be wiped out in a personal Chapter
filing personally in both cases—and he’s still 7 bankruptcy.
the same Fred.
The eight-year bar applies only if you received a
If your current business is a separate entity (a discharge in your earlier bankruptcy case. If your
corporation or an LLC), it can file for Chapter 7 case was dismissed or otherwise ended without a
business bankruptcy even if you filed a Chapter discharge, it doesn’t count.
7 personal bankruptcy case within the past eight
years. Because you and your business are legally Previous Bankruptcy Dismissal
separate, you are different filers, and the bar
You cannot file for Chapter 7 bankruptcy if
wouldn’t apply (unless the corporate veil is pierced
your previous Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 case was
and you and the corporation or LLC are deemed
dismissed in the last 180 days because you violated
to be the same entity; see Ch. 1 for more on this).
a court order, the court found that your case was
Similarly, you can file for Chapter 7 personal
fraudulent or abusive (as explained below), or you
bankruptcy even if your corporation or LLC has
requested the dismissal after a creditor asked for
filed a business bankruptcy case in the last eight
relief from the automatic stay. (See Ch. 4.)
years.
22 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
the economic right to receive income from the Example: Ned, a truck driver, is the sole
partnership or LLC; typically, a person assigned owner of a corporation that has few debts and
economic rights is not allowed to manage or vote holds title to an 18-wheeler. Ned wants to file
in the partnership or LLC nor to assume other for personal bankruptcy to get rid of a huge
membership rights granted to full owners under amount of credit card debt. Because Ned’s
the partnership or LLC operating agreement. corporate stock becomes part of his bankruptcy
The trustee can assign or sell the economic rights estate, the trustee can exercise all powers
in your ownership interest to someone else, but conferred by the stock, including dissolving
generally cannot transfer or sell your share of the the corporation, selling the corporation’s sole
partnership or LLC. asset (the truck), and distributing the proceeds
to Ned’s unsecured creditors (unless Ned can
claim the truck as exempt under his state’s
CAUTION laws).
You may need to get out of a partnership or
LLC before filing for bankruptcy. If you are a partner in a If you own a viable corporation with other
partnership or a member of an LLC, you may have signed members, then your personal bankruptcy may
a buy-sell agreement that requires you to terminate your or may not affect your business. For example, if
ownership interest before filing for bankruptcy. If you you own a corporation equally with two or three
violate a provision like this, you could be facing a lawsuit other shareholders, you may be able to file for
from your co-owners. A small business attorney can help personal bankruptcy without any consequences
you assess your obligations and options here. to the corporation. Although the trustee has the
right to vote shares in a corporation, he or she
generally won’t be able to call a meeting and force
Corporations and Single-Member LLCs a dissolution of the corporation to get at its assets
Your bankruptcy estate includes your corporate unless you are the majority shareholder. Your stock
shares or LLC membership. If you are the sole or is still part of your bankruptcy estate, but it won’t
majority owner of the corporation or LLC, the have much value to the bankruptcy trustee unless
bankruptcy trustee can take over your shares or one of the other owners wants to buy it.
membership interest and vote to sell or liquidate
the business, then distribute the proceeds to the
business’s creditors. CAUTION
In deciding whether to dissolve a single-owner Trustees may be able to dissolve even a
corporation or LLC, the trustee will take a cost/ multiowner corporation or LLC. When one person, or
benefit approach. The trustee will look at the cost a small group of related or closely associated people,
of dissolving and liquidating the business, how have complete control over a corporation or LLC, and
much the assets can be sold for, and whether any of the corporation or LLC has been used in questionable
the assets are exempt. In many cases, the business ways (perhaps it has recklessly borrowed and lost money
owes almost as much as (or more than) it owns, so or perpetrated financial fraud), a trustee can try to
liquidating the business wouldn’t make financial “reverse pierce” the corporation or LLC’s veil of liability
sense. But if the business has a moderate amount protection. This is similar to piercing the corporate veil,
of debt and valuable, nonexempt assets, the trustee discussed in Ch. 1, but instead of holding the owner
is likely to dissolve the corporation or LLC and sell liable for the business’s debts, reverse piercing allows the
the assets. trustee to hold the business liable for the owner’s debts.
If there was commingling of personal and business funds,
the corporation or LLC was inadequately capitalized, or
ChaPter 2 | How Chapter 7 Personal Bankruptcy works | 25
corporate or LLC formalities were neglected, the trustee down on inventory. As a result, the value of the
might be able to dissolve the business and sell the assets bank’s security for the loan decreases as well.
attributable to the bankruptcy filer for the benefit of the Under the terms of the loan, the bank calls for
bankruptcy filer’s creditors. immediate payment of the loan in full.
Realizing that he can’t pay off the loan (and
that his business is no longer economically
Your Business Assets
viable), Kevin closes his doors and files for
The bankruptcy trustee has the power to take Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy. In addition to
valuable business equipment and supplies in your Kevin’s personal assets, the bankruptcy estate
bankruptcy estate and sell them for the benefit of includes the store’s remaining inventory, valued
your unsecured creditors. The trustee, however, at roughly $40,000. Because Kevin owes the
can’t take and sell: bank more than the inventory is worth, all of
• property that secures a loan (collateral) the proceeds from auctioning off the inventory
• exempt property, or would go to the bank. There would be nothing
• property that belongs to your corporation or left for Kevin’s other creditors, and the trustee
LLC. couldn’t claim a commission for the sale. The
trustee decides instead to leave the inventory
Property Acting as Collateral alone (in bankruptcy terms, to “abandon” the
Here’s a brief overview of what happens to property property) and let the bank take it back.
acting as collateral for a loan (secured property);
for more detailed information, see Ch. 8. If your
Exempt Property
property serves as collateral for a loan, the trustee
If any of your business property is entirely exempt,
can petition the bankruptcy court for permission
the trustee can’t take it and sell it. There are two
to sell the property. The trustee will do this only if
types of exemptions that may apply to business
he or she believes that there will be money left over
assets:
after selling the property, paying off the lender, and
• “wildcard” exemptions, which give you a
paying you any exempt amount you are entitled
lump sum exemption amount you can apply
to. The money left over would be paid to your
to any type of property, including business
unsecured creditors.
property (wildcard exemptions range from
Unless the collateral is worth much more than
several hundred dollars to $20,000 or
the loan securing the property, the bankruptcy
$30,000, depending on your state’s law), and
trustee will often allow the secured creditor to
• “tools of the trade” exemptions, which let you
take the property (the trustee will “abandon” the
keep tools or equipment up to a certain dollar
property to the secured creditor), because there
amount in value (typically, several thousand
wouldn’t be any money left over from a sale to
dollars). However, most states allow you to
distribute to the unsecured creditors.
exempt property as tools of the trade only
Example: Kevin opens Kitchen Playpen, a sole if you will continue to use them to make a
proprietorship that carries a select inventory of living.
upscale home kitchen products. To stock his
Example: Chuck, a sole proprietor, has a car
shelves, Kevin borrows $60,000 from a local
repair and restoration shop in a trendy area of
community bank at a low interest rate. The
Venice, California. Four years ago, he signed a
loan is secured by the store’s entire inventory.
ten-year lease for $48,000 per year, payable in
As business falters, Kevin substantially cuts
$4,000 monthly installments. After suffering
26 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
some health problems and seeing a sharp Property That Belongs to Your Corporation or LLC
decline in his business, Chuck decides to close If your business is a corporation or LLC, the
his doors. Because he can’t pay off what he trustee can take and sell its assets only if you are
owes on the lease, his landlord is unwilling to the sole or majority owner and the trustee votes to
negotiate, and he has a growing pile of medical dissolve the business, as explained above. If you
and personal bills, Chuck files for Chapter 7 are a minority owner, the corporation’s or LLC’s
personal bankruptcy. property is off limits to the trustee.
Chuck’s bankruptcy estate consists primarily
of used shop equipment and tools, the possible Example: Heather starts a gelato shop on a
value of the six years remaining on his lease, busy corner in San Francisco and organizes
and Chuck’s house. Chuck values the shop it as a corporation. After Heather spends a
equipment at $20,000 in his bankruptcy fortune on expensive equipment (purchased
papers and claims a full wildcard exemption with a small business loan), the business does
under California law. If the trustee takes the poorly and Heather has to shut down. She
equipment and sells it, Chuck is entitled to arranges to keep her equipment in a storage
his exempt amount before one penny can be facility, hoping that she can use it to restart
distributed to his unsecured creditors. Figuring the business in a different location when the
that Chuck’s valuation is pretty accurate and economy improves. Mired in credit card debt
taking into account the costs of an asset sale, and burdened by a mortgage that’s higher than
the trustee lets him keep the equipment instead the current value of her house, Heather files for
of selling it. personal Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy.
As for the lease, the trustee is legally She doesn’t list her shop equipment as an
entitled to “assume” it and then sell it off to a asset because the equipment belongs to the
willing buyer, or “reject” it and let it die with corporation, which isn’t filing for bankruptcy.
the bankruptcy. If Chuck’s space was worth Heather does, however, list her stock in the
much more than $4,000 a month, the trustee corporation as one of her assets. Heather hopes
could probably make some money for Chuck’s the trustee will “abandon” the stock, because
creditors by selling the right to take over the there’s really no market for it, and leave
lease to an interested customer. Because times Heather with her equipment. This is wishful
are so bad, however, the lease is now greatly thinking, however. Because the corporation
overpriced, so the trustee chooses to reject it. owns valuable assets, the trustee becomes
Finally, Chuck’s house is “underwater” (he owner of the corporation and “votes” to
owes more than it is worth), so the trustee has dissolve it and liquidate its assets, including the
no interest in selling it; all of the proceeds from shop equipment, for the benefit of Heather’s
a sale would go to the mortgage lender. unsecured creditors.
Had Heather formed the corporation equally
These examples illustrate the typical facts on the with a couple of friends, the situation would
ground: People who declare bankruptcy don’t tend have been different. The trustee would have
to own much valuable property, especially not free had the right to vote Heather’s shares, but
and clear. Often, the trustee won’t be able to sell wouldn’t have had the power to force a dis
property belonging to the bankruptcy estate, either solution of the corporation over the objections
because the property (or the owner’s equity in it) of the other shareholders. Because the shop
is exempt or because the property is collateral for equipment belongs to the corporation, it’s not
a secured debt, and the creditor would get all the part of Heather’s bankruptcy estate, and the
proceeds if it were sold.
ChaPter 2 | How Chapter 7 Personal Bankruptcy works | 27
trustee wouldn’t have been able to take it and states exempt your residence no matter how much
sell it. it’s worth (though some have large acreage limits).
Note that the homestead exemption applies only
to main residences, not second houses, vacation
Tip houses, or rental property.
Records of asset ownership are essential. It’s If your equity in your home is less than your
important to know which business assets belong to you state’s exemption amount, the trustee wouldn’t
and which belong to the business entity (if any), so you get anything from a sale; what you owe to the
know what will be part of your bankruptcy estate. This is mortgage lender and your exempt amount would
especially important if you are one of several co-owners together eat up all of the sale proceeds. You’ll be
of your corporation or LLC; the trustee has no right to able to keep your house—again, if you keep up
take any assets belonging to the corporation or LLC if on your mortgage payments during and after the
you are a minority owner. bankruptcy. But if your equity significantly exceeds
the exempt amount, the trustee will want to sell the
house, pay off your mortgage and any other loans
Your House secured by the house, give you the exempt amount,
Ch. 7 explains in detail what happens to your and distribute the rest of your equity among your
house in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, but here’s a brief unsecured creditors.
overview. Small business owners often pledge their
Example: Andy’s New York travel company,
homes as collateral for business loans or lines of
a sole proprietorship, goes under. Andy owes
credit. If you default on this type of loan (or you
$40,000 on a small business loan, $10,000 in
stop making your mortgage payments for any
rent for his commercial space, and $25,000 in
reason), the lender can foreclose. Filing for Chapter
credit card bills for both personal and business
7 bankruptcy can delay the foreclosure, but
expenses. He decides to file for Chapter 7
ultimately, if you don’t make the payments, you’ll
personal bankruptcy.
lose your house. (Note: Chapter 13 bankruptcy can
Andy’s house is worth $300,000, and he
provide a more long-term solution to keeping your
owes $245,000 on his mortgage, leaving him
home—see Ch. 3.)
with $55,000 in equity. New York’s homestead
What about debts that aren’t secured by your
exemption protects up to $50,000 in equity.
home? To determine whether your house might
In theory, the bankruptcy trustee could sell
be sold to pay debts you owe your commercial
the house, give Andy his $50,000 exemption
landlord, suppliers, or other business creditors,
amount, and pay the remaining $5,000 toward
you need to understand your state’s homestead
Andy’s creditors. However, the trustee knows
exemption law. Most states let you keep your
that it will cost more than $5,000 to take the
principal residence if your equity in it doesn’t
house and sell it. This makes the sale a losing
exceed the state’s homestead exemption amount
proposition for the trustee, so Andy gets to
(assuming, of course, that you keep making the
keep it.
mortgage payments). In most states, $10,000 to
$70,000 of your home equity is exempt from
creditors. A few states, including Tennessee, Ohio, Tip
Maryland, Kentucky, and Alabama, exempt $5,000
Chapter 7 bankruptcy can buy you some
or less, and New Jersey and Pennsylvania don’t
breathing room. When you file for bankruptcy, the
have a homestead exemption at all. At the other court issues an “automatic stay,” an order that requires all
end of the spectrum, Texas, Florida and a few other creditors to immediately stop their collection activities
28 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
(including foreclosure) and prevents them from filing You may get to keep your car even if your
lawsuits, taking assets, or shutting off utilities. This equity significantly exceeds your state’s vehicle
delay might give you at least a few months to bring in exemption. The costs of taking and selling a car
the income you need to get current on your mortgage can be substantial, and a bankruptcy sale typically
or other secured debt, so you can keep the house or yields less than the car is worth. Recognizing this,
other collateral. After a month or two, however, secured the trustee is likely to give you an opportunity to
lenders can usually get the court’s permission to proceed “buy back” the car for substantially less than the
with a foreclosure, repossession, or collection. The nonexempt amount. For example, if your vehicle
automatic stay is discussed in detail in Ch. 4. exemption is $5,000, your car is worth $10,000,
and you own the car free and clear, the trustee
might let you keep the car for $2,000 cash, since
Your Vehicle the trustee would likely not receive any much more
If your car secures your car loan, and you default than that after deducting the costs of sale. If you
on the loan, the lender can repossess your car. decline this “generous” offer, the trustee will sell
Bankruptcy can delay the repossession for a while it, give you the exempt amount, and use the rest to
and give you a chance to get current on the loan. pay your creditors.
Ultimately, however, you’ll lose your car if you You’ll find more information on what happens
can’t make your payments. to your car and other personal property in
If your car doesn’t serve as collateral for a debt, bankruptcy in Ch. 6.
the trustee can still take it and sell it to pay your
unsecured creditors if your equity exceeds your
CAUTION
state’s vehicle exemption amount. Most states allow
Don’t pay off your car before you file for
you to keep one vehicle with equity up to a certain
bankruptcy. Many people are under the erroneous
amount—usually between $1,000 and $5,000.
impression that they get to keep one vehicle when they
Your state may also have a wildcard exemption
file for bankruptcy, no matter how much it’s worth.
you can apply to your car, either instead of or in
They do whatever they can to pay off their best car or
addition to the vehicle exemption.
truck before they file. This is exactly the wrong strategy,
Example: Carlos and Melyssa have two however. Because exemption laws protect only a limited
vehicles. One is a newish Dodge Sprinter on dollar amount, it’s usually better to owe money on your
which they are making payments; its value car when you go into bankruptcy. The less equity you
have in the car, the more likely it is to be protected by an
went down quite a bit in the last year, so they
exemption, which means you get to keep it (assuming
don’t have any equity in it. The other is a ten-
you can keep up the payments on it).
year-old car they own free and clear, worth
about $3,000.
When Carlos and Melyssa file for bankruptcy,
the Sprinter goes back to the lender because
Your Other Personal Property
they can’t afford the payments. The amount the Every state’s exemption laws allow you to keep a
lender is able to sell it for doesn’t cover what certain amount of essential personal property, such
they still owe on the loan, but the remaining as clothing, appliances, and furniture. As is true
debt (called a “deficiency”) will be wiped out in of vehicles, even if your personal property is worth
bankruptcy. Their state exempts up to $5,000 somewhat more than the exemption in your state,
worth of equity in a vehicle, so they get to keep the trustee is not likely to take it; the costs of a legal
their older car. sale are considerable, and used personal property
ChaPter 2 | How Chapter 7 Personal Bankruptcy works | 29
doesn’t typically bring a high price. Pensions and if the bankruptcy judge decides you made the
retirement accounts are also exempt, although some payment or transfer for fraudulent purposes, your
types of “retirement” annuities may not be. bankruptcy case could be dismissed.
If you own valuable nonexempt property, such as How far back the trustee can look depends on
expensive art, collectibles, boats, antiques, stocks, the type of transaction and your relationship to
bonds, and highly valuable jewelry, you should the other party to the transaction. The time limits
expect them to be taken and sold by the bankruptcy can be anywhere from a few months to four years.
trustee. See Ch. 6 for more information on how Ch. 5 covers fraudulent transfers and preference
your personal property is handled in bankruptcy. payments in detail.
may survive your bankruptcy, depending on the for bankruptcy. Which debts are and are not
circumstances. What happens to debts in Chapter discharged is covered in detail in Ch. 11; here are
7 bankruptcy is discussed in detail in Ch. 11. Here some of the most common types of debts that
is a brief overview. cannot be discharged in Chapter 7 bankruptcy:
• back child support, alimony, and other
Debts That Are Discharged domestic support obligations
• court-imposed fines, penalties, and restitution
Many of the debts that drive business owners to
• certain tax debts, including recent back taxes;
bankruptcy are dischargeable. This means that
any back taxes for which you didn’t file a tax
you are no longer responsible for paying them
return; trust fund taxes (the employee portion
once your Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy case is
of Social Security and Medicare taxes); and
complete. Once the trustee sells your nonexempt
debts you incurred to pay nondischargeable
assets (if you have any) and distributes the proceeds
taxes (for example, if you took a cash advance
among your unsecured creditors, then the court
on your credit card to pay your most recent
discharges any amount that remains unpaid on the
tax bill)
debts when your case ends.
• debts of more than $550 to any one creditor
Here are some common types of debts that are
for luxuries in the 90 days before you file
discharged in Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy:
(charges for reasonably necessary items don’t
• credit card bills
count)
• lawsuit judgments
• cash advances of more than $825 taken
• medical bills
within 70 days before you file
• unsecured business debts owed by a sole
• loans you owe to your pension plan (such as
proprietor, such as debts to suppliers,
money you borrowed from your 401(k))
consultants, and professionals (accountants or
• student loans, unless repaying them would
architects, for example)
constitute an extreme hardship (this is very
• obligations under leases and contracts
hard to prove)
entered into by a sole proprietor, including
• debts arising from your fraudulent activity
commercial and residential property leases
(for example, lying on a loan application),
and leases to rent equipment, and
if the creditor proves the fraud to the
• personal loans and promissory notes.
bankruptcy court’s satisfaction, and
Secured debts are handled differently. As
• debts resulting from an incident in which you
explained above (and in detail in Ch. 8), the lender
kill or injure someone while you are driving
can take back the collateral securing the loan if
under the influence.
you don’t make your payments, even if you file for
bankruptcy. If you owe more on a secured debt
Debts Owed By Others (Your
than the collateral is worth, the difference (called a
“deficiency”) is discharged in bankruptcy. But the Company, Partners, and Cosigners)
lender still has the right to take back the collateral Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy wipes out only
if you default. your debts (and possibly those of your spouse, as
explained in Ch. 1). It does not get rid of:
Debts That Survive Chapter 7 Bankruptcy • Debts owed by your corporation or LLC.
Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy discharges
Several types of debt are not dischargeable in
your personal liability for debts, but does not
Chapter 7, which means you will still owe them
affect your corporation’s or LLC’s liability. To
when your case is over, just as if you hadn’t filed
ChaPter 2 | How Chapter 7 Personal Bankruptcy works | 31
If you’ve concluded that Chapter 7 bankruptcy may vacation time-share, or similarly opulent purchase
be in the cards, there are certain actions you should on credit, the creditor can argue that the debt is
avoid taking. While it’s natural to try to come up with fraudulent, no matter when you took it on. And,
“creative” methods to pay down your debt or protect cash advances for more than $825 taken within 70
your assets, you can harm your bankruptcy case—or days before you file may also be deemed fraudulent
lose your right to file for bankruptcy altogether—if you (if the creditor can prove fraud, even smaller
do any of the following: advances will be suspect). In any of these situations,
• Hide assets. You may be tempted to give assets the debt won’t be discharged.
to your friends and relatives, change the title to • Pay off your unsecured debt or car loan. If you’re
property so it looks like you don’t own it, or “sell” planning to file for bankruptcy, don’t bother paying
property to loved ones for far less than it’s worth. debts that will be fully discharged. And, as discussed
Creditors’ attorneys and trustees are experienced above, you’re better off owing money on your car
in ferreting out these tactics, which can lead the when you go into bankruptcy; the more equity you
trustee to take the property back or even charge have in the car, the more likely you are to lose it.
you with fraud and prevent you from receiving a • Take property from your LLC or corporation.
discharge of your debt. If your corporation or LLC is insolvent, its assets
• Lie on loan applications. We know you need money belong to its creditors. If you take that property,
to stay afloat. But overstating the value of your you’re committing theft—which could result in the
assets, inflating your income, or failing to disclose dismissal of your bankruptcy case or even criminal
other debts on a loan application can lead to charges.
fraud charges. The bankruptcy court may refuse to • Pay yourself a bonus or back pay. The bankruptcy
discharge any debt that you took on through fraud. system treats you as an insider creditor. If you pay
• Make preference payments. As explained above, yourself a bonus, repay a loan you made to the
the trustee will take a close look at all payments you business, or pay yourself back wages in the year
made to creditors during the year before you file— before you file, these will be considered preference
and may take those payments back to distribute payments that the court can take back. It could also
among all of your creditors. Any payments above a be considered fraud, which might result in dismissal
certain threshold made within 90 days before you of your case or worse.
file might be considered a preference; if the payment • Let your insurance lapse. If you may stay in
was to an insider creditor (a relative or close business business, or you simply need to keep your liability
associate), the court can take payments made over insurance while you wind down, file for bankruptcy
the past year. just after you renew your policy. After you file, you
• Engage in shopping sprees and cash advances. may have a tough time finding a carrier willing to
If you buy luxury goods or services within three renew your coverage or issue a new policy. As long
months before filing, the trustee will assume as you continue your payments, your insurance can’t
that you intended to defraud the court and your be canceled just because of your bankruptcy.
creditors. If you really splurge and buy a new car,
32 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
take care of debts owed by the corporation Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy may be the best
or LLC, the business will have to file its own option for business owners who:
business bankruptcy (or settle them). • have personal liability—either alone or with a
• Debts owed by your partners in a partnership. spouse—for many of their business debts
Your Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy wipes • are willing to shut down their business if the
out your personal liability for partnership trustee requires it
debts, but your partner(s) will still be on the • don’t have much valuable, nonexempt
hook for the full amount. property
• Debts someone else cosigned. If someone else • aren’t concerned about leaving a partner or
cosigned a loan or otherwise took on a joint cosigner on the hook for debt
obligation with you, that person can be held • have mostly debts of the type that are
wholly responsible for the debt if you don’t discharged in Chapter 7, and
pay it. Your Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy • are willing to put up with a damaged credit
discharges only your personal liability for the rating, at least for a few years.
debt, not the debt itself. Your cosigner will After reading this far, you should have a pretty
still be stuck with it. good idea of whether Chapter 7 will work for
you. Before making a final decision, however,
you should evaluate other options for handling
Is Chapter 7 the Right Choice? your business debt. Ch. 3 covers some alternative
strategies and explains how they compare to
Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy can be a powerful
Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy.
solution to overwhelming business debts, but it isn’t
the right choice for everyone. As you now know,
l
3
C H A P T E R
C
hapter 7 personal bankruptcy is a powerful capital necessary to save it. In this situation, you
tool—but it isn’t the only strategy available are probably looking at closing your business with
for dealing with business debt. Depending a good-sized pile of debts—to landlords, suppliers,
on your situation, it might make more sense to try to utilities, service providers, and possibly a bank or
settle your debts outside of bankruptcy, use another private lender.
form of bankruptcy, or even just sit tight for a while You have several options for handling your
and see what happens. This chapter explains how personal liability for business debt in addition to
each of these alternatives compares to Chapter 7, so filing for Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy:
you can make sure that filing for Chapter 7 personal • Do nothing and see what happens. Some
bankruptcy is the right way to go. creditors may conclude that trying to collect
In some circumstances, you’ll need to consider from someone with a pile of debt and few
other options for handling business debt in assets isn’t worth the trouble.
addition to—rather than instead of—Chapter • Sell your business and use the proceeds to pay
7 personal bankruptcy. Chapter 7 personal off your business debts to the extent possible.
bankruptcy takes care of your personal liability • Close your business, sell its assets, and pay off
for business debts, but a separately structured your business debts to the extent possible.
business might have its own debt problems. For
example, perhaps you’ve decided to file for Chapter Do Nothing
7 personal bankruptcy to wipe out your personal
liability for certain corporate debts, but your One option that some business owners take, often
corporation also needs to take care of its liability as a result of sheer exhaustion rather than careful
for its own debts. Options for handling corporate planning, is to just wait and see what happens.
and LLC debt are covered briefly at the end of this Some creditors, perhaps realizing that the debtor
chapter. has nothing valuable to take, will give up their
collection efforts after sending a threatening letter
or two. On the other hand, some creditors will
Resource sue, get a judgment, and try to take your personal
Want detailed information on other assets to satisfy your debt. If you have nothing
strategies for handling debt? Pick up a copy of Save worth taking now, these creditors may simply wait
Your Small Business: 10 Crucial Strategies to Rescue and hope you get a job or acquire some valuable
Your Business or Close Down and Move On, by Ralph property in the future, when they’ll come back to
Warner, J.D, and Bethany Laurence, J.D. (Nolo). This collect.
valuable resource is filled with great ideas for dealing If you really are “judgment proof” (that is, you
with a struggling business, whether you decide to keep don’t have anything a creditor can take), you may
operating or shut your doors. You’ll also find more not need to file for bankruptcy. To figure out if
information on each of the options in this chapter. just doing nothing is a viable option, however, you
should understand what your creditors can do, and
what will happen to your property, if you go this
route.
If You Want to Close Your Business You can’t be thrown in jail for not paying your
As explained in Ch. 1 and Ch. 2, Chapter 7 debts (unless you refuse to pay child support
personal bankruptcy can be a good choice if you’ve that you are able to pay). And unless you owe
decided your business is not going to survive, back taxes or you’ve defaulted on a student loan,
or you aren’t interested in spending the effort or creditors can’t just take money out of your bank
ChaPter 3 | Other options for handling business debt | 35
account or intercept your tax refund. A creditor creditor will have the same repossession rights
with a secured debt can generally take back the discussed above. Also, some department store
collateral if you default on the loan (although in credit card contracts give the creditor a security
some states, a lender has to go to court before interest in the property you buy; if you don’t pay
foreclosing on a home mortgage). But most the bill, the creditor might try to repossess the
other creditors have to sue you and win a money property. However, because creditors must get
judgment against you before they can actually a court order to enter your home or business,
go after your property and wages. And even after repossession of personal property other than
they get a judgment, creditors can’t take property vehicles is rare, except for business property that’s
that’s exempt. Let’s look at how secured and valuable enough to justify the creditor’s time and
unsecured creditors can collect their debts. trouble.
Foreclosures. If you have a home equity line of
Secured Debts credit or you refinanced your mortgage to take
Lenders with secured debts generally have the cash out for your business, you must make your
right to take back the property that secures the payments on time to keep the house. If you don’t,
collateral if you default. Here are the rules for the lender can foreclose on the collateral for your
particular types of property. debt: your house. But foreclosures are not as
Vehicle repossessions. If you default on a car quick as vehicle repossessions. In about half of
loan secured by your car, the lender has the the states, a lender has to go to court for what’s
legal right to repossess it: to physically take the called a judicial foreclosure proceeding before
car and sell it to recover the money you owe, foreclosing when you default on a mortgage. In
plus the costs of the sale and attorney’s fees. the other states, the lender has to at least give you
The lender doesn’t have to get permission or a some advance notice before foreclosing. Either
court judgment. You will still owe the difference way, it can take several months to a year or more
between what the lender can get for the car to lose your house, which gives you time to save
(typically only a fraction of what it’s worth) and some money and, if necessary, find a new place
what you owed on the loan, called a “deficiency.” to live.
To collect a deficiency, the lender will have to If you pledged your house as collateral for a
sue you and obtain a money judgment. As with business loan or line of credit and you default
other unsecured debts, this debt can be wiped on that loan, the lender can also foreclose on
out in a Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy. Absent your house. In this situation, however, the lender
bankruptcy, the repossession will appear on your must always file a foreclosure action in court, no
credit report for seven years. matter what state you live in. To avoid having the
Vehicle leases usually also give the dealer the lender foreclose, you must either repay the debt
right to take the car without a court order, but or, if the debt exceeds your equity in the house,
the dealer will have to take you to court for any at least pay the lender the amount of your equity
damages owed as a result of your breach of the so that it no longer has a reason to foreclose.
lease if it wants to collect them.
Other repossessions. Vehicles are the most
Resource
commonly repossessed type of property, but
the same procedures apply to other property. Foreclosure information. For up-to-date
For example, if you borrowed money to buy information about your options if you are facing
foreclosure, see The Foreclosure Survival Guide, by
business equipment or machinery and pledged
attorney Stephen Elias (Nolo).
the equipment as security for the loan, the
36 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
If You Are Underwater on Your Line pay the judgment. Unless there’s a lot of money at
of Credit or Second Mortgage stake, and you have or anticipate getting significant
cash or valuable assets the creditor could go after,
It’s not uncommon for homes to be worth far less the creditor might not bother to sue you at all.
than the total of all the liens against them. Assume, Before seriously considering a lawsuit, a creditor
for example, that Juliet’s home is worth $200,000 usually tries to collect the debt for several months,
but she owes $250,000 on a first mortgage. She and then turns it over to a collection agency or
has no equity in her house. In addition, to keep attorney, who will restart the process with a series
her freelance engineering business in operation,
of demand letters and phone calls. If you don’t
she took out $50,000 on a line of credit back when
pay, the creditor may decide that it isn’t worth
her home was worth $400,000. If Juliet defaults on
the trouble to sue. Let’s say, for example, that
her line of credit, the lender of the credit line has
your consulting business has few assets and is
no foreclosure remedy; if the house were taken
doing poorly, your house is worth less than you
and sold, all the proceeds would go to the first
owe on your mortgage, and your income now
mortgage holder. If defaulting on a line of credit
comes mostly from Social Security (which can’t be
or second mortgage would help you stay current
on your first mortgage, the default would be a
taken to pay debts). A creditor, or any collection
relatively safe strategy to stay in your house. Of attorney or agency your debt is turned over to,
course, the secondary lender will still have a lien might look at these circumstances, decide there’s
on the home that it can enforce if you attempt no point trying to collect from you, and write off
to sell it or if the home appreciates in value. Also, your debt as a deductible business loss. Typically,
the secondary lender could sue you for breach of in four to six years (depending on your state’s
contract, but that may be the least of your worries. statute of limitations), the debt will become legally
uncollectible.
You can, however, expect to be sued if there is
Right to offset. If you owe money to a bank on significant money at stake and you have valuable
a loan or credit line, and you have other accounts personal or business assets (or the creditor expects
at the same bank (such as a checking or saving you to get some in the future). For instance, if
account), the bank can take cash from your account your dress shop is failing but you have an MBA,
to pay off the debt without getting a court order. your creditor might assume you’ll eventually make
This is called a “setoff” or an “offset.” So, if you’re a good salary. If so, chances are the creditor will
about to default on a loan, it makes sense to move sue you, get a judgment, and wait for you to start
your other accounts to another institution first. earning again. In many states, a court judgment
can be collected for at least ten years.
Unsecured Debts
How Creditors Can Collect on a Judgment
As we’ve mentioned, most unsecured creditors—
including credit card companies, doctors, lawyers, It can be even harder for a creditor to collect
contractors, and suppliers—must sue you and win a judgment than to win it in the first place.
a money judgment before they can collect. To sue Theoretically, if a creditor has gone to court and
you, a creditor has to hire and pay a lawyer, pay won a judgment to collect an unsecured debt, the
court fees, and wait around for up to a year to win creditor will be able to take your business assets,
the lawsuit (unless you fail to respond, in which business income, and any cash in your business
case the creditor can obtain a default judgment bank account to pay off the debt. The creditor can
very quickly). In either case, the creditor then may also get a court to order customers and clients to
have to wait a while if you don’t have any assets to pay any money they owe to your business directly
ChaPter 3 | Other options for handling business debt | 37
to the court (although this collection device is If you have time remaining on a residential
rarely used). or commercial lease when you move out, your
If you’re a sole proprietor or partner, or you landlord can sue you for the remaining months’
signed a personal guarantee for a debt, the judg rent. However, in most states the landlord is
ment creditor can also garnish your wages (and in obligated to try to find a new tenant to minimize
community property states, your spouse’s wages) the loss. This is called “mitigating the damages.”
and take money from your personal bank account, If the landlord can rent the place for at least what
as well as your nonexempt personal property, to you were paying, you are off the hook for the
pay off the debt. remaining rent. However, the landlord can charge
Of course, all of this is possible only if you have you rent for the time the space was vacant, plus the
nonexempt property or income to take, the creditor costs of finding a new tenant. If the landlord is not
finds it, and the creditor then gets a court order able to find a replacement tenant with reasonable
and pays the sheriff, marshal, or constable to take effort, you will be on the hook for the rent for
it. Many creditors won’t go to these lengths to get the remainder of the lease. (This debt can be
your property. Instead, if your business owns real discharged in Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy.)
estate, valuable equipment, or other tangible assets, You may be able to negotiate a lease termination
the creditor will simply file a judgment lien against with your landlord in exchange for paying an extra
that property (or any valuable personal property or month or two of rent. Your landlord will probably
real estate that you own, if you are personally liable be happy to arrive at a negotiated solution rather
for the debt). The lien allows the creditor to collect than risk getting nothing if you file for bankruptcy.
when you or the business sells or refinances the If you have a month-to-month rental rather than
property. a lease, you can simply give your landlord written
A creditor cannot take exempt property. As notice that you’re terminating your agreement. If
explained in Ch. 2, certain types of property you are current in your rent payments, you won’t
are exempt and cannot be taken and sold in owe anything. You’ll probably have to give 30 days’
Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy. Depending on notice, but some commercial agreements require
your state’s exemption laws, the types of property more. Check your lease or rental agreement.
you get to keep include your clothing, furniture,
appliances, and other necessities; your retirement
or pension plan; some equity in a car; and some Tip
equity in a home (you can find lists of each state’s Negotiate your way out of an equipment
exemptions in Appendix A). For the most part, lease before you return the equipment. If you return
these exemptions apply whether or not you file for equipment before your lease term ends, the same rule
bankruptcy. In other words, just as the bankruptcy usually applies: You will be liable for the remainder of
trustee can’t take this property and sell it for the the payments in the lease term (or at least for an early
benefit of your creditors, your creditors can’t take it return penalty). Try to negotiate a better deal while
directly, either. you’ve still got the equipment. For example, you might
offer to return two forklifts to the leasing company along
Special Rules for Leases with two months’ additional payments, in exchange for a
complete release of further obligations. If lots of money
Back rent is treated like any other unsecured debt, is at stake and the leasing company won’t cooperate,
but if you don’t pay your rent, you can be evicted having a lawyer call, possibly with the suggestion that
in fairly short order. And a commercial eviction you may file for bankruptcy, can be a huge help. The
happens even faster than a residential eviction, leasing company will want its property back as soon as
often in just a few weeks.
38 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
possible, without having to wait for months and deal impossible to arrange even a bargain-basement
with the bankruptcy court. sale. But there are exceptions. A business with a
great reputation, market position, or location might
find a buyer even when profits have disappeared.
Doing Nothing Compared to Chapter 7 Businesses that have been historically profitable
Ignoring your creditors and hoping they will usually retain at least some value, even when they
ignore you in return might be tempting, but think stop making money.
hard before you go this route. If your debts are Your competitors are the most likely buyers.
significant—and especially if you have valuable They know that buying up your customers, and
nonexempt property such as equity in real estate or perhaps your equipment and employees, will allow
the prospect of earning a decent wage—creditors them to corner the local market, gaining significant
are likely to sue you and try to collect their judg pricing power. Talk to a local business broker to see
ment. Doing nothing probably also means that if you might be able to sell your business.
you’ll spend the next couple of years hounded by
collection agencies, repossessors, lawyers, lawsuits,
and wage garnishments. Resource
If you file for Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy, Information on selling. The Complete Guide
you can wipe out many types of business debt. to Selling Your Business, by Fred Steingold (Nolo), is a
If you truly are “judgment proof,” most of the helpful companion for those planning to sell. It will help
property you own is probably exempt, which means you decide whether it makes more sense to approach
likely purchasers yourself or hire a business broker to
you won’t lose it if you file for bankruptcy. Plus,
do it for you, and it takes you through a typical sales
filing for bankruptcy allows you to resolve all of
contract clause by clause, identifying the key issues you’ll
your outstanding debt issues now; you won’t have
need to negotiate.
to worry about collection actions in the future. If
you later acquire valuable property or get a high-
paying job, you won’t have to feel anxious that Selling Your Business Compared
you’ll lose your assets to creditors. to Chapter 7 Bankruptcy
In short, it almost always makes more sense to
file for Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy than to take Most business owners won’t have the option to sell
a “wait and see” approach. Only those who have their business, simply because they won’t be able to
few assets, little prospect of employment, and a find a buyer. If you’re one of the lucky few who is
high tolerance for uncertainty should even consider able to sell, it can be a better option than filing for
ignoring their debts. bankruptcy—as long as you are able to wipe out
your personal liability for your business debts by
paying off or settling all the business’s debts with
Sell Your Business
the sales proceeds.
Some debtors get out of business not by closing
down, but by selling their business as a going
concern. CAUTION
Disclose all debts, liabilities, and problems
Is Selling an Option? with your business. If you are contemplating selling
In the best of times, it can be tough to sell a your business, be careful that you don’t misrepresent its
profitable small business. When times are tough financial condition or cash flow. If the buyer is unable
and a business is losing money, it can be nearly to turn a profit, he or she may turn around and sue you
ChaPter 3 | Other options for handling business debt | 39
for fraud. If the buyer wins this type of lawsuit, you will of what your business owes as full settlement of
have to return the sales proceeds and you probably the debt. But if you owe a debt personally and
won’t be able to discharge that debt if you later file for have valuable personal assets, or worse, a wealthy
bankruptcy. Because the outcome of fraud lawsuits is friend or relative cosigned for it, the creditor has
always uncertain, be absolutely clear about the business’s much more leverage and will likely demand a larger
financial problems—or file for Chapter 7 bankruptcy portion of the amount owed. In our experience, if
instead of selling. you can pay 30% to 70% cash on the barrelhead,
you may be able to interest your creditors in a deal.
Liquidate Your Business Example: Quinn runs Read More Books LLC,
and Settle Your Debts which sells new books upstairs and used books
downstairs. It has a loyal following, but when
Rather than trying to sell their business as a the economic downturn hits the book industry
going concern, some business owners close the especially hard, Quinn can’t earn enough to
business down, sell its assets, and then use the pay her expenses. When she decides to close
proceeds (perhaps along with some personal assets) the business, she owes three publishers a total
to negotiate settlements with their creditors, often of $80,000, owes $4,000 to her landlord on
for a fraction of what they owe. By liquidating your the month-to-month lease that she personally
business on your own rather than allowing the guaranteed, and has $1,000 in utility bills.
bankruptcy trustee to do it, you will likely get more She gives her landlord the required 30 days’
money for your assets (and therefore, have more notice. She returns as much book inventory as
money to pay your creditors) than a bankruptcy possible to the publishers, reducing the amount
trustee could get, and you won’t have a bankruptcy she owes them to $40,000, and notifies them
on your credit report for the next ten years. in writing that she’s going out of business. Of
course, they call her immediately to press for
How Liquidation and Settlement Works
payment on their invoices, but Quinn says
To liquidate your business, you shut down, sell she’ll get back to them.
the assets, then contact your creditors and try to She then sells off her used book inventory
settle your debts. When you negotiate with your as well as her bookshelves, cash registers, and
creditors, you will be asking them to accept partial computers (mostly to a competitor, the rest on
payment of the debt as payment in full—and craigslist), leaving her with $25,000 in cash.
to give you a full written release of your liability She pays her landlord the $4,000 past due—
for the debt. Why would a creditor agree to this? this is a high priority debt for her because she
Because it often makes more sense than suing you personally guaranteed the lease—and writes
and trying to chase down your remaining assets checks to the utility companies. She has
while hoping you don’t file for bankruptcy (which $20,000 left. Quinn then writes to each of the
would probably leave your creditors with nothing). publishers offering a final payment of 50 cents
How little will your creditors settle for? It on the dollar ($20,000 to satisfy her debts of
depends on the type of creditor, the legal details of $40,000). She makes the offer contingent upon
the debt, and the creditor’s attitude. For example, all of the publishers’ signing a written release
if your business is an LLC or corporation and you that releases Read More Books LLC, Quinn,
haven’t personally guaranteed its debts, a creditor and her spouse from any liability for the debts.
will know that it can’t collect from you personally, The publishers know that Read More Books is
so it may be more willing to accept a small fraction an LLC, which means that Quinn can walk
40 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
lawyer, it can costs thousands of dollars in attorney unless the business can recover after being shut
fees as well. down while your bankruptcy is pending, perhaps
In addition, you may not be able to convince all three to six months.
of your creditors to settle their debts, or you may If you can raise enough money after filing for
not have sufficient assets to make it worth their bankruptcy, or you are willing to give the trustee
while. In this situation, you’re probably better off some exempt property, you might be able to
filing for bankruptcy in the first place and having buy back some of your business assets from the
all of your debt wiped out, rather than paying out bankruptcy trustee to start a new business. But the
money to some creditors that you could have saved business you once ran will most likely be liquidated
by filing for bankruptcy or that the trustee could and long gone.
treat as a preference. If you run a sole proprietor service business that
has few assets and no essential location, and you
aren’t likely to incur new debt during bankruptcy,
Resource the trustee might let you to stay in business. A
Information on settling your debts. For trustee might allow a small service business, such as
help negotiating with your creditors, making settlement a bookkeeping, graphic design, or massage therapy
offers, and getting signed agreements that release you business, to continue during the owner’s Chapter
from liability, read Save Your Small Business: 10 Crucial 7 personal bankruptcy if the business can be
Strategies to Rescue Your Business or Close Down and operated without using up or damaging assets that
Move On, by Ralph Warner, J.D, and Bethany Laurence, should be taken and sold to repay creditors. In that
J.D. (Nolo). case, Chapter 7 bankruptcy may be a fine solution
for you.
But if you own a larger business and want to
If You Want to Continue keep operating without interruption (or having
to try to buy back your business assets from the
Your Business bankruptcy trustee), you’ll have to file for another
Most readers of this book will be planning to shut type of bankruptcy or try to negotiate and settle
down. Their businesses are in such poor shape, your debts through a “workout”: a plan you reach
with so much debt, that the best strategy is close with all of your creditors to settle your business’s
their doors, settle their debts or discharge them in debts outside of court.
bankruptcy, and move on to new opportunities.
But some business owners will want to continue Other Types of Bankruptcy
operations after getting some relief from their Chapter 7 bankruptcy is sometimes called
debts. This is most common when the owner “liquidation” bankruptcy because the trustee has
believes the business could succeed once one or two the right to take and sell (liquidate) the debtor’s
missteps are corrected. For example, perhaps the nonexempt property, in exchange for wiping out
underlying business could be profitable if not for most debt. Chapter 7 provides a true clean slate: In
debts resulting from an ill-timed expansion. just a few months, the debt is gone and the debtor
As explained in Ch. 1 and Ch. 2, most business has a fresh start.
owners who file for Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy In contrast, other types of bankruptcy—
will have to shut down: If your business sells or including Chapter 11, Chapter 12, and Chapter 13
manufactures products and/or owns significant —are referred to as “reorganization” bankruptcies.
assets, you probably won’t be able to continue the These procedures allow a person or a business (or
same business after Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy,
42 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
in the case of Chapter 12, a farm) to put creditors owe your creditors over time. The length of your
on hold while the bankruptcy filer comes up with repayment plan will depend on your income. If
a plan to repay debts over the next few years. In a your average monthly income in the six months
reorganization bankruptcy, the debtor doesn’t have before you file for bankruptcy is less than or
to give up any property. Instead, the debtor uses equal to the median income for your state, your
income to repay debts. If the debtor makes all of repayment plan need not last more than three
the payments required by the repayment plan, most years. But if your income is more than the state
debts that remain after the plan ends are wiped median, your plan must last long enough to repay
out. all of your debt, or five years, whichever is shorter.
(See “The Means Test,” in Ch. 2, for information
on calculating your income and comparing it to
See an Expert the state median.)
If your debt comes primarily from the Your repayment plan must devote all of your
operation of a family farm, Chapter 12 might be the anticipated disposable income to repaying your
answer. Because it won’t be available to most businesses, debts over the repayment plan period. In Chapter
we don’t cover Chapter 12 here. For more information 13 bankruptcy, you must pay some debts in full
on Chapter 12 bankruptcy, speak to a lawyer with (back taxes, child support, and short-term secured
experience in this area. loans are the most common examples). For your
other debts, the rule is that your unsecured
creditors must receive at least as much as they
Chapter 13 Bankruptcy
would have gotten if you had filed for Chapter
Chapter 13 bankruptcy is the only type of 7 bankruptcy. That is, you will have to pay out
reorganization bankruptcy that’s appropriate for an amount equal to the value of your nonexempt
most small business owners. In Chapter 13, you property (the property that the trustee could have
use your income to fund a repayment plan that taken and sold in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy). If
lasts from three to five years. If you make all of the you have a lot of nonexempt assets, you’ll have to
payments required by the plan, most remaining pay more toward your debts during your Chapter
debts are discharged when the plan ends. 13 repayment plan, unless you voluntarily sell
Only individuals can file for Chapter 13. You the assets and make the proceeds available to the
can use Chapter 13 to rid yourself of business debts trustee.
for which you have personal liability (for example, If you successfully complete the repayment plan,
if you are a sole proprietor or you have taken on most categories of remaining debt are wiped out.
personal liability for some corporate or LLC debts), The same categories of debt that are discharged in
but a corporation, an LLC, or a partnership cannot Chapter 7 are also discharged in Chapter 13. And,
file for Chapter 13 as an entity. Also, Chapter 13 some debts that aren’t dischargeable in Chapter
bankruptcy is available only to those who have 7 bankruptcy can be discharged in Chapter 13,
unsecured debt of up to $336,900 and secured including:
debts of up to $1,010,650; those with higher debt • cash advances for more than $825 taken
totals can’t use Chapter 13. within 70 days before filing for bankruptcy
• recent debts for luxuries
How Chapter 13 Works • loans owed to a pension plan or 401(k)
In a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, you don’t necessarily • marital debts (other than for spousal support)
lose any property. Instead, you use a portion of created in a divorce or settlement agreement
your future income to pay some or all of what you
ChaPter 3 | Other options for handling business debt | 43
• debts taken out to pay a nondischargeable tax 13 versus $299 for Chapter 7), you will almost
debt, and certainly need a lawyer to file for Chapter 13,
• court fees. which can cost thousands of dollars. In addition,
you’ll usually be required to repay at least some
Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Compared to Chapter 7 of your unsecured debt (although some courts
Unfortunately, Chapter 13 bankruptcy doesn’t approve what are known as 0% plans, in which
work for most small business owners. Overall, only unsecured creditors receive nothing), something
about 35% of all Chapter 13 filers complete their you wouldn’t have to do in Chapter 7. What’s
repayment plans. And for entrepreneurs, it’s even more, a Chapter 7 bankruptcy case is over in a
harder. If you decide to continue your business matter of months, compared to the three to five
during your Chapter 13 plan, you’ll be operating years you’ll spend in Chapter 13.
under the scrutiny of the bankruptcy trustee For all of these reasons, Chapter 7 personal
and devoting all of your money to paying off the bankruptcy is almost always the better choice for
business’s debts—often an impossible task for an business owners. Rather than trying to continue
enterprise struggling to stay afloat. your debt-ridden existing business under the close
It’s difficult to run a business while in bankruptcy. supervision of the bankruptcy court, it usually
All of your personal and business property is under makes more sense to close down, file a Chapter 7
the bankruptcy court’s control. You must get personal bankruptcy to deal with your debts, and
court permission to borrow money or to buy or then start a new—but similar—business free of
sell business assets (other than typical, day-to-day debt.
operating decisions). You can’t use credit cards, This isn’t always the case, however. For some
and you have to submit monthly reports to the business owners, Chapter 13 might make more
bankruptcy trustee. If business picks up or you sense than Chapter 7:
take on a side job, the extra money will have to go • Those who can’t pass the means test or are
toward your debts. otherwise ineligible to use Chapter 7 will have
It might be even harder for a business owner to use Chapter 13 to get bankruptcy relief.
to keep up with plan payments for three to five (The means test is covered in Ch. 2 and Ch. 9.)
years. You need to make every plan payment on • Those who want to keep an asset-rich business
time, even if your income is seasonal or fluctuates open during bankruptcy shouldn’t use Chap-
with the economy. If you can’t keep up with your ter 7, because the trustee will likely shut the
payments, the bankruptcy judge can modify the business down and sell its assets. (However,
plan to some extent. However, if it appears that these business owners might be best served by
you won’t be able to make at least the payments avoiding bankruptcy altogether and trying to
required by the bankruptcy code, the judge will settle their debts, as discussed below.)
likely convert your case to a Chapter 7 bankruptcy • Debtors might choose Chapter 13 if they
or dismiss it. If your case is dismissed, you’ll owe don’t want to lose particular, perhaps unique,
your creditors the balance of your debts: what you nonexempt assets that they would lose in a
owed at the start of your bankruptcy case, plus the Chapter 7 bankruptcy. (This is a tricky area
interest that stopped accruing while you were in and you should probably go over the details
bankruptcy, less whatever you paid through your with a lawyer).
repayment plan. • Debtors might want to use Chapter 13 if
Chapter 13 typically costs more—and always they have significant debts that wouldn’t
takes longer—than Chapter 7. Although the filing be discharged in Chapter 7, but would be
fees are comparable (currently, $274 for Chapter discharged in Chapter 13.
44 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
charge less than a $10,000 retainer just to get things But making a workout work isn’t easy, primarily
started, and the expenses for creditor attorneys can because you’ll have to come up with some money
be astronomical; lengthy meetings and negotiations for your creditors.
are necessary in a Chapter 11 bankruptcy, and the Because your business probably doesn’t have the
attorney fee meter is always ticking. As a result, a cash available to pay off your creditors in a lump
business that limps into Chapter 11 bankruptcy sum, you would need to get a loan, attract new
often feeds its meager remaining operating capital equity investment, or pay your creditors regular
to attorneys, accountants, appraisers, and other installments from your business’s income. All of
professionals to come up with a plan the court these options are fairly difficult for a struggling
will confirm. Unless the business can obtain a business to pull off. Finding a lender or an
loan to finance its bankruptcy (called “debtor- investor who’s willing to invest money in a small
in-possession” financing), once the business’s company on the verge of bankruptcy may be next
money is gone, the case is typically converted to to impossible, unless you can find a sympathetic
Chapter 7 business bankruptcy where the business friend or family member with cash to spare.
is liquidated and the proceeds distributed under If your business plans to pay your creditors from
various bankruptcy priority rules. future cash flow, you have to find a way to turn the
business around, stop losing money, and eventually
Chapter 11 Compared to Chapter 7 become profitable. And, your plan will have to be
Chapter 11 is rarely the right choice for a small convincing to creditors. They won’t accept more of
business. You should consider it only if your business the same: They’ll want to see that something big is
has enough income—and the ability to swing going to change in a way that’s likely to turn your
debtor-in-possession financing—to both stay in fortunes around (for example, that you are picking
business and pay tens or even hundreds of thousands up a major new customer or a new revenue stream
of dollars in legal fees to successfully emerge from from a new service). You’ll have to show that you
the bankruptcy intact. If you are interested in can earn enough to pay your current expenses and
Chapter 11 bankruptcy, speak to an attorney who make your installment payments on your debt, too.
is experienced in Chapter 11 filings. If you receive If you’re interested in attempting a workout
advice that a Chapter 11 is your best option, either that goes beyond asking for an installment plan,
for your business or for you personally, make sure you will no doubt need a business lawyer to help
you understand exactly where the money will come you negotiate; otherwise, your creditors probably
from to pay the various players—including the one won’t take you seriously. A lawyer can explain the
trying to talk you into Chapter 11. situation to your creditors and the consequences of
not cooperating. A lawyer can also help you offer
Workouts creditors more creative options. For instance, if
you need to keep doing business with a particular
A workout is sort of like a Chapter 13 repayment
creditor, you can offer a lien on your inventory,
plan, without the bankruptcy court. In a workout,
equipment, or accounts receivable. Even offering a
you negotiate with all of your business’s creditors to
small ownership stake in your corporation or LLC
settle the business’s debts out of court.
can work. A lawyer can explain these options and
How a Workout Works will probably offer more ideas as well.
least temporarily. So, if you are determined to stay bankruptcy. Even if the owners of a corporation or
in business and you can come up with the money, an LLC file for personal bankruptcy to wipe out
either up front or in installments, to bring your their personal liability (if any) for the business’s
creditors on board, a workout may be your best debts, the corporation or LLC itself will still owe
option. However, a couple of cautions are in order the debts that the business incurred. Corporations
if you’re considering this route: and LLCs have a few options here:
• You won’t have the protection of the bankruptcy • Allow the corporation or LLC to simply lapse.
court. Remember that, if you file for either Creditors to whom you have also obligated
Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 bankruptcy, yourself personally will likely go after your
creditors won’t be able to take your property personal assets. If you don’t have much
or demand that you pay them back during they can take, however, these creditors may
your bankruptcy case. Because a workout is conclude that it’s more sensible to just write
an out-of-court solution, your creditors can off their debts.
pull the plug on your settlement or repayment • Assign the corporate or LLC assets to a
plan if you’re late with a payment or you liquidation company or law firm, which will
can’t come up with your installment for the pay off your creditors (called an assignment
month. So be very certain that you can meet for the benefit of creditors).
your obligations under the workout plan • File for Chapter 7 business bankruptcy.
before you start.
• Make sure you can afford it. Before you agree Allow Your Corporation or LLC to Lapse
to obligate yourself to pay back all of your
If you file for personal bankruptcy to wipe out your
business debt, take a long, hard look at
own liability for your corporation or LLC’s debts—
your business’s chances of success. Are you
or you aren’t personally liable for any of those debts
really going to earn enough to pay off all of
in the first place—there’s probably no reason to
your debt, pay your operating expenses, and
file a business bankruptcy case. Instead, you can
make a living? Is keeping this business open
use the business’s remaining assets to pay off its
worth obligating yourself to years of debt
debts to the extent possible, and then just dissolve
repayment? Keep in mind that if you file for
your corporation or LLC. You do this by filing
bankruptcy, you could wipe out much of
dissolution documents with your state’s corporate
your debt rather than paying it back. And
or LLC office; that office will have the proper form,
if you spend months or even years faithfully
usually called a certificate of dissolution, certificate
following your workout plan and then can’t
of cancellation, articles of dissolution, or something
keep up the payments, you may end up in
similar. By dissolving your entity, you ensure that
bankruptcy anyway—and all of the debt you
you are no longer liable for paying annual fees,
repaid could have simply been erased instead.
filing annual reports, and paying business taxes.
If a corporation or an LLC owes debts when
Options for Dealing With it’s dissolved, and it owns cash or assets, the
owners (and the directors and officers) have a
Corporate and LLC Debt
statutory duty to pay off the business’s debts to
Because corporations and LLCs are legal entities the extent possible. Only after you have paid all
separate from their owners, they will owe the debts creditor claims and repaid all loans can you legally
of the business after they close down unless those distribute any remaining cash and assets to the
debts are paid, settled, or discharged in a business owners. If your corporation or LLC distributes its
ChaPter 3 | Other options for handling business debt | 47
assets to its owners without following the proper LLC’s debt), winding down a corporation or LLC, and
procedures to notify and pay back creditors, filing dissolution papers, read Save Your Small Business: 10
creditors can sue the business owners personally Crucial Strategies to Rescue Your Business or Close Down
after the corporation or LLC dissolves. In addition, and Move On, by Ralph Warner, J.D, and Bethany Laurence,
some states won’t allow the corporation or LLC J.D. (Nolo). It has a comprehensive chapter on how to
to dissolve until it has repaid its debts. The state avoid personal liability while closing down a business.
corporate and LLC registration lists are full of
business that have been suspended: They have debts
that can’t be paid, which prevents them from being Assignment for Benefit of Creditors
dissolved. You (and your co-owners, if you have them) may
You could simply sell the remaining assets of the feel you don’t have the knowledge or time necessary
business, use the proceeds to pay business creditors to liquidate the corporation or LLC’s assets and
on a pro rata basis, and then officially dissolve pay off the business’s debts. If your corporation or
the entity. But it’s a better idea to insist on signed LLC has a significant amount of debt, it can take
releases from all creditors, releasing the business many months to wind things down—and you may
and its owners from liability for the debt. As need to spend your time earning some money. For
explained in “Liquidate Your Business and Settle many business owners, it makes more sense to hire
Your Debts,” above, creditors are often willing to someone else for the job.
sign releases so they can recover at least part of You could hire a local lawyer to negotiate for
what you owe them, especially if the request comes you. Or, you could make an “assignment for the
from a lawyer. Assigning your assets to a law firm benefit of creditors” (ABC). In this process, you
or liquidation company can also avoid personal hire one of the many ABC companies or law firms
lawsuits, as can putting the corporation or LLC that specialize in liquidating insolvent businesses.
through a business bankruptcy, both of which are The company or law firm (called the assignee) sells
discussed below. the company’s assets and pays off its creditors while
you and your co-owners move on with your lives.
The assignee collects a percentage of the funds it
CAUTION
is able to distribute to your creditors after selling
Don’t cheat your creditors. The directors and
your assets, much like a bankruptcy trustee. ABC
officers of an insolvent corporation or LLC (one whose
companies or firms are regulated by state law, so
assets are worth less than its liabilities) have a legal duty
the details vary depending on the location of your
to minimize losses to the company’s creditors. This
business.
obligation includes the duty to try to get fair market
value for business assets. You commit fraud if you give
Here’s how it works in general terms: In an
away or sell business assets at below market rates, or put ABC, your business assigns (transfers) all of its
your interests ahead of those of creditors. In other words, assets and debts to the assignee. The assignee
forget about selling assets cheaply and pocketing the then owns the business assets and is liable for its
cash or giving assets to friends or family. debts, just as your business was. The assignment
makes it easier for the ABC firm to sell assets and
negotiate with creditors, because the firm doesn’t
Resource have to consult with you every time it wants to do
Information on dissolving your corporation something. Instead, the firm can sell the assets and
or LLC. For help in giving proper notice (which will reduce settle the debts as it sees fit, motivated to get top
the chance of personal liability for the corporation or dollar by its commission payment structure.
48 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
Example: Emile’s French Laundry, Inc., has intellectual property your business owns—your
been suffering from poor sales for the past business name, customer lists, and trademarked
year as restaurants have cut back on their linen product names or patents—which a bankruptcy
requirements. French Laundry’s accounts trustee usually won’t even try to do. If you haven’t
payable list is growing, creditors are demanding also filed for Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy, you
payment, and the company will be out of cash will still be personally liable for debts you have
within a few months. Emile decides to close personally guaranteed, so you will want to make
down and wants help paying off the many sure the assignee understands the importance of
debts French Laundry owes. settling these debts and getting rid of your personal
Emile consults with a few ABC firms liability to repay them.
and finds one with experience liquidating Assigning your debts to an assignee is quicker
companies that have made big investments in than liquidating your business yourself, and it can
commercial equipment. Because this ABC firm also be faster than a business bankruptcy. To learn
may be more likely to get top dollar for French more about ABCs, speak to a local business lawyer
Laundry’s equipment, Emile signs a contract or search online.
with the firm (now called the assignee) and
provides a list of the company’s creditors and Chapter 7 Business Bankruptcy
business assets.
Like hiring a lawyer to help you negotiate debt
First, the assignee investigates whether
settlements or making an assignment for the
Emile’s company can be sold as a going
benefit of creditors, filing for business bankruptcy
concern. If not, it will send a letter to all
means someone else steps in to liquidate your
creditors, telling them that the assignment has
business’s assets and settle its debts (in this case, the
been made and providing a form each creditor
bankruptcy trustee).
can use to submit a claim to the assignee. At
the same time, the assignee advertises the assets
for sale in industry publications and, using Tip
its contacts, searches for another company
One-owner LLCs or corporations may not
that might be willing to pay a fee to take over
need business bankruptcy. If you are the sole owner
Emile’s lease. It also publishes a press release
of a corporation or LLC, filing for Chapter 7 personal
stating that it has acquired the assets of French bankruptcy may be the solution to both your and your
Laundry, Inc. After all of the assets have been business’s debt problems. In this case, the bankruptcy
liquidated, the assignee takes a percentage of trustee might decide to take over your corporation or
the proceeds as its fee, and then distributes the LLC and liquidate and dissolve the business for you. Your
rest to the creditors, based on their claims. In Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy would free you of any
six months, it’s all done—and Emile has been personal liability for the business’s debts.
free to spend that time on other pursuits.
This option may work better than doing it A corporation or an LLC files a Chapter 7
yourself or working with a local lawyer, but only business bankruptcy, a different animal than a
if your business has a lot of debts and assets. An Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy. Filing a business
assignee can often get more for your assets than bankruptcy lets the owners turn their business
you could on your own (and certainly more than over to the trustee for an orderly liquidation. The
a bankruptcy trustee could get). An assignee can business stops operating, and the court liquidates
also often monetize hard-to-sell assets such as the its assets and pays what it can to business creditors.
ChaPter 3 | Other options for handling business debt | 49
Exemptions don’t apply in a business bankruptcy, fee, because the trustee is paid on commission:
so the trustee can take anything the business owns: The more of your business property and assets
The entire company is liquidated. the trustee can liquidate and distribute to your
When the liquidation is complete and the creditors, the more the trustee is paid. This money
proceeds have been paid out to creditors, the comes out of what the creditors would otherwise
business won’t owe any remaining debts. Lease get, however; you don’t have to pay it directly.
obligations, contracts, utility bills, credit cards, The real added expense in a business bankruptcy
loans, overdue accounts, and all other business is attorney fees. You must hire a lawyer to file for
debts will have been paid to the extent possible business bankruptcy; you can’t do it yourself.
by the bankruptcy trustee. If creditors aren’t fully In a business bankruptcy, the trustee will
paid, that’s their tough luck. The business owners undoubtedly sell your assets for less than you (or
are off the hook unless they are personally liable for an ABC firm) could get for them, and the process
the debts. won’t be private. In contrast, if you sell your
In theory, the business owners receive anything business’s assets and settle the business’s debts
left over after the creditors are paid. Typically, yourself (or with the help of a lawyer or ABC
however, a business that files for Chapter 7 business firm), there may be little reason to file for business
bankruptcy has liabilities that exceed its assets, and bankruptcy. As long as you aren’t personally liable
there is nothing left for the owners. for any remaining debts—or you file a personal
Chapter 7 bankruptcy to wipe out that liability—
you are off the legal hook, your business is closed,
CAUTION and the debts can’t be collected.
Business bankruptcy does not erase personal
liability. If you are personally liable for corporate or
LLC debts, you’ll still be on the hook even after your CAUTION
business’s liability is discharged in business bankruptcy. Business bankruptcy is not suitable for
You will need to discharge your personal liability for partnerships. Partnerships rarely file for Chapter 7
the debts by filing for Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy business bankruptcy because it doesn’t rid the partners
or by negotiating a settlement with the creditor(s). of their personal liability for the business’s debts. In
Otherwise, the creditor(s) can still come after you for full fact, it actually makes it easier for creditors to reach
repayment of the debt, even after the business is closed the partners’ personal assets, because the trustee in
and its liability for the debts is discharged in business a Chapter 7 bankruptcy case may sue the partners
bankruptcy. personally to recover some cash to pay the partnership’s
debts. Speak to a business lawyer if you’re interested in
The court fees in a Chapter 7 business bank filing a business bankruptcy for your partnership.
ruptcy are the same as for Chapter 7 personal l
bankruptcy. The trustee is likely to get a bigger
Part 2:
Filing for Chapter 7
Personal Bankruptcy
4
C H A P T E R
files its own bankruptcy action or settles the collection activities after you file your bankruptcy
debt will all of the calls finally stop. case. They cannot:
• call you or send letters to you
If your business is a sole proprietorship, you
• file a lawsuit or proceed with a pending
and your business are considered a single debtor.
lawsuit against you
If you file for Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy, the
• record liens against your property
automatic stay will apply to both your personal
• report the debt to a credit reporting
and your business creditors, and the stay should
bureau, or
stop all collection efforts against you, at least
• seize your property or income (such
temporarily.
as money in a bank account or your
paycheck) to repay the debt.
Actions Prohibited by Example: For years, Michelle and Brad
the Automatic Stay ran a business making and selling wooden
handcrafted canoes, but in 2009 their sales
The automatic stay goes into effect as soon as you
plummeted. They close up shop owing
file for bankruptcy. It’s “automatic” because you
various suppliers $35,000. They file for
don’t have to ask the court to issue the stay, and
Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy. Under the
the court doesn’t have to take any special action
automatic stay, suppliers can’t call them, send
to make it effective. Once you file, the stay is in
them letters, sue them, report their bad debt
place, automatically. The stay prohibits creditors
to a credit bureau, or seize any remaining
and collection agencies from taking any action to
supplies or inventory.
collect most kinds of debts you owe them, unless
the law or the bankruptcy court says they can.
In some circumstances, the creditor can file Public Benefits
an action in court (called a motion) asking the
judge to lift the stay and allow the creditor to If you were overpaid public benefits such as SSI,
proceed with its collection efforts. In others, the Medicaid, or Temporary Assistance to Needy
creditor can simply begin collection proceedings Families (welfare) benefits, the government agency
without advance permission from the court. cannot reduce or terminate your benefit payments
The good news is that the most common type to get that money back while your bankruptcy
of creditor collection actions are stopped by the is pending. If, however, you become ineligible
stay, including harassing calls from debt collectors, for benefits, including Medicare, the agency
threatening letters from attorneys, and lawsuits to may deny or terminate your benefits because of
collect payment for credit card bills. This section your ineligibility, even if you are in the midst
explains which collection actions are stopped by of a bankruptcy proceeding. In other words,
the automatic stay. bankruptcy doesn’t allow you to keep collecting
benefits to which you are no longer entitled.
continue. The debt component will be put on hold before you filed for bankruptcy, the 90-day notice
while your bankruptcy is pending. For example, if period would continue to run right through the
you were convicted of writing a bad check and have bankruptcy proceedings. However, if the mortgage
been sentenced to community service and ordered holder did not issue a notice of default before
to pay a fine, your obligation to pay the fine will you filed for bankruptcy, the mortgage holder is
be stopped by the automatic stay, but you will still prevented from issuing the notice of default until
have to perform your community service. the bankruptcy is over. In other words, filing
for bankruptcy before the 90-day notice would
substantially delay the foreclosure process, but
IRS Liens and Levies
filing after the 90-day notice would have little or
Certain tax proceedings are not affected by the no effect on the foreclosure. (See The Foreclosure
automatic stay (see “When the Automatic Stay Survival Guide, by Stephen Elias (Nolo), for a more
Doesn’t Apply,” below, for more information). The detailed look at how bankruptcy can work to delay
automatic stay does, however, stop the IRS from or prevent foreclosure.)
issuing a lien or seizing (levying against) your
property or income.
CAUTION
You can’t delay a foreclosure by filing serial
Foreclosures bankruptcies. Although foreclosure activities are stayed
initially by your bankruptcy filing, the automatic stay
Foreclosure is the procedure a mortgage holder
won’t apply if you filed another bankruptcy case within
must use to regain title to the property securing
the past two years and the court, in that proceeding,
the mortgage. It is the main (and sometimes only)
lifted the stay and allowed the lender to proceed with
remedy available to a mortgage holder when a
the foreclosure.
homeowner defaults.
Foreclosure procedures differ from state to state.
If a court has ordered you to leave your
In about half the states, foreclosures are carried out
home following foreclosure and the sheriff is
in court just like any other civil proceeding; these
trying to evict you, filing for bankruptcy will
are called “judicial” foreclosures. In other states, the
legally postpone the eviction until you receive
mortgage holder doesn’t have to go to court, but
a bankruptcy discharge or until the judge lifts
must follow complex state rules regarding notices,
the automatic stay, whichever happens first.
reinstatement periods, and redemption periods.
Although changes to the bankruptcy law in 2005
These are called “nonjudicial” foreclosures.
make it somewhat easier for property owners to
When you file for bankruptcy, the automatic
evict tenants who have filed for bankruptcy (see
stay stops all foreclosure proceedings. They can’t
“Residential Evictions,” below), these rules don’t
resume until you receive your final discharge or the
apply in actions to evict property owners rather
bankruptcy judge lifts the stay, upon request by the
than tenants.
mortgage holder.
Filing for bankruptcy doesn’t stop the clock
on foreclosure notice requirements, however. For Utilities
instance, in California, a foreclosing bank or Companies providing you with utilities (such as
mortgage company must provide the homeowner gas, heating oil, electricity, telephone service, and
with a notice of default at least 90 days before water) may not cut off your services because you file
setting a date for the actual foreclosure sale. If for bankruptcy. However, they can stop providing
the mortgage holder issued a notice of default services 20 days after you file for bankruptcy if you
ChaPter 4 | The Automatic stay | 57
don’t provide them with a deposit or other means • modify child support and alimony
to assure future payment. They can also terminate • report overdue child support to credit
services if you fail to pay for them after you file. (See bureaus
In re Jones, No. 06-10105-RS (D. Mass. 2006).) • collect back child support and alimony
If your utilities were shut off, either at your from property that is not in the bankruptcy
house or at your place of business (if it’s a sole estate (Ch. 5 explains what property is part
proprietorship), before you filed for bankruptcy, of the bankruptcy estate, such as income
you are entitled to have them turned back on you earn after filing for bankruptcy)
immediately after you file for bankruptcy. • withhold income to collect child support
One court has found that cable television isn’t • intercept tax refunds to pay back child
a utility, and service can therefore be stopped if you support
fail to pay the bill before filing for bankruptcy. (In • withhold, suspend, or restrict drivers’ and
re Darby, 470 F.3d 573 (5th Cir. 2006).) professional licenses as leverage to collect
child support
• determine child custody and visitation
When the Automatic • establish paternity in a lawsuit, and
Stay Doesn’t Apply • protect a spouse or child from domestic
violence.
The stay doesn’t put a stop to every type of collec-
tion action, nor does it apply in every situation. Tax Proceedings
Congress has determined that certain debts or
The IRS can continue certain actions against
proceedings are sufficiently important to “trump”
someone who files bankruptcy. These actions
the automatic stay. In these situations (described
include:
in “Actions Not Stopped by the Automatic Stay,”
• conducting a tax audit
below), collection actions can continue just as if
• issuing a tax deficiency notice (including for
you had never filed for bankruptcy.
unpaid payroll taxes)
In addition to the specific types of collection
• demanding a tax return
actions that can continue despite the stay, there are
• issuing a tax assessment, or
circumstances in which you can lose the protection
• demanding payment of an assessment.
of the automatic stay through your own actions.
These are described below as well. Pension Loans
The automatic stay doesn’t prevent withholding
Actions Not Stopped by from a debtor’s income to repay a loan from an
the Automatic Stay ERISA-qualified pension (this includes most job-
related pensions and individual retirement plans).
The automatic stay does not prohibit the following See Ch. 5 for more on how pensions are treated in
types of actions from proceeding. bankruptcy.
Divorce and Child Support
Almost all proceedings related to divorce or How You Can Lose the Protection
parenting continue unaffected by the automatic of the Automatic Stay
stay. These include actions to:
Even if the stay would otherwise apply, you can
• set and collect current child support and
lose its protection through your own actions. The
alimony
stay may not protect you from collection efforts if:
58 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
beyond the 30-day period, but the court will grant More Than One Bankruptcy Case
the motion only if you (or whoever else makes the Dismissed in the Past Year
request) can show that your current case was not If you had two or more cases pending and dismissed
filed in bad faith. during the previous year, no automatic stay will
The motion to continue the stay must be apply in your current case. You won’t even get the
scheduled for hearing within 30 days after you file initial 30-day stay that would apply if you had only
for bankruptcy and must give creditors adequate one bankruptcy case pending within the past year.
notice of why the stay should be extended. This The only way to get the benefit of the automatic
means the motion must: stay in this case is to convince the court, within 30
• be filed within several days after you file for days of your filing, that your current case was not
bankruptcy (unless you obtain an “Order filed in bad faith and that a stay should therefore be
Shortening Time” from the judge, a simple granted. The court will look at the factors outlined
procedure) above to decide whether you have overcome the
• be served on all creditors to whom you want presumption of bad faith.
the stay to apply, and
• provide specific reasons why your current Missing Deadlines for Handling Secured Debts
filing is not in bad faith and the stay should If you have property that secures a debt—that
be extended. is, property that the creditor has a right to take
When deciding whether to extend the automatic if you don’t pay the debt—you will have to file a
stay beyond 30 days, the court will look at a number form called a “Statement of Intention” with the
of factors to decide whether your current filing is in court and serve it on your creditors. The Statement
good faith. Here are some of the factors that will of Intention explains what you want to do with
work against you: the collateral. If you don’t meet the deadlines for
• More than one prior bankruptcy case was handling your secured debts, the automatic stay
filed by (or against) you in the past year. will no longer apply to that property (although it
• Your prior case was dismissed because you will continue to protect you otherwise).
failed to file required documents on time For example, assume you want to keep your car
(for instance, you didn’t file your credit and continue making payments on your car note,
counseling certificate within 15 days or but you don’t serve your Statement of Intention
didn’t amend the petition on a timely basis on time. The automatic stay will no longer protect
when required to do so). If your failure was your car or prevent the creditor from repossessing
inadvertent or due to a careless error, that it, but your other property will still be protected.
won’t help you with the judge unless you Secured debts and the Statement of Intention are
used an attorney in the prior case. Judges covered in detail in Ch. 8 and Ch. 9.
are more willing to give debtors the benefit
of the doubt if an attorney was responsible
for the mistake. Rules for Commercial Leases
• The prior case was dismissed while a In 2005, Congress made significant changes
creditor’s request for relief from the regarding the application of the automatic stay
automatic stay was pending. to residential tenants. These are discussed in
• Your circumstances haven’t changed since “Residential Evictions,” below. Importantly, how
your previous case was dismissed. ever, none of those changes apply to commercial
60 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
tenancies. If you file for bankruptcy while your stay will prevent the landlord from beginning or
commercial lease is in effect, you are entitled to continuing with eviction proceedings. However,
remain for the duration of your bankruptcy case the landlord can always ask the judge to lift the
unless the court lifts the automatic stay and permits automatic stay.
an eviction or the bankruptcy trustee decides to
assume the lease (see Ch. 9 for more on how leases CAUTION
and contracts are treated in bankruptcy). But the
Landlords can always ask the court to lift
stay won’t protect you from eviction proceedings if the automatic stay. Although the automatic stay will
your lease expired by its own terms before or as a kick in unless one of the above exceptions applies, the
result of your bankruptcy filing. judge can lift the stay upon the landlord’s request. And
many courts are willing to do so, because most evictions
will have no effect on the bankruptcy estate—that is,
Residential Evictions your tenancy isn’t something that the trustee can turn
In the past, many renters filed for Chapter 7 into money to pay your creditors. As a general rule,
bankruptcy to stop the sheriff from enforcing bankruptcy courts are inclined to let landlords exercise
a judgment for possession (an eviction order). their property rights regardless of the tenant’s debt
While landlords could come into court and ask problems.
the judge to lift the automatic stay so the eviction
could proceed, many landlords didn’t know they If the Landlord Already
had this right—and many others didn’t have the
Has a Judgment
wherewithal to hire attorneys (or the confidence
to handle their own cases). In other words, filing If your landlord has already obtained a judgment
for Chapter 7 bankruptcy often stopped eviction of possession against you when you file for
proceedings for the duration of the bankruptcy. bankruptcy, the automatic stay probably won’t help
Today, things are a bit different. The 2005 you. The landlord may proceed with the eviction
bankruptcy law gives landlords the right to evict a just as if you had never filed for bankruptcy. But
residential tenant, despite the automatic stay, if: if the eviction order is based on your failure to
• the landlord got a judgment for possession pay rent, you may be able to get the automatic
—that is, took the tenant to court for stay reinstated. This exception applies only if your
eviction and won—before the tenant filed state’s law allows you to stay in your rental unit
for bankruptcy (however, if the judgment and “cure” (pay back) the rent delinquency after
was for failing to pay rent, there is a possible the landlord has a judgment for possession. Here’s
exception to this rule, discussed below), or what you’ll have to do to take advantage of this
• the landlord is evicting the tenant for exception:
endangering the property or illegal use of Step 1: As part of your bankruptcy petition,
controlled substances on the property (more you must file a certification (a statement under
on this below). oath) stating that your state’s laws allow you to cure
If the landlord does not already have a the rent delinquency after the judgment is obtained
judgment for possession when you file for and to continue living in your rental unit. Very few
bankruptcy, and he or she wants to evict you for states allow this. To find out whether yours is one
reasons other than endangering the property or of them, ask the sheriff, someone at your local legal
using controlled substances (for example, the aid office (if you have legal aid in your area), or a
eviction is based on your failure to pay rent or tenants’ rights group. In addition, when you file
violation of another lease provision), the automatic your bankruptcy petition, you must deposit with
ChaPter 4 | The Automatic stay | 61
the court clerk the amount of rent that will become possession in hand when you file for bankruptcy:
due during the 30-day period after you file. The landlord may start an eviction action against
Once you have filed your petition containing you or continue with a pending eviction action
the certification and deposited the rent, you even after your filing date if the eviction is based
are protected from eviction for 30 days unless on property endangerment or drug use.
the landlord successfully objects to your initial To evict you on these grounds after you have
certification before the 30-day period ends. If the filed for bankruptcy, your landlord must file and
landlord objects to your certification, the court serve on you a certification showing that:
must hold a hearing on the objection within ten • the landlord has filed an eviction
days, so theoretically you could have less than 30 action against you based on property
days of protection if the landlord files and serves endangerment or illegal drug use on the
the objection immediately. property, or
Step 2: To keep the stay in effect longer, you • you have endangered the property or
must, before the 30-day period runs out, file and engaged in illegal drug use on the property
serve a second certification showing that you have during the 30-day period prior to the
fully cured the default in the manner provided landlord’s certification.
by your state’s law. However, if the landlord If your landlord files this certification, he or
successfully objects to this second certification, the she can proceed with the eviction 15 days later
stay will no longer be in effect and the landlord unless, within that time, you file and serve on the
may proceed with the eviction. As in Step 1, the landlord an objection to the truth of the statements
court must hold a hearing within ten days if the in the landlord’s certification. If you do that, the
landlord objects. court must hold a hearing on your objection within
ten days. If you prove that the statements in the
certification aren’t true or have been remedied,
See an Expert
you will be protected from the eviction while your
If you really want to keep your rental, talk
bankruptcy is pending. If the court denies your
to a lawyer. As you can see, these rules are somewhat
complicated. If you don’t interpret your state’s law
objection, the eviction may proceed immediately.
properly, file the necessary paperwork on time, and As a practical matter, you will have a very
successfully argue your side if the landlord objects, you difficult time proving that you weren’t endangering
could find yourself put out of your home. A good lawyer the property or using drugs. Similarly, once
can tell you whether it’s worth fighting an eviction—and, allegations of property endangerment or drug
if so, how to go about it. use are made, it’s hard to see how they would be
“remedied.” In short, this is another area where
you’ll need a lawyer if you have to fight it out.
