Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The practice of manual cleaning of sewers without safety equipments is not only violation of
the laws of the land but reflects the inhuman attitude towards certain sections of society, the
life conditions they face. There is urgent need to take proactive actions against such
practices and those violating the laws should be strictly punished. Thus, hereby discussing
the issue of manual scavenging in India.
Scavenging has been an occupation imposed upon certain citizens of the country by the
society, which later on continued as a traditional occupation among Scheduled Castes. This
class of citizens of India is known as Manual Scavengers.
Manual scavenging exists primarily because of absence of water borne latrines. The House-listing
and Housing Census, 2011 reported that there are about 26 lakh insanitary latrines in the country.
With emergence of urban areas these people were also employed for cleaning of sewers or septic
tanks.
Low level of education, awareness about their rights, laws and low self esteem force them to take
such work.
Lack of empathy among the government, contractors and household members employing manual
scavengers is another reason, wherein these class of people fail to see the agony of the manual
scavengers.
Poor implementation of the existing laws has also helped in continuation of this practice.
These section of society are not organized and don’t have any significant voice in the government
structures which cause their voice being unheard.
Manual scavengers are exposed to the most virulent forms of viral and bacterial infections
that affect their skin, eyes, limbs, respiratory and gastrointestinal systems. The toxic gases
from sewers create death threat for them. Their children are also caught up in this
quagmire. Under these circumstances, it is almost impossible for their children to become
educated. Even though, in modern times these people desire to leave the profession, their
social, economic, educational and cultural aspects have made it difficult for them to find an
alternate profession. The social stigma of untouchability continues to stick, in one form or
the other largely because of the unclean nature of their occupation.
Government initiatives to eliminate manual scavenging
Considering the seriousness of the situation government has taken a number of initiatives
focussing on conversion of insanitary latrines, rehabilitation and employment of manual
scavengers, scholarships for their children being the main focus area.
Prohibition of Employment as Manual Scavengers and their Rehabilitation Act, 2013’ (MS Act,
2013) which came into effect from 6thDecember, 2013 replaced Employment of Manual
Scavengers and Construction of Dry Latrines(Prohibition) Act, 1993.This Act intends to achieve
its objectives to:-
1. Eliminate the insanitary latrines.
2. Prohibit:-
1. Employment as Manual Scavengers
2. Hazardous manual cleaning of sewer and septic tanks.
Survey of Manual Scavengers and their rehabilitation,
within a time bound manner. The act says National Commission for Safai Karamcharis
(NCSK) would monitor implementation of the Act and enquire into complaints regarding
contravention of the provisions of the Act.
The National Safai Karmachari Commission which was mandated to implement the act has not been
functioning properly. Its website has not been updated about recent developments and new
initiatives.
In urban areas municipalities are cash short to use machines for cleaning of the sewers or provide
protective equipments. They generally blame contractors for any loss of life.
The States/UT’s are slow in identification of insanitary latrines and manual scavengers as there is no
time-bound plan for identification of insanitary latrines and manual scavengers.
Further, in a case filed in the Supreme Court of India, many States/UTs gave affidavit that there are
no insanitary latrines in their jurisdiction. Due to fear of contempt of the Court, they hesitate in
reporting existence of insanitary latrines and manual scavengers in their States/UTs.
At present the work of conversion of insanitary latrines into sanitary latrines is being attended to as a
part of broad programme of construction of toilets. There is a need to have a time-bound approach as
per the mandate of the MS Act, 2013, for conversion of insanitary latrines.
Rehabilitation of manual scavengers is also slow and in many cases not adequate due to
various problems being faced, which include:-
1. Manual scavengers are mostly illiterate and have no exposure to any work, other than sanitation
related work. Many of them are old. They lack confidence for running self employment projects.
Many of them are not willing even to avail any skill development training.
2. Banks are hesitant about providing loan to manual scavengers. Even many State Channelising
Agencies, due to low rate of recovery of loan from safai karamcharis, are not willing to extend loan
to manual scavengers.
Due to low confidence levels the identified manual scavengers demand that they may be
provided jobs of safai karamchari in local authorities.
Way forward
In India of 21st century, which aspires to be world power the practice of manual scavenging
must be completely abolished, otherwise it will remain a blot on India and its value system.
An aggressive campaign for this which focus on attitudinal change of the all sections of the
society must be followed. The National Commission for Safai Karamchari must be made
responsive and responsible to the needs of time. Swachh Bharat Mission may be used to
actively target conversion of insanitary latrines on priority basis. Liberated manual
scavengers must be linked to social security and other welfare schemes to ensure that they
are not dependent on this inhuman work for their survival. All these steps if taken seriously
the problem of manual scavenging can be eliminated
In News: With an aim of eliminating human entry into septic tanks and drains for cleaning, the
Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs has launched a ‘technology challenge’ seeking suitable
solutions from individuals and NGOs.
