Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Springer-Verlag
Berlin Heidelberg NewYorkTokyo 1984
Professor Dr. W. Hartrnut G. Goethe
Scientific Director
Bemhard-Nocht-Institut für Schiffs- und
Tropenkrankheiten, Abt. für Schiffahrtsmedizin,
Bemhard-Nocht-Straße 74,2000 Hamburg 4/FRG
Tbis work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part ofthe material is concerned, spe-
cifically those of translation, reprinting, re-use of illustrations, broadcasting, reproduction by photocopying machine
or similar means, and storage in data banks. Under § 54 ofthe German Copyright Law where copies are made for oth-
er than private use, a fee is payable to 'Verwertungsgesellschaft Wort', Munieh.
Tbe use of registered names, trademarks, ete. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific state-
ment, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use.
Product Liability: Tbe publisher can give no guarantee for information about drug dosage and application thereof
contained in this book. In every individual case the respective user must check its accuracy by consulting other phar-
maceuticalliterature.
2119/3020-543210
Contributors
Anderson, W. R, MD,
Anderson Medical Group, Inc., San Pedro, California 90731, USA
Badehaus, A, Dr. med., OMD,
Port and Airport Health Authorities, Hamburg, FRG
Bäter, H., Dr. med. dent.,
Lauenburg/Elbe, FRG
Ball, Tb.,
Bernhard-Nocht-Institute for Nautical and Tropical Diseases,
Department of Nautical Medicine, Hamburg, FRG
EI Batawi, M. A, Prof. Dr. med.,
Chief Medical Officer, Office of Occupational Medicine, WHO, Geneva,
Switzerland
Boehm, H., Professor, Dr. rer. nat., Dipl.-Psych.,
Nautical School, Bremen, FRG
Cox, RAF., MA, MB, BChir, MFOM,
Medical Director, Phillips Petroleum Company Europe-Africa, London,
UK
Dolmierski, R, Professor, Dr. med.,
Director Institute of Maritime and Tropical Medicine, Gdynia, Poland
Duffy, J. c., Professor Dr.,
Assistant Surgeon General, Office ofthe Surgeon General U.S. Public
Health Service, Rockville, Md, USA
Ebert, H., OMR Doz. Dr. sc. med.,
Medical Service ofthe Transport System ofthe GDR, Rostock, GDR
Gardner, A Ward, MD, FRCPI, FFOM (Ireland), FFOM (London), DIH,
Esso Medical Centre, Fawley, Southampton, UK
Goethe, W. H. G., Professor Dr. med.,
Scientific Director
Bernhard-Nocht-Institute for Nautical and Tropical Diseases,
Department of Nautical Medicine, Hamburg, FRG
Harrington, J. M., Professor, MSc, MD, FRCP, FFOM,
Tbe University of Birmingham, Institute of Occupational Health,
Birmingham, UK
VI Contributors
Herrmann, R, Dipl.-Ing.,
Bernhard-Nocht-Institute for Nautical and Tropical Diseases,
Department of Nautical Medicine, Hamburg, FRG
Huisman, J., Professor Dr. med.,
Chief Department for Communicable Diseases and Hygiene, Municipal
Public Health Service, Rotterdam, Netherlands
Ivergard, T., PhD, ScD,
Scandinavian Airlines System (SAS), Stockholm, Sweden
Jamall, O. A., FRCS (Edin.)
Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon, Dreadnought Seamen's Hospital,
Greenwich, London, UK
The Late D. T.Jones, BSc, MB, BCh, MFCM, DCH Eng, DPH,
formerly Medical Offker of Health, Port and City of London, UK
Low, A., Dr. med.
Bernhard-Nocht-Institute for Nautical and Tropical Diseases,
Department of Nautical Medicine, Hamburg, FRG
Milton-Thompson, G.J., Surgeon Commodore, QHP, FRCP,
Deputy Medical Director General (Naval), Ministry ofDefence, London,
UK
Naeve, W., Professor, Dr. med.,
Forensic Medical Service, Hamburg, FRG
Ohashi, N., Senior Research Fellow,
Maritime Labour Research Institute, Tokyo, Japan
Oliver, P.O., RD, MD, FFOM RCP, DPH, DIH,
Group Medical Director, Cunard Steam-Ship Company, Southampton,
UK
Pettersen, J. W. E., B. Sc. (Eng.)
Principal Research Engineer, Det Norske Veritas, H0Vik, Oslo, Norway
Renfrew, R R, MB, ChB, MFOM,
Medical Officer, Fish Docks Medical Services, Grimsby, UK
Shafran, L., MD, Dr. med. sc.
Branch of the Institute of Watertransport Hygiene, Toxicological
Laboratory, Odessa, USSR
Sobol, Z., Dr. Ing.,
Institute of Maritime and Tropical Medicine, Head of Department of
Transport Hygiene and Environment Protection, Gdynia, Poland
Schadewaldt, H., Professor Dr. med.,
Director of the Institute for History of Medicine of the University of
Düsseldorf, FRG
Stenko, J. M., Professor Dr. med.,
Director Scientific Research Institute of Water Transportation and
Hygiene, Moscow, USSR
Contributors VII
International cooperation on the health of seafarers began many years ago. As early
as 1921, an international convention regarding this matter was presented to govern-
ments of maritime countries for ratification. The First World Health Assembly, in
1948, recommended that WHO should establish, with the International Labour Of-
fice, a Joint Committee on the hygiene of seafarers. The first session of this Com-
mittee, held in 1949, defined the problems affecting the health of seamen and made
a number of recommendations.
In the opinion of this Joint Committee, the health of seamen called for interna-
tional attention for a nu mb er of reasons. By the nature of his work, the seafarer is
obliged to travel from country to country and is exposed to great variations of cli-
mate and also to any disease that may be prevalent in the port of call. He may there-
fore become a carrier of disease, so that the protection of his health is of importance
not only to himself and the other members of the crew but also to the populations of
other countries he visits. Yet, on account ofthe nature ofhis employment, it is diffi-
cult to provide the seafarer with the same standard of health care that is gene rally
available to other sections of the population.
At the time of the opening session of the Joint Committee, the following factors
were of most importance to the seafarer's health: medical examinations, medieine
chests on board, accomodation and food supplies on board, hospital treatment, re-
habilitation and social welfare. The Committee made recommendations aimed at
finding solutions to problems in these areas. Also, proposals were made regarding
the control of tuberculosis and venereal diseases among seamen.
In 1954, the Joint ILO/WHO Committee met for the second time and suggested
the minimal list of medicaments which should be contained in a ship's medicine
chest. It also discussed the model scheme of diagnosis, treatment and other control
procedures in venereal infections, reviewed the diagnostic and therapeutic mea-
sures for these infections in a number of large ports throughout the world and dis-
cussed the medical examinations of seamen to detect tuberculosis.
Ouring the third meeting of the Committee, in 1961, it was realized that it had
been difficult to present adefinite picture of seafarers' health problems as very little
accurate or reliable data had been available. Not all countries were able to give pre-
eise employment statistics regarding seafarers. Even fewer countries were able to
provide an age group structure of their merchant navy personnel. Without such in-
formation, no morbidity study was possible. Also, there was considerable variation
in the problems encountered between various countries owing to different geogra-
phical and soeial conditions.
A further step in expanding the international cooperation on the health of sea-
farers was the WHO International Medical Guidefor Ships. published in 1967.
Following the resolution ofthe World Health Assembly, WHO Pilot Health Cen-
X Foreword
tres for Seafarers were designated in Gdynia, Poland and Auckland; New Zealand
in order to collect international data on morbidity and aceidents among seafarers,
to conduct research related to their health, to provide medical and dental services
for seamen and fishermen and to conduct postgraduate training in maritime medi-
eine. In 1975, the Department ofNautical Medieine, Hamburg, was also designated
byWHO.
The fifth (1973) and sixth (1981) sessions ofthe Joint Committee in Geneva.dealt
with medical and first-aid training for ship personnel, preventive care ofteeth and
mouth and emergency dental faeilities for seamen in ports, medical examination of
crew members of tankers carrying bulk chemicals, existing medical centres for sea-
men, immersion hypothermia, recording of medical examinations and treatment of
seafarers and the updating of the International Medical Guide for Ships. In 1982, in
collaboration with the Centre in Gdynia, this Guide was updated and the new edi-
tion will be published by WHO in 1984.
With developments in the world shipping industry during recent years - the in-
troduction of new types of ships and new technologies - the pattern of the health
problems of seafarers has changed. Infectious diseases have become less important
(in fact, smallpox was completely eradicated from the world in 1976). One of the
new problems has been their exposure to the dangers connected with carrying
chemical cargoes in bulk. This new challenge has been met by experts and by inter-
national organizations. In 1973, the Medical First Aid Guidefor Use in Accidents In-
volving Dangerous Goods was published by IMCO. Other problems inc1ude the ef-
fect of environmental stress on the seafarer's health the psychosoeial aspects of
work on-board ship, the need always to maintain high standards of health on mod-
ern, highly automated ships, on which the number of crew has decreased compared
with standards existing in the 1960s and 1970s, and also the need to introduce the
telemetric system of exchanging health information from ship to shore-based hospi-
tals.
All these and many other problems still need to be studied and answers found
through the combined efforts of shipowners, seafarers, seientists and experts in
maritime medieine.
For all of them, the Handbook of Nautical Medicine will be an excellent source of
up-to-date information on all relevant subjects. It will also provide a source of in-
spiration for further research and efforts to improve the environmental conditions
on board ships which influence the health of seamen and to improve the health ser-
vices provided for them, both at sea and on shore.
The Handbook is an important contribution to international cooperation on the
health of seamen. Experts, invited by the editors and representing a number of well-
known research centres on maritime medicine from eleven countries, have present-
ed here a wide range of subjects c1early and coneisely, indicating appropriate direc-
tions for further research.
Dr. M. A. EI Batawi
Chief Medical Officer
Office of Occupational Health
WHO,Geneva
Preface
Over recent decades the shape ofthe shipping industry has changed considerably in
response to the pressures exerted by changing international patterns oftrade togeth-
er with the swings of fortune in national economies. Many of the traditional mari-
time countries have suffered a decline in their fleets while over the same period
there has been a corresponding increment in those of emerging countries. The
competition for available cargoes in depressed world markets has been intense.
However, the international trade in exports from and imports to countries through-
out the world is stilliargely dependent upon transport by sea. This has been respon-
sible for the continued growth of the shipping industry as a whole, despite the loss
of passengers to air and land travel, which has resulted in the severe decline in the
number of passenger liners. Indeed, it is estimated that there is a total world
strength in excess of 70000 ships registered within the fleets of over 70 maritime
countries.
A direct consequence of heightened competition in international sea trade has
been the impetus given to continuing advances in ship design, technology and cargo
handling. This has led to the development of larger, faster ships manned by fewer
crew and spending much less time in port. In many countries the average cargo ship
carries only 20 crew members and this complement has been reduced still further by
some shipping companies. The advent of container ships and other highly specia-
lised types, such as carriers of bulk chemicals, liquified gas, oil and ore, has brought
additional attendant problems for both seafarers and the occupational doctors con-
cerned with health and welfare.
The unfortunate impact of these commercial changes has been that nowadays,
with the exception of certain eastern European countries, few doctors are carried by
merchant ships and, regrettably, just as few are employed in full-time practice in
maritime organisations and shipping company offices ashore. This is a matter for
continuing concern because, although living standards on ships have improved, it
has yet to be shown that these have produced a commensurate improvement in the
health of crew members. It is quite possible to argue that the reduction of hard
physical work in conjunction with plentiful rich food and cheap tobacco and alco-
hol has had a deleterious effect. Furthermore, the alm ost universal trend towards
single cabins for all crewmembers is not always psychologically beneficial.
It is true that a carefully selected smaller crew should result in a higher average
standard of health on board irrespective of a possible healthier environment. The
drawback is unfortunately that given a smaller crew, there is less reserve to cushion
the effect of interim illness among crew members. Therefore, the pre-employment
medical examination should be made even more stringent to exclude anyone who
has a condition, or pre-condition, which might develop into unfitness for work at
any time in the future. It is alm ost universally agreed that medical examinations of
XII Preface
such crucial importance are best carried out by doctors who have long personal
experience in the industry.
When to all this is added the increase in the number and complexity of dangerous
cargoes, it is seen that the burden of c1inical and preventive medicine which falls
upon the shoulders of the smaller number of nautical medicine specialists is very
great and will remain so in the foreseeable future. Despite all the changes, the sea-
farer is still one of the most medically deprived of workers. Although working in an
industry which is becoming more and more technologically and commercially ad-
vanced, he is still almost totally divorced from any form of fully qualified medical
care during his time at sea, and when he comes ashore he may find it very difficult
to locate a doctor in hospital or general practice who has any knowledge or experi-
ence of nautical medicine.
It is apparent that there is a field of fascinating work for young doctors who
would like to combine medical practice with an opportunity to see more of ships
and the sea but, in view of the smaller number of doctors already in the field, where
can these young doctors, and the doctors ashore who see a seafarer only occasional-
ly, look for information and opinion based upon experience?
We see that as one of the functions of this book. Each of the authors is an expert
in his own field, with long experience of the care of seafarers, and we should like to
express to each of them our grateful thanks for the time they have given from their
already over-busy lives. As appropriate to an industry which enjoys so much inter-
national co-operation in its practices and procedures, the authors have been chosen
to give as much varied national participation as possible. However, it should be ac-
cepted that the individual contributions reflect not only personal concepts of nauti-
cal medicine but also the prevailing practices in the countries of origin. The chap-
ters must be seen as such, with the understanding that both therapy and practice
vary from country to country. In this respect the editors decided to inc1ude at the
end of each chapter a comprehensive list of references greater than usual. It is our
sincere wish that this Handbook will represent not only an up-to-date account of
nautical medicine but also a useful guide to the future reading from international
sources, which is necessary if progress is to be maintained in the development of
this often neglected speciality.
The editing of a book compiled from the work of authors from so many countries
presents inevitable difficulties but none greater that the task of reconciling the dif-
fering versions of the English language which make up the international lingua
franca of today. In this we wish to express our profound gratitude to the copy-edit-
ing staff of the publishers who have assisted us and also to the authors, who have
accepted with goodwill the changes to their original texts.
monthslong, unbroken voyage had to be al- Italian custom to keep the bodies of those
lowed for. When one considers that, on who had died on board in the bilge for later
technical grounds, the size of the ships was burial on land. The now usual burial at sea
usually limited to 300-500 tons, and that was first introduced on English ships and
sufficient water and provisions for the may be principally traced back to consider-
lengthy crossings had to be carried, one can ations of hygiene. It was only when it be-
imagine how excessively cramped it was on came normal to use blocks of iron instead
board. These conditions were for the most of sand for ballast, to wash the bilge out
part to blame for making this period of sea- regularly with seawater, and to provide toi-
faring history the most tragic chapter in lets and ventilation facilities on board that
nautical medicine. this source of many serious diseases was
This era's voyages of exploration, e. g. eliminated.
the discovery of the sea route to India by For the reasons mentioned above, the
Vasco da Gama (1469-1529) in 1498 and numerical size of crews was very large in
the first circumnavigation of the globe un- comparison with that of modern ship, e. g.
der the command of Fernäo de Magalhäes the East India Company's ship "Dragon"
(c. 1480-1521) in the years 1519-1522, of 600 t had 300 people on board. The
claimed many lives. sleeping accommodation was usually par-
In the course of the long voyages - the ticularly bad. Until the year 1772, when the
journey to America by sail could last any- famous world voyager Captain James
thing from 23 days to 23 weeks - the plank- Cook (1728-1779) introduced the three-
ing became porous, especially as the fever- watch system, there were only two watches.
ish shipbuilding activity after the discovery Only enough sleeping space was provided
ofthe New World led to the frequent use of for the men not on duty, in the form of
green, badly seasoned wood. In addition, plank beds that were intended for four
the wood was attacked by the notorious men, but often had to do for six. On slave
shipworm, teredo navalis, which belongs to and convict ships conditions were even
the family Teredinidae. The result was that more catastrophic. The door was open for
below the waterline it was continually the spread of venereal and other infections
damp. In the bilge, the lowest part of the and for homosexual excesses.
ship, water always gathered and mixed The hammock, today a symbol of life at
with the ballast sand to form a sludge. At sea, was a Caribbean gift to the seaman,
that time there were still absolutely no sani- brought back to Europe by Columbus'
tary facilities; in bad weather, leftovers, crew from the West Indies, where the na-
urine and excrement were tossed into the tives wove hamacas (hence the English
bilge, where rats and other vermin pros- name) which could be hung one over the
pered. An infernal stench resulted, and this other and did not let the occupant fall out
putrefying muck was often the source of even with the motion at sea - an ideal form
devastating epidemics. All possible pro- of bed in view of the great shortage of
cesses were used to prevent ships from space. This practical innovation was intro-
leaking - charring the outer surface of the duced into the Royal Navy by Queen Eliz-
hull, treating it with ferrous sulphate, tar- abeth in 1597 and adopted on the warships
ring (still practised today), lining the inner and merchant vessels of all other nations
surface of the hull with a second layer of soon thereafter. There was still only one
wood, pumping out the bilge - but all had hammock for every two men. Anyone who
their dis advantages. Only copper-sheath- wanted one for himself had to get it, and as
ing, introduced in 1758, brought an im- usual, at the evening "Pfeifen und Lunten
provement. aus" (lights out), the seaman's signal to go
For a long time it was the French and to bed, it was the strongest who could get
1.1 The History of Nautical Medicine 5
the best spot by a hatch or a ventilator; and finally, leaky wooden hulls, with all
there are said to have been pitched brawls. their attendant evils, became a thing of the
The third period of seafaring history past.
shows friendlier aspects. In 1777 James However, it soon became unpleasantly
Watt (1736-1819) built the first usable obvious that iron was a good conductor of
steam engine, and 11 years later Patrick heat. In summer the new ships were un-
Miller (1731-1819) and William Syming- bearably hot, particularly in the engine
ton (1763 -1831) constructed the first small room - temperatures of up to 75 oe were
steamboats, long before Robert Fulton's measured on French ships - and in winter
(1765-1815) steamship made her maiden or in the north terribly cold, the steam heat-
voyage on the Hudson. Of course, ship- ing introduced first on German ships prov-
builders and -owners had no great trust in ing insufficient. The result was a conspicu-
the newfangled engine, and for security re- ous increase in colds and chills, to which
tained all the sails and rigging. For this rea- the condensation gathering on the cold
son, the early steamships had even bigger iron must have contributed. This problem
crews. A new category of seaman came into was tackled with cork or wood panelling
existence: the stoker. and absorbent paint. Nowadays the air-
The decisive advantages of mechaniza- conditioning units on merchant vessels and
tion were the shortening of time at sea and warships do not allow such variations in
the relative independence from wind and temperature. The original engines were not
weather. Questions of water and provisions insulated and caused considerable vibra-
no longer took first place, and a replace- tion, thereby greatly increasing the inci-
ment crew was no longer necessary, partic- dence of seasickness.
ularly as medical examination of all new With the introduction of armour-plated
recruits had in the meantime been intro- ships (e. g. the Gloire, 1859), the pattern of
duced in all the navies of the world. New injuries in sea battles changed. Whereas
engineering and sanitary problems arose, sabre slashes, bullet wounds and wood-
however; space had to be made for the en- splinter injuries had previously been in the
gine and the paddle wheels - the propeller forefront, now bums and inhalation of poi-
was not generally introduced until 1847 - sonous fumes became common, in the bat-
and coal and water for the engine had to be tle of Skagerrak accounting for as many as
carried. On top of that there was the over- 25% of all injuries. The installation ofbulk-
whelming heat in the engine room to heads to make the armoured ships not so
combat, which was the cause of many easily sinkable forced changes in the meth-
heatstrokes and was particularly unpleas- ods of ventilation and in the accomodation
ant in the tropics. The stokers' washing fa- of the wounded.
cilities had to be improved, and special at- The sick bay - commonly called the
tention had to be paid to the ventilation "cockpit" in the British navy - was former-
systems. ly accommodated above the waterline in
With the introduction of iron ships, from the bow, often separated only by a sailcloth
about 1840, some problems were solved at curtain from the crew quarters, and was
a stroke, but others were intensified. While naturally very vulnerable in battle. For ex-
it had previously been impossible on tech- ample, in the Russo-Japanese war, a direct
nical grounds to build ships with a dis- hit on a Japanese ship during the battle of
placement of more than 3000 tons, size was Tschuschima (1905) destroyed the only
now no longer limited; this relieved the dressing station and killed both doctors
acute shortage of space, especially on mer- and all the stretcher bearers. Therefore, lat-
chantmen. It became unnecessary to carry er ships were equipped with two or more
ballast, the ships were more manoeuvrable, sick bays under the armoured deck, as far
6 1 Introduction to Nautical Medicine
amidships as possible, in order to prevent a doctor, whose position had by then im-
complete loss of medical facilities. proved to the extent that he no longer had
The great shortening in the duration of to perform the degrading duty hirns elf.
voyages after the opening of the Suez and Midshipmen were also subject to such pun-
Panama canals (1869 and 1914), as weIl as ishment, the only difference being that they
international disease control measures, were beaten with a rope, in which a red
made a decisive contribution to the re duc- cloth was weaved. Also barbaric was the
tion of morbidity and mortality at sea to to- punishment of nailing cut-throats to the
day's levels, not significantly higher than mainmast by their hands. However, the
on land. The effect of the introduction of worst which could happen to a sailor was
steamships can be illustrated by the follow- the infamous keelhauling, which some
ing example: In a 12000-strong French ex- poor souls did not survive. The offender
peditionary force to China in 1859, mortali- was tied to a rope, thrown from the mast,
ty was only half as high among those and dragged under the keel to the other
accommodated on 13 steamships as in side of the ship. This inhuman punishment
those on six sailing ships. was abolished as a result of the influence of
In earlier centuries crews were a mixture the French Revolution and the repeated in-
of all possible positive and negative ele- tervention of many ship's doctors.
ments. Next to adventurers and runaway
adolescents could be found sensitive na- 1.1.2 Hygiene
tures attracted to the seafaring experience.
Emigrants and naturalists, ex-army officers 1.1.2.1 Diet
and revolutionaries filled the ranks of offi- The Barcelona Ordinance (1258) laid down
cers and crew. In England, for example, a victualling scale containing salt, meat,
convicts were pressed into service, prefer- bread, vegetables, oil, wine and water. It is
ring to go to sea rather than spend their therefore reasonable to say that a medi-
lives at forced labour in a quarry. If there aeval seaman in the Mediterranean at that
was a shortage of seamen, the Royal Navy time was probably better fed and quartered
in particular did not shy away from a sort than his 18th Century counterpart.
of slaving expedition, the press-gang How important a complete, well-bal-
rounding up the drinkers from the nearest anced diet was for health at sea is shown by
quayside inns and dragging them on board the prevalence of scurvy although other av-
to serve the king. It is no wonder, then, that itaminoses were also common. During the
iron discipline was needed to keep this Russo-Japanese war, 31 % of the Japanese
motley crowd in check. The infamous cat- sailors suffered from beri-beri. The cases of
0' -nine-tails, consisting of nine finger-thick hemeralopia which occurred on British
knotted thongs or ropes, was no invention ships in 1768 were mostly healed by the ad-
of any writer of sea adventures, but was for dition of mashed carrot to the diet.
centuries a harsh reality. The French navy There were three main reasons for the
was the first to abolish corporal punish- unsatisfactory nature of the supplies taken
ment in 1848, followed in 1850 by Sardinia on board in earlier tim es: the inadequate
and, although not until 1866, by Britain. knowledge of nutritional physiology, the
The ship's doctor had an important role to lack of sufficient me ans of preservation,
play in this punishment; indeed, he often and the uncertain duration of the voyage,
had to carry out the whipping hirns elf, often with no chance of replenishing the
since he could best judge what was reason- provisions en route.
able in each individual case. From 1830 At sea as on land, the greatest worth was
onwards the captain could pass such sen- attached to bread and meat. As only salted
tences only with the consent of the ship's meat and fish could be taken on longer
1.1 The History of Nautical Medicine 7
voyages, they made up the main part of the the coarse material grogram, and hence
daily ration. When captains or unscrupu- acquired the nickname "Old Grog", from
lous shipping agents wanted to spend as which the name of the drink came. His
little as possible, they bought half-rotten or creation has since attained greater popular-
otherwise spoiled meat, the taste being ity. A second modern drink with a naval
disguised by heavy salting. The bread was origin, although the ingredients differ, is
no better. Fresh bread was first baked on the "flip", a mixture ofrum and small beer.
board ship around 1880; before then the The name sterns from the joke that after
men had to be content with the so-called drinking several glasses one could fly over
ship's biscuit, which incidentally was al- the mainmast.
ready known to the ancient Romans, who On English and German ships beer,
called it "panis nauticus". On lengthier which was reputed to have antiscorbutic
voyages the constant wet conditions re- properties, was preferred. In the main,
duced it to crumbs, on which the assorted however, it was small beer, which was con-
vermin on board - worms, cockroaches, sumed on board ship at the rate of 4-51 per
mice, rats - did very weIl, not without leav- crew member per day; French seamen pre-
ing their filth behind. Half-starved sailors ferred to drink between 0.5 and 11 of wine
must have forced down some revolting a day. In all navies a substantial quantity of
meals on long journeys. Besides bread and brandy, rum or arrack, varying from 0.25 to
meat, other provisions carried were oil, 0.51 was consumed daily. There was often a
butter, cheese and pulses. The French and greater supply of alcohol than of drinking
the Spaniards took onions and garlic, to water. The Spanish Armada, for example,
which is attributed the fact that they had a carried 570001 of water, but 820001 of
lower rate of scurvy than English seamen. wine. It was not until 1823 that alcohol at
The Dutch, for their part, placed great val- breakfast was replaced by tea or cocoa in
ue on sauerkraut, which later, on Captain the British navy, and by coffee in the
Cook's advice, was adopted by the British French, although there had been the alter-
as an anti-scurvy measure. native of oat or barley gruel if anyone
Alcohol played a very important part in wanted to forgo his morning beer or wine.
life at sea, and when one considers the sea- The results of this alcohol abuse were in-
man's daily ration, in the form of beer, evitable; whereas among land forces delir-
brandy, rum or wine, one must conclude ium tremens accounted for 2.8%0 of all
that many were drunk every day. This high sickness, in the British navy, even after
consumption is understandable in view of 1830, the figure was 18.1%0.
the continually cold and wet conditions, In the eighteenth century the weekly
and the alcohol was also sometimes in- food ration for a sailor in the Royal Navy,
tended as a safe substitute for contaminat- to give one example, consisted of 2 kg of
ed water. beef, 1 kg of pork, 1.5 kg of peas, 1.5 kg of
The constant drinking on board often oatmeal, 180 g of butter, 360 g of cheese,
led to disputes and violence, the most in- condiments and possibly fish, with 0.5 kg
veterate ruffians eventually being put in of ship's biscuit each day. This made up
irons and making the acquaintance of the about 3700 calories a day, enough for a
cat-o'-nine-tails. For this reason, in 1740 man doing heavy manual work, but lacking
the British admiral Edward Vernon in vegetables. Beginning in 1757, adopting
(1684-1757) ordered the official rum ra- James Lind's suggestions, the meat ration
tion, the "king's allowance" or "necessity", was cut, and cabbage, cucumber, and occa-
to be mixed with three parts of water and sionally fruit and vinegar were added to the
have sugar added. The admiral, little liked diet. In very rough weather cooking was
for this order, always wore a jacket made of sometimes impossible, so the crew had to
8 1 Introduction to Nautical Medicine
eat their rations raw and cold. From these bad, became c1oudy, tasted revolting, and
times comes the well-known sailor's meal caused many infections. Strangely, this dis-
Labskaus (the name sterns from Norwe- gusting liquid often c1eared and tasted rela-
gian), in which for simplicity the meat, fish, tively good after about 3 weeks at sea. Now
peas, carrots, cucumbers and condiments we know that the acid sulphur salts in the
were cooked together in one pot, originallY water were reduced by organic compounds
with flour, later with potatoes. Even with in the wood to hydrogen sulphide, which,
the ship pitching and rolling, the ship's along with the putrefactive bacteria, was
cook could still just manage. then used by the flourishing algae which
The food available became more varied gathered at the bottom of the barrel, with
thanks to the preserving methods invented the result that the water became c1ear
by the Swiss-French cook Nicolas Appert again. For many years there was truth in
(c. 1750-1841) in 1806. They were tested by the old sailor's rule that water must be al-
the French navy in the same year, and from lowed to go bad three times before it could
1830 onwards the use of preserved food- be drunk with impunity. The countermea-
stuffs was widespread at sea. Dried carrots, sures recommended were sulphurization of
dried potatoes, and vegetable me al were the barrels and charring and painting of the
first used in 1850, Liebig's meat extract in inside surface. Beginning in 1800, deodor-
1865, and in 1866 condensed milk was in- izing with charcoal and powdered lime and
troduced for infants on passenger ships. filtration assumed prominence. In 1815
"Portable soups", blocks of compressed iron water tanks were introduced, eliminat-
soup ingredients and flour, had been ing many problems.
known as early as 1757 and were taken by The water ration was very low, only
Captain Cook on his voyages. From 1853 0.25-0.5litre per day, and had to do for
onwards there were "cereal stones" with was hing (inc1uding c1othing) as weIl as
beer wort, from which a tasty beer substi- drinking. Even in the tropics it was raised
tute could be made. to only a litre or so. According to modem
The development of refrigeration units calculations one should allow at least
ended centuries of problems for captain, 5-6Iitres.
ship's doctor and cook. Any kind of food Naturally, the attempts to gain drinking
could now be taken to any part of the water during the voyage began very early.
world, and the reduction in time needed for The most primitive method was the coIlec-
any given voyage has also helped to ensure tion of rainwater in large sails, an inade-
that in modem times food on board ship quate process in areas of low rainfall. The
hardly ever runs short. What in earlier disgusting taste was improved by the im-
times was at best possible only for mon- mersion in the water of glowing-hot iron
archs and the nobility, namely to have fresh rods.
fish or poultry available at sea, is today tak- Another method, appropriate for arctic
en for granted by every passenger on a lin- and antarctic regions, was the melting of
er. ice, first reported in 1671. Captain Cook
supplied a great proportion of his water
1.1.2.2 Water Supply needs in this way. Icebergs were preferred
The supply of drinking water without as the source. Cook observed the very fre-
doubt posed a greater problem than the quent occurrence of sore throat after con-
transport of food. The Greeks and Romans sumption of such water, and from a mod-
carried their modest stock of water in em viewpoint these may have been the first
goatskins or leather bags. Later, larger epidemics of Pfeiffer's glandular fever de-
wooden barrels came into use, but again scribed at sea.
and again it was found that the water went The greatest significance was attached to
1.1 The History of Nautical Medieine 9
attempts to obtain fresh water from seawa- One further point worth mentioning is
ter. The first attempted distillation is attri- that seawater was long held to be unsuit-
buted in legend to Saint Basil (born c. 330), able for putting out fires; the urine of the
who was cast away on an island after a crew was therefore collected in large casks
shipwreck. He is said to have boiled seawa- for this purpose.
ter and caught the steam in sponges, there-
by saving hirns elf from death by thirst. 1.1.2.3 Ventilation
The world has Andres a Laguna On Greek and Roman, and later on Vene-
(1499-1560), personal physician to Emper- tian and Genoese, galleys ventilation was
or Charles V (1519-1566), to thank for the no problem. The vessels were mostly open
rediscovery of this process. Other experi- or had a 'tween deck which let in sufficient
menters attempted distillation with the ad- air. It was first around 1500, with the con-
dition of chemicals, Sir Richard Hawkins, struction of more decks, the larger crews,
for one, in 1588, with lunar caustic, lime and the building in of gun ports, that artifi-
and boneblack, and Hauton in 1670 with cial ventilation of the lower decks became
alkalis. In 1717 Hubert Gautier (1660- necessary. Around the middle of the nine-
1737) constructed a distillation apparatus, teenth century the arrangement of bulk-
but it was unusable in heavy seas because heads on armour-plated ships placed fur-
the newly won fresh water then got mixed ther demands on the ventilation system. In
with the remaining seawater again. Many World War I it was shown how crucial this
others occupied themselves with this prob- problem was for the crew members in the
lem until around 1770, when both Lind and armoured turrets, many of whom died not
Pierre Poissonnier (1720-1798) constructed after a direct hit, but as a result of inhaling
workable devices and the dispute over who poisonous fumes. The lower parts of the
had been first attracted public interest. Al- ship, especially the bilge, were very unheal-
though Lind was the first who strove to ma- thy. The English surgeon Tobias Smollett
nage without the addition of chemicals, (1721-1771) describes the conditions as
Poissonnier's apparatus was undoubtedly they then were:
more practical. Quite wrongly, the ship's
We descended by divers ladders to aspace as
doctor George James Irvine (1722-1798) dark as a dungeon, which I understood was im-
was credited with invention of the seawater mersed several feet under water, being immediately
distillation process, and in 1772 he received above the hold: I had no sooner approached this
a prize which had been put up by the Brit- dismal gulph, than my nose was saluted with an in-
tolerable stench ofputrified cheese, and raneid but-
ish Parliament. ter, that issued from an apartment at the foot ofthe
In 1817, Balthasar Sage (1740-1824) ladder, resembling a chandler's shop, ...
claimed that distilled water was harmful,
but the untenability of this theory was Around the same time, in 1748, carpen-
proved by an experiment in which 60 slaves ters working on bilge pumps are known to
were put on a small island without natural have asphyxiated, and they were certainly
water and given only distilled water to not the only victims.
drink. Sage was not altogether wrong, how- The oldest kind of ventilator was the
ever, in that on French ships the distilled wind sail. An improvement on this was the
water flowed through lead pipes, often wind tube, through which the air could
leading to lead colic, the so-called coliques travel to the lower decks. Such systems
seches des pays chauds. The cause was first were of course useless when there was no
recognized in 1837 by Alexandre Segond wind. The first attempts at artificial ventila-
(1799-1841). The problem did not arise on tion go back to the first half of the eigh-
English ships, as the receptacles and pipes teenth century. In 1734, Jean Theophile
contained hardly any lead. Desaguliers built a machine that worked
10 1 Introduction to Nautical Medicine
on the principle of the fan. The man who Things were just as bad with the heating.
operated the machine became known as On wooden ships there was always the
the ventilator, a name later transferred to danger of fire, one of the reasons why
the machine itself. In 1741, Stephen Haies chewing tobacco so quickly gained popu-
(1677-1761) suggested a system based on larity among sailors. Even on whaling ships
the principle of the bellows, the bad air be- the men tried to warm themselves only in a
ing pumped out of the room through one makeshift way, using red-hot cannonballs.
tube, fresh air in through another. A small The first iron stoves were used on Captain
respirator, two "ass's ears" which the sea- Cook's expeditions, but served mainly to
man working in the bilge could put on, was dry out the eternally wet bilge. It is no won-
made on the same principle, but had hardly der that "heating from inside" with strong
any practical significance. Around 1745, alcoholic drinks was so popular. Often the
Samuel Sutton constructed a ventilation flint and tinder or the pinewood kindling
system of tubes connected to the fireplace needed for starting the fires were soaked
in the ship's galley. The hot air was sup- through, and the cook anxiously watched
posed to draw off the unhealthy vapours, over the only fire on board. The honour of
but the system could not be used in heavy having introduced steam heating - an obvi-
seas, when all doors, companionways and ous development on steam-powered ships
portholes were closed and the fire had to - belongs to the navy ofthe North German
be put out. Finally, no further attempts Confederation. The first trials began in
were made, not least out of fear of the scor- 1856, and the method was later adopted by
butic sea air, until the coming of steam all navies.
power enabled the technical solution of the Lighting was for long a problem as weil.
problem (which will not be discussed here). The crew tried in a rough and ready way to
light the nearly always dark living quarters
1.1.2.4 Cleanliness, Heating and Lighting with wretched little oil lamps, but these
In contrast to modern warships or mer- naturally went out in heavy seas. Their
chant vessels, which the visitor always place was later taken by stearin candles. It
finds spick-and-span, the cleanliness on was a great step forward when in 1822, on
earlier ships left a lot to be desired. To the French ship of the line "Jean Bart",
blame were the crowded conditions on portholes were first added to the gun ports,
board and the scarcity of fresh water. Until which were closed in bad weather. This
the Age of Enlightenment the captain and meant that some light entered the lower
officers did not bother themselves with decks the whole day long, regardless of the
these problems; they hardly took the trou- weather. The introduction of electric light-
ble to go from their cabins on the upper ing solved all the problems at a stroke.
deck to the crew's dark, cramped, stifling
quarters. Soap was unknown on board ship 1.1.2.5 Clothing
until 1787, when Sir Gilbert Blane Whereas land troops started wearing uni-
(1749-1834) introduced it into the British forms in the time of Gustavus 11 Adolph of
navy, each man getting half apound of soft Sweden (1594-1632), this was not normal
soap a week. The fresh water was still re- among navies until much later. Everyone
served for drinking, and as before, the knew all the others on board, and direct
crew's ragged clothes were changed only contact with the enemy through boarding
when they were nearly falling off. The became ever rarer. The crew wore what
upper deck was washed regularly with salt they liked or what they had. Often enough
water; the lower decks, which dried badly, they were quite inadequately equipped, or
hardly ever. At most, juniper or pine had squandered their hiring-on fee in tav-
branches were burnt in the bilge. erns ashore and couldn't afford a change of
1.1 The History of Nautical Medicine 11
clothes. Occasionally a captain would de- In many navies the staff of Aesculapius
mand that his crew should have some kind has become the specific emblem of the
ofuniform, but more than likely this was to ship's doctor. The practical-minded Ameri-
avoid having unsuitably dressed men beg- cans replaced the staff (which in Prussia
ging for warmer clothes on the high seas was conferred on naval doctors in 1868)
and for preventing desertion. with the letters MD (medicinae doctor) and
The first uniform regulation for offkers, later with an oak leaf. Peru (and the Ameri-
however, came from King James I can army) chose the staff of Hermes (the
(1566-1625) in 1603, and with time this be- so-called caduceus, or kerykeion), mistak-
came the rule. The traditional blue of navi- ing its significance. The Brazilian navy uses
es throughout the world is supposed to the stethoscope as emblem for its doctors.
trace its origin to the Duke ofBedford, who Many countries, Great Britain and France
at the British court in 1746 wore a blue among them, now prefer to use a particular
jacket which pleased the king so much that colour, especially green or crimson, as a
he determined to introduce it for his valued background for the insignia of rank.
naval officers. BIue had already been made
the colour for medical offkers, at least on 1.1.3 Quarantine
land, under the prince elector Georg Wil-
helm of Brandenburg (1595-1640) in 1631. The history of quarantine begins in the
In 1748 blue uniforms were officially pre- fourteenth century in Venice. As early as
scribed for officers in the British navy, but 1348 there were "health inspectors", whose
the ship's doctors continued to wear civil- duty it was to visit suspected ships and en-
ian clothes. It was in the French navy in force any disinfection measures that were
1767 that the doctors first got colourful un- necessary, and then in 1374 the harbour
iforms; the blue first appeared in 1798, dur- was closed to ships from plague areas. The
ing the French Revolution. In the mean- period of quarantine was at first only
time, in 1776, the American navy had 10 days, but was soon increased to 30, as in
introduced uniforms for its ship's doctors, Ragusa in 1377, and then to 40 (hence the
although this measure seems not to have name), as in Marseille in 1383. The term of
been popular, as a special decree made fail- 40 days "quaranta dies" was not chosen ar-
ure to wear the uniform punishable by dis- bitrarily, but represented the long-estab-
missal. The German navy furnished its lished boundary between acute and chron-
doctors with uniforms on the English pat- ic illnesses. Since the infectious diseases
tern in 1849, 1 year after it was founded. were all considered acute, 40 days would
Nevertheless, even the doctors with offi- always suffice.
cer's rank were differentiated from other The first isolation ward, enabling better
porte-epee officers, the absence of the supervision, was built on an island off Ven-
sword-knot being a clear indication of their ice in 1403, followed in 1450 by similar in-
lower position. Among the crew it had be- stitutions in Zara and Ragusa. The second
come an established nautical custom to significant Mediterranean sea power, Ge-
wear a wide collar, still today called the sai- noa, followed suit in 1467. From 1665 on-
lor's collar, to protect their oiled pigtails. wards, ships' "health certificates" served to
Almost all navies adopted the collar as it alleviate the problems incurred by the
was in the British navy at the time of the growth in sea traffic; the penalty for falsifi-
Napoleonic Wars, the black or deep-blue cation was death. Contaminated ships had
ground representing the death of Nelson to be either completely fumigated or sim-
and the three white stripes standing for his ply burnt.
three naval victories at St. Vincent, Aboukir Various international conferences, the
and Trafalgar. first in 1838 and one of the last in 1920,
12 1 Introduction to Nautical Medicine
have laid down details of length and type 600 of the 2300 men under his command in
of quarantine. Nowadays, radio communi- 1585, and a few years later, in 1589, the sto-
cation enables rapid c1earance on board by ry was repeated, probably as a result of
virtue of its rapid transmission of compre- scurvy; this time half of the 1200 men died
hensive information on epidemics all over and hardly a quarter were fit for duty. Of
the world, but passengers and crew on a the 680 men under Sir James Lancaster
ship flying the yellow flag still may go (died 1618) on his voyage to the East Indies
ashore only when c1eared by the port medi- in 1600, 180 were dead before the begin-
cal officer. ning of the return trip and half did not see
England again. Particularly tragie was the
1.1.4 Diseases at Sea fate of the English ship "Gloucester",
whieh in 1617 lost 626 of its 961 men! Espe-
An example of an early provision made for cially high losses were suffered aboard ves-
siek seafarers is contained in the Judg- sels in the yellow fever areas ofWest Africa
ments of Oleron (c. 1194) upon whieh code and Central America, sometimes the entire
northern European maritime law was crew, inc1uding the doctor, dying and hav-
founded. The Judgments stipulated that if ing to be replaced. Sometimes the insidious
a sick sailor had to be put ashore the Mas- disease would first manifest itself at sea,
ter must provide lodgings, light, rations leading in southern waters and in the
and either engage a nurse or put a ship's cramped conditions on board the wo oden
servant ashore to attend hirn. ships - ideal breeding conditions for
During the long voyages by sail in the fif- Stegomyia - to devastating epidemies. No
teenth to nineteenth centuries, diseases of- wonder serious researchers assurne that
ten occurred at sea which were only seI dom sailing vessels whose crews were dead
observed in the ship's country of origin, could have been the model for the legend
such as scurvy or the various tropieal dis- of the Flying Dutchman.
eases, and obviously seasiekness was seen However, two examples can be brought
only on board ship. Other typieal condi- to show that even in those times, suitable
tions inc1uded the occupational diseases means were sometimes used to combat this
contracted while the seamen worked in the extremely high mortality. In 1759, Admiral
rigging, or later in the engine-room, and all Edward Hawke (1705-1787) of England
sorts of injuries and bums from engage- led a fleet of 14000 men so successfully
ments with the enemy. Without doubt, tu- that only 20 men had to be disembarked,
berculosis, various skin conditions and although some of the ships had crews 700
venereal infections also played a special or 800 strong. His squadron was always fol-
role, although they could not be said to be lowed by a tender carrying fresh provi-
typieal seamen's diseases. sions, and on the one occasion when
The surviving statisties on morbidity and bad weather prevented the tender from
mortality on board ship are shocking, sailing the number of cases of illness rose
showing that contemporary voyagers' re- sharply.
ports were not exaggerated and that up to Even more impressive are the figures
the nineteenth century more seamen died from Captain Cook's round-the-world ex-
as a result of illness than from wounds re- peditions. He personally took charge of the
ceived in hostilities. Vasco da Gama's crew medical care, rations, and general hygiene
was not the only one to suffer catastrophie on the ships in his command. On his first
losses. For example, in 1506 a Spanish ves- voyage to the Pacific (1768) 23 of the 85
seI lost 123 of its approximately 360 men crew members on the flagship died, but on
within 2 months, mostly to malaria. Sir the second (1772-1775) it was only four of
Francis Drake (c. 1540-1596) lost almost 81 men during a journey of 6000 nautieal
1.1 The History of Nautical Medicine 13
miles. Three perished in accidents, leaving The improvement in medical care also
only one single victim of illness. affected the treatment of injuries sustained
The British navy was very early in keep- in battle, but the new, long-range, large-cal-
ing precise records of deaths, from which ibre guns caused much greater devastation
we leam that in the years 1780-1783, dur- than the old direct rain of cannonballs.
ing the sea fighting in the West Indies, 1148 Shrapnel wounds from explosive shells in-
of the 21608 men were lost in engagements creased dramatically, and bums and smoke
with the enemy, but 3200 - weIl over twice inhalation were common. Some British sta-
as many - as a result of illness. Thanks to tistics also speak eloquently here (see
the endeavours of Lind, Blane and Trotter, Table 1).
the three most important British ship's doc-
tors, mortality had decreased markedly by 1.1.4.1 Scurvy
the turn of the century. In 1760 the rate was In ancient times scurvy was hardly known;
still as high as 125%0, but by 1810 it had for example, Homer's Odyssey, the greatest
sunk to 50%0-40%0, and by 1878 to 6.7%0. sea epic in the history ofliterature, contains
However, this was still high er than the re- no mention of it. The first reports come
markably low German rate of 3%0, which from the distant north in the tenth century.
did not go up even in World War 11, when Indeed, the name itself (old German Schar-
the figure was only 2.55%0, compared with bock, Latin scorbutus) is said by some to
the 2.38%0 who died through enemy ac- come from the old Norse skyrbjur
tion. The relationship had therefore und er- (skyr = sour milk, bjur = oedema), though
gone a fundamental change, particularly according to others it can be traced back to
impressive evidence of the work of ship's the Slavonic scorb (disease). In any case,
doctors. Losses in the merchant marine at the long-used specialist term "morbus sax-
this time were still at the much higher level onicus" indicates a northem origin. The
of 10%0. Notifications of ilIness and sick- disease was certainly known to the Norse-
bay admissions also decreased. In 1779, men who around the year 1 000 crossed to
24266 of the 70000 members of the Royal Greenland and Iceland. There are reports
Navy, i. e. one in three, were sent to the sick of high-ranking people, e. g. abishop, who
bay, but in 1810 it was only 9965 of 145 000, to everybody's astonishment lost their teeth
a ratio of 1: 14. early in life. The oft-mentioned swelling of
The statistics that Lind gave in 1760 for the legs raises the possibility of the concur-
the British naval hospital Haslar, where he rent appearance of beri-beri, and purpura
was in charge, mayaiso be interesting. was frequently described. On the crusade
Over a 2-year period, the 5743 patients ad- led by Louis IX of France (1226-1270) in
mitted included those with the following the year 1250, scurvy appeared in the
diagnoses: south.
The disease first became of crucial im-
Fever 2174 portance at sea after the discovery of A-
Scurvy 1146 merica. True, it had affected the crew ofthe
Consumption 360 Venetian merchant Pedro Quirino when
Rheumatism 350 their galleon was stranded in the waters be-
Dysentery and other fluxes 245 tween Norway and Iceland, but it was the
Complaints of old injuries 80 account of Vasco da Gama's 1497-1498
Cutaneous diseases 73 voyage to the East Indies by the Portuguese
Ague or intermittent fever (malaria?) 67 poet Luis Vaz de Camöes (1524-1580), the
epic poem entitled "Os Lusiadas", describ-
No other condition formed a significant ing the explorer's experiences, which pre-
proportion of the total. sented the horrors of this new disease to a
14 1 Introduction to Nautical Medicine
wider public. Before then the only people were proposed to explain the origin of this
on land acquainted with scurvy were the disease, which appeared infectious but
inhabitants of besieged cities. could be quickly and certainly cured when
A second catastrophe of similar propor- the patient was back on land. Without
tions was described by Jacques Cartier doubt, scurvy was often mistaken for the
(1491-1557), who on the way to New- lues, rheumatism or gout, or, under the
foundland had to spend the winter name of "purpura nautica", confused with
1535-1536 on his ship in the St. Lawrence infectious exanthemas. Felix Platter
River. Only three of the 110 members of his (1536-1614) was convinced in 1608 that
crew remained healthy, and 25 died. Most scurvy had been brought back from Ameri-
of those on board, probably mi sied by the ca along with the lues. Around 1650, the
ecchymoses, were convinced that the dis- doctor Abraham Leonard Vrolingh re-
ease was a kind of plague. After unsuccess- garded it as a "disease of decay" and pre-
fully trying every possible remedy, they fol- scribed preparations against mould. Steven
lowed the advice of the local Indians and Blankaart (1650-1704) set against this the-
ate the ti ps of the needles of the thuja tree, ory the hypothesis of the thickening of the
with the result that many recovered. The blood through acids, sugar and cold, and
tree became known as the arbor vitae, and discarded lemon juice in favour of alkali,
the needle tips of pine trees formed apart coffee and tea. In 1675 Verbrugge believed
of the treatment of scurvy for centuries that the purpura could be re1ieved by the
thereafter. sinking of the thick humours of the blood
In 1541, Johannes Echt (born before and prescribed fresh vegetables. Cornelis
1515) gave what is said to be the first scien- Bontekoe (1640-1685) attributed a great
tific description of scurvy in his book "Oe range of diseases to scurvy, including can-
scorbuto vel scorbutica passione Epitome". cer. Many authors suspected a dyscrasia of
He considered the malady to be infectious the humours (to take one example from as
and based on tainted blood, in his time a late as 1789 William Cullen (1710-1790)
natural conclusion. assumed a dissolution of the humours),
In 1564 followed the Outch doctor Bou- and climatic influences, the cold wet condi-
dewjn Ronsse's (1525-1597) volume "Oe tions on board and the unseasoned wood
magnis Hippocratis lienibus Pliniique from which the ships were constructed
stomacace ac sceletyrbe, seu vulgo dicto were all blamed. Oue attention was first
scorbuto libellus", regarded for many years paid to nutrition in the nineteenth century,
as the standard work. Ronsse traced the ill- and even then the treatments proposed
ness back to the turbulent, cold sea air, and were as numerous as the theories men-
was repeatedly cited by serious doctors tioned above. Salt and salt meat were given
when they wanted to prove the damaging preference, but other suggestions included
potential of artificial ventilation. alkalis or acids, particularly dilute phos-
Over the years, the most varied theories phoric acid, and electuaries and distilla-
1.1 The History of Nautical Medicine 15
tions of the most varied materials - Bonte- thern Europe from 1290 onwards, but the
koe, for instance, created an "elixier antis- knowledge of their antiscorbutic properties
corbuticum" out of cinnamon, cloves, must have been lost. In 1564, the same year
orange peel and oil of vitriol. in which Ronsse's work appeared, this
The beneficial effect of fresh vegetables knowledge was accidentally rediscovered
was recognized at an early stage through by shipwrecked Dutch sailors. They drifted
practical experience. Around 1560, the on the ocean, scurvy began to spread; the
doctor Franz Joel I (1508-1579), from provisions were exhausted, and in despera-
Greifswald, learned from sailors that wa- tion they ate the oranges which had been
tercress (Nasturtium officinale) was an an- taken on board only as delicacies. To every-
tiscorbutic. In northern regions a big role one's great surprise, the scurvy sufferers re-
was played by the spoonwort (Cochlearia), covered. Ronsse made ineidental mention
also referred to as scurvy grass, which may ofthe favourable effect of oranges, and one
have saved the lives of some very ill people. may assume that, direct1y or indirect1y, he
Horseradish and mustard grass were wide- had come to know of this involuntary
ly used, and later Pierre Seignette (1660 experiment. This knowledge was never
-1719) discovered the antiscorbutic prop- completely lost, but not even the recom-
erty of mustard during a siege. Pine beer, mendations of such learned men as Felix
prepared from needles and cones, was very Platter (1536-1614), John Woodall
popular for this kind of illness. The advice (1556-1643) and Thomas Sydenham
to bury scurvy sufferers up to the neck in (1624-1689) led to the stocking of this sim-
the ground for one day after coming ashore ple remedy on board all ships. Thousands
is an interesting curiosity. More sensible upon thousands of seamen died wretched-
was the 1844 recommendation for the pat- Iy of scurvy over the next 200 years before
ients to eat potatoes. Sauerkraut and eider, this policy was generally adopted.
pomegranate and chicken broth were all A few progressive ship's captains used
prescribed. The evidence of the antiscor- this knowledge; for instance, we learn that
butic effect of a seawater cure must have on the flagship of Admiral Sir James Lan-
led Czar Peter the Great (1672-1725) to caster's expedition in 1601 three teaspoons
recommend that his seamen's children of lemon juice formed part of the daily ra-
should regularly drink salt water. tion. The result was that hardly anyone
Astrange but successful treatment was contracted scurvy, whereas the crews of the
that used by travellers to Greenland who other ships in the fleet suffered terribly.
were trapped in the ice by the Arctic win- It was James Lind's brilliant experiments
ter; they drank the fresh blood of whales on board the "Salisbury" in the year 1747
and seals. This idea was taken up in the which ushered in the new era of the battle
scientific literature in 1683, C. Dellon against scurvy. Probably for the first time in
(1649-1709) recommending guinea pig medical history he used a control group, in
blood as an antiscorbutic. In 1696, Archi- that he gave his preparation (al ready estab-
bald Pittcairne (1652-1713) advised against lished as effective) to one part of the crew
the then usual blood-letting, suggesting in but not to the other members living und er
contrast transfusions of animal blood. the same conditions. In a preliminary
The causal therapy, intake of fresh experiment he tested all possible antiscor-
orange or lemon juice, may have been butics recommended in his day on groups
known very early. At any rate, it was de- of two; only lemon juice and, to a minor
scribed around 1450 in "Tractatus de li- degree, cider were found effective. In the
monibus", a translation by Andrea Alpago main experiment the treated crew members
of the work of Ibn-al-Baitär (1197-1248). remained scurvy free; the untreated were
Oranges and lemons were known in nor- affected and could quickly be cured with
16 1 Introduction to Nautical Medicine
small amounts of lemon juice. Lind sum- phylactic, only two cases were recorded
marized his experience in "A Treatise of during the entire period from 1806 to 1810.
the Scurvy" (1753). Blane could rightly say to the Admiralty:
At that time lemons were naturally very "Fifty oranges or limes mean one sailor
expensive, and on long voyages with large more".
crews sufficient stocks took up a lot of One more example of the paramount im-
space. Attempts were therefore made to re- portance of lemon juice in the prevention
place lemon juice with the cheaper but of scurvy is provided by the Arctic expedi-
equally effective lime juice. Only after a tion of 1850-1853. When after 2years the
long time, however, was it recognized that lemon juice ran out, more than 80% of the
lime juice, in contrast to lemon juice, loses crew got scurvy. The ship's surgeon, Alex-
its antiscorbutic properties very quickly in ander Armstrong (1818-1899), carried out
storage. Efforts were then made to prepare what was probably the very first autopsy
the lemon juice on land by adding sugar ever on board ship, on the body of one of
and boiling it down. Although Jacob Za- the victims, without contributing much to
halon (1630-1693) had already established the c1arification of the pathology of the dis-
in 1683 that boiling decreased the antiscor- ease.
butic properties of fresh juices and veg-
etables, it was not until 1785 that Blane 1.1.4.2 Tropical Diseases
won recognition for this fact. Under his in- Seafarers were the first to come into con-
fluence, the use oflemonjuice and the car- tact with the tropical diseases of the New
rying of fresh fruit was obligatory in the World, so it is not surprising that ship's
navy from 1795 onwards. Unfortunately it doctors wrote most of the early books on
did not become compulsary in the mer- the subject. One can say without exaggera-
chant marine unti11865. Captain Cook had tion that tropical medicine originated in
not believed in the effect of lemon juice be- nautical medicine. Until weIl into the nine-
cause he had boiled it. In the French navy teenth century, most colonial doctors were
the giving out of lemon juice was first offi- from the navy.
cially introduced in 1856, and in the Ger-
man navy the first regulations on the sub- Yellow Fever
ject date from 1855, although the food on One of the unwelcome gifts from the newly
German warships was previously very var- discovered continents was yellow fever,
ied and scurvy was rare. Unfortunate1y it which had travelled from West Mrica and
was believed, under the influence of Trot- the Congo, particularly to the West Indies,
ter, that lemon juice could be replaced by where it spread widely and for centuries in-
citric acid, an error that was only c1eared fected whole fleets. By the middle of the
up in 1928 with the discovery ofvitamin C. nineteenth century there were over 150 dif-
The introduction of lemon juice as a ferent names for the disease. Whether the
remedy, and a little later as a prophylactic, weIl-known term "ship's typhus" meant ty-
had undreamed-of results. Whereas scurvy phoid or yellow fever cannot now be deter-
had previously crippled whole fleets - for mined with any certainty. What is beyond
example the Spanish Armada in 1588 - it doubt is that many varied diseases were
was now hardly significant. According to confused with yellow fever, e.g. malignant
Admiral Sir Richard Hawkins (1562-1622), malaria, blackwater fever and hepatic am-
at least 10000 men died of scurvy in his oebiasis. In 1847, an official edict laid
10years of office, and even in the year down for the British navy the choice be-
1780, 1457 scurvy sufferers lay in the Brit- tween only three terms instead of this great
ish naval hospital Haslar. However, after variety: febris intermittens (malaria), febris
the introduction of lemon juice as a pro- remittens (malaria or typhus, phlebotomus
1.1 The History of Nautical Medicine 17
fever, etc.) and febris maligna (yellow northem latitudes, where every epidemie
fever). For more than a century yellow vanished instantly.
fever was held not to be infectious, because With the advent of iron ships the gnats
there was no further spread when the ships were largely robbed of their breeding
retumed to northem waters. It could not be ground, and today the use of preventive
known that the disease-carrying gnats vaccination means that the disease presents
needed a certain ambient temperature to be no great problems at sea.
able to develop. As late as 1829, two British
ship's doctors thought they had proved that Malaria
yeHow fever was non-infectious by me ans The English naval doctors Lind and Blane
of an heroie experiment on themselves; recognized that malaria rarely occurred at
they drank the vomited bile of a patient more than a certain distance from land,
and scratched it into their skin, without be- and suggested that ships in hazardous re-
coming ill. A similar experiment had been gions should not berth in harbour, but
carried out by several French ship's doctors should lay anchor in the roads before sun-
some years previously. set. On the same grounds it was recom-
The statistics spoke clearly against this mended not to set up hospitals on land in
view. In 1585, Drake lost 750 of his the tropics, but to accommodate the siek on
2300 men to yeHow fever alone, and his hospital ships. These suggestions were still
own death (1596) was a result of the dis- followed by the Allies in 1943 during the
ease. In Santo Domingo, 208 of 300 doc- building of bases in the Pacific; every eve-
tors died in 1802, and the mortality of the ning the construction workers were
ship's doctors in these waters stood at over shipped a few miles out to sea. Hardly any-
60%. Crews frequently had to be complete- one fell victim to malaria.
ly replaced within 3 months. On the west Cinchona bark was not to be found in
co ast of Mrica, where the slave trade flour- most ships' medicine chests for many years
ished, an average of a third of the white after it was known on land. It was first
crew members fell victim to yellow fever. around 1780 that it was administered in
As late as 1845 the ship "Eclair" lost 74 of wine. In 1803, Lord Nelson (1758-1805)
120 men within a short time in this area. ordered all ships in his Mediterranean fleet
The English marine doctor James to carry cinchona bark.
L.Donnet (1817-1905) differentiated yel-
low fever clearly from malaria, but it was 1.1.4.3 Other Diseases
not until 1881-1901 that Carlos Finlay Among other infectious diseases, plague
(1833-1915) and Walter Reed (1851-1902) played an important role in earlier centu-
clarified the transmission by Stegomyia ries and, as mentioned above, was the main
calopus. Only then was it possible to build reason for one of the most significant hy-
the Panama Canal (1910-1914), as the giene measures, quarantine. Probably less
region was plague ridden with yellow well-known is the fact that Indian coal-
fever. trimmers very sei dom contracted plague,
There was no effective therapy for yel- because they rubbed their bodies with oil
low fever. From time to time it was as- to protect themselves from the heat and
sumed that the harmful matter must come sun, a practice which largely kept the rat
from the bilges, so these were fumigated fleas away.
and disinfected as weH as possible. Some It was similar with another well-known
believed in the prophylactic effect of seamen's disease, typhus, the significance
blood-letting, which the ship's doctor had of which was for centuries disguised by the
to carry out when the equator was crossed. losses from scurvy, yellow fever and malar-
Otherwise the only help was flight back to ia. It was plain to be seen that the slaves
18 1 Introduction to Nautical Medieine
shipped from Africa to America were foolish, with eonstant vomiting and ineontinenee,
much less vulnerable. Today we know that salvo honore".
this can be traced back to their scanty Heinrich Heine (1797 -1856) wrote a po-
clothing, which offered the transmitting em entitled "Seasickness". Leo Slezak
lice much less shelter. The typhus lice were (1873-1946) and the writer Jerome K.Jer-
often carried onto ships in their horne ome (1858-1927) also reported their own
ports, especially in the ragged clothing of dismal experiences.
those forced on board to serve in the crew. Remedies were advanced by the thou-
Here, too, it was Lind who, in exemplary sands, and more than one charlatan filled
fashion, saw to it that freshly enlisted sail- his pockets. Sniffing at pomegranates or
ors were first taken onto a quarantine ship, quinces; consumption of rose syrup, hys-
bathed, and given new clothing. In this way sop and raw opium; henbane, nutmeg
a continual source of infection was sealed blossoms and boiled lentils; all kinds of
off. confections and elixirs, some for external
use: all were recommended. The strangest
1.1.4.4 Seasickness pieces of advice were given, such as the set-
ting of cupping-glasses over the stornach
The earliest treatment for seasickness is to area, or boating before a sea voyage for
be found in the "Lilium medicinae", writ- general acclimatization to the movements
ten in 1303 by Bernhard von Gordon (died ofa ship.
c. 1318). He recommended fresh air and Even though the nausea was not danger-
the sniffing of toasted, vinegar-soaked ous and claimed no lives, the numerous
bread, advised against eating vegetables, remedies show what great importance was
and gave the difficult-to-follow suggestion attached, also in earlier times, to this most
of holding the head high and moving it typical of nautical ailments.
with the rolling of the ship. The first de-
scriptions of this disorder, which may af- 1.1.4.5 Venereal Diseases
fect anyone on board, come from the time Sexual infections were always rife on
of the Crusades. People of rank carried board ship, largely as a result of the weeks
special containers around with them into alone and the free-and-easy conditions in
which to vomit; the remaining voyagers port. The course of the diseases, however,
had to empty their stomachs overboard, or varied not in the least from that on land.
in heavy seas into buckets, barrels or the Worthy of note, though, is the infection of
bilge. whole islands and regions, mostly by sea-
In the poem "The Pilgrim's Sea Voyage", men. Captain Cook also set an example in
which appeared during the reign of Henry this respect, strictly forbidding sexually in-
VI of England (1422-1471), the main fected crew members to go ashore.
symptoms were accurately portrayed: nau- A great step forward, in 1891, was the in-
sea, vomiting, debility, and heart and stom- troduction by the German naval doctor
ach complaints. Fran~ois Rabelais (1494- Walther Uthemann (1863-1944) of obliga-
1553) may have known the illness at first tory prophylactic treatment, later adopted
hand, but in any case, he gave a graphic de- by all the navies of the civilized world.
scription in his picaresque novel "Gargan- It can be mentioned briefly that the
tua and Pantagruel". Meister Johann Dietz English ship's doctor Trotter viewed gonor-
(1665-1738), the German-Dutch surgeon, rhoea and syphilis as different diseases be-
reported his own experience: fore their definitive separation by Philippe
"There was misery and anxiety. There was not Ricord (1800-1889). Trotter wrote in 1797:
one, even 30 years at sea, who was not deathly sea- "The lues, I think, never pro duces gonor-
siek. I no longer knew who and where I was, quite rhoea".
1.1 The History of Nautical Medicine 19
1.2.1 Greek and Roman Age corps of today can be seen in the groups
and guilds into which ship's doctors were
In view of the great importance that navi- organized - perhaps to perform religious
gation had for the peoples of the Mediter- ceremonies. Even the "naval staff doctor,
ranean, it is not surprising that ship's doc- retired" existed then, for one inscription
tors are mentioned in various literary refers to a "quondam medicus duplicar-
sources of the ancient world. The earliest ius".
reference is found in a document falsely at- It can be assumed that for every trireme
tributed to Hippocrates: The coundl of the with a crew of 200 in the mighty Roman
Athenian fleet deliberated about whether fleet - during the reign of Septimus Se-
to send a naval doctor on an expedition led verus (193-211) it numbered 30000 men -
by Alcibiades (ca. 450-404 B. c.). there was a ship's surgeon. His position,
On a marble slab dating from the first however, was quite low. As a "miles" he
century B. C. and found near Constantino- was at the level of the enlisted men, or of
pIe, the crew members of a trireme are re- the non-commissioned officers, at best. The
corded in Greek. Listed among the ship's better pay is explained today as having
staff, along with captain, navigator and been an inducement to join the navy. Naval
others, is an "iatros". A tomb in the area of doctors enjoyed certain privileges as wen.
Naples is dedicated to a Roman, M. Satrius Like members of the present-day Red
Longinus, who was a ship's doctor on Cross they were "immunes", that is, free
board the "Cupido" during the reign ofthe from military duties, and if they had given
emperor Hadrian (117-138 AD.). To date, up a private practice they had the "ius resti-
some more tomb inscriptions of ship's doc- tutionis", the right to compensation.
tors in the service of Rome are known; In Byzantine times as weIl, there must
several of them were Roman and three have been ship's doctors, as Paul of Aegina
were Greek. What is unusual is that they (seventh century A D.) proposes that doc-
were always referred to as "medici dupli- tors at sea be given written instructions to
carii", which can only me an that they re- take along.
ceived double pay. Never was a doctor in
the army so designated. It is also striking
1.2.2 The Middle Age and Venice
that an of them entered the navy when they
were very young, at 20 or 21 years, and that Until the thirteenth century nothing more
even then there must have been specialists is mentioned about ship's doctors. It is
on board, for Galen (129-199 A D.) ex- quite clear from an order issued by Eleanor
pressly mentions an eye doctor, Axios, who of Aquitaine (ca. 1122-1204), wife of Louis
served with the Roman fleet in Britain and VII of France and later of Henry 11 of
who compounded a salve from cinnabar England, who had experienced first-hand
which was universally valued in his day. A the suffering of the siek on board during
precursor to the naval medical officer one of the Crusades, that there was no
1.2 The Ship's Doctor Yesterday and Today 21
medieal care on the ships. She obliged all law, quacks of all types and men of a decid-
captains under her authority to have all edly adventurous nature. As every last
wounded or siek persons taken ashore and hand was needed on a sailing ship, it often
cared for there. happened that, instead of an experienced
Later on, in an exceptional case, a cap- doctor with a good reputation, a less-edu-
tain was instructed by his superiors to take cated man was signed on, who could also
a doctor on board: around 1300 a certain be used in an emergency to hoist the sails
"Master Gualtieri" is mentioned as sur- or in expeditions on land. The surgeon was
geon ofthe Venetian galleys. He must have often hired with the express instruction to
been either highly esteemed or quite poor, shave crew members once a week, the cap-
as he was issued an entire year's salary in tain, however, daily. He had to serve as vet-
advance. Among the files of the Venetian erinary surgeon as well. Many a command-
archives there are a number of documents er preferred to practise quackery hirnself,
whieh point to the existence of doctors on rather than spend the money for a ship's
board ships. doctor: As late as 1798 an English captain
The first of these decrees is adecision by expelled from his ship a surgeon who had
the High Council of Veniee, dated 3 July been engaged by the state, believing that
1322, to the effect that "unus medieus phi- he, hirns elf, knew all that was necessary.
sieus mittatur cum istis galeis pro servitio Some years earlier, an English admiral had
mercatorem et hominum galearum". In refused to stop his ship in heavy seas to res-
1369 doctors were mentioned among the cue a surgeon who had fallen overboard,
staff members, and later appeared directly because he "was useless on board any-
after the commander on the list of person- way".
nel on board. In aresolution of 14 Febru-
ary 1411 two ship's doctors were deemed
1.2.3 The Age of the Explorers
necessary by the Venetian senate: "Tenean-
tur habere ... ad expensas galearum et du- On his voyage around the Cape of Good
os medieos, unum phisicum et unum ciru- Hope, Vasco da Gama hadn't a single per-
siem ... ". Up to this time, naval physicians son on board with medical training; of the
were highly respected; the surgeon was al- 150 men on his flagship, 55 died. Magellan
so regarded as "medicus", and so-called embarked with five ships and a 265-man
barbierotti worked only as assistants, under crew, taking along a surgeon and three
the direction of university-trained surgeons barbers. Only his flagship, the "Vietoria",
who had been examined by experienced reached horne in 1522, with a skeleton crew
city and port physicians before embarka- of 18 men. Magellan and his ship's doctor
tion. There was apparently no lack of sur- died en route, as weIl as two of the barbers;
geons who wanted to go to sea; indeed, the third barber had the good fortune to see
there were provisos limiting the filling of his homeland again, and wrote a shocking
vacancies on board, due to the huge de- report of this first voyage around the world.
mand. In 1574 there were one barber and one as-
In later years the standard and reputa- sistant on board a 100-ton corvette; in 1637
tion of ship's doctors declined consider- as many as six surgeons were available for
ably. Up to the seventeenth century fully the 666-man crew of the "Couronne".
educated physicians were the exception. There were also six surgeons captured
Their position was filled by ship's sur- along with the 646 men of a privateer in
geons, some of whom were industrious, 1657. Even in those days the surgeons ap-
studious and talented "Masters". Others, pear to have received better treatment; in
however, were flawed characters, indolent any case, the chronicler stresses the fact
scholars, "barbers" who had broken the that they were accommodated in aseparate
22 1 Introduction to Nautical Medicine
cabin. The first evidence of military rank without notice. From 1600 to 1625, 114 sur-
for ship's doctors in the English navy ap- geons and three physicians were hired for
pears in 1512, during the reign of Henry the Company. An academy for the further
VIII (1509-1547), when the terms "sur- education of ship's doctors was founded in
geon" and "surgeon's mate" were intro- Batavia (now Djakarta) in 1685, so that sur-
duced. The rank of "surgeon"exists even geons on ships lying in port could make use
today in the British and American navies; of their time to add to their medical knowl-
the "surgeon's mate" became an "assistant edge. Quite early, ship's doctors were
surgeon" in 1828, a complete university ed- ranked equally with officers, and, if they
ucation having been made a requirement were university trained, they had the right
for this position in the British navy as early to be addressed as "Sinjeur"; if they were
as 1809. surgeons they received the tide "Meester".
It was up to the captain to decide who Barbers, who usually had a very low lev-
was employed as ship's doctor; it was also el of education, nevertheless occupied a
the captain who paid his salary, usually cal- special position on the whaling ships in the
culated as head-money per crew member. seventeenth century. As did their counter-
There were often bonuses in addition: a parts in ancient Rome, they received
premium for each crew member who re- double pay if, in addition to performing
turned healthy. It wasn't until the seven- their surgical duties, they kept the log
teenth century that government boards books and lists, supervised the issuing of
took over the payment of doctors' fees. A rations, and in particular saw to it that the
year's pay for a doctor in England at the services of worship, celebrated by the cap-
time of James 1(1566-1625) amounted to 1:, tain, were regularly attended.
200; surgeons received only half of this
sumo Until the nineteenth century sailors 1.2.4 French Naval Medicine
had to cover the costs of treatment for
venereal diseases themselves; presumably, The view gradually gained acceptance in
this was a source of not inconsiderable in- all countries that - particularly on long
co me for poorly paid ship's doctors. The voyages - medical care should not be left
fact that, for this reason, many sailors up to the captain or the shipowner, but
might not pI ace themselves under medical rather that laws were necessary to guaran-
treatment until it was too late was not ap- tee adequate medical treatment for crew
preciated until the Age of Enlightenment. and passengers. On this point, France was
Toward the end of the eighteenth century ahead of all other seafaring nations. As ear-
free treatment was offered for these dis- ly as 1628, an article was adopted into the
eases, too. statutes of the surgeons' guild of Marseille
Experienced and well-educated sur- requiring an examination before the chirur-
geons went to sea on Dutch ships even be- giens jures prior to embarkation. A royal
fore the Dutch East India Company was decree of 1655 forbade the employment of
founded. From 1610 on, ship's doctors medically trained persons who had not
were required to pass an examination given been examined. In 1681 appeared the fa-
in Middelburg by two sworn town physi- mous "Grande Ordonnance de la Marine"
cians and two town surgeons before they by the French minister of the navy Jean-
could be engaged. There was a rigorous Baptiste Colbert (1619-1683), which also
governmental inspection of the instrumen- dealt with problems of health on ship-
tarium and the medicine bag, both of board. From 1668 on, the examination for
which the candidate had to provide; ship's ship's surgeons was held centrally by the
doctors who did not conscientiously fulfil "premier chirurgien du Rai" or his represen-
their duties were occasionally dismissed tative, and no longer by the local guild of
1.2 The Ship's Doctor Yesterday and Today 23
barber-surgeons. All the same, there were for service with the Royal Navy. In the
sundry abuses under Louis XIV merchant marine, on the other hand, medi-
(1643-1715): many a certificate was ob- cal services were often performed by ques-
tained with abribe. Beginning in 1673, an tionable characters. This was particularly
oath had to be sworn that the surgeon in true on the numerous convict ships sailing
question would not leave his ship before between England and Australia, and on the
the end of the voyage, and that he would emigrant ships sailing to America. For ex-
take no sick sailors on board. In the first ample, there were "ship's doctors" who
8 years following the promulgation ofthese were penalized for selling the rations desig-
regulations 41 diplomas were issued. In nated for the sick and letting the prisoners
contrast, from 1684 to 1692 117 examina- starve, to the extent that they didn't report
tions were held; these must have been quite the death of fellow-prisoners to whom they
easy, as there is no known case of a candi- were chained, in order to have the benefit
date who failed. In 1717, as a result of the oftheir scanty rations. Other "doctors" act-
growing corruption, a new naval decree ed as pimps on ships carrying female pris-
was made under Louis XV (1715-1774), oners, in this way - and in macabre con-
whereby the examiners were to be appoint- trast to their professional duty - promoting
ed in future by the "Admiral de France", a generalized venereal infection on board.
nonmedical authority. In 1746 the "Ecole For this reason special laws for emigrant
maritime de chirurgie, d'anatomie et de ships were issued around 1830, and the
medecine pratique" was founded in Mar- "Passengers Act" followed in 1849, con-
seille; it was closed after a short time, open- taining precise figures on the proportion of
ed again in 1777, then closed permanently doctors to passengers on board and regula-
at the time of the revolution. The school tions covering the medicines to be taken
admitted 14-year-old boys who could read, along. There was to be one doctor for every
write and - shave. The sons of ship's sur- 50 passengers on long voyages, and the
geons had preference. In striking contrast power to decide whether a sailor was fit for
to the efforts that were made to produce duty was transferred to the ship's doctor.
well-trained ship's doctors is the fact that in He was also entrusted with certain public
the period up to the revolution the name is health duties especially in foreign ports,
known of only one naval physician in and medical reports were required from
France with a doctorate. hirn at specified intervals. In the navy daily
sick bulletins were introduced, with de-
1.2.5 British Naval Medicine tailed descriptions of the cases treated. A
number of such reports are still available in
In England Henry VIII had established a various English archives; they are no dif-
"Navy Board" which had only an advisory ferent in structure from our present-day
function. In 1588 this authority entrusted case histories. As of 1838 the younger naval
four physicians with the supervision of the physicians were still not admitted to the of-
fleet. Outstanding among them was Willi- ficers' mess, but in 1859 the British navy
am Gilbert (1540-1603), who later became followed the French example: in France as
personal physician to Queen Elizabeth and early as 1793 all physicians were given
president of the Royal College of Physi- equal rank with officers, and even the
cians. He won great honour for his treat- youngest surgeons occupied the rank of a
ment of the diseases that broke out on junior physician (an aspirant). The Ameri-
board ship. can navy, founded in 1775, raised its ship's
Medical care in the navy improved con- doctors to the rank of officer in 1828; until
siderably after this period. By 1805 only then they had been equal to the lower com-
fully qualified physicians were accepted missioned deck officers. A young navy, the
24 1 Introduction to Nautical Medicine
German Federal, founded in 1848, did re- In France these medicine chests were in-
quire of its candidates a licence to practise spected by the most senior surgeons and
and a doctoral degree, but only the Imperi- pharmacists of the port before the ships set
al German navy founded in 1871 had its out, but never by the same pharmacist who
own naval medical officer corps in 1896, had delivered the supplies. The inspection
and only after the First World War did na- was set for the third to last day before em-
val doctors receive rank equal on all points barkation to avoid any kinds of irregulari-
to that of the other naval officers. In the ties.
Austro-Hungarian Empire the separation Dieppe was one of the pi aces where a
from the army medical officer corps was medicine-chest industry sprang up in the
made in 1855, and even Italy, in 1861, was seventeenth century, producing standard-
far ahead of Germany in this respect. ized chests in various sizes. It did good bu-
It is remarkable that with the establish- siness, for Colbert's naval legislation of
ment ofthe North American navy in 1775 1668 stipulated that every ship that put to
four ship's doctors were employed, who, sea for an extended period had to take
however, held no service rank. Military along a medicine ehest.
ranks were first introduced in 1871, and it By 1778 the contents of such chests had
was stilliater that the rank of the naval doc- become modernized. A British ship's doc-
tor was adjusted to correlate with that of tor, for example, suggested the following
the other officers. medicaments: cinchona, cascarilla, ipecac,
tartar emetic, white antimony glance, opi-
1.2.6 The Ship's Doctor, the um, laudanum, magnesium sulfuricum, po-
tassium bitartrate, mercurial ointment, cal-
Pharmacist and the Medicine omeI, ammonium carbonate, spirit of vitri-
ehest ol, gum arabic and various vesicating
Pharmacists were an exception on board pIasters. A comprehensive description of
up until the French Revolution, although ship's apothecary chests during the era of
in ancient times they beIonged to the navy. sailing ships can be found in Müller [11].
Under the Romans surgeons held the same A great many ship's doctors performed
rank as the highest non-commissioned of- services that went far beyond the medical
ficers. They were often recruited from care on board. Only a few of the doctors
among former Greek and Arab slaves, and are mentioned here, who - ahead of their
received Roman citizenship after serving time - made decisive contributions, not on-
for a specified amount of time. In all prob- ly in their special fieIds, but also in other
ability, however, they prepared the medica- disciplines of the natural sciences.
ments for the ships on land, and did not go
to sea themselves. 1.2.7 Medical Guides and Famous
Later on, people made do with medicine
Ship's Doctors
chests which were carried on long sailing
voyages. Two such chests are preserved at Many a doctor who went to sea tried, by
the Wellcome Historical Medical Museum means oftreatises and monographs, to pass
in London; they held instruments and nu- on the knowledge gained during long,
merous medications compounded from eventful voyages, or to make new findings
more or less beneficial ingredients. Among generally available to other colleagues. The
other medications there were purgatives oldest surviving accounts of this type are
and emetics, theriaca and substances made probably the health regimens drawn up for
with terra sigillata, the tusks of elephants or high-ranking gentlemen by their personal
the horn of the legendary unicorn, bezoar physicians. Just such a manual is preserved
and viper oil. in the state library in Kassel, along with the
1.2 Tbe Ship's Doctor Yesterday and Today 25
travel diary of the landgrave Wilhelm I the one of the first to recommend lemon juice
eider of Hesse (1466-1515), who sailed to for scurvy. "An Account of the Nature,
Palestine in 1491-1492. In it, wearing scar- Causes, Symptoms and Cure of the Dis-
let robes was recommended to ward off tempers that are incident to Seafaring Peo-
dysentery; the gentlemen were supposed to pie", by William Cockburn (1669-1739)
take live animals in cages on board, as ex- appeared in London in 1696. In "The
perience had shown that the nutrition was Navy-Surgeon", published in London in
inadequate and the provisions often 1734 by lohn Atkins (1685-1757), the Afri-
spoiled; finally, they were advised to take can sleeping sickness is described for the
wrapped urinals and spittoons with lids as first time in English; this was much earlier
it is weil known that there were still no toi- than the description by Thomas Master-
lets at that time. man Winterbottom (1765/66-1859), whose
The "Raiß Büchlin", or Reise Büchlein report from Sierra Leone in 1830 was long
(travel diary) by Georg Pictorius (ca. regarded as the first.
1500-1569), which appeared in Straßburg The eighteenth century was the age of
in 1557, can be regarded as the first manual the "classics ofnautical medicine": In 1753
of nautical medicine. It was primarily in- lames Lind (1716-1794) published "A
structions for captains and navigators, but Treatise of the Scurvy"; in 1757, the basic
it included an appendix with the heading work on ship's hygiene, "An Essay on the
"wie sich auff dem Möre oder andern Most Effectual Means of Preserving the
Wasser zu schicken" (i. e. "how to adapt to Health of Seamen in the Royal Navy"; and
the sea or other waters"). in 1768, a paper on tropical medicine enti-
A second, similar treatise was written not tled "An Essay on Diseases Incidental in
by a physician, but by an English poet and Europeans in Hot Climates". In 1785 fol-
courtier, George Whetstone (1544-1587); lowed the "Observations on the Diseases
his work on nautical medicine and the incident to Seamen" by Sir Gilbert Blane
tropical diseases then known was publish- (1749-1834), who had great success in get-
ed posthumously in 1598. Incidentally, ting Lind's demands with regard to hygiene
Whetstone's strikingly prescient advice for carried out in the Royal Navy. In 1797
dysentery, which was suffered frequently came "Medicina nautica" by Thomas Trot-
on board ships, was first to administer a ter (1761-1832), who was at that time a
purgative, then to give red wine and rice doctor with the British fleet. The first
water, and to apply a mustard pIaster to the American work on nautical medicine was
body. The first work on tropical medicine written in 1808 by Edward Cutbush
in general, and on medicinal herbs of India (1772-1843).
in particular, sterns from a Portuguese The name of one ship's doctor is prob-
ship's doctor, Garcia dei Huerto (ab Orta) ably universally known, that of Thomas
(1490-1570), who lived for a long time in Dover (1662-1742), who became famous
Goa, and is regarded as the first to have de- during his lifetime through aseries of ad-
scribed the Rauwolfia serpentina, whose ventures. In 1732 he published the still au-
root plays such a large role in the treasury thoritative work "Pulvis Ipecacuanhae opi-
of modern medicines. His "Coloquios dos atus", and he owed the establishment ofhis
simples e drogas hä causas medicinais da eminent London practice to his successful
India" appeared in Goa in 1563. privateering expeditions in southern wa-
lohn Woodall (1556-1643) was also an ters. He was the owner of two ships; today
author with previous medical training; he he would be called a pirate. In 1709, on a
was a ship's doctor with the Dutch East In- three-year sea voyage, he rescued the
dia Company and published his "Sur- shipwrecked sailor Alexander Selkirk
geon's Mate" in London in 1617. He was (1676-1721) from the 10ne1y luan Fernan-
26 1 Introduction to Nautical Medicine
dez Island. Selkirk's story was the inspira- were Europe-North America, Eu-
tion for the 1719 novel "Robinson Crusoe" rope-South America, Europe-East Asia
by 9aniel Defoe (1660-1731). and Europe-Southeast Asia. From the
A number of pI aces on the map are middle of the nineteenth century onward,
named in honour of the ship's doctors who almost all of the important shipping coun-
discovered them: the Bass Strait is named tries had regulations covering the carriage
after George Bass (1771-later than 1802), of ship's doctors. In the absence of regula-
who proved that Tasmania was not part of tions, the competition between the large
the mainland; EIliot's Cove, after the sur- shipping companies forced them to keep
geon's mate who was shipwrecked during a relatively good medical facilities on board
voyage of exploration in 1740 and died af- and to carry ship's doctors. On the great
ter long privation; and Capes Richardson passenger ships of the European and
and Armstrong, after two respected North American shipping lines there were
English naval physicians. excellently equipped ship's hospitals, op-
The Edinburgh clinician William Cullen erating and consulting rooms, and - quite
(1712-1790); the biologist Thomas Huxley early on - X-ray equipment. Crew mem-
(1825-1895), founder of neuropathology; bers were cared for by one to five ship's
Charles Darwin (1809-1882), who went to doctors and by male and female nurses.
sea as a medical student - he never took a Even though there were no longer acade-
medical examination; the nautical and mies for ship's doctors, as during the seven-
tropical physician Bernhard Nocht teenth and eighteenth centuries in France,
(1857-1945), after whom the Institute for the occupation of ship's doctor was recog-
Nautical and Tropical Diseases in Ham- nized and was often pursued as a field of
burg was named in 1942; the naval medical specialization for many years. The Institute
corps captain Eduard Hoffmann (born for Nautical and Tropical Diseases
1837), one of the reorganizers of the medi- founded in Hamburg in 1900 held its own
cal-surgical academy in Tokyo; his col- courses for ship's doctors. Its director
league Führmann, who as early as 1872 de- Nocht published his own textbook, "Vorle-
tected malaria plasmodia in blood, but sungen für Schiffsärzte" (Lectures for
misinterpreted them; the bacteriologists Ship's Doctors) [13]; he wrote in the fore-
Albert Calmette (1863-1933), Georg Gaff- word:
ky (1850-1918) and August Gärtner
A modem passenger ship is a very complex or-
(1848-1934): all are well-known medical ganism. For the young ship's doctor everywhere it
men who spent decisive periods of their is exceptionally difficult to make quick and correct
lives as ship's doctors. And even the cele- judgements about hygienic conditions on board
brated RudolfVirchow (1821-1902) was of and the peculiar characteristics of the crew and
passengers, and to get a clear idea at the outset of
the opinion that
his own position, the range ofhis duties, and the re-
for a young man who, along with amassing a rich sources available to hirn for fulfilling them.
store of empirical knowledge, has also trained in
the practise of autopsy and of epicritic examina- The book clearly illustrates the problems
tion, a long sea voyage ... fis] an invaluable oppor- of that time; infectious diseases, particu-
tunity to do his own work and to reflect more dee- larly the diseases subject to quarantine
ply.
such as plague, yellow fever, smaIlpox and
The final important phase in the work of cholera, as weIl as typhus, amoebic dysen-
ship's doctors covers over 100 years, from lery, malaria, filariasis and trypanosomiasis
the mid-nineteenth century to the mid- are the centre of discussion. Among the de-
twentieth. During this period the ever-Iarg- ficiency diseases beriberi is dealt with in
er, fast passenger and emigrant ships plied detail, although scurvy is no longer impor-
the oceans. The most renowned stretches tant. A substantial chapter is devoted to
1.2 The Ship's Doctor Yesterday and Today 27
ship's hygiene, with special regard to water eompanies of today that still operate pas-
supply and disinfeetion. senger liners have similar regulations.
Another book widely read by ship's doe- From them ean be gained an impression of
tors was "The Ship Surgeon's Handbook", the extremely broad area of operations,
by Vavasour EIder [19]. It eontains classie usually described in plain, dry language.
deseriptions of the problems faeed by For instanee, the booklet Duties and Re-
ship's doetors, some ofwhich are still valid sponsibilities 0/ Ship's Surgeon, Nurses, and
for today, even if the eurrent ailments of Hospital Attendant, published in 1969 by
passengers and crew members may have the Moore-McCormaek Line for the medi-
ehanged. cal personneIon its passenger ships, eon-
tains, among others, the following instrue-
No thought is ever given by the travelling public
to his responsibilities, medical and moral, in deal-
tions:
ing with an epidemie disease which may, perhaps, The ship's Surgeon as a staff officer is in charge
attack the whole ship; his anxiety in case of enteric of the medical department of the vessel. He is re-
fever or pneumonia, where careful nursing, almost sponsible for the physical welfare of the crew and
the whole essence of treatment, is practically unob- passengers and is in direct charge of the treatment
tainable unless a trained nurse happens to be and care of all siek and injured persons on board
among the passengers, and volunteers her services; ... The ship's surgeon should at all times remember
his doubts in case of probable malingering, know- that he is a physician and that his actions may eas-
ing full well that if he makes amistake in either di- ily be the subject of discussion by passengers ...
rection his reputation among the crew is gone; the The surgeon shall consider himse1f on duty at all
decision as to the exact point at which a slightly times and shall not leave the ship at any foreign
siek man must be laid off duty - all these are un- port without notifying the master ... [Sherlock 15].
known and unseen, consequently unappreciated ...
He is in a position of spendid isolation, having no
one on board in sympathy with his work. In fact, 1.2.8 The Ship's Doctor in Recent
the very exercise ofhis duty at times antagonizes all Decades and Nowadays
other departments in so far as their own work is
concerned. Moreover, none of these will share any The large passenger liners experienced an
blame attaching to the results of his attempts to upswing onee again at the end ofthe 1940s
satisfy everybody ... A ship-surgeon lives on pos- and in the 1950s, following the Second
sibilities. The whole gamut of medicine, surgery World War. However, they disappeared
and midwifery lies within his sphere, and may arise
at any moment calling for prompt measures. The
from the oeeans rather quiekly at the begin-
following record of a day's work while taking 1,600 ning of the 1960s. As had already hap-
emigrants to Australia may be of interest. It in- pened in the 1920s and 1930s, various large
c1uded one normallabour, a compound fracture of shipping companies switched increasingly
tibia and a dislocation of shoulder (the weather was to the running of freighters and passenger
bad at the time), three dental extractions, four ab-
seesses incised, in addition to routine surgery ships as so-called combination ships. Ac-
hours, and with diphtheria and scarlet fever both cording to their size, these ships had crews
prevalent in epidemie form. This is not quoted as numbering between 50 and 80 men and
being typieal of an ordinary day's work at sea, but women and carried up to 100 passengers.
more as illustrating the various possibilities at any
given moment. ..
The occupation of ship's doetor also expe-
rienced an upswing once more with this
In 1937, in one of the last books to ap- change, although rarely any longer as a
pear along these lines, the editor Korten- long-term eommitment; it was mueh more
haus eolleeted all the regulations that were usual for a doctor to make only a few trips,
relevant to the ship's doetor and the port or even just one. Medically relevant de-
doctor ofhis day [14]. seriptions of the oecupation of ship's doe-
Eaeh of the major passenger shipping tor are beeoming inereasingly rare. On the
lines had its own instruetions and rules for other hand, various publieations by ship's
the ship's doctors and other medical per- doctors have aehieved belletristic quality
sonnel it employed. Even the few shipping (Xadow [20)).
28 1 Introduction to Nautical Medicine
In the late 1960s and the 1970s the great female nurses, enfermeros, paramedics).
passenger liners vanished altogether from Since, with only a few exceptions, the com-
the seas; passenger transport is now han- bination ships have practically disap-
dled by the airlines. One form of passenger peared, ship's doctors can be found only
shipping has survived - however, with con- on the passenger-cruise ships or on a few
siderably smaller ships: the cruise. It has special ships. Ships of the Eastern-Bloc
become a speciality. Whereas passengers countries, especially of the Soviet Union,
used the huge liners, and to some extent the Poland and the German Democratic Re-
combination ships, only as a means of public, still carry doctors on freighters with
transportation, to get from one part of the large crews. However, as the average crew
world to the other - particularly at the time size has dropped sharply even in these
of mass emigration - the cruise passenger countries, it can be anticipated that on
travels purely for enjoyment, or luxury. The these ships as weH the health of the crew
make-up of the passengers has changed ac- will soon be looked after only by ship's of-
cordingly. Almost all cruise lines have ficers or paramedical personnel.
abolished passenger c1asses; the only dif- Ship's doctors are still to be found, how-
ferences now are among cabin prices, but ever, on some special ships, particularly
all passengers have the same recreation fishery protection vessels, fishing factory
area on board and receive the same menu. and processing boats, research ships and
The average age of the cruise passenger has cable laying ships. These vessels carry doc-
risen quite considerably. On many trips, tors because of their large crews or their
90% of the passengers are over 60 years scope of duties. The fishery protection ves-
old. sels resemble smalI, specially equipped
The peculiar characteristics of the trav- hospital ships, with the best facilities for
ellers are so distinctive that the term "cruise operative and conservative treatment on
medicine" has already found its way into board (Goethe [3]; Kaerger [9]; Naumann
the literature of nautical medicine (Jäger [7, [12]).
8]). Carter [2] goes into the matter of "ship- "In the eyes of the public, the life of a
board medicine on package cruises" in de- ship-surgeon is commonly invested with
tail. He writes: glamourous and pleasurable surroundings
and circumstances of all sorts" (Meighan
Cheap package cruises have become very popu- [10]). This is an unfortunate, but wide-
lar in Great Britain, but the ships used for these
cruises are often not suitable for elderly, handi-
spread, error. Even if the doctor on a pas-
capped, and mentally unfit people. The cruises run senger ship has to play, more or less volun-
to very tight schedules with many strenuous shore tarily, a certain social role, on neither
excursions, and do not necessarily constitute restful passenger ships nor fishery protection or
holidays at sea. Many passengers who embark on research vessels does he have an easy, com-
these cruises are suffering from pre-existing dis-
eases, which may become exacerbated during the fortable life. A ship's doctor who takes his
voyage ... job seriously is required to have a good
knowledge of general medicine, as weH as
Taking the entire world into considera- experience with minor and intermediate
tion, only a few ships today sail with a surgery and radiography. Some knowledge
ship's doctor. There are no longer any fully of dentistry is also necessary; at the very
trained doctors on the freighters of the least, a ship's doctor is expected to be able
western industrialized countries, or on to extract teeth. He must be capable of
those of the developing countries. On these treating fractures or injuries, of performing
ships, health care is provided by the ship's appendectomies, and possibly even of
officers, or, in the case of a few shipping treating a perforated or bleeding stornach
companies, by medical assistants (male or ulcer on his own - aH this without the facil-
1.2 The Ship's Doctor Yesterday and Today 29
ities of a large hospital, and often with in- The ship's doctor must always make do
adequate assistance, or none at all. Never- with the medicaments, instruments and
theless, an experienced ship's doctor equipment at hand. Things that are lacking
avoids operations as far as possible. The must often be improvised; this is an art that
fact that the ship's doctor is left entirely to every successful ship's doctor must acquire
his own resources in diagnosis and treat- quickly (Heits and Fischer [6]).
ment constitutes an essential reality. A doc- The equipment that a ship's doctor finds
tor from a developed country is not used to on board corresponds to the regulations ei-
such circumstances. The junior doctor at a ther of the country whose flag his ship flies
hospital has many colleagues, the depart- or of his shipping company. Many coun-
ment head, and the director; moreover, tries with a shipping industry have stipula-
there is a great variety of special wards. In tions regarding medications, medical
private practice there are specialists in equipment and instruments, as weil as the
every field, and hospitals to which a doctor rooms required, for ships which, according
can refer cases which he cannot handle to their regulations, must have a doctor.
hirnself. None of these are available at sea. Some shipping countries, however, have no
Every ship's doctor is his or her own assis- regulations governing the equipment of
tant, department head and director. There ship's hospitals and operating and consult-
are no specialists whom one can consult. ing rooms. In these countries it is left to the
Even if one decides to ask the ship's man- shipping companies to provide the ship's
agement to put in at the next port, one must doctor with an adequate supply of instru-
care for the patient oneself until that port is ments and other necessary equipment. As
reached - and this can often take many experiences in international shipping show,
days. Moreover, the captain will be most this problem is not always perfectly solved,
unwilling to put in at a port not on the although good shipping companies en-
planned route, as this could entail heavy fi- deavour - if only because of competi-
nancial losses. The ship's doctor is expect- tion - to have a competent ship's doctor
ed to be able to handle all illnesses or acci- on board and to provide the proper equip-
dents on board. A country doctor, or one in ment.
a less developed country, is used to work- In general, the ship's doctor can expect
ing completely on his own, and would be to find a consulting room and aseparate
able to cope more easily with such de- operating room. These rooms should be
mands. Beyond the purely medical sphere, equipped with the necessary apparatus for
a ship's doctor must be a person with a diagnosis, sterilization and operative treat-
large amount of self-confidence, diplomat- ment, including dental care. A good ship's
ie talent in his dealing with the idiosyncra- pharmacy, sufficiently provided with mod-
sies of the sailors, passengers and the au- em medicaments, is especially important.
thorities, and last but not least, must have a A lack of instruments and apparatus can be
good knowledge of languages (Goethe [4]). compensated for by experience and impro-
An essential feature of the ship's doctor's visation; a lack of medication, and particu-
job is independent, responsible decision- larly of bandaging material, cannot. Equip-
making (Unger and Ebert [18]). ment today should include an effident
The ship's doctor plays a major role on X-ray unit for pictures of bones, an ECG
board in lowering morbidity among sea- machine, and a small laboratory. In addi-
men. Slutzker and Balakirev [16] especially tion, one or several - according to the num-
point out the possibilities of improving the ber of passengers and crew on board -
health of the crew through therapeutic and sick-rooms are necessary in the immediate
preventive measures, as weil as through vicinity of the consulting and operating
sanitation. rooms.
30 1 Introduction to Nautical Medicine
rine Medicine, Leningrad, 1968. Eds. E. P. Ser- 18. Unger, 1. E. and H. Ebert: Schiffsarzt heute.
geev at al. Moscow 1969. pp. 164-166. Verk.-Med. 29, 3, 115-119 (1982).
17. Tortori-Donati, B. and L.Giannico: Practice of 19. Vavasour EIder, A.: The ship surgeon's hand-
medical profession on board passenger ships, book. London: Bailliere, Tindall & Cox 1926.
remarks on equipment and activity ofthe medi- 20. Xadow, Ch.: Whisky, Haut & Serum .... Aus
cal department of the liners and on morbidity dem Tagebuch eines Schiffsarztes. Herford:
on board. In: III International Symposium on Koehlers 1974.
Marine Medicine, Leningrad, 1968. Eds.
E. P. Sergeev et al. Moscow 1969. pp 189-196.
1.3 The Ship's Medical Centre and Medicine Chest
A.Backhaus
Since men first travelled long distances on bay and a sufficiently large room for medi-
land and sea they have found it necessary cal examination and treatment. This room
to carry medical equipment (Ewald [18]; should contain a bath and a show er, the
Goethe [27]; Larsen [54, 55]; Schadewaldt facilities to perform infusions, suitable
[82, 83, 85]; Volbehr [104, 105]). The afore- equipment for cleaning and rinsing the
mentioned papers document the ingenuity eyes and good means of temperature regu-
applied at various times in history in decid- lation for severely burnt patients. There
ing the type of equipment according to pre- must be provision for administering oxy-
vailing medical knowledge and theories. gen. The supervision of the patient is vital,
Few countries then enforced strict regula- and an emergency bell that could be used
tions for their ships. Nowadays however, by a semiconscious person should be con-
most countries have recommendations and sidered.
regulations governing the medical equip- Other high-risk vessels and structures are
ment on their ships. These requirements dredgers, excavators, cranes, drilling plat-
change to take account of developments in forms and drilling platform supply boats.
medical science. Consequently, fundamen- These must have a treatment room; since
tal questions as well as aspects of medical they are not far from shore or from helicop-
assistance on board will be discussed be- ter landing places, there is no need for a
low (Fischer [19, 20]; Halm [32]; [76]; Ram sick-bay. Today, most ships of this type
[79]; White [107]). have a treatment room, but this room
should be large and should have an exami-
1.3.1 Shipbuilding nation couch that has access from all sides,
achair for the treatment of eye, ear and
The design of small ships with a small crew mouth, facilities for carrying out infusions,
makes no provision for a special room or a telephone link with the shore, an emer-
pi ace for medical care. A necessary factor gency alarm, a sufficient water supply, a
to be taken into account for larger ships is bath and a shower. The minimum size
how far a ship will usually be from shore, should be 20 m2, including the bath and
i. e. from medical assistance in a port. An shower.
additional factor is the use for which the Statutory safety regulations demand less
ship has been built. This parameter is of of the fishing fleet than of the merchant
prime importance in shipbuilding when fleet (Krynicki [52]; Sobol and Zurawiecki
medical provisions have to be considered [93]). Small fis hing boats usually put to sea
(Angelov et al. [1]; Koch [48]; Milcheva et in the evening and returned in the morning.
al. [69]; [74]; [81]; Schmidt and Kludas [87]; This type of fishing has ended in the indus-
Sobol and Krynicki [94]; Staton [97]; Vin- trial countries but is still to be found in
kovetski and Krivenda [103]). All ships car- other parts of the world. Nowadays, there
rying dangerous cargo, especially tankers are different methods of fishing, for exam-
and chemical tankers, should have a sick- pie, large factory ships that process the
1.3 The Ship's Medical Centre and Medicine Chest 33
DE CK
The economic point of view may be an tions have generally neglected these facts
essential one, but if the statistical probabili- even for passenger ferries solely engaged in
ty of accidents and diseases among, say, ten coastal voyages. There have been avoid-
crew members is considered and the time able deaths on these ferries. The medical
to the next port with medical assistance re- facilities should therefore be improved by
garded, the following internationally ac- the provision of wards and examination
knowledged fact can be appreciated: In rooms. Passenger vessels and ferries on
voyages near the coast, not more than 12 h routes where the maximal time required to
from a port of call, no special room is shore and medical assistance is about 24 h,
needed for medical treatment; a box for will, with few exceptions, not have a physi-
medical equipment is sufficient. cian on board. The number of crew and
The essential parameter is not the num- passengers may be more than 1000. Many
ber of crew members but the possibility of of the passengers will have no cabin of
medical assistance of reasonable quality their own. Both young and old people will
from shore. Today we expect the number of sleep on deck or dance all night in the bar.
crew to be as small as possible. Ships near a There may be many children, even babies,
coast with ports providing good medical on board. On a luxury ship every passenger
assistance are sufficiently equipped if they will have his own cabin and is likely to stay
have a place for first-aid treatment and a there if he falls ill. On the ferries in coastal
box or a small cupboard for the medical waters, there must be sufficient room for
equipment. sick or injured persons, including drunken
or mentally disturbed passengers.
Until now, national and international
1.3.3 Vessels Engaged in Deep Sea regulations have not considered this point.
Voyages Luxury vessels have generally more rooms
If a ship is more than 24 h from medical as- and wards for patients than necessary, but
sistance, be this at sea or in regions with no ferries and similar ships often do not have
hospitals or emergency stations ashore, it even an emergency room for first aid. On
should have a room for examination and these ships there should be:
treatment (Krynicki [52]). There should be 1. A room for first aid, large enough to
an examination bed to which there is clear have an examination bed with access
access from all sides, and a locker to store from all sides, washing facilities and
the necessary medicines. There should be a adequate lighting and a locker for medi-
sick-bay for two people with an emergency eine, bandages etc.; the door way should
bell and/or telephone, WC, bathroom and be large enough for a patient on a
natural light. stretcher to be brought into and out of
the room.
2. Two rooms for patients (female or male)
1.3.3.1 Passenger Vessels with sanitary facilities, emergency bell
Passenger ships, even if small, have many and natural light. One room should be
more people on board than cargo ships. equipped for a mentally disturbed or
Most crew members on a cargo ship are drunken person. The room should be
under 40 years of age, in contrast to the lockable from the outside and there
passengers on a liner, which may include should be an observation window to per-
babies and elderly people. The crew of a mit supervision from outside whenever
cargo ship will be checked regarding their the patient is not accompanied by an at-
fitness for duty at sea. There are virtually tendant. The content of the room should
no regulations to prevent a sick person be such that nothing can be used by the
boarding a passenger vessel. The regula- patient to injure hirnself.
1.3 The Ship's Medical Centre and Medicine Chest 35
[97); Stjepanovic [98); Urner and Staton author is of the opinion that infusion
[102]). This question is linked with another: equipment is necessary as weH.
Should a ship be supplied with effective
medicines normaHy used by a doctor, con- 1.3.5.2 High-Risk Vessels
sidering that there will be no person on There are special problems involved in div-
board who has any medical training (or at ing owing to the work being carried out un-
best somebody with only a minimum of der high pressure, but the medical supplies
training)? But ifthe medical chest contains should be the same as in ships on long voy-
only less effective medieines, what should ages. Technical assistance, good connec-
be done on board in case of emergency? tion by telephone and radio with the shore,
This problem is complicated by the very optimal stretcher equipment, helicopter
different mIes, regulations and laws in dif- landing places and other technical faeilities
ferent countries, conceming the adminis- are more essential than medieines. Severe
tration of medieine. However, a shipowner buming of large areas of the skin may oc-
or a master must be aware of his national cur. This means more than usual quantities
regulations (Ebert [16); Grewe [28); Kle- of: dressings for bums, special prepara-
patski [47]). A list of suitable medicines is tions for applying to the skin, large alumi-
recommended in the International Medical nium-backed dressings, infusions in large
Guide for Ships [35) and in the IMO's Medi- quantities (not less than 10000 ml) antibiot-
cal First Aid Guide for use in Accidents In- ic ointments and analgesics for long-term
volving Dangerous Goods[66). Many seafar- treatment. For aH high-risk vessels the
ing countries have issued medical scales for medical outfit must be at least of the stan-
their own ships. These may differ consider- dard ofthat in cargo vessels engaged in for-
ably in the number and kind of medieines eign-going voyages.
and other supplies.
1.3.5.3 Fishing Vessels
1.3.5.1 Ships Carrying Dangerous Cargo The crew of fishing boats are, as previously
Irrespective of the size of a ship or the pointed out, particularly exposed to a high
number of crew members, medieine must risk of aceidental injury. They should be
be available for immediate treatment and weH equipped [72). On fishing boats which
in sufficient quantity for the first hours. Ex- spend months far from land and still far-
perience proves that many types of danger- ther from a hospital, at sea in bad weather
ous cargo may be carried in a particular and with the crew carrying out hard work,
ship. So the medical outfit should be stan- the equipment should be the same as on
dardised and include all known antidotes cargo vessels engaged in deep sea voyages
and medieine for basic treatment of poi- (see below). However, even this equipment
soning. There are international schedules is aminimum. If the fishing vessel is a fish
ofthe IMO which should be observed [66]: factory ship, it should carry a doctor and be
Included are: atropine injection, polyethy- equipped to a medical scale similar to that
lene glycol (minimum 2000 ml), amyl nitrite of a passenger ship. Some adjustment to
for inhalation, a strong sedative such as di- the scale would be important because the
azepam for injection, oxygen equipment, crew of a fish factory ship are more ex-
strong analeptics for injection, analgesic posed to aceidents and infections. Corre-
eyedrops, suffieient water supply, means of spondingly, it is unnecessary to carry medi-
eyewashing, radio and knowledge of eines for geriatric treatment.
sources of speeific information. In addition The fish factory ships work in conjunc-
to these contents, methyl prednisolone tion with a fleet of small fishing boats. The
aerosol for inhalation and methyl prednis- central medical equipment should be on
olone for injection should be carried. The the former. Thus, the equipment for the
1.3 The Ship's Medical Centre and Medicine Chest 37
fis hing boats may be restricted to first-aid wald [29]; Klepatski [47]; Leach [58]; Low
kits, i. e. the same as the equipment for car- [63]; Schaefer [86]; Tortori-Donati [100])
go vessels solely engaged in coastal trade. may be used as a basis in compiling a list of
If a fishing vessel carries out both the fish- medical scales. According to international
ing and the processing and has no doctor statistics (see Chap. 3.1), experience in the
on board, it should be equipped according Port Health Authority, Hamburg, and dis-
to the medical scale of ships engaged in cussions with many medical specialists,
deep sea voyages, but must have in addi- the sequence and frequency seem to be sim-
tion the equipment appropriate for high- ilar. The sequence in general is as fol-
risk ships. The probability of many minor lows:
accidents will be high. The supply should 1. Injury;
be: elastic bandages; increased supply of 2. Diseases of the digestive system;
splints for finger, arm and leg; special 3~ Diseases of the respiratory system;
splints that can be applied with little 4. Diseases of the musculoskeletal system
knowledge of first-aid, e. g. inflatable and connective tissue;
splints; special adhesive pIaster for large 5. Diseases of the nervous system and
areas of the body; and stretchers, floatable sense organs;
and capable ofbeing picked up by helicop- 6. Diseases of the skin and subcutaneous
ter. The transportation of a patient in a tissue;
rough sea to another ship or helicopter is 7. Symptoms, signs and ill-defined condi-
not difficult, but is dangerous. tions;
8. Diseases of the circulatory system;
1.3.5.4 Vessels Solely Engaged in Coastal 9. Diseases of the genito-urinary system;
Regions 10. Infections and parasitic diseases;
On board ships that work dose to the 11. Mental disorders;
shore, accidents and illnesses may happen 12. Endocrine, nutritional and immunity
but accidents are the main risk. The medi- disorders;
cal supply should indude: bandages, elas- 13. Neoplasms;
tic bandages, adhesive pIaster of two sizes, 14. Diseases of blood and blood-forming
dressings for bums, splints, ointment for organs;
bums, antibiotic ointment and tight ban- Disease ranked 1 to 4 amount to 70% of all
dages for stopping haemorrhages if surgi- diagnoses (according to ICD = Interna-
cal assistance is not available. There may tional Classification of Diseases).
be cases ofheadache, stomach trouble, sea- The ships' officers in charge ofthe medi-
sickness and sunburn; the simplest equip- cal duties on board who were questioned
ment here will suffice. The supply should by the port medical officers said experience
comprise, for example, ten tablets analge- on board shows that there are three groups
sie and ten tablets sedative. Whether medi- of medicine that ought to be better suppli-
eine should be provided for serious condi- ed:
tions such as cardiovascular trouble and 1. Medicines for common colds;
heart failure is doubtful and depends on 2. Medicines for contusions, sprains etc.;
the medical training of the officer. 3. Medicines for so-called rheumatic com-
plaints, e.g. lumbago and myalgia;
1.3.5.5 Vessels on Deep Sea Voyages These comments correspond dosely with
The distribution of diseases on board ships the sequence of diseases. Regarding the
([3]; Borchgrevink et al. [8]; [21]; [22]; [23]; compilation of relevant medical scales for
[24]; [25]; [36]; [37]; [38]; [40]; [45]; Larsen these ships, another consideration may be
[55, 57]; Nocht [71]; [77]; [78]) and the re- useful, i. e. which medicines and other sup-
ports of ships' medical officers (Gruhn- plies are necessary for:
38 1 Introduction to Nautical Medicine
Charcoal for diarrhoea is widely used tion by certain chemicals, polyethylene gly-
and should be on board as tablets or col 400 may be used for eyewashing,
in granulate form, minimum 100 tablets. minimum 500 ml.
There should, however, be medicine avail-
able in case of painful diarrhoea that can- 1.3.5.14 Kidney and Bladder Complaints
not be stopped by eharcoal. In ships of If antibioties are contra-indicated, an anti-
many nations, opium or morphine in liquid septic and analgesie infusion of certain
form is used for this purpose. It does not herbs e. g. fol. uvaeursi may be sufficient. It
seem to be neeessary, but many doctors eould be prepared from a concentrate, min-
and ship's officers request this kind of imum 100 ml.
medieine. There have been no reported For urinary and gall-bladder stones, see
eases of addiction in eonsequence of this "Analgesics", and for infections with an in-
usage, but there are other sufficiendy effec- crease in temperature, see "Antibiotics".
tive drugs. Every year, new antidiarrhetic
drugs are being developed; nevertheless 1.3.5.15 Mycosis
opium and morphine are still in use and Mycosis is more frequent than statisties in-
still to be found in some ships' medical dicate. The number of infections by fungi is
chests. The conclusion must be that there still increasing. Different strains of fungus
should be some form of effective antidiar- give rise to disease, so there should be two
rhetie medicine on board, but it is open to or three different fungicides. Fungicides
discussion as to wh ether this should be opi- should be in liquid, ointment and powder
um or its derivatives; minimum 20 tab lets. form, minimum five botdes each. The
Cases of salmonella and amoebiasis may quantity should be in accordance with the
occur. Diarrhoea with blood in the excre- number of crew members and the need for
ment must be treated on shore by a special- long-term treatment.
ist. Amoebiasis must not be treated on the
basis of suspicion only but must be investi- 1.3.5.16 Ear Trouble
gated on shore. There should be on board analgesic and
anti-inflammatory eardrops, minimum one
1.3.5.12 Diseases of Muscles and Joints bottle, and antibiotie eardrops, minimum
This includes different forms of illness one bottle.
such as rheumatism, myalgia, arthritis and It has proved very useful to have an oto-
ischialgia. On board there should be: anal- seope on board and the person in charge to
gesie and eounter-irritant ointment, mini- be trained to use it. The diagnosis of ceru-
mum 2 x 20 g; acetylsalicylic acid, codeine, men, inflammation and abscesses can be
paraeetamol phenylbutazone or similar made by a layman if he has received in-
tablets, minimum 20 tablets; eounter-irri- struetion in this field. If an ear syringe is on
tant pIaster, minimum five. These will be board, it should be of small size or made of
used frequently. rubber to prevent damage when washing
out the auditory canal.
1.3.5.13 Eye Trouble
On board there should be: Undine for eye- 1.3.5.17 Burns
washing, minimum one; analgesie eye In addition to what is Iisted under "Ae-
drops without cocaine, minimum one bot- cidents" and "Skin Diseases", paraffin
de; antibiotic eyedrops, minimum one bot- gauze dressing is necessary, minimum
de; antibiotic and analgesie ointment for 10 cm x 10 cm, five each, as weil as paraffin
the eyes, minimum one bottle. Neither gauze backed by metallic foi! in large size,
drops nor ointment with eortisone, nor eye- minimum 10em x 1Oem, ten eaeh. (see also
shields, are recommended. For contamina- 1.3.6.3 and 1.3.6.5).
42 1 Introduction to Nautical Medicine
most beverages. It will rarely be used but suffer a first fit while at sea, preventive
must be on board in sufficient quantity; therapy could be achieved with one of the
minimum 20 ml haloperidol solution 2 mg sedatives (see nervous complaints).
in 1 ml.
1.3.5.30 Asthma
1.3.5.25 Abscesses Asthma is a rarity, but it does occur. In a11
See "Skin Diseases". investigated cases, the patients had had
previous attacks. However, considering the
1.3.5.26 Hepatitis toxic effect of, for example, dangerous
Every medicine chest has vitamin tab lets ; goods, toxic spastic bronchitis and oedema
the centuries of avitaminosis, especia11y on of the lungs could occur. Aerosols with
seagoing ships, have passed. Today avita- adrenaline or adrenaline compounds and
minosis caused by lack of fresh food is a cortisone or cortisone compounds should
rarity; rather it is caused by alcoholism. be added to the medical equipment; mini-
Vitamins are the only medicine to be given mum one aerosol.
for hepatitis. If, in an emergency case of
acute hepatic failure, cortisone has to be In the remainder of this chapter, considera-
given under radio advice, the cortisone in tion is given to important groups of medi-
the basic medical equipment will be suffi- cines and indications, and to various other
cient. For hepatitis, alcoholism and colds, diverse factors.
multivitamin tablets may be added to the
equipment. There has been no evidence of 1.3.6 Other Medical Supplies
excessive use of these vitamins on board;
minimum 50 multivitamin tablets. 1.3.6.1 Medicines for Diseases of the Heart
and Cardiovascular System
1.3.5.27 Diabetes Regular medical examinations in most
Specific therapy, e. g. insulin, should only countries perhaps diminish the incidence
be given by a doctor. But for the diagnosis, of cardiovascular diseases on board.
the medicine chest should contain diagnos- Nevertheless, cases of angina pectoris, cor-
tic strips for detecting glucose in the urine. onary thrombosis and heart failure do oc-
To our knowledge, every year there has cur. Suitable medicines for these condi-
been one case of diabetes in which the pat- tions should be carried, but digitalis or
ient was less than 30 years old and ignorant antihypertensive drugs should not be in-
of his condition. It should be routine prac- cIuded. However, a sphygmomanometer
tice on board ship to use the strips for diag- will provide useful information that may be
nosis. It would be an advantage to use transmitted to a doctor on shore giving ra-
combination strips for glucose, albumin, diomedical advice. According to our expe-
blood (erythrocytes), urobilin and pH. rience the sphygmomanometers were very
successfully used on board and radiomedi-
1.3.5.28 Miscarriage cal advice was easier for the doctor.
For bleeding in miscarriage, an ergot deriv- The fundamental point here is: every-
ative in ampoules should be included in the thing should be done to improve the diag-
medicine chest, minimum ten ampoules. nosis of cardiovascular conditions on
board ship as far as modern technical in-
1.3.5.29 Epilepsy struments a11ow. The same applies to the
In general it will not be necessary to carry prophylaxis, e.g. by regular medical exami-
anti-epileptic medicines on board because nation. Medicine in liquid form and am-
most countries will not allow epileptics to poules for the treatment of fainting and low
be employed at sea. If a seafarer should blood press ure, e. g. noradrenaline, should
44 1 Introduction to Nautical Medicine
spectrum type may be of use in special situ- one? The conclusion is inevitable: The in-
ations, e. g. prophylactically after severe fusion which can save lives in a few cases is
buming or poisoning, for infections resis- only possible if the training of the person
tant to injection of penicillin or sulphon- responsible for medical care is sufficiently
amides, for diarrhoea thought to be caused high. The first priority is training, the sec-
by salmonella or cholera, for chancroid ond is equipment.
and for lymphogranuloma.
1.3.6.6 Disinfectant
1.3.6.4 Cortisone There may be incidents of infected potable
Research in the medical use of cortisone is water. There are different means, such as
developing every day. One cortisone deriv- Cl-, Ag- ,03 and ultraviolet rays, of killing
ative should be available for injection. For bacteria in water supplies. From experi-
cases of aHergie re action, insect, fish or ence, Cl-, administered as a chemieal
snake bites, poisoning, acute hepatitis etc., powder, is the best one. It is obtainable in
an effective cortisone derivative in am- every port as a powder or hypochlorite so-
poules must be on board; minimum five lution. It can be detected by smell. If too
ampoules/1000 mg. Tablets of cortisone de- much is added to the water, the taste will be
rivative are rarely used. There may be indi- bad, but it can do no physieal harm. To add
cations, e. g. cases of poisoning and asth- Ag- would also be effective, but it is not
matic allergic reaction, for a prolonged possible to determine whether too much
treatment by tab lets of cortisone deriva- has been added; Ag-, even in high concen-
tives. These tablets complete the equip- trations, is tasteless and odourless. Mini-
ment, but they are not absolutely necessary mum: The ship should be equipped with a
(20 tablets are recommended). Cl- donator sufficient for about 15 tons
of potable water. There may be infected
1.3.6.5 Infusions rooms and sanitary installations. A disin-
It is obvious that in some cases an infusion fectant for walls, fumiture and sanitary in-
saves a life (Ivanov [44]). However, very staHations should be available. Different
many infusions given in hospital, in an am- products such as formaldehyde or quater-
bulance or in a helicopter do no harm but nary ammonium salt (QAC) could be em-
are not really life saving. ployed for this purpose. If they are admin-
There may be cases of severe buming, istered in the right way, i. e. correct concen-
extreme bleeding, poisoning etc. on board tration at the right time, they will be
in which only an intravenous infusion effective. However, the training in disinfec-
might be life saving. However, even a doc- tion is more important then the type of dis-
tor sometimes has difficulties in giving an infectant.
intravenous infusion in an emergency; the Research has proved bacterial contami-
problems facing a lay person in charge of nation to be present in many pantries,
medical care are thus far greater. There are kitchens and provision stores. Regular dis-
infusions that can be administered subcu- infection once a week or twiee a month
taneously, but they are less effective. The would prevent infections and diarrhoea. In
question is whether there should be infu- kitchens, provision stores and pantries,
sions for intravenous use only, whieh in an however, the disinfectant used should not
emergency may weH be useless (minimum have a bad odour or taste. Quatemary am-
5 x 500 ml), infusions for subcutaneous ap- monium salt seems to be suitable for this
plication, the effectiveness of whieh is very purpose.
uncertain, or both infusions. In the latter Conclusion: Recommended are (a) a dis-
case, will the person in charge, in the con- infectant for potable water, minimum CI-
fusion of the emergency, choose the right for 15 tons; (b) a disinfectant for rooms,
46 1 Introduction to Nautical Medicine
20 IV i SS IV
" 11
~ ____ __ =j i -
r-~' -
'1 NARCOTICS ~ ~
t ::.::.:::::.-=:::.---t--_--=-=.::-~~;;;::;.~=~ .,~~ ~~~~':
I 1
I J'---- --..,
" ~
t .:---=.:-.:--=---=::. =- -------=--=1i -----j ~ L.:=~~ 0
o
I 11 --+ ~ BOHLES
t::::.:-.::.: .:::.:. ~--=--=--=--j:IL __ ___ I ~ ~ S2
1 ~
:--------- ---
r-------- - - -
- --- -~i-----,
--- ---< , I
SLiDING
PANEL ()
G L A SS - P L ATED ~ ,, __
j ..
I :' I
~--- - -- --- - ---=-:1t - ~~~ ~ :::~J J-
~~~~~~,,=__
IF= .lo~ __
- -...,- --_
r--.. -r-L .r--L
viet Union, where for long voyages a doc- 1.3.9.2 No Doctor on Board (see also
tor is obligatory. Special training for the Chap.1.4)
doctor is very rarely given. This special If the medical chest is to be used as effec-
training is becoming more and more neces- tively as possible, the person who will use it
sary nowadays. We have many specialised must be correspondingly highly trained.
physicians who are trained in hospitals This training should enable the person in
with modern and ultramodern equipment charge to make a correct diagnosis, to give
from X-ray facilities to well-equipped labo- treatment as advised in the medical guide
ratories. They are not, however, trained to on board ship and to make the necessary
do their job in the environment of a ship al- observations which will assist a radiomedi-
most without technical assistance. Never- cal adviser ashore. An important aspect of
theless, even if a ship is equipped with X- the training will be competence in first aid
ray facilities, electrocardiograph and labo- and emergency treatment. There may be
ratory, this equipment will rarely need to little opportunity for practical experience
be used. The ship cannot be equipped and it is essential that refresher courses be
therefore with the modern diagnostic in- arranged at regular intervals (Backhaus [6];
struments for economic as weil as for prac- Ebert et al. [15]; [24]; [25] ; [30] ; Hager [31] ;
tical reasons. The doctor must be trained to [35]; [36]; [37]; [38]; [39]; [40]; [41]; [46]; [53] ;
carry out his diagnosis and therapy without [59]; [70]; Staton [97]).
the help of these facilities. Soon it may be-
come difficult to find a medical teacher to
train hirn. This is and will remain a very im- 1.3.10 Medical Locker
portant question. It will be helpful for the personnel in
charge and it will save a great deal of mon-
ey if there is a standardised medicallocker
48 1 Introduction to Nautical Medicine
pitäne und Schiffsoffiziere. Berlin: VEB Ver- men Beirats f. Verkehrsmedizin. 24 March
lag Volk und Gesundheit 1980. 1971.
16. Ebert, H.: Die Gewährleistung des Gesund- 29. Gruhnwald, R.: Die medizinische Versorgung
heitsschutzes auf Seeschiffen ohne Arzt, unter an Bord aus der Sicht des Schiffsoffiziers, un-
den Bedingungen und den sich abzeichnen- ter besonderer Berücksichtigung der Ausbil-
den Entwicklungstendenzen im Zusammen- dung in der Gesundheitspflege. Hamburg,
hang mit dem wissenschaftlich-technischen Fachhochschule Hamburg, Department of
Fortschritt in der Schiffahrt der DDR. Disser- Navigation 1980.
tation, University of Rostock 1979. 30. Guia sanitaria a bordo. Madrid: Instituto So-
17. Einführung der Vorschrift über Mitnahme von cial de la Marina 1976.
Medikamenten und med. Ausrüstung in 31. Hager, G.: Die Grundausbildung von Schiffs-
Frankreich, Dänemark und England. StAH: offizieren zu Behandlung von Augenerkran-
Medizinalkollegium, 11, F 2 Vol.I, p.38. kungen und die dazu notwendige Standard-
18. Ewald, M.: Ausrüstung von Seeschiffen mit ausrüstung auf Seeschiffen. In: Fragen der
Arzneimitteln in der Zeit zwischen dem 16. Schiffahrtsmedizin. Vorträge aus dem [nter-
und Anfang des 19.Jahrhunderts. Personal nationalen Symposion, Heiligendamm,
Communication 1971. 28-31 March 1963. Ed.: E. Kersten. Sonder-
19. Fischer, K.-D.: Hafen-Apotheke und medizi- heft des Medizinischen Dienstes des Verkehrs-
nische Schiffsversorgung. In: Medizinische wesens 11. pp. 159-164.
Betreuung an Land und auf See. Ed.: Medizi- 32. Halm, W: Schiffsapotheke, Medikamente und
nischer Dienst des Verkehrswesens der DDR, Medikamentenverluste an Bord. [n: Fortbil-
Direktion Rostock. Rostock 1969, pp.21-22. dungslehrgang über Fragen der Verkehrsme-
20. Fischer, K.-D.: Die medizinische Schiffsaus- dizin und Verkehrspsychologie, 10-15 Feb.
rüstung in Praxis und Lehre. In: V. Internatio- 1964. Sonderheft des Medizinischen Dienstes
nales Symposium über Schiffahrtsmedizin, des Verkehrswesens der DDR 111. pp.
Rostock, 29-31 Oct. 1972. Ed.: Medizinischer 379-392.
Dienst des Verkehrswesens der DDR. Rostock 33. Hospital auf A-Deck (Deck 4). [n: Kreuz-
1973, pp. 93-101 fahrtschiff "Europa". Erbaut von der Bremer
21. Fischereischutzboote und Fischereifor- Vulkan AG Schiffbau und Maschinenfabrik,
schungsschiffe der Bundesrepublik Deutsch- Bremen-Vegesack. Hansa 1/8 [Sonderausgabe
land - Aufgaben und Tätigkeiten von 1948 bis MS "Europa"), 37 (1981).
