You are on page 1of 30

The Postgraduate Arts &

Humanities Centre (PAHC)


04

What is the purpose of the


Symposium
08

Programme
10

Abstracts of Papers
14

Presenter Biographies
52

1 2
The The Postgraduate Arts and Humanities Centre as
a community of practice

PAHC is far more than a physical or administrative space

Postgraduate
for PhD students, it is a vision of a community of practice.
According to Lane and Wenger (2000) a community of
practice is constituted in a ‘group of people who share a
concern or a passion for something they do and learn how
to do it better as they interact regularly’. But a community

Arts &
of practice is not just a group of people that happen to have
a common interest. They are a group of practitioners:
active participants in the practices of social communities,
and in the construction of, in this case, a researcher’s
identity, through these communities.

Humanities Our vision then is of PAHC as a re-imagination of


postgraduate culture which transcends disciplinary
boundaries not just through the research culture already
evident in the faculty, but via PhDs where an inter-

Centre
disciplinary mindset is a natural port of call.

The traditional view of a PhD is of the lone scholar


burrowing away in their ivory tower. But why can’t a PhD
be more than that? Why can’t PAHC coalesce around a
PhD culture that is about utilising the communal passion
of postgraduate researchers? Why can’t we think more
broadly of the PhD as having potential benefit to the local,
regional, national and international communities with
which our faculty already engages so effectively?

3 4
PAHC then is about seeing postgraduate research as being Being the Head of PAHC is, no doubt, the best job in the
the shining light of our faculty’s underpinning philosophy: a known the universe…! I get to work with highly motivated
philosophy that is in turn outward-facing and which has a researchers and with a PAHC team passionate about
renewed focus on the public and the professional and on helping those students through the ups and downs, whilst
actually making a difference to the worlds of work, culture reminding them that their unique experience of the PhD is
and society: of a community working within a community for one that many others are actually going through.
the common good.
Doing a PhD is a unique challenge. But we can all learn
Doing a PhD is not simply about the marathon challenge of from each other. PAHC is here to remind us all that this is
completing a perfectly rounded project. It’s a professional the case. Have a brilliant symposium!
training. At the centre of this lies PAHC’s Research Training
Programme which is designed to provide a comprehensive
range of training opportunities. But professional training is
about more than just attending training workshops, it’s about
understanding what it means to be part of a non-hierarchical
research culture. It’s about being a pro-active and collegiate
part of that research culture and PAHC aims to provide the
foundations upon which this becomes possible.

This is a process that you could usefully compare to the


completion of a PhD itself. What makes a good PhD is above
all a convincing narrative. A PhD doesn’t need to transform Steve Miles, Head of PAHC
the world; it just needs to present for examination a world
that the student, through their passion and determination,
has indisputably defined: a carefully sculpted world in which
there remains no doubt as to what the student has sought to
achieve, how and why.

PAHC is in the process of defining its own narrative and the


Annual PAHC symposium is at the very heart of that.
Organised by students for students the symposium
showcase’s the outstanding work that our PhD students are
engaged in. This year’s symposium is all about sharing and
learning from the challenges that all PhD students face and in
this sums up what PAHC and our 5 students are all about. 6
The Annual Arts & Humanities Research Student
Symposium is an opportunity for research students across

What
the Faculty of Arts & Humanities, to meet and discuss their
research with other research students, and to receive
comment and feedback on their research from more
experienced researchers.

is the
The Symposium has been designed to be supportive, but
critical. The abstract submission and review process is
straightforward, and offers constructive feedback, and the
atmosphere at the Symposium is collegial and supportive,
whilst challenging all participants to improve and advance

purpose
their research.

of the
Symposium?
5th Annual Symposium, 2017
7 8
Program
09:00 Registration Angeliki Andrikopoulou
Academic libraries and Research Data
Management
09:15 Welcome
Sarah Walker
Nikolai Duffy
Challenges for the Interdisciplinary Researcher
Deputy Head of PAHC

09:45 Panel 01 11:10 Refreshments


Chair, Craig Carey
Postgraduate Research Student 11:30 Panel 03
Chair, Nahla Raffaoui
Freya Ernsting Student Organising Committee
Getting to grip(e)s with Grounded
Theory Method: The constant comparison within
Dounia Ouided Hachelef
the research journey
The New Witch: A contemporary interpretation of
Nahla Raffaoui female power between reality and fiction
The Challenge of Using Intersectionality as a
Catherine Elkin
Research Methodology
'Mother was Making Angels': The Challenge of
Discussing Infanticide
10:45 Panel 02: Poster Presentations
Magdalena Marchowska-Raza
12:30 Lunch
My road to shaping the subject of my research
9 10
13:30 Panel 04
Chair, Freya Ernsting
Student Organising Committee

Rodica Arpasanu
An emotional journey: the risk and changes
associated with undertaking sensitive research
on mortality mediation in dark tourism
Latifa Alharbi
Effects of Social Media Use in Teaching English:
An investigation of Instagram adoption in teaching
English as a second language

14:30 Panel 05
Chair, Halima Benzdira
Student Organising Committee

Antony Hall
Experiments in art and perceptual illusion:
Exploring methods used in experimental
psychology within a framework of artistic practice
Andrew Forster
Paths in the Wilderness: The Challenges of Nature
Poetry as Creative/Critical Research

15:30 Refreshments

16:00 Prizes and close of symposium

11 12
Getting to grip(e)s with Grounded Theory
Method: The constant comparison within
the research journey

Freya Ernsting
Languages, Information and Communications

As an early stage researcher, declaring the use of


Grounded Theory Method (GTM) is often met with a
surge of meticulous enquiries and controversial
perspectives. The use of GTM is, debatably unnecessarily,
renowned for being a challenging approach for qualitative
research, shrouded in scholarly tradition. Originally
formulated by sociologists Barney Glaser & Anselm
Strauss (1967), GTM aims to generate theory from
empirical data by an inductive approach, and evaluates
the relationships between concepts. The emphasis is to
generate a theory that is grounded within the data, and
free of researcher bias. The method features a distinct
systematic coding practice; dependant on the approach

Abstracts
selected, and requires data analysis to occur alongside
data collection to facilitate constant comparison with
newly collected data, only coming to a halt once no further
concepts emerge.

of Papers
This paper aims to challenge what GTM can mean to the
researcher, and why it is a worthwhile qualitative research
method, despite the accompanying challenges, and how to
navigate through the variety of myths and approaches
13 14
before making a selection relevant to the project. Often familiar. This can result in feelings of discouragement and
critiqued, GTM is accompanied by a wealth of reluctance to discuss, or even adopt, the method. Combined
misconceptions, contributing to confusion and potentially with elements of imposter syndrome, naturally characteristic
creating an apprehension between the researcher and of research students, this paper further discusses how to
supervisory team, as discussed in this paper. The primary approach a daunting method, persisting with, and confidently
myth maintains the researcher as a ‘blank slate’, to avoid any defending the adoption of GTM. In addition, this research
influences upon the data collection and analysis, thus delaying suggests how other researchers may face similar challenges
the bulk of literature review process to after the data within their own methodological selections, and how to
collection. In addition, other myths include the generation of effectively overcome them.
a despairingly detailed theory, and the production of inflexible
theories, rendering the cope of the research to be limited.

