You are on page 1of 10

05 Geissler (JB/D) 9/11/01 1:10 pm Page 362

HEALTH POLICY AND PLANNING; 16(4): 362–371 © Oxford University Press 2001

Self-treatment by Kenyan and Ugandan schoolchildren and the


need for school-based education
P WENZEL GEISSLER,1,2 LOTTE MEINERT,1,2 RUTH PRINCE,1,2,3 CATHERINE NOKES,3
JENS AAGAARD-HANSEN,2 JESSICA JITTA4 AND JOHN H OUMA5
1Institut for Anthropology, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark, 2Danish Bilharziasis Laboratory,

Copenhagen, Denmark, 3Partnership for Child Development, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK, 4Child Health and
Development Centre, Kampala, Uganda and 5Division of Vector Borne Diseases, Ministry of Health, Nairobi, Kenya

Studies on Kenyan and Ugandan primary schoolchildren’s knowledge of medicines and self-treatment prac-
tices show that children aged between 10 and 18 years have a broad knowledge of herbal and biomedical
remedies and that they use them frequently, often without adults’ involvement. They use pharmaceuticals,
including prescription-only drugs, but lack knowledge about indications and dosages.

There is a gap between the children’s life worlds and the school health education as it is presently designed
and taught in Kenya and Uganda. It limits itself to disease prevention and health promotion, and does not
teach treatment or medicine-use. Self-treatment based on insufficient knowledge poses a threat to children’s
health and to the health of the wider community. Therefore, education on the critical and appropriate use of
medicines needs to be developed and tested for possible use in Kenya, Uganda and other countries in which
home-treatment is common. The proposed education on medicines should go beyond providing information
on accurate dosage and indication: it should create critical awareness with regard to medicine-use, enabling
children to use them appropriately and cautiously. Kenyan and Ugandan primary schoolchildren are active
agents within pluralistic medical fields. By taking the children seriously as competent health care agents, the
dangers of self-treatment could be reduced, and the potential of children could be guided to fruitful use.
Educational interventions cannot solve the problems of self-treatment, which are related to the wider social
and economic context, but they could contribute to increased awareness as a necessary condition for change.

Introduction taken for symptoms of common cold, different drugs with the
same effect were combined, and hardly ever was a full course
Primary schoolchildren’s knowledge of medicines and self-
of the appropriate drug taken by a child.
treatment of common ailments were investigated between
1996 and 1998 among the Luo of western Kenya and among Both the children’s knowledge of hospital medicines and
the Iteso of eastern Uganda (for details on the study areas and their reported use of these increased with age throughout
populations as well as detailed findings, see Meinert 1998, primary school. Likewise, the proportion of treatments with
2001; Geissler et al. 2000). These studies have shown that chil- hospital medicines as compared to herbal remedies increased
dren of primary school age possess knowledge of both herbal with age, and around the age of 16 years, the children seemed
remedies and ‘hospital’ medicines1 and that they use medi- to have acquired the medicine-use patterns of adults
cines to treat themselves as well as their younger siblings. (Geissler et al. 2000). The Kenyan children dealt with more
Among the hospital medicines, aspirin, paracetamol and than two-thirds of all minor illness episodes without consult-
chloroquine and their generics were well-known and widely ing adults, and they provided more than one-third of all treat-
used, but also other antimalarials – notably Fansidar® and ments themselves, without an adult’s aid. With growing age,
generics – and antibiotics like Flagyl® and Septrin® were the proportion of adult-assisted treatments fell, and around
acquired and used independently by primary schoolchildren the age of 16 years, few children consulted adults if they felt
in both Kenya and Uganda. The children seemed to use these ill (Geissler et al. 2000). In the Ugandan study, most of the
drugs too frequently – many children resorting to antimalari- children contacted an adult at some point in the treatment
als more or less every month – and often inappropriately. seeking process and often they obtained the money to buy
Very few of them knew the correct dosage of chloroquine for medicines from an adult caretaker, but they were often left
the treatment of malaria, or the difference between anti- to administer the medicines themselves (Meinert 1998, 2001).
malarials, antipyretics and analgesics. Brand names, which This difference between the Kenyan and the Ugandan
often transported confusing messages, were usually the only children may be due to the availability of money to children,
source of information on the indication of different drugs which probably is greater in Kenya. Along the Kenyan shore
(Geissler et al. 2000).2 Antimalarials were thus commonly of Lake Victoria, boys from the age of 10 onwards earn cash
05 Geissler (JB/D) 9/11/01 1:10 pm Page 363

Self-treatment and health education of schoolchildren 363

through fishing, and redistributive mechanisms among the intestinal worms and HIV/AIDS (for Kenya see, for example,
children make small amounts of money widely available to MOH 1992; for Uganda see, for example, Barton and Wamai
children (Geissler et al. 2000). The hospital medicines that 1994). With the exception of AIDS, these diseases are pre-
the children bought were cheap (e.g. aspirin or chloroquine ventable or curable, in principle at least. Morbidity is high
were sold for the equivalent of less than £0.01 per tablet at the among school-aged children, and malaria and intestinal infec-
time of the study). Older children often took care of younger tions cause suffering, school absenteeism, poor learning
children’s illnesses and administered medicines to them capacity and working capability (for Kenya see Brooker et al.
(Meinert 2001). 1999).