1975. Ed.: Bundesministerium für Ernährung, 34. [nhalt der Schiffsapotheken und funkärztliche
Landwirtschaft und Forsten. Hamburg: Beratung der Schiffe auf See. [nternationale
Moehlke 1975. Arbeitskonferenz, 41st Meeting 1958. Genf:
22. Fischereischutzboote und Fischereifor- [LO 1957.
schungsschiffe der Bundesrepublik Deutsch- 35. International medical guide for ships. Eds.:
land - Aufgaben und Tätigkeiten von 1948 bis ILO, IMCO, WHO. Geneva: WHO 1967.
1981. Ed.: Bundesministerium für Ernährung, 36. 11 International Symposium or Maritime Med-
Landwirtschaft und Forsten. Hamburg: icine. Gdansk-Gdynia, 16-19 Sept. 1965. Lec-
Moehlke 1982. tures and Reports. Bull. Inst. mar. Med.
23. Fortegnelser over skibsmedicinkisters indhold Gdansk /7,3(1966).
Ufr. handelsministeriets bekendtgorelse, 31 Ju- 37. 111 International Symposium on Marine Med-
Iy 1974, om skibes forsyning med laegemidler icine. Leningrad 1968. Eds.: E. P. Sergeev et al.
m. v.). Appendix to: Laegebog for söfarende. Moscow 1969.
2nd ed. Viborg: Nörhaven Bogtrykkeri 1976. 38. V Internationales Symposium über Schiff-
24. Fourth International Symposium on Marine fahrtsmedizin, Rostock 19-210ct. 1972. Ro-
Medicine, Varna, 15-17 Oct. 1970 stock: Medizinischer Dienst des Verkehrswe-
25. Fragen der Schiffahrtsmedizin. Vorträge aus sens der DDR 1973.
dem Internationalen Symposion, Heiligen- 39. VI International Symposium on Maritime
damm, 28-31 March 1963. Ed.: E.Kersten. Medicine Gdansk, 17-190ct. 1974. Reports.
Sonderheft des Medizinischen Dienstes des Bull. Inst. mar. trop. Med. Gdynia 25, 2/3/4
Verkehrswesens 11. (1974).
26. Goede-Oudegeest, W J.: Farmacie aan boord. 40. VII [nternational Symposium on Marine
Omnia Praescribendi Gratia 34, 27-31 (1968). Medicine 23-30 Sept. 1976, Odessa. Ed.:
27. Goethe, H.: Schiffahrtsmedizin und Tropen- U. M. Stenko. Moscow 1976.
hygiene. In: Taschenbuch der praktischen 41. VIII International Symposium on Marine
Medizin. Ed.: G. Schettler. Stuttgart: Thieme Medicine - Abstracts, Varna, 24-28 Oct. 1978.
1980. pp.1184-1205. 42. Inventario deI materiale sanitario. Ed.: Italia
28. Grewe, H.-E.: Apothekenausrüstung in der di Navigazione. Genoa 1976.
Seeschiffahrt. Lecture. 7. Sitzung d. gemeinsa- 43. [nventory and requisition for medical sup-
50 1 Introduction to Nautical Medicine
plies. (D.S.-Medical equipment list). Revised cante. Junta Nacional da Marinha Mercante,
Sept. 1956. Lisbon 1964.
44. Ivanov, V. N.: Izgotovlenie sterilnykh rastvo- 61. List of medical products suggested by
rov v apteke gospitalya flota. [Preparation of c.1. R. M. Vessels lacking medical facilities.
sterile solvents in ship hospitals' pharmacies]. Boll. anno C. I. R. M., pp. 11-12 (1975).
Voen.-med. Zh. 8, 86 (1969). 62. Liste der medizinischen Schiffsausrüstungen
45. Jahresberichte des hafen- und flughafenärzt- für Seeschiffe der Deutschen Demokratischen
lichen Dienstes. Hamburg 1973174, 1975, Republik (gemäß § 3 der Anordnung über den
1976/77, 1978/79. Gesundheitsschutz an Bord von Seeschiffen,
46. Joint ILO/WHO committee on the health of 23 Jan. 1963. GBI. 11. p.64. Medizinischer
seafarers. Sixth report. Geneva: ILO/WHO Dienst des Verkehrswesens Direktion Schiff-
1981. fahrt, Rostock. Rostock 1964.
47. Klepatski, O.A: 0 nekotorykh pokazatelyakh 63. Low, A: Bericht über die schiffahrtsmedizi-
raboty sudovykh ambulatori vo vremya plava- nischen Untersuchungen an Bord des Segel-
niya. [Some notes on the use of ship's medi- schiffes "Amphitrite" (Clipper Verein e. V.) im
cine chests during sea voyages]. Zdravookhr. Verlauf der 70.Reise vom 2. bis zum 15.Juli
Ross. Fed. 15,29-33 (1971). 1977 in der Ostsee. Hamburg 1977.
48. Koch, W.: Konstruktive Vorschläge zur Ein- 64. Medical allowance list - CG 344. Part 2. Ves-
richtung und Ausrüstung des Hospitaltraktes sels cIass 2A, 2B, 2C, 2D. Prepared by: Medi-
auf Schiffen. Lecture. Meeting Verband cal Control Point USCG Supply Center.
deutscher Schiffswerften (Architekten), Brooklyn: U.S. Coast Guard 1970.
29 Jan. 1970. 65. Medical equipment on board Indian ships.
49. Kohfahl, M.: Sind Sie wirklich nie seekrank? The Gazette ofIndia 42, 1746-1812 (1966).
Boote 10,35-36 (1981). 66. Medical first aid guide for use in accident in-
50. Kohfahl, M.: Seekrankheit. Lecture. Seminar volving dangerous goods. Chemical supple-
"Sicherheit auf See". Landesseglerverband ment to the International medical guide for
Bremen 17-18 Nov. 1979 ships (IMGS). Eds.: IMO, WHO, ILO. Lon-
51. Kontrollbok för svenskt skeppsapotek. Sjöbo: don: WHO 1982.
Nordvall1966. 67. Medicinali, materiale sanitario ed istruzioni
52. Krynicki, A: Analysis ofthe utilization ofhos- per iI loro uso, di cui devono essere dotate le
pital beds of merchant and fishing vessels. imbarcazioni e le zattere di salvataggio. Rome:
Bull. Inst. mar. Med. Gdansk 23, 3/4,131-137 Ministerio della Marina Mercantile 1965.
(1972). 68. The merchant shipping (medical scales) regu-
53. Laegebog for sofarende. Eds.: c.J. Mollen- lations 1974. Statutory instruments. 1974,
bach and A Mahneke. Viborg: Norhaven No.1193 Merchant shipping: masters and sea-
Bogtrykkeri 1976. men. London: Her Majesty's Stationery Office
54. Larsen, 0.: Medisinsk journalmateriale fra 1974.
1700-tallet som utgangspunkt for historiske 69. Milcheva, Yem., M. Mikhaylov and T. Todo-
undersökelser. Sydsvenska Medicinhistoriska rov: Za standartizirane ustroystvoto na korab-
Sällskapets Arsskrift 1968. nite aptechni shkafore i podrezhdaneto na le-
55. Larsen, 0.: Med sjofolks helse som siktepunkt. karstvenite sredstva v tyakh. [Standardization
Det sjofartsmedisinske institutt i Hamburg. of ship's medicine chest's design and the ar-
Liv. og helse 38, 174-177 (1971). rangement of medicaments therein]. Transp.
56. Larsen, 0.: Schiff und Seuche 1795-1799. Ein med. Vesti 22, 2, 44-51 (1977).
medizinischer Beitrag zur historischen Kennt- 70. Nauticus. EncycIopedie pratique du bateau.
nis der Gesundheitsverhältnisse an Bord 1. Medecine en mer sans medecin. 4. Guide
dänisch-norwegischer Kriegsschiffe auf den pratique de la vie a bord. Ed.: G.Borg. Paris:
Fahrten nach Dänisch-Westindien. Oslo: Uni- Editions Maritimes et d'Outre-Mer 1977.
versitetsforlaget 1968. 71. Nocht, B.: Vorlesungen für Schiffsärzte der
57. Larsen, 0.: Schiffsarztjournale dänisch-nor- Handelsmarine über Schiffshygiene, Schiffs-
wegischer Kriegsschiffe aus der Zeit vor und Tropenkrankheiten. Leipzig: Thieme
1814, die im Reichsarchiv von Kopenhagen 1906.
aufbewahrt werden. Eine Quellenübersicht. 72. NomencIature du materiel medical et phar-
Oslo: Universitetsforlagets Trykningssentral maceutique a embarquer sur les navires de
1967. peche (sans medecin a bord). Draft by an
58. Leach, R. D.: The medicine of ocean yacht rac- international group of physicians for E. c.,
ing. Brit. med. J. 2, 6154, 1771-1773 (1978). 1978.
59. Leach, H.: The ship captain's medical guide. 73. NomencIature du materiel medical et phar-
London: Simpkin, Marshall1879. maceutique aembarquer. Paris: Journaux offi-
60. Legisla~äo de interesse para a marinha mer- ciels 1971. (Navigation maritime No. 71-16)
1.3 The Ship's Medical Centre and Medicine Chest 51
74. Normal-Einrichtungen der Hospitäler und 91. Ships' medicine chests. Bol!. anno C. I. R. M.
Operationsräume auf Schiffen - nach Anga- pp. 10-11 (1971).
ben von H.Minning. Hamburg: Schulz & 92. The ship's medicine ehest and medical aid at
Zaage 1939. sea. Ed.: U. S. Department of HeaIth, Educa-
75.0nnen, M.: Untersuchungen über die Versor- tion, and Welfare, Public HeaIth Service,
gung der Schiffahrt mit Medikamenten, Ver- Health Services Administration, Bureau of
bandstoffen und Hilfsmitteln zur Kranken- Medical Services. Washington: U.S. Govern-
pflege. (Ein kritischer internationaler Ver- ment Printing Office 1978.
gleich). Dissertation, University of Hamburg 93. Sobol, Z. and K.Zurawiecki: Nowa wersja
1975. rozwiazania bloku szpitalnego na trawle-
76. Pomorska medicina II [naucne rasprave]. rach-przetworniach. [New design of hospitals
Nautical Medicine II [Scientific reports]. Bel- on manufacturing fish trawlers]. Bull. Inst.
grad: Izdanje Mornarickog glasnika 1979. mar. Med. Gdansk 14, 3/4, 309-312 (1963).
(Pomorska biblioteka. Sveska 30) 94. Sobol, Z. and A. Krynicki: Design of hospital
77. Proceedings ofthe European nautical medical rooms and sickbays on ships. In: Human fac-
meeting, Hamburg, 1978. - Panel discussion tors in the design and operation of ships. Pro-
of day to day problems. Ed.: H. Goethe. ceedings ofthe First International Conference
78. Proceedings of the second European nautical on Human Factors in the Design and Opera-
medical officers meeting, West Sussex, tion of Ships. Gothenburg, February 1977.
10-14 Sept. 1979. Stockholm: Garmat Service 1978.
79. Ram, l.: Maritime health services at sea. 95. Socialstyrelsens Kungörelse om skeppsapotek.
SAPANUT 6, 2, 4-8 (1976). (40ct. 1968). Kung!. Sjöfartsstyrelsen Medde-
80. Recommendation concerning the contents of landen 8, 1-19 (1969).
medicine chests on board ship. Recommenda- 96. Socialstyrelsens Kungörelse om skeppsapotek,
tion 105. Geneva: International Labour Con- 31 Oct. 1979. Socialstyrelsens författningssam-
ference 1958. ling 25 (1979).
81. Sanitarnyie pravila dlya morskikh sudov 97. Staton, A. B.: Handbook of medicines and
SSSR. [Sanitary regulations for seagoing ships their use for the ship's medicine ehest at sea.
ofthe USSR]. Odessa: Moryak 1964. New Orleans: Lykes Lines 1980.
82. Schadewaldt, H.: Bemerkungen zur Ge- 98. Stjepanovic, R.: Prirucnik 0 brodskim apote-
schichte der Marinepharmazie. Veröff. int. kama. [Handbook of ship's medicine chests].
Ges. Gesch. Pharm. 10,157-177 (1957). Belgrad : Udruzenje zdravstvenih radnika SR
83. Schadewaldt, H.: Geschichte der Schiffahrts- Crne Gore 1973.
medizin und Marinepharmazie. Wehrdienst 99. Sudovye aptechki. [Ship's medicine ehest]. In:
Gesundheit 9, 5-56 (1963). Meditsinskoe posobie dlya kapitanov sudov.
84. Schadewaldt, H.: Lazarettschiffe und Marine- 2nd edn. Moscow: Reklambyuro 1970.
lazarette. Ciba-Z. 7, 2531-2533 (1955). pp. 202-233.
85. Schadewaldt, H.: Die Schiffsapotheke im Mit- 100. Tortori-Donati, 8.: La attrezzatura ed il fun-
telalter. Sollemnia 700 anno rum stationis aro- zionamento deI reparto sanitario di grandi
maticae. Traguriensis de qua primitus memo- transatlantici stranieri. Lav. e Med. 20, 3,
ria extat MCCLXXI. Zagreb 1973. 105-118 (1977).
86. Schaefer, H.l.: Die medizinische Versorgung 101. Ulrich, B.: Ärztliche Hilfe auf hoher See.
an Bord aus der Sicht des Schiffsoffiziers, un- Deutsches Forschungsschiff im Einsatz. Der
ter besonderer Berücksichtigung der medizi- schwimmende Operationssaal. General-An-
nischen Ausrüstung. Hamburg, Fachhoch- zeiger d. Stadt Wuppertal, 20 April 1968. p.29.
schule Hamburg, Department of Navigation 102. Urner, c.J. and A.8.Staton: The medi-
1980. eine ehest at sea. New Orleans: Lykes Lines
87. Schmidt, R. and A.Kludas: Die deutschen La- 1981.
zarettschiffe im Zweiten Weltkrieg. Stuttgart: 103. Vinkovetski, A. Ya and Ye. P. Krivenda: Spra-
Motorbuch Verlag 1978. vochnik po oborudovaniyu bytovykh i medi-
88. Serdarevic, S., O. Cupahin, V. Tonkovic et a!.: tsinskikh pomeshcheni na morskikh sudakh.
Sastav brodske Ijekarne. [Assortment of the [Manual on the equipment of living rooms and
ship's medicine ehest]. In: Pomorska medici- medical centers on seagoing ships]. Lenin-
na. [Naucne rasprave]. Belgrad: Izdanje Mor- grad: Izdatelstvo "Sudostroenie" 1968. .
narickog glasnika 1975. pp.99-105. (Pomor- 104. Volbehr, K.: Arzenei aus dem Meere vom
ska biblioteka. Sveska 26) 17.lahrhundert bis heute. Bremerhaven: NW
89. Sherlock, P.: Recommended drug and equip- Ditzen.
ment list. Manuscript 1969. 105. Volbehr, K.: Gesundheit an Bord. Kleine Ge-
90. The ship's medicine ehest. Department of schichte der Hygiene und Arzneimittelversor-
Nautical Medicine, Hamburg 1977. gung auf Schiffen. Bremerhaven: Deutsches
52 1 Introduction to Nautical Medicine
Schiffahrtsmuseum 1979. (Führer des 108. Zorn, E.: Einmalspritzen in der Krankenbe-
Deutschen Schiffahrtsmuseums, No. 11) handlung an Bord. Hansa 106, 3, 240-241
106. Volkov, Yu. N.: Razvertyvanie rentgenologi- (1969).
cheskogo otdeleniya na pasazhirskom teplo- 109. Zorn, E.: Die Verwendung von Verbandpfla-
khode. [Establishment of an X-ray station on a stern an Bord von Schiffen. Hansa lOS, 1750
passenger ship]. Voen.-med. Zh. 7, 19-20 and 1760 (1968).
(1971).
107. White, P. c., jr.: A survey of medical care in the Addendum
United States merchant marine. Milit. Med. 110. Brochmann, 1. H. H.: F0rstehjelp ombord.
142,8,613-616 (1977). [Oslo:) Gf0ndahI1982.
1.4 Medical Care on Ships Without a Doctor-
Radio Medical Advice
W. H.G.Goethe
1.4.1 Health Situation on Board ty to bear as he has to care for the health
and well-being of the ship's crew. His
When considering the possibilities and the judgement on the severity of an iIIness, on
standard of heaIth care on board and the need for radio medical advice and/or
ashore, the following facts become evident: on whether to call at a port may, if faulty,
In an emergency, people of industrial put a life in danger.
countries are used to prompt medical care The health standard of crew members on
in a c1inic and/or a hospital. Even in de- board often leaves much to be desired. In
veloping countries medical services are many shipping countries regular fitness
generally available within several hours. check-ups are necessary as a preventive
On board ships the situation is quite differ- measure. If there are high examination
ent. Only a very few ships anywhere still standards the general state of health of
carry a doctor; thus the crew members are crew members can be considered satisfac-
dependent on the medical care of laymen tory, but irrespective of this fact intercur-
with very limited medical qualifications. In rent diseases or accidents still occur, requir-
others words, there is a discrepancy be- ing immediate medical treatment.
tween the possibilities of medical care There are crew members on board many
ashore (high standard) and on board (low vessels of different countries who either
standard). This discrepancy increases from have never had any medical fitness check-
year to year, which might be explained by ups or only cursory inadequate examina-
the fact that standards of health care ash- tions. The environment on board can exac-
ore are constantly rising in most countries erbate a pre-existing lesion which may in
whereas, according to the experience of turn lead to Iife-endangering illness with
nautical medical experts, care on board has no doctor on board.
scarcely improved in recent years. It has to In principle, the possibilities of improv-
be emphasised that seamen on board rep- ing the health care on board are rather re-
resent a population at risk in respect of stricted. There are only three ways of im-
medical care in cases of accident and dis- portance:
ease. 1. Training of personne! in charge of the
It is often assumed that in cases of acci- health care on board;
dent or disease on board seagoing vessels 2. Ship's medical kit (medical chest) in-
only medical first aid is required. This is a c1uding the ship's medical guide;
complete misunderstanding as most seago- 3. Radio medical advice.
ing vessels will be at sea for days or even The medical training of shipboard per-
weeks before they reach any port. Conse- sonne! is, without doubt, the most impor-
quently not only first aid but also second tant factor in securing a satisfactory stan-
and third aid have to be given.The crew dard of health care on board. An adequate
member in charge of medical care (usually ship's medical kit must be complemented
one of the officers) has a great responsibili- by an officer in charge who is competent in
54 1 Introduction to Nautical Medicine
basic medical skills. Naturally, it is useless ry of medieines and supplies and immuni-
to have an excellent kit with unskilled per- sation procedures. White [58] found that
sonnel using it. midshipmen who received treatment
The standard of the medical outfit on aboard ship were not adequately treated.
board varies from country to country. He recommended the following:
Many seafaring countries do not have any 1. Improvement ofthe medical training, in-
regulations pertaining to the medical kit on c1uding better training standards;
board, whereas others are required by law 2. Refresher courses for shipboard medical
to have excellent kits. personnei;
Industrial countries usually have their 3. The first aid requirements for first li-
own medical guides (e.g. Great Britain: cences should exceed those of the basic
The Ship Captain's Medical Guide [46]; the first aid course of the American Red
United States: The Ship's Medicine Chest Cross;
and Medical Aid at Sea [47)). The Interna- 4. Better and standardised medical content
tional Medical Guide Jor Ships (WHO/ILO of the sick-bay and medieine chest
IIMCO [20)) sQould be compulsory on aboard ship;
board vessels of those nations not having 5. Improvement of immunisation sched-
national guides. Radio medical advice is in ules.
many cases a great help but its possibilities Another who reports on the necessity of
are still rather limited (see 1.4.4). improving the medical training of ships' of-
Only a very few publications are avail- ficers is Vuksanovic [56]. In his opinion the
able conceming the general health situa- present medical tuition in maritime schools
tion on board. Most of them deal with spe- is restrieted and quite inadequate. Conse-
eific health hazards only, exc1uding the quently he urgently recommends extension
general considerations. However, as long of the medical tuition syllabus, with em-
ago as 1968 Goethe [9] pointed to the gen- phasis on how to render first aid until the
eral health situation on board and the ne- ship reaches port and thus a hospital.
cessity of improving the medical training of The WHO and the Joint ILO/WHO
ship's officers. Tumbull [55] reviewed the Committee on the Health of Seafarers in
different aspects of the seafarer's health in their various sessions dealt fully with the
a study of European shipping countries heaIth care of seafarers and its resuItant ef-
and the USA. White [57], in his review, em- feets on the ship's operation. The Commit-
phasises the need for striet health stan- tee made a considerable number of recom-
dards for ships' crews. Different authors re- mendations which in many countries are
port on the standard of health on board still awaiting implementation [19, 22, 23,
merchant vessels of their countries, ex- 24, 25, 26, 44].
pressing most varying opinions on the ap- Slutsker [50] and Gurvich and Styazhki-
propriate health care and/or relevant med- na [16] report on the assignment of doetors
ical training: Ram [41]; Tenfjord [53]; and surgical assistants on board USSR ves-
Grewe [13]; Kharalanov et al. [27]; Goethe sels. Ships with more than 40 persons on
[10]; Ebert [3, 4, 5]; Tumbull [54]; Kraljevic board have to carry a doetor, 25-40 per-
and Ditrih [28]; Mikhailova et al. [33]. Siem sons on board require a surgical assistant
[48] reported speeifically on self-care and if there are less than 25 one of the offi-
among seamen on Norwegian ships. cers is usually entrusted with the medical
A questionnaire study was made on care.
board 89 US merchant marine ships deal-
ing with the training of personnel in charge
of the medical care, sick-bay facilities,
availability of medical references, invento-
1.4 Medical Care on Ships Without a Doctor - Radio Medical Advice 55
1.4.2 Who Performs Medical flag may have a purser on board who has
Treatment on Board? undergone the additional medical training
of a marine physician assistant. This in-
In practically all seafaring nations the volves several years' paramedic training,
ship's captain has to bear the entire respon- which was introduced in the USA by the
sibility for the ship's operation, the crew Staff Officers' Association. Of course, only
members and the cargo. This naturally in- a small nu mb er of US flag vessels carry a
cludes the health care of seafarers as weil purser and thus a marine physician assis-
as medical aid in case of sickness and acci- tant. The training standards are rather high
dent. Only in exceptional cases does he and consequently guarantee appropriate
perform the medical care on board himself. health care of the ship's crew [38].
In general three occupational groups On board most ships medical care is the
which may be assigned to the medical care duty of one of the deck officers who has
of crew members and passengers on board been designated by the ship's captain. In
can be distinguished: many countries the first officer is entrusted
1. The ship's doctor; with the task but in others it is the respon-
2. The paramedic (enfermero, feldscher, sibility of the second or third officer. In the
surgical assistant, marine physician as- German Federal Republic it is traditional
sistant etc.); to delegate the duty to the second officer.
3. Master, deck officer (chief steward on In some countries, however, the most quali-
some English and Asian ships). fied officer is assigned, irrespective of rank.
Nowadays very few doctors are employ- The deck officer in charge usually gives
ed at sea. In most countries only passenger the medical care in addition to his normal
vessels, fishery protection vessels, research duty, e.g. watchkeeping. Normally there
vessels and large fish processing vessels are no fixed consulting hours. The officer
still carry a doctor. There are a few excep- has to be present in case of sickness or acci-
tions in countries such as the USSR Po- dent. On some of the ships, however, fixed
land, the GDR Bulgaria and Rumania, consulting hours have been instituted.
which provide a doctor on board vessels
with a large number of crew members. It 1.4.3 Medical Education of
would seem that 95% of all seafarers are Shipboard Personnel
employed on board vessels without doc-
tors. The extent of the medical training of the
The occupation of a so-called paramedic crew me mb er in charge of health care on
is recognised in only a few countries. Por- board is the decisive factor in successful
tuguese, Brasilian and other South Ameri- treatment of sick or injured crew members.
can vessels carry an enfermero. This is Incorrect diagnoses and/or careless han-
usually a male or fe male who has had addi- dling of an accident may lead to severe
tional medical training for sea service. Be- physical disablement or even death. Cases
sides their medical duties they are usually have arisen where the disregard of certain
in charge of administrative tasks. USSR symptoms and/or the failure to call at a
vessels with a medium number of crew port in emergency has had fatal results (e. g.
members frequently carry a surgical assis- high fever and no treatment in cases of
tant (feldscher) who is given a special med- malaria). The load of responsibility is rath-
ical training for several years, which, how- er heavy and can be made bearable only if
ever, does not come up to a medical degree adequate medical training has been given.
standard. The surgical assistant is responsi- The following possibilities and practices of
ble for the preventive and curative medical basic medical training of ship's officers can
care on board. Ships sailing und er the US be found worId-wide:
56 1 Introduction to Nautical Medicine
The training programme of the 4-week mates and captains. Experience shows that
course for licences AM and AG (senior of- good results have been achieved with par-
ficers and masters) is based on an agree- ticipants sent by shipping companies. The
ment between the Free and Hanseatic City seafaring officers and captains know the
of Hamburg and the German Federal Min- problems of medical treatment of sick or
istry of Transport. The syllabus naturally injured persons on board, so they are keen
alters slightly from time to time, but basi- to become more proficient. The course
cally the content has remained unchanged consists of combined theoretical/practical
in recent years. The theoreticallectures and lessons spanning roughly 35 h.
demonstrations are given to the group as a Similar refresher courses on a voluntary
whole, but for practical training, even bed- basis which, however, last 4 weeks are held
side teaching, the 18 participants are split at the Maritime Institute of Technology
up into groups of three to achieve a better and Graduate Study (International Organi-
teaching impact. The course finishes with zation ofMasters, Mates and Pilots) in Bal-
practical and theoretical examinations. In timore, USA. The training programme is
the practical examination the participants quite intensive, predominantly involving
have to prove, inter alia, knowledge of practical exercises, but also including the-
physical examination techniques, emergen- oretical lectures and occasional assign-
cy care, injection techniques and urine ments to in-patient wards in hospitals. The
analyses. The theoretical examination is a first part of the course ends with the award
written test according to the multiple of a certificate of an Emergency Medical
choice system. The issue of licences is sub- Technician [31].
ject to the candidate passing the examina-
tions. 1.4.4 Radio Medical Advice
For the AK licence (masters and mates
in coastal trade) a 2-week course with a Radio medical advice is the only possibility
limited training programme was set up. the ship's officer has of asking for medical
The tutor has overall responsibility for help in the event of disease or accident
planning the curriculum timetable and for when he is in difficulty [37]. The potential
co-ordinating the final examination. The of radio medical advice is, however, often
success ofthe course depends to a great ex- overestimated. Very often the opinion is
tent on his enthusiasm and ability to liaise heard that radio medical advice practically
with staff and students. Unless he can keep replaces the medical training of the ship-
the course running smoothly and keep in- board personnel and makes a well-
terest and morale at a high level, the results equipped medical chest superfluous. This
will suffer. is, in fact, amistaken view. Radio medical
In planning the course, emphasis must advice from doctors can only succeed if
be given to practical aspects as opposed to there is a competent person on board with
set lectures, which should be kept to a min- a basic knowledge of medicine. The crew
imum requirement. Wherever possible, the- member in charge must be able to describe
oretical instruction should be interspersed the symptoms and must know what infor-
with demonstrations, practical training and mation is needed to make a diagnosis and
teaching in out-patient and in-patient to advise treatment. The risk ofwrong diag-
wards of the Port Hospital. In addition, the noses is very high when the inadequate ba-
participants should be given the opportuni- sic medical knowledge of the shipboard
ty to attend out-patient, night-time and personnel does not provide enough clear
weekend emergency duty services. details of the history, signs and symptoms
Refresher courses of 1 week on a volun- to enable a fairly safe diagnosis to be made.
tary basis are also offered for experienced One should never forget that the advising
58 1 Introduction to Nautical Medicine
doctor is not in a position to see and to ex- 1931, Yugoslavia in 1938 etc. Since 1932
amine the patient hirns elf but that, on the the International Telecommunication Un-
contrary, he is dependent on the inexpert ion (ITU) has published information on
observations made by the shipboard per- coastal radio stations which provide these
sonne!. He has to perform "teletherapy", a services.
method of medical treatment which is not The International Radio medical Centre
provided for in medical education at uni- (CIRM) was founded in 1935 in Rome on
versities. the initiative of Professor Guida as the first
The following short history of radio institution for international cooperation on
medical advice was given by Goethe et a!. radio medical consultation. Over the years
[11]: Radio medical advice became possi- it became the main European centre for ra-
ble with the introduction of radiotelegra- dio medical advice. After World War 11 the
phy by Marconi in 1897. With the intro duc- CIRM joined forces with the US Coast
tion of radio equipment on ships and the Guard and the Automated Mutual Assis-
construction of coastal radio stations it be- tance Vessel Rescue System (AMVER sys-
came possible for ships with or without a tem), which has been providing invaluable
doctor on board to obtain medical advice help to shipping in the Atlantic since 1958
by radiotelegraphy. There were, however, and the Pacific since 1966. The Coast
no national or international rules for this Guard regularly issues information in the
procedure. On November 18, 1920 a com- form of the AMVER Bulletin throughout
mercial radio license was issued to the Sea- the AMVER system.
men's Church Institute of New York for The Joint ILO/WHO Committee on the
the purpose of providing radio medical ad- Health of Seafarers at its second session in
vice to ships. At that time the manpower 1954 also discussed the matter of radio
losses of the world merchant fleet as a re- medical advice for ships at sea. After a
sult of sickness and injury in the open sea number of meetings and conferences the
averaged seven seamen daily. The station following ILO Recommendation NO.106
of the Seamen's Church Institute of New [42] was adopted on 13 May 1958:
York, with a broadcasting range of a) Medical advice by radio to ships at sea
2500 miles, offered radio medical advice is available free of charge at any hour of
from a team of doctors. Information on the the day or night;
existence of radio medical advice was b) The medical advice available includes,
propagated on first - aid courses and in the where necessary and practicable, spe-
Manual on Ship Sanitation and First AidJor cialist advice;
Merchant Seamen, published by the medi- c) Adequate use is made of the radio ad-
cal team of the Seamen's Church Institute vice facilities available, inter alia, by in-
(Manning [32]). struction of seagoing personnel and by
International regulations in this field medical guides which indicate clearly
were not introduced before the 1927 Wash- and concisely the type of information
ington Conference, when a comprehensive which will help the doctor in giving his
medical section was added to the Interna- advice, so that the person on board ship
tional Code of Signals with the support of who seeks advice understands what sort
the Office International d'Hygiene Pu- of information is required by the advis-
blique. The medical part was intended to ing doctor;
make radio medical consultation easier for d) An up-to-date and complete list of radio
the physicians. Radio medical services stations from which medical advice can
were set up in many maritime countries in be obtained is carried on each ship
the late 1920s and 1930s - namely Japan in equipped with radio installations, and
1928, the Netherlands in 1930, Germany in kept in the custody of the officer or, in
1.4 Medical Care on Ships Without a Doctor - Radio Medical Advice 59
the case of smaller vessels, of the person Ebert [51]; Ebert and Warncke [6]; USSR,
responsible for radio duties. Sinitsyn et al. [49]; Poland, Krynicki et al.
Today there are over 200 radio stations [29], USA, Manning [32], Sweden, Hansson
engaged in radio medical advice all over et al. [18] and the UK, Lamont [30]; Brayley
the world. Thus medical advice can quickly [59]; Renfrew [43].
be obtained and proper measures taken in
emergencies at sea. 1.4.4.1 The Ship's Side - Medical
There are very few international publica- Emergencies on Board
tions dealing with the problem of radio Radio medical advice is normally required
medical advice. Special attention has to be on board vessels in emergencies only. The
paid to the long-term in-depth studies of main reasons for medical consultations are
CIRM (Durante [1]; Guida [14, 15]). In the as follows:
Netherlands, Steensma [52] was an early pi- 1. The medical skill of the ship's captain
oneer when he established the radio medi- and/or officer or even the paramedic is
cal service which is attached to the tele- insufficient for a proper diagnosis and
communication system of the coastal radio the subsequent medical treatment.
station Scheveningen. The study by Myhre 2. The crew member in charge of the health
[34] on the radio medical advice via radio care on board wants to share his sole re-
Bergen became quite well known in Nor- sponsibility by consulting a radio medi-
way. cal doctor. Legally the responsibility is
Goethe et al. [11] state in their review of then largely delegated to the consulting
the problems and the need for improve- physician.
me nt of the radio medical service some es- 3. The medical kitl chest on board (instru-
sential points of qualified radiomedical ad- ments, remedies, other auxiliary materi-
vice: al) is insufficient and the expert advice
1. Good quality of telecommunication; of a doctor is needed.
2. Considerable improvement to be expect- 4. It may happen that in special cases the
ed by means of satellite communication; necessity for surgical procedures or spe-
3. General medical and nautical medical cial life-saving measures cannot be de-
skill of the advising physician; cided by those on board.
4. Medical training oflay persons entrusted Häberle [171 interviewed 43 nautical offi-
with medical care on board (ship's offi- cers and captains about their experiences
cer, paramedic etc.); with radio medical advice and found that
5. Medical guide with instructions on how the total number of radio medical consulta-
to ask for medical advice; tions by German officers is low. Only 75
6. Appropriate content of the ship's medi- consultations took pi ace during a total of
cine chest (drugs and medical instru- 309 years of ship board service. In other
ments), including directions for use. words: approximately every 4 years a
Some authors report on the national fa- ship's officer asks for radio medical advice.
cilities and practical experience of radio Of the interviewed officers, 30% had never
medical advice. Ohashi [35] published sta- called for radio medical advice.
tistical data ofthe Japanese maritime radio The radio medical advice call is normal-
stations. The evaluation of these data rep- ly instituted on board on agreement be-
resents - beside the regular CIRM reports tween the officer in charge and the ship's
(Bollettino Annuale) - one of the very few captain. An attempt at contact with a coast-
available sources of any such information. al radiostation of the horne country is of-
The national experience of radio medical ten made. Obviously the ship's officers
advice is also documented for the foIlow- have more faith in the doctors of the horne
ing countries: GDR, Paul [36]; Stanzeit and country who on account of their knowl-
60 1 Introduction to Nautical Medicine
edge of shipboard conditions and the lan- The check-list form ofthese questionnaires
guage are expected to give the best adviee. differs, but they all basieally rest on the cri-
If this is not possible they try to reach a teria of collecting within a very short time
nearby coastal station or a particular sta- all the necessary data on the medieal histo-
tion already known for high-quality adviee, ry, the present state of the patient, the med-
e.g. CIRM. On board USSR, GOR and ical treatment already given, the medieal
other vessels an attempt is invariably made facilities on board etc. Goethe et al. [11].
to reach their home countries. Unfortunately, radio medieal check-lists
Radio medieal adviee calls are made ei- are used to only a very limited extent
ther by telegraphy or telephony. Both world-wide. General use of this method
procedures have their advantages and dis- would improve the quality of the advice
advantages. The advantage of telegraphy is given.
that the enquiry and the answer are trans-
mitted in full text without any atmospheric 1.4.4.2 The Shoreside - Who Gives Radio
interference. The scant information in a Medical Advice?
telegram however, provides insufficient in- More than 200 radio stations of countries
formation. The International Code of Sig- world-wide transmit radio medieal adviee
nals provides a medieal code. By using the calls, mostly free of charge. With few ex-
code, language difficulties are easier to ceptions the advice is given not only by the
overcome, but the decoding is time con- doctor attached to the radio station. A link
suming. In the International Signal Book is established with a nearby specialist, e. g.
[21] it is recommended that enquiries a port health officer or - as in most cases -
should be set out fully and that only in case a specialist in the nearest local hospital
of language difficulties should the code be (Goethe et al. [11]). There are, of course, ad-
used. vantages and disadvantages to this method.
The advantage of telephone calls is that It is very helpful to consult a hospital if a
direct communieation with the radio medi- specialist is available at all times, but it may
cal adviee doctor ensues. Good communi- be that there is no specialist on duty. In that
cation is usually possible via UHF, but event there may be a relatively young, inex-
technical difficulties frequently occur and perienced doctor on duty, especially at
interfere with contacts via short wave or night or at the weekend, which does not
medium wave. The calls are occasionally contribute to the effectiveness of the radio
completely disturbed through atmospheric medical advice. Radio medieal work dif-
interference. Satellite communication of- fers in many ways from ordinary medical
fers a considerable improvement of radio- practice. The doctor is trained and required
medical adviee facilities. It is, however, to examine the patient with the help of his
necessary to have the phone numbers of own senses (eyes, ears, touch) and to estab-
the radio medical advice institutions avail- lish a diagnosis on the basis of his own ob-
able on board. The use of coastal radio sta- servations and additional laboratory, x-
tions as intermediaries is not possible. ray, ECG and other data. Establishing a
A precise diagnosis is aprerequisite for diagnosis and proceeding with treatment
correct radio medical adviee. The advising without even seeing the patient (remote
doctor is in a position to make a correct di- treatment, teletherapy) is not only unusual,
agnosis only if the verbal information con- but in several countries is also forbidden by
tains as many details as necessary to get a law. In most civilised countries the treat-
clear pieture of the disease or accident in ment of the siek and injured is entrusted to
question. This requires adequate expertise qualified doctors only. Radio medical ad-
from the officer in charge. Many countries vice is an exception where both of the
developed questionnaires for use on board. above-mentioned principles must be violat-
1.4 Medical Care on Ships Without a Doctor - Radio Medical Advice 61
ed (an emergency where the law cannot be sand. The radio medical activities of differ-
applied). ent countries can be compared only to a
There are a few well-established radio certain degree. An idea of the incidence in
medical advice systems with different so me countries mentioned here can be seen
structures: in the following table (Goethe et al. [11]).
Centro Internazionale Radio Medico
(CIRM) Average number of consultation cases
per years
This system, which is linked with all Italian
and also with numerous non-European ra- Upto 100 cases Belgium, Ger-
dio stations, was founded in 1935 by Pro- man Democratic
fessor Guida in Rome. A nautical medical Republic, Fin-
specialist is on duty at all times, thus ensur- land, Sweden
ing high-quality advice. Additional special- Upto 500 cases Federal Repub-
ist advice is available upon request. lic of Germany,
Great Britain, Is-
Netherlands/Radio Scheveningen rael, Yugoslavia,
This service always has one experienced Norway, Poland
nautical-medical specialist on duty. The U P to 1 000 cases Japan
doctor can be reached via a wireless receiv- More than 1000 cases Italy (CIRM),
er placed at his disposal by the Dutch Post The Nether-
Telephone-Telegraph Service (Semaphone lands, USA
Service similar to the Euro Signal System).
Upon receiving the signal, the duty doctor Unfortunately information on frequency
calls Radio Scheveningen via telephone, rates of diagnoses in radio medical advice
receives telegrams or telephone messages is scarce world-wide. Goethe et al. [11] gave
and establishes a direct telephone link with a considerable nu mb er of further refer-
the ship in trouble ([39]; [40]; Steensma ences, but it is impossible to compare these
[52]). accurately because the diseases were classi-
fied in different ways. In no case was the
The Spanish Radio Medical Advice Centre International Classification of Diseases of
in Madrid (Centro Radio Medico Espaiiol) the WHO referred to.
A doctor can be consuIted day and night. The most detailed documentation is
The medical records of all Spanishseafar- available from Japan, Italy (CIRM) and
ers are available. the Netherlands. In addition, some of the
data from Poland, the German Democratic
Japan Republic, Sweden and Yugoslavia could
The Seamen Relief Association set up ra- be evaluated.
dio medical advice facilities in 1928. Today The detailed statistical data from Japan
13 hospitals are linked with 10 coastal ra- show that the majority of diagnoses re-
dio stations. Ten of these hospitals belong ferred to diseases of the digestive system. It
to the Japan Seamen Relief Organization, is evident from this analysis that the rate of
three to the Japanese Seamen Insurance diseases of the digestive system is higher on
Association. foreign (30.6%) than on Japanese vessels
(27.9%). The statistics of CIRM also show
1.4.4.3 Results of Radio Medical Advice a high percentage of diseases of the diges-
The number of consultations per year var- tive system (19.6%). Nevertheless, in
ies greatly from one country to another, CIRM data the frequency rate of 21.2% for
ranging from a few cases to several thou- "symptoms, senility and morbid states not
62 1 Introduction to NauticaI Medicine
5. Adequate provision of drugs and medical 10. Goethe, H.: Probleme der medizinischen Be-
instrumentation. Most countries enforee treuung an Bord von Schiffen ohne Arzt - Die
Situation der Ausbildung in der Bundesrepu-
their national reeommendations for the
blik Deutschland. In: V. Internationales Sym-
eontent of the medieal ehest. However, posium über Schiffahrtsmedizin vom 19. bis
on many vessels the medieal kit available 21.0ktober 1972 in Rostock. Vorträge. Ed.:
is poor and/or obsolete so that treatment Medizinischer Dienst des Verkehrswesens der
advised via radio medical adviee may DDR. Rostock [1973]. pp.103-108.
11. Goethe H., E. Zorn and A. Azzuqa: The radio
not be possible. International reeom- medical advice in seafaring. Problems and pos-
mendations on the minimum require- sibilities of improvement. Hamburg: Schiff-
ments for the medieal ehest are indispen- fahrts-Verlag "Hansa" 1981.
sable. 12. Goethe, H.: Sicknesses, injuries and health care
on board - medical education of shipboard per-
sonnel. Lecture. International Workshop on
References Human Relationship on Board. Bremen, Janu-
ary 21-22,1982.
1. Durante, F.: Servizio medico del C. I. R. M. e 13. Grewe, H.E.: Erste Hilfsmaßnahmen und
suoi riflessi nella condotta dei comandante in Krankenbehandlung auf den Seeschiffen der
occasione di malati a bordo. Atti dei Centro di Bundesrepublik Deutschland. Arbeitsmed.
studi e ricerche per l'assistenza sanit. soc. dei Sozialmed. Präventivmed. 7, 180-183 (1976).
marittimi C. I. R. M. 115-120 (1961). 14. Guida, G.: L'assistenza radio-medica. 1,2. 2nd
2. Ebert, H.: Die Gewährleistung des Gesund- Ed. Roma: C.1.R.M. 1966.
heitsschutzes auf Seeschiffen ohne Arzt unter 15. Guida, G.: Le radio-communicazioni mediche
den Bedingungen und den sich abzeichnenden dei c.I. R. M. In: Atti dei prima congresso int.
Entwicklungstendenzen im Zusammenhang sull'assistenza di malattia e la tutela infort-
mit dem wissenschaftlich-technischen Fort- unistica della gente dei mare nei paesi della
schritt in der Schiffahrt der DDR. Sci. Disserta- c.e.e. Vol.2. Genova, 3-50ttobre 1960.
tion, University of Rostock 1979. pp.487 -491.
3. Ebert, H.: Die Gewährleistung des Gesund- 16. Gurvich, L. I. and W I. Styazhkina: 0 rabote su-
heitsschutzes auf Seeschiffen ohne Arzt unter dovykh feldsherov. [Work of ships' feldshers
den Bedingungen und den sich abzeichnenden (physician assistants)]. Feldsh. Akush. 8,41-42
Entwicklungstendenzen im Zusammenhang (1981).
mit dem wissenschaftlich-technischen Fort- 17. Häberle, W: Die funkärztIiche Beratung aus
schritt in der Schiffahrt der DDR. Verk.-Med. der Sicht des nautischen Offiziers - Fallstu-
27,3,95-107 (1980). die II. Hamburg, Abschlußarbeit Fachhoch-
4. Ebert, H.: Health care on modem ships. Arb. schule Hamburg 1982.
Hig. Rada 30, suppl. 1597-1599 (1979). 18. Hansson, L., S.Johannsen and G.Berglund:
5. Ebert, H.: Health protection on the GDR sea- The Swedish Radio Medical Organization. J.
going ships without medical personnel. Bull. roy. nav. med. Servo 57,2,95-97 (1971).
Inst. mar. trop. Med. Gdynia 28, 3/4, 125-128 19. Health of seafarers: Study ofthe nature and ex-
(1977). tend of the health problems of seafarers and the
6. Ebert, Rand J. Warncke: Unterstützung der health service available to them. Ed.: Executive
Gesundheitsoffiziere durch funkärztIiche Bera- board, 37th Session. Genf: WHO 1965.
tung. In: V. Internationales Symposium über 20. International medical guide for ships. Ed.: ILO,
Schiffahrtsmedizin vom 19. bis 21.0kt. 1972 in IMCO, WHO. Geneva: WHO 1967.
Rostock. Vorträge. Ed.: Medizinischer Dienst 21. Internationales Signalbuch. (I. S. B.) Amtl.
des Verkehrswesens der DDR. Rostock [1973]. dtsch. Ausg. Ed.: Dtsch. hydrograph. Inst. im
pp. 85-92. Auftrage des Bundesministers f. Verkehr. Ber-
7. First-aid and radio-medicine course. Boll. anno lin: de Gruyter 1969.
C.I.R.M. 6-7 (1973). 22. Joint ILO/WHO committee on the hygiene of
8. Goethe Rand H.-E.Grewe: Gesundheitliche seafarers. Report on the first session. Geneva:
Betreuung und Notfallsituation auf See. In: WHO 1950. (Technical report series No. 20)
Jahrestagung der Deutschen Gesellschaft für 23. Joint ILO/WHO committee on the hygiene of
Verkehrsmedizin, Hamburg, 11.-13. April 1975, seafarers. Second report. Geneva: WHO 1955.
pp. 45-49. (Technical report series No.92)
9. Goethe, R: Die medizinische Betreuung des 24. Joint ILO/WHO committee on the hygiene of
Seemannes auf Schiffen ohne Arzt. [Lecture seafarers. Third report. Geneva: WHO 1961.
held at the meeting "Sektion Schiffahrtsmed." (Technical report series No. 244)
3./4. April 19681. Hansa 106, 1,27-29 (1969). 25. Joint ILO/WHO committee on the health of
64 1 Introduction to Nautical Medicine
seafarers. Fourth session. Geneva: ILO/WHO meeting 1978. Panel discussion of day to day
1965. problems. [Including additional paper and ap-
26. Joint ILO/WHO committee on the health of pendicesj. Ed.: H.Goethe. Hamburg 1978.
seafarers. Sixth report. Geneva: ILO/WHO 38. Purser marine physician assistant. Ed.: Staff Of-
1981. ficers' Association of America Training Pro-
27. Kharalanov, v., P. Polonov and I. Dimitrov: gram. [New York) 1970.
Mnenie moryakov otnositelno meditsinskovo 39. Radio medische dienst voor de scheepvaart.
obespecheniya na sudakh. [Medical treatment Overzicht 1974-1976. [Scheveningen) 1975-
on board from the point of view of the sailors). 1977. Manuscript.
In: V. Internationales Symposium über Schiff- 40. Radio medische dienst van het Nederlandse
fahrtsmedizin vom 19. bis 21.0ktober 1972 in Rode Kruis voor de scheepvaart, via het Rijks-
Rostock. Vorträge. Ed.: Medizinischer Dienst kuststation Scheveningen Radio (PCH).
des Verkehrswesens der DDR. Rostock [1973). [Scheveningen 1978). Manuscript.
pp. 59-62. 41. Ram, J.: Maritime health services at sea. SAPA-
28. Kraljevic, L. and Z. Ditrih: Hitna medicinska NUT 6, 2, 4-8 (1976).
pomoc i hitne intervencije na brodu i u po- 42. Recommendation concerning medical advice
morstvu. [Medical first aid and emergency steps by radio to ships at sea. Recommendation 106.
on board of ships.) In: Pomorska medicina. Ed.: International Labour Conference. [Ge-
(Naucne rasprave). Beograd: Izdanje Morna- neva) 1958.
rickog glasnika 1975. pp.415-420. (Pomorska 43. Renfrew, R.R.: Medical advice by radio. Ed.:
biblioteka No. 26) The Grimsby Fish Docks Medical Services.
29. Krynicki, A., A. Dyzewski and L. Majewski: Ra- Grimsby [abt. 1978).
dio-medical consultations in the years 44. Report of the joint ILO/WHO committee on
1970-1972. Bull. Inst. mar. trop. Med. Gdynia health of seafarers. [5th session). Geneva: ILO/
26,3/4,249-260 (1975). WHO 1973.
30. Lamont, D.: Medical aid to ships at sea by radio 45. Schepers, B.-F.: Die funkärztliche Beratung von
transmission. Community Hlth 2, 3, 137-143 Seeschiffen am Stadtkrankenhaus Cuxhaven.
(1970). Notfallmed. 7, 1146-1158 (1981).
31. Lesson plans for maritime module. Ed.: Mari- 46. The ship captain's medical guide. 21st ed. Lon-
time Institute of Technology & Graduate don: Her Majesty's Stationery Office 1983.
Studies. Linthicum Heights [abt. 1979). 47. The ship's medicine chest and medical aid at
32. Manning, R. D.: Radioed medical advice at sea. sea. Ed.: U.S. Department of Health, Educa-
In: Atlantic International Air and Surface. tion and Welfare. Public Health Service. Health
Search and Rescue Seminar. New York, Services Administration. Bureau of Medical
22-25 April 1975. pp. 123-124. Services. Washington 1978: U.S. Government
33. Mikhailova, M.I., A. A. Dukhanina, V. Ya. Spe- Printing Office.
sivtsev et al.: Zabolevaemost plavsostava bol- 48. Siem, H.: Health status and medical problems
shikh morozilnykh rybopromyslovykh traule- on Norwegian ships, as reported by the seafar-
rov: Prichiny i profilaktika. [Crew morbidity on ers. Lecture. Symposium "Safety of life at sea",
big freezer trawlers (BMRT): Its causes and Oslo, 20.-21.0kt. 1980. Research program as-
prophylaxis). In: V.Internationales Symposium sociated with The Royal Norwegian Council
über Schiffahrtsmedizin vom 19.-21.0ktober for Scientific and Industrial Research. System
1972 in Rostock. Vorträge. Medizinischer for Sikkert Skip. Manuscript.
Dienst des Verkehrswesens der DDR. Rostock 49. Sinitsyn, S. A., M. P. Volchenko and A. S. Buda-
[1973). pp.63-68. nov: Meditsinskaya pomoshch moryakam v mi-
34. Myhre, J. R.: Radiolegetjeneste for sjöfolk - rovom okeane. [Medical and aid for seafarers at
evakuering av syke og skadete fra skip i sjöen. sea all over the world). Sovetsk. Zdravookhr. 30,
In: Sjöfartsmedisinsk forskning, Rapport fra 2,51-53 (1971).
nordisk symposium, Oslo 16.-17.6. 1975. Ed.: 50. Slutsker, D. S.: On the performance of ship-
Nordiska raadet och Nordiska ministerraadets board medical staff. Bull. lust. mar. trop. Med.
sekretariat i Oslo. Stockholm 1976: Gotab. Gdynia 25, 2/3/4, 273-275 (1974).
pp.15-18. 51. Stanzeit, H.J. and H. Ebert: Zu den Ergebnissen
35.0hashi, N.: Outline of medical aid to ships at funkärztlicher Beratungen und ihre Bedeutung
sea in Japan. Personal Communication. Tokyo für den Gesundheitsschutz auf DDR-Seeschif-
1979. fen ohne Schiffsarzt. Verk.-Med. 26,4,146-150
36. Paul, W: Erfahrungen der Universitäts-Augen- (1979).
klinik in Rostock mit der funkärztlichen Bera- 52. Steensma, W.: De radio medische dienst van het
tung von Seeschiffen. Verk.-Med. 17, 10, Nederlandsche Roode Kruis voor de Scheep-
428-432 (1970). vaart. Dissertation, University of Amsterdam
37. Proceedings of the European nautical-medical 1969.
1.4 Medical Care on Ships Without a Doctor - Radio Medical Advice 65
53. Tenfjord, O. w.: Om behandling av sykdom og dard and practices in the United States mer-
skadetilfelle ombord. Skip 617, 27-32 (1964). chant marine. Milit. Med. 142, 9, 706-709
54. Tumbull, T. A.: Problems associated with medi- (1977).
cal aid in the mercantile marine of the United 58. White, jr., P. C.: A survey of medical care in the
Kingdom. J. roy. nav. med. Servo 63, 166-171 United States merchant marine. Milit. Med.
(1977). 142,8,613-616 (1977).
55. Tumbull, T. A.: A review of medical and train-
ing facilities in the U.K. and other countries. Addendum
Ed.: Merchant Navy and Airline Officers Asso-
59. Brayley, N. F.: A review of three years experi-
ciation London 1979.
ence of medical advice to seafarers by the Casu-
56. Vuksanovic, P.: Medicinsko obrazovanje po-
alty Officer, Royalty Naval Hospital Plymouth,
morskih officira. [Medical education of ship's
via Portishead Radio (W/T Medico Porti-
officers]. Zbomik ViSe pomorske skole u Koto-
shead). J. roy. nav. med. Servo 66, 2, 93-106
ru 1,239-246 (1975).
(1980).
57. White jr., P.C.: An evaluation of health stan-
2 The Seafarer's Environment
2.1 Work and Recreation at Sea
E.Zom
Throughout the ages ships' crews have al- of the individual jobs, but common to them
ways had to adapt to the special circum- all is the unavoidable stress caused by the
stances oflife at sea. Irrespective ofthe size noise and vibration of the machinery, the
and type of ship, the common factor in sea- motion of the sea and other macroclimate
faring is the requirement to live and work influences. The microdimate and possible
in a restricted community under special en- chemical or radiation hazards at the indi-
vironmental conditions. The hard life en- vidual work-place are additional dangers.
dured by seafarers in former years has been The work-Ioad varies according to type
made much easier by revolutionary en- of vessel, occupation and work-place. The
gineering progress and better ship design, work-Ioad may be increased or decreased
but technical innovations always create according to the environmental factors.
new problems. The increasing trend to- Therefore, the data ofwork-Ioad studies on
wards automation on board has reduced board are not strictly comparable with each
considerably the physical work required, other. These very different results cannot
and the standard of safety at work has been be considered as representative data.
correspondingly raised. This has naturally On board nearly all vessels world-wide,
been accompanied by facilities for a heal- the crew is subdivided as follows:
thier and generally improved way of life. Deck staff
While these changes are to be welcomed, Engine room staff
there is still room for improvement. The Catering staff
change from traditional seafaring to a Attempts have been made in several
modem shipping industry, associated with shipping countries during re cent years to
fewer crew members and quicker ship tum- integrate the deck and engine room person-
round in ports has increased the mental nel owing to the reduction of the ship's
strain and the isolation from social con- crew and the increasing rationalisation of
tacts ashore. Any research project on "the the ship's operation. Modem merchant
ship of the future" must take account of vessels have become larger in size and ton-
these aspects in addition to subjects such as nage and are provided with greater propul-
the ship's operation and professional edu- sion power. Consequently, the average
cation of the seafarers. gross tonnage of German vessels increased
from approximately 2000 gross tons in
2.1.1 Work Structure and Hazards 1952 to approximately 10000 gross tons in
of the Individual Shipping 1970. Simultaneously, the ship's crew was
Branches reduced from, say, 70 in 1957 to 30 or even
less in 1974. The duration of voyages and
All the various shipping trades, whether calls at ports were reduced to approximate-
foreign-going, coastal or fishing, have nu- ly half of the former time periods (Goethe
merous hazards. These hazards vary ac- et al. [10]). In the meantime, approximately
cording to the type of ship and the nature 90% of German Federal vessels have been
70 2 The Seafarer's Environment
fully automated. This applies to nearly all vesse1s has been reduced considerably with
highly developed shipping countries, the introduction of container vessels.
whereas the situation of the countries of Bulk liners predominantly carry coal,
the so-called third world is frequently in ores, cereals and fertilizers. The severity of
conformity with the conditions of about possible hazards depends on the peculiari-
1950 in the industrial world. ties of the transported cargo. If, for exam-
The modem merchant fleet predomi- pIe, the ventilation of the cargo tanks of a
nantly consists of motor vessels and only in coal freighter is insufficient, this may cause
small part of turbine-driven ships. The fol- a high concentration of carbon dioxide,
lowing groups ofvessels are concemed: methane and sometimes hydrogen sul-
Dry cargo vessels phide in the air. When entering the tanks,
Special cargo vessels (container vessels, crew members may consequently suffer
LASH carriers, bulk carriers) toxie effects. Spontaneous combustion
Tankers (crude oil tankers, chemieal tank- may sometimes occur. Although severe
ers, gas tankers etc.) bums are the usual injury in this event, poi-
Multipurpose vessels soning by carbon dioxide mayaIso hap-
Passenger vessels pen. The strict control of ventilation is es-
The peculiarities of the cargo to be trans- sential to guarantee the safety of the ship's
ported by the above-mentioned types of crew. Ore cargo carries the risk of inhaling
vessels have a big influence on the work- high concentrations of dust in addition to
load and the hazards on board. gas produced by the ore. This may happen
The fishery fleet, with its different types if the ore gets wet, forming toxie chemieal
of vessels, naturally has its own partieular combinations with hydrogen (e. g. hydro-
problems. gen sulphide). Heavy ore cargo may shift
The cargo vessels which make up the with the ship's motion during rough seas,
biggest part of the merchant fleet mostly severely affecting the ship's stability. The
serve as liners. They regularly visit a num- transportation of cereals presents similar
ber of defined ports according to a time- hazards. Wet cereals mayaiso lead to spon-
table and then return to the horne port. taneous combustion and thus to a very high
There are no fixed shipping routes in concentration of carbon dioxide. There is
tramping. Home ports are visited at ex- also the risk of cargo shifting. The same ap-
tremely irregular intervals - maybe only plies to other bulk cargoes, which, trans-
every couple of years. Tramping means un- ported under the influences of high envi-
favourable work conditions because of ronmental temperatures and humidity, may
greater mental stress. form carbon dioxide and other kinds of
If avessei is chartered, it is assigned to a toxie gas. This includes a large variety of
shipping company and/or agency for one cargoes normally considered absolutely
or more voyages. This implies similar con- harmless, e. g. vegetables, maize, rice, soya,
ditions for the crew as in tramping. potatoes and fruit. Fruit and vegetables
There are two types of cargo vessels: which have been bruised and have rotted
general cargo vessels and bulk carriers. are a particular hazard.
General cargo consists of mixtures of car- Fruit carriers are special ships equipped
go, e. g. engine parts, vehides, technieal ar- with large cooling plants to prevent over-
tides, chemicals, wood and spiees. The car- ripening. These cooling systems may leak
go has to be stowed safely. Therefore, coolants such as Freon, whieh may be
stowing means very skilIed and difficult dangerous because it displaces oxygen and
work. Non-adherence to safety regulations can cause asphyxia. The regular inspection
and carelessness at work may lead to severe of cargo requires frequent lengthy visits to
accidents. The number of general cargo the cold stores. These temperature changes
2.1 Work and Recreation at Sea 71
may precipitate minor ailments. There is subject to the highest work-Ioad (Israeli et
the added danger that poisonous creatures al. [14]), which increases with every change
may be present in the cargo (spiders, scor- of passengers. Frequently, the living quar-
pions and sometimes snakes), especially ters of the crew members on board pas-
when bananas are carried. senger ships are fairly modest in compari-
Container vessels are designed for the son with those on cargo vessels, due to the
transportation of large cargo containers. limitation of available space and the pref-
The loading and unloading of the contain- erence given to passengers. There are no
ers is very responsible work and thus in- specific hazards from the occupational
volves a high mental load. This work is health point of view.
done by means of special "cargo comput- The fishery fleet has to be subdivided in-
ers" if larger vessels are concemed. LASH to (a) coastal fishery and (b) deep sea fish-
carriers (lighter aboard ships) are also spe- ery. Both categories have various methods
cial vessels carrying floating containers - of fishing. Thus the work-Ioad and the
the so-called barges - which go by inland hazards differ considerably. Coastal fishing
waterways to the loading port and from is done from small boats (cutters and
there by ship to the final port of destina- others) at sea for only a fairly short time.
tion. The work procedures and the possible These small boats are specifically exposed
hazards are similar to those on board con- to the hazards of high wind and rough sea.
tainer ships. Deep sea fishing is normally carried out by
Tankers are designed for the transporta- a fishing flotilla comprising one or more
tion of liquid bulk cargo (see Chap.5.3). large processing ships besides smaller
These vessels are equipped with special trawlers. Heavy physical work is required
safety devices. Very strict regulations con- and the frequency rate of accidents is much
siderably reduce the potential hazards of higher than in seafaring as a whole (Goethe
explosions and bums. Gas and chemical et al. [12]).
tankers are special types of tankships. The fishermen have no regular working
Liquid gas - mostly hydrocarbons - is pattern with arestricted number of work-
pumped under pressure into the tanks of ing hours. The fishing itself and fish pro-
the ship from shoreside facilities. This im- cessing represent unbalanced kinds of
plies a high risk of bums and explosions. work in respect of intensity and duration.
Therefore the safety regulations are very This, naturally, may lead to overstrain. As a
strict. The tanker crew are subject to stress consequence of the the very high work-
caused by the potential hazards and by cer- load, living space and personal hygiene of-
tain personal restrictions (ban on smoking) ten leave much to be desired (see
and by the fact that the rapid loading and Chap.5.4). Very often females do the fish
unloading mostly takes place in very unat- processing on board. The employment of
tractive and isolated port areas. females does not seem advisable due to the
Passenger vessels have become less im- unfavourable working atmosphere and the
portant during recent decades, when long very high stress on the musculoskeletal sys-
voyage liners could not compete with air tem (Marschall and Kersten [16]). Fishery
travel. There are still many passenger fer- protection vessels are sent with the fishery
ries in short coasting and intermediate fleets of several countries for the health
trade, excursion steamers and, in foreign care and technical support of the fishing
trade, the cruisers. The so-called combi- boats within a special fishing area.
shipping, i. e. freight vessels with a limited Some special kinds of ships have still to
number of passengers aboard, has also be mentioned, i. e. the buoy-Iayers and ves-
been considerably reduced. sels serving as lightships. These vessels are
On passenger vessels the catering staff is to guarantee safe shipping lanes. All work
72 2 The Seafarer's Environment
required on board these special vessels has chart work (ca1culating the ship's position
to be done irrespective of the prevailing and plotting the course) modern naviga-
weather and sea conditions. Thus the acci- tional aids have taken over a lot of the for-
dent risk is rather high. Besides the mono- mer tasks. Consequently, from time to time
tony of shift-work (watchkeeping) it has to officers of the watch on these voyages suf-
be emphasised that the crew is specially ac- fer from monotony, lack of stimulation and
cident prone owing to the frequently very a sense of isolation. This does not apply
bad weather conditions. The same applies during voyages in dangerous shipping
to work and life on board mooring and/or areas, in coastal trades and calls at ports
fastened offs hore platforms. The risk of ac- when crowded shipping lanes, high er
cidents on board salvage ships is very high speeds and larger vessel size, put the navi-
because salvaging operations are usually gators under considerable nervous strain.
carried out in severe weather conditions. This strain is increased by the steady gener-
The function of the local sea pilot figures al trend to reduce the size of crews so that
large as he is assigned to the ship's captain in emergencies, each individual on board is
to operate the ship in dangerous sea and under extra strain (Hynitzsch [13]).
port areas (see Chap. 5.8). Sea pilots have a Watchkeeping at night is more difficult
highly responsible and worrying job. The and darkness adds to the general strain of
physicalload is also fairly high because of the job. High demands are made on the ef-
the necessity to board vessels in open sea, ficiency of vision and in particular on dark
which may be rather dangerous during adaptation, as the density of light varies
rough weather (Zorn [32]). considerably during the individual tasks:
observation of the sea route, radar control
2.1.2 Occupational Health and chart work (Zorn [33]).
Conditions of Individual The deck officers also supervise loading
and discharging of cargo. In this capacity
Working Areas
they are naturally exposed to the same haz-
Although there are typical working areas ards as the deck ratings and port workers
on board seagoing vessels, the working who carry out the work.
conditions themselves may differ consider- The physical load of the radio officer is
ably according to type of vessels, location insignificant whereas he has to endure a
and sea and weather conditions. So the rather high mental load, especially from in-
work-load caused by one specific activity terference with the radio reception. Since
may differ considerably, ranging from low the introduction of the ultra-short-wave ra-
to extremely high. Therefore, the data of dio-telephone, morse telegraphy is actually
several occupational studies are hardly being used to only a small extent. Thus, the
comparable. radio officer is under less strain. The ves-
The captain and his deck officers are re- sels of the intercoastal trade nowadays car-
sponsible for navigating the ship in addi- ry a radio officer only occasionally. Wire-
tion to their other duties. They share the less communications are then effected by
watchkeeping duty on the bridge, which is the navigation officers.
by tradition divided into 4-h periods to en- In port, the deck personnel are occupied
sure alertness and concentration. It is phys- with loading or discharging cargo, with
ically inactive work which, under normal berthing the ship and with safety and main-
conditions, does not have a high accident tenance work. However, in most ports, car-
risk for the individual. On the other hand, it go handling is performed by special shore
is very responsible work which is mentally gangs and no longer by deck staff. Further-
tiring. During long voyages at sea it is more, the work-Ioad has considerably de-
much easier because, except for occasional creased because of the increasing automa-
2.1 Work and Recreation at Sea 73
tion on ships, so that nowadays heavy engines), noise and vibration levels in-
manual work on deck is necessary only oc- creased considerably. In addition to the
casionally with the exception of rough main engine, the auxiliary engines (genera-
weather at sea, when the work-Ioad is tors, converters, ventilators etc.) produce
usually increased. On board modern bulk considerable noise. By the construction of
and container vessels or LASH carriers, sound-absorbing and temperature-regulat-
heavy physical work is required only in ed engine control rooms, these dangers can
short bursts. Occasionally, the securing and be considerably cut down. Furthermore,
strapping of containers or barges may be modern vessels are operated from the
heavy physical work. In former times, bridge, making the permanent manning of
cleaning and maintenance work (rust the engine room superfluous. This drasti-
scraping, painting, washing of paintwork, cally shortens the periods of noise expo-
rigging etc.) were compulsory. Nowadays, sure of crew members. Also the work-Ioad
such work is performed at sea by the deck in the engine room has decreased consider-
crew only to a limited extent due to the per- ably as an effect of the ship's automation.
sonnel reduction on board many vessels. Engine room personnel are, however, still
At the same time, the volume of work on subject to a great physical load if repair
deck has been cut down considerably on work becomes necessary and this may even
board vessels manned by a so-called inte- result in overstrain. The mental load of the
grated or multipurpose crew. On board engine room staff corresponds with the
such fully automated vessels, requiring on- deck ratings, so the high-responsibility job
ly little maintenance, the crew members do of the chief engineer is accompanied by
both deck and engine room work. In spite high mental stress. The chief engineer has
of the fact that the crew is rarely exposed to to supervise the strict adherence to the
environmental weather conditions, climatic ship's time schedule and the faultless func-
influences may, from time to time, have tioning ofthe engine plant. His responsibil-
harmful effects. Making all secure on deck ity is shared by the engineer on watch, who
during heavy storm and bad weather may works longer hours in the engine room
occasionally lead to severe injuries or even than the chief engineer. Thus, he has to en-
to being swept overboard. Severe contu- dure high mental stress too. The engine
sions, fractures or injuries followed by am- staff (mechanics, motormen, greasers,
putation can be caused by broken steel cleaners ete.) perform eontrol functions,
wire ropes or cords. Adherence to the tech- cleaning and repair work under the diree-
nical safety regulations (accident preven- tion and supervision of the engineers. The
tion regulations) largely eliminates these physicalload is much higher but the men-
kinds of accidents. During maintenance tal load is mueh lower than in the en-
work on board, e. g. rust scraping, injuries gineers.
to the eyes are frequently caused by foreign Aecidents also oecur in the engine room,
bodies. Poisoning by inhalation may be especially contusions during heavy seas.
caused by painting with spray devices in Bums and sealds, as weil as electric bums,
narrow rooms. Such accidents can be pre- are rare on board modern vessels, as are
vented by making it compulsory to wear in- toxie effects from the inhalation of smoke
dividual protective equipment (eye protec- from loose exhaust pipes. Heat illness, for-
tors and breathing apparatus). merly a frequent disorder in firemen (fire-
Engine room personnel are exposed to men's cramps), is exeeptionally rare under
rather high noise and vibration levels and normal conditions on board modern ves-
to unfavourable microclimatic influences sels. Engine crew members oecasionally
in the engine rooms. With the introduction SUffer from oil aene or allergie reactions of
of high-speed propulsion engines (diesel the skin to oil contact. Exposure to high
74 2 The Seafarer's Environment
noise levels [above 90 dB(A)] has frequent- ture drops in the cold stores, which have to
ly resulted in damage to the inner ear. Irre- be controlled by the crew members in
versible hearing damage was found in a charge several times per day, increase the
large number of older engine room crew load. Therefore, the physical load is high
members by means of audiometric exami- and, from time to time, even extremely
nations (Goethe et al. [11]). Noise and vi- high, especially for the ship's cook, who
bration may explain why older crew mem- has a most responsible job. The galley crew
bers frequently complain of nervous ex- as weil as the catering personneion board
haustion and neuroses. It has to be empha- vessels of most shipping countries have to
sised that the control of the complicated undergo regular medieal examinations for
automatie engine plant - especially if there infectious diseases.
are any engine faults - produces a lot of
mental stress whieh may be followed by ex-
haustion and neuroses in the older en-
2.1.3 Results of the Examinations
gineering staff.
The electrician is in charge of the whole
of the Psycho-physical Load
electrical supply system and the many elec- in Crew Members on Board
trical devices on board, as weil as being re- Seagoing Vessels
sponsible for urgent repairs. By the intro-
duction of numerous electrically operated Studies of the individual environmental
deviees in all areas - the navigation and en- load factors have been carried out fre-
gine area, on deck, in the galleys and the quently, whereas studies on the psycho-
cold stores - his function became more im- physiclalload are rare. As the basis and the
portant. The combined mental and physi- examination methods of these few studies
cal stress can be regarded as from moder- differ, the data obtained are not compar-
ate to high. The pumpmen on board able.
tankers have to supervise all activities asso- In 1963 Kersten [15] examined the work-
ciated with the liquid cargo. The hazards load of deep-sea fis hermen by means of
whieh may occur are poisoning from inha- pulse and blood pressure recordings. He
lation of gas fumes from the cargo, as weil concluded that the work-load was extreme-
as injuries during work on deck during ly high during the fishing process itself and
heavy seas. that the working capacity of young fisher-
The work of the catering personnel men was reduced by the constant load.
(pursers, male and female stewards) on In 1966 Sandratskaya [23] published ex-
board is harder than comparable duties amination results of working conditions on
ashore owing to the ship's motion and the board fishery vessels during operation in
environmental load factors (noise, vibra- cold climatic zones. Changes of the pulse
tions, changes of the macroclimate). On and breathing rates as weil as of the blood
board cargo vessels the work-load is fairly pressure were recorded which exceeded
moderate, compared with passenger ves- the physiologieallimit values.
sels, where it is quite high. Slight injuries Zorn [28] in 1966 reported on an exten-
may occur during work as weil as derma- sive study of the environmental and work-
toses caused by the use of detergents. The load of crew members on board different
ship's cook and his assistant personnel are types of warships. Environmental factors
exposed to high engine vibrations as the such as macroclimate, noise and vibrations
galleys are mostly lodged far abaft. Fur- have a significant influence on board prac-
thermore, the very unsatisfactory microcli- tieally all navy vessels. The parameters
mate of the galleys may be even worse than were: records of pulse and blood pressure,
that ofthe engine room. The large tempera- body temperature, secretion of sweat as
2.1 Work and Recreation at Sea 75
The individual load was recorded by ronmentalload factors may vary at any one
means of telemetry during a total of 309 defined work-place and any one special
working cycles: heart rate and action professional activity. Owing to the mani-
(ECG), respiratory rate, skin temperature fold mixtures of multifactorial effects, the
and internal body temperature and humid- work-Ioad may be much higher than orig-
ity of skin were noted.Self and observer as- inally suspected for that work.
sessment served as the basis ofthe graduat- It go es without saying that the evaluated
ed scheme (Zorn [30]). From the 309 data may serve only as guide values owing
recordings the following was evident: in to the lack of relevant criteria. The acceler-
24 cases (7%) clear signs of mental load ation and deceleration caused by the ship's
were found: 7 cases concerned the engine motion represent only a temporary and in-
room, 17 the deck staff (including the constant load, which affects, however, all
bridge and the radio officer). ratings. Values between 1 and 3 m/s 2 were
The mental load was follows: frequently registered; occassionally they
Deck: Very low to 130(42%) increased to 7-9 m/ S2 which, besides kine-
moderate tosis, have a harmful effect on crew mem-
High 20 (6%) bers in any case, i. e. by the necessary
Veryhigh 8 (3%) compensatory activities of the muscles and
the lowering of recuperative capacity.
Engine Room: Very low to 128(41%) The technical staff is more strained by
moderate noise and vibrations which particularly ap-
High 17 (6%) ply to some of the professional activities.
Veryhigh 6 (2%) At many work-places, vibration values
No case of extreme physical load was above 4.0 K and noise levels even above
found. 100 dB(A) were registered. Also, the values
From these results the psycho-physical measured in the living quarters in any case
load may be assessed as follows: Normally imply a high load by interfering with the
the deck crew is under more strain in ports recreation of crew members. The climatic
and the engine room staff more at sea. In influences may be a constant load, pre-
the normal ship's operation the mental dominantly for the ship's cook and the en-
load was rather low, whereas it consider- gine room personnei, and temporarily for
ably increased in all cases under extreme the deck staff too. During voyages in tropi-
conditions. It has to be pointed out that cal waters, the effective temperatures mea-
emergencies such as severe damage, ship- sured in the engine room and in the galley
wreck or fire were not experienced. The normally exceed not only the limit values,
mental load is in conformity with the grade but in most cases also the limit of light
of responsibility of the respective crew permanent duty (above 30 0 effective tem-
member. Consequently, the ship's manage- perature). Stenko [25] reported slight rises
ment is more stressed than the ordinary rat- in body temperature and heart rate and a
ings. Normally the physical load is very slight drop in blood pressure during tropi-
low, but it may increase considerably with cal voyages. Ditrih and Celio Cega [5]
special repair work in the engine room or found changes in the acid-base balance
certain loading procedures on deck. The and the blood electrolytes.
reduction of the ship's crew and the more Chemical dangers occur very infrequent-
and more applied practice of multipurpose ly in spite of the continuously increasing
manning, as well as the ship's automation, mixtures and quantities of dangerous car-
lead to more mental stress. The total indi- go. This can apparently be attributed to
vidual load involving the psycho-physical strict safety regulations (Zorn et al. [34]).
load and the effects of the different envi- Nevertheless, a temporary load may occur
2.1 Work and Recreation at Sea 77
for the deck officers and the engineering from the family and related groups of peo-
staff as weIl as for the ordinary crew. The pIe ashore, lack of spare time activities and
levels ofhigh-frequency radiations are gen- possibilities of compensation and relaxa-
erally below the limit values as the radia- tion, unsatisfied sexual requirements and,
tion intensity ofthe radar is fairly low. This finally, the potential hazards of seafaring
hazard is, therefore, of no practical impor- (see Chap.2.10).
tance. Insufficient lighting may be an indi-
rect load factor as the light intensity at 2.1.4 Leisure Time - Hobbies and
many work-places is far below the required Games
guide values. Frequently, the intensity of
light in the different parts of the engine Besides the lack of recreational possibili-
room differs considerably. In the bridge ties, the unsatisfactory situation in respect
area, very often concern for the required of spare time activities has a harmful men-
dark adaptation of the personneion duty tal influence on crew members. Although
leaves much to be desired. The insufficient the situation has considerably improved
lighting thus provided means an additional during recent years, it generally remains in-
mental load. sufficient. The frequent lack of interest dur-
Watchkeeping on board vessels is a load ing long voyages may be related to the de-
factor of great importance, but it is difficult crease of spontaneity caused by the mono-
to assess. The navigation officers are liable tony of life at sea. Repeated stimulation by
for watchkeeping. Only part of the deck reasonable hobbies or/intellectual activi-
staff is involved, and the engine room per- ties may be adequate measures to amelio-
sonnel only in exceptional cases and never rate the situation (Zorn [29]).
on board automated vessels. In order to create a good psychological
On most vessels the three-watch system atmosphere on board, spare time activities
is customary, Le. 4 h duty, 6 hoff duty. On are an essential prerequisite in addition to
board smaller vessels (mostly coastal ves- the collective working efficiency. These ac-
sels) the two-watch system is applied, Le. tivities are necessary to guarantee satisfac-
6 h duty, 6 hoff duty or the so-called tory recreation. It is evident that passive be-
"English watch", Le. 4h duty, 4h off duty haviour during leisure time has a smaller
and then 6 h duty and 6 hoff duty, which recuperative effect than active participa-
means a continuous rotation (shifting) of tion in leisure interests (Stiewe [26]). It is
working hours. This kind of shift work im- very important to take into consideration
plies a permanent additional load which the national and social peculiarities of the
should not be underestimated. Colquhoun individual crew members on board when
et al. [4] intensively studied the effects of planning recreational activities. Individual
the circadian rhythms, deprivation of sleep crew members, and especially the ship's
and fatigue on the watchkeeping crew management, may have strong positive or
member at night. The watch systems dimin- negative influences. Unfavourable working
ish the possibilities of private communica- conditions and the lack of any positive im-
tion (social contacts). This is aggravated by pulses often lead to abuses of stimulants,
the increasing proportion of watchkeeping including tea and coffee but predominantly
crew members in relation to the total num- alcohol, as some kind of compensation. Es-
ber of crew members on board. In any case, pecially on board deep-sea fishery vessels,
the permanently influencing psychological enormous quantities of stimulants are con-
factors have, of course, to be included in sumed which at other work-places can
the assessment of the individual total load, scarcely be as high (Stiewe [26]). It has also
i. e. monotony during long sea voyages, to be emphasised that alcoholism on board
mental isolation, reduced crews, seclusion only reflects the situation of the whole so-
78 2 The Seafarer's Environment
ciety. Therefore, national, social and reli- Visits to museums, theatres etc. should be
giuous differences figure largerly. The gen- included.
erally held idea that a "proper" seaman lt is very important to have a library on
consumes a considerable quantity of alco- board as many vessels as possible, pro-
hol has to be eradicated (Zorn [31]) (see vided that it is adapted to the on board con-
Chap.4.4). ditions. It should contain books for general
Although a lot of attempts have been education as well as good literature and
made during recent years to offer the pos si- light reading. Audiovisual devices (radio,
bility of spare time activity on most vessels, television, tape recorder, records, cine-pro-
the situation differs substantiallyon board jector) are available on most vessels. The
vessels of various nations. The facilities on screening of interesting films is very popu-
board and the financial me ans are fre- lar. So are parties and social meetings if
quently insufficient to organise spare time there is a good working atmosphere on
activities. In other cases there may be a lack board. Of course, the desire for social con-
of stimulation towards any such activities tacts normally decreases during long voy-
in the ship's crew, especially towards edu- ages and from time to time there are
cational work. lt seems that the crew mem- increasingly petty misunderstandings as a
bers on board vessels of the Eastern block result of monotony and the inclination to
countries show more interest, and that neuroses which afflicts seamen as a result
more possibilities of education are avail- of the special living conditions on board
able, than crew members on board vessels (Dolmierski [8]; Dolmierski et al. [7]).
of the Western shipping countries. On In spite of the material improvements,
these vessels, all activities are normally left the planning of spare time activities on
to the individual crew member. On board board will become much more difficult in
vessels of the Eastern block countries, spe- future owing to the busier life of seafarers
cial education programmes and planned caused by personnel reduction. In order to
spare time activities are offered. make reasonable spare time activity possi-
Recreational requirements should al- ble, the folLowing facts have to be realised:
ready have been considered with the ship's 1. In the ship's design, sufficient space and
design and equipment. On bigger vessels, / or rooms should have been provided
special hobby rooms are provided for tech- for recreational activities (free deck
nical hobbies, wood-carving, painting, areas, rooms for hobbies and sports etc.).
photographic works, preparation of sea an- Of course, they have to be equipped
imals etc. It is also possible to pursue accordingly.
sports. Besides physical exercises with 2. Improvement of possibilities of educa-
dumb-bells, expanders and horne athletic ti on via the library and audiovisual edu-
implements (like fixed ergometers or row- cation appliances.
ing devices), various ball games (like medi- 3. Delegation of a qualified crew member
cine ball) are possible. Table tennis is much to organise spare time activities in a suit-
favoured. A general enthusiasm for this able way in order to oppose the passive
easy form of sport can be observed when attitude ofthe ship's crew.
organising table tennis tournaments. Big- 4. Also, in nautical schools and training
ger vessels often have a swimming pool. centres, attempts should be made to give
During stays in port, occasionally, football guidelines for a proper planning of
matches can be organised, which may help recreational activities on board.
to overcome passive attitudes and the
deficiency of social contacts. Of course,
this becomes very difficult with the in-
creasingly shortened turn-round in ports.
2.1 Work and Recreation at Sea 79
chophysiological state of seamen. In: III. Inter- 19. Paslaru, V. and V. Repta: Data concerning sail-
national Symposium on Marine Medicine, Len- or's activity and stress conditions in the B1ack
ingrad 1968. Moscow 1969. pp. 24-29. Sea and the Mediterranean sea navigation.
7. Dolmierski, R., S. R. Kwiatkowski and J. Nitka: Bull. Inst. mar. trop. Med. Gdynia 25, 2-3-4,
Neurotic disorders and the EEG picture in sea- 335-338 (1974).
men. Bull. Inst. mar. trop. Med. Gdynia 25, 20. Rodahl, K., Z. Vokac, P. Fugelli et al.: Circulato-
2-3-4,320-326 (1974). ry strain estimated energy output and catechol-
8.Dolmierski, R.: Neurosen und Verhaltens- amine excretion in Norwegian coastal fisher-
störungen bei Seeleuten. In: V. Internationales men. Ergonomics 17,5,585-602 (1974).
Symposium über Schiffahrtsmedizin, Rostock, 21. Rodahl, K.: Arbeidsstress til sjös. Ed.: Arbeids-
19-210ct. 1972. Rostock 1973, pp. 25-30. fysiologisk Institutt. Oslo 1980. (System for Sik-
9. "Flensburger Studie" Vol.5 with Appendix: kert Skip).
Untersuchungen über die psychischen und 22. Rünger, H.: Individuale und soziale Probleme
physischen Belastungen von Schiffsbesatzun- des Menschen auf dem zukünftigen Schiff. In:
gen. Forschungsstelle für Schiffsbetriebstech- Bedingungen für den Betrieb zukünftiger
nik. Forschungsauftrag "Schiffsbesetzungsord- Schiffe. Symposium, 26 Sept. 1980. Ed.: Fach-
nung". F1ensburg 1974. hochschule Hamburg, Fachbereich Seefahrt.
10. Goethe, H., E. Zorn, R. Herrmann et al.: Die 23. Sandratskaya, S. E.: Izuchenie usloviy truda
psycho-physische Belastung des Personals plavayushchego sostava na rybolovnykh su-
moderner Seeschiffe als aktuelles Problem der dakh tipa RT i BMRT. [Investigation on the
Schiffahrtsmedizin. Zbl. Bakt. Hyg., LAbt. crews' working conditions on trawlers and
Orig. B 166, 1, 1-36 (1978). freezing trawlers]. Bull. Inst. mar. Med. Gdailsk
11. Goethe, H., E.-G. Schmidt, E. Zorn et al.: 17,3,231-234 (1966).
Lärrnbelastung auf See- und Binnenschiffen, 24. Schmidtke, H.: Mensch und Technik in Ortung
Untersuchungen zur effektiven Lärrnbelastung und Navigation. Nationale Tagung "Mensch
der Besatzungen. Ed.: Bundesanstalt für Ar- und Technik in Ortung u. Navigation", Dtsch.
beitsschutz und Unfall forschung, Dortmund. Ges. f. Ortung u. Navigation, Essen, 26, 270ct.
Bremerhaven: Wirtschaftsverlag NW 1979. 1971. Düsseldorf: Dtsch. Ges. f. Ortung u.
(Forschungsbericht 201). Navigation 1971.
12. Goethe, H., E. Zorn and J. Vrcelj: Unfälle an 25. Stenko, Yu. M.: Usloviya truda i otdykha mo-
Bord von deutschen Seeschiffen und ihre Ur- ryakov na sukhogruznykh sudakh pri plavanii v
sachen. Hansa 118,20,1513-1517 (1981); Han- tropikakh. [Occupational and recreational con-
sa 118,23,1699-1700 (1981). ditions of seamen on dry cargo vessels in tropi-
13. Hynitzsch, G.: Schiff der Zukunft - aus der cal zones]. Gig. i Sanit. 30, 117-119 (1965).
Sicht des Praktikers. Eine kritische Betrach- 26. Stiewe, M.: Die Freizeit der Seeleute an Bord in
tung. Hansa 114,8,743-744 (1977). der Hochseefischerei. Verk.-Med. 18, 8,
14. Israeli, R., M. Weinstein and D. Süssmann: Un- 345-355 (1971).
tersuchungen über die Arbeitsplatzanforde- 27. Zade, G.: Simulatoren in der Ausbildung nauti-
rungen an Bord von Passagierschiffen. Neuzeit- scher Schiffsoffiziere. Schiff und Hafen 28, 11,
liche Gesichtspunkte bei Einstellungsuntersu- 1116-1118 (1976).
chungen von Seeleuten. Arbeit und Leistung 28. Zorn, E.: Profesionale stetnosti na brodovima u
21,8,145-147 (1967). ovisnosti od pogonskih uredjaja. [Occupational
15. Kersten, E.: Die Berufsbelastung der Hochsee- dangers on ships depending on ship-propul-
fischer. Bull. Inst. mar. Med. Gdailsk 24, 112, sion]. Dissertation, University of Zagreb 1966.
117 -130 (1963). 29. Zorn, E.: Freizeitgestaltung und Rekreation an
16. Marschall, B. and E. Kersten: Arbeitshygie- Bord von Schiffen. In: V. Internationales Sym-
nische Betrachtungen zum Strukturwandel in posium über Schiffahrtsmedizin, Rostock,
der Hochseefischerei unter dem besonderen 19-210ct. 1972. Rostock 1973, pp. 355-361.
Aspekt der Frauenarbeit an Bord. Verk.-Med. 30. Zorn, E.: Umgebungs-und Arbeitsbelastungs-
18,11,481-491 (1971). studien an Bord von Seeschiffen. In: Arbeits-
17. Marschall, B. and E.Straube: Zur Erfassung medizinische Probleme des Transport- und Ver-
physiologischer Reaktionen unter den Bedin- kehrswesens. Bericht über 14.Jahrestagung der
gungen der Berufstätigkeit auf See. In: V. Inter- Deutschen Gesellschaft für Arbeitsmedizin,
nationales Symposium über Schiffahrtsmedi- Hamburg, 17-190ct. 1974. Ed.: G.Lehnert,
zin, Rostock, 19-210ct. 1972. Rostock 1973. D. Szadkowski and H. J. Weber. Stuttgart: Gent-
pp.45-51. ner 1975.pp.125-135.
18. Ohashi, N. and Y. Hirota: The mental strain of a 31. Zorn, E.: Alkoholkonsum an Bord. Beobach-
ship manoeuvrer. In: XVIInternational Con- tungen aus der Praxis. In: Jahrestagung der
gress on Occupational Health, Tokyo, Deutschen Gesellschaft für Verkehrsmedizin,
22-27 Sept. 1969. pp.419-420. Hamburg, 11-13 April 1975, pp.7-16.
2.1 Work and Recreation at Sea 81
32. Zorn, E.: Beiträge zur Berufsbelastung und ter besonderer Berücksichtigung gefährlicher
kardialen Mortalität der Seelotsen von 1945 bis Ladung. Hansa 116,6,465-469 (1979).
1973. Hamburg 1976.
33. Zorn, E.: Die Nachtfahrt und ihre sehphysiolo- Additional Reference
gische Problematik. Der Seewart 41. 4, 157-162
(1980). Gaethe, H.: Arbeitshygiene in der Schiffahrt. In:
34. Zorn, E., B.-F.Schepers and H.Goethe: Ge- Handbuch der gesamten Arbeitsmedizin.
sundheitsgefährdung durch Chemikalien. Un- Val. IV, Part 2. Ed.: H. Symanski. Berlin, Urban
tersuchungen an Bord deutscher Seeschiffe un- & Schwarzenberg 1963. pp. 597-648.
2.2 Ship Design - its Effects on the Seafarer's Physical
and Mental Health
T.Ivergärd
tions on board differ greatly from the con- maps and, not least, radar. Auditory infor-
ditions ashore. Exposure to the various en- mation also plays an important role, but
vironmental factors occurs in different must be seen as subordinate to the visual. If
ways from those on land; for instance, the information is to be effective then the
while on a voyage the crew is exposed to visual surroundings must be designed with
environmental conditions such as noise consideration for the information trans mit-
and vibration far 24 hours a day. ted and for man's needs.
The large Swedish survey study The Recommendations on lighting in ships
Work Environment on Ships (Ivergärd [14]) are mainly concerned with the general
and studies about ergonomics and reliabili- lighting level. For example the Swedish
ty in ship handling (Istance and Ivergärd Board for Shipping requires that the gener-
[10]; Istance and Ivergärd [11]) form the allighting be at least 80 lux, and that occa-
base for most of the results reported in this sional work-places have at least 40 lux. On
chapter. gangways and platforms, at least 80 lux is
needed. The authority also gives simple
2.2.2.1 Lighting (see also Chap.2.5) recommendations on comparative illumi-
A ship is often likened to a miniature socie- nation, but there are no detailed descrip-
ty. With regard to lighting this means that tions of how lighting conditions should be
all the requirements made of lighting in so- arranged on the bridge in order to create
ciety should also exist on board ship. This optimal visual conditions. Night lighting
is indeed true when one considers that the on the bridge should be designed in such a
ship contains work-places, hornes (in the way as to balance the need for dark adapta-
sense of individualliving areas) and recrea- tion ofthe eyes with the need to see with an
tion areas. Considering that the work on acceptable degree of clarity. It is also im-
board ranges from highly qualified naviga- portant that the bridge lighting is suitable
tional work to heavy lifting and moving ob- for daylight conditions. During daytime
jects on the deck, it can be said that every the illumination inside the bridge must be
area on board has its own special lighting high, as this reduces the problem of glare
requirements. General lighting criteria from the bright extern al environment and
have been published by the US Illuminat- also allows easier reading of instruments.
ing Engineering Society [20]. Ivergard [12] has developed recommenda-
The ship can be divided into four areas, tions for bridge lighting.
each with different lighting requirements: The risk of reflections in instrument
1. Control rooms, i. e. the bridge, the radio glass and windows is an obvious problem
station, the engine control rooms and, in which can be solved by suitable positioning
certain cases, the cargo control room; of lamp fittings and orientation of instru-
2. The engine room and other areas with ments and windows.
technical equipment and apparatus; Lighting conditions on bridges are bad
3. The deck; in most ships. The possibility of maintain-
4. Living and recreation areas. ing good dark adaptation is very slim.
The problem of lighting is important in Work on the bridge is therefore normally
many steering and controlling jobs on done with only partly adapted eyes, which,
board ships, and lighting is also important of course, severely reduces visual ability.
in the avoidance of accidents. The role of (The distance at which another ship can be
visual information is a crucial factor in the detected on a clear night may be less than
safe handling of the ship. Visual informa- one-tenth of the detection distance for the
tion comes from outside as weIl as inside fully dark-adapted eyes). The way in which
the ship from: other ships, land contours, information is presented on dials and in-
lighthouses, instruments, charts, weather struments varies considerably. Sometimes
84 2 The Seafarer's Environment
they have white text on a black back- length of exposure are difficult to make.
ground, sometimes black on a white back- Noise masks sound signals and speech
ground and occasionally combinations of communieations, making the use of the in-
other colours. If the bridge is lit with stan- tercom system, phones, VHF radio etc.
dard red light at night then instruments very difficult, and can cause considerable
with white text on red background can only disturbance. Noise on ships often has a
be read with the help of a toreh. Lighting in very large low frequency component; this
many other places in the ship is so bad that is especially so on the bridge.
there are clear risks of accidents, particu- One must remember that noise not only
larly in stair areas and gangways. affects man's hearing, but can also be dis-
Recommendations regarding illumina- turbing and troublesome, and affect effi-
tion levels are normally given in lux. In er- ciency in other ways. Noise affects man's
gonomies literature, one often finds discus- effectiveness and behaviour indirectly via
sions ab out the suitability of this type of the autonomie nervous system. It causes a
criterion for lighting. It is, of course, the lu- "general stress reaction" in the body,
minance and not the illumination which whieh, at least temporarily, causes a higher
one experiences; but from a design point of level of alertness and tension. In the longer
view it is much easier to design a light fit- term, tiredness effects occur. Low frequen-
ting to fulfil certain illumination require- cy noise and infrasound cause risks of
ments than to fulfil certain luminance crite- other psychologieal effects which can re-
ria. It should be possible to fulfil lumi- duce man's ability to carry out monoto-
nance criteria if the illumination engineer nous work demanding a high level of vigi-
has detailed knowledge of the form of the lance.
room, the superstructure, the colour, the The situation on the bridge is often
type of surface etc. This will probably be worse due to extra infrasound arising from
too complicated. Recommendations about the funnel and also, being at a higher level
suitable levels of luminance (cd/m2) on the ship, bears the greatest effect of am-
should therefore only be given for rooms plification from low frequency vibrations
with special requirements from a visual in bulkheads etc. Infrasound can affect
point of view. Instead, one has to combine man in different ways, including slower
the recommendations about illumination reaction times.
levels with recommendations about suit- As was mentioned previously, it is diffi-
able values for reflection factors on walls, cult to use normal hearing damage criteria,
instruments etc. Maximum contrast differ- as men on board ships are exposed to the
ences for the surroundings should be re- noise for 24 hours per day for many days.
commended, using some type of suitable Probably the general stress criteria for
glare indices. noise exposure will be much more impor-
tant. Before it is possible to define some
2.2.2.2 Noise (see also Chap.2.6) general maximum exposure level for noise
Noise is a factor causing substantial prob- on board ships it is probably necessary to
lems for work and recreation on board. In know a lot more about man's systemic
Chap.2.6 limits are presented for noise lev- reaction to noise. One could also question
els in ships according to IMO [4]. General the value of general exposure levels as de-
data about noise on ships are found in Berg sign criteria.
[3]. From a design point of view, ashore it is
Noise levels in the engine room can ex- very useful to know the maximum sound
ceed 110 dB, but the fact that even in the power level from a certain machine unit. In
living quarters noise is continuously about industries it is often possible to compute
60 dB means that recommendations about sound pressure levels at different places
2.2 Ship Design - its Effects,on the Seafarer's Physical and Mental HeaIth 85
from knowledge of sound power levels that vibration on the bridge floor is espe-
from different machine units. However, the cially noticeable. Men are often standing
ship's structure and the different machine still for long periods on the bridge (e. g. the
units are so integrated that it becomes too helmsman). Subjective complaints ofvibra-
complicated a procedure. Instead, one has tion, pain in the knees etc. have often been
to rely mainly upon knowledge of how reported. Measurements have shown that
noise from the main sources is distributed the amplitudes exceed the ISO limit values
throughout the ship. for 24 hours' exposure, yet these measure-
ments are taken only occasionally, which is
2.2.2.3 Vibrations (see also Chap.2.6) surprising considering the number of com-
Vibration is an important environmental plaints.
factor closely linked to noise. Its effects on Use of damped chairs on board can be
man are either local or whole-body effects. of great help in reducing the load on the
The local effects are primarily those from body, and perhaps especially in legs and
handtools etc. and will not be dealt with knees, which can eventually be injured by
here as these problems are the same as vibration. Skolnick [23] and Rumyantsev
those on land. Of greater interest is whole und Mekhelson [21] discuss the effect ofvi-
body vibration to which in principle one is bration on seamen aboard.
continuously exposed wherever one is on
the ship. 2.2.2.4 Thermal Environment (see also
The main resonant frequencies of the Chap.2.4)
human body are between 3 and 7 Hz, and The thermal environment is a very special
the impedance is considerably higher for problem on ships [5]. The main reason is
people standing than for a relaxed, sitting that the ship moves through different cli-
person. Vibration can cause a feeling of matic zones that can be either very hot and
discomfort and can become painful at humid or extremely cold. Although pas-
higher amplitudes. Very low frequency vi- sages through Arctic waters can cause se-
bration at high amplitude causes move- vere problems for unprotected personnei, it
ments of the body and increased sweating is the hot climate that most often presents
and salivation, headache and nausea. At difficulties.
higher frequencies, headaches and fatigue Most modem ships are equipped with
occur. air-conditioning in the control rooms and
Very powerful vibration over a long peri- living quarters. In the engine room and car-
od can cause damage to the skeleton and go space it is not possible to control the
inner organs, and visual ability is also re- thermal climate and this will result in an
duced. It can also cause a general stress ef- excessive heatload.
fect and increased metabolic rate. There Work is being done in Sweden towards
are currently no recommendations on vi- an international standard index for hot cli-
bration, but there are some internationally mates. The US limit values are based on the
agreed limits [7]. Chapter 2.6 presents some following formula, known as WBGT (wet
commonly used vibration criteria accord- bulb globe temperature index):
ing to ISO recommendations. There is evi- WBGT=O.7 WB+O.3 GT
dence which indicates that the levels in Out-of-doors, it is calculated thus:
these recommendations ought to be low- WBGT=O.7WB+0.2GT+O.1 DB
ered. As with noise, the values do not take where WB = wet bulb temperature
into account that exposure exceeds DB = dry bulb temperature
24hours. GT = globe temperature
Vibration measurements on the deck at The wet bulb temperature is measured
different positions in the ship have shown with athermometer which has a piece of
86 2 The Seafarer's Environment
Table 1. Permissible US threshold limit values for 2. The deck, where the external climate de-
exposure to heat (values are given in 0C)a termines the thermal conditions.
Work-rest regimen Work-load 3. The engine room, where the thermal en-
vironment is influenced by the external
Light Moderate Heavy
climate and the power output of the
Continuous work 30.0 26.7 25.0 main engines.
75% work 4. The cargo holds and storage areas,
25% rest, each hour 30.6 28.0 25.9 where the climate is decided by the water
50% work temperature and the external climate.
50% rest, each hour 31.4 29.4 27.9
2.2.2.5 Air Pollution
25% work
75% rest, each hour 32.2 31.1 39.0 Air pollution on board is a problem that
a Higher heat exposures than those shown are per-
occurs in many different forms. Pollution
missible if the workers have been undergoing can arise from the cargo, the engines and
medical surveillance and it has been established (most often) the work that is performed.
that they are more tolerant to work in heat than Contrary to common belief, the air quality
the average worker. Workers should not be per-
mitted to continue working when their deep body
in the engine room is generally good. This
temperature exceeds 38.0°C is mainly because of the high air consump-
tion of the combustion in the engines,
which gives a high turnover of the air and
dilutes air pollutants.
wet gauze around the bulb, and the dry Air pollution is most serious while han-
bulb temperature with an ordinary ther- dling cargo. For instance, when loading a
mometer shielded from radiated heat. A crude oil tanker a large amount of hydro-
globe temperature is read from a common carbons is released on the deck and may
thermometer placed in the centre of a spread to the living quarters (depending on
15-cm diameter black-painted copper the wind direction). On RoRo ships and
globe. ferries, the exhaust fumes from vehicles
Table 1 shows the allowed values for dif- with internal combustion engines result in
ferent working conditions and loads. These serious problems. Dust from bulk cargoes
values are in fact experienced as fairly can also cause problems if open handling
stressful, and heat stress is thus a serious methods are used.
risk which can cause special problems for Local problems with air pollution arise
the elderlY and those with circulatory trou- while performing different kinds of jobs.
ble. Studies show that many places on Examples of this in the engine room are oil
board show temperature levels above the mist while working in the crankcase of
recommended index values. In the engine large bore diesels a short time after stop-
room, conditions at times are such that the ping the engine and the handling of chemi-
work/rest ratio should be 1 : 3. cals for boiler water treatment (hydroxine).
In the galley the cook may experience Examples on the deck are rust rem oval
thermal overload despite air conditioning, and, of course, use of solvents while paint-
owing to heat radiation from the stove. ing, especially in closed spaces with limited
With respect to the thermal environment, ventilation.
the ship can be thought of as consisting of There are, in most countries, special
four principal areas: threshold limit values or maximum al-
1. Internalliving and service areas (cabins, lowed concentrations for air pollution ex-
messes, the galley, offices etc.), which on posure at work-places. Threshold limit val-
most ships in worId-wide services are ues (TLV) are divided into time-weighted
equipped with air-conditioning. average (TWA), ceiling limits (CL) and
2.2 Ship Design - its Effects on the Seafarer's Physical and Mental Health 87
short-term exposure limits (STEL). These great differences, in, for example, the
limit values are of great importance in de- height from the dockside, and also the
ciding if there are health risks from air pol- steep slope of the gangway, slippery steps
lution. However, in designing a ventilation and unsatisfactory or missing hand rails.
system these threshold exposure limit val- The lighting is often very poor. Consider-
ues alone are of less value in avoiding ex- able risks exist in work at heights, and acci-
cessive air pollution at work-places. Addi- dents due to slipping are very common.
tional criteria have to be used. It has been Apart from the direct and obvious health
suggested that consideration should be giv- risks, there are many problems of wear and
en to the maximum concentration of emit- tear and fatigue. On the bridge, these are
ted air pollution from different machine often associated with standing and with
units. One could for example specify that constrained working positions. Changes of
diesel engines should only be allowed to design of the equipment on the bridge
emit X mg S02 per hour. This value could should enable the conditions to be created
then be used in combination with similar for variation in sitting and standing work,
values from other machines to design a for comfortable and effective working po-
suitable ventilation system with local ex- sitions. Studies of work on the bridge have
haust and general ventilation. also revealed the occurrence of problems
of vision, but the degree and seriousness of
2.2.2.6 Accidents and General Work
these could not be determined; neither has
Problems
it been possible to show more exactly the
In investigating these problems, the types reasons for these problems. It can be stated
of task a particular crew member has to generally, however, that the lighting condi-
perform must be considered. Before decid- tions on the bridge are often wholly unsat-
ing how a bridge, engine control room or isfactory, and this in combination with spe-
cargo control room shall be designed, it is cialised and difficult visual tasks (e. g. radar
necessary to carry out a function and task observations) could weIl be the cause.
analysis, and then to decide which func- Great problems of fatigue and a number
tions will be performed by man and which of smaller injuries also occur in the engine
by machine. When the various tasks to be room in connection with maintenance and
done by man have been defined, they can service work. In all ships studied, even
be grouped into suitable jobs. From this those which in other respects have been
one can decide upon the types of instru- weIl designed, little thought has been given
ments and controls needed at a particular to the maintenance and repair of the ship.
work-place. In aseries of reports by Toni The main trouble, from an ergonomic point
Ivergard and Howell Istance, published by of view, arises from the very heavy work
the Swedish Ship Research Foundation, that is occasionally required and from a
the problems of bridge design have been lack of working space, which leads to high-
discussed and recommendations made [9, ly unsuitable working positions.
10,11,12,13]. The galley is also the site of fatigue, ow-
The risk of accidents varies with the type ing to the bad working positions associated
of ship. In general, however, serious risks with standing work. In combination with
are present in mooring and certain forms of these problems of fatigue, there is also a
cargo handling (e. g. work with motor vehi- host of risks similar to those found in
eIes or with cargo hatch covers). Gangways kitchens on land. The risks are, however,
and accommodation ladders are also seri- magnified considerably by the movement
ous areas of risk. The method of boarding ofthe ship.
large ships does not differ markedly from The notable factor about maritime con-
that of boarding small ships, in spite of the ditions is that many problems often occur
88 2 The Seafarer's Environment
relatively satisfactory from the thermal and work, reduced turnover of personnel and
noise points of view. increased safety on board.
The c1imatic conditions, which in many Continued research and investigative
cases are difficult, can be dealt with in work in this area must be directed towards
many different ways [18]: Ventilation to finding solutions to the problems cited (in
produce an environment conforming to cooperation with the crew members) and
current recommendations should be pro- not be Iimited to merely identifying those
vided in the galley. In the engine room the problems.
intake air to powerful machines in small
rooms should be fed directIy to the air inlet 2.2.3.2 Project Methodology
on the engine, thereby avoiding the
draught problem. Various smaller machine Methods of planning, designing and build-
systems in the engine room, such as auxil- ing ships vary considerably between differ-
iary engines and separators, can be posi- ent places in the world, and also within any
tioned in aseparate space where the c1i- one country. In certain cases the shipyard
mate can be more easily controlled. Hot builds ships wholly according to its own
parts of machines can to a large extent be specifications, without any arranged buyer.
insulated so that the heat radiated out into The ship is then put onto the market in the
the engine room is reduced. This, however, same way as many other capital goods. The
must be investigated and planned carefully, possibility for the purchasing shipping line
so that maintenance is not made more diffi- to influence the working environment on
cult. Gardner and Coker [6] have presented board is almost non-existent in these cases.
occupational hygiene guidelines for ship It is more common in Europe for the ship-
construction. On deck at the bow and stern, ping line to put forward some form of gen-
observation places shielded from the wind eral specification for the ship they require,
can be provided, so that the waiting time and the yard which gets the order carries
involved in mooring and other activities in out a more detailed design. In these cases
harbour can be spent in protected areas the shipping line has a good opportunity to
with good visibility. There are already ex- influence the design and fitting-out of the
amples of this, but the idea can be further ship with working conditions in mind.
developed. In recent years some of the larger ship-
As far as psychosocial factors are con- ping lines in Europe have built up relative-
cerned, the only changes and improve- ly large technical departments which ac-
ments which can in the long term be of tively participate in the design and con-
benefit for the officers and crew are those struction of ships. This participation can
which are based on the willingness of the occur in several ways. One way is to carry
crew themselves. A move to tackle some of out a very detailed specification for the
these problems involves, among other ship before offers from shipping Iines are
things: invited. Another is for a more general spec-
The co operation of the whole crew in the ification to be produced, the shippers then
planning and sharing of the work, agreeing with the yard on cooperation in
Improved leadership training the design of certain parts of the ship.
The introduction of permanent crew mem- These two, and especially the latter project
bers. methodology, give the shippers an excel-
These measures can be expected to lead lent opportunity to influence the future
to considerable benefits - for example, in- working conditions on board.
creased interest and concern for one an- In discussing the possibilites for chang-
other, deeper relationships, fewer psycho- ing or influencing the working environ-
social problems, increased satisfaction with ment conditions in connection with ship
2.2 Ship Design - its Effects on the Seafarer's Physical and Mental Health 91
design, three complementary methods can The thinking behind this is that they will
be used: have the chance to enrich the planning
1. Expert cooperation, direct and indirect; work with their own experience and knowl-
2. User influence in the planning process; edge. A proposal now being considered by
3. A systematic approach. the Swedish government will provide simi-
lar conditions for those employed on ships.
Expert Cooperation Planning should be carried out in such a
This can take pi ace in several ways. The way that the employees and/or their re-
first is by calling in experts from different presentatives are not merely given the func-
fields concerned with the environment to tion of examining drawings made in the
take part in the planning process. This traditional way. For those who are not fa-
would apply in the production of specifica- miliar with reading a traditional drawing
tions for which regulations or norms must of, for example, a crew's mess, it is very dif-
be observed and in the design of ventila- ficult to understand and to get a c1ear pic-
tion, sound-absorbing equipment etc. It ture of what this drawing will mean in
can also take the form of indirect coopera- terms of environmental conditions. A per-
tion, with the use of checklists, handbooks spective drawing can give a considerably
etc. which the working environment ex- better understanding of how the environ-
perts have produced. This latter method is ment will finally appear. For the participa-
difficult in practice, as there is little rele- tion of the employees to be fruitful, it is
vant knowledge which is accessible in such thus necessary to change the presentation
a form that it can be used easily by the non- methods of different construction sugges-
expert. One is therefore dependent upon tions so that it becomes easier for the em-
using experts directly in the planning work, ployees to get a picture of what the differ-
and it is vital that they are called in early ent alternatives will entail.
enough in the different planning phases. One problem with the planning and de-
The basic environmental and ergonomic sign of a ship, which also occurs on land
demands must be formulated at the specifi- with the design of a completely new indus-
cation stage. Care should be taken to in- try, is that when the planning begins there
c1ude such general problems as the overall are no employees. Where the higher grades
design, positioning of the whole super- are concerned, this problem has recently
structure, choice of the number and type of begun to be solved by employing officers at
main engines, etc. It is also a matter of de- a very early stage in the planning. This is
signing the specifications for the different good, and is used to the greatest possible
environmental factors such as noise, vibra- extent. As regards the crew members, one
tion, lighting, thermal c1imate, accident could imagine representatives of the crews
risks and work factors. of similar ships taking part in the planning
process. But it is perhaps even more impor-
Cooperation from Employees
tant to try to build flexibility into the ship
In today's planning and construction so that the employees themselves can take
stages of a ship there exist certain interest part in the design. This flexibility can be of
groups such as the future owner (shipping several different types. In some instances it
line), the shipyard, the constructors, the can be achieved by means of sliding parti-
planners and the future crew members. It is tions, adjustable lighting fixtures, or walls
the shipping line which holds the casting and partitions which can be taken down
vote in making decisions. For those em- and re-installed elsewhere, although this
ployed on land a law may exist which gives may be difficult to reconcile with the re-
employees the right to take part in the plan- quirements of ventilation, water and power
ning of new industries and work-places. systems etc.
92 2 The Seafarer's Environment
Definition of
objectives
Specification of
functions
Allocotion of Task
functions synthesis Skill
Task analysis
analysis
Person ne I
System System
Manufacture
integration evaluation
Fig.3. Decisions in the systems design approach (Singleton [22])
go into any function analyses for the differ- It is important that design ofthe individ-
ent subsystems involved in the man-ship ual work-places does not follow directly
interface. It suffices to stress the impor- upon the allocation phase. Starting with al-
tance of carrying out the function analysis location, one should first analyse the tasks
with as few prejudices as possible, and of which the crew member has been given,
not deciding upon which technical solu- and these tasks can then be divided into
tions will be chosen for different applica- their separate components. In this way job
tions during the function analysis phase. descriptions are obtained. From these,
Neither should one decide in this phase work-places can then be built up which ful-
whether a certain function should be per- fit the needs of particular job. This is very
formed by machine or man; this decision important but very neglected in ships,
should be taken in the next phase of the where work-places are often put together
work. without direct consideration of the work
The allocation phase is, perhaps, in involved in the different jobs. This has re-
many ways the most important, because it sulted in there being only a few distinct
is here that the degree of automation is work-places on board ship, which in turn
chosen. It is therefore very important that leads to misunderstandings and a risk of
the employees or their representatives are mistakes.
given the chance to participate. In discuss-
ing the degree of automation one must 2.2.3.3 Evaluation
judge the effectiveness and abilities of man In this section, only questions of evaluating
compared with machines; to do this one work environment problems and man-ma-
must have an understanding of the total chine systems will be discussed briefly.
work situation which the new system will Special mention will be made of the need
involve. It is often easy, for example, to for a more continuous follow-up of the
choose a technical solution for predicting ships within one yard, or the merchant
collision risks (collision avoidance system) fleets of a whole country. It is obviously de-
because it might be thought that the techni- sirable to attempt to carry out different
cal system is more effective. But in this case types of evaluation of those measures
there is the risk of choosing the technical which one tried to introduce in the design
system without giving closer thought to of the ship. If, for example, one has at-
what happens when it fails. One can dis- tempted to comply with certain noise regu-
cuss in this case how man's ability to han- lations or recommended pollution levels, it
dle the ship in the traditional way is affect- is desirable to measure how weil the goal
ed by having worked for a long time with has been attained. But it is seldom that
the automatie system, which may have led these follow-up studies are done later in
to areduction in skill in controlling the sys- the ship's life. It is often said by shipping
tem manually. management that they have a fairly good
A badly designed automatie system used picture of the types of problems on their
for too long can lead to impaired perfor- ships, the complaints received from the
mance during normal work, and in abnor- crew, and the repairs and service work
mal situations (e. g. systems failures or needed to be done on board. Similarly, at
other overloading) the crew member will the shipyard it is stated that one gets a good
have had insufficient training and conse- picture of how successful one has been in
quently will function badly. This reasoning different ways through the complaints re-
when choosing the degree of automation ceived and the work which has to be done
can be used in the discussion of both (a) under guarantee.
bridge systems and machine control rooms If ships are viewed from the purely tech-
and (b) maintenance and repair work. nical point of view, it is possible to regard
94 2 The Seafarer's Environment
these present follow-up methods as suffi- working groups within the shipping lines
cient. But when a ship is regarded as a could also be incorporated in national, and
man-machine system, the existing methods perhaps also international associations
at company management and shipyard lev- which could follow-up the work of the
el are without doubt inadequate. Many of groups and handle the statistics which
the ergonomic faults found on ships are not could be produced by the groups. In this
noticed in the same way as obvious techni- way, one should achieve a sufficiently wide
cal faults or failings. Instruments unsuit- statistical basis to be able to evaluate rela-
ably positioned on the bridge are perhaps tively quickly the effect of new technical
feit by the bridge personnel to be some- developments on safety at sea. This form of
what irritating and troublesome, but they evaluation system would also provide a ba-
do not necessarily affect the work under sis for pinpointing areas where there is a
normal conditions. On the other hand, an need for technical research and develop-
unsuitable instrument position or an un- ment work.
suitable direction of movement of a control Beside this form of evaluation of the di-
can be a serious fault in a critical situation rect man-machine interplay, there is also a
where one must suddenly and quickly car- need to follow-up individuals. There is, in
ry out a manoeuvre correctly. If no acci- Sweden today, a comprehensive system of
dent occurs, it is just a question of a com- industrial health care for employees on
mon critical incident which is easily forgot- land, where they undergo health checks di-
ten. The causes are not analysed in more rected towards those problems, which exist
detail and there is no feedback of this type at each employee's work-place. As yet, the
of information concerning technical fail- shipping industry in Sweden has no similar
ings to the shipping company and ship- system of health care. The creation of a
yard. If an accident actually happens, it can similar system in the shipping industry,
be too late to report. based (regarding choice of health screen-
It can similarly be discussed whether one ing, medical examinations etc.) on the type
becomes accustomed to and does not no- of health risks and working environment
tice many different types of failings in the problems actually found on ships, would
man-machine system in a dangerous work- also be a valuable form of follow-up of the
ing environment, e. g. a machine room well-being of seamen.
where one works many hours each day.
Probably it is only when a reaUy obvious
accident occurs that the fault is noticed and References
there is a chance that it will be reported. In
order to detect this form of failing it is nec- 1. Accident prevention on board ship at sea and in
essary to have some sort of continuous fol- port. Geneva: ILO 1978. (ILO Codes of prac-
tice)
low-up of the ship under operational con- 2. Bark, G.: Propellerkaviation som bullerkälla.
ditions. For example, one could conceive Ed.: Statens Skeppsprovningsanstalt. Gothen-
of some form of working group within a burg 1978. (AIlmän rapport No. 52).
shipping company, consisting of offkers 3. Berg, P.Aa.: Noise abatement on ships. Ma-
and crew members working systematically, chines and machinery. Measuring and presen-
tation of noise data. Gothenburg 1972 and
meeting regularly and discussing the faults 1973. (SSFreport NO.5309:12 E)
in different parts of the ship which might 4. Code on noise levels in ships. Ed.: IMCO. Lon-
endanger health or cause accidents or colli- don 1980.
sions at sea. 5. Fläkten. Svenska Fläktfabriken 32, 33 (1970).
6. Gardner, A. W. and D. Coker: Occupational hy-
At the same time, in order to have a base giene guidelines for ship construction. Ed.:
for a broader national follow-up of new ESSO Petroleum Co. Ud. Fawley/ Abingdon
technical developments in shipping, these 1977.
2.2 Ship Design - its Effects on the Seafarer's Physical and Mental Health 95
7. Guide for the evaluation of human exposure to International Transport Workers' Journal 23, 5,
wholebody vibration. 2nd ed. 1978-01-15. ISO 112-113 (1963).
2631. 1978. 18. Recommendation concerning air conditioning
8. Hult, M.: Noise abatement on ships. Gothen- of crew accommodation and certain other
burg 1976. (SSF report 118) spaces on board ship. Recommendation 140.
9. Istance, H.: Utformning av en manövermodul. Geneva: ILO 1970. pp. 32-33.
Gothenburg 1978. (SSF report 178) 19. Recommendation concerning protection
10. Istance, H. and T. Ivergard: Ergonomics and re- against hazards of poisoning arising from ben-
liability in ship handling systems - Theories, zene. Recommendation No. 144. Geneva: ILO
models and methods. Gothenburg 1976. (SSF 1971.
report 5311: 10) 20. Recommended practice for marine lighting,
11. Istance, H. and T. Ivergard: Ergonomics and re- RP-12, of the Illuminating Engineering Society,
liability in ship handling system. Gothenburg USA, July 1974.
1978. (SSF report 157) 21. Rumyantsev, G.1. and D.AMekhelson: Vliy-
12. Ivergard, T.: Belysning pa bryggan. Ed.: Sjöfar- anie shumo-vibratsionnogo faktora v kom-
tens Arbetarskyddsnämnd. Gothenburg 1977. plekse sudovykh uslovi na organism moryakov.
13. Ivergard, T.: Ergonomics and reliability in the [The effect of noise and vibration on seamen
handling of ships - A criticalliterature review. aboard oceangoing vessels]. Gig. i Sanit. 35,9,
Gothenburg 1975. (SSF report 5311: 8) 25-27 (1971).
14. Ivergard, T. (ed): Arbetsmiljö inom sjöfarten. 22. Singleton, W. T.: Current trends towards system
Sjöfartens Arbetarskyddsnämnd. Gothenburg design. London: Her Majesty's Stationery Of-
1978. fice 1966. (Ergonomics for Industry)
15. Laborit, H.: Opinions concernant la fatigue et 23. Skolnick, A: Crew performance requirements
l'adaptation de l'homme a la chaleur. Resultats in the vibration environments of surface effect
acquis et orientation actuelle des recherches ships. In: Vibration and combined stresses in
dans la marine. Rev. Med. nav. 14,3,217-236 advanced systems. Aerospace Medical Panel
(1959). Specialists' Meeting, 0810, 22-23April 1974.
16. Oborne, D.J.: Vibration and passenger comfort. AGARD Conference Proceedings No 145, B3-1
Appl. Ergonomics 8,2,97-101 (1977). - B3-9.
17.0tterland, A: Accidents to Swedish Seafarers. 24. Söderqvist, S.: Propellerinducerat buller i far-
tyg. Gothenburg 1972. (SSF report No. 5309: 8)
2.3 The Effect of the Macroclimate
H.Ebert
2.3.1 External Climatic Conditions humid c1imate with intense sunlight (tem-
peratures up to 36 oe with a mean humidity
Under climate we understand a group of of 80%- 90%).
permanent meteorological conditions that The totality of meteorological and at-
remain typical for a prolonged period. The mospheric conditions form the basis for the
term weather, in contrast, denotes only external c1imate (macroclimate) in a given
short-term meteorological changes lasting, part of the world. This external c1imate has
say, for a day, a month, or even a season. a considerable influence on the c1imate
The earth can be divided into four large c1i- within c10sed stationary or mobile spaces
matic zones: (microclimate) created by man as part of
The polar zone is characterized by long, his living and working conditions. In gen-
bitter and very foggy winters with consider- eral, working spaces and living spaces are
able precipitation and cold summers with not in the vicinity of each other. The condi-
little sunshine. tions established in the living space permit,
The temperate zone characteristically has depending on the social situation, more or
cool summers, moderately cold winters less complete recuperation of the pro-
and frequent precipitation. ductive capacity where working conditions
The subtropical zone is warm and sunny. are arduous. The situation in the shipping
Humidity is low, and there is little precipi- industry is different: the ship serves the
tation. The winters are short and mild. seafarer as both living and working space
The tropics are characterized by a hot, simultaneously for considerable periods. It
'i? ~dL
c==J ever sullry c:==J Periodically sultry UIIIIIIIIIID Permanenfly sultry
Fig.1. Sea zone according to the degree of heat and humidity (sultrine ). (after Scharlau)
2.3 The Effect ofthe Macroclimate 97
is important that this be taken into account via blood circulation and temperature. In
when assessing the requirements he must warm c1imates this is manifested as in-
fulfil and the stresses he has to bear, includ- creased circulation of blood through the
ing those imposed by the climate (Ebert skin, sweating and faster breathing. In cold
[4]). c1imates, in contrast, blood circulation in
the skin decreases and, to produce more
2.3.2 Effects of the Climate heat, muscle tonicity increases until shiver-
on Seafarers ing sets in. Extreme overstressing ofthe cir-
culatory sytem in either direction can lead
Developments in science and technology to heart failure. From the standpoint of oc-
have enabled modern ships to cover large cupational medicine such stresses can be
distances in very short times. This results in assessed by measuring changes in values
rapid and frequent movement from one cli- such as body temperature, heart rate and
matic zone to another and, consequently, sweat loss, which are measures of certain
substantial stresses on the human organ- body functions.
ism. Man is influenced by c1imatic effects According to Granz [16] the acclimatiza-
and changes in atmospheric conditions tion of man takes place in two phases, each
(cycIones and anticyclones) which have a of which lasts about 60 days. The first
radical effect on his physical and mental phase is characterized by a reduction in
reactions (loss of productive capacity, de- overall capacity, i. e. a reduction in physical
pressions, neuralgia etc. can occur). In view and mental concentration and the ability to
ofthis it is essential to take into account the react accompanied by diminishing oxygen
variations in the performance capabilities consumption. In the second phase the
of seafarers when exposed to different cli- above parameters increase again until they
mates if harmful effects on their health and have returned to the original values. The
safety are to be avoided while at sea. heart rate is the most important criterion of
An analysis of the available literature re- physiological stress and it permits conclu-
veals that the working capacity of people sions to be drawn regarding the adaptabili-
under different c1imatic conditions has ty of the organism. Under tropical condi-
been studied mainly at stationary work- tions, physical work promotes acclimatiza-
pI aces or under simulated conditions in tion and has an additional training effect
laboratories (climatic chambers). Such on the heart and circulatory system as
studies involve short-term loads and the re- shown by recent investigations published
suIts cannot be applied without further by Granz and Ziegler [17]. Factors which
consideration of conditions on board. Ac- may delay adequate adaptation to a hot cli-
cording to our present knowledge, the mate are obesity, lack of exercise, excessive
long-term effects of c1imate on well-being, adaptation to enclosed spaces, lack of
physical and mental capability and health sleep, tension, psychological instability
are expressed by two biochemical and and, finally, abuse of alcohol, nicotine and
physical reactions: drugs. Under tropical conditions, sweating
1. Increase of the basal metabolism from and, more important, evaporation of sweat,
the norma170 kcallh (293 kJ/h) to about which depend on humidity, air temperature
100 kcallh (419 kJlh); and air movement, are the most important
2. Constant regulation of the body temper- phenomena that regulate the body temper-
ature to a steady state of 36-37 °C. ature. Sweating starts at 30°C and in-
The main load of these regulatory pro- creases considerably with the temperature.
cesses is carried by the heart and circulato- Under conditions of extreme heat a liquid
ry system because heat is exchanged be- intake of 5-11litres per day may be neces-
tween the organism and its environment sary (Granz and Ziegler [17]).
98 2 The Seafarer's Environment
sible, unless, of course, the ship spends involved in different activities. Work cate-
several weeks at anchor. The problem of gories are categories based on total meta-
acc1imatization is particularly relevant bolic activity into which activities are
nowadays, when seafarers frequently join graded on the basis of the postures, mo-
ship by air travel. Often they are expected tions and loads they typically involve. They
to take up their duties shortly after joining do not, of course, take emergency situa-
the ship, while suffering from jet-lag and tions into account. According to Noack
before acc1imatization has been possible. and Schulz [26], work on board can be
Granz [16] and Ejsmont et al. [6-12] have split into three work categories which can
reported on the constantly changing loads be used as a basis for deciding hours of
to which seafarers are exposed due to acc1i- work:
matization and their effects on perfor- Category 1 contains activities that are
mance. performed standing or seated and in which
the physical component of the work con-
2.4.2 Evaluation of Microclimatic sists mainly oflight handwork. The work of
Loads on Seafarers radio operators and deck officers, for in-
stance, belongs in this category.
Industrial hygiene values have been elabo- Category 2 contains activities that in-
rated to permit assessment of the loads im- volve standing and walking, but not the
posed on people by c1imatic conditions at movement of loads, and activities that are
their place of work and the microc1imates performed while seated and involve con-
existing in working spaces. However, these stant work with one and light work with
cannot be applied to work-places in the two arms or heavy work with the hands.
open air or in roofed structures which are The work ofthe engine room personneI, for
only partly enc10sed (Noack and Schulz instance, belongs to this category.
[26]). It is necessary to distinguish between Category 3 is characterized by the mov-
optimum and permissible microc1imatic ing of light loads and activities performed
conditions: mainly while standing or walking; activi-
1. Optimum microc1imatic conditions are ti es involving constant heavy or moderately
those which induce no change in the heavy work with both arms while seated al-
functional or general status of the hu- so belong hefe. This category includes the
man organism and do not load the ther- work of the galley personneI, stewards and
moregulation of the body, even during stewardesses and deck ratings.
prolonged exposure. They maintain a In the shipping industry it will be impos-
comfortable temperature and provide sible as a rule to obtain optimum microcli-
optimum conditions for work. matic conditions on account of the con-
2. Permissible microc1imatic conditions are stantly changing macrocIimatic situation. It
those which no longer guarantee a com- is therefore necessary to define permissible
fortable temperature but, while imposing microclimatic conditions appropriate to
a major load on the temperature regula- the different seasons for the above work
tion system, do not exceed the limits of categories. Permissible values for the cold
physical adaptability. They do not dis- season are based on mean daily tempera-
turb or harm the health but, depending tures of 12 oe or below. The period when
on the activity concemed and the values the daily mean temperatures are over 12 oe
of the c1imatic components, are more or is referred to as the warm season. The per-
less detrimental to well-being and per- missible microc1imatic conditions for the
formance capacity. different work categories may be stipulated
When assessing these effects it is also ap- in national regulations for the various
propriate to categorize the physical loads times of year.
