You are on page 1of 10

Efectos del ejercicio físico

de alta intensidad y
Background: Physical activity is
sobrecarga en parámetros associated with an improvement in
de salud metabólica en cardiovascular health, however there is
mujeres sedentarias, pre- a paucity of information about the
effects of sprint interval training on
diabéticas con sobrepeso individuals with high metabolic
u obesidad risk. Aim: To determine the effects of
three exercise programs on
anthropometric and metabolic markers
Effect of sprint interval
in overweight, sedentary and
training and resistance prediabetic women. Material and
exercise on metabolic Methods: Forty three women were
markers in overweight ascribed to four groups matched by
women body mass index and body fat: high
intensity intervals (HIT, n = 12),
resistance (R, n = 8), combined group
(HIT +R, n = 10) and control group
(CG, n = 13). Participants completed 12
Cristian Álvarez1,a, Rodrigo weeks of exercise intervention. Body
Ramírez2,b, Marcelo Flores3,4,c, Cecil mass index, waist circumference,
Zúñiga5,d, Carlos A. Celis-Morales6,e percentage of fat mass measured by
impedanciometry, blood pressure,
1
Centro de Salud Familiar de Los Lagos. fasting glucose, insulin and homeostasis
Centro de Promoción de Salud de la model assessment for insulin resistance
mujer, Región de Los Ríos, Chile. (HOMAlR) and fitness assessed using the
2
Departamento de Ciencias de la two km walk test were measured at
Actividad Física, Universidad de Los baseline and after the training
Lagos, Osorno, Chile. period. Results: No changes in
3
Unidad de Kinesiología, Hospital de anthropometric and body composition
Carabineros de Chile, Santiago, Chile. variables were observed. However, in
4
Departamento de Fisiología, HIT and R groups, significant reductions
Universidad de Melbourne, Australia. were observed on fasting glucose (5.4
5
Departamento de Educación Física, and 16.6% respectively), insulin (18.6
Universidad San Sebastián, Región de and 43.4% respectively) and
Los Ríos, Chile. HOMAIR (24.1 and 55.4% respectively),
6
Centro de Investigación en Nutrición 72 hours after the intervention. No
Humana, Instituto de Investigación en significant changes were found for the
Envejecimiento y Salud. Universidad de observed values in the combined and
Newcastle. Inglaterra. Reino Unido. control groups. Conclusions: HIT and
a
Profesor de Educación Física, MSc. resistance training improve glycemic
Entrenamiento Deportivo. control and insulin sensitivity in females
b
Profesor de Educación Física, MSc. with a high metabolic risk.
Fisiología del Ejercicio.
c
Kinesiólogo, MSc. Fisiología del (Rev Med Chile 2012; 140:1289-1296).
Ejercicio.
d
Kinesiólogo, MSc. Educación, ISAK
Key words: Exercise; Insulin
nivel III.
Resistance; Obesity; Sedentary
e
Doctor en Ciencias Cardiovasculares y
Lifestyle.
Biomédicas (PhD).

