Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1
Badawi as a Prime minister of Malaysia. Since 2003 and onwards, under the leadership of
Dato’ Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi, foreign policy initiatives were further refined and
strengthened and aimed to build a resilient Malaysian economy. In order to implement such
objectives, leaders incorporated several initiatives in the foreign policy domain including
strong look east policy, policy of prosper thy neighbour, etc. Moreover, Malaysian
government under Prime Minister Badawi considered economics as their primary focus of
his foreign policy formulation. Hence, the economics remained as the main vehicle in his
foreign policy pursuit of country’sdomestic economicdevelopment and how to make that
pursuit more effective would remain the prime propel to Malaysian foreign policymakers.As
a matter of fact, overall orientation of the Malaysian foreign policy formulation under Prime
Minister Badawi realisticallybased on the same principles of foreign policy formulated by
Dr Mahathir Mohammad during his tenure. In other words, it can be said that Badawi’s
foreign policy approaches were nothing but an extension of foreign policy goals set forth by
his predecessor after the end of Cold War. In this chapter, the primary focus will be to
analyse the nature of political as well as economic and trade relationship between Malaysia
and China and how far this bilateralrelationship under Prime Minister Badawi brought this
two countries closerto each other.
2
Malaysia under Badawi’s leadership religiously followed the principle of Prosper-thy-
Neighbour as well as tried to maintain the peaceful environment in the international level.
As a result, the bilateral ties between Malaysia and China became more and more close to
each other. Dato Seri Badawi took the office of Prime Minister on October, 2003 and since
then he was meticulously pursued the rapprochement policy towards China either bilaterally
or sometimes through multilateral mechanisms. Under his leadership, Malaysian
Governmentcelebrated the 30–Years of Diplomatic Relations with China in 2004. Started in
January 2004 with a photo exhibition, the Sino-Malaysian Friendship Year was launched to
mark the 30th anniversary of the establishment of diplomatic relations between these two
countries. During this occasion, Malaysian Minister of Culture, Art and Tourism Mr Abdul
Kadir and Chinese Vice minister of Culture Mr MengXiaosi expressed their optimistic
outlook towards the prosperous bilateral relations. Malaysian Minister Abdul Kadir viewed
that his country was eager to work closely with China so that the bilateral ties has always
been on the best of terms, feelings and solidarity and in this context, he said, “We want to
always have very, very, special relationship with China.”1 The Chnese Minister
MengXiaosi,in the same occasion, also said:
“We believe that the series of celebrations for Malaysia-China Friendship Year
will have significant impacts on the development of political, economic and
cultural relations and play a positive role in enhancing mutual understanding
and friendship between the two countries and ushering in their common
prosperity.”2
1
Malaysian Minister of Culture, Art and Tourism Mr Abdul Kadir, during his visit to China,
commented. This was published in a news “Malaysia Hopes to Enhance Ties with China”, Xinhua
News Agency, available at www.peopledaily.com/en/ (accessed on 23 July 2010)
2
Ibid.
3
committed…Malaysia’s China policy has been a triumph of good diplomacy
and good sense. Our position was that of undivided China, secure, prosperous,
at peace with itself and with the region, and this has remained undiminished all
these years. What is more, I believe that we blazed a trail for others to follow.
Our China policy showed that if you can look beyond your fears and
inadequacies, and can think and act from principled positions, rewards will
follow.”3
3
Speech given by Prime Minister Abdullah Badawi during the occasion of The China-Malaysia
Economic Conference, held in Malaysia on February 2004, for details see www.pmo.gov.my
(accessed on 8 March 2011)
4
Ibid.
4
“It is said that a good neighbour is always better than a friend far away. It is
invaluable to have a good neighbour that keeps his or her house in order and
devotes time and expense to taking care of others in the surrounding
neighbourhood. A prosperous China has a historic opportunity to use its size
and influence to push the envelope of peace and stability outwards, both for the
region and the world at large.”5
5
Ibid.
5
interests of both countries.6Mr Badawi during the occasion of the official opening of the
embassy of Malaysia Chancery Building, Beijing in May 2004, enthusiastically expressed:
6
See Appendix 3.
