Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ahdab Elmorshedy)
Chapter 1
Grounding Systems
• Effects can range from a barely perceptible tingle to immediate cardiac arrest.
• There are no absolute limits or even known values that show the exact injury from any
given current.
• The so-called low voltages can be extremely dangerous because, all other factors being
equal, the degree of injury is proportional to the length of time the body is in the
circuit.
• A severe shock can cause considerably more damage to the body than is visible.
• For example, a person may suffer internal hemorrhages and destruction of tissues,
nerves, and muscles.
• The final injury may well be from a fall, cuts, burns, or broken bones.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 1
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
Voltage is almost always a constant so electrical current levels are determined by the
resistance to flow. When there is a potential for electrical shock we can protect ourselves by
maximizing our resistance to current flow. This is done by wearing insulating shoes and
gloves, and by not making direct contact with a source of ground potential such as plumbing
or other sources of ground.
less
SAFE
• Electrical
• Arc
• Thermal contact
* Electrical burns are the result of the electric current flowing through tissues or bone.
* Tissue damage is caused by the heat generated by the current flow through the body.
* Electrical burns are one of the most serious injuries you can receive and should be given
immediate attention.
* Arc or flash burns, on the other hand, are the result of high temperatures near the body and
are produced by an electric arc or explosion.
* Thermal contact burns are those normally experienced when the skin comes in contact with
hot surfaces of energized equipment.
* Additionally, clothing may be ignited in an electrical accident and a thermal burn will
result.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 3
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
Extension cords are approved for temporary use only. If extended use is required, hard
wiring such as a new outlet should be installed. Extension cords are easily frayed, a condition
which may expose bare wires. If not properly placed, extension cords may also become a trip
hazard.
Short circuit
Shorts cause a great increase in the flow of current through the cord producing heat and
perhaps initiating a fire.
Short
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 4
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
GFCI
Switches Receptacle
Hot Line In
Current
Sensor
Neutral Line In
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 5
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
* A GFCI compares the amount of current in the ungrounded (hot) conductor with the
amount of current in the neutral conductor.
* If the current in the neutral conductor becomes less than the current in the hot conductor, a
ground fault condition exists.
* The amount of current that is missing is returned to the source by some path other than the
intended path (fault current).
* A fault current as low as 4 mA to 6 mA activates the GFCI and interrupts the circuit.
* Once activated, the fault condition is cleared and the GFCI manually resets before power
may be restored to the circuit.
GFCI Use
Any outlet within 6 feet of a sink or other source of plumbing should be equipped with a
GFCI. Recalling Ohm’s law, V=IR, very low resistances such as an earth ground (plumbing
etc.) allow for very high levels of current flow.
GFCI device may be located at a circuit breaker instead of an outlet. This arrangement allows
several outlets to be protected with a single GFCI device.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 6
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
Electrical Fires
Dry chemical extinguishers (also know as ABC extinguishers) are approved for fighting
electrical fires. The label indicates the type of extinguisher that is present. Electrical fires
should only be fought if the situation is well in hand. If you feel uncomfortable fighting a fire,
pull the alarm and exit the building.
Grounding
* To offer enhanced protection, an additional ground, called the "equipment ground," must
be furnished by providing another path from the tool or machine through which the current
can flow to the ground.
* This additional ground safeguards the electric equipment operator in the event that a
malfunction causes any metal on the tool to become accidentally energized.
* The resulting heavy surge of current will then activate the circuit protection devices and
open the circuit.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 7
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
5. To stabilize voltage during transient conditions and to minimize the probability of flashover
during transients.
6. To divert stray RF energy from sensitive audio, video, control, and computer equipment.
2. To assure that a person in the vicinity of grounded facilities is not exposed to the danger of
critical electric shock.
* The soil resistivity is the single most important factor affecting the resistance of the
ground system.
* For high frequency and steep-front waves penetrating a very high resistive soil, the earth
may be presented by a parallel connection of resistance R, capacitance C, and a gap.
* For low frequencies and dc the charging current is negligible comparing to the leakage
current, and the earth can be presented by a pure resistance R.