Correspondencia a:
Forty-three women participated in the
study (n = 43), who were recruited at the
Overweight and obesity are states that are Family Health Center of Los Lagos
associated with the development of (CESFAM), Los Ríos Region, Chile. The
insulin resistance (IR), type 2 diabetes study design corresponds to an
(T2D) and cardiovascular disease (CVD) experimental study with simple random
1-3. Additionally, sedentary lifestyle has sampling. The participants were divided
been pointed out as another relevant into four groups: interval program (PI),
factor in the increase of these overload program (PS), mixed program
pathologies3-5. In Chile, 93% of women (PI + PS) and control group (GC). The
are sedentary and 64% are overweight or allocation of the participants in each
obese and CVDs are currently the main group was matched according to BMI
cause of death in the country6,7. and% fat mass. The sample size was
estimated using observed changes in
Despite the association between the plasma insulin (delta = 2.16 mU / L, SD =
practice of physical activity (PA) and the 1.38) in a group operated with different
reduction of CVD8, AF levels remain low exercise programs13. A total of 9
in the population9. This has led to the participants per group gives a power of
proposal of new AF recommendations for 80% and an α of 0.05.
the adult population, which reduce the
traditional 150 min of AF per week to 20 The inclusion criteria were: a) sedentary
min of AF of greater intensity and with (exercise <30 min / week), b) BMI> 25.0
shorter duration (eg 3 times per week) kg / m2, c) blood glucose level 100 to
10,11. This change could be an important <125 mg / dl14. Exclusion criteria were:
step to increase the levels of FA, since the a) history of osteoarticular disease,
lack of time has been identified as one of ischemic, arrhythmias, tachycardia and /
the main barriers to the practice of PA in or chronic obstructive pulmonary disease;
the adult population12. However, in b) with pharmacological treatment for
relation to the effects of this new practice metabolic alterations. This study was
of AF in people with metabolic risk is carried out considering the Declaration of
limited. Taking into account the levels of Helsinki and was approved by the ethics
sedentary lifestyle, obesity, DT2 and committees of CESFAM Los Lagos,
CVD in Chile, it is necessary to design, Osorno, Chile. All participants gave their
and evaluate other models of FA, that are written informed consent prior to the
feasible to be implemented in local health intervention.
services and programs throughout the
country. Therefore, the objective of this Procedures
study was to evaluate the impact of 3 AF
programs on anthropometric parameters Body weight, fat mass (MG) and muscle
and cardiovascular health in sedentary, mass (MM) were determined, using a
pre-diabetic and overweight women. digital scale of bioimpedance of feet and
hands (OMRON®, Model HBF-INT).
Material and methods The height was measured with a 0.1 cm
precision height rod (Health or Meter®,
Participants USA). BMI was calculated by dividing
body weight by height squared (kg / m2)
and overweight was defined as BMI> 25 Table 1. Description of the
kg / m2. The waist circumference was physical exercise protocols used
measured just above the line of the iliac in the intervention
crest15 with an inextensible tape and
precision of 0.1 cm (Hoechstmass®, West
Germany 1-150 cm).

Blood pressure was determined with a


digital monitor (OMRON, model HEM-
742INT). Each participant remained in a
seated position at least 15 minutes prior to
the measurement, reporting only the
average of three measurements. Fasting
Program of physical exercise of overload
blood samples (4 ml) were obtained
(PS): consisted of performing 5 different
between 8:00 AM and 11:00 AM (Pre-
exercises of overload (squat, flexo-
intervention, 24 h and 72 h Post-
extension of biceps, flexo-extensions of
intervention). Glicemia was determined
ankle, flexo-extension of shoulders and
with an enzymatic method (Trinder,
flexo-extensions of elbow). Each exercise
Genzyme Diagnostics, Canada) and
was performed for 1 minute (reaching
insulin was determined by RIA (DPC,
muscle failure) and repeated 3 times per
Los Angeles, CA). Insulin resistance was
session, with pauses of 2 min of recovery
determined with HOMAIR16.
between each series18 (Table 1).
The UKK test was applied to determine
Program of Combined Physical Exercise
bipedal translation capacity17. Socio-
(PI + PS): consisted of performing both
demographic and health questionnaires
exercise programs on non-consecutive
were applied to determine age, history of
days, making a total of 5 days of physical
pharmacological treatment, family history
exercise per week (Table 1).
of diseases indicated in the inclusion and
exclusion criteria.
Diet, Physical Activity and
Design of intervention programs Adherence

Programs of interval physical exercise All participants were instructed not to


(PI): consisted of performing careers and change their diet and FA patterns during
recovery pauses in an interval way until the course of the intervention. The
completing a volume of 20 min of AF per adherence presented by the three groups
day and twice a week. In each session the was PI (85%), PS (95%) and PI + PS
participants completed 7 high-intensity (74%).
racing intervals (> 85% of the maximum
heart rate (220-Age), each interval lasted Statistics
20 s and increased by 2 s (10%) every 2
weeks, while that the recovery interval of The data are presented as mean ±
120 s, decreased by 5 s (~ 4%) every 2 standard deviation. The Shapiro-Wilk test
weeks (Table 1). was applied to determine if the variables
corresponded to a normal distribution.
Differences between Pre and Post
intervention were determined with presented differences between the groups
Student t test for related samples. To prior to the intervention (p <0.001), being
determine if there were significant significantly higher in the PI group
differences in quantitative variables compared to the PI + PS group and the
between the four Pre-intervention groups, control group. However, diastolic blood
two-way ANOVA analysis was applied pressure, cardio-respiratory test UKK,
and to determine differences between pre- glycemia, insulinemia and HOMAIR did
test, post-test 24 h and post-test 72 h, one- not show significant differences between
way ANOVA was applied, the test groups prior to the intervention (Table 2).
Bonferoni was used to detect where these
differences were. The analyzes were Table 3. Metabolic characteristics of
adjusted for age and adherence to the the participants Pre and Post
intervention program. All analyzes were intervention stratified by group.
performed in SPSS (version 19). The
level of significance accepted was p
<0.05.

