Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ancial Problems among College Students: The Role of Financial Literacy in Malaysia
he relationship of savings behavior and financial problems to financial literacy among college students in
for correlates of financial literacy, multivariate analysis of a sample obtained at 11 colleges and
ated that students who had higher financial knowledge test scores were more likely to report savings
orted fewer financial problems. The influence of childhood consumer experience and financial
n savings and financial problems was more mixed, indicating that financial experience before college
s or poor attitudes toward financial management that could be mitigated through financial education
ations of these findings for targeting financial education on particular kinds of students are discussed.
research
bers
cations
rojects
Ad
Ad
ohamad Fazli Sabri Author content Download full-text PDF
Abstract: This study analyzes the relationship of savings behavior and finan
problems to financial literacy among college students in Malaysia. Controlling
correlates of financial literacy, multivariate analysis of a sample obtained at 11 colle
and universities demonstrated that students who had higher financial knowledge
scores were more likely to report savings behavior and also reported fewer finan
problems. The influence of childhood consumer experience and financial socializa
agents on savings and financial problems was more mixed, indicating that finan
experience before college may create bad habits or poor attitudes toward finan
management that could be mitigated through financial education during colle
Implications of these findings for targeting financial education on particular kind
students are discussed.
Key words: Savings behavour; financial problems; financial literacy; college studen
Senior Lecturer, Department of Resource Management & Consumer Studies, Faculty of Human Ecology, U
utra Malaysia, 43400 UPM Serdang, Selangor, Malaysia. Email: fazli@putra.upm.edu.my.
Professor/Director School of Family Studies and Human Services, 302 Justin Hall, College of Human Eco
ansas State University, Manhattan, KS 66506-1403, USA. Email: morey@ksu.edu
Received 17 May 2010; accepted 22 August 2010
103
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/50946039_Savings_Behavior_and_Financial_Problems_among_College_Students_The_Role_of_Fina… 2/16
3/12/2019 (PDF) Savings Behavior and Financial Problems among College Students: The Role of Financial Literacy in Malaysia
INTRODUCTION
or a majority of college students, university attendance is the first time they have experienced
ndependence without a parent's supervision. With the expansion of educational services in M
hich tripled the number of college students in two recent decades (Economic Planning Un
niversity or college students have become an important consumer market segment. However
een limited research on financial behavior (e.g. savings and indebtedness) and problem
Malaysians, especially college students, since the concern over the role of young consumers is r
ew. Studies in the United States and other countries indicated that college students had plenty to s
hey also had low levels of financial literacy and tended to be impulse consumers (e.g., Danes, Hu
& Boyce, 1999). A similar situation exists in Malaysia. Sabri, MacDonald, Hira, and Masu
stablished that Malaysian college students also had low levels of financial literacy, and that thei
as related to their ethnicity, childhood consumer experience, and whether they attended privat
ublic institutions. This study analyzes the relationship of financial practices (specifically savings
nd financial problems to financial literacy among college students in Malaysia. Understanding
nd how financial literacy may influence savings and specific kinds of financial problems will be
fforts to design more effective financial education programs to prepare young Malaysians to be
ersonal financial managers when they enter the job market and start their own families. Although
ome studies of the influence of financial education on savings behavior (Bernheim, Garrett, & M
eng, Bartholomae, Fox, & Cravener, 2007) that research has not examined the role of financial kn
hile in college, and most studies of financial problems of college students (e.g. Lyons, 2004) or
nancial practices (Lawrence, Cude, Lysons, Marks & Machtmes, 2006) have not linked those pro
ractices to financial knowledge. Hence this study may be the first to connect college students’
teracy directly to their savings behavior and financial problems. Demonstrating such a
haracterizing its importance relative to other influences during college could provide evid
xpanding campus financial education efforts. The specific objectives of this study are to ide
ompare savings behavior and the financial problems experienced by students and to explore the
f financial literacy on savings behavior and financial problems. The first general hypothesis fo
onsiders potential correlates of financial literacy and posits that those may also be related to
ehavior and financial problems. The second hypothesis considers whether, controlling for those c
f financial literacy, financial literacy has its own independent influence on savings behavior and
roblems. That is:
Hypothesis 1: The following variables will predict effective savings behavior and fewer
roblems: gender, ethnicity, place of origin, parent’s marital status and educational level, family
hildhood consumer experience, sibling rank, type of college, residence, funding from governme
nancial socialization, GPA, spending patterns, and financial literacy.
