Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Suryanto, Virginia Plummer & Malcolm Boyle (2017): Healthcare System in
Indonesia, Hospital Topics, DOI: 10.1080/00185868.2017.1333806
Download by: [The UC San Diego Library] Date: 27 June 2017, At: 22:16
HOSPITAL TOPICS
, VOL. , NO. , –
https://doi.org/./..
ABSTRACT KEYWORDS
The cultural diversity, its archipelago, and the major religion being Muslim have all influenced the Developing country;
development of the healthcare in Indonesia. The authors’ objective is to describe the evolution of the emergency care; health
healthcare system in Indonesia. Community-based health service, called puskesmas, is the key of the system; healthcare;
Indonesia
healthcare service in the country. The World Health Organization estimated that 64% of all deaths in
Indonesia are caused by noncommunicable diseases, which might relate to the mostly unorganized
prehospital care system. The healthcare system in Indonesia continues to improve its care delivery
and outcomes by an escalation in the number of health services.
Introduction
and Hartati 2003). Data from the Indonesian Min-
There have been several key changes to the Indone- istry of Health shows that there were 244,775,797
sian healthcare system since its independence in 1945 people living in Indonesia in 2012 with 50.3% men
(Heywood and Choi 2010). As one of the less devel- and 49.6% women (Kementerian Kesehatan Republik
oped countries in the world, the evolution of the health- Indonesia 2013b). Data from the Ministry of Health
care system in Indonesia might be similar to that of also show that in 2012 the majority (66.1%) of peo-
other developing countries (Shields and Hartati 2003). ple in Indonesia were between 15 and 64 years of age
However, Indonesia has some unique characteristics. while 28.9% were under 15 years of age and 5.1% were
It is the fourth largest country after China, India and greater than 65 years of age. There are 12 major eth-
United States of America and the fourth most highly nic groups; 41.7% of the population identify themselves
populated (United Nations 2014b). It is noted for its as Javanese, the largest single ethnic group; and there
cultural diversity and its archipelago of 13,000 islands are four major religious groups, with 86% identifying
(Shields and Hartati 2003), as well as the political themselves as Muslim, the largest single religious group
framework and government regime (Kristiansen and (United Nations 2014a).
Santoso 2006). The development of a healthcare system Emergency care, both prehospital and in-hospital,
in Indonesia might also be unique. is one of the major issues in Indonesia. In-hospital
Indonesia comprises five mains islands (Java, Sumat- emergency care, which mostly occurs in the emergency
era, Kalimantan, Sulawesi, and Papua) with a land department (ED) of the hospital, is important because
area of 1,922,570 km2 and a broad waters area the ED is the microcosm for other events of patient care
of 3,257,483 km2 (Kementerian Kesehatan Republik in the hospital (Brown et al. 2013).
Indonesia 2013b; Meliala, Hort, and Trisnantoro 2013). The purpose of this article is to describe the evo-
This large area is populated with more than 253 million lution of the healthcare system in Indonesia focus-
people, with Java Island the most densely populated ing on the healthcare facilities in Indonesia. The
island. Java Island consists of West Java, Central Java, development of two types of healthcare facilities,
and East Java with the main cities being Jakarta and puskesmas and hospitals, will be described. Specific
Jogjakarta (Kementerian Kesehatan Republik Indone- issues about emergency care in Indonesia will also be
sia 2013b; Meliala, Hort, and Trisnantoro 2013; Shields discussed.
CONTACT Suryanto suryanto.s@monash.edu; suryanto.s@ub.ac.id School of Nursing and Midwifery, Monash University, P.O. Box , Frankston ,
Victoria, Australia; School of Nursing, Brawijaya University, Jalan Veteran, Malang, Jawa Timur, Indonesia.
© Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
2 SURYANTO ET AL.
Government and Healthcare Management of age and neonatal mortality rates (World Health
Organization 2016).