Results

Table 2 describes the anthropometric


variables stratified by AF Pre and Post
intervention program. The age and
anthropometric characteristics (weight,
height, BMI, waist circumference
and% fat mass) of the participants did
not show significant differences
between groups prior to the
intervention. After 12 weeks of intervention, the
anthropometric variables did not show
Table 2. Anthropometric and physical significant changes between the
condition characteristics of the intervention groups. In the UKK cardio-
participants Pre and Post intervention respiratory test, the PI and PI + PS groups
stratified by group significantly reduced the time used to
travel 2 km after the 12 weeks of
intervention (p <0.001), but not the PS
and GC groups.

Systolic blood pressure showed a


significant reduction Post intervention
only in the PI group (p = 0.043). The
metabolic markers of glycemia,
insulinemia and HOMAIR were
measured 24 h and 72 h post intervention.
The glycemia shows a significant
In relation to the metabolic variables reduction of 6.7% in the PI group (p =
(Table 3), systolic blood pressure 0.011) and 7.4% in the PS group (p =
0.019), but not in the group PI + PS and Groups are marked as
GC at 24 h Post intervention . No (PI: Interval Program,
significant reductions were found in PS: Overload Program,
insulin and HOMAIR at 24 h Post PI + PS: Combined
intervention in any of the groups. Group and GC: Control
However, these variables showed a Group). Significant
significant reduction at 72 h Post differences between pre,
24 h post and 72 h post
intervention in the PI and PS groups, but
were determined with
not in the PI + PS and GC group. The one-way ANOVA. The
magnitude of these reductions were 5.4% models were adjusted
and 6.5% in glycemia levels, 18.6% and for age and program
43.4% in insulinemia, 24.1% and 55.4% attendance. Values of
in HOMAIR in the PI group and PS, significance are
respectively. The average% of reductions indicated as * p <0.05,
(delta 24 and 72 h Post intervention) are ** p <0.01.
presented in Figure.1.