As a research student, selecting a method of which the The Challenge of Using Intersectionality as a
theorists themselves vastly disagreed on, and since being Research Methodology
remodelled numerous times, can prove to be an intimidating
task. The different approaches, including classic (Glaser &
Strauss, 1967), Straussian (Strauss & Corbin, 1990), and
constructivist (Charmaz, 2006), can complicate the research
design, subsequently requiring a history lesson to effectively Nahla Raffaoui
position the research project within the fitting approach. Department of English
Adding this aspect into the mix of tasks a research student is
simultaneously managing can be burdensome, an aspect
which often is not relevant when considering alternative
methods. The questions of race and gender have always been the core
themes that have preoccupied the writings and the agendas of
Black feminists across different generations. Each generation
of Black feminists has interrogated these vectors of social
The practice of constant comparison is a key feature of data injustice differently in their texts and in their activism
collection and analysis within GTM. However, due to the However, the constant focus on the interconnectedness of the
challenges of selecting an approach and the subsequent paradigms of race and gender led to the necessity of
defence of that choice, the constant comparison becomes a employing intersectionality within the field of Black feminism
feature of the research journey. As a result of these aspects, as to categorise both race and gender as interlocking
a research student, a degree of courage is required upon oppressions. Thus, my research is concerned with examining
coming forth as utilising GTM within a project, as those more the different negotiations of the intersections of race and
familiar with the approach can be critical of those less gender with the addition to diaspora in contemporary texts of

15 16
Black feminist writers. The study includes post-2010 cross- debatable. In addition to studying these texts, the
genre texts with a cross-border transatlantic dimension of a presentation will also shed light on Adichie beyond the writer
range of Black feminist writers from different locations. These and focuses on her public persona to examine her way of
texts comprise variations of fiction and non-fiction including globalising the image of the Black feminist in relation to race
memoirs, manifestos, autobiographies, poetry, lyric, and gender discourse. The purpose of this intersectional
journalistic writing, and novels of African American, Black analysis is to put under scrutiny Adichie’s approach towards
British, African, and Caribbean feminist writers. Despite the negotiating the intersections of race and gender through her
focus on cross-genre, the study will refer to life writing as the writing and public presence. In addition, applying the
point of commonality between these texts in order to examine intersectional praxis will help explore the extent to which
the writers’ experiences and representations of these these two texts could be considered intersectional.
intersections. It will also refer to the theorization of Black
feminism by the earlier generation of Black feminists to draw Yet, despite the popularity of intersectionality in different
the difference as well as the relevance of their model of fields such as feminism and critical race studies, there is a
interrogating these intersections to contemporary Black consensus that the approach itself lacks a directly identified
feminists. methodology. According to Leslie McCall (2005), one of the
unintentional outcomes of intersectionality is the limitations
of the approaches that engage with intersectionality as a
research methodology. These limitations construct a challenge
The methodology employed in this study is a textual analysis of how to carry intersectional research to result in producing
based on different theoretical texts of Black feminism and the the type of knowledge wanted. Thus, different critics and
framework of intersectionality. This approach was presented scholars have attempted to draw a clear set of approaches that
by Kimberlé Crenshaw (1989) in her ground-breaking article could be compatible with the variation of intersectional
‘Demarginalizing the Intersection of Race and Sex.’ For research. For example, McCall (2005) outlines three analytical
Crenshaw, intersectionality refers to the way race and gender approaches based on categorisations, which are:
interlock to create a fundamental oppression which forms anticategorical complexity, intercategorical complexity, and
Black women’s experiences (1991). However, the focus of this intracategorical complexity. The first approach refuses to
paper is to present an intersectional reading to illustrate how focus on social categories claiming to define social categories
intersectionality could be engaged with as a methodology as a complex endeavour (McCall, 2005). However,
which some critics believe the framework fails to clearly intercategorical complexity approach works on the
outline. Thus, in this presentation I will provide an relationship between the different social categories (McCall,
intersectional reading to the non-fiction feminist works by the 2005). The last approach, intracategorical complexity calls for
contemporary Nigerian feminist writer Chimamanda Ngozi social categories to be studied critically as it locates
Adichie We Should All Be Feminists (2014) and Dear Ijeawele intersectional identities as subjects of analysis (McCall, 2005).
A Feminist Manifesto in Fifteen Suggestion (2018). These two
texts present Adichie’s rendering of Black feminism based on
her personal experiences; however, her approach and
arguments in these texts made her and her works highly
17 18
The approach of intercategorical complexity might be more My road to shaping the subject of my research
relevant to such study as it employs Black women’s narrative
about these social categorizations to expose the experiences of
marginalized identities (Nash, 2008). Still, despite the Magdalena Marchowska-Raza,
arguments that are directed against intersectionality as a Languages, Information & Communications
method, I argue in this paper for the lucidity of the approach
and the unlimited categorizations that define intersectionality.
McCall herself stresses that not all intersectional research can Introduction
fall under these three approaches (2005). Thus, I further When I decided to pursue a PhD, I had a vision of what
argue that it allows for space for researchers to develop their research I would like to complete. The initial research
approach that would be convenient for their study and the proposal I presented was an extension of my Master research
wished results. By providing an intersectional reading to the and was designed to investigate influence of social media on
works of Adichie, this paper contends that despite the consumer behaviour and purchasing decisions. I was asked to
complexity of the concept, the open-ended nature of the scale down the proposal as the lack of details caused it to be
approach makes it lucid. Finally, I consider my presentation a too broad.
learning opportunity for early researchers in the field of
intersectionality. By sharing my experience, researchers might
become aware that intersectional research like any research The next draft of my proposal was much more detailed. I have
comes along with challenges. However, the challenge in such chosen an industry of interest (cosmetics). I also have decided
rich research field turns around the validity of to focus on communities on social media. The research was
intersectionality as a methodology which this paper aimed at designed to conduct a comparison study between consumer-
discussing. initiated brand communities on social media and brand-
initiated communities. I have distinguished two types of
engagement, namely cognitive and sociological, that I wanted
to closely examine. I planned to used Community of Practice
theory for the cognitive engagement and social influence
theory lens for sociological element.

