Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
This report synthesizes evidence about innate hormonally mediated physiologic processes in women and
fetuses/newborns during childbearing, and possible impacts of common maternity care practices and inter-
ventions on these processes, focusing on four hormone systems that are consequential for childbearing. Core
hormonal physiology principles reveal profound interconnections between mothers and babies, among hor-
mone systems, and from pregnancy through to the postpartum and newborn periods. Overall, consistent
and coherent evidence from physiologic understandings and human and animal studies finds that the innate
hormonal physiology of childbearing has significant benefits for mothers and babies. Such hormonally-
mediated benefits may extend into the future through optimization of breastfeeding and maternal-infant
attachment. A growing body of research finds that common maternity care interventions may disturb hor-
monal processes, reduce their benefits, and create new challenges. Developmental and epigenetic effects are
biologically plausible but poorly studied. The perspective of hormonal physiology adds new considerations
for benefit-harm assessments in maternity care, and suggests new research priorities, including consistently
measuring crucial hormonally mediated outcomes that are frequently overlooked. Current understanding
suggests that safely avoiding unneeded maternity care interventions would be wise, as supported by the Pre-
cautionary Principle. Promoting, supporting, and protecting physiologic childbearing, as far as safely pos-
sible in each situation, is a low-technology health and wellness approach to the care of childbearing women
and their fetuses/newborns that is applicable in almost all maternity care settings.
©2015 National Partnership for Women & Families. All rights reserved. Reproduced with permission. To access full report and related
documents, see http://www.childbirthconnection.org/HormonalPhysiology.
146 The Journal of Perinatal Education | Summer 2015, Volume 24, Number 3
labor hypoxia and newborn transitions via the fetal PHYSIOLOGIC ONSET OF LABOR AT TERM
catecholamine surge. The physiologic (spontaneous) onset of term labor
is a complex and incompletely understood pro-
INTERORCHESTRATION AMONG HORMONE cess. Critical for survival, its timing is thought to
SYSTEMS be essentially determined by the baby’s maturity,
The hormone systems described here have com- via fetal cortisol production, coordinated with the
plex interactions in the perinatal period, including mother’s readiness for parturition, via estrogen pro-
promoting or inhibiting one another’s activity. This duction and other processes. Timing of the physio-
can amplify hormonal effects, leading to the peaks logic onset of term labor is difficult to predict due to
that characterize physiologic birth. For example, normal variation in the length of human gestation.
late-labor oxytocin peaks, promoted by high lev- With the physiologic onset of labor at term, ma-
els of prolactin and oxytocin itself, assist with the ternal and fetal systems are fully primed and precisely
pushing stage. Similarly, excessive stress and stress aligned for safe, effective, labor and birth, and for
hormones may disrupt labor progress via hormonal optimal postpartum physiologic transitions, includ-
interorchestration. ing breastfeeding initiation and maternal–newborn
attachment, according to physiologic understand-
CASCADE OF INTERVENTION ings, and human and animal studies. Physiologic
Hormonal disruptions can be amplified when one prelabor preparations occur in the weeks, days, and
intervention necessitates and leads to another that (in animal studies) hours before the onset of labor.