Background: Three labourers died cleaning a sewage treatment plant in Loni, Ghaziabad. The
deaths were allegedly caused by poisonous gas in the plant. Reports suggest that none of them were
even aware of the gases, and were without the necessary safety equipment.
Key Points:
Socio-Economic and Caste Census (SECC) released in 2015, states that there were around 0.18
million manual scavenging households in rural areas.
A government survey identifies 12,226 manual scavengers in 12 states. Most septic tanks are
emptied manually in Indian cities.
The lack of proper safeguards puts manual scavengers at risk of infections, which are
occasionally fatal.
Statistics show that 80% of India’s sewage cleaners die before they turn 60, after contracting
various infectious diseases.
The Technology Challenge:
The initiative is in line with the vision of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who recently expressed a
desire for a challenge to promote latest technologies to avoid human intervention in cleaning of
sewers and septic tanks in the country.
Objectives:
Identify technological and business process innovations
Endorse viable business models suitable for cities of different sizes and geographies, and pilot
test shortlisted technologies and solutions in select project cities
Bridge the gap between innovators or manufacturers and beneficiaries such as urban local bodies
and citizens
Loopholes in the Law:
Manual scavenging was banned in India in 1993. Employing people to the profession carries
possible imprisonment penalties for up to one year and fine of 50,000 rupees. Still, demand for
scavengers remains high.
The 2013 Prohibition of Employment of Manual Scavengers and Their Rehabilitation Act aimed
to introduce safety measures for manual scavengers and encouraged their rehabilitation. Activists
and manual scavengers have since criticized the law on the grounds that it does not strictly ban
the practice.
Manual scavenging also persists due to the continued presence of “insanitary latrines,” where
human waste has to be cleaned physically and not by a machine or sewage system. The majority
of such latrines are dry latrines, which don’t use water. According to the 2011 Census, there are
about 2.6 million dry latrines in India.
Protective gear like gloves, gas masks and boots are often not provided by employers, in
violation of the 2013 law, leading to diseases and even death. There is no proper accountability
system in place.
The 2013 Act allows manual scavenging if the employer provides ‘protective gear’; However,
the Act does not define what constitutes ‘protective gear,’ creating a possibility for employers to
exploit this provision
Social Exclusion experienced by Manual Scavengers: Both for belonging to a low caste and being
in a stigmatized profession
Denied access to places of worship, public sources of water
Excluded from cultural events
High gender pay gap (2014 report by Human Rights Watch (HRW) titled “Cleaning Human
Waste released”)
Patriarchy made women clean where no one else wants to clean up. Rehabilitation is also more
difficult for women as most of them are middle-aged and elderly.
When we look at the practice of manual scavenging in light of the caste hierarchies prevalent it
becomes amply evident that manual scavenging has traditionally been relegated to those present at
the bottom-most step of this caste ladder. So, even among the Dalits, manual scavengers are one of
the lower-most sub-groups, and are treated as such, even by the Dalits who occupy a higher place
than them in the caste hierarchy.
The Way Forward:
Government needs to now act with speed, sensitivity and consideration.
Urgent need of the hour – Political Will: The machines to clean sewers and septic tanks are already
available globally, but they need to be adapted to Indian conditions, and the government needs to
show the political will to actually use the technology on the ground on a large scale. A strong
political will is required to reform the system, and rescue the thousands from a life that denies them
basic dignity and rights.
Fulfil Present Legal Provisions: Neither contractors nor municipalities are providing the equipment
and logistical and medical support mandated by the law. Thus, even as we consider technology
solutions, there is a need to fulfil the provisions of the law already there. Otherwise, all the
innovation will not result in change on the ground.
Human Rights need to be Respected: India cannot claim to be “clean,” because we have doomed a
specific caste to clean our toilets, our garbage and our sewers manually. Some 95% of the people
engaged in this degrading practice are Dalits. The National Human Rights Commission has termed
manual scavenging as one of the “worst violations” of human rights. The casteist mindset of the
Government also needs to go an overhaul.
Swachh Bharat Abhiyan needs to work for the manual scavengers first: The Swachh Bharat
Abhiyan hasn’t made things better either as dry latrines are being built under the scheme. Although
the campaign encourages building composting toilets, bio-toilets and leach pits, people mostly
choose to build toilets with septic tanks and dry pits, which have to be serviced manually.
Book officials failing to enforce manual scavenging law
Please Note:
Mahatma Gandhi: “Everyone must be his own scavenger.”
“Open defecation free” not only means that there is no visible faeces in the environment; it also
means that every household and public institution uses safe technology to dispose of the same.
The National Policy on Faecal Sludge and Septage Management, 2017, states that
employment of manual scavengers is illegal, but it does not suggest mechanical alternatives to
unclog septic tanks, drains and sewers.