Endangering the Property or Illegal
Use of Controlled Substances
Resource
Under the 2005 bankruptcy law, an eviction Need help with your residential landlord?
action will not be stayed by your bankruptcy For more information on dealing with landlords—
filing if your landlord wants you out because you including landlords that are trying to evict you—see
endangered the property or engaged in the “illegal Every Tenant’s Legal Guide, by Janet Portman and Marcia
use of controlled substances” on the property. And Stewart (Nolo).
your landlord doesn’t have to have a judgment for l
5
C H A P T E R
required debtors who converted from Chapter 13 to Property You Are Entitled to Receive
Chapter 7 to hand over their clothes, $3,660 worth of
personal property, and their family dog, because the As a small business owner, you may be entitled to
debtors hadn’t claimed an exemption for any of this receive money or property that hasn’t yet found its
property. (In re John, 352 B.R. 895 (N.D. Fla. 2006).) way into your hands (a bird that’s still in the bush,
Although you get to keep all of your property in Chapter so to speak). Property that might fall into this
13 bankruptcy, you still have to claim exemptions to category includes the following (some are explained
calculate your minimum plan payment. in more detail below):
• accounts receivable
• stock options
Property in a Revocable Living Trust • commissions
• tax refunds that are due and payable
A revocable living trust is a popular estate planning • causes of action (legal grounds for bringing
tool in which the grantor puts property in trust a lawsuit)
to be managed by the trustee, for the benefit of
• vacation or severance pay you earned before
one or more beneficiaries. The trust is revocable
filing
because the grantor can change his or her mind
• proceeds from property in your bankruptcy
and revoke it at any time. If the grantor owns a sole
estate (such as royalties you have earned on
proprietorship business, it’s typically included in
copyrighted material)
the trust.
• proceeds of an insurance policy, if the
If you are both the grantor and the trustee
injury or other event that triggers payment
of your revocable living trust (the most common
arrangement), property in the trust is considered
has already occurred when you file, and
property of your bankruptcy estate, even though • an inheritance that you are entitled to but
the trust technically “owns” the property. Courts haven’t yet received.
haven’t yet determined what happens if you name These types of assets are part of your bank
someone else to be the trustee, but it’s likely that ruptcy estate because you are already entitled to
the same result would occur: The trust would be them when you file. Although a typical Chapter 7
considered part of your (the grantor’s) bankruptcy bankruptcy case is over in just a few months, your
estate because you could still change you mind and case can be held open, for years if necessary, until
revoke the trust. these assets materialize. For example, if you are
If, however, the trust is irrevocable (that is, you a named heir of someone who has already died,
can’t change your mind and dissolve or amend it), but the will is held up in probate for months,
property in the trust won’t be considered part of the bankruptcy judge will keep your case open
your bankruptcy estate unless: until the will is finally settled and you receive the
• the trust was created within the previous inheritance, so that if can be taken to pay your
two years (or even earlier if you were trying creditors.
to avoid your creditors) and qualifies as a If, however, the asset will be protected by an
fraudulent transfer, or exemption when it finally arrives, your bankruptcy
• the trust was created within the previous case will probably be closed on schedule. For
ten years and is self-settled (that is, example, if you are still owed $5,000 in accounts
you created the trust and are also its receivable, but the exemption system you plan
beneficiary). to use include a “wildcard” exemption for up to
Both of these situations are described in $5,000, the trustee won’t keep your case open (see
“Property You Transferred Improperly,” below.
Ch. 6 for more on exemptions). Because you’ll get
66 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
to keep the money when it comes, there’s no reason options = [number of vested stock options] x [fair
to delay the end of your bankruptcy. market value – option price].) Even if the value of
Let’s look in more detail at a few types of your options is uncertain, they are still part of your
property you may receive in the future. bankruptcy estate and the trustee will take them if
they are marketable.
Accounts Receivable
Even if you don’t think you’ll be paid by a par- Causes of Action
ticular creditor, any debt owed to you is part of If you have a potential legal claim for money
your bankruptcy estate. It’s the trustee’s job to go damages against another person or business, it is
after the money, if possible, so it can be distributed part of your bankruptcy estate even if the value
to your creditors (unless you are able to protect it of the claim hasn’t yet been determined. For
with an exemption). Leaving current or overdue example, if you entered into a purchase agreement
accounts receivable off the bankruptcy forms can with a vendor, and the vendor failed to deliver
get you into trouble. supplies as promised, you have a legal claim for
breach of contract. Even if you haven’t yet filed a
Stock Options lawsuit—and may never do so—you must include
If you own stock options, you have the right to this potential source of money in your bankruptcy
purchase company stock at the price that was papers.
assigned when the stock options were granted. When If you don’t list your potential causes of action
you actually buy the stock, you are “exercising” your in your bankruptcy petition, you may lose the
stock options. right to bring a lawsuit on the claims after your
As a general rule, stock options that you bankruptcy. Under a legal principal known as
own when you file for bankruptcy are part of judicial estoppel, failing to raise a legal claim in
your bankruptcy estate. In addition, any stock one judicial proceeding could prohibit you from
you purchase by exercising your stock options is raising it in a later proceeding. For example, if you
also part of the estate, even if you exercise those file for bankruptcy to prevent a foreclosure sale of
options after you file for bankruptcy. Courts treat your home, but fail to list a cause of action you
these postfiling stock purchases as proceeds of the may have against the lender under the Truth in
bankruptcy estate. Lending Act, you may be prevented from suing the
Most of the time, you have to wait for a while lender after your bankruptcy is completed. (See In
after you are awarded options before you are re Lopez, 283 B.R. 22 (9th Cir. BAP 2002).)
entitled to buy the stock. When the waiting period
ends, the stock options “vest” and you may exercise Proceeds From Property in
them. Whether stock options are part of your Your Bankruptcy Estate
bankruptcy estate depends on when you received This category of property includes, for example,
them and when they vest. If your stock options do rent from commercial or residential real estate,
not vest until you have been with your company royalties from copyrights or patents, and dividends
for a certain period of time, your bankruptcy estate earned on stock. If property in your bankruptcy
will include only those stock options that have estate earns income or otherwise produces money
already vested on the date you file for bankruptcy. after you file for bankruptcy, this money is also
To calculate the value of your stock options, part of your bankruptcy estate. For example,
multiply the number of vested stock options you suppose you have a contract to receive royalties
own by the difference between your option price for a book you wrote before filing bankruptcy.
and the fair market value of the stock. (Value of That contract is part of your bankruptcy estate, as
ChaPter 5 | Your Bankruptcy estate | 67
are any royalties you earn after you file for bank to change it. Technically, this type of arrangement
ruptcy. The one exception to this rule is money qualifies as a gift to the beneficiary rather than an
you earn from providing personal services after inheritance, and it’s part of your bankruptcy estate.
filing for bankruptcy; this money isn’t part of your Property you inherit within six months after
bankruptcy estate. Continuing our example, work filing is also part of your bankruptcy estate. Even
you do to create a new edition of the book after you if the person leaving the inheritance is still alive
file for bankruptcy would be considered personal when you file your bankruptcy, property left to you
services. The royalties you earn for that new work by will or by intestate succession (the way property
would not be part of your bankruptcy estate. passes when no will or other estate planning device
Proceeds from a “contingent future interest” dictates who will receive it) will be part of your
are also part of the bankruptcy estate. This bit bankruptcy estate if the person dies within 180
of legalese refers to money that you will receive days after you file for bankruptcy (see “Certain
if certain things happen in the future. The mere Property Acquired Within 180 Days After You
possibility that you will receive property after filing File,” below).
for bankruptcy is enough to put that property in Some inheritances are set up so that you
your bankruptcy estate once you do file. In one receive periodic payments from a trust, although
case, for example, an employee had the right to you are not entitled to the full amount of the trust
participate in a profit-sharing plan, but only if he yet. For example, you may be the beneficiary of a
was still employed by the company at the end of spendthrift trust, which pays you a certain amount
the year. He filed for bankruptcy before the end each year until you reach a particular age, when
of the year, but remained employed and at the you are entitled to whatever’s left in the trust.
end of the year received a hefty check, which the Because spendthrift trusts restrict the trustee’s
trustee claimed belonged to the bankruptcy estate, ability to use the funds to pay creditors, the
at least in part. The court ruled that the check the funds in the trust are not technically part of your
employee received belonged in the bankruptcy bankruptcy estate.
estate even though the employee didn’t receive it Nonetheless, when you complete your
until after the filing date, because the employee’s paperwork in Ch. 9, you should identify any such
interest in the profit-sharing plan was a contingent trust on your Schedule B (where you list all your
future interest. (In re Edwards, 273 B.R. 527 (E.D. personal property) and describe it as a spendthrift
Mich. 2000).) trust that isn’t part of your bankruptcy estate. You
don’t want to be accused of trying to hide it. The
Inheritances trustee may want a copy of the trust paperwork
If you are entitled to receive an inheritance, that to find out whether it’s a true spendthrift trust or
money or property is part of your bankruptcy whether there is a way for creditors (and thus the
estate, even if you have not yet received it. Generally, trustee) to get at the funds.
you are “entitled” to receive an inheritance only after
the person leaving the inheritance has died. After Your Share of Marital Property
all, that person could always spend the money, sell
the property you hope to one day inherit, or change How much of your marital property—the property
his or her estate plan to cut you out. you and your spouse own together—is included in
There are a few exceptions to this rule. If you your bankruptcy estate depends on two factors: (1)
are the beneficiary of an irrevocable trust, the whether you file jointly or alone, and (2) the laws of
person who created the trust is not legally entitled your state regarding marital property.
68 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
If you file jointly, all marital property that fits bankruptcy separately after his consulting
into any of the categories discussed in this section business fails. Their house is worth $250,000.
belongs to your bankruptcy estate. Paul must list that entire value as part of his
However, if you are married and you file for bankruptcy estate on his bankruptcy papers—
bankruptcy alone, some marital property may that is, he can’t list only half of that amount
not be part of your bankruptcy estate. Whether because he owns the house jointly with Sonya,
property is part of the estate depends on whether nor can he subtract the $20,000 Sonya would
you live in a community property, tenancy by the be entitled to if they divorced.
entirety, or “common law” property state.
Example: Paul owns a twin-engine Cessna as The general rules of property ownership in
his separate property (he owned it before he common law states are:
married Sonya). Sonya came to the marriage • Property that has only one spouse’s name
owning a grand piano. Because Paul is filing on a title certificate (such as a car, a house,
for bankruptcy alone, Paul’s aircraft will be or stocks) is that spouse’s separate property,
part of his bankruptcy estate, but Sonya’s even if it was bought with joint funds.
piano won’t be. • Property that was purchased or received as a
gift or inheritance by both spouses is jointly
You may need to do some research into your
owned, unless title is held in only one
state’s property laws to make sure you understand
spouse’s name (which means it belongs to
which of your property is separate and which is
that spouse separately, even if both spouses
community. (See Ch. 12 for tips on legal research.)
use it).
Tenancy by the Entirety States • Property that one spouse buys with separate
funds or receives as a gift or inheritance for
States that recognize some form of tenancy by
that spouse’s s eparate use is that spouse’s
the entirety for married couples are Delaware,
separate property (unless, again, a title
Florida, Hawaii, Illinois, Indiana, Maryland,
certificate shows differently).
Massachusetts, Michigan, Missouri, North
• If one spouse owns and operates a business
Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island,
under his or her name, and the other spouse
Tennessee, Vermont, Virginia, and Wyoming,
is not engaged in operating the business, the
along with the District of Columbia.
business will be the separate property of the
Real estate (and personal property, in some
first spouse.
states) that a couple owns as tenants by the entirety
belongs to the marriage, rather than to one spouse Same-Sex Couples and Domestic Partners
or the other. If both spouses file for bankruptcy,
If you are married to, or in a domestic partnership
property held in tenancy by the entirety is property
with, someone of the same sex, you may be wonder
of the bankruptcy estate. If only one spouse files for
ing whether you can file for bankruptcy together
bankruptcy, however, this property is not part of
with your partner—and what effect bankruptcy will
the bankruptcy estate and is generally exempt from
have on property you own together. Many issues
claims for which only one spouse is liable. Because
involving these relationships are still up in the air,
the property belongs to the marriage, one spouse
and, because same-sex marriage has only recently
cannot give it away or encumber it with debts on
become possible, it isn’t clear how things will shake
his or her own. The property is not exempt from
out.
debts the couple takes on jointly, however. We
If you and your partner have married (currently
discuss this further in Ch. 7.
allowed in Massachusetts, Iowa, Vermont,
Common Law Property States Connecticut, and New Hampshire) or registered
as domestic partners in a state that offers registered
If your state is not listed above as a community
partners some of the benefits of marriage, you
property or tenancy by the entirety state, it is a
might be considering a joint bankruptcy filing.
“common law” property state. When only one
Thus far, however, such efforts have not been
spouse files for bankruptcy in a common law
successful, primarily because federal law does not
property state, all of that spouse’s separate property
recognize same-sex marriage and allows states to
plus half of the couple’s jointly owned property
disregard such marriages performed in other states.
goes into the filing spouse’s bankruptcy estate.
This law, known as the Defense of Marriage Act
70 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
(DOMA), also defines marriage, for purposes property owned with any other person: The share
of federal law, as a union between a man and a that you own will be part of the bankruptcy estate
woman. The DOMA has led at least one court to and subject to the court’s jurisdiction. Your partner
deny a lesbian couple who had married in Canada will be treated as a codebtor on any debts you owe
the right to file jointly for bankruptcy. jointly. But your partner will not be part of your
bankruptcy case.
Separate but Equal Can Be If you and your partner or spouse are con
Helpful in Bankruptcy sidering filing jointly or have concerns about the
treatment of your debts and property in bank
Believe it or not, the federal bankruptcy system’s ruptcy, you should consult with a bankruptcy
discrimination against same-sex couples can also be attorney who is familiar with legal issues facing
an advantage. An example of this is the exemption same-sex couples.
system. In many states, married couples are not
allowed to double exemptions, whether they file
together or separately. And in community property Property You Transferred Improperly
states, all of the couple’s community property is part Even property you no longer possess or own can
of the bankruptcy estate, even if only one spouse be pulled back into your bankruptcy estate if you
files. These problems disappear for unmarried transferred it improperly. For example, if you sold
couples. Because unmarried partners must file or gave away property during the two-year period
separately, each can claim the full amount of every
immediately before you file for bankruptcy (or
exemption, and one partner can file for bankruptcy
even longer in some cases), you will have to disclose
without worrying that his or her partner’s property
those transfers on your bankruptcy forms. And if
will be considered part of the bankruptcy estate. The
you gave away or sold the property for less than it
downside—beyond being prohibited from classifying
was worth within the past year, the trustee can get
your relationship as you wish—is having to pay a
it back and sell it for the benefit of your creditors.
separate filing fee (and some extra attorney fees if
Fraudulent transfers take place when debtors
you are using an attorney).
try to unload their assets so that their creditors (or
the bankruptcy trustee) won’t be able to take and
sell them. These transactions often take the form of
There is even less certainty as to how state
selling property to a friend or relative for a nominal
exemptions and property ownership laws will
amount (such as a dollar), with the understanding
be applied to same-sex couples who are married
that the friend will give back the property once
or registered as civil or domestic partners. For
the bankruptcy case is closed. Another common
example, a New Jersey Tax Court allowed a
example of a fraudulent transfer is taking one’s
disabled veteran’s claim that the home he owned
name off a joint account, deed, or vehicle title
with his male partner was exempt from taxes,
(which is really a gift of half of the property to the
because the men had registered as domestic
other joint owner). Or, a debtor might try to reduce
partners in New Jersey and owned the home
his or her equity in property by using it as collateral
in tenancy by the entirety—a form of property
for a new loan shortly before filing for bankruptcy.
ownership previously reserved to married couples.
Even if you didn’t intend to improperly shield
This uncertainty extends only to couples that
your assets, a transfer can be set aside—and the
have married or registered, however. If you and
property returned to the bankruptcy estate—if you
your partner are neither married nor registered in
received less than reasonably equivalent value in
a state that gives partners marriage-like benefits,
exchange for the property, and:
any property you own together will be treated like
ChaPter 5 | Your Bankruptcy estate | 71
2. The debtor retained possession or control of consider, but judges are free to disregard certain
the transferred property after the transfer badges—or give certain badges more weight—
(for example, the property was transferred depending on the circumstances. A judge could
to a trust in which the debtor continued to decide that a transfer is fraudulent even if only one
possess the property as trustee). or two badges are present; similarly, a judge might
3. The transfer or obligation was not disclosed decide that a transfer is not fraudulent even if a
(for example, the debtor tried to conceal number of badges are present.
the transfer from the court by failing to list While fuzzy logic may work in certain types of
it on the bankruptcy paperwork). math, it tends to undercut the certainty that people
4. Before the transfer was made, the debtor look for in the law. If you’ve made a transfer that
had been sued or threatened with a lawsuit. you’re concerned about, you’ll need to examine
5. The transfer included substantially all of the circumstances surrounding the conversion,
the debtor’s assets (if the debtor transferred consider which “badges of fraud” might apply, and
only a small part of his or her assets, the be prepared to argue with the trustee.
court is less likely to find fraud).
6. The debtor changed his or her address or Time Limits
moved out of state for no apparent reason The bankruptcy court can undo transfers like
other than to avoid the creditor. these only if you make them within a certain
7. The debtor removed or concealed assets time before filing for bankruptcy. Generally, the
(for example, the debtor changed bank trustee can look back two years before you filed for
accounts, moved his or her money to a bankruptcy to find fraudulent transfers; that’s why
foreign jurisdiction or off-shore account— the bankruptcy paperwork requires you to list all
often called “situs trusts”—or changed the transactions in the two years before you filed.
name on the property’s title). If, however, you made a fraudulent transfer within
8. What the debtor received for the property the year before filing, the trustee may decide to
was not reasonably equivalent to its value go a step further and ask the court to deny you a
(that is, the property was either given away bankruptcy discharge of your debts.
or sold for an amount far lower than could
Example 1: You want to file for Chapter 7
be obtained on the open market).
bankruptcy, but you are listed on a deed
9. The debtor became insolvent shortly after
as the co-owner of property where a friend
the transfer was made.
is living (which was necessary to allow the
10. The transfer occurred shortly before
friend to buy the property because he has bad
or shortly after a substantial debt was
credit). After learning that the trustee could
incurred.
take and sell that property for the benefit of
11. The debtor transferred the essential assets
your unsecured creditors, you take yourself
of a business to a lienholder, who then
off the deed before you file for bankruptcy.
transferred the assets to an insider (a
Because you’re unwilling to commit perjury,
business associate, friend, or relative) of the
however, you have to list the transaction on
debtor.
your bankruptcy papers, and your entire
It can be tough to predict how a particular
bankruptcy case could go down the tubes.
judge will weigh the presence or absence of
particular factors to decide whether a transfer was EXAMPLE 2: You own a used book store as
fraudulent. The badges of fraud are nothing more a sole proprietor, and business isn’t good.
than a laundry list of suspicious acts for judges to If you file for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, you’ll
ChaPter 5 | Your Bankruptcy estate | 73
have to close down your business (at least wasn’t aware of the fraud. Still, if you transferred
temporarily), and you’ll lose most of your valuable property within the last four years, you
inventory and fixtures to the bankruptcy might want to consult with a lawyer.
trustee, who will try to sell them to raise
Example: The fraudulent transfer act in Pete’s
money for your creditors. To avoid this result,
state has a statute of limitations of four years.
you “sell” the business to a friend. Although
Three years ago, Pete transferred ownership of
the business has a fair market value of
a real estate parcel to his Uncle Paul to hide it
$50,000, your friend pays only $1,000.
from a vendor that was threatening to sue for
When you file for bankruptcy a month
breach of contract. No money changed hands;
later, you leave the business—and the sale to
Pete just changed the name on the title, and
your friend—off of your paperwork because
Uncle Paul agreed to transfer the property
you don’t see any way the bankruptcy trustee
back to Pete after the dust had settled. The
could find out about it. However, you are
vendor sued Pete, but settled for pennies on
required to file your most recent tax return
the dollar; the vendor didn’t know about the
with the bankruptcy court, from which the
property.
trustee learns that you own a store. At the
After settling the lawsuit, Pete files for
creditors’ meeting, the trustee questions you
Chapter 7 bankruptcy (in part, to get out
closely about the store. At this point, you
of making the payments required by the
fess up and show the trustee your bill of sale.
settlement agreement). Pete leaves the transfer
Because this was a recent transfer for far less
to Uncle Paul off his records because it
than fair market price, the trustee can oppose
happened more than two years ago. As part
your entire bankruptcy discharge. And,
of a routine search of public records, the
because you deliberately left the transfer off
bankruptcy trustee discovers the transfer
your paperwork despite clear instructions on
and learns of the fraud by questioning Pete
the form to list it, you risk being prosecuted
at his creditors’ meeting. After the trustee
for perjury (a felony).
threatens to sue him to get the property back,
These one- and two-year look-back periods Uncle Paul willingly transfers the parcel to
come from federal bankruptcy law. However, all the trustee, who sells it and distributes the
states also have laws that forbid unlawful transfers proceeds to Pete’s unsecured creditors. Had
and allow creditors to sue to get back property Pete known this would happen, he may
that was improperly transferred. These fraudulent have decided not to file for bankruptcy until
transfer laws often have a statute of limitations of another year had passed. If more than four
four years, which means the trustee can look back years had passed between the transfer and
that far into the past for property to pull back into Pete’s bankruptcy filing, the transfer would
the bankruptcy estate. have been beyond the trustee’s reach.
If one of these laws gives a creditor the right
to sue, the trustee can step in and exercise that If You’ve Made a Fraudulent Transfer
same right in the creditor’s place. Trustees don’t
Whatever form they take, gifts and sales of
often use these laws because they require a lot of
property for substantially less than the property
time and effort. The trustee must file a lawsuit in
is worth are frequently judged to be improper or
the bankruptcy court, win it, and then enforce
fraudulent transfers. This means the property can
the judgment before actually laying hands on the
be taken—from its new owner—and sold for the
property. Also, the person to whom you transferred
benefit of the creditors, and the bankruptcy case
the property might win the lawsuit if he or she
74 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
could be dismissed. Even if you’re able to convince Often, property that people try to transfer
the trustee that your intentions were good, the before filing for bankruptcy would have been
trustee can still require the person to whom you exempt anyway. In other words, these transfers
gave or sold the property to give it back. In these often occur simply because the debtor doesn’t
situations, you may not have the opportunity to understand the bankruptcy laws. Had the person
claim that the property is exempt, so you won’t just kept the property and claimed it as exempt, he
even get any of the sale proceeds. or she could have held on to it and avoided a whole
If you made a mistake like this, you may be lot of trouble.
tempted to try to undo it by, for example, getting
the property back, putting your name back on the
How Do Trustees Find Out?
deed or title certificate, and so on. This looks even
worse to the trustee, however: It indicates that you People often wonder how the trustee would find
are trying to deceive the court. The best way to out about a particular transfer. If the transferred
handle these transfers is simply to wait out the two- property has a title document (as with cars, boats,
year (or four-year) period, if possible. For example, and real estate), the transfer might show up in the
if you sold your car to a relative on the cheap, you trustee’s routine search of state and local databases
should wait two years before filing. (for example, at the state DMV). And the tax return
Unfortunately, it’s not always possible to you are required to provide will give the trustee
wait. You may have a wage garnishment in the useful information about your previous possessions
works, or you may be trying to buy some time and transactions. Also, when you attend the
in a foreclosure or eviction situation. What then? creditors’ meeting, you must affirm, under oath,
Probably the next best strategy is to disclose the that you truthfully answered the questions in
transfer and attempt to use your exemptions to your bankruptcy papers, including questions
keep the property. Some lawyers advocate undoing about property you transferred in the past two
recent transactions, even if the trustee may see years. Because trustees profit directly from finding
this as further evidence of deception. You can list property they can take and sell, they are very skilled
the property on your schedules as part of your at picking up on any hesitancy or anxiety you may
show at the creditors’ meeting. A trustee who
bankruptcy estate, explaining that you earlier
senses trouble can question you under oath in a
transferred it but now have it back. Then, you
deposition-like proceeding. Most importantly, it’s a
should be able to claim any exemptions that apply
bad idea to commit perjury. Period.
to the property.
In some cases, the property you transferred
may not exist or be available for the trustee to seize.
For example, say you took your name off the title Self-Settled Trusts
to a car you owned jointly with your brother, and
If you created an irrevocable “self-settled” trust
he pays you nothing in return. Several months
within the last ten years, intending to defraud your
later, your brother sells the car to raise money to
creditors, this might also count as a fraudulent
pay off his child support arrearages. If you filed
transfer. A self-settled trust is one that you created
for bankruptcy, there is little the trustee can do to
and funded with your own property, and for which
get this money back. The car is gone, your brother
you are the beneficiary. A trust is irrevocable if you
is broke, and the trustee can’t go after his ex for
can’t take it back; once you create an irrevocable
the child support money. In a situation like this, a
trust, it’s final. If the trustee finds that you created
fraudulent transfer won’t have any effect on your
a self-settled trust in the past ten years with fraudu-
bankruptcy.
ChaPter 5 | Your Bankruptcy estate | 75
lent intent (based on the badges of fraud discussed considered a preference if it was made within a year
above), the trustee can undo it and distribute all to insider creditors (business associates, friends,
of the assets of the trust to your creditors, without or relatives), or within three months to others (see
letting you claim any exemption. below). If, however, you are a business debtor—that
is, a majority of your debt arises from your business
Unequal Divorce Settlements activities—the court will look only at transactions
People frequently file for bankruptcy within a year that exceed $5,475. (Ch. 2 explains how to
or two of ending a marriage. Is it a fraudulent determine whether you are a business debtor for
transfer if one spouse gives all or most of the purposes of this rule.)
marital property to the other spouse and then files
bankruptcy? While some trustees have attempted Payments to Insiders
to recover property transferred to an ex-spouse The time period during which payments will be
under these circumstances, most courts have ruled considered a preference depends on whether the
that property given up in a divorce is deemed to creditor is an insider (a business associate, friend, or
be transferred for fair consideration, even if the relative). If you pay more than $600 (or $5,475 if
spouse filing for bankruptcy got little or nothing you are primarily a business debtor) to any creditor
in return. There are many reasons why one spouse who’s an insider during the year before you file
might come out with the short end of the stick for bankruptcy, that payment is a preference. For
in a divorce, and these judges have found that it’s example, if you use your tax refund to pay back
not appropriate for a federal bankruptcy court to an emergency loan from your sister, brother, or
second-guess the outcome of a state court divorce mother, you have preferred that creditor over your
settlement or decree. other unsecured creditors. Bluntly put, when in
bankruptcy, you are required to treat your mother
Preference Payments and Visa equally.
A basic principle of bankruptcy law is that all Example: In October, Robin borrows $2,000
creditors deserve to be treated fairly in comparison from her mother to pay off a supplier. In
to each other. In many cases, fair treatment means March of the following year, Robin receives
that no one gets anything. In some cases, it means a tax refund of $3,000. She pays her mother
that your unsecured creditors share equally in back and uses the remaining $1,000 to catch
the proceeds if the trustee takes your nonexempt up on other bills. Even though no one could
property and sells it. blame Robin for paying back her mom,
This principle is undermined if you make a this would likely be considered a preference
payment to some creditors and not others before payment if she files for bankruptcy within
you file for bankruptcy. Payments like these may be the year. She’ll have to disclose it in her
considered “preferences” because you are favoring bankruptcy paperwork, and her mom may
some creditors over others. When payments qualify have to cough up the money.
as preferences, the trustee can demand that the There is one important exception to this rule:
creditor return the money to your bankruptcy estate, A payment to an insider won’t be considered a
where it will be divided equally among all of your preference if you made the payment more than 90
creditors (subject to any exemptions you can claim). days prior to filing for bankruptcy and you weren’t
For consumer debtors (those whose debts are insolvent at the time. For example, if you repaid
primarily for personal debt rather than business a $3,000 loan from your mother more than three
debt), any payment of more than $600 might be months before you file, and you can show that the
76 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
value of your assets was greater than your liabilities dispute over the quality of materials provided.
at the time you repaid her, the payment won’t be Tim lands another job, for which he secures
considered a preference. This insolvency rule also $10,000 worth of tile on credit from ABC
applies to preferences to noninsiders. Masonry Supplies. Two months later, when
Insolvency is presumed during the 90-day he is paid for the job, he pays ABC $10,000,
period before you file for bankruptcy, so if you which brings his ABC account current. This
made a preference payment within the past 90 transaction would most likely qualify as one
days, you should expect it to be undone if you file made in the ordinary course of Tim’s business,
for bankruptcy. because it meets his normal practice of
immediately paying his suppliers.
Payments to Others
Regular payments for personal expenses—such
If the creditor is not an insider, but instead is a
as utilities or services—typically also qualify as
regular “arms-length” creditor like most of your
payments made in the ordinary course of business
business creditors, such as a vendor or credit card
or financial affairs, rather than preferences. And
company, the rules are different. The court will
regular monthly payments on long-term debt (for
look at your transactions with that creditor for
example, making a usual monthly payment on a
only three months before you file for bankruptcy.
mortgage, credit card bill, or student loan) also fall
During this time period, any payment of more
within this exception.
than $600, or $5,475 if you are primarily a
Even if a payment to a creditor was not made
business debtor, will be considered a preference
in the ordinary course of business or financial
affairs, it still may escape the trustee’s clutches if the
Antecedent Debt Rule
debtor receives “new value” as a result of making
To qualify as a preference, the payments must be
the payment. This means the debtor is receiving
made on an “antecedent” debt. In other words, the
some current benefit for making the payment, not
debt must already be past due and owing. Even if
just paying off an old debt. For instance, let’s say
you are current on an account, it might still qualify
Tim, from the example above, paid off Tom’s Tile
as an antecedent debt. For example, you may be
so he could order more materials on credit from
current on a large credit card debt because you have
that company. This extension of credit might be
been making the minimum monthly payments. As
considered new value received for paying off the
long as interest is being charged on the underlying
old debt, which means the payment wouldn’t be a
debt, however, it will be considered an antecedent
preference.
debt, and paying off the debt would be considered
a preference.
Tip
Payments Made in the Ordinary Course Transferring balances may be a preference.
of Business or Financial Affairs At least one court has found that transferring your
A payment is not a preference if it is made in the balance from one credit card to another might be
ordinary course of business or the debtor’s financial considered a preference. In that case, the debtor used her
affairs. credit on one credit card to pay off her debt on another
credit card. Because she made the transfer within three
Example: Tim, a masonry contractor, owes
months of filing for bankruptcy, and she could have used
Tom’s Tile $3,500 from a past job. Although
the money for any purpose (in other words, she didn’t
it’s always been Tim’s practice to immediately have to use it to pay off her other card), the court ruled
pay for his supplies as soon as he’s paid for that the transfer was a preference. (In re Dilworth, 560
the job, he hasn’t paid Tom’s Tile because of a F.3d 562 (8th Cir. 2009).)
ChaPter 5 | Your Bankruptcy estate | 77
If You’ve Made Preference Payments exceptions. If you acquire (or become entitled to
The consequences of violating the preference rules acquire) certain items within 180 days after you
can be harsh. The bankruptcy trustee is authorized file, you must report them to the bankruptcy
to take back the money and distribute it among court—and the trustee may take them if you can’t
your creditors. If you paid back a family member, protect them with an exemption.
this may cause some tension. Even if you paid The 180-day rule applies to:
back a creditor that isn’t an insider, it could cause • property you inherit during the 180-day
problems. For example, if you paid back a credit period (some courts have held that property
card issuer so you could keep your card, the issuer that passes to you as a beneficiary of a
will probably revoke your credit card if it has to revocable living trust is not part of your
cough up the money to the trustee. The same bankruptcy estate; see, for example, In re
problem could come up if you paid a debt to a core Mattern, 55 Collier Bankr. Cas. 2d 1677
vendor or a commercial landlord or equipment (D. Kan. 2006) and In re Roth, 289 B.R.
leasing company. 161 (D. Kan. 2003))
The trustee may not go after every preference • property from a property settlement
payment. For example, the trustee might decide agreement or divorce decree that goes into
not to go after a preference if the cost of suing effect during the 180-day period (excluding
to collect it would outweigh the amount to be child support and alimony payments), and
gained. If you can claim an exemption that covers • death benefits or life insurance policy
the preference, the trustee has even less incentive proceeds that become owed to you during
to pursue it. For example, assume your state has the 180-day period.
a wildcard exemption (discussed in Ch. 6) for up You must report these items on a supplemental
to $5,000 of any property. If the trustee discovers form, even if your bankruptcy case is over before
a preference payment of up to $5,000, and you the 180-day time period is up. (You can find
haven’t used any of the wildcard exemption, the instructions for filing the supplemental form in
trustee has no reason to undo the preference. Ch. 10.)
Even if the trustee went to the trouble to get If you convert from a Chapter 7 bankruptcy to
the preference back, you would get to keep the a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, the 180-day period runs
money when it is returned to the bankruptcy from the date you originally filed for Chapter 7, not
estate; forcing your creditor to pay the money back from the date you converted to Chapter 13. (In re
wouldn’t raise any money for your other creditors. Carter, 260 B.R. 130 (W.D. Tenn. 2001).)
Even though you can’t pay a favorite creditor
before you file, nothing prevents you from doing
so after you file, as long as you do it with income
Property That Is Not in
earned after you file for bankruptcy or with Your Bankruptcy Estate
property that isn’t in your bankruptcy estate. Property that is not in your bankruptcy estate is
not subject to the bankruptcy court’s jurisdiction,
Certain Property Acquired which means that the bankruptcy trustee can’t take
Within 180 Days After You File it to pay your creditors under any circumstances.
Property that belongs to someone else is not
Most property you acquire—or become entitled
part of your bankruptcy estate—even if you
to acquire—after you file for bankruptcy isn’t
control the property—because you don’t have the
included in your bankruptcy estate. But there are
right to sell it or give it away.
78 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
Example 1: A parent establishes a trust for her “Certain Property Acquired Within 180
child and names you as the trustee to manage Days After You File,” above)
the money in the trust until the child’s 18th • pensions and retirement plans
birthday. You possess and control the money, • property in a spendthrift trust that cannot
but it’s solely for the child’s benefit under the be reached by the debtor’s creditors
terms of the trust; you cannot use it for your • tax-deferred education funds, with certain
own purposes. It isn’t part of your bankruptcy conditions and restrictions
estate. • property pledged as collateral for a loan,
if a licensed lender (pawnbroker) retains
Example 2: Your sister has gone to Zimbabwe
possession of the collateral
for an indefinite period and has loaned you her
• property in your possession that belongs to
computer system while she’s gone. Although
someone else (for instance, property you are
you might have use of the equipment for years
storing for someone)
to come, you don’t own it. It isn’t part of your
• wages that are withheld, and employer
bankruptcy estate.
contributions that are made, for employee
Example 3: You are making monthly benefit and health insurance plans, and
payments on a leased car. You are entitled • child support arrearages owed to the debtor,
to possess the car as long as you make the because the parent is entitled to the funds
monthly payments, but you don’t own it. It only in his or her capacity as trustee for the
is not part of your bankruptcy estate (but the child. (In re Perry, No. 06-50237 (Bkrtcy
lease itself is). D. So. Dak. 2009).)
Example 4: Your name appears on the title
(and note) to your son’s car because he was too Tip
young to get a loan when he bought it. Your Retirement accounts are exempt. When
son makes all the payments. While the two Congress passed the new bankruptcy law in 2005, it
of you probably consider the car to “belong” created a broad exemption for all types of tax-exempt
to your son, the bankruptcy laws initially retirement accounts, including 401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit
consider it to be yours, and you have to sharing and money purchase plans, IRAs (including Roth,
disclose it in your bankruptcy paperwork. You SEP, and SIMPLE IRAs), and defined-benefit plans. These
can explain that you have “bare legal title” exemptions are unlimited—that is, the entire account is
and your son is the equitable owner, which exempt, regardless of how much money is in it—except
means it shouldn’t be considered part of your in the case of traditional and Roth IRAs. For these types
bankruptcy estate. However, the court may of IRAs only, the exemption is limited to a total value of
$1,095,000 per person (this figure is adjusted every three
disagree, which means your son could lose the
years for inflation).
car unless it fits within an available exemption.
Courts have gone both ways on this issue; you
Under the 2005 bankruptcy law, funds
should definitely talk to a lawyer if valuable
placed in a qualified tuition program or Coverdell
property held this way is at stake.
education savings account are also not part of your
Other types of property that don’t fall within bankruptcy estate, as long as:
your bankruptcy estate are: • the beneficiary of the account is your child,
• property you buy or receive after your filing stepchild, grandchild, step-grandchild, or in
date (with the few exceptions described in some cases, foster child, and
ChaPter 5 | Your Bankruptcy estate | 79
It’s common for older parents to put an adult child’s If you are able to exempt the account, you can
name on the parent’s bank account. This allows the just list it on Schedule B as your own property and
child to write checks and otherwise manage the avoid any argument over who owns it. For example,
account if the parent becomes unable to do so; it also suppose your mother has put your name on her
means the account goes straight to the child when the savings account, which has a balance of $4,000. If the
parent dies, outside of probate or other inheritance exemption system you are using in your bankruptcy
procedures. protects that amount of money (and you don’t have
If you are named on someone else’s account and an account of your own to protect), you could list the
file for bankruptcy, however, that account could be account on your personal property schedule (Schedule
considered property of your bankruptcy estate, subject B) and claim the full amount as exempt on your
to being taken by the trustee for the benefit of your Schedule C. That way you won’t have to argue over who
unsecured creditors. Of course, it’s not really your owns the money; either way, the trustee can’t take it.
money while your parent is living, but if the trustee To avoid all this trouble, you may be tempted
thinks you are free to withdraw the money and use it to remove your name from the account before you
for your own purposes (as lowdown as that would be), file bankruptcy. Don’t do it. Removing your name
the trustee may consider at least some of it to be part makes it look like you are trying to hide the whole
of your bankruptcy estate. issue from the bankruptcy court. The trustee might
In this situation, it’s important to tell the trustee, well convince the court to dismiss your bankruptcy
up front, that it really isn’t your money to use as you altogether, on the ground that you committed fraud
wish. It would be a breach of your fiduciary duty (duty on the court. You’re better off leaving your name on
of trust) toward the account holder—and possibly the account and explaining the situation to the trustee.
elder abuse—for you to use the money for any If there is significant money in the account, consider
purpose other than his or her welfare. To make sure consulting with a lawyer about the best way to handle
that the trustee understands why you are named on the situation in your paperwork. Incidentally, if you
the account, you should declare the account on your are thinking that the trustee won’t find out about the
property schedule (Schedule B) but explain that it account if you don’t list it, don’t go there. They have
really isn’t yours. You should identify the account and their ways.
explain why you are named on it in Question 14 on Custodian Note: If you are listed as a custodian or
the Statement of Financial Affairs. Finally, you would a trustee of the account funds for a minor under the
be well advised to gather documents showing that the Uniform Transfers to Minors Act, you don’t have to
sources of the money in the account clearly belong to worry about the bankruptcy trustee taking the funds.
the main account owner. (See Ch. 9 for more on these The law is clear that those funds belong to the minor,
paperwork requirements.) not to you in your fiduciary capacity as a custodian or
trustee.
80 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
you’ll need to fill out forms listing what property If you are entitled to choose between state or
you own, how much it’s worth, and what you claim federal exemptions, you must select one system or
as exempt. The work you do in this chapter can be the other: You can’t mix and match, using some
transferred to those forms. exemptions from one list and some from the other.
However, if you use one system when you first file
related topic
your petition and later decide that the other system
would work better for you, you can usually amend
For home and real estate exemptions, see
Ch. 7. This chapter explains how exemptions work gener
your bankruptcy paperwork to change systems.
ally, and provides detailed information on exemptions for California has adopted its own unique
personal and business property. For many bankruptcy exemption system. Although California law doesn’t
filers, however, the main concern is whether they’ll allow debtors to use the federal exemptions,
be able to keep their home. Because this is such an California offers two sets of state exemptions.
important issue, we’ve devoted a separate chapter (Ch. 7) With a few important exceptions, the second set of
to exemptions that apply to your home and other real California exemptions are the same as the federal
estate. exemptions. As in the states that have the federal
bankruptcy exemptions, people filing for bank
ruptcy in California must choose one or the other
set of state exemptions.
How Exemptions Work
Each state’s legislature has created a set of Tip
exemptions primarily for use by people who are You might be able to keep your nonexempt
residents of that state. These state exemptions apply property. If you have property that does not fall within
both to bankruptcy cases and to all other collection an exemption, the trustee won’t necessarily take it. You
efforts. In addition, 16 states (and the District of may not have to surrender nonexempt property if you
Columbia) allow debtors to choose between their have the cash to buy it back from the trustee, who will
state’s exemptions or another set of exemptions often accept less than its replacement value to avoid
created by Congress, called federal bankruptcy having to collect, store, and sell it at auction (probably
exemptions. for far less than its full value). Instead of cash, the trustee
may be willing to accept exempt property of roughly
equal value instead. Also, the trustee might choose to
States That Allow Debtors to
reject or abandon the item (in other words, to let you
Choose the Federal Exemptions
keep it), if it would be too costly or cumbersome to sell
Arkansas New Jersey
and you aren’t willing or able to buy it back. So when
Connecticut New Mexico we say that you have to give up property, remember
District of Columbia Pennsylvania that you still might be able to keep it, depending on the
circumstances.
Hawaii Rhode Island
Kentucky Texas
Massachusetts Vermont
Types of Exemptions
Michigan Washington
Both state and federal exemptions come in several
Minnesota Wisconsin
basic flavors.
New Hampshire
84 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
other states, you may be able to use the tools of the roperty, and which types of property, a debtor
p
trade exemption even if you have no plans to use should be forced to give up when a creditor collects
that property to make a living in the future. on a judgment. These attitudes are rooted in local
Tools of the trade used to include only hand values and concerns. But in many cases there is
tools, but now it refers more broadly to the things another reason why state exemptions differ. Some
you need in order to do the job you rely on for state legislatures have raised exemption levels in
support. Here are some examples: recent times, while other states haven’t looked at
• art camera, scanner (artist) their exemptions for decades. In states that don’t
• car or van that is used for more than just reconsider their exemptions very often, you can
commuting (sales manager, insurance expect to find lower dollar amounts.
adjuster, physician, traveling salesperson,
real estate salesperson)
Exemptions and Business Assets
• truck (logger, tire retreader, truck driver,
farmer, electrician, mechanic) Other than the “tools of the trade” exemption,
• cream separator, dairy cows, animal feed there are almost no state exemptions explicitly
(farmer) for business assets or the value of the business
• drills, saws (carpenter) as reflected in its goodwill. Historically, business
• electric motor, lathe (mechanic) owners have used Chapter 7 bankruptcy to
• guitar, acoustic amplifier, coronet, violin liquidate the business (sell the business or, more
and bow, organ, speaker cabinet (musician) frequently, its assets in an auction). Those who
• hair dye, shampoo, cash register, furniture, wanted to keep the business operating used
dryer, fan, curler, magazine rack (barber, Chapter 11 bankruptcy. In keeping with this
beauty parlor operator) practice, legislatures have seen no reason to
• oven, mixer (baker) extend exemptions to business assets or goodwill
• personal computer, printer (insurance in Chapter 7 bankruptcies. (See Ch. 3 for more on
salesperson, lawyer, accountant) Chapter 11 bankruptcy.)
• photographic lenses and darkroom If your business is a sole proprietorship,
equipment (photographer) however, you may be able to protect your business
• power chain saw (firewood salesperson) assets using personal exemptions. For example, if
you have a truck that you use in your handyman
• sewing machine (tailor).
sole proprietorship business, you can apply a
state vehicle exemption. And, if your state offers
Why State Exemptions Vary So Much a wildcard exemption, you can use that for any
Each state’s exemptions are unique. The property property you wish, including your business assets
you can keep, therefore, varies considerably from and inventory. (As explained in Ch. 1, if your
state to state. Why the differences? As mentioned, business has assets or inventory that could easily
be sold while you are in bankruptcy, you may have
state exemptions are used not only for bankruptcy
to close your business, at least temporarily, so the
purposes but also to shelter property that otherwise
trustee has an opportunity to appraise the assets
could be taken by creditors who have obtained
and analyze whether they fit within your claimed
court judgments. The exemptions reflect the
exemptions.)
attitudes of state legislators about how much
86 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
Domicile/Residency Requirements than two years, you can file in that state.
for Using State Exemptions However, you must use the exemptions
of the state where you were domiciled
Prior to the 2005 bankruptcy law revisions, for the better part of the 180-day period
filers used the exemptions of the state where they immediately prior to the two-year period
resided when they filed for bankruptcy. Under the preceding your filing.
revised rules, however, some filers have to use the • If you have had your domicile in your
exemptions of the state where they used to reside. current state for less than 91 days, you
Congress was concerned about people gaming can either file for bankruptcy in the state
the system by moving to states with generous where you lived immediately before (as long
exemptions, just to file for bankruptcy. As a result, as you lived there for at least 91 days) or
it created domicile requirements that filers have wait until you have logged 91 days in your
to meet before they can use a state’s exemption new home and file in your current state.
system. Once you figure out where you can file for
To apply these rules, you must first understand bankruptcy, you’ll need to use whatever
where your domicile is. Domicile has been exemptions are available to you according to
defined as the place where someone has his or her the rules set out above.
“true fixed and permanent home and principal • If the state you are filing in offers a choice
establishment” and to which the person intends between the state and federal bankruptcy
to return after any period of absence. This means exemptions, you can use the federal
something more than your residence, which exemption list regardless of how long you’ve
generally means wherever you are living at any been living in the state. In other words, the
given time. rules of the state where a person files for
Your domicile is the place where you are living bankruptcy determine whether the filer can
and intend to live for the indefinite future, the use the federal exemptions, even if the filer
place where you work, vote, receive your mail, pay has not lived in the state long enough to use
taxes, do your banking, own property, participate its state exemptions.
in public affairs, register your car, apply for your • If these rules deprive you of the right to
driver’s license, and send your children to school. use any state’s exemptions, you can use
Your domicile might not be the state where you the federal exemptions, even if they aren’t
are actually living when you file for bankruptcy. otherwise available in the state where you
For example, members of the military, professional file. For example, some states allow their
athletes, and corporate officers all might spend exemptions to be used only by current
significant amounts of time working in another state residents, which might leave former
state or country, but their domicile is the state residents who haven’t lived in their new
where they make their permanent home. home state for at least two years without
Here are the rules that govern which state’s any available state exemptions. (See, for
exemptions you must use: example, In re Underwood, 342 B.R. 358
• If you have made your domicile in your (N.D. Fla. 2006); In re Crandall, 346 B.R.
current state for at least two years, you can 220 (M.D. Fla. 2006); and In re West, 352
use that state’s exemptions. B.R. 905 (M.D. Fla. 2006).) If you have
• If you have had your domicile in your recently returned to the U.S. after being
current state for more than 91 days but less domiciled in another country, and no state
ChaPter 6 | Understanding Property Exemptions | 87
exemption system is available to you under As it turns out, however, Texas gives filers
these rules, you are also entitled to use the the option of using either its state exemptions
federal exemptions. or the federal bankruptcy exemptions. Because
the rules of the state where a person files for
bankruptcy determine whether the federal
CAUTION
exemptions are available, Sammie Jo can use
A longer domicile requirement applies
the federal exemptions instead of the South
to homestead exemptions. If you acquired a home in
your current state within the 40 months before you
Carolina state exemptions. Under the federal
file for bankruptcy (and you didn’t purchase it with exemptions, Sammie Jo is entitled to exempt
the proceeds from selling another home in that state), a motor vehicle worth up to $3,225—still
your homestead exemption will be subject to a cap not enough to cover her van. But wait: The
of $136,875, even if the state homestead exemption federal exemptions also provide a wildcard of
available to you is larger. For detailed information on $1,075, plus $10,125 of homestead exemption
homestead exemptions, see Ch. 7. (together $11,200). Sammie Jo doesn’t own
her home, so she can add the entire wildcard
exemption of $11,200 to her $3,225 vehicle
Example 1: Sammie Jo lives in South Carolina
exemption, for a total exemption of $14,425,
from July 2008 until January 2010, when
which she can apply to her van to keep it.
she gets lucky at a casino, moves to Texas,
and starts a dog walking business with her Example 2: Julia ran a day care center in
winnings. She buys a Dodge Sprinter for North Dakota for many years. As part of her
$20,000 and has her new business name, health care and retirement plan, she had set
VanDog, painted on the side. Her business up a high-deductible health care plan with a
really never takes off, and in March 2011, health care savings account (HSA). In January
Sammie Jo files for Chapter 7 personal 2010, when she has $20,000 in her HSA,
bankruptcy in Texas. Her van is now worth she closes down her business and moves to
$14,000. Because Sammie Jo has been living Florida. She files for bankruptcy in Florida
in Texas for only 14 months—not two years— on November 30, 2011, 23 months later.
she can’t use the Texas exemption for vehicles, Because she has lived in Florida for slightly
which can be up to $30,000, depending on less than two years when she files, she must
the value of other personal property that a filer use the exemptions from the state where she
claims as exempt. Because Sammie Jo filed lived for the better part of the 180-day period
for bankruptcy in March 2011, she must use that ended two years before she filed—which
the exemptions of the state where she lived for is North Dakota. As it turns out, Julia’s most
most of the six-month period ending two years valuable possession is her $20,000 HSA.
before she filed for bankruptcy, or March While the account would be exempt under
2009. Sammie Jo lived in South Carolina for Florida law, North Dakota has no exemption
the six months prior to March 2009, so she for this type of property. Nor are the federal
must use the South Carolina exemptions. As exemptions available in Florida. So the trustee
it turns out, the South Carolina exemption will probably seize the HSA and use the
for vehicles is only $5,000, which means that money in it to pay Julia’s creditors. Had Julia
Sammie Jo will probably lose her van if she waited another month to file, she would have
uses the South Carolina exemptions.
88 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
■ Antiques ■ Photographs
■ Clocks Apparel
■ Dishes ■ Clothing
■ Food (total value) ■ Furs
■ Furniture (list every item; go from room to room
so you don’t miss anything) Jewelry
■ Gardening tools ■ Engagement and wedding rings
■ Lamps ■ Watches
■ Ski equipment Other debts for which the amount owed you is
■ Other sports equipment known and definite
■ Other weapons (swords and knives) ■ Disability benefits due
■ Disability insurance due
Interests in insurance policies
■ Judgments obtained against third parties you
■ Credit insurance
haven’t yet collected
■ Disability insurance
■ Sick pay earned
■ Health insurance
■ Social Security benefits due
■ Homeowners’ or renters’ insurance
■ Tax refund due under returns already filed
■ Term life insurance
■ Vacation pay earned
■ Whole life insurance
■ Wages due
Annuities ■ Workers’ compensation due
Pension or profit-sharing plans Any special powers that you or another person can
■ IRA exercise for your benefit, other than those listed under
“real estate”
■ Keogh
■ A right to receive, at some future time, cash, stock,
■ Pension or retirement plan or other personal property placed in an irrevocable
■ 401(k) plan trust
■ Current payments of interest or principal from a
Stock and interests in incorporated and
trust
unincorporated companies
■ General power of appointment over personal
■ Corporate shares
property
■ Stock options
■ LLC membership An interest in property due to another person’s death
■ Sole proprietorship business ■ Any interest as the beneficiary of a living trust, if
the trustor has died
Interests in partnerships ■ Expected proceeds from a life insurance policy
■ Limited partnership interest where the insured has died
■ General partnership interest ■ Inheritance from an existing estate in probate
(the owner has died and the court is overseeing
Government and corporate bonds and other the distribution of the property), even if the final
investment instruments amount is not yet known
■ Corporate bonds
ChAPter 6 | UNDERSTANDING PROPERTY ExEMPTIONS | 91
■ Outboard motor
92 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
Using the Property For cash on hand and deposits of money, indicate
Exemption Worksheet the source of each, such as wages or salary,
insurance policy proceeds, or the proceeds from
Now that you have a comprehensive list of your selling an item of property. Although cash on hand
property, you can decide how to use the exemptions is usually not exempt, you may be able to exempt
available to you to your best advantage. This will all or some of it if you can show that it came
require you to come up with a value for each item, from an exempt source, such as unemployment
decide which exemption system to use (if you insurance.
have a choice), then figure out how to apply those
exemptions to your property. Column 2: Replacement Value
To do this, use the Property Exemption Work- Enter the replacement value of each item of
sheet in Appendix B. A portion of the worksheet property in Column 1. (Under the former rules,
is set out below. As you can see, it includes four filers used the market value—what they could get
columns: for the property if they sold it at their own garage
1. a description of the property sale. The 2005 bankruptcy law requires filers to use
2. the property’s replacement value the replacement value, which is typically a higher
3. the exemption (if any) that applies to the figure.)
property, and
4. the number of the statute where that
TIP
exemption appears (you’ll need this
Trustees are often more interested in
information when you complete your
what the property would fetch at auction. You are
bankruptcy forms).
supposed to use the replacement value of property in
Complete each of these columns following the
your bankruptcy papers. However, the trustee will be
instructions below.
more interested in how much money could be made
Column 1: Property Description from selling the property, often at auction at an extreme
discount. For example, a car with a replacement value of
Using your completed checklist as a guide, describe
$10,000 might sell for $6,000 at auction, and the trustee
each item of property and its location. For personal might let you keep it if you can come up with about
property, identify the item (for example, 1994 Ford $3,000 in cash. Why? Because the trustee would have to
Mustang) and its location (for example, residence). take the car, store it, get permission from the judge to
1 2 3 4
Replacement
Property Value Exemption Statute No.
1. Cash on hand
sell it, and then sell it, typically for less than it’s worth. go for a used laptop computer, lathe, or mechanics
To save these costs, most trustees will be willing to take tools? These days, your best bet for valuing property
significantly less than the replacement value—and even may be Google, Craigslist or eBay on the Internet.
less than the property would sell for at auction—and If you can’t find it there, you’ll have to value your
let you keep the property. Be aware, however, that some property by estimating what it would sell for in
trustees are more inclined to squeeze every last dollar a local flea market or classified section of a news
out of a debtor’s property; if your case is assigned to one paper, online or off.
of them, you shouldn’t count on keeping property that Small businesses typically have property that
isn’t fully exempt (or close to it). can readily be valued. For retail or manufacturing
businesses, for example, you may have inventory
It’s easy to enter a dollar amount for cash, that could easily be liquidated on the open market.
bank deposits, bonds, and most investment Here are some examples of other business assets
instruments. For items that are tougher to value, you might need to list:
such as business equipment, machinery, inventory, • business equipment, such as computers,
an ownership interest in an LLC or a corporation, phones, cash registers, credit card machines
insurance, annuities, and pensions, you may need • inventory, components, and materials
to get an appraisal from someone who has some • office furniture, art, and supplies
financial expertise. • vehicles and tools
For your other property, estimate its replace • real estate
ment value—that is, what you could buy it for from • security deposits with landlords, utilities, or
a retail vendor, considering its age and condition. taxing agencies, and
As long as you have a reasonable basis for your • prepaid insurance premiums you can get
estimates, the lower the value you place on property, refunded to you.
the more of it you will be allowed to keep. But be As a general rule, tangible business assets are
honest when assigning values. Trustees have years of fairly easy to value. You can use eBay, craigslist, or
experience and a pretty good sense of what property bid4assets.com to find prices for comparable items.
is worth. It’s okay to be wrong as long as you have There also may be specialized auction sites for your
an arguable basis for the value you list and briefly industry that you could consult.
explain any uncertainties. If you can’t come up with Intangible business property. In addition to
a replacement value, leave this column blank. If you tangible property, your business may own intangible
file for bankruptcy, you can simply indicate that property you should record on your Property
the value is unknown. If the trustee is concerned Exemption Worksheet, such as:
about the value, you will be asked at your creditors’ • accounts receivable (see below)
meeting to provide more detail. • works in progress that could have some value
Putting a value on personal property can be • your customer list and your company name
a difficult task. Here are some tips for valuing (essentially, the goodwill your company has
specific items. built up—see below)
Tangible property. If the property you are trying • intellectual property such as copyrights,
to value can be readily purchased from a vendor on patents, and trademarks (see below)
the open market, you can use what you’d have to • a commercial lease at below-market rent
pay for it. You can visit local stores to get a price; and/or at a good location
for instance, many areas have used appliance stores, • contracts with suppliers at below-market
and used furniture can readily be purchased from rates, and
the Salvation Army or Goodwill. But where do you • contracts with customers at profitable rates.
94 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
Accounts receivable. The value of accounts not have goodwill worth a significant amount. The
receivable depends on whether they are current or value of goodwill is what’s left when you subtract
past due, so you shouldn’t just list their face value. all property, accounts receivable, and intangible
A current account receivable (one that fell due assets such as intellectual property, from the value
within the last 30 days) is worth much more than a of the business. If you think your business has
90-day past due account that you’ve already tried to enough goodwill that someone would want to buy
collect with no results. The most common method your business name or your customer list, you may
to estimate the collectability of receivables is to need to contact an expert in business valuations—a
use an aging schedule. In a typical aging schedule, business appraiser—who can determine how much
accounts receivable are divided into categories of this intangible aspect of your business might be
current, 31-60 days, 61-90 days, and over 90 days worth. (See “Finding a Business Appraiser,” below.)
past due. But it will be up to you to estimate how Appraisers are expensive, however, so it might be
collectible your accounts receivable are based on best to wait and let the trustee decide on what the
your past collection experiences. For instance, you value of the company’s goodwill might be.
might estimate that 90% of your current accounts
receivable will be paid, 70% of those between 31
Finding a Business Appraiser
and 60 days, 50% of those between 61 and 90
days, and 40% of those over 90 days. You would Anyone can value a business—generally, there are
then multiply the amount of accounts receivable in no licensing requirements for business appraisers.
each category by these percentages to come up with However, we suggest hiring an independent
a value for the accounts receivable in each category, appraiser with professional credentials. While many
and then total them up for the total value of your appraisers are also certified public accountants,
accounts receivable. the American Society of Appraisers (a widely
respected private accreditation group) uses these
Sample Aging Schedule designations:
Percentage Discounted • AM (Accredited Member): requires two
Category Amount Collectible Amount years of full-time appraisal experience
<30 days $50,000 90% $45,000 • ASA (Accredited Senior Appraiser): requires
five years of full-time appraisal experience
31-60 days $40,000 70% $28,000
• FASA (Fellow Appraiser): an Accredited
60-90 days $30,000 50% $15,000
Senior Appraiser who has been recognized
over 90 days $40,000 40% $16,000 by ASA’s International Board of Governors
Total $160,000 $104,000 for outstanding services to the appraisal
profession and/or the Society of Appraisers.
Another group, which accredits appraisers of
Goodwill. Goodwill represents how customers
closely held businesses according to education and
feel about your business, as evidenced by the
experience qualifications, is the Institute of Business
business’s history of customer recognition and
Appraisers—see its website at www.go-iba.org.
patronage. For example, if Joe’s Liquor has been
doing business on the corner of 5th and Main in
Whoseville for 25 years, the store’s “goodwill” may
Intellectual property. Your business may have
be worth many thousands of dollars because of the
valuable intellectual property, such as trademarks,
number of customers who have patronized it over
patents, trade secrets, and copyrights. For example,
the years. However, most small businesses that are
assume Valerie is half-owner of a start-up LLC
newer or don’t have a widely recognized name do
ChaPter 6 | Understanding Property Exemptions | 95
that manufactures solar-powered eyeglasses for similar businesses, particularly when a business
with mini windshield wipers, for use in snowy is floundering. For example, assume Valerie’s LLC
climates. Valerie’s company might own a patent is roughly $50,000 in the red and isn’t expected
in its eyeglass wiper design, a valuable and unique to make much money over the next several years.
trademark under which to market the eyeglasses What is the LLC worth? Possibly not much, but
(Vision Wipes), a trade secret involving its if the LLC showed promise of making a decent
innovative manufacturing techniques, and maybe profit in the future, the ownership interest might
even a copyright in pamphlets explaining the care be worth a considerable sum, and the trustee
and use of the product. could market the ownership interest to interested
Valuing intellectual property is often diffi members of the public, competitors, or co-owners.
cult in bankruptcy because its value lies in its One way to put a value on a business (which
potential to yield future profits, not as a present you can use to come up with a value for a partial
source of cash that the trustee can use to pay off ownership interest) is to find out how much
your creditors. However, the trustee may shop similar businesses are selling for. But, depending
your company’s intellectual property around to on the competitive pressures in your industry, the
appropriate businesses (perhaps your competitors) economy, the financial wellbeing of your business,
to see whether there are any takers. Copyrights plus other factors, the value of your company
owned by small businesses, by themselves, are often could be more or less than what a similar business
essentially worthless. sold for.
Another way to value a business is by using a
formula such as assets minus liabilities (that is, the
Resource
current fair market value of the company’s assets
Need more information on intellectual
minus the company’s liabilities) or a capitalization
property? Pick up a copy of Patent, Copyright and
Trademark, by Richard Stim (Nolo), a desk reference that
of earnings method (the company’s average annual
includes all you need to know about these important earnings multiplied by a certain number of years).
business assets. If the ownership interest is likely to be worth a sig-
nificant amount of money, you may want to consult
Ownership of business entities. If you are sole or with an appraiser to put a value on the company; see
part owner of a limited liability company (LLC), “Finding a Business Appraiser,” above.”
corporation, or partnership, you’ll need to know If you own a minority share of the business,
the value of your ownership interest to figure out however, there may be no market for your
whether you can protect it with the exemptions ownership interest—that is, no one may want to
available to you. buy it, assuming the other owners aren’t in the
Ownership shares in small business entities market to sell the business. It’s often impossible to
are notoriously hard to value. Of course, if a find an interested buyer for a minority interest in a
corporation’s stock is trading on an exchange, you company. After all, a minority share gives an owner
can use that value. But small, private corporations little or no control over how the business is run
and LLCs pose a much tougher valuation problem. and no guarantee of profits. Because of this, the
Unless the board or management is in the practice IRS allows a valuation discount of 20–40% to be
of deciding on a value for the company on a routine applied to the value of minority interests because
basis, some guesswork will have to take place. For of their lack of marketability. And if there are
one thing, unlike publicly traded corporations, restrictions on whether you can sell your minority
there is no public market for small business interest, the ownership interest might even be
interests, so it’s hard to establish comparative prices worth 30–60% less than an unrestricted, majority
96 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
if the domicile requirements leave you with no wish to claim under that exemption. Then compare
available state exemptions, you must use the the total with the exemption limit. If the total
federal exemption list; you don’t have a choice of is less than the limit, then there is no problem.
exemptions. However, if the total is more than the limit, you
If you have only one set of exemptions to may have to either give the trustee enough property
consider, follow these steps: to bring your total back under the limit or apply
Step 1: In Column 3, list the amount of the a wildcard exemption to the extra property, if the
exemption or write “no limit” if the exemption is system you are using has one. The trustee may not
unlimited. In Column 4, list the number of the be interested in used furniture or other items that
statute identified in Appendix A for the exemption will fetch little or nothing at an auction, even if
that may reasonably be applied to that item. If you the replacement value is officially higher than the
need more information or an explanation of terms, exemption limit. In these instances, the trustee will
check the notes at the beginning of Appendix simply “abandon” the property, which means you
A and the glossary. In evaluating whether your can keep it even if it doesn’t fit entirely within the
cash and deposits are exempt, look to the source exemption.
of the money, such as welfare benefits, insurance
proceeds, or wages. If You Have a Choice of Exemption Systems
If the state system you’re using allows you to use
the federal exemptions or you qualify to use the
Tip
California exemptions (which give you a choice
Err on the side of exemption. If you can
between two state systems), you’ll need to decide
think of a reason why a particular item might be exempt,
which exemption system to use. You can’t use some
list it even if you aren’t sure that the exemption applies.
exemptions from one system and some from the
If you file for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, you will only be
other. If you own a home in which you have equity,
expected to do your best to fit the exemptions to your
property. Of course, if you do misapply an exemption
your choice will often be dictated by which system
and the bankruptcy trustee or a creditor files a formal gives you the most protection for that equity. In
objection within the required time, you may have to California, for example, the homestead exemption
scramble to keep the property that you mistakenly in System 1 protects from $75,000 to $175,000 in
thought was exempt. If you have property that you equity (depending on factors such as age, income,
would hate to lose but you aren’t sure whether it fits and disability), while the System 2 list protects
within an exemption, pay for a consultation with a only $21,825 (including the $1,100 wildcard).
bankruptcy attorney on the issue. (See Ch. 12 for more While System 1 used to be the system of choice for
on bankruptcy attorneys.) California homeowners, that’s not necessarily the
case since home values have declined so sharply.
Step 2: If a particular exemption has no Unless your choice of exemption lists is
dollar limit, then apply that exemption to all dictated by your home equity, you’ll be best
property items that seem to fall into that category. served by going through the Property Exemption
For example, if you can exempt all household Worksheet twice. The first time through, use the
furnishings without limit, list all furniture, state exemptions (or System 1 in California). The
appliances, home theater and stereo equipment, second time, use the federal exemptions (or System
tableware, linens, rugs, and so on in this category. 2 in California).
If there is a limit (for instance, an exemption allows After you apply both exemption lists to your
you to keep up to $1,000 worth of electronic property, compare the results and decide which
products), total the value of all property items you exemption list will do you the most good. You may
98 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
find that one set of exemptions is more generous exemption, and Paula can now exempt
or better protects the property you really want to $2,875. This doesn’t begin to cover the
keep. You may be sorely tempted to pluck some value of her computer equipment, which
exemptions out of one list and add them to the means that if Paula uses the Michigan state
other list. Again, this can’t be done. You’ll either exemptions the trustee would probably sell the
have to use your state’s exemption list or the federal equipment, give Paula her $2,875 exemption,
exemptions—you can’t mix and match. and distribute the rest of the sales proceeds to
Paula’s unsecured creditors.
Example: Paula Willmore lives in Detroit,
Paula next checks to see whether Michigan
Michigan, and runs a storefront computer
allows debtors to use the federal bankruptcy
repair shop. Business has been dwindling
exemptions. She looks at the top of the
over the last two years. Paula decides she can’t
exemption page and sees a note that the
continue to lose money and float the business
federal bankruptcy exemptions are available
with her personal credit cards, so she closes
to Michigan filers. Hoping that the federal
her doors. Deep in personal debt, Paula files
exemptions will give her a higher exemption
for Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy. Other
limit for her computer equipment, she
than clothing, household furniture, and
turns to the end of Appendix A (right after
personal effects, Paula owns several computers,
Wyoming) and finds the federal bankruptcy
accessories (such as scanners and zip drives),
exemption list. Under personal property she
and some inventory (computer parts, spare
sees household goods to $525 per item. Even if
hard drives, and so on). Paula often reads
computers fall into this category (they usually
computer magazines and knows that her
don’t if they’re used for business purposes),
computers and parts are worth about $12,000,
it’s still not enough to do her much good.
total. Paula wants to know if she will lose her
She next notes a tools of trade exemption
property.
for $2,025, which won’t cover much of her
Because Paula has lived in Michigan for
equipment. Paula then examines the federal
more than two years, she will use that state’s
bankruptcy exemptions to see whether they
exemption rules. Her first step is to locate
provide a wildcard exemption. She discovers
the exemptions for Michigan in Appendix A.
that the federal bankruptcy exemptions let
Near the bottom of the Michigan exemption
you use up to $10,125 of the homestead
listings for personal property, Paula finds
exemption as a wildcard. Because Paula has
an entry for computers and accessories and
no home equity to protect, she can apply
sees that the exemption is $575. Paula begins
the wildcard to the computer equipment, in
to worry that she may lose her computers,
addition to the tools of trade exemption for
which she’d like to keep in the hopes that she
$2,025. Further, Paula sees that she can get
can continue to work with computers on a
an additional wildcard exemption of $1,075
freelance basis from home.
under the federal exemption list. Putting
Paula’s next step is to search the Michigan
these exemptions together, Paula sees she can
state exemptions for a tools of trade exemption.
exempt up to $13,225 of property—more than
Paula discovers that she has a $2,300 tools
the value of her computer equipment.
of trade exemption that she can apply to
Because the federal bankruptcy exemptions
tools, materials, and other property. Paula
let Paula keep all of her computer equipment
next looks for a wildcard exemption, but
while the state exemptions don’t, Paula decides
Michigan doesn’t offer one. Add the tools
to use the federal bankruptcy exemption list.
of trade exemption to the $575 computer
ChaPter 6 | Understanding Property Exemptions | 99
decision.) Payments over these limits may be could hold on to it through bankruptcy,
considered a preference, and the trustee may making regular payments on the loan. The
be able to get the money back and add it to trustee would not take the truck to sell it,
your bankruptcy estate. (See Ch. 5 for more because there would be no money left for
on preference payments.) If the creditor you unsecured creditors if the truck were sold
pay is a relative, close friend, or company in with $5,000 in debt still hanging over it.
which you are an officer, you should wait at And John might be able to hold on to the
least one year before filing, rather than just musical equipment by paying a small price
90 days. to the trustee.
• You can pay regular bills. You can pay regular
monthly bills right up until you file for
bankruptcy. So you can keep paying your You Can Pay Favored
utilities and mortgage or rent with the Creditors After You File
proceeds you make from selling nonexempt You may be tempted to leave certain creditors
property. off your bankruptcy papers, perhaps because the
• Think twice before paying secured debts. creditor is a relative or a provider of services that
If you want to use the proceeds from are important to you personally (a veterinarian or
nonexempt property to pay off a debt doctor, for example) or in your business (such as a
secured by collateral, read Ch. 8 first. If major supplier or vendor), and you want to pay that
the collateral for the debt isn’t exempt, person or business off rather than having the debt
paying off the debt won’t do you much discharged in bankruptcy. Unfortunately, bank
good because the trustee will take the ruptcy requires that all creditors be identified on
collateral when you file for bankruptcy. If the appropriate schedules. However, you can still
you have equity in the collateral that you pay a debt that has been (or will be) wiped out in
can exempt, you will be able to keep it even bankruptcy, as long as you wait until after you file
if you don’t pay off the debt before filing for and don’t use property of the estate. For instance, if
bankruptcy. you file for bankruptcy on March 12, 2011, you can
use income you earn on March 13 and afterwards
Example: John owes $5,000 on the 2004 to pay the creditor, because that income is not
Toyota utility truck he used in his plumbing part of your bankruptcy estate. One last point:
business. The truck is worth $4,000. John While you are free to pay off a discharged debt, the
sells some nonexempt musical equipment creditor is not permitted to hound you for it.
for $5,000, pays off the $5,000 truck loan,
and files for bankruptcy. It turns out that
John can e xempt only $1,000 in the motor
vehicle. The trustee orders John to turn over
CAUTION
the truck, which John does. The trustee
If you own your home. If you own your
sells the truck and gives John his $1,000
home and plan to claim a homestead exemption to
exemption amount. Not only did John
protect your home equity (see Ch. 7), your exemption can
lose his truck, but he also no longer has his
be reduced, dollar for dollar, by the value of nonexempt
musical equipment or $4,000 of the money
property you converted if (1) the conversion took place
he earned by selling it.
in the ten years before you filed for bankruptcy, and (2)
A better alternative: Because John owes
you converted the property to defraud your creditors.
more on the truck than it’s worth, he
(Homestead exemptions, including these conversion
102 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
rules, are covered in detail in Ch. 7.) Because the amount 4. Sell and buy property at reasonable prices.
of your homestead exemption often determines whether When you sell nonexempt property in order to
or not you can keep your home, you should definitely purchase exempt property, charge an amount as
not try to convert nonexempt property without close to the item’s market value as possible. This
first talking to a lawyer who knows how your local is especially true if you sell to a friend or relative.
bankruptcy court handles this issue. If you sell your brother a $900 stereo system
for $100, a creditor or the trustee may cry foul,
and the judge may agree. At the other end of
Six Guidelines for the transaction, if you pay a friend or relative
Prebankruptcy Planning significantly more for exempt property than
it is apparently worth, the court may suspect
Here are six important guidelines for staying out
that you’re just trying to transfer your assets to
of trouble when you’re making these kinds of pre-
relatives to avoid creditors.
bankruptcy transactions.
5. Don’t make last-minute transfers or purchases.
1. Don’t convert nonexempt property if you have
The longer you can wait to file for bankruptcy
equity in your home. As noted above, you risk
after making these kinds of property transfers,
losing some or all of your homestead exemption
the less likely the judge is to disapprove. For
if you engage in this type of planning. Our
example, judges frequently rule that a hasty
advice is not to do it until you talk to a lawyer.
transaction on the eve of filing shows an
2. Accurately report all your transactions on Form
intent to cheat creditors. The open, deliberate,
7, the Statement of Financial Affairs. (See Ch. 9
and advance planning of property sales and
for more on completing the official bankruptcy
purchases, however, is usually considered
forms.) If the subject comes up with the trustee,
evidence that you didn’t intend to defraud. But
creditors, or the court, freely admit that you
even this isn’t foolproof. One court ruled that
tried to arrange your property holdings before
the debtor’s deliberate planning more than a
filing for bankruptcy so that you could better
year before filing was evidence of intent to cheat
get a fresh start. Courts see frankness like this
creditors. This conflict reinforces our earlier
as a sign of honorable intentions. If you lie or
warning: You must find out your bankruptcy
attempt to conceal what you did or why you did
court’s approach before you sell nonexempt
it, the bankruptcy trustee or court may conclude
property.
that you had fraudulent intentions and either
6. Don’t just change the form of property ownership.
not allow the transaction or—even worse—
Simply changing the way property is held from
deny you a bankruptcy discharge.
a nonexempt form to an exempt form is usually
3. Sell and buy for equivalent value. If you sell
considered fraudulent.
a $2,000 nonexempt item and purchase an
exempt item obviously worth $2,000, you Example: Although he’s married, Jeff owns
shouldn’t have a problem. If, however, you sell a house as his separate property. Also, Jeff
a $2,000 nonexempt item and purchase a $400 incurred virtually all of his debts alone, so he
exempt item, be prepared to account for the plans to file for bankruptcy alone. In Jeff’s
$1,600 difference. Otherwise, the court will state, the homestead exemption is only $7,500,
probably assume that you’re trying to cheat your but Jeff’s equity in his home is nearly $30,000.
creditors and either force you to cough up the Jeff finds out that his state also exempts
$1,600 (if you still have it) or, possibly, dismiss property held as tenancy by the entirety,
your bankruptcy case. so Jeff transfers ownership of the house to
himself and his wife as tenants by the entirety.
