Professional Documents
Culture Documents
In any metropolitan city, a common man’s kilometer, in India. For proper management
life moves along with its traffic. For them life of traffic, there are many hindrances, which
becomes smooth and less stressful if the might come into the way of efficient service
traffic is smooth. The traffic police, especially delivery.
the constables play a significant role to keep The city of Kolkata is particularly
the traffic moving where the population density challenging for those attempting to regulate
is very high. The constables’ physical and traffic. The traffic population has grown ten
psychological well-being is a crucial factor for times in the last two decades and the number
enhancing their work efficiency. Kolkata is one of traffic policemen has remained almost the
of the bright examples of a city with very high same. Imagine having a job where you have
population density i.e. 33, 000 per square to stand in the middle of hundreds of noisy
20 Coping Strategies of Traffic Constables
and polluting vehicles throughout the working health problems. The reasons for stress are
day. The job is physically demanding as well plenty; long working hours, irregular eating
as mentally challenging. How efficiently one habits, sleepless nights, poor living conditions,
will deliver services depends on a number of ill treatment by seniors, disturbed personal life
factors like interest, benefits received, proper and the dwindling public confidence in the
coordination and cooperation among the staff police force. In fact, it is said that policing is
etc. If somebody works out of compulsion, the most stressful job among all government
then the output is not expected to be very high professions. For constables, the problem is
in terms of quality and resulting into stress. If more acute. A vast section of the constabulary
a person has problems in the family then also wastes a lot of time traveling from police
he may not be able to concentrate on work. station to their homes and vice-versa. Due to
Stress is defined as an upset in the body’s lack of adequate accommodation in the City,
balance due to physical, mental or emotional constables are forced to stay in the outskirts,
stimuli. When stress occurs, the body usually at some distance from their stations.
undergoes several physiological changes and Some of the constables’ travel more than 40
adrenaline, sugar and fat are released. Stress kilometers a day while a few of them works
manifests itself in different ways, including continuously for a week by sleeping in the
fatigue, chronic headaches, irritability; swings police station itself.
in appetite or mood, low self-esteem and Stress among policemen would manifest
diminished sex drive. Such adverse reactions in the form of fatigue, depression, inability to
are seen to contribute to mental and physical concentrate and impulsive behaviour. These
illness and several acts and regulations place danger signals are quite common among the
a duty of care on employers to protect their traffic policemen whose nature of work is such
employees. that they hardly can control their
It’s a tough job, which has direct influence temper. During VIP visits, the patience level
on the constables’ life as it is found that many of a traffic cop hits the nadir as they not only
traffic constables suffer from critical have to put in more than three hours of extra
respiratory problems, partial deafness, high duty but also are accountable to any lapse
blood pressure and gastric problems due to during the convoy movement. People normally
irregular food habits are also frequently complain that policemen are rude and high-
reported. Some attempts are being made to handed, but what they fail to see are the
reduce burden on traffic constables like new extreme conditions under which they lead their
signal lights are being installed that will lives. Stress also has a negative effect on
automatically detect the number of vehicles the health of the policemen and makes them
on the road and adjust signal duration more susceptible to heart attacks and strokes.
accordingly – and this should help lighten the A number of studies were carried out in
burden and increase the efficiency of the traffic different parts of the world for understanding
department. the level of stress among Police Personnel.
Stress is one of the factors which hinder In a recently conducted study among the West
the activities of traffic police for continuous Bengal Police Officers revealed that 42 and
six hours during summer, that also in a city 12% of the West Bengal Police Officers were
like Kolkata where the summer diurnal suffering from moderate and high
temperatures are generally between 35-45 psychological stress respectively. Further
degrees. Owing to these factors a good analysis of data revealed that the main areas
number of police constables are subjected to of stress included un-profitability (32%), role
overload (74%), role conflict (50%),
Sibnath Deb et al. 21
powerlessness (28%), role ambiguity (36%), the inordinate use of alcohol associated with
unreasonable group and political pressure this condition. Results suggest that certain
(58%), intrinsic impoverishment (32%) and traumatic police work exposures increase the
under participation (60%). Findings suggest risk of high-level PTSD symptoms, which
that special attention is required for taking subsequently increase the risk of high alcohol
need-based measures for each of the above use and suicide ideation. The combined
areas of stress for unburdening the level of impact of PTSD and increased alcohol use
stress among West Bengal Police Officers led to a ten-fold increase risk for suicide
(Deb, Chakraborty, Chatterjee, & Srivastava, ideation. Violanti and Gehrke (2004)
2005a). In another study carried out in Kolkata concluded that increased frequency and type
Traffic Police Officers, authors found that the of traumas, especially those occurring to other
main causes of stress were inadequate rest, co-workers and those associated with gender,
no leave, abstaining from social occasions might eventually lead to a secondary process
and excessive work pressure (Deb, of emotional compassion fatigue.