Discussion
The results of this study indicate that the
application of more intense PA programs,
such as the PI and PS programs, are
effective tools for the reduction of IR
levels in sedentary, pre-diabetic and
overweight women. It is also important to
note that the design of shorter AF
programs can be used as a strategy to
increase the practice and adherence to AF
Figure 1. Changes in
programs in adults with metabolic risk,
glycemia and HOMAir
after 12 weeks of which is a necessity considering the
intervention. Data national reality in relation to the high
presented as mean ± levels of sedentary lifestyle (~ 93%),
standard error of the overweight or obesity (~ 64%) and
mean. Graphs a and c prevalence of diabetes (~ 9%) in
show the levels of women6, 7.
glycemia and insulin
resistance pre- The interventions proposed in this
intervention, 24 h and 72 investigation did not produce changes in
h post intervention.
BMI, waist circumference and% fat mass
Graphs b and d show
the% reduction
in any of the 3 groups operated on. Our
(Post72h-Pre) in results agree with previous studies where
glycemia and HOMAIR similar AF programs in obese women did
post intervention. not produce significant changes in
adiposity19,20. These results could be insulin sensitivity, after 7 weeks of
explained by the short intervention training in overweight women and family
period. history of diabetes26. However, it is
important to note that the greater
Although no changes were detected in reduction in HOMAIR associated with
adiposity markers in our study, the the PS group compared to the PI group
proposed FA programs significantly could be explained by differences in the
reduced post-intervention glycemia volume and training time in our study
levels. Glycemic control is an important (Table 1).
factor in the treatment of T2D and is
associated with vascular complications in Similarly, the lack of adherence to the
diabetic patients21. This study reported program could be one of the factors that
an average reduction of 6.1% and 6.9% in could explain the non-significant changes
post-intervention blood glucose levels in in the PI + PS group. However, it is
the PI and PS group, respectively. These important to note that all three programs
changes were lower than those reported have a clear tendency to reduce glycemia
by Little and cols19, who reported a and insulin resistance. The potential
reduction of 13% after 6 sessions of (PI) mechanisms through which PI or PS
during 2 weeks of intervention. Similar programs improve glycemic control and
reductions in glycemia (15.6%) were insulin sensitivity are interesting
reported by Cauza et al22, after an considering that there were no changes in
intervention with PS exercises. This the variables of body composition. It has
difference in blood glucose reduction recently been reported that programs of 4
could be explained by the type of patients repetitions interval of 30 s, produce a
who underwent surgery, since both minimum energy expenditure of ~ 40-80
studies involved diabetic patients and, as kcal but nevertheless, reduce muscle
previously mentioned, the benefits of AF glycogen between 30% and 45% through
are greater in people with metabolic risk the metabolic pathway of AMPK that
(overweight, sedentary and diabetic). plays a role paramount in the
23.24. translocation of GLUT4 and muscle
glucose consumption27. Interestingly, the
The average reductions in insulinemia (PI level of reduction in muscle glycogen
~ 16%, PS ~ 27.6) and HOMAIR (PI ~ induced by 4 repetitions of 30 s of PI
17%; PS ~ 38), reflect the vascular exercises is similar to that induced by a
benefits associated with the application of 90-min session of moderate intensity
PI and PS exercises in women with aerobic exercise28. Additionally, another
metabolic risk. These reductions have mechanism that could explain the
important clinical implications due to the reduction in IR is muscle adaptation to
association between IR and the increase training programs. It has been reported
in mortality levels attributed to CVD25. that diabetic patients or those with
The reduction in insulinemia and metabolic risk have a reduced capacity for
HOMAreported in our study are similar mitochondrial oxidation, 29 and that
to the benefits obtained with traditional interventions similar to those proposed in
training programs, where 150-300 min our study increase mitochondrial
per week of aerobic exercise (65% of oxidation capacity in both healthy
VO2MAX) reduces in 22% the levels of subjects30 and metabolic risk31.
insulinemia and improvement in 32%
Additionally, changes in systolic blood magnitude and direction of the results.
pressure (SBP) were detected in the Finally, adherence to the intervention
interval group, this could be explained programs is another factor of confusion,
because the PI group had higher levels of therefore the analyzes were adjusted by
SBP than the other Pre-intervention level of assistance.
groups. The mechanisms by which PI
exercises reduce SBP have not been fully In conclusion, the PI and PS programs are
elucidated, but they may be mediated by a effective alternatives for the reduction of
reduction in sympathetic nervous system insulin resistance in sedentary, pre-
vascular control32 and vasodilation diabetic and overweight women. The total
mechanisms associated with an increase exercise time required per week to
in nitric oxide production by the body. produce metabolic benefits was 60 min in
endothelium33. the PI group and 90 min in the PS group,
representing 40% and 60%, respectively,
It is important to highlight some strengths of the traditional AF recommendations
of the present study, as it was matched (150 min x week) 10. Considering that
according to BMI and fat mass levels of the lack of time has been one of the main
