Professional Documents
Culture Documents
82
Indian Journal of Economics and Development (2018) 14(3), 473-480 www.naasindia.org
Received: June 29, 2017 Manuscript Number: MS-17101 Revision Accepted: July 10, 2018
ABSTRACT
India' agricultural trade with SAARC member countries was not very impressive as a percentage of its world agricultural trade. The
agricultural exports from India to other SAARC countries increased from $1553.61 million in 2005-06 to $5475.26 million in 2014-
Downloaded From IP - 59.144.9.6 on dated 27-Apr-2019
15. A similar increase occurred in agricultural imports of India from $634.74 million to $1266.88 million. India's agricultural
exports to other SAARC countries were higher as compared to imports, thus the balance of trade was favourable to India except for
Members Copy, Not for Commercial Sale
Afghanistan (2006-15) and Bhutan (2007 and 2008). The compound growth rate of agricultural exports of India with SAARC as a
www.IndianJournals.com
whole came out to be 14.26 per cent per annum at current prices and 7.84 per cent at constant prices which indicated a tremendous
increase in agricultural exports to these countries after SAFTA agreement. The agricultural growth in imports at constant prices
was negative and non-significant for all SAARC member countries with India except for Afghanistan and Bangladesh which were
the major importing countries with respect to agricultural trade. After SAFTA agreement in 2006, no doubt, trade increased in the
SAARC region, but lack of proper implementation was observed among SAARC countries. The study suggested that as India's total
agricultural trade multiplied more than three-times after the formation of SAFTA in the region, it should play a key role in the
implementation of SAFTA.
Keywords
Agricultural trade liberalization, growth rate, regional economic cooperation.
JEL Codes
F13, O13, Q17.
473
Indian J Econ Dev 14(3): 2018 (July-September)
SAARC would benefit from regionalism if its Table 1. India' agricultural trade with SAARC region
cooperation would extend beyond formal trade (Metha & and world, 2006-2015
Kumar, 2004). Regional cooperation and integration will (US $million)
allow the SAARC states to benefit from international Year SAARC World
investment, technology and trading opportunities (Kher,
Export Import Export Import
2012).
India's trade with the individual SAARC country is 2006 1553.61 634.74 11257.5 7066.8
mostly governed by bilateral agreements made between (13.80) (8.98)
India and individual SAARC country from time to time to 2007 2098.51 649.50 16707.7 8092.4
promote mutual trade. India's trade with Nepal though (12.56) (8.03)
exhibited moderate progress until 2002-03, it gained 2008 3374.39 790.02 17306.9 9140.5
momentum thereafter. While exports registered a (19.50) (8.64)
staggering growth of 27 per cent per annum, imports grew 2009 2327.19 573.40 15660.7 12819.6
at no less significant level of about 17 percent per annum. (14.86) (4.47)
Expect in one year, the share of India's trade with Nepal as 2010 2215.67 631.71 19974.6 10663.8
a proportion of India's total exports and imports were less (11.09) (5.92)
than one percent. The growth of both exports and imports 2011 3783.17 789.92 30291.3 17258.6
were statistically significant (Maheswararao, 2015). (12.49) (4.58)
However, SAFTA is an initial step in the evolution of 2012 3901.60 904.91 38165.8 20184.8
the SAARC as a regional trade bloc and an economic (10.22) (4.48)
union. There is much debate about its favourable effect on 2013 4865.35 1003.71 42489.5 19216.1
intra-regional trade. Keeping this in mind, this study (11.45) (5.22)
Downloaded From IP - 59.144.9.6 on dated 27-Apr-2019
474
Naseri and Sidana: India's agricultural trade relationship with SAARC countries
Afghanistan significantly increased to $101.54 million in country's main endowments included its vast human
2011-12 due to increased export of cereals and tobacco. In resource base, rich agricultural land, relatively abundant
the case of agricultural imports except in the terminal year water, and substantial reserves of natural gas, which were
there was near fluctuation up to 2012-13, imports after items of exchange among the SAARC countries. The
2012-13, continuously increased. For instance, India's share of Bangladesh's agricultural trade in its total trade
agricultural imports from Afghanistan doubled from with India increased from 11.8 per cent in 1989 to 30.8 per
$130.04 million in 2011-12 to $260.65 million in 2014- cent in 2010. Foodgrains accounted for the overwhelming
15. India's exports to Afghanistan as a proportion of her share in the agricultural trade between these two
total agricultural exports to SAARC region were less than countries. About one-third of total exports from India to
3.8 percent. The share of India's agricultural imports from Bangladesh were of agricultural, fishery and livestock
