You are on page 1of 5

XXIV World´s Poultry Congress 5 - 9 August - 2012 • Salvador - Bahia - Brazil

Poultry production and climate change


cycle is considered (i.e. livestock production cycle
only, or full life-cycle analysis considering emissions
Ph.D., P.E.; Assistant Dean for Agriculture, Natural from crop production and fossil fuel use). The
Resources & Resource Development; Food and Agricultural Organization of the United
The University of Tennessee Extension; 120 Nations (FAO report, Livestock’s Long Shadow, a
Morgan Hall, 2621 Morgan Circle; Knoxville life-cycle assessment of the global environmental
TN 37996-4522; (865) 974-7112 impact of livestock production, estimates that
rburns@utk.edu livestock production is responsible for 18% of all
Skype ID: rtburns anthropogenic GHG emissions in the world (FAO et
al., 2007). This report considers emissions of CO2,
N2O and CH4 from enteric fermentation, manure
management, land application of manure, and also
from deforestation that the FAO associates with
Summary livestock production in developing countries. The
life-cycle analysis methodology used by the FAO
has been questioned by other scientists involved

T
he production of livestock generates in GHG emission quantification. Specifically, some
greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, including have questioned the GHG contribution from
carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrous oxide (N2O) and deforestation. Also it has been suggested that
methane (CH4). When animals respire they the life-cycle analysis for livestock emissions was
produce CO2. Methane is produced during enteric more complete, and therefore reported more

Robert T. Burns
fermentation in the animal’s digestive tract and is emissions than the analysis for other sectors, such
released into the atmosphere. Manure can produce as transportation, that were used to derive the total
CO2, N2O and CH4 from microbial activity during GHG emissions in the FAO analysis (Pitesky et al.,
storage and following land application. When 2009).
viewed in a life-cycle analysis, the GHG emissions
from the production of crops used to feed livestock In contrast to the estimate that livestock production
and poultry as well as fossil fuel consumption is responsible for 18% of all anthropogenic GHG
during the rearing of livestock and poultry should emissions, the contribution from livestock production
also be considered. Increases in greenhouse gas to GHG emissions in the form of CH4 and N2O in the
levels in the atmosphere have been linked to global Unites States from enteric fermentation and manure
climate change. As the public has become more management has been estimated to be less than
concerned with global climate change, they have 3% of the total anthropogenic GHG emissions by
sought information on the environmental footprint the US EPA (US EPA, 2009). The 2007 US EPA GHG
of various products, including food. Because poultry emissions inventory estimates that U.S. agriculture is
have lower GHG emissions due to their lower responsible for 5.8% of the total U.S. anthropogenic
enteric methane production rates than ruminant GHG emissions. Agricultural soil management is
livestock species, many consider poultry to have an by far the largest contributor to agricultural GHG
environmental advantage compared to many other emissions, representing approximately 50% of the
animal protein sources (Verge et al., 2009). agricultural GHG emissions. The US EPA inventory
includes emissions from both commercial fertilizer
The contribution of livestock and poultry and manure application in the agricultural soil
production to GHG emissions has been estimated management category. Enteric fermentation
and reported by various groups. The estimated represents the second largest agricultural GHG
magnitude of GHG emissions from livestock emissions source accounting for 34% of the
production varies by how the estimates are made agricultural emissions. Manure management is the
(i.e. which gases and source types are considered), third largest agricultural GHG emissions source,
with the spatial area being considered in the representing 14% of the GHG emissions from
estimates (i.e. for a specific region, country or for the agriculture.
entire world), and on how much of the production