Due to my lack of experience, I was unaware that my research


proposal was too complex for the time frame of a PhD course.
My DoS have drawn my attention to the fact that not only
19 20
comparison study would require gathering immense amount  Crystallise methodology
of data to be significant, there also might be difficulties Repeated conversations with my supervisors that:
obtaining permissions from all community members as some
communities reached thousands of members.  Guided me in the direction of further exploration
 Gave me feedback about the drawn ideas for research

After much thought I have decided to focus on brand-initiated  Pointed areas of possible interests for exploration
communities based on social media as the communities are
open spaces and therefore obtaining ethical clearance would
Results
be much more straight forward. The elimination of consumer-
initiated brand communities also allows to limit the research Scoping literature allowed me to identify theories I would like
data needed to be collected. to apply in my research. Through my literature search, I was
able to secure key research papers for my study and identify
gaps in research. I was able to establish research methods
The progress I have made since enrolling to the PhD most suitable for my research. All the progress mentioned
programme was possible through extensive literature research above allowed me to shape the research proposal that is
as only when I examined closely the state of knowledge and manageable and achievable within the given timeframe.
acquainted myself with the theoretical base I was able to Throughout my initial journey, I received tremendous support
shape my research proposal to a manageable size. Invaluable and guidance from my supervisors without whom swift
was also the help of my supervisors who offered guidance progress would not be possible. The work resulted in a clear
when I felt overwhelmed by the volume of research and its plan that allowed me to move forward with my research. I was
complexity. also able to create an RD1 titled:

Materials and methods Engagement in cosmetics’ social media brand communities:


benefits and influences.
Scoping the literature to:
 Established state of knowledge My research will look into customer engagement on cosmetic
social media brand communities through the community of
 Identify the knowledge gaps
practice theory and social influence theory. Though my
 Substantiate area for my research research I would like to discover whether the engagement

21 22
displayed by communities’ members is driven by cognitive or  Keep the aim of planned research at the back of the head
emotional (feeling of belonging to a group) need. I also would  Filter all new data gathered by literature research
like my research to determine how the engagement translate through the planned research
into action and whether actions differ when activated by
different need (cognitive or emotional).

I am planning to collect data through in-depth interviews and


netnographic observation of selected social media brand
communities. As mentioned above, I am interested in Academic libraries and Research Data
cosmetics sector as I believe purchases are based on emotions Management
and opinions of others, therefore such constructs as
communities are vital for members to make purchasing
Angeliki Andrikopoulou
decisions. The selection of a community will be based on the
members’ activity; strands of conversations that will be Languages, Information and Communications
characterised by most engagement will be picked for analysis.

Aim
Next steps This study aims to contribute to theory, knowledge and
In the following months I plan to: practice regarding the role of academic libraries in Research
Data Management (RDM). The central research question of
 Conclude literature research this research is: To what extent does the involvement of
 Apply for ethical approval through EthOS system university libraries in RDM contribute to: embedding them in
the research process; and, re-shaping notions of the identity
 Conduct a pilot study of the university library?
 Prepare for RD 2 and annual review

Objectives
In consequence, I learned to: The objectives of the study are:
 To listen to advice given by supervisors  To review previous research on the future of academic
 Do not be afraid to modify research libraries and to review the previous research on research

23 24
data management practice in universities, in general, important contribution given the fact that researchers, the
and academic libraries, more specifically. actual producers of scientific knowledge, has been proved that
are not engaged or familiar with the notions of Research Data
 To develop an understanding of the policy and Management (RDM) and Research Data Management Plans
contextual considerations associated with RDM (RDP) (Chowdhury et al., 2017). However, RDM agenda
including collaboration and competition areas. involves many stakeholders such as IT services departments,
 To develop a deep and nuanced understanding of the research support services and researchers and academics
role and contribution of librarians as research data themselves thus, does not come out as library's exclusive
managers, which will form the basis for the development matter (Cox et al., 2017). This fact directly places the library in
of a conceptual model of the successes and challenges a chain of continuing and interacting collaboration and
associated with RDM. competition.

 To identify the skills required and expected of librarians


working as research data managers, to propose a Recently, networks of collaboration through the RDM agenda
conceptual model. have been identified by Van Strien & Fellous-
Sigrist (2017). Additionally, Cox and Verbaan (2014) have
exposed the nexus of competition between the librarians and
Background other professionals, mostly IT specialists, under the point of
Research Data Management is considered as the governance view of professional jurisdiction. Certainly, library plays
of data through the entire research lifecycle, in order these significant role in the new evolving area associated with the
data to become shareable and reusable (Whyte & Tedds, data lifecycle (Branin, 2009). Similarly, librarian’s skillset
2011). Academic institutions and research funding regarding RDM has emerged discussions about reskilling and
organizations advocate that the quality of data management is the adoption of new roles such as “data librarians” (Cox et al,
an important requirement to maintain scientific progress 2017).
(Verbaan & Cox, 2014). The increasing interest on Research
Data generated by the Universities, has emerged great
discourse among Library and Information Science (LIS) Given that the reality of RDM in academic libraries is in
specialists (Cox, 2017) about the role of the academic library. constant change, in a manner that is described by Cox et al. as
The topic is considered as extremely complex, multifaceted “maturity” (2017), it is important for the current research to
and source of uncertainty (Verbaan & Cox, 2014; Brochu and conduct an in-depth analysis of the factors that involve
Burns, 2018). collaboration and competition in the RDM activities.
Furthermore, the librarians’ point of view is important to be
recorded regarding the above topics and the skills needed to
Brochu and Burns (2018) claim that librarians play a key role address the challenges of the RDM.
in RDM as educators and supporters. That is considered as an