ChaPter 6 | Understanding Property Exemptions | 103
That would normally exempt the house from • A debtor sold nonexempt property that was
all debts Jeff incurred separately. But because worth enough to pay off all her debts (but
Jeff merely changed the form of property didn’t pay them off).
ownership, rather than buying exempt • A debtor sold nonexempt items for consider
property or paying off debts to give himself ably less than they were worth.
a fresh start, the bankruptcy court would • A debtor sold valuable property to a non
probably find the transfer fraudulent and take filing spouse for one dollar.
Jeff’s house. (Jeff might get $7,500 from the • A debtor transferred nonexempt property
sale for his homestead exemption amount, but the day after a creditor won a lawsuit
not necessarily.) against him, then filed for bankruptcy.
• A debtor in a state with an “unlimited”
homestead exemption sold all of her
CAUTION nonexempt property and used the proceeds
Community property warning. As to pay off a large portion of her mortgage.
mentioned earlier, if you’re married and live in a • A debtor bought a piano and harpsichord
community property state (Alaska, Arizona, California, and a whole life insurance policy, all
Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, New Mexico, Texas, Washington, exempt in his state. He didn’t play either
or Wisconsin), the trustee can usually take both your instrument, and he had no dependents who
share of community property and your spouse’s, even needed insurance protection.
if your spouse doesn’t file for bankruptcy. But if you’re
tempted to change all or a portion of the community
property into your spouse’s separate property, beware:
Taking Out Loans to Pay
Nondischargeable Debts
Creditors or the trustee are apt to cry fraud, and the
trustee is likely to take the property anyway. Some people are tempted to borrow money to pay
off debts that aren’t dischargeable—for instance,
To give you an idea of what judges consider a student loan—and then list the new loan as a
improper behavior shortly before filing for bank dischargeable unsecured debt. Be careful if you do
ruptcy, here are some transactions that courts have this. A court could consider your actions fraudulent
found to be fraudulent: and dismiss your bankruptcy. If the court doesn’t
A debtor bought goods on credit but never paid dismiss your case, the creditor may ask the court
for them. He then sold those goods and bought to declare the debt nondischargeable. In short, if
property that he tried to exempt. you take out the loan while you’re broke and file
A debtor with nonexempt property was forced for bankruptcy soon after, you probably will be
into involuntary bankruptcy by a creditor. The penalized. And, if you borrow money or use your
debtor convinced the creditor to drop the forced credit card to pay off a nondischargeable tax debt,
bankruptcy. Then the debtor sold the nonexempt you will not be able to discharge the loan or credit
property, purchased exempt property, and filed for card charge in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy (although
Chapter 7 bankruptcy. you could in a Chapter 13 bankruptcy).
l
7
C H A P T E R
Whether you have some equity in your home or deed of trust on the home probably owns most
or you are completely underwater (that is, you of it. (Throughout this chapter, we use the term
owe more than your home is worth), filing for “mortgage” to include deeds of trust.) In addition,
Chapter 7 bankruptcy won’t ultimately prevent some homeowners have taken out a second
a foreclosure on your property if you are behind mortgage or home equity loan. And some homes
on your payments. The automatic stay will put are encumbered by mechanics’ liens, tax liens, or
foreclosure proceedings on hold while your bank judgment liens.
ruptcy case is pending, but they will start up again
once your bankruptcy is over—or sooner, if the What Happens to Your Mortgage(s)
mortgage holder convinces the court to lift the stay.
The bottom line is, no matter how you decide to Mortgages have two parts: a promissory note,
deal with your debts, you must keep making your which is your agreement to repay the debt, and
payments if you want to keep your home for the a lien on the property, which gives the lender
long run. the right to foreclose on the property to get its
money back. The promissory note will be wiped
out when your bankruptcy case is over, unless you
Real Estate Other Than Your Home reaffirm it—that is, you tell the lender you want
As explained in this chapter, most exemption
to keep the house and you enter into a new loan
systems (including the federal exemption list) agreement with the lender, which will survive your
include a homestead exemption, which protects bankruptcy. (See Ch. 8.) On the other hand, the
some or all of your equity in the home where you lien on your home is not wiped out in bankruptcy.
live. However, most exemption systems don’t have This means that you must keep making your
a specific exemption that covers real estate you payments or face foreclosure. Once the lien is paid
aren’t using as a residence, such as a vacation home, off, you will own the home just as if you had been
commercial real estate, or rental property. You may paying off the promissory note.
be able to protect your equity in other real estate Sometimes, mortgage holders refuse to accept
using a wildcard exemption (see Ch. 6). In some payments from a debtor who is in bankruptcy. If
states, you may use any portion of your homestead you tender your payments but the lender rejects
exemption that you don’t use for your home as a them, create a separate bank account in which
wildcard, which you could use to protect other real to deposit the payments each month—and be
estate. For example, if you used the West Virginia prepared to pay these funds to the lender whenever
$25,000 homestead exemption, and you had only it agrees to start taking your money again. Why
$10,000 equity in your home, you could apply the create a separate bank account? To make sure it’s
remaining $15,000 of the homestead exemption to there when you need it. If you leave that money
any other property, including other real estate. in your regular bank account, you may end up
spending it on other things. For example, if your
mortgage payment is $1,500 a month, and your
bankruptcy lasts four months, you may be in
How Bankruptcy Affects hock for $6,000 by the time your bankruptcy
a Typical Homeowner ends and you have to bring your account current.
That’s a lot of money that you might be tempted to
Most homeowners don’t really “own” much of their
spend unless you lock it away in its own dedicated
home—a bank or other lender that has a mortgage
account.
108 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
If you are interested in modifying your mortgage These days, many people have second or third
following bankruptcy (you usually may not modify mortgages on their homes that are no longer
during your bankruptcy case), you may need to secured by home equity, due to the recession.
reaffirm the promissory note. Unless you reaffirm,
Example: A few years ago, Toni took out
there will be no promissory note to modify. But
a mortgage and bought a house. As the
reaffirming a mortgage can leave you with a huge
property rose in value, Toni took out two
debt that you’ll still be responsible for after your
additional mortgages (a second deed of trust
bankruptcy, which often makes it a bad idea.
and a home equity line of credit). Now, the
Check with your bank or HUD-approved housing
house’s value has declined from $300,000
counselor (call 888-995-HOPE to find one) to
to $150,000. Toni owes $175,000 on her first
see how bankruptcy may affect your mortgage mortgage and $50,000 each on the second and
modification efforts. The best approach is often third mortgages. When the house was worth
to hold off filing for bankruptcy until your $300,000, all of the mortgages ($275,000)
modification efforts are completed—whether were covered by the home’s value. Any of the
successfully or not. mortgage holders could have foreclosed on
If you don’t reaffirm your mortgage, your their lien if Toni defaulted. If the second or
lender may allow you to keep making payments third mortgage holder tried to foreclose now,
on the house under the old terms. The lender however, all the money from the sale would go
won’t report your payments to the credit reporting to the first mortgage holder; the second and
agencies, which means your payments won’t third mortgage holders would get nothing.
help you rebuild your credit. But it’s a bad idea
to reaffirm a mortgage solely to rehabilitate your If your home’s value has declined so much
credit: For the relatively small benefit of some that a second or third mortgage holder no longer
positive credit history, you’ll be obligating yourself has any equity upon which to foreclose, and you
to repay an enormous debt for years to come. discharge the underlying debt (the promissory note)
in your bankruptcy, there will be no immediate
consequence if you stop making payments on those
mortgages. The mortgage holders can’t hold you
personally liable on the promissory note because it
What Happens to Your will have been discharged in your bankruptcy. And
Equity in Your Home there’s no reason for the holder to foreclose on the
lien, because it wouldn’t get any money from the
Even if you keep up with your mortgage payments,
foreclosure. If, however, your home later regains
you may still lose your home unless a homestead enough equity to cover the additional liens, those
exemption protects your equity. How do you liens could become valuable again; they might
measure your equity? If you were to sell your home once more be secured by your home, and could be
today, without filing for bankruptcy, the proceeds enforced through foreclosure.
from the sale would go first to the mortgage The moral of this story is pretty simple. If you
lender(s) to pay off the mortgage(s), then to any lien have more than one mortgage and are having
holders to pay off the liens, and finally to real estate trouble keeping up with your house payments,
agents to pay the costs of sale and to city or county default on the second and third mortgages first.
governments to pay off any property taxes due. You The consequences are likely to be far less severe
would get to keep anything left over: your equity. than if you default on your first mortgage.
ChaPter 7 | What Happens to Your home | 109
a motion to avoid the lien. You may also be able to About the only way Chapter 7 bankruptcy
get rid of some liens by filing a separate lawsuit in can help you hang on to your home for the long
bankruptcy court. You can find more information haul is by discharging your other debts, which will
on lien avoidance in Ch. 8. allow you to devote more money to getting current
on your mortgage to prevent foreclosure. Also, if
What Happens to Foreclosure your property has sufficiently decreased in value,
Proceedings Chapter 7 bankruptcy can effectively eliminate the
need to pay your second and third mortgages, as
Chapter 7 bankruptcy’s automatic stay (covered in explained above.
Ch. 4) won’t prevent an eventual foreclosure if you If foreclosure is inevitable, you should know
fall behind on your mortgage payments. At most, that losing your home in a bankruptcy sale might
it will delay foreclosure for a few months. In many be better for you than losing it in a foreclosure
cases, the lender will just wait out your bankruptcy sale, for two reasons: First, a forced sale of real estate
case and then proceed with the foreclosure. And in bankruptcy is supervised by the bankruptcy
if your lender gets impatient and files a motion court, which wants to sell the house for as much as
to lift the automatic stay, the judge might allow possible. In a foreclosure sale, the foreclosing creditor
the lender to process the foreclosure during your cares only about getting enough to cover its own
bankruptcy case. debt. So, a bankruptcy sale often yields a higher
price—and if you have a homestead exemption
Fighting a Motion to Lift the on the house, the amount you get increases as the
Stay and Foreclose amount your home sells for goes up.
Second, debtors are rarely entitled to the
Until the housing bubble burst, bankruptcy judges
homestead exemption if the house is sold through
routinely granted lenders’ motions to lift the stay
foreclosure. In a bankruptcy sale, however, you are
and proceed with a foreclosure. However, in some
entitled to your homestead amount in cash, if there
recent cases, bankruptcy courts have taken a closer
are proceeds left over after the secured creditors
look at these motions and discovered that the
institutions filing them aren’t necessarily entitled
have been paid.
to ask the court to lift the stay. Only the holder of
a promissory note is a “party in interest” with the
right to request that the stay be lifted. Because of
Will You Lose Your Home in
the way mortgages have been divided, bought, and a Chapter 7 Bankruptcy?
sold lately, the institution asking to lift the stay often
If you file for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, the fact that
cannot produce a valid copy of the promissory note
you’ve kept up on your house payments may not
or otherwise prove that it is the legal holder of the
protect you from losing it. As explained above, if
note. (See In re Kang Jin Hwang, 396 B.R. 757 (Bkrtcy
selling your house will produce some cash for your
C.D. Cal. 2008) for more on this argument.)
unsecured creditors (and you aren’t able to pay the
Judges are increasingly likely to deny motions
trustee an equivalent amount), the trustee may well
to lift the stay. Instead, they might make the party
decide to sell it. But if the sale won’t produce cash,
wait until the bankruptcy case is over to pursue the
foreclosure. (Even if you defeat a motion to lift the
the trustee will not take the house.
stay by questioning the institution’s right to do so, Whether the sale will produce cash depends on
your bankruptcy will provide only temporary relief two factors:
from the foreclosure.) • whether you have any equity in your home,
and
112 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
• if so, whether you can protect that equity Line 4: Amount of liens
with an exemption. Enter the amount of all liens recorded against
Use the Homeowners’ Worksheet below to your home (other than liens created by mortgages
figure out the a nswers to these questions. (You’ll and home equity loans). Liens are claims against
find a tear-out copy of the worksheet in Appendix your home that have been recorded with the land
B.) Here are the instructions for filling out the form. records office. The three most common types of
liens are tax liens, mechanics’ liens, and judgment
Part I: Do You Have Any Equity
liens. Tax liens can be recorded against your
in Your Home?
home by the county, state, or federal government
for failure to pay property taxes, income taxes,
Line 1: Estimated market value of your home
payroll taxes, collected sales taxes, or other taxes.
Estimate how much money your home could People who do work on your home and claim that
produce in a quick, as-is sale. The trustee will you didn’t pay them what you owe can record
often use this value in deciding whether to sell the mechanics’, or materialmen’s, liens against your
home. However, some trustees will instead use the home. And judgment liens can be recorded by
full market value of your property, so if there is a anyone who has sued you in court and won.
significant difference between the quick sale value If you think there might be liens on your
and the full value of the home, use the latter to be home, visit the county land records office. Tell
on the safe side. To get a rough idea of what your the clerk you’d like to check your title for liens.
home is worth in either type of sale, ask a realtor The clerk should direct you to an index (often
what comparable homes in your neighborhood computerized) that lists all property in the county
have sold for. Or, look in newspaper or online real by the owner’s last name. Next to your home
estate sections. You can also generate rough home should be a list of any liens recorded against it. In
valuation estimates from websites such as www. come counties you can also use an online database
zillow.com, www.domania.com, www.homegain. to check for liens against your home.
com, or www.realtor.com.
Line 5: Total costs = Line 2 + Line 3 + Line 4
Line 2: Costs of sale
Add up the total costs that would have to be paid if
Costs of sale vary, but they tend to be about 6%– you were to sell your home.
8% of the sales price. The trustee is not required to
subtract the costs of sale in determining whether Line 6: Your equity = Line 1 – Line 5
to take your home, but most do. (If you want to
If Line 1 is more than Line 5, subtract Line 5 from
err on the side of caution, put “0” in this blank.)
Line 1, and put the result on Line 6. For bankruptcy
When you complete your bankruptcy paperwork,
purposes, this is your equity in the property: the
you can note that you are deducting the costs of
amount that would be left over after all mortgages,
sale from the property’s fair market value.
loans, liens, and costs of sale are paid.
If the amount on Line 5 is more than the
Line 3: Amount owed on mortgages
amount on Line 1, you have no equity; you can
and other loans
stop here. There will be no reason for the trustee
Enter the amount needed to pay off your mortgage to take your home in bankruptcy—once all of the
and any other loans that are secured by the home liens and mortgage(s) are paid off, there would
as collateral. If you can’t come up with a reasonably be nothing left to distribute to your unsecured
reliable estimate, contact each lender and ask how creditors.
much is necessary to cancel the debt.
ChAPter 7 | WHAT HAPPENS TO YOUR HOME | 113
Homeowners’ Worksheet
10. Do you own the property with your spouse in “tenancy by the entirety”?
■ Yes. See the instructions and talk to a bankruptcy attorney to find out
whether your house is fully protected.
■ No. Go on to Line 11.
114 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
The Trustee’s Power to Eliminate Liens—And How It May Cost You Your Home
When property has liens on it for more than the a notary public and recorded in the local land records
property is worth, it is “oversecured.” If a trustee office. While real estate practitioners usually have a
were to sell oversecured property, there wouldn’t firm grasp of these rules, mistakes can happen. If the
be enough money to pay off all of the liens, which trustee finds that a lien wasn’t perfected properly, it
means that one or more lienholders would be left with could be knocked out, meaning there is more equity
nothing. And there certainly wouldn’t be any money in the house than you thought, maybe enough for the
to pay unsecured creditors, who get paid only after all trustee to justify a sale.
lienholders have been paid off. The trustee can also knock out liens that have
The trustee’s job is to find money to pay been created to enforce a money judgment. If getting
unsecured creditors, so the trustee usually won’t rid of such a lien would free up some equity over
bother trying to sell an oversecured home. The picture and above any exemption you could claim, you may
changes, however, if the trustee can successfully lose the house for that reason. This means that you
petition the bankruptcy court to knock out enough shouldn’t rely on judgment liens to keep your home
lienholders to free up some equity. Once that happens, unless you are able to claim a homestead exemption
it might make sense to sell the home. in the equity that would be produced by getting rid of
If a lien hasn’t been perfected, the trustee may the lien.
try to knock it out, turning an oversecured property Before you file for bankruptcy, check on the legal
into one that, when sold, will yield some cash after the status of any liens you are relying on to save your
remaining lienholders get their share. All states have home or other property. In particular, make sure the
laws specifying the procedures that must be followed document creating the lien is recorded and contains a
to make a mortgage or other secured agreement or proper acknowledgement. If not, you may have more
lien valid (called “perfecting” the lien). These typically equity than you think—and the trustee may have a
include a proper acknowledgement signed in front of greater incentive to sell your home.
116 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
the state where they used to live—and they may Maine’s exemptions, because they have lived
be subject to a $136,875 limit on the amount of there for more than 40 months. If they had
equity they can exempt. (Because many states moved to Maine three years ago, they would
protect less than $136,875 in home equity anyway, still be able to use Maine’s exemptions, but
this cap won’t affect the majority of filers.) The their homestead exemption would be capped
purpose of these rules is to prevent filers from at $136,875. Maine’s homestead allowance
moving to another state to take advantage of its for joint filers who are at least 61 years old
better homestead protection. is $180,000, so John and Susie would have
Here are the rules: lost just over $43,000 worth of homestead
• If you bought your home at least 40 months exemption ($180,000 exemption minus the
ago, you can use the homestead exemption $136,875 cap).
of the state where your home is.
Example 2: After moving from Vermont to
• If you bought your home at least two years
Boston in 2009, Julius and his family buy
ago, you can use the homestead exemption
a fine old Boston home for $700,000. After
of the state where your home is. However,
borrowing heavily against the home because of
if you bought your home within the last
financial reversals, Julius files for bankruptcy
40 months, your homestead exemption is
in early 2011, when he owns $250,000 in
capped at $136,875, unless you bought the
equity. Although the Massachusetts homestead
home with the proceeds from the sale of
exemption of $500,000 would cover Julius’s
another home in the same state.
equity, he can claim only $136,875 of that
• If you bought your home within the last
exemption because he moved to Massachusetts
two years, then you must use the homestead
from another state within the last 40 months.
exemption of the state where you were
living for the better part of the 180-day Example 3: Eighteen months ago, Fred moved
period that ended two years before your from Florida to Nevada, where he purchased
filing date. And you are still subject to the his current home with $400,000 he received
$136,875 limit. from an inheritance. Fred files for bankruptcy
• If the state you are filing in offers a choice in his current home state of Nevada. Because
between the state and federal bankruptcy Fred lived in Florida for two years prior to
exemptions, you can use the federal moving to Nevada, he must use Florida’s
exemption list regardless of how long you’ve homestead exemption—and because Fred
been living in the state. In other words, the hasn’t lived in Nevada for 40 months, his
rules of the state where a person files for exemption is subject to the $136,875 cap.
bankruptcy determine whether the filer can The cap imposes an extreme penalty on Fred,
use the federal exemptions, even if the filer because Florida offers an unlimited homestead
has not lived in the state long enough to use exemption and Nevada’s homestead exemption
its state exemptions. is $550,000, but because of the cap, Fred can
protect only $136,875 of his equity, which
Example 1: Four years ago, John and Susie
means that the trustee will undoubtedly sell
retired and moved from Massachusetts to
his home, give Fred his $136,875, and use the
Maine, where they bought a home. If they
rest to pay off his unsecured creditors.
file for bankruptcy in Maine, they can use
ChaPter 7 | What Happens to Your home | 117
Line 7: Does the available homestead Line 8: Do you have to file a “declaration of
exemption protect your homestead” to claim the exemption?
kind of dwelling?
Only three states do not have a homestead
States That May Require a
Declaration of Homestead
exemption. If you are using the exemptions in one
Alabama Montana Utah
of these three states, enter $0 on Line 11.
Idaho Nevada Virginia
Massachusetts Texas Washington
States With No Homestead Exemption
Maryland New Jersey Pennsylvania
To claim a homestead exemption in Virginia, you
must have a declaration of homestead on file with
For all other states, check Appendix A to see the land records office for the county where the
whether your type of dwelling is protected. Some property is located when you file for bankruptcy.
types of dwellings may not be covered, including: The other states on this list vary in what they
• Mobile homes. Most states specifically require and when. If you are using the homestead
include mobile homes in their homestead exemption for one of these states, the safest
exemptions. Other states state that any “real approach is to file a declaration of homestead.
or personal property used as a residence” Requiring you to record a declaration before
can use the homestead exemption. This you can get the benefit of a homestead exemption
covers a trailer, mobile home, or houseboat, may violate the bankruptcy laws. (In re Leicht, 222
as long as you live in it. Some states don’t B.R. 670 (1st Cir. BAP 1998).) Regardless of the
detail the types of property that qualify as legalities, however, you will be best served by filing
a homestead. If your mobile home does not your declaration of homestead before you file for
qualify for a homestead exemption, it would bankruptcy.
be protected only by the exemption for a Other states allow (but do not require) you
motor vehicle. to file a homestead declaration in certain circum
• Co-ops or condominiums. Some homestead stances. In Texas, for example, you may file a
exemption laws specifically cover co-ops homestead declaration to claim protection for
or use language that says the exemption property you own but are not currently living in.
protects “any property used as a dwelling.”
Example: John and Doris live in Texas. They
• Apartments. Most homestead exemption
have retired and have decided to rent out
statutes do not protect rental apartments,
their spacious country home and move to an
because tenants don’t have equity in an
apartment closer to town. They can still claim
apartment. If you have a long-term lease
their country home as their homestead by
in an apartment, the exemption statutes of
recording a declaration of homestead with the
a few states may provide protection if the
land records office in the county where their
trustee were inclined to sell the lease.
country home is.
If your type of dwelling is not covered, enter
$0 on Line 11. In some states, a “declared” homestead offers
If it is unclear whether your type of dwelling is additional protection in situations other than
covered by the available homestead exemption, you bankruptcy. Also, if you own more than one
may need to do some legal research. (See Ch. 12 for piece of real estate, some states allow a creditor to
help getting started.)
ChaPter 7 | What Happens to Your home | 119
In these states, you can easily determine Georgia New Mexico Washington
whether your home is exempt. The homestead Idaho New York West Virginia
exemption is based simply on acreage. Look in Illinois North Carolina Wisconsin
Appendix A for the acreage limitation for the Indiana North Dakota Wyoming
state. (In Oklahoma, if you use more than 25% Kentucky Ohio
of the property as a business, the one-acre urban
homestead exemption cannot exceed $5,000.)
If your property is smaller than the maximum If the state homestead exemption is based
allowable acreage, your home is fully protected. on e quity alone, or you are using the federal
You can skip the rest of this chapter. exemptions, go to Line 10.
If your property exceeds the maximum
allowable acreage, the trustee will sell the excess Line 10: Do you own the property with your
acreage if you have any equity in it (unless you are spouse in “tenancy by the entirety”?
able to buy it back from the trustee for a negotiated If you are married and live in the right state, you
amount). Enter $0 in Line 11 of the worksheet. may be able to exclude your home from your
120 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
amount (called “doubling”). Other states don’t small, they might be enough to tip the balance in
allow doubling. When you look at Appendix A, favor of keeping your home.
check to see whether doubling is prohibited. If Check Appendix A to see whether the state
the chart doesn’t mention doubling, assume that where you’re filing has a wildcard exemption you
you and your spouse can double the exemption can use for real estate; if so, write the amount
amount. on Line 12. If your state doesn’t have a wildcard
exemption that you can use for real estate, leave
Line 12: Can you protect more equity this line blank.
with a wildcard exemption?
Some states allow you to add a wildcard exemption Line 13: How much of your equity is protected?
to the amount of your homestead exemption. Add Lines 11 (the state homestead exemption
Although these wildcard amounts are usually available to you) and 12 (any wildcard exemption
The 2005 bankruptcy law allows the court to look back If all of these statements are true, the homestead
ten years before you filed for bankruptcy to find out exemption available to you for that property will be
whether you have “defrauded” your creditors by selling reduced by the value of the property you improperly
nonexempt property and using the proceeds to buy converted.
exempt property (often real estate). If the court finds
Example: You have $50,000 of equity in your
that you converted property with the intent to cheat
home, and your state offers a $50,000 homestead
your creditors out of their lawful right to take it, the
exemption. Nine years ago, you were sued by a
value of your homestead exemption will be reduced
creditor over a real estate deal that went bad.
by the value of the property your converted. (11 U.S.C.
To protect a $50,000 investment portfolio you
§ 522(o); In re Maronde, 332 B.R. 593 (D. Minn. 2005); In
owned at the time, you cashed it out and bought
re Lacounte, 342 B.R. 809 (D. Mont. 2005).)
an exempt life insurance policy. Five years ago,
Your homestead exemption may be at risk only if
you cashed out the life insurance policy and used
all of the following are true:
the proceeds as a down payment for your home.
• Within the last ten years, you converted any
Because you meet all of the factors listed above,
type of nonexempt property into any type of
you could lose your homestead exemption
exempt property.
entirely, and your house could be sold so your
• You used the converted property as a means
equity can be distributed to your creditors.
of acquiring or improving residential property
you or a dependent currently inhabits (or a real Few real-life situations are this clear-cut, of course.
estate co-op or a burial plot). (For example, It’s usually easy to tell whether or not you converted
you sold valuable antiques to raise the down nonexempt property to exempt property. However,
payment for your house.) the question of whether you converted the property
• You have some equity in the property that to cheat, defraud, delay, or hinder your creditors is not
could be protected by an exemption. so simple. Generally, bankruptcy courts use the badges
• You are using a state exemption system rather of fraud list (covered in Ch. 5) to determine whether
than the federal exemptions. you intended to cheat your creditors.
• When you converted the property in question,
you intended to cheat, defraud, delay, or hinder
your creditors.
122 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
you can add to your homestead exemption). This shouldn’t file for Chapter 7 bankruptcy if you want
is the amount of home equity you can protect in to keep it. The trustee will almost certainly sell it,
bankruptcy. If you aren’t subject to the $136,875 cap unless you can come up with the cash to keep it.
(explained above), a reduction of your homestead You’ll probably fare better—and hold on to your
protection because you converted nonexempt home longer—by using your equity to help pay
property to defraud a creditor, or the creation of a off your debts, either directly or through a reverse
self-settled trust (see Ch. 5), write this amount on mortgage, or to fund a Chapter 13 reorganization
Line 13. plan. Some of these strategies are discussed in
If you are subject to the $136,875 cap, it might “Ways to Keep Your House” below.
limit the amount of equity you can protect. If the
total of Lines 11 and 12 doesn’t exceed $136,875, it CAUTION
doesn’t matter—the cap won’t affect you, and you
This worksheet is for estimate purposes
can write the total amount on Line 13. However, if only. If this worksheet shows that your equity is equal to
the total is more than $136,875 and the cap applies, or near the maximum amount of your state’s homestead
you can protect only $136,875 in equity. Even if exemption, take note: The trustee can challenge the
your state law would otherwise allow you to take a value you claim for your home and may determine that
larger exemption, you’ll be limited to $136,875, and it’s worth more than you think. If this happens, and the
this is what you should write on Line 13. trustee concludes that your equity exceeds the amount
you can claim as exempt, the trustee may seek to have
Line 14: Is your home fully protected? your home sold. If your estimates show that you might
Subtract Line 13 from Line 6, and enter the total be close to the exemption limit, arrange for a formal
on Line 14. If you generate a negative number, all appraisal or get some advice from an experienced
of your home equity should be protected by the bankruptcy lawyer.
applicable exemptions, if your estimates are correct.
The trustee probably won’t have your home sold,
because there would be no proceeds left over (after Ways to Keep Your House
your mortgage holder was paid off and you received
your exempt amount of equity) to pay your If you have nonexempt equity in your home, there
unsecured creditors. are a few strategies that might be available that
If, however, you generate a positive number, will allow you to keep your house even if you file
your equity exceeds the applicable exemption—in for bankruptcy. We outline them briefly here, but
other words, you have unprotected (nonexempt) you should ask an experienced bankruptcy lawyer
equity in your home. If your estimates are right, for help. (For a quick overview of strategies to keep
and a sale would produce a profit to be paid to your house if you decide not to file for bankruptcy,
your unsecured creditors after the costs of sale are as well as a list of resources, see “Alternatives to
deducted (5% to 10% of the sale price), the trustee Chapter 7 Bankruptcy If You Might Lose Your
can force the sale unless you can pay the trustee Home,” below.)
the value of your unprotected equity. From the
proceeds of the sale, your secured creditors will be Reduce Your Equity Before
paid their mortgages, liens, and so forth; you will Filing for Bankruptcy
receive your exempt amount; and your unsecured
If you can reduce your nonexempt equity before
creditors will get the rest.
you file for bankruptcy, you may be able to save
If you have significant unprotected equity in
your home. (You may even be able to avoid bank
your home (over and above the costs of sale), you
ChaPter 7 | What Happens to Your home | 123
ruptcy altogether if you use the money to pay off property from nonexempt to exempt status is covered
your other debts.) in Ch. 6.
There are two ways to reduce your equity:
• borrow against the equity, or
• sell part ownership of your house. Borrow Against Your Equity
You can use the proceeds to buy exempt
property or to pay off other debts. If you borrow against your equity, you won’t reduce
your overall debt burden. You may be able to lower
your overall monthly bills, however, if you can
CAUTION get a lower interest rate mortgage or a longer-term
Consult a local bankruptcy lawyer before equity loan to pay off short-term, high-interest debts.
reducing your equity. If you file for bankruptcy after You can also fully deduct the interest you pay on
reducing your equity, the bankruptcy court in your area mortgages and home equity loans from your income
might view your actions as an abuse of the bankruptcy taxes.
process and dismiss your bankruptcy petition. This is
Be careful when you shop for a loan. Many
more likely if you reduced your equity within two years
lenders offer loans with very high rates to people in
of filing. How to stay out of trouble when converting
If you want to keep your home but you have payments over the life of your repayment
unprotected (nonexempt) equity and/or you are plan. (You can also use Chapter 13 to get rid of
behind on your mortgage and facing foreclosure, second or third mortgages that are no longer
Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy may not be the best secured by your home due to depreciation.)
way to deal with your debt. Some alternative strategies For debtors who have a lot of home equity,
you might consider include: filing for Chapter 13 bankruptcy may be the better
• Negotiate a plan with your lender to make up bankruptcy choice, because Chapter 13 filers aren’t
the missed payments. required to give up any property. While business
• Agree to a mortgage workout, in which owners typically find it very difficult to complete a
you renegotiate the payment terms of your Chapter 13 repayment plan (as explained in Ch. 3),
mortgage to avoid foreclosure. Chapter 13 might be a viable option if you can propose
• Refinance your loan with another lender. a plan that will pay your creditors at least the value of
• Negotiate a “short sale,” in which the lender your nonexempt equity in your home.
agrees to accept whatever you can sell the For more information on these and other
house for as payment in full on your mortgage. strategies for dealing with home debt outside
• If you are at least 62 years old, look into the of bankruptcy, talk to a HUD-approved housing
possibility of a reverse mortgage. counselor (you can find one by calling 800-569-4287
• Consider whether you have any defenses to a or visiting HUD’s website at www.hud.gov/foreclosure/
foreclosure action, such as an interest rate that’s index.cfm). You can learn more about government-
too high, violations of the Truth in Lending Act, sponsored mortgage modification programs at www.
or the lender’s failure to prove that it owns the makinghomeaffordable.gov. You may also want to pick
loan and has the right to foreclose. up a copy of The Foreclosure Survival Guide, by Stephen
• File for Chapter 13 bankruptcy, in which you R. Elias (Nolo), which includes lots of tips and strategies
can propose to make up your missed for saving your home.
124 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
because the creditors will end up with permits you to spread out repayments of
almost as much as they would have gotten missed installment payments, taxes, and late
if the home were sold—and the trustee will charges on a mortgage. And, if your lender
be spared the hassle and expense of selling has begun foreclosure proceedings, Chapter
the Robertsons’ home. 13 bankruptcy can halt them as long as
your house hasn’t yet been sold. (For more
• Convert to Chapter 13 bankruptcy (or file
information on Chapter 13, see Chapter 13
for Chapter 13 in the first place). Chapter
Bankruptcy: Keep Your Property & Repay
13 bankruptcy lets you pay your debts
Debts Over Time, by Stephen Elias and
out of your income rather than by selling
Robin Leonard (Nolo).)
your property. If you file for Chapter 13
You can convert to Chapter 13 bankruptcy any
bankruptcy, you won’t have to give up
time during a Chapter 7 bankruptcy proceeding.
your home, even if you have nonexempt
If you miss mortgage payments after you file for
equity. (However, you will have to pay
Chapter 7 bankruptcy, however, some courts won’t
your unsecured creditors at least the value
let you include them in your Chapter 13 repayment
of your nonexempt property over the life
plan. So try to make all payments due after you file
of your plan.) Chapter 13 bankruptcy also
for Chapter 7.
l
8
C H A P T E R
Secured Debts
Lenders Must Perfect Their Security Interests Common Examples of Security Interests
For bankruptcy purposes, security interest agree Many everyday loans qualify as security interests,
ments qualify as secured debts only if they have including:
been perfected: recorded with the appropriate local • Mortgages. Called deeds of trust in some
or state records office. For instance, to create a states, mortgages are loans to buy or
lien on real estate, the mortgage holder (the bank refinance a house or other real estate. The
or other lender) must typically record it with the real estate is collateral for the loan. If you
recorder’s office for the county where the real estate fail to pay, the lender can foreclose.
is located. To perfect security interests in cars or • Home equity loans or HELOCs. You can
business assets, the holder of the security interest borrow against the equity in your home
must typically record it with whatever statewide to provide your business with cash flow,
or local agency handles recordings under the remodel your home, or pay for other things,
Uniform Commercial Code (these are called “UCC such as college tuition or a car. No matter
recordings,” and they are usually filed with the how you spend the money, the house is
secretary of state, or department of state). collateral for the loan. If you fail to pay, the
It’s not uncommon for informal business lender can foreclose.
documents to provide that one party will receive a • Loans for cars, boats, tractors, motorcycles,
“security interest” in some collateral in exchange or RVs. Here, the vehicle is the collateral. If
for granting a loan or business credit to the other you fail to pay, the lender can repossess it.
party. Informal agreements like these, called • Loans for business equipment, machines,
security agreements, can be enforced generally, but or inventory. The lender can repossess the
the seller will have a lien on the collateral only if property you pledged as collateral if you
the agreement is properly recorded. don’t repay the loan.
• Store charges with a security agreement.
Example: Clear Water, a swimming pool
Almost all purchases on store credit cards
maintenance firm, buys a high-power
are unsecured, as are major credit cards.
vacuum from Acme Vacuum for $25,000.
Some stores, however, print on the credit
Clear Water signs a boilerplate promissory
card slip or other receipt that the store
note and security agreement, agreeing to
“retains a security interest in all hard goods
pay the debt in monthly installments over
(durable goods) purchased,” meaning that
one year and giving Acme a security interest
if you don’t pay the credit card bill, the
in the vacuum. Acme doesn’t record the
store will have the right to take back the
agreement with the appropriate government
purchased items. If you didn’t specifically
agency. Soon afterwards, Clear Water files
sign a security agreement setting out
bankruptcy. Acme believes it has a security
repayment terms, debts like these are
interest in the vacuum that will be protected
generally considered unsecured debts in
in the bankruptcy proceedings. However, the
bankruptcy. However, if the store makes
bankruptcy trustee takes the vacuum and
you sign an actual security agreement
sells it without paying Acme the amount due
setting out the amount financed, the
on its loan. Because Acme didn’t perfect the
interest rate, and the number of required
agreement by recording it, it has no security
payments (the basics required by the Truth
interest that would require the trustee to pay
in Lending Act for installment payments)
off its debt before distributing any remaining
when you use the store’s credit card, the
proceeds to Clear Water’s unsecured creditors.
130 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
debt may be secured. For example, if you against you by a court automatically c reates a lien
buy building supplies on credit, the store on the real estate you own in that county—that is,
may require you to sign a security agree the judgment creditor doesn’t have to record the
ment in which you agree that the items judgment to get the lien.
purchased are collateral for your repayment. A judgment lien affects real estate you own
If you don’t pay back the loan, the seller can in the county where the lien is recorded or the
repossess the property, as long as it perfects judgment is entered. In many states, a judgment
its security interest. lien also applies to your personal property (property
• Title loans, or personal loans from banks, other than real estate) for a period of time after the
credit unions, or finance companies. Often, judgment, if certain judgment collection techniques
you must pledge valuable personal property are employed. However, judgment liens on personal
you already own, such as a paid-off motor property are generally ineffective, because most
vehicle, as collateral for this type of loan. personal property has no title, and the liens are not
This is a non-purchase-money secured debt, recorded. This means that the personal property
which will be treated as a secured debt could easily be sold to a third party who has no
in your bankruptcy as long as it has been idea that the lien existed. However, if the personal
perfected by the lender. property is business equipment and inventory,
and the lien has been recorded under the Uniform
Nonconsensual Liens Commercial Code because the equipment or
inventory is collateral for a loan, the lien will prevent
In some circumstances, a creditor can get a lien you from selling the property with clear title if the
on your property without your agreement. These buyer conducts a UCC search.
are called nonconsensual liens. In theory, a
nonconsensual lien gives the creditor the right to
Tip
force a sale of the property in order to get paid.
In practice, however, few creditors exercise this How to find liens recorded against you.
The secretary of state’s office in every state maintains
right because forcing a sale is expensive and time-
a registry of liens, listing judgment liens, tax liens, and
consuming. Instead, they typically wait until you
security interests that creditors claim in your property.
sell or refinance the property, at which point the
You can do your own lien search online by searching the
lien has to be paid off with the proceeds, to give
Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) records database at
the new owner or lender clear title to the property.
your secretary of state or department of state’s website,
For bankruptcy purposes, there are three major
to see whether any liens have been recorded against
types of nonconsensual liens:
you and your business. (Search for your personal name
• judgment liens and your business names.) If you find any incorrect
• statutory liens, and information—for example, you have paid off a debt but
• tax liens. there’s still a lien against you—ask the lender in question
for a UCC release, which it is legally required to provide.
Judgment Liens
A judgment lien can be imposed on your property A judgment creditor can also file a judgment
only after somebody sues you and wins a money with your state motor vehicles department to get
judgment against you. In most states, the judgment a judgment lien on any car, truck, motorcycle, or
creditor (the person or company who won) must other motor vehicle you own. You may not know
then record the judgment by filing it with the about this type of lien unless you check with the
county or state. In a few states, a judgment entered motor vehicles department or the creditor files a
ChaPter 8 | Secured Debts | 131
proof of claim in your bankruptcy case, describing office. While the federal tax lien attaches to all
its interest as “secured.” of your property, for practical purposes a lien
Typically, judgment liens that have been will be effective only if your real estate equity,
recorded in your county will attach to property your retirement account, or your bank account is
that you acquire later. For example, a judgment sufficient to cover the debt. Similarly, your local
may be recorded in your county land records office government can attach a lien to your real estate for
even if you don’t own any real estate. If you buy unpaid property taxes. And, if your state taxing
some real estate a few years later, you’ll discover authority sends you a bill and you don’t contest or
that it is now burdened by that pesky old lien that pay it, the state can record a tax lien against your
was just sitting there, waiting for you to make a real estate in that state.
move. Most real estate liens expire after a certain
number of years (seven to ten in most states),
though they can typically be renewed. What Happens to Secured Debts
When You File for Bankruptcy
Statutory Liens
Unsecured debts and secured debts are treated
Some liens are created by law. For example, in
differently in Chapter 7 bankruptcy. Creditors
most states, when you hire someone to work on
with unsecured debts may receive some money
your house, the worker or supplier of materials is
in the bankruptcy process, if the trustee is able
entitled to obtain a mechanic’s lien (also called a
to take and sell any of your nonexempt property.
materialman’s lien) on the house if you don’t pay.
(The proceeds from a sale of your nonexempt
In some states, a homeowners’ association has the
property are divided among all of your unsecured
same right if you don’t pay your dues or special
creditors according to priorities established in the
assessments.
bankruptcy code.) Once your case is over, however,
Statutory liens affect only your real estate. They
unsecured creditors have no rights. Most types
don’t attach to your personal property, such as a car
of unsecured debts are wiped out in bankruptcy,
or equipment.
whether or not the creditor was paid off, and the
Tax Liens creditor has to simply take the loss and move on.
Secured debts are different in two ways: First,
Federal, state, and local governments have the
if the trustee takes and sells property that secures
authority to impose liens on your p roperty if
a debt, the secured creditor is entitled to be paid
you owe delinquent taxes. If you owe money to
in full before unsecured creditors get anything.
the IRS or another taxing authority, the debt is
This may effectively allow you to keep the property
secured only if the taxing authority has recorded
securing the debt, because the trustee has no
a lien against your property (and you still own the
incentive to take the property and sell it if the
property) or has issued a notice of tax lien, and the
secured creditor would be entitled to all of the
equity in your home or retirement plan is sufficient
nonexempt proceeds.
to cover the debt. For example, in these times of
Second, even though bankruptcy wipes out
upside down or underwater mortgages, a debt to
your personal obligation to repay a secured debt,
the IRS may be unsecured even if a lien has been
the creditor’s lien on your property survives your
imposed on your home, if you don’t have enough
bankruptcy case (unless the property is returned to
equity to secure the debt.
the creditor). A secured debt consists of two parts:
If you don’t pay an IRS bill, the IRS can
• Your personal liability for the debt, which
record a Notice of Federal Tax Lien at your county
obligates you to pay back the creditor. Bank
land records office or your secretary of state’s
ruptcy wipes out your personal liability for
132 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
Li e
n
restrictions that may apply, when each option makes simply means allowing the creditor to take it back
sense, and what steps you have to take to use each or foreclose on the lien. This is the simplest option
option. You should review this material carefully and for dealing with secured property. It completely
decide how you want to treat the collateral for each frees you from the debt: Giving back the property
secured debt before you file for bankruptcy. If you satisfies the terms of the lien, and the bankruptcy
plan on keeping the collateral, call the lender before discharges your personal liability for the original
filing to see whether you will have to reaffirm the debt (and prevents the creditor from seeking a
debt (agree to be liable for it under a new contract deficiency judgment).
after your bankruptcy, as explained further below) Advantages. A quick and easy way to completely
or whether you can keep the collateral by simply rid yourself of a secured debt.
remaining current on your payments. Disadvantages. You lose the property.
Once you’ve filed for bankruptcy, the automatic Restrictions. None. You can surrender any kind
stay prevents secured creditors from repossessing of collateral for a secured debt.
property that serves as collateral for a secured debt, When to use it. For property that you don’t need
unless the court gives permission or you miss the or want or that would cost too much to keep.
deadline for carrying out your stated intention. It’s How it works. On the Statement of Intention
much easier to hold on to property in the first place form, check the box indicating that you will
than to get it back after the creditor repossesses it. surrender the property. You must file the form and
So, if you have some secured property that a creditor send a copy to the secured creditor. It’s then up to
is about to take and you haven’t filed for bankruptcy the creditor to contact you and arrange a time to
yet, you may want to file right away to prevent the pick up the property. You must make the property
seizure. available to the creditor within 30 days after the
creditors’ meeting. If the creditor doesn’t take the
CAUTION
property, and the trustee doesn’t claim it, it’s yours
to keep. This might happen if the property isn’t
You may lose your property if you fail to
choose. If you don’t make a choice about how you intend
worth much. For example, it probably isn’t worth
to treat collateral, the secured creditor might have the the creditor’s time to pick up, store, and auction
right to repossess the collateral 30 days after you file for off used household furniture or old computer
bankruptcy, whether or not you have kept up with your equipment, no matter how much you still owe on
payments. Most security agreements contain what’s it.
known as an “ipso facto” clause, which says that filing for
bankruptcy qualifies as a default allowing the creditor to Option 2: Redeem the Collateral
repossess the property, even if you are current on your
payments. If you don’t use one of the choices provided
If you want to keep certain types of property, you
by the bankruptcy code, the creditor may use the ipso may “redeem” it by paying the secured creditor
facto clause to grab your property. However, some the property’s current replacement value (what
states don’t honor these ipso facto clauses as long as you you would have to pay a retail vendor for that type
remain current on your payments. of property, considering its age and condition),
usually in a lump sum. Essentially, you are buying
the property back from the creditor. In return, the
creditor delivers title to you in the same manner
Option 1: Surrender the Collateral
as if you had followed through on your original
If you don’t want or need to keep the property, agreement. You then own the property free and
you can surrender it. Surrendering the collateral clear.
134 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
Advantages. Redemption is a great option if you the abandonment or may simply wait for
owe significantly more than the property is worth. your discharge to be granted, at which
The creditor must accept the current replacement time the property will automatically
value of the item as payment in full. If you and be considered abandoned. Either way,
the creditor don’t agree on the replacement value once the property is abandoned, you can
of the property, the court will d ecide the issue in redeem it by paying the secured creditor
a proceeding called a “valuation” hearing. (Ch. 6 its replacement value. If you know you’ll
explains how to figure out the replacement value of want to redeem property if the trustee
various types of property.) abandons it, check the “redeem” box on
Disadvantages. Most debtors will have to pay the Statement of Intention. If you haven’t
the full replacement value of the item in a lump done this and the trustee abandons the
sum in order to redeem it. It may be difficult for property, you may have to amend your
you to come up with that much cash on short Statement of Intention (instructions for
notice. You may be able to get a loan; some amending a form are in Ch. 10). Call the
companies specialize in lending to people seeking trustee to find out.
to redeem their collateral in bankruptcy. Or, When to use it. Redemption may be a good idea
you can try to get the creditor to agree to accept if you really want to keep personal property, but
installment payments, but courts cannot require you don’t want the debt to survive your bankruptcy
creditors to make this type of deal. Importantly, (this is a consequence of reaffirmation, discussed
redemption is not available for business property. below). Use redemption only if you owe more
Restrictions. You have the right to redeem than it would cost to purchase the property and
property only if all of the following are true: you would not be able to get rid of the lien (lien
• The debt is a consumer debt: one incurred avoidance is covered below in Option 5). It often
“primarily for a personal, family, or house makes sense to redeem small items of household
hold purpose.” This includes just about property that you want to keep, because raising
everything except collateral for loans and money for the lump sum payment probably will
credit obtained for business purposes. not be that difficult.
• The property is tangible personal property. How it works. You and the creditor must
Tangible property is anything you can agree on the value of the property, then draft and
touch. A car, furniture, a boat, a computer, sign a redemption agreement. Agreeing on the
and jewelry are all examples of tangible replacement value may take a little negotiation.
property. Stocks are intangible. The Sometimes, you can get the creditor to accept
property must also be “personal property,” installment payments if you agree to pay a higher
which simply means it can’t be real estate. total amount. Whatever you agree to, put it in
You aren’t allowed to redeem property the redemption agreement. (See Appendix D for
you use in your business, even in a sole sample agreements and instructions.)
proprietorship.
• The property is either: Option 3: Retain and Pay (the
■■ claimed as exempt (exempt property is “Ride-Through” Option)
explained in Ch. 6), or
■■ abandoned by the trustee. A trustee will Before the bankruptcy law changed in 2005, a
abandon property that has little or no majority of bankruptcy courts recognized the
nonexempt value beyond the amount of “ride-through” or “retain and pay” option for
the liens. The trustee may notify you of dealing with secured debts. Where this option
ChaPter 8 | Secured Debts | 135
was available, debtors could keep the collateral the creditor, and the creditor’s experience with the
for a secured debt without reaffirming the debt reaffirmation process.
or redeeming the property, as long as they stayed If your lender doesn’t want you to use this
current on their payments. Debtors who took option, it might still be available to you if one of
advantage of this option wouldn’t owe a deficiency the following is true:
balance if they had to give the property back after • Your state’s law forbids lenders from
receiving their bankruptcy discharge. repossessing property as long as you stay
The ride-through option is no longer an current on your payments. In this situation,
explicit part of the bankruptcy code, and it isn’t if you don’t redeem or surrender the
recognized in the bankruptcy courts of every state. property, or reaffirm the debt, the debtor
However, some lenders (and some courts) still allow can’t do anything to enforce its security
debtors to keep the collateral without reaffirming interest as long as you keep making those
a secured debt, as long as they remain current on payments. (For information on researching
the payments. These lenders would rather continue your state’s law, see Ch. 12.)
to receive payments from a reliable borrower than • The court rejects your reaffirmation
have to repossess and auction off the property only agreement. In this situation, most courts
to receive a fraction of what they’re owed. have allowed debtors to keep their
Advantages. The ride-through option allows property as long as they continue making
you to keep property without obligating yourself their payments. These courts have held
to a debt that will survive your bankruptcy or that, as long as you sign and file a valid
having to come up with lump-sum payment. You reaffirmation agreement and attend the
can keep the property as long as you can keep up hearing, you will be protected from
with your payments. If you reach a point where repossession, even if the court ultimately
you can’t afford the payments, you can essentially rejects the agreement (typically, because it
surrender the property: give it back without owing looks like you won’t be able to make the
a deficiency balance. payments required by the contract). (See In
Disadvantages. Because the ride-through option re Chim, 381 B.R. 191 (Md. 2008); In re
is no longer part of the bankruptcy code, your Moustafi, 371 B.R. 434 (Ariz. 2007).)
lender usually gets to decide whether to allow it or In at least one federal judicial circuit—the
not. And, the ride-through option isn’t allowed in 11th Circuit, which covers Alabama, Florida, and
every judicial district. Even if you are allowed to Georgia—debtors may not use the ride-through
use this option, you’ll have to keep making your option. If debtors in these states want to keep
payments if you want to keep the property. In property, they must either redeem it or sign a
contrast, surrendering or redeeming the property reaffirmation agreement for the debt. (See In re
both allow you to exit your bankruptcy case Linderman, Case No. 6:09-BK-02087-KSJ (M.D.
without ongoing payment obligations (unless your Fla. 2009).
lender allows you to redeem on an installment When to use it. If your lender will allow it and
plan). you think you’ll be able to make your payments,
Restrictions. Generally, your lender gets to the ride-through option is often the best choice for
decide whether to allow you to use the ride- property you really want to keep. It allows you to
through option or to require you to redeem or retain the property and avoid any penalty (in the
reaffirm the debt. Whether or not your creditor form of a deficiency judgment) if you later have to
will be so accommodating depends on how close give it back.
you are to paying off the debt, your history with
136 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
How it works. First, you’ll have to contact your the ride-through option of keeping the property
lender to see whether it will allow you to “retain and continuing your payments, you won’t owe
and pay for” the collateral rather than reaffirm. If a deficiency balance if you have to give back the
the lender agrees, check the box on the Statement property.
of Intention indicating that you will retain the Advantages. Reaffirmation provides a sure way
property. Then, check the “Other” box, and write to keep collateral as long as you abide by the terms
this in the space provided: “Debtor will retain of the reaffirmation agreement and keep up your
collateral and continue to make regular payments.” payments. Reaffirmation also provides a setting in
If you default to the ride-through option which you may be able to negotiate new terms to
because the court rejects your reaffirmation reduce your payments, your interest rate, and/or
agreement, you should complete your Statement the total amount you will have to pay over time.
of Intention as explained in the instructions for Disadvantages. Because reaffirmation leaves
reaffirming a debt, below. you personally liable for the debt, you can’t walk
away from the debt after bankruptcy. You’ll still be
Option 4: Reaffirm the Debt legally bound to pay the deficiency balance even if
the property is damaged or destroyed.
And because
When you reaffirm a debt, you agree that you you have to wait eight years before filing another
will still owe the debt after your bankruptcy case Chapter 7 bankruptcy case, you’ll be stuck with
is over. Both the creditor’s lien on the collateral that debt for a long time.
and your personal liability for the debt under
the original promissory note survive bankruptcy Example: Tasha owes $35,000 on a pickup
intact—often, just as if you never filed for truck she uses in her masonry contracting
bankruptcy. For example, if you owe $25,000 on business. Because she needs the truck for
your car before you file for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, her business, she enters into a reaffirmation
you most likely will continue to owe $25,000 on agreement with the dealership financing
your car after you file for bankruptcy (unless you company that is subsequently approved by
negotiate a lower amount in your reaffirmation the bankruptcy judge. Two months after
agreement). If you can’t keep up your payments her bankruptcy case is over, Tasha’s income
and the car is repossessed, you’ll owe the difference plummets when her main general contractor
between the amount you reaffirm for and the goes out of business. Tasha is forced to give
amount the lender is able to sell the car for at back the truck. Shortly afterwards, the lender
auction (considerably less than you owe, in most auctions off the truck for $15,000, then sends
cases). This is called a “deficiency b alance.” Nearly Tasha a deficiency notice for the $20,000
all states permit a creditor to sue for a deficiency remaining on the loan. When Tasha doesn’t
balance for most types of property. About half of pay up, the lender sues Tasha, obtains a
the states, however, don’t allow deficiency balances judgment, and begins aggressive collection
on repossessed personal property if the original efforts that won’t let up until Tasha can file
purchase price was less than a few thousand another bankruptcy case, eight years later.
dollars. Restrictions. Reaffirmation can be used
Whether or not you reaffirm the debt, if you with any kind of property and any kind of
default on your payments once your bankruptcy lien, but the creditor must agree to the terms of
case is over, the creditor can r epossess the collateral. the reaffirmation if they are different from the
But if you don’t reaffirm the debt, and instead use current agreement. You or the lender must file the
ChaPter 8 | Secured Debts | 137
agreement in court as part of your bankruptcy hold on to assets you really need. Only you can
case. Unless an attorney is representing you in the decide whether the property you want to keep is
bankruptcy or in the reaffirmation process, the worth saddling yourself with a large debt for years
bankruptcy court must review the agreement in a to come.
reaffirmation or discharge hearing. At that hearing,
Example: Joanie borrowed $25,000 three
the judge will review your bankruptcy paperwork
years ago to purchase three computer servers
to see how the reaffirmation might affect your post-
she uses in her Web-based bookkeeping
bankruptcy budget and whether you can afford the
service. Joanie still owes the lender about
payments. The judge can disapprove the agreement
$20,000 because of the 12% interest she pays
if it is not in your best interest or would create an
on the loan. However, because computer
undue hardship for you. The judge is likely to reject
hardware depreciates so fast, the servers are
the agreement if it looks like you won’t be able to
now worth only $8,000. Joanie tells the lender
make the payments after paying your basic living
that she’s willing to reaffirm only if it reduces
expenses or if you owe much more on the debt
the balance on the note to $8,000 and cuts
than the property is worth.
the interest rate to 5%, which would lower
When to use it. Because reaffirmation comes
her monthly payments by more than half.
with the very serious disadvantage of leaving you in
When the lender refuses, Joanie says that she
debt after your bankruptcy case is over, you should
will have to simply surrender the servers and
consider it only if:
buy new ones for much less. Caught between
• it’s the only way to hang on to collateral
the proverbial rock and hard place, the lender
that you really need to keep, or
makes a counteroffer of $10,000, at an interest
• you are able to negotiate new payments
rate of 6.5%. Joanie agrees to reaffirm the
terms that are attractive enough to warrant
debt under these new terms. Even though she
the reaffirmation.
might be able to replace the servers for less,
Even if your creditor doesn’t require you to
that would take more time and effort than she
reaffirm the debt, it may make sense to do so
has to spare.
anyway if you can use the process to negotiate a
significantly lower payment. Your leverage will If you need to reaffirm a debt in order to keep
often be considerable. After all, you have the option the collateral, make sure you keep up your pay
of surrendering the collateral and walking away ments prior to filing for bankruptcy so you can
without owing a dime, while the lender will be stay on the creditor’s good side. If you fall behind,
stuck having to sell the collateral at auction for a the creditor has the right to demand that you
small fraction of the property’s value. make your account current before agreeing to a
You generally shouldn’t reaffirm a debt for reaffirmation contract, but you will probably have
more than the property is worth unless your some room to negotiate. If the creditor rejects
credit score and other circumstances would your payments during bankruptcy (which often
make replacing the property too difficult. As happens), deposit that money into a separate
you undoubtedly know, it’s hard to buy a new account so it’s available once the creditor decides to
car, business equipment, or inventory without a accept it. If you can’t make these rejected payments
good credit score—and filing for bankruptcy will when the creditor wants them, you might lose your
certainly lower your score. Even if reaffirmation property.
doesn’t make the best economic sense, you may How it works. There are several official forms
be inclined to do it anyway, if it’s the only way to you must use to reaffirm a debt: a form cover sheet
138 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
(Form 27), and the reaffirmation forms themselves it in a separate legal proceeding in your bankruptcy
(Form 240A, Form 240B, and Form 240C). You’ll case.
find blank copies of these forms in Appendix C. One common lien avoidance procedure lets
Most large creditors will complete the paperwork, you eliminate or reduce liens on certain types of
ask you to sign it, and file it with the court. If exempt personal property, depending on the value
you’re dealing with a smaller creditor, you may of the property and the amount of the exemption
have to file it yourself. available to you. This procedure is available only
The reaffirmation agreement includes a number for what are called “nonpossessory, non-purchase-
of legally required disclosures and warnings. These money liens”: liens on property that you already
provisions are intended to put you on notice of owned when you pledged it as security for a loan. It
how much you’ll be paying overall, the interest can’t be used for real estate.
rate, and your liability to pay the debt in full, even A different lien avoidance procedure allows you
if something happens to the collateral. In Part to eliminate judgment liens on personal property
D of the agreement, you must explain why you or real estate that falls within an exemption. By
are reaffirming the debt and provide information eliminating the judgment lien, you get to keep the
on your income and expenses, so the court can property free and clear without paying anything
determine whether the agreement creates an more to the creditor, assuming the underlying debt
undue hardship for you. Your income and expense can be discharged in bankruptcy (which it usually
information should be in the same ballpark as can).
the information you include in Schedules I and J
(see Ch. 9). If these figures indicate that you can’t Nonpossessory, Non-Purchase-Money Liens
afford the required payments, the court may reject If you have pledged some item of personal property
your reaffirmation agreement. (See In re Laynas, (not real estate) that you already owned as security
345 B.R. 505 (E.D. Penn. 2006).) If this happens, for a loan, and the property is completely or
you will probably be able to keep the property partially exempt, you may be able to eliminate a
as long as you stay current on your payments lien on the property. (You’ll find sample forms
under the old loan; see Option 3, above, for more for this remedy in Appendix D; you will need to
information. modify them to fit your situation.)
You can cancel a reaffirmation agreement by How much of the lien can be eliminated
notifying the creditor before the later of: depends on the value and type of property and
• the date of your discharge, or the amount of the exemption. If the property (or
• 60 days after you filed the reaffirmation your equity in it) is entirely exempt, the court
agreement with the bankruptcy court will eliminate the entire lien, and you’ll get to
If your case is already closed, however, you will keep the property without paying anything. If the
not be able to switch to the other options listed in property (or your equity in it) is worth more than
this chapter. the exemption limit, the lien will be reduced to the
difference between the exemption limit and either
Option 5: Eliminate (Avoid) Liens the property’s value or the amount of the debt,
whichever is less.
Lien avoidance is a procedure by which you ask the
bankruptcy court to eliminate or reduce liens on Example: A creditor has a $5,000 lien
some types of exempt property. Lien avoidance is on Dena’s professional embroidery and
neither automatic nor required: You have to request monogramming machine, which is worth
ChaPter 8 | Secured Debts | 139
$3,000. In Dena’s state, the embroidery • Security interest means the lien was created
machine is exempt as a tool of trade only by voluntary agreement between you and
to $2,000. Dena could get the lien reduced the creditor. In other words, the lien wasn’t
to $1,000. The other $4,000 of the lien involuntary, like a tax or judgment lien.
is eliminated (avoided); $3,000 (value of Second, the property you pledged as collateral
item) – $2,000 (exemption amount) = must be exempt under the exemption system you
$1,000 (amount of lien remaining after lien are using. (Remember that domicile requirements
avoidance). may limit the exemptions available to you—see
Advantages. This type of lien avoidance costs Ch. 6 for more information.) If the property
nothing (if you are representing yourself), involves isn’t exempt, then the lien doesn’t impair your
only a moderate amount of paperwork, and often exemption rights, and it can’t be eliminated.
allows you to keep property without paying Third, only certain types of property are
anything. covered. Unfortunately, the property most
Disadvantages. Some paperwork is involved. commonly pledged as collateral for nonpossessory,
Also, by trying to avoid a lien on exempt property, non-purchase-money security interests don’t
you may reopen the issue of whether the property qualify—homes and cars (unless the vehicle
really is e xempt in the first place. This may happen qualifies as a tool of trade, discussed below). You
if the property was deemed exempt by default (that may eliminate a nonpossessory, non-purchase-
is, the property is exempt because the trustee and money security interest lien only if the collateral
creditors didn’t challenge your claim of exemption falls into one of these categories:
within the applicable time limit). Some courts have • household furnishings, household goods,
allowed creditors to argue that the property is not clothing, appliances, books, and musical
exempt at a hearing on a motion to avoid a lien. instruments or jewelry that are primarily for
As a practical matter, however, motions to your personal, family, or household use
avoid a lien are usually not contested. • health aids professionally prescribed for you
Restrictions. There are several important limits or a dependent
on this type of lien avoidance. First, as noted • animals or crops held primarily for your
above, you may avoid only nonpossessory, non- personal, family, or household use (but only
purchase-money security interests. That sounds the first $5,575 of the lien can be avoided),
complicated, but it makes sense when you break it or
down: • implements, machines, professional
• Nonpossessory means the creditor does not books, or tools used in a trade (yours or a
physically keep the property you’ve pledged dependent’s), but only the first $5,575 of the
as collateral. It stays in your possession; the lien can be avoided.
creditor only has a lien on it. (In contrast, You can remove up to $5,575 of a lien from
if you leave your property at a pawnshop a vehicle that qualifies as a tool of your trade.
to get a loan, that is a possessory security Generally, a motor vehicle is considered a tool of
interest—for which this lien avoidance trade only if you use it as an integral part of your
procedure is not available.) business—for example, if you do door-to-door sales
• Non-purchase-money means that you didn’t or delivery work. It is not considered a tool of trade
use the money you borrowed to purchase if you simply use it to commute, even if you have
the collateral. Instead, you used property no other means of getting to work.
you already owned as collateral for the loan.
140 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
To determine whether you can eliminate a judicial lien, If the total of all these items is greater than the
apply this simple formula. Add the following items: value of the property, then you can completely eliminate
• all consensual liens on the property (for judicial liens on the property. The Judicial Lien Work
example, a mortgage and home equity loan) sheet, below, will help you do the math. Here are a few
• all tax liens, and sample calculations:
• your exemption amount.
Amount of judicial lien $ 30,000 Amount of judicial lien $ 30,000 Amount of judicial lien $ 30,000
RESULT: Lien cannot be eliminated. RESULT: $10,000 of lien can be RESULT: Judicial lien can be
eliminated, $20,000 of lien cannot completely eliminated.
be eliminated.
One more point to remember: For the purposes of Example C above, it would not matter if the $30,000
bankruptcy lien avoidance provisions, judicial liens get judgment lien was created before or after the $40,000
the lowest priority, behind consensual liens and tax second mortgage: The judicial lien can be eliminated
liens, regardless of when the liens were placed on the either way.
property and regardless of what state law says. So, in
142 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
an exemption and can’t be avoided. If your home’s value Chapter 7 bankruptcies only, space does not permit us to
later increases enough to give you some equity, you give a full explanation of how to do a successful follow-
might consider reopening the bankruptcy and bringing a up Chapter 13 case. For more information, see Chapter
lien avoidance action. 13 Bankruptcy: Keep Your Property & Repay Debts Over
Time, by Stephen Elias and Robin Leonard (Nolo).
l
9
C H A P T E R
Chapter 7 bankruptcy can be a very straightforward • Be absolutely complete and honest in filling out
process, but only if you follow the rules. If you don’t your paperwork. Except for Form 23, file all of
—even by accident—your bankruptcy case might be your documents at the same time (unless you
dismissed. Not only will you continue to owe your have to file an emergency petition to stop an
debts and face creditor collection actions, but you impending foreclosure, wage garnishment, or
might also lose the protection of the automatic stay in repossession).
any future bankruptcy case you file (see Ch. 4 for more • Don’t file your case until you have your most
information on the automatic stay). recent federal tax return (or a transcript) in
If you keep these golden rules in mind, you’ll save your hands.
yourself a lot of time and trouble: • Serve your tax return (or transcript) on the
• Don’t file for Chapter 7 bankruptcy unless you trustee and any creditors who request it as soon
are sure it is the right choice (Part I explains after you file as possible. If you don’t serve it at
how to make this decision). least seven days before the creditors’ meeting,
• Don’t file until you have completed all of your your case could be dismissed.
documents as directed in this chapter. • Immediately amend your paperwork if the
• Don’t file until you have a certificate showing trustee asks you to.
that you have completed your credit counseling. • Don’t forget your personal financial manage
• If you can, pay your filing fee in full rather than ment counseling. You won’t receive a discharge
in installments, so you don’t have to worry unless, within 45 days after your creditors’ meet
about your case being dismissed if you miss a ing, you file Form 23 certifying that you have
payment. completed this course. (Ch. 10 explains how.)
other bankruptcy papers. Some credit counseling Exceptions to the Counseling Requirement
agencies don’t charge anything for the counseling, You don’t have to get counseling if the U.S.
but require a fee of $50 or more for the certificate. Trustee certifies that there is no appropriate agency
Agencies are legally required to offer their available to you in the district where you will be
services without regard to your ability to pay. (11 filing. However, counseling can be provided by
U.S.C. § 111(c)(2)(B).) If an agency wants to charge telephone or online if the U.S. Trustee approves,
more than you can afford, inform the agency of so it is unlikely that approved debt counseling will
this legal requirement. If the agency doesn’t back ever be unavailable.
down, make notes of your conversations (including In one case, however, a bankruptcy court
who you talked to, what was said, and the date found that counseling was not “available” to a
of the conversation), and then inform the agency debtor who spoke Creole because none of the credit
that you are going to report it to the U.S. Trustee’s counseling agencies in his area could accommodate
Office for failing to take your poverty into account. his language needs. (In re Petit-Louis, 344 B.R.
If that doesn’t bring down the price, go ahead and 696 (S.D. Fla. 2006).) Presumably, this same rule
report the agency. You’ll be doing others in the would apply to any debtor who doesn’t speak
same situation a great favor. (You can find contact standard English and can’t obtain counseling in
information at www.justice.gov/ust.) his or her native language (or through a translator).
Since this case was decided, the U.S. Trustee has
ChaPter 9 | Complete and file Your BAnkruptcy Paperwork | 149
In urban areas especially, you may get no appearing before a trustee at a creditors’ meeting.
response to a letter or phone call to the court Still, some rules may affect routine Chapter 7
clerk. You may need to visit the court and get the bankruptcy cases. You can get your local rules
information in person. Or, the information may be from the bankruptcy court—in person or on its
available on the Internet. Almost all bankruptcy website—but be prepared to comb through reams
courts have websites with this sort of information. of material to find the one or two rules that might
To find your court’s website, visit www.uscourts. apply in your case.
gov/courtlinks.
Number of Copies
Fees Before filing your papers, find out how many
The current fee charged by the court to file for copies your court requires. Most ask for an
Chapter 7 bankruptcy is $299. Fees change, original and one copy. The original will be scanned
however, so make sure you verify the amount with into the court’s database, and your copy will be
the court. This fee is due upon filing, unless the “conformed” for your records. (A conformed copy
court waives the fee or gives you permission to pay is either stamped or receives a computer-generated
in installments. (To make these requests, you must label, with information showing that you filed,
complete Form 3A or 3B, as explained below.) the date of your filing, your case number, and the
tentative date of your creditors’ meeting.) A few
Local Forms courts still require you to provide an original and
four copies.
In addition to the official forms that every bank
ruptcy court uses (they are listed below), your local
bankruptcy court may require you to file one or two
Order of Papers and Other Details
additional forms that it has developed. For example, Every court has a preferred order in which it wants
different courts have different forms that you must to receive the forms in the package you submit
file along with your wage stubs (as explained above). for filing. Most courts also have rules indicating
You can get any required local forms from your whether the forms should be hole-punched or
local bankruptcy court or you can download them stapled, and other details. If you mess up, most
from your court’s website. (Go to www.uscourts. clerks will put your forms in the correct order or
gov/courtlinks for a list of links to local courts.) punch and staple your papers in the right way. Some,
There are far too many local forms for us to explain however, will make you do it yourself. This can be
them here. Most, however, are easy to complete. If a major pain if you are filing by mail. Every court
you need help obtaining or understanding a local has an exhibit of the standard Chapter 7 bankruptcy
form, ask a bankruptcy lawyer or visit a bankruptcy filing with the forms arranged correctly. If you
petition preparer. (See Ch. 12 for information on want to get it right the first time, visit the court and
bankruptcy petition preparers.) carefully examine the court’s sample filing, taking
notes on which forms fall in which order.
Local Court Rules Below is a sample letter you can adapt to your
situation and send to the court, requesting the
Most bankruptcy courts publish local rules that information discussed above. Include a large, self-
govern that court’s procedures. These rules mainly addressed envelope. Call and ask the court if you
govern hearings conducted by the bankruptcy need to affix return postage. Again, if you live in
judge; they aren’t relevant in routine bankruptcy an urban area, you’ll probably have to visit the
cases, which usually involve only filing papers and court to get this information.
152 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
of common law marriage, but the rules for what couple, and one of you has all the debts, it
constitutes a marriage differ from state to state. may make sense for that spouse to file for
And, several of these states will only recognize bankruptcy alone (especially if the nonfiling
common law marriages that were created before a spouse has good credit to protect).
certain date. • If you are living in a community property state,
If you live in one of these states and you most of your debts were incurred during
meet your state’s requirements for a common law marriage, and most of your money and
marriage, you may file jointly if you wish. property was acquired during marriage, you
should probably file jointly. Even if only
Same-Sex Marriage one spouse files, all community property is
If you married your same-sex partner in a state, considered part of that spouse’s bankruptcy
country, or province that recognizes same-sex estate. The same is generally true for debts—
marriage, the prevailing opinion among bankruptcy that is, all community debts are listed and
lawyers and judges is that the federal Defense of discharged even though only one spouse files
Marriage Act (1 U.S.C. § 7 and 28 U.S.C. § 1738C) (although some creditors may attempt to
prohibits federal courts from recognizing your collect community debts that are listed in the
marriage for bankruptcy purposes. In other words, names of both spouses). See Ch. 1 and Ch. 5
you have to file for bankruptcy separately. for more on community property.
At least one court has refused to allow a • If you and your spouse own property as
lesbian couple that had married in Canada to file tenants by the entirety (see Ch. 7), you owe
a joint bankruptcy petition. If you choose to file most of your debts in your own name, and
jointly with your same-sex spouse, you may well you live in a state that excludes property
face opposition on these grounds from the trustee held in a tenancy by the entirety from the
or the U.S. Trustee. Consider consulting with a bankruptcy estate when only one spouse
bankruptcy attorney who has some experience files, you may want to file alone. This is a
with issues facing same-sex couples before you particularly important consideration if you
decide how to proceed. While filing separately will own your home as tenants by the entirety—
require you to pay an extra $299 filing fee, it also filing jointly could cause you to lose your
effectively doubles the amount of exemptions you home unnecessarily.
can claim in states where spouses are not allowed • If the exemption system you are using allows
to double. spouses to double their exemptions, filing for
bankruptcy jointly may help you hang on to
Should You File Jointly? more of your property. (See Ch. 6 for more
information on exemptions, and Appendix
Unfortunately, there is no simple formula that will A for state-by-state information on whether
tell you whether it’s better to file alone or with doubling exemptions is allowed.)
your spouse. In the end, it will depend on which • If you are married and share finances, you
option allows you to discharge more of your debts should consider a joint filing. The court
and keep more of your property, and whether at will look at your total household income
least one of you still has good credit that can be to determine whether you pass the bank
maintained by a separate filing. Here are some of ruptcy means test (and are therefore eligible
the factors you should consider: to use Chapter 7). If your spouse’s income
• If you have recently married, you haven’t is significantly larger than your own, filing
acquired any valuable assets as a married alone could lead the court to dismiss your
154 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
case for abuse, particularly if the court name statement, bank account, or other formal
believes that you filed alone to prevent business documents).
the court from considering your spouse’s
income. If the debts you are trying to See an Expert
discharge benefited both of you, and
The decision to file jointly or alone can have
your finances are combined, a court may significant consequences. Because the best choice will
consider your nonfiling spouse’s income depend on your situation and the laws of your state, we
in determining whether you could afford advise you to talk to a bankruptcy lawyer if you have
a Chapter 13 repayment plan. (See In re any questions about which option makes more sense.
Haney, No. 06-40350 (W.D. Ky. 2006), in We’ve provided some general guidelines, but you should
which the court considered the nonfiling definitely consult with a local lawyer regarding what will
spouse’s income of $6,000 or $7,000 a happen to your business assets and debts if only one of
month in dismissing the bankruptcy case of you files.
the filing spouse, who brought in less than
$400 a month.)
• If you are still married but separated, you
may have to file alone if your spouse won’t Required Forms and Documents
cooperate (for example, by providing finan- Bankruptcy uses official forms prescribed by the
cial information, signing the papers as a Federal Office of the Courts. In addition, you
codebtor, attending the mandatory counsel- must file certain documents, as described above
ing sessions, and appearing at the creditors’ in “Gather the Necessary Documents.” Here we
meeting). provide complete lists of (1) the official forms you
When deciding whether to file jointly or alone will be completing in this chapter, and (2) the
in a community property state, you’ll need to know documents that you will have to file along with
whether you both own the “family business” or the official forms. We also explain how to get these
whether only one of you owns it. This isn’t as easy forms and documents.
as you may think. As a general rule, if the filing
spouse owned the business going into the marriage,
and the nonfiling spouse has not been added as an Checklist of Required
owner on any of the business-related documents— Bankruptcy Forms
such as fictitious business name registration—then These are the standard forms that must be filed in
the nonfiling spouse isn’t an owner and won’t be every Chapter 7 bankruptcy:
held liable for any of its debts. On the other hand, ■■ Form 1—Voluntary Petition
if the nonfiling spouse owned the business prior ■■ Form 3A (if you want to pay your filing fee
to the marriage and the filing spouse hasn’t been in installments)
added as an owner, the business assets needn’t be ■■ Form 3B (if you apply for a fee waiver)
included in the bankruptcy. If the business was ■■ Form 6, which consists of:
started during the marriage, it will generally be ■■ Schedule A—Real Property
considered community property and included in ■■ Schedule B—Personal Property
the bankruptcy even if only one of you files. ■■ Schedule C—Property Claimed as
In “common law” marital property states, the Exempt
business belongs to the spouse whose name appears ■■ Schedule D—Creditors Holding
on the title documents (such as a fictitious business Secured Claims
ChaPter 9 | Complete and file Your BAnkruptcy Paperwork | 155
• proof that you have completed a course in Type your final forms. If you are using the Nolo
personal financial management (you must forms or the PDF forms available from the U.S.
attach this to Form 23). courts’ website (see above), you may enter your
information by hand. Unless your handwriting
Where to Get the Official Forms is very neat, however, your case will likely go a
lot more smoothly if your forms are typewritten.
Appendix C of this book includes tear-out copies If you don’t have access to a typewriter, many
of all of the required bankruptcy forms. You can libraries have typewriters available to the public (for
type the necessary information in the blanks or a small rental fee), or you can hire a bankruptcy
complete the forms by hand. Some of these forms form preparation service to prepare your forms
may be out of date by the time you use this book, using the information you provide. (See Ch. 12 for
so you should always check the dates on the forms more on these services.)
against the dates on the most current versions Be ridiculously thorough. Always err on the side
available online. The website of the United States of giving too much information rather than too
Courts offers a complete and current set of official little. If you leave information out, the bankruptcy
forms at www.uscourts.gov/bkforms/index.html, trustee may become suspicious of your motives or
which you can fill in electronically and print (but delay your case until you provide more information.
not save on your computer). Bankruptcy law requires you to disclose all of your
creditors. Your bankruptcy may be jeopardized if
Tips for Completing the Forms you intentionally omit anyone. The debts you owe
creditors who are left off your forms might even
Here are some tips that will make filling in your
survive your bankruptcy—hardly the result you
forms easier and the whole bankruptcy process
want. If you intentionally or carelessly fail to list
smoother. A completed sample form accompanies
all your property and debts, or fail to accurately
each form’s instructions. Refer to it while you fill in
describe your recent property transactions, the
your bankruptcy papers.
court may find that you acted with fraudulent
Use your worksheets and credit counseling plan (if
intent. It may deny your bankruptcy discharge
you have one). If you’ve completed the worksheets
altogether, and you may lose some property that you
in previous chapters, you’ve already done a lot of
could otherwise have kept. The three basic rules of
the work. These worksheets will save you lots of
bankruptcy form preparation are disclose, disclose,
time when you prepare your bankruptcy forms,
and, you guessed it, disclose.
so keep them handy. If you skipped any of those
Respond to every question. Most of the forms
chapters, refer to the worksheets and accompanying
have a box to check when your answer is “none.”
instructions for help in figuring out what to put in
If a question doesn’t have a “none” box and the
your bankruptcy forms.
question doesn’t apply to you, type in “N/A” for
Make several copies of each form. Having several
“not applicable.” This will let the trustee know that
copies allows you to make a draft, changing things
you didn’t overlook the question. Occasionally,
as you go until the form is complete and correct.
a question that doesn’t apply to you will have a
Prepare final forms to file with the court only
number of blanks. Put “N/A” in only the first blank
after you’ve double-checked your drafts. If you use
if it is obvious that this applies to the other blanks
the PDF fill-in-the-blanks forms available on the
as well. If it’s not clear, put “N/A” in every blank.
official U.S. courts’ website (see above), remember
Explain uncertainties. If you can’t figure out
that you can’t save the information in the forms.
which category on a form to use for a debt or an
It’s easiest to do a draft by hand, then complete the
item of property, list the debt or item in what you
form and print it all at once.
