Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Catherine Woodard
Abstract
In this paper we will discuss the creation of music, the effects, what should Christians listen to,
what is appropriate for worship, and what philosophy for music is. Music is very important in
life as we know. The effects can be positive or negative. This is why as Christians we should be
careful what we listen to. That also leads into, what is appropriate for worship and can we use
any type of music? Eventually, we notice the purpose for a philosophy regarding music which
While there are many aspects that music provides; one must look deeper in order to find
out what lies behind it. Music is something that has a power whether good or bad. As Christians
we should seek after what glorifies and honors Christ. First, one question we should ask is what
does glorify Christ? Well if you look at it from the perspective of others who would believe that
music gives way to amoral thinking, which means no moralities. In today’s society it is easy for
us to get caught up into thinking this and that music is okay, but when you start to see what it
does to one’s emotions, physical, and outward appearances then you will notice whether negative
or positive aspects of who they really are. Music is a big part of life as God intended it to be
from the very beginning as we read in Genesis 1:1 KJV which says, “In the beginning God
created the heaven and the earth”, since He created everything as stated here He must have
created music, we find that to be true as we read a bit further into the book of Genesis. Also, neat
to find out He also created music for us spiritually, mentally, and physically as well, yet all for
the glorifying and edifying of Himself. Music is so important and so crucial in today’s world
however; Satan likes to infiltrate his philosophy against God. My response and philosophy is that
as Christians we should listen to the things God would have us listen to and even if it is so called
Christian, we need to be careful that the music does not drown out the message of what God is
trying to get across. God says “come out from among them and be ye separate” (Bible KJV) in
other words, we should not go after the things of this world, but portray Christ and let others see
Music can affect a person physically, emotionally, and spiritually. First, it effects it
physically by for example the beat of music can make one dance in sexual ways and promote
self, which if that is being portrayed by Christian music artists then it is not of Christ and does
GOD CREATED MUSIC 4
not bring Him honor at all rather it gives way to only to you. Second, way it affects you is
emotionally and how it does that is through the rhythm and lyrics, which can be good or bad
depending on the song. One way it is good is through the direction of the Holy Spirit and if the
music with lyrics of that nature and you as a musician are following His leading, then there
should be no issue. On the other hand if you are a musician in the Church and you try to
manipulate by choosing songs so people will be stirred emotionally and only have that kind of
experience then it is only of you and it will not help the other person’s walk with God by doing
that, in fact it will hinder rather than help. Third, music affects you spiritually either by
disturbance or peace. If you cannot feel at rest as a Christian then what is the purpose for your
walk with the Lord. God wants you to have peace in Him. Yes, there are times He wants you to
be excited, but it doesn’t lead you in a positive direction in Christ. Martin Luther found out that
when he tried to use certain music that affected people in several different, disturbing ways, so
he changed the music that he had chosen and that no longer happened. Music is very powerful in
many ways.
With that in mind, what should we be listening to as Christians then? We should listen to
things that glorify Christ as stated above. Again you don’t want anything to harm your
relationship with God including music. As a Christian music leader you must know the history
and lyrics behind the music. There are many historical aspects about music from rap, hip-hop,
rock, folk, bar-tones, and so much more that give you pros and cons about each one. Now, as
Christian musicians we took what the world had and just set Christian words to it. That is not to
say that we haven’t done this before it’s been done for centuries at a time. It was interesting
though to find out in the Bible David was sent to ward off spirits through music, by King Saul.
God continues to use music even to this day; however the devil, who was once right under God
GOD CREATED MUSIC 5
wants to use music as well to counter fit God. Satan, in the beginning was someone who knew
and played an important role when it came to music, however he was not the creator of
everything as mentioned before, God is that creator and He included music in His creation as
well.