Soil Characteristics
* Soil type: Soil resistivity varies widely depending on soil type, from as low as 1
Ohmmeter for moist loamy topsoil to almost 10,000 Ohm-meters for surface limestone.
* Moisture content is one of the controlling factors in earth resistance because electrical
conduction in soil is essentially electrolytic.
* The resistivity of most soils rises abruptly when moisture content is less than 15 to 20
percent by weight, but is affected very little above 20 percent.
* The moisture alone is not the predominant factor influencing the soil resistivity.
* If the water is relatively pure, it will be of high resistivity and may not provide the soil with
adequate conductivity.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 8
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 9
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 10
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
* The soluble salts, acids or alkali presented in soil influence considerably the soil
resistivity.
* The most commonly used salting materials are sodium chloride (common salt), copper
sulfate and magnesium sulfate.
* Different types of salts have varying depletion rates; consequently, different types may be
combined to produce the optimum depletion and conditioning characteristics.
* The temperature effect on soil resistivity is almost negligible for temperatures above the
freezing points.
* When temperature drops below water freezing point, the resistivity increases rapidly.
* Compactness and granularity affects soil resistivity in that denser soils generally
have lower resistivity.
* The two factors—moisture and salt content—are the most influential ones on soil resistivity
for a given type of soil.
* Therefore the chemical treatment of soil surrounding ground rods is preferable and in some
cases the only economically sound solution in obtaining low impedance of the ground system.
* They consist of a metal (or combination of metals) which do not corrode excessively for the
period of time they are expected to serve.
* Because of its high conductivity and resistance to corrosion, copper is the most commonly
used material for ground electrodes.
* Other popular materials are hot-galvanized steel, stainless steel and lead.
* Ground electrodes may be rods, plates, strips, solid section wire or mats.
* Solid Copper-Copper -clad steel rod ( copper shrunk onto the core)-Copper bonded steel
core (copper is molecularly bonded to nickel plated steel rod).
* Solid copper rods not prone to corrosion, but are expensive and difficult to drive into hard
ground without bending.
* A steel cored copper rod is used for this reason, however those rods that are simply clad are
prone to the cladding tearing away from the core when driven in rocky ground, or when bent.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 11
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
* The most cost effective solution is the molecularly bonded steel cored copper rod.
The main part of any electrode resistance is that of the body of earth
surrounding the electrode.
* The equations for the resistance of any complex system of ground electrodes can be
developed from the fundamental principles.
* The starting point for such a development is the use of a buried metallic electrode with a
hemispherical base of radius r.
* When a current I enters the ground through such an electrode, due to its hemispherical
base, the current flows radial outward as shown in the sketch below.
A Hemispherical electrode
ρ dx
dR =
2π x 2
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 12
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
* If ρ is the resistivity of the soil, the resistance offered by a hemispherical shell of thickness
dx at a radial distance x from the electrode is given by
r1
ρdx
R=∫
a
2πx 2
* Hence, the resistance encountered by the ground electrode up to the depth of r1 is
ρ 1 1
R= −
2π a r1
* If r1 is made ∞, the total resistance of the ground electrode will be
ρ
r1 → ∞ R∞ =
2π a
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 13
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
* The general equation of the resistance shown above can be modified to a suitable form.
* If a current I enter the ground electrode, the potential drop up to the shell radius of r1 will
be given by
1 1
ρ
R= −
2π a r1
aρ
R= 1 −
2πa r1
a
V = IR = IR∞ 1 −
r1
ρ
R =
2πC
* Where C is the electrostatic capacitance of the electrode and its image above earth.
Q
Vsphere =
4πε 0 r
Q
= C = 4πε 0 r
V
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 14
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
* At very high values of r1, the resistance value will approach the value R∞, beyond which
true ground can be assumed to be present.
* The figure below shows the plots of R, V and Vabs, the absolute potential with respect to the
true ground against the radial distance r1 from the electrode.
a
V = IR = IR∞ 1 −
r1
a
Vabs = IR∞
r1
Iρ a
Vabs =
2πa r1
Iρ
Vabs =
2πr1
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 15
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
ρI
E x = ρi =
2πx 2
r1
ρI ρI 1 1
Vr = ∫ dx = −
1
a 2πx
2
2π a r1
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 16
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
Step potential
* “Step potential” is the voltage between the feet of a person standing near an energized
grounded object.