These findings indicate that the studied East African children The Ugandan government health system is slowly being
are handling medicines more independently than their Euro- rebuilt after decades of decay due to political instability and
pean counterparts (Trakas and Sanz 1992; Bush et al. 1996). a declining economy. In Kenya, several decades of economic
They are competent agents in a pluralistic medical field and decline have resulted in ineffective government health ser-
they move actively between different medical traditions, vices in most rural areas. Private health care facilities of
including local herbal and hospital medicines. The aim of this varying quality – licensed as well as illegal private clinics,
paper is to examine how school-age children’s medical com- drugstores and small shops selling pharmaceuticals – are the
petence could be taken into account in the design and prac- main source of medical assistance outside the home and the
tice of health education programmes in Kenya, Uganda and family (Whyte 1991; Snow et al. 1992). Most health care and
other countries with similar socioeconomic conditions and lay treatment of sickness, however, take place in the domestic
treatment practices. sphere. For instance, a recent study from Uganda shows that
about three-quarters of all treatments taken are home-treat-
ments (Adome et al. 1996). While herbal medicines are
Background
widely trusted in Kenya and Uganda, hospital medicines play
Children in Kenya and Uganda account for more than half of an important role in home-treatment. Common drugs (both
the total population and school-aged children for more than prescription only and OTC) reach the remotest village
one-third of it (GOK 1996; Grauballe and Balslev 1998, through extensive marketing and sales networks, and can be
p. 12). Most children in the rural areas grow up in extended bought in the smallest kiosk as well as in many homesteads
families; their social life is situated in a group of siblings and (Whyte 1997; Geissler et al. 2000; Maende and Prince 2000).
around the family’s home. From an early age children par-
ticipate in productive activities, such as caring for smaller
Children, medicine and society
siblings, fetching water and firewood, herding cattle or
weeding the gardens. The active participation of African children in the treatment
of illness and their use of medicines contradicts the ‘ethno-
Kenya has universal primary school education up to Standard centric, medicocentric and adult-centric’ (Van der Geest
8, which is officially free, though in reality the costs of 1999) notion that children and medicines are two domains
uniforms, books and materials and various ‘activity fees’ put that should be kept apart. In this view, children are vulner-
significant financial pressure on the children’s caretakers. able and should be protected by adults; medicines are
School facilities in the rural areas vary between rough but powerful and at times dangerous and should be controlled
functional buildings and classes that are held under trees for by experts.
lack of any shelter. According to Kenyan government
statistics, school enrolment in the studied area is above 90% Both the constitution of the weak and passive child, who has
(MOE 1998). This figure might be exaggerated and school to be taken care of by adults and taught in schools (e.g. Aries
attendance is often irregular, but most children do attend 1962), and the construction of ‘medicine’ as a domain of
primary school at some point. Many leave school before expert knowledge (e.g. Foucault 1975) have co-evolved in a
completion of Standard 8 because they lack funds, because historical process linked to overall European modernization
their labour is needed in the household, or because they lose during the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Central to
interest in school. In Uganda in 1997, the government this process was the development of the nation-state and a
launched the Universal Primary Education programme, system of governance based on efficient taxation and the
which offers free education for four children from each family creation of institutions taking care of the welfare – and to
(UNICEF/GOU 1997). Due to this policy, the number of some extent controlling – the citizens. The institutions of
pupils in primary schools has more than doubled, which has school and hospital epitomize this process of modernization.
caused problems in terms of infrastructure and teaching State influence was extended to the most personal dimen-
capacity. School attendance is irregular in rural areas, for the sions of social life: care for one’s children and one’s body. In
same reasons as in Kenya, and drop-out rates are high. schools, children’s development and access to knowledge
was increasingly disciplined and canonized, and in a parallel
The health situation in Kenya and Uganda is relatively poor, process, care for the body and its health became organized
as indicated by the estimated infant mortality rates (IMR) of in academic medical discourse and monopolized in the hand
59 and 91 respectively, and a life expectancy at birth of 47 and of experts, based in hospitals. The construction and separ-
43 years respectively (CIA 1999). The major diseases ation of the domains of children and medicines result thus
responsible for the high mortality and morbidity rates are from specific historical processes and societal conditions;
malaria, acute respiratory infections, diarrhoea, measles, they are not universal.
05 Geissler (JB/D) 9/11/01 1:10 pm Page 364

364 P Wenzel Geissler et al.

As mentioned above, the idea of a ‘childhood’ free of prevented, and it aims – at times successfully – at a definite
responsibility and distinct from adult life cannot, without cure to get rid of illness. While in this understanding curative
qualification, be applied to East African children, whose lives practices should be left to the experts, prevention is the duty
are not separated from the every-day life of older members of of lay people. In contrast, in the understanding of many rural
their domestic groups. Children participate in most produc- Luo, illness is always present in the body and must accord-
tive activities; they take care of siblings, the elderly and the ingly be controlled continuously. People’s medical practice
sick, and they participate in the treatment of illness. thus consists of continuous activity using all available materia
medica, which is part of every-day life and which does not
Likewise, the split between professional and lay medical separate treatment from prevention (Geissler 1998; see also
knowledge that is created by the historical constitution of bio- Pearce 1993). This kind of practice involves medicine use, but
medicine differs from the medical ideas and practices in many in contrast to biomedical treatment, in many cases it does not
African communities. Some specialized healers here possess aim at a final ‘victory’ over the illness – its ‘eradication’ – but
knowledge to treat rare and serious illnesses, but most rather at keeping it at bay or ‘dispersing’ it (see Parkin 1996).
medical knowledge is distributed over the community, and Similar features of medical culture have been found in
everybody knows some treatments for the illnesses from Uganda (Whyte 1997; Meinert 1998). A consequence of these
which they or their family members commonly suffer (Whyte views on illness and treatment is that hospital medicines,
1991; Pearce 1993; Sindiga et al. 1995). In the Kenyan study which in a biomedical understanding are intended to ‘cure’ a
area, we showed that mothers without any claims to be specific, diagnosed sickness, are used frequently, and often in
healers had the same consensual core of medical (plant) low doses, as a response to minor signs of the potential of
knowledge as a large sample of healers in the wider study dis- illness. Consequently, hospital medicines are used too fre-
trict (Johns et al. 1990; Geissler et al. 2001). This community quently, unspecifically, in low doses, and by everybody in the
knowledge of healing is not regarded as inferior to that of the family.
specialist healers, but belongs to a continuum of accepted
ways of counteracting illness. Everybody in the household Both because this kind of independent family-based medici-
can have a share in this knowledge and thereby participate in nal treatment is rooted in the local medical practices, and
the domestic medical practices. because the formal health system is often unable to provide
satisfactory medical care, home- and self-treatment are
Despite its historically specific origin, the ‘modern’ ideology common in societies such as those studied in Kenya and
separating children and medicines guides the official policy of Uganda. Research on community drug use in the developing
most countries today. Governments set age limits for the world shows that legislation alone cannot efficiently control
acquisition of over-the-counter drugs and aim to monopolize medicine use, and that people everywhere integrate hospital
the prescription of medicines in the hands of professionals medicines into their established patterns of home care (Haak
(Lee and Herzstein 1986). This policy is guided by the prin- and Hardon 1988; Adome et al. 1996). Restrictive legislation
ciple that it is professionals who should control treatment and can affect treatment patterns, but the improvement of treat-
provide medicines to the parents, who should then negotiate ment practices cannot be sustained unless satisfactory treat-
the treatment with the child. In this way, the health system ment facilities and education accompanies the legislation. If
should bar children from all independent contact with medi- the state cannot provide health care and people have to help
cines and concentrate medical power in the hands of adults. themselves, a rigid legislation is rather likely to hide existing
health care practices from the public eye and thereby pose a
risk for people’s health.
Home and self-treatment
Restrictive drug legislation and the limitation of medical The cited studies on children’s medicine use in Kenya and
knowledge to experts may be appropriate where illness is a Uganda indicate that attempts to protect children from medi-
relatively rare event, and where governments efficiently cine use fail their purpose when the three assumptions of
provide and control treatment. It becomes problematic where western policies regarding medicines and children are not
serious illness is an almost daily experience and the health given:
care system is unable to provide even basic services, as is the
case in many parts of Kenya, Uganda and other economically (1) Children here are not passive creatures constantly super-
deprived countries. vised by adults, but are responsible community members.
(2) Knowledge of medicines is not an expert’s domain, but is
Home- and self-treatment is a central part of local medical common property and everybody participates in healing.
culture in these societies, where people are used to taking (3) The state does not have the capacity to provide health
treatment into their own hands (Whyte 1988; Van der Geest care or control the trade in medicines.
and Whyte 1989; Adome et al. 1996). Most common illnesses
are dealt with by lay people on their own; only when an illness Due to the ideology of childhood and of medical expertise as
is prolonged or serious do people seek expert advice, be it a described above, knowledge about the proper use of medi-
local healer or a biomedical professional. Moreover, lay cines is withheld from children and other lay people, while
medical practice in the studied communities seems not to be access to medicines, including potent hospital medicines, is
dichotomized into ‘preventive’ and ‘curative’ practice, as it is easy. Where the barrier between children and medicines is
in biomedical thought. Biomedical illness concepts see illness broken down in practice, the described ideology, meant to
as occurring due to specific, defined causes, which can be protect children from harm, endangers their health.
05 Geissler (JB/D) 9/11/01 1:10 pm Page 365