To be clear again though I do believe the Christian should not use rock-based music for
music ministry, because it gives way to sinful indulgences, such as sex. Second, some of the tests
for choosing the right music for worship, should ask questions like does it make one want to
move in such a way, dance, or even delve deep into bar tendencies? If that is the case do not use
it. Third, I believe that music should, as the ultimate purpose of worship to be ultimately to
glorify and edify who God is. Fourth, the reason why the Christian should answer the question
what is right and what is wrong for church music is because you are going to be ministering to
others that may not have heard the gospel before or even those who have and you don’t want to
give way to what the devil has planned. Fifth, what it means to be conformed to the world is
giving in to the sexual perversions and self-adoration. Sixth, what is meant by renovated is that,
“to be made new or to be restored” (Church Music Matters). Seventh, the reason the Bible does
teach separation from the world is because the world serves their self and want only their fleshly
desires. Eighth, the reason that I believe that the style of music can pervert or convert a person
equally well because on the one hand if you give them the music of the world it will pervert their
lives as a Christian and possibly send them back to their old ways and it can convert them if they
listen to the things of Christ the new person who doesn’t know why others are totally
worshiping, in depth it makes them want it as well. Ninth, I believe that it is unwise to abandon
traditional styles of music because of the theology and peacefulness that just moves you towards
a relationship with Christ. Tenth, the reason emotion in music should exude from meaning rather
GOD CREATED MUSIC 6
than meaning from emotion is because music it’s so powerful towards one’s emotions that we
You, notice that there are several different aspects towards music even in some words
that like renovated. As Christians we are to exhibit newness of life and restoration in Christ from
the patterns of this world. “Let your light so shine before men, that they may see your good
works, and glorify your Father which is in heaven” (Matthew 5:16 KJV). We must walk in the
Following that in thinking about music you notice words like modernism, post-
modernism, and aesthetics. First, modernism means a new way of thinking or knowing about
modern man; past modern times or after modern times. Second, the things that should matter to a
Christian church musician is where the song originated from, if it first of all glorifies Christ, and
never for self-gain. Third, it is both necessary and unnecessary to maintain our traditional church
music because there are some songs out there that are Holy Spirit filled now if it disturbs the
spirit then obviously don’t use it. Doesn’t matter if it is old or new music it must glorify Christ at
all times. Fourth, again we must be careful when it comes to post-modern and modern, however
there is a point to be made as stated earlier about post-modern it can be dangerous, but modern as
long as it has the edification of Christ use it. Fifth, there really isn’t anything inherently wrong
with using a new style or new composition as long as the spirit of God is in and through it. Sixth,
what is meant by how you use musical instruments is if it overpowers the words of a certain song
then simply don’t use it. Seventh, the conservative Christian musician should always conserve
the things/music of Christ that it doesn’t distort or disturb anything God wants to do. Eighth, the
difference between preserving the musical heritage and being a musical antiquer is preserving
GOD CREATED MUSIC 7
something that is sacred rather than just something old and only used rather than needed. Ninth,
the problem with mixing sacred and profane they are very two different things entirely one is
closest to Christ which is sacred and the other being profane that is sinful to be blunt. Tenth,
what the author meant about a Christian musical worldview is make sure you know music
those points. God not only wants you understand what is going on around you, but have the
knowledge engraved in your heart that you don’t let certain influences to hinder your walk with
Christ. There are some dangers in music which is portrayed in this next segment.
determines whether or not something is beautiful or ugly and the effects whereas with regular
philosophy focuses only on historical and worldview points. Second, the definition of Musique
concrete is something “that exploits acousmatic listening, meaning sound identities can often be
intentionally obscured or appear unconnected to their source cause” (online dictionary). Third,
indeterminacy means in music, “is a composing approach in which some aspects of musical
work are left open to chance or to the interpreters free choice. Fourth, the significance about
Claude Debussy as it relates to a philosophy is that the music he had was only symbolic and
vague to say the least to give impressions to reflect musically what painting where showing.
