Professional Documents
Culture Documents
LITERATURE REVIEW
INTRODUCTION
Itaconic acid is well known as a pioneer for polymer synthesis and has been
involved in industrial processes for decades but the discovery of itaconic acid has still
been a growing interest because of its potential role as a replacement for crude oil–based
products, such as acrylic acid. This chemical enables a self-polymerization to poly-itaconic
acid. Therefore, it is industrially used as a precursor for plastic polymer synthesis as well
as for resins, lattices, fibers, coatings, adhesives, thickeners and binders (Hiller et.al,
2015). In general, itaconic acid and its derivatives have wide applications in the textile,
chemical and pharmaceutical industries.
There are petroleum-based methods of itaconic acid production but the depletion
of fossil fuels and the need for sustainable development require fermentative itaconic acid
production to replace these. The increasing concern on sustainability, environmental
conservation and energy shortage drives the search for viable, renewable and
environmentally friendly alternatives to replace fossil resources as raw material in the
production of important chemicals. Plant biomass is the most feasible alternative as it is a
sustainable resource and does not liberate fossilized carbon.
Plant biomass is one of the major renewable raw material sources on earth and
the Philippines has a lot of it. It is composed of carbohydrates and aromatic polymers.
These carbohydrates (cellulose and hemicellulose) and aromatic polymers (lignin) are a
potential resource for the industrial production of value-added products and biofuel. One
under-utilized form of plant biomass is corncob.
In the Philippines, corn cobs are commonly utilized as fuel. However, even if many
people use it as fuel, there are still a lot of corn cobs and even the ash from the burnt cobs
piles up. Sadly, if not used as fuel, corn cob is disposed and destroyed by fire on the farms
to prepare for the next coming season. The dumping and burning of corn cobs on the
farms constitute gross air pollution.
13
Therefore, there is a big reason to think of ways how to utilize corn cob. Not only
itaconic acid can be produced from corn cobs. There are other value-added chemicals like
xylitol that can be produced. The current xylitol production globally involves the
employment of high temperatures (80-140°C) and pressures (up to 50 atm) with
expensive, toxic raney nickel catalyst for the hydrogenation of xylose which is a non-
economical and non-ecofriendly process. Hence, biotechnological production of xylitol
employing lignocelluloses as substrates would be an ideal substitute for the chemical
route. As mentioned, we can conclude that it is of great significance to counterpart this
increasing concern on sustainability, environmental conservation and energy shortage by
converting corn cobs into a potential resource.
Maicon, Inc. will pursue its idea to construct and optimize the utilization of the
whole lignocellulosic biomass (corn cobs) and not only the cellulose or the
hemicellulose fraction. This idea is called “bio-refining”, which means fractionation of the
biomass, and producing value added products from each fractions. The goal is obviously
to gain the highest profit, what means that the most valuable products should be produced
with the less financial outlay.
To be successful on our objective, only the ideal strategies that will overwhelm the
concerns of the existing technologies in the current industrial production of itaconic acid
and also of xylitol will be used. This is also to satisfy the increasing demand of these
chemicals for widespread applications.
RAW MATERIALS
Corn cobs
Due to corn's chemical composition, corn residues such as corn cobs show great
potential as a renewable raw material for producing a variety of added-value chemicals,
such as lactic acid, citric acid, sugars, ethanol and itaconic acid. As a lignocellulose
biomass, corncob has an energy content of about 18.5 MJ/kg, slightly higher than that of
corn stover (17 MJ/kg) and switchgrass (18 MJ/kg). However, it has an energy density of
14
about 5,000 MJ/m3, about two times that of corn stover and switchgrass; this gives it the
significant advantage for reducing transportation cost in industrial production for value-
added chemicals.
Lignocellulosic biomasses consist of three main components: cellulose,
hemicellulose and lignin, and some minor fractions, such as proteins, lipids, and ash.
Common lignocellulosic biomasses are: wood, grass, bagasses, waste paper, and the
stalks of cereals.
Table 2.1
Chemical properties of corncob
Characteristics Percentage (wt%)
Cellulose 36.43
Hemicellulose 41.96
Lignin 9.6
Moisture 12.01
15
Table 2.2
Volume of corn production by region, Philippines: 2017 (In metric ton)
Aspergillus Terreus
Aspergillus is one of the oldest named genera of fungi. By 1926, Aspergillus had
become one of the best-known and most studied mould groups. Their prevalence in the
natural environment, their ease of cultivation on laboratory media and the economic
importance of several of its species ensured that many mycologists and industrial
microbiologists were attracted to their study. Aspergilli grow abundantly as saprophytes
on decaying vegetation and have been found in large numbers in mouldy hay, organic
compost piles, leaf litter and the like. Most species are adapted for the degradation of
complex plant polymers, but they can also dine on substrates as diverse as dung, human
tissues, and antique parchment. There is even a report of an unidentified Aspergillus
species being capable of the solubilization of low rank coal (Machida, M., 2010).