7
Speech given byAbdullah Ahmad Badawi, Prime Minister of Malaysia, at the official opening of
the Embassy of Malaysia Chancery Building in Beijing on May, 2004, for details see
www.pmo.gov.my (accessed on 4February 2011)
6
the field of transportation, energy and finance as well as recognizing the significance in the
application of science and technology in the development of both countries.8
Apart from these issues, the Communique also spoke on upholding the
respect for the independence, sovereignty and territorial integrity of each other and
acknowledge that peace, security and development have currently been the main themes and
concerns to the world. In the Communique, regional cooperation has also been discussed. In
this context, both the countries should acknowledge the tremendous progress in China-
ASEAN relations in post-Cold War years and both the leadership expressed their readiness
to continue to strengthen cooperation in the ASEAN+3 process and the development of the
ASEAN-China Free Trade Area. Apart from ASEAN, both the leadership spoke on
enhancing regional and international peace and development as well as agreed to strengthen
consultations and coordination at the UN, ARF, APEC, ASEM, WTO and other multilateral
forum. Through the Communique, both the leadership expressed their concern towards the
situation in Middle East and Iraq and they uphold their commitment to fight against
terrorism in all its forms and manifestations and stressed that the international community
should enhance cooperation and address both the symptoms and root causes of terrorism.9
8
See Appendix 3for details.
9
Ibid.
7
Later on, in October of the same year,State Councillor of China Tang
Jiaxuan visited Malaysia. During his visit to Malaysia, he met separately with Prime
MinisterDatuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi and Vice Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib
TunRazak. During his meeting with Tang Jiaxuan, Badawi indicated that Malaysia took
pleasure in the smooth development of Sino-Malaysian relationship. The two sides had
frequent exchanges of visit on all levels, fruitful achievement in all areas of cooperation, and
broad consensus on regional and international issues. In the field of strategic, trade and
economic cooperation Malaysia was dedicated to its strategic cooperation with China, in
particular. While reciprocating Badawi’s mind set regarding China, Tang Jiaxuan,
highlighted the smooth development of Sino-Malaysian relationship which has been
exclusively based on political mutual trust. He said that China attached importance to its
relations with Malaysia and remained willing to elevate the all-dimensional, and friendly
cooperative relationship between the two countries to a new high and that led to further
expanded and deepened strategic cooperation between China and Malaysia which conform
to the fundamental interest of both peoples; as well as also contribute positively to regional
stability and prosperity.10
He also felt that the two countries have trusted and supported each other
politically, pursued common economic development through mutually beneficial and
10
Speech given by Chinese State Councilor Tang Jiaxuan in Kuala Lumpur on 22 October 2004, for
details see http://www.Chinaembassy.ee/eng/dtxw/t168185.htm (accessed on 24 December 2010)
11
Speech given by Wu Banggao, Chairman of the Standing Committee of China’s National People’s
Congress, on May 2005 in Kuala Lumpur, for details see
http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/eng/wjb/zzjg/yzs/gjlb/2732/2734/t198068.htm (accessed on 20 January
2011)
8
reciprocal cooperation, and conducted dynamic exchanges and support in the various areas,
which augmented for the steady growth in bilateral relations. Moreover, during the same
visit he explicitly said:
“Upon the 30th anniversary of our diplomatic relations last year, Prime Minister
Abdullah Ahmad Badawi paid a successful visit to China, during which he
reached important consensus with the Chinese leaders on pushing forward
China-Malaysia strategic cooperation, charting the course for the deepening of
our relations…We have been heartened by the visible results and sound
momentum in our economic cooperation and trade which has lent an
inexhaustible impetus to the development of our relations.”12
In this context, it can be said that Prime Minister Badawi has been able to
sustain the ambience of cordiality in the bilateral political relationship between these two
countries. Chinese leadership also aptly reciprocated their warmth and friendly gestures
towards Malaysia. Such friendly gesture has been reaffirmed once again when Chinese
Premier Wen Jiabao visited Kuala Lumpur on December, 2005. During that visit, Chinese
12
Ibid.