* It is equal to the difference in voltage, given by the voltage distribution curve, between two
points at different distances from the “electrode.”
* A person could be at risk of injury during a fault simply by standing near the grounding
point.
Touch potential
* “Touch potential” is the voltage between the energized object and the feet of a person in
contact with the object.
* It is equal to the difference in voltage between the energized object and a point some
distance away.
* The touch potential could be nearly the full voltage across the grounded object if that object
is grounded at a point remote from the place where the person is in contact with it.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 17
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
Driven rods
ρ 8l
R = ln − 1
2π l d
* Examples:
(a) 20mm rod of 3m length and Soil resistivity 50 Ω-m .....R=16.1 Ω
(b) 25mm rod of 2m length and Soil resistivity 30 Ω-m.....R=13.0 Ω
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 18
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
* They should be driven far apart as possible to minimize the overlap among their areas of
influence.
* It is necessary to determine the net reduction in the total resistance by connecting rods in
parallel.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 19
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
Equivalent hemisphere
ρ ρ 8l
= ln − 1
2πreq 2πl d
l
req =
8l
ln d − 1
* The combined resistance is a function of the number and configuration of electrodes, the
separation between them, their dimensions and soil resistivity.
* Rods in parallel should be spaced at least twice their length to utilize the full benefit of the
additional rods.
* If the separation of the electrodes is much larger than their lengths and only a few
electrodes are in parallel, then the resultant ground resistance can be calculated using the
ordinary equation for resistances in parallel.
* In practice, the effective ground resistance will usually be higher than this.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 20
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
* They should be driven far apart as possible to minimize the overlap among their areas of
influence.
* It is necessary to determine the net reduction in the total resistance by connecting rods in
parallel.
* The method consists of assuming that each equivalent hemisphere carries the same charge.
* From this and the total charge the capacity and the resistance can be calculated.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 21
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
Equivalent
Hemisphere
* Actual value ρ
Re qideal =
4πr
* Ideal value
V ρ 1 1
Re qactual = = +
I 4π r d
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 22
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
ideal Re qideal
η= = ≤1
actual Re qactual
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 23
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
¾ A common method for obtaining low ground resistance at high voltage substations is to
use interconnected ground grids.
¾ A typical grid system for a substation would comprise 4/0 bare solid copper
conductors buried at a depth of 30-60 cm, spaced in a grid pattern of about 3-10 m.
¾ Grid meshes are often used to complement rods or can be used separately when deep
driven rods are impractical due to soil considerations.
¾ Grid meshes are often used for the grounding in substations to create an equipotential
platform and also to handle the high fault currents returning to the transformer
neutrals.
¾ They are particularly useful when multiple injection points are required, at a
substation.
¾ In this case a number of items will be connected to the grid at various locations, the
mesh provides a good ground irrespective of the injection point of the fault current.
¾ Grounding resistance of buried grid meshes can be considerably lower than those
implemented using vertical ground rods.
¾ Increasing the area of the grid coverage can also significantly reduce the ground
resistance.
The side of grid conductors required to avoid fusing under the fault current I is estimated as
1
76t 2
a =I
ln(234 + Tm )(234 + Ta )
¾ where a is the copper cross-section (circular mils), t is the fault duration s, Tm is the
maximum allowable temperature, and Ta is the ambient temperature.
¾ Such a grid not only effectively grounds the equipment, but has the added advantage
of controlling the voltage gradients at the surface
of the ground to values safe for human contact.
¾ Ground rods may be connected to the grid for further reduction in the ground
resistance when the upper layer of soil is of much higher resistivity than that of the soil
underneath.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 24
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
A practical approach to safe grounding considers the interaction of two grounding systems:
¾ The intentional ground, consisting of ground electrodes buried at some depth below
the earth surface, and the accidental ground, temporarily established by a person
exposed to a potential gradient at a grounded facility.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 25
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
¾ The ground potential rise at the facility site increases proportionally to the fault
current; the higher the current, the lower the value of total system resistance which
must be obtained.