Bio-toilets: Bio-digester toilets are designed to convert human waste into gases and manure.
o The zero-waste biodigester technology uses psychrotrophic bacteria like Clostridium and
Methanosarcina (these microbes can live in cold or hot climate and feed on waste to
survive) to break down human excreta into usable water and gas. Once applied, the bacteria
can work for a lifetime.
o Waste from toilets are sent to a giant underground bio-digester tank where anaerobic
digestion takes place. Methane gas produced in the tanks can be used for different purposes,
including firing up gas stoves and generating electricity while the leftovers (popularly called
Humanure or ‘Human manure’) can be used for gardening and farming. It does not have any
geographical or temperature limitation and also does away with the need to set up large
sewerage networks.
o The technology was originally developed by the Defence Research Development
Organization’s (DRDO). The best feature of this toilet is that it totally does away with
manual scavenging, is low on maintenance and installation cost and can be adapted to any
geo-climatic conditions of the country.
o _____________
Enforcing Manual
Scavenging Law
iasparliament
September 17, 2018
6 months
1408
0
There were instances of death while cleaning septic tanks, in Delhi and
Odisha, recently.
This calls for addressing the shortfalls in implementation of the manual
scavenging law.
The workers in Delhi were asked to perform the task in violation of the
manual scavenging Act.
Apparently, many requirements of worker safety provided in the law are
often ignored.
A well-funded programme as the Swachh Bharat Abhiyan (SBA) pays little
attention to this aspect of sanitation.
More tanks are being built in rural and urban areas as part of the drive to
construct toilets.
But manual scavenging law is not being enforced, and there is no fear of
penalties.
Ministry of Drinking Water and Sanitation had itself acknowledged that in
rural areas, mechanical pumps to clear septic tanks are not available.
In the southern States, sanitation has expanded along with urbanisation.
But it has brought with it a higher number of deaths as workers clean
septic tanks manually.
E.g. Tamil Nadu recorded 144 fatalities of workers engaged for septic tank
cleaning in the past three years.
What is to be done?
The Centre must ensure that this does not become an avenue to oppress
members of some communities, reflecting social inequalities.
The Swachh Bharat Abhiyan should make expansion of the sewer network
a top priority.
It should come up with a scheme for scientific maintenance that will end
manual cleaning of septic tanks.
1. >1.6 lakh households had at least 1 member working as a MS. This puts the number of
manual scavengers in India at ≅1.7 lakh (mostly women).
2. ≅12k manual scavengers were identified across India in 2016 – 82% of these are in UP
(Ministry of Social Justice figures, 2016)
3. There exist 2.6 Mn insanitary latrines. 72% of these are in Andhra, Assam, J&K, Maha,
TN, UP and WB
Undignified life (all the 6 Fundamental Rights are compromised, directly or indirectly)
It perpetuates casteism
Modern, secular india has no place for such “professions”
Doesn’t suit India’s rising global profile – ‘super power’ aspirations
Women empowerment (most manual scavengers are dalit women)
MSRA 2013
Prohibits
survey insanitary latrines (i.e latrines without water) within its jurisdiction and
construct sanitary community latrines (demolition cost to be borne by the owner of such
latrine)
Anti-MS Efforts
Legal measures
budgetary support for the implementation of MSRA, 2013
Policy support
Scholarship schemes for children of those engaged in MS
Swachh Bharat Abhiyan
By the states
MSRA, 2013
primary responsibility for its implementation
UP govt
‘Daliya Jalao’ initiative freed almost 10% MS (of the state’s total MS burden) within a
year (spillover effects in terms of control over polio and diarrhoea)
Institutional action
Govt apathy
2.6 Mn insanitary latrines still exist (NGO Safai Karamchari Andolan, Census 2011 data)
72% of these are in Andhra, Assam, J&K, Maha, TN, UP and WB
1.3 million Dalits (mostly women) make living as manual scavengers (NGO data)
Indian Railways
1. continues to be the largest employer of MS (no data available about the no. of MS
employed)
2. typically employs MS through ‘contractors’
Societal prejudice
Way Forward
Civil Society
1. more intense activism is needed
Judiciary
1. judicial activism should be resorted to
2. if the SC can ban liquor stores on highways, why is MS being ignored?
Vigilant Media
1. can pressurize govt into action by animating the issue of MS
Govt
1. strict implementation of MSRA, 2013
Share this:
[This article is written specifically for UPSC IAS exam aspirants.
visit www.iasexpress.net for more articles]
Why in news?
Statistics prove that 80% of India’s sewage cleaners die before they
turn 60, after contracting various infectious diseases.
Manual Scavenging
Are you the ONE who don't like to take chances and waste one precious year by failing in Prelims?
Do you want to test your knowledge after reading a particular topic? Then The MCQ Factory (TMF) is for you! It provides topic
wise high quality MCQs for testing your knowledge in a particular topic. More details here
What is Manual Scavenging?
“Manual scavenger” means a person engaged in or employed for manually
carrying human excreta and the expression “manual scavenging” shall be
construed accordingly.