For the operational function of the government,
However, the World Bank’s report also highlighted
Indonesia has a five-tier government hierarchy. These
that the Indonesian healthcare system remains ineffi-
tiers are national government, province, district (kabu-
cient, unequal, and with low supervision rates where
paten/regency and kota/city), subdistrict (kecamatan),
most people continue self-treatment, thereby creating
and village (kelurahan/urban village and desa/rural
a decline of health services utilization. This underuti-
village; Kristiansen and Santoso 2006). Indonesia is
lization was especially evident after the 1990s financial
currently divided into 33 provinces, 497 districts (399
crisis where medical doctors tended to provide services
regencies and 98 cities), 6,994 subdistricts, 77,465
in private clinics where their distribution is unequal
villages (8,216 urban villages and 69,249 rural villages;
among the population (Rokx et al. 2009).
Kementerian Kesehatan Republik Indonesia 2013b). In
Implementation of a universal health insurance
1999, Indonesia initiated a decentralized government,
for Indonesian people, called Badan Penyelenggara
including healthcare management, with authority and
Jaminan Sosial, was also part of the healthcare ser-
regulation at the provincial or district level. Never-
vices development in Indonesia. The universal health
theless, central oversight by the Ministry of Health
insurance was launched on January 2014 and will
still delivers national guidelines and regulations to
cover all Indonesians by the end of 2019 (Indone-
provide directions or instructions for health offices at
sia strides toward universal health care 2014). The
the provincial and district level (Meliala, Hort, and
development of healthcare services in Indonesia is
Trisnantoro 2013).
related to the increase of the total health expenditure.
Data from the Ministry of Health of Indonesia show
It had been increased from 2.0% of the gross domestic
that the number of poor people had decreased from
product (GDP) in 2000 to 3.0% in 2012 (World Health
17.8% (39.3 million) in 2006 to 11.7% (28.5 million)
Organization, 2015). However, compared with other
in 2012 (Kementerian Kesehatan Republik Indonesia
countries, this expenditure was below the average of
2013b). Efforts have been made to improve healthcare
health expenditure among other SEA countries and
outcomes among the poor by achieving targets toward
lower middle-income countries of 3.7% and 4.1%
the United Nations Millennium Development Goals,
of GDP, respectively (World Health Organization,
with major improvements in healthcare management
2015). In Indonesia, 60.4% of health expenditure in
being realized by the Indonesian government during
2012 was supported by the private sector and 39.6%
the last four decades (Rokx et al. 2009). The major
was supported by the government (World Health
developments include decentralization in healthcare
Organization, 2015).
management, reformation of compensation for health-
Telecommunication in health is one of the develop-
care providers servicing remote areas, and increasing
ing areas of healthcare service provisions in Indone-
the distribution of midwives in rural and remote areas
sia. The Indonesian government launched a USD$27
(Rokx et al. 2010). These actions have had a positive
billion program for enhancing information and com-
impact on healthcare outcomes based on the World
munications technology including telemedicine, which
Bank’s report with infant mortality rates almost halved
could help in delivering health services to the more
from 67.8 per 1,000 live births in 1992 to 34.0 per 1,000
remote areas (Tabor and Yoon 2015). The program
live births in 2007 (Rokx et al. 2010). The mortality
is called the Indonesia Broadband Plan and will have
rate among children under 5 years of age has also
been implemented from 2015 to 2019 to provide a
undergone a similar downward trend from 97.4 to 45.0
broadband access to 80% of all rural institutions includ-
per 1,000 (Rokx et al. 2009). The latest report from the
ing government offices, schools and hospitals with the
World Health Organization (2016) shows that the mor-
use of e-governance, e-education, and e-health (Tabor
tality rate of children under 5 years of age and neonates
and Yoon 2015).
in Indonesia was 27.2 per 1,000 live births. Compared
with other Southeast Asian (SEA) countries, this num-
ber is below the average (30.8 per 1,000 live births),
Healthcare Facilities
with the Maldives having the lowest number (8.6) and
India (47.7), Myanmar (50.0), and Timor-Leste (52.6) From 1945 to 1950, the healthcare system was focused
the countries with the highest children under 5 years on a curative program mainly concentrating on the
HOSPITAL TOPICS 3
Puskesmas
(n = 9,655)
treatment of adults and mothers and infants (Heywood experienced economic hardship and it was estimated
and Choi 2010). This system was in line with the situ- that 80 million Indonesians were below the World
ation in 1950 where the population was approximately Bank defined poverty line (Shields and Hartati 2003).
