Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/224651853
CITATIONS READS
34 359
5 authors, including:
38 PUBLICATIONS 727 CITATIONS
McGill University
385 PUBLICATIONS 10,575 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Lisa Dignard-Bailey on 15 October 2015.
I. INTRODUCTION
development are promising. The current level of installed
Fig. 5. Ramea wind-diesel remote site configuration IV. RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT
The modern power system has greatly benefited from
D. FortisAlberta
microprocessor based devices as well as recent
FortisAlberta is an electricity distributor that operates developments in communication for applications ranging
networks in Southern Alberta and has integrated large from protection to control and operation. DG as an
amounts of DG into their systems. One particular feeder emerging technology also offers the potential to improve
incorporates both wind and hydro generation, a power system reliability, increase diversity, and provide
combination that will likely become more common in greater flexibility to help match the increasing and ever
Canada, particularly for rural systems. changing energy needs of the world’s population. Small
On the Fortis Alberta rural feeder of interest, the capacity generators essentially operate in three types of
installed capacity of the generation exceeds that of the load modes: grid connected, remote grids, and capability to
and during times of high generation the DG may produce operate grid connected or in islanded mode. The third
more than the local requirements, Fig. 6. This results in mode can greatly benefit from experience gained operating
reverse power flow across many of the voltage regulators, the former two. In all cases, the flexibility and ease with
which has caused unpredictable operation and in some which DG can be integrated will depend in large part on
cases unfavorable voltage profiles, [8]. the monitoring and communication capabilities present in
This base case is of interest as it combines a number of the network of interest.
renewable technologies (total 3 MW hydro and 3.78 MW
wind) and illustrates some of the technical problems that A. Distribution System Automation
can occur when DG is interconnected to systems with long The power of communication in a power system is that
lines. The participation of the utility and their willingness one has greater access to information, enabling improved
control, observability and planning of the system. It is fuel technologies is tightly tied to the price of fuel and the
apparent that DG will depend on an improved transportation and maintenance costs, which are typically
communication infrastructure and therefore would benefit much higher in remote locations; therefore, there is a
from increased investment in distribution system greater incentive to consider the application of renewable
automation. As many distribution companies are currently energy, combined heat and power retrofits, and demand
implementing distribution system automation (DSA) response strategies.
programs (e.g. Hydro-Québec), they are at the same time
D. Microgrids
investing in DG although this is usually not the primary
driving force. Not only will this permit monitoring of DG Applied research on microgrids that consider integrated
operation but it can also be used in the future to aid in network infrastructure and a power delivery system that
planning and optimized system operation. can operate in parallel with the grid or in an intentional
Communication between DGs, and between DG and the island mode is being supported by several international
distribution system operator will increase the likelihood of research programs. In Canada, there is an interest in
high penetration of DG. At present it is not clear how this considering the opportunity of linking distribution system
distribution infrastructure should be designed and, more automation infrastructure upgrades and the benefits for
importantly, who will be responsible for these network greater integration of distributed and renewable energy
system upgrade costs. In the case of large wind parks, technologies. However, the economic argument for
communication is vital to properly coordinate its operation configuring a system for microgrid is difficult, particularly
with that of the power system. In many cases the given the relatively high degree of reliability that is
transmission upgrades required to bring wind power to presently offered by most modern power systems.
regional loads was spread among rate payers since it was The extension from research to utility adoption will only
seen as a public good objective. Similarly, widespread follow with demonstration that microgrids provide both
integration of DG on the distribution network will not value and significant benefits. Although various utility case
occur until the necessary communication and distribution studies have been cited, it has yet to be established whether
automation and protection infrastructure is in place and the widespread utility adoption of the microgrid concept can
integration costs are accounted for. be anticipated. Research on microgrid management and
operation strategies that consider the use of renewables and
B. Demand Response Resources (DRR) environmentally preferred distributed power; peak-load
The connection of DG to the main grid can bring about management strategies; and automated distribution and
a number of benefits, which can be maximized by protection system architecture, have been initiated as part
coordinating the response of the different units in order to of the DEP program activities.
achieve various objectives. Combining the response of
generators with on demand load curtailment can further V. CANADIAN OUTLOOK
improve the effectiveness of this type of a program. The Presently, a great deal of knowledge has been gained
benefits of DG as part of a demand response program regarding DG technologies and their implementation.
design, such as Sherbrooke Hydro, needs to be considered. However, with the exception of wind parks, the actual
The province of Ontario has set a target of 250 MW for number of these systems is still minimal. In order to
demand response, and the aggregation of DGs can be increase the acceptance and level of DG, further steps are
considered when considering deferral of investments by required, each of which have been incorporated into the
utilities and “non-wires” solutions. design of the DEP research program.