is used to monitor, prevent, or treat its side effects. Maternal preparations include:
This escalation of technology can further disrupt
hormonal physiology and introduce extra risks for • Rising estrogen levels, activating the uterus for an
mother and baby. For example, the reduction in efficient labor
maternal oxytocin that generally follows admin- • Cervical ripening due to increases in oxytocin and
istration of epidural analgesia may lead to use of prostaglandin activity (receptors, levels)
synthetic oxytocin to compensate. Prolonged use of • Increasing inflammation, which also activates the
synthetic oxytocin may desensitize the oxytocin re- cervix and uterus
ceptor system and increase the risk of postpartum • Increasing uterine oxytocin receptors, giving ef-
hemorrhage. fective contractions during labor, and after birth
to reduce bleeding
CONCERN ABOUT LONG-TERM IMPACTS • Increasing brain-based (central) receptors for
Non-physiologic exposures during the sensitive beta-endorphins (animal studies), contributing to
perinatal period may disrupt offspring hormone endogenous analgesia in labor
systems, with amplified and/or enduring biologi- • Elevations in mammary and central oxytocin and
cal, developmental, and/or behavioral impacts, prolactin receptors (animal studies), which pro-
as found in animal offspring, likely via epigenetic mote breastfeeding and maternal-infant attach-
programming effects. High-quality, long-term hu- ment after birth
man studies following fetal/newborn exposure to Similarly, processes before and during labor fos-
perinatal drugs and interventions are very limited. ter the baby’s adaptations for labor and peak readi-
Thus, the current evidence-based approach to iden- ness for the critical transition to life outside the
tifying safe and effective care, based on short-term womb. These include:
follow-up and limited examination of hormonally-
mediated outcomes such as breastfeeding, may • Prelabor maturing of the lungs and other organ
not provide adequate safeguards for mothers and systems, and of the processes that clear lung fluid
babies. Similarly, conventional shorter-term phar- in labor
macologic considerations of fetal/newborn drug • Prelabor development of oxytocin neuroprotec-
exposure (e.g., dose, duration, metabolism) may tive processes (animal studies)
not adequately safeguard the baby. Current levels • Prelabor increase in epinephrine-norepinephrine
of uncertainty about long-term impacts suggest receptors, giving protection from labor hypoxia
research priorities and support avoiding unneeded via the late-labor epinephrine-norepinephrine
interventions. (catecholamine) surge
148 The Journal of Perinatal Education | Summer 2015, Volume 24, Number 3
While the administration of synthetic oxyto- • Prolonged pushing stage with increased use of as-
cin for induction or augmentation is beneficial sisted vaginal birth
in selected circumstances, adverse impacts have • Disruption of maternal adaptations and
been found in women and babies. Synthetic oxy- attachment
tocin administered in labor is not thought to cross
These can also adversely affect the newborn.
into the maternal brain in biologically significant
High-quality research is lacking.
amounts, and so may lack calming and analgesic ef-
With prelabor cesarean section, mothers and ba-
fects. However, when synthetic oxytocin stimulates
bies miss their complete prelabor physiologic oxy-
contractions, positive feedback cycles may lead to
tocin preparations; and with any cesarean section,
central oxytocin release, promoting further contrac-
the full oxytocin processes, including the maternal
tions, labor progress, and continued central release.
late-labor oxytocin surge and postpartum oxytocin
Synthetic oxytocin may impact maternal oxyto-
peaks, may be reduced or absent. Impacts on breast-
cin and physiology. Possible effects include:
feeding, maternal adaptations, and postpartum
• Uterine hyperstimulation with potential fetal hy- hemorrhage have been found. Scheduled cesarean
poxia, requiring monitoring carried out after the physiologic onset of labor may
• Stronger contractions and increased pain without have fewer adverse oxytocin impacts than prelabor
central oxytocin analgesia cesarean section.
• Synthetic oxytocin overexposure causing desen- Postpartum separation of healthy mothers and
sitization of oxytocin receptors, contributing to newborns may have detrimental short- and longer-
reduced contractility, prolonged pushing, instru- term impacts on the oxytocin system, including:
mental birth, and/or postpartum hemorrhage • Reduced oxytocin due to lack of skin-to-skin con-
• Disruption of newborn breastfeeding behaviors, tact, with increased newborn stress and stress hor-
reduced maternal oxytocin release with breastfeed- mones, hypoglycemia, and hypothermia
ing, and possible reduced breastfeeding duration • Disruptions to breastfeeding initiation and long-
Physiologic principles, animal studies, and evolv- term success
ing human evidence suggest that perinatal synthetic • Deficits in maternal hormones and adaptations,
oxytocin exposure may have longer-term impacts on with longer-term impacts on maternal–infant
offspring. While high-quality research is lacking, po- attachment
tential mechanisms include: In animal studies, variations in maternal care-
• Direct fetal brain–hormone effects from synthetic giving in the newborn period lead to epigenetic
oxytocin transfer through placenta programming of offspring oxytocin systems, with
• Indirect signaling of maternal oxytocin to fetal brain enduring effects on offspring stress reactivity, and
• Indirect effects from subclinical hypoxia on the maternal care given by female offspring.