Hypothesis 2: Financial literacy will be related positively to effective savings behavior. Th
eport greater financial problems will report low levels of financial literacy.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/50946039_Savings_Behavior_and_Financial_Problems_among_College_Students_The_Role_of_Fina… 3/16
3/12/2019 (PDF) Savings Behavior and Financial Problems among College Students: The Role of Financial Literacy in Malaysia
ForSeebrevity
all › the See
primary
all › focus will be on financial literacy, financial socialization, and c
onsumer experience,
34 Citations which were all expected to be indicators of
10 References financial
Download knowledge
citation Shareadvantage Download full-text PDF
104
METHODOLOGY
reliminary analysis to test for differences in savings behavior and financial problems included t
ariables measured in continuous units, and analysis of variance (Anova) for demographic chara
nd other categorical variables. Multiple regressions were obtained to determine which predic
gnificant effects on savings behavior and problems. To test our second hypothesis, financial lite
ncluded as the predictor of savings behavior and financial problems to explore the influence of
nowledge.
Sample. The study sample is comprised of students in public and private universities, and 11 un
ere randomly selected for the study (six public and five private universities). For each unive
udents were selected randomly using the list of names obtained from each student affairs of
umber of distributed questionnaires to 11 universities was 3,850. A total of 2,519 completed an
uestionnaires were returned by the students producing a 65% response rate. Of the 2,519 stud
esponded to survey, 40.4% were male and 59.6% were female students. The ethnic composi
Malay (67.2%), Chinese (21.6%), Indian (5.0%) and others (6.1%). The mean age of the respond
0.9 years (SD=2.99). Regarding parental marital status, 55% of students reported that their pare
married and living together, 21% reported were divorced and 12% reported their parents were w
idower. More than half of the students in our sample were not employed (59%). A majori
udents lived on campus. The average CGPA (cumulative grade point average) was 3.00 and m
udents were at second class level (72.4%). Most of the students identified themselves as singl
% were married.
Dependent Variables. Two dependent variables were used in separate regression models to an
esearch questions related to savings behavior and financial problems. Three savings behav
saving to achieve a goal”, “saving until the end of the semester”, and “saving for paying down
rovided “Yes=1” and “No=0” coding to create a scale from zero to three as the dependent var
ffective saving behavior. The average score was 1.13, with standard deviation of 0.89. Alpha r
or savings was 0.695. The ten financial problem questions were asked on a 5-point Likert scale fr
) to everyday (5) and focused on problems as follows: uncertain about where money is sp
iend(s) money; spend more than can afford; borrow money to buy food; skip meals to save mo
money without permission from parents/others; upset when cannot buy things; shopping t
nsion/stress; impulsive shopping, and lending money to friends. The range in total scores for
roblems was from a low of zero to a high of 48. The mean score on specific problem items vari
igh of 2.58 for “uncertain about where money is spent” to 1.15 for “take money without permiss
arents or others”. The average score was 19.75, with a standard deviation of 5.78. Alpha relia
nancial problems was 0.764.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/50946039_Savings_Behavior_and_Financial_Problems_among_College_Students_The_Role_of_Fina… 4/16
3/12/2019 (PDF) Savings Behavior and Financial Problems among College Students: The Role of Financial Literacy in Malaysia
Independent
See all › Variables.
See all › Predictors of particular interest included childhood consumer ex
Download citation Share Download full-text PDF
nancial socialization,
34 Citations and financial literacy. Childhood consumer
10 References experience was measured b
espondents when (at what age) they became involved in financial activities: received an allowa
avings account; received money from work; discussed financial matters with parents; made de
ersonal expenses; knowing family financial status; and made their own purchases. The “whether,
what age” categories were coded as “Less than 7 years=5”, “8-12 years=4”, “13-15 years=3
ears=2”, and “18 years and above=1”, and “Never=0”. Thus, higher scores indicate earlier c
onsumer experience and those who never had the experience were scored as zero. The mean
onsumer experience was 20.76. Financial socialization was measured by asking respondents h
ocialization agents influenced their financial behaviors based on scale from zero (no influence)
high influence). Socialization agents include parents, peers, siblings, school, religion, and elec
rinted media, and the mean score was 48.13. Financial literacy was measured by testing fo
nswers on 25 questions concerning for example financial goals, financial records, savings, inv
etirement, banking system, time value of money, wills, insurance, education loan, and general kn
n personal finance (see Appendix). The mean test score was 11.77.