Targeted requests for proposal for demand response
projects can favour specific regions where the benefits are A. Standardized impact assessment and integration
valued. Favourable pricing signals can be established in techniques
order to show partiality towards the interconnection of DG Significant effort has been made to develop
in those areas. This needs to be supported by the necessary interconnection standard and codes, as well as application
regulatory framework and demand response program guides. To complement these, more effort is now required
design. to improve the planning tools used by distribution
engineers, since they currently do not provide any guidance
C. Remote applications specific to the integration of renewable and distributed
In many countries the use of diesel generation in remote generation. These software tools need to evolve in order to
applications and communities is quite important. In facilitate the technical assessment of DG integration. A
Canada, there is a great interest to consider schematic that described the Canadian strategy is shown in
environmentally preferred options, such as integration of Fig. 7. NRCan is collaborating with CYME International
small hydro and wind. In addition, methods for load and utility partners to improve the software tool to
following in these communities could be demonstrated and accommodate modeling of DG and integration studies,
validated as part of these research activities. complemented with the development of case studies based
The economics associated with diesel and other fossil
TEAM
Fig. 7. Canadian technical strategy for addressing integration of DG.
upon Canadian benchmarks. These will be used to educate clear is what the actual amount should be. In certain cases a
and increase our knowledge base on the integration of DG DG may negatively impact the system whereas in different
and the use of these new software functionalities. circumstances DG will greatly contribute to improvements
in the overall operation of the system. Whereas methods
Regulatory support
for determining the technical impacts have already been
While many of the technical issues can be addressed developed methods for quantifying the benefits and costs
through the development of guides and interconnection associated with DG are not well defined, [10].
standards, regulations are typically a greater barrier to DG As the economics associated with DG presents itself as
integration. Due to the fact that the utility owns the likely the most important barrier, it is imperative that
infrastructure and are responsible for its operation, the methods for assessing the costs and benefits of DG be
responsibility for serving the client rest almost entirely with defined. Without properly defined methodologies much
this entity. As a result, the motivation for integration uncertainty remains regarding the actual costs that are
privately owned generators is not great considering that charged to DG owners and benefits will never be
these systems generally add a degree of complexity and appropriately acknowledged.
decrease the ability to which the system can be controlled.
Government policy changes can help to impose C. Regional characteristics
acceptance of certain amounts of renewable generation, Distributed generation has experienced a greater degree
however, equally important will be sharing of the of growth in certain countries where the technologies
responsibility for serving the load. Likely, DG will diverge implemented may not necessarily have been those best
into two general classes: those that are exempt from suited to the area in question. As the industry matures, site
responsibility and simply disconnect in the event of selection of the DG and selection of the technology itself
disturbance; and those that share in the responsibility and should reflect what makes most sense in terms of cost,
aid in supporting the grid network and in providing benefits, and needs of the local community. While optimal
ancillary services. For example, large wind parks are placement of DG may be too limiting in the site selection a
accepting more responsibility for grid support, whereas this move towards favoring certain regions over others through
additional complexity and costs for simple residential price signals should be considered. Furthermore, the
photovoltaic rooftop applications is not justified. The technologies that are chosen should be taken into
distinction should become clearer for all technologies in consideration when selecting the site as well. Wind and
order to streamline the process for integrating different small hydro are technologies that could certainly help to
types of environmentally preferred DG sources. serve rural systems, however they are less likely to play a
role in urban settings. Part of making renewables more
B. Cost benefit analysis
competitive with conventional technologies may be in
Greater responsibility for certain DG as well as supply choosing where they are most beneficial for the regional
of various services should be compensated for requirements.
economically. This will improve the economic viability of The application of microgrids in Canada will be based
DG but also will encourage participation in operation of the primarily on cost and reliability. Currently there are a
system. While this is more or less apparent, what is not as
number of applications that are of significant interest, such Energy Technology Centre – Varennes, Natural Resources Canada,
July 2005, pp. 20.
as to improve service on rural feeders (low probability, [8] Katiraei, F., C. Abbey, and R. Bahry, “Analysis of voltage regulation
high impact events), to reduce the use of diesel fuel in problem for a 25 kV distribution network with distributed
remote communities, and where sensitive loads on the grid generation” PES General Meeting 2006, accepted, Montreal, June
2006.
demand a higher level of reliability (emergency and back-
[9] Natural Resources Canada, CANMET R&D program web link :
up power supply). http://cetc-varennes.nrcan.gc.ca/en/er_re/inter_red/
[10] Rawson, M., “Distributed generation costs and benefits issue paper”,
VI. CONCLUSIONS California Energy Commission (CEC), Public Interest Energy
Research Staff Paper, July 2004.