¾ For most large substations the ground resistance should be less than 1 Ohm.
¾ For smaller distribution substations the usually acceptable range is 1-5 Ohms,
depending on the local conditions.
¾ The grounding system of power plants and substations is usually formed by several
vertical ground rods connected to each other and to all equipment frames, neutrals
and structures that are to be grounded.
¾ Such a system that combines a horizontal grid and a number of vertical ground rods
penetrating lower soil layers has several advantages in comparison to a grid alone.
Sufficiently long ground rods stabilize the performance of such a combined system making it
less dependent on seasonal and weather variations of soil resistivity.
¾ Rods are more efficient in dissipating fault currents because the upper soil layer
usually has a higher resistivity than the lower layers.
¾ The current in the ground rods is discharged mainly in lower portion of the rods.
¾ Recently, some new methods have been proposed to decrease ground resistance. These
methods are listed in the following section.
1-Chemical Rods
¾ Chemical rods are electrodes with holes along their length, filled with mineral salts.
¾ The specially formulated mineral salts are evenly distributed along the entire length of
the electrode.
¾ The rod absorbs moisture from both air and soil.
¾ Continuous conditioning of a large area insures an ultra-low-resistance ground which
is more effective than a conventional electrode.
¾ If the conductive salts are running low, the rod can be recharged with a refill kit.
¾ These rods are available in vertical and horizontal configurations.
¾ They may be used in rocky soils, freezing climates, dry deserts, or tropical rain forests.
¾ They provide stable protection for many years.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 26
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
Disadvantages are:
¾ Chemicals concentrated around electrodes will cause corrosion.
¾ It is obvious that replacing all or part of that soil with a highly conductive backfill will
facilitate the achievement of a low-resistance ground connection.
¾ The greater the percentage of soil replaced, the lower the ultimate grounding
resistance.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 27
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
¾ The amount of the backfill material required is determined in most cases by the
Interfacing Volume and Critical Cylinder principles.
¾ For practical purposes for a ground rod the entire connection to earth is contained
within an IV whose radius is 2.5 times the length of the rod.
¾ Most of the earth connection takes place in a cylinder close to the electrode, called the
Critical Cylinder.
¾ A study of the influence of soil within the IV demonstrates that six inches of soil along
any radial makes up 52 per cent of the connection to earth; a 12 inches makes up 68
percent of the connection.
¾ Beyond a diameter of 24 inches there is very little improvement for much larger
diameters.
¾ Therefore, the recommended diameter for the Critical Cylinder is between 12 and 24
inches, and the calculated amount of the required backfill material is based on that
diameter and the length of the ground rod.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 28
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
¾ drilling deep holes in the ground, developing cracks in the soil by means of explosions
in the holes, filling the holes with low resistivity materials (LRM) under pressure.
¾ Most of the cracks around the vertical conductors will be filled with LRM, and a
complex network of low resistivity tree like cracks linked to the substation grid is
formed.
¾ Field tests show that the optimum span between vertical conductors is in the range of
1.5-2 times the length of the vertical conductor.
z Cement-like compound
z Non-corrosive
z Extremely conductive
z Installed around the electrode
z Easy installation
z Permanent
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 29
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
¾ Since it is hygroscopic by nature it will tend to absorb moisture when available and
keep it up to 30 days, thus maintaining a resistivity lower than the surrounding soil.
¾ However, during a long dry season concrete will dry out with a subsequent rise in
resistivity.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 30
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
Neutral Grounding
¾ Ungrounded system.
¾ Solid grounding.
¾ Impedance grounding (R and X).
¾ Resonant grounding.
Ungrounded Systems
• Early Electrical systems are almost universally operated ungrounded.
• On small systems an insulation failure on one phase did not cause an outage.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 31
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
• In normal operation the capacitive current of all three lines is leading the respective
line to neutral voltage by 90˚, and the vector sum of all three currents is zero.
• An ungrounded system is one in which there is no intentional connection between the
conductors and earth ground.
• In any system, a capacitive coupling exists between the system conductors and the
adjacent grounded surfaces.
• In fact, it is beneficial, because it establishes, in effect, a neutral point for the system
and as a result, the phase conductors are stressed at only line-to-neutral voltage above
ground.