25 26
Methodology Challenges for the Interdisciplinary
The study will commence with a preliminary scoping stage, Researcher
the aim of which will be to develop an understanding of the
policy and contextual considerations associated with
RDM. The main stage of this research will focus on the Sarah Walker
perceptions of three groups of key stakeholders in the RDM
Department of Design
process: senior academic library managers, librarians with
specific responsibility for RDM, and academic researchers
with experience of depositing their research
data. The research will adopt a case study-based approach, This poster paper aims to provide some insight in navigating
focussing on the RDM practices in five UK Russell Group an interdisciplinary approach and discusses my own journey
university libraries. Case study university libraries will be of adapting different disciplines for a PhD. Increasingly
selected based on their research ranking, research funding sought after within academia, multidisciplinarity provides a
profile, experience with RDM, and the level of contribution of platform for different expertise to come together to develop
the university library to RDM processes. Primary data will be impactful research by asking bigger and different questions
gathered through semi-structured interviews with key that go beyond each separate discipline (Lach, 2014).
stakeholders. However, it poses a methodological challenge where
numerous potentialities emerge and a sense of direction can
be blurred. Likewise, stretching yourself across disciplines
and crossing new boundaries between discourses does not
Ethics
necessarily equate to a clear trajectory into employment as
The research will consider ethical issues arising from the individual projects might not delve equally into each distinct
adopted methodology. The researcher will maintain discipline.
confidentiality of data and will not reveal the identity of any
participant, ensures that the data is accurate and up to date,
and holds all data safely, using physical and digital security My current research is guided by the hypothesis that creative
measures. participatory practices can not only encourage communities to
take care of their local greenspace but also influence policy
within Manchester and Leeds. One of my main challenges is
that I am not only weaving and mixing discourses in Design,
Landscape Architecture and Geography, I am also proposing
quick adaption to negotiate with, be with and be response-
able for all stakeholders. The principle aim of this project is to
uncover opportunities for stakeholders to feel some sense of
stewardship in their local environment and identify the

27 28
potentiality of creativity in urban greenspace. When provide most of the necessary facilities, for a sense of
considering stewardship of nature and stakeholders, I am community to flourish, it must develop naturally through
interested in examining those ‘beings’ that do not explicitly proactive individuals (Barton, Grant and Guise, 2010).
ask permission to change their surroundings; this study
contends that it is the role of designers and planners to
facilitate and encourage this notion. The challenge here is If the designer’s job is to understand and predict behaviours
building and developing communication between academia (Chick and Micklethwaite, 2011), when considering urban
and society. greenspace it is also important for future projects to take on
board multiple perspectives (CABE/DETR, 2000). This
ultimately suggests that designers should provide a holistic
In my project, I focus on urban greenspaces in Manchester and interdisciplinary approach to every project. Haraway
and Leeds. These spaces provide numerous benefits to well- (2016) puts forward a new epoch named the Chthulucene as
being and the environment (Kabisch and Haase, 2014). an all-encompassing and on-going notion of living with,
However, despite the overwhelming benefits, they remain working with and dying with each other as both human and
under constant threat from lack of funding and available land non-human counterparts. Throughout, she discusses that
often being sacrificed to supply the increased demand for new deeper bonds to all living ‘critters’ are essential to nourish the
housing developments (Shams and Barker, 2019). One way to planet and live within a sustainable world. We must learn
mitigate these challenges is to use design thinking as a from what is dying and what is living as well as understand
mechanism to drive environmental sustainability and human how to protect the visible and acknowledge the invisible
well-being within urban greenspace (Wolch, Byrne and (Haraway, 2016). Despite this being a hefty and time-
Newell, 2014). Although there may be confusion over consuming challenge, as a designer, I will adopt this mode of
ownership of land in certain spaces, greenspaces can and do thinking to bridge together my chosen disciplines.
belong to the public therefore, they can be a place for equal
ownership. Collaborating with individuals and communities
who live and work near urban greenspaces as well as members Ultimately, the core responsibility of the interdisciplinary
of local authority and institutions, this project applies researcher is to delve into intersecting epistemologies in order
recursive design practices to ensure a continuous feedback to make innovative connections between the dots. Adopting
loop informing the overall outcome (Leavy, 2017). Utilising co this approach involves not only patience and tolerance for
-design with my stakeholders will help find opportunities for unfamiliarity but remaining open to multiple perspectives and
behaviour change that favour the reconnection to nature or pathways (Lach, 2014). For those unafraid of the unknown
the natural environment. This project looks to understand (and perhaps overly ambitious), an interdisciplinary approach
place and its planning which will ultimately inform a is a worthy challenge.
compelling and resonant outcome for community building
that helps support all living things. Community building is
something that is difficult to facilitate and there is no formula
to guarantee the success of a project. Although you can
29 30
The New Witch: A contemporary The changing feminist perspectives on the figure of the witch
interpretation of female power between invite us to establish a more careful view on the current
representation of this figure, and thus a deeper analysis on
reality and fiction
how the iconography of the witch is portrayed in fictional and
realistic contexts. In Witches, Sluts, Feminists: Conjuring the
Sex Positive Kristen J. Sollée explains the contemporary
Dounia Ouided Hachelef proliferation of the figure of the witch as an attempt to
Department of English revive “bad” female archetypes. Sollée also implores women to
consider these archetypes as a feminist guide and a gateway
towards female liberation (Sollée, 2017). Pam Grossman
The witch as a myth or an archetype has changed her shape challenges traditional dichotomies of
from one decade to another according to social change. From patriarchal American philosophy and describes it as the
an early feminist point of view, the witch has been formed and persistence of male misogynistic views on non-conformist
reformed time and again. She has been a demonic women (Grossman, 2017). It has been suggested that the
figure (Pavlac, 2001); she has been a healer, a midwife and a monstrous potential of the witch is perceived as equivalent to
wise-woman who was persecuted and burned because of the powerful potential of feminists. The witch according to
men’s supremacy (Hodgkin, 1998); she was also seen Creed is among the most used monstrous female figures in
as a temptress and a sinful woman who suffered Horror films (Creed 1993). In that context, when women
from ‘phallogocentric hegemonies’ (Sempruch, 2008). embrace their inner power, they indirectly awaken female evil
potential and unleash the uncanny version of themselves that
it may be liberating for women but most importantly
obstructing for society.
In the 21st century, American popular
culture significantly influenced the reshaping of the figure of
the witch from mythology and historical interpretations
to contemporary complex figuration in film and Redefining the contemporary iconography of the witch plays a
television. Scholars have narrowed these extensive views revealing role in the shaping of her identity, which reflects the
about the figure of the witch to define her as a straightforward relationship between the female witch and the changing
feminist icon. However, minimal consideration has circumstances of the modern society. Feminist theory was and
been provided to the kind of relationship such portrayals still is the theoretical position that produces nuanced
might have with the issue of female power. Recently, the interpretations of the witch character; however, this theory of
contemporary representation of the witch suggests an criticism has been exhausted, which makes it particularly
alternative perspective of ambivalence that is key to challenging to introduce new feminist models.
redefining the iconography of the witch.