13
Wu Banggao, Chairman of the Standing Committee of China's National People's Congress, made
the remarks when delivering a speech titled "Deepening Good-neighborly Friendship in A Joint
Effort for Asian Prosperity," in Kuala Lumpur, on May 2004, for details see
http://english.peopledaily.com.cn/200505/31/eng20050531_187604.html(accessed on 15 January
2011)
9
Premier had anin-depth discussion with the Malaysian Prime Minister Badawi, where
Premier Wen mentioned that ‘the Chinese and Malaysian governments are formulating the
next 5-year plans. It is our common need to strengthen the cooperation. The Chinese side
would like to work with the Malaysian side to strengthen the cooperation in the following
areas: first, maintaining high-level contacts and enhancing mutual understanding and trust;
secondly, the two foreign ministries should work together to formulate joint action plans for
China-Malaysia strategic cooperation and make concrete arrangements for the cooperation
in every area; thirdly, further expanding bilateral trade, promoting energy cooperation and
discussing the common exploration of the gas and oil resources in South China Sea; and
finally, strengthening the coordination and collaboration in the East Asian cooperation
process and pushing for constant growth of East Asian cooperation.’14In response to this
statement, Dato Seri Badawi viewed that Malaysia-China relations continue to expand more
rapidly than the past years and both sides expressed deep satisfaction on account of the
growing cordial understanding.It was also felt by the Malaysian leadership that both sides
could establish closer economic and trade linkages, as well as expand trade, increase two-
way investment, and strengthen the mutually beneficial cooperation in energy, finance and
other areas.15
10
“Some countries may have quietly harboured that view -- however tenuous the
grounds -- but none overtly described China as a potential threat…This has now
changed. For the first time, the United States and Japan have issued a joint
statement declaring Taiwan a matter of mutual security concern…”17
“Malaysia-China relations continue to expand and deepen and both sides have
benefited from this relationship. The development of China is rather an
opportunity than a threat to Malaysia. We regard China as a reliable friend.
Malaysia and China are developing rapidly.”20
11
relationship between them; however, he could not wither away the China threat concept
totally from the Malaysian mind set. It was Prime Minister Badawi while following the path
of his predecessor abled to dismiss the threat perspective in totality of China from the
Malaysian side.Badawi’s firm negation to the China threat theory has been influenced by
certain issues. China, during his tenure, gained huge prominence in the world political and
economic sphere and attempted to create a benign image in the Southeast Asian region.
Badawi’s primary concern in the foreign policy area remained economic development of the
country as well as maintaining peace and stability in the international and regional level.
Due to this reason, he was vocal against the China threat and thereby able to keep his
identity different from his predecessor.
12
in the context of strategic and geo-political perspective for the Asia-Pacific region.
Nevertheless, this issue has time and again played a major determining factor in the course
of development of ties between Malaysia and China. The fact remains that during
Mahathir’s tenure this issue often created tension between these two countries since both of
them along with some other ASEAN countries have been the major claimant parties in the
South China Sea dispute. Against this backdrop, this chapter will focus how Badawi
perceived as well as tackled this issue in the context of the then on going bilateral ties
between Kuala Lumpur and Beijing.
21
Prime Minister Badawi commented on October 2006, available at
http://asean-Chinasummit.fmprc.gov.cn/eng/zxxx/t277397.htm (accessed on 23February 2011)
13
ways for joint exploitation of South China Sea in the principle of mutual respect, equality
and mutual benefits and make South China Sea a bond for bilateral energy
cooperation.”22He further added that the two countries should turn the South China Sea into
a link of energy cooperation on the basis of mutual respect and mutual benefit.
Apart from South China Sea issue, both the countrieshave started working
on improvingbilateral defence ties during Prime Minister Badawi’s tenure. For instance, in
September 2005, both the Government signed a Memorandum of Understanding on Defence
Cooperation. The Memorandum is basically aimed to facilitate activities such as military
training, exchange of personnel and regular dialogue. As a consequence of the
Memorandum, a number of Malaysian military officers have attended military academies in
China, and vice versa. China has also offered to sell weapon systems, including naval ships
to Malaysia;howeverlatter has politely refused those offers rather preferred to continue its
major arms purchases from traditional suppliers such as United States, Britain and Russia
due to different reasons.