Area: Poultry Welfare and Environment • August 08


1
XXIV World´s Poultry Congress 5 - 9 August - 2012 • Salvador - Bahia - Brazil

Emissions of GHG from manure storage, considers geese and ostrich production in their
treatment and land application are generated by calculations we well (Dong et al., 2006).
microbial activity. Emissions of CH4 occur under
anaerobic conditions, while N2O emissions occur Both poultry meat production and egg
when alternating aerobic and anaerobic conditions production have been increasing, in a large part due
exist. To reduce the uncertainty of GHG emissions to an increase in per capita consumption of both
inventories, additional and higher quality GHG poultry meet and eggs in Asia. As shown in Figure
emissions data is needed. Additionally, more data on 1, the production of chicken meat has shown a
the impact of different manure storage, treatment continual increase over the last decade. Figure 2
and land application systems is needed to better shows the world production of in shell hen eggs. As
identify potential GHG mitigation opportunities noted, the world consumption of both poultry meat
related to manure management. Additional manure and eggs has shown a continual increase over the
management emissions data is especially needed for past decade.
N2O.
The majority of GHG emissions data available
In addition to improved GHG emissions data for to date is for broiler and layer operations, although
inventory purposes, research to identify practical some data can also be found for turkey, duck and
and cost effective GHG mitigation options is also goose production systems as well. Many studies
needed. While it is recognized that some current report emissions on an average bird mass. However,
manure best management practices (such as because meat poultry are gaining weight throughout
biofilters for odor control, vegetated treatment the grow-out cycle it is more appropriate to use
systems for manure run-off control, and permeable emission factors for a per bird produced basis than
manure storage covers) may actually increase GHG to use average bird weight to estimate emissions.
emissions associated with manure management
systems, and other best management practices (such Emissions of CO2, N2O and CH4 can be released
as sub-surface manure injection) can decrease GHG from animal housing areas. While bird respiration and
emissions, the overall potential of these systems to manure produces CO2 emissions, the current IPCC
impact GHG emissions from animal agriculture has Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories
Robert T. Burns

not been well defined at this time. do not consider CO2 generated by livestock or poultry
to be a source of emissions that should be included
in GHG inventories.These CO2 emissions are not
Greenhouse emissions considered in GHG emission inventories because
they are assumed to be zero on a net annual basis.
from poultry production It is assumed that the CO2 generated by livestock
and poultry respiration and manure storage and
handling will be photosynthesized by crops and
Greenhouse gas emissions
are generated from poultry
housing areas, manure storage,
manure treatment and manure
land application from both meat
and egg poultry production
operations. The Intergovernmental
Panel on Climate Change (IPPC)
GHG emissions methodologies
include emissions from both meat
and egg production systems.
Categories include confined
broiler chickens, ducks and turkeys
and free range chicken and turkey
systems for meat production.
The IPPC inventories include dry
and wet manure management
confinement layer systems as well
as free range chicken systems for Figure 1 - World chicken meat production: 2000 – 2010 tonnes of
egg production. The IPPC also eviscerated meat. Data Source - FAOSTAT.

2 Area: Poultry Welfare and Environment • August 08


XXIV World´s Poultry Congress 5 - 9 August - 2012 • Salvador - Bahia - Brazil

enterprises.

Since CO2 from respiration


and manure management and
enteric CH4 and N2O are typically
not reported in GHG emission
inventories for poultry, the
storage and handling of poultry
manure represents the sources
of N2O and CH4 emissions
associated directly with the
poultry production system. Also,
the combustion of fossil fuels
for winter heating in confined
meat and egg production systems
represents a source of CO2
Figure 2 - World hen egg production: 2000 – 2010 thousands of eggs. emissions that should be included
Data Source - FAOSTAT. in GHG inventories associated
with poultry production. Similarly,
in a complete life-cycle analysis,
plants used as animal feed in the annual production GHG emissions from cropping systems used to
cycle and as such does not contribute to increasing produce poultry feed would be considered as well.
GHG concentrations in the atmosphere over the Few GHG emission studies take a comprehensive
long term. As such, GHG emissions inventories approach and consider all of these sources.
based on IPCC methodology do not include CO2
emissions from livestock or poultry respiration or One study that does consider the complete
manure. Methane can also be produced directly production system is one conducted by Verge et al.