Self-treatment and health education of schoolchildren 365

Risks of self-treatment education in most contemporary school curricula. It usually


focuses on disease prevention – mainly by avoiding doing
Self-treatment of illness entails a number of health risks.
certain things – rather than on active coping with illness.
Pharmaceuticals can have toxic effects when they are taken in
Treatment and curing of illness and use of medicines are only
too high doses or too frequently. Chloroquine and analgesics
taught to medical professionals as part of their ‘medical edu-
were the hospital medicines most commonly taken by chil-
cation’, while ‘health education’ gives advice on how to
dren in the studies cited above. Chloroquine can lead to acute
remain healthy.
intoxication and is a frequent cause of death in Kenya (Maitai
et al. 1981); analgesics like aspirin can cause stomach bleed-
In Kenya, school health education is part of the subject
ings (Dengler and Roberts 1996), and paracetamol can
‘Home Science’, which comprises a wide range of topics, for
damage liver and kidneys (Whelton 1995). Beyond these
example, cooking, sewing, child-care and gardening (Kenya
individual side-effects, frequent use of antimalarials and
Institute of Education 1992). In the schools studied, it was
antibiotics, and underdosing of these drugs, can contribute to
given low priority by teachers, parents and children. Its
the development of drug resistance and thus harm the wider
stated aim is to ‘help the individual realise and solve family
community (Brinkmann and Brinkmann 1991; McCombie
problems, as well as adapt more easily to the changing living
1997). Self-medication without knowledge of these risks and
conditions in the home, community and society as a whole’
of the proper indication and dosage is therefore likely to have
and ‘to give . . . basic skills, knowledge and attitudes which
iatrogenic effects.
can be applied in day-to-day living, and to improve the
quality of life of an individual and the society’ (Kenya Insti-
Herbal remedies are not without dangers either. There is a
tute of Education 1992, p. 71). The general objective of
risk that plant products contain toxins, which can be
health education in this framework is to enable children ‘to
dangerous in themselves or may interact with hospital
observe health practices and take precautionary measures . . .
medicines. Furthermore, experimentation with herbs and
in relation to personal hygiene, kitchen hygiene, sanitation,
traditional healers might delay the patient’s visit to a bio-
water, poisonous substances and health hazards’ (Kenya
medical practitioner or a government health facility
Institute of Education 1992, our emphasis). The focus of
(Adome et al. 1996).
health education is thus on prevention. Apart from first aid,
it does not contain any advice on curative practice. Neither
The potential of children as agents of health herbal nor pharmaceutical remedies are part of the syllabus
(Kenya Institute of Education 1992). If reference to treat-
Despite these risks of self-treatment, the children’s use of ment is made in school books, this is always linked to a pro-
medicines and their appropriation of herbal remedies and fessional health care provider, as in the advice: ‘Get
hospital medicines reveals also children’s potential as agents treatment from the hospital’ (Kenya Institute of Education
of health. Many common infectious diseases could, if not be 1993a,b).
prevented, easily be treated in a better way than is presently
the case. Given the state’s inability to provide health care, In Uganda, since 1985 health education has been an indepen-
children might be able to take a greater share in improving dent part of the science syllabus and forms a remarkably large
community health. part of the primary school curriculum. The National Curricu-
lum Development Centre, together with an Interministerial
The children’s knowledge of medicines, which grows with Expert Panel on School Health Education, the Ministry of
their age, shows that they provide a good target group for Health, the Ministry of Education and UNICEF, made a
educational interventions on treatment and drugs. In the revision of the health education syllabus in 1988
process of rapid and radical changes of the medical system, as (UNICEF/GOU, undated). A School Health Education Pro-
occur for example in Kenya and Uganda, children are gramme was launched in which one teacher from each
exposed to a multitude of medical traditions ranging from the primary school was given training in health education and
grandmothers they live with to the advertisements of drug new materials were produced and distributed. Upon evalu-
companies on local markets. They learn quickly, and most of ation, health education was made an examinable part of the
them attend school and could therefore be easily reached by science syllabus in order to signal the importance of the
relevant health education. subject and make sure that the content was actually taught.
The School Health Education Programme ambitiously aims
at teaching schoolchildren knowledge, skills and attitudes in
Medical knowledge and health education
a way that will stimulate them to change their behaviour and
The hierarchy of medical power described above, which also pass their knowledge on to parents and other children
stretches from professional experts to lay adults to children, (GOU 1990). To what extent these goals have been achieved
reflects an unequal distribution of medical knowledge is unclear as no evaluation of the effects of health education
between these groups. Professional expert knowledge guides has been undertaken so far. The assumption that school-
the active use of powerful medicines for treatment, while for children can promote better health practices in the family by
lay people – in particular for children – a passive knowledge communicating school health messages to their parents is
of how to prevent illness and compliance to the doctor’s problematic in the context of steep hierarchical family struc-
advice is regarded as sufficient. This distribution of roles in tures. Children are, however, able to communicate changes in
the medical field – curative practice as expert competence, more subtle ways, through their own practices and through
prevention and compliance as lay duties – has shaped health communication to other children.
05 Geissler (JB/D) 9/11/01 1:10 pm Page 366

