Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Portfolio Artifact #2
Madison Evans
Edu 210
9/10/18
2
Freddie Watts and Jimmy Brothers are the principal and vice principal of a school. They
are both African American and work in a high school with the majority of students being black.
During an argument with Watts and Brothers, Ann Griffin, a white teacher, said that she “hated
all black folks”. The administration and her colleagues were upset about her statement. Watts
suggested to fire her, as he is afraid she will act this way towards her students. The Texas v.
Johnson case (1989) and the Tinker v Des Moines School District (1969) case support Griffin’s
side that she should not be dismissed. The Heart of Atlanta Motel, Inc. v. United States (1964)
case and the Givhan v. Western Line Consolidated School District (1979) case support the
In the Texas v. Johnson case (1989), Gregory Lee Johnson burned an American flag in
protest. The public was outraged, but the Supreme Court ruled even speech that is offensive is
protected by the first amendment, even if the public is outraged (United States Courts). Griffin’s
statement that she “hated all black folks” is offensive speech, but this case gives her protection
In the Tinker v Des Moines School District (1969) case, students were protesting the
Vietnam War by wearing black arm bands to school. The principal told the students that they
would be suspended for wearing them, but the students wore them anyway. After being
suspended, the parents decided to sue the school. The Supreme Court ruled that first amendment
right applies to teachers and students, as long as they are not disruptive or infringe on the rights
of others (United States Courts). Griffin’s statement was not disruptive nor did it harm anyone
In the Heart of Atlanta Motel, Inc. v. United States (1964) case, the owner of a hotel
refused to rent rooms to people who were not white. He claimed that he was allowed to do this,
3
and Congress was over stepping their privileges by saying that this violated the Civil Rights Act
of 1964. The court decided that discrimination in public accommodations is prohibited (Cornell
Law School). Griffin’s statement raised concerns that she would not treat students fairly because
of their race. This discrimination would not be allowed in this setting because schools are a
public accommodation.
In the Givhan v. Western Line Consolidated School District (1979) case, a teacher was
dismissed due to her racist statements. The teacher claimed that the first amendment gave her the
right to say these things and that she should get her job back. The court decided that public
employees have the right to free speech. However, the Court of Appeals deemed that one is not
entitled to constitutional protection if the speech is not public (Justia US Supreme Court). In the
teacher’s case, her statements were made in private. Ann Griffin’s statements were also made in
private. She was in an office with two other people, and her complaint was expressed privately,
The court will likely rule on the principal’s side. There is substantial reason to believe
that Ann Griffin would discriminate against her students. Since discrimination is not allowed in
public accommodations, this would be prohibited (Cornell Law School). It would also have a
negative impact on the students’ education and wellbeing. Also, since her statement was
expressed in private, it is not protected by the first amendment (Justia US Supreme Court). It is a
teacher’s responsibility to treat all students equally. It would not be fair for a student to be treated
differently than the rest because of their skin color. Teachers should work to reach every student;
it seems that Griffin might not be capable of this. Although her statement was said during a
heated argument, what she said is most likely how she sees all black people, even her students. It
4
would not be worth the risk of having a biased teacher when someone else can take her place that
References
Cornell Law School. (n.d.). Heart of Atlanta Motel, Inc. v. United States. Retrieved September 8,
Justia US Supreme Court. (n.d.). Givhan v. Western Line Cons. Sch. Dist., 439 U.S. 410 (1979).
United States Courts. (n.d.). Facts and Case Summary - Texas v. Johnson. Retrieved September
and-case-summary-texas-v-johnson
United States Courts. (n.d.). Tinker v. Des Moines Podcast. Retrieved September 8, 2018, from
http://www.uscourts.gov/about-federal-courts/educational-resources/supreme-court-
landmarks/tinker-v-des-moines-podcast