• In any system, a capacitive coupling exists between the system conductors and the
adjacent grounded surfaces.
• In fact, it is beneficial, because it establishes, in effect, a neutral point for the system
and as a result, the phase conductors are stressed at only line-to-neutral voltage above
ground.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 32
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
• A ground fault on one line results in full line-to-line voltage appearing on the other
two phases.
• A voltage 1 .73 times the normal voltage is present on all insulation on the ungrounded
phases.
Line-to-line voltage
A B
C
Each phase is
line-to-neutral Neutral point Phase C is now at ground
voltage above ground.. established Ground potential
C by distribution
(a) (b)
NORMAL OPERATION GROUND FAULT ON PHASE
• This involves a tedious process of trial and error; first isolating the correct feeder, then
the branch, and finally the equipment at fault.
• Despite the drawbacks of an ungrounded system, it does have one main advantage.
• The circuit may continue in operation after the first ground fault, assuming it remains
as a single fault.
• This permits continued production, until a convenient shutdown can be scheduled for
maintenance
• The interaction between the faulted system and its distributed capacitance may cause
transient over-voltages (several times normal) to appear from line to ground during
normal switching of a circuit having a line to ground fault (short).
• These over-voltages may cause insulation failures at points other than the original
fault.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 33
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
• In addition, a second fault on another phase may occur before the first fault can be
cleared.
• This can result in very high line to line fault currents, equipment damage and
disruption of both circuits.
• When there is a short circuit on phase C; IC --> o as its voltage to ground is zero.
• The voltage of the unfaulted phases increase to full line-to-line value with respect to
ground, and their charging currents increase proportionally.
• The charging currents shift accordingly and the sum of the charging currents in the
unfaulted phases is three times the normal value and appears in the ground, returning
to the system through the fault.
• If the fault can be interrupted, it will be at a current zero, current zero occurs at the
instant of a voltage maximum, if the fault momentarily clears, a H.V immediately
appears across the fault, and restrike of the fault will occur.
• In this moment, the excessive voltage charge of the capacitors on the unfaulted lines
has been trapped as a dc charge.
• When the arc restrikes again, the capacitors are again recharged by a line-to-line
voltage added to the trapped charge.
• This will lead to an insulation failure on another phase and a major two-ph-fault.
• The capacitive current in the two healthy phases increase to 3 times the normal value.
• The capacitive current in the faulty phase is 3 times its normal value.
• A capacitive fault current flows in the ground. An arc is maintained in the ionized path
of the fault ---> "arcing ground“
• Under fault: the voltage to earth of the two healthy phases rises from their normal
phase to neutral voltage to full line value ---> insulation break down.
• The protective relays may not operate due to small fault current.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 34
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
Grounded System
All power systems of today operate with grounded neutrals.
It is important because:
4-Neutral grounding gives protection against arcing ground, unbalanced voltage with respect
to earth, and protection from lightning.
The intentional connection of the neutral points of transformers, generators and rotating
machinery to the earth ground network provides a reference point of zero volts.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 35
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
• The neutrals of any star connected transformers, generators are connected to ground.
• It minimizes the magnitude of the over voltage that will appear on the unfaulted
phases during a ground fault, resulting in a reduction in the stress on insulation.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 36
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
Solidly Grounding
• A solidly grounded system is one in which the neutral points have been intentionally
connected to ground with a conductor having no intentional impedance.
• This partially reduces the problem of transient over-voltages found on the ungrounded
system, provided the ground fault current is in the range of 25 to 100% of the system
three phase fault current.
• However; if the reactance of the generator or transformer is too great, the problem of
transient over-voltages will not be solved.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 37
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
• While solidly grounded systems are an improvement over ungrounded systems, and
speed the location of faults, they lack the current limiting ability of resistance
grounding.
• The destructive nature of arcing ground faults in solidly grounded systems is well
known and are caused by the energy dissipated in the fault.
Disadvantages:
• A solidly grounded system produces the greatest magnitude of ground fault current
when a fault to ground occurs and the destructive nature of arcing ground faults.