Robert T. Burns
by poultry through enteric fermentation. Methane in 2009 for the Canadian poultry industry. The study
emissions from enteric fermentation from poultry considered all aspects of commercial Canadian
are many times considered negligible and not poultry production (broilers, layers and turkeys for
included in poultry GHG emission inventories. The meat production and layers for egg production) using
IPPC GHG emission calculation methodologies for data from the period spanning 1981 to 2006. The
example, do not have an enteric CH4 emission factor study considered the full production cycle including
for poultry. While significantly less enteric CH4 are crop production and fossil fuel heating. The study
generated from poultry compared to ruminant did not include enteric emissions from poultry. The
livestock, poultry do produce some enteric CH4 study found that the primary contributor to GHG
emissions. Wang and Haung reported enteric emissions was N2O emissions from crop production
CH4 and N2O emissions from commercial broiler systems associated with growing poultry feed, with
chickens, Taiwan country chickens and White crop and manure N2O emissions representing 57%
Roman Geese based on respiration chamber
studies (Wang and Haung, 2005). Figure 1 has
been reproduced from Dunkley, 2011 to give a
comparison of enteric emissions from ruminant
livestock, in this case dairy cattle, to poultry.
Dunkley shows that on an annual per animal
basis, dairy cattle emit about 475 times more
enteric methane than poultry. Adjusted for
body mass assuming a 680 kg (1500 lb.) dairy
cow and a 2.27 kg (5 lb.) chicken, the enteric
CH4 emission values presented by Dunkley for
poultry are approximately 2.7 times greater than
those reported by Wang and Haung for broiler
chickens (Wang and Haung, 2005). Additional
research on poultry enteric emissions is needed
to better define the magnitude of these Figure 3 - Methane emissions from enteric fermentation
emissions for various meat and egg poultry reprinted from Dunkley, 2011.

Area: Poultry Welfare and Environment • August 08


3
XXIV World´s Poultry Congress 5 - 9 August - 2012 • Salvador - Bahia - Brazil

of the total GHG emissions. The use of fossil fuels to come from the production of crops for poultry
heat poultry houses represented the second largest feed, the greatest opportunity to reduce emissions
contributor to GHG emissions, representing 38%. is within this sector. Greenhouse gas emissions in
Methane generated from poultry manure systems the form of are produced from the manufacture
represented 5% of the total GHG emissions. Based of nitrogen fertilizer and from nitrogen conversion
on overall Canadian meat production data from in the soil during the crop production cycle. The
2001, poultry was determined to emit 47% as much reduction of nitrogen addition to the soil through
GHG per unit live weight as pork and only 10% as various methods is one possible mitigation strategy.
much GHG per unit of live weight as beef (Verge et This could be achieved by selecting cropping and
al., 2009). The results of this study are specific to management systems that increase nitrogen
Canadian conditions however. The Canadian poultry efficiency in poultry feed production. Possible
industry uses confined production systems that options to increase nitrogen efficiency include using
require heating in the colder months. Also the study crops with that require less nitrogen per unit of yield
was specific to Canadian crop productions systems. compared to traditional poultry feed crops or tillage
Two similar life-cycle analysis studies for commercial or crop management methods that reduce crop
broiler production in Sweden provide similar results. nitrogen requirements.
A 2008 study by Thynelius and a 2009 study by
Cederberg et al., indicate that the majority of GHG Typical commercial poultry production systems
emissions from broiler production are associated require auxiliary heating in many production
to the production of feed crops (Sonesson et al., locations. The use of fossil fuels to heat poultry
2009). Table 1 shows a comparison of the results houses generates GHG emissions. As shown in
from these two studies to the Verge et al., study Table 1, the use of fossil fuels represents the
second largest source of
GHG emissions for poultry
Table 1 - Distribution of greenhouse gas emissions by category. production systems in
Percentage of total emissions (%) climates where heating is
Study
Crop production Fossil fuel heating Manure required. Fossil fuel use can
be reduced by adopting
Robert T. Burns

Verge et al., 2009 57 38 5


conservation measures
Thynelius, 2008 67 17 16 that reduce house heating
Cederberg et al., 2009 84 3 13 requirements and by
replacing fossil fuels with
alternative, renewable
conducted in Canada for broilers and layers. Similar fuels. Conservation methods include the use of high
holistic studies that consider GHG emissions from efficiency lighting systems, improved ventilation
crop production and fossil fuel heating are needed management, selecting and maintaining high
that provide data for meat and egg
poultry production systems in other
parts of the world.