16
A. terreus is known for its pronounced sensitivity with regard to the maintenance
of sufficiently aerobic conditions (Gyamerah, 1995; Kubicek et al., 1985; Kuenz et al.,
2012; Lockwood and Reeves, 1945).
Table 2.3
Comparison of different substrates
and fungal strains used for itaconic acid production
Microorganism Substrate IA titer (g L-1)
Aspergillus terreus Jatropha cake 48.7
A. terreus CECT 20365 Olive & beet waste 44
A. terreus Glucose 26.9
Glycerol 30.2
A. terreus DSM23081, NRRL Glucose 86.2
1960, NRRL 1963
A. terreus SKR10 Sago starch 48.2
A.terreus POME 5.76
A. terreus M-8 Starch hydrolysate 55
A. terreus Citric acid 1
A. terreus NRRL 1960 Various starches 18.4
A. terreus MTCC 479 Corn starch 10.3
Maize flour 6.5
Potato starch 5.8
A. terreus Sorghum bran 10
A.terreus Ast165 Corn starch 53.8
A. niger (genetically engineered) Glucose 2.5
Ustilago maydis Glucose 29
Source: Machida, 2010
Debaryomyces nepalensis
Debaryomyces nepalensis NCYC 3413, a halotolerant strain that has been
previously isolated from rotten apple, it can utilize both hexoses and pentoses; and is also
17
important in production of commercially valuable products such as arabitol, xylitol and
ethanol (Gummadi and Kumar 2006a; Kumar and Gummadi 2011; Kumdam et al. 2012).
Bioconversion of xylose to xylitol can be carried out by bacteria, fungi and yeast. Among
the reported microbial strains, Candida (Barbosa et al. 1988) and Debaryomyces (Converti
and Domı´nguez 2001; Converti et al. 2002) are the best-known yeast species for xylitol
production.
Sulfuric Acid
Sulfuric acid (alternative spelling sulphuric acid), also known as vitriol, is a mineral
acid composed of the elements sulfur, oxygen and hydrogen, with molecular formula
H2SO4. It is a colorless, odorless, and syrupy liquid that is soluble in water, in a reaction
that is highly exothermic.
Sodium Hydroxide
Liquid sodium hydroxide is colorless and has no odor. It can react violently with
strong acids and with water. Sodium hydroxide is used in many other industrial and
manufacturing processes. It is used to manufacture rayon, spandex, explosives, epoxy
resins, paints, glass and ceramics. It is also used in the textile industry to make dyes,
18
process cotton fabric and in laundering and bleaching, as well as in metal cleaning and
processing, oxide coating, electroplating and electrolytic extracting.
PRODUCTS
Itaconic Acid
19
free carboxyl groups that confer advantageous properties on the polymer. It can either be
self-polymerized or can act as a co-monomer with other monomers to form
heteropolymers.
In this study we will utilize the waste corn cobs to produce a bio-based itaconic
acid which involves the fermentation of the pretreated ground corn cobs with the aid of
Aspergillus terreus as an active fungus.
Table 2.4
Physical and chemical properties of itaconic acid
Property Name Property Value
Molecular formula C5H6O4
Physical state and appearance Solid (white crystals)
Molecular weight 130.1g/mole
Odor Odorless
Color White crystals
Boiling point 286 C
pH (5% water) 1.5-2.0
Melting point 167-169 C
Specific Gravity 1.573 (Water =1)
IUPAC name 2-methylidenebutanedioic acid
Solubility 76.8 mg/mL at 20 °C
Source: ScienceLab.com
In the study of Okabe, M., et.al., 2009, IA has been used in a wide range of
industries. During the 1950s, IA was used in industrial adhesives. Overall, during this
period, IA was used at an industrial scale, and large amounts of it were required. The alkali
salt or sulfonated form of poly IA is used as a detergent and in shampoos. The polymerized
20
methyl, ethyl, or vinyl esters of IA are used as plastics, adhesives, elastomers, and
coatings. In the textile industry, IA was employed in nonwoven fabric binders.