31 32
Using a critical feminist approach to study the American
21st popular culture fantasy fiction portrayals of the witch
figure, my research will investigate the resurgence of the
“bad” witch figure, and will establish an interconnection
between the cosmeticized witch in American fantasy and
the American cultural theories about powerful women in the
mainstream. This research will create a conversation between
cultural and fictional representations of the witch in
contemporary America, to problematize the reclamation of
the witch in works such as Maleficent (2014), A Discovery of
Witches (2017), and The Chilling Adventures of
Sabrina (2018). This paper will demonstrate how the
character of the witch can be synonymous to female power
and female liberation through her contemporary symbolism
in popular culture, fiction, and film.

Women such as Hillary Clinton who strive for power are still
typecast as witches; this representation urges us to
conceptualize female power through the diverse agendas of
the character of the witch. By exploring American popular
culture fiction, I will be developing an alternative
interpretation of female power in order to determine whether
the contemporary American perception on female power is
relevant to both the image of the witch
in contemporary fiction, and the image of the new woman in
the US.

Figure1: A tweet that compared Hillary Clinton to the Wicked Witch of


the West.

33 34
'Mother was Making Angels': The Challenge other material involving infanticide can lead researchers to
of Discussing Infanticide become desensitised, which can negatively affect
communication of their work. This aspect in particular,
reveals the far-reaching consequences which can occur should
a person’s own emotional needs be neglected. Shocking
Catherine Elkin
material can also have a far more serious effect on those that
Department of English choose their specialism within it, and must wade through
graphic photographs, etchings and vivid descriptions of
cruelty. This effect is amplified in the case of field work
The study and communication of baby farming poses a undertaken for research in these areas, working with
number of challenges, both to the researcher and those to vulnerable people, discussing difficult, and often extremely
which they present their work. I will demonstrate these personal, topics (Janet et al., 2010).
challenges in my presentation, exploring practical and
personal means to combat such adverse effects. Baby farming
was an informal means of adoption, in which (usually) a Research undertaken in higher education is often all-
woman reared the children of others, in exchange for encompassing and when the pressures of academia are
payment. A small number of those in this trade, however, combined with the stress of an emotive topic, the effect on the
deliberately caused the deaths of infants in their care in order researcher is seldom likely to be positive. Hence, long-term
to maximise their profits (Behlmer, 1982). The material that exposure to such methods and material can cause states of
evidences this can be of an upsetting nature, whether in the depression and anxiety, which, if left unchecked can develop
form of pictures, etchings or graphic description. Historians into chronic illnesses, seriously affecting mental and physical
often acknowledge the difficulty of discussing topics such as health (Tips for Coping with Depression, 2018). It has been
infanticide (Hendrick, 1994). One challenge is to tread the pointed out by those feeling the effects of their work that as of
delicate line between conveying an accurate portrayal of yet, there are no measures in our procedures of ethical
events and avoiding graphic content capable of disturbing an approval to help with this challenge for researchers
audience. There is a real danger of causing emotional harm (Arpasanu, 2019.). I will address these issues in my
when discussing the more gruesome aspects of baby farming presentation, suggesting methods based on empathy and
and this must be recognised and acknowledged during the collaboration to ensure the appropriate presentation of
presentation of this research to others. However, due to the difficult topics. Additionally, I will suggest coping
individualistic emotional context of each person, choosing mechanisms and avenues of support to help prevent a
what content to include can be quite a difficult thing to guage. temporary negative emotional state from becoming a long-
term problem. These issues are frequent and serious and
therefore deserve further discussion and it is my aim to do
Prolonged study of baby farming can also lead to an ever- justice to them in my presentation. With this, I hope to open a
growing emotional burden. Over-exposure to this and, indeed, constructive and supportive dialogue between researchers, to

35 36
find ways we can ease the continually mounting pressure for is problematic, open to ongoing debates
ourselves, and each other. and numerous interpretations.

Sieber and Stanley (1988:49) define sensitive research as an


inquiry, which elicits emotion-laden responses, generates
An emotional journey: the risk and changes risks and can result in a wide range of social implications “for
associated with undertaking sensitive participants in the research of for the class of individuals
research on mortality mediation in dark represented by the research”. However, sensitive research
tourism topics have been used variably to define a range of issues,
methods and settings across a varied number of
disciplines. Thus, sensitive topics can include inquiries on
Rodica Arpasanu, mental health (Mitchell and Irvine, 2008), life-threatening
illnesses (Rodriquez, 2018), deviant behaviour, difficult
School of Science and the Environment heritage (Tucker, 2009), death and bereavement
(Goodrum and Keys, 2007). The sensitive nature of a research
topic is also context depended. As such, Lee
The postgraduate research journey has been and Renzetti (1990, 1993) recommend researchers to develop
commonly centred on making a novel contribution to ethical protocols and methodological precautions aligned to
knowledge and positioning the researcher within a particular the context in which each research process unfolds (e.g.
field of research. However, in recent years, there has been an fieldwork, transcription, analysis,
upsurge in awareness that performing researcher is an dissemination). Although this viewpoint might present a
embodied experience with transformative and affective more inclusive approach to understanding sensitive
qualities (Dickson-Swift et al., 2007, 2008, 2009). This research, as Johnson and Clarke (2003) highlight, all
experience can be particularly intense for those researchers these definitions tend to share a common limitation. That is,
undertaking projects, which explore topics of a sensitive the overemphasis on the potential impact of sensitive research
nature (Gibson, 1996; Quinlan and Quinlan, 2010). on participants and an overall omission of the risk and
More so, when data generating processes and strategies consequences incurred by researchers, which remain largely
encompass (qualitative) methods that unacknowledged or confined to issues of methodological rigor
i n v o l v e d i r e c t e nc o u n t e r s a n d and fieldwork access (Doloriert and Sambrook,
conversations with distressing and potentially damaging 2009). However, as Zurbriggen (2002) and Schmied et al.
consequences, for both participants and the (2011) point out, carrying out sensitive research can pose
researcher (Cowles, 1988; Stanley and Wise, emotional, psychological and even physical distress for
1988). Nevertheless, defining sensitive research researchers (more so if they are inexperienced) (Dunkely and
Whelan, 2006).