366 P Wenzel Geissler et al.

The Ugandan primary school, health education syllabus is Children and parents are less interested in a subject that is
oriented towards health promotion and disease prevention. It supposed to teach them domestic skills, i.e. ‘work’, which
does not include curative knowledge, although it gives more they have enough of before and after school. Children
concrete, applicable information on care for sick people than come to school, or are sent by parents, to learn ‘modern’
the Kenyan syllabus. Health education covers hygiene, skills such as reading, writing and calculating; skills that
sanitation, family life, HIV/AIDS and STDs, reproduction, they hope will eventually take them to salaried employment
nutrition, immunization, the body, alcohol, smoking, drugs, and urban lifestyles (see Serpell 1993 for examples of what
first aid, caring for sick or disabled people, and the causes and he terms the ‘extractive’ model of schooling). The topics
symptoms of various diseases (MOE 1988). The module on dealt with in home science and health education are often
drugs describes ‘traditional medicine’, ‘manufactured’/ traditionally both gendered and generationalized, but this is
‘modern medicine’ and ‘drugs of dependency’, and encour- not tackled in health education. Moreover, the health
ages teachers and children to consider useful, harmful and education aims at practical tasks, and therefore is not effec-
harmless effects of different medicines within these groups tively taught in the conventional style of learning described
(MOE 1988). It is emphasized that pharmaceuticals should be above.
obtained from official sources and not from ‘the market’; the
issue of ‘spoiled drugs’ (expiry and storage) and the risk of The aims, content and style of the existing health education
drug poisoning are pointed out. Compliance with regimens contrast with the practice of the children as described in the
and drug resistance are mentioned (GOU et al. 1988). studies cited above. While the children are very active in the
treatment of illness, the teaching in school confines their role
Although there are some significant differences between the to preventive measures. By neglecting the children’s true situ-
Kenyan and Ugandan school health education programmes, ation, school health education is likely to fail in its stated goals
the overall approach in both countries is in agreement with to provide basic life skills for the improvement of their daily
the ‘modern’ ideas about children and medicines as separate life.
domains. Children are attributed a role in the prevention of
illness, but not given knowledge to engage actively in the
Felt needs of health education
treatment of illness (see Lutwama and Bennett 1969). This is
in accord with the concept of ‘primary health care’ based on When the discrepancy between the school’s preventive
the idea that prevention should have priority before cure syllabus and the children’s curative practice was brought
(WHO 1978). However, it is also rooted in the much older tra- up in conversations with teachers in Kenya and Uganda,
dition of tropical public health, which formed an integral part two contrasting positions were evident. On one side was a
of the colonial enterprise and – particularly in Africa – was minority who adhered to an ideological position, maintain-
built on the idea of local people being passive, ignorant recip- ing the separation of children and medicine. Some of these
ients of western curative services or disease control (Vaughan denied that children were treating themselves at all, or
1991). Formal schooling in Africa also originated in colonial that they used hospital medicines; or they maintained that
times, and has equally been shaped by colonial ideology and ‘. . . teaching them about these things will make them do it
‘western’ ideas of childhood and education (Serpell 1993). even more . . .’ (primary school teacher, Kenya). On the
Due to this post-colonial legacy, health education in Africa other side was the majority, who acknowledged the
today is still largely providing ‘dos and don’ts’, i.e. instruc- situation as described and suggested that teachers, children
tions on how to promote general health and prevent the and other lay people need to be taught about the proper
threat of illness. These often cannot be followed under the use of medicines.
given economic conditions. Very little knowledge is conveyed
to children on how to cope with bodily afflictions in their daily The latter group discussed which drugs should be taught
lives and to handle the potent medicines that are readily avail- about, and whether the aim should be to provide correct
able to them. information for medicine use or if the children should be
discouraged from using potentially harmful drugs. These
Presently, teaching in health education in Uganda and Kenya, discussions showed that an open and thorough debate
as in most other subjects, consists of conventional, teacher- involving all stakeholders will be needed to attain a viable
centred practices conveying pre-formulated health messages consensus on the content of health education. Some
as are provided by syllabus and text books, which the children teachers suggested that issues such as drug dosages and
copy from the blackboard or repeat after the teacher. It does drug resistance could be explained to schoolchildren, and
not involve discussion, active understanding of the principles that this could even be integrated into subjects not related
of health, or practical exercises. This teaching style does not to health, like mathematics, in order to enhance the effect
help children transform their knowledge into changed health of health education itself: “Dosages of medicines for differ-
practices. Furthermore, the content of teaching is often unre- ent body sizes provides a good example for teaching maths
alistic. For example, the advice to avoid contact with lake . . .” (primary school teacher, Uganda). Another teacher
water in a warm region where this is the only water source, or from this school gave an ingenious example of how to
the advice to boil all drinking water when firewood for explain the issue of drug resistance: “We can use the idea
cooking is scarce, seem misplaced. of stubborn children, which is something we know very well
. . . If children are always beaten a little, but not enough to
In both Kenya and Uganda the teachers tend to give more make them behave well, they become stubborn. Malaria
importance to the ‘main’ subjects like English or mathematics. parasites are like that. If you treat them with medicines a
05 Geissler (JB/D) 9/11/01 1:10 pm Page 367