Chakraborty, Chatterjee, & Srivastava, Deschamps, Paganon-Badinier, Marchand,
2005b). Green (2004) carried out a study and Merle (2003) found that Police from
among Police Officers with a view to minority groups such as ageing subjects or
ascertaining whether the Police Officers had police officers have been reported to
severe post-traumatic stress than PTSD in experience greater stress. This population is
civilians. No significant differences were adversely affected by lack of available
found, although there was a tendency for manpower and long working hours. In fact
higher use of alcohol and to try not to think sources of stress in the police population are
about the trauma. Police Officers had more found both in the weariness of the job and
experiences of reliving the trauma or acting private life planning. Levenson and Dwyer
as if the trauma were recurring but, again, not (2003) reported that peer support component
to a significant degree. Yang, Wang, Lan and of law enforcement and other emergency
Wang (2004) found statistically significant services agencies has contributed to an
difference in occupational stress and strain increase in professional mental health
between doctors, Police Officers and teachers referrals and a decrease in on-the-job
was statistically significant (P< 0.01), and the suicides, sick days, and poor work
score of the police-officers was higher than performance. Furthermore, peer participation
that of the doctors and teachers (P<0.05), but in debriefings following a traumatic event, and
the personal resources of Police Officers were peer support during a crisis facilitates the
lower than those of the doctors and teachers process of psychological closure and
(P<0.05). Further analysis of all items of mourning and enables emergency services
personal strain revealed that the scores of workers to cope more effectively with tragedy
vocational strain, psychological strain, so they can continue to perform their jobs
physical strain, but not of interpersonal strain, efficiently and with satisfaction.
were significantly higher in police Officers than Pole, Neylan, Best, Orr, and Marmar
in doctors and teachers (P< 0.05). (2003) emphasized the importance of
Violanti (2004) explored suicide ideation contextual threat and suggest that laboratory
in Police Officers and possible correlates measures of startle improve upon self-
associated with such ideation focusing on reported exaggerated startle alone in indexing
psychologically traumatic police work PTSD symptom severity in urban police
experiences, the development of officers. Collins and Gibbs (2003) confirm
posttraumatic stress (PTSD) in officers, and previous findings of organizational culture and
22 Coping Strategies of Traffic Constables
workload as the key issues in officer stress. are ‘false-keyed’. The items relate to all
Given that the degree of symptom appears to relevant components of job life which causes
be worsening, management action is required. stress in some way or the other, such as, role
Further research is indicated within the police over-load, role ambiguity, role conflict, group
population into a possible increased and political pressures, responsibility for
susceptibility in female officers. Literature persons, under participation, powerlessness,
review indicates that no such study has been poor peer relations, intrinsic impoverishment,
carried out among the traffic constables with low status, strenuous working conditions, and
a view to understanding their level of stress. unprofitability. This apart, one Semi-
From the above discussion it is also clear that Structured Questionnaire was used for
no attempt had, however, been made to study understanding the causal factors, coping
the other problems the traffic constables face strategies and other allied problems faced by
during service life. Accordingly the present the traffic constables in Kolkata as well as their
investigation was aimed to achieve the perceived solutions.
following objective: Results
Objective: Analysis of the overall score shows a
The broad objective of the present study mean score of 154.5 on a scale of 46 - 230
was to understand the job-related stress of and a standard deviation of 18.33. The mid
traffic constables, causal factors behind the point/mid value was calculated using the
same, coping strategies as well as other formula like Mid Value= (Lower Limit + Upper
problems faced by them in discharging their Limit)/2, which in this case was 138. The
duties efficiently and perceived solution. constables who got score above mid point
Method have been regarded as suffering from
occupational stress. Further, they were
Sample: divided into two groups i.e., moderately
Data were collected from 68 traffic stressed and highly stressed. Moderately
constables proportionately selected from 11 stressed are those who got score between
Traffic Guards in Kolkata following random 138-184 and highly stressed are those who
selection method and their informed consent got score above 185 and above. Findings
was obtained explaining the objective of the revealed that 76.5 and 2.9% traffic constables
study. All the 68 constables filled up the were suffering from moderate and high
psychological test while 62 filled up the Semi- psychological stress. Moderate psychological
structured Questionnaire. stress means the constables who got the
Tools: score between 138-184 and highly stressed
means who got score between 185-230
Occupational Stress Index developed by ranges. Further effort was made to analyze
Srivastava and Singh (1995) was used for the data domain-wise.
achieving the objective of the present study.
This scale aims to measure the extent of Domain–wise analysis of data revealed
stress, which the employees perceive arising that the traffic constables were found to be
from various constituent and conditions of their highly stressed particularly in the domains:
job. The stress researchers have developed under participation (82.4%), powerlessness
the scales which the stress arising exclusively (80.9%), role overload (77.9%), Unprofitability
from job roles. The scale consists of 46 items,
(76.5%), poor peer relations (61.8%),
each to be rated on the five-point scale. Out
of 46 items 28 are ‘true-keyed’ and rest 18 strenuous working conditions (66.2%) and
Sibnath Deb et al. 23
they have suggested followed by recruitment 2. Providing a platform for the constable to
of more staff, participation of constables in share their problems with the higher
policy formulation and/or allocation of duty, authorities frankly and openly.
increase in salary, proper coordination of 3. Guard-wise more and more rewards for
interaction of different categories of staff all the categories of traffic police in the form
irrespective of political categorization. Traffic of memento should be introduced to
constables also emphasized on some of the increase their self-worth and level of
important issues like introduction of Euro II motivation.
vehicles which will in turn reduce the level of 4.Higher authorities of the Traffic Department
air pollution and enforcement of strict should take the initiative to initiate dialogue
discipline in the department along with with different television channels in
creating awareness among common people creating awareness of traffic controlling
about the rules of traffic through media. system among general public.