Decentralized energy production has the potential to
offer improvements in power system efficiency, reliability IX. BIOGRAPHIES
and energy diversity, as well as provide an opportunity to Chad Abbey (S’01) received degree in electrical engineering from the
integrate a more significant level of renewable energy into University of Alberta in 2002. In 2004, he graduated with an M. Eng
our current generation mix in Canada. While significant degree from McGill University, Montréal where he is currently pursuing
his Ph.D.
knowledge has been gained through past experience, the He is presented working with CANMET Energy Technology Centre,
practical implementation of smaller distributed generation in Varennes, Québec where he is a Research Engineer and coordinates a
has proved to be more challenging than perhaps originally joint research program on the modeling and integration of distributed
generation. His current research interests include wind energy, distributed
anticipated. Numerous barriers have presented themselves
generation and their integration to the grid.
in opposition to large-scale integration, namely technical
challenges, lack of the necessary regulatory framework, Farid Katiraei (S’01, M’05) received B.Sc. and M.Sc. degrees in
and cost. The extent of future DG growth will depend in electrical engineering from Isfahan University of technology (Iran) in
1995 and 1998 respectively. He received his Ph.D. degree also in electrical
large part on a greater understanding of its impact on the engineering from University of Toronto (Toronto, Canada) in 2005. He is
power system, improvements in current utility system currently a T&D research engineer at the CANMET Energy Technology
planning tools, and significant collaboration from all Center (Varennes, Québec). His research interests include power
electronic applications on power systems and distributed energy
stakeholders in cooperatively developing a sustainable generation systems for microgrid applications.
strategy for integration of renewable and distributed
generation in Canada. Carl Brothers received his BSc in Mechanical Engineering from the
University of New Brunswick (1976). Since 2004, he is General Manager
at Frontier Power Systems, a wind-diesel systems integrator and developer
VII. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS responsible for the RAMEA project. He has been Site Manager, for twenty
years at the Atlantic Wind Test Site, a national facility for testing and
The authors would kindly like to acknowledge
developing wind turbines. Previously, he has held engineering positions at
contributions from BC Hydro, Canadian Wind Energy Nitrochem Inc., CE Canada and Amoco Oil Company.
Association (CANWEA), Sherbrooke Hydro, CIMA, Mr. Brothers has received the Canadian Wind Energy Association’s
Newfoundland and Labrador Hydro and FortisAlberta. R.J. Templin Award (1995) for his outstanding contribution to the
development of Canadian wind-energy technology.
Financial support for this research project was provided
in part by Natural Resources Canada through the Lisa Dignard-Bailey received her Ph.D. in Chemistry (1986) from the
Technology and Innovation Initiative as part of the climate University of Western Ontario in London, Canada, and also worked as a
post-doctoral fellow in the Engineering Physics Department of École
change plan for Canada. Polytechnique in Montréal, Canada. She joined CANMET research
laboratories of Natural Resources Canada in 1987 and is currently a science
VIII. REFERENCES and technology program manager at the CANMET Energy Technology
Centre based in Varennes, Québec. She is the R&D program leader for the
[1] http://www.canwea.ca application of renewable energy in remote communities and theme leader
[2] http://www.micropower–connect.org for the integration of decentralized energy resources. She is actively
[3] Joos, G., “Grid code review”, Integration of Renewable Energy involved in the development of international standards and is a member of
Sources and Distributed Energy Resources Conference, Brussels, the Canadian Standards Association committee responsible for renewable
Dec. 1-3, 2004. energy standards.
[4] Dignard, L., “Canadian program on decentralized energy production:
a component of the technology and innovation initiative”,
Géza Joós (M’82, SM’89) graduated from McGill University,
Integration of Renewable Energy Sources and Distributed Energy
Montreal, Canada, with an M.Eng. (1974) and Ph.D. (1987). His
Resources Conference, Brussels, Dec. 1-3, 2004.
employment experience includes ABB, the Ecole de technologie
[5] www.climatechange.gc.ca/english/team_2004/
supérieure, Concordia University, and since 2001, McGill University,
[6] Fulton, R., and C. Abbey, “Planned islanding of 8.6 MVA IPP for
Montreal, Canada. He is involved in fundamental and applied research
BC Hydro system reliability”, Integration of Renewable Energy
related mostly to the application of high-power electronics to power
Sources and Distributed Energy Resources Conference, Brussels,
conversion and power systems, an area in which he has published
Dec. 1-3, 2004.
extensively.
[7] Cantin, M., “Use of emergency generators for peak load shaving in
He is Vice-Chair (2001-2003) of the Industrial Power Converter
Quebec”, report # CETC-Varennes 2005-162 (TR), CANMET
Committee of the IEEE Industry Applications Society (IAS) and is active
on a number of IEEE Power Engineering Society working groups,
including the DC and FACTS Subcommittee of the Transmission and
Distribution Committee and Chair (2003-)