Self-treatment and health education of schoolchildren 367

bit here and a bit there, but you never put them down com- number of young victims of AIDS, some representatives of
pletely, they develop that stubbornness. They can transfer churches and the government continue to refuse to include
this stubbornness to other parasites, just like stubborn contraception and safer sex in the primary school curriculum,
children can make other children become like them.” arguing that increased knowledge would incite the children to
Although this particular metaphor might raise ethical objec- engage in sex. Research has shown that this is not the case;
tions, the idea of using local metaphors or appropriate children who have received education on sex and AIDS
analogies in health communication has proven to be work- generally delay their sexual debut and/or practice safer sex
able (Nichter and Nichter 1989). compared with children who have no sex education (WHO
1993).
Among the health staff in and outside the MOH, with whom
we discussed the possibility of teaching children about medi- In Uganda, AIDS has been given special attention in the
cines, opinions were also split. Local health workers and School Health Education Programme since recognition of the
nurses often welcomed the idea; others raised valid concerns. epidemic. The Ugandan government’s openness about AIDS
Their concerns focused on the dangers of: and the health communication and education programmes
that have been implemented, together with other factors,
(1) further undermining drug control legislation; have been associated with a reduced incidence of HIV infec-
(2) enhancing an existing tendency for over-medication; and tion (Barton and Wamai 1994). The openness shown by the
(3) the unintended consequences of education on treatment, Ugandan government in the field of sex education could
creating ‘lots of little doctors’, as one of the interviewed benefit broader health education as well. Moreover, the
nurses put it. experiences gained in Uganda could provide information and
inspiration for the current revision of the Kenyan school
These concerns will each have to be taken into account when curriculum.
planning educational interventions:
An ethical educational policy, which takes seriously the aims
(1) Close collaboration with the MOH, as well as with drug of schooling and health education as quoted above, must
authorities, is necessary to ensure complete agreement leave behind the paternalistic legacy in educational and
between teaching and legislation. public health thought. It should depart from the existing
(2) Teaching needs to focus on issues of overuse and over- situation and include children in the ‘acceptance of greater
dosing as well as correct dosages; given the scarcity of responsibility for health by communities and individuals and
resources, children should have an interest in using their active participation in attaining it’, as demanded by the
medicines as little and as efficiently as possible. Alma Ata declaration (WHO 1978, p. 39).
(3) This is an important warning, since Meinert’s research
shows how health education enhances the competence The authors therefore propose that health education on the
and activity of children’s health action far beyond the use and misuse of medicines should be added to existing
content of the educational messages themselves (Meinert health education from primary school onwards, especially in
2001). Medical knowledge, however scanty, is a resource, developing countries where self-treatment is common and
which people try to make maximal use of. This is illus- sources of information are scarce. This should take school-
trated by the omnipresence, in East Africa, of injection- children’s knowledge and use of herbal and hospital medi-
ists with no formal training apart from their employment cines as its point of departure and adjust its teaching to the
as hospital subordinates or medical research assistants. medical reality the children live in. It should include the
Again, this tendency has to be balanced by an emphasis, potential and risks of traditional herbal remedies as well as
in the teaching, on the dangers of medicines. Unintended information on the appropriate use of common pharmaceuti-
effects of this kind must be monitored when educational cals. The initiative should, of course, be based on careful
interventions on medicines are implemented. studies of medicine use in specific local settings. Teacher
training programmes and education materials should be
developed in collaboration with teachers, children and health
Education on medicine-use
workers, in order to represent the interests of all stakehold-
The prevention of disease should remain a paramount goal of ers involved. Similar suggestions have been made for the UK
public health policies. But the discrepancy between children’s (Dengler and Roberts 1996), and a need for this kind of teach-
practice and schools’ ideas about health illustrate that the ing has been shown by various studies (Trakas and Sanz 1992;
available health education is insufficient to enable children to Bush et al. 1996; King et al. 1996), but no appropriate edu-
deal with the health and illness situation they face in their cational measures have been taken yet.
everyday lives.
The minimum goal of school-based education about medi-
The preventive focus of current health education is based cines should be to create awareness among schoolchildren
on an idealistic conception of the local health situation, about the risks and potential of any treatment and the power
neglecting problems rather than facing them (Meinert 1998). of medicines, be they herbal or hospital medicines. With
This approach seems characteristic of official (especially regard to herbal remedies, it ought to encourage the children
educational) discourses in Uganda and Kenya. The long dis- to learn about medicines from older family members and to
cussion about sex education in Kenyan schools is an example value their skills, while at the same time stressing the import-
of this. Despite widespread teenage pregnancy and a growing ance of using herbal medicines as cautiously and responsibly
05 Geissler (JB/D) 9/11/01 1:10 pm Page 368