Currently, the most important application of itaconic acid in terms of market size is
the production of synthetic styrene-butadiene rubber (SBR) (Weastra, 2012). SBR is, for
instance, used in coated papers, where the addition of up to 5 % itaconic acid improves
the adhesive characteristics of the rubber (Warson and Finch, 2001; Willke and Vorlop,
2001). Furthermore, itaconic acid is applied as a lubricant and dye additive, a dispersant,
as well as for the production of chemical fibers (Weastra, 2012). Aside from the already
established areas, new, high-potential applications are of considerable importance as they
could significantly influence future growth of the itaconic acid market.
Possible bulk chemicals which could be replaced by IA, are acrylic acid, acetone
cyanohydrin, maleic anhydride, and sodium tripolyphosphate. Among other investigated
processes, itaconic acid is used as a platform chemical for the production of the fuel
compound 3-MTHF. In the envisioned fuel production process, lignocellulosic biomass is
subjected to mechanical, chemical, and enzymatic pretreatment yielding glucose, pentose
sugars such as xylose, and lignin.
Xylitol
Xylitol, a pentose alcohol has been used as a sugar substitute which has
anticariogenic, microbiostatic and insulin independent metabolic nature. The xylitol
molecule consists of five carbon atoms and five hydroxyl groups (Chen et al., 2010).
A recent study on rats confirmed its antidiabetic nature. It has been approved by
the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) as a safe food additive. The extremely low
Glycemic Index (GI) of 7 has made it a promising substituent for glucose which has GI of
100.
It has applications in sugar free gums, sugar free confectionaries, common foods
and drinks, dietetic products, oral hygiene, pharma and cosmetic products, as well as in
anti-cancer and anti-AIDS (betulin) products. As a medicine, xylitol is used to prevent
middle ear infections (otitis media) in young children, and as a sugar substitute for people
21
with diabetes. Xylitol is added to some chewing gums and other oral care products to
prevent tooth decay and dry mouth. It is sometimes included in tube feeding formulas as
a source of energy. Xylitol is added to water for use in nasal irrigation for people with sinus
problems.
The demand-supply ratio for xylitol has been constantly rising for the past few
years. But the ecofriendly exploitation of lignocelluloses for xylitol production is still a
persistent challenge in the field of white biotechnology.
Table 2.5
Physical and chemical properties of xylitol
Property Name Property Value
Molecular formula C5H12O5
IUPAC name (2R,3r,4S)-Pentane-1,2,3,4,5-pentol
Physical state and appearance Solid (powdered solid)
Molecular weight 152.15 g/mole
Odor Odorless
Taste Sweet
Color White
Boiling point 216 °C
Melting point 94 °C
Specific Gravity 1.52 (Water =1)
Solubility Easily soluble in cold water. Soluble in methanol
Source: Sciencelab.com
22
METHODS OF MANUFACTURING
OXIDATIVE MICROWAVE-ASSISTED
DELIGNIFICATION PRETREATMENT
PROCESS
23
making it a cost intensive method and difficult to scale up for industrial purposes. (Zhu,
et.at., 2010).
24
2. Chemical pre-treatment processes for lignocellulosic biomass
They are used to remove some of the components like lignin and hemicellulose
which form structural barrier to enzymatic accessibility of cellulose in the biomass.
2.1 Ozonolysis
Ozone treatment is one way of reducing the lignin content of lignocellulosic wastes.
This results in an increase of the in vitro digestibility of the treated material, and unlike
other chemical treatments, it does not produce toxic residues. Ozone can be used to
degrade lignin and hemicellulose in many lignocellulosic materials such as wheat straw,65
bagasse, green hay, peanut, pine,66 cotton straw,67 and poplar sawdust.68 The
degradation is mainly limited to lignin. Hemicellulose is slightly affected, but cellulose is
not.
A drawback of ozonolysis is that a large amount of ozone is required, which can
make the process expensive.
25
2.3. Alkaline Hydrolysis
Some bases can be used for the pretreatment of lignocellulosic materials, and the
effect of alkaline pretreatment depends on the lignin content of the materials. Alkali
pretreatment processes utilize lower temperatures and pressures than other pretreatment
technologies. Alkali pretreatment can be carried out at ambient conditions, but
pretreatment times are on the order of hours or days rather than minutes or seconds.
Compared with acid processes, alkaline processes cause less sugar degradation, and
many of the caustic salts can be recovered and/or regenerated. Sodium, potassium,
calcium, and ammonium hydroxides are suitable alkaline pretreatment agents. Of these
four, sodium hydroxide has been studied the most.