Afghanistan in total SAARC import increased from 9.0 to products (WTO, 2006). The perusal of Table 3 showed
20.6 percent during the period under study. The trade that over the period of ten years India's agricultural export
balance with Afghanistan was unfavourable to India, as to Bangladesh increased from $804.94 million in 2005-06
imports exceeded exports. to $2952.87 million in 2014-15. The results further
India's Bilateral Agricultural Trade with Bangladesh revealed that among SAARC countries Bangladesh had
Being one of the world's poorest and most densely the highest share in India's agricultural export to SAARC
populated countries, Bangladesh has stepped up its efforts comprising of 51.8 and 53.9 per cent agricultural export
to meet the food needs of its increasing population, by of SAARC region respectively. India's import of
augmenting domestic production. Bangladesh's industrial agricultural commodities from Bangladesh was $54.6
base was weak with limited reserves of coal and oil. The million in 2005-06, it increased to 314.44 US $million in
Downloaded From IP - 59.144.9.6 on dated 27-Apr-2019
(US $million)
www.IndianJournals.com
475
Indian J Econ Dev 14(3): 2018 (July-September)
2011-12 and, it reached $279.59 million in 2014-15. The same period. The balance of trade was positive for the
share of agricultural import from Bangladesh in the total period under study except for 2006-07 and 2007-08;
agricultural import of SAARC region ranged from 8.6 to India's agricultural imports were higher than her exports
34.7 percent. On the whole, India's total agricultural trade to Bhutan which was unfavourable for India. During the
with Bangladesh increased from $859.54 million in 2005- study period, the proportion of India's agricultural exports
06 to $3232.46 million in 2014-15, depicting a favourable to Bhutan viz-a-viz SAARC region varied between 0.3 to
balance of trade. Thus, exports exceeded imports as far as 1.2 percent. The share of India's agricultural import from
bilateral trade between India and Bangladesh is Bhutan in the total agricultural import of SAARC region
concerned during the years under study. ranged from 0.6 to 6.6 percent during the study period. In
India's Bilateral Agricultural Trade with Bhutan the year 2014-15, India's agricultural imports from
The mutually beneficial economic relationship Bhutan constituted only 0.8 percent of India's total
between India and Bhutan are an important element in imports from SAARC. India's total agricultural trade with
bilateral trade. India continues to be the largest trade and Bhutan increased from $33.41 million in 2005-06 to
development partner of Bhutan. The first contract on trade $61.57 million in 2014-15. The export figure reaching at
and commerce between Bhutan and India was signed in the peak to $51.73 million in 2014-15 and the highest
1972. Since then, the contract was renewed four times. import was recorded in 2006-07 and 2007-08. The animal
The final contract was renewed on July 28, 2006, and was and vegetable fats were the major import items for two
valid till July 29, 2016. India, Pakistan, Sri Lanka and consecutive years making the unfavourable balance of
Bangladesh exported 9.3, 10.0, 8.1 and 12.5 per cent, trade for India. Similarly, dairy products and bird's eggs,
respectively of their agricultural exports within SAARC, wood and wooden articles were the major export items in
and the remaining (close to 90 percent) was exported to 2014-15 leading to a huge jump in export.
outside region by these countries. Afghanistan and India's Bilateral Agricultural Trade with the Maldives
Downloaded From IP - 59.144.9.6 on dated 27-Apr-2019
Bhutan were the minor players, trade maximum within India's significant trade partner is the Maldives,
the region. The overall share of intra-SAARC trade in bilateral trade agreement signed on March 31, 1981. The
Members Copy, Not for Commercial Sale
total trade is 4.29 per cent which ranged from as low as perusal of Table 5 showed that agricultural trade
www.IndianJournals.com
2.15 per cent in India too as high as 79.81 per cent in performance between India-Maldives was favourable
Bhutan. Intra-SAARC agricultural trade ranged from 7 since exports exceeded imports. India's agricultural
per cent in India to 95 per cent in Bhutan (Saxena, Paul, export to the Maldives was $14.91 million in 2005-06; the
Rana, Chaurajia, Palk & Joshi, 2015). Table 4 agricultural export marginally increased to $44.03
incorporated absolute values of India's agricultural million in 2011-12 and it further increased to $53.79
exports to and imports from Bhutan along with the million in 2014-15. The share of agricultural export to the
percentage of shares in relation to India's total agricultural Maldives in the total agricultural export of SAARC
exports and imports to the SAARC region. The perusal of ranged from 0.8 to 1.4 per cent during the study period.