368 P Wenzel Geissler et al.

as any other medicine. Similarly, children should learn about and knowledge that is valuable for an innovative educational
the consequences of misusing the most widely used commer- intervention. The example of this broad institutional frame-
cial pharmaceuticals and about the correct dosages and indi- work illustrates the need for a consultative process involving
cation of some of these drugs. Drugs used for the treatment different stakeholders in the preparation and implementation
of malaria – antimalarials, analgesics and antipyretics – will of school-based education on medicines.
be particularly important here.
Education about medicines in primary schools could con-
Given the wide distribution of pharmaceuticals with a tribute to an improved drug use and activate children as
variety of brand names, it would be useful to teach children agents of medical care and of a changing health discourse.
the differences between these medicines and the distinction The ‘child-to-child’ programme has explored some ways of
between generic and proprietary drugs. The fundamental involving children in community health with some successes
difference between drugs against symptoms, like analgesics, (Haws 1988). Approaches based on children communicating
and those against the disease itself, like antimalarials, ought preventive health messages to parents and other adults some-
to be taught. What should be learned, and at what age, will times face difficulties, because of children’s lack of influence
have to be discussed for different medicines, and will vary on household decisions (Meinert 1998). The children’s
greatly between different target populations. While for activity in the curative field might provide new grounds for
analgesics appropriate use can be taught easily, antibiotics child-centred initiatives on community health. Concrete,
entail greater risks. The content of education about medi- applicable skills for the treatment of acute illness may be
cines will thus need a balance between the established drug more readily acknowledged and used by adults than long-
use patterns of the children and their communities, and the term, labour intensive preventive measures like latrine-build-
risks as assessed by medical professionals, teachers and the ing.
children’s caretakers. Public discussion about the aims and
content of health education is required to achieve such a Education on medicines must provide knowledge for medi-
balance. cine use as well as against it. It should raise awareness about
the ‘commodification’ and ‘pharmaceuticalization’ of health
Education about medicines needs to be integrated into the (Whyte and Birungi, in press), and provide information on
existing education and health policies through collaboration the economic interests connected to the spread and market-
with different agencies and agents. The authors are presently ing of pharmaceuticals. It should emphasize that medication
setting up an intervention study in Kenya, in which education is not a solution to ill-health, and that only effective resource
on the management of fevers and malaria, including the distribution, improved infrastructure, active prevention and a
appropriate use of medicines, will be implemented and evalu- functioning health system will have a long-term effect on
ated in a controlled trial in a number of primary schools. The health. In other words, it must not advocate a further ‘medi-
preparations for this intervention study will be undertaken calization’ of social, economic and political problems, which
after consultations with children, parents and teachers in the have their roots in poverty and unequal distribution of wealth
respective areas. They will involve representatives of two div- (Illich 1977; Scheper-Hughes 1992, pp. 195–212), but create
isions of the MOH, namely the Division of Health Education critical awareness alongside concrete information and skills.
(DHE) and the Division of Vector Borne Diseases (DVBD). The topic of pharmaceuticals not only provides an oppor-
Both divisions are represented in the National Malaria tunity for education on illness and treatment, but also invites
Control Programme (NMCP), which coordinates the efforts teaching about the broader context of health and illness in
of different ministries and NGOs in malaria control through global economic and political relations. Education on medi-
its Malaria Control Unit (MCU). The DHE is currently cines does not provide a ‘magic bullet’ against the misuse of
involved in the development of new ‘information, education medicines, and it will not improve children’s health practices
and communications strategies for the promotion of health by by itself. Changes in knowledge by themselves rarely lead
community members’. The DVBD has been the national directly to improved practices (Yoder 1997). Economic and
centre for the control of malaria and other infectious diseases other contextual factors limit changes in practice, and an
for most of the past century and has expertise in all aspects of improved school curriculum will not change these. If, because
malaria control. Within the Ministry of Education and of poverty, a child is confronted with the choice between an
Human Resource Development (MOE), the School Health insufficient treatment, which nevertheless will alleviate her
and Nutrition Section (SHN) is responsible for health and suffering, and no treatment at all, she will choose the former,
nutrition in Kenyan schools, including curriculum develop- even if she knows the right drug or dosage. However, in the
ment on these issues. Also linked to the MOH is the Kenya given situation of widespread use of hospital medicines by
Institute of Education (KIE), which provides expertise for children, the introduction of education on medicines in the
curriculum and schoolbook development and edits the stan- primary school curriculum will contribute to a gradual
dard textbooks used in primary schools. improvement in health care practices and, eventually, in the
health of school-age children.
Representatives of these government bodies on the national
and the local level and the National Drug Authority need to
be consulted and their expertise and opinion sought in the Endnotes
planning of the intervention. In addition, a variety of UN 1 In this article we use the term ‘hospital medicine’ for indus-
organizations and NGOs are working within health education trially produced and marketed materia medica (medicinal materials)
and malaria control in western Kenya and possess experience in contrast to local herbal medicines or religious healing rituals. This
05 Geissler (JB/D) 9/11/01 1:10 pm Page 369