• The solidly grounded system has the highest probability of escalating into a phase-to-
phase or three-phase arcing fault, particularly for the 480 and 600V systems.
• A safety hazard exists for solidly grounded systems from the severe flash, arc burning
and blast hazard from any phase-to-ground fault.
• Controlling the fault current and clearing the fault promptly, the amount of damage at
the fault will be reduced.
• Thus the fault current can be limited, in order to prevent equipment damage.
• I=V/R
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 38
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
TRANSFORMER
NEUTRA
SYSTEM VOLTAGE
LINE NEUTRAL
NEUTRAL GROUNDING
RESISTOR
• Low resistance grounding of the neutral limits the ground fault current to a high level
(typically 50 amps or more) in order to operate protective fault clearing relays and
current transformers.
• These devices are then able to quickly clear the fault, usually within a few seconds.
• The limited fault current and fast response time also prevent overheating and
mechanical stress on conductors.
• Note that, like the solidly grounded neutral system, the circuit must be shut down after
the first ground fault.
• Low resistance grounding resistors are typically rated 400 amps for 10 seconds, and
are commonly found on medium and high voltage systems.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 39
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
• High resistance grounding of the neutral limits the ground fault current to a very low
level (typically under 25 amps).
• It is used on low voltage systems of 600 volts or less, under 3000 amps.
• By limiting the ground fault current, the fault can be tolerated on the system until it
can be located, and then isolated or removed at a convenient time.
• This permits continued production, providing a second ground fault does not occur.
• The resistor must be sized to ensure that the ground fault current limit is greater than
the system's total capacitance-to-ground charging current.
• By strategic use and location of ground fault sensing relays, trouble shooting can be
greatly simplified.
• High resistance neutral grounding combined with sensitive ground fault relays and
isolating devices, can quickly detect and shut down the faulted circuit.
• This provides operating personnel with the added safety that's essential in this
environment.
• This makes it possible to identify the faulted feeder with sensitive ground-fault relays.
• There is no arc flash hazard, as there is with a solidly grounded system, since the fault
current is limited to approximately 5A.
The reasons for limiting the current by resistance grounding may be one or more of the
following:
1) to reduce burning and melting effects in faulted electric equipment, such as switchgear,
transformers, cables and rotating machines.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 40
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
3) to reduce electric-shock hazards to personnel caused by stray ground fault currents in the
ground return path.
4) to reduce arc blast or flash hazard to personnel who may have accidentally caused or who
happen to be in close proximity to the fault current.
5) to reduce the momentary line-voltage dip occasioned by the occurrence and clearing of a
ground fault.
6) to secure control of transient over voltages while at the same time avoiding the shutdown
of a faulty circuit on the occurrence of the first ground fault.
System Type
High
Productivity Impact Solidly Low Resistance Resistance
Ungrounded Grounded Grounded Grounded
System System System System
• No current at the fault, preventing restrikes and eliminates the cause of voltage
buildup.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 41
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
Resonant grounding
• Using Peterson coil which is a tunable iron cored reactor connected between the
neutral and ground.
Vph V ph I C = 3I = 3Vphωc
I= =
Xc 1 / ωc
I F = I A + I B = −3IC
I L = 3IC & IF + IL = 0
EC E
IL = − = −3 C = 3IC
XL XC
XC
∴ XL =
3
1
L=
3ω 2 c
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 42
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
• A temporary fault caused by falling branch, lightning surge, etc, creates an arc
between an overhead line and ground.
• The arc extinguishes and restrikes in a repeated, regular manner Æ arcing ground.
• The distributed capacitance discharges through the fault when the gap between point
of fault and ground breaks down.
• Arcing grounds produce reverse voltage oscillations reaching 3-4 times normal value.
• The voltage of a healthy line above earth is increased by √3 times when an earth fault
occurs on a line.
• This causes stress on the insulation of all the machines and equipment connected to the
system.
• The voltage rise of the line above earth is sustained and thereby insulation failure
likely to occur through fault current may be negligible.
• The voltage of healthy lines above ground becomes equal to line voltage which is √3
times the phase voltage.
• Earth faults cannot be sensed and the earth fault relaying becomes complicated.