22
JiaQinglin, Chairman of the National Committee of the Chinese People's Political Consultative
Conference (CPPCC) made this comment on March 2006, for details see
http://www.gov.cn/misc/2006-03/30/content_240142.htm (accessed on 2April 2011)
14
Malaysia’ Relations with China: ASEAN as a Linking Bridge
15
they have to safeguard and promote just rights and interest of developing nations. The
summit in celebration of the 15th anniversary of China-ASEAN relations was held in
Nanning this October and China would like to work with all ASEAN countries including
Malaysia to take this summit as an opportunity and push for greater development of bilateral
relations.On issueslike human rights, democracy and China’s peaceful reunification,
Malaysia explicitlydemonstrated their support for China, and played an important role in
boostingChina-ASEAN cooperation.23 The two countries have been cooperating in
problemsinvolving regional and bilateral securities of anti-terrorism, preventing and
checkingacute diseases from spreading, anti-drug campaign, cracking down on cross-border
crimes.
It is explicit in the above discussion that the Joint Communique and the
celebration of 30-Year Diplomatic Relationship essentially provided a friendly environment
during Prime Minister Badawi’s tenure in the context of bilateral ties with China. The
initiatives came from both Malaysia and China in order to sustain the cordial
accommodation. It is true that Badawi’s predecessor Mahathir worked hard to create such
23
Official report of Third China-ASEAN Business and Investment Summit, available at
www.fmprc.gov.cn (accessed on 22 August 2010)
16
pragmatic accommodation and thereby the main credit certainly goes to him; however,
Badawi’s contribution in the maintenance of such amicable situation has also been
commendable. His pragmatic insight and approach in dealing with foreign relations helped
in the overall development of country’s economy.
“China’s economy is currently the sixth largest in the world and in the near
future, it is conceivable that it will become fifth, perhaps even the fourth. The
principal consequence of this incredible growth is that the world’s centre of
economic gravity will shift towards East Asia. Political and social linkages are
bound to eventually follow suit.”24
24
Speech given by Prime Minister Badawi at the China-Malaysia Economic Forum on February
2004, held in Kuala Lumpur, for details see www.pmo.gov.my (accessed on 14 October 2010)
17
Badawi has been very over-whelmed of the growing economic clout of
Chinain emerging global politics and he felt that would have a spill over effect on
Malaysia’s economic and trade relations with China. In the same speech he enunciated:
“Already, we have started to witness this shift and Malaysia has been a prime
beneficiary of these changes. From 1999 to 2002, our bilateral trade with China
grew by 960 per cent, from RM 4.6 billion to RM 44.1 billion. In 2003,
Malaysia was China’s seventh largest export market, while China was
Malaysia’s fourth. The situation certainly augurs well for both our countries.”25
It has already been discussed that one of thethrust areas of his foreign
policy formulation remained the concept of maintaining peace and stability as well as
maintaining good neighbourly policy and thereby achieving the economic growth. Such
outlook has been reflected in the same speech given at the occasion of China-Malaysia
Economic Forum, where he said:
With such realistic outlook, Prime Minister Badawi in May 2004 signed a
Joint Communique with Chinese Government which undoubtedly enhanced their mutual
cooperation in each other’s development. In the Communique, it is mentioned that in order
to enhance the relationship both the countries would exploit the comparative economic
25
Ibid.
26
Ibid.
18
advantages of their respective economies in order to strengthen and deepen economic
cooperation which resulted inan increaseof two-way trade to a significant level by 2010. The
two sides warmly welcomed the signing of the Memorandum of Understanding on
Strengthening the Cooperation of WTO/TBT and the Memorandum of Understanding on the
Strengthening the Cooperation of WTO/SPS. Both the countries also agreed to resolve any
arising trade disputes in the spirit of mutual understanding and cooperation in accordance
with the relevant principles of the World Trade Organization.27It was also decided by them
to strive for a balance of trade and would recogniseChina's full market economy status by
the Malaysian side.In this connection, Badawi mentioned:
"I believe there is a good potential for improvement in various fields. While
maintaining and strengthening the trade and investment cooperation, we shall
go into intensive cooperation in areas of science and technology such as bio-
technology, information and communication technology."28
27
See details of the Joint Communique 2004 in Appendix 3.