the groups operated on. Additionally, the justifications for the non-practice of
design of the exercise programs was physical activity, we believe that this
carried out considering protocols of strategy of reducing exercise time could
simple application, and feasible to be be a viable alternative to increase
replicated in other CESFAM at a national adherence to intervention programs. The
level. Finally, standardized techniques for exercise programs presented in this
the measurement of anthropometric and research show that implementing shorter
metabolic parameters were considered. programs in Family Health Centers at the
However, it is important to mention national level is an alternative
potential limitations in the design of the prescription tool, easy to implement and
study that should be considered in future effective in reducing cardiovascular risk
research. Within the limitations is the associated with insulin resistance in
control of caloric intake during the patients with metabolic risk.
intervention, since the changes detected
in metabolic markers could be affected by Acknowledgments: To all the
changes in eating patterns, however, the participants, for their commitment to
participants were constantly instructed the program. Carmen Gloria Flores,
not to modify their diet. Similarly, Director of CESFAM Los Lagos and
physical activity levels were not Leslie Ruiz, Coordinator of the Health
Promotion Program, of CESFAM, for
objectively controlled during the their administrative management of the
intervention, however, the non- project.
performance of physical activity outside
the intervention programs was
emphasized. Another limitation was the
References
age distribution in the groups, the average
1. McLaughlin T, Allison G, Abbasi F,
age was higher in the PS group which Lamendola C, Reaven G. Prevalence of
could explain why said program shows insulin resistance and associated
greater reductions, however, the age was cardiovascular disease risk factors
adjusted in the statistical models and no among normal weight, overweight, and
differences were detected in the
obese individuals. Metabolism. 2004; 10. Garber CE, Blissmer B, Deschenes
53 (4): 495-9. MR, Franklin BA, Lamonte MJ, Lee IM,
et al. American College of Sports
2. Reaven GM. Insulin resistance: the Medicine position stand. Quantity and
link between obesity and cardiovascular quality of exercise for developing and
disease. Med Clin North Am. 2011; 95 maintaining cardiorespiratory,
(5): 875-92. musculoskeletal, and neuromotor
fitness in apparently healthy adults:
3. Celis-Morales CA, Pérez-Bravo F, guidance for prescribing exercise. Med
Ibanes L, Sanzana R, Hormazabal E, Sci Sports Exerc 2011; 43 (7): 1334-
Ulloa N, et al. Insulin resistance in 59.
Chileans of European and indigenous
descent: evidence for an ethnicity x 11. O'Donovan G, Blazevich AJ,
environment interaction. PloS One. Boreham C, Cooper AR, Crank H,
2011; 6 (9): e24690. Ekelund U, et al. The ABC of Physical
Activity for Health: a consensus
4. Proper KI, Singh AS, van Mechelen statement from the British Association
W, Chinapaw MJM. Sedentary behaviors of Sport and Exercise Sciences. J Sports
and health outcomes among adults: a Sci 2010; 28 (6): 573-91
systematic review of prospective
studies. Am J Prev Med. 2011; 40 (2): 12. Reichert FF, Barros AJD, Domingues
174-82. MR, Hallal PC. The role of perceived
personal barriers to engagement in
5. Thorp AA, Owen N, Neuhaus M, leisure-time physical activity. Am J
Dunstan DW. Sedentary behaviors and Public Health 2007; 97 (3): 515-9
subsequent health outcomes in adults a
systematic review of longitudinal 13. Whyte LJ, Gill JMR, Cathcart AJ.
studies, 1996-2011. Am J Prev Med. Effect of 2 weeks of sprint interval
2011; 41 (2): 207-15. training on health-related outcomes in
sedentary overweight/obese men.
6. Villalón GC GG, Vera SS. Evolución Metabolism 2010; 59 (10): 1421-8
de la mortalidad en Chile según causas
de muerte y edad: 1990-2007. 14. ADA. Report of the Expert
Publicacion Especial. Chile: Instituto Committee on the Diagnosis and
Nacional de Estadistica; 2010. Classification of Diabetes Mellitus.
Diabetes care 1997; 20 (7): 1183-
7. MINSAL. Encuesta Nacional de Salud 97. [ Links ]
2009-2010. Chile: Ministerio de Salud;
2010. 15. Marfell-Jones M, Olds, T., Stewart,
A., Carter, L. International standards
8. Ahmed HM, Blaha MJ, Nasir K, Rivera for anthropometric assessment: ISAK
JJ, Blumenthal RS. Effects of physical 1st ed. Potchefstroom, South Africa:
activity on cardiovascular disease. Am J The International Society for the
Cardiol. 2012; 109 (2): 288-95. Advancement of Kinanthropometry
(ISAK); 2006.
9. Dumith SC, Hallal PC, Reis RS, Kohl
HW, 3rd. Worldwide prevalence of 16. Matthews DR, Hosker JP, Rudenski
physical inactivity and its association AS, Naylor BA, Treacher DF, Turner RC.
with human development index in 76 Homeostasis model assessment: insulin
countries. Prev Med 2011; 53 (1-2): resistance and beta-cell function from
24-8. fasting plasma glucose and insulin
concentrations in man. Diabetologia 24. Armstrong MJ, Boule NG, Sigal RJ.
1985; 28 (7): 412-9 Exercise interventions and glycemic
control in patients with diabetes. JAMA
17. Laukkanen RM, Kukkonen-Harjula 2011; 306 (6): 607
TK, Oja P, Pasanen ME, Vuori IM.
Prediction of change in maximal aerobic 25. Hu G, Qiao Q, Tuomilehto J,
power by the 2-km walk test after Eliasson M, Feskens EJM, Pyorala K, et
walking training in middle-aged adults. al. Plasma insulin and cardiovascular
Int J Sports Med 2000; 21 (2): 113-6 mortality in non-diabetic European men
and women: a meta-analysis of data
18. Saavedra C. Guía de actividad física from eleven prospective studies.
para el adulto mayor. Santiago, Chile: Diabetologia 2004; 47 (7): 1245-
Instituto Nacional del Deporte; 2006 56.