2.4 The Microclimate of the Ship 101
Area Air con- Fresh air Air condi- Room air Relative Air speed
dition- tioning humidity in (draughts)
ing the case of air
conditioning
Summer Winter
Above
outside tem-
perature
Accommodation, 25°C ~5°C 20°-23°C ?;20°C 50% ± 10% ~0.2m/s
common rooms, etc.
(cabins, messes, hos-
pital, club rooms, ra-
dio and teleprinter
room)
Catering spaces (gal- 28°C ~8°C 20°C ?; 16°C 50% ± 10% ~0.3 m/s
leys, pan tri es)
Control centres 28°C ~5°C 22°C ?;20°C 50% ± 10% ~O.4m/s
(bridge, machinery
control room)
phosphate levels in serum urine and sweat. Arbeitsfähigkeit und Gesundheit der Seeleute.
Bull. Inst. mar. Med. Gdansk 17, 4, 521-528 Bull. Inst. mar. Med. Gdansk 17, 3, 225-229
(1966). (1966).
11. Ejsmont, W., Cz.Bartnicki, R.Dubrawski et al.: 21. Kersten, E.: Zur Beurteilung der Klimaver-
The problem of acclimatization in the tropical träglichkeit des seefahrenden Personals
zone. Report VII. Dynamics of some physiolog- während der Tropenfahrt. Verk.-Med. 14, 1,
ical indexes in unadapted persons, under con- 29-36 (1967).
ditions of experimental humid heat. Bull. Inst. 22. Knapik, A: Microclimatic conditions on ves-
mar. Med. Gdansk 19, 112,97-106 (1968). sels. Bull. Inst. mar. Med. Gdailsk 17, 3,
12. Ejsmont, W., RDubrawski and CZ.Bartnicki: 155-156 (1966).
The problem of acclimatization in the tropical 23. Lehmann, G.: Die Arbeitsfähigkeit des
zone. Report VIII. Dynarnics of sodium and Menschen im tropischen Klima. Köln, Oplad-
potassium in urine of unadapted persons ex- en: Westdeutscher Verlag, 1968.
posed to the effect of experimental high tem- 24. Lewalski, B. and W. Ejsmont: The problem of
peratures. Bull. Inst. mar. Med. Gdansk 19, 112, acclimatization to hot-climate regions. 2. Uro-
107-115 (1968). pepsin contents in the urine from men staying
13. Frank, w.: Zum gegenwärtigen Stand der raum- in the chamber of high temperature. Bull. Inst.
klimatischen Forschung. Gesundheits-Ingeni- mar. Med. Gdailsk 15, 3/4, 193-198 (1964).
eur 90, 2, 40-46 (1969). 25. Marine Air Conditioning. Shipbuilding Inter-
14. Gigienicheskoe osnovanie nonnirovaniya mi- national (London) 14,7,2-12 (1971).
kroklimata v sudovykh pomeshcheniyakh. [Hy- 26. Noack, H. and G.Schulz: Klima am Arbeits-
giene guidelines for microclimatic standards for platz. In: Arbeitshygienische Nonnen und
ship rooms]. In: Trudy nauchno-isledovatelsko- MAK-Werte. Eds.: Häublein, H.G., G.Schulz
vo instituta gigieny vodnogo transporta. Eds.: et al. Berlin: Tribüne, 1974. pp.43-90.
E. P. Sergeev and G.1. Bondarev. Moscow 1968. 27. Reinders, H.: Mensch und Klima. Klima-
15. Goethe, H.: Klimabelastung in der Tropenfahrt. Klimaphysiologie-Klimatechnik. Düsseldorf:
In: Fragen der Schiffahrtsmedizin. Internatio- VDI-Verlag.1969.
nales Symposium, Heiligendamm 28-31 March 28. Sadovskaya, N. N.: Ventilatsiya i otoplenie
1963. Medizinischer Dienst des Verkehrswe- proisvodstvennykh i zhilykh pomeshchenii ry-
sens, Special issue 11, pp. 189-200. bopromyslovykh sudov. [Ventilation and heat-
16. Granz, w.: Untersuchungen über die Akklima- ing of working and living rooms on fishing ves-
tisation des Mitteleuropäers an natürliche tro- sels]. In: Gigiena truda i byta na promyslovykh
pische Klimabelastungen. Dissertation Univer- sudakh v zapolyarye. Ed.: Ya.E.Neishtadt and
sity of Leipzig 1980. L. Elpiner. Moscow: Pishchevaya promyshlen-
17. Granz, W. and K.Ziegler: Tropenkrankheiten. nost 1967. pp. 52-63.
Leipzig: Johann Ambrosius Barth. 1976. 29. Vorobev, AA: Gigienicheskoe obosnovanie
18. Häublein, H.G., G.Schulz et al.: Arbeitshygie- komfortnykh uslovii mikroklimata pomeshche-
nische Nonnen und MAK-Werte. Berlin: nii sudov suchetom akklimatisatsionnykh
Tribüne. 1974. ismenenii u moryakov v reise. [Hygienic rea-
19. Hygienevorschrift für den Bau von Seeschiffen. sons for microclimatic comfort of ship's rooms
Ed.: Medizinischer Dienst des Verkehrswesens in view of seafarers' acclimatization during voy-
der DDR. Rostock 1980. age]. Gig. i Sanit 6, 24-28 (1976).
20. Kersten, E.: Der Einfluß des Tropenklimas auf
2.5 Tbe Sbip's Li~bting
R.Herrmann
They have a very low efficacy level and a the luminance level over a range of 10 de-
large proportion of the available energy is cades.
emitted as heat. The light is produced by The adaptation of the eye is brought
heating an incandescent filament. The col- about by alterations in the size of the pupil,
our of the light is determined by the tem- by switching processes on the retina and by
perature of the incandescent filament. fluctuations in rod and cone sensitivity.
In the last few years luminescence and/ The time needed for these processes de-
or gas-discharge lights have found various pends upon the difference in luminance.
new areas of use. Their light is produced The adaptation period is considerably
through the electric discharge process in a longer in transition from light to dark than
gassy atmosphere. The efficacy of such a vice versa. A frequent need to re-adapt
light is substantially superior to that of an leads to signs of fatigue and impedes vi-
electric light-bulb. The colour of the light sion.
produced is determined by the type of gas
and the coating of the inner surface of the 2.5.5 Special Points Regarding
luminant. The use of semi-conductor light Illumination on Board Ship
sources can be considered far special pur-
poses. These are used almost exclusively Considerable problems arise in the fields
for the illumination of scales and for warn- of construction and evaluation of illumina-
ing lights. tion in shipping. Cramped, narrow and
windowless rooms are often to be found.
2.5.4 Light Receptors in the Eye The construction of lighting systems is
made difficult because of the marked
There are about 6-7 million cones on the changes in luminance between the rooms
retina which convey impressions of colour themselves and between the rooms and the
and colour brightness to the brain. A lu- open deck. The danger of accidents is in-
minance of10 cd/m2 is regarded as the out- creased because of the limited visibility in
side limit for the efficacy of the cones. The the passageways due to construction re-
maximum point of light sensitivity is quirements as weIl as the motion of the
reached at a wavelength of approximately ship in rough seas. Areas ofwork which are
550 nm, i. e. in the yellow-green range, and interconnected or adjacent present prob-
decreases accordingly at shorter or longer lems because of the markedly different vi-
wavelengths. Cones are to be found mainly sual requirements involved.
on the central part of the retina. Towards It is usual practice that the type of illumi-
the periphery their number decreases. nation system to be found in inner, win-
The approximately 100-125 million rods dowless rooms on a ship and its intensity
on the retina are needed for twilight vision are in accordance with the national stand-
(black/white vision). Pure rod vision be- ards in force. Examples of such rooms are:
gins at a luminance of 10- 3 cd/m2 or un- office rooms, control rooms, engine rooms,
der. The rods and cones interact in a tran- workshops, storerooms, provision stores
sition area found above this range, the rods and kitchens. The same applies to stair-
gradually taking over vision when lumi- ways and passageways.
nance decreases. The maximum wave- Table 1 shows the approximate values of
length at which the rods retain their sensi- the luminous dose, illuminance and the re-
tivity is to be found nearer the short quired efficacy level and contains some
wavelength range - at 507 nm. general comments on the illumination of
The capacity to adjust to modifying lu- different areas and types of room on ships.
minance is called adaptation. The human The illumination of the upper deck, car-
eye can adapt to a change of intensity of go holds and engine rooms along with the
106 2 The Seafarer's Environment
Visual demands; IIIumi- Incandes- Ruores- Recom- General remarks Points worthy of
examples of use nance (Ix) cent light- cent light- mended special attention
ing fixture ing fixture light
W/m2 W/m2 colour of
Iluorescent
Igt. fixtures
(L_Lp)a
General
orientation
Adjoining rooms 20-40 10 5 25 At low iIIumi- Pay attention to
Upperdeck (exception- nances the anti-dazzling de-
Cargo holds ally up to source(s) of light vices (nautical
60) must correspond tasks) on the free
to the type ofvisu- deck. Greater
al demand, so en- iIIuminances on
abling danger the upper deck,
areas to be recog- on fishery ves-
nised, thus pre- sels, must be tak-
venting accidents en into consider-
ation
Low visual
demands
Passageways 50-75 20 10 25 The sources of The differences
Stairways (exception- light must be so in brightness be-
Storerooms ally up to arranged as to cast tween inner and
Magazines 120) as few shadows as outer rooms must
Cold Stores possible and pro- be considered
Toilets duce no dazzling when planning
effects the lighting sys-
tem
Medium demands
Washrooms and 100-150 30 15 250r In cabins and sim- With mirror iIIu-
bathrooms 32 ilar rooms where mination one
Sanitary accom- work-places are to should avoid
modation be found, general dazzling caused
Cabins (general) illumination fixed by the light
at the work-places sources and the
themselves should glaring rellection
be used. IIIumina- in the mirror it-
tion at the work- self
places - at least
200 lux
Medium demands:
work illumination
(permanent
illumination)
Operations, 100-150 30 15 25 Principally gener-
switch and (exception- al illumination is
pumprooms ally up to called for. Avoid
Air-conditioning 250) reflection in the
centre instruments
Different
demands
(illumination in
living-quarters)
Messrooms 150-250 40 20 32 Mainlyaccentuat- Lighting regula-
Community ed illumination is tions must also
rooms desirable be followed in re-
Musicrooms gard to deco-
rative lights
2.5 The Ship's Lighting 107
Table 1.
Visual demands; IlIumi- Incandes- Fluores- Recom- General remarks Points worthy of
examples of use nance (Ix) cent light- cent light- mended special attention
ing fixture ing fixture light
W/m2 W/m2 colour of
fluorescent
Igt. fixtures
(L-Lp)a
Higher demands
(permanent
illumination)
Operations 150-250 40 20 25 If possible, gener- Light sources
rooms, e. g. engine al illumination. 11- must not dazzle.
and boiler rooms, (exception- lumination must Use a screen/ras-
control platforms ally up to be regular but not ter, lamina or op-
and stations, tech- 500) free of shadow. tical medium
nical and hobby Exception: con-
rooms trol platforms and
stations. Unfa-
vourable shadow
effects, e. g.
strongly cast
shadows, to be
avoided
Illumination for
specialpurposes
Hospital area 200 and over40 over 20 250r The standard of Siek rooms, for
Examination more 15 (19) the general iIIumi- example, must be
rooms (exception- nation must con- designed in ac-
allyupto form to the special cordance with
1000) illumination fix- the experiences
tures. made with hospi-
(OP lights or other tal illumination.
medical-technical When
apparatus) L-Lp is similar
to daylight, at
least 1 000 lux is
necessary
Illumination for
special purposes
(aggravating con-
ditions)
Bridges, chart 100-150 30 15 25 Generallighting is Variable work-
rooms (exception- necessary for place iIIumina-
ally up to maintenance and tion, adjustable
250) care. In any other to the dark-
cases special iIIu- adapted eye.
mination, e.g. the Screening off of
chart table (at iIIuminated
least 500 lux work-places (e.g.
adjustable to 0) the chart table)
with curtains
a (L-Lp): 25, universal white; 32, warm tone de-Iuxe; 15, daylight(6000 K); 19, daylight de-Iuxe (5000 K)
108 2 The Seafarer's Environment
ancillary engine plants can present espe- surface should therefore be kept as small as
cially great difficulties. Substantially irre- possible. The light must also be adjustable
gular illuminance levels sometimes appear from 500 to 0 Ix. The most favourable type
here, forcing the eye to re-adapt itself con- of chart-table illumination device is the
tinually. Adaptation from dark to light is trans illumination of the sea chart by means
accomplished relatively quickly, but for ad- of a luminant table. This method of illumi-
aptation from light to dark a longer period nation has the advantage of less illumin-
is necessary which is not always allowed or ance and fewer disturbances caused by sur-
foreseen. Therefore, with irregular lighting plus light. Instruments bearing signallights
the danger of accidents is increased. For or indicators must be illuminated with red
this reason regular lighting is desirable. light from 650 to 700 nm. The intensity
Shadow-free illumination impedes orienta- must be infinitely variable. In order to con-
tion and should therefore not be used. fine the illuminated section to as smaU an
Strong cast shadows should be avoided be- area as possible, the scales, switches and
cause adaptation problems arise within the other surfaces have to be darkly coloured.
area of the shadow. The problems of glare The pointers, figures, lines and lettering
and dazzle should also be taken into ac- should be recognizable in white light dur-
count. ing the day and at night be transiUuminat-
The transition areas between areas with ed in red.
artificial illumination and daylight (work- In every observation room, such as the
ing passageways to the open deck) must be captain's bridge, the engine control room
illuminated more brightly during the day and the harbour operation centre, one
and less brightly at night. should make sure that the lights for general
The transit area between the stairways illumination are placed so as to prevent re-
and working passageways to the captain's flections fonning on instruments or shining
bridge deserves particular attention. The surfaces, e. g. switches and windows at the
bridge crew is adapted to the dark at night. customary pi ace of operation.
Therefore when the entrance door is open- Ruf [6] expounds on the basic principles
ed no light should faU from the working of iUumination on board ships. The author
passageways onto the bridge. An adapta- mentions the different sources of light, giv-
tion zone must be created at the entrance to ing their application, the recommended ef-
the bridge, necessarily adjusted to the room ficacy and the type of light in table fonn.
illumination level of the bridge. Special regulations are noted, whereby the
General room iUumination on the cap- requisites of waterproofing and precau-
tain's bridge should contribute to keeping tionary measures against explosion are tak-
disturbances in the dark-adaptation of the en into account. Lastly the standard and
crew to aminimum. The intensity of illumi- quality of the lighting system in relation to
nation must be variable, i. e. red light at a the peculiarities of work on board are con-
wavelength of 650-700 nm or filtered white sidered. The articJe defines the physiologi-
light. By filtering the white light, the vital cal and psychological demands on the arti-
blue components are removed. ficial lighting on board. The illumination
To this day illumination of the chart system should guarantee faultless orienta-
table has been accomplished with white tion as weU as optimal operational method.
light because the coloured signs and sym- Attention should also be given to the main-
bols would otherwise become totally illegi- tenance of productivity levels and to the
ble. The illumination of the chart table well-being of the crew members both in
should be concentrated on the necessary work and recuperation periods.
chart section, the superfluous areas being Adrian [1] describes the problem of illu-
covered by sector screens. The iUuminated minating the ship's bridge. In regard to the
2.5 The Ship's Lighting 109
dark-adaptation capacity of the eye, a var- on very theoretical principles. This aspect
iety of unfavourably lit objects are to be of dark adaptation was examined experi-
found on board. Scales and low-voltage mentally by Landolt-Rings. He describes
(weak) lamps etc. situated on the ship's experiments in which white light was used,
bridge disturb considerably the dark adap- the proportion (quantity) of blue compo-
tation of the personnel embarking on nents having been first filtered out. The
watch duty during the night or twilight pe- brightness of the room illumination was
riods because of their luminous intensity 1-10 Ix and the target contrast 113%.
and colour composition. The author rec- The results show that the human opera-
ommends red light for all indicators and tor is able to identify objects at practical
lamps because the ability to adapt to dark- night illumination levels within some sec-
ness is then substantially increased. onds after having been exposed to bright-
Zorn [9] examines the ship's bridge from ness levels up to 3 Ix. Red light has no ad-
the viewpoint of ophthalmology and occu- vantage over filtered white light with re-
pational medicine. He describes the work- gard to the identification time. The conclu-
ing area on the bridge as an information sions of these experiments are: it is not
centre and quotes the eye as being the most necessary to install red light with all its dis-
crucial receptor of the total information in- advantages in rooms like a ship's bridge. A
put. He go es on to describe short- and "3-lx filtered white light" illumination will
long-sightedness, colour differentiating meet the requirements of shortest dark ad-
ability, stereoscopie vision (tunnel vision), aptation time for night vision. These exper-
dazzlement and dark adaptation. Recom- iments were conducted under marine con-
mended or approved measurements often ditions.
result in too high a luminance with unfa- Lamoureux [5] says in the Guide to Ship
vourable consequences for the dark adap- Sanitation that illumination requirements
tion of the eye. It becomes clear from these are dependent on their purpose and the
data that the dark adaptation of seafarers is work being conducted and therefore they
impaired because re-adaptation periods of can vary greatly. Information on suitable il-
10-15 min. are necessary by currently pre- lumination should be made available by
vailing luminances. the Health or Harbour Authorities - a re-
The article closes by making the follow- quirement that is plagued with difficulties
ing recommendations: painting of all co m- in practice.
ponents with a matt overcoat, avoidance of In the technical regulations published by
reflection through tilted windows, fitted the government of the Federal Republic of
doors to prevent infiltration of light, fa- Germany [8] with regard to the building
vourable posltlOning of light-source and equipping of accommodation facilities
screening devices, avoidance of continuous on seagoing vessels, the illuminances for
indication when only intermittent supervi- accommodation facilities on merchant
sion is called for, red light at a wave length ships are given in great detail.
of 660 nm and removal of the chart table An unpublished ergonomie checklist [2]
from the general bridge area. The author drawn up by a committee on ergonomics of
suggests further experiments to determine the Society of Naval Engineering gives var-
more favourable illumination possibili- ious directives concerning the problem of
ties. lighting in habitability areas as well as a
Schubert [7] deals with the problem of table (shown here as Table 1) with recom-
"red or white light on the ships' bridges". mended illuminances for each area on a
The author mentions previous claims in fa- ship. DIN 5035 parts 1 and 2 (3, 4) contain
vour of red light for the ship's bridge but valid guidelines for inner-room lighting
emphasises that this view is based only up- with artificial light, including terms and
110 2 The Seafarer's Environment
general demands as weil as critical values Richtwerte für Arbeitsstätten. DIN 5035. Part 2,
(approximate values) for work-places. Oct.1979.
5. Lamoureux, V. B.: Guide to ship sanitation. Gen-
eva: WHO 1967.
6. Ruf, J.: Grundzüge der Beleuchtung an Bord von
References Schiffen. Schiff und Hafen 15,3,260-268 (1963).
7. Schubert, E.: Red or white light on ship bridges?
1. Adrian, w.: Die Beleuchtung auf Schiffsbrücken. In: Proceedings of 5th Ship Control Systems
Zbl. Arbeitsmed. 20,4,101-110 (1970). Symposium, Annapolis, 1978. Ortung und Navi-
2. Ergonomische Checkliste. Ed.: Arbeitskreis Er- gation 2, 301-317 (1978).
gonomie der Schiffbautechnischen Gesellschaft. 8. Technische Regeln für Bau und Ausrüstung von
Hamburg 1974. Unterkunftsräumen auf Seeschiffen. Bundesar-
3. Innenraumbeleuchtung mit künstlichem Licht. beitsbl. Fachbeilage Arbeitsschutz 1, 33-40
Begriffe und allgemeine Anforderungen. DIN (1976).
5035. Part 1, Oct. 1979. 9. Zorn, E. : Die Schiffsbrücke aus ergophthalmolo-
4. Innenraumbeleuchtung mit künstlichem Licht. gischer Sicht. Schiff und Hafen 32, 9, 327 (1980).
2.6 Noise and Vibration Aboard Ship
J. W. E. Pettersen
be worn during continuous exposure to their younger colleagues, and are thus li-
noise from the ship's main propulsion ma- able to loneliness, withdrawal and non-
chinery and auxiliaries where noise levels participation in leisure activities.
in the range of 90-110 dB( A) may be ex- As a ship's engine room personnel may
pected. already have suffered some degree of
permanent threshold shift during their
Impulse Sound. The ear is more vulnerable training period in shore-based industries or
to damage from unheralded or unexpected during leisure activities, audiometric test-
impulse sounds, the extent depending on ing should be performed prior to entry into
sound peak level and pulse rise time and sea service. Regular audiometric screening
duration. The sudden release of safety tests during service would be useful in de-
valves or the taking of indicator readings tecting personnel susceptible to noise-in-
on diesel engines may expose engine crew duced hearing loss. Screening tests should
to such impulse sounds. also cover higher frequencies (e.g. 4000,
6000,8000 Hz).
Noise-Induced Hearing Impairment
The general effects of noise on hearing are 2.6.2.3 Other Effects
discussed in Henderson et al. [10]. The
A general survey on the behavioural and
reader should refer to ISO 1999 [29] with
physiological effects of noise has been car-
regard to risk of suffering a noise-induced
ried out by Lambert and Hafner [48] as
threshold shift sufficient to impair the un-
background material for consideration of
derstanding of everyday speech.
shipboard noise evaluation procedures.
Noise c1imates in ship engine rooms
The psycho-physical load on ship per-
have been reviewed by Bailey [4] and Acton
sonnel under various environmental loads
et al. [2], and the effect of noise on hearing
(incl. noise and vibration) is discussed by
among engine room personnel has been re-
Goethe et al. [16].
ported on by Quist-Hanssen [60], Harris
Requirements for sleep, solving prob-
[20], Nowak and Dahl [56], Kanda [42],
lems and speech communication in ship-
Grewe and Rodegra [18] and Szczepanski
board compartments are discussed by
et al. [67]. A comprehensive survey of the
Lambert [47].
noise conditions in sea-going and inland
waterway ships, focussing on the exposure
of ship personnel to noise, is found in Interference with Speech and Aural
Goethe et al. [14]. Communication Signals
The result of audiometric examinations The speech interference level (SIL) is gen-
is reported by Herrmann et al. [21]; they erally taken as the me an of levels of noise
show that of engine room personnel, 21 % in the octave bands with centre frequencies
suffered from significant threshold impair- of 500, 1000 and 2000 Hz (or the A-weight-
ment. In addition, 12% of deck crew mem- ed ambient sound level). In some working
bers showed hearing impairments (cause situations the signals are limited to some
unknown), and threshold impairments well-established commands often accom-
were diagnosed in 40% of radio officers. panied by specific hand signals. Klumpp
It may be noted that older ship person- and Webster [45] showed that for ship-
nel affected by presbycousis and possibly board noises (naval personnel) satisfactory
some noise-induced hearing loss in the signal comprehension occurred at a higher
upper frequency range may be handi- ambient A-weighted noise level than that
capped in following the conversation in the corresponding to the general SIL level.
dayrooms [about 65 dB(A) medium fre-
quency dominated noise] compared with
2.6 Noise and Vibration Aboard Ship 113
time Consultative Organization (IMCO) Table3. Limits for noise levels as specified in IM-
has more recently prepared a draft propos- CO-DEXXIII [23, p.20].
al for a code on noise levels in ships [IM- Work spaces dB(A)
CO-DEXXIII [23]]. The draft proposal Machinery spaces (continuously manned) 90
deals with: general scope and purpose, Machinery spaces (not continuously 110
measuring equipment, measurement con- manned)
ditions and procedures, noise exposure Machinery control rooms 75
Workshops 85
limits, noise exposure protection, acoustic
Non-specified work spaces 90
insulation between accommodation
spaces, ear protection and safeguards, in- Navigation spaces dB(A)
structions to crew and responsibilities, and Navigating bridge and chartrooms 65
format of noise survey reports; it also gives Listening post, including navigating 70
suggestions for methods of controlling bridge", wings and windows
noise exposure. Table 3 is reproduced from Radio rooms (with radio equipment ope- 60
rating but not producing audio signals)
this code. This code should be consulted Radar rooms 65
when finalized and ratified copies become
available. Accornrnodation and recreation spaces dB(A)
In addition IMO has issued Recommen- Cabins and hospitals 60
dations on Methods of Measuring Noise Mess rooms 65
Levels at Listening Posts (IMCO Resolu- Recreation rooms 65
tion A.343,IX), which recommends permis- Open recreation areas 75
sible noise levels at listening posts/bridge Service and office spaces dB(A)
wing:
Galleys, without food processing equip- 75
Maximum sound pressure levels in dB in ment operating
octave bands at centre frequencies of Serveries and pantries 75
250Hz - 68dB Offices 65
500Hz - 63dB
Norrnally unoccupied spaces dB(A)
as measured at three-quarters of normal
ship speed. Spaces not specified 90
Noise levels relating to various types of " Reference is made to resolution A.343(IX), which
ships are listed in Table 4, while Fig.1 illus- also applies
trates the ship types, and Table 5 outlines
suggestions for noise control measures to
meet IMO guidelines, taken from Brubakk
[6].
116 2 The Seafarer's Environment
Table4. Distribution of noise levels for various types of ship (Brubakk [6])
Positions Engine Control A- B- C- D- E- Wheel Radio Bridge Open
room room (main- house room wings recr,
Ship deck) deck area
groups
Table 5. Proposed measures to enable the various ship groups to meet the IMO code regarding noise (Bru-
bakk[6])
'";30
Noise reducing
-=,.,.u
measures -0
<l,)
S
....
<l,)
-0
§ ci.. '">-.
:::
<l,)
80..
Ship
"Oll 0I::
.~ .~ .,
;:l
0
...;
....
ob I:: ..; a'"u .... Oll
1;;
2
....
E ::..:CIS
<U
CI>
Ei i:l
u ~ <l,)
0 0 >-.J§
,g 'ö ~
'" uI:: c.8
<l,)
groups CIS-o I:: >-. u
u 0 0 >< -ci ..ci <l,)
CIS u ~
1l S ~ E ;:l
....
<l,) >< ~ f Oll
Oll
I::
.e
0
...
0..
~ S ~ ~
CIS
r;l
<l,)
<l,)
'e;;
r;l ..ci
:E <l,)
I::
.~ 's. ..0
..;
CIS 0
o..u ;3 'e;; CIS '"
'0 CIS '"
'" '0 0
S
CIS
0
CI>
'"CIS
><
~ Z
..0
r;:.
<l,)
U
<l,)
rJl CIS ~ @ Z @ ~ ~ Cl <t: @
e:
remotely from main sound sources.
4. Noise prediction: Estimation of the ex-
Am
plan (path of noise propagation). Com-
parison of results with design objectives.
5. Noise control measures: Evaluation of
es ;''''0' additional noise control measures neces-
sary to reach the specified requirements
L '---------~7 Group F in relation to noise reduction at the
source, in the transmission path and at
Fig.1. Ship groups (Brubakk [6]) the occupied spaces. Consideration must
be given to the weight, size and cost and
ease of maintenance of acoustic devices
2.6.4 Noise Control in Ships applied to shipboard conditions.
6. Safety and reliability: Noise-reducing
2.6.4.1 Acoustic Planning devices must comply with general re-
quirements regarding fire resistance,
The overall objective of the acoustic plan- strength/ fatigue, moisture etc. as pre-
ning in ships should be to meet the specifi- scribed by national/international mari-
ed noise level requirements by means of time authorities and classification socie-
balanced, cost-effective design, due consid- ties.
eration being given to such factors as safe-
ty, habitability and comfort. 2.6.4.2 Ship Noise Sources
Preliminary and contract level consider- and Transmission Path
ation on noise control in ship design has Abrief outline is given below of important
been outlined by Maniar and Daidola [51], shipboard noise sources and major paths
while the present state-of-the-art in ship of propagation; noise control measures are
noise control is surveyed by Noonan and covered in the following section.
Feldman [55] and ship trial noise measure-
ments and evaluation are discussed by Pet- Sourees. The major noise sources on a ship
tersen [58]. Experiences with ship noise are the propeller, the main propulsion die-
control are reported by Wragge [73]. sel engine and auxiliary generating sets.
The procedure for a systematic analysis Hydraulic systems often need particular at-
of relevant factors involved in deriving a tention to noise reduction measures. Con-
118 2 The Seafarer's Environment
tributory sources at the navigating bridge The transfer of acoustic energy into the
and wheelhouse are diesel exhaust noise ship's structure depends upon the response
and navigating equipment noise, while in characteristics of the plate elements of the
deck recreation areas engine and cargo afterbody structure. The energy transmit-
room air intake and outlet openings are ted to the accommodation area could
probable offenders. therefore be reduced by increasing the hull
plate impedance (Nilsson et al. [54]). An
Transmission. The main path of trans- empirical formula for structure-borne
mission to the accommodation quarters, noise from the propeller has been develop-
offices and living spaces is in the form of ed (Ward and Hoyland [70]) as a general
structural sonic vibration - structure-borne guide for noise estimation.
noise. The casing can be a source of radia-
tion of air-borne noise into nearby cabins. Machinery. Empirical relationships for es-
Hydraulic noise may be transmitted timating air-borne and structure-borne
through ducting system and supports, be- noise resulting from diesel engines and
ing radiated by supporting bulkheads. gear boxes have been developed (Ward
Noise from air conditioning in the accom- and Hoyland [70]).
modation quarters is primarily conducted Reduction of structure-borne noise from
through the ventilation piping, while exces- a slow-speed pro pulsion diesel engine by
sive flow-induced noise may be generated means of elastic support meets with special
and radiated at the ventilation outlet grille. problems of engine stability in the seaway
owing to the difficulty in achieving a satis-
2.6.4.3 Elements of Noise Control in Ships factory mounting for machinery speeds of
below, say, 350 rpm.
General principles of noise reduction are
Structure-borne noise from auxiliary en-
described in standard reference books.
gin es/generating sets may be of significant
Noise control measures to be adopted
importance for the noise levels aboard
aboard ship must, however, be evaluated in
ship. At the general rotational speed of
terms of the specific conditions applying to
generator sets, elastic mounting is quite
ship service environment.
feasible, although special precautions
Handbooks dealing directly with noise
should be taken to ensure satisfactory oper-
control in ships are available, e.g. [1]; [5];
ations under seaway conditions (pettersen
[19]; Kluikin [44], Pettersen and Storm
and Storm (Eds.) [59]).
(Eds.) [59];
Elastic mounting has today become a
Reduction of Sound Sources
routine measure. The noise-reducing effi-
ciency also depends upon the mass/ stiff-
Propeller. Propeller cavitation leads to gen- ness distribution of the seating/founda-
eration of high noise levels into the ship. tion. Resiliently mounted engines on plat-
Cavitation is caused by uneven wake distri- forms te nd to transmit high er structure-
bution over the propeller plane, particu- borne noise levels than those placed on
lady the high wake peak behind the stern ship's double bottoms.
post. The most important noise reducing
measures would be (a) designing the after- Exhaust Systems. Exhaust systems should
body for minimal wake variations at the be fitted with suitable silencers. Reduction
propeller plane and (b) optimal design of of structure-borne noise transmitted from
the propeller geometry for the given wake exhaust piping is achieved by flexible
field, by appropriate choice of main pa- mounting supported by adequately stif-
rameters (rpm, diameter) to reduce propel- fened brackets.
ler tip speed.
2.6 Noise and Vibration Aboard Ship 119
and elastically supported at the steel bulk- by Goethe et a1. [15], dealing with vibration
head to prevent structure-borne noise measurements related to ISO 2631 [31]. Ex-
transmission. Acoustic absorption material posure of crew to disturbing vibration in
is fitted in the empty space to dampen work environment, leisure activities and
acoustic standing waves. The suspended periods of relaxation (sleep) is discussed.
ceiling is mounted in a similar mann er.
The facing of ceiling and walls may be 2.6.5.1 Nomenclature
fitted with acoustic absorption material to For sinusoidal vibration the following
absorb noise generated in the room and to quantities apply:
improve aural communication (adjusted - Vibration displacement, x = Asinoot,
reverberation time). numerical amplitude = A
Instead of a floating accommodation - Vibration velocity, dxl dt = ooAcosoot,
system, visco-elastic damping layers numerical amplitude = ooA
(Asztely [3]; Burroughs et a1. [7]) may be - Vibration acceleration,
used to reduce the transmission of struc- d2xl dt2 = - oo 2Asinoot,
ture-borne sound in the steel structure. numerical amplitude = 00 2A
The ventilation noise produced by the - Angular frequency, 00 = 211:f in radis
air-conditioning system often makes a no-
ticeable contribution to the noise in cabins.
_ rms magnitude = [-.L
211:0
Yx 2 dt] 112
The system should be fitted with silencers - Crest factor = ratio peak amplitude to
and absorption lining in the ducting. The rms value
air velo city at the outlets into the cabins - Mode of vibration: characteristic vibra-
should be kept low, and the outlet grilles tory pattern related to number of nodes
should be designed for low noise genera- - Node: positions ofvibratory rest
tion. - Natural frequency: a frequency of free
The fan room containing the air-condi- vibration
tioning plant should be acoustically treat- - Resonance: state of coincidence be-
ed, and the plant itself and the air-flow tween periodicity of excitation force and
ducting should be elastically supported. system natural frequency
- Critical speed: a speed (of machine,
Bridge/Deck Areas. A major component shafting ete.) at whieh resonanee oecurs
of noise from diesel propulsion at the For further terminology see ISO 2041 [30].
bridge may be the exhaust noise. To main-
tain ease of listening, efficient silencers 2.6.5.2 Whole-Body Vibration Effects
should be installed. Low frequency range Exposure of the human body to mechani-
attenuation is also desirable. Other sources cal vibration results in relative displace-
of noise are air intakes and outlets from en- ment of adjacent tissue in various parts of
gi ne rooms fans and cargo room fans. The the body. For small amplitudes these rela-
ducting should be fitted with acoustic ab- tive displacements may not be noticeable,
sorption lining and special louvres at the but at higher amplitudes they can stimulate
air inlets and outlets. The air velocity a variety of receptor organs, interfere with
should be kept as low as possible. human perceptual and motor performance
and cause discomfort, pain or, in extreme
2.6.5 Appraisal of Effects cases, injury.
of Exposure to Vibration Parameters affecting the evaluation of
human response to vibration are:
A comprehensive study of the load im- 1. Direction of applied vibratory motion
posed on the ship's personnel by exposure with respect to the co ordination of the
to vibration aboard ship has been prepared human body;
2.6 Noise and Vibration Aboard Ship 121
2. Waveform of the vibratory input to the quency response to ISO 2631, addendum
body; DADI2 [32].
3. Application of simultaneous multidirec-
tional vibration; 2.6.5.3 Evaluation of Human Whole-Body
4. Biodynamic response characteristics of Vibration
the body; For general-purpose evaluation, reference
5. Condition ofthe subject (physiological); is made to ISO 2631 [31], which should be
6. Psychological effects (motivation, habi- consulted for further study with respect to
tuation); scope, field of application, method of mea-
7. The activity ofthe individual; surement and evaluation procedures. Rec-
8. Presence of additional environmental tilinear vibration transmitted to man
factors. should be measured in the appropriate
In dealing with shipboard vibration we are axis at the point of application to the
primarily concerned with two types of ex- human body. The frequency range covers
posure to vibration: 1-80 Hz.
1. Global vibration transmitted to the The standard (i. e. ISO 2631) gives guid-
body through the feet of a standing person, ance as to the evaluation of exposure to
through the buttocks of a sitting person, or various levels and durations of vibration.
through the supporting area of a reclining The evaluation concepts are:
person. This type of exposure is termed 1.0bjective physicallphysiological re-
"whole-body vibration ". It covers the fre- sponse (hazard) term: "tolerance limit".
quency range of 1-80 Hz. 2. Efficiency of performing work (inter-
A proposal for evaluation of shipboard ference) term: "decreased projiciency
vibration has been put forward by Kanaza- boundary".
wa [41]. A collection of Japanese shipboard 3. Subjective (psycho-physiological) re-
vibration data evaluated from the point of sponse (annoyance) term: "reduced com-
view of habitability has been submitted to fort boundary".
ISO/SC4 by the Japanese delegate [8]. Vi- The standard is of a general nature, specific
bration load on ship personnel is discussed situations being covered by addenda.
by Zaborski and Szczepanski [74] and Swi- One such addendum to ISO 2631 is
taiski [66], while selection of measuring po- in preparation as a draft proposal, ISO/
sitions for vibration in occupied spaces is TC108/SC4-N116 [33], concerned with
suggested by Wieg [72]. evaluating exposure of crew to vibration.
2. High displacement-Iow frequency vi- This addendum deals specifically with the
bration applied as wholebody vibration vibratory input to the human body, so that
and related to motion sickness (kinetosis) information can be gathered for direct
and work proficiency effects. It covers the comparison purposes using the methods
frequency range 0.1-1 Hz. outlined in the parent document, ISO 2631
Measurements of ship motion effects [31].
have been carried out by Goto [17] on five The rating curve for vibration in occup-
training voyages for apprentices, using a ied spaces in this draft proposal is derived
motion sickness index (MSI): from the lower envolute of combining the
Grade I Slightly uncomfortable. requisite curves for vertical and horizontal
Grade 11 Rather uncomfortable, feeling of vibration exposure from the parent docu-
nausea, difficulty in continuing ment ISO 2631. This addendum [33] is pres-
ordinary tasks. ently under revision, and it may be altered
Grade 111 Very uncomfortable, vomiting, so that the rating procedure follows the
completely spiritless. scale for evaluation of whole-body vibra-
The measurements are related in fre- tion described in ISO 2631.
122 2 The Seafarer's Environment
60 100 6000
There are draft international codes for
I I ! J d
measurement and reporting of hull girder 10 100
vibration (ISO DP4867 [34] and local vibra- Frequency in Hz
tion (ISO DP 4868 [35]). These codes apply
to general vibration surveys, the main ob- Fig.2. Guidance for the overall evaluation of verti·
ject being to verify the overall vibration re- cal and horizontal vibration in merchant ships (sim-
plified). Quantities expressed in maximum repeti-
sponse of the huH girder, superstructure tive magnitude (peak value) (ISO DP6954 [36])
and local spaces as weH as selected posi-
tions for indication ofvibratory force trans-
mission. The test and ship operational con-
ditions are outlined, and a format of primarily expressed in maximum repetitive
reporting is given. magnitude (peak value). Through accumu-
Special measurements, such as detailing lated (semantic) data, cognizance ofthe hu-
exposure of personnel to whole-body vi- man reaction to shipboard vibration is in-
bration at all occupied areas, would require corporated into ISO DP6954, the evalua-
a comprehensive survey. tion curves from which are reproduced in
The codes do not deal with "trouble- Fig.2, the measurements being taken at
shooting" aimed at detecting causes and deck structure. If a direct measurement of
providing a basis for particular corrective whole-body vibration is desired, this would,
measures - this would require more exten- for a sitting person for instance, entail in-
sive investigations. Solumsmoen [64] and terposing a suitable measuring device be-
Ojak [57] describe service shipboard vibra- tween the buttocks and the seat cushion as
tion problems. outlined in ISO 2631 [31], and the adden-
ISO/TC10S/SC2 has prepared a draft dum to it [33], which is currently being
proposal: ISO DP6954 - Overall Evalua- revised.
tion 0/ Shipboard Vibration in Merchant The rating curves in ISO DP6954 are
Ships [36]. This code is based on interna- based on information submitted to ISOI
tionally collected data from shipboard con- TC108/SC4-N116 [33] for sinusoidal vibra-
ditions, the measurements being taken at tion exposure, together with data sub mit-
relevant positions in the ship structure and ted from other participant countries.
2.6 Noise and Vibration Aboard Ship 123
~ 1.0
E from the latter is included. For shipboard
.!: 0.5
;;; vibration, which may be characterized as
::E:
~
narrow-band random in nature, crest fac-
c:: 0.1 tors (CF) of 1.6-3 are shown. Typical crest
.~
"§ 0.05
QI
factors may be in the order of 2.0-2.5.
Qj
U
From this diagram it follows that evalua-
U
« -- 51eeping quorl./ ISO 2631 Md.3
- -- Olher occup 01 tion using DP6954 tends to be on the con-
0.01
--- OP 6954 CF: 1.6 servative side. With the present state-of-
0.005
---- DP 6954 CF : 3.0 the-art in shipbuilding, good practice
would be to aim in the design for the lower
45 8 16 31.5 63 80 curve while applying corrective measures if
Frequency in Hz vibration is found to exceed significantly
the upper curve during trial trips.
Fig_ 3_ Comparison between maximum repetitive
values, including effect of crest factor (ISO DP6954
[36]) and rms value (ISO 2631 draft proposal ad-
dendum 3; working paper ISO/ TC108/ SC4-N116 2.6.7 Vibration Control in Ships
[33]) From ISO DP6954 [36].
2.6.7.1 Design Planning
The overall objectives of vibration control
ISO DP6954 describes three categories, in ships are to meet the requirements re-
viz. a lower zone where adverse comments garding structural strength and safety and
are not probable, a transition zone at which to ensure a satisfactory level of exposure of
unfounded complaints may arise and an the ship's personnel to vibration.
upper zone at which adverse comments are Preliminary contract considerations in
probable. Vibration levels exceeding the ship design with regard to vibration are dis-
upper curve are to some extent met with in cussed by Maniar and Daidola [51], while
ship accommodation areas. the present state-of-the-art in ship vibration
The rating curves of ISO DP6954 may be control is outlined by Noonan and Feld-
applied to shipboard vibration in both ver- man [55]. Design stage measures to prevent
tical and horizontal directions. This differs harmful vibration are outlined by Leenaars
from the separate evaluation of vertical and Forbes [49] and Johannessen and
and horizontal whole-body vibration as Skaar [39], while vibration measurement
outlined in ISO 2631. This difference in du ring a trial trip is discussed by Pettersen
evaluation may be due to some additional [58] and vibration problems are reported
effects in the complaints regarding expo- upon by Ojak [57].
sure to horizontal vibration, e. g.: Vibration in ships is conveniently cate-
1. Muscle tension due to relative motion of gorized as (Noonan and Feldman, [55]):
work surfaces rather than whole-body 1. Hull girder vibration
vibration 2. Vibration in major substructures
2. Discomfort induced by additional rotary 3. Local vibration (deck areas, bulkheads,
motion accommodation areas)
3. Nuisance increased by vibration 'beat- 4. Propeller, machinery and shafting vibra-
ing' effects tion
4. Psychological effects (disturbance of lei- 5. Vibration in components, control panels
sure activities) and instrument on their supports
124 2 The Seafarer's Environment
These items are all related to the dynam- Transmission Path. The excitation forces
ic structural behaviour and safety of the are transmitted from the major sources into
ship and to the safety and operational per- the structure, setting the hull girder and
formance of machinery and equipment. major substructures (such as the deckhouse
The first three items are of particular con- and engine room) into "global" mo des of
cern with regard to the exposure of person- vibration. The global vibratory motion acts
nel to vibration. as input to local vibratory systems, deck
The procedure for analysis of ship dy- areas, bulkheads and supported equip-
namic response follows the evaluation of: ment. Owing to greater local flexibility and
1. Design objective: Clarify the require- to mass distribution effects, local elements
ments regarding ship and machinery usually experience an increase in vibration
performance and special requirements level, in some cases magnified by local res-
regarding levels of vibration exposure in onance effects. The major aim ofthe design
relevant areas of occupation. is therefore to arrive at a satisfactory level
2. Vibration sources: Evaluate strength of of vibration in the hull girder and major
ship's major vibration sourees, propeller substructures, as this would indicate ade-
and machinery. quacy in design as regards propeller source
3. Transmission: Identify major paths of strength and dynamic behaviour of the
transmission to relevant structural con- ship as a whole. Additional refinements to
figurations. ensure low-Ievel vibration in local elements
4. Vibration prediction: Estimate the dy- can then more readily be incorporated in
namic response of major structural ele- the structure.
ments.
5. Vibration evaluation: Review expected 2.6.7.3 Elements of Vibration Control
levels of vibration to evaluate possible Generally the evaluation of source strength
correction to attain a level of vibration and vibration response characteristics of a
satisfactory from the point ofview of(a) ship is comprehensive, requiring computer-
the ship's safety and operational require- ized prediction programs. Reviews based
ments and (b) exposure of personnel to on accumulated data and experience, sup-
vibration. ported by preliminary estimates, may be
applied at the early, conceptual stage.
2.6.7.2 Sources ofVibration The logistics of ship vibration control are
and Transmission Path outlined briefly below:
Sources. The propeller is the major source
of vibration in ships. Some 90% of com- Propeller. The excitation from the propel-
plaints about vibration in the accommoda- ler is propagated as (a) propeller-induced
tion spaces arise from propeller-induced hull surface forces (pressure fluctuations)
local vibration (Solumsmoen, [64]). Sec- and (b) shaft-induced forces, transmitted to
ondary vibration effects, such as "rattling" the hull through stern tube bearing and
and random movements of supported thrust bearing seating (Vorus [69]).
items, are frequent sources of annoyance to The optimal design of propellers for low
the crew. Free, unbalanced forces and mo- excitation purposes requires testing of the
ments in main pro pulsion diesel engines ship aft-body lines (wakefield) in a model
and in auxiliaries are potential sources of tank and cavitation testing of the propeller
excitation of low-noded hull girder reso- and/or calculations to arrive at an estimate
nant vibration and/or vibration in plat- of the expected range of propeller forces
forms and other local structures. (Lindgren and Johnsson [50]; Rutherford
[61]). The aim would be to optimize the
propeller/aft end conditions for the extent
2.6 Noise and Vibration Aboard Ship 125
son, RP.Hamernik, D.S.Dosanjh et al. New 25. Infrasound and low frequency vibration. Ed.:
York: Raven 1976. W Tempest London: Academic 1976.
11. Falensky, G.: Elastisch gelagerte Deckshäuser 26. ISO gives guidance on symbols for quantities
auf Seeschiffen. Schiff und Hafen 25, 7 (1973). and units. 1. acoust. Soc. Amer. 67,1,360 (1980).
12. George, A. W: Shipboard airborne noise con- 27. ISO R266 Normal Equal-loudness Contours
tro!. Ed.: SNAME. Philadelphia section 1980. for Pure Tones and Normal Threshold of Hear-
13. Godin, L. S.: Subjective ratings as a criterion in ing under Free Field Listening Conditions.
developing hygienic standards of noise and Geneva 1961.
vibration on shipboard. Bull. Inst. mar. Med. 28. ISO 1996 Assessment of Noise with Respect to
Gdailsk 25, 2/3/4, 372-374 (1974). Community Response. Geneva 1971.
14. Goethe, H., E.-G. Schmidt, E. Zorn et a!.: 29. ISO 1999 Acoustics - Assessment of Occupa-
Lärmbelastung auf See- und Binnenschiffen, tional Noise Exposure for Hearing Conserva-
Untersuchungen zur effektiven Lärmbelastung tion Purposes. Geneva 1975.
der Besatzungen. Ed.: Bundesanstalt für Ar- 30. ISO 2041 Vibration and Shock - Vocabulary.
beitsschutz und Unfallforschung, Dortmund. Geneva 1975.
Bremerhaven: Wirtschaftsverlag NW 1979 31. IS02631.GuidefortheEvaluationofHumanEx-
(Forschungsbericht 201). posure to Whole-body Vibration. Geneva 1978.
15. Goethe, H., E.-G. Schmidt, H.-D. Bode et a!.: 32. ISO 2631, draft addendum ISO 2631/DAD2.
Schwingungen an Bord von Seeschiffen. Ed.: Evaluation of Human Exposure to Whole-body
Bundesanstalt für Arbeitsschutz und Unfallfor- Vibration in the Frequency Range 0.1 to 1.0 Hz.
schung, Dortmund. Bremerhaven: Wirtschafts- Geneva 1980.
verlag NW 1981. (Forschungsbericht 262) 33. ISO 2631, draft proposal addendum 3; working
16. Goethe, H., E.Zorn, RHerrmann et al.: Die paper ISO/TC108/SC4-N116. Guide for the
psycho-physische Belastung des Personals mo- Evaluation of Crew Exposure to Vibration on
derner Seeschiffe als aktuelles Problem der Board Seagoing Ships. Geneva 1981.
Schiffahrtsmedizin. Zb!. Bakt., I. Abt. Orig. B. 34. ISO DP4867 (draft) Code forthe Measurement
166,1,1-36 (1978). and Reporting on Shipboard Vibration Data.
17. Goto, D.: Evaluation of ship's vertical motion Geneva 1980.
from point of view of motion sickness. Paper at 35. ISO DP4868 (draft) Code for the Measurement
U.K.Informal Group on Human Response to and Reporting of Shipboard Local Vibration
Vibration. Meeting of Herriot-Watt University, Data. Geneva 1980.
Edinburgh 1981. 36. ISO DP6954 (draft) Guidelines for the Overall
18. Grewe, H. E. and H. Rodegra: Untersuchungen Evaluation of Vibration in Merchant Ships.
über die Lärmschwerhörigkeit des Maschinen- Geneva 1980.
personals. Hansa 112, 21 (1975). 37. Janssen, J. H.: Hypothesis on simultaneous
19. Handbook for shipboard airborne noise con- noise-and-vibration annoyance rating in ship-
tro!. Ed.: U.S. Coast Guard Washington 1974. board accommodation. Noise Control En-
(Tech. Pub!. 073-100) gineering 16, p.145 (1981).
20. Harris, J. D.: Hearing-loss trend curves and the 38. Janssen, J. H. and J. Buiten: An acoustical de-
damage-risk criterion in diesel-engine-room sign on naval architecture. Proc. Inter-Noise 73
personne!. J. Acoust. Soc. Amer. 37, 3 (1965). (1973).
21. Herrmann, R, H.Goethe, E.-G.Schmidt et a!.: 39. Johannessen, H. and K. T. Skaar: Guidelines for
The noise load of crew members on board sea- prevention of excessive ship vibration. Trans.
going and inland waterway vessels of the Fed- SNAME 88, p.319 (1980).
eral German Republic (Latest Results). In: VIII 40. Johnson,A.J. and W McClimont: Machineryin-
International symposium on marine medicine - duced vibration. Trans I. M. E. 75,4,121 (1963).
Abstracts - 24-280ctober 1978. Varna 1978. 41. Kanazawa, T.: A proposal for the vibration lim-
pp. 249-250. its of ships. Wissenschaft!. Z. Univ. Rostock 10,
22. Human factors in the design and operation of 2/3,313-321 (1961).
ships. Proceedings of the First International 42. Kanda, H.: Present state of engine-room noise
Conference on Human Factors in the Design and crew's hearing impairment. Paper. The Ma-
and Operation of Ships. Ed.: D. Anderson, rine Engineering Society in Japan, Tokyo,
H.Istance and J. Spencer. Stockholm : Garmat 12-15 November 1973.
Service 1978. 43. Kihlman, T. and 1. Plunt: Prediction of noise
23.IMCO-DEXXIII (draft only). Code on Noise levels in ships. In: Proceedings of the Interna-
Levels in Ships, Intergovernmental Maritime tional Symposium on Shipboard Acoustics.
Consultative Organization (IMCO), Sub-com- Amsterdam: Elsvier 1973.
mittee on Ship Design. London, 12 Dec. 1980. 44. Kluikin, I. I.: Control of noise and sonic vibra-
24. IMCO-DEXIX/WP7 agenda item 9. Noise tion in ships. Trans!. from the Russian lang. by
Levels in Ships (ad hoc group). London 1978. the U. S. Dept. of Commerce, Office of Techni-
2.6 Noise and Vibration Aboard Ship 127
cal Services, Joint Pub\. Res. Servo Washington 60. Quist-Hanssen, S.: Noise induced hearing loss
1963. amongst engine-room personneIon board Nor-
45. Klumpp, R. G. and J. C. Webster: Physical mea- wegian Merchant ships. Ed.: Det norske Veri-
surements of equally speech-interfering navy tas. Oslo 1964. (DnV Publication 44)
noises. 1. Acoust. Soc. Am. 35, 1328-1338 61. Rutherford, R.: Mt end shaping to limit vibra-
(1963). tion. Paper. NEC lnst. Eng. and Shpbldrs. Gen-
46. Lambert, D. R.: Airborne noise levels in mer- eral meeting, NewcastIe, 26 March 1979.
chant ships. Ed.: Naval Ocean System Center. 62. Schmidt, D. R.: Noise levels and crew noise ex-
San Diego 1979. (NOSC-TD 243) posure aboard V.S. merchant vessels. Ed.: Na-
47. Lambert, D. R.: Requirements for sleep, solving val Ocean System Center. San Diego, 1979.
problems and speech communication in ship- (N OSC-TR 405)
board compartments. Ed.: Naval Ocean System 63. Skaar, K. T. and A. E. Rrestad: The relative im-
Center. San Diego 1980. (NOSC-TR 559) portance of ship vibration excitation forces.
48. Lambert, D. R. and ES. Hafner: Behavioral RINA Symposium. London 1980.
and physiological effects of noise on people. 64. Solumsmoen, O. H.: Ship vibration. Experience
Ed.: Naval Ocean System Center. San Diego from service measurements. Ed.: Det norske
1979. (NOSC-TD 267) Veritas. Oslo 1977. (DnV Publication 96)
49. Leenaars, C. E.J. and P. E. Forbes: An approach 65. Stiansen, S.G.: Propeller and wave induced
to vibration problems at the design stage. RINA hull structure vibrations. In: Ship Vibration
Symposium. London 1980. Symposium. Arlington, 16-17 Oct. 1978. Ed.:
50. Lindgren, H. and C.A.Johnsson: On the influ- The Society of Naval Architects and Marine
ence of cavitation on propeller-excited vibrato- Engineers, New York.
ry forces and some means of reducing its ef- 66. Switaiski, B.: Belastung des Menschen durch
fects. Internat. Symposium, PRADS, SNAJ. Schiffsvibrationen. Schiff und Hafen 31, 11,
Tokyo 1977. p.343. 991-998 (1979).
51. Maniar, N. M. and J. C. Daidola: The consider- 67. Szczepanski, c., L. Zaborski and M. Taniewski:
ations ofvibrations and noise at the preliminary Acoustic and vibrational media aboard ship
and contract levels of ship design. In: Ship Vi- type B-516 and the state of hearing in the crew.
bration Symposium, Arlington, 16-17 Oct. Bull. Inst. mar. trop. Med. Gdynia 31, 3/4,
1978. Ed.: The Society of Naval Architects and 165-175 (1980).
Marine Engineers, New York. 68. VoJcy, G. G.: Interaction and compatibility be-
52. Mano, M., Y.Ochi and K. Fuji: Prevention and tween machinery and hull from a static and vi-
remedy of ship vibration. IHI Rev. 10, 10 bratory point of view. In: Ship Vibration Sym-
(1975). posium. Arlington, 16-170ct. 1978. Ed.: The
53. Nilsson, A. c.: Noise prediction and prevention Society of Naval Architects and Marine En-
in ships. In: Ship Vibration Symposium, Arling- gineers, New York.
ton, 16-17 Oct. 1978. Ed.: The Society of Naval 69. Vorus, WS.: CaJculation of propeller-induced
Architects and Marine Engineers, New York. vibratory hull forces, force distribution, and
54. Nilsson, A. c., B. Persson and N. P. Tyvand: press ures, free surface effects. J. Ship. Res. 20,
Propeller induced noise in ships. Paper. 2,107 (1976).
SNAME Propeller 81-Symposium. Virginia 70. Ward, G. and A. Hoyland: Ship design and
Beach 1981. noise levels. Paper. Annual Meeting, March
55. Noonan, E. F. and S. Feldman: State of the art 1979. NEC Inst. Engrs. and Shpbldrs.
for shipboard vibration and noise contro\. In: 71. Ward, G. and T. Willshare: Propeller-excited vi-
Ship Vibration Symposium, Arlington, 170ct. bration with particular reference to full scale
1978. Ed.: The Society of Naval Architects and measurements. Paper No.4, RINA, Spring
Marine Engineers, New York. meeting 1975.
56. Nowak, R. and D.Dahl: Die Lärmschwerhörig- 72. Wieg, P.: Orientierende Meßpunkte zur
keit des Schiffsmaschinenpersonals. Z. ges. Einschätzung des Schwingungsniveaus der
Hyg, 17,7,488-492 (1971). Aufenthaltsorte von Besatzungen auf Hoch-
57. Ojak, W: Vibration problems on modem ships seeschiffen. Verk.-Med. 22, 1, 11-17 (1975).
due to propeller excitations. 4th Italian-Polish 73. Wragge, F.: Erfahrungen bei der Lärmbekämp-
Seminar on Ship Structures and Hydrodynam- fung auf Seeschiffen. Hansa 1J3, 2, 142-147
ics. Genoa, June 1979. (1976).
58. Pettersen, J. W E.: On the philosophy of con- 74. Zaborski, L. and C. Szczepanski: A hygienic
ducting and evaluating sea trials vibration and analysis of mechanical vibrations in a voyage
noise measurements. Ship Trials Symposium, aboard the semicontainer ship M/S "Kalinow-
Naval Architects Association. Zagreb 1980. ski". Bull. Inst. mar. trop. Med. Gdynia 27, 3/4,
59. Pettersen, J. W E. and J. EStorm (Eds.): Hand- 279-288 (1976).
book on noise control in ships. Oslo: Selvig 1975.
2.7 The Ship's Water Supply
Z.Sobol
2.7.1 Introduction call at ports and since their stay at sea has
been considerably reduced due to their in-
Technological progress in shipbuilding has creasing speeds (Elpiner [1]; Sobol and
solved the quantitative problems concern- Wasilewska [10]; Sobol [11]). Another prob-
ing a ship's fresh water supply, but the lem is that distilling plants often cannot be
problem of ensuring that fresh water meets used because of short stays in the areas
modem sanitary standards remains (Sobol where sea water is fit for distillation. On the
and Szumilas [8]; Sobol and Elpiner [9]; other hand, on specialised ships staying at
Sobol and Wasilewska [10]; Sobol [11]). To sea for a prolonged period of time (fishing,
obtain water meeting the standards, it is ne- hydrographie and research vessels, or even
cessary to be conversant not only with the tramps), distilling plants may be the only
problems of the ship's water supply, but al- source of unlimited fresh water.
so, and primarily, with the structure and The operation of seawater distilling
operation of the ship's water system. Little plants results in additional responsibilities
attention is paid to the problem of water for the crew, i. e. checking the technical
systems since it is believed to have no direct condition of distilling and purification
connection with navigational safety. The equipment as weIl as turning off the desali-
crew keeps changing, and it is difficult for nation plants during the ship's stay in high-
them to become fully acquainted with the ly polluted zones. Generally, waters up to
water system. Thus the ship's doctor or of- 12 miles off the co ast, areas of mass out-
ficer charged with medical care on board is flow of oil products and fisheries with large
responsible for instructing the crew on the numbers of fish processing vessels are reck-
correct use of the water system and for su- oned to be polluted zones.
pervising its operation (Sobol [11]; Zorn
[12]). 2.7.3 Quantitative Problems with
the Ship's Water
2.7.2 Sources of the Ship's
Fresh Water Water consumption on a ship depends on a
number of factors, i. e. the possibility of
Traditional ships may receive fresh water pro vi ding the required amounts of hot and
directly from the port's water system or cold water from the ship's water system,
from water boats (Goethe and Herrmann the standard of personal hygiene of the
[2]). Since the 1950s seawater distillation crew and the sanitary facilities in the living
plants have been reintroduced to enable and working areas. Quantitative standards
fresh water supplies to be replenished. The of water consumption defined in the 1950s
choice of the ship's water supply, i. e. from affected the design of water systems on
shore sources or the ship's own distillation ships (Herrmann [5]; Lamoureux [6]; Ma-
plant, is merely a question of economy on teev et al. [7]; Sobol and Elpiner [9]; Sobol
cargo liners since these ships frequently and Wasilewska [10]). According to those
2.7 The Ship's Water Supply 129
Table 1. OId and new standards for water con- and purification (Elpiner [1]; Goethe and
sumption Herrmann [2, 3]; Herrmann [5]; Sobol and
Uses of water Standards hi- Actual water Wasilewska [10]; Zorn [12]).
therto observed consumption Water systems all over the world fulfil
(litres per per- and the new different requirements, depending on the
son perday) sanitary stan-
dards (litres
number of users. The water systems at
per person per ports supplying fresh water for ships must
day) have the highest standards. The standards
of ships' water systems are usually some-
Morning wash 10 10
After-watch 35 70 (2 x 35) what lower. Since the quality of water ob-
bath tained from different ports varies, it is diffi-
Washing hands 15 (5 x 3) 15 cult to control its mineral content. There-
before meals fore, the turbidity standards of the water
Preparing meals 30 30
and dish-
stored in the ship's tanks for a few days or
washing longer are not so strict (up to 5 mg/litre
Washing hands 10 (4 x 2.5) 10 Si02). Very soft water is in some countries
after visiting thought to have a harmful effect on the hu-
the toilet man organism. Therefore, the distillate
Toilet flushing 35
Laundry 25 used to supply fresh water should be min-
Cleaning in the 5 eralised to obtain a hardness of 5° _6° N
living spaces (about 2 mval) and to provide a full com-
Total 100 200
plex of the micro-elements occurring in
natural water.
In a number of countries, the value of
the mineralised distillate is considered to
standards, overboard water was used for be the same as or even higher than that of
toilet flushing and cleansing purposes, and the water from shore sources but the sani-
the daily ration of water amounted to tary standard of water may be inadequate
100 litres per person. in some ports. Irrespective of the bacterio-
In the 1970s, as a result of the increasing logical state of the water at the time when it
pollution ofharbour and coastal waters, at- is obtained [rom shore sources or purified
tempts were made to replace sea water with aboard, the water should be disinfected di-
fresh water. Analysis of the actual water rectly before its distribution. Correct oper-
consumption on ships indicates that the ation of disinfecting plants, now installed
standards for fresh water consumption are on all ships, makes it possible to meet the
outdated and in practice considerably ex- highest standards, i. e. not a single faecal
ceeded. Thus, it has become necessary to coliform bacteria in 100 ml of water, while
work out new sanitary standards based on the coli index (or MPN in 100 ml) must not
actual needs (Table 1) (Lamoureux [6]; So- exceed 1.
bol and Szumilas [8]; Sobol and Elpiner [9];
Sobol and Wasilewska [10]). 2.7.5 Water Systems on Ships
2.7.4 QualityofFresh Water The ship's water system includes water
on Board Ship storage tanks, pressure tanks, pumps, a pu-
rification plant and a distribution system
The quality of potable water on board ship (the piping) (Elpiner [1]; Goethe and Herr-
which has been obtained from shore mann [2]; Lamoureux [6]; Sobol [11]).
sources depends on the quality of fresh wa- To provide potable water for all pur-
ter in ports as weIl as storage conditions poses when using a single water system, in-
130 2 The Seafarer's Environment
aged during the ship's voyage, welding of agents must be stored aboard, and their ac-
zinc-coated pipes often damages the pro- tivity must be checked regularly. Chlorina-
tective coating. For this reason these sec- tion can be applied only on a ship with a
tions must be repaired in the nearest port. large crew where a particular crew member
Copper pipes can be used if they are ac- can be appointed to take care of the equip-
cepted by the national health administra- ment. It is advisable to use the procedure
tion and do not contain harmful contami- after any kind of water system repairs,
nants. when the whole system must be disinfect-
Technical systems should be connected ed.
with the drinking water system in case
there is only one water system. This con- 2.7.6.2 Filtration
nection should be back-flow proof. Open- On ships with small crews (10-15 persons),
air gaps, vacuum breakers or pipe dividers filters with silver-impregnated ceramie can-
are preferable. Non-return valves are not dIes are recommended (Sobold and Wasi-
safe from the hygienie point of view. lewska [10]; Sobol [11]; Zorn [12]). The
Hot potable water (338-343 K, method consists of trapping all impurities
65° -70°C) should be piped to washbasins, on the filters. The filters are impregnated
showers and sinks, and to galley and pan- with silver ions, thereby preventing the
try for scalding dishes and utensils growth ofbacteria. In the 1950s and 1960s,
(363-368 K, 90° -95°C). Showers have to this method was used on a number of
be fitted with automatie temperature limit- ships, but recently some more effective
ing valves in order to avoid scalds. methods have been introduced.
As impurities gather on the filter, effiu-
2.7.6 Disinfection of Water ent resistance increases and the filter's effi-
ciency decreases. Therefore, filters must be
Water stored on ship for a long period may cleaned when the resistance reaches a cer-
become contaminated and therefore tain value. The filter can be regenerated
should be disinfected (Elpiner [1]; Goethe 14 times, providing an average of 4000 li-
and Herrmann [3]; Herrmann [4]; Sobol tres of filtrate after each regeneration. Thus
and Wasilewska [10]; Zorn [12]). The use of a total of 60000litres of water can be
one of the disinfection methods restores gained from a single filtration candle. A
the previous sanitary standard of the water. serious dis advantage of this method is the
There is a need to improve the design of labour-consuming regeneration of filters.
disinfection plants which will simplify the
whole process of disinfecting and limit the 2.7.6.3 Disinfection with Ultraviolet Light
participation required of the crew. The bactericidal properties of ultraviolet
radiation are also used to disinfect water.
2.7.6.1 Chlorination The method is simple to apply and the
Until quite recently chlorination was the procedure can be automated. The most ef-
only method of disinfection (Goethe and fective bactericidal action is observed at
Herrmann [3]; Sobol and Wasilewska [10]). 2500-2800 A. It is proportional to the radi-
Although effective, it has certain disadvan- ation intensity and contact time (Elpiner
tages. Firstly, the amount of chlorine [1]).
needed to disinfect a given amount of wa- According to the manufacturer's data
ter must be determined every time. When (General Electric), ultraviolet lamps trans-
overchlorination occurs, the organoleptic mit about 20% of the energy supplied. Fur-
properties of water change; therefore de- ther energy losses depend on the extent to
chlorination must be achieved using which the water is polluted, since impuri-
activated charcoal. Secondly, chlorinating ties absorb ultraviolet radiation. Suspen-
132 2 The Seafarer's Environment
sions of iron salts, acid carbonates, humus 1. The method of taking water from the
compounds and other substances reduce port system and especially the sanitary
the transmission rate and gather on the conditions of the wate ring equipment
protective quartz tubes separating the lamp and hydrants, as weIl as the period of
from the water. Disinfection effectiveness flushing the filling hoses (a minimum of
depends on the following factors: lifetime 5 min).
of lamp (6000 h according to the manufac- 2. The technical condition of the tanks and
turer) measured by the lamp's work count- corrosion-resistant protective coatings;
er, cleanness of the quartz glass protecting flushing the tanks before taking large
the lamp and the degree of water pollution. supplies of water and draining the tank
The lamp's radiation intensity is measured bottom as often as necessary to remove
by a photoelectric cell regulating the flow the sediment and impurities.
of water or warning of malfunctioning of 3. Disinfection of the tanks and water sys-
the system. Impurities deposited on the tem after they have undergone any re-
lamp's quartz protections must be re- pairs.
moved. The impurities can be reduced by 4. Utilisation of spare pumps in the potable
filters installed before the unit. Because of water system only when there is no pos-
the unit's simple construction it is easy to sibility of them being used for liquids
operate, uses little energy and seems to be other than potable water.
the most suitable of all water disinfecting 5. To prevent water pollution, all connec-
plants on the ship. Operating tests made tions and pump glands must be leak-
aboard ship showed that a 100% bacteri- proof.
cidal effect is observed at the exposure of 6. Measurement of water storage must be
4 Wsec./litre, i. e. we can obtain 2litres per done by instruments not to be removed
sec. disinfected water with a lamp of 40 W. from the tank.
The organoleptic properties of water re- 7. The method of seawater distillation, de-
main unchanged (Herrmann [4]; Sobol and salination and mineralisation of the
Wasilewska [10]; Sobol [11]). Other disin- distillate before the water is pumped to
fection procedures such as pasteurisation, storage tanks.
ozonising and iodising are not gene rally 8. Water-disinfecting equipment, its effi-
used (Elpiner [1]; Goethe and Herrmann ciency, following the operating instruc-
[2]; Zorn [12]). tions, periodical surveys and repairs.
9. Keeping records of all activities connect-
2.7.7 Utilisation and Sanitary ed with the water-system equipment.
Supervision of Water Systems Water-system equipment is und er sani-
tary control by the harbour medical service
To use a water system properly it is neces- in the port of registry. Water sampies, mini-
sary to have complete working plans and mum of 100 ml each, for bacteriological
operating instructions for all parts of the tests are taken from all tanks and from noz-
system. Good cooperation with the har- zles of the water system. The frequency of
bour medical service can be achieved when sampling depends on ship traffic. The sam-
the doctor or officer charged with medical pies should be collected after each voyage
care on board is introduced to ship's hy- lasting over 3 months, or in the case of
giene and knows how to supply the ship shorter ones, after every fourth voyage.
with potable water and how to check the Water sampIes should be taken before fill-
water's sanitary standard (Sobol [11]). ing the tanks, to find the hygienic standard
The following problems connected with of water from the last voyage. The harbour
using the ship's water system must be taken medical service is obliged to keep records
into account: of the sanitary inspection of the ship's wa-
2.7 The Ship's Water Supply 133
ter systems. Basic information conceming this operation has to be noted in the ship's
the water system, results of tests and rec- log-book. To facilitate the exchange of the
ommendations after controls should be in- water in the lifeboats it is recommended
cluded. Physicochemical tests are also re- that points taking potable water be in-
quired by order of the harbour medical stalled on the boat's deck. Ouring the ex-
service. Mter all repairs or when the bacte- change of water or other functions, the
riological condition of water has been smallest of leakages of water from the
found unsatisfactory, the ship's water sys- tanks has to be immediately reported to the
tem and equipment must be disinfected. ship's captain and wherever possible these
Oisinfection is done with 80 g of active leakages must be eliminated. The tradition-
chlorine per ton of water in the tanks and al method of keeping water in lifeboats in
in the distribution system. Mter adding the tanks should be replaced by individual wa-
chlorinating agent and filling the system ter rations in hermetically sealed tins made
with water, a 2-h contact period is required. of material resistant to corrosion. On the
To obtain an accurate disinfection of all tins the date of validity should be given.
equipment, the draw taps at the farthest Orinking water in tins is used with success
section of the water system must be open- in inflatable rafts and retains an adequate
ed. Chlorinated water must flow through quality providing that the principle of peri-
the entire system so that it will have the odic replacement of the tins is observed.
clear odour of chlorine. Mter 2 h, chlori- This duty to replace tins is often neglected
nated water must be removed from the sys- on ships from various countries. The dis-
tem, which is filled with clean water from charge of water from the tanks when a ship
the shore source. enters regions with temperatures below
freezing-point is impossible. The water re-
2.7.8 Drinking Water on Lifeboats serves on the lifeboats must be subjected to
and Rafts periodical control by the harbour medical
services.
Lifeboats and rafts are equipped with a re-
serve of drinking water (Sobol [11]). The ca-
pacity of this reserve must at least be suffi- References
cient to replace the loss of body fluid for a
completely occupied boat or raft. The out- 1. Elpiner, L.I.: Vodosnabzhenie morskikh sudov.
[Water supply on seagoing ships]. Moscow:
fit of lifeboats includes about 3 litres of
Izdatelstvo Transport 1975.
drinking water per person, while in inflat- 2. Goethe, H. and R. Herrmann: Hygienische Ge-
able rafts there is a minimum of 1.51itres sichtspunkte bei Konstruktion und Betrieb von
per person. This reserve may be reduced to Schiffswasserversorgungsanlagen. In: Jahrbuch
21itres per person on lifeboats and 1litre in der Schiffbautechnischen Gesellschaft, Vol. 63,
1969. Berlin, Heidelberg, New York: Springer
inflatable rafts provided with desalting 1970. pp. 293-302.
equipment. 3. Goethe, H. and R. Herrmann: Zur Problematik
In lifeboats the drinking water is kept in der Trinkwasserdesinfektion an Bord von See-
at least two waterproof tanks ofzinc-plated schiffen. In: Desinfektion von Trinkwasser.
Stuttgart: G.Fischer 1970. pp.91-98. (Schrif-
steel or other material resistant to corrosion tenreihe d. Vereins f. Wasser-, Boden- und Luft-
and accepted by the sanitary authorities as hygiene No.31)
being adequate for this purpose. The tanks 4. Herrmann, R.: Die UV-Anlage an Bord von
should be provided with a dipper, a gauge Schiffen. Hansa 116,2,149-150 (1979).
and a cup fastened to a chain, serving for S. Herrmann, R.: Wasserhygiene an Bord. Schiffs-
Ing. J. 20, 104, 10-14 (1973).
water rationing. 6. Lamoureux, V. B.: Guide to ship sanitation.
The crew members must change the wa- Geneva: WHO 1967.
ter in the tanks at least once a month, and 7. Mateev, 1., V. Panteleev and G. Bumbalova:
134 2 The Seafarer's Environment
Certain requirements to be observed in sup- 10. Sobol, Z. and H. B. Wasilewska: Supply of the
plying ships with water. In: VII International sea going ships with fresh water. Budownictwo
symposium on marine medicine, Odessa, okretowe 26, 5/6, 225 (1981).
23-30 Sept. 1976, USSR Ministry of Health, 11. Sobol, Z.: Zaopatrzenie statk6w w wode slodka.
Moscow 1976. p.310. [Fresh water supply of ships]. In: Dolmierski, R.
8. Sobol, Z. and T. Szumilas: Current trends of et al. (eds): Morski poradnik medyczny. [Medi-
fresh water supply on ships. BuH. Inst. mar. cal guide for seafaring]. Warsaw: Panstwowy
trop. Med. Gdynia 30, 2, 143-152 (1979). Zaklad Wydawnictw Lekarskich 1981.
9. Sobol, Z. and L. I. Elpiner: Elaboration of a uni- pp. 341-356.
form methodology of water supply investiga- 12. Zorn, E.: Wasserhygiene auf Schiffen. Mat.
tion on ships. In: VII International symposium med. Nordm. 21, 12, 708-713 (1969).
on marine medicine, Odessa, 23-30 Sept. 1976,
USSR Ministry ofHealth, Moscow 1976. p.305.
2.8 Waste and Waste -Water Disposal Aboard Ship
Z.Sobol
other than those in (a), called grey sew- international regulations. The black and
age. grey sewage systems are shown in Figs.1
Black sewage includes the waste from and2.
drains and toilets, the entire waste from the
ship's hospital and the waste from holds 2.8.3 Requirements of the
where live animals are kept. Of the grey se- International Conventions
wage, the most noxious components for the
marine environment are galley and laundry The MAR POL IMCO Convention, Lon-
waste since they contain the greatest don 1973, dealt with the prohibition of the
amounts of impurities. Galley waste con- discharge of black sewage into protected
tains considerable amounts of food and waters, i. e. harbour waters and a zone of
grease, while laundry waste contains deter- coastal waters up to 12 nautical miles off-
gents. Waste from washbasins and showers shore. Black sewage discharge outside the
is more diluted but contains the highest protected areas is unrestricted. Discharge
amount ofbacterial impurities. Thus, in the of grey sewage is unrestricted. According
event of contagious or infectious diseases to the convention, ships must have holding
on board ship, this waste must be disinfect- tanks of adequate size proportional to the
ed along with the black sewage. They grey number of crew members and passengers
sewage contains only potable water, while aboard and the approximate duration of
the black sewage contains potable or sea stay in protected waters. The sewage re-
water. tained in the tanks may be discharged into
On ships built in the 1960s, i. e. ships that the sea after leaving the protected areas or
may still be in operation, overboard water may be transferred to sewage-treatment
is generally used for flushing toilets and plants ashore.
urinals. Since the 1970s, single potable wa- Crushed and disinfected waste may be
ter systems have been used on cargo ships discharged into the coastal waters
for all sanitary purposes, including toilet 4-12 nautical miles offshore, provided the
flushing and cleansing sanitary areas. The system comminuting and disinfecting the
kind of water used for toilet flushing and sewage intended for discharge fulfils the
cleansing sanitary areas is of particular im- following effluent standards:
portance to hygiene when a ship stays in a (a) Faecal coliform bacteria in the efflu-
highly polluted harbour or coastal waters, ent should not exceed 1000/100 ml; (b) the
espeeially in countries in which infectious weight of the material retained on the filter
and highly contagious diseases are en- screen (no.12 with openings of 1.68 mm)
demie. after it has been dried to a constant weight
Black sewage makes up 20%-30% ofthe in a oven a 103 °C/376 K must not exceed
total amount of sewage, i. e. about 40-60 li- 10% of the total suspended solids.
tres per person per 24 h. Its concentration To avoid the inconveniences resulting
depends on the sanitary habits of the crew from having to retain sewage on protected
and passengers, the frequency of toilet waters, attempts have been made to work
flushing and the technical condition of the out effective methods of sewage treatment
flushing facilities. The amount of grey se- aboard ship. Treated sewage discharge
wage on ships with individual sanitary fa- is unrestricted, irrespective of the place,
eilities (washbasins and showers for all provided that the sewage treatment plant
crew members) is 140-160 litres per person satisfies the following effluent standards:
per 24 h (Sobol et al. [9]; Sobol [10]). With (a) the faecal coliform count does not ex-
the dual sewage system, it is possible to iso- ceed 250 faecal coliform bacteria per
late the sewage most noxious for the natu- 100 ml; (b) the suspended solids do not ex-
ral environment and treat it according to ceed 50 mg/litre when the equipment is
2.8 Waste and Waste-Water Disposal Aboard Ship 137
Overboard
discharge
Yen! Yen!
I
I
Overboord
discharge
Oischorg e pump
tested on shore and are not 100 mg/litre geometrie mean of the 5-day bioehemical
above the suspended-solid eontent of the oxygen demand (BODs) of the effluent
sea water used for flushing purposes when sampies does not exeeed 30 mg/litre (Inter-
the equipment is tested aboard ship; (e) the national Conference on Marine Pollution
residual level of ehlorine in effluent does [4]). To meet the above standards is not easy
not exeeed 5 mg/litre as free available and requires eontinuous operation of the
ehlorine. In addition to these eonditions, plant by the crew. Care is absolutely essen-
the plant should be so designed that the tial - no objects or liquids that might inter-
138 2 The Seafarer's Environment
It should be stated that systems properly Table 1 Standard dimensions of flanges for dis-
used and operated can provide a degree of charge connections
sewage purification in accordance with the Description Dimension
international standards, if the sanitary re-
Outside diameter 210mm
quirements are strictly supervised by port Inner diameter Dependent on pipe out-
or government authorities. side diameter
Bolt circle diameter 170mm
Siots in flange Four holes, 18 mm di-
2.8.6 Sewage-Treatment Facilities ameter, equidistantly
in Ports placed on a bolt circle of
the above diameter, slot-
There are a great number of ships that have ted to the flange periph-
only holding tanks and thus the necessity ery. The slot width should
arises that in all ports of the world there be 18mm
should be facilities for dealing with the se- Flange thickness 16mm
wage from such ships (Buxton and Schor- Bolts and nuts - Four, each 16 mm
quantity and diameter
mann [1]; Environment Canada, Water
Pollution Control Directorate, [2]; Sobol
[10]). This is particularly important during
long stays in ports when waiting on the In those ports in which the building of
roadstead or in the case of a ship being land-based sewage-treatment facilities is
quarantined. In addition, ports are used by not expected in the near future, the sewage
a great number of small fishing and auxil- collecting and/or treatment unit ships are
iary ships on which the installation of self- the only means of maintaining a sanitary
contained treatment plants would be im- barrier capable of protecting a country
possible. Port authorities are, therefore, against the spread of infectious and conta-
obliged to instal sewage-storage and purifi- gious diseases. The transfer of sewage from
cation facilities. ships to ports that do not have any sewage-
The transfer ofthe sewage to the munici- purification installations is purposeless be-
pal sewage plant is not possible because of cause the sewage will only be discharged
the danger to public hygiene. Considering untreated into the port or nearby waters.
that in each port it is necessary to transfer To limit the contamination of the port
the sewage from ships on the roadstead or waters by sewage during its transference
direct from the wharf, ports must be from the ship to the port sewage-treatment
equipped with floating sewage collecting facilities, both the transfer pipes of the
and/or treatment units. These units may treatment plant and those of the ship
transfer the sewage to the reception facili- should be fitted with standard dis charge
ties or treat it in their own plants, and after- connections in accordance with the dimen-
wards discharge the treated sewage directly sions presented in Table 1.
into the waters of the port or into the near- The flange is designed to accept pipes up
by coastal waters, without limit. The spe- to a maximum internal diameter of 100 mm
cialist crew on such ships guarantees the and should be of steel or equivalent materi-
correct functioning of the treatment plants. al having a flat surface. This flange togeth-
An analysis of the transfer, handling and er with a suitable gasket should be suitable
manoeuvring time indicates that one unit for a service pressure of 6 kp/ cm2•
could deal with 10-15 ships in 24h. The
number of the sewage collecting and/or 2.8.7 Holding Tanks
treatment units should be in accordance
with the number of ships calling at the port Holding tanks are especially used for se-
within 24h. wage, i. e. faeces, urine and the associated
140 2 The Seafarer's Environment
Sewoge from
occommodolion
Dverboord
dischorge
comminuIO~.2.~.~.i!..
3 level
swilches
flush water. Raw sewage contains different with discharge pumps and it is recom-
solids, such as paper, rags, faeces and even mended that two discharge pumps be fit-
garbage. To reduce the size of solids so that ted, one working and one standby. The
they can be more easily transported and pumps should be capable of handling
pumped, holding tanks are equipped with heavy liquids and suspended solids of up
a comminutor (Environment Canada, Wa- to 5 mm. To facilitate cleaning of the tank,
ter Pollution Control Directorate, [2]). flush water should be supplied. Each hold-
Fresh sewage contains an enormous ing tank should be equipped with a control
nu mb er of aerobic and anaerobic bacteria. system. The control system should consist
If the characteristics of the sewage favour of three level switches mounted in the tank
aerobic bacterial respiration, then very and detecting the following levels - tank
IittIe in the way of obnoxious odour will be 90% full, tank 50% full and tank empty.
present. For this reason, many designers The level switches activate alarms and
prefer to aerate the sewage in the tanks. lights according to the amount of se wage in
If free air is in short supply in the se- the holding tank (Fig.3). The capacity of
wage, then conditions become favourable the holding tank is dependent upon the
for anaerobic bacteria and the presence of flow rate in litres per man per day, the
sulphur odour can be detected. If the con- number of crew and passengers, and the
tents of a holding tank are aerated so as to sewage retention time in days.
maintain a dissolved oxygen content in
excess of 1.0 mg/ litre, the sewage will be 2.8.8 Solid Waste on Ships
kept aerobic and the production of odours
and dangerous gases should be minimised. Solid waste accumulates on ships as a re-
The holding tank must have an outlet vent sult of the preparation and consumption of
that should be located above the highest food, the cleaning of the ship's holds and
ship's deck to disperse any odours into the the professional work carried out on board
atmosphere. The vent pipe needs to be (Lamoureux [5]; Sobol [10]). The solid
checked periodically to ensure that it is not waste comes (a) from the catering and
blocked, especially during cold weather accommodation areas - various kinds of
when the formation of ice in the vent can wrappings and containers, food remains,
occur. old magazines and newpapers, old clothes;
Each holding tank should be equipped (b) from the working decks - old work ma-
2.8 Waste and Waste-Water Disposal Aboard Ship 141
terials, (e. g. paint containers, brushes, wire, of waste on ships and, in particular, the
ropes), old appliances no longer in use, troublesome handling of it in ports, have
loading and unloading waste; and (c) from led to the installation of waste combustion
the engine room - old engine parts, pack- devices on ships, which continually bUffi
ing materials, discharged lubricants, old away all kinds ofwaste. Although advanta-
rags. The quantity of waste from the galley geous from the sanitary point of view, this
is estimated at 2 kg per person per 24 h on solution does require great quantities of
average and from all other areas 20-40 kg fuel and is very time consuming. Owing to
per 24h. the increased cost of fuel, the waste com-
The composition of the waste from ships bustion device is often switched off in an
is as follows: 40% paper, 14% metal, 20% effort to reduce expense. Irrespective ofthe
food remains, 18% glass, 4% wood, 2% tex- methods of rendering the waste less harm-
tiles and 2% plastic. On sanitary grounds, ful, there still exists the problem of storing
the greatest danger is caused by food re- it for a long or a short period of time on
mains and the wrappings from food prod- the ship. A good hygienic effect can be
ucts, as these can encourage insects and ro- achieved by storing the waste in plastic
dents. A danger to health can also exist in bags, tightly closed after filling, in which
the residues from transported toxic materi- form the waste can be taken to shore or dis-
als. These residues are a constant problem posed of in the combustion devices. The
during the loading and unloading of the use of strong containers that can be tightly
ship. The other solid waste, e. g. kitchen sealed prevents their being penetrated by
waste, packing material (bottles, cans, insects and rodents. When the required
boxes) and household waste, arises during quantity of plastic bags or suitable contain-
the whole time the ship is being used. ers for waste is lacking, one observes on
Up to the time ofthe MAR POL 1973 [4] ships the increase of refuse on the open
convention, solid waste from ships was (af- decks, which may present a sanitary danger
ter leaving the port) usually dumped direct- not only for the ship itself but also for the
ly into the sea. In many countries, such a environment (Sobol [10]).
method of waste dis pos al is tolerated even With longer stays in ports or on road-
now. As a result of the introduction of the stead, the sanitary state of the ship is de-
MAR POL convention stipulations, solid pendent on the sanitation service of the
waste disposal is now restricted not only in port, which is responsible for accepting the
ports but also in coastal waters. Beyond a waste from ships. Here, one observes cer-
distance of 12 nautical miles from the tain deficiencies in many ports, and the
co ast, waste that sinks or that can be natu- keeping of rotting waste is a burdensome
rally broken down by the sea water can be problem for both the ship and the port en-
jettisoned; beyond 25 nautical miles from vironment. It would be advisable for all
the co ast, wood and floating waste may be countries to make the waste from ships as
jettisoned (International Conference on hygienic as possible in the port region so as
Marine Pollution, [4]). The convention com- to maintain a sanitary barrier. The delivery
pletely prohibits the disposal of plastic of waste to the communal dumping ground
waste into the sea on most shipping routes involves the possibility of spreading insects
(excluding the high seas). and rodents that normally do not occur in a
On ships, therefore, the problem arises given geographical zone, but could weIl be
of finding a means of storing waste for a introduced by ships.
long period of time and making it as far as
possible safe on board until it can be trans-
ferred to the sewage-treatment facilities.
The difficulties connected with the storage
142 2 The Seafarer's Environment
only medium level, but that occasionally The energy requirement of fishermen is
they have to do heavier physical work (see considerably higher than the above figures:
Chap.2.1). Ouring the stay in ports the it is generally calculated at 16800-28400 kJ
deck staff naturally work harder in the pro- (4000-7000 kcal), although results report-
cess of loading and unloading; the same is ed by different authors vary considerably.
true of the ship's management. The engine Oifferences in type of vessel, equipment,
room staff do extraordinarily heavy physi- weather and sea conditions in the fishing
cal work during repairs and thus the con- areas may figure prominently. For Polish
sumption of energy is relatively high. deep sea fishermen average values of
The physical work-Ioad of crew mem- 16400-21000kJ (4000-5000kcal) per day
bers on board fishery vessels still represents are indicated by Kierst [14]. An even higher
an exception in seafaring. Although the energy consumption was found in Soviet
physical work-Ioad has generally been re- trawler fishermen, i.e. 17270-30400kJ
duced, the tasks during the period of fish- (4136-7238 kcal) (Bondarev et al. [3]). Ac-
ing must still be regarded as the heaviest cording to Weibelzahl [26], fishermen ofthe
physical work (Bühring [5]). German Oemocratic Republic showed an
On passenger vessels the activities of the approximate value of 23100 kJ (5500 kcal).
catering staff are defined as heavy physical Thorough investigations by analysis of
work too (Israeli et al. [13]). breathing gas in Yugoslav seamen resulted
Unfavourable climatic and sea condi- in values from 14180kJ to 18555kJ
tions mean additional load factors. Fur- (3376-4444kcal) (Maver et al. [16]).
thermore, factors like noise, vibrations and The high energy requirement and the
chemicals may affect the appetite and the high energy consumption of fishermen are
metabolism of seamen. Finally, unfavour- exceptional in the merchant fleet. Conse-
able psychological working conditions may quently the food of fishermen has to be
influence the appetite and the energy ex- more nourishing, i. e. it has to supply more
change. On account of the many factors in- energy than that of crew members on board
volved, evaluation of their individual effect cargo vessels.
is very difficult and the available data can When comparing, very carefully and
serve only as a guide. with restrictions, the average values of en-
Balanced energy exchange (metabolism) ergy consumption of crew members of the
is easily obtainable by exact measurement merchant fleet with the values of the vict-
of the body weights of the individual crew ualling bill and the calculated nutritive sub-
members and the weight of the crew as a stances provided by allotments of provi-
whole, as the body weights of healthy sions on board, it is evident that frequently
adults may indicate the differences be- the nutritive value of the consumed food is
tween the storage and expenditure of ener- far higher than the value of energy con-
gy. As the work-Ioad on board modem ves- sumption. The discrepancy between the
sels is fairly moderate, the average energy supply of energy and the energy consump-
requirement is generally estimated at tion may be related to the fact that physical
12600-14700kJ (3000-3500kcal). Signifi- work has decreased considerably on board
cant deviations may, however, occur as the modem vessels. The nutrition, however,
load differs according to occupation. Addi- has remained unchanged. The actual nour-
tional deviations may be caused by work at ishment of crew members corresponds to
sea or in ports. As the work-Ioad of the ca- the quantity of energy consumption several
tering personneion board passenger ves- decades ago. Consequently the very sub-
sels is rather high, the energy requirement stantial food intake involves the risk of
is in general estimated at approx. 16800 kJ ovemutrition, whereas undemutrition oc-
(4000kcal). curs in very exceptional cases only.
2.9 The Seafarer's Food 145
The gross nutritive value of the food al- The ship's motion and the resulting ac-
lotments of most maritime countries is celeration impulses affect the metabolism.
above 16800kJ (4000kcal) (Wandel [25]; It goes without saying that the gastrointes-
Bogetti [2]; Giannico et al. [8]; 0grim [19]; tinal disorders caused by motion sickness
Kierst [14]). The victuaIling bill of the Ger- lead to loss of nutriment and fluid. Slight
man Federal Republic - which is not fol- cases of motion sickness involve a loss of
lowed in practice - even contains a gross appetite, and even in cases without the typ-
value of 25000 kJ (6000 kcal) (Zorn [29]). ical symptoms of nausea and vomiting the
On an ocean-going oil tanker the average metabolism may be disturbed and glucose
energy intake was 15070 kJ (3600 kcal) per and ketone bodies are traceable in the
man per day, ofwhich 13230 kJ (3160 kcal) urine (Goethe [9]). Consequently the ener-
were derived from non-alcoholic sources gy exchange may be disturbed by accelera-
(Eddy et al. [6]). tion impulses. Long-term motion sickness
As stated above, weight measurements sometimes causes considerable loss of
and medical examinations have proved body weight.
that the mentioned nutritive values on
board merchant vessels do not correspond 2.9.3 Nutritive Substances
with the actual energy consumption. Kry-
nicki [15] found one-third of 1682 ex- Adequate physiological nourishment con-
amined Polish seamen to be overweight, sists firstly in the intake of weIl-balanced
and several other authors have reported proportions of the main nutritive sub-
similar results (Goethe [10]; Roberts et al. stances - proteins, fat and carbohydrates -
[20]; Mitkova [17]). When calculating the as weIl as substances not providing energy:
total energy supply, alcohol should not be vitamins, minerals, bulk material and wa-
forgotten. On board West German vessels ter. Consequently, the total value of nutri-
the average consumption is 4-5 bottles of tive substances is not the only important
beer per person per day (Zorn [28]). factor in optimal nutrition. A wisely bal-
The climatic influence on energy ex- anced nourishment in respect of these sub-
change should also be considered. As the stances is frequently unavailable on board.
rate of exchange decreases under high en- The proportions of the individual sub-
vironmental temperatures and increases stances should be:
under low temperatures, the composition - Proteins, fat, carbohydrates 1 : 1 : 4
of food should be modified according to - In the tropics this should be 1 : 0.8 : 1
the conditions of the individual climatic (Strothmann et al. [21])
zones to be crossed during long voyages. Consequently, the foIlowing quantities are
During voyages in the tropics the average adequate:
energy requirement is approximately 10% - Proteins 100-110 g (in the tropics
lower than normal, whereas it is approxi- 80 g)
mately 10% higher than normal during - Carbo-
voyages in the polar zones. The changes in hydrates 400-440 g
energy consumption caused by climatic in- relative to a total nutritive value of
fluences may be even larger. The energy 12600-13440kJ (3 000-3200 kcal).
consumption is estimated at Calculations of the nutritive substances
and the total nutritive value provided by
- 12600 kJ (3000 kcal) in temperate zones the food aIlotments on board European
- 10500 kJ (2500 kcal) in the subtropics vessels resulted in rather high values for
and the tropics lipids, which often exceeded 200 g. The
- 16800 kJ (4000 kcal) in polar zones proportion of fat frequently makes up
(Giannico et al. [8]) 30%-40% of the total nutritive value, or
146 2 The Seafarer's Environment
logical and hygienic aspects are of major ed out that, owing to improper storage and
importance. inadequate preservation facilities, spoiled
food formerly led to outbreaks of food poi-
2.9.5 Procurement of Provisions soning during long voyages.
Naturally, different foodstuffs have to be
The procurement of provisions may be ef- stored in different ways:
fected in three different ways: 1. In deep-freeze rooms,
1. By the shipowning company; 2. In cold-stores,
2. By the shipowning company together 3. In store-rooms with temperatures from
with crew members in charge of nutri- +2 °eto +12 oe,
tion on board; 4. In store-rooms with living room temper-
3. By the catering staff only. atures.
Presumably the procurement of provi- The deep-freeze rooms should be kept at
sions by the shipping company only, is un- temperatures of -18 oe and below. A tem-
favourable for the ship's crew, as it is fairly perature of - 30 oe is recommended for
difficult to meet the actual requirements of long-term storage, i. e. for more than three
crew members. months. This prevents losses of vitamin e
Furthermore the following points are to in foodstuffs. Premature thawing of deep-
be borne in mind (Wandel [25]): frozen foodstuffs must always be avoided.
1. Fruit and vegetables should be supplied The food should be thawed only directly
when they are in season. before use. Quick heating to + 100 oe (by
2. Only certain kinds of foodstuff can be micro-waves) is most favourable. If there
prepared in the galley, given the avail- are temperatures high er than -15 oe, the
able equipment and the numbers and refrigerating requirements of deep-frozen
knowledge of the catering staff. foods are no longer met, and they can no
3. Storage facilities aboard may limit the longer be stored. Temperatures of + 2 oe
choice of food. to + 4 oe guarantee preservation of perish-
The cost of foodstuffs should not be the able food for a few days only.
most important factor. Very often ready- It is necessary to keep a cold-store abso-
made deep-frozen dishes, packed meat in lutely clean. Meat, fish, vegetables and fruit
individual portions, or fruit and vegetables should be stored in separate compart-
of high quality seem to be more economi- ments. Preserved foodstuffs should be
cal as there is less waste and the catering stored in well-ventilated rooms with tem-
staff have less work to do (Troeder [23]; peratures of + 4 oe to + 12 oe. Dried
Wolf [27]). foodstuffs in original packing can be stored
Some further points are important: at living room temperatures.
1. Duration of voyage; In order to preserve the taste and quality
2. elimatic zone to be crossed; of the individual foodstuffs, they should be
3. Long periods at deep sea, when it is im- stored vacuum packed in foil or bags and
possible to procure further provisions. be protected against damage by destructive
insects. Mouldy foodstuffs should be de-
2.9.6 Storage of Provisions stroyed because of their aflatoxin content.
on Board The following kinds of store-room
should be available on board larger vessels
The preservation of foodstuffs is depen- (Strothmann et al. [21]):
dent on the storage facilities available. 1. Deep-freeze room with temperatures of
They should be highly effective to guaran- - 20 oe to - 30 oe for meat, meat prod-
tee good, wholesome food which is greatly ucts and fish;
appreciated by the crew. It has to be point- 2. Deep-freeze rooms with temperatures of
2.9 The Seafarer's Food 149
-18°C to - 30°C for ready-made dish- al cook ashore, i. e. he should be able to of-
es, vegetables and ice cream; fer a lot of different dishes from a restricted
3. Cold-store with temperatures of + 2 °C variety of foodstuffs in order to prevent
to + 4 °C for butter, margarine, eggs, monotony. Furthermore, he has to have
cheese, milk products, prepared food, and employ a basic knowledge of sanitary
bread and confectionery; hygiene. Naturally, the shipowning com-
4. Cold-stores with temperatures from pany requires the ship's cook to make the
+ 2 °C to + 8 °C for fruit and vegetables; best use of food and to victual economical-
5. Dry-store (approx. + 15°C) for pre- ly in foreign ports (Herrmann [12]).
served food, coffee, tea, flour, rice, pota-
toes, fresh and dried vegetables etc. 2.9.8 Further Problems of Nutrition
The store-rooms should be inspected on Board
regularly in order to avoid shortcomings.
The following instructions should be ob- 1. The future vessel will predominantly be
served: at sea.
1. Before starting the voyage: cleaning and 2. The stay in ports will be shortened to a
disinfection of store-rooms; inspection minimum.
of store-rooms; older provisions to be 3. The number of crew members will be re-
stored at the front of the rooms. duced to the lowest possible level (see
2. During the voyage: regulation and con- Chap.2.1).
trol of air temperatures and humidity; This will naturally complicate the pro-
opening of rooms only once per day, es- curement of provisions in foreign ports.
pecially deep-freeze rooms, to take out The personnel reduction, of course, also in-
food-stuffs; older provisions and perish- volves the catering staff. It will then be nec-
able food to be used first. essary to deliver ready-prepared food to
3. At the end ofthe voyage: old provisions the ship and to adequately adapt the facili-
to be marked and stored at the front of ties of the galleys and store-rooms to the
the rooms. special requirements (Troeder [23]; Hein
It goes without saying that if the ship [11]). Semi-prepared foodstuffs (e.g. potato
carries a doctor, he is in charge of sanitary products, dry sou ps, cakes and ready
control, inc1uding inspection of store- mixed pastries) make preparatory work un-
rooms and the catering area. necessary. They require only brief cooking
or baking. The same is true of dehydrated
2.9.7 The Qualification of the products (e.g. dried vegetables). Ready-
Ship's Cook made products (dishes, soups, puddings
etc.) require only brief heating (Wolf [27];
The qualification ofthe ship's cook is ofut- Wachtel [24]). There are several advantages
most importance for the quality of nutri- in using these products: minimum waste
tion on board and thus affects the well-be- disposal, space-saving storage, no seasonal
ing of crew members. A high-quality cater- difficulties with the supply offruit and veg-
ing staff is a conditio sine qua non on etables, satisfactory level of hygiene and
board passenger vessels, whereas the quali- quick preparation for serving. Technical
fication of cooks employed on cargo liners prerequisites for the storage and prepara-
often leaves much to be desired. Three tion of these products are sufficiently large
months' theoretical-practical training, as deep-freeze rooms and galleys with quick-
practised in the German Federal Republic thawing devices (micro-waves etc.). Disad-
at Travemünde and in the UK at Grave- vantages are higher prices, organisational
send, should be compulsory. A ship's cook difficulties in procuring deep-frozen prod-
should be more creative than a convention- ucts in some ports and maintenance of the
150 2 The Seafarer's Environment
Studies in obesity among naval personnel. Med. einrichtungen. In: Referate d. Arbeitstagung
Serv.1. Can. 19,8604-630 (1963). über "Probleme d. Ernährung an Bord". Ham-
21. Strothmann, H., R.von Richthofen, E.Zorn et burg 1969. pp. 119-130.
al.: Ernährung und Proviant an Bord von See- 25. Wandel, A.: Die Ernährung in der Bundesma-
schiffen. Ed.: Sozialwerk für Seeleute e. V. rine. In: Referate d. Arbeitstagung über "Pro-
Lübeck 1978: LN-Druck. (up to date, Weiterbil- bleme d. Ernährung an Bord". Hamburg 1969.
dung an Bord 14) pp. 42-60a.
22. Stutz, E. and G. Reil: C-Vitaminspiegeluntersu- 26. Weibelzahl, H.: Ernährung unter Bordbedin-
chungen während der Westindienreise der Se- gungen. Verk.-Med. 14,7,239-250 (1967).
gelschulschiffe "Horst Wessei" und "Albert 27. Wolf, W: Dehydrokost im Dienste moderner
Leo Schlageter". Veröffentlichungen aus dem Küchenpraxis. In: Referate d. Arbeitstagung
Gebiet des Marine-Sanitätswesens 30, 148-156 über "Probleme d. Ernährung an Bord". Ham-
(1938). burg 1969. pp. 138-147.
23. Troeder, H. G.: Zukunftsprobleme der Bord- 28. Zorn, E.: Die Ernährung der Schiffsbesatzun-
ernährung. In: Referate d. Arbeitstagung über gen. Zbl. Arbeitsmed. 28,10,280-283 (1978).
"Probleme d. Ernährung an Bord". Hamburg 29. Zorn, E.: Die Ernährungssituation der Seeleute.
1969. pp.96-108. In: Referate d. Arbeitstagung über "Probleme
24. Wachtel, u.: Die Verwendung von vorgefertig- d. Ernährung an Bord". Hamburg 1969.
ten Produkten in Gemeinschaftsverpflegungs- pp.19-30.
2.10 Psychological Problems in Seafaring
H.Böhm
ent groups. Applying this to seafaring leads causes ofhallucinations (formed by certain
to the observation that, although seafarers "outside" constellations of stimuli or "in-
of different countries share similar prob- side" structure of motivation) and the re-
lems, they react in different ways; in addi- sultant errors and dangers.
tion, since research is not intemationally
coordinated, its main emphasis lies on Intelligence. Intellectual factors such as
solving specific national problems - conse- quick apprehension, flexibility, concentra-
quently the possibility of comparisons is tion, imagination, faculty to abstract and a
very limited. There is another conse- retentive memory are of basic importance.
quence: giving the results of national re- Especially, the officers must be able to rec-
search can lead to bias in the psychological ognize inter-relationships in new situa-
assessment and favour wrong decisions. tions, to find adequate solutions and to ver-
Very often there is but one national result balize them. We do not yet know the effects
available and there is no scientific possibil- of intelligence - whether a high er level pro-
ity of generalizing this result without fur- duces fewer mistakes or an average one
ther knowledge. General scientific state- produces a better capacity for observing.
ments presuppose general knowledge
based on differentiated research and com- Knowledge. Professional knowledge is
parisons on the basis of a defined level of probably more effective as a result of expe-
significance. nence.
The present state of nautical psychology
does not allow us to generalize results of Motivation. The structure of motivation in-
psychological research but does permit us fluences the power of observation and de-
to describe problems in seafaring. cision.
the working and living conditions on board units etc.). The ship is a sort of total insti-
is necessary. This requires the cooperation tution, because all three fields are neady
of psychologists and experts with nautieal, inseparable and unchanging. They form a
ergonomie, medical, physieal and technieal unit in which each part influences the
knowledge and experienced operators, others constantly and to a high degree.
masters and pilots of ships. The differen- There is almost no chance for the crew
tiated picture of capacities and the order of members to forget their function within the
priority could be shown by a flow-diagram. working system and playanother role dur-
This would enable us to perform the im- ing their leisure time. An officer, for exam-
portant task of selection in the best (objec- pIe, is an officer in all situations and during
tive and efficient) manner possible. The his entire presence on board. His role, i. e.
different capabilities of persons could be his expected behaviour according to his
made useful in different parts of the sys- position in the hierarchy, is like an armour
tems. Furthermore this would help us to whieh he cannot leave off. This can have
observe and discover the effects of the sys- advantages and dis advantages : advantages
tem regarding men working in and depend- if he is a labile, unstable person who needs
ing on it and to control the changing of the support, dis advantages if he is a "normal"
system for the benefit of man. (in the statistieal sense), "average" person.
"Selection" can also help the candidate Psychologieal theories agree on the fact
to avoid a wrong decision and thus avoid that it is important for the mental hygiene
an unhappy, unsuccessful life at sea, and and development to change roles. If a per-
would support the efforts to reduce acci- son is denied this chance the consequences
dents and improve safety at sea. can be frustration and rigidity.
Nobody believes it to be a foolish waste Frustration leads to: aggression, regres-
of time to select according to defined stan- sion, indifference and fixation. The ability
dards of professional knowledge and skills. to tolerate frustrating situations differs
The value of health and body fitness as cri- from person to person. Accidents, siek-
teria in the selection of seamen is beyond nesses, crimes and misdeeds, quartels and
all dispute, but many of the responsible fights, hard drinking etc. are significant
people in the shipping industry hesitate to symptoms of widespread frustration.
accept mental structure as a similar criteri- The fixed working hierarchy and sched-
on. By contrast, in other industries the im- ule, the unvarying living conditions and
portance of psychological tests has been quarters, and the ever-present and never-
known for a long time and selection made changing company of other crew members
obligatory. form apressure which makes it under-
It is not my intention to go into further standable that rigid roles, with all their
details - all I want to do is, as a result of drawbacks, are chosen as a method of self-
many discussions with colleagues from dif- defence.
ferent countries, to promote the idea of se-
lection and to ask all experts for help. 2.10.2.3 Watch System
A specific factor of the working conditions
2.10.2.2 Function and Role on board is the watch system. On most
ships the watch of the deck officers is
Working and living conditions normally
4 hours twice a day in a never-changing
can be separated into (a) place of wode,
pattern:
(b) social field and (c) individual sphere.
This is applicable to most conditions Officer A: 0.00- 4.00 12.00-16.00
ashore, an exception being so-called total Officer B: 4.00- 8.00 16.00-20.00
institutions (prisons, hospitals, military Officer C: 8.00-12.00 20.00-24.00
2.10 Psychological Problems in Seafaring 155
This system stresses the physical and "negative cJimate": envy, jealousy; ten-
mental capabilities of man. It is proven that sion, discordance; quarrel, struggle, con-
working in shifts and during the night has a flicts; defamation; insecurity, uncertain-
cumulative effect with the consequence of ty; compulsion, force, constraint, pres-
a higher rate of sicknesses. This situation sure; excessive strain, tediousness, dull-
cannot be totally changed as long as ships ness; lack of organization; dissatisfac-
work for 24 hours a day. All that can be tion. lt is one of the main tasks of all
done is to test different watch systems and those responsible for the well-being of
to minimize the harmful effects by medical seafarers to reduce as many negative fac-
and psychological compensations. tors as possible.
2.10.2.4 Social Climate 2.10.2.5 "Natural" and "Artificial"
It is not an easy task to define what is Environment
called "social climate". It would be very Observing man and his environment leads
satisfying to have an all-round definition to the general sentence that man lives - to
but it is reasonable to confine the attempt state an extreme case - within two environ-
to the more pragmatic side of the problem. ments: the one is formed by "natural" con-
Trying to analyse "social climate" leads to ditions, the other by "artificial" ("techni-
the conclusion that there are at least two cal", "man-made") conditions. The "bor-
categories of psychological and sociologi- ders" are not exactly defined, because there
cal factors which are used to define it: are overlappings and mixtures of every
1. The first category is based on scientific kind. But it seems to be important to show
research and includes results of a wide the psychological difference between those
range of experiments and observations. two environments.
Some ofthese factors are: type of organi- In the natural environment, man reacts
zation, information, communication, co- to conditions as if by instinct; in the artifi-
operation, interaction, group relations, cial environment he lacks the pattern -
role functions, participation, social ad- which is replaced by the limitations of his
aptation, acceptation etc. Also part of intelligence. He must be guided, through
this category are descriptions of the in- ongoing conscious relearning of the laws
fluence of working and living conditions and mies of procedure. Frequently auto-
on board and the knowledge that a "neg- matic response replaces conscious effort as
ative" social climate decreases produc- a result of training.
tivity and activity and increases the num- Present-day ships do not belong to the
ber of accidents and sicknesses. natural environment of man. Their specific
2. The second category contains factors problems can be solved in greater part only
which express more the direction in with the aid of additional instruments and
which "social climate" should be devel- methods. The naive transposing of natural
oped. The words used are more emotion- patterns of behaviour into the technical
al and philosophical than rational and world of seafaring leads to gross oversim-
scientific. Some examples: good will, plification and apparent solutions in many
mutual help, responsibility for others, cases. The resultant feeling of security
confidence, social mind, understanding, creates an additional danger; "additional"
friendship, respect, care, compassion, because we can expect more failures within
peacableness and loyalty. In many fields the technical environment than within the
the negative form is better known than natural one.
the positive type. This is applicable to Specific laws and rules must be develop-
the social cJimate too. There are a num- ed to master the technical world - rules
ber ofwell-known factors which create a which are adapted as much as possible to
156 2 The Seafarer's Environment
human nature. Rules which are not adapt- ditioned and the reactions follow a con-
able require rational learning, sometimes stant path. A certain stimulus (for exam-
conflicting with natural patterns of behav- pIe a certain traffic situation) produces a
iour. The quality of rules and remedies de- conditioned response.
pends on the more or less successful ap- 2. Being prepared to take risks is - amongst
proximation to natural behaviour and the other things - an expression of self-confi-
more or less comprehensible, clear, simple dence and self-evaluation. This self-rating
and precise formulation and definition. shows the subjectively perceived power
Consequently, we have to find out the to cope with the problems of life; and it
borders between the natural and the artifi- is in just this part of the individual men-
cial environments, to adapt technical rem- tal structure that a relative constancy of
edies as closely as possible to human na- behaviour can be observed. Variations of
ture and to adapt man to the remainder by behaviour connected with self-confi-
suitable means and methods. dence in the direction of self-overrating
or underrating point to mental dis order
2.10.2.6 Safety and Proneness to Accidents and a psychopathological personality.
It is known that a certain mental structure 3. In situations to which the individual is
predestines a person to become involved in not (yet) adjusted, the subject tries im-
accidents, either actively as the "producer" mediately to acquire this adjustment by
or passively as the victim. If determinate self-regulation. In order to master risky
characteristic attributes appear, it would be circumstances and to react effectively, a
reasonable to check the candidate more conscious or unconscious regulation is
closely in order to prevent safety risks. The needed. This regulation of behaviour
long-term aim of the project is a contribu- strives towards the long-term aims of the
tion to aptitude tests for seafaring person- individual. It is part of the personality
nel. Some day it will probably become pos- structure. Experiments have confirmed
sible to select the "non-successful" even that this typical self-regulation lasts
before he (or she) sets foot aboard a ship. nearly continuously during the individu-
Below are set out the main theoretical al's lifetime.
considerations from which it could be con- Persons with a high accident rate do not
cluded that the "safety attitude" and the adjust their behaviour to the mIes and stan-
"risk-taking attitude" form a stable mental dards of their group easily and without
set which does not change quickly under problems. They tend to violate laws and
different influences. regulations. Very often they grew up in
1. It is common psychological knowledge families with various problems (economic
that patterns of behaviour are stable and distress, divorced parents, mental dis orders
do not alter in similar situations. Accord- and sicknesses). Ouring their time in school
ing to the behaviouristic learning theory, they faced specific difficulties: reduced
reactions are innate or learned. If they learning capacity and power of concentra-
are innate, they appear at all times in the tion, falling behind in their work, quarreis,
same or slightly modified course like in- first encounters with the police, actions
stinctive behaviour. Whether reactions contrary to an order, offering resistance,
are learned or not depends on whether penalties etc.
they are successful: Unsuccessful reac- These problems continue uninterrupted
tions more or less vanish - speaking of during their vocational career: interruption
the normal and not of the psychopath - of apprenticeships, changing of companies,
whereas successful reactions are repeat- fights and quarreis with colleagues and
edly shown. Positive reinforcement leads officers, irregularity, unpunctuality, sick-
to repetition until the individual is con- nesses etc. The devil's circle often closes
2.10 Psychological Problems in Seafaring 157
with the same problems in their own family 5. Members of two or three linguistic
as were present in their parents' family. groups are on board and have to cooper-
ate in all sectors. This is where the real
2.10.2.7 Communication on Board problems do arise, since a common basis
The existence of communication difficul- for communication has to be created.
ties caused by language barriers on board From linguistic points of view, three dif-
many ships is a well-known fact, at least to ferent levels of linguistic performance can
those concemed. Outsiders, on the other be distinguished:
hand, tend to handle these problems by 1. Level of instructionsand orders
"easy solutions". Usually their proposal is 2. Level of simplified conversation
to make the language of the country of reg- 3. Level of perfection
istry the compulsory means of communica- The differences between these levels are
tion. In reality, however, this is not always not only in the extent and complexity of
feasible. Multinational crews have become grammar and vocabulary, but also in their
an accepted feature of seafaring and efforts main sectors of application.
to overcome language barriers connected Good communication is indispensable
with this trend must be made by all con- for:
cemed. 1. The safety of the crew and vessel. Com-
Communication among crew members munication on board is not a personal
is not possible on all vessels to the same ex- matter for crewmen - it is above all nec-
tent. Five typical situations may be distin- essary to ensure the safety of all.
guished: 2. Smooth operation. All crew members
1. All crew members come from the same must possess a common basis for (verbal
country and speak the same language - and non-verbal) communication if the
their mother tongue. Communication ship is to operate smoothly.
problems do not arise, as long as all have 3. The social climate on board. Communica-
a command of nautical terminology. tion with other people is necessary if in-
2. All crew members but one speak in their dividuals are to be balanced and effi-
same mother tongue. There are bound to cient. Isolation results in mental altera-
be few communication problems, as this tions and abnormal behaviour which
linguistic outsider has to adapt quickly may have undesirable consequences.
and will do so, in order to become inte- 4. Individual satisfaction. Beyond its imme-
grated into his social surrounding. diate applicability as a means of commu-
3. On board ship there are members of dif- nication, linguistic competence can be a
ferent national groups with no common medium to achieve a more complex
mother tongue. Even in this case no ma- personality and a broader approach to
jor problems are to be expected as all life.
have to agree to the use of one common All these aspects show communication
language. Experiences on tramp vessels and language to be a vital feature of life on
have shown English to be this lingua board.
franca. It will be difficult to reach a general
4. Two or three national groups are en- agreement on the issue of who has to leam
countered aboard ship, being employed the other's language - if it should be (a) the
in different departments, types of work foreigner, who has to master the ship's lan-
etc. Generally an interpreter in a key guage, or (b) the officer, who must be able
function, e. g. as boatswain, will be a to employ the language of his foreign crew
member of the crew. Thus communica- members in order to achieve perfectly
tion causes few problems, at least in the functioning working conditions. As the
operational field. safety of all crew members is at stake, every
158 2 The Seafarer's Environment
and psychotherapeutics during long sea voy- General Situation on Board, Working and Living
ages.) Voen.-med. Zh. 9, 53-54 (1974). Conditions, Leisure-time
Dolatkowski, A., K.Dega and S.Klajman: The ef-
fect of working conditions at sea on the psycho- Aubert, V. and D.Arner: The ship as a social sys-
physiological state of seamen. In: IlI. Interna- tem. Oslo: Institute for Social Research 1962.
tional Symposium on Marine Medicine, Lenin- Backhaus, A.: Vom Leben an Bord. Physische und
grad, 1968. Moscow 1969. pp. 24-29. psychische Betreuung der Seeleute. In: Unfall-
Dolmierski, R. and J.Palubicki: Anxiety level in und Sicherheitsforschung Straßenverkehr.
seamen during sea trip. Bull. Inst. mar. trop. Kongreßbericht Jahrestagung 1981 der Dtsch.
Med. Gdynia 31, 1/2, 15-20 (1980). Ges. f. Verkehrsmed. gemeinsam m. d. Dtsch.
Dolmierski, R.: Neurosen und Verhaltensstörun- Verkehrswacht. Hamburg, 7-9 May 1981. Ed.:
gen bei Seeleuten. In: V. Internationales Sympo- Bundesanstalt f. Straßenwesen, Bereich Unfall-
sium über Schiffahrtsmedizin, 19-210ct. 1972. forschung, Köln, i. Auftrage d. Bundesministers
Rostock 1973. pp. 25-30. f. Verkehr. Braunschweig: Waisenhaus-Buch-
Dolmierski, R. and K.J. de Waiden: Ocena klinicz- druckerei 1981. pp. 107 -114.
na przyczyn samob6jstw u marynarzy. (Clinical Campailla, G.: Indagini e metodi psicologici nel
evaluation of suicides by se amen.) Psychiat. Pol. lavoro marittirno. In: Atti dei prima congresso
6,3,255-258 (1972). int. sull'assistenza di malattia e la tutela infortu-
Ejsmont, W.: Higiena pracy na statkach a stan nistica della gente dei mare nei paesi della c. e. e.
zdrowia marynarzy w Polskiej Marynarce Han- Genoa, 3-5 Oct. 1960, Vo1.2, pp. 399-402.
dlowej. (Occupational hygiene on ships and sea- Christiansen, H.: Neue Gesichtspunkte für die Un-
man's health state of the Polish Merchant Ma- terbringung der Besatzung. In: Referate und Dis-
rine). Warsaw: Panstwowy Zaklad Wydawnictw kussionsbeiträge d. Sitzung des Fachausschusses
Lekarskich 1966. "Schiffsentwurf und Schiffssicherheit" d. STG
Engelhardt, H.: Seelische Faktoren bei der See- vom 15-17 Oct. 1975. Hamburg 1975.
krankheit. Ärztl. Prax. 10,33,573-574 (1958). pp.415-430.
Grimmer, G.: Probleme der psychophysischen Ein- Dean, L. M.: The effects of shipboard living condi-
wirkungen der Seefahrt. In: V. Internationales tions upon personnel. In: International ship-
Symposium über Schiffahrtsmedizin, 19-21 Oct. board environmental design conference,
1972. Rostock 1973. pp.11-17. 21-25April 1974. Maryland: Center of adult
Haeberle, E. G.: Psychosomatische Erkrankungen education. University of Maryland. Vol. II. pp.9.
bei Seeleuten. Empirische Untersuchung aus Jakobsen, G.: Mennesket i skipssamfunnet. In:
Versicherungsdaten und einer Feldstudie an Sjofartsmedisinks forskning. Rapport fra nor-
Bord deutscher Schiffe auf See. Dissertation, disk symposium, Oslo, 16-17 June 1975. Ed.:
University of Hamburg 1979. Nordiska radet och Nordiska ministerradets
Horbulewicz, J.: From studies on the influence of sekretariat i Oslo. Stockholm: Gotab 1976.
work on the personality of man in nautical envi- pp.33-35.
ronment. BuH. Inst. mar. Med. Gdansk 17, 3, Kiryakov, Kr., P. Polonov and Ts. Kardashev:
379-381 (1966). Prouchvane varku nyakoi trudovo-meditsinksi i
Nishibe, T.: Untersuchungen über Krankheiten sotsialnopsikhologhicheski polozhenye na plav-
und Schädigungen bei Seeleuten im Hinblick auf sastavite. (Investigations of occupational medi-
die Arbeitsbedingungen. Report 5: Arbeitsbela- cal and socio-psychological situation of ships'
stung bei Seeleuten. (Summary in German from crews.) Transp. med. Vesti 18,1,1-5 (1973).
Japanese) J. Sci. Lab. 35,9,656-663 (1959). Rünger, H., W.Kleemann und E.Ingenhoven: Er-
Reimer, F.: Suizide bei jugendlichen Seeleuten. Int. gebnisse einer Befragung zur sozialen und beruf-
J. prophyl. Med. 6, 1,7-11 (1962). lichen Situation des seemännischen Personals in
Wodarg, w.: Psychische Krankheiten der Seeleute. der deutschen Seeschiffahrt. DAG-Schiffahrt 21,
Dissertation, University of Hamburg 1977. 2,2-9 (1968).
Wodarg, w.: "... auf dem Pott wird unheimlich ge- Schadewaldt, H.: Die psychische Situation des
soffen". Seefahrt 2,12-15 (1978). Menschen an Bord. Lecture. Nautischer Verein
Zorn, E.: Zur mental-hygienischen Problematik bei Lübeck 10.3.1977.
Seeleuten. Arbeitsmed. Sozialmed. Präventiv- Tenfjord, O. w.: The personal and family implica-
med. 15,7,166-168 (1980). tion of being a seaman. Lecture. International
Zorn, E.: Alkoholkonsum an Bord. In: Verkehrs- Christian Maritime Assoc.
medizin. Probleme in der See- und Binnenschiff- Tkachenko V. D. and S. T. Hramtsova: Questions of
fahrt. Hamburg 11-13 April 1975, pp.7-16. psychology and sociology in the commercial
fleet. In: VII. International symposium on ma-
rine medicine, Odessa, 23-30 Sept. 1976. Mos-
cow 1976. pp. 297-298.
Stiewe. M.: Die Freizeit der Seeleute an Bord in der
2.10 Psychological Problems in Seafaring 161
Hochseefischerei. Verk.-Med. 18, 8, 345-355 Jensen, H.-J., H. Studt and W Fink: Das zukünftige
(1971). Schiff und seine Besatzung. Ed.: Verband
Zorn, E.: Rekreationsmöglichkeiten in der See- Deutscher Reeder. Hamburg 1976.
fahrt. Lecture. 11. Internationales verkehrsmedi- Schepers, B.-F.: Auswirkung der Besatzungsreduk-
zinisches Kolloquium. Hamburg 1971. tion auf die Belastungssituation des Seemannes,
Zorn, E.: Freizeitgestaltung und Rekreation an Aspekte auf das "Schiff der Zukunft" und seine
Bord von Schiffen. In: V. Internationales Sym- Besatzung. In: Unfall- und Sicherheitsforschung
posium über Schiffahrtsmedizin, 19-210ct. Straßenverkehr, Kongreßbericht Jahrestagung
1972. Rostock 1973. pp. 355-361. 1981 der Dtsch. Ges. f. Verkehrsmed. gemeinsam
m. d. Dtsch. Verkehrswacht. Hamburg, 7-9 May
Selection 1981. Ed.: Bundesanstalt f. Straßenwesen, Be-
Böhm, H.: Psychische Anforderungen an die reich Unfallforschung, Köln, i. Auftrage d. Bun-
Führung von Seeschiffen. Arbeitsgruppe "Psy- desministers f. Verkehr. Braunschweig: Waisen-
chische Probleme der Schiffsführung". d. Dtsch. haus-Buchdruckerei 1981. pp. 37-41.
Gesellsch. f. Ortung u. Navigation e. V. Sitzung, Schadewaldt, H.: Der Mensch an Bord. Schiffahrt
9 Nov. 1973. international 6, 273-280 (1974).
Boganelli, E.: Orientamento e selezione psicotecni- Talkenberger, W-D.: Probleme der Arbeitsorgani-
ca dei marittimi. In: Atti dei Centro Studi e sation und der Entwicklung der Arbeits- und le-
ricerche per l'assistenza sanitaria e sociale dei bensbedingungen auf teilautomatisierten Schif-
marittimi pp. 122-126 (1959). fen des VEB DeutfrachtiSeereederei. Verk.-
Dolmierski, R. and 1. Nitka: Analysis ofthe reasons Med. 22, 8/9, 323-330 (1975).
for subjecting officers of the Polish merchant
Safety
marine to psychophysiological examination.
Bull. Inst. mar. trop. Med. Gdynia, 30, 2, Böhm, H.: Seafarers and safety - an experimental
123-125 (1979). approach. Lecture. Meeting on "Marine traffic".
Zorn, E.: Das Problem der psychischen Eignung Liverpool, April 1978.
für den Seefahrtsberuf. Kehrwieder 21, 8,9-10 Soerhaug, H.-Chr.: Social science and research on
(1977). safety at sea. Lecture. Symposium "Safety of life
at sea". Oslo, 20-21 Oct. 1980. Research program
Future Ships Reduced ManninglAutomation
associated with The Royal Norwegian Council
Bey, H.-P.: Gedanken zur menschlichen Isolation for Scientific and Industrial Research. (System
an Bord. ESSO-Reporter 2, 7-8 (1976). for Sikkert Skip).
2.11 Psychological Aspects of Work-load on Board
N.Ohashi
r--::::-
e::
e:: '"
.- E
25
'"
(f)
~
~'>
o e::
.r::. W
uCi
"O~
._ :::J
0.-
o 0
"" e::
-Z:-
'0-
"Oe::
w
w E
:5 6
'O.~ -----..
e:: e:: (f) e::
0'"
:';::0)
:::J
0.-
0
:::J-
Oe:: e:: 0
E'-
0-'"
.- E
-0
U ~ e:: U (f)
0 0 8g "0
e::
-
-"3
'"0.
'"
.'" - "Oe::'"
-",DU
U
~ e::
o o~.~
3- ~
-
(f)
o '"
",wo.
.r::.
f- = '"
~ x
.~6
-'" "0
o 0
:.~
o t:'
.~ ~
a:;.r::.