105
N f l d ti ( f ) 5
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/50946039_Savings_Behavior_and_Financial_Problems_among_College_Students_The_Role_of_Fina… 5/16
3/12/2019 (PDF) Savings Behavior and Financial Problems among College Students: The Role of Financial Literacy in Malaysia
106
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/50946039_Savings_Behavior_and_Financial_Problems_among_College_Students_The_Role_of_Fina… 6/16
3/12/2019 (PDF) Savings Behavior and Financial Problems among College Students: The Role of Financial Literacy in Malaysia
Younger
See all › child
See all › .026 (.902) .065 (2.296)*
Middle child
34 Citations 10 References .004 (.150) Download citation .053 (1.853)
Share Download full-text PDF
Public university .020 (.716) -.098 (-3.474)***
Spending patterns (3-5 item) -.072 (-2.782)** -.069 (-2.681)**
Spending patterns (< 2 item) -.208 (-7.930)*** -.016 (-.605)
R2 .102 .113
Adjusted R2 .085 .095
F value 5.774*** 6.382***
RESULTS
reliminary descriptive analysis revealed that more than half of the respondents did not save an
hen they received their scholarship or education loan. More than half of the students used their m
hopping. About 45% of them spent all their money before the end of the semester; 17% of stude
ome money to their family, and 13% used their money to repay debts. Results from Anovas for di
n savings behavior with respect to financial literacy, financial socialization, and childhood c
xperience demonstrated that there were significant differences. Those students with higher
nowledge were more likely to engage in savings behavior, while those students with greater
om socialization agents and late exposure in their childhood consumer experience were less
ngage in savings behavior. Statistically significant bivariate results also revealed that students
te exposure in their childhood consumer experience, or who reported greater influence from soc
gents were significantly less likely to report financial problems. However the regression analys
ontrolled for student demographics and other characteristics, provided some different findings
elationships of financial knowledge indicators to students’ financial practices. After sample re
ue to missing data, there were 1574 cases for regression analysis of saving behavior, and 1560
egression analysis of financial problems.
107
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/50946039_Savings_Behavior_and_Financial_Problems_among_College_Students_The_Role_of_Fina… 7/16
3/12/2019 (PDF) Savings Behavior and Financial Problems among College Students: The Role of Financial Literacy in Malaysia
n savings
See all behavior
› thanallmale
See › students. Ethnicity were found to be a strong predictor of savings
ith 34
a negative
Citations coefficient indicating that Chinese students wereDownload
10 References substantially
citationless likely
Share to have Download full-text PDF
nancial behavior than the reference category (ethnicity other than Malay, Chinese, or Indian). T
f U.S. college students’ financial practices by Lawrence, Cude, Lyons, Marks, and Machtmes (2
ound that ethnicity was a significant predictor of college students’ financially fitness scores
gnificant variables explained 8.0% of the variance. This is somewhat similar to the present stud
108
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/50946039_Savings_Behavior_and_Financial_Problems_among_College_Students_The_Role_of_Fina… 8/16
3/12/2019 (PDF) Savings Behavior and Financial Problems among College Students: The Role of Financial Literacy in Malaysia
REFERENCES
bu Bakar, E., Masud, J., & Md. Jusoh, Z. (2006). Knowledge, attitude and perceptions of univer
students towards educational loans in Malaysia. Journal of Family and Economics Issues, 27,
ernheim, B.D., Garrett, D., & Maki, D. (2001). Education and saving: The long term effects of hig
financial curriculum mandates. Journal of Public Economics, 80, 435-465.
anes, S. M., Huddleston-Casas, C. & Boyce, L. (1999). Financial planning curriculum for teens
evaluation. Financial Counseling and Planning, 10(1), 25-37.
conomic Planning Unit (2006). Malaysian Ninth Plan (2006-2010). Prime Minister Department, P
Retrieved March 3, 2010 from
http://www.epu.gov.my/html/themes/epu/html/rm9/english/Chapter16.pdf
mail, N.A., & Awang, H. (2008). Differentials in mathematics achievement among eight-grade st
Malaysia. International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education, 6, 559-571.
oseph, C. (2008). Ethnicities and education in Malaysia: Difference, inclusions and exclusions. In
(ed.), The Education of Diverse Student Populations: A Global Perspective. Springer: New Y
(p.183-208).
awrence, F.C., Cude, B.J., Lyons, A.C., Marks, L., & Machtmes, K. (2006). College students’ fi
practices: A mixed method analysis. The Journal of Consumer Education, 23, 13-26.