28
Excerpt from an interview of Malaysian Prime Minister Badawi on May 2004, available at
http://english.peopledaily.com.cn/200405/21/eng20040521_143986.html (accessed on 13 December
2010)
29
Ibid.
19
China's 7th largest export market while China was Malaysia's 4th export market. During the
same occasion Badawi happily mentioned that such bilateral relations have certainly
benefited Malaysia as well as China. The growing economic relations between Malaysia
under Prime Minister Badawi’s tenure can be reflected from the Table1 below.
Table 1
20
promising as well as consistent in nature. Regarding such flourishing bilateral relations
between Malaysia and China, then Prime Minister Badawi in 2006commented:
During the years between 1991 and 2004, two-way trade increasedyear by
year. Malaysia has become a major trading partner of China among ASEAN countries. In
this context, then Chinese legislator Wu Banggao, Chairman of the Standing Committee of
China's National People's Congress,while he was in Malaysia during his four-nation Asia-
Pacific tour, delivered a speech titled "Deepening Good-neighbourly Friendship in A Joint
Effort for Asian Prosperity",where he expressed optimism towards bilateral trade and said:
“As developing countries, China and Malaysia share broad agreement and have
maintained good cooperation and coordination on many major international and
regional issues, which has contributed to maintaining and promoting the
legitimate rights and interests of the developing countries.”32
30
Comment made by Malaysian Prime Minister Badawi, n.21.
31
Wu Banggao, n.13.
32
Ibid.
21
“The two countries have trusted and supported each other politically, pursued
common economic development through mutually beneficial and reciprocal
cooperation, and conducted dynamic exchanges and cooperation in various
areas, all contributing to the steady growth in bilateral relations.”33
Such view was corroborated by Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao in the same
year while he paid an official visit to Kuala Lumpur and said:
“New progress has been achieved with the economic and trade relations. The
trade volume between China and Malaysia accounted for newly one quarter of
the total trade volume between China and ASEAN.”34
Moreover, during the same visit, Wen Jiabao exhibited his more interest
towards developing an increasing economic and trade relations with Malaysia and said:
“The Chinese side would like to work with the Malaysian side to…further
expanding bilateral trade, promoting energy cooperation and discussing the
common exploration of the gas and oil resources in South China Sea.”35
“The Malaysian side hopes that both sides establish closer economic and trade
linkage, expand trade, increase two-way investment, and strengthen the
mutually beneficial cooperation in energy, finance and other areas.”36
“Malaysia and China can be considered as natural trading partners due to our
historical ties, geographical proximity, rich product diversity and robust
33
Ibid.
34
Wen Jiabao, n.14.
35
Ibid.
36
Abdullah A. Badawi, n.21.
22
economic growth…China is Malaysia’s fourth largest trading partner with a
total trade valued at almost 19 billion US dollars in 2004. Trade with China
made up about 8 per cent of Malaysia’s global trade in the same year. This
makes Malaysia China’s largest ASEAN trade partner. Meanwhile, Malaysian
exports to China have also increased by almost 25 per cent, reaching a new high
of 8.5 billion US dollars in 2004. Malaysia was also China’s 8th largest trading
partner last year. This position was mainly achieved through the sale of power
generation equipment, mineral fuels and animal fats.”37
“The trade ties between the two sides were more active than in the past, and the
trade volume was continuing to increase…China was Malaysia's friend and
Malaysia had maintained close consultation and cooperation with China in
many fields.”38
Thus, with such optimistic approaches of the leadership of both the two
countries, the trade and economic ties further enhanced and took the relationship to a
different extent.Later on in 2009, Abdullah A Badawi’s successor, Prime Minister Tun
Nazib expressed:
“Bilateral trade between Malaysia and China reached $39.06 billion in 2008 an
increase of 10.3 percent compared with 2007. Two-way trade was less than
$100 million in 1974 when Tun Razak made the historic visit. China is now
Malaysia's fourth largest trading partner and fourth largest export market. Most
of Malaysia's imports come from China. China is also a very important
destination for Malaysian investments.”39
37
Speech given by Malaysian Prime Minister Badawi at Malaysia-China Business Forum held in
Malaysia on August 2005, for details see www.pmo.gov.my (accessed on 5 December 2011)
38
Comment made by Malaysian Prime Minister Badawi, n.21.