'" -.>
CL ""
tori [7] performed a trial study on psycho- this analysis. Each card had an item ex-
logical factors ofthe work-Ioad ofseafarers pressing seafarers' awareness, attitude,
and their inter-relationships, analysing the evaluation ofwork-life, career, occupation-
results by means of the so-called K.l. al circumstances and so on. These items
method (Kawakita liro, problem solving were adopted from the data which had
method, [10]). been obtained and filed from the various
Approximately 400 cards (hereafter re- past researches (Morikiyo et al. [1]; Ohashi
ferred to as the Card Group) were used in [2]; Ohashi and Hirota [8]; Ohashi and
164 2 The Seafarer's Environment
1 1
Continuous
exposure 10 noise Limited activity Pitch ing an d Risk from Rapid changes
and vibralion space rolling the elements in climate
Heavy workload
Inadequate due to
accommodation for noise, vibration
private use and heat
~
Inadequate Sudden changes ~
accommodalion for work environment
common use from one occasion
to anolher
I Easy 10 !I
produce faligue
I Hard 10 recover I
from faligue
Fig.2. Work-load factors and their inter-relationships, related to the environment and the accommodation
Morikiyo [9]), such as research carried out mous (external determination of work)
on board, questionnaire surveys and inter- and seems like a 24-hour working day.
view surveys (Ohashi and Aoki [5]; Ohashi The authors found that the basic reason
et al. [6]). Most ofthe content, expression or why the work has such characteristics is
wording of items was made by seafarers the locomotion of the daily working en-
themselves. vironment (movement of the ship). Fur-
thermore, this locomotion is a slow and
2.11.2 Psychological Factors of continuous process over a long time and
Work-load and their far from the ordinary human living
space ashore. This is the paramount fac-
Interaction tor which sets the pattern of seafarers'
1. Work-loadJactors and their inter-relation- work. The items listed in Fig.1 can be
ships, related to the characteristics oJ the considered as work-Ioad factors.
work on board. The result is shown in 2. Work-loadJactors and their inter-relation-
Fig.1. However, items related to labour ships, related to the environment and ac-
conditions in a narrow sense or to a par- commodation. Items related to the envi-
ticular shipping company have been ex- ronment and accommodation were with-
cluded. As shown in the figure, seafarers' drawn from the Card Group and sorted,
work ranges widely from difficult to with some slight generalization. The re-
easy, depends greatly on experience, is sults are shown in Fig. 2. The study of the
subject to considerable variation, in- relationship between the items listed is
volves marked changes in work pressure not comprehensive and there may be
and energy expenditure, is heterono- some additional items that should have
2.11 Psychological Aspects of Work-load on Board 165
Continuous confinement
for 24 hours 0 day
Minimized number of
Group without or
crew cannot afford
with few women
spore mon power
Limited variety
of leisure activity
Limited range of
obtainable information
Fig.3. Work-load factors and their inter-relationships, related to continuously restricted living conditions
been inc1uded. However, it is clearly in- ty hours in the genuine sense of the terms
dicated that a decisive factor is the 10- only when they are signed off from a
comotion of the daily working environ- ship. This indicates the importance and
ment. Under such circumstances, when necessity of their paid leaves.
sufficient consideration has not neces- Figure 4 shows another result of analysis
sarily been paid to accommodation, the of the correlation between these factors.
work-Ioad factors increase. The item "Cannot enjoy meals" in Figs. 3
3. Work-loadfactors and their inter-relation- and 4 was further analysed to clarify the
ships, related to continuous restricted liv- reasons for this condition, as shown in
ing conditions (confinement). The result is Fig.5. Some elements with a probable
shown in Fig.3. The effect of 24 hours' bearing on the reason, however, such as
confinement is not, of course, limited to environmental factors like "Rapid
the items shown in the figure and various changes in climate", were not included.
other significant effects are also pro- Nevertheless, it is clear that various fac-
duced. If the generalization is possible, it tors affect adversely the enjoyment of
can be concluded that confinement meals. Another example is shown in
creates difficulties for seafarers in their Fig. 6.This gives a result of analysis on
sociallife. Also, the figures indicate that the item "Limited range of obtainable in-
seafarers can have rest hours and off-du- formation". It is clear how various sorts
166 2 The Seafarer's Environment
'"'"
Cl>
'"'"ev
c:""" c:
'" c:
o=> '"
~
'"
=>
.2-
·ü "'C u
",ev
c:
'"
c: c:
0 c: E
o 0-
u~
u '" o
""0 '" ""Cl.
c: ev
eu
c: -
v:; 0
0'"
.!:::-
V) 0
SJ!dOI JO
~la!JOA pallWll
'"s::
~pnls 01 PJOH I .~
:.as::
0
(,)
>->
v;
I daals po05 la5 01 PJOH I ::l
0
::l
.5
C
0
AI!A!PO aJnS!al jO (,)
~la!JOA pal!W!l .8
"0
~
'E
5u!laaj aw04 10 ON I '"
....
0
t)
~
c
11)
saw!I 110 10 IUasaJd 11)
~
s,aldoad Ja410 10 'd:i
..0
snopsuoJ aq 01 alloH s::
0
.~
Q)
....
sloaw Ao[ua 10UUOJ I ....
0
u
-<i
AI!WOI WOJj paIOIOS! I ~
fi:
offactors contribute to limiting the range and attitudes of seafarers to their work
of information obtainable, and this also and lives were analysed. Some of these
creates more and different work-Ioad items have not been used in this article
factors . so far, but of course they may be useful
4. Other work-foadJactors, inc/uding the dis- for understanding the work-load of sea-
satisJaction oJ seaJarers with their work farers as related to a particular company
and fife. As mentioned before, approxi- or the society in general. As an example,
mately 400 items concerning awareness Fig.7 demonstrates work-load factors re-
2.11 Psychological Aspects orWork-load on Board 167
~ CZl
(1)
~
IStrong consciousness 01 rank, I
class and section I>l
:E ;>
o
i?" ~~
'"
[ 1 [
;> 1 Hard to obtain (3
A Hard to obtain required 11 I d t t 1
o accurate inlormation inlormation on one' s no eq ua e. amoun
.;;1 on time own initiative 01 Inlormatlon S
(1)
S' g
Q.
&.
~. !
Limited range 01 obtainable inlormation I
So
(1)
e: !
'"'"
~. Inadequate acquisition 01 new Difficully In under- Inadequate
;> Difficully in
g. knowledge and technology (poor standing the lamily Difficully in information on Liable to get Limited variety
making objective
o training in refresher courses and/ situation. (Lack of enjoying life other industries / narrow minded 01 topics
::l decisions
o or lack 01 other inlormation) news tram home) employment
-,
'"(1)
I>l
;>
a 1
1 Fear of becoming Fears regarding Fears regarding
~ out-ot-date on future employment, luture occupational
So technology destabilization career os sealarer
!!1 •
...
~ Fig.6. Factors limiting the range ofinformation obtainable
~
§
0..
:;:::.
(1)
'"
~
E
'"
~O"> U In
=> e:
'0
'"
,-
-""'" "0
'"'"
~E ;> '"
e:e: Cl>
.t=
U "
'0">
00 ~~ .§ ~ 0"> c:
U) - :;:
0">' - "'",0 E:§ ~ f3.9- 0
c:: _ 0
'". _
Q.)-
'" '"
g~:e 'i::: c..c ~-gc;
.9- '-
§0.t=C) =~gEVl
:e:
: '"
0 > ~.s E
a; V) E Ci V) CI -co
0. _ 0"> e: Cl."C 'E z
o >< e: ..t:::=._ C ' - - 'E :Ei c:
c::l 0:'= V10-~O ~ 0._
L..) '" 0
I~he environmen1 01
o ship is lhe se<!
t
Conlinuoos
limiled oclivily Pitching Qnd Risk lrom Rapid chonges
exposure 10 noise
spoce rOlling nolure in clirnole
ond vibralioo
r
"
Conlinuous confinemenl
Impossible to leove
Ihe workshOp spoc~
/ Minimized number 01
Group wilhoul or
crew cannot olford
with tew wamen
Limited chance
spore monpower
Li<lble to form on
-
10 ossociole unstoble ond
wilh women smoli gfOUp
-
Iram work-ploce and res t hours
I
Limiled voriety Lirnited No
fsolated Hard 10 gel Monalonaus Hard
of leisure voriety 01 horne
!rom lamily good sleep aclivity doily lile 10 study 01 topics feel ing
~
InodeQuofe
occommodolion for
private use
InodeQuote Hord to recover I
accommodolion for Irom foligue
'\
common use
~
living spoce
- / "-
Sociel isolation Spotiol isolation Rapid changes in
/ "-
nalural environment
I
Personnel replacement
I
Supply 01 technology.
reintorcement materi ol ond
is dilficull information is difticult Heovy worklood
due 10 noise.
~L vibro tion ond heGt
vjOW 0'
Strang cansciousness of rank,]
-
closs ond department
V "'
""ob;';',
I mochine systems
The work hos a Operating schedute
Feeling of working The work depends
wide ronge trom ,hip I, ,,",",
2t hours in 0 day ditficu lt to eosy greatty on experience tighter
~I
lhe Seomen low is insuffieienl os
the 10'111 01 lobour proteclion
the remaining items should also have 4.0hashi, N. and S.Aoki: Shinei Kosokusen ni
been analysed further. okeru Seikatsu to Shudankino no Kanren ni
tsuite. (Work and life of seafarers on the most
Analyses of work-Ioad factors by this
advanced ship). (Japanese) In: Report of Mari-
method should be developed and estab- time Labour Research institute. Tokyo 1975.
lished as one of the effective methods of pp 1-82.
describing the work-Ioad situations as fully 5.0hashi, N. and S.Aoki: Nihon Yusen Sen' in
as possible to ensure further progress in Iken Chosa. (Attitude and consciousness of
NYK seafarers to their work, life, and com-
future studies. pany). (Japanese). NYK Special Report. S.Mi-
Work-Ioad factors on board are numer- hara (ed) Tokyo 1976. pp 1-179.
ous and their interrelationship is quite 6.0hashi, N., S.Aoki and A.Hattori: Sen' in no
complicated, as these figures have shown Seikatsu Taiyo to Ishiki Chosa. (Attitude and
consciousness of deep sea trade seafarers to
so far. These work-Ioad factors should be
their actual living and working conditions).
reduced as soon as possible to provide bet- (Japanese) Report of Nihon Kaigi Kyokai, To-
ter working and living conditions on board kyo 1975. pp 1-218.
for seafarers, to make their occupation 7.0hashi, N. and A.Hattori: Kaijo Rodo no To-
more attractive and to improve important kushusei ni motozuku Rodo no Hyokaho ni
kansuru Yobiteki Kenkyu. (A preliminary anal-
aspects of health and safety. ysis of work-load factors and their mutual rela-
tionship). (Japanese) In: Report of Maritime
Labour Research Institute. Tokyo 1982.
pp 1-49.
References 8.0hashi, N. and Y.Hirota: Mental strain of a
ship manoeuvrer. In: Proc. 16th Int. Congr.
1. Morikiyo, Y., N.Ohashi and H.Iida: Verbal Occup. Health. H. Kita (ed) Tokyo 1969.
communication in human information process· pp 419-420.
ing for ship manoeuvring. J. human Ergology 1, 9.0hashi, N. and Y. Morikiyo: Differences in
129-142 (1972). human information processing for ship
2.0hashi, N.: Designed and real working situa· manoeuvring in the daytime and at night. J. hu-
tions in machine systems operation. J. human man Ergology 3, 29-43 (1974).
Ergology 5, 187-193 (1976).
3. Ohashi, N.: Life and work of seafarers on an
Addendum
ocean going container vessel. (Japanese) 1. Jap. 10. Kawakita, 1.: Tbe original KJ method. Kawaki-
appl. Psych. 1,17-38 (1978). ta Research Institute (ed) Tokyo 1983.
3 The Pathology of the Seafarer
3.1 The Occurrence, Frequency and Aetiology
of Diseases and Trauma Among Seamen
P. Vuksanovic and W. H. G. Goethe
3.1.1 Factors Which May Affect the recuperative capacity, particularly when
Health of Seamen they occur during the sleeping time.
Poor illumination, insufficient ventila-
3.1.1.1 Macroclimate, Microclimate and
tion and, amongst other things, chemical
Other Load Factors
fumes caused by work materials and dang-
Modem technology enables ships to sail at erous cargo create a potentially adverse ef-
high speed and thus pass through different fect on the health of seamen.
climatic zones within a very short time. The The ship's movement is a special load
consequent rapid climatic changes may af- factor. It not only causes motion sickness in
fect the physical and mental health of sea- sensitive persons but also represents a
men considerably. Sud den temperature stress factor for crew members by reducing
changes, combined with more or less high the depth of sleep because of the unavoid-
degrees of air humidity, wind, rain, fog, able muscular compensatory movements.
strong solar radiation and other macrocli- It is considered that 95% of seafarers suffer
matic factors, have a greater effect on once, or even several times, from motion
board seagoing vessels than elsewhere. In sickness, if only when starting service on
spite of all the technical facilities, the mac- board, irrespective of the fact that motion
roclimate also has a big influence on the sickness does not appear as a disease in the
microclimate on board. Seamen work and statistics of distribution of diagnoses.
live on board within a most restricted space
and with an alm ost isolated environment. 3.1.1.2 Working Time
When there are extremely high exterior Crew members work partly under abnor-
temperatures and humidity, the microcli- mal physiological conditions. On board
mate on board, particularly in the engine modem ships, heavy work is rare but on
rooms of older ships, is adversely affected. many older vessels such duty is still un-
Also, climatic conditions in the living quar- avoidable, especially in connection with re-
ters of those ships without (or with insuffi- pair work in the engine room. The recu-
cient) air conditioning lead to a consider- perative capacity is, moreover, addition-
able reduction of the recuperative capacity ally reduced by multifactorial environmen-
of crew members. This mayaiso happen on tal loads, resulting in a total load which
board modem ships with efficient air con- is much higher than the original work-
ditioning under extreme macroclimatic load.
conditions. A further stress factor for some crew
Noise and, particularly, vibration may be members is watchkeeping, which, in prac-
stress factors not only in the engine rooms tice, is the oldest form of shiftwork. The ro-
but also on the bridge and other work- tating three-watch system, with 4 h on duty
pi aces and in the living quarters. These fac- and 8 hoff, guarantees longer times of rest,
tors may increase the psycho-physicalload, whereas the two-watch system, with 12 h
resulting in a considerable reduction of the duty per 24 h is highly demanding with re-
176 3 The Pathology ofthe Seafarer
spect to health. This particularly affects longed to the most frequent diseases of sea-
older seafarers. men and scurvy and beriberi were terrify-
ing diseases aboard ships.
3.1.1.3 Socio-psychological Factors The physical work-load, and thus the re-
According to former investigations the av- quirement for energy, have now been con-
erage seaman spends 20% of his working siderably reduced. Combined with over-
life at home with the family and 80% fee ding, this leads to health disorders, such
aboard his ship. This may still apply to as obesity, diabetes, arteriosc1erosis and
many maritime countries. Only in the in- cardiovascular diseases. Additional dis-
dustrial maritime countries and some other turbing and not exceptional factors are, un-
shipping countries with a highly developed fortunately, abuses of alcohol, coffee, tea
social system is the duty on board restricted and tobacco and the consumption of too
in favour of more spare time ashore. Thus cold drinks, which has an adverse effect on
it is thought that seamen spend two-thirds the gastro-intestinal tract.
of their working life on board and one-
third ashore (inc1uding holidays and all 3.1.1.5 Other Factors
other days off). In the United States this re- Doctors who, because of their specific
lationship is 1: 1. medical education and motivation, are pos-
During his leisure time aboard, the sea- itively influencing general health standards
farer is alm ost isolated from all social on ships have become rare nowadays. In
events ashore as nowadays the turnround most maritime countries, only passenger
time in ports is generally very short and is vessels, some cargo ships with very large
still being reduced in the so-called quick crews, fish processing and fishing protec-
ports. Turnround times from 1 to 2 days tion ships and research or similar special
down to only a few hours are, in fact, not vessels still carry a doctor.
exceptional. Because of their heavy work- Most seafarers world-wide are likely to
load aboard, many crew members then be employed on vessels without a ship's
have no time to go ashore. doctor. Appropriate courses of medical in-
The continuous modernisation in ship- struction for nautical officers who are in
building has altered the seafarer's life con- charge of medical care on board, no doubt,
siderably. The ship's automation has re- contribute much towards better health
leased the crew members from heavy standards on board. An officer with insuffi-
physical work, but has simultaneously in- cient medical knowledge cannot render ef-
creased the mental load. The additional ficient help in emergency cases. In extreme
standardisation of working procedures cases this may be fatal. It has often been
aboard has allowed a large reduction of noticed that, particularly on board vessels
crews. There is also a high personnel turn of developing countries or those sailing un-
over which was formerly unknown. Instead der flags of convenience, this officer has
of a permanent crew having some kind of very scant medical knowledge.
family relationship, nowadays there is a
heterogeneous crew in a multifactorial 3.1.2 General Characteristics of
sense, resulting in an unfavourable socio- Diseases in Seamen
logical and psychological environment on
board. Vuksanovic, in his epidemiological study
[26], analysed the diseases of approximate-
3.1.1.4 Nutrition ly 8000sick Yugoslav seamen within a pe-
Formerly, partial or absolute malnutrition riod of 10 years. Port workers served as a
directly affected the health of seafarers. control group. The study showed the fol-
Undernutrition and avitaminosis then be- lowing result: The average age of sick sea-
3.1 The Occurrence, Frequency and Aetiology of Diseases and Trauma Among Seamen 177
(Vuksanovit and Goethe [27]). Most prob- orders of this kind. Other diseases of the
ably there is a large additional number of nervous system are rare.
unrecognised mental disorders which are Diseases of the eyes are not specific in
diagnosed and classified only according to seafaring. Nevertheless, pterygium is some-
their somatic symptoms. In an epidemio- times diagnosed, particularly in seamen
logical study on Yugoslav seamen, Vuksa- from Asia and in fishermen, although the
novit [26] came to the conclusion that the total number of cases is not very high in the
rate of mental disorders was significantly distribution of diagnoses. Many seamen
higher than among the population ashore. complain of hearing disorders due to the
Young seamen with no seafaring experi- high noise levels on board vessels. The en-
ence and insufficient adaptability to the en- gine room staff are specially affected. Im-
vironment on board are the most predis- pairment of hearing capacity is not exclu-
posed to psychoses and neuroses. There sive to the engine personnel but is found in
has been an increasing world-wide tenden- some deck workers and radio officers too
cy to mental disorders during the past (Goethe et al. [12]). Hearing disorders are
20 years, the deck personnel showing high- not obvious from the statistical data as,
er rates than the engine room staff (Carev presumably, they are in most cases not per-
and Sokec [5]). ceived or indicated as a disease. Hardness
In this connection the problem of alco- of hearing due to noise is an occupational
holism is frequently considered. Naturally, disease subject to an award only in mari-
alcohol consumption varies according to time countries with a highly developed so-
national and cultural habits, but Carev and cial security system.
Sokec [5] emphasise that seamen seem
more inclined to alcohol abuse than the 3.1.4.7 Diseases of the Circulatory System
average population ashore. Last but not (VII)
least the special situation of seafarers These diseases are found in eighth place in
may be considered a reason for mental dis- the international statistics (4.8%) (Vuksa-
orders. novit and Goethe [27]). Myocardial infarc-
tion and other ischaemic cardiac diseases
3.1.4.6 Diseases of the Nervous System are predominantly diagnosed in older sea-
and the Sense Organs (VI) farers, especially in masters and ships' offi-
In the international distribution of diag- cers, who have a high load of responsibili-
noses, these diseases are represented with ty, and, of course, in sea pilots. Zorn [32]
5.7% (Vuksanovit and Goethe [27]). It is found that myocardial infarction was re-
very difficult to classify the individual diag- sponsible for 51 % of the deaths among sea
noses within this heterogeneous group (it pilots in the age group 41-50 years in Ham-
includes diseases of the eyes and ears as burg between 1945 und 1973.
weH as the different diseases ofthe nervous The death rate of sea pilots in this age
system). Some of the cases of myalgia and/ group amounted to 2.66%0, whereas the
or lumbo-ischialgia may be classified either rate of the comparable group of the male
under this group or under group XIII (dis- population in Hamburg was only 0.63%0.
eases of the musculoskeletal system and Ejsmont [7] reports similar findings. Fedele
connective tissue). Lumbo-ischialgia and [9] came to the conclusion in his extensive
similar disorders of the nervous system are study that more than 80% of ischaemic car-
extremely frequent in seafaring. Heavy diac diseases occurred on the sea. Cardi
physical work under unfavourable condi- and Puddu [4] also worked on the impor-
tions (motion of the sea, engine repairs in tance of cardiovascular diseases on board,
restricted space, work on deck under unfa- and found that varicose veins are often a
vourable climatic influences) leads to dis- problem, particularly with the catering
3.1 The Occurrence, Frequency and Aetiology of Diseases and Trauma Among Seamen 181
staff. Mundal et al. [33] and Rodahl [34] coffee and tea, and consumption of too
found that the risk of coronary heart dis- cold drinks in hot zones;
ease among Norwegian ship captains and 6. Monotony in nutrition;
officers was considerably higher than in a 7. Dental caries, partieularly in the seamen
comparable population ashore. of some countries ;
8. Uncontrolled intake of medieaments.
3.1.4.8 Diseases of the Respiratory System Dental disorders naturally represent a
(VIII) big problem among seamen. According to
Trunov et al. [24], 92.7% of examined sea-
These diseases are in third place in the
men suffered from dental caries, while
morbidity statistics, with 11.2% (Vuksano-
Zannini and Tortori-Donati [31] found a
vic and Goethe [27]). Predominantly the
rate of95%.
deck personnel are exposed to adverse
macroc1imatic conditions and so the sick- 3.1.4.10 Diseases of the Genito-urinary
ness rate is higher than in the engine room System (X)
staff.
These diseases, with 3.5%, are in ninth
place in the total morbidity of seamen
3.1.4.9 Diseases of the Digestive System
(Vuksanovic and Goethe [27]). They show a
(IX)
rising tendency. Deck staff are affected
Diseases of the digestive system (15.7%) most frequently, possibly owing to the in-
are in second place in the morbidity statis- fluence of macroc1imatie factors.
tics, behind accidents. Nearly an nautieal In many cases, ureter and kidney stones
medieal experts throughout the world are are found. It is known that these diseases
aware of the fact that these diseases repre- often appear in tropical zones because of
sent a considerable problem among sea- insufficient fluid intake and this obviously
men. Statistieal morbidity data show that in applies to seamen as wen. According to
some countries the rate even reaches 30% different authors (Chmielewski et al. [6];
(Vuksanovic [26]). It was found that gastri- Pellegrinelli [22]; Arduini and Rizzo [1]),
tis and ulcers were chiefly represented. typieal stones account for up to 60% of all
Laba [18] and Gras and Parodi [14] diseases within this group.
found that young seamen fall ill more fre-
quently from these diseases. Several au- 3.1.4.11 Diseases of the Skin
thors came to the conc1usion that gastric or and Subcutaneous Tissue (XII)
duodenal ulcers are more often diagnosed These diseases (5.4%) are in sixth place in
in seamen than in the average population the morbidity structure (Vuksanovic and
ashore. Watt [29] speaks of the "sailor's Goethe [27]). They show a slightly falling
stomach". tendency, most probably owing to im-
The fonowing aetiologieal factors are proved general and personal hygiene on
considered as perhaps significant here: board.
1. Kinetic load from the ship's motion Contact dermatoses are very frequent
(kinetosis, fatigue); skin diseases among seamen, presumably
2. Noise and vibration as wen as other load being caused by chemieal work materials
factors such as macro- and microc1i- and additives in oil and lubricants as wen
mate; as by detergents as used by the catering
3. Work under abnormal physiological staff. Allergie reactions to detergents are al-
conditions and lack of recreation on so found in the deck staff.
board; Fishermen world-wide suffer from skin
4. Mental stress; diseases caused by contact with salt water
5. Abuses of stimulants such as alcohol, while working with nets during fish pro-
182 3 The Pathology ofthe Seafarer
Bremerhaven: Wirtschaftsverlag NW 1979. lavora nei porti e sul mare. Lav. e Med. 16,
(Forschungsbericht 201). 31-35 (1962).
13. Goethe, H., E.Zorn, RHerrmann et a!.: Die 23. Trapp, E.: Die Morbidität in der Handelsschiff-
psycho-physische Belastung des Personals fahrt. Verk.-Med. 13,4-5,174-185 (1966).
moderner Seeschiffe als aktuelles Problem der 24. Trunov, J.I., N. V. Pavlov, L. M. Shafran et a!.:
Schiffahrtsmedizin. Zb!. Bakt. I. Abt. Orig. B Analysis of stomatological morbidity among
166,1,1-36 (1978). seamen and its prophylaxis. Bull. Inst. mar.
14. Gras, G. and V.Parodi: Relievi clinico-statistici trop. Med. Gdynia 25, 236-240 (1974).
sull'ulcera gastroduodenale nei marittirni. Lav. 25. Vuksanovic, P.: Najcesce bolesti pomoraca.
e Med. 5, 1, 8 pp. (1951). (Most frequent illnesses of seamen) In: Po-
15. Jovic-Paskvalin, L., V. Prpic and V. Furlan: Dia- morska medicina 11 (Naucne rasprave) Beo-
betes mellitus u pomoraca (Diabetes mellitus grad: Izdanje Mornarickog glasnika 1979. pp.
among sailors). In: Pomorska medicina 11 297 -302. (Pomorska biblioteka 30).
(Naucne rasprave) Beograd: Izdanje Morna- 26. Vuksanovic, P.: Uticaj savremene plovidbe na
rickog glasnika 1979. pp.311-314 (Pomorska strukturu morbiditeta jugoslovenskih pomora-
biblioteka 30). ca (epidemioloska studija) [lnfluence of mod-
16. Körbler, J.: Bolest rak kod pomoraca (Can- em seafaring on the morbidity structure of
cer among sailors) In: Pomorska medi- Yugoslavian seamen - (an epidemiological
cina (Naucne rasprave) Beograd: Izdanje study)] Dissertation, University of Sarajevo
Mornarickog glasnika 1975. pp. 439-444. 1981.
(Pomorska biblioteka 26). 27. Vuksanovic, P. and H. Goethe: Diseases and ac-
17. Komarov, EJ., L.E.Poljakov and D.P.Zui- cidents among seamen - an international com-
khin: The methods of studying the morbidity of parison of distribution of diagnoses. Bull. Inst.
sailors in navigations. In: VII Int. Symp. on mar. trop. Med. Gdynia 33, 112, 13-33 (1982).
Marine Medicine, 23-30 Sept. 1976 Odessa. 28. Vuksanovic, P.: Primjena epidemioloskih meto-
Moscow 1976. p.254. da u pomorskoj medicini. (Application of ep-
18. Laba, L.: Some chronic diseases ofthe alimen- idemiologie investigations in nautical medi-
tary tract in sailors in the light of periodic health cine). Pomorski zbornik 12, 593-599 (1974).
examinations. Bull. Inst. mar. Med. Gdansk 11, 29. Watt, J.: The sailor's stornach. J. roy. nav. med.
112,21-27 (1960). Servo 58,1,12-34 (1972).
19. Molfino, E: Le malattie della gente dei mare. 30. Westphal, O. R: Magenerkrankungen bei See-
(Aspetti etiologici, clinici, preventivi ed assi- leuten. Bull. Inst. mar. Med. Gdansk 17, 3,
stenziali). Dagli atti del primo congresso intern. 257-262 (1966).
sull'assistenza di malattia e la tutela infortuni- 31. Zannini, D. and B. Tortori-Donati: Rilievi sulla
stica della gente dei mare nei paesi della c. e. e. morbilit!l dei marittimi in navigazione. Lav. e
Genova, Napoli, Trieste: Casse marittime per Med. 14, 5, 88-95 (1960).
gli infortuni sullavoro e la malattie 1960. 32. Zorn, E.: Beiträge zur Berufsbelastung und
20. Mohar, N., F. Grober and A. Wolf: Dijagnostika kardialen Mortalität der Seelotsen von
i lijeeenje spolnih bolesti u pomoraca. (Diagno- 1945-1973. Hamburg 1976.
sis and cure of venereal diseases of seamen).
Pomorska medicina 11 (Naucne rasprave) Beo- Addendum
grad: Izdanje Mornarickog glasnika 1979. 33. Mundal, R, J.Erikssen and K.Rodahl: Latent
pp.335-338. (Pomorska biblioteka 30). ischaemic heart disease in sea captains. Scand. J.
21. Oliver, P. 0.: A study of the causes of medical Work environ. Hlth 8, 178-184 (1982).
attendance aboard British Merchant ships. 34. Rodahl, K.: Arbeitsstress til sjös. Ed.: Norges
Pub!. Hlth (Lond.) 95, 74-81 (1981). Teknisk-N aturvitenskapelige Forskningsgräd.
22. Pellegrinelli, G.: La medicina al servizio di chi Oslo 1980. (System for Sikkert Skip).
3.2 Accidents in Seafaring
P. Vuksanovic and W. H. G. Goethe
3.2.1 Frequency and Aetiology doubt increases the hazards. Work in the
of Accidents engine room, particularly repair work and
the handling of engine parts, sometimes
Occupational accidents were at the top of during severe movement of the ship, is as-
the list of morbidity rates in arecent inter- sociated with a higher accident risk. A large
national comparison (Vuksanovic and number of accidents are caused by the han-
Goethe [24]). Numerous authors have pub- dling of ropes, hoists and cargo-lifting
lished statistical data on the frequency of equipment. Environmental factors such as
accidents on ships and on their occurrence noise, vibration, insufficient illumination
and aetiology during recent decades. Fleets and dust are additional risks.
belonging to different countries show acci- The mental stress due to the monotony
dent rates from 10% to 30%, while in some oflife at sea and its physical manifestations
maritime countries accidents reached 50% is an important cause of accidents. No
of all diagnoses in seamen. Fortunately ac- doubt, alcohol is involved in a large num-
cidents in seafaring have shown a tendency ber of accidents, but it is difficult to trace
to decrease in number (Vuksanovic and any reliable data. The number of concealed
Goethe [24]). cases may be rather high (Vrcelj [22]).
Normally, seamen suffer less from acci- Poisoning caused by dangerous cargo
dents than do labourers ashore. Neverthe- and chemical work materials play a special
less, the mortality of injured seamen due to role in the causation of accidents. It is
accidents is 5 to 7 times higher than that of rather surprising that the number of acci-
the labourers ashore. Fishermen gene rally dents caused by chemical work materials
show a high er rate of accidents than other (such as acids, solvents and detergents) is
seafarers. A study over 7 years by Goethe considerably high er than that of the acci-
and Vuksanovic [6] concluded that the rate dents caused by dangerous cargo (Schepers
of accidents is twice as high among fisher- [19]).
men as among merchant seamen. Vrcelj
[22] investigated very thoroughly the aetiol-
ogy of accidents among seamen. According 3.2.2 Occupational Accidents
to his findings, the age of seamen and the in Seafaring According to
type and size of vessels play an important Different Parameters
role. The smaller and older a ship is, the
more accidents are registered. Accidents 3.2.2.1 Age
are most frequent among young seamen Most ofthe injuries occur in young se amen
beginning seagoing duties. Causative fac- up to 25 years of age (Vrcelj [22]). The acci-
tors may be the ship's motion caused by dents are obviously due to the as yet poor
rough sea, a deck made slippery by spilled adaptation to the work and life on board.
cargo, ice or rain, snow, bad vision etc. The Furthermore, young people take more risks
load caused by macroclimatic changes no than older persons. However, according to
3.2 Accidents in Seafaring 185
Dimitrov [2] seamen of advanced age the ship. These are the so-called passage-
groups are more accident pro ne than mid- way accidents.
dle-aged seamen. In a study by Vuksano-
viC [25] dealing with occupational accidents 3.2.2.4 Injured Body Parts
of seamen the average age of injured crew In recent decades numerous authors have
members is 30.5 years while that ofthe con- been eoneemed with the subject of which
trol group of injured labourers ashore is body parts were more frequently injured
32.5 years. The difference is statistically sig- (Dolatkowski et al. [3]; Giannieo and Tor-
nificant. tori-Donati [5]; Puskeiler and Kersten [16];
Ejsmont and Filipek [4]; Moore [13]; Dimi-
3.2.2.2 Period of Duty on Board trov [2]; Vrcelj [22]; Vuksanovic [25]; Cro-
vari [1]; Tortori-Donati [20]). Nearly all of
It can be shown that se amen are most fre-
them came to the eonclusion that the upper
quently injured at the start oftheir seagoing
extremities are affeeted most frequently
life (Dimitrov [2]; Vuksanovic [25]). There
(approximately 45%); naturally, the hands
is a high correlation between the number of
suffer most. The lower extremities follow
accidents and the length of service at sea.
with approximately 31 %, the head with ap-
This should supply a motive to pay more
proximately 13% and the trunk in last pI ace
attention to the prevention of accidents
with 11%.
among younger seamen when organising
the work on board. 3.2.2.5 Kinds of Injury
The statistical data show the following se-
3.2.2.3 Work-places
quenee: 1) contusions 34%, 2) wounds
The majority of accidents happen on deck (predominantly lacerations) 22%, 3) frac-
(approximately 43%), in the engine room tures (predominantly c10sed fractures )
(approximately 41 %) and in the working 19%, 4) strains (predominantly of the
area of the catering staff (approximately ankle) 17%. The remaining 8% includes
16%). bums, injuries involving foreign bodies, in-
Nearly 80% of the injured se amen do juries to the eyes and intemal injuries (Do-
heavy physical work. The remaining 20% latkowski et al. [3]; Giannico and Tortori-
are crew members with light physical duty, Donati [5]; Dimitrov [2]; Vrcelj [22]; Vuksa-
e. g. the ship's officers. Within the group of novic [25]; Trapp [21]). The above-men-
officers the engineers are more frequently tioned sequence c10sely corresponds with
injured than the deck or catering officers the evaluation of the data regarding la-
(Vuksanovic [25]; Dimitrov [2]; Vrcelj [22]). bourers ashore (Vuksanovic [25]).
The frequency of accidents also depends As, evidently, one-quarter of all acci-
on the type of vessel. More accidents occur dents aboard cause open wounds, appro-
on the deck of cargo vessels than on tank- priate preventive measures should be ini-
ships. On fishery vessels, accidents pre- tiated and the ship's medicine chests
dominantly occur during handling of the should be supplied aeeordingly.
deck maehinery. The aecident rate on ves-
sels of an older design is generally higher 3.2.2.6 Number of Siek Days
than on modem vessels (Goethe and Vuk- According to Vrcelj [22] the average num-
sanovic [6]; Vrcelj [22]). ber of sick days following an accident is
With respect to the time of the accident 37.6; Vuksanovic [25] gave 21.3 days and
before starting work or at work, Vrcelj [22] Dimitrov [2] 29.4 days. No other seamen's
came to the amazing conclusion that most disease involves so many siek days. More
of the accidents happened in passage-ways than 50% of the accidents require 10-30
when moving from one pi ace to another on siek days. Of the total number of siek days
186 3 The Pathology of the Seafarer
on board, 22% are due to occupational ac- is done during the day. An investigation of
cidents. the eventual result of the injuries showed
that approximately 90% of the injured per-
3.2.2.7 Aetiology sons recovered completely. Approximately
Many authors (Dolatkowski et al. [3]; Di- 7% remained invalids life-long and retired
mitrov [2]; Vrcelj [22]; Ejsmont and Filipek from the sea. Approximately 1%-4% ofthe
[4]; Otterland [15]; Vuksanovic [25]; Guida accidents were immediately fatal or the vic-
[7]) have analysed occupational accidents tims died subsequently from the effects of
on board and come to the following con- their injuries (Dimitrov [2]).
clusions: The most important cause is the International comparison of the rates of
human factor. More than 40% of the occu- accidents, classified according to the type
pational accidents are due to inattention, of vessel, shows the fishery fleet to be top
overfatigue, unfitness, carelessness, alcohol of the list. Apparently, tankship crews are
consumption and other factors predomi- not greatly pro ne to accidents. The figures
nantly correlating with the personality of for occupational accidents on board other
the victim. Approximately 20% of occupa- types of vessel vary considerably. The fre-
tional accidents are considered to have quency rates of accidents according to ship
been caused by engine parts or other tech- sizes show a negative correlation. The
nical fitments on board. A further 20% may smaller the ship, the higher the rate of acci-
be associated with bad work organisation, dents. Most of the occupational accidents
including macro- and micro-climatic load occur on smaller vessels of up to
factors. As mentioned above, the move- 10000 gross tonnes (Vrcelj [22]).
ment of the sea has a considerable influ-
ence on the occurrence of accidents. Very 3.2.2.9 Death Due to Occupational
often, severe accidents are caused by heavy Accidents on Board
objects moving as a consequence of a Death by drowning (56%) ranks first in the
storm. Considering the fact that the human order of frequency, followed by death
factor is the chief cause of occupational ac- caused by closed fractures, predominantly
cidents on ships, preventive measures ofthe skull (17%). These two causes account
should be put into force urgently. Without Jor 73% oJ alt deaths; the remaining 27%
doubt it should be possible to avoid a large cover all other kinds of accident (Vrcelj
number of accidents by strict accident pre- [22]).
vention measures, including an optimum The results of accident aetiology re-
work organisation. search have shown that, in fatal accidents
also, the human factor is of the utmost im-
3.2.2.8 Further Parameters portance, followed by moving objects and
International comparison of accidents in work organisation (Kersten [8]; Puskeiler
seafaring over the past 20 years fortunately and Kersten [16]). In the international com-
showed a tendency towards a constant parison ca. 1.2% of all casualties die as a re-
slow fall, presumably because of improved sult of accidents on board. This rate is
accident prevention (Vuksanovic and 5-10times higher than that for labourers
Goethe [24]). ashore (Otterland [15]; Vrcelj [22]; Dimi-
A seasonal correlation of accidents trov [2]; Nolan [14]) used the "Standard
could not be demonstrated (Vrcelj [22]), Mortality Rate" (SMR) in order to com-
whereas the time of day seems to be a very pare the rates of seamen with those of the
important factor. Approximately 60% of population ashore. He came to the conclu-
accidents happen between 8 a. m. and sion that, generally, life is much more per-
5 p. m. (Dimitrov [2]; Vrcelj [22]). This is to ilous at sea and that, as a consequence, the
be expected as the greater part of the work rate of fatal accidents to se amen at sea is
3.2 Accidents in Seafaring 187
higher than that to labourers ashore. His therefore that every seafarer should under-
figures for seafarers, however, include go at least one medical first aid course.
barge and boatmen. Mter first aid has been completed, any
The casualty rates among deck and en- necessary further care and treatment of the
gine room personnel are nearly equal. The casualty should be given by a ship's officer
number of casualties among deck officers who has been trained for the purpose to a
is slightly higher than that among en- level higher than that of the usual first aid
gineers. Seamen are considered to be more certificate. This further treatment is often
suicidal than labourers ashore. To a certain necessary because it may be days before
extent the unsolved disappearances of sea- the ship can reach port or a doctor be
men are explainable in terms of suicide. It brought aboard to a seriously injured sea-
seems that young, inexperienced seamen farer (see also Chap.1.4).
are more suicide-prone. No doubt, alcohol In the case of mass casualties caused by
has an adverse effect on the mental condi- collisions, explosions or other major acci-
tion of men at sea (Reimer [17]; Wodarg dents, many patients have to be treated si-
[26]). multaneously. Such a situation necessitates
very calculated action by the captain and/
or ship's officers, but often they are unpre-
3.2.3 Treatment of Accidents on pared or untrained for this kind of crisis.
Board The training of ship's officers should in-
clude the handling of such events (triage).
On land, injured people are generally Many maritime countries make available
transferred quickly to the care of the near- national medical guides (Ship Captain's
est doctor or Hospital. In contrast injured Medical Guide or similar). They contain de-
crew members on ships are dependent on tailed instructions for the treatment of acci-
the medical first aid of laymen, as only a dents and injuries. Where there is no na-
very few vessels still carry a doctor. On long tional guide available, the International
voyages, the injured person sometimes has Medical Guide for Ships (WHO) should be
to wait for hours or even days to get medi- compulsory on board.
cal treatment by a doctor. Incorrect medi-
cal first aid and subsequent treatment may
seriously reduce the chances of recovery 3.2.4 Prevention of Accidents
and in some cases may result in irreparable The aetiology of occupational accidents is
damage. Severe injuries, particularly frac- multifactorial. Analysis of shipboard acci-
tures, may cause great pain and increased dents points to the following as chief
shock owing to the ship's motion in rough causes:
seas, when satisfactory immobilisation is 1. The human being and the human factor;
impossible. 2. The work organisation;
In a medical emergency on board a ship 3. The work environment.
without a doctor, adesignated ship's offi- Preventive measures should consider the
cer is responsible for giving the essential sequence of the above-mentioned factors.
quick medical first aid. However he may be Accident prevention should be an integral
involved in other duties or asleep and pre- part of the education of officers and sea-
cious time may be lost before he collects his men at the schools for ratings and at the
medical kit and attends the casualty. In nautical colleges. It should be emphasised
many instances it falls to comrades present even more during the practical training.
at the incident to give such lifesaving meas- Careful occupational selection of sea-
ures as control of bleeding, treatment of men is a precondition of successful acci-
shock and/or resuscitation. It is imperative dent prevention on board. Besides purely
188 3 The Pathology ofthe Seafarer
medical fitness, the psycho-social aptitude Environmental factors such as high and
is of great importance. The psycho-physi- low temperatures, noise and vibration are
cal selection, i. e. the medical fitness exami- controllable only to a certain extent. Every-
nations, should incIude vision, hearing and thing possible should be tried in the ship's
psycho-motor function, and should attest design to keep noise and vibration levels
the mental stability of the applicant. Under below the permitted limit values (see also
no circumstances should accident-prone Chap. 2.6). Special attention should be paid
people be employed on board vessels. Re- to accident prevention under unfavourable
examinations should be performed at regu- macro- and microclimatic conditions.
lar intervals. Work clotIies, as weH as the use of pro-
During the actual operation of the ship, tective methods, are a special field of acci-
management should take special care of dent prevention. It has frequently been ob-
the mental condition of crew members. The served that working seamen wear insuffi-
social and political structure of some of the cient protective clothing. Very often they
maritime countries certainly makes this do not use safety ropes nor do they wear
possible, but often there is not much gloves or safety boots. GeneraHy, they seem
chance of doing so. Nevertheless, every- to be rather careless. Regular accident and
thing possible should be done to amelio- safety education for crew members is re-
rate the situation. Naturally, there is the quired and certainly creates a high er con-
problem of excess alcohol consumption on sciousness of accidents. Psychological
board, which, no doubt, leads to numerous training in accident prevention can never
accidents. Prevention of alcohol abuse re- be overdone. The effectiveness und er-
sults in the prevention of accidents. standably varies from country to country
A further important point is the work or- and from company to company. It has been
ganisation. Overfatigue and/or insufficient possible to eliminate a large number of ac-
vigilance are important factors. Overfa- cidents on the vessels of some shipping
tigue is caused by watch periods being too companies by intensive psychological and
long and by overtime work being required technical methods of accident prevention
too often. A higher accident risk is und er- but, of course, this necessitates continuous
standable under such conditions. Overfa- educational efforts. Good behavioural pat-
tigue can be eliminated by an optimum terns by captains, deck offkers and en-
work organisation. It may be that the two- gineers contribute a lot towards general ac-
watch system (12 h watch), which is prac- ceptance of good safety practice, and
tised on small vesse1s, particularly coastal awards or rewards for accident-free work
vessels, results in higher accident rates. can be a stimulating means of accident pre-
The work environment on board seems vention. The aim of accident prevention on
to increase any tendency towards acci- board ships must be "Education for Self-
dents. Ship designers should pay particular protection" as any accident to anyone on
attention to optimal design of engines, fit- board threatens the health of the seaman
ments, ladders, stairways and passages to himself.
ensure personal safety. Regretfully, an-
thropotechnics are, so far, applied too rare-
ly in the design of ships. Movement of the
ship is practicaHy unavoidable at sea. As References
13% of the occupational accidents are di-
rectly or indirectly caused by rough seas 1. Crovari, P.: Malattie dei marittimi e condizioni
di vita a bordo delle navi nei loro aspetti igieni-
(Vrce1j [22]), only urgent repair work co-sociali. Ed.: Istituto Italiano di medicina so-
should be carried out under these circum- ciale. Roma 1962. (Collana di studi sui proble-
stances. mi medico-sociali).
3.2 Accidents in Seafaring 189
2. Dimitrov, I. V.: Proisvodstvniyat travmatizam by deep sea fisherman. Brit. 1. industr. Med. 26,
vsred balgarskite morjatsi [Occupational trau- 1, 1-24 (1969).
matism among Bulgarian seamen]. Autorefer- 14. Nolan, B.: Tripie doses: a view of seamen's
endum medical dissertation. Varna 1975. health. Marit. Pol. Managemt. 6, 2, 119-127
3. Dolatkowski, A, J. Burka and K. Dega: Unfälle (1979).
auf Schiffen im Zeitraum von 1960-1962. In: 15.0tterland, A: Unfälle bei Seeleuten der Han-
Fragen der Schiffahrtsmedizin. Vorträge aus delsmarine. Abbottempo 2, 20-25 (1970).
dem Intern. Symp. vom 28.-31.3.1963 in Hei- 16. Puskeiler, T. and E.Kersten: Tödliche Unfälle
ligendamm. Sonderheft des Medizinischen in der Seefahrt. Verk.-Med. 12,2,69-75 (1965).
Dienstes des Verkehrswesens H. pp. 93-105. 17. Reimer, F.: Alkohol und Selbstmord bei See-
4. Ejsmont, W. and B.Filipek: Traumas, accidents leuten. Akt. Probl. Verk.-Med. 2, 190-193
and fatal cases in the Polish merchant marine. (1965).
Bull. Inst. mar. Med. Gdansk 17, 3, 343-349 18. Reimer, F.: Suizide bei jugendlichen Seeleuten.
(1966). Int. 1. prophyl. Med. 6,1,7-11 (1962).
5. Giannico, L. and B. Tortori-Donati: L'incidenza 19. Schepers, B.-F.: Gesundheitsgefahrdung durch
di infortuni a bordo di navi da passageri e con- Chemikalien an Bord deutscher Seeschiffe un-
siderazioni sulla relativa azione a caratere pre- ter besonderer Berücksichtigung gefährlicher
ventivo. Lav. e Med. 12,2(1974). Ladung. Dissertation, University of Hamburg
6. Goethe, H. and P. Vuksanovic: Distribution of 1978.
diagnoses, diseases, unfitness for duty and acci- 20. Tortori-Donati, B.: Considerations about mor-
dents among seamen and fishermen. Bull. Inst. bidity, diseases, siek leave and accidents among
mar. trop. Med. Gdynia 26, 2, 133-158 (1975). seamen according to the data concerning Ital-
7. Guida, G.: The pathology of the seaman (Re- ian seafarers. Bull. Inst. mar. trop. Med. Gdynia
port on the activity of the C. 1. R. M. "Studies 26,2,159-164 (1975).
Section": 1959-1967). Atti della "Sezione Stu- 21. Trapp, E.: Die Morbidität in der Handelsschiff-
di" dei C. 1. R. M. 19-23 (1967). fahrt. Verk.-Med. 13,4/5,174-185 (1966).
8. Kersten, E.: Erkrankungen der Seeleute - Eine 22. Vrcelj, J.: Die Unfälle an Bord von deutschen
Analyse des Lehrstuhls für Arbeitshygiene. In: Seeschiffen und ihre Ätiologie von 1974-1976.
Fragen der Schiffahrtsmedizin. Vorträge aus Auswertung des Materials der See-Berufsge-
dem Intern. Symp. vom 28.-31.3. 1963 in Hei- nossenschaft - Hamburg. Dissertation, Univer-
ligendamm. Sonderheft des Medizinischen sity of Hamburg 1981.
Dienstes des Verkehrswesens H. pp. 23-32. 23. Vuksanovic, P.: NajeesCe bolesti pomoraca.
9. Kraemer-Hansen, H.: Diagnosenverteilung bei [Most frequent illnesses of seamen]. In: Po-
Seeleuten. Auswertung der Erkrankungsbögen morska medicina H (Naucne rasprave). Beo-
der Abteilung für Schiffahrtsmedizin am grad: Izdanje Mornarickog glasnika 1979. pp.
Bernhard-Nocht-Institut für Schiffs- und Tro- 297-302. (Pomorska biblioteka. Sveska 30).
penkrankheiten in Hamburg aus den Jahren 24. Vuksanovic, P. and H.Goethe: Die Morbi-
von 1966 bis 1975. Dissertation, University of ditätsstruktur der Seeleute - ein internationaler
Hamburg 1977. Vergleich. In: Unfall- und Sicherheitsforschung
10. Kraljevic, L. and Z.Ditrih: Hitna medicinska Straßenverkehr. Kongreßbericht Jahrestagung
pomoc i hitne intervencije na brodu i u po- 1981 der Dtsch. Ges. f. Verkehrsmed. gemein-
morstvu. [First medical aid and urgent medical sam m. d. Dtsch. Verkehrswacht. Hamburg,
interventions on board]. In: Pomorska medici- 7.-9.5. 1981. Ed.: Bundesanstalt für Straßen-
na (Nauene rasprave). Beograd: Izdanje wesen im Auftrage des Bundesministers f. Ver-
Mornarickog glasnika 1975. pp. 415-420. kehr. Braunschweig 1981: Waisenhaus-Buch-
(Pomorska biblioteka 26). druckerei u. Verl. pp. 57 -66.
11. Lungarotti, R. and A Picciocchi: Alcune con- 25. Vuksanovic, P.: Uticaj savremene plovidbe na
siderazioni sugli infortuni a bordo. (Osservazio- strukturu morbiditeta jugoslovenskih pomora-
ni sul personale navigante di un transatIantico). ca (epidemioloska studija). [Influence of mod-
Atti della "Sezione Studi" dei C. 1. R. M. ern seafaring on the morbidity structure of Yu-
155-159 (1965). goslavian seamen (an epidemiological study).]
12. Matthiensen, R. P.: Diagnoseverteilung bei Er- Dissertation, University of Sarajevo 1981.
krankungen in der Schiffahrt. Auswertung von 26. Wodarg, w.: Psychische Krankheiten der See-
Schiffskrankentagebüchern und ein Vergleich leute. Untersuchung über Selbsttötung, Alko-
mit dem statistischen Material der SBG sowie holismus und andere wichtige psychiatrische
der Ortskrankenkassen. Dissertation, Universi- Erkrankungen anhand von 236 von der See-
ty of Hamburg [1969]. Berufsgenossenschaft gesammelten Seeamts-
13. Moore, S. R. W.: The occupation of trawl fish- verhandlungen aus den Jahren 1960 bis 1973.
ing and the medical aid available to the Grims- Dissertation, University of Hamburg 1977.
3.3 Gastro-Intestinal Diseases
G.1. Milton-Thompson and 1. G. Williams
and a little fluid in one costophrenic angle, signs; this is supported by the response to
while the abdominal X-ray shows no air treatment with H 2-receptor antagonists, but
under the diaphragm. Mucosal tears with- referral for specialist investigation in due
out perforation of the oesophagus may oc- course will confirm the diagnosis. It is ac-
cur in similar situations, when they often cepted by the British Royal Navy that un-
cause bleeding - the Mallory-Weiss syn- complicated duodenal ulcer does not con-
drome (see "Gastro-intestinal Bleeding"). stitute a bar to men returning to sea since
Although dysphagia may be associated drugs are available that are highly effective
with oesophageal reflux and other benign both in the acute attack and in reducing the
conditions, it should always be taken seri- rate of relapse, but caution should be exer-
ously and investigated as soon as possible. cised with regard to those who have a his-
tory of bleeding. Men at sea with a history
3.3.3 Gastritis, Gastric Ulcer and of duodenal ulcer should be treated at once
Gastric Carcinoma when their symptoms recur with cimetidine
or another H 2-receptor antagonist in full
Acute gastritis is common in seamen, for it dosage for at least 4 weeks (Burland et al.
is associated with dietary indiscretion, al- [9]), but the need for maintenance therapy
coholic excess and staphylococcal entero- is controversial and it is probably as effec-
toxin in pre-prepared meals. This gastritis tive to treat attacks as they occur (Bardhan
may be associated with acute gastric ero- [5]). Seamen who develop pyloric stenosis
sions which are likely to bleed. Chronic or other significant complications of duo-
gastric ulcer and gastric carcinoma do not denal ulcer should have surgery. This gen-
show any unusual characteristics in sea- eral view is not shared by the majority of
men. doctors looking after merchant seamen.
Cases of peptic ulceration are often re-
3.3.4 Duodenal Ulcer ferred for fuH investigation and treatment
ashore and, in some countries, Hz-receptor
Although the incidence is changing, duo- antagonists are not allowed to be carried
denal ulcer remains a common condition on board.
affecting males rather than females and
most prevalent between the ages of 20 and 3.3.5 Gastro-intestinal Bleeding
60. It has been suggested that it is more
common in seamen than in a matched Upper gastro-intestinal bleeding has nu-
group ashore (Watt [34]). But such compar- merous causes, but the commonest
isons of incidence are complicated by con- amongst seafarers are alcohol, Mallory-
stitutional, genetic and geographical differ- Weiss tears and peptic ulcer disease. The
ences and firm conclusions cannot be effects of alcohol on the gastro-intestinal
drawn. tract have been reviewed recently (Van
The clinical picture is less clear-cut than Thiel et al. [33]). Vomiting induced by acute
traditionally believed, but periodic symp- or chronic alcohol ingestion may cause lin-
toms relieved by food and antacids and ear tears at the lower end of the oesopha-
waking the patient at night are characteris- gus (Mallory and Weiss [22]) or in the
tic. It has been observed that seamen de- upper fundus (Axon and Clarke [3]). These
veloping duodenal ulceration may notice lesions are also seen in relation to severe
an increase in the severity of motion sick- seasickness. Other lesions related to exces-
ness (Cliff [10]). The condition frequently sive alcohol ingestion which give rise to
occurs in association with reflux oesopha- bleeding include oesophageal varices sec-
gitis. At sea the condition may reasonably ondary to portal hypertension and liver dis-
be diagnosed on the history and physical ease (Baker et al. [4]) and Barrett's oesoph-
192 3 The Pathology ofthe Seafarer
agus with or without u1ceration, secondary always carried. Drugs do not reduce the
to chronic oesophagitis (Martini and Wein- likelihood of further haemorrhage, except
back [24]). for cimetidine in acute erosive gastritis
In the stornach, acute superficial ero- (Welch et al. [35]). Although cimetidine has
sions and acute haemorrhagic gastritis are not been shown to lessen the possibility of
common problems following an acute a1co- bleeding from peptic u1cers, it will acceler-
holic binge (Gottfried et al. [16]), particu- ate the healing of such lesions, both gastric
larly when there has been concomitant and duodenal (Burland et al. [9]), and
aspirin ingestion. Both alcohol and aspirin should therefore be given routinely if possi-
cause rapid turnover and loss of gastric ble following a gastro-intestinal bleed.
cells (Krasner [18]; Croft [11]) and disrup- Lower gastro-intestinal bleeding tends to
tion of the gastric mucosal barrier (Smith et be less dramatic than haematemesis. Al-
al. [29]. Alcohol appears to be directly toxic though patients may present with an acute
to the gastric mucosa. It also causes acute severe bleed, most will complain of chronic
haemorrhagic lesions in the duodenum intermittent bleeding. The causes tend to
and jejunum but these are of doubtful clini- vary with age, so that in young adults in-
cal significance (Gottfried et al. [16]). flammatory bowel disease and adenoma-
Peptic u1cer disease in seafarers has al- tous polyps are the most common, in mid-
ready been discussed. Peptic ulcers are re- dIe aged patients carcinoma, diverticular
sponsible for some 50% of bleeding ep- disease and ischaemia predominate. Local
isodes requiring admission to hospital in anal conditions such as fissures and haem-
the United Kingdom (Dronfield et al. [12]), orrhoids are common in all age groups. Fi-
and although the proportion is probably nally, the possibility that apparent lower
smaller among seamen because ofthe high- gastro-intestinal bleeding may have an
er incidence of Mallory-Weiss lesions and upper intestinal source should be borne in
acute a1coholic gastritis, peptic u1cer re- mind.
mains a significant cause of bleeding. A Dysenterie infections may be difficult to
pre-morbid history is suggestive of peptic differentiate from other inflammatory
u1cer disease, although dyspepsia is com- bowel disease. Suggestive features will be
mon in seamen in the absence of peptic ul- the particularly acute onset of dysentery as-
ceration. sociated with systemic symptoms and the
Management of upper gastro-intestinal clustering of a number of cases. If there is
bleeding will be dictated by the facilities doubt, such cases should be isolated. Cam-
available on board and by the proximity of pylobacter enteritis, usually caught from
medical care ashore. Fortunately, both contact with animals (especially live or
acute alcoholic gastritis and Mallory-Weiss dressed chickens and other contaminated
te ars tend to be self-limiting conditions food) and transmitted by the faecal-oral
with a good prognosis. Bleeding from pep- route, may mimic inflammatory bowel dis-
tic ulcer is more dangerous but only 20% ease very closely in its presentation. Fortu-
do not stop bleeding spontaneously and nately it is a self-limiting illness that does
this is related to age (Young [38]). In the ab- not usually require antibiotic treatment.
sence of skilIed medical care in hospital, re- Valuable pointers to the level ofbleeding
suscitation with intravenous fluids and from the gastro-intestinal tract are the pat-
preferably blood is still possible and ient's age, sex and medical history. Bright
should be carried out when there is evi- red rectal bleeding is usually from the rec-
dence of considerable blood loss, hypoten- turn or sigmoid colon. Dark red blood
sion and anaemia. However, transfusion of usually comes from the more proximal co-
blood will not be possible on board mer- lon, or infrequently from brisk bleeding
chant vessels and intravenous fluids are not higher in the gut. Melaena usually reflects
3.3 Gastro-Intestinal Diseases 193
upper gastro-intestinal bleeding, but may have adverse effects on the bowel flora
also be associated with lesions in the termi- both in the short and long term, with an in-
nal ileum or caecum where there is stasis of creased risk of superinfection, masking of
blood in the right colon. Associated altera- more serious infections and difficulties in
tion of bowel habit or weight may suggest making a bacteriological diagnosis. The in-
neoplasia, while diarrhoea may suggest in- cidence ofboth symptomatic and asympto-
flammatory bowel disease and dysentery. matic Salmonella infections is higher in
Abdominal pain, its site, radiation and re- those taking regular oxyquinoline prophy-
lationship to food intake or defaecation laxis than in those who take no prophylac-
may be highly significant, particularly if a tic medication.
new symptom. Other causes of diarrhoea include para-
Treatment must be conservative if on sitic infections, colitis, malabsorption and
board ship, but should include isolation the irritable bowel syndrome. With the ex-
unless a dysenteric cause has been defi- ception of malabsorption due to pancreatic
nitely excluded. Most cases will settle insufficiency in the longstanding alcoholic,
spontaneously and bleeding will not be se- these diseases are no more likely to be en-
vere enough to warrant resuscitation with countered at sea than ashore.
blood, although iron may be necessary. All Management of diarrhoea on board ship
cases of rectal bleeding require full medical requires assessment to establish the cause
assessment when appropriate, as most and isolation until an infective cause has
cases will have a cause that can be success- been confidently excluded. Assessment
fully treated. should include a dietary and a drug history.
Control of diarrhoea, if severe, is best
3.3.6 Diarrhoea achieved by a fluid diet [27] with codeine
phosphate by mouth each time there is a
Diarrhoea is, surprisingly, a relatively un- fluid bowel action. Antibiotics are not indi-
common complaint in seamen, unlike trav- cated unless a specific dysenteric infection
ellers overland. Infective causes of diar- has been diagnosed (Lambert [20]).
rhoea will be encountered at ports of cal\.
Most common among such will be the sim- 3.3.7 Constipation
ple change in bowel flora producing a self-
limiting 24-72 h diarrhoea (Nye [26]). But Although the causes of constipation in sea-
other more florid infections, such as with men are those of any other social group, re-
Salmonella and Shigella, Campylobacter duction of transit time and less frequent
and Giardia may be encountered. The passage of stool tends to occur with varia-
closed environment of a ship makes infec- tions in diet and the reduction in the crude
tion with dysenteric organisms liable to fibre content of the diet that commonly oc-
achieve epidemie proportions with great curs during voyages. The irritable bowel
ease. It is therefore of great importance that syndrome, manifested by constipation or
sufferers from diarrhoea, particularly constipation altemating with diarrhoea,
where an infective cause is suspected, with spasmodic abdominal pain often re-
should be isolated and instructed to be lieved by the passage of flatus, is a diagno-
scrupulous in their personal hygiene. In sis of exclusion. Such patients should be re-
most cases of infective diarrhoea, antibiot- ferred for full investigation when time
ics are not indicated since they do not has- allows. It should not be forgotten that a
ten the resolution of the symptoms and are change in bowel habit in the older patient
more likely to promote a carrier state [32]. must be regarded with suspicion.
The same considerations apply to the pro-
phylactic use of antimicrobials, which may
194 3 The Pathology ofthe Seafarer
contact and by the sexual route. The sexu- er biopsy, and will need long-term follow-
ally promiscuous, particularly male homo- up (36).
sexuals, are at high risk. Hepatitis B surface
antigen has been found in blood and var- 3.3.9 Other Infections Causing Liver
ious body fluids such as saliva, menstrual Disease
and vaginal discharges, seminal fluid,
breast milk and exudates, and these have A viral hepatitis may be caused by infec-
all been implicated in transmission of in- tious mononucleosis. The assoeiation of
fection. The infection mayaiso be trans mit- lymphadenopathy, sore throat and palatal
ted by aceidental inoculation of minute petechiae are helpful clues. Tropical causes
amounts of blood or fluids contaminated include amoebiasis, schistosomiasis, hyda-
with blood such as may occur during medi- tid disease, Lassa fever and yellow fever.
cal, surgical and dental procedures, intra- These have recently been reviewed by Fa-
venous and percutaneous drug abuse, tat- kunle [13].
tooing, ear piercing and acupuncture.
As for hepatitis A, management will be 3.3.10 Biliary Disease
symptomatic with scrupulous attention to
personal hygiene, while nursing staff The spectrum of disease attributable to
should protect themselves from contact gallstones will be no different among sea-
with blood and secretions. Hepatitis B im- men than among those ashore. Presenta-
munoglobulin should be administered if tion will be with flatulent dyspepsia, biliary
there has been a single acute exposure to colic, acute cholecystitis or jaundice, all of
hepatitis B virus, such as occurs with inocu- which require appropriate management
lation from a known contaminated source. and, in due course, hospital assessment.
Non-A, non-B hepatitis shares a number
of features with hepatitis B. It is most com- 3.3.11 Pancreatitis
monly recognised as a complication of
blood transfusion but may account for Alcohol-induced pancreatitis is the com-
10%-25% of adults with presumed viral monest form to be encountered among sea-
A hepatitis. The illness is usually mild, of- men, although the acute variety mayaiso
ten subc1inical or anicteric, but may be se- be associated with gallstones, certain drugs
vere and can cause fulminating hepatitis. and other rarer factors which should be
Like hepatitis B, it may be followed by a borne in mind (Trapnell and Duncan [31]).
persistent carrier state. Pancreatitis induced by alcohol tends to
The carrier state associated with hepati- assume the chronic form although the
tis B (and non-A and non-B) is defined as mechanism is unknown. It occurs not only
persistence of the B surface antigen in the in alcoholics, but in the heavy soeial drink-
eirculation for more than 6 months. The er, affecting the young or middle-aged male
carrier state may be lifelong and may be as- after years of over-indulgence (Benjamin
soeiated with varying degrees of liver dam- [6]). Acute episodes tend to come on
age. Several risk factors have been identi- 12-48 h after a drin king bout, pain during
fied: it is more common in males, more the 'afternoon after the night before' being
likely to follow infection acquired in child- typical. Such attacks of varying severity last
hood and more likely to occur in patients 3-7 days, with intervals of months or years.
with natural or acquired immune defieien- Later (hut rarely before episodes of pain)
eies. A carrier state becomes established in evidence of pancreatic insuffieiency, par-
5%-10% of infected adults. All patients ticularly diabetes, develops. Less common
with persisting hepatitis B antigenaemia re- is the fulminating attack, in which the pat-
quire full clinical assessment, including liv- ient may become gravely ill with severe
196 3 The Pathology ofthe Seafarer
abdominal pain, distension, guarding, ileus tions. - Occasional survey -. Lancet 1,707-711
and shock. A diagnostic laparotomy may (1981).
3. Axon, AT. R. and A Clarke: Haematesis: A
be necessary. new syndrome? Brit. med. J. 1,491-492 (1975).
The acute fulminating attack should be 4. Baker, L., C. Smith and G. Lieberman : The nat-
treated as a surgical emergency, with con- ural history of esophageal varices. Amer. J.
tinuous gastric aspiration, parenteral nutri- Med. 26,228-231 (1959).
tion and maintenance of fluid and electro- 5. Bardhan, K. D.: Intermittent treatment of duo-
denal ulcer with Cimetidine. Brit. med. 1. 281,
lyte balance. Pethidine, rather than mor- 20-22 (1980).
phine, should be used for analgesia and 6. Benjamin, I.S.: Alcoholism: New knowledge
surgery avoided unless to make the diagno- and new responses. Ed.: M.Grant. London:
sis (Trapnell [30]). The subject of alcohol- Croom Helm 1977.
7. Brayley, N. F.: A review of three years experi-
induced pancreatitis has been weIl re- ence of medical advice to seafarers by the casu-
viewed by Marks [23]. alty officer, Royal Naval Hospital Plymouth,
Chronic alcohol-induced pancreatitis via Portishead Radio (WIT Medico Por-
must be treated by total abstinence from al- tishead). 1. roy. nav. med. Servo 66, 2, 93-106
(1980).
cohol, for no other regimen will abolish the
8. Brayley, N. F. and F. R. Wilkes: A case of spon-
episodes of pain. Other treatment must aim taneous rupture of the cervical oesophagus: a
to improve the nutritional state and allevi- reminder. J. roy. nav. med. Servo 68, 1, 30-33
ate diabetes and steatorrhoea. In most (1982).
countries a merchant seafarer suffering 9. Burland, w.L., R. H. Hunt, J.G.Mills and
G.1.Milton-Thompson: Cimetidine. J. Phar-
from chronic pancreatitis would be barred macotherapy 2, 24-40 (1979).
from further seafaring because of the pos- 10. Cliff, J. M.: Personal communication 1969.
sibility of (a) needing treatment that cannot 11. Croft, D. N.: Aspirin and the exfoliation of gas-
be provided owing to the lack of medical tric epithelial cells. Cytological and biochemi-
cal observations. Brit. med. J. 2, 897-901 (1963).
facilities on board and (b) reduced working
12. Dronfield, M. w., M. J. S. Atkinson, T. W. Bell et
capacity. al.: Outcome of endoscopy and barium radiog-
raphy for aeute upper gastrointestinal bleeding:
controlled trial in 1037 patients. Brit. med. 1. 2,
3.3.12 Nutrition 897 -901 (1963).
13. Fakunle, Y. M.: Tropicalliver disease. Medicine
Over the centuries nutritional problems
18,932-934 (1979).
have played a major part in the life of sea- 14. Glover, S. D. and E. W. Taylor: Surgical prob-
men (Milton-Thompson [25]). Modem lems presenting at sea during 100 British Polaris
methods of food preservation have com- submarine patrols. J. roy. nav. med. Servo 67, 1,
bined with a greater understanding of nu- 65-69 (1981).
15. Gottfried, E. B., M.A Korsten and C. S. Lieber:
tritional requirements virtually to abolish Gastritis and duodenitis induced by aIcohol: an
these problems. Alcoholism remains a con- endoscopic and histologie assessment. Gastro-
tributory factor to poor nutrition in indi- enterology 70,890 (1976).
vidual se amen, and nutritional problems 16. Gottfried, E. S., M. A Korsten and C. S. Lieber:
Alcohol induced gastric and duodenaliesions
and vitamin deficiencies are still encoun- in man. Amer. J. Gastroent. 70,587-592 (1978).
tered in wartime (Schadewaldt [28]). 17. Kaufman, S.E. and M.D.Kaye: Induction of
gastro-oesophageal reflux by aIcohol. Gut 19,
336-338 (1978).
References 18. Krasner, N.: Alcohol and the gastrointestinal
tract. 1. roy. Col!. Phycns Lond. 12, 15-20
1. Abbot, O. A, K. A. Mansour, W. D. Logan jr. et (1977).
a!.: A traumatic so-called "spontaneous" rup- 19. Krasner, N., T. J. Thomson, G. Crean et a!.: Gas-
ture of the oesophagus: a review of 47 personal tric epithelial cell tumover after acute and
eases with comments on a new method of surgi- chronic aIcohol ingestion. Gut 15, 336 (1974).
eal therapy. J. thorae. eardiovase. Surg. 59, 20. Lambert, H. D.: Antimicrobial agents in diar-
67-82 (1970). rhoeal disease. Clin. Gastroent. 8, 827-833
2. Alcoholic liver disease: morphologie manifesta- (1979).
3.3 Gastro-Intestinal Diseases 197
21. Lieber, C. S. and E. Rubin: Alcoholic fatty liver teration by acetylsalicylic acid and ethanol.
in man on a high protein and low fat diet. Amer. New Engl. J. Med. 285, 716-721 (1971).
J. Med. 44, 200-206 (1968). 30. Trapnell, J. E.: The natural history and progno-
22. Mallory, G. K. and S. Weiss: Hemorrhages from sis of acute pancreatitis. Ann. roy. Coll. Surg.
lacerations of the cardiac orifice of the stomach Engl. 38, 265-287 (1966).
due to vomiting. Amer. J. med. Sci. 178, 31. Trapnell, J.E. and E.H.L.Duncan: Patterns of
506-515 (1929). incidence in acute pancreatitis. Brit. med. J. 2,
23. Marks, 1. N.: Alcohol induced pancreatitis. In: 179-183 (1975).
Topics in gastroenterology 7. Ed.: S. C. Truelove 32. Traveller's diarrhoea - leading article - Lancet
and C. P. Willoughby. Oxford: Blackwell Scien- 1,777-778 (1982).
tific 1979. 33. Van Thiel, D. H., H. D. Lipschitz, L. E. Porter et
24. Martini, G.A and M. Weinback: Begünstigt Al- al.: Gastrointestinal and hepatic manifestations
kohol die Entstehung eines Barret-Syndroms of chronic alcoholism. Gastroenterology 81,
(Endobrachyesophagus)? Dtsch. med. Wschr. 594-615 (1981).
10,434-439 (1974). 34. Watt, J.: The sailor's stomach. J. roy. nav. med.
25. Milton-Thompson, G.J.: Two hundred years of Servo 58,12-34 (1972).
the sailors' diet. In: Starving Sailors. Ed.: 35. Welch, R w., H.L.Bentch and S.C.Harris: Re-
J. Watt, E.1. Freeman and W. F. Bynum. Green- duction of aspirin induced gastrointestinal
wich: National Maritime Museum 1981. bleeding with cimetidine. Gastroenterology 74,
26. Nye, F.J.: Traveller's diarrhoea. Clin. Gastro- 459-463 (1978).
ent. 8,767-781 (1979). 36. What shall we do with the HBAg carrier? -
27. Oral therapy for acute diarrhoea -leading arti- leading article - Brit. med. J. 4,427-428 (1974).
cle - Lancet 1, 615-617 (1981). 37. Winship, D.H., R.Carlton and F.Calflesa: De-
28. Schadewaldt, H.: Nutritional deficiencies in the terioration of oesophageal peristalsis in patients
crews of German raiders in two world wars. In: with alcoholic neuropathy. Gastroenterology
Starving Sailors. Ed.: J. Watt, E.J. Freeman and 55,173-178 (1968).
W. F. Bynum. Greenwich: National Maritime 38. Young, AE.: Stopping the haemorrhage from
Museum 1981. peptic ulcer. Brit. med. 1. 284,530 (1982).
29. Smith, B.M., J.J.Skillman and B.G.Edwards: 39. Zuckerman, AJ.: Acute viral hepatitis. J. roy.
Permeability of the human gastric mucosa: al- Coll. Phycns Lond. 15,88-94 (1981).
3.4 Respiratory Diseases
w. H. G. Goethe and T. Ball
3.4.2 Common Cold, Influenza and in particular to the effect of the air-
conditioning. Iwanoff [8] and Iwanoff et al.
The relatively confined living quarters on [9], in a study of the occurrence of common
board ship provide a particularly favour- cold infections on board ship based on size
able environment for the spread of infec- of crew and duration of voyage (man-
tious diseases, especially those which are days), found a significantly higher inci-
airborne. In past centuries the problem of- dence on air-conditioned ships than on
ten reached epidemie proportions owing to non-air-conditioned vessels.
the large numbers of people living together The seamen working on deck and in the
in crowded conditions. On most of the superstructure on air-conditioned ships
world's merchant vessels the se amen are have a rate of diseases of the airways twice
still accommodated in shared cabins; it is as high as that among those on vessels
only on the more modem ships from the in- without air-conditioning, and on voyages
dustrially developed nations that the crew in tropical regions the difference is particu-
have individual cabins. larly great. The authors draw the conclu-
The crew of a ship is isolated from the sion that air-conditioning on board ship
normal continuous battle between a com- must conform to outside temperatures, not
munity ashore and the ever-changing in- to subjective comfort. For example, condi-
fecting organisms ubiquitous in that com- tions of 25°C and 50% relative humidity on
munity. The immunity of the crew may board are probably too cold in the hot, hu-
thus decline during a long voyage and ren- mid tropics and too warm in winter in
der the members more prone to infections northem latitudes.
as soon as they start to mix with landsmen The type of air-conditioning can in cer-
even at horne. Colds and similar illnesses tain circumstances be one of the contribu-
often spread like wildfire after the infection tory factors in the spread of infectious dis-
of one or more crew members by the local- eases. The air-conditioning system fre-
ly current common cold or influenza virus quently cannot co pe with unfavourable
in port. A few days after the ship has put to extern al macroclimatic conditions such as
sea it is not uncommon for most or all of high temperature and humidity, and the
the crew to have become infected. Depend- ship's engineers then often drive it partly or
ing on the pathogen, there may be only totally as a simple air-circulating unit, i. e.
slight symptoms or many crew members the cool, dry air is circulated without any
may suffer from fever and prolonged ill- admixture from outside. In this way the
ness, which can in some cases cause signifi- whole crew can naturally very quickly be-
cant problems in running the ship. come infected by any bacteria or viruses
Abrupt changes in climate are obviously present in the air.
an important causative factor. Ejsmont et In a study of respiratory diseases in the
al. [4] found that acute diseases of the re- United States Navy and Marine Corps,
spiratory tract occurred chiefly on sudden Hoeffler [7] found evidence to suggest that
changes of temperature in the macrocli- the use of suitably .constituted adenovirus
mate. vaccines lessens the frequency and severity
This problem is worsened on modem of respiratory illness in naval recruit popu-
ships by the powerful air-conditioning sys- lations. In merchant shipping, mass inocu-
tems, which impose an artificial microcli- lations against influenza are not often car-
mate and sometimes cause very strong ried out because of the difficulties in
draughts in the crew quarters. Naeve [15] organisation.
attributed the very frequent common colds
and the severe pharyngitis that he observed
on board to rapid changes in temperature
200 3 The Pathology of the Seafarer
21. Tuberkulose wieder auf dem Vormarsch. cyjnego odoskrzelowego zapalenia pluc po
Münch. med. Wschr. 125,8,10 (1983). zachlysnieciu sie ropa naftowa (A case ofbron-
22. Uselis, J., W. Ejsmont, L. Laba et al.: Gesund- chial aspiration pneumonia due to a choke with
heitszustand der Seeleute in der polnischen crude oil). Bull. Inst. mar. Med. Gdansk 15, 1/2,
Handelsmarine. In: Fragen der Schiffahrtsme- 83-85 (1964).
dizin. Internationales Symposium, Heiligen- 26. Zannini, D. and B. Tortori-Donati: Rilievi sulla
damm, 28-31 March 1963. pp 252-254. morbilita dei marittimi in navigazione. In: Atti
23. Uselis, J., A. Krynicki and S. Tomaszunas: dei primo congresso internazionale sull'assi-
Health condition of seamen examined at the stenza di malattia e la tutela infortunistica della
outpatient's division for occupational diseases gente del mare nei paesi della c. e. e. Genoa:
of the Institute of Marine Medicine in Gdansk Casse marittime per gli infortuni sullavoro e le
(1961-1963). Bull. Inst. mar. Med. Gdansk 15, malattie 1960. Vol. 2, pp 672-691.
213-218 (1964).
24. Vuksanovic, P. and H. Goethe: Diseases and ac- Addendum
cidents among seamen - An international com-
parison of distribution of diagnoses. Bull. Inst. 27. Di Nardo, u.: Su di alcuni aspetti particulari
mar. trop. Med. Gdynia 33, 1/2, 13-33 (1982). delle allergopatie nei marittimi. Atti della "Se-
25. Wojdat, W. and St. Winnicki: Przypadek aspira- zione studi" dei C. 1. R M., 75-81 (1963).
3.5 Musculoskeletal Diseases
O.A.JamalI
50
of 77 cases (15.5%) in 1980 and 17 of 102
cases (16.6%) in 1981.
45
Degenerative joint disease treated with
40 38% osteotomy (upper tibial or combined upper
35 tibial and femoral osteotomy) was infre-
~ 30 quent: 3 of 105 knees treated in 1979, 60f
0
~ 25 77 knees treated in 1980 and 5 of 102 knees
u
~ 20
treated in 1981. It accounted for 4.9% of
the total number of knee dis orders requir-
15
ing surgery over these three years.
10
5
3.5.3 The Hip Joint
1977 1978 1979 1980 1981
Yeor
Most of the patients needing hip replace-
Fig. 1. Operations perfonned on the knees as a per- ments were non-seamen or se amen retired
centage of the total number of orthopaedic opera- from active service. For example, of39 pat-
tions perfonned at the Dreadnought Seamen's ients who underwent total hip replacement
Hospital per annum
in 1980, only seven ofthe patients were be-
low the age of 50, the youngest being a
present, having occurred after injuries sus- 26-year-old male. However, over the 5-year
tained on a previous occasion. period ten seafarers were able to return to
Analysis of patients with surgical prob- work, albeit restricted to coastal duties.
lems in the knee presenting for exploration
of the knee joint during the three years 3.5.4 The Upper Limbs
1977, 1978 and 1979 shows that derange-
ment of the menisci accounted for 72 of Disorders of the hands (Dupuytren's con-
107 cases (67%) in 1977, 62 of 88 (70%) in tracture, tenosynovitis, ganglion) also ac-
1978 and 77 of 105 (73%) in 1979. These counted for a significant percentage of the
figures represent a remarkable consistency. musculoskeletal disorders needing surgical
The vast majority of cases presenting for care :
surgery had a history of sporting injuries to
the knee, mainly caused by playing foot- 1977 42/281 -14.9%
ball, in earlier years. Further exacerbation 197837/ 293 -12.6%
resulted from seafaring activities. Knees 1979611306 - 19.9%
certainly form the major bulk of the prob- 1980 52/258 - 20.2%
lems needing urgent surgical intervention. 1981 44/ 271 - 16.2%
This was born out in the Profile of Ortho- Recurrent dislocation of the shoulder is
paedic Surgical Practice reported from the a common c1inical problem seen at the
Naval Regional Medical Centre, Illinois Dreadnought Seamen's Hospital, and over
(Konkel et al. [1]). the above 5-year period shoulder problems
Infra- and pre-patellar bursae or en- accounted for the following percentages of
larged semi-membranous bursae are infre- c1inical cases needing surgical care:
quently seen - only six cases needed sur-
gery during 1977, 1978 and 1979, out of a 1977 7/281 - 2.5%
total nu mb er of 300 knees, i. e. 2%. 1978 5/ 293 - 1.7%
The knee joint was explored for condi- 1979 9/ 306 - 2.9%
tions other than derangement of the menis- 1980 7/258 - 2.7%
ci in 9 of 105 cases in 1979, i.e. 8.5%, in 12 1981 4/271 - 1.5%
3.5 Musculoskeletal Diseases 205
Cl>
30
27% 25% 3.5.6 Discussion
:5' 25
c: z~ ~
~
~ 20 ll5% ~ In a study of the disease patte~ in seamen
15 17.2% from seven countries, diseases'of the , mus-
10 culoskeletal system were fourth most fre-
quent, with a morbidity rate of 8.9% (Vuk-
sanovic and Goethe [3]). Disorders of the
o 1977 1978 1979 1980 19B1 knee joints produced the highest morbidity
Yeor
rate in our experience, accounting for 34%
Fig.2. Operations perfonned on the elbows and of all cases needing surgical care. Most of
hands as a percentage of the total number of ortho- these give a history of earlier injuries to the
paedic operations perfonned at the Dreadnought knee joints made worse by trauma on
Seamen's Hospital per annum board ship, caused through accidents on
the deck or in the engine room. It was not
3.5.5 The Trunk possible to associate any particular task or
type of work in either ship department with
Diseases of the trunk requiring laminecto- the occurrence of knee injury. The inci-
my or spinal fusion were confined to male den ce of knee disorders over a 5-year peri-
seamen. od of study appears to be constant (Fig. 1).
Table 1. Orthopaedic operations perfonned at the Dreadnought Seamen's Hospital, London, between
1977 and 1981
Classifi- Hips Spines Shoulders Knees Feet Misceil. Elbows Total no.
cation and hands of cases
Disorders related to the elbows and surgical care. It seems unlikely that this in-
hands accounted for 23% of all cases need- cidence of knee dis orders will change sig-
ing surgical care over the 5-year period. An nificantly in the coming years.
interesting feature was the dedine seen in Back pain will continue to be a signifi-
1981 (Fig.2). It is possible to foresee a de- cant disorder amongst seamen. Lifting of
clining incidence of hand injuries with the heavy weights on board will be necessary
changing techniques of handling cargo on even in the seafaring of the future. The
board and with modernisation of the stress factor "lifting" will be increased by
equipment in common use. the ship's motions (rolling, pitching, slam-
Recurrent dislocation of the shoulder is ming). Wrong techniques in lifting and car-
a small but interesting and continually re- rying heavy weights with a bent vertebral
curring problem amongst seamen both on column will lead to an increased risk of spi-
deck and in the engine room. Shoulder nal disorders. The seaman should be in-
problems account for only about 2% of the structed as to appropriate lifting tech-
cases needing surgical care. niques, i. e. lifting with a straight back while
The morbidity of recurring back prob- using the leg musdes to exert the lifting
lems has been adequately studied; facts force.
have been collated in different studies Tendonitis, bursitis and degenerative ar-
amongst seamen and have tended to indi- thritis are the cause of attendance in 30% of
cate that back disorders account for about the seamen presenting in the out-patient
one in ten cases presenting at out-patient dinics. The numbers needing surgical
dinics [Konkel et al. 1]. This figure agrees treatment, however, are considerably
dosely with the pattern observed at the smaller.
Dreadnought Seamen's Hospital in Green- Diseases of the hip account for a small
wich. Findings by Sevilia and Shafrir [2] in but significant number of cases needing
a Seaman's Outpatient Clinic of the Israel surgical care amongst seamen - about 2%.
Merchant Marine show considerable dif- Disorders ofthe upper limbs account for
ferences. The majority of the patients one-quarter of the surgical care needed in
(77.7%) consulted the dinic for back pains seamen, and as such their importance must
and among them 57% because of spondy- be recognised.
losis.
Konkel et al. [1] also report a low inci-
dence of spinal disorders needing surgery.
They state that axial skeleton operations References
account for only 0.92% of all cases involv-
ing orthopaedic surgery. In the Dread- 1. Konkel, K. F., H. L. Spencer and R. C. Elliott:
nought Seamen's Hospital over the 5-year Profile of orthopaedic surgical practice at a non-
teaching naval regional medical centre. Milit.
period between 1977 and 1981, ofthe 1409
Med.143,8,575-577(1978)
patients who underwent surgery, only 53 2. Sevilia, J. and A. Shafrir: Orthopedic diseases
had spinal disorders, i. e. less than 3.7%. treated in the Israel merchant marine seamen's
In summing up, orthopaedic diseases dinic. Atti della "Sezione Studi" deI C. I. R. M.,
form a high proportion of morbidity 249-253 (1968)
3. Vuksanovic, P. and H.Goethe: Diseases and ac-
amongst seamen and in a relatively young cidents among seamen - an international com-
and active group disorders of the knee parison of distribution of diagnosis. Bull. Inst.
joints provide most of the cases needing mar. trop. Med. Gdynia 33, 112, 13-33 (1982).
3.6 Venereal Diseases ("Sexually Transmitted Diseases" : STD)
J.Huisman
by private physicians and not by the offi- It should be accepted that there are dif-
cially designated "free" c1inics. ferences of opinion on the treatment of
Besides the provision of treatment, free venereal diseases at sea by laymen, espe-
of charge, to seamen ashore and of treat- cially syphilis and gonorrhoea. These dif-
ment on board by doctors or (trained) lay- ferences are conditioned not only by the
men, the importance of health education as opinions of shipping doctors and special-
a preventive measure cannot be stressed ists working in venereal disease c1inics but
enough. It should be directed at stimulat- also by government regulations concerning
ing the seaman to seek medical advice after treatment on board and the content of the
exposure and at enabling hirn to recognize ship's medicine chest. The following guid-
the symptoms of STD, and should be of- ance must, therefore, be regarded as the
fered in a way that is acceptable to modem opinion of the author.
seamen. It goes without saying that the
positive effects of social welfare, education
and recreation activities on board also play 3.6.2 Gonorrhoea
an important part in the prevention of STD
in seamen. Gonococcal infection causes purulent dis-
A few words about personal preventive charge from the anterior urethra with dys-
measures. The simplest of these, washing uria in men 2-7 days after infection. Some
with soap and water, has been widely advo- men, however, have no symptoms or symp-
cated, but the effect of this technique is, in toms so slight that there is no discomfort.
fact, to date undocumented. So-called Rectal infection, common among homo-
"prokits" were used by troops and naval sexual males, is at times also asymptomatic
personnel in World War 11. The exact but may cause pruritis, tenesmus and dis-
make-up of these kits varied but basically charge. It is evident that, in general, medi-
inc1uded a solution for urethral irrigation cal advice will be sought only in the case of
containing silver, mercury or permanga- symptoms. It is of prime importance that
nate and an ointment to be applied to the two or three urethral smears should be tak-
penis following intercourse. en from all patients with suspected gonor-
Although carefully controlled studies rhoea. On board ship, it may not be possi-
were not carried out, infection rates in per- ble for such a smear to be examined at
sonnel using kits were generally lower than once, but the glass slides, when dry, should
in non-users (Darrow and Wiesner [4]). be sealed in an envelope, dated, marked
Condoms have been in use for more than with the patient's initials and taken by hirn
400 years and when used properly appear for examination by the specialist when he
to be highly effective in preventing the visits the c1inic at the next port of call. Typi-
transmission of genitally located STD. cal Gram-negative intracellular diplococci
However, the value of the condom as an can be considered diagnostic in male ure-
STD prophylactic has been limited by im- thral smears. Bacterial culture on special
proper and infrequent use. Barlow [3] media confirms the diagnosis. Treatment of
showed that, when correctly and invariably gonorrhoea with inadequate doses of an-
used, the condom can be associated with tibiotics leads to resistant chromosomal
decreased incidence of gonorrhoea in par- mutants of Neisseria gonorrhoeae. The per-
ticular. Washing with soap and water and centage of strains less sensitive to penicillin
using condoms are advocated as preventive is considerably higher in countries where
measures in the International Medical drug controllaws are not strictly enforced
Guide for Ships [10], as is supplementary - the rate increased by 30% within 5 years
washing with 1 : 1 000 mercuric chloride so- in Ethiopia and by almost 13 % in 3 years in
lution (Wandel [15]). Singapore (Antal [2]).
3.6 Venereal Diseases 209
spread by sexual contact. Mter this "early cal false-positive reactions. A dark-field
syphilis" the disease enters astate of laten- examination is indicated in all suspected
cy during which the disease can be detect- cases of primary or secondary syphilis and
ed only by serological tests. Latency may is indispensable in early seronegative pri-
last many years but still be followed in mary syphilis.
some patients by the development of late Penicillin continues to be the drug of
lesions. For our purpose we will deal only choice for all stages of syphilis. Whenever
with early syphilis. The first steps are to there is a history of penicillin allergy, every
make an accurate diagnosis of syphilis, to effort should be made to confirm the spe-
establish the stage of the disease and then cific allergic state before choosing other
to consider it in relation to the patient's antibiotics, because these antibiotics have
wife, family, fiancee or other sexual consort been studied less extensively than penicil-
(male or female). For a disease with the lin. Treatment of early syphilis (primary,
consequences of syphilis, with a long peri- secondary or latent syphilis of less than
od of observation following treatment, an 1 year's duration) should be with a long-
accurate diagnosis is essential. acting benzyl penicillin (benzathine penicil-
Mter an incubation period of 10 days to lin) 2.4 mega-units total by intramuscular
10 weeks (usually 3 weeks) a primary lesion injection at a single session. Benzathine
appears, usually as a single papule at the penicillin is the drug of choice because it
site of initial invasion; after erosion it pre- provides effective treatment at a single visit
sents a variety of forms, the most distinc- [14]. This is of prime importance for the
tive (but not the most frequent) being an in- treatment of seamen.
durated, hard, painless chancre. Invasion Patients who are allergic to penicillin
of the bloodstream precedes the initial le- may be given tetracycline hydro chloride
sion, and a firm, non-fluctuant, painless 500 mg four times a day by mouth for
satellite bubo commonly follows. Mter 15 days or erythromycin (stearate, ethylsuc-
4-6 weeks, even without specific treatment, cinate or base) 500 mg four times a day by
the chancre begins to he al and a general- mouth for 15 days. In-patient treatment for
ized secondary eruption may appear. Syph- early syphilis is almost never indicated (ex-
ilitic exanthema, generalized lymphaden- cept in patients with very extensive lesions
opathy and condylomata lata or "plaques of secondary syphilis). All patients with
muceuses" are often accompanied by mild early syphilis should be encouraged to re-
constitutional symptoms (malaise, fever, turn for repeat quantitative, non-trepone-
headache, soreness of the throat, arthralgia mal tests 3, 6 and 12 months after treat-
and skeletal pains). The saliva and dis- ment. Careful follow-up serological testing
charges from sores in the (untreated) sec- is particularly important in patients treated
ondary syphilitic patient are highly infec- with antibiotics other than penicillin. Ex-
tious, but indirect transmission by contami- amination of the cerebrospinal fluid
nated articles must be considered rare. should be planned as part of the follow-up
Primary and secondary syphilis are con- visit after treatment with alternative anti-
firmed by dark-field (or phase-contrast) ex- biotics. Some prefer examination of CSF
amination of exudates of lesions or aspi- 2 years after treatment with penicillin. Gen-
rates from lymph nodes (if no antibiotic erally no penicillin should be administered
has been administered) and by serological on board ship by laymen to patients with
tests of blood. Positive tests with non-trep- undiagnosed genital or other sores of pos-
onemal antigens should be confirmed by sible venereal origin, and it must be ex-
tests employing treponemal antigens (i. e. plained to the patient that it is better to wait
fluorescent antibody or treponemal haem- till the next port of call. A course of sul-
agglutination) to aid in excluding biologi- phonamides (e.g. sulphadiazine) may be
3.6 Venereal Diseases 211
considered as many non-syphilitic genital applied. The latter should not be used
conditions will be cured by this, while not when a seaman presents his lesion only a
preventing syphilis being diagnosed later. few days before arriving in port, as it may
Only if it takes more than 3 weeks to re ach prejudice the dark-field examinations. De-
the next port of call and the symptoms are pending on the number of days before a
very suspicious, may penicillin treatment port is reached and the clinical picture (risk
as described be given. It is always best to of suppurating buboes), radiomedical ad-
seek radio medical advice in such cases. vice should be considered. Any case or sus-
Patients should be advised to visit a vene- pected case of chancroid must be referred
real disease clinic at the first port of call to a venereal disease clinic at the first port
and at the horne port the previous treat- of call so that the diagnosis can be con-
ment must be assessed by a specialist. If the firmed and syphilis excluded.
treatment is considered incomplete it might
be advisable to start again. 3.6.6 .Lymphogranuloma Inguinale
(Venereum)
3.6.5 Ulcus Molle
Tropical bubo or Nicolas-Favre's disease is
Chancroid or ulcus molle (soft sore) is an caused by Chlamydia trachomatis and is
acute infectious disease of the genital tract mostly seen in the (sub-)tropics. In temper-
caused by Haemophilus ducreyi. Most of- ate zones it is rare and mainly observed in
ten, the diagnosis of chancroid is made seamen as inguinallymphadenopathy. The
through the exclusion of syphilis, granulo- disease begins with a small painless ero-
ma inguinale and Iymphogranuloma vene- sion, papule or nodule, frequently unno-
reum. It is seen more often in the (sub-) ticed. The first signs and symptoms are,
tropics, especially in underprivileged therefore, often the painful swellings, of
promiscuous groups with poor body hy- the inguinallymph nodes (mostly unilater-
giene. al). The swollen lymph nodes become ad-
In temperate zones ulcus molle is seen in herent to the skin and may undergo suppu-
seamen and prostitutes in the big ports, ration, fluctuation and sinus formation.
where the incidence may be even higher General symptoms are fever, pain in the
than that of syphilis. The most important back and headache. Laboratory diagnosis
aspect of its treatment is the exclusion of is by demonstration of inclusion bodies in
syphilis. Any genital sore, whatever its ap- leucocytes of the bubo aspirate, by culture
pearance, should be suspected of being or by specific micro-immunofluorescence
syphilitic until proven otherwise. At least test.
three (daily) negative dark-field tests The complement-fixation test is positive
should be performed and negative serum earlier than the intradermal test with Frei
tests for syphilis should be obtained over a antigen. Treatment with tetracycline hy-
period of 3 months before syphilis can de- drochloride is effective in all stages. Dos-
finitively be excluded (Willcox [16]). The age: 500 mg four times a day orally for at
treatment of choice is sulphonamides (no least 10 days or longer as indicated by clini-
masking effect on syphilis), but more and cal response (4-6 weeks). Bed-rest is neces-
more sulphonamide-resistant ulcera mollia sary. Sulphonamides can be used when tet-
are observed. Sulphadiazine is given in an racycline is contra-indicated. Buboes should
initial dose of 2-4 g orally, followed by a not be incised but, if necessary, be drained
maintenance dose of 1 g every 6 h for 7-14 by aspiration. In the next port of call the
days. The sore should be washed with venereal disease clinic should be visited so
physiological saline, or a bum or wound that tests for syphilis and confirmatory skin
dressing without local antibiotic may be tests (Frei antigen) for lymphogranuloma
212 3 The Pathology ofthe Seafarer
inguinale can be performed. It should be transmitted diseases and its new aspects. Post-
realised that in 20% of patients with lym- grad. Course on STD. Amsterdam 1977.
3. Barlow, D.: The condom and gonorrhoea. Lan-
phogranuloma inguinale the non-trepone-
cet H, 811-812 (1977).
mal tests for syphilis are falsely positive. In 4. Darrow, W. W. and P.J. Wiesner: Personal pro-
the horne port, specialist assessment should phylaxis for venereal diseases. J. Amer. med.
be obtained. Ass. 244,444-448 (1975).
5. Eng, J. and A.Jensen: Serologiske erfaringen
ved rutinemessig unders0kelse av morske
3.6.7 Granuloma Inguinale sj0folk med Treponema Pallidum Immobiliza-
(Donovanosis) tion Test (TPI). Nord. Med. 64, 2-8 (1960).
6. Fergusson Ross, A. 0.: The different aspects of
Donovanosis is a chronic, non-fatal, mildly maritime venereal-disease contro!. In: Mari-
time Venereal-Disease Control, Selected Lec-
communicable bacterial disease of the ex-
tures Rotterdam 1953-1954, WHO, Reg. Office
ternal genitalia and inguinal areas of the for Europe. Geneva 1956.
body. The disease begins with a papule in 7. Goethe, H. and A.Backhaus: Die Gonorrhoe-
the genital area. This becomes a slowly Behandlung in der Schiffahrtsmedizin. z.
spreading serpiginous, granulomatous le- Hautkr. 52, 1,43-49 (1977).
8. Gonorrhea, CDC recommended treatment
sion, which is frequently painless. Usually schedules. J. Infect. Dis. 139,496-501 (1979).
the patient has no fever and does not feel 9. Hawks, D.: Getting the prostitutes offthe ships:
unwell. Calymmatobacterium granulomatis or health education as a design problem. Pub!.
(or Donovan body) is the aetiologic agent. Hlth Lond. 90, 5, 247-250 (1974).
10. International Medical Guide for Ships. Ed.:
The diagnosis is based on demonstrating
ILO, IMCO, WHO Geneva: WHO 1967.
the intracytoplasmatic Donovan bodies in 11. Morton, R. S.: Sexual freedom and venereal dis-
Giemsa-stained smears of granulation or ease. London: Peter Owen 1971. p.48.
biopsy material. Tetracycline hydrochlo- 12. Perine, P. L., R. S. Morton, P. Piot et a!.: Epide-
ride (500 mg four times a day orally for miology and treatment of penicillinase-pro-
ducing Neisseria gonorrheae. Geneva 1979.
10-20 days) is the specific drug for the (WHO Document WHO/VDTI79. 419)
treatment of donovanosis. As granuloma 13. Schokking, C.Ph.: The Brussels Agreement in
inguinale develops rather slowly, there is retrospect. In: Maritime Venereal-Disease Con-
no urgent need to start treatment on board. trol, Selected Lectures Rotterdam 1953-1954,
WHO, Reg. Office for Europe. Geneva 1956.
The condition requires examination by a
14. Syphilis, CDC recommended treatment sched-
specialist at a properly equipped clinic ules. Morb. Mort. Wkly Rep. 25, 101-107
ashore. Treatment on board should be di- (1976).
rected to the prevention of secondary infec- 15. Wandel, A.: Elementare Prophylaxe der Ge-
tion. In many cases, hospital admission will schlechtskrankheiten. Münch. med. Wschr. 114,
452-459 (1972).
be recommended. 16. Willcox, R.R.: The therapy ofvenereal diseases
in seamen. In: Maritime Venereal-Disease Con-
trol, Selected Lectures Rotterdam 1953-1954,
WHO, Reg. Office for Europe. Geneva 1956.
References 17. World directory of venereal diseases treatment
centres at ports. Geneva: WHO 1972.
1. The agreement ofBrussels 1924. Geneva: WHO 18. Tomaszunas, S.: Venereal diseases among mer-
1958. (Technical Report Series 150) chant seamen. Bull. Inst. mar. Med. Gdansk 13,
2. Antal, G. M.: The world situation on sexually 112,47-58 (1962).
3.7 Skin Diseases
Dorothy I. Vollum
Se amen are affected by a wide range of sis and eventually skin cancer in the fair
skin diseases which differ slightly in type skinned. As the effects of UVB are en-
and frequency from those found in the hanced by wind and potentiated by reflec-
population ashore. Conditions due to sun tion from the sea, seamen are particularly
exposure, irritant and contact dermatitis of at risk from them. Even in cloudy weather
the hands and fungal infections in the enough UVB penetrates to cause sunburn.
groins and feet are common but the more Sunburn can be intense and severe even in
usual chronic diseases such as psoriasis, the dark skin. The erythema comes within
atopic eczema and severe acne are not seen hours of exposure and may be associated
so often because shipping medical stan- with oedema and blistering. There may be
dards may not allow employment of men a high fever with shivering, headache and
known to suffer from them. vomiting. UVB stimulates epidermal thick-
Zorn [20] and Shaposhnikov [15], dis- ening and for some days after exposure in-
cussing skin disease in seafaring, have stat- creased melanin formation and tanning,
ed that fungal infections, dermatitis, oil which are protective. Treatment is to avoid
acne and solar dermatitis are frequent. further exposure until the erythema has
Büchner [3] reported that 17% of 38000 settled. The patient should be questioned
se amen had skin disease, the common con- to make sure that he is not taking any drugs
ditions being skin infection, irritant skin which may make him light-sensitive; sul-
disease, contact dermatitis and fungal in- phonamides, tetracycline and phenothia-
feetion. It should be noted that the diag- zines, to name a few. Mild bums will be
noses were not made by medical staff. soothed by frequent applications of cala-
Ambrosius [2] found that a clinical diag- mine lotion or cream and more severe ones
nosis of fungal infection was made in 63 respond to topical steroids with non-adher-
members of a crew of 102 on board a nu- ent dressings.
clear-powered merchant vessel and the di- Elastosis or changes due to degeneration
agnosis was confirmed by microscopy or in the dermal collagen ("sailor's skin") as a
culture in 31; the author emphasised that result of ultraviolet exposure are common
mycoses occur frequently in seamen. in fair skinned se amen in early middle age.
Goethe [7] suggested that fungal infec- The facial skin is thinned and markedly
tions in the hands and feet were common wrinkled while that on the back ofthe neck
in seamen, especially in tropical sea areas. may be deeply furrowed and thickened.
He blamed low standards of hygiene and The skin, particularly over the fqrehead
communal baths and showers. and temples, may have a yellowish hue and
the facial pigment may be irregular in dis-
3.7.1 Solar Changes tribution. In the older patient the changes
around the eyes are particularly marked
Ultraviolet radiation in the wavelength and there are multiple comedones. The V
290-320 nm (UVB) causes sunburn, elasto- of the neck, the forearms and backs of the
214 3 The Pathology ofthe Seafarer
hands, areas which are always exposed, are ways to wear covering clothing - shirts
similarlyaffected. with long sleeves and long trousers. The
Solar keratoses often present in all these tightness of the weave of the cloth is more
light-exposed areas but particularly on the important than the thickness or colour in
bald scalp, forehead, cheeks, backs of the protection against light (Welsh and Diffey
hands and forearms. They are yellow- [18]). A sunscreen should be used on the
brown scaly lesions up to a centimetre exposed areas at least once a day. Prepara-
across with a well-demarcated scale. The tions containing mexenone or para-ami-
scale is adherent and removal leaves a nobenzoic acid and its esters are suitable.
roughened surface with bleeding points.
The lesions are premalignant and any with 3.7.2 Urticaria
an enlarging or indurated base should be
biopsied. About 20% of patients with mul- Urticarial attacks occur in 10% ofthe pop-
tiple keratoses are said to develop squa- ulation so it is a fairly frequent cause of a
mous cell carcinoma in one lesion, but the generalised skin eruption in the fit seafarer.
incidence of metastases in carcinoma aris- Urticarial weals are raised and red and
ing from these keratoses is low, probably soon appear white centrally. They have a
less than 1% (Lund [11]). well-demarcated edge and vary in size con-
Seccia et al. [16], in their study of cutane- siderably. Each one lasts from 4 to 48 h. Ir-
ous tumours in sailors, found that 90% ap- ritation may be intense. Angio-oedema is a
peared on the exposed skin. variant of urticaria with deep subcutaneous
Multiple keratoses can be treated with swellings. The eyelids and lips are often af-
curettage and cautery, or a topical cytotox- fected and in a severe attack there may be
ic cream such as 5-fluorouracil applied dai- swelling of the tongue, laryngeal oedema
ly for ab out a month. Hydrocortisone and asthma. The weals are due to dermal or
cream can be used as well in an attempt to subcutaneous oedema from localised in-
reduce the resulting inflammation. Cryo- creased vascular permeability, and hista-
therapy with liquid nitrogen is also effec- mine is just one of the vaso-active media-
tive. tors released from mast cells and basophils
Rodent ulcers are not uncommon in the which may produce it (Munroe [13]).
same light-exposed areas, particularly on Acute urticaria may sometimes be due to
the face in older seamen. Nodules with a an immediate type I hypersensitivity reac-
pearly surface and dilated capillaries or su- tion to foods such as nuts, fish and eggs or
perficial ulcers which fail to heal and have to penicillin. The allergen links with IgE on
a beaded pearly edge are classical. How- the mast cell and histamine is released.
ever, any crusted or indurated lesion which Other foods and drugs may produce urti-
persists should be regarded with suspicion caria by non-immunogenic means but
and biopsy or cytology should be used to usually no cause is found and the condition
confirm the diagnosis. Adequate surgical resolves within a few weeks.
excision is the treatment of choice but cu- Chronic urticaria, which is arbitrarily de-
rettage and cautery can be used for smaller fined as an attack lasting more than
lesions and cryotherapy is an alternative 6 weeks, may sometimes be due to preser-
(Zacarian [19]). vatives and dyes in foods - benzoic acid,
Malignant melanomata also occur but salicylates and tartrazines. Occasional
are less common than keratoses and rodent cases clear after treatment of intestinal par-
ulcers. asitic infestations. Many drugs may pro-
Prevention of the damaging effect of ul- long or provoke an attack by histamine re-
traviolet light is important, and susceptible lease or other means; morphine, co deine,
fair-skinned seamen should be advised al- aspirin and indomethacin should all be
3.7 Skin Diseases 215
avoided in the patient with urticaria (Akers nematocysts in the sting cells. The cause of
and Naverson [1]). In cholinergic urticaria the weal is usually obvious as it comes out
small weals appear in association with more or less immediately after exposure
sweating after exercise or emotion. Cold and may be relieved by calamine lotion or
and pressure mayaiso cause urticaria topical steroids; supportive measures for
(Warin and Champion [171). the systemic side-effects may be necessary.
A history may suggest a cause and a gen- Patients with scabies may have occasional
eral examination should rule out an under- weals and dermographism.
lying systemic disorder, such as an early in-
fective hepatitis. If a routine blood count, 3.7.3 Miliaria
ESR and stool examination are normal, an-
tihistamines should be tried to suppress the Miliaria rubra or prickly heat occurs as a
condition. Hydroxyzine (Atarax) 10 mg result of obstruction to the sweat ducts. It is
t. d. s. and triprolidine (Pro-Actidil) 10 mg common in hot humid conditions in the
nocte may be helpful when promethazine tropics, particularly in men working in the
hydrochloride (Phenergan) and tartrazine- kitchens or engine room. Minute erythema-
free chlorpheniramine maleate (Piriton) tous papules in large numbers occur espe-
have failed. Keeping a food diary may re- cially in the flexures and in areas of friction
veal an unsuspected cause and eventually from clothing. There is an unpleasant sen-
challenge tests with dyes and preservatives sation of prickling irritation. The only relief
in foods may be helpful. A diet free of pre- is to stay in air-conditioned surroundings
servatives and dyes mayaIso be useful in the and wear loose cotton c10thing for a few
chronic case. Severe angio-oedema may re- days. The anhidrosis persists for at least
quire treatment with adrenaline 0.5-1 mg 3 weeks after an attack. As a result of the
subcutaneously or intramuscularly. A anhidrosis, hyperpyrexia may develop.
chronic recurrent urticarial reaction on the
trunk and arms in the crew of a tanker on 3.7.4 Hand Eczema
the Orinoco river was eventually found to
be due to the anal hair tufts of the female Hand eczema is a fairly common dis order
butterfly Hylesia canitia Stoll. The hairs in seamen and may threaten their employ-
were blown throughout the ship in the ven- ment. It is therefore important to identify
tilation system (Goethe et al. [6]). primary irritant and contact dermatitis as
The differential diagnosis inc1udes insect avoidance of the irritant or allergen may
bite reactions which depend on the type of achieve cure.
insect and the host's response to the inject- The eczema may be acute with vesic1es
ed irritant. There may be no reaction at all, and erythema or more chronic with erythe-
a tran sie nt macule or weal, or after 24 h a ma, scaling and fissuring. There are many
papule which persists for several days and patterns of constitutional eczema but in
often has a central punctum where the in- most the palms of the hands and the sides
sect proboscis has penetrated. The bites are of the fingers are affected, whereas in con-
usually grouped. Some, particularly mos- tact and irritant dermatitis it is the backs of
quito bites, may cause large solitary blis- the hands and fingers and frequently the
ters. ulnar borders ofthe forearms which are in-
Jellyfish stings cause urticarial reactions volved. Constitutional eczema tends to re-
at the site of the sting which often become lapse and recur. Irritant and contact der-
necrotic and haemorrhagic (Halstead [8]). matitis may complicate it or occur alone.
They may be associated with nausea, vom- Anyone exposed to an irritant substance
iting and sudden collapse. The weal is due for long enough in a high enough concen-
to the toxic substances introduced by the tration will eventually develop the irritant
216 3 The Pathology ofthe Seafarer
dermatitis. It is frequently seen in was hing- eral toe webs. The nails are often infected
up boys who do not wear protective gloves and dystrophic. Asymmetrical vesicular
and do not dilute the detergent according and bul10us lesions on the insteps are
to instruction and also in engineers ex- usual1y due to Trichophyton mentagro-
posed to oils and solvents. phytes, while the erythema and dry scaling
Contact dermatitis is an allergic reaction in a slipper distribution is usually a Tricho-
and as well as an acute eczema on the phyton rubrum infection. An acute tinea pe-
backs of the hands and fingers, the face dis will sometimes produce a secondary
and genitalia may be involved. Frequently vesicular eruption on the palms. The diag-
it is due to chemicals in rubber gloves, nosis of the foot infection should be con-
usually the accelerators, in which case the firmed by microscopic examination of the
sharp cut-off line at the level of the top of skin scales for fungus or by a positive my-
the glove is obvious (Cronin [5]). A seaman cological culture. A topical antifungal ap-
with endogenous eczema may wear rubber plication such as 2% miconazole cream or
gloves for protection and then become sen- econazole lotion or powder is suitable for
sitised. Most shipping companies now rec- treating toe web infections. More extensive
ommend PVC gloves. Every case of hand lesions should in addition have a course of
eczema which persists after the standard griseofulvin 500 mg daily until the skin is
treatment of avoiding water as much as clear, which usually requires several weeks.
possible, using emulsifying ointment in- Treating nail infections with griseofulvin
stead of soap and applying a topical steroid takes many months and is often unsuccess-
ointment should be referred for patch test- fu!.
ing. A yellow-brown scaling of the toe web
spaces may be due to erythrasma, a prop-
3.7.5 Skin Problems on the Feet ionibacterial infection. Examination und er
Wood's light shows a brilliant coral red flu-
Seamen often wear heavy protective boots orescence, and 2% miconazole cream is a
in tropical heat and the subsequent sweat- useful application. In very sweaty feet there
ing and maceration exacerbate any skin may be superficial erosions of the homy
conditions on the feet. Endogenous eczema layer of the epidermis and multiple pits on
on the feet may be associated with palmar the weight-bearing surfaces. This is a con-
eczema or occur alone. The insteps and toe dition known as "pitted keratolysis" and is
flexures tend to be involved symmetrically thought to be due to a propionibacterial in-
and the eruption is frequently vesicular or feetion. It usually responds to treatment for
bullous and later erythematous, fissured the hyperhidrosis.
and scaly. Contact dermatitis on the feet Groin rashes and irritation are common
can be due to sensitisation to boots and in seamen. Tinea cruris due to a dermato-
shoes. The plantar weight-bearing surface phyte causes erythema with a well-demar-
is involved when it is due to the soles. and cated scaly border and is readily recog-
the dorsum ofthe foot when it is due to the nised. Mycological examination should be
uppers - usually the dichromate used for used to confirm the diagnosis and the treat-
tanning the leather or the dye. ment is as for tinea pedis. In eczema of the
Tinea pedis or athlete's foot is a dermat- groins there is usually a history of spon-
ophyte infection of the homy layers of the taneous clearance and recurrence. There
epidermis. Trichophyton rubrum, Tricho- may be eczema elsewhere. The eczematous
phyton mentagrophytes and Epidermophyt- lesions often lack the clearly demarcated
on jloccosum are the usual ones. All three border of tinea. Here hydrocortisone or a
may present as a soggy intertrigo with fis- weak topical steroid applied once or twice
suring or as a vesicular eruption in the lat- a day is usefu!. Erythrasma gives a macular
3.7 Skin Diseases 217
hyperpigmentation with a well-demarcat- ient and his close contacts are treated at the
ed border which is often symptomless. same time to prevent re-infestation. After a
Wood's light examination shows the typi- bath 1% y -benzene hexachloride cream is
cal coral red fluorescence and treatment is applied from the neck down to and includ-
with systemic erythromycin 250 mg three ing the soles of the feet, covering all areas
times a day for 21 days and topical micona- of the skin. Another application is used
zole. Flexural psoriasis may present as 24 hiater, and 24 h after that the patient has
well-demarcated erythematous scaly inter- a bath, puts on clean underclothes and uses
triginous plaques in this area. Typical le- clean sheets. Alternatively benzyl benzoate
sions of psoriasis may be seen elsewhere on emulsion 25% can be used.
the body or in the scalp. Lice are small, grey bloodsucking insects
Tinea versicolor is a yeast infection fairly which crawl among the body hairs. Differ-
common in seamen working in hot humid ent types infest the scalp, body and genital
conditions. It is due to Pityrospornm orbicu- region - pediculosis capitis, corporis and
[are. It causes a macular rash on the trunk pubis. They are difficult to see as they are
and upper arms with dark brown, light alm ost translucent except after a meal of
brown or depigmented and slightly scaly blood. The head louse lays about ten eggs a
lesions. After sunbathing, the affected day which are cemented onto the base of
areas remain pale so that the eruption is the scalp hairs. The eggs hatch out after a
fairly unsightly. The diagnosis can be con- week to 10 days and as the hair grows the
firmed microscopically. Treatment with now empty egg cases or nits grow out with
econazole lotion or 10% sodium thiosul- it. Irritation from the lice causes excoria-
phate solution daily for a month is usually tion and secondary sepsis with occipital
effective but the condition tends to recur. lymphadenopathy. Scalp sepsis should al-
Recently ketoconazole in a dosage of ways suggest a search for nits, which are
200 mg daily for 28 days has proved suc- frequently found in the area just above the
cessful in the difficult case but liver- ears. Treatment is with malathion 0.5% or
function must be monitored (Jolliffe and carbaryl 0.5% lotion allowed to dry on the
Ngai [10]). hair and left on for 24 h (Maunder [12]).
This will kill the lice but not the egg, so the
3.7.6 Some Problems Due to application should be repeated after
Parasites 10 days when these have hatched. All close
contacts should also be treated, and combs
Scabies is a common cause of generalised and hair brushes which cannot be properly
irritation. It is due to infestation with the cleaned should be destroyed.
mite Sarcoptes scabiei. This burrows into Body lice cause a generalised irritation
the ho rny layer of the epidermis, laying with a macular erythematous eruption,
eggs as it travels. The burrows are about papules and many excoriations. The eggs
3 mm long and are seen as grey thread-like are found mainly in the seams of the cloth-
lines. They are found mostly between the ing and occasionally on body hairs. It is
fingers and on the flexor aspects of the easiest to destroy the clothing and bed
wrists. There is a characteristic generalised clothes ifthey are heavily infested or to put
papular excoriated rash. There may be them dry into a hot tumbier dryer. The pat-
some weals and dermographism is often a ient can be treated with applications of
feature. Persistent papules are common on benzyl benzoate or y -benzene hexachlo-
the scrotum and penis. The infestation is al- ride cream 1%.
ways transmitted by close bodily contact Pubic lice are usually acquired by sexual
and in the adult is usually acquired sexual- contact and other forms ofvenereal disease
ly. In treatment it is important that the pat- may have been transmitted at the same
218 3 The Pathology ofthe Seafarer
12. Maunder, J. w.: Clinieal and laboratory trials 18. Welsh, C. and B. Diffey: The proteetion against
employing Carbaryl against the human head solar aetinic radiation afforded by eommon
louse. Clin. Exp. Dermato!. 6, 605-612 (1981). clothing fabries. Clin. Exp. Dermato!. 6,
13. Munroe, E. w.: Urtiearia. Int. 1. Dermato!. 20, 577-582 (1981).
32-40 (1981). 19. Zaearian, S.A.: Cryosurgieal advanees in der-
14. Newhouse, M.L.: Dogger Bank Iteh: Survey of matology and tumours of the head and neck.
trawlermen. Brit. med. J.1, 1142-1145 (1966). Urbana: Thomas 1977.
15. Shaposhnikov, O.K.: Profilaktika dermatitov u 20. Zorn, E.: Die Bedeutung der Hauterkrankun-
mory akov. [Dermatitis prohylaxis among sea- gen bei Seeleuten. Berufsdermatosen 16,
farers]. Voen.-med. Zh. 7,77-79 (1973). 215-227 (1968).
16. Seeeia, A., R. Braeaglia and E. Farallo: La eute
dei marinaio egli epiteliomi; Problemi di fisio- Addendum
patologia eutanea. Terapia e prevenzione. Atti Rook, A., D.S. Wilkinson and F.J.G.Ebling: Text-
della "Sezione Studi" dei C. 1. R. M. 14 pp. book of dermatology, 3rd ed. London: Blaek-
(1978). weil 1979.
17. Warin, R.P. and R.M.Champion: Urtiearia.
Philadelphia: Saunders 1974.
3.8 Cardiovascular System Diseases
W.H.G.Goethe, T.BaIl
3.8.1 Morbidity, Mortality diseases in the Italian navy, Pons [21] found
that cardiovascular diseases took third
The increase of cardiovascular diseases pi ace with 11.4%. A comparison ofthe con-
(CVDs), especially hypertension, arte rio- ditions of merchant shipping and the navy
sclerosis, myocardial infarction, arterial oc- is, however, possible only to a limited ex-
clusive diseases, arrhythmias and circula- tent. In an analysis of the diagnostic statis-
tion disturbances, have been attributed to tics in an outpatient clinic for seamen,
certain harmful aspects of the environment Kraemer-Hansen [14] found 4.6% in ICD
and our way of life. group VII. In a thorough review of the lit-
In the statistical breakdown of diseases erature published on this subject, she
at sea, cardiac and circulatory disorders are points out that most authors found disease
not so common as among comparable pop- rates between 1.6% and 8.8%. Rates over
ulations on land, especially among those of 10% are very rare in the literature and are
developed industrial countries. This is defi- probably caused in most cases by different
nitely attributable to the more favourable assumptions and formulation of questions,
age structure among seamen and to the se- as weIl as by the difficuIty of classification.
lection procedures. Furthermore, the often too specialised se-
Applicants with cardiac and circulatory lection and the restriction to certain ship-
system diseases are eliminated at the pre- ping areas or certain types of activities may
liminary and periodic examinations for fit- be reasons for the range of variation.
ness for duty at sea. If such diseases occur Leaving aside their frequency, cardiovas-
during a voyage the seaman affected will in cular diseases exhibit a few particular char-
most cases become unfit for seafaring duty acteristics with regard to nautical medicine.
very quickly and will appear in the statis- Their possibly dramatic sudden occurrence
tics only once. As he is no longer a seaman, at sea and the associated problems of diag-
no relapse or new incidence will reappear nosis and therapy put these diseases in a
in the medical statistics of seamen. When special position.
comparing the statistical data of the Unfortunately, there are only a very few
morbidity pattern of seamen from seven statistical data available on the reason for
seafaring countries according to the Inter- the death of seamen during their career.
national Classification of Diseases [15], According to Otterland [19] the most com-
Vuksanovic and Goethe [29] found that mon medical cause of death among Swed-
cardiac and circulatory system diseases ish seafarers proved to be "heart disease".
(group VII of the ICD) occupied eighth In the sequence of the distribution of
pi ace with 4.8%. causes of death, accidents and violence led
There are, however, considerable differ- with 42%, followed by drowning with 22%
ences in the rates of the nations included, and diseases of the circulatory system with
varying between 2.1 % (Denmark) and 7.4% 10% (in third place). Unfortunately, this
(Fed. Rep. of Germany). In an analysis of latter term was not further differentiated
3.8 Cardiovascular System Diseases 221
(coronary heart disease?, cerebral stroke?). air temperatures and humidity. This indi-
The Danish Shipowner's Association has cates a semi-pathological condition.
published yearly reports of the mortality Vasilev [26] considers possible an ischae-
among Danish seafarers [1]. In a summary mic change of the myocardium through the
of the years 1971-1981 there were 513 alteration of the coagulation potential of
deaths. The most frequent reason was acci- the blood which he observed during long
dents (135 cases), followed by death ofun- sea voyages. A number of authors carried
certain cause (122 cases). Third in the se- out selected electrocardiographic examina-
quence were CVDs with 116 deaths, fol- tions on board ship. Di Nardo [9] found
lowed by carcinoma with 36. According to frequently occurring extrasystoles of differ-
British Department of Trade statistics on ent types and in some cases P-wave
the mortality of seamen whilst on articles at changes. Together with the changes in
sea, it was repeatedly found that 60%-70% blood pressure which he observed, he at-
of all deaths from disease at sea are caused tributes these findings to the c1imatic
by cerebral strokes and heart attacks in- changes during voyages.
c1uding CHD (Watson [31]). In contrast to Wittwer [33], in conducting selected elec-
the morbidity statistics, the mortality data trocardiographic investigations and deter-
of several seafaring countries demonstrate mining cholesterollevels of seamen on au-
that some of the cardiovascular diseases tomated ships, also found ECG changes,
may be of high risk to seafarers - higher which he interpreted as signs of stimulation
than all other diseases. of the autonomic nervous system in the
precordial lead. No definite correlation
3.8.2 Risk Factors with the degree of automation of the vessel
could be established. Waskiewicz and Ba-
The main risk factors, such as smoking, hy- naszkiewicz [30] made exhaustive investi-
pertension, obesity, arteriosc1erosis and gations into the state of the cardiovascular
psychological stress factors, are basically systems of Polish Ocean Lines seamen who
the same at sea and ashore. Some authors, were over 40 years of age. Among 307 offi-
however, point out specific aspects pertain- cers investigated in accordance with the ac-
ing to sea travel. Pons [21] mentions disor- cepted principles of c1assification of the
ders of the cardiovascular system brought Minnesota code, 69.38% of ECGs were
about by the influence of the ship's move- normal and 30.62% abnormal. The number
ments on the neurovegetative system and of abnormal ECGs among the officers in-
by vasomotor strain during voyages in the vestigated considerably exceeded the fig-
tropics. This strain is said to cause cardio- ures from studies of industrial populations
vascular diseases indirectly through gener- in Poland. Q-wave, ST-segment and T-
al arteriosc1erosis. Muzyka and Levina [18] wave disorders were considerably more
report on shipboard examinations showing frequent than similar abnormalities report-
a severe demand and stress on the cardio- ed in the literature concerning the industri-
vascular system during sudden changes of al population in the same age group.
c1imate.
Jungmann [12] arrives at similar conc1u- 3.8.3 Hypertension
sions, pointing out that adaptation of the
cardiovascular system to c1imatic changes Several authors mention blood pressure
will be achieved only after several weeks, changes and the tendency to hypertension.
especially on tropical voyages. Apanasen- Rizzo and Tumbiolo [22] examined 1175
ko [3] and Apanasenko and Gura [4] report seamen who were considered to be healthy.
on the increase of mean arterial blood pres- Hypertension was present in 16.9% of
sure caused by sea voyages in rather high those over 50 years of age. Hypotension
222 3 The Pathology of the Seafarer
was found in 15% of the same age group ship the most frequent are the acute forms,
and in 20% of those aged 25 years or under. such as collapse, hypotension and conges-
Among 8000 long-serving seamen of the tive heart failure. The higher incidence of
Russian merchant marine, Vinnikova and cardiocirculatory diseases is found among
Matsevich [28] found 5.9% with arterial hy- engine-room personnel and among the
pertension. "general stafr', with those worst afflicted
Bamatskii et al. [6, 7] report on hyperten- being ships' captains.
sion, which is common in seamen and is
thought to be in direct correlation with in- 3.8.4 Angina pectoris, Myocardial
creased salt consumption. They consider
successful prophylaxis with sodium hydro-
Infarction
gen carbonate to be possible. Wolf [34] It is surprising that only a very few authors
found a temporary increase in blood pres- deal with the occurrence of angina pectoris
sure in about 40% of the crew members of or myocardial infarction (coronary heart
ships travelling in or through the tropics disease - CHO) in seamen, which due to
and a temporary decrease in about 50%. At the frequently dramatic course of events
the end of the voyage 53% of the crew can cause considerable difficulties on
members showed an increased blood pres- board. In the years from 1955 to 1959 Oe
sure, which persisted even after disembar- Carolis and Odaglia [8] recorded an aver-
kation. In an examination of Polish seamen age frequency of 1.04% infarctions in Ital-
Filikowski [10] reports on the well-known ian seamen. Shishlova and Galich [24],
correlation between obesity and hyperten- writing about infarction in Russian sea-
sion. men, report that approximately 50% of
A number of very different diseases are myocardial infarctions appeared when the
to be found classified in group VII of the patients were in good physical condition
ICO cardiac and circulatory system dis- and did not show any symptoms of angina
eases. In his statistics conceming frequen- pectoris. Mazzoli [16] and Parodi [20] con-
cy, Pons [21] gives the following sequence: cemed themselves with varicosity and oth-
er peripheral vascular diseases in seamen,
Circulatory system disorders 64.3%
which in their opinion occur relatively of-
Angina pectoris 19.7% ten and can prejudice fitness for future
Myocardial infarction 11.6% duty at sea.