Fifth, the meaning of Dadaism is, “using old-fashioned techniques and subverting realism by
painting dreams as if they were real…[yet] dada has no meaning for life ” (Comparison of Dada
and Surreal site), while Surrealism, “has meaning for life; one has to find its logic by unlocking
visual and verbal codes secreted in the chambers of the unconscious mind…” (Comparison of
Dada and Surreal site). Now, one of the similarities in relation to each other between Dadaism
GOD CREATED MUSIC 8
and Surrealism is that, “…both movements work with Chance” (Comparison of Dada and
Surreal site). Sixth, the twelve tone technique is of great significance philosophically because it
deals with more or less attention to twelve notes thus enhancing the lyrics to some degree.
Seventh, what is meant by joyful noise in KJV is to sing for Joy and to exalt the Lord. Eighth,
music is; first the formalist believes in the beauty of music, it’s nature, and value on the other
hand, referentialists believe that music meaning must have meanings outside of music, and last
symbolist believe that music has symbols which use objects to give insight to an understanding
for the nature of human feeling (Church Music Matters). Ninth, when one doesn’t develop an
esthetic philosophy in reference to the ownership of God towards music then you have danger of
self-gratification, emotions that drift the wrong way, and ultimately a loss of the Spirit to enter in
worship. Tenth, I believe that Christian music should not include large amounts of noise because
the whole point is the words and I think if you have an atmosphere of quietness that enhances
them more and there is a time for some louder points, but never to the point where it can disturb
your spirit cause once that happens then you have a problem.
Noise is not what we thought it to mean in the Bible and that we should be careful to
give an atmosphere for the Holy Spirit. The elements that will contribute to my own personal
music philosophy is the term of noise, the history of relativism, and different philosophies to
have a better understand of what I will be confronted with if ever in a music leadership role. This
new truth has impacted me to think and look deeper at what I listen to I want my life to be the
Interesting enough when you let the Holy Spirit take over and He is able to work what
then happens in that service is a peace, calm, and convicting power that can only come from
GOD CREATED MUSIC 9
Him. First, music is filled with the Holy Spirit if we allow it, but can be filled with a different
type of spirit that isn’t the Holy Spirit it must honor God user in the Holy Spirits presence.
Second, Christian Musicians should always have the baptism of the Holy Spirit in order to be
used for music ministry that is what dunamis means. Third, a life in the spirit simply means that
your very own life is controlled by the Holy Spirit living in and through you exampled in truth.
Fourth, was for a song meant you could tell the differences in music and how burdensome it
must have been. Fifth, sharath means, “ to attend as menial worshiper, to contribute, serve, or
wait on”(Church Music Matters). Sixth, it is important for a music minister to have a fresh new
vision of God’s glory because that way God can work even in the here and now because He
never changes, but we should always seek what God has for us as long as it is truly His vision
not ours. Seventh, the Levites were instructed in the Lord to walk after Him and so should we as
well by asking ourselves are we truly doing what God wants through music or are we simply
giving Him over to other things that do not like certain secular music and so call Christian music
might do. Eighth, the significance of being called a seer is getting the vision of the Lord and
Christian’s musicians today should seek after such responsibility to have such a vision from the
Lord. Ninth, the realized how undone they were compared to such an all-powerful God. Tenth,
unction means they have an anointing of God. From this reading one should not just get up there
and lead worship without have the anointing that comes from God. The elements that contribute
Christocentric and should have the vision of the Lord in all that is said and done through music.
This new truth has impacted me to never take anything especially with music lightly and always
have His mindset and make sure it is His mindset in music and life in general.
GOD CREATED MUSIC 10
So much to think about when considering music, however it is very important as you see.
God must be at the center otherwise all your efforts are for not.
Now, for what music has done in the Church, first off I believe that the church should
admit styles of music that are antagonistic because it opposes Christ and brings an ungodly spirit
into the place of worship. Second the difference between men’s and women’s music was,
“Men’s music was text and melody-based with rhythm of the words always being the rhythm of
the text. Women’s music was rhythm-based with only a few melodic turns repeated over and
over again….women’s music was excluded from all public worship for sociological reasons, and
because it was rhythm-based and was used for public mourning, dancing and even harlotry.”