72 million and 1,200 medical doctors. The infant After the fall of Suharto’s regime in 1998 due to reform
mortality rate at the time was 200 per 1,000 and the triggered by massive corruption and lack of trans-
life expectancy was 48 years of age (Kristiansen and parency (Kristiansen and Santoso 2006), there was the
Santoso 2006). Traditional healers (dukun) and tra- first democratic election. Decentralization of the gov-
ditional medicine were commonly used within the ernment was established in 2001 where authority was
community (Kristiansen and Santoso 2006). In the given to provincial and district governments to deliver
early 1950s, based on the Bandung Plan, the govern- services to the community, including health (Abdullah
ment initiated the integrative program of preventive et al. 2012; Heywood and Choi 2010). This decentral-
and curative healthcare along with the establishment ization reduced administrative bureaucracy and led to
of Pusat Kesehatan Masyarakat (puskesmas) or com- more efficient public services (Kristiansen and Santoso
munity health centres at the subdistrict level with 2006). Even though funding from the central gov-
each centre staffed with medical doctors, nurses, and ernment decreased, local government expenses were
midwives (Heywood and Choi 2010). However, due to increased using local tax revenues of business activities
slow economic development and political instability, and local resources (Kristiansen and Santoso 2006).
the concept of a puskesmas in every subdistrict was not Each puskesmas is in conjunction with not only a
achieved until 1968. The aim was for one puskesmas for Pustu, but also a Pondok Bersalin Desa (Polindes) or vil-
30,000 people and one puskesmas pembantu (Pustu) or lage delivery center, Pos Pelayanan Terpadu (Posyandu)
subcommunity health center in each village covering or integrated health post, and Pos Kesehatan Desa
around 3,000 people, with the full coverage of the sys- (Poskesdes) or village health post (see Figure 1; Abdul-
tem not achieved until 1988 (Kristiansen and Santoso lah et al. 2012). Each puskesmas coordinates the
2006). main service for the preventive and curative programs
The centralized government under the regime of including antenatal and postnatal care, immunization,
President Suharto increased the number and quality family planning services, nutrition and sanitation con-
of health facilities in Indonesia, especially during the sultations, and dental service. Some puskesmas have
1970s to 1980s when there was an establishment of dis- inpatient facilities (puskesmas with beds), whereas a
trict hospitals and subdistrict community health cen- pustu increases the quality and outreach of a puskesmas’
ters throughout the country. There was a correspond- function at the village level (Abdullah et al. 2012;
ing decrease in infant mortality and an increased life Kristiansen and Santoso 2006). Polindes is a village
expectancy (Kristiansen and Santoso 2006). However, health center that is staffed with midwives and used
during the Asian economic crisis in 1997, Indonesia mainly for delivery services. Posyandu is one of the
4 SURYANTO ET AL.
that focuses on providing basic healthcare services Private Military and Police Department
Para-State Agency (BUMN) Other Ministries
for mothers, infants, and toddlers (Kementerian Kese- 900
833
hatan Republik Indonesia 2013b). Poskesdes is another 800
724 736
700 687 705
of the community-empowering activities at village level 600
676
599
ties that are not only for maternal and infant ser- 400
300
vices, but also for health services in general, including 200
159 169 167
health surveillance for nutrition, environment, emer- 100
67 67 62
7 8
gency, and disasters (Kementerian Kesehatan Republik 0
2013
3
2014 2015
Source: Republik Indonesia (). Source: Kementerian Kesehatan Republik Indonesia ().