• The overvoltages due to induced static charges are not conducted to earth in
ungrounded systems.
• The voltages of healthy lines with respect to earth remain at harmless value. They do
not increase to √3 time normal value.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 43
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
• The earth fault relaying is relatively simple. Useful amount of earth fault current is
available to operate earth fault relay.
• Greater safety for personnel or equipment due to operation of fuses or relays on earth
fault and limitation of voltages.
A
V
~
1 2 3 4
Four-Electrode Method
• The most common method of measuring ρ employs four electrodes driven into the soil.
• The theoretical basis of this method depends on using four small electrodes.
• The electrodes are inserted into four small holes in the earth all to a depth of b m, and
spaced along a straight line of intervals a m, and making electrical contact with the
earth only at the bottom.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 44
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
• A test current I is injected through the earth between the two outer electrodes and the
potential difference E between the two inner electrodes is measured with a
potentiometer or high impedance voltmeter.
• The ratio between the observed potential difference and the injected current is
referred to as the apparent resistance, which is a function of ρ and the electrode
geometry.
4π aR
ρ=
2a 2a
1 + −
a 2 + 4b 2 a2 + b2
4π aR
ρ=
n
ρ = 2π aR
• The arrangement of four electrodes in a straight line at equal intervals is known as the
Wenner configuration.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 45
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
A
↓ ↑
V
1 2 3 4
V
R =
I
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 46
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
Iρ 1 1
V4 2 = r − 2a
2π
Iρ 1 1
V43 = −
2π r a
Iρ 1 1
V 23 = −
2 π 2 a a
Iρ 1 1 (− I )ρ 1 1
V23 = − + −
total 2π a 2a 2π 2a a
Iρ 1 1 Iρ
= − =
π a 2a 2π a
V23 ρ
=R=
I 2π a
⇒ ρ = 2π aR
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 47
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
When an electrode system has been designed and installed, it is usually necessary to measure
and confirm the ground resistance between the electrode and “true Earth”. The most
commonly used method of measuring the ground resistance of a ground electrode is the 3-
point measuring technique shown in Figure 1. This method is derived from the 4-point
method, which is used for soil resistivity measurements.
The 3-point method, called the “fall of potential” method, comprises the Ground Electrode to
be measured and two other electrically independent test electrodes, usually labeled P
(Potential) and C (Current). These test electrodes can be of lesser “quality” (higher ground
resistance) but must be electrically independent of the electrode to be measured. An
alternating current (I) is passed through the outer electrode C and the voltage is measured, by
means of an inner electrode P, at some intermediary point between them. The Ground
Resistance is simply calculated using Ohm’s Law; Rg = V/I.
Other more complex methods, such as the Slope Method or the Four Pole Method, have been
developed to overcome specific problems associated with this simpler procedure, mainly for
measurements of the resistance of large grounding systems or at sites where space for locating
the test electrodes is restricted.
When performing a measurement, the aim is to position the auxiliary test electrode C far
enough away from the ground electrode under test so that the auxiliary test electrode P will
lie outside the effective resistance areas of both the ground system and the other test electrode.
If the current test electrode, C, is too close, the resistance areas will overlap and there will be
a steep variation in the measured resistance as the voltage test electrode is moved. If the
current test electrode is correctly positioned, there will be a ‘flat’ (or very nearly so)
resistance area somewhere in between it and the ground system, and variations in the position
of the voltage test electrode should only produce very minor changes in the resistance figure.
The instrument is connected to the ground system under test via a short length of test cable,
and a measurement is taken.
Measurement accuracy can be affected by the proximity of other buried metal objects to the
auxiliary test electrodes. Objects such as fences and building structures, buried metal pipes or
even other grounding systems can interfere with the measurement and introduce errors.
Often it is difficult to judge, merely from visual inspection of the site, a suitable location for
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 48
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
the tests stakes and so it is always advisable to perform more than one measurement to ensure
the accuracy of the test.
This method is generally not suited to large grounding installations, as the stake separations
needed to ensure an accurate measurement can be excessive, requiring the use of very long
test leads (refer to Table 1).