37 38
This paper draws on the available literature to discuss some of The results of this study are overall consistent with the
the challenges involved in undertaking research exploring the existing literature and research from various disciplines,
concept of mortality mediation – a potentially which highlight the challenges and difficulties experienced by
sensitive research topic, examined in the context of dark (novice) researchers carrying out (qualitative) investigation
tourism (Stone, 2012). Dark tourism can be generally defined on sensitive topics in various disciplines (Wettergren et al.,
as the visitation of sites of and associated with death, natural 2016). Although dark tourism is a relatively novel area of
or man-made disasters and human tragedy (Lennon and research, academic structures and practitioners need to move
Foley, 2000). The author will also reflect on the personal beyond the controversies surrounding dark tourism
dilemmas and the difficulties encountered during the early research (Stone, 2012). Instead, there should be a
stages of the research and the data collection processes. The concentrated effort to develop structural frameworks and
fieldwork involved interviewing research participants about research protocols, which will help identify and mitigate
their visits at a former notorious Greek prison (Heptapyrgion potential risk and challenges associated with performing and
Fortress) and a Romanian graveyard (Merry Cemetery). Both taking part in studies investigating death, disaster and
sites have been identified as being dark touristic attractions, difficult heritage (Rager, 2005a, 2005b). These developments
where visitors can have a symbolic encounter with hold a particular significance for novice and unexperienced
mortality (Stone at al., 2018). researchers undertaking sensitive research. This study aims to
contribute to the broader academic discussion about sensitive
research in the context of dark tourism, by raising the
Following the definitions of sensitive research provided awareness needed to advance ethical and methodological
by Sieber and Stanley (1988) and Lee and Renzetti (1990, precautions early in the research process. This paper
1993), the present study can be considered as being of a will suggest potential strategies, which could help novice PhD
sensitive nature. Firstly, because as Moscardo and Ballantynes researchers recognize and manage personal challenges when
(2008: 247) remark, nowhere else are strong emotional undertaking sensitive research.
responses “more clearly present than in…dark tourism
places”. Secondly, because this study asks participants to
converse and reflect on their encounters with symbolic
mortality in dark tourism places. This also
involves participants talking about their deeply intimate and
potentially painful personal lived experiences of loss and
bereavement (Walter, 2009; Buda 2015). Although there are
several studies, which indicated that visit to ‘dark’ touristic
sites can evoke a range of emotional responses from curiosity
and horror, to empathy and sadness, anger and anxiety (Buda
et al., 2014, Light, 2017); there are considerably less or no
studies exploring the emotional implications of scholars
undertaking dark tourism research.
39 40
Effects of Social Media Use in Teaching to cover the theories necessary, both in communication and
English: An investigation of Instagram learning theories, to be able to develop a new/modified
communication model that is fit for teaching English as a
adoption in teaching English as a second
foreign language using Instagram.
language

Berlo’s SMCR model:


Latifah Alharbi
Languages, Information and Communications
Berlo’s SMCR model of communication contains four main
elements: Source (S), Message (M), Channel (C) and Receiver
With the recent proliferation of communication technologies (R) (Berlo, 1960). Each contains sub-elements necessary to
allowing instant global communication for many, using these satisfy a communication link (Narula, 2006, p.31). This model
tools for learning has become more popular (Laestadius, is not exclusive to one communication medium. Figure 1
2018). This raises the question, how effective is teaching via below shows an overview of the communication model
Social Media? This research will investigate this matter, devised by Berlo. It is worth mentioning that other
specifically addressing teachers using Instagram to teach researchers have adapted the model to suit their individual
English as a second language. It involves interviewing active needs, this could be by adding extra elements or sub-elements
teachers to gain an insight into their experiences with to the model, or otherwise, picking the suitable sub-elements
Instagram as a communication and teaching tool. The from each main element and neglecting the rest (Croft,
research encourages teachers to keep up to date with 2004).
advancing communication and teaching tools and exploit
them to enhance creativity and the overall teaching
experience. This research will bridge the gap in knowledge
regarding the value and use of Instagram for teaching English
as a second language, and as an effective communication tool.
It seeks to assess Instagram’s effectiveness by determining its
communication characteristics. Teachers who teach English
using Instagram will be interviewed in-depth, with pre-tested
questions to identify how Instagram can be used effectively,
barriers to and motives for using it in teaching.

The aim is to study Instagram in teaching English as a foreign


language, and therefore, it is appropriate that the research has Figure 1: Berlo’s SMCR

41 42
Figure 2 shows my attempted proposal of a communication
model, adapted from Berlo’s communication model. It
involves a crucial element, presented in Instagram’s way of
communication, which is ‘Feedback’ (Hargie, 2006, p.26-
28) and it helps to create a looped model or a two-
way communication scheme instead of Berlo’s one-
way communication process, having feedback as an element
will help to assess the effectiveness in
communication (Narula, 2006, p. 31). The figure below
represents communication process with Instagram as a
channel and the new essential elements and sub-
elements added. Moreover, there are some components added
which are influencing the information flow and

Figure 2: The proposed communication model.


handling, such as barriers and noise, which are factors that
effect the quality of the information. Hence, these are not
elements but rather components that take action in the
transition between the elements.

The questions arising from the above model are:

1. What source factors or characteristics are significant to


the effectiveness of the communication?
2. Are there any potential problems or barriers when
teaching English using Instagram or sending a message?
How should we deal with them?
3. What characteristics of the message or the channel
would contribute to effectiveness of communication?
4. What is the relationship between message content and
channel of communication?
5. Where might noise appear in communication? How can
we reduce it?