ChaPter 9 | Complete and file Your BAnkruptcy Paperwork | 157
think is the appropriate place and briefly note next from this fictional gal. DO NOT COPY THESE
to your entry that you’re uncertain. The important EXAMPLES VERBATIM.
thing is to disclose the information somewhere.
The bankruptcy trustee will sort it out, if necessary.
About Our Fictional Debtor
Be scrupulously honest. As part of your official
bankruptcy paperwork, you must complete declara Annie is a recently divorced mother of one who
tions, under penalty of perjury, swearing that owns a boutique women’s accessories store. Her
you’ve been truthful. It’s important to realize that business has been steadily going downhill since
you could be prosecuted for perjury if it becomes 2007, along with the economy. Her commercial
evident that you deliberately lied. landlord likes Annie and would like to keep her in
Use continuation pages if you run out of room. her retail space, but he isn’t willing to reduce her
The space for entering information is sometimes rent to an amount she can afford or forgive the
skimpy, especially if you’re filing jointly. Most of back rent she owes him. This means that Annie will
the forms come with preformatted continuation have to close her business whether or not she files
pages that you can use if you need more room. But for bankruptcy. She is looking for a job to tide her
if there is no continuation form in Appendix C, over, but hopes to open a new boutique when the
prepare one yourself, using a piece of regular, white economy improves.
8½" × 11" paper. Write “see continuation page” Because Annie’s business is a sole proprietor
next to the question you’re working on and enter ship, she can use her state’s personal exemptions to
the additional information on the continuation keep some of her business assets. She has decided
to try to protect her customer list and inventory
page. Label the continuation pages with your name
but give up her store’s hard assets (fixtures, office
and the form name, and indicate “Continuation
equipment, and so on). She can’t really place a
page 1,” “Continuation page 2,” and so on. Be sure
value on her store’s good will, so she’s decided not
to attach all continuation pages to their appropriate
to claim an exemption for that. As is true of many
forms when you file your bankruptcy papers.
small business owners, Annie can only provide a
Get help if necessary. If your situation is
best guess as to the value of some of her business
complicated, you’re unsure about how to complete
assets. If some assets turn out to be worth more
a form, or you run into trouble when you go to file than she thought, she can amend her paperwork to
your papers, consult a bankruptcy attorney or do try to exempt the items that are most important
some legal research before proceeding. (See Ch. to her. (Coincidentally, Annie’s fictional state
12.) of Anonymous follows California’s exemption
Refer to—but don’t copy—the sample forms. system, and Annie has chosen to use the System 2
Throughout this chapter, we have included exemptions.)
the completed sample forms of Annie Justine Annie’s debts are primarily from her business,
Kaye, a small business owner who lives and does so she doesn’t have to take the means test
business in her hometown of Freshstart, in the (although she still has to file Form 22A).
fictional state of Anonymous (AA). These forms
are intended to be used as examples, so you can
see what a completed form should look like.
However, everyone’s bankruptcy situation is
different—and obviously, you will owe different Form 1—Voluntary Petition
debts, own different property, have different bank
A completed sample Voluntary Petition and line-
accounts and Social Security numbers, live in an
by-line instructions follow.
actual state, and otherwise be utterly dissimilar
158 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
Type of Debtor. Check the first box— file Proof of Claim forms. If you haven’t a clue yet
“Individual(s)”—even if you are self-employed or about your property and exemptions, come back to
operate a sole proprietorship. this question after you’ve completed Schedules A,
Nature of Business. See a bankruptcy lawyer B, and C.
if any of these descriptions apply to you or your Similarly, if you can provide pretty good
spouse. For instance, if you or your spouse owns an estimates of the other information requested
assisted living facility (11 U.S.C. § 101 (27A)), you (estimated number of creditors, assets, and
would need a lawyer’s services, because the law has liabilities), fill in the appropriate box on the form.
gotten quite complicated regarding how health care If not, come back to these questions when you’ve
businesses are treated in bankruptcy. completed more of your paperwork.
Tax-Exempt Entity. Leave this blank. This box is
for nonprofits only. Second Page
Chapter of Bankruptcy Code Under Which the Name of Debtor(s). Enter your name, and your
Petition is Filed. Check “Chapter 7.” spouse’s if you are filing jointly.
Nature of Debts. Check the box for consumer All Prior Bankruptcy Cases Filed Within Last 8
debts if most of your debts are personal debts rather Years. If you haven’t filed a bankruptcy case within
than business debts. If, however, the bulk of your the previous eight years, type “None” or “N/A” in
debts are due to the operation of a business, check the first box. If you—or your spouse, if you’re filing
the business debts box. If you are in doubt, check jointly—have, enter the requested information. A
the business debts box. If the bulk of your debts are previous Chapter 7 bankruptcy discharge bars you
business debts, you don’t have to take the means from filing until eight years have passed since you
test (see Ch. 2 for more information). filed the previous case. And, if you filed a Chapter
Filing Fee. If you will attach the entire fee, 7 bankruptcy case that was dismissed for cause
check the first box. If you plan to ask the court for within the previous 180 days, you may have to wait
permission to pay in installments, check the second to file again, or you may not be able to discharge
box. (Instructions for applying to the court are all your debts. (See Ch. 2 for more information.)
in “How to File Your Papers,” below.) If you wish If either situation applies to you, see a bankruptcy
to apply for a full waiver of the filing fee, check lawyer before filing.
the third box and see “How to File Your Papers,” Pending Bankruptcy Case Filed by any Spouse,
below. Partner, or Affiliate of this Debtor. “Affiliate” refers
Chapter 11 Debtors. Leave this section blank. to a related business under a corporate structure.
Statistical/Administrative Information. There “Partner” refers to a business partnership. Again,
are a number of boxes here. The first set of boxes you shouldn’t use this book if you’re filing as a
tells the trustee whether you think there will be corporation, partnership, or other type of business
assets available to be sold for the benefit of your entity. If your spouse has a bankruptcy case
unsecured creditors. If you did your homework pending anywhere in the country, enter the
in Ch. 5 and Ch. 6, you will have a good idea of requested information. Otherwise, type “None” or
whether all of your assets are exempt, or whether “N/A” in the first box.
some will have to be surrendered to the trustee. Exhibit A. This is solely for people who are filing
Check the top or bottom box accordingly. If you for Chapter 11 bankruptcy. Leave it blank.
check the bottom box, your creditors will be told Exhibit B. This is solely for people who are
that there is no point in filing a Proof of Claim represented by an attorney. If you are representing
unless they hear differently from the trustee. If you yourself or using a bankruptcy petition preparer,
check the top box, your creditors will be told to leave this section blank.
ChAPter 9 | COMPLETE AND FILE YOUR BANKRUPTCY PAPERWORK | 161
Exhibit C. If you own or have in your possession Signature of Attorney. Assuming you are
any property that might cause “imminent and representing yourself, type “debtor not represented
identifiable” harm to public health or safety (for by attorney” in the space for the attorney’s
example, real estate that is polluted with toxic signature.
substances, or explosive devices such as hand Signature of Non-Attorney Bankruptcy Petition
grenades or dynamite), check the “yes” box, fill in Preparer. If a bankruptcy petition preparer typed
Exhibit C (see Appendix C), and attach Exhibit C your forms, have that person complete this section.
to this Petition. If you are unsure about whether a
particular piece of property fits the bill, err on the Exhibit D
side of inclusion.
Exhibit D. As explained above, debtors filing for At the top of the page, fill in the court name, your
Chapter 7 bankruptcy are required to participate name(s) as debtor(s), and the case number (if you
in debt counseling sessions within 180 days of have it).
their bankruptcy filing. Exhibit D tells the court The warning in bold letters explains that you
whether you’ve complied with this requirement. have to check one of the five statements regarding
Instructions for completing Exhibit D are set credit counseling listed in Exhibit D.
out below. Check the top box in this part of the Most people will check box 1, which means
petition if you are filing individually and have you obtained the certificate of completion from
completed Exhibit D; if you are filing jointly and the credit counseling agency and can attach the
your spouse has completed Exhibit D, check the certificate (and any debt repayment plan developed
bottom box. through the agency) to your petition.
Information Regarding the Debtor—Venue. If you have received counseling but haven’t
Check the top box. got your certificate yet, check box 2. To remain
Certification by a Debtor Who Resides as a in bankruptcy, you’ll need to obtain and file your
Tenant of Residential Property. Certain evictions are certificate (and debt repayment plan if any) within
allowed to proceed after you file for bankruptcy, 14 days after your bankruptcy filing date.
despite the automatic stay. The questions in this Checking box 3 indicates that you have
section are intended to show whether your landlord requested credit counseling but were unable to
has already gotten a judgment for possession obtain the services within seven days after your
(eviction order), and whether you still may be request, and have not yet received counseling. If
able to postpone the eviction. See Ch. 4 for the you check this box, you’ll have to explain why you
information you need to complete these boxes, if couldn’t complete the credit counseling before
they apply. your filing date. Read the bold type for additional
information regarding your obligations if you wish
Third Page to remain in bankruptcy.
Signature(s) of Debtor(s) (Individual/Joint). You—and Box 4 summarizes the exceptions to the credit-
your spouse, if you are filing jointly—must sign, counseling requirement and asks you to check the
date, and provide your telephone number where appropriate reason.
indicated. By signing, you—and your spouse, if Box 5 only applies if the credit-counseling
you are filing jointly—declare that you are aware requirement doesn’t apply in your district. This
that you may file under other sections of the exception is very rare.
bankruptcy code, and that you still choose to file Sign and date this document under penalty of
for Chapter 7 bankruptcy. perjury and file it with your petition.
164 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
Description and Location of Property. For each Simply being named in a will, revocable
piece of real property you own, list the type of living trust or beneficiary designation
property—for example, house, office building, instrument doesn’t create a future interest,
farm, or undeveloped lot—and street address. You because the p erson who signed any of these
don’t need to include the legal description of the documents could change it to cut you out.
property (the description on the deed). • Contingent interest. This ownership interest
Nature of Debtor’s Interest in Property. In this doesn’t come into existence unless one
column, you need to provide the legal definition or more conditions are fulfilled. Wills
for the interest you (or you and your spouse) sometimes leave property to people under
have in the real estate. The most common type certain conditions. If the conditions aren’t
of interest—outright ownership—is called “fee met, the property passes to someone else.
simple.” Even if you still owe money on your For instance, Emma’s will leaves her house
mortgage, as long as you have the right to sell the to John provided that he takes care of
house, leave it to your heirs, and make alterations, her until her death. If John doesn’t care
your ownership is fee simple. A fee simple interest for Emma, the house passes to Emma’s
may be owned by one person or by several people daughter Jane. Both John and Jane have
jointly. Normally, when people are listed on a deed contingent interests in Emma’s home.
as the owners—even if they own the property as • Lienholder. If you are the holder of a
joint tenants, tenants in common, or tenants by the mortgage, deed of trust, judgment lien, or
entirety—the ownership interest is in fee simple. mechanics’ lien on real estate, you have an
Other types of real property interests include: ownership interest in the real estate
• Life estate. Fairly uncommon, this is the • Easement holder. If you are the holder of a
right to possess and use property only right to travel on or otherwise use property
during your lifetime. You can’t sell the owned by someone else, you have an
property, give it away, or leave it to someone easement.
when you die. Instead, when you die, the • Power of appointment. If you have a legal
property passes to whomever was named right, given to you in a will or transfer
in the instrument (trust, deed, or will) of property, to sell a specified piece of
that created your life estate. This type someone’s property, that’s called a power of
of ownership is usually created when appointment and should be listed. You may
the sole owner of a piece of real estate have authority to sell someone’s property
wants his surviving spouse to live on the under a power of attorney, but that’s not
property for the rest of her life, but then the same as a power of appointment and
have the property pass to his children. In shouldn’t be listed as a real estate interest on
this situation, the surviving spouse has Schedule A.
a life estate. Surviving spouses who are • Beneficial ownership under a real estate
beneficiaries of AB, spousal, or marital contract. This is the right to own property
bypass trusts have life estates. by virtue of having signed a binding real
• Future interest. This is your right to own estate contract. Even though the buyer
property sometime in the future. A doesn’t yet own the property, the buyer
common future interest is owned by a does have a “beneficial interest”—that is,
person who—under the terms of a deed or the right to own the property once the
irrevocable trust—will definitely inherit formalities are completed. For example,
the property when its current owner dies. property buyers have a beneficial ownership
168 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
Sample Schedule A
ChaPter 9 | Complete and file Your BAnkruptcy Paperwork | 169
interest in property while the escrow is example, if you and your brother own a home as
pending. joint tenants (each owns 50%), split the property’s
If you have trouble figuring out which of these current market value in half and list that amount
definitions best fits your type of ownership interest, here.
leave the column blank and let the trustee help you If your interest is intangible—for example, you
sort it out. are a beneficiary of real estate held in trust that won’t
Husband, Wife, Joint, or Community. If you’re not be distributed for many years—enter an estimate
married, put “N/A.” If you are married, indicate provided by a real estate appraiser or put “don’t
whether the real estate is owned: know” and explain why you can’t be more precise.
• by the husband (H)
• by the wife (W)
Mobile Home Owners
• jointly by husband and wife as joint tenants,
tenants in common, or tenants by the If you own a mobile home in a park, use the value
entirety (J), or of the home in its current location, even though
• jointly by husband and wife as community the mobile home itself might qualify as personal
property (C). property. Many parks are located in desirable areas,
If the real property is held in the name of a and the park itself adds value to the motor home
sole proprietorship business, check the column even though you may not have any ownership
indicating the business owner. If you are married interest in the park itself. A mobile home that
and live in a community property state, the might not be worth much on its own could be
business is most likely the community property of worth quite a bit if it’s sitting in a fancy park.
both spouses (C). If the business was owned by one
spouse prior to marriage, it would belong to that
spouse alone, at least for purposes of filling out this Total. Add the amounts in the fourth column
form. If you live in a common law property state, and enter the total in the box at the bottom of
ownership will depend on who signed the deed, the page. The form reminds you that you should
registered the business, or otherwise indicated also enter this total on the Summary of Schedules
ownership on formal documents. (see the instructions for completing the Summary,
Current Value of Debtor’s Interest in Property, below).
without Deducting any Secured Claim or Exemption. Amount of Secured Claim. List mortgages and
Enter the current fair market value of your real estate other debts secured by the property. If there is no
ownership interest. If you filled in the Homeowners’ secured claim of any type on the real estate, enter
Worksheet in Ch. 7, use the value you came up with “None.” If there is, enter separately the amount of
there (assuming the real property is your home). each outstanding mortgage, deed of trust, home
Don’t figure in homestead exemptions or any equity loan, or lien (judgment lien, mechanic’s
mortgages or other liens on the property. Just put lien, materialmen’s lien, tax lien, or the like) that is
the actual current market value as best you can claimed against the property. If you don’t know the
calculate it. However, you can deduct the costs of balance on your mortgage, deed of trust, or home
sale from the market value and enter the difference, equity loan, call the lender. To find out whether
as long as you explain what you did on the schedule. there are liens on the property—and if so, for how
(See Ch. 7 for information on valuing real estate.) much—visit the land records office in your county
If you own the property with someone else (or check online) and look up the parcel in the
who is not joining you in your bankruptcy, list records; the clerk can show you how. Or, you can
only your ownership share in this column. For order a title search through a real estate attorney or
170 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
title insurance company. If you own several pieces Schedule B—Personal Property
of real estate and there is one lien on file against
all of it, list the full amount of the lien for each Here you must list and evaluate all of your
separate parcel. Don’t worry if, taken together, the personal property, including intangible property
value of the liens is higher than the value of the (such as accounts receivable and possible legal
property; it’s quite common. claims), property that is security for a debt, and
How you itemize liens in this schedule won’t property that is exempt. If you didn’t fill in the
affect how your property or the liens will be treated Personal Property Checklist and Property Exemp
in bankruptcy. The idea here is to notify the trustee tion Worksheet in Ch. 6, turn to that chapter
of all p
ossible liens that may affect your equity in for explanations and suggestions about what
your real estate. property you should list in each of the schedule’s
If you are simply unable to obtain this infor- categories. Remember that the assets of your sole
mation, and you can’t afford the help of a lawyer proprietorship business are your personal property
or title insurance company, put “unknown.” This and must be listed on Schedule B.
will be okay for the purpose of filing your papers, When listing all of your stuff on a public
but you may need to get the information later. For document like Schedule B, you might feel tempted
example, a question might come up as to whether to cheat a little. Don’t give in to the temptation to
the equity in your home is protected by your exemp- “forget” any of your assets. Bankruptcy law doesn’t
tion. Suppose your state’s homestead exemption is give you the right to decide that an asset isn’t worth
$10,000 and your equity is $30,000. You would mentioning. Even if, for example, you’ve decided
probably lose the house and receive $10,000 for your that your CD collection is worthless given the
exemption, and your creditors would get $20,000, advent of the iPod, you still have to list it. You can
less the cost of sale and the trustee’s commission. But explain on the form why you think it’s worthless. If
if there were an unknown lien on the property for you omit something and get caught, your case can
$20,000, then you wouldn’t lose the house because be dismissed—or your discharge revoked—which
the trustee wouldn’t sell the property because means you’ll get no bankruptcy relief for your
there would be nothing left over for the unsecured current debts. Remember, you can use exemptions
creditors after the lienholder was paid. So it’s to your to keep much of your property; if no exemption is
benefit to get this information any way you can. available, you may be able to buy the property back
from the trustee.
A completed sample of Schedule B and line-
How to List Property That Is Subject
by-line instructions follow. If you need more room,
to Foreclosure Proceedings
use an a ttached continuation page, or create a
Even if your property is subject to foreclosure continuation page yourself.
proceedings, you still own the property until the In re and Case No. Follow the instructions for
foreclosure sale is held and a new deed is recorded Schedule A.
either in the lender’s name (if the property fails to Type of Property. The form lists general
sell) or in the purchaser’s name (if the foreclosure categories of personal property. Leave this column
auction ends in a successful bid). You should list as is.
the property in Schedule A and include all of the None. If you own no property that fits in a
required information. You should also explain that category listed in the first column, enter an “X” in
the house is in foreclosure and provide the date set the “None” column. But make sure that you really
for the foreclosure sale (if it has gotten that far) or, don’t own anything in this category.
if not, when you expect the property to be sold.
ChaPter 9 | Complete and file Your BAnkruptcy Paperwork | 171
Description and Location of Property. List ice cream scoop; instead, put “kitchen cookware”
specific items that fall in each general category. (unless one of these items is worth a lot). If you
If you filled out the Personal Property Checklist list numerous items in one category (as is likely for
and Property Exemption Worksheet in Ch. 6, you household goods and furnishings), you may need to
already have this information. If not, be sure to attach a continuation sheet.
go over the Personal Property Checklist, which For each category of property listed, you must
lists types of property to include in each category. indicate where the property is. If your personal
Although the categories in the checklist correspond property is at your residence, just enter “Residence”
to the categories in Schedule B, the checklist or your home address beneath the property
describes some of them differently (where we felt description. If the property is at your business,
the Schedule B descriptions weren’t clear). enter the business address beneath the property
description. If someone else holds property for you
(for example, you loaned your woodworking tools
CAUTION
to a friend), put that person’s name and address in
Start with the property’s replacement
this column.
value. Although some bankruptcy commentators believe
that you must use the property’s replacement value—
Here are further instructions for some of the
what it would cost to purchase the property from a retail categories:
vendor, given the property’s age and condition—for your Items 1 and 2. List the amount and source
estimates on Schedule B, we are not convinced that this of any cash on hand or money in financial
is legally required. The only value that matters in this accounts—for example, from business receipts,
context is its “fire sale” value (what the trustee would get wages (if you have a day job to supplement your
for the property in a trustee’s sale), which would likely business income), Social Security payments, or
be less than the property’s replacement value. Despite child support. Listing everything will help you
our view of this matter, we recommend that you at (and the trustee) decide later whether any of this
least start with the property’s replacement value. If that money qualifies as exempt property. You must list
value renders the property nonexempt to a significant the amount in your account on the day you file
degree, then consider listing the lower “fire sale” value for bankruptcy, even if you have written checks
and disclosing that fact along with the description of the on the account that haven’t yet cleared. All money
property. Chances are that the trustee will choose not in your accounts on the day you file is property of
to take the property because there would be little or your bankruptcy estate, and the trustee can take
nothing left to pay the creditors with after you receive that money unless it’s exempt (even if that means
your exemption amount. (See Ch. 6 for more on how you bounce a check or two). (In re Schoonover, No.
exemptions work.) 05-43662-7 (D. Kan. 2006).) The amount you list
should be about what will be in the account when
Separately list all items worth $50 to $100 you file your bankruptcy paperwork (and shortly
or more (there is no hard and fast rule about afterwards). If you list a small amount on your
this). Combine small items into larger categories forms but your account balance grows significantly
whenever reasonable. For example, you don’t need just after you file, the trustee may freeze the
to list every spatula, colander, garlic press, and account pending further investigation.
172 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
If You Are Listed on Someone Item 13. Here is where you describe your
Else’s Account ownership interest in your business, unless it is
a partnership or joint venture (see Item 14). Sole
As explained in Ch. 5, if you are named on a proprietors should list their business here, whether
parent’s bank account (typically, to manage the or not it’s conducted under a different name. If
parent’s finances if he or she becomes incapacitated you are a sole or partial owner of a corporation or
or otherwise needs help), the trustee might believe
LLC, describe the exact nature of your interest in
that account should be part of your bankruptcy
the company or entity (for instance, “sole owner
estate. To prevent the trustee from getting a false
with wife of a C corporation,” or “owner of 50%
idea about the nature of the account, the best
stocks in ABC Inc.” or “owner of a 40% interest in
approach is to list it under Item 2 and then explain
an LLC”). If you have stock options, describe them
the true facts, which usually are that the money in
here.
the account came from and belongs to the parent,
If your business is a sole proprietorship, its
that the bankruptcy filer was only added to the
account as a fiduciary (a trusted assistant), and that
value will most readily be measured by the value
it would be a breach of the fiduciary duty for the of its assets (equipment, machines, inventory,
filer to use any of the parent’s money for the filer’s accounts receivable, goodwill, and so on). You
own purposes. should itemize your assets as best you can, attaching
If the exemptions you are using allow you as many continuation sheets as you need. For
to exempt bank accounts or cash up to a certain instance, if you have a retail business, you can
amount, and you have enough of that exemption attach a recent inventory (if you have one), or bring
left over to apply to the money in your parent’s your inventory current if you haven’t done one in a
account, it makes sense to claim the money in while. If you have a service or professional business,
your parent’s account as exempt on Schedule or otherwise don’t have inventory, list your larger
C (explained below). The claim of exemption is assets and summarize the small stuff (for instance,
legally unnecessary, but it will prevent the trustee desk $200, chair, $300, labeling machine $500,
from trying to prove that the money should be stationary and supplies $400).
considered part of your bankruptcy estate; even if it If you own shares in a publicly traded
is, you’ll be able to keep it all anyway. corporation, use the listed value of the shares. If
your corporation is a close corporation or LLC,
it will be difficult to value your interest. (See Ch.
Item 11. Although an education IRA and a 6 for more in how to value ownership interests in
qualified state tuition plan may technically not business entities.) If the corporation or LLC has
be part of the bankruptcy estate, list them here been capitalized, then the value of your interest can
anyway. Also, you are required to file any records be measured by its capital (assets minus liabilities).
you have of these interests as an attachment to Or, for a corporation, the corporate accountant
Schedule B. may be able to give you an estimate based on the
Item 12. Although ERISA-qualified pension number of shares issued and the book value of
plans, 401(k)s, IRAs, and Keoghs may not be the corporation used for taxation and bank loan
part of your bankruptcy estate, list them here purposes. An alternative is to list the value as
anyway and describe each plan in detail. In the “unknown” and let the trustee help you sort it out.
Current Value column, enter the value of the Item 14. If you own a partnership or joint
pension, if known. Otherwise, list the value as venture, list it here. You’ll almost certainly need
“undetermined.” help from the business CFO or accountant to place
a value on your ownership interest.
174 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
Item 15. As a small business owner, you may your parents’ trust gives them the right to live in
not own government or corporate bonds. However, the family home, that’s a “life estate.” If the trust
you may own other instruments that carry some gives you the home when they die, you have an
value, such as promissory notes. If so, describe “equitable interest” in the home while they’re alive.
them here and provide their face value in your “Powers exercisable for the benefit of the debtor”
description (for example, “promissory note in the means that a person has been given the power to
amount of $4,500 signed by Bob Pascarelli, dated route property to you, but it hasn’t happened by
2/10/2010”). the time you file your bankruptcy petition. In
Item 16. If you are a sole proprietor or inde sum, if it looks like property is coming your way
pendent contractor, one or more of your customers eventually, and that property hasn’t been listed in
probably owe you some money that isn’t formally Schedule A, list it here. These kinds of interests are
documented in a promissory note or other written hard to value. You’ll need to get some help from an
instrument. If so, list each debt by customer name, appraiser or list the value as “unknown” and let the
the reason for the debt, and the date the debt was trustee sort it out.
incurred. These debts belong to your bankruptcy Item 20. You have a contingent interest in
estate and may be collected by the trustee unless property if, for example, you are named the
you are able to claim them as exempt. remainder beneficiary of an irrevocable trust (a
Item 17. List all child support or alimony trust that can’t be undone by the person who
arrears—that is, money that should have been created it). It’s contingent because you may or may
paid to you but hasn’t been. Specify the dates the not get something from the trust—it all depends
payments were due and missed, such as “$250 on whether there’s anything left by the time it
monthly child support payments for June, July, gets to you. A noncontingent interest means you
August, and September 20xx.” Also list any debts will definitely get the property sooner or later, for
owed you from a property settlement incurred in a example, under the terms of an insurance policy.
divorce or dissolution. Also list here any wills or revocable living trusts on
Item 18. List all other money owed to you and which you are named as a beneficiary. Even though
not yet paid, other than accounts receivable (those you don’t have any right to inherit under these
go in Item 16) and child support, alimony, and documents (because they can be changed at any
property settlements (which should be listed in time prior to the person’s death), the trustee wants
Item 17). If you’ve obtained a judgment against to know this information because the inheritance
someone but haven’t been paid, list it here. State becomes part of your bankruptcy estate if the
the defendant’s name, the date of the judgment, person dies within six months after you file for
the court that issued the judgment, the amount of bankruptcy.
the judgment, and the kind of case (such as “car Item 21. List all claims that you have against
accident”). If you are filing for bankruptcy early in others that might end up in a lawsuit. For instance,
the year and know how much your tax refund will if you were recently rear-ended in an automobile
be, you should list the amount here even though accident and are struggling with whiplash, you
you haven’t received it yet. If your state’s exemption may have a cause of action against the other driver
system allows you to exempt cash, you can exempt (and that driver’s insurer). Or, you might have
the tax refund on Schedule C (explained below). contractual claims against a vendor or customer of
Item 19. An “equitable or future interest” means your business. Make sure you list and do your best
that sooner or later you will get property that is to value all possible “causes of action.” If you don’t
currently owned by someone else. Your expectation list this type of claim here, you may be prohibited
is legally recognized and valuable. For instance, if from pursuing it later.
176 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
Item 22. This question asks about intellectual that you obtained from people as part of providing
property assets. State the type of intellectual them with consumer goods or services. For example,
property you own (patent, copyright, trademark, if you have a database of customers’ email addresses
or similar right) and its subject matter. Give the and contact information for your graphic design
number assigned by the issuing agency and the business, state “database with customer contact
length of time the patent, copyright, trademark, information,” or simply “customer list” (no need
or other right will last. Keep in mind that both to list any names). If you have promised your
copyright and trademark rights may exist even if customers not to share the information or sell the
you haven’t registered them with a government information to third parties, or otherwise safeguard
agency. If you claim trademark rights through the information, note that here. The trustee may or
usage, or copyright through the fact that you may not be able to sell your customer list, and the
created the item and reduced it to tangible form, value of your customer list will depend on whether
describe those rights here. the list can be sold.
Your business may also have trade secrets. A Items 25–27. Include the make, model, and year
trade secret is confidential information that gives of each vehicle or accessory.
you a competitive advantage precisely because it’s Item 28. Most small businesses have offices,
a secret. Examples include recipes, manufacturing or at least home offices. Here, you should list and
techniques, marketing strategies, product designs, value your office fixtures, desks, chairs, computers,
and computer algorithms. (Although customer lists telephones, and other equipment and supplies. In
are often categorized as trade secrets, they go in Item 13, you had to value your interest in your
Item 24, below.) Trade secrets are very difficult to business. That value might be the same as the
value: You may want to list the value as “unknown” value you list here, if your office holds all of your
for now. The important thing is to tell the trustee business assets. You can use the same number here
that a trade secret exists, which gives the trustee a or simply refer back to Item 13.
chance to sell it if it’s marketable and you can’t use Item 29. This is where you list everything
an exemption to keep it. else—other than your office furniture and
Item 23. List all licenses and franchises, what supplies—that you use in your business. If you
they cover, the length of time remaining, who they already listed everything in Item 13, you can refer
are with, and whether you can transfer them to to that answer. Make sure your responses match:
someone else. Franchises and licenses are contracts If you remember an additional an additional piece
in which an owner of tangible or intellectual of equipment here, for example, you should also go
property gives another party permission to use back and add it to Item 13.
it under the conditions set out in the contract. Item 30. List all inventory here, in broad
Examples include a license to drill or mine for oil strokes. For instance, a restaurant might list “wine,
or minerals on real estate, a fast food or carpet liquor, and food”; a retail store might list “clothing,
cleaning franchise, or the right (license) to use a shoes, and accessories”; and a manufacturing
software program for a certain customer base. As company might list various categories of parts and
a bankruptcy debtor, you may be on either side materials to be used in making its products. In
of this type of contract (that is, you may own the Item 20 of the Statement of Financial Affairs (see
property or have the owner’s permission to use the below), you are asked to detail inventories you have
property). Either way, you should list the license or taken. You can use the most recent inventory to
franchise here. guide your description here.
Item 24. Describe customer lists or other Items 32-34. For crops, list whether they’ve been
compilations of personally identifiable information harvested, whether they’ve been sold (and, if so, to
178 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
whom and for how much), whether you’ve taken Total. Add the amounts in this column and put
out any loans against them, and whether they are the total in the box at the bottom of the last page.
insured. In Items 33 and 34, list your farming If you used any continuation pages in addition
equipment and supplies. to the p
reprinted form, remember to attach those
Item 35. This is the catchall question. If you pages and include the amounts from those pages in
have any type of personal property that you haven’t this total.
been able to squeeze into the other categories, list it
here and do your best to give it a value. Schedule C—Property
Husband, Wife, Joint, or Community. If you’re not Claimed as Exempt
married, put “N/A” at the top of this column.
If you are married and live in a community On this form, you claim all property you think
property state, then property acquired during the is legally e xempt from being sold to pay your
marriage is community property and you should unsecured creditors. In the overwhelming majority
put “C” in this column. Gifts and inheritances of personal Chapter 7 bankruptcies, all—or
received by one spouse are separate property, as is virtually all—of the debtor’s personal property is
property a spouse owned prior to marriage or after exempt.
separation. Identify this property with an “H” (for The same is not necessarily true for business
husband) or “W” (for wife), as appropriate. assets, however. Most state exemption systems do
If you live in any state that is not a community not specifically address business assets other than
property state, write “J” if you own the property as “tools of the trade,” an exemption that usually
jointly with a spouse, and “H” or “W” if a spouse covers a very limited dollar amount. To the extent
owns that property as an individual. that any of your business assets cannot reasonably
Current Value of Debtor’s Interest in Property, be listed in this category, the only way you can
without Deducting any Secured Claim or Exemption. exempt them is through a wildcard exemption.
You can take the information requested here from For example, if your state allows you to use the
the Property Exemption Worksheet in Ch. 6. List federal exemptions, you can use any portion of the
the replacement value of the property, without homestead allowance that you don’t use to protect
regard to any secured interests or exemptions. For home equity for any type of property, including
example, if you own a car with a replacement value business assets. (See Ch. 6 for more on exempting
of $6,000, you still owe $4,000 on the car note, business-related assets.)
and your state’s motor vehicle exemption is $1,200, When you work on this form, you’ll need to
put down $6,000 for the market value of the car. refer frequently to several other documents. Have
Providing values for intangible personal in front of you:
property can be tricky. For instance, the actual • the worksheets from Ch. 6 and Ch. 7
value of a promissory note may not be the same as • your drafts of Schedules A and B
its face value, because the note is only worth what • the list of state or federal bankruptcy
it can be sold for. For example, a $500 promissory exemptions you’ll be using, provided in
note may be worth less if you would have to pay Appendix A, and
someone to collect it, and if you went to sell it, • if you’re using a state’s exemptions,
you likely would get pennies on the dollar. (Ch. 6 the additional nonbankruptcy federal
provides some tips on valuing commercial paper.) exemptions, also provided in Appendix A.
If you can’t come up with a value for intangible Set out below is a sample completed Schedule
assets, list it as “unknown” and let the trustee sort C and line-by-line instructions. Looking at
it out. the sample Schedule C exemptions, you might
180 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
notice that a particular exemption could apply In re and Case No. Follow the instructions for
to more than one category of personal property Schedule A.
from Schedule B. That’s because the exemption Debtor claims the exemptions to which the
categories are set up by each state, but the property debtor is entitled under. If you’re using the federal
categories are determined by the feds, who also exemptions, check the top box. Everybody else,
wrote Schedule B. As a result, the property and check the second box. See Ch. 6 for information
exemption categories don’t necessarily match up on residency requirements for using a state’s
neatly. For example, the California “tools of the exemptions and tips on how to choose between
trade” exemption (see Appendix A) could apply to a the federal and state exemption systems. If you are
number of the property categories, including Item living in a state that offers the federal exemption
28 (office equipment, furnishings, and supplies), system, but you haven’t been there long enough to
Item 33 (farming equipment and implements), meet the two-year residency requirement to use the
Item 25 (automobiles, trucks, trailers and other state exemptions, you can still choose the federal
vehicles, and accessories), and Item 5 (books, system (and check the top box on Schedule C).
etc.). On Schedule C, you’ll group the property
you want to claim as exempt by the categories
See an Expert
printed on Schedule B. For example, you’d list
If you own property out of state. You’ll
“Office Equipment, Furnishings and Supplies,” and
generally choose the exemptions of the state where
“Machinery, fixtures, equipment, and supplies used you live when you file as long as you’ve lived there for
in business,” rather than creating one big category at least two years. Most exemptions for home equity
of your own making for “tools of the trade.” require that you be living in the home when you file for
bankruptcy, but this isn’t always the case. If you want to
Give Yourself the Benefit of the Doubt protect your equity in a home in a state other than the
one where you plan to file, see a lawyer.
When you claim exemptions, err in your own favor.
If an exemption seems to cover an item of property, Check if debtor claims a homestead exemption
claim it. You may find that you’re legally entitled to that exceeds $136,875. Check this box if:
keep much of the property you’re deeply attached • the exemptions of the state you are using
to, such as your home, car, and family heirlooms, allow a homestead of more than $136,875
though not all of your business assets if they are • you have more than $136,875 equity in
valuable and easily liquidated. your home, and
Your exemption claims will be examined by • you acquired your home at least 40 months
the trustee and possibly a creditor or two, although prior to your bankruptcy filing date.
historically few creditors monitor bankruptcy If you acquired your home within 40 months of
proceedings. In close cases, bankruptcy laws require filing, and you didn’t purchase it using the proceeds
the trustee to honor your exemption claims. In
from selling another home in the same state, your
other words, you’re entitled to the benefit of the
homestead exemption may be capped at $136,875,
doubt. If the trustee or a creditor successfully
regardless of the exemption available in the state
objects to an exemption claim, you’ve lost nothing
where your home is located. (See Ch. 7 for detailed
by trying. See Ch. 10 for more on objections to
information on the homestead exemption cap.)
claimed exemptions.
The following instructions cover one column
at a time. But rather than listing all your exempt
property in the first column before moving on to
ChaPter 9 | Complete and file Your BAnkruptcy Paperwork | 181
the second column, you might find it easier to list be used for any type of property) with a regular
one exempt item and complete all of the columns exemption, list both citations. If the wildcard and
for that item before moving on to the next exempt the regular e xemption have the same citation, list
item. the citation twice and put “wildcard” next to one
Description of Property. To describe the of the citations. If you use any reference other than
property you claim as exempt, take these steps: one found in the state statutes you are using, such
Step 1: Turn to Ch. 6 to find out which as a federal nonbankruptcy exemption or a court
exemptions are available to you and which property case, list the entire reference for the exempt item.
to claim as exempt (if you have already used the Value of Claimed Exemption. Claim the full
Property Exemption Worksheet to identify your exemption amount allowed, up to the value of the
exempt property, skip this step). item. The amount allowed is listed in Appendix A.
Step 2: Decide which of the real estate you Bankruptcy law allows married couples to
listed on Schedule A, if any, you want to claim double all exemptions unless the state expressly
as exempt. Remember that state homestead prohibits it. Doubling exemptions means that
allowances usually apply only to property you are each of you can claim the entire amount of each
living in when you file, but that you can use a exemption, if you are filing jointly. If your state’s
wildcard exemption for any type of property. Use chart in Appendix A doesn’t say your state forbids
the same description you used in the Description doubling, go ahead and double. You are entitled to
and Location of Property column of Schedule A. double all federal exemptions, if you use them.
Step 3: Decide which of the personal property If you are using part or all of a wildcard
you listed on Schedule B you want to claim as exemption in addition to a regular exemption,
exempt. For each item identified, list both the list both amounts. For example, if the regular
category of property (preprinted in the Types of exemption for an item of furniture is $200, and
Property column) and the specific item, from the you plan to exempt $500 worth of furniture by
Description and Location of Property column. If adding $300 from your state’s wildcard exemption,
the exemptions you are using apply to an entire list $200 across from the citation you listed for
category, such as clothing, simply list “clothing” as the regular exemption and $300 across from the
the item you are exempting. citation you listed for the wildcard exemption (or
Specify Law Providing Each Exemption. You’ll across from the term “wildcard”).
find citations to the specific laws that create exemp-
tions in the state and federal exemption lists in CAUTION
Appendix A. Remember to use the rules for choos-
Don’t claim more than you need. For
ing your exemptions explained in detail in Ch. 6. instance, if you’re allowed household furniture up to a
You can simplify this process by entering the total amount of $2,000, don’t inflate the value of each
name of the statutes you are using at the top of the item of furniture simply to get to $2,000. Use the actual
form. For example, you might type “All law refer property values from Schedule B.
ences are to the Florida Statutes Annotated unless
otherwise noted.” The name of the statute is noted Current Value of Property Without Deducting
at the top of each exemption list in Appendix A. Exemption. Enter the current (replacement) value
For each item of property you are claiming as of the item you are claiming as exempt. For most
exempt, enter the citation (number) of the specific items, this information is listed on Schedules A
law that creates the exemption, as set out on the and B. However, if you listed the item as part of
exemption list. If you are combining part or all a group in Schedule B, list it separately here and
of a wildcard exemption (an exemption that can assign it a separate replacement value.
182 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
Sample Schedule D
ChaPter 9 | Complete and file Your BAnkruptcy Paperwork | 187
unliquidated, or disputed. Here’s what the terms Amount of Claim Without Deducting Value
mean: of Collateral. For each secured creditor, list the
• Contingent. The claim depends on some amount it would take to pay off the secured claim,
event that hasn’t yet occurred and may regardless of what the property is worth. The
never occur. For example, if you cosigned a lender can give you this figure. In some cases, the
secured loan, you won’t be liable unless the amount of the secured claim may be more than the
principal debtor defaults. Your liability as property’s value.
cosigner is contingent upon the default.
Example: Your original business loan was for
• Unliquidated. This means that a debt may
$13,000, plus $7,000 in interest (for $20,000
exist, but the exact amount hasn’t been
total). You’ve made enough payments so that
determined. For example, say you’ve sued
$15,000 will cancel the debt, which is what
someone for injuries you suffered in an auto
you should list in this column.
accident, but the case isn’t over. Your lawyer
has taken the case under a contingency If you have more than one creditor for a
fee agreement—he’ll get a third of the given s ecured claim (for example, the lender and
recovery if you win, and nothing if you a collection agency), list the debt only for the
lose—and has a security interest in the final lender and put ditto marks (") for each subsequent
recovery amount. The debt to the lawyer is creditor.
unliquidated because you don’t know how Subtotal/Total. Total the amounts in the
much, if anything, you’ll win. “Amount of Claim” column for each page. Do not
• Disputed. A claim is disputed if you and the include the amounts represented by the ditto marks
creditor do not agree about the existence or if you listed multiple creditors for a single debt. On
amount of the debt. For instance, suppose the final page of Schedule D (which may be the
the IRS says you owe $10,000 and has put a first page or a preprinted continuation page), enter
lien on your property, and you say you owe the total of all secured claims.
$500. List the full amount of the lien, not Unsecured Portion, If Any. If the replacement
the amount you think you owe. value of the collateral is equal to or greater than the
Check all categories that apply. If you’re amount of the claim, enter “0,” meaning that the
uncertain of which to choose, check the one that creditor’s claim is fully secured. If the replacement
seems closest. If none apply, leave them blank. value of the collateral is less than the amount of the
Although these categories aren’t really important claim(s) listed, enter the difference here.
in a Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy (because your
Example: If the current value of your truck is
debts are discharged regardless of the category you
$5,000 but you still owe $6,000 on your truck
choose), you must check the boxes.
loan, enter $1,000 in this column ($6,000 –
$5,000). This is the amount of the loan that is
Tip unsecured by the collateral (your truck).
You’re not admitting you owe the debt.
If you list an amount in this column for a
You may think you don’t really owe a contingent,
creditor, do not list this amount again on Schedule
unliquidated, or disputed debt, or you may not want to
F (where you will list all other creditors with
“admit” that you owe the debt. By listing a debt here,
however, you aren’t admitting anything. Instead, you are
unsecured claims). Otherwise, this unsecured
making sure that, if you owe the debt after all, it will be amount will be counted twice.
discharged in your bankruptcy, if possible.
ChaPter 9 | Complete and file Your BAnkruptcy Paperwork | 189
How to List Creditors Associated and money owed to employee benefit plans. Read
With Foreclosed Property further before deciding whether to check this box.
Types of priority claims. These are the categories
Until your property is sold in a foreclosure sale of priority debts, as listed on Schedule E. Check
and a deed has been recorded showing a transfer the appropriate box on the form if you owe a debt
of ownership to the lender or new purchaser, in that category.
you still own the property and any mortgages on
n Domestic support obligations. Check this box
the property are secured debts. You must list all
for claims for domestic support that you owe to, or
lenders, mortgage servicers, foreclosing trustees,
that are recoverable by, a spouse, former spouse, or
and attorneys listed on foreclosure papers as
child; the parent, legal guardian, or responsible rela-
secured creditors on Schedule D. You should list
tive of such a child; or a governmental unit to whom
the amounts of the mortgages only once, however.
such a domestic support claim has been assigned.
After a deed has been recorded showing that you
n Extensions of credit in an involuntary case.
no longer own the property, your mortgage debt is
no longer secured debt, and you should list all these
Don’t check this box. You are filing a voluntary,
parties on Schedule F as unsecured creditors. not an involuntary, bankruptcy case.
n Wages, salaries, and commissions. If your
business owes a current or former employee wages,
vacation pay, or sick leave that was earned within
180 days before you filed for bankruptcy or ceased
Schedule E—Creditors Holding doing business, check this box. If you owe money
Unsecured Priority Claims to an independent contractor who did work for
Schedule E identifies creditors who hold priority you, and the money was earned within 180 days
claims. These creditors may be entitled to be paid before you filed your petition or ceased doing
first (by the trustee) out of your nonexempt assets. business, check this box only if, in the 12 months
Even if you don’t have any nonexempt assets to before you filed for bankruptcy, thisindependent
be distributed, you still need to fill out this form contractor earned at least 75% of his or her total
if you have any unsecured priority debts. Most independent contractor receipts from you.
debtors won’t care too much about who gets paid n Contributions to employee benefit plans.
first, but you should still identify your priority Check this box if your business owes contributions
debts carefully to avoid having to amend your to an e mployee benefit fund for services rendered
papers later. by an employee within 180 days before you filed
Set out below are a sample completed Schedule your petition or ceased doing business.
E and line-by-line instructions. n Certain farmers and fishermen. Check this
In re and Case No. Follow the instructions for box only if you operate or operated a grain storage
Schedule A. facility and owe a grain producer, or you operate or
Check this box if debtor has no creditors holding operated a fish produce or storage facility and owe
unsecured priority claims to report on this Schedule E. a U.S. fisherman for fish or fish products.
Priority claims are claims that must be paid first in n Deposits by individuals. If you took money
your bankruptcy case. The most common examples from someone who planned to purchase, lease,
for personal bankruptcy debtors are unsecured, or rent goods or services from you that you never
nondischargeable income tax debts and past due delivered, you may owe a priority debt. For the
alimony or child support. There are several other debt to qualify as a priority, the goods or services
categories of p
riority debts that may also apply must have been planned for personal, family, or
to small business owners, including payroll taxes household use.
190 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
n Taxes and certain other debts owed to govern the one provided by the creditor in two written
mental units. Check this box if you owe unsecured communications you have received from the
back taxes or any other debts to the government, creditor within the past 90 days, if possible. You
such as payroll or other trust fund taxes, or fines may have more than one priority creditor for a
imposed for driving under the influence of drugs given debt. For example, if you’ve been sued or
or alcohol. Not all tax debts are unsecured priority hounded by a collection agency, list the collection
claims. For example, if the IRS has recorded a lien agency in addition to the original creditor.
against your real property, and the equity in your If the creditor is a child, list the child’s initials
property fully covers the amount of your tax debt, and the name and address of the child’s parent or
your debt is a secured debt. It should be listed on guardian. For example, “A.B., a minor child, by
Schedule D, not on this schedule. Also, if your tax John Doe, Guardian, 111 Alabama Avenue, San
debts are dischargeable (see Ch. 11), they should Francisco, CA 94732.” Don’t state the child’s name.
be listed on Schedule F as nonpriority unsecured Codebtor. If someone else can be legally forced
debts. to pay your debt to a priority creditor, enter an
n Commitments to maintain the capital of an “X” in this column and list the codebtor in the
insured depository institution. Don’t check this box. creditor column of this schedule. You’ll also need
It is for bankruptcies brought by corporations or to list the codebtor as a creditor in Schedule F and
other business entities. Schedule H. Common codebtors are listed in the
n Claims for death or personal injury while debtor instructions for Schedule D.
was intoxicated. Check this box if there are claims Husband, Wife, Joint, or Community. Follow the
against you for another’s death or personal injury instructions for Schedule A.
resulting from your operation of a motor vehicle or Date Claim Was Incurred and Consideration for
vessel while intoxicated from using alcohol, a drug, Claim. State the date you incurred the debt—this
or another substance. This priority applies only to may be a specific date or a period of time. Also
personal injury or death, not property damage. briefly state what the debt is for. For example,
If you didn’t check any of the priority debt “goods purchased,” “hours worked for me,” or
boxes, go back and check the first box, showing “deposit for my services.”
you have no unsecured priority claims to report. Contingent, Unliquidated, Disputed. Follow the
Then go on to Schedule F. instructions for Schedule D.
If you checked any of the priority debt boxes, Amount of Claim. For each priority debt other
make as many photocopies of the continuation than taxes, list the amount it would take to pay off
page as the number of priority debt boxes you the debt in full, even if it’s more than the priority
checked. You will need to complete a separate sheet limit. For taxes, list only the amount that is
for each type of priority debt, as follows: unsecured (and therefore a priority). You should list
In re and Case No. Follow the instructions for the secured amount on Schedule D. If the amount
Schedule A. isn’t determined, write “not yet determined” in this
Type of Priority. Insert the category for one of column.
the boxes you checked (for example, “Domestic Amount Entitled to Priority. If the priority claim
support obligations”). is larger than the maximum indicated on the first
Creditor’s Name, Mailing Address Including Zip page of Schedule E (for example, $10,950 of wages
Code, and Account Number. List the name and owed to each employee; this amount will increase
complete mailing address (including zip code) in April 2010), put the maximum here. If the claim
of each priority creditor, as well as the account is less than the maximum, put the amount you
number, if you know it. The address should be entered in the Total Amount of Claim column here.
192 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
Amount Not Entitled to Priority, If Any. List any Example: Peter Kinson, owner of a sole
portion of the debt that is not entitled to priority proprietorship called PK Plumbing, owes
here. For example, if you owe an employee $15,000 his local hardware store $2,000 for various
in wages, only the first $10,950 is entitled to materials he ordered prior to filing bank
priority (this amount will increase in April 2010). ruptcy. Peter plans to continue his business
That amount should be listed in the “Amount and would prefer not to list the debt, so he
Entitled to Priority” column; here, you would list can keep doing business at the store. However,
the remaining $4,050. he understands that must list all debts on
Subtotal/Total. At the bottom of each continua Schedule F, which he does. The hardware store
tion page, list the subtotals of the “Amount of debt is discharged along with Peter’s other
Claim,” “Amount Entitled to Priority,” and “Amount debts. After his bankruptcy, Peter approaches
Not Entitled to Priority, If Any” columns. Enter the the store owner and voluntarily settles up on
total amounts for each of these categories on the his bill. The store restores his credit rating.
final page of Schedule E. Peter can once again obtain materials on
credit so he can continue his business. But
Schedule F—Creditors Holding repaying the debt was completely voluntary on
Unsecured Nonpriority Claims Peter’s part. The store can’t sue him to collect
the debt.
In this schedule, list all creditors you haven’t listed
in Schedules D or E. You should include creditors Inadvertent errors or omissions on this schedule
on debts that are or may be nondischargeable, such can come back to haunt you. If you don’t list a debt
as student loans. Even if you believe that you don’t you owe to a creditor, it might not be discharged
owe the debt or you owe only a small amount and in bankruptcy if your creditor has been harmed
intend to pay it off, you must include it here. It’s by not learning of your bankruptcy. For example,
essential that you list every creditor to whom you an omitted creditor would be harmed if you had
owe, or possibly owe, money. The only way you can assets that were liquidated for the benefit of your
legitimately leave off a creditor is if your balance creditors, and the creditor missed out on its share
owed is $0. of the distribution. (Fortunately, it is sometimes
You may be tempted to leave some creditors possible in these circumstances to reopen the
(like your doctor, a favorite electrician, an indis bankruptcy and include the creditor retroactively.)
pensable vendor, or a relative who loaned you Also, leaving a creditor off the schedule might
money) off of your bankruptcy schedules, in order raise suspicions that you deliberately concealed
to stay in their good graces. Don’t do it. You must information, perhaps to give that creditor
list all of your creditors. However, there is nothing preferential treatment in violation of bankruptcy
to prevent you from paying a dischargeable debt rules.
after your bankruptcy is complete. The only effect
bankruptcy has on the debt is that the creditor Tip
can’t pursue it through collections or place it Use your credit reports. You aren’t required
on your credit report. If you plan to pay certain to use a credit report to find creditors when filing for
creditors after your bankruptcy, let them know. bankruptcy, but it will help you make sure you don’t
This will lessen the sting of your bankruptcy filing. miss anyone. You will likely find entries on your credit
Although your promise is unenforceable, creditors report for debts you didn’t know you owed. But it never
will gladly accept your money. hurts to list a creditor in your bankruptcy, even if you
194 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
don’t think you owe the debt (you can always check the
Creditors That Are Often Overlooked
“disputed” box). If you can get credit reports for free,
it’s a good idea to get a copy of your report from all One debt may involve several different creditors.
three major credit reporting agencies; the information Remember to include:
in them does vary. Don’t rely exclusively on credit • your ex-spouse, if you are still obligated
reports, however; you must disclose every debt on your under a divorce decree or settlement
bankruptcy forms, whether or not it appears in a credit agreement to pay joint debts, turn any
report. property over to your ex, or make payments
as part of your property division
Below are a sample completed Schedule F and • anyone who has cosigned or guaranteed
line-by-line instructions. Use as many preprinted a promissory note or loan application you
continuation pages as you need. signed
In re and Case No. Follow the instructions for • any holder of a loan or promissory note that
Schedule A. you cosigned for someone else
Check this box if debtor has no creditors holding • the original creditor, anybody to whom
unsecured claims to report on this Schedule F. Check the debt has been assigned or sold, and
this box if you have no unsecured nonpriority any other person (such as a bill collector or
debts. This would be very rare. attorney) trying to collect the debt, and
Creditor’s Name, Mailing Address Including Zip • anyone who may sue you because of a car
Code, and Account Number. List, preferably in accident, business dispute, or the like.
alphabetical order, the name and complete mailing
address of each unsecured creditor, as well as the
account number (if you know it). If you have more Codebtor. If someone else can be legally forced
than one unsecured creditor for a given debt, list to pay your debt to a listed unsecured creditor,
the original creditor first, followed by the other enter an “X” in this column and list the codebtor
creditors. For example, for a particular debt, as a creditor in this schedule. Also, list the codebtor
you might have the name, address, and account in Schedule H. The instructions for Schedule D list
number for the original creditor, a collection common codebtors.
agency run by the original creditor, an independent Husband, Wife, Joint, or Community. Follow the
collection agency, an attorney debt collector, and instructions for Schedule A.
an attorney who has sued you. Date Claim Was Incurred and Consideration for
It’s best to list every creditor. But you could Claim. If Claim Is Subject to Setoff, So State. State
omit the intermediate collectors and just list the when the debt was incurred. It may be one date
original creditor and the latest collector or attorney. or a period of time. With credit card debts, put
Or, if you no longer have contact information for the approximate time over which you ran up the
the original creditor, listing the latest collector charges, unless the unpaid charges were all made
will do. on one or two specific dates. Then state what the
When you are typing your final papers, if you debt was for. You can be general (“office supplies”
get to the end and discover that you left a creditor or “furnishings”) or specific (“refrigerator” or “Dell
off, don’t start all over again in search of perfect laptop computer”).
alphabetical order. Just add the creditor to the end If you are entitled to a setoff against the debt—
of the list. that is, the creditor owes you some money, too—
list the amount and why you think you are entitled
to the setoff. If there is more than one creditor for a
ChAPter 9 | COMPLETE AND FILE YOUR BANKRUPTCY PAPERWORK | 195
single debt, put ditto marks (") in this column for “Executory” means the contract is still in force—
the subsequent c reditors. that is, both parties are still obligated to perform
Contingent, Unliquidated, Disputed. Follow the important acts under it. Similarly, “unexpired”
instructions for Schedule D. means that the contract or lease period hasn’t run
Amount of Claim. List the amount of the debt out—that is, it is still in effect. Common examples
claimed by the creditor, even if you dispute the of executory contracts and unexpired leases are:
amount. If there’s more than one creditor for a • car leases
single debt, put the debt amount across from the • residential leases or rental agreements
original creditor and put ditto marks (") across • business leases or rental agreements
from each subsequent creditor you have listed. Be • service contracts
as precise as possible when stating the amount. If • business contracts
you must approximate, write “approx.” after the • vendor contracts
amount. • time-share contracts or leases
Subtotal/Total. Total the amounts in the last • contracts of sale for real estate
column for this page. Do not include the amounts • personal property leases, such as equipment
represented by the ditto marks if you listed used in a beauty salon
multiple creditors for a single debt. On the final • copyright and patent license agreements
page (which may be the first page or a preprinted • leases of real estate (surface and
continuation page), enter the total of all unsecured, underground) for the purpose of harvesting
nonpriority claims. On the first page in the bottom timber, minerals, or oil
left-hand corner, note the number of continuation • future homeowners’ association fee
pages you are attaching. requirements
• agreements for boat docking privileges, and
Listing Debts on Foreclosed • insurance contracts.
and Repossessed Property
Debts that were secured prior to a foreclosure or CAUTION
repossession become unsecured debts after title If you’re behind in your payments. If you are
reverts to the secured lender when the foreclosure not current on payments that were due under a lease or
or repossession is complete, and you should executory contract, the delinquency should also be listed
list them on Schedule F as unsecured debts. If as a debt on Schedule D, E, or F. The sole purpose of this
you know what the alleged deficiency was (the schedule is to identify existing contractual obligations
difference between what you owed and what that you still owe or that someone owes you. Later, when
the lender ultimately got in the foreclosure or completing the Statement of Intention, you will be given
repossession sale), list that amount. If you don’t yet the opportunity to state whether you want the lease or
know—because the foreclosure or repossession was contract to continue in effect.
so recent—list the entire debt.
Below are a sample completed Schedule G and
line-by-line instructions.
In re and Case No. Follow the instructions for
Schedule A.
Schedule G—Executory Contracts Check this box if debtor has no executory
and Unexpired Leases contracts or unexpired leases. Check this box if it
In this form, you list every executory contract applies; otherwise, complete the form.
or unexpired lease to which you’re a party.
198 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
Sample Schedule G
ChaPter 9 | Complete and file Your BAnkruptcy Paperwork | 199
Name and Mailing Address, Including Zip Code, • a basic description (for instance, residential
arties to Lease or Contract. Provide the
of Other P lease, commercial lease, car lease, business
name and full address (including zip code) of obligation or contract, or copyright license)
each party—other than yourself—to each lease or • the date the contract or lease was signed
contract. These parties are either people who signed • the date the contract is to expire (if any)
agreements or the companies for whom these • a summary of each party’s rights and
people work. If you’re unsure about whom to list, obligations under the lease or contract, and
include the person who signed an agreement, any • the contract number, if the contract is with
company whose name appears on the agreement, any government body.
and anybody who might have an interest in having
the contract or lease enforced. If you still aren’t Schedule H—Codebtors
sure, put “don’t know.”
Description of Contract or Lease and Nature of In Schedules D, E, and F, you identified those
Debtor’s Interest. For each lease or contract, give: debts for which you have codebtors—usually, a
The trustee has 60 days after you file for bankruptcy your business is closing down, or a residential lease,
to decide whether an executory contract or unexpired auto lease, or time-share you can’t afford. Be sure
lease should be assumed as property of the estate to state at the bankruptcy meeting or even on your
(continued in force) or terminated (rejected). If the papers that you would like the trustee to terminate the
lease or contract could be sold to raise funds for your agreement. But remember this is up to the trustee to
unsecured creditors, then the trustee will assume it; decide.
otherwise, it will be rejected. As a general matter, most If the lease is assigned or terminated or the
leases and contracts are liabilities rather than assets, contract is terminated, you and the other parties to the
and are rejected by the trustee. However, even if the agreement are cut loose from any obligations, and any
trustee rejects the lease or contract, you have the right money you owe the creditor will be discharged in your
to assume it if it is for personal property (for instance, bankruptcy, even if the debt arose after your filing date.
a car lease or vendor contract), provided you give the For example, say you are leasing a car when you file for
creditor written notice and the creditor agrees. (11 bankruptcy. You want out of the lease. The car dealer
U.S.C. § 365(p).) You provide this written notice in the cannot repossess the car until the trustee terminates
Statement of Intention, discussed below. the lease, which normally must occur within 60 days of
Generally, people filing Chapter 7 bankruptcies when you file. During that 60-day period, you can use
are not parties to leases or contracts that would likely the car without paying for it. The payments you don’t
add value to their bankruptcy estates. This isn’t an make during this period will be discharged as if they
absolute rule, however. If the trustee could sell a lease were incurred prior to your bankruptcy.
to someone else for a profit (because you’re paying Bankruptcy law has special rules for executory
less than market rent for prime commercial space, contracts related to intellectual property (copyright,
for example), the trustee might assume the lease and patent, trademark, or trade secret), real estate, and
assign it for a lump sum that could be distributed to time-share leases. If you are involved in one of these
your creditors. situations, talk to a bankruptcy lawyer.
It’s also possible that you’ll want to get out of a
contract or lease, such as a commercial lease when
200 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
Sample Schedule H
ChaPter 9 | Complete and file Your BAnkruptcy Paperwork | 201
Sample Schedule I
ChaPter 9 | Complete and file Your BAnkruptcy Paperwork | 203
Employment. Provide the requested employment or other documents if you’re paid weekly, every two
information. If you have more than one employer, weeks, or twice a month. The most commonly required
enter “See continuation sheet” just below the box conversion is from payment every two weeks to a
containing the employment information, then monthly payment. You do this by dividing your biweekly
complete a continuation sheet. If you are self- payment in half and then multiplying by 4.3. If your
employed or operate a sole proprietor business, or business income is sporadic, you may have to total your
you are retired, unemployed, or disabled, enter the annual income, then divide by 12.
appropriate words in the blank for “occupation.”
Items 1–3. Enter your estimated monthly gross Item 4: Payroll Deductions. In the four blanks,
income from regular employment, before any enter the deductions taken from your gross salary.
payroll deductions are taken. In the second blank, The deductions listed are the most common
put your estimated monthly overtime pay. Add ones, but you may have others to report. Other
them together and enter the subtotal in the third possible deductions are state disability taxes, wages
blank. If your only income is from your business, withheld or garnished for child support, credit
leave these lines blank. union payments, or perhaps payments on a student
loan or a car. Again, if your only income is from
your business, you may not have anything to enter
Three Different Income Figures here or for Items 5 and 6.
Item 5: Subtotal of Payroll Deductions. Add your
The bankruptcy law that went into effect in October
2005 produces a number of strange results. One of payroll deductions and enter the subtotal.
these is that you will report three different income Item 6: Total Net Monthly Take Home Pay.
figures: the “current monthly income” figure in Form Subtract your payroll deductions subtotal from
22A, the actual income you report here, and the your income subtotal.
annual income figures you report in your Statement Item 7: Regular income from operation of business
of Financial Affairs (see below). or profession or farm. If you are self-employed or
Schedule I explicitly states that the income operate a sole proprietorship, enter your monthly
you report there will likely be different from what gross income from your business here. If it’s been
you report as your current monthly income on fairly steady for at least one calendar year, divide
Form 22A. That’s because the income you report your gross income amount from your most recent
on Form 22A is your average gross income for the tax return (IRS Schedule C, Profit or Loss From
six months before you file, but the income you Business) by 12 to come up with a monthly amount.
report here is the actual net income you expect If your income hasn’t been steady for at least a year,
to be receiving every month going forward. If, for enter the average monthly gross income from your
example, your business income started to plummet business or profession over the past three months.
a couple of months ago, your income will be lower In either case, you must attach a detailed statement
on this form than what you reported on Form 22A. of your income (you can use your IRS Schedule C).
You’ll be able to account for your business expenses
on Schedule J, covered below.
Item 8: Income from real property. Enter your
CAUTION monthly income from real estate rentals, leases, or
Make sure the numbers add up. As you licenses (such as mineral exploration, oil, and the
juggle these income and deduction numbers, remember like).
that you need to use a monthly amount. This means Item 9: Interest and dividends. Enter the average
you may need to convert the numbers on your pay stub estimated monthly interest you receive from bank
204 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
or security d
eposits and other investments, such as in business income (after all, nothing is certain in
stocks. business). Whatever the cause, you must disclose
Item 10: Alimony, maintenance, or support anticipated future income changes here. Of course,
payments payable to the debtor for the debtor’s use if your income is due to decrease any time soon,
or that of dependents listed above. Enter the average you should use this part of the form to indicate
monthly amount you receive for your support that as well.
(alimony, spousal support, or maintenance) or for
your children (child support). Schedule J—Current Expenditures
Item 11: Social security or government assistance. of Individual Debtor(s)
Enter the total monthly amount you receive in
Social Security, SSI, public assistance, disability In this form, you must list your monthly expenses.
payments, veterans’ benefits, unemployment This includes both your family’s personal expenses
compensation, workers’ compensation, or any other (even if you’re married and filing alone) and the
government benefit. If you receive food stamps, expenses of your sole proprietorship business. (If
include their monthly value. Specify the source of your business is a separate entity, don’t include its
the benefits. expenses here.) Be complete and accurate.
Item 12: Pension or retirement income. Enter the Expenditures for items the trustee considers
total monthly amount of all pension, annuity, IRA, luxuries may not be considered reasonable and
Keogh, or other retirement benefits you currently may be disregarded for the purpose of deciding
receive. whether you should be allowed to file a Chapter 7
Item 13: Other monthly income. Specify any other bankruptcy or instead be limited to Chapter 13.
income (such as royalty payments or payments from For instance, the trustee may disregard lavish
a trust) you receive on a regular basis, and enter entertainment expenses, a lease on premises
the monthly amount here. You may have to divide that are clearly more upscale than your business
by three, six, or 12 if you receive the payments requires, or payments on expensive cars or invest
quarterly, semiannually, or annually. ment properties. If this happens, you may not
Item 14: Subtotal of Lines 7 through 13. Add up be allowed to use Chapter 7 bankruptcy because
your additional income (Items 7 through 13). your disposable income (income after deducting
Item 15: Average Monthly Income. Add Items 6 reasonable expenses) is considered too high. How
and 14 and list the total here. ever, reasonable business expenses and expenses
Item 16: Combined Average Monthly Income. If for housing, utilities, food, medical care, clothing,
you are filing jointly, combine your total from Item education, and transportation will be counted.
15 with your spouse’s total from Item 15. And you should include them all: the higher your
Item 17: Describe any increase or decrease in reasonable expenses, the less likely the trustee is
income reasonably anticipated to occur within the to challenge your eligibility to use Chapter 7. Be
year f ollowing the filing of this document. If you ready to support larger expense amounts with bills,
indicate that you will soon have a significantly receipts, and canceled checks.
higher income, you might face a motion from the Example 1: Joe owes $100,000 (excluding his
U.S. Trustee seeking to force you into Chapter mortgage and car), earns $4,000 a month,
13 if the increase would allow you to repay a and spends $3,600 a month for the other
substantial portion of your unsecured debt (25% items listed on Schedule J, including payments
or more) over three to five years. In most cases, the on a midpriced car and a moderately priced
increase is due to a scheduled promotion or raise family home. Joe would probably be allowed
in employment income, not an anticipated increase
ChaPter 9 | Complete and file Your BAnkruptcy Paperwork | 205
Sample Schedule J
ChaPter 9 | Complete and file Your BAnkruptcy Paperwork | 207
Items 1–17. For each listed item, fill in your two totals on Line 15 (one for you and one for your
monthly expenses. If you make some payments spouse), subtract your expenses from the combined
biweekly, q uarterly, semiannually, or annually, total on Line 16. This will show at a glance whether
prorate them to show your monthly payment. Here you have significantly more income than expenses.
are some pointers:
• Do not list payroll deductions you listed on Summary of Schedules
Schedule I.
• Include in your figures payments you make This form helps the bankruptcy trustee and judge
for your dependents’ expenses as long as get a quick look at your bankruptcy filing. Below
those e xpenses are reasonable and necessary are a completed Summary of Schedules and line-
for the dependents’ support. by-line instructions.
• Utilities—Other: This includes garbage, Court Name. Copy this information from Form
Internet, and cable TV service for your 1—Voluntary Petition.
personal use (utilities for your business In re and Case No. Follow the instructions for
should be listed under “Business expenses,” Schedule A.
below). Name of Schedule. This lists the schedules.
• Installment payments—Other: In this Don’t add anything.
blank, put the amount of any installment Attached (Yes/No). You should have completed
payments you are making on a secured debt all of the schedules, so type “Yes” in this
or a debt you plan on reaffirming. Do not column for each schedule, even if you added no
include payments you have been making information.
on a credit card or other debt that does No. of Sheets. Enter the number of pages you
not involve collateral and that you plan to completed for each schedule. Remember to count
discharge in your bankruptcy. Installment continuation pages. Enter the total at the bottom
payments related to your business go under of the column.
“Business expenses,” below. Assets, Liabilities, Other. For each column—
• Business expenses: List all of your business Assets, Liabilities, and Other—copy the totals
expenses here; your gross income from from Schedules A, B, D, E, F, I, and J and enter
your business goes on Schedule I. This them where indicated. Add up the amounts in
means your net business income can be the Assets and Liabilities columns and enter their
calculated subtracting the business expenses totals at the bottom. (Once you’ve completed this
on Schedule J from the gross income on form, you can go back and fill in the “Statistical/
Schedule I. Administrative Information” section on Form 1—
Item 18. Average Monthly Expenses. Total up all Voluntary Petition.)
your monthly expenses.
Item 19. Describe any increase or decrease in Statistical Summary of Certain
expenditures reasonably anticipated to occur within Liabilities and Related Data
the year following the filing of this document. For
This form asks you to list information from your
instance, if you plan to pay off a car note during
other bankruptcy paperwork. Fill in the blanks
the coming year, indicate that fact.
using your completed schedules. You will need
Item 20. Statement of Monthly Net Income.
to come back to this form to fill in your current
Deduct your total expenses on Line 18 from your
monthly income after completing Form 22A
total income on Line 15 of Schedule I. If you have
(instructions for this form are below).
208 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
Declaration Concerning your forms, have that person complete this section.
Debtor’s Schedules otherwise, type “N/A” anywhere in the box.
Declaration Under Penalty of Perjury on Behalf of
In this form, you are required to swear that every- Corporation or Partnership. Enter “N/A” anywhere
thing you have said on your schedules is true and in this blank.
correct. Deliberate lying is a major sin in bankruptcy
and could cost you your bankruptcy discharge,
a fine of up to $500,000, and up to five years in Form 7—Statement of
prison. Financial Affairs
Below is a completed Declaration with
instructions. This form gives information about your recent
In re and Case No. Follow the instructions for financial transactions, such as payments to
Schedule A. creditors, sales or other transfers of property, gifts,
Declaration Under Penalty of Perjury by Individual losses, and litigation. Under certain circumstances,
Debtor. Enter the total number of pages in your the trustee may be entitled to take back property
schedules (the number on the Summary of that you transferred to others prior to filing for
Schedules plus one). Enter the date and sign the bankruptcy, and sell it for the benefit of your
form. If you are filing jointly, be sure that your unsecured creditors.
spouse signs and dates the form. The questions on the form are, for the most
Declaration and Signature of Non-Attorney part, self-explanatory. Spouses filing jointly may
Bankruptcy Petition Preparer (BPP). If a BPP typed combine their answers and complete only one form.
If you have no information for a particular year, to get the money or property back for your
item, check the “None” box. If you fail to answer bankruptcy estate. For transactions with non-
a question and don’t check “None,” you will have insiders, the look-back period is only three months.
to amend your papers—that is, file a corrected 1. Income from employment or operation of
form—after you file. Add continuation sheets if business. Enter your gross income for this year
necessary. and for the previous two years. Your gross income
A completed Statement of Financial Affairs and means the total income before any amounts are
instructions follow. subtracted: taxes, payroll deductions, or business
Court Name. Copy this information from Form expenses. Make sure the amounts you provide here
1—Voluntary Petition. are consistent with the income disclosed on the tax
In re and Case No. Follow the instructions for return you provided to the trustee. For example, if
Schedule A. you claim $50,000 gross income from a business
Definitions. The Statement of Financial Affairs for the previous year on this form, your tax return
starts off with definitions that are important to for that year should be in the same ballpark.
small business owners. 2. Income other than from employment or
In business. You are likely to be considered “in operation ofbusiness. Include interest, dividends,
business.” In addition to debtors that are business royalties, workers’ compensation, other government
entities (corporations, LLCs, and partnerships), benefits, and all other money you have received
individuals are “in business” if they are, or have from sources other than your job or business
been in the past six years: during the last two years. Provide the source of
• an officer, director, managing executive, or each amount, the dates received, and the reason
owner of 5% or more of the voting or equity you received the money so that the trustee can
securities of a corporation verify it if he o r she desires. Again, make sure the
• a partner of a partnership (other than a amounts you provide here are consistent with the
limited partner), or income disclosed on the tax return you provided to
• a sole proprietor or self-employed person, the trustee.
whether full time or part time. 3. Payments to creditors. Here you list payments
You will also be considered to be “in business” you’ve recently made to creditors. There are three
if you are engaged in a trade, business, or other categories of payments that must be disclosed in
activity, other than as an employee, to supplement this section:
your income from primary employment (for a. payments made to creditors; only for
instance, you have a job as a computer network debtors whose debts are primarily (more
coordinator and do some consulting on the side). than 50%) consumer debts
This “in business” definition is especially important b. payments made to creditors; only for
when responding to Item 3(b) and Items 18 and debtors whose debts are primarily (more
beyond. than 50%) business debts, and
Insider. “Insiders” include relatives of any c. payments made to creditors who are
degree, your general partners and their relatives, insiders; for all debtors.
and corporations or LLCs of which you are Here’s how to fill out these sections:
an officer, director, or person in control. This a. Individual or joint debtor(s) with primarily
definition determines the length of the look- consumer debts. If your debts are primarily
back period for transactions. As explained in consumer debts—that is, more than 51%
Ch. 5, the trustee can undo certain transactions of the amount you owe was incurred for
you’ve engaged in with an insider in the previous consumer, not business reasons—list
212 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
payments made to a regular creditor that money, declare it on Schedule B, and claim it as exempt
total more than $600, if the payment was on Schedule C. Then, after your bankruptcy, you can
made: do what you want with it. If you’ve already repaid a
■■to repay all or part a loan, installment loan to a relative, perhaps the relative can return the
purchase, or other debt, and money and you can exempt it as described above. If
■■during the 90 days before you filed your the money is gone, your relative can reject the trustee’s
bankruptcy petition. demand to return the money and say, in effect, “Sue
If you have made payments exceeding $600 me.” For amounts less than $1,000 or so, it’s unlikely
during that 90-day period to satisfy a domestic that the trustee will sue; the expense will likely outweigh
support obligation (child support or alimony), whatever the trustee could recover. But you never know.
identify that payment with an asterisk. Include
payments made as part of a creditor repayment 4. Suits and administrative proceedings,
plan negotiated by an approved budget and credit executions, garnishments and attachments.
counseling agency. a. List all suits …. Include all court actions that
b. Debtor whose debts are not primarily
you are currently involved in or that you
consumer debts. If your debts are primarily
were involved in during the year before
business debts (which is often but not filing. Court actions include personal
always true of small business owners), list injury cases, small claims actions, contract
any payments or other transfers you made disputes, divorces, paternity actions,
within 90 days of filing that total $5,475 or support or custody modification actions,
more to any one creditor. and the like. Include:
c. All debtors. List all payments or other
■■ Caption of suit and case number. The
transfers made to an insider creditor, if the caption is the case title (such as Carrie
payments or transfers were made within Edwards v. Ginny Jones). The case
one year before you filed your bankruptcy number is assigned by the court clerk
petition. Include alimony and child and appears on the first page of any
support payments. court-filed paper.
The basic purpose of these questions is to find
■■ Nature of proceeding. A phrase, or even
out whether you have preferred any creditor over a one-word description, is sufficient.
others. As explained in Ch. 5, the trustee can For example, “suit by debtor for
demand that a creditor who received a preference compensation for damages to debtor’s
payment return the money so the trustee can use it car caused by accident,” “small claims
to pay your other unsecured creditors. The trustee case by debtor for unpaid invoices from
may ask you to produce written evidence of any client,” “divorce.”
payments you list here, such as copies of canceled
■■ Court or agency and location. This
checks, check stubs, or bank statements. information is on any summons you
received or prepared.
■■ Status or disposition. State whether the
CAUTION case is awaiting trial, pending a decision,
Don’t use your tax refund to repay a debt on a ppeal, or finished.
to an insider. Many people use their tax refund to repay b. Describe all property …. If, at any time
a loan from a relative without realizing that the payment during the year before you filed for
may count as a preference that the trustee can take back. bankruptcy, your wages, real estate, or
If the exemptions available to you provide protection
personal p roperty were taken from you
for the refund, the better strategy is to hang on to the
214 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
under the authority of a court order to pay 7. Gifts. Provide the requested information
a debt, enter the requested information. If about gifts you’ve made in the past year.
you don’t know the exact date, put “on or The bankruptcy court and trustee want this
about” and the approximate date. information to make sure you haven’t improperly
5. Repossessions, foreclosures and returns. If, unloaded any property before filing for bankruptcy.
at any time during the year before you filed for List all charitable donations of more than $100 and
bankruptcy, a creditor repossessed or foreclosed gifts to family members of more than $200.
on property you had bought and were making You don’t have to list gifts to family members
payments on, or had pledged as collateral for a that are “ordinary and usual,” such as reasonably
loan, give the requested information. For instance, priced birthday gifts, but it can be difficult to know
if your car, boat, video equipment, or inventory which gifts are ordinary and usual. The best test is
was repossessed because you defaulted on your whether someone outside of the family might think
payments, describe it here. Also, if you voluntarily the gift was unusual under the circumstances. If so,
returned property to a creditor because you list it.
couldn’t keep up the payments, enter that here. Forgiving a loan is also a gift, as is charging
6. Assignments and receiverships. interest substantially below the market rate for a
a. Describe any assignments …. If, at any time personal loan. Other gifts include giving a car or
during the 120 days (four months) before prepaid trip to a business associate.
you filed for bankruptcy, you assigned 8. Losses. Provide the requested information
(legally transferred) your right to receive for losses from theft, fire, or gambling. If the loss
benefits, or any type of property, to a was for an exempt item, most states let you keep
creditor to pay a debt, list it here. Examples the insurance proceeds up to the limit of the
include assigning a percentage of your exemption. (See Appendix A.) If the item was not
wages to a creditor for several months or exempt, the trustee is entitled to the proceeds. In
assigning a portion of a personal injury either case, list any proceeds you’ve received or
award to an attorney. The assignee is the expect to receive. If you experience a loss after you
person to whom the assignment was made, file, you should promptly amend your papers, as
such as the creditor or attorney. The terms this question applies to losses both before you file
of the assignment should be given briefly— and afterward.
for example, “wages assigned to Snorkle’s 9. Payments related to debt counseling or
Store to satisfy debt of $500.” If you made bankruptcy. If you paid an improperly high fee to
an assignment for the benefit of creditors an attorney, bankruptcy petition preparer, debt
(ABC) within the previous four months, consultant, or debt consolidator, the trustee may
you should disclose the details here (what try to get some of it back to distribute to your
was assigned, to whom, and so on). (ABCs creditors. Be sure to list all payments someone
are covered in Ch. 3.) else made on your behalf, as well as payments you
b. List all property …. Identify all of your made directly.
property that has been in the hands of a 10. Other transfers.
court-appointed receiver, custodian, or a. List all other property, other …. List all real
other official during the year before you and personal property that you’ve sold
filed for bankruptcy. If you’ve made child or given to someone else during the two-
support payments directly to a court, and year period before filing for bankruptcy.
the court in turn paid your child’s other Some examples are selling or abandoning
parent, list those payments here. (junking) a car, pledging your house as
216 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
security (collateral) for a loan, granting Example 2: Within the year before filing for
an easement on real estate, donating bankruptcy, Louise, a freelance Web designer,
unsold inventory, or trading property. sold a vintage Jaguar E-type for $17,000.