Phlebitis 2.2% Mundal et al. [38] investigated latent is-
Varicosity 2.2%
chaemic heart disease in sea captains. Of
Kraemer-Hansen [14] reports that the 110 apparently healthy Norwegian cap-
frequency distribution of diagnosis in the tains on ocean-going ships, a near maximal
material she worked on is as folIows: bicycle exercise test revealed a pathological
exercise electrocardiogram for 10.0%,
Cardiac disorders, including 55.11% while the corresponding results for a com-
hypotension parable group of Oslo men and a group of
Haemorrhoids (piles) 36.36% Norwegian sea pilots were 4.6% and 11.8%,
Varicosity, varicose ulceration, 9.53% respectively. The significant difference in
phlebitis prevalence between the captains and Oslo
men could not be explained by differences
Without giving exact data, Guida [11] ex- in serum lipids, blood pressure or a family
presses the opinion that diseases of the car- history of coronary heart disease. The cap-
diocirculatory system are more frequent tains were taller and more physically fit
among seamen than among other workers. than the Oslo men, but they were signifi-
Among the CVS illnesses found on board cantly heavier and had a more rapid age
3.8 Cardiovascular System Diseases 223
von 1966 bis 1975. Dissertation, University of stoyaniya serdechno-sosudistoy sistemy i ko-
Hamburg, 1977. agulogrammy u moryakov. (Indexes of func-
15. Manual of the International statistical c1assifi- tional state ofthe cardiovascular system and the
cation of diseases, injuries, and causes of death. coagulogram in sailors). Vrach. Delo 7, 26-29
Vol. 1 and 2. Based on the recommendations of (1980).
the Ninth Revision Conference, 1975, and 27. Vieweg, W. V.R. and D.A.Lee: Coronary artery
adopted by the 29th WHO Assembly. Geneva: disease: Hs impact on naval and marine corps
WHO 1977 and 1978. personnel. Milit. Med.139, 187-191 (1971).
16. Mazzoli, N.: Le flebopatie degli arti inferiori fra 28. Vinnikova, V. N. and L. M. Matsevich: Con-
la gente deI mare. (Phlebopathic diseases of the cerning the question of hypertension and ulcer
legs of seamen). In: Atti deI prima congresso in- morbidity of seamen. Bull. Inst. mar. trop. Med.
ternazionale sull' assistenza di malattia e la tu- Gdynia 25, 2/3/4, 221-224 (1974).
tela infortunistica della gente deI mare nei paesi 29. Vuksanovic, P. and H. Goethe: Diseases and ac-
della c.e.e. Genova, Napoli, Trieste: Casse cidents among seamen. - An international com-
marittime per gli infortuni sullavoro e le mal at- parison of distribution of diagnoses. BuH. Inst.
tie 1960. Vo1.2, pp 514-521. mar. trop. Med. Gdynia 33, 112, 13-33 (1982).
17. Multiple risk factor intervention trial. Risk fac- 30. Waskiewicz, J. and T. Banaszkiewicz: The eval-
tor changes and mortality resuIts.1. Amer. med. uation of the state of the circulatory system in
Ass. 248, 12,1465-1477 (1982). the officer personnel of the Polish ocean lines.
18. Muzyka, V. I. and T. I. Levina: Cardio-vascular 1. A general characterization of the investigated
system of maritime se amen during changes population. 11. Changes in ECG rest recording
connected with quick changes of c1imate. In: and in phonocardiographic recording. BuH.
VII International Symposium on Marine Medi- Inst. mar. trop. Med. Gdynia 32, 3/4, 153-158,
cine, 23-30 Sept. 1976, Odessa. Moscow 1976. 159-167 (1981).
p396. 31. Watson, N.: Personal communication 1983.
19.0tterland, A.: The mortality among seafarers. 32. Wittwer, N.: Beurteilung der Seetauglichkeit bei
Atti della "Sezione Studi" deI c.1. R. M. 39-52 Herz- und Kreislaufkrankheiten unter beson-
(1963). derer Berücksichtigung der Hypertonie.
20. Parodi, V. M.: Le vasculopatie periferiche nella Verk.-Med. 14,6,189-202 (1967).
gente di mare. (Diseases of the peripheral 33. Wittwer, N.: Ergebnisse elektrokardiogra-
blood-vessels of seamen). Lav. e Med. 13, 4, phi scher Untersuchungen sowie Cholesterol-
1-11 (1959). wertbestimmungen bei Seeleuten automatisier-
21. Pons, R.: La pathologie du marin et sa preven- ter Schiffe. Verk.-Med. 22, 10, 355-358 (1975).
tion. Rev. int. Servo Sante Armees 49, 7/8, 34. Wolf, J.: Veränderungen des Blutdrucks bei Be-
579-586 (1974). schäftigten in der Hochseeschiffahrt. In: Fra-
22. Rizzo, N. and A. Tumbiolo: Analisi dei valori gen der Schiffahrtsmedizin. Vorträge aus dem
pressori di un gruppo di marittirni. (Analysis of Intern. Symp. vom 28.-31.3. 1963 in Heiligen-
blood pressure among a group of seamen). Atti damm. Sonderheft des Medizinischen Dienstes
della "Sezione studi" dei C. 1. R. M. 89-94 des Verkehrswesens 1I. pp 175-181.
(1967).
23. Shani, E.: Personal communication 1980. Addendum
24. Shishlova, L.A. and Z.M.Galich: Course and 35. Kallio, V., H. Hämäläinen, J. Hakkila et a!.: Re-
results of myocardial infarction in seamen. In: duction in sudden death by a multifactorial in-
VII International Symposium on Marine Medi- tervention program after acute myocardial in-
eine, 23-30 Sept. 1976, Odessa. Moscow 1976. farction. Lancet p 1091 (1979).
p407. 36. KanneI, W. B. et al.: Sudden coronary deaths.
25. Toschev, G.: Dynamik der Herz-Gefäßkrank- The Framingham study. Ann. N. J. Acad. Sci.
heiten unter den Bedingungen einer Dis- 382,3-21 (1982).
pensairbetreuung der Schiffstransportarbeiter. 37. Mann, G. V.: Diet heart question. New Eng!. 1.
In: Fourth international symposium on marine Med. 297,644-650 (1977).
medieine, Varna, October 15-17, 1970. Sofia 38. Mundal R., 1.Erikssen and K.Rodahl: Latent
1972. pp 214-219. ischemic he art disease in sea captains. Scand. J.
26. Vasilev, N. F.: Pokazateli funktsionalnogo so- Work Environ. Hlth 8, 178-184 (1982).
3.9 Urologie Diseases
P.O.Oliver
In this chapter commonly occurring uro- ment of urinary flow, and dinical testing of
logie diseases which may affect either pas- the urine. Oliguria, with a urinary output of
sengers or ship's crew are covered. It less than 400 ml per day, is an indication of
should, however, be understood that cer- renal failure whereas polyuria, with a uri-
tain of the methods of treatment advised nary flow of 3-4 litres per day, may be sug-
could be carried out only on a passenger gestive of diabetes mellitus, chronic renal
liner or other ship carrying a doctor. The disease or diabetes insipidus. Nocturia
extent of the treatment given in a merchant may indicate bacterial cystitis. The colour
ship would depend entirely on the training and appearance ofurine may prove signifi-
and competence of the ship's officer re- cant. Red urine usually indicates the pres-
sponsible for health care and the content of ence of red blood cells whereas a dark
the medical ehest aboard the ship. Some of brown urine leads to a suspicion of ob-
the more complicated surgical procedures structive jaundice. Milky urine may suggest
discussed could, of course, be carried out chyluria; bright green or blue, the presence
only by a specialist in urology ashore. of methylene blue from proprietary kidney
The kidneys are concerned not only with pills.
the excretion ofthe end-products ofmetab- Radiological investigation, induding
olism and of foreign products and their excretion urography, renal pyelography
metabolites but also with the maintenance and angiography, plays a part in the diag-
of the tissue fluids at a constant composi- nosis of renal disease. Additional informa-
tion. In doing so they ass ist in maintaining tion can be obtained by direct inspection of
the pH and volume of the urine within the urinary tract by cystoscopy or urethro-
physiological limits. The dinical features scopy coupled with ureteric catheterisa-
of renal disease arise from disturbances of tion. The more recent developments of
renal function or as a result of pathological radio-isotope and computerised scanning
changes in the renal tract. There is often no are useful adjuncts in diagnosis. In certain
dose relationship between the disease pro- cases renal biopsy is of value. The impor-
cess and the disturbance of renal function tance of correct diagnosis in seafarers suf-
(Robson [10]). Diagnosis frequently results fering from renal disease cannot be over-
from abnormalities in the urine or blood emphasised and no seaman should be
and for this reason careful examination of allowed to be at sea until all underlying re-
the urine is essential in order to determine nal disease has been eliminated. Arecent
abnormal urinary constituents or bacterio- study of the causes of medical attendance
logical involvement. Likewise, chemical aboard British merchant vessels demon-
analysis of the blood with estimates of glo- strated the high incidence of diseases of the
merular function are useful procedures in genito-urinary system in seafarers (Oliver
estimating renal dysfunction. [6]).
Valuable information can however be
obtained by simple observation, measure-
3.9 Urologie Diseases 227
3.9.1 Urinary Tract Stone the engineers was much higher than the
sickness rates of the firemen and mechan-
The high incidence of urinary stone in the ics.
seafaring community has long been recog- Pellegrinelli [7] stated that, of all insured
nised as a major source of dis ability. It is Italian seamen in the period from
estimated that around five new cases per 1957-1958, 0.836% suffered from kidney
annum occur in every 10000 ofthe popula- disease. Of all nephropathies the most fre-
tion in the United Kingdom, with a pre- quent was kidney stone, which made up
ponderance of males over females of 2:1. 60.8%.
Of particular significance to seafarers is the Nearly all of the authors discussed the
fact that over half of all cases will suffer a reason for the frequent occurrence of uro-
recurrence within 10 years, and although lithiasis. Macro- as well as microclimatic
the majority of stones are passed spontane- loads, especially during tropical voyages,
ously, some 30% will necessitate surgical are considered a main cause.
removal. A variety of conditions are fre- They report that kidney stone was pre-
quently associated with stone formation, dominantly diagnosed in seamen who are
all of which may, to some degree, contrib- repeatedly on longer tropical voyages.
ute to its causation. Persistent crystalluria The majority of patients presenting with
due to oversaturation of urine with aggre- stone disorders have calculi consisting of
gation of acids and salts often associated calcium oxalate or calcium phosphate, the
with c1imate or occupation, particularly in greatest number being idiopathic in origin
conditions involving excessive sweating and resulting from increased urinary cal-
and reduced urinary output, places seamen cium oxalate associated with changes in
at high risk. Other factors such as urinary pH and urinary volume. The diagnosis of
infection and stagnation, biochemical urinary calculi is rarely in doubt as the dull
changes and metabolic or genetic abnor- ache located in the lumbar region, often ac-
malities are significant. companied by severe renal colic, is unmis-
There are only a very few nautical medi- takable. As the calculus passes down the
cal publications dealing with kidney dis- ureter, pain may be excrutiating and radi-
ease in general and urinary stone in partic- ate down into the scrotum. Such symptoms
ular. Ejsmont [4] stated that 8.1 % of 446 are usually associated with haematuria
Polish seamen treated in hospital for dis- and, occasionally, obstruction to the uri-
eases of the urinary system suffered from nary flow.
urinary stone. Arduini and Rizzo [1] found Patients suspected of having a renal cal-
urinary stone in 4.35% of hospitalised Ital- culus require radiological examination of
ian seamen, while Renke and Bublewska the urinary tract, preferably by intravenous
[8] reported on another group of seamen pyelogram, and urinary analysis to deter-
admitted to hospital, 5.9% of whom suf- mine biochemical constituents and asso-
fered from urinary stone. ciated infection. The immediate treatment
In a study on the occurrence ofurolithia- of severe kidney pains or colic involves bed
sis in the Royal Navy, Blacklock [2] found rest, warmth to the site of the pain and ad-
that especially the engine staff and the offi- ministration of pain-relieving drugs such as
cers were prone to this condition. The inci- pethidine 100mg or morphine hydrochlo-
dence rate was almost twice as high as that ride 15-30 mg by injection, repeated at in-
among other occupational groups on tervals of 2-3 h if necessary. Fluid intake
board. should be increased to at least 4litres daily
Arduini and Rizzo [1] reported a much and more under tropical c1imate condi-
higher frequency rate in ordinary seamen tions. Antispasmodic drugs, like atropine
than in officers; also the sickness rate of sulphate 0.9 or 1 mg intramuscularly, may
228 3 The Pathology of the Seafarer
in structurally normal urinary tracts. Al- ficult and maintenance antibiotic therapy
though symptoms may indicate involve- may be necessary for several months to
ment of the lower urinary tract such as prevent recurrence. A regular daily dose of
bladder or urethra, it is usually considered cephalexin 250 mg or nitrofurantoin 50 mg
that the kidneys and upper urinary tract are may prove effective. Particular attention
inevitably involved. should be paid to personal hygiene and
Acute pyelonephritis is characterised by avoidance of triggering factors such as
infection in the renal parenchyma and pel- vaginal deodorants.
vis of the kidneys and is associated with se-
vere constitutional symptoms, such as fever 3.9.4 Haematuria
and rigors. Symptoms of urinary infection
with renal pain, frequency of micturition The appearance of blood in the urine to
and haematuria are apparent. The condi- any significant degree is usually apparent
tion should not be confused with acute ap- to the naked eye, although certain other
pendicitis, and urinalysis should normally causes of a red urine, such as intermittent
establish the true diagnosis. Treatment porphyria and drug-induced changes,
should be directed to eradication ofthe uri- should be excluded. Careful urine micros-
nary infection by the early commencement copy is essential to establish the correct di-
of appropriate antibiotic therapy, for ex- agnosis, particular care being taken to ex-
ample, ampicillin, co-trimoxazole or nitro- clude false-positives. Normal urine con-
furantoin. Chronic or recurrent urinary tains less than five red blood cells per mm3•
tract infection is an indication for long- Multistix blood tests are reliable in carry-
term chemotherapy in the form of ampicil- ing out routine screening procedures, al-
lin 250 mg twice a day or nitrofurantoin though they do not prove that the blood is
50 mg twice a day. Co-trimoxazole 480 mg glomerular in origin. The distribution of
daily is a useful alternative. the haematuria may be significant as an ini-
Investigation ofurinary tract infection in tial blood-stained urine is suggestive of a
adults should always require the quantita- lower urinary tract source whereas a uni-
tive bacterial culture of a mid-stream urine formly blood-stained urine is characteristic
specimen together with adetermination of of an upper renal source. Kidney involve-
red and white blood cell concentrations. ment is confirmed by the presence of red
Catheterisation should be avoided. Men of blood cell casts in the urine. The classical
all ages with a urinary tract infection description of painless intermittent hae-
should be fully investigated to exclude an maturia as an indication of neoplasm and
underlying obstruction to the renal tracts, painful haematuria as due to infection may
such as prostatic hypertrophy. Seafarers be misleading.
with a history of uncorrected recurrent re- Red cells may be found in the urine in a
nal infection should not be permitted to re- variety of clinical conditions involving the
main at sea. urinary tract which can be diagnosed by
With the increasing number of women the presence of characteristic symptoms
being employed at sea, the incidence of and signs in addition to haematuria. In-
cystitis has steadily risen. The high inci- flammation of the kidney and urinary tract,
dence of lower urinary tract infection in acute glomerulonephritis, tumour and re-
women during the reproductive years is nal ca1culi will each present a classical pic-
now recognised although significant bac- ture. Haematuria as the sole presenting
teruria is often lacking. Symptoms consist symptom may be indicative of renal tu-
of increased frequency of micturition asso- mour or tuberculosis, bladder papilloma or
ciated with dysuria. Treatment of recurrent malignancy, prostatic benign enlargement
cystitis in women can prove immensely dif- or carcinoma. In those individuals who
230 3 The Pathology of the Seafarer
have been resident in the tropics, schisto- course of afebrile illness. In the nephrotic
somiasis should not be overlooked. No in- syndrome large amounts of protein may be
dividual with a history of haematuria excreted - the daily output is normally in
should be permitted to return to seagoing excess of 5 g and may exceed 10-15 g. The
duties or to embark as a passenger on a majority of cases are due to glomerulo-
long sea voyage without thorough renal nephritis, though some are drug induced or
tract investigation to determine the und er- associated with carcinomata.
lying pathology and without the common Persistent proteinuria, even in a young
causes of haematuria, being excluded. Par- person, should never be regarded as a be-
ticular care should be taken to recognise nign condition until full renal investiga-
patients on anti-coagulant therapy or suf- tion, including kidney biopsy if necessary,
fering from thrombocytopenia; such pat- has proved negative. Chronic renal disease
ients present a serious hazard at sea should is a disabling condition and is a contra-in-
a sudden and catastrophic haemorrhage dication to seafaring. All cases of protein-
occur without appropriate medication be- uria detected at pre-engagement medical
ing available. examination should, therefore, be thor-
oughly investigated before an assessment
3.9.5 Proteinuria of fitness for seagoing duties is made.
for patients with a history of bladder tu- 3.9.10 Disorders of the Testes
mour, however successfully treated, to
serve at sea. 3.9.10.1 Undescended Testes
It is estimated that 0.7% of testes remain
3.9.9 Renal Tuberculosis undescended into the scrotum after the 1st
year. The seminiferous tubules develop be-
Tuberculosis of the kidney tends to occur
tween the 5th and 9th year and it is there-
in young people and is invariably second-
fore advisable to recommend orchidopexy
ary to' tuberculosis elsewhere, resulting
before the age of 6 years if fertility is to be
from blood-borne infection. Regrettably,
preserved.
the incidence of genito-urinary tuberculo-
Despite the awareness of the need for
sis has not fallen in line with that of pul-
early corrective surgery, cases of unde-
monary tuberculosis. Unlike the latter,
scended testes are still encountered in the
where radiography has proved such a valu-
course of routine pre-engagement medical
able diagnostic procedure, genito-urinary
examinations in young adults. Such indi-
tuberculosis is difficult to diagnose. The
viduals should undergo orchidectomy in
disease usually manifests itself with hae-
view of the high risk of malignancy. The
maturia and dysuria in addition to which
annual incidence of testicular tumour is
the general symptoms of tuberculosis, i. e.
more than 2 per 100000 males and this is
malaise, pyrexia and weight loss, may be
increased 35 times if the testic1e remains
apparent. Urine is often sterile on examina-
undescended. In addition to the removal of
tion or may show evidence of secondary in-
the undescended testis, surgery should aim
fection typical of a bacterial cystitis. Tuber-
to give the genitalia anormal appearance
culous cystitis is always secondary to a
by insertion of a plastic testicular prosthe-
tuberculous focus in the kidneys which is
sis. Unilateral orchidectomy does not af-
usually recognisable on radiological ex-
fect fertility or testosterone function. No
amination following an intravenous pyelo-
person should be permitted to embark on a
gram. Urine culture, either from the blad-
seagoing career with an undescended testis
der or both ureters, demonstrating acid/al-
not corrected by surgery.
cohol fast bacilli should confirm the diag-
nosis and enable early treatment to com-
mence, even before final culture is conclu- 3.9.10.2 Torsion of the Testis
sive. Standard oral treatment of tuberculo- Sudden severe pain originating in the testi-
sis in the form of rifampicin, isoniazid and c1e, scrotum or groin in a young man in his
pyrazinamide is effective and should be teens or early twenties is typical of this con-
continued for at least 6 months. Nephrec- dition. Care must be taken not to confuse
tomy or epididymisectomy is indicated on- this sudden emergency with that of an
ly in the cases where the tuberculous lesion acute epididymo-orchitis, which is uncom-
is weIl advanced and tissue destruction ex- mon in this age group. Torsion of the testis
tensive. Surgery may be of value in reliev- is attributed to congenitally abnormal at-
ing the complications of urethral stricture tachments permitting a twisting of the mes-
and fibrotic bladder following chemother- entery ofthe testis within the tunica vagina-
apy. Very careful appraisal and follow-up lis. Unless there is conc1usive evidence of a
studies for at least 2 years should be under- urinary tract infection, surgical exploration
taken before considering an individual fit is essential. Failure to relieve the torsion
to return to seafaring duties. The risk of re- within 4 h of onset of symptoms may result
lapse is always present and the difficulties in serious and irreparable testicular dam-
of diagnosis formidable in a seagoing situa- age. Under seagoing conditions it is better
tion. to risk an unnecessary operation ofthis na-
3.9 Urologie Diseases 233
The seaman has to adapt to continually physician will find that often he is consult-
changing conditions in which the work and ed by patients of a different race, culture
rest periods scarcely differ (Dolmierski and language. As part of the disorder the
[12]). The monotony of life is often hard to patient may not wish to talk about his
bear and the continual noise and vibration symptoms and, consequently, crew mates
and the possible hazards of the cargo, will be unaware of his suffering and unable
among other factors, are undoubtedly fre- to contribute to the his tory of the disease.
quent causes of disturbance, particularly in The majority of cases will not be examples
the form of neuroses (Dolmierski and de of florid, mental disorders but they will fall
Waiden [7]). into the category of borderline distur-
In the long term a combination of ner- bances which are inevitably difficult to
vous tension, worry and homesickness may assess.
cause areaction, the harmful effect of In evaluating the mental state of the pat-
which is sometimes greater than that of a ient, the usual history taking and observa-
single mental shock. These factors may be tion ofthe patient will also present difficul-
connected with work, family worries or en- ties. His behaviour, personal hygiene,
vironmental conditions and have unpleas- means of self-expression and relationship
ant effects ranging from nervous tension to to the rest of the crew will vary from ship to
psychoneurotic behaviour (Bilikiewicz [1]). ship according to race and culture. It may
Over-fatigue, lack of sleep, the unsettled be time consuming and require great thor-
way of life and other factors also lead to oughness to evaluate and put in proper
psychoneurotic reactions. perspective observations such as level of
Atmospheric and climatic influences are mood, restlessness or anxiety.
important contributory causes of neuroses The system of periodic routine medical
which are often underrated by doctors. examination will have excluded seafarers
Sexual trauma and the lack of continuity in suffering from chronic mental disorder.
the sex life are also very important aspects Typical cases usually present as acute func-
in the evaluation of the seaman's mental tional disorders. For the most part they are
health. In the same way, one has to consid- connected with somatic conditions such as
er internal factors which do not arise from infection, trauma or poisoning or with al-
change of environment, but are rather an cohol misuse. They are sometimes due to
expression of the attitude of the given per- growing conflicts during long voyages but
son towards his surroundings. Difficulty in one has to remember that the conflicts of-
making social adjustments mayaiso playa ten stern from mental dis orders which have
part in the development of neurosis (Dol- begun to develop earlier.
mierski and Nitka [6]).
In dealing with seafarers, it is consider-
ably more difficult to assess mental health
than it is to diagnose organic disease. The
3.10 Mental Disease 235
(Bilikiewicz [1]). The formation of person- ing great resilience. Anyone developing a
ality, normal or abnormal, depends on var- mental disorder should be placed in the
ious biologieal, genetic factors and on ex- ship's hospital (if there is no hospital, in a
ternal environmental influences. The bor- separate cabin) under continuous supervi-
der between normal and pathological is sion.
here indistinct. One accepts, not taking into Mental disorder is here taken to include
consideration the aetiology of distur- not only cases of acute psychosis with great
banees, that all character deficiencies are psychomotor agitation, but also, for exam-
included under psychopathy. pIe, depressive states, which very often lead
At present we believe most cases of to suicide attempts, sometimes successful.
pathological alterations of the character to Medication consists of neuroleptics (avail-
result from organic lesions of the central able on board ship in special medicine
nervous system. The most typical symp- chests), mostly chlorpromazine hydrochlo-
toms of pathological alterations of the ride at 150-300mg124h in three doses of
character are irritability, sudden rages, the 50-100 mg injected deep into muscle. One
tendency to impulsive actions and affective should remember that high dos es of neuro-
discharge in the form of fits of fury due to leptics lead to orthostatic disturbanees,
narrowing of the area of consciousness/ manifested as a sudden decrease in arterial
awareness (Cramer [2]). Other peculiarities pressure, and if this occurs the patient's
are similar to those in psychopathy, i. e. ly- head must be lowered. It may be necessary
ing, stealing, laziness, lack of discipline and to give hirn drugs which improve circula-
inability to live together with other people, tion, and if they have no calming effect,
all to the detriment of good relationships. one can give one injection of phenobar-
Furthermore, the patient can show lack of bitone sodium 200 mg intramuscularly.
reserve, cruelty, a tendency to addiction Should the agitation persist, the patient is
(particularly to misuse of alcohol and drug to be tied carefully to the bed, the bonds
dependence), sexual extravagances and un- securing the lower and upper extremities
ethical or criminal behaviour. The atmo- and the ehest. When the patient calms
sphere on board ship, particularly during down he can be released. Even when the vi-
very long voyages, is disturbed by individu- olent phase has passed, one should not
als with a pathologically altered character, keep the patient on the ship, but put hirn
whom we used to evaluate from the point ashore in the nearest port for hospitalisa-
of view of morality instead of treating them tion or transfer hirn to another ship with a
as ill owing to lesions ofthe central nervous doctor on board. Conversation with the
system. Such individuals should be subject- patient should be of a calming nature; his
ed to specialist examination, and if symp- delusions should not be discussed for fear
toms and signs of an organic lesion of the of aggravating the situation. Psychiatrie
nervous system are found they must not treatment on board is difficult, and there-
continue to work in an occupation as ardu- fore only emergency measures are possible.
ous as that of seamen. Detailed instructions can be obtained by
radiomedical advice, and specialist treat-
3.10.7 Treatment of Mentally III ment in the nearest port.
Crew Members on Board Ship
The attitude of society to a mentally ill per- References
son is an indicator of the culturallevel. It is
obvious that a mentally ill person cannot 1. Bilikiewicz, T.: Psychiatria kliniczna [Clinical
work at sea, as this profession requires the psychiatry]. 5th ed. Warsaw: Panstwowy Za-
appropriate mental characteristics, includ- klad Wydawnictw Lekarskich 1973.
242 3 The Pathology of the Seafarer
2. Cramer, A.: Strukturen des vorsprachlichen 10. Dolmierski, R and K.J. de Waiden: Ocena
Eindrucks- und Ausdrucksverhaltens in der kliniczna przyczyn samob6jstw u marynarzy.
Leidensgebärde. Nervenarzt 42, 607-609 [Clinical evaluation of the cause of suicides
(1971). among seamen]. Psychiat. po!. 3, 255-258
3. Dolmierski, R, K.J. de Walden-Galuszko and (1972).
J. Nitka: Alkoholism a zdolnosc do pracy w 11. Dolmierski, Rand J.Nitka: Stosowanie Espe-
Polskiej Marynarce Handlowej. [Alcoholism ralu w leczeniu alkoholizmu u marynarzy.
vrs. work ability in Polish merchant marine]. [Usage of Esperal in alcoholism therapy of sea-
Ann. Acad. med. Stetinensis, Supp!. 10,95-100 men]. In: Zagadnienia zdrowotne w gospodarce
(1973). morskiej. Warsaw: Pailstwowy Zaklad Wy-
4. Dolmierski, R, K.J. de Walden-Galuszko and dawnictw Lekarskich 1980. pp. 117-119.
J. Nitka: Analysis of cases of mental distur- 12. Dolmierski, R.: Zaburzenia nerwicowe mary-
bances in the light of present regulations and narzy. [Neurotic disorders in seamen]. Ann.
rulings of the medical appeal board in years Acad. med. Stetinensis, Supp!. 10,79-84 (1973).
1971-1972. BuH. Inst. mar. Med. Gdansk 24, 13. Galuszko, P.: Niekt6re problemy powstawania
243-51 (1973). nerwic u marynarzy floty handlowej. [Some
5. Dolmierski, R. and J. Nitka: A preliminary ap- problems conceming the sources of neuroses
praisal of the state of the central nervous system among seamen of merchant marine]. In: Pa-
in the seamen of the Polish merchant marine. mietnik 28. Naukowego Zjazdu Psychiatr6w
BuH. Inst. mar. trop. Med. Gdynia 26, 1, 17-24 Polskich, Lublin 1963. Warsaw: Pailstwowy
(1975). Zaklad Wydawnictw Lekarskich 1965,
6. Dolmierski, Rand J. Nitka: Estimation of the pp. 69-75.
occurence of neurotic disorders in sea economy 14. Hopkinson, G.: Delusions of infestation. Acta
workers exposed to the action of electromag- psychiat. scand. 46, 111-119 (1970).
netic waves. BuH. Inst. mar. trop. Med. Gdynia 15. Kepiilski, A.: Psychopatologia nerwic. [Psy-
27,1,57-61 (1976). chopathology of neuroses] Warsaw: Pailstwowy
7. Dolmierski, Rand K.J. de Waiden: Environ- Zaklad Wydawnictw Lekarskich 1972.
mental factors causing neurosis in seamen. BuH. 16. Kretschmer, W.: Reifung als Grund von Krise
Inst. mar. Med. Gdansk 23, 1/2, 7-11 (1972). und Psychose, Untersuchung zum psychia-
8. Dolmierski, Rand J. Nitka: Häufigkeit der trischen Entwicklungsgedanken. Stuttgart:
Neurosen unter den Besatzungen der polni- Thieme 1972.
schen Handelsmarine. Verk.-Med. 25, 5, 219- 17. Weitbrecht, H.-J.: Psychiatrie im Grundriß. 3rd
222 (1978). ed. Berlin, Heidelberg, New York: Springer
9. Dolmierski, Rand J. Nitka: Neurosen und Lei- 1973.
stungsfähigkeit auf See bei der polnischen Han-
delsmarine. Verk. Med. 25, 5, 223-228 (1978).
3.11 Other Diseases (Neurologieal, Ophthalmie, ENT
and Other Conditions)
W. H. G. Goethe
included in the group of "neurological dis- sures to prevent permanent damage in case
eases and diseases of the sense organs". of acid bums of the eye. Furthermore, he
Consequently, ophthalmic and ENT dis- gives instructions on how to treat perforat-
eases often do not appear in the compara- ing injuries and contusions of the eye-ball,
tive statistics as separate figures. Offer-Ohl- glaucoma, arc eye etc.
sen [22] found that diseases of the eyes Hager [14] emphasizes that the medical
account for about 3% of all diagnoses in training of ships' officers should include
Norwegian seafarers. In detail, conjuncti- the treatment of eye diseases and injuries.
vitis predominated at 55%, while "eye He is of the opinion that an adequately
aches" at 20% and refraction disorders at equipped ship's medicine chest and even
17% were the other major complaints. the facilities of radiomedical advice are
Several authors dealt with the impor- useless if the ship's officer in charge does
tance of eye injuries caused by accidents not possess the required basic skills which
and their secondary effects. Bietti and Van- include: description of the state of the eyes
ni [4] gave practical advice on urgent first after examination, opening of the eyelids
aid for injuries of the eyes. They distin- with eyelid retractor, rinsing of the con-
guish between four kinds ofbasic injury: junctival sac, administration of eye-drops
1. Injuries caused by foreign bodies at the and ointment, description of the state of
conjunctiva and the cornea and injuries the cornea upon lateral reflection, rem oval
caused by penetration; of foreign bodies from the cornea with
2. Contusions of the eye-ball; medical instruments, assessment of intra-
3. Thermal bums; ocular pressure by palpation of the eye-ball
4. Acid bums caused by contact with chem- and assessment of visual fieIds or visual
icals. acuity. Also de Bary [2] reports on the haz-
The authors discuss the rather restricted ards involved with eye injuries and the sub-
diagnostic and therapeutic possibilities sequent medical treatment. He deerns it ab-
aboard. Zorn [25] investigated the problem solutely necessary that iron particles
of eye injuries and the subsequent medical should be completely removed from the
treatment on board. He believes that eye eye as they may otherwise cause rust rings
injuries happen more frequently on board on the cornea which are scarcely reparable
than is acknowledged. Considering that oc- later on and may lead to permanent im-
casional slight injuries are not recorded at pairment of vision as a secondary effect.
all and that in many countries accidents are Friemann et al. [10] and Friemann and
only notifiable if there is an unfitness for Overhoff [11] describe a specific kind of
duty lasting more than 3 days, it can be as- eye disease in relation to the fishing indus-
sumed that eye injuries make a total of ap- try. It is a quickly developing keratitis
proximately 8%-10% of the occupational which predominantly occurs with the han-
accidents of seafarers. Zorn investigated dling of herring oil during the loading pro-
the possible treatment of eye injuries and cess. The irritation is caused by saprogenic
diseases in relation to the content of the ptomaine, particularly dimethylamine and
ship's medicine chest available on board trimethylamine. This type of corneal dam-
vessels of different nations. age was also mentioned by Kersten and
Elze [9] points to the need for immediate Mansch [15].
medical treatment of acute eye diseases Statistical data show (see above) that dis-
and injuries on board and the required eases and accidents of the eyes are not fre-
medical facilities. The ship's crew or at quently diagnosed in seamen in out-patient
least the ship's officer in charge of medical clinics ashore. It is evident from the total
care should have had the necessary train- number of diagnoses involving seamen
ing in the immediate medical first aid mea- from many countries that presbyopia and
3.11 Other Diseases 245
the need for reading glasses rank first, fol- labyrinthine deafness caused by noise. Var-
lowed by conjunctivitis of differing origin. ious authors from many countries have
Frequently seamen, particularly from Asia, studied this problem. Goethe et al. [12] re-
present with a developing or an already ad- port on the reduction of hearing capacity
vanced pterygium. This condition is also owing to noise exposure, especially among
frequently found during the course of a the engine room crew. Most surprisingly,
general medical examination. this condition was also found in deck per-
Ch'en and Huei-ying [5] report on the oc- sonne1 without any specific explanation
currence of pterygium in Chinese fisher- having been found as to how they could
men. These patients complain often of con- have been exposed to high levels. Grewe
junctival irritation and want the pterygium and Rodegra [13] studied the results of
to be removed. more than 6800 audiometric screenings
Injuries of the eyes rank only third in the and found bilateral hearing loss due to
frequency distribution curve. They are noise in 136 cases. In 24 cases the loss was
mostly caused by foreign bodies at the con- severe enough to be classified as a pre-
junctiva and the cornea. Perforating inju- scribed occupational disease.
ries and, surprisingly, glaucoma very sel- Nowak [21] reports on a considerable
dom occur. number of cases where hearing loss due to
noise on board was diagnosed, especially
in older persons. Menyakin and Poperet-
3.11.3 Ear, Nose and Throat Diseases skaya [19] examined 553 fishermen and
seamen and found that 43.7% had suffered
In the ICD, ENT diseases are to be found noise damage in varying degrees from
either under "diseases of the respiratory slight to severe.
system" (VIII) or "diseases of the nervous According to personal experience in a
system and the sense organs" (VI). So, seamen's out-patient ward, the most fre-
ENT diseases do not appear as an individ- quent ear diseases were wax obstruction
ual group of diseases. and otitis extema. Acute otitis media was
Ear diseases were found by Kraemer- not frequent. Occasionally chronic otitis
Hansen [16] to have a frequency rate of media with perforation of the tympanum
2.87%. Dolmierski et al. [6] state an average and persistent discharge was seen.
rate of 1.3%. The study of medical log Seamen frequently complain of nose dis-
books by Matthiensen [18] showed a fairly orders. Seafarers from Asia, tropical and
high frequency rate of 7.8%. subtropical countries are especially pro ne
Only one specific publication on the im- to nasal congestion which is often caused
portance of ENT diseases in seafaring can by polyposis or deviation of the septum.
be found. De Bary [3] published a review of Surgical treatment may be indicated but in
"ear troubles at sea". His experiences have many cases this is put off because of the
predominantly been with ear diseases on lack of time and other difficulties. Nose
board DC tankers. Nevertheless, his find- bleeding is very rarely seen in the seamen's
ings may be representative for seafaring in out-patient ward itself. According to the
general. Otitis externa was the most fre- patients' complaints, post festurn nose
quent diagnosis, followed by wax obstruc- bleeding seems to occur on board more fre-
tion. The much more dangerous otitis me- quently. Diseases of the throat are mostly
dia fortunately occurred infrequently. He diagnosed as pharyngitis and laryngitis ac-
gave instructions for diagnosis and therapy companying head colds. They mayaiso oc-
at sea. cur together with bronchitis. There are only
A specific kind of ear disease which par- a very few cases of septic tonsillitis and/ or
ticularly affects the engine room staff is quinsy; patients with these disorders nearly
246 3 The Pathology ofthe Seafarer
always have a high fever and, therefore, re- social isolation from other people ashore.
quire intensive treatment. Sometimes shipping doctors describe these
There are only a few publications deal- conditions as "tankeritis". Apparently, this
ing with nose and throat diseases of sea- term derives from the fact that tankers are
men. Durante [8] mentions in his study on at sea for long periods with only very short
the "physiopathology of the respiratory calls at remote ports. Very often the crew
system among fishermen" the occurrence members have no chance to go ashore and
of throat diseases and tonsillitis. He ana- to establish social contacts. The seafarer is
lysed the sickness data of 635 seamen suf- then virtually locked in his small environ-
fering from diseases of the respiratory sys- ment which may be likened to a cage even
tem and found infections ofthe pharynx in if it is (sometimes desirably) gold-plated.
67 and tonsillitis in 76. Diseases ofthe nose Feelings of frustration which may lead to
are not specifically mentioned. Balestrieri ill-defined disturbances are the conse-
and D'Alessandro [1] observed a more fre- quence. Nowadays this applies not only to
quent occurrence of tonsillar disease in tankers but to the shipping industry in gen-
seamen. eral.
Epidemics of upper respiratory infec-
tions and infectious pharyngitis sometimes
occur. Ulewicz and Dolmierski [24] de- References
scribed their observations of such an ep- 1. Balestrieri, N. and A. D' Alessandro: Osserva-
idemic on board a passenger ship. In total, zioni sulle tonsillopatie dei marittimi. Atti dei
282 persons fell ill - 84 crew members and Centro di Studi e Ricerche per l' Assistenza sa-
198 passengers. Treatment was effected nitaria e sociale dei Marittimi c.1. R. M. Rome
1961, pp. 87-92.
with procaine penicillin and tetracycline.
2. Bary, J. L. 1. de: Diagnosis and treatment of in-
The presumptive diagnosis of streptococcal juries and diseases of the eye at sea. [Circular
infection was proved ashore by means of letter]. Fawley 1960.
serological tests. 3. Bary,J. L. 1. de: Ear troubles at sea. [Circular let-
ter]. Fawley 1960.
4. Bietti, G. B. and V. Vanni: Nozioni pratiche sui
3.11.4 Other Pathological Conditions soccorsi di urgenza nelle lesioni traumatiche
or Disorders dell'apparato oculare. Atti dei Centro di studi e
ricerche per l'Assistenza sanitaria e sociale dei
In most of the international statistics on the Marittimi c.1. R. M. Rome 1961, pp. 19-28.
5. Ch'en, Li and Y.Huei-ying: Eine statistische
frequency of diagnoses (see Chap.3.1) the'
und histopathologische Untersuchung des
groUP of "symptoms and ill-defined condi- Pterygiums bei Fischern und Bauern. Med.
tions" (group XVI of the ICD) is about Sowjetunion Volksdem. 6,9,1851 (1959).
halfway down in the list. In many in- 6. Dolmierski, R., J. Filikowski and A. Kotlowski:
stances, this group of diseases does not ap- Activities of WHO Pilot Health Centre for Sea-
farers in Gdynia. Bull. lust. mar. trop. Med.
pear at all and, obviously, the authors in Gdynia 31, 3/4, 149-156 (1980).
those studies tried to classify them in other 7. Dolmierski, R. and 1. Nitka: A preliminary ap-
groups. praisal of the state of the central nervous system
Symptoms of uncertain origin are often in the seamen of the Polish merchant marine.
Bull. Inst. mar. trop. Med. Gdynia 26. 1, 17-24
defined in the seamen's out-patient wards
(1975).
as general weakness, fatigue, exhaustion, 8. Durante, E.: Contributo allo studio della fisio-
pains and paraesthesia in the limbs or patologia dell'apparato respiratorio nei maritti-
trunk and similar vague complaints. In rare mi. Atti della "Sezione Studi" dei C. I. R. M.,
instances, these disorders may be caused Rome 1968, pp. 211-220.
9. Elze, K. L.: Akute Augenerkrankungen und de-
by malnutrition, but presumably they are ren Behandlung auf See. In: Jahrestagung der
mostly due to the boredom and frustrations Deutschen Gesellschaft für Verkehrsmedizin,
of shipboard life, the mental stress and the Hamburg, 11-13 April 1975, pp. 61-63.
3.11 Other Diseases 247
10. Friemann, w., W.Overhoff and J.R Walter: 18. Matthiensen, R P. : Diagnosenverteilung bei
Augenerkrankungen in der Industriefischerei. Erkrankungen in der Schiffahrt. Auswertung
Arch. Gewerbepath. Gewerbehyg. 17, 1-56 von Schiffskrankentagebüchern und ein Ver-
(1959). gleich mit dem statistischen Material der SBG
11. Friemann, W. and W.Overhoff: Keratitis als sowie der Ortskrankenkassen. Dissertation,
Berufserkrankung in der Ölheringsfischerei. University of Hamburg 1969.
Klin. Mbl. Augenheilk. 128, 4, 425-438 (1956). 19. Menyakin, RP. and V.I.Poperetskaya: Profe-
12. Goethe, H., E.-G.Schmidt, E.Zorn et al.: sionalnye ismeneniya organa slukha i ravnove-
Lärmbelastung auf See- und Binnenschiffen, siya u moryakov i rybakov. [Occupational
Untersuchungen zur effektiven Lärmbelastung changes ofhearing and vestibular system in sea-
der Besatzungen. Ed.: Bundesanstalt für Ar- men and fishermen]. In: Vestn. Oto-rino-Iaring.
beitsschutz und Unfallforschung, Dortmund. 1, 39-42 (1980).
Bremerhaven: Wirtschaftsverlag NW 1979. 20. Molfino, A.: Aspetti di patologia oculare nella
(Forschungsbericht 201) gente dei mare. In: Atti dei primo congresso int.
13. Grewe, H.-E. and H. Rodegra: Untersuchungen sull'assistenza di malattia e la tutela infortunis-
über die Lärmschwerhörigkeit des Maschinen- tica della gente dei mare nei paesi della c. e. e.,
personals. Hansa 112, 21 (1975). Genoa 3-5 Oct. 1960, Vol.2, pp. 537-549.
14. Hager, G.: Die Grundausbildung von Schiffs- 21. Nowak, R: Die Lärmschwerhörigkeit des
offizieren zur Behandlung von Augenerkran- Schiffsmaschinenpersonals. Z. ges. Hyg. 17,7,
kungen und die dazu notwendige Standard- 488-492 (1971).
ausrüstung auf Seeschiffen. In: Fragen der 22. Offer-Ohlsen, D.: The Norwegian seafarer - the
Schiffahrtsmedizin. Vorträge aus dem Intern. picture of health? Analysis of health - and
Symp., Heiligendamm, 28-31 March 1963. medical reports from the merchant navy. Lec-
Medizinischer Dienst des Verkehrswesens 11. ture. Symposium "Safety of life at sea". Oslo,
pp. 159-164 (1963). 20-21 Oct. 1980. Research program associated
15. Kersten, E. and L.Mansch: Zur Möglichkeit with The Royal Norwegian Council for Scien-
berufsbedingter Hornhautschädigungen in der tific and Industrial Research. System for
Futterflschindustrie. Z. ärztl. Fortbild. 55, 20, Sikkert Skip. Manuscript.
1191-1194 (1961). 23. Somov, O. G., M. N. Baishtruk, D.1. Bobrikova
16. Kraemer-Hansen, H.: Diagnosenverteilung bei et al.: Questions of neurological morbidity
Seeleuten. Auswertung der Erkrankungsbögen among crew members. In: VII International
der Abteilung für Schiffahrtsmedizin am Symposium on Marine Medicine, Odessa,
Bernhard-Nocht-Institut für Schiffs- und Tro- 23-30 Sept. 1976. Moscow 1976, p. 420.
penkrankheiten in Hamburg aus den Jahren 24. Ulewicz, K. and R.Dolmierski: Pharyngitis ep-
von 1966 bis 1975. Dissertation, University of idemic on a passenger ship. Bull. Inst. mar.
Hamburg 1977. trop. Med. Gdynia 27, 1, 105-108 (1976).
17. Manual ofthe International Statistical Classifi- 25. Zorn, E.: Probleme der Diagnose und Behand-
cation of Diseases, Injuries, and Causes of lung von Augenverletzungen und -erkrankun-
Death. Vois. 1 and 2. Based on the recommen- gen auf See. Klin. Mbl. Augenheilk. 165, 2,
dations of the Ninth Revision Conference, 369-376 (1974).
1975, and adopted by the 29th WHO Assembly.
Geneva: WHO 1977 and 1978.
3.12 Dental Problems in Seafaring
H.Bäter
Diseases of the teeth, mouth and jaw can wide in relation to the national population.
affect the general state of health consider- He found dental caries in 96% of the sea-
ably and it often happens that, on account men examined.
of this, a ship has to make an emergency Trunov et al. [16] reported that diseases
call at a port or a fishery protection vessel of the mouth were among the most fre-
has to be asked to assist. Very often it needs quent on the general list of seamen's com-
only a short inspection of the cavity of the plaints. The longer the voyage lasts, the
mouth in order to achieve an early diagno- higher is the frequency of the complaints as
sis and to apply effective treatment. There- an effect of prolonged exposure to the ad-
fore the alarming increase of dental dis- verse conditions on board and failure to
eases, and with it the problems on board adapt to them. Diseases of the mouth and
arising from such diseases, is surprising. their complications constitute 30%-35% of
In fact, the regular medical fitness ex- all cases where seamen ask for medical as-
aminations as they have been carried out sistance in foreign ports. Among diseases
since 1946 in many seafaring countries are of the mouth, dental caries is by far the
of great value in fighting dental diseases. most frequent. The second place is occu-
However, in 1973 the Joint Committee of pied by such complications of dental caries
the World Health Organization (WHO/ as pulpitis and pericementitis. Amphodon-
ILO) made it quite clear that the "problem tosis resp. periodontitis -lesion ofthe peri-
of the continuously increasing number of odontal tissue - is often found and requires
dental diseases with seafarers cannot be great care on the part of the doctors. Stom-
solved by them" [7]. atitis, gingivitis and other lesions ofthe mu-
cous membrane of the mouth are not infre-
3.12.1 Morbidity quent.
Although intensified international and
Papers by Evjen [4], Otterland [12] and national efforts have been made to solve
Matusov [11] were based on the first statis- the problem of diseases of the mouth, re-
tics which the WHO published in 1975 cent publications by Goethe et al. [5], Zorn
showing the most frequent diseases of sea- [18], Kaerger [8], Klafstad [9] and Bormann
farers. According to these statistics, dental [2] show an improvement in only very few
diseases took fourth place in frequency af- countries. In fact, a deteriorating situation
ter coronary diseases, accidents and vene- can be observed in most countries. At pre-
real diseases. sent in some ofthe statistics on distribution
These statistical data induced further of diagnoses, diseases of the teeth, mouth
countries to carry out dental examinations and jaw already take second place behind
in seamen. In 1975 Sandbekk [15] ex- accidents on board ships. The number of
amined Norwegian se amen, who make up cases on board ships is significantly higher
2% of the Norwegian work-force and are than among a comparable group of the
thus the biggest seafaring group world- population ashore. The causes of these dis-
3.12 Dental Problems in Seafaring 249
eases are complex and partly concern the vince them of the necessity of regular den-
specific life on board with its extremely tal care and treatment.
long and irregular working hours, its abuse As stated above, a further cause of in-
of sugar, alcohol and tobacco and quick creasing dental disease is the constantly re-
turnarounds in port. All of this causes duced times in port which nowadays are
physical and psychological stress. calculated in hours, leaving the se amen
Especially for se amen on fishery factory little opportunity for thorough dental treat-
vessels, tankers, container ships or other ment. Because of this, and because very
cargo ships in line shipping, life on board few dentists ashore are prepared to treat
can lead to total social neglect due to mo- seamen without advance notice, the only
notony and isolation over a long period. measure they are offered when suffering
The fact that a seaman often cannot leave from severe tooth-ache is extraction of the
the ship for months is also a reason for to- tooth. This is also one of the reasons why
tal neglect of the care of the teeth. many seamen postpone a necessary dental
Schmidt [14] gives an extensive report on examination as long as possible. The result
the experience with dental treatment on can be a severe and sometimes dangerous
board fish factory ships. These ships of the abscess during a voyage.
GDR have a ship's dentist on board who is WHO claim that se amen ashore should
responsible for the stomatological care of have precedence over other patients in ur-
the entire fishery fleet in his area. gent cases. The recommendations of
Of2740 seamen who were examined be- Marchenko [10] go much further. He not
tween 1974 and 1976, Bäter [1] found two- only proposes dental treatment for seamen
thirds to have moderate or bad oral hy- before the beginning of each voyage but al-
giene, one-third to have evident odontoli- so suggests that they should be visited and
thiasis and 50% to be in need of dental treated by mobile dental stations during
care. In addition to this, one-third were suf- their voyage. These mobile stations should
fering from parodontopathias. be installed on board bigger passenger
Even worse findings were made by ships or a dentist should visit smaller ships
Wianz [17], who examined 422 fishery men: carrying portable instruments with hirn,
64% were suffering from odontolithiasis staying on board ship until all crew mem-
and 53% from parodontosis. bers have been treated. Afterwards the den-
In a clinical-statistical study on parodon- tist could board another ship. Dental con-
topathias, Sacco and Galassi [13] found trol and treatment in this way would be
that 92.5% of 1500 examined seamen had a very effective; however, up to now this
parodontic alteration or a mucosal lesion; practice has been implemented mainly in
65% showed gingivitis purulenta or haem- countries of the Eastern bloc. From first
orrhagica, 21.7% an atrophie-hypertrophie publications it can be concluded that the
parodontosis with pyorrhea alveolaris, 11 % German Democratic Republic in particular
gingivitis-stomatitis with alterations and is working on a further development of this
2.3% an epithelial defect. system. Bormann [2] reports on 11 726 cases
of dental treatment at sea which were car-
3.12.2 Oral and Dental Care ried out in 1969. By this method, the num-
ber of carious dentitions could be reduced
It is therefore obvious that a high propor- from 81 % to 50%. Some shipping compa-
tion of dental disease is due to lack of oral nies of Western countries have developed
hygiene. and carried out similar programmes.
WHO has demanded repeatedly an ex- Research in various countries has shown
tensive education in dental diseases and that changes in the social security system
oral hygiene for seamen in order to con- have no significant effect on the standard
250 3 The Pathology of the Seafarer
of dental health of their seamen. (Seamen ical guide is provided and no dental medi-
in some ofthe countries ofthe Eastern Bloc eines or equipment are available. In severe
are an exception.) Bäter [1], for instance, cases the officer will ask for additional ra-
found only 50% of all gaps between teeth dio-medical advice. The medical chest of
of West German seamen to be closed pros- ships ofthe German Federal Republic con-
thetically whereas foreign seamen, who tains, among other things, eugenol (oil of
generally have to pay far more money for clove), provisional fillings and antiseptic
this kind of treatment, had hardly less den- mouth washes as weil as dental forceps, ex-
tal prostheses. Apart from a certain indif- cavators, mirrors and probes. The ships of
ference toward gaps between teeth, one of some other countries carry similar dental
the reasons for this obvious lack of pros- faeilities, but others do not have adequate
thetic treatment may be lack oftime, which provisions.
does not allow a seaman to undergo a diffi- The aim of emergency treatment can on-
cult and long procedure of prosthetic treat- ly be to relieve the toothache and to pre-
ment. In most countries, appointments vent a deterioration in the patient's condi-
months ahead are necessary for this kind of tion until he is able to undergo appropriate
treatment. The treatment itself is so exten- dental treatment ashore.
sive and time consuming that in order to Most of the time the dental therapy is re-
complete it a seafarer would have to stay stricted to the application of strong anal-
ashore. gesics and to provision al closure ofthe car-
It seems that in most countries seamen, ious defects. Even a provisional closure,
being a soeial minority, are neglected. Of- however, requires skill and some diagnostic
ten the seamen feel that no provision is knowledge. In the case of an early pulpitis,
made for their dental problems, with the re- the officer in charge will succeed in reliev-
sult that more and more emergency treat- ing pain with the help of eugenol, as this
ment on board proves necessary. medieine will protect the pulp from ther-
mic and chemical influences and has an
3.12.3 Dental Care on Board alleviating effect.
In the case of a pulpitis necroticans,
In general one of the deck offkers is in however, he will increase the patient's pain
charge of the medical treatment on board. to an unbearable state by this method as
He is entrusted with this task by the captain the gas pressure of the putrescent tooth can
of the ship before the beginning of a voy- then no longer escape.
age. The officer in charge of medical treat-
A deck offker has to undergo medical ment would undoubtedly be und er great
training during his nautical studies ashore. stress if required to extract a tooth. During
There are few countries, however, which in 10 years of being a radio officer at sea I
addition to theoretical medical training, de- never heard of an extraction of a tooth by a
mand a course of practical work in a hospi- ship's officer. This precautionary measure
tal, but no country demands practical ex- seems to me sensible and advisable now,
amination in basic dental medicine. knowing the dangers of unskilled anaesthe-
The officer in charge of medical treat- sia, a broken root left in place or even a
ment usually obtains his dental knowledge mandibular fracture after extraction. For
from the medical guide which should be these reasons the medical guide ofthe Ger-
part of the medical chest according to na- man Democratic Republic (DDR) "Health
tional regulations on medical equipment Safety on Board" strictly prohibits extrac-
on board. On many ships the "Internation- tion of teeth by officers (Ebert [3]). There-
al Medical Guide for Ships" [6] is available. fore dental treatment on most ships is re-
On ships of certain flags, however, no med- stricted to re1ieving the patient's pain and
3.12 Dental Problems in Seafaring 251
to tranquillising the tooth for some days. In board and show - in contrast to the latter -
most cases, trepanations by excavator, an- an increasing tendency.
tibiotics and cold compresses can slow the There is no denying that seamen tend to
process until the next port is reached. In an be indifferent and negleetful where the care
extreme case, ships could call at a port as of their teeth is concerned. However, re cent
an emergency within hours or days in order findings also show that dental treatment of
to land the patient. This, however, causes seamen is not satisfaetory owing to unfa-
technical difficulties and is expensive so vourable factors in seafaring, such as very
that a captain would agree to this decision short times in port and reduetion of per-
only as a last emergency measure. sonneIon board, leaving Httle or no time
for conservative or prosthetic treatment.
la gente dei mare nei paesi della c. e. e. Genoa, 16. Trunov, 1.1., N. V. Pavlov, L. M. Shafran et al.:
3-50ct. 1960. Genoa: Casse Marittime per gli Analysis of stomatological morbidity among
infortuni sul lavoro e le malattie 1960. Vol. 2, seamen and its prophylaxis. BuH. lust. mar.
pp. 636-639. trop. Med. Gdynia 25, 2·3·4, 236-240 (1974).
14. Schmidt, L.: Ein Schiffsstomatologe im Nord· 17. Wianz, E.: Die zahnärztliche Versorgung von
meer - Erfahrungsbericht. Z. ärztl. Fortbild. 75, Seeleuten der deutschen Hochseefischerei.
483-489 (1981). Dtsch. zahnärztl. Z. 37,4,391-396 (1982).
15. Sandbekk, O. W: Tannhelse og bruk av tannle· 18. Zorn, E. W: Betrachtung über die Schiffahrts·
getjenester blant sjöfolk i utenriksfart. Norske medizin und ihre Entwicklung in Deutschland.
Tannlägeforen. Tid. 87, 275-281 (1977). Der Seewart 37, 3, 93-98 (1976).
3.13 The Siek Seafarer Ashore
W. R. Anderson and w. H. G. Goethe
The ship's master must make all decisions of sick se amen of all nationalities. It partic-
on the need for medical care for his crew ularly referred to the activities of the Pilot
when at sea. In the event of illness or injury Health Centres for Seafarers in Gdynia
it is extremely important for hirn to decide (Poland) and Auckland (New Zealand).
as soon as possible whether the patient can According to Dolmierski et al. [2] and Dol-
be cared for aboard or should be removed mierski [3], a total of 10484 consultations
from the ship. When in doubt, his first pri- were given to foreign seamen and fisher-
ority is to obtain radiomedical advice from men of more than 16 nationalities. Of
a reliable source. If advised to evacuate the these, 8309 were for general medical and
patient he may request airlsea rescue ifthe surgical conditions, while 2175 were spe-
ship is within an acceptable distance ofthat cifically for diseases of the mouth, includ-
facility. If not, it may be necessary to divert ing dental conditions.
his ship to the nearest port. A major port is Goethe and Vuksanovic [5] also empha-
always preferable because many of the sized that seafarers on articles represent a
smaller ports are without adequate medical population at risk in regard to medical
facilities and suitable means of subsequent care. They pointed out that nowadays few
repatriation. doctors work on merchant ships. Medical
The treatment of seafarers in foreign care at sea is given by laymen who may or
ports presents significant sociallmedical may not be competent to deal with any
problems. The WHO drew attention to emergency. In general, seafarers are treated
these problems at a Conference on Health by doctors only when in port. Ram [10], in
and Welfare of Seafarers in Marseille in his survey of Maritime Health Problems,
1959. Evjen [4] made a full detailed report noted a great tendency for ships' officers to
of the discussion. During the 37th session avoid personal responsibility in medical
of the WHO in 1965 these problems were matters and to rely on advice from port
discussed again [6]. The WHO report esti- doctors as much as possible.
mated a total population of about 750000 During the European Nautical Medical
seafarers to which could be added Meetings in 1978 in Germany [8] and 1979
250000 fishermen. Thus one million people in Great Britain [9] the participants dealt
working at sea were at risk, of illness and comprehensively with the subject of medi-
injury and they might require medical cal care and hospitalization of seamen in
treatment aboard, at horne or in foreign foreign ports and the problems of medical
countries. care overseas.
The Joint ILO/WHO Committee on the It is surprising that there are so few pub-
Health of Seafarers has also dealt with this lications on this problem, which affects all
matter repeatedly. In the report of the ses- maritime countries. Most authors, such as
sion in September 1973 [11] the Committee Haralanov and Angelov [7], deal only with
pointed out the importance of establishing national aspects.
medical centres in ports for the treatment A special problem which has nearly been
254 3 The Pathology ofthe Seafarer
solved by the signatory states is the treat- maero- and mieroclimate, gas, dust and va-
ment of venereal diseases. The so-ealled pours demand a wide knowledge if the
Brussels Agreement [1], signed by a great doetor is to deal satisfaetorily with the
number of seafaring nations in 1924, states sometimes very atypical eomplaints of the
that the nations who signed the agreement patients and to decide whether the seaman
ought to establish free treatment eentres for ean eontinue his duty on board or not.
seamen suffering from a vene real disease. Often ships nowadays remain only a
In 1972 the WHO published a World Di- short time in the port so that usually there
rectory of Venereal Diseases Centres at is very little time left for special investiga-
ports in wh ich the addresses of the eentres tions and treatment. The seamen's doctor
and the doctors as weIl as the opening must be able to perform laboratory exami-
hours are listed [12]. nations, ECG, X-raying ete. with no delay
and to make a diagnosis quiekly. Normally
3.13.1 The Seamen's Doctor all these measures have to be taken in one
or two days, sometimes in a few hours.
In his horne country a siek seaman normal- Owing to the lack oftime, a long and ex-
ly eonsults his family doetor or the doetor tended investigation is impossible. Usually
of his shipping eompany. This doetor will the deeision whether the seaman ean stay
treat the seaman hirnself or admit hirn to on board or must sign off is expeeted by the
hospital. Aeeording to the customary prae- eaptain or by the ship's agent as soon as
tice no problems normally arise. The situa- possible. This decision is of great impor-
tion beeomes quite different as soon as the tanee for the patient as well as of great
seaman falls ill on board and the ship, as is economie importance, because the costs of
usual nowadays, has no ship's doetor and repatriation and the replaeement of the ill
treatment has to be given by the eaptain or seaman ean be very high.
another offieer on board. This treatment When seafarers are sent to a doetor by an
normally comprises only urgent first aid agency, very few take with them any infor-
measures. The patient will be sent to a doe- mation about their medical history, previ-
tor in the next port. In ports where there is ous treatment or reports of medieal investi-
no special medieal eentre for foreign and gations carried out at other ports. Indeed, it
horne seamen irrespective of nationality, is often very difficult to obtain an adequate
the representative of the owner looking af- history of the present complaint unless the
ter the ship will choose a doctor known to seafarer can speak some English or an in-
hirn, either sending the seaman to hirn or terpreter is available. With the reduced
asking the doctor to come on board. In number of crew members, it is usually not
most countries se amen cause problems for easy for the captain so send an officer to
a general medieal practiee because they act as interpreter. The doctor is therefore
present very specific difficulties. The main seriously handicapped in making a diagno-
problem is the language barrier. As the in- sis and deciding upon treatment. He will
ternational language in navigation nowa- often have to repeat investigations which
days is English, it is necessary for a doetor have been done at another port. This re-
who wants to treat se amen suceessfully to sults in a eonsiderable loss of time and ex-
speak medieal English fluently and as far tra unnecessary eosts.
as possible to know other major languages. The siek seafarer's problems may vary
Besides this there are some other diffi- from one country to the other. When the
culties eoneerning the treatment of seamen. seamen's doctor does not speak English
The specifie conditions on board like and there is no interpreter available, lan-
working conditions, watch systems and en- guage barriers reduce medical history to
vironmental load such as noise, vibration, basies. In some ports interpreters may be
3.13 The Siek Seafarer Ashore 255
available. Church groups and seamen's ser- The modern merchant service has
vice organizations as weIl as consulates changed. The ships are larger, the crews are
may be asked for help regarding interpreta- smaller, there is usually one man for one
tion and general assistance to sick seafar- job. Containerized cargo and new methods
ers. of bulk loading and discharging have
A very simple thing like medical report- changed port turnaround time from days to
ing may create considerable problems. hours. The doctor no longer has adequate
Generally a typewritten report in English is time to make in depth studies of a seaman's
issued after treatment. There are many medical problem while the ship is in port.
complaints by masters and owners that the The first decision is: Can he be treated on
seamen's doctors do not always issue a board or must he sign offfor treatment ash-
typewritten report in understandable lan- ore. Onee the sick seaman has been re-
guage. The report normally contains the di- moved from the ship there are three alter-
agnosis, laboratory findings, X-ray find- natives: the seaman may be repatriated to
ings and instructions for further treatment. his home immediately for further care, he
This information is necessary for the sea- may be admitted to a hospital or he may be
men's doctor in the next port or in home placed in a hotel or seamen's home for sub-
country in order to continue the proper se quent out-patient medical care.
treatment. X-ray films and other original
documents should be given to the patient
as weIl, as he rarely returns to the doctor 3.13.2 Personal Experienees
who performed the initial examination. of Practice at a Port Clinie
Unfortunately, the company or the mas- in the U.S.A.
ter very often do not issue the forms which
should be filled in by the doctor, so that the Early recognition of potential medical
doctor must use his own form. Some forms problems is essential. Too frequently a sea-
in use by certain companies, on the other man requests medical care while in port
hand, are such sophisticated question- and is told that there is insufficient time or
naires that the seamen's doctor will not fill that he can see a doctor in the next port.
it in or use it. Up to now it has proved to be Most doctors familiar with seamen's habits
impossible to agree internationallyon one realize that many visits to the doctor are a
special form for this purpose. The Joint means to get off the ship for a few hours.
ILO/WHO Committee on the health of However, many of these seamen may have
seafarers recommended in 1981 a special a potentially serious medical problem that
form consisting of 3 pages "Medical Re- cannot be adequately treated on board. It
port Form for Seafarers" and urged the behoves all doctors to anticipate this pro-
" ... adoption of a standard medical form gression or degeneration in the case of a
for use by doctors examining and treating patient who is a seaman. An example: An
seafarers which would be an important engineer visited a doctor in a European
step in improving medical care for seafar- port because of fatigue. Medication was
ers, and the Joint Committee recom- prescribed. His report was completed and
mends that the Medical Report Form for sent to the ship. The patient arrived in an
Seafarers should be used to facilitate the American port. The fatigue persisted. He
exchange of information regarding the sick presented his report from the prior visit;
or injured seafarer between the ship's the diagnosis was leukaemia. The haemo-
master and the doctor/hospital on shore globin was 9.5 g. Three weeks later the hae-
[13]." moglobin was 8.2 g. It is obvious that he
Up to now this medical report form has should not have embarked on a prolonged
not been generally introduced. voyage. This man could have been repatri-
256 3 The Pathology of the Seafarer
ated from the European port to his horne in also readily admitted that he was not ill.
less than 1 h by air rather than a 12-h tiring Malingerers will continue to tax the brains
flight from America. There was a total lack of the medical profession. When malinger-
of communication between the doctor, the ing is suspected the doctor should notify
patient and the owner'~ representative. the owner through the agent that this sea-
Unlike the population ashore, seafarers man should have a thorough evaluation on
do not have the advantage of being able to return horne and be reprimanded and pos-
consult their own doctor readily when wor- sibly pay his repatriation expense at his
ried about their health. As a result minor horne port. It is useless to return these men
symptoms which persist are often exagger- to their ship only to try their charade again.
ated when there is an opportunity to attend The seaman's doctor must determine if a
a doctor in a port in a foreign country. A seaman is not fit for fuH duty on board be-
shipping doctor is aware of this tendency cause of iIIness or disabling injury. A rec-
but in addition he must watch carefully for ommendation to remove or sign off the
the occasional real malingering patient. disabled seaman is given to the master
A malingerer may have such a well-doc- through his agent or his consulate. Normal-
urnen ted illness that a doctor cannot, in ly the master will follow this advice. But the
good faith, send the seaman back to the master may elect not to sign off his crew
ship. An example: A European ship ar- member and the doctor has no recourse ex-
rived in an American port for bunkering. cept to give any advice and medication that
The master requested medical care for a may be of value for use on board. Such re-
seaman who was coughing blood. The ship fusals are not common but do occur and
arrived at 03.00 and was sailing at 07.00. frequently have disastrous results, includ-
ehest X-rays were taken and showed evi- ing permanent disability and death which
dence of tuberculosis, activity undeter- would not have occurred had the seaman
mined. An erythrocyte sedimentation rate been left ashore.
was 20 mm/h. A sputum smear was non- Many masters will not accept a seaman
diagnostic. The patient was admitted to with recommendations for light duty or no
hospital for further evaluation. The ship's duty for a few days, e. g. the Australian Sea-
destination was Hong Kong. The day after men's Union Agreement states that a sea-
admission the patient admitted that he had man who is temporarily unfit or limited in
had adequate treatment in his homeland any way must be repatriated. There are
and that he faked haemoptysis to get off similar union agreements within the major
the ship. He was aware of his abnormal maritime powers. But such agreements do
chest X-ray and was very confident that he not exist in all countries, especially not
would be removed from the ship for medi- among those ships manned by third world
cal reasons. nations' crews. Captains of those ships
Quite frequently a master will collabo- usually prefer to keep the man on board
rate with a seaman to request medical pay- even ifhe is temporarily unfit or fit only for
off so that the man would be repatriated at light duty.
the expense of insurance underwriters Frequently an injured seaman arrives
rather than company expense. A common having been treated in another port and ob-
ploy for this type of patient is a urinary viously needs daily care which cannot be
tract stone history with severe pain and given on board but he does not necessarily
haematuria. On one occasion a Greek sea- need hospitalization. The master may re-
man actually shaved his fingertip to pro- quest treatment so that the seaman may re-
duce sufficient blood to cause the haemat- join the vessel within a reasonable time.
uria. His ruse was uncovered when dried These seamen may be treated as out-pat-
blood was found under his finger-nail. He ients while living in a hotel or a seamen's
3.13 The Siek Seafarer Ashore 257
Acute trauma, fracture, laceration etc. The doctor must determine the need for
Cardiac disease, coronary artery disease an escort for the patient en route. The es-
etc. cort should be advised of any visas neces-
Peptic u1cer disease with bleeding or per- sary for the trip. Escorts should be chosen
foration with respect to their medieal qualifications
Hypertension, uncontrolled and informed of the patient's condition
Acute infections, respiratory etc. and any problems anticipated en route. Pri-
Urinary tract stones or authorization should be received from
Diabetes the owners before embarking on expensive
Alcoholism with pancreatitis, delirium tre- elective procedures such as open heart sur-
mens and psychosis gery with coronary bypass. A seamen's
Hepatitis doctor should consider the availability of
Psychosis medical care in the seaman's homeland be-
fore repatriation. Aftercare of many medi-
3.13.4 Repatriation by Air cal problems is essential. Hypertension and
diabetes must have continued control. It is
International air travel between major frustrating to hear tales of despair from
cities of the world has made a great contri- seamen who have not been offered on-
bution to the repatriation of siek seamen. A going medieal care in their homeland.
seaman can be repatriated halfway around
the world in 24 h by jet travel. The doctor 3.13.5 General Recommendations
must decide whieh patients can be repatri-
ated immediately for further care. Safety As the seaman belongs to a population at
and comfort are of paramount importance. risk relating to health, special attention
The doctor should be aware of the regula- should be given to his medieal care in port.
tions of the airlines regarding transporta- The foHowing points of view should be
tion of patients. Most airlines have a medi- considered:
cal director who decides if and when a 1. A foreign seaman does not fit into a gen-
particular patient can be transported. Most eral medical practice or into a general
airlines request a medical report from the out-patients' ward which is adjusted on-
attending physician. These remarks refer to ly to the native population of the coun-
those patients who obviously are ill or in- try.
jured, such as stretcher patients or those 2. The seaman should be treated by a sea-
needing assistance in walking. men's doctor who is familiar with the
The shipping industry is experiencing an characteristies of seafaring and with the
economie crisis. Many ploys are used to problems on board. This may be a pri-
save money. Third world seamen are rapid- vate practiee, a community practiee or a
ly replacing crews on ships under flags of special out-patient clinic for seamen.
convenience. Masters frequently attempt to 3. For a seamen's doctor it is necessary to
bypass medieal care in order to repatriate have good nautical medical knowledge
seamen who are in need of medical care. and some multilingual ability as weH as
Incidents have occurred where a psychotic to show understanding forthe ethnologi-
seaman has disrupted the flight plan of an cal background of his patient.
international airline. The man was sub- 4. There should be easy, quiek access to di-
dued by airport security and hospitalized agnostie facilities such as laboratory
for psychiatric care. All nations have a sim- tests, ECG and radiology.
ilar set of immigration and quarantine reg- 5. Shipping companies and their agents
ulations that may vary but basically serve should be informed that an interpreter
the same purpose. must accompany the patient whenever
3.13 The Siek Seafarer Ashore 259
there is a language barrier. A list of inter- farers in Gdynia. Bull. lust. mar. trop. Med.
preters in the loeality who ean be ealled Gdynia 33, 3/4, 149-156 (1980).
3. Dolmierski, R.: Progress report for 1980 on the
upon at short notiee is also useful.
activities of WHO Pilot Health Centre for sea-
6. All ease notes inc1uding personal details, farers in Gdynia (Poland) 1981.
medieal his tory, previous treatment and 4. Evjen, A.: Medical faeilities ashore. Conferenee
investigation results should be sent to the on health and welfare of seafarers, Marseille,
doetor by the ship's eaptain. These 16-21 February 1959. Geneva: WHO 1959.
5. Goethe, H., P. Vuksanovic: Sieknesses, injuries
should be returned to the eaptain after and health eare on board - medieal edueation
the eonsultation either by the patient or ofshipboard personnel. In: International work-
through the agent. Use of the WHO shop on human relationship on board, Bremen,
medieal report form is strongly advised 21-22January 1982. Ed.: H.Böhm. Bremen,
pp 119-130.
for this purpose.
6. Health of seafarers: a study of the nature and
7. The seamen's doetor should give the siek extend of the health problems of seafarers and
seafarer his report and his preseription the health service available to them. Geneva:
for further treatment on board typed in WHO 1965.
English. Without these measures further 7. Haralanov, v., B.Angelov: Medical service in
the Bulgarian water transport system. In: III In-
sueeessful treatment of the patient on ternational symposium on marine medicine,
board is not possible. Medicine must be Leningrad 1968. Moscow, pp 160-164.
supplied or preseribed in sufficient 8. Medical care and hospitalisation of se amen in
quantities. foreign ports. In: Proeeedings of the European
nautical medical meeting, Hamburg, 24-28
8. This information should be passed on by
May 1978, Ed.: H. Goethe.
the ship's eaptain to the doetor in the 9. Proeeedings of the second European nautical
next port if further treatment is neees- medical offieers meeting, West Sussex, 10-14
sary. Sept. 1979.
10. Ram, J.: Maritime health services at sea. SAPA-
NUT J Israel Shipping Res lnst 6, 2, 4-8 (1976).
11. ILO/WHO Joint Committee: Report on health
References of seafarers. 5th session. Geneva: ILO/WHO
1973.
12. World directory of venereal-disease treatment
1. WHO Study Group: The agreement of Brussels, centres at ports. Geneva: WHO 1972.
1924, respecting facilities to be given to mer-
Addendum
ehant seamen for the treatment of venereal dis-
eases. Geneva: WHO 1958. 13. Joint ILO/WHO committee on the health of
2. Dolmierski, R., J. Filikowski, A. Kotlowski: Ae- seafarers. Sixth report. Geneva: ILO/WHO
tivities of WHO Pilot Health Centre for sea- 1981.
4 Preventive Medicine Aboard
4.1 Health Education of the Seafarer
Y.Stenko
4.1.1 Safety and Health Training same time, it is necessary to pay attention
to the organization of control of personal
Attention should in particular be paid to an and vessel hygiene observance by an the
aspects of personal safety and survival at members of the crew and the passengers,
sea in emergencies. These subjects are dealt and also to ensure a knowledge of interna-
with wen in two publications of the U. K. tional conventions and rules of environ-
Department of Trade [5, 6]. Seafaring has mental protection, both at sea and in ports.
always been a dangerous occupation which To this end, manuals such as the Ship Cap-
can have an adverse effect on health either tain's Medical Guide, various visual aids
through disease or injury. Therefore, every (teaching models, posters), colour slides
seafarer should know the dangers inherent (Stenko [7]) and publications by WHO,
in his work. He must also know and strictly ILO and the Alliance of the Red Cross and
observe the specific requirements and safe- Red Crescent Societies are utilized. In a
ty rules necessary to prevent avoidable ac- number of countries, this activity involves
cidents. All crew should be taught how to the participation of specialized medical na-
rescue and transport casualties from bilges, val institutions such as the Transport Medi-
narrow passages and through confined cal Institute in the People's Republic of
spaces. It is also necessary that they should Bulgaria, the Institute of Marine and Trop-
be trained in the technique of mouth-to- ical Medicine in Hamburg (FRG), the In-
nose and mouth-to-mouth artificial respi- stitute of Marine and Tropical Medicine in
ration. Gdansk (PPR), the Water Transport Hy-
On fishing ships the work is particularly giene Research Institute of the USSR Min-
dangerous and the crew should be properly istry of Health, the Department of this In-
trained in the special techniques of trawl- stitute in Odessa and marine hospitals and
ing, sorting and processing of fish. In addi- clinics in ports of many countries of the
tion to working procedures, fishermen world. Numerous public organizations are
must know the varieties of dangerous fish involved in health education activity. In
(sharks, electric fish etc.) and be aware that several countries there exists a special net-
some fish can inflict poisonous stings. work of establishments - houses or rooms
Methods of health education are diverse of health education where the training of
and depend on the place and establishment medical personnel for health education
where it is organized. A basic knowledge of work is provided by the state and general
health protection and major hygienic health education measures are organized
norms should be provided by doctors and for the population, including sailors (lec-
specialists in maritime colleges and special tures, exhibitions, radio broadcasts, films
marine training institutions. For senior of- etc.).
ficers and ship command personnei, spe-
cial training courses and practical classes
should be organized (Morozov [4]). At the
264 4 Preventive Medicine Aboard
2. Factors connected with rest and relaxa- non-smokers, while fatal myocardial in-
tion during leisure time, including sleep; farctions are seen four times as often. Out
3. Factors connected with physical ele- of 100 adult TB patients, 95 are smokers.
ments of the habitat environment, e. g.
the round-the-clock effect of vibration,
noise, rolling and pitching, high frequen- 4.1.3 Smoking and Alcohol
cy and ultra-high frequency radiation,
etc.; An anti-smoking campaign pursues two
4. Factors connected with chemical ele- purposes: 1) prevention of the develop-
ments of the shipboard environment, ment of the habit itself, 2) the giving up of
e. g. emission of chemical compounds of smoking by sailors who are already addict-
polymers contained in vamishes, paints ed. Effective health education should be
and glues used in the decoration of cab- given to deal with smoking. Illustrated pos-
ins and compartments, and also the pro- ters and pamphlets should be displayed
cess of transport of chemicals; prominently on board: medical treatment
5. Socio-psychological factors connected alone cannot succeed. There should be a
with the isolated habitat of sailors; strong desire on the part of the smoker to
6. Stress factors: fires, survival of a ship- give up the habit. The sailor's wish, the
wrecked victim. doctor's will and medical treatment taken
Therefore, heaIth education should in- together can yield the desired effect. Anti-
volve appropriate literature, vivid posters smoking campaigns are organized by such
and leaflets conceming the above-men- UN organizations as WHO, UNESCO and
tioned factors which influence the sailor UNICEF and also by many govemmental
during his stay on board the ship. and nongovemmental organizations.
Harmful habits of smoking and alcohol Alcohol addiction represents one of the
consumption (see Chap.4.4) should be par- serious health risk factors for sailors. Elab-
ticularly highlighted in health education oration of a system of anti-alcohol educa-
work. Anti-smoking heaIth education cam- tion work is a task for health education.
paigns in different countries are organized Four groups of non-specific factors favour-
with the help of various techniques: pos- ing alcohol addiction in sailors are:
ters, leaflets, radio and TV programmes
A. Disruption of the personal environment
and state legislation such as waming no-
by absence from home and frequent
tices on cigarette packets and their limited
changes of ship
sale. Tobacco smoking is the most common
a) Family problems
dangerous habit representing a mass
b) Alcohol addiction among the family
chronic routine intoxication. This problem
members
was emphasized in the decisions of the
c) Harmful psyctiological background in
63rd session of WHO Executive Council
the family
[2]: "This is one of the most serious prob-
d) Inadequate level of education of par-
lems of modem health care and a major
ents and unsatisfactory family up-
problem of premature death which can be
bringing
avoided." It has been established that the
risk of developing cancer is ten times great- B. Somato-neurological factors
er among smokers than non-smokers. Lip a) Congenital mental diseases
and larynx cancer are observed four times b) Severe somatic diseases and infections
more often in smokers, while pancreatic of the nervous system in early child-
cancer occurs twice as often. Death result- hood
ing from duodenal ulcer is three to four c) Organic cerebral defects
times more frequent in smokers, than in d) Mental deficiency and infantilism
266 4 Preventive Medicine Aboard
board, where abstinence represents a nor- 4. Morozov, A. A.: Study of hygienic knowledge
mal condition for sailors, and life on shore, and practice of personnel engaged in fishing and
fish processing at sea as a means of evaluating
where a sailor should possess knowledge of
the standard and effectiveness of health educa-
personal hygiene and the methods of VD tion in the fishing fleet. In: VII International
prevention. symposium on marine medicine, Odessa
23-30 Sept. 1976. Moscow 1976. p.265.
5. Personal Safety on Ships. Prepared by the De-
References partment of Trade and the Central Office of In-
formation. London: Colibri Press 1979. Dd
1. Dolmierski, R., J. Filikowski, 1. Golebiowska et 803473 1 Pro 12510.
al.: Morski poradnik medyczny. [Medical guide 6. Personal Survival at sea. Prepared by the Depart-
for seafaring]. Warsaw: Panstwowy Zaklad Wy- ment of Trade and the Central Office for Her
dawnictw Lekarskich 1981. Majesty's Stationery Office by Collier/Searle
2. Executive Board 63rd Session. WHO Chronicie Ud. Dd 596696 Pro 11369.
33,7,337 (1979). 7. Stenko, YU.M.: Meditsinskaya pomoshch v
3. Lamoureux, V. B.: Guide to ship sanitation. Ge- more. [Medical aid at seal. Min. of Fishprod.
neva: WHO 1967. USSR. Moscow 1975.
4.2 The Seafarer's Personal Hygiene
YStenko
sents a reflex reaction to cooling, manifest- the skin in those who enter a cooled instal-
ed by skin vessel contraction and skin cool- lation where the decrease of solar tempera-
ing as a result of cold blood stimulation of ture by 5° -30 oe results not only in a more
both skin exteroceptors and interoceptors intense body heat exchange but also in su-
of deep tissues, organs, veins and arteries. percooling.
Depending on the intensity of extern al Rapid change of heat exchange modes is
temperature stimulation, verious thermo- of great significance. Thus, during work on
regulatory mechanisms come into action, deck a sailor's body receives heat from the
characterized by skin depot-to-depot blood warmed deck and bulkheads, and also as a
redistribution, an increase of arterial blood result of intensive solar radiation, and re-
pressure, reflex slowing of the pulse rate leases heat mainly through evaporation of
and increased heat production. The greater sweat. When entering a compartment with
the strain is on the thermoregulating sys- a cooler temperature, in addition to the
tem, the more vividly the primary organism continuing loss of heat through the sweat
re action is manifested. This is confirmed evaporation, there is a loss due to radiation
by the fact that during air temperature and convectional cooling, the former being
drops of 20 oe (a change of temperature more intensive.
conditions from 40° to 20°C) the primary Microc1imatic conditions in ship com-
reaction is so great that it involves musc1e partments (Table 1) are characterized by a
fibres ("gooseflesh") in addition to skin combination of four parameters: tempera-
vessels. So-called cold shock can develop. ture, relative air humidity, air speed and
When sailors are on deck und er condi- mean radiative temperature of the bulk-
tions of high air temperatures the ther- heads.
moregulation processes adapt to maximal The body is characterized by broad
heat exchange. Enhanced heat exchange adaptive potential. An unfavourable effect
continues during the first 5-15 min after a of cold c1imate can be eliminated by a
person enters an area with a lower air tem- proper organization of leisure time and
perature, owing to thermoregulatory iner- heating (Stenko [5]).
tia, already "adjusted" to maximal heat ex- To prevent the cooling down of the body
change. This enhanced heat exchange dur- and the feeling of freezing during breaks it
ing the first 5-15 min can be explained by is necessary to raise the room temperature
the fact that the whole body is covered with to a value between 15 oe and 20 oe and to
perspiration when the sailor leaves a high decrease the air speed to 0.5 m/s.
temperature environment.
eonsiderably raised water conduction,
4.2.3 Clothing
exceeding air heat conduction by a factor
ofthree and its thermal capacity by a factor Sailors' clothes must be waterproof, ade-
of four, results in better evaporation from quately protecting the body from cold and
Summer period
Cabins, public, medical
Northem 20-22 70-40 0.15-0.2
and service compart-
ments Moderate 22-23 60-40 0.20-0.3
Southem 23-24 60-40 Up to 0.5
Tropics 25 60-40 Up to 0.5
4.2 The Seafarer's Personal Hygiene 271
The amount of sex and other blood hor- come a source of infection. Thus, they
mones stabilizes at a certain constant level. should be individual.
As a result of sexual fantasies, film shows In view of elose daily mutual contacts of
etc., this level can be elevated, resulting in the crew members during their work, in
natural ejaculation during sleep. This is a cabins and public places, strict observance
normal function of a healthy body. Oecora- of the personal hygiene norms by every
tion of the cabin walls with erotic pin-ups sailor wi11lead to a satisfactory health sta-
should be discouraged because they are a tus. By strengthening his body, man can
disturbing influence in the absence of nor- cope with many hardships. The sea favours
mal outlets for sexual energy, especially at people with strong bodies and high morale.
night. Oaily exercise and a shower at bed-
time encourage a relaxed mood. Ouring
tropical voyages and shore leave sailors
should wear caps and sun glasses. In view
References
of the fact that a heating microclimate is
1. Dolmierski, R., J. Filikowski, I. Golebiowska et
created at a distance of 30-50 cm from the
al.: Morski poradnik medyczny. [Medical guide
open deck surface which is due to the for seafaring]. Warsaw: Panstwowy Zaklad Wy-
raised surface temperature of the deck and dawnictw Lekarskich 1981.
secondary air heating plus direct solar radi- 2. Ebert, H.: Health protection on the GDR sea-go-
ation, the wearing of long woollen socks is ing ships without medical personnel. Bull. Inst.
mar. trop. Med. Gdynia 28, 3/4, 125-128 (1977).
necessary. They will protect the feet and 3. International medical guide for ships. Geneva:
shins from overheating. Wearing heavy WH01967.
elothing in tropical conditions inhibits 4. Naeve, w.: Schiff ohne Schiffsarzt. Erkrankun-
thermoregulation; sensible elothes (shorts, gen und Verletzungen der Besatzung eines
Frachtschiffes im Liniendienst Europa-Süd-
shirt with short sleeves and open collar
amerika. Münch. med. Wschr. 113,24,909-913
without a tie) prevent the sailor from over- (1971).
heating. But strong sun radiation should be 5. Stenko, Yu.M.: Meditsinskoe posobie dlja kapi-
taken into account. tanov. [Medical guide for captains]. 2nd ed. Mos-
Any small personal artiele, such as a cow: Advert. Bureau of Min. Merch. Mar. Mos-
cow 1970.
handkerchief, smoking pipe or mouth- 6. Stenko, Yu. M.: Psikho-gigiena morjaka. [Psy-
piece, sandals and shaving articles, can, cho-Hygiene of seamen]. Leningrad: Meditsina
when used by more than one person, be- 1981.
4.3 Food Hygiene Aboard Ship
Dilwyn T.Jones
was shown in one instance (Poultney [12]) in this chapter). There must be no half-
that passengers would have been better ad- measures or scruples about this and it is al-
vised to eat off the toilet seats than off the ways advisable to ensure the support of the
cafeteria tables. ship's master by consulting hirn before-
The lack of microbiological expertise hand, by telling hirn precisely what is in-
and equipment on board makes it very dif- tended and by keeping hirn informed at
ficult to mount a thorough investigation of every stage. In this way, even an abortive
gastrointestinal outbreaks between ports. investigation can be used for the cementing
Any determination of the causative organ- of good relations and the establishment of
ism and its method of spread will frequent- an educational programme on board, re-
ly depend upon clinical examination and a sulting in great benefit to all.
detailed consideration of the symptoms The organisms found in shipboard out-
and signs and of their timing in relation to breaks of food-borne disease are the same
the consumption of suspect foods. A care- as on shore, Salmonella, Shigella, Staph.
ful study of the foods served at each meal aureus and Vibrio parahaemolyticus having
and a listing of the foods eaten by each all been incriminated at times. Attention
crew member or passenger, whether suffer- has also been drawn to the importance of
ing from the condition or not, may, with certain serotypes of enterotoxigenic E. coli
luck, demonstrate which food is responsi- - both heat-stable and heat-Iabile toxin be-
ble. On most occasions, however, there is ing involved, together or separately (Hobbs
no such good fortune and food preference et al. [4]); Wachsmuth et al. [15] and Lu-
charts will go no further than an indication mish et al. [8] - and the method of spread
that certain foods must be viewed with sus- on ships has been studied (Solodovnikov et
pi cion. It may even be possible to allocate al. [13]). It is apparent that good food hy-
different degrees of suspicion to the foods giene is a primary defence against the prob-
but, without certainty, it can be difficult to lem (Hobbs et al. [4] and Hobbs et al. [6]).
persuade those responsible that changes The occurrence on ships of viral gastroen-
should be made. On a ship with no SUf- teritis, such as that caused by the Norwalk
geon, the investigation may have to be de- agent, cannot be ruled out. The difficulty of
layed until the ship arrives at the next large isolating viruses makes shipboard investi-
port and then the success of the enquiry gation rarely practicable but evidence is
will depend on the accuracy of the memo- slowly accumulating to suggest that viruses
ries of those on board. In many of these may be a cause of food-borne gastroenteri-
cases it is impossible even to assemble a list tis (Appleton et al. [1]). Viruses do not repli-
of suspect foods, except in the most general cate in food (Appleton et al. [1]), so it seems
terms. Where ships' officers responsible for reasonable to consider that where tempera-
food hygiene have had sufficient training ture and humidity are associated with an
or have had a protocol prepared for them, increase in cases, a viral cause is unlikely.
they may carry out a preliminary investiga- Factors, other than food hygiene stan-
tion at the time of the attack and this could dards, which may be important in deter-
prove very useful. mining whether a person suffers a gastroin-
In all cases, any outbreak of possibly testinal infection on a ship include (a)
food-borne illness should invariably be fol- climatic conditions (b) foods eaten and (c)
lowed, as so on after the onset as possible, resistance to infection of the person con-
by a most stringent check of all food hy- cerned. The latter factor may be influenced
giene practices on board, together with a by (a) the previous exposure of the person
detailed examination of the gastrointesti- to such infections (people from more "sani-
nal history of every food handler (N. B. the tised" countries are at greater risk), (b) di-
broad definition of this word is set out later etetic irresponsibility, (c) overexposure to
4.3 Food Hygiene Aboard Ship 275
the sun, (d) lack of sleep and general non- galley is weil known, so it must represent a
adaptation to shipboard life and (e) upset- potential food poisoning threat but its actu-
ting movement of the ship (Parker [11]; al involvement has yet to be shown. Hobbs
Merson et al. [10]; Werner et al. [17] and et al. [5] demonstrated that galley cloths
Gangarosa et al. [2]). On cruise ships, there and cutting boards had high bacterial
is a relationship between the incidence of counts and recommended that they be
food-borne diseases and the length of the thoroughly cleansed at the end of each day
cruise, its geographical location and the (the cutting boards being additionally sub-
ambient temperature. It is also worth not- jected to hard wire brushing), then soaked
ing that survey work (Merson et al. [9]; overnight in a solution of sodium hypo-
Werner et al. [17]) has shown that the real chlorite containing 130 ppm of available
number of cases in any outbreak (and, one chlorine. Morning rinsing in water of pota-
suspects, on any cruise) is likely to be four ble quality renders them safe and pleasant
or five times the number logged by the sur- to use. On the other hand, Goethe and
geon but this has been disputed (Parker Herrmann [3] took scratch sampies from
[11]). fixtures in a large number of seagoing ships
Eating ashore is very often blamed for and examined them bacteriologically. Only
illness on ships. In fact, the ports visited by a third of the sampies were free from E. eoli
cruise ships are such that they might be but it was found that the E. eoli count of the
said to be carrying their passengers into wooden surfaces was only half that of the
risk of infection (Langley [7]). Too much plastic surfaces.
should not be made of this. It is too facile Gastrointestinal disease on ships is
an answer to a complex problem. Certain- usually mild in character but is occasional-
ly, if shipboard standards of food hygiene ly severe. In young children, old people
are low or if outbreaks recur in the same and those already debilitated by other con-
ship on cruises to different waters or if pri- ditions, it is always potentially serious and
mary illness occurs in people who have not may be life threatening.
been ashore or before the first port of call is The necessity of maintaining high food
reached, grave suspicion must fall on the hygiene standards on ships, given the diffi-
ship. It is not uncommon to find, on inves- culties already discussed, underlines the
tigation of a major outbreak, that there has need for shipboard food handlers to be
been a number of minor outbreaks on the highly trained. They should have to und er-
same ship during the previous few months, go a complete trade training, designed for
but these have been ignored by the ship's work on ships, before going to sea, and at-
officers or regarded as a "normal" happen- tendance at refresher courses, at reason-
ing. This attitude should be strongly at- ably short intervals, should be an estab-
tacked and all ships' masters should be in- lished practice.
structed by their companies to report even If a ship's master is in doubt as to the
the smallest outbreak at the earliest mo- safety of the food hygiene practices on his
ment. ship, he should apply to a Port Health Au-
Recent work has supported the tradi- thority or similar organisation. Their staff
tional suspicion of some shipboard condi- are expert in this field and will investigate
tions and practices. That ancient compan- and advise willingly.
ion of seafarers, the cockroach, has been
shown (Merson et al. [9] and Wegner et al. 4.3.3 Food Handling and Food
[16]) to be sometimes contaminated with
Handlers
food poisoning organisms, including sever-
al serotypes of Salmonella. The li king of The general principles of food handling -
the cockroach for warm dark corners in the obtain the food from a good source, cook it
276 4 Preventive Medicine Aboard
thoroughly, handling it as little as possible, to prepare it. This principle applies just as
and eat it immediately or hold it below 6 oe strongly to food prepared early for seamen
or above 60 oe - are as applicable at sea as working awkward shifts. In all mass cater-
they are on shore but, once again, they are ing, the use of large joints of meat and huge
more difficult to apply at sea. The inevi- specimens of poultry has economic advan-
table limitations on space make the provi- tages. There are health problems, however,
sions of sufficient refrigerated storage very in that the middle of the joint may not
difficult, while the variation in ambient reach a sufficiently high temperature to kill
temperature often makes generous refriger- off any pathogenic organisms. Therefore, it
ated space absolutely essential. The same is better to cut the meat into smaller pieces
type of problem occurs with the separation for cooking but, if this is not possible, the
of different types of foods. Shortage of cooking time must be adjusted. The tem-
space leads to a temptation to handle all perature at the middle of any joint must
foods in the same containers or on the reach at least 74 oe during cooking and
same work surfaces but this must be firmly anything, such as masses of moist stuffing,
resisted. Of great importance here is the which makes this more difficult should be
separation of raw and cooked foods and actively discouraged. This temperature
particularly of raw and cooked meats - no (74°C) is a useful figure to remember, as re-
contact, direct or indirect, between these heated leftovers must always be raised to at
foods should ever be permitted. Expendi- least that before being served.
ture on specially labelIed containers and It cannot be repeated too often that, with
refrigerated spaces combined, perhaps, the exception of canned or otherwise pre-
with a system of colour coding (Poultney served food and of fruit and vegetables,
[12]) is amply justified. food must not be left at temperatures be-
The general rules on the temperatures at tween 6 oe and 60 oe for any longer than is
which foods should be held can be summa- absolutely necessary. The ambient temper-
rised as folIows: ature in a galley will fall within this risk
range - therefore it is dangerous to leave
Allfrozen foods Below -18 oe food in the galley for any length of time.
Milk, cream and all foods This is especially important when food is
containing them 6 oe thawing or cooling. Thawing must be car-
Raw meat, poultry and fish ried out in a refrigerator and cooling after
(for short periods) Below 6 oe cooking must be as rapid as possible, the
Manufactured or pasteur- food being transferred to a refrigerator at
ised meat or meat prod- the earliest practicable moment.
ucts BeloW 6 oe Unwashed salads and fruit from any
Fruit and vegetables 6° -10 oe source are often contaminated with coli-
form bacteria, amoebae and other parasites
These temperatures do not guarantee in- and, therefore, potentially with pathogenic
definite keeping qualities and producers' organisms. They should, if to be eaten raw,
or manufacturers' instructions should al- always be washed in a solution of sodium
ways be carefully followed. hypochlorite providing 80 ppm of available
For buffets on deck, it is a temptation to chlorine which, after 30 s of immersion,
prepare the food early and hold it on deck will reduce the coliform count to negligible
at ambient temperatures. This can be high- figures (Hobbs et al. [5]).
ly dangerous and the "below 6 oe or above A food handler has been defined as a
60 oe" rule must be rigidly applied, food person who carries out any process in the
being allowed to remain between these sale of food or in the preparation, trans-
temperatures only for the short time it takes port, storage, packaging, wrapping expo-
4.3 Food Hygiene Aboard Ship 277
sure for sale, service or delivery of food or equipment. Each food preparation area
who cleans any article or equipment with should be equipped with an adequate num-
which food comes into contact and in the ber of wash-hand basins, each fitted out
context of shipping applies to everybody in with hot and cold water (delivered by mix-
the catering department, especially to the er tap), soap, nailbrush and disposable
cooks, the other kitchen personnel and the towels or hand-drying machine. Constant
stewards. This rather legalistic definition care should be taken to ensure that these
serves to emphasise the point that anyone are used before starting work, after every
who touches, directly or indirectly, another handling of raw food, after any dirty job
person's food or drink is a food handler and, invariably, before handling any
who must, during his work, keep hirns elf cooked or otherwise ready-to-eat food. In
and his clothing as clean as is practicable in addition to these facilities in the food prep-
the circumstances. This may not appear to aration areas, there must be handwashing
be a particularly stringent requirement but, basins easily available near each toilet. Of
as in all food hygiene, the practical (as op- all food hygiene precautions, thorough
posed to the totally theoretical) approach is washing of the hands after using the toilet
to be preferred. Only in that way can the es- is by far the most important. Health educa-
sential cooperation be obtained from those tion plays a great part here and all food
who actually do the work. For instance, in- handlers should be taught the reasons why
sistence on snow-white cleanliness when a toilet/hand hygiene is so important. How-
food handler is heaving large joints of fro- ever, all that will go for nothing ifthe wash-
zen raw meat about is a nonsense - but it is basins are not immediately available on
absolutely correct to ins ist that he change leaving the toilet or if the basin is not fully
into clean clothing and wash thoroughly fitted out. Response can be greatly im-
before he go es back to work in the galley, proved by the use of posters giving the
handling food (raw or cooked) which is "Now wash your hands" message in those
being prepared for consumption. Bodily languages normally spoken by the food
cleanliness is just as important as clean handlers.
clothing and all food handlers should be It may be that if these precautions are
expected to maintain clean hands, face and faithfully observed, the chances of a food
head. Ambient temperatures on board tend handler transmitting any food poisoning
to be high, especially in the tropics, and a will be greatly reduced. However, it is a
casual approach to dress (or undress) is of- commonsense precaution to prevent the
ten the result. The food handler working in employment of a food handler who is suf-
such temperatures must be even more care- fering from, or carrying, any potentially
ful to maintain personal cleanliness and to food-bome disease. Medical screening, de-
cover those parts of his body which may signed with the job in mind, is essential be-
come into contact with food. Contamina- fore signing on. In addition, there must be
tion of food with drops of sweat may also an invariable rule on board that any food
be a problem. handler who falls ill must report sick imme-
Good personal hygiene is greatly diately, be taken off food handling work
encouraged by an easy availability of wash- and not be allowed back to it until all possi-
ing facilities. Baths and/or showers must bility of his suffering from a potentially
be plentiful and easy of access. Of particu- food-bome infection has been excluded by
lar importance to food handlers are the a qualified person. Especial care must be
handwashing facilities - these must be so taken with gastrointestinal illness, and the
easily available that no food handler is ever mildest diarrhoea or nausea in a food han-
tempted to wash his hands in a sink in- dler should initiate the above procedure.
tended for the washing of food, utensils or Discharges from the nose, ear or mouth
278 4 Preventive Medicine Aboard
and skin conditions such as boils or other In deciding what degree of risk is pre-
staphylococcal infections are other reasons sent, it is reasonable to consider (a) the na-
for exclusion from work. Cuts on hands are ture of the food (i. e. raw vegetables would
a matter for judgement. If they are clean not present any risk), (b) the way in which
and covered with a clean, waterproof the food is packed, (c) any process to which
dressing, they may be allowed. Smoking, the food will be subjected before it is eaten
spitting or nailbiting in a food preparation and (d) any possibility of contamination
area must be absolutely forbidden. being passed secondarily to other foods.
principle of safe temperature ranges must must be free running and easily cleaned out
be well understood by the staff. and washed through. They should be
The lighting of all food rooms must be covered with easily removable, heavy
such that there are no dark corners where plates of perforated metal.
dirt and debris can collect unnoticed and The design of equipment for washing
the work surfaces should have an illumina- and sterilising utensils and crockery should
tion of at least 200 lux. be based on simple logic rather than good
Condensation may be a considerable looks. Whatever scheme is used, there must
problem. The standard of ventilation is a be a capacity for removing food debris,
crucial factor he re but, even where ventila- with or without detergent, for rinsing and
tion is excellent, some condensation may for bactericidal treatment. This can be effi-
occur and the design of the equipment and ciently carried out in three stages - first, re-
of overhead trunking and pipework must moval of gross food debris by hand, sec-
ensure that drips do not occur where food ond, washing in a detergent solution at not
may be contaminated. less than 60°C and third, a bactericidal
Efficient cleaning is of first importance rinse. The latter can be by immersion for at
and the galley design must make this as least 30 s in water at not less than 82°C or
easy as possible. Thorough cleaning be- for at least 1 min in a lukewarm solution of
neath equipment can be facilitated or made sodium hypochlorite providing, at all
impossible by its design. Tubular construc- times, more than 50 ppm available chlo-
tion with no under-worktop cupboards is rine. It cannot be overemphasised that tem-
sometimes recommended but may be too peratures and concentrations of bactericid-
space consuming. The space beneath al agents are crucial factors and must be
equipment should be either at least 15 cm meticulously monitored. If a dishwasher is
high to allow easy access or completely available, the first stage, i. e. removal of
eliminated by bedding and bolting down gross food debris, must still be carried out
the equipment to the deck so that dirt, food by hand before the dishes are placed in the
debris, insects and rodents cannot obtain machine. The washing phase should be
entry. Work surfaces should be regularly maintained at more than 60°C for at least
swabbed down with sodium hypochlorite 1 min and the rinse at more than 82 oe. Af-
solution. Wood chopping blocks should be ter any of these methods, the utensils or
examined regularly. They wear badly in use crockery should be allowed to air-dry with-
and the surface becomes so cut about that out wiping. If they must be wiped, the
it is impossible to clean. Planing will estab- cleanliness of the cloths must be carefully
lish a new surface and remove the heaIth monitored.
risk. The deck should be regularly washed Some mention must be made of two po-
down to remove grease and food debris. It tential design problems which are often ig-
has been the habit to use sea water for this, nored. First, on a ship it is quite impossible
through special outlets, carefully labelled, to avoid pipes and ducts being fixed on
located at not more than 45 cm above the deckheads and bulkheads, even in the food
deck. In polluted waters, however, even preparation areas. It is, therefore, impera-
these can be dangerous in use, because of tive, especially with sewage and other
the possibility of the water splashing on to waste pipes, that the possiblity of leakage is
work surfaces or into containers (Merson et avoided by a refusal to accept inspection or
al. [10]). It is better, therefore, except in the drainage points within the food areas and
unlikely event of absolute certainty that the an insistence that any inevitable joints are
water overside is unpolluted, to use only regularly inspected. Second, it is impossi-
potable water for washing down. Drainage ble to maintain high standards of food hy-
of all this water must be efficient - gulleys giene if untrained staff are able to pass ca-
280 4 Preventive Medicine Aboard
sually through the food areas. Therefore, period of supply. If ice is made on board,
good design will ensure that these areas the water supplied to the machine must be
cannot be used as a short cut from one part of a potable quality and the machine must
of the ship to another. be maintained and serviced strictly accord-
Waste and refuse collection and removal ing to the manufacturer's instructions. Re-
must be carefully planned, with the empha- moval of ice from the machine by hand
sis on removal. Refuse collection in the should be roundly condemned. The use of
food areas can be in metal bins or in bags a scoop should be encouraged by its ready
hung off the deck but removal, and imme- availability and the use of posters. The
diate replacement with clean containers, shape and size of the scoop should be such
must be carried out regularly and frequent- as to permit the removal of a reasonable
ly. If metal bins are used, an area outside amount of ice in one operation and the ma-
the food handling areas must be set aside terial of which it is made should be imper-
where they can be cleaned and steam-ster- vious, smooth and easily cleaned - and it
ilised. Refuse storage must also be located should be so cleaned, frequently and care-
well away from any form of food handling. fully. When not in use, the scoop should be
The area should be specially and clearly kept in a container of sodium hypochlorite
marked and the containers therein must solution, on, or very near, the ice-making
be tight lidded and be rodent and insect machine.
proof. Machines for reconstituting milk have
All food storage, serving and prepara- been the source of a number of outbreaks
tion areas must also be protected, so far as of disease. Although fresh milk, bought
is possible, against rodents and insects, ashore and refrigerated aboard, must be
crawling or flying. However, the best pro- carefully handled and the sources regularly
tection is sometimes unavailing and a con- monitored, it is preferred by most seafarers.
stant surveillance should be maintained. In This fact, and the availability of ultra heat-
a modem ship, insects are likely to be the treated milk, which keeps for long periods,
greater problem and a regular spraying have greatly reduced the number of recon-
programme, using residual and space in- stituters in use. There are instances, how-
secticides, should be undertaken but the ever, when reconstituted milk is used, ei-
greatest care should be exercised to ensure ther out of preference or necessity. Dried
that there is no contamination of food or whole milk is the usual "raw" material used
surfaces likely to come into contact with and this must be stored in a dry, cool place,
food. protected from rodents and insects. It must
also be protected from taints and odours,
4.3.6 Ice-Making and Milk-Making which it picks up very quickly. The dried
Machines milk must be carefully loaded into the con-
stituter to ensure that it all falls into the
Ice is a substance which is vastly misunder- mixing vat, otherwise a mass of caked milk
stood on some ships - because it is cold, it powder will form which, if the ambient
is thought to be totally harmless. Nothing temperature is high enough, will act as an
could be farther from the truth. It is a tru- excellent medium for the replication of or-
ism that, in any shipboard outbreak of gas- ganisms (Hobbs et al. [5]).
trointestinal disease, all ice sources, ma- After use of any food or drink machine,
chines and storage methods should be it is ofthe utmost importance that it should
subjected to the most careful scrutiny. be thoroughly cleaned and sterilised.
Commercially bought ice should be partic- Where a machine is in constant use, regular
ularly suspect and the sources checked cleaning and sterilising, at least once every
thoroughly before purchase and during the 24 h, should be instituted. Manufacturers
4.3 Food Hygiene Aboard Ship 281
of these machines usually issue excellent The method of storage must permit good
instructions for their maintenance and ventilation of the foods and efficient rota-
cleansing and these should be meticulously tion. The need to keep raw and cooked
followed. foods apart is as important here as any-
where else. The shelving should be easily
4.3.7 Refrigerated Stores cleaned and made of materials which will
not deteriorate at low temperatures. All
The temperatures at which various foods foodstuffs in a deep freeze, if not already
should be kept have already been dis- packed in sealed containers, should be kept
cussed. The temperature maintained by or- in sealed individual plastic wrapping.
dinary refrigeration is commonly 4° -6°C Foods kept in refrigerators should be si mi-
while deep freeze units maintain a temper- larly wrapped or kept in covered contain-
ature no higher than -18 oe. The mainte- ers although the requirements need not be
nance of these temperatures is the reason as stringent.
for the not inconsiderable cost of installing Thawing of deep-frozen food should al-
the units and a refusal, on financial ways be carried out in ordinary refrigerated
grounds, to fit adequate monitoring equip- spaces, never at ambient temperatures.
me nt to ensure that the temperatures are This method of thawing may take longer,
maintained, day and night, makes no sense. but it removes the possibility of a high am-
In fact, such refusal leaves matters worse bient temperature causing rapid multipli-
than they would be if there were no re- cation of organisms already in the food.
frigerated stores at all. In the latter case, Adequate thawing time must always be al-
staff can be educated to select foods and lowed for large joints and poultry.
use cooking methods which do not rely up- Ship's refrigerated stores must not only be
on low temperature storage; but if a refrig- efficient, they must be big enough for all
erated store is available in which the tem- the demands that will be made upon them.
perature can exceed the safe limit without Even in a small merchant ship, an amount
anyone being aware of it, the staff may be of space is required which may seem over-
dangerously misled. The permanent pres- ambitious to people with other plans. It is
ence of an accurate maximum/minimum not normally difficult to make out a con-
thermometer inside (or outside, showing vincing case for adequate long-term re-
the temperature inside) each refrigerated frigerated stores. Short-term daily-use re-
store is the minimum acceptable. Continu- frigerated stores are more difficult. Unin-
ous temperature recording systems are formed opinion may not see the need for
even better. The sealing strips of refrigera- the refrigeration of food prepared in ad-
tor and deep freezer doors should be ex- vance and not to be eaten for some hours
amined regularly. They are liable to perish, but it is here that outbreaks of food poi-
so decreasing efficiency and increasing soning often originate.
cost.
In common with all other food areas, the 4.3.8 Unrefrigerated Stores
deck, deckhead and bulkheads of these
stores must be impervious, light in colour These stores are sometimes regarded as
and easy to clean. There must be no smells spaces where anything or everything can be
within a store as food taint is a surprisingly stowed away without any regard for food
pervasive and distasteful phenomenon. hygiene, safety or even commonsense. This
Such smells should be sought immediately can be very dangerous. There should be
on entering the store as, in some people, different stores for different purposes.
the sense of sm eil is rapidly diminished by Unrefrigerated stores for food are better
inhalation of cold air. labelIed as cool stores. It is unnecessary for
282 4 Preventive Medicine Aboard
a!.: Study of the presence of Salmonella and Standards of sanitation and ratproofing for the
other pathogenic bacteria in cockroaches on construction of vessels. Ed.: V. S. Department
ocean-going ships. I. Basic investigations on of Health, Education, and Welfare. Washing-
isolation of bacterial strains from Blattella ger- ton: V.S. Govemment Printing Office 1967.
manica (L.). Bull. Inst. mar. trop. Med. Gdynia (Public Health Service Publication No. 393).
30.1,59-67 (1979). Handbook on sanitation of vessels in operation.
17. Wemer, S. B., M. P. Hudgins, F. R. Morrison et Sanitation features and facilities on vessels in
a!.: Gastroenteritis on a cruise ship - a recur- operation. Ed.: U. S. Department of Health,
ring problem - Pub!. Hlth Rep. 91, 5, 433-436 Education, and Welfare. Washington: V.S.
(1976). Govemment Printing Office 1963, (Public
Health Service Publication No.68)
Additional References Hobbs, B.C. and R.J.Gilbert: Food poisoning and
Code of practice on the hygiene of food and fresh food hygiene. 4th ed. London: Edward Amold
water supplies in passenger ships. London: 1978.
General Council of British Shipping. 1981. Supplemental instruction guide for vessel sanita-
The food hygiene (docks, carriers, etc.) regulations, tion. Inspection report. Ed.: U. S. Department
1960. The food hygiene (markets, stalls & deliv- of Health, Education, and Welfare. Center for
ery vehic1es) regulations, 1966. Disease Contro!. Bureau of Epidemiology.
The food hygiene (general) regulations, 1970. Quarantine Division. Atlanta, 1976.
The food hygiene (ships) regulations, 1979. Lamoureux, Y. B.: Guide to ship sanitation. Ge-
London: Her Majesty's Stationery Office. neva: WHO 1967.
Handbook on sanitation of vessel construction.
4.4. Alcohol, Drugs and Smoking in Seafaring
A.Backhaus,E.Zorn
offences concerning discipline and social liberal or opportunistic attitude towards al-
life (Gunderson and Schuckit [16, 17]; cohol consumption and whose 'captains
Kanstorf [24]; Measey [30]; Schuckit and themselves are fond of alcohol. As a result,
Gunderson [39, 40, 42]; Tetzlaff[43]). the differences between ships are consider-
The consumption of alcohol and the able, and fragmentary data cannot be re-
prevalence of alcoholism itself vary greatly garded as having general validity.
between nationalities. Apart from national On board, just as in the world of work
customs and economic factors, ideological ashore, beer holds a special position. Sea-
and religious factors also have a certain men very often regard it as thirst quenching
limited influence. Habits regarding alcohol and refreshing, but not as an alcoholic
consumption that are present on land con- drink.
tinue to be adhered to on board. Germans, Ouring studies on work-Ioad on board
and north Europeans generally, predomi- seagoing vessels (the 'Flensburg Study',
nantly consume beer, whereas south Euro- 1972-1974), 180 probands were closely
peans tend to consume wine, and North questioned on, among other things, their
Americans and Scandinavians, high-proof consumption of alcohol. Twelve percent
alcohol. Since Islam totally forbids the were teetotallers; the remaining 88% drank
consumption of alcohol, alcoholism is very between two and ten bottles of beer a day
rare on ships with a Muslim crew. Alcohol (average, ca. five bottles). A third also con-
consumption is also restricted on ships sumed concentrated alcoholic beverages
from the USSR and the People's Republic on a regular basis - about one bottle a
ofChina. Among Norwegian, Swedish and week.
Finnish crews, alcohol consumption is In 1975 Zorn [51], in another study,
probably far greater than on land, and al- found on German ships an average con-
coholism is a current problem (Brun-Gul- sumption of three to four bottles of beer
brandsen and Irgens-Jensen [6]; Kj0lstad per man and day and one to two bottles of
[25]). In the light of all the evidence, one spirit per week. The individual beer con-
can certainly make the assumption that the sumption differed between zero and ten
very different national characteristics have bottles of beer per day. About 10 years ear-
a considerable influence on alcohol con- lier Backhaus [1] had reported an average
sumption among seafarers. be er consumption of five to six bottles per
Nevertheless, one cannot assess alcohol man andday.
consumption simply on the basis ofthe na- According to the experience of the Ger-
tionality ofthe crew members, for the influ- man Seeberufsgenossenschaft, alcoholism
ence of the shipping company and the ex- has the highest incidence rate among the
ample set by the captain also play an seamen who are officially declared unfit
essential role in determining the nature of for duty at sea. In 1981 a total of 117 sea-
life on board and thus also the extent of al- men were declared unfit, 53 thereof for al-
cohol consumption. There are 'dry' as weIl coholism or other addictions [44].
as 'wet' ships, and whether a ship is dry or Ouring the proceedings of the Maritime
wet depends essentially on the orders ofthe Court of Enquiry in Hamburg between
company and the captain's example. Thus 1965 and 1974, five cases of running
no seaman dependent on alcohol will be aground or collision and 41 accidents with
found on ships which belong to companies a fatal outcome were registered as essen-
that forbid the sale ofhigh-proof alcohol or tially resulting from the influence of alco-
even all alcoholic drinks and whose cap- hol. In at least eight cases of fire on board,
tains keep a tight control on alcohol con- excessive intake of alcohol had played a
sumption. The opposite is the case on the decisive role. One can, however, assurne
ships of those companies that adopt a very with certainty that a not negligible number
286 4 Preventive Medicine Aboard
of unexplained accidents - especially those ties and the court. It has been recom-
involving the disappearance of crew mem- mended that the level be set at 1.3%0
bers from the ship - were caused by alco- (Janssen [23]; Naeve [32]). Supervision to
hol. There are undoubtedly many accidents ensure that the permissible level is adhered
caused by alcohol that are not attributed to to could, in conjunction with long-term ex-
it afterwards (Zorn [51]). planation of the effects of alcohol, have a
In an evaluation of 176 acutely fatal ac- positive influence on the drinking habits of
cidents on board or near to the ship in seafarers and thus make alcoholic intoxica-
Hamburg harbour, blood concentrations of tion among them a rare occurrence.
alcohol were between 1.5%0 and 3.0%0 in It is not possible to rule out a certain in-
80% of the victims (Naeve [32]). Approxi- take of persons of unsuitable character into
mately two-thirds of the accidents occurred the occupation of seafaring, although such
during leisure time. instances are certainly less frequent than in
Reports of excessive alcohol consump- previous centuries. Nevertheless, since ex-
tion are often kept secret by the arcane na- aminations to establish the suitability of
ture of the seafaring community. Of 900 candidates scarcely take into account the
Polish seamen, 201 (22.3%) were registered psychological sphere, it is virtually impos-
as periodically drinking to excess, which sible to exclude those with character de-
also led to conflicts. There is a need for fects, neuroses, low intelligence and other
prophylactic measures against excessive al- faults in personality structure. In such men,
co hol consumption among 20%-30% of exogenous factors such as the monotony of
seamen, and approximately 3% are in need life on board, the lack ofworthwhile leisure
of treatment (Dolmierski [11]). activities and the build-up of tension
There is no doubt that overindulgence in among the all-male crew can result in alco-
alcohol poses a serious risk to the crew, the holism. Alcohol consumption will also be
ship and the environment. It is, however, promoted by a variety of other factors, e. g.
difficult to assess the extent ofthis risk, and the low cost of alcoholic drinks on board, a
comparisons with land and air traffk are possible lack of good non-alcoholic drinks,
scarcely possible. That a crew member is difficulties in making contacts when going
drunk need not necessarily and directly ashore - which are supposed to be eased
have an effect on the ship's safety, since the by alcohol - and, finally, the hackneyed be-
person concerned can usually be relieved lief that to be areal seamen one must drink
by another crew member (this should be a large quantity of alcohol.
done if at all possible). The risk to safety as There are persons, who need the relaxing
a result of alcohol consumption will in- effect of alcohol to start a conversation.
crease quite considerably owing to the re- That is not a problem for sailors only, but it
ductions in personnel and the introduction may be so for them more frequently than
of bridge designs for one-man control as for others. If this is true, people who need
weil as to the higher speeds of ships and the alcohol for this purpose should train them-
increased traffk in shipping lanes. From selves to use alcohol reasonably in creating
both a medical and a legal point of view it friendship. Northern European culture and
seems necessary to introduce as soon as civilisation does not help much in this
possible, for both sea and inland shipping, training, as opposed to other countries,
a limit regarding the permissible concentra- such as Spain, Italy and Greece, where the
tion of alcohol in the blood. This would re- reasonable use of alcohol is the normal sit-
move the legal confusion in the area, facili- uation. They drink not only wine, but also
tate police measures and take the burden of some stronger forms of alcohol, not for the
proof (which poses a considerable prob- toxic effect, but for the taste and for the
lem) away from the investigating authori- spirit of hospitality and community (Back-
4.4 Alcohol, Drugs and Smoking in Seafaring 287
haus [2]; Bonfiglio and Cieala [3]; Carev Since we cannot hope for the coopera-
and Sokec [7,8]; Cieala [9]; Kolb et al. [26]). tion of the alcohol addict in the early stage
Loneliness is clearly not a problem re- - the lack of cooperation (Gardner [14];
stricted to ships, but it is common on ships Schuckit and Gunderson [41]) is a symp-
and depresses seamen more than people on tom of his sickness - everyone from friends
land. Naturally, ships with extremely bad to authorities is responsible for the poten-
accommodation and a large crew can give tially fatal development of the illness,
a feeling of isolation to those on board. The whieh at the beginning is still curable. Strict
same effect can also be caused, however, rules are needed whieh should be based on
where there is good accommodation and a law. For example:
small crew. The ship is a place of isolation. - The captain should report all difficulties
This can be feIt in the continual company probably caused by alcohol
ofthe same crew: company not selected by - In all accident cases, an alcohol test
the individual. It can also be feIt in one's should be given without exception
own accommodation, in small groups at - A company should not be allowed to
work or in one's leisure time. At sea, the send someone who is under the influ-
crew is cut off from all social contacts with ence of alcohol to a ship or to a doctor
people on land. for routine examination
Today the facilities on board ships and - Liver function tests should be obligatory.
in the network of organisations looking af- In the case of pathological findings, fur-
ter seafarers are the best possible (Glass ther investigations should be made to es-
[15]; Haasz et al. [19]; Hiles [20]). If every- tablish whether the person is an alcohol
body cooperates, the addict cannot avoid addiet (Hitz [21])
treatment (Bourg et al. [4]). Forcing an ad- - Every person who is an alcoholic or is
diet to undergo treatment will not lead to suspected ofbeing one should be treated
success. Only when the circumstances per- as a siek person: he should not lose his
mit no escape will the addict surrender job or pay, and free treatment should be
hirns elf to being saved. Among his many given
contacts are crew members, friends, staff of A very simple test of alcoholism is to ask
the company personnel office, trade union the seafarer to drink no alcohol for at least
officials, the security authorities (e. g. har- one week or even longer. No alcoholic can
bour police and coast guard), the company do without alcohol. It might be possible to
doctor and the authority's doctor. Every- promote a general interest in an alcohol-
one should feel responsible. The best free week to prove that the participants are
course is to speak to the addiet personally, not alcoholics, but it would require the co-
although this is not easy. Subsequently the operation of the seafarers' organisations
authorities must be informed, not as a con- and the shipping company.
demnation but as a suspicion. Alcoholism among adolescent seamen
A person thought to have an organic dis- represents a special problem. Young sea-
ease or even a venereal infection is sent farers who join a ship prior to their 18th
horne and not allowed to work until he is birthday, coming directly from a protective
cured. There is no condemnation and no family background, enter an environment
moral verdict. A similar attitude should be where customs and attitudes directly de-
adopted and no other steps are necessary mand the abuse of alcohol (Kj0lstad [25])
in alcoholism. Such a scheme has been de- and are especially at risk. The Institute of
veloped and practised with good results in Research into Alcoholism in Oslo, which to
the USA (Brownell [5]; Molloy et al. [31]).1t a large extent is concerned with the danger
implies a fundamental change in our atti- to seamen of alcohol, has established that
tude to alcohol abuse. most alcoholics in seafaring already con-
288 4 Preventive Medicine Aboard
9. Cicala, S.: L'alcoolismo nei marittirni. Atti della mißbräuchlichen Alkoholgenusses in der Ma-
"Sezione Studi" dei C. 1. R M. pp 111-121 rine. Analyse und Folgerungen. Studienarbeit,
(1962). StabsoffIzier- und Auswahllehrgang der Ma-
10. Cocking, R: Nearly one crew member in five rine 3/73.
aboard ship has a problem with alcohol, and 25. Kjolstad, Th.: Alkoholisme hos Sjomenn. T.
the situation is getting worse all the time. norske Laegeforen. 84, 18, 1243-1248 (1964).
Freighting World, 8 October 1975. 26. Kolb, D., E.K.E.Gunderson and S.Bucky:
11. Dolmierski, R: Alkoholismus unter Seeleuten Prognostic indicators for Black and White alco-
der polnischen Handelsmarine. Verk.-Med. 30, holics in the U. S. Navy. 1. Stud. Alcohol 37,
1/2, 18-23 (1983). 1094 (1976).
12. Drinking and drowning. Brit. Med. J. 1,70-71 27. Krause, L.: Trink- und Rauchgewohnheiten bei
(1979). Hamburger Arbeitnehmern verschiedener Be-
13. Fonssagrives, J.-B.: Traite d'hygit'me navale. Pa- rufsgruppen. Arbeitsmed., Sozialmed., Präven-
ris: Bailliere 1877. tivmed. 7, 139 (1975).
14. Gardner, A W: Identifying and helping seafar- 28. Kubisch, G.: Blutalkohol und Ertrinken. Blutal-
ers who are problem drinkers. Fawley 1982. kohol2 (1963).
Manuscript. 29. Marjot, D.H.: Delirium tremens in the Royal
15. Glass, G. S.: The alcohol rehabilitation unit, Navy and British Army in the 19th century. J.
National Naval Medical Center, Bethesda. Mil- Stud. Alcohol38, 9,1613-1623 (1977).
it. Med. 139,486-488 (1974). 30. Measey, L.G.: Alcohol and the royal naval of-
16. Gunderson, E.K.E. and M.ASchuckit: Hospi- fender. 1. roy. nav. med. Servo 58, 1, 52-55
talization rates for alcoholism in the navy and (1972).
marine corps. Dis. nerv. Syst. 36, 681-684 31. Molloy, D., 1. Barron, RFarkas et al.: A union
(1975). alcoholism program working with many em-
17. Gunderson, E. K. E. and M. Schuckit: Alcoho- ployers. Labor-Mgmt. Alcsm. 1. (N. Y.) 9,
lism in the navy and marine corps: hospitaliza- 234-245 (1980).
tion rates by age and pay grade. Manuscript 32. Naeve, W.: Bedeutung des Alkohols bei
[1975]. tödlichen Unfällen an Bord und im Hafen.
18. Haasz, A, LHaasz, S.Cuk et al.: Pomorci i Blutalkohol 13, 27-38 (1976).
droge. [Seafarers and drugs]. In: Pomorska 33. Nail, RL. and E.K.E.Gunderson: Drug histo-
medicina H. (Naucne rasprave). Beograd: Iz- ries of navy amnesty cases. Milit. Med. 140,
danje Mornarickog glasnika 1979. pp 321- 172-178 (1975).
325. (Pomorska biblioteka. Sveska 30.) 34. Nolan, B.: Seamen, drink and social structure.
19. Haasz, 1., S.Cuk and AHaasz: Alkoholizam u Marit. Pol. Mgmt. 4,77-88 (1976).
pomoraca. [Alcoholism among seafarers]. In: 35. Plag, J.A and J.M.Goffman: Characteristics of
Pomorska medicina. (Nauene rasprave). Beo- naval recruits with histories of drug abuse. Mil-
grad: Izdanje Mornarickog glasnika 1975. it. Med. 138,354-359 (1973).
pp 357-362. (Pomorska biblioteka. Sveska 26.) 36. Sarg jr., M.J.: Heroin use in the navy. New
20. Hiles, F. M. J.: The prevention and treatment of Engl. J. Med. 286, 2, 111-112 (1972).
alcoholism in the Royal Navy.l. A policy. J. roy. 37. Schadewaldt, H.: Alkohol an Bord. Schiff und
nav. med. Servo 66,3,180-185 (1980). Zeit 2,55-65 (1975).
21. Hitz, D.: Drunken sailors and others. Drinking 38. Schmidt, L.: Gifte mit Wirkungen auf die
problems in specific occupations. Quart. J. Psyche in der Vergangenheit und Gegenwart.
Stud. Alcohol 34, 496-505 (1973). Med. heute 15, 12, 365-367 (1966).
22. Hoeffier, D. F.: Smoking and health in the 39. Schuckit, M.A and E.K.E.Gunderson: Alco-
Navy. U.S. Navy Med. 71,2,15-19 (1980). holism among navy and marine corps offIcers.
23. Janssen, W.: Alkohol auf dem Wasser - Erfah- Navy Medical Neuropsychiatric Research
rungen der letzten Jahre und Begründung der Unit. San Diego, Cal. [abt. 1972].