43 44
6. What factors are significant in Instagram as a A key challenge within this research has been exploring the
communication medium? subjective experiences of participants and recording their
perceptual illusory experiences. The results so far suggest, not
7. What elements combine to create effective Instagram all participants are able to experience these kinds of illusions,
communication in teaching? and if experienced, they can be difficult for participants to
The results will highlight good practices in teaching and articulate. How can participants be made to feel more
communication using Instagram comfortable in speaking about these sensations openly? Is it
possible through practice and preparation, to become more
aware, and therefore more effectively articulate these unusual
sensations?

In light of this, a hybridised methodology is developing,


combining elements from Artistic Research and Interpretative
Experiments in art and perceptual illusion: Phenomenological Analysis [IPA] (Smith and Osborn, 2015).
Exploring methods used in experimental IPA is an investigative method commonly used in
psychology within a framework of artistic experimental psychology, offering the researcher insight into
the participants subjective experiences (Smith and Osborn,
practice 2015). These will be used in combination to devise a form of
Arts-Informed IPA (Sadkowska, 2016). Additionally,
Somaesthetics (Shusterman, 2013) provides a critical and
Antony Hall philosophical framework for this project, which encompassing
Department of Media bodily practice and training as a means to enhance bodily
experience. Recent studies have employed a somaesthetic
approach in the context of product design and human-
computer interaction (Höök et al., 2015) (Lee, Lim and
This practice-based artistic research builds on methods used
Shusterman, 2014) (Schiphorst, 2009). The ideas emerging
in experimental psychology. Exploring the phenomenology of
from this research are informed by and embody this
multisensory perceptual illusion and exploiting the creative
approach.
possibilities that these mechanisms of experience afford
within the context of artistic practice. Innovative multimedia
experiments are designed using digital and analogue
technologies, to manipulate multisensory stimuli, and induce To date, over 300 people have participated in family
illusory experiences. Experiments test if it is possible to orientated workshops, while over 30 experiments were
embody entirely unfeasible objects, the experience of sensory conducted one-to-one. Experiments allowed participants to
deprivation and simulated out of body experiences. play with illusory experiences and develop their own versions,

45 46
using clay, VR goggles, and drawing. The first phase revolved and "the study of perceptual consciousness" (Noë, 2000 p11)
around a perceptual experiment known as the 'Rubber Hand opening a space for reflexive experience to unfold,
Illusion' [RHI] (Rohde, Di Luca and Ernst, 2018) which is heightening self-awareness, creating richer more embodied
widely used in experimental psychology to explore ideas experiences. If this proves to be true, it may potentially
around body dysmorphia and body ownership. A new generate richer, more useful data for artistic and scientific
experiment was devised for this research; the 'Clay Hand research, giving a deeper understanding of the nature of
Illusion'. This expanded model asks participants to make subjective experience and consciousness itself.
objects, and explore for themselves the possibilities of
embodying entirely self-made unfeasible objects.

Building on the results of this initial research, several new Paths in the Wilderness: The Challenges of
experiential artworks have emerged which incorporate a Nature Poetry as Creative/Critical Research
sequence of questions and non-verbal assessments,
combining perceptual activities, and mindful reflection on
anomalous sensory experiences. 'Autoscope' (Hall, 2019) is
both performance and experiment developed for phase two of Andrew Forster
this research. A back-mounted armature mounts a camera
behind the user at a distance of 2m, feeding live video to VR Department of English
goggles, giving an experience of self-seeing. A real-time 3rd
person experience or out of body experience. The device uses
the same model as the RHI, combining multisensory elements For the last three years I have been engaged with a ‘practice-
to generate the illusion (Ehrsson, 2008) this model is now led’ PhD on Poetry and Environmentalism. This presentation
being used to test the wider implications of self-seeing (Osimo will explore the process, and some of the challenges, of a PhD
et al., 2015) and body swapping both from artistic and that blends critical and creative elements. Though practice-led
scientific perspectives (http://beanotherlab.org/, 2018). is the current term for this, my preference is for ‘creative-
Autoscope builds on these studies, taking it beyond the critical’, because the two aspects are inextricably linked and
laboratory and allowing the user to navigate and interact with influence each other. The presentation will include readings of
the real world. Autoscope can be seen as both artwork and poems from the thesis.
experiential tool within the framework of this research.

As a poet, my interest in this area began with my second and


It is proposed that in using this hybridised methodology, third books, Territory and Homecoming, which were both
these experiments [workshops and experiential artworks] can concerned with the process of making homes in new places,
be thought of as a toolkit for phenomenological investigation, through poems mapping the landscape, history and natural

47 48
history of each place. While working on these, I became aware and romanticised. They question the relevance of poetry that
of the rise in ecopoetry and ‘new nature writing’. Jonathan focuses on individual experience and responsibility ‘in a world
Bate’s The Song of the Earth, published in 2000, became the where the most serious environmental challenges are dealt
focal point for poetry addressing the ecological crisis, calling with by international and global institutions.’
for a poetry of dwelling, that attunes readers to the

Garrard and Lidström do not recognise that it is possible for a


environment, thereby making them better able to care for it. poem to both ecophenomenological and environmental at the
Bate’s book had considerable influence on British lyric nature same time. They ignore longstanding differences between
poets such as Kathleen Jamie. I gained a critical context for traditions of nature poetry in Britain and North America,
my poetry in Bate’s concept of dwelling, but as my awareness where poets such as Wendell Berry, Gary Snyder and Mary
of the environmental crisis developed I felt the limitations of Oliver, among others, have a long history of directly activist
this approach, and wanted to explore the idea of a more place-based environmental poetry, based on individual
politically activist nature poetry. experience, that makes connections to the wider geopolitical
situation. The challenge I set myself was to draw on the work
of these poets to write ecologically-aware nature poetry, in the
Recent ecocritics such as Timothy Morton, Timothy Clark and British lyric tradition, that was both ecophenomenological
Matthew Griffiths shared my sense of the limitations of much environmental.
of the work I was reading. For them, nature poetry within the
British lyric tradition is restricted by locality and
characterised by ‘ecomimesis’, or sensory engagement which
fails to show the complexity of the environmental crisis. Their
solution, however, was in a more allusive and complex form of
poetry, more aligned to modernism.

