Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Introduction .................................................................................................................... 3
References .................................................................................................................... 17
2
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The net profit of the Bukit Dahar PLC was continually decreased over the years and
this happened because of increasing company expenses over the years without
significant increase of the company revenue. Because of the company dividend
policy, they have issued the fixed dividend whether company financial performance
was good or bad. Therefore, payouts also were increasing with the current financial
position. With this situation, company dividend policy needs to be changed to MM -
Dividends irrelevant theory from Bird in the hand's theory.
Foreign Exchange risk is a one of significant risk which can happen to the exporter
and importers in the international trading and to companies with the overseas
subsidiaries. To reduce FX risk, there are four internal hedging techniques and the
two main external hedging techniques.
INTRODUCTION
BUKIT DARAH PLC is a publicly quoted company which is incorporated in 1916 is
headquartered Colombo, Sri Lanka. The main operation activity is the cultivation of
oil palm in Indonesia and Malaysia. The company is engaged in managing and
holding the investment portfolio and providing financial services. Other than that, real
estate, resorts, airways are also key operational activities of the Bukit Darah.
Key financial statistics such as Revenue, Net profit, EBITDA, Operating Cash flows,
Net Assets and Net debt were performed within the last three financial years 2014,
2015, 2016 as follows.
As shown in figure 1, the highest revenue was represented in 2015 when comparing
last consecutive three years. Nearly 12 billion rupees was increased from 2014 to
2015 but it was decreased by nearly 3 billion rupees in 2016. Net profit (figure 2) of
the Bukit Dahar PLC was decreased continuously from 2014 to 2016.
3
Revenue (Rs. '000 ) Net Profit (Rs. '000)
90,000,000 9,000,000
88,000,000 8,000,000
86,000,000 7,000,000
84,000,000
6,000,000
82,000,000
5,000,000
80,000,000
4,000,000
78,000,000
3,000,000
76,000,000
74,000,000 2,000,000
72,000,000 1,000,000
70,000,000 0
2014 2015 2016 1 2 3
14,000,000 14,000,000
12,000,000 12,000,000
10,000,000 10,000,000
8,000,000 8,000,000
6,000,000 6,000,000
4,000,000 4,000,000
2,000,000 2,000,000
0 0
2014 2015 2016 1 2 3
4
In 2016, Net Asset was increased to highest level comparing other two years and it
was nearly 5 billion rupees from 2015 to 2016. Net Debt was increased continuously
within consecutive last three years.
68,000,000 70,000,000
67,000,000
60,000,000
66,000,000
50,000,000
65,000,000
40,000,000
64,000,000
30,000,000
63,000,000
20,000,000
62,000,000
61,000,000 10,000,000
60,000,000 0
2014 2015 2016 1 2 3
5
dividend policy may change company to company based on the various factors and
some of them view the dividend policy as an integral part of the corporate strategy of
the company (Investopedia, 2016). Buki Dahar PLC paid a fixed dividend rate over
the last 4 year period. They had not changed the dividend according to their financial
performance. They are always trying to improve the shareholder's value and yield a
better return to both companies and the shareholders in a long-term perspective (Bukit
Dahar PLC, 2016).
1. The effect on the internal finance that is available to the company. The
dividend is paid after tax profit and it is divided into two portions one is a
dividend and another one is reserved. Reserves are internal financial and if it’s
paid the more divided amount of reserves are reduced.
2. The effect on return on investment of the investors on their share. If it is
received more dividend, dividend yield of the share is increased. When it is
calculated with the capital gain, the return on investment of the investors is
increased. Because dividend rate is directly affected to the investors return.
3. It is maximising the shareholder’s wealth. With the dividend decision the
return on investment and the value of a share are increased and then their
wealth of the shareholders will be increased.
As mention above, the dividend decision may directly affect to not only shareholders
but as the company.
When considering main investor relation ratios such as DPS, EPS and Payout trend
following fluctuations are obtained.
6
Dividend per share (LKR)
3.1
According to the figure 7, a fixed dividend
3
ratio was declared by Bukit Dahar PLC
2.9
within last four years period. It was LKR 3
2.8
per share. But before 4 years at 2012, they
2.7
were declared only LKR 2.5. This is a
2.6
certain dividend rate and it was low risk
2.5
2.4
for the shareholders and them always
2.3
prefer it.
2.2
1 2 3 4 5
60
20
10
5
7
0
1 2 3 4 5
With the effect of fixed dividend rate and the decreasing earning per share, dividend
payout represents the regular increasing payout. It was increased 5% to 22% within 5
years of the period. When comparing the 2014 and 2016, it was more than doubled.
Shareholders are most preferred this kind of the low-risk dividend scenario. And it
was encouraged the people to invest.
This happened because of the dividend policy of the Bukit Dahr PLC. They were
offered a certain dividend and it was preferred by the investors and low-risk dividend
policy of shareholders. This type of dividend theory called as Bird-in-the-Hand
Theory.