Notwendigkeit einer zukünftigen Grenzwert- 40. Schuckit, M. A and E. K. E. Gunderson: Alco-
gestaltung für den Sicherheitsbereich an Bord holism in navy and marine corps women: a first
von Schiffen. In: Unfall- und Sicherheitsfor- look. Milit. Med. 140,268-271 (1975).
schung Straßenverkehr. Kongreßbericht Jah- 41. Schuckit, M.A and E.K.E.Gunderson: Early
restagung 1981 der Dtsch. Ges. f. Verkehrsmed. identification of alcoholism in navy psychiatric
gemeinsam m. d. Dtsch. Verkehrswacht. Ham- outpatients. Navy Medical Neuropsychiatric
burg, 7.-9.5. 1981. Bundesanstalt f. Straßen- Research Unit. San Diego, Cal. [abt. 1972].
wesen, Bereich Unfallforschung, Köln, i. Auf- 42. Schuckit, M. A and E. K. E. Gunderson: Deaths
trage d. Bundesministers f. Verkehr (ed). among young alcoholics in the U. S. Naval Ser-
Braunschweig: Waisenhaus-Buchdruckerei vice. Quart. J. Stud. Alcohol 35, 856-862 (1974).
1981. pp 44-45. 43. Tetzlaff, M.: Disziplin und Alkohol. Dienst-
24. Kanstorf, G.: Ursachen und Auswirkungen vergehen unter Alkoholeinfluß, dargestellt an
4.4 Alcohol, Drugs and Smoking in Seafaring 291
Beispielen aus dem Bereich der Marine. Trup- 49. With, O. H.: Gesundheitspflege auf Seeschiffen
penpraxis 10, 785-788 (1977). für Gebildete aller Stände, namentlich für
44. Unfallverhütung, Schiffssicherheit, Gesund- Schiffsoffiziere und Auswanderer. Bremerha-
heitsdienst. Bericht 1981. See-Berufsgenos- ven: v. Vangerow 1858.
senschaft (ed) Hamburg 1982. 50. Wodarg, w.: Psychische Krankheiten der See-
45. Vellar, O. D.: Rokevaner blant norske sjomenn leute. Untersuchung über Selbsttötung. Alko-
og menn i land. (Smoking habits among Nor- holismus und andere wichtige psychiatrische
wegian seamen and men ashore). Landsfore- Erkrankungen anhand von 236 von der See-
ningen mot Kreft (ed) Oslo 1965. Berufsgenossenschaft gesammelten Seeamts-
46. Wenzel, K.-H.: Des Seemanns bester Freund ist verhandlungen aus den Jahren 1960 bis 1973.
der Rum. Hamburger Gerichtsmediziner legen Dissertation, University of Hamburg 1977.
Studie über "Trunkenheit am Ruder" vor. Ärztl. 51. Zorn, E.: Alkoholkonsum an Bord. Beobach-
Prax. 26, 100,4349-4350 (1974). tungen aus der Praxis. In: Verkehrsmedizi-
47. Wietfeld, H.: Seemann und Betäubungsmittel. nische Probleme in der See- und Binnen-
Kommandobrücke 184-185 (1964). schiffahrt. Jahrestagung der Deutschen Gesells-
48. Wietfeld, H.: Tabletten können die Schiffsfüh- chaft für Verkehrsmedizin Hamburg,
rung gefährden. Kommandobrücke 220 (1965). 11.-13. April 1975. pp 7-16.
4.5 Infectious Diseases - Vaccination and Passive Immunization
J.Huisman
mune seamen. Chloroquine is, notwith- cept a doctor's certificate indicating that
standing the rising resistance against it, the vaccination against smallpox was not
drug of choiee for Mrica, the South-west performed because of medieal reasons
Pacific and Central and South America. In ("risk of complications"). These certificates
areas where chloroquine-resistant falcipa- should be authenticated by the health au-
rum malaria occurs (for instance in many thorities as in the case ofWHO vaccination
countries of the Far East and East Mrica, certificates. Vaccination against smallpox
as well as in Papua, tropieal South America should now be considered as an unneces-
and Panama), a fixed combination of sary prophylactie medical treatment and
500 mg sulfadoxine and 25 mg pyrimetha- therefore be abolished. This is especially
mine (Fansidar) should be used, adminis- true for primary vaccinations because of
tered once a week. Alternatively half of the relatively high risk of serious complica-
these amounts may be given weekly for a tions (e.g. postvaccinal encephalitis).
maximum period of 6 months [3).
Prophylactie drugs should be taken from 4.5.2.2 Vaccination Against Yellow Fever
a few days before arrival in malarious The areas in which yellow fever is endemie
zones and be continued at least 4 weeks af- are in Central and (parts of northern)
ter leaving these areas. The fact that ships South America and in Mrica between
anchor at the roads is not always a guaran- 15°N and 10 0 S (including the Sudan, Ethi-
tee that malaria transmission will not oc- opia and countries of West Central and
cur; the flight range of female Anopheles East Mrica). There is no evidence that yel-
mosquitos averages 2 or 3 km from their low fever ever has been present in Asia or
breeding place (Bruce-Chwatt [2]). Oramat- on the northern coast of Mrica [3). Vaccina-
ic outbreaks of falciparum malaria on tion against yellow fever is required of any
board among seamen not taking suppres- person leaving from, or arriving at, a port
sive drugs have been described (Schultz et or airport situated in these endemie areas.
al. [16]). The yellow fever vaccine used must be ap-
proved by the World Health Organization
and the vaccinating centre must have been
4.5.2 Vaccination and Passive
designated by the health administration for
Immunization the territory in which it is situated. The
World Health Organization must be as-
4.5.2.1 Vaccination Against Smallpox sured that the vaccines used for this pur-
Notwithstanding the fact that the Thirty- pose continue to be of suitable quality [7).
third World Health Assembly in May 1980 Yellow fever vaccine consists of an atten-
officially dec1ared that the global eradica- uated virus (170), cultivated in chiek em-
tion of smallpox had been achieved [15), a bryos in eggs from avian leucosis-free
number of doctors continue to (re-)vacci- flocks and is effective. The 170 vaccine
nate travellers and seafarers against this used today is a freeze-dried preparation,
now non-existent disease. On the basis of whieh is reconstituted in sterile water
available information - as from May 1982 immediately before use. The dose is 0.5 ml
- only Chad and Oemocratic Kampuchea subcutaneously. Antibodies appear 7-10
may be requiring smallpox vaccination days after vaccination and persist for many
from travellers [18). Unfortunately there are years. Revaccination is officially required
still instances where the action taken at at the end of 10years. Yellow fever vaccine
ports and airports in some countries is not should not be given to children under
consistent with the requirements of the na- 1 year of age since it may give rise to ence-
tional health administration as notified to phalitis in the very young. Sensitivity to
WHO [5). In practice all countries now ac- eggs and egg products is also a contra-indi-
4.5 Infectious Diseases - Vaccination and Passive Immunization 295
cation. This fact must officially be stated in general reaction after previous (subcutane-
the International Certificate of Vaccina- ous) vaccination as an indieation to give
tion. If the contra-indieations are observed, the vaccine only intradermally. After vacci-
reactions are extremely rare (occasionally a nation one does indeed observe, occasion-
mild local reaction or a slight malaise oc- ally, local tendemess and redness at the in-
curs on about the 7th day after immuniza- jection site. Fever, headache, general mal-
tion). The International Certificate is valid aise and even diarrhoea may occur. The
from 10 days after primary vaccination but vaccination offers some protection over a
immediately in the case of revaccination. 6 month period and reinforcing infections
Certificates are required for travel to or will be necessary every 6 months in coun-
through the endemic areas and for Asia tries where a valid certificate is required.
and the Far East if the traveller enters from
an endemie area. 4.5.2.4 Typhoid Vaccination
Because ships may enter ports in countries
4.5.2.3 Vaccination Against Cholera where the general standard of sanitation is
It is now generally agreed that the require- unsatisfactory, many shipping companies
ment of a cholera vaccination certificate provide routine vaccination against ty-
will not prevent the introduction of the dis- phoid fever. Vaccination is recommended
ease into any country [5]. Since immuniza- for se amen travelling to areas outside
tion against cholera is ofvery limited value, Northern Europe and North America. The
a change was made in 1973 in the Interna- vaccine consists of killed, whole cells of
tional Health Regulations: it was agreed Salmonella typhi, preserved with phenol or
that cholera vaccination was no longer offi- acetone. It usually contains 1 x 109 killed
cially required for most countries, no mat- organisms. Two doses of 0.5 or 1 ml (de-
ter where the traveller came from. This is pending on the type of vaccine used) are
the reason why many countries (including given with a 4-week interval. A single dose
some located in endemic areas) no longer will give some protection. Some authors
require a valid certificate of vaccination prefer two injections of 0.2 ml intradermal-
against cholera. On the other hand some ly with a 4-week interval (Woodruff and
countries do still require valid vaccination Bell [20]). Reinforcing injections are desir-
certificates from seamen. able after 3 years. Vaccination protects
The whole-cell cholera vaccine consists 70%-90% of individuals against water-
of heat killed, phenol- or acetone-pre- borne infections (i. e. small infecting inocu-
served, serotypes of Vibrio cholerae of the la). Local and general reactions may occur
classic Ogawa and Inaba strains. The vac- after typhoid vaccination, especially when
cine should contain 4 x 109 organisms of it is given in combination with paratyphoid
each serotype per millilitre [13; 14]. A and B vaccine and cholera vaccine. Rare
The usual dose is 1 ml subcutaneously or complications of the neurological cardio-
0.2 ml intradermally, followed by a second vascular and renal systems have been ob-
dose 1-4 weeks later. Most countries ac- served. Contra-indications are poor gener-
cept a vaccination certificate as "valid" al health, acute infections and chronic
from 6 days after the first injection of vac- illness. If vaccination is nevertheless judg-
cine. Many countries require only one in- ed necessary in these patients, monovalent
jection of cholera vaccine but some require typhoid vaccine, intradermally injected,
two. It is wise to check with the latest WHO may be considered, but a risk may arise as
Weekly Epidemiologieal Bulletin. There weil. In some countries only the monoval-
are only a few contra-indications to cholera ent vaccine is used and recommended be-
vaccination; bad general health is one and cause there is evidence that the paraty-
some authors also consider serious local or phoid A component is not very effective in
296 4 Preventive Medicine Aboard
TAB vaccine and the B fraction is usually Immunity after IPV is long lasting;
of too low antigenicity to offer worthwhile booster injections may be given after
protection against paratyphoid B infection. 5-10 years. There are no specific contra-in-
The importance of local immunity in the dications to IPV and postvaccinal reactions
gut in typhoid fever has stimulated re- are extremely rare. OPV should not be giv-
search for a live, attenuated, oral vaccine. A en to unhealthy adults nor to anyone with
promising attenuated strain is the gal mu- acute or intercurrent illness, especially
tant, Ty 21a, isolated and characterized by diarrhoea or other intestinal dysfunction.
Germanier and Furer [6]. After neutralizing
the gastric acidity with sodium bicarbonate 4.5.2.6 Other Vaccinations
a capsule containing 109 viable attenuated In many countries, BCG vaccination is giv-
live cells is taken orally. This is repeated on en in infancy or at school-leaving age. It is
days 3 and 5. Except for slight gastro-intes- not necessary to revaccinate against tuber-
tinal symptoms, no adverse reactions are culosis at the start of a maritime career.
seen. Vaccine organisms have been found Se amen from those countries in which
in stool cultures from only half of the vac- BCG vaccination is not performed on a
cinees, usually for 1 day. Controlled studies routine basis do not need to be immunized
have established the efficacy of this type of against tuberculosis, but should be ex-
vaccine (Wahdan et al. [19]). Oral immuni- amined if they have been exposed to a
zation for typhoid fever is probably the known, smear-positive case of pulmonary
most promising and optimal form of vacci- tuberculosis and should have a yearly chest
nation; the vaccine does not give adverse X-ray. Immunization against diphtheria
reactions, produces local intestinal immu- and tetanus - also provided in many coun-
nity and is protective even in the face of tries in infancy and at school age - does not
high inocula (Levine and Hornick [10]). need to be given routinely to seamen (at the
most in combination with IPV). Influenza
4.5.2.5 Vaccination Against Poliomyelitis vaccine may be given to high-risk person-
nel (e.g. those suffering from chronic pul-
Routine immunization against polio is ad- monary conditions) or for economic rea-
vised for all non-immune seamen travelling sons (uninterrupted work routine on board
to areas outside Europe and North Ameri- seagoing vessels). From 1982 onwards, an
ca. Many seamen have been immunized inactivated vaccine against hepatitis B will
against polio in infancy or at school age, be available in many countries. This very
predominantly with live oral poliovirus expensive vaccine should at this moment,
vaccine (OPV). One booster dose with OPV not be given routinely to merchant seamen
or IPV (inactivated polio vaccine) is ad- because the risk of acquiring this disease is
vised at the start of a career at sea. Adults relatively low. Pre-exposure vaccination
not previously vaccinated are preferably against rabies should be considered only
vaccinated with inactivated poliovirus vac- under very special circumstances (e. g. for
cine (IPV). OPV mayaiso be used but car- those in charge of the care of exotic ani-
ries a slight risk of vaccine-associated par- mals being transported over sea).
alytic poliomyelitis. IPV is given in three
doses; two with a 1-month interval be- 4.5.2.7 Passive Immunization
tween them and a third dose 6 months later. with Normal Immunoglobulin
IPV can be given as plain polio vaccine or Routine administration of normal immu-
in combination with diphtheria and tetanus no globulin for the prevention of a clinical
immunization. As plain vaccine it is admin- attack of hepatitis Ais unrealistic; it should
istered subcutaneously and as combination only be given to close contacts of an actual
vaccine (DTP), intramuscularly. case of hepatitis A on board. Normal im-
4.5 Infectious Diseases - Vaccination and Passive Immunization 297
munoglobulin should be given as early as phoid vaccine. 1. infect. Dis. 131, 553-558
possible after exposure, but it is still effec- (1975).
7. International Health Regulation 1969. 2nd anno
tive if given as late as 14 days after expo-
edn. Geneva: WHO 1974.
sure. The dose is 0.02 ml/kg body weight, 8. Jaarverslag 1945-1980. Ed.: Gemeentelijke
intramuscularly. Geneeskundige en Gezondheidsdienst. Rotter-
dam: Gemeentedrukkerij 1946-1981.
4.5.2.8 Passive Immunization 9. Knight, Y.: Tuberculosis afloat. 1. Amer. med.
with Specific Immunoglobulins Ass. 203, 154-155 (1968).
10. Levine, M.M. and R.B.Hornick: Immunology
The indications for the use of specific im- of enteric pathogens. In: Comprehensive Im-
munoglobulins on board are very limited munology. Vo1.8, part 1. Eds.: R.A.Good and
indeed. In exceptional circumstances its S. B. Day. New York: Plenum Med. Books 1981.
p.249
use (ashore) can be considered (human an-
11. Merson, M. H., 1. M. Hughes, B. T. Wood et al.:
tirabies immunoglobulin together with ra- Gastrointestinal illness on passenger cruise
bies vaccination after exposure to a rabid ships. J. Amer. med. Ass. 231,7,723-727 (1975).
animal, human antihepatitis B immuno- 12. Merson, M. H., J. H. Tenney, 1. D. Meyers et al.:
globulin after exposure to HBV-positive Shigellosis at sea: an outbreak aboard a pas-
senger cruise ship. Amer. J. Epidem. 101, 2,
blood, human antitetanus immunoglobulin 165-175 (1975).
after wounds or bums in those who have 13. Requirements for cholera vaccine. (Require-
not been actively immunized). From this ments for biological substances No.4). Revised
summing up it is clear that, in general, the 1968. In: WHO expert committee on biological
standardization. Twenty-first report. Annex 1.
indications for the use of specific immu-
Geneva: WHO 1969. pp. 27-44. (WHO Techni-
noglobulins are the same for seamen as for cal Report Series No.413).
people living ashore. 14. Requirements far cholera vaccine. (Require-
ments for biological substances No.4). In:
WHO expert committee on biological standard-
References ization. Twenty-fifth report. Annex 2. Geneva:
WHO 1973. pp. 18-21. (Technical Report Series
1. Annual reports of the medical officer of health No. 530).
for the Port and City of London. London: 15. Resolution WHA 33.3 In: WHO Handbook of
Corp. of London Port Health Authority resolutions and decisions. Geneva: WHO 1980.
1950-1980. 16. Schultz, M. G., S. N. Cohen, W Greifinger et al.:
2. Bruce-Chwatt, L. 1.: Essential malariology. Lon- An outbreak of malaria on shipboard. Amer. 1.
don: Heinemann Medical Books 1980. trop. Med. Hyg. 16,5,576-579 (1967).
3. Control of communicable diseases in man. Ed.: 17. Survey of the incidence of gastro-intestinal ill-
A. S. Benenson. Official report of the Amer. ness in cruise ship passengers. Morb. Mort.
Publ. Health Ass. Washington 1980. p.31. Wkly Rep. 23,65-66 (1974).
4. Davies, J.W, K.C.Cox, WR.Simon et al.: Ty- 18. Travel information manual. A joint publication
phoid at sea: an epidemie aboard an ocean lin- of fourteen IATA Airlines. Amsterdam, May
er. Canad. med. Ass. J. 1061,877-883 (1972). 1982. p.12.
5. Functioning of the international health regula- 19. Wahdan, M.H., C.Serie, y'Cerisier et al.: A
tions for the period 1 January to 31 December controlled field trial of live salmonella typhi Ty
1979. Wkly. epidem. Rec. 55, 49, 377-384 21a oral vaccine against typhoid: three-year re-
(1980). sults. J. infect. Dis. 145,292-295 (1982).
6. Germanier, R. and E. Furer: Isolation and char- 20. Woodruff, A. Wand S. Bell: A synopsis of in-
acterization of Gal E mutant Ty 21a of salmo- fectious and tropical diseases. 2nd edn. Bristol:
nella typhi; a candidate strain for a live, oral ty- Wright 1978. p.18.
4.6 DDD - Disinfection, Disinfestation and Deratting
ABackhaus
must be cleaned and in many cases disin- is caused by fungi. Mycosis (athlete's foot)
fected. This is generally done ashore. If it is the frequent result. Construction of such
has to be done on the ship, the cleaning facilities has to avoid places where fungi
must be effective, for dust and other resi- can grow, but even the best floor and wall
due of the previous cargo will not only en- surfaces will not prevent growth of certain
ter the interior of the container but also be forms. Investigations on ships, often done
found in the ventilation ducts between the by the Port Health Authority of Hamburg,
walls of the container if a wall is damaged. proved frequent contamination. The situa-
The galley of the ship has typical prob- tion in vessels is a special one, for tropical
lems with the source of the food supply or subtropical climates are advantageous
(Terbeck [39]). If all food is supplied from for the multiplication of fungi, which are
the ho me port, the difficulty of storage brought on board the ship by crew mem-
grows with the length of the voyage. If bers and passengers. Disinfection with fun-
fresh food is bought in foreign ports, it gicidal chemicals should be done regularly,
might carry the danger of contaminating ideally at least once a week; it is even more
the galley. Investigations in galleys and efficient to add fungicidal chemicals to the
store rooms have demonstrated by bacteri- cleaning water every day. As fungi are gen-
ological examination that the number of erally not visible, the person responsible
micro-organisms per cm2 was significantly for the sanitary facilities may not believe
higher after obtaining stores in foreign that the clean tiled floor is contaminated.
ports. Disinfection once a week with qua- The possibility, even on board ship, of
temary ammonium compounds effectively demonstrating with culture plates must
reduced the number of bacteria. Regular be used. By such a demonstration the
disinfection of galleys after cleaning is of- personnel will be made aware of the
ten done in port. The possibility of contam- danger and can be motivated to disinfect
ination is more probable at sea than in port, regularly.
but to date disinfection at sea is an excep- The swimming pool and the sauna are
tion, not the rule. Diarrhoea among crew generally contaminated by many bacteria,
members or passengers is considered inevi- including Escherichia coli in high number.
table; it is nevertheless very necessary to The water is not changed continuously and
disinfect the galley, pantry and provision the empty pool is rarely disinfected. One
store room. Diarrhoea depends to some ex- must be aware of the danger, in spite of the
tent on the number of bacteria to which fact that so far no proved infections have
one is exposed, and disinfection can reduce been reported.
the number drastically, even if it is far from Ice cubes are sometimes contaminated,
sterilisation (Graham-Rack and Binsted even though they have been made of pota-
[19]). ble water. The method of storage is the
The provision store may be contami- usual source of contamination by patho-
nated by a variety of micro-organisms, genic micro-organisms; ice machines are
brought on board with the provisions. The seldom, if ever, cleaned and very rarely dis-
construction of the storage room should infected. The scoop for taking the cubes
avoid pI aces which are difficult to clean. out ofthe machine is seldom stored in a hy-
Disinfection cannot be effective without gienic way. In many pI aces the ice cubes
cleaning. The micro-organisms hide in dust are simply removed with the hand; conse-
and dirty pI aces and are sheltered by dirt quently the remaining ice cubes are con-
from the disinfectant. Sanitary installations taminated and when used infect the water
(shower, lavatory, swimming pool, sauna) or other beverage and the ice tools (Back-
may be contaminated by many micro-or- haus [8]). Therefore, disinfection of ice ma-
ganisms, but the prevalent contamination chines and ice scoops is necessary. The
4.6 DDD - Disinfection, Disinfestation and Deratting 301
danger can be reduced if Ag- is added to sengers and crew. They lay their eggs in
the water from which the ice is made. cargo, food and on people (Bull [13]). They
Fruits and vegetables, especially salad, multiply very quickly: a pair of cock-
that are bought abroad mayaiso be con- roaches brought on board at the beginning
taminated by micro-organisms, worms and of a voyage can develop into an army by
other parasites. Disinfeetion of uncooked the time the port of destination is reached.
foods, such as salads, is difficult, and the The fight never ends, and negligence can
smell of disinfeetant chemicals is unpleas- be fatal to the crew and lead to destruetion
ant. Vinegar has proved to be an effeetive of the cargo. Even inseets that do not trans-
disinfectant for those fresh vegetables and it disease can make life miserable for hu-
fruits that are consumed without being man beings, if only by depriving them of
heated. Soaking in 5% vinegar for 5 min sleep.
kills most of the pathogenic bacteria such In the Guide to Ship Sanitation, Lamou-
as E. eoli and Salmonella. Vinegar does not reux [23 a] gives information on inseet (ver-
spoil the taste and has been in use for the min) control.
preparation of salad for thousands of years
(Backhaus and Wolter [5]). 4.6.2.1 Transmission of Disease
Far more inseets transmit disease than was
4.6.1.3 Conclusion previously thought. Even those that do not
Crews are - if at all - only slightly trained injeet baeteria or poison through the skin
in disinfection, and are not aware of the by biting (as with malaria, yellow fever or
danger of contamination by micro-organ- the plague) can carry germs, and if they are
isms. They should use disinfeetants, and killed and crushed against the human body
must be thoroughly taught that disinfeetion the germs can enter the body through small
without cleaning beforehand is impossible cuts or wounds, as happens with typhus.
and that no disinfeetant kills micro-organ- The more known about the way of life and
isms instantaneously: the necessary time is habits of these pests, the more can effeetive
indicated on the package of every disinfec- methods be developed to fight them.
tant, and this information must be read and
followed. Every effort should be made to Yellow Fever
demonstrate contamination with bacteria The eradication of Aedes aegypti is the first
and fungi (Pöhn [32]). Dried baeteriologi- and most effeetive step in the prevention of
cal culture media have been developed, yellow fever. The mosquito was formerly
which are activated upon use. Such a dem- found on many ships and was often re-
onstration can encourage interest in disin- sponsible for the death of an entire crew.
fection (Backhaus [3]). There are currently no reports on infesta-
tion; nevertheless, in some ports the health
4.6.2 Disinfestation authorities investigate for infestation not
only by rats but also by Aedes aegypti. The
Most inseets on board ships are pests mosquitoes prefer to stay in the area of the
which can transmit diseases such as malar- deck, but may be found in the outer rooms
ia and yellow fever, spoil food and cargo, as weil, and this is where disinfestation
and even destroy the ship itself. They do must first be done. If the ship is destined
damage to wood and may damage the insu- for a country or port which is known to be
lation of eleetric installations, plastic mate- infested, pesticides with a long-Iasting ef-
rial and textiles. feet should be used beforehand as a pre-
Inseets crawl or fly aboard ship or are ventive measure.
brought by the wind. They are brought with
cargo, or in the clothing and hair of pas-
302 4 Preventive Medicine Aboard
eggs are disseminated all over the world in young emerge several weeks to a year later,
ships, planes, automobiles and on people. and if there is a long-Iasting effect, and if
The oothecae are more resistant than the the pesticide has not been removed in
adults to pesticides, making cockroaches c1eaning, the newly developed inseets will
masters at survival (Plestina [31]; Ulewicz be killed on their search for food. Coopera-
et al. [42]). A ship is an ideal place for cock- tion between the DDD speeialist and the
roaches. Food is freely available; there is a ship's staff is essential to the success of a
cargo residue in the holds; and there is campaign against cockroaches (Penev [30]).
sewage and waste in many corners. Small
hiding places are open to them, such as 4.6.2.2 The Hold
tubes, chinks and slits. They can move free- Pests can spoil cargo in many ways. Flies
ly about a ship using the ducts for ventila- lay their eggs in fruit, which is then spoiled
tion and electrical connections. There is a by the maggots, and worms may eat the en-
great deal of moisture, and the temperature tire fruit. Grain may be infested with bee-
in the hiding places is ideal for breeding. tles; there are one or two at first, but when
Pestieides do not penetrate into the long the holds are opened at the port of destina-
conneeting duets, so that if adults are killed tion nearly every kernel has been ruined by
the newly hatched take their place. It is inseets and maggots.
possible to fight cockroaches, but a short
campaign has no positive effeet (Bakic [9]; 4.6.2.3 In-transit Fumigation
Cernjul [14]; Dimitrov and Penev [17]). It would seem reasonable to have cargo
Long-term fumigation is successful using disinfested ashore, before it is loaded onto
cyanide (3-5 days). It is necessary to take a ship. But since agents and companies do
periodic sampies and sometimes to add not always do this, in-transit fumigation,
more of the fumigant to keep the concen- espeeially of grain, is becoming more and
tration effeetive. Other pestieides that can more common, and this is done in the
be used are pyrethrum (natural or chemi- holds of the ship (Leesch et al. [25]); Red-
cally synthesised and with a long-Iasting ef- linger et al. [33]). The only fumigant in use
feet), carbamates and chlorinated insecti- today is phostoxine. To date more than
eides. These must have a flushing effect, or 5000 cargoes have been fumigated in tran-
a chemical with such an effect must be sit; there were several fatal aceidents at the
added. beginning, but the technique is now said to
Spray, liquid or dust will never reach the be foolproof, and no mishaps have been re-
farthest places; the cockroaches must be ported recently.
forced to come out. Pyrethrum was the first Nevertheless, there are some countries
natural inseetieide that had a flushing ef- and private companies which have strictly
fect, but many others have since been syn- forbidden in-transit fumigation. In port the
thesised. After being flushed out, the adults crew should leave the vessel while it is be-
are killed when they come into contaet with ing disinfected. Only trained personnel re-
the effeetive concentration of pestieide. But main on board and they take all necessary
cockroaches so on 1earn to avoid pI aces preventive steps. On the open sea, however,
which have been treated, and every spot no one can leave the ship. The captain must
must therefore be covered systematically; have full knowledge of the facts about
the smallest pathway should not be free of phostoxine (PH 3) at his disposal.
the chemical. On the positive side, PH3 is applied in a
The application of pestieides must be re- safe way; the gas forms only slowly after
newed every 2-4 weeks for many months the fumigant has been sprayed. It can be
to ensure success, because the oothecae are smelled even at very low concentrations,
not harmed by the initial treatment. The below the danger level, and there is enough
304 4 Preventive Medicine Aboard
time for workers to evacuate an area. Tech- board may not notiee the penetration ofthe
nical instruments are available for ambient fumigant into his accommodation (Back-
air monitoring. Fumigant residue is harm- haus [7]; Brodniewicz [12]). Technical sys-
less if it is collected at the port of destina- tems must be used to detect the fumigant in
tion by trained personnel. PH 3 is very suc- time, but they may be used without suffi-
cessful in combatting beetles and other cient precaution or they may fail because
pests if applied over a sufficiently long pe- of a technieal defect. The cargo itself may
riod of time, which is normally guaranteed be dangerous, however, after fumigation
by the length of the voyage. and ventilation. Cargo such as expellers
On the negative side, although PH 3 has a that are in bags may be fumigated and ven-
penetrating odour, there have been cases tilated without difficulties. But the same
where it was ignored. There is no simple cargo in bulk retains the toxic fumigant far
way to distinguish between a harmless con- longer. The sampies of air in holds and in
centration and one that is toxic. Poisoning sleeping quarters may seem to be free of
bya fatal dose is not realised immediately; toxic substances, but with a change in tem-
symptoms appear after 12-48 h, but no perature or atmospheric pressure, toxie
medical help is available in most cases, and substances can penetrate from the holds to
even then it would be too late and have no the accommodation (Backhaus [6]; [23]).
effect. Women and children are known to The concentration of the fumigant must be
be more susceptible than men to PH 3 poi- checked continually. Methylbromide will
soning. The company, the captain and the adhere to the cargo if there is albumin and
countries involved must decide, on the ba- oil in the product, e. g. in expellers. Only
sis of these facts, whether to take the risk of when the cargo is unloaded and brought to
fumigating in transit. a storehouse ashore or to another ship, is
There are other fumigants but the situa- the ventilation ideal.
tion does not differ. Methylbromide is ef- Very often there is no poisoning, but fu-
fective but it has no odour. The time be- migation personnel and the crew can get
tween poisoning and the first symptoms is careless. Fatal accidents have proven that
the same as, or even longer than, that for we should be aware of the high risk, both at
PH3• Cyanide is effective but nearly impos- the time of and after fumigation of cargo.
sible to use in the hold in transit. Its effect The literature quoted is only a small ex am-
on insects is not as strong, and higher con- pIe of reports of poisoning.
centrations would be required. The fact re-
mains that realistic knowledge of the dan- 4.6.2.5 Containers
ger involved may reduce the risk of fatal The cargo in a container may be infested in
accidents. the same way as cargo in the holds of a
ship; containers do not prevent infestation
4.6.2.4 Fumigation of Holds in Port by pests. As the container is thought to be
Fumigation is done in many thousands of water- and gasproof, it is taken to be the
ships a year to kill pests such as the copra best pi ace to fumigate. Containers can be
beetle, with methylbromide and phostox- collected in special places for the process,
ine as the main agents. The lethai effect de- and ventilation seems to be no problem.
pends on time, temperature, concentration This may be true for the new types of con-
and penetration of the fumigant. tainers, but older ones are not gasproof
There are countries that demand fumiga- and, with only one dOOf, are poorly or not
tion, even if there is no proof of infestation. at all ventilated.
To fumigate while the crew is on board is One container, fumigated with toxic gas
dangerous. Fatal accidents have occurred on shore, then taken to the ship after being
on all five continents. A man sleeping on inadequately ventilated, may be harmless,
4.6 DDD - Disinfection, Disinfestation and Deratting 305
but if 25% or more of the cargo on a con- rats can transmit many different diseases,
tainer vessel contains residual fumigant the they must be fought on board and in port.
crew members may experience toxic ef- In some countries international and na-
fects. To avoid this, containers must be la- tional regulations contain the word "ro-
belled with the name of the fumigant, the dents", in others the word "rats". There are
time of fumigation, and the type and miee on board ships as weil. They can also
amount of ventilation. The officer in trans mit diseases and are more resistant to
charge and the captain must be informed coumarin, but their number is smaller. It is
of the number of fumigated containers and reasonable to include mice in the pro-
must receive specific data on the fumigant gramme of eradication. Knowledge of the
used, the symptoms of toxicity and appro- species is important to effeetive killing.
priate first-aid measures. Rattus rattus and Rattus norvegicus behave
Fumigated containers must be added to differently. A method of poisoning whieh is
the list of dangerous cargo. They are disin- effeetive with one can be useless with the
fested with pesticides which are applied to other. The well-adapted strategy is as im-
the walls, the openings and the ventilation portant as the poison itself. A specialist is
system. After disinfestation has been done needed to investigate and to find the effec-
repeatedly as a preventive measure, the tive method of killing a partieular species,
container surface becomes not only fatal to but some general rules and experiences can
insects, but also toxie to men. All those be reported here (Snitko [34]).
who have to work with containers must be
thoroughly informed. 4.6.3.1 Prevention of Rats
Ratproof construetion of ships has done
4.6.2.6 Conclusion more towards eradieating rats than traps
It is necessary to be aware of the danger and poison. Detailed information on the
both of inseets and of pesticides and fumi- ratproofing of ships is given in the Hand-
gants. Through knowledge, vigilance and book on Sanitation of Vessel Construction
patience it is possible to fight pests success- [21 a], in a special manual [32a] and by
fully, and at the same time prevent toxie ef- Lamoureux [23 a]. The smaller the area of
feets on human beings from fumigants and the ship in which rats can live and which
pesticides (Plestina [31]; Vukovic and Svetli- they cannot leave, the more difficult it is for
eie [44]). them, and the better the chances are of
hunting them. If rats can reach every part
4.6.3 Deratting ofthe ship, they can escape all danger: they
will find sufficient food and water and
International health regulations [22 b] order have time and space to multiply. But rat-
the continuous fight against rodents in proof construetion has, so to speak, a psy-
ports, on board ships and planes and in chologieal effeet on rats. They do not like
heavily populated areas. As long as men to be in places where they cannot find ways
cross the sea by ship, rodents will try to go out. They have their own security system.
with them. Rats are curious; they adapt to They like small tunnels and many hiding
every climate and to nearly all methods places and avoid large open areas. They
devised for killing them. Rats transmit may not choose a ship without possibilities
plague, murine typhus, brucellosis and to hide and to escape. The communication
Weil's disease, via insects they carry and in system of rats is one of the best in the
their urine and faeces. It is hoped that world. Messages ab out dangerous food or
plague has been eradicated, but other dis- a dangerous place are sent from group to
eases are always being discovered - haem- group. It is impossible to construet a ship
orrhagic fever will not be the last - and as without any hiding pi aces for rats. They do
306 4 Preventive Medicine Aboard
not like the smell of gasoline, and they walls by the rat's tail. If there is even the
leave a ship in the dockyard if there is too suspicion of rat infestation, steps to derat
much noise. But they adapt themselves, should be taken immediately, even though
even to refrigeration holds, by growing a the process of eradication may be expen-
thick coat, and have been found in the sive.
modem system of transportation, in the
container. However, it is always possible to 4.6.3.3 Control of Rats
collect garbage, to clean the deck and the Detailed information on rodent control is
holds and to take away any source of food given by Lamoureux [23 a] and in a special
from the kitchen or from the cargo. To keep chapter of the Handbook on Sanitation oI
a pi ace clean is the fundamental rule of hy- Vessels in Operation [21 b].
giene in general, but it is fundamental, too, If there are few rodents, traps are help-
to the prevention of rat infestation. Nearly ful, but different types are required for dif-
every sailor and every captain knows in ferent species. Traps will reduce the num-
which ports rats thrive today. Unfortunate- ber of rats but will not eradicate them
ly, it is nearly impossible to prevent the rats (Lebedev et al. [24]); a rat dying of poison
from coming on board (Bull [13]). They serves as a warning of danger to other rats,
may gain entry by crawling up the mooring which will avoid the place and the poison.
ropes and may enter via gangways. Their communication system is mysterious,
The best means of controlling rats is to but highly efficient. Consequently, any poi-
kill them as early as possible. A few may be son used must kill within a short time, as
caught in traps or killed by poison before does sodium fluoroacetate (1080) (Corn-
they have a chance to multiply if immedi- weIl [15]; [16]; [35]; [36]; [38]), or it must kill
ate action is taken. If they have a chance to all the rats at once, as do gases such as cya-
multiply in the ship's holds and accommo- nide. A third possibility is a poison which
dation quarters it is much more difficult to kills a long time after it is consumed, pre-
kill them. venting the rats from establishing a connec-
tion between the food and death. Couma-
4.6.3.2 Searching for Rats rin, which prolongs the coagulation time, is
Rodents leave tracks and faeces. Without a an example of this type. Any poison used
doubt they mark their path by urine as weil, must be safe to the people on board the
which is of importance regarding the con- ship; safety should be the foremost con-
tamination of food by germs; but urine is cern. Every poison that is administered to
visible only with the help of a speciallamp eradicate rats is dangerous to man; the
which is not generally in use. quantity of coumarin or one of its deriva-
Faeces are the clearest evidence of the tives which is lethai to rats is not lethai to
presence of rodents, and provide more in- human beings. Nevertheless, even couma-
formation than do tracks left by feet or rin must be put in a pI ace where no other
tails. An examination ofthe faeces can help small animals or children can consume it.
to determine the species. With experience The compound 1080 is fatal in small
one can say with great accuracy whether quantities to rats, though the lethai dose for
the animal is a rat or a mouse, young or man is perhaps 10 times the lethai dose for
old, and when the faeces were excreted. rats. However, if the intention is to kill
From the distribution of the faeces one can 50-100 rats, 1080 must be prepared in a
tell the approximate nu mb er of rodents quantity which can kill more than one man.
and which species one is dealing with. Ro- The use of 1080 is permitted in only a few
dents also leave tracks in dust or in poison countries und er strict rules and effective
which has been distributed on the ship. supervision ([1]; Swann [37]). Cyanide can
Traces of coloured poison may be left on be administered only by trained personnel.
4.6 DDD - Disinfection, Disinfestation and Deratting 307
ary objects and their repelling]. In: Pomorska 26. Liste der vom Bundesgesundheitsamt geprüften
medicina (Naucne rasprave). Belgrad: Izdanje und anerkannten Desinfektionsmittel und Ver-
Momarickog glasnika 1975. (Pomorska biblio- fahren. 7th ed. Bundesgesundhbl. 21, 16, 255-
teka. Sveska 26). 261 (1978).
15. Comwell, P.B.: Pest control in buildings. A 27. Longn!e, K.: Quantity food sanitation.
guide to the meaning ofterms. London: Hutch- New York: Wiley Interscience 1980.
inson 1973. 28. Munro, J. W: Pests ofstored products. London:
16. Deratting procedures. In: Foreign quarantine Hutchinson 1966.
manual of operations. Washington 26 August 29. Novakovic, T. and J.Bakic: Mogucnost pri-
1960. mene i efikasnost insekticidnih lakova u dezin-
17. Dimitrov, M.Iv. and IV.Penev: Otnosno nyakoi sekciji brodova Ratne momarice. [Possibilities
savremenni metodi sredstva za borba s khlebar- of application and efficacy of insecticidal lac-
kite v korabite. [Modem methods and means in quers in disinfection of the navy ships]. Vojno-
cockroach control on board ships]. Transp. sanit. Pregl. 37, 5,392-397 (1980).
med. Westi 22, 1,6-8 (1977). 30. Penev, Iv.: Prouchvaniya varkhu nyakoi metodi
18. Eggensperger, H.: Desinfektionswirkstoffe und i sredstva za borba sas sinantropnite khlebarki.
ihre Wirkungsmechanismen. Dtsch. Apoth.-Ztg [Studies on certain methods and means in syn-
113,21,785-791 (1973). antropic cockroaches campaign]. In: Nauchni
19. Graham-Rack, B. and R.Binsted: Hygiene in trudove po transportna meditsina. Vo1.5. Ed.:
food. Manufacturing and handling. London: Ministerstvo na transporta. Transporten medit-
Food Trade Press 1964. sinski institut. Sofia: Meditsina i fiskultura
20. Günther, M.: Salmonellose und ihre Bekämp- 1979. pp. 34-46.
fung durch personal- und betriebshygienische 31. Plestina, R.: Toksikologija nekih antikolinester-
Maßnahmen. Dtsch. Z. Lebensmitteltechnol. aza sto se upotrebljavaju u dezinsekciji. [Toxi-
26,8/9 (1975). cology of some insecticides used in desinsec-
21. Hahn, W: Desinfektionsmittel - Wirkungs- tion]. In: Pomorska medicina (Naucne ras-
weise, Wirkungsspektrum und toxikologische prave) Belgrad: Izdanje Momarickog glasnika
Aspekte. Hyg. Med. 10 (1981). 1975. (Pomorska biblioteka. Sveska 26).
21 a. Handbook on sanitation of vessel construc- 32. Pöhn, H.-Ph.: Exotische Krankheiten? Legio-
tion. Standards of sanitation and ratproofing nellose. Bundesgesundhbl. 22, 25, 457-461
for the construction of vessels. Ed.: U.S. De- (1979).
partment of Health, Education, and Welfare. 32 a. Rat proofing of ships. Ed.: V. S. Department
Public Health Service. Washington: V. S. Gov- of Health, Education, and Welfare. Public
emment Printing Office 1965. (Public Health Health Service. New York: Stevens & Wood
Service Publication No. 393). 1959.
21 b. Handbook on sanitation of vessels in opera- 33. Redlinger, L. M., J. M. Zettler, J. G. Leesch et al.:
tion. Sanitation features and facilities on vessels In-transit shipboard fumigation of wheat. J.
in operation. Ed.: U. S. Department of Health, econ. Entomol. 72, 4, 642-647 (1979).
Education, and Welfare. Public Health Service. 34. Snitko, V.M.: Gazovaya deratizatsiya i dezin-
Washington: V.S. Govemment Printing Office sektsiya na morskom flote. [Deratisation and
1963. (Public Health Service Publication desinsection by gas in seafaring]. Voen.-med.
No. 68). Zh. 2, 51-53 (1979).
22. Hickin, N.E.: Household insect pests. London: 35.Sodium fluoroacetate. In: Operational memo-
Hutchinson 1964. randa on economic poisons. Savannah: Com-
22a. Huismann, J.: Personal communication 1978. municable Disease Center 1956.
22b. International health regulations (1969). 3rd 36. Sodium fluoroacetate FCHzCOO Na AFL
annotated edn. Geneva: WHO 1983. p 26-29. 1080. London: Associated Fumigators Limited
23. Jahresberichte des hafen- und flughafenärzt- 37. Swann, WG.: Vse of"1080" in the PortofLon-
lichen Dienstes. Hamburg 1973/74, 1975, don. Ed.: The Medical Officer of Health, Port
1976/77, 1978/79. and City of London. London 1970.
23 a. Lamoureux, V. B.: Guide to ship sanitation. 38. Technical sodium monofluoroacetate. In: Spec-
Geneva: WHO 1967. ifications for Pesticides. 2nd ed. Geneva: WHO
24. Lebedev, G.I., N. N. Rutkevich and V. A. Sed- 1961.
nev: Deratizatsiya fentolatsinovoy pastoy na 39. Terbeck, G.: Hygieneanforderungen im
korablyakh i beregovykh obyektakh. [Deratisa- Küchenbereich zur Verhütung übertragbarer
tion by phenoated paste onboard and ashore]. Krankheiten. Bundesgesundhbl. 20, 25, 373-
Voen.-med. Zh. 7, 64-65 (1981). 378 (1977).
25. Leesch, J.G., L.M.Redlinger, H.B.GiIlenwater 40. Tomaiic, D., I. Vodopija and M. Kozar: Dezin-
et al.: An in-transit shipboard fumigation of fekcija brodskog tereta. [Desinfection of ship's
corno J. econ. Entomol. 71,6,928-935 (1978). cargo]. In: Pomorska medicina (Naucne ras-
4.6 DDD - Disinfection, Disinfestation and Deratting 309
Over the centuries, certain diseases have being dealt with at all. These 1951 Regula-
been responsible for pandemics which tions were amended over the years and
were sometimes so catastrophic that civili- consolidated as the International Health
sation itself was threatened. Diseases such Regulations in 1969 [1] which were, in turn,
as influenza, malaria and typhoid have all amended with effect from 1 January 1974
caused international disasters in the past and from 1 January 1982. It is this
but it was the "quarantinable" diseases amended form which is dealt with in this
which so terrorised nations that govern- chapter.
ments were eventually forced to come to- It is useful for doctors involved in nauti-
gether and agree measures to be taken cal medicine to know how the system
against them. This was neither a quick nor works, if only to know how much interna-
an easy process - between 1851 and 1897 tionally disseminated information is the
there were ten international sanitary con- considered opinion of the experts at Gen-
ferences but signed and ratified conven- eva and how much is merely what the in-
tions did not result until the last decade of fected country wants the rest of the world
the century. In the twentieth century, the to know.
first decade saw the establishment of the Many countries have their own national
Pan American Sanitary Organization (and regulations which, while they may be based
Bureau) and the Office International d'Hy- on the International Regulations, are likely
giene Publique. The latter was responsible to differ in detail from them. Therefore, it is
for worldwide international health matters always wise, when approaching a port in
until the World Health Organisation was an unfamiliar country, to spend a few mo-
set up in 1946. ments talking on the radio to the Port
The International Sanitary Regulations Health Authority. In this way, much time
were adopted by the Fourth World Health and, possibly, embarrassment may be
Assembly in 1951. They set out to establish saved. This radio consultation should take
essential measures to be adopted by mem- place some hours before the estimated time
ber countries in order to minimise interna- of arrival at the port, so allowing plenty of
tional spread of disease but they also laid time for any extra documentation or other
down maximum controls permitted to procedures that may be required.
those countries, so that disturbance of in- The Regulations are divided into parts
ternational trade would also be minimised. and the remainder of this chapter is given
The aim was to encourage countries to rely over to some attempt to select and summa-
on their own internal health services rather rise each part. No attempt will be made to
than extreme measures at their frontiers produce any legal interpretations and the
and ports. Primarily, the Regulations set up chapter has no force in any law system.
a uniform system for controlling the spread If more detailed or accurate information
of the quarantinable diseases, other infec- is needed, an approach should be made
tious diseases and other health matters not to the appropriate national health admin-
4.7 International Health Regulations 311
istration or to the World Health Organisa- and inspection of, the ship, scrutiny of vac-
tion. cination certificates and/or passports and
questioning oftravellers but includes phys-
ical examination only if the circumstances
4.7.1 Part I - Definitions
of the individual case justify it.
Most of these are self-explanatory, but
some might benefit from a little comment. 4.7.2 Part 11 - Notification and
The definition of "arrival" dodges the Epidemiological Information
real problem - it does not state which part
of a port is the point of arrival. Some coun- This deals with the means by which infor-
tries define it as the first crossing ofthe out- mation is fed in to WHO by individual
er edge of the port area, others as the act of countries and them disseminated by WHO
first mooring or anchoring within the port to all member states. It says that astate
area and yet others as the act of passing must inform WHO within 24 h of the first
some point arbitrarily designated as the suspected case and then confirm it (or
quarantine point. otherwise) at the earliest possible moment.
The definition of "container" is very spe- Details of the case or cases, source and
cific and refers only to the 20-ft equivalent type of disease, the area infected and pro-
units, not to vehicles, conventional cargo phylactic measures taken must be notified
packings, small parcels or boxes. by the state to WHO immediately they are
The "diseases subject to the Regula- available and updated thereafter, frequent-
tions" used to be referred to as "quarantin- ly and in detail. It is the responsibility of
able diseases". It is of interest that the 1851 the state to decide when an area becomes
International Sanitary Code (drafted at an free from infection, but the criteria for such
international conference but ratified by on- adecision are laid down. Astate must in-
ly three countries) dealt only with cholera, form WHO of the measures which it in-
plague and yellow fever. Then, over the tends to take against shipping coming from
years, louse-borne typhus, relapsing fever an infected area and it must also inform
and smallpox were added. Now, however, shipping companies of its vaccination re-
these three latter additions have been re- quirements.
moved and the definition covers only the For its part, WHO publishes a Weekly
original three diseases. Epidemiological Record and transmits dai-
"Free pratique" - that ancient phrase - ly epidemiological bulletins by radio as
is defined as permission for a ship to enter part of its duty to disseminate the informa-
a port, disembark and commence opera- tion received from individual countries.
tion. It is now so commonplace for a ship
not to be approached for health purposes 4.7.3 Part 111 - Health Organisation
until it is weIl inside the port that this defi-
nition becomes something of a nonsense. A This part lays down that every state must
much better definition would be "permis- set up an organisation to ensure that each
sion for a ship to go alongside, disembark port has a supply of drinking water and
and commence operation". food, an effective system for the removal of
The definition of "infected area" makes sewage and other wastes and a health orga-
it clear that the limits of the area are de- nisation to monitor these functions and to
fined by the government of the country deal with medical matters, especially infec-
concerned, not by any independent author- tious diseases. Deratting (and rat-proofing)
ity. is specifically mentioned as a function of
"Medical examination" of a ship is an the health organisation, as is the issue of
important definition. It includes a visit to, Deratting or Deratting Exemption Certifi-
312 4 Preventive Medicine Aboard
cates. WHO issues a list of ports worldwide tary guard and the ship must be permitted
which have been approved for these derat- to take on fuel, water and stores. However,
ting functions. if the ship is infected or suspected, its pas-
sage through a canal counts as arrival at a
4.7.4 Part IV - Health Measures port and it will have the full procedures ap-
and Procedure plied to it.
Wherever practicable, free pratique
The measures set out are the maximum should be granted by radio, before arrival,
permitted and must be started immediately, to a ship which represents no risk to the
carried out as rapidly as possible and ap- public health. However, the port health au-
plied to all to exactly the same degree. thority may retain the right to carry out
There must be as little disturbance as possi- medical examination of a ship or person on
ble to the person concerned and his health arrival, any further health procedures de-
must not be damaged - neither must his pending on the findings of that examina-
baggage or the ship and its cargo. Mter the tion. Destination addresses in writing may
procedures are completed, the traveller and be required from travellers. Any infected
the ship's master are entitled to a certificate person may be removed and isolated by the
setting out what has been done and why it health authority and must be so removed if
was necessary. A ship which is not infected the ship's master requires it. Any suspect
or suspected may not be refused free pra- person may be placed under surveillance
tique. A person under surveillance may not until the end of the appropriate incubation
be restricted in movement in any way but period.
he may be required to report regularly, es- Once these measures have been complet-
pecially if he is about to change his ad- ed, they should not be repeated at any sub-
dress. He may be subject to medical inves- sequent port unless there has been a further
tigation but not to rectal swabbing. He may incidence of disease or the measures have
even be allowed to continue his voyage, in- otherwise been shown to be ineffective. No
formation on his case being sent ahead to ship may, for health reasons, be prevented
his next port of call. from calling at a port. If, however, the port
The health authority must do all it can to lacks the facilities to deal with the health
ensure that a ship leaving port does not car- problem, the ship may be ordered to the
ry any infected or suspected people or any nearest port that does have them. Any ship
vectors ofthe diseases subject to these Reg- which will not submit to these measures
ulations. The authority may medically ex- may be required to leave port, being per-
amine any person before departure and, if mitted only to take on fuel, water and
the area is infected, may require vaccina- stores. It must not then call at any other
tion certificates to be held. port in that state.
A ship which is merely passing through a Cargo and goods may be dealt with un-
country's waters may not have any health der these Regulations only when coming
procedures applied to it. A healthy ship, from an infected area and when there is
passing through a country's canals or wa- reason to think that the goods may be con-
terways on its way to another country, may taminated with disease. Other than live ani-
not be subject to any procedures except mals, goods in transit may not be dealt with
medical examination (and the same applies at all if remaining on the ship. If goods
to the arrival at a port of any healthy ship have been disinfected, the port health au-
from which the passengers and crew do not thority must issue a certificate, giving de-
disembark). Even if there is a person from tails, to the interested parties, inc1uding
an infected area on board, procedures are the ship's master. Baggage belonging to a
limited to the placing on board of a sani- healthy traveller may be disinfected or dis-
4.7 International Health Regulations 313
the vaccine used must have been approved printed in English and French and com-
by WHO and the vaccination must be car- pleted in one ofthose languages. The Inter-
ried out at an approved centre. Every mem- national Certificate of Vaccination must be
ber of the crew of a ship trading into any signed by a medical practitioner in his own
port in an infected area must hold a valid hand or by another person authorised by
certificate of vaccination. the national health administration. Official
Every ship leaving a port where Aedes stamps are no substitute. If vaccination is
aegypti still exists, for an area where it has contra-indicated on medical grounds, the
been eradicated, must be kept free of it in vaccinator must so certify, with reasons,
all its stages. On arrival, a ship may be re- written in English or French "which health
garded as infected if there is a case of yel- authorities should take into account",
low fever on board or one has occurred on whatever that means!
the voyage. It may be regarded as suspect if No health document other than those set
it left an infected area less than 6 days be- out in these Regulations may be required in
fore arrival or, if arriving less than 30 days international traffic.
after leaving such an area, a vector of yel-
low fever is found on board. Any other ship 4.7.7 Part VII - Charges
must be regarded as healthy.
On arrival of an infected or suspected No charge may be made by a health au-
ship in an area where yellow fever vectors thority for any medicalor supplementary
are present, any passenger or crew member examination required to ascertain the
who disembarks without a valid certificate health of the person examined or for any
of vaccination may be isolated for 6 days vaccination (or its certification) of a person
from the date of last exposure. Further- on arrival. Any other charges for measures
more, any such ship (or any healthy ship under these Regulations must conform
from an infected area) may be inspected with anational tariff, notified to WHO,
and any yellow fever vectors destroyed, and must be moderate and not exceed the
and the ship may be required to keep at actual cost ofthe service provided. Further-
least 400 m from land until this is done. more, there must be the same charges for
When all this is completed, the ship must each person or shipping company.
be given free pratique.
4.7.8 Part VIII - Various Provisions
4.7.6 Part VI - Health Documents
Every ship leaving a port in an area where
Before arrival at the first port of call in any transmission of malaria or other mosquito-
country, a ship's master must ascertain the borne disease is occurring (of where insec-
state of health of all on board and, where ticide-resistant mosquito vectors or disease
the country requires it, must fill in and give are present or where a vector species is pre-
to the Port Health Authority a Maritime sent which has been eradicated in the desti-
Declaration of Health, countersigned by nation area) must be kept free from all
the ship's surgeon, if there is one. He must stages of the mosquito concerned. A foot-
also provide any other health information note draws attention to the need for nauti-
required by the Port Health Authority. cal medical officers to be trained in the di-
Deratting and Deratting Exemption Cer- agnosis and treatment of malaria and for
tificates, the Certificate of Vaccination all crews of ships in malarial areas to be
against Yellow Fever and the Maritime given "supervised suppressant treatment
Declaration of Health are reproduced in during a suitable period oftime".
the appendices to these Regulations and Any ship carrying migrants, nomads,
this format must be used. They must be seasonal workers or pilgrims (and the peo-
4.7 International Health Regulations 315
pIe concerned) may be subjected to addi- lations between WHO and the member
tional health measures as laid down by the states.
states concerned. The standard of hygiene
on such ships must not be inferior to that
laid down in Annex V of the Regulations. References
1. International health regulations (1969). 3rd an-
4.7.9 Part IX - Final Provisions notated ed. Geneva: WHO 1983.
The eight articles in this part deal only with
administrative provisions regulating the re-
5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
5.1 Health Standards - Fitness for Duty at Sea
E.N.Watson
The International Labour Organisation has That opinion may be correct but it requires
shown its concern for the health of sea- some qualification.
farers by adopting ILO Instruments at the The essence of Convention NO.73 is the
special maritime sessions of its confer- requirement that every seafarer must pos-
ences. The first of these Instruments, the sess a certificate attesting "that he is not
Medical Examination of Young Persons suffering from any disease likely to be ag-
(Sea) Convention NO.16 [3] was adopted at gravated by or to render hirn unfit for ser-
the 3rd ordinary session in 1921. Further vice at sea or likely to endanger the health
attention was given to the medical exami- of other persons on board". That advice,
nation of all seafarers at the 28th maritime while excellent as a general statement,
session in 1946 when the Medical Exami- leaves open the determination of the many
nation (Seafarers) Convention NO.73 [4], diseases which would preclude work at sea.
which laid down certain requirements It has rested with the competent authority
for these examinations and the related med- in each country to determine the crucial is-
ical certificates, was adopted. These two sue of specific health standards. In conse-
Instruments still represent the base from quence, differing sets of medical criteria
which all subsequent developments have have been evolved in the maritime coun-
evolved. tries and that position remains unchanged.
Unfortunately, Convention NO.73 had a The lack of international criteria had
mixed reception and only 29 countries had been recognised by the World Health As-
ratified it by 1982. There is hope, however, sembly in 1948, when the Joint ILO/WHO
that the Merchant Shipping (Minimum Committee on the Hygiene of Seafarers
Standards) Convention No. 147 of 1976 [5], was set up [7]. At its first session in Decem-
which requires only substantial equiva- ber, 1949 the Joint Committee selected for
lence with No.73, will bring about wider early study a number of subjects, including
implementation. Provision for the inspec- the standard of fitness for seafarers. This
tion of certificates by port state officials was considered at the conference organised
may add to the impetus. by the ~egional Office for Europe of the
The joint ILO/WHO Committee, writ- World Health Organisation in Marseilles
ing in 1961 [10], regretted that the ILO Con- (in 1959) [2]. The prophylactic value of
ventions and recommendations on seafar- the pre-employment medical examination
ers' health had either not been ratified by of seamen was generally acknowledged.
all nations or not been fully implemented. However, it was agreed that although it was
It was feIt that full implementation of Con- simple to set standards to exclude chronic
vention NO.73 by all seafaring countries somatic diseases, there remained many
would have considerably raised the general lesser medical conditions where it was ex-
health standard of seafarers and forestalled tremely difficult, or impossible, to make
many complaints, justified or otherwise, re- such precise recommendations. The need
garding unfit men being passed fit for sea. to resolve the difficulty was reiterated at
320 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
further ILO Maritime Meetings in 1967 [12] text of seafaring, can cause conflict with
and 1970 [8] but the matter has remained in medical colleagues who frequently have
abeyance. little understanding of the medical and ad-
The difficulties of achieving an interna- ministrative problems affecting seafarers.
tional consensus on health matters was At national level, in an attempt to over-
weIl illustrated by reaction to the ILO/IM- come these difficulties, the responsibility
CO/WHO International Medical Guide for supervising the health of seafarers is
for Ships [6] and the accompanying list of usually shared by government, seafarers'
approved essential drugs. Despite its repre- organisations and shipowners. Their tripar-
sentation of modern medical opinion over tite agreements are often issued in the form
the wide range of subjects at that time, na- of statutory regulations governing the var-
tional differences in medical practices and ious aspects of the medical examination to
treatment resulted in many countries pro- be carried out. The potentially hazardous
ducing their own guides. This position re- nature of seafaring is given much consider-
mains unchanged and WHO still admits ation in deciding the objectives, content
that the preparation of a drug list [13] of and method of the medical examination,
uniform, general applicability and accept- together with detailed advice on diseases
ability is not possible. Each country is left considered to be incompatible with seafar-
with the direct responsibility of evaluating ing. In addition to the inherent dangers of
and adopting drugs according to its own navigating in any kind of climate, weather
policy in the field of health. This fact has and sea conditions, a ship has much mov-
considerable bearing when setting national ing machinery in the engine-room, on deck
medical standards and it militates against and elsewhere. It is not only a place of
achieving international agreement. work requiring attention throughout the
It might appear extraordinary that after day and night, but also a temporary home
so many years it has not been possible to in which the crew must eat, sleep and find
produce, and to agree, a set of international recreation. The crew itself is a closed com-
medical standards. However, those who munity divided by traditional hierarchy
have been involved in the complicated is- into the three departments, deck, engine-
sues of setting national standards would room and catering, which are supervised
not share that view. Even where it is pos si- by the shipmaster and his officers. These
ble to get agreement between the doctors officers are responsible for carrying out
involved in the task, their decisions may statutory regulations to ensure the safety of
conflict with general legislation governing a ship. It follows that a seafarer unable to
the rights of employed persons. Full medi- fit in or unwilling to take responsibility or
cal facilities are taken for granted ashore to accept a reasonable measure of disci-
but very few doctors work in merchant pline, could impair efficiency and affect
ships, with certain exceptions such as the safety. Within the confines of such an or-
Polish merchant fleet (Tomaszunas, et al. dered society day-to-day relationships tend
[14]). Medical treatment has therefore be- to be formal and that, combined with the
come the responsibility of designated limited facilities for recreation, the separa-
ships' officers whose ability to diagnose tion from family and friends and rapid
and treat is commensurate with their lim- turnround in port, can lead to tension.
ited medical training and knowledge. This Much has been done to ameliorate living
circumstance excludes many medical con- and working conditions but some difficul-
ditions which could be permitted at sea un- ties can never be completely overcome. The
der the supervision of a doctor. In conse- propulsion engines and generators pro-
quence, practices and treatments which are duce noise and vibration which, although
used ashore but are unsuitable in the con- suppressed, are constantly present in the
5.1 Health Standards - Fitness for Dutyat Sea 321
background. The ship's movement, exter- written and published on the medieal
nal weather conditions, forced ventilation aspects of seafaring and the bibliography
system and acoustic properties ofthe mate- published by the Department of Nauti-
rials used in ship construction may add sig- cal Medieine, Bernhard-Nocht-Institute,
nificantly to this discomfort. Hamburg gives nearly six thousand refer-
A fuller -description of life and work ences. Yet, surprisingly little has been writ-
aboard can be found elsewhere but the cur- ten on the method employed in arriving at
rent trend is towards employing fewer sea- the lists. It would seem that the doctors re-
farers in a crew carefully adjusted in size to sponsible for examining seafarers in each
obtain maximum efficiency. This is parti- country have drawn on their experience of
cularly relevant in newer ships with much morbidity and mortality to produce similar
modern equipment where the crew is re- conclusions.
quired to be more highly trained and It has always been extremely difficult to
skilled than in former years. Any illness elicit medieal statistics on diseases affect-
aboard ship may throw an extra burden on ing seafarers whieh would satisfy strict
the other crew members, who are obliged epidemiological criteria. This has been ac-
to take over the extra duties wherever pos- knowledged at WHO/ILO conferences
sible in addition to nursing and treating the but, nevertheless, it has been possible to
siek person. It follows that there can be no identify categories of diseases which are
category of "light work" at sea. All jobs more prevalent. From these categories dis-
must be properly performed and all crew eases liable to cause unacceptable conse-
capable of carrying out strenuous tasks in quences can be culled for addition to the
the event of an emergency. Nevertheless, basic list of chronie somatic diseases and
the extent of duties and their physieal re- disorders seriously affecting bodily func-
quirements have adefinite bearing on the tion or the special senses such as eyesight
application of medical standards and doc- and hearing. In addition, analysis of radio
tors dealing with seafarers should under- requests for medical advice has assisted
stand fully the nature of each job if sensible in identifying intercurrent illnesses whilst
decisions are to be made. on artieies aboard ship (Brayley [1] and
Serious illness occurring unexpectedly Schepers [11]).
and perhaps at the least opportune time in The system used in applying medical
ship operation presents great difficulty for standards varies from country to country. It
the shipmaster. He would always obtain is common to find that a single set of stan-
medical adviee by radio whieh might en- dards has been laid down whieh is applied
able hirn to remain on course without pre- strictly when examining young entrants but
judice to the patient. Alternatively, he due allowance for age and the nature ofthe
would if necessary divert his ship to nearby duties to be performed is made when as-
help from another ship or to port in cir- sessing serving seafarers in accordance
cumstances where a life might be endan- with those standards. In effect, that system
gered. It is in the true interest of all that has purposely avoided setting definitive
such costly diversions and delay should be standards for serving seafarers; an individ-
avoided wherever possible by excluding ual and arbitrary assessment is made in
seafarers of suspect health. each case. Wherever a number of doctors is
A comparison of the various national entrusted with the examination of seafar-
sets of medical standards shows much gen- ers, there should be accepted rulings to be
eral agreement on the medical conditions observed in order that their decisions may
which are regarded as a bar to seafaring. It be seen to be uniform and fair. A medical
is pertinent to reflect on how these lists standard by definition should be a measure
have been drawn up. A great deal has been to which all decisions may conform. All too
322 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
often many of the national sets contain where continued seafaring becomes unac-
positive, concise rulings that are vitiated by ceptably hazardous. Many of these com-
qualifying clauses which render them diffi- mon diseases are amenable to treatment
cult to interpret and apply. That can lead to which, if timely and successful, will enable
conflicting opinions on "fitness" from a quick return to sea duty. However, it is
shipping doctors involved in any particular necessary for the examining doctor to have
case and the difficulty may be com- an agreed ruling to ensure the compliance
pounded by additional views from family of the patient. This is also necessary when
doctors and hospital consultants. dealing with the more serious diseases
The overall responsibility within any in- which may result in a permanent bar to sea-
dustry rests with its management. It is less faring.
than satisfactory to burden lay managers It is impossible to include speeific advice
and union officials with problems which on every medical condition which might be
they are not competent to solve. Wherever encountered. In order that such cases are
decisions are in accordance with unambig- not left to arbitrary decision, it is necessary
uous medical standards agreed by both to include a general statement of principles
sides, friction is kept to aminimum. to be observed which may be used when as-
It could be argued that medical practice sessing the suitability of persons suffering
is so complex and the individual response from the rarer diseases. This should,
to illness so varied, that it is not possible to amongst other considerations, take account
devise firm medical standards for use in of the side-effects and incompatibilities of
dealing with serving seafarers. That perpet- any required medication and include the
uates the concept that arbitrary assessment therapeutic consequences of losing a medi-
by individual doctors is superior to a con- eine or being unable to obtain it abroad.
sensus ruling. If that is accepted, no further The willingness or ability of the patient to
efforts should be made. However, there is comply with the treatment is another im-
an alternative method which could be ex- portant issue. It should also exclude those
plored. This would define a set of strict cri- suffering from a medical condition where
teria for those entering the industry, bear- the possibility of serious exacerbation re-
ing in mind the limited use and application quiring expert treatment could occur dur-
of seamanship skills when applying for ing the voyage.
work ashore. A breakdown in health early It may be possible in a national fleet or
in a career may cause difficulty in obtain- in a shipping company to impose a condi-
ing suitable retraining and, in that context, tion of restricted service. By this means a
it represents wasted years. A similar break- particular type of ship or shipping trade
down in mid-career at a time when domes- may be avoided and the length of voyage
tic and finaneial responsibilities may be at may be adjusted to fit in with medical re-
their height, must be avoided wherever quirements. An acceptable degree of flex-
possible. This is a rational approach to pro- ibility is thus introduced but the system can
tect the interests of applicants to the indus- succeed only if used with discretion. In
try, but different considerations apply some countries it has been customary to
when dealing with the inevitable impair- place in the coastal trades seafarers who
ment in health which will affect the serving are no longer medically suitable for pro-
seafarers. It is therefore necessary to have a longed deep sea voyages. However, coastal
separate set of standards for them. This set work is often more arduous than other
should be based upon the entrant stan- shipping trades and it may place an added
dards but should also define for the com- strain on a seafarer of impaired health. It is
monly occurring diseases, the point in the also undesirable that the coastal trades
progression of the pathological process should accumulate a significantly greater
5.1 Health Standards - Fitness for Duty at Sea 323
proportion of seafarers who are medically quired. A Dutchman should be barred but
sub-standard. The benefit . of arestricted the history of his previous employment on
service system is mainly to accommodate board ships would be a major factor affect-
seafarers suffering from a remediable con- ing the assessment. ABriton would conti-
dition which needs close supervision and nue only if the condition could be con-
treatment over a short period. trolled by food restriction without strict
Irrespective of the system chosen, it is es- diet, insulin or oral treatment. A Norwe-
sential that a procedure for dealing with gian requiring insulin would not be permit-
appeals against decisions of permanent un- ted to sail on foreign-going vessesl but
fitness for sea service and restriction of ser- might be allowed to continue in the coastal
vice should be introduced. The ILO Con- trades or on ferries in the North Sea.
vention No.73 stipulates that such appeals That represents a considerable range of
should be lodged with a medical referee or opinion on case disposal and given that the
referees who shall be independent of any disease and its progression are similar in
shipowner or of any organisation of ship- each country, an explanation for the diver-
owners or seafarers. That arrangement is sity should be sought. To evaluate these ru-
undoubtedly fair to seafarers but, unless lings it is necessary to weigh various factors
the referee has a full knowledge of working which include the basic knowledge of the
conditions at sea and experience of nauti- disease process and its treatment, epide-
cal medicine, decisions unacceptable to miological studies and the occupational
shipping doctors will be made. aspects.
The pathology of diabetes mellitus and
5.1.1 Differences in Regulations the usual clinical course are common
Concerning Specific Disorders knowledge. The severity of the metabolic
disorder is in direct proportion to the de-
It is not my intention, nor is it possible gree of insulin deficiency. About a quarter
here, to make widespread comparisons of of all diabetics have a deficiency severe
the different sets of national medical stan- enough to require insulin injections to
dards. But it is instructive to look closely at maintain whatever control of blood glu-
the advice given in these sets when dealing cose is possible when balanced against car-
with some of the more commonly occur- bohydrate and other energy intake. The life
ring diseases such as diabetes mellitus, hy- expectancy of affected persons, even those
pertension, ischaemic heart disease, myo- who are without symptoms, is reduced by
cardial infarction and epilepsy. the accompanying progressive arterial de-
generation. Most diabetics will die not
5.1.1.1 Diabetes from fluctuations of blood glucose but
Most nations bar diabetics from entry into from the manifestations of arterial degene-
the shipping industry. Few would quarrel ration. To accept that does not underesti-
with that decision yet just as few are able to mate the consequences of marked fluctua-
agree on advice regarding serving seafarers tions which may cause either ketosis or
who develop the disease during their ca- hypoglycaemia. Acute infection and seri-
reer. The insulin-dependent Swede may ous injury are frequent precipitating
continue at sea unless the insulin doses causes. Both must be regarded as serious
prove difficult to adjust. A Frenchman may emergencies which need skilled urgent at-
continue on certain types of voyage, pro- tention if tragedies are to be avoided.
vided the condition is stabilised by diet or If such cases are permitted to remain at
oral treatment. A German requiring insulin sea, due consideration should have been
is barred, but milder cases may continue on given to several occupational factors. There
oral treatment only, if strict diet is not re- is the impracticality of catering for individ-
324 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
ual food preferences or all the require- that the pathological process has been
ments of a prescribed diet as opposed to slowed to a degree acceptable under strict
general food restriction. This is especially medical supervision. Most countries are
so when linked to the watchkeeping system prepared to allow continued service in such
which covers periods of duty throughout cases where the seafarer will play his part
the night, when full catering facilities are fully in following the treatment regime.
not available. In addition, those responsi- However, there is always a minority unable
ble for the ship's safety in adverse weather to reduce food intake. It is common prac-
in busy shipping lanes may for long peri- tice to prescribe oral hypoglycaemic drugs
ods be unable to leave their post. In such for these patients. The rationale of such
circumstances, carefully measured food therapy for seafarers is open to question.
and fluid intake is a secondary considera- There is no suggestion of cure and major
tion and this may lead to temporary hypo- studies over a substantial period such as
glycaemia which, even if not severe enough that by Meinert et al. [9] have shown that
to precipitate collapse, may mar judge- the prognosis is not improved by this treat-
ment. Ever present is the knowledge that it ment. The oral hypoglycaemic drugs have
is not always possible to gauge with much incompatibilities, side-effects and contra-
precision the degree of arterial degenera- indications to use. On balance, this should
tion affecting the peripheral and central be weighed against the ability of these
blood vessels, so an extra mortality from drugs to moderate fluctuations of blood
unpredictable myocardial infarction and glucose for a patient unable to control his
allied conditions must be accepted. appetite and therefore with an accelerated
Most countries have decided against the disease process.
employment at sea of insulin-dependent With this view of the three categories of
serving seafarers. It is likely that the deci- diabetic patients, it is possible to formulate
sion has been based upon a concept of a standard which is reasoned and compati-
what medical surveillance can be expected ble with an agreed overall philosophy
to achieve. In making allowance for the which has been accepted by any group of
other complications of diabetes which af- doctors entrusted with the task. And yet, as
fect also the eyes, kidneys and neuromus- already cited, there is little agreement be-
cular system, it may be feit that it is not pos- tween countries on case disposal although
sible or, indeed, desirable that surveillance the medical position is common knowl-
should embrace the monitoring of a severe edge. There are differences in national
disease process through to the point where medical practices and attitudes to disease
life is endangered or severe disability ap- but that is not a convincing explanation.
pears. The answer probably lies within the con-
The remaining three-quarters of all dia- flict of interests of those involved in the in-
betics are mainly of the maturity onset dustry: shipowners, insurers, govemment,
type, the majority of whom are, or have unions and seafarers. The medical interest
been, overweight. It is generally accepted and well-being of the seafarer should al-
that ovemutrition is the most important ways be the paramount consideration. But,
aetiological factor in this group. Most of paradoxically, medical advice to that end is
these cases can be treated solely by re- not always acceptable to a seafarer. Some
stricting food intake. The success of this can envisage no other sort of life, nor can
treatment depends on the willingness ofthe they adjust to the thought of illness and un-
patient to maintain the altered eating habit. employment ashore. Within a system of ar-
Those who are able and willing to comply bitrary assessment it is unfortunately usual
succeed in leading an apparently normal that those who protest most vigorously, and
li fe in which it is reasonable to suppose who can rally most support from unions,
5.1 Health Standards - Fitness for Duty at Sea 325
politicians and doctors ashore, manage to double and treble that to be expected in
remain at sea long after they have become the unaffected. Wherever hypertensive pat-
medically unsound. ients are allowed to continue working at
The shipowners are responsible, usually sea, an increased mortality and morbidity
under law, for providing and paying for must be accepted.
any medical attention required by the crew. Once again there is much disparity be-
They accept with good grace the cost of tween the national standards. Some coun-
medical emergencies which cannot be fore- tries will go no further than suggesting
seen but they expect crews to be free from that the cause, severity and complications
the risk of predictable illness. The ship should be considered. Others state that any
owners usually join with the seafarers' or- excess over 100 mmHg diastolic pressure is
ganisations in ensuring that an acceptable unacceptable, while yet others set figures
system of medical surveillance is main- for both systolic and diastolic pressures.
tained. Nevertheless, no system is trouble- The difficulty is the general reluctance of
free, and it is in those circumstances when doctors to state what should be regarded as
doctors fail to agree that issues other than anormal blood pressure.
the purely medical may intrude. However, the introduction ofthe specific
Diabetes mellitus was chosen as a good antihypertensive drugs has forced some
illustrative example ofthe many difficulties general agreement on the level of pressure
which have to be resolved if a workable so- at which treatment for uncomplicated
lution is to be reached. The resolution of essential hypertension should be com-
those difficulties is fundamentally con- menced. As a general guide when treating
cerned with the identification of adefinite those under 65 it is regarded as reasonable
stage in the progression of disease beyond and prudent to prescribe when the diastolic
which it is not possible to support the risks pressure reaches 100 mmHg recorded at
of the treatment regime and possible com- the fifth phase. There is less agreement on
plications of the disease itself. the level at which raised systolic pressure
should be treated but some studies suggest
5.1.1.2 Cardiovascular Disease 165 mmHg. In setting a standard it may
The cardiovascular degenerative diseases then be held that above the level of
present some similar problems. Most coun- 165/100 mmHg the risks of complications
tries will not permit seafaring ifthere is evi- have increased to an unacceptable degree.
dence of organic heart disease or serious 1fthat is fixed as a maximum permitted un-
disorder of conduction, rhythm or rate. The treated level, the position is clear. But the
diagnosis is usually firmly based and the question of accepting those treated with
disposal in these cases is clear-cut. Unfor- antihypertensive drugs at high er levels re-
tunately, that does not apply when dealing mains to be answered.
with essential hypertension without other The cardiovascular degenerative dis-
demonstrable evidence of hypertensive eases are progressive ill-understood disor-
heart disease. ders which are not amenable to curative
In the United Kingdom, as well as some treatment. Hypertension is a single mani-
other countries, coronary heart disease is festation which can be controlled but it re-
the major cause of death in middle and old quires daily medication, often for pro-
age. The seafaring population shares that longed periods and sometimes for life, with
fate. Hypertension is a major precursor to powerful drugs which have well-docu-
both ischaemic heart disease and coronary mented side-effects and incompatibilities.
occlusion. In the natural progression of hy- For patients with well-controlled pressure
pertension both these complications occur the rate of strokes and kidney damage will
at a rate which is somewhere between be reduced but it has yet to be convincingly
326 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
shown that the myocardial infarction rate serious disease by less than reliable meth-
is significantly reduced or the progression ods which may not detect impending dan-
of the underlying degenerative process gerous complications.
slowed. There has been a plethora of pub- Most national sets of standards regard
lished work on all aspects of the use of the organic disease of the heart and major
antihypertensive drugs and it is not possi- blood vessels as a bar to further seafaring.
ble to cover that ground here. It must be That decision is complicated by recent ad-
considered in great detail with the utmost vances in surgical procedures such as heart
care before adecision is reached. However, valve replacement, coronary artery by-pass
in the context of standards, certain aspects surgery and the repair of aortic aneurysms.
are important. Once treatment has been The re placement valves used, whether
started, it must not be stopped abruptly. A prosthetic or tissue, are pro ne to develop
guaranteed supply of the drug and confi- serious incompetence. A prosthetic valve,
dence in compliance from the patient which is usually supported by anticoagu-
would be obligatory. Many hypertensive lant therapy to reduce the risk of emboli,
patients are considerably overweight and may fail suddenly within hours or several
some are unwilling to moderate their food days. Tissue valve failure is usually more
and alcohol consumption or to deal with gradual over several days or weeks. Tran-
other risk factors which may be present. sient ischaemic attacks with accompanying
Whether treated or not treated, they repre- focal neurological dis order can occur in
sent a "poor risk" group. And so, many patients receiving either type of valve.
specific factors must be delineated. These These occurrences are often unpredictable
include decisions on wh ether there should and of too serious consequence to be con-
be satisfactory control of personal habits sidered safe for seafaring. The improved
and reduction to desirable weight before quality of life following these life-saving
treatment is started with nominated drugs operations is not sufficient reason to put
(some are unsuitable) for which a maxi- aside the known possible sequelae. The
mum perrnissible dose would have to be same consideration applies to coronary ar-
stated. Perhaps the most difficult problem tery by-pass surgery which, although bring-
is the assessment of the underlying disease ing symptomatic relief of anginal pain,
process by ordinary cIinical methods with- does not excIude the risk of sud den occIu-
out repeated very specialised procedures. sion ofthe graft or affect the progression of
Angina pectoris may be suppressed and the the al ready considerable degree of arterial
he art rate slowed in treated hypertension. degeneration. There is, as yet, doubt that
The true level of blood pressure will be un- the general prognosis is significantly im-
known. The electrocardiogram is not a proved or the rate of sudden death reduced
wholly reliable indicator. Various studies to an acceptable level. Whatever the final
such as the Framingham survey have indi- outcome of balancing the conflicting opin-
cated the limitations of the ECG in detect- ions from various studies, it is highly un-
ing disease (Wilson and Junger [15]). It may likely that the level will be acceptable. For
be felt that these complex matters can be the same reason the degree of arterial dis-
resolved satisfactorily and a rational stan- ease which is necessary to produce an aor-
dard forrnulated which fulfils the require- tic aneurysm would preclude a seafarer
ments of Convention NO.73 [4]. However, even after a successful repair. Peripheral
it is doubtful that this objective could be vascular disease causing interrnittent clau-
achieved and, if that conclusion is accept- dication is in the same category and it has
ed, treatment with antihypertensive drugs been shown to be associated with increased
at sea should not be permitted. In reality it risk of arterial disease affecting the heart
constitutes the medical supervision of a and brain.
5.1 HeaIth Standards - Fitness for Duty at Sea 327
Serving as the basis for the development of men and animals. In a wider toxicological
shipboard toxicology for the last two de- sense the deleterious effect of noxious sub-
cades has been the increasing importance stances is understood as not only their abil-
of chemical factors in relation to a) the ity to cause acute and chronic poisoning
characteristics of work and rest of sea- but also a) their capacity for acting selec-
going personnel of modem ships of all tively on some organs and physiological
types and descriptions, and b) environ- systems, macromolecules and metabolic
mental pollution. Shipboard toxicology is links, b) their capacity for affecting the abil-
part of preventive toxicology, dealing with ity of the organism to react and c) their
the interreaction between the organism and blastomogenic, embryotoxic, teratogenic
chemical factors under specific conditions and mutagenic effects (Sanotskii and Ula-
of shipboard environment (Tiunov and nova [16], Kagan [9]). However, in marine
Savateev [19]). cargo handling operations and hygiene, a
Notwithstanding the great variety of in- still wider use has been found for the pri-
dices such as quality and quantity, sources mary definition as it includes in practice
and nature, as well as properties of ship- the whole variety of adverse effects con-
board chemical factors, these can be inte- nected with the carriage of dangerous
grated from the point ofview ofhygiene in- goods by sea. It also presents a reasonable
to three main groups: a) dangerous chemi- basis for studying the effects of particular
cal goods, b) polymeric and synthetic goods or the whole range of dangerous car-
materials c) chemically harmful substances goes carried by sea and can therefore be '
in everyday life and work (Fig.1). As can used effectively in maritime hygiene.
be seen from the diagram, one of the lead- In recent years an ecological trend in
ing trends· in shipboard toxicology is the shipboard toxicology has developed, find-
study of the properties of dangerous goods ing its reflection in the work on environ-
and their toxic affects on the body resulting mental protection in ships carrying danger-
in biological changes, as weH as the work- ous goods (Navaz [15]; Ulewicz [22]; Voit-
ing out of effective measures for ensuring enko and Shafran [23]). Up to the present
the safety of personnel, ships and port time, however, except for the well-develop-
structures and for protecting the environ- ed studies on the prevention of pollution of
ment during shipment, handling and stor- the sea by oil, little progress has been made
ing of dangerous goods (Andronov and in investigating the effects of dangerous
Shafran [2]; Zorn [25]; Kolkovski [10]). goods transported by sea.
Included as dangerous goods are sub-
stances and articles which, in carriage, may 5.2.1 Definitions and Criteria
be the cause of explosions, fires or damage ofHazard
to vessels, structures, warehouses or build-
ings, as well as loss of life, injury, poi- The dominant hazardous properties of
soning, bums, irradiation or diseases of many cargoes are flammability, liability to
330 5 Special Fields in Nautieal Medicine
B. Sources
H
C. Circumstonces where hormful effects moy occur
D.
H
Possible hormful effects
Fig.1. General system (schematic) of ship's chemieal factors showing sources, conditions and possible
harmful effects. C-l, loading/unloading; C-2, sea voyage; C-3. tank washing; C-4, fumigation; C-5, corro-
sive effects; C-6. fire on board; C-7, explosion; C-8. water in holds; D-l, acute poisoning; D-2, chronie
poisoning (diseases caused by poisoning); D-3, slowly developing toxic process; D-4, toxie effect causing a
change in the normal ability ofthe organism to react (disadaptation); D-5, fire on booard; D-6, explosion;
D-7, corrosive effect; D-8, atmosphere; D-9, sea; D-JO. co ast
explode and toxicity, and goods can easily hazardous properties could appear in
be categorized according to these proper- emergency situations.
ties. Other goods disclose their hazardous Considering the fact that the exhibition
properties only und er specific conditions of hazardous properties by various goods
(for instance, goods which emit toxic gases depends both on the goods themselves and
and vapours when they come into contact on the specific conditions of transporta-
with water or fire and goods which have tion, which usually differ from those in in-
been infected before shipment with pa- dustry, agriculture and everyday life, it is
thogenic bacteria, spores, viruses etc.). In necessary to define such basic concepts as
all these cases, the goods are to be regarded transport hazard and transport toxicity.
as dangerous, bearing in mind that their From the viewpoint of toxicology and
5.2 Toxieology in Seafaring - Dangerous Goods 331
Table 2. Criteria for cIassification of dangerous goods depending on degree of toxicity, physical state and
route of exposure
vention of accidents among seamen and 1. Unity ofwork and rest zones ofthe crew,
dockside workers, especially in emergency owing to the limited size of the ship and
incidents involving real danger of acute superstructure - habitat ofthe se amen
poisoning. At the same time, it must be tak- 2. Prolonged and continous adverse effects
en into account that the median lethai present at sea due to the weather along
doses (LD so) and concentrations (LC so) with the influence of physical, chemical
have been established in toxicological and socio-psychological, occupational
experiments on laboratory animals and and everyday-life conditions on board
may differ substantially from those with re- 3. The dynamic nature of the complicated
spect to human beings, depending on their range of adverse environmental factors
specific and individual features, as weil as acting on seamen, among whieh the ma-
on the specific shipping conditions. The jor component cannot always be dis-
latter are of paramount importance be- cerned
cause, as emphasized by Chaigneau [4], the 4. Constant stress in the work of seamen
toxicological principle of cIassification of which, in combination with the general
vapours and gases can be evaluated only lack of physical activity, makes them
relatively because their toxicity varies with more prone to any toxic effects.
the rise of temperature, reduction of oxy- 5. Conditions of continous relative social
gen content and presence of carbon mon- isolation when living within a small
oxide and carbon dioxide and other gases group of men, combined with general
in the surrounding air, i. e. environmental sensory deprivation. This may cause the
conditions typically existing in ships' seaman to overestimate possible dangers
spaces. and to over-react in emergencies.
Apart from this, there are conditions
5.2.2 Shipping Conditions and Toxic which influence the potential toxic danger
Effects of Dangerous Goods on board ship. These are the purpose and
type 0f the ship, the duration of the voyage
The ship is an industrial and communal en- and the sailing area, and specific features
tity, the distinctive features of which have a appertaining to the working activities of
pronounced influence on the toxie effects various professional groups within the
of dangerous goods and other chemical ship's complement.
factors on seamen. Pertaining to these fea- It is important to bear in mind toxieolog-
tures, as shown by Shafran et al. [18], are: ical hazards during loading of goods, pas-
5.2 Toxicology in Seafaring - Dangerous Goods 333
sage by sea with the cargo on board, dis- stages are of relatively short duration, they
charging of goods, stripping, washing or include intensive labour-consuming opera-
gas-freeing of holds and tanks, and also tions with considerable expenditure of en-
passage by sea in ballast with degassed or ergy on the part of the members of the
undegassed tanks. The last stage is impor- crew. These operations are also character-
tant with respect to tankers, gas carriers ized by a sharp increase in the concentra-
and bulk chemieal carriers. tion of noxious fumes and dust in the air,
The handling of dangerous goods in not only in the cargo spaces but often in the
ports involves the accumulation of large crew accommodation areas as weil, where-
amounts of toxic substances within limited by the toxic substances are not only in-
areas or spaces (cars, piers, holds) and their haled but also find their way into the or-
transfer by lifting cranes, vehicles and ganism through the skin.
dockside workers, which creates a risk of From the above it can be seen that con-
damage to the containers and packing and sideration of specific sailing conditions
thus a risk of poisoning a great number of and peculiarities of each processing stage
seamen and workers in a short time. Dur- in the carriage of dangerous goods is a nec-
ing these handling operations, the principal essary requirement to ensure safety of sea-
sources of gas emission and dust formation men when noxious chemical factors are
are the goods stowed on shore. When dis- present on board.
charging the goods, a short intensive re-
lease of vapours and gases may take place
upon opening the holds, owing to the accu- 5.2.3 Kinds of Toxic Effect of
mulation of fumes during the voyage fol- Dangerous Goods; Principal
lowing contact of chemical substances with Clinical Syndromes
water, intensive oxidizing processes during
the voyage, or damage to containers and The variety of kinds and conditions of con-
packing etc. All these factors must be taken tact of seamen and dockside workers with
into consideration when elaborating meas- dangerous goods brings about the multiple
ures to ensure safety in handling dangerous character of display of toxic effects, along
goods. with physical, chemieal and biologieal
The passage by sea with cargo on board properties specific to each substance. Both
is the chief part of the overall transport direct and indirect consequences of chemi-
process and the longest period when the cal injury can considerably hinder diagno-
seaman is likely to come into contact with sis and treatment of developed pathologi-
the carried goods. During this period, nox- cal states and disease conditions. Depend-
ious substances are emitted into the sur- ing upon the active doses and concentra-
rounding atmosphere exclusively from the tions, the individual features of the organ-
ship's sources, and the estimated concen- ism and the conditions of contact, danger-
tration of vapours and gases depends on ous goods and their components can cause
the period of time the goods are stowed on the following kinds of toxic effects:
board, as weil as on the climatic and geo- 1. Accidents involving acute poisoning and
graphieal conditions of navigation (espe- critical conditions
cially on the metereologieal factors). 2. Chronic poisoning and occupational dis-
Any forthcoming change of cargo or re- eases
pairs to the ship demand special prepara- 3. Certain symptoms, syndromes, pre-
tion ofthe cargo spaces, which is known on pathologieal states, reduction of adap-
dry cargo vessels and bulkers as cleaning of tive reserves and changes in reactivity.
holds, and in tankers as stripping, washing In addition, under the action of ship-
and degassing of tanks. Although these board toxie factors the quantitative indices
334 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
and structure of diseased states of seamen scriptions are known of cases of mass poi-
may change. As the first group of the soning by pesticides when eating food
above-mentioned effects is most important products contaminated during carriage by
in carriage of dangerous goods in all-cargo sea (Weeks [24]). Similar cases have been
vessels, it will be necessary to consider its periodically described in the literature up
characteristics in some detail. to the present time.
According to their type of toxie action, In spite of the fact that practically all
all dangerous goods can be conventionally chemical substances have specific toxic ef-
subdivided into substances having a pre- fects, the collective intoxication symptoms
dominantly local or systemic (resorption) following acute poisoning are usually con-
effect. In the first case, areaction of skin fined to a number of basic clinical syn-
and mucous membranes at the pi ace of dromes, among which the most significant
contact is evident, whereby burning, irrita- diagnostically, und er shipboard condi-
tion or an inflammatory effect in noted. tions, are the following: neurologieal syn-
Evidence of the local effect will not ex- drome, disturbance of respiration, circula-
clude resorption symptoms which can de- tory disturbance, hepatic and renal insuffi-
velop as the poison is absorbed and circu- ciency, and gastric disturbance. Their char-
lates in the organism. acteristics are described in detail in all
Sometimes, und er the action of irritants handbooks on clinical toxieology (Luzhni-
or toxic agents, the nervous system may be kov et al. [13]; Golikov [7]; Ganzhara and
damaged; this can cause serious lesions Novikov [6]; Locket [11]; Ludewig and
and even have a fatal outcome. Lohs [12]; Braun and Dönhardt [3]), thus
As a rule, und er conditions of acute poi- making it quite unnecessary to elucidate
soning with toxic components of danger- them in this section.
ous goods, a selective action of the toxic The diagnosis of acute poisoning when
agent on the functional systems of the or- carrying dangerous goods by sea is greatly
ganism is noticed. However, detection of a facilitated by data obtained on the contact
specific action is hindered because most of of the crew members with known chemical
the toxic agents have mediatory, indirect substances stowed on board, by the ab-
effects (Albert [1]). Besides in intoxication sence among the crew of persons with ag-
with some chemical substances, the charac- gravated diseases, the differential diagnosis
teristic features are the development of the of which could be made difficult, and by
pathological process in phases and the oc- the crew personnel undergoing compulso-
currence of a latent period, the manifesta- ry periodic medical examinations at which
tion and duration of which depend on the aggravated diseases can usually be re-
amount (dose, concentration) and proper- vealed. Typical complaints among a num-
ties of the toxic agent and on the rate of its ber of crew members or dockside workers
biotransformation and elimination from at the same time under conditions of con-
the organism, as well as on the toxicity of tact with dangerous goods must always
the formed metabolites (Luzhnikov et al. alert the ship's administration and the
[13], Tiunov [20D. medical staff to possible poisoning from
Most important in the development of the components of the goods in hand, This
the toxic effect and in the clinical picture of is especially important under passage at
poisoning is the route of exposure. Under sea, where there are minimum possibilities
shipboard conditions, when carrying dan- to ren der skilled (and specialized) medical
gerous goods, poisoning occurs most often aid. Therefore, early diagnosis ofpoisoning
by inhalation and also through the skin, as is the most important aspect of medical
was shown convincingly in the comprehen- treatment.
sive study by Schepers [17]. However, de-
5.2 Toxicology in Seafaring - Dangerous Goods 335
5.2.4 Medical First Aid and (on salvage and rescue service ships). Also,
Treatment of Poisoning the respiratory centre is stimulated by giv-
ing the patient mixtures of oxygen and car-
The general first aid measures for po i- bon dioxide to inhale.
soning include: When in hospital, to which the patient
1. Withdrawing the patient from contact must be sent as soon as possible, these
with the toxic agent without any delay; measures should be supplemented by ap-
2. Reducing the content of toxic substance plying haemodialysis, haemosorption and
in the organism; replacement of blood.
3. Provision of skiIled medical aid; Of great importance in the complex
4. Prevention of probable complications. treatment of poisoning is antidotal therapy,
Apart from this, even while giving the the agents and possibilities of which are
initial treatment to the patient, it will be steadily growing. Antidotes should be giv-
necessary to exclude the possibility of new en to the patients right at the initial stages
cases of poisoning by warning the person- of the first aid treatment, and by means of
nel and by temporary stoppage ofwork un- them it is possible to prevent the develop-
til the causes of the accident can be dis- ment of intoxication or to minimize the
covered. pathological process. It is important that
All measures of treatment of acute poi- antidotes should be given only when the
soning may be divided into three main source of poisoning is definitely known.
groups: ensuring rapid evacuation of toxi- All antidotes are divided into a number
cants from the organism, specific (antido- of main groups depending on their mecha-
tal) therapy and symptomatic treatment nism of action. Thus, activated charcoal
(Ganzhara and Novikov [6]). and ion-exchange resins are the typical
Unabsorbed toxic agent may be evacuat- representatives of the physicochemical
ed from the gastrointestinal tract by gastric group. Pure chemical action is characteris-
lavage, by the use of cleansing and syphon tic of dithiols, aminopolycarboxylic and
enemas and by purgatives, as weIl as by as- aminopolyphosphoric acids. The group of
tringents, envelopers, absorbents and neu- functional antidotes includes agents which
tralizers. The techniques of the necessary are counterpoisons by their pharmacologi-
procedures are set forth in the Medical cal effect or antimetabolites (Conner et al.
First Aid Guide for Use in Accidents In- [5]). For instance, the primary oxidation of
volving Dangerous Goods [14]. Gastric la- ethyl alcohol delays the formation in the
vage was regarded as being inappropriate organism of toxic products from methanol,
for shipboard use by laymen. which brings about the antidotal effect of
The removal of toxicant from the organ- ethanol in intoxications with methanol.
ism is accelerated by forced diuresis, effect- Neostigmine and pyridostigmine, which
ed by an excessive water intake and the use are inhibitors of cholinesterase, serve as an-
of diuretics and uragogues. tidotes for poisoning with antidepressants,
Stimulation of respiration also makes for and when cholinesterase is depressed by
the evacuation of intoxicants from the or- organic phosphorus compounds, antidotes
ganism through the respiratory tract. This such as atropine and pralidoxime are its
is achieved either by pharmacological reactivators.
agents or by applying artificial respiration Symptomatic therapy is aimed at restor-
with the use of special apparatus or mouth- ing the functions disturbed by the toxic
to mouth and mouth-to-nose respiratory agent and at the prevention of complica-
methods. At the same time, use should be tions. This type of treatment is often pre-
made of oxygen therapy and hyperbarbic dominant because there are, as yet, no anti-
oxygenation in a high-pressure chamber dotes for a number of toxic agents and in
336 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
cases of poisoning with unknown chemical so that the concentrations of noxious va-
substances symptomatic therapy is the only pours, gases and dust within the working
kind of treatment available. Coping with zones do not exceed the maximum permis-
the distrubances of respiration and oxygen sible concentrations. The various national
deficit in the organism, arresting the distur- regulations may differ slightly from the in-
bances of haemodynamics and cardiac ac- ternational recommendations but as a rule
tion, controlling psychoneurotic distur- they ensure the prevention of acute poi-
bances and hepatic and renal insufficiency, soning among seamen and dock workers.
restoring water - salt and acid - base bal- In solving the problems of safety for men
ance, as weIl as maintaining homeostasis when carrying and handling dangerous
and using me ans for preventing infection - goods, great importance should also be at-
aIl these measures comprise the strategy tached to sufficient lighting of the working
and tactics of symptomatic treatment of places, provision of guards and warning
poisoning, which measures are within the notices.
capacity of the shipboard medical staff. Special attention should be drawn to the
availability of individual appliances for the
5.2.5 Means for Prevention of protection of respiratory organs and to the
Poisoning provision of adequate overalls, as weIl as to
the necessary drugs and antidotes in the
Ensuring safe shipping, storage and han- ship's first aid dispensary. The organization
dling in ports of chemical goods is a quite of storing and was hing the overalls should
practicable task, provided the totality of be subject to permanent checks by the
preventive measures is planned and strictly ship's administration and the medical staff.
followed. This will include organizational, A comprehensive approach to solving
technological and sanitary measures. The the problems of prevention of poisoning
carriage of dangerous goods by sea should will guarantee success in the safe carriage
be organized as envisaged by the IMO of dangerous goods by sea.
Dangerous Goods Code. If the chemical
substance to be carried is not included in
the Code list, then the consignor should References
present written information on the degree 1. Albert, E.: Isbiratelnaya toksichnost. [Selective
and kind of risk, and, if necessary, provide toxicity). Moscow: Mir 1971.
2. Andronov, L.P. and L.M.Shafran: Voprosy gi-
individual means of protection, such as gas
gieny truda moryakov i reglementatsiya mor-
masks, instruments for detection of nox- skikh perevozok opasnykh gruzov. [Problems of
ious vapourS and gases in the air, etc. seamen's hygiene of work and regulations for
Knowledge by the ship's administration carriage of dangerous goods by seal. In: Trudy
and the members of the crew coming in III Mezhdunarodnogo simpoziuma po mor-
skoy meditsine. Leningrad, 26-28 June 1968.
contact with the goods of the hazardous Moscow 1969. pp. 44-47.
properties of the goods being carried al- 3. Braun, W. and A. Dönhardt: Vergiftungsregi-
lows for timely provision of safety for the ster. Haushalts- und Laborchemikalien, Arznei-
crew, the ship and the environment. mittel. Symptomatologie und Therapie. 2nd ed.
Stuttgart: Thieme 1975.
The technology of cargo handling opera-
4. Chaigneau, M.: Classification des gaz de1(:teres.
tions, the stowage of cargo on board and its Ann. Anesth. 21,6,683-688 (1980).
compatibility with other goods carried by 5.Conner, Ch., N.J.Robertson, M.J.Kelly et al.:
the vessel, as weIl as sufficient mechanical Rational use of emergency antidotes. Top.
ventilation of the cargo spaces during the Emergency Med. }, 3, 27-42 (1979).
6. Ganzhara, P. S. and A. A. Novikov: Uchebnoe
voyage and in the course of handling the posobie po kIinicheskoy toksikologii. [Manual
goods at ports must be in compliance with on cIinical toxicology]. Moscow: Meditsina
international and local hygiene regulations, 1979.
5.2 Toxicology in Seafaring - Dangerous Goods 337
7. Golikov, P.S.: Neotlozhnaya pomoshch pri os- 18. Shafran, L. M., L. P. Andronov, L. V. Basalaeva
trykh otravleniyakh. Spravochnik po toksikolo- et al.: Razrabotka aktualnykh gigienicheskikh
gii. [First aid in cases of acute poisoning. Hand- problem sudovoy toksikologii. [Elaboration of
book on toxicology]. Moscow: Meditsina 1978. topical hygiene problems of shipboard toxicol-
8. International maritime dangerous goods code. ogy]. In: X Ukrainskii syezd gigienistov. Tezisy
Vols. 1-4 and supplements Ed.: IMCO, Lon- dokladov. Vo1.2. Kiev 1981. pp. 118-119.
don. London 1972. 19. Tiunov, L.A. and N.N.Savateev: Nekotorye
9. Kagan, Yu. S.: Obshchaya toksikologiya pestit- voprosy korabelnoy toksikologii. [Some prob-
sidov. [General toxicology of pesticides]. Kiev: lems of shipboard toxicology]. Voen.-med. Zh.
Zdorovye 1981. 6,64-66 (1962).
10. Kolkovski, P.: Khimicheskiyat factor v usloviy- 20. Tiunov, L. A.: Osnovnye mekhanizmy metabo-
ata na transporta. [Chemical factors in trans- lizma ksenobiotikov v organizme cheloveka i
port]. Transp. med. Vesti 20. 1/2,20-23 (1975). zhivotnykh. [Principal metabolic mechanisms
11. Locket, S.: Clinical toxicology. The c1inical di- of xenobiotics in men and animals]. In: VINI-
agnosis and treatment of poisoning. London: TI. Itogi nauki i tekhniki. Toksikologiya.
Henry Kimpton 1957. Vo1.12. Moscow 1981. pp. 5-64.
12. Ludewig, R. and K. Lohs: Akute Vergiftungen. 21. The transport of dangerous goods. Recommen-
Ratgeber für toxikologische Notfälle. 6th ed. dations of the United Nations Economic and
Stuttgart: Fischer 1981. Social Council's Committee of Experts.
13. Luzhnikov, E. A., V. N. Dagaev and N. N. Fir- New York: UN 1977. ST/SG/ AC. 10/1/Rev. 1.
sov: Osnovy reanimatologii pri ostrykh otravle- pp. 372.
niyakh. [Fundamentals of reanimatology in 22. Ulewicz, K.: Sea-going vessel as biological eco-
cases of acute poisoning]. Moscow: Meditsina system. In: VIII International symposium on
1977. Marine Medicine, Varna, 24-280ct. 1978.
14. Medical first aid guide for use in accidents in- p.241.
volving dangerous goods. Eds.: IMO, WHO, 23. Voitenko, A. M. and L. M. Shafran: Voprosy
ILO. London: IMO 1982. sanitarnoy okhrany vozdukha v svyazi s pere-
15. Navaz, M.Z.: The carriage by sea ofhazardous vozkoi na sudakh i pererabotkoi v portakh
cargoes, requiring environmental control. Parts opasnykh khimicheskikh gruzov. [Problems of
land 11. Holl. Shipbuilding 20, 112-114 and sanitary protection of air linked with shipping
198-202 (1971). and handling in ports of dangerous chemical
16. Sanotskii, I. V. and I. P. Ulanova : Kriterii vred- goods]. In: Gigiena naselennykh mest. Respu-
nosti v gigiene i toksikologii pri otsenke opas- blikanskiy mezhdunarodnyy sbornik. 20th ed.
nosti khimicheskikh soedinenii. [Criteria of Kiev: Zdorovye 1981. pp. 72-75.
harmfulness in hygiene and toxicology when 24. Weeks, D. E.: Endrine food-poisoning. Areport
assessing hazardous properties of chemical on four outbreaks caused by two separate ship-
compounds]. Moscow: Meditsina 1976. ments of endrine-contaminated flour. BuH.
17. Schepers, B.-F.: Gesundheitsgefährdung durch Wld. Hlth Org. 37,499-512 (1967).
Chemikalien an Bord deutscher Seeschiffe un- 25. Zorn, E.: Gefährliche Güter. Toxikologische
ter besonderer Berücksichtigung gefährlicher Problematik an Bord. Hansa 108, 5, 435-437
Ladung. Dissertation, University of Hamburg (1971).
1978.
5.3 Health Problems on Tankships Carrying Oil,
Gas or Bulk Chemieals
A. Ward Gardner
available statements are contradictory. was a striking result of the subjective part
Shafran et al. [37] reported that significant of the examinations that tankship crew
changes were discovered in the total num- members seem to suffer more frequently
ber of leucocytes and the ratio of unusual from nausea, lack of appetite, uncomfort-
forms in addition to changes in the con- ably sweetish taste and the feeling of being
tents of polynuclear aromatic compounds, disturbed by bad odour than non-tankship
glucogene and lipoids as well as in the ac- crew members.
tivity of the acid and alkaline phosphates These varied findings by different au-
in the plasma. Kirjakov et al. [21] examined thors show no consistent pattern or relation
the crews of five tankers and identified leu- with known hazards. Underthe specific en-
cocytopenia in 13% and thrombocytopenia vironmental conditions and unfavourable
in 7% of the examined seamen. They fur- work hygiene on board some tankships it
thermore mentioned considerable rises of appears that there may be in some people
glucose-6-phosphate and cholesterol lev- short-term alterations of the biochemical
els, a considerable fall of albumins, a rise and haematological values. Collins et al. [7;
of the ß-globulin in the electrophoreses, an 8] and Eddy et al. [10] studied the specific
increase of ammonia and other changes. environmentalload. The authors found out
Tomaszunas et al. [41] found in 184 crew that besides the considerable thermal load
members on board tankers a reduced num- in tropical waters, the continuously chang-
ber of white blood cells, as well as an in- ing climatic conditions and the need for ac-
creased urine phenol level and a lower per- climatisation seem to be a repeated and
centage rate of organic sulphates in urine. strong stress factor. A study by Rodahl et
These findings are not confirmed by oth- al. [35] on work physiology dealt with the
er authors. Andreani and Strambi [2] also work-Ioads of crew members, especially of
examined tankship crews and made the deck officers, during defined processes of
following subdivisons: crew members serv- work and/or activities, under unfavourable
ing for more than 10 years, crew members weather conditions and calls at ports. The
serving less than 2 years duty on board. stated very high load corresponds with that
They could not trace significant differences described by the authors for non-tanks hip
in the numbers of white blood cells, red personnel.
blood ceUs, cholesterollevel and total pro- In spite of the fact that no specific dis-
tein level. In their comparative study of da- eases were found in tankship crew mem-
ta of medical examinations in 201 tankship bers, the distribution of diagnoses seems to
and 205 non-tankship crew members, differ slightly from that of the dry cargo
Goethe et al. [15] could not attest hazards ships. The few cases of poisoning, figuring
affecting the haematological and biochem- as accidents, are excluded (see Chap.3.1).
ical values. There were no pathological dif- Goethe [14] found that the rate of skin dis-
ferences in number with respect to red eases (17.7%) was high er on tankships than
blood cells and haemoglobin percentage. on board other merchant vessels. Skin dis-
There was, however, a significantly slight eases were the most frequent of all regis-
increase of white blood cell numbers in tered diagnoses oftankship crew members.
tankship crew members compared with the In his study on the health status of ocean-
findings in non-tankship crew members. going oil tanker seamen, Nakamura [28]
The differential blood cell count showed found very low blood pressure and low
decreased numbers of eosinophils and dif- cholesterol levels with slight obesity. He
ferences were found in alkaline phospha- did not, however, find signs of specific
tase levels. These levels were lower than in hazards.
non-tankship crew members, and the same Carter [3] examined the absences of
applied in respect of acid phosphatase. It tanker crews and found more frequent ab-
340 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
iron and water. Deaths have resulted from are, therefore, reversible if caught in time
failure to appreciate this danger when crew and treated correctly.
members have not followed the precau-
tions for confined space entry. Tanks in Oil Mists or Sprays. Oil mists or sprays, if
ballast are not safe to enter simply because inhaled in high enough concentrations,
they do not contain petroleum products or may cause irritation of the lungs which
other cargo. Oxygen lack is a serious risk in may lead to pneumonitis. Even medicinal
any confined space where iron and water mineral oil will cause such areaction.
are present. However, this is not unique to petroleum
oils, since the excessive inhalation of many
5.3.2.2 Toxie Effects of Hydroearbons compounds may cause the development of
Hydrocarbons can cause harm to people in chemical pneumonitis.
two main ways: Long-Term Effects by Inhalation. There
1. By inhalation; are, with the exception of benzene, no
2. By skin contact. long-term effects which are directly due to
In each case the problem can be further inhalation of hydrocarbon vapours. How-
dassified under two headings: ever, permanent damage can easily result
1. Short-term effects; from lack of oxygen or from the complica-
2. Long-term effects. tions of becoming unconscious, all of
Inhalation of Hydroearbons which may be associated with hydrocarbon
vapour inhalation.
Following inhalation, the toxicity ofhydro- Benzene is in a risk dass by itself in
carbons as a dass is not great, with the im- terms ofthe long-term hazard from inhala-
portant exception of benzene (C6H6). With tion of very low amounts of the vapour. It
this one exception, volatility and risk are should also be noted that some commercial
dosely related; the more volatile the hy- grades of toluene and xylenes frequently
drocarbon, the greater the likelihood of in- contain considerable amounts of benzene.
halation leading to poisoning by 'gassing'. Toluene and xylenes should therefore be
Remember too that a rise of temperature viewed with the same concem as benzene,
will lead to an increase in volatility. until, or unless, they are known to be ben-
zene-free.
Short- Term Effects by Inhalation. Inhala- Many gasolines also contain benzene,
tion of hydrocarbon vapours will, in the sometimes up to 10%. In any case, the
presence of adequate oxygen, produce a amounts should be known so that suitable
slow anaesthetisation of the person ex- precautions can be taken.
posed. The rate of change in the person's
condition will be roughly proportional to Skin Contact with Hydrocarbons
the amount of hydrocarbon inhaled, and Hydrocarbons are best kept off the skin.
will therefore depend upon both the con- The short-term effects may be to cause
centration of the hydrocarbon inhaled and dermatitis or oil acne, and with certain hy-
the time for which it is breathed. drocarbons, the long-term effects may be to
Beginning with a stage of excitation, the cause skin cancer if contact is prolonged.
effects give rise to 'drunken' behaviour, There is no substitute for personal deanli-
slurred speech, staggering, confusion and ness and tidy working in preventing oil
loss of consciousness. Further inhalation contact, and thus preventing any possibility
will lead in due course to arrest of breath- of short- or long-term effects.
ing and heart beat and finally to death.
The hydrocarbon vapour can be Short- Term Effects on the Skin. The lighter
breathed out again in fresh air. The effects hydrocarbons such as gasoline and kero-
342 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
sine can cause skin defatting which may clothes and aseparate one for other
lead to dermatitis. Heavier hydrocarbons, clothes in order to avoid contamination
such as lubricating oils, can cause plugging of the other clothes with oil.
of the pores and hair follicles which may 7. Prompt medical advice should be sought
go on to a condition known as 'oil acne'. for any skin disease at an early stage in
its development. Once dermatitis ap-
Long- Term Effects on the Skin. Heavier hy- pears in an individual, it may be possible
drocarbons, particularly those containing to prevent it from becoming more severe
polynuclear (polycyclic) aromatic com- by transferring the man to a 'clean' job
pounds, in contact with the skin for pro- until the dermatitis subsides.
longed periods may give rise to skin can-
cers, particularly to scrotal cancer. Benzene (CJli;) (Benzol)
Benzene is a clear, colourless liquid, with a
Precautions Against Skin Effects. The fol- pleasant aromatic odour. Its TLV 'c' varies
lowing preventative measures are recom- between countries but is usually in the
mended whenever any petroleum product S-10ppm range (10ppm: 30mg/m3).
is handled:
1. Avoid all unnecessary contact with the Inhalation Hazard. The effect of short-
oil. Contact can be minimised by protec- term inhalation of benzene vapour is
tive gloves and other protective clothing. anaesthetisation, similar to that caused by
2. If contact with oil does occur, it should other hydrocarbons. Benzene vapour is al-
be removed from the skin as soon as pos- so irritant in high concentrations. However,
sible. Towels should be clean when used the important problem with benzene is that
and an adequate supply of them avail- it is a serious and insidious destroyer of
able. Harsh soaps should be avoided blood-forming organs, even when inhaled
since they may cause dermatitis. in low concentrations. Repeated exposure
3. Solvents such as kerosine and gasoline to low concentrations of benzene can lead
should not be used to remove oil from to serious illness. Benzene vapour must not
the skin. Oil should be removed by be inhaled. Where benzene vapours occur,
washing with soap and water, or with a breathing apparatus must be worn. Deck
preparation designed for skin cleansing. officers, pumpmen and others who may
Neveruse hydrocarbons as skin cleaners. handle benzene frequently should be under
4. Crew members should be encouraged to medical supervision so suitable tests which
take showers at the end of a day's work indicate benzene exposure can be carried
in order to remove all traces of oil from out.
the skin. When benzene is being handled, the ac-
5. If waste or rags are used to wipe oil from commodation spaces should be tested at
the skin or off machinery, sufficient regular intervals for benzene vapour, using
quantities of them should be available a suitable detector. The concentration of
so that the cleaning materials can be vapour must be maintained below the
changed frequently and therefore kept TLV; note the 'C' notation after the TLV,
relatively clean. Oily rags should not be indicating that the TLV is a ceiling value.
kept in overall or trouser pockets. Closed loading systems are advisable for
6. Seafarers should be encouraged to wear benzene.
clean work clothes, since oil-soaked
outerwear or underclothes may hold the Skin Contact Hazard. Benzene can be ab-
oil in contact with the skin longer than sorbed through the intact skin but there is
would otherwise occur. It may be advis- little danger of absorption by this route
able to provide one locker for work provided contact with the liquid is not pro-
5.3 Health Problems on Tankships Carrying Oil, Gas or Bulk Chemieals 343
longed. The main dang er associated with composition varies widely. Its TLV is
benzene spills on clothing is that the va- 100-200ppm (0.05%). Make sure that the
pours are released into the breathing zone benzene content is below the TLV.
and the inhalation hazard is increased. Many additives are used - usually in
small amounts - but some, such as tetra-
Bitumen ethyl lead (TEL) and tetramethyl lead
The only likely hazard from bitumen is a (TML) ean, under some cireumstanees, be
burn. Bitumen burns are not usually seri- hazardous.
ous, because bitumen is carried at a rela- TML and TEL are added to gasoline to
tively low temperature. Unless the bitumen give it 'anti-knock' properties. TML and
burn is on the face, the best treatment is to TEL are extremely toxie. The quantities in
cool the burn at once by showering for which they are added to gasoline are so
10 min in cold water. The resultant hard bi- small that they do not normally increase
tumen should be left on the skin, covered the toxieity of the gasoline. Nevertheless,
with dry gauze and left. When the bitumen the addition of these eompounds does in-
drops off, healed skin will be found. On the crease the hazard when tank cleaning. The
face, after cooling as above, the bitumen reason for this is that these lead additives
should be removed by swabbing with me- tend to aceumulate in the sludge and scale
dicinalliquid paraffin. Then treat as a heat in the tank. Dangerous eoneentrations may
burn in the usual way. build up if the tank is continually carrying
Cut back bitumens may contain creosote leaded gasoline. Deaths have oceurred
- a coal tar derivative with many polynu- whilst cleaning shore tanks which are eon-
clear aromatic compounds in it. These tinually in leaded gasoline service, when
polynuclear aromatics are liable to cause known precautionary measures have been
skin cancer following prolonged exposure. neglected.
It therefore follows that as cut baek bitu- Benzene mayaiso be present in gasoline.
mens are potentially earcinogenic they The amount should be known and appro-
should always be kept off the skin. priate precautions taken.
erude on Inhalation Hazard. Because gasoline is
very volatile, high coneentrations of va-
erude oil is a mixture of hydrocarbons of
pour can readily occur in enclosed or con-
all kinds. Its composition will vary with
fined spaces. such as cargo tanks or pump-
source. Crude oil may, and usually will,
rooms. The short-term effeets of gasoline
contain other substances, some of which
inhalation are described under inhalation
are toxic, e. g., hydrogen sulphide. It is not
of hydrocarbons.
easy to generalise about the toxieity of
It is apparent from Table 1 that, contrary
crude oils. However, the effects of inhala-
to some popular belief, a concentration of
tion of crude oil vapours will be approxi-
2000ppm (about 20% of the lower flam-
mately similar to the combined effect of the
mable limit) is not safe for even short expo-
inhalation of gasoline vapour and of other
sures. The lower limit for immediate toxic
toxie vapours whieh may be present. For
effects is of the order of 900-1000 ppm.
example, when considering a sour erude,
For safety, personnel must not enter cargo
approximate details of its toxicity will be
tanks or pumprooms unless the vapour
found under gasoline and hydrogen sul-
concentration is below the TLV of
phide.
100-200 ppm (making sure that the ben-
Gasoline (Petrol) zene content is below the TLV).
Gasoline is a mixture of hydrocarbons in Skin Contact Hazard. Gasoline on the skin
the boiling range 30° - 200°C (390° F). The can cause defatting and may thus lead to
344 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
Table 1. Human Response to Inhalation of Gaso- be avoided. Mists or sprays may be en-
line Vapours countered when oil is being loaded.
Concentra- Exposure Effects
tion(ppm) time Skin Contact Hazard. The main problem
160-270 8h Slight, but not generally with kerosine is dermatitis, and this is the
objectionable, irritation hazard which will be of most importance to
of eyes and throat seamen. In addition to its defatting action
500 1h No significant on the skin, kerosine mayaiso cause some
complaints irritation. Kerosines of naphthenie and
900 1h Slight eye, nose and aromatie origin have been shown to be
throat irritation; some more irritating than kerosines of paraffin
dizziness and un- origin, but all types may cause dermatitis.
steadines
On prolonged contact the skin becomes
2000 1h Symptoms of anaesthe- red, dry and scaly, and ultimately begins to
sia begin in 30 min
crack. When in this condition, the skin is
10000 10min Nose and throat irrita- susceptible to bacterial infection. Dermati-
tion in 2 rnin, dizziness
tis problems are best prevented by avoiding
in 4 min and definite
symptoms resembling unnecessary contact with kerosine. The
alcoholic intoxication skin should not be cleaned of oil, tar or
in4-10rnin paint by the use of kerosine.
11000 5 min Nose and throat irrita-
tion in 20 s; dizziness Eye Hazard. In contact with the eyes, ker-
and drunkenness in osine causes only slight transient irritation.
5min
Lubricating Oils
The composition of lubricating oils varies
dermatitis. Skin contact should therefore widely. Before being sold to the customer,
be avoided. In addition, certain gasoline lubricants will also have varying amounts
additives may cause skin allergy. of additives of all kinds.
Lubricating oils and greases are a rela-
tively harmless c1ass of materials. No un-
Kerosine (paraffin) usual hazard is involved in their carriage,
Kerosine is a mixture of hydrocarbons in provided that ordinary care is taken both to
the boiling range 150 225 oe. The com-
0
- keep them offthe skin and to avoid inhala-
position varies widely, but compounds of tion of their vapours (if heated) or of their
the paraffin, naphthene and olefin series mists. While all types of lubricating oil
generally predominate. Hs TLV is 100- have not been systematieally evaluated for
200 ppm (making sure that the benzene their toxicity, experience has shown that
content is below the TLV). Kerosine has a there are no striking differences in their
low degree of toxie hazard when handled toxic effects on the body; In general, they
normallyon tankers. have a low order oftoxicity when taken in-
ternally.
Inhalation Hazard. Because of low toxici- Lubricating oils are often loaded
ty and volatility the inhalation hazard is through the tank lid and the free fall of liq-
negligible unless the cargo has been heat- uid can produce mist or spray. These usual-
ed, in whieh case the increase in vapour ly have no unpleasant effect on persons on
pressure may give rise to toxic concentra- deck, or on those peering down the tank
tions of vapour. lid. If the mists are found to be a problem,
Inhalation of oily mists or sprays should or when personnel have to be exposed to
5.3 Health Problems on Tankships Carrying Oil, Gas or Bulk Chemieals 345
Local Effects. The main potential problem 5.3.2.3 Toxic Effects of Hydrogen Sulphide
associated with the handling of lubricating (H2S) (Sulphuretted Hydrogen)
oils is dermatitis resulting from frequent
and prolonged contact. This is character- Hydrogen sulphide is a colourless gas with
ised by acne (red or black spots at the an odour of rotten eggs. Its TLV is 10 ppm
pores), mainly on the back of the hands, (14 mg/m 3). Very low concentrations can
forearms and thighs. The hair follicles and be detected by smell (0.1 ppm). Smell
sweat pores become infected with the for- should not, however, be used as a guide to
mation of small boils or pimples (oil folli- the presence or absence of hydrogen sul-
culitis). For the occasional person who de- phide because in high concentrations the
velops an individual sensitivity to lubricat- gas paralyses the sense of smell. The effect
ing oils, very severe skin reactions may of this will be that although hydrogen sul-
develop, requiring special medical atten- phide may be present in high concentra-
tion. In general, however, dermatitis need tions, it cannot be detected by smell. The
not be a problem if unnecessary contact dangers of using smell as a guide will there-
with the oils is avoided and good personal fore be obvious.
hygiene is observed. Most cmde oils contain some hydrogen
An additional aspect of skin contact is sulphide - those which contain 10 ppm (or
that of the dang er of skin cancer. Cases of more) as a liquid are classed as sour cmdes.
human skin cancer have resulted from con- There is a very real dang er of poisoning by
tact with certain lubricating oils and waxes. hydrogen sulphide when loading or dis-
In these instanees, the skin eontaet was charging sour emdes. Precautions must be
severe and prolonged over many years. The taken to ensure that vapours containing hy-
sensible approach, therefore, is to keep lu- drogen sulphide are not breathed. Closed
bricating oil offthe skin. loading systems are recommended for
Experimental evidence indicates that ships carrying sour cmdes. In the absence
washing with soap and water after applica- of these, breathing apparatus must be worn
ti on of a cancer-forming oil to the skin by those engaged in the loading operation.
greatly reduces its tumour-inducing activi- These precautions apply equally to ballast-
ty. There is thus a good experimental basis ing after the discharge of sour cmde oil
for recommending frequent washing when- from a tank.
ever oils are handled. The short-term effects of hydrogen sul-
phide are damage to the brain and the kid-
Petroleum Products neys. Eye irritation mayaiso be feit. In high
The lighter petroleum liquids can cause de- concentrations a few breaths may be
fatting of the skin and can thus give rise to enough to produce unconsciousness, fol-
a dermatitis of occupational origin. Preven- lowed swiftly by death.
tion is by keeping these substanees off the Table 2 shows how different concentra-
skin. They should never be used to clean tions of hydrogen sulphide gas will affect
the skin on account of the risk of defatting. the human body.
346 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
Table 2. Human response to inhalation of hydro- ide extinguishes fire by displacing the air -
gen sulphide the oxygen content ofthe space is therefore
Concentra- Exposure Effects reduced. If there is insufficient oxygen for
tion (ppm) time a fire to burn, there is certainly insufficient
50-100 1h Irritation of eyes, nose,
oxygen for a man to live.
throat and breathing Crew members must not be allowed to
passages. Longer expo- enter compartments where carbon dioxide
sures to concentrations has been used as a smothering agent, until
of the order of
an adequate supply of oxygen has been as-
100ppm, induce a
gradual increase in sured. If entry is essential in the presence of
severity of these symp- high concentrations of carbon dioxide,
toms, and death may then breathing apparatus must be worn.
occur within 4-48 h The secondary hazard from carbon diox-
200-300 1h Marked irritation of ide is frost-bite. As liquefied carbon di-
eyes, nose throat and oxide leaves the applicator of a fire extin-
breathing passages.
Langer exposures to
guisher or of a fixed installation, it expands
concentrations would and cools considerably owing to the latent
probably not be tolerat- heat of evaporation. The applicators be-
ed come so cold that if touched by the human
500-700 0.5-1 h Loss of consciousness flesh they will 'burn' .
and possibly death
700-900 Fewmin. Unconsciousness and
5.3.2.5 Toxie Effects of Organic Lead
to 0.5 h death will occur rapidly Compounds
1000-2000 Few min. Immediately fatal Tetramethyl and tetraethyl lead (TML,
TEL) are used as anti-knock compounds in
gasoline to raise the octane number. These
Long-Term Effects. Repeated exposures to organic lead compounds can be found in
low concentrations of hydrogen sulphide tank scale and in tank sludge in higher con-
may cause some irritation and coughing. centrations than in the gasoline. So, entry
However, hydrogen sulphide does not ac- to all tanks which have contained leaded
cumulate in the body, and long-term poi- gasoline must be controlled and, unless the
soning is, therefore, not a problem. threshold limit values are not exceeded, no
entry must be permitted except to persons
Local Effects. The irritating effects of hy- wearing breathing apparatus.
drogen sulphide are most pronounced in Any operation which disturbs scale or
the eyes. Pain, sensitivity to light and other which moves sludge will increase the con-
visual difficulties may also occur. centration of organic lead in air - so these
operations greatly increase the dangers to
5.3.2.4 Toxie Effeets of Carbon Dioxide people. It is therefore of the utmost impor-
(C0 2)
tance for the safety of all crew members
Carbon dioxide is a colourless gas which is who may be involved that such operations
heavier than air. It will be found on board, are conducted under expert ship officer,
mainly in association with fire-fighting medical and hygiene supervision. Urine
equipment. Its TLV is 5000 ppm (9000 mg/ lead levels can be used for biological moni-
m 3). toring of organic lead exposure.
The main hazard from carbon dioxide
will arise when it has been used to extin-
guish a fire or to prevent a fire occurring in
a pumproom or engine room. Carbon diox-
5.3 Health Problems on Tankships Carrying Oil, Gas or Bulk Chemieals 347
5.3.2.6 Toxic Effects of Sodium Hydroxide Similarly, showering of the skin must be
(Caustic, Caustic Soda) carried out for at least 10 min, timed by the
dock, using copious amounts of water.
Sodium hydroxide may be found in tank- Contaminated dothing should be removed
ers in the white crystalline form, or as a so- whilst under the shower. Burned areas of
lution in water. skin should then be treated as heat bums.
Sodium hydroxide is usually used as a If caustic gets into the eye, medical aid
deaning agent on ships. However, a con- must be sought at the earliest possible mo-
taminated caustic solution, known as spent ment, because serious consequences may
caustic, is sometimes shipped in cargo follow such an injury. Prevention is easy.
tanks and is jettisoned when at sea. Spent eure may be impossible.
caustic contains many of the by-products
and waste from a refinery that cannot be 5.3.2.7 Working on Petroleum Tankships
safely dumped into estuarial water through
The larger tankships which carry crude oil
the refinery's effluent plant. Spent caustic
round the world often have long voyages
may contain hydrogen sulphide, hydrocar-
and only one day in loading and discharge
bons and other sulphur compounds. It
ports. This me ans most crew members are
must therefore be treated as a high corro-
excessively busy during loading and dis-
sive, toxie and flammable liquid.
charge and that during the long sea voy-
ages they can setde to a routine which may
Hazards. The short-term effect of caustic
become boring. Many of these seafarers
soda is to burn body tissue with which it is
follow creative hobbies in their spare time,
in contact. It is highly corrosive to the skin
but a few find the time difficult to fill and
and the eye, in the crystalline form and
usually decide to leave this kind of job. For
when it is in a water solution. It is also an
anyone who has personal or family prob-
irritant if vapours are breathed which con-
lems, the lines of communication are long
tain caustic soda.
and home seems far away. The importance
Caustic can cause severe bums. It is one
of regular radio-phone calls and mail in
of the worst possible chemicals to get into
preventing breakdowns of all kinds hardly
the eye where it can cause much damage.
needs to be stressed. Coastal tankship sea-
Therefore, when handling caustic, even in
farers face an entirely different set of prob-
weak solutions, eye proteetion must be
lems: the difficulty here may be to get
worn. A tiny splash of concentrated caustic
enough sleep and rest between the ports of
solution in the eye may cause, and has
loading and unloading, and to find time for
caused, loss of sight.
leisure activities.