Self-treatment and health education of schoolchildren 369

designation is the direct translation from the local terms among the Centre, Interministerial Expert Panel on School Health
Luo – Yath osiptal – and Iteso – Ekeya lokadakis. Descriptions of Education, Ministry of Health and Ministry of Education. 1988.
medicine-use in pluralistic medical systems often use ‘biomedicine’, Basic primary science and health for Uganda. Health education.
‘western medicine’, ‘cosmopolitan medicine’ or ‘pharmaceuticals’ to Pupils book seven. Kampala: UNICEF.
designate medicines linked to the medical tradition that emerged in Government of Uganda (GOU). 1990. Primary school syllabus.
Europe after the eighteenth century, and that today are commer- basic science and health education. Kampala: Ministry of
cially produced and sold on global markets. There are some prob- Education.
lems with all of these designations. The designation ‘western’ Grauballe L, Balslev M. 1998. Mere end den halve verden. Børn og
detracts in our view from the fact that people everywhere in the unge i den danske udviklingsbistand. København: Dansk
world have appropriated these medicines into local practices; Ungdoms Fællesråd.
‘cosmopolitan’ suggests a unity of medical practices and ideas Haak H, Hardon AP. 1988. Indigenised pharmaceuticals in develop-
associated with these medicines, which cannot be assumed, as people ing countries: widely used, widely neglected. The Lancet 2:
give varying meanings and use to medicines in different contexts; 620–1.
‘pharmaceuticals’ implies that herbal medicines would work in a Hawes H. 1988. Child-to-Child. Another Path to Learning. Hamburg:
non-pharmacological way, which they do not necessarily do; ‘bio- UNESCO Institute for Education.
medicines’ refers to the links that these medicines have to the- Illich I. 1977. Limits to medicine. Medical Nemesis: The Expropria-
‘biological’ thinking that dominates European medical and scientific tion of Health. Harmondsworth, UK: Penguin Books.
discourse and does not account for the fact that medicines may be Johns T, Kokwaro JO, Kimanani EK. 1990. Herbal remedies of the
moved away from this epistemological context and into an other. All Luo of Siaya District – establishing quantitative criteria for con-
these terms tend to unify heterogeneous ideas, practices and sub- sensus. Economic Botany 44: 369–81.
stances in an undue way, which is why we mainly use the emic term Kenya Institute of Education. 1992. Primary education syllabus.
‘hospital medicine’ here. Nairobi: Kenya Literature Bureau.
2 For example, Homanol (gen. panadol) and Homaquin (gen. Kenya Institute of Education. 1993a. Home science. Pupil’s book for
chloroquin) – both deriving their names from Kiswahili homa, which Standard Six. Nairobi: Kenya Literature Bureau.
often is translated as malaria – were indiscriminately used by Luo Kenya Institute of Education. 1993b. Home science. Pupil’s book for
children for common cold, which in western Kenya is often referred Standard Seven. Nairobi: Kenya Literature Bureau.
to as homa. King A. 1996. The health of youth. A cross national Survey. WHO
Regional Publications, European Series No 69. Copenhagen:
World Health Organization.
References Lee PR, Herzstein J. 1986. International drug regulation. Annual
Review of Public Health 7: 217.
Adome RO, Whyte SR, Hardon A. 1996. Popular pills. Community Lutwama JSW, Bennett FJ (eds). 1969. Health education in Eastern
drug use in Uganda. Amsterdam: Het Spinhuis. Africa. A challenge to the schools. Dar es Salaam/Kampala/
Ariès P. 1962. Centuries of childhood. New York: Vintage. Nairobi: Longman.
Barton T, Wamai G. 1994. Equity and vulnerability: a situation analy- Maende JO, Prince RJ. 2000. Medicines from the ‘village’: the role
sis of women, adolescents and children in Uganda. Kampala: of households in the provision of pharmaceuticals used by
Government of Uganda & Uganda National Council for Chil- school-age children in western Kenya. In: Geissler PW,
dren. Meinert L (eds). People and medicines in East Africa. Work-
Brinkmann U, Brinkmann A. 1991. Malaria and health in Africa: the shop proceedings, pp. 161–7. Copenhagen: Danish Bilharziasis
present situation and epidemiological trends. Tropical Medicine Laboratory.
and Parasitology 42: 204–13. Maitai CK, Guantai A, Mwangi JM. 1981. Self medication in
Brooker S, Guyatt H, Omumbo J, Shretta R, Snow B. 1999. Situation management of minor health problems in Kenya. East African
analysis of malaria in school-aged children in Africa: disease Medical Journal 58: 593–600.
burden and opportunities for control. Report prepared for the McCombie SC. 1996. Treatment seeking for malaria: a review of
International School Health Initiative of the World Bank, recent research. Social Science & Medicine 43: 933–45.
November. Washington, DC: The World Bank. Meinert L. 1998. Usund viden? Sundhedsundervisning og medicinsk
Bush PJ, Trakas DJ, Sanz EJ, Vaskilampi T, Prout A (eds). 1996. praksis blandt Iteso børn i Uganda. Tidskriftet antropologi 38:
Children, medicines and cultures. New York and London: 65–78.
Haworth Press. Meinert L. 2001. Health communication and competence among
Central Intelligence Agency (CIA). 1999. The world fact book 1999. Iteso schoolchildren in Eastern Uganda (Preliminary title).
Washington, DC: Central Intelligence Agency [www.odci.gov/ PhD Thesis, Institute of Anthropology. Copenhagen: Uni-
cia/publications/factbook]. versity of Copenhagen.
Dengler R, Roberts H. 1996, Adolescents’ use of prescribed drugs Ministry of Education (MOE). 1988. The revised basic science and
and over-the-counter preparations. Journal of Public Health health syllabus for primary schools in Uganda. Kampala:
Medicine 18: 437–42. Ministry of Education.
Foucault M. 1975. The birth of the clinic: an archaeology of medical Ministry of Education (MOE). 1998. Education Statistics Section of
perception. New York: Vintage/Random House. the Planning and Development Department. Nairobi: Ministry
Geissler PW. 1998. “Worms are our life“: understandings of worms of Education.
and the body among the Luo of western Kenya (Part 1 + 2). Ministry of Health (MOH). 1992. Public Health Report for Siaya
Anthropology and Medicine 5: 63–81, 133–44. District. July to December 1992. Nairobi: Government
Geissler PW, Nokes K, Prince RJ, Odhiambo RA, Aagaard-Hansen Publishers.
J, Ouma JH. 2000. Children and medicines: self-treatment of Nichter M. 1989. Education by appropriate analogy. In: Nichter M.
common illnesses among Luo primary schoolchildren in Anthropology and international health. Asian case studies.
western Kenya. Social Science and Medicine 50: 1771–83. Tucson, AZ: Gordon and Breach publishers.
Geissler PW, Harris SA, Prince RJ et al. 2001. Medicinal plants used Parkin D. 1995. Latticed knowledge. Eradication and dispersal of the
by Luo mothers and children in Bondo District, Kenya. In prep- unpalatable in Islam, medicine, and anthropological theory. In:
aration. Fardon R (ed). Counterworks. Managing the diversity of know-
Government of Kenya (GOK). 1996. Kenya Population Census. ledge. London and New York: Routledge, pp.143–63.
Nairobi: Government Printers. Pearce TO. 1993. Lay medical knowledge in an African context. In:
Government of Uganda (GOU), National Curriculum Development Lindenbaum S, Lock M (eds). Knowledge, power, and practice:
05 Geissler (JB/D) 9/11/01 1:10 pm Page 370