8
significance to the dividend historical past of a corporation and thus, dividends are
beside the point in calculating the valuation of a manufacturer. This concept is in
direct contrast to the ‘Dividend Relevance’ concept which beliefs dividends to be
fundamental in the evaluation of an organisation. If investors need cash, they have the
opportunity to sell shares and take money, if they do not need cash, dividends can be
used by new shares and increased their ownership (Anon., 2015).
If there is a too big company’s dividend, more shares can be bought by the investors
and it will be over satisfy them. If it is too small, share can be sold by the investors.
However, the dividends irrelevant theory is not based on taxes or brokerage costs.
In 1961, Modigliani and Miller have introduced the relevant theory and its
investment policy was driven off the Company value. Companies should re-invest
incomes as long as they have valuable investment chances and should pay out
dividends only when they have no more investment value undertaking. If incomes
lesser than the required amount the finance was raised from outside. If the investor
prevents the valuable investment that dividend payment are essential. That is a cost of
opportunity may be imposed (Anon., 2015).
There are some assumptions for MM dividend relevant theory. Such as,
9
Firms have no access to external finance
3. Bird-in-the-Hand Theory
Bird in Hand theory introduced by the Myron Gordon and John Lintner as a
development of the dividend irrelevance theory of the Modigliani-Miller. Which
continues that investors are unresponsive as to whether their returns from preserving
shares ascend from dividends or positive factors for capital investment (Investopedia,
2016).
Bird in Hand theory says that despite taxes and operational expenses, and also all
investor likes to the dividend with a certain amount receiving now relatively to an
uncertain dividend with the better amount for a future dividend. In a lower tax paying
situation. Most of the investors search the low-risk investment method and they think
the dividend is less risky than future capital gain. But in another way dividend tax is
higher than the capital gain tax. Because of that firms must pay out as much as
possible from profit after tax as dividend and retain is very little. High-performing
firms are doing high payout as a result of the high profit. But this is not a principle of
the universal truth. Bukit Dahar PLC is also using this policy which is “Bird in Hand
theory” is as their dividend policy.
Long-term capital gains are lead to reserved earnings. Those capital gains are taxed at
lower rates than dividends. Personal tax situation are depending on investors. Some of
the shareholders more liked to capital gains over dividends and vice versa as capital
10
gains are taxed at a lower rate than dividends. The clientele effect is simply different
stockholders' preference on receiving dividends compared to capital gains. For
example, a shareholder in a high rate of tax support may favour shares with a low rate
of dividend payouts compared to a shareholder in a low tax support who may favour
shares with a higher rate of dividend payouts.
In my point of view, the most suitable and the correct dividend theory to applicable
for any kind of situation is Dividends irrelevant theory because it has a manageable
risk for both parties investor and the company. In this situation, the stocks have high
liquidity and the company have not a liable responsibility to pay a dividend at a fixed
rate.
Some of the firms have continuously increasing payouts over the period of time. This
situation happens causing various kinds of factors. Such as revenue, profit, capital
requirement etc. And also management decisions, dividend policy, investment
policies etc. According to the Bukit Dahr PLC, there was decreased the profit after tax
continuously, the main reason behind this profit reduction, the level of expense was
increased over the years without a significant change of the company income. And
also share price also continuously decreased but they offered fix rate of dividend.
When analysing this situation the current dividend policy of the company is not
suitable for the company and need to change current dividend policy. Among main
four dividend theories, according to my concern, the most viable dividend policy for
the Bukit Dahr PLC is Dividend Irrelevance Theory which is “Investors are
indifferent between dividends and retention-generated capital gains. If they want
cash, they can sell stock. If they don’t want cash, they can use dividends to buy
stock”. Because currently, the company was giving fixed dividend whether their profit
increased or not. But the firm's profit was decreased over years in last five years
period.
11
risk of the change of the investment value due to the currency exchange rate
(Investopedia, 2016).
The risk of foreign currency exchange is severely affected to the anyone who
involved to the import and export business such as product, services and supplies. It's
also important to recognise values uncovered to the gigantic hazard of loss and
thereby decide whether foreign exchange charges can also be forecast and thus devise
a compatible hedging strategy or not.
1. Transaction risk
2. Translation risk
3. Economic FX risk
1. Transaction Risk
Transaction risk is the rises out of the transactions of import and export. It is a risk
which happened in between credit period over the exchange rate. If it happened within
a short period of time, it will be directly impacted the cash flow of the company. This
transaction risk happens because of the receivable and the payables. Contracts
between two one-of-a-kind businesses with specific local currencies set contracts with
selected principles. This contract offers particular prices for services and particular
transfer dates. But, this contract faces the risk of exchange rates among the involved
exchange varying before the services are distributed or before the deal is settled
(Investopedia, 2016).
2. Translation Risk
The translation risk happens because of the non-current assets and/or liabilities of the
company. This risk is detected at end of each year when translating the company
assets and liabilities to company own domestic currency, and they included the annual
statement of the financial position. In another way, when translating the financial
statements of the overseas subsidiaries in to the domestic currency also can be
happened this translation risk of the foreign exchange. Actual this is the risk
happening when translating the real money from one currency to another currency.