26
The total sugars are the sum of the reducing and non-reducing sugars including
several types of saccharides: monosaccharides (i.e. glucose and fructose), disaccharides
(i.e. sucrose and cellobiose), and trisaccharides (i.e. maltotriose). The pretreatment
results gave lower yields of glucose but higher yields of total sugars. The high yield of total
sugars showed that the pretreated corncob (pre-hydrolysate) was high in di- and tri- (or
bigger) saccharides which can be converted to smaller sugars or glucose by
acid/enzymatic hydrolysis. Alternatively, the amounts of glucose, total sugars, and
cellulose suggest that the pretreated corncob would be appropriate as the substrates in a
simultaneous saccharification and fermentation process for ethanol production During
pretreatment under alkaline conditions, the lignin was removed from the lignocellulose,
the crystalline structure of the cellulose was disrupted, the porosity of the lignocellulose
increased.
CHEMICAL
SYNTHESIS
FUNGAL STRAINS
BIOSYNTHESIS AND INOCULUM CULTIVATION FERMENTATION
PREPARATION
1. Chemical Process
The first method of producing IA was by pyrolysing citric acid and hydrolysing the
anhydrides (Baup 1837). Another early method, discovered by Crasso, was the
27
decarboxylation of aconitic acid. Chemical synthesis is mainly performed by dry distillation
of citric acid and subsequent treatment of the anhydride with water (Blatt 1943), or using
the method of Montecatini (Italy), from propargyl chloride, carbon monoxide, nickel
carbonyl and water (Chiusoli 1962). Alternative approaches are the oxidation of mesityl
oxide and subsequent isomerisation of the formed citric acid (Berg and Hetzel 1978), or
the oxidation of isoprene (Pichler et al. 1967). But none of these processes can really
compete with fermentation by fungi and therefore none are practised commercially (Tate
1981). The main drawback of chemical synthesis is that it depends on substrates within
the same price range as IA, and a requirement for a high reaction temperature, which
makes the process more cost-intensive. Moreover, the multistep chemical synthesis of IA
has proved to be uneconomical because of high substrate cost and/or relatively low yields
and it cannot compete with fermentation process.
Itaconic acid was historically produced by various chemical methods such as
destructive distillation of citric acid, and this was the main method of producing it prior to
the 1960s; heating the calcium aconitate solution produced in the cane sugar refining
process; the patented Montecatini method involving propargyl chloride; the oxidation of
mesityl oxide and subsequent isomerization of the formed citric acid; and the oxidation of
isoprene. Maleic anhydride is also used in the production of IA, but the process has not
yet achieved industrialization. None of these processes compete favorably with the
fermentative production process, and IA is now almost entirely produced by fermentation
of sugars by Aspergillus terreus. (El-Imam AA, Du C,2014). Itaconic acid is primarily used
as a co-monomer in the production of acrylonitrile butadiene styrene and acrylate latexes
with applications in the paper and architectural coating industry.
2. Biotechnological Production
Itaconic acid biosynthesis in A. terreus is achieved via the central metabolism, i.e.
the Embden-Meyerhof-Parnas (EMP) pathway, pyruvate (de)carboxylation, and the
tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle. Thus, first of all glucose is converted to two pyruvate
molecules, which yield acetyl-CoA and oxaloacetate by decarboxylation and
carboxylation, respectively. Within the TCA cycle, these compounds are then transformed
28
to citrate, which is further converted to cis-aconitate, the precursor of itaconic acid. Cis-
aconitate is transported from the mitochondria to the cytosol, where it is decarboxylated
to itaconic acid via the cis-aconitate decarboxylase (CAD) (Li et al., 2011a).
Since A. terreus is known for its pronounced sensitivity with regard to the
maintenance of sufficiently aerobic conditions, phases of insufficient oxygen supply can
thus stop product formation entirely, even if they last only several minutes. Upon
restoration of aerobic conditions, itaconic acid biosynthesis is then slowly resumed within
a time frame of several days indicating an involvement of protein synthesis. A possible
explanation for this sensitivity can be found in the export mechanism for itaconic acid. As
it requires ATP, it directly depends on oxidative phosphorylation. Hence, insufficient
oxygen supply could result in a reduced level of ATP, which hinders the export of itaconic
acid from the intracellular space (Gyamerah, 1995). In addition to oxygen supply, the pH
during the cultivation has a decisive role in itaconic acid production. Commonly, the pH
decreases from its initial value of 3.1 to approximately 2 due to the consumption of
ammonium (Hevekerl et al., 2014b; Rychtera and Wase, 1981).