Table 4 revealed that India's agricultural exports to India's agricultural import from the Maldives was
Bhutan soared from $18.64 million to $51.73 million insignificant. India's balance of trade with the Maldives
registering almost three-fold increase during the study was favourable throughout the study period.
period. India's agricultural imports from Bhutan India's Bilateral Agricultural Trade with Nepal
decreased from $14.77 million to $9.84 million in the The economic relationship between Nepal and India
476
Naseri and Sidana: India's agricultural trade relationship with SAARC countries
is unique. India is the largest trading partner of Nepal with has increased more than four-fold, whereas agricultural
whom Nepal conducts almost 2/3rd of its trade. In South imports ( in value terms) increased nearly twice from
Asia after Bhutan, Nepal has the second highest degree of $127.19 million in 2006 to $235.55 million in 2015. The
trade intensity with India. Therefore, the trade and other share of agricultural export to Nepal in the total
related relationship between Nepal and India have its own agricultural export of SAARC ranged from 7.1 to 14 per
significance. On the other hand, it is worth mentioning cent; whereas the share of import from Nepal, viz-a-viz
that the economic cooperation between Nepal and India is SAARC is 20 per cent. The trade balance with Nepal was
based on the mobility of goods and services across the favourable to India, as exports exceeded imports.
Nepal-India border of about 1,600 km. A major contract India's Bilateral Agricultural Trade with Pakistan
agreement of trade and cooperation was signed between The trade relations between India and Pakistan, the
the two governments on October 27, 2009, at Kathmandu two neighbouring countries remained suspended for nine
in Nepal. The agreement aimed at improving bilateral years and affected trade between both the countries. Trade
trade between the two countries by agreeing to the between India and Pakistan slowed down over the past 50
mutually agreed points of trade. More than 43 percent of years due to three main reasons such as political tensions,
the total agricultural import of Nepal came from India. the import-policies to encourage industrialization and in
The share of India in Nepal's total export of agricultural comparison to other regions of the world and relatively
commodities increased from 21 percent in TE 1995 to little commitment to regional integration (Naqvi, Schuler
about 56 percent in TE 2011 (Pandey, Punet, Santosh & & Richter, 2007). India's agricultural exports to Pakistan
Rakesh, 2014). The perusal of Table 6 revealed that showed a much better performance than agricultural
during last ten years India's agricultural export to Nepal exports from Pakistan to India (Das, 2016). Agricultural
Downloaded From IP - 59.144.9.6 on dated 27-Apr-2019
477
Indian J Econ Dev 14(3): 2018 (July-September)
export was the main source of growth for Indian economic cooperation. Over the last ten years, India's
agriculture in the 1990s, which was facilitated by trade agricultural export to Sri Lanka increased from $284.25
liberalization policies and the devaluation of Indian million in 2005-06 to $924.02 million in 2014-15. The
Rupee (Misra & Rao, 2003). The perusal of Table 7 share of agricultural export to Sri Lanka in the total
revealed that India had favourable trade with Pakistan agricultural export of SAARC ranged from 10.9 to 22.5
where exports were more than imports. Though India's per cent whereas the share of agricultural import varied
agricultural export and import have increased in value between 18.1 and 38.9 per cent. Agricultural import from
terms with Pakistan over last ten years, the increase was Sri Lanka was $243.56 million in 2005-06 and, it increased
not significant. It was only due to inflation or a rise in to $279.93 million in 2014-15. Since export and import of
prices that there was an increase in current exports and India increased during the period, therefore, India's total
imports. The share of agricultural export to Pakistan in the agricultural trade with Sri Lanka increased from $527.81
total agricultural export of SAARC ranged from 12.4 to million in 2005-06 to $1203.95 million in 2014-15. It was
34.4 per cent, whereas on import side it varied from 15.3 observed that the exports in respect of Sri Lanka surpassed
to 23.4 per cent. Total India's agricultural trade with the imports throughout the study period stretching from
Pakistan increased from $350.96 million in 2005-06 to 2005-06 to 2014-15, displaying a favourable balance of
$880.88 million in 2014-15. trade (Table 8).