HOSPITAL TOPICS 5
puskesmas and the general and specialist hospitals, caused by injury, as well as threatening medical cases
which are publically or privately owned. such as cardiac arrests. The World Health Organization
Another report from the World Health Organiza- (2011) estimated that 64% of all deaths in Indonesia
tion (2014) shows that the ratio of hospitals in Indone- are caused by noncommunicable diseases with injuries
sia to population in 2013 was 0.4 per 10,000 people. being the fourth largest cause (9%). Current data from
Compared with other countries, the ratio is similar to the World Health Organization show that the road
Nepal but higher than Bangladesh, 0.2 per 10,000 peo- traffic mortality rate in Indonesia was 15.3 per 100,000
ple. Other SEA countries, Myanmar and Thailand, had people, it was below the average among SEA countries
higher ratios of hospital to population, 0.6 and 1.8 per (17.5). Compared with other SEA countries, Thailand
10,000 people, respectively (World Health Organiza- had the highest road traffic mortality rate with 36.2
tion 2014). and Maldives had the lowest rate with 3.5 per 100,000
Nurses accounted for the highest number among people (World Health Organization 2016).
healthcare providers in Indonesia, 233,910 (34.6%) The awareness of the importance of an emergency
of whom 73,311 staff a puskesmas and 147,264 of medical system was raised in 1969 by the Indonesian
them staff hospitals (Kementerian Kesehatan Repub- Surgeons’ Association, when they recognized that no
lik Indonesia, 2015). A majority of those nurses have prehospital system was dealing with 70% of trauma
a diploma in nursing qualified or below; as an exam- mortality resulting from traffic accidents (Pitt and
ple, there were 26,056 (92.3%) diploma of nursing Pusponegoro 2005). A pilot ambulance project was
qualified or below and 2,180 (7.7%) bachelor of nurs- established in 1972 but due to financial problems it
ing qualified nurses in East Java province (Dinas was shelved. Further development occurred in the late
Kesehatan Provinsi Jawa Timur 2013). Midwives 1980s or early 1990s when municipal offices from seven
accounted the second largest human resources in cities in Indonesia (Jakarta, Palembang, Yogyakarta,
health in Indonesia, at 111,736 (12.7%; Kemente- Surabaya, Makassar, Malang, and Denpasar) intro-
rian Kesehatan Republik Indonesia, 2015). To mea- duced the 118 Emergency Ambulance Service (Pitt
sure the minimum standard of competencies for nurses and Pusponegoro 2005). Then, the ambulance system
and midwives, new graduates of both professions was expanded to 18 cities in Indonesia. This develop-
must undertake a national competency exam (Direk- ment was in conjunction with the introduction of the
tur Jenderal Pendidikan Tinggi, 2013). Medical doctors Advanced Trauma Life Support course in 1995 and the
were the third largest healthcare workers in Indone- increase in government awareness of prehospital care.
sia, 101,615 (11.6%) (Kementerian Kesehatan Repub- The government launched the Safe Community Pro-
lik Indonesia, 2015) and the competency national gram in 2000, a program that aimed to provide health
exam for medical doctor graduates has been in place care for the safety and health of citizens in both rural
since 2004 (Republik Indonesia, 2004). The small and urban areas (Pusponegoro 2003).
portions of other healthcare providers in Indonesia From those 18 cities implementing the 118 emer-
include pharmacists, public health officers, biomedi- gency services, Jakarta, as the capital city of Indonesia,
cal technicians, medical technicians, dieticians, phys- had the most advanced development of prehospital
iotherapists, psychologists, and traditional healthcare care services. In 2005, there were 26 functioning ambu-
providers (Kementerian Kesehatan Republik Indone- lances and 12 motorcycles that provided prehospital
sia, 2015). services. The service received 50–70 calls per day in
Jakarta where the emergency vehicles were positioned
in 10 strategic locations (Pitt and Pusponegoro 2005).