Also, describe any transfer within the past Because this isn’t part of her business, Louise
year to your ex-spouse as part of a marital should list this sale here.
settlement agreement. If you are filing
b. List all property transferred …. List all
alone, describe gifts to your current spouse
transfers of your own property that you
made during that same period.
have made in the previous ten years to an
Don’t include any gifts you listed in
irrevocable trust that lists you as a benefi-
Item 7. Also, don’t list property you’ve
ciary. These types of trusts—referred to as
parted with as a regular part of your
self-settled trusts—are commonly used by
business or financial affairs. For example,
wealthy people to shield their assets from
if you operate a mail order book business,
creditors and by disabled people to preserve
don’t list the books you sold during the
their right to receive government benefits. In
past year. Similarly, don’t put down
bankruptcy, however, assets placed in a self-
payments for regular goods and services,
settled trust will be considered nonexempt.
such as your phone bill, utilities, or
There is an exception that applies to assets
rent. The idea is to disclose transfers of
placed in certain special needs trusts. (In re
property that might legally belong in your
Schultz, 368 B.R. 832 (D. Minn. 2007).) If
bankruptcy estate.
you are the beneficiary of a self-settled trust,
you should talk to a bankruptcy attorney
CAUTION before filing.
Earlier transfers may also be in question. 11. Closed financial accounts. Provide inform
The Statement of Financial Affairs asks about transfers ation for each account in your name or for your
made during the previous two years only. However, you benefit that was closed or transferred to someone
may be questioned at your creditors’ meeting about else during the past year.
transfers occurring four or five years ago. In most states, 12. Safe deposit boxes. Provide information for
the law prohibits fraudulent transfers of property going each safe deposit box you’ve had within the past
back that long, and the trustee may decide to chase year.
down such transfers if the circumstances seem fishy and 13. Setoffs. A setoff is when a creditor, often
the money is significant. (See Ch. 5 for more on state a bank, uses money in a customer’s account to
fraudulent transfer laws.)
pay a debt owed to the creditor by that customer.
For example, many credit unions tie loans to the
Example 1: John has accumulated a collection borrower’s savings and checking accounts, so that
of junked classic cars and runs a business any default on the loan can be deducted from those
reselling the cars to restoration hobbyists. accounts. Setoffs are not covered by the automatic
Within the past year, John has sold three of stay. When you file for bankruptcy, the credit
the cars for a total of $20,000. Because this union can freeze your deposit accounts and recover
is part of John’s regular business, he needn’t at least part of the loan. Here, list any setoffs that
report the sales here. However, as a sole your creditors have made during the previous 90
proprietor, John will be completing questions days.
18 through 20. 14. Property held for another person. Describe all
the property you’ve borrowed from someone else or
218 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
that you are storing or holding in trust for someone 15. Prior address of debtor. If you have moved
else. Examples include property you’re holding as within the three years before you file for bankruptcy,
executor or administrator of an estate and funds list all of your residences within those three years.
in an irrevocable trust held for someone else as 16. Spouses and former spouses. If you lived in a
beneficiary, but controlled by you as trustee. This community property state (or Puerto Rico) within
type of property is not part of your bankruptcy eight years prior to filing for bankruptcy, list the
estate. However, you must disclose these funds name of your spouse and of any former spouses who
so the trustee is aware of them and can ask for lived with you in the community property state. (To
more details. (Some people dishonestly describe remind you, community property states are Alaska,
all of their property as being in trust or otherwise Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, New
belonging to someone else, hoping to avoid having Mexico, Texas, Washington, and Wisconsin.)
to give it to the trustee. Disclosures in this part of 17. Environmental information. Few individuals
the Statement of Financial Affairs allow the trustee will have much to say here. It’s intended primarily
to explore this possibility.) for businesses that do business on polluted
premises. Still, read the questions carefully and
If You Are Listed on Someone provide the requested information, if applicable.
Else’s Account 18. Nature, location and name of business.
Provide all of the information requested on line a
In the instructions for completing Schedule B, we for your business. As mentioned earlier, note that
explained that you should list any bank accounts the definition of business is very broad: It includes
you have been added to for money management not only sole proprietors, but anyone self-employed
purposes. Here, you should describe the account,
in a trade, profession, or other activity either full or
explain (as you did on Schedule B) that you are on
part time—or involved in a business in which the
the account only to manage it for your relative, and
debtor owned 5% or more of the voting or equity
state that the money in the account belongs to the
securities within the six-year period. It is very
relative, not to you.
important that you answer this question completely
A trustee who becomes interested in property
so that the trustee will have a good idea of how you
you describe here may invoke several court proce-
earned your money over the past six years and what
dures designed to get more information. However,
it is unlikely that the trustee will invade your house
you did with your business interests (if you are no
to seize the property. If you can establish that longer in business).
the property truly belongs to someone else—by If the majority of your business income for
producing the trust document, for example—you any one business comes from renting, leasing, or
needn’t worry about losing it in your bankruptcy otherwise operating a single piece of real property
case. (other than an apartment building with fewer than
four units), include your business name and the
Example: You are renting an unfurnished
address of the property on line b.
apartment owned by a friend. The friend has
19. Books, records and financial statements.
left a valuable baby grand piano in your care.
a. List all bookkeepers …. Identify every person
If and when you decide to move, you have
other than yourself—usually a bookkeeper
agreed to place the piano in storage for your
or accountant—who was involved in
friend. Because you don’t own the piano, but
the accounting of your business during
rather are taking care of it for your friend, you
the previous two years. If you were the
would describe it here.
only person involved in your business’s
accounting, check “None.”
220 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
b. List all firms …. If your books weren’t person or original manufacturer, put “no inventory
audited during the past two years, check required” or “materials purchased for each order as
“None.” Otherwise, fill in the r equested needed.”
information. 21 through 25. These items are intended for
c. List all firms …. Usually, you, your book filers who are business entities—such as a partner
keeper, your accountant, an ex-business ship, corporation, or limited liability company.
associate, or possibly an ex-mate will This book is designed for individual filers—that is
have business records. If any are missing, owners of small businesses—so you should be able
explain (you’ll be better off if the loss of to check “None” for each of these items.
your records was beyond your control). Declaration Under Penalty of Perjury by Individual
d. List all financial …. You most likely prepared Debtor. Sign and date this section. If you’re filing
a financial statement if you applied to a jointly, be sure your spouse dates and signs it as
bank for a loan or line of credit for your well.
business or in your own name. If you’re self- If completed on behalf of a partnership or
employed and applied for a personal loan corporation. Type “N/A.”
to purchase a car or house, you probably Certification and Signature of Non-Attorney
submitted a financial statement as evidence Bankruptcy Petition Preparer. If a BPP typed your
of your ability to repay. Such statements forms, have that person complete this section.
include: Otherwise, type “N/A” anywhere in the box.
■■ balance sheets (these compare assets with Be sure to insert the number of continuation
liabilities) pages you attached (if any).
■■ profit and loss statements (these compare
income with expenses), and
■■ financial statements (these provide an Form 8—Chapter 7 Individual
overall financial description of a business). Debtor’s Statement of Intention
This form is very important if you owe any
CAUTION secured debts (Schedule D), or you are a party to
If you haven’t kept adequate business any ongoing contracts, loans, or unexpired leases
records, talk to an attorney. If the trustee wants to (Schedule G). This is where you tell the trustee and
see records of your business activity and you come your secured creditors how you want to handle
up empty, the trustee may challenge your right to a each of your secured debts. Briefly, you may:
bankruptcy discharge on the ground that your failure to • reaffirm the debt, and keep the collateral
keep adequate records demonstrates bad faith. Whether under a reaffirmation agreement that will
your business records are so bad that your discharge
continue your liability for the debt despite
is at risk is something that only a bankruptcy attorney
your bankruptcy
familiar with your court can answer. Also, an attorney
• redeem the debt by buying the collateral at
may be able to help you reconstruct records that would
its replacement value, or
be satisfactory to the trustee.
• voluntarily surrender the collateral.
These options were discussed in detail in Ch.
20. Inventories. If you have an inventory, fill in
8; return to that chapter now if you want more
the information requested in items a and b. If your
guidance on your options here.
business doesn’t have an inventory (many service
As explained in our discussion of Schedule G
business don’t), check “None.” If your business
above, your trustee gets first crack at any leases and
deals in products, but you are primarily the middle
ChaPter 9 | Complete and file Your BAnkruptcy Paperwork | 225
contracts to which you are a party, for up to 60 Court Name. Copy this information from Form
days after your filing date. If they have any intrinsic 1—Voluntary Petition.
value, the trustee may take them over, sell them, In re and Case No. Follow the instructions for
and distribute the proceeds among your unsecured Schedule A.
creditors. However, in your Statement of Intention, Chapter. Type in “7”
you should indicate how you’d like each lease or Part A—Debts secured by property of the estate.
contract to be handled if the trustee isn’t interested. Here, you list each of your secured debts and
For example, if you have leased equipment for your indicate what you plan to do with the property
business, you can indicate on this form that you securing the debt (the collateral). The form provides
want to assume the lease (provided your creditor space to list three secured property items; if you
agrees) and continue on with your business after have more, attach extra sheets. For each piece of
your bankruptcy. If you want to walk away from property, you must list the creditor’s name and
a lease or contract, you can indicate your intent to describe the property, as you did on Schedule
reject it. D. Then, you must check the appropriate box to
Under 11 U.S.C. § 365p, you must provide indicate whether you are surrendering the property
the lessor (the leasing company) with written (giving it back to lender) or retaining it.
notice that you intend to assume the lease (if the The next choices are more difficult. If you plan
trustee doesn’t sell it). You do this by sending the to enter into a reaffirmation agreement with the
lessor a copy of the Statement of Intention. The lender, check the “reaffirm the debt” box. If you are
statute gives the lessor the option to agree to the able to redeem the property by paying the creditor
assumption and notify you of any conditions you the lesser of what you owe or the replacement
must meet (for example, catching up on your value of the property, check that box. (But few
payments, if you’re behind). The lessor is very likely debtors can afford this option.) If there is equity
to let you assume the lease; the alternative would be in the property and you qualify to “avoid the lien”
for you to walk away without any penalty. because it impairs an exemption, check the “other”
box and write “avoid the lien” in the blank space.
(All of these options are covered in detail in Ch. 8.)
CAUTION
In some cases involving secured personal
Check your mileage on a leased car. Before
property such as a car or business equipment, your
you decide to assume a car lease, check your mileage. If
your mileage substantially exceeds the limit in your lease
lender will not require you to reaffirm the loan but
and you plan on turning your car in when the lease is up, rather will let you keep the property as long as you
think again about whether it makes sense to keep the remain current on the payments. If this is your
car. You may be better off letting it go now and getting lender’s choice, you can check the “other” box and
out from under the excess-mileage charges. put “Debtor will retain collateral and continue to
make regular payments.”
If you are moving to avoid a lien, check the
For Married couples
“claimed as exempt” box. Also, if you have any
If you are married. If you’re filing jointly,
equity in the property securing the debt (that is,
complete only one form, even though it says “Individual
the property is worth more than you owe), check
Debtor’s Statement of Intention.”
the “exempt” box. If you are underwater on the
property (you owe more than it’s worth), check the
Below is a completed Statement of Intention
“not claimed as exempt” box; you have no equity to
and instructions.
protect with an exemption.
226 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
Reaffirming a Mortgage
Bankruptcy professionals often advise against bankruptcy without further complying with your
reaffirming a mortgage because it will leave you with state’s rules regarding foreclosure. As a result, you
a large debt after your bankruptcy case is over. If you may be kicked out of your home months earlier than
don’t reaffirm, there are some consequences. Your would otherwise be the case.
lender won’t report your continued payments on the And, as explained in Ch. 8, some courts may
mortgage to the credit reporting agencies, so your require you to either redeem or reaffirm if you want
payments won’t help you rehabilitate your credit. to keep the property. In other words, these courts
Also, you may not be able to modify your mortgage don’t recognize the “ride-through” option.
unless you reaffirm, because many mortgage servicers In these situations, you may want to reaffirm
take the position that once your bankruptcy filing your mortgage to buy yourself more time. This
wipes out the promissory note, there’s nothing left to means you would still owe the lender after your
modify. Generally speaking, however, it’s a better idea bankruptcy. But if you live in what’s called a
to finish your modification efforts before filing for “nonrecourse” state, this shouldn’t be a disadvantage.
bankruptcy—and to avoid reaffirming your mortgage. In nonrecourse states, the lender cannot collect a
There are exceptions to this general rule, deficiency judgment on a first mortgage. If the house
however. If you are facing foreclosure and using is worth less than the mortgage, the lender must
bankruptcy as a strategic maneuver to increase accept the home’s value as payment in full. If your
the amount of time you can remain in your home state allows collection of deficiencies on second
without making any payments, reaffirmation makes mortgages, however—which almost all states do—
more sense. If you surrender the house in your you’ll still be on the hook for that debt. As you can
Statement of Intention, or don’t indicate how you see, reaffirming a mortgage as a strategy to gain more
want to handle your mortgage, the lender may time in your home can be tricky; you should consult
immediately foreclose on the mortgage after your with a lawyer if you’re planning to go this route.
to receive it before the six-month period began. (In re unemployment insurance as income, but this issue
Burrell, 399 B.R. 620 (Bkrtcy C.D. Ill., 2008).) is still up in the air. It’s a good idea to include
this income on your first draft of the form. If
Line 3. Enter your average monthly earnings you fail the means test but would pass it without
over the last six months from gross wages, salary, your unemployment, go ahead and exclude it
tips, bonuses, overtime, and commissions. (“Gross” and see what happens. Your court may not count
means before any taxes, Social Security benefits, or unemployment insurance payments as income.
other amounts are withheld.) Line 10. Insert the average monthly amount you
Line 4. Deduct your ordinary and necessary received from any other source. Do not include
business operating expenses from your gross money or benefits received under the SSI, SSA, or
receipts and enter the difference here. While TANF programs. These are Social Security benefits
your gross income from employment determines and are excluded from your current monthly
whether you fall under the median income, it’s income computation.
your net business income that you use if you are Line 11. Compute the subtotals for column A
in business. Be prepared in the course of your and B (if used). Remember, these subtotals should
bankruptcy to produce records that support the net reflect an average monthly figure for all of the items
income figure you enter here. you entered in Lines 3 through 10.
Line 5. Enter your average monthly rental Line 12. Add the subtotals for columns A and
income for the six-month period (if you have any), B together. This is what the new bankruptcy law
and deduct ordinary and necessary operating calls your “current monthly income.” Because it’s a
expenses for that same period. six-month average, it might not match your actual
Line 6. Enter your average monthly income monthly income at the time you file, especially if
from interest, dividends, and royalties over the last you’ve closed your business or become unable to
six months. work in the last six months.
Line 7. Here’s where you include your average
monthly pension and retirement income. Don’t Part III: Application of § 707(b)(7) Exclusion
include Social Security retirement benefits. This is where the rubber meets the road: In this
Line 8. Enter the monthly average of any part, you must compare the current monthly
amounts regularly contributed by someone else to income figure you calculated in Part II with the
your household income. If you are filing separately median family income for your state. If your
but your spouse’s income is included in Column B, income is more than the median, you’ll have to fill
don’t include any contributions that your spouse out the rest of the form—and you may be barred
makes to your household—his or her income is from using Chapter 7. If your income is equal to or
already being taken into account. less than the median, you can skip the rest of the
Line 9. Your average monthly unemployment form and file your Chapter 7 papers.
compensation goes here. If you want, you can Line 13. Convert your monthly figure on Line
argue that unemployment compensation should 12 to an annual figure by multiplying it by 12. This
be excluded under the general Social Security is your current annual income.
exclusion (see In re Munger, 370 B.R. 21 (D. Line 14. Enter the median income for your state
Mass. 2007) and In re Sorrell, 359 B.R. 167 (S.D. and household size. The most recent state median
Ohio 2007)) and omit it from Columns A and income figures as of the date this book is published
B. However, you’ll need to enter the amount you are in Appendix B. To make sure that you are using
receive in the boxes supplied for this purpose. the most current figures, however, you should visit
The main trend in bankruptcy courts is to count the U.S. Trustee’s website, www.justicej.gov/ust, and
234 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
click “Means Testing Information.” Scroll down a your dependents. For example, if Line 11, Column
bit for the link to the state median income figures. B shows that your nonfiling spouse has a monthly
Line 15. Do the math. If your income figure income of $2,000, but your spouse contributes only
exceeds the state median, check the bottom box on $400 a month to your household, you can enter
Line 15 and continue to Part IV. $1,600 here.
If your income does not exceed the median, Line 18. Subtract the amount on Line 17 from
check the top box on Line 15, and sign and date the amount on Line 16. Enter the total here.
the form in Part VIII. Then, return to the first page
of the form, where you should check the bottom Part V. Calculation of Deductions
box (“The presumption does not arise”) in the top, From Income
right-hand corner. In this part, you will figure out what expenses you
can deduct from your current monthly income.
Tip
After you subtract all allowed expenses, you will
be left with your monthly disposable income—the
Consider postponing your filing. If you
conclude that you’ll have to take the means test, think
amount you would have left over, in theory, to pay
about whether your income will decrease in the next few into a Chapter 13 plan.
months. If your spouse recently lost a high-paying job or
your business receipts have really declined, for example,
Subpart A: Deductions under Standards of
your average income over the past six months might the Internal Revenue Service (IRS)
look pretty substantial. But in a few months, when you If you have to complete this part of the form—that
average in your lower earnings, it will come down quite is, if your current monthly income exceeds the
a bit—perhaps even to less than the state median. If so, state median income—you are not allowed to
you might want to delay your bankruptcy filing if you subtract all of your actual expenses. Instead, you
can. must calculate some of your expenses according
to standards set by the IRS. (The IRS uses these
standards to decide how much a delinquent
Part IV. Calculation of Current Monthly taxpayer should have to give the agency each
Income for § 707(b)(2) month to repay back taxes on an installment plan.)
This is the beginning of the means test. With Line 19A. Enter the total IRS National
a couple of exceptions, the values you will be Standards for Food, Clothing, and Other Items
entering in the form are fairly straightforward. for your family size and income level. This is the
The purpose of the means test is to find out amount the IRS believes you should get to spend
whether you have enough income to pay some of for food, clothing, household supplies, personal
your unsecured, nonpriority debts over a five-year care, and miscellaneous other items. You can get
period. (Your unsecured, nonpriority debts are these figures from www.justice.gov/ust. Click
those you listed in Schedule F, above.) “Means Testing Information,” then scroll down to
Line 16. Enter the total from Line 12. the correct link. You also can get these figures from
Line 17. If you checked the box on Line 2c your court clerk.
(married, not filing jointly, and not making the Line 19B. Enter the amount you are allowed to
declaration in Line 2b), you can subtract any claim for health expenses from the IRS National
portion of your spouse’s income (as listed in Standards for Out-of Pocket Health Care. You can
Line 11, Column B) that was NOT regularly find these figures at www.justice.gov/ust. Click
contributed to your household expenses or those of “Means Testing Information,” then scroll down to
236 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
the appropriate link. As you’ll see, you can claim Line 22A. You are entitled to claim an expense
more for household members who are at least 65 here regardless of whether you actually have a car.
years old, which is reflected on the form. You’ll also First, indicate the number of cars for which you
see that the total amount you can claim is quite pay operating expenses or for which somebody
small; if you spend more than you’re allowed to else contributes to the operating expenses as
claim here, you can claim it on Line 31. part of the amount entered on Line 8. If you
Line 20A. Enter the amount of the IRS Housing don’t have a car, enter the amount listed under
and Utilities Standards, nonmortgage expenses “Public Transportation” from the IRS Local
for your county and family size. Get these figures Transportation Expense Standards. You can find
from www.justice.gov/ust. Click “Means Testing these at www.justice.gov/ust; click “Means Testing
Information,” then scroll down to the IRS Housing Information” and scroll down to the appropriate
and Utilities Standards section and enter your state link, where you will choose your region. If you
in the drop-down menu. Find the figures for your indicated that you have one or two cars, enter the
county and family size, then enter the figure that amount listed for your region (and sometimes, your
appears under the heading “Non-Mortgage.” city) under “Operating Costs” in the same chart.
Line 20B. On Line a, enter the amount of the Line 22B. If you have a car and also use
IRS Housing and Utility Standards, mortgage/ public transportation, you may claim a public
rental expenses for your county and family size. transportation expense here. Find the correct
These figures appear on the U.S. Trustee’s website, amount by following the instructions for Line 22A,
on the same chart as nonmortgage expenses— above.
follow the instructions for Line 20A, above. Line 23. These are your expenses for owning
On Line b, enter the average monthly payment or leasing a car. On Line 23a, enter the IRS
for any debts secured by your home, including a Local Transportation Standards for ownership
mortgage, home equity loan, taxes, and insurance. of a first car. This amount is actually a national
The average monthly payment is the total of all figure; currently, it is $489. To make sure you
amounts contractually due to each secured creditor are using the most up-to-date numbers, use
in the five years after you file for bankruptcy, www.legalconsumer.com or check the website
divided by 60. of the U.S. Trustee, www.justice.gov/ust. Click
On Line c, subtract Line b from Line a. This “Means Testing Information.” Then scroll down
may turn out to be a negative figure—if so, enter a to the Local Transportation Expense Standards
zero in the right-hand column. Later in the means drop-down menu and choose your region. The
test, you’ll be able to add your average monthly ownership figure is near the bottom of the page.
payment back in as an expense.
Line 21. If your actual rental or mortgage
CAUTION
expense is higher than that allowed by the IRS, you
If you aren’t making payments, you might
can claim an adjustment here. For instance, if the face a challenge. A dispute exists over whether you can
IRS mortgage/rental expense for a family of two claim this expense if you aren’t paying for or leasing a
is $550, you pay an actual rent of $900, and that car. Some U.S. Trustees (and courts) insist that you can’t
amount is average for the area in which you live, claim the expense. However, the National Association for
enter the additional $350 here and explain why Consumer Bankruptcy Attorneys has filed briefs arguing
you should be able to subtract it (that you couldn’t that you should be able to, because old cars wear out,
possibly find housing in your area for less, for and you will need to lease or buy a new car sometime
example). during the next five years. Currently, the courts are split,
ChAPter 9 | COMPLETE AND FILE YOUR BANKRUPTCY PAPERWORK | 237
• the total monthly amount you pay for already claimed it in subpart A or on Lines 4 or 5
the education of a physically or mentally in Section II (business expenses), don’t list it again
challenged dependent child for whom no here.
public education providing similar services Line 34. Here, list your reasonably necessary
is available. Include in this amount the monthly expenses for health insurance, disability
actual costs of after-school enrichment insurance, and health savings accounts (HSAs) on
educational services for a physically or the lines provided. The form was revised in 2008
mentally challenged child, and the actual to clarify that you can list a “reasonable” expense
education expenses you are paying in whether you actually pay that amount each month
support of an individual educational plan. or not. If, however, you pay less than the reasonable
Line 30. Enter the average monthly expense amount you list, you must indicate how much
of child care (including baby-sitting, preschool, you actually spend each month on the additional
nursery school, and regular child care. If your line provided. If the U.S. Trustee or one of your
employment (and therefore, your need for child creditors later wants to challenge your expense
care) is seasonal, add your child care costs up for claims—for example, to argue that you really have
the year and divide the total by 12. Do not equate more disposable income than the form indicates—
education with child care. For instance, child care they can use this information.
for a child who is of public education school age Line 35. Anything you spend to care for a
should only cover the hours before and after school. member of your household or immediate family
Line 31. Enter the average monthly amount because of the member’s age, illness, or disability
you pay for out-of-pocket health care expenses, can be deducted here. If your contributions are
but only to the extent it exceeds the amount you episodic—a wheelchair here, a vacation with a
were allowed to claim on Line 19B. Do not include companion there—estimate your average monthly
payments for health insurance or health savings expense and enter it here.
accounts; those go on Line 34.
Line 32. Enter the average monthly expenses
CAUTION
you pay for any communication devices that are
Your response here could affect eligibility
necessary for the health and welfare of you or your for government benefits. Expenses you list here could
dependents. Examples provided by the form are cell render the person you are assisting ineligible for Social
phones, pagers, call waiting, caller identification, Security or other government benefits. For example, if
and special long distance or Internet services. you state that you are spending $500 a month for the
Virtually all of these devices arguably are necessary care of a relative, and that relative is receiving SSI, your
for the health and welfare of your family. However, relative might receive a lower benefit amount each
some expenses might not be allowed (for example, month, to reflect your contribution. Despite this possible
cell phones you use for your business, or broadband consequence, if you are making such expenditures, you
Internet service). When in doubt, list the expense. are required to disclose them here. If you find yourself in
Line 33. Add the expenses you entered in Lines this predicament, talk to a lawyer.
19 through 32 and put the total in the column at
the right. Line 36. The average monthly expense for
security systems and any other method of
Subpart B: Additional Living Expense Deductions protecting your family should be entered here.
The expenses in this subpart are allowed by the Line 37. If your actual home energy costs exceed
Bankruptcy Code, in addition to the IRS expenses. the figure you entered on Line 20A, enter the extra
However, you can’t list an expense twice; if you amount you spend here. As the form indicates, you
240 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
may need to prove this extra expense to the trustee. you haven’t paid your mortgage for months or are
Whether you need to provide proof will depend on even in foreclosure, these courts would allow you
the results of this means test. If the amount you to list the required payments anyway as deductions
enter here is the deciding factor in determining against your income. Other courts won’t allow
that you don’t have enough disposable income to this, however. If you don’t know how your local
fund a Chapter 13 plan, proof will definitely be bankruptcy court deals with this issue, don’t
required. include any payments you aren’t actually making
Line 38. This item is for money you spend on on your first round of calculations. If you pass the
your children’s education. If your average monthly means test without these payments, great! If you
expense is $137.50 or more, put $137.50 in this need to deduct the payments to pass the means
blank; that’s the maximum you can deduct. test, however, go back and include them; you may
Remember not to list an amount twice; if you need to argue your side in front of the judge. (See
already listed an expense on Line 29 or 30, for Ch. 12 for suggestions on legal research; you can
example, don’t repeat it here. find citations to cases addressing this issue at www.
Line 39. Here, you can list the amount by which legalconsumer.com.)
your actual expenses for food and clothing exceed Line 42. List the average monthly payment
the IRS allowance for these items as entered in you will have to make over the next five years
Line 19. However, you cannot list more than 5% to creditors that hold a secured interest in your
over the IRS allowance. property (for example, the mortgage holder on
Line 40. If you have been making charitable your house, a creditor holding your car note, or a
contributions to an organization before your business creditor who has a secured interest in your
bankruptcy filing date, you can enter them here business equipment, inventory, or other assets).
as long as the group is organized and operated As explained in the instructions for Line 23, you
exclusively for religious, charitable, scientific, can calculate this amount by figuring out the total
literary, or educational purposes; to foster national amount you will owe over the next five years, then
or international amateur sports competition (but dividing that total by 60.
only if no part of its activities involve the provision Line 43. Here, list the average monthly
of athletic facilities or equipment); or for the payments you would have to make to pay off any
prevention of cruelty to children or animals. The past amounts due to creditors for property that you
organization also can’t be disqualified from tax must keep to support yourself or your dependents.
exemption status because of its political activities. Property necessary for support typically includes
Line 41. Enter the total of Lines 34 through 40 a car, your home, and any property you need for
in the column on the right. your employment. Past-due business obligations
should not be listed here. Come up with the
Subpart C: Deductions for Debt Payment monthly figure you have to enter here by dividing
Here, you deduct average monthly payments you the total amount you would have to pay by 60.
will have to make on secured debts over the next Line 44. List the average monthly amount you
five years. Once you complete this section, you can will have to pay for priority claims over the next
put all the numbers together to figure out whether five years. Your priority claims are all claims you
you pass the means test. listed earlier in Schedule E. Divide by 60 to arrive
Most courts to consider the issue have held that at the monthly average.
debtors are entitled to list all payments on secured Line 45. Here, you must calculate the fee
debts they are contractually obligated to make, that the trustee would charge if you ended up in
even if they aren’t paying them. For example, if Chapter 13 bankruptcy. That fee would depend
242 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
on how much you would be paying, through the Line 48. Enter the amount from Line 18 in the
trustee, to your secured and unsecured creditors. column on the right.
It’s impossible to come up with a figure at this Line 49. Enter the amount from Line 47 in the
point in the form, so leave it blank for now. column on the right.
You don’t have to complete this section if you Line 50. Subtract Line 49 from Line 48 and
pass the means test without it. However, if you enter the result in the column on the right.
leave this blank on your initial pass through the Line 51. Multiply the total from Line 50 by 60
form and your disposable income, from Line 51, is (to find out how much disposable income you will
over the limit, follow these instructions to come up have over the next five years, according to these
with a figure for Line 45: figures). Enter the result in the column on the
Add Lines 42, 43, and 44. right.
Divide the total on Line 54 by 60 (for the Line 52. Here you must check one of three
average monthly payment you would have to make boxes. If the amount on Line 51 is less than $6,575,
to pay down 25% of your unsecured debt over five check the top box. This means that you don’t
years). have enough money left over to make a Chapter
Add this number to the total of Lines 42, 43, 13 plan feasible, so you can file for Chapter 7. If
and 44, and put the result on Line 45a. This is the total on Line 51 is more than $10,950, you
the average amount you would have to pay into have enough income to make a Chapter 13 plan
a Chapter 13 plan to cover your secured debts, feasible, and you probably won’t be allowed to stay
arrearages on those debts, priority debts, and 25% in Chapter 7. If your total is at least $6,575 but no
of your unsecured debts. more than $10,950, you will have to do a few more
On Line 45b, enter the multiplier percentage calculations to figure out where you fall.
from the U.S. Trustee’s website for your state and If you checked the top box, go back to the first
district. Go to www.justice.gov/ust, click “Means page and check the bottom box at the top, right-
Testing Information,” scroll down to the section hand side of the page (“The presumption does not
called “Administrative Expenses Multiplier” and arise”). Then, complete the verification in Part VIII
click “Schedules,” then scroll down to your district below.
to get the percentage. If you checked the middle box, go back to Page
Multiply Line 45a by Line 45b and enter the One, check the top box (“The presumption arises”),
result in the column on the right. and complete the verification in Part VIII.
Line 46. Add Lines 42 through 45, and enter If you checked the bottom box, continue on to
the total in the column on the right. Line 53.
Line 53. Enter the total nonpriority, unsecured
Subpart D: Total Deductions from Income. debt that you entered in your Schedule F, above.
Enter the total of Lines 33, 41, and 46 in the
column at the right. This is the total amount you CAUTION
can subtract from your current monthly expenses Don’t double a debt for duplicate creditors.
to arrive at your disposable income. To get an accurate result here, you must make sure that
you didn’t duplicate the amount of any debt for which
Part VI: Determination of
you have more than one creditor on Schedule F. If you
§ 707(b)(2) Presumption did, go back and recalculate the total on your Schedule F,
This is where you find out whether you received a adding each debt only once even though you are listing
passing grade on the means test. two or more creditors for a specific debt (for instance the
original debtor, a collection agency, and an attorney).
244 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
Line 54. Multiply the amount on Line 53 by left out an expense that is provided for in the form,
the number 0.25 and enter the result in the box make the adjustments and see whether you can get
on the right. This is equal to 25% of your total a passing grade. Because this form is so complex,
nonpriority, unsecured debt. we recommend that you go through it at least twice
Line 55. Here, you determine whether the before arriving at your final figures.
income you have left over (listed on Line 51)
is sufficient to pay 25% of your unsecured, See an Expert
nonpriority debt (listed on Line 54). If Line 51 is
See a lawyer if the presumption arises
less than Line 54, congratulations: You have passed and you want to stay in Chapter 7. If you have to
the means test. Go back to the first page, check the check the box stating that the presumption (of abuse)
bottom box at the top right-hand side of the page arises, your Chapter 7 filing is in trouble. Unless you
(“The presumption does not arise”) and complete are willing to proceed under Chapter 13, or have your
the verification in Part VIII below. bankruptcy dismissed, we strongly suggest that you find
If Line 51 is greater than Line 54, you have a bankruptcy lawyer to help you.
failed the means test. The form instructs you to
go back to the first page, check the top box at the
top right-hand side of the page (“The presumption
arises”), and complete the verification. Form 201A—Notice to
If you don’t pass the means test, you can Consumer Debtors Under
complete Part VII, in which you list additional
expenses that were somehow not included in the § 342(b) of the Bankruptcy Code
earlier parts of the form. Those expenses will be This form, required by the revised bankruptcy law,
taken into account by the U.S. Trustee as long gives you some information about credit counseling
as they don’t duplicate earlier expenses and are and the various chapters of bankruptcy available. It
reasonably necessary to support you and your family. also warns you sternly of the consequences of lying
In one case, for example, a married couple who on your bankruptcy papers, concealing assets, and
filed jointly both had jobs in rural communities failing to file the required forms on time.
that required them to drive enormous distances. By You can find a blank copy of the form in
documenting the travel expenses, which were not Appendix C. You don’t have to file it with your
adequately covered in the means test transportation bankruptcy paperwork. Your signature on the
allowance, they were able to reduce their disposable bankruptcy petition indicates that you have received
income below the means test threshold. (In re and read this notice. (Although there is a separate
Batzkeil, 349 B.R. 581 (N.D. Iowa 2006).) certification form—Form 201B—indicating that
If you have to check the “presumption arises” you have read and received this notice, you don’t
box, the U.S. Trustee will issue a notice and have to sign or file it unless you failed to sign the
schedule a hearing at which the judge will be petition for some reason.)
asked either to dismiss your case or convert it to
Chapter 13. This is something that you probably
don’t want. What to do? Before completing Mailing Matrix
Part VIII, we suggest that you go back over the As part of your bankruptcy filing, you are required
form and carefully examine the expense items to submit a list of all of your creditors so the court
that aren’t mandated by the IRS. Often, people can give them official notice of your bankruptcy.
underestimate their actual expenses. If you find Called the “mailing matrix,” this list must be
that you underestimated one or more expenses, or prepared in a specific format prescribed by your
246 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
local bankruptcy court. Your court may also require the debt will still be discharged, unless the creditor
you to submit a declaration, or “verification,” stating could have successfully challenged the discharge
that your list is correct (as always, be sure to check had it known of your bankruptcy. See Ch. 11 for
your court’s local rules). In a few courts, the form more information.
consists of boxes on a page in which you enter the
names and addresses of your creditors. This is an
artifact from the time when the trustee would use How to File Your Papers
the form to prepare mailing labels. Gather up all of the forms you have completed,
Now, however, most courts ask you to submit as well as the documents you gathered at the
the list on a computer disk in a particular word beginning of this chapter. Make sure you have
processing format, or at least submit a computer everything on the Bankruptcy Form Checklist
printout of the names so that they can be scanned. and Bankruptcy Documents Checklist (you can
You should check with the bankruptcy court clerk find them in Appendix B). If you use a petition
or the court’s local rules to learn the precise format. preparer, there will be several additional forms to
Then, take these steps: file.
Step 1: Make a list of all of your creditors,
in alphabetical order. You can copy them from
Schedules D, E, F, and H. Be sure to include
Basic Filing Procedures
cosigners and joint debtors. If, however, you and Once you’ve got all of your papers together, follow
your spouse jointly incurred a debt and are filing these filing instructions.
jointly, don’t include your spouse. Also include Step 1: Put all your bankruptcy forms in the
collection agencies, sheriffs, and attorneys who proper order.
either have sued you or are trying to collect the Step 2: Check that you, and your spouse if
debt. And, if you’re seeking to discharge marital you’re filing a joint petition, have signed and dated
debts you assumed during a divorce, include both each form where required.
your ex-spouse and the creditors. Finally, if you Step 3: Make the required number of copies,
have two or more debts owed to the same creditor plus one additional copy for you to keep just in
at the same address, you can just list one. case your papers are lost in the mail (if you file by
Step 2: Make several copies of the mailing mail). In addition, make:
matrix form in Appendix C. • one extra copy of the Statement of Intention
Step 3: If you are using the “box” format, enter for each person listed on that form, and
your name and address in the top left-hand box • one extra copy of the Statement of Intention
on the sheet you designate as the first page. Then for the trustee.
enter the names and addresses of each creditor, one Step 4: Unless the court clerk will hole-punch
per box and in alphabetical order (or in the order your papers when you file them, use a standard
required by your local bankruptcy court). Use as two-hole punch (copy centers have them) to punch
many sheets as you need. the top center of your original set of bankruptcy
It is very important to be complete when papers. Don’t staple any forms together.
preparing the matrix. If you leave a creditor off the Step 5: If you plan to mail your documents to
matrix and the creditor does not find out about the court, address a 9" × 12" envelope to yourself
your bankruptcy by some other means, that debt and affix adequate postage to handle one copy of
may survive your bankruptcy—and you will have all the paperwork. Although many people prefer
to pay it down the line. However, if you have no to file by mail, we recommend that you personally
assets to be distributed (as is typically the case), take your papers to the bankruptcy court clerk if
ChaPter 9 | Complete and file Your BAnkruptcy Paperwork | 247
at all possible. Going to the court will give you a Paying in Installments
chance to correct minor mistakes on the spot.
Step 6: If you can pay the filing fee, clip or You can pay in up to four installments over 120
staple a money order to the petition, payable to the days if the judge approves. You can ask the judge to
U.S. Trustee (courts won’t accept a check). If you give you extra time for a particular installment, but
want to pay in installments, attach a completed all installments ultimately must be paid within 180
Application and Order to Pay Filing Fee in days after you file. You’ll probably have to appear
Installments (Form 3A), plus any additional papers at a separate hearing a couple of weeks after you file
required by your court’s local rules (see “Paying in to make your case for installment payments before
Installments,” below). If you have paid an attorney the bankruptcy judge. If the judge refuses your
for help with your bankruptcy, you don’t qualify request, you will be given some time to come up
for installment payments. If you don’t think you with the fees (probably ten days, perhaps longer).
can afford installment payments, you may be able Because of this “appearance before the judge”
to obtain a fee waiver. Use Form 3B (included in requirement, many debtors prefer to raise the whole
Appendix C) for this purpose. For both installment fee before filing and hopefully get through their
payments and fee waivers, you’ll have to appear entire bankruptcy without ever meeting up with
before the bankruptcy judge to justify your request. the judge.
Step 7: Take or mail the original and copies of If you are applying to pay in installments, you
all forms to the correct bankruptcy court. must file a completed Form 3A (Application and
Order to Pay Filing Fee in Installments) when
you file your petition. You can find a blank copy
Serving the Statement of Intention of this form in Appendix C. You cannot apply for
permission to pay in installments if you’ve paid an
The bankruptcy rules require you to serve (by
attorney to help you with your bankruptcy.
mail) the Statement of Intention on each creditor
listed on the statement. You have between 30
The application is easy to fill out. At the top,
and 45 days to do this. We recommend you do it fill in the name of the court (this is on Form 1—
immediately so you don’t forget. If you don’t serve Voluntary Petition), your name (and your spouse’s
your Statement of Intention on time, the creditor name if you’re filing jointly), and “7” in the blank
can repossess the collateral. The trustee must also after “Chapter.” Leave the Case No. space blank.
be served. The trustee’s contact information will be Then enter:
provided either on the copy of your papers that the • the total filing fee you must pay: $299
clerk returns to you or on the notice of filing you (Item 1)
receive several days after you file. • the amount you propose to pay when you
Have a friend or relative (other than your file thepetition (Item 4, first blank)
spouse, if you are filing jointly) over the age of 18 • the number of additional installments you
mail, by first class, a copy of your Statement of need (the total maximum is four), and
Intention to the bankruptcy trustee and to all the • the amount and date you propose for each
creditors listed on that form. Be sure to keep the installment payment (Item 4, second, third,
original. and fourth blanks).
On a Proof of Service by Mail (a copy is in You (and your spouse, if you’re filing jointly)
Appendix C), enter the name and complete address must sign and date the application. Leave the rest
of the trustee and all creditors to whom your friend blank. As mentioned, you may be required to
or relative sent your Statement of Intention. Have appear for a hearing at which the judge will decide
that person sign and date the Proof of Service. whether to approve or modify your application.
248 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
date—unless and until the bankruptcy trustee says If some of your property is nonexempt, the
otherwise. Even if all of your property is exempt, trustee may ask you to turn it over. Or, the trustee
you are expected to hold on to it, in case the trustee may decide that the property is worth too little to
or a creditor challenges your exemption claims. bother with and abandon it. (Typically, the trustee
doesn’t let you know that property is abandoned,
but once you receive your discharge, the property is
What Happens to Business Property
legally considered abandoned.)
If you are operating a business that has valuable You are allowed to spend cash you had when
property or inventory, you may have to shut you filed (declared on Schedule B) to make day-
down once you file your bankruptcy—at least to-day purchases for necessities such as groceries,
temporarily—unless the trustee is willing to quickly personal effects, and clothing. Just make sure you
assess the nature and value of your business assets. can account for what happened to that cash: You
This shut-down period may last for a couple of may need to reimburse the bankruptcy estate if the
months or even longer. On the other hand, if your money wasn’t exempt and the trustee disapproves
business is service-oriented and lacks machines or your purchases.
inventory, you may be able to continue in business In a Chapter 7 case, with a few exceptions,
without interruption. the trustee has no claim to property you acquire
As a general rule, corporations and other or income you earn after you file. You are free to
business entities aren’t part of a personal spend it as you please. The exceptions are: property
bankruptcy. However, if you (or you and your from an insurance settlement, marital settlement
spouse) are the sole or majority owner of an entity, agreement, or inheritance that you become entitled
the trustee can legally “step into your shoes,” vote to receive within 180 days after your filing date.
your shares to dissolve the business, and sell off (See Ch. 5.)
whatever inventory and assets you can’t protect
under your personal exemptions such as they
l
are. Because it takes some time to assess business
assets and go through the necessary corporate
procedures, you would have to shut down your
business at least while that process is going on. And
if you aren’t able to exempt your business assets,
you’ll probably have to shut down for good.
10
C H A P T E R
several weeks later. Mark this date carefully—it is take place. The IRS cannot, however, record
very important for several reasons. a lien or seize your property a fter you file
• You must attend the creditors’ meeting; for bankruptcy.
if you don’t, your case can be dismissed • Evictions from residential premises can go
(although you’ll probably be given another forward in some circumstances.
opportunity to appear at a rescheduled (Ch. 4 provides detailed information on the
meeting). automatic stay, including which actions it does—
• Your creditors must file their claims (if it and does not—prohibit.)
is an asset case) within 30 days after this In addition, the bankruptcy court can lift the
meeting. automatic stay for a particular creditor after notice
• Your creditors must file any objections they and hearing—that is, allow the creditor to continue
have to the discharge of their debts within its collection efforts. (Lifting the automatic stay is
60 days a fter this meeting. covered in “Special Problems,” below.)
Although the stay kicks in immediately,
Contact Information for the Trustee creditors won’t know that they have to stop their
The notice of filing will also provide the name, collection efforts until they receive notice of your
address, and telephone number of the trustee bankruptcy filing from the court. This official
assigned to your case. You probably won’t receive notice may take a week or more to reach your
the trustee’s email address, even though almost creditors. A lot can happen in a week, especially
all trustees prefer to communicate electronically. if you’re facing an immediate foreclosure,
If you use email, call the trustee’s office, get the repossession, or other emergency. That’s why you
trustee’s email address, and communicate via email might want to notify creditors of your bankruptcy
if possible. This is where you’ll need to send a copy filing right away. For instance, if you file for
of your most recently filed federal tax return, as bankruptcy a couple of days before a foreclosure
explained below. sale, the sale is legally barred by the automatic stay,
even though the creditor hasn’t received official
Your Creditors Must Cease notice of your filing yet. If you notify the creditor
Most Collection Actions directly of your bankruptcy, the sale will be put
The automatic stay goes into effect the moment you on hold. If you don’t, the sale may go through, but
file your bankruptcy papers. The automatic stay then will have to be put aside.
prohibits most creditors and government support If you’re facing immediate collection efforts,
entities from taking any action to collect the debts send your own notice to creditors (and bill
you owe them until the court says otherwise. collectors, landlords, or sheriffs about to enforce
There are some notable exceptions to the auto an eviction order). A sample letter notifying your
matic stay, however. Even if you file for bankruptcy, creditors is shown below. You can also call your
the following proceedings can continue: creditors. Be prepared to give your bankruptcy case
• A criminal case can proceed against you. number, the date you filed, and the name of the
• A case to establish paternity or to establish, court in which you filed.
modify, or collect child support or alimony If a creditor tries to collect a debt in violation
can go forward. of the a utomatic stay, you can ask the bankruptcy
• A tax audit, the issuance of a tax deficiency court to hold the creditor in contempt of court and
notice, a demand for a tax return, the issu- award you money damages. The procedures for
ance of a tax assessment, and the demand making this request are beyond the scope of this
for payment of such an assessment can all book—and few debtors are likely to need them.
ChAPter 10 | HANDLING YOUR CASE IN COURT | 255
Because the penalties for willfully violating the or omissions in your paperwork. Some trustees
automatic stay can be severe, most creditors play question debtors more closely about their
it safe and back off once they’ve heard that you’ve bankruptcy papers than others. The trustee may
filed for bankruptcy. want to see documentation of some of your figures,
such as the value of a house or car; if you don’t
have this paperwork with you, the trustee will
Notice to Creditor of Filing for Bankruptcy
continue the meeting to another date to give you
time to find the necessary documents. Typically,
Lynn Adams
you won’t have to appear at another meeting, but
18 Orchard Park Blvd.
can submit these documents by mail.
East Lansing, MI 48823
Debtors who have been operating a business
June 15, 20xx may come under closer scrutiny at the creditors’
Cottons Clothing Store meeting if their record keeping was sloppy and the
745 Main Street trustee can’t readily determine how much money
Lansing, MI 48915 the business has been making (or losing). As a
Dear Cottons Clothing: small business owner, your bankruptcy will go a
lot smoother if you have a profit-and-loss statement
On June 14, 20xx, I filed a voluntary petition under
(or something similar) that clearly depicts your
Chapter 7 of the U.S. Bankruptcy Code. The case
business’s economic activity. If you have a retail
number is 43-6736-91. I filed my case in pro per; no
attorney is assisting me. Under 11 U.S.C. § 362(a),
business or a business with significant assets (such
you may not: as tangible goods or high accounts receivable), the
trustee will likely order you to shut the business
• take any action against me or my property to
down at the creditors’ meeting, if not before.
collect any debt
Even though it’s called a creditors’ meeting,
• enforce any lien on my real or personal property few (if any) creditors typically show up. That
• repossess any property in my possession doesn’t let you off the hook, however: You—and
• discontinue any service or benefit currently your spouse, if filing jointly— must appear at
being provided to me, or the meeting. If you don’t appear and you haven’t
notified the trustee in advance, you’ll probably
• take any action to evict me from where I live.
receive a letter from the trustee setting a new date
A violation of these prohibitions may be considered and warning you that your case could be dismissed
contempt of court and punished accordingly. if you fail to show up again. You aren’t legally
Very truly yours, entitled to this “second chance,” however: Failing
Lynn Adams to show up for the first scheduled meeting might
Lynn Adams earn you a hearing before the judge where you’ll
have to explain yourself.
meeting. Ask the trustee whether both of you have to • if you had to take the means test, proof of
come back, or whether one will do. your monthly expenses.
of creditors if you think that might help alleviate stated on the bankruptcy notice. A number of
some anxiety. Just check with the U.S. Trustee’s other people who have filed for bankruptcy will be
office in your district to find out when these there, too, for their own creditors’ meetings. When
meetings are held (see www.justice.gov/ust for your name is called, you’ll be asked to sit or stand
contact information). near the front of the meeting room. The trustee
A day or so before the creditors’ meeting, will swear you in and ask for your identification. At
thoroughly review the papers you filed with the that point, many trustees look you in the eye and
bankruptcy court. If you discover mistakes, make sternly ask whether everything in your papers is
careful note of them. You’ll probably have to 100% true and correct. If you are uncertain about
correct your papers after the meeting, but that’s an information in your papers or you have lied, the
easy process. (Instructions are in “Amending Your trustee is likely to pick up on your hesitancy and
Bankruptcy Papers,” below.) follow up with more questions that may make you
After reviewing your papers, go over the list uncomfortable. That’s why it’s so important that
of questions the trustee may ask (set out in “What you:
Will the Trustee Ask You?” below). Despite the fact • review your papers before filing them
that these are “required” questions, few trustees ask • file amendments before the creditors’
all of them, and many trustees ask only one or two. meeting if you discover any errors after you
Still, it’s a good idea to be prepared to answer them file (refer to “Amending Your Bankruptcy
all, if they relate to your situation. Papers,” below)
At the beginning of the meeting, the trustee • review your papers again shortly before the
may ask you whether you have read the Statement creditors’ meeting, and
of Information required by 11 U.S.C. § 342 (this • volunteer any additional changes at the
is Form 201, which you signed and filed with meeting before you are asked about them.
your other papers). By reading this book, you have Then you can confidently answer “yes” to the
learned all the information on this form. Still, trustee’s first question.
review it before the meeting, so you can tell the The trustee will probably be most interested in:
trustee that you’ve read it. • how you came up with a value for big ticket
items, such as your home, car, or business
assets
CAUTION
• anticipated tax refunds
Don’t forget your ID. You’ll need
• any possible right you may have to sue
identification at the creditors’ meeting. Bring both
a photo ID (such as a driver’s license, passport, or
someone because of a recent accident or
identification card) and proof of your Social Security business loss
number from a third-party source (like a Social Security • reasons for inconsistencies in your
card, wage stub, retirement account statement, or paperwork or omitted information (such as
passport ). answering “none” to the questions about
clothing or bank accounts when it’s obvious
that you have either or both)
The Routine Creditors’ Meeting • recent large payments to creditors or
Most creditors’ meetings are quick and simple, relatives, and
even for small business owners. You appear in the • possible inheritances or insurance proceeds
designated meeting place at the date and time coming your way.
258 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
Technically, the trustee is required to ask the following • For property that you’re renting: Have you
questions at your creditors’ meeting (although most ever owned the property where you live? Is the
don’t): property owner in any way related to you?
• State your name and current address for the • Have you made any transfers of any property,
record. or given any property away, within the last two
• Have you read the Bankruptcy Information years (or a longer period if applicable under
Sheet provided by the U.S. Trustee? state law)? If so, what did you transfer? To
• Did you sign the petition, schedules, state whom was it transferred? What did you receive
ments, and related documents you filed with in exchange? What did you do with the funds?
the court? Did you read the petition, schedules, • Does anyone hold property belonging to you?
statements, and related documents before you If so, who holds the property, and what is it?
signed them, and is the signature your own? What is its value?
• Please provide your picture ID and Social • Do you have a claim against anyone or any
Security number card for review. business? If there are large medical debts, are
• Are you personally familiar with the informa the medical bills from injury? Are you the
tion contained in the petition, schedules, plaintiff in any lawsuit? What is the status of
statements, and related documents? each case, and who is representing you?
• To the best of your knowledge, is the informa • Are you entitled to life insurance proceeds or
tion contained in the petition, schedules, an inheritance as a result of someone’s death? If
statements, and related documents true and so, please explain the details. (If you become a
correct? beneficiary of anyone’s estate within six months
• Are there any errors or omissions to bring to of the date your bankruptcy petition was filed,
my or the court’s attention at this time? the trustee must be advised within ten days of
• Are all of your assets identified on the the nature and extent of the property you will
schedules? receive.)
• Have you listed all of your creditors on the • Does anyone owe you or your business money?
schedules? If so, is the money collectible? Why haven’t you
• Have you previously filed for bankruptcy? (If so, collected it? Who owes the money, and where
the trustee must obtain the case number and is that person?
the discharge information to determine your • Have you made any large payments (more than
discharge eligibility.) $600) to anyone in the past year?
The trustee may also ask additional questions, • Were your federal income tax returns filed on
such as: time? When was the last return filed? Do you
• Do you own or have any interest in any real have copies of your federal income tax returns?
estate? When you filed your petition, were you entitled
• For property that you own: When did you to a tax refund from the federal or state
purchase the property? How much did the government?
property cost? What are the mortgages • Do you have a bank account, either checking or
encumbering it? What do you estimate the savings? If so, in what banks and what were the
present value of the property to be? Is that the balances as of the date you filed your petition?
whole value or your share? How did you arrive • When you filed your petition, did you have:
at that value? • any cash on hand
260 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
• any U.S. Savings Bonds • Do you anticipate that you might acquire any
• any other stocks or bonds property, cash or otherwise, as a result of a
• any certificates of deposit, or divorce or separation proceeding?
• a safe deposit box in your name or in anyone • Regarding any consumer debts secured by
else’s name? your property, have you filed the required
• Do you own an automobile? If so, what is the Statement of Intention with respect to the
year, make, and value? Do you owe any money exemption, retention, or surrender of that
on it? Is it insured? secured property? Please provide a copy of the
• Are you the owner of any cash value life statement to the trustee. Have you performed
insurance policies? If so, state the name of that intention?
the company, face amount of the policy, cash • Have you been engaged in any other business
surrender value (if any), and beneficiaries. during the last six years? If so, where and when?
• Do you have any winning lottery tickets? What happened to the assets of the business?
petition preparers who may have improperly you claimed and files a written objection with
provided you with legal advice (see Ch. 12 for more the bankruptcy court, the court will schedule a
about bankruptcy petition preparers). hearing. After listening to both sides, the judge will
decide the issue. (See “Special Problems,” below.)
CAUTION
If you really want to keep certain nonexempt
items and you can raise some money, you may
You’re responsible for your paperwork,
even if you used a bankruptcy petition preparer.
be able to pay the trustee for the property. The
You must provide the property valuation and other
trustee, whose sole responsibility at this stage
information in your bankruptcy papers. You cannot shift is to maximize what your creditors get paid, is
responsibility for the accuracy and thoroughness of your interested only in how much money your property
petition to the preparer, whose job is just to enter the can produce, not in taking a particular item. So
information you supply. If you use a preparer, check all the trustee will probably be happy to accept cash
of your paperwork carefully before signing it and filing it instead of nonexempt property you want to keep.
with the court. Example: Maura files for Chapter 7 bank
ruptcy and claims her industrial coffee roaster
as exempt. The trustee disagrees, and the judge
Make Sure the Creditors’ rules that the coffee roaster is not exempt. To
Meeting Is “Closed” replace the coffee roaster on the open market
The 30-day period in which the trustee and will cost Maura about $7,000. The trustee
creditors may file objections to your exemption determines that the coffee roaster would
claims starts running when the creditors’ meet probably sell for $4,500 at an auction, and is
ing is finished or “closed.” The meeting is officially willing to let Maura keep the coffee roaster
closed—and the clock starts to run on objections— if she can come up with $3,750, to avoid the
only when the trustee so notes in the court’s docket. cost of moving the coffee roaster, storing it,
The trustee’s oral statement alone at the creditors’ and selling it at auction.
meeting isn’t enough to officially close the meeting.
The trustee may also be willing to let you
Check the court file to make sure that the trustee
keep n onexempt property if you volunteer to trade
closed (or adjourned) the creditors’ meeting, and
exempt property of equal value. For instance, the
follow up with the trustee if you don’t see an e ntry
trustee might be willing to let Maura keep her
like that. Otherwise, the 30-day period to file
nonexempt coffee roaster if she gives up her car,
objections never starts to run, and the trustee and
even though Maura could claim the car as exempt.
creditors will technically have an unlimited time to
Again, the trustee is interested in squeezing as
file objections.
many dollars as possible from the estate and usually
won’t care whether the money comes from exempt
or nonexempt assets.
Deal With Nonexempt Property
Deal With Secured Property
After the meeting of creditors, the trustee is
When you filed your Statement of Intention, you
supposed to collect all of your nonexempt
told the trustee and your creditors whether you
property and have it sold to pay off your creditors.
wanted to keep the property securing the debt or
Normally, the trustee a ccepts the exemptions you
give it to the creditor.
claim on Schedule C and goes after only property
The law contradicts itself on the time limits
you haven’t claimed as exempt. If, however, the
for carrying out your intentions. Depending on
trustee or a creditor disagrees with an exemption
262 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
which provision you believe, you have either 30 or • you have a severe physical impairment
45 days after the date set for your first creditors’ • you make a reasonable effort, despite
meeting to deal with your secured property. If you the impairment, to participate in the
miss the deadline, the creditor can repossess the counseling, and
collateral—the automatic stay no longer applies • you are unable, because of your impairment,
(see Ch. 4). Because of these serious consequences, to meaningfully participate in the course.
we strongly recommend that you follow through (See In re Hall, 347 B.R. 532 (N.D. W.Va.
on your plans for secured property (as expressed on 2006).) For example, in a case in which a married
your Statement of Intention) within 30 days of the couple filed jointly, the judge waived the counseling
creditors’ meeting, just in case the court enforces requirement for the husband who was disabled by
the earlier deadline. (Ch. 8 covers your options for moderate Alzheimer’s.
dealing with secured property.)
Attend a Discharge Hearing
Complete an Approved Debtor (If One Is Scheduled)
Education Course You may have to attend a brief court hearing at
After you file for bankruptcy but before you get the end of your case, called a d ischarge hearing.
your discharge, you must take a two-hour course in At the hearing, the judge explains the effects of
personal financial management. Known as “debtor discharging your debts in bankruptcy and lectures
education,” or “pre-discharge” counseling, this you about staying clear of debt. You should receive
course is typically offered by the same agencies that a discharge order from the court within four weeks
provide the credit counseling you must complete of the hearing. If you don’t, call the trustee.
before you file. (You can find counseling agencies Most courts don’t schedule a discharge
at www.justice.gov/ust; click “Credit Counseling hearing unless you signed and filed a reaffirmation
and Debtor Education.”) Like credit counseling, agreement, in which case the court definitely will
you can expect to pay about $50 or less for this hold a hearing. At the hearing, the judge will
course, and you can ask for a fee waiver if you can’t determine whether reaffirmation would impose an
afford the fee. Unlike credit counseling, which you undue hardship on you and whether it would be
can complete by phone, you are supposed to take in your best interest to reaffirm the debt. You can
your debtor education course in person or online. find a complete explanation of the reaffirmation
Once you complete the counseling (and no process—including what happens if the judge
later than 45 days after the first date set for your won’t approve the agreement—in Ch 8.
creditors’ meeting), you must file Form 23 with the
court to certify that you’ve met the requirement. Understand Your Discharge Order
(You’ll find a copy of the form in Appendix C.) About two or three months after the creditors’
If you don’t file this form on time, the court can meeting, the court will send you a copy of your
close your case without granting you a discharge of discharge order. On the back, it says that all debts
your debts, which means your bankruptcy case was you owed as of your filing date are discharged—
pointless. While it’s possible to reopen your case to unless they aren’t. It then lists the types of debt
file the required form, it’s obviously much easier to that are not discharged. (A sample discharge order
get the counseling and file the form as soon after is below.) You will notice that the order does not
you file your bankruptcy papers as possible. refer to your debts or state which of your specific
You might be able to obtain a disability waiver debts are or are not discharged. To get a handle on
of this counseling requirement—which means you this crucial information, carefully read Ch. 11.
wouldn’t have to take it—if:
ChAPter 10 | HANDLING YOUR CASE IN COURT | 263
264 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
ChaPter 10 | Handling Your Case in Court | 265
Open Letter to Debtors and Their Counsel Add or Delete Property on Schedule A or B
You may have forgotten to list some of your
I have noticed a disturbing trend among debtors property on your schedules. or, you may have
and their counsel to treat the schedules and received certain types of property after filing for
statement of affairs as “working papers” which can bankruptcy. As explained in Ch. 5, the following
be freely amended as circumstances warrant and
property must be reported to the bankruptcy
need not contain the exact, whole truth.
trustee if you receive it, or become entitled
Notwithstanding execution under penalty of to receive it, within 180 days after filing for
perjury, debtors and their counsel seem to think bankruptcy:
that they are free to argue facts and values not • property you inherit or become entitled to
contained in the schedules or even directly
inherit
contrary to the schedules. Some debtors have felt
• property from a marital settlement
justified signing a statement that they have only
agreement or divorce decree, and
a few, or even a single creditor, in order to file an
emergency petition, knowing full well that the • death benefits or life insurance policy
statement is false. proceeds.
If you have new property to report for any of
Whatever your attitude is toward the schedules,
these reasons, you may need to file amendments to:
you should know that as far as I am concerned they
are the sacred text of any bankruptcy filing. There • Schedule A, if the property is real estate
is no excuse for them not being 100% accurate and • Schedule B, if the property is personal
complete. Disclosure must be made to a fault. The property
filing of false schedules is a federal felony, and I do • Schedule C, if the property was claimed as
not hesitate to recommend prosecution of anyone exempt and it’s not, or you want to claim it
who knowingly files a false schedule. as exempt
I have no idea where anyone got the idea that • Schedule D and Form 8—Chapter 7
amendments can cure false schedules. The debtor Individual Debtor’s Statement of Intention,
has an obligation to correct schedules he or she if the property is collateral for a secured
knows are false, but amendment in no way cures debt
a false filing. Any court may properly disregard • Form 7—Statement of Financial Affairs,
[a] subsequent sworn statement at odds with if any transactions regarding the property
previous sworn statements. I give no weight at all haven’t been described on that form, or
to amendments filed after an issue has been raised. • The mailing matrix, if the item is tied to a
As a practical matter, where false statements or particular creditor.
omissions have come to light due to investigation If your bankruptcy case is already closed, see
by a creditor or trustee, it is virtually impossible for Ch. 11.
the debtor to demonstrate good faith in a Chapter
13 case or entitlement to a discharge in a Chapter Change Your Plans for Secured Property
7 case. I strongly recommend that any of you If you’ve changed your plans for dealing with an
harboring a cavalier attitude toward the schedules
item of secured property, you must file an amended
replace it with a good healthy dose of paranoia.
Form 8 —Chapter 7 Individual Debtor’s Statement
Dated: September 10, 20xx of Intention.
Alan Jaroslovsky
Alan Jaroslovsky Correct Your List of Creditors
U.S. Bankruptcy Judge, N.D. Cal., Santa Rosa To correct your list of creditors, you may need to
amend:
ChaPter 10 | Handling Your Case in Court | 267
them an opportunity to file a motion to dismiss or • You didn’t really fail the means test. To defend
convert your case to Chapter 13 bankruptcy. yourself on this basis, you must be able to
Within 30 days after filing this statement, the show that you actually passed the means
U.S. Trustee must either: test, and that the party bringing the motion
• file its own motion to dismiss or convert to dismiss or convert your bankruptcy
your case on grounds of abuse, or case misinterpreted the information you
• explain why a motion to convert or dismiss provided in Form 22A or misinterpreted the
isn’t appropriate (for example, because applicable law (for example, by including
you passed the means test or special Social Security benefits in your current
circumstances exist). monthly income when the law says they
These duties and time limits apply only to the should be excluded).
U.S. Trustee. If your income is more than the state • Special circumstances exist that allow you
median, your creditors can file a motion to dismiss to pass the means test. The new law gives
or convert any time after you file, but no later than a serious medical condition or a call to
60 days after the first date set for your meeting of active duty in the armed forces as examples
creditors. of special circumstances, but this isn’t an
exhaustive list. However, just showing that
Defending a Motion to Dismiss or Convert special circumstances exist isn’t enough:
If the U.S. Trustee (or a trustee or a creditor, in You must also show that they justify
some cases) files a motion to dismiss or convert additional expenses or adjustments to your
your case on the basis of presumed abuse, you current monthly income “for which there is
are entitled to notice of the hearing at least 20 no reasonable alternative.”
days in advance. You will receive papers in the To prove special circumstances, you must
mail explaining the grounds for the motion and itemize each additional expense or adjustment of
what you need to do to respond. Because abuse is your income and provide:
presumed, you will bear the burden of proving that • documentation for the expense or adjust
your filing really isn’t abusive, and that you should ment, and
be allowed to proceed. • a detailed explanation of the special
There are three basic defenses to this type of circumstances that make the expense or
motion: adjustment necessary and reasonable.
• You are exempt from the means test provisions You will win only if the additional expenses
because your debts were primarily business or adjustments to your income enable you to pass
debts. If you checked the appropriate box on the means test. (Ch. 9 explains how to make this
your petition to indicate that your debts are calculation.)
primarily business debts, now is the time
Example: Maureen and Ralph have a
when you may be called on to prove it. In
child (Sarah) with severe autism. Sarah is
Ch. 2, we provide some general guidelines
making remarkable progress in her private
for separating consumer debts from
school, for which Maureen and Ralph pay
business debts. With that material in front
$1,000 a month. No equivalent school is
of you, review and recategorize all of your
available at a lower tuition. Under the means
debts. If you conclude that you correctly
test guidelines, Maureen and Ralph are
characterized them as primarily business
entitled to deduct only $150 a month from
debts, you’ll need to show the court how
the income for private school expenses. If
you came to that conclusion.
Maureen and Ralph were allowed to deduct
ChaPter 10 | Handling Your Case in Court | 269
Motions to Dismiss for Abuse the full $1,000 monthly tuition, they would
Under All the Circumstances easily pass the means test. By documenting
Sarah’s condition, the necessity for the extra
Even if you pass the means test on paper, your case educational expense, and the fact that moving
can be dismissed if it appears that your Chapter her to a less expensive school would greatly
7 filing is an abuse of the bankruptcy code under undermine her progress, Maureen and Ralph
“all the circumstances.” In this context, “all the would have a good chance of convincing the
circumstances” means all of the facts before the
court to allow the $1,000 expense, which
judge. Motions to dismiss for this reason often
would overcome the presumption of abuse and
focus on whether the debtor’s claimed expenses are
allow them to use Chapter 7.
unnecessarily extravagant. For example, an Ohio
bankruptcy court ruled that a mortgage expense Bankruptcy courts have issued written
on a $400,000 home and an expense for repayment decisions on a variety of special circumstance
of a 401(k) loan should not be allowed. Without claims. If you need to prove special circumstances
those expenses, the debtors would have adequate to pass the mean test, you will definitely want
income to fund a Chapter 13 plan, which made to check with a local attorney or do your own
their case an abuse under all the circumstances. (In research to find out how bankruptcy court or
Re Felske, 385 B.R. 649 (N.D. Ohio 2008).) the courts in your state have treated the special
The facts justifying dismissal of a Chapter circumstances you’re claiming. (See Ch. 12.) A
7 bankruptcy because of abuse under all the frequently addressed issue is whether payments on
circumstances don’t necessarily have to exist when nondischargeable student loans can be considered
you first file for bankruptcy. One appellate court a special circumstance. While a few courts have
ruled that a motion to dismiss may be based on held that they can be, more courts have gone the
events occurring anytime before the discharge,
other way and ruled that student loan payments
which typically occurs between three and four
do not constitute special circumstances. (See, for
months after filing. (In re Cortez, 457 F.3d 448 (5th
example, In re Champagne, 389 B.R. 191 (Bkrtcy
Cir. 2006).) So if, after you file for bankruptcy, you
Kan. 2008) and In re Pageau, 383 B.R. 281 (S.D.
get a new job or win the lottery, or some other event
Ind. 2008).)
happens while your case is pending that would
Here are some cases in which the court has
enable you to proceed under Chapter 13, you may
allowed a particular special circumstances claim,
face a challenge to your Chapter 7 case. (See also In
re Henebury, 361 B.R. 595 (S.D. Fla. 2007).)
but remember that courts in your area may see the
If you face dismissal on this ground, you issue differently:
must explain why it’s unlikely you could complete • unusually high transportation expenses (In
a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, or why expenses the re Batzkiel, 349 B.R. 581 (Bkrtcy N.D.
trustee has challenged are necessary for you to Iowa 2006); In re Turner, 376 B.R. 370
get a fresh start. There is no clear test of what (Bkrtcy D. N.H. 2007))
constitutes abuse under all the circumstances; it • mandatory repayment of 401(k) loan (In
depends on how your judge views the situation. re Lenton, 358 B.R. 651 (Bkrtcy E.D. Pa.
Fortunately, the U.S. Trustee (usually the party 2006))
bringing these motions) must prove the abuse. • reduction in income (In re Martin, 371 B.R.
If you pass the means test, your eligibility for 347 (Bkrtcy C.D. Ill. 2007) (diminished
Chapter 7 bankruptcy is presumed, and the trustee future availability of overtime hours); In
has to overcome that presumption. re Tamez, No. 07-60047 (Bkrtcy W.D.
Tex. 2007) (reduction in income due to
voluntary job changes))
270 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
• wife’s pregnancy, in a joint bankruptcy case discharge, even though your case would still be
(In re Martin, 371 B.R. 347 (Bkrtcy C.D. open.
Ill. 2007)) As long as the stay is in effect, most creditors
• joint debtors who have two separate must get permission from a judge to take any
households (In re Graham, 363 B.R. 844 action against you or your property that might
(Bkrtcy S.D. Ohio 2007); In re Armstrong, affect your bankruptcy e state. (See Ch. 4 for
No. 06-31414 (Bkrtcy N.D. Ohio 2007)) information on which creditors are affected by the
• unusually high rent expenses (In re stay and which are free to proceed with collection
Scarafiotti, 375 B.R. 618 (Bkrtcy D. Colo. efforts despite the stay.) To get this permission,
2007)), and the creditor must file a request in writing called a
• court-ordered child support payments (In “Motion to Lift the Stay.” The court will schedule
re Littman, 370 B.R. 820 (Bkrtcy D. Idaho a hearing on this motion and send you written
2007)). notice. You will have a certain period of time to file
Most small business owners won’t be able to a written response. Even if you decide not to file a
claim special circumstances based on business response, you may still be able to appear in court to
expenses, because the means test already takes argue that the stay shouldn’t be lifted. Check your
those expenses into account. When you calculate local rules on this point.
your current monthly income, you are allowed to If you don’t show up for the hearing—even if
subtract ordinary and necessary business expenses you filed a written response—the stay will probably
from your business income to come up with the be lifted as requested by the creditor, unless lifting
total. If you have a business expense that’s out the stay would potentially harm other creditors.
of the ordinary and doesn’t fit into any of the For instance, if the creditor is seeking permission
categories used in the means test, you could try to repossess your car, and your equity in the car
to convince the judge to allow you to claim it as a would produce some income for your unsecured
special circumstance expense. (See, for example, In creditors if sold by the trustee, the court may refuse
re Turner, 376 B.R. 370 (Bkrtcy D. N.H., 2007), to lift the stay whether or not you show up.
in which the debtor was allowed to count his After hearing the motion, the judge will either
business mileage as a special circumstance, because rule “from the bench” (announce a decision right
he logged it separately from his personal mileage then and there), or “take it under submission” and
and had not already subtracted it as a reasonable mail a decision in a few days. A creditor can ask a
and ordinary business expense when calculating his judge to lift the stay within a week or two after you
current monthly income.) file, but a delay of several weeks to several months
is more common.
A Creditor Asks the Court to
Lift the Automatic Stay Grounds for Lifting the Automatic Stay
Your automatic stay lasts from the date you The bankruptcy court may lift the automatic stay
file your papers until the date you receive your for several reasons:
bankruptcy discharge or the date your bankruptcy • The activity being stayed is not a legitimate
case is closed, whichever happens first. For concern of the bankruptcy court. For
example, assume you receive a discharge but the instance, the court will let a child custody
trustee keeps your case open in order to collect hearing proceed, because its outcome won’t
your pending tax refund or an inheritance you are affect your economic situation.
due to receive in the future. In this situation, the • The activity being stayed is going to happen
automatic stay would not be in effect after your no matter what the bankruptcy court does.
ChaPter 10 | Handling Your Case in Court | 271
car, equipment, or jewelry, the creditor will service unless you provide adequate
probably argue that the stay should be lifted assurance that your future bills will be paid.
because you might damage the collateral (11 U.S.C. § 366(b).) Usually, that means
or because the collateral is depreciating you’ll have to come up with a security
(declining in value) while your bankruptcy deposit. If you and the utility can’t agree
case is pending. Your response should on the size of the deposit, the utility may
depend on the facts. If the property is still cut off service, which means you’ll need to
in good shape, be prepared to prove it to the get a lawyer and ask the bankruptcy court
judge. to have it reinstated. If the utility files a
If the property is worth more than you motion to lift the stay, argue at the hearing
owe on it, you can argue that depreciation that your deposit is adequate.
won’t hurt the creditor, because the property • Evictions. Filing for bankruptcy has been
could be repossessed later and sold for the a favorite tactic for some eviction defense
amount of the debt or more. But if, as is clinics (legal housing clinics that help
common, you have little or no equity in the tenants fight eviction), which file a bare-
property, you’ll need to propose a way to bones bankruptcy petition to stop evictions
protect the creditor’s interest while you keep even if the tenant’s debts don’t justify
the property (if you want it). One way to bankruptcy. Under the 2005 bankruptcy
do this is to pay the creditor a cash security law amendments, the automatic stay
deposit to offset the expected d epreciation doesn’t apply if your landlord obtained
(called “adequate assurance of payment”). a judgment for eviction before you filed
If you intend to keep secured property, for bankruptcy, or if the eviction is based
you can argue that lifting the stay would on your endangerment of the property or
deprive you of your rights under the use of illegal controlled substances on the
bankruptcy laws. For example, if you intend premises. These exceptions are explained in
to redeem business equipment by paying its Ch. 4.
replacement value, the court should deny
the motion to lift the stay until you have an The Trustee or a Creditor Disputes
opportunity to do so. a Claimed Exemption
• Utility disconnections. For 20 days after After the creditors’ meeting, the trustee and
you file your bankruptcy petition, a creditors have 30 days to object to the exemptions
public utility— electric, gas, telephone, or you claimed. If the deadline passes and the trustee
water company—may not alter, refuse, or or a creditor wants to challenge an exemption, it’s
discontinue service to you or your business, usually too late, even if the exemption statutes
or discriminate against you in any other don’t support the claimed exemption. (Taylor v.
way, solely on the basis of an unpaid debt Freeland and Kronz, 503 U.S. 638 (1992).) The
or your bankruptcy filing. (11 U.S.C. objections must be in writing and filed with the
§ 366(a).) If your service was disconnected bankruptcy court. Copies must be served on the
before you filed, the utility company must trustee, you, and your lawyer, if you have one.
restore it within 20 days after you file for In some cases, the trustee can object to an
bankruptcy—without requiring a deposit— exemption after the 30-day period has passed.
if you request it. For instance, in one case the debtor stated that
Twenty days after the order to continue the value of certain stock options was unknown
service, the utility is allowed to discontinue and used a $4,000 or so wildcard exemption to
ChaPter 10 | Handling Your Case in Court | 273
cover the value, whatever it was. Eight months • Within ten years before filing for
after the bankruptcy case was closed, the trustee bankruptcy, you sold nonexempt property
asked the debtor what happened to the stock and purchased exempt property to hinder,
options. As it happened, they had been cashed out delay, or cheat your creditors.
for nearly $100,000. The trustee sought to have • Property you claimed as exempt is worth
the case reopened to recover the excess value. The more than you say it is. If the property’s
debtor argued that the 30-day period prevented a true replacement value is higher than the
reexamination of the exemption claim. The issue exemption limit for that item, the item can
was ultimately decided in favor of the trustee. be sold and the excess over the exemption
The court found that the debtor’s use of the term limit distributed to your creditors (assuming
“unknown” relieved the trustee of the obligation to you don’t buy the property back from the
challenge the exemption claim within the 30-day trustee at a negotiated price).
limit. If, on the other hand, the debtor had listed a
Example: In Connie’s state, tools of the trade
specific value for the options, the trustee’s duty to
are exempt up to $6,000. Connie, a general
file an objection within the deadline would have
contractor, values her tools at $2,000 and her
been triggered. (In re Wick, 276 F.3d 412 (8th Cir.
truck at $4,000, which means they fit within
2002).)
the $6,000 total exempt amount. A creditor
Reasons for Objecting to Exemptions objects to Connie’s valuation of the truck,
claiming that it’s worth $8,000 by itself. If
The most common reasons trustees and creditors
the creditor prevails, Connie would have to
object to exemptions are:
surrender the truck to the trustee. She’d get
• You aren’t eligible to use the state exemp-
the first $4,000 (the exempt amount of the
tions you claimed. Under the 2005 bank-
truck’s sale price). Or, Connie could keep
ruptcy law, you may use a state’s exemptions
the truck if she gave the trustee a negotiated
only if you have made that state your domi-
amount of cash (perhaps $2,000 or so) or
cile (your true home) for at least two years
other property of equivalent value.
before filing. If you haven’t been domiciled
in your current state for at least two years, • You and your spouse have doubled an
you must use the exemptions for the state exemption where doubling isn’t permitted.
where you were living for the better part of
Example: David and Marylee, a married
the 180-day period ending two years before
couple, file for bankruptcy using California’s
you filed for bankruptcy. (See Ch. 6 for
System 1 exemptions. Each claims a $2,550
more on these rules, and Ch. 7 for more on
exemption in their family car, for a total of
the stricter rules that apply to homestead
$5,100. California bars a married couple from
exemptions.)
doubling the System 1 automobile exemption.