39
Speech given by Malaysian Prime Minister Tun Nazib in June 2009 available at
http://www.Chinadaily.com.cn/China/2009malaysia/2009-06/02/content_7961842.htm
23
Therefore, economic relations between Malaysia and China during the
Badawi period increased very sharply than his predecessor.
Table 2
(in RM million)
24
Note: RM stands for Malaysian Ringgit
SOURCE:Prepared by author based on various Monthly Statistical Bulletin, Bank
Negara Malaysia. For details see http://www.bnm.gov.my/(accessed on 15 December
2011)
One of the major foreign policy goals of Malaysia, under the leadership
of Prime Minister Badawi, remained ‘Prosper-thy-Neighbour’, or in other words, his
25
inclination towards maintaining good-neighbourly policy in the Southeast Asian region.
Malaysia has always been a significant member of ASEAN and other such regional
initiatives; especially under the empirical leadership of previous Prime MinisterMahathir bin
Mohammad, Malaysia initiated building such cooperative arrangements. Badawi also
engaged himself in increasing existed economic and trade cooperation in the region. The
rationale behind such exercises remains through such organisation, Malaysia and other
Southeast Asian countries could develop their own respective economies with the increasing
trade with China. Apart from Malaysian perspective on the enhanced regional cooperation,
the then Chinese leadership also emphasised their interests towards developing a cordial tie
with ASEAN countries including Malaysia. In this context, Prime Minister Badawi on the
occasion of ASEAN-China Commemorative Summit, held in China on October 2006, firmly
viewed:
“Over the years, the level of trust and confidence between ASEAN and China
grew from strength to strength. This has contributed substantially to the
sustaining of regional peace, stability, progress and prosperity….Malaysia has
always viewed China as a very important strategic partner for ASEAN. China is
both an important source and destination of trade and investment. China is also
an important global player which can exert much influence not only on regional
but also international peace and security.”40
“We thank China for hosting this special commemorative summit, to mark
fifteen years of friendship and cooperation which was formally launched in
1991 and developed into a full dialogue partnership in 1996. We have faced
many challenges together including the Asian financial crisis in 1997, during
which we convened the First ASEAN-China Summit.”41
40
Speech given by Prime Minister Badawi at the occasion of ASEAN-China Commemorative
Summit held in China on October, 2006, for details see www.pmo.gov.my (accessed on 24 June
2011)
41
Ibid.
26
Prime Minister Badawi sincerely felt that the economic advancement of
the entire ASEAN region including Malaysia has been integrally related to Chinese
cooperative attitude towards this region. In this context, in the same speech, he further
added:
42
Ibid.
43
Speech given by Prime Minister Abdullah Badawi at the Third China-ASEAN Business and
Investment Summit held in China on October 2006, for details see www.pmo.gov.my (accessed on
20 February 2011)
27
On 22 October 2004, Malaysian Prime Minister Badawi met with Chinese
State Councillor Tang Jiaxuan in Kuala Lumpur, who was on an official friendly visit to
Malaysia. During his visit, Tang Jiaxuanpointed out that China would support to the East
Asian regional cooperative arrangements and he said:
44
Tang Jiaxuan, n.10.
45
Excerpt from an interview of Prime Minister Badawi, n. 21.
28
Summarily then, it can be said that Malaysia’s relations with China,
during Abdullah Badawi’s period, was very much friendly in nature. In political and
strategic sphere, they have signed various agreements for better coordination. Both the
countries’ gave importance to the regional cooperation in order to promote a better
environment in the region as a whole and that would entail a better ambience for individual
development. Apart from that, Malaysia’s economic and a trade relation with China, during
Prime Minister Badawi’s period, has portrayed a strong as well as steady relationship. The
total volume of trade has been proliferated during his period. In this context, it can be said
that Badawi’s predecessor Dr. Mahathir was the main architect for developing a pragmatic
cordiality with China especially in the economic and trade sector. However, Prime Minister
Badawi followed the path of his predecessor and has been able to overcome all sorts of
obstacles in the evolving bilateral ties and that cordial ties even continued by Tun Nazib
who took over power as a new Prime Minister of Malaysia in 2009.
29