Normally, the outer test electrode, or current test stake, is driven into the ground 30 to 50
meters away from the ground system, (although this distance will depend on the size of the
system being tested - refer to Table 1) and the inner electrode, or voltage test stake, is then
driven into the ground mid-way between the ground electrode and the current test stake, and
in a direct line between them.
Table 1. Variation of current and voltage electrode separation with maximum ground system
dimensions, in meters.
Let E be the electrode whose resistance to ground is required to be measured and let P and C
be the auxiliary rods driven into the ground. A known value of current I is circulated between
C and E, and the voltage drop V between E and P is measured.
The resistance of the electrode E to the ground is V/I. The optimum location for the potential
electrode P is 0.62 of the distance from E to C when the distance D is at least 30 times the
depth of the electrode E.
Let the base of the electrode E be a hemisphere of (equivalent) radius r and the other two
electrodes designated as shown in the figure.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 49
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
The potential at E due to the entering current is Iρ /2π r and due to the current leaving at C is
- Iρ /2π D. The total potential at E can be given by
Similarly the total potential at P due to the current entering at E and that leaving at C can be
given by
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 50
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
V = VE -VP
If the resistance curve (Figure 2) between E and C is observed, it flattens beyond P (if located
optimally between E and C) and the resistance of the ground electrode between E and P and
that between E and C are nearly same. An upward bend in the resistance curve above, near
the point C is due to the resistance of the auxiliary rod C itself and does not affect
measurement of the resistance of the main electrode E.
Therefore the potential difference between E and C and between E and P will also be the
same. Hence, the measured resistance of the electrode E will be
p2 + pc + c2 = 0
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 51
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
From this, it follows that H = 0.618D will satisfy this condition. This indicates that for any
separation of the current electrodes (E and C), the true resistance of one of them is obtainable
when the potential electrode (P) is 61.8% of the distance toward the other.
The Fall of Potential method incorporates a check to ensure that the test electrodes are indeed
positioned far enough away for a correct reading to be obtained. It is advisable that this check
be carried, as it is really the only way of ensuring a correct result.
To perform a check on the resistance figure, two additional measurements should be made;
the first with the voltage test electrode (P) moved 10% further away from the ground under
test, and the second measurement with the (P) electrode moved 10% closer to the ground
under test.
If these two additional measurements are in agreement with the original measurement, within
the required level of accuracy, then the test stakes have been correctly positioned and the DC
resistance figure can be obtained by averaging the three results. However, if there is
substantial disagreement amongst any of these results, then it is likely that the stakes have
been incorrectly positioned, either by being too close to the ground system being tested, too
close to one another or too close to other structures that are interfering with the results. The
stakes should be repositioned at a larger separation distance or in a different direction and
the three measurements repeated. This process should be repeated until a satisfactory result is
achieved.
All the other requirements of test stake location - that they be in a straight line and be
positioned away from other structures - remain valid. When using this method, it is also
advisable to repeat the measurements with the inner test stake moved 10% of the ground
electrode-inner test stake separation distance, as before.
The main disadvantage with this method is that the theory on which it is based relies on the
assumption that the underlying soil is homogeneous, which in practice is rarely the case. Thus,
care should be taken in its use and a soil resistivity survey should always be carried out.
Alternatively, one of the other methods should be employed.
Three such methods are briefly described below. Specific details are not given here, but
instead the reader is referred to the relevant technical paper where these systems are
described in detail.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 52
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
The additional measurement and calculation effort tends to relegate this system to use with
only very large or complex grounding systems.
This technique is well suited to use with large systems in built up areas or on rocky terrain,
where it may be difficult to find suitable locations for the test electrodes, particularly over
long distances in a straight line.
Three test electrodes are used, set up at the corners of an equilateral triangle with the ground
system in the middle and measurements are made of the total resistance between adjacent
electrodes, and also between each electrode and the grounding system.
Using these results, a number of calculations are performed and a result can be obtained for
the resistance of the ground system.
This technique, developed by Dr G.F. Tagg, helps overcome some of the problems associated
with the requirement for knowing the electrical center of the grounding systems being tested.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 53
3 rd Year – High Voltage Engineering (Prof. Dr. Ahdab Elmorshedy)
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Kahraba 54