yons, A. (2004). A profile of financially at-risk college students. Journal of Consumer Affairs, 3
56-80.
eng, T.M., Bartholomae,S., Fox, J.J., & Cravener, G. (2007). The impact of personal finance edu
delivered in high school and college courses. Journal of Family & Economic Issues, 28, 265
abri, M.F., MacDonald, M., Hira, T.K., & Masud, J. (2010). Childhood consumer experience an
financial literacy of college students in Malaysia. Family and Consumer Sciences Research J
38 (4), 455-467.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/50946039_Savings_Behavior_and_Financial_Problems_among_College_Students_The_Role_of_Fina… 9/16
3/12/2019 (PDF) Savings Behavior and Financial Problems among College Students: The Role of Financial Literacy in Malaysia
See all › See all › 109 Download citation Share Download full-text PDF
34 Citations 10 References
APPENDIX
tatement
True
Buying goods on credit will reduce purchasing power in future
The increase of the price of goods will reduce buying power
Balance sheet shows your financial status
Credit card holder can spend without limit
We overspend when using savings to buy daily necessities
The value of money can double after 10 years
Savings is extra income after deducted expenses
Interest will influence the future value of savings
Income statement shows income and the expenses of a family in a specific period
0. Will is unnecessary for a family
1. Buying insurance is the best investment
2. Savings account interest exceeds fixed deposit interest
3. Life insurance protects policy holder from financial burden
4. The longer the education loan is due the greater cost of financing it
5. Unregistered business needs to pay income tax
6. Owning a credit card will increase one’s purchasing power
7. One can spend more than 20% of their monthly income for installments
8. Using credit card to get cash has the lowest finance charge
9. All types of investments are profitable
0. We can borrow to invest
1. Motorcyclist do not need insurance
2. Employment Provident Fund (EPF)* contribution are sufficient for retirement
3. All Muslims must pay zakat**
4. In Malaysia we only have a conventional banking system
5. Family needs to save three months income for emergencies
otes: * The Malaysian Employees Provident Fund (EPF) Act of 1991 grants employees retirem
enefits that are managed via a body that is intended to manage their savings;
*Paying a small percentage of one's surplus wealth to charity for poor and needy Muslims.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/50946039_Savings_Behavior_and_Financial_Problems_among_College_Students_The_Role_of_Fin… 10/16
3/12/2019 (PDF) Savings Behavior and Financial Problems among College Students: The Role of Financial Literacy in Malaysia
110
References (10)
Malaysia on how to become a high income economy in year Evidence confirms that financial knowledge
early have the most positive influence on financial management (Sabri & MacDonald, 2010 ). Based on
MacDonald (2010) recommend that all Malaysian universities and colleges should experiment with
to educate students about personal financial management and planning (Sabri & MacDonald, 2010). ...
Malaysia on how to become a high income economy in year Evidence confirms that financial knowledge
early have the most positive influence on financial management (Sabri & MacDonald, 2010). Based on
MacDonald (2010) recommend that all Malaysian universities and colleges should experiment with
to educate students about personal financial management and planning (Sabri & MacDonald, 2010). ...
Malaysia on how to become a high income economy in year Evidence confirms that financial knowledge
early have the most positive influence on financial management (Sabri & MacDonald, 2010). Based on
MacDonald (2010) recommend that all Malaysian universities and colleges should experiment with
to educate students about personal financial management and planning (Sabri & MacDonald, 2010) . ...
anization on savings behavior and practices among Saudi Arabian families immigrants in the United
ilable
ngan terdiri dari tiga dimensi yang saling berhubungan, yaitu pengetahuan (Lusardi & Scheresberg, 2013);
nald, 2010) ; (Remund, 2010); dan kesadaran (Rahmandoust, Norouzi, Hakimpoor, & Khani, 2011).
ntang bagaimana kinerja bisnis dan kondisi bisnis diukur dengan menggunakan model untuk
ung, atau memperkaya dalam pengambilan keputusan (Lusardi & Mitchell, 2007). ...