19. Little JP, Gillen JB, Percival ME, 26. Barwell ND, Malkova D, Moran CN,
Safdar A, Tarnopolsky MA, Punthakee Cleland SJ, Packard CJ, Zammit VA, et
Z, et al. Low-volume high-intensity al. Exercise training has greater effects
interval training reduces hyperglycemia on insulin sensitivity in daughters of
and increases muscle mitochondrial patients with type 2 diabetes than in
capacity in patients with type 2 women with no family history of
diabetes. J Appl Physiol 2011; 111 (6): diabetes. Diabetologia 2008; 51 (10):
1554-60 1912-9.

20. Gibala MJ, Little JP, van Essen M, 27. Towler MC, Hardie DG. AMP-
Wilkin GP, Burgomaster KA, Safdar A, activated protein kinase in metabolic
et al. Short-term sprint interval versus control and insulin signaling. Circ Res
traditional endurance training: similar 2007; 100 (3): 328-41
initial adaptations in human skeletal
muscle and exercise performance. J 28. Krssak M, Petersen KF, Bergeron R,
Physiol 2006; 575 (Pt 3): 901-11. Price T, Laurent D, Rothman DL, et al.
Intramuscular glycogen and
21. Ceriello A. The possible role of intramyocellular lipid utilization during
postprandial hyperglycaemia in the prolonged exercise and recovery in
pathogenesis of diabetic complications. man: a 13C and 1H nuclear magnetic
Diabetologia 2003; 46 Suppl 1: M9-16 resonance spectroscopy study. J Clin
Endocrinol Metab 2000; 85 (2): 748-54
22. Cauza E, Hanusch-Enserer U,
Strasser B, Kostner K, Dunky A, Haber 29. Ritov VB, Menshikova EV, Azuma K,
P. Strength and endurance training lead Wood R, Toledo FGS, Goodpaster BH, et
to different post exercise glucose al. Deficiency of electron transport
profiles in diabetic participants using a chain in human skeletal muscle
continuous subcutaneous mitochondria in type 2 diabetes mellitus
glucose monitoring system. Eur J Clin and obesity. Am J Physiol Endocrinol
Invest 2005; 35 (12): 745-51 Metab 2010; 298 (1): E49-58

23. Gill JMR, Malkova D. Physical 30. Burgomaster KA, Howarth KR,
activity, fitness and cardiovascular Phillips SM, Rakobowchuk M, Macdonald
disease risk in adults: interactions with MJ, McGee SL, et al. Similar metabolic
insulin resistance and obesity. Clin Sci adaptations during exercise after low
2006; 110 (4): 409-25 volume sprint interval and traditional
endurance training in humans. J
Physiol. 2008; 586 (1): 151-60.
31. Hood MS, Little JP, Tarnopolsky MA,
Myslik F, Gibala MJ. Low-volume
interval training improves muscle
oxidative capacity in sedentary adults.
Med Sci Sports Exerc 2011; 43 (10):
1849-56

32. Halliwill JR, Taylor JA, Eckberg DL.


Impaired sympathetic vascular
regulation in humans after acute
dynamic exercise. J Physiol 1996; 495
(Pt 1): 279-88

33. Halliwill JR. Mechanisms and clinical


implications of post-exercise
hypotension in humans. Exerc Sport
Sci Rev 2001; 29 (2): 65-70

You might also like