Susanna Lidström and Greg Garrard, try to clarify these


differing positions. They distinguish between
‘ecophenomenological’ and ‘environmental poetry.’
Ecophenomological poetry is rooted in an individual response
to the environment, while environmental poetry explores the
wider geopolitical context of the environmental crisis.
Lidström and Garrard are critical of poetry they consider to be
ecophenomenological. From their perspective, the ‘natural
world’ that such poetry aims to connect to is ‘generally idyllic’

49 50
Freya Ernsting
Languages, Information & Communications

Freya Ernsting is a current doctoral student at Manchester


Metropolitan University, investigating the identity
formulation of smartphone users amongst young adults.
In particular, taking a grounded theory approach, she is
exploring the embodiment and interactions between the
user and device, and how these are experienced and
perceived. In addition, she is interested in the broader
relationship between technological development and
society. Freya graduated from The University of Sheffield
in 2013 after completing a Master of Arts in Japanese
Studies, and from Manchester Metropolitan University in
2011 with a BA (Hons) in Film and Media Studies.

Nahla Raffaoui
Department of English

Presenter
Nahla Raffaoui is a full-time second -year Ph.D. student in
the school of English in the Faculty of Arts and
Humanities at Manchester Metropolitan University. She is
doing a fully funded research under the title of reading the
intersectionality of race, gender, and diaspora in

Biographies
contemporary Black feminist writing. Her thesis includes
an intersectional study of transnational Black feminist
texts across multi- genres, such as autobiographies,
essays, memoirs, novels, and feminist manifestos.

51 52
Magdalena Marchowska-Raza Sarah Walker
Languages, Information & Communications Department of Design

I am a first year PhD student in the Information and Trained as a designer and artist, Sarah studied at Manchester
Communications department at Manchester Metropolitan Metropolitan University and later the University of Leeds with
University. My research focuses on customer engagement in an interest in sustainable design and public engagement. She
cosmetics brand communities based on social media. My has worked on several projects that have included
interest in social media started during my Bachelor course collaborations with Leeds City Council to improve community
that I completed with a dissertation focusing on the engagement through co-design, a design renovation project in
blogosphere and social media. My Master's dissertation Almeria, Spain and an artist residency in Mexico City.
concentrated on social media and its influence on consumer Currently, Sarah is researching how creative participatory
behaviour. Both of my degrees, Bachelor and Master, are of practices can foster sustainable action to protect and enhance
marketing background, with Bachelor majoring in Advertising greenspaces within urban environments in Manchester and
and Marketing and Master majoring in Social Communication Leeds in partnership with the Woodland Trust.
and Marketing.

Dounia Ouided Hachelef


Angeliki Andrikopoulou
Department of English
Languages, Information & Communications

Miss Dounia Ouided Hachelef is an Algerian Ph.D candidate,


Angeliki is a first-year PhD student at Manchester at Manchester Metropolitan University, Art and Humanities
Metropolitan University (Faculty of Arts and Humanities, Faculty. Dounia has received her BA in Language, Literature
School of Information, Communication and Languages), and and Anglo-Saxon Civilisation in 2014, and her Masters in
holds undergraduate and postgraduate degrees in Anglo-American studies in 2016, from Mohamed Lamine
librarianship (BA Hons, Athens & MA, Sheffield). She has Debaghine Sètif University in Algeria. She has previously
worked for many years as a professional librarian in various written a dissertation about fantasy film adaptations taking
positions in academic and public libraries in Greece, and her the Lord of the Rings as a study case. Her research interests
research interests focus on the contemporary role of the include the postfeminist representations of women in the
academic library. Currently, she conducts doctoral research, fantasy genre; Dounia is currently completing a PhD project
which aims to explore how Research Data Management on contemporary American representations of the witch figure
(RDM) can affect the identity of the academic library and the in American Popular Culture.
position of the academic librarian.
53 54
Catherine Elkin Latifah Alharbi
Department of English Languages, Information & Communications

Catherine Elkin is a first-year PhD student at Manchester A second year PhD student in Manchester Metropolitan
Metropolitan University, researching representations of baby University. Researching on ways to improve teaching using
farming (and other informal methods of adoption) throughout new technologies, specifically, teaching English as a second
the nineteenth and early-twentieth centuries. This was also language using social media platforms. I am looking deeply in
the subject of her MA dissertation, which she completed at the utilising Instagram to achieve that goal, to see whether it is a
University of Chester, before it was realised that the topic was good candidate, and if so how to effectively incorporate it. I
deserving of a much bigger project. Catherine is a strong earned my Masters degree in 2015 in information
believer in the benefits of interdisciplinary work, and is management at Leeds Beckett University. My masters
currently exploring the advantages that the digital humanities dissertation was also on using Instagram in education.
could bring to her project.

Antony Hall
Rodica Arpasanu
Department of Media
School of Science and the Environment

Antony Hall is an interdisciplinary artist and amateur


Rodica is a 3rd year PhD student in Human Geography at the scientist, working through experiments and workshops, across
Manchester Metropolitan University. Her PhD explores media and materials. Taking behavioural systems as a starting
cultural variations of contemporary expressions and point, control structures, devices and instruments, are
encounters with mortality in the context of death tourism. developed, within which these unique behavioural
Specifically, her research investigates if and how modern phenomena can exist. Perpetuating their existence for
individuals engage with and reflect upon the idea of death extended observation, study and experience. For example;
(their own or others) while visiting sites of and associated Harnessing the signals from electro-genic fish, and
with death, disaster and human tragedy. She earned her MA interconnecting these with human physiology, or using a laser
in Applied Cultural Analysis from Lund University in Sweden to record movement and sound from microscopic pond
and BSc(Hons) in International Business Management from creatures in a drop of pond water. He is a founding member of
Cardiff University. Owl Project who work with wood and electronics to fuse
sculpture and sound art and craft.
55 56
Andrew Forster
Department of English

Andrew Forster has published three collections of poetry:


‘Fear of Thunder’ (2007), ‘Territory’ (2010), and
‘Homecoming’ (2014). He has worked as Literature
Development Officer for twelve years, for Dumfries &
Galloway Arts Association and for the Wordsworth Trust. He
currently works as a freelance literature professional on a
number of projects, including the Michael Marks Awards for
Poetry Pamphlets, and as an Associate Lecturer at MMU. He
graduated from MMU on the MA Creative Writing in 2009.
His PhD, in Poetry and Environmentalism, was awarded
subject to minor revisions in March this year.

57 58
59

You might also like