(Okello et al., 2017), (3). Sikap (attitude) (Remund, 2010; Sabri & MacDonald, 2010) . ...
uw
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/50946039_Savings_Behavior_and_Financial_Problems_among_College_Students_The_Role_of_Fin… 11/16
3/12/2019 (PDF) Savings Behavior and Financial Problems among College Students: The Role of Financial Literacy in Malaysia
out a study on working adults and illustrated that their financial knowledge is a significant determinant of
asured as budgeting, investments and preparing for financial emergencies. With regard to financial literacy
on, Sabri and MacDonald (2010) examined financial literacy of college students in Malaysia. The basic
hese studies is that investigations into the financial literacy of Gen Y investors is largely missing, and their
cisions has hardly been focused on. ...
known and reported that socio- demographic factors affect the saving behaviour (Modigliani,
e, 1998). Among others, the effect of age, gender and educational level are considered as possible factors
996 , Sabri & Macdonald, 2010 . Gender is of a special case in this study since in Pomak minority, the
hrace depend on the family income without being paid for their labour. ...
kolaos Satsios
vel of financial fi- teracy can influence student's saving behavior positively and significantly, so as to
sumption (Sabri &Macdonald, 2010) . It is supported by following research (Imawati, Susilaningsih, &
cial literacy is quite influential on teen consumption behavior with negative signifi- cance, when financial
onsumer behavior will decrease. ...
en Instagram Social Media Usage, Hedonic Shopping Motives and Financial Literacy on Impulse
le
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/50946039_Savings_Behavior_and_Financial_Problems_among_College_Students_The_Role_of_Fin… 12/16
3/12/2019 (PDF) Savings Behavior and Financial Problems among College Students: The Role of Financial Literacy in Malaysia
Show more
Recommendations
Discover more publications, questions and projects in Literacy
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/50946039_Savings_Behavior_and_Financial_Problems_among_College_Students_The_Role_of_Fin… 13/16
3/12/2019 (PDF) Savings Behavior and Financial Problems among College Students: The Role of Financial Literacy in Malaysia
View project
Project
The influence of financial literacy, money attitude, financial strain and financial capability on young employees' financial well-being
Mohamad Fazli Sabri
View project
Project
FINANCIAL CAPABILITY AND UTILIZATION OF FINANC
Mohamad Fazli Sabri
View project
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/50946039_Savings_Behavior_and_Financial_Problems_among_College_Students_The_Role_of_Fin… 14/16
3/12/2019 (PDF) Savings Behavior and Financial Problems among College Students: The Role of Financial Literacy in Malaysia
Childhood Consumer Experience and the Financial Literacy of College Students in Malaysia
June 2010
The purpose of this study was to investigate the impact of personal and family background, academic ability, and childhood
consumer experiences on the financial literacy of college students in Malaysia. The sample comprised 2,519 students in 11 public
and private colleges in Malaysia. Financial literacy was measured with a 25-item test of financial knowledge. On average,
students answered less ... [Show full abstract]
Read more
Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to examine the relationships between personal and family backgrounds, academic ability,
childhood consumer experience, financial socialization, financial literacy, and perceived financial well-being of college students.
Design/methodology/approach – Data were collected using a multi-stage sampling technique from 11 public and private
universities across ... [Show full abstract]
View full-text
Pathways to financial success: Determinants of financial literacy and financial well-being among you...
January 2011
The issue of financial literacy and financial well-being among college students has received increasing research attention. This
investigation was designed to examine several unanswered questions about college students' financial knowledge, how it is
derived, and the overall financial literacy and well-being of young adults. The dissertation follows a journal paper format and
consists of two ... [Show full abstract]
View full-text
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/50946039_Savings_Behavior_and_Financial_Problems_among_College_Students_The_Role_of_Fin… 15/16
3/12/2019 (PDF) Savings Behavior and Financial Problems among College Students: The Role of Financial Literacy in Malaysia
Assessment a model of financial satisfaction predictors: Examining the mediate effect of financial b...
January 2012 · World Applied Sciences Journal
Satisfaction with one's financial status can enhance personal satisfaction and more broadly, life satisfaction and in contrast
financial difficulties and dissatisfaction with one's financial status can lead to stress and depression. Research related to financial
satisfaction revealed financial behaviour has a major contribution to satisfaction or dissatisfaction with financial situation. More ...
[Show full abstract]
View full-text
An Exploratory Study of Personal Financial Wellbeing Determinants: Examining the Moderating Effect o...
January 2015 · Asian Social Science
Leila Falahati · Mohamad Fazli Sabri
Financial educators have placed importance on the study of the determinants of financial wellbeing for some decades now. The
subject of the research has comprised factors such as marital status, employment status, education, income and health, which
impact on financial wellbeing. However, there is as yet, a lack of research on the perceived influence of differences in financial
wellbeing between ... [Show full abstract]
View full-text
Discover more
Ad
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/50946039_Savings_Behavior_and_Financial_Problems_among_College_Students_The_Role_of_Fin… 16/16