Emergency Care in Indonesia
Each ambulance was crewed by two paramedics and
Emergency care can be discussed from two perspec- equipped with oxygen, defibrillator, ventilator, spinal
tives, prehospital and in-hospital care. In terms of board, and splints, whereas the motorcycles were
prehospital emergency care, there is no system of equipped with a basic resuscitation kit to enable a
ambulance service or patient retrieval in Indonesia paramedic to stabilize a patient while waiting for an
(Pitt and Pusponegoro 2005; Pusponegoro 2003). This ambulance (Pitt and Pusponegoro 2005).
situation may influence the mortality rate in Indone- Even though the number of ambulance was
sia, especially accident-related mortality such as death increased to 32 vehicles in 2010 (First REIT 2010),
6 SURYANTO ET AL.
the number has dropped back to 21 (Dinas Kesehatan multisector collaboration (Kementerian Kesehatan
Provinsi DKI Jakarta 2014). The system was not able Republik Indonesia 2016). The most current develop-
to cover all of the Jakarta area and hence the average ment of prehospital care services in Indonesia was the
response time varied from 30 min up to 1 hr. The launch of Emergency Service 119 at a national level
system also struggled with financial issues, which also in July 2016. The 119 medical emergency service is
decreased its efficiency (First REIT 2010). now available in 27 locations in Indonesia with the
In 2010, based on Governor Law No. 144 of 2010, establishment of the National Command Centre in
118 emergency services in Jakarta were converted into Jakarta and several Public Safety Centers in every
Ambulans Gawat Darurat Dinas Kesehatan Provinsi city implementing the 119 medical emergency service
DKI Jakarta (AGD DINKES) with the 118 call center (Dzulfiqar and Riza 2016).
becoming a Public Service Agency or Badan Layanan In terms of in-hospital emergency care, there are
Umum under the provincial government (Dinas Kese- two pathways for patients to obtain care in the ED,
hatan Provinsi DKI Jakarta 2014). In 2014, there are first is presenting directly to the ED of the hospital or
239 staff in the AGD DINKES, consisting of 255 being referred from another ED (First REIT 2010). The
nongovernment employee staff and 14 government patients can come directly to ED by ambulance, private
employees including healthcare providers and non- car, public transport, or, in the case of traffic accident,
health workers who provide free ambulance services picked up and transported by a passerby. Depending
for the general public and commercial services such on the facilities within an ED at the level of the hospital,
as standby for special events such as sport, music patients can be treated straight away or transferred into
or other gatherings (Dinas Kesehatan Provinsi DKI a higher-level ED at another hospital (First REIT 2010).
Jakarta 2014). Based on the Indonesian Ministry of Health law No.
Due to insufficient prehospital services provided 856 of 2009, there are four levels of ED in Indonesian
by the government, there are now several hospitals hospitals; level IV ED is the highest level and becomes
in Jakarta, mainly private hospitals, which provide the minimum standard of a Class A hospital, a level
their own ambulance service, including air evacuation III ED is the minimum standard of a Class B hospi-
services (First REIT 2010). This is a fee-for-service tal, a level II ED is the minimum standard of a Class
arrangement that may be rebatable thought the private C hospital, and a level I ED is the minimum standard
health fund or self-funded by the patient of the pri- of a Class D hospital (Kementerian Kesehatan Republik
vate hospitals. Some nongovernmental organizations Indonesia 2009).