First Aid. If contamination occurs, imme-
diate showering, with prior and special at- 5.3.3 Chemical Carriers
tention to the eyes, must be carried out to
remove contamination. The eyelids should A wide range of chemicals are transported
be held apart and the eyes washed out with by ships. An "International Maritime Dan-
water for at least 10 min, timed by the gerous Goods Code" and supplements [18]
dock. This step must not be skimped or list the substances and the hazards. IMO
hurried. Unless all traces of the chemical have produced a medical first aid guide for
are removed, burning will continue. Be- use in accidents involving dangerous goods
cause ofthe severe pain, the victim may not [26].
willingly open his eye. The lids must there- In 1971 IMCO published a "Code for
fore be held open while was hing is carried the Construction and Equipment of Ships
out. Carrying Dangerous Chemicals in Bulk".
348 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
Several amendments were published sub- chemical tankers. During the investigated
sequently [5]. period, 35 seafarers suffered from intoxica-
This code contains the technical details tions due to dangerous cargo (from
for the design and operation of chemical 22 tankers), predominantly on board chem-
tankers from safety aspects. The National ical tankers, and five out of seven fatal in-
Academy of Science, USA published a re- toxications occurred on board tankers.
port for the United States Coast Guard on Most chemical injuries of the skin also
the evaluation of the hazards of water happened on board tankers - 43 out of
transportation ofbulk industrial chemicals, 68 cases. Severe chemical bums were com-
indicating in detail the toxicological haz- monest on chemical tankers - 10 out of
ards to crew members [11]. 12 cases. The increase of the rate of chemi-
These documents give most of the infor- cal intoxications was due to an increased
mation which will be required for the safe rate of accidents on board chemical tank-
operation of chemical carriers. ers.
The manifold health problems occurring The problems associated with the carri-
during work on board chemical tankers age of chemicals were discussed at the 2nd
have been descrlbed by several authors (for European Nautical Medical Officers'
example Johnson [20], Trennt [42]). Aseries meeting (1979) in Great Britain. It was em-
of studies performed by several Norwegian phasised that the crews of chemical tankers
authors (Mowe et al. [27]; Riis Simonsen are more exposed to the risk of hazards
[34] and Wermundsen and Mowe [43]) than are the crews of other vessels. The
show results of extensive chemical-techni- Joint ILO/WHO Committee on the Health
cal, safety-technical, physiological and oc- of Seafarers was already in 1974 intensively
cupational medical examinations and a concemed with the question of medical ex-
large variety of detailed individual infor- aminations of tankship crews carrying
mation on the chemical hazards, the health chemicals in bulk [25]. In aresolution the
problems of the crew and the hazards oc- committee recommended that special med-
curring during the process of loading and ical examinations should be given to all
unloading as weIl as on the general load of crew members serving on board chemical
the crew. The biochemical examinations in tankers. These examinations should in-
chemical tanker crews showed quite a clude clinical, laboratory and other tests as
number of abnormal transaminase results. appropriate. FinaIly, it should be remem-
A significant correlation with the length of bered that all chemicals which are carried
service on board chemical tankers could should be identified for what they are -
not be determined. The frequency rate of proprietary names will not do. The hazards
pathological transaminase values was high- must be c1ear to all crew members [40] who
er after 1 or 2 years' service on board than have to load, handle and discharge the
after 10years' service. Of the examined dangerous goods so that appropriate and
seamen, 29% showed abnormal values. A adequate safety precautions can be ap-
large number of the seamen, however, con- plied. Failure to take these elementary and
sumed alcohol and this is known to affect essential steps can have serious conse-
transaminase results. quences.
Following a thorough study of the trans-
port of dangerous cargoes for several years 5.3.4 Occupational Hygiene
within the German Federal merchant fleet Considerations
Zorn et al. [44] and Schepers [36] came to
the result that the biggest risk of intoxica- In tankships and chemical carriers particu-
tions or of chemical injuries of the skin lar attention must be paid to designing in
exists on board tankships, predominantly safety and to designing out hazard. This
5.3 Health Problems on Tankships Carrying Oil, Gas or Bulk Chemicals 349
principle applies, of course, to all ships, hut Work and leisure on oil tankers. In: In. Inter-
is especially important when hazardous national Symposium on Marine Medicine,
Leningrad, 1968. Moscow 1969. pp. 34-36.
cargoes are carried. Coker and Gardner [6] 14. Goethe, H.: Arbeitshygiene auf Tankschiffen.
have produced a set of occupational hy- In: Fragen der Schiffahrtsmedizin. Intern.
giene guidelines for ship construction. Symp., Heiligendamm 28-31 March 1963. Me-
dizinischer Dienst des Verkehrswesens 11.
pp. 89-92.
15. Goethe, H., R.Herrmann, R.Geister et al.: Die
References Frage der toxikologischen Beeinflussung der
Besatzung von Tankschiffen. Eine verglei-
1. Amirov, R.O. and AM.Gasanova: Labour chende Pilotstudie über Tankschiff- und Nicht-
conditions in the oil-tankers and the floating tankschiffahrer. Arbeitsmedizin, Sozialmedizin,
means used in the oil-extracting industry in the Präventivmedizin 11, 2,46-51 (1976).
sea. BuH. Inst. mar. trop. Med. Gdynia 25, 16. Goethe, H.: Gesundheitliche Probleme bei
2-3-4,409-412 (1974). Tankschiffbesatzungen. BuH. Inst. mar. Med.
2. Andreani, D. and E.Strambi: Osservazioni suHa Gdansk 17,3,241-248 (1966).
crasi ematica di marittimi imbarcati su navi- 17. Herrmann, H.: Arbeitsmedizinische Probleme
cisterna (1). Atti dei Centro Studi e ricerche per bei der Seeschiffahrt insbesondere der Tank-
l'assistenza. Sanitaria e sociale dei marittimi schiffahrt. Hansa 103, 14, 1218-1220 (1966).
7-20 (1959). 18. International maritime dangerous goods code.
3. Carter, J. T.: Absence attributed to sickness in Vols. 1-4 and supplements. London: IMCO.
oil tanker crews. Brit. J. industr. Med. 33, 9-12 1972.
(1976). 19. International safety guide for oil tankers and
4. Clark jr. w.R. and C.H.Montgomery: Arctic terminals. London: Witherley 1978.
Tanker Medicine. Ind. Med. 39, 3, 132-136 20. Johnson, J.E.: Safe and efficient operation of
(1970). chemical tankers. Lecture. Symposium "Safety
5. Code for the construction and equipment of of life at sea". Oslo 20-210ct. 1980. Research
ships carrying dangerous chemicals in bulk. program associated with The Royal Norwegian
1977 edition incorporating and amendments. Council for Scientific and Industrial Research.
London: IMCO 1977. System for Sikkert Skip.
6. Coker, D. T. and A Ward Gardner: Occupation- 21. Kirjakov, K., P. Kolkovskij, P. Petrov et al.: Oc-
al health guidelines for ship construction. Ship- cupational petroleum intoxication among tank-
ping World and Shipbuilder 172, 339-341 er fleet crews. BuH. Inst. mar. Med. Gdansk 17,
(1979). 3, 249-254 (1966).
7. Collins, K.J., T. P. Eddy, D.E.Lee et al.: Nutri- 22. Le Chuiton, M., B. Dartigues, J. Blade et al.: In-
tional and environmental studies on an ocean- cidences medicales du naufrage du petrolier
going oil tanker. 1. Thermal environment. Brit. "Boehlen". Mild. et Armees 5, 243-248 (1977).
J. industr. Med. 28, 237-245 (1971). 23. Malizia, E. and M.Cecconi: Consigli terapeuti-
8. Collins, K.J., T. P. Eddy, A Hibbs et al.: Nutri- ci per i marittimi a bordo di navi trasportanti
tional and environmental studies on an ocean- sostanze tossiche. L'Assistenza radio-medica 2,
going oil tanker. 2. Heat acclimatization and pp.12 (1968).
nutrient balances. Brit. J. industr. Med. 28, 24. Matsevich, L. M.: Uslovia truda na neftenaliv-
246-258 (1971). nykh sudakh i mery ikh ozdorovlenia. [Work
9. Duck, B. W.: Some medical aspects of tanker conditions on tankships and steps to their im-
safety. School of Navigation, University of provements.] In: XXIV moskovskaya nauchno-
Southampton 1966. prakticheskaya konferentsia po problemam
10. Eddy, T. P., AL. Stock and E. F. Wheeler: Nutri- promyshlennoy gigieny 1969 g. Ed.: Sektsia gi-
tional and environmental studies on an ocean- gieny truda morskogo nauchnogo gigieniche-
going oil tanker. 3. Energy balances and phy- skogo obshchestva. Moscow 1969. pp. 115-116.
sique. Brit. J. industr. Med. 28, 330-341 (1971). 25. Medical examinations of crew members on
11. Evaluation of the hazards of bulk water trans- tankers carrying chemicals in bulk. Report of
portation of industrial chemicals. A tentative the joint ILO/WHO committee on health of
guide. Revised edition. Committee on Hazar- seafarers. Geneva: WHO Executive Board
dous Materials. Washington, D.C.: National 1974. pp. 6-7.
Academy of Sciences 1970. 26. Medical First aid guide for use in accidents in-
12. Farrel1, T.R. and C.Eng: Chemical tankers - volving dangerous goods. (MFAG). Chemical
the quiet evolution. The Royal Institution of Supplement to the International Medical
Naval Architects 147-165 (1974). Guide for Ships (IMGS). London: IMO 1982.
13. Gasanova, AM., N. G. Trifel and P.J. Datiev: 27. Mowe, G., O. R. Simonsen and B. Wermundsen:
350 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
Sj0folk i kjemikaliefart. Hovedprosjektet delI. govskij et al.: Changes in the functional state of
Kjemiske milj0 - og helseproblemer blant the cardio-vascular system and electrolytic me-
mannskap pä skip som frakter flytende kjemi- tabolism in the body adaption process during
kalier i bulk. HD 7101770701. Oslo: Yrkeshy- voyages on liquid gas carrier vessels. BuH. Inst.
gienisk Institutt 1974. pp. 162. mar. trop. Med. Gdynia 25, 2-3-4, 415-419
28. Nakamura, F.: Health status of ocean-going oil (1974).
tanker seamen. BuH. Tokyo med. dent. Univ. 20, 38. Shishlovskaya, K. Ya., B. Ya. Brodskaya,
3, 221-224 (1973). O. V. Verzilova et al.: Hygienic requirements for
29. Nikilov, S. H. and P. V. Nefeudov: About the cleaning operations on tankers. BuH. Inst. mar.
health measures in tanker fleet. In: VII Interna- trop. Med. Gdynia 25, 2-3-4, 300-302 (1974).
tional symposium on marine medicine, Odessa 39. Svedung, 1.: Air quality on board a tanker. In:
23-30 Sept. 1976. Moscow 1976. p.249. Human factors in the design and operation of
30. Page, R. c.: Bulk carriage of liquid chemicals by ships. Proceedings of the First International
sea. Ann. Occup. Hyg. 14, 205-211 (1971). Conference on Human Factors in the Design
31. Page, R.C. and A W Gardner: Petroleum tank- and Operation of Ships. Gothenburg, February
ship safety. London: Maritime Press 1971. 1977. Stockholm: Garmat Service 1978.
32. Paulsen, J.: Gasskipet som arbeidsplass - prak- pp. 633-653.
tisk erfaring med samarbeid meHom sjö og 40. Threshold limit values for chemical substances
land. In: Foredrag ved 3S-konferansen om sik- and physical agents in the workrooms environ-
kerhet til sjös, Oslo, 21 November 1978. ment. Cincinnati: ACCIH.
pp. 70-76. (System for Sikkert Skip. Rapport 41. Tomaszunas, S., J. Uselis, A Krynicki et al.:
78/4). Working conditions on tankers and seamen
33. Proceedings of the second European nautical health. BuH. Inst. mar. Med. Gdansk 16, 3/4,
medical officers meeting held in the United 209-218 (1965).
Kingdom, West Sussex, 10-14 September 1979. 42. Trennt, W: Uns Scheep. Probleme der Chemi-
London 1980. kalienfahrt. Das Tankschiff vom Rohöl zur
34. Riis Simonsen, 0.: Sjöfolk i kjemikaliefart. Ho- Phosphorsäure. Lecture. Nautischer Verein
vedprosjektet dei 11. Tekniskhygieniske under- Kiel. 28.11. 1974. p.5.
sökelser om bord paa 19 skip som frakter fly- 43. Wermundsen, B. and G.Mowe: Sj0folk i kjemi-
tende kjemikalier i bulk. HD 7091770701. Oslo: kaliefart. En yrkeshygienisk og medisinsk un-
Yrkeshygienisk Institutt 1974. ders0kelse vedmrende transport av flytende
35. Rodahl, K., ABoliing and O.Tenfjord: Ar- kjemikalier i bulk pä norske skip. Rapport fra
beidsfysiologiske undersökelser paa MIT Texa- forprosjektet 1973-1974. Oslo: Yrkeshygienisk
co Bergen. Oslo. (System for Sikkert Skip). Institutt 1975.
36. Schepers, B.-F.: Gesundheitsgefährdung durch 44. Zorn, E., B.-F.Schepers and H.Goethe: Ge-
Chemikalien an Bord deutscher Seeschiffe un- sundheitsgefährdung durch Chemikalien an
ter besonderer Berücksichtigung gefährlicher Bord deutscher Seeschiffe unter besonderer
Ladung. Dissertation, University of Hamburg Berücksichtigung gefährlicher Ladung. Zbl. Ar-
1978. beitsmed. 30,1,12-19 (1900).
37. Shafran, L. M., E. B. Yanushevskaya, V.I. Vi-
5.4 The Fishing Fleet
R. R. Renfrew
acuity, using aids if necessary, sufficient to The Comission of the European Com-
allow them to carry out their duties effi- munities has recently published a study of
ciently. When visual aids are worn, spares the accidents to fis hermen which were re-
should be carried on each trip to sea. ported during the years from 1977 to 1980
Further medical examinations should be [4]. This study was intended to involve eight
undertaken at regular intervals and also af- countries, an of which have active modem
ter injury or serious or prolonged illness. fishing fleets. Unfortunately, two countries
This will not only ensure that good stan- failed to supply returns and one did not
dards of fitness are maintained but that supply returns after 1978. In an 6731 acci-
early detection of physical and mental ill- dents were reported and analysed over the
ness takes place. Those conditions co m- 4-year period. It must be accepted that an
mon in the industry - gastritis and peptic accidents were not reported as there are
ulcer, bronchitis, hypertension and the fluctuations in the numbers from year to
sequelae of excessive consumption of alco- year which could not be accounted for by
hol - are easily detected by clinical ex ami- better safety standards.
nation. The published figures show that one-
Medical standards for merchant se amen third of an the accidents are the results of
are discussed in Chap.5.1. As fishing is falls and slips on board, whilst another
known to be more hazardous and arduous third involve the fishing gear. A high pro-
than service with the merchant fleets, there portion of the accidents take pi ace during
is no valid reason why these standards the fishing operation when the deck crews,
should not also be applied to fishermen. which form the bulk of the men at risk, are
at work, and on the working deck space of
5.4.2 Accidents the ships where most of the activities con-
nected with the fis hing operation take
Fishing is known to be one of the most place.
hazardous of occupations. The Standard Hands and fingers suffer most frequent
Mortality Ratio (SMR) gives an estimate of injury whilst contusions, sprains and frac-
the occupational risk after standardising tures are the commonest results of trauma.
for age. This was calculated for an fishing Most accidents occur when the injured
vessels in the U. K. far the years 1959 to person has been at work continuously for
1963 and covered the age groups from 15 to 2-4 h, which may indicate an element of fa-
64 years. For fis hermen, the SMR was tigue, and the bulk of them occur during
found to be 1726, whilst for coal miners in' the daylight hours. This latter finding is of
the comparable period, the figure was 373 little significance as a high proportion of
(Schilling et al. [5]). The SMR for fishermen ships fish only during the hours of daylight.
represents a risk factor of 17 against the The figures do not suggest that inexperi-
male working population within the same ence or increasing age result in higher acci-
age groups. These findings are not solely dent rates, as would be expected.
confined to the United Kingdom. Joensen Again contrary to expectations, the high-
[3], reviewing the literature, claims that the est percentage of accidents occurs during
mortality rate amongst British and Danish wind farces of 0 to 3 (wind speeds of less
fis hermen is considerably higher than than ,1 knot to 7-1 0 knots) and in sea state
amongst workers in any other trade whilst of 0 to 3 (wave heights from flat calm to
Goethe and Vuksanovic [1] have shown 17'3 ft), that is, during very good weather
that the accident rates amongst German conditions. In bad weather the ships cease
fishermen were two and a half times high er fishing and ride out the gales and the men
than those in their merchant fleet in the who were asked all stated that during bad
period 1954 to 1972. weather they were more aware of the
5.4 The Fishing Fleet 353
dangers and tended to take a lot more 5.4.3 General Medical Problems
care.
Excessive fatigue considerably increases Schilling et al. [5], writing on the mortality
the possibility of accidents in any hazard- of fishermen in Great Britain, gave the fol-
ous occupation and slips and falls are often lowing standardised mortality ratios for
the result of muscle fatigue. Whilst there is fis hermen for the period 1959 to 1963 for
no doubt that fishermen remain on duty for England and Wales:
longer periods than many shore workers, Coronary he art disease 130
modern fishing vessels are designed to cut Hypertension 215
down the amount of physical effort which Cancer ofthe lung and bronchus 191
must be undertaken by the crews. Hydrau- Cancer ofthe stomach 189
lically operated power rollers and strategi- Accidents not at work including
cally placed winches take away much of Suicide 169
the back-breaking work. The ropes, wires Bronchitis 147
and nets are rolled on to drums when out
of the water and so constitute less risk to The authors also reported a tendency for
the men. Notwithstanding these factors, the men to suffer from gastro-intestinal ill-
fis hing is still hard work. The period spent ness, notably gastritis and peptic u1cer, pos-
on deck depends on the time taken to haul, sibly attributable to a combination of over-
to carry out any net repairs and to shoot the indulgence in a1cohol and tobacco and to
ge ar once again, together with the time tak- stress. The SMRs, where available for
en to gut, wash, sort and stow the fish. Scotland showed appreciable variatidn at-
When the decks are cleared up, me als and tributable to the difference in fishing meth-
rest periods can be taken before the next ods between the individual countries of the
haul takes place. The number of daily U. K. Since the publication of the figures in
hauls varies considerably with the type of 1969, tremendous changes have taken
vessel. Some ships fish through the whole pi ace within the industry in the U. K. and
24 hours, when a system of duty watches is these figures can no longer be an accurate
employed, whilst others, usually the small- reflection of the pattern of disease amongst
er ships, fish during the hours of daylight fishermen. However, they do give a clear
and anehor for the night. Rest periods, indication of the necessity of regular physi-
therefore, tend to be short and broken cal examination for all fis hermen for early
which results in increasing fatigue over th~ detection of disease.
whole trip. The Report on Trawler Safety To the above list should be added the
1969 [6] recognised these factors and rec- problems associated with obesity. Skippers
ommended that, whatever the type of fish- and engineers in trawlers are usually over-
ing, crewmen should be allowed at least 6 h weight. Their duties confine them to the
of unbroken rest daily, and that they bridge or engine room, their exercise is very
should have shore leave between trips of at limited and, often, they are unable to go be-
least 2lh days. In practice, at present, crews low for proper meals and so they exist on
have more than 60 h shore time between tea and sandwiches of monstrous propor-
trips. This allows for not only adequate rest tions. This regime inevitably gives rise to
but for the men to catch up with their social obesity and is, in turn, linked to hyperten-
and family life. Rest periods for countries sion. It is very noticeable that, where skip-
other than the U. K. are prescribed, some pers are involved in the fis hing operations,
by law and others by agreement. In France as in the smaller vessels, obesity is not a
there is a minimum of 8 h rest whilst on the problem.
fis hing grounds, in Germany, 8 hand in
Iceland, 12 h.
354 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
5.4.4 Diseases Specific to Fishermen dried and dressed with 10% ichthammol
(ammonium sulpho-ichthyolate) in glycer-
Probably the commonest conditions found ine, twice daily. Alternatively after washing
amongst fishermen are various types of and drying, the lesions can be swabbed
skin lesions, notably those caused by infec- with spirit and then covered with a dry
tions and allergies and some by infesta- dressing. Antibiotics are usually unneces-
tions. Facilities for washing may be primi- sary unless large boils develop.
tive in the smaller ships whilst in the larger Prevention consists of thorough washing
vessels the use of such facilities is limited of the wrists and hands at the end of each
because of the need to conserve the avail- watch on deck. The cuffs of waterproof
able fresh water supplies. Although sea wa- clothing should be scrubbed with fresh wa-
ter is readily available, special sea water ter inside and out at regular intervals, and
soaps are necessary for adequate cleansing when the cuffs become badly worn or
of the skin. Ordinary domestic dishwash- cracked the garment should be repaired or
ing detergents are effective with sea water discarded.
and are commonly used by the fishermen
for hand washing. In susceptible people 5.4.4.2 Dogger Bank Itch or Curly Weed
this can carry a risk of establishing dermati- Rash
tis. This is a contact eczematous dermatitis
The hands are always vulnerable to found amongst the men who fish in the
pricks from wire strands, fish bones and North Sea. The causal agent is a seaweed-
fish spines and when, as a result of these, like Alcyonidium, known to fishermen as
infection from the fish slime is carried into 'curly weed', which grows in shallow wa-
the deeper tissues, septic lesions of varying ters. It is found in profusion in the Dogger
degrees of severity ensue. This type of inju- Bank area, hence the derivation of the
ry is so commonplace that it is usually ig- name, but it has spread to the waters offthe
nored but adequate cleansing and a first West of Scotland and to some parts of
aid dressing could prevent much morbidi- Greenland and Norway. The disease oc-
ty. curs in men who have become sensitised
Antibiotics are now carried on most whilst fishing in the North Sea but it has
ships and their use has drastically cut down been seen in those women who are employ-
the number of cases of palmar space infec- ed ashore to clean and repair certain types
tions which have to be dealt with. of nets used in that area. The process of
5.4.4.1 Salt Water Boils sensitisation can take many years or it can
occur after only a few trips but, once estab-
Grit and sand brought up in the nets, to- lished, even if the man is kept ashore it re-
gether with dried salt, lodges in the cuffs of quires only brief contact with fishing gear
the waterproof clothing worn by fishermen . used in the area to precipitate an attack.
and causes chafing and minute abrasiops' Deep water fishermen are only rarely af-
of the skin of the wrists and the backs bf fected but ifthey are, history taking will re-
the hands which become infected. veal that they have fished at some time in
The condition appears first as multiple the areas of the North Sea in which the
small irritating papules on the wrists and 'weed' grows and that they have recently
the dorsum of the hands. These soon be- been fishing in the other areas mentioned
come pustules and some enlarge further to above. The curly weed is prevalent during
form boils. The whole area becomes in- the months between March and November
flamed, indurated and painful. and it is during this time that the majority
Treatment. The area affected should be of new cases occur. The rash usually ap-
thoroughly washed with soap and water, pears as a dermatitis affecting the dorsum
5.4 The Fishing Fleet 355
of the hands, the wrists and the forearms. thrix rhusiopathiae, which is found in fish
Once established, further contact causes slime. The area around the minor wo und
the rash to spread to the face, especially to becomes inflamed. The inflammation
the forehead and around the eyes. Oedema spreads rapidly and the lesions c10sely re-
of this area and conjunctival inflammation semble erysipelas although the oedema is
are features at this stage. Ultimately, the not so marked. Lymphangitis and lymph-
whole body may become involved. adenitis are often a feature.
The parts affected are itchy, reddened,
oedematous and often excoriated. When
Treatment. The treatment of choice is pen-
icillin, either oral or by injection. If oral
the rash becomes eczematous, the weeping
and drying of the area causes painful penicillin is used, it is best to give double
the standard dose for the first 48 h. Patients
cracks to appear in the skin.
allergic to penicillin should be given co-tri-
moxazole (each tab let contains trimetho-
Treatment. The only effective treatment is
to remove the patient from all further con- prim 80 mg and sulphmethoxazone
400mg).
tact with the curly weed and it is usual to
advise transfer to ships fis hing in deep wa- Prevention. As with other skin complaints
ters. In the early stages, the rash will c1ear originating from fish slime, thorough skin
up when the man comes ashore for a short c1eansing is the best method of prevention.
period, but, in established cases, further
treatment will be required. 5.4.4.4 Haddock Rash
Treatment on board is by the administra-
This condition is fairly common in those
tion of an antihistaminic drug and the ap-
areas where the preponderance ofthe catch
plication of hydrocortisone ointment 1% to
consists of haddock. These fish seem to in-
the affected part. The conjunctivitis will be
gest grit when fee ding and when gutting is
relieved by the use of ß-methasone sodium
carried out on large numbers of fish, this
phosphate 0.1 % eye drops with or without
grit abrades unprotected skin and these
neomycin. In established cases a daily bath
abrasions become infected. The lesions are
to which is added 20 ml of liquor picis car-
seen as inflamed weeping areas between
bonis is recommended, together with the
application of an ointment made up as fol- the fingers and on the backs of the hands.
lows: Treatment. The affected part should be well
washed before the application of dressings
Liquor picis carbonis 2%
and antibiotics should be given.
Ung. hydrocortisone 1% 25%
Ung. aquosum to 100% Prevention. The condition can be prevented
by the use of protective gloves. Thick plas-
Further contact with curly weed must be
tic gloves are better than cotton gloves but
avoided. Oral steroids are rarely necessary
they must be in asound condition to pre-
in the treatment of this condition.
vent the grit getting through to the skin.
5.4.4.3 Fish Erysipeloid
This skin disease normally occurs during 5.4.4.5 Acute Tenosynovitis of the Wrist
the warmer months of the year. Although (Jumbo Wrist)
most frequently seen in the fish process When the fisherman returns to sea after a
workers ashore, it is not unknown at sea. long period ashore or where he is involved
The disease arises from infection intro- in prolonged gutting following large hauls
duced by minor pricks and ab ras ions of fish, the repetitive movements required
caused by the bones and spines of fish. The by the gutting operation may cause teno-
causal organism is commonly Erysipelo- synovitis of the wrist.
356 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
In order to gut a fish efficiently, the fish enters the eye it sets up an intense irritation.
isheld at the tail section, ventral side up- The conjunctivae become rapidly infected
wards, by one hand, whilst with the other and soon subconjunctival oedema occurs.
hand the knife is inserted into the abdomen The selera then appears to be covered by
and an incision is made right up to the red blisters and there is marked photo-
head of the fish. This involves a movement phobia and pain. Later the eyes elose up.
of the wrist through an arc of about 75 de- Treatment. Immediate treatment is to wash
grees. A similar movement is made to cut the eyes with either warm plain water or
out and remove the guts, liver and the dor- with normal saline. Eyedrops containing ß-
sal vein. Constant repetition of this move- methasone sodium phosphate 0.1% w/v
ment causes the inflammation of the ten- and neomycin sulphate 0.5% w/v should
don sheath. be instilled three or four times daily until
There is localised pain, swelling and the condition subsides.
crepitus, usually in the dorsum of the hand
and wrist. The grating can be felt by the ex- 5.4.4.7 Poisonous Stings
amin er when he lays his hand on the affect-
ed part and asks the patient to flex and Fishing in the warmer waters of the tropics
dorsiflex the wrist. and subtropics is not without additional
hazards. Certain fish, jelly-fish, marine
Treatment. The only effective treatment is growths and sea snakes can produce pain-
immobilisation of the hand and wrist. This ful and often major reactions in the fisher-
can be done conveniently at sea, using a man coming into contact with or being
padded splint, whilst ashore the treatment bitten or stung by them.
of choice is a scaphoid pIaster cast. Im- Doctors in these areas are well experi-
mobilisation should be continued for enced in dealing with casualties from these
7 -1 0 days. An elastic adhesive bandage ap- bites and stings and although these condi-
plied from the hand to just below the elbow tions are mentioned for the sake of com-
will relieve the symptoms and support the pleteness, no attempt will be made to ad-
part but the patient must not be allowed to vise specific treatment other than to say
continue gutting, otherwise the condition that in the event of collapse, normal resus-
will be aggravated and the period of im- citative manoeuvres should be undertaken.
mobilisation will be prolonged. The condi-
tion frequently recurs after further periods 5.4.5 Medical Training
of heavy fishing and gutting.
Unlike workers ashore, the fisherman at
5.4.4.6 Fishermen's Conjunctivitis sea does not have ready access to medical
Whilst the nets are being dragged along the aid and hospitals. Consequently, he must
bottom of the sea, they collect not only fish be prepared to deal with any accident or
but stones and boulders and various types medical emergency until such aid can be
of marine growths. obtained.
A particular type of marine benthos re- As a life-endangering situation, which
sembles a suet dumpling and has finger- requires immediate treatment, may arise in
like structures protruding from it. These any part of a ship at any time, it is essential
growths are known by colloquial names that all fis hermen be given a basic first aid
such as tits or duffs by the fishermen. training, preferably as part of an induction
As the net is brought on board, the course. This training should inelude the ar-
weight of the contents ruptures these rest ofbleeding from various sites, artificial
growths and a fluid containing microscopic respiration and the treatment ofthe uncon-
silicaceous partieles is released. If this fluid scious patient.
5.4 The Fishing Fleet 357
All fishing vessel officers should be giv- trauma. Illness can strike any member of
en further medieal training, based either on the crew at any time as in any community
their own country's medical guide for sea- but medieal assistance is available only
farers or on the International Medieal through a radiomedical adviee facility. The
Guide for Ships, as part of the courses doctor's ability to come to a diagnosis then
leading to the award of certificates of com- depends entirely on the observations of a
petency. The length of the courses and the layman. Unfortunately, there is no interna-
depth of the training can be varied in ac- tionaHy agreed standard of medieal train-
cordance with the certificate of competen- ing for ships' officers nor indeed of medi-
cy whieh is awarded. When fishing activity cal stores whieh must be carried on fishing
is restricted to coastal waters and prompt vessels and on whieh a crewman's life may
medieal assistance is available, the degree depend.
of training need not be so great as when no This was realised by the member states
restrictions are imposed. of the E. E. C. and some 9 years aga a
The aim of the training is to give ships' Working Group of Maritime Medieal ex-
officers such knowledge as is required in perts was set up under the auspiees of the
order to provide care for siek or injured Joint Committee on Social Problems in Sea
crew members, either until they are fit or Fishing to study means of harmonising the
until they can be put under medieal care medieal scales carried on fishing vessels,
ashore, to make proper use of the radio- medieal standards for new entrants to the
medieal adviee facilities available for sea- industry, regular medical examinations for
farers and to prevent the spread of disease ships' crews to ensure that the men can car-
on board. ry out their duties without detriment to
When the course is taken at, or in asso- themselves or the safety of the ship and fi-
ciation with, a hospital, those organising nally to produce an acceptable training syl-
the course must monitor the content care- labus to cover the treatment of both injury
fuHy as there is a danger that the staff will and illness.
give instruction in practices suitable for a During the discussions, it emerged that
hospital situation but totally unsuitable for even within the member states of the
a small ship. E. E. C., medical standards varied consider-
ably. Some countries require a thorough
5.4.6 International Standards pre-employment medical examination and
of Medical Care chest X-rays whilst others have no such re-
quirement. Some countries produce a com-
In the interest of safety at sea, each major plex medical guide whilst others have a
country of the world lays down standards simple guide, virtuaHy a first aid manual,
of competence in seamanship and naviga- and rely on the International Medical
tion which must be attained before a man is Guide for Ships (IMGS) [2] for further in-
aHowed to take command of avessei sail- formation. Some countries have long medi-
ing out of sight of land. These standards cal training for officers, some of it in a hos-
vary little from country to country and they pital setting to varying standards according
apply to smaH fishing vessels just as much to their professional ticket and taken as a
as to the large ocean-going ship. The crew block course. Others have hour-Iong lec-
of a fishing vessel is a smaH community tures at weekly intervals throughout their
whieh, from the minute it leaves its horne professional training period. The contents
port until it returns, is not only subject to of medical chests vary from one country to
the rigours imposed by the environment another and the drugs supplied in them
but by the very nature of the work under- vary in accordance with medical teaching
taken by that crew, has a very high risk of in the country concerned.
358 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
5.5.2 Females and the Ship's The highest absolute and relative figures
Community occurred in 1965. That year, 259 were re-
patriated, representing 4.3% ofthe total fe-
Why do women seek employment at sea? male population in overseas service. Later
For several reasons - some like to join their on, there was a steady decrease and the fig-
husbands who are seafarers, some want to ures reached the lowest level in 1980, with
travel and see the world, others have more 21 and 0.5% respectively [1]. This substan-
practical reasons - they need money. Some tial reduction is certainly a result of the
make a few trips, others become profes- common use of contraceptives.
sional seafarers. They will, on board, face a There is no doubt that, whatever prob-
5.5 The Female Seafarer 361
Table 3. Distribution, by major disease eategory, of females and males signed off siek from Norwegian
ships in overseas service between 1954 and 1970
lems the women may have created, they There are hardly any reliable statistical
have been greatly beneficial to the ship's data available conceming diseases among
community and have contributed largely to seamen (Vuksanovic and Goethe [20]) and
normalizing the life on board and helping this is even more the case with female sea-
to make the atmosphere more sober and farers. One of the very few sets of data re-
homelike [4]. lates to Norwegian women [2]. Ouring the
Today, women are received on board 17-year period 1954-1970, 20028 women
without objections, even if they are not al- and 148261 men were signed off sick and
ways accepted as equal partners. Women repatriated from ships in overseas service.
from the countries of the Third World will, The main diagnostic categories are pre-
however, be unable to work on ships regis- sented in Table 3.
tered in those countries. Their status in The women who were repatriated consti-
their own community makes it impossible. tute a heterogeneous group with regard to
the seriousness of the diseases. Some of
them had to be admitted to hospitals imme-
5.5.3 Health Problems diately. Others were able to stay at horne
while undergoing treatment. They had one
5.5.3.1 Merchant Marine
feature in common: the ships' masters were
Health problems are reflected in morbidity unable to accept the responsibility for fur-
and mortality rates. Without access to these ther treatment on board. It should be re-
data it is difficult to make an evaluation of membered that this occupational group
the risks and hazards for women working consists of mainly young and healthy wom-
at sea and to take the necessary preventive en who had passed a careful medical ex-
steps. amination before they signed on.
362 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
The figures in Tables 3 indicate that the sion into four subgroups disclosed that
seven major categories - accounting for neuroses and maladjustment were by far
about 80% of the discharged - were dis- the largest and that diagnoses relating to
eases of the genito-urinary system, mental personal disorders such as psychoses and
diseases, diseases of the musculoskeletal alcoholism occurred less frequently. This
system, diseases of the respiratory system, was in sharp contrast to Norwegian male
diseases of the digestive system, complica- seafarers who presented a picture which
tions of pregnancy and childbirth, and ac- was completely opposite. Schuckit and
cidents, in that order. Hoiberg made a Gunderson [18] report in a study of psychi-
study of the health care needs of women in atric incidence rates for navy (US) women
the (U. S.) navy, based on the hospitaliza- that the psychiatric hospitalization rate for
tion rates during the years 1966-1975 (Hoi- enlisted women in the period 1966-1969
berg [7]). They were young women selected was four times higher than for enlisted
for military service and under constant men. The diagnostic distribution for both
medical observation. Although these two sexes corresponded to that of Norwegian
groups are not quite comparable, it is inter- seafarers referred to above. Discussing the
esting to note that there are many points of disparity between the sexes, Schuckit and
resemblance between them regarding the Gunderson [18] point to four possible ex-
distribution of the main diagnostic catego- planations: selection of young single wom-
ries. en who have a tendency to es cape difficul-
It is no surprise that the Norwegian data ties at horne, the rigid life in the navy,
showed that diseases of the genito-urinary certain inbom biological factors in women
system headed the list for the female sea- and a tendency to hospitalize even minor
farers, the rate of 15.2% being in accor- cases - and an interaction between the
dance with the distribution in the general four. Obviously, there are some striking
population (Fugelli [6]). Abortions and similarities between life and work in the
menstruation abnormalities were not re- navy and in the merchant marine.
corded separately, but are, by experience, Diseases of the respiratory, musculo-
very common. In a study of 148 Wave (na- skeletal and digestive systems are major
val) recruits, Boehm and Salemo [3] report categories, just as in the general population
that 72 (48.6%) indicated that they had (Fugelli [6]). A substantial reduction of dis-
menstruation abnormalities: 60 amenor- eases of the digestive system has taken
rhea 7 metrorrhagia and 5 metrorrhagia place during the period, while the other
and amenorrhea. Normal menstruation re- categories have remained fairly constant.
sumed after 3-4 months on average. Mi- Accidents are less frequent among wom-
chalk [12] reports that one-third of all fe- en because they work in more sheltered
male process workers in fis hing vessels ex- surroundings. Offer-Ohlsen [15] records
perienced similar irregularities on their first that by far the greatest number of accidents
sea voyage. Irregularities of this kind occur occur on deck and in the engine room
rather frequently during stressful periods while only a small proportion happen in
of adjustment. the catering department.
Diseases of the genito-urinary system Skin diseases constitute a rather small
and complications of pregnancy and child- but important group. Frequent contact
birth accounted for 25% of all women with detergents may cause dermatitis and
signed off sick. eczema which may finally result in unfit-
The second largest category in the Nor- ness for work at sea.
wegian study is mental diseases (diseases The remaining categories, including neo-
of the nervous system constitute a small plasms and diseases of the circulatory sys-
fraction only of the total number). A divi- tem, are rare. This is not surprising. Women
5.5 The Female Seafarer 363
Table 4. Data on the Norwegian females and males who signed off siek from ships in overseas service
during the years 1964-1970
suffering from serious or chronie diseases is difficult and requires special equipment
should not be permitted to work at sea. whieh is not available on board. One can
understand the reluctance of masters fac-
Any Differences Between the Sexes? ing the examination and treatment of these
As indieated in Table 3, there are some patients. Secondly, the women cannot eas-
striking differences between the sexes. Ac- ily be replaced in their capacities on board.
cidents and diseases of the digestive system This applies to radio officers as weIl as staff
account for more than 40% of the men who in the catering department. This observa-
signed off siek, compared with less than tion seems to indicate that during this peri-
20% of women. Four times as many men od women were signed off siek more fre-
were signed off siek from infectious dis- quently than men even if they suffered
eases, including venereal diseases, and from minor disorders. Since the last de-
twiee as many from diseases of the circula- cade, no statistical data have been available
tory system. What happens to seafarers either from Norway or any other country.
who fall siek on board? How many can be It is therefore not possible to draw any con-
treated on board, and how many have to be clusions as to the general validity of this
signed off? Are there any differences be- observation.
tween the sexes in this respect?
For the years 1964-1970, figures are 5.5.3.2 Fishing Vessels
available giving details of the total popula- Since 1960, the German Democratic Re-
tion on Norwegian ships in overseas ser- public has employed women as process
vice, as weIl as the number who signed off workers on fishing factory vessels owing to
siek [1, 2]. The figures are recorded in the shortage ofmale workers. In 1960, only
Table4. seven were employed. The number reached
As indieated in Table 4, women were a maximum of 120 in 1969 and then slowly
signed off siek twice as often as men, 25% decreased to 114 in 1970 and 107 in 1971
compared with 11 %-13%. This is a striking (Stiewe [19]). The work was hard: standing
difference. How can this disparity be ex- at process machines and conveyer belts,
plained? Certainly, there are at least two lifting, carrying and piling cases of about
possible explanations. First of aIl: ships' 15 kg at high speed. The working condi-
masters are obviously less familiar with fe- tions were uncomfortable, the temperature
male than with male illness. Instruction low, the humidity high, the illumination be-
and practice in gynaecology and obstetries low standard and the noise level very high.
are typically inadequate and theoretical. The movement of the ships, particularly in
The clinical examination of these patients rough weather conditions, made work most
364 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
stressful. The working days were 12 h in infections of different kinds. Medhus [11]
two shifts of 6 h each without pauses. The examined the demand for health services
journeys lasted 2-3 months (Stiewe [19]; on six ships with mixed crews. The majori-
Michalk [12]; Marschall and Kersten [10]). ty of the cases were infections and, of 124
The women employed belonged to the age different drugs which were dispensed, 83,
group 18-35. Work physiology tests had in- or 66.9%, were antibiotics. The medicine
dicated that women in this age group pos- chest should therefore contain a suitable
sessed the maximum work capacity (Stiewe selection of these.
[19]). Before they signed on they went Of the special female disorders, vaginal
through a careful medical (and gynaeco- bleeding is rather common either as a
logical) examination. symptom of infection or organic disease of
The most frequent diseases among the the internal genital organs or in connection
female crew members were accidents and with abortions. Stress situations may pro-
diseases of the musculoskeletal system, di- duce menstruation irregularities. Child-
gestive system, skin and respiratory sys- birth on board is rare. Ergometrine is the
tems (Oschatz [16]; Müller [13]). They had a drug of choice to use in many of these cases
higher incidence of diseases than the men, and should be included in the medicine
and their average morbidity rate was 4.4 chest.
compared with 2.5 for the men (Kersten
[9]). Their loss of working days was also 5.5.5 Standards of Fitness
higher (Stiewe [19]).
The men expressed dissatisfaction with Some maritime insurance companies had
the fern ale workers. In case of sickness they established their own standards of fitness
had to be replaced by men who were able (e.g. in Norway) before ILO passed Con-
to do any type of work on board while the vention no.73 dealing with the medical ex-
women could work only in the galley. amination of seamen. At the end of 1981
Some authors recommend, after 10 28 countries had ratified this Convention.
years' experience, that women should grad- Among them are important maritime coun-
ually be replaced by male workers. They tries such as Argentine, Belgium, Canada,
consider the work to be too hard for them Denmark, Finland, France, West Germany,
(Stiewe [19]; Marschall and Kersten [10]). Italy, Japan, The Netherlands, Norway,
Panama, Poland, Portugal, Spain, Sweden,
5.5.4 Medical Provisions the Soviet Union and Yugoslavia, but not
Greece, Liberia, the United Kingdom or
A ship must be self-supporting to a great the U.S.A.
extent and this includes the medical ser- According to the rules of this Conven-
vices. With a few exceptions, ships' masters tion, every person who is going to sign on a
are responsible for care and treatment of ship must produce a medical certificate
the sick and injured. They have at their dis- which states that he/she is fit for service at
posal a medicine chest with a certain selec- sea. He/she must not be suffering from a
tion of medical equipment, bandages, disease which can a) endanger the health of
drugs, etc. The contents of this chest are the other persons on board, b) be aggravat-
subject to regulations ofthe various nation- ed during the service or render hirn/her
al health authorities and vary a great deal. unfit for further work at sea.
Should the chest contain any equipment A person serving on deck must have sat-
or drugs particularly for women? Typical isfactory colour vision, power of vision and
female disorders are diseases of the genito- hearing. A health certificate is valid for
urinary system and complications of preg- 2 years, a certificate for colour vision for
nancy. The majority ofthese conditions are 6years.
5.5 The Female Seafarer 365
The framework of the Convention is and engineers are busy planning the future
settled by ILO. It is left to the different ship with a crew of 10-12. Many compa-
countries to work out the details and their nies have cut the sailing time to
own standards of fitness. As a rule, women 2-4 months. In the near future, ships may
as well as men suffering from serious or be operated by two regular crews who re-
chronic diseases should not be permitted to lieve each other and have a sailing time of
sign on. The following examples may serve 1-2 months. In the offshore industry, the
as an illustration: personality disorders, period of service is 2-6 weeks on and
psychoses (even after recovery), severe 2-6 weeks off according to the position of
cases of neurosis, alcoholism and drug ad- the vessel.
dictions, chronic polyarthritis, bronchial The seafarer will mainly be engaged in
asthma and myocardial infarction. New safety work and practically no mainte-
applicants should be assessed strictly ac- nance work will be carried out. The days of
cording to the rules while professional sea- hard physical work will nearly have come
farers may be given an individual assess- to an end, but on these ships there will be
me nt. few opportunities for social activities - and
It is particularly important that seafarers the work at sea will be less attractive than it
on modern ships have a satisfactory health used to be.
standard. The crew is reduced to such a de- What will the opportunities be for fe-
gree that there is no spare capacity and males on these future ships? They will cer-
work is so specialized that a person can tainly work in the catering department as
hardly be replaced. In the first ever pub- they have done for decades, but we may ex-
lished work-Ioad study in seafaring person- pect to find them in greater numbers in oth-
nei, Israeli et al. [8] found that the physical er capacities as well, as navigators and as
work-Ioad in catering staff was unexpect- engineers. There is already a decline in the
edly high. Recently Rodahl [17] drew atten- recruitment to the merchant marine in
tion to the fact that women working in the some countries and this fact may offer
catering department have a heavy work- them an additional opportunity.
load for extended periods, corresponding
to 30%-50% of their maximum physical
work capacity. A work-Ioad test might have References
been desirable in these cases but was con-
1. Aarsberetning for 1964-1980 for Direktoratet
sidered to be impossible to carry out. How-
for sjömenn [Oslo]. Bergen: Reklametrykk
ever, these women ought to be in good 1965-1981.
physical condition. 2. Aarsmelding og regnskap 1964-1970. Trygde-
kassen for sjömenn i utenriks fart.
3. Boehm, F. H. and N.J. Salemo: Menstrual ab-
5.5.6 The Future normalities in the Wave recruit population. Mil-
it. Med. 138,30-31 (1973).
Greater changes in design and specializa- 4. Female personne1 aboard ship: Habitability de-
tion have taken place during the last 2-3 sign considerations (Report of FY 73 findings).
decades than ever before. New technical Washington: Naval Ship Engineering Center.
Department of the Navy 1974.
equipment such as the computer have been
5. Fraser, S.: Nurse at sea. Can. Nurse 67, 17-19
introduced and have changed conditions (1971).
on board fundamentally. Anti-collision 6. Fugelli, P.: Helsetilstand og helsetjeneste paa
systems and unmanned engine rooms have Väröy og Röst. Oslo: Universitetsforlaget 1978.
been in operation for some time. 7. Hoiberg, A.: Health care needs ofwomen in the
Navy. Milit. Med. 144,2,103-109 (1979).
During the last three decades, the size of 8. Israeli, R., M. Weinstein and D. Süssmann: Un-
the crew has been reduced from 50 to 20 tersuchungen über die Arbeitsplatzanforde-
and, in several countries, naval architects rungen an Bord von Passagierschiffen. Neuzeit-
366 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
liehe Gesichtspunkte bei Einstellungsuntersu- Wilh. Wilhelmsens Rederi 1976-1978. In: Syk-
chungen von Seeleuten. Arbeit und Leistung domsbildet hos sjöfolk - helsetjenesten til sjös.
21,8,145-147 (1967). Ed.: Institutt for almenmedisin. Oslo: Norges
9. Kersten, E.: Arbeitshygienische Beurteilung der Teknisk-naturvitenskapelige Forskningsraad
Arbeitsanforderungen in der Schiffahrt unter 1980. pp. 15-54. (System for Sikkert Skip. Rap-
besonderer Berücksichtigung der Beschäfti- port 80/1)
gung von Frauen und Jugendlichen an Bord. 16.0schatz, R: Die derzeitige Situation der Frau-
Verk.-Med. 14,6,203-219 (1967). enarbeit an Bord der Fang- und Verarbeitungs-
10. Marschall, B. and E. Kersten: Arbeitshygie- schiffe. Dissertation, University of Rostock
nische Betrachtungen zum Strukturwandel in 1967.
der Hochseefischerei unter dem besonderen 17. Rodahl, K.: Arbeidsstress til sjös. Oslo: Ar-
Aspekt der Frauenarbeit an Bord. Verk.-Med. beidsfysiologisk Institutt 1980. (System for Sik-
18,11,481-491 (1971). kert Skip. Rapport 8012)
11. Medhus, M.: Kartleggning av helsearbeidet om 18. Schuckit, M. A. and E. K. E. Gunderson: Psychi-
bord paa skip. In: Sykdomsbildet hos sjöfolk- atrie incidence rates for navy women: implica-
helsetjenesten til sjös. Ed.: Institutt for al- tions for an all volunteer force. San Diego 1972.
menmedisin. Oslo: Norges Teknisk-naturvi- 19. Stiewe, M.: Eine kritische Einschätzung der
tenskapelige Forskningsraad 1980. pp. 68-99. Frauenarbeit in der Produktionsabteilung der
(System for Sikkert Skip. Rapport 80/1) Fang- und Verarbeitungsschiffe. Verk.-Med. 18,
12. Michalk, H.: Frauenarbeit auf See. In: Fragen 12,521-528 (1971).
der Schiffahrtsmedizin. Intern. Symp., Heili- 20. Vuksanovic, P. and H.Goethe: Die Morbi-
gendamm 28-31 March 1963. Medizinischer ditätsstruktur der Seeleute - ein internationaler
Dienst des Verkehrswesens II, pp.42-51. Vergleich. In: Unfall- und Sicherheitsforschung
13. Müller, u.: Woman labor aboard ships. In: III Straßenverkehr. Kongreßbericht Jahrestagung
International Symposiom on Marine Medicine, 1981 der Dtsch. Ges. f. Verkehrsmed. gemein-
Leningrad 1968. Moscow 1969. pp. 69-70. sam m. d. Dtsch. Verkehrswacht. Hamburg,
14. Münster, U.: Frauen an Bord. Was eine AG- 7.-9.5. 1981. Ed.: Bundesanstalt für Straßen-
Studentin dazu meint. Hansa 114, 14, wesen im Auftrage des Bundesministers f. Ver-
1372-1375 (1977). kehr. Braunschweig: Waisenhaus-Buchdrucke-
15.0ffer-Ohlsen, D.: Skadebildet hos sjömenn i rei 1981. pp. 57-66.
5.6 The Child at Sea
o. W. Tenfjord
5.6.1 Introduction what extent does this occur and under what
conditions? Is there any uniform practice?
Throughout the ages children have been
In order to obtain information ab out the
passengers on board ships and have usual-
different aspects of carrying children on
ly been attended in sickness or in health by
board, colleagues from seven maritime
their mothers or members of their families.
countries and 13 Danish and six major
In former days the recreational and medi-
Norwegian shipping companies were con-
cal facilities for children were often sparse.
tacted and asked various pertinent ques-
Modern passenger liners are equipped
tions. The answers received are set out be-
with kindergartens and have doctors and
low.
nurses on board together with the neces-
sary facilities to deal with children of all 1. Do seamen - officers as weil as ratings -
ages in case of diseases or accidents. have permission to bring children with
Until quite recently members of the them on their sea vovages?
crew, with the exception ofthe master, have
In the USA, no company seems to allow
not, however, been permitted to bring their
children to accompany seafarers on a voy-
children with them. The position of the
age. As passengers on freighters with ac-
master on board is very special. Even in the
comodation for 12, children may travel and
era of sailing ships his living quarters were
the minimum age is 1 year (Urner [8]).
spacious with several rooms weIl suited to
In the UK, children are allowed on
accomodate several persons. This gave hirn
the opportunity of bringing his wife and board ships belonging to large companies
with mainly foreign-going vessels and to
children with hirn, even on deep sea voy-
companies with mixed passenger and car-
ages.
go vessels, but not on ships belonging to
As long as the remaining crew members
medium-sized companies and multination-
had to share cabins with each other it was
al oil companies. Children are never per-
impossible for them to take any of their de-
mitted on oil tankers. The permission to
pendents with them on board. A satisfacto-
bring children on board extends to offkers
ry standard of living quarters was not at-
only, or offkers and petty officers on com-
tained by many maritime countries until
pany service contract (Watson [9]).
after the Second World War. From the
In Italy and the Netherlands, seafarers -
1950s onwards, children tend to appear fre-
offkers as weIl as ratings - can bring chil-
quentlyon board with the permission and
dren with them (Tortori-Donati [7]; Groe-
kindness ofvarious shipping companies.
neweg [4]). The same practice applies to
two of the large shipping companies in
5.6.2 Children on Board: The Present ~weden and a major navigation company
Situation m Israel (Lehmann [5]; Shani [6]).
As mentioned above, ships from many . In West Germany, the large oil compa-
countries carry children on board today. To mes do not permit children on board, but
368 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
many other companies give such permis- the children to stay on board 2-3 months;
sion. One of the major companies extends five have no restrictions at all.
this permission only to seafarers who have A number of shipping companies do not
been on a contract for 6 months - officers permit children to take part in deep sea
as weIl as ratings. Excepted from this rule voyages, but on restricted ships only, e. g.
are cadets undergoing training and crew coastal waters (Norwegian companies),
members of ships taking part in an 18-man North European waters (Norwegian com-
crew project. The number of children on panies) or the Mediterranean area (Tortori-
board must not exceed six (Backhaus [2]). Donati [7]).
In Denmark, 12 of the companies, in-
c1uding all the major ones, permit children 3. Is there any family accomodation on
on board, the one exception being a sal- board?
vage company. Seven of the companies With one exception the answer was no.
grant this permission to officers and petty One of the major Norwegian tanker co m-
officers only, two to officers and ratings on panies has two family apartments on each
company contract and three to all groups of their ships built later then 1975. As a
of seafarers. rule, the wife and children will have to
The majority of Norwegian shipping share the cabin of the seafarer.
companies gives permission to all seafar-
ers, officers and weIl as ratings, but in some 4. Is there a minimum age?
cases this is restricted to seafarers on com- There is a great deal of variation: 1 year
pany service contract only. Sometimes the (Shani [6], one Swedish company), 2 years
final decision rests with the master. (some Norwegian companies), 3 years
It is gene rally understood that the chil- (Tortori-Donati [7], Backhaus [2]), 4 years
dren should be accompanied by their (Groeneweg [4], Lehmann [5], Backhaus
mothers. It is also requested that the wives [2]), 5 years (Watson [9]) and 6 years (Back-
of the seafarers make their beds, clean their haus [2]). Five Danish companies stipulate
cabins and give a helping hand when asked no minimum age at all , the others 2-5
for. Additional people on board are an ex- years. Some Norwegian companies stipu-
tra burden on the members of the catering late no minimum age at all or no minimum
department. age when the trip is restricted to coastal wa-
The children will usually have free ters only. The final decision may rest with
board, but some companies charge a fee the master.
per day for food (Groeneweg [4]; Backhaus
[2]). 5. Is a health certificate required?
With a few exceptions the answer was no.
2. Are there any restrietions regarding the The navigation company in Israel requires
type of joumey or time to be spent on a health certificate and this must be issued
board? by a paediatrician (Shani [6]), some British
companies and the largest Danish com-
In two ofthe countries referred to, there are pany require a health certificate from the
no restrictions on the length of time chil- family doctor (Watson [9]) and a major
dren can stay on board. (Watson [9]; Shani West German company requires a health
[6]), but in all the other countries there is a certificate issued by an approved seaman's
time limit which extends from 2-3 months doctor (Backhaus [2]).
to 6 months. In a Dutch company the se- As a rule the children must be properly
nior officers may keep their children on vaccinated.
board for 26 weeks (Groeneweg [4]).
Seven of the Danish companies permit
5.6 The Child at Sea 369
6. Are there any stipulations on who should tis and, if the temperature runs high,
meet the cost of a) medical treatment and fever cramps. Diagnosis and treatment
care in foreign ports, b) repatriation and may be difficult. These conditions are
c) deviation? particularly dangerous for small chil-
Usually these costs will be covered by Ma- dren and infants.
rine insurance (Proteetion and Indemnity 3. Diseases of the digestive system. The dis-
Club) and for some companies this is obli- order most feared is diarrhoea, which is
gatory (Watson [9], Groeneweg [4], Shani [6] particularly difficult to treat and serious
Backhaus [2]). If the national health insur- for small children and infants.
an ce does not cover all the costs of medical
treatment or repatriation, some Norwegian 4. Accidents. Children are liable to acci-
companies will debit the balance to the sea- dents on board as weil as ashore. They
man involved; otherwise it is paid for by may fall while on ladders and staircases
the companies themselves. The heavy costs and stumble and fall on loose objects on
of deviation will usually be paid for by the deck, particularly when the ship is roll-
companies if they are not covered by the ing badly. Small children have a tenden-
insurance. Two of the Danish companies cy to crawl all over the pi ace, are quick
require that all costs should be met by the and have a wide sphere of operation. At
seafarer hirnself. the age of 1-4 years they must be looked
after properly, otherwise they may get
on deck and run the risk of falling over-
5.6.3 Children on board: Health board.
problems 5. Tropical diseases. The most widespread
is malaria and this and a great number
The children are supposed to be healthy
of other tropical diseases may present
when they arrive on board and not suffer-
diarrhoea as the most important and
ing from any chronic disorders. Naturally,
dangerous symptom.
they may fall siek or be injured during a
journey. What kind of medical problems In addition to these five categories,
may occur? It will mainly be a question of emergencies of many types may arise.
everyday medical disorders, but some spe-
cial problems may arise, and these can ap-
5.6.4 The Future
propriately be divided in the following five
categories: A large number of companies in many
maritime countries permit children to trav-
1. Common children 's diseases. Many of
el on their ships provided they are accom-
these, such as diphtheria, polio and
panied by their mothers. An increasing
whooping cough, are rare today among
number of children may be expected on
children from the Western countries.
board in the years to come, from an
Others, such as measles and chicken-
increasing number of countries. There is a
pox, run a mild course and should sel-
great difference between the companies
dom give rise to any problems or com-
concerning requirements as to minimum
plications of importance.
age, health certificates etc.
2. Diseases of the respiratory system. These As discussed previously, many of the
occur rather frequently, particularly dur- common diseases may be serious, above all
ing winter; the common cold heads the for small children and infants. The masters
list. Other important diseases or compli- are in charge of medical care and treat-
cations in this category are bronchitis, ment. The responsibility for siek children is
pneumonia, acute otitis media, laryngi- an extra burden on them and somewhat
370 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
Jones [12], Tortori-Donati [22], Tortori- against certain diseases is still strongly rec-
Donati and Giannico [23] and Warncke [25] ommended for the majority of cruise pas-
reported on experiences of doctors on sengers. Depending on the countries to be
board and the relevant preventive and ther- visited, typhoid, tetanus and cholera may
apeutic conc1usions to be drawn. They all all be indicated. Certain countries will re-
emphasized that, besides his occupational quire yellow fever inoculation, though for-
health knowledge, the doctor on board tunately smallpox vaccination is no longer
passenger vessels - particularly cruise necessary. Poliomyelitis should not be
ships - should be familiar with geriatric omitted and in special situations hepatitis
medical problems and the care of the dis- inoculation may be advisable, especially in
abled, which may present particular diffi- the Middle East and North Africa. Intend-
culties on board. Despite the awareness of ing passengers should be advised to com-
special medical problems which may arise plete all inoculations well in advance of de-
on board, there are always passengers who parture, preferably 2 weeks, so as to avoid
normally should have been advised against the discomfort of any adverse re action
a sea voyage. which may occur and which can all too eas-
Jäger [8-11] dealt repeatedly with the ily spoil an otherwise pleasant vacation. In-
problems of medical care on board pas- formation regarding vaccination require-
senger vessels at sea. He invented the term ments can normally be obtained from the
"cruise ship medicine". This author offices of the shipping company con-
stressed the very high qualifications cerned. Correct documentation ofvaccina-
needed by a doctor on board a passenger tion certificates is essential if inconve-
vessel. He is usually on his own and has no nience by local health authorities overseas
specialist or emergency hospital facilities at is to be avoided. Where it is known that
hand. there is a risk from malaria, appropriate
Doctors recommending a holiday cruise prophylactic tablets should be recom-
for their patients should always ensure that mended such as Paludrine (proguanil hy-
they are provided with full medical docu- drochloride) 100 mg one tablet daily or
mentation relating to their condition and Maloprim (pyrimethamine 12.5 mg, dap-
details of any medication which they may sone 100 mg) one tablet weekly. Dosage
be receiving. All too often patients in de- should be continued for at least 6 weeks af-
c1ining health are encountered, having mis- ter leaving a malarious area.
laid their medication and without medical
documentation. Such a situation can cause 5.7.3 Passenger Facilities
serious medical problems for the ship's
doctor, whose diagnostic and therapeutic A wide range of facilities are available to
resources may be limited. Obviously, larger intending passengers, depending on the
passenger vessels are more likely to pro- cost of the cruise, size of the vessel and na-
vide more extensive medical facilities and tionality of the crew. At one end of the
this should be borne in mind by the family scale is the cheap package tour offering ba-
doctor when advising a patient to embark sic conditions with poor air conditioning,
on a sea voyage. limited menus, absence of elevators and
possibly low standards of food hygiene as
5.7.2 Immuuization well as minimal medical services. At the
other end is the more expensive luxury
Despite the considerable progress that has cruise line providing high standards of
been made by the World Health Organiza- catering and air conditioning as good as or
tion in the eradication of contagious dis- better than any luxury hotel ashore, togeth-
eases world-wide, protective immunization er with comprehensive medical facilities in-
374 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
chotic illness should, therefore, not be al- quent convulsions, should present no prob-
lowed to embark on a prolonged sea voy- lem. However, where there is any doubt it is
age. Long days at sea, a warm sunny prudent for such individuals not to travel
climate with consequent boredom often as- alone.
sociated with increasing alcohol intake
may all aggravate the condition. Unfortu- 5.7.8 Alcoholism
nately, individuals suffering from severe
psychoneurotic illnesses are often encour- Alcohol dependence is an increasing prob-
aged to go on a holiday cruise under the lem in the Western World owing to rising
mistaken impression that the change of en- standards ofliving and the ready availabili-
vironment will be of benefit. In practice ty of alcohol. It is estimated that there are
nothing is further from the truth and subse- currently 500000 alcohol-dependent per-
quent deterioration is all too common. Pat- sons in the United Kingdom and an equal
ients with a psychotic iIIness such as schiz- number with alcohol problems.
ophrenia present a serious problem at sea Not surprisingly, this type of person is
and should not be permitted to travel. attracted to a holiday cruise with its conviv-
Their behaviour is unpredictable and ial atmosphere, cheap alcohol and unre-
causes serious annoyance and alarm to stricted bar hours. It is most unwise to ad-
other passengers, particularly if cabin ac- vise an alcoholic patient to go on a holiday
commodation is shared with strangers for cruise with the high risk of deterioration,
weeks at a time. Serious immigration prob- resulting in mental dis order or delirium tre-
lems can arise if a passenger suffering from mens. Successful treatment with heavy se-
amental iIIness is refused permission to dation, vitamin B supplements and re-
disembark at his destination. In such cir- striction of access to alcohol can sometimes
cumstances the responsibility far repatria- be achieved although this places great re-
tion rests with the shipping company con- sponsibility on the shipboard medical staff.
cerned and may involve the provision of a Many alcoholics suffer from severe anxiety
medical escort with all its attendant prob- problems in which the risk of suicide is
lems. In contrast busy business executives high. Aggressive behaviour by male alco-
suffering from mild anxiety and stress ben- holics, resulting from loss of libido, may
efit greatly from a relaxing sea voyage, re- precipitate physical assault on their con-
moved from their daily worries with the de- sorts or other passengers. Restraint in such
tached relaxation of the sea and the circumstances is usually violently opposed
absence of telephones and sometimes by the patient and can result in endless so-
world news - the cruise may produce a re- cial and legal complications. Incarceration
markable improvement in a short space of in a hospital ashore, where the language is
time. not understood and social and religious
Severe epilepsy at sea with frequent at- cultures are very different, is to be avoided
tacks is a serious hazard and however weil wherever possible.
controlled should always be viewed with
caution. There are numerous dangers on 5.7.9 Genito-urinary Problems
board from falling overboard, collapsing
on wet, slippery decks, or using stairs to Acute urinary retention resulting from
open decks, sometimes in inclement and prostatic hypertrophy is a frequent medical
rough weather. Changes in social habits, emergency in passenger vessels. Catheter-
overtiredness from late nights and excess ization under aseptic conditions usually
alcohol may all precipitate a convulsion. relieves the condition, although where dif-
Normally passengers with epilepsy, if ade- ficulty is encountered owing to spasm of
quately treated and with a history of infre- the bladder sphincter supra-pubic puncture
378 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
may be required. The retention of an in- priate dark ground illumination, and cul-
dwelling catheter for the remainder of the ture where indicated. Passengers contract-
voyage may be distressing ap,d embarrass- ing a sexually transmitted disease at sea
ing to the patient. Patients with a pre-exist- should always be provided with a full med-
ing history of prostatic obstruction should ical report of the investigations and treat-
be most carefully assessed before being ment so that this can be continued ashore
permitted to undertake a long sea voyage. until cure is complete.
Recurrent urinary infection from partial
urinary retention can prove troublesome as 5.7.10 Seasickness (Kinetosis)
the range of urinary antibiotics may be lim-
ited and sensitivity tests unavailable. The incidence of motion sickness has been
Acute renal colic from the passage of re- dramatically reduced since the introduc-
nal calculi, frequently precipitated by a low tion of stabilizers in most modem passen-
fluid intake in tropical climates, may be a ger liners. However, in rough weather con-
very painful and disabling condition re- ditions, especially in the first few days,
quiring hospitalization on board and the some cases usually occur. The most suc-
administration of pain-relieving injections cessful treatment is prevention, as once
such as pethidine hydrochloride 100 mg vomiting has commenced oral medication
combined with anti-spasmodics, like atro- is of little value. A wide range of remedies
pine sulphate 0.8-1.2 mg. Urinary obstruc- are available, although the most effective
tion from a calculus lodging in the urethra and acceptable are promethazine com-
may precipitate an acute urinary retention. pounds such as Phenergan or Avomine.
Venereal disease is not uncommonly en- Phenergan 25 mg orally taken at night and
countered in passenger vessels where the repeated two or three times the following
duration of the voyage is in excess of a day is beneficial and generally more effec-
week. The opportunity for sexual exposure tive than hyoscine hydro bromide, which
from casual contacts, both on board and causes considerable drowsiness. Phener-
ashore, is high. Although syphilis is fortu- gan 50 mg intramuscularly, repeated 6-
nately relatively rare, the reverse is true for hourly if necessary, the patient being in-
gonorrhoea and non-specific urethritis. structed to lie down for 2-3 h following
Tbe need for correct diagnosis and com- each injection, is usually successful. It is
plete treatment with appropriate antibiot- rare for a single 50-mg injection of Phener-
ics is essential, coupled with bacteriologi- gan to fail. Alternative remedies such as hy-
cal examination of smears as appropriate. oscine hydrobromide as Quick Kwells, cy-
Blood examination to exclude syphilitic in- clizine as Marzine and dimenhydrinate
fection should be carried out before treat- 50 mg as Dramamine are all of value. Re-
ment is commenced, and the passenger ad- cently Stugeron (cinnarizine 15 mg) has
vised of the result in due course. Regret- gained in popularity owing to its lack of
tably, under seagoing circumstances diag- sedative properties. Children respond weil
nosis and treatment are all too often to Phenergan Elixir 5-10ml according to
incomplete. Contacts on board should be age, with chlorpromazine (Largactil) in re-
identified as so on as possible so that serve. Suppositories of dimenhydrinate
spread of the disease can be prevented and 50 mg (Dramamine) can be of value where
treatment instituted wherever necessary. oral medication is ineffective owing to
Much antibiotic drug resistance to gonor- vomiting and intramuscular injection is de-
rhoea is encountered overseas, largely ow- clined.
ing to incomplete treatment of the affected A new transdermal therapeutic system
population. All penile sores and ulcers (ITS) was introduced some years aga in
need the fullest investigation with appro- the treatment of motion sickness. It con-
5.7 Health Care of Passengers 379
sists of a small gummed plate, 2.5 cm2 in Severe cases may require antihistamines by
size, containing 1.5 mg scopolamine. This mouth, such as Fabahistin (mebhydrolin)
small plate is affixed to the skin in the ret- 50 mg, or steroid preparations applied 10-
ro-auricular area. According to the manu- caIly. Antihistamine creams are best
facturer it releases totally 0.5 mg scopola- avoided in view ofthe risk of skin sensitiza-
mine over aperiod of 3 days and this is tion. Many a holiday cruise can be spoilt,
absorbed transdermally. The achieved especially for fair-skinned people, by over-
plasma level of the active substance is, exposure to sun in the early days and fail-
presumably, in most cases sufficient to ure to adopt common-sense precautions.
suppress kinetosis without showing the
weIl-known side-effects of scopolamine 5.7.12 Physical Handicap
(Price et al. [19]).
Many vessels, particularly those in excess
5.7.11 Sunburn of 20000 gross tonnage, are unable to go
alongside at some less weIl developed
Most passengers on a holiday cruise in ports, especially in the West Indies, and
tropical climates suffer some degree of sun- this necessitates the movement of passen-
burn because of the overwhelming desire gers ashore in launches or small boats,
of most holidaymakers to acquire a glori- sometimes up to a distance of several miles.
ous, romantic suntan and their neglect to The physically handicapped may find this
adopt a programme of gradual acclimatiza- a serious problem, especially if distur-
tion during the first few days of exposure. bances of balance co-exist, unless they are
Many forget the serious dangers from re- accompanied by someone who can give
flected light which results from a clear sea them careful support. No passenger with a
and light sandy beaches. Failure to realize serious physical disability should embark
the dangers of exposure from an overcast on a cruise vacation or long sea voyage
sky with a warm dry wind may result in se- unless they are accompanied by a friend or
vere bums with constitutional signs of relative or are physically independent and
headache, general malaise, nausea and able to use the bathroom and toilet facili-
sometimes vomiting. ties without outside assistance. Wheelchair
Sunburn can easily be prevented by cases may be a difficulty as the standard
adopting a programme of gradual expo- size wheelchair will not pass through most
sure to the sun's rays from 30 min initially cabin doorways and access to the bath-
to 1 and then 2 h as the days progress. room may be restricted. Elevators, steps
Avoidance of the mid-day sun, dark glasses and stairs can be an obstacle to general mo-
and a sun hat, together with the judicious bility. A few passenger ships provide spe-
use of a good-quality sun screen or lotion cial facilities for the disabled but these are
can all help in avoiding sunburn of any unusual. Blind persons or the partially
severity. Some people may benefit from a sighted should not travel by sea unless ac-
course of Sylvasun taken orally twice daily companied, for reasons which are obvious.
for the first 2 weeks of their vacation. The Those persons with serious errors of refrac-
action is based on the concept that vita- tion requiring spectacles should always
min Ais an antagonist to vitamin D, which carry a spare pair with them and especially
is concerned in the process of sunburning. so if contact lenses are worn, as replace-
Pre-exposure to UVA may be helpful to ment overseas may prove difficult.
patients with sensitive skins.
Sunburn can be treated successfully with
analgesics, bland lotions such as calamine
together with added salt and fluid intake.
380 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
iar with the problems of nautical medicine. fahrungen auf modernen Passagierschiffen.
The employment of a succession of relief Ther. d. Gegenw. 118,4,616-631 (1979).
11. Jäger, H.: Schiffsarzt - immer noch ein Aben-
doctors and nurses on a temporary basis,
teuer. Praktische Erfahrungen bei Kreuzfahr-
often ill paid and without senior officer sta- ten. Ärzt!. Prax. 30,95,3248-3250 (1978).
tus, is to be deprecated. Medical staff 12. Jones, H. A.: Health problems in cruise ships.
should possess asound knowledge of Canad. Pac. Steamship Ud., 10 pp.
emergency, accident and resuscitative 13. Koreak, M.: Follow-up report on cruiseships:
have sanitation standards improved? Canad.
procedures and have some expertise in car- med. Ass. J. 121,7,998-1012 (1979).
rying out basic laboratory procedures. 14. Merson, M.H., 1.M.Hughes, B.R Wood et al.:
Passenger vessels engaged on short sea Gastrointestinal illness on passenger cruise
voyages such as ferries do not normally ships. J. Amer. med. Ass. 231, 7, 723-727 (1975).
15. Merson, M. H., 1. H. Tenney, J. D. Meyers et a!.:
carry medically qualified personneion
Shigellosis at sea: an outbreak aboard a pas-
board, despite the fact that passenger num- senger cruise ship. Amer. 1. Epidem. 101, 2,
bers may exceed several hundred. In these 165-175 (1975).
circumstances a sufficiently well-stocked 16. Oliver, P.O.: Health problems of passengers at
medicine chest together with resuscitation sea. Practitioner 219,1310,204-210 (1977).
17. Oliver, P.O.: Medical hazards at sea. Brit. J.
equipment should be available for use by a Hosp. Med. 22,6,615-618 (1979).
doctor passenger should he be called upon 18. Polonov, K.: Characteristics of morbidity
to deal with a sudden emergency. This among passengers during voyages with hotel-
should be in addition to the normal first aid dass ships. In: Fourth International Sympo-
sium on Marine Medicine. Oct. 15-17, 1970,
medical supplies and dressings available
Varna. Varna 1972. pp. 298-303.
for use by the crew. 19. Price, N., L.G.Schmitt and J.E.Shaw: Trans-
dermal delivery of scopolamine for prevention
of motion-induced nausea in rough seas. Clin.
Therapeutics 2,4,258-262 (1979).
References 20. Survey of environmental sanitation on 12 pas-
senger cruise ships operating in the Caribbean.
1. Cameron, D.C.: The hazards of ocean cruises Ed.: V.S. Department of Health, Education,
for the elderly and infirm. Seat. med. J. 17, and Welfare. Public Health Service, Center for
168-171 (1972). Disease Contro!. Atlanta, Georgia 1974.
2. Carter, J. w.: Shipboard medicine on package 21. Survey of incidence of gastrointestinal illness
cruises. Brit. med. 1. 1, 553-556 (1972). on passenger cruise ships. Ed.: V.S. Depart-
3. Dahl, E.: Almenpraksis til sjos. Medisinske er- ment of Health, Education, and Welfare. Public
faringer fra en jordomseiling. T. norske Laege- Health Service, Center for Disease Contro!. At-
foren. 99,6,327-330 (1979). lanta, Georgia 1974.
4. Dannenberg, A. L., J. C. Yashuk and R. A. Feld- 22. Tortori-Donati, B.: La attrezzatura ed il fun-
man: Gastrointestinal illness on passenger zionamento dei reparto sanitario di grandi
cruise ships, 1975-1978. Amer. J. pub!. Hlth 72, transatlantici stranieri. Lav. e. Med. 20, 3,
5,484-488 (1982). 105-118 (1977).
5. Davies, D.M.: Medical experience in nudear 23. Tortori-Donati, B. and L.Giannico: Practice of
submarines. J. roy. nav. med. Servo 57, 3, medical profession on board passenger ships,
136-141 (1971). remarks on equipment and activity ofthe medi-
6. Davies, J. w., K. G. Cox, W. R. Simon et a!.: Ty- cal department of the liners and on morbidity
phoid at sea: epidemie aboard an ocean liner. on board. In: III.International Symposium on
Can. med. Ass. 1. 106,877-883 (1972). Marine Medicine, Leningrad 1968. Moscow-
7. De Dombai, F.T.: Acute abdominal pain - An Leningrad 1969. pp. 189-196.
OMGE survey. Scand. J. Gastroent. 56, 14, 24. Vlewicz, K. and R.Dolmierski: Pharyngitis ep-
29-'B (1979). idemie on a passenger ship. Bull. Inst. mar.
8. Jäger, H.: Ärztliche Versorgung auf See. Kreuz- trop. Med. Gdynia 27, 1, 105-108 (1976).
fahrt - medizinische Erfahrungen. Fortsehr. 25. Warncke, J.: Gesundheit, Sicherheit und Be-
Med. 97,27,1191-1194 (1979). quemlichkeit des Reisenden aus der Sicht der
9. Jäger, H.: Kreuzfahrtmedizin. Ärztliche Betreu- Schiffahrtsmedizin. Verk.-Med. 15,4, 133-146
ung von Besatzung und Passagieren auf See. Z. (1968).
Alig. Med. 56,942-948 (1980). 26. Wemer, S. B., M. P. Hudgins, F. R. Morrison et
10. Jäger, H.: Kreuzfahrtmedizin. Bordärztliche Er- al.: Gastroenteritis on a cruise ship - a recur-
382 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
Africa, for example, the process of pilotage the work-force itself. Such was the case re-
is often a relatively simple task of escorting garding British sea pilots. In 1970, at the
avessei directly from the open sea to the time of the mortality study of English
harbour berthing. Channel Pilots (Harrington [5]), no other
published investigation of sea pilot mortal-
5.8.2 The PHotage Operation ity was extant. Indeed, only two studies of
sea pilot morbidity were available, both
The wide diversity in skill required for var- from Sweden (Dahlmann [3], Kilbom [8]).
ious pilotage procedures is reflected in the Both studies noted an excess incidence of
training and experience necessary to be a peptic ulcer morbidity which was consid-
pilot in various ports. For example, ap- ered by the authors to be related to the
prentices are trained to guide vessels in the work-load. Dahlmann considered that the
Liverpool/Manchester port complex gastric disorders were due to the "exacting
whereas on the EIbe and the Thames, a pi- duties of the pilot service with irregular
lot must be at least 30 years old and hold a working hours ano meals and increased
valid master mariner's ticket. The induc- duties during and after World War Two".
tion period is then, long intensive and often In this respect, the effects, ifreal, are organ-
poorly paid. The German pilots on the isational rather than truly occupational.
EIbe operate to and from the Kiel Canal ei- Shift working, though much maligned, has
ther seawards or towards port, but in the been shown to cause few incontrovertible
Thames estuary, a pilot operating from health effects other than gastric disorders
Gravesend, for example, is either licensed (Harrington [7]), and the irregular hours of
to pilot avessei in or out but rarely both. work with scant regard for time of day
The time involved in piloting may be an could similarly be responsible for the pi-
hour or so for a straightforward job into an lots' digestive disorders.
open sea harbour, up to 6 h from Grave- Mortality studies have implied other
send to the North Sea in good weather. hazardous effects. A study of 393 English
Thus the length of time away from the pilot Channel pilots for the period 1956-1968
station may be as long as 36 h on the EIbe showed a statistically significant excess of
or the Thames. Bad weather can consider- coronary artery deaths, particularly in the
ably extend the length of the tour and may younger pilots aged 35-49 years (Harring-
even prevent the sea-going pilot from dis- ton [5]). Extensions of this study to Man-
embarking. Indeed, the vagaries of time, chester and Liverpool showed similar
tide and vessel movement can involve the though statistically insignificant results and
pilot in considerable periods of waiting for the same picture emerged from an investi-
a ship. The prolonged period of inactivity gation of Humber pilots (Kywe [9]). A
may be rapidly followed by a vertical climb study of 525 deaths in pilots who worked
of perhaps 20 m to reach the bridge. There on the EIbe, Weser and Kiel Canal noted a
the pilot may be confronted with a bewil- 5.5-fold excess of coronary artery deaths
dering array of modem navigational equip- compared with urban male populations
ment aboard a foreign vessel. Given such and, once again, this excess occurred in the
working conditions it would not be surpris- younger pilots (31-50years old) and in the
ing to discover some occupational health pre-1960 period (Zorn et al. [13]). Erikssen
sequelae. et al. [4a] found a significant difference be-
tween Norwegian pilots and the male Oslo
5.8.3 The Health of Sea PHots population regarding ECG and exercise
performance and other indicators of coro-
It is not uncommon for occupational nary heart disease: the pilots seemed to be
health problems to be brought to light by more prone to coronary artery disease.
5.8 The Sea Pilot 385
Each of these studies suggests that the comparisons were made with referent land-
stress of the job and the work-load in- based populations.
volved could be at least partially responsi- Direct work-load studies were undertak-
ble for the excess mortality from coronary en using portable instruments for measur-
artery disease. However, there is anecdotal ing heart rate. Higher pulse rates were not-
evidence of heavy cigarette smoking and ed in pilots handling very large crude
high alcohol consumption amongst pilots, carriers (VLCC) (104.5 per minute versus
the former habit when on duty, the latter al- 77 .8) and this was particularly in evidence
most exclusively off duty. during the procedure of "swinging" these
However, the latent period for athero- vessels as compared with forward move-
sclerotic change is likely to exceed the ment. Heart rates in excess of 150 beats/
length of pilotage experience for this young minute were recorded during manoeuvring
population, and their Merchant Navy ex- vessels in restricted waters though there
perience could weil be involved as an addi- was little difference between day and night
tional, if ill-defined, risk factor. time operations. Nor, surprisingly, did the
Attempts to test these hypotheses have size of the vessel seem to correlate weil. It
met with some methodological difficulties. appears that the act of manipulating any
A study of catecholamine excretion as a vessel in a restricted pi ace is a stressful situ-
measure of so-called stress was undertaken ation. Boarding avessei could also produce
on five volunteer pi lots over three separate heart rates twice the resting level. In this re-
pilotage operations (Zorn and Seifert [14]). spect, such episodes of tachycardia com-
The results showed a statistically signifi- pare with those noted in racing car drivers
cant rise in urinary catecholamines during but were far in excess of rates observed in
all pilotage operations. business executives and air traffic controll-
As a direct consequence of these studies, ers "under stress".
a full-scale work-load investigation was un- Nevertheless, at times of peak activity,
dertaken (Shipley [12]). In a random sam- heart rates in excess of 120 beats/minute
pie of 55 London based pilots, 36% were are not necessarily hazardous and thus al-
noted to have a health impairment on rou- though a pilot's work-load may be high,
tine examination. When more stringent such a conclusion does not necessarily im-
health criteria were adopted, the percent- ply a dangerous situation. To that extent,
age of "failed" pi lots rose to 55%. A com- pre-existent heart disease may create a po-
parison with business executives suggested tentially dangerous state but the work relat-
that significant health impairment was ed "stress" then becomes a contributory
twice as common in the pilots. More- rather than an underlying risk factor für
over, the pilots showed high er prevalences myocardial damage.
of abnormal li ver function, excess tobac- In a later human factor study the fatigue
co consumption and hypercholesterol- of pilots was especially investigated (Cook
aemia. and Shipley [16]) by means of ambulatory-
Questionnaire surveillance of 800 pi lots monitored electrocardiograms and inter-
(55% ofthe total United Kingdom popula- mittent measurements of oral temperature,
tion) suggested that they reported half as skin conduction, reaction time, and self-
much sickness absence as the general male ratings of subjective feelings. The main
population, with approximately 6% report- conclusions were that the sea pilots experi-
ing work-related injuries. These were main- ence considerable challenge to their alert-
ly falls during embarking or disembarking. ness, and are extremely tired after "long
The commonest reported diseases were haui" pilotage, particularly at night. Their
musculoskeletal disorders (39%), haemor- body rhythms are those of normal day
rhoids (27%) and varicose veins (14%). No workers, and they must frequently need to
386 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
rely on an effort of will to maintain ade- injuries caused by slipping on wet or dan-
quate vigilance when on watch during un- gerous surfaces. Such accidents are occa-
eventful passages. sionally fatal. There is also a need, on be-
There is clearly room for more extensive half of mariners as wen as pilots, for
studies of pilotage activity, preferably with improvements in the ergonomic design of
data collected from other countries and a bridge controls (Brigham [1D. For example,
variety ofworking conditions. The cause(s) a VLCC must be brought into contact with
for the pilots' seeming predilection for cor- a jetty at a speed frequently less than
onary artery disease has not been satisfac- 0.12 m/s. Direct perceptions required by
torily elucidated though that should not the pilot or master to achieve such a
prevent measures being taken to diminish manoeuvre are frequently below psycho-
the risk factors discovered thus far. physical thresholds. The strategic position-
ing of buoys would greatly aid such deli-
5.8.4 Prevention and Control of cate manipulations of avesseI. Such exter-
Occupational III Health nal devices would need to be supplement-
ed by improved on-vessel electronic equip-
Measures to protect the health of pilots fall ment, such as computer-assisted simula-
into two broad groups: procedures to ame- tions of planned manoeuvres, and interna-
liorate the work-load factors, and measures tional agreement should be sought con-
to monitor the health of pilots both before cerning the minimum navigational require-
and during employment. ments for a given vessel berthing at a given
port. In addition, greater uniformity of
5.8.4.1 Work Practices equipment design is needed to ensure that
The current, relatively haphazard, monitor- a pilot boarding a foreign vessel is at least
ing of pilot duties could be considerably not faced with unfamiliar navigational
improved. The aim should be to make equipment.
more efficient use of on-duty hours by di-
minishing the time spent on standby and 5.8.4.2 Pilot Health Monitoring
by ensuring that, once the pilotage is over, In the early 1970s it was clear that no major
the pilot is either transported rapidly back European pilotage authority was operating
to base or provided with clean, quiet and any efficient monitoring of pilot health.
comfortable rest facilities at the pi ace of The confirmation of excess coronary artery
disembarkation. Although the arrival of disease mortality and morbidity has
vessels in the pilotage area is subject to encouraged considerable changes in the
considerable variability due to weather, occupational health surveillance of British
sailing times and tides, the present short pilots.
notice given to pilots is unacceptable and In 1975, a new set of health standards
unnecessary. A longer notice of the need was proposed to Trinity House for pre-em-
for avessei to require a pilot is feasible and ployment health screening and this has
this would lead to more predictable duty been applied since 1976 (McLean [10D. All
periods. new entrants are required to complete a de-
Although accident and illness rates as a tailed medical history questionnaire and all
whole appear to be comparatively low, the are subsequently required to pass a full
current working arrangements of many pi- clinical examination. Electrocardiography
lots would militate against their taking time and serum biochemistry are also per-
off for any but the most serious illnesses or formed. In order to pass, a pilot must be
injuries. Improved design of pilot cutters demonstrably fully fit in terms of life assur-
and the methods of ascent and des cent ance and permanent health assurance stan-
from the vessel piloted would reduce the dards. The information collected is confi-
5.8 The Sea Pilot 387
dential to the exammmg doctor, though disorders which, at least in part, may be
Trinity House are provided with a state- due to the job or the previous Merchant
ment of "up to required standard" or "not Navy life-style. Little attention had been
up to required standard". Visual acuity paid to the provision of an occupational
standards are those laid down for Mer- health surveillance programme for pilots
chant Navy navigating officers. It appears until the mid 1970s, but in the United King-
that such entrance requirements are now dom, at least, some progress has now been
more stringent and more effectively im- made in the recognition of their specific
posed than for other European pilotage au- needs and the development of a formal
thorities. programme of health monitoring is under-
Subsequent periodic medical reviews are way. Less satisfactorily, much work re-
less weil established and the problems con- mains to be done to improve the rostering
cerning pilots who become temporarily or of pilot duties and the establishment of ef-
permanently disabled have yet to be sorted ficient and uniform procedures for the
out. There are good reasons for this delay. work these men do whilst on the bridge.
Firstly, the pilotage authorities are in astate
of flux both organisationally and financial-
ly. Secondly, adecision was made recently
to introduce a new set of medical standards
References
for maritime shipping which is likely to 1. Brigham, F. R.: Ergonomie problems in ship
be promulgated as Government regula- contro!. App!. Ergonomics 31, 14-19 (1972).
tions in July 1983. When these regulations 2. Cook, T. C. c.: A study of pilotage in a U. K. oil
have come into force, the pilotage authori- port including workload monitoring. Disserta-
tion, University of London 1977.
ties are likely to follow suit.
2a Cook, T.C. and P.Shipley: Human factors
Therefore, in the near future, the health studies of the working hours of UK ship's pi-
monitoring of Trinity House pilots is ex- lots. App!. Ergonom. 11,2,85-92 (1980) and 11,
pected to approach the desiderata of a 3, 151-159 (1980).
well-organised factory-based occupational 3. Dahlmann, T.: Incidence of peptic ulcer and
gastritis amongst Swedish sea pilots. Brit. J. in-
health service with appropriate pre- and dustr. Med. 10, 157-162 (1953).
post-employment health screening com- 4. Economics and marine pilotage. London: Her
bined with contingency planning for tem- Majesty's Stationery Office 1973. (Department
porary and permanent disablement from ofTrade Report)
4a Erikssen, J.A., Höiem Johansen and K.Ro-
the job. There remains, however, a need for
dahl: Coronary heart disease in Norwegian sea-
so me Europe-wide standards which could pilots; part of the occupational hazard? Acta
be profitably extended to other pilotage au- med. Scand. (Supp!. 0) 645,79-84 (1981).
thorities world-wide. 5. Harrington, J. M.: A mortality study of English
Channel pilots (1956-1968). Dissertation, Uni-
versity of London 1972.
5.8.5 Conclusions 6. Harrington, J. M.: Mortality from coronary ar-
tery disease of English Channel and Hamburg
The occupation of sea pilot is an ancient pilots. Trans. Soc. occup. Med. 22, 19-23
and skilled one which in re cent years has (1972).
7. Harrington, J.M.: Shift work and health - A
been the subject of some medical scrutiny.
critical review of the literature. London: Her
It appears that although the work-Ioad is, Majesty's Stationery Office 1978. (Health and
at times, heavy, the majority of pilots are Safety Executive [Employment Medical Advi-
capable of coping with the rigours of the sory Service] Monograph)
job. Nevertheless, research in several Euro- 8. Kilbom, A.: Pilots and piloting. Stockholm : Ar-
betsmedicinska Institutet 1969.
pean countries has demonstrated an excess 9. Kywe, K.M.: A mortality and morbidity study
mortality and morbidity from coronary of Humber maritime pilots (1956-1972). Disser-
heart disease and possibly gastro-intestinal tation, University of London 1973.
388 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
10. McLean, A.: Personal information 1981. chemie heart disease and work stress in West
11. Schilling, R. S. F.: Hazards of deep-sea-fishing. German sea pilots. J. occup. Med. 19, 11,
Brit. J. industr. Med. 28, 27-35 (1971). 762-765 (1977).
12. Shipley, P.: A human factors study of marine 14. Zorn, E. and R. Seifert: Catecholamine excre-
pilotage. London: Dept. of Industry. Ship and tion by marine pilots in action. Agressologie 18,
Marine Technology Requirements Board 1978. 5,269-272 (1977).
13. Zorn, E. w., J.M. Harrington and H.Goethe: Is-
5.9 Extreme Conditions Aboard Ship
B. Tortori-Donati
This chapter deals with situations which operations are successful. The ship's per-
are uncommon during a voyage. They as- sonnel must be aware that, during any voy-
sume the feature of an emergency, which age, a shipwreck can happen, even if this is
means an unlikely event. An emergency a very rare occurrence. The crew members
does not follow any foreseeable rule; there- must receive careful instructions on what to
fore it is impossible to give general instruc- do in the case of an emergency, with the
tions which may be considered valid for aim of improving the chances of survival
every case. Shipwreck, extremely long (Tortori-Donati [15]).
working hours without rest, extreme stress Life boats, rafts and all other life-saving
for long periods or at frequent intervals equipment must be checked periodically.
and extremes of temperature are discussed Giving instructions only once on a lengthy
in this chapter. voyage is useless; regular, repeated instruc-
tions including practical training in the
5.9.1 Shipwreck handling of all of the equipment is neces-
sary. There must be fixed rules and exer-
Shipwreck with the loss ofthe ship is a rare eises for all emergency procedures includ-
event. The International Maritime Conven- ing fire fighting drills, manning of boats in
tions bring up to date safety measures de- the proper dress and rescue operations.
signed to improve the safety of ships and of There must be well-known and practised
human beings on board. rules regarding the additional supply of
It is difficult to outline precisely how one boats and rafts with clothing, blankets, wa-
should behave in a shipwreck because this ter, food, first aid and medical supplies etc.
can happen for different reasons and be- In emergency situations under adverse
haviour has to change according to the pat- conditions only procedures which have
tern of events. been well practised will prove successfull
On board a ship which is about to be and life-saving. Otherwise panic reactions
abandoned, the medical personnel usually will worsen the shipwreck dis aster, adding
have to co pe with the traumas due to the to the danger to the lives of passengers and
dramatic event which alm ost always exac- crew.
erbate any previous chronic ill-health. In
addition, very frequently first aid medical 5.9.2 Extreme Length of Working
activity is hampered by the listing of the Hours Without Rest
ship and the inaccessibility of medical
equipment. Moreover, the passengers and The working activity aboard ships is orga-
crew are frightened and anxious to an ex- nized in watches; therefore, norrnally, the
tent which impedes satisfactory treatment. work/rest cycle allows the seaman to recu-
There is no doubt that psychological perate physically and mentally. However, it
training of seafarers is one of the most im- can happen that during a voyage the afore-
portant factors in ensuring that the rescue said organization of work must be can-
390 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
celled and the seaman continues to work adversely influence the physical and psy-
without being relieved for several hours. In chological integrity ofthe shift worker, pro-
these cases, fatigue ensues because of the ducing dissatisfaction and anxiety. Physi-
intensity and the length ofthe work and in- cal reaction to that anxiety may inc1ude the
fluences the psychological and physical onset of dyspepsia, bowel malfunction and
balance (Granati and Melino [11]). even peptic ulcer [1]. Moreover, when phys-
Fatigue is not easy to define or measure. ical or psychological overloading results
It is the sensation of being tired during pro- from both the quantity and the quality of
longed efforts. It cannot be measured spe- work (excessive working hours, unsatisfac-
cifically and it is subjectively expressed as tory type of work, extreme responsibility,
an impairment of the working capacity. frequent arguments while working etc.)
Whether acute or chronic, general or local- there is a particularly adverse influence on
ized, it produces a diminution of the func- the cardio-circulatory system which can
tional efficiency of the body and, conse- predispose to the onset of hypertension,
quently, of work performance and concen- ischaemic heart disease or coronary heart
tration. Fatigue develops when the working disease.
activity is immoderate, either in rhythm,
length or intensity. These factors have no 5.9.3 Extreme Stress or
absolute value, but they are related to indi- Responsibility
vidual sensitivity and to environmental
conditions (Brown [3]). Aboard ship, every seaman carries a certain
Obviously, the more the working envi- degree of responsibility. This is especially
ronmental conditions are influenced by ad- true on the newly built ships with refined
verse c1imatic factors or by pollution, or the technologies, which result in a progressive
more the quality of the work is psychologi- reduction of manual work and, as already
cally stress producing, the more rapid is the stated, an increase of activities which re-
onset of fatigue with subsequent malaise quirs a high degree of professional train-
for the worker. As to the influence of cli- ing and concentration. The degree of pro-
matic factors in the onset ofthe fatigue, it is fessional training varies according to the
easy to understand the importance of this rank of the seafarer, being directly propor-
link in the activity of seafarers, who, during tional to the importance ofthe type ofwork
the voyage, have to work under c1imatic carried out on board. It can happen that,
conditions quite different from those to because of some very particular c1imatic
which they are accustomed. In addition, conditions encountered during a voyage or,
psychological stress is a constant compo- for example, because the ship has to pass
ne nt of the working activity aboard ships through very dangerous waters, the load of
and seafarers therefore frequently undergo responsibility becomes extreme and pro-
this upsetting experience (Moreigne [13]). longed without allowing adequate periods
The situation is worse on newly built of mental relaxation and physical rest. As a
ships, which have a high degree of automa- consequence of this stressful rhythm of ac-
tion; this calls for greater concentration tivity, some seamen, particularly those who
and results in more fatigue and monotony feel deeply a sense of responsibility in their
(Drummer [8]). Furthermore, modem re- work, undergo mental strain which can be
search on the sociological organization of followed by anxiety or even, later on, by
the work has emphasized the harmful con- anguish, these being the three degrees of
sequences of the working shifts: frequent severity of a particular emotional condition
alteration of the biological rhythms, of the of an unpleasant nature (Dolmierski [7]).
relationship between sleep and being This progression of unpleasant feelings,
awake and of living habits. These changes which can have a damaging influence on
5.9 Extreme Conditions Aboard Ship 391
the physical health of those who are sub- out there having been a sufficient period of
jected to it, happens inside the unconscious acclimatization, is it possible that the phys-
mind. The anxiety state especially when iological mechanism of thermoregulation
prolonged, induces a group of somatic will become inadequate, with consequent
troubles, among which the most frequent damage to the human body.
are tachycardia, polyuria, profuse sweat-
5.9.4.1 Extremes of Cold (see also
ing, vasomotor troubles, changes in the
Chap.5.10)
blood pressure and angina-like syndrome
(Cesena et al. [4]). Exposure of a person to cold weather for
Usually the conscious mind is in order prolonged periods produces two harmful
and lucid but, without doubt, in the most effects: a) damage to the part of the body
serious cases it can be impaired, with a de- direct1y exposed (cold injury) and b) a neg-
cline of critical powers and the presence of ative influence on the core temperature
an abnormal psychological reaction (hypothermia).
amounting to panic. This is more apparent Cold injury is due mainly to vascular
when affecting a senior officer who is damage in the exposed tissues, with de-
forced to take an important decision too crease of the blood circulation and result-
quickly when the ability to analyse the dan- ing hypoxia.
gerous situation and choose the right solu- The damage is direct1y proportional to
tion may be impaired. (Matsevich and Por- the degree of cold, to the length of expo-
oshenko [12]). It is evident that in emergen- sure, to the presence of some aggravating
cies there is a physical and mentaloverload factor such as humidity or wind, and to the
which reduces the effectiveness of the suf- extent to which the body is protected by
ferer (Paslaru [14]). Man, when facing a suitable clothing. Cold injury is divided in-
critical situation, behaves in an unpredic- to four degrees according to the serious-
table manner, which is frequently indepen- ness of the symptoms and the importance
dent of his background of physical and of the sequelae.
mental resistance.
1st degree: hyperaemia and oedema
2nd degree: hyperaemia and blister forma-
5.9.4 Extremes ofTemperature tion
Aboard Ship 3rd degree: necrosis ofthe skin and ofthe
subcutaneous tissues, with ul-
A ship, during a voyage, passes from one
cer formation
climate to another in a relatively short time.
4th degree: deep necrosis with loss of tis-
However, in newly built ships the air condi-
sue
tioning system greatly reduces the possibil-
ity of the extremes of temperature encoun- The degree of a cold injury cannot be as-
tered during a voyage becoming harmful to certained immediately after the accident,
the seamen. but only in retrospect, when the evolution
Human beings possess a remarkable of the lesion is complete [5].
thermoregulatory capacity, which allows For the onset of hypothermia it is neces-
the body to maintain, within certain limits, sary to take into account several factors,
a constant core temperature, even when which may be a) general, such as the degree
great extemal thermal ranges are present. of cold and the length of exposure, togeth-
Only when the outside temperature reaches er with the presence or absence of other en-
a particularly high or low degree and this is vironmental factors such as humidity and
accompanied by other climatic compo- wind, or b) individual, such as age, sex,
nents with potentially harmful effects, such race, physical constitution, previous health
as humidity and movement ofthe air, with- conditions, presence of fatigue and inci-
392 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
dence of trauma (Glaser and McCance work in the engine room and in the galley,
[10]). When the physical and chemical ther- because, in addition to the outside heat,
moregulation is inadequate to counteract they have to work in premises with several
the influence of the cold weather, the core sources of radiant heat.
temperature falls. When the core tempera- Particularly important for the under-
ture reaches 34°C, general hypothermia, standing of the effects on the human body
which can be fatal, sets in. Four degrees of of exposure to extremely hot environments
this very serious syndrome have been de- are the experiments performed to discover
scrlbed corresponding to the extent to the objective criteria by which it is possible
which the internal temperature is lowered. to foresee an imminent heat collapse.
General hypothermia can thus be mild As has been underlined when discussing
(core temperature between 35°C and extremes of cold, there exists an individual
32°C), moderate (between 31°C and level of tolerance of heat, which is separate
28°C), deep (between 27°C and 25°C) or from the other general criteria of evalua-
profound (below 25°C). When the core tion such as age, sex, race, previous health
temperature falls to around 24°C the pat- condition, fatigue and intoxication, with
ient dies from unsatisfactory oxygenation particular emphasis on alcohol. Moreover,
of the tissues, lack of glycogen and conse- it must be remembered that of importance
quent accumulation in the tissues of lactic in addition to the air temperature are the
and carbonic acid, so inducing terminal ac- degree of humidity, the movement of the
idosis. air, the quality of the work, the clothing
The symptoms of general hypothermia and, most importantly, the degree of accli-
are, in the beginning, sudden blanching of matization of those exposed. Therefore,
the skin, fatigue, indifference, sleepiness, seamen who are "first trippers" are particu-
reduction of eyesight and of hearing, pro- larly liable to thermal stress.
nounced hypotension and bradycardia fol- The human body, in an attempt to keep
lowed by cardiac arrhythmia. If the patient the internal temperature constant in the
is not immediately and adequately treated, face of high thermal radiation, increases
with the aim of raising the core tempera- the loss of heat through sweating, cutane-
ture to normal levels, he will die, because, ous vasodilatation and pulmonary hyper-
after the cortical centres, the bulbar centres ventilation. When these mechanisms be-
are involved. Generally, death is due to a come inadequate, a multiform symptoma-
cessation offunction ofthe respiratory cen- tology develops, characterized by general
tre. malaise, asthenia, headache, vertigo, nau-
sea and vomiting, pseudo-angina syn-
5.9.4.2 Extremes of Heat (see also drome, hallucination, incoherence, mental
Chap.2.4) confusion, reduced concentration, memory
Frequently, ships are employed in geo- defects and irritability or depression. It is
graphical areas characterized by high tem- easy to understand that this mental impair-
perature and a high degree of humidity. ment can be very dangerous on board a
Usually, the ships, particularly the newly ship, because it can provoke in those sea-
built ones, have a system of air condition- men who have responsibility for naviga-
ing which allows the crew to enjoy good tion, a psychological inability to cope with
conditions of life and of work on board. their task (Collins [6]; Walters and Bell
Therefore, it is unlikely that heat exhaus- [16]).
tion and, especially, heat stroke due to the Heat collapse can be foreseen in the
influence of the high temperature on the presence ofthe following objective data: a)
human body, will take place. The most ex- raising of the internal temperature above
posed among the seamen are those who 39 oe; b) remarkable increase of the pulse
5.9 Extreme Conditions Aboard Ship 393
rate (more than 150 beats per minute), skin is dry because sweating has stopped,
wh ich becomes arrhythmie; c) onset of the breathing is rattling, the pulse rate is
general tiredness, nausea, vomiting, sleep- very high, the blood pressure is low and the
lessness and psychological troubles; and d) urinary output is much reduced or even
dehydration caused by an excess of sweat- stopped. Death can be a question of a few
ing with muscular cramps and a tendency hours or even less (fulminating heat
to heart failure. The increase of sweating stroke). Probably the pathogenesis of death
pro duces, besides the loss of water, a loss from heat stroke can be seen as a cessation
of the Cl-, Na + and K + ions, which are of function of the cerebral thermoregulator
very important for the maintenance of the centres owing to the environmental high
chemical and physical condition of the temperature and humidity in a person who
protoplasma colloids, to which the tenden- is particularly predisposed by general and/
cy to he art failure and the onset of cramp or particular sensitivity. When a case of
are closely related (Bell et al. [2], Eismont heat stroke occurs, it is necessary to start
[9]). The increased thermo dispersion correct therapy immediately, with the aims
through which the human body tries to mit- of: a) reducing hyperthermia by cooling
igate the consequences of thermal stress re- down the body until sweating starts again;
quires a wastage of energies, which only b) improving the dehydration by intrave-
the organism in good general condition can nous infus ions of salt solution; c) support-
tolerate. ing the circulation in order to prevent car-
Beside the previously described heat ex- dio-circulatory collapse, which is frequent
haustion, under particular circumstances and extremely serious; and d) calming
during a trip in tropical zones a crew mem- down the nervous system.
ber may undergo an acute episode of heat
stroke, which has dramatically serious
symptoms and requires urgent therapeutic References
measures to prevent the death of the pat-
ient. 1. Lavoro e turni, cronobiologia e protezione della
salute. Atti simposio nazionale, Verona 15 mar-
Reat stroke is an acute rise in the body zo 1980. Verona: Zendrini 1980.
temperature owing to inadequate thermo- 2. Bell, C. R, M. J. Crowder and J. D. Walters: The
dispersion when the environrnental tern- prediction of safe exposure times for men work-
perature and hurnidity are very high. Indi- ing in thermally severe environments. Ed.:
Medical Research Council. Royal Naval Per-
vidual sensitivity and predisposing factors,
sonnel Research Committee. ES 5. London
such as impairment of the cardio-circulato- 1970.
ry system or of the kidney or liver function, 3. Brown, I. D.: Measurement of fatigue in abnor-
together with the presence of harmful cli- mal physical environments. In: The effects of
matic condition, are of the greatest impor- abnormal physical conditions at work. Ed.:
C. N. Davies, P. R. Davis and F. H. Tyrer. Edin-
tance in precipitating the onset of heat burgh: Livingstone 1967. pp. 168-178.
stroke. The mechanism of thermodisper- 4. Cesena, G. c., R. Zanettini, R Curti et al.: Stress
sion, through which the human body de- e patologia cardio vascolare. Med. d. Lavoro 1,
fends itself against thermal stress, passes 3-12 (1981).
5. Cold injury. TB MED 81, NAVMED
from a condition of excitement (hyperhy-
P-5052-29, AFP 161-11. Ed.: Departments of
drosis) to a condition of depression or pa- the Army, the Navy, and the Airfgrce, Washing-
ralysis (anhydrosis). Consequently, the ton, D.C. Washington U.S. Government Print-
body temperature quickly rises above 41°C ing Office: 1976.
with loss of consciousness, hallucinations 6. Collins, C. P.: Health and efficiency in men of
the Royal Navy under thermal stress. J. roy.
and the possibility of convulsions. The ner- nav. med. Servo 41, 199-217 (1955).
vous system is so compromised that coma 7. Dolmierski, R: Neurosen und Verhaltens-
can occur. The face ofthe patient is red, the störungen bei Seeleuten. In: V. Internationales
394 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
In all the annals of man's adventure on the i. e. in seas anywhere outside the tropics.
world's seas, no more chilling a subject can The temperature ofthe sea along the Atlan-
be found than "shipwreck". Popular litera- tic routes and around the coasts of Great
ture has recounted tales of survival after Britain, Northern Europe and North
shipwreck involving weeks and months. America is never much higher than 15°C
Tragically, all too often these stories were (Hutchins and Schaarf [13]); thus most
the exception and not the rule. The vast people immersed in the sea outside the
majority of seamen died, many owing to a tropics and not rescued will die within
phenomenon only recently understood - 1-6 h, depending on the latitude and time
hypothermia. of year. Even after a survivor has boarded
Perhaps no other working environment a conventional ship's boat or life-craft,
can present the extremes that may confront McCance et al. [16] showed that the cold
the seafarer and challenge his ability to sur- hazard remains. During short voyages in
vive. The research on the physiology of sur- such a craft at sea temperatures below 5°C,
vival systems of "search and rescue" from a the death rate was between 20%-30%,
medical point of view, and practical ap- whereas it was less than 1% on voyages of
proaches to survival techniques for seamen similar length when the sea temperature
will be reviewed in this chapter. was over 20°C. "Immersion foot", more-
The British Royal Navy and its Survival- over, was always a serious risk even in a
at-sea Subcommittee reviewed the variety conventional life-craft because occupants
of physiological parameters in survival at often had to sit for long periods with their
sea. feet in the water (Ungley et al. [22]). These
Although isolated individuals from the problems were largely solved as a result of
time of Herodotus onwards had recognized the research into equipment referred to
the importance of cold as the primary above and it was found that in the newly
threat to life of men immersed in water, on- designed inflatable covered life-craft,
ly in the 1940s did this come to be generally c10thed men lying in c10se proximity
recognized (Critchley [4]; McCane, et al. tended to generate enough heat to keep
[16]; Molnar [17]). Mention must be made themselves and the air inside the raft suffi-
also of the experiments carried out by the ciently warm for survival even when the ex-
Nazis on prisoners at Dachau, which, al- ternal air temperature was at freezing point
though totally repugnant morally, estab- (Glaser and McCance [8]).
lished a number of facts about immersion Survivors are still at risk when they are
hypothermia that subsequent work has picked up, particularly if they have low
confirmed (Alexander [2]; Hervey [9]). body temperatures. During the Battle of
Molnar [17] showed particularly c1early the Falkland Islands in the First World
that progressive fall in body temperature War, most of the 200 survivors from the
occurs in nearly all people immersed in wa- Gneisenau died on board the rescue ships
ter at any temperature below about 20°C, (Scott-Daniel [19]). Mter the sinking of the
396 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
Lusitania in 1915, some of the survivors based on the patient's measured temper-
died on board the fis hing vessels which ature.
picked them up (Hoehling and Hoehling E. Axiom: With the hypothermia patient,
[10]). During the Second World War, both think heat.
the Allies and the Germans became aware 1. No cold intravenous (iv) fluids.
that some survivors who were alive when 2. No cold ventilation therapy.
they were rescued from cold water died 3. No cold treatments of any kind.
shortly afterwards. The Nazi's SS (Schutz- F. Unheated oxygen should not be used
Staffel) was responsible for the notorious for the hypothermia victim because it
Dachau experiments, reported by Alexan- will add cold to the victim. Attempt to
der [2], in which some subjects removed administer warm, moist oxygen if possi-
from cold water while still alive died short- ble.
ly afterwards and usually within 30 min. G. We must, at least, prevent further heat
McCance et al. [16] found that 17% of sur- loss at the core. This can be done only by
vivors rescued from water at 10°C or less insulating the entire patient, plus adding
died within 24 h, whereas none of the 210 heat to the "core areas" (head, neck,
survivors rescued from water above 20°C chest and groin).
died. Critchley [4] reports that of ten men H. Add heat gradually and gently:
who spent 30 min. in water at - 1°C, nine (The term "add heat" is used rather than
died immediately after rescue. "rewarm" because often the patient is
The best research available for treatment not actually any warmer with the addi-
of hypothermia may be summarized as fol- tion of heat, but rather only a further de-
lows: crease in core temperature is mini-
mized).
A. The evaluation and treatment of hypo- 1. Apply external warm objects to the
thermia, whether wet or dry, on land or head, neck, chest and groin. Use:
water, is essentially the same. Therefore, a) Hot water bottles
the following discussion does not specif- b) "Warm packs" (chemical heat
ically distinguish between chronic and packs must be used with great care
acute, or wet and dry hypothermia. so as not to burn the patient's skin,
B. In the cold patient, a rectal temperature e. g. wrap in a towel and watch
is one of the vital signs. In terms of the carefully)
ABCs, think: c) Warm rocks wrapped in towels
A- Airway d) Warm bodies
B - Breathing 2. Administer warm, moist air or oxy-
C - Circulation gen.
D- Degrees I. Never try to cool the extremities or use
C. "Low reading" thermometers are impor- tourniquets, or other occlusive dress-
tant in the care of the hypothermia pat- mgs.
ient. Regular thermometers are useless J. Be wary of statements or actions while
and probably dangerous in this setting. working on patients who are "uncon-
D.Obtaining a temperature reading is im- scious" or require cardiopulmonary re-
portant and useful when treating hypo- suscitation (CPR). These patients fre-
thermia. However, there is considerable quently remember what is done and said
variability in individual physiological and severe psychological problems may
responses at specific temperatures. In result. This applies equally to warm and
addition, there will be times when a low cold patients.
reading thermometer is not available. If hospital facilities are available, the
Therefore, these guidelines are not staff should understand the special require-
5.10 Search and Rescue Medicine - Survival at Sea 397
ments of these patients. A total approach is patient's level ofhydration and labo-
required by the hospital staff. ratory data.
4. Urinary bladder catheter.
A. Some General Points 5. Nasogastric tube, ifthe patient is un-
1. Treat to the level of your ability as conscious and the airway is protect-
your hospital equipment, staff and ed.
skills dictate. 6. Endotracheallnasotracheal tube is
2. All patients should be stabilized be- indicated in the deeply unconscious
fore any transport to another facility. patient with lack of spontaneous re-
The patient should be kept in the flexes after carefully checking the
sending hospital until the condition is cervical vertebrae for possible dam-
stable. age.
B. Evaluation 7. Oaily weights: intake and output.
1. Initial attention to the airways, 8. Always ventilate with warm, moist
breathing and circulation (ABC) and air or oxygen. [Typical unwarmed
to CPR. ventilation is approximately 72 °F
2. Vital signs, inc1uding rectal tempera- (22°C).]
ture. 9. Sodium bicarbonate administration
3. Briefhistory. is based on arterial blood gases.
4. Brief physical examination: 10. Continue monitoring until stable
a) Feel forskin coldness orwarmth and warm.
b) Level of consciousness o. Adding Heat
c) Cardiopulmonary examination 1. The recommended possibilities in-
d) Associated trauma c1ude:
5. Suggested laboratory and X-ray eval- External Internal
uation, depending on available staff- methods methods
ing and equipment: a) Gradual spon- a) Warm
a) Chest X-ray taneous re- steam in-
b) 12-lead electrocardiogram warmmg halation/
c) Urine: sediment, pH, glucose, pro- ventilation
tein, ketone, sodium and osmotic b) Warming b) Peritoneal
concentration (osmolarity) blankets, lavage
d) Blood: complete blood count in- warming mat-
c1uding platelets, blood-urea ni- tresses etc.
trogen, creatmme, electrolytes, c) Tub bath c) Warmiv
sugar, prothrombin time, liver fluids
function tests, amylase d) Extracor-
e) Arterial blood gases poreal cir-
f) Weight culation
C. Monitoring and Treatment (Atrio-
1. Basic treatment is the same as that ventricu-
indicated for pre-hospital personnel lar shunt)
in these guidelines.
2. Cardiopulmonary monitoring. 2. Regardless of the method chosen for
3. An iv and/or central venous pres- adding heat, the patient must be under
sure line (in the superior vena cava, total physiological control, to allow
not the right heart), with Os W at you to deal with his metabolie needs.
75 cc per hour. The iv fluid and rate of 3. Tub bath is one of the most rapid
infusion will vary depending on the methods and requires immediate lab-
398 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
oratory results and extremely elose 3. Hyperkalaemia: Monitor and treat ac-
physiological monitoring to maintain cordingly.
control of the situation. (00 not infuse potassium in iv fluids).
4. 00 not compromise extremity circu- 4. Hyperglycaemia: Monitor and treat
lation by using tourniquets, pneumat- accordingly.
ic antishock garments or ice packs.
Much can be done to reduce the conse-
5. The recommended temperature is
quences of hypothermia by educating the
about 105° -110°F (40° -43 0c) for all
seafarer on what he can do in a practical
methods.
way to improve his survivability. Such edu-
6. For severe hypothermia without signs of
cation should inelude the following infor-
life (requiring CPR)
mation directed at his level of understand-
Warm the core as rapidly as you can,
ing.
using one or more of the methods
(e. g. warming mattress, warm steam
inhalation and peritoneallavage), try- 5.10.1 The Human Body
ing to get the patient warmer than ap-
proximately 85 ° F (30°C). An understanding of how the body reacts
7. For severe hypothermia with signs of to cold air or water exposure and knowing
life the steps that can be taken to help the body
Use your judgment, using one or delay the damaging effects of cold stress,
more of the methods. will help in the struggle to stay alive in the
E. Most Common Problems event of cold water exposure.
Note: Drug therapy should be moder- Nature requires that the body core be
ated because in cold patients medica- kept at an ideal temperature of 98.6°F
tions are both inefficient and poorly (37°C). A network ofblood vessels running
metabolized. through the core and the outer layer of the
1. Arrhythmias - these are usually atrial body picks up the heat produced by the
arrhythmias: "furnace" within the core, and distributes
a) If patient is very cold, these atrial that heat throughout the body. Nature also
arrhythmias will usually convert gives the body a very accurate system to
spontaneously with rewarming. regulate automatically the core tempera-
b) If the temperature is rising and the ture at 98.6°F (37°C). For example, if the
arrhythmia does not convert, you surrounding temperature conditions are
may want to use the usual anti- high, as on a warm day or in a hot boiler
arrhythmie medication. room, the blood vessels near the skin of the
c) If the treatment is not working, body enlarge, allowing more blood to flow
add more heat. to the skin area and give off greater
d) Ventricular fibrillation in the very amounts of body heat. This is to keep one
cold patient is treated with CPR, comfortable and to keep the core tempera-
adding heat, and cardioversion af- ture 98.6 °F (37°C) from rising. However, if
ter the temperature reaches ap- the surroundings are cool, the body will
proximately 85°F (30°C). constrict the blood vessels at the skin sur-
e) In the patient whose temperature face and keep that valuable body heat from
is rising, the standard treatment for being lost too rapidly.
ventricular fibrillation should be
utilized (American Heart Associa- 5.10.2 Hypothermia
tion,others).
2. Dehydration: Monitor and treat ac- The loss of body heat is one of the greatest
cordingly. hazards to the survival of a person in the
5.10 Search and Rescue Medicine - Survival at Sea 399
sea. The rate of body heat loss depends on lifejacket and be sure to secure it cor-
water temperature, the protective clothing rectly.
worn and the manner in which the survivor 4. All persons who know that they are
conducts hirnself. An abnormally low body likely to be affected by seasickness
core temperature can be recognized by a should, before or immediately after
variety of symptoms. Very early during ex- boarding the survival craft, take some
posure, the body tries to combat the exces- recommended preventive tablets or
sive heat loss both by constricting its sur- medicine in a dose recommended by
face blood vessels (to reduce heat transfer the manufacturer. The incapacity
by blood to surface) and by shivering (to caused by seasickness reduces the
produce more body heat). However, if the chance of survival; vomiting removes
exposure is severe, the body is unable to precious body fluid while seasickness
conserve or produce enough heat. Hs core in general makes one more prone to
temperature begins to fall, creating a condi- hypothermia.
tion known as "hypothermia". As the body 5. Avoid entering the water if possible.
core temperature approaches 95°F (35°C), Board davit-Iaunched survival craft
it starts to fall more rapidly. By then dis- on the embarkation deck. If davit-
comfort, tiredness, poor coordination, launched survival craft are not avail-
numbness, impaired speech, disorientation able, use overside ladders, or if neces-
and mental confusion appear. As the inter- sary lower yourself by means of a rope
nal temperature decreases into the 80s (be- or fire hose.
low 32.2 Oe), unconsciousness may result, 6. Unless it is unavoidable, do not jump
as weIl as a blue tinge of the skin, collapse from higher than 5 m (16.4 ft) into the
of the veins in the skin, enlargement of the water. Try to minimize the shock of
pupils, and muscle stiffness. sudden cold immersion. Rather than
The heart becomes irregular and the jumping into the cold water, try to low-
pulse barely detectable. Although death er yourself gradually. A sudden plunge
may occur whenever the core temperature into the cold water can cause rapid
is below 90°F (32.2 0c), it is very difficult to death or an uncontrollable rise in
be sure whether the patient is alive or dead breathing rate may result in an intake of
when the body core temperature is below water into the lungs. On occasions it
85°F (29.4 0c). Death is then defined as may be necessary to jump into the wa-
failure to revive on rewarming. ter; if so, you should keep your elbow
Survival procedure in the event of a ship at your sides, cover your nose and
sinking should be preplanned to increase mouth with one hand while holding the
the chance of a successful rescue. Records wrist or elbow firmly with the other
show that ship sinkings, even in the worst hand. One should not jump into the
cases, usually require at least 15-30 min for water astern of the life-raft lest there is
the vessel to fully submerge. This affords any remaining headway on the ship.
valuable time for preparation. Here is some 7. Once in the water, whether accidently
sound advice that should be remembered or by ship abandonment, orientate
in a situation of this type: yourself and try to locate the ship, life-
1. Put on as much warm clothing as pos si- boats, life-rafts, other survivors or other
ble, making sure to cover head, neck, floating objects. If you were unable to
hands and feet. prepare yourself before entering the
2. If an immersion (exposure) suit is avail- water, button up clothing now. In cold
able, put it on over the warm clothing. water you may experience violent shiv-
3. If the immersion (exposure) suit does ering and great pain. These are natural
not have inherent flotation, put on a body reflexes that are not dangerous.
400 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
You do, however, need to take action as vas cover or tarpaulin, or an unused
quickly as possible before you lose full garment. Huddling dose to the other
use of your hands; button up c1othing, occupants of the lifeboat or raft will al-
turn on signallights, locate whistle, etc. so conserve body heat.
8. While afloat in the water, do not at- 11. Do not use "drown-proofing" in cold
tempt to swim unless it is to reach a water. "Drown-proofing" is a tech-
nearby craft, a fellow survivor or a nique whereby you relax in the water
floating object on which you can lean and allow your head to submerge be-
or c1imb. Unnecessary swimming will tween breaths. It is an energy-saving
"pump" out any warm water between procedure to use in warm water when
your body and the layers of c1othing, you are not wearing a life-jacket. How-
thereby increasing the rate ofbody-heat ever, the head and neck are high heat
loss. In addition, unnecessary move- loss areas and must be kept above the
ments of arms and legs send warm water. That is why it is even more im-
blood from the inner core to the outer portant to wear a life-jacket in cold wa-
layer of the body. This results in very ter. If you are not wearing a life-jacket,
rapid heat loss. Hence, it is most impor- tread the water only as much as neces-
tant to remain as still as possible in the sary to keep your head out of the water.
water, however, painful it may be. Re- 12. Keep a positive attitude about your sur-
member, pain will not kill you, but heat vival and rescue. This will improve
loss will! your chance of extending your survival
9. The body position you assume in the time until rescue comes. Your will to
water is also very important in conserv- live does make a difference!
ing heat. Float as still as possible, with
your legs together, elbows c10se to your 5.10.3 Man Overboard
side and arms folded across the front of
your life-jacket. This position mini- Any man overboard is probably not pre-
mizes the exposure of the body surface pared and off his guard. Some useful ad-
to the cold water. Try to keep your head vice to follow for preventing this situation
and neck out of the water. Another and being better prepared is:
heat-conserving position is to huddle 1. Always wear a life-jacket when safety
c10sely to one or more persons afloat, regulations require it or when you have
making as much body contact as pos si- to go on deck for any reason in poor
ble. You must be wearing a life-jacket weather.
to be able to hold these positions in the 2. Use extreme care when walking along
water. decks, up and down ladders, and across
10. Try to board a lifeboat, life-raft or other gangways.
floating platform or object as soon as 3. Grip firmly any rails and other support
possible in order to shorten your im- devices. Do not lean on rails or life-
mersion time. lines.
Remember, you lose body heat many 4. Be alert when moving around the main
times faster in water than in air. Since deck of the ship and especially around
the effectiveness of your insulation is cable and rope. Keep hands out of
seriously reduced by water soaking, pockets, free to grab for support if you
you must now try to shield yourself fall.
from wind to avoid a wind-chill effect 5. Be particularly careful at night or in
(convective cooling). If you manage to fog. Poor visibility increases both the
dimb aboard a life-boat, shielding can chances of accident and the difficulties
be accomplished with the aid of a can- in locating you in the water.
5.10 Search and Rescue Medicine - Survival at Sea 401
5.10.6 Treatment of Hypothermia 5. Insulate the victim from further heat loss
by warming hirn in ablanket. 00 not at-
The treatment of hypothermia will, of tempt to aggressively rewarm the uncon-
course, depend on both the condition of scious victim. Severe hypothermia is a
the survivor and the facilities available. true medical emergency, but rewarming
Generally speaking, survivors who are ra- the victim can be associated with many
tional and capable of recounting their ex- complications. Definitive rewarming
periences, although shivering dramatically, should be attempted in a hospital. The
merely require removal of all wet clothes, main goal in providing first-aid is to pre-
replacement with dry clothes or blankets vent the victim from getting colder.
and rest in a warm environment. 6. If there will be a long delay in getting the
In more serious cases, where the victim is victim to a hospital, gentle rewarming
semiconscious, unconscious or apparently techniques may be used:
dead, contact should be made immediately a) Apply heating pads or hot-water bot-
with a ship or shore medical facility for de- tles under the blanket, to the victim's
tailed information on the care and han- head, neck, chest and groin. Keep the
dling of the victim. While awaiting medical victim wrapped in the bl anket.
instructions, the following first-aid care b) Apply body warmth by direct body-
should be administered immediately: to-body contact with the victim. A
1. Remove the victim from the cold; rescue blanket should be wrapped around
and carry hirn if possible only in a hori- both people to conserve the heat be-
zontal position; do not move hirn unnec- ing supplied.
essarily and be sure to avoid rough han- 7. In no case should the victim be given al-
dling; check for the presence of breath- cohol. Unconscious victims should be
ing and heartbeat. given nothing to eat or drink.