Subsequently, the pH could, however, be increased to higher values without any
negative effects on itaconic acid formation. This strategy was implemented in a process
by the Pfizer company. Recently, Hevekerl et al. (2014b) furthermore combined this pH
29
shift with an optimized medium and a supply with additional glucose. This led to a process
with a productivity of 1.15 g L-1 h-1 and a final itaconic acid concentration of 129 g L-1. At
the expense of productivity, a maximum final product titer of 146 g L-1 was achieved,
which represents the current maximum in the scientific literature.
30
C. Utilization of Hemicellulose Hydrolyzates of Corn Cobs
31
were moderate compared to other strains (Candida strains) with non-detoxified
hydrolysates, the strain has shown high tolerance. The salt tolerance up to 2 M NaCl, 3 M
KCl and 1 M LiCl is the remarkable property of this strain, maintained by the accumulation
of glycerol, sorbitol and other polyols under hyperosmotic conditions. It could also grow in
a broad range of pH (3- 11) and temperature (8-42°C).
32
from major drawbacks in terms of requirement of specialized and expensive equipments,
extensive intermediate purification steps, product recovery, catalyst deactivation and
recycling (complicated due to homogeneity of solution) with huge energy requirements to
make the overall process very expensive.
2. Biotechnological Production
Alternative cost effective production strategies through biotechnology route have
been envisaged by the scientific fraternities for decades and attentions were given towards
cheap source of xylose and its biocatalytic conversion into xylitol under ambient
conditions. This is a potentially attractive replacement for chemical process, as it occurs
under much milder process conditions and can be based on sugar mixtures derived from
low-cost industrial and agri-waste.
33
Figure 2.9. Comparison between catalytic hydrogenation and biotechnical
production for xylitol production
CHOICE OF PROCESS
34
Air Lift Reactors for Fermentation
Utilization of air lift reactors were expected to lower production cost. As mentioned
in the literature, ALR provided higher production rates with less power input per volume
compared to STR. This would provide a significant difference in the whole production and
an advantage over other existing reactors which uses large amount of energy.
35
reactions showing its efficiency (Kappe, 2008). Microwave heating also decrease the
consumption of chemicals and reduce the reaction time (Yoshida et al., 2010).
36
are prepared separately as stock solutions. The pH value is adjusted to 3.1 with 1 M
H2SO4, except the CaCl2 solution. The temperature is maintained at 33 °C with circulating
tempered water, and the broth is stirred (hanging magnetic stirrer). The initial pH value is
adjusted to 3.1 and not corrected during the cultivation.
Basis on Purification of IA
The process for the industrial production of IA from the culture broth consists of
five steps. The culture broth is filtered to remove mycelia and other suspended solids. The
filtrate of the IA culture is concentrated to 98% at 30-40C and crystallized at 15°C. The
crystallized IA is washed, dried and packaged. The IA recovery yield is 95% in the filtration
process, 98% in the concentration process, and 99% in the crystallization and drying
processes. The total IA recovery yield from cultivation to final packaging is approximately
80%. IA purified from glucose had a purity of 99.0% (Okabe, et al., 2009).
37
mg/l; MnSO4·H2O, 3.4 mg/l; ZnSO4·7H2O, 8.9 mg/l; CuSO4·5H2O, 0.25 mg/l; citric acid,
6.9 mg/l, pH, 7.0 was adjusted using H3PO4 and NaOH. Among these, the parameters are
xylose, K2HPO4, ZnSO4·7H2O. The values are optimal from Kumdal et al., 2012. All the
components are autoclaved separately and mixed subsequently. Then, it is inoculated
with 2-10% (v/v) of inoculum and incubated at 33°C.
38
Basis on Purification of Xylitol
A process of purification of Xylitol obtained by fermentation of corn hydrolysates
was adapted from Torre, et al., 2016. After biomass removal, the media were subjected
to further processing (sequential stages of adsorption, concentration, precipitation,
concentration, and crystallization) to obtain food-grade xylitol. Liquors from the adsorption
step were concentrated by vacuum evaporation at 30-40 °C to reach a xylitol concentration
of .6968 g xylitol/ g NVC. The preferred crystallization conditions corresponded to a
temperature of 15 °C. This gives .7181g xylitol crystals/gNVC. Crystallization led to
regularly shaped, well-formed, homogeneous crystals containing 98.9 wt % of xylitol,
exceeding the purity threshold required for food applications.
39