India's Bilateral Agricultural Trade with Sri Lanka Analysis of Growth in Trade of Agricultural
Bilateral relations between Sri Lanka and India were Commodities
friendly but affected by the Sri Lankan civil war and failure The compound growth rate of agricultural exports and
of Indian intervention during the Sri Lankan civil war. imports of India with other SAARC countries for a period
India is Sri Lanka's only neighbour, separated by the Palk of ten years (2006 to 2015) presented in Table 9. The
Strait; both nations occupy a strategic position in South results showed that growth rate of agricultural exports of
Downloaded From IP - 59.144.9.6 on dated 27-Apr-2019
Asia and have sought to build a common security umbrella India at current prices with Bhutan and Nepal came out to
in the Indian Ocean. India was the first country to respond be around 16 per cent per annum; indicating a tremendous
Members Copy, Not for Commercial Sale
to Sri Lanka's request for assistance after the tsunami in increase in agricultural exports to these countries after
www.IndianJournals.com
December 2004. India and Sri Lanka experienced welfare SAFTA agreement. Due to hostile relations with Pakistan,
attained from the FTA. Moreover, it was evident that the the growth rate of agricultural exports was not significant.
India and Sri Lanka full trade liberalization scenario The growth rate of agricultural import, was less than the
secured higher welfare for both the countries than the India growth rate of agricultural export; indicating more growth
and Sri Lanka FTA with negative lists (Perara, 2008). Sri in export than import with SAARC nations. The growth
Lanka was traditionally a major export market for India. rate was negative with Bhutan, Sri Lanka and Pakistan. If
India-Sri Lanka Free Trade Agreement (ISFTA) was we deflate the current data of agricultural export with
signed on December 28, 1998. This agreement is in wholesale price index (all commodities, Base year 2004-
operation since March 01, 2000. Under this agreement, 05=100) then even at constant prices, agricultural exports
both nations agreed to phase out trade tariffs from each increased in the range of 2 to 9 percent per annum. The
other within a fixed time frame except for those items in agricultural export at constant prices showed a significant
the negative list of each other. They agreed to take forward trend with Bangladesh, Maldives and Nepal whereas
the process of signing a comprehensive agreement for import with Afghanistan and Bangladesh.
478
Naseri and Sidana: India's agricultural trade relationship with SAARC countries
Table 9. Compound growth rate of agricultural trade of India with SAARC countries, 2006 - 2015
Country CGR of export CGR of export CGR of import CGR of import
(Current prices) (Constant prices) (Current prices) (Constant prices)
Afghanistan 8.12NS 1.29NS 18.66** 11.19**
Downloaded From IP - 59.144.9.6 on dated 27-Apr-2019
479
Indian J Econ Dev 14(3): 2018 (July-September)
Library/ecidc2013miscl 1_pb5.pdf. Pandey, D., Punet, K.A., Santosh, K., & Rakesh, S. (2014).
Maheswararao, K. (2015). Growth of India's trade with Indo-Nepal trade relations in agricultural commodities.
individual SAARC countries. International Journal of Economic Affairs, 59(185), 711-725.
Academic Research, 2(1), 102-110. Perara, M.S.S. (2008). Impact of the Indo-Sri Lanka free trade
Metha, S.P., & Kumar, P. (2004). RTAs in South Asia: Option in agreement on the Sri Lank economy. South Asia Economic
the wake of Cancun Fiasco ASARC. Working Paper 2004- Journal, 9(1), 1-50.
11 Canberra: Australian National University. Saxena, R., Paul, R.K., Rana, S., Chaurajia, S., Palk, Z., & Joshi,
Misra, V.N., & Rao, M.G. (2003). Trade policy agricultural D. (2015). Agricultural trade structure and linkage and
growth and rural poor: Indian experience. Economic and SAARC: An empirical investigation. Agricultural
Political Weekly, 38(43), 4588-4603. Economics Research Review, 28(2), 311-328.
Naqvi, Z.F., Schuler, P., & Richter, K. (2007). Pakistan-India WTO. (2006). Trade policy review Bangladesh. WTO
trade: Overview and key issues in the challenges and document WT/TPR/S/168/Rev.1. Geneva: WTO.
potential of Pakistan–India trade. World Bank Report. Retrieved from https://www.wto.org/english/tratop_e/t
Washington, DC : World Bank. pr_e/tp269_e.htm
Downloaded From IP - 59.144.9.6 on dated 27-Apr-2019
Members Copy, Not for Commercial Sale
www.IndianJournals.com
480