• Interference with fetal neuroprotective mecha-
BETA-ENDORPHINS: NORMAL PHYSIOLOGY
nisms (animal studies)
Beta-endorphins are endogenous opioids that give
• Fetal/newborn impacts from synthetic oxytocin
analgesic and adaptive responses to stress and pain.
co-interventions such as epidural
Beta-endorphins also activate brain reward and plea-
• Long-term programming of offspring hormonal
sure centers, motivating and rewarding reproductive
systems, likely via epigenetic effects (animal studies)
and social behaviors, and support immune function,
• Indirect effects via disruptions to maternal oxy-
physical activity, and psychological well-being.
tocin systems that impact attachment, reward,
From labor through the postpartum period,
breastfeeding, and/or mutual regulation
beta-endorphins promote:
Epidural analgesia reduces maternal oxytocin in
• Endogenous analgesia though prelabor increase in
labor, likely because of numbing of the sensory feed-
central receptors (animal studies) and increases in
back that promotes central oxytocin release. Possible
beta-endorphins as labor progresses
impacts include the following:
• An altered state of consciousness that may help
• Slowed labor with increased need for synthetic with labor stress and pain
oxytocin • Fetal neuroprotection from hypoxia (animal studies)
150 The Journal of Perinatal Education | Summer 2015, Volume 24, Number 3
• Promoting newborn alertness and energy for fetal hypoxia, stress, and stress hormones in labor,
breastfeeding initiation and the risk of cesarean for fetal distress.
With cesarean section, both mothers and babies
After birth, epinephrine-norepinephrine levels
may miss late-labor epinephrine-norepinephrine el-
drop steeply in mother and baby. These decreases
evations, and be less alert after birth for breastfeed-
promote uterine contractions, which may limit ma-
ing initiation. Lack of the fetal catecholamine surge
ternal bleeding, and, for the newborn, reduce energy
may significantly contribute to newborn morbidi-
consumption. Warmth and undisturbed skin-to-skin
ties following cesarean section, including breathing
contact may be important in facilitating maternal and
difficulties, hypoglycemia, hypothermia, and drows-
newborn epinephrine-norepinephrine reductions.
iness that may impact interactions and breastfeed-
ing. Cesarean birth may impair newborn and infant
COMMON MATERNITY CARE PRACTICES stress responses.
THAT MAY IMPACT EPINEPHRINE- Separation of healthy mothers and newborns is
NOREPINEPHRINE AND RELATED more likely following cesarean section, leading to
STRESS HORMONES newborn stress and stress hormone elevations. Early
Aspects of contemporary pregnancy care may have separation may also be stressful to the mother, de-
unintended negative (nocebo) effects by increasing priving her of the opportunity to reduce epinephrine-
maternal stress and anxiety. Stress and anxiety in preg- norepinephrine for herself and her baby through
nancy can elevate maternal stress hormones, including oxytocin elevations with skin-to-skin contact and
epinephrine-norepinephrine and cortisol, with detri- mutual interactions. In animal studies, repeated brief
mental long-term effects on offspring, including im- separations in the newborn period can lead to detri-
pacts on brain development and stress responsiveness, mental impacts on offspring stress hormone systems,
as established in human and animal studies. Studies likely via epigenetic programming, with enduring
suggest that maternal relaxation techniques may re- effects including depression-like behaviors in adult
duce pregnancy stress and its detrimental effects, but offspring and also in separated new mothers.
high-quality research is lacking in this important area.
In labor, anxiety or situations in which the woman PROLACTIN: NORMAL PHYSIOLOGY
does not feel private, safe, and undisturbed may pro- Prolactin is a major hormone of reproduction as
voke epinephrine-norepinephrine elevations, which well as breast-milk synthesis. Prolactin adapts ma-
may slow or stall labor and reduce fetal blood supply ternal physiology for pregnancy and breastfeeding,
via epinephrine-norepinephrine effects. Stress may promotes maternal adaptations, and is a caregiv-
also slow labor by reducing pulsatile oxytocin and/ ing hormone in mammalian mothers and fathers.
or by increasing beta-endorphins. Outside of reproduction, it is a stress and growth
Attention to emotional well-being may promote hormone.
labor progress. The reduced need for labor interven- Maternal prolactin elevations from early preg-
tions associated with doula and midwifery care may nancy may have stress-reducing effects that also
reflect this beneficial focus. Conversely, many com- benefit the fetus. Late-pregnancy prolactin eleva-
mon maternity care practices may be stressful for tions promote the formation of prolactin receptors
laboring women. High-quality research is lacking in the brain and mammary gland (animal studies).
in relation to physiologic aspects of labor stress, and Near term, prolactin production also increases in
methods for ameliorating this. the uterine lining (decidua), and may be involved in
Epidural analgesia can beneficially reduce ma- labor processes. Prolactin in amniotic fluid, which
ternal pain and epinephrine levels, which may have fills the fetal lungs, may assist with respiratory
been inhibiting labor. However, the rapid drop in epi- preparations. Fetal prolactic production increases
nephrine may contribute to hypotension and uterine close to the physiologic onset of labor, and may pro-
hyperstimulation. More commonly, contractions mote newborn transitions.
reduce over time because oxytocin also decreases.