• The claimed item isn’t exempt under the
They can claim only $2,550.
law. For example, a plumber who lives in
New Jersey and s elects his state exemptions
might try to exempt his plumbing tools Responding to Objections
under the “goods and chattels” exemption. When objection papers are filed, the court
The trustee and creditors are likely to object schedules a hearing. The creditor or trustee must
on the ground that these are work tools prove to the bankruptcy court that the exemption
rather than goods and chattels, and New is improper. You don’t have to prove anything. In
Jersey has no “tools of trade” exemption. fact, you don’t have to respond to the objection or
274 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
show up at the hearing unless the court orders, or sift through a pile of documents and attempt to
local rules r equire, that you do so. Of course, you reconstruct the debtor’s business affairs.
can—and probably should—either file a response In considering an inadequate records objection,
or show up at the hearing to defend your claim of the court may consider:
a legitimate e xemption. If you don’t show up, the • the complexity and volume of the business
bankruptcy judge will decide on the basis of the • the amount of the debtor’s obligations
paperwork filed by the objecting party and the • whether the debtor was at fault in failing to
applicable laws, which most often means you’ll keep adequate records
lose, especially if the trustee or an attorney is • the debtor’s education, business experience,
objecting. and sophistication
• customary business practices for record
A Creditor Objects to the Discharge of a Debt keeping in the debtor’s type of business
There are a variety of reasons a creditor may object • the degree of accuracy disclosed by the
to the discharge of a debt. The most common are: debtor’s existing books and records
• the creditor believes you made fraudulent • the extent of any egregious conduct on the
statements to obtain the loan or credit in debtor’s part, and
the first place • the debtor’s courtroom demeanor.
• the debt or obligation arose from your For a good discussion of how this objection
willful and malicious act (such as assault or works, see In re Moreo, Case No. 07-71258-478
libel), or (Bankr E.D. N.Y. 2009).
• you violated a duty of trust or embezzled
funds from your employer or co-owned You Want to Get Back Exempt
company. Property Taken by a Creditor
See Ch. 11 for more on these and other You may have filed for bankruptcy after a creditor:
potential grounds for objecting to the discharge of • repossessed collateral (such as a car) under a
a debt. security agreement, or
• seized some of your property as part of a
A Creditor or the Trustee Objects judgment collection action.
to Your Bankruptcy Discharge If so, you should have described the event in
In some situations, a creditor or the trustee can your Statement of Financial Affairs, which you
object to your entire discharge. If an objection filed along with your bankruptcy petition and
like this is granted, none of your debts would schedules. Repossessions are difficult to undo,
be discharged. In small business bankruptcies, because they occur under a contract that you
this type of objection may be based on the voluntarily entered into. However, property seized
business owner’s failure to keep adequate records. to satisfy a judgment can be pulled back into your
For instance, under 11 U.S.C. § 727 (a)(3), a bankruptcy estate if the seizure occurred within the
bankruptcy discharge may be denied if the debtor’s three months before you filed. If the property is not
failure to keep or preserve books or records exempt (or at least some of it is not exempt), the
makes it impossible to determine the debtor’s true trustee may go after it so that it can be sold for the
financial condition. benefit of your unsecured creditors. If the property
Although the creditor or trustee has the burden is exempt (meaning you are entitled to keep it), you
of proving the failure to keep adequate records, can go after it yourself. However, you’ll have to file
the debtor is required to provide adequate records a formal complaint in the bankruptcy court against
if called on to do so. A creditor is not required to the creditor.
ChaPter 10 | Handling Your Case in Court | 275
The process for getting the bankruptcy judge You Want to Dismiss Your Case
to order property returned to you is complex; you’ll If you change your mind after you file for bank
probably need the assistance of an attorney. Given ruptcy, you can ask the court to dismiss your case.
the cost of attorneys, it’s seldom worth your while Common reasons for wanting to dismiss a case
to go after this type of property unless it is worth include the following:
a lot or has great sentimental value. Keep in mind • You discover that a major debt you
that most property is only exempt up to a certain thought was dischargeable isn’t. You don’t
value. Thus, even if you get the property back, the have enough other debts to justify your
trustee may decide to sell it, in which case you’ll bankruptcy case.
receive only the exempt amount from the proceeds. • You realize that an item of property you
thought was exempt isn’t. You don’t want to
Recapturing Garnished Funds lose it in bankruptcy.
• You come into a sum of money and can
When funds are garnished to pay a judgment, afford to pay your debts.
the garnishing agent typically holds on to the • You realize that you have more property in
money over several pay periods before giving it your estate than you thought and decide
to the creditor. If you file for bankruptcy while that you don’t have to file for bankruptcy
the agent is holding funds, they will be put in after all.
an escrow account pending further notice from
• Your bankruptcy case turns out to be more
the bankruptcy trustee. If you are able to claim
complex than you originally thought. You
the funds as exempt, the bankruptcy trustee will
need a lawyer, but you don’t have the money
“abandon” any claim to the funds, and you will be
to hire one.
entitled to receive them when the trustee files a
• You made transfers before filing for
notice of abandonment or your bankruptcy case is
bankruptcy, you learn that these transfers
over.
will likely be undone by the trustee, and
Some trustees notify the garnishing agent
you want to avoid that result.
that they have abandoned their claim to the funds;
others don’t send any notice, but simply allow the
• You learn that the trustee will require you
funds to be abandoned automatically when your to close your business, and you won’t be
case is closed. If your trustee doesn’t send a notice, able to survive under those conditions.
you should send your own letter to the garnishing • The emotional stress of bankruptcy is too
agent explaining that you claimed the funds as much for you.
exempt, the bankruptcy trustee abandoned the It is within the court’s discretion to dismiss
funds by not asserting jurisdiction over them your case. That means the court can grant or refuse
during your bankruptcy, and you are now the the d ismissal. How courts make this decision
rightful owner of the funds. This will usually do varies from district to district. In some districts,
the trick. If not, you’ll have to obtain a court order dismissing a case is next to impossible if your
either by filing a complaint against the garnishing bankruptcy estate has assets that can be sold for the
agent or by filing a motion (courts follow different benefit of your creditors. However, if you have few
procedures in this situation). assets the trustee could take and no creditor objects
to the dismissal, you may have better luck getting it
dismissed.
If you want to dismiss your case, you must
file a request with the court. Instructions on how
to do this are in Appendix D. Depending on
276 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
how receptive your local bankruptcy court is to to provide formal notice to the other parties in
dismissal, you may need the help of a lawyer. your case. Instead, you just have to prepare and
file your request and an accompanying order, and
You Want to Reopen Your Case demonstrate that you have given written notice of
At several places in this book, we’ve suggested that your motion to the trustee and the U.S. Trustee.
you might have to reopen your case (for example, You don’t have to schedule a hearing; the judge will
to file a motion to avoid a lien you didn’t include consider your request and either grant or deny it
on your papers, or to file Form 23 proving that based solely on your paperwork. In Appendix D,
you completed budget counseling). To reopen we provide the forms necessary to ask the court to
your case, you must file what’s called an “ex parte reopen your case to allow you to file Form 23, and
motion.” This simply means that you don’t have to ask the court for a discharge.
l
11
C H A P T E R
Money judgments are almost always discharge sure whether you owe a debt, you should list
able in bankruptcy, no matter what circumstances it in your bankruptcy case to make sure it gets
led to the lawsuit in the first place or when the discharged.
judgment was obtained. There are a couple of
exceptions (discussed in “Debts That Survive Debts That Survive
Chapter 7 Bankruptcy,” below), but in the vast Chapter 7 Bankruptcy
majority of cases, money judgments are discharged.
Even liens on your home arising from a court Under bankruptcy law, there are several categories
money judgment can be cancelled if they interfere of debt that are “not dischargeable” in Chapter
with your homestead exemption. (See Ch. 7 for 7 (that is, you will still owe them after your
more on how bankruptcy affects a judicial lien on bankruptcy is final):
your home.) • Some debts can’t be discharged under any
circumstances.
Debts Arising From Car Accidents • Some will not be discharged unless you
Car accidents usually result in property damage convince the court that the debts fit within
and sometimes in personal injuries. Often, the a narrow exception to the rule.
driver who was responsible for the accident is • Some will not be discharged, but only if
insured and doesn’t have to pay personally for the the creditor convinces the court that they
damage or injury. Sometimes, however, the driver shouldn’t be.
who was at fault either has no insurance or has
insurance that doesn’t cover everything. In that Are Secured Debts Dischargeable?
situation, the driver is financially responsible for
the harm. If you have a debt secured by collateral, bankruptcy
If the accident was the result of the debtor’s eliminates your personal liability for the underlying
negligence—careless driving or failing to drive debt—that is, the creditor can’t sue you to collect
in a prudent manner—the debt arising from the the debt itself. But bankruptcy doesn’t eliminate
accident can be discharged in bankruptcy. The debt the creditor’s hold, or “lien,” on the property that
might also qualify for discharge even if it resulted served as collateral under the contract. The same
from reckless driving. If, however, the accident is true of secured debts that you haven’t entered
was the result of the driver’s willful and malicious into voluntarily, often arising as a result of a lawsuit
act (defined in “Debts Not Dischargeable in judgment or an enforcement action by the IRS on
Bankruptcy If the Creditor Successfully Objects,” taxes that are old enough to be discharged (covered
below). In these cases, too, bankruptcy gets rid of
below) or the result of drunk driving that causes
the underlying debt, but may not eliminate a lien
personal injury, it will not be discharged in
placed on your property by the IRS or a judgment
bankruptcy.
creditor.
Other Obligations
The sections above outline the most common
debts that are discharged in bankruptcy, but this
Debts Not Dischargeable Under
isn’t an exhaustive list. Any obligation or debt
Any Circumstances
will be discharged unless it fits within one of
the exceptions discussed in “Debts That Survive There are certain debts that bankruptcy doesn’t
Chapter 7 Bankruptcy,” below. Even if you aren’t affect at all: You will continue to owe them just as
if you had never filed.
ChaPter 11 | After Your Bankruptcy | 281
• a determination by a child support Note that this rule doesn’t apply to debts
enforcement agency or other government arising from a separation agreement between
unit that is legally authorized to impose domestic partners. This is one example of many
support obligations. as to why civil unions do not provide the same
A support obligation that has been assigned benefits as marriage.
to a private entity for reasons other than
collection (for example, as collateral for a loan) Fines, Penalties, and Restitution
is dischargeable. This exception rarely applies, You can’t discharge fines, penalties, or restitution
however: Almost all assignments of support to that a federal, state, or local government has
government or private entities are made for the imposed to punish you for violating a law.
purpose of collecting the support. Examples include:
• fines or penalties imposed under federal
Other Debts Owed to a Spouse, election law
Former Spouse, or Child • charges imposed for time spent in a court
Under the old bankruptcy law, debts owed to a jail (In re Donohue, No. 05-01651 (N.D.
spouse or child, other than support that arose from Iowa 2006))
a divorce or separation, were discharged unless • fines for infractions, misdemeanors, or
the spouse or child appeared in court to object felonies
to the discharge. Under the 2005 bankruptcy • fines imposed by a judge for contempt of
law, this category of debt is now automatically court
nondischargeable if owed directly to the child • fines imposed by a government agency for
or ex-spouse. The most common of these types violating agency regulations
of debts is when one spouse agrees to assume • surcharges imposed by a court or agency for
responsibility for marital debt or promises to pay enforcement of a law
the other spouse in exchange for his or her share • restitution you are ordered to pay to victims
of the family home. These types of obligations in federal criminal cases, and
will now be nondischargeable if they are owed to • debts owed to a bail bond company as a
a spouse, former spouse, or child, and arose out result of bond forfeiture.
of “a divorce or separation or in connection with However, one court has held that a restitution
a separation agreement, divorce decree, or other obligation imposed on a minor in a juvenile court
order of a court of record, or a determination made proceeding can be discharged, because it isn’t
in accordance with State or territorial law by a punitive in nature. (In re Sweeney, 341 B.R. 35
governmental unit.” (11 U.S.C. § 523 (15).) (10th Cir. BAP 2006).)
Importantly, your obligation to pay debts like
these is discharged in respect to the creditor. If the Court Fees
creditor tries to collect the debt from your former If you are a prisoner, you can’t discharge a fee
spouse, however, your former spouse can go after imposed by a court for filing a case, motion,
you for repayment because your obligation to complaint, or appeal, or for other costs and
him or her cannot be discharged. In other words, expenses assessed for that court filing, even if you
even though the creditor cannot collect from you claimed that you were unable to afford the fees.
directly, the creditor may still have a right to collect (You can discharge these types of fees in Chapter
from your ex—who still has a right to collect from 13, however.)
you.
ChaPter 11 | After Your Bankruptcy | 283
See an Expert
Different Rules Apply Out West
Consult with a lawyer about discharging
If you try to discharge your student loans in your loan. There are dozens of court cases that interpret
one of the federal courts that make up the 9th the three factors from the Brunner case or explain what
Circuit Court of Appeals (which includes Alaska, the “totality of the circumstances” include. Debtors
Arizona, California, Hawaii, Idaho, Montana, lose most of these cases, but sometimes they win. If
Nevada, Oregon, Utah, and Washington), a much you are filing for bankruptcy and you have substantial
wider variety of factors might be considered. student loan debt, you should talk to an attorney who is
Circumstances that could potentially allow a knowledgeable on these issues.
discharge include:
• The debtor or debtor’s dependent has a
serious mental or physical disability, which Can Your School Withhold
prevents employment or advancement. Your Transcript?
• The debtor has an obligation to care for
dependents. If you don’t pay back loans obtained directly
• The debtor has a lack of, severely limited, or from your college, the school can withhold your
poor quality education. transcript. But if you file for bankruptcy and receive
• The debtor has a lack of usable or market a discharge of the loan, the school can no longer
able job skills. withhold your records. (In re Gustafson, 111 B.R.
• The debtor is underemployed. 282 (9th Cir. BAP 1990).) In addition, while your
• The debtor’s income potential in his or her bankruptcy case is pending, the school cannot
chosen field has maxed out, and the debtor withhold your transcript, even if the court eventually
has no more lucrative job skills. rules your school loan nondischargeable. (Loyola
• The debtor has limited work years remaining University v. McClarty, 234 B.R. 386 (E.D. La. 1999).)
in which to pay back the loan.
• The debtor’s age or other factors prevent
retraining or relocation as a means of
earning more to repay the loan. Regular Income Taxes
• The debtor lacks assets that could be used People who are considering bankruptcy because of
to repay the loan. tax problems are almost always concerned about
• The debtor’s potentially increasing expenses income taxes they owe to the IRS or the state
outweigh any potential appreciation in the equivalent. There is a myth afoot that income tax
debtor’s assets or increases in the debtor’s debts can never be discharged in bankruptcy. This
income. is not true, however, if the debt is relatively old
• The debtor lacks better financial options and you can meet several other conditions. Tax
elsewhere. debts that qualify under these rules are technically
See Educational Credit Management Corp. v.
discharged; however, the IRS may continue to try
Nys, 446 F.3d 938 (9th Cir. 2006).
to collect the debt until you file a complaint in the
bankruptcy court to determine dischargeability of
the debt and receive an order from the court that
the debt is discharged.
Income tax debts are dischargeable if you meet
all of these conditions:
• You filed a legitimate (nonfraudulent) tax
return for the tax year or years in question.
ChaPter 11 | After Your Bankruptcy | 287
If the IRS completes a Substitute for Return You’re probably safe if you do not receive a
on your behalf that you neither sign nor formal notice of assessment of federal taxes
consent to, your return is not considered from the IRS within that 240-day period. If
filed. (See In re Bergstrom, 949 F.2d 341 you’re unsure of the assessment date, consider
(10th Cir. 1991).) seeing a tax lawyer—but don’t rely on the
• The debt stems from a tax return (not a IRS for the date. If the IRS gives you the
Substitute for Return) that you actually wrong date—telling you that the 240 days
filed at least two years before you filed for have elapsed—the IRS won’t be held to it if
bankruptcy. it turns out to be wrong. (See, for example,
• The tax return for the liability you wish to In re Howell, 120 B.R. 137 (9th Cir. BAP
discharge was first due at least three years 1990).) Under the 2005 bankruptcy law, the
before you filed for bankruptcy. (If you get 240-day period is extended by the period
an extension on the filing date, the three- of time collections were suspended because
year period begins on the extended due you were negotiating with the IRS for an
date, not the original due date.) offer in compromise or because of a previous
• The IRS or state taxing agency has not bankruptcy.
assessed your liability for the taxes within
Example: Fred filed a tax return in August
the 240 days before you filed for bankruptcy.
2009 for the 2008 tax year. In March
The IRS views certain facts as red flags of possible • using a foreign bank account
willful tax evasion. They include: • changing name or spelling of name; changing
• membership in a tax protest organization Social Security number
• a pattern of unfiled returns • an altercation with a revenue officer
• filing a fraudulent, frivolous, blank, or • engaging in money laundering
incomplete return • withdrawing cash from bank and hiding it
• repeatedly understating income or overstating • claiming incorrect number of exemptions on
deductions on returns tax return
• serial failure to pay taxes • purchasing property in someone else’s name
• concealing, giving away, or trading away • refusing to cooperate with a revenue officer or
valuable assets or transferring title deliberately obstructing audit or investigation.
• selling assets way below fair value (especially to • losing, concealing, or destroying financial
insiders) documents
• setting up abusive trust or sham tax shelter and • maintaining inadequate records
transferring assets to it • concealing actual residence address or business
• creating a corporation and transferring assets address
to it • trading valuable assets for less valuable assets
• changing bank or bank account frequently • devising clever schemes (such as divorcing your
• closing bank account and conducting business wife, directing all income to her, and renting a
in cash only room in her house), and
• adding another person’s name to bank account • living a lavish lifestyle knowing that delinquent
• depositing income in another’s bank account taxes had not been paid.
288 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
2011, the IRS audited Fred’s 2008 return and penalties and interest of $12,000. Jill
and assessed a tax due of $8,000. In May files for bankruptcy in January 2012. Because
2012, Fred files for bankruptcy. The taxes Jill didn’t file a return for 2005, she can’t
that Fred wishes to discharge were for tax discharge the tax, even though it became due
year 2008. The return for those taxes was more than three years past (and more than
due on April 15, 2009, more than three 240 days have elapsed since the taxes were
years prior to Fred’s filing date. The tax assessed). Jill may be able to discharge the IRS
return was filed in August 2009, more than penalties for failure to file a tax return and
two years before Fred’s bankruptcy filing failure to pay the tax. Or course, the IRS is
date, and the assessment date of March likely to argue that she cannot discharge the
2011 was more than 240 days before the penalties, and some courts will agree.
filing date. Fred can discharge those taxes.
• You didn’t willfully evade payment of a tax. If You Borrow Money to Pay
What constitutes willful tax evasion is a Nondischargeable Debts
subjective matter, depending on the view of
the IRS personnel making the judgment. Debts incurred to pay nondischargeable taxes
See “Willful Evasion of Tax,” above, for will also be nondischargeable. If you borrowed
a list of factors that may cause the IRS to money or used your credit card to pay taxes that
would otherwise not be discharged, you can’t
suspect willful tax evasion.
eliminate that loan or credit card debt in a Chapter
7 bankruptcy. In other words, you can’t turn a
Tip nondischargeable tax debt into a dischargeable tax
Get an account transcript to make sure debt by putting it on your credit card. This is true
you’ve got the dates right. If you want to make sure for any type of nondischargeable tax owed to a
you have met all the requirements to get a tax debt governmental agency.
discharged, you can obtain an account transcript from However, credit card companies may not
the IRS. To find out how, visit www.irs.gov and type come after you for this type of debt. Even if a debt
“account transcript” in the search box. is not dischargeable under this rule, the creditors
may not know it. In many Chapter 7 bankruptcy
If you meet each of these five requirements, your cases, credit card lenders don’t scrutinize their
personal liability for the taxes should be discharged. records to find out exactly what you paid for with
However, any lien placed on your property by the a particular card. Even if you did use the card to
taxing authority will remain after your bankruptcy. pay a tax, the underlying tax debt would have to
The result is that the taxing authority can’t go after be nondischargeable (which would require some
your bank account or wages, but you’ll have to pay analysis by the credit card entity’s staff).
off the lien before you can sell your real estate with a On the other hand, if you obtained a loan
clear title. for the specific purpose of paying a tax, you can
Penalties and interest on taxes that are dis count on the lender knowing this rule and relying
chargeable are also dischargeable. If the underlying on it to continue its collection efforts after your
tax debt is nondischargeable, courts are split as to bankruptcy.
whether you can discharge the penalties or not. Debts you take on to pay nondischargeable
debts can be discharged in Chapter 13 bankruptcy.
Example: Jill failed to file a tax return for See Ch. 3 for more information on debts that are
2005. In 2009, the IRS discovers Jill’s failure dischargeable only in Chapter 13.
and in January 2011 assesses taxes of $5,000
ChaPter 11 | After Your Bankruptcy | 289
Debts Not Dischargeable in Bankruptcy • You wrote a check for something and
If the Creditor Successfully Objects stopped payment on it, even though you
Four types of debts may survive Chapter 7 kept the item.
bankruptcy if, and only if: For this type of debt to be nondischargeable,
• the creditor files a formal objection—called your deceit must be intentional, and the creditor
a Complaint to Determine Dischargeability must have relied on your deceit in extending credit.
—during the bankruptcy proceedings, and Again, these are facts that the creditor has to prove
• the creditor proves that the debt fits into before the debt will be ruled nondischargeable by
one of the categories discussed below. the court.
Debts from a false written statement about
your financial condition. If a creditor proves that
Tip you incurred a debt by making a false written
Creditors might not bother to object. Even statement, the debt isn’t dischargeable. Here are the
though bankruptcy rules give creditors the right to object rules:
to the discharge of certain debts, many creditors—and • The false statement must be written—for
their attorneys—don’t fully understand this right. Even instance, made on a credit application,
a creditor who knows the score might sensibly decide to
rental application, resume, or balance sheet.
write off the debt rather than contesting it. It can cost a
• The false statement must have been
lot to bring a dischargeability action (as this type of case is
“material”—that is, it was a potentially
known). If the debt isn’t huge, a cost benefit analysis might
significant factor in the creditor’s decision to
show that it will be cheaper to forgo collecting the debt
extend you credit. The two most common
than to fight about it in court.
types of materially false statements are
omitting debts and overstating income.
Debts Arising From Fraud • The false statement must relate to your
financial condition or the financial
In order for a creditor to prove that one of your
condition of an “insider”—a person close to
debts should survive bankruptcy because you
you or a business entity with which you’re
incurred it through fraud, the debt must fit one of
associated.
the categories below.
• The creditor must have relied on the false
Debts from intentionally fraudulent behavior. If
statement, and the reliance must have been
a creditor can show that a debt resulted from your
reasonable.
dishonest act, and that the debt wouldn’t have
• You must have intended to deceive the
arisen had you been honest, the court probably
creditor. This is extremely hard for the
will not let you discharge the debt. Here are some
creditor to prove based simply on your
examples:
behavior. The creditor would have to show
• You rented or borrowed an expensive item
outrageous behavior on your part, such as
and claimed it was yours, so you could use
adding a “0” to your income (claiming you
it as collateral to get a loan.
make $180,000 rather than $18,000) on a
• You got a loan by telling the lender you’d
credit application.
pay it back when you had no intention of
Recent debts for luxuries. If you run up more
doing so.
than $550 in debt to any one creditor for luxury
• You wrote a check against insufficient funds
goods or services within the 90 days before you file
but assured the merchant that the check was
for bankruptcy, the law presumes that your intent
good.
was fraudulent regarding those charges. Therefore,
290 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
the charges will survive your bankruptcy unless Debts From Embezzlement, Larceny,
you prove that your intent wasn’t fraudulent. or Breach of Fiduciary Duty
“Luxury goods and services” do not include things A debt incurred as a result of embezzlement, larceny,
that are reasonably necessary for the support and or breach of fiduciary duty is not dischargeable if the
maintenance of you and your dependents (what creditor successfully objects to its discharge.
that means is decided on a case-by-case basis). “Embezzlement” means taking property
Recent cash advances. If you get cash advances entrusted to you for another and using it for
from any one creditor totaling more than $825 yourself. “Larceny” is another word for theft.
under an open-ended consumer credit plan within “Breach of fiduciary duty” is the failure to live
the 70 days before you file for bankruptcy, the debt up to a duty of trust you owe someone, based on
is nondischargeable. “Open-ended” means there’s a relationship where you’re required to manage
no date when the debt must be repaid, but rather, property or money for another, or a relationship
as with most credit cards, you may take forever that is close and confidential. Common fiduciary
to repay the debt as long as you pay a minimum relationships include those between:
amount each month. • spouses
• business partners
Debts Arising From Debtor’s • corporations and LLCs and their officers
Willful and Malicious Acts • business entities and their creditors
If the act that caused the debt was willful and • attorney and client
malicious (that is, you intended to inflict a specific • estate executor and beneficiary
injury to a person or property), the debt isn’t • in-home caregiver and recipient of services,
dischargeable if the creditor successfully objects. and
However, perhaps because they don’t know their • guardian and ward.
rights, creditors often don’t object in this situation.
Generally, crimes involving intentional injury Debts or Creditors You Don’t List
to people or damage to property are considered In your bankruptcy paperwork, you must list all
willful and malicious acts. Examples are assaults, of your creditors and provide their most current
rape, intentionally setting fire to a house (arson), or addresses. This gives the court some assurance
vandalism. that everyone who needs to know about your
Your liability for personal injury or property bankruptcy will receive notice. As long as you do
damage the victim sustained in these types of cases your part, the debt will be discharged (as long as
will almost always be ruled nondischargeable—but it’s otherwise dischargeable under the rules), even
(once again) only if the victim-creditor objects if the official notice fails to reach the creditor for
during your bankruptcy case. Other acts that some reason beyond your control. For example,
would typically be considered to be willful and if your notice doesn’t get to the creditor because
malicious include: the post office errs or the creditor moves without
• kidnapping leaving a forwarding address, that won’t count
• deliberately causing extreme anxiety, fear, or against you.
shock Suppose, however, that you forget to list a
• libel or slander, and creditor on your bankruptcy papers or carelessly
• illegal acts by a landlord to evict a tenant, misstate a creditor’s identity or address. In that
such as removing a door or changing the situation, the court’s notice may not reach the
locks. creditor and the debt may not be discharged. Here
are the rules:
ChaPter 11 | After Your Bankruptcy | 291
• If the creditor knew or should have known complaint any time after you file for bankruptcy.
of your bankruptcy through other means, Some courts may impose their own deadlines,
such as a letter or phone call from you, the however, so check your court’s local rules.
debt will be discharged even though the Suppose, for example, that you want to have
creditor wasn’t listed. In this situation, the a student loan discharged. As discussed above,
creditor should have taken steps to protect you will have to prove that it would be an undue
its interests, even though it didn’t receive hardship to repay the loan. You will file at least two
formal notice from the court. forms: a Complaint to Determine Dischargeability,
• If all of your assets are exempt—that is, stating the facts that make repayment an undue
you have a no-asset case—the debt will hardship, and a proof of service, showing that you
be discharged unless the debt is non served the complaint on the affected creditor and
dischargeable in any circumstances. In the trustee.
this situation, the creditor wouldn’t have
benefited from receiving notice because
CAUTION
there is no property to distribute. However,
Get help from a lawyer if you need it. Before
if the lack of notice deprives a creditor of
you charge off into court, here is a heartfelt warning:
the opportunity to successfully object to Embarking upon litigation in the bankruptcy court can
the discharge by filing a complaint in the be quite a challenge if you don’t have help from someone
bankruptcy court (such as for a fraudulent who has experience in the field. At the very least, you’ll
debt), the debt may survive your bankruptcy. want to obtain a copy of Represent Yourself in Court,
by Paul Bergman and Sara Berman (Nolo), and maybe
consult with a bankruptcy lawyer from time to time to
Disputes Over Dischargeability get your bearings. If your case is fairly straightforward—
If your debt is not one that’s automatically dis for example, a medical or similar condition is keeping you
charged, there may be a dispute over whether the from working enough to pay your student loan—you
debt should survive your bankruptcy. For example, may be able to proceed on your own. However, some
if the debt will survive bankruptcy unless the judge people find it stressful or uncomfortable to discuss their
orders otherwise, the burden is on you to file and own medical or other problems in court. If you think
litigate a Complaint to Determine Dischargeability. this might be difficult for you, consider filing your own
Or, if the debt will be discharged unless the judge bankruptcy case and hiring a lawyer to handle only this
procedure.
orders otherwise, the creditor must prove that the
debt should not be discharged, and you might have
to defend yourself in court against the creditor’s
Complaint to Determine Dischargeability. Creditor Objections to Discharges
If you are defending against a creditor’s claim
Complaints to Determine that a debt should not be discharged, you and the
Dischargeability trustee will be served with a copy of the complaint.
To defend against the objection, you must file a
If you want to have a student loan or tax debt
written response within a specified time limit,
wiped out (if the IRS doesn’t recognize your right
respond to any requests for information that the
to discharge it), you will have to prove to the court
creditor sends you, and be prepared to present
that you meet all of the requirements for discharge.
your case in court through declarations (written
To do this, you must file a formal complaint with
statements under oath) and possibly live witnesses.
the bankruptcy court. Generally, you can file your
292 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
If the debt is one of the types that will be The fact that the creditor has the burden of
discharged unless the creditor objects, the creditor proof in this type of case doesn’t mean that you
has the burden of proving that the debt fits within should sit back and do nothing. You should be
the specified category. For instance, if the creditor prepared with proof of your own to show that the
claims that the debt arose from a “willful and creditor’s allegations in the complaint are not true
malicious injury” you caused, the creditor will (unless, of course, you already admitted your guilt
have to prove that your actions were willful and in a prior case).
malicious. Similarly, if the creditor is arguing that
a particular debt arose from your fraudulent acts, Objections on the Basis of
the creditor will have to prove that all the required Credit Card Fraud
elements of fraud were present. Absent this type
of specific proof, the bankruptcy court will reject These days, the creditors most likely to object
the creditor’s lawsuit and maybe even award you to the discharge of a debt are credit card issuers.
attorneys’ fees (if you use an attorney). Except for charges made shortly before filing for
Keep in mind, however, that if you plead guilty bankruptcy, there are few specific rules about
to a criminal charge involving fraud, a document what constitutes credit card fraud in bankruptcy.
from the court showing your conviction may be But courts are looking to the following factors to
all that’s n
ecessary to convince the judge to rule determine fraud:
the debt nondischargeable. A no-contest plea, on • Timing. A short time between incurring
the other hand, would not have the same effect, the charges and filing for bankruptcy may
because that type of plea can’t be used as evidence suggest fraudulent intent.
in a later civil case (such as a bankruptcy case). • Manipulation of the system. Incurring more
In a civil case that resulted in a judgment debt after consulting with an attorney
prior to the bankruptcy filing, the judgment can may lead a judge to conclude that you
sometimes determine the outcome of the Complaint ran up your debts in anticipation of your
to Determine Dischargeability. This will depend bankruptcy filing.
on whether the civil court (or jury) made specific • Amount. Recent charges of more than
findings of misconduct that meet the requirements $550 for luxuries will be presumed to be
set out above (for example, for fraud). fraudulent.
• Crafty use of the card. Multiple charges
Example: Ben sues Francis in civil court under $50 (to avoid preclearance of the
for breach of contract. The jury finds that charge by the credit card issuer) when
Francis owes Ben $10,000 for failing to repay you’ve reached your credit limit will start to
a loan, Francis made deliberate and fraudulent look like fraud.
misrepresentations with the intent to trick Ben • Deliberate misuse. Charges after the card
into lending the money in the first place, and issuer has ordered you to return the card or
Ben is entitled to punitive damages because sent several “past due” notices don’t look
of these fraudulent statements. Francis files good.
for bankruptcy and tries to discharge this • Last-minute sprees. Changes in the way you
debt. Because the jury found that Francis use the card (for instance, much travel after
committed fraud of the type that precludes a sedentary life), charges for luxuries, and
the discharge of the debt in bankruptcy, multiple charges on the same day could lead
however, the bankruptcy judge honors the to problems.
prior judgment and rules that the debt cannot
be discharged.
ChaPter 11 | After Your Bankruptcy | 293
• Bad-faith use. Charges made when you were the creditor he or she was considering
clearly insolvent and unable to make the bankruptcy and had talked to an attorney
required minimum payment (for instance, about it).
because you lost your job and had no other A rapid increase in spending, followed by
■■
income or savings) are a no-no. Banks claim 60–90 days without activity.
that insolvency is evidenced by any of the The date noted on any attorney’s fee state
■■
If you are facing a dischargeability action over a credit ■■ The debtor had a reduction in income.
card debt, you’ll have an opportunity to send written ■■ The debtor formed the intent not to repay
questions (called interrogatories) to the company, to this debt.
be answered under oath. Here are some you might ■■ The debtor violated the terms of the credit
considering asking: agreement.
• You (the card issuer) have alleged that the ■■ State whether you believe that every user of a
debtor obtained funds from you by false credit card who does not later repay the debt
pretenses and false representations. Please has committed fraud.
state with particularity the nature of the false ■■ If the answer to the preceding question is no,
pretenses and false representations. state all facts that give rise to allegations of
• State all steps taken by you, the card issuer, to fraud in this debtor’s use of the card.
determine the creditworthiness of the debtor. After receiving a list of questions like these,
• Identify all means that you, the card issuer, used the credit card issuer is likely to conclude that you
to verify the debtor’s income, expenses, assets, are s erious about defending yourself. It might even
or liabilities. Identify any documents obtained withdraw its complaint.
in the verification process. If you want to read cases supporting the debtor’s
• Identify your general policies concerning the position when a credit card issuer claims fraud, visit
decision to grant credit and how those policies a law library or search the Internet for some of these
were applied to the debtor. cases:
• You have alleged that at the time the debtor • In re Hearn, 211 B.R. 774 (N.D. Ga. 1997)
obtained credit from you, the debtor did • In re Etto, 210 B.R. 734 (N.D. Ohio 1997)
not intend to repay it. State all facts in your • In re Hunter, 210 B.R. 212 (M.D. Fla. 1997)
possession to support this allegation. • In re Davis, 176 B.R. 118 (W.D. N.Y. 1994)
• Identify all credit policies you allege were • In re Kitzmiller, 206 B.R. 424 (N.D. W.Va. 1997)
violated by the debtor. State how such policies • In re Christensen, 193 B.R. 863 (N.D. Ill. 1996)
were communicated to the debtor, and identify • In re Chinchilla, 202 B.R. 1010 (S.D. Fla. 1996)
all documents that contained those policies. • In re Grayson, 199 B.R. 397 (W.D. Mo. 1996), and
• Identify the dates on which you claim any of the • In re Vianese, 195 B.R. 572 (N.D. N.Y. 1995).
following events occurred: For tips on doing your own legal research, see
■■ The debtor consulted a bankruptcy attorney. “Legal Research” in Ch. 12.
294 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
under your state’s laws, and how you can Attempts to Collect Clearly
protest. You can protest a garnishment if it Discharged Debts
isn’t justified or causes you hardship. To
protest, you’ll have to file a document in If a creditor tries to collect a debt that clearly was
the state court. That document goes by discharged in your bankruptcy, you should respond
different names in different states. In New at once with a letter like the one shown below.
York, for example, it’s called a Discharge Again, you can assume a debt was discharged
of Attachment; in California, it’s a Claim if you listed it in your bankruptcy papers, the
of Exemption. If you do protest, the creditor didn’t successfully object to its discharge,
state court must hold a hearing within a and it doesn’t fall into one of the nondischargeable
reasonable time, where you can present categories listed above. And, if yours was a no-asset
evidence as to why the court should not case, you can assume the debt was discharged even
enforce the garnishment. The court may not if the debt wasn’t listed. If you live in a community
agree, but it’s certainly worth a try. property state and your spouse filed alone, your
Protesting a wage garnishment creditors will likely also treat your share of the
is usually a relatively straightforward community debts as discharged.
procedure. Because states are required to
tell you how to proceed, you’ll probably be Letter to Creditor
able to handle it without the assistance of a
lawyer. 1905 Fifth Road
N. Miami Beach, FL 35466
Most states also have procedures
for objecting to other types of property March 18, 20xx
garnishments, such as a levy of a bank Bank of Miami
account. You’ll have to do a bit of research 2700 Finances Hwy
at a law library to learn the exact protest Miami, FL 36678
procedure, which is generally similar to To Whom It May Concern:
the one for protesting a wage garnishment.
I’ve been contacted once by letter and once by
(See Ch. 12 for tips on doing your own
phone by Rodney Moore of your bank. Mr. Moore
research.)
claims that I owe $4,812 on Visa account number
1234 567 890 123.
Dealing With Difficult Debts
As you’re well aware, this debt was discharged
After Bankruptcy
in bankruptcy on February 1, 20xx. Thus, your
For some debts, such as taxes, child support, and collection efforts violate federal law, 11 U.S.C. § 524.
alimony, exempt property may be taken, and a If they continue, I won’t hesitate to pursue my legal
garnishment protest will do little good. Don’t be rights, including bringing a lawsuit against you for
surprised if the U.S. Treasury Department initially harassment.
garnishes nearly 100% of your wages to pay back Sincerely,
federal income taxes. The best strategy here is to Dawn Schaffer
attempt to negotiate the amount down, not to Dawn Schaffer
fight the taxing agency’s right to garnish in the first
place.
ChaPter 11 | After Your Bankruptcy | 299
If a debt was discharged, the law prohibits policy or death benefit plan within 180 days
creditors from filing a lawsuit, sending you after you filed for bankruptcy.
collection letters, calling you, withholding credit, • You deliberately failed to report property
and threatening to file or actually filing a criminal that you had when you filed (for example, a
complaint against you. commission that was due but not yet paid
If the collection efforts don’t immediately stop, when you filed).
you’ll likely need the assistance of a lawyer to write • Before your case was closed, you refused to
the creditor again and, if that doesn’t work, to sue obey an order of the bankruptcy court or,
the creditor for harassment. If the creditor sues you for a reason other than the privilege against
over the debt, you’ll want to raise the discharge self-incrimination, you refused to answer an
as a defense and sue the creditor yourself to stop important question asked by the court.
the illegal collection efforts. The bankruptcy court For the court to revoke your discharge on the
has the power to hold the creditor in contempt basis of fraud, the trustee or creditor must file a
of court. The court may also fine the creditor complaint within one year of your discharge. For
for the humiliation, inconvenience, and anguish the court to revoke your discharge on the basis of
you suffered, and order the creditor to pay your your fraudulent failure to report property or your
attorneys’ fees. (See, for example, In re Barbour, refusal to obey an order or answer a question, the
77 B.R. 530 (E.D. N.C. 1987), where the court complaint must be filed either within one year
fined a creditor $900 for attempting to collect a of your discharge or before your case is closed,
discharged debt.) whichever is later. You’re entitled to receive a copy
You can bring a lawsuit to stop collection of the complaint and to respond, and the court
efforts in state court or in the bankruptcy court. must hold a hearing on the matter before deciding
Bankruptcy courts are often more familiar with the whether to revoke your discharge.
prohibitions against collection and may be more If your discharge is revoked, you’ll owe your
sympathetic to you. If the creditor sues you (almost debts, just as if you’d never filed for bankruptcy.
certainly in state court), you or your attorney can Any payment your creditors received from the
file papers requesting that the case be transferred to trustee, however, will be credited against what you
the bankruptcy court. owe.
of the bankruptcy filing date). However, Example: When Laverne files for
income earned after your filing date is not Chapter 7 bankruptcy in 2011, she owns
part of your bankruptcy estate. a house valued at $300,000. Laverne
owes approximately $250,000 (on a
Example: Phil operates an organic pear
first mortgage for $175,000 and second
farm as a sole proprietor. Shortly after he
mortgage for $75,000), leaving her
sells his crop for $30,000, the buyer of
with $50,000 equity in the house. The
the pears files for Chapter 11 bankruptcy,
exemption laws available to Laverne allow
and Phil isn’t paid when he expected to
her to exempt $50,000 for any home
be. Because Phil borrowed the money to
she is living in, so Laverne doesn’t worry
produce the crop in the first place, and
about losing her house in bankruptcy;
because he is overwhelmed with other
all of her equity in the house is protected
personal and business debts, Phil files
when she files for bankruptcy. As it
for Chapter 7 bankruptcy. While the
turns out, however, property in Laverne’s
farm and Phil’s personal property are all
neighborhood is appreciating by 15% a
protected under California exemption
year (which started in late 2010). Instead
laws, the $30,000 Phil had coming
of closing Laverne’s case on schedule, the
from the buyer is not. Phil receives his
trustee keeps Laverne’s case open for an
Chapter 7 discharge in a timely manner
additional year, and then sells the house
(60 days after the creditors’ meeting),
for $350,000. After the lienholders are
but the trustee keeps his case open in the
paid off and Laverne is given a check for
hopes that he can recover some part of
her exemption claim ($50,000), the trustee
the money due Phil from the pear buyer’s
makes off with $50,000, less the costs of
Chapter 11 bankruptcy estate. Once the
sale.
trustee decides that he’s gotten as much as
he can from the buyer’s Chapter 11 estate, • The trustee tries to “reverse pierce” the
he closes Phil’s case. corporate veil and collect personal debts from
your corporation or LLC. The trustee may be
• Property you have is likely to appreciate in
able to access assets in a corporation, LLC,
the short term. Back in the days of rapidly
or partnership in extreme circumstances,
rising real estate prices, trustees and courts
even if the business has more than one
took the position that the trustee was
owner. When one person, or a small group
entitled to the amount by which property
of related or closely associated people,
appreciated while the case was open. For
have complete control over a corporation
example, if the debtor’s equity in his or her
or LLC, and the corporation or LLC has
home was fully exempt when the debtor
been used in questionable ways (perhaps it
filed for bankruptcy, but the debtor’s home
has recklessly borrowed and lost money or
appreciated in value by $20,000 during
perpetrated financial fraud), a trustee can
the bankruptcy proceedings, the trustee
try to “reverse pierce” the corporation’s or
would likely argue that any nonexempt
LLC’s veil of liability protection—similar
appreciation belonged to the bankruptcy
to the “piercing of a corporate veil”
estate, not the debtor. Although this
discussed in Ch. 1. In this situation, the
scenario has become less likely, it could
separate nature of the corporation or
arise once the real estate market begins to
LLC won’t protect it from your personal
improve.
ChaPter 11 | After Your Bankruptcy | 301
debts. If personal and business funds were v. Pennsylvania Housing Finance Co., 876 F.2d
commingled, the corporation or LLC was 1090 (3rd Cir. 1989), and Toth v. Michigan State
inadequately capitalized, or corporate or Housing Development A uthority, 136 F.3d 477 (6th
LLC formalities were neglected, the trustee Cir. 1998).) Still, the government cannot use your
might be able to dissolve the business and bankruptcy as a reason to:
sell the assets attributable to the bankruptcy • deny you a contract, such as a contract for a
filer in order to pay off the bankruptcy filer’s construction project
creditors. This is fairly rare and reserved for • deny you or refuse to renew your state
situations where the corporation or LLC has liquor license
committed fraud. • deny you a job or fire you
Although debtors are always notified of their • deny you or terminate your public benefits
discharge, they seldom receive notice that their • evict you from public housing (although if
case is closed. Check with the court about a month you have a Section 8 voucher, you may not
after you get your discharge to see whether your be protected)
case is closed. If it isn’t, send the trustee a letter • withhold your college transcript, or
demanding that it be closed. While the trustee isn’t • deny you a driver’s license.
required to go along with your request, you will In addition, lenders may not exclude you from
have put it on record that your case is open and government-guaranteed student loan programs. (11
you believe it should be closed. At the very least, U.S.C. § 525(c).)
this will require the trustee to justify keeping your In general, once any government-related debt
case open. In some cases, attorneys have actually has been discharged, all acts against you that arise
sought and obtained a court order requiring closure out of that debt also must end. If, for example, you
of the case. lost your driver’s license because you didn’t pay
a court judgment resulting from a car accident,
Postbankruptcy Discrimination you must be granted a license once the debt is
discharged. If your license was also suspended
Although declaring bankruptcy has serious because you didn’t have insurance, you may not get
consequences, it might not be as bad as you think. your license back until you meet the requirements
There are laws that will protect you from most set forth in your state’s financial responsibility law.
types of postbankruptcy discrimination by the If, however, the judgment wasn’t discharged,
government and by private employers. you can still be denied your license until you pay
up. If you and the government disagree about
Government Discrimination
whether or not the debt was discharged, see
All federal, state, and local governmental units are “Postbankruptcy Attempts to Collect Debts,”
prohibited from denying, revoking, suspending, above.
or refusing to renew a license, permit, charter, Keep in mind that only government denials
franchise, or other similar grant solely because based on your bankruptcy are prohibited. You may
you filed for bankruptcy. (11 U.S.C. § 525(a).) be denied a loan, job, contract, bid, or apartment
This law provides important protections, but for reasons unrelated to the bankruptcy. This
it does not insulate debtors from all adverse includes denials for reasons related to your future
consequences of filing for bankruptcy. Lenders, creditworthiness—for example, because the
for example, can consider your bankruptcy filing government concludes you won’t be able to repay a
when reviewing an application for a government Small Business Administration loan.
loan or extension of credit. (See, for example, Watts
302 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
If you decide to seek bankruptcy relief, you can represent yourself, you can hire an
attorney to represent you, or you can get help in some localities from a bankruptcy
petition preparer who is not an attorney. THE LAW REQUIRES AN ATTORNEY
OR BANKRUPTCY PETITION PREPARER TO GIVE YOU A WRITTEN CONTRACT
SPECIFYING WHAT THE ATTORNEY OR BANKRUPTCY PETITION PREPARER WILL
DO FOR YOU AND HOW MUCH IT WILL COST. Ask to see the contract before you
hire anyone.
The following information helps you understand what must be done in a routine
bankruptcy case to help you evaluate how much service you need. Although
bankruptcy can be complex, many cases are routine. Before filing a bankruptcy case,
either you or your attorney should analyze your eligibility for different forms of debt
relief available under the Bankruptcy Code and which form of relief is most likely
to be beneficial for you. Be sure you understand the relief you can obtain and its
limitations.
To file a bankruptcy case, documents called a Petition, Schedules and Statement
of Financial Affairs, as well as in some cases a Statement of Intention need to be
prepared correctly and filed with the bankruptcy court. You will have to pay a filing
fee to the bankruptcy court. Once your case starts, you will have to attend the
required first meeting of creditors where you may be questioned by your creditors.
If you choose to file a chapter 7 case, you may be asked by a creditor to reaffirm a
debt. You may want help deciding whether to do so. A creditor is not permitted to
coerce you into reaffirming your debts.
If you choose to file a chapter 13 case in which you repay your creditors what you
can afford over 3 to 5 years, you may also want help with preparing your chapter
13 plan and with the confirmation hearing on your plan which will be before a
bankruptcy judge.
If you select another type of relief under the Bankruptcy Code other than chapter 7
or chapter 13, you will want to find out what should be done from someone familiar
with that type of relief.
Your bankruptcy case may also involve litigation. You are generally permitted
to represent yourself in litigation in bankruptcy court, but only attorneys, not
bankruptcy petition preparers, can give you legal advice.
ChaPter 12 | Help beyond the book | 307
What a Bankruptcy Petition typed and organized in a way that will sail past
Preparer Can Do for You the court clerk and satisfy the trustee. Because
BPPs can’t provide legal advice, however, you are
BPPs are very different from lawyers. BPPs are pro responsible for getting the information you need to
hibited from giving you legal advice, which under make important choices and comply with the basic
11 U.S.C. § 110(e) includes information such as: bankruptcy procedures.
• whether to file a bankruptcy petition or
which chapter (7, 11, 12, or 13) is appropriate
How Bankruptcy Petition
• whether your debts will be discharged
under a particular chapter of bankruptcy
Preparers Are Regulated
• whether you will be able to hang on to Anyone can be a BPP. Yes, anyone. There is
your home or other property if you file nothing in the bankruptcy code that requires BPPs
under a particular chapter (that is, which to have any particular level of education, training,
exemptions you should choose) or experience. Unlike most other jobs, a prison
• information about the tax consequences of record is no handicap to becoming a BPP. How,
a case brought under a particular chapter then, are BPPs regulated? Regulation is provided
or whether tax claims in your case can be by the U.S. Trustee’s office, which reviews all
discharged bankruptcy petitions prepared by a BPP. BPPs must
• whether you should offer to repay or agree provide their name, address, telephone number,
to reaffirm a debt and Social Security number on the bankruptcy
• how to characterize the nature of your petition, as well as on every other bankruptcy
interest in property or debts, and document they prepare. The U.S. Trustee uses this
• information about bankruptcy procedures information to keep tabs on BPPs.
and rights. BPPs are also regulated at the creditors’
meeting, where the bankruptcy trustee can ask
Fees you about the manner in which the BPP conducts
his or her business. For instance, if you are
All fees charged by debt relief agencies are reviewed representing yourself, the trustee might ask how
by the U.S. Trustee for reasonableness. However, you got the information necessary to choose your
unlike lawyers’ fees, which can vary widely accord exemptions (see Ch. 6) or how you decided which
ing to the circumstances, a BPP’s fees usually are bankruptcy chapter to use.
subject to a strict cap, somewhere between $125 If the BPP provided you with this information,
and $200, depending on the district. The rationale the trustee may refer the case to the U.S. Trustee’s
offered by the U.S. Trustee for this cap—and by office, and the BPP will be hauled into court to
the courts that have upheld it—is that BPP fees explain why he or she violated the rules against
can be set according to what general typists charge giving legal advice. The BPP may be forced to
per page in the community. Because BPPs aren’t return the fee you paid and may even be banned
supposed to be doing anything other than “typing” from practicing as a BPP, if it’s not the first
the forms, the argument goes, they shouldn’t be offense. In some circumstances, the BPP may
able to charge the rates professional services can even be forced to pay you up to $2,000 for their
command. transgression, as explained below. None of this will
Rates allowed for BPPs are far less than lawyers have any effect on your case, however, other than
charge. For that reason, BPPs are a good choice the inconvenience of being dragged into court and
for people who want some help getting their forms the possibility of being awarded damages.
308 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
own case. Under this arrangement, you are still Bankruptcy Lawyers
representing yourself, but you are combining
legal and secretarial resources to get the job done. Bankruptcy lawyers (a type of debt relief agency
The attorney is providing what is known as an under the new law) are regular lawyers who
unbundled legal service: The attorney performs specialize in handling bankruptcy cases. Before
a discrete task (providing some legal advice, for 2005, it was usually possible to find an affordable
example) rather than the whole enchilada we bankruptcy lawyer who would provide at least a
know as “legal representation.” For instance, for a minimal level of representation throughout your
one-time flat fee, the Affordable Attorney Advice case. However, for the reasons discussed below,
service operated by Stephen Elias (a coauthor of lawyers are charging a lot more to represent clients
this book) provides legal information and advice in bankruptcies filed under the 2005 Bankruptcy
over the phone to California small business owners Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act
filing for Chapter 7 bankruptcy with the assistance (BAPCPA).
of a BPP. The contract for, and information about,
this service can be obtained directly from most When You May Need a Lawyer
California BPPs.
With the help of this book, your Chapter 7
bankruptcy should sail through without a hitch.
A Bankruptcy Petition Preparer However, there are some situations in which you
Cannot Represent You may need some help from a bankruptcy lawyer:
If you decide to use a BPP, remember that you are • Your average gross income during the six
representing yourself and are responsible for the months before you file is more than your
outcome of your case. This means that you must state’s median income, and it looks like you
not only learn your rights under the bankruptcy won’t be able to pass the means test. (See
law and understand the proper procedures to be Ch. 2 and Ch. 9 for more information on
followed, but also accept responsibility for correctly these calculations.)
and accurately filling in the bankruptcy petition • You want to continue operating your
and schedules. If, for example, you lose your home business during your bankruptcy case, but
because it turned out to be worth much more the trustee wants to shut you down and
than you thought, and the homestead exemption liquidate your business.
available to you didn’t cover your equity, you can’t • You are the sole or majority owner of a
blame the BPP. Nor can you blame the BPP if the corporation or an LLC, and you need
trustee takes your business assets or shuts your information on what will happen to the
business down while trying to figure out what you company’s assets if you file a personal
own and whether it can be taken for your creditors. Chapter 7 bankruptcy case.
Unless you hire a lawyer to represent you, you are • You want to get rid of a student loan or
solely responsible for acquiring the information income tax debt that won’t be wiped out
necessary to competently pursue your case—and, in bankruptcy unless you convince a court
as a small business owner, you will probably need that it should be discharged.
more information than the typical Chapter 7 • A creditor files a lawsuit in the bankruptcy
bankruptcy filer. court claiming that one of your debts
should survive your bankruptcy because
you incurred it through fraud or other
misconduct.
310 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
• The trustee seeks to have your whole make sure that your documents are complete and
bankruptcy dismissed because you didn’t accurate, get all your paperwork filed on time, and
give honest and complete answers to generally handle all of the little details that go into a
questions about your assets, liabilities, and successful bankruptcy case. Although representation
economic transactions. comes at a price—which can be considerable,
• The U.S. Trustee asks the court to dismiss especially for business owners—you will have the
your case—or force you into Chapter peace of mind of knowing that someone is watching
13—because your income is high enough your back. While we obviously believe that many
to fund a Chapter 13 repayment plan, or small business owners can handle their own Chapter
because the trustee believes that your filing 7 bankruptcies, it isn’t right for everyone, especially
is an abuse of the Chapter 7 bankruptcy if your previous business transactions are complex or
process for other reasons. your business will have to close down once you file
• You have recently given away or sold for Chapter 7 bankruptcy. Or, you may have other
valuable property for substantially less than significant sources of stress in your life or just not
it is worth. feel up to handling it all by yourself.
• You went on a recent buying spree with
your credit card (especially if you charged Full-Service Lawyer Representation
more than $550 on luxury goods within the
past 90 days or obtained a cash advance of In a general sense, a lawyer represents you if you
more than $850 in the past 70 days). contract with the lawyer to handle some or all
• You want help negotiating with a creditor of your bankruptcy case. There are two types of
or the bankruptcy court, and the amount representation—the type where you hire a lawyer to
involved justifies hiring a bankruptcy assume complete responsibility for your bankruptcy,
lawyer to assist you. and the type where you represent yourself but
• You have a large lien on your property hire a lawyer to handle one particular aspect of
because of a court judgment against you, your bankruptcy case. We refer to the first type of
and you want to remove the lien in your representation as “full-service representation” and
bankruptcy case. the second type of representation as “unbundled
• A creditor is asking the court to allow it to services” (discussed below).
proceed with its collection action despite When providing full-service representation, a
your bankruptcy filing (for instance, a bankruptcy lawyer is responsible for making sure
creditor wants to foreclose on your house that all of your paperwork is filed on time and that
because you are behind on your mortgage the information in your paperwork is accurate.
payments). These duties require the lawyer to review various
• You are being evicted by your landlord documents—for instance, your business records,
because you have fallen behind on your rent business and personal credit reports, tax returns,
or lease payments. and home value appraisal—to make sure both that
Even if you aren’t facing one of these complica your paperwork is accurate and that you are filing
tions, you may still want a lawyer’s help. If you for bankruptcy under the appropriate chapter.
find the thought of going through the process Under the new law, if your paperwork is inaccurate
overwhelming, a lawyer can take charge of your or you filed under Chapter 7 bankruptcy when you
case and relieve you of the responsibility to get should have filed under Chapter 13, the lawyer can
everything done. The lawyer can accompany be fined a hefty amount and be required to return
you to the creditor’s meeting, work with you to your fees.
ChaPter 12 | Help beyond the book | 311
In exchange for their basic fee, full-service yourself, even though this increases the risk that
bankruptcy lawyers typically are obligated under the creditor will win. If, however, the dispute is
their contracts to provide the routine services worth $1,000 and the attorney will charge $200,
associated with a Chapter 7 bankruptcy. Their hiring the attorney makes better sense.
contracts also typically provide for additional fees Unfortunately, many bankruptcy attorneys do
for nonroutine work (See “Fees” below.) not like to appear or do paperwork on a piecemeal
Sometimes, a case appears to be simple at the basis. Justified or not, these attorneys believe that
beginning but starts looking more complicated by doing a little work for you, they might be on the
later on. In that event, you might start out hook if something goes wrong in another part of
representing yourself but later decide to hire an your case—that is, if they are in for a penny, they
attorney to handle a tricky issue that arises. are in for a pound. Also, the bar associations of
some states frown on unbundled services on ethical
Unbundled Services grounds. On the other hand, a number of other
state bar associations are starting to encourage
Although many people represent themselves because their attorneys to offer unbundled services simply
they simply can’t afford full-attorney representation, because so many people—even middle-income
they still may need to hire a lawyer to help out with people—are unable to afford full representation.
some aspect of the case. When lawyers do specific
jobs at a client’s request but don’t contract for full-
service representation in the underlying case, they
Bankruptcy Consultants
are providing an unbundled service. For example, Many small business owners will be able to
you may be able to hire an attorney to handle a represent themselves with this book as their main
specific procedure—such as to defend against a source of information. As explained throughout
motion for relief from stay—while you handle the this book, this will depend on how complex
main part of the bankruptcy yourself. This may your business transactions have been over the
require some shopping around; not all lawyers are past several years, how you have structured your
willing to offer unbundled services. business, and the type of business you operate.
Few court cases discuss the boundaries of Fortunately, in many cases, it’s still just a matter
unbundled services. Some courts have held that of knowing what to put on the forms and which
attorneys can’t “ghostwrite” legal documents for forms to file. For many people, however, a book
nonlawyers—because that would be a type of just won’t do the trick, no matter how well written
fraud on the court—but the issue has not been and complete: They want to talk to a human
decided in most states. Also, nothing prevents a being. Because of unauthorized practice laws and
lawyer from appearing for you in a limited capacity restrictions in the bankruptcy law, however, there is
and putting his or her own name on associated only one kind of human being who is authorized to
documents. answer your questions about bankruptcy law and
Lawyers providing unbundled services usually procedure: a lawyer.
charge an hourly fee. As a general rule, you should Fortunately, there are lawyers who provide
bring an attorney into the case for an unbundled bankruptcy consultations (a category of unbundled
service only if a dispute involves something service) for a transaction fee (for example, a $100
valuable enough to justify the attorney’s fees. If a flat rate) or a fee based on the amount of time your
creditor objects to the discharge of a $500 debt, call takes (for example, $3 a minute). There are also
and it will cost you $400 to hire an attorney, you free consultations offered by private attorneys and
may be better off trying to handle the matter bar associations. Similar services—free and paid—
312 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
are available on the Internet. To find a telephonic some bankruptcy attorneys who are both
or online consultation service, in addition to those competent and sympathetic to self-helpers.
mentioned here, go to your favorite search engine It is here that you are most likely to find a
and look for bankruptcy legal advice telephone or good referral to attorneys who are willing to
Internet. Internet lawyer directories are another deliver unbundled services, including advice
good resource. For example, Nolo’s online lawyer over the telephone.
directory, at www.nolo.com/ldir/findlawyer.do, • Legal aid. Legal aid offices are partially
provides detailed information about each lawyer’s funded by the federal Legal Services
practice and philosophy, including the bankruptcy Corporation and offer legal assistance in
lawyer’s willingness to consult with self-helpers. many areas. A few offices do bankruptcies,
Even if you are using this book and hiring a although most do not. To qualify for legal
BPP to help with your paperwork, you may wish to aid, you must have a very low income.
talk to a lawyer to get the information you need to • Legal clinic. Many law schools sponsor legal
make your choices and tell the BPP what you want clinics and provide free legal advice to con
in your papers. For instance, a BPP can’t choose sumers. Some legal clinics have the same
your exemptions for you, because that would be income requirements as legal aid; others
considered the practice of law—something only offer free services to low- and moderate-
lawyers can do. However, a lawyer can help you income people.
decide which exemptions to pick so you can tell • Group legal plans. If you’re a member of a
the BPP what to put in the form that lists your plan that provides free or low-cost legal
exemptions. assistance and the plan covers bankruptcies,
As with other debt relief agencies, lawyers make that your first stop in looking for a
offering telephonic services are considered debt lawyer.
relief agencies and will have to offer you a contract • Lawyer-referral panels. Most county bar
detailing their services and provide the other associations will give you the names of
notices described above. bankruptcy attorneys who practice in your
area. But bar associations may not provide
How to Find a Bankruptcy Lawyer much screening. Take the time to check out
the credentials and experience of the person
Where there’s a bankruptcy court, there are to whom you’re referred.
bankruptcy lawyers. They’re listed in the yellow • Internet directories. Both bar associations
pages under “Attorneys” and often advertise and private companies provide lists of
in newspapers. You should use an experienced bankruptcy lawyers on the Internet, with
bankruptcy lawyer, not a general practitioner, to a lot more information about the lawyer
handle or advise you on matters associated with than you’re likely to get in a yellow pages
bankruptcy. ad. A good place to start is Nolo’s lawyer’s
There are several ways to find the best bank directory, www.nolo.com/ldir/findlawyer.do
ruptcy lawyer for your job:
• Personal referrals. This is your best approach.
If you know someone who was pleased with
Fees
the services of a bankruptcy lawyer, call For a Chapter 7 bankruptcy involving a small
that lawyer first. business, a full-service lawyer will likely charge
• Bankruptcy petition preparers. If there’s you somewhere between $2,000 and $3,000 (plus
a BPP in your area, he or she may know the $299 filing fee), depending on the state you
ChaPter 12 | Help beyond the book | 313
are filing in, whether you are in a rural or urban the line, you may be charged $2,000 or more in
setting, and the complexity of your case. You will anticipation of the extra work.
almost always have to pay the attorney in full Other attorneys will happily just charge you
before the attorney will file your case: Once you file their standard fee up front and wait until after you
your Chapter 7 bankruptcy, any money you owe file to charge you for the extra work. Because these
the attorney is discharged along with your other fees are earned after your bankruptcy filing, they
dischargeable unsecured debts. won’t be discharged in your bankruptcy and the
On your bankruptcy papers, you must state the attorney need not collect them up front. However
amount you are paying your bankruptcy lawyer. the attorney charges you, you are protected against
Because every penny you pay to a bankruptcy fee gouging. An attorney must file a supplemental
lawyer is a penny not available to your creditors (at Rule 2016 form to obtain the court’s permission for
least in theory), the court has the legal authority to any fees charged for work after your bankruptcy
make the attorney justify his or her fee. This rarely filing.
happens, however, because attorneys know the
range of fees generally allowed by local bankruptcy What to Look for in a Lawyer
judges, and set their fees accordingly. This means
that you probably won’t find much variation in the No matter how you find a lawyer, these three
amounts charged by lawyers in your area (although suggestions will help you make sure you have the
it never hurts to shop around). best possible working relationship.
The scope and range of services that the First, fight any urge you may have to surrender
attorney promises you in return for your initial fee to, or be intimidated by, the lawyer. You should
will be listed in what’s called a Rule 2016 Attorney be the one who decides what you feel comfortable
Fee Disclosure Form. This form is filed as part of doing about your legal and financial affairs. Keep
your bankruptcy papers. In the typical Chapter in mind that you’re hiring the lawyer to perform
7 case, the attorney’s fee will include the routine a service for you, so shop around if the price or
tasks associated with a bankruptcy filing, such personality isn’t right.
as counseling, preparing and filing the necessary Second, make sure you have good chemistry
bankruptcy forms, negotiating reaffirmation and with any lawyer you hire. When making an
other agreements with your secured creditors, appointment, ask to talk directly to the lawyer.
and attending the creditors’ meeting. Any task If you can’t, this may give you a hint as to how
not included in the Rule 2016 disclosure form is accessible he or she is. Of course, if you’re told that
subject to a separate fee. a paralegal will be handling the routine aspects
If your case will likely require more attorney of your case under the supervision of a lawyer,
time than the basic fee covers, you may—and you may be satisfied with that arrangement. If
probably will—be charged extra, according to you do talk directly to a lawyer, ask some specific
the attorney’s hourly fee or other criteria he or questions. Do you get clear, concise answers? If
she uses. A typical bankruptcy attorney charges not, try someone else. Also, pay attention to how
between $200 and $300 an hour (rural and urban) the lawyer responds to your knowledge. If you’ve
and would charge a minimum of roughly $400 to read this book, you’re already better informed than
$600 for a court appearance. If they see the extra most clients (and some lawyers are threatened by
work coming, many attorneys will add these fees clients who have done their homework).
to their standard fee and require you to pay it all in Finally, once you find a lawyer you like, make
advance. For instance, if the attorney’s standard fee an hour-long appointment to discuss your situation
is $1,000, but the attorney sees extra work down fully. The lawyer or a paralegal in the lawyer’s
314 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
office will tell you what to bring to the meeting, if Legal Research: How to Find & Understand the Law,
anything (if not, be sure to ask ahead of time). Some by Stephen Elias and the Editors of Nolo (Nolo),
lawyers will want to see a recent credit report and tax which provides a plain-English tutorial on legal
return, while others will send you a questionnaire research in the law library and on the Internet.
to complete prior to your visit. Depending on the
circumstances, you may also be asked to bring your Sources of Bankruptcy Law
bills and documents pertaining to your home and
other real estate you own. Some lawyers prefer not Bankruptcy law comes from a variety of sources:
to deal with details during the first visit, and will • federal bankruptcy statutes passed by
simply ask you to come as you are. Congress
Your main goal at the initial conference is • federal rules about bankruptcy procedure
to find out what the lawyer recommends in your issued by a federal judicial agency
particular case and how much it will cost. Go • local rules issued by individual bankruptcy
home and think about the lawyer’s suggestions. courts
If they don’t make sense or you have other • federal and bankruptcy court cases applying
reservations, call someone else. bankruptcy laws to specific disputes
• laws (statutes) passed by state legislatures
that define the property you can keep in
Tip
bankruptcy, and
Look for a member of the National • state court cases interpreting state exemption
Association of Consumer Bankruptcy Attorneys.
statutes.
Because of the massive changes enacted by the 2005
Not so long ago, you would have had to visit
bankruptcy law (BAPCPA), you will want to find an
a law library to find these resources. Now you can
attorney who has a means of keeping up to date
find most of them on the Internet. However, if
and communicating with other bankruptcy lawyers.
you are able to visit a decent-sized law library, your
Membership in the National Association of Consumer
research will be the better for it. Using actual books
Bankruptcy Attorneys (NACBA) is a good sign that your
allows you to more easily find and read relevant
lawyer will be tuned in to the nuances of the BAPCPA
and how courts are interpreting its provisions. Lawyers
court interpretations of the underlying statutes
in this group typically represent consumers rather than and rules—which can be crucial to getting a clear
businesses, but most know how to handle the business picture of what the laws and rules really mean.
aspects of a personal Chapter 7 bankruptcy case brought There is another important reason to visit
by a small business owner. Of course, if you can find a the law library, if possible. While you can find
bankruptcy lawyer who specializes in small business superficial discussions and overviews of various
bankruptcies, so much the better. aspects of bankruptcy on the Internet, you’ll find
in-depth encyclopedias and treatises in the law
library that delve into every aspect of bankruptcy.
In other words, you can find not only the law itself,
Legal Research but also what the experts have to say about all the
picky little issues that have arisen over the years.
Legal research can vary from the very simple to the
Also, books in a law library are almost always
hopelessly complex. In this section, we are staying
subjected to a rigorous quality control process—as
on the simple side. If you would like to learn
is this book—whereas you never know what you’re
more about legal research or if you find that our
getting on the Internet. To avoid getting lost
suggestions come up a bit short in your particular
in cyberspace, follow our suggestions below for
case, we recommend that you obtain a copy of
ChaPter 12 | Help beyond the book | 315
researching bankruptcy law online and avoid the a good overview of your state’s exemptions would
temptation to settle for the first hit in a Google get you started on the right track.
search. The most complete source of this type of
Below, we show you how to get to the resources background information is a set of books known
you’ll most likely be using, whether you are doing as Collier on Bankruptcy, by Lawrence P. King, et
your research on the Internet or in the law library. al. (Matthew Bender). It’s available in most law
libraries. Collier is both incredibly thorough and
Bankruptcy Background meticulously up to date; semiannual supplements,
Materials: Overviews, with all the latest developments, are in the front
of each volume. In addition to commentary on
Encyclopedias, and Treatises
every aspect of bankruptcy law, Collier contains the
Before digging into the primary law sources bankruptcy statutes, rules, and exemption lists for
(statutes, rules, cases, and so on that we discuss every state.
below), you may want to do some background Collier is organized according to the bank
reading to get a firm grasp of your issue or question. ruptcy statutes. This means that the quickest way
to find information in it is to know which statute
The Internet best addresses the issue you’re researching. (See the
A number of Internet sites contain large collections Bankruptcy Code sections set out below.) If you
of articles written by experts about various aspects still can’t figure out the governing statute, start
of bankruptcy. Good starting places are Nolo’s with the Collier subject matter index. Be warned,
website, www.nolo.com, and www.legalconsumer. however, that the index can be difficult to use
com, which offer lots of information and resources. because it contains a lot of bankruptcy jargon you
may be u nfamiliar with. The glossary at the back
The Law Library of this book will be a big help. In addition, an
Providing you with a good treatise or encyclopedia assortment of legal dictionaries will be available in
discussion of bankruptcy is where the law library the library.
shines. This type of resource is not typically
available online unless you find a way to access the Bankruptcy (National Edition)
expensive legal databases—Westlaw and Lexis— published by The Rutter Group
marketed almost exclusively to lawyers. Many law This four-volume set authored by Kathleen P.
libraries subscribe to either Westlaw or Lexis and March, Esq., and Judge Alan M. Ahart provides nice
provide these services for free to their patrons. crisp treatments of all the pesky little issues that can
arise in a bankruptcy case. Because of its relatively
Collier on Bankruptcy low cost (at least from a library’s standpoint; it goes
It’s a good idea to get an overview of your for $495), you are more likely to be able to find it in
subject b efore trying to find a precise answer to small county and court law libraries.
a precise question. The best way to do this is to
find a general commentary on your subject by Foreclosure Resources
a bankruptcy expert. For example, if you want If you are facing foreclosure, you’ll definitely want
to find out whether a particular debt will be to look at The Foreclosure Survival Guide, by Stephen
discharged in bankruptcy, you should start by Elias (Nolo). This book explains the options available
reading a general discussion about the type of debt to you, then walks you through the necessary steps
you’re dealing with. Or, if you don’t know whether for handling your particular situation. If you are
you’re entitled to claim certain property as exempt, looking for a more comprehensive resource written
316 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
The Law Library Once you have found and read the statute,
Virtually every law library has at least one you can browse the one-paragraph summaries
complete set of the annotated United States Code of written o pinions issued by courts that have
(“annotated” means that each statute is followed interpreted that particular statute. You will be
by citations and summaries of cases interpreting looking to see whether a court has addressed your
that provision). If you already have a citation to the particular issue. If so, you can find and read the
statute you are seeking, you can use the citation to entire case in the law library. Reading what a
find the statute. However, if you have no citation— judge has had to say about the statute regarding
which is frequently the case—you can use either facts similar to yours is an invaluable guide to
the index to Title 11 (the part of the Code that understanding how a judge is likely to handle the
applies to bankruptcy) or the table we set out just issue in your case, although when and where the
above, which matches various issues that are likely case was decided may be important.
to interest you with specific sections of Title 11.
318 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
Finding the Federal Rules of Court websites usually contain other helpful
Bankruptcy Procedure (FRBP) information as well, including case information,
official and local bankruptcy forms, court guide-
The Federal Rules of Bankruptcy Procedure lines (in addition to the local rules), information
govern what happens if an issue is contested in the for lawyers and BPPs, information about the court
bankruptcy court. They also apply to certain routine and its judges, and the court calendar.
bankruptcy procedures, such as deadlines for filing At the law library, the Collier Bankruptcy
paperwork. Because most cases sail through the Practice Manual has the local rules for most (if not
court without any need for the bankruptcy judge’s all) of the nation’s bankruptcy courts.
intervention, you may not need to be familiar with
these rules. However, certain types of creditor
Finding Federal Court
actions in the bankruptcy court must proceed by
way of a regular lawsuit conducted under both these
Bankruptcy Cases
rules and the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure—for Court opinions are vital to understanding how
example, complaints to determine dischargeability a particular law might apply to your individual
of a debt (see Chapter 10). If you are representing case. The following levels of federal courts issue
yourself in such a lawsuit, you’ll want to know these bankruptcy-related opinions:
rules and look at the cases interpreting them. Any • the U.S. Supreme Court
law library will have these rules. Your bankruptcy • the U.S. Courts of Appeals
court’s website will also have a link to the rules, as • the Bankruptcy Appellate Panels
does www.law.cornell.edu. • the U.S. District Courts, and
• the bankruptcy courts.
Finding Local Court Rules Most bankruptcy-related opinions are, not
surprisingly, issued by the bankruptcy courts. By
Every bankruptcy court operates under a set comparison, very few bankruptcy opinions come
of local rules that govern how it does business out of the U.S. Supreme Court. The other courts
and what is expected of the parties who use it. are somewhere in the middle.
Throughout this book, we have cautioned you to
read the rules for your particular court so that your The Internet
dealings with the court will go smoothly—and so Depending on the date the case was decided,
you won’t end up getting tossed out of court if you U.S. Supreme Court decisions and U.S. Court
become involved in litigation, such as an action of Appeals d ecisions are available for free on the
to determine the dischargeability of a debt or a Internet (discussed below). For $13.95 a month,
creditor’s motion to lift the automatic stay. you can also subscribe to VersusLaw (at www.
Your bankruptcy court clerk’s office will have versuslaw.com), which provides U.S. Court of
the local rules available for you. Most courts also Appeals cases for an earlier period than you can get
post their local rules on their own websites. To find for free—often back to 1925. VersusLaw doesn’t
the website for your court, take these steps: require you to sign a long-term contract. So, one
Step 1: Go to www.uscourts.gov/links.html. payment of $13.95 gets you a month’s worth of
Step 2: Click the number on the map that is closest research. Not too shabby. VersusLaw also publishes
to where you live. many U.S. District Court cases on its website.
Opinions by the bankruptcy courts are not yet
Step 3: Browse the list until you find your court
systematically available over the Internet, unless
and click on it.
you subscribe to one of the databases described
Step 4: Click on the local rules link.
ChaPter 12 | Help beyond the book | 319
below. However, more often than not, a Google Many U.S. District Court cases are published
search will drum up some recently decided cases in the Federal Supplement (F.Supp), a series
(typically because they appear on the court’s available in most law libraries.
website or in a bankruptcy blog). Written opinions of bankruptcy judges, and
U.S. Supreme Court. Google now has all related appeals, are published in the Bankruptcy
Supreme Court cases available online. Under Reporter (B.R.), available in most mid- to large-
“Advanced Search” on the Google home page, sized libraries. To accurately understand how your
choose “Google Scholar.” Then select “Legal bankruptcy court is likely to interpret the laws in
opinions and journals” and type in a case name. If your particular case, sooner or later you will need
you don’t know the case name and you don’t have a access to the Bankruptcy Reporter.
citation, enter some relevant words relating to your
issue and see what you pull up. State Statutes
U.S. Court of Appeals. Google now has federal
appeals cases going back to 1925. Under “Advanced The secret to understanding what property you can
Search” on the Google home page, choose “Google keep frequently lies in the exemptions that your
Scholar.” Then simply select “Legal opinions and state allows you to claim. These exemptions are
journals” and type in a case name. found in your state’s statutes.
Again, if you are looking for a case decided
The Internet
prior to 1925, your best bet is to sign up for
VersusLaw, d escribed just above. Every state has its statutes online, including its
U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court. Cases exemption statutes. This means that you can read
reported by the bankruptcy courts may not be your state’s exemption statutes for yourself. Follow
available to you online unless you subscribe to these steps:
Westlaw, Lexis, or FastCase (www.fastcase.com). Step 1: Go to Appendix A. At the top of your
However, if you know the name of a particular state’s exemption table, you’ll see a general
case, a Google search might lead you to a court’s reference to the collection of state laws
website, where judges frequently post their for your state that contain the exemption
decisions. statutes.
Step 2: Go to www.nolo.com; select “Legal
The Law Library
Research.”
U.S. Supreme Court cases are published in three
Step 3: Select “State Laws,” then find your state.
different book series:
• Supreme Court Reports Step 4: Locate the collection of statutes mentioned
• Supreme Court Reporter, and in Appendix A.