However, translation exposed would possibly not have an impact on a corporation's
cash flow; it could possibly exchange the total pronounced gains of the company,
12
which affects its stock cost (Investopedia, 2016). The reported performance of a
foreign subsidiary in home-based exchange terms can be highly distorted if there has
been a significant foreign exchange movement.
3. Economic FX Risk
Economic FX risk is the risk happening to the company long term cash flows because
of the economical exposure (Investopedia, 2016). Currency fluctuations can be caused
by the company position it’s compared the competitors of the company. For example,
if a UK company’s, US factory investment is generating a stream of US dollar cash
flows then, Economic Risk is the risk that the value of that $ cash flow –in £s – will
become worth less and less over time, caused by a longer-term, adverse movement in
the $/£ exchange rate. According to the above example, economic FX risk is the
long-term version of the short-term transaction. And, it is an impact to the company
cash flows.
13
periods. In the case of this scenario, exporters received a sufficient monopoly power
and importers automatically push into FX risk. If not, they will risk losing the deal to
a competitor who will invoice in British pounds.
2. Currency Netting
Currency Netting is an internal hedging technique which is used if there are both
receipts and the payments, in the same foreign currency with the same credit period.
There are instances where an organization has associates in a couple of countries that
actively exchange with each other. If so, they must have bills receivable and payable
with every different, which would give rise to a flurry of foreign exchange
transactions in multiple currencies that could trigger any quantity of hedging hobbies.
(Accounting Tools, n.d.). In this method, reduce FX risk offsetting one against the
other.
As an example, if the firm has a payment of $500,000 with the 3 months’ credit
period and the receipt of the $450,000 with the 3 months’ credit period. According to
this technique, the firm needs to settle only the balance of payment $50,000. Because
of that only $50,000 is exposed to foreign exchange risk.
3. Currency Overdraft
Another main method which reduces the foreign exchange risk is the currency
overdraft. Currency Overdraft is used where fairs have a large amount of small scale
customers invoicing in one foreign currency. The low-value nature of each invoice
makes it administratively inconvenient to deal with each one separately. Instead, they
are dealt with collectively.
14
euro’s receipts is bought, the money is used to ceaselessly repay the company’s
€500,000 overdraft. That is the currency Overdraft hedge.
As an example, Therefore, our German Toy producer, who is about to invoice their
UK client for £84,746 on 3 months’ credit, might try to convince the client to pay
instantly. In other words, to lead the payment, if they fear that the €/£ exchange rate
will move harmfully over the next 3 months.
To take strong currency involvement, need to be followed the following sequence for
payments.
15
exchange. This conveniently fixes the longer-term fee (Kaplan Financial Knowledge
Bank, 2016). In this method, foreign currency received from the forward rate in the
future. At the receiving point, the forward rate may be two types. One is minus the
premium and another one is a plus from a discount. In another word, it can be said as
Supply the purchaser the proper, however now not the duty, to buy (“name”) or
promote (“put”) a specific amount of foreign money at a specified price on a specific
date. Contracts entered into the ahead market are binding on the events concerned.
Forward markets are used for trading a range of devices including currencies and
interest charges.
As an example, BMW is the one of German car producer and has sold a car to a US
customer for $100,000 in 3 months’ credit period. $/€ spot is $1.3560 and after 3
months it is $1.3720. Annual interest rate for loans and deposits of USD respectively
is 6% and the 3% and for the euro, it is 4% and 2%. BMW is due to receive $100,000
in 3 months’ time to undertake a forward market hedge, the company goes to its bank
today and enters into a contract to sell the $100,000 three months forward to give a
certain receipt of €72,886 receipt in 3 months. Thus, the German exporter has no
doubt as to the outcome in euros of their export transaction. They will receive €72,886
after 3 months’ time, for certain.
Step 3: At the end of 3 months, use the $y receipt from the customer to repay the $x
loan, plus interest.
16
REFERENCES
Accounting Tools, n.d. Foreign Currency Netting: Accounting Tools. [Online]
Available at: http://www.accountingtools.com/foreign-currency-netting [Accessed 29
October 2016].
Bank, K. F. K., 2016. Money Market Hedges: Kaplan Financial Konowledge Bank.
[Online] Available at: http://kfknowledgebank.kaplan.co.uk/KFKB/Wiki%20Pages
/Money%20market%20hedges.aspx?mode=none [Accessed 29 October 2016].
Bukit Dahar PLC, 2016. Annual Report 2015/16, Colombo: Bukit Dahar PLC.
17
Kaplan Financial Knowledge Bank, 2016. Forward Contracts: Kaplan Financial
Knowledge Bank. [Online] Available at: http://kfknowledgebank.kaplan.co.uk
/KFKB /Wiki%20Pages/Forward%20Contracts.aspx?mode=none[Accessed 29
October 2016].
18