LABOR RELATIONS APRIL 16 & 23 CASES Page 1 of 2

VII. Pages 568 to 689 4. NATURE OF THE NOTICE OF RETURN TO WORK ORDER

1. WORK STOPPAGE AS ILLEGAL STRIKE

MANILA HOTEL EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION and its
members, petitioners, vs. MANILA HOTEL CORPORATION, res
SANTA ROSA COCA-COLA PLANT EMPLOYEES UNION, pondent. [G.R. No. 154591. March 5, 2007.]

Donrico V. Sebastian, Eulogio G. Batino, Samuel A. Atanque,

Manolo C. Zabaljauregui, Dionisio Tenorio, Edwin P. Rellores,
Luis B. Natividad, Myrna Petingco, Feliciano Tolentino,
Rodolfo A. Amante, Jr., Cipriano C. Bello, and Ronaldo T.
Espino, Efren Galan, and Jun Carmelito
Santos, petitioners, vs. COCA-COLA BOTTLERS PHILS.,
5. STRICT COMPLIANCE WITH THE REQUIREMENT OF
NOTICE OF STRIKE, STRIKE VOTE AND COOLING OFF
PERIOD ON THE LEGALITY OF STRIKE

INC.,respondent. [G.R. Nos. 164302-03. January 24, 2007.]

THE HONGKONG & SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION

EMPLOYEES UNION, MA. DALISAY P. DELA CHICA,
MARVILON B. MILITANTE, DAVID Z. ATANACIO, JR.,
2. EFFECT OF ILLEGAL STRIKE TO UNION MEMBERS AND CARMINA C. RIVERA, MARIO T. FERMIN(†), ISABELO E.
OFFICERS
MOLO, RUSSEL M. PALMA, IMELDA G. HERNANDEZ,
VICENTE M. LLACUNA, JOSEFINA A. ORTIGUERRO, MA.
VISAYAS COMMUNITY MEDICAL CENTER (VCMC), Formerly ASUNCION G. KIMSENG, MIGUEL R. SISON, RAUL P.
known as METRO CEBU COMMUNITY HOSPITAL GERONIMO, MARILOU E. CADENA, ANA N. TAMONTE,
(MCCH), petitioner, vs. ERMA YBALLE, NELIA ANGEL, AVELINO Q. RELUCIO, JORALYN R. GONGORA, CORAZON
ELEUTERIA CORTEZ and EVELYN ONG, respondents. [G.R. E. ALBOS, ANABELLA J. GONZALES, MA. CORAZON Q.
No. 196156. January 15, 2014.]
BALTAZAR, MARIA LUZ I. JIMENEZ, ELVIRA A. ORLINA,
SAMUEL B. ELLARMA, ROSARIO A. FLORES, EDITHA L.
BROQUEZA, REBECCA T. FAJARDO, MA. VICTORIA C.
3. ACTUAL PARTICIPATION IN ILLEGAL STRIKE NECESSARY LUNA, MA. THERESA G. GALANG, BENIGNO V. AMION,
TO DISMISS EMPLOYEES 
GERARDO J. DE LEON, ROWENA T. OCAMPO, MALOU P.
DIZON, RUBEN DE C. ATIENZA, MELO E. GABA, HERNAN B.
CHUAYUCO STEEL MANUFACTURING CORPORATION AND/ CAMPOSANTO, NELIA D.M. DERIADA, LOLITO L. HILIS,
OR EDWIN CHUA, petitioners, vs. BUKLOD NG GRACE C. MABUNAY, FE ESPERANZA C. GERONG, MANUEL
MANGGAGAWA E. HERRERA, JOSELITO J. GONZAGA, ULDARICO D.
SA CHUAYUCO STEELMANUFACTURING CORPORATION, re PEDIDA, ROSALINA JULIET B. LOQUELLANO, MARCIAL F.
spondent. [G.R. No. 167347. January 31, 2007.] GONZAGA, MERCEDES R. PAULE, JOSE TEODORO A.
MOTUS, BLANCHE D. MOTUS, DAISY M. FAGUTAO,
LABOR RELATIONS
ANTONIO A. DEL ROSARIO, EMMANUEL JUSTIN S. GREY,
FRANCISCA DEL MUNDO, JULIETA A. CRUZ, RODRIGO J.
DURANO, CATALINA R. YEE, MENANDRO CALIGAGAN,
MAIDA M. SACRO MILITANTE, LEONILA M. PEREZ, and
APRIL 16 & 23 CASES Page 2 of 2
DELA ROSA LINER, INC. AND/OR ROSAURO DELA ROSA,
SR. AND NORA DELA ROSA, petitioners, vs. CALIXTO B.
BORELA AND ESTELO A. AMARILLE,respondents. [G.R.
No. 207286. July 29, 2015.]

EMMA MATEO, petitioners, vs. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS

COMMISSION and THE HONGKONG & SHANGHAI BANKING NILO S. RODRIGUEZ, FRANCISCO T. ALISANGCO,
CORPORATION, LTD., respondents. [G.R. No. 156635. January BENJAMIN T. ANG, VICENTE P. ANG, SILVESTRE D.
11, 2016.]
 ARROYO, RUDERICO C. BAQUIRAN, WILFREDO S. CRUZ,
EDMUNDO M. DELOS REYES, JR., VIRGILIO V. ECARMA,
ISMAEL F. GALISIM, TITO F. GARCIA, LIBERATO D. GUTIZA,
6. PAYROLL REINSTATEMENT IN LIEU OF ACTUAL GLADYS L. JADIE, LUISITO M. JOSE, PATERNO C. LABUGA,
REINSTATEMENT UPON ASSUMPTION OF JURISDICTION
JR., NOEL Y. LASTIMOSO, DANILO C. MATIAS, BEN T.
MATURAN, VIRGILIO N. OCHARAN, GABRIEL P. PIAMONTE,
NATIONAL UNION OF WORKERS IN THE HOTEL JR., ARTURO A. SABADO, MANUEL P. SANCHEZ, MARGOT
RESTAURANT AND ALLIED INDUSTRIES (NUWHRAIN-APL- A. CORPUS as the surviving spouse of the deceased
IUF) DUSIT HOTEL NIKKO CHAPTER, petitioner, vs. THE ARNOLD S. CORPUS, and ESTHER VICTORIA A.
HONORABLE COURT OF APPEALS (Former Eighth Division), ALCAÑESES as the surviving spouse of the deceased EFREN
THE NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION (NLRC), S. ALCAÑESES, petitioners, vs. PHILIPPINE AIRLINES, INC.
PHILIPPINE HOTELIERS INC., owner and operator of DUSIT and NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS
HOTEL NIKKO and/or CHIYUKI FUJIMOTO, and ESPERANZA COMMISSION,respondents. [G.R. No. 178501. January 11,
V. ALVEZ, respondents. [G.R. No. 163942. November 11, 2008.]
2016.]

7. APPLICATION OF RES JUDICATA IN CASES OF ILLEGAL

STRIKE, UNFAIR LABOR PRACTICES, VIOLATION OF LABOR
STANDARDS CASES

CLUB FILIPINO, INC. and ATTY. ROBERTO F. DE

LEON, petitioners, vs. BENJAMIN BAUTISTA, RONIE SUALOG,
JOEL CALIDA, JOHNNY ARINTO, CARLITO PRESENTACION,
and ROBERTO DE GUZMAN, respondents. [G.R. No. 168406.
January 14, 2015.]