• Supreme Court Lawyer’s Edition. Step 5: Use the exemption citation to the far right
Some law libraries carry all three of these of your state’s exemption table to search for
publications; others have only one. The cases are the statute.
the same, but each series has different editorial
enhancements. The Law Library
U.S. Court of Appeals cases are published in Your law library will have your state’s statutes
the Federal Reporter (abbreviated simply as “F.”). in book form, usually referred to as your state’s
Most law libraries, large and small, carry this series. code, annotated statutes, or compiled laws. Use
Appendix A in this book to find a reference to
the e xemption statute you want to read, then use
320 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
T
he charts in this appendix summarize the CAUTION
laws that determine how much property These charts provide general information
debtors can keep when they file for only. There are exceptions to state exemption laws that
Chapter 7 bankruptcy. As you will see, the charts are much too detailed to include here. For example, even
are divided into categories of property, such as if an item is listed as exempt in one of these charts, you
might have to give it up to pay a child support or tax
insurance, personal property, and wages. Following
debt. Consider doing further legal research or consulting
each exemption, we list the numerical citation to
an attorney about the exemptions you plan to claim,
the state statute that includes the exemption. You’ll
particularly if you anticipate—or are facing—a challenge
need this information to complete your bankruptcy
to the value or types of property you want to keep.
forms, as explained in Ch. 6.
And, if valuable or cherished property is at stake, you
The states are listed alphabetically, followed
may want to consult a local lawyer or accountant who is
by the federal exemptions. (We also note the states
experienced in asset protection strategies.
that allow you to choose between the federal and
state bankruptcy exemptions—see Ch. 3 for more
information.) Residency Requirements for
Claiming State Exemptions
related topic
Prior to the new bankruptcy law, filers could
Need help understanding a term? Many of
use the exemptions of the state where they lived
the categories, types of property, and other terms used
in these charts are defined in the Glossary, which you’ll
when they filed for bankruptcy. Under the new
find right before this appendix. rules, however, some filers will have to use the
exemptions of the state where they used to live.
Congress was concerned about people gaming the
Doubling system by moving to states with liberal exemptions
just to file for bankruptcy. As a result, filers must
When married couples file for bankruptcy jointly,
now meet certain residency requirements before
federal law and the laws of many states allow each
they can use a state’s exemption system.
person to claim the full amount of an exemption.
Here is a summary of these new rules:
(11 U.S.C. § 522.) Because these couples get to
• If you have been domiciled (that is, made
claim twice the amount available to those who
your permanent home) in your current state
file alone, this practice is informally known as
for at least two years, you can use that state’s
“doubling.”
exemptions.
Not all states allow doubling, however.
• If you have been domiciled in your current
And some states allow married filers to double
state for more than 91 days but less than two
only certain exemptions (for example, they can
years, you must use the exemptions of the
double personal property exemptions but not the
state where you lived for the greater part of
homestead exemption). In the charts that follow,
the 180-day period immediately prior to the
we indicate exemptions that cannot be doubled
two-year period preceding your filing.
(and states that don’t allow doubling at all). Unless
• If you have been domiciled in your current
you see a note stating that you cannot double,
state for less than 91 days, you can either
assume that you can.
Appendix A | State and Federal exemption charts | 327
file in the state where you lived immediately homestead exemption available to you is larger. For
before (as long as you lived there for at least detailed information on homestead exemptions,
91 days) or wait until you have logged 91 days see Ch. 4.
in your new home and file in your current
state. Once you figure out where you can file,
you’ll need to use whatever exemptions are Retirement Accounts
available to you according to the rules set out Under the 2005 bankruptcy law, virtually all types
above. of tax-exempt retirement accounts are exempt in
• If the state you are filing in offers a choice bankruptcy, whether you use the state or federal
between the state and federal bankruptcy exemptions. You can exempt 401(k)s, 403(b)s,
exemptions, you can use the federal profit-sharing and money purchase plans, IRAs
exemption list regardless of how long you’ve (including Roth, SEP, and SIMPLE IRAs), and
been living in the state. defined-benefit plans.
• If these rules deprive you of the right to use These exemptions are unlimited—that is, the
any state’s exemptions, you can use the federal entire account is exempt, regardless of how much
exemption list. For example, some states allow money is in it—except in the case of traditional
their exemptions to be used only by current and Roth IRAs. For these types of IRAs only, the
state residents, which might leave former exemption is limited to a total value of $1,095,000
residents who haven’t lived in their new per person (this figure will be adjusted every three
home state for at least two years without any years for inflation). If you have more than one
available state exemptions. traditional or Roth IRA, you don’t get to exempt
For more detailed information and examples, $1,095,000 per account; your total exemption,
see Ch. 3. no matter how many accounts you have, is
A longer residency requirement applies to $1,095,000.
homestead exemptions: If you acquired a home If you are using the federal bankruptcy
in your current state within the 40 months before exemptions, you can find this new retirement
you file for bankruptcy (and you didn’t purchase account provision at 11 U.S.C. § 522(d)(12). If
it with the proceeds from selling another home you are using state exemptions, cite 11 U.S.C.
in that state), your homestead exemption will § 522(b)(3)(C) as the applicable exemption when
be subject to a cap of $136,875, even if the state you complete your bankruptcy papers.
328 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
public Adult assistance to elderly, blind, disabled 47.25.550 personal 2 beds & bedding; 1 living room chair per 33-1123
benefits Alaska benefits for low-income seniors 09.38.015(a)(11) property person; 1 dresser, table, lamp; kitchen table;
husband & dining room table & 4 chairs (1 more per per-
Alaska longevity bonus 09.38.015(a)(5) wife may son); living room carpet or rug; couch; 3 lamps;
Crime victims’ compensation 09.38.015(a)(4) double all 3 coffee or end tables; pictures, paintings, per-
Federally exempt public benefits paid or due 09.38.015(a)(6) personal
sonal drawings, family portraits; refrigerator,
property
General relief assistance 47.25.210 stove, washer, dryer, vacuum cleaner; TV, radio,
Senior care (prescription drug) benefits 09.38.015(a)(10) stereo, alarm clock to $4,000 total
20% of permanent fund dividends 43.23.065 Bank deposit to $150 in one account 33-1126(A)(9)
Unemployment compensation 09.38.015(b); Bible; bicycle; sewing machine; typewriter; 33-1125
23.20.405 burial plot; rifle, pistol, or shotgun to $500 total
Workers’ compensation 23.30.160 Books to $250; clothing to $500; wedding & 33-1125
tools of trade Implements, books, & tools of trade to $3,640 09.38.020(c) engagement rings to $1,000; watch to $100;
pets, horses, milk cows, & poultry to $500;
wages Weekly net earnings to $456; for sole wage 9.38.030(a),(b);
musical instruments to $250
earner in a household, $716; if you don’t receive 9.38.050(b)
weekly or semimonthly pay, you can claim Food & fuel to last 6 months 33-1124
$1,820 in cash or liquid assets paid any month; Funeral deposits to $5,000 32-1391.05(4)
for sole wage earner in household, $2,860 Health aids 33-1125(9)
wildcard None Motor vehicle to $5,000 ($10,000, if debtor is 33-1125(8)
physically disabled)
Arizona Prepaid rent or security deposit to $1,000 or 33-1126(C)
1½ times your rent, whichever is less, in lieu of
Federal bankruptcy exemptions not available. All law references are to Arizona
homestead
Revised Statutes unless otherwise noted.
Proceeds for sold or damaged exempt property 33-1126(A)(5),(8)
ASSET EXEMPTION LAW Wrongful death awards 12-592
homestead Real property, an apartment, or mobile home 33-1101(A) public Unemployment compensation 23-783(A)
you occupy to $150,000; sale proceeds exempt benefits Welfare benefits 46-208
18 months after sale or until new home
Workers’ compensation 23-1068(B)
purchased, whichever occurs first (husband &
tools of trade Arms, uniforms, & accoutrements of 33-1130(3)
wife may not double)
husband & profession or office required by law
May record homestead declaration to clarify 33-1102 wife may Farm machinery, utensils, seed, instruments of 33-1130(2)
which one of multiple eligible parcels is b eing double
husbandry, feed, grain, & animals to $2,500 total
claimed as homestead
Library & teaching aids of teacher 33-1127
insurance Fraternal benefit society benefits 20-877
Tools, equipment, instruments, & books to $2,500 33-1130(1)
Group life insurance policy or proceeds 20-1132
Health, accident, or disability benefits 33-1126(A)(4) wages 75% of earned but unpaid weekly net earnings 33-1131
or 30 times the federal minimum hourly wage;
Life insurance cash value or proceeds, or 33-1126(A)(6);
50% of wages for support orders; bankruptcy
annuity contract if owned at least two years 20-1131(D)
judge may authorize more for low-income
and beneficiary is dependent family member
debtors
Life insurance proceeds to $20,000 if 33-1126(A)(1)
wildcard None
beneficiary is spouse or child
miscellaneous Alimony, child support needed for support 33-1126(A)(3)
Minor child’s earnings, unless debt is for child 33-1126(A)(2) Arkansas
pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C. § 522(b) Federal bankruptcy exemptions available. All law references are to Arkansas Code
see also wages 401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money (3)(C) Annotated unless otherwise noted.
purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and Note: In re Holt, 894 F.2d 1005 (8th Cir. 1990) held that Arkansas residents are
defined-benefit plans limited to exemptions in the Arkansas Constitution. Statutory exemptions can
Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C. § 522(b) still be used within Arkansas for nonbankruptcy purposes, but they cannot be
person (3)(C); (n) claimed in bankruptcy.
Board of regents members, faculty & adminis- 15-1628(I)
ASSET EXEMPTION LAW
trative officers under board’s jurisdiction
homestead 1. For married person or head of family: Constitution 9-3;
District employees 48-227
choose unlimited exemption on real or personal 9-4, 9-5; 16-66-210;
ERISA-qualified benefits deposited over 120 33-1126(B) Option 1 or 2 property used as residence to ¼ acre 16-66-218(b)(3), (4);
days before filing in city, town, or village, or 80 acres In re Stevens, 829
IRAs & Roth IRAs 33-1126(B); elsewhere; if property is between ¼–1 F.2d 693 (8th Cir.
In re Herrscher, acre in city, town, or village, or 80–160 1987)
121 B.R. 29 (D. acres elsewhere, additional limit is $2,500;
Ariz. 1989) homestead may not exceed 1 acre in city,
Firefighters 9-968 town, or village, or 160 acres elsewhere
Police officers 9-931 (husband & wife may not double)
Rangers 41-955 2. Real or personal property used as resi- 16-66-218(a)(1)
State employees’ retirement & disability 38-792; 38-797.11 dence to $800 if single; $1,250 if married
330 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
insurance Annuity contract 23-79-134 not match the amounts that appear in the cited statutes. The current exemption
amounts can be found on the California Judicial Council website, www.courtinfo.
Disability benefits 23-79-133 ca.gov/forms/exemptions.htm.
Fraternal benefit society benefits 23-74-403
ASSET EXEMPTION LAW
Group life insurance 23-79-132
homestead Real or personal property you occupy includ- 704.710; 704.720;
Life, health, accident, or disability cash value 16-66-209; ing mobile home, boat, stock cooperative, 704.730;
or proceeds paid or due to $500 Constitution 9-1, community apartment, planned develop- In re McFall, 112
9-2; In re Holt, ment, or condo to $75,000 if single & not B.R. 336 (9th Cir.
894 F.2d 1005 (8th disabled; $100,000 for families if no other BAP 1990)
Cir. 1990) member has a homestead (if only one spouse
Life insurance proceeds if clause prohibits 23-79-131 files, may exempt one-half of amount if
proceeds from being used to pay beneficiary’s home held as community property & all of
creditors amount if home held as tenants in common);
Life insurance proceeds or avails if beneficiary 23-79-131 $175,000 if 65 or older, or physically or men-
isn’t the insured tally disabled; $175,000 if 55 or older, single,
& earn gross annual income under $15,000 or
Mutual assessment life or disability benefits 23-72-114
married & earn gross annual income under
to $1,000
$20,000 & creditors seek to force the sale of
Stipulated insurance premiums 23-71-112 your home; forced sale proceeds received
pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C. § 522(b) exempt for 6 months after (husband & wife
401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money (3)(C) may not double); separated married debtor
purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and may claim homestead in community prop-
defined-benefit plans erty homestead occupied by other spouse
Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)(3) May file homestead declaration to protect 704.920
person (C); (n) exemption amount from attachment of
Disabled firefighters 24-11-814 judicial liens and to protect proceeds of
voluntary sale for 6 months
Disabled police officers 24-11-417
insurance Disability or health benefits 704.130
Firefighters 24-10-616
Fidelity bonds Labor 404
IRA deposits to $20,000 if deposited over 16-66-218(b)(16)
1 year before filing for bankruptcy Fraternal benefit society benefits 704.170
Police officers 24-10-616 Fraternal unemployment benefits 704.120
School employees 24-7-715 Homeowners’ insurance proceeds for 704.720(b)
6 months after received, to homestead
State police officers 24-6-205; 24-6-223
exemption amount
personal Burial plot to 5 acres, if choosing federal 16-66-207;
property Life insurance proceeds if clause prohibits Ins. 10132;
homestead exemption (Option 2) 16-66-218(a)(1)
proceeds from being used to pay beneficiary’s Ins. 10170;
Clothing Constitution 9-1, creditors Ins. 10171
9-2
Matured life insurance benefits needed for 704.100(c)
Motor vehicle to $1,200 16-66-218(a)(2) support
Prepaid funeral trusts 23-40-117 Unmatured life insurance policy cash 704.100(b)
Wedding rings 16-66-219 surrender value completely exempt; loan
public Crime victims’ compensation 16-90-716(e) value exempt to $10,775
benefits Unemployment compensation 11-10-109 miscellaneous Business or professional licenses 695.060
Workers’ compensation 11-9-110 Inmates’ trust funds to $1,350 (husband & 704.090
wife may not double)
tools of trade Implements, books, & tools of trade to $750 16-66-218(a)(4)
Property of business partnership Corp. 16501-04
wages Earned but unpaid wages due for 60 days; in 16-66-208;
no event less than $25 per week 16-66-218(b)(6) pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)
401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money (3)(C)
wildcard $500 of any personal property if married or Constitution 9-1,
purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and
head of family; $200 if not married 9-2; 16-66-218(b)
defined-benefit plans
(1),(2)
Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)
person (3)(C); (n)
California—System 1
County employees Gov’t 31452
Federal bankruptcy exemptions not available. California has two systems; you
must select one or the other. All law references are to California Code of Civil County firefighters Gov’t 32210
Procedure unless otherwise noted. Many exemptions do not apply to claims for County peace officers Gov’t 31913
child support. Private retirement benefits, including IRAs & 704.115
Note: California’s exemption amounts are no longer updated in the statutes Keoghs
themselves. California Code of Civil Procedure Section 740.150 deputized the Public employees Gov’t 21255
California Judicial Council to update the exemption amounts every three years.
Public retirement benefits 704.110
(The next revision will be in 2010.) As a result, the amounts listed in this chart will
Appendix A | State and Federal exemption charts | 331
personal Appliances, furnishings, clothing, & food 704.020 miscellaneous Alimony, child support needed for support 703.140(b)(10)(D)
property Bank deposits from Social Security Adminis- 704.080 pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)
tration to $2,700 ($4,050 for husband & wife); 401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money (3)(C)
unlimited if SS funds are not commingled purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and
with other funds defined-benefit plans
Bank deposits of other public benefits to Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)(3)
$1,350 ($2,025 for husband & wife) per person (C); (n)
Building materials to repair or improve home 704.030 ERISA-qualified benefits needed for 703.140(b)(10)(E)
to $2,700 (husband & wife may not double) support
Burial plot 704.200 personal Animals, crops, appliances, furnishings, 703.140(b)(3)
Funds held in escrow Fin. 17410 property household goods, books, musical
Health aids 704.050 instruments, & clothing to $525 per item
Jewelry, heirlooms, & art to $6,750 total 704.040 Burial plot to $20,725, in lieu of homestead 703.140(b)(1)
(husband & wife may not double) Health aids 703.140(b)(9)
Motor vehicles to $2,550, or $2,550 in auto 704.010 Jewelry to $1,350 703.140(b)(4)
insurance for loss or damages (husband & Motor vehicle to $3,300 703.140(b)(2)
wife may not double) Personal injury recoveries to $20,725 (not 703.140(b)(11)(D),(E)
Personal injury & wrongful death causes of 704.140(a); to include pain & suffering; pecuniary loss)
action 704.150(a) Wrongful death recoveries needed for 703.140(b)(11)(B)
Personal injury & wrongful death recoveries 704.140(b),(c),(d); support
needed for support; if receiving installments, at 704.150(b),(c) public Crime victims’ compensation 703.140(b)(11)(A)
least 75% benefits Public assistance 703.140(b)(10)(A)
public Aid to blind, aged, disabled; public assistance 704.170
benefits Social Security 703.140(b)(10)(A)
Financial aid to students 704.190
Unemployment compensation 703.140(b)(10)(A)
Relocation benefits 704.180
Veterans’ benefits 703.140(b)(10)(B)
Unemployment benefits 704.120
tools of trade Implements, books, & tools of trade to 703.140(b)(6)
Union benefits due to labor dispute 704.120(b)(5) $2,075
Workers’ compensation 704.160 wages None (use federal nonbankruptcy wage
tools of trade Tools, implements, materials, instruments, 704.060 exemption)
uniforms, one commercial vehicle, books,
wildcard $1,100 of any property 703.140(b)(5)
furnishings, & equipment to $6,750 total
($13,475 total if used by both spouses in same Unused portion of homestead or burial 703.140(b)(5)
occupation) exemption of any property
Commercial vehicle (Vehicle Code § 260) to 704.060
$4,850 ($9,700 total if used by both spouses Colorado
in same occupation) (this counts toward total Federal bankruptcy exemptions not available. All law references are to Colorado
tools of trade exemption) Revised Statutes unless otherwise noted.
wages Minimum 75% of wages paid within 30 days 704.070 ASSET EXEMPTION LAW
prior to filing
homestead Real property, mobile home, manufactured 38-41-201;
Public employees’ vacation credits; if 704.113 home, or house trailer you occupy to $60,000; 38-41-201.6;
receiving installments, at least 75% $90,000 if owner, spouse, or dependent is 38-41-203;
wildcard None disabled or at least 60 years old; sale proceeds38-41-207;
exempt 2 years after received In re Pastrana,
California—System 2 216 B.R. 948
(D. Colo., 1998)
Refer to the notes for California—System 1, above.
Spouse or child of deceased owner may claim 38-41-204
Note: Married couples may not double any exemptions. (In re Talmadge, 832 F.2d homestead exemption
1120 (9th Cir. 1987); In re Baldwin, 70 B.R. 612 (9th Cir. BAP 1987).)
insurance Disability benefits to $200 per month; 10-16-212
ASSET EXEMPTION LAW if lump sum, entire amount exempt
homestead Real or personal property, including co‑op, 703.140(b)(1) Fraternal benefit society benefits 10-14-403
used as residence to $20,725; unused Group life insurance policy or proceeds 10-7-205
portion of homestead may be applied
Homeowners’ insurance proceeds for 1 year 38-41-209
to any property
after received, to homestead exemption
insurance Disability benefits 703.140(b)(10)(C) amount
Life insurance proceeds needed for support 703.140(b)(11)(C) Life insurance cash surrender value to $50,000, 13-54-102(1)(l)
of family except contributions to policy within past 48
Unmatured life insurance contract accrued 703.140(b)(8) months
avails to $11,075 Life insurance proceeds if clause prohibits 10-7-106
Unmatured life insurance policy other than 703.140(b)(7) proceeds from being used to pay beneficiary’s
credit creditors
332 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
tools of trade Arms, military equipment, uniforms, musical 52-352b(i) public Aid to blind 31-2309
instruments of military personnel benefits Aid to aged, disabled; general assistance 31-513
Tools, books, instruments, & farm animals 52-352b(b) Crime victims’ compensation 11-9011
needed Unemployment compensation 19-3374
wages Minimum 75% of earned but unpaid weekly 52-361a(f) Workers’ compensation 19-2355
disposable earnings, or 40 times the state or tools of trade Tools of trade and/or vehicle necessary for 10-4914(c)
federal hourly minimum wage, whichever is employment to $15,000 each
greater
Tools, implements, & fixtures to $75 in New 10-4902(b)
wildcard $1,000 of any property 52-352b(r) Castle & Sussex Counties; to $50 in Kent County
wages 85% of earned but unpaid wages 10-4913
Delaware wildcard $500 of any personal property, except tools of 10-4903
Federal bankruptcy exemptions not available. All law references are to Delaware trade, if head of family
Code Annotated (in the form title number-section number) unless otherwise
noted. District of Columbia
Note: A single person may exempt no more than $25,000 total in all exemptions Federal bankruptcy exemptions available. All law references are to District of
(not including retirement plans and principal residence); a husband & wife may Columbia Code unless otherwise noted.
exempt no more than $50,000 total (10-4914).
ASSET EXEMPTION LAW
ASSET EXEMPTION LAW homestead Any property used as a residence or co-op that 15-501(a)(14)
homestead Real property or manufactured home used as 10-4914(c) debtor or debtor’s dependent uses as a residence
principal residence to $50,000 (spouses may not Property held as tenancy by the entirety may be Estate of Wall,
double) exempt against debts owed by only one spouse 440 F.2d 215
Property held as tenancy by the entirety may be In re Kelley, 289 (D.C. Cir. 1971)
exempt against debts owed by only one spouse B.R. 38 (Bankr. insurance Disability benefits 15-501(a)(7);
D. Del. 2003) 31-4716.01
insurance Annuity contract proceeds to $350 per month 18-2728 Fraternal benefit society benefits 31-5315
Fraternal benefit society benefits 18-6218 Group life insurance policy or proceeds 31-4717
Group life insurance policy or proceeds 18-2727 Life insurance payments 15-501(a)(11)
Health or disability benefits 18-2726 Life insurance proceeds if clause prohibits 31-4719
proceeds from being used to pay beneficiary’s
Life insurance proceeds if clause prohibits 18-2729 creditors
proceeds from being used to pay beneficiary’s
Life insurance proceeds or avails 31-4716
creditors
Other insurance proceeds to $200 per month, 15-503
Life insurance proceeds or avails 18-2725 maximum 2 months, for head of family; else $60
pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C. per month
401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money § 522(b)(3)(C) Unmatured life insurance contract other than 15-501(a)(5)
purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and credit life insurance
defined-benefit plans
miscellaneous Alimony or child support 15-501(a)(7)
Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C. pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C.
person § 522(b)(3) see also wages 401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money § 522(b)(3)(C)
(C); (n) purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and
IRAs, Roth IRAs, & any other retirement plans 10-4915 defined-benefit plans
Kent County employees 9-4316 Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C.
person § 522(b)(3)
Police officers 11-8803
(C); (n)
State employees 29-5503
ERISA-qualified benefits, IRAs, Keoghs, etc. to 15-501(b)(9)
Volunteer firefighters 16-6653 maximum deductible contribution
personal Bible, books, & family pictures 10-4902(a) Any stock bonus, annuity, pension, or profit- 15-501(a)(7)
property sharing plan
Burial plot 10-4902(a)
Judges 11-1570(f)
Church pew or any seat in public place of 10-4902(a)
worship Public school teachers 38-2001.17;
38-2021.17
Clothing, includes jewelry 10-4902(a)
personal Appliances, books, clothing, household 15-501(a)(2)
College investment plan account (limit for year 10-4916 property furnishings, goods, musical instruments, pets to
before filing is $5,000 or average of past two $425 per item or $8,625 total
years’ contribution, whichever is more)
Cemetery & burial funds 43-111
Principal and income from spendthrift trusts 12-3536 Cooperative association holdings to $50 29-928
Pianos & leased organs 10-4902(d) Food for 3 months 15-501(a)(12)
Sewing machines 10-4902(c) Health aids 15-501(a)(6)
334 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
personal Higher education tuition savings account 47-4510 pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)(3)(C)
property Residential condominium deposit 42-1904.09 see also wages including 401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-
(continued) sharing and money purchase plans,
All family pictures; all the family library to $400 15-501(a)(8)
SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and defined-
Motor vehicle to $2,575 15-501(a)(1) benefit plans
Payment, including pain & suffering, for loss of 15-501(a)(11) Traditional and Roth IRAs to 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)(3)
debtor or person depended on $1,095,000 per person (C); (n)
Uninsured motorist benefits 31-2408.01(h) County officers, employees 122.15
Wrongful death damages 15-501(a)(11); ERISA-qualified benefits, including 222.21(2)
16-2703 IRAs & Roth IRAs
public Aid to blind, aged, disabled; general assistance 4-215.01 Firefighters 175.241
benefits Police officers 185.25
Crime victims’ compensation 4-507(e); 15-
501(a)(11) State officers, employees 121.131
Social Security 15-501(a)(7) Teachers 238.15
Unemployment compensation 51-118 personal Any personal property to $1,000 Constitution 10-4;
property (husband & wife may double); to In re Hawkins, 51 B.R.
Veterans’ benefits 15-501(a)(7)
$4,000 if no homestead claimed 348 (S.D. Fla. 1985)
Workers’ compensation 32-1517
Federal income tax refund or credit 222.25
tools of trade Library, furniture, tools of professional or artist 15-501(a)(13)
Health aids 222.25
to $300
Motor vehicle to $1,000 222.25
Tools of trade or business to $1,625 15-501(a)(5)
Pre-need funeral contract deposits 497.56(8)
Mechanic’s tools to $200 15-503(b)
Prepaid college education trust 222.22(1)
Seal & documents of notary public 1-1206
deposits
wages Minimum 75% of earned but unpaid wages, 16-572
Prepaid hurricane savings accounts 222.22(4)
pension payments; bankruptcy judge may
authorize more for low-income debtors Prepaid medical savings account 222.22(2)
deposits
Nonwage (including pension & retirement) 15-503
earnings to $200 per month for head of family; public Crime victims’ compensation, 960.14
benefits unless seeking to discharge debt for
else $60 per month for a maximum of two
months treatment of injury incurred during
the crime
Payment for loss of future earnings 15-501(e)(11)
Public assistance 222.201
wildcard Up to $850 in any property, plus up to $8,075 of 15-501(a)(3)
unused homestead exemption Social Security 222.201
Unemployment compensation 222.201; 443.051(2),(3)
Veterans’ benefits 222.201; 744.626
Florida
Workers’ compensation 440.22
Federal bankruptcy exemptions not available. All law references are to Florida
Statutes Annotated unless otherwise noted. tools of trade None
ASSET EXEMPTION LAW wages 100% of wages for heads of family up 222.11
to $500 per week either unpaid or
homestead Real or personal property including 222.01; 222.02; 222.03;
paid & deposited into bank account
mobile or modular home to unlimited 222.05; Constitution
for up to 6 months
value; cannot exceed half acre in 10-4
municipality or 160 acres elsewhere; In re Colwell, 196 F.3d Federal government employees’ 222.21
spouse or child of deceased owner 1225 (11th Cir. 1999) pension payments needed for support
may claim homestead exemption & received 3 months prior
May file homestead declaration 222.01 wildcard See personal property
Property held as tenancy by the Havoco of America, Ltd.
entirety may be exempt against debts v. Hill, 197 F.3d 1135 Georgia
owed by only one spouse (11th Cir. 1999) Federal bankruptcy exemptions not available. All law references are to the
insurance Annuity contract proceeds; does not 222.14; In re Pizzi, 153 Official Code of Georgia Annotated unless otherwise noted.
include lottery winnings B.R. 357 (S.D. Fla. 1993)
ASSET EXEMPTION LAW
Death benefits payable to a specific 222.13
homestead Real or personal property, including co-op, 44-13-100(a)(1);
beneficiary, not the deceased’s estate
used as residence to $10,000 (to $20,000 44-13-100(a)(6); In
Disability or illness benefits 222.18 if married and debtor spouse is sole re Burnett, 303 B.R.
Fraternal benefit society benefits 632.619 owner); up to $5,000 of unused portion of 684 (M.D. Ga. 2003)
Life insurance cash surrender value 222.14 homestead may be applied to any property
miscellaneous Alimony, child support needed for 222.201 insurance Annuity & endowment contract benefits 33-28-7
support Disability or health benefits to $250 per 33-29-15
Damages to employees for injuries in 769.05 month
hazardous occupations Fraternal benefit society benefits 33-15-62
Appendix A | State and Federal exemption charts | 335
tools of trade Implements, books, & tools of trade to 44-13-100(a)(7) public Crime victims’ compensation & special 351-66; 351-86
benefits accounts created to limit commercial
$1,500
exploitation of crimes
wages Minimum 75% of earned but unpaid weekly 18-4-20; 18-4-21
disposable earnings, or 40 times the state or Public assistance paid by Department of 346-33
federal hourly minimum wage, whichever Health Services for work done in home or
is greater, for private & federal workers; workshop
bankruptcy judge may authorize more for Temporary disability benefits 392-29
low-income debtors Unemployment compensation 383-163
wildcard $600 of any property 44-13-100(a)(6) Unemployment work relief funds to $60 653-4
Unused portion of homestead exemption 44-13-100(a)(6) per month
to $5,000 Workers’ compensation 386-57
336 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
tools of trade Tools, implements, books, instruments, 651-121(3) personal Burial plot 11-603(1)
uniforms, furnishings, fishing boat, nets, property College savings program account 11-604A(4)(b)
motor vehicle, & other property needed for (continued)
Crops cultivated on maximum of 50 acres, to 11-605(6)
livelihood
$1,000; water rights to 160 inches
wages Prisoner’s wages held by Department of 353-22.5
Health aids 11-603(2)
Public Safety (except for restitution, child
support, & other claims) Jewelry to $1,000 11-605(2)
Unpaid wages due for services of past 651-121(6) Motor vehicle to $5,000 11-605(3)
31 days Personal injury recoveries 11-604(1)(c)
wildcard None Proceeds for damaged exempt property for 11-606
3 months after proceeds received
pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)(3)(C) wildcard $4,000 of any personal property (does 735-5/12-1001(b)
including 401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing not include wages)
and money purchase plans, SEP and
SIMPLE IRAs, and defined-benefit plans
Indiana
Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)(3)
Federal bankruptcy exemptions not available. All law references are to Indiana
per person (C); (n)
Statutes Annotated unless otherwise noted.
Civil service employees 40-5/11-223
County employees 40-5/9-228 ASSET EXEMPTION LAW
Disabled firefighters; widows & children 40-5/22-230 homestead Real or personal property used as residence 34-55-10-2(c)(1)
see also to $15,000
of firefighters
wildcard
IRAs and ERISA-qualified benefits 735-5/12-1006 Property held as tenancy by the entirety may 34-55-10-2(c)(5);
Firefighters 40-5/4-135; 40-5/6-213 be exempt against debts incurred by only one 32-17-3-1
spouse
General Assembly members 40-5/2-154
House of correction employees 40-5/19-117 insurance Employer’s life insurance policy on employee 27-1-12-17.1
Judges 40-5/18-161 Fraternal benefit society benefits 27-11-6-3
Municipal employees 40-5/7-217(a); 40-5/8- Group life insurance policy 27-1-12-29
244
Life insurance policy, proceeds, cash value, 27-1-12-14
Park employees 40-5/12-190 or avails if beneficiary is insured’s spouse or
Police officers 40-5/3-144.1; 40-5/5-218 dependent
Public employees 735-5/12-1006 Life insurance proceeds if clause prohibits 27-2-5-1
Public library employees 40-5/19-218 proceeds to be used to pay beneficiary’s
Sanitation district employees 40-5/13-805 creditors
State employees 40-5/14-147 Mutual life or accident proceeds needed for 27-8-3-23; In re
State university employees 40-5/15-185 support Stinnet, 321 B.R.
Teachers 40-5/16-190; 477 (S.D. Ind.
40-5/17-151 2005)
personal Bible, family pictures, schoolbooks, & 735-5/12-1001(a) miscellaneous Property of business partnership 23-4-1-25
property clothing pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)
Health aids 735-5/12-1001(e) 401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money (3)(C)
Illinois College Savings Pool accounts 735-5/12-1001(j) purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and
invested more than 1 year before filing defined-benefit plans
if below federal gift tax limit, or 2 years
Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)
before filing if above
person (3)(C); (n)
Motor vehicle to $2,400 735-5/12-1001(c)
Firefighters 36-8-7-22
Personal injury recoveries to $15,000 735-5/12-1001(h)(4)
36-8-8-17
Pre-need cemetery sales funds, care 235-5/6-1; 760-100/4;
funds, & trust funds 815-390/16 Police officers 36-8-8-17;
10-12-2-10
Prepaid tuition trust fund 110-979/45(g)
Proceeds of sold exempt property 735-5/12-1001 Public employees 5-10.3-8-9
Wrongful death recoveries 735-5/12-1001(h)(2) Public or private retirement benefits & 34-55-10-2(c)(6)
public Aid to aged, blind, disabled; public 305-5/11-3 contributions
benefits assistance Sheriffs 36-8-10-19
Crime victims’ compensation 735-5/12-1001(h)(1) State teachers 5-10.4-5-14
Restitution payments on account of 735-5/12-1001(12)(h)(5) personal Health aids 34-55-10-2(c)(4)
WWII relocation of Aleuts & Japanese property
Americans Money in medical care savings account 34-55-10-2(c)(7)
Social Security 735-5/12-1001(g)(1) Spendthrift trusts 30-4-3-2
Unemployment compensation 735-5/12-1001(g)(1),(3) $300 of any intangible personal property, 34-55-10-2(c)(3)
Veterans’ benefits 735-5/12-1001(g)(2) except money owed to you
Workers’ compensation 820-305/21 public Crime victims’ compensation, unless seeking 5-2-6.1-38
Workers’ occupational disease 820-310/21 benefits to discharge the debts for which the victim
compensation was compensated
tools of trade Implements, books, & tools of trade to 735-5/12-1001(d) Unemployment compensation 22-4-33-3
$1,500 Workers’ compensation 22-3-2-17
wages Minimum 85% of earned but unpaid 740-170/4
tools of trade National Guard uniforms, arms, & equipment 10-16-10-3
weekly wages or 45 times the federal
minimum hourly wage (or state mini wages Minimum 75% of earned but unpaid weekly 24-4.5-5-105
mum hourly wage, if higher); bankruptcy disposable earnings, or 30 times the federal
judge may authorize more for low- hourly minimum wage; bankruptcy judge may
income debtors authorize more for low-income debtors
338 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
wildcard $8,000 of any real estate or tangible personal 34-55-10-2(c)(2) personal Residential security or utility deposit, or 627.6(14)
property property advance rent, to $500
(continued)
Rifle or musket; shotgun 627.6(2)
Iowa One motor vehicle to $7,000 627.6(9)
Federal bankruptcy exemptions not available. All law references are to Iowa Code Wedding or engagement rings, limited to 627.6(1)(a)
Annotated unless otherwise noted. $7,000 if purchased after marriage and within
last two years
ASSET EXEMPTION LAW
Wrongful death proceeds and awards needed 627.6(15)
homestead May record homestead declaration 561.4 for support of debtor and dependents
Real property or an apartment to an unlimited 499A.18; 561.2; public Adopted child assistance 627.19
value; property cannot exceed ½ acre in town 561.16 benefits Aid to dependent children 239B.6
or city, 40 acres elsewhere (husband & wife may
not double) Any public assistance benefit 627.6(8)(a)
insurance Accident, disability, health, illness, or life 627.6(6) Social Security 627.6(8)(a)
proceeds or avails Unemployment compensation 627.6(8)(a)
Disability or illness benefit 627.6(8)(c) Veterans’ benefits 627.6(8)(b)
Employee group insurance policy or proceeds 509.12 Workers’ compensation 627.13
Fraternal benefit society benefits 512B.18 tools of trade Farming equipment; includes livestock, feed to 627.6(11)
$10,000
Life insurance proceeds if clause prohibits 508.32
proceeds from being used to pay beneficiary’s National Guard articles of equipment 29A.41
creditors Nonfarming equipment to $10,000 627.6(10)
Life insurance proceeds paid to spouse, child, or 627.6(6) wages Expected annual Amount NOT 642.21
other dependent (limited to $10,000 if acquired earnings exempt per year
within 2 years of filing for bankruptcy) $0 to $12,000 $250
Upon death of insured, up to $15,000 total 627.6(6) $12,000 to $16,000 $400
proceeds from all matured life, accident, health, $16,000 to $24,000 $800
or disability policies exempt from beneficiary’s $24,000 to $35,000 $1,000
debts contracted before insured’s death $35,000 to $50,000 $2,000
miscellaneous Alimony, child support needed for support 627.6(8)(d) More than $50,000 10%
Liquor licenses 123.38 Not exempt from spousal or child support
pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C. Wages or salary of a prisoner 356.29
see also wages 401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money § 522(b)(3)(C) wildcard $1,000 of any personal property, including cash 627.6(14)
purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and
defined-benefit plans Kansas
Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C. Federal bankruptcy exemptions not available. All law references are to Kansas
person § 522(b)(3) Statutes Annotated unless otherwise noted.
(C); (n)
ASSET EXEMPTION LAW
Disabled firefighters, police officers (only 410.11
homestead Real property or mobile home you occupy or 60-2301;
payments being received)
intend to occupy to unlimited value; property Constitution
Federal government pension 627.8 cannot exceed 1 acre in town or city, 160 acres 15-9
Firefighters 411.13 on farm
Other pensions, annuities, & contracts fully 627.6(8)(e) insurance Cash value of life insurance; not exempt if 60-2313(a)(7);
exempt; however, contributions made within 1 obtained within 1 year prior to bankruptcy 40-414(b)
year prior to filing for bankruptcy not exempt with fraudulent intent
to the extent they exceed normal & customary Disability & illness benefits 60-2313(a)(1)
amounts
Fraternal life insurance benefits 60-2313(a)(8)
Peace officers 97A.12
Life insurance proceeds 40-414(a)
Police officers 411.13
miscellaneous Alimony, maintenance, & support 60-2312(b)
Public employees 97B.39
Liquor licenses 60-2313(a)(6);
Retirement plans, Keoghs, IRAs, Roth IRAs, 627.6(8)(f) 41-326
ERISA-qualified benefits
pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C.
personal Bibles, books, portraits, pictures, & paintings to 627.6(3) 401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money § 522(b)(3)(C)
property $1,000 total purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and
Burial plot to 1 acre 627.6(4) defined-benefit plans
Clothing & its storage containers, household 627.6(5) Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)
furnishings, appliances, musical instruments, person (3)(C); (n)
and other personal property to $7,000 Elected & appointed officials in cities with 13-14a10
Health aids 627.6(7) populations between 120,000 & 200,000
Jewelry to $2,000 627.6(1)(6) ERISA-qualified benefits 60-2308(b)
Appendix A | State and Federal exemption charts | 339
pensions Federal government pension needed for 60-2308(a) insurance Health or disability benefits 304.14-310
(continued) support & paid within 3 months of filing for (continued)
Life insurance policy if beneficiary is a married 304.14-340
bankruptcy (only payments being received)
woman
Firefighters 12-5005(e);
Life insurance proceeds if clause prohibits 304.14-350
14-10a10
proceeds from being used to pay beneficiary’s
Judges 20-2618 creditors
Police officers 12-5005(e); Life insurance proceeds or cash value if 304.14-300
13-14a10 beneficiary is someone other than insured
Public employees 74-4923; miscellaneous Alimony, child support needed for support 427.150(1)
74-49,105
pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C.
State highway patrol officers 74-4978g
401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money § 522(b)(3)(C)
State school employees 72-5526 purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and
Payment under a stock bonus, pension, profit- 60-2312(b) defined-benefit plans
sharing, annuity, or similar plan or contract Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C.
on account of illness, disability, death, age, person § 522(b)(3)
or length of service, to the extent reasonably (C); (n)
necessary for support
ERISA-qualified benefits, including IRAs, SEPs, 427.150
personal Burial plot or crypt 60-2304(d) & Keoghs deposited more than 120 days before
property filing
Clothing to last 1 year 60-2304(a)
Food & fuel to last 1 year 60-2304(a) Firefighters 67A.620;
Funeral plan prepayments 60-2313(a)(10); 95.878
16-310(d) Police officers 427.120;
Furnishings & household equipment 60-2304(a) 427.125
Jewelry & articles of adornment to $1,000 60-2304(b) State employees 61.690
Motor vehicle to $20,000; if designed or 60-2304(c) Teachers 161.700
equipped for disabled person, no limit Urban county government employees 67A.350
public Crime victims’ compensation 60-2313(a)(7); personal Burial plot to $5,000, in lieu of homestead 427.060
benefits 74-7313(d) property
Clothing, jewelry, articles of adornment, & 427.010(1)
General assistance 39-717(c) furnishings to $3,000 total
Social Security 60-2312(b)
Health aids 427.010(1)
Unemployment compensation 60-2313(a)(4);
Lost earnings payments needed for support 427.150(2)(d)
44-718(c)
Veterans’ benefits 60-2312(b) Medical expenses paid & reparation benefits 304.39-260
received under motor vehicle reparation law
Workers’ compensation 60-2313(a)(3);
44-514 Motor vehicle to $2,500 427.010(1)
tools of trade Books, documents, furniture, instruments, 60-2304(e) Personal injury recoveries to $7,500 (not to 427.150(2)(c)
equipment, breeding stock, seed, grain, & include pain & suffering or pecuniary loss)
stock to $7,500 total Prepaid tuition payment fund account 164A.707(3)
National Guard uniforms, arms, & equipment 48-245 Wrongful death recoveries for person you 427.150(2)(b)
wages Minimum 75% of disposable weekly wages or 60-2310 depended on, needed for support
30 times the federal minimum hourly wage per public Aid to blind, aged, disabled; public assistance 205.220(c)
week, whichever is greater; bankruptcy judge benefits
may authorize more for low-income debtors Crime victims’ compensation 427.150(2)(a)
wildcard None Unemployment compensation 341.470(4)
Workers’ compensation 342.180
wages Minimum 75% of disposable weekly earnings or 427.010(2),(3) personal Arms, military accoutrements; bedding; 13:3881(A)(4)
30 times the federal minimum hourly wage per property dishes, glassware, utensils, silverware
week, whichever is greater; bankruptcy judge (nonsterling); clothing, family portraits,
may authorize more for low-income debtors musical instruments; bedroom, living room,
wildcard $1,000 of any property 427.160 & dining room furniture; poultry, 1 cow,
household pets; heating & cooling equipment,
refrigerator, freezer, stove, washer & dryer,
Louisiana iron, sewing machine
Federal bankruptcy exemptions not available. All law references are to Louisiana Cemetery plot, monuments 8:313
Revised Statutes Annotated unless otherwise noted.
Disaster relief insurance proceeds 13:3881(A)(7)
ASSET EXEMPTION LAW
Engagement & wedding rings to $5,000 13:3881(A)(5)
homestead Property you occupy to $25,000 (if debt is 20:1(A)(1),(2),(3)
result of catastrophic or terminal illness or Motor vehicle to $7,500 13:3881(A)(7)
injury, limit is full value of property as of 1 year Motor vehicle modified for disability to $7,500 13:3881(A)(8)
before filing); cannot exceed 5 acres in city or Spendthrift trusts 9:2004
town, 200 acres elsewhere (husband & wife
may not double) public Aid to blind, aged, disabled; public assistance 46:111
benefits
Spouse or child of deceased owner may claim 20:1(B) Crime victims’ compensation 46:1811
homestead exemption; spouse given home in Earned income tax credit 13:3881 (A)(6)
divorce gets homestead
Unemployment compensation 23:1693
insurance Annuity contract proceeds & avails 22:647
Workers’ compensation 23:1205
Fraternal benefit society benefits 22:558
tools of trade Tools, instruments, books, $7,500 of equity in 13:3881(A)(2)
Group insurance policies or proceeds 22:649 a motor vehicle, one firearm to $500, needed
Health, accident, or disability proceeds or 22:646 to work
avails wages Minimum 75% of disposable weekly earnings 13:3881(A)(1)
Life insurance proceeds or avails; if policy 22:647 or 30 times the federal minimum hourly wage
issued within 9 months of filing, exempt only per week, whichever is greater; bankruptcy
to $35,000 judge may authorize more for low-income
miscellaneous Property of minor child 13:3881(A)(3); debtors
Civil Code Art. wildcard None
223
pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C. § 522(b) Maine
401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money (3)(C)
Federal bankruptcy exemptions not available. All law references are to Maine
purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and
Revised Statutes Annotated, in the form title number-section number, unless
defined-benefit plans
otherwise noted.
Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)
person (3)(C); (n) ASSET EXEMPTION LAW
Assessors 11:1403 homestead Real or personal property (including 14-4422(1)
cooperative) used as residence to $47,500; if
Court clerks 11:1526 debtor has minor dependents in residence, to
District attorneys 11:1583 $95,000; if debtor over age 60 or physically or
ERISA-qualified benefits, including IRAs, Roth 13:3881; 20:33(1) mentally disabled, $95,000; proceeds of sale
IRAs, & Keoghs, if contributions made over exempt for six months
1 year before filing for bankruptcy insurance Annuity proceeds to $450 per month 24-A-2431
Firefighters 11:2263 Death benefit for police, fire, or emergency 25-1612
Gift or bonus payments from employer to 20:33(2) medical personnel who die in the line of duty
employee or heirs whenever paid Disability or health proceeds, benefits, or 14-4422(13)
Judges 11:1378 avails (A),(C); 24-A-2429
Louisiana University employees 11:952.3 Fraternal benefit society benefits 24-A-4118
Municipal employees 11:1735 Group health or life policy or proceeds 24-A-2430
Parochial employees 11:1905 Life, endowment, annuity, or accident policy, 14-4422(14)(C);
proceeds or avails 24-A-2428
Police officers 11:3513
School employees 11:1003 Life insurance policy, interest, loan value, or 14-4422(11)
accrued dividends for policy from person you
Sheriffs 11:2182 depended on, to $4,000
State employees 11:405 Unmatured life insurance policy, except 14-4422(10)
Teachers 11:704 credit insurance policy
Voting registrars 11:2033 miscellaneous Alimony & child support needed for support 14-4422(13)(D)
Appendix A | State and Federal exemption charts | 341
personal Appliances, utensils, books, furniture, & 600.5451(1)(c) miscellaneous Earnings of minor child 550.37 subd. 15
property household goods to $525 each, $3,450 total pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)
Building & loan association shares to $1,150 600.5451(1)(k) 401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money (3)(C)
par value, in lieu of homestead purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and
Burial plots, cemeteries 600.5451(1)(a)(vii) defined-benefit plans
Church pew, slip, seat for entire family to 600.5451(1)(d) Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)
$575 person (3)(C); (n)
Clothing; family pictures 600.5451(1)(a) ERISA-qualified benefits if needed for support, 550.37 subd. 24
Food & fuel to last family for 6 months 600.5451(1)(b) up to $63,000 in present value
Crops, animals, and feed to $2,300 600.5451(1)(e) IRAs or Roth IRAs needed for support, up to 550.37 subd. 24
$63,000 in present value
1 motor vehicle to $3,175 600.5451(1)(g)
Computer & accessories to $575 600.5451(1)(h) Public employees 353.15; 356.401
insurance Accident or disability proceeds 550.39 Wages paid within 6 months of returning 550.37 subd. 14
to work after receiving welfare or after
Fraternal benefit society benefits 64B.18
incarceration; includes earnings deposited in a
Life insurance proceeds to $42,000 if benefi- 550.37 subd. 10 financial institution in the last 60 days
ciary is spouse or child of insured, plus $10,500
per dependent wildcard None
Police, fire, or beneficiary association benefits 550.37 subd. 11 Note: In cases of suspected fraud, the Minnesota constitution permits courts to
Unmatured life insurance contract dividends, 550.37 subd. 23 cap exemptions that would otherwise be unlimited. (In re Tveten, 402 N.W.2d 551
interest, or loan value to $8,400 if insured is (Minn. 1987); In re Medill, 119 B.R. 685 (Bankr. D. Minn. 1990); In re Sholdan, 217
debtor or person debtor depends on F.3d 1006 (8th Cir. 2000).)
344 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
pensions Highway & transportation employees 104.250 insurance Medical, surgical, or hospital care benefits 25-13-608(1)(f)
(continued) (continued)
Police department employees 86.190; 86.353; Unmatured life insurance contracts 25-13-608(1)(k)
86.1430 miscellaneous Alimony, child support 25-13-608(1)(g)
Public officers & employees 70.695; 70.755 pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)
State employees 104.540 401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money (3)(C)
purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and
Teachers 169.090
defined-benefit plans
personal Appliances, household goods, furnishings, 513.430(1)
property Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)
clothing, books, crops, animals, & musical
person (3)(C); (n)
instruments to $3,000 total
IRAs & ERISA-qualified benefits deposited 31-2-106
Burial grounds to 1 acre or $100 214.190
over 1 year before filing bankruptcy or up to
Health aids 513.430(9) 15% of debtor’s gross annual income
Motor vehicle to $3,000 513.430(5) Firefighters 19-18-612(1)
Wedding ring to $1,500 & other jewelry to 513.430(2) IRA & Roth IRA contributions & earnings 25-13-608(1)(e)
$500 made before judgment filed
Wrongful death recoveries for person you 513.430(11) Police officers 19-19-504(1)
depended on
Public employees 19-2-1004;
public Crime victim’s compensation 595.025 25-13-608(i)
benefits
Public assistance 513.430(10)(a) Teachers 19-20-706(2);
Social Security 513.430(10)(a) 25-13-608(j)
Nebraska Nevada
Federal bankruptcy exemptions not available. All law references are to Revised Federal bankruptcy exemptions not available. All law references are to Nevada
Statutes of Nebraska unless otherwise noted. Revised Statutes Annotated unless otherwise noted.
ASSET EXEMPTION LAW ASSET EXEMPTION LAW
homestead $60,000 for married debtor or head of household; 40-101; homestead Must record homestead declaration 115.020
cannot exceed 2 lots in city or village, 160 acres 40-111; before filing for bankruptcy
elsewhere; sale proceeds exempt 6 months 40-113 Real property or mobile home to $550,000 115.010; 21.090(1)(m)
after sale (husband & wife may not double) Husband and wife may not double
May record homestead declaration 40-105 insurance Annuity contract proceeds to $350 per 687B.290
insurance Fraternal benefit society benefits to $100,000 44-1089 month
loan value unless beneficiary convicted of a crime Fraternal benefit society benefits 695A.220
related to benefits Group life or health policy or proceeds 687B.280
Life insurance proceeds and avails to $100,000 44-371 Health proceeds or avails 687B.270
pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 401(k)s, 11 U.S.C. § 522(b) Life insurance policy or proceeds if annual 21.090(1)(k); In re
see also 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money purchase plans, (3)(C) premiums not over $1,000 Bower, 234 B.R. 109
wages SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and defined-benefit plans (Nev. 1999)
Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C. § 522(b) Life insurance proceeds if you’re not the 687B.260
person (3)(C); (n) insured
miscellaneous Alimony & child support 21.090(1)(s)
County employees 23-2322
Property of some business partnerships 87.250
Deferred compensation of public employees 48-1401
Security deposits for a rental residence, 21.090(1)(n)
ERISA-qualified benefits including IRAs & Roth 25-1563.01 except landlord may enforce terms of
IRAs needed for support lease or rental agreement
Military disability benefits 25-1559 pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)
School employees 79-948 including 401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing (3)(C)
and money purchase plans, SEP and
State employees 84-1324 SIMPLE IRAs, and defined-benefit plans
personal Burial plot 12-517 Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)(3)
property per person (C); (n)
Clothing 25-1556(2)
ERISA-qualified benefits, deferred 21.090(1)(r)
Crypts, lots, tombs, niches, vaults 12-605
compensation, SEP IRA, Roth IRA, or IRA
Furniture, household goods & appliances, 25-1556(3) to $500,000
household electronics, personal computers, books, Public employees 286.670
& musical instruments to $1,500
personal Appliances, household goods, furniture, 21.090(1)(b)
Health aids 25-1556(5) property home & yard equipment to $12,000 total
Medical or health savings accounts to $25,000 8-1, 131(2)(b) Books, works of art, musical instruments, 21.090(1)(a)
& jewelry to $5,000
Perpetual care funds 12-511
Burial plot purchase money held in trust 689.700
Personal injury recoveries 25-1563.02
Funeral service contract money held in 689.700
Personal possessions 25-1556 trust
public Aid to disabled, blind, aged; public assistance 68-1013 Health aids 21.090(1)(q)
benefits
General assistance to poor persons 68-148 Interests in qualifying trusts 21.090(1)(cc)
Unemployment compensation 48-647 Keepsakes & pictures 21.090(1)(a)
Metal-bearing ores, geological specimens, 21.100
Workers’ compensation 48-149
art curiosities, or paleontological remains;
tools of Equipment or tools including a vehicle used in or 25-1556(4); In re must be arranged, classified, cataloged, &
trade for commuting to principal place of business to Keller, 50 B.R. 23 numbered in reference books
$2,400 (husband & wife may double) (D. Neb. 1985)
Mortgage impound accounts 645B.180
wages Minimum 85% of earned but unpaid weekly 25-1558 Motor vehicle to $15,000; no limit on 21.090(1)(f),(o)
disposable earnings or pension payments for head vehicle equipped for disabled person
of family; minimum 75% of earned but unpaid
1 gun 21.090(1)(i)
weekly disposable earnings or 30 times the federal
hourly minimum wage, whichever is greater, for all Personal injury compensation to $16,500 21.090(1)(u)
others; bankruptcy judge may authorize more for Restitution received for criminal act 21.090(1)(x)
low-income debtors Stock in certain closely held corporations 21.090(1)(bb)
wildcard $2,500 of any personal property except wages, in 25-1552 Tax refunds derived from the earned 21.090(1)(aa)
lieu of homestead income credit
Wrongful death awards to survivors 21.090(1)(v)
Appendix A | State and Federal exemption charts | 347
public Aid to blind, aged, disabled; public 422.291 personal Cooking & heating stoves, refrigerator 511:2(IV)
benefits assistance property Domestic fowl to $300 511:2(XIII)
(continued)
Crime victim’s compensation 21.090 Food & fuel to $400 511:2(VI)
Industrial insurance (workers’ 616C.205 Furniture to $3,500 511:2(III)
compensation)
Jewelry to $500 511:2(XVII)
Public assistance for children 432.036
Motor vehicle to $4,000 511:2(XVI)
Social Security retirement, disability, SSI, 21.090(1)(y)
survivor benefits Proceeds for lost or destroyed exempt 512:21(VIII)
property
Unemployment compensation 612.710
Sewing machine 511:2(V)
Vocational rehabilitation benefits 615.270
1 cow, 6 sheep & their fleece, 4 tons of hay 511:2(XI); (XII)
tools of trade Arms, uniforms, & accoutrements you’re 21.090(1)(j)
required to keep 1 hog or pig or its meat (if slaughtered) 511:2(X)
Cabin or dwelling of miner or prospector; 21.090(1)(e) public Aid to blind, aged, disabled; public assistance 167:25
mining claim, cars, implements, & benefits Unemployment compensation 282-A:159
appliances to $4,500 total (for working Workers’ compensation 281-A:52
claim only)
tools of trade Tools of your occupation to $5,000 511:2(IX)
Farm trucks, stock, tools, equipment, & 21.090(1)(c)
Uniforms, arms, & equipment of military 511:2(VII)
seed to $4,500
member
Library, equipment, supplies, tools, 21.090(1)(d)
inventory, & materials to $10,000 Yoke of oxen or horse needed for farming or 511:2(XII)
teaming
wages Minimum 75% of disposable weekly 21.090(1)(g)
earnings or 30 times the federal minimum wages 50 times the federal minimum hourly wage 512:21(II)
hourly wage per week, whichever is more; per week
bankruptcy judge may authorize more for Deposits in any account designated a payroll 512:21(XI)
low-income debtors account.
wildcard $1,000 of any personal property 21.090(1)(z) Earned but unpaid wages of spouse 512:21(III)
wildcard $1,000 of any property 511:2(XVIII)
New Hampshire Unused portion of bibles & books, food & fuel, 511:2(XVIII)
Federal bankruptcy exemptions available. All law references are to New furniture, jewelry, motor vehicle, & tools of
Hampshire Revised Statutes Annotated unless otherwise noted. trade exemptions to $7,000
pensions Alcohol beverage control officers 43:8A-20 pensions Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C.
(continued) City boards of health employees 43:18-12 (continued) person § 522(b)(3)
(C); (n)
Civil defense workers App. A:9-57.6
Pension or retirement benefits 42-10-1;
County employees 43:10-57; 43:10-105
42-10-2
ERISA-qualified benefits for city employees 43:13-9
Public school employees 22-11-42A
Firefighters, police officers, traffic officers 43:16-7; 43:16A-17
personal Books & furniture 42-10-1;
IRAs In re Yuhas, 104 F.3d property 42-10-2
612 (3d Cir. 1997)
Building materials 48-2-15
Judges 43:6A-41
Clothing 42-10-1;
Municipal employees 43:13-44 42-10-2
Prison employees 43:7-13 Cooperative association shares, minimum 53-4-28
Public employees 43:15A-53 amount needed to be member
School district employees 18A:66-116 Health aids 42-10-1;
State police 53:5A-45 42-10-2
Street & water department employees 43:19-17 Jewelry to $2,500 42-10-1;
42-10-2
Teachers 18A:66-51
Materials, tools, & machinery to dig, drill, 70-4-12
Trust containing personal property created 25:2-1; In re Yuhas,
complete, operate, or repair oil line, gas well, or
pursuant to federal tax law, including 401(k) 104 F.3d 612
pipeline
plans, IRAs, Roth IRAs, & higher education (3d Cir. 1997)
(529) savings plans Motor vehicle to $4,000 42-10-1;
42-10-2
personal Burial plots 45:27-21
property public Crime victims’ compensation 31-22-15
Clothing 2A:17-19 benefits General assistance 27-2-21
Furniture & household goods to $1,000 2A:26-4
Occupational disease disablement benefits 52-3-37
Personal property & possessions of any kind, 2A:17-19
stock or interest in corporations to $1,000 total Unemployment compensation 51-1-37
public Old age, permanent disability assistance 44:7-35 Workers’ compensation 52-1-52
benefits Unemployment compensation 43:21-53 tools of trade $1,500 42-10-1;
42-10-2
Workers’ compensation 34:15-29
wages Minimum 75% of disposable earnings or 40 35-12-7
tools of None
times the federal hourly minimum wage,
trade
whichever is more; bankruptcy judge may
wages 90% of earned but unpaid wages if annual 2A:17-56 authorize more for low-income debtors
income is less than 250% of federal poverty
wildcard $500 of any personal property 42-10-1
level; 75% if annual income is higher
$5,000 of any real or personal property, in lieu 42-10-10
Wages or allowances received by military 38A:4-8
of homestead
personnel
wildcard None
New York
Federal bankruptcy exemptions not available. All references are to Consoli-
New Mexico dated Laws of New York unless otherwise noted; Civil Practice Law & Rules are
Federal bankruptcy exemptions available. All law references are to New Mexico abbreviated C.P.L.R.
Statutes Annotated unless otherwise noted.
ASSET EXEMPTION LAW
ASSET EXEMPTION LAW homestead Real property including co-op, condo, or C.P.L.R. 5206(a); In re
homestead $60,000 42-10-9 mobile home, to $50,000 Pearl, 723 F.2d 193 (2nd
insurance Benevolent association benefits to $5,000 42-10-4 Cir. 1983)
Fraternal benefit society benefits 59A-44-18 insurance Annuity contract benefits due the Ins. 3212(d); Debt. &
debtor, if debtor paid for the contract; Cred. 283(1)
Life, accident, health, or annuity benefits, 42-10-3 $5,000 limit if purchased within 6
withdrawal or cash value, if beneficiary is a New months prior to filing & not tax-deferred
Mexico resident
Disability or illness benefits to $400 per Ins. 3212(c)
Life insurance proceeds 42-10-5 month
miscellaneous Ownership interest in unincorporated 53-10-2 Life insurance proceeds & avails if Ins. 3212(b)
association the beneficiary is not the debtor, or if
Property of business partnership 54-1A-501 debtor’s spouse has taken out policy
pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C. Life insurance proceeds left at death Est. Powers & Trusts
401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money § 522(b)(3)(C) with the insurance company, if clause 7-1.5(a)(2)
purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and prohibits proceeds from being used to
defined-benefit plans pay beneficiary’s creditors
Appendix A | State and Federal exemption charts | 349
miscellaneous Alimony, child support C.P.L.R. 5205 (d)(3); public Social Security Debt. & Cred. 282(2)(a)
Debt. & Cred. 282(2)(d) benefits Unemployment compensation Debt. & Cred. 282(2)(a)
Property of business partnership Partnership 51 (continued)
Veterans’ benefits Debt. & Cred. 282(2)(b)
pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)(3)(C) Workers’ compensation Debt. & Cred. 282(2)(c);
including 401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing Work. Comp. 33, 218
and money purchase plans, SEP and
tools of trade Farm machinery, team, & food for 60 C.P.L.R. 5205(a),(b)
SIMPLE IRAs, and defined-benefit plans
days; professional furniture, books, &
Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)(3) instruments to $600 total
per person (C); (n)
Uniforms, medal, emblem, equipment, C.P.L.R. 5205(e)
ERISA-qualified benefits, IRAs, Roth C.P.L.R. 5205(c); Debt. horse, arms, & sword of member of
IRAs, & Keoghs, & income needed for & Cred. 282(2)(e) military
support
wages 90% of earned but unpaid wages C.P.L.R. 5205(d)
Public retirement benefits Ins. 4607 received within 60 days before &
State employees Ret. & Soc. Sec. 10 anytime after filing
Teachers Educ. 524 90% of earnings from dairy farmer’s sales C.P.L.R. 5205(f)
Village police officers Unconsolidated 5711-o to milk dealers
Volunteer ambulance workers’ benefits Vol. Amb. Wkr. Ben. 23 100% of pay of noncommissioned C.P.L.R. 5205(e)
Volunteer firefighters’ benefits Vol. Firefighter Ben. 23 officer, private, or musician in U.S. or
personal Bible, schoolbooks, other books to $50; C.P.L.R. 5205(a)(1)-(6); N.Y. state armed forces
property pictures; clothing; church pew or seat; Debt. & Cred. 283(1) wildcard None
sewing machine, refrigerator, TV, radio;
furniture, cooking utensils & tableware, North Carolina
dishes; food to last 60 days; stoves with
fuel to last 60 days; domestic animal Federal bankruptcy exemptions not available. All law references are to General
with food to last 60 days, to $450; Statutes of North Carolina unless otherwise noted.
wedding ring; watch to $35; exemptions ASSET EXEMPTION LAW
may not exceed $5,000 total (including homestead Property held as tenancy by the entirety may In re Chandler,
tools of trade & limited annuity) be exempt against debts owed by only one 148 B.R. 13 (E.D.
Burial plot without structure to ¼ acre C.P.L.R. 5206(f) spouse N.C. 1992)
Cash (including savings bonds, tax Debt. & Cred. 283(2) Real or personal property, including co-op, 1C-1601(a)(1),(2)
refunds, bank & credit union deposits) used as residence to $35,000; $60,000 if 65 or
to $2,500, or to $5,000 after exemptions older, property owned with spouse as tenants
for personal property taken, whichever by the entirely or joint tenants with right
amount is less (for debtors who do not of survivorship, and spouse has died; up to
claim homestead) $5,000 of unused portion of homestead may
College tuition savings program trust C.P.L.R. 5205(j) be applied to any property
fund insurance Employee group life policy or proceeds 58-58-165
Electronic deposits of exempt property C.P.L.R. 5205(l)(1) Fraternal benefit society benefits 58-24-85
into bank account in last 45 days
Life insurance on spouse or children 1C-1601(a)(6);
Health aids, including service animals C.P.L.R. 5205(h) Const. Art. X § 5
with food
miscellaneous Alimony, support, separate maintenance, and 1C-1601(a)(12)
Lost future earnings recoveries needed Debt. & Cred. 282(3) child support necessary for support of debtor
for support (iv) and dependents
Motor vehicle to $2,400 Debt. & Cred. 282(1); In
Property of business partnership 59-55
re Miller, 167 B.R. 782
(S.D. N.Y. 1994) Support received by a surviving spouse for 1 30-15
year, up to $10,000
Personal injury recoveries up to 1 year Debt. & Cred. 282(3)
after receiving (iii) pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C.
401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money § 522(b)(3)(C)
Recovery for injury to exempt property C.P.L.R. 5205(b)
purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and
up to 1 year after receiving
defined-benefit plans
Savings & loan savings to $600 Banking 407
Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)
Security deposit to landlord, utility C.P.L.R. 5205(g) person (3)(C); (n)
company
Firefighters & rescue squad workers 58-86-90
Spendthrift trust fund principal, 90% of C.P.L.R. 5205(c),(d)
income if not created by debtor IRAs & Roth IRAs 1C-1601(a)(9)
Wrongful death recoveries for person Debt. & Cred. 282(3)(ii) Law enforcement officers 143-166.30(g)
you depended on Legislators 120-4.29
public Aid to blind, aged, disabled Debt. & Cred. 282(2)(c) Municipal, city, & county employees 128-31
benefits Crime victims’ compensation Debt. & Cred. 282(3)(i) Retirement benefits from another state to 1C-1601(a)(11)
Home relief, local public assistance Debt. & Cred. 282(2)(a) extent exempt in that state
Public assistance Soc. Serv. 137 Teachers & state employees 135-9; 135-95
350 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
personal Animals, crops, musical instruments, books, 1C-1601(a)(4),(d) pensions Public employees deferred compensation 54-52.2-06
property clothing, appliances, household goods & (continued) Public employees pensions 28-22-19(1)
furnishings to $5,000 total; may add $1,000 per
personal One Bible or other religious text; schoolbooks; 28-22-02(4)
dependent, up to $4,000 total additional (all
property other books
property must have been purchased at least
90 days before filing) Burial plots, church pew 28-22-02(2),(3)
Burial plot to $18,500, in lieu of homestead 1C-1601(a)(1) Wearing apparel to $5,000 and all clothing & 28-22-02(1),(5)
family pictures
College savings account established under 1C-1601(a)(10)
26 U.S.C. § 529 to $25,000, excluding certain Crops or grain raised by debtor on 160 acres 28-22-02(8)
contributions within prior year where debtor resides
Health aids 1C-1601(a)(7) Food & fuel to last 1 year 28-22-02(6)
Motor vehicle to $3,500 1C-1601(a)(3) Health aids 28-22-03.1(6)
Personal injury & wrongful death recoveries 1C-1601(a)(8) Insurance proceeds for exempt property 28-22-02(9)
for person you depended on One motor vehicle to $2,950 (or $32,000 28-22-03.1(2)
public Aid to blind 111-18 for vehicle that has been modified to
benefits Crime victims’ compensation 15B-17 accommodate owner’s disability)
Public adult assistance under work first 108A-36 Personal injury recoveries to $15,000 28-22-03.1(4)(b)
program Wrongful death recoveries to $15,000 28-22-03.1(4)(a)
Unemployment compensation 96-17 Head of household not claiming crops or grain 28-22-03
Workers’ compensation 97-21 may claim $5,000 of any personal property
tools of trade Implements, books, & tools of trade to $2,000 1C-1601(a)(5) Unmarried with no dependents not claiming 28-22-05
wages Earned but unpaid wages received 60 days 1-362 crops or grain may claim $3,750 of any personal
before filing for bankruptcy, needed for property
support public Crime victims’ compensation 28-22-03.1(4);
wildcard $5,000 of unused homestead or burial 1C-1601(a)(2) benefits 28-22-19(2)
exemption Old age & survivor insurance program benefits 52-09-22
$500 of any personal property Constitution Public assistance 28-22-19(3)
Art. X § 1 Social Security 28-22-03.1(8)(a)
Unemployment compensation 52-06-30
North Dakota Veteran’s disability benefits 28-22-03.1(8)(b)
Federal bankruptcy exemptions not available. All law references are to North
Workers’ compensation 65-05-29
Dakota Century Code unless otherwise noted.
tools of trade Books, tools, & implements of trade to $1,500 28-22-03.1(3)
ASSET EXEMPTION LAW
wages Minimum 75% of disposable weekly earnings or 32-09.1-03
homestead Real property, house trailer, or mobile home to 28-22-02(10);
40 times the federal minimum wage, whichever
$100,000 (husband & wife may not double) 47-18-01
is more; bankruptcy judge may authorize more
insurance Fraternal benefit society benefits 26.1-15.1-18; for low-income debtors
Any unmatured life insurance contract, other 26.1-33-40; 28-
wildcard $7,500 of any property in lieu of homestead 28-22-03.1(1)
than credit life insurance 22-03.1(4)
Life insurance proceeds payable to deceased’s 26.1-33-40
estate, not to a specific beneficiary Ohio
Life insurance surrender value to $8,000 per 28-22-03.1(5) Federal bankruptcy exemptions not available. All law references are to Ohio
policy, if beneficiary is insured’s dependent Revised Code unless otherwise noted.
& policy was owned over 1 year before filing ASSET EXEMPTION LAW
for bankruptcy; limit does not apply if more
homestead Property held as tenancy by the entirety In re Pernus, 143 B.R.
needed for support
may be exempt against debts owed by 856 (N.D. Ohio 1992)
miscellaneous Child support payments 14-09-09.31; 28- only one spouse
22-03.1(8)(d)
Real or personal property used as 2329.66(A)(1)(b)
pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C. residence to $20,000
401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money § 522(b)(3)(C)
insurance Benevolent society benefits to $5,000 2329.63; 2329.66(A)
purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and
(6)(a)
defined-benefit plans
Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C. Disability benefits needed for support 2329.66(A)(6)(e);
person § 522(b)(3)(C); 3923.19
(n) Fraternal benefit society benefits 2329.66(A)(6)(d);
Disabled veterans’ benefits, except military 28-22-03.1(4)(d) 3921.18
retirement pay Group life insurance policy or proceeds 2329.66(A)(6)(c);
ERISA-qualified benefits, IRAs, Roth IRAs, & 28-22-03.1(7) 3917.05
Keoghs to $100,000 per plan; no limit if more Life, endowment, or annuity contract 2329.66(A)(6)(b);
needed for support; total of all accounts avails for your spouse, child, or 3911.10
cannot exceed $200,000 dependent
Appendix A | State and Federal exemption charts | 351
insurance Life insurance proceeds for a spouse 3911.12 tools of trade Implements, books, & tools of trade to 2329.66(A)(5)
(continued) Life insurance proceeds if clause 3911.14 $2,025
prohibits proceeds from being used to wages Minimum 75% of disposable weekly 2329.66(A)(13)
pay beneficiary’s creditors earnings or 30 times the federal hourly
miscellaneous Alimony, child support needed for 2329.66(A)(11) minimum wage, whichever is higher;
support bankruptcy judge may authorize more
for low-income debtors
Property of business partnership 1775.24; 2329.66(A)(14)
pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, 11 U.S.C. § 522(b) wildcard $1,075 of any property 2329.66(A)(18)
including 401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing (3)(C)
and money purchase plans, SEP and Oklahoma
SIMPLE IRAs, and defined-benefit plans Federal bankruptcy exemptions not available. All law references are to Oklahoma
Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)(3) Statutes Annotated (in the form title number-section number), unless otherwise
per person (C); (n) noted.
ERISA-qualified benefits needed for 2329.66(A)(10)(b) ASSET EXEMPTION LAW
support
homestead Real property or manufactured home to 31-1(A)(1);
Firefighters, police officers 742.47 unlimited value; property cannot exceed 31-1(A)(2);
IRAs, Roth IRAs, & Keoghs needed for 2329.66(A)(10)(c), (a) 1 acre in city, town, or village, or 160 acres 31-2
support elsewhere; $5,000 limit if more than 25% of
total sq. ft. area used for business purposes;
Public employees 145.56
okay to rent homestead as long as no other
Public safety officers’ death benefit 2329.66(A)(10)(a) residence is acquired
Public school employees 3309.66 insurance Annuity benefits & cash value 36-3631.1
State highway patrol employees 5505.22
Assessment or mutual benefits 36-2410
Volunteer firefighters’ dependents 146.13
Fraternal benefit society benefits 36-2718.1
personal Animals, crops, books, musical 2329.66(A)(4)
property instruments, appliances, household (b),(c),(d); In re Funeral benefits prepaid & placed in trust 36-6125
goods, furnishings, firearms, hunting Szydlowski, 186 B.R. Group life policy or proceeds 36-3632
& fishing equipment to $525 per item; 907 (N.D. Ohio 1995)
Life, health, accident, & mutual benefit 36-3631.1
jewelry to $1,350 for 1 or more items;
insurance proceeds & cash value, if clause
$10,775 total
prohibits proceeds from being used to pay
Burial plot 517.09; 2329.66(A)(8) beneficiary’s creditors
Cash, money due within 90 days, tax 2329.66(A)(4)(a); In re Limited stock insurance benefits 36-2510
refund, bank, security, & utility deposits Szydlowski, 186 B.R.
to $400 total 907 (N.D. Ohio 1995) miscellaneous Alimony, child support 31-1(A)(19)
Compensation for lost future earnings 2329.66(A)(12)(d) Beneficiary’s interest in a statutory support 6-3010
needed for support, received during trust
12 months before filing Liquor license 37-532
Cooking unit & refrigerator to $300 each 2329.66(A)(3) Property of business partnership 54-1-504
Health aids (professionally prescribed) 2329.66(A)(7) pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C.
Motor vehicle to $3,225 2329.66(A)(2)(b) 401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money § 522(b)(3)(C)
Personal injury recoveries to $20,200, 2329.66(A)(12)(c) purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and
received during 12 months before filing defined-benefit plans
Tuition credit or payment 2329.66(A)(16) Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C.
person § 522(b)(3)(C);
Wrongful death recoveries for person 2329.66(A)(12)(b)
(n)
debtor depended on, needed for support,
received during 12 months before filing County employees 19-959
public Crime victim’s compensation, received 2329.66(A)(12)(a); Disabled veterans 31-7
benefits during 12 months before filing 2743.66(D)
ERISA-qualified benefits, IRAs, Roth IRAs, 31-1(A)(20), (24)
Disability assistance payments 2329.66(A)(9)(f); Education IRAs, & Keoghs
5115.07
Firefighters 11-49-126
Public assistance 2329.66(A)(9)(d); (e);
5107.75; 5108.08 Judges 20-1111
Unemployment compensation 2329.66(A)(9)(c); Law enforcement employees 47-2-303.3
4141.32 Police officers 11-50-124
Vocational rehabilitation benefits 2329.66(A)(9)(a); Public employees 74-923
3304.19
Tax-exempt benefits 60-328
Workers’ compensation 2329.66(A)(9)(b);
4123.67 Teachers 70-17-109
352 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
personal Books, portraits, & pictures 31-1(A)(6) insurance Health or disability proceeds or avails 743.050
property (continued)
Burial plots 31-1(A)(4); 8-7 Life insurance proceeds or cash value if you 743.046; 743.047
are not the insured
Clothing to $4,000 31-1(A)(7)
miscellaneous Alimony, child support needed for support 18.345(1)(i)
College savings plan interest 31-1A(24)
Liquor licenses 471.292 (1)
Deposits in an IDA (Individual Development 31-1A(22)
Account) pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)
401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money (3)(C)
Federal earned income tax credit 31-1(A)(23)
purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and
Food & seed for growing to last 1 year 31-1(A)(17) defined-benefit plans
Guns for household use to $2,000 31-1A(14) Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)
Health aids (professionally prescribed) 31-1(A)(9) person (3)(C); (n)
Household & kitchen furniture; personal 31-1(A)(3) ERISA-qualified benefits, including IRAs & 18.358; 18.348
computer and related equipment SEPs; & payments to $7,500
Livestock for personal or family use: 5 dairy 31-1(A)(10),(11), Public officers’, employees’ pension payments 237.980; 238.445;
cows & calves under 6 months; 100 chickens; (12),(15),(16),(17) to $7,500 18.348(2)
20 sheep; 10 hogs; 2 horses, bridles, & saddles; personal Bank deposits to $7,500; cash for sold exempt 18.348; 18.345(2)
forage & feed to last 1 year property property
Motor vehicle to $7,500 31-1(A)(13) Books, pictures, & musical instruments to 18.345(1)(a)
Personal injury & wrongful death recoveries 31-1(A)(21) $600 total
to $50,000 Building materials for construction of an 87.075
Prepaid funeral benefits 36-6125(H) improvement
War bond payroll savings account 51-42 Burial plot 65.870
Wedding and anniversary rings to $3,000 31-1(A)(8) Clothing, jewelry, & other personal items to 18.345(1)(b)
public Crime victims’ compensation 21-142.13 $1,800 total
benefits Public assistance 56-173 Compensation for lost earnings payments for 18.345(1)(L),(3)
debtor or someone debtor depended on, to
Social Security 56-173
extent needed
Unemployment compensation 40-2-303
Domestic animals, poultry, & pets to $1,000 18.345(1)(e)
Workers’ compensation 85-48 plus food to last 60 days
tools of trade Implements needed to farm homestead; 31-1(A)(5); Federal earned income tax credit 18.345(1)(n)
tools, books, & apparatus to $10,000 total 31-1(C)
Food & fuel to last 60 days if debtor is 18.345(1)(f)
wages 75% of wages earned in 90 days before filing 12-1171.1; householder
bankruptcy; bankruptcy judge may allow 31-1(A)(18);
Furniture, household items, utensils, radios, 18.345(1)(f)
more if you show hardship 31-1.1
& TVs to $3,000 total
wildcard None
Health aids 18.345(1)(h)
Higher education savings account to $7,500 348.863; 18.348(1)
Oregon Motor vehicle to $3,000 18.345(1)(d),(3)
Federal bankruptcy exemptions not available. All law references are to Oregon Personal injury recoveries to $10,000 18.345(1)(k),(3)
Revised Statutes unless otherwise noted. Pistol; rifle or shotgun (owned by person over 18.362
ASSET EXEMPTION LAW 16) to $1,000
homestead Prepaid rent & security deposit for renter’s In re Casserino, public Aid to blind to $7,500 411.706; 411.760;
dwelling 379 F.3d 1069 benefits 18.348
(9th Cir. 2004) Aid to disabled to $7,500 411.706; 411.760;
Real property of a soldier or sailor during time 408.440 18.348
of war Civil defense & disaster relief to $7,500 401.405; 18.348
Real property you occupy or intend to occupy 18.395; 18.402; In Crime victims’ compensation 18.345(1)(j)(A),(3);
to $40,000 ($50,000 for joint owners); property re Wynn, 369 B.R. 147.325
cannot exceed 1 block in town or city or 160 605 (D. Or. 2007) General assistance to $7,500 411.760; 18.348
acres elsewhere; sale proceeds exempt 1 year
Injured inmates’ benefits to $7,500 655.530; 18.348
from sale if you intend to purchase another
home or use sale proceeds for rent Medical assistance to $7,500 414.095; 18.348
Tenancy by entirety not exempt, but subject In re Pletz, 225 Old-age assistance to $7,500 411.706; 411.760;
to survivorship rights of nondebtor spouse B.R. 206 (D. Or. 18.348
1997) Unemployment compensation to $7,500 657.855; 18.348
insurance Annuity contract benefits to $500 per month 743.049 Veterans’ benefits & proceeds of Veterans 407.125; 407.595;
Fraternal benefit society benefits to $7,500 748.207; 18.348 loans 18.348(m)
Group life policy or proceeds not payable to 743.047 Vocational rehabilitation to $7,500 344.580; 18.348
insured Workers’ compensation to $7,500 656.234; 18.348
Appendix A | State and Federal exemption charts | 353
tools of trade Tools, library, team with food to last 60 days, 18.345(1)(c),(3) personal Bibles & schoolbooks 42-8124(a)(2)
to $3,000 property
Clothing 42-8124(a)(1)
wages 75% of disposable wages or $170 per week, 18.385 Military uniforms & accoutrements 42-8124(a)(4);
whichever is greater; bankruptcy judge may 51-4103
authorize more for low-income debtors
Sewing machines 42-8124(a)(3)
Wages withheld in state employee’s bond 292.070
savings accounts public Crime victims’ compensation 18-11.708
benefits
wildcard $400 of any personal property not already 18.348(1)(o) Korean conflict veterans’ benefits 51-20098
covered by existing exemption Unemployment compensation 42-8124(a)(10);
43-863
Pennsylvania Veterans’ benefits 51-20012; 20048;
Federal bankruptcy exemptions available. All law references are to Pennsylvania 20098; 20127
Consolidated Statutes Annotated unless otherwise noted. Workers’ compensation 42-8124(c)(2)
ASSET EXEMPTION LAW tools of trade Seamstress’s sewing machine 42-8124(a)(3)
homestead None; however, property held as tenancy by In re Martin, 269 wages Earned but unpaid wages 42-8127
the entirety may be exempt against debts B.R. 119 (M.D. Pa.