are able to provide prehospital care in Jakarta, for exam- There is no national triage system in Indonesia,
ple Medic One, a service based on membership for and each hospital applies a varying level triage sys-
middle- to upper-class people in Central, South, and tem with a four-level triage system most commonly
West Jakarta (First REIT 2010). Based on this situation, used; however, the effectiveness of the triaging systems
the other cities that previously provided the 118 emer- has never been evaluated (Rochana 2013). In Sanglah
gency services were in a difficult position with no other General Hospital, the largest hospital on Bali Island,
options, such as in Malang, where the 118 call center with the most famous tourist attractions in Indone-
is no longer available. However, there is no published sia, there is no systematic triage system to manage the
literature covering the current situation of prehospital patients (Brown et al. 2013). Even though triage doc-
care services in Indonesia. tors are more available than triage nurses, the imple-
The development of prehospital care mostly mentation of a triage system in Indonesia is commonly
occurred in Jakarta, the capital city of Indonesia. neglected and inconsistent (Rochana 2013). Thus, it is
In March 2013 DKI Jakarta Province launched the 119 not surprising that even though the triage skill is at
Emergency Call Centre, part of the Sistem Penanggu- a moderate level, triage knowledge among ED nurses
langan Gawat Darurat Terpadu (SPGDT) program or in Indonesia is at low level (Fathoni, Sangchan, and
Comprehensive System of Emergency Management Songwathana 2010).
(Kementerian Kesehatan Republik Indonesia 2013a).
The SPGDT program is a Ministry of Health program
Conclusion
that was initiated in 2000 in order to promote pre-
hospital emergency care, in-hospital emergency care, The healthcare system in Indonesia continues to
and interhospital referral using cross-program and improve its care delivery and outcomes with many
HOSPITAL TOPICS 7
Republik Indonesia. 2004. Undang Undang Republik Indone- on Asia No. 07. Available at: https://www.adb.org/sites/
sia Nomor 29 Tahun 2004. Available at: http://luk. default/files/publication/177029/ino-paper-07-2015.pdf
staff.ugm.ac.id/atur/UU29-2004PraktikKedokteran.pdf (accessed November 3, 2016).
(accessed November 7, 2014). United Nations. 2014a. United Nations Development Pro-
Republik Indonesia. 2009. Undang-Undang Republik Indone- gramme: Indonesia. Available at: from http://www.undp.
sia Nomor 44 tahun 2009. Available at: http://www. or.id/general/about_culture.asp (accessed July 14, 2014).
kemendagri.go.id/produk-hukum/2009/10/28/undang- United Nations. 2014b. World population 2012 wall chart.
undang-no-44-tahun-2009 (accessed April 9, 2014). Available at: http://www.un.org/en/development/desa/
Rochana, N., 2013. An analysis of the triage system in emergency population/publications/trends/wpp2012.shtml (accessed
departments in Indonesia. Clayton, Australia: Monash Uni- July 14, 2014).
versity. World Health Organization. 2011. Noncommunicable dis-
Rokx, C., J. Giles, E. Satriawan, P. Marzoeki, P. Harimurti, and eases country profile 2011. Available at: http://www.who.
E. Yavuz. 2010. New insight into the provision of health ser- int/nmh/publications/ncd_profiles2011/en/ (accessed
vices in Indonesia: A Health workforce study. Available at: April 23, 2014).
https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/handle/10986/2434 World Health Organization. 2014. World health statistics
(accessed August 26, 2013). 2014. Available at: http://www.who.int/gho/publications/
Rokx, C., G. Schieber, P. Harimurti, A. Tandon, and A. world_health_statistics/2014/en/ (accessed May 14, 2015).
Somanathan. 2009. Health financing in Indonesia: A World Health Organization. 2015. World health statis-
reform road map. Available at: https://openknowledge. tics 2015. Available at: http://apps.who.int/iris/
worldbank.org/handle/10986/2710 (accessed August 26, bitstream/10665/170250/1/9789240694439_eng.pdf?ua=1
2013). (accessed November 3, 2016).
Shields, L., and L. E. Hartati. 2003. Nursing and health care in World Health Organization. 2016. World health statistics
Indonesia. Journal of Advanced Nursing 44:209–16. 2016: Monitoring mealth for the SDGs. Available at: http://
Tabor, S., and S. Y. Yoon. 2015. Promoting information and www.who.int/gho/publications/world_health_statistics/2016/
communications technology in Indonesia. ADP Papers en/ (accessed November 3, 2016).