(Church music matters Garen L. Wolf) Third, the reason I believe that all art forms are the
product of the artist’s philosophical presuppositions is because people try to come up with
something that they are particularly interested in. Fourth, historically music was the servant of
words by not having the words drowned out by music rather it was more of a reading like the
psalms in the Bible however, there was some music, but not always. Fifth, the reason
directionality in music is so significant is because it places where the music is going and what
effects it has on people and how it effects religious music is by, for example, you use no
directionality at all even for religious purposes you would have chaos, so I would say it greatly
effects religious music. Sixth, the church can resist rock-based and still remain current in its
enactment of church music because we don’t need to appeal to the culture of this world,
especially when God says that we should, “come out from among them and be ye separate saith
the Lord” (Romans). Seventh, I do not believe that music is neutral or amoral because that would
be just like what the world says that all truth is relative and not necessarily wrong. Eighth, I do
not believe that traditional forms of music are an ancient landmark for worship because some of
GOD CREATED MUSIC 11
it is still relevant today. Ninth, the lifestyle of composers, arrangers, and performers enter into a
Christian musicians decision process when it because not their own lifestyle, but the lifestyle of
Christ. Tenth, the reason Christians believe that it is okay to sing, play, and listen to religious
rock music and not secular rock music, is simply because they think it’s fine to hear on the basis,
that the words are different. Things aren’t always as they appear just because you change the
word’s does not always make the music correct especially when music has a certain effect on
people that should be taken into consideration. My philosophy on this issue would be that Jesus
be glorified in all that is said and done in which one must refrain from using anything that will
hurt ones including your own walk with the Lord. Having light on this issue I will examine every
In continuation, for music we read about the prescriptive approach to music which means
basically style. Second, the reason why it is important to draw the line when it comes to music is
because of your listeners if you bring worldly music you could affect them negatively or
positively. Third, I do not believe that Church music is a matter of taste because you can have
certain feelings about something, but if those feelings do not have the mind of Christ in them
than it isn’t worth delving into. Fourth, for me I do not think nor believe that the Church should
take a prescriptive approach to Church music, because it isn’t just a matter of style that we are
talking about there has to be something much more than that, which God clearly lays out for us
that music should be based on Biblical grounds not mere style, again that is our own feelings
about something. Fifth, the reason I believe that there isn’t room for more than one style of
music is, because God does not want noise or ruckus, but joyfulness, peace, and rest in Him.
Sixth, some of the main principles for music found in the bible is to proving what is acceptable
unto Lord, make melody to the Lord, glorify, and praise God. Seventh, the meaning for making a
GOD CREATED MUSIC 12
joyful noise in the KJV means a spirit with power and acclamation and great joy not noise.
Eighth, regarding dance it reveals the facts of dancing for the Lord and not anything sexual at all.
Ninth, I cannot really say that the Bible refers to noise as music and hamown means noise.
Tenth, I think it is appropriate for us as Christians to approve what is good for Church worship,
however I do not think it is appropriate for us to do it on our own we need to consult the Lord in
every aspect especially with music. What I learned from this chapter was that what people call
noise should never be acceptable in the church and it was interesting to find out the Bible doesn’t
really say that noise applies to music. My question is this then, why are we trying to bring noise
that doesn’t apply to what God said? Again, we take things out of context. My philosophy on the
matter is this God created music and not for noise as we see it, but for the edifying of Himself. I
knew about some of this, but the noise part of it just amazing how we got that twisted around.
This has impacted me towards making a better stance for music so that others won’t be confused
either. Consequently, music should never be taken lightly. Music does have a power that needs to
be taken into consideration as a music minister or just for music in general. When considering
music for worship think of the effects it will have on the other person who is listening. One other
aspect to think about is will this glorify God, since He created music for that purpose anyway, or
does it honor me? Do not take music lightly it does make a difference and will impact greatly in
someone’s life, so be wise and have the Holy Spirit give you discernment when making a
decision.