370 P Wenzel Geissler et al.

the anthropology of medicine and everyday life. Berkeley: Uni- Whyte (University of Copenhagen) encouraged us. The fieldwork
versity of California Press, pp.150–65. was funded by the Danish Bilharziasis Laboratory (DBL) and the
Prince RJ, Geissler PW, Nokes K et al. 2001. Knowledge of herbal Council for Development Research, Denmark. The study was
and pharmaceutical medicines among Luo schoolchildren in carried out within the framework of the Kenyan-Danish Health
western Kenya. Anthropology and Medicine, in press. Research Project (KEDAHR) and the Tororo Community Health
Prince RJ, Geissler PW. 2001. Becoming ‘one who treats’: a case Project (TORCH), both funded by the Danish International
study of a Luo healer and her grandson in western Kenya. Development Agency (Danida). At the time of the study, PWG was
Anthropology & Education Quarterly, in press. working for DBL in Copenhagen and RP and KN for the Partner-
Scheper-Hughes N. 1992. Death without weeping. The violence of ship for Child Development, University of Oxford. We are grateful
everyday life in Brazil. Berkeley: University of California Press. to our colleagues from the Division of Vector Borne Diseases
Serpell R. 1993. The significance of schooling. Life journeys in an (DVBD), Nairobi and Child Health and Development Centre,
African society. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Kampala for their help.
Sindiga I, Nyaigotti-Chacha C, Kanunah MP (eds). 1995. Traditional
medicine in Africa. Nairobi: East African Educational Publish-
ers. Biographies
Snow RW, Peshu N, Forster D, Mwenesi H, Marsh K. 1992. The role
Paul Wenzel Geissler trained as a biologist and parasitologist. He
of shops in the treatment and prevention of childhood malaria
wrote his PhD at the University of Copenhagen about worm infec-
on the Kenyan coast. Transactions of the Royal Society for
tions and nutrition among primary schoolchildren in western Kenya.
Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 86: 237–9.
He has a second degree in social anthropology from the University
Trakas DJ, Sanz EJ (eds). 1992. Studying childhood and medicine
of Cambridge. He is currently working on a medical anthropology
use: perceptions and attitudes. COMAC workshop on medicines
study, investigating the construction of care among rural and urban
and childhood. Athens: ZHTA.
Luo people in Kenya. As a part which, he is looking at children’s
UNICEF/Government of Uganda (GOU) (undated). School Health
interaction with elderly people and for chronically or terminally ill
Education Programme and Health Education Network. Plans of
family members, and at children’s competence and activity in the
Operation (1985–90 and 1990–95). Kampala: Government of
area of treatment and medicine use.
Uganda.
UNICEF/Government of Uganda (GOU). 1997. Implementing Uni-
Lotte Meinert is a social anthropologist from the Institute of Ethnog-
versal Primary Education (UPE): enrollment and registration.
raphy and Social Anthropology, University of Aarhus. Now based at
Kampala: Government of Uganda.
the Institute of Anthropology, University of Copenhagen and the
Van der Geest S. 1999. Training shopkeepers and schoolchildren in
Danish Bilharziasis Laboratory, she is writing up her PhD research
medicine use: experiments in applied medical anthropology in
on health communication and competence among Iteso school-
East Africa. Medical Anthropology Quarterly 13: 253–55.
children in eastern Uganda. She has undertaken research and pro-
Van der Geest S, Whyte SR (eds). 1989. The context of medicines in
fessional assignments in Uganda within health communication,
developing countries. Amsterdam: Kluver.
children and adolescents since 1994.
Vaughan M. 1991. Curing their ills. Colonial power and African
illness. Cambridge and Oxford: Polity Press.
Ruth Jane Prince is a medical anthropologist. She studied Human
Whelton A. 1995. Renal effects of over-the-counter analgesics.
Sciences at Oxford and Medical Anthropology at University College
Journal of Clinical Pharmacology 35: 454–63.
London and has been working in Kenya for the Partnership for Child
WHO. 1978. Primary health care. Report of the International Confer-
Development at Oxford University and the Danish Bilharziasis
ence on Primary Health Care in Alma-Ata. Geneva: World
Laboratory from 1996–98. Currently, she is studying for a PhD at the
Health Organization.
Institute of Anthropology, University of Copenhagen. The topic of
WHO. 1993. Sex education leads to safer sex. The newsletter of the
her thesis is women’s medical culture, religion and historical change
WHO Global Programme on AIDS 4. Geneva: World Health
among the Luo people in western Kenya.
Organization.
Whyte SR. 1989. The power of medicines in East Africa. In: Van der
Catherine Nokes worked from 1992–98 with the Partnership for
Geest S, Whyte SR (eds). The context of medicines in develop-
Child Development first at Imperial College and later at Oxford Uni-
ing countries. Amsterdam: Kluver, pp.217–33.
versity. Her main research interests include investigation of the
Whyte S. 1991. Medicines and self-help: the privatisation of health
effects of ill-health on mental development and educational achieve-
care in Eastern Uganda. In: Hansen, Twaddle A (eds). Chang-
ment; in particular, the effects of intestinal parasitic infections
ing Uganda. The dilemmas of structural adjustment and revol-
amongst school-age children in developing countries. Related inter-
utionary change. London: James Curry, pp.130–48.
ests include the study of intelligence in relation to context; the design
Whyte SR. 1997. Questioning misfortune. The pragmatics of uncer-
of culturally appropriate tests of cognition and educational achieve-
tainty in Eastern Uganda. Cambridge: Cambridge University
ment; communicating about health to children using pictures and the
Press.
promotion of activity based learning; and the evaluation of rapid
Whyte SR, Birungi H (in press) The business of medicines and the
assessment methods related to the treatment and control of parasitic
politics of knowledge. In: Whiteford LM, Manderson L (eds).
infections.
Globalization, health and identity: the fallacy of the level playing
field. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner.
Jens Aagaard-Hansen is a social anthropologist and medical doctor
Yoder S. 1997. Negotiating relevance: belief, knowledge and practice
(Specialist in General Medicine, DTM, DPH) from the University
in international health projects. Medical Anthropology Quar-
of Copenhagen. He is based at the Danish Bilharziasis Laboratory
terly 11: 131–46.
in Copenhagen, where he has worked in research, supervision,
teaching and consultancies at the interdisciplinary interface. His
Acknowledgements research interests are childhood and health, especially in Eastern
Africa.
We want to thank the children of Bar-Awendo and Majengo
Primary Schools in Kenya and of Asinge, Kwapa and Apuwai Jessica Jitta is Director of the Child Health and Development Centre
Primary Schools in Uganda, as well as their parents and teachers for at Makerere University, Uganda. She is a medical doctor with a
their co-operation. We are indebted to the field assistants Philister specialization in paediatrics and is a Senior Lecturer at Makerere
Adhiambo and Collins Omondi in Kenya and Aja Michaeli, Pius University. She is Chair of the Committee on Health Research under
Emojong and Agnes Akuleut in Uganda. Professor Susan Reynolds the National Council for Science and Technology. Her research
05 Geissler (JB/D) 9/11/01 1:10 pm Page 371

Self-treatment and health education of schoolchildren 371

interests include: nutrition, mothers’ perception and management of in Kenya from the latter. He has conducted research on parasitic dis-
children’s illnesses, and health care systems. eases in East Africa for the past 20 years, and is actively involved in
health policy, including malaria control, in Kenya.
John H Ouma is the Head of the Division of Vector Borne Diseases,
Ministry of Health, Kenya. He was trained as a parasitologist at the Correspondence: P Wenzel Geissler, Institut for Antropologi,
University of Nairobi and the Liverpool School of Tropical Fredriksholms Kanal 4, DK-1220 Copenhagen K, Denmark. Email:
sMedicine, and obtained his PhD with a study on helminth infections wenzel.geissler@anthro.ku.dk

You might also like