Prison inmate’s wages 61-1054
owed by only one spouse 2001)
Wages of victims of abuse 42-8127(f)
insurance Accident or disability benefits 42-8124(c)(7)
wildcard $300 of any property, including cash, real 42-8123
Fraternal benefit society benefits 42-8124(c)(1),(8)
property, securities, or proceeds from sale of
Group life policy or proceeds 42-8124(c)(5) exempt property
Insurance policy or annuity contract 42-8124(c)(3)
payments where insured is the beneficiary,
cash value or proceeds to $100 per month
Rhode Island
Federal bankruptcy exemptions available. All law references are to General Laws
Life insurance & annuity proceeds if clause 42-8214(c)(4)
of Rhode Island unless otherwise noted.
prohibits proceeds from being used to pay
beneficiary’s creditors ASSET EXEMPTION LAW
Life insurance annuity policy cash value or 42-8124(c)(6) homestead $300,000 in land & buildings you occupy or 9-26-4.1
proceeds if beneficiary is insured’s dependent, intend to occupy as a principal residence
child or spouse (husband & wife may not double)
No-fault automobile insurance proceeds 42-8124(c)(9) insurance Accident or sickness proceeds, avails, or 27-18-24
miscellaneous Property of business partnership 15-8342 benefits
pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C. § 522(b) Fraternal benefit society benefits 27-25-18
401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money (3)(C) Life insurance proceeds if clause prohibits 27-4-12
purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and proceeds from being used to pay
defined-benefit plans beneficiary’s creditors
Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C. § 522(b) Temporary disability insurance 28-41-32
person (3)(C); (n)
miscellaneous Earnings of a minor child 9-26-4(9)
personal Consumer cooperative association holdings 7-8-25 insurance Proceeds & cash surrender value of life 38-63-40(A)
property to $50 (continued) insurance payable to beneficiary other than
(continued) insured’s estate & for the express benefit of
Debt secured by promissory note or bill of 9-26-4(7)
exchange insured’s spouse, children, or dependents
(must be purchased 2 years before filing)
Jewelry to $2,000 9-26-4 (14)
Proceeds of life insurance or annuity 38-63-40(B)
Motor vehicles to $12,000 9-26-4 (13) contract
Prepaid tuition program or tuition savings 9-26-4 (15) Unmatured life insurance contract, except 15-41-30(A)(8)
account credit insurance policy
public Aid to blind, aged, disabled; general 40-6-14 miscellaneous Alimony, child support 15-41-30(A)(10)(D)
benefits assistance
Property of business partnership 33-41-720
Crime victims’ compensation 12-25.1-3(b)(2)
pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)
Family assistance benefits 40-5.1-15
401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money (3)(C)
State disability benefits 28-41-32 purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and
Unemployment compensation 28-44-58 defined-benefit plans
Veterans’ disability or survivors’ death 30-7-9 Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)
benefits person (3)(C); (n)
insurance Accident & disability benefits 38-63-40(D) public Crime victims’ compensation 15-41-30(A)(12);
benefits 16-3-1300
Benefits accruing under life insurance policy 38-63-50
after death of insured, where proceeds General relief; aid to aged, blind, disabled 43-5-190
left with insurance company pursuant Local public assistance 15-41-30(A)(11)
to agreement; benefits not exempt from
Social Security 15-41-30(A)(11)
action to recover necessaries if parties agree
Unemployment compensation 15-41-30(A)(11)
Disability or illness benefits 15-41-30(A)(10)(C)
Veterans’ benefits 15-41-30(A)(11)
Fraternal benefit society benefits 38-38-330
Workers’ compensation 42-9-360
Group life insurance proceeds; cash value 38-63-40(C);
to $50,000 38-65-90 tools of trade Implements, books, & tools of trade to 15-41-30(A)(6)
$1,500
Life insurance avails from policy for person 15-41-30(A)(8)
you depended on to $4,000 wages None (use federal nonbankruptcy wage 15-41-30(A)(7)
exemption)
Life insurance proceeds from policy for 15-41-30(A)(12)(C)
person you depended on, needed for wildcard Up to $5,000 for any property from unused
support exemption amounts
Appendix A | State and Federal exemption charts | 355
public Crime victims’ compensation to $5,000 26-2-111(2)(A); pensions County & district employees Gov’t. 811.006
benefits (see personal property) 29-13-111 (continued)
ERISA-qualified government or church Prop. 42.0021
(continued)
Local public assistance 26-2-111(1)(A) benefits, including Keoghs & IRAs
Old-age assistance 71-2-216 Firefighters 6243e(5);
Relocation assistance payments 13-11-115 6243a-1(8.03);
6243b(15); 6243e(5);
Social Security 26-2-111(1)(A) 6243e.1(1.04)
Unemployment compensation 26-2-111(1)(A) Judges Gov’t. 831.004
Veterans’ benefits 26-2-111(1)(B) Law enforcement officers, firefighters, Gov’t. 615.005
Workers’ compensation 50-6-223 emergency medical personnel survivors
tools of trade Implements, books, & tools of trade to 26-2-111(4) Municipal employees & elected officials, 6243h(22); Gov’t.
$1,900 state employees 811.005
wages Minimum 75% of disposable weekly 26-2-106,107 Police officers 6243d-1(17);
earnings or 30 times the federal 6243j(20);
minimum hourly wage, whichever is 6243a-1(8.03);
more, plus $2.50 per week per child; 6243b(15);
bankruptcy judge may authorize more 6243d-1(17)
for low-income debtors Retirement benefits to extent tax-deferred Prop. 42.0021
wildcard $4,000 of any personal property 26-2-103 Teachers Gov’t. 821.005
including deposits on account with any
personal Athletic & sporting equipment, including Prop. 42.002(a)(8)
bank or financial institution
property bicycles
to $60,000
Bible or other book containing sacred Prop. 42.001(b)(4)
Texas total for family,
writings of a religion (doesn’t count
$30,000 for
Federal bankruptcy exemptions available. All law references are to Texas Revised single adult toward $30,000 or $60,000 total)
Civil Statutes Annotated unless otherwise noted. (see also tools Burial plots (exempt from total) Prop. 41.001
of trade)
ASSET EXEMPTION LAW Clothing & food Prop. 42.002(a)(2),(5)
homestead Unlimited; property cannot exceed 10 Prop. 41.001; 41.002;
Health aids (exempt from total) Prop. 42.001(b)(2)
acres in town, village, city or 100 acres Const. Art. 16 §§ 50,
(200 for families) elsewhere; sale proceeds 51 Health savings accounts Prop. 42.0021
exempt for 6 months after sale (renting Home furnishings including family Prop. 42.002(a)(1)
okay if another home not acquired, Prop. heirlooms
41.003)
Jewelry (limited to 25% of total exemption) Prop. 42.002(a)(6)
Must file homestead declaration, or court Prop. 41.005(f);
Pets & domestic animals plus their food: 2 Prop. 42.002(a)
will file it for you & charge you for doing so 41.021 to 41.023
horses, mules, or donkeys & tack; 12 head (10),(11)
insurance Church benefit plan benefits 1407a(6) of cattle; 60 head of other livestock; 120
Fraternal benefit society benefits Ins. 885.316 fowl
Life, health, accident, or annuity benefits, Ins. 1108.051 1 two-, three- or four-wheeled motor Prop. 42.002(a)(9)
monies, policy proceeds, & cash values vehicle per family member or per single
due or paid to beneficiary or insured adult who holds a driver’s license; or, if not
licensed, who relies on someone else to
Texas employee uniform group insurance Ins. 1551.011 operate vehicle
Texas public school employees group Ins. 1575.006 2 firearms Prop. 42.002(a)(7)
insurance
public Crime victims’ compensation Crim. Proc. 56.49
Texas state college or university employee Ins. 1601.008 benefits
benefits Medical assistance Hum. Res. 32.036
miscellaneous Alimony & child support Prop. 42.001(b)(3) Public assistance Hum. Res. 31.040
Unemployment compensation Labor 207.075
Higher education savings plan trust Educ. 54.709(e)
account Workers’ compensation Labor 408.201
Liquor licenses & permits Alco. Bev. Code 11.03 tools of trade Farming or ranching vehicles & Prop. 42.002(a)(3)
included in implements
Prepaid tuition plans Educ. 54.639 aggregate
dollar limits Tools, equipment (includes boat & motor Prop. 42.002(a)(4)
Property of business partnership 6132b-5.01
for personal vehicles used in trade), & books
pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, 11 U.S.C. § 522(b) property
including 401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing (3)(C)
and money purchase plans, SEP and wages Earned but unpaid wages Prop. 42.001(b)(1)
SIMPLE IRAs, and defined-benefit plans Unpaid commissions not to exceed 25% of Prop. 42.001(d)
Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)(3) total personal property exemptions
per person (C); (n) wildcard None
Appendix A | State and Federal exemption charts | 357
Health aids 78-23-5(1)(a)(ii) pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)
401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money (3)(C)
Heirlooms to $500 78-23-8(1)(d) purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and
Motor vehicle to $2,500 78-23-8(3) defined-benefit plans
Personal injury, wrongful death recoveries for 78-23-5(1)(a)(x) Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)
you or person you depended on person (3)(C); (n)
Proceeds for sold, lost, or damaged exempt 78-23-9 Municipal employees 24-5066
property Other pensions 12-2740(19)(J)
Refrigerator, freezer, microwave, stove, sewing 78-23-5(1)(a)(viii) Self-directed accounts (IRAs, Roth IRAs, 12-2740(16)
machine, washer & dryer Keoghs); contributions must be made 1 year
Sofas, chairs, & related furnishings to $500 78-23-8(1)(a) before filing
358 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
pensions State employees 3-476 homestead Surviving spouse may claim $15,000; if no 64.1-151.3
(continued) (continued) surviving spouse, minor children may claim
Teachers 16-1946
exemption
personal Appliances, furnishings, goods, clothing, 12-2740(5)
property books, crops, animals, musical instruments insurance Accident or sickness benefits 38.2-3406
to $2,500 total Burial society benefits 38.2-4021
Bank deposits to $700 12-2740(15) Cooperative life insurance benefits 38.2-3811
Cow, 2 goats, 10 sheep, 10 chickens, & feed 12-2740(6), (9)-(14) Fraternal benefit society benefits 38.2-4118
to last 1 winter; 3 swarms of bees plus honey;
5 tons coal or 500 gal. heating oil, 10 cords Group life or accident insurance for 51.1-510
of firewood; 500 gal. bottled gas; growing government officials
crops to $5,000; yoke of oxen or steers, plow Group life insurance policy or proceeds 38.2-3339
& ox yoke; 2 horses with harnesses, halters, Industrial sick benefits 38.2-3549
& chains
Life insurance proceeds 38.2-3122
Health aids 12-2740(17)
miscellaneous Property of business partnership 50-73.108
Jewelry to $500; wedding ring unlimited 12-2740(3),(4)
pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)
Motor vehicles to $2,500 12-2740(1) see also 401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money (3)(C)
Personal injury, lost future earnings, wrongful 12-2740(19)(F), wages purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and
death recoveries for you or person you (G),(I) defined-benefit plans
depended on
Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)(3)
Stove, heating unit, refrigerator, freezer, 12-2740(8) per person (C); (n)
water heater, & sewing machines
City, town, & county employees 51.1-802
public Aid to blind, aged, disabled; general 33-124
benefits assistance ERISA-qualified benefits to same extent 34-34
permitted by federal bankruptcy law
Crime victims’ compensation needed for 12-2740(19)(E)
support Judges 51.1-300
wages Minimum 75% of weekly disposable 34-29 personal Health aids prescribed 6.15.010(3)(e)
earnings or 40 times the federal minimum property Keepsakes & family pictures 6.15.010(2)
hourly wage, whichever is greater; (continued)
Motor vehicle to $2,500 total for individual (two 6.15.010(3)(c)
bankruptcy judge may authorize more for
vehicles to $5,000 for community)
low-income debtors
Personal injury recoveries to $16,150 6.15.010(3)(f)
wildcard Unused portion of homestead or personal 34-13
property exemption Tuition units purchased more than 2 years 6.15.010(5)
before
$10,000 of any property for disabled veterans 34-4.1
public Child welfare 74.13.070
benefits Crime victims’ compensation 7.68.070(10)
Washington
General assistance 74.04.280
Federal bankruptcy exemptions available. All law references are to Revised Code
of Washington Annotated unless otherwise noted. Industrial insurance (workers’ compensation) 51.32.040
Old-age assistance 74.08.210
ASSET EXEMPTION LAW
Unemployment compensation 50.40.020
homestead Must record homestead declaration before 6.15.040
sale of home if property unimproved or home tools of trade Farmer’s trucks, stock, tools, seed, equipment, & 6.15.010(4)(a)
unoccupied supplies to $5,000 total
Real property or manufactured home to 6.13.010; Library, office furniture, office equipment, & 6.15.010(4)(b)
$125,000; unimproved property intended for 6.13.030 supplies of physician, surgeon, attorney, clergy,
residence to $15,000 (husband & wife may not or other professional to $5,000 total
double) Tools & materials used in any other trade to 6.15.010(4)(c)
insurance Annuity contract proceeds to $2,500 per month 48.18.430 $5,000
Disability proceeds, avails, or benefits 48.36A.180 wages Minimum 75% of weekly disposable earnings 6.27.150
or 30 times the federal minimum hourly wage,
Fraternal benefit society benefits 48.18.400 whichever is greater; bankruptcy judge may
Group life insurance policy or proceeds 48.18.420 authorize more for low-income debtors
Life insurance proceeds or avails if beneficiary is 48.18.410 wildcard $2,000 of any personal property (no more than 6.15.010(3)(b)
not the insured $200 in cash, bank deposits, bonds, stocks, &
miscellaneous Child support payments 6.15.010(3)(d) securities)
pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C.
401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money § 522(b)(3)(C) West Virginia
purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and
Federal bankruptcy exemptions not available. All law references are to West
defined-benefit plans
Virginia Code unless otherwise noted.
Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C.
person § 522(b)(3) ASSET EXEMPTION LAW
(C); (n) homestead Real or personal property used as residence to 38-10-4(a)
$25,000; unused portion of homestead may be
City employees 41.28.200;
applied to any property
41.44.240
insurance Fraternal benefit society benefits 33-23-21
ERISA-qualified benefits, IRAs, Roth IRAs, & 6.15.020
Keoghs Group life insurance policy or proceeds 33-6-28
Judges 2.10.180; Health or disability benefits 38-10-4(j)(3)
2.12.090 Life insurance payments from policy for person 38-10-4(k)(3)
Law enforcement officials & firefighters 41.26.053 you depended on, needed for support
Police officers 41.20.180 Unmatured life insurance contract, except 38-10-4(g)
credit insurance policy
Public & state employees 41.40.052
Unmatured life insurance contract’s accrued 38-10-4(h)
State patrol officers 43.43.310
dividend, interest, or loan value to $8,000, if
Teachers 41.32.052 debtor owns contract & insured is either debtor
Volunteer firefighters 41.24.240 or a person on whom debtor is dependent
personal Appliances, furniture, household goods, home 6.15.010(3)(a) miscellaneous Alimony, child support needed for support 38-10-4(j)(4)
property & yard equipment to $2,700 total for individual pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C.
($5,400 for community) 401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money § 522(b)(3)(C)
Books to $1,500 6.15.010(2) purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and
Burial ground 68.24.220 defined-benefit plans
Burial plots sold by nonprofit cemetery 68.20.120 Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C.
association person § 522(b)(3)(C);
Clothing, no more than $1,000 in furs, jewelry, 6.15.010(1) (n)
ornaments ERISA-qualified benefits, IRAs needed for 38-10-4(j)(5)
Fire insurance proceeds for lost, stolen, or 6.15.030 support
destroyed exempt property Public employees 5-10-46
Food & fuel for comfortable maintenance 6.15.010(3)(a) Teachers 18-7A-30
360 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
personal Animals, crops, clothing, appliances, books, 38-10-4(c) pensions Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)
property household goods, furnishings, musical (continued) person (3)(C); (n)
instruments to $400 per item, $8,000 total
Certain municipal employees 62.63(4)
Burial plot to $25,000, in lieu of homestead 38-10-4(a)
Firefighters, police officers who worked in city 815.18(3)(ef)
Health aids 38-10-4(i) with population over 100,000
Jewelry to $1,000 38-10-4(d) Military pensions 815.18(3)(n)
Lost earnings payments needed for support 38-10-4(k)(5) Private or public retirement benefits 815.18(3)(j)
Motor vehicle to $2,400 38-10-4(b)
Public employees 40.08(1)
Personal injury recoveries to $15,000 38-10-4(k)(4)
personal Burial plot, tombstone, coffin 815.18(3)(a)
Prepaid higher education tuition trust fund & 38-10-4(k)(6) property
College savings account or tuition trust fund 14.64(7); 14.63(8)
savings plan payments
Wrongful death recoveries for person you 38-10-4(k)(2) Deposit accounts to $5,000 815.18(3)(k)
depended on, needed for support Fire & casualty proceeds for destroyed 815.18(3)(e)
public Aid to blind, aged, disabled; general assistance 9-5-1 exempt property for 2 years from receiving
benefits Crime victims’ compensation 38-10-4(k)(1) Household goods & furnishings, clothing, 815.18(3)(d)
keepsakes, jewelry, appliances, books, musical
Social Security 38-10-4(j)(1)
instruments, firearms, sporting goods,
Unemployment compensation 38-10-4(j)(1) animals, & other tangible personal property
Veterans’ benefits 38-10-4(j)(2) to $12,000 total
Workers’ compensation 23-4-18 Lost future earnings recoveries, needed for 815.18(3)(i)(d)
tools of trade Implements, books, & tools of trade to $1,500 38-10-4(f) support
wages Minimum 30 times the federal minimum 38-5A-3 Motor vehicles to $4,000; unused portion of 815.18(3)(g)
hourly wage per week; bankruptcy judge may $12,000 personal property exemption may
authorize more for low-income debtors be added
wildcard $800 plus unused portion of homestead or 38-10-4(e) Personal injury recoveries to $50,000 815.18(3)(i)(c)
burial exemption, of any property Tenant’s lease or stock interest in housing 182.004(6)
co-op, to homestead amount
Wisconsin Wages used to purchase savings bonds 20.921(1)(e)
Federal bankruptcy exemptions available. All law references are to Wisconsin Wrongful death recoveries, needed for 815.18(3)(i)(b)
Statutes Annotated unless otherwise noted. support
ASSET EXEMPTION LAW public Crime victims’ compensation 949.07
homestead Property you occupy or intend to occupy to 815.20 benefits
Social services payments 49.96
$75,000; $150,000 for married couples filing
jointly; sale proceeds exempt for 2 years if you Unemployment compensation 108.13
intend to purchase another home (husband Veterans’ benefits 45.03(8)(b)
& wife may not double) Workers’ compensation 102.27
insurance Federal disability insurance benefits 815.18(3)(ds)
tools of trade Equipment, inventory, farm products, books, 815.18(3)(b)
Fraternal benefit society benefits 614.96 & tools of trade to $15,000 total
Life insurance proceeds for someone debtor 815.18(3)(i)(a) wages 75% of weekly net income or 30 times the 815.18(3)(h)
depended on, needed for support greater of the federal or state minimum
Life insurance proceeds held in trust by 632.42 hourly wage; bankruptcy judge may authorize
insurer, if clause prohibits proceeds from more for low-income debtors
being used to pay beneficiary’s creditors Wages of county jail prisoners 303.08(3)
Unmatured life insurance contract (except 815.18(3)(f) Wages of county work camp prisoners 303.10(7)
credit insurance contract) if debtor owns
contract &insured is debtor or dependents, Wages of inmates under work-release plan 303.065(4)(b)
or someone debtor is dependent on wildcard None
Unmatured life insurance contract’s accrued 815.18(3)(f)
dividends, interest, or loan value to $4,000 Wyoming
total, if debtor owns contract & insured is
Federal bankruptcy exemptions not available. All law references are to Wyoming
debtor or dependents, or someone debtor is
Statutes Annotated unless otherwise noted.
dependent on
miscellaneous Alimony, child support needed for support 815.18(3)(c) ASSET EXEMPTION LAW
Property of business partnership 178.21(3)(c) homestead Property held as tenancy by the entirety may In re Anselmi, 52
be exempt against debts owed by only one B.R. 479 (D. Wy.
pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)
spouse 1985)
401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money (3)(C)
purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and Real property you occupy to $10,000 or house 1-20-101; 102; 104
defined-benefit plans trailer you occupy to $6,000
Appendix A | State and Federal exemption charts | 361
homestead Spouse or child of deceased owner may claim 1-20-103 Federal Bankruptcy Exemptions
(continued) homestead exemption Married couples filing jointly may double all exemptions. All references are to
insurance Annuity contract proceeds to $350 per month 26-15-132 11 U.S.C. § 522. These exemptions were last adjusted in 2007. Every three years
ending on April 1, these amounts will be adjusted to reflect changes in the
Disability benefits if clause prohibits proceeds 26-15-130
Consumer Price Index. Debtors in the following states may select the federal
from being used to pay beneficiary’s creditors
bankruptcy exemptions:
Fraternal benefit society benefits 26-29-218
Arkansas Massachusetts New Jersey Texas
Group life or disability policy or proceeds, 26-15-131
cash surrender & loan values, premiums Connecticut Michigan New Mexico Vermont
waived, & dividends District of Columbia Minnesota Pennsylvania Washington
Individual life insurance policy proceeds, cash 26-15-129 Hawaii New Hampshire Rhode Island Wisconsin
surrender & loan values, premiums waived, &
Kentucky
dividends
Life insurance proceeds held by insurer, if 26-15-133 ASSET EXEMPTION SUBSECTION
clause prohibits proceeds from being used to homestead Real property, including co-op or mobile home, (d)(1); (d)(5)
pay beneficiary’s creditors or burial plot to $20,200; unused portion of
miscellaneous Liquor licenses & malt beverage permits 12-4-604 homestead to $10,125 may be applied to any
property
pensions Tax-exempt retirement accounts, including 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)
401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money (3)(C) insurance Disability, illness, or unemployment benefits (d)(10)(C)
purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and
Life insurance payments from policy for person (d)(11)(C)
defined-benefit plans
you depended on, needed for support
Traditional and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)
Life insurance policy with loan value, in accrued (d)(8)
person (3)(C); (n)
dividends or interest, to $10,775
Criminal investigators, highway officers 9-3-620
Unmatured life insurance contract, except (d)(7)
Firefighters’ death benefits 15-5-209 credit insurance policy
Game & fish wardens 9-3-620 miscellaneous Alimony, child support needed for support (d)(10)(D)
Police officers 15-5-313(c) pensions Tax exempt retirement accounts (including (b)(3)(C)
Private or public retirement funds & accounts 1-20-110 401(k)s, 403(b)s, profit-sharing and money
purchase plans, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, and
Public employees 9-3-426
defined-benefit plans
personal Bedding, furniture, household articles, & food 1-20-106(a)(iii)
property IRAs and Roth IRAs to $1,095,000 per person (b)(3)(C)(n)
to $2,000 per person in the home
Bible, schoolbooks, & pictures 1-20-106(a)(i)
personal Animals, crops, clothing, appliances, books, (d)(3)
Burial plot 1-20-106(a)(ii) property furnishings, household goods, musical
Clothing & wedding rings to $1,000 1-20-105 instruments to $525 per item, $10,775 total
Medical savings account contributions 1-20-111 Health aids (d)(9)
Motor vehicle to $2,400 1-20-106(a)(iv) Jewelry to $1,350 (d)(4)
Prepaid funeral contracts 26-32-102 Lost earnings payments (d)(11)(E)
public Crime victims’ compensation 1-40-113 Motor vehicle to $3,225 (d)(2)
benefits
General assistance 42-2-113(b) Personal injury recoveries to $20,200 (not to (d)(11)(D)
Unemployment compensation 27-3-319 include pain & suffering or pecuniary loss)
Workers’ compensation 27-14-702 Wrongful death recoveries for person you (d)(11)(B)
depended on
tools of trade Library & implements of profession to $2,000 1-20-106(b)
or tools, motor vehicle, implements, team & public Crime victims’ compensation (d)(11)(A)
stock in trade to $2,000 benefits
Federal Nonbankruptcy Exemptions miscellaneous Indian lands or homestead sales or lease 25 § 410
These exemptions are available only if you select your state exemptions. You proceeds
may use them for any exemptions in addition to those allowed by your state, but Klamath Indian tribe benefits for Indians residing 25 §§ 543;
they cannot be claimed if you file using federal bankruptcy exemptions. All law in Oregon 545
references are to the United States Code. Military deposits in savings accounts while on 10 § 1035
ASSET EXEMPTION LAW permanent duty outside U.S.
death & Government employees 5 § 8130 Military group life insurance 38 § 1970(g)
disability Longshoremen & harbor workers 33 § 916 Railroad workers’ unemployment insurance 45 § 352(e)
benefits
War risk, hazard, death, or injury compensation 42 § 1717 Seamen’s clothing 46 § 11110
retirement Civil service employees 5 § 8346 Seamen’s wages (while on a voyage) pursuant to 46 § 11109
a written contract
Foreign Service employees 22 § 4060
Minimum 75% of disposable weekly earnings 15 § 1673
Military Medal of Honor roll pensions 38 § 1562(c)
or 30 times the federal minimum hourly wage,
Military service employees 10 § 1440 whichever is more; bankruptcy judge may
Railroad workers 45 § 231m authorize more for low-income debtors
Social Security 42 § 407
Veterans’ benefits 38 § 5301
l
survivor’s Judges, U.S. court & judicial center directors, 28 § 376
benefits administrative assistants to U.S. Supreme Court
Chief Justice
Lighthouse workers 33 § 775
Military service 10 § 1450
B
appendi x
■■ Antiques ■■ Photographs
■■ Clocks Apparel
■■ Dishes ■■ Clothing
■■ Food (total value) ■■ Furs
■■ Furniture (list every item; go from room to room
so you don’t miss anything) Jewelry
■■ Gardening tools ■■ Engagement and wedding rings
■■ Lamps ■■ Watches
■■ Ski equipment Other debts for which the amount owed you is
■■ Other sports equipment known and definite
■■ Other weapons (swords and knives) ■■ Disability benefits due
■■ Disability insurance due
Interests in insurance policies
■■ Judgments obtained against third parties you
■■ Credit insurance
haven’t yet collected
■■ Disability insurance
■■ Sick pay earned
■■ Health insurance
■■ Social Security benefits due
■■ Homeowners’ or renters’ insurance
■■ Tax refund due under returns already filed
■■ Term life insurance
■■ Vacation pay earned
■■ Whole life insurance
■■ Wages due
Annuities ■■ Workers’ compensation due
Pension or profit-sharing plans Any special powers that you or another person can
■■ IRA exercise for your benefit, other than those listed under
“real estate”
■■ Keogh
■■ A right to receive, at some future time, cash, stock,
■■ Pension or retirement plan or other personal property placed in an irrevocable
■■ 401(k) plan trust
■■ Current payments of interest or principal from a
Stock and interests in incorporated and
trust
unincorporated companies
■■ General power of appointment over personal
■■ Corporate shares
property
■■ Stock options
■■ LLC membership An interest in property due to another person’s death
■■ Sole proprietorship business ■■ Any interest as the beneficiary of a living trust, if
the trustor has died
Interests in partnerships ■■ Expected proceeds from a life insurance policy
■■ Limited partnership interest where the insured has died
■■ General partnership interest ■■ Inheritance from an existing estate in probate
(the owner has died and the court is overseeing
Government and corporate bonds and other the distribution of the property), even if the final
investment instruments amount is not yet known
■■ Corporate bonds
■■ Outboard motor
1 2 3 4
Replacement
Property Value Exemption Statute No.
1. Cash on hand
6. Clothing
10. Annuities
15. Bonds
30. Inventory
31. Animals
10. Do you own the property with your spouse in “tenancy by the entirety”?
■■ Yes. See the instructions and talk to a bankruptcy attorney to find out
whether your house is fully protected.
■■ No. Go on to Line 11.
8. Exemption amount..................................................................................................................$
If Line 8 is greater than Line 7 you can stop here—you can eliminate all
judicial liens. Otherwise, go on to Line 9.
Alaska $52,130 $74,073 $77,544 $85,422 Nebraska $40,352 $56,861 $63,702 $72,542
Arizona $42,628 $56,894 $62,066 $69,452 Nevada $46,316 $60,449 $67,052 $71,104
Arkansas $33,531 $44,415 $48,721 $57,905 New Hampshire $51,515 $64,204 $79,668 $93,926
California $48,140 $64,878 $70,890 $79,477 New Jersey $60,026 $72,000 $86,070 $103,261
Colorado $47,253 $64,985 $69,977 $81,644 New Mexico $36,773 $50,637 $50,637 $55,561
Connecticut $58,529 $72,586 $86,643 $102,124 New York $46,485 $58,109 $69,421 $82,457
Delaware $46,414 $60,953 $70,075 $88,725 North Carolina $38,794 $52,194 $56,930 $67,295
DC $42,270 $68,892 $69,294 $69,294 North Dakota $36,884 $54,662 $62,635 $75,140
Florida $41,226 $52,259 $58,574 $69,009 Ohio $41,873 $52,216 $61,772 $73,301
Georgia $40,691 $55,258 $61,104 $68,502 Oklahoma $39,068 $50,891 $54,522 $62,037
Hawaii $55,418 $67,199 $77,539 $91,483 Oregon $42,495 $56,019 $62,832 $72,667
Idaho $39,625 $51,474 $52,765 $62,051 Pennsylvania $44,555 $53,763 $67,757 $77,867
Illinois $46,105 $60,052 $71,329 $81,465 Rhode Island $45,222 $62,806 $76,846 $87,002
Indiana $40,828 $52,554 $59,650 $70,873 South Carolina $39,191 $51,374 $55,296 $65,655
Iowa $40,061 $55,284 $64,372 $72,961 South Dakota $36,844 $54,331 $63,153 $70,182
Kansas $41,357 $57,767 $63,438 $72,610 Tennessee $37,732 $49,110 $54,014 $64,228
Kentucky $37,584 $45,653 $54,683 $64,459 Texas $38,940 $55,859 $59,222 $66,381
Louisiana $37,464 $48,287 $53,461 $66,256 Utah $50,568 $56,932 $61,905 $69,990
Maine $38,812 $50,912 $62,076 $70,374 Vermont $41,742 $56,858 $65,326 $74,163
Maryland $55,238 $73,061 $85,455 $101,803 Virginia $48,362 $65,122 $74,151 $85,939
Massachusetts $53,505 $69,451 $82,591 $99,648 Washington $51,344 $64,158 $72,533 $82,716
Michigan $43,611 $52,620 $61,737 $74,824 West Virginia $39,275 $43,224 $51,836 $58,479
Minnesota $45,262 $62,384 $75,073 $86,637 Wisconsin $42,356 $57,405 $68,123 $80,530
Mississippi $32,068 $42,758 $46,685 $58,518 Wyoming $44,161 $59,830 $65,820 $76,964
Missouri $39,645 $51,568 $60,371 $71,059 * Add $6,900 for each individual in excess of 4.
C
appendi x
Tear-Out Forms
Exhibit “C”
[If, to the best of the debtor’s knowledge, the debtor owns or has possession of property
that poses or is alleged to pose a threat of imminent and identifiable harm to the public health or
safety, attach this Exhibit “C” to the petition.]
1. Identify and briefly describe all real or personal property owned by or in possession of
the debtor that, to the best of the debtor’s knowledge, poses or is alleged to pose a threat of
imminent and identifiable harm to the public health or safety (attach additional sheets if
necessary):
................................................................................................................................................
................................................................................................................................................
................................................................................................................................................
................................................................................................................................................
2. With respect to each parcel of real property or item of personal property identified in
question 1, describe the nature and location of the dangerous condition, whether environmental
or otherwise, that poses or is alleged to pose a threat of imminent and identifiable harm to the
public health or safety (attach additional sheets if necessary):
................................................................................................................................................
................................................................................................................................................
................................................................................................................................................
................................................................................................................................................
D
appendi x
Pleadings
are colorfully called “scream or die” the judge signs to grant your request.
motions—see the sample Notice of Motion Specify exactly what property the creditor
and Motion to Avoid Judicial Lien on has secured in the space indicated in the
Real Estate, below, for language you can sample. You can get this information
use instead of a formal notice if your from the s ecurity agreement you signed.
district follows this procedure.) Because Make two extra copies, and take them
motions to avoid liens are usually pretty with you to the hearing if there is one. The
straightforward and are usually granted, court’s local rules may require you to file
many creditors don’t bother to respond. If the proposed order with the rest of your
they do, however, either you or the creditor motion papers.
will have to schedule a hearing. Step 8: Prepare at least two Proofs of Service by
Step 6: If a hearing is required, call the court clerk Mail, one for each affected creditor and
and give your name and case number. Say one for the trustee. These forms state that
you’d like to file a motion to avoid a lien a friend or relative of yours, who is at
and need to find out when and where the least 18 years old and not a party to the
judge will hear arguments on your motion. bankruptcy, mailed your papers to the
Under some local rules the clerk will give creditor(s) or the trustee. Fill in the blanks
you a hearing date; ask for one at least 31 as indicated. Have your friend sign and
days in the future, because you must mail date the form at the end as shown on the
notice of your motion to the creditor at sample. See “How to Serve the Creditor,”
least 30 days before the hearing (unless below, for more information.
local rules set a different time limit). Write Step 9: Make at least three extra copies of all
down the information. If the clerk won’t forms.
give you the information over the phone,
Step 10: Keep the proofs of service. Have your
go to the bankruptcy court with a copy
friend mail one copy of the motion, notice
of your motion filled out. File that form
of motion, and proposed order to each
and schedule the hearing. Write down the
affected creditor and the trustee.
information about when and where your
motion will be heard by the judge. Step 11: File (in person or by mail) the original
If there will be a hearing, prepare a (signed) notice of motion, motion (and
Notice of Motion that lists the date, time, proposed order, if required in your area),
and place of the hearing. (See the sample and proof of service with the bankruptcy
Notice of Motion to Avoid Nonpossessory, court.
Non-Purchase-Money Security Interest, Step 12: The trustee or creditors affected by your
below.) If you are filing in a district that motion may submit a written response.
requires a hearing only if the creditor However, most courts will grant your
requests one, use the language in the motion if the trustee or creditor doesn’t file
sample Notice of Motion and Motion to a response to the motion and you ask the
Avoid Judicial Lien on Real Estate, below, court to enter a default judgment in your
to give the creditor proper notice of this favor (see Step 14, below).
procedure. Step 13: If there is a hearing, attend it. The hearing
Step 7: Prepare a proposed Order to Avoid usually lasts ten minutes or less. Because
Nonpossessory, Non-Purchase-Money you filed the motion, you argue your side
Security Interest. This is the document first. Explain briefly how your property
536 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
See an Expert
Get an attorney, if you need one. If you are
having trouble figuring out how to draft the necessary
paperwork to avoid a lien, think about asking a lawyer
for help—especially if the lien is substantial.
APPenDix D | PLEADINGS | 537
In re )
[Set forth here all names including married, )
maiden, and trade names used by debtor )
within last 8 years.] ) Case No.
Debtor )
) [Special number for Avoidance of Lien motions,
Address ) if any]
)
) Chapter 7
)
Last four digits of Social Security or Individual )
Taxpayer Identification (ITIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
Employer’s Tax Identification (EIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
and security agreement granting to [name of creditor] a security interest in and on the debtor’s personal
property, which consisted of [items held as security as they are listed in your loan agreement] which are held
primarily for the family and household use of the debtors and their dependents.
4. All such possessions of debtors have been claimed as fully exempt in their bankruptcy case.
5. The money borrowed from [name of creditor] does not represent any part of the purchase money
of any of the articles covered in the security agreement executed by the debtors, and all of the articles so
covered remain in the possession of the debtors.
6. The existence of [name of creditor]’s lien on debtor’s household and personal goods impairs
exemptions to which the debtors would be entitled under 11 U.S.C. § 522(b).
538 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
WHEREFORE, pursuant to 11 U.S.C. § 522(f), debtors pray for an order avoiding the security interest in
their personal and household goods, and for such additional or alternative relief as may be just and proper.
In re )
[Set forth here all names including married, )
maiden, and trade names used by debtor )
within last 8 years.] ) Case No.
Debtor )
) [Special number for Avoidance of Lien motions,
Address ) if any]
)
) Chapter 7
)
Last four digits of Social Security or Individual )
Taxpayer Identification (ITIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
Employer’s Tax Identification (EIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
In re )
[Set forth here all names including married, )
maiden, and trade names used by debtor )
within last 8 years.] )
Debtor ) Case No.
) [Special number for Avoidance of Lien motions,
Address ) if any]
)
) Chapter 7
)
Last four digits of Social Security or Individual )
Taxpayer Identification (ITIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
Employer’s Tax Identification (EIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
Unless debtor’s bankruptcy case is dismissed, the lien of the respondent is hereby extinguished and the
lien shall not survive bankruptcy or affix to or remain enforceable against the aforementioned property of the
debtor.
[name of creditor] shall take all necessary steps to remove any record of the lien from
the aforementioned property of the debtor.
Sample Notice of Motion and Motion to Avoid Judicial Lien on Real Estate
In re )
[Set forth here all names including married, )
maiden, and trade names used by debtor )
within last 8 years.] )
Debtor ) Case No.
) [Special number for Avoidance of Lien motions,
Address ) if any]
)
) Chapter 7
)
Last four digits of Social Security or Individual )
Taxpayer Identification (ITIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
Employer’s Tax Identification (EIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that Debtor [debtor’s name] is moving the court to avoid a
judicial lien held by [name of lien owner] on certain real property owned by the Debtor.
This motion is being brought under procedures prescribed by [local bankruptcy rule allowing motion
to be decided without a hearing unless the creditor objects] .
If you wish to object to the motion, or request a hearing on the motion, your objection and/or request
must be filed and served upon Debtor within 20 days of the date this notice was mailed.
You must accompany any request you make for a hearing, or any objection to the relief sought by
Debtor(s), with any declarations or memoranda of law you wish to present in support of your position.
If you do not make a timely objection to the requested relief, or a timely request for hearing, the court may
enter an order granting the relief by default and either 1) set a tentative hearing date or 2) require that Debtors
provide you at least 10 days written notice of hearing (in the event an objection or request for hearing is timely
made).
1. Debtor [debtor’s name] commenced this case on [date of
bankruptcy filing] by filing a voluntary petition for relief under Chapter 7 of Title 11 of the United States
Bankruptcy Code.
APPenDix D | PLEADINGS | 543
Sample Notice of Motion and Motion to Avoid Judicial Lien on Real Estate (continued)
2. This court has jurisdiction over this motion, filed pursuant to 11 U.S.C. Sec. 522(f), to avoid and cancel
a judicial lien held by [name of lien owner] on real property used as the debtors’ residence, under 28 U.S.C.
Sec. 1334.
3. On [date of lien being recorded] , creditors recorded a judicial lien against the debtors’ residence at
[address] . The said judicial lien is
In re )
[Set forth here all names including married, )
maiden, and trade names used by debtor )
within last 8 years.] ) Case No.
Debtor )
) [Special number for Avoidance of Lien motions,
Address ) if any]
)
) Chapter 7
)
Last four digits of Social Security or Individual )
Taxpayer Identification (ITIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
Employer’s Tax Identification (EIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
caused a Notice of Motion and Motion to Avoid Judicial Lien on Real Estate to be served on [name
of person served on behalf of lien owner] .
2. A copy of the Notice of Motion and Motion and a proposed order are attached to this request. Also
attached is a Proof of Service of this request on [name of lien owner] , the
Trustee, and the U.S. Trustee.
3. The Trustee and the U.S. Trustee were also served with the Notice of Motion and Motion on [date
notice and motion served].
4. A proof of service duly executed by [name of person who mailed the notice]
as to service of the Notice of Motion and Motion is on file with the court.
5. The Notice of Motion and Motion complies in all respects with [local bankruptcy rule allowing motion
to be decided without a hearing unless the creditor objects] .
APPenDix D | PLEADINGS | 545
6. The Debtor has received no response from any of the served parties as of the date of this request, more
than 20 days after the service of the Notice of Motion and Motion.
WHEREFORE, Debtor respectfully requests that the court enter by default the attached Order to Avoid
Judicial Lien on Real Estate.
1
AGREEMENT FOR LUMP SUM REDEMPTION OF PROPERTY
2 (Debtor)
3 and (Creditor) agree that:
4 1. Creditor owns a security interest in (Collateral).
6
3. Creditor’s security interest is valid and enforceable despite the Debtor’s bankruptcy case.
4. Debtor agrees to pay the full value of the collateral no later than .
7
5. Upon receiving the payment specified in Paragraph 4, Creditor will take all steps necessary to
8
terminate its security interest in Collateral.
9
10 Dated:
Debtor in Propria Persona
11
12
Dated:
Creditor
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Agreement for Lump Sum Redemption of Property
548 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
2 (Debtor) and
12 7. If Debtor defaults, Creditor will have its rights under the original contract.
13
Dated:
14 Debtor in Propria Persona
15 Dated:
Creditor
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Agreement for Installment Redemption of Property
Appendix D | Pleadings | 549
In re )
[Set forth here all names including married, )
maiden, and trade names used by debtor )
within last 8 years.] )
Debtor ) Case No.
)
Address )
)
) Chapter 7
)
Last four digits of Social Security or Individual )
Taxpayer Identification (ITIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
Employer’s Tax Identification (EIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
Presented herewith are the original and one copy of the following:
■■ Voluntary Petition (Note: Spouse may not be added or deleted subsequent to initial filing.)
■■ Schedule H—Codebtors
■■ Summary of Schedules
■■ I have enclosed a $26 fee because I am adding new creditors or changing addresses after the
I (we)
and ,
the debtor(s) in this case, declare under penalty of perjury that the information set forth in the amendment
attached hereto consisting of pages is true and correct to the best of my (our) information and
belief.
Dated: , 20
In re )
[Set forth here all names including married, )
maiden, and trade names used by debtor )
within last 8 years.] )
Debtor ) Case No.
)
Address )
) Chapter 7
)
)
Last four digits of Social Security or Individual )
Taxpayer Identification (ITIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
Employer’s Tax Identification (EIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
Signature of Debtor
In re )
[Set forth here all names including married, )
maiden, and trade names used by debtor )
within last 8 years.] )
Debtor(s) ) Case No.
Address )
)
) Chapter 7
)
Last four digits of Social Security or Individual )
Taxpayer Identification (ITIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
Employer’s Tax Identification (EIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
Dated:
Signature of Debtor
Dated:
Signature of Debtor’s Spouse
556 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
In re . )
[Set forth here all names including married, )
maiden, and trade names used by debtor )
within last 8 years.] )
Debtor(s) ) Case No.
Address )
)
) Chapter 7
)
Last four digits of Social Security or Individual )
Taxpayer Identification (ITIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
Employer’s Tax Identification (EIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
Dated:
U.S. Bankruptcy Judge
APPenDix D | PLEADINGS | 557
In re )
[Set forth here all names including married, )
maiden, and trade names used by debtor )
within last 8 years.] )
Debtor(s) ) Case No.
Address )
)
) Chapter 7
)
Last four digits of Social Security or Individual )
Taxpayer Identification (ITIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
Employer’s Tax Identification (EIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
7. Wherefore Applicant prays that the above-entitled case be reopened for the purpose of
permitting Applicant to file Official Form 23 and move the Court for a discharge in [his/her] Chapter 7
bankruptcy case.
Dated: Signed:
[your name]
APPenDix D | PLEADINGS | 559
In re )
[Set forth here all names including married, )
maiden, and trade names used by debtor )
within last 8 years.] )
Debtor ) Case No.
)
Address )
)
) Chapter 7
)
Last four digits of Social Security or Individual )
Taxpayer Identification (ITIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
Employer’s Tax Identification (EIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
Based on debtor’s Ex-Parte Application to Reopen Closed Case and applicable law, it is hereby ordered
that Case No: [case number] be reopened for the purpose of permitting Applicant to file Official Form 23 and
apply for an order of discharge under 11 U.S.C. Section 727.
Date: Signed:
U.S. Bankruptcy Judge
560 | BANKRUPTCY FOR SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS: HOW TO FILE FOR CHAPTER 7
In re )
[Set forth here all names including married, )
maiden, and trade names used by debtor )
within last 8 years.] )
Debtor ) Case No.
)
Address )
)
) Chapter 7
)
Last four digits of Social Security or Individual )
Taxpayer Identification (ITIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
Employer’s Tax Identification (EIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
Date: Signed:
[your name]
APPenDix D | PLEADINGS | 561
In re )
[Set forth here all names including married, )
maiden, and trade names used by debtor )
within last 8 years.] )
Debtor ) Case No.
)
Address )
)
) Chapter 7
)
Last four digits of Social Security or Individual )
Taxpayer Identification (ITIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
Employer’s Tax Identification (EIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
Based on debtor’s Ex-Parte Application for the Court to Enter an Order of Discharge, it is hereby ordered
that a discharge be entered under 11 U.S.C. Section 727 in Case No. [case number] .
Date: Signed:
U.S. Bankruptcy Judge
562 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
In re )
[Set forth here all names including married, )
maiden, and trade names used by debtor )
within last 8 years.] )
Debtor ) Case No.
)
Address )
) Chapter 7
)
)
Last four digits of Social Security or Individual )
Taxpayer Identification (ITIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
Employer’s Tax Identification (EIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
This property was obtained through an inheritance, marital settlement agreement or divorce decree,
death benefits or life insurance proceeds, or other (specify):
I (we) and
,
the debtor(s) in this case, declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
Dated: , 20
Signature of Debtor
In re )
[Set forth here all names including married, )
maiden, and trade names used by debtor )
within last 8 years.] )
Debtor ) Case No.
)
Address )
)
) Chapter 7
)
Last four digits of Social Security or Individual )
Taxpayer Identification (ITIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
Employer’s Tax Identification (EIN) No(s). (if any): )
)
I, , declare that: I am a
resident or employed in the County of , State of .
My residence/business address is
. I am over the age of eighteen years and not a party to this case.
on the following parties by placing true and correct copies thereof enclosed in a sealed envelope with postage
thereon fully prepaid in the United States Mail at ,
addressed as follows:
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct, and that this declaration was
executed on
Date: , 20 at
City and State
Signature
l
Index
Exhibit D, 147, 158, 163–165 current monthly income, 19, 203, 230–233,
instructions, 158–163 235, 269, 270
Form 3A—Application to Pay Filing Fee in expenses and disposable income, 235–245,
Installments, 160, 247 268–270
Form 3B—Application for Waiver of the Chapter 7 median income comparison, 233–235
Filing Fee, 155, 247, 248 See also Means test
Form 6—Schedules, 154–155. See also specific Form 23—Debtor’s Certification of Postpetition
schedules Instructional Course Concerning Personal Financial
Form 7—Statement of Financial Affairs, 102, Management, 147, 148, 156, 262, 276
210–224 Form 27—Reaffirmation Agreement Cover Sheet,
amending, 265, 266, 267 137–138
assignments and receiverships, 215 Form 201A—Notice to Consumer Debtors Under
business information, 177, 219, 224 §342(b) of the Bankruptcy Code, 245, 257
court actions, garnishments and attachments, Form 201B, 245
213, 215 Form 240A—Reaffirmation Agreement, 138
definitions section, 211 Form 240B—Motion for Approval of Reaffirmation
environmental information, 219 Agreement, 138
gifts made, 215 Form 240C—Order on Reaffirmation Agreement,
income, 211 138
other property transfers, 215, 217 Forms and documents, 147–249
payments related to debt counseling or amending your papers, 148, 252, 257, 265–267,
bankruptcy, 215 297, 549–551
payments to creditors, 211, 213 basic filing procedure, 16–17, 148, 246–248
prior addresses, 219 checklists, 154–156
property held for others, 217, 219 continuation pages, 157
property losses, 215 credit counseling certificate, 147–149
spouses and former spouses, 219 emergency filings, 148, 158, 248
Form 8—Chapter 7 Individual Debtor’s Statement errors and omissions, 156, 170, 193, 257, 258,
of Intention, 132, 133, 134, 224–229 265–267, 290–291, 295
amending, 265, 266 filing fees, 16, 17, 151, 247–248, 308
deadlines for dealing with property, 58, 133, fraudulent, 156
247, 261–262 getting help with, 157, 305, 307–309
extra copies, 246 local forms and rules, 150–152, 245–246, 247,
failure to file, 58, 59 248, 318
judicial lien avoidance, 140 making copies, 151, 156, 246, 265
leases and contracts on, 197, 199, 225, 227 paycheck stubs, 150, 155
serving on creditors, 247 preparing for creditors’ meeting, 256, 257
trustee questions about, 260 responsibility for accuracy, 261, 309, 310
Form 21—Full Social Security Number Disclosure, sample forms, 157
158, 229, 248 signatures, 163
Form 22A—Chapter 7 Statement of Current tax return requirement, 148, 149, 155, 211
Monthly Income and Means Test Calculation, tips for completing, 156–157
19–20, 155, 229–245 trustee questions about, 258, 259
index | 577
Insiders IRS
defined, 211 attempts to collect discharged tax debts, 286
listing payments and transfers to, 213 audits, 254, 287–288
paying after filing, 213 effect of automatic stay on, 56, 57
preference payments to, 31, 40, 75–76, 213 expense standards for means test, 235–239
pre-filing property transfers to, 71, 72, 73–74 requesting tax return transcript, 149, 288
Insolvency, 75–76, 143 Substitute for Return filing by, 287
Installment payments tax assessment notices from, 287–288
of filing fees, 160, 247 tax lien basics, 131
listing on Schedule J, 207 value discount, minority business interests,
redemption agreements, 546, 548 95–96
See also Debt payments See also Tax entries
Insurance contracts, 31, 197, 271
Insurance expenses, in means test calculations, J
236, 238, 239 Jewelry, 96, 140
Insurance proceeds Joint bankruptcy filing
for exempt property, 215 basics, 153–154
federal exemptions, 361, 362 doubling of exemptions, 70, 88, 99, 120–121,
received after filing, 65, 77, 249, 266, 294–295, 153, 181, 273, 326
299 expenses for separate households, 270
state exemptions listed, 328–361 marital property in bankruptcy estate, 68
unemployment benefits, 204, 233 same-sex couples, 10, 69–70
Intangible property, 64, 93–94, 179, 271. See also spousal debt liability and, 10, 11–12, 153–154
specific types tenancy by the entirety property and, 120
Intellectual property, 64, 66–67, 93, 271 Joint debts. See Codebtors; Marital debts
executory contracts, 199 Jointly owned property, 167
licenses, 177, 197 bank accounts, 79, 173, 219
royalty income, 66–67, 204, 211, 233 as bankruptcy estate, 70, 78, 79
Intentional fraud, 289, 299 changing title before filing, 70, 72, 79,
Intentional injury, 117, 274, 290, 292 102–103
Interest, below-market, 215 co-owners as codebtors, 185
Interest charges, 288 selling a portion of your home, 124
Interest income, 203–204, 211, 233 unmarried couples, 70
Internet service, 239 See also Marital property
Interrogatories, 293 Joint ventures, 173
Intoxicated driving, debts arising from, 30, 191, Judgment liens. See Judicial liens
283 Judgment proof status, 34, 38
Inventories. See Business inventories Judgments. See Money judgments
Investments, 64, 66. See also Financial accounts; Judgments for possession, 60–61, 163
specific investment types Judicial estoppel, 66
Ipso facto clauses, security agreements, 133 Judicial foreclosures, 35, 56
IRAs, 78, 173, 327. See also Retirement accounts Judicial liens, 37, 185, 187
Irrevocable trusts, 65, 67, 74–75 as assets, 167
future interests in trust property, 166, 167, 175 basics, 130–131
580 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
lien avoidance, 110–111, 138, 140–143, 310, for pre-filing planning, 100
541–545 as secured creditors, 185, 188
on your home, 110–111, 112, 280 selecting and hiring, 312, 313–314
See also Liens unbundled services, 308–309, 310, 311–312
Judicial Lien Worksheet, 141, 142 when you may need, 309–310
See also Legal fees
K Leases, 26, 37–38
Keogh plans. See Retirement accounts as business assets, 93
Kidnapping, 290. See also Willful and malicious commercial, 25–26, 37, 39, 59–60, 93, 271
acts dischargeability of lease debts, 279
effect of automatic stay, 59–61
L equipment leases, 37–38, 197, 225, 278
Landlords if you’re behind on your payments, 197
lawsuits by, 37 listing income from, 203
motions to lift stay, 60 listing on schedules, 166, 197–199
refusal to rent based on bankruptcy filing, 302 listing payment delinquencies, 197
See also Evictions; Leases; Rental property; ownership interests in, 271
Renters residential, 37, 59, 60–61, 118
Larceny, 290 sole proprietors, 30
Law library research, 314–316, 317, 319–320 Statement of Intention, 224–229
Lawsuits vehicle leases, 35, 78, 197, 199
by bankruptcy trustees, 73 what happens to them in bankruptcy, 26, 199,
by business buyers, 38–39 224–225
coparties as codebtors, 185 See also Contracts; Rent entries
by creditors, 34, 35, 36–37, 297, 309 Legal advice
listing on Form 7, 213 BPPs and, 307, 308, 309
by LLC or corporation creditors, 47 See also Lawyers
pre-filing transactions and, 72 Legal claims. See Causes of action
prior, involving fraud, 292 Legal document assistants/preparers, 308
to stop collection efforts, 299 Legal fees, 307
See also Causes of action; Money judgments business entity filings, 49
Lawyers, 309–314 Chapter 11 bankruptcy, 44–45
assignments for benefit of creditors and, 47–48 Chapter 13 bankruptcy, 43
for Chapter 7 business filings, 49 contingent claims held by lawyers, 185, 188
for Chapter 13 bankruptcy, 43 as debts, 20, 55, 128, 281, 313
at creditors’ meeting, 256, 310 for full-service representation, 310–311,
as debt relief agencies, 304, 309 312–313
disclosing fees on bankruptcy forms, 313 listing on Statement of Financial Affairs, 215
fees, 307, 310–311, 312–313 Rule 2016 disclosure, 313
full-service representation, 310–311, 312–313 typical amounts, Chapter 7 filings, 17, 43,
for help negotiating with creditors, 37, 40, 45, 312–313
310 for unbundled services, 311
for help protecting real estate, 106 Legal research, 88, 241, 314–321
for help recovering seized property, 275 background materials, 315–316
index | 581
bankruptcy law sources, 314–315 Living trusts, 65, 77, 117, 167, 175
credit card debt dischargeability, 293 LLCs (limited liability companies), 160
federal cases, 318–319 bankruptcy filings by, 1, 6, 21, 48–49, 224
federal statutes, 316–317 bankruptcy trustee’s powers, 23–25, 26
local rules, 316, 318 business debt liability of owners, 1, 6, 7–9, 39,
special circumstances, means test, 269–270 46
state statutes and cases, 319–320 concerns about company assets, 309
Liability for debts. See Business debt liability; dischargeability of business debts, 30, 32
Personal liability effect of automatic stay, 54–55
Liability insurance, 31 homes owned by, 106
Libel, 290. See also Willful and malicious acts liability for personal debts of owners, 24–25,
Licenses, license agreements, 177, 197 300–301
Lien avoidance, 96, 132, 136–143, 225 listing ownership interest on schedule, 173
basics, 138 multimember LLCs, 23–25
judicial liens, 110–111, 138, 140–143, 310, ownership interest as bankruptcy estate
541–545 property, 64
liens on your home, 110–111, 115, 141, 143 selling ownership interest before filing, 71
nonpossessory, non-purchase-money security single-member LLCs (limited liability
interests, 138–140, 534–540 companies), 24, 48, 300
oversecured property, 141 taking property from, before filing, 31
personal property liens, 138–140 valuing ownership interest, 95–96
Liens voluntary dissolution/liquidation, 39–40,
as assets, 167 46–48, 49
basics, 20, 128–131, 187, 280 See also Buy-sell agreements
charging orders, 23–24 Loans
listing on schedules, 169–170, 185–189 borrowing money after filing, 17
paying off in follow-up Chapter 13 bankruptcy, for business funding, 8–9, 19
143 for Chapter 11 bankruptcies, 45
on personal property, 96 cosigners or guarantors, 32, 185, 194, 201
recording requirements, 115, 129, 130 as dischargeable debts, 279
remaining after discharge, 8, 20, 107, 108, 132 to finance workouts, 45
researching, 112, 130–131, 169–170 loan applications, 9, 30, 31, 205, 258, 289
tax liens, 56 to pay off nondischargeable debts, 103, 288
on your home, 36, 107, 108, 112, 115, 170 from pension plans, 30, 42, 57
See also Lien avoidance; Secured creditors; personal assets as collateral, 8, 35
Secured debts; Secured property personal liability for, 1, 6, 8–9
Life estates, 167, 175 personal loans, 30, 130
Life insurance, 96, 238, 266, 294–295, 299 refinancing, 123, 284
trustee questions about, 259, 260 repaying loans you made to business, before
Liquidating your business, 39–41 filing, 31
corporations and LLCs, 46–48, 49 setoffs, 36, 217
Liquidation bankruptcy, Chapter 7 bankruptcy as, types of secured loans, 129–130
16, 41, 48–49 See also Mortgages; Secured debts; Student
Living expenses. See Expenses; specific types loans; Vehicle loans
582 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
Look-back periods, pre-filing transactions, 71, spouses as codebtors, 10–12, 153–154, 185, 187,
72–73, 75–76, 121, 211, 217 201, 246
Lump sum redemption agreements, 546, 547 spouse’s income in means test calculations, 230,
Luxury debts, 30, 31, 42, 289–290, 310 233, 235
Luxury expenses, 204, 205 wage garnishments, 37
See also Divorce; Marital debts; Marital property
M Materialman’s liens. See Mechanics’ liens
Mailing matrix, 158, 245–246, 248, 252 Means test, 42, 229–245
amending, 265, 266, 267 basics, 18–20, 205, 229, 235
Mandatory credit counseling. See Credit business debtor exception, 18–19, 160, 229, 230,
counseling requirement 268
Marital debts, 10–12, 153–154, 185, 187, 298 current monthly income, 19, 203, 230–233,
dischargeability of debts owed to spouses, 282 235, 269, 270
ex-spouses as codebtors, 185, 194, 246 defending a motion to dismiss or convert,
spousal debt liability, 10–12, 153–154, 185, 187, 268–270
201 disabled veterans exception, 19, 230
Marital property disposable income calculations, 20, 205,
as bankruptcy estate property, 67–70, 166 235–245, 268–270
fraudulent title changes, 102–103 if you fail, 229, 245, 267, 309
identifying on schedules, 169, 179 income above state median, 20, 229, 235–245
joint vs. separate filing and, 153–154 income below state median, 19, 235
tenancy by the entirety property, 11, 69, 106, online calculator, 19, 20, 229
119–120, 153 postponing bankruptcy filing, 235
See also Common law states; Community presumed abuse and, 205, 229, 245, 267–268
property states special circumstances, 245, 268–270
Marital settlement agreements Mechanics’ liens, 131, 185, 187
debts arising from, 42, 281 as assets, 167
property received through, 249, 266 on your home, 110, 112
See also Divorce See also Liens
Marital trusts, 167 Median income comparison, 19, 229, 233–235. See
Market value. See Valuation of property also Means test
Married couples Medicaid, 55
common law marriages, 152–153 Medical debts, 20, 30, 55, 128, 279
creditors’ meeting attendance, 255–256 Medicare, 55
doubling of exemptions for, 70, 88, 99, Meeting of creditors. See Creditors’ meeting
120–121, 153, 181, 273, 326 Mental incapacity, 149
home equity, separate filers, 106 Military personnel
husband-wife sole proprietorships, 7, 68 excepted from credit counseling requirement,
joint vs. separate filing, 153–154 149
listing separate filing by spouse, 160 means test and, 19, 230, 268
listing spouses on Form 7, 219 Minority business interests, valuing, 95–96
same-sex marriages, 10, 69–70, 153 Minors
separated couples, 230, 281, 282 as creditors, 166, 185, 191
special circumstances, means test, 270 dischargeability of debts owed to, 282
index | 583
credit repair, 18, 108, 302 time limits for court scrutiny, 71, 72–73, 75–76,
dealing with collection activities, 296–299 121, 211, 217
discrimination, 18, 301–302 title document changes, 70, 72, 79, 102–103
if your case is kept open, 299–301 trustee’s power to undo, 29, 70–77, 211, 213
property acquired/discovered after discharge, undervaluing property, 71, 72–74, 102, 310
294–295, 299 undoing before filing, 74
Poverty guidelines, 155 when you may need a lawyer, 310
Powers of appointment, 167 See also Form 7; Preferences
Preferences, 13, 40, 75, 143, 213 Presumed abuse, 205, 229, 245, 267–270
basics, 29, 31, 75–77, 100–101 Prior bankruptcy filings
Pre-filing planning attempting to discharge the same debts, 283
assessing business debt liability, 6–12 automatic stay and, 56, 58–59
assessing business viability, 12–13 dismissals of, 21, 58–59, 160, 283
delaying filing to pass means test, 235 eligibility to file again after, 18, 20–21, 160
determining which property is exempt, 82, listing on bankruptcy petition, 160
92–99 Priority debts/claims, 189–193, 241, 279. See also
guidelines for, 102–103 specific types
inventorying property, 88–91 Profit and loss statements, 224
protecting home equity, 122–124 Promissory notes
reducing nonexempt property, 99–102 as dischargeable debts, 107, 108, 279
removing homes from living trusts, 117 lenders who are not legal note holders, 111
what not to do before filing, 31, 40 listing as assets, 175, 179
when you may need a lawyer, 309–310 See also Personal loans
See also Bankruptcy alternatives Proof of Claim filing, 160
Pre-filing transactions, 13 Proof of service, 562, 564
amending forms to add, 267 amendments to bankruptcy petition, 549
basics, 29, 31, 70–77 basics, 562, 564
changing title to property, 70, 72, 79, 102–103 change of address notices, 552
charitable contributions, 71, 217 complaints to determine dischargeability, 291
disclosing on bankruptcy forms, 71, 72, 73, 102 lien avoidance motions, 535, 536, 541
gifts made, 31, 73–74, 215, 217 Statement of Intention, 247
guidelines for, 31, 102–103 supplemental property schedule, 562
home equity sales, 124 voluntary dismissal petitions, 554
lawyers for help with, 100 Property
luxury purchases and cash advances, 30, 31, 42, acquired or discovered after discharge, 294–295,
289–290, 310 299, 562, 563
planning guidelines, 102–103 acquired or expected after filing, 17, 67, 77, 78,
property transferred to ex-spouses, 75 249, 266, 269
questions about, at creditors’ meeting, 258, 259 basics, 16, 20, 22–29
self-settled trusts, 65, 74–75, 217 correcting property schedules, 265, 266
selling/giving away secured property, 132 describing on exemption worksheet, 92
selling nonexempt property, 99–102, 103, 121, failure to list, 156, 295
273 improper pre-filing transfers, 31, 65, 70–75, 99,
state laws, 73 102–103, 121, 132
index | 587
Relatives. See Insiders Residential leases, 37, 59, 60–61, 118, 197. See also
Rental agreements, 37, 197, 271. See also Leases Leases; Rent entries
Rental income, 66, 203, 233 Retain and pay option. See Ride-through option
Rental property, 219. See also Real property Retirement accounts, 64, 78, 327
Rent debts, 37, 60–61 federal exemptions, 361
Renters, 163, 259 income from, 204, 233
postbankruptcy issues, 302 loans from, 30, 42, 57, 269, 281
rent payments in means test calculations, 236, payroll deductions for, 238
270 state exemptions listed, 328–361
See also Evictions; Landlords; Leases tax liens and, 131
Reopening your case See also Pensions
to add omitted creditors, 193, 265, 296 “Reverse piercing” (corporations and LLCs), 24–25,
basics, 276, 554, 557–561 300–301
to determine dischargeability, 284, 297 Revocable trusts. See Living trusts
to file debtor education course form, 262 Ride-through option, secured debts, 134–136, 138,
to file lien avoidance motion, 141 227
Reorganization bankruptcy, 41–42. See also Roth IRAs, 78, 327
Chapter 11 bankruptcy; Chapter 12 bankruptcy; Royalty income, 66–67, 204, 211, 233
Chapter 13 bankruptcy Rule 2004 proceedings, 260
Repayment plans Rule 2016 Attorney Fee Disclosure Form, 313
Chapter 11 bankruptcy, 44–45
Chapter 13 bankruptcy, 42, 43, 269 S
developed during credit counseling, 147, 155 Safe deposit boxes, 217
workouts, 12, 41, 45–46, 123 Salaries, 189. See also Wages
See also Means test Sales taxes, 281
Replacement value. See Valuation of property Same-sex couples, 10, 69–70, 153, 282
Repossessions, 128 Savings accounts. See Financial accounts
automatic stay and, 133, 262, 271–272 Schedule A—Real Property, 166–170
basics, 35, 133 amending, 265, 266
if you fail to serve Statement of Intention, 247 Schedule B—Personal Property, 170–179
if you stay current on your payments, 35, 135 amending, 265, 266
listing on Form 7, 215 attachments, 173
recovering property repossessed before filing, joint bank accounts on, 79, 173
143, 274–275 listing trust property on, 67
vehicles, 28, 35, 128, 143, 199, 215, 271 tax refunds on, 213
See also Deficiency balances/judgments Schedule C, Profit or Loss From Business (IRS
Request for Discharge, 554, 560 form), 203
Request for Entry of Order by Default, 541, 544– Schedule C—Property Claimed as Exempt,
545 179–184, 213
Request to Reopen Case, 554, 557–558 amending, 265, 266, 267
Reservists, 230 citing statutes on, 97, 99, 181
Residency requirements, state exemptions, 86–88, instructions, 179–181
96–97, 115–117, 180, 273, 326–327 sample, 182–184
index | 589
debts incurred to pay, 30, 43, 103, 288 Title loans, 130
dischargeability, 191, 281, 286–288 Title searches, 169–170
dischargeability disputes, 284, 309 Title to property, changing before filing, 70, 72,
garnishments for, 298 79, 102–103
listing on schedules, 185, 187, 189, 191 Tools of trade exemptions, 25, 84–85, 139, 179,
See also Tax liens 273
Tax deficiency notices, 254 federal, 361
Taxes state exemptions listed, 328–361
on forgiven debt, 40 Torts
payment amounts in means test calculations, debts arising from, 30, 191, 280, 283
238 homestead exemptions and, 117
payroll taxes, 7, 189, 191, 238, 279, 281 intentional injury, 117, 274, 290, 292
property taxes, 236, 281 personal liability for, 9
Tax fraud/evasion, 281, 286–288 Trademarks. See Intellectual property
Tax levies, 56, 254 Trade secrets, 177. See also Intellectual property
Tax liens, 56, 187 Transcripts
automatic stay, 254 educational, withholding of, 286
basics, 131, 141 requesting income tax transcript, 149, 288
listing on Schedule D, 185, 187, 191 Transportation expenses
nondischargeability, 280, 281, 288 in means test calculations, 236, 245, 269
on your home, 110, 112 See also Vehicle expenses
See also Tax debts Trustee. See Bankruptcy trustee; U.S. Trustee
Tax refunds, 65, 175, 213 Trust fund taxes, 281. See also Payroll taxes
Tax returns, 74, 148, 149, 155, 211 Trusts, trust property
for creditors’ meeting, 256 future interests in, 166, 167, 175
failure to file, 286–287, 288 living trusts, 65, 77, 117, 167, 175
if you haven’t filed recently, 149 managed for someone else, 79, 219
requesting a transcript, 149, 288 self-settled trusts, 65, 74–75, 217
trustee questions about, 259 spendthrift trusts, 67, 78
TBE. See Tenancy by the entirety trust income, 204
Telephone expenses, 239
Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (TANF), U
19, 55, 233 UCC (Uniform Commercial Code) lien
Tenancy by the entirety, 11, 69, 106, 119–120, 153 recordings, 129
Theft, debts arising from, 290 researching, 130
Theft losses, 215 Unconscionable burden standard, 285
Third mortgages. See Subsidiary loans Underwater mortgages. See Negative home equity;
341 meeting. See Creditors’ meeting Oversecured property
Time limits Undue hardship discharges, student loans,
dealing with secured property, 58, 233, 247, 284–286, 291
261–262 Unemployment benefits, 204, 233
scrutiny of pre-filing transactions, 71, 72–73, Unexpired leases. See Leases; Schedule G
75–76, 121, 211, 217 Uniform Commercial Code. See UCC
Time shares, 166, 197, 199 Unliquidated creditor claims, 188
592 | Bankruptcy for Small Business Owners: How to File for Chapter 7
Unmarried couples V
common law marriages, 152–153
Vacation pay, 65
exemption system advantages, 70
Valuation of property, 82
See also Same-sex couples
accounts receivable, 94
Unsecured creditors, 20, 131
auction vs. replacement value, 92–93
caution about multiple creditors for a single
below-market pre-filing transactions, 71, 72–74,
debt, 243
102, 310
creditors’ rights if you don’t file for bankruptcy,
business appraisals, 94, 95
36
collectibles, 96
See also Unsecured debts
corporation, LLC, or partnership ownership
Unsecured debts
interests, 95–96
basics, 128, 131, 235
for exemption purposes, 92–96, 181, 273
Chapter 13 bankruptcy, 42, 43
goodwill, 94
dischargeability, 30
intellectual property, 94–95
dollar limits for Chapter 13 bankruptcy, 42
life insurance, 96
if you don’t file for bankruptcy, 36
minority ownership interests, 95–96
listing nonpriority claims, 188, 193–197, 243
mobile homes, 169
listing priority claims, 189–192
online resources, 93, 96, 112, 320–321
subsidiary loans on oversecured property, 36,
for redemption purposes, 134, 546
108, 111, 123–124, 141
tangible property, 93, 96
unsecured portions of secured debts, 188
trade secrets, 177
Upside-down debts. See Negative home equity;
trustee questions about, 260
Oversecured property
vehicles, 96
U.S. Code
your home, 112
bankruptcy sections listed, 317
See also Property values
researching, 316–317
Vehicle accidents, 9, 280
U.S. Court of Appeals decisions, 318
driver’s license suspensions, 301
U.S. Courts website, 151, 156, 248, 318
intoxicated driving, 30, 191, 283
U.S. District Court decisions, 318, 319
Vehicle expenses, 236, 238, 245, 270
U.S. Supreme Court decisions, 318, 319
Vehicle insurance, 280
U.S. Trustee, 204, 229
Vehicle leases, 35, 78, 197, 199, 225
BPP oversight, 307–308
payments in means test calculations, 236, 238
expense challenges, 239
Vehicle loans, 22, 82, 101, 128, 129
motions to dismiss or convert your case, 245,
if you are behind, 44
267–270, 310
paying off, 28, 31, 101
requesting accommodation if you can’t appear
payments in means test calculations, 236, 238
at creditors’ meeting, 256
reaffirmation example, 136
website, 233, 235–236, 243
Vehicles, 22, 28, 140
website resources, 320
applying exemptions to, 82, 84, 87
Utilities expenses, 207, 236, 239, 241
homestead exemptions for mobile homes, 118
Utility bills, as debts, 57
judicial liens on, 130–131
Utility service, 56–57, 272
lien avoidance, 139, 140–143
UTMA custodianships, 79
listing on schedules, 177
index | 593
When you want help with debt problems, you don’t want just any
lawyer—you want an expert in the field, who can provide up-to-the-
minute advice to help you protect your loved ones. You need a lawyer
who has the experience and knowledge to answer your questions about
Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 bankruptcy, foreclosure, business bankruptcy,
and debt workouts.
All lawyers listed in Nolo’s directory are in good standing with their state
bar association. They all pledge to work diligently and respectfully with
clients—communicating regularly, providing a written agreement about
how legal matters will be handled, sending clear and detailed bills and more.
WWW.NOLO.COM
The attorneys shown above are fictitious. Any resemblance to an actual attorney is purely coincidental.
Keep Up to Date
Go to Nolo.com/newsletters/index.html to sign
1 up for free newsletters and discounts on Nolo
products.
BUSB1
and USA TODAY
Cutting-Edge Content, Unparalleled Expertise
Retire Happy
What You Can Do NOW to Guarantee a Great Retirement
by Richard Stim & Ralph Warner • $19.99
First-Time Landlord
Your Guide to Renting Out a Single-Family Home
by Attorney Janet Portman, Marcia Stewart & Michael Molinski • $19.99
O R D E R A N Y T I M E AT W W W. N O L O . C O M O R C A L L 8 0 0 -7 2 8 - 3 5 5 5
About the Authors
Stephen R. Elias is an attorney and current President of the National
Bankruptcy Law Project. He is the author of many Nolo books, most recently
The Foreclosure Survival Guide: Keep Your House or Walk Away With Money
In Your Pocket and The New Bankruptcy: Will It Work for You? Other titles
include How to File for Chapter 7 Bankruptcy and Chapter 13 Bankruptcy:
Keep Your Property & Repay Debts Over Time. Elias holds a law degree from
University of California, Hastings College of Law and was a practicing
attorney in California, New York, and Vermont before joining Nolo in 1980.
He has been featured in such major media as The New York Times, The Wall
Street Journal, Newsweek, Good Morning America, 20/20, Money, and more.
Steve coauthors a popular blog www.bankruptcyforeclosureblog.com.
Bethany K. Laurence has been a Nolo editor and author since 1997,
combining her legal and financial expertise to edit many Nolo small business
books. She is the coauthor of Save Your Small Business: 10 Crucial Strategies
to Survive Hard Times or Close Down and Move On and Business Buyout
Agreements: A Step-by-Step Guide for Co-Owners as well as codeveloper of
Nolo’s Online LLC and Quicken Legal Business Pro software. Laurence
holds a law degree from University of California, Hastings College of
the Law, a B.A. degree from Boston University (Phi Beta Kappa, magna
cum laude), and is a member of the California State Bar. Before joining
Nolo, Laurence developed online legal products for CCH, Inc. (a division
of Wolters Klewer, Inc.). Over the last decade she has been active on the
board of directors of several local environmental and educational nonprofit
organizations. Laurence has recently begun to blog about small business
issues for Nolo’s business customers at www.smallbusinesslegalblog.com.