Mitigation of Gre-
enhouse emissions
from poultry pro-
duction
Poultry production GHG mitigation
opportunities can be classified into
categories relating to poultry feed crop
production, bird housing heating and
manure management. Because the
largest proportion of GHG emissions
associated with poultry production

4 Area: Poultry Welfare and Environment • August 08


XXIV World´s Poultry Congress 5 - 9 August - 2012 • Salvador - Bahia - Brazil

efficiency exhaust fans and improved building Management.” Vol. Volume 4: Agriculture, Forestry,
insulation. The replacement of fossil fuels with and Other Land Use. 2006 IPCC Guidelines for
renewable fuels such as wind, solar, biomass, energy National Greenhouse Gas Inventories, Prepared by
crops, the combustion of poultry broiler litter, or the National Greenhouse Gas Inventories Programme.
EGGLESTON, H.S., BUENDIA, L., MIWA, K., NGARA,
other manures, and CH4 produced from manure,
T. & TANABE, K. (Eds.) Hayama: Institute for Global
can provide a direct reduction in GHG emissions. Environmental Strategies (IGES).
DUNKLEY, C. (2011) Global Warming: How Does it Relate
Mitigation of manure GHG emissions represents to Poultry?. UGA Cooperative Extension Bulletin,
the smallest opportunity to reduce emissions No1382. The University of Georgia Cooperative
compared to other contributing areas. Mitigation Extension Service.
options involve the selection of manure management METZ, B., DAVIDSON, O.R., BOSCH, P.R., DAVE, R.
options that reduce the formation of N2O. The and MEYER, L.A. (2007) Climate Change 2007:
production of N2O in manure management systems Contribution of Working Group III to the Fourth
requires anaerobic conditions. As such, maintaining Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on
aerobic conditions during manure storage by Climate Change, 2007: Working Group III: Mitigation
keeping manure dry and reducing manure storage of Climate Change. (Cambridge, United Kingdom and
time can help reduce N2O emissions. New York, NY, USA, Cambridge University Press).
PITESKY, M., STACKHOUSE, K.R. and MITLOEHNER, F.M.
(2009) Clearing the Air: Livestock’s Contribution to
Conclusions and Climate Change. Advances in Agronomy 103:1-40.
SONESSON, U., CEDERBERG, C. and BERGLUND, M.
recommendations (2009) Greenhouse Gas Emissions in Chicken
Production: Decision Support for Climate Certification.
Klimatrmarketing For Mat, pp. 1-19.
• Increased nitrogen efficiency during the
STEINFELD, H., GERBER, P., WASSENAAR, T., CASTEL, V.,
production of crops used as poultry feed
ROSALES, M. and HAAN, C. (2006) Livestock’s Long
offers the largest opportunity to reduce GHG
Shadow: Environmental Issues and Options. Rome:
emissions from the poultry production system. Food and Agriculture Organization, pp. 390.

Robert T. Burns
• Within the animal production and housing
VERGE, X.P.C, DYER, J.A., DESJARDINS, R.L. and WORTH,
phase of the poultry production system, a D. (2009) Long-term trends in greenhouse gas
reduction in fossil fuel consumption through emissions from the Canadian poultry industry. The
either conservation and or the replacement Journal of Applied Poultry Research 18:210-222.
of fossil fuels with renewable fuels provides WANG, S. and HUANG, D. (2005) Assessment of
an important opportunity to reduce GHG Greenhouse Gas Emissions from Poultry Enteric
emissions. Fermentation. Asian-Australian Journal of Animal
• Because meat poultry are gaining weight Science 18:873-878.
throughout the grow-out cycle it is more
appropriate to use emission factors for a per
bird produced basis than to use average bird
weight to estimate emissions.
• More holistic data collection that better
defines the system level GHG emissions from
complete poultry and egg production systems
is needed to build more comprehensive
poultry GHG emission inventories.
• Additional research is needed to better
identify practical and cost effective GHG
mitigation options for livestock production
systems.

References
DONG, H., MANGINO, J., MCALLISTER, T.A., HATFIELD,
J.L., JOHNSON, D.E., LASSEY, K.R., APARECIDA
DE LIMA, M. and ROMANOVSKAYA, A. (2006)
“Chapter 10: Emissions from Livestock and Manure

Area: Poultry Welfare and Environment • August 08


5

You might also like