2. Take the victim to a sheltered place; re- It should be kept in mind that the tech-
move his clothes with a minimum of niques of rescue procedures including the
movement of the victim's body; cut the treatment of hypothermia differ very wide-
clothes away with scissors or knife, if ly from country to country. Especially the
necessary. 00 not massage. appropriate treatment of hypothermia is
3. Lay the unconscious or semiconscious still under discussion, and even specialists
victim in the recovery position. Be sure have different opinions in rewarming tech-
to check the victim's breathing and niques.
heartbeat frequently. One must be pre-
pared to give cardio-pulmonary resusci-
tation if breathing and heartbeat stop.l 5.10.7 Motion Sickness
4. If available, administer warm, humidifi-
ed oxygen by face mask. The oxygen will Motion sickness is an age-old problem for
not only benefit victims if they are hav- seafarers. In the development of the tented
ing difficulty breathing or have a low re- inflatable life-craft it became evident early
spiratory rate, it will also provide some on that this is a particularly seasickness-in-
core rewarming. ducing craft. The crew are enclosed with-
out any horizon and the raft is flexible and
It should be accepted that even a doctor might adheres to the surface, so that its floor fol-
have difficulty in detecting a pulse or breathing lows the contour of even the smallest wave.
movements in a severely hypothennic patient. It is most important that motion sickness
The patient is particularly prone to the onset of
serious cardiac irregularity. In consequence there should be prevented in raft occupants. Sea-
are considerable differences of opinion on the sick men lying immobile in the bottom of a
administration of CPR. craft are much more likely to become casu-
5.10 Search and Rescue Medicine - Survival at Sea 403
alties from hypothermia. Sickness can lead Considerable further work has been
to loss of morale and so to failure to per- done on motion sickness, with some ad-
form essential actions such as eIosing down vance in fundamental understanding. A
and bailing, searching for further survivors, particularly important contribution was by
tying rafts together, and so forth. Vomiting Johnson et al. [15] and Johnson and Mayne
causes loss of body fluids and so acceler- [14], who demonstrated convincingly the
ates death from dehydration. importance of Coriolis Force as a factor in
Holling et al. [11] tackled the problem on the causation of motion sickness. Although
behalf ofthe Armed Forces and carried out it is difficult to relate it to the survival-at-
some of the first systematic and realistic sea situation, the development of de-condi-
experiments on prevention of motion sick- tioning treatment in the RAF by Dobie [5]
ness. They began by investigating the pro- was an important therapeutic advance. The
prietary "seasick medicines" of the day, study of brain-stem neurotransmitters
and found "Mother Siegal's Soothing Syr- opens up the possibilities of a better under-
up" the most effective. This contained hy- standing of the physiological processes
oscine, which they then studied systemati- which produce motion sickness, and may
caIly. They found that doses of 0.6 or eventually lead to a new rationale for seek-
1.2 mg were highly effective, provided the ing preventive drugs. Money [18] has pub-
drug was given weIl before the onset of mo- lished an excellent review of the natural
tion. Some of the test subjects complained history and pathogenesis of motion sick-
of dryness of the mouth, but the authors ness.
did not regard this as a serious disadvan-
tage. They stressed the difficulty of per-
forming satisfactory trials at sea, where the 5.10.8 Water
motion was never the same from day to
day, and suggested that some form of ma- A survivor who has reached a life-craft has
chine might be built to simulate wave mo- also to face the hazards of dehydration. A
tion. They obtained some results with a man's water requirements vary consider-
swing, but did not consider this adequately ably with a) the environmental tempera-
simulated a ship. ture, wind and sun, b) his eIothing and mi-
In the United States, Tyler and Bard [20] ero-environment, c) his physique and phys-
wrote an important review of motion sick- ical activity, d) the past and present nature
ness. The discovery by Gay and Carliner [6] of his food and e) his renal efficiency
that Dramamine was an effective treatment (Adolph, et al. [1]). The physiology of the
received publicity, but their work was not urge to drink and the problem ofwater lack
weIl controlled and this drug has since be- have been collated by Wolf [23].
come less popular. Chinn et al. [3] investi- Although water carried in containers is
gated a large number of remedies. Glaser relatively heavy, it is a sure source of sup-
[7] studied the side-effects of hyoscine, ply and makes the minimum demands on
promethazine hydrochloride and diphen- effort by an exhausted man (Holt [12]).
hydramine hydrochloride in subjects on Chemical desalting kits are not favoured as
land. He coneIuded that the side-effects they are expensive and troublesome to
were proportional to the drugs' ability to operate. These kits give about a five-fold
prevent motion sickness, and might reflect gain in terms of space or weight and have
a common hyoscine-like action. Tolerance application where these are not the aIl-im-
was acquired after administration for portant factors as, for example, in one-man
4 days. He also noted that the experimental dinghies. A solid-fuel still which was tested
procedure without drugs sometimes pro- during the Singapore trials produced lethai
voked the "side-effects". concentrations of carbon monoxide (0.2%)
404 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
immersed in the ocean. J. Amer. med. Ass. 131, 21. Ungley, C. C.: The immersion foot syndrome.
1046-1050 (1946). Advanc. Surg. 1,269-336 (1949).
18. Money, K.E.: Motion siclmess. Physiol. Rev. 22. Ungley, C. c., G. D. Channell and R L.
50,1,1-39 (1970). Richards: The immersion foot syndrome. Brit.
19. Scott-Daniel, D.: World WarI: an illustrated J. Surg. 33, 17-31 (1945).
history. London: Benn 1965. 23. Wolf, A. V.: Thirst - physiology of the urge to
20. Tyler, D.B. and Ph. Bard: Motion siclmess. drink and the problems of water lack. Spring-
Physiol. Rev. 29,4,311-369 (1949). field: Thomas 1958.
5.11 Life-Saving Appliances
R.Hernnann
In spite of rapid progress in the technology The contents of the book record the con-
of ship construction and navigation, the struction and practical application in addi-
problem of developing the best possible tion to dealing with future construction
life-saving appliances to ensure certain sur- forms. In conclusion the author indicated
vival for seamen in all weather conditions the full extent of the difficulties. In Decem-
and in every distress situation still has not ber 1972 in The Standard Specijications for
been solved. Merchant Ship Construction of the Mari-
Technical publications deal exhaustively time Administration [27], the standards of
with this problem. As earlyas 1947 Sweger individual and collective life-saving appli-
[28] examined the question, "What have ances are described.
you done for the fleet sailor's life?" in a re- Haag and Jacobi [4, 5, 6, 7] described the
port entitled Advances in Shipboard Life- extent and use of different types oflife-sav-
saving Equipment. He outlines the history ing appliances. The details of their use in
of life-saving appliances, reports on the certain emergencies are given, together
currently available life-saving appliances with defects which have been found in
and speculates on future developments in practice. Comment was made on the guide-
the expectation of nearing an optimum. He lines which are to be found in the recom-
presents a few answers to his question; mendations and instructions issued by the
however he adds, "But to carry on even See-Berufsgenossenschaft and other ma-
more effectively it is time for the U. S. Navy rine authorities. The authors emphasize
to recognize the need and dedicate men, that the suggested improvements are tech-
money and resources to the successful nically possible and could be achieved if
implementation of a complete and co-ordi- properly funded.
nated programme designed to protect and The different life-saving appliances may
save the lives of our men." From this sen- be categorized as follows:
tence we may infer that the author thought 1. Individuallife-saving appliances
at the time that more must be done in that 2. Collective life-saving appliances
direction. 3. Life-saving appliances designed to res-
Holt [10] described the development of cue the shipwrecked of other ships.
life-saving appliances, giving special atten- This chapter deals with the first two
tion to life-jackets and different sorts of in- types, as well as discussing cold protection
flatable life-rafts, immersion suits and dis- suits.
tillation apparatus.
Nicholl [19] detailed, in 1960, in his work 5.11.1 Individual Life-Saving
Survival at Sea, under the headings "Histo-
Appliances (Life-jackets)
ry", "Application" and "Technology", the
problems posed by different life-saving ap- When ships are abandoned and also in oth-
pliances ranging from life-jackets and life- er shipping emergencies, it may be nec-
rafts through to water distillation systems. essary to spend relatively long periods im-
5.11 Life-Saving Appliances 407
(Fig. 5), turn it on its back (Figs.6, 7) and the buoyancy ofthe life-jacket (A2 and A3)
maintain it in this position. However, the acts at its flotation points (F2 and F3). The
head would automatically sink backwards ; stability of the whole system depends on
in order to counteract this effect an addi- the distance between the point (F) - the
tional buoyant appliance should support centre of gravity - and the point (G) - the
the head from behind. Measures should al- buoyancy capacity of the whole system.
so be taken to prevent sideways tilting. The greater the distance between (F) and
These measures will require a higher (G), the more stable is the whole system. It
buoyancy than the above-mentioned 4.5 kp is important that (F) lies above (G). The
(45 N) in order to bring ab out the best posi- system shown in the last diagram is the one
tioning in the water. most commonly used in shipping today.
In accordance with the different possible However, the author's investigations have
uses, the volume of a life-jacket varies from shown that considerable problems arise in
10 to 16dm3 (sports sailing) up to 16dm3 rough seas. The inertia of the human body
(professional shipping). The life-jacket's in water delays its movement in the waves
surplus buoyancy volume protruding even when a life-jacket with a greater vol-
above the surface stabilizes the whole sys- urne is worn. This results in the face of a
tem and counteracts submersion ofthe face person floating in the sea being periodical-
when the sea becomes rough. Thus the per- ly and unavoidably under water at a wave-
son is enabled to make the necessary move- height of 60-80 cm. The life-jackets ap-
ments to stay afloat. The now completely proved of by merchant shipping do not
serviceable life-jacket is shown in Fig. 8, prevent this happening at a frequency of
whereby the buoyancy of the human body 15- 20 per minute, the duration lying be-
(A1) acts at its centre of gravity (F1), and tween 20% and 30% of the total immersion
5.11 Life-Saving Appliances 409
Fig.9. Fig.11.
Macintosh and Pask [16] were the first to lished in 1974 in the international agree-
report on methods of testing life-jackets. ment for safety on ships [11]. Nearly all na-
The authors describe the technique of intu- tional regulations conform to this agree-
bation anaesthesia which enables the ment.
experiments to be done on unconscious Lauckner [13, 14, 15] describes the histor-
subjects - in this case, anaesthetized per- ical development of life-jackets, man's
sons. The most important result of this physical capacity to swim and the stability
rather heroic test was the discovery that the of the body in relation to the Iife-jacket.
best floating position of the human body The physical principles of appliances for
could be reached at an angle of 45°to the individuallife saving are clearly defined by
surface. means of sketches and formulae.
Bernhardt [1] describes the physical Pask [22] gives an insight into the prob-
aspects of the human body in relation to lems of life-jackets in practice. He also re-
swimming. Based on the physical proper- ports on experiments with anaesthetized
ti es of the body, he offers some construc- persons. In his opinion such experiments
tional suggestions on how to design the are impracticable for the future . He recom-
best life-jackets. These propositions are mends conducting such experiments with
presented in diagram form, backed up by immersible dummies which should func-
physical and mechanical laws and formu- tion in a way as near as possible to persons
lae. swimming. In conclusion he gives the crite-
A detailed standardization of regulations ria which lead to the development of such
for life-jackets on merchant ships was pub- dummies and describes first experiments
5.11 Life-Saving Appliances 411
cold water and they cause profuse sweating caused the incapacitation that led to the
if worn in warm surroundings, especially if immersion incident.
there is work to be done. It is often neces- 4. If ventilatory support is required, PEEP
sary for protective c10thing to be put on should be instituted as soon as possible.
sometime before an anticipated emergency. Keatinge [12] writes in his book Survival
This aspect limits the usefulness of such in Cold Water about the physiology and
suits which, up to now, have been worn on- treatment of immersion hypothermia and
ly in special circumstances such as off- of drowning. The mechanism of body tem-
shore drilling projects or on transport heli- perature control and the effect of the c1oth-
copters over cold seas. ing and fitness on body temperature are
The Intergovermental Maritime Consul- considered. The author suggests points in
tive Organization (IMCO) published a re- the treatment of hypothermia immersion
port in 1970 entitled "Prevention of Hypo- victims when the factors of age, drugs, al-
thermia" [23] in which the various aspects cohol and acc1imatization have influenced
are examined in detail. This report deals the core-temperature regulation of the
with the physiological processes of the body.
body under the influence of such factors as Mac1ean and Emslie-Smith [17] publish-
age, drugs, alcohol and c10thing and their ed their book Accidental Hypothermia in
relation to consequent symptoms and indi- 1977. This can be considered as the most
cations of hypothermia. The treatment of comprehensive work on hypothermia and
persons suffering from hypothermia and its treatment.
the changes in their condition are de- Hayward et al. [8] describe the effective-
scribed. The subcommittee thinks that still ness of 23 different cold protection suits,
more should be done to prevent hypo- inc1uding a few diving-suits. Experiments
thermia and recommends that the follow- with and without cold protection suits are
ing points be taken into consideration in compared.
future studies: The Finnish Board of Navigation pub-
1. To investigate the criteria of selection, lished in 1981 Testing of Immersion Suits
training and acc1imatisation; [29], in which nine cold protection suits
2. To improve the specific treatment of from Finland, Norway, the U. S. A. and
complications of hypothermia; Canada are examined in extensive testing
3. To define the nature ofthe best cold pro- reports in relation to their cold protection
tection (sort of c1othing, use of oil or other effectiveness.
material).
Golden [3] gives a detailed report on the
problems of immersion and comes to the 5.11.3 Collective Life-Saving
following conc1usions: Appliances
1. All immersion casualties should be ad-
mitted to hospital for observation. If wa- The function of collective life-saving appli-
ter has been inhaled and there are c1ini- ances is to offer protection to fairly large
cal signs in the chest they should be numbers of people after the ship has been
admitted to an intensive treatment unit. abandoned. There are different systems,
2. Attempts at resuscitation should always but each system has its own drawbacks and
be made in apparently dead hypother- advantages. Life-boats have the advantage
mic immersion victims and only aban- of easy manoeuvrability, which means,
doned if unsuccessful after rewarming firstly, that survivors floating about in the
has occurred. sea can be systematically rescued, and sec-
3. Always consider the possibility that an ondly, that the boat can be steered. The dis-
underlying pathological disturbance . advantage is their vulnerability in rough
5.11 Life-Saving Appliances 413
seas. Unfortunately it often happens that Survival chances are greatly endangered
the boat is so badly damaged by the rough if the supply of water on a lifeboat is not
weather before the dis aster that it is no sufficient. Most lifeboats contain only
longer seaworthy when required. It is also enough water to provide half a litre a day
not always possible to lower the boat when per person for aperiod of 1 week.
the ship is listing. The danger of hypo- One danger exists in every collective life-
thermia is also present in the case of open saving appliance, especially the covered in-
boats sailing in bad weather as the c10thing flatable life-rafts, namely a higher risk of
of the people on board is constantly motion sickness. Apart from the general
soaked, resulting in a considerable evap- physical and mental weakening of the af-
orative cooling due to high winds. fected person, the loss of fluid which ac-
Rigid life-rafts are less easily damaged companies motion sickness is extremely
but it is just as difficult to get them into the dangerous when coupled with the limited
water. Covered rafts help prevent hypo- water supply on board. It is therefore ex-
thermia. All life-rafts are difficult to ma- tremely important to provide the crew with
noeuvre or steer in comparison with a life- medication against sea sickness at least
boat. The currently used system allows 1 hour before the expected abandonment
inflatable life-rafts to be floated without of the ship. Simultaneously the crew mem-
any damage ensuing. But the danger re- bers should put on cold protection suits if
mains that they will drift in high winds. such suits are available. Failing this warm,
These rafts are therefore attached to the insulating c10thing should be worn.
ship by a cord which must have a specific It is c1ear that at present conventional
breaking point so that the sinking ship does lifeboats and inflatable life-rafts do not of-
not pull the life-raft down with it. But as fer the best solution. For this reason con-
high winds may cause similar tension there troversial views are common in many tech-
is a danger that the cord will snap at the nical publications.
specific breaking point and the raft would Müller et al. [18] treat the problem of
then drift away before the crew can c1imb drinking water conservation in lifeboats.
in. Unfortunately, inflatable life-rafts cap- Among other things they describe conser-
size fairly often when set into water or in- vation experiments. Drinking water from a
flated and they may be difficult to right in public water supply was used to fill poly-
bad weather. Inflatable life-rafts offer good ethylene cans with a volume of 30litres
protection against the weather, and hypo- each. After being treated with 0.1 mg per li-
thermia is not to be feared if an adequate tre Ag (silver colloids), the cans were stored
number of people are on board. for 3 years and were frequently examined
Currently, some countries are investigat- for bacteriological and chemical state. The
ing methods whereby life-saving appli- results showed the water had no objection-
ances can be launched when the ship is able properties even when some cans had
floating in an abnormal position, e. g. list- been kept under tropical conditions. The
ing. Ideally, any new system should be in- possibility of contaminating water reser-
stalled in the superstructure ofthe ship and voirs in lifeboats has always been very high
be approachable from the emergency as- and means of preventing this should be in-
sembly point without it being necessary to troduced.
cross the dangerous open decks. The crew Herrmann and Stöver [9] describe bac-
should be able to launch the capsule from teriological examinations of drinking water
shipboard sitting inside the capsule. Once from lifeboats on ships under German and
these survival capsules are in water, they other flags. There were no serious hygienic
shou,ld give the crew the best possible pro- differences between water from horne and
tection. foreign ships.
414 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
Drinking water that had been frequently interior atmosphere. A positive pressure
changed was prone to bacteriological con- builds up within the boat, preventing the
tamination. It is clear that this contamina- penetration of vapours and gases.
tion of the water had been brought about in Hansa [25] reports on a Swedish study
most cases during the exchange of the new made on life-saving appliances carried out
water for the old. In order to avoid diar- by the Kockums Shipyard. They developed
rhoea among the crew members during a type of survival capsule that acts as a
long periods in life-boats the authors rec- shelter and control room from which mea-
ommend that pure drinking water be stored sures to save the ship can be taken. The
for at least a year and an approved water capsule should be placed as near to the ac-
disinfectant be added. Because of the fa- comodation quarters as possible and, being
vourable long-term effect the authors rec- accessible from the free deck and stairway,
ommend colloidal silver treatment in pref- serves as the main assembly point in an
erence to other disinfecting processes. emergency. Other features were a gim-
In Hansa [2] areport appeared in 1977 balled structure to retain its usefulness
on the first self-stabilizing, self-bailing life- even if the ship listed, fire proofing, ade-
boats for effective use. These boats are not quate ventilation and the ability to remain
completely covered, which makes the self- afloat even if the ship should sink. When
bailing design necessary. The boats were floating, the deck of the capsule was sup-
tested by the See-Berufsgenossenschaft on posed to act as a helicopter touch-down
their self-bailing and -righting capaeity. pad.
When fully flooded the boat bails itself out Zander [31] makes recommendations for
completely in approximately 20 s. When self-rescue measures for the crews of mer-
the boat was forced to keel over it righted chant ships. A newly developed life-saving
itself in ab out 6 s. The water which poured appliance should be constructed to be easy
into it as the boat was stabilizing itself and safe when put into action, to have shel-
(ab out 20% ofthe inner volume ofthe boat) tered access and to have prolonged attach-
had run out after 7 s. The engine, which au- ment to the ship until its sinking becomes
tomatically shuts down if the boat capsizes, inevitable. The appliance should be opti-
could be started immediately after the boat mally designed so as to allow for self-res-
was upright. eue in all eireumstanees, e.g. fire and sink-
In another publication [30] other types of ing. Developmental considerations are de-
boats are reported on. These were intro- scribed in as much detail as the early
duced by Watercraft Ud., Boat Building planning stage allows.
Company. Of glass-fibre manufacture, The appliance is a so-called survival cap-
these boats are completely covered and are sule, which can be entered by the crew di-
for use on tankers, including gas-tankers, rectly from the assembly point in emergen-
and also in a modified version on offshore eies. The appliance must be able to with-
oil-rigs, production platforms and drilling stand fire on board for aperiod before it is
ships. These boats should enable the crew launched. The crew should be able to
to leave a danger area consequent upon launch it at any time without additional
any and every imaginable hazard. This help.
boat's crew is completely independent of Överaas [20] describes the results of a
the exterior atmosphere. Fire safeguards Scandinavian research project which also
fixed to the outer boat, i. e. spraysystems, deals with a survival capsule. In contrast to
protect the whole surface for up to 10 min the ones in the aforementioned excerpts
in case of fire. This means a distance of from the literature, this capsule is not at-
1 mile at a speed of 6 knots. Compressed tached to the superstructure of the ship.
air is available in the boat to maintain the However, it can be launched in any posi-
5.11 Life-Saving Appliances 415
tion the ship might take. Freefall from 14. Lauckner, G.: Überleben in Seenot. 11. Ein Ka-
heights of 20 m, pitching angle of up to pitel über "Schwimmphysik". Kommodore 4,
262-265 (1963).
15° and a listing position of up to
15. Lauckner, G.: Überleben in Seenot. III.Stabi-
300should be possible. Ifthe ship sinks, au- lität des Körpers und der Einheit Körper-
tomatie release is planned. This life-saving Schwimmweste. Kommodore 5, 323-326
appliance has already been tested in prac- (1963).
tiee. 16. Macintosh, R. R. and E. A. Pask: The testing of
life-jackets. Brit. 1. industr. Med. 14, 168-176
(1957).
17. Maclean, D. and D.Emslie-Smith: Accidental
References hypothermia. Oxford: Blackwell1977.
18. Müller, G., Th.Kempf, H.Goethe et al.: Trink-
1. Bernhardt, J.: Der Mensch im Medium Wasser. wasserkonserven für Rettungsboote. Forum
Ein Beitrag zur Problematik der Schwimm- Städte-Hygiene 28, 2, 33-34 (1977).
weste. Schiff und Hafen 11. 3, 244-247 (1959). 19. Nicholl, G. WR.: Survival at sea. The develop-
2. Die ersten selbstaufrichtenden selbstlenzenden ment, operation and design of inflatable marine
Rettungsboote für den praktischen Einsatz. lifesaving equipment. London: Coles, Harrap;
Hansa 114, 19,1715-1716 (1977). New York: de Graff 1960.
3. Golden, F. St. c.: Problems of immersion. Brit. 20. Överaas, S.: Die Entwicklung neuer Rettungs-
J. Hosp. Med. 23,4,371-383 (1980). mittel. Schiff und Hafen 29, 9, 838-841 (1977).
4. Haag, R. and H.Jacobi: Art, Umfang und Ein- 21. Pask, E.A.: The design oflife-jackets. Brit. med.
satz von Rettungsmitteln. Einzelrettungsmittel. 1. 11,1140-1142 (1961).
Part 1. Hansa 116,17,1311-1314(1979). 22. Pask, E.A.: Prüfung des Individuellen Ret-
5. Haag, R. and H.Jacobi: Gruppenrettungsmit- tungsmittels in physiologischer Hinsicht. Mitt.
tel. Part 2. Rettungsboote. Hansa 116, 19, Dtsch. Ges. Verkehrsmed. 15,21-31 (1964).
1473-1476 (1979). 23. Prevention of hypothermia. Note by the Secre-
6. Haag, R. and H.Jacobi: Gruppenrettungsmit- tariat. IMCO. Sub-Committee on Life-Saving
tel. 2. Teil: Rettungsflöße. Hansa 116, 20, Appliances. 11th Session. Agenda item 5. Ge-
1569-1571 (1979). neva,22ApriI1977.
7. Haag, R. and H.Jacobi: Gruppenrettungsmit- 24. Prüfungs- und Zulassungsbedingungen für Ret-
tel. Schluß: Fremdrettung. Hansa 116, 21, tungswesten. 250ctober 1977. Hamburg: SBG
1657-1658 (1979). Hamburg 1978.
8. Hayward, 1. S., P. A. Lisson and M. L. Collins: 25. Rettungsmittelstudie aus Schweden. Hansa 115,
Survival suits for accidental immersion in cold 5,417 (1978).
water: Design concepts and their thermal pro- 26. Richtlinien für die Herstellung und Prüfung
tection performance. Ed.: University of Victo- von Rettungswesten für die Sportschiffahrt.
ria. Victoria 1978. Bundesanzeiger No. 140, 30July 1977.
9. Herrmann, R. and A.Stöver: Seenot-Trinkwas- 27. Standard specifications for merchant ship con-
ser. Hansa 115,15/16, 1311-1314(1978). struction. Springfield: U. S. Dept. of Com-
10. Holt, WJ.: Recent developments in navallife- merce, Maritime Administration 1972.
saving equipment. Transact. Institut. nav. Ar- 28. Sweger, G. A.: What have you done for the fleet
chitects 97, 331-352 (1955). sailor's life today? Advances in shipboard life-
11. Internationales Übereinkommen von 1974 zum saving equipment. Washington: Association of
Schutz des menschlichen Lebens auf See Senior Engineers of the Naval Ship Systems
(SOLAS 74). BGBL Teil 11, 8 (1979). Command. Department ofthe Navy. 1974.
12. Keatinge, WR.: Survival in cold water. The 29. Testing of immersion suits. Finnish Board of
physiology and treatment of immersion hypo- Navigation 1981.
thermia and of drowning. Oxford: Blackwell 30. Watercraft enclosed lifeboats. Schiff und Hafen
1969. 28.10,991 (1976).
13. Lauckner, G.: Überleben in Seenot. I. Die 31. Zander, A.: Überlegungen zur Eigenrettung von
Schwimmweste - "Eyn gar nuetzlich Geraet" - Handelsschiffsbesatzungen. Schiff und Hafen
Kleiner Streifzug durch die Geschichte. Kom- 33, 12, 74-76 (1981). Dtsch. Küstenschiffahrt
modore 3, 198-204 (1963). 11,322-324 (1981).
5.12 Offshore Medicine
R.A.F.Cox
The term "offshore medicine" covers all are allowed offshore, the incidence of ma-
health matters which arise in connection jor medical problems is minimised.
with the exploration for and production of The medical examination for offshore
hydrocarbons from beneath the sea. Such work is designed to detect conditions
activities now take place on most of the which would be a danger to the employee
world's continental shelves in water depths or to others in the remote, offshore envi-
to 1000 m, often in extremely hostile condi- ronment where the only source of immedi-
tions and sometimes in areas remote from ate medical assistance is the medic. From
medical services of any sort. Offshore work time to time offshore installations may be
falls into one ofthree phases - exploration, completely isolated by bad weather, per-
development and construction, and pro- haps for several days. Fog, for example,
duction. During the first phase, drilling is may prevent any movement of helicopters
conducted from isolated mobile structures while evacuation by sea may take 48 h or
which usually have 75-100men on board. more.
In the second phase there is pipelaying and Drillings rigs and barges do not have
heavy engineering and construction taking spare quarters or reserve crew and, there-
place from various specialised vessels fore, anyone sick or injured and unable to
which may have crews of up to 350 or work for more than about 24 h must be sent
400 men. Diving is a prominent activity ashore. Not only are such evacuations ex-
during this period. In the third phase the pensive, they mayaiso be dangerous.
oil and gas is in continuous production and When a siek man needs to be evaeuated in
the main activities are those of control, bad weather conditions, the helicopter
monitoring and maintenance. Throughout crew may weIl be endangering their own
the life of a field, which averages 12-20 lives. At least one helicopter with all its
years, medical support must be provided at crew, including a medical team, has been
the site and on shore to cover environ- lost during a medical evacuation in the
mental hygiene, day-to-day health care of North Sea.
the workers, major disasters and occupa- The medical policy conceming stan-
tional health. dards of fitness must, therefore, take ac-
The various functions are discharged by count of these factors and no person
appropriately trained nurses or sick berth should be allowed offshore with any detec-
attendants (known as medics) on the instal- table medical condition which could dete-
lations themselves and by properly orga- riorate or become complicated and require
nised supporting services from doctors and urgent medical intervention within 48 h.
hospitals on shore. The offshore medics The policy must also take account of infec-
need suitably designed and equipped hos- tious or contagious diseases which could
pitals or sick bays from which to work. By be a danger to others and of disabilities
ensuring that all offshore employees meet which may be a liability to the person af-
certain basic medical standards before they fected or to others should an emergency
5.12 Offshore Medicine 417
arise which may be serious enough to re- their continued fitness for offshore em-
quire evacuation of the rig. ployment. In all cases where fitness for off-
The examining doctor should be aware shore work is confirmed, the employee
of the fact that the financial rewards of the should be fumished with a written state-
offshore industry are so attractive that ment to that effect. Many companies and
some potential employees will go to great some Govemment agencies will require
lengths to conceal their disabilities. The ex- this to be entered on an official document.
aminer should take a very detailed medical,
personal and occupational history and the 5.12.1 The Medics
examination itself should be no less thor-
ough. Routine ancillary investigations are The term "medic" deserves a little explana-
not necessary, though a ehest X-ray is tion. It is in common use throughout the
usually advisable and an audiometry will offshore industry to describe the appointed
provide a permanent record of the employ- person, irrespective of his qualifications,
ee's hearing, which is important as offshore who is responsible for all medical and
structures may be noisy. Most companies health matters. The term "nurse" does not
will supply detailed forms for recording the adequately describe this more highly quali-
results of the examination. fied status, while "paramedie" is usually
In some countries, Norway for example, applied to an American type of medical
the examinations are legally required and auxiliary whose functions are rather differ-
official forms must be completed by the ex- ent. "Emergency medical technician" is too
amining doctor, who must also be ap- cumbersome and pretentious while the
proved by the Norwegian Health Director- term "medie" has a friendly connotation
ate. In other countries, such as the U. K., about it and its exact meaning is clearly un-
there is, at present, no statutory require- derstood by all who work offshore.
ment although it is accepted by the respon- The medic is the key to the provision of
sible Govemment agencies that such ex- good offshore medical care. He will cope
aminations are necessary and they have with the day-to-day minor complaints of
approved the medical standards of fitness the crew as weIl as being the source of
which have been compiled by the industry. skilled first aid and immediate primary
These standards are contained in the book care in the event of single or multiple major
Recommended General Medical Standards accidents. He must be able to examine a
of Fitness for Designated Offshore Employ- patient, accurately assess his clinical condi-
ees [6] published by the United Kingdom tion and convey his findings precisely and
Offs hore Operators Association (UKOOA) objectively to the supporting doctor on
and obtainable from that organisation at shore, under whose direction he will be
192 Sloane Street, London SW1X 9QX. It working. He is, in short, the eyes and ears
is suggested that any doctor called upon to of the shore-based doctor, who depends
examine an offshore employee should first entirely upon the medic for reaching his
consult this document. The standards have clinical decisions until he arrives on site
been compiled primarily to cover persons himself.
working in the North Sea but the principles Apart from their purely medical func-
embodied apply to offs hore locations any- tions, the medics also have other duties, in-
where in the world. A more detailed discus- cluding maintaining all medical and first
sion of offshore medical fitness can be aid equipment on board, making regular
found in Offshore Medicine [5]. hygiene inspections and writing reports,
Apart from their pre-placement exami- first aid training, participation in safety
nations, offshore employees should be re- meetings and counselling, as well as var-
examined every 2 or 3 years to determine ious non-medical clerical duties.
418 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
Most offshore me dies are registered in the medics' training and refresher
nurses or equivalent or military siek berth courses.
attendants with additional training and ex- Though most offshore medics are male,
perience. There is now an increasing ten- there are now an increasing number of fe-
dency to employ only registered nurses male nurses being employed and this is
(SRN in the U. K.), partly to ensure that likely to rise in the future as more women
they have the essential basic training and in other jobs are employed offshore.
partly because the professional status con- The medic can expect to perform about
ferred by such an official qualification con- 6 new consultations per day for every
fers medicolegal protection both on the 100 men on board, and, on average, about
medic and on the doctor from whom he is 3 people per 2000 are sent ashore daily for
taking instructions. The responsibilities of medical reasons.
a medic, and the difficulties oftraining and Doctors are permanently stationed off-
up-grading persons with lesser qualifica- shore in some operations where there may
tions, are such that anyone lacking a full be more than 1 500 people living. In these
nursing qualification should be considered circumstances some operators claim that
for employment only in the most excep- the additional cost of a doctor is balanced
tional circumstances. by the saving in the reduction of medical
Having acquired his or her basic nursing evacuations and lost working time. How-
qualification, the potential medic will need ever, at the present time, doctors offshore
several years post-qualification experience, are the exception rather than the rule.
especially in departments such as accident
and emergency, ophthalmology, otolaryng- 5.12.2 Back-Up Services
ology, dermatology and venereal diseases.
The technical skills he must acquire are Alloffshore operations are dependent up-
the setting up of intravenous infusions, on shore-based medical services for sup-
simple suturing, cardio-pulmonary resusci- port. This may be in the form of advice fur-
tation and endotracheal or oesophageal nished to the medic by radio, the reception
obturator intubation, gastric lavage and on shore of patients evacuated for medical
bladder catheterisation. He must also de- reasons or the despatch of a doctor or spe-
velop his diagnostie skills and have a good eialised medical team to the offshore loea-
knowledge of therapeutics. Above all, he tion in the event of a major incident.
must have the necessary knowledge, skills In most areas ashore medical support is
and confidence to aet independently and organised in two tiers; a primary care team
without direct supervision. At the same usually consisting of local general praeti-
time he must be aware of his professional tioners, and a specialist team for major
limitations. disasters.
In order that he can maintain all these at- It is necessary to have a doctor perma-
tributesand skills he must regularly attend nently on call so that he can give radio ad-
practical refresher courses at appropriate vice to the medics or can fly offshore im-
hospitals. Such courses last for about mediately in an emergency. It is usually
4 weeks and should be repeated every 2 or most convenient to equip the "on call" doc-
3 years. Only in this way will the medic be tors with pocket radios, to keep them on
adequately prepared to cope with any med- call and avoid restricting their mobility.
ical emergency which may occur. The members of the specialist team usually
In order that the closest possible rapport work full time in the local hospitals and so
can be established between the me dies and are readily obtainable by telephone. There
the supporting doctors ashore, it is a is also less urgency in mobilising a special-
great advantage if the latter can participate ist team.
5.12 Offshore Medicine 419
Both the primary doctors and the spe- mobilised to proceed to the site of the
cialist team must be properly equipped incident.
with all necessary drugs, dressings and 2. An adequate stock of drugs, dressings
equipment, as well as personal protective and equipment to be held on every off-
and survival clothing (dry immersion suits shore installation.
will be needed in all but tropical climates). 3. The designation ofthe nearest unaffect-
All members of the medical teams must ed installation for the reception of casu-
be familiar with the offshore environment alties for triage.
and each member must visit the offshore 4. The provision of adequate space on
installations and understand the activities every installation for the performance
which go on there. They must appreciate oftriage.
the logistics of helicopter and supply ship 5. The organisation of a properly trained
operations and be fully familiar with all the and equipped team of specialist doc-
channels of communication which they tors from shore hospitals who can be
may need to use. They must also be fully rapidly mobilised to fly to the rig.
trained and experienced in the technique 6. The integration of the offshore disaster
of being winched from a helicopter as they plan with other plans which may, or
will, not infrequently, find themselves should, have been made for handling
called to casualties on vessels which have local disasters.
no helicopter landing facilities. 7. The local police, hospital and other
The frequency of calls to the doctors emergency services must be fully incor-
ashore is variable. It is highest during the porated into the offshore disaster plan.
exploratory phase of the operation and es- 8. Adequate and additional communica-
pecially from rigs with new or inexperi- tion channels must be provided.
enced crews. It should be emphasised that 9. Administrative procedures for the
any advice tendered to a medic, even by ra- proper documentation and accounting
dio, may have serious medicolegal conse- of casualties and survivors must be es-
quences, and careful notes of all such con- tablished.
versations should always be kept. Where 10. A senior, knowledgeable and experi-
possible all instructions should be con- enced industry doctor must be located
firmed by telex. in the disaster control room where he
Specialist assistance from the shore will can advise the controllers on all medi-
be essential when major disasters occur. cal matters and especially on priorities.
The most likely causes of major disasters 11. All major dis aster procedures must be
are blowout (the uncontrolled emission of rehearsed from time to time.
gas or oil), fire, collisions or the foundering A detailed description of the organisa-
of a rig in a storm. In any of these events, tion required for the planning of major di-
total evacuation of the installation will be sasters appears in Offshore Medicine [5] and
necessary and the number of people in- in the Practitioner 1970 (Cox [1]).
volved may vary from 20 to 300 or more
with an equally variable number of casual- 5.12.3 Medical Facilities
ties.
Plans for such a dis aster must be careful- Some sort of first aid room or hospital is
ly formulated in advance. The important necessary on all manned offs hore struc-
features of such plans, which should be tures irrespective of their location or dis-
written into a manual, are as folIows: tance from the shore. Any facility must be
designed and equipped to accommodate
1. The provision of at least three primary patients for 48 h. It must also be sufficient-
care doctors who can be immediately ly equipped not only for the normal com-
420 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
plement of workers on the installation but the hospital, in spite of current practices on
also for the additional maintenance con- some ngs.
tractors and other workers who are fre- A more detailed description of offs hore
quently on board. It must be capable of medical facilities can be found in OJJshore
acting as adesignated reception pi ace for Medicine [5] and Offshore Services and
survivors from any adjacent rig. Technology (Cox [2]).
The size of the room will vary according Lists of suitable medical stores for off-
to the size of the vessel or installation but, shore hospitals may be found in OJJshore
on most rigs, a room of about 18 m2 is ade- Medicine [5], U. K. Statutory Instrument
quate. To comply with Norwegian regula- Number 1019[4] and the Norwegian regula-
tions, the hospital, if a single room, must be tions regarding medical facilities on off-
20 m2. The hospital should be located with shore installations [3].
easy access to elevators and the helideck
and close to a large room which, in a major 5.12.4 Special Problems
emergency, can be quickly cleared of all
furniture, to receive a large number of ca- Most of the medical problems associated
sualties for triage. A messroom, lounge or with offshore drilling and production arise
recreation room is often convenient. The from the geographical isolation and the
hospital must have a sink with elbow-op- hostile environment in which the activities
erated taps and an adjacent waterproof are conducted and trauma is the common-
work surface of adequate size. It will also est reason for medical intervention. How-
need aseparate toilet, washbasin and ever, there are a few specific problems
shower and the bathroom should contain a which should be mentioned:
standard bath for the immersion treatment
of cases of hypothermia. 5.12.4.1 Hydrogen Sulphide
There should be at least two free-stand- This so-called sour gas may occur in vary-
ing beds allowing access from all sides. On- ing concentrations but in some parts of the
lyon the very largest installations are more North Sea it may be as high as 500 parts
beds necessary. Bunks are not suitable. An per million (pprn). It may be encountered
examination couch and, preferably, a mi- unexpectedly during drilling, when uncon-
nor operating table will also be required. trolled release of gas may occur. It mayaiso
Good lighting with a shadowless light over occur in the stagnant water which accumu-
the table is essential. lates in oil storage reservoirs, oil water sep-
Plenty of storage space for stretchers, in- arators and the legs of offshore platforms
travenous fluids, blankets, resuscitators, and semi-submersibles. Respirators must
drugs, dressings and general equipment is be worn whenever the concentration rises
required, along with lockable storage cab- above 8ppm.
inets for medical records. A small refrigera-
tor and a steriliser or autoclave should also 5.12.4.2 Methane
be provided, and some form of incinerator Methane is the prineipal constituent ofnat-
for the disposal of dirty dressings is valu- ural gas, of which it constitutes about 85%
able. by volume. It is non-toxie but will cause
It is essential that there should be a radio asphyxia in high eoncentrations.
link extension in the hospital so that the
medic can speak directly to the doctor on 5.12.4.3 Methanol
shore without leaving the patient. There Methyl alcohol is used in gas production to
must also be a call system between the hos- prevent the formation of hydrates whieh
pital and the medic's cabin. It is not per- may freeze and obstruct the pipelines. For
missible for the medic to live and sleep in practical purposes it is only toxic if ingest-
5.12 Offshore Medicine 421
ed and offshore workers can therefore be noise, steps have been taken to reduce it on
reassured that they will not be exposed to modern installations and it is less of a prob-
any risk during their normal handling of lem than it used to be. Nevertheless, off-
the material. shore structures will never be as quiet as
most work-places on shore and there
5.12.4.4 Ethylene Glycol should be a hearing conservation pro-
This is used to absorb water during gas pro- gramme in operation for all offshore work-
duction and, like methanol, is only toxie ers.
when ingested.
5.12.4.7 Psychological Disturbances
5.12.4.5 Drilling Mud
When offshore exploration and production
The chemieally variable and complex ma-
first began in the North Sea in the mid-
terial used to lubricate the drilling bit, re-
1960s, psychological disturbances were
move rock fragments from the well and
common. Those most likely to suffer from
counteract the pressure ofhydrocarbons by
this problem have now "selected themselves
a hydrostatie counterpressure is known as
out" ofthe general pool of offs hore workers.
mud. The dry constituents are com-
Nevertheless, it is a problem in new areas
pounded in the mud room and then mixed
or when new, inexperienced crews are re-
with water or oil before injection into the
cruited. The offshore environment is an iso-
weIl. Common constituents of mud are
lated, rough, tough world where the men-
bentonite (a clay from volcanie ash), ba-
tal balance of any person who is not
rytes (barium sulphate), asbestos fibre, cel-
completely stable may well be disturbed.
lulose polymers, carboxymethyl cellulose,
Conditions on many drilling rigs are far
ligno-sulphonates, diatomaceous earth and
from comfortable, there is a lack of privacy
various caustic materials.
and a mixed community of people very dif-
If the operators do not handle drilling
ferent socially· and intellectually. There is
mud with care, wearing protective clothing
constant noise and intense, arduous work
all the time and respirators when appropri-
interspersed with periods of great bore-
ate, they may suffer serious effects on ~he
dom. The people most likely to develop
skin, eyes and respiratory tract accordmg
psychologieal symptoms, usually of anxi-
to the particular eonstituents. Many der-
ety or depression, are the more intelligent,
matologieal and other problems oeeurring
professional types, such as engineers and
in offshore workers ean be traeed to eon-
geologists. Some may have areal fear of
taet with drilling mud.
flying and the weekly helicopter ride may
5.12.4.6 Noise be a cause of severe stress. This has been
particularly notieeable after helicopter
Noise can be a serious problem, partieu-
crashes.
larly on the older structures, eausing in-
Occasionally a patient may develop an
somnia, stress and, in some eases, hearing
overt psychosis which can pose a difficult
loss. The highest noise levels occur in com-
management problem. He must be sedated
pressor houses and pump rooms, where ear
and confined until the arrival of a doctor
defenders must be worn, but there may be a
who will then need to sedate hirn very
high background noise level in the accom-
heavily for the helicopter journey ashore.
modation areas of some installations. In
these circumstances, where it may cause
5.12.4.8 Diving
stress and interfere with normal conversa-
tion, it may create a safety hazard by inter- The medieal problems associated with div-
fering with communieation. With the great- ing also figure prominently in the practice
er realisation of the potential dangers of of any doctor associated with the offshore
422 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
industry but they are dealt with in another 6. Recommended general medical standards of fit-
chapter of this book. ness for designated offshore employees. Ed.:
UKOOA. London 1983.
5.12.4.9 Summary
Additional References
Offshore drilling for oil and gas is a heavy
Medical aspects of North Sea oil (editorial). Brit.
arduous job, usually conducted in a harsh med. J. 3, 576-580 (1975).
and ho stile environment. Proper medical Offshore Medicine (editorial). Lancet 2: 751
support is an essential part ofthe operation (1977).
but it imposes upon those who provide that Proctor, D.M.: Medicine and the North Sea - hos-
pital support in offshore emergencies. J. Soc. oc-
support physical and professional chal- cup. Med. 26, 50-52 (1976).
lenges which they will not find in many Rawlins, J.S.: Medical problems in support ofthe
other aspects of medical practice. offshore oil industry. Trans. med. Soc., London
94,25-32 (1977-1978).
Medical problems of oil development in Shetland
(editorial). Scott. med. J. 20, 146-147 (1975).
References Shepherd, F.G.G.: Medicine and the North Sea-
emergencies for the general practitioner. 1. Soc.
1. Cox, RA.F.: An emergencyplan for an offshore occup. Med. 26, 50-52 (1976).
disaster. Practitioner 205, 663-670 (1970). Training of offshore sick bay attendants (rig med-
2. Cox, RA. F.: Offshore hospitals need better ics). Ed.: Health and Safety Executive. London:
design and expert advice. Offshore Services and H. M. S. O. 1978. (H and S Exec. Guidance Note
Technology, July 1982. MS16).
3. Norwegian Royal Decree of25th November 1977, Offshore construction health, safety and welfare
relating to hygiene, medical equipment and med- guidelines. Ed.: Health and Safety Executive.
icines, etc., on installations for production of London: H.M.S.O. 1980. (HS (G) 12).
submarine petroleum resources, etc. Oslo: So- Offshore installations' emergency procedures regu-
sialdepartmentet 1977. lations. London: H. M. S. O. 1976. (S1 no.1542).
4. Offshore installations (Operational Safety, Bustin, H. E.: Environmental health guidelines for
Health and Welfare) regulations 1976. London: offshore installations. Ed.: UKOOA. London
H. M. S. O. 1976. 1980.
5.0ffshore medicine. Ed.: RA.F. Cox. Berlin,
Heidelberg, New York: Springer 1982.
5.13 Underwater Medicine and Diving
ALow
Table 2. Brief history of development of diving worldwide [20). And finally, the medical
(Adapted from Bennett and Elliott [2]; [6]) principles of saturation diving were investi-
Approx. date Milestones, achievements or gated between the mid-1950s and 1962,
inventions opening new horizons for long sojourns,
330 B.C. Alexander goes underwater in a i. e. days or weeks, under pressure on the
"diving bell" . seabed ([20]; Ruff et al. [24]).
1535 de Lorena develops first true "div- Historie milestones in the conquest of
ing bell" the deep are thus of a medical as weIl as of
1620 von Driebel makes first submarine
a technical nature, the foremost ofthese be-
1640s von Treileben's primitive bell des-
cends to 132 ft (40 m) ing in the author's opinion Haldane's de-
1690-91 Halley builds first modern diving compression tables (1908) and Cousteau/
bell, descends to 60 ft (18 m) Gagnan's aqualung (1943). They have
1715 1-atm diving suit made by Lether- made diving on a worldwide scale possible.
idge
1774 Freminet develops a heimet-hose-
pump system and stays at 50 ft
(15 m) depth for 1 h 5.13.2 Diving
1790 Smeaton's diving bell with air
pump 5.13.2.1 Means and Methods of Diving
1819 Siebe (London) rivets a copper
heimet to a leather jacket and air In principle, there are four means of diving
hose from which all others have evolved: skin
1837 Siebe makes a waterproof suit diving with no aids; diving with a mask,
bolted to a breast-plate and heimet snorkel and fins; scuba (= self-contained
with valves and air-exhaust valves
1879 Fluess develops first scuba with underwater breathing apparatus) diving;
oxygen and finally, caisson/bell diving. Several
1913,1920 1-atm diving suits methods of diving exist and are used/ ap-
1926 Le Prieur patents a scuba plied according to the work, task, estimated
1930 First use of swim fins
duration etc. underwater. The most fre-
1933 1-atm diving suit
1943 Cousteau/Gagnan introduce their quent method is diving from the surface
aqualung (demand regulator) with and without scuba gear. The next most
1945 Browne makes a lightweight trian- frequent methods are partial saturation
gular diving mask for descents of diving from the surface in a bell and satura-
up to 90-100 ft (27-30m)
1962 First underwater saturation diving tion diving, e. g. from underwater habitats,
habitats with or without excursion dives to greater
1972 Development of a 1-atm armoured depths. Finally, in recent years, mini-sub-
suit "lim" usable to a max. depth marines with 1-atm internal pressure or
of 1 000 ft (300 m) (31 atm)
pressurisable to the ambient pressure and
i-atm armoured diving suits have been
used increasingly.
1878 Bert, a pioneer high-pressure re- Diving is performed by many hundreds
searcher, proved that gas bubbles appeared of thousands of people, by many govern-
during quick decompressions and found mental agencies and also by the military for
oxygen to be toxic at elevated pressures a great variety of reasons, but basically div-
(p02 > 2 atm). Haldane developed his now ing can be subdivided into sports-recrea-
famous decompression tables for com- tional-Ieisure diving, professional diving
pressed air work in about 1908 and End and scientific/research diving, in that order
dived to a depth of 420 ft (127 m) breathing of frequency (Table 3). Sports diving can
a helium/oxygen mixture in 1937. 1945 take place in inland waterways, i. e. rivers
saw the release of new US Navy decom- and lakes, and also along the coastlines of
pression tables that were so on to be used seas and oceans. Professional divers in
5.13 Underwater Medicine and Diving 425
Table 3. C1assification of diving and maximal as separate items. In this case, the mask on-
depths ly covers the eyes and nose. In scuba div-
Personnel Type of diving Max. depths ing, further equipment is required: one or
two compressed air cylinders (often called
Civilian Sports/recreational < 60m "tanks"), each of 7-12litres and pressur-
Commercial/profes- < 450m+
sional isable to 200-300 atm (2940-4410 psi). The
Scientificl research ,,;;;;1600m+ cylinders are attached to a back-harness
Govemment Fire brigade, police, < 60m and a lung-demand regulator (aqualung)
life-saving/rescue with one or two hoses leading to a mouth-
groups etc. piece through which air is breathed auto-
Military Navy, army, air force ,,;;;;2000m+ matically adjusted to the same pressure as
and military research the surrounding depth of water. A belt with
(research and devel-
lead weights and a quick-release buckle is
opment = R & D)
needed to compensate for the lift of the cyl-
inders and thus reduce the muscular energy
otherwise necessary to counteract the un-
small and large diving companies (national desired lift. A diver's knife is a vital re-
and international) perform a multitude of quirement in case of entanglement; also
sophisticated jobs in predominantly dan- important are a water- and pressureproof
gerous environments in rivers, harbours, watch and a depth meter (see 5.13.5: De-
lakes and in ever increasing numbers in our compression).
seas and oceans, especially in the offshore Normally, scuba gear works as an open-
oil and gas industries with their drilling circuit system, in which exhaled air is not
rigs, submarine pipelines and seabed in- reprocessed but passes on into the water as
stallations (Low [18]). large bubbles. The equipment can, how-
ever, be designed as semic10sed and as
5.13.2.2 Types of Underwater Work c1osed-circuit systems. Semic10sed means
At least 25 different skills are demanded of that exhaled air passes through a CO2
the professional diver, for example, salvag- scrubber (baralime), which eliminates
ing, demolition, inspection and repair, un- metabolie CO2• Oxygen either alone or
derwater construction, welding, cutting with N2 is automatically or manually
and rivetting, maintenance, search and res- added as required to make up for the loss,
cue, underwater surveying and mapping, and any excessive pressure build-up in the
photography, plumbing, archeology, de- breathing bag is vented into the water. In a
rusting and preserving of ship hulls and un- c1osed-circuit system, no gas is vented at all
derwater structures, and bomb and mine (Haux [13]). Instead of carrying all their
raising and/or deactivating. This list is by compressed air equipment on their backs,
no means complete. many professional divers are linked by air-
supply hoses to the surface in predomi-
5.13.2.3 Diving Equipment nantly open systems having only a small
Within the last 3 decades, a great variety of emergency compressed air cylinder with
makes, types and models of diving equip- them, should surface airflow suddenly
ment have appeared on the market. The stop.
minimal gear necessary for skin diving is a To enable safe deep divirig beyond a
mask, snorkel and tins. Masks can be depth of 50 m, i. e. without N 2 narcosis,
bought integrated with one or two snorkels mixed-gas diving systems have been devel-
(dangerous!) and covering eyes, nose and oped. In these, the diver breathes He/02 or
mouth; so-called full-face masks or, more He/N 2/0 2 in predetermined mixture ratios
commonly, mask and snorkel are acquired depending on his working depth. In princi-
426 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
pIe, these systems are basically the same as Depending on the working depth, planned
the above-mentioned compressed air gear overall working time, gas mixtures and
- open, semiclosed or closed circuit. Owing whether partial saturation or saturation
to the increasing price of helium, great ef- techniques (see 5.13.5) are used, the eom-
forts are at present being made to re-use the position ofthe logistie system can vary. Ba-
exhaled He. Thus, most interest is in sieaIly, it eonsists of: eranes for raising and
closed-circuit systems. Due to the great lowering the diving beIls, personnel trans-
depths (50-500 m) involved in offshore fer ehambers (PTCs), deek transfer eham-
diving, the majority of mixed-gas diving is bers (DTCs), deek deeompression eham-
done via a hose connection between the bers (DDCs), portable DDC, mixed-gas
surface gas supply/reprocessing unit and supply, monitors for the divers' breathing
the diver far below, either direcdy or using gas and for the DDC, He-recycling equip-
the diving bell as an intermediate (Haux ment, a diving supervisor, reserve divers
[13]). and a paramedic qualified in diving medi-
Oxygen diving equipment consists of a eine. All ehambers and PTCs should be
closed-circuit breathing system and it has able to interloek hermetieally with eaeh
been in use for many years by the military. other to enSure no pressure drop when div-
Because of the danger of O2 poisoning ers are transferred, for instanee, from the
(100% O2), it is only permitted for depths PTC into the DTC at say 16 atm (Bennett
no greater than 8-10 m and its use requires and Elliott [2]).
extensive special training. Oxygen diving
gear is not obtainable on the commercial 5.13.2.6 Pathways to the Deep
market. As mentioned earlier, several methods are
at hand to enable divers to reaeh the depths
5.13.2.4 Diving Suits necessary for their underwater work. The
With depth, water temperatures become ehoiee depends on various factors, e. g. wa-
progressively colder. It is obvious that man ter temperature, currents, visibility, pres-
has to be protected against cold and gener- sure/ depths and estimated duration of the
al hypothermia. During the last 2 centuries, job. These methods are: free deseent with
five types of diving suits (Table 2) have scuba, hose or mixed gas; deseent in a
been designed and further developed to 1-atm bell (PTC) with external manipula-
high standards - wet (neoprene) suits, dry tors; deseent in a pressurised bell (PTC)
vulcanised rubber constant volume suits, with opening of hatch at depth and exit of
dry foam suits, heimet diving suit combina- hose-eonnected diver; and deseent in
tions (copper or plastic) and 1-atm ar- work/mini-submarines without or with
moured suits. Depending on the design, lock-out capabilities, the latter enabling
they protect against cold, marine plants/ divers to Ieave the submarine via a buiIt-in
animals, injuries, environmental poisons press ure chamber with an airlock.
and eontamination (e. g. radio-aetive or In theory, aeeess to stationary habitats
toxic/allergie substanees), and against the on the seabed is possible with all four
surrounding hydrostatie press ure (e. g. methods. Regulations, however, only per-
1-atm armoured suits). mit compressed air diving to a maximum
depth of 50-60 m. Therefore all offs hore
5.13.2.5 Logistics/Surface Support diving, down to the greatest eurrent opera-
In eommercial diving, espeeially when eon- tional depth of 450 m or 46 atm (by the Co-
dueted in the open seas at depths beyond mex Company in 1977), is done with He/
50 m, eomplex surfaee support faeilities on O2 or He/N 2/0 2•
the shore, on oil rigs and on special diving
mother ships or tenders are mandatory.
5.13 Underwater Medicine and Diving 427
5.13.2.7 Working in the Deep pie can be found in all states ofhealth, even
Once at his place of work, either at some with such ailments that would automatical-
predetermined level, e.g. for inspection of Iy ban them from diving from a doctor's
a ship's hull, or on the seabed, the com- point of view. They also range from ex-
pressed-air diver works for up to several tremely lean to grossly obese individuals.
hOUfS, in part depending on his depth and 5.13.3.2 Professional Divers
the decompression table (see 5.13.5.2) he
plans using; he is then hoisted to the SUf- Within the category of professional divers,
face or ascends hirnself after giving a pre- the picture is a different and more favour-
arranged signal on his safety line or by able one. Their ages lie between 20 and
ph.one to the surface. The mixed-gas diver, 45 years in general and retirement from ac-
bemg far deeper, works up to approximate- tive diving is usually around 55 years at the
ly 100 m from the diving bell, either at the latest. Their personality structure is such
same depth, slightly above or at a maxi- that many tend to be loners and experts re-
mum of 50 m below it, and is connected to sponsible to and trusting primarily only
it by agas supply and heating hose, a themselves. Their motivation to work in
phone cable and a safety line, i. e. the "um- harsh environments can be regarded as
bilical". For reasons given below (see high, knowing that work at depth can be
5.13.5.2), upon completion of his task the both mentally and physically extremely de-
bell diver returns to the bell, closes the manding (Low [18]).
hatch and is hoisted to the surface while The health status of these several thou-
the same pressure is maintained within the sand professional divers is on average good
bell as at the site of work. It is then con- to very good, especially in those perform-
nected to a DDe and decompression be- ing mixed-gas and saturation diving. This
gins (Haux [13]). Divers or aquanauts is because the offs hore industry, for exam-
working from underwater habitats adhere pie, employing 2000-2500 divers world-
in principle, to the same rules as bell diver~ wide, performs a thorough medical check
except that they live at the bottom of the of these men as disablement during an un-
sea for days or weeks [20]. derwater deep sea mission would be very
Caisson workers differ from divers inso- expensive for the oil company. Profession-
far as they work in a dry and not in a wet al divers often have an athletic build and
hyperbaric environment at a maximum are not too tall. Their jobs are mainly man-
depth of 30m (4atm), have a 6-h working ual and it is usually essential that they have
day under pressure and return to the SUf- lea:n.ed a craft before commencing diving
face dry, usually decompressing in a cham- trammg.
ber at the top. A caisson is used for under- Most of the highly developed countries
water bridge support construction, for the have special training schools for civilian
building of underwater tunnels and even professional divers encompassing 1- to
for the archeological retrieval of sunken 6-month courses in normal and even ad-
ships (Wünsche and Scheele [27]). vanced diving techniques, e. g. in Aber-
deen. Germany, unfortunately, has no facil-
ities of this type. Professional divers are
5.13.3 The Diver usually very well paid. Their salaries vary
according to the depth, duration of dive
5.13.3.1 Skin and Sports Diver
and inherent dangers at particular loca-
Skin and sports divers come from every age tions. An example of the dangerous tasks
group from children to the elderly. As there that are performed is diving in the cooling
are no compulsory laws for pre-dive medi- system of an atomic reactor to repair a de-
cal check-ups in most countries, these peo- fective valve.
428 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
5.13.3.3 Diver Health Certificate Table 4. Some current diving heaIth certificates
and standards
It is obvious from the above that prerequi-
sites for safe diving are or should be good Name Required for
health, average weight, stable personality, Physical Standards for Sport scuba divers (ap-
physical strength, good work-Ioad toler- Scuba Divers (USA) proved by Undersea
ance and the ability to work independently Medical Society)
and calmly in extreme situations. Since dif- CMASl (Europe) Sport scuba divers
ferent types of diving (skin diving, scuba, NOAA2(USA) Research divers, aqua·
diving bell, caisson etc.) involve different nauts
particular stresses, several types of diving Taucherarbeiten VBG 39 Commercial divers, re-
health certificates (DHCs) are used by doc- (Federal Republic of search divers, aqua-
tors. Asports diver, for instance, does not Germany) nauts
encounter the same dangerous deep-sea
environments that bell divers do, and cais- 1 Commission Mondiale des Activites
Sous-marines
son workers stay in dry hyperbaric sur- 2 National Oceanic and Atmospheric
roundings. Thus, DHCs have been modi- Administration
fied (with time). Bell divers going to
extreme depths as weIl as saturation divers
must, understandably, comply with the lidity, he is required to see his doctor and if
most stringent medical health standards need be go through a new medical check-
(Ehm and Seemann [7]; [20]). up prior to commencing diving again.
Unfortunately, DHCs are not yet stan-
dardised internationaIly, although efforts
Definition are being made in this direction. Therefore,
A DHC is a document from a qualified many countries have their own DHCs. Mil-
doctor, preferably with a knowledge of div- itary divers, of course, adhere to specific
ing medicine, stating that a certain person health regulations. Table 4 lists a few cur-
is medically fit or healthy enough to pursue rent DHCs and standards.
a particular type of diving. It is also an im-
portant document in the event of a diving When Is a Diver Vnfit for Diving?
accident to prove that a diver had no ail- A doctor examining divers should be well-
ment that could have led to the accident or acquainted with underwater conditions to
injury and thus will entitle hirn to health/ understand why a number of ailments, dis-
accident insurance benefits. Diver health eases and physical abnormalities, either in-
certificates are issued with a 1-, 2-, or 3-year herited or acquired, bar a person perma-
validity period. In sports diving, DHCs are nently or temporarily from diving. The
often valid for 3 years up to the age of most important of these are: obesity and
40 years and must then be renewed annual- underweight; intestinal hernias (due to the
ly. In offshore, bell, saturation and scientif- possible danger of incarceration); diabe-
ic diving, it is becoming more usual for an- tes; hyper- and hypotension; coronary and
nual diving medical check-ups to be de- lung diseases; tendency to spontaneous
manded, independent of the diver's age. pneumothorax; epilepsy; disturbances of
For these extreme forms of diving, X-ray equilibrium; nervous and vegetative disor-
pictures of the large joints taken at regular ders ; stornach, liver and spleen disorders ;
intervals are compulsory so that any asep- history of kidney colic; and eye and ear,
tic bone necrosis may be detected early nose, and throat (ENT) diseases, especially
(Harvey [12]; McCaIlum et al. [19]). Should perforated eardrums and otitis media and
a diver become ill or have an operation or externa (Ehm and Seemann [7]; Linaweav-
accident within the period of the DHC va- er [17]; [20]). A physician must realise that
5.13 Underwater Medicine and Diving 429
he takes on a great responsibility when lead to aseptic bone necrosis with damage
asked to issue a DHC and should weigh to the large joints, for instance, hip, shoul-
the pros and cons objectively. der or knee joints. Finally, diving medicine
deals with chronic ailments of disabled or
prematurely pensioned former divers, such
5.13.4 Diving Medicine as deformed major joints, arthrosis, accel-
erated decline in hearing (often caused by
5.13.4.1 Definition incorrect pressure equalisation in the mid-
Diving medicine, also known as underwa- die ear over aperiod of many years), men-
ter and/or hyperbaric medicine, investi- tal decay and sequelae of thorax squeeze
gates, researches and treats medical prob- (Bennett and Elliott [2]; [6]).
lems associated with man diving below the
surface of the water. It differs from tradi- 5.13.4.3 Necessity of Diving Medicine
tional medicine in several fundamental Now the reader will begin to understand
aspects since a nu mb er of physiological pa- why more and more emphasis is being put
rameters taken for granted at sea level, i. e. on diving medicine worldwide. Diving
at apressure of 1 atm, change to other val- medicine is becoming an integrated part of
ues according to depth and the time spent diving in sport. In non-professional diving,
at depth. Courses on diving medicine for underwater-medical doctors have worked
doctors are given at certain universities and with scientific and research projects for
by the navies of various countries. many years, whereas in commercial diving
this has become so primarily since the ad-
5.13.4.2 Scope of Diving Medicine vent of offshore diving. Divers employed
The theoretical and practical curriculum of by government agencies - in fire brigades,
diving medicine encompasses many medi- police departments, life-saving and rescue
cal, chemical and physical fields, such as: groups etc. - usually contact specialists in
inert gas physiology - N 2, He, Ar, Ne, Xe, hyperbaric medicine only for DHC rene-
N 2 narcosis; gas toxicity - CO, CO 2, O 2, wals. In the military services, doctors spe-
N 2 ; hyperbaric physiology and its effects cialised in diving medicine are assigned to
on the body, e. g. positive- and negative- navy, army and air force units, though pri-
pressure barotraumas of the sinuses and marily to the navy, and are also employed
lungs, the high-pressure nervous syndrome in research and development institutes.
(HPNS); hyperbaric biochemistry; ENT
problems, surgery and internal medicine; 5.13.4.4 General Tasks of Physicians in
effects on and efficiency of drugs adminis- Diving Medicine
tered at high pressures ; neurological altera- These tasks may be summarised as folIows:
tions of the CNS associated with depth DHC examinations and renewals; supervi-
(EEG), psychomotor changes; and decom- sion of diving excursions; experiments on
pression and therapeutic recompression land (in high-pressure chambers) and at
techniques. sea; acting as consultant to divers and div-
Occupational medicine, an accepted ing companies; development of prophylac-
special discipline on land, is also a necessi- tic measures and of alarm and rescue plans
ty underwater with factors and complica- for diving missions; providing hyperbaric
tions like work-Ioad, hypothermia, cur- first-aid training; treatment of diving casu-
rents, hyperventilation, panic, equipment alties on the surface and underwater; and
failure, entanglement and injuries affecting theoretical and practical diving medical re-
divers to be taken into account and dealt search.
with. A knowledge of orthopaedics is de-
sired as decompression sickness (DCS) can
430 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
1- No decompression dive
2.3.4- Dives with stage decompression stops
Deplh to eliminate excessive inert gases
Iml
- c i ~~==,.
Time Imi~1
_ No decompression_
time - - - d- --
Stage decompression slops
necessary from here on
5.13.5 Living and Working the various body tissues, which become sat-
Underwater urated either rapidly (pressure equilibrium)
or more slowly, depending on their perfu-
From a medical point of view, every dive sion and diffusion rates and their gas-stor-
consists of three phases: compression, iso- age capacities (so-called short or long half-
pression and decompression. Each phase time values), hence the expressions partial
affects the body physiologically in different saturation and saturation. For example, the
ways. These must be understood to avoid saturation time for nitrogen in human tis-
dangers and injuries (Fig.1). sues is approximately 100 h. If p02 is high-
er than 0.5 atm for several days, O 2 intoxi-
Compression. Increase in external press ure cation of the lungs along with a drop in
leads to barotraumas of the rigid air-filled vital capacity and possibly pneumonia will
sinuses, the middle ear, teeth with incorrect occur. If the p02 rises above 2 atm, twitch-
fillings and the thorax if pressures are not ing, neurological symptoms, cerebral sei-
or cannot be equalised. This causes in- zures and eventually death will take place
creasing pain, blood pooling, haemor- (Rister and Baehner [22]).
rhages and burst blood vessels and, in the
chest, can lead to lung oedema, heart dila- Decompression. This refers to external
tation and death (negative barotrauma or pressure reduction or ascent. If the air-
"squeeze"). Compression can cause N 2 filled sinus passages become blocked, e. g.
narcosis (> 40 m), He tremor, HPNS (> by mucus or because of a sore throat, ex-
200 m) and O 2 toxicity (> 2-3 atm O 2) cessive pressures cannot es cape and will
(Bennett and Elliott [2]). cause a positive barotrauma with increas-
ing pain the high er a person ascends.
Isopression. This term means that the ex- Should a laryngospasm inhibit the exhal-
ternal or ambient pressure stays constant, ing of air, the lungs will overinflate and fi-
i. e. the working depth has been reached. nally tear, causing gas embolism and/ or
Immediate factors confronting the diver pneumothorax with gas bubbles reaching
are high press ure, darkness, cold water and the heart, viscera and cerebrum. Death can
currents. As time goes on, hypothermia can occur quickly if gas emboli reach the vital
gradually commence, lowering the core cerebral centres. Unequal pressure decre-
temperature. More and more compressed ment in the middle ear causes aIternobaric
gas (air or He/ 02) goes into solution in all vertigo, and a sudden loss of hearing has
5.13 Underwater Medicine and Diving 431
been noted in divers coming up from great humidity (60%-95%) leads to a softening
depths (Roydhouse [23]). Depending on of the skin, making it more susceptible to
the depth and time spent underwater, a div- mycosis and injuries, and accelerates a
er must give his body ample time to elimi- shift from Gram-positive to Gram-negative
nate the hyperbarically dissolved N 2 or He bacteria in the external auditory canal and
in his tissues by making several exactly on the body's surface (Alcock [1]).
predetermined stops on the way up (de- Hypothermia can make a diver more
compression tables). Ifhe fails to do so and prone to colds and infections, decrease his
ascends too fast, he will suffer from decom- manual dexterity and re du ce his mental
pression sickness (DCS), either mildly or capabilities. High pressure seems to reduce
severely, and can even die. Decompression or augment the effects of medicines de-
sickness can occur as tingling, joint and ex- pending on which drug is given. However,
tremity pains, chokes and CNS symptoms. as yet, little is known about the latter. The
It is important that an incorrect or missed raising of the boiling point of water from
decompression be immediately treated by 100°C to 120°C and even higher, under hy-
recompression in a DDC at the surface perbaric conditions has, for instance, ac-
with ensuing decompression to avoid pos- cidentally led to internal and external
sible DCS. Hypothermia can affect gas scalds and burns.
elimination speed and necessitate longer
decompression schedules (Fig.1). 5.13.5.2 Working from Diving BeIls, from
Underwater, a diver perceives a reduc- Underwater Habitats and in
tion in weight or even weightlessness; there Caissons
is an increase in the speed of sound but a Divers working underwater have to cope
person is incapable of pinpointing its with some or all of the seven major prob-
source. Falling objects have a decreased ve- lems common to such conditions - depth
locity, the diver's breathing gas mixture has (i. e. hydrostatic pressure), strong currents,
an increased density and the boiling point semi or total darkness, time, hypothermia,
of water is higher. dangerous and painful extern al ear infec-
tions, and accidents. Most of these can, if
5.13.5.1 The Effects on Humans protective measures are not taken, easily
Greater gas densities and viscosities lead to reduce the efficiency and performance of
a change in the pitch of the human voice divers in the aqueous environment and
and in the intelligibility of the spoken rapidly endanger their lives. These prob-
word, to alterations in the senses of taste lems, together with the difficulties they
and smell, to different grades of subtle eu- may bring ab out, are listed in Table 5. As
phoria and to a slower pace of work than can be seen, most of these difficulties are of
expected. This has especially been noted in a medical nature.
underwater habitats (Goeters [10]; Ruff et In addition to leading to hypothermia,
al. [24]). diving at depth can cause several disorders,
The adaptation time for the body to ad- such as HPNS, N 2 narcosis, toxic oxygen
just to hyperbaric conditions, e.g. for aqua- effects on the lungs and CNS, and DCS.
nauts in underwater habitats, is dependent It is erroneous to assurne that in most
on the depth and gas mixture and can take places in which professional divers work
1-3 days. The mental drive is slower under the water is clear. On the contrary, in al-
hyperbaric conditions and a shift in the most all rivers and estuaries the visibility is
ambient comfort temperature zone towards zero on or not far below the water surface.
higher temperatures, b. 35°C, occurs as a In the North Sea, usually hardly anything
result of the greater thermal conductivity of is discernible below 30 m. Visibility can be
helium (Low [18]). The increased relative greatly impaired by plankton and sus-
432 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
Table 5. Major problems for divers and possible several fold, fatigue sets in and perfor-
difficulties and dangers mance dec1ines. Current velocities of up to
Major problems Possible difficulties 2 m/s and more are commonplace under-
water in rivers and in the sea (Ruff et al.
Depth/ pressure Positive and negative barotrau-
[24]).
mas, N 2 narcosis, impaired pul-
monary function, HPNS, in- The total time spent underwater is an im-
creased diuresis, DCS portant medical factor in diving. The long-
Darkness Disorientation, entanglement, er the time underwater, the greater the
panic, death amount of inert gas, N 2 or He, that is ab-
Currents Increased work-load, decline in sorbed by the aqueous and fatty tissues of
performance, faster fatigue, en- the body. N 2 is absorbed by fat and water
tanglement, disorientation in a 5: 1 ratio, whereas the ratio for He is
Time Hypothermia, decline in perfor- 1.2: 1. Therefore, the longer a diver remains
mance, more gas goes into solu- at depth, the more inert gas is dissolved in
tion->partial or full saturation, his body (partial saturation, then satura-
DCS
tion) and so decompression becomes
Hypothermia/ Increased metabolism, increased lengthier, hours or days, in order that these
cold diuresis, decrease in dexterity,
performance and efficiency, rap-
excessive quantities of gas can be slowly
id cooling through helium exhaled via the lungs without harming the
breathing, DCS, euphoria, diver. Failure to adhere to the decompres-
drowning, death sion rules can or will lead to severe DCS
Otitis extema Contagious, rapidly worsening with multiple micro and macro gas emboli,
ear pain, reduced ability or in- often combined with hemi-, para- or tetra-
ability to dive, early termination
plegia and perhaps immediate death. Time
ofunderwater missions (high ex-
penses) is also a factor contributing to hypothermia
and decreased performance [6].
Underwater Injuries, unconsciousness,
accidents drowning, death Cold, or hypothermia, is one of the most
detrimental factors influencing human effi-
ciency underwater. Hypothermia depends
on the depth, length of dive, water temper-
pended microdebris. Divers must, there- ature, thickness and material of suit, and
fore, depend to a great extent on their sense the breathing gas mixture, i. e. its helium
of touch. Deep-sea divers are connected to content. The pressure increase with depth
the bell or habitat by air-hose and tele- compresses the diver's suit, reducing its
phone cable, which are a means of finding thickness and thus its insulating properties.
the way back should danger arise. Owing Water has approximately 25 times the ther-
to the possibly fatal risk of DCS, the en- mal conductivity of dry still air of the same
dangered diver must first of all always try temperature and 1000 times its specific
to reach the bell/habitat and not ascend to heat. These factors together with the obser-
the surface. vation that hypothermia is accelerated in
At rest, O2 uptake is approximately 0.5 correlation with the volume percentage of
litres/min. It rises to 1.2-3.5litres/min. for He in the breathing mixture (through its
divers wearing heavy lead boots. When having five to six times the thermal conduc-
swimming against strong underwater cur- tivity of air) make a cooling of the diver via
rents with fins, O2 uptake increases to be- the skin surface and the respiratory tract
tween 2.5 and 4litres/min. Metabolism is likely if no protective measures are taken.
accelerated greatly and glycogen stores are Below a certain depth, heat loss through
depleted faster, in addition to an earlier on- the airways becomes greater than increased
set of hypothermia. Work-Ioads increase metabolism is able to cope with. Thus, the
5.13 Underwater Medicine and Diving 433
diver's core temperature will inevitably be- of keeping a watch on their diving compan-
gin to drop. As it does so, O2 uptake and ion(s) as the underwater world is a hostile
metabolic rate increase, while manual dex- environment for the human being and a
terity deteriorates and with it job efficiency dangerous situation can develop very
and performance. Cold-induced diuresis quickly. For this reason, sports divers
leads to a voiding of latent heat stores; should never dive alone. Before commenc-
mental sluggishness and euphoria can fi- ing a dive, the proposed duration, depth
nally occur and drowning becomes very and location should be told to the surface
probable (Hanson [11]). Two methods of personnel and recorded. Monitoring of the
avoiding or at least minimising hypother- divers can take place either from the sur-
mia in deep diving conditions have been face or underwater or both:
utilised with good results: (a) heating the 1. From the surface, by diving supervisor,
wet (Neoprene) or dry diving suit, either reserve diver, signalman, diving para-
electrically or by conducting hot water medic or diving doctor.
(40°C) from the surface to the diver via a 2. Underwater, by a diving companion vi-
hose and thence through underwear of an sually and/or connected by "buddy-
interwoven plastic tube design; (b) preheat- line" (wrist to wrist) or by a second diver
ing the breathing gas mixture in accor- in a bell, habitat or minisubmarine.
dance with the underwater work-Ioad and 3. Combined, by a diver in a bell, habitat or
depth, and carefully monitoring it from the mini submarine, who can also be and
surface « 45°C gas temperature). usually is in contact with surface control.
Otitis externa in divers is usually caused Several technical me ans are at our dis-
by Proteus vulgaris, Pseudomonas aerugino- posal to improve communication with the
sa and Staphylococcus aureus either singly diver. The oldest and most frequently used
or in combination. The ear becomes very method is a signalline attached to the div-
tender and painful, and a watery to thick er's waist along which messages can be
greenish-yellow pus is found in the audito- passed. Underwater telephones built into
ry canal. Outer ear infections are encoun- the diver's heImet and running to the sur-
tered much more frequently in deep-sea face in waterproof cables have been in use
saturation diving, in which the divers re- for decades. This telephone link can also
main under pressure for days or weeks, be between diver and bell, bell and surface
than in short duration shallow-water diving etc. Underwater ultrasonic communication
or sports diving. In diving teams living and is a relatively new development, liberating
working together in hyperbaric environ- divers from cables which can hamper their
ments (increased p02, relative humidity movements. Underwater television cam-
and temperature), otitis externa can be very eras can also be mounted in beIls and habi-
contagious and if prophylactic measures tats and even be carried by divers, the
(see 5.13.7) are not strictly adhered to, most corresponding monitor screens being in-
of the divers will be incapacitated and un- stalled where appropriate.
able to dive for a few days. Doctors in div- The problem of monitoring physiologi-
ing medicine and hygienists have been cal parameters under high pressure has led
working on this problem for many years to the development of new systems and
(Alcock [1]; Jones and Davis [14]). sensors (Oser and Wegmann [21]). Heart
With regard to underwater accidents, the frequency, breathing, EEG, ECG, core
reader is referred to the section 5.13.6. temperature etc. can be monitored and reg-
istered in open-sea dives and in simulated
5.13.5.3 Supervision of Divers Underwater hyperbaric chamber dives to depths of ap-
Sports and commercial divers are taught proximately 2000 m (201 atm) (Bennett and
the importance of diving supervision and Elliott [2]; Walsh [26]). Breathing and
434 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
breathing frequency are indirectly moni- mation of one's strength and overexertion.
tored via the telephone affixed to the div- Incorrect swimming and diving techniques
er's heImet, which is constantly kept in the surf zone may lead to difficulties and
switched on in the one-way direction from give rise to panic. Nausea with vomiting
diver to surface or to bell. Thus, it is possi- caused by waves can incapacitate a swim-
ble to discern whether the diver is breath- mer or diver down to about a depth of 5 m.
ing regularly, hyperventilating (e. g. due to Hyperventilation, a technique often used
excessive work-Ioad, rise in CO 2 or panic) by snorkel divers to remain longer under-
or not breathing at all. It is impractical to water or to dive a greater horizontal dis-
monitor physiological parameters in com- tance, has caused numerous cases of un-
mercial deep diving, however, as the sup- consciousness (drop in arterial p02) and
port team on the surface usually does not death upon ascending, usually just below
have the medical experience to be able to the surface. The majority of sports diving
analyse immediately abnormal ECG or accidents occur at weekends and frequent-
EEG curves and to take the appropriate ly in areas where immediate first aid and a
first-aid or rescue measures. recompression chamber are not available.
Voice distortion through He in deep div- Swimming and diving after meals and con-
ing has often led to support teams not be- sumption of alcohol have caused death in
ing able to understand what the diver be- healthy individuals, alcohol raising the N 2
low is saying. This can be tragic if the diver narcosis level to a depth of approximately
is in great danger, i11 or injured and urgent- 10m in extreme cases (Bennett [3]).
ly needs help. A variety of He unscram- Medicines taken for various reasons by
bIers have been developed in several coun- divers, e. g. tranquillisers, analgesics and
tries, e. g. USA, France and Germany, in an anti-emetics, may have side-effects such as
effort to solve this problem. Current mod- drowsiness or decrease in concentration
els now provide an intelligibility level of and perceptive faculties, which, acting to-
80%-90%, thus giving deep divers greater gether with increased pressure, can greatly
psychological assurance while on the endanger divers. Ear barotraumas can oc-
seabed. cur during descent through incorrect pres-
sure equalising in the middle ear (Valsalva
manoeuvre) and on ascending; tbe latter
5.13.6 Aecidents, Siekness causes alternobaric vertigo with nausea. In
Underwater and Reseue sports diving, the increasing number of
cases of DCS - comprising "niggles",
5.13.6.1 Accidents bends, chokes, spinal cord lesions or CNS
Accidents are caused by a number of fac- symptoms - as weIl as cases of gas embo-
tors, each in itself usually not dangerous, li sm through overextended or burst lungs
interacting with one another and some- are causing concern (see 5.13.5: Decom-
times leading to disastrous or fatal results, pression). An important rule in diving is
especially when occurring underwater. "never dive alone", i.e. the "buddy" sys-
Prime factors influencing accidents are sea tem. This functions weIl ifboth parties trust
and weather conditions, individual skills, each other and have had the same training.
training standards, health status and tech- If not, mistakes with grave consequences
nical and equipment malfunctions. can occur.
example, through blasts, welding acci- very low-flying airplane ( < 300 m) and re-
dents, suction devices, explosions and en- compress the patient in accordance with
tanglernent, occur in addition to those the therapeutic tables [20].
through equipment malfunction at depth Deep-water rescue raises more problems
or in surface support facilities. An example due to the increased pressure and the great-
may illustrate the dangers involved: In Jan- er amount of dissolved inert gas in the div-
uary 1976, two divers had been working for er's body tissues. If an accident occurs at a
1 h at the bottom of the North Sea at a depth of say 200 m, the diver in the bell
depth of 78 m, one inside and one outside a must notify surface control at once and
diving bell. The latter returned to the bell then go out and try to retrieve the injured
but before he could elose the hatch, the diver, bring hirn through the 60- to 80-cm
ground-weight of the bell detached itself. circular entrance hatch into the bell, elose
The bell shot to the surface in 42 s, rapidly the hatch and, while remaining at working
losing interior pressure. One of the divers depth pressure, be hoisted to the surface,
died immediately through a massive lung giving cardiopulmonary resuscitation if
overpressure trauma, whereas the other, necessary (Fisher [8]). Topside, the bell is
deeply unconscious, was recompressed to a connected to a large DDC in which first
pressure level of 81 m in a very short time aid can be given by diver paramedics as the
and survived (Frankel [9]). The training DDC is slowly (hours or days) decom-
standards of professional divers also affect pressed to 1 atm. If a rapid ascent without
accident prob ability, bearing in mind the slow decompression were to be made, e. g.
extremely hostile surroundings they often in panic, death would follow within mi-
have to work in (Biersner et al. [4]). nutes. Sending a paramedic down to a dis-
abled deep-sea diver (depth > 150 m) is the-
5.13.6.2 Rescue oretically possible but impractible because
When a diver is injured or otherwise inca- he would have to be compressed slowly in
pacitated underwater, the obvious reaction order to maintain his mental capabilities
is to bring hirn out of the hostile environ- and avoid the HPNS (Fisher [8]).
ment and to the surface as fast as possible.
Yet what seems simple on land may often 5.13.6.3 Decompression Sickness and Its
be difficuIt in diving. For example, it is Symptoms
usually easier to bring a disabled diver up If asports or professional diver, irrespec-
from shallow depths - unless he is trapped tive of the reason, ascends too fast for the
- than from greater ones without addition- time spent at a certain depth or decom-
ally endangering hirn. presses incorrect1y, i. e. incorrect duration
In shallow waters, rescue should, in prin- of predetermined stops on the way up, he
ciple, be: Dive to the casualty, free the air- can easily suffer from DCS. It usually com-
ways, administer compressed air (if nec- mences minutes to hours after surfacing or
essary), release the weight belt, inflate the even while the diver is still underwater, de-
buoyancy collar (or personal flotation de- pending on the amount of N 2 rapidly
vice) and ascend to the surface with the ca- changing from the dissolved state to the
sualty, checking that he exhales on the way gas-bubble state and the location of such
up to avoid a possible and often lethallung bubbles in the body. Table 6 summarises
overextension. Continue cardiopulmonary possible DCS symptoms that could con-
resuscitation on the surface if necessary front a doctor or layman.
and treat any wounds. Determine whether Table 6 progresses from mild to very se-
DCS symptoms are present, transfer to the vere DCS or even death, i. e. from dermal
next decompression chamber, preferably in to cerebral symptoms. In the current medi-
a recumbent position, either by road or in a calliterature on diving, DCS with skin sen-
436 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
Table 6. Types of decompression sickness and the very efficient recompression tables (known
symptoms as Tables 5, 5 A, 6 and 6 A) using 100% O 2
Name Symptoms breathing (~2.8 atm) alternating in part
with short intervals of compressed-air
Skin symptoms Transient rashes and itches,
breathing [6]. The 100% O 2 breathing elimi-
tingling, buming feeling
nates the dissolved N 2 and N 2 in the bubble
"Niggles" Slight pains in Iimbs
state much faster than compressed-air
Bends Severe pain in musc\es and breathing, owing to the greater N 2 gradient.
joints
Recompression is necessary for tissue
Bends in the Seldom, involves CNS and and bone or joint inert gas bubble (emboli)
vertebral column leads to paralysis of limbs
symptoms originating from:
Chokes Chest pain, stemming from
lungs and increasing with in- Too rapid ascent in sports, professional
spiration. If severe, can cause and saturation diving
shock and collapse Correct decompression in very cold wa-
Cerebral effects Examples: visual disturbances, ter or in cases of obesity
vertigo, deafness (death) Incorrect stage decompression
Staggers Type of vertigo Overextension or rupture of lungs with
gas emboli
Cerebral gas emboli
F1ying shortly after scuba diving (omit-
sations and muscle or joint pains only is
ting the advised 24-h interlude)
called type I DCS and the severe forms
DCS of caisson or tunnel workers
with neurological effects and traumas,
Air in veins with subsequent coronary or
type 11 DCS.
cerebral emboli due to incorrect infu-
5.13.6.4 Therapeutic Recompression sions or artificial kidney malfunctions in
hospitals
This term refers to returning someone with
Anaerobic gas gangrene
suspected or manifest symptoms of mild or
severe DCS to high pressure. It is the only As described elsewhere untreated inert
method known for treating DCS and air gas emboli can lead to permanent tissue or
embolism with 100% success if applied cor- joint damage and even to death (Wünsche
rectly and at the right time. Any inert gas and Scheele [27]).
bubbles in the body tissues can only be re-
duced in size and go back into solution, i. e. 5.13.6.5 Internal Medical and Surgical
the DCS symptoms disappear, by in- Treatment Under High Pressure
creasing the external press ure. In therapeu- During therapeutic recompression, situa-
tic recompression, this is done by putting tions can occur that necessitate surgical or
the patient into a one- or multiseated hy- internal medical treatment by a doctor or a
perbaric ch amb er, raising the pressure to diving paramedic inside the hyperbaric
the level (~6 atm) prescribed for treating chamber. For this purpose, they would en-
his specific symptoms, keeping hirn there ter the chamber via an airlock. Such cases
until these symptoms vanish and then care- may, for example, be gastric pains or ul-
fully decompressing the patient in stages cers, kidney pains or colic, heart and chest
while observing his condition. About six ailments. Any of these, commencing sud-
different tables for hyperbaric treatment denly underwater, might have been the
with compressed air exist (US Navy Diving prime reason for a too rapid ascent or miss-
Manual). Over the past 15 years, these have ed decompression in the first pi ace, thus
gradually been combined with and finally causing DCS and requiring recompression.
superseded by four short-durational and When serious, injuries, wounds and frac-
5.13 Underwater Medicine and Diving 437
tures sustained while diving may have to be a medicine need not be valid at higher pres-
treated by a surgeon in the DDC, Le. be- sures; it may be necessary to increase or de-
fore the chamber has again reached sea- crease the dose. Anaesthetie drugs often al-
level pressure. ter in hyperbaric environments, leading to
In hospitals, there is an increasing ten- the question of which of them is best suited
dency to establish hyperbarie units or de- for operations in high-pressure chambers.
partments for coronary surgery (e. g. of Cox and Robinson [5] found that ketamine
"blue babies"), gas gangrene casualties, is least altered in its effects in comparison
cases of carbon monoxide poisoning, and with propanidid and thiopentone, of which
other emergencies, usually with remark- the doses have to be increased with in-
able and rapid success previously impossi- creased pressure. Owing to the danger of
ble. contamination of the chamber atmosphere,
lumbar or intravenous anaesthesia should
5.13.6.6 Possible Problems in Medical be given preference over inhalation
Treatment in Diving anaesthesia.
When a disabled diver is recompressed for
treatment he may be conscious or uncon- 5.13.7 Frequent Diseases in Diving
scious. In the latter case, he would not be
able to equalise the pressure in his middle Sports as well as professional divers, pre-
ear in accordance with the rising chamber dominantly engaged in activities in a wet
pressure and thus his eardrums could eas- and cold environment, are prone to various
ily rupture (at an increase in pressure~ diseases beside those caused by barotrau-
0.5 atm). To avoid this, doctors sometimes ma and DCS, whieh have been dealt with
carefully puncture each eardrum (para- elsewhere. These are mostly nose and
centesis). If a diver with a burst lung (gas throat ailments and colds. The usual rem-
emboli) together with pneumothorax is edies and nasal decongestants bring relief.
recompressed, a dangerous tension pneu- The use of nose drops, however, should not
mothorax may develop, requiring immedi- become ahabit for the diver. Various skin
ate medical action. Using infusions in rigid diseases of an allergie origin (jellyfish),
glass bottles is potentially dangerous dur- fungal (pH shift and softening of the skin),
ing compression and decompression traumatic (underwater rocks and corals),
phases with their pressure gradients. Blood animal (eel, shark bites) or toxie (stonefish,
can be sucked up into the drip bottle or ex- catfish) origin can and do occur and must
cessive air in the bottle can be forced into be treated appropriately ([6]; Ehm and See-
the venous blood stream, leading to multi- mann [7]).
ple gas emboli. Implosions of bottles have Skin wounds tend to heal slower in div-
also occurred in DDCs. These dangers are ers owing to the salt water contact. Contact
non-existent when infusions in soft sterile of the external auditory canal with a high
plastic bags are used. relative humidity or with water for aperiod
The behaviour of drugs and medicines of days often causes excessive cerumen
administered under pressures > 1 atm is production. This, together with noise from
very complex and depends on many fac- air compressors and incorrect Valsalva
tors. According to Walsh [26], there appears manoeuvres, can lead to transient or even
to be a complete void in the literature as to long-Iasting hearing decrements or losses.
the toxicity and interaction of medicines Otitis externa is a frequent and painful bac-
with compressed air between 2 and 7 atm, terial infection known to divers worldwide.
which also spans the range of current re- Caused, among other reasons, by high rela-
compression pressures. A doctor should tive humidities or water entering the ear, it
bear in mind that the sea-Ievel properties of is best healed by abstaining from diving
438 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
and using antibiotic eardrops, if possible in a) Sports divers, large enough gas cylin-
conjunction with an antibiogramme (Al- ders with reserve compressed-air
cock [1]). supply
Infections of the urogenital system can b) Professional divers. emergency com-
be seen in the northern latitudes owing to pressed-air cylinder and perhaps a
the colder waters giving rise to hypother- second regulator
mia. Kidney and bladder pains should be a 12. Making medical emergency and trans-
warning sign for divers to see their doctor. portation plans to next DDC before
Diving puts a certain strain on the kidneys commencing a dive.
owing to immersion-induced as weIl as
cold-induced diuresis, as has been found in 5.13.9 Future Trends in Modern
re cent research. Diving and Diving Medicine
Myalgia and rheumatic pains through
overexertion and cold are also quite often Progress in diving has been enormous over
encountered among divers. the last 100 years (Table 2). The next de-
cade will bring advanced ideas, new
knowledge and new equipment to the diver
5.13.8 Prevention of Diving Accidents and to diving in general. Spectacular
breakthroughs, however, are not to be ex-
Diving medicine incorporates diving acci- pected. Theoretical and practical diving
dent prophylaxis, although this is also a medical research will continue in an at-
part of diving technology and support. Ac- tempt to make shaIlow and, in particular,
cident prevention underwater, though not complex deep diving safer and will in-
completely possible, can be achieved to a crease, step by step, the operational work-
high degree by adhering to the foIlowing ing depth. For instance, six men recently
precautionary measures: spent 35 days at a simulated depth of 500 m
(51 atm) in Norway [25].
1. A thorough medical check-up (once a
year) 5.13.9.1 Diving Medicine
2. A very good training in sports or profes- Research into the causes of pulmonary and
sional diving, i. e. in courses or diving cerebral oxygen toxicity at high pressures
schools and its avoidance will continue (Rister and
3. Education in underwater and DCS first Baehner [22]). High-pressure inert-gas
aid physiology, especially of the CNS, will re-
4. Sufficient protection against hypo- main important, as will the interactions and
thermia effects of drugs on the CNS and their
5. Medical prophylaxis against colds and changes in efficiency under high pressure
otitis externa (Walsh [26]). New gas mixtures (birnix, tri-
6. Exact adherence to appropriate decom- mix - mixture of three gases) resulting
pression tables from such research will be of benefit to the
7. Knowledge of recompression tables diver. Current decompression tables far
8. Never diving alone, after meals, with re- sports divers will be subtly improved where
sidual alcohol in body or when not feel- they are still not ideal, and efforts to stan-
ing weIl dardise them internationaIly will be pur-
9. Terminating dive before exhaustion sued. The tables used in commercial off-
10. Wearing manually activated buoyancy shore deep diving - and often regarded as
vests to assist in emergency ascents confidential by the companies (time is mo-
11. Having an adequate life-support sys- ney) - will be streamlined. The protection
tem: of commercial deep divers from hypo-
5.13 Underwater Medicine and Diving 439
thermia as weIl as the treatment thereof is 10. Goeters, K. M.: Die Beeinflussung der geistigen
still a subject of great importance, consid- Konzentrationsfähigkeit durch Überdruck un-
ter Berücksichtigung der zusätzlichen Bela-
ering that the comfort temperature zone
stungsfaktoren Arbeitsbeanspruchung und Iso-
rises and becomes progressively smaller lation. Ed.: Deutsche Forschungs- und Ver-
with increasing depth (Hanson [11]). Inves- suchsanstalt für Luft- und Raumfahrt. Köln/
tigation into the possibilities and potentials Porz 1978. (Deutsche Luft- und Raumfahrt.
of liquid breathing originally begun by Forschungsbericht 78-12)
11. Hanson, R.deG.: Working in cold environ-
Kylstra et al. [15] many years ago may be ments - lessons to be learned from diving. Ann.
resumed. occup. Hyg. 21, 193-198 (1978).
12. Harvey, C.A: Dysbaric osteonecrosis in divers:
5.13.9.2 Diving Technology a survey of 611 selected US Navy divers. Un-
dersea biomed. Res. 3, 1, A41 (1976).
In diving technology, an emphasis on
13. Haux, G.: Tauchtechnik. Ed.: Drägerwerk.
reducing the breathing resistance in scuba Lübeck 1968.
gear and the development of electronic 14. Jones, D.M. and P.Davis: Upper respiratory
decompressiometers can be expected. Re- tract and aural flora of saturation divers. J. clin.
search into electronic gas-sensor-con- Path. 31,721-723 (1978).
15. Kylstra, 1. A, C. V. Paganelli and E. H. Lan-
trolled semic1osed- and c1osed-circuit gas- phier: Pulmonary gas exchange in dogs venti-
mixture breathing equipment will be pur- lated with hyperbarically oxygenated liquid. J.
sued. Inert gas recovery systems, especially appl. Physiol. 21, 177-184 (1966).
for helium, will be used more and more in 16. Lemaire, C. and E. L. Murphy: Monitoring the
heart rate and core temperature of divers to sig-
order to decrease the enormous costs of
nal dangerous levels of cooling or overheating.
deep, and offshore diving (Low [18]). Undersea biomed. Res. 3, 1, A 45 (1976).
17. Linaweaver, P.G.jr.: Physical examination re-
quirements for commercial divers. J. occup.
Med. 19,12,817-818 (1977).
References 18. Low, A: Medizinische Probleme des modemen
Taucherwesens, besonders im Offshore-Be-
1. Alcock, S. R: Acute otitis externa in divers reich. In: Unfall- und Sicherheitsforschung
working in the North Sea: a microbiological Straßenverkehr. Kongreßbericht Jahrestagung
survey of7 saturation dives. J. Hyg. (Lond.) 78, 1981 der Dtsch. Ges. f. Verkehrsmed. gemein-
395-409 (1977). sam m. d. Dtsch. Verkehrs wacht, Hamburg,
2. Bennett, P.B. and D.H.Elliott: The physiology 7-9May 1981. Ed.: Bundesanstalt f. Straßen-
and medicine of diving. London: Ballit~re Tin- wesen, Bereich Unfallforschung, Köln, LAuf-
da111975. trage d. Bundesministers f. Verkehr. Braun-
3. Ben.nett, P.B.: Nitrogen narcosis. In: Diving schweig: Waisenhaus-Buchdruckerei 1981.
medicine. Ed.: RH.Strauss. New York: Grune pp. 52-56.
& Stratton 1976. 19. McCallum, R 1., D. N. Walder and V. B. Thick-
4. Biersner, R.J., M. L. Dembert and M. D. Brown- ett: Bone necrosis in commercial divers. Under-
ing: Comparisons ofperformance effectiveness sea biomed. Res. 3, 1, A41 (1976).
among divers. Aviat. Space environ. Med. 51, 20. NOAA Diving Manual. Washington: U.S.Gov-
11, 1193-1196 (1980). ernment Printing Office 1975.
5. Cox, J. and D. J. Robinson: Anaesthesia at 21. Oser, H. and H. M. Wegmann: Die Ausschei-
depth. Brit. J. Hosp. Med. 23, 2, 144, 147, dung von Katecholaminen und 17-Hydroxy-
150-151 (1980). corticosteroiden bei 5 Aquanauten während des
6. Diving medicine. Ed.: Richard H.Strauss. New Aufenthaltes im Unterwasserlabor "Tektite II".
York: Grune & Stratton 1976. Ed.: Deutsche Forschungs- und Versuchsan-
7. Ehm, O.F. and K.Seemann: Sicher Tauchen. stalt für Luft- und Raumfahrt. Köln/Porz 1978.
Stuttgart: Müller 1965. (Deutsche Luft- und Raumfahlt. Forschungs-
8. Fisher, J. M.: Immediate care pack for the diver. bericht 74-02).
In: Proceedings of the 3rd International Con- 22. Rister, M. and R.L.Baehner: Neue Aspekte zur
ference on Disaster Medicine, Monaco, Toxizität des Sauerstoffs. Dtsch. med. Wschr.
6-10ApriI1979. Geneva: International Society 103,23,977-981 (1978).
on Disaster Medicine 1980. 23. Roydhouse, N.: Sudden deafness and scuba
9. Frankei, H. L.: Paraplegia due to decompres- divers. N. Z. med. J. 93,678,131 (1981).
sion sickness. Paraplegia /4,306-311 (1977). 24. Ruff, S., H. D. Fust, H. Oser and A Low: Unter-
440 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medieine
wasserlaboratorium Helgoland. Ed.: Deutsche 26. Walsh, J. M.: Drugs in diving. In: Diving medi-
Forschungs- und Versuchsanstalt für Luft- und eine. Ed.: R.H.Strauss. New York: Grune &
Raumfahrt. Inst. f. Flugmedizin. Bonn-Bad Go- Stratton 1976.
desberg 1971. (Deutsche Luft- und Raumfahrt. 27. Wünsche, O. and G.Scheele: Röntgenologische
Forschungsbericht 71-63). Untersuchungen bei Druckluftarbeitem. Köln,
25. Taucher in 500m Wassertiefe. Hansa 119, 112, Opladen: Westdeutscher Verlag 1973. (For-
106 (1982). schungsbericht d. Landes NRW. No.2351).
5.14 Forensie Nautical Medicine
W.Naeve
ficult due to more or less serious changes tion. When necessary, an expert in tropi-
caused by putrefaction. cal medicine or a pathologist with a
2. To clarify a case of aceident, or for the knowledge of tropical pathology must be
penal judgement of bodily injury or consulted.
ho mi eide, it is often important to know 6. In cases of death at sea or in foreign
whether the injured person or the victim ports, the order for autopsy is often is-
of a crime or the perpetrator was under sued by the shipping agent when the au-
the influence of alcohol. A test to deter- thorities do not demand it. The doctor's
mine the alcohollevel in the body may attention is at times not called to the spe-
not be made in certain eircumstances: eific points in question, including the le-
a) The body has been buried at sea gal requirements of insurance compa-
b) The ineident took place at sea where nies. Quite often the examination has to
facilities for the examination were not be delegated to doctors who have no, or
available very little, pathological-anatomical and
c) Testing was not the custom or it was forensic medical knowledge and experi-
thought to be unnecessary ence.
It must also be accepted that the meth- 7. Sometimes the crew cannot be ques-
ods oftesting for alcohol and the speeific tioned for facts by the doctor until
requirements vary between countries. months after the ineident at sea. Then it
Unsatisfactory preservation of the is often found that the ineident is made
corpse may make testing for alcohol in light of or details are concealed because
the blood or tissues at a later date almost of camaraderie. Also it is often the case
impossible. that crew members who could contribute
to the forensic medical clarification of
3. In the case of persons having suffered the case by their statements have already
bodily injury by aceident, injury by oth-
left the ship and cannot be found.
ers or self-mutilation abroad or at sea, as
a rule only a few indications are avail- These observations on the difficulties
able to the forensic medical specialist with which the forensic medical speeialist
for making a judgement (i. e. whether a can be confronted when professionally
wound is open or closed; depth of inju- evaluating incidents on board ships were
ry; alcohol intoxication ofthe person in- compiled on the basis of more than 30
jured aceidentally, the victim of a crime years' activity and experience as a forensic
or the perpetrator). medical specialist in a seaport (Naeve [14],
Naeve [16]). The resulting conclusions
4. The living and working conditions on
about the problems, the kind of evaluation
board ships and in foreign ports differ in
data and the sources of error in forensic
many ways from those ofthe evaluator's
nautical medicine form the basis of this
horne country. A basic knowledge of
chapter.
nautical medicine is required for foren- In reviewing the literature some collated
sic medical evaluation.
information can be found on the field of
5. Also to be judged are cases of death and forensic nautical medieine (forensic pa-
ineidents on board ships which at the thology and toxicology) as weH as statisti-
time of occurrence were in other climatic cal data ab out the influence of alcohol on
zones than that of the native country. In seamen having had an aceident at sea or
this connection, the tropics and the sub- while working in ports. There is, however,
tropics are significant. A basic knowl- no comprehensive study presenting the
edge of tropical medieine and tropical specific problems of forensic nautical med-
pathology is then required for an evalua- ieine.
5.14 Forensie Nautical Medicine 443
putrefaction when being embalmed or pre- with reservation. If the corpse is sent to the
served (death at sea, death by drowning in horne country, a second autopsy is often
port), results suitable for evaluation can necessary to obtain specimens for histolog-
still be expected by applying special meth- ical examination. The organs removed at
ods of examination. When decay has set in, the first autopsy are rarely retained or for-
one blood sampie should be taken from warded to the horne country.
each of two or three blood vessels sepa- Personal observations: a) Death at sea.
rately (i. e. right and left upper thigh vein, Coronary thrombosis and infarction given
upper arm vein). as cause of death by examiner. Further ex-
The examination of blood changed by amination: no coronary thrombosis, coro-
decay and the critical assessment of results nary arteries not incised. Cause of death
of analyses should always be delegated to a histologically proved: chronic myocarditis.
forensic medical specialist experienced in b) Partial autopsy abroad. Cause of death:
this special field. When available, in addi- angina tonsillaris - sepsis. Further autopsy
tion to blood sampies from decayed including histological examinations: cere-
corpses, a urine sampie (8-10 ml or less) bral form of an acute malaria tropica. c)
should be kept for an alcohol test. Some- Death at sea, autopsy abroad. Cause of
times it is not possible to withdraw a blood death: lung oedema after previous proto-
sampie from decayed corpses, not even zoal infection. Further autopsy including
from the heart (blood from the heart is less histological examination. Cause of death:
suitable for alcohol determination). In any recurrence of malaria tropica, acute cere-
particular case alcohol may diffuse from bral form.
the stornach after death, thus raising the Serious occupational poisoning resulting
amount which would be found there at almost exclusively from inhalation of poi-
post-mortem examination. If no blood can sonous gases or vapours is not rare in sea-
be withdrawn, the alcohol concentration of faring. The same holds true for death by
the urine alone can indicate the presence of suffocation while in parts of the ship in
alcohol influence. If neither blood nor which there were actually no toxic sub-
urine are available for sampies, an attempt stances but where the oxygen content of
should be made to withdraw fluid from ei- the air was substantially reduced (storage
ther the eye chambers or the knee joints. If rooms). Some of these cases of death are,
that fails, a rough estimate of the influence according to the facts, indisputable as far
of alcohol may be obtained from examina- as the cause is concerned - poisoning or
tion of tissues such as brain or skeletal suffocation - and do not necessarily re-
muscle. Preservation and storage of these quire a medical examination. In some
should be as described for "blood sam- cases, however, doubt may exist as to the
pIes". In some countries death from natu- cause of sudden death. Natural death, poi-
ral causes can under certain circumstances soning or suffocation may be the cause.
be recognised in law as qualifying for Sometimes there has been an attempt by
compensation. The histological findings in others to conceal some deficiency, such as
such a case are indispensable. Unfortu- a defective respirator, which is an offence
nately, an autopsy carried out in a different against existing safety regulations. In the
country may be restricted to deciding only same way others may have deliberately or
on death from natural or violent cause and subconsciously attributed a natural death
histological findings may not have been ei- to an accidental cause. A good example of
ther made or recorded. The general post- this is death resulting from acute poisoning
mortem findings made by a doctor called while working (pension claim).
upon only occasionally to perform an au- The clarification of questionable causes
topsy must also be evaluated critically and of death by poisoning in seafaring can be
5.14 Forensie Nautical Medicine 445
associated with the greatest of difficulties ment of the scene of the accident in ques-
because findings in suffocation are unchar- tion and of the equipment possibly used.
acteristic. They also occur in connection Carbon monoxide intoxication must al-
with cardiac death. Without question a ways be considered in cases ofunexplained
macroscopic and microscopic anatomical death (blood withdrawal, quantitative ex-
examination should be sougtht. As far as amination of blood for carbon monoxide
existing circumstances permit, an attempt content).
to obtain chemical-toxicological proof Sud den and unexpected death from nat-
should be made in cases of questionable ural causes may give reason to suspect ac-
poisoning by inhalation. From practical ex- cidental death from exterior violence or in-
perience, such examinations prove success- toxication. In general, the forensic signifi-
ful only if the organs and body fluids to be cance of these deaths is based on the fact
examined are obtained properly and soon that, as a rule, their cause is unknown and
after death and when the analysis is made cannot be clarified without further exami-
at an institute where suitable facilities for nation. It has proved convenient for the in-
examination are at hand. terpretation of findings made during the
Organs and body fluids (lung, brain, autopsy in such cases to classify them in
blood, urine) which are designated for toxi- three degrees of severity. The first group in-
cological examination must be placed in a cludes findings which in themselves, on the
securely closed container immediately after basis of their degree of severity and their
withdrawal, kept cool and examined soon localisation, make death self-explanatory
thereafter. In the practice of forensic nauti- (i. e. infarction, apoplexia cerebri, pericar-
cal medicine, however, such chemical-toxi- dial tamponade after cardiac rupture by in-
cological examinations can hardly ever be farction, bleeding to death from peptic ul-
carried out under the necessary conditions ceration, internal bleeding after rupture of
because of the circumstances peculiar to an aortic aneurysm, massive pulmonary
seafaring. embolisrn). In the second group of cases of
In connection with questionable poi- sudden death, changes in organs are found
soning by inhalation at sea, an attempt is which may explain death but from which,
generally made to either prove or exclude a however, a cause for a sudden and unex.-
natural death by means of an autopsy in- pected death cannot be recognised. In most
cluding histological findings. Anatomical cases it is a matter of chronic diseases (gen-
alterations of the respiratory tract and the eral arteriosclerosis, coronary sclerosis, hy-
lungs are not frequent in cases of intoxica- pertension, valvular heart disease). Death
tion by inhalation. If they occur these alter- occurs mostly from an induced cause or
ations are more or less characteristic, even from special predisposing factors. The
though not specific, and may indicate poi- third group includes cases of death where
soning by inhalation. When medical judge- no positive cause of death can be proved in
ment is made according to the legal penal spite of comprehensive and careful exami-
point of view, such cases of death often re- nation. Undoubtedly the number of such
main "doubtful", because intoxication can- medically unsolved cases depends on the
not be proved from the anatomical findings quality and exactness of the examinations
alone with the assurance required by crimi- (Janssen and Naeve [8]).
nallaw. From this it can be seen that medi- The deaths in the second and third
cal findings alone are not sufficient to clari- groups often cause one to connect fatalities
fy such deaths if this is required. It is with working conditions in seafaring. Ana-
indispensable that, outside the field of tomical findings alone are not sufficient to
medicine, a technician or a chemist should decide whether external effects were the es-
make an objective examination and judge- sential reason for death. The evaluation of
446 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
such cases is made especially difficuIt by curs in the course of an act of violence
anatomieal findings made in a foreign among members of the crew, at least as far
country without the possibility of a second as the cases are known at all. As a rule the
autopsy or preservation of organs used for perpetrator and the victim are under the in-
histologieal examination du ring the first fluence of alcohol. For the most part death
autopsy. Among the external conditions is caused by knife stabbing or by punching
which may be a cause of death or may be and kicking. Of 29 cases of homicide
the precipitating factor in death from an among crew members on ships examined
existing illness, minor accidents, abnormal in recent years in Hamburg, 13 involved
bodily stress, extreme climatic conditions stab wounds, 7 severe bio ws (fist or blunt
(Kutz [10], Tromp [19]) and extremely acute instrument), 4 shooting, 3 being thrown in-
mental strain are especially important. At to the water, and 2 being pushed down
times the question arises whether death or stairs or thrown into a cargo hold. Notably,
inducement of natural death was brought there were no deaths by strangulation
about by animals via allergie reactions or (choking, strangling). About half of these
toxic effects (Banner [1]; Russel [18]), by homicides occurred at sea, the others on
consumption of incompatible or poisonous board ships lying in port.
plants or parts of plants with the food Where there is evidence of external
(Morton [12]) or by consumption of con- force, autopsies on persons having died at
taminated food. sea are carried out whether it is a matter of
An occupational illness of seamen, ma- homieide or the result of an accident.
laria, is often overlooked (Haas et al. [5]). These ·examinations refer especially to
Malaria must always be considered when skull-brain injuries. Personal experience
establishing the cause of death of seamen. has shown that, especially in deep sea fish-
Death from malaria can be pathologically- ing, accidental skull injuries may occur
anatomieally proved even if the organs to which, at first, cannot be distinguished
be examined are in astate of advanced from the effects of a blow made by an at-
putrefaction (Naeve [13]). tack with a blunt instrument. Together with
Among the natural causes of sud den a careful autopsy, knowledge and consider-
death at sea, the relevant statistics show ation ofthe existing working conditions are
that coronary diseases outnumber all oth- required for c1arification of this kind of
ers (coronary sclerosis with or without cor- case (Knight [9]). Forensic medical evalua-
onary thrombosis and with or without mor- tions are especially a problem in cases
phologieally proved infarction). where it is a question ofunproved guilt and
Formerly the assistance of a doctor was the deceased was buried without autopsy at
seldom considered necessary when judging sea or abroad.
a homicide. "The methods of killing were If it is a matter of legal consequence, sui-
rough and could easily be ascertained from cides on board ship are sei dom a forensic
external findings. It was not uncommon for medical problem. This is not the case when
a captain to be murdered in the times of judging such fatalities for social accident
sailing ships. In the times of the big pas- insurance or private insurance. It is of im-
senger liners the following three groups portance for this kind of evaluation, de-
gained prominence: killing in fighting and pending on the type of insurance, whether
in sexual excitement among the crew, mur- the effects ofworking conditions (accident,
der in connection with insurance deception extreme climatie conditions, extreme phys-
and the murdering of passengers not by ical or mental stress), organic diseases
members of the deck crew but by other (fever), endogenous mental illnesses,
members of the crew" (v. Hentig [6]). Now- chronic alcoholism (also alcoholie delir-
adays it is exclusively homicide which oc- ium), acute alcoholic intoxication or medi-
5.14 Forensie Nautical Medicine 447
cine/ drugs were present. It is also of im- severity ofthe existing illness or injury with
portance in cases of suicide where the his basic medical knowledge gained in con-
balance of the mind is disturbed. Without nection with his professional training?
exact case histories and anatomical as weil Each of these questions present added
as chemical-toxicological examinations, difficulties. No generally valid guidelines
some of these cases of suicide at sea remain can be laid down. Pure theoretical-medical
unclarified with regard to aspects of insur- evaluations of such cases do not do justice
ance. In most cases only possibilities, at to all circumstances. The manifold pecu-
most probabilities, can be presented for liarities of seafaring must be taken into ac-
purposes of evaluation. count, and a theoretical and practical basic
It is common experience that not a few knowledge of nautical medicine is a pre-
fatalities on board ships, viewed critically requisite.
from a forensic medical standpoint as to
their cause, remain unsolved in the end. 5.14.4 Identification in the Realm of
The explanation for this lies in the pecu- Forensic Nautical Medicine
liarities of seafaring. It is better for the
medical administration of justice to accept A forensic medical specialist may be asked
this fact rather than to construct a hypo- to identify a dead person when the meth-
thetical cause of death. ods used by the police and criminologists
When evaluating death at sea for pur- fail or can no longer be applied. This task is
poses of forensic medicine, the question usually made very difficult by bodily
must at times be answered whether death changes caused by fire, explosion or pro-
of the injured or sick seaman would have, longed immersion in the sea. The loss of
in aB probability, occurred under condi- limbs and facial deformities can add to the
tions ashore, i. e. with regular medical care. difficulties. It may be necessary to consult
Such questions, of course, can be answered other specialists such as radiologists, dental
only after a pathological-anatomical ex- surgeons and anthropologists (Hunger and
amination. Similar problems occur in eval- Leopold [7]).
uating the question of a lack of effort to Should several corpses be found floating
help when, because of the ship's schedule on the water after a mishap on board ship
or other reasons, a siek or injured seaman then it is not only a matter of identifying
was not attended by a doctor although that missing crew members but also a question
would have been a possibility. The follow- of whether persons not belonging to the
ing questions would then have to be taken crew were on board and lost their lives at
into account: Could a complication of an the time of the incident. Such investiga-
illness, or the fatal development of such, tions of identity regarding the positions
have been prevented by medical help, ob- where the individual corpses were found
tained by caBing at a port? Which diagnos- on board ship may sometimes make it es-
tic and therapeutic possibilities would have sential to establish the cause of a mishap.
existed in the ports which could have been In addition to identification, the cause of
reached within reasonable time? How death as weIl as other findings are of signif-
much time would have elapsed between icance: determination of carbon monoxide
the decision to call at a port and the arrival in the blood of bumed corpses to clarify
of the ship in the harbour? Would there the question of whether the effects of the
have been a possibility for the officer in bums occurred during life or after death;
charge to obtain radiomedical advice? confirmation or exclusion of death by
What signs and symptoms were evident on drowning in reference to corpses recovered
examination ofthe injured or sick person? from the water; the influence of alcohol
Should a layman have recognised the etc. Unless it has been reported previously
448 5 Special Fields in Nautical Medicine
Philadelphia, London, Toronto: W.B.Saunders 17. Naeve, w.: Bedeutung des Alkohols bei
1977. pp. 1456-1567. tödlichen Unfällen an Bord und im Hafen. Blut-
13. Naeve, W.: Zum histologischen Nachweis einer alkohol 13,27-38 (1976).
akuten Malaria tropica an fäulnisveränderten 18. Russel, F.: Terrestrial and marine venomous
Organen. Z. Rechtsmedizin 69, 210-216 (1971). snakes. In: Forensic Medicine, Vo1.3. Philadel-
14. Naeve, w.: Forensische Schiffahrtsmedizin. Z. phia, London, Toronto: W.B.Saunders 1977.
Rechtsmedizin 73,321-324 (1973). pp. 1437-1444.
15. Naeve, W. and U.Klages: Trunkenheit bei der 19. Tromp, S. W.: Influence ofthe physical environ-
Führung eines Schiffes. Blutalkohol 11, 357 -385 ment on accidents, crime, suicide and disease of
(1974). man. In: Forensic Medicine, Vo1.3. Philadel-
16. Naeve, w.: Gerichtsmedizinische Obduktionen phia, London, Toronto: W.B.Saunders 1977.
und Begutachtungen von Todesfällen auf See. pp. 1627-1642.
Acta medicinae legalis et socialis 24, 961-964
(1975).
Sources of Information
-, mental diseases 234 - fleet, work at sea 70,71 flexural psoriasis 217
-, pilot's health 385 - protection vessels 28 flies
-, survey 162 fis hing vessels -, disinfestation 302, 303
-, work environment prob- -, accidents 185,352 - in cabins 269
lems 87 -, acute tenosynovitis ofthe flue gas 340
feldscher 55 wrist 355 fluid
female seafarer 359 -, conjunctivitis 356 - and electrolyte balance 196
-, accidents 362 -, curly weed rash 355 - intakte 227
-, diseases and discharge 362 -, Dogger Bank itch 354 fluorouracil 214
-, equipment of drugs parti- -, erysipeloid 355 Flying Dutchman 12
cularly for women 364 -, excessive fatigue 353 food
-, fitness standards 364 -, fern ale seafarer 359,363 -, avitaminosis 146
- in the ship's commu- -, haddock rash 355 -, balanced nourishment 145
nity 360 -, hands and fingers 352,354 -, catering 273
-, medicine chest 364 -, health education 263 -, cleaning and disinfection
- on fishing vessels 363 -, medical of store-rooms 149
-, repatriation 341 centre 36 -, climatic influence 145
-, specific health prob- problems 353 -, disinfection 301
lems 361 standards 351 -, energy requirement, fisher-
-, type of ships 359 training 356 men 143,144
females, work at sea 71 -,officers 357 -, fruits 147
ferry boats 359 -, ophthalmic diseases 244 handling equipment, inter-
fever, infectious diseases 295 -, pre-employment medical national health regula-
fibre content 193 examination 357 tions 313
films, recreation 78 -, radiomedical advice facil- hygiene 273,281
filtration, water supply 131 ity 357 -, buffets on deck 276
fingerprints, forensic nautical -, risk factor 352 -, canteen or dining
medicine 448 -, salt water boils 354 room 273
Finnish Board of Navigation, -, specific diseases 354 -, cool stores 282
testing of immersion -, visual acuity 351 -, crockery design 279
suits 412 -, Working Group of Mari- -, deep freeze units 281
fire time Medical Experts 357 -, delivery 278
- extinguisher 346 fissures 192 -, disease outbreaks 274,
- fighting drills 389 fitness 275,277,292,374
first aid for duty at sea 319 -, disposable towels 277
- care, search and rescue -, cardiovascular dis- -, epidemiology 273
medicine 402 ease 325 -, equipment and work
-, eye injuries 244 -, conclusion 327 surfaces 278
- on ships without a doc- -, diabetes mellitus 323 -, galley design 278
tor 53, 56 -, epilepsy 327 -, hand washing facili-
-, tankers, health problems -, health standards 319 ties 277
on 347 -, peptic u1cers 327 -, handling 274,275,276,
- treatment, toxicology 335 for sea travel 374
fish - children at sea 372 -, health education 277
- factory ship 36 - health care of passeng- -, machine, sterilised 280
-, food hygiene 276 ers 376 -, microbiological state in
- slime, fis hing vessels 355 -, sick seafarer ashore 256 food areas 273
fishermen standards -, packing or wrap-
-, accidents 184 - -, female seafarer 364 ping 278
-, epidemiology 181 - -,offshore medicine 416 -, personal hygiene 269,
-, food 144 flatulent dyspepsia 195 277
-, work-Ioad 74 flatus 193 -, pesticides 282
fishery fleas 302 -, pipes and ducts in food
-, deep sea vessels 98 Flensburger Studie preparation areas 279
factory vessels, dental -, alcohol 285 -, preparation 269,273,
care 249,251 -, work at sea 75 278
Subject Index 465
insomnia, mental diseases 235 -, nautical medical offi- oxide, tankers, health prob-
Institut za pomorsku medicinu cer 314 lems 340
(Maritime Medicine Insti- -, plaque 313 ships, history 5
tute) Split 451 -, point of arrival 311 stoves, history 10
Institute -, Port Health Author- irritable bowel syndrome 193
for Maritime and Tropical ity 310 irritant vapours, tankers 346,
Medicine in Gdynia 451 -, ships carrying migrant, 347
of Nautical and Tropical nomads, seasonal workers, Irvine, George James 9
Diseases, Hamburg 263 pilgrims 314 ischaemia 192
ofNaval Medicine, Alvers- -, yellow fever 313 ischaemic
toke 451 Maritime Conventions, ex- cardiac diseases 180
of Research into Alcoho- treme conditions 389 change, cardiovascular dis-
lism in Oslo 287 Maritime Dangerous eases 221
instruments, medieine chest 39 Goods Code heart disease
insulation suits, life-saving ap- -, chemical tankers 347 -, extreme conditions 390
pliances 411 -, toxicology 331 -, fitness for duty at
insulin-dependent Maritime Organization sea 325
-, diabetes mellitus 323 (IMO)* 331 -, in sea captains 222
- serving seafarers 324 Medical Guide for Ships isolation
insurance, children at sea 369 -, aceidents 187 and infectious diseases,
intelligibility of the spoken -, fishing vessels 357 health care of passeng-
word, diving 431 -, health standards, fitness ers 380
internal for duty at sea 320 -, international health regula-
combustion engine exhaust -, medical care on ships tions 313
fumes 86 without a doctor 54 -, psychological prob-
injuries 185 -, medieine chest 36 lems 152
medical and surgical treat- -, venereal diseases 208 - ward, history 11
ment under high pressure, Radio Medical Center isoniazid, renal tuberculo-
diving 436 (CIRM) 58 sis 232
temperature, extreme con- Safety Guide for Oil Tank- isopression, diving 430
ditions 392 ers and Terminals 338 Israel Merchant Marine Sea-
International Sanitary men's Clinic 203
Agreement for Safety on - Code 311 ITU see International Tele-
Ships, life-jackets 410 - Regulations 311 communication Union
Certificates of Vaccina- Signal Book 60
tion 295 Standards of Medical Care,
fishing vessels 357
J
Classification of Dis-
eases 177, 178, 198 Telecommunication Union jaundice 190, 194, 195
Conference on Safety of (ITU) 58 jealousy, paranoia 239
Life at Sea 331 intestinal jelly fish
Health Regulations haemorrhage or perfora- -, fishing vessels 356
-, charges 314 tion 327 - stings 215
-, cholera, definiton 311 parasitic infestations 214 Jerome, Jerome K. 18
-, diseases subject to 311 intoxication and addiction 238 jet-lag 100
-, disinfestation 305 intracranial pressure 237 Joi:1, Franz 15
-, epidemiological infor- intravenous pyelogram 227, Joint Committee
mation 311 232
-, free practique 311 introspection 235
-, health documents 314 investigations
-, health measures and and treatment ashore 254 * In 1981/82 this organiza-
procedure 312 - identity, forensie nautical tion was renamed from
-, infected area 311 medieine 447 "Intergovernmental Mari-
-, infectious diseases 295 iodising potable water 132 time Consultative Organi-
-, malaria 314 IPV see inactivated polio vac- zation" (IMCO) to "Inter-
-, medical examina- eine national Maritime Organi-
tion 311 iron zation" (IMO).
Subject Index 471
teaching and training, psycho- - diseases 245, 246 -, noxious substances, delete-
logical problems 158 thrombocytopenia 230 rious effect 329
telegraphy 60 -, tankers 339 -, pesticides 334
temperature thymoleptics, psychoses 237 -, preparation ofthe cargo
-, extreme conditions 391 thyroid gland diseases, psycho- spaces 333
-, food hygiene 274 tic syndromes 236 -, prevention of poison-
-, personal hygiene 269,270 time ing 336
-, search and rescue medi- -, spent underwater div- -, principal clinical syn-
eine 395 ing 432 dromes 333
temperatures -, temperature, concentration -, route of exposure 334
-, ambient 277 and penetration ofthe fu- -, shipboard chemical fac-
-, rules on, food hygiene 276 migant 303 tors 329
testes, disorders 232 tinea -, shipping conditions of
testicular tumour 232 - pedis 216 dangerous goods 332
testosterone function, orchid- - versicolor 217 -, toxicological principle of
ectomy 232 TLV see thershold limit values classification of vapours
tetanus vaccination, infectious tobacco 190 and gases 332
diseases 296 - consumption 289 -, transport hazard 330
tetracycline -, fishing vessels 353 trace elements 143, 146
-, granuloma inguinale 212 toilets 129, 135, 136 training syllabus, fishing ves-
-, health care of passen- toluene, tankers 341 sels 357
gers 376 tonsillitis 246 tramping 70
-, (hydrochloride), gonor- tooth diseases 248 tranquiliser, psychoses 237
rhoea 209 tooth-ache 250 transfusion, blood, health care
-, Iymphogranuloma vene- topical steroids of passengers 375
reum 211 -, foot eczema 216 transient ischaemic attacks,
-, medicine chest 44 -, hand eczema 216 health care of passen-
-, NGU 209 -, solar changes 213 gers 376
-, prostatitis 231 toxic transport hazard, toxicol-
-, skin diseases 213 effects of dangerous goods, ogy 330
-, syphilis 210 toxicology 332 Transport Medical Institute,
-, throat diseases 246 effects, health educa- Sofia 263,451
tetraethyllead, tankers 343, tion 264 Transporten meditsinski insti-
346 gas, disinfestation 303 tut, Sofia 451
tetramethyllead, tankers 343, oxygen effects, diving 431 traps, rats, disinfestation 305,
346 toxicological examination, fo- 306
thawing of frozen food 276, rensic nautical medi- trauma
281 cine 445 among seamen 175
thermal toxicology - on board, musculoskeletal
bums, eyes 244 -, acute poisoning 333,334 diseases 203
environment 85 -, chronic poisoning 334 traumas, extreme condi-
stress, extreme condi- -, climatic and geographical tions 389
tions 393 conditions 333 traveller, international health
thermometer, maximum/mini- -, handling of dangerous regulations 312
mum 281 goods in ports 333 travellers' diarrhoea, health
thermoregulatory -, hazard, chemical 329 care of passengers 375
capaeity, extreme condi- -, IMO Dangerous Goods trawlers 71
tions 391 Code 331 Treponema palIidum 209
mechanisms 270 -, International Conference triage 187
thioridazine hydrochlo- on Safety of Life at Trichomonas vaginalis 209
ride 240 Sea 331 Trichophyton
threshold limit values (TLV) -, medical first aid and treat- - mentagrophytes 216
-, ship design 86 ment 335 - rubrum 216
-, tankers 342, 346 -, Medical First Aid Guide tri glyceride 146
throat for Use in Aceidents Invol- Trinity House, pilot's
- ailments, diving 437 ving Dangerous Goods 331 health 383
Subject Index 487