Reductions in both epinephrine-norepinephrine Cortisol may promote contractions, increase central oxytocin
and oxytocin with epidural analgesia may contribute
effects on maternal adaptations and attachment, and enhance
to a prolonged pushing stage and assisted vaginal
birth. Epidurals do not assist with, and may increase, postpartum mood.
152 The Journal of Perinatal Education | Summer 2015, Volume 24, Number 3
• Initially using less invasive measures to address ABOUT THE NATIONAL PARTNERSHIP FOR
challenges, and stepping up to more consequential WOMEN & FAMILIES
interventions only as needed At the National Partnership for Women & Families,
we believe that actions speak louder than words,
A table in the report summarizes the established
and for four decades we have fought for every major
and potential effects of the maternity care practices
policy advance that has helped women and families.
addressed in the report on the four hormone
Today, we promote reproductive and maternal-
systems.
newborn health and rights, access to quality, af-
The following recommendations for education,
fordable health care, fairness in the workplace, and
policy, practice, and research arise from the syn-
policies that help women and men meet the dual
thesis presented here. Care practice recommenda-
demands of work and family. Our goal is to create a
tions below are intended to apply whenever safely
society that is free, fair and just, where nobody has to
possible. To optimize hormonal physiology in
experience discrimination, all workplaces are family
childbearing:
friendly and no family is without quality, affordable
• Educate all maternity care providers in the hor- health care and real economic security.
monal physiology of childbearing. Founded in 1971 as the Women’s Legal Defense
• Use effective policies and quality improvement Fund, the National Partnership for Women & Fami-
strategies to foster consistent access to physiologic lies is a nonprofit, nonpartisan 501(c)3 organization
childbearing. located in Washington, DC.
• Strengthen and increase access to care models that
promote physiologic childbearing and safely limit ABOUT CHILDBIRTH CONNECTION
use of maternity care interventions. PROGRAMS
• Use effective consumer engagement strategies Founded in 1918 as Maternity Center Association,
to inform women about physiologic childbear- Childbirth Connection became a core program of the
ing and involve them in related aspects of their National Partnership for Women & Families in 2014.
care. Throughout its history, Childbirth Connection pio-
• Provide prenatal care that reduces stress and anxi- neered strategies to promote safe, effective evidence-
ety in pregnant women. based maternity care, improve maternity care policy
• Foster the physiologic onset of labor at term. and quality, and help women navigate the complex
• With hospital birth, encourage admission in ac- healthcare system and make informed decisions about
tive labor. their care. Childbirth Connection Programs serve as
• Foster privacy and reduce anxiety and stress in a voice for the needs and interests of childbearing
labor. women and families, and work to improve the quality
• Make nonpharmacologic comfort measures for and value of maternity care through consumer en-
pain relief routinely available, and use analgesic gagement and health system transformation.
medications sparingly.
• Make nonpharmacologic methods of fostering la- ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
bor progress routinely available, and use pharma- The following provided much-appreciated financial
cologic methods sparingly. support for the full report: Childbirth Connection,
• Promote continuous support during labor. National Partnership for Women & Families, Trans-
• Foster spontaneous vaginal birth and avoid un- forming Birth Fund, Lamaze International, and
needed cesareans. DONA International.
• Support early and unrestricted skin-to-skin con-
tact after birth between mother and newborn.
Disclaimer. The information provided in this docu-
• Support early, frequent, and ongoing breastfeed-
ment is not intended as a substitute for the profes-
ing after birth.
sional guidance of qualified maternity care providers.
• Identify and carry out priority research into hor-
monal physiology of childbearing, and routinely
incorporate this perspective in maternity care SARAH J. BUCKLEY is a family physician and independent
research. writer and speaker in Brisbane, Australia.