Healthy interpersonal relationship is a 5. Involvement of representative constables
very important motivating factor for the staff in decision-making process.
in discharging their duties efficiently. 6. Adequate staff at all levels in the traffic
Therefore the present study also explored the department should be recruited.
issue. Findings indicated a positive picture that
7. A common fund should be generated for
the constables also extend support and
extending support to any staff during
cooperation to one another in case of personal severe health and other family problems.
problems of their colleagues. Personal
problems and/or problems in the family also References
affect the efficiency of the staff while Collins, P.A., & Gibbs, A.C. (2003). Stress in police
discharging their duties. Findings suggests officers: a study of the origins, prevalence and
severity of stress-related symptoms within a
that more then 50.0% of the constables have
county police force. Occupational Medicine
major problems in their families like financial (Lond). 53, 256-64.
crisis, chronic illness of family members,
Deschamps, F., Paganon-Badinier, I., Marchand,
mental disturbances for not being able to give A.C., & Merle, C. (2003). Sources and
minimum time to their family members, which assessment of occupational stress in the
adds to their mental disturbances. At times of Police. Journal of Occupational Health. 45,
crisis, close family members and friends are 358-64.
the most preferred choices followed by Deb, S, Chakraborty, T, Chatterjee, P., &
colleagues and neighbors for sharing their Srivastava, N. (2005a, Jan.-March). Are West
problems. Bengal police officers stressed? The Indian
Police Journal, L-2, 63-72.
Recommendations: Deb, S, Chakraborty, T, Chatterjee, P., &
On the basis of the findings of the present Srivastava, N. (2005b, July–Sept.).
study, the following points are recommended Psychological stress of traffic police officers,
causal factors behind the same and their
for immediate attention of higher authorities.
coping strategies. The Indian Police Journal,
1. Some recreational and/or group activities L-2, 16-30.
should be introduced and practiced Green, B. (2004). Post-Traumatic stress disorder
religiously in the traffic guard to release in UK police officers. Current Medical
the job related stress of 79.4% constables. Research and Opinion, 20, 101-5.
Levenson, R.L. Jr, & Dwyer, L.A. (2003). Peer
28 Coping Strategies of Traffic Constables
support in law enforcement: past, present, and Violanti, J.M., & Gehrke, A. (2004). Police trauma
future. International Journal of Emerging encounters: precursors of compassion
Mental Health,5, 147-52. fatigue. International Journal of Emerging
Pole, N., Neylan, T.C., Best, S.R., Orr, S.P., & Mental Health, 6, 75-80.
Marmar, C.R. (2003). Fear-potentiated startle Yang, X.W., Wang, Z.M., Lan, Y.J., & Wang, M.Z.
and posttraumatic stress symptoms in urban (2004). Compare the occupational stress and
police officers. Journal of Trauma Stress, 16, work ability among the police-officers, doctors
471-9. and teachers. Sichuan Da Xue Xue Bao Yi
Violanti, J.M. (2004). Predictors of police suicide Xue Ban. 35, 251-4.
ideation. Suicide and Life-Threatening
Behaviour, 34, 277-83. Received: August 26, 2006
Accepted: September 12, 2007
Address for Correspondence: Sibnath Deb, PhD, Faculty Member, Dept.
of Applied Psychology; University of Calcutta, Council Member, The
International Society for Prevention of Child Abuse and Neglect, USA, Member
of the Editorial Board, The Journal of Interpersonal Violence, USA; 92,
A.P.C.Road, Kolkata-700 009, India, E-mail: sibnath23@rediffmail.com/
sibnath23@gmail.com
Tanusree Chakraborty, MSc in Applied Psychology is the Guest Faculty in
the Dept of Psychology. Ashutosh College.
Pooja Chatterjee, PhD in Applied Psychology is the Head, Dept of Psychology,
Ashutosh College.
Neerajakshi Srivastava, PhD in Nutrition is currenlty working as consultant.
Acknowledgements: Authors wish to acknowledge their gratitude to the
Commissioner of Police, Kolkata for giving permission for data collection.
Authors are also grateful to the Director General of Police, State Crime Records
Bureau, Additional Commissioner of Police, Kolkata and Deputy Commissioner
of Police (Traffic) for extending all sorts of cooperation for successful completion
of the study and for sharing their experiences regarding the issue of
investigation. Finally, authors are thankful to all the respondents of 11 